Professional Documents
Culture Documents
路德的罪觀和華人的羞恥觀
路德的罪觀和華人的羞恥觀
路德的罪觀和華人的羞恥觀
5
8
11
17
20
22
48
54
60
60
64
69
74
74
76
82
87
101
108
109
110
113
vs. 116
vs. 118
121
124
God
3
4
1
2009 59
2
59-60
3
2011 491
4
1999
194
1
On the Two Kinds of
Righteousness, 1519
Against Latomus, 1521
On the Bondage
of the Will, 1525
1517 10 31 The
Ninety-Five Theses
1519
1521 1525
1505 7 StoternheimSaxon
St. Anne5
Thuringia
5
2005 2
5
Sanctus
BenedictusAgnus DeiConfiteor
6
11
7
11-12
8
12
9
1991 80
6
10
1538
11
10
513
11
WA 40 II.445.24-29. WA Martin Luther, Luthers Werke, Weimarer
Ausgabe, 1883-2003.
7
A. Nygren
12
13 Paul Avis14
1516 1545
iustitia Dei
15
16
12
1950 415
13
1997 9
14
P. D. L. Avis, The Church in the Theology of the Reformers (Louisville, KYJohn Knox Press,
1981), p. 1.
15
Alister E. McGrath, Luthers Theology of The Cross: Martin Luthers Theology Breakthrough ( New
York: Basil Blackwell Inc., 1985), p. 103.
16
Ibid., p. 100.
8
William of Ockham
nomialism18
Gregory of Rimini
19 Erfurt
via antiqua
realism20
17
Ibid., pp. 27-92.
18
Ibid., p. 30.
19
Leif Grane, Gregor von Rimini und Luthers Leipziger Disputation, Studia Theologica 22 (1968),
pp. 29-49.
20
McGrath, Luthers Theology of The Cross, p. 30.
9
21
22
humanitas
23
24
25
21
Ibid., p. 36.
22
Steven Ozment, The Age of Reform 1250-1550: An Intellectual and Religious History of Medieval
and Reformation Europe (New Haven, CTYale University Press, 1981)p. 59.
23
McGrath, Luthers Theology of The Cross, p. 36.
24
Ibid., p. 35.
25
Ibid., pp. 55-63.
10
26
grace27
substance
28
29
26
Ibid., p. 58.
27
2006
141
28
141
29
81
11
30
31
32
33
30
31
1985
242
32
12
34
35
1225-1274
36
37
38
2009 14
33
21
34
22
35
244
36
vol.2, 53
2009 24
37
25
38
vol. 4, 233
13
39
40
Latomus 1520 6 15
41
42
39
vol. 4, 138
40
26-27
41
Articulorum doctrine fratris M. Lutheri per theologos Lovaniensis damnatorum ratio ex sacris
literis et veteribus (1521).
42
LW 32:136. LW Luther's Works vol. 32: Career of the Reformer II.
Fortress, 1958
14
Jerome
43
44
45
46
47
48
49 123
450
51 52
53
43
Jerome, Dialogue Against the Pelagians, Migne 23, 537.
44
LW 32:153, note 24.
45
LW 32:153.
46
LW 32:153.
47
LW 32:154.
48
LW 32:157.
49
LW 32:158.
50
LW 32:193.
51
LW 32:194.
52
LW 32:204.
53
LW 32:203.
15
54
55
56
57
58
59 60
61
62
54
LW 32:207.
55
LW 32:210.
56
LW 32:213.
57
LW 32:238-239.
58
LW 32:212.
59
LW 32:159.
60
LW 32:159.
61
LW 32:159.
62
LW 32:160.
16
Renaissance
humanism
rhetoric
willclassical
antiquity63
ad fontes
1516 Greek
New Testament64
65
63
Lewis W. Spitz, The Protestant Reformation 1517-1559 (New York: Harper & Row, Publishers,
1992), pp. 55-56; Cf. William J. Bouwsma, Renaissance and Reformation: An Essay in Their Affinities and
Connections, in Heiko Oberman, ed., Luther and the Dawn of the Modern Era (Leiden: Brill, 1974), pp.
