Professional Documents
Culture Documents
College Life Mini-Study 1
College Life Mini-Study 1
Abstract:
Minority student-athletes have drastically different collegiate experiences than their non-
athlete counterparts, especially at a small and private liberal arts university like Bucknell. This
qualitative study, based on interviews with five individuals, highlights important inequalities
between the lives of minority student-athletes and those of their peers. A series of questions
were created preemptively in order to guide interviews, but research participants were allowed to
guide the interview, to some extent, towards topics of their own interest. After transcription and
coding of the interviews, a few important themes revealed themselves about life at Bucknell for
professors to those of their peers, a perceived difficulty in making friends and connections
outside of their realm of comfort (race or sports team), the need to join Greek life in order to be
accepted socially, and a feeling of being misunderstood due to the lack of diversity in attendance
at Bucknell. A difference in backgrounds (private or public high schools, area they grew up in,
etc.) also influenced the participants in their perceived acclimation to the culture at Bucknell.
This qualitative study gives insight into the important cultural and educational inequalities of
I made an effort to interview people of different backgrounds whether that meant that
they played different sports, were of different minorities, or were of different genders. I was,
however, limited by the people available and willing to participate as well as my own comfort
level. I first reached out to minority student athletes with whom I was already friendly or
familiar with. After interviewing them, I asked them whether they knew of any other athletes
that they could point me towards that would be willing to participate in such a study. The
resulting study focuses on five participants (all participants names have been changed to protect
their identities):
from Cleveland, Ohio and plays wide receiver on the football team. While originally
recruited to both run track and play football, his football coaches have prohibited his
participation in track activities due to the possibility of getting injured. Sam went to a
public high school where there was a variety of diversity, including that of race and
socioeconomic status.
2. Carlos: Carlos is a Brazilian male and a junior at Bucknell University. He was
rowed throughout high school and came to Bucknell to continue doing so. He comes
from a relatively wealthy family and frequently travels back to Brazil to visit his
before ultimately attending Bucknell. His public high school was relatively non-
University. Darren is a special teams member on the football team and is originally
from Shaker Heights, Ohio. Darren comes from a modest backround and went to a
Womens Volleyball team. She is a Senior from Virginia and went to a diverse public
high school before transferring to a private school for her final two years before
attending Bucknell.
5. Rachel: Rachel is an African-Canadian female who is a right side hitter on the
get either a more complete picture of what being a minority student-athlete is like and to get
upbringing, sport of choice, gender, personality, race, etc. their experience here at Bucknell could
be drastically different. Even participants who had relatively similar backgrounds could have
had a variety of diverse experiences. Moreover, this study was designed to provide insight into
All the interviews that I conducted utilized the same basic line of questioning chosen
beforehand to direct the discussion in a general direction. The discussion would begin with
basics regarding what sport the research participants played and where they were from in order
to create a level of relative comfort. After creating a comfortable base for which the
conversation could stem, questions began delving into more difficult and personal topics such as
racial and social inequality. These interviews ranged from 29 to 45 minutes. If the interviewee
was willing to open up and share a lot without a lot of prodding, usually the sessions went a lot
more smoothly and lasted longer, whereas interviewees who felt less comfortable required more
Interviews were audio recorded so that I could go back, listen, transcribe and code them
after the interview had concluded. Coding included reading through the transcribed material and
making thematic notes. I attempted to normalize these notes as much as I could in order to
discern patterns amongst my findings across the board with all of my interview sessions. When I
went back through my coding for all my interviews, I was then able to find a few common
themes that each interview touched upon and examine them in the discussion portion of my
study in relation to my original question: what is the experience of a Bucknell minority student-
athlete like?
background and story in relation to reoccurring themes. I believe this approach will better
display the important similarities, and differences, in the lives of minority student-athletes that I
found.
Educational Inequalities?
While not all of the interviewees viewed it in the same way, almost all of them said that
they had witnessed or experienced some sort of educational bias based on their athletic status to
some extent.
