Operarecognovitb 03 Platuoft

SCRIPTORUM CLASSICORUM
BIBLIOTHECA OXONIENSIS
OXONII
E TYPOGRAPHEO CLARENDONIANO
LONDINI ET NOVI EBORACI
APUD HENRICUM FROWDE
PLATONIS OPERA
RECOGNOVIT
BREVIQVE ADNOTATIONE CRITICA INSTRVXIT
IOANNES BURNET
IN VNIVERSITATE ANDREANA LITTERARVM GRAECARVM PROFESSOR
COI.I.EGII MERTONENSIS OLIM SOCIVS
TOMVS III
TETRALOGIAS V-VII CONTINENS
OXONI
E TYPOGRAPHEO CLARENDONIANO
OXONIl
Excudebat Horatius Hart
Typographus academicus
ft
t-3
4
PRAEFATIO
In his dialogis recensendis partim novis collationi-
bus usus sum. integerrimum in tetralogiis V-VI testem
Clarkianum (B) ipse denuo excussi et pauca quaedam
a Schanzio parum accurate enotata obiter correxi, id
agens praecipue ut veterem diorthotam (B 2 ), sive is
Arethas sive librarius Arethae fuit, a recentioris aetatis
correctoribus (b) ubique secernerem. codicis Vindo-
bonensis 54. suppl. phil. gr. 7 (W) lectiones in tetra-
logiis V-VI viro doctissimo Iosepho Kral plerasque
debeo ; is enim de omnibus fere locis gravioribus

certiorem me fecit et in Lachete et Menone collationes
suas comiter mecum communicavit. in tetralogia
VII eiusdem libri collationes a Kunzio in Schanzii
usum comparatas compilavi. in Gorgia, quotiens de
codicis W scriptura non constabat, in eius locum suc-
cessit eiusdem stirpis Palatinus Vaticanus 173 (P),
quem diligenter contulit scholaris noster Petrus S.
M c
Intyre, in Italiam a curia universitatis Andreanae
studiorum causa missus. codicis denique Vindobonensis
5$. suppl. phil. gr. 39 (F) conferendilaborem singulari
humanitate ultro suscepit et perfecit Iosephus Kral,
cui praeter omnes ex animo gratias ago. codicis
Veneti Marciani app. class. 4. 1 (T) lectiones Schanzii
editioni omnes acceptas refero.
PRAEFATIO
In tetralogia VII, cum Clarkiani (B) auxilio
destituti simus, ducem potissimum nobis eligendum
esseVenetum T rectissime statuit Schanz, ita tamen
utVindobonensem W
non ex T ad nostram memoriam
propagatum esse fateretur, sed ex communi fonte,
quem littera M significavit, derivatum esse. illud
addit, in tetralogia VII familiae primae auctorem esse
W (Platonis opera, vol. IX, p. x). duorum praeterea
librorum, Veneti Marciani 189 (S = Bekkeri 2) et
Vindobonensis $5. suppl. phil. gr. 39 (F) rationem
habendam esse duxit, suoque iure statuit nec S ex
Vindobonensi nec Vindobonensem ex S descriptum
esse, in Hippia minore, Ione, Menexeno ambos
sed
libros ex uno fonte, quem "nota N significavit, de-
scendisse, quem fontem novum esse neque ex M
derivatum, collatis locis quibusdam a Dionysio Hali-
carnassensi et Stobaeo excerptis, demonstravit. vides
igitur Schanzium in his tribus dialogis fontem ab
archetypo familiae primae et secundae diversum
agnoscere quod tamen addit, Venetum S et Vindo-
;
bonensem F non testium duorum loco esse sed pro

uno teste valere, licet in Hippia minore, lone, Menexeno
probabile sit, de Hippia maiore vereor ne festinantius
concluserit. scilicet ipse nos docuit in Gorgia, Menone,
Hippia maiore descriptum esse S ex Veneto Marciano

31 (Bekkeri T), codicis W affini, qui hos dialogos post
Parmenidem insertos habet, ut ordo Thrasylleus turba-
tus sit, post Alcyonem vero in S quasi novum librum
incipere, cui nihil cum T commune sit ; complures
enim dialogos ex diverso fonte petitos adiunctos esse,
quorum primi sunt Hippias minor, Io, Menexenus
(Platonis opera IX, p. xix). vides in his sex dialogis
PRAEFATIO
duos fontes repraesentare codicem S, quorum alterum,
ex quo Hippiam minorem, Ionem, Menexennm habet,
non est dubium quin recte statuerit vir in his rebus
sagacissimus Vindobonensis F quoque fontem esse, sed
nullo pacto inde colligere licet etiam in Hippia maiore
eandem memoriam referre F et S, ut in hoc dialogo
vetustissima memoria redintegranda sit ex solo M
(ib. p. xviii), id est ex librorum TW communi arche-
typo. etenim veri similius videri debebat Vindo-
bonensem F, qui Gorgiam, Menonem et tetralogiam
VII iusto ordine deinceps exhibet, hos dialogos omnes
ex eodem fonte, archetypo N, descriptos habere.
nempe hic est ille liber quem in Politia ex exemplari
pervetusto uncialibus litteris exarato derivatum esse
monui, idemque de eo etiam in Gorgia, Menone,
Hippia maiore valere iam tum suspicatus sum, cum in
eius apographis, vel certe affinibus, Flor. x et Ang. v,
complures errores invenissem, quos ex unciali scriptura

ortos esse in aperto erat, et rem procul dubio ita se
habere ex Kralii collationibus statim intellexi. ex libro
manco et mutilo uncialibus litteris exarato hic quoque
descriptus est Vindobonensis F, cuius rei fidem faciunt
lacunae in textu altera manu (f) suppletae et errores
quales sunt Gorg. 467 b ex crat a P r0 0"X erAta (CX6TAIA)
et 525 c ZSibov pro h aibov ( AIAOT) *. tenemus igitur
in Gorgia, Menone, Hippia maiore novum archetypi
N testem, in Hippia minore, Ione, Menexeno aliquanto
sinceriorem codice Veneto S, quae res vel inde apparet
quod in F loci Homerici non ad exemplar librorum
Homericorum quod passim in S factum
correcti sunt,
1
Classical Review, xvii. pp. 12-14.
PRAEFATIO
videbis, ut uno alterove exemplo allato iam monuit
Schanz.
Codicem Vindobonensem F in Politiae praefatione
non aliunde ut fit interpolatum esse dixi, id est nullas
lectiones a prima manu habere ex aliis libris Platonicis
invectas, quod video nonnullos perperam intellexisse.
non enim in mentem mihi venire potuit interpolationi-
bus omnino carere textum quem praebet. immo vero
interpolata erat et multifariam deformata recensio
quam sequitur, sed haec omnia magistello nescio cui
Byzantino, non librario indocto, imputanda esse
arbitror. his igitur neglectis, vide num interpolatorem
redoleat lectio kv -nvOLov pro h ttvOoi (Gorg. 472 b) vel
oVois pro 0eoij (ib. 492 b). num casu factum videtur ut
plurimas Aristidis, Dionysii, Stobaei egregias lectiones
F aut solus aut cum Veneto S confirmet ? nemo, opinor,
haec serio affirmabit. quare meo iure videor etiam
in Gorgia, Menone, tetralogia VII, hunc codicem in
testimonium vocasse.
IOANNES BURNET.
Scribebam Andreapoli
e Collegio S. Salvatoris et D. Leonardi
mense Mariio m.cm.iii
Impressio secunda non nullis in locis correcta.
mense Ianuario m.cm.ix

6
DIALOGORVM ORDO
TOMVS I
TETRALOGIA I ED. STEPH.

EVTHYPHRO I. pp. 2-1
Apologia Socratis . . . . I. pp. 17-42

Crito I. pp. 43-54
Phaedo I. pp. 57-118
Tetralogia II
Cratylvs I. pp. 383-440

Theaetetvs I. pp. 142-210
SOPHISTA I. pp. 216-268
POLITICVS . . . . . . II. pp. 257-3II
TOMVS II
Tetralogia III
Parmenides III. pp. 126-166

Philebvs II. pp. 11-67
Symposivm III. pp. 172-223
Phaedrvs III. pp. 227-279
Tetralogia IV
Alcibiades I II. pp. 103-135
Alcibiades II II. pp. 138-151
HlPPARCHVS II. pp. 225-232
Amatores I. pp. 132-139
DIALOGORVM ORDO
TOMVS III
Tetralogia V
Theages I. pp. 121-131
Charmides II. pp. 153-176
Laches . II. pp. 178-201
Lysis II. pp. 203-223
Tetralogia VI
evthydemvs I. pp. 271-307
Protagoras I. pp. 309-362
GORGIAS I. pp. 447-527
Meno . II. pp. 70-100
Tetralogia VII
HlPPIAS MAIOR III. pp. 281-304
HlPPIAS MINOR I. pp. 363-376
10 . I. pp. 530-542
Menexenvs . II. pp. 234-249
TO.MVS IV
Tetralogia VIII
Clitopho III. pp. 406-410
Respvblica . II. pp. 327-621
TlMAEVS III. pp. 17-105
Critias . III. pp. 106-121
DIALOGORVM ORDO
\+*x/
TOMVS V
Tetralogia IX
MlNOS . II. pp. 313-321
Leges . II. pp. 624-969
Epinomis II. pp. 973-992
Epistvlae III. pp. 309-363
Definitiones III. pp. 411-416
N06EY0MEN0I
De Ivsto III. pp. 372-375
De VlRTVTE . III. pp. 376-379
Demodocvs . III. pp. 380-386
SlSYPHVS III. pp. 387-391
Eryxias III. pp. 392-406
Axiochvs III. pp. 364-372
SIGLA
B = cod. Bodleianus, MS. E. D. Clarke 39 = Bekkeri 21
T = cod. Venetus Append. Class. 4, cod. = Bekkeri
1 t
W = cod. Vindobonensis 54. suppl. phil. Gr. 7 = Stallbaumii

Vind. 1
F= cod. Vindobonensis 55. suppl. phil. Gr. 39
P = cod. Vaticanus Palatinus 173 s

*= Bekkeri b
S = cod. Venetus Marcianus 189 = Bekkeri 2

; :
0EATH2
st.i
AHM0A0K02 2&KPATH2 EArHS P I21
AH. *X2 ScoKpare?, (be6p.r)v arra <roi lbio\.oyrjcracrOaL, a

et o-)(oArp kolv et acryoXCa 8e p.r) Tiavv rts ueydArr, duco?
euorj eVeKa 7rotr/o-ai crxoAr/r.
2,12. 'AAAd Kat dAAcos rrjyxdrjco oypXaijjov, kol br) crov
ye eVeKa Kat -navv. dAA' et rt j3ov\ei Aeyetr, eeoru\ 5
AH. BorJAei orjy derjpo ets rr)v tov Atds rorj eAerjfleptorj
aToav iicnoboov aTToyu>pr)cr(x>p.ev
212. Et 001 8oKet.

AH. "Icouey brj. '12 2coKpares, 7rdrra ra cpvrd klv- b
dwerjet rw avrojj Tpoirov e\eLV, Kal tcl Zk rr/s yrjs <pvop.eva
Kal 7a ioa Ta re dAAa Kat avdpcoTros. koX yap iv rots

cprjrots pacrTov r)p!iv tovto ytyrerat, octol rf/rj yrjv yeu>pyov-
uer, to TtapacTKCvacracrdaL iravra rd 7rpd rorj cpvreveLV Kal 5

avTo rb cpvrerjcrar e7ret8di> 8e rd cpvrevOev /3tco, uerd rorjro
OepaireCa tov cpvvros Kal TroAAf/ Kat xaXerrr) Kal bvcrKokos

yCyveraL. orjrco be e\eiv eotKe Kal to Trepl rcor avdpoiiTOiV C
dird rcov eyâvrov eyob 7rpayudrcoi' reKpatpouat Kat es raAAa.
Kat ydp euot r) tov veos tovtovl, etre cpvreCav etre 7rat8o-
ttolCov bei avrr)v ovop.aêLV, irdvTOiV paarrr yeyovev, r) be
rpocpf) bvcrKokos T Kal del ev cpofioi 7repi ovtov 8e8to'rt. 5
a 1 ltiio\oyf)<raffOai] Sta\oy(ffaffdai ci. Cobet a 2 nav el) Kav $

vulg. a3 tvtKa T : 'ivtKtv B W b1
post S^ dist. Cobet
post ffwKparts BT b 3 avOpwiros Schanz: &vOpwiros B T C 2 rSAAa
B W : to aAAa T C 4 ficj.ffTri ytyovev, fj 5e rpo<pi} T /$aaT7}' ytyove
:
Si rpotpr) B
PLATO, VOL. III. 1
Mic IIAAT&NOS
to. fxev ovv akka Trokka. av eti) keyeiv, r) be vvv Trapovcra
eTTLdvfxCa TOVTca irdvv p.e </)o/3et eVrt fxev yap ovk ayevvrjs,
o~(pa\pa be lTn6vy.il yap bi) ovtos r)fuv, o> ScoKpares, u>$
d c/>rjcri, crocpbs yeveadaL. y&p p.0L, tG>v tjXlkuot&v Tives

8okco
avTov Kal br)fX0TG>v, els to &arv KaTafiaCvovTes, koyovs Tivas
aTTOfxvr)p.ovevovTes 8tarapdrrovo-ty avrov, ovs e(yjko>KV Kat
7rdA.at fxoL Trpa.yp.aTa Ttapiyei, o.lG>v eTTLfxekrfdfjvaL p.e kav-
5 tov Kal xPVriaTa rekiaaL tlvI tG>v aocpLO-TG>v, octtls avrbv

crocpbv iroLrjo-eL. ifxol be tG>v fxev xPVlJ aT0> v Ka * ^karrov '
122 fxe\eL, r)yovp.ai oe tovtov ovk els fiiKpbv Kivbvvov teVat 61

o-TrevbeL. t4o>s fxev ovv avrbv Kareixoy Trapap.vdovij.evos'
eTretbr) be ovk4tl olos t4 et/xt, f)yovp.aL KpaTicrrov elvaL 7ret-
6ecr6aL avrG>, Xva fxf) tto\\6.kls avev ep.ov avyyevofxevos rco
5 bLacpdapfj. vvv ovv 77KCO eV avra ravra, tva rco tovto>v

tG>v crocpLCTTGtv boKOVvro>v elvaL o-vo-rqcroi tovtovl. o~u ovv
fffxlv els KaXbv Trapecpavrfs, & ap eyco /xdAtora ej3ovk6fxr)v
,
Trepl tG>v TOLorjTo>v fxekko>v irpaêLV o~vfxf3ov\evo-acr6aL. a\\
et tl e^xcts o~Vfxj3ov\eveLV e &v efxov a.Ki)Koas, eeort re
b Kat XPV'
212. 'AAAa fxkv br), S> ArjfxoboKC, Kal \eyera( .ye crvp,-
(3ov\f) Upbv XPVP- a ^vai. (t-rep ovv ml akkr) ffTLcrovv
icrTLV Upa, Kal avri) av eir) Trepl rjs o~v vvv crvfxj3ov\evi)'
5 ov yap ecrTL irepl otov deLOTepov av av6po>Tros (3ov\evcraLTo

7) Trepl TraLbeCas Kal avrov Kat rcoy airov otKeiW. 7rpG>TOv
fxev ovv eyco re Kat crv o~vvofxokoyr)o~o>fXV tl ttot olofxeda

tovto etvaL TrepX ov j3ovkev6p.da' fxr) yap TrokkaKLs eyco
c piev akko tl avTo VTTo\afx(3avo>, o~v be a\\o, Ka7retra Troppoi
TTov Tijs o-vvovcrCas alo-doifxeda yeAotot ovtcs, eyo> re 6 o~vfx-
C 6 roWa &/] -ro\v a" fpyov Cobet d 1 Sokw ydp fioi an Soku
ydp fioi ? Stephanus SoKeTv ydp fioi Cobet
: d. 5 avrbv abtuiv W |
BT d. 6 Ka\ secl. Cobet a 1 /xeAei B fxiWzi T rovrov :
B: tovtuv T fiiKpbv BT fiaKpbvW :aa ffirevSei (ô-ittvSovra)

Schanz Q,- &/] 5); Cobet a8 (rt) irpdêiv Cobet Ci inro-
\afif3dvuv Cobet C 2 ffvvovffias B T crvvriOetas alffdtifieda
: W
BT : oi'o-0o>0 W
0EATH2 I22C
iSovkevm- kcu (tv o oTu/3orjAerjo'uero9, fxrjbev rS>v avrStv
r)yovp.evoL.
AH. 'AAAa uot boKels 6p6<as KeyeLV, co 2ooKpares, Kal 5
TtOLCLV \pi] OVT(D.
2X2. Kat Ae'yco ye opdoos, ov ueVrot iravTa.TTao-( ye*
0-p.LKpov ydp rt /jterartfleuai. woco yap ur/ koll 6 uet-

paKLo-Kos ovtos ov tovtov ZiTLOvpLe? ov r/uets avrov ol6p.eda
(TTL6vp.eLV aAA' erepov, etr' au ûei? ert aTOTrooTepoi coueu d
7rept aAAou rorj /3ouAerjo'uei>oi. opdoraTov ovv uot 8oKet
etrai cnj arjroC rowrou apyjecr6aL, bLaTrvv6avop.evovs ort Kai
eorty oS e7ri#i;uet.
AH. KtrSwevet yow ovrco /3e'Artcrrw etâi co? cru Aeyet?. 5
2X2. EtVe 8r/ uot, rt KaAoi> ovop.a rco veavio-Ku; tl avrbv

Trpoo-ayopeva>p.v ;
AH. edyrjs ovop.a rorjrco, ob 2coKpares.

2X2. KaAoV ye, a> Arjuo'8oKe, tG> vel ro 6vop.a edov Kal
lepoirpeTTes. ei7re 8?/ r/uii>, co 0e'ayes, eTTLdvp-elv obrjs crot/>os e

yeveo-6aL, /cat dtois o-ou tw 7rare'pa roy8e eêvpelv dvbpos
tlvos o-vvova-iav tolovtov oo-tls ae o~o<pbv iroLrjo-ei;
0E. Nat.
2X2. 2ocporjj be Kakels -noTepov tovs e7rtoTrjuoms, 7rept 5-
6'rorj ay TTL(TTi)p.oves Sxtlv, r) tovs p.r\;
0E. Tovs eTrtorrjuoi-as eycoye.

2X2.Tt ow; otjk e8t8daro' tre 6 7rar?/p Kat e7ratoerjo-ei>
aTrep kv601.be 01 aAAot 7re7rat8erj7jrai, 01 rcoy KaAcoy Kaya6S>v
7rare'pcoy vet?, otoy ypap.p.aTa re Kat KLdapCêLV Kal TraXaieiv 10
Kat T^y dAArj7j dyooviav;

0E. 'Eue ye.
v
2X2. Ert ow otet rti>6s e7rtcrrr/urjs eWeiiTeiv, ^? Trpoo~r\KeL 123
V7rep o-orj rov irarepa TTLp.e\r}6rjvaL;
C9 Wu^fiBTW: 4wi6viJLTJ scr. Ven. 184 d6 aAii' secl.

Baiter : koI ci. H. Richards d 7 irpo<rayopcvu> H. Richards
e8 /coJ (naiSfvo-tu secl. Cobet ai eAAei7rcii' B 2 T: ÂAittcii/ B
1*
123 a 11AAT12N02
v
0E. Eycoye.
212. Tts (otlv avrr); et7re kol r)pxv, Xva <roi xapLod>p.eda.
5 0E. Otder Kal ovtos, 3) 2coKpares e7ret 7roAAaKts eyco
avrco etprjKa dAAd ratVa ee7rtr?/8es' 7rpos o"e Ae'yet, cos 8?/
ovk etdcos 1
ov eyto kiTL6vp.Gi'. rotatSra yap erepa Kal Trpos e/xe
/xdêrai re Kat o?3k e#e'Aet pe ovSevi o"?jtrr?7o-ai.
212. 'AAAd rd p.ei> cp.-rpoodev ool T/y 7rpds toutov p?/0eVra

b too"7rep dzêu p.apTVpcov Aeydpera* vuzn 8e e/xe 7rot?/o-ai p.dp-
rupa, Kat ivavTLOv ip.ov Karet7re rts etrrw avrr/ r/ o~o(f>ia rjs
tindvp.is. <ptp* y&P> e ' e7re0d/xets ravrr/s t^ ot avdpcoiroL

tcl 7rAota Kv(3epv<aoLV, Kal eyco cre erdyxaroy dyepcorcozr
5 "*12 0e'ayes, rtVos e?;Se?js coz> oocpias /xe'p,t/)?/ rto 7rarpt drt
ovk e0e'Aei cre ovvLOTavaL itap &v av oi) oocpbs yeVoto;"

tl av p.0L ancKpLVoo; riva avTr)v eXvai; dpa ou Kvfizpvr)-
tik?jz>;
0E. Nat.
c 212. Et oe iiTL6vp.(av Tavrrjv Tr)v oo(piav etz>at oo(pbs r/
rd app.ara KvfitpvGiOLV etr' ep.4p.cpov rto irarpi, e/jtou au

ip(OT<ovTos tls ioTLV avTrj r) oocpia, TLva av aiT(KpLVcx) avrrjv
etmt; ap' o^t r)vLO\LKr]v;
.5 0E. Nat.
212.
?
Hs 8e 8?) w ruyxdz>ets iTTidvp.G)V, noTepov avco-
vvp.6s tls icrTLv r) exet ovop.a;
0E. Ot/xat eycoye exetz>.
212. ndrepoy oSy avrr)v p.\v oXo-6a, ov /xeVroi rd ye
io 6vop.a, ?/ Kat rd 6vop.a;
0E. Kat rd 6vop.a eycoye.
2/12. 1 1 ow otlv; et7re.
d. 0E. Tt 8e dAAo, S 2toKpares, ai/r?/ ovofid tls ipair) dz>
etVai dAA' r/ oocpiav;
eyei) oiit^ B T
a5 avrip iy&> a 7 erepa
: W W et in marg. b :
eVtB eTt Kal trepa T

: a 8 ovSevl B T ovSfV : W b2 ivavriov
B T ivavriwv B
2
: b 3 iire6v(<L(is corr. Coisl. : rin0t/jue?s B T
b 6 i$e\(i T t'0e'A?; B :
0EATH2 I23d
2X2. Qvkovv nai r) f)VLox*Ca aocpCa IutCv; rj ajxadia

hoKii o-ol elvai;
0E. Ovk e/uotye. 5
2X2. 'AAAa crocpCa;
0E. Nat'.
2X2. *Hi tC \p<aixcda; ov\ rj Itnroiv iiTLcrTdp.6a (evyovs

dpx^Lv;
0E. Nat. io
2X2. Ovkovv kol r) KvfiepvriTLKi] crocpCa ccttCv;
0E. "Ep.oLye Sokci.

2X2. 'Ao' oi>x avrrj r) TtkoCoiv kTTLcrTdp.(.6a dpytLv;
0E. Avrrj pikv ovv.

2X2. *H? 8e 8r) o-rj cttl6vplls r) cro<pCa tCs Zcttlv;
fj
tCvos 15
TTL(TTdp.6a dp\LV / e
0E. 'E/aoi /utev 8okci, $ tu>v av6poiiroiV.
2X2. M<Sv rf t<2v Kap.vovTOiV
0E. Otj btjra.
2X2. 'Iarpur) yao at/rrr iariv r) ydp; 5
0E. Nat.
2X2. 'AAA' rf rcoy ahovToiV kTTLaTdp,t6a V tols xP^ s
dpxeLv;
0E. Or5.
2X2. MorjtrtKr/ ydp arjrrj ye; 10
0E. Yldvv ye.

2X2. 'AAA' rj twv yvp.vaCop.ivoiv e7Tto-ra/ue0a dpx^tv;
0E. Ov.
2X2. Tvp.vacrTLKi) ydp avrrr ye;
0E. Noi. 15
2X2. 'AAA' 17 tS>v tC ttolovvtcov; Trpodvp.ov elirciv uxnrep
tyoi crol rd Zp.Trpoa6ev.
d.3 ^cioêia T W
rjvtoxla : B d.6 irocpia B : aocpia T
d 13 oux
01/TTj vet.b ovk avri]
: BT d 15 77 B3 : tj B 62
j scr. recc.
^BTW fet mox 63) e 10 fxovfftKri corr. Par. 1812 fiovo-iKrjs
:
BTW
124 a 1IAATX2N02
T
124 0E. Hi tG>v iv rr/ 7ro'Aet, epotye 8oKet.
212. Ovkovv kv rr/ 7ro'Aet dcriv koll oi Kap.vovTs;

0E. Nat, dAA' ov tovtojv Ae'ya> p.6vov, dAAd Kat tw^
ak\a>v tG>v cv Ty 7ro'Aet.
5 212. *Apd ye p.av6dvco fjv Aeyets Ttx vyl v i boKels ydp /uot
\4yiv ov\ fj
tG>v 6epi6vT(ov e7rto-rd/xe0a apyjuv koll rpvycbv-
TCOV Kal T&V (pVTtVOVTCDV Kal CTTTCLpOVTCOV Ka\ akoCOVTCOV
avTr] p.ev yap yeoopytK?/, ?/ tovtojv ap\op.ev. ?] ydp;
0E. Nat.
b 2X2. Ovbe ye otpat 17 tojv irpLôvToov Kal TpvTtojvrojv Ka\
(6vto)V Kal TopvcvovToov crvp.TrdvTOJv e7riordp.e0a ap\Lv,

ov TavTt]V Aeyets* avrr\ p.\v yap ov tktovlkiJ;
0E. Nat.
5 212. 'AAA' to-cos ?/ tovto)v re irdvTcov Kal ovtGjv tG>v
yeojpyG>v Kal tG>v tcktovojv Kal tu>v brjp.iovpyG>v d-ndvTOJV

koI tG>v IbioiT&v koX tG>v yvvaLK&v Kal avbpG>v, raurr/r lacos
Ae'yet? ttjv crocpCav.
0E. Tavrr/y 7rdAat, S 2aKpares, f$ov\op.ai Ae'yeu\

v '
C 2X2. Exeis ovv et7reu>, AlyLcrdos 6 Ayapi.ip.vova d-no-
v
KT(vas iv Apyet apa tovtojv & v ~v Aeyets, tGjv re
rjpx* v
br\p.LovpyG>v kol IbicoT&v koX dvbpGv kol ywatKwy crvp.tidvTojv,
?/ dAA<oi> tlvGjv;
5 0E. Ovk, dAAd tovtojv.

212. Tt Se brj; Hrjkevs 6 AlaKov Iv <>6ia ov tG>v avrG>v
tovtojv ripxw;
0E. Nat.
2X2. rTepta^Spoy 8e tov Kv\f/ikov dpxovTa zv Kopiv6co
10 ?/8?/ aKrjKoas yevtcrdaL;
0E. "Eycoye.
2X2. Ov tG>v ovtojv tovtojv dpxovra tv rfj avrov 7ro'Aet;
d 0E. Nat.
a 6 TpvydvTwv B T W t&v TpvywvTwv t

: bi irpiovTwv Cobet
b3 yap oi>] yap Schanz e 12 avrov B: ax/Tov T: ai>Tij
vulg.
0EArH2 i24d
212. Ti 8e 'Apxekaov tov YlepbiKKov, tov zêcocrrt tovtov

apyjovTa iv MaKe8oju'a; ov tG>v avT&v r)yf] tovtoov dpyjtiv;
0E. 'Eycoye.
2X2. 'ImrCav 8e rbv neitHOTpdrou iv Tf]bt rfj 7ro'Aet 5
apavTa tCvojv otet apai; ov tovtojv;

0E. rToSs" yap ov;
2X2. Etirois av ovv p.oi Tiva iircovvfxiav eêi Bolkis re
Kal 2i/3uAAa Kal 6 r)p.baTibs \AiitptAt>ros;
0E. TCva yap aWrjv, 3) 2coKpares, irXijv ye xprja-paoboC; io
212. 'Opd&s Aeyet?. dAAd Kal Tovabz p.oi ourco 7retp<S e
aTTOKpivaaOai, Tiva (Trojvvp.iav eêi 'I7r7rias Kal YlepCavbpos
8td rr)v avTr)v ap\r\v;
0E. Ot/xat p.\v Tvpavvoi' H yap dAAo;
212. Ovkovv OCTTiS (Tn6vp.ii T&V dvdpOiTTOiV t&v iv rfj 5
7ro'Aei arvixTrdvTOiv apyjav, Trjs avrijs dpxrjs Tovrois e7ri0i>/*ei,
TvpavviKrjs, Kal Tvpavvos clvai;
0E. 4>atVerat.
2X2. Ovkovv TavTtjs ktnOvp.eiV av cprjs;
y
0E. EotKe'y ye e<f &v eyco et7rov. io
2X2. *X2 /xtape', Tvpavvtiv dpa r)p.S>v iiTi6vp.S>v 7rdAat

(p.ip,<pov r<5 Trarpt ort ae ovk e7rep.7rei> ety [8iacrKaAou] 125
Tvpavvobibao-Kakov tivos; Kal av, 01 Ar/pdSoKe, ouk aiayyvr)
7raAat ei'8cos ov e7ri0up;ei ovros, Kat extov o0t Trip.\}/as avrbv
br]p.iovpybv dv e7roi?7cras' rr/y trotptas rjs e7rt0up:ei, eVetra
(pdovis re atrto Kat o?3k e0e'Aets 7re'/z7reti>; dAAa w opay; .
5
e7rei8r/ IvavTiov ip.ov KaTtCprjKi aov, Koivfj /3ouAeJJtop:e0a
eyco re Kat tn/ es rtVoy dv avTov Tiip.Ttoip.iv koX bid tt\v

tCvos avvovaCav crotpds dv yivovro Tvpavvos;
AH. Nal p.d Ata, co 2a>Kpare?, /3ouAeuto/xe0a o?/ra, cos b
8oKet ye' pot fiovkrjs btlv irepl tovtov ov (pavkrjs.
d.2 rovrov corr. Par. 1812 tovtwv : BTW:

secl. ci. Stephanus
e3 aurVl avrwv Baiter e 9 i-n-iQvp.tlv T imBvfitis B (sed :
suprascr. r) a 1 SiSacrKaAou secl. Schleiermacher a 3 '6di\

owoi Bekker ol Cobet : a 6 &ov\tvw(ie6a b t3ov\tv6iit0a B T :
a 7 e'y rtVos Bekker (is riva corr. Coisl.) : iariv ol B : io-Tiv oX B T

2

I25b ITAATX2N02
2X2. "Echtov, H>ya6i. bi.aTTvd<op.tda avrov 7rpG>Tov iKavGts.
AH. Ylvvddvov brj.
5 2X2. Tt ovv av et Evpnribri rt Trpoo~xprjo~aip.6a, S> 0e'ayes;

Ev0t7rt8r?s ydp ttov (f>rjo~i.v
crocpoX rvpavvoL tG>v o~o(pG>v crvvovcriq'
et ovv epotro' rts tov Evpnribrjv "*X2 Evpnribr\, t&v ri

C o~ocpG>v o-vvovo~iq <pr\<s o~o<povs clvai tovs Tvpdvvovs ;" locnrep
av et et7roVra
o~o(pol y(opyol tG>v croqbdov (rvvovcriq,

" TG>v n
r)p6p.eda ti cro(pG>v; ri av r)pXv aTTtKpivaTo; ap av
5 aAAo ti rj tG>v ra yecooytKa;
E. Ovk, aAAa. tovto.
2X2. Tt be ei et7re
crocpol /aayetoot tG>v o~0(pG>v o~vvovo~iq,
et r)pop.t6a' " TGjv rt o~o(pG>v; " ri av r)p.lv diTt\KpivaTo; oi>x
io ort tGjv p.ayt\ipo)v;

0E. Nat.
2X2. Tt 8' et
o~o(pol TraAaiarai tGjv o~o(pG>v crvvovaiq
lttV, et r)p6p.cda' "TG>v ri (rocfiGiv;" apa oi)K av tG>v
d TTakaUiv (prj;
0E. Nat.
2X2. 'E7ret8T/ Se et7re
croqbol Tvpavvoi tG>v o~o<fiG>v crvvovcriq,

"
5 r)p.G>v cpo)T(ovTo>v " TG>v H cro<fiG>v Aeyets, o> Evpnribr);
rt av cpairj; Tjoia av eTvai raura;
0E. 'AAAa p.a At" ovk 018' eycoye.
b5 irpoirxprjcai/ueOa BT : irpoffxpri(r6fie6a W C4 ijp6fie$a Tb :
ripuifxida B tj ai' ^/uiV airfKpivaro BT W : ti ai' ofe airroi' airoKpl-

vacrOat in marg. yp. T Wb C 10 tcvi' fiaytipwv BT W ruv ixayttptKwv
W
:
in marg. yp. : tSv rb. fiaysipiKa Hirschig d 6 4>air) T : cpeuTji'
B (sed suprascr. n) irola JivTW: ttota a B : iro?a Hermann : fort.

tto?o 5^ d 7 iywyt T : iyt B (sed suprascr. "yw)
:
0EATH2 I25d
212. 'AAAd fiovkti eyco trot eiTrco;

0E. Et av /3orJAet.
212. Tavr ZcttIv airzp ecpr/ 'AraKpeW rrjv KaAAtKpirr/i; 10
e7Ttcrracr0af r/ ovk oXcrOa to aapa;

0E. "Eycoye.
2X2. Tt ovv; rotarjrr/s rwds Kat av crvvovcrias 7TL0vp.LS
avbpbs dtrrts Tvy\dvL dpdrexôs cov KaAAtKptrr/ ry Kvavrjs e
Kat " e7rt'crrarat TvpavvLKa," cocr7rep (KeCvrjv ecpr/ 6 7rotr/rr/s,
Lva Kal crv rjpuv rvpavvos yzvr\ Kal rfj 7rdAet;
0E. ndAat, co 2coKpares, crKco7rreis Kat 7rat'ets 7rpo's p.c.
212. Tt 8e'; ov ravrr/s tprjs rr/s crocpCas Zttl6vp.(lv rf 5
7raVrcoi; av t5>v 7roAtrcoi> apyoLs; tovto oe ttoliov dAAo rt r/
rdpawos di> etr/s;
0E. Er}atpr/i> per ay otjuat eycoye rvpavvos yevicrdaL,

pdAtcrra pev 7rdi>rcoi> avdpcairoov, et 8e p:r/, cos 7rAetcrrcoi>' Kat 126
crrj y av otpat Kat ot dAAot Trdvres avQpanTOL ert bi ye
tcrcos paAAoy 0eds yevicrOai
dAA' ov tovtov eAeyoi; eTrt-
OviLiLV.
212. 'AAAd rt hr) etrrt 7rore ou kiTL&vpeLs; ov rcoi> 5
7roAtrcoy tprjs apyeiv e7ri#rjpeti>;
0E. Ov /3t'a ye ovo' tocr7rep ot TvpavvoL dAA' (KovTOdv,

oZcrTTep Kal ol dAAot ot er rr/ 7ro'Aet eAAdytpot drdpes.
212. *Apd ye Aeyets tocr7rep 0ep.toroKAr/s Kat neptKAr/s
Kat Ktpcoy Kat dcrot rd 7roAtrtKa deti>ot yeydracrty; io
0E. Nr/ Ata tovtovs Ae'yco.
212. Tt ovv et rd i7r7rtKa kTvyyaves ttl6vllS>v trocpds
yereVflat; irapa rCvas av d<ptKo'pei;os cor/0r/s detrds ecrecrc9at b

t7r7revs; r/ 7rap' dAAous rtfds r) tovs l7tttlkovs;
0E. Md Ata ovk eycoye.
d io KaWiKptrrjv scr. Ang. C. I. 4 KaWiKprjrrjv B T d 13 <rv W

W
:
BT: om. ei Ka\\iKpr)rrj BT Kvavrjs B: kuoj/tjs T

63 Ka\ Tj) B T &/ t? : W
et iv suprascr. b a 5 Sr) Laur. lxxxv. 6
TW et fort. B 5al B : b 1 rivas
a
tiVos B T et sic legitW :
schol. B
I26b IIAATX2N02
2X2. 'AAAa 7rao' avrovs av tovs htLVovs ovras Tavra, nai
5 ols tlcriv re 'lttttol kol xpGtvrai eKaarorc Kal oiKetots Kal
aWoTpCois ttoXXols.
0E. Aij\ov OTL.
212. Tt oe i tcl aKOVTLcrTLKa crocpbs ifiovkov yevicrOaL;

ov irapa tovs olkovtlcttlkovs <oou av eA#coy crocf)bs eVeaflat
IO TOVTOVS, oh 0-TLV T( CLKOVTLa Kal TToXkOLS KOL okkoTpLOLS Kal
C oiKLOLS kKOLO-TOT \pG)VTaL CLKOVTLOLS!
0E. "E/xotye SoKet.

2X2. Ae'ye brj p.ov eVet 8e br) Ta ttoXltlkcl /3ovAet croq^bs
yevtcrdaL, otet 7rao' aAAous tlvcls acpLKopevos o-ocf>bs ecrecrdaL
5 rj tovs ttoXltlkovs tovtovs, tovs avTovs re beLvovs ovras ra

ttoXltlkcl Kal xptopevovs eKaorore rrj re avr&v 7ro'Aet Kat
aAAats TroAAaty, Kal 'EWrjvicrLV TrpocropLXovvTas ttoKco-lv
Kal /3ap(3dpoLS ; rj ooKets aAAots rto-ti> crvyyevopevos o-otpbs
eVeo-0at Tavra airep ovtoi, aAA' ovk avrols tovtols;
d 0E. 'AKr/Koa ydp, a> 2<Kpares, ovs cri cpacriv Ae'yeiy tovs
Xoyovs, otl TovTdiv tG>v ttoKltlkG>v dvbpG>v oi vels ovbev
/3eArtot>s elcrlv rj oi tG>v crKVTOTopcov Kai /uot boKels akr\6e-
crraTa Ae'yety e tov eyco bvvapaL alcrOicrOaL. avor]Tos av
5 ovv etrjv et oloiprjv tlvcl tovtcov e/xot /xez> av irapabovvaL tijv
avTov croc})Lav, tov 5e vbv tov avrov p.r]bev tocpeXrjcraL, ei rt
otos t r)v ets TavTa aKpeAeii> aAAop SvTLvaovv dvOptairtov.
2X2. Tt ovv dv, 2> /3e'Aricrre dvbpG>v, \pricraLO cravrG), et
ctol e7ret8^ yivoLTO vbs TOLavTa irpdypaTa trapiyoL, Kal cpairj
e pev av eTTLOvpeiv dyaObs yevicrOaL o>ypdcf>os, Kal pepcf)OLTo
crol tG> TraTpl qtl ovk e0e'Aet? dvaXCcrKtLV ets avrbv tovtoov
avrGiv eVeKa dpyvpLov, tovs 8e brjpLovpyovs avrov tovtov,
tovs faypdcpovs, aTLpd{fiL re Kat pr) /3ov\olto Trap avT&v
b5 ots . 'linroi yp. t et in marg. W oJ tinrtKol BT W

W
. . : . . .
C i ctKovrlots secl. Hirschig C 3 iirel Se 5^ BT inetb'))Se

W
:
d4 itv oZv B : oZv ttv T d. 5 7rapa5owcu BT : irpoSovvat

d8 Schleiermacher
o-auT^)] avrcji : secl. Fritzsche d9 rotoDra]
Too-aoTa ci. H. Richards e 1 ttv] Sij ci. H. Richards 62 fort.
i0f\ots H. Richards
0EATH2 i26e
p.avddvLv; rj tovs avkrjTas, (3ovk6p.Vos avkr]Tr)s ycvio~6aL, 5
?/ tovs KiOapicrTas; eyoLS av axiT<2 otl XP$ KaL 07T0L Trip.TTOLS
dkkoo~ lAi] idikovra irapd tovtcdv p.av6dvLv;

0E. Md Ata ovk iyooye.
212.Nvv ovv ravTa ratira avrbs Trpbs tov itaTtpa ttolG>v 127
9avp.d(Ls, Kal pip.<P}] et drropei otl o~ol xPV"TraL KCLL ottol
TTcpLTroi; iirel 'AdrivaLcov ye t&v Kakatv KayaOStv tcl 7roAtriKd

6Ya> av fiovkj) o~vo~Ti]crop.iv o~, os o~ol irpolKa o~vveo~rai' Kal
dp.a p.V apyvpLov ovk dvakaxrtLS, dp.a 8e Trokv p.dkkov 5
cvboKLp.rjcreLs Trapd tols irokkols dvdpcoiTOLS ?/ dkkeo ra>
crvvcov.
0E. Tt ovv, w 2a>Kpare<?; ov Kal <rv t&v Kak&v Kaya- ^y

6<ov (fi^dvbpcav; et ydp crv p.oL idikoLs avveivaL, eâoKet Kal ~^~~ /
ovbiva dkkov V/ra>. 10
2X2. Ti tovto Aeyets, Qiayes; b

T
AH. X2 2a>K/)ares, ov p.ivTOL KaK&s Aeyet, Kal dp.a p.\v
x aP LV' OTL tvtov p.ti(pv dv Hpp.aLov

ip.o\ &* ^ K ^ "^'
fy-
r)yr]aaip.r]v, rj et ovros re dpicrKOLTo rrj o~rj crvvovcria kcu crv
idikois TOVT(ti crvvtivaL. Kal p.ivTOL KaX aio~yyvop.aL kiyeLV 5

a>s o~<p6bpa (3ovkop.aL. dAA' eya> dp.<poTip<tiv vp.Gtv biop.aL, o~i
t idikLv TovT(ti o~vvaXvaL Kal o-e p.r) (j~tlv dAAa> p.r]bvl
crvyyavicrdaL ?/ Sca/cparef Kai p. Trokkttiv kol <po/3eod>z> dirak-

Adere <PpovTib<tiv. <as vvv Trdvv <po(3ovp.aL vtrtp tovtov p.r\ c
rti>t dkk<ti ivTvxj] ota> tovtov biatpOt-ipai.
0E. Mr/Ke'rt vvv, a> iraTtp, vnip y ipov <po(3ov, et7rep
olos r et 7reto-at tovtov tijv ip.r]v crvvovcriav TrpocrbiâcrdaL.

AH. Tidvv Kak<as Ae'yets. a> 2a>Kpare?, Trpbs o-e 5' dv 5
?/8r/ etr/ 6 /xera roiJro Ao'yos" eya) ydp o-ot eroi/xds et/ut, a)S
8td (3paxi<tiv et7rety, Kat ejue xat rd e/xd <os oXov re otKetd-
e6 XPV T :
XPv!^> T ' B Siroi BT gjrr? W a3 x/yairot BTW:
W
:
-T(fi-TT) Bekker b 1 \eyeis T

(sed add. in marg. rec. b) om. B
W
:
b4 t BT: om. dpeV/cojTo B et yp. T: apKtaoiTO B (ut

2
W
videtur) T c 2 8ta^)0?pai B T Sia<pdapi]vai c 6 toOto : W
scr. Ven. 189 tovtov B T VV : om. B (sed add. in & TW:
marg. b)

137 c IIAATX2N02
rara itapiyziv, otov av 8e'r/ ep.fipayy, iav edyrr tovtovI
d aa-ira^rj re Kal eueoyerr/s otl av otds re r/s.
212. '12 Arj/xdSoKe, to uev icrTTovbaKevai <re orj davuafa,

et7rep otet rjV ip.ov /xdAtcrr' av croi tovtov <lxpekr]9rjvai ov
yap olba vrrep otov av rts vovv excoiv fxaXkov <nrovba(fiL r)
5 rj7rep rjeos ovtov 6ir<os ws /3e'Aricrros ecrrat ottoOcv 8e eooe'

crot rouro, cbs eyco ay judAAov tov crbv vbv oXos r' ebjv
<o<pekfj<raL Trpbs to irokirriv ayaObv yevi<r9aL r) crv arjrds, koX
OTrodev ovtos cpr/0>? iue puxkkov rj <re avrbv <o<pekr]<reLV, tovto
e iravv 9avuaC<o. crv yap irp&Tov uev 7rpecr/3rjrepos et iuov,
eirevra 7roAAas rjbr] dpxas *at rds /xeytcrras 'A0r/ivaiots ?}pas,

Kal tluo. V7TO 'AvayvpacrCcov re rcoiv Srr/xorcoiv Trokv p,dAtcrra
xat rj7ro rr/s dAArrs 7rdAecos ouServds tjttov e/xot 8e rorjrcor
5 ovbev ivopq ovberepos vu<ov. eireLTa et dpa rr]s pez> rcoy
ttoXitlk&v avbpGrv crvvovcrias Qedyrjs obe KaracppoveL, txkkovs

be rtvas ^r/r-et ot 7rat8erjetiv irrayyekkovTaL oloi re etvat re'orj$
av9p<oirovs, ecrrtiv ivrav9a k<u ripd8iKos 6 Ketos /cat Topytas

128 6 AeoivriVos /cat ITcoAos 6 'AKpayaivrtivos ccat dAAot irokkoi,
ot orjrco crocpoi eicnv cocrre efs rds 7rdAets tdivres irei9ovaL
t<2v ve<ov tovs yewatordrous re /cat 7rAorjo-tcordrorjs ots
eecrriiv rcoiv 7roAtrcoiv co ay fiovXeovTat. TtpoiKa crvvelvat
5 rorjrous 7rei9ov<TLV cnrokeiTTOVTas rds iKeiv<ov crvvovcrias
avTois crvvelvai, Trpo<TKaTaTi64vTas apyvpiov iraw irokv
p.L<r96v, Kal yapiv Trpbs tovtols elbevaL. tovtcov tlvcls etKos
r/y 7rpoatpetcrcât Kat tov vov <tov Kal avrbv cri, e/xe b' ovk
b et/cds* orjSey ydp tovt<ov iiricrTauaL t>v uaKapi<av re Kat
KaAcoy ua9r\uaT<tiv eirei kfiovk6p.rrv av dAAd Kat Ae'yco
brjiTov det ort eyco rrjyxd^co cos e7ros etTreiV orjdey e7rtcrrdju,eyos
irkriv ye <rp.LKpov tlvos p.a9r]uaTOs, t>v epcoriK&iy. tovto
d5 eSo|e <rot BT : <rot eSoge Priscianus d6 &/ secl. Cobet : 8^

H. Richards r' elriv Priscianus : re r fy B : re ?iv T e1 ^tfj/
in ras. B e8 Kelos B : kios T a5 roirrous B T om.: W

(sed cf. Apol. 19 e, 6) awoKeiirovTas BTW (cf. Prot. 316) : ebro-
Aiirovras Cobet (cf. Apol. 20 a, 1) a6 apyvpwv secl. Schanz (et
mox scr. iroAbv) irdvv ito\v Beck : irdfj.iroAv Cobet : irdvv iroAvv BT
:
0EATH2 ia8b
fxevroL to p.ddrjp.a rrap' ovtlvovv 7rotoi>/xat beivbs eti>at Kal tG>v 5

irpoyeyovoTOiv dvOpojirojv Kat tu>v vvv.
0E. 'Opas, S> Trdrep; 6 2,a>KpaTri$ ov irdvv p.OL doKet
[n] ert e0e'Aeti> epot ovvhiaTpifiziv e7ret to y ep.bv erot/uoy,
kav ovtos e0e'A?7 dAAd raura iraifav irpbs rjpus Ae'yet. c
e7ret eyco otoa tQ>v ep,u>v 7/AiKtcorcoiv Kat dAtyco Trpeofivtepojv
01 7rpti> p.ev tovtu> ovvelvai oibevbs dtot r)oav, iirtibr) 8e

crvveyevovTO tovtu>, iv irdvv dAiycp Xpovto TrdvTcov /3eArtot>S'
(paivovrai S>v trpoTepov \eipovs. 5

2X2. Otcrfla ovv olov tovto (otlv, co 7rat Ar}p.oboKOv;
0E. Nat p.a Ata eycoye, ort, eay cn> ftovkrj, Kal eyco
otos r' eo-ojLtat rotovros' yeveoOaL otot7rep Kat eKeti>ot.
2X2. Ouk, d>ya0, dAAd o*e Xe/Xrjdev olov tovt Hcttlv, eyco d
Se' crot cppdcrco. eort ydp rt 0eta /vtotpa TrapeTr6p.evov euot
eK 7rat56s apap.Vov baLpovLov. eort 8e rovro (po)vrj, r)
otov yivryraL dei p.OL o-r\p.aiveL, av /xe'AAco irpaTTeLV, rovrou

uTroTpoTrrjv, 7rporpe'7ret 8e OTjSeVore* Kat edi> rts /xot rco> 5
(pikoiv dvaKOLvG>TaL Kal yivrrraL r\ qjoivr], tovtov tovto, diro-

TpiirtL Kal ovk ea 7rpdrreti>. Kat tovtojV vpuv p.dprvpas
Trapiop.aL. Xapp.ibrjv ydp tovtovI ytyrcoo-Kere tov Kakbv
yevop.evov, tov TkavKOjvos' ovtos ttotz eTvyyave cp.o\ dva- e
KOLVovpavos /xeAAcoz> do-Ki]o-LV oTabiov ets Ne/xe'av, Kat ev6vs
avrov dpypp-ivov Ae'yeti> ort pe'AAot dcrKetV eyiveTo 77 cpojvij,
Kat eyco cWkcoAtjoV re avrbv Kat et7roj; ori " AeyovTos o~ov
v
p.Tav yeyove /xot rj (pojvi) 77 rou baLp.oviov dAAd p,? / dcrKet." 5
""Icrcos'," ec/>??,
" 0-rjp.aiveL ool otl ov vlktjooj' eycb 8e K&y
p,?/ pe'AAco vLkdv, yvp.vaodp.ev6s ye rotrroy r6i> \povov coc/JeA??-
t^?/cropat." raura et7rcoy ?/crKet* d^toy ow irvOeodaL avrov
b5 irojoCfcoi] /mV qui otofxai attt irpoa-iroiov/j.ai legendum putaret

Stallbaum : kvr iiroiov/j.ai Fritzsche rryov/j.ai Cobet
: b 7 6 Cobet
Srt BT (jiot secl. ci. b 8 rt om. Ven. 189
H. Richards)
c r idf\rj corr. Coisl. 40e\ot B T a\\a sqq. alteri tribuit B
W
:
e 5 (paiuovTat] ecpaivovro Schleiermacher d 5 8e T om. B (8' b) :
e r ytv6fitvov] \(y6/xevov Cobet e 2 vn4av T vtjxaiav B e 3 ri

W
:
B T om.: 67 w<p(\i)o-o/xat Cobet

:
I2Q a ITAAT&N02
129 a avT& (rvvefir) diro raurrjs Trjs dcrKT/creco?. et be fiovkecrde,
tov Tifj.apxpv abekcpov KkeLTop.ayov epecrde rt elirev avrQ
Tip.apxos fjvUa airodavovp.evos r/et + ev6v tov baip.oviov +,
eKeivos re Kat Et/a0Ao? 6 oTabLobpop.oov 0? Tip.apyov vtt-
5 ebeaTo (pevyovra' epel yd/) v/utz> ort et7rey avrco raurt.

0E. Ti';
212. "*2 KAeiro'/*axe," ec/>?i,

" eyco pevroL epyopaL diro-
Oavovpevos vvvi, 8to'rt 2coK/)dret ovk rjdekov ireideo-daL." ri
br) ovv ttot tovto eTirev 6 Tip,ap\ps; eyo> (ppdaoi. ore
b avio-Taro eK rou (rvp.TTO(riov 6 Tip.apyos nal <>Lkijpo)v 6
$>Lkr)p.ovibov airoKTevovvTes NtKtay tov 'Hpoo-Kap.dvbpov,
r)-KLcrTaarQr\v p.ev avrco /udz/co tt)v einfiovkrjv, 6 be Tt/xapx ?
avLo-Tap.evos irpos ep.e et7rei>, " Tt Aeyet?," e(pr), " 2> 2co-
5 Kpares; ip.eLS piev iriveTe, epie be beX ttol eâvaa-TrjvaL' rjo>
be okiyov vo-repov, eav Tvya>." Kai p.oL eyevero r) cpo>vrj,
Kat et7roi> irpos ovtov, " Mr)bap.S>s," eq>t)v, " avacrTrjs' yeyove
ydp poL to elo>66s crrjp.elov to baLp.6vLov." Kat 6s e-necrye.
C Kat 8taAt7rcoy yjpovov avdLS o>pp.aTO levai, Kal i-cpr)' " Et/ut
brj, 2coK/>ares." a30is eyevero r) (poovi)' av&Ls ovv avrov
r)vdyKacra eirLo-yjelv. to rpirov, (3ovk6p.ev6s p.e kadelv,
dvecrTr) ovKeVt eliro>v p.oi ovbev dAAd kado>v, eTTLD)prjaas
5 dAAocre tov vovv eyovra' Kat ovtojs cpxero d7Tttoi> Kat 8te-
7T/)dfaro e cov $et aTro6avovp,evos. oQev br) tovto etirev
77/)os tov dbe\(p6v orrep vvv vp.lv eyoj, otl lol airo6avovp.evos
Oid to epol aTTLo-Trjo-aL. ert Toivvv irepl t5>v ev StKeAta

d 7roAAcoy aKovaeo-Oov a eyco ekeyov irepl rrjs bLa(p6opas tov
o-TpaTOTTebov. Kal tcl p.ev 7TapeX.r)Xv66Ta rcor etSdrcor ecrrtr
aKovo-aL' irelpav 8' eêcrri vvvl Aa/3eti> tov ar)p.eiov et dpa
tl Ae'yet. eVt yap rf) eirl crTpaTeiav eopp.f) Savviwvos tov
a I B T PovKeaOai B
PovXetrOe
2
: a 2 tpeadai B T (sed e supra W
ai W) a 3 jB T: ejfyt in marg. B
2
Sat/xoyiov] drj.uiou vel
Sr)/j.oo'iov Baiter a 5 ravri T ravra B W
b 4 a.vi(rrd.(i(vos
W
:
T aviffrai**/*evos B
: irpbs 4/xh B irp6s /xt T C 1 SiaXitriiv
:
B Sia\eiira>v T C 8 ruv T ri B di StatpOupas B T

:
W
:
6a</>o/>Ss d 4 toD KaAoO Ficinus {Cali filiitm)

:
0EATHS i2 9 d
kcl\ov eyevero poL to crr/petoi/, otycTat. be vvv /uerci pacrrJA- 5
Aou o-TpaTevo-6p.evos evOv 'EcpeVou koI 'Ico^tay. eyco ovv

oiop.ai eKelvov r) cnrodavelo-OaL r) 6p.ov tl tovtio y ekav, /cal
TrepC ye Trjs crrpartas Trjs dWrjs tt&vv <po/3o?3/xai.
Taura 8r/ Trdvra elpr)Ka ctol, ort r) bvvap.Ls aurrj tov e

baip.ov(ov tovtov Kal eis tcls crvvovo-ias rcoy /xer' ep.ov o-vv-
biaTpi[36vT(ov to dirav bvvaraL. irokXdls p.ev yap evav-
rtourat, fcat ovk ecrTL tovtols cocpeAr/flrpjat per' ep.ov 8tarpt-
(Bovctlv, cScrre ovx oXov re p.oL rourots o-vvbLaTpifieLV 5
isoWoXs 8e crvvelvaL p.ev ov 8ta/ccoA?Jei, hxpekovvraL be ovbev

ovvovTes. oXs 8' o\v cruAAd/3?jrai Trjs ovvovaias 77 tov
baLp.ovCov bvvap.LS, ovToi elcriv S>v koX crv fjcrdrjcraL' Taxy
yap Trapaxprjp.a e7rt8t8o'acrii\ kcll tovtu>v av rcoi/ thrtSt-
bovroiv ol p.ev Kal fiefiaLov ex ovo ~<- /cat irapap.6vLp.ov rr/z/ 130
cocpeAtW' iroAAol 8e, ocrov av p.er ep.ov yjpovov Z>ctlv, dav-
p.acrLov eitLbLboacrLV, eireLbav be p.ov a7roV)(corrat, iraAty ovbev
8ta<pe'poucri" otovovv. tovto ttot etraQev 'Aptcrret8?js 6
Avo~Lp.ayov vbs rorj 'Aptcrrei8ou. 8iarpi/3coi' yap /xer' ep.ov 5
Trap.TTokv eTTebeba>KeL ev dAiyco xpoVco* e7retra aurco crrpareta
rts eyevero /cat coxero eKTr\ea>v, tjkcov be KaTe\6p.f$ave /xer'

ep.ov 8tarpt/3oirra QovKvbibrjv tov MeArjcrtou vov tov Qov-
Kvbibov. 6 be QovKvbibrjs rf/ irpoTepaiq. p.0L bC direxdeias b
v
ev XoyoLS tlo\v eyeyoveL' 18001/ ovv p.e 6 'Aptcrrei8?js, e7ret8? j
?jcr7rdcrard' re /cai raAAa 8teAe'xt9?/, " Qovicvbibrjv 8e," ecpr/,
" clkovo), S> 2co/cparey, crep.vvvecr6aL aTTa Trpos cre /cat x.Ae-
7ratyeti' cos rt oyra. Lcrrt yap, ecpr/y eyco, ourcos. 5
" Tt 8e', otjk otbev," ecprj, " irp\v crol crvyyevecrdaL olov r)v
to avbpcLTTobov" " Ovk eoLKev ye," eqbrjv eyco, " vrj tovs
deovs." " 'AAAa pJqv Kal avros ye," ec/>r/, " KarayeAdcrrco?
d5 to suprascr. B om. 2
: BT OpcurvWov B T 6pa<rv\ov
: W
d7 y i\av Hermann ys\av : B t\av T W d 8 arpanas Cobet
W
:
(TrpaTflas B : irpayfiareias T e3 air av) irav Cobet e g aZ

ruv] avrwv BT a4 eiradev T W : e/j.adev B a5 vbs rovi] rov
Ast a 8 fM(\r)o-(ov B : fxf\to~(ov T ibv rov] rov Ast b 7 rb
secl. Cobet p)?] /ucj Cobet
130C nAATHNOS
C e)(co, o) zcoKpares. 1 t MaAtora; ec^rji/ eyco. Urt,
ec/jrj,
" Trptv juey eK7rAetz>, oTuyovv av8pa>TT<x> otds r' r) 8taAe'-
yecrflat koI urj8eids yeipu>v (paivea-dat ev tols Adyots, coore
koX ebicoKOV rds o-uôucias rcoi> yapiecrTaTa>v avdpanrojv,
5 z/wt 8e TovvavTiov cperjyco av Ttva Kal alo-0avu>p.aL irenai-
bevp.evov ovtoos alo-yyvop.aL eVt rrj ep.avrov c/jauAdrrjri."

