lncoducelassignifcan new
polis Fst, hse ae
‘to egulte popular msi
Sal pne lated oboe
ty Second cone popula,
ttnaton of Live Ai, ad
urn tothe sigan of
einche me
il ot be coe to exper
Say be ices acer
er fom the sine of omoion
enc ere That lb
ether dhe eestiions
vied vero ba rl etn
‘ance, who have ween
snyet heb ew here
renin Tol she
Trterene provider acl
demourl nny mene
pot Pap Mi) ewe
shoves from the Rensis
eracknowidement eto
hee mri od myo
Erm, Sgr an een
Sage of The Spe Gi,
a Coan an ford
testo my Routede ets
th, New Zslnd, Aug 2000.
Chapter t
‘What’s goin’ ont?
Popular culture, popular music, and media teracy
Test nitty popes Whe wo pe sb
sacécvientclim, mech wing on populist west ti heaton
‘ome eu inche pene eld thin whichicesitaxed The il enc
heres wit the general mature and ole of poplar eure» wll phenmeno,
Primacy in contemporary soi but abo i em oft hist Jevelopmet,
‘Wihio this broader amb my inert with guetons about the nat ed
ration of poplar elt soil eeption, and consume, the de of
stain poulie cule and he way in which wch studs can bat be el
‘Tho questions embrace the dyamies of popular cule, cludes sal
the polite we In examining these quttons {ave dawn on ange ofthe
‘ei nd cesta material ees ste cll teh ly
td worsens ais. This overview indicates wha asm fo met be the srt
Poin snd peoecupaions ha chou form the dy of pop calare
| move fm this general dacasion eo fac on the stay of pop mn.
‘Academic nals of popular muse and sacs maniesans an ally
sow to develop. Daring the 197s and 1980s, even the increasingly popula ido
‘ed ses ened concentrates atenion onthe ial medi parley
‘elcvbon, nd nlc popular muse Tere wee nb exceptions nh the
wotk of schol such as Simon Fith, Geo Lipsy lain Chabot. Acgela
McRobbie, Richard Mido, Joba Shepherd, Dave Lang. Lawrence Gober,
sea Nebon Gage, Dring the 190, hee ws wtb ood of water, wel
saved ere sth umber of cone che dee on popular ns oon
lcasanapet of popularclareand mada ates While aed poplar ne
‘shal continued produce important ew wok (eg Fh 1996, Groner, 92Lipits19, chy were joe by write sich Andy Bennet, Manas Bas
Mavs Bye Sata Cahon,Recboe Onl, Phil Hopwank Seve Jon, Tony
“Machel Ret Nos, Wil Stand Deena Weise.
fe flats mean of chp
The new pinence of opular msc st
ties cent 9 sol cll pbenomenon, asocied with » mb
Cllr. nao many fasted popu clare ech ot ino every ng
‘Paste Th marying leary epost and peice
top fom 1 range offence, ncaling poli economy
Fein sti, sod medina cis ith ome ch here o film
(rarer wed eval thoy foe the wt
Bisiogayes in Oren 1995, Hagen 19952, pec, Sherbet 1997
sho Shker 199)
“The dcanion hee neces slective se highly condensed cencentating
cn thse questions theoreti postne ad appeoaehes which oom the back
‘pointe tent Ihave tterptedtomake theoreti mania ccc
{oon falar mith he moe extensive original dcusons, while the wx
‘sed endercan allow thse up ia the ferences povided
‘As Horer nd Sw (1997) shure, the diernt mening given tems
commun tthe vray of popu muse wate including the very terms
oul nt ms’ el shape the music ad ourexpeience oft Accordingly,
‘ain by claifingsome ey empire’, Poplar opel ms
then moe onto able examination of ver cetal us sy atempe ta
alse he popu the lnm Betver ved etre rd ear preeences
‘Begone eno se prefered esting the planer ofthe ext and eau
ring rae and dete ove he eof popular sre. A ber ays i
the eumieaon of popular clue ar then outines the high elt toon,
cried vith Leave English etic the mam ocey tess seca ith
Frankie Schost Marsan thee vines of ertcal dia theory ~ poliiel
economy eval, ad ctu and aly attempts wart ps
Inne sles ofthe popuac In ach ev, examples of the apt ofthe
theoreti penpecive to poplar muse ae presente
“Themeaningand iy oftrmsstcha poplar ans specily ine
(ceo empl, Willams I98I; Ep and Sedgwick 1999) irl, "popule
tsi’ a asocind ee uh Tok ork ll and pop are sed by ms
‘Cn fnsandscaenc nals inaconfing variety of ap Then heres ed
Ivemy’ sera which ert ter to econespain eer leeicy
tome cea dng of al os of medi, mln popular mas nll
2Any Bennet, Marie Brn
1 Hayward, Seve Jone, Tony
des sngion of whoop
tocted wih ullon
beret fan appoate the
ial econo ula sali,
ech hee if le,
seca they (ce the ie
especialy, Shepherd eal. 1997,
thiy condo, concentrating
‘Shs whic kom nde ck
hort trl ccs
"co, ede ce
vr.