In my interview with Darren, he focused a lot on his relationships with professors inside
and outside of the classroom. He thought that both being an athlete and being a minority had a
definite effect on the way he was treated and also perceived by his professors. Darren viewed
these inconsistencies in treatment as mostly positive, but did note that they existed. For example,
he said, they notice that youre an athlete and they mention sometimes in class, you know, they
use you as the examplefor certain things, so yeah I mean, but its never in a bad wayits
always, if anything its always helping me outthat they notice that Im a athlete. Moreover,
while he didnt have a problem with it, he admitted that he has been singled out in class for being
an athlete and sometimes asked for his perspective on something because of his race. Some
minority student-athletes might have a problem with being singled out in such a way, but Darren
did not. He also mentioned that he thought professors were more likely to extend a due date or
help an athlete in office hours because they understand the time constraints and responsibilities
Like Darren, who said that he believed professors would lend a helping hand to an athlete
more often than they would to a non-athlete, Rachel said that she felt teachers were more
accommodating. With that being said, she did not have a positive view of this inequality.
Sometimes I feel likeI dont know, what about my situation makes me deserve this
more than someone else? Im sure other kidsother non-athletes have just as good of an excuse
While Darren viewed the extra willingness to help from professors as an accommodation
for the added stresses of being an athlete, Rachel seems to think that she shouldnt be offered a
handicap just because she plays a sport. Rather, she believed everyone has things that take up
time on any given day so everyone should be on the same level. It was surprising for me to hear
this from her because it does seem obvious that athletes have less time to offer to their work than
other students just because of the nature of their schedules. Furthermore, successful student-
athletes tend to be those that are excellent at time management simply because of the unequal
amount of free time they have to devote to home work and studying.
That aspect of time management and the constraints placed on athletes was also
something that the participants all brought up repeatedly. Sam noted that the time that he needs
to devote to being on the football team ends up being a large factor in most if not all of his
decisions. While regular college students may have time to devote to extracurriculars of their
choosing, athletes must utilize most of their free time for work that other students may have
done already because they do not have athletic practice. Sams statement that football factors
into all of his decisions is a direct result of the amount of time he does not have due to being a
Carlos came to Bucknell to row because he wanted to play a sport at the collegiate level,
but did not want it to consume his entire life. Thus, he decided to come to Bucknell where he
was recruited to row in a Division 3 (Crew at Bucknell is Division 3, rather than Division 1 like
the rest of the sports teams) program that would allow him to compete at a high level, but also
maintain a life outside of athletics. While Carlos mentioned, just like every other athlete, that
time constraints made things more difficult for him than the average student, he believed that the
demands of a Division 3 sport that didnt practice year-round were much less than that of other
sports teams. With that being said, Carlos was one of only a few recruits and was immediately
pulled to the varsity team instead of rowing with the other freshmen. With that added
responsibility, he noted that more of his time was devoted to crew than some of the other guys
and he had to learn more time management skills. Carlos added that he was thankful for the
added time constraints now because he has learned how to budget his time better as a result of
make friends within either their race or sports team on Bucknells campus. For many, as a result
of spending the majority of time with their teams, they made their collegiate friendships on their
Sam repeatedly said it was difficult to make friends and form meaningful relationships
with people who didnt also play a sport on this campus and he gave multiple reasons. First off,
he relayed that athletes and non-athletes honestly just have different interests and while you
have your occasional friend here and thereits just tough to find friends that you wanna hang
out with that have the same interests as you. Sam said that while athletes are concerned with
school and practice, other students simply have to focus on school and otherwise can choose
what they are interested in doing. Athletes dont really have the time to search for other niches
that they might be interested in so they dont really mingle with non-athletes that often. This
lack of interest and general apathy on both sides (athletes and non-athletes) seems to perpetuate a
In terms of the relationships he forms, he says that its easier and more comfortable to
find friends on sports teams because they understand the time constraints better than non-athletes
do and are simply around each other more often whether that be in practice, during regular meal
times, etc. In terms of making friends on the football team specifically, Sam assured me that his
since I see them every day for about four/ five hours a day, you gotta like those people,
you gotta love em, cause if you dont then youre just gonna be miserable.