127-49.
64
Ozment, The Age of Reform 1250-1550, p. 292.
65
II2004 610
17
skepticismassertions
68
69
70
66
Ozment, The Age of Reform 1250-1550, p. 290.
67
Martin Brecht, Martin Luther: Shaping and Defining the Reformation 1521-1532., (trans. James L.
Schaaf ; Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1990), pp. 215; Cf. P.S. Allen and H. M. Allen, eds., Opus epistolarum
Des. Erasmi Roterdami, 12 vols. (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1906-58). Vol. 4, no. 1195, lines 64-66.
68
65613 Luther and Erasmus: Free Will and Salvation, trans. E. Gordon Rupp, LCC 17
(Philadelphia: Westminster, 1969), p. 37.
69
618 Luther and Erasmus: Free Will and Salvation, , p. 47.
70
619
18
71
72
73
74
75
76
71
619
72
620
73
74
629
75
634
76
635-40
19
20
77
78
1513 8 1513 8
1515 4 1516 10
1517 10 31
79
80
77
20-21
78
WA 54.185.12-186.2158
79
80
McGrath, Luthers Theology of The Cross, p. 149.
21
On the Two
Kinds of Righteousness, 1519Against Latomus, 1521
On the Bondage of the Will, 1525
1519 81
1520 3 82 1520 6 15
83
84 1521 5 26
85
81
Facultatis theologiae Lovaniensis doctrinalis condemntio Martini Lutheri, WA 6, 175.
82
Responsio Lutheriana ad condemnationem doctrinalem per magistres nostros Lovaniensis et
Coloniensis, WA 6, 181-195.
83
78164
84
Articulorum doctrine fratris M. Lutheri per theologos Lovaniensis damnatorum ratio ex sacris
literis et veteribus (1521).
85
LW 32:135.
22
1524 9 1 A Diatribe
87
88
1525
1525 12 31 De
89
86
Brecht, Martin Luther: Shaping and Defining the Reformation 1521-1532., (trans. James L. Schaaf ;
Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1990), pp. 220.
87
Ibid., p. 218-19.
88
To Johann Lang, WABr 1, p. 90. 65613
89
Ibid., no. 86, pp. 224-25.
23
90
91
92
93
94
90
LW 32:222.
91
LW 32:223.
92
LW 32:175.
93
LW 32:146.
94
LW 32:148.
24
95
96
synecdoche
97 98
99
100
101
102
103
104
12
95
LW 32:148.
96
LW 32:149.
97
LW 32:161.
98
LW 32:161.
99
LW 32:161.
100
LW 32:165.
101
LW 32:165.
102
LW 32:166.
103
LW 32:167.
104
LW 32:167.
25
105
106
107
108
3109
110
111
112
105
LW 32:168-169.
106
LW 32:170.
107
LW 32:182.
108
LW 32:184.
109
LW 32:188.
110
LW 32:189.
111
LW 32:200.
112
LW 32:196.
26
113
114
ad fontes
116
117
7 32118
119
obscure
120
121
113
LW 32:244.
114
LW 32:245.
115
Ozment, Steven, The Age of Reform 1250-1550, p. 292.
116
65610
117
614
118
614-5
119
615
120
616
121
617
27
122
clarity
assertioncertainty
skeptic.123 assertion
certain
124
122
617-8
123
LW, vol. 33, p. 24. WA 18, 605, 32.
124
Ibid., no. 10, p. 221.
28
125
126
clarity127
128
45
15129
130
dual clarity
131
125
II
2004 340 De servo arbitrio (1525) WA XVIII,
606.22-24=LW 33, 25.
126
340
127
Ibid., no. 86, p. 227.
128
Ibid.
129
125341
130
29
132
133
134
131
343
132
Ibid., no. 86, p. 227.
133
125343
134
399-400
30
1524 10 9 135
1361524
works
137
1525
138
1.