erent mening ger ves
specs fe Aconting
Peale and pple mie
ral ses i any mp
hae aclu preeencs
sles of heen and eer
Tare. A number of ys
tthe high ular waon,
Society thei asoced wih
te media theory ~ ple
Is atemps to aaltepet
ples of the application ofthe
i
4 ma epecily nein
dere Gucusion and debate
ck 1999). Silly opr
Mandy ate sd By mas
rf way Then tered
‘eae prinorental tee”
‘eating popu musa
thas tne be remake hii w define nem whi
se wll practice wally comomicphes or pote cones od hah
awe aot sie but consandy eval Indked pate Hk ways pease pend Sting
Keane hile ering
within bite gop Ths 0 se des
Bevin drriing
‘Ar Buuntin oseve, thing ons cldy afis ones hig
‘nice donee nis’ (98418) Academia wn aly
“onto cpr the relinstapbstwoen pul ue nd lala
mrs be row acy of ts expering ou sins am
floss asc toc enc ge, aetna ati th
‘thea (0! Choyer 11). oun nos of elo expe a Ben ly
fever wa apie tov
“Thornton dation of eller the UR).
te pate and les of i preeenes (
Aner ine of debt oun popular ele st belo rl in iin
repent voles Wits wh concent onthe text se fi
“ng cones fom semocc and pychoanuytic alas ae tat these
‘hoe in he tour apf ing ha a dbouimant mesa st win the
Stra leeds conversions and practices o he prcennd onsie
Thrash there doin ule, vw strony dled ineuaa
theory Een i we acest the ation of telogelydominan vals an whi
le onsen may et lily ov wun by ache per
wing cmaiing ds als, est Be pea md the acres
tre that eau a whole a0 In prt cdot our ee
Freese eps aking ens’ of hem a diferent war. Tsp a
Thee ef popular esicnceandeabversn of dominant cule,
“The ann ay encima bee atx ads consumes cannot be
ame te of, on tent carceritc lone, The extshisr con
‘nol podton and comunpenaeamprtant ss the nati of i allen
sn the aroun ways in whih they mite thelr encountcr with Ce text
‘Ginvendy, nr can meaning be py ea of fom ee ctrl Tain of the
‘Sonmmer Tet and andes inert, Herman al Hoare (1979) pone to amumber
sdemgles of his occuring ith poplar aie wx the Sev’ "Pat of he
UUnon vended dec sack on tae untonin, achive he oposte fee
by Coventry car wear we ional Balla, You News Wk
o
when
‘Aone en up by Liverpool ol Ci spore ece athe
ety they conclade: "Bron corte intertts, Boa they
Song th consmptonw nor macy pase A sors meanings ot nab,
“4keting. Forde Sack
dleconomicenerencc ef poet
Int penal gender sopra
socal ponte open
{offense ln uthingmon:
‘Aca ily wily
i an any
oing os een se
‘lca, on ater ee
vaca a eon ly
slr of aie pecrences (eg
1 olga ae reefing
‘eet the txt eh, fen
Solan age tact foc
“inne msgs etn ce
‘ceo the prem an ane
teu deed neu
aly donoee ve and te
Seto buy i the red
Finder ei col
Tinie way Thon
bien cle.