What Sam said really made me think about how little interaction there is between athletes
and non-athletes. If he truly believes that he would be miserable if he didnt get along with his
teammates, it can be gathered that he believes he wouldnt have many meaningful relationships
otherwise. He even mentioned that his friends and relationships outside of athletics usually were
still related to sports anyways. For example, he said that he had friends in the pep band and also
Greek life because certain members of the team were involved in fraternities. Without the outlets
that football gave Sam to branch out and form non-athletic relationships, his experiences could
have been more limited had he not made friends on the team to begin with.
While Darren said he definitely noticed that it was difficult to make relationships outside
of the football team, he didnt seem to see at as much of a problem, unlike Sam. Darren seemed
to think it was only natural and fair that the football players tended to get along better with each
I think we just find more things in common whether its our passion for sports or the
type of communities we come from, the type of schooling we went through or, you know, things
like that, the areas we grew up in so I just think we tend to be with each other, its just more
Darren also explained that he thinks theres a maturity difference between the athletes and
non-athletes. He posited that athletes, through their sports and responsibilities, have learned
discipline, respect, time management and other useful skills that non-athletes just havent needed
to learn to the same extent. With those inequalities in maturity levels, at least as he perceives
them, he believes it is hard for athletes and non-athletes to mingle effectively. In other words, at
least some portion of the separation between athletes and non-athletes at this school is self-
imposed by the athletes. Darren obviously believes that if athletes truly wanted to branch out
they would, but they just have different interests and would rather clump together than branch
out.
Carlos also seemed to have a different relationship with the Bucknell community as a
whole than Sam. He didnt care that Bucknell wasnt the most diverse school and said,
Bucknell is a good school with good academics and good programs and a good crew team and
that was the biggest thing for meif there were 100% Brazilian students or 100% white
students, 100% whatever, that wouldnt have been a huge determining factor. The fact that,
right off the bat Carlos had a different perception of the rest of campus might have had
something to do with the experiences that Carlos has had in his life. Sam viewed the schools
undiversified nature as a negative from the beginning and couldnt bring himself to see past it as
a problem, whereas Carlos seemed to brush it off and wanted to focus on things that he believed
mattered more.
Carlos also seemed to have a positive view about being a minority at a school with such
an undiversified majority. When I asked him about making friends and forming relationships
I think its easier to make friends that are minorities because they kind of like, have gone
through the same thing that you have gone through. I think its kind of like a new territory for
them, like a newthey never really lived in the U.S. for this longfor me its different cause I
lived in the U.S. for a while, but I can still kinda relate to them cause myall my family is in
Latin America so whenever I go back home I have to go visit themI have gone to the airport
with some of these minority studentsand so its nice cause you have an underlying connection
withto each otherand even if like thats the only connection we have, we can kind of build off
on that and Ive done that a couple times, especially my freshman year when I first got hereI
met a bunch of minority friends, Ive met some kids from like, all over Latin America, some
European students as welland with the Bucknell students who arent minority students, I think
making friends with them is the same thingand ifand for some people its differenteasier
than otherssome minority students Ive talked to have easily made friends with allstudents of
all different colors, all different home townsother minority students have really struggled
making friends cause theyre so different, but I think all in all making friends at Bucknell is, is
For Carlos, as an outgoing and friendly person, he has found being a minority not to
hinder his abilities to make friends, but rather aid him in making more meaningful connections.
He is quickly able to form relationships with other minority students, especially those with
similar Latin American backgrounds, due to shared experiences. However, he also feels that his
unique-ness as a minority student allows him to bridge gaps between himself and the majority of
Brittany actually mentioned some initial problems with forming relationships on the
volleyball team, which I thought was interesting in relation to what the other athletes had said.