139
un-free
choice
135
WA 15:713-16.
136
Ibid., no. 86, p. 224.
137
Ibid.
138
125332
139
Ibid., no. 86, p. 222.
31
140
141
142
143
144
2.
140
65618
141
125414
142
415
143
416
144
417
32
145
146
147
148
149
150
145
421
146
423-4
147
423-6
148
429
149
435
150
429
33
151
152
151
547
152
554
34
153
Martin Brecht
154
155
123
456
7156 1
23157
153
603-4
154
Ibid., no. 86, p. 220. 65614
155
Ibid., p. 220-21.
156
LW 32:136.
157
LW 32:136.
35
1.
158
159
160
4:15 5:20
161
162
163
164
165
158
LW 32:151.
159
LW 32:153, note 24.
160
LW 32:153.
161
LW 32:154.
162
LW 32:155.
163
LW 32:155.
164
LW 32:156.
165
LW 32:157.
36
2.
166
167
13:10
168
169
8:2
170
171
172
166
LW 32:157.
167
LW 32:158.
168
LW 32:158.
169
LW 32:200-201.
170
LW 32:207.
171
LW 32:208.
172
LW 32:208.
37
173
174
3.
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
173
LW 32:209.
174
LW 32:209.
175
LW 32:159.
176
LW 32:159.
177
LW 32:159.
178
LW 32:160.
179
The Leipzig Debate (1519), Thesis 2. LW 31:317.
180
LW 32:172.
181
LW 32:173.
182
LW 32:174.
38
183
184
185
186
187
4.
188
189
190
191
183
LW 32:175.
184
LW 32:182.
185
LW 32:191.
186
LW 32:192.
187
LW 32:212-213.
188
LW 32:194.
189
LW 32:195.
190
LW 32:202.
191
LW 32:203.
39
192
193
194
195
196
197
12
198
199
200
192
LW 32:210.
193
LW 32:213.
194
LW 32:213.
195
LW 32:214.
196
LW 32:214.
197
LW 32:238-239.
198
LW 32:239.
199
LW 32:239.
200
LW 32:240.
40
201 202
5.
203
204
205
206
207
208
12
12
201
LW 32:249.
202
LW 32:250.
203
LW 32:177.
204
LW 32:177.
205
LW 32:178.
206
LW 32:178.
207
LW 32:178.
208
LW 32:178.
41
209 1
210
211
212
213
214
215
24:47
216
209
LW 32:223.
210
LW 32:224.
211
LW 32:224.
212
LW 32:226.
213
LW 32:227.
214
LW 32:227-228.
215
LW 32:229.
216
LW 32:231-233.
42
217
6.
218
219
220
221
222
7.
223
224
217
LW 32:233.
218
LW 32:251-252.
219
LW 32:254.
220
LW 32:254.
221
LW 32:255.
222
LW 32:256.
223
LW 32:213.
224
LW 32:213.
43
225
226
227
15181519
228
225
LW 32:193.
226
LW 32:236.
227
LW 32:236.
228
LW 31:296.
44
1.
229
12:3
230
229
LW 31:297.
230
LW 31:299.
45
231
2.
proper righteouseness
232
233
234
3.
231
LW 31:299.
232
LW 31:299.
233
LW 31:300.
234
LW 31:300.
46
235 56
236
237
238
239
240
235
LW 31:300.
236
LW 31:301.
237
LW 31:301.
238
LW 31:302.
239
LW 31:302.
240
LW 31:303.
47
241
242
W. Pannenberg
243
241
LW 31:304.
242
LW 31:304.
243
W. Pannenberg, Freedom and the Lutheran Reformation, Theology Today, 1981/38-3, p. 291.
48
244
DisputationVercruysse1-28
1-12 13-18
19-24
25-28
245
244
McGrath, p. 149.