tea comes can
Alone The tents ave cond
sermithe ef der
tice ecnntr wh thee
som the waco fhe
‘rte (97) pneos umber
“eve the Seu Pat fhe
tion achtved the epee Be
Sol bal, Yo Never le
pores beeen othe ot
sce hey ante
“cnt neg om
lrnkpesoc of cnt’ (Herman nt Hore 1979:53)-The ty pp me
ss ein dt eau ean ar only mae by ores oe
thi rosa t uskr conditions aed eros
(Grape)
Some aon commento lading to being del opal eal, de
ac fal conveying he hin of uly plese, an aeaton of are
Jidwmene chroush the mpi sugustion ea culn' lp ml Yet eo
Bnuman and Darth Vit, ER and he Simpsons, Maton and Spengacrs
Ryord Chandlers Moro nl Raber Pathe’ Spon sto sl schnelee
hace alien in pout el, an that pas sigan le inca
lives This she eae even withthe wo ley eet in pe Boone he
reduction of popu cle Fogerty sides the eeu ly to mee
ory marks taste: For example, ne 90 percent of receded mk ld
ronfock msc nd its asecinted genres, he ince fm ths core mare nly
nef subsiding dealer market or tcl ms cha claclnd
‘The show lt of popular clr hee and tus ines the words
Played by herent Tobe able to parte nthe mori eat kia
Aicasing lst evenings television programmes (Want Cope Closer pa
that emerency room sene In ER, peippss a knowledge ofthe pal
propane, ts mig charter a native dynamics Te pose sone
‘eth mn’ arent ove hereltve eof ani ofthe vata mrs
Parla performer Srl You'd ape th Dyan 19ers ae suptor thie
Aube wok? The inser able jin ihe ite, pode eo se ha he
omy background knowlege ~ cura ail - todos. Allee pe ew
fas ben tered the pleas ee exch sic sleet with prc eras
&F popu colare anda fume wih its cides and Convertor, they
ovine tan estes remot enjoyment ofthe fr
he pean ofthe text can lo be phys: the slay pleases of bring
Sheri in ‘aus rent, creeing anos of privacy a lf sation ay
‘ins and craton the sheer tale ples fang corals, th
Sis scxorenving rial of wing the scene for leteningcleming the eon and
ganew be deeve notes and the physical plu thse oe ef eat
Belt which vove activ paripaton, txt nly dine. Then th ae the
onal esses ro be dered fem both he anton and eomsmgton a
Bilis pls a weeloved ecole fll, 4 fvourte aot eon
geo anther once bya fot performer Fagen sah pau
Hin cee of citar the lene fom eve eons nd once
880 se moment oeonspeon Theses dnenson ol hi
1s‘hate asumytin ees ae with rnd Gal nd lve an pavak
Contest ford porat ofthe ge, fo catching up om gpa othe ne
Tra bck row oftheir peal replaced ye ngs
there vd, or he Int dt om! Comunption as acl tty oes
to pay the indivi hota of dhe tet whic
Popular culture, ‘ettects! and morat pante
“The atience reset (0 poplar caer media has fe
sesctanon host enced owl stay chal ode In Earl nthe
ims ceed fea) se
rete cotry parce
Cle wih the cist wis and el of workings an ner
tlle la groups The mile closes lanl conceived of these lower clas boc
ind behav annoying, mast immoral ada tte, deen an
Alngercu Accondacly thee energal dee to replte and ental popula
pry thse expsmns of ated wih roy, pbb
toe ecesive dking and lence
The dapee of tcc the Visovan ring cw enjoyed i dt project, al
woring-
che sen ase "What reo doops ld fr thr ch
encod heavy meal fk ete” Tica it teed ou us
Hertel lfrntcion thi is evider win ees sachs heavy nt
feshnadance mnie ace Caper),
opens whan you we ear o view sath that you mde che
furs his proces of medion no uth ta nda pc
level. silenced bythe conten within whch he activity exe,
Sex, eerily us ecteamic dem, tha the Fc of piel“The pli csnomy ape o dhe pans ms hs ts ting
thefissuethe po ed an taco ive
bythe logical the purse ssi
reared only. lively sl
Pike acl are tud i dhe United Ste i
et Hsopeal pow, Sflr (199) fw raced he per