" Horepov 8e'," r)v 8' eyco,
ae irpovkLTrev aurrj " eatc/>i>rjs
?7 8wa/jtts r/ " Kara crutKpdu," r) 8' os.

Kard o-p.LKpov;"
d " 'HvtKa 8e crot 7rapeyeVero," r)v 8' eyco, " iroTtpov padovri
Ttap e/xoS rt 7rapeyeVero ?/ tlvl dAAco rpo7rco;" " 'Eyco aot
epco," ec/brj,
" 2> ScoKpares, clttlo-tov p.ev vr) tovs deovs, dArjfles
8e\ eya> ydp ep.a6ov p.\v 7rapd aorj or38ei> 7rco7rore, cos ar/rds
5 oTaOa' ktrebibovv 8e oirdre crot ovveirjv, k<\v et eu rrj avrrj
p.6vov otKta etr/y, urj ev rco at>rco 8e otKr//xart, udAAojv 8e

07rdre ev rco aurco otKrjuari, Kat e/xotye eSoKOUi' 7roAu udAAoi>
6ttot iv rco avrS> oiKrj/jiari cov Aeyourds trou /3Ae7rot/xt 7rpos
e ce, /xdAAoy r/ cWdre dAAotre opcprjv, ttoKv 8e MaAttrra Kat

7rAeio-roy e7re8t8ou.y ottotc irap avrov ae Kadoip.r]v eyop.ev6s
o-ov ko.1 aTTT6p.iVos' vvv 8e'," r) 8' ds, " 7rdo-a eKeiwj 77 ets
eeppurjKe."
5 "Ecrrty ovv, a 0e'ayes, rotaurrj /j 7jpere'pa cruuouo-ia* eav

weu tQ> 0eQ> (pikov iravv ttoAv e7rtocoo-ets Kat ra^v, et oe
f\,
/xrj, oi/. dpa ovy prj aot dac/JaAearepoy r} 7rap' eKetvcou ru>t
7rat8eveo-c9at ot eyKparets airot eto-tu rf/s coc/jeAtas t/v
cocpeAouo-ty rovs av6p(a7TOVS /xdAAoy r/ 7rap' epou dri dy

10 rrj^r/ rouro 7rpdât.
131 @E. 'E/aol p.ey tolvvv 8oKet, 2 ScoKpares, r/uds orjrcocrt
TTotrjo-ai, aTTOTTCLpadrjvaL tov baLpovCov tovtov ovvovTas
c a avOpdnry B avdpwirocv T &j/ avOpdirtp B 2

^ scr. Coisl. ^v
W
: : :
B T C5 alcrddvooixai aladdvo/uat BT a1<rdwfj.ai scr.

W
7 :
W
: :
Coisl. C 7 irpo&\.i7rej> : 7rpovA67r' BT d4 fxev B :
om. T d. 7 oi/cjjjuoTi T : 8e oiK^fxari B e 1 bpifav BT :
bp<#ii.t\v W 8^Wb:6^>BT ea /caflotV'?'] KaQri^v Cobet

e8 ot T: &V B : 0? t' W 69 ôC] itxol Hermann 'e 10 ti/x??]
t\>xv s c '* Bekker

EArHS i3 ia
dAAr/Aots. ml iav fxkv -TTapeiKr/ rjpuv, ravra /3e'Ario-ra'
ei oe [xij, tot ?/8r/ Trapaxprjp.a (3ov\evo-6p.eda 6Vt hpacrojxev,

eire akXot o-vveo~6p.eda, etre Kat avrb to Oziov to o~ol yvyvo- 5
p.evov TTipao-6p.eda Trapap.v6zio~6aL evâtat re xat dvo-iais
koX aAAfa) ot(o av oi p.avT<iLS e^rjywyrat.
AH. Mr/fceVi Trpos raura dfretVr/s, a> Swfcoares, r<S
jaetpaKta)" eS ydp Ae'yet 0edyr/s.

212. 'AAA' et 8ofcet xprjvac ovto> ttol^v, ovtg> 7rot<S/xez\ 10
a3 ravra fitKTiara secl. ci. Hirschig
PLATO, VOL. 1!I.

</
($
:
XAPMIAHS
st. II
2I2KPATH2 p. 153
"Hko[X(V rfj TrpoTtpaCq o~-~ripas e* ITorei8aias dirb tov a

aTpaTOTTebov, olov 8e bta \povov a<ptyp.vos ao~p.ivo)s f)a
eVt tols ovvijdtts 8tarpt/3as. koX bf) Kal ets rf)v Tavpiov
T;akaio~Tpav tt)v KaTavTtKpv tov rijs Ba<rtA??s Upov do-fjk-
6ov, Kal avTodt KaTi\a(3ov irdvv 7roXkovs, tovs ptiv /cat 5
o.yv&Tas iptoi, tovs 8e 7rAei<7roi>s yvcopiptovs. Kai p.t\ <ws
elbov et<rtoVra e aTipoo~boKr\Tov, ev6vs iroppcadtiv f)0"ird(pvTo b

aAAos aAAofley Xatpe</)<Sz> 8e, a.T Kal ptavtKos &v, dva-
Trr]bi]o~as k p.io~a>v e'0ei irpos p.e, Kai p.ov kaft6p.evos Trjs
T
\etpos, I2 Swfcpare?, f) 8' os, ir>s io~a>dr)s ex tt}s p.d\r)$;
'OXiyov 8e irplv fjpJds dirtivat p.dyj) iyeyovet iv Trj TIoTetbaiq, 5
571 aort f)o~av ot Tjjbe ireTrvcrp.ivot.
Kat iyu> irpos avrbv d-~roKptv6p.evos, Ovrcoat, <pr]v, &$

o~v opqs.
Kat pr)V ijyyeXrai ye bzvpo, e<p??, ?/' re ]w.\r] irdvv lcryypd
yeyovivat Kal iv avTrj ttoXXovs tS>v yvcopipxov Tedvdvat. c
Kat e7rtetK<3y, f)v 8' iya>, akt]6f) a7r?/yyeArai.
IlaoeyeVou p.iv, f) 8' 6s, Tr) p.dyj);
Tlapeyev6p.r)v.
Aeuoo bt], icpr), Kadetpp.evos fjptiv btr]yr)o~ar ov ydp rt 5
a 1 riKo/j.ev BT ?ikov /xkv b t a2 afffxivais B : affftevws T :
afffievos Hirschig a4 BaffiKrjs] $afft\-~s B (sed suprascr. <k) :
0affi\iKrjs T b 1 -?5ov t : VSov BT c5 rt scr. recc. : roi

BTW
2*
153 c 11AATJ2N02
7rco irdvTa aa(p(as TTeTW(TfX$a. Kal dp.a p.e Ka0tet dyuv
irapa Kpvriav tov Kakkaio-^pov.
TlapaKade6pi.evos ovv i]o-7ra^6p.r]v tov re Kpvriav Kal tovs
akkovs, Kal hi7]yovp.r]V avroXs ra aixb o-TparoTrebov, otl p.e
d rts avipoiTO' 7/pwrcoy 8e aAAos dkko.

'E7ret8T/ 8e t&v tolovtoov dbr]v e1.yop.ev, avdLs eyco avrovs
avr]pa>T(0V ra rfjbe, irepl (pLkocroqbias o7rcos eôt tcl vvv, ixepi
re rcoz/ veiav, et rii>es ev avrot? bLaqSepovTes r] aoqîq i] KaAAet
5 i] d/xcporepois eyyeyovores elev. Kal 6 Kptrtas a7ro/3Ae\i/a?
154 7rpos tt]v Qvpav, ibwv TLvas veaviaKOVs elaiovras Kal Aot-
bopovpLevovs akkrjkoLs Kal akkov o\kov oiTLo-dev e-n6p.evov,
Ylepl p.ev tG>v KakG>v, ecpr?, co ScoKpare?, avrUa /xot boKels
etcrecrtfar ovrot yap Tvyydvovo-LV 61 etcrtbVres -rtp6bpop.oi re
5 Kat epaaral ovres tov boKovvTos KaAAtVrou elvaL to. ye 8?)
vvv, cpaiveraL be p:oL Kal ai/Tos eyyvs rjbr] ttov elvaL 7rpocrtcoV.
"EaTLV be, rjv 8' eyco, ris re Kai ro);
Oladd ttov crv ye, ecp??, dAA' ovtto) ev ?/AiKia rfy irpiv oe
b amevaL, Xapp.ibrjv tov tov TkavKcovos tov rjp.eTepov 0etou
vov, ep.bv be aveijnov.
Otoa /xeVrot z>t) Ata, r|y 8' eyco* ov ydp rt (pavkos ovbe
tot r]V ert 7rats &v, vvv 8' otjuat 7rou ev p.aka av ?/8t/
5 p.upa.KL0V eir].
Avrim, eqbrj, elo-r\ Kal rjkUos kol otos yiyovev. Kat dp.a
TavT avTov keyovros 6 Xappt8r/s elcrepyeTaL.

'E/uoi p.ev ovv, co eratpe, ovbev o-Tadp,r]T6v' drexy&s yap
keVKr) crTaOpLr] elp.1 TTpbs tovs koXovs crxeSov ydp ri p.OL
10 7ravres ot ev Trj ÂtKta KaAot qbaivovTaL drap ovv br] Kal
C Tore eKelvos e]xol OavpLao-rbs e<pdvr] to re p.eye6os Kal to

Kakkos, ol be br] aAAot 7rcWes epdv epLOLye eboKovv avrov
odrcos eKTrettkriyp.evoL re Kat Te6opvfit]p.evoi rjaav, fjviK
d I avepoiro T : &j/ tpono B (yp. /cal avtpoJ b) b7 6Ve'px Tat

T : tpxtrai B (yp. urepx< Ta4 ^) b8 o-ra6/j.r)T6v BT : acrradixr\-
rov b
XAPMIAH2 154 c
el<rr\ei ttoAAoi 8e br) dAAot epaorat nai h rot? oTncrdev
etirovTo. koI to fxev T/pe'repoi> to tG>v avhp&v rJTTov dav- 5
lxao-Tov rjv dAA' eycb naX rot? 7ratcri irpoo-ecryov tov vovv,
d>? orj8et? aAAoo-' eftkeTrev avT&v, ovb' oort? o-jLiiKpdraro?
rjv, dAAd 7ra7Jre? uxrirep ayaXp.a eOeQiVTO avrov. Kal 6
Xatpecpcoi- KaAeVa? /ue, Tt o-ol cpatWrat 6 veavLVKOS, ecprr, d

00 ScoKpare?; otjk eTj7rpo'rrco7ro?;
'T7repcp?jco?, r)v 8' eyco.
OtjYo? peVrot, ecprr, et eOeXoL a7ro8wat, 8o'et crot d7rpoVco-
7TO? etmt* orjrco? rd et8o? 7rdy/caAd? eorty. 5
Svvecpao-av ovv koX ol dAAot rarjrd rarjra rco Xatpecpconrr
/cdyco, 'H/sdxAet?, e<pT]7J, co? ap.ayov Aeyere rdu avhpa, et eri
aurco ez> 8r/ p.6vov TvyyaveL TTpoabv o-pnKpov rt.
Tt; ecprj d Kptrta?.
Et r?;y ^\rvyr\v, rjv 0' eyco, rrjyxdvet eu 7recp?jKco?. irpeTrei e

oe' 7ro?j, co Kptrta, rotoJjro7J avrdy etmt rr/? ye i3juere'pa? dWa
ot/cta?.
'AAA', lcprj, 7rdru KaAd? /cat ayados ecrTLv ml TavTa.
Tt ovv, ecprjv, OTj/c aiThvo-ap.ev avTOv avTo tovto Kal 5
e6eacrap.eda irpoTepov tov etbovs; 7rdz>rco? ydp 7rou rrjAtKOTjro?
cotj t/8tj edeXeL 8taAe'yecr0ai.

Kat 7rdrju ye, ecprj d Kptrta?, e7ret rot Kat eartJj cptAd-
crocpos re xat, a>? doKet dAAot? re Kat eavrco, 7rd7jv 7rotTjrtKo'?. 155
Tovro p.ev, rjv 8' eyco, 00 cptAe Kptrta, iroppoiOev vp.lv to
KaXbv virapxei airb Trjs 2o'Aco7JO? o-vyyereta?. dAAd ri otjk
e7re'8etd? pot tov veaviav KaXecras 8erjpo; orj8e ydp av ttov
et ert ervyxai>e recorepo? cotj, alcr\pbv av i)v avrco 8taAe- 5
yecrflat r)\xiv IvavTiov ye crov, e7rtrpo'7rou re d/ua Kat aveyj/iov

Ol>TO$.
C 7 #AAo<r' e$\(ir(v scr. Coisl. SAXos ef3\ev(v B

: aXXoo-ejSAeirei' T :
(sed w supra o b) W d 4 êAoi B W

d 7 ^tyere scr. efleAej T
W
:
recc. \eyeran.
: BTW om. T
d 8 S)) Se B e 8 <pi\6ao<p6s
: :
re B W
(sed ^, supra t W)
<pt\6<ro<pos ye T : a 4 V 7rou] SVjitoi ci.
Naber a 5 tl eri ervyxa.ve Goldbacher (e l trvyxavev eri Cobet) :
!ti rvyx^vei B W
el iriryxave T :
yp. el y e ri>yx av * v rnarg.
:
>
m W
I55a nAATilNOS
'AAAa KaAcos, ecpr/, Aeyets, kol Ka\ovp.(v avrov. Kai
b dp.a Ttpbs tov aKokovdov, Y\ai, ecpr/, KctAet XaputSr/y, uirouv
otl /3orJAouat avrbv tarpco o-uorr/crai 7rept rijs do-devcias rjs
irpoiqv irpos ue eAeyey ort ao-0vol. Ylpbs ovv eue 6 Kpt-

rtas, "Qvayyos tol ecpr/ /3apvveo-6ai tl tt)v KecpaAr/y eco#ei>
5 avio-Tapievos' akkct rt oe KooAvet 7rpocr7roir/cracrt9ai irpbs
avTov iTricrTacrdai rt KecpaArjs (pdppiaKOv;
Ovbiv, i)v 8' eyco* p.6vov ikdiroi.

'AAA' r/fei, ecpr/.
*0 orjz; Kat ZyiviTO. rJKe ydp, Kal e7rotr/cre ye'Acora
C Trokvv Kao-Tos yap r)p.G>v tG>v Ka6r]p.ivoiv crvy\oipG>v tov

Trkqo-iov eco0et o-irovbfj, Xva irap avTut Ka6ioLTo, eco? tG>v
eV icrydroi Ka6qp.ivoiv tov p.ev dvo-Trj(rap.ev, tov 8e TrkdyLov
Kare/3dAouef. 6 8' ikdoiv p.(Tav ipcov re Kal tov Kptrtoi;
5 eKa0e'ero. ivravda p.ivTOL, S> cptAe, eyco r/8r/ r)ir6povv, Kai

p.ov r) irpoo-dtv dpacrvrqs ecfeKe'K07rro, fjv elypv eyob cos ndvv
pqbiois avrG> 8 taAecfdueyos.' e7ret8r/ 8e', cppdcravTos tov KpiTiov
otl iyu> etrjy 6 ro qbdpp.aKov eTricrrdueyos, ivi^ke^riv re' uot
d rot? oq^dakpoLS ap-rjxctvov tl olov kol dvrxyero cos ipoirqo-oiv,
Kal oi iv rf] irakaio-rpq diravTns 7repte'ppeoi' r/ucis kjjkAco
Kout8r/, tot 8t/, co ytvvdba, ctbov re tcl ivrbs tov tuartou

Kat ecpAeydur/y Kat ovKtT iv ip.avrov r)v kol ivop.Lcra crocpco-
5 TaTov elvaL tov Kvbiav tcl epcoriKa, bs tlirev e7ri Kakov

kiyoiv 7rat8ds, dAAco viroTL6ip.zvos, eJjAa/Seicrflai p,r) Kare'-
vavTa kiovTos vefipbv ikdovra p-olpav atpeicrflai
e Kpecoir avrbs ydp uot eSoKOvz' rj7rd tov tolovtov 6pip.paTos
eaAcoKeVat. opuos 8e avroC ipoirqo-avros et e7rtcrratu7}i' ro rr/s
KcqiaXrjs (pdpp.aKOV, uo'yts 7rco? aTTKpLvdp.r]v otl iTTLcrTaiprjv.
a8 KaXovfxev BT W : Ka\wfj.f scr. Ambr. 56bg &BW: ^jrep T

^K T : $}ice B
supra c< W (sed e W) W. Dindorf &dei
e 2 Wflet :
BT Kadiôno in marg. T 04 Karef3d\o/x(v T Karf\d$o/ji.ev B :
c 8 T /uo T (sed e supra ot) 5e' /xe B d 3 eTSoj' W iSov B T

W W
: :
d. 4 eV T : îr' B d 6 Karevavra T k<xt' ivavria B

W
:
d7 /jioTpav T : fioipav : dSacoTcocrjj 6eia fioipa B a/pero-flai]

aj*Te?o-0ai ci. Cobet e 1 auTbs B T /cal ai>Tbs rec. b
:
XAPMIAH2 i55e
i ovv, ?/ 5 o?, ttlv;
Kat eya> et7roi> ort airo /xei> ei/r/ <pv\kov tl, eTrubr) 8e' rts 5
eii tw <papp.aK<a etr/, ?/y et /xeV rts iiraboi dp.a Kal XP$ T0
avru>, iiavTa-nao-iv vyta ttoloI rb (pa.pfj.aKOV avev 8e rrjs
cTTwbfjs ovoev ocpeAos et?/ tov <pv\Xov.

Kat ds, 'A7roypdx//o/xat tolvvv, ecprj, irapd orov Tr)v 156
e7ro)8?/r.
ndrepoi>, ?p> 8' eya>, edv /xe 7ret%s r) Kav /x?j;
TeA.ao-as ow, 'Edy <rc 7ret0a>, e<pr), 2> SwKpares.

Etei>, ?/i>
8' ey&r Kat Tovvop.d p.ov av dKpt/3ots; 5
Et /x?j d8tK&> ye, e<p?J ov ydp rt o-ou dAtyos Adyos eortv

eV rots ?//xere'pois TjAiKitorais, p.p.vt]p.aL 8e eytoye Kat 7rats
a>i> Kptria ra>8e avvovTa o-e.
KaA<3s ye <rd, 7jv 8' eyw, 7rota>7r /xaAAov ydp o-ot 7rap-
p?/o-ido-o/xat 7rept r?js e7ra>8?js ota rvyxdret oSora* dprt 8' b

v
riiropovv tlvl rpo7ra> (Toi eV8et<5at/x?ji> r?/y hvvap.iv avr?js.
iaTL ydp, S) Xap/xt8?j, ToiavTr] oia /x?/ 8vz>ao-0at r?/y
Ke<pahr)v p.6vov vytd ttolzlv, dAA' ooairep to-a>s ?j8rj Kat <rv
aK?jKoas tS>v dyad&v laTp&v, eircLbdv rts avrots 7rpoo-- 5
e'A0?j rovs 6<p6aXp.ovs dXyiav, XiyovaC ttov otl oi>x olov
re awoi/y p.6vovs tTriyziptiv rovs 6<pdaXp.ovs laadai, dAA

drayKatoy et?/ d/xa Kat r?/y KpaXr)v dtpairtvtLV, ei /xe'AAot
v
Kat rd ra>y d/x/xdra>y ev exetzr Kat av rd r?/v Kc<pa\rjv C
oteo-flat dv 7rore 0epa7rev<rat avTr]v e<p' eavr?js drev oAov
v
tov o-a>/xaros 7roAA?/y dvoiav elvai. eK 8t/ ro?iroii ro?3 Adyou
Statrats e7rt 7ray to o-wpa rpe7ro'perot perd ro?3 o'Ao?j ro
pepos TTix.(ipov<nv depairevtLV re Kat lac6aL' 77 ovk rjadrj<raL 5
6'rt raura ovrtos XiyovaCv re Kat exet;
ndrv ye, e<p?/.
Ovkoiw KaAws o-ot 8oKet Ae'yeo-(9at Kai a7ro8e'x?/ r6v Adyoy;
a3, 4 ireidys . . . ireiOw] irdaTis . . . irtiaw ci. H. Richards

a4 07) T W : om. B a7 tyarye T : iyd> re B a 9 ye
corr. Coisl. : 5e BT b8 eiVjl &v 117 ci. Madvig C2 7roT
T W : iro0fv B
156C nAATGNOS
YldvToov /jtdAtora, ecpr/.
A
d Kdyco aKovcras avrov eiraLvicravTos avz6appr\cra re, Kat
/xot Kara crp.LKpbv tt&Alv r) 6pacrvTT]s criw/yetpero, Kal dreco-
irvpovp.r]v. Kal e?Trov Tolovtov tolvvv ccttlv, cb XappLLbt], Kal
t6 ravrrjs Tr)s iircabrjs. eptaOov 8' avrr\v eyco eKet cttI crrpartds
5 7rapd rti>os tG>v QpqK&v t&v ZakpLofrbos larp&v, ot Xeyovrai
Kal airaOavaTLî-v. eAeyer 8e 6 pq ovtos otl ravra fxev
[tarpoi] ol "Ekkrjves, a vvvbrj eyco eAeyoy, koAcos kiyoLev
dAAd ZdA/jiois, ec/)?7, Ae'yet 6 ?//jieVepos fiacrikevs, 6ebs &v,
e ort wcnrep 6cp6akpL0vs avev Kecpakrjs ov det e7ri)(eipetv lacrdaL
ovbe KcpaXr)v avV trco/jiaros, ovrcos ovbe crco/jta areu \lrv\V s >
dAAd roSro Kai atrtoy et?j tov bLacpevytLV tovs irapa tols
"FiXkrjcrLV larpovs tcl 7roAAd vocnjpLara, otl tov okov d/xeAotey
5 ov bioL Tip e7Tt/xe'Aetay 7rotetcrcât, ov /u?j KaAcos exo#vros abv-
vaTov iir) to p.zpos eS (\LV. irdvTa yap tcpr) (K rfjs \}rv)(i)s
u)pp.r)cr6aL Kal tcl KaKci /cai rd dya0d rco crcop.art kol iravTl
rco avOpatTTia, Kal eKeWtv kirLppcLV tocnrep e/c Trjs Kec/>aA?/s iirl
157 tcl o/x/xara* belv ovv eKetyo Kai irpdTOV Kai judAtcrra cêpa-
TreveLV, et /ie'AAet Kai ra r?/s Kec/>aA?/s Kai rd rou dAAou
o~u>p.aTos KaAcos. exetz\ Oepa-rrevecrOaL 8e r?)i> \j/vx>l v t&h -
paKapte, e7rcpSats tlctlv, rds 0' e7rco8ds ravras rois Aoyous

5 eti>at rovs KaAovs* eK 8e rcoV rotovrcoy koycov eV rats xj/vxaXs
croxppocrvvrjv iyyCyvecrdaL, r)s eyyVop,ivrjS Kai ixapovcrr\s
pqbLov ijbri. etivai Tr)v vyitLav kol ti) Kcpakr) Kai rco dAAco
b o-copart ttoplC^lv. bLbdcrKcav ovv /ue rd re cpdpp\aKOv kol rds

<<r/
e7rcp8ds, 07rcos," ecp?j, " rco cpap/xaKCp rovrcp /jt?/8eis cre
7retVet r?/i> avrou Kcpaki]v depaTreveLv, bs av /u?/ r?/y \j/vxi]v
d.2 vv7)yeiptTo Tb fi/i/e-yfipeTO B : d3 posterius /caJ om.

Stobaeus d 4 ffrparias B T ffTparttai Stobaeus d 5 CôA/to-
:
|iSos B (afi6\fîSos T b
: oTpwj'] voXiruv Stobaeus d 6 /*/]
fihv Hi) Stobaeus d7 larpol secl. Cobet larpol oi"E\\7ivts
BT: ot "EWrjves larpol Stobaeus d8 (d\fxoîs B (d/xo\^s Tb :
4 toO SA.01 scripsi tou iiWou Stobaeus rb S\ov B T ape\oTfv :
W
:
yp. T Stobaeus ayvooltv B T

: a 2 fxfWot Heindorf ÂAou B
Stobaeus 3Aou T : a 5 iv om. Stobaeus b 3 7Tio-ei scr.
Par. 1812: TTfiar) BTW
XAPMIAH2 i57b
Ttp&Tov Trapdayi) T7/ 770)8?/ vtto orov depaTrevdrjvaL. Kai yap

vvv," ecpr/,
" tovt eoTLV to ap.dpTr)\xa irepl tovs av6pu>7Tov$, 5
otl x M P^ eKaripov, oco(ppoovvr)$ re /ccu vyLeCas, tarpot tlvcs
TTV)(eipov<nv eticar" Kat pot irdvv cr(p6bpa iverikkero /AT/re
ttXovo-lov ovtco \xr)biva elvaL p?/re yevvawv \xr\re Kakov, 0$

i\xe TreCoeL dkkcos ttolzlv. iyco ovv dpcopoKa yap avT<2, C
*cai fxoL dvdyKt) TreC6eo6aL 7reicropat ovv, kol 00C, iav
[XV \3ovkr) KaTCL TCLS TOV ivOV ivTokds TT]V \j/VXt)V TTpOiTOV
irapaoyew e7rao-at rat? rov QpqKos e7rcp8ai?, irpocroCcrco to

<pdp\xaKov Tj) Kecpakj)' et 8e p/, ovk av exoL\xev ort 7rototp;eV 5
ool, co cptAe XaputSr/.
'AKOvo-as ow \xov 6 Kptria? rairr' et7roVros, Epuator,

e<pr), u> ScoKpare?, yeyoros av et?/ 7 r?/s Ke<pakr}s acrdiveLa
rco j>eai>to-Kco, et avayKao-t9?/o-erat Kat tt)v 8tai>otay 8ta r?/i>
K<pakr]v fiekrCcov yeviodaL. kiyco fxivroL ool otl Xappt'8r/s d

t<2v fjkLKLcoT&v ov p.6vov Tr) Ibiq boKel Stacpepet^, akkd Kal
avr<2 tovtco, ov ov (pr)$ tt)v e7rcp8?)i> eyew' (pr\$ be oaxppo-

ovvqs- r) ydp;
Yldvv ye, rjv 8' eyco. 5
E3 toCvvv lo6l, (pr), ort irdvv Trokv boKel crcocppoyeVraros
elvaL r<2v vvvl, Ka\ rdkka irdvTa, el$ ocrov ?/AtKtas i]KL,
ovbevbs yjeCpcov cov.
Kat yap, r)v 8' eyco, Kat StKato^, co Xappt'8??, Stacpepeir cre
tG>v dkkcov TTdcrLV toIs tolovtols' ov ydp otpat aAAor ovbiva e

rcoy ivddbe pqbCcos dv ex.Lv e7rt8etc;at Trotat bvo oiKtat
,
o-weA0ot>crat ets ravrbv t&v A6t]vt]o-lv K t&v lkotcov
b6 <rw<ppQ<rvvr)s t ko.1 vytfias om. Laur. lxxxv. 6 C 1 ovv BT :
y' ovv W 6fiti/xoKa T et yp. : W

w/xo<ra B W (-yp. /col wfi^fxoKa
yap b) 04 liraaai B 2
: aTraVcus B
(ut videtur) T et in marg. yp. b
rats . . . iirwSa?s] rits . . . iirwScts ci. H. Richards d2 8o/c7 W :
fSoKet BT d6 iracu 7roAv So/ce? crw<ppove<rraros T et <yp. W : irAeiarwv

5ok(? iroAvcppeviffraros B : irkeicrrwv Sok(7 iro\v <rw<ppov(<rraros W : irA.c?-
cttoi/ So/c? o~w<ppov(<rraros Hermann : ir\(i<rrots Sok(7 <rw<ppov(<rraros ci.

Madvig ir\d<rrwv Sok(?ito\v <rw<ppov(<rr(pos ci. Goldbacher
: e 2 itotat
Svo otKiat Aldina iro?at Svo?v otKiat
: iroiatv Svo?v oiKiatv corr. BTW :
e 3 <rw(\6ov<rat T : cal vvv (\Oovcrat B vvv 4\Qov<rat (sed <r supra : W

v W) Ka\ vvv iXdovaatv corr. G
:
157 e nAATX2N02
KaAAtco av Kal ap.iva> yVvt]<TLav r\ e &v <rv yiyovas. i\
5 re yap iraTpha vpxv otKta, 57 K/nrtou tov Apooiribov, Kal virb

'AvaKpiovTos Kal vtto 2o'Acoz>os Kal vtt akkutv 7roAAcoi> 7roiriTco>
yKKd>p.iaarp.ivr] 7rapa8e'8orai rjpXv, tos bLa<pipov<ra KaAAet re

158 Kal aperrj Kal rrj dAAr/ Aeyo//,eVrr evbaip.ovCq, Kal av r) Trpbs
p.r)Tpbs toaavT<os' YIvpiX.ap.Trov$ yap tov crov detov ovbeis tS>v
kv rfj r)-Tip<o Aeyerat KaXkicov Kal /xet(/ov avr)p 8o'at etvai,
bcraKis tKtivos r) irapa. \xiyav /3acrtAe'a r) Trapa akkov tlvcl
5 tG>v kv Tjj r)irip(o irpcr(3V(ov dcptKero, <rvp.ira<Ta 8e avrr) r)
otKta ovbev rrjs tTtpas inrobeecrTepa. K 8r) tolovtojV yeyovora

etKo'? o-e et? iravTa Trp&Tov etyat. rd pkv ovv 6pcop.va rrjs
b t8ea?, a> cpiAe iraZ TkavK(ovos, 8oKet? p.0L ovbiva tcov rrpb
crov V ovbtvl ?37ro/3e/3r?KeVar et 8e 8?) Kat 7roo? <ro)<ppocrvvr]v
Kat 7rpos raAAa Kara tov rovbe \6yov LKavcos iri<pvKas,
p.aKapLov <T, r\v 8' eyco, co cptAe Xap/xi8r?, r) p.r\Tt)p tlktV.
5 eêt 8' ovv ovtcos. et p.iv <tol r\br) irapcrTLV, co? Aeyet
Kptrta? ob, crcocppocrvvr) kol et acocppcov LKavcos, ovbV TL
<tol e8et 01/re rcoi> ZaA/xdt8o? oilre rcoy 'A/3dpt8o? tov
*T7rep/3 opiov Trcobcov, dAA' avTo <tol c\v ?/8r? boriov etr? rd
C Trjs K<pa\rjs <pa.pp.aKov et 8' ert tovtcov e7rt8e?/? etrat SoKet?,
7rq<TTiov irpb rrjs tov <papp.a.KOV 8oVeco?. avTos ovv p.0L
enre iroTepov dp.oAoyet? rco8e Kat <pr)s uayco? r/8r? acocppocrvvr]s
pLTi\Lv r) ivbr]s etrat;
5 ÂvcpvdpLacras ovv 6 Xapp.ibr)S Ttp&TOV p.V ert KaAAtcoz'
e 4 KoXKloi . . . a/xeivw yevvf]<retav T et in marg. yp. W (sed yep-ffcr-iav

W) : KaWiwv . . . a/xeivtov yevfifferat B W e5 otKta T W et yp. b :
ovaia B et suprascr. a 2 tov aov Oeiov WrovSe aov Se deiov T W : :
rovSe \eyovo~tv B ovSe\s T: ovSe to>v t))v B BW TW

W
:
83 tj 7)ireipto T t?) iretpip B Tifireipto Schanz (et mox)

: S6at T
: :
S6l-a B a 4 SffdKts T 6ff6.Kts Te B a 5 t' :îreipu secl. . . .
Ast b1 tcDc 7r^ (ToC ^y ouSevl vi-ofSefiriKevai ci. Madvig : tcDv 7rpb
ffov 4v ovSevl vTrepfSel3\r)Kevai B W tSov irpoyovuv KaTatarxvvetv T et -yp.
W
:
b2 /coJ 7rp6s ffuippoffvvriv koi irpbs T W : ko! ir6ppu6ev ffu<ppo-

<rvvr\v Ka\ B D3 irerpvKas T : ire<pvKvias B b5 ws B W (sed
suprascr. & W) : o T Aeyei T : \eyot B : et \eyot W b7 e5 1]
Set ci. Cobet ^ctA^Jf i8os B : (âfx.6\^tSos T b8 ixuto' o-oi] avroffot
T : outJs coi W : outos olov B C3 t/Sj; T : r"Sri Ka\ B
XAPMIAH2 158C
ecpdvr) kcu yap rb alcrxvVTr]kbv avrov Trj r/AtKta eTrpe\f/ev

eireLTa Kal ovk dyevvcos aireKpivaTO' eXirev yap otl ov pqhiov
etr/ ev rco irapovTL ov& bp.okoyeiv ovre e^dpvco eivaL tol
epcoTc6p.eva. eav p.ev ydp, ?]

8' os, /xr/ cpco elvat crcocppcov, d
dp.a p.ev aTOtrov avrbv KaO* eavrov rotaCra keyeiv, dp.a 8e
Kal KpiTiav Tovbe ^revbr] errt8eico Kal aXAovs irokkovs, ots

8okco etvaL crcocppcov, co? 6 tovtov koyos' eav 8' av cpco Kal
ep.avTov erraLvco, icrcos eTraxOes <paz>etrat. cocrre otjk e^co ort 5
crot airoKpivcop.aL.
Kat eycb et7roi> ort jutot etKoVa (paivrj keyeLV, ) Xapp.ibrj.
Kat p.0L SoKet, rjv 8' eyco, kolvt} av etri crKeTrreov etre KeKTrjcraL
etre ftr/ 6 Trvv6a.vop.aL, tva prjre crv dyayKa^?/ keyeiv a p.r) e

fiovkeL, p.r\T av eyco dcrKeirTcos eirl Ti]v iaTpLKrjv rpeVco/uai.
et ovv crot <pikov, edekco aKoireiv jtxera crov' et 8e p.r'], edv.

'AAAd irdvTcov pdAttrra, ecpr), cpikov cocrre tovtov ye
eveKa, 07r?/ ai/Tos otet (3ekrLov crKe\j/acrOaL, Tavrr) crKbVet. 5
Tfjbe Toivvv, ecp-qv eyco, 8oKet juot /3eArtcrTr/ etmi r/ crKe\pLS
irepl aiiTov. brjkov yap 6V1 et trot irdpecrTLV crcocppocrvvt],
e\eLS tl irepl avrrjs bodeLV. dvdyKr) ydp ttov evovcrav 159

avrr\v, eiirep eveoTLv, alcr6r]criv TLva TtapeyeLV, e rjs 8o'a av
ris croL Ttepl avrrjs etr/ ort ecrrty Kat ottoioV rt r) crcocppocrvvr)'
r/ ovk otet;
"Eycoye, ecpr), ot/xat. 5
Ovkovv tovto ye, ecprjv, 6 otet, e7ret8?77rep ekkr)vieLV

etricrTacraL, kolv eXiroLS brjrrov avTo otl ctol cpatVerat;
"Icrcos, ecpr).
"Iva Toivvv TOTrdcrcopLev etre crot eveorLV etre /xr/, eiire, r/i/
8' eyco, t'l cpr)S eXvaL crcocppocrvvrjv Kara Tr]V crr)v boav. 10
Kat 6s to p.ev irpcoTov coKveL re Kat ov Trdm; rjdekev airo- b
C 7 ov fiaSiov T et yp. W : &\oyov B W d3 4iri5ti(o] awoSeigw

ci. Stallbaum d8 av Ven. 189
tlrj : Jtj av eTvai BT (ehai secl.
ci. Stephanus : elfrj secl. ci. Salvini) 6 2 o3 B T
e4 oAAa
: a3r'
irdvTwv T: a\A' arrai^rwi' B 65 $\tiov Heindorf: /SeArico
ci.
BT : f}4\Ttov av ci. Cobet o-Kttytadai Stephanus e 6 T7)5e
Bt : ti 8* T : ti Sal t (altera manu) a 1 oi-ttJs B t : outV T
i59b IIAAT&N02
Kpivaadai' e7retra ueVrot eT7re7> ort 61 8okoT o-UHppocrvvr\ elvai
t6 koctuico? Ttavra TipaTTe.LV Kal fjo-vxf}, eV re raty dSots

/3a8tety /cai 8taAe'yecr#ai, /cai tcl dAAa TravTa cocrairrco?
5 TToielv. KaC uot 8oKet, ec/)rj, crvAkrjftbriv rjcrvyjLOTrjs tls (Tvai
6 ZpoiTqs.
'Ap' ow, ?Jv
8' eyco, ev Aeyets; c/>acri ye rot, co XaputSrr,
tovs rjcrvyjiovs cruxppovas eti>ar t8copei> 8r/ et rt Ae'youcriz\
C enre ydp uot, ov rcov Ka.\&v p.ivToi r) acacppoo-vvrj IcttCv;
Yldvv ye, ec/>rj.
YloTepov ovv koXXio-tov V y pap.p.ar icttov t<x ouota ypdp-

p.aTa ypdcpe.LV Tayv rj rjcrvxft;
5 Taxv.
Tt 8' divaytyivcocrKeti'; raxe'cos ?/ /3pa8e'co?;
Taxe'co?.
Kat uey 8r/ Kat rb KLdapC&LV Tayeoas koX tq ixakaCeLv
oe'cos 7roAi KaWiov tov r)o-v\f] re /cat /3pa8e'cos;
io Nat'.
Tt 8e irvKTevtLv re Kat irayKpaTLaêLV ; ov\ cbcravrcos;
ITdjnr ye.
@etv 8e Kat dAAecr#at Kat tcl tov crcouaro? airavTa epya,

d ov rd uey d<fe'co? Kat raxi) yLyvop.eva rd roS koAou cttlv, tol
be [/3pa8e'a] udyt? re Kat r]0~vyr\ ra rorj alo-\pov;

4>atVerat.
4>au>erat dpa r/uty, ecpr/y eyco, Kard ye rd crcoua ov rd
5 rjcrvxLov, dAAd rd rdxtcrrov Kat o^vTaTov KaAAtcrror dV.
?/ ydp;
Yldvv ye.
'H 8e' ye croicppocrvvri Kakov ri 7/r;
Nat'.
b 2 of B 2 T : oSi/ W (sed suprascr. ol W) 5o/fo? B W (sed e
supra o7 W) : Soxer T b 7 <paai ye roi T W : 0a<ri/ B 03 ko.\-

Ajo-tov] k&Wiov Stephanus : k<L\\i6v ecrriv Schanz e 9 tov T :
irov B : nov t) B 2
d 1 ra toD T : tou B d2 /SoaSea secl. ci.
Heindorf d4 &pa T y &pa B

: : Tapa Cobet
XAPMIAH2 I59d
Ov toLvvv KaTa ye rb acopa r) fja-v^LOT-qs av dAA' r) 10
Ta\VTi]s aaxppoviaTepov etr/, e7ret8r/ Kakov r) aooq^poavvr).
"EoiKtv, <pr].
Tt 8e'; r)v 8' eyco, evp.a6La KakkLov r) bvap.a6La; e

Evp.a6La.
"Eo-tlv 8e' y, (prjv, r) p.ev tvp.a6La Tayius p.av6avLV, r)
8e bvo~p.a6La r]o-v\r\ Kal /3oa8e'cos;

Nat'. 5
Aibao-KeLv 8e akkov ov raxecos [kol] Kakktov Kal acpobpa
p.akkov r) r)avxfj re Kal fipabem;
Nat.
Tt 8e'; avap.Lp:vrjcrKeadaL ml ^p.vr)cr6ai r)o~vxfj re Kal
fipabtojs KakkLov ?*/ a(p6bpa Kal raxecos; 10
2c/>o'8p', e</3r/, Kal Taxôos.

C
H 8' ayxLvoLa ovx<- 6vTr)s tLs Zcttiv tt/s ^fvxvs dAA' ovxl 160
r)avxLa;
'AAr/0r/.
Ovkovv Kal to orvvLivat ra Aeyo'pez>a, Kal iv ypap/xaricrrorj

koX KLdapLOTov Kal akkodt iravTaxov, oi>x <*>s r/crrjxatrara akk 5
cos rdxtcrrd ecrrt KaAAtcrra;
Nat.
'AAAd pJqv ev ye rats TjTr/crecrii> rr/s xj/vxijs koX tw
fiovkeveadaL oi>x 6 r/cruxicoraros, cos eyco oTpai, /cat /xdyts
fiovkevopevos re Kat avevpLcrKOJV ktraLvov 8okci dtos etrat, 10
dAA' 6 pacrTa. re /cat rdxicrra rorjro 8pcoi\ b

"Eariv raura, <=(pr).
Ovkovv iravTa, rjv 8' eyco, co Xapp.Lbr), r)p2v xat rd TTepi rr/y
tyvxhv Ka i rd 7rept rd crco/xa, rd rorj rdxous re Kat rr/s d<fTJrT/TOS
KaAAtco cpatWrai 77 rd rf/s j3pabvTr)Tos re Kat rjavxt-OTrfTos; 5

KtPtWevet, e<pT/.
Otjk dpa r/cruxtoVr/s rts r/ CTOMppocrvvr] av etr/, otj8' rjavx 10 *
d 10 ?j T ^crux^Trjs B
7)<xvxi6t7)s : e6 al BTW: del. corr.
Coisl. a6
KaAAio-Ta] /w<* <7 (rri ku\\l<ttov niallet Stallbaum
a9 ^<n/xiTOToy Cobet y)<rv\wTaTos : BT
i6ob nAATX2N02
v
6 (Tu>(pp(av /3t'os, eK ye tovtov tov Adyorj, e7ret8? / Kakov airrov
8et eti>at auxppova ovra. bvolv yap br) tcl erepa" 77 ovbap.ov
C iip.1v ?/ Traû 7Tou dAtyaxou at r)avyj.OL 7rpdets iv rco /3tcp
KaAAtous icpdvrja-av r) at Ta\ etat re Kat layypai. et 5' ow, a>
c/jiAe, 6'rt /xdAtcrra /xr/8ei> eAarrorjs at r)o-v\ioi rcoy acpobp&v

re Kat raxetcoy irpdêoiv Tvy^dvovcrtv koAAiotjs ovaai, ovbk
5 TavTrj aoxppoavvr) av etr/ /xdAAdz; tl to rjavxfj TTpaTTtiv r) to

acpobpa re Kat raê'co?, ovre kv /3a8tcr/j,cp o?jre ev Ae'et 07jre
dAAofli ovbap.ov, ovbe 6 r)avx i0S /3tos [KoV|mos]ro7j /x?) r)av\iov
d crcoc/jporjeVrepos av etrj, e7retS?/ ez> rco Adycp rco/j KaAcoi rt 7//xty
77 aoxppoavvr) v-ntTedr), Ka\a 8e otj^ ^rroy (rd) ra\e'a rcov

r)av\io)v TTtfpavTat.
'Opflcos pot 8oKets, e0r/, 2> ScoKpares, etpr/KeVat.

5 IlaAiv tolwv, rjv 8' eyco, S XappLt.br), paAAoi irpoazyu)v
tov vovv Kal ets aeavTov ep/3Ae\/>as, ewoT/cras 07roto'y riyd
cre 7rotet 77 auxppoavvr) irapovaa Kal iroia rts orjaa roiorjrorj

a7repyd(/>iro ay, 7rdjjra raura o"?jAAoyicrd/xei>os et7re ev Kal
e avbpeiuts tl ctol qbaivtTaL etyat;
Kat os e7rtcrxcby Kat 7rayu d7j8piKcos 7rpds earjroy StacrKe\/>d-
p.cvos, AoKet tolvvv piOL, ecprj, alayyveadaL 7roieti> r) aojcppo-
avvr) Kat aicrxwr?/A6z> tov avOponrov, Kal clvaL 07rep atScos ?/
5 aojcppoavvr).
Elev, r]v 8' eyco, ov m\6v dprt co/xoAdyets tt)v auicppo-

crvvr)v eti>at;
Ildyrj y, ec/>??.
0?JKorj7j Kat dya#ot drjSpes 01 auxppoves;

10 Nat.
T
Ap' orjy dy etr/ dyaOov 6 p?) dyatôrjs a7repyd(ferat;
C 5 ^ tJ Priscianus f) rov B T rov Schanz C6 oijre ovWi

W
: . . .
W
:
Priscianus: ov rb ov rb B T . . . 7 ovSe corr. Coisl. : ovStv B T

c
Kô-fuos secl. ci. Heindorf: ko\ k6o-ixios corr. Coisl. oAct da T
"
Kal &\\a B tA add. corr. Coisl. t/xf$\(\}/as scripsi d6
cbrejuj8A<tyas B (sed Aif in ras.) : d7ro^3AeôsTW e6 ehv T
elra B e npost elrj lacunam indicat Schanz ayadovs, (koI
/j.1) ayaQov, ayaOovs} ci. Goldbacher
XAPM1AH2 i6oe
Ov brjra.
Ov fxovov ovv apa Kakov, akka nal ayadov eoru/.

"E/ioiye 8oKet. i6i
Tt ovv; r)v 8' eyor '0/u.rjpa) ov 7rtoTer;eis KaAois Ae'yety,
kiyovTi drt
atSa)? 8' ovk ayaOr) Ke\prip.V(o avbpl itapelvai;
"Eycoy, ecprj. 5
'Eartv apa, a>s eotKey, ai8a)S ot)k ayaObv Kat 6\ya66v.
SaxTjpoarjVrj 5e' ye ayafldV, et7rep ayaOovs 7roiei ots ar

7raprj, KaKovs 8e /atj.
'AUa /xrjy orjra) ye 8oKet p,oi eêty, a>? av Aeyets. 10
Ovk apa atixppoavvr) av etri ai8a)s, et7rep rd pikv ayaBbv

Tvyyavei ov, at8a>s 8e [pvq] ovbev p.akkov ayadbv r) Kat b
kokoV.
'AAA' epotye SoKet, ecprj, a> 2a>Kpares, tovto p\v opd&s
Ae'yeo-0ar ro'8e 8e o-Ke'\//ai rt aot 8oKet etrat 7rept aa)(ppo-
o-vvrjs. dprt yap avp.vqo-0r)v o t/8tj tov rjKovaa kiyovTos 5
ort crattypocrvvr) av etr/ rd ra kavTov Tspa.TTf.iv. aKOTret otji>
tovto et dp6a>s (rot 8oKet Aeyetr 6 keycov.

Kat eya>, *I2 /xtape', e<pr/y, Kptrtou ror38e aKTjKoas arjrd r/
aAAou rou t&v aoqb&v. C

v
EotKer, ecprj 6 Kptrtas, aAAou* orj ydp 8tj ep.ov ye.
'AAAa rt 8ta<pe'pet, r/ 8' os, 6 Xap/xt'8r/s, a> 2a)Kpares, drorj
r/Kouaa;
Ovbev, rjv 8' eyco" 7rdyra)S yap ov tovto o-kttt(ov, doTis 5
arjrd et7rei>, dAAa iroTtpov dArjfles Aeyerat 77 orj.
Nw dpflais Ae'yets, r) 8' ds.
Nr/ Ata, r/y 8' eya>. dAA' et Kat erjpTjo-opey avrd o7rr/ ye
eêt, 6avp.a(pi.p? av atvty/xart ydp rtrt ioiKev.
Ort 8r/ rt ye; (pr/. 10
bi /iji secl. Ast Kai om. Par. 1809 : secl. Cobet b6 ar

secl. Bekker c 10 '6n 5); T : eiS)|BW (sed suprascr. 6'ti W)
i6id rTAAT&N02
d "Oti ov briTTOv, r)v o' eyco, r) tcl pr]p.aTa ec/>0e'yaro TavTrj
Kal kvocL, kiyoiv <roi<ppo<rvvt]v zlvai to tql avrov irpaTTt.LV.
r) o-v oibev fjyfj TrpaTTeiv tov ypap.paTL(TTr]V otov ypa<pr\ r)
avayiyv(i)(TKr\;
5 "Eycoye, r)yovp.aL pikv ovv, ec/>T?.
AoKet ovv aot to avTOv 6vop.a p.6vov ypacpeiv 6 ypap.-

/Liartarr)? /cat avayLyv<a<TKLV rj vpias tovs TraXbas oi5aaKea>,
7} ovbtv rJTTov to. tQ>v kyOpGtv eypac/>ere r) to. vp&repa Kat tcl
t&v (pCkcov 6v6p.aTa;
10 Ovbev tJttov.
'H ovv TToX.VTTpayp.oviTe Kat ovk eaa)a>povetre tovto

e bp&VTCs;
Ovbap.<2s.
Kal p.r)v ov tcl Tj/xeYeod ye avT&v e7rparrere, enrep to
ypaqbeiv TrpaTTt.Lv tC eartv Kat to dvayLyv<o<TKLV.
5 'AAAd p.r]v Zcttlv.
Kat yap to tdac9ai, a> eratpe, Kat to olKobop.LV Kal t6

ixpaCvtLv Kat to jjtlvlovv T\vr] otlovv t<2v Tiy^vqs Hpytov
aTreoydfeatfat 7rparrety o?/7rou rt earti>.
Tldw ye.
10 Tt ovv; r)v 8' eyco, SoKet av aot 7ro'Ats eu otKetaflai vito

TOVTOV TOV VOp.OV TOV KikdVOVTOS TO kaVTOV lp.aTLOV CKaOTOV
iKpaCveLV kol ttXvvclv, Kat v7robr)p.aTa <TKVTOTop.clv, Kal kr)-
kv6ov Kat arAeyyt'8a Kat rdAAa irdvTa Kara tov ovtov koyov,
162 t5>v pckv akkoTpCoov p.r) aTTTeaOaL, tcl 8e eaurou t-Kao-rov
tpya&o-daC re Kat irpaTTCLv;
Ovk e/iotye ooKet, ?/
5' os.
'AAAd /xeVrot, ec/>r/y eyco, <roxpp6vo>s ye otKOuaa eu av

5 otKotro.
n<Ss 8' oi!k; ec/>?/.
d 1 77 W : B : om. T d2 <S ante add. corr. Coisl.

A.eya'
e 10 eS* olice?(r6ai
fy
T W : apKelffdcu B e 12 \-fiKv0ov BT
\Lkv6ov t
a 4 7*
:
e 13 itoi/to] TroioOvTa vel iravTa iroiovvra ci. H. Richards

B 2
: tBT
XAPMIAH2 i62a
Ovk dpa, r)v 8' eyco, rd tcl Toiavra re nai ovtco to. avrov
TrpaTTtLV croicppocrvvr) av etrr.
Ov (paiveTai.
'Htz/trrero dpa, cos j-olkcv, 07rep dprt eyco ekeyov, 6 keyoiv 10

rd ra ar/rou 7rpdrreti' croicppocrvvriv etz>ar ov ydp ttov orjrco
ye rjv evrjdtjs. r\ tlvos r]ktQiov rjKovcras tovtl kiyovTos, co b

Xappt8rr;
"HKtcrrd ye, ecprr, e7ret rot Kat irdvv eSoKet crocpbs eirat.
na^ros tolvvv pxikkov, cos e/uoi 8oKet, alvLyp.a avTo

npovfiakzv, o)? oy x.
a ^ e7roi; TO ra vrw Trpdrrety yz/coVat 5
ort 7rore ecrrtz\
"lcrois, ecprr.
Tt orjz> dz> etrr 7rore to tcl avrov irpdmLv; eêts et7rety;
Ovk ot8a p.a Ata eycoye, r/ 8' 6V dAA' fcrcos orj8ev KcoArjet
p.r)be tov kiyovra /xrrSey etSeVat otl ez/det. Kat dju.a rarjra io
kkyoiv imeyika re Kat ets tov KptrtW a7re'/3Ae7rez>.
Kat 6 Kptrtas 8r/Aos pez> 77^ Kat 7rdAat dycoz>t<oz> Kat C

cpiAori/Acos irpos re rdz> X.app.Cbrjv Kat 7rpds rovs 7rapdrras
exôy, pdyts 8' earjrdz> kv ru irpocrdiv KaT%oiv totc ov\ otos

re iykveTO' 8oKet ydp pot 7raz>rds pJakkov akrjdes etz>at, 6 ey<w
inrikafiov, tov Kptrtorj aKT/KoeVat rw \app.Lhr\v TavTrjv rr)v 5

aTTOKpLcrLV 7rept ttjs crcocppocrvvrjs. 6 p.ev ovv XapLttSr/s /3orjAd-
peroj pr/ arjrds viriytLV koyov dAA' eKetroy r^s a7roKptcrecos,
vttklvL avrbv tKZLVov, kclX cvebeLKVVTo cos eêAr/AeypeVos etrj* d

6 8' otjk rjZJeVxero, dAAd pot e8oez/ opyLcrdrjvaL avTca cocnrep
TT0Lr]Tr)s viTOKpLTf) KaKcos 8tari0eVrt rd earjrorj 7rotrjpara.
wo-r' ep/3Ae'\xVas avrw et7rey, Orvrcos otet, to Xapp,t8rj, et o-v
/mr) oXcrOa otl ttot erdet o? ecprr croicppocrvvr)v etvaL rd rd eauroO 5

7rpdrrety, orj8e 8r) eKetroi et8e'vai;
'AAA', co /3e'Artcrre, ecprji eyco, Kptrta, rorjroy /xey or38er

6avp.acrTov dyvotLV rrjAtKoCroy di^ra* cre 8e' 7rou etKos elbevaL G
d. 4 cri T : aol B d5 itot' ^/<Jt t : ttqtc iviet B irore foe? T

W
:
e 1 elKos elb*4vai T : efSfVat re vera B

PLATO, VOL. III. 3
i62e nAATX2N02
Kdl r/AtKias ZveKa kcu eiTLpLekeCas. et ovv crvyxcopels tovt
elvaL o-(o(ppoo"vvr}v oirep ovtoo\ Ae'yet koX 7rapa8e'x?/ t6v koyov,
eycoye 7ro\v av 578101 p,era aov o-KoiroCpjrjV etr' dkrjOes etre
5 pVt) to ke\6ev.
'AAAa itavv (rvyyu>pG>, ecpr\, Kal 7rapaSe'xop.at.
KaAcos ye cri; toCvvv, r)v 8' eyco, 7rotco>. Kat p.01 Ae'ye, 77
Kal a vvvbr) r\pd>T(ov eyco o-Tjyxcopets, tovs brjpuovpyovs 7rdvTas
TToieiv rt;
10 "Eycoye.
I63 *H OVV b0K0V(TL (TOl TCL kaVT&V pLOVOV TTOUlv T) KOl T(X tG>V
dkkdiv;
Kat tcl tG>v dkkcov.
"2i(0(pp0V0V(TLV OVV OV TCL kaVT&V pLOVOV TtOLOVVTes;

5 Tt ydp KcoAvet; ecpr/.
Ovbev epe ye, r)v 8' eyco* dAA' opa pvq eKelvov KtokveL, bs
virodep.evos o-coqbpoo-vvriv elvaL t6 ra eavrov TrpaTTtLV eirevra

ovbev cprjo-L kcoKvclv Kal tovs Ta tG>v dkkiov irpaTTOVTas
O-COCppOVCLV.
10 'Eyco ydp trov, r) 8' os, Tovd' copoAoyr/Ka, cos 01 rd

tG>v akkoov 7TpaTT0VTS crcocppovovo-LV, et rovs TTOLOVVTaS
cop,oAdyrjcra.
b Et7re /xot, r)v 8' eyco, ov Tavrov KaAets to ttoluv Kai to

TTpaTTLV;
Ov jueyrot, ecpT]* o?38e ye ro epydecr0at Kat ro 7rotetf.
ep:a8ov ydp trap 'HcridSou, os ecpr/ epyov [8'1 ot8ei> etmt

5 oVetSos. otet ovv avrov, et Ta TOLavra epya eKaAet Kai
epydêo-QaL Kat irpaTTeLV, ola i/w8r) crv eAeye?, ov8ert cw
oVetSo? (pdvaL etvaL (tkvtotoplovvtl t/ TapiypircokovvTL r/ e7r
otKT/paros KadripLV(p; ovk otecrdaC ye x/ 37? * 2coKpares, dAAa

Kat eKetô? otpat ttoCtjo-lv 7rpdfecos Kai epyacrCas dAAo eVd-
C pter, Kat TToCripLa p,ev yCyveo-QaL oveLbos ivCore, oTav pr/
a4 ou B : of T : of /u^ W a 10 ^cfcp iroo Cobet a11 e ci.
Heindorf ^ B ^ T W b4 5' vel ehai secl. ci. Steplianus

W
:
: :
jj
b 6 e\7S T : Ktytts B
XAPMIAH2 163C
uera tov Kakov yCyvrvraL, epyov 8e ovbeiroTe ovbev ovtLbos"
tcl yap Kaktos re <a\ totpekCfxcos iroLov\xeva epya eKaAet, /ccu
epyatrCas re Kal TTpaêts tcls TOLavTas TTOLT\creLS. tpdvaL be
ye Xprj Kal otKeta uoVa tcl Toiama r\yettrdat airov, ra be 5

e
fikafiepa Trdvra akkorpta' cocrre Kal Hcrto8oy \pr\ otecrOat

Kal dkkov otrrts tppovt\xos tov tcl avTOv irpaTTovTa tovtov
aaxppova Kakelv.
'12 KptrCa, r\v 8' eyco, Kal evOvs apyotxevov o-ov tr-êbbv d
e\xdv6avov tov koyov, otl tcl otKeia re Kat tcl avrov ayada
KakoCrrs, Kal tcls Ttov ayadtov irotrjcreis' irpdêLS' koI yap
YlpobtKov \xvpCa Ttva aKr\Koa irepl 6vo\x6tcov btatpovvTos.
dAA' eyco crot rCdecrdat \xev tcov 6vo\xaTcov 8t8cout oirrj av 5
\3ovkr\ eKatTTOV brjkov be \xovov e<p' 6'rt av tpepr\s rovvo\xa
otl av keyr\s. vvv ovv irdktv e dpxvs cratpetrTepov optcrar

apa tt)v t&v ayadtov irpa^LV r) TroCr\crLV r\ ottcos ctv /3ovAet e
6vo\xd(eLv, Tavrr\v keyeLS av o-cotppooijvrrv elvai;
v
Eycoye, etpr\.
Ovk apa crcotppovel 6 tcl KaKa Trparrcov, dAA' 6 rdyadd;

2ot 8e', rj b' 6s, co /3e'Artcrre, ov^ ovtco boKeX; 5
v
Ea, rjv 8' eyco* \xr\ ydp irco to e\xol ookovv tTKOircoixev,
dAA' o crv keyets vvv.