245
Gerhard O. Forde, On Being a Theologian of the Cross: Reflections on Luthers Heidelberg
Disputation, 1518 (Grand Rapids, Michigan: William B. Eerdmans Publishings Co., 1997), pp. 21-22;
Vercruysse, Gesetz und Leibe: Die Struktur der Heidelberger Disputation Luthers (1518),
Lutherjahrbuch 48 (1981) 7-43.
49
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
16
255
246
Walther von Loewenich, Luthers Theology of the Cross (Minneapolis: Augsburg Publishing House,
1976), p. 29.
247
Explanation of Thesis 20, Heidelberg Disputation, W. I, 362; LW 31, 52.
248
WA. 1.357.3-4: vivimus in abscondito Dei, id est, in nuda fiducia misericordiae eius.
249
McGrath, p. 152.
250
WA 1.362.30-31.
251
WA 1.362.12-13.
252
McGrath, p. 150.
253
Ibid., p. 149.
254
Ibid., p. 151.
255
Forde, p. 59.
50
256
257
258
Anfechtung
259
260
256
LW 31.50.
257
LW 31.50-51.
258
McGrath, p. 151.
259
Ibid., p. 151.
260
Forde, p. 1.
51
261
humanitas
262
19-21
19
20
21
263
22
261
Ibid., pp. 18, 23.
262
McGrath, p. 36.
263
Forde, p. 23.
52
23
24
20
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
264
WA 5.163.28-29.
265
WA 1.362.14.
266
McGrath, p. 150.
267
Ibid., p. 152.
268
WA 5.176.32-3: CRUX sola est nostra theologia.
269
Forde, pp. 23-24.
270
Ibid., p. 18.
53
271
271
James Nestingen, Luthers Heidelberg Disputation: An Analysis of the Argument, in All Things
New, Essays in Honor of Roy a. Harrisville, ed. Arland J. Hultgren el al., Word and World Supplement
Series, no. 1 (St. Paul: Luther Seminary, 1992), 147-48.
54
272
273
274
Fides Christirighteousness
275
276
277 Loewenich
278
272
WA 5.107.5-9; 5. 263.17-18.
273
WA 5.615.17-22.
274
McGrath, p. 152.
275
Ibid., p. 155.
276
Ibid., p. 156.
277
Loewenich, Luthers Theology of the Cross, p. 112.
278
Ibid., p. 113.
55
279
280
281 Beintker
Anfechtung
282
283
284
285
286
279
McGrath, p. 155.
280
Ibid., p. 150.
281
Ibid., p. 151.
282
H. Beintker, Die Uberwindugn der Anfechtung bei Luther: Eine Studies zu seiner Theologie nach
den Operatones In Psalmos 1519-21 (Evangelische VerlagsanstaltBerlin, 1954), pp. 38-56, 99-104, 106-7,
132-44.
283
H. M. Barth, Der Teufel und Jesus Christus in der Theologie Martin Luthers (Gottingen:
Vandenhoeck u. Ruprecht, 1967), pp. 165-6, 183, 188, 200-201P. T. Buhler, Die
Anfechtung bei Martin Luther (Zurich: Zwingli-Verlag , 1944)
284
WA 5.165.39-166.1.
285
McGrath, p. 151.
286
Ibid., p. 154.
56
287
288
289
290
291
292
287
Loewenich, Luthers Theology of the Cross, p. 135.