In all of my other interviews, the participants mentioned that the only times that they truly felt
comfortable were when they were with their teammates who accepted them for who they were.
Brittany had a different experience at least to begin with and explained that the volleyball team is
relatively non-diverse and more representative of the Bucknell population than many of the other
teams.
I did kind of have a disconnect with my teammates thats in my class year my freshman
year, partially because I was shy, but I dont know just since I was like the only black girl out of
the four of them and they just kept, I dont know, they justwere always trying to socialize and
socialize with people I didnt really care about or justI dont know, justI dont know, do stuff
where I would be like the only, I guess, black girl present in that group of friends or things like
that
It is interesting to look at how race plays a role on the volleyball team, whereas on the
other athletic teams, interviewees told me about how the diversity on their teams allowed them to
have an outlet for diversity and feel as though they belonged and could be entirely themeselves.
The volleyball team being so similar to the rest of the school didnt offer Brittany that escape that
the others experienced and actually ended up creating more problems for her, at least at first.
She assured me that things are much better between her and her teammates now, but she had to
venture out and make her own friends outside of the team during her freshman year, which
offered an interesting exception to the general rule. Brittany told me that she didnt feel
comfortable initially doing things with her teammates because they had different interests to
begin with. For example, she said that her friends liked to go out and party, but she didnt feel
welcome because she was among the minority at the parties and she didnt like to go to them
either. That being said, it seemed easy for her to go out and make friends in other minority
different from what I had heard from the others. She said that sometimes it felt like being an
athlete was an occupation and the coaches sometimesI dont want to say treat it like a job, but
its a business I guesseven at the college level. With that added pressure of having to treat the
sport you love as a job instead while also having to understand that the coaches are there to do
their jobs as well, athletes surely must be stressed more than the average student. That added
stress could definitely affect the lives of athletes in a way that no non-athlete has to experience
In the event that the research participants felt that they reached common ground and
acceptance with their non-athlete peers, it was most often due to participation in Greek life to
some extent. In other words, interviewees mostly felt that if they were to venture outside their
comfort zones, in order to truly be accepted they would have to participate in Greek life. It was,
sadly, not uncommon for these athletes to have had experiences in which they felt that they were
discriminated against.
For example, Sam told me that his experience here has definitely changed as a result of
being a minority. He believes that he experiences racism in the form of micro aggressions on
the regularnot that vulgar[but] probably once every day. As for more major examples of
discrimination, he did tell me about a specific incident that occurred that truly opened his eyes to
blackand the quarterback Nathan, whiteso two black kids, one white kidwere walkin
downtown, not really doing anything, we just got done with a game I think we werewere just
out to have a good timego to a house, knock on the door and, kid came outjust belligerent,
just drunk, like it was bad, it was badand then he states, no niggas allowedget these niggas
off my porch, so like we didnt want any trouble so I go like, lets get outta here and Nathan, he
hes ride or die bro, hes ready to fight at any time if he feels like somethingssomethings not
likesomeone or some people arent being treated right, hes gonna say how he feelsand
usually thats how I feel, but I dont want any trouble at that point, justlets get outta here. So
the kid runs inside, Nathan takes his back foot and just starts bangin on the door, kid comes out
and hes like, what are these niggas still doin on my porch, soall in alla fight almost breaks
out, we had a lot of chicks hold us back and that kinda stuff andyeah thats pretty much the end
of that
as a researcher. Realizing full well that being a member of the white majority made my
experience very biased, I could not fathom such an exchange taking place on the same campus
that I have made my home for the past three years. When he noticed that I found his story to be
rather shocking, Sam made sure I realized that that kind of thing doesnt happen all the time, but
it has happened to him and other minority students here on campus. When I went back and
examined my interview with Sam it became obvious as to why he might sometimes re-think his
choice to come to Bucknell based on some of the experiences he has had here. In addition to the
seclusion he experiences as an athlete, he also has to deal with the added isolation of being a
minority here on a campus where there are so few others with his background.