'AAAa ueVrot eycoye, etprj, tov utj ayada akka KaKa
TroLovvra ov tpr\\xL crcotppovew, tov be ayada akka \xr) KaKa
crcotPpovtLV rr\v yap tcov ayaOcov Trpa^LV crtotppocrvvrrv etvat 1
tratptos ctol btopC(ft\xat.
Kat ovbiv ye cre tcrcos KcoAvet akr\6r) keyetv ro'8e ye 164

pievTot, r\v 8' eyco, 6av\xaco, et trcotPpovovvTas avOpcoirovs
r\yr\ o~v ayvoeCv ort crcotPpovovatv.
'AAA' ov% r)yov\xat, ec/>r/.
Ovk okCyov Trporepov, etpr\v eyco, eAe'yero inrb crov ort toxjs 5
d5 &v &ov\ri W : hv de\ri B : /Sou/uj T : &/ ?A?; Hermann d6 h.v
<piprisBT h.v (ptpois al. : 8^ <p4peis ci. H. Richards 6 10 rmv

W W
:
aya6tiv T : ruv B a 1 7 cr B : ye T
3*
;
i64a IIAAT&N02
br]p.Lovpyov$ ovbev KcoAi/et nal av tcl tG>v dXkcov iroiovvTas
craxppov&v
'EAeyero ydp, %<pr\' dhkd tC tovto;
Ovbiv akka Ae'ye et boKel tls ctol larpos, vyia Tiva
b ttolG>v, dxf>ikLp.a na\ eaurco itoiziv Kal eKetVcp ov tcpro;
"Ep.ot.ye.
Ovkovv Ta hiovTa irpcLTTZi 6 ye raura Trpdrrcor;

Nat.
5 'O ra btovra irpaTTtov ov craxppoval;
ôxppoveX pikv ovv.
'H ovv Kal yLyvdxrKCLV avdyKrj tQ> tarpco otov re cocpeAi/Acos
tdrat Kat orav p.r); Kal eKacrrco tSv br\p.Lovpyo>v bWav re p.iXXr\
ovrjcrecrdaL cnrb tov epyov ov av irpdTTri kcil orav pJ\;
y
10 Icrcos ov.
'Einore apa, rjv 8' eyco, dxpek.Lp.ois irpdâs rj /3Aa/3epcos 6
C larpbs ov yLyvaxrKeL eavrbv co? eirpaêv Katrot coc/>eAi'/xco?
irpdâs, cos 6 cros Ao'yos, <raxpp6va>s eirpaêv. rj ov^ oi/rcos
lAeyes;
v
Eycoye.
5 Ovkow, cos eoiKev, eviore cocpeAi/jicos irpdâs irpdrret /Aev
(raxpp6va>s Kal croxppovel, dyvoel 8' eai^"oy ort craxppovel;
'AAAd rouro /xeV, e<//, co ScoKparey, ovk dv 7rore yevoLTO,
dAA' et rt cry otet eK rcoy ep.irpocrOev vti ep.ov a>p.oXoyr)p.eva>v
els roOro dvayKaxov elvaL crvp.(3aLveLV, eKeivo>v dv tl eycoye
d /xaAAoi/ dva6eLp.r\v, kol ovk av aicr)(yv6eLr]v p.rj ovyj. 6p6S>s

(pdvaL etpr/KeVat, ptd.XX.ov 77 Trore crvy^copT/crat/x' di> dypoowra
ovtov kavTov avdponrov craxppovelv. cryebbv ydp tl eycoye
ax/TO tovto (pr)p.L eTvaL craxppocnjvqv, rb yLyvdxTKeLV eauroV,
a6 ci. Heindorf
aS secl. a9 av vel post 5o/c? vel post b 1 u<p(\i/xa
add. ci. H. Richards b5 to] 8e to corr. Coisl. b 8 tKacrrw
TW eKaffrw tJ B eKdffrep riv\ Schanz b9 ov T W
rov B
W
: :
W
:
irpirrri B : irpdfy T sed r in marg. T C8 crb crot B T

:
e 9 ts secl. Hirschig di ju)) Stobaeus &Vi /t))

: B T oVtS^/ ci.
:
Bekker t fiti ci. Madvig

: brwvv : ci. Cobet
fii) ToVe : /u)j Schanz
d.3 &vdpoyirov avrbv eavrbv Stobaeus
XAPMIAH2 i64d
xai crvp.cpipop.aL ra> iv AaXcpois avaBkvri ro tolovtov ypdp.p.a. 5

/cat yap tovto ovtco pot boKei to ypdp.p.a avaKeicr0aL, a>s br)
7rpoVpr?a"ts ovo-a tov 0ov tcov (Ictlovtcov clvtX tov Xatpe, a>s
tovtov p.\v ovk opdov ovtos tov Trpocrpr)p.aTos, tov yatpeiv, e

ov8e btiv tovto 7rapaKeAeveo-ât dAA?/Aots ctAAa crcocppovtiv.
ovtco p.\v br) 6 0a6s Trpocrayopevet. tovs etVioVras ets ro
tepoi' biacpipov tl rj oi dv0pcoiTOL, cos hiavooviievos dvi0r\Kzv
6 avaOets, ais /xot 8oKet' Kat Aeyet 7rpos t6v det eto-toVra ovk 5
aAAo rt ?j SaxppoVet, cprjcrLV. aaiyuara>8eVrepor 8e brj, <as
p.dvTis, Ae'yef ro yap TvcoOl cravrov Kat ro SaxppoVet eVriy

pey Tavrov, d>? ra ypdp.p.aTa cprjcrLV koX iyco, Taya 8' av rts 165
otr/fletr? dAAo etvai, o 8?] /txot boKovcrLV iraOtLV Kal oi tcl vcrT^pov
ypdp.p.aTa dvaOivTiS, to re M??8ey dyav Kat to 'Eyyvr? 7rdpa
8' aTt). kol ydp ovtol crvp.(3ovX.r)v cat]0ricrav etvaL to TvcoOl
cravTov, dAA' ov tcov dcnovTcov [eVeKey] ?J7ro tov deov 5
irpocrprjcrLV' et0' tva br) Kal crcpeis p.r)btv tjttov o~vp.(3ov\as
XprjcrLp.ovs dva$LV, Tama ypd^j/avres avidecrav. ov br) ovv
eVeKa Ae'ya>, co 2a>Kpare?, Tavra irdvTa, rdS' eVrtV ra p.\v
^pLTTpocrdev croL irdvTa d<ptr?p,i io-a>s pkv ydp tl crv lAeyes b
7rept avTcov 6p0OTpov, lcrcos 8' eya>, cracpes 8' o?38ei> irdvv r\v
cov iX.iyop.cv vvv 8' e0e'Aa> tovtov ctol 8t8oVat Xoyov, el p.r)
opoAoyets crcocppocrvvrjv etyat to yLyvco<TKLV avTov iavrov.

'AAA', r)v 8' eya>, w Kptrta, crv pkv a>s <pd<TKOVTOS ip.ov 5
etSeVat 7rept cov ipcorco -npocrcpipr] irpos p.e, Kal idv brj ftov-
Aa>pat, 6p.o\oyrjcrovT6s ctol' to 8' ov\ ovtcos êt, dAAa
CqTco ydp p.tTa crov det to TTpoTL0ip.evov 8ta to p.rj avros
e 1 tov xdpiiv B 2
Stobaeus : rh xp"' BT : secl. Cobet e 2 iA-
\4\\ois B Stobaeus : aW^Kovs T 63 outco /uev Srj] tovtcj> olv 8^j
Stobaeus 056 om. Stobaeus /tot] ^/*o2 Stobaeus e 6 o--
<ppov(iv Stobaeus a 3 iyyvrj T ^yyicfj B iyyvit) b iyyva t : : :
Stobaeus a 4 #t?} B T frra t Stobaeus : a 5 eve K(v B T W

Stobaeus addub. Heindorf, secl. Cobet
: a 6 tW om. Stobaeus
<r(pus T outoI Stobaeus owtoI o-<pus outoj <pris B W
avfi&ovAas
W
: : :
Xpy<ri/xovs B xP7 (T ilii0VS <rv/j.fiov\as T Stobaeus

: l b 2 avT&v
T : aurbi' B b7 bix.o\oyi\<iovT6s aoi ci. Heusde : 6/xo\oyfio-avT4s
(Tov BT
165C nAAT&NOS
C ei8eVat. vKety&ixevos ovv e0e'Aco et7reiJ> etre 6/xoAoyco elre
/at/. dAA' eTricryzs ecos av o-Ke\//-coixai.
SKoVet 877, 77
8' os.
Kat ydp, t/v 8' eyco, crK07rco. et yap 87) yty^coo-Ketv ye'
5 rt ecrriy 77 o-ui^poo-vvri, bij\ov otl iTno-Trjfxri tls ay etr/ Kat

TLVOS' 7/ o{!;
"Ea-riy, ec/>7/, kavTov ye.

Ovkow Kai tarpiK77, ec/jr/z/, eTrto-r^ri eo-rtz; rou vytetyoTj;
ndzn> ye.
10 Et tolvvv /xe, eqbrjv, epoto o-tt " 'IarptKT/ vytetvoC e7rt-
arTj/XTj ovo-a rt 77/xu'

xPrl~ l xr eariy
'r l
Kat rt a7repyaêrat,"
d et7roi/x' av ori ov o-fXLKpav dxpeXCav rr)v yap vyitLav Kakbv
rjpuv epyov d7re/)yderai, et d7ro8e'x?/ ro S ro '
'A7ro8e'xo/xat.
Kat et Toivvv /xe epoto rrjv oikoSo/xikt/v, e7rtoT7///,r/y oSo-ai'
5 rou otKoSo/uety, rt o3r//xt e/)yoi> a7re/)ydeo-0ai, zi"noLp? av otl

otKT/o-ets* cocraTJrcos 8e Kat rcoz> dAAcoz; rexy&v. XPV ovv Ka *
v
o-e VTttp Trjs crajcppocrvvrjs, e7ret87 / c/>r)s avrr)v kavTOv e7rtcrr7/-
"T
/xtjz; etz>at, exetz; et7reiz> epcorr/têWa, H Kptrta, crcoc/>/)oo-7Jz;r/,
e e7rto-r7//xr/ ovo-a eavroC, rt Kakbv rjp.LV epyov d7repyderat Kat

dcjtoy roS 6vop.aTos; " Wi oSz;, eiTre'.
'AAA', co ScoKpares, eajr/, ovk 6p6a>s Cr/rets. ov 7 a P /xota

avrr/ irecpvKev rat? dAAat? e7rtcrr7//xat?, oi>8e ye at dAAat dA-
5 AT/Aats* crt 8' cbs o/xoicoz; ovoSiV TtoLr) tt)v (jiTr)o-LV. e7ret Ae'ye
/xot, ec/>r/, r7/s AoytcrrtKf/5 Ttyvris r) Tr)s yecojuerptK^? rt eorty

TOLOVTOV ipyOV oloV OtKta OlKoSo/AtK^S 7/ ipXJLTLOV vqjaVTLKTJS 7/
dAAa rotaSr' epya, a 7roAAd dy tls expt 7roAAcoy rex^coz;

l66 8etc;at; e^f t? ow pot Kat crv tovtcov tolovtov tl epyov 8etât;
dAA' oi>x ecfets.
C 4 yiyvdxTKftv Tb : yiyvdxTKd B C 8 eîjf W : t^tj BT

d. 5 OlKO$0/Jle?V T W : OlKotofllKOV B e 3 OfJ.ola aVTT] T 6,uola>s
W
:
aSrr) : dfwiws Tavrri B e4 a\\-fi\ats ci. Heusde : aWais B T

e5 7roif) "H)j/ ^ttrifffiu W : irote7 tt;/ ^TTjfftu B : t^v i\T7\atu irotei T Ae-yg
TW : 8e 76 B e6 Aoyjo-TiKrjs T W : A.o7<kt)s B 67 toiovtov
T t6 : toiovtov B a i toioOtoV B T 2
: toiovtwv B
;
XAPMIAHS i66a
Kat eyco elirov otl 'AAr/0r/ Aeyets* dAAd ro'8e ctol ex<o
8etcfai, rtVo? eorty e7rtcrrr/jur/ kKao-Tr) tovtojv tG>v e7n.0-Trnj.6iv,
6 Tvyyavei ov dAAo avrrjs Trjs e7rtoTr///r/s. olov r) AoyicrrtKr/ 5

eOTiy TTOV TOV apTLOV Kal TOV 7TpLTT0V, TrXfjOoVS OTTOjS \L
irpbs avra /cat rrpbs dAAr/Aa* r/ ydp;
Yldvv ye, e<pr/.
Ovkovv cTtpov ovtos tov TTepLTTov Kal dpTLOV avTr)s Trjs

KoyLcrTLKrjs; 10
IIcos 8' ov;
Kat p.r)v av r) crTaTiKr) tov fiapvTtpov re Kat Kovcporipov b

crTadpiov io-TLv ctTaTLKr]' tTepov 8e ko-TLV to fiapv re Kat
Kovcpov Tr)s crTaTLKrjs avTrjs. o-rjyxcooei? ;
v
Eycoye.
Ae'ye 8r/, Kat r) crojcppooijvr) tlvos iorlv 7TLcrTr)fxr), 6 5
rrjyxdvet frepov ov avrrjs rfjs croj(ppocrvvr)s

Touro cfcrriv eKetro, cpr), S) ScoKpares* e7r' avrb rJKiis
epewcoy to S> 8tacpe'pet iracr&v tojv TTLcrTr)p.ojv r) crojchpocrvvr)'
crv 8e 6p.oLOTr)Td TLva (^rirets avrr)s rats dAAats. to 8' ovk

cttlv ovtojs, dAA' at fxkv dAAat TracraL dkkov eicrlv e7Ttcrrr/- C
fxai, havT&v 8' ov, 7/ Se pVt) rcoy re dAAcor 7TLcrTr)p.ojv
e7rtcrrr/pr/ ecrrt /cat arjrr/ eaurr]y. Kat rairrd cre 7roAAoS 8et
AeAr/t9eVat, dAAd ydp ot/xat 6 dprt ovk ecpr/crcâ 7rotety, tovto
ttolhs' e/xe ydp e7rtxetpet? eAe'yxi*> idaas 7rept orj d Adyos 5
ecrrtV.
OXov, rjv 8' eyco, Trotets r)yovfXVOS, et ort /xdAtcrra cre
eAe'yx<o, dAAorj rwds eVeKa ikiy\LV r/ oxnrep VKa kolv
ifxavrbv 8tepewcop,r/i> tl Aeyco, (po/3ovp.VOS fxf) ttot kdOoj d

otdperos peV rt etSeVat, etScb? 8e /xr/. Kat m 8r/ ovv f-yooyi
(pr)p.L tovto 7T0Llv, tov koyov ctko7Tlv /xdAiara fJ.V ifiavTov
VKa, lcrois 8e 8r/ Kat rcoy aAAcoy e7Ttrr/8etcoy' r/ orj kolvov
b2 (rrariK-fi secl. ci. Heindorf t /caJ T Ka2 tJ> B b 8 rb

W
:
$ ci. H. Richards ortp B 'ry (sic) T:

: : iraoS>v T et ^p. t^W :
irAeuo B W C 8 &\\ov Tivbs T a\\' ob rivbs B W

d. I Sifpev
W
:
ixp/j.riv B SiepevvcpV" T
: d 4 koj^^ B 2 T tcotvwv B :
i66d nAAT12NOS
5 otet ayadbv elvaL axeSdy tl Tia(nv avdpoiTTOLs, yiyv0~6ai
Karacpaves eKaarov t5>v ovtodv otttj exet;
Kai /xdAa, r) 8' 6s, eycoye, co "ScoKpares.
appS>v tolvvv, r)v 8' eyco, co p,aKapte, cnroKpLVopLevos to
epu>Toop.evov ottjj trot cpatVerat, ea yaiptLV etre Kptrias ecrriv
e etre ScoKpdrrjs 6 eAeyxd/xevos* dAA' avrco -npoo-eyuiv tov

vovv t5> Adycp trKoVet oTrr? 7rore eK/Sr/aerat eAeyxd/jtej>os.
'AAAd, ec/jr/, TtoLiqo-co ovtoo' 8oKets ydp /uot /xeYpta Xeyeiv.

Aeye tolwv, r)v 8' eyco, 7repi r^s eroxppoa-vvrjs ttG>s Aeyets;
Aeyco tolwv, 8' os, ort /xdw? rcoi> dAAcoz/ e7rto-rr//ucoy
5 r)
avrr/ re avrrjs ecrriz> Kai rcov dAAcor e7rtorr/p,coy e7rtcrrr//ur/.
OvkojjV, rp/ 8' eyco, Kai av7rLo-Trjp.ooijvrjs 7rLOT^p.r] az> etrr,
et7rep Kai e7rtoTr;/urrs;
ndyrj ye, ecfjrr.
167 'O dpa aoxppoiv [xovos avros re eauroy yrcocrerat Kai otds
re ecrrat etferdaat tl re rrjyxdrjet etScos Kai rt /ur;, Kai rovs
dAAorjs coaarjrcos Swards eorai e7rtcrK07rety rt rts oTSe/j Kai
Kai rt av oterat p.ev eibevaL, otbev 8'

oterat, enrep ot8ez>,
5 ov, tS>v 8e dAAcoy orj8eis' Kat ecrnz> br\ ro?3ro to arooobpovelv

re Kai o-oxppoovvr) Kai to eavrbv avTov yLyva>o-KLV, to etSeVat
& re oTbev Kal a p,ri ot8ez\ apa rarjrd earu> a Ae'yets;
v
Eycoy', ecprr.
ITdAty tolvvv, r)v 8' eyco, r6 TpWov rco crcorr^pt, &cnrep e

b apxvs e7rtcrKe\^cop.eâ irpGtTov p.ev et 8uz>ardz> eortz> rorjr' etz>at
r) ov .r6 a oT8ez> Kai a /otr) oT8ez> eibevai (otl oXbe Kai) ort ovk
oT8ez> eVetra et ort /udAtara 8vz>ardz>, rts czy e
v
r/ r)pXv cocpeAta
etSdcrtr avrd.
5 'AAAd XPV> ctpVi o-KotreXv.
"Wl 8r/, ecprjv eyco, S Kptrta, o-Keyj/aL, eav tl 7repi avr&v
e2 ffKeJire ci. Heindorf : ffK6ire?vB T e 6 ovt^ T

: (tkoituv :
afrnj B a4 o5 Bekker : BT
aS tjs Buttmann
ai>Tbs a 5 ruv
:
Se T : twc B a 6 a&TOc scr. recc. avrb B T rb ecSeVat B T

: W :
irot elStvai b a 7 Kol a W

koI are B T: b 1 iirio-Ktif/d/xeBa
T : iiricKoird/Jieda B to 2 ^ ov to T ^ ou Tot B oti oJSe Kal
:
add. recc.
;
XAPMIAH2 i67b
evTropcorepos (pavrjs ep.ov' eyco p.ev ydp arropS). rj be anopS>,

<ppao-<a crot;
Yldvv y, e(pr].
y
"Akko tl ovv, r)v b eyco, Travra ravr av etr/, et tcrrw 10
oirep crv wvbr) ekeyes, p.Ca tls e7ncrr?//u77, rj ovk dkkov tlvos
0~tlv r) eavrrjs T ko.1 tS>v dkko)V e-TLO~Tr]p.S>v TTLO~Tr]p.r], Kal C
br) Kal avTna-Tr]p.oo~6vrjS r) avTr) avTr\;
Yldvv ye.
'Ie br) cos aroTtov zTnyjeipovp.zv, u> eratpe, keyeiv ev
dkkoLs ydp irov to avTo tovto eav o~KOirfjs, boei croi, cos 5
eyco/ât, dbvvaTov eXvaL.
YIS>s br) Kal ttov;
'Ey rotcrSe. evvoeL yap et croi 8oKet oi//ts tls eXvai, r) 3>v
p.ev al dkkaL 6\f/LS elcrCv, ovk cttlv tovtojv 6\j/ls, eavrfjs be
Kal tS>v dkko>v 6\j/eo)v 6\f/LS ecrrti koj. //?/ 6\}/cov S>aavTO)s, 10
Kat y^pS>p.a p.ev opq ovbev 6\f/LS ovo~a, amr)v be Kal tcls dkkas d
6\j/eLS' boKeX tls ctol eXvaL TOLavTrj;
Ma At' ovk e/uotye.
Tt 8e aKor\v, f) cpojvrjs piev ovbep.Las aKoveL, avTrjs be kol
tS>v dkko>v aKoS>v aKoveL Kal tS>v p.r) aKoS>v; 5
Ovbe tovto.
2jjAAt//38t/i; brj ctk6ttl TrepX 7rao~S>v tS>v alo~0r]o~eo)v et tls
o~ol boKel etvaL alo~0r]o~eo)V piev alo~0r)o~LS Kal eavrrjs, 5>v be

br] al aAAat atcrflr/creis atcr0di>oz>rat, p.r]bevbs alo~0avop.evr]
Ovk ep.0Lye. 10
'AAA' TTL0vp,La boKel rts o~ol eXvaL, r/rts rjbovrjs piev ovbe- e
/u.tas ecrrtr TTL0vp.La, avTrjs be Kat tS>v akkoiv ttl0v]j.lS>v ;
Ov brjra.
Ovbe p.r]v ]3ovkr]o~Ls, cos eyco/xat, rj aya0bv piev ovbev

(3ovkeTaL, avr>]V be Kal rds ctAAas /3oi>AT/frets fiovkeTaL. 5
b 10 el tariv ftirep av t : e ecrTtj/ oirtp T : elt} effrtv f> <rb B (sed ij
supra efri B 2 ) C8 t) B : f) T e 10 fiij otyewv BW: nij) otyews T

d1 oboev T : ovSe B d4^B:^T ei ooKel ris ffoi B W
W (sed w supra
:
tIs aoi tioKe? T e 4 ayadbv T o W) : ayaOuv B

;
i67e nAATilNOS
Ov yap ovv.
"Epcora be (pait]s dv riva etvaL tolovtov, os Tvyyjtvei o>v
epcos koKov piev ovbevos, avTov oe nal tG>v dkko>v epcorcor;

Ovk, (pt], eycoye.
10 o/3oy be ?/8t/ Tiva KaravevorjKas, bs kavTov p.ev kol tovs
168 ciAAous (f>6j3ovs cpo/3eirat, tS>v beLV&v 8' ov8e kv cpo/3etrat;
Ou KaravevoriKa, $77.
A6av be boo>v boav kol avrrjs, 8>v be at ctAAat 8oa-
^bucrty p.r]bev bod(ftVcrav
5 OvSafttos.
'AAA' iino-Trjp.r}v, cos eoLKev, cpap.ev Tiva elvaL TO\.avTr\v,
T/rts p.a6r)p.aTos p.ev ovbevos iortv e7ricrr?7/xr/, avTrjs be koX
t&v dkko>v i-nio-Tr)p.8>v imo-Tr)p.r\;
ap.ev ydp.
10 Oiikow (iTOTrov, et apa Kat ecrrizv; p.r]bev ycip ttco Sucrxupi-
(ti>p.a6a (hs ovk ecmv, dAA' et loriv ert crKOTT(2p.ev.
b 'Opflcos Ae'yets.
^Wpe Sr/* ecrrt /jter atfrr/ 77 iTTL(TTf)pr] Tivbs ii:L(TTr)p.r], Kat
eêt tlvcl TOiavrrjv bvvap.iv coore rwos etVaf rj ydp;

Yldvv ye.
5 Kat yctp to p-eiCov (pap.ev ToiavTr\v tlvcl eye.Lv ^vvapxv,
coare tivos elvaL p.ei(pv;
v
Exet ydp.
Ovkovv ikaTTOvos tlvos, etirep eorat /uetby.
'AvdyKr/.
10 Et ovv tl evpoLp.ev peiCov, o rcou p.ev p.etbVcoiv icTTLV
P,lov Kal eavrov, 8>v be raAAa /utet^co ecrrtv p.i]bevbs p.eiôv,
C TrdvTo>s dv ttov iKeivo y arjrco virdpyoL, eXirep eavrov petbi>

etr/, Kat ekaTTOv eavTOV etvat' r) oii;
e8 kolKov /jlcv T W Ka\ovfxev B 69 e^rj scr. recc. icp-rtv BT W

W
: :
a4 fiTjdhv Bt
/xrjSe T a11 er j 0-Kovw/j.ev BT : mo~Koirwfiev t
b 1 ooflcSs T el W : opdws B (sed in marg. t\ (sic) B) b 10 evpoifiev

B T: eSpot îef B
2
bn fielfa T :
fieifav B Ci &/ iroi/ Schanz :
Sr) Av ?rov B T
XAPMIAHS i68c
FIoAA?) dvdyKr), icprj, co Scoxpare?.

Ovkovv Kal et rt hmkacnov ecrru> tS>v re akkcov bLirka-
crimv Kal kavTov, rj/xCcreos brjrrov ovtos kavrov re Kal tG>v 5
dkkcov bLTrkacriov dv tlrp ov ydp kcrTLV ttov dkkov hntkao-LOV

rj r)p.(o-eos.
'AAT7&/.
IIAeW 8e avTov ov ov koI eAarroy ttrrtU Kal fiapvTcpov
OV KOVCpOTtpOV, KoX 7rpCrftvTpOV OV V(OT(pOV, Kal TO-kka IO
Travra cocraJjrcos, oTiirep av ttjv kavrov bvvap.iv irpbs kavrb d

ex^/, ov Kal iKiCvrjv ecfet tt)v ovcrCav, TTpbs rjv r) bvvap.LS
avrov rjv; Ae'yco 8e to Toiovbv olov r) aKorj, cpap.4v, ovk
dkkov tlvos rjv aKor) r) cpoovfjs" rj ydp;
Nat. 5
Ovkovv et7rep avrr) avTrjs aKoucrerai, cpcovr)v ixpvvys
kavrfjs dKOVo-eraL' ov ydp av dkkcos aKovcrLV.
Ylokkr) dvdyKr].
Kal r) oifsLS yk ttov, co dpiore, et7rep otyerat avTr) kavT-qv,
X/)<Sjua rt avrr)v dvdyKt) ty^LV dyjpoov ydp 6\jns ovbkv [dv] 10
p.r) 7rore 1877. q
Ov yap ovv.
'Opas ovv, co Kptrfa, ort ocra 8teAriAv0a/xei', rd p.\v avTutv
dbvvara TravTai:ao~L cpatWrat r)plv, rd 0' d7rtcrreirat crcpobpa
p.r) ttot av ttjv kavrcov bvvap.LV irpbs kavrd cry&v; p.yiQr\ 5

pkv yap kol irkrjOr] Kal rd TOLavTa iravTditacTLV dbvvaTov r)
oi>xC;
Tidvv ye.
'Akot) 8' av Kal 6\j/ls /cat ert ye klvi~o-ls avrr) kavrqv
KLvtlv, Kal 6pp.0Trjs KatLV, kol TrdvTa av Ta TOLavTa tols 10
pikv aT7Lo~TLav {av) Trapdo-yoL, tcrcos 8e' rtcrty ov. pLtydkov brj 169
rtyos, co eptAe, dvbpbs 8et, ocrrts tovto Kard irdvToov LKavcos
c6 h.v T: &v iiv B 09 (<ttcu B : 4<rri compendio T d 10 avdyicr)

T : b.v6.-yK-t\v B %.v secl. Stallbaum e 1 1% B e?877 T :
e 9 76 T 3 : Te B T e 10 o BT : 8^ Schanz a 1 oc add.
Heindorf
i6ga IIAAT&N02
btatpt]<reTat, TTOTepov ovbev tcov ovrcov rrjv avrov hvvap.iv
avrb irpbs iavrb iricpVKev ix ilv [wAr)v (iiio'T-qp.r)$], akka nrpbs
5 aAAo, 77 to. p.iv, Tct 8' ov koX d io-rtv av artva avTa irpbs avrct
X et > <V iv tovtols io-rlv eTTi.o-Trip.r), rjv br) r)p.eis <rco<ppo-

ovvrjv (papiiv etvat. iy<b p.iv ov TTt<rTev<o ip.avrco lnavbs aTvat
Tavra dieAecrflaf btb nal otjt' d bvvarov ecrrt tovto yevi<r0at,
b iirto-T-qpqs iirt<TTr]p.r]v elvat, ex^ btt<rxvpi<ra<T0at, ovt et ort
p.akt<rra eori, o-co<ppoavvr]v aTTobi)(op.at avrb etvat, irplv av
7Tt<rK<i\fni)p.at etre rt av r)pJas clxpekot TOtovrov ov etre p.t].
rr)v yap ovv br) (rco(ppooTJvr]v <ocpiktp.6v rt /cat ayaObv ptav-

5 revop.at etvat' orii ovv, co trai Kakkaio~xpov rtflecrai yap
<r<a<ppoo-vvr}v tovt elvat, iirtcrTr]p.r]v iirtcTTr]p.r]s Kal br) Kal
av<-TTto-Tr]p.o<TVVr]s irpcoTov piev tovto evbetat, ort bvvarbv
[airobiiâi ae] 6 vvvbr) ekeyov, eVetra Trpbs tco bvvaTco ort
C Kat co<piktp,ov Kap,e Ta\ c\v airoTrkqpcocrats cos 6p0cos kiyets

7rept <T<a<Ppo<TVvr]s o ecrrty.
Kat 6 Kptrtas aKovaas Tavra Kat lbd>v p.e airopovvTa,

cocnrep oi Toiis x ao J' 0l) lJL * vo vs KaravTtKpv Tavrbv
'
~l
opcovTes
5 TOVTO <TVp.7TCt<TXOV<TtV, KCLKcivOS eboi p.Ot VTT epOV CLTTOpOVVTOS
avayKao-Qrjvat Kal avrbs ak&vat vtto airopias. are ovv ev-
boKtp.S>v kKao-TOTi, fjaxvveTo tovs Trapovras, Kal ovTe ovyxoo-
prjaai p.ot r)0ekev abvvaros etvat btekicr0at a TrpovKakovp.i]v
d ovtov, ekeyiv re ovbev <ra<pis, iTTtKakviTTCov Tr)v a-nopiav.
Kayco rjptiv Iva 6 koyos irpotot, ttirov 'AAA' et 8oKet, a>
Kptrta, vvv piev tovto o-vyx(t>prio-cop.V, bvvarbv etât yavi-

<r0at iTTt<TTr]p.r]v iTTt<TTr]pr]S' av0ts bi iTTt<TKe\j/6p.e0a etre
5 ovtcos eêi etre p.rj. I0t br) ovv, et ort jtxaAtcrra bvvarbv
tovto, ri ptakkov olov ri iortv dbivat a re rt? ot8e Kat a
p.r]; tovto yap brfirov i<pap.ev alvat to ytyvcocrKatv ovtov koX
acocppovdv r) yap;
Udvv ye, t] 0' os, koI o-vp.(3aivet yi ttov, co ScoKpares. et
a3 avrov BT : avriiv T 3
a4 irK^v eiri<rT-rjfj.7)s secl. Schleier-
macher b8 O7ro5e?at <re secl. Heindorf e 6 avayKao-drjvai
secl. ci. Badham : an avarrkrio-erjvai 1 d6 ku! a B t : koI T
XAPMIAH2 i6ge
ydp tls exet Tticn-qixr)v rj avrr) avrr]V yLyvo>o-KCL, tolovtos e

av avTos elr) olovncp iarlv o exer towtp orav rdxos tls
ex*/> Ta)(ys, Kal orav koXKos, koKos, koX orav yvdcriv, yi-
yvG>crK(t>v, oTav 8e br) yv&criv avrrjv avrrjs tls XV> ytyvo>-
ctko>v ttov avTos kavTov tot eorat. 5
Ov tovto, rjv 8' iyd>, d/u,GW/37/r<3, ws ov\ orav t6 avrb
yiyvS>crKov tls ex??, ovtos avrbv yvo>crTaL, dAA' i)(0VTL tovto
tls dvdyKr) et8e'vat a re ot8ez> Kal a p.r) otbcv;

Otl, d> 2coKoares, tovtov io~TLV tovto eKeizxp. VJO
*\cro)s, f<pr]v, dAA' iyo> KLvbvvtvco det o/xotoy ctvai' ov
yap av p.av6dvo> co? Icttlv to avro, a otSei/ et8ei>at Kal d tls
p.i] otbev etSeVat.
Tl&s Aeyet?, ec/>?/; 5
T
f2Se, r)v 8' eyco. iiTLcrTr)p.r) irov e7riaTT//u7/s ovcra dpa
itXiov tl o'ia r' ecrrai Statpetif, r/ ort tovtoov rdSe plkv
iTTLO~Tr]p.r), ro'8e 8' ovk iTTLO"n)p.r);
Ovk, dAAa toctovtov.

TavTov ovv io-TLV iTTLOTr)p.r) re Kat avniTLcrTr]p.ocrvvr] vytet- io
vov, Kal iiTLOTr)p.r) re Kat aveTTL(JTr)p.oo-vvr) StKatou; b

Ovbap.5>s.
'AAAa to p,kv ot/xai tarpiKT/, to 8e 7roAtriKr/, to 8e ovbkv
aAAo r) iiTLOTr]p.r).
X\S>s ydp ov; 5

Ovkovv iav p.r) 7rpocre7rtoTr/rat tls to vyLCLvbv kol to
bUaLov, dAA' iTTL(TTrjp.r)v p.6vov ytyywoK?/ dre tovtov p.6vov
ex^y iiTL(TTr)p.r)v, otl pAv tl iiricrTaTaL koX otl iTTLo-Trjp.r)v
TLvd exet, eiKorcos &v yLyvojo~Koi Kal 7reot avrou Kat 7rept t5>v
dXKo>v r) ydp; io
Nat.
e 8 Ka\ a scr. Ambr. 56 : koL aVe B T W

a i toCto Cornarius :
to avTb B T a 3 -rb clvt6] tJ avrb to ci. Heindorf & o!8e' . . .
a 4 oTSei' tlSevcu secl. Hoenebeek Hissink a 7 tiiaipe7v T 2 5tevpe7i>

BT W a 10 ToiTbv oZv T towt' olv oZv B W iirio-T^fj.T) et mox
:
:
aveirurTivxoavvy (bis) ci. Bonitz iirio-T-fifir) . aveiriaT7)ixoo-vvr) (bis)

: . .
BT b7 yiyvdo-Kt) scr. recc. : yiyv&o-Ket BT W

;
i7ob I7AAT&N02.
"Ort 8e ytyycooKet, ravTij rfj irLo-Tr)p.ri tt>s etcrerat;
C yiyvcocrKet yap br) to p.ev vyieivbv rr/ larpiKr/ dAA' ov crcocppo-
crvvr), to 8' app.0v.LK0v p.ovcriKr) dAA' ov croicppoo-vvr), to 5'
olKobopuKov olKobopiiKr} dAA' ov craxppocrvvr), kol ovtu iraVTa'

r) ov;
5 (Paivcrai.
~2oiqipocrvvr) de', ei7rep p.6vov ecrrir 7TLcrTr)p.>v kTTLcrTr)p.r),
tt&s etcrerat drt t6 vyi.et.v6v ytyvcocncet r) otl to olKobop.LKov

Odoaucos.
Ovk apa etoerai d otoey 6 tovto ayvo>v, dAA' ort otoei
io p.6vov.
"EoLKV.
d Ovk apa o-oiqbpoveXv tovt av drj ovbe o-oicppocrvvr), etdeVat
& re otSer Kai a p.r) otder, dAA', cos eoiKey, ort otdey Kai ort
ovk oidev p.6vov.
KLvbvvevei.
5 Odoe dAAoy dpa otd? re eorat ovros eêrdoat qiacrKovra
tl e7rtoracr0ai, iroTepov e7rtcrrarai o cpr/cru' kTTLcrTacrOaL r) ovk

eiTLcrTaTaL' dAAd rocrouroi; p.6vov, cos eotKey, yvcocrerat, drt
exet ru>d 7TLcrTripLr)v, otov oe ye, r/ croiqipocrvvr) ov TroLi]crzL
avrov yLyvoicrKCLV.
io Ou cpatuerat.
e Oi/re dpa rdy irpocnroLOijp.evov iarpov etrat, dVra oe p.r/,
Kai rdi> cbs dAr/flcos' dVra otds re eorat bLaKpCvcLv, ovre aWov
ovbiva t5>v iTTLorqpLovoiv Kal p.r). crKe\//cop.e#a de K T&vbe'
et jueAAet d o-oicppoiv r) oo-tlctovv dAAos tov cbs dAr/flcos larpov
5 8tayvcocrecr0ai Kai rdi> /ur/, ap' oi>x <Soe Troir/cref 7repi /uey
tarptKr]s or/7rou avrco ov dtaAeferat ovbev yap e7ratet, cbs
ecpapeu, d tarpds dAA' r/ rd uytewdv Kai rd rocrcodes- r) ov;

Nat, ovrcoy.
riepi 8e' ye e7rtorr/pr/s ovdey ot8e*>, dAAd ToSro 8r/ rr)
io crcocppocrwT/ p.dvr/ a7re'8opev.
b 12 7rs W: Sircos BT 64^T:tjB

XAPMIAH2 i7 o
Nat.
Ovbe irepl larpLKrjs apa oTbev 6 larpiKos, cTTLbrJTTp r)
larpiKr) e7rioTr/ju.?7 ovo-a TvyyavaL. 171

'Akr)6r).
"Otl piv br) TTLo-Trip.r]v tlvcl eyci, yvcocreTai 6 crcocppcov
tov iarpov beov oe Tttipav Xafialv ijtls <ttlv, dXXo tl <tk4-
\fraTaL covtlvcov; rj ov tovtco copLoraL kKaaTt) kTTLcrTr)p.r) p.r) 5

p.6vov 7tL0-Tr)pr) (TvaL dXXd koX tls, tco tlvcov eti>ai;
ToVTCp p.V OVV.
Kal r) laTpLKi) br) krc-pa cTvaL tcov dXXcov 7TLcrTr)Licov
copLcrOy) rw tov vyLdLVOv aTvaL Kal voacobovs TTL<rT7)p.r).
Nat. 10
Ovkovv kv tovtols dvayKalov o-kottlv tov t3ovX6p.i>ov

laTpLK.r)v ctkottclv, v ols ttot cttlv ov yap brjrrov tv ye b
TOLS <!i~CO, <\v ols OVK CTTLV;
Ov bfjra.
'Ev rots vyLLV0Ls dpa /cat vocrcobacrLV e7rto-Ke'\//-erai tov

laTpov, r/ laTpLKos kcTTLV, 6 opdcos CTKOTTOVIXeVOS. 5
"F,OLKV.
OvKOVV V TOls OVTCOS T/ Xeyop.VOLS T) TTpaTTOpniVOLS TCl
p.ev Xey6p.eva, et dXr)6r) XeyeraL, <tkottovihvos, tcl be irpaT-
TopLdva, et opdcos 7rparrerat;
'AvayKJ). IO
T
H ovv dvev laTpLKrjs bvvaur dv rts tovtcov TTOTepois
CTTaKoXovOfjcraL;
Ov bf)Ta.
Ovbe ye dXXos ovbeCs, cos eoiKev, ttXt)v larpos, ovt br) 6 C

crcocppcov larpbs ydp av etrj TTpbs Trj cTco<ppocrvvr).
"Ecttl Tavra.
e 12 larpiKbs BT: larpbs t 114 SeW 5e Goldbacher (SeiV 5e

Hermann) : 5e? $1) B 5e 8))
: T : eVixeipwj/ 5e $}) corr. Coisl. : e? 5e 5e?
ci. Heindorf SL$ wvtivwv t : wvtivvv B : wvnvvv T &,g t$
tov B : T<fto T b 11 ^ T : i B Trorepois T : irporepois B
C 1 ov5e' ye] otire ye Naegelsbach
t
171 c nAAT&NOS
Tlavrbs apa p.d\\ov, et r) crct)cppoo~vvr) e7rioTT/u77s TTio-Trjpr)
5 p.6vov ecrrty kol avTno~Tr}p.oo-vvris, ovt larpbv biaicplvai oia

re ecrrai TTLo-Tap.Vov ra Trjs T)(vr)s i) p.r) TTL<rTdpVov,
7Tpoo--roi.ovp.evov 8e t) olop.Vov, ovt aXkov ovbiva t<2v ttl-
o-Tap.ivu>v koi otlovv, Trkrjv ye tov avrov 6p.oTyyov, cocnrcp
ol aAAot br\p.iovpyoi.
io âtverat, <prj.
d Ti? ovv, r)v 8' eyco, a> Kptrta, a></jeAia r)pxv ert av etr/
aTTO rrjs o-uxppoo-vvrjs TOiavTt]s ova-qs; et p.v ydp, b <;
ap)(f}s VTreTL0p.e9a, r/8et 6 auxppcov a re ^Set Kat a p.r) rjbei,
tcl p.ev otl ot8ey, tcl 8' ort ovk oTbev, Kal akkov tovtov
5 tovto TreTTovOoTa TTLo-K^/ao-0aL olos t r)v, /xeyaAcocrrt av
r)plv, <pap.v, a><p4\Lp.ov r)v crcocppocrLV etvar dvap.dpTi)TOL
yap av tov (3lov Ste^Suey avrot re [xai] ot Tr)v cruxppoo~vvr)v
xvtS Ka ' ^ clAAot TTavTes octol vcp' r)p.u>v r)pyovTO. oi>T
e yap hv avTol TT\Lpovp.V TTpa.TTLV a p.r) r)TTLCrTdp.6a, aAA'

^VpL(TKOVTS TOVS TTLO~Tap.VOVS KLVOLS CLV 7TapbCbop.V,
OVT TOLS ClAAotS TTTpTTOp.V, (OV r]p\Op.V, ClAAo TL TTpaT-

TLV r) OTL 7TpaTTOVTS 0/30(3? eweAAoy 7Tpd^LV TOVTO 8' 1]V
5 av, ov TTL<TTr)p.r]v ^Xyov koX ovtco br) vtto cruxppocrvvr^s otKta
re olKovp.vr) eju.eA.Aey KaAcos otKetcrflai, 7roAt9 re 7roAirevo-

p.vr), koX dKko irav ov auxppocrvvr) dpyoL- ap.apTLas yap
172 ^r)pr)p.vr)s, dp6oTr)TOS 8e r)yovp.vr)S, V Trdcrr) 7rpaêt KaA<3s
Kat v 7TpaTTLV dvayKaxov TOVS OVTU) bLaKip.VOVS, tovs 8e

eS TrpaTTOVTas vbaip.ovas ctvat. ap' ov\ ovtojs, r)v 8' eyco,
S Kptrta, eAe'yo/xey 7rept o-oicppoo-vvr)s, \iyovTS bcrov dyadbv

5 etrj to et8eVai a re oT8eV rts Kat a /xt) ot8ey;
Flayu p.V ovv, (pr), ovtoos.
04 eiB2 T: elr; B 65 avein<rry-ô<rvvirts B W : aveirio-Trtfioo-vvris

iirio-Tr)nr) T
C 8 Sxrirep B W : &o"irep av T d5 /j.tya\uo-T\ ci.
Stephanus êyoAws ti BT d7 Sjej/DjUee T iw/j.ev B W
W
: :
cal del. Heindorf e 3 oCre T : t> o&tc B e6 oiKov/xevri B

W
:
oiKOVOfxov/jLfvri T e/ieWev KaAws B : KaAws e/iieWev T e8 irav

T t ttSi' B a 1 i^ripriixevris TW $ir}pr)fj.evr)s B Ka\a>s rrpdTTeiv
W
: :
ayayKaiov KaAws Kal eZ rrp6.TTHV B : dra^Karo^ /caAy aJ eS irpdTTeiv T

:
XAPMIAHS 172 a
Nvv 8e', r)v 8' eyco, dpas otl ovbap.ov e7rtcrr?/pr/ oti8ep.ta
ToiavTT) ovcra TrccpavraL.
'Op<3, ec/)?/.
*Ap' ovv, r)v 8' eyco, rour' eêt ro o\ya6bv rjv vvv evpC- b
0-Kop.ev craicppocrvvriv ovcrav, to kiTLcrTr)p.r)v eTTtcrracrflat nal
av(TTLo-Tr}p.ocrvvriv, otl 6 TavrrjV excor, otl av akko p.avdavt),
paov re ua#7/crerat koX ZvapytcrTepa iravTa avrco cpaveLTai,
are TTpds eKacrra) cp av p.avQavr\ irpocrKaOop&VTL ti]v Ittl- 5
crr?/u?j?r Kal tovs akkovs bi) KakkLov eerdcret TTept &v av
Kal avrbs p.a6rj, ol oe avev tovtov e^ferdôyres ao-Qtvio-Ttpov
Kal cpavkoTepov tovto bpacrovo~Lv; ap, co <piAe, rotaCra
tiTTa (cttIv a ci7Tokavcr6p.eda rrjs cra>cppocrvvr\<i, T/pets 8e pet^dy C
rt /SAeVopeu Kat Qt)Tovp.ev ovto Meib'z> rt etmt ?/ 6Voy eartr;
Taya 8' ay, ecpr/, ovrcos exot.
v
Icrcos, 7/y 8' eyco 1 tcrcos 8e' ye ?7uets ovSey xprjcrTOV
e^r/rr/cra/xei'. TKp.aCpop.ai 8e', ort uot droTr' arra Karac/W- 5
uerat ?rept crcocppocrvvrjs, et rotourd/V ecrrii\ tScouer ydp,
et /3odAet, crvyyoipr)cravTS KaL eTtcrracrflat (7TLcrTrip.r)v bv-
varbv etmt [etSeVatj, Kat o ye e ap\r]s ert(9e'/xet9a crcocppo-
o-vvr\v (tvaL, rb et8eVat a re ot8e#v Kat a p.77 ot8ei>, p?)

dTrocrrepr/crco/uey, dAAd bcop.ev Kat TTavra rarjra 8oVres ert d
/3e'Arto2/ cTKe\^co/Ltec?a et dpa rt Kat 7/pds dm/crei roto?jroy di\
& ydp vvvbi] eAeyouey, cos ue'ya dy eiT/ ayaObv 7/ croicppoo-vvr)
et roio7jro7J etr/, 7/yovpeVr/ StotKT/crecos Kat otKtas Kat TToAecos,
ov uot 8oKO?j/uey, a> Kptrta, KaAws co/uoAoyT/Kerat. 5

n<2s 87/; 7/
8' ds.
"Ort, 7/y 8' eyco, paStcos u>p.okoyr]crap.(v p.4ya tl ayadbv

ilvaL rots av$pa>iTOLs et eKacrrot r)p.G>v, a pkv XcracrLV, irpaT-
roter raSra, a 8e /ut/ eTTtcrrat^ro, dAAots 7xapa8t8otey rots

eVtcrra/jteVots. 10
C 5 reKfxaipofiai 8^ T reKfj.aip6n(voi B (sed ot 8e suprascr. W) W

W
:
C 8 j'8eVo* secl. ci. Heusde d 1 dAXo Sw/te' T et yp.

dAA.' iSa>fj.(y B W
tovto touto B toCto airavTa T tovto ttocto : : W
d2 Spo Tt B 3
: &pri BT ovfjffti T : bvqativ B
PLATO, vol. III. 4
;
i72e nAAT&NOS
e Ovk ovv, ecpr], KaAcos c\>p.o\oyr]crap.ev
Ov p.oL boKovp.ev, qv 8' eyco.
"Aroira Aeyets cos dArrflcos, ecprr, co ScoKoares.