anneal in ace information ander paces de t che
re oad erttion abroad aie her ection od
and pbc emus Commesgon the Unie txts Bin (197)
ae ea smal mb of the cot ngs i eomorations ave
Sos pom than any pate basins fs ever
{ec posed nmol soy peter cet
ae uy farce prof this poses of comoliiton of peril oro
caesarean vam 198), Arbus the consequent vein contl
eee rend ube trees operat i a the laos beowecn diver
inert
va aay (he Feit School aubl a
‘Chil pital
sr el wo devel te sgniance of cule, ing pray the
pus aeey, The inflocnce of pies ooo i
tcfltion of the con
ce fhe cupmcntf han contempt Marxists who exh th owe
SERIA canton tc mnplte anderen cans: mata auences
More hn ay fhe the efoming ts the wo ong donned By
eee eae eon the ne and el the orl ens he mia othe
Tne ptbliy of aeraive sim mating termes eu ale
sae rants chan pom non-erene The son stcsongiba ely
spel comma The vy that ogi te pve rope of
- (Rosen 179-40)
“The ptr of pom oot cpt ns indry. abe 0 mails
ea erie forte and malice strees how che mac bine ROW 0
Me ofa aetwek of ese nd enterinment cpio pied
Pree melon an ait mximinto (Bere and Cavanagh 199)
Fos areeihr i lami am ecole unetalon thes, popularised
aera ah pled ht ss mated opel, piary om
(hc, swamping the nest ality of ia ka forms
“Schgcstmsconal os easiap ino aormof econo Seerminsn moi
ro eames) coniney thew sing cle rc by oni elon,
20st mis in ie seting in
‘tal atten nly rv
seu. The bt ha thee ce
Mumberafpelysnl seman
ed Ses ssn inven,
>) ap ened the pore and
san call pra ew the
ibe hereto, nd
Fe Unie Sees, sgh (1997)
pet ilar corporis ave
fam any pate bins a ever
Ings new communication cre
afeomeluacn of gral rp
thecomaxuent quston of onto
rlhereatmbipBetweoh der
Frankf School i angably, a0
lr, sing i primal 2 the
Indence of pollen
lant whoerphaiethe pert
sect ates
the wrk of song dominated by
somal ere ofthe lic the
‘aking themsles heal aby
The son that sang a ly
‘og the pve pope bs
(Rosetan 1979-40)
se ima to mania ad
tow the ei ines nat
eraamen corporations, pitied
ton (Benet an Cavanagh 194)
{tal ingen tens poplar
sporulation
‘eset a
‘ef ecoromi dermis, maria
‘proce by economies
POPULAR CULTURE AND Music, MEDIA LITERACY
soning ay Seo he
‘ecm pelea male be
ce (nc
ato of he peste. Tey noe
rh oerting dhe conapion om
rive aetvy. Chica politi econo sli en toner
bb urge thc many mane ofoppoirn is mock ngthe
symbubereolrf abun ifetey comune andthe diction
Ice the ely Reston fem Hammar oe 1979:un Gage 2).
CContangurary poll wanomy thera have become more spite in
thei aprctton ofthe recieve elton Between fe aed spentnactie,
Medi rsctcons hve ben examine by aking main ets who pte the
‘est? For wha aon! In whose terete Wht ese? Sach interop
thn nsesiins examin pat alin em thins cones
func fwesechnol lie tne a hie ont of
«nse. sr loblcatyalenaupo th cha colar pci ve
has uranic, with the stat ofthe lea aa ils oo
elstion being seen in more open and ameter oe Wala td Ml
1984 Robinson 191 anal he dicsion im Chapter 4), This ew wos hoe
‘smertedthe importance piel econo, which come i in he
let dele in efaming olor mse
Structural and musicotogy
‘Sinctui view of pula cular concentate on how meaning gee
ate in ot texs exmining how the art’ of the tex (al, eto
hor) pots pre okilteanings Sah ye pray thoy
sens the sudy fs a ete which termes totale hom the toca
tener fatext combi o reenter extn’ (ors mente doer
san, mesoge or munity) forthe enaumer (iene, iene, rae Sch
pooch involves ystetclyuoonering the vr layer of meaning in eae,
‘Attn sophisicae oreeee, Spending on ouput ew), thsevales
the aplication of pyehenalps, i conjuction wih emits to ck hoe