Brittany told me just like the other minority athletes that she feels misunderstood and
sometimes feels that other students judge her unfairly before they even know her. When I asked
her about whether she thinks she gets treated differently because of being a minority student
I havent had anything too extreme happen to me, which I dont know if its cause of my
height or people just seem like intimidated by me (laughs) or somethingI mean its like a lot of
people say a lot of stereotypical things, but nothing extremely racistbut, I dont know, I just
think from what I know about other peoplewith minorities on campus, they just feel a little lost
I guess
It seemed through her explanation that she thinks people are wary of her. She described
thinking that people sometimes seem as though they are intimidated by her height or may say
things that indicate that they dont understand her background or experiences.
Unlike, Brittany and Sam, Carlos and Rachel tended to view the campus as very
accepting all around. When prompted as to why they felt that way, both credited their
involvement in Greek life as the primary reason for their relative comfortability at Bucknell.
Carlos admitted that his involvement in fraternity life has definitely aided him in his ability to
feel comfortable talking to other people. On this campus where most of the social scene is run
by Greek life, he feels it is important to be involved, even as an athlete, if you want to form
meaningful relationships. Furthermore, through his assessment it seemed like one of the only
routes for minority students and athletes to escape their isolation is to join a Greek organization
Rachel also commented on the usefulness of Greek life in making more meaningful
connections outside of the athletic realm. Rachel did not have trouble making friends on the
volleyball team like Brittany did, however she did note that she had similar interests as the rest of
I love my teammates, yeah all my best friends are on the team and in my sororitythere
are girls on the team who dont get involved in Greek life and they have a tougher time making
friends I thinkI just think being in Greek life trains you how to interact with the rest of the
Although my sample size was small at five participants, it is worth noting that some
participants felt much more at home on Bucknells campus right away. Those that felt most
comfortable often attributed it to their backgrounds and experiences in dealing with crowds as
non-diverse as Bucknell. Those that went to private school beforehand, or public schools that
exhibited a white majority, felt more comfortable rather than shocked at the state of Bucknells
Because Sam went to school at a relatively diverse and integrated high school in
Cleveland, Ohio, he seemed to say he was caught off guard when he came to a school as
undiversified as Bucknell.
Its funny cause when I first started lookin here, we didnt even look at the race
breakdown solooking back, I probably would say that I probably shouldve paid more
attention to thattheres a lot of things going to college that a lot of people just doesnt even
look into
Because of his history in a diverse public high school Sam did not know what to expect
upon arrival as a student. Others, like Rachel and Brittany, who had previously attended private
schools were relatively used to the disparity in race. Carlos also went to a high school that was
not very diverse, even though public. When I questioned what their reactions were to the racial
breakdown at Bucknell, they similarly responded that while obviously not diverse at all, they
were kind of used to it. Their ability to assimilate into Bucknell culture, however was very
different. Whereas Rachel utilized her private school background and Carlos used his high
school to their advantage in order to fit in with the, similarly white, kids at Bucknell, Brittany
mentioned difficulties at first. Perhaps this was due to her initial years in public school, or rather
a different racial breakup of the sports teams she was a part of during high school.
Darren told me that he had to change the way he portrayed himself before ultimately
neighborhood had taught him to walk around without a smile and to look through people.