Nr) rov kwo, ecprrz;, kcu epot tol 8oKet ovrco, Kavrav6a
5 Kat aprt aTrofiXexj/as aro7r' arr' ecprry pot TrpocpaCvecrdaL, Kal

ori <pofioiixr\v p.r) ovk opQ&s crKOTtolp.ev. cbs dAr?0cos ydp,
et otl /uaAio-ra tolovtov io-Tcv rj aoicppocrvvr], ovbev uol

173 Sr/Aoy etzmi boKtl otl ayaOov r)pxis d7repyderat.
IIcos br]; r) 8' o?. Aeye, Xva kol r^pets et8copei> 6'rt Aeyets.
Otjuat jueV, t]z> 8' eyco, Arrpeiv /xe* op,cos ro ye irpocpaLvo-
p.evov avayKaiov o-KOTrelv Kal p.r) zIkjj 7rapieVai, et rts ye
5 avTov Kal crp.LKpov K?j8erai.
KaAcos yap, ecprr, Aeyets.

v
AKoue brj, ecprjv, to ip,bv ovap, etre 8td Kepdrojv etre
81' iXicpavros ikqXvdev. et yap otl /idAtora ?7ju.coj> dpxot
77 crcocppoowrr, ovcra otay w 6pL^6p.eda, dAAo rt Kara rds
b e7rto-r?7ju,as 7rdi>r' dz> 7rpdrrotro, Kat oflre rts Kv($pvr]Tr]s
(pdaKcov elvaL, a>v be orj, ea7rarco dz> rypds, oure tarpos ovre
crrparrryds oiir' dAAos ov8ets, TrpocnroLovp.ev6s tl elbevaL
6 p,r) oT8ei>, Aav0di>ot ay eK 8r) rovrcoy ovrcos iypvTav dXko
5 di> T^juty rt o~vp,j3aLVOL r/ vyLecrLV re ra crco/xara etmt pdAAoi'
7) vvv, Kat ey . rr] JaAdrrr7 KLvbvvevovras Kat ei> 7roAe'p,co
crcoecr#ai, Kat ra o-Kevrr Kal rr)v ap.Tre\6vr]v koX virobecrLV

C 7racray Kat ra xP'7rxara Trdvra TeyvLK&s rjpuv elpyacrp.eva
etvaL Kal aAAa 7roAAa 8ta ro aXrjdLVOLS brjuLOVpyots \pr(cr6aL;

et 8e /3orJAoto' ye, Kat rr)y p.avTLKr)v etvat crvyx<*>prjcrojp.v
64 5ok? T: SoKerv B o%tw' Kauravda Hermann : outcos e/

tvravda B : oyrois ivravOa T : ot/rwcl ^toDOo W 65 aVo7r ^tt'
ci. Badham &.tott& : &roird y BT : t Bekker i<pi\v T : e</>7j B
a4 nrapUvai T
7rapeiVat B :a 9 vt/^] 8t) vvv Stobaeus b 1 nd.VT
ov scripsi irdvra Stobaeus av B T
: : b 2 e'|o7raTy av T : ^|a7raTa'
B (&>v Se . ^/ias om. Stobaeus)
. . b3 ouSeis] ris ovSels Stobaeus
b4 Stj BT
Stobaeus: Se Hermann bs ti post &\Ao transp.
Stobaeus 7) add. ci. Heindorf jur) Stobaeus om. B T : : b6 tjj
om. Stobaeus b 7 to] to Te Stobaeus C 2 a\r)0ivo?s SrifxiovpyoTs
T W
Stobaeus a\7)6ivbv fitiniovpybv B
: c 3 f}ov\oto'] fiov\ei ci.
H. Richards

XAPMIAH2 173C
eTTL0~Tr]p.r]V TOV p.ekkoVTOS <TCr6ai, KOl T1]V CTO)CppOaVV1]V,
avrrjs Trio~TaTovcrav, tovs p.ev aka(6vas a~TOTpeireLV, rovs 5

8e cos akrjdcos p.avreLS Ka6io~Tavai r)p.LV irpocpr]Tas tcov p.ek-
kovrcov. KaTeo~Kevacrp.evov br] ovtco to avdpcoTTLVov yevos
otl p.ev TTLo~Tr)p.6vo)s av irpaTTOL Kal 0)17, eVojuai r) yap d
crcocppoo-vvr] cpvXaTTovcra ovk av eiot] irapepL-TiTrTovcrav Tr]v
ave7no~Tr]p.oorvvr]v o~vvepyov r)puv etVat ort 8' 7TLO~Tr)p.6vo)s

av TrpaTTOVTes ev av Trpa.TTOLp.ev Kat eibaLp.ovoXpi.ev, tovto
be ovttco bvvap.eda p.a6eiv, 00 cpCke Kptrta. 5
'AAAa p.evTOL, r) 8' 6s, ov pabCcos evpi]creLS akko tl reAos

tov ev TrpaTTeLV, eav to TTLo-Tr]p.6vcos a.TLp.ao~r]S.
"2pLKpbv tolwv p.e, r)v 8' eyco, ert irpoo-bCbatjov. tCvos

eiTLcTTr]p.6vois Aeyets; r) ctkvtcov rop.r)s;
Ma At" ovk eyojye. Q

'AAAa x.oAko{) epyaaCas;
Ovbap.S>s.
'AAAa epCoov r) vkcov rj akkov tov tcov tolovtcov;
Ov brJTa. 5
Ovk apa, r)v 8' eyco, ert ep.p-evop.ev r<5 koyco r<S evbaC-
p.ova etvaL tov TTLo~Tr]p6vcos <oVTa. ovtol yap eTTLo~Tr]p.6vois
Ccovres oir^ 6p.okoyovvraL Trapa o~ov evbaCp.oves elvai, akka

irepC tlvcdv eTTLo~Ti]p,6vo)S (cavTa crv 8oKets ;uoi a<popC<rdaL
tov evbaCp.ova. Kal tcrcos keyeLs 6v vvvbr) eyco ekeyov, tov 10
ei8o'ra tcl p.ekkovTa ecrecrdaL iravTa, tov p.avrLV. tovtov 174

r] akkov TLva keyeLs;
Kat tovtov eycoye, ecpr], kol akkov.
TCva; rjv 8' eyco. apa p.r) tov TOLovbe, el tls irpos tols
p.ekkovo~LV kol tcl yeyovora Travra elbeCr] ko.1 tcl vvv ovra, 5
Kat p.r]bev ayvool; 6<op.ev yap TLva elvaL avrov. ov yap
d. 4 Uv irpaTTovTes T : t& irpaTTOVTes B d. 5 SwdfieBa BT W :
Svvai/jLeOai (sic) T 2
d9 ctkvtwv to/xtjs T W : o-KVTOTOfirjs B : o-kvtoto-
/iiKrjs b e 6 evSaifiova T b ei>Saifj.ovia B : e 8 SfioXoyovvTai
BT : 6fxo\oyovffi t e 9 ^tS^To ci. Schleiermacher {wvtwv B T :
crv Bekker S : BT SoKets Basileensis altera : SoKet BT a6 Owfiev]

<pu>fiev Schanz avr6v) toiovtov ci. H. Richards
4*
174 a ITAAT&NOS
ot/xai tovtov ye eri hv enrots ovbeva eTTLo~Tr)p.oveo~Tepov
G>VTa elvai.
Ov brjra.
10 To'8e br) ert Trpocnro6G>, tCs avrbv tG>v eiTL<rTr)p.G>v iroLel
evbaCp.ova; r\ cbracrai 6p.oC(o$;
Ovbap.G>$ 6p.oC(o$, <pr).
b 'AAAa TToCa p.dkLo~Ta; r) t[ otbev nal tG>v ovtgjv koX tG>v

yeyovoTcov Kal tS>v p.ekkovT<x>v eo~ear6aL; apd ye r) to Trer-
tzvtlkov;
notoy, r) 8' 6$, ttttvtlkov;
5 'AAA' fi
to AoyioriKoV;
Ovbap.G>s.
> A \ \ > ? v * '
AAA 57 to vyLCLVov;
MaAAoy, ecpr).
'EKeCvr) 8' rjv keyu> /ixdAtcrra, 7/y 8' eya>, 17 rt;

t
10 Hl to dyadov, e(pr), koX to KaKov.
*H p.Lape, e(pr)v eya>, irakaL p.e TrepLekKeLS kvkAo), airo-
KpVTTTOp.eVOS OTL 01) TO eTTLO~Tr)p.6v(OS T)V i)V TO V TTpaTTiLV

C re Kat evbaLp.oveLV ttolovv, ovbe (Tvp.~~ra(rG>v t5>v dkk(ov
eiTL(TTr)p.G>v, dkkd /xtas ovo-qs ravTtis p.6vov Trjs irepl to
dyadov re Kat KaKOV. eireC, S> Kptrta, et 'dekeLS eêkelv
TavTrjv rr)v TTLO-rt)p.r)V eK rwy aAAcoy TTLO~Tr)p.G>v, rJTrov tl
5 77 p.ev laTpLKr) vyLaCveiv TTOLr)o~eL, r) 8e o~KVTLKr) v7robebeo~6aL,

r) be {xpavTLKrj r)p.(pL0~6aL, r) be Kv/3epvr)TLKr) KcoAwet ev rfj
OakaTTr) d7rodvrjo~KLV koX r) crrparTjytK?) ev irokepô;
Ovbev rJTTOv, eqbr).
'AAA', S> cptAe Kptrta, to ev ye tovto>v eKaora yCyveo~6aL

d Kat (oqbekCp.(o$ aTTokekoLTros r)p.ds earat TavTt)$ aTrovo-qs.
'Akrjdrj keyeLS.
Ovx avTr) be ye, a>s eoLKev, eo-rlv i) o~oxppoo~vvr), aAA' rjs
hi $ rlB: 9itiT bs d\\' y B: d\\' $) T bgyi

B : 77 t T b 10 7} to T : to B C6 7)n<pi(<r0ai T : a/j.<pi4ff0ai
B d1 d7ro\e\ojiros B T
2
: diro\e\oi7ri)s B d3 d\\' secl. ci.
Madvig
XAPMIAH2 i74d
Hpyov iarlv rb cocpeAetTJ r/pds. ov yap zTtia-rrip.&v ye Kal

aVTUo-Tr}iAoo-vvS)V r) e7rioT?/u7/ kcrriv, dAAd ayadov re nal 5
Kanov' a>o-T et avTt) (<tt\v cocpe'Atuos, r) croj(ppoo~vvr) akko
ti av etr/ [f) cocpeAtpr/] f)p.Zv.
Tt 8', 17
5' ds, ov/c di> aTjrr/ cocpeAot; et yap otl udAtora
rcorj e7rtcrrr/ucojJ e7rio-r?//x?7 eo-rijj ?/ aoicppoo-vvr), e7noraret
8e Kat rats dAAats e7rtoTr/uats, /cat rarjrr/s 8r/7rorj drj apyovaa e
rrjs 7repi Tayadbv iiTLcrTr)pi.r)s cocpeAot djj ?/uds.
'H kojj vytaivdv ttoloI, t/jj 8' eyco, a7jr?/, dAA' ov^ 77
tarpiK?/; Kai rdAAa rd rcojj t^xvoov avrrr djj 7rotot, Kai otjx
at dAAat rd ar5rr/s epyov eKdorrj; r/ ov 7rdAat Steuaprrjpo'- 5
uet9a ort e7rtcrrr7p.rjs p.6vov eorijj Kai diJeTricrrrjuocrrjjjrjs
e7rtcrrT/urr, dAAorj 8e orjSejjds* orjx_ ovtco;
<J>atVerat ye.
Otjk dpa rjytetas ccrTaL 8r/utorjpyo's;

Orj 8rjra. IO
v
AAArjs yap rjv re'x^J vyUia' 77 orj; l^g
'AAAtjs.
Or38' apa cocpeAtas, a> eratpe' dAArr ydp av cnreoopiev
tovto to zpyov Tkyv\) vvvhr')' rj yap;
Yldvv ye. 5
n<S? otjjj co<pe'Atuos eorat f) crcocppocrrjjjrr, orj8eutds cocpe-
Atas ovo-a 8?juio?jpyds;
Orj8aucos, ) ScoKpares, olk4v ye.
'Opas otjjj, io Kptrta, cbs eyco TrdAat etKorcos eSeSot^KTj
Kai 8tKatcos p.avTov rjrtcourjij 6'rt 07j8ejJ XPW" 7reP' " ft) - IO
cppocr7j7jr/s crK07rco; orj ydp djj 7rou o ye KdAAtcrrojJ 7rdijrcojj
dpoAoyetrat etJJat, tovto t/uijj djJcocpeAes icpdvr), e? tl epod b

dcpeAos ?]jj 7rpds rd KaAcos CT/retrj. Jjrjjj 8e 7rajjraxr/ ydp
r/rrcopec9a, Kai orj 8u7jdpet9a erjpetjj ecp' orco 7rore rcojj ovtoov
d. 4 -ye] t Heindorf d. 7 tj axpfKifiT] B : o><pe\t/xri T : ^ w<p(\l/ji.r)
Schleiermacher secl. Madvig

: 63 /c&j/ Schanz : ical BT
e 4 oix * Hermann oixi B T : ba 6<pe\os T : &<pe\os B
b3 70. ttipuv T: ex el,/ ^^
i75b DAATONOS
6 VOfXoOeTTffS TOVTO TOVVOfXa eOeTO, T1]V 0~<t)<ppOCrVVr]V. KaiTOL
5 7roAAd ye crvyKeyu>pr]Kafxev ov crvfxfiaivovtf rjfXLV ev rai Adycp.

nal yap eirLcrTr]fxr]v eTTLcrTrifxr]s eii>at crvveyu>prfaafxev, ovk
e&vros tov Xoyov ovbe cpdcrKOVTOS elvaL' Kat TavTrj av rrj
eTTLcrrqfxr] Kal rd tG>v dKKcov eTTLo~Tr)fxS>v epya ytyz>cocrKeiz>
C crvveyj^prfcrafxev , ovbe tovt eS>vros tov Adyou, tva 8t/ i]]uv
yivoLTO 6 crc6c/>pcojj eTTLcrTr]fxc>)v 8>v re ot8ez> ort ot8ez>, Kal

&v fxrj ot8ez> otl ovk otbev. tovto fxev 8t/ ko.1 TTavTairacrL
/ueyaAo7rpe7rcos crvveyjMpricrafxev, ovb* eiTLcrKe^/dfxevoi t6 abv-
5 varov eivai a tls fxr) oXbev fxrjbafxSs, raiSra elbevaL dpcos

ye' ttojS' ort yap ovk oXbev, cpifcrlv avra, elbevaL T7 rjfxerepa
ofxoXoy ta. Katrot, cos ey&fxai, OTj8ez>ds drou ov^t dAoyco-

repoz> roSr' av cpaveirj. dAA' op,co? otjVcos' t/jucoi/ eTjr/0tKcoz>
d rTjôucra t/ ^T/rrjcrts Kat ou o"kAt/pcoz>, ovbev tl fxakXov evpelv

bvvarai rr/z> dkrj6eLav, dAAd roo-07jroz> Kareye'Aacrez> avrrjs,
&&Tt 6 T7/jtets 7rdAat o-Tjz>ojuoAoyo?jVres' Kat 0Tj/jt7r Adrroz>res
erLdefxeda cruxppocrvvqv eXvai, tovto r)fxlv irdvv Tj/3ptcrriKcos
5 dz>cocpeAes dz> direcpaLve. to fxev ovv efxov Kat T/rroz> dya-

vaKTG)' virep be crov, r)v 8' eyco, S) Xapfxibr], 7rdz>7j dyavaKrS,
et o-Tj rotOTjros coz> tt\v ibeav kol Trpos roTjVco Tr)v ^rvyj]v
e craxppovecrTaTos, fxrjbev dvrjcrr] cltto TavTt]s ttjs crcoqbpocrvvrjs
fxrfbe tl cr coc/jeAT/crei ez> rcp /3tcp irapovcra. ert 8e fxaXKov
a.yavaKTu> virep rrjs eiriobrjs fjv irapa tov OpqKos efxadov,

et fxrjbevos dîov irpdyfxaTOs ovcrav avrrjv /xerd 7toAAt^s
5 o"7totj8t^s efxdvdavov. ravT ovv irdvv fxev [ovv] ovk oto/xat
ovtcos exety, dAA' e/xe <pav\ov etvai ^r]Tr]Tr]V' eVei Ti]v ye

croocppocrvvrjv fxeya rt dyadov etvai, Kal eX-nep ye fyeLS avro,
176 fxaKapLov elvai cre. dAA' opa et ex^ts re Kat fxrfbev 8e'r/
rr/s eTrcpST/s* et ydp eêt?, fxdWov dv eycoye crot crvfxfiov-
b4 vofio04rr]s BT W dvofiarodeTijs scr. recc. bs &>om. Schanz

W
:
b8 al ra T /cal B C2 yivoiro T yô'to B ê oIoto

W aWoos yi
: : :
C 5 a.fj.ws ye irais T : troos B C 8 evrjOiKwv BT : (vr)6iKus

t an evvoiKwv ? di evpuv T ^peTv B alpetv
2
B 63 iryS^s
W 65
:
T W iirwdias B
: :
: et 70. o)v secl. Winckelmann e 7 76

T: reB
^
XAPMIAHS i76a
\eucratpt epe p.\v Xrjpov ?/yetcr(9at zlvai Kal abvvarov Adyco

otiovv fyreiv, creavTov 8e, dcrco7rep crcocppoyeVrepos et,
rocrourco eTvat /cai eu8atpoue'cn-epoi\ 5
Kat 6 Xappt8?/s, 'AAAa /xa At", ?/

8' os, eycoye, co 2co-
v
Kpares, ovk oT8a our' et ex_co our' et p? / ex<o' 7rcos ydp a*v
et8et?/u o ye p.7/8' upets otot re ecrre eeupetu drt 7ror' ecrrtu,
cos cpr/s crd; eycb peVrot ov 7rduu crot 7ret#op,at, Kat ip.avTov, b
a ScoKpares, 7rduu ot/xat 8eur0at r?/s e7rcp8?/s, Kat ro' y' epdu
ou8ei> KcoAuet e7ra8ecrc9at vtto crov dcrat ?ype'pai, etos du <p?/s
av Uaucos eêty.
Eieu' dAA', ecpT/ 6 Kptrtds, co Xappt8?/, (t/u) 8pas tovto 5
ep.oiy' ecrrat rouro TtKpJipiov otl o-axppouets, ?/u e7ra8etu

v
irapzyr}* ScoKpdret Kat p? / airoX.z[irr) tovtov /LtT/re pe'ya p?/re
crptKpdy.
'X2s dKoAou0?/croivros, ecprj, Kat p;?/ dTroAetôpeVou* 8etm

ydp du Troioirjv, et pr/ Ttei6oip.r}v crol rto e7rirpo'7rco Kat p.77 C
Troioirjv a KeAeuets.
'AAAd //tjjv, ec/>7/, KeAeuco eycoye.
llot7/crco Toivvv, e<p7/, a7ro raur?jcrt r?js ?//xe'pas dpdpeuos.
Ovtol, ?)u 8' eyco, ri /3ouAeuecr<9otv 7rotetu; 5
Ovbev, e<p?j d Xap/xt8?js, dAAa /3e/3ouAeup.e0a.
Btdcr?/ dpa, ?ju 8' eyco, Kat ou8' avctKpLcriv pot Scocrets;
c
f2s /3tacropeVo?j, ecp?/, e7ret8?j7rep o8e ye e7rtrdrrer Trpds
TavTa crv av /3ouAeuou drt 7rot?7creis.
'AAA' ou8e/xta, Zcprrv eyco, Aei7rerat (BovXrj' crot ydp d

iiTLxeLpovvTL irpaTTtLV otlovv Kal )8taôp;eVco ou8eis otds r'
earat eVaurtoucrflat avOpdoircov.

Mtj Toivvv, ?/
8' ds, p?j8e cru euaurtou.
Ou Toivvv, rjv 8' eyco, euaurtcocropat. 5
a4 Bcripirep T W &s &<rirep B a7 oSt' K%w * : *^T ' *X W ^ : * T

'
W
:
e/ ex&> T b3 ws : fcrois BT b5 add. Goldbacher (et

fy/
add. recc.) Sptys toOto secl. Hermann : 5p3 toCto ci. Madvig
b6 ^j/ B W : tv T b7 airoAeiirTi (suprascr. j) W : (nroKiirri BT
C5 oStoi Bt : o;to T C7 fiidffei BT : jSjô-fii t d4 ivavriov
Bt : ivavriov T
A
<f
AAXH2
AT2IMAX02, MEAH2IA2, NIKIA2, AAXH2,
nAIAES AT2IMAX0T KAI MEAH2I0T, S t. II
2&KPATH2 p. '178
AT. Te#eW0e p.ev tov dvbpa p.axdp.evov sv ottXols, S) a

NtKia re nal AdxrjS' ov 8' eVe/ca vp.ds eKeAerJcra/Ae*> crvvOcd-
cracrOaL eyco re Kal MeAr/crtas obe, rore p.\v ovk et7ro/i.ei>, vvv
8' kpovp.cv. r)yovp.e6a yap xPV vaL npos ye vp.ds itappr\aik-
(ecrdai. etcrt ydp tlvcs 0% tG>v tolovtcov KarayeAwcrt, Kal idv 5

rts avrots cr?j/A/3ouAerJcrr/rai, ovk &v (litolv a yooCcrt^, dAAd b
crToya(pp.VOL tov crvp.\3ovXcvop.ivov aXXa Aeyorjcrt irapd Tr)v
avT&v boav vp.ds 8e r//xets i)yr)crdp.*voL /cat LKavovs yva>vaL
Kcil yvovTas airXGis av et7rety a SoKet vp.lv, ovtco 7rapeAd/3o/xeu
e7rt rr/y crvp.fiovXr)v 7rept <Sy p.4XXop.ev avaKOLVovcrdaL. (cttlv 5
otj> rorjro, 7rept ov 7rdAat rocrarjra 7rpooiptd{bpai, ro'8e. r/ptv 179

etcrty vetj ovtoll, obe pikv rovbe, TrdinTov (\cdv ovop.a Qovkv-
bCbtis, ep.bs 8e av obe TraTrn&ov b\ koX ovtos ovop? eêt
Tovp.ov iraTpos' 'AptcrreiSr/y ydp avrov KaXovp.ev r)p.w ovv
TOVT(av biboKTOL kTTLp.eXr\6r)vaL cos otdy re pdAtcrra, /cat p.r)
5
TTOLrjcraL oirep ol ttoXXol, e7rei8rj peipaKta yiyovzv, dveivaL
avTovs otl (SovXovTaL ttolzlv, aXXa vvv 8f/ /cat dp\ecrdaL
avr&v e7rt//eAetcrc9at /ca0' ocrov otot r' ecrp,eV. etSdres ow Kat
178 a2 ffwdedo-curOai t <rvvdea<rao~8e B : owreOeao-fla T W

W
:
b 2 Aeyown T : voovcri B et yp. t : voov<rt suprascr. \ey

179 a 1 tovto del. corr. Coisl. : to ci. Badham a3 Se ical scr.
Vat. 1029 Tt ca! : BTW a7 Badham
5^)] ^5tj ci. a8 ofoi
t B W : ofdV t T
i7gb IIAATGN02
b vpXv vels ovras rjyqa-a.ij.e0a pep.ekrjKevaL irepl avrStv, elirep
8'
Tt,a\v akkois, ttws clv OepairevOevTes yevoLvro aptorot* et
apa TToXkaKis p.r) TTpocrecrxrjKaTe tov vovv tS> rotovra), VTTop.vr\-
crovres otl ov XPV ctvrov c\p.ekelv, Kat 7Ta/)aKaAowres vpas

5 e7rt to eTnp.ikei.av TLva TToirjcracrdai, rS>v vetov KOLvy p.ed'
r)p.S>v. odev be r)piv Tavr ehoêv, 2> Ni/cta re Kat Aayr)s,
Xpr\ aKovaai, kclv 6Aiya) p.aKp6repa. crvcrcri.Tovp.ev yap

fj
br) eyoj re Kat MeA?io-ias obe, kol r)pXv tcl /xetpaKta irapa-
C otret. oVep ovv Kal apxop.evos elTrov tov koyov, Trapprj-
crLacropeOa irpbs vpJas. rjpSv yap eKaxepos irepl tov eavrov

iraTpbs irokka Kal mka. epya eêt keyeLV irpbs tovs veavicrKovs,
Ka\ ocra ev TTokep.<o rjpyacravTO koX ocra ev elprjvy, ototKowres
5 tol re T&v o~vp.p.ayjj>v kol tcl Trjcrbe tijs irokeoiS' r)p.eTepa b
ai)TS>v epya ovbeTepos eêt keyeLV. raSra 8r) vTraLcryyv6p.e6a

i
re rovcrSe Kat atrtcojaeâ tovs iraTepas r)p.S>v ort r)pas p.ev
d elaiv Tpvcpav, e7ret8?/ /xetpaKta eyevop.eOa, tcl be tS>v dkkcov

-Tpa.yp.aTa eirpaTTov Kal Tolcrbe rots veavicrKOLS avra. raura
evbeiKvvpeOa, keyovTes ort et p.ev ap.ekf]crovcrLV eavrSv Kal
p.r) TreCcrovTaL rjp.LV, aKAeets yevqcrovTaL, et 8' eirLp.ekf)crovTaL,
5 t&x av tS>v 6vop.a.Ttov cllol yevoLVTO a e\ovcrLV. ovtol p.ev
ovv cpacrLV Treio-ecrdaL' r)p.eis be br) tovto aKOTrovpev, tl
av ovtol p.a66vTes r) eirLTrjbevaavTes otl dptorot yevoLVTO.

e eto-T/yT/o-aro ovv tls i)p.lv Kal tovto to p.a.0rjp.a, otl Kakbv etr/
tS> ve<p p-adeLV ev OTrkoLS p.ayeo~6aL- kol eTrrjveL tovtov bv
vvv vp.eis eOeacracrQe eTTLbeLKVvp.evov, ko.t eKekeve OeacracrdaL.

eboe br) XPV V(U avrovs re eAêty e7Tt deav Tavbpbs Kal vpMS
5 crvp.irapakafielv ap.a p.ev crvvOeaTas, ap.a be crvp.i3ovkovs re
Kat kolvcovovs, eav Povkrjcrde, irepl Tr)s t&v vetov e7rt/xeAetas.
b i 7ryri<rdn-6a] frynadfjievot Badham (Sevpo eVoAeVoêv v/jLas excidisse

ratus) (ets o-vnfiovX^v vfxas -rapeKa\4(rafiev 3t<) Tjyrtadfieda Schanz
:
b 6 vel post rifiwv (Kral) vel post b i 6vras (Schanz) excidisse aliquid
videtur C4 iroKffiep .fVBWt: om. T
. . 05 rrjffSe rrjs
BWt: rrjsT C 7 rovaSe B ro7crSe T W ei ifnTW: ou
:
W
B : us in marg. B z
e 2 r&> vew Badham e 3 dedffaadai T :
6ed<re<rdai B
T
AAXHS i8oa
tolvt Cttlv a e/3ouAdjue#a vfxlv avaKOLVojcracr0aL. rjbrj ovv 180

vfxeTepov fxepos o-vfxfiovXeveLV koX TTepl TOVTOV tov fxaOrjfxaTos,
etre boKtl xpijvai fxavOdveLV etre fxrj, Kal irepl tG>v dkkojv, et
tl exere eiraLveo-aL fxdOrffxa veco dvbpl rj eTTLTifbevfxa, Kal Trepi
rrjs KOLVcavCas keyeLV ottoZov tl 7rot?/o-ere. 5

NI. 'Eycb fxev, a> Avo-Cfxaye ko\ MekrfcrCa, eiraLvSj re vfxSjv
TTfV bLOLVOLaV Kol KOLVOJVelv CTOLfXOS, olfXOL be KaX AdyjfTa
TOvbe.
,
AA. AX.rf6r} yap otet, 2> NtKta. o>s o ye ekeyev 6 Atxri- b
fxayos apTL irepX tov traTpbs tov ovtov re /cat tov MeXrfcrCov,
Ttavv fxoi boKel ev dprjcrOaL Kal els eKeCvovs Kal els ?7/xas Kai
ets airarras 6Vot tcl tSjv irokeojv irpdTTOvcrLV, otl avrots

o-yzbov tl Tama crvfXfSaCveL a ovtos Ae'yet Kai 7repi 7rat8a? 5
Kat Trepi raAAa, ra t8ta dAtycopeto-flat re Kai dfxe\Ss Start-
6eo-6aL. raura /u.ei/ ow KaA<3? Aeyets, S AvcrCfxaye' drt 8'
rjfxas fxev crvfxfiovkovs TrapaKakels ehri Tr)v tS>v veavCcrKOJV
iraLbeCav, ScoKparrf be rovbe ov irapaKakels, Oavfxafa, irpSjTov c

fxev ovTa brjfxoTrfv, e7retra ivTavOa del rds 8tarpt/3as ttolov-
fxevov ottov tC ecrTL tSjv tolovtojv (ov o-v fTirets 7repi tovs
viovs r) fxaOrffxa i) eTTLrifbevfxa koKov.
AT. HSjs Aeyets, 00 Aax^s; 2a)Kpar?/s ydp o8e rtvos tSjv 5
rotodrcov eiTLfxekeLav 7re7rot?irai;
AA. IIaz>v /xer ow, a At>o-/zax.
NI. Touro /xeV orot kclv eycb eyoLfXL eliretv ov yjTpov

AayjfTos' Kat ydp ai3r<S fxoL evayyps avbpa TTpovêvrfcre tSj
vet 8t8do-KaAoy fxovo-LKrjs, 'AyadoKkeovs [xa6rfTr)v Adfxojva, d

dvbpSjv yapn-CTTaTov ov fxovov Tr)v fxovcrLKrfV, dAAa Kai raAAa
ottoo-ov /3ovAet d^toy crvvbLaTpCfieLV rr/AiKovrots veavCcrKOLS.
&2 /tepos T W : êVos B secl. Gitlbauer a 3 XPW* 1 T W :
W
:
X/>^'. | ^ B b2 toC avrov B Stobaeus auToC : T t /col]

<caJ Stobaeus /iA|(ri'ouTW: tii\7i<Tiov B b4 irjAe**o)i/
b6 to fflm Stobaeus: BmBTW oA.i7pero-ea BTW Stobaeus:
oXiywpfTf Badham oktydpcos
: Schanz b7 Ka\>s TW /caAejy
W W
:
B C 1 raiStlav B 2 T : iratS.av B C5 38e BT : 8e

d3 bic6aov BW : iirScra T
i8od nAAT&N02
AT. Orjrot, 2) ScoKpares re kcu NtKta kol Ad\r]9, ol
5 r/AtKot eyob fri yiyvaxTKOixev rorjs i>ecore'porjs, clt kclt oikiolv
tcl 7roAAd 8tarpi/3oi>res vtto rr/s r)kLKias' dAA' et rt Kai o~v,
3) 7rat Saxppovio-Kov, exets rtf>^ e rt? <rauro Srrpdrrr dyaObv

e crrj/j./3ouAe?jcrai,
XP 7) vvp.fiovkevzLV. StKatos 8' et* xat yap
7rarptKos ^/xty cptAos Tvyyaveis &v det ydp eyco Kat 6
crds TraTTjp eratpco re Kat c/uAco T7pej>, Kat irpoTepov eKetros
ereAerjrrrcre, 7rpiu rt Ipot hLveydr)vaL. 7rept<pe'pet 8e' rts pe
5 Kat p.vqp.r) dprt rcorjSe AeyoVrcozr ra ydp petpdKta rd8e 7rpds
dAAr/Aorjs oikoi dtaAeydpevot Dajua e7rtp.ep,vrrvrat ScoKpdrorjs
Kat crcpobpa eTraiyorjcriy orj pAvTOL 7Tco7rore arjrorjs dyr/pcorrrcra
181 et rw ûxppovicrKOV Ae'yotei>. dAA', co 7rat8es, Aeyere' /xot,

6'8' ecrrt ScoKpdrrrs, 7rept orj eKacrrore epe/7.i>rrcrc?e;
ITAI. ITdyrj /xey ow, co 7rdrep, ovros.
AT. Erj ye i>r) rrjv "Hpar, a ScoKpares, ort dptfois rdr

5 7rare'pa, apio-TOV dvbpStv ovra, Kat dAAcos Kat 8r) Kat otl
otKeta rd re crd r)pXv rj7rdpet kol crot rd i)p.Tpa.
AA. Kat p.r/y, co Avo-ip.ayje, p.r) dcptecrd ye rdvdpoV cos
eycb Kat dAAo#i ye avTov efleacrdprri' ov p.6vov tov 7rarepa

b dAAd Kat Tr)v iraTpiha opdovvTa' iv yap rfj dirb ArrAtorj
cpvyr) per' epou crvvavey&peL, Kayco crot Aeyco ort et ot dAAot

rjOekov tolovtol LvaL, 6p6r) av r)p.S>v r) 7rdAis r)v ml ovk av
e7recre totc tolovtov 7rrcopa.
5 AT. '12 ScoKpares, orjros peVrot 6 tiraLvos otlv KaAds, 6z>
crv vvv e7ratyf) rj7r' dvbp<av dia>v iTLcrTVo-$aL Kal ets rarjra
ets d orjrot kiraLVOvo-LV. erj orjy fcrt9t ort eyco rarjra aKOVcov
Xatpco drt erj8oKtp,ets, Kat otj 8e r)yov p.e ey rots erjjjovcrrardy
d. 4 o^to Badham otfroi ti BT: o&rot tjW d5 7j\ikol B

W
:
W
:
%\ikoi Kal T e2 ael B 0 T : ahl t 64 TTfpKpepeil

BTW
:
irepitppei Badham e6
K
b ta\ey6fj.evoi : StaXe yo/xe va t Oafj.a
T W : Sûa B a2 âiKpaTris secl. Badham enefjLvrio-de BT W :
fiefivrta-de scr. Ven. 189 as /cal SAAws secl. Badham a6 rc

Bekker : ye BT W b2 et 01 Vat. 1029 fiBT: ol : W (fort. tl
&\\ol fuit) b3 rjfiwv extra versum T b8 euSoKifie?s T :
(vSoKifie? W : evSoKlfxcos B ^yot; /*e B W : r)yovfxai T evvovararov

scripsi : <y' evvovffrarov Schanz : eiipouoTaVois TW :
y evvovcrrarois B

AAXH2 i8ic
croL elvaL. xpr)v p.ev ovv kcu Trporepov ye (poirav avrbv Trap c
r)p.as nal olKeCovs r/yelcrdaL, ooo-trep t6 bUaiov vvv 8' ovv
airb Trjo-be rfjs r)p.epas, eTreLbr) aveyvoopCcrap-ev dXXrjXovs, p,r)
dXXoos ttoiei, dXXd crvvLcr6C re ml yvutpiê Kal r)p.ds Kal

Tovabe tovs veoorepovs, oiroos av bLao~oo(r]Te Kal vfxels rr)v 5
r)p.erepav qbiXCav. ravra p.ev ovv Kal crv 7roir]o~eis fcai r)p.eLS
o~e Kal avdis v7rop.vrjo-op.ev irepX be oov r)pdp.eda tL <paTe;

tl boKei; to p.ddr]p.a toIs ju.eipa/aois' eTnTrjbeiov etvat r\ ov, to
p.adelv ev ottXols p.dyeo-6aL;
2X2. 'AAAa Kal tovtcov rrepL, a AvcrCp.a)(e, eyooye ireLpd- d
arop.ai crvp.j3ovXeveLV av tl bvvoop.aL, Kal av a TrpoKaXfj irdvTa
TTOLeTv. bLKaLOTarov p.evT0L p.0L boKel elvaL epie veooTepov ovra
Tcovbe Kal direLpoTepov tovtcov aKoveLV irpoTepov tC XeyovcrLV
kol \xav6aveLv irap avToov edv 8' ex ft) Tt &XXo irapd Ta virb 5
tovtcov Xey6p.eva, tot 7/817 bibdcrKeLV kol TreCdeLV Kal o~e kol
tovtovs. aXX\ 00 NiKâ, vt ov XeyeL Trorepos vp.<av;
NI. 'AAA' ovbev KooXvei, co SooKpares. boKel ydp Kal
ep.ol tovto to p.ddr]p.a toIs veoLS oo<peXLp.ov etvaL eirCo-Tao~6aL e
iroWaxrj. Kal ydp to p.r) dXXodi bLarpCfieLV, ev ols br)
cpLXovcnv ol veoL Tas faaTpLfids iroLelcrdaL orav o-x?Xr)v
dycocriv, dAA' ev tovtoo, ev e\eL, o6ev kol to oG>p.a fieXTLOV

lcryeiv avdyKrj ovbevbs ydp tGv yvp-vao-Coov cpavXorepov ovb' 5
eXaTToo ttovov ex at &p.a irpoo~r}KeL /xdAior' eXevdepoo 182

tovto re to yvp.vacrLov koX r) LTnrLKr]' ov ydp dyatvos d6Xr]Tal
eo~p.ev kol ev oXs r)p2v 6 ayoov irpoKeiTaL, p.6voL ovtol yvpva-
(ovTaL ol ev tovtols tols [tov] irepl rbv iroXep.ov opyavoLS
yvp.vaC6p.evoL. eireLra ovrjo-ei p.ev tl tovto to p.ddr]p.a Kal 5
ev Trj p.dyj] avrrj, orav ev rdeL bej] p.dyea6aL p.Ta iroXXoov

dXXcov p.eyLo~Tov p.evTOL avTov ocpeXos, orav Xvd&crLV al
C 1 7] ir corr. Coisl. C3 airb rrjaSe rrjs TW : air6Se rrjs B

d 7 iroTfpos BT irpdrepos W d8 /cai T
4/j.ol 4/xo\ Ka\ W :
W W
: :
ifiol B 64 ex l B : fx eiv T o5 B T ou a2 : aywvos

addubitat Schanz a 3 ourot] opdws ci. A. T. Christ yvfJLva(ovrai]
aywvi(ovTat ci. Wotke a 4 tov B T om. recc. W :
i82a IIAATfiNOS
raets /cat 7/877 rt ber\ p.6vov irpbs p.6vov 77 buOjKOVTa duvvo-
b p.ev<o tlvX eirLQecrQaL r) KaX ev (pvyfj eirLTLQep.evov dkkov

duvvaaOaL avrov ovt av vtto ye evbs els 6 tovt e-7rtord-
pevos oibev av irdQoL, lctcos 8' ovbe vtto TrkeLovojv, dkkd

TravTayrj av TavTtj irkeoveKTOL. ert 8e Kal els aWov Kakov
5 uaOf)p.aTos 7TL0vfj,(av irapaKakeZ ro tolovtov ttcls yap av
p.aQ(ov ev ottKols p.ayjeo-0aL eiTLQvp,f)creLe Kal tov efjs p.aOf)-
p.aTos tov irepl tcls rdfet?, Kal Tavra kafitov Kal (pLkoTLurjOels
C ev avTOLS ZttI 7TCLV clv to irepi tcls o-TpaTr\yCas dpp.f)(TCLe' /cat
7/877 brjkov otl tcl tovtmv exueva Kai p.aQr)p.aTa TTCLVTa
Kal TTLTribevp.aTa Kal Kaka Kal irokkov dfta avbpl p.aQeiv
re kol eiTLTrjbevo-aL, 3>v KaOr\yf)craLT av tovto to p.d0r\pa.
irpoo-0r)o-op.ev 8' avrai ov crp.LKpav irpoo-Qf)Kr\v, otl irdvTa

5
dvbpa ev irokeuio kol OappakeioTepov Kal dvbpeLOTepov dv

iroLf)o-eLev avTov avrov ovk okiyco avTt\ rj eTTLcrTr\p.r\. p.r\
aTLp.do-u>p.ev be elTrelv, el /cat ra> o-p.LKpoTepov 80/cet elvaL, otl
Kal evcryjip,oveo-Tepov evravOa ov XPV T0V av ^pa evo-yj)p,ove-
d o-repov qbaCvecrOaL, ov dp,a /cat beLvoTepos tols exOpoXs qjavetraL

Std rr\v evo-x^p.oo-vvr\v. ep.ol piev ovv, (h Avo-[p.axe, (ocnrep ,
keyco, 80/cei re xP r) vaL 8t8dcr/cetz> tovs veavCcrKOVS ravra Kal

8t' a 80/cei elprjKa' Adx^TOS 8', et tl irapd ravra keyei, Kav
5 avros r\be(os aKovcraLp.L.
AA. 'AAA.' eort p.ev, 2> Nt/cta, xa^ (7T0V êyetv irepl
otovovv p.aOf)paTos (os ov XPV pavOdveLV iravTa yap eirC-

crrao-QaL dyaObv 80/cei elvaL. /cat br\ Kal to otrkLTLKOv tovto,
e et uev ecrTLV udQr\p,a, oirep cpacrlv ol bLbdaKovres, nal olov
Nt/ctas keyeL, XPV avrb p.avOdveLV ei 8' eoTti> p.ev p.r\ p.dOr\pa,
akk' eâ-naTQto-Lv 61 v7TLcrxvovp.evoL, r) p.d0r\ua p.ev TvyxdveL
a8 rt] riva Badham : wov Kral b 1 eiriTidt/ji.evov BT : ri-

6efj.wov W b2 obW avT: '6r av B W : ov Tav Hermann : ofa' &p'
Badham secl. Gitlbauer
: et mox yap pro ye C3 eiriTi}Sev/xaTa
T: iTriT^Sev/j.aTa irdvTa BW c8 elire?v secl. A. T. Christ
d1 o5 TW:
olv B : 5t' ov scr. susp. Schanz (secl. mox Sia. t^v
m ~
evo x yUx 00 vv v J
-
''l
e 3 a" T ^ ^ avTOV B W /J.i) om. B,
suprascr. b
AAXHS 182 e
ov, fxr) fxivrot irdvv o-rrovbaiov, tC koX bioL av avrb fxavOdvcLv;

Ae'yco 8e ravra 7reot avTov ets rdbc aTrof3ki\j/as, otl olfxai 5
eyco tovto, et t\ r)v, ovk av kckrfQivaL AaKebatfioviovs, 0X9

ovbkv dkko /u,e'Aet kv rco /3tco 17 tovto QnTtiv Kat iirLTrfbeviLV,
otl av fxaQovTcs Kal (TTLTrfbevcravTes 7rAeoi>eKroiei> tG>v akkcuv 183

7reoi tov irokefxov. et 8' (KtCvovs kikrfQev, &AA' ov tovtovs
ye tovs bLbao-Kakovs ax/Tov kikrfQtv avrb tovto, otl ZkzIvol
juaAtcrra tG>v 'F>kkifV()V cnrovbdôvcrLV em rots tolovtols kol
otl irap zklvols av tls TLfxrfdels ets Tavra kol Trapa tG>v 5
akktov Trkelo-T av ipydÔLTO \piffxaTa, coo-7rep ye kol rpa-
ycobCas TroLrfTrfS irap r)fxCv TLfxrfQzCs. TotydproL bs av oujrat
TpaycobCav KaAcos ttolzlv, ovk e^coQtv kvkAco 7re/H Tr)v 'ArrtKT/i'
KaTa ras dkkas 7ro'Aets ZirLbtLKVVfxevos ircpiipxtTai, dAA' tvQvs b

btvpo <pe'/oerat- Kat roto-5' e7ri8eua>va-iy eiKoVcos' rois de eV
oTrkoLS fxaxpp-ivovs eyco tovtovs 6pG> rr)v fxev AaKfbaCfxova
r)yovfxivovs eii>ai a/3aTOV Upbv Kat oi>8e ctKpcp 7ro5t eTrt-
fiaCvovras, kvkAco 8e 7repiioY/ras avrrfv Kal iracrL p.dkkov 5

eirLb^LKVvfiivovs, Kal fxdktcrTa tovtols o\ kclv avrol 6p.okoyrf-
cretay Trokkovs crcputv TrpoTtpovs tlvaL irpbs ra tov Trokifxov.
(ireLTa, co AvcrCp.ayje, ov irdvv dAtyots eyco tovtcov irapa- C

ykyova kv avrG> tG> epyco, Kat 6pco otot etcnz\ eeart 8e Kal
ai/ToOev fffxlv crK\\racr6aL. coo-7reo yap e7rtr?j8es ovbels 7rco7ror'
vboKLp.os yiyovcv iv tG> 7roAe/xco dvrfp tu>v tcl oTrkLTLKa
TrLTrfbvcrdvTO)v. Katrot ets ye raAAa irdvra eK tovtcov ol 5

oVo/jtaoTOt yCyvovTaL, \k tG>v kirLTrfb^vcrdvTcav eKacrra' ovtol
b\ tos olk, irapa tovs dkkovs ovrco crcpobpa ets tovto
bcbvcrTVxriKacrLv. e7ret Kat tovtov tov SrTjcrtAecoi;, bv vfxtLS
/xer' ejuou iv rocrovrcp oxAcp iOedcracrOt cTrLbtLKVvfxevov Kal tcl d
/xeyaAa 7rept aurou kiyovra a eAeyey, erepcot^t eyco KaAAtoy
e4 fjLtmoi scr. recc. : /xii fiivroi ri TW /t?jSeV roi rl B rl

W
fjLTj
W
:
Ka\ : Kal BT 67 fxeKet B (sed in ras. b) fieWei T

t :
a2 \f\t)0ev Kral: l\e\-f)0eL BTW a3 avrov \e\t]9ev] avrov

'\e\-fidetv Schanz : ttv faeÔet A. T. Christ b 2 4wi$e(Kvvo-iv]
eiri5e'tKvvrat Badham imdeiKWT Schanz b3 6pS TW: ipSo B
W
:
b6 ot Kav T : ovk av B 07 oSt BT : om. W

:
i83d nAAT&NOS
e6eao-dp.r\v ev tjj akrjdeCq (%s akr\6a>s einbeiKvvpevov ov^
eKOVTa. TTpoo-f3akovo-r\s ydp Trjs veoos ecp' rj e7re/3dreuei>
5 Trpbs 6\Kaba Tivd, p.aytTO ex.cov bopvbpeiravov, bia<pepov br\
oirkov dre Kal avrbs t<2v dkkoov biacpepoov. rd p.ev ovv akka
ovk aia keyeiv irepl ravbpos, to be o-6<pi<rp.a to tov bpeirdvov
e tov irpbs rfj koyyr) olov direfir). p,ayop.tvov yap avrov
zvio-yzTO ttov ev rots rf/s veoos (TKevecnv kcu di>reAd/3ero*
dkKV ovv 6 2)rrirrtAecos /3ovk6p,evos dirokvo-ai, Kal ovx olos
t r)v, r) be vavs rr\v vavv 7raprjet. Teoos piev ovv irapedei
5 ev Trj vr\\ dvTex6p.evos tov bopaTOS' e7ret 8e br) 7rap7jpei/3ero
rj vavs Tr)v vavv Kal kitio-na avrbv tov boparos ex6p.evov,

184 ecptet to bopv bia tt\s xeipos, eoos axpov tov crrdpaKos avre-
Ad/3ero. r\v be yekoos Kal Kporos vtto t&v k tt~)s okKabos
eirC re rco cr^7jp,ari avTOv, Kal eireibr) ftakovTQS tlvos kCOoo
Trapa tovs 7rd8as ovtov em to KaTao-Tpoip.a dcpterat rofj
5 8dparo?, tot rjbr\ Kal ol K rf/s Tpir)povs ovk(tl 0I0C t r)crav

tov yeAcora Karexetr, dpcovres aloipovp.evov eK rrjs okKabos
to bopvbpeiravov eKelvo. tcrcos piev ovv etr\ h\v t\ rafJra,
uxnrep NtKtas Xeyet* ots 8' ovv eyoo evTtTvyrjKa, ToiavT

b drra eo-rCv. o ovv koX e apxrjs elirov, etre ovtoo crp.iKpas
cocpeAtas exet p,d0r\pa ov, etre pvrj ov cpacrt Kat TrpoaTTOiovvTai
avTo elvaL p.d0rjp,a, ovk diov eTTiyeipeiv p.avddveiv. Kal yap
ovv poi boKel, et p.ev beikos rts cov ototro avrd e7ricrrao-t9ai,
5 OpaavTepos av bi avTO yevop.evos eTTKpaveo-Tepos yevovro

dlos rjv, ei be avbpetos, (pvkaTTop.evos av vtto to>v dvdpojiroiv,
et Kat o-p.iKpbv eap,dpToi, p.eydkas av 8ta/3oA.d? to-xeiy
C eiricpOovos ydp r) TTpocnroCrjcns Trjs Toiavrr\s eTTio-Trjprjs, ooo-t
d3 iv tt; a\r]dua om. Vat. 1029: secl. Schanz as oArjflws secl.

W
:
A. T. Christ e 4 iraprjei. rtus rec. t iraprjci re' &s B irapeit) :
W
:
riws T e 5 iirtl 8e d)) B iirefi)) Se T : a 1 icpiei B T ' W :
7}(pUi vel Karticpiei scr. recc. a 7 ckuvo scr. recc. iKcivcp B T : W

b 1 etre Gitlbauer Srt efre B : '6ri T W
b 4 otoiro avrb scripsi
W
:
oloiro avrbv B : oloiro avrbv Se?v : oloiro avrbv Selv T b5 iiri-
<pave<rrepos] Karacpaveorepos Badham b6 oTos Schleiermacher :
\ olos BW:| otos T ?jv] efri ci. H. Richards b7 firx*']

%<rx l Schanz
:
AAXII2 184C
et /xr/ tl Oavp.acrTov ocrov 8ia<pe'pet rfj dperfj tG>v dkkoiv, ovk

ecrt9' ottlos av tls cpvyoL to KaTayikacrros yzvicrQaL cpdcrKOiv
eX* lv TavT-qv Tr)v iirLcrTr]p.r]v. TOLavrr) tls epotye 8oKet, S)
Avo-Lfia\e, r/ irepl tovto to pAOrjpM. ttvaL cnrovbr]' yjpr) 5

b' oTrep o-ol e <*PXV S ekeyov, koX 2a)Kpdrr/ rovbe pr/
dcpteVat, dkkd belcrOaL cnjp/3oi;Aer/eiy ottt/ 8oKet avrco 7rept

TOV 1Tp0KLp.V0V.
AT. 'AAAd biopML iyooye, S ârKpares* kol yap axnrep
TOV (TTLbLaKpLVOVVTOS boKL p.0L bLV fjpLLV T/ /3oTjAt/. et piiv 6.
yap crvvecpepicrOrjv ra>8e, tjttov av tov tolovtov e8er vvv

be Tr]v ivavrCav ydp, cos opas, Ad)(Tjs NtKta ZOzto, v br)
exet dKovcraL koX aov 7rorepa> tolv avbpolv crvpjtyrjcpos et.
212. Tt bi, a> AvcrLpLaxe; 07ro'rep' av ol TrkeCovs iirai- 5
v&ctlv r)p.S)v, tovtols pe'AAets xpr/cri9ai;

AT. Tt yap dv tls Kal ttoloZ, a> 2a>Kpares;
212. *H Kat otj, a> MeAr/crta, otircos ay 7rotots; Kai et
rts 7rept dyoivias tov vios croi j3ovkr] eh] rt xph dcnceiV, dpa e
rots1 TtkdocrLV dv r)pG>v ttlOolo, r) 'klvo) oorts- rvyxdvL tjtto
7ratoorpt/3r/ dya6G> iriraLbvp.ivos koX r/crKr/Kcos;
ME. 'EKetyco etKo? ye, a> 2coKpares.

212. Avt<2 dp dv pxxkkov ttzlQolo t/ reVrapcrii' ovcriv 5
r)puv;
ME. "Icms.
212. 'E7rio-rr//uTr yap otpat 8et Kpiv<yOaL dkk' ov irkrjOeL
to pikkov Kak&s Kptt9r/crecrt9ai.
ME. Elwy ydp ou; 10
2X2. Ovkovv Kal vvv XPV Trp&Tov avrb tovto crKixj/acrOaL,
et ecrrty rts r]p.<av t^xvlkos irtpl ov fiovkevopLtOa r/ orj* Kat et 185
C3 <pvyoi BT W C 9 &<rmp tov iviStaKpivovuros Ast

<pvyq t
W
: :
Sbffirtp (irl tov SiaKptvowTos BT

Sorrep en tov SiaxpivovvTos Hein-
W
:
dorf d 1 S(7p B t 8? T d 5 dir^Ttp' Schleiermacher

:
&it6t( B T W d 8 jM\r)o-ia T fu\i\ffia B W

e 1 aywvias:
toC T aywvio-Tov B
: W
e 2 tvj xdvot Bekker e 3 watSoTpifiti
pr. T Kal ^ koi BT
: W
es jjTW: om. B 09 k/h-
0-fio-fffOai B W
Stobaeus et in marg. T KpiveffOat T :
plato, vol. m. 5
;
i85a IIAAT12N02
piev cttlv, cklvu> TTeCdecrdaL evl ovtl, tovs 8' dAAous edv, et
8e \jJ], dkkov tlvcl (j]TeXv. ?/ irepl o~p.LKpov otecrde vvvl

KLvbvveveiv Kal crv Kal AvcrLLia\os dAA' ov irepl tovtov tov
5 KTr\p.aTos o tG>v vp.Tepo)v LLtyLCTTOV ov TvyyaveL; veo)v ydp

ttov t] xpricrT&v 1] ravavTLa yevop.evo)v Kal ttcls 6 oikos 6 tov
Trarpos ovtcos otK?/o-erat, O7rotoi dv TLves ol 7rat8es yevoivrai.
y
ME. A\r]6r) Aeyets.
212. UoXXrfv dpa oet Trpop.r]6Lav avrov fyeLV.

io ME. Yldvv ye.
b 212. n<3? ovv, 6 eya> dprt ekeyov, eo-Kotrovp.ev dv, el
J3ovk6p.eda crKeyfracrdaL rts r)p.G>v irepl dyo)vCav TexyLKCoTaros;

ap' oi>x 6 p.ado)v kol TTLTT]bevcras, a> Kat 8i8do-KaAoi dyaflot
yeyovoTes r)crav avrov tovtov;
y
5 ME. Euotye 8oKet.
212. Ovkovv tl irpoTepov, tlvos ovtos tovtov [ofi) t]tov-
p,ev tovs bLhacrKakovs;

ME. UG)S Aeyets;
?
212. 128e icroos p,dkkov KaTabt]kov earat. ov p.oi boKeL
io e dpxfjs r)pxv d)p.okoyi]crdaL tl ttot Otlv irepl ov ftovkevo-
p.eda [*at a-KTTTop.eda\, ootls r)p.G>v rexvLKos koI tovtov
C VKa bLbaCTKdkOVS KTT]CraTO, KOL OOTtS ]XT].
NI. Oi ydp, S) 2&>Kpares, irepl tov ev ottAois [J-dye-
crdaL crK07Tovpi.v, etre XP7) avT0 T0V $ veavicrKovs fiavOdveLv

LT ]XT];
5 212. Yldvv piev ovv, o) NtKta. dAA' otov trepX <papp.aKOv
tls tov irpbs 6cpdakp.ovs o-KoirrJTaL, elre XP 7) avT virakei-

cpecrdaL etre pjj, troTepov otet tot etvai tt)v (3ovkr]v irepl
tov cpapp.aKov r) rrepl tG>v 6cp6akp.G)v
NI. Ilept tG>v 6(p6akp.G)V.

d 212. Ovkovv Kat orav lttttu)
x a^- vov ,' cKOTTrjTaC rts ei
a 3 ottffde Stobaeus oUcrOai B T : W a6 6 ante rov T W

Stobaeus om. B in fine paginae
: b6 ov secl. Jacobs bn xal
<TKirT6(ie0a secl. Ast C 6 rls rov Cron : ris rov B W : rls rov b
vel avrip vel iira\d<pto-Oai ci. H. Richards
AAXH2 i85d
Trpoo-oMTTtoi' r/ p.r\, koX ottotz, totc ttov Trepl tov Xttttov
/3ot>Aerjerat dAA' ov irepl tov xaAti>ot>;

NI. 'AAr/0r/.
2X2. Ovkovv kv\ Adyco, oTav tis rt VKa tov o-KOTrfj, 5

7repi Zkclvov r) /3ovX.r) Tvyyavu ovaa ov VKa o-kottL, dAA'
ov Trepl tov eVe/ca dAAou k($TZL.
NI. 'ArdyKr/.
212. Aet dpa Kat tov crvpi[BovXov ctkottuv apa TZjtyLKos
Icttlv ets tKeivov depairîav, ov eVeKa o~KOTrovp.tvoL o~ko- 10
7TOVp.V.
NI. Ylavv ye.
2X2. Oukow zw <pap.ev Ttepl p.aOrjp.aTos (tkotthv tt}$ e

\j/V\i]S VKa TIJS TSiV VmVLCTKOdV;
NI. Nat.
2X2. Et ris dpa ?//acoi> rex^tKos 7reot \jrvxvs Oepairdav
Kal otds Te KaAcos roSro 0eoa7rer3crai, kclI drcp 8i8dcrKaAoi 5
dya#ot yeydracrtz;, rorjro (tk7tt4ov.