288
LW 31, 346-3482004
5-8
289
LW 31, 3442
290
LW 31, 349-35111-13
291
LW 31, 351-35214-16
292
LW 31, 35620-21
57
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
293
LW 31, 364-36538-39
294
LW 31, 364-36538-39
295
LW 31, 36436
296
LW 31, 36740
297
LW 31, 36741
298
LW 31, 37147
299
LW 31, 36841
58
300 1911
301
300
1979 24-25
301
25
59
302
303
302
1986 208-209
303
209
60
304
305
304
1976 34
305
40
61
306
307
308
309
306
41
307
30
308
309
31
62
310
311
312
313
314
310
311
32
312
2010 9
313
304146
314
1992 60
63
315
234
316
317
315
60
316
1979 71
317
1997 2
64
318
319
320
321
322
318
3
319
3-4
320
3
321
21
322
45
65
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
323
19
324
22
325
25
326
47
327
4
328
55
329
4
330
6
66
331
332
333
334
335
331
7
332
13
333
12
334
13
335
54
67
336
337
338
336
54
337
48
338
19
68
339
340
341
339
45
340
45-46
341
69
69
342
343
344
12
345
descent
346
342
73
343
74
344
345
2011
109
346
1983
261
70
347
348
349
350
347
111
348
1991 112
349
110
350
72-73
71
351
352
353
351
86
352
353
87
354
90
72
355
356
357
1234
56358
359
360
361
355
267
356
111
357
267
358
110
359
111
360
466
361
63
73
362
363
364
362
69
363
17
364
15
74
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
365
16
366
17
367
368
18
369
20
370
79
371
65
75
372
373
374
375
376
372
79-80
373
465
374
72
375
49
376
265
76
family
377
378
379
380
381
382
377
255
378
265
379
85-86
380
106
381
107
382
108
77
383
384
385
386
387
383
108-109
384
1979 73
385
119
386
119
387
1987 391
78
388
389
390
391
392
393
388
391
389
54-55
390
2010 20
391
1983 172
392
283
393
21
79
394
395
396
397
398
394
282
395
120
396
1979 73
397
11
398
12
80
399
400
1991
131 401
402
399
13
400
23
401
207
402
81
403
404
403
260
404
1981 20-22
82
405
406
407
408
409
410 411
405
1990 204-205
406
234
407
234-235
408
7
409
17
410
52
411
53
83
412
413
414
415
416
412
62
413
54
414
54
415
48-51
416
70
84
417
418
419
417
2010
50-51
418
53
419
126
85
420
421
422
423
424
425
420
127
421
1983 3
426
427
426
48
427
169-171
87
428
429
430
428
260-261
429
7
430
131
88
431
432
1.
433
434
435
436
437
438
431
432
433
2
434
4
435
7
436
7
437
9
438
11
89
439
440
441
442
439
8
440
9
441
442
11
90
2.
443
444
445
3446
443
157
444
3
445
15
446
12-14
91
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
447
14
448
17
449
17
450
31
451
452
72
453
242
92
454
1.
455
456
454
45
The Chinese Concepts of Face, American Anthropology, Vol. 46, 45-64,
1944Hu, Hsien-Chin
2010 45-70
455
72
456
45
93
457
458
459
460
461
462
457
46
458
132
459
76
460
461
462
76
94
463
464
465
2.
1845-1932 22 Chinese
Characteristics, 1890
466
463
77
464
92
465
79
466
133
95
467
468
469
470
471
467
39
468
66
469
470
67
471
133
96
472
473
474
475
476
477
472
135
473
138
474
475
231-233
476
235
477
239
97
478
479
480
481
482
483
478
263
479
240
480
288
481
482
111
483
249
98
484
485
486
487
488
484
257-260
485
124
486
22
487
488
22-23
99
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
489
23
490
24
491
93
492
211
493
212
494
22
495
343-344
100
496
497
498
496
497
8-9
498
227
101
499
500
501
Amato
502
503
504
Benedict
499
157
500
269
501
270
502
219
503
504
220
102
505
506
507
34
508
509
510
505
215
506
216
507
508
221
509
270
510
157
103
511
512
1.
513
514
511
512
157
513
71
514
76
104
515
2.
516
517
518
515
77
516
129
517
130
518
96
105
519
520
521
3.
519
520
96
521
99
106
522
523
524
525
526
522
65
523
51
524
46-47
525
49-50
526
57
107
527
528
529
530
527
208
528
53
529
158
530
89
108
531
Lily Abegg
532
531
218
532
39
109
533
533
218
110
25
Wilhelm, 1928
534
535
1981
536
534
74-75
535
95
536
50-52
111
537
538
539
540
537
168
538
172-173
539
92
540
93
112
541
542
543
544
545
541
35
542
346
543
344-345
544
179
545
214
113
546
10
15
16-18
547
546
218
547
50-51
114
115
vs.