‘ei teats shape the inva uncon the consumer Secor ee
Sher fr example, wll ero how fl und tevin roams potion the
“ites ‘cnsrct sets in secon withceen colo positon
‘The macloia agpeich canbe regalo 8 eet om ela
alysis ieprileptbe et by pine empha inlyom eer popc
fs: Mascolgi tackle grves such pop and eck mse, sing comet
tel derived fom the say of more eons frm of sie harmony,
Fela bes teh, andthe re: Academic miso, meer, esi ane
Wes Mc 986; Shep 1991: Midleton 1980), al as a ied ingen
Pelermecrcan Tus suet mt on-clsicamcn eal
PPK general lck formal meal, ad he ler proce
2ith he wcidoy of mek The obs daly wih dhe masa pp
thor the proceuation with the tex nad of olf many cons kceon
Imi ab Socal henrmenon. The mic Done dene yrcene
Tachi soil ee,
Tne, cm be
cl that much poole mc ly a mac of dhe ba
sl emoxon nits nna enna nly be shea ong ens
shown by Path comparan of tao expanaton ofthe Anima” 196 he
Ching Rikon! Midleton, 8 mscloge,empbaiesin hi exp eh
arma msl quali th competion inching the pon te
The cos elation in the sit (hich oie and a
spalens of la not ring fi
‘onal impletions ‘The del
te) meth
maine confic erm mel
ake moverent ofthe int, wiht
bie cles wth he teal ned fr ar ink imped ye 2
Baers
(ite Fit 198.13,
Comareshis th Alan Pc deepen wot the mica ve (Bunko) dc
the words and ve a tren opts nee in Blackpeol We ja ack
‘ogetherand rede tad by chance ow ces i)
Sich exampes aside, msclogy deters eter pes than thas eee ne
we an point ea nmi of ect examples fs help pletion o> pol
ric (eg Mowe 195; Becker 1995, Comach and Bonne 1997) kas
sppcaton ropa ext ae examined a Caper
Carat peretves on populace hare examined the ution f how he
imei acl ndetake the poditon of consent esc concn and ole
‘ea srucres which fou the maintenance of dominant ters ace, fr
‘example, che ely mor of Sot Hall) Those working in thas have hoon
ttt infenced by the Wew of the lean Marit hens, Arsene
Gramsci che concep of espa hegemony. advanced by Crome
phn how a ming cass maieans i doninanc doh achieving popular
‘conser mdse though he vrcus nine cladng thes
in ren hee
sclgion an popular eat. olga hegemony hes ee
Sen the emgmsition of consent,» proses underpinned by the how of sce
yal curcin by the Sate Aa important ase hep that iis
and cones exsting oer ret nd soi rngerens. Plead
‘ule ae conse ttc nd univers eo
2
set ae the poplar menty wth he mesg pyran
‘Lal omit ny inalratonof
Teeomer» demoed pre,
rideraionel
sic is ig 90
twihca ton spec
tral en cosy boone rte
thn ofthe Animal 1964 btm
smghases in his explanation dhe
ding the on ha
is melodie and harmon) ne dhe
sila confecr berween mel st
torent ofthe oxi, with
aor teed pal bythe L2-bat
(ete eth
S13)
se the msn reason) dl
san Blackpool Wet ck
ent (i)
ere prea has ese and
2p application to pole
{and Boone 197) vale and
Supers
tralism and popular muse
examin he quation of how the
Se forts economic nd pb
oman nares 6
‘Sn Manta theoreti, Aone
Fegeny advance! by Gras 2
cance though achieving 2 pops.
fonsofaciey nluing esol
“ecg hepemon dh pe
‘ered by te deat cto
fpectofhepemoay isch msi
Tenge Particles ad
son ene and he pop il
ay eng olen his proces Heweve,sinony ve abt, Bt
inte’ ond being eallngal nd,
“Those who tr dhe remo of pope
psitpreces, who Mey che many sens of epi
‘mica who cipher and connctons at wee within the ae
‘katy an he sally esrb ‘lati nthe wing on pope nn
fulalon sbseprny he wrk on mn nd youth subeleres cet
wih Bingham Gene fr Cater Carl Sais (BOCLS) rn
‘he 197s Will 1973 Heb 1979 Hal ol foro £978) This ta dy
‘ork nhs the pce of dhe inva in dhe dentin of carck
cnr, For expe, Chabert the onan inp between cmt
Galfcson Kiva engeince!