AA. Tt e', co 2coKpares; ov7rco ecopaKas dyeu 8t8acrKdAcoz>
/^ T^x.VLKUiTpovs yeyo^dras ets evta t/ /xerd StSao-KdAcor;
v
2X2. Eycoye, co Adxr/s* ots ye cn> ovk av e#e'Aots 7rto"Teu-
crat, et (paizv aya6o\ etifat hi)p.Lovpyoi, et /xr/ rt crot rf/s 10
avrtav T)(vr]s tpyov exotey e7ri8etai ev dpyacrp.ivov, Kat e>

Kat 7rAetco. 186
AA. Tovro p.kv aXrjdrj Aeyets.
2X2. Kat r)p.as apa 8et, co Adx?/s Te Kat NtKta e7ret8T/
Aucrt/xaxos Kat MeAr/crias ets crvp.(3ovkr)v TraoeKaAecrdrrjy

rjpds 7rept rotv vioLV, Trpo6vp.ovp.ivoL ovtoIv otl dptcrras 5
yei>e'cr0ai rds y\rv\as et p.iv cpap.tv i\iLV, e7rt8etat avrots
d7 & eWxa aAAot/ Cornarius : ov 'ivena &\\o BT W d 10 ffKoirov-

ftevot] ffKoirov^fv a Matthiae : ffKoirov/j.(v 6 Cron d 12 iravv ye . . .
191 b3 tlirev avrbv tria folia manu

recenti scripta in W 64 f)f
tis] offris Schanz e6 rovro G: rovrov BT: rovrov Apelt

a2 rovro . . . a\t)9r}BT : tovto . . i.\ijdis vel ravra
. . . . a\i]6rj scr.
recc. a 5 avrotv B rec. t : abrqv T
T
i86a nAATX2N02
nal bibcMTKakovs o'ltlvs [r)p.G>v yey6vao~Lv] avrol TrpG>Tov
dya6o\ ovres Kal 7rokkG>v veo>v TedeparrevKOTes ^rvxds eVetra
b Ka\ i)p.as bibdavTes cpaCvovraL' r/ et tls r)p.G>v avrG>v kavTut
hihao~Kakov piev ov cpr)o~L yeyovevai, dAA' ovv epya ovtov

avTov e\Lv tw&v * a' (Tnbelât. rCves 'ABrjvaCoov rj tG>v
evo>v, rj SouAot rj ekevOepoL, ot' eKeivov bp,okoyovp.evo>s dya-
5 0ol yeyovacrLV et Se p.r)bev rjpuv tovto>v imapyjei, dkkovs
KekeveLv (jt}Teiv kol p.r) ev eratpooy dvbpG>v veo~LV KLvbvveveiv
bLa<pdeCpovras Tr)v pLeyCcrrrjv ahCav eyeLV virb tG>v otKeiord-
to>v. eyo> p.ev ovv, o> Avo~Cp.a)( re koI MekrjcrCa, irp&Tos
C irepl ep.avTov keyo> otl bLbdo~Kakos p.OL ov yeyove tovtov irepL.
KaCroL eiTLdvp.5) ye tov 7rpa.yp1.aT0s K veov dpdp.evos. dkkd

tols p.ev aocpLo-Tais ovk eyo) rekelv p.LO~6ovs, dtirep p.6voL
erniyyekkovTO p.e 0I0C t eXvai noLrjo-aL Kakov re Kayadov

5 avros 8' av evpelv Tr)v Teyvr\v dbvvarG> tl vvvC. el be
NtKtas r) Adyjjs rjvprjKev r) p.ep.ddr)Kev, ovk dv 6avpAo~aLp.L'
Kal yap yjpr)p,ao~LV e/xou bvvarutTepoL, coo~t pxxOelv Trap &k-
ko>v, Kal dp.a rcpecrfivTepoL, toare ijbr) r)vpr)KvaL. boKodcrL
d brj p.0L Swarot elvaL 7rat8eirai dv0po)7rov ov ydp dv irore
dbeG>s airecpaCvovTO rrepl e7rtr?]oeu/adrcoz/ veo> yj>r)o~To>v re Kat
Trovr)pG>v, et p.r) avrois eTrCcrrevov IkovG>s eibevai. ra pkv ovv
dkka eyo>ye tovtols TTLorevo)' otl be bLacpepecrOov dkkr/koLV,
5 edavp.acra. tovto ovv o~ov eyd> dvTLbeop.aL, o> Avo~Cp.aye'
Kaddrrep dprt Adxrjs /xr/ acpCecrdaC cre ep.ov oteKeAeuero dkkd

epo>Tav, Kal eyo> vvv TrapaKekevop.aC o~ol p.i) dcf>Ceo~daL Adx^ros
p.r)be NtKtou, dAA' epo>rav keyovra otl 6 piev 2,o)KpdTr)s ov
e q^rjo-Lv eTraieLv irepl tov irpdyp.aTos ovb' lkovos elvaL 8ta-
KplvaL brroTepos vp.G>v dkr)6rj Aeyet ovre yap evperr)S ovre
p.adr)Tr)s ovbevbs irepX tG>v tolovtcov yeyovevaL ot) b\ o>
&'} 7)fia>v ycy6vaffiv secl. Badham : tj/xwv yey6vacriv, ot Bekker

vpurov ci. Stephanus vpurot B T
: b2 avrbv ci. olim Stallbaum :
avrbs B b 3 (X fi " scr rec c- :

X et BT b 4 inelvov corr.
Coisl. ixelvuv B T
: b 6 Kt\evtiv corr. Coisl. : tceKeve 1 BT
e 5 evpelv T ipuv B : d 2 ve<$ T fi.ev B
: e3 irepi B
AAXH2 i86e
Aax7? fol Nuta, eureroy r)p.lv eKaTepos tLvl bi] beLVordroi

crvyyeyovaTov "nepl Trjs tG>v veo)v Tpoqjrjs, kolL iroTepa p.a06vTe 5
napa tov eTTLoracrOov r/ avro) eevp6vT, Kal el piev p.a06vT,
tLs 6 otSdo-KaAoy eKarepo) Kal rLves dAAot 6|u.o'rex*'ot arjrots, 187
Xv, av fxr) vp.lv o-xoAr) V V7T T v r ^ ? "nokeois Trpayp.aTOiV,
tt' eKeLvovs Xoip.ev Kal TTeL0o>p.ev r/ bwpoLs r/ xaoio-ii> r/ dp.-
qboTepa kTTLp.e\r\67\vai koi tG>v i]p.eTpo>v Kal tG>v vp.Tepo)v

TraLbo)V, ottojs p.i] KaTaLo-yyvo>crL tovs avT&v TTpoyovovs cpavXoL 5
yev6p.evoL' et 5' arjrot evperal yeyovore tov tolovtov, boTe

napdbeLyp.a tLvoov t/8t/ aWoiv TTLp.\r]OevTS K qbavXoiv
Kakovs T Kayadovs e7roir/o-are. et yap vvv TrpG>Tov dpêo-Oe
Traibevetv, crKOTrelv \pr) /j,t/ ovk ev rw Kapt vplv 6 KLvbvvos b

KivbvvevrjTaL, dAA' iv tols veVt re Kat ev rols tG>v <ptAa)i
iraiaL, kol aTe^v&s to keyop.evov Kard ti]v irapoLp.Lav vp.lv
rrvp,]3aLvr] ev ttLOo) r) Kepap.eLa yLyvop.evr]. Aeyere orjy rt

tovto)v r) qraTe vp.lv v-ndpyeLV re Kat irpocrqKeLV r) ov qbare. 5
Tavr, o> AvcrLp.a\e, 7ra/>' avT&v irvvOdvov re koi p.r) p.eOLei
tovs dvbpas.
AT. KaA<3? p.ev e/xotye SoKet, a dvbpes, SoiKpaTris \eyeiv
et be ]3ov\op.VOLS vp.lv eort 7reoi tG>v tolovto>v epoiTacrOaL C
re Kat 8i6oVat Adyoy, avrorjy br) XPV yiyvoicrKeLV, Si NtKta
re xat Ad%r]s. ep.ol p.ev yap koX MeAr/ata rG>be brj\ov otl
r)bop.evoLs av etr/ et rrdvTa a SaiKodrT/? epcora eOekoLTe Adycp
bie^LevaL' kol yap e dpyrjs evrevOev r)pypp.r]V XeyoiV, ort 5
ets o~vp.{3ov\i]V 8ta Tavra vpxis TTapaKa\ecraip.ev, otl /xe/xeAr/-
KeVai vp.lv i]yovp.eda, ots etKo'?, irept tG)V Toiovroiv, kol aAAojy
at e7ret8r/ ot 7rat8es vp.lv 6\Lyov Sicnrep 61 r)p.TepoL r/AiKtay
eôuat TratSerjeo-ât. et ovv vp.lv p.r) tl 8ta<rjepet, enrare koi d

kolvi) p.era ôiKpdrovs o-K-q/ao~$e, bibovTes re koi be)(6p:VOL
6 7 avrois Kv* T : o.vroiaiv B a 6 ytyov^re B yey6vare : T

a8 irpu>Tov apao-0at (sic) B sed aff puncto notata ap^fffde irpSnov : T
b2 viffi] vfitTtpois Schanz b4 ffv/xfiaivp Bekker : ffvfi&aivei BT
Ktpa/j.ciaJ] Kfpaixia BT A.f7Te T : \eyerai B C3 Kal
HfKrjffia T : 2> /xt\rjffia B C4 a T : eoj/ B 2
: &i B C 5 tvTtvOtv
r/px^nriv B : ripx^nrjv tvTevdev T
i87d nAAT&NOS
koyov 1x0.0' akkr)ku>v ev yap Kal tovto Ae'yet bb(, otl 7rept
tov p,y[o~Tov vvv fiovkev6p.e6a tG>v ?/pere'pco7J. dAA' opdre

5 et 8oKet xprjvat ovrco itolzTv.
NI. '12 Avainay*, 8oKets p,ot cbs dkr)6G>s ôoKpart] 7rarpd-
0ev yLyva>o-KLV p.6vov, ovtG> 8' ov crvyyeyovivaL dAA* ?/
e 7rat8t dVrt, e? 7ro?j cv rots Sr/pdrais /xerd rorj iraTpbs aKoAorj-
0cotj e7rA?/criacreV ctol r) kv lepco rj kv dAAco r<j> crrjAAdyco rcov
br)poTG>v e7ret8?/ 8e 7rpecr/3?jVepos yiyovev, ovk e>jreru)(?jKcos
rco di>8pt 8?/Aos ert et.
5 AT. Ti /xdAtcrra, o> NtKta;

NI./ Ov ju,ot 8oKets etSeVai otl bs av eyydrara ScoKpdrous
?/ [Adyco cocr7rep yeVei] Kat 77Ar/o-td0/ 8taAeyo'p,e7Jos, dvdyKt)
aurco, edv apa Kal 7rept aAAorj tov Trporepov ap^rjTaL 8taAe'-
yecrflat, /xt/ TravccrdaL ?j7rd rovrojj 7reptayd/>teJJ0V rco Adyco,
io 7rptz; (di>) ep.7reVr/ ets ro 8t8oVat 7rept arjrod Adyov, ovTLva
l88 TpoiTov vvv re ?j koi ovTLva tov 7rapeArjA?j#o'ra /3iW /3e/3t-
coKe/j' e7ret8dy 8' ep7re'tr?j, drt ou irpoTepov avrbv dcprjcrtL
1 6 ScoKpdrrjs, Trpti' d/j fiacravicrr) ravra eS re Kat koAcos diravTa.

lyu> 8e tr?ji>?j#rjs re etpt rco8e Kat 018' ort dvdyKt) vtto tovtov
^ 5 TtacrytLV ravra, kol ert ye adros drt 7retcropat rarjra ev otSa*
XCttpco ydp, co Arjcrtpaê, rco drjSpt 7rAr/crtd(fcoy, Kat odSe/J

otpat KaKorj etrat to vTTop.Lp.vr)crKcrdaL drt p.r) KaAcos ?/ 7re7rotij-
b Kap.V rj TTOLovp-ev, dAA' ets tov i-TTtLTa fiiov Trpop,r)6eo-Tepov
avdyKrj etvat rdy ravra p,r) cpedyorra dAA' 6zkovTa Kard

rd rorj SdAcoôs koX a^LovvTa p.av6dveLV ecoo"7rep av Cfj,
Kat
/x?) olop.(vov avrco rd yrjpas vovv (\ov TrpocrteVat. epot pey
5 orjrj orjSey dr/tês o?j8' av d?/8es ?J7ro 2coKpdro?js /3acrart(fecrc9at,
dAAd Kat 7rdAat crxeSdi' rt ?/7ricrrdp?jy drt ou 7rept rcorj p,et-
d 6 <T(Kpa.Tr) B T 2
: <ra>KpaTei B e4 trt e? T : el B e 7 rj
B T fy Sauppe
: Adyi^ Sxnrep yeVe secl. Cron Sxrirtp "yeVet secl. :
Schleiermacher al . SiaKey^fifvos fort. secludenda

. . 69 7rau-
etrflaj B irav<re<rdai T
: eiolf Ifnrear) scr. recc. (av add. vet. t) :
e'yU7re'<ret B T
(irply i/j.ir(ffi?v Gitlbauer) a 5 erj ori B a 7 otj T :
B T Stobaeus et tj Ast : b 3 rb rov Stobaeus toD B rovs : : T

b4 avrSi BT
Stobaeus abrb ': avr<j> avrb Orelli
: W

AAXHS i88b
paKmv rjjjuv 6 koyos ecrotro ScoKpdrous TrapovTos, akka Trepl
rjpcov avrQiv. oirep ovv Ae'yco, rb p.ev ipov ovbev KcoAvet c

2coKpdret o-vvbiaTpi(3et.v 6tto)s ovtos (3ov\cTai' AayjfTa b\
rovbe opa ottcos eêi irepl tov tolovtov.
AA. 'Airkovv to y ip,6v, co NtKta, irepl koyo)V ecrriV, et
be /3odAet, oir% ajrkovv akka biirkovv' Kal yap av b6aipi 5

rco cptkokoyos etVat Kal av pLcrokoyos. otov pkv yap
aKovco avbpos irepl aptTrjs bt.akcyop.tvov r) irepi tivos crocpias
o)y akrjdcas ovtos avbpos Kal aiov tcov koyoiv &v Aeyet,
yaipo) vTrepcpvcos, dtcopevos apa tov re kiyovTa Kal tcl d
keyopeva otl ixpk-novTa akkr]kois Kal appoTTovTa ecrrt. Kal
Kop.ibfj uot boKtl plovo~lk6s 6 toiovtos etz>at, appoviav Kak-
kio-rrjv r)ppoo~p.ivos ov kvpav ovbe 7rat8tay opyava, akka rto
ovtl [r}v r)pp.ocrp.ivos ov\ avrbs avrov tov fiiov o~vp.cf)0)vov 5

rots Adyots 7rp6s tcl ipya, dre^ycos 8coptcrrt dAA' ovk lao~Ti,
otojuat 8e ovbe cppvytcrrt ovbe kvbLori, dAA' rjirep p.6vr\ *EA-
krjVLK-q eo~TLV appovia. 6 p.ev ovv tolovtos \aipcLV pe ttolcl
cpOeyyopevos kclI boKelv 6t<oovv cpLkokoyov etrat ovto) crcpo- e
bpa aTTobi\opaL irap clvtov tcl keyopeva 6 8e TavavTia
tovtov irpaTTiov kvnel pe, ocrco av boKrj ap.LVov keyew,
toctovto) pMkkov, Kal 7rotet av boKeXv etrat /mcrdAoyoy.
2o)KpaTovs 8' eyco rcou pev Adycoy ovk epireLpos elpu, akka 5
irpoTepov, cos eotKe, rcoi> epyov iTTCLpdOriv, Kal eKet avrov

rjvpov cllov ovra koyo)v Kakcov Kat 7rdo-rj? Trapprjaias. et 189
ovv Kal tovto eêt, crvp(3ovkopaL Tavbpi, Kal ^Stcrr' b\v
ieTaoip.r)v vtto tov tolovtov, Kal ovk av ay6oip.r)v p.av6d-

vo)v, akka Kal eycb rco 2dAco^t, kv p.6vov TTpoo~ka(3o)v, crvy-
Xcopco* yr)pdcrKO)v yap Trokka bLbdcrKecrdaL ediko) vtto yjprjorGiv 5
povov. tovto ydp poL cruyxcopetrco, dyaQov Kal avrov elvaL
C2 oStos] avrbs Hoenebeek Hissink c6 ai fitffo\dyos (sic) T :
ov fiicrdo\6yos B d 1 to \ey6fj.wa T : -rbv \ty6fj.fvov B et suprascr. T

d2 irpcirovra a.\\r)\ots T : irpeirov ra, 8' oA.A17A.ots B d4 iratdtas T 2
:
iratSetas BT d5 ^rjv ^p/uoffyueVoy ov secl. Badham : r\pixoo~it.tvos ov

secl. Schanz e4 /j.t<ro\ 6yov BT a6 yu<{vov BT :
y
uoV' Par.
1809 rovro BT : tovtw T 2
ffvyxuptl tu> B
i8ga IIAATJ2N02
tov bibdcrKaXoi', iva //?/ bvcrp.adr]s cpaiva>p.aL dr?o<Ss p,av6dvu>v
et be veu>repos 6 bibdcrKoov larai 17 p,t]itu> ev bor] u>v ?/ rt
b dAAo t&v tolovtcov ex^v, ovbev p.0L jU.eA.et. crol ovv, u>
ScoKpares, eyco e7rayyeAAopat Kai 8tdo-Ketv Kai eXeyxtw

ejue ort cw /3ovArj, Kai p,avddveiv ye ort aS eycb otoa* ovrco
otj 7rap e/xoi 8taKetcrai a7r' eKeivqs Trjs r)pepas 17 /uer' epoiS
5 o-wSieKii^weuo-as Kai eocoKas cravTov irelpav dperrjs rjv XPV

bibovat, tov p.eXXovTa oiKatcos bu>creLV. Ae'y' ovv ort trot
cpiXov, p,r]bev Tr)v r)p.Tepav 7/AikiW viroXoyov i:oLovp.evos.

C 22. Ov ra vp.Tepa, wy eoLKev, atrtacrd/xeâ ft?) ot>x
erot/xa etvat Kat crvp.f5ovX.evtw koL crvcrKoireLV.
AT. 'AAA' yperepov br) epyov, u> 2coKpares eVa yap ae

eycoye r)p,u>v ridr]p,L ctk6ttL ovv dvT ep,ov virep tu>v veavi-
5 o-KO)y ort bedfxeOa Trapa Tu>vbe TrvvOdvecrOai, ko.1 crvp.fiovXeve
bLaXey6p,evos tovtols. eyu> piev yap Kal eirikav6dvop,ai rjbt]
Ta 7roAAa bia rr]V fjXiKiav u>v dv biavor]6S> epecrQai Kal av a

av aKovou>' edv be p.Tav dAAot Adyot yeva>VTai, ov irdvv
d p.ep.vr]p,at. vpieXs ovv Aeyere Kat ote'tre 7rpos vp,as avrovs
Ttepi 3>v Trpov6ep.e6a' eyu> 0' aKOXicrop.ai Kal aKovcras av perd
MeXr]criov rovbe TTOLt]cru> tovto otl dv Kat vp.iv boKrj.
2,12. TTeto-re'oi', S> NtKta re Kat Ad\r]s, Avcnp,d)( kol

5 MeAr/ata. a p.ev ovv vvvbr] eTre)(eipr]crap.ev crKOTielv, rives
ol bibacrKaXoL r)pxv Trjs ToiavTrjs 7ratoetas yeyovacriv ?*/ rtVas
dAAov? fteXTiovs Tre-noir]Kap.ev, tcrcos p.ev ov KaK&s c*X V
e eêrdêLv Kal rd Toiavra r)p.ds avTovs' dAA' oXp.ai kol 1)
TOLabe o-k\jsls ets TavTov cpepei, crx^bbv be tl Kal pdXXov e

dpxvs eir] dv. et yap rvyxdvop,ev eiiLcrTdp.evoL otovovv irepL
otl irapayev6p.ev6v rco (3eXrLov 7rotet eKetô to 7rapeyeveT0,
h
7 vir6\oyov Stephanus BT :c 8 0 8e] iav corr.
virb Koyov
Coisl. : idv yt Schanz B T orn. Ars. d3 d 4 wtcrrfov
nal :
pr. T S> viKta re ical Kaxvs ^ T *#**oi Ars. {fx4vroi ci. Smyly) :
KvffifidxV T Ars. Avtrifiaxos B

: wai fie\i)aia B T ****i Ars. {tovtcj! :
ci. Smyly) d6 0 B T Ars. 'd 7 e?x Ars.

: 77 $x ^ B T :
Gz crxeSbv Se'] /co(i o-)xe8o(i') Ars. 63 efrj / secl. Badham

Tvyxdvo/xev ci. Stephanus : iTvyxdvo/xev BT e 4 ^ irapeyeveTo T :
tij' irapeyevovTO B
AAXHS i8ge
Kal TrpocrtTL oloL re ko-p.ev avrb Troielv TrapayLyveadaL eKetW, 5

bfjKov otl avro ye io~p.tv tovto ov ixkpi o"Vfxftov\oi av yevoL-
p.eda ws av tls avTo paaTa Kal apior av KTr]o~aLTo. io~(os
ovv ov p.av6dveT p.ov otl Ae'yco, dAA' <58e paov p.a6r]o~eo-6e:.
et Tvy\dvop.ev iTCLo-TapLivoL otl 6\(/ls Trapayevop.tvr] ocpdak- 190

p.ols /3eAriow 7rotet (KeLvovs dls 7raoeyeVero, Kal irpoo-eTL
0I0L t ecrp.\v TTOLelv avTi]V TrapayLyveo-daL 6p.p.ao~L, bfjkov

otl o\}/lv ye lo-p.v avTi)v 6Vt ttot co-tlv, fjs irkpL o"Cp.$ov\oL
av yevoLp.(6a cos dv tls avTi]V pacrTa koX dpLo~Ta KTrfcravro. 5
et yap /xr/8' avrb tovto etSetjuer, ort ttot <-o~tlv 6\j/ls t/ otl
io-Tiv czko?/, o-x_oAr/ av o-vp.(iovkoL ye a<fiot Ao'you ycvoLp.ti6a

Kal tarpot ?/ 7rept 6cp6akp.G>v rj 7rept wtwv, ovTLva Tpoirov
clkoi]v ?/ oxffLV KaAAtar' av KTr]o~aLTo tls. t>
AA. 'AAr/c9r/ Ae'yet?, & 2toKoares.

212. Ovkovv, a> Adxr]s, Kal vvv r/juds rco8e 7rapaKaAetroi>
et? crvp.(3ov\,f]v, tLv av Tpoirov tols vko-LV avrGtv dpCTi]
TTapayvop.vt] rat? ^/v\als dp.eLvovs 7rotr/o-ete; 5

AA. Yldvv ye.
212. 'Ao' ovv f]pXv tovto y vTrdpxaLv 8et, ro et8eVai ort
Tror' Hcttlv apaTr]; et ydp ttov /jtr/8' dp(Ti]V et8et//.er to
TTapdirav otl 7rore Tvy\dveL 6v, t'lv av Tpo-rrov tovtov
o-vp.(3ovX.oL yerot/jte^' dv 6t(oovv, otto^s dv avrb KaAAtcrra C
KTijaaLTo;
AA. Ov8eVa, e/xotye 8oKet, 2 2coKoare:?.
212. <t>ap.tv dpa, a> Adx>]S, et8eVat airo ort eoriu.

AA. <J>auei/ /xeVrot. 5
212. OrjKouy o ye lcrp.V, Kav et7rotuei> br]irov tL (cttlv.
e7 &phtt' &j/ BT : &pio-Ta scr. recc. e8 fjLaQfoeo-Oe B T2 :
T
IxaQ^fftcrGai a1 T : om. B a4 h ri ttot T : B
ir6r' :
ti suprascr. B T B a
2
a6 tlSdrnxev B'
2
: efSe/rj /ief 7 <rxoA^
BT a8 /col /oTpol secl. Badham b5 to?s tyvxaTs BT : ras
^Xs Vat. 1029 b7 '6ri B T
^?v Ars. om. B T tj Ars.
: :
b 9 tiV ap Ars. TtVa B T : C 1 yevoifi.cO' av Ars. yevoifieda B T :
av post oVa>y B T : post KaKXiffra Ars. outo Ars. : oiit^ B T

C 3 ou8Va] oiiHtv Ars. C 4 5 Aox^s tlStvat outo] outo 5 Aox 7? 5
etSerat Ars. C5 <pajxtv fiivrot om. Ars.
I9oC 11AATX2N02
AA. n<3? yap ov;
2X2. Mt) Toivvv, oo dptore, Trepl okrjs apeTrjs ev0eois
o-KoiTOip.e0a <irkeov yap lcrois epyov dAAd p.epovs tivos
J irtpi irpGiTov Xboop.ev ei iKavobs exop.ev irpbs to elbevar Kal
d rjpuv, b)s to (Ikos, paoov r) o-Kexjns eorat.
AA. 'AAA' ovtoj iroiG)p.V, a> HwKpares, cos o~v /3ovkei.
2X2. Tt ovv av 7rpoekoip.e0a tG>v rrjs dperfjs p.epG>v; r)
bfjkov br) otl tovto els 6 reiveiv boKel r) ev tols oirkoLS
5 p,d0r] o- is ; boKeX be ttov toXs ttoXXois ds dvbpeiav. rj ydp;

AA. Kat p.dka brj ovtoo boKel.
2X2. Touro toLvvv irpGiTov TTL)(Lpr)croip.ev, & -^"X 7? 5
et7reu', avbpeia ti ttot ecrriv' eVetra /xerd tovto o-Key\r6p.e0a
e Kai otoj av rpoTroj rot? veavio~KOLS irapayevoLTO, Kat9' ocrov

oXov re e eTTLT-qbevp.drojv re Kat p.a0r)p.dTOJV Trapayevecr0aL.
dkkd 7reip<3 elireXv b keyoo, ti eoriv avbpeia.
AA. Ov p.a tov Ata, a> 2wKpare?, ov x a^ e7rov *fa*&'
5 et ydp rts 0ekoL ev Trj rdet p.evojv ap.vvecr0aL tovs iroke-
p.iovs /cat p.77 (pevyoi, ev lcr0i otl dyopeto? b\v eXrj.
212. ES ju,ey Ae'yet?, co Adx^s* dAA' io-a>s eyoj atrto?,
ov craqb&s eliroiv, to cre aTTOKpivao-0at p.f) tovto 6 biavoov-

p.evos r)p6p.rjv, dAA' erepov.
io AA. n<S? roCro Ae'yet?, u> 2coKpares;
191 212. 'Eyco qbpdcroi, eav oXos re ye.voip.ai. avbpelos ttov
ovtos, 6v Kal o~h Ae'yet?, o? dy ev rfj rdet p.evu>v p.dyr\Tai
tois TTo\ep.iois.
AA. 'Eyco yorw cpr)p.i.
5 2X2. Kat ydp eyco. dAAd rt av obe, os av cpevyojv

p.dyr]Tai rots TTokep.iois dkkd p.i] p.evmv;
AA. Ilcos' cpevyoiv;
Cio iSufiev BT
Ars. effiw/tevB
2
: d 2 &A\'] a** Ars. wj <ru]
S7Ts av (teste Blass) Ars. d 8 /xe-ra] rb /tero Ars. e 3 rl
effriu avopeia] rbv wopeiov Ars. e 5 tovs~\ tos Ars. e 7 eS
BT: Ka\ws Ars. as raêt Ars. a4 eîi 7' o5/ B : eywy
,
ovv T a6 fjLaxQTai toIs Tro\efj.iois] ro7s iro\e/tio<s fit&xVTai Ars.

AAXH2 igia
2X2. "X2cr7rep ttov koI 'SkvBcli kiyovrai ovx rjrrov cpev-

yovTcs rj biaiKovTes p.d\zo-6aL, Kal "Op.r]p6s ttov iiraLV&v
tovs tov AlveCov lttttovs Kpaiirva p.dk' evda Kal 4v6a 10
((pr) avTovs TTLo-Tacr6at. bia>KLV r)S <pefieo-6ai.' Kal avrbv b

tov Alveiav KaTa tovt eyeKcoptacre, /cara ttjv tov (pofiov
(TTLo-TtjpLrjv, Kal et7re/v avTov eii/at p.r)o-T(jopa (pofioLO.
AA. Kat KaAcos ye, co 2coKpares* 7rept app.aT(ov yap
eAeye. Kat a-v to t&v 2ktj0cou lttttôov 7re'pt Aeyets* to p.\v 5
yap Ittttlkov [to e/cetfcoy] ovrco p.ay*TaL, to oe d7rAtrtKdi> [to

ye rcoi> 'Ekkfjvcov], co? eyco Ae'yco.
2X2. rtAryy y' tcrcos', co Ad^T]?, rd AaKe8at/xomW. AaKe-

baLp.ov(ovs ydp cpao-Lv ei> nAaratat?, e7rei8?/ 7rpos rots c
yeppocpopoLS kykvovTO, ovk e0e'Aeti> p,kvovras irpbs avTovs
v
pdxecrflat, dAAd (pevytLV, e7ret8? / 8' Zkvdrjo-av al rdcfets
rcoy Ylzpo-G>v, dvao-Tp<pop.t:vovs coo-7rep t7r7re'as /udêcrcât
Kat ovrco VLKrjo-aL ttjv eKet p.dyr]v. 5

AA. 'Ak-qdr) Aeyets.
2X2. Touro tolvvv b dprt ikeyov, otl eyco atrtos /x?/
KaAco? o*e aTT0KpLvacr6aL, ort ov KaAcos r)p6p.rjv (3ovk6p.evos
ydp aov TTv6ia6aL p.r) p.6vov tovs iv rco o7rAtrtKco avbpcCovs, d

dAAd Kal tovs iv rco i7r7UKco Kat t)v o~vp.TravTL rco 7roAeptKco
et8et, Kai /at/ p.6vov tovs Iv rco 7roAe/xco, dAAd Kat rovs ey
rots 7rpo? rqv ddkarrav KLvbvvoLS dvbpdovs ovras, Kat ocrot
ye 7rpds iwous Kat ocrot 7rpds Trevias r) Kat 7rpds rd 7roAtrtKa 5
dvbptLOL etVty, Kat ert aS p.r) p.6vov dcrot 7rpds Au7ras dvbptloi
a8 irou] iroT Ars. b 3 eh ai]

in hac voce redit b 5 ab W
to BT W Ars. : crb a3 to Stallbaum
ci. b 6 rb iiceivwv om. Ars.
(secluserat Badham) t6 ye ruv 'E\\i)vwv om. Ars. b 8 Aae-
Sai/xoviovs BTW toi5toi>s Ars. C 1 (pafftv B (prjfftv compendio W
W
: :
T iv irKaratals BT : icai irXarei . . . Ars. (Ka\ Tl\aTatao ,
i ci.
W
I .
Diels )
1
c 2 avTobs b aiiTojj BT 03 (\v6rjo-av BT :
W
:
f\r)\vdei(rav C7 o apTi Ars. (apri coniecerat Ast) alTtov

W
:
BT W c8 i)p6nr}v] o-e ijpo/xTjv Ars. d1 700 aov B Ars. :
yap T tows] tos Ars. d.2 ical iv~\ ev tui Ars. d.4 kivSvvois
B TW:
2
kivDvvovs B: KtvSvvevovcri Ars. d. 5 *ye] re Ars.
d 6 Ti W Ars. : 6't BT avSpeloi etcriv r) (poflovsl r) cpofiovs avtipetoi
eiatv Ars.
igid I1AATX2N02
eicrti; r) (frofiovs, dXXd nal Trpos TTLdvp,ias r) r)hovas htLVol
e ixayjea-Oai, nal peVorres Kal dvacrTpeqjovTes aicrl ydp ttov
tlvcs, d> Ad)(r]s, nal kv toIs tolovtols dvhpcloL

AA. Kat acpohpa, 2> 2coKpares.
2X2. Ovkovv dvhpaloL p.(\v Trdvres ovroi tlcriv, aAA' ol
5 piev kv rjhovais, ol o' kv XvrraLs, ol o' kv k-mQvp.iais, ol ti* kv

<p6(3oLS rrjv dvhpdav Ke/crrjirrai* 61 ht- y otpat heikiav iv
Tots aVTols TOVTOLS.
AA. Hdvv ye.
2X2. Ti TTOTt ov kmTepov tovtu>v; tovto (TrvvOavop.rjv.
io 7rdX.LV ovv 7retpco zIttv.v dvhpaiav irpG>Tov ri ov ev irdcrL
tovtols Tavrov iariv 7] ovttco KaTap.av6dvLs 6 Aeyco;

AA. Ov Trdvv tl.
ig2 2X2. 'AAA' <58e Ae'yco, (Zmrep dv et Taxps r)p(oTcov t'l ttot
koriv, b Kal eV rco TptytLV TvyydvtL ov rjpuv Kal kv r<5
KiOapi^LV Kal eV rco Aeyetr Ka\ t\v tQ> p.av0dvLV Kal kv

aAAois ttoAAois, Kat cryjhov tl avro KKTr)p.0a, ov Kal 7re'pt
5 d^Lov X(-yLV, r\ kv tols tu>v xeipcoi> 7rpa<fecru> 77 <TKeA<3i> r\
o~Top.aT6s re Kat (pojvfjs r) hLavoias' rj ov\ ovrco Kat o~v Aeyets;

AA. Yldw ye.
2X2. Et Toivvv rtspe epotro" "'X2 2coKpares, t'l Ae'yeis

10 tovto 6 kv iracrLv ovop.d&Ls TayvTrJTa etrat; " tiiroLpf dv
b atrco ort Tr)v iv dAtyco \povoi rroXXa hLaTTpaTTopvr)v hvvap.iv
rayyrrJTa eycoye KaAco Kat 7repi (po)vr]v Kal 7rept hpop.ov Kat
7repl raAAa mdvTa.
AA. 'Opfloos ye crv Xtiyoiv.
5 2X2. ITeipco hr) kcu trv, co Adyr)s, rt]v dvhpziav ovtojs
ei al ante /xevovres om. Schanz (sed habet Ars.) kcu post

iievovres Kral (et sic Ars. ut videtur") : ^ BT W 03 na\ o-<p6Spa]
cr(p6Spa ye Ars. 6 4 avSptTot fiev -rdvres ovroi] avSpetai /xev -ravres
ovroi avSpeioi Ars. e 6 f/crTjrTOt Schanz (sed KeKTrjvrai Ars. cum
B T W) SeiKiav : T W
SejA.ioi' B
eg t>v] ovv Ars. (et mox e 10)
e-rvv0av6/j.7]v] irwQaviô^.ai) Ars. e 10 avSpeiav] rijv avSpeiav Ars.
&2 rpexav] rpex* Ars. a3 r T6 twi /j.av9ave([ivy Ars. a6 ?)
Siorofos om. ut videtur Ars. (^ vo-finar6s re yuo pro ^ <TT6fnar6s re ci.
Diels)
AAXH2 i 9 2b
el-nelv tCs ovara bvvap.LS f) avTi] ev fjbovfj kol ev kvTrrj nal

iv &Tracnv oXs vvvbr) ekeyop.ev avTr]v eXvai, eirevra dvbpeCa
KiKkr]Tai.
AA. AoKet toCvvv p.0L KaprepCa tls eXvai rrjs \jrv)(rjs, ei
to ye bia irdvTcov [irep\ dvbpeCas] ire<pvK.bs bel eiTrelv. C

2X2. 'AAAa p.f)v beX, et ye to epo>T<ap.evov aTroKpLvovp.e6a
fjpuv avTols. tovto toCvvv epotye <paCveTaL' ovtl ird<rd ye,
s eyZ>p.aL, KaprepCa dvbpeCa o-ol (patrerat. TCKp.aCpop.aL be
evOevbe' <r\ebbv ydp tl otba, S> Ad)(i]s, otl tS>v irdvv KakCov 5
npaypMTcov i)yfj crv dvbpeCav eXvaL.
AA. ES piev ovv l<t6l otl tS>v KakkCcrTtov.
2X2. Ovkovv f] p.ev p.Ta <ppovr]<recos Kaprepta Kakf]
KayaOr];
AA. Yldvv ye. xo
2X2. Tt 8' r/ p.er d(ppocrvvr]s; ov TovvavrCov ravTr] d

/3Aa/3epa Kat KOKovpyos;
AA. Nat.
2X2.Kakbv ovv tl <pr]<reLS <rv eXvaL to tolovtov, ov
KOKovpyov re Kat /3Aa/3epoV; 5
AA. Ovkovv bUaLov ye, S> 2toKpares.
2X2. Ovk apa rrjv ye TOLavrrjv KaprepCav dvbpeCav ouoAoyr/-
0-eis etyai, e7retr/7rep ov Kaki] ecrrLV, f) be dvbpeCa Kakov ccttlv.
AA. 'Akr]6r} keyeLs.
2X2. 'H (f>p6vLp.os dpa KapTepCa Kara tov crbv koyov 10
dvbpeCa dv etr].
v
AA. EoiKe*\
2X2. "\bo>p,ev br), f) els tC cppoVtuoj; f) f) els a-navTa kol e
Ta ueydAa k<x\ tcl <rp.LKpd; dlov et rts Kaprepet dvakCcrKcov
dpyvpLov (ppovCpxtis, eibo>s ort dvak<a<ras irkeov eKTr]<reTaL,
tovtov dvbpelov Kakols dv;
C 1 irtpl avfjptlas secl. Badham c 2 ye post Se? fort. transpo-

nendum c3 otiri BT W 3tl scr. recc. oti otiri Schanz
^ 011
: :
ei BT: ^W ea Kaprtpe? BT W Kaprepo? vulg. e 3 ir\cov

W
:
*KT{\aiTai B : irAeoyfK-rtjo-era: T
ig2e nAATONOS
5 AA. Ma At" ovk eycaye.
212. 'AAA' olov et rts tarpos o)V, TTepLirkevp.ovLq tov
vios kypp,ivov r) akkov tlvos kol beop.ivov melv r) <payeti>
193 hovvai, p.r) Kapt.TTTOi.TO dkka /caprepot;
AA. Qib' ottojo-tlovv ovb' avrt).
212. 'AAA' kv 7roAe'u<j> Kaprepovvra dvbpa Kal idikovra

p.dyecr6aL, <ppovip.o)S koyL^6p.evov, elbora p.<-v otl fiorjOr)-
5 o-ovo-lv dkkoL avT<2, irpbs ikdrTOvs be Kal (pavkoripovs

uaxetrat r\ ue#' <av avros <ttlv, ert 8e \u>pLa eêt Kpeirra),
tovtov rbv p.eTa Trjs TOLavT-qs <ppovr)o-eo)s Kal Trapao-Kevrjs
KapTepovvra avbpeLorepov av <paLr)s r) tov iv t<2 ZvavTLu
orparo7re'8a) idikovra vTrop.iveLv re Kat Kaprepelv;
b AA. Tbv iv ra> ivavrL<o, euotye SoKet, 0) 2a>Koares.

212. 'AAAa p.r)v dcppovecrTipa ye r) tovtov r\ r) tov eripov
KapTtpia.
AA. 'AkqOr} kiyeis.
5 212. Kat tov p.T eiricm/ujjs apa lttttlktjs KaprepovvTa
Iv L7TTTop.a\Lq rJTTOv <pr/o-eis avbpetov etrat r) tov avev
iTTLO-Tf)p.r]S.
y
AA. Euotye 8oKet.
212. Kat tov p.Ta <T<pvbovr)TLKT]S r) tolkt}s rj dkkrjs

10 tlvos rexyris KaprepovvTa.
C AA. Udvv ye.
212. Kat 00-01 dv ZdikoxrLV et? (ppiap KaTafiaLvovTts koX
Kokvp./3<avTS Kaprepelv kv tovt<o t<o epya), p,r) ovres beivoL,

r) ev tlvl akkoi tolovto), avbpcLOTepovs (pf)creLs t&v raura
5 b(iLV(2v.
AA. Tt yap av tls akko <paLr), S) 2<oKpares;

212. Ovbiv, eXirep ololto ye ovtoos.
AA. 'AAAa p.r)v otuat ye.

2X2. Kat pf)v ttov d(ppovecrTipo)s ye, <o Aayjis, ol tolovtol
a2 avTi) T W : aiir-fi B bg yuera W /xev /xera BT C 2 av

W
:
B : &iu/ TW : S^ Schanz (qui mox Z64\ovtriv) iQtXvcnv :
iOfXovaiv BT
AAXH2 193 c
Ktvbvvevovcriv re koX KapTepovcriv r) ol /uerd Te\vrjs ai)To 10

TTpa.TTOVTS.
AA. <t>a(vovrai.
2X2. Ovkovv al&xpa rj acppa>v rdA/ua re Kat Kapre/arrcris d

eV rco rrpocrdev ecpdvrj r)pZv ovcra Kal (Bkaj3epd;
AA. ITdw ye.
2X2. 'H 8e ye avbpeia co/otoAoyetro KaAoV rt etvat.
AA. 'X2/ôAoyetro ydp. 5

2X2. Nvv 5' aS 7rdAti> cpap.ev eKeXvo ro aicry^pov, tt)v
dcppova KapTeprjcriv, avbpeiav elvai.

AA. 'EotKa/uter.
2X2. KaAcos ow crot boKovp.ev keyeiv;

AA. Ma r6i> At", co 2coKpare?, e/xot /xeu ov. io
2X2. Ovk apa ttov Kara tov crbv koyov Scoptcrrt fjpfxo-
crp.e6a eyco re Kat crrj, co Adxr??' ra ydp epya ov crvfjicpcavet q

r)pXv rots Ao'yots. epyco y.ev ydp, cos eotKe, cpatrr av rts
?//ixay dvbpeias p,eTeyeiv, Aoyco ', cos eyco//at, ovk dy, et vvv
r)p.a>v aKowcrete biakeyop.evu>v.
AA. 'AAr/flecrrara Aeyety. 5
2X2. Tt ovv; boKel Kakbv eXvai ourcos r/juas 8taKetcr0ai;
AA. Otj8' 67rcocrrtow.
2X2. BorJAet ovv co keyop.ev 7ret0cop.e0a ro ye rocroSroy;

AA. T6 770101 8r) rouro, Kai rtii tovtcd;
2X2. Tco Ao'ycp bs Kaprepeiv Kekevei. et ovj; /3orJAet, Kat 194
57/xets e7rt rr/ (fr/rr/cret eTnp.eivcop.ev re Kat Kaprepr/ crcopev, ti>a
Kat pr) 7/jucoy avrr/ 7/ d?;8peia KarayeAdcn/, ort ovk avbpeicos

avT7]v (fT/ro{)juev, et dpa 7roAAaKts avn) r/ Kapreprjcris ecrTtv
dvbpeia. 5
AA. 'Eyco /uer erot/xos, co 2coKpares, p.77 irpoacpicrTacrOat,.
Katrot d?/0r]s y' et/xt rcoz> rotorjrcoy Adycozr dAAd rts />te Kat
d3 irdVi/ 7 BT: om. W

d.4,5 w/xo\oyt7ro (bis) B: wjj.o\6yriTo
TW 64 d/cowreje Jacobs aKovcrei B T W e8 Trei6<&/ji(da
W
:
B T Kei66/u.eda
: a 2 ttj B T om. W a 3 avr^ T : avri)
W
:
a#T7j B a6 tToitxos T trolixws B W : a 7 d^07js 7' T:

W
:
7' d^Tjs dArjflrfc 7' B

:
194 a riAAT&NOS
c/jtAoviKia eiA?/<pe/J Ttpos ra etp?/p,eVa, Kal <as dA?/0o>s dya-
b vaKrGi et ovrajo-t a ro3 /xr/ otds r' etp.i et7reu\ yoety uei>
ydp euotye 8oko> 7rept dvbpeias ort o~tlv, ovk olba 8' o7n/
ue dprt bL<pvyv, dVre u?/ o-?jAAa/3eu> rai Adya> avTi]v Kal

LTTLV OTL <TTLV.
5 212. Ovkow, 2> <pt'Ae, roi> dyadbv KVvr\yTr\v ueraêtf
XP?) Kat u?) a.VLvaL.

AA. Ilai>ra7rao-i pez> oSv.
212. Boi/Aet ovy Kat NtKtay Tovbe 7rapaKak<2p.v ttl to

Kwr\y<TLov, et rt r)p,<ov e?J7ropa>repds <ttlv;
c AA. BovAo/xat* 7ra)s ydp ov;
v
212. It9t 8?/, a NiKta, avbpacrL cptAots \Lp.aopvoLS kv
Adya) Kat a7ropo?jo"t7J j3oj}0r)<rov, et r>a \LS bvvap.LV. tcl
v
p.\v yap 8? / 7/ue'repa dpas a>s a-ropa' rru 8' et7rd>y ort rjyf]
5 avbp^Cav eu>ai, ?7uds re r?/s d-ropias eKAua-at Kat avrds a

roets ra> Adya> /3e/3ai'a>o-ai.
NI. AoKetre tolvvv uot 7rdAat od KaAais, a> 2a>Kpares,

6pt'eo-0ai rrjv avbpLav 6 ydp eya> oo?3 ?/8?/ KaAais Aeyoyros
aKr/Koa, rovra) ov \pr)<r6.
io 2X2. riota) 8?/, a NtKta;
d NI. IIoAAdKts aK?/Kod oou Aeyovros ort raura ayados
Kao~TOS r)p.<2v aircp <ro<p6s, a 8e ap.a6r)s, raiira 8e KaKos.
2X2. 'AXrjdr) ueVrot vr) Ata Aeyets, a) NtKta.
NI. Ovkow et7rep 6 di>8petbs dyaflds, brjXov drt o~o<pos
5 <TTLV.
212. "HKOuoas, a> Adx??s;

v
AA. Eya)ye, Kat ov a<f>6bpa ye p:av6dvio 6 Aeyet.
212. 'AAA' eya> 8oko> p.av6dvLv, Kai uot SoKet dr?jp
<ro<piav TLva rr)v avbpciav \iyLV.

io AA. Ilotay, a> 2a)Kpares, <ro<piav;
e 2X2. 0?jko?ji; rdr8e rouTo epooras;
C5 %K\v<rai TW : t\Kv(rai B et yp. t C6 fiefiaicixrai T W :
fc&aiacrat B C 7 /to( B W : /*e T d8 aviip Bekker : av^p

BTW
AAXH2 i 94 e
AA. "Eycoyt.
2X2. "16l bi], avTco et7re', 5> NtKia, iroia crocfiia dvbp^Ca av
etr/ Kara tov crbv koyov. ov ydp ttov rj ye arjAr/riKT/.
NI. Ovbap&s. 5
212. Ovbe p.i]V r/ KidapicrTiKr].
NI. Ov brjra.
2X2. 'AAAd rts br) avrt] r) tCvos e7Ttcrr?///,r/;
AA. Ilayu p.tv ovv 6p0S>s avrbv epcoras, co ^coKpares,

Kal et7re'rco ye r>a (pt]cr\v avrr)v tlvai. io
NI. TavrTji' eycoye, co Ad\r]s, rrjy rcorj 8eti<3y fcat 6ap-
paAeW TTicrTi]p.r]v Kal kv 7roAe'/xcp Kal Iv toIs akkois diiacnv. 195
AA. 'X2? aro7ra Ae'yet, a 2coKpares.
2X2. Tlpbs tC tovt ei7res' /3k\j/as, o> Ad)(r]s;
K
AA. IIpos ort; x.-p s fiyirov croc/ua ZcttIv
- avbpeCas.
2X2. Ovkovv (pt]crC ye NtKta?. 5
AA. Otj /xeVrot /xd Ata* Tavrd rot Kat Ar/pei.
2X2. OtjkotjV 8t8dcrKco/xei' avrbv dAAd /xr/ Xoi,bopa>p.V.
NI. Otjk, dAAa /xot SoKet, co 2coKpares, Adxr/s kin6vp.iiv

mp. (pavrjvai /xr/8ev Ae'yoi>ra, ort Kat arjros dpTi tolovtos
rts cqbdvr]. b
AA. ITdyrj p\kv ovv, co NtKta, Kat 7reipdcro/xai ye d-rocprjvaL'
ovb\v yap Aeyeis. e7ret avrtKa eV rat? rdcrot? otjx ot tarpot
rd 8eu>d kirCcrTavTaL; 77 01 drSoetoi Sokotjcti crot knCo-Tacrdai;

rj tovs larpovs crv avbpcCovs KaAeis; 5
NI. Otj8' o7rcocrrtow.
AA. Or38e ye rorjs yecopyorjs ot/xat. KaCroi rd ye ei>
rr) yecopyta 8eti>d orjrot or/7rorj e7rtcrrayrat, Kat 01 dAAot

8r///torjpyot aTrayres rd eV rats arjrcoy TX.vais Setrjd re Kal
#appaAe'a lcracnv' dAA' orjSeV rt /xdAAoy orjrot drSpetot C
etcr\
e8^W:^B:^T a 2 \lpi b : \4yus BT (?) W a 4 gn

Par. 1813 ti BTW &] SjSaVKavue' t: SiSdaKO/xev BTW
TW
:
b1 tis : om. B
PLATO, VOL. III. 6
195 c nAATilNOS
212. Tt 5oKet A&xr)S Xiyf.iv, co NtKia; eoiKez> /ueWot
Aeyetr rt.
5 NI. Kat yap Aeyet ye' rt, ov p.kvToi akrj6is ye.

2X2. IIcos 8?/;
r/
NI. Ort oterat tovs tarpot/s Tikeov ti elbivat. 7rept rovs
Kd[xvovTas r) to vyieivbv "fenrety oiojv re Kat *voo"co8es. ol 5e
brJTTov toctovtov \iovov lcracriv et 8e SetôV rcp roCro' ecrrtz>
10 ro vyiaiv(.w pukkov ?/ ro Kapweiv, f]yr\ crv tovtC, cb Aax?/s,

tovs iarpovs ZiricrTacrdai; t] ov irokkois otet eK r?/s vocrov
ap.et.vov etivat p,?/ avacrTrjvat. ?*/ avacrTfjvat,; tovto yap elire'
d ot> 7racrt </j?)s ap.et.vov et/vai rjv koI ov nokkols KpeiTTOv

Tedvdvat;
AA. Otjuai eycoye tovto ye.
NI. Ots ouy re0*>cu>at Auo-treAei, Tavra otet 6etâ eimt
5 Kat ots f]v;
AA. Ovk eycoye.
NI. 'AAAa rouro br) crv bibuts rots tarpots yiyvcoo-Keiy
?/ aAAcp rtjvt brjp.Lovpy^ Trkr)v rco rcoy 8etrcoi> Kat /x?/ Set^cbjv
e7rtcrr?//xoyi, 6i> eyco dvbpelov KaAcb;

10 2X2. Kararoets, co Adx?7S, ort Ae'yet;
e AA. "Eycoye, ort ye rot>s /udrrets KaAet roi/s dySpetoTJS'
rts yap br) dkkos etcrerat orco ap.et.vov Cv v V TedvdvaL;
Katrot crv, co NtKta, TTOTepov opokoyels pdvTLS elvai ?/ ovre
p.avTis ovt avbpelos;
5 NI. Tt 8e'; /u,dWet av otet Trpocrf]KeL rd 8eti>d ytyvcocrKeii>
Kat rd dappakea;
AA. "Eycoye* rtyt ydp dAAco;
NI. *X2t eycb Ae'yco 7roAu p.dkkov, a> /SeÂrto-re' e7ret
C8 etVeTj/] fort. TrojejV uireiv olov secl. Badham ofoV re] oldV
ti ci. Stephanus C9 8fj7rouTotroOrov Hermann : 8?; tj too-outoj'
87j7roi; W BT : 8r) to tooovtov 8jj7tou ci. Madvig Setv6v Ttp T W :
B
Sejj^b tS) d3 oiTtoj BW: om. T d.4 touto scr. recc. :
tooto B T W d. 7 tooto T W : toD B d 8 kclI fir] Setvwv

B W om. T : CI9 SrBW: olov T es irpoo-r)Kti B : irpoo-fjKav
T : Trpoo~rJKtv W
:
AAXH2 195 e
fxdvTiv ye ra cri]p,eia povov 8et yiyv(aaKiv tS>v ecrop.zv(ov,

etre ra> OavaTos etre voaos etre aTroftoKr) \pr]p.dTo>v ecrrat, 10
etre >vtK?7 etre ?^rra 17 TTok4p.ov r) Kal dXkrjs Tivbs ayoovias- 196
6'rt 8e' ro) dpet/VO/V tovtcov ?/ TtaOelv ?/ ju?j iradrfv, t( p.d\\ov
IxavTei TrpocnJKd. Kpivai r) dAAcp 6t(oovv;

AA. 'AAA' eyco rovrou ov p.av6dvo>, > ScoKpare?, drt ftov-
Aerat Aeyetv oure ydp p.dvTLV ovt larpov ovt dkkov ovbeva 5
8r?Aot ovTLva Ae'yet rov dvbpziov, et p.77 et 0ebV rtâ Ae'yet

avrbv (tvai. epot /xey ow (patVerat NtKtas otjk etVAeiu
yzvvaiois 6/xoAoyetr ort ou8ei> Ae'yet, dAAd orpe'</!)erai ai>a> b
Kat Karto 7TLKpvTTT6p.evos Tr)v avrov airopiav' Katrot Kar
?//xets otot re ?/pe/V dprt eyco re Kat 00/ rotaura crrpe'cpecr0ai,
et e/3ovAo'pec9a p?/ 8oKeii> evavTia 11p.1v avrois Ae'yet7>. et
p.e/V ow ey 8tKao-r?/pia) r//xt^ ot Ao'yot ?/o"a/V, etêy di> rt/va 5
Xoyov ra?3ra 7rotety vvv 8e rC dv tls iv crvvovcriq rotaSe

p.aTi]v Kevois Aoyots avros ai/Tov KOo~p.oi;
2X2. Ovbev ovb' epot 8oKet, co Ad^s* dAA' 6pG>p.tv p.r) C

NtKtas oteraf 1
rt Ae'yeti> Kat ou Adyou i-veKa ravra Ae'yet.

aiiroS ovv cracpioTepov TTvd(op.eda tl ttotc vocl" Kal kdv tl
(paLvrjTaL Ae'ycor, crvyyjj>pr]cr6p.e6a, et 8e //?/, 8t8d<fdp;ei\
AA. 2i/ rou>i>/V, co 2<oKpares, et /3ovAet nvvddvecrdai, 5
-rvvddvov eyoo 8' to-cos iKa/V<3s 7re'/TVcrp.at.
212. 'AAA' ovSeV /xe KtoAver Kotj/r) ydp eorat ?/ ttvcttls
vircp epou re Kat ctotj.
AA. nd/vu /xey ovy.
212. Ae'ye 8?/ /jtot, co NtKta /xdAAoy 8' ?//jtty KOLVovpitda 10
ydp eya) re xat Adxrjs tov Koyov r?/y avbpziav iTTLcrT )]p.r]v
,
d
<p?/s bcLV&v re Kat dappaXicov etyat;
v
NI. Eycoye.
212. Tovro 8e ov iravTos br) etrat dvbpos yvGtvaL, ottotz
a4 tovtov Schanz : tovto BT W : tovtov Bekker a5 h&vtiv

TWb: M /B b6 8eTi'TW: SertB C 1 ovi' tfiol T W
ovSf /xoi B 2 oUtm T : oJfr/Tat Wb : oXoiTai B ou T W :
ovB
6*
ig6 d nAATX2N02
5 ye WT larpbs /J.?/re p.dvTLs clvto yvaxreraL p.r]be dvbpelos
ecrrat, iav p.r) avTi]V TavTr\v Tr)v e7riaTT/ju?77J 7rpoo~kdfir]' ov\
ovtcos eAeyes;
NI. Orjrco fxkv ovv.
2X2. Kara r7)7J napoip.iav dpa tio ovti ovk clv Trdcra vs
io yvoir] ovb' av dvbpeia yivovro.
NI. Ov piOL 8oKet.
e 2X2. Aijkov br], a> NtKia, ort ovbe ti)v Kpop.pvcoviav vv

incrTevus o~v ye dvbpeiav yeyovevaL. rouro be Ae'yw otj
TraCijLov, dkk avayitaTov oTp.aL rco rarjra AeyoTJrt p.r]bevbs

6t]piov airobtytcrOai dvbpeiav, i) crrjyxcopetTJ 6t]piov rt orjrco
5 crocpbv elvai, cocrre a dAtyot dvdpcoTrcov tcracri 8ta ro j(aAe7ra

etrjat yvcoTJai, ravra keovra 77 7rdpbaX.LV 7/ rtra naTrpov cpavai
etSeVat* dAA.' dvdyKi] 6/xotcos keovra kcll ekacpov kol Tavpov
Kal TTL$r]Kov rrpbs dvbpeiav (pdvau TrecpvKevaL tov TL&ep.evov
avbpeiav tov6' orrep trv TidetraL.
197 AA. Nt) rorjs 6eovs, Kai ev ye Aeyeis, co 2coKpares*. fcal
?/ju.t7J cos dkrjdtos tovto CLTTOKpLvaL, S) Ni/aa, iroTepov trotpto-
repa c/>t)s t//xcoi' rarjra etyat ra 6r]pia, a 7ra7Jres dp.okoyovp.tv
dvbpela etTJat, t/ TrdcrLV evavTLOvp.evos Tokp.as p.r]be dvbpela

5 arjra KaAetTj;
NI. Orj yap rt, co Aaxr/s, eytoye dvbpela Kakta orjre tfrrpta
orjre dXko ovbev rb tcl beLva virb dvoias p.i) tpo/3ovp.evov,
dkk' atpofiov Kat puopov r) koX tcl iraibia Trdvra otet p.e
b dvbpela Kakelv, a 81' dvoLav ovbev beboLKev; dkk' otp.at rb
a<po/3o7J Kat to avbpelov ov ravrov o~tlv. eyco be dvbpeias
piev Kal Trpop.r]6ias Trdvv tlctlv okiyois ot/uat /xeretyat, 6pa-
e 1 Kpoixjjivwviav BT Kpufj.voviav W Kpo/xvuviav ci. Stallbaum

W
: :
e2 ffv ye T : eS B
76 a 1 nal eS] incipit papyrus Oxy. ye
om. Oxy. &2
ir6rtpov] (iro)rtpa suprascr. (0)1/ Oxy. o~o<pd>-
repa . . ao^-bwrfpa i)jxw)v ravra (ra 77/)ia raj <j3)tjs Oxy.
. flrjpia]
a6 (w) Xoxt?s post 70)76 ut videtur Oxy. a7 ouSev om. ut
videtur Oxy. tc\] ras Oxy. aô/as] ayvoias Basileensis altera
(lacuna in Oxy.) a8 Kal fiwpov secl. Gitlbauer (sed Kai habet
iani Oxy. in fine versus) b 1 5i* &votav yp. Siayvoiav t BTW:
(in Oxy. nihil praeter vo av) . . . .
AAXH2 i 97 b
cnrn/ros* be kcu To\p.r]s kcu tov dcpojSov uerd aTTpop.r]6ias
TTiXVV TToXkols KCU dvbpioV KoX yVVClLK&V KCli TTaibcOV KCIL 5

6r\picov. ravT ovv a crv KaAets avbpela Kal ol iroWoi, eyco
dpacrea KaAcS, avbpela be rd cppdvip.a 7rept &v Ae'ya>. C
AA. 0e'acrat, w ScoKpares, cos ev obe eavTov br/, cos
oUraL, KOcrp.L r<3 Adycr ovs be Trdvres 6p.o\oyovcrLV av-

bpeiovs elvai, tovtovs dirocrTepeLV e7rtxeipei TavTi]s Trjs rtu?/s.
NI. Ovkovv cre ye, Si Adx*/s, aAAa 6dppeL' c/jui ydp 5
cre etrat aocpdv, Kai Adp.aydv ye, elrrep ecrre avbpeHoL, Kai
'
dWovs ye crvxvovs '
A6r]vai<ov.
AA. Ovbev epco irpbs Tavra, eyuv elirelv, iW u?/ ue cpf]S
o>s dArjc9c3s Alcovea eTvai.

212. Mr]be ye enn/s, & Adxj]S' Kai ydp uot boKels ovbe d
i]cr6rjo~0aL otl TavTryv ti]v crocpiav trapd Adp.covos rov r)p.eTe-
pov eraipov irapeikrjcpev, 6 be Adp.u>v tco YlpobiKto TroAAa
7rA?7<ridei, os 8?/ boK(L t&v crocpLcrTiov KaAAto-ra ra TOLavra
dWuara 8taipeii\ 5
AA. Kat ydp TrpeTreL, w 2c)Kpares, crocpicrr?/ rd rot-
aCra udAAov Kop.\\revecr6aL ?/ dvopt 6i> 77 ttoAis d<fiot avr?/s
7rpoeo-rdz;ai.
2X2. IlpeVei ueV ttov, <x> ua/cdpte, rcoy p.eyicncov Trpo- e

oraTovvri ueyi<rr?/s cppovqa-ecos uere'xe'" SoKet 8e' uot NtKtas
dcftos etrat eTTLcrKexjrecos, ottol 7rore /3keTrcov TOvvop.a tovto
t'l6t]ctl ti]V avbpeiav.
AA. Avrds Toivvv crK07ret, d 2<oKpares. 5
b 4 a.Trpo/j.ri6ias B T airpo/j0eiay B Oxy. (sed e puncto notatum in

:
2
Oxy.) C2 ws e3 cfSe eairro*' 817] o>s e(u e)avTOj/ {0) Se Oxy. |
c 3 o&s] tous Oxy. (sed t deletum et puncto notatum) c 5 cre -ye

Oxy. tyuye : BTW c6 \i/xax^v apaxov Oxy. &fxax6v BTW: :
corr. Ven. 189 c 7 -ye om. Oxy. 09 alccv(a B 2

Oxy. TW :
iluivia B d 1 ye\ y Oxy. ou8e Oxy. ovtie Liij B T ToCSe : W :
Lii} ci. d 2 oti] '6rt S^ Oxy.

Keck d 3 iraoetAr/êj/] iropeiATjâ
Oxy. ttoAAo] to iroAAo Oxy. -yap om. Oxy. d6
d7 afSpi
ov\ avSptiov Oxy. (sed e deletum et puncto notatum^ a|(ioi i) iroAis)
ut videtur Oxy. d8
irpoeffrdvai scr. Ven. 184: (irpo)eo-Tav(a<)
Oxy. : irpoiardvat BT W e 1 /*eV irov Stobaeus . . . itov Oxy. :
W
:
Ltevroi BT
:
197 e FIAAT12N02
212. Tovro p.ekko) ttoihv, > dpLcrre' p.f) p.evroL oiov ue
d(pr]creLV cre rfjs KOLViovias rov koyov, dkkd rtpoaeye rbv
vovv koX crvo-KOTrei ra keyop.eva.