116
117
vs.
548
548
2008 51
118
549
549
54-56
119
120
121
122
123
2009
1991
1973
1988
1987
1989
2008
1978
1991
2011
1988
1985
1981
1978
1976
14-22
2009
2008
1990
1995
1959
1983
1984
2010
124
2009
1997
1981
2001
1977
2006
1999
2007
2003
2006
2000
2004
II
2004
1980
1978
2000
1979
23-43
2009
1979
1984
1995
2009
1983
1981
1991
2006
1964
2010
1988
1986
125
1997
1998
1992
2011
1979
2005
Avis, P.D.L. The Church in the Theology of the Reformers. Louisville, KY:John Knox Press, 1981.
Barth, H. M. Der Teufel und Jesus Christus in der Theologie Martin Luthers. Gottingen: Vandenhoeck u.
Ruprecht, 1967.
Beintker, H. Die Uberwindugn der Anfechtung bei Luther: Eine Studies zu seiner Theologie nach den
Operatones In Psalmos 1519-21. Evangelische Verlagsanstalt: Berlin, 1954.
Bouwsma, William J. Renaissance and Reformation: An Essay in Their Affinities and Connections. In
Luther and the Dawn of the Modern Era. ed. Heiko Oberman, 127-49. Leiden: Brill, 1974.
Brecht, Martin. Martin Luther. Vol. 2, Shaping and Defining the Reformation 1521-1532. Translated by
James L. Schaaf. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1990.
Forde, Gerhard O. On Being a Theologian of the Cross: Reflection on Luthers Heidelberg Disputation,
1518. Grand Rapids, Michigan: William B. Eerdmans, 1997.
Grane, Leif. Gregor von Rimini und Luthers Leipziger Disputation. Studia Theologica 22 (1968): 29-49.
Loewenich, Walther von. Luthers Theology of the Cross. Minneapolis: Augsburg Publishing House, 1976.
Lohse, Bernhard. Martin Luthers Theology: Its Historical and Systematic Development. Minneapolis:
Fortress Press, 1999.
Luther, Martin. Luther's Works vol. 31: Career of the Reformer I. Concordia, 1957; vol. 32: Career of
126
the Reformer II. Fortress, 1958; vol. 33: Career of the Reformer III. Fortress, 1972; vol. 40: Church
and Ministry II. Fortress, 1958; vol. 50: Letters III. Fortress, 1975.
Luther, Martin, and Erasmus, Roterodamus Desiderius. Luther and Erasmus: Free Will and Salvation.
Translated by E. Gordon Rupp. LCC 17. Philadelphia: Westminster, 1969.
McGrath, Alister. Luthers Theology of The Cross: Martin Luthers Theology Breakthrough. New York:
Basil Blackwell Inc., 1985.
Nestingen, James.Luthers Heidelberg Disputation: An Analysis of the Argument. In All Things New,
Essays in Honor of Roy a. Harrisville. ed. Arland J. Hultgren el al., Word and World Supplement
Series, no. 1. St. Paul: Luther Seminary, 1992.
Ozment, Steven. The Age of Reform, 1250-1550: An Intellectual and Religious History of Late Medieval
and Reformation Europe. New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1980.
Pennenberg, W. Freedom and the Lutheran Reformation. In Theology Today. 1981:38-3, 291.
Spitz, Lewis W. The Protestant Reformation 1517-1559. New York: Harper & Row, 1992.
Thompson, Mark D. A Sure Ground on Which to Stand: The Relation of Authority and Interpretive Method
in Luthers Approach to Scripture. Cumbria: Paternoster Press, 2007.
Vercruysse, Gesetz und Leibe: Die Struktur der Heidelberger Disputation Luthers (1518). Lutherjahrbuch
48. 1981:7-43.
127