For afr the commrchal power af the rear companies has been coisa
ser the ponenine sie of Ue rab sku, arth ecomen
‘onsof he mse pow me lly dhs who by the cond tne
theryhm allve tothe exh demons, dete the determina con
‘ose procton, the wid poste ep
{Chambers 1985 lendtion
Ins Fhion, Millen (1950) places popular unica the pce of oti
ton an camstion ying eewsen the ped? an he then’ a
tphasses there acanony fcr cies,
Filly. the mye of potoderis ee oe acknowl with it challenge
1@ the ctblshed notions of repesentin ithe verbal hd ul apres
osoolem eis co blr nat ely ds the ain ppt ad
Brendes ren the ett a the mci herent och moe
al eorer ih rd low ela The prec rate of pstmt, howree,
roves ar o in down anche ia ated lack of tty a cosieacy all
ang vase the erm
Ts sey ely contbeton, Poseoderisn, or the Curl Logi of Late
alan Janeon overviews posnoderian a the cll expres of new
ff capil, chants! by cotmuicatons achnolge cating he
ly escnamious shfig of incerta erie, the emerges how
sf epi (Japan) i gba eons, new clas foratns beng
be oe Lour ver capital don, anda cone capt hich
nage and tates as much acta product. The commodiction of
Fas esl anew poplin ofthe min ule ental rd
2Bsity of emeurtl eeaion (mca 1984; a a the weng oF
pester hr Beat and yor
Despite pln as gene explo of deepen ia
clr, reser ae fom » amber of dn. To eed
(inlay ae, prdeo hardy 2 wnt th
Fost) thos tt ruc lack pectic, over psec with fs
nd suines tthe expe of loti tha ihn the eorumica prec
‘coneext wih whch cult pot rae alc
rs enon ‘aton clases tons of pod
(scence 19.
‘A for patasder ths we popular in the 1980s wath cee cement
torson popu au who dhe me, once cid with youl clin
nd plain enw dhonohly commercial nd cpr i
estar cipal oer What was once revolt ha Bs
mother apd polite
mca and okie
the
fell emp, Mae fr Pm (1988), pd in bis contbucon ths id
"olune Fang The Mio (19880), Sion Fah ugg dea fcuk
nc, poxmekeic pops woluetoe ne where seat jee re
Ht: nan arate of 3 numberof yor contemporary pop sts, Hill echo!
Ado esti of ppl neat maufetial mam cute. Apprprntely
subd "Manuctcing the *0s Pop Dre Hil dy of performer suc
‘Mehl Jackn, Dun Dun, sd Madonna, aged that hs eh pin of
senuinel lal prctitonen ar reajand wing to mance themselves (ht
erp) and that never before ave commerce an rey 20 haps eld
Ind (1869, While bh ith and Hil conc that‘ ely ber
shoe more hv ja msc hey ed
chad never been aoe oad was
increingly abvered tothe eis commercial, Ths eo mize
stro opr mn, which han lays ben at em party ku lend ones
ss do pis the continue pil axe o many comin ere
tuaclon ovo pected endef, he nceang eden of sicher
ality and eck and cond nerened ctu futon andthe calling of
Tow cle pe diction in ack Pasmodeni view of man vide or
ample egy rend ia exemplifing ce calle ofall intone
‘erwcen art nd the commer, the athte and the uae, andthe
sthertc nd ae (ey Kaplan 1987), However thi conan pox
hing actly boing me adolf ding the ater 19%.
ablieao mn elven sch w MTV, Goodin (99; 199) et
24Sve ko the wring of rch
af explanation of developments in
mmber of dificil
‘se hay bey theta
iets overprenccputin wth ets
thin the economia probe
is edt of ary and pis
sss of preteen
4h 1980 wih academe coment
ascot with youth bln
vec an incorpo ito the
revo hal bse le In his
‘in bis condom to his eid
I sageted heal of ans
where ssh jenny are
fon MTV and i pic in Ssh
temporary pop st, Hil echosd
‘ture ma eure. Appopriaely
ils say of eformer such =
ned hi th sh pels of
lingto manutictre themselves (hie
sce and rest 0 gpl Bed
ence that hs lays ben
idrever ben meres an ws
‘ian Tho trope te
‘eee ply abo yeaa
my fs consent ee
‘isco popular mae rary
rngevidence of sche, inert
Saal fon andthe alg
desist views of ts vide
‘allie of radon dine
tie nd the ume, and de
‘ever th conflation of perm
sxc, wth mate tele
Sem digheler 1904,
Goi (1991 le 1993)
fs numberof pon whee the debe sou postmen nce with
orl ms: che mnt whee clans ve mae or teat een ofp
‘mods; the we of ampling and panic; the emenence of oredr
Foran of sane "which exktnte pusiche nal soeiel eee oe