AA. Tavra bf) ecrroi, et boKel \prjvai.
10 212. 'AAAa 8oKet. o~h be, NtKta, Ae'ye rjpuv tt<x\iv e
198 apxfjs* otcrfl' 6V1 tt)?> dvbpeiav Kar dpxas rov koyov eciKo-
-rovp.ev cos p.epos dperfjs crKo-xovvres;
NI. nd*>u ye.

/" 212. Ovkovv koa, av Tovro direKpLVOi o)? p-optov, ovroiv
/ 5 bf) Kal dkkoiv p.ep<2v, a crvp.Travra dperf] KeKkrjraL;
NI. Yl&s yap ov;

9
212. Ap' ovy a7rep eyoi koa crv ravra keyeLs; eyoi be
KaAw 7rpos dvbpeCa croicppocrvvr]v koj. biKaiocrvvr]v koX aAA'
arra roiavra. ov Kal o~v;
b NI. Yldvv piev ovv.

v
212. Eê brj. ravra p.ev yap 6p.okoyovp.ev, ~repl be rm>
beiv>v Kal dappakeoiv crKe\j/bipLe9a, OTTOiS p.r) crv piev akk
arra rjyfj, fjp.ets be dkka. a p.ev ovv fjp.els f)yovp.eda, cppd-
5 crop.ev o-ol' o~u be av p.f] 6p.okoyfjs, bibaeis. f)yovp.e6a 5'
7/ueis beiva piev elvai a kol beos rrapeyeL, dappakea be a p.f]
beos irapexei 8e'o? 8e rrapexei ov ra yeyovora ovbe ra

napovra r&v KaK<2v, akka ra ~rpocrboKOip.eva' beos yap eCvat
rrpocrboKLav p.ekkovros KaKOV f) oi>x ovroi Kal avvboKet, 00
10 Adxqs;
C AA. Yldvv ye crcpobpa, a> 2toKpaTes.
212. Ta p.ev f)p.erepa roCvvv, 00 NtKia, aKOvet?, oti 8et?'a
p,ev ra p.ekkovra KaKa <pap.ev elvaL, dappakea be ra p.f] KaKa

r) dyaOa p.ekkovra m
av be ravrr] ?/ dkkjf rrepl tovtoiv keyeLs;
5 NI. Ta?rn? eyoaye.
e6 (fie o)wv ~<p(r)o-tiv) Oxy. 69 55) Oxy. (coniecerat Schanz)

8eBTW b4 iryri W
rryu B T : b7 Seos iraptx ft sec '-
A. T. Christ Se irap4x*i] 5 irapex^ 1 " Ast b 9 koI ffuvSoKf?
scripsi : xa\ <rv Sokc? B W
SoKe? Kal av
: Ka\ T : croi Sok(? B
2
SoKt? k~\
:
aoi t : Ka\ crv Schanz

AAXH2 i 9 8c
2X2. Tovt(ov be ye ti)V T-L(TTi']p.r)v uvbpeiuv Tipocr-
uyopeveLs;
NI. Kop.ibrj ye.
v
2X2. Eu 8?/ rd Tpirov <TKe\ff<i)p.da et ctui/8oki oot re /cat
i]pXv. io
NI. Td Troior 0?/ roiVo;

2X2. 'Eyco 8?) <ppd<roi. 8oki ydp 8?/ e/xot re Kai rcoSe, d
7rept 6<r<av eoriz> e7rtcrr?//>i?/, ov/c dAA?/ p.ev elvai rrepl yeyo-
votos elbevac oTir) yeyovev, uk\r\ be irepl yLyvop.ev<av oirrj
yiyverai, ak\r\ 8e oitt] av KaAAtcrra yevoiro ku\ yei>?/crerai
rd /x7/7rco yeyords, dAA' // adr?/. otoy 7reoi to vyieivbv et? 5
a7ra^ra? rpv? \povovs ovk aAAr/ rts 7/ tarptK?/, /xta oiVa,

e<popa koX yLyvop.eva Kal yeyovora Kai yevr)<r6p,evu o7n/
yeT^/o-erat" Kai 7repi rd k rrjs y?/? at <pv6p.eva 1) yccopyia e

u)crai;rcos eêt* Kai br/Trov ra 7reoi tov 7rdAe/xoi> aiVoi dr>
p.apTVpr)o~aiT ort ?/ crrpar?/yta KaAAtora Trpop.rjOetTut. tu

re aAAa Kai 7repi rd p.ek\ov e<re<r0UL, ov8e r?/ p.avTiKJj
oterat 8eu> virripeTeXv dkka upyeLV, cos et8vta KaAAtoi> 5
rd 7repi rdi> 7rdAe/xoi> Kai yt.yv6p.eva Kal yevi]o~6p.evu' kul 199

v
6 w/xo? ovrco rdrret, /x? / tov fxdvTLV tov <TTpuTi)yov dpyjetv,
dAAd rdi> o-TpaTi]ybv tov /xdi>reco?. <pi']<rop.ev ravTa, S)
.\dx??;
AA. ?/cro/ier. 5
2X2. Tt 8e'; <rv i]plv, co NiKta, <rvp,<pr]9 Trepl r<o> uvt<Zv
Ti]v avTi]V e7rtoT?/u?/i> Kal e<rop.ev<x>v Kal yLyvop.ev<av kuI
yeyovoTOiv eiraleiv;
v
NI. Eycoye* 8oKet ydp poL odrco?, <o 2coKpare?.
2X2. Ovkow, co dptare, kuI ?/ dvbpeia rcoz> bew<av eiri- 10
<TTr')p.i] eo-Tiv kuI dappukewv, cos 0?/?* ?/ ydp; b

XI. Nat.
d.2 yeyovoTos TW: yeyovbs B d.4 koJ yewficreTai secl.

Schanz d.6 ^ BTW: ^ ^ corr. Coisl. d7 2irp 7^/)-
crtTai secl. Hirschig 63 /j.apTvpô-aire scr. recc. : /xaprvpâ-eTe
BTW G4 TW: HcreaOe B
r<7f<T0ai
:
iggb FIAAT12N02
212. Td 8e beiva co/uoAdyrrrat kcu to, dappakta Ta pev
p.e\XovTa dyadd, to, 8e /xe'AAoi>ra Kaxa etrat.
5 NI. ITdyu ye.
212. 'H 8e' y' avrr/ e7rto-rr7ur? ra>i> ovt&v kul p,kk6vTu>v
xat 7rdi>rco? Zxovtcov etVat.
NI. "Ecrrt ratJra.
212. Ov p.6vov apa tQ>v beiv&v Kai OappakioiV r) dvbptCa

io lTH(TTy]p.r] eortV ov yap p.ekk6vTO)v p.6vov 7re'pt tS>v ayaOG>v
re Kai KaK&v e7ratet, dAAd Kai yLyvop.4v(ov Kal yeyovoTU>v
C Kat 7rdyrcos' exoVrcoy, coo-7reo at dAAat iTTLo~Trjp.ai.
NI. "EotKeV ye.

212. Mepos dpa dvbpeCas i)pXv, S> NtKta, aTreKpCvoj cryzbov
tl TpLTOV Katrot r;/xets r)paiT(ap.V 6kt]v dvbpeCav 6tl etrr. Kai
| vvv brj, cb? olkV, Kara tov crbv koyov ov p.6vov beLV&v re
Kai 6appaktu>v kirio-Tripvr] r) dvbpeCa iarCv, dAAd o~xeb6v tl r/
7repi irdvTiov dyad&v re Kai KaK&v kol\ TravTOis iyovTu>v, cos

d i;?jj; aS d crds Adyos, dvbpeCa dv etr/. ovrcos ar3 Merartc9eo-0at
r) 7rcos Ae'yets, co NtKta;
v
NI. Euotye 8oKet, co 2coK/)ares.
212. AoKet ovv o~ol, S> 8aiudvte, d7roAet7reu' dv rt d rot-
5 ovtos dperr/s, et7rep et8eirj rd re dyatfd 7rdi>ra Kai 7rai>rd-
Tiao-LV 0)? ytyyerat Kai yeyr/crerai Kai yiyove, Kal tcl KaKtx
cocradrcos ; Kai roOrov otet di> cru ei>8ed ett>at crw-ppocrvvris rj
dtKatocrwrrs re Kai ocrLOTrjTos, co ye udrco T~pocrr]KL ko.l irepl
0eoi>s Kal 7repi dvOpamovs igzvkafielo-daC re rd 8etz>d Kai rd

/xr/, Kai TayaOa 7rooiecr#ai, e7rto-raueVco dp0cos 7rpoo-outAeiV;
NI. Ae'yew> ri co 2coKpare's uot 8oKets.
Ovk dpa, ai NtKta, p.6pL0v

212. dperrjs av eiri to vvv ctol
keyop.evov, dAAd crvp.itacra dperr/.
b3 to Se TW: toDto 5e B /cal tcc TW: *cal revera B?

C i /cal T-avTois xcWttj/ secl. Stallbaum C 4 auSpeiav corr. Coisl.
av avSpeiav BTW: S^ avSpeiav Schanz d 1 avSpia av (sed t ex
emend.) B : avSpeiav TW d7 ^fSeai T d8 irpoo-fiKfi~\
rrpocr^Koi ci. H. Richards d9 koI rh. fi^ secl. Badham ei *cal
Tctyaâ secl. Gitlbauer

AAXH2 199 e
NI. "EoLKV. -
212. Kcu /ur/r (papV ye Ti]V avbptCav popiov etVat h>

tcov rrjs apeTrjs.
NL "F,cpapV ydp.
212. Td 8e ye w Keyopcvov ov c/kitVerai.
NI. OirK OLKV. 10

212. Ovk dpa 7]vpi]Kapv, co NtKta, dvbpcCa otl ecrru>.
NI. Orj cpaLv6p.6a.

AA. Kat /xr/i> yu>y, co c/)iAe NtKta, co/urjz' <re vpr)(Tiv,
e7ret8r/ ipov KaT<ppovi](ras 2coKpdret diroKpLvapivov irdvv 200

87/ /xeyaAr/y eA7rt8a eixo^, cos r?) 7raod rov Ad/ucoros croc/Jta
avrrjv a.Vvpi]o-is.
NI. Ev ye, co Adxr/?, ort ovdei' otet crt/ ert Trpaypa ivai
otl ar/rd? dprt icpdvrjs dvbpeias irepL ovbev clbcos, dAA' et 5
Kat eyco Tpos toiovtos dva<pavi]<ropaL, irpbs tovto /UAeVets,
Kat ovbcv ert 8totcret, cos eotKe, crot /uer' e/xou pi]bV et8eVat
<oy Trpocri]Ki irL(TTi]pr]v \iv dvbpl oiopivco rt etz>at. crv
ph> ovv poL boKis cos dArjtfcos dv6pcoTTLov irpaypa kpydCjeo-Qai b

ov8e 7rpo? cravTov (3X.TTlv dkkd Trpbs tovs dAAorjs* eyco 8'
olpai ipol TTpl &v kyopV vvv re eTrteiKcos Lprjcr6ai, Kat
et TL aVTCOV pi] LKaVWS etprjrat, VOTpOV TTaVOp6(ti(TCr6aL Kal

p.Ta Adp.covos ov crv 7rou otet Karay\av, Kal ravra ovb' 5
Ibcov 7rco7rore t6v Adpcova Kal /uer' dWcov Kal iTLbav
/3e/3atcocrco/xai avrd, 8t8d<fco Kat <re', Kat ov cp6ovr)(T(o' 8oKefo
yap poL Kal pd\a cr<p6bpa 8etcrt9at p.adLV. C
AA. 2oc/)os ydp tol <rv et, co NtKta. dAA' dpcos eyco
Aucrtjud)(cp rco8e Kat MeAr/crta <rvpfiov\Vco cre p.V kclI e/ue
TTpl Trjs 7rai8etas tcov VavicrKcov yaipLV av, 2coKpdrr/ 8e

tovtovl, oiTp e<f dp^s eAeyoy, p.r) dc/JieVaf et 8e Kat e/xot 5
ey r/AtKta r/<ray ot 7rat8ey, ravrd dy rarjr' TTOlovv.
e 13 $ut/j/ <re (vp-fiareiv secl.Badham a7 <rol scr. recc. <r\>
W
:
BT b 1 avOpdireiov B T 2
W
avQpuviov B b2 01186 <;i.
W
:
Gitlbauer : ovoev BT ffavrbv corr. Coisl. : avrbv BT avrbv W

W
:
b 5 iroi/ ofei] t< otft Schanz C 6 raura T : TaCra B

B
2ooc nAATONOS
NF. TavTa p.ev Kayw crvyyoapQf eavnep ede\r) ScoKpaTris
T&v p.eipaKLOiv e-nLp.ekelcr6aL, p.t)beva akkov Qqrelv. eirel kclv
d eycb tov NiKijpaTov tovtco r/cWra e7rirpe'7rotp,i, et edeXoL

ovtos' dAAd yap aWovs p.0L eKao-Tore crvvLo-Tr)crLV, orav tl
avrco 7rept tovtov p.vt]crdo>, avrbs be ovk edeXeL. dAA' opa, co
AvcrCp.a)(, et rt crov av paAAoi viraKovoL 2a)Kpdr7js.

5 AT. At/catoV ye rot, co NtKta, eTret Kat eyco tovtco ttoXXo.
av edekrjo-aLp.L 7tollv, a ovk av dAAot? Trdvv 7roAAot? edekoLpLL.
7rws oui' <pJ??, 3) "2a>KpaTs; viraKOvcrr) tl Kal o-vp.Trpo6vp.ijo->]
cos /3eArtaT0ts yevecrdaL rot? petpaKtots;

2X2. Kat ydp dy beLvbv etrj, co Aio-tju.axf, rovro ye, /b;
edekeiv rco crvp.Trpodvp.elcrdaL cos /3eArioTre? ez aTtopLa eyevop.eda'
tl ovv av tls r)p.Stv TLva 7rpoatpotro; ep,ol juey ow 8t/ aijrco
201 8oKet ovbeva.' dAA' e7rei8?/ raiVa ovtcos ex et -Ke'\//-ao-0e dv

tl boui o-vp./3ovkeveLV vpXv. eyco ydp cpr\p.L \pr)vaL, co dvbpes
oudets yap eKcpopos koyos KOLvrj Trdvras r)pas (fr/retV
pdAtora p.ev r)p.lv avTOLS bLbdcrKakov cos dpLcrTOV beopeda

5 ydp eVeira Kat rot? /uetpaKtots, p.t]T \pr\p.aTO)v cpeLbop.evovs
p.r]Te dkkov p.r)bevos' edv be r)pas avTovs e\LV c*>? vvv eyo-
p.ev ov crvp.j3ovkevoj. et be tls r)p.ctiv KaTayekdaeraL, otl
b rr/AtKOt8e ovTes els bibacrKakatv d^Lovpev cpoLTav, Tov"Op.i]pov
boKel p.oL xPV vat Trpoj3dkXecr6aL, bs ecpr) ovk aya6r)v elvaL

at8co Ke\pt)p.ev(a avbpl itapelvaL. Kal r)p.eLS ovv ed-
cravres yaipeLV et rt? rt epet, KOLvr) r)p.G>v avrcoy Kat rcoz'
5 p.eLpaKLOJV e7rt/ueAetai TTOLrjcroipeda.
c8 &\\oi> T W
b &\\o B : iirtl ko.p T fVeiS' ^6 Wd 4 *t
:
ti T W ov ri B
: d 7 ffvfjLirpoQvfiT)o-fi B W: o-vfnrpodvfxr]Q-i]ira T
d8 f3e\TtffT0is TW: 0f\TiffTOS B e6 nVa BTW: nâ scr.
recc. irpocupo?To T b W
irpoepo?To B
: a 1 ffKfyaffBe W :
ffKfipaffdai (suprascr. ) BT a3 AJ-yos] A.J70U Heusde a6 eay

TW: ea' bi TTjAi/co/8e B TW r)\iKo(8e B 2
: b4 epe?
TWb: afperB
AAXH2 2oib
AT. 'E//ot p.h> dpeV/cet, S) Sw/coare?, a Aeyets* kcu e0e'A<o,

o<r()7rep yepaiTaros et/xt, roo-oirra) irpo$vp.6TaTa p.av6aveiv
Plcto. tG)V veavLo~Ku>v. akka p.01 ovrcool Ttolr\oov avpiov
cu>9ev aq^CKOv oi/ca8e /cat p.i} aAAoo? 7rotr/a-7/s, JW /3oi>Aev- c
ou>p.e6a irepl avr&v tovtcov, to be vvv elvat ri]V ovvovoiav
oiakvo-(op.V.
2i2. 'AAAa Troirjoa}, w AvoLp.a\e, Tavra, Kal rj(o irapa

oe avpiov, eav debs edeXij. 5
C3 8ta\v<rci)/xei> W : SiaKvffOftev BT
n^
AT2I2
st. II
2X2KPATH2 p. 203
'E7ropeuo'prji> fxev e 'AKa8r7/xeias evdv AvKeiov tt)v eco a

tcC\ov$ vtt avrb to reixos ' e7ret8f7 8' ky-\v6p.r\v naTct ttjv
TTvXtba ?f 77 riayo?T09 Kpr\vr\, ivTavda crvviiTvyov 'l7T7roc9dAei re

tu 'lcpoyvvfxov Kal Krrjcri7T7T<o rco Ilaiaviet Kal dAAots /uera
rorjrtoy vtavicrKOts ctOpoots o~vveo~Tc2o~t. Kai /xe irpoo~t6vTa 6 5
'iTTTToâArys t8cor, *i2 ScoKpares, ecpr/, 7roi 8fj iropevrj Kat

irodev; b
'E 'AKaSrj/xeia?, r]y 8' eyco, 7Tope7Jop.at erjflu ArjKetou.
Aevpo bfj, 77
8' os, eu0t 77pcoi\ ov 7rapa/3dAAets; dtoi>
fJLt-VTOt.
Ylot, ecprji/ eyco, Ae'yet?, Kat Trapa rtvas roi/s vpias; 5
Aerjpo, ecjbrj, Setfas p.01 ei> rco KaTavTtKpv tov reixpus Trept-
Kat Ovpav dyetoypeVrji'. 8tarpi/3op,ei> 8'

/3oAo'i> re' rti/a 8e', ?/
os, avrodt Tj/xets re ar/rot Kat dAAot 7Tdvrj 7roAAot Kat koAoi.
v
Ecrrii> 8e 8f) rt rorjro, Kat rts 77 Starpi/Srj; 204
IlaAaicrrpa, ecprj, vecocrri (pKoSo/xr/peVrj* 77 8e 8iarpi/3f/ rd
7roAAa eV Adyoty, cojj ?j8e'cos av crot pera8i8otpei\
KaAcoj ye, 771;
8' eyco, Trotorjvres" 8i8do-Kei 8e rts avrodt;
2os kratpos ye, 77

8' os, Kat t\i:atviiTr]s, Mikko?. 5
203 a 1 d/caSrj/uios B (sed ex emend. B) T (et mox b 1)
a 3 ii-iroddKft B (et mox a 6 <Viro0aA.rjs) b 3 fvdv* B et>0us :
TW irapa$a\\tis~] irapafia\e7s Hirschig 65 <J>tj'] v postea

add. B b8 W
avro\ T : avro\ $ B 204 a a e</>7j t : B
<j>rji/ :
%<pT)v T : </>7j<n b &v T a3 : 5<j B a 4 76 W : 8 BT

a 5 7 scr. recc. : BTW
204^ nAATilNOS
Md Ata, i)v 8' eyco, otv cpavkos ye d?;?//?, dAA' tKaros'
troc/Wrr/s.
BovAet ovv (iirecrOaL, </?, <W Kat t8?/s rotvs ovras avrodi
[avrov];
b YIp&Tov ?/8e'cos aKOvaaiy? av eVi rco Kat etcretut Kat tls 6
Kakos.
v
AAAos, <pr), dAAco r/ucov 8oKet, co IScoKpares.
2ot 8e 8?) rts, a 'iTrTroâAes; tovto uot et7re'.
5 Kat os eptorr/tfets r)pv8piacrV. Kat eyco etTrojr *I2 7rat
'Iepcovtvuoi; 'iTTTroâAes, rotiro ue*> u?jKe'rt etvrrr/s, etre epas rou
etre u?j' ot8a yap 6'rt ot p.6vov epas, dAAa Kai 7r oppco rjbrj et
7ropei>o'uevos tov epcoros. etut 8' eyco rd uer dAAa cpaCAos

C Kat dx/??jcrros, rouro 8e uot 7rcos eK c9eoo 8e'8orat, Ta%y otco
r' etuat yrcoât epcoird re Kat *pa>p.vov.

Kat 6s aKovtras 7roAv ert udAAoy r)pv6piacrev. 6 ovv
KTTJcrnnTos, 'AcrretoV ye, r/ 8' 6s, ort ZpvdpL&s, co 'l7r7ro'0aAes,
Kat okvus eiireiv 2coKpdret Tovvop.a' iav 8' ovros Kat crp.LKpbv
5
Xpovov crwbLaTptyr\ crot, 7raparat9?/crerai V7r8 aoS aKorJco?;
0aud Ae'yoz>ros. r/ucoy yovv, co ScoKpares, eKKeKcocpcoKe rd

d cora Kat eu7re'7rA?/Ke AucrtSos' av /xei> 8r) Kat VTTOTtir), evuapta
r/uty etrru> Kat e virvov eypoueVots Atvtrt8os otecrflai Tovvop.a
aKOveiv. Kat d uei> KaraAoyd8?/i> 8i??yetrai, 8eu>d ovra, ov

itavv tl btLva cttlv, dAA' e7ret8di/ rd 7rot?/uara r/ucof e7rt-
5 \iLpr\crr\ KarayrAetv Kat crvyypap.p.aTa. Kal 6 kcrTLV tovtcov
beLVOTepov, otl Kal a8et ets Ta 7rat8tKa cpcornj 6avp.ao~iq, rjv
r/uds 8et aKovoz/ras avzytcrOaL. vvv 8e epcorcouevos V7rd cro?3
epu^pta.
e "Ecttlv 8e', ?/y 8' eyco, 6 Awts ve'os rts, cbs eotKe* TKp.ai-
pouat 8e', ort aKO?Jcras TOvvop.a ovk eyvcov.
&6 avhp Schanz : df^p BTW a8 IfSjjs Ficinus etSfjs BT :
out^j om. Schanz ag outoC seclusi (alteri tribuunt BT)

b i ddiifxi T : eltrifjLi B b 4 fioi T ttoi B :b 5 Tjpvfloioo-e'] ^ ex
emend. B b6 'lirir6da\es secl. Cobet b8 iropevofievos secl.
Schanz C7 e/c(ceKw<^wK BT : tKKfKw<priKi T" d5 KOTovTAe?']
\ cx emend. B
:
AT212 204 e
Ov yap iravv, ecprz, tl avTov rovvofxa kzyovcriv, ahJC ert

TtaTjwOzv e7rovopderat 8td to acpobpa tov iraTcpa yiyvv-
crKtadai avrov. e7ret ev olb' otl ttoKAov 8ets to elbos ayvotiv 5
tov Traibos' iKavos yap Kal airo p.6vov tovtov yLyvc6o~K*o~6aL.

AeyeVflco, rp) 8' eyco, ovtivos <Lo~tlv.
Arjp.oKpaTovs, ecpr/, tov Al(iiV<as 6 TrpecrfivTaTos vos.

EUv, i]V 8' eyco, co T7T7ro'0aAes, cbs yevvalov Kal vzavLKOv
tovtov tov epcora TravTayr) avqvpes' KaC p.01 16 t e7ri8etai a 10
Kal rolabe e7rt8eiKz>rjcrat, Xva et8co et e7rtcrracrat a \pi) epaarr/v 205

Trept TraibLK&v Trpos avrov 77 irpos akkovs Ae'yeti\
Tovtcov 8e' tl, <pr\, o~Tadp.q, co 2,coKpaTs, cov 6'8e Ae'yet;

Ylorepov, rjv 8' eyco, kol to kpav <-apvos et ov Aeyet d8e;
Ovk eycoye, ec/)Tj, dAAd /u^ 7rotety ets rd 7rat8tKa pr/5e 5
crrjyypdcpeiv.
Ovx vyiaivn, ecprj 6 KTrjaLTnros, dAAa Ar/pet re Kat

patVerat.
Kat eyw et7roy '12 'iTrTroâAey, ov rt rcov p.e'rpcov 8e'o/xat
a.Kovo~aL ov8e /xe'Aos et rt irtTtOLi-Kas ets rdv veaviaKov, dAAd b

rT/s Stayotas, <W et8co rtVa Tpoirov 7rpocr<pe'p?/ irpos tcl
7rat8iKa.
f
'08e 8r/7rov crot, ecpr/, epet* aKpt/3cos ydp e7rtcrrarai Kat
p.ep.vriTaL, et7rep, cos Ae'yet, V7r' epov det aKOVtov 8tare0pvAr/rai. 5
N77 rovs 0eovs-, ecpr/ 6 Krr/crt7r7ros, 7rdi>v ye. Kat ydp

eWt Karaye'Aaora, co ScoKpares. rd ydp epaarr/v dvra Kat
8tacpepo'vrcos rcov aAAcoy rdv rovv 7rpocre'xovra rco 7rai8t t8iov
aev p.rrSei' exet^ Aeyetv o ovxi *dv 7rats et7rot, 7rcos ovxl C
KaTayikaorov ; a 8e r/ 7ro'Ats dAr/ a8et 7rept Ar/poKpdrorjs Kat
i\rJcri8os roo 7ra7r7rou ro?3 7rat8ds Kat iravrcov -txipL tcov irpo-
yovtov, ttXovtovs re Kat t7T7rorpo(ptas Kat vUas Iluôt Kat
6 3 Ti T : (l B 64 trcbodpa rhv T W : acpohpcrrarov B

e 5 5r$ B (sed s erasum) W $u ac T 67 oSTi^s T olv. rivos
W
:
W
:
B : ovv (t rtvos (sed ov supra ey W) e 8 altwvews T

iwve<iis B e lo d^cCpcs T: av tvpts B a3 ti'6e TW:
om. B
205C nAATI2N02
5 'Icr0/xoi? Kal Nep.e'<x TeOpLTnroLs re Kat KeÂrrcrt, ravra 7roiet re
Kat Ae'yet, irpbs oe rorjYois fri tovtcov KpovLKcorepa. tov yap
tov 'HpaKkzovs evtcrpdv Trpurrjv r)plv iv 7rotr/p.art tlvl dtr/et,
cos dtd r^y rorj 'HpaKAeorjs crvyykvtLav 6 irpoyovos avT&v

d rj7rooe'<fairo tov 'Hpa/cAea, yeyovcbs avrbs e/c Atds re /cat rrjs
tov bijp.ov apyriytTov Ovyarpos, ctirep al ypatat qbovcn, Kal

dAAa ttoWcl TOLavra, S> ScoKparer ravr ccttIv a oSros Aeycoy
re Kat cxScotj dyay/ca(jft xat r)pJas aKpoacrdaL.
5 Kat eyco aKorjcras' etTrojr *i2 Karaye'Aacrre 'l7r7rd0aAes, 7rpty
veviKrjKtvaL 7rotets re kol aoets ets cravrbv eyKco/xtorj;

'AAA' ovk ets ejuaurw, ecprj, aj ScoKpares, orjre 7rotco orjre
adco.
Ovk otet ye, ^y d' eyco.

io Td 8e 7rcos exet; ecpjj.
e nd^rcov /xdAtcrra, et7roi>, ets cre tlvovctlv arjrat al codat.
edy p,ez> ydp eA?7S rd 7rat8iKa rotarjra ovra, Kocrpios ctol
ecrrat tcl Aex#eWa Kat dcrOevTa kcu rco oz/rt eyKcojuta &o-nep
vevLKrjKOTL, otl tolovtcov 7rai8iKcoy eruxes* f dy 8e o-e dtacprjy?/,
5 ocrcj) dr p,etco crot tlpr)p,4va 7] eyKco/xta 7rept rcoy 7rat8tKcoy,
rocrorjrcp /j.etbVcoz/ do'ets KaA<3z> re Kat ayaOGtv ecrrepT7p,eY/os
206 KaTayzkacrTos eTz>at. ocrris otjtj rd kpa>TLKa, 00 cptAe, crocpos,
ovk ZiraLveX tov epco/xerjoy irplv av eA?/, deStcos rd /xeAAoy 07n7

d7ro/3r/crerat. Kat dpa 01 KaAot, c?7ret8dv rts arjrorjs e7raty|/ Kat
arj^r/, (ppovrjp.aTos e/Ji7ri/x7rAai>rai Kat peyaAarjYjas* r/ ovk otet;

5 "Eycoye, ec/jr/.
OtjkotjV dcrcp dy //eyaAarjxdrepoi ooctijj, SucraAcoroVepot

ytyroyrat;
Eikos ye.
Ilotds rts ovy av croi ooKet 0rjpevTr)s etvat, et dyacro/3ot
10 drjpevcov Kal 8rjcraAcororepay rr^rj aypav ttoloX;
C5 fe/x(a T : vfixea. B c6 KpoftKwrepaTW X9 0VlK Ti P a ^ : <*l

'
d6 rairri)' BT !
: outJ' TW d 10 tJ> Sc T ToSe B : 89 Soer
scr. recc. : So/cot BT W aio o-yptfav B (ut videtur aypiav
fuit)

AT2I2 206 b
Arjkov ort cpavkos. b

Kat pkv 5?/ koyois re nal co5aiV p.i] Krjkelv dAA' eaypiaCveiv
7roAA?/ dpovcrCa' ?) ydp;

Ao/cet /xoi.
SxoVet 5r/, co 'iTrTrdtfaAes, O7rto? /*f/ Tracri tovtols evoyov 5

cravTov 7roi?/o-ets 5td r^y iroCqcrLV Katrot ot/xat eyco dvbpa
TTO(,rio~ei ftkaTTTOVTa kavTov ovk dv cre kQektLV 6/uoAoyf)crai cl?
dyaflo'? 7ror' ecrrtf 7rot?/r?/?, /3Aa/3eod? a>y eaurco.

v
Ov /xd roz> Ata, </)?/ 7roAA?/ ydp av dkoyCa et?/. dAAd 5td
raura Sr/ ctol, o> ôjKpares, avaKoivovp.ai, Kal el rt dAAo c
exet?, o-vp./3ov\cv rCva dv tls Adyoy SiaAeyd/xeyos r) tC
TrpaTToov 7rpocrc/)iA?/? 7rai5iKots yevoLTO.
Ov pabtov, r)v 5' eyco, et7rety dAA' et p.01 e0eA?/crais avrbv
TTOirjo-aL et? koyovs kkdetv, tcrcos av bvvaCp.r]v crot kiribeiâi 5
d XPV o.vT<o 5taAe'yecr0at dvri tovtojv &v ovtol keyeiv re Kal
qbtLV cpacrC cre.
'AAA' ovbev, ecpr], xa^ 7r v " &v y-P elcrekdrjs /uerd

Kr??o-t7r7ro7j roCSe /cat Ka6e(6p.evos 5iaAe'yr/, ot/xat /xer Kat
avros crot 7roo'creicri cptAr/Koos ydp, co ScoKpare?, biacpcpovTOJS 10
IcttCv, Kat d/xa, w? 'Eppata dyoDcrty, avap.ep.tiyp.4voi, iv ra?3rco d

etcriy 01 re veavCcrKOL Kal ol 7rai5es Trpocrcicriv oZv croi.
et 5e p?/, Kr?/cri7r7rcp crvvr)dr)s (crrlv 5td rd*> rovrou dve^l/ibv
Meviêvov Meveevo> pey ydp 5?/ 7rdz>rcoi> /xdAtcrra eratpo?
coy r?jyxdyet. KaAecrdrco otw ovros avTov, eav dpa p.r) 7rpocri?/ 5
avros.
TaCra, r)v 5' eyco, XPV ÔLeiv. Kat dpa Aa/3a>y rdi>
Kr?/crt7r7roi; 7rpoo~r/a ets r?/y irakaCcrTpav ol 5' dAAot vorepot e

r/txcoi; ficrav.
ElcrekdovTes 5e KareAd/3o/xey avr60L TedvKOTas re rov?

7raT5a? Kat rd 7rept rd tepeta o-xeSdy rt ?/5?/ 7re7rot?//>teVa,
b4 80/C6? T W : SoKt? ydp B b6 iroi^creiy scr. Ven. 184 :
irofffffris BTW C7 TW: ytB d4 Ito?oosTW: erepos

B (sed at supra B 2
) ds irpoa-ir) T : wpocretj? B ;sed supra i B 2
t
)
e 1 jrpoo-fjo] irpoo-fct T : irpoffdi) B 64 lepua ex emend. B {Upta fuit)
plato, vol. 111. 7
2o6e nAATilNOS
5 dcrrpayaAibr>rd? re brj kcu KKOo-p.r)p.evovs airavTas. ol p,ev
ovv iroXXol ev rfj avXfj eiraLôv eco, ol be Tives tov airo-

dvTrjpiov ev ycoina r)pTLaov dcrrpaydAots Trap.Tr6XXoLS, eK
pOppLLCTKOiV tlvS>v irpoaLpovpLevoL' tovtovs 8e TTepLicrTacrav
clXXol 6eu>povvTes. 8>v br) kol 6 Avctls r)v, koI etcrr^Kei ev
207 tols iraLCTL re kol veavicrKOLs eo-Teqbavcop.evos Kal Tr]v o\jslv
bLacpepcov, ov to KaXbs etmi \xovov dto? aKovcraL, dAA' otl

Kakos re Kayados. kcu r)p.LS els t6 KaravTLKpv airoyu>pr)-
cravres Ka6e{fip.e6a rjv yap avTO0L r)crvyj.a /cat ri aXXr/XoLS
5 8teAeyb/xe0a. TrepLcrTp(p6p.evos ovv 6 Avctls 6ap.a eireo-KO-
7retro r)p.as, kol brjXos r)v e-jL6vp.S>v TrpocreX6elv. recos p.ev
ovv fjTropeL re Kat coKzêt p.6vos irpoo-LevaL, eVetra 6 Meveevos

b eK rrjs avXrjs p.Tav irai(a>v elvepyeTaL, koll cos et8ev ep.4 re
Kat tov KTf)crLTnTov, rjeL TrapaKa6L(r]cr6p.evos' Ibaiv ovv avrov

6 Avcris enrero Kat o-vp.TrapKa6e^To p.Ta tov Meveevov.
TrpocrrjXdov br) kolX 61 clXXol, kol br) kOl 6 lTnrodaXrjs,
5 eireLbr) irXeiovs ecopa ecpLcrrapLevovs, tovtovs eTrrjXvyLcrdp.evos

TrpocrecrTr) 77 p.r) coero KaT6\ffeo~6aL tov Avctlv, SeStcos p*r) avT<2
aiTy6avoLTO' Kal ovtco irpocrecrTtos r)Kpoa.To.

Kal eyco irpos tov Meveêvov a-TofiXexlras, *l ttol Ar)p.o-
C cp&vTos, r)v 8' eyco, 7rdrepo? vp.G>v irpeo-fivTepos;

3
'Ap.cpLcr/3r]TovpLv, ecprj.
Ovkovv kol OTTOTepos yevvaLorepos, epLLjOLT av, r)v 8' eyco.
Ylavv ye, ecpr).
5 Kal p.r\v oiroTepos ye KaXXicov, coo-adrcos.

'EyeAacrdrrii' ovv d/xc/jco.
Ov p.r)v oiroTepos ye, ecprjv, TrXovcrnoTepos vp.S>v, ovk

epr)o~op.aL' (piXco y&p ecrrov. r) yap;
e 7 a<TTpayd\ovs irafxir^Wovs al. Pollux e 8 -Tpoaipov/j.evot~\ xare-

pwixevoL Pollux Ka\bs (sed A in aa B \\ ut videtur rasura B) T:
naWos W b1 elb~ev T : IStv B b3 tlixero B et in marg. T :
eWe-ro T b4 ol secl. ci. H. Richards b 5 f-Tri\vyicrdfxtpos

BT W : e-Tti^vyaffdLiei/os t b 6 irpoo~o~T7) Stephanus -rpotaTi~ :
BT W % T .
f) B SeS-i-s B t SeSuus T
: c 8 ip-i)<ro[xai] 4 ex
emend. B

AT2IS 207 c
Tldvv y i<paTr\v.
,
Ovkovv KOiva rd ye <pikcov Ae'yerat, cocrre rojjrco ye ovbev 10
btoicreTov, efarep akr\6r\ irept rrjs cpikias kiyeTov.
2vve<pdTr\v.
. 'E7rexetpo?Ji> ^V P*tcl tovto ipcoTav OTioTepos 8iKato'repos d

Kat aocpcorepos avrcov etr\. p.erav ovv tls 7rpo<rekdcov dv-
e'crrr/cre tov Meveêvov, <pd<rK<ov Kakeiv tov 7TaLboTpCj3r\v
iboKei ydp poi lepoiroLcov Tvyydveiv. iKeivos piev ovv coxero*
eyco be tov Avctlv r)p6p.r\v, 'H tjov, r\v V iyco, oo Awi, 5
<r<p6bpa c/jtAet cre 6 7rar? /p Kat
v
7/ p.r\Tr\p; ITaia) ye, 77
8' o?.
Ovkovv fiovkotvTo dv <re coy evbaLp.ove<TTaTov elvai;

ITcdy yap ov; AoKet 8e' crot evbaCptcov etvat dvdpcoTros e
bovXevcov re Kat co p.r\bev eet?? 7roteu> cou einOvpLoT; Ma
At" ovk epotye, ec/>r/. Ovkow et cre c/jiAet 6 7rar?/p Kat r/
p.r\Tr\p Kat evbaipovd cre i7TL6vp.ov<TL yevi<rdai, tovto Travrl

TpoTTto brjkov ort 7rpo6vp.ovvTaL ottcos &v evbaip.ovoir\s.- ITcos 5
ydp ovyj.; e<pr\,-
'Ecocrti> dpa <re & /3ovAet 7roteti>, Kat ovbev
iiTtTTKr\TTov<Ttv ovbe btaK<o\vov<TL TTOteiv 8>v dv iirtOvpvqs;
Nat ptd Ata ipti ye, a> ^coKpaTes, koX p.dka ye 7roAAd
KcoAvoTjcriy. ricos Aeyets; r)v 8' eyco. fiovk6p.evoi <re /xaKa-
ptov etrat StaKcoAvoucri tovto iroteiv 6 <\v (3ovkr\; cobe bi 208
/xot Ae'ye. r\v iTTt6vp.r\<rr\s irri tlvos tG>v tov iraTpbs dppaTcov
oyeicrdaL kaj3<ov rds r)vias, otov d/>uAAarai, ovk av itoiv cre
dAAd otaKcoAvotei'; Md At" ov ptivrot dv, e<pr\, icoev.-
'AAAd rtVa p.rjv; Ecrru>
v
tls r)vioyos irapd tov 7rarp6s 5
p.t<r6bv <pipcov. ITcos Ae'yets; p,t<rdtoT<o ptdkXov iTTtTpi7Tov<rtv

r\ <ro\ TTOLeiv ort dv fiovkr\TaL 7rept tovs lttttovs, kol 7rpocre'rt
avrov tovtov dpyvptov Ttkovatv; 'AAAd rt p,r\v; <pr\. b
AAAd tov optKov (evyovs 01/xai iiTLTpiTTOva-iv <tol dp\LV,
Kav et fiovkoLo kafitov tt\v /xdcrrtya r?J7rreiy, ecoey dv.
e 1 <&!/) &v6pa>iros Madvig as riva] rl Schanz (a\\ct ri iiA\v;
Lysidi tribuit H. Richards) a6 /xio-dur^ T: fj,t<r0a>rij B
b 1 rovrov B rovro T :
2o8b nAATX2N02
Ylodev, r) 8' os, ea>ev; Tt 8e'; r)v 8' eyco* ovhzvl %cortv
5 avrovs TVTTTetv; Kal ptaXa, ec/>r?, r<S 6peoKop.od. AovAco
ovti rj e\ev6epo>; AotjAco, ecprj. Kat 8oyAozv, cos eotKev,
r)yovvTat irepX TrXeiovos r) o~e tov vov, koI eTTtTpeTrovcrt ra
eavT&v p:aXXov r) o~oi, koI eS>o~tv Trotetv drt )3ovXeTat, o~e 8e
C StaKcoAvoucri; /cat jotot ert rd8e et7re. o~e avTov eS>o~tv dpyetv
creavTov, rj ovbe tovto eTTtTpeirovcri croi; ITg>s ydp, ecpr),
iTTLTpeTTovcriv;
'AAA' dpyet rt? crou;
"08e, 7rai8aycoyo'?,
ec/>77. Mcoz> 8oi5Ao? w^;

'AAAd rt /u.77^; r)p.eTepos ye, ec/>77.
5
'H 8etivo'z>, 7/1; 8' eyco, eXevdepov ovra vtto bovkov dpyecrdat.
rt 8e TTOtS>v av ovtos 6 Tratbayooyos o~ov dpyet;
"Aycoy br/irov,
ecpr), els btbao~KaXov. Mcov pvq Kal ovToi crov dpyovcrtv, 01

d btbdcrKakot; YldvTcos brjTrov. YlaptTroXXovs dpa crot be-
crTTOTas Kal dpyovTas eKoov 6 iraTr)p ecpio-Trjcrtv. dAA' dpa
eTretbdv otKabe eXdrjs irapd Trjv ptrjTepa, eKeivrj cre ea irotelv
oTt dv (3ovXr), ti>' avTjj p,aKaptos rjs, rj irepl ra epta 7/ irepl
5 tov Icttov, oTav vcpaivr) ; ov Tt ydp ttov btaKooXvet cre r) rrjs
cnrdOrjs rj Trjs Kepîbos rj dAAou tov tS>v irepX Takacrtovpyiav
opydvcov dirTecrOat. Kat 0? yeAaaa?, Md Ata, ecprj, >
e 2coK/>are?, ov p.6vov ye btaKooXvet, aXXd Kat TV7TToip.r)V av el

aTTToip.r]V.
'HpaKAet?, r)v 8' eyco, p.S>v /u.77 rt r)biKr)Kas tov
iraTepa 77 rr)v ptrjTepa; Md At' otjk eycoye, eqbrj.
'AAA' dz>rt rivos ptrjv ovtoo cre betv&s btaKcoXvovcrtv evbai-
5 ptova etvat Kat irotelv ort dv (3ov\r), Kat bt r)p.epas oXrjs
Tpecpovcri cre aei rw bovXevovra Kal evt Aoyw dAtyov a>v
eirt6v)xets ovbev irotovvTa; coare crot, a>? eotKev, ovre tu>v

XprfixaTcav toctovtoov ovtoov ovbev ocpeXos, dAAd ?rd^re?
209 aiiT&v pLaWov dpyovcrtv r) crv, ovre tov crco/xaros ovrco yev-
vaiov ovtos, dAAd Kat tovto dAAo? 7rot)xaivet kol Bepairevef
o~v be dpyets ovbevos, 00 Avo~t, ovbe Trotels ovbev S>v eirtOv-
b4 (pej/ secl. Hirschig b8 a\ 5e T: ce B (sed suprascr. Se B 2 )

e 1 Kai fj.01
%Ti B W et in marg. T : /col ert fiot T C 3 S5e] o
5iBT iratSaywySs secl. ci. H. Richards d4 flovKr) 'lv avry
T : fiovArji vavrt) B rjy $ T : r)o~\i) B ei ivT: om. B
>
AY2I2 2og a
p,ets. Ov ydp 7ra>, ecpr/, t/AikiW exo>, 2> 2o>Kpares. Mt/ ov

TOVTO CT, tii TTai ArjpOKpaTOVS, KOikvTj, TTl TO y TOCToVde, 5
<y? ey<opat, Kat 6 7rarT/p Kal r) p.r]Tr]p <rot eTTLTpeTrovcriv Kal
ovk dvap.evovcrLV eW av TjAtKtW XV S ' Tav V a P /3ovAa>VTai

avrots rtva avayvooo-Orjvai r) ypacprjvaL, cre, a>s ey<Spat,
TTpOOTOV TtiiV (V TTJ OIKIO, 67Tt TOVTO TaTT0V0~LV. 7] yap',-~ D

>
Flaru y', ecprj. Otjkow ecfecrri aot evTav& otl dv /3otjAtj
Trp&Tov T(2v ypap.p.aTOiv ypd(pLV Kal ort ai> bevTepov kol

avayiyvdiaKiiv oicravTcos eêcrTLV. Kat e7ret8ai', a>s eya>p.at,
rrjv kvpav kdfiris, otj bLaKookvovo-i cre oilre 6 iraTr)p otJre t/ 5
pTjrrjp e7rtretât re Kat d*>eu>at tji> di/ /SotJAt/ ra>y \opb(2v,
Kal \/>TjAai Kat Kpoveiv rw 7rATjKrpa>. t/ <jiaKa>ATJoiJo-ii>; Od

OT/ra. Tt 7ror' ay otjV etrj, ai Atjcti, rd atrtoi' ort evravOa
p.ev ov biaKiokvovcrLV, ev ots be apTL ekeyop.ev kcoAtjotjcti; C
"Ort otpat, ecprj, ravra p.ev eiricrTapLaL, eKeiva o' ov. Ete^,
i]v b' eya>, a> apto-re -

ovk apa Tr)v T/AtKtay o~ov 7reptjueVet
6 7rarr/p eTTLTpeireLV 7rdwa, dAA' r/ d^ r)pepa r)yi]crr)Tai <re
/3e'Artov avrou (ppoveiv, ravrT/ e7rtrpe'\//et aot Kat a7jroi> Kat 5
rd avrov. Otpat eycoye, ecprj. Eier, t/i/

8' eyar rt 8e'; r<3
yetrort ap ov\ 6 avros dpos ocrirep rto 7rarpt 7rept <roi>;
iroTepov otet avrbv e7rtrpe'v//etv <rot ttjtj avrou olKiav olkovo- d

peiv, oTav TjyT/o-Tjrat /3e'Ario>J 7rept olKovop.ias kavTov
qbpovziv, t/
<re
ai/roy e7rt<rrarT/<retr;
'E/xot e7rtrpe'\êty otpat.
Tt o'; 'At^Tji/atovs otet aot ovk e7rtrpe'\/>ety rd avrSiv, orav
aiarOdvoiVTaL otl LKavws (ppov&s; -"Eycoye. ITpos Atds, t]v 5
8' iyoi, t'l dpa 6 p.ty as /3ao-iAevs; Trorepov rco 7rpe<r/3vrarcj)
vet, ou t/ ri]s 'Aatas dpx^) yiyveraL, pakkov av e7rtrpe-
v/Veiei k\f/op,evoiv Kpeotv [Zpftdkkciv} otl av ftovkrrraL Ip.-
a4 irw corr. Coisl. : irov BT W a 7 %XV S scr# recc - :

X '^
BTW :
<rxf)s? H. Richards Tiva] ri f) Badham
a8 b7 tyrjAat
BT W sed in marg. tiA.ch T yp. Kal ri\\at in marg. W C 1 iv
W
:
ols . . . KuKvovfft om. sed add. in marg. W c6 ti Sai' rwt in

ras. B 3
d1 oIkovojxuv T 2
olKotio/xelv BT W d2 olKovo/xias
W W
:
T : otKoSo/xias B d7 4ntTpfyetev tyui/xtvwv (sed o supra w

W) : ntTpt\Ltiv 4vt\f/0fxevwv B : intTpetyttev iv t\f/o/.itvwv T d8 e'/u-
&a\\uv secl. Hcindorf : if.ifio.htiv Bekker (secl. mox ifxfiahtlv)

;
2og e IIAATfiNOS
e /3aAetu ets rbv oop.6v, r/ rjp.lv, et d<pLKop.evoL 7rap' eKelvov
eV8etatp,e0a avr<o drt r)pels KaAAtoy <ppovovp,ev r) 6 vbs
avrov irepl o\//ou crKeuacrias; 'HpXv 8Âoy drt, e<pr).
Kat roy /xeV ye ov8' di> <rp,LKpbv edcretev e/x/3aAeiy r/p,ds
5 8e', /cdy e f3ovX.oCp.c6a bpadp.evoL t<ov dX.&v, ecor/ di/
ep,/3aAeu\ ITcos ydp ov,*' Tt 8' et tovs 6<p9aXp,ovs 6 vbs

avTov ao-Qevol, apa ecor/ av avTov a-nTtcrOai toov eavTov
2io 6<p9a\p,S>v,
'Hpds
p.r) larpbv i)yovp,evos, r) koo\vol av; KcoAriot
dv. 8e ye et VTTo\ap,(3dvoL laTpuovs etvai, Kav
et (3ov\oCp,e9a bLavoCyovTes tovs 6<p9a\p.ovs ep7rdcrai rrjs
Tecppas, olp.ai ovk. av K<o\v<reLev, r)yovp.evos 6p9a>s cppovelv.
5
'AAr/0r/ Aeyets.
'Ap' ovv Kal rdAAa 7rdi>ra r)p2v kiti-
rpe7rot av paWov r/ eaurco Kat rco vet, 7rept 6Vcoz> av

booop.ev avria <ro<p<oTepoL eKeCvoov elvaL; 'AydyKr/, ec/>r/, a
2coKpares.
Ovt<os apa eêt, r)v 8' eyco, co cptAe Arjcrr ets p.ev Tavra,
f/
b d av <pp6vip.0L yev<6p.e9a, cnravTes rjpuv eitLTpeypova-LV, EA-
Ar/ves re Kat (3dp(3apoL Kal avbpes Kal yvvalKes, TTOLr)crop,ev
re ev tovtols otl av (3ov\<6p,e9a, ko.1 orjSets rjpJas eKoov elvaL

e/x7ro8tet, dAA' avrot re e\ev9epoL ecrope9a ev avrols kol
5 dWoov apxovTts, rjperepd re ravra lcrrat 6vrjcr6p,e9a yap
air' avrcov
ets & 8' av vovv p.r) KTr)cr(6p,e9a, ovre tls rjpiv
e7rtrpe'\êt itepl aurd iroLelv tcl rjpXv boKovvra, dW ep.7ro-
C 8io{kh 7rdyres Ka&* otl dv bvvoovTai, ov p.6vov ol dAAdrptoi,

dAAd Kat d 7rarr)p Kat r) p.rrrr]p Kal et rt tovtoov otKetdrepdv
icrTLv, ai)TOL T v ovtoIs <r6p,9a dAAcoy VTrqKOOL, koll rjplv
ecrrat dAAdrpta' ovbev yap d-n avToiv 6vr]cr6p.<i9a. crvyyot-
5 pet? ovrcos eêty; 2uyxcopcd. -'Ap' ovv rco c/)tAot ecr6p.e9a
KaC tls r)p,ds cptA?/cret ev tovtols, iv ols dv oopav dvoxpekcls
ai foTpb^BTWPriscianus: larpiKbv scr. Coisl. &% Stavolyovres

W :Siayayovres B Siav vyovres T: a6 Jc S6^wjxtv] Si] $6ai/xev
ci. H. Richards a 7 aurip fitelvoov] avrwv eKeivy Heindorf
. . . . . .
a 9 &pa x t Priscianus &pa x ot ^ ^ : : av ex 01 c ^ Stallbaum

&p'
b6 & in ras. duarum litterarum B c6 <pt\-fi<rei ev scr. Laur.
Ixxxv. 17 : <pi\ricreiev eVBTW
AT2I2 210 c
Ov
.
biJTa, i(pi]. Nw dpa ovba cra 6 irarrjp oiba dkkos
dkkov ovbava (pLkal, Kad' ocrov av ?/ d\pr)crTos. Ovk aoLKav,

|0jj. .'Eaz> pXv apa cro(pbs yavij, S) iraT, TrdvTas ctol (pikoL d
koX irdvTas ctol otKetot tcrovTai xpr]crLp.os yap ml ayadbs
icrrj et ba p.r], crol ovra akkos ovbels ovra 6 7rar?/p (pikos
earat ovTd r) p.i]Tr]p ot/re ol oiKetot. olov re ovv airl tovtols,
& Avctl, p.aya (ppovaiv, av ols tls p.r)Tro) cppoval; Kat tt&s 5
av; acpt). Et V apa crv bibacrKakov bar), ovtto) (ppovals.

'AkrjOr}. Ov8' apa p.ayak6(ppo)v et, atirap dcppoov ert. Ma
Ata, acpt), oi) ScoKpares, ov p.ot boKaX.
Kat eyco aKovcras avrov dirafikaypa Trpbs tov Yimodakr), e
cat okiyov arjp,apTov' aTrrjkOa ydp /uot et7retv ort Ovrco
X/)?/,
co 'linToOakas, rols 7rat8tK0ts biakayacrOai, Ta-naivovvTa
koX crvcrTakkovTa, dkka p.r) &cnrap crv yawovvTa koX biaOpv-
TiTovra. KaTLbtov ovv avrbv dycozuooVra Kal Ta8opv(3r)p.avov 5
virb tQ)V kayop.avo)V, dvap.vr]o~8r)v otl Kal TrpocracrTws kav-

OdvaLV tov Avctlv afiovkaTO' dvakafiov ovv ap.avrbv kol
aTracryov tov koyov. koX av roirrcp 6 Mavaavos TrdkLV r)Kav, 211
Kat aKada*T0 Trapd tov Avctlv, 66 av kol ecfaueVr?/. 6 ovv
Avctls p.dka 7rat8iK(Ss Kat (pLkiK(2s, kddpq tov Mavaavov,

crp.LKpbv TTpos p.a kayoov aqbr)' *X2 ScoKoares, dirap Kal ap.ol
kayaLs, alira kol Mavaavo). 5
Kat eyco olttov, TaCra p.av crv avTia apals, o) Avctl'
TrdvToos ydp TTpocraTx*s T0V vovv.
Yldvv piav ovv, aabr).
rTetp<3 toCvvv, rjv b' ayor, aTTop.vr)p.ovavcraL avTa. otl
p.dkicrTa, tva tovto) cracpws irdvTa atirrfs' adv ba tl avT&v b

aTTtkddr), avdis p.a dvapacrOat oTav avTV\r)s irp&Tov.
'Akka TTOL-qcro), a(pr), ravTa, o) 2coKpare?, irdvv acpobpa,
av lctOl. dkkd tl dkko avrG> kaya, tva Kat eyco aKOVo),
acos av OLKaba u>pa 17 diTLavaL. 5
C 7 ovSe . . oiiSe . . .] oijre . . . oijre . . . ci. H. Richards d 5 (ppove?