He said that at home, walking around smiling or without caution could be interpreted as
weakness and it is important to seem confident and solemn. At school, however, he quickly
learned that seeming unapproachable was a very quick way to become an outcast to the rest of
the student body. It was his relationship to his teammates, however, that he credits for the ability
In the end, there were several things that emerged as the most important things to take
note of from all of the interviewees. I made sure to take note of things that were true across the
board and also how different each participants individual experience here at Bucknell is, even
when their backgrounds were fairly similar in nature. The first thing that I noted was that
depending on how the interview perceived themselves, the relationships they formed could have
been limited. For example, Darren talked a little bit about how people view him as
unapproachable when he walks around campus, so he feels as though he could make more
friends if he didnt mistakenly portray that. That also played into the next concept that touched
on how athletes believe others perceive them. If they believed that others perceived them in a
negative light or rather one that they did not believe was accurate, it was unlikely that they would
An athletes background and childhood growing up before coming to Bucknell also had a
lot to do with what they experience from day to day. Some participants grew up in very diverse
neighborhoods and went to public and diverse high schools. So, when those athletes came here
they received a huge culture shock and had to learn how to adjust to such a non-diverse
community that they werent used to. Other minority athletes grew up in the same kinds of
settings as they experience here at Bucknell. Those athletes went to private school and
experienced being a minority in high school as well. Therefore, when they came to Bucknell
they werent as shocked and were more easily able to fit in and find people that they could form
friendships with.
An athletes friendships were largely determined by their time constraints across the
board. Even the athletes involved in Greek life talked about how much more time they have to
devote to their sports lives than their social lives. Thus, the most amount of time in their weeks
are spent with the other athletes and they form their most meaningful relationships with them. If,
however, the athlete is involved in Greek life on campus, their attempts to make friendships
outside of sports seemed to be grandly more feasible. In the end, it was way that the athletes
structured their activity outside of an athletic setting that seemed to truly impact whether they
had non-athletic relationships. Most athletes seemed to choose the easier route and stick to their
original group and spend time with other athletes even in their free time. Some, however few,
chose to join Greek life or seek out other minority students in order to find other opportunities.
Every single athlete had a drastically different experience here based on a number of
different factors as explained above. Some had opinions as drastic as saying that they would
have changed their decision to come to Bucknell if they had known about how undiverse the
population was and what that meant for the community. Others thought that even though
Bucknell isnt a diverse school they consider it one of the safest places for anyone to go to school
In the introduction section above, I mentioned in my theoretical framework that there are
certain structures in place that perpetuate a certain level of segregation and structural constraints
that cause the same. This was true across the board for the athletes. They all explained that
because a lot of the influx of minority students to this school is due to athletics, their main
interactions with other minority students here on campus took place in an athletic setting. Many
said that they felt more comfortable talking to other minority students even if they werent
athletes, but those interactions were minimal. Moreover, a large portion of minority students is
part of the athletic community here at Bucknell, which keeps the community somewhat
segregated. The time constraints and structure of athletic schedules also perpetuates that
segregation. Since athletes are on the same schedule and dont have as much time to spare as do
non-athletes, they tend to stick together even outside of athletic settings just because they
Doing this study I learned quite a few valuable lessons about doing a qualitative study.
First and foremost, I learned that you might not come out to find a single answer but rather a
more complex combination of a bunch of factors that results in the experience that you are
studying. In my case, I gained knowledge about the different backgrounds and experiences of
five minority student-athletes here at Bucknell and, while their experiences were all different,
they all helped reveal more about the subject of interest. I also learned that my own relationship
with an interviewee had an effect on the quality and longevity of the answers I received.
Furthermore, the participants that I already knew and had relationships with beforehand were
much more likely to open up and share with me so our interviews went more smoothly and
offered a greater amount of information. The student-athletes that I had never met before were a
Knowing what I do now, if I were to continue this study, I would interview each
participant more than once and develop different lines of questioning for each successive
interview in order to develop comfort between the interviewee and myself. If I had more
questions and a greater comfort dynamic in all of my interviews, I suspect I could find out even
more information about the experience of a minority student-athlete here at Bucknell as there is
Comeaux, E., and C. K. Harrison. "A Conceptual Model of Academic Success for Student-
Kimball, Aimee, and Valeria J. Freysinger. "Leisure, Stress, and Coping: The Sport Participation
Harper, S. R., Williams, C. D., & Blackman, GREEK. GREEK. (2013). Black male student-
athletes and racial inequities in NCAA Division I college sports. Philadelphia: University of