T : <pp6vi/xos B W (sed o? supra i/ios W) d 8 80*] Sokw ci.
H. Richards h 2 avepeo-Qai] e in ras. B

2iib nAAT&NOS
'AAAd xprj ttouiv ravra, r)v 8' yco, kTrtt.hr) ye /cat <rv
KeAevets. dAAd opa ottcos kiriKovp^crus /uot, edr p.t eAe'yxetv

eVtxetpr/ 6 Mej>eei>os' 77 ovk olcrda ort eptariKds zcttiv;
Nat /xd Ata, ec/jr/, crcpohpa ye* 8ta ravrd rot Kat /3od-
C kop.aC cre avrco 8taAe'yecr#ai.
"Iya, r/v 5' eyco, Karaye'Aaaros yeVco/utai;
Ow /ixd Ata, ecprr, dAA' tW avrbv KoAdcrrrs.
Ylodtv; r)v 8' eyco. ov pahiov heivbs yap 6 av6pd>Tros,
5 Krriat7r7rou p.a6r]Tf)s. 7rdpecrrt 5e' rot avrds ovy^ bpas;

Krr/cri7r7ros.
MriSeyds crot, ec/jrr, p.eAe'rco, co ScoKpares, dAA' i#i
8taAe'yorj avrco.
AtaAeKreor, r/v 0' eyco.
10 Taura ow r)p.S>v keyovroov Trpbs ??/xds avrods, Ti v/xets,
ec/jrr 6 Krr/at7r7ros, arjrob p.oVco kcmao-6ov, fip.lv 8e ov

d pera8t'8oroi; rcov Adycoz;;
'AAAd p.f)v, r)v 0' eyco, p,era8ore'oi>. o'8e ydp rt coy Ae'yco
011 p.avdavei, dAAd cpr/crtv otecrflat Mez>e'ei>ov etSeVat, Kat

KeAevet tovtov epcordy.
5 lt ow, r/ os, ovk epcorcts;
'AAA' epr/cro/xai, r/i> 8' eyco. Kat //,01 et7re', a Mei>e'ez>e,
d av cre epco/xat. ruyx c* i;a) yaP ^K watSds kTn.6vp.Qiv Krr]-
/uards rou, cocr7rep dAAos dAAorj. pei> ydp rts i7r7ro?js
e (Trtfvp.eT KTacrdat, 6 8e Kvvas, 6 8e yjpvcrCov, 8e rtpds*

eyco 8e 7rpds /uei> raura 7rpacos e^co, 7rpds 8e Tr\v tG>v cpCkcov
KTrjcrcv Trdvv epcortKcos, Kat j3ovkoCp.r)v av p.01 cpCkov ayadbv

yevicrdai p.akkov r) tov dptcrroj' iv avdpa>Trois oprvya r/
5 ak^KTpvova, Kat val p.a Ata eycoye p.akkov r/ i7T7rov re Kat

Kwa olp.ai 8e', 7Jr) rdf w, p.akkov r) to AapeCov xpvcriov
KTf)cracr6ai heaCp.r]v Trokv TrpoTepov tTaxpov, p.akkov (8e)
b7 Cobet
fipa secl. tiriKovpJjcreis T : iiriKovpâris B (rjjtr refictum
in sed non videtur etcr fuisse)
ras. 6 2 irp^ws'] irapepycos ci.
H. Richards (coll. Dinarch. 3. 14) e 7 fiaWov t) aiiruv Aapuov
secl. Schanz 6e add. Buttmann

ATSI2 2iie
r) ovtov Aapelov ovto>s eya> oiiAeVatpo'? rts et/u. vp.as
ovv 6pG>v, o-4 re Kal Avctlv, KTTTrkr]yp.aL Kat vbaLp.ovCo) 212

ort ovtu> VOL 6vtS oXol r kcrTov TOVTO TO KTT]fXa Ta\v Kal
pqbC<os KTaa-OaL, Kal <rv re tovtov ovtoj cpCkov kti]<to> ra\v
re Kal acpobpa, Kal av ovtos <t' eya> 5e ovra> Troppco et/xt
TOV KTT]p.aTOS, U>OT 01*5' OVTLVa TpOTTOV yCyVTaL <f)Ck0S 5

Tpos krtpov otba, dkkd ravra 5t) avrd o-e (3ovkop.aL
ipicrdaL a.T ejurretpor.
Kat p.oc Lirv e7ret5dy rts rtz>a <pLkrj, 7ro'repos Troripov
<pCkos yiyvTaL, 6 <pLk<OV TOV <pLkovp,VOV rj 6 <f)Lkovp.VOS b

tov <pLkovvTos' v ovbV StadWpet; Ovbiv, cf>t], e/xotye
5oKet bLacppLV. ITajs Ae'yets; r)v 5' eyw" dp.<poTpoL apa

dkkl]ko>V <f)CkoL yCyVOVTaL, <XV p.OVOS 6 TpOS TOV Tp0V
cpLkij;
"E/uotye, cpr\, 5oKet. Tt ovk <ttlv cpikovvTa 5
5e';
p.i] dvTLcpLkLcr6aL vtto tovtov bv

dv <pLkfj; "Eotiv. Tt 5e';
dpa cttlv Kal pucr^lcrdaL cpLkovvTa; oXov ttov eznore boKovcrL
Kal ol epaorat 7rdo~x. LV ^pos Ta 7rai8tKd* cpikovvTcs yap
<ws oXov re /xaAtaTa ol p.V otovTaL ovk dvTLcpLk^lcrdaL, ol C
5e at pLLo~lcr6aL. r/ ovk dkr]6S . 5oKet o*ot tovto;
Scpobpa ye, <pr], dki]6S. Ovkovv iv tG> tolovtco, r)v
8'
eya>, 6 p.v <pLkL, 6 5e c/jiAeirai; Nat,- noYepos ovv av-

tG>V TTOTpOV CpCkoS CTTLV; 6 <pLkG>V TOV <pLkovp.VOV, aVT 5
Kat dvTLcpLkijraL avT Kat /xto^rat, rj 6 <pLkovp.vos tov
<f)Lk0VVT0S; 1] Ol)bTpOS av V r<5 TOLOVTO) Ol/bTpOV CpCkoS
dv dp,<poTpoL dkkijkovs <f>Lk<2cnv; ÊotKe yovv
<ttlv,
ovto>s eêt^.

fir)
'AAAotoos apa vvv r)pXv SoKet rj irpoTpov d

bo^V. TOT p.V ydp, et 6 TpOS 0tAot, <pCko> LVaL apt,cpo)'
vvv 8e', dv p.r) d/xojo'repot cpLkGxriv, ovbTpos cpCkos. Klv-

bvvVL, cpr]. Ovk dpa <tt\v cpCkov r<S cpikovvTL ovb\v p.1]
OVK aVTLCpLkoVV. Ol)K OLKV. Ov8' &pa <pCkLTT7ToC clcTLV 5
a 3 crv T Heindorf <rb 8e B T : b4 (i6vos~\ fi6vos fi6vov ci.

C. Schmidt /xovov ci. H. Richards
: ci ol fiev Heindorf : ol6/xevoi
BT C4 itoTtpos Hirschig dnortpos : BT c6 nal a.vTt<pi\rJTai\
fir) avTKpiA^Tai ci. H. Muller

212 d nAAT&NOS
ovs av ot iWoi 1X7] d/mcpiAcocrizJ, ovb\ cptAdpruyes, o?j8' av
tpiXoKvvis ye Kal cptAoivot kol cpiAoyjjpmcrrai nal cptAdcrocpot,
av p.r\ r) o-oqbCa avrovs avTiqbtXfj. r) cptAoJJcri p.ev ravra
e eVcaoroi, ov peVrot cptAa ovra, dAAd \x/eJj8e0' 6 i:oLriTr]s, bs
oA/3io?, co iralbes re cptAot Kat p.b)vv\es '11:1:01
Kal kvvcs aypevTal Kal 4vos a\\obai:6s;
5 Ojjk epotye 8oKet, r] 8' os 'AAA' akrrOrj 8oKei? \4ytLV croi;
Nat. Td qbLX.ovp.evov apa rcp cpiAoJjVri qbCXov Icttlv, cos
olkV, ) Mev4tV, tavTe cptAr/ ZavTt Kat /wictt]' otoy Kat

tcl vcuxttl yeyovdra 7rai8ta, ra piev OJjSeVco cpiAojjVra, ra
213 8e Kat pLLo-ovvra, drai> KoAdr/rai v7ro rr/s p.r)Tpbs 17 v7ro ro?j
7rarpo'?, d/xco? Kat p.LcrovvTa ei> eKetVco xpovu
rcp i:avTU)v
pdAtcrrd ecrrt rots yojjejjcrt cptArara.
"Epotye 8oKet, ecpr/,
ojjrco? eêtv. Otjk dpa 6 cptAcor qbCXos eK tovtov tov Xoyov,

5 dAA' d qbiXovpievos. v
EotKez>. Kat 6 p.Lcrovp.vos exflpds
dpa, dAA' ojjx 6 piaw. <J>at7Jerai. HoAAot dpa Tj7rd rcoy
tyOp&v cptAojjVrat, vi:b 8e rcoy qbCXoov picroTjVrai, Kat rots
b pey kyOpois cptAot etcrtz;, rot? 8e cptAots 4y6poC, et rd cptAojj-
fxtvov qbCXov ecrrir dAAd pr/ rd (pLXovv. Katrot 7toAAt/
aXoyCa, cptAe eratpe, pLaXXov 8e otpat Kai abvvarov, rco

co
re cptAco exOpbv Kal rco ex#pco <p&ov etyat.

'AAr/flr], ecpr/,
5 eotKas \4yeLv, a ScoKpares. Otjkojjz; et roJjr' d8waroJ, rd

cpiAoijv di> etr/ qbCXov roCi qbLX.ovpi.4vov. âtz/erat. Td
piLarovv apa ttoXlv iydpbv tov p.Lo-ovp.ivov. .'AydyKr/. Od-
KoSy TavTa ripXv cr?jp/3T/crerat avayKoxov etrat dpoAoyetr,
C a7rep e7ri rcoy npoTepov, 7roAAaKis cptAoy etz>at pr/ cptAou,
7roAAaKts 8e Kai ydpv> OTav r) p.rj qbikovv tls (pL\fj r) Kal

p.LO~ovv cptA^* 7roAAaKty 8' i)(6pbv etmt pt) kydpov r) ml
cptAou, oray t) (/j,t)) pLLcrovv tls pio"f/ r} Kai cptAow ptcrr/.
5 KtijSjjyeTjet, ecpr/.^ Tt otjjj 8t/ xpr)o-(ap.z6a, r/v 8' eyco, et pr/re
6 7 aj' re (/ur?) ^jAt} Schanz a 6 /xitwv scr. recc. <piAa>i> :
BT W e4 ^ (U^ (iktovv tis Cornarius ^ m<rovv ns B T

: /utj :
lj.i<rovv Tts scr. recc. yuto-jj scr. recc. (/jjAtj B T

: om. Cornarius :
; :
AT2I2 213C
01 (pL\0VVT(S (pCkOL 0~OVTOU UT/re 01 (pL\0V]XV0L ]Xr']T 01
(f)t,\ovvTes re kcu cptAoTJueyot; dAAd Kai 7rapd Tavra aAAous

tivcls ert (pi]cro]Xv etrat (pCkovs dKkqkoLs yiyvofxzvovs <
Ov fxa. tov ACa, ecpT/, co ScoKpares, ov irdvv aviTopS) eycoye.

*Apa ]xrj, r)v 8' eyco, co Mez>e'ei>e, to Trapcnrav ovk 6p6u>s d
(r]Tov]Xv; Ovk epLoiye doKet, co ScoKoares, ecpT/, 6 Avcrt?,
Kai d]xa et7JW ripvdpCacrtv e8oKet ydp uot <xkovt ovtov
eKcpe?Jyetz> to \ty6\v bta to crrpobpa 'npocrtyeiv tov vovv
toIs AeyoueVot?, brjkos 8' rjv Kal otc rjKpoaTo ovtuis cov -
<!x. 5
'Eyco ovv ]3ov\6pi.evos tov re Meêêrop avaitavcrai Kal
ckzCvov r)cr6els rfj cptAocrocpia, ovrto uera/3aAcoi> 7rpos tov

Axxtlv (7roLOV]xr]v tovs Xoyovs, Kal (lttov *Xi Avcrt, a\r]6rj e
uot SoKets Ae'yeti> ort et 6pd<2s T/ueis crK07Tov]xev, ovk av
7rore ovt(s 7rX.avco]X6a. dAAd tovti] ]xkv u?7Ke'rt tcouei>
Kai yap x a^^V rfe ]xol (paCvtraL axnrep obos r) crKt\pLs r/
8e (TpaTrrifxev, 8oKet ]xol \prjvaL UvaL, (TKOTTOvvTa [to.) Kard 5

tovs TTOLtfTas' ovtol yap r)]xlv uxrirep 7rare'pes Trjs cro(pCas 214
etcriv Kat rjyefxovts. Aeyoucri 8e br/irov ov (pavkuts diro<paLv6-
]xevoL 7rept Tu>v (pCXcov, 0% Tvyydvovo-LV oWes* dAAd rdz> 0edy
avTov (pao-LV ttolcIv <pC\ovs ovtovs, dyovTa- itap dXXrjXovs.
Aeyovcrt bk ttms raura, cos eycouat, co8t 5
atet rot tov olloIov dyet 0eos co? tw olloIov
Kal 7rotet yvdpLfxov ?/ ovk errerTJx^Kas rovrots rots <[tto~lv; b

"Eycoy', ecpT/. Ovkovv Kal tols tQ)V crocpcordrcoi> crvyypd]x-
p.acrLV evTTV)(r]Kas Tavra avrd X&yovcrLV, otl to ollolov rco
ouotcp d^dyKT/ dei (pCkov eTvac; dcrlv 8e' 7rou ovrot ot 7rept
cpvcrecos re Kai roi) oAou StaAeyoperot Kai ypd(povTcs. 5

'AAr/^r}, ecpT/, Ae'yets. -*Ap' ovv, r)v 8' eyco, ev \iyovo~Lv;
c 7 &\A&] 2po ci. Comarius (ante dAAa signum interrogandi posuit
Goldbacher) C 9 eviropw B T 2 a-ropw T d 2 (/>?; Vat. 1029
: :
om. B T 65 aKoirovvra] ffKo-rovvras ci. Schleiermacher ra secl.

Heindorf a 5 uoi T unSt B (sed 5f ex emend. in ras.) diS-fjv
: : W
b 3 ravra avra^ ravra ravra Heindorf b 4 avdyKi- B
avdyKri T
-
214 b ITAATI2N0S
"Ictojs, icprj. "1(T(0S, r)v 8' eyco, to rjp,io~v avrov, tcrcos 8e kclI
ttclv, dAA' r)p.els ov crvvCep.v. 8oKet yhp r)piv 6 ye Trovrjpos

C rv yCyvecrdau dStKet ydp' dbiKOVVTas 8e koX

dbiKovp.ivovs abvvaTov irov cpCkovs elvai. ovx ovrcos; Nat,
r) 8' os. Tadrr/ piiv av tolvvv tov AeyotteVorj to rjp.i.crv ovk
dkrjdts dkkr)kois
5
Aeyets.
'AAAa drj, et7rep
/uot
ol Trovrjpol
boKovcnv Aeyety tovs ayadovs 6p.oCovs

d/uotot. ?A.kr\6r)
etât dkkr)kois Kat cpCkovs, tovs 8e KaKovs, oTrep Kat Ae'yerat

Trept avT&v, p.r)biiTOT 6p.oCovs /u,r/8' avrovs avrois etvai, dAA'
d p.irkf}KTovs re Kat acrTa6p.r\Tovs' o 8e avro avrco avop.oi.ov
etri Kat bidcpopov, o-\okfj yk rcp dAAw 6p.oi.ov r) cpCkov yivovr
dv. r\ ov Kat <rot 8oKet ovtcos; "Ep.o-y, icprj. ToCro
toCvvv alviTTOvrai, <ws ip.ol boKovcriv, <o eratoe, ot to 6p.oi.ov
5 tG> 6p.oCu> cpCkov kiyovrts, a>? d dyados r<5 aya6S> p.6vos

p.6v(ti cpCkos, 6 8e KaKos ovre dya6S> oi/re KaK<3 ovbirroTe
ets akr]6r) cpikCav ipytTai. <rw8oKet <rot; KareVerjo-er.
"Eypp.V apa r/8r/ rtzês etVty ot cpCkoi' 6 yap Adyos fjp.lv
e crrjp,aCvi. drt -ot av cocrii/ dyadoC. Yidvv ye, ec/>rr, 8oKet.

Kat ip.oC, r]y'8' eyco. Katrot bvcryepaCva> tC ye ei> arjrar
</>e'pe ow, a irpos Atd?, tb(op.V tC Kal vttotttVu>. 6 6p.oios

r<3 6p.oC(o Ka0' oo-oy 6p.oios (pCkos, Kat eoTtz> yjpf)crip.os 6
5 rotorjros r<3 rotorjrw; pukkov 8e <58e* driow op.oiov otuovv
d/xotfa) ru>a cacpekCav eêty r/ rtâ j3kdfir]v dv Trotr^crat
8rjyatro, 6 /ur) Kat avrd ar)r<3; ?7 rt dy Tradelv, 6 p.r\ Kat r3</>'
215 avTov irddoi; ra brj TOiavra tt&s dv vtt' dkkfjkcov dyaTrrjdtCr],

p.r\bep.Cav iiriKovpCav dAAr/Aot? eypVTa > ôtiv ottojs; Ovk
icrTiv. A
8e p.r\ dyair&To, irG>s cpCkov; Oi>bap.&s.
'AAAd
br) 6 piev 6p.01.os rai d/xoto) ov cpCkos' 6 8e dyaOos rai dya6Q>
b8 011 T W : om. B e 1 -irpotrtr) T : wpoo-etT) B C2 Se in

ras. refinxit
7' Bekker
B 2
d2 l'i) T : &> efrj B
BT
ax ^ 7
62
BT : rxoAp
î/ yivoir &v scripsi : yevoiro ti 7] 76 ti
ci. H. Richards e6 ex' B ex 6 T: : sec '- Schanz e 7 prius
i] ^v ci. H. Richards at/Tcp B T abro : T*

AT2I2 2J5a
y v
na.Q' ocrov dyados, ov Ka6 ocrov op.oios, cpCkos av e?r/; Io-cos. 5
Tt ov\ 6 dyados,
y
Ka6 ocrov dyados, Kard toctovtov
Nat.'O ye
8e';
iKavbs av et?/ avTu>; 8e' iKavbs ovbevbs beo-

p.evos Kard rr)v iKavoTrjTa. ydp 'O IIcos ov; be pf] tov
bop.evos ovbk rt dyair^r]Ov yap *0 av. ovv. 8e p.r) b
ayaiiwrj, ovb* av cptAot. Ov 'O ye bijra. 8e /xr/ cptkcav ov
cpikos. Ov cpalvzTai. ayaOoi ayadois
Ilais ovv 61 rots
r)p.lv cpCkoL ccrovTai. Trjv apyxiv, 0% //rjre d7roVres Trodeivol
dAAr/Aots tKavol yap earjrots Kal \u>pls dVres p-rjre 7ra- 5
poVres xpeiav avrS>v eyovcriv; tovs br) tolovtovs tis p.rj\avi]
7repi Trokkov 7roteto-c9at dAAr/Aorjs; Ovb(p.ia, ecpr/. <J>t'Aoi
8e ye ovk av etey p.i] 7repi iroWov TroLovp.VOL kavrovs. C

'AAr/flr/.
v
At9pet bij, a Avcri, irfj irapaKpovopeda. apd ye oAcp
tivX e<fa7rarcopec9a; IIcos br/; ecpr/.- "Hbrj ttot4 tov iJKovcra
kiyovTOS, koX dprt avap.ipvr\crKopai, otl to p.\v opoLOV tS> 5
oftota) Kal ol dya6ol rots dyatfots TroAejutco rarot etey Ka\ brj
Kal tov 'Ho-toSoy e7rr/yero p.dprvpa, kiycov cos apa <$>

Kat Kepa/xei/? Kepapet Kore'et Kai dotdos dot5co U 1
Kat TTT(i>-)(OS 7!TC0X<f>> d
Kat raAAa br) irdvTa ovtcos ecpr/ dvayKaiov etrat pdAtcrra ra
6//otdrara (jrpbs) dAAr/Aa cpQovov re Kat cpikovLKias k6X
e\6pas epiripirkacrdaL, tcl 8' dvopoioTara cpiAias* r6y ydp
Trkvrxra tS> 7rAot>cricp drayKaêcrdai cpikov etrat Kai rw dcrdevfj 5
rai lcrxvpQ Trjs iTriKovpCas VKa, kol tov KapvovTa rco larp5>,
Kai iravTa 8r/ roy /xr) et8o'ra dyairdv tov et'80'ra Kai cptAetr.
Kai 8r/ Kai ert e7re<^/et rco Ao'ya) /AeyaAo7rpe7re'orepo^, Ae'ycoy e
cos dpa 7rai>r6s 8e'ot ro opoiov rco 6/xotco cpCkov eXvai, dAA'
avro ro kvavrCov etr/ rorjrou* ro ydp evavricaTaTov tS>
eravrtcordrcp etrat p.dAtcrra cpCkov. (TridvpeTv yap tov
b 1 & . . . o-yainp?)] i . . . ctôirwj' ci. Schleiermacher d2 ec/>j
BW: &f>dVT) T d3 add. corr. Coisl.

irpor d7 c^jAer^TW:
</>iAe?>' koI c/>(\6t*^* B : <pi\tiv /col </>iAe?fftro( b 64 iirt0vfie?i> T W :
iiriBvfxf? B
2i5e nAATHNOS
5 tolovtov eKacrrov, dAA' ov tov 6p.oiov to p.ev yap <^r\pbv
vypov, tq be xj/vxpbv 6eppov, to be TiiKpbv yXvKeos, rb be

6v dp,j3Xeos, to be Kevbv irXriptocrecos, kol to TrXrjpes be
Kevcocrecos, kcu rdAAa ovtco Kard rbv avrbv Xoyov. rpocpr)v
yap etvaL to evavriov ru evavrico' to yap op.oLov tov 6p.oiov
216 ovbev av diroXavcraL. koX p.evTOL, S> eratpe, Kal Kop.\j/bs
eboKL elvai raura Xeycov ev yap eXeyev. vp.lv be, r\v 8'
eyco, 770)s 8oKet Xeyeiv; Ev ye, Hcpr] 6 Mevegevos, cos ye

ovT(t)arl aKovaai. $>G>p.ev apa to evavTiov rco evavrico p.d-
5 Atora cpiXov elvai; Yldvv ye. Elev, r\v 8' eyco* ovk dXXo-
kotov, co Meveêve; Kal fjpZv evdvs acrp,evoi TTLTTr]brjtrovTaL
ovtoi ol TrdcrcrocpoL dvbpes, ol dvTikoyiKoi, Kal epr)o~ovTaL et
b ovk evavTKOTarov t\6pa cpiXiq; dls Ti airoKpivovp.eda; rj
ovk dvdyKr) 6p,oXoyeiv otl dXrjdrj XeyovcrLV, 'AvdyKrj. 'Ap'

ovv, cprjcrovcrLV, to eydpbv rcp cpiXco tpiXov to cpiXov rcp
Ovberepa, 'AAAd bUaLov
rj
ey6pco; etprj. to rco d8iKco, rj to

5
'AAAd dyadbv rw
crtocppov Tto aKoXacrTco, Ovk dv rj ro kokco; p.oi
boKel ovtlos exeii\' ye Kara p.evTOL, r\v 8' eyco, elirep
tt]v evavTLOTryrd tC tco ravra

[cptAco] tpiXov etrriv, dvdyKr) kcxl
cpiXa eTvaL. Owre dpa

'AydyKrj. to bpiOLOV rco 6p.oiio ovre
to evavriov rcp eyazmco cpiXov. Ovk eoLKev.
C "Etl be Kal ro'8e o-Ke^rtop.e6a, p.r) ert p.dXXov r)p.as Xav6d-

VL to cpiXov tos dXr]6G>s ovbev tovtcov ov, dXXd to p.rrre
dyadbv p.r\Te mKov cpiXov ovtco ttot yLyvop.evov tov dyadov.

ITcos, rj 8' bs, Aeyeis,*' 'AAAd p.d Aia, r\v 8' eyco, ovk
5 oi8a, dAAd rcp ovtl avrbs eiAiyytco vtto rfjs tov Xoyov diro-
pias, Kal KLvbvveveL Kara Tr\v dpyaiav TTapoLp.iav to KaXbv
cpiXov etvaL. eoLKe yovv p.aXaKto tlvl Kai Aetcp Kat XLTrapco'
d 8to Kat tcrcos pabicos bLoXLcrdaiveL Kal 8ta8verat rjpMS, dre
tolovtov ov. Xeyco ydp rdyadbv KaXbv etWf trv 8' ovk
as o.\\6kotov Baiter o.\\ok6tohv B T

: o.\\ok6tus t : b^ to
T : to B (sed ^ suprascr. B 2 ) b 7 Ttp <pi\ov Cornarius t <pi\u :
<pi\ov Bt: Ttfi <pi\ov <pi\ov T ci tn fiaWov TW: om. B

\av$&vei] ei in ras. B d 1 fcrws] ovtws Schanz

AT2I2 2i6d
otet;
w
Eycoye. Aeyco tolvvv diropavTevopevos, rov Kakov
re Kai dyadov (pikov elvaL to pr]Te dyaObv pr]T /ca/coV
irpbs a be keycov pavTevopaL, aKovo~ov. boKel jjlol (ixnrepel 5
Tpia arra etimt yivt], to pev ayaOov, to be KaKov, to 8' ovr

dyadbv ovre KaKov tl be croi; Kat ep.oi, ecpr). Kat ovtz
TayaObv Taya6G> ovtc to KaKov rw KaKu> ovt rayaObv rco
kokco cpikdv elvai, uxrnep ovb' 6 epLTrpoo-Qev koyos ea* Aet- e

irerat 8?j, ei7rep rco rt cttlv cpikov, to pi]T ayaObv pi]T
KaKov (pikov elvaL i] tov dyaOov r/ tov tolovtov olov avro
cttlv. ov yap dv ttov rco KaK(o (pikov av tl yevoLTO.
:
' k\r\Qr\. Ovb\ pr)v to op.OLOV rco 6poi(o e(papev aprt* rj 5
ydp; Nat. Ovk dpa ecrrat rco p.t]Te dyaflco p.i]T KaKco to
tolovtov (pikov olov ovto. Ov (paiveraL. Tcp dya6G> apa
to prrre ayaObv p.i]T KaKov p.6v(o povov (rvp. r3aiveL yiyvecr6aL 217
(pikov. *
kvayKt], co? eoLKev.
*Ap' ovv Kal Kaka>$, rjv 8' eyco, S) Tralbes, ixprjyeLTaL r)piv
to vvv keyopevov ; et yovv dekoipev evvorjcraL to vyLaXvov

crco/xa, ovbev larpLKrjs Setrat ovbe dxpekias' LKav(2s yap X* L > &
cocrre vyLaivcov ovbels tarpco cpikos 8td rr)v vyieLav. rj ydp;

Ovbeis. 'AAA' 6 Kapv(ov olpaL 8td Tr)v voaov. FIcos yap
NoVos pev
ov; br) KaKov, tarpiKT/ be GxpekLpov Kat dyaOov. b
Nat. Sco/xa 8e ye 7rou Kara to crG>p.a clvai ovre dyadbv
ovre KaKov.- Ovrcoj. 'Ayayxdêrat 8e ye crco/ua 8td voctov
XaTpLKr)v do"ndêcr6aL Kal (pikdv. Ao*cet poL,Tb /u?/re
KaKov apa pr\T dyadbv cpikov yiyveraL tov dyadov 8td KaKOu 5
Trapovo-iav. v
EoiKez>. AÂo^ 8e' ye ort TTplv yevea-QaL avrb
KaKov virb tov KaKov ov eêL. ov yap brj ye KaKov yeyovbs
ert dv tl tov dyaOov [ov] etTLdvpol koCl (pikov etrj* dbvvaTov C
yap e(papev KaKov dya9S> (pikov eXvaL. 'Abvvarov ydp.
d5 Aeywj/] fiAetruv ci. anonymus apud Heindorf e a 8^
Heindorf: 5'BT 63 rov ayaBov B ov rov ayadov T
: 64 &/
7roi/] diiirov Schanz a r yiyveaQai <pl\ov T yiyvfcrOat B W :
a4 48(\oifj.fv Ast c 1 ert ci. Salvini eVn B 4o~riv T

: &v ri
:
C. Schmidt : avrl BT : av Heindorf ov om. recc.

::
ai7 c nAATjQNOS
^Ke\pacr6e 8j/ 6 Aeya>. Ae'y<o yap otl eVta p.ev, olov av f\
to irapov, ToiavTa eort kcu avra, evLa 8e ov. &cnrep et
5 edekoL tls \p<ap.aTi ro> otiovv [tl] cxkefyaL, trapecrTCv ttov
t& aXeLcpdevTL t6 TrakeLcp6ev. Tlavv ye. kp r

ovv /cat
eo-Tiv tot tolovtov ti]v xpoav to akeicpdev, olov to ttov;
d Ov p.avdavco, r) 8' os.

'AAA' <38e, ?fy
8' eyco. ei rts
y\ (tou avdas ovcras tcls TpCâs \}rLp.v6C(f akeC\j/Lev, Trorepov
tot kevKal eTev av; <PaCvoLVT av, 8' 09.
Nat.
rj cpaCvoLVT r)
Kat p.r)v irapeLi) y av avrals kevKorrjs. 'AAA' 6p.cos
ovbev tl p.akkov av elev kevKaC ttco, dkka irapovo-ns kevKo-
fj
5
ti]tos ovre tl kevKal ovt p.ekaLvaC LCTLV. 'AAA'

'AXrjOr).
/f otov
y6-yf\,
br\, 3) cpCke, to yrjpas avraXs tovtov tovto xp5>p.a eira-
tot eyivovro oXovrrep to irapov, kevKov irapovo-Ca
tf
e kevKaC- USts yap ov; Touro toCvvv epcorw vvv brj, el a>
av tl irapr), tolovtov earat to ex ov oXov to irapov rj eav

piev Kard Tiva Tpoirov Trapfj, earat, eav be p.r), ov; OvTca
p.dkkov, ecpr). Kat to p.r)T KaKov apa p.r\T ayadov evCore
kokov eoTLV 8' ot to
5 KaKOV irapovros ovttoi ecrrLV, ijbr)
tolovtov yiyovev. Ylavv ye. Ovkovv orav p.r)Troi KaKov f\
KaKov trapovTOS, avrr) p.ev r) irapovo-Ca dyadov avro ttoll
TTL6vp.lv 7) 8e KaKOV TTOLOVCra aTTOCTTepeZ aVTO TT)S T TTL-
6vp.Cas ap.a Ka\ tt)S cpLkCas tov ayadov. ov yap ert eo-rlv
218 ovt KaKov ovt o.ya66v, aAAa KaKov cpCXov 8e aya6> KaKov
ovk rjv. Ou yap ovv. Ata Tavra br) cpoZp.V av kol tovs
rjbr) crocpovs p.t]KTL cpLkocrocpeLV, etre 0eot etre avdpoiiroC
elcTLV ovtol' ou8' av eKeCvovs cpLXocrocpeLV tovs ovrcos ayvoLav

5 exovras &o-T mKovs eXvaL' KaKov yap koll ap.adrj ovbeva
cpLkoarocpeLV. KeCirovTaL brj ol exovTes p.ev to KaKov tovto,
Tr)v ayvoLav, p.r)irui 8e vtt avTOv ovres ayv(op.oves p.r)be
C5 Tt BTW:om. recc. c6 irdvv ye om. T BW:

C 7 a\ei<t>6cpHeindorf iiraKiupOiv B T : iirov (vel 4iri6v) Heindorf
Zri 6vBT d 3 rSre Heindorf irore B T altero loco <\>aivoir' av
:
B d 7 rovro B tovto rb T : a 1 oyafl^ naicbv Heindorf

ayaduiv KaKtZ T ayaObv Kay B t
:

ATSI2 2i8b
o.p.adels, a\\' crt r)yovp.evoL p.i] elbevaL a pi) lo-aatv. 810 b

8?/ koX <pLkoo~o<f)Ovo~iv ol ovt ayaOol ovre kukol ttlo ovtcs,
oa-ot be KaKol ov <pL\oa-o<povo-Lv, ovbe ol ayadoC' ovTe yap
TO (VaVTLOV TOV (VaVTLOV OVT TO OflOLOV TOV OpoCoV <pC\0V
7J-UV e<pavr) ev rots ep.Trpoo-dev \6yoLS. rj ov p.ep.vr)o-de; 5
Ylavv ye; icpaTrjv. Nw apa, rjv 8' eyco, u> Avcri re Kal
Meveêve, iravros p.a\\ov er]vpr)Kap.v 6 eo-TLV to <pC\ov ko.1
ov. <pap.ev yap avro, ml Kara Tr)v ~

rfvyr]V Kal Kara to
<rcop.a Kal iravTaypv, to p.r]Te KaKov /u?/re ayadov 8ta KaKOv C
irapovo-iav tov ayadov <pC\ov eXvaL,- YlavTairao-LV <pa.Tr)v re
Kat crvve\copeLTr)v ovtco tovt eyjEiv.
Kal 8?/ koI airros eyco itavv eyaLpov, coa-nep OrjpevTfjs tls,
ex<ov ayaTrrjTLos 6 e6r)pv6p.r)v. kcltt(lt ovk 018' cmodev p.OL 5

a.TOTro)TaTrj rts V7ro^/Ca elo-r)\6ev tos ovk a\r)6fj elt) ra
<op.o\oyr)p,eva f)pXv, koX evdvs a\6eo-6e\s eLTrov Ba/3at, w
Avo-t re <at Mereêre, KLvbvvevop.ev ovap 7re7rAoirr77KeVai.
Tt /xaAto-ra; e<pr) 6 Meveêvos. d

<$>ofiovp.aL, f)v 8' ey<o, p.r) cocnrep av6pcoiroLS aka6<riv
A.o'yots rto-ty rotovrots [\\n\vbi<TLv\ VTTv\r)Kap.ev irepX tov
<pC\ov.
Yl&s brj; e<pr). 5

p
I28e, r)v 8' ey<6, <TKOTxG>p.ev <pC\os os av eXrj, TroTepov
io-rCv tco <pC\os ov; 'AvdyKr), e<pr). YloTepov ovv ovbevos
eveKa Kal 8t' oibev,
?/
r) eVeKa tov Kat 8ta rt;

"EreKa tov Kal
8ta rt. rioVepov <pC\ov ovtos eKeCvov tov Txpayp.aTos, oS
eveKa <pC\os 6 <pC\os ra> <pC\io, ?*/ ovre <pC\ov ovre eydpov; io
Ov irdw, e<pr), e?TO/u,ai. EikoVods ye, f)v 8' eyco' dAA' e

c58e Ictcos aKo\ov6r]<TLS, ot/xat be kol eyco p.a\\ov eio-o/xat
ort \eyco. 6 Kap.vcov, vvvbi] <pap.ev, tov larpov <pC\os' ov\
ovrcos; 'Nat. Ovkovv 8ta voo-ov evem vyLeCas tov tarpou
b6 irovi/ 7 i(part)v' vvv opa B : vvv irdvv yt 4<pdrriv &pa T W

b8 avr6] fort. ovtu H. Richards d3 ^fvStatv secl. ci. Heindorf
d6 iroTtpov scr. recc. : irrfrtpoy BTW 63 tyantv Heindorf:
<pafiiv BT
PLATO, VOL. III. 8

2i8e nAAT&NOS
5 <p(kos; Nat. 'H 8e ye vocros kclkov; ricas 8' ov; Tt 8e
vyUia; r)v 8' eyco* dyadbv rj KaKov ovbtrepa; 'Aya0o'i/,
219 i<pr\.
'EAe'yo/xei; 0' dpa, cos OLKv, otl to <r<2p.a, ovt
?/
aya-
6bv ovt KaKov ipv), 8ta ttjv vocrov, tovto 8e 8td to KaKov,
rrjs laTpLKrjs <p(kov Zotlv, dyaObv 8e laTpLKrp eye/ca 8e tt^s
uytetas tt]v cpikLav r) tarptK?) avr\pr\Tai, r) 8e vyUia dyaOov.

5 r) ydp; Nat. <$>Ckov 8e r\ ov <p(kov r) vyUia; (kov.
'H 8e voo~os tyOpov. Yldvv ye. Tb ovre mKov ovt
b ayaObv dpa 8td to KaKov koX to kydpbv tov dyadov <p(kov
corlv <-VKa tov dyadov Kal <p(kov. 4>ati>erat. "EvKa dpa
tov (f>(kov {tov (p(kov) to <p(kov <p(kov Sta to eyQpov.-
v
EoiKei\
5 Eter, r)v 8' eyco. e7ret8rj ivravOa r]Kop.v, S> 7rai8e?,
Ttp6a-o-yu>p.v tov vovv p.r\ âiraTr)6S>p.V. otl p.V ydp <p(kov

tov <p(kov to (p(kov ykyovV, eco yaipeiv, Kal tov 6p.o(ov ye
to 6p,OLOv <p(kov y(yvTaL, 6 <pap.V abvvarov etWr dAA'
6p.a)S rd8e crKe\/fco/xe0a, ftr/ r)pids ea7rar?/cr?7 to vvv Aeyo-
C pievov. r) tarpt/cr/, cpajueV, ereKa tt)s uytetas <p(kov. Nat.
Oukow Kat r) vyteta <p(kov; Yldvv ye. Et apa (f>(kov,
(veKa tov. Nat. 4>tAou ye' tlvos 8t/, enrep dKoAoutfr/crei tij
Trpocrdtv 6p.okoy(a. Yldvv ye. Ovkovv koX eKetvo <p(kov av
5 ecrrat eVeKa Nat. (f>(kov; *Ap' ovv ovk dvdyKrj direLTrelv

r)p.as ovt(i)S lovras rj dcptKe'crc9ai e7rt rtva dp\r\v, r) ovkzt
e7rai>otcret e7r' dAAo (f>(kov, dAA' 7/et e7r' eKetzô o ecrrti'
d ov iveKa Kal rd dkka

etyat;

irpcoTov (p(kov,
'ArdyKr/. Touro brj (ttlv 6 Aeyco,

(f>ap.v
p.rj
TtdvTa (p(ka
rjpJds raAAa
7rdyra a ei7ro/>tez> Klvov VKa (f>(ka etrat, cocr7rep et8coAa
&2 ov add. Heindorf 8id t^ ko!/cJ>c B (sed Sta in ras. et t?> ko.
extra lineam suppl. B 2 ) a3 Se] 5 ^ Heindorf a 4 avtfp-OTai
B T (sed suprascr. V B 2 1) b3 rov <pi\ov addidi post rb <j>i\ov add.
:
Hermann b6 T
b7 7] 7' 8tj ci.
irp6cr<rx<>>l>-ev np6crx<>>tJ.fv B
W
:
Madvig b 8 ôju^ B T tyafitv t e2 om. e 3 81^ ^ BT

W
: :
8e? B T (an 8^7 tiwj Schanz) e 6 ^ Schanz /coJ B T

? %
W
: :
recc. ^ BT
: 07 &AAo scr. recc. &\\ov B T
: f) aAA.' 7)|ei :
secl. Schanz d 1 <^to) trpoiTov Heindorf d 2 ^ûas t5aa.o T

et yp. W
/xoAio-to SAAo B
: fj.d\iffTa 0AA0 B :
2
W

AT2I2 2igd
aTTd ovtol avrov, ea7rara, 5' e/cetvo to irp<7>Tov, 6 cos

f/
dAr/flcos ecrrt <pikov. kvvor)<TO}p.V yap ovtuxtC' orav tCs tl 5
7rept irokkov irotrJTaL, olovnep ei>tore TTarrjp ibv avrl TrdvToov

tujv dkkcov xprjp.aT(ov 7rportpa, 6 bi] tolovtos eW*ca tov tov
vbv 7rept TtavTos rjyelcrOaL apa /cat dkko tl av 7rept Trokkov e
ttololto; olov et alcrOdvoLTO ambv kgivclov 7re7rcoKo'ra, dpa
7rept 7roAAo{> ttoloXt dv olvov, et7rep tovto rjyoXro rbv vbv
crd>crLv; Tt p.r)v; ecprr.
*Ap'
Ovkovv Kal rb dyyelov, ev co 6
oXvos iveCrj ;Yldvv ye. ovv tot<- ovbtv 7rept 7rAetWos 5
7roteirat, KrJAt/ca K<-pap.av r) rbv vbv tov avrov, ovbe rpets

KorvXas oXvov r) rbv vov; r) co5e' 7rcos exer ^dcra r) TOLavTi]
CTTTOvbl] OVK iirl TOVTOLS icTTLV <TTTOvbacrp.(iVr], iljl ToXs VKa

tov irapacTKtvaôp.ivoLs, dAA' eV k<zCv<o ov evtKa irdvTa rd
TOLavra 7rapacrKet;derai. ov\ otl TrokkaKLS keyopev <os 220
7rept ttoXXov TTOLOvp.<-0a \pvcrCov Kal dpyvpLov dkkd p.r)
ovbzv tl p.akkov ovrco to ye dkr]6es ex?/> a ^-' Zkclvo Icttlv
7rept 7rarros TTOLOvp.e0a, 6 av qbavr) ov, otov <?VKa Kal

XpvcrCov fcat irdvTa rd TrapacrKva6p.va 7rapacrKeuderat. 5
y
ap ovtu>s <pr)crop.zv; Yldvv ye. Ovkovv *at 7rept tov cpCkov
6 ovtos koyos; dcra ydp <pap.av <pCka etrat rjpXv ere/ca <pCkov
tlvos krt-pov, pi]p.aTL cpaLvopeOa kt-yovTes avTO' <pCkov 6e b

rco ovtl KLvbvvevdL iK<iZvo avrb elvai, els o 7rdcrat avrat at
Aeyo'p,erat c/uAtat reAewcocrir. KLvbweutL ovrco?, Zcprj, eyeLV.
Ovkovv to ye rco oVri cpChov ov <pCKov tlvos eê/ca cpCkov

<ttlv; 'AAtjAt}. 5
Touro p!kv bi] d7rrjAAacrat, p.i] cpCkov tlvos erefca to
cpCkov cpCkov tuvaL' dAA' dpa to dyaOdv <ttlv cpCkov;*
'Ejuotye SoKet. ?Ap' ovv 8td to KaKov to dyaObv cptAetrai,
Kal exet cS8e* et rptcoy ovtcov <ov vvvbi] <}k4yop.<-v, dyaOov C
<cat KaKOv Kal p.7]T dyaOov p?/re KaKov, ra bvo Aetcpcêtrj, ro
d5 ivvoiitrw /xev T Srav ci. Stephanus t av B T

: d av : t> W
t* secl. Heindorf (servato h &v) e6 xepafieav TW
epo/tea B :
bi trtpov Hermann : trtpw BT C2 Ktiipdtin. Heindorf XupQti-ri. :
(ut videtur^) B : Kn<pdtit) B T

2
8*
]
220C IIAATQNOS
be KaKOV KTTob(OV CLTTk0OL Kdl fJLTjbeVOS (paTTTOLTO fxr\T(
o-(a[xaTOs p.r)T \jrvxvs P-tJ T t5>v dkkcov, a br) (pap.V avra

5 Ka0' avTa ovt KaKa (TvaL oijT dya0d, apa tot ovbev av
r)pXv \pr\crL[iov etr/ to dyaOov, dAA' dyjpr\crTov av ycyovbs
etr/; et yap p.rjbv r/uds ert fikaiTTOL, ovbev av ot/Seutds
d oxpekCas boCp.0a, Kal ovtco orj av tot yivoLTo KaTabrjkov
otl 8td to KaKov Taya0bv r)ya7T&p.ev Kal (pLkovp.V, ws
(pa.pp.aKov ov tov KaKov rb dyaOov, to oe KaKov voo-r\p.a-
voo~rjp.aTos 8e ur/ ovtos ovbtv 5et (papp.a.Kov. ap* ovtco
5 TT(pvK re Kal (fJiAeirat TayaObv otd to KaKov v(\> r)p.S>v, tQ>v
p.tTav ovtcov tov KaKOv re Kal Tayadov, avrb S' kavrov

eveKa ovbp.iav xp^Cav *X -> "EoiKev, ?/
5' os, ovtcos \lv.
To apa (pCkov fjp.LV ckclvo, ets o ereAevra 7rdyra tcl dkka
e VKa Tpov (pCkov (pCka (pap.v LvaL Klva ovb\v [oe]
TOVTOLS OLKV. TaVTa p.V ydp CpCkoV VKa q>Cka KK\r\TaL,

TO b TCO OVTL (pCkoV TTCLV TOVVaVTLOV TOVTOV (pa(.VTaL TT(pV-
kos' (pCkov yap r)plv av(pdvi~ ov \0pov eVexa, et oe to
5 X0pbv CLTTk6()L, OVKTL, WS OLK ,

0"^' r)p.LV (pCkoV. Ov UOt
boKL, (pr\, cos ye vvv Aeyerat. UoTpov, fjv 8' eyco, npbs
Alos, iav to KaKov d7rdA?/rai, ovb TTCLvrjv TL farat Ol)b
221 bLxfrijv ovbe akko ovb^v tcov tolovtcov; r) ttcCvi] p.V eo-rat,
cdvTTcp av6pa>TToC T Kal Takka wa r), ov p.VTOL /3Aa/3epd

ye; Kat btya bi] Kal al dAAat eTTtû/xtat, dAA' ov Kaxat, dre
tov KaKOv aTTokookoTos ; r) yeAotor to epwrtjua, ort 7ror'
5 eorai tot r/ p.r) eorrat; rts ydp ot8er; dAA' ovv robc y
LCrp.V, OTL Kal VVV 0~TLV TTLvSiVTa (3kaTTTCrdaL, 0~TLV Se KOl
&>o3eAeto-0at. r) ydp; Tldvv ye. Ovkovv Kal bLxfrwvTa Kal
b Tb)V akko>V T(OV TOLOVTtOV TTaVTCOV TTL0Vp.OVVTa 0~TLV VLOT
p.V 0)(f)kCpL(OS TTL0Vp.'LV, vCoT b~ (3ka/3pS>S, vCoT Oe

urjSeVepa; *2(p6bpa ye. Ovkovv cclv d7roAAvr/rat tcl KaKa,
a ye p.r) Tvy\dvL ovra KaKa, tC irpocrr]Ki rots KaKots crw-
e i & ante fu-na add. Cornarius secl. mox tKuva post ttvai St
Sr? Heindorf: om. Cornarius a2 cdvirtp] twff-rep &pci. H. Richards
\> 4 rvyxdvei scr. recc. : rvyxdvri BTW

AT2I2 22ib
airokkvaOai; Ovbev. "Eaovrai. dpa al p.i]T dyaOal p.i]Te 5
KaKal TTL0vp.iaL KaX eav d7ro'A?jrat tcl Kam. 4>au>erat.
Ol6v T OVV io-TLV TTL0Vp.OVVTa Kal epG>VTa TOVTOV OV 6776-
0vp.ei Kal epa p.i) <f>Lkeiv; Ovk ep.ot.ye boKei. "Earai dpa
Kal tS>v KaK&v aTTokop.eva>v, <as eoLKev, <pik' arra. Nat. C
Ovk avj et ye to KaKov oXtlov r\v tov <pikov tl elvaL, ovk av
rjv tovtov airokopLevov <pikov erepov ere'pa>. atrtas yap
dirokop.vr)s abvvarov ttov rjv er' exeiVo elvai, ov rjv avrr\ 1)
ahia. 'Op0<Ss keyeLS. Ovkovv <\>p.okoyr]TaL r)p!iv to <pikov 5
<pLkeiv tl Kal 8td rr Kal <j}ijOr]p.ev rore ye 8td to KaKov t6

MTjre dyaOov p-ine KaKov to dyaOov <f>Lkeiv; 'Akrjdrj.
Nvv be ye, ws eotxe, cpatVerat akkrj tls ahia tov <pLkeiv re d
*at <pLkeL<T0aL. "Eolkv. *Ap' ovv r<2 ovtl, <%airep dprt
ekeyop.ev, 1) eiTL0vp.ia rijs <f>Lkias atrta, Kal to eTtL0vp.ovv
<pikov earlv tovtu> ov eiTL0vp.ei kol tot orav 7TL0vp.f], 6 be

to irpoTepov ekeyop.ev <pikov eti>ai, vOkos tls rjv, axnrep
iroir)p.a p.aKpov avyKeip-evov; K^vbvveveL, e<prj.
'AAAd p.ev-
5
tol, rjv 8' eya>, to ye TTL0vp.ovv, ov av evbees 1), tovtov

eirL0vp.ei. r) T6
ydp; Nat. b' evbees dpa <pikov eKeivov e
ov av evbees Aokci
fj;
p.01 'Ez>Sees 8e yiyverai ov dv tl
d<patp?/rai.
ITa>y 8' ov; Tot) olkLov 8?/, cos eoLKev, 8 re
epo>s Kal ptAia Kat eirL0vp.ia rvyxdveL ovaa, o>s (paiVerat,
S> Meveeve
1)
re Kat Auo-t.
1)
^vve^partiv.
'Tuets dpa et <iAot 5
earov dAAjjAoty, <pvaeL 7T7/ OLKeioi ea0' vp.iv avrois. Kop.Lbfj,
e<pa.Tr)v. Kat et dpa tls erepos frepov eTTL0vp.ei, rjv 8' eyw,
S> iraibes, r) epd, ovk dv ttot eireOvp.eL ovbe ijpa ovbe e<fiikei, 222
et p.1) olKeios irr\ t<2 epa>p.ev<j> eTvy\avev o>v r\ Kara ti\v
ypvxr)v r) Kard tl rrjs \j/v\rjs tfOos r\ Tpoirovs i] et8o?.

Yldvv ye, e<pr\ 6 Meveêvos' 6 be Avais eaiyr\aev. Elev,
b6 air6\riTai scr. recc. airok\i)Tai B T : a.no\h)Tai C 2 oi/ic

: W
&v' ov t&v H. Richards
ci. C4 &v post abvvaTov add. ci. Gold-
bacher d 6 iroir)fj.a nanpov] iroirifia fiarriv ci. Ast iroirifjia Kp6vv T ov B W

a 3 Tp6irovs :
B T (sed v erasum in B)

222a IIAATX2N02
5 r)v 8' eyw. to p.ev bi\ <pv<reL oUelov dvayKalov r\pXv ire<f)av-
rai (pLkelv. "EoiKev, (f>r\.

'AvayKatov dpa rw yvr\<ri
epaarrr) Kat /xr; TTpo<riroLr\T<$ <f>Lkel<r0aL vtto tS>v iraLbLK&v.

b 'O piev ovv Av<tls Kal 6 Meveêvos p.6yLS ttcos errevevaaTrjv,
6 be 'iTTiro^dkrjs vtto tt)s fjbovrjs iravTobaiia r)<f>ieL xpd>p.aTa.
Kat eyoo clttov, /3ovk6p.evos tov koyov TTL(TK^/a(r0aL, Et

p.V TL TO olKZLOV TOV OpLOLOV bia<f)pL, keyOLp.V aV TL, (OS
5 e/not Sokci, S> Av<tl re Kal Meveeve, irepX <f>ikov, 6 eo-rtv
et 8e Tavrbv TvyyJweL ov o/xotoV re Kat otKetor, ov pqbLov

a7ro/3aXety tov TTp6<r0ev koyov, <os ov rb 6p.oLov r<3 6p.oi<j>
Kara rqv 6p.0L0Tr\Ta d\pr\crTov' to be a\pr\<TTov <f>ikov

8' eyw,
C 6p.okoyelv TTkr\p.p.ekes. /3orJAe<rt9' ovv, rjv e7ret8r)
uxjTTep pi.e0vop.ev vtto tov koyov, <Tvy\pr\cru)p.V Kal <fxap.ev
erepov tl etvai to OLKelov tov 6p.oiov; Tldvv ye. Ylorepov

ovv Kal Taya0bv olKelov 0r\<ro\iev iravrL, to be KaKov dkkorpLov
5 etvai; r) to p.ev KaKov r<3 KaK<2 otKetoy, r<3 8e dya0io to

dya06v, r<3 8e p.r\Te dya0<2 \ir\Te KaK<3 rd p.r\T dya0bv
p.r\re KaKoviOvtcos e<f>aTr\v 8oKeu> <r<pi<TLV Ka<rTov eKaora)
d otKetou etyat. YldkLV dpa, r\v 8' eyw, <x 7rai8es, orjs ro
ttp&tov koyovs aTTefiak6p.e0a irepl <pikias, ets rorjrorjs
eto-TreTrrwKa/xey 6 ydp dbLKOs r<3 a8tK<) Kat 6 KaKos r<S
KaK<3 orj8ei> Tjttov <pikos e<naL r\ 6 dya0bs r<S

dya0<o.
5 "EotKei>, e<rjr/. Tt 8e'; to dya0bv kol to oUelov dv ravrbv

<pG>p.ev eXvaL, dkko tl r) 6 dya0bs t5> dya0<2 p.6vov (pikos;
Udvv ye. .'AAAa p.r\v ko.1 tovto ye <oop.e0a e<feAe'y<fat r\p.ds
avrovs' r) ov p.ep.vr\<r0e; Mep.vrip.e0a.

e Tt ovv dv ert \pr\<Taip.e0a t<?> k6ya>; r) bijkov otl ovbev;
beopLai ovv, uxrirep ol <ro<pol ev rots bLKa<rrr\pioLS, ra elpr\p.eva
diravTa dvaTTep.TTd<ra<r0ai. el yap p.r\T o\ q>Lkovp.VOL /tr/re
b4 ri &s T
irus B W b
7 airofSaXuv T : avo\iire?v B : ano\uv
W sed W
:
yp. Kal airo\tiruv ical airofia\(?v in marg. C2 /x(dvo/x(v

in marg. T /j.vdevofiev
: BT C4 O^ffofiev] <p4o-o/j.ev Schanz
d6 &\\o TiT: ^ &\\o t< B e3 avaireLnrdo-ao-Qai B (sed e supra
2
a<B )
AT2I2 222 e
ol cpikovvTes fJLijre ol o/uotot fxf)r 61 avofxoioi. fxrjre ol ayadol

/*?/re ol oiKetbt fxr)T ra akka ocra bukrfkvdafxev ov yap 5
eycoye ert fj.ifxvrip.ai. vtto tov Trkrjdovs dAA' et fxrfbev tovtcov
cpikov icrTiv, eyco /xh> ovKert eâ> rt Ae'ya>.
Tavra 8' etTjw ei> va> e?xoi> dAAor 7/877 Tiva. t5>v irpecrftv- 223
ripcov Kiveiv Kara, &cnrep baifxovis tivzs, TrpocrtkdovTes 01
7rat8aya>yoi, o re roS MeveeVou Kat 6 rou Avo-180?, eyovres
avT&v tovs abekcpovs, napeKakovv nal iKikevov avrovs otKa8'
airiivai' 7/877 yap r)v 6\}/i. to fxkv ovv irpGtTov ko.1 fffxtis 5
Kat 01 7reptecrrd)rej avrovs airrfkavvofxw iTrabff 8e ov8>
e<ppovTi.ov fffx&v, dAA' viroftapfiapiCovTts r)yava.KTovv re Kat
,
o?j8ej> rJTTov eK&kovv, akk iboKovv fffxiv vTroTTenu> Kores iv toIs b
'Epfxaiots airopoL etvai Trpocrcpipecrdai., ffTTrfdivTes ovv avr&v
bukvcrafxtv Tifv crvvovcriav. ofxws 8' eycoye 7)877 airiovTOiv
avT&v, Nuv fxiv, f)v 8' eyco, a> Avcn re Kat Mevi^tve, Kara-
ye'Aaorot yeyovapcv eyco re, yipcav avr)p, koX vfxeis. ipovcn 5
ydp ot8e d7rtoVres co? olofxzOa fffx&s akkr)ka>v cpCkoi tivai

Kat e/xe ydp iv vfxiv TCOrjfxt. ovtto) be ort ecrriv 6 cpCkos 0X0C
re iyevofxeda iêvpdv.
e 7 </>/Aoj' B : </>/A/ T a 2 Sra B : aVa T : eZra in marg. T

b 1dA\'] Kal Heindorf iiroireiruK^Tcs B (sed irw refinxit B)2
:
wroweirrw/coVey T
p
rsj
n*
ET0TAHMO2
st. i
KPITGN 2I2KPATH2 p. 271
KP. Tts r)v, Si 2&>Kpare?, co

x^ y * v AuKeta) bickiyov; a
?; 7roAvs ifxds oxkos TrepteicrrT/Ket, uxtt Zycoye ftovkdfxevos
aKovtiv TTpoo-eXdcbv ovbev otos r' r) aKovo~ai cratpeV vTrepK.vy\ras
fxevroL KaTelbov, Kai fxot eboev etvat 4vos Tts to biekiyov.

rt? j)V, 5
212. ITorepop Kat epcoTqs, 00 Kpiroov; ov yap els dkXd
bv' ijorrjv.
KP. *Ov fxev eyco Aeyco, eK 8eta? rpiro? diro crou KaOrjo-TO'
(v peVco 8' vjucor ro 'Ato'xou fxeLpaKLOv r)v. ko.\ fxdka irokv, b

3) 2coKpare?, e?ri8e8coKeVat fxoL eboev, ko.1 tov r)fxeTepov ov
ttoAv rt tt]v fjktKiav 8iacpe'pew KptTofiovkov. dAA' Ktvo$
fxev (TKkrjq^pos, ovros 8e TTpocpepT/? Kal KaAo? Kal dyaObs rr)v
oxj/tv. 5
2X2. EiOvbrffxos ovros ecrriz/, co Kpiroov, bv epcora?, 6 8e

irap efxe KaOrjfxevos e dptcrTpds dbekcpbs tovtov, Alow<to-
boopos' pere'xet 8e Kat ovtos tG>v koyoov.
KP. Ovberepov yLyv<j)<TK<i), S) 2coKpare?. KaLVoi tlvS av
ovtol, <as OtK, côcplc^ral Trobairoi; Kat ri? r) crocpta; C
212. Ourot to fxev yevos, co? eycopai, evrevOev iroOev
l<tlv K Xiov, dir(OKr}<rav be e? Qovpiovs, (pevyovTes 8e
aa B
^ (sed in ras.) Demetrius tT T : a4 KareTSov T:
KariSov B a6 irArepov Hermann biroWepov BT: Xey 6-irorepov
:
ci. Badham b2 tirtSeSwKevat B 2 t: in8e87jAaceVa< BT b6 i

Se irap' efie TW : hs Si trapefieve B b 8 fterexei] fieretxe Heindorf
c3 <pevyovrei\ <pvy6vres Heindorf
PLATO, VOL. III. 9
27i c I1AATI2N02
tKtWev ttoW' rjbr) errj 7rept Tovabe tovs tottovs hiaTpifiovcnv.
I b he o~v epcoras tt]v crocpiav avToiv, 6avp.acria, cb Kplrcoz>
Trdo~<ro<poL drexycos tco ye, ovb' rjbi) irpb tov otl etez> ol
TiayKpaTiaa-Tai. rodrco ydp karov Kopubrj Trap.p.dx<o. ov Kara

rco 'AKapvave kytvo~6r)v rco TrayKpaTLacrTa dêAc/JCo* eKe6'co
d p.ev yap rco crcop,art p.6vov otco re p.dyea~dai, tovto) 8e irpS>Tov

p.\v rfi crcopart 8eti>ordrco ecrrdi> [koX p.dxj], irdvTiov eort
f)
Kparetz>] ez> ottXols yap avrco re croc/ico irdvv p.d\<Eo-6at. Kal
272 dAAoz>, 6? av 8t8co puardov, otco re 7rot?7crai e7retra r^fr ez>
rots SiKacrrrjpiois p.dyr)V KpariaTU) Kat dycozucracrflai /cat
dAAoz> 8t8dai Ae'yetz> re Kat o~vyypd<picr6aL Adyous olovs
ets rd 8tKaoTT7pta. 7rpd tov piv ovv Tavra 8etz>co rjo-rrjv
5 -xovov, vvv 8e re'Aos e7rtrec9?7Karoz> 7rayKpartacrriKT7 T-\\vr\. rj
yap r\v Xonrrj ovtoZv p.d\r) dpyos, TavTryv vvv eetpyacrc9oz>,
cocrre ju.778' dz> era avrots oio'z> r' etz>at /^t^S' avTapai' ovrco
8etz>cb yeydz>aroz> ez> rots Adyots p\d\eo~6ai re Kat eeAe'yxeii>

b rd dei Aeyo'/xez>oz>, d/xotcos edz>re \i/eu8os edz>re dArjc3es 7J.
eyco
p.\v ovv, <W Kptrcoz>, ez> v<2 e^co rotz> dvbpoXv Trapabovvai
efxavTov Kal ydp <parov ez> dAiyco xp6v<* TToirjo~ai av Kal
aWov ovTivovv tcl avra Tavra 8etz>o'z>.
5 KP. Tt 8e', co 2co KpaTts; ov <po(3f] tt)v r)\iKiav, p.r) rjbt)
7rpecr/3vrepos rjs;
2X2. "HKtard ye, co Kptrcozr tKaz>dz> TKp.r]pLov e\to Kat
7rapap1.vd1.ov tov p.r) c/>o/3eto-0ai. avrco ydp tovtoo, cos e?Tos
et7rety, yepovrc ovtc r)pdo~6r)v ravTr)s Tr)s o~o<pias r)s eycoye
IO 7TLdvp.<a, TTJS ipKTTLKrjS' TTpVO~LV rj 7Tp0TTpV0~LV OvbtTTU} r]<TTr)V
C <ro<p<a. dAA' eyco cv p.6vov <pofiovp.aL, p.r) av dvetSos roa>

îvoLV 7reptd^co, cocr7rep K6vvu> rco M?jrpoj3tou, rco KicâpicrrTj,
C5 flav/to<ra B : 6avfia<riai T : dav/xd<rat Winckelmann c6t<J

76 BW: &s eyoeye T c8 iywtffdriv BW: om. T: post d 1
fxdxtffOai transp. Hermann d 2 al . . . Kparuv secl. Badham
o-Ti T W : om. B a 2 koL
ante erywviVaa-flat
\oi-rii aiirolv ^vT m
secl. Schanz a5 %
b
yap i)v Kot-ri] avrolv B T yp. % yap : 7 <x w
B W exw' T
: b 10 t^s ipio-riKvs secl. Naber itipvctw :B
iripvo-iv 5e T C 1 a? B ai>Tbr T : W
ET0TAHMO2 272 c
6s e/xe 8t8do-Ket ert Kal vvv KiQapi&iv op&vres ovv oi 7rat8es
oi o-u/xc/>otr?/rat p.oL e/xou re KarayeAcoo-t Kat tov Kovvov

koXovol yipovTobibacrKaXov . //?/ ovv Kal toIv volv tls 5
tovtov. tovto bVeiSio-?/' oi 8' avrb tovto to-cos <po(3ovp.VOL

ra\a p.c ovk av e#e'Aoier irpoobzâoOaL. eyco 8', 00 KpLT<av,
eKeiae p.(v dXkovs 7re'7retKa ovp.p.a6r]Tds p.0L qboLTav 7rpe-
crfivTas, ZvTavda 8e' ye erepovs TTipdoop.aL 7ret#etr. xal ov tl d

ov o-vp.<poLTqs ; cos 8e 8e'Aeap avrols aop.(.v tovs ooxis vets*
e<pie'p.evot ydp ckclvcov 018' ort Kat ?/p:as 7rai8evo-ovo-iv.
KP. AAA' ov8ev KcoAvet, co ScoKpares, edv ye crot 8oKr/.
irpStTov 8e' /uot 8t?jy?jo-at r?/z; aocpiav tolv avbpolv rts eo-ru>, 5
tva ei8<3 ort Kat p.adr\o6p.eda.
212. Ovk dv cpOdvoLs clkovu)V cos ovk av eôt/ut ye et7retv
ort ov TtpocrzLyov tov vovv airolv, dAAd 7rdi>v Kat TrpootLypv

kol p.dp.vt]p.aL, Kat aot 7retpdo-o/*ai e dpx*js aTravra 8t?jy?j-
o-ao-0at. Kard debv ydp TLva <-Tvypv Ka6i]p\cvos ivravda, e

ovirep crv /xe e?8es, iv rco d7ro8vr?jpicp p.6vos, Kal ?/8?j ev r
e?xov dvaoTTJvaL' dvtora/xeVov 8e /xov tyivzTo jb etco#ds
or)fxilov to ba.Lp,6vLov. irdkLV ovv e\a0eo/x?/v, *<*< oAtyco
vorepov doepyjzadov tovt(o6 t Ei6vbr]p.os kcli 6 Alow- 273
oobcopos Kat dAAot p.a6i]Ta\ dp.a aS 7roAAot e/xot SoKetv
eio-eA#oVre 8e 7repie7rareir?jv ev rco KaTaoriy^ 8pdpco. kol
ovttu) tovto) 8v' i) rpets bpop.ovs 7repteA?jAv0dre ijoTrjv,
Kal etcrepxerat KAetrtas, ov ov cpr]s irokv e7rt8e8a)KeVat, 5

dkriOrj Ae'ycoir oiTLodcv 8e avrov epaoral Trdvv ttoXXol re
Kat dAAot Kat Kr?/o-t7r7ros, vcavCo-Kos rts FTata^teus, p.dka
koXos re KayaObs tt]v cpvoLV, ooov p.r] vj3pLOTr]S [8e] 8td to
C3 olv\ yovu Hertlein C4 fioi W : /j.ov BT d 1 a-v ri oi>
ffvn<poiras; us Winckelmann o~b ri (ri T) irov ffvfupolra Iffws BT

W
: :
o&ri irov ffvfupoira' tcrus d 2 &ô/xfv T : ej-ofitv B W (sed a

supra ? W) d 4 80/qj T : 5ok? B e 2 fcs W : BBT
e 3 8 /toi; T 8'ôC B a i rovru secl. Cobet a 2 aS B
W
: :
om. T : ov Hermann : avrolv Schanz post noWol lacunam

indicat Schanz, {Vo intercidisse ratus Sokuv B 8ok? BT
J
W
:
a3 t lfft\06vre : e lffe\$6vres BT a8 offov firj B T (sed /t^ supra

versumT) v&piffr-fis- <j5p*o-T7?s) 8e Baiter 8e secl. Winckelmann
9*
273 b nAAT&NOS
b veos elvai. ibcov ovv )u.e 6 KAetvtas anb rrjs tlcrooov p.6vov
KaOrjfjievov, avTLKpvs itov 7ra/}eKa#e'ero Zk 8etas, totTirep kcll
crv <pr\s. ibovT* 8e avrbv 6 re At.ovvo-6bcopos Kal 6 Evdv-

b-qpios irptoTov p.\v kTTiaravTZ 8teAeye'o-07/i> akXi]koLV, dAAr/p
5 Kat akX.r}v cLTroftktTrovTe cis tjplcls Kat yap ttclvv avrolv
irpoo-cixpv tov vovv eVetra toVre 6 pkv irapa to p.LpaKLOv
tKade&To, 6 Ev6vbr]p.os, 6 8e irap* airrbv eue e dptcrreods',
ol 8' dAAot ws %Kao~Tos eTvyyaviv.

C 'Lar--ra(6p.r]v ovv avrto are 8td yjyovov ecopaKcoV werd 8e
T
tovto etirov irpbs tov KAeiviazv i2 KAeuna, rco8e ueVrot rcb
avbpe; crotpia, Ev6vbrjp,6s re Kat ALovvcrobcopos, ov tcl crp.LKpa
dAAd tcl fxeydAa* ra yap irepl tov 7ro'Ae/xoi> irdvra (ttl-
5 o~Tao~6ov, ocra 8et rbv pAXkovra dyadbv crrpaTqybv ecrecr&n,

Tas re rdfets Kat tcls T/yeuorta? TtHtv tTrpaToiribtov nal [6o~a\
ei> o7rAoty udxeo-0at [8t8aKre'oi>]* otco re 8e Kat 7roi?/crai
8waroy etz>at avTov avrco [iorjdcLV iv tols SiKao-rr/ptots, dy

rts avTov dbLKrj.
d Et77coy ow raura KaTtppovt]dr]v vtt* avTolv eyeAao-dr^y
ovv ap.tpto /3Ae'\/Vaz>re ets dAAr/Aco, Kat 6 Evdvbr]p.os et7rezr
Ouroi ert raura, a 2ScoK/oare?, cr7rouod(buei', dAAd irapepyoLS
avTols xptap.0a.
5 Kdycb 6avp.do~as slttov KaXbv av ttov to ipyov vp.t2v ttij,
et Tf]\LKavTa irpdyp.aTa Trdpepya vp.LV TvyydvtL ovra, kol

Trpbs 0ecoz> cXttctov p.0L tl ecrrt tovto ro koKov.
Aperqv, ec/>r/, cb ScoKpares, otduet?a otco r' etât TrapaSowat

KaAAto-r avdptaTroov Kal rd^tcrra.
e 12 Zeu, otoy, ?/z; 8' eyco, Ae'yeror rrpayp.a' irodev tovto
b2 ko2 T : om. B b3 I56vre T

: tSoVres B b5 O7ro-
/3A.6iroj/Te T : awot3\tirovTes B outo?^ Ttpoo~e7)(pv B : irpoo~e?x ot'
avrolv T 7 6b eu0u57jyuos T : evdvd7i/j.os B outov e/te B : outJv
/te T e| apiffTepas T .: C 5 a-yafl&v T
eV apio~T(pa B W W :
om. B c 6 6Va et C 7 SiSaKreov secl. ci. Schanz (ad '6o~a Set

adscriptum fuit) c 7 /taxeo-flaj secl. Badham d 2 odv~\ yovv
fiKtyavTe T f}Ae\pavTts BT dAXÂco T 2 aWfaovs
2
Heindorf :
W
:
BT d5 TTou T : tj B ei jji/J' eVco corr. Coisl. : e</>jj/
î/ S' iyw BT Ae' yT0i' secl.

,
Cobet
:
ET0TAHMO2 273e
to epp-atov r]vpTr)v; eyo) be 7rept vp.<2v btevoovp.rjv ert, oxnrep

vvvbr) ekeyov, a>s to irokv tovto beLVolv ovtolv, ev orrkoLS
p.d\(r6aL, kol Tavra ekeyov irepl <T<p<2v ore yap to irpoTepov
TTebr]p.r]o-dTi]v, tovto p.ep.vr)p.aL <r<po) eirayyekkopcevo). ei 5
be vvv akr)6G>s TavTryv ri]v iTTi.0Trip.riv e\Tov, iAea> eTrov
aTxvS)S yap eycoye <T(po) o)o~Trep 6e<o Trpocrayopevo), <rvy-
yv(op.r]v be6p.evos e\LV i101 v %l*-itpocr6V eipr)p.evo)v. dAA' 274

opaTov, S) Ev6vbr)p.e re Kal ALovvo-oboope, et akr)6rj keyerov
virb yap tov p-eyedovs tov Trayyekp.aTos ovbev 6avp.a<xTov
aino-Tiiv.
'AAA' ev X<t6l, o) 2a>Kpares, [e<paroi>,] tovto ovto)s eyov. 5
MaKapt(t) dp' vpjxs eya>ye tov KTf)p.aTos irokv p.dkkov i)
p.eyav fiao-tkta ttjs apxfjs' Tocrovbe be p.01 ltttov, ei ev vG>

eyeTov eTTibeiKvvvai Tavrr)v tj)v <ro<pCav, r) tt<os <T<p<2v (Sefiov-
Aewat.
'Eir' avro ye tovto Tra.peo-p.ev, a> 2a>Kpares, a>s einbeCôvTe 10
Kat 8tSdwre, edv rts edekrj p.av6dveiv. b

'AAA' drt p.ev edekrjo-ovo-iv aTravTes ol p.r) e\0VTes, eya>
vpXv eyyv(ap.ai, 7rp<Sros p.ev eya>, eVetra 8e KAetznas ovto<tC,
Trpbs 0' ijpuv Kr?/o-t777rds re obe Kal ol dAAot ovrot, r)v 8' eya>
beiKvvs avr<o roi/s epaords tovs KkeivCov ol be eTvyyavov 5
r)p.as rjbr) Trepuo-Tap.evoi. 6 yap Kr^0-i777TO? ervê iroppo)
Kade(6p.evos tov KkeLvCov Kap.ol boKelv a>s ervyyavev 6

Evdvbr)p.os ep.ol biakeyop.evos TrpovevevKO)s els t6 irpocrdev,
ev p.e<r<o ovtos r)p.(2v tov KkeivCov TTo-k6tL rw KrT)o-i7r7ra> C
rrjs 6eas /3ovk6p.ev6s re ovv 6edcracr6aL 6 Ktô-lttttos tcl
7ratotKa Kat dp.a (pLkr]Koos o)v dvaTrrjbrjo-as ttp&tos TTpoo-eorr]
r)p.lv ev t<2 KaTavTLKpv' ovtccs ovv Kal ot dAAot eKeivov

ibovTes TTepLcrTr)<Tav r)p.ds, ot re tov KkeLvCov epao-Tal Kal 5
e 5 iireSrnjL7i<ra.Ttjt' B W
et yp. T ivttrnieirriv T
: a 2 \eyeToi/)
iXeyerov BT (sed e erasum in B) as etpaTov secl. Cobet
e<pdTrtv Bekker b 2 oAA' T om. B : b 5 avrip T avTi> T 2 : :
avT< B: avTolv Hirschig rovs KAeiviov B: rov tcKeiviov TW

b 7 Ka.fj.ol Badham cuol B T (wa9' ws Schanz ws 8 Bekker)
: :
274 c nAATilNOS
ol tov Ev6vbr)p.ov re kcu ALovvcrob<apov eratpot. tovtovs brj
eyu> beLKVvs ekeyov rw Ev6vbr)p.<a otl 7rdz>res erotuot etez>
d p.av6dveLV 6 re ovz> Kr?/cri7r7ros <Tvve<pri udAa Trpodvp.a>s
Kal oi akkoL, Kat eKekevov avrto koiz>?/ 7ra^res e7rtSeiacr0at

r^y bvvap.iv rfjs cocpias.
T
ETttov ovv eya>' 2 Evfli/Sr/ue Kat Atozn>cro'8cope, 7rdyt; p.ev
5 ow> 7raz>rt rpoVcp Kal tovtols yapiaacrOov Kal ep.ov eveKa

ki;ibeiao-6ov. tcl piev ovv irkelaTa brjkov otl ovk okCyov
epyov e7ri8eraf robe be pot eXireTov, iroTepov ireTTeL<Tp.evov
?/Sr/ cbs \pi] Tiap vp.<2v p.av6dveiv bvvaLcrd' av dya6bv TTOLrjcraL
e dvbpa p,6vov, r) Kat eKelvov tov p.f)ir<ti TreTreLcrpLevov Std rb pi]

v
otecrât oAcos to irpdyp.a Tr]V aperrjv p.a6r)Tov eTvai rj u?/ crcpco
etvaL avrrjs StSacrKaAco; <pepe, kol tov ourcos expvra tt)s
avTrjs Tex vr
l
s epyov 7retcrat cas Kal bibaKTov r) dperi] Kal ovtol
5 vuets eore irap 8>v av KaAAtcrrd rts ai/TO p.ddoL, ?/ akkrfs;

TavTt]s p.ev ovv, ecprj, rrjs avrijs, co ScoKpares, 6 Atozn;-
crdScopos.
'Tuets dpa, rjv 8' eyco, co Aiozn;cro'8cope, tG>v vvv dv6p<a-

275 7rcoi> KakkLCTT dv Trporpetyatre ets <pLkocro<pCav Kat dper?/s
e7riue'Aetaz;;
Olop.e6d ye 8r/, co ScoKpares.

Tcoy uey tolvvv dAAcoy r?/i; eirCbeL^LV ?/uty, ecpr/y, ets av#ts
5 airodecrdov, tovto b* avrb eiTLbeCâcrdov' tovtovl tov veavCcrKOV
ireCcraTOV <as XPh cpLkocrocpelv Kal aperfjs e7rtueAeto-0at, Kat
XapLetcrdov euot re Kat rourotcrt TrdcrLV. <Tvp\fiefit]Kev yap rt
tolovtov rcp uetpaKtcp rovrcp* eyco re Kat ot'8e 7rdyres ruyxd-

vop,ev eiTLdvp.ovvTes u>s (3ekTL(rTov avrbv yevecrdaL. eo~TL be
d 2 avrii B t avry T : d6 e7rtS6i|a(rflov T : -ri$eiaTOV B W

d 7 epyov iiri5e7ai B ep-yoi' : av e'7ri5e7|ai e/jôi'
i-rtSutat elt) av T : efrj
W (sed supra e?'?j et epyov add. signis transpositionis) irSrepov

TW -rp6repov B
: e 2 to irpayixa secl. Hirschig apeTî/ tV
secl. Cobet (et mox ovtoG) 64 i) aperi] et oStoi secl. Cobet
e5 wv T: & B outo T: at-To*s B aAArjy B
2
a\A.s : BT
a 1 -rpoTptyaire Aldina : -rpoTpeêre BT a7 toutoio-j T : tov-
Toiari B
ET0TAHMO2 275a
ovtos 'A<fto'xo?j pei' vbs tov 'AAKt/3ia8ov tov irakaLov, avra- 10
rev/uos 8e tov vvv ovtos AAKt/3tc8ov ' ovop.a 8' avrco KAetiuas. b
eort 8e reos* Gjo/3ovpe0a 8?/ 7rept a?3rcp, otor etKos 7rept ie'co,
p?/ rts cpt9?/ ?//>tas e7r' aAAo rt e7rir?j8e?jp,a rpe\//as avrov Tr)v
biai>otav Kal 8iacpi9eip?/. o-c/><o ovv iikctov ets KaAAio-ro^'

aAA' et p?/ rt 8iac/>epet v/xir, Aa/3erw irclpav tov /AetpaKiou 5
/cai 8iaAe'x0?/Toi> ivavTiov r)

r
iG)V.
EIttovtos ovv e/xo{5 crxeSov rt avra raura 6 Ev0i>8?j/i>ios
apa dvbpeCcos re Kat 6appa\4o)s, 'AAA' ovSey 8ta<pe'pet,

ScoKpares, e<p?j, eai> p.6vov e#e'A?j diroKpCvecrOaL 6 veavCo-Kos. C
'AAAa pei> 8tj, e<p?ji> eyco, rotJro ye Kat eiflto-rar 6ap.a yap
avTu ot'5e 7rpoo-toVres 7roAAa epcorcoo-ti> re Kat 8taAe'yorrat,
coore eTrteiKcos 0appet to aiTOKpCvacrOaL.

Ta brj fxeTO. ravra, 6) Kptrcoy, ir&s av KaAoos <rot 8t?jy?j- 5
craCprjv; ov yap o-p.LKpbv to tpyov bvvacrdaL dvaXafi&v
ote^toVra croqbCav ap.r\yavov ocrrjv coot' cyaiye, KaOdirep ol
7rotr/rat, 8e'opat dpy6p.tvos rrjs 8t?jy?jo-ecos Movcras re kol d
MiTj/xooTJinjy e7rtKaAeto-(9at. rjpâro 8' o?3i> kvOivbc Trodev
6 EvOvbrip.os, cos eycp/jtar *il KAetiua, 7ro'repot ettri rcoy
av9pu>TTLOv ol /xavOdvovTcs, ol arocpol ?/ 01 apafleis;
Kat ro fxcLpaKLov, are /xeyaAou oVros rou po)Trjp.aTOS, 5
r)pv6pCacriv re Kat a7rop?/cras ivi(3ke\j/v ets epe'* Kat eyco

yi>oi/s ovtov Tdopv/3rjp:4vov, appet, ?ji> 5' eyco, co KAeti>ta,
Kat aiTOKpLvaL dvbpeCo^s, OTrorcpd gol <f>aii>eTar trrcos ydp e
rot aK/JeAei ttji/ /xeyto-r?/y cocpeAtar.
Kat ei' rot/rco 6 Aiot>t>o-o8copos 7rpo<rK?J\âs pot p.LKpbv

Trpos ro ovs, Traru /xet8iacras rto 7rpocr&)7r<o, Kat /ur/i;, e<p?j,
crot, co ScoKpares, 7rpoAe'yco ort ofroTep' av cnTOKpCvr)TaL to 5

p.(LpaKLOv, eeAeyx0?7o-erai.
b2 ai>T^ . vlt# B W : avrov . . . viov T b3 avrov T W :
om. B b4 8ia<p0(ip7} B : StatyOaprj T b8 fijua] /âAa Badham

C 1 airoKplvcaOai B : airoKpivaaOai T 04 airoKpivacrOai B : owro-
KpivtoÔat T 05 KaAcos] tKavus Badham d 1 rrjs BT : -yp.
rocrrjarSc T d2 fivi)fLoavvr}v T W : /xvfi/xriv B d6 4vff$\(\j/(v
T : YÂ.firei' B 62 &<t>\e7] w<pf\r)o-*t Buttmann
275e IIAATX2N02
Kai avrov fxera^v ravra keyovros 6 Kkeivias tTvêv
a7TOKpLvdp.evos, Sxjre ovbe TrapaKekevo-acrOai p.01 eêyevero
276 vkaj3r]0rjvaL t<2 p.LpaKi<o, dAA' aTTeKpivaro ort oi crotpol
etev oi p.avOdvovTes.
Kal 6 Ev0vbr]p.os, KaAets oe TLvas, e<pr], bLbao-Kakovs, rj
ov; 'Q.p.okoyeL. Ovkovv t<2v p.av0av6vr<nv oi bLbdcrKakoL
5 bLbdo-KakoL elo-LV, axnrep 6 KL0apLo-Tr)s Kal 6 ypap.p.aTLo-Tr)s

bLbdo~KakoL bt]TTOv rjo-av o~ov Kal tG>v dkkoiv TraiboiV, vp.els
8e p,aOr]rai; 'Evvecprj. AAAo
v
tl ovv, r)vUa ep.avOdveT,
ovtto) riT!Lo-Tao-0 ravra a ep.avOdveTc; Ovk e<pr].
'Ap' ovv
b <ro<po\ rjTe, ot ravra ovk r)7ricrTao-0e; Ov brjra, rj 8' os.
Ovkovv el p.r) o-ocpoi, dp.aOeZs; Yldvv ye. 'Tp.ets dpa
p.av0dvovT$ a ovk r]7rio-Tacr0, dp.a0els ovres ep.avOdveT.
'EiTevevo-e rb p.eLpaKLov. Ot ap,aOels apa p,avOdvovaLv, 2)
5 KAetina, dAA' ov^ 01 <ro<poi, <os <rv otet.
Tavr ovv el-Tovros avTov, &o"nep vtto bLbacrKakov xPs

d7Too"qp.r]vavTos, ap.a aveOopv/Brjo-dv re Kal eyeka<rav 01 eiro-
C p.evoL eKelvoL /xera tov ALOWcroboipov re Kat Ev0vbrjp.ov' kol

irpXv avaiTvevcraL koAws re Kat ev to p.LpaKLOv, Kbedp.vos
6 ALovvo-obcopos, Tt be, <o KAetina, ecprj, 6tt6t diroo-Top.aTLôL
vp.lv 6 ypap.p.aTLo-Trjs, TTorcpoi epAvOavov t<2v iraiboiv rd

5 d7roo"ro/Aartfo/u,ei'a, 01 cro<pol rj oi ap.a0els; Ot <ro<poi, ecpr\
6 KkeLvias. Ot crocpol dpa p.avOdvovcrLV dAA' ov\ oi dpaOels,

Kat ovk ev crv aprt Ev0vbt]p.<p aireKpivco.
d 'EvravOa br) Kal irdvv p.cya eyckacrdv re Kat e0opvj3r]<rav
oi epacrjaX tolv dvbpolv, ayao-Oevres rrjs o-ocpias avTOLV 01
8' aAAot ^juets KTTirkr]yp,cvoL c<TL<oTT<op.cv. yvovs bc r)p.as
6 Ev0vbr]p,os KTTTTkr]yp.Vovs, tv eTL pakkov 0avp.dijoLp.ev
5 avrov, ovk dvieL rb p.LpaKLOv, dAA' rjpcora, Kal &o"irep oi

ayaOol 6pyj]OTai, bLirkd eo-rpecpe rd epoiTrjpara irepl tov
a 7 &\\o Tt T :
&\\' iWt B b3 j)-riffTa<r8e T : 4irl<rraff0- B
b4 &pa TW : &pa ffo<pol B C4 ifj.1v T : rifuv B C7 eS <rv
scripsi (fv Schanz) evdvsBT di /j,eyaTW: om. B 6.5 avUi
W
:
T : av Ui B r)p<ira Kal T : B secl. Schanz

-f)pTa :

ET0TAHMO2 276d
avrov, nal ecprj- Yiorepov yap ol p.av6dvovTes p.av6dvovcrLv

a imcrTavTaL rj a /x?/ e7ricrravrai;
Kal 6 ALOvvcrdbcopos TtakLV [XLKpbv iipos p.e \f/L6vpicras,
Kat tovt, ecprj, & ScoKpares, tTtpov tolovtov olov to e

Trporepov.
v
*I2 Zeu, ecprjy eyco, ?) pt? /i> koX to irpoTtpov ye Kakbv r)pXv
ecpdz/rj to epcor?jp.a.
WavT, ecprj, 2 2&)Kpares, TOLavra ?j/uets epcorcoperj dcf>vKTa. 5
Totydprot, r)v 8' iya>, SoKetre' /uot evSoKtpteiy 7rapd rots
/xa^r/rats'.
'Ei> 8e rovra) 6 /xer KAetTJta? r<j> E?j0?j8?j/uc) aireKpLvaTo

otl navOavoLev ol p,av6dvovTts a o?jk iirioTaLVTO' 6 8e ?/pero
a?jroi> 8td tG>v avr&v &vnep to irpoTepov Tt 8e'; r)
8' os, ovk 277
eVtcrracrat cr?j
"Orav ovv ypdp.p.aTa; .Nai, ecprj. Ovkow airavTa;

'12/uoAo'yet. rts a7rocrro/uaTi(f?7 ortow, ov ypd/u/uara
t
a7rocrro/uariei; I2poAo'yet. 0?3kow coy rt cru e7Ttcrracrai,
ec/jr/, d7rocrrop.ariei, e?7rep 7rdz>ra e7rtcrracrai; Kat rorjro 5
cb/uoAo'yet. Tt ovy; ?/
8' 0?, apa crv (pv) p.avddveLS &tt clv
aTTocrrojuart^/ rts, 6 8e /u?j e7rtcrrd/ue7Jos ypd/x//ara p.av6dvei;

Ouk, dAA', ?/
8' os, p.av6dvoi. Ovkovv cx e7rtcrracrai, ?/
8'
6's, p.avddveLS, enrep ye diravra tcl ypd\xp.aTa e7rtcrracrai. b

'i2juoAo'yrjcrey. 0?jk dpa opd&s dmKpLVO), ecp?j.
Kat ov7rco crcpo'8pa rt raura etpr/ro rco E?30?j8?jp.co, Kat 6

Ato7Ji>cro'8copos cocr7rep crcpalpav eK8e<fd/ue2Jos roy Ao'yoi> 7rdAit
ecrroxdêro ro?3 p.(LpaKLOv, Kal elirev 'Ea7rara cre E?jc3?j- 5
S?j/xos, a> KAet/Jta. et7re ydp /ucn, to p.avddvLV ovk i-nLo-Tr)p.r]v
iorl \ap.j3dvLV tovtov ov dv tls pLavddvr); 'Xl/uoAdyet 6

KAet^tas. T6 8' e7rtcrracr(9at, r) 8' os, dAAo rt ?^ ex ety
iTTLCTTrnxrtv ?/8r/ ecrrtV; 2we'cpr/. To dpa /x?/ iirLcrTacrdaL
e3 Ttfui/ Stephanus : 6/ui' BT W e 4 tJ ipwTtnxa. secl. Hirschig

as iraj/ro] ToyTa scr. Coisl. a6 ou add. Coisl. a8 fiavddvw
T fjLO.vBa.va B W (sed o> supra etW) ^ 5' Ss Routh flSiis T
W </>??
: : :
B b 1 ypd/xixaTa B ypdn/xaTd r T b3 toOto IpijTo

W
:
B : etprjTo toCto T
PLATO, VOL. III. 10

277 c IIAAT12N02
c /x?/7rco e'xety kiTLcrTr)p.r)v eoriv; '{2/>ioAo'yei avrco. Ylorcpov
ovv etcrir ol Kap,(3dvovTs otlovv oi \ovts rjbi) r) o\ av p,r)
tyuxriv; Ot &v Ovkovv p.r). (hp,oK6yr)Kas etvai tovtohv koX

tovs p.r) (iTLcrTap.ivovs, t>v p.r) kyovTC&v; KareVeucre.
5 Tcoy X.ap.(3av6vT0iv dp' clcrlv ol p.avddvovTS, dAA' ov tu>v
ty6vT(v; vve(pr]. Ot p.r) iirLcrTdp.VOL dpa, Zcpr), p.avdd-
vovctlv, (h KAetiua, dAA' ov% ol kiri.crTdp.ivoi.
d "Ert br) im to rpirov Kara/3aAcov axnrep irakaLcrp.a &pp.a

6 Ev6vbr)p.os tov vtavicrKOV Koi iya> yvovs fSairTi(j6p.evov to
pLeipaKiov, (3ov\6p.cvos dvairavcraL avro, p.r) rjpXv a7ro8eiAtd-
crete, Trapap.vdovp.ivos ftirov *12 KAetiua, p.r) 6avp.a(e et
5 crot (paivovrat. dr]6ns ol Adyot. tcrois ydp ovk alcrddvrj
olov ttol^ltov rcb eVco 7re/>t cre* 7roteiroy 8e tovtov dirtp
oX Iv rfj reAer?) rcov Kopv(3dvT(ov, orav rr)v 6p6vaxriv

ttol&ctlv irepl tovtov ov av /xe'AAcocri reAetr. Kal yap eKei
Xppeia tls ecrrt /cat 7rat8id, et dpa Kal rere'Aecrar Kal vvv
e tovtco ovbtv dAAo r) yop^veTov 7rept cre Kat oXov 6p\(dcr6ov
7ratwre, cos /^terd tovto reAowre. vvv ovv vop.Lcrov ra
7rp<3ra rcoy teocov aKovet^ rcoy cro(pLcrTLK(2v. TTpS>Tov ydp,
cos <pr\crL YlpobLKos, 7rept 6vop,aT(av opdoTtjTos p.adtlv 8et*
5 o 8^ Kat (vbeUvvcrdov ctol rco e'i>co, ort ovk r)br)crda to
p.avddvLV oti ol dvdponroL koKovctl pii-v e7rt rco rotcoSe, orav
tls e dpxV s Ptfbep.iav ex<oz> kirLcrTr)p.r)v 7reot 7rpdy/xaro's
278 rtyoy e7retra vcrrepov airov kap,(3dvr) rr)v TTicrTr)p.r)v, KaAovcrt
8e Tavrdv tovto kcu e7retddi> e^coy r)brj Tr)v kiTLcrTr)p.r)v Tavrr)
Trj TTL(TTrip.r) Tavrdv tovto Tr(fayp,a e7rtcrK07n/ r) irpaTTop.Vov
?/ \ty6p.vov p.dk\ov pikv avrb crvvLivaL KakovcrLV r) p.av-
6avtLV, ecrrt 8' otc kol p.av6dvtLV ae 8e tovto, cos ovrot

ivbeiKWVTai, bLaXc-Xrjdfv, ravrbv ovop.a ^7r' dv6p(aiTOLS kvav*
C 1 iffriv T <sx (iv ^

: ir6repov B T irorepoi C 3 ex&xn'
: W
huc transp. Badham post /tij BT: secl. Schanz
: d 1 nara-
fiaKwv Heindorf: KarafiaXibv BT: secl. Badham (etiam rbv vtavio-Kov
secl. Cobet) d 5 o^fleis T et in marg. yp. aAij6e?s B W : W
d8 iroiSxrtv BTWiroiwvrai in marg. T
: CI9 xopeia in marg. Wt ;
Xop-qyia B T W 6 2 naiCovTt T iraifavTts B :

ET0TAHMO2 278 a
rtcos eypvcriv Keip.evov, rco re ei8o'rt koi e7H rco /xr/* irapa-
irkr]crLov b\ rozrra) Kat ro ey rco 8e?jre'pcp epcor?/part, ei> co
r/pcorcoTJ cr 7ro'repa p.av6dvovo~LV ol avdpcoTTOL d ktricrTavTaL b

?} a /xr/. rairra 8r/ rcou p.adr)p,aT(ov ?raita ecrrti> 810 Kat
cp?/p,t eyco crot rourous irpocriTai^LV 7rat8tdy 8e Ae'yco 8td
Tavra, otl, et Kat 7roAAd rts r/ Kat 7rdz>ra ra roiavra p,a6oL,

tcl pJkv TTpa.yp.aTa ovbev av p.akkov et8etr7 7rr/ ex> vpoo~- 5
7ratXety 8e otds r' ay etr/ rots avdpconoLS 8td rrjv t&v ovo-
/xdrcoz; biacpopav VTTOcrK-iki(jov kol avaTpiircov, cocr7rep 01 ra
crKokvOpia tG>v /xeAAoWcoi' Kadiijjcrtcrdai imocrTr&vTes ya.ipovo~L
Kat yskS>crLV, e7ret8di> tScocru; vtttlov avaTZTpap.p.vov. ravra C
/xei> ow crot 7rapd tovtcov ro'/xte 7rat8tdy yeyovevaL' to oe
p,erd ra?3ra 8?/Aoiv ort tovtco yi croi ovtco tcl cr7rou8ata
eV8eteo-0oi>, kol eycb vcprjyr\crop.aL avroXv 'iva /xot o VTrio-ypvTo
airobSxTLV. k(pa.T~~v ydp e7rt8eiacr0at rr/y 7rporpe7rrtK?/iv 5
crocpiav vvv 8e', /xot 8oKet, 8eiV (orjdrJTt-v TTpoTnpov iralcraL

jrpbs cri. TavTa /xei> ovv, co Evdvbrjp.i re Kat Ator>i>cro'8cope,
TTZTTaicr6(o re ?3/xiV, Kat tcrcos iKai>cos ex et * T0 ^ e ^' i
werc* ^.
ra?3ra e7rt8etaroi> TTpoTpiirovTi. tq /xeipaKtoi> o7rcos XP 7)

crocptas re Kat apeTrjs tTTLp.-\kr\6r)vaL. irpoTc-pov 8' eyco crcpcoi'
ei>8eto/xat olov airrb vTrokap.fSav(o kol otov avrov kiTL6vp.(o

ctKOvcraL. iav ovv 8o'co vp.lv tStcoriKcos re Kat yeAotcos aird 5
7rotetV, p.f) p.ov KaTayekarv vtto irpo6vp.ias yap tov aKovaaL

rrjs vp.Tepas o-o(pias Tokp.r)cr(o airavToo~x ( bi>ao~aL ivavriov
vp.(ov. avao-y^cr6ov ovv dyeAacrrt aKovovTes avroi re Kat e
ot p.a6r)Ta\ vp.G>v o~v 8e /xot, co 7rat 'A^tdxoi, aTTOKpivaL.
'Apd ye 7rdrres avdpôiroL /3o?jAo'/xet9a eu 7rpdrrety; ?*/
a7 Tiji T B: eiri t^ tc TW iirl secl. Schanz C3 auTi] aS

Schleiermacher outo Heindorf c4 ^8e/|(r&o' B ii>Scil-cu<T6ov
W
: :
T : evtieil-ao-dov (sed supra a W) C5 &?ro5w(r' W : a7ro5c6o'ei'

BT {avrolv a fj.01 virto^xovTo airoZdativ ci. Winckelmann) e'Trt5ei'|e-
crcâi Stephanus c6 5ei' (f^Q^ry-v i-p6repov T 5eiV cprj0T/T;v

W
:
~rp6rtpov 5e?f B 7ra?crat T : iraiat B : irat|aj W t di TreTratcrflco

T : TreTraucrf a> B d7 dTrauTocrxe8tcicrai W : drr' avrb o"x e 5tacrat B :
auT00"x5tacrai T 6 i dracrxô-fov T : dvacrxefof B

10*

278 e IlAATilNOS
tovto p.ev epa>Trjp,a &v vvvbrj eqbof3ovp.r)V ev tS>v Karayekd-
5 crTOiv; avorjTov yap hrjiiov kol to epcorav ra TOLavra' rts yap
ov /3o7JAerat dv0pa>TTOi>v ev irpaTTeLv; Ou8ets oorts ovk, ecprj
279 6 KAetznas. Etez', r\v 8' eyw* ro brj p.eTa tovto, tTrei.br) (3ov-
kop.e0a ev Txpa.TTe.lv, ttS>s av ev TrpaTTOLp.ev ; ap' av el rjp.lv
irokka KayaOa eirj; r) tovto eKeivov ert evrj0ecrTepov ; brjkov

ydp ttov Kal tovto otl ovtcos eêt. ^vvecprj. <t>epe brj,
5 dyaOa be Trola dpa tS>v ovtoov Tvyydvei rjp.lv ovra; rj ov

XakeTrbv ovbe crep.vov dvbpbs irdvv tl ovbe tovto eoLKev etvaL
evrropelv; iras yap av rjp.lv elrroL ort to rrkovTelv dyadov
rj
ydp; Yldvv y , ecprj. Ovkovv Kal r6 vyLaiveiv kol to
b Kakbv eXvaL Kal raAAa KaTa. to crS>p.a LKav&s TrapecrKevd-

crdaL; StweSoVet. -'AAAa p.rjv evyeVetat ye Kat bvvdp.eLS koX
ri/xat ev rf/ eavrov brjkd ecrTLV ayada oi>ra.' .'12/i.oAo'yet.
Ti ovv, ecprjv, ert rjpXv Aet7rerat tS>v dya0S>v; tl dpa ecrTLv
5 to crcacppovd re euai Kal biâLov Kal dvbpelov; iroTepov
Trpbs Alos, > Kkeivia, rjyfj crv, eav Tavra TL0S>p.ev &>s
ayadd, 6p0S>s r)p.ds 0rjcreLV, rj edv p.rj; lcroos yap &v tls rjp.lv
dp.cf>Lcrl3rjTrjcreLev crol 8e ttS>s boKel; 'Aya0a, ecprj 6 KAet-

c vias. Etei>, rjv 8' eya> % Trjv 8e crocpiav ttov yppov Taop.ev;
ev tols dya0ols, rj ttS>s keyeLs; 'Ev rots aya0ols.
'Ev#u-
p.ov br) p.rj tl TrapakeiTToop.ev tS>v dya0S>v, otl Kal &lov
koyov. 'AAAa p.oL boKovp.ev, ecprj, ovbev, 6 KAeiutay. Kat

5 eyw dvap.vrjcr0els elTrov otl Nat p.d Ata KLvbvvevojxev ye
to jxeyLcrTov tS>v aya0S>v TrapakLTrelv . ^Tt rouro; rj 8' 6s.
Trjv evTvxiav, a> KAetrta* o 7rai>res <rjao-t, Kat ot irdvv
(pavkoL, p.eyLcrTov tS>v dya0S>v eTvaL. 'AAtj^ Ae'yets, e^rj.
Kat eyo)i av TrdkLV p.eTavorjcras elirov otl 'OAtyou Kara-

d ye'Aacrrot eyevop.e0a vtto tS>v evu>v eyca re \at crv, u> iral
'A^to')(ou. Tt brj, ecprj, tovto; -"Ort evTv\iav ev rols ep.-
TTpocr0ev 0ep.evoL vvvbrj av0LS Trepl tov avrov ekeyop.ev.

e 6 a.vdpcirra>v T om. BW : a7 tviroptiv B tvptiv
: hv 1
I" :
om. B b2 yt scripsi : t BT C3 napa.teiirwntv] rrapc

\iirofi(V Cobet
.
ET0TAHMO2 279*
Tt ovv bi) tovto; Karaydkao-Tov br]irov, 6 Tiakai irpoKeLTaL,

tovto itakiv TtpoTtQkvai kol bls Tavra keyeLV.
tovto Aeyets;
'H aocpia bi]iTov, r)v 8' eyca,
TI&s,
zvTvyjia iariv;
ecprj, 5
tovto be Kav Kat e6avp.aaev

ttols yvoirj. bs ovtcos <-tl veos
re Kal evf)6r]s eari. Kdyco yvovs ovtov *Apa 6avp.d(pvTa,
ovk oXada, ecprjv, o> KAetiua, ort 7rept avkr/pLaTcov evirpayiav e
ol avXrjTal evrt>xeVrarot Ovkovv,
eloLv; ^vvecpi]. r)v S'
eyco, Kal 7rept ypap.p.aTo>v ypacprjs re Kal dvayvo>aea>s oi

ypap.p.aTicTTai; Tt
Ylavv ye. 8e'; TTpos tovs ttjs 6akaTTi]s
Kivbvvovs p.G>v otet evTVX*o~Tepovs tlvos etvaL tG>v aocpG>v 5
KvficpvrjTctiV, a)? e7ri Trav lttlv; Ov Tt orpa- brjra. be;

Tev6p.evos p.Ta Trorepov av tov fjbiov Kivbvvov re Kal Trjs
Tvyj]S pere'xoty, p.Ta aocpov arpaTriyov r) p.eTa ap.a6ovs; 280

Merd aocpov. Tt perd moTepov dv
be; dadevG>v rjbeoos
Kivbvvevois,
'Ap'
p.Ta crocpov perd Mera
larpov r) dp.a6ovs;
aocpov. ovv, r)v 5' eya>, ort tvTvytcrTepov av otet 7rpdr-
TLV p.TCL OOCpOV TTpOLTTCOV 1] p.Ta dpLadoVS ',
'2w\pH. 5
'H crocpia apa iravTaxov evrvx^LV 7roiet tovs dvdpo>TTovs.

ov yap br]Trov dp.apTa.voL y dv ttot tl aocpia, dAA' dvdyKt]
dpOcas TrpaTTe.LV koX TvyxdveLV r) yap dv ovkTL aocpia elr}.
2,vva>p.o\oyr]crdp.e6a TekevrGjVTes ovk 018' ottoos ev Kecpa- b

kaia> ovTOi tovto ex LV > ~ocpias irapovcrr]S, <S dv irapr), pL-qbev
TTpocrbiLcrdaL evrvxias- e7rei8?) be tovto avvcop.okoyt]aapLda,

irdkLv iTrvvdav6p.i]v avTov tcl TrpoTepov b>p.okoyr]p.4va tt>s
&v i]p.LV xol. 'Q,p.okoyi]oap.v ydp, ecprjv, et rjpLLV dyaQd 5

7roAAa Trapeirj, evbaLpLOvew &v kol ev irpaTTeLV. ^vvecpt].
*Ap* ovv evbaLp.ovolp.ev dv 8ta ra irapovTa dyaOd, et p.r]bev
ijpRs cticpekol i] et cacpeko?; Et axpeAot, ecpt].

*Ap' ovv dv
tl cocpekoL, et eli] p.6vov r)pXv, xP^P-â b' airots p.f); olov C
d 5 vporidivai] ridevai Cobet e I tinrpaylav secl. ci. Schanz

8L2 rjStus] fiSwv Hirschig a3 KivSvvtvois Bt: KivSvvtitis T
a 7 ti ci. Heindorf -m B T (rts votpia Aldina) b2 $ Uv Casaubon
W
: :
ttrav
b5
BT b3 o-vvwfjLo\oyr)aa/j.t6a T W : o~vvu>ixo\oy7)o~6ntQa B
av] ap Badham c 1 u-pt\o1 tl tX-n Bekker (et sic legit
Iamblichus) : wtpt\olri -n B : w<pt\oiin ei r)i T
;
2 8oc nAATilNOS
<riTia et rffxiv etr/ TroAAd, eadioLfxev be /ur/, r/ ttotov, TrivoLfxev
be fxr), eo-0' otl (Ixpekoip.ed' dv; Oi/ brjra, e<pr/. Tt be;

ol brjfxiovpyol Trdvres, et avrot? eXr\ TrdvTa to. eirtrrfbeta
5 irapeaKevaa p.eva exaoro) ets t6 kavrov epyov, xpfyv70 ê

avTols fxr), ap &v ovrot ev irpaTTOLev btd Tr)v KrrjaLV, otl
KeKrrr/ueVot etev irdvTa a Set KKTrja6aL t6v brffxLovpyov

olov TeKTCov, et TrapeaKevaaptevos etr/ rd re opyava aTravra
Ka\ vXa LKavd, TeKTaivotTO be /ur/, eo-0' otl axpeAotr' av
d cltto rrjs KTrjaeoos; Oi>bap,S>$, ecprf. Tt be, et Tts Kexrrj-
p.evos etr/ 7rAoi5roV re Kat a znwor) ekeyofxev Trdyra ra dya0d,

XP<> ro 8e awrots /urj, ap av evbatfxovot btd Tr)v tovtchv
Krrjatv t>v dya6S>v; Ov brJTa, u> SwKpares. Aet dpa,
5 etprjr, cos eotKev, fxr) p.6vov KeKTrjadat tol roiavra dyadd tov
fji.4kX.ovTa ivbaifiova eaeadat, dkkd Kat xPW^ ai avrols'
ovbev ocpekos rfjs KTrjaecos yiyverat. 'AArjflrj Ae'yets.
*Ap' 57
e ovv, a> KkeLvia, i)br\ tovto lkovov irpos ro evbaiptova irotrjaai

TLva, to re KeKTrjadat rdyadd Kat ro xprjcrOaL avrols;
w
E,uotye 8oKet.
ndrepoz>, r)v 8' eya>, edv 6p6>s xPV TaL Tt?
r) Kal edv /urj; 'Eay dp#<3s. KaAais ye, rjv 8' eyw, Aeyets.
5 irkeov ydp ttov olfxat ddrepov eaTtv, edv rts XPV otiaovv
fxr) 6p6S>s irpdyp.aTt r) edv ea* to fxev yap KaKov, to be ovre
281 kukov oijTe dyadov. rf oi>x ovtu> <pap.ev; Swexwpet. Tt
ovv; ev Trj epyacrtq re Kat xPV~ t T fl ^P' Ta vka fx&v
aAAo rt eorrtr to dTTepya(6p.evov 6p6S>s xPV <r ^ aL V e7rto-rr/pr/
r) TeKTOvtKrj; Ov bifTa, ecfrrf.

'AAAa \xr\v irov Ka\ ev rff
5 7rept ra o-KerJr/ epyao-tq to 6p65>s TTtcrTr\p.r] eariv r/ drrepya-

{fip:evrf. Sivvicprf.
?Ap' ovv, r)v 8'
eya>, Kat 7repi Tr)v xP* Lav
8>v ekeyofxev to TTp&rov t&v dya6S>v, ttXovtov re Kat vyLeias
C 2 itot6v~\ irord ci. Heindorf e 6 &v T W : om. B '6rt T : 0/ B

d.3 rijv rovruv rSov ayadwu kttjctiv Iamblichus d4 Sf? Iamblichus :
5Ti/ BTW d6 fjIamblichus: &s BT

ei ^Sr? TW
Stobaeus h 8)) B rovro licavbv T Stobaeus rovry tcaWicp B
W
: : :
rovrai KaWia) 64 ^ ica! ^ BTW:

Stobaeus ye Sto-
baeus St B T
: W 65^
bpdus ot<?ovv 1rpd.yfj.ar1 Iamblichus
Stobaeus
:
ET0TAHMO2 28ia
kcu KaKhovs, to 6p6cos 7ra<n rots tolovtols \prja-6aL cttl-
(TTijp.ri tjv 7jyovfj.4vtj Kal Karopdovcra Ti]v irpaîv, ?*/ dkko ti; b
'E7rtcrr?//>i??, ?/
8' 6s. Ov p.6vov dpa tvTv\iav akkd Kal
evirpayiav, oos colkcv, Trapzyjti toXs dvOpooTTOLS
iv irdcrr\ Kr??cret re kol

r) e7rtcrr?7U??
7T/)dei.
'Q/xoAdyet. "Âp ovv co
Trpbs Atd?, r)v 8' eyco, ocpzkos tl toov dkkcov KTr\p.aToov dvev 5
cppovqcrecos Kal crocpias; dpd ye dv ovavro dvQpooiros Trokka

KKTTf}p.VOS Kal TTOkkd TTpaTTCOV VOVV /UO/ i\OiV, Tj p.dkkov
okiya vovv X- V &^ ^ 6 ctkottcl' ovk eAdrrco irpaTTcov
>
eAdrrco dv kap.apTavoL, kkaTToo 8e dp.aprdvcov tJttov dv C

Ka/cws TTpdrTOL, t]ttov 8e KaKws TtpaTToov ddkios rjrrov dv
eiri ; Yldw y, ec/>??. II orepov ovv dv p.akkov eAdrrco tls
irpaTTOL irvr)s oov r) Trkovcnos; Ylevrjs, ec/jr?. UoTepov 8e
dcrOcvrjs r) lcrxypos;
'Ao-flezn/s. HoTepov 8e zvTLp.os r) 5
drtuos; "ATLp.os. UoTepov 8e dvbpelos oov /cat croocppoov
eAdrrco ar irpaTTOL r\ 8etAds; AetAd?. Ovkovv Kal dpybs

p.akkov ?*/ ipydTrjs; Kat2we)(copei. ftpabvs p.akkov ?*/
rax^?, Kat ap.(3kv opcov kol aKovcov p.akkov

'Ey r) 6v; nd^ra d
rd TOLavra crvvexcopovp,V dAA?/Aot?. Kec/>aAatcp 8', ec/jr/r,
a KAetyta, KLvbvveveL o-vp.TravTa a rd irpooTov ecpap.tv dyadd

tlvaL, ov Trepl tovtov 6 Adyos atirot? eti>at, ottoos avrd ye
Ka&* avrd TrecpvKev ayaOa [etVat], dAA' oos (OLKev co8' eêf 5
(dv p*v avT&v rjyrjraL dpiadia, /xetco KaKa elvai tcov evav-
ricov, dcrcp 8ui>arcorepa VTTrjptTCLV rco r)yovp.*vop k<xkQ> ovtl,
edv 8e cppovrjcris re Kat crocpia, /xet^co dyac^d, avra 8e Kac^'
airrd o?38e're/?a avroov ovbzvbs dtjta etrat. 4>atyerai, ec/>?/, e
co? colkv, ovtoos, cos crv Aeyet?. Tt ovv r)pXv crvp.fiaivt.L Ik
a8 rb . . . xpvcdai secl. Badham b 1 ?)v~] tj Badham b3 ro7s

a.vdpd>irois TW Iamblichus om. B
: b6 av ovairo B : bvivair'
av T b7 /xaWov
i) 6\lya ; (om. voy/
xft"/) C3 &i/ Iamblichus
T om. B
: c6 wl adxppuv secl. Badham c 7 irparrot T
irpdrrois B (sed 0- punctis notatum) d 2 fu'x a'P ''M e ' T {w- W :
Xtipovv iv B d 3 KicSfcei^ct B kic St/revcis T d 4 6 \6yos

:
avro?s] avroTs 6 \6yos Iamblichus d 5 ?âi T (sed postea additum

videtur Schanzio) Iamblichus om. B d6 rjyjjrai B rrytTrat
: W :
T (sed suprascr. rj)

28ie nAATX2N02
tG>v eipr\\xV(av ; dkko tl ?/ tG>v \xev dkko>v ovbev ov ovt
ayaObv ovre Kanov, tovtolv be bvoiv ovtolv r\ \xev crocpia
5 dyadov, rj be a\xadia KaKov; Q,\xok6yL.

v
282 Ert toCvvv, ecpr\v, to koLirbv eiTLcrKy\ro>ixe6a. eiTLbr\
evbai\xoves \xev elvaL Trpo6v\xov\xe6a TrdvTes, ecpdvr\\xev be

tolovtol yLyvo\xevoL K tov yj>r\cr6ai T TOIS TTpdypaCTLV Kal
6p6G>s \pr\cr6aL, rr\v be 6p6oTr\Ta Kal evrvyjiav TTLcrTr\\xr\ {r/v)
5 r\ irapeyovcra, bel br\, o>s eoLKev, K iravTos Tporrov diravTa

dvbpa tovto TrapacrKevdCecrdal, 6tto>s a>$ o~ocpu)TaTos ecrraL'
77 ov; Nat, ecpr\. Kat 7rapa 7rarpo? ye 6t/7toi) toSto 010'-
\xevov belv Trapaka\x\3dvLV irokv \xakkov 77 ypr\\xara, kox
b 7rap' eiTLTpoTTCOv Kal cpiko>v tG>v T dkkcov Kal tG>v cpacrKov-

tu>v epacrT&v LvaL, /cat eva>v <al tto\ltG>v, beofxevov kcu
iKTVOVTa crocpias peraoiSciVai, ovbev alcrypov, S> KkeLvia,
ovbe ve\xecrr\Tbv eveKa tovtov vTrr\pTLV kol bovkeveLV Kal
5 epaoTT/ /cat 7rarTi dv6po>TT(o, otlovv edekovra virrjpeTeXv tG>v
KakG>v virrjpTr}pLaTO>v, -Tpo6v\xov\xVov crocpbv yev(r6aL' 7/ ov

80/cet crot, (prjv eya>, ovto>s; Yldvv \xev ovv ev \xol boKls
C keyLV, rj 0' os. Et eort ye, o> KkeLvia, r\v 8' eyco, 7/ crocpia
bLbaKTov, dkka. \xr\ dirb TavTo\xaTov irapayiyvTaL toZs dvdpo>-
TTOLS' TOVTO ydp TffXLV TL dcTKTTTOV Ka\ OVTTO) dtCOpoAoy?/-

fxevov efxoi T kol croL .'AAA' e/xotye, e(pr\, S> ScoKpaTe?,
5 8i8aKroi> etvat 8oKet. Kat eyo> f\crdels etTrov *H KakG>s

Aeyets, S> dpLcrre dvbpG>v, Kal ev eiroCr\cras dirakkdâs fxe
O-K\l/0t)S TTokkijS 1Tp\ TOVTOV OVTOV, 7TOTpOV bLbaKTOV 7/ 07J
8t8aKToy 77 cro(pCa. vvv ovv eTreLbrj crot Kal bLbaKTov boKet

Kal \x6vov tG>v ovtcov evbaC/xova Kal eiiTVxrj ttollv tov
d dv6pa>TTov, dkko tl 7/ <paCr\s dv dvayKcxiov elvaL cpLkocrocpeLV
kol avTos ev vG> eyeLS avTO TTOLeiv; Tidvv \xev ovv, ecpr\,
S) ScuKpaTes, o>s olov Te \xdkLcrTa.
a 1 eirttSi] T : eireiSl) 8e B a4 9jv rj Badham (^j/ ci. Heindorf ) :
iar\v Iamblichus : ^ BT a5 awavra] irdvra Iamblichus

b6
ri
irpodv/j.ovjj.evoi' T W : irpodvfiovfievos B (sed v suprascr. b)

C 3 &aK(irrov B W : aKticriov T
:
ET0TAHMO2 2 82d
Kdyco tclvto. do~p.evos aKovo~as, To p.ev ep.6v, e(pr]v, irapd-
beiyp.a, a> ALOvvcroboope re /ccu Ev6vbi]p.e, oXcov TTL6vp.G> tu>v 5
TTpOTpTTTLKu)v koyOOV eXvaL, TOLOVTOV, IbLOOTLKOV 10-0)9 KOt
f/.o'A.t? 8td p.aKpG>v keyop.evov o~(pS>v be O7ro're0o? /3ovAerat,

TavTov tovto Teyvr] irpaTToov e7ri8etc;drco fjpuv. ei be p.rf
tovto j3ovkeo~6ov, 66ev eyco cmiknrov, to kr)s eTTLbeiârov e

rco p.eipaKiu>, TTOTepov Traaav Trio~T~jp.r]v bel avTov KTacrdaL,
r) ecrrt tls p.ia rjv bel kafiovTa evbaLpLovelv re Kal ayadbv

avbpa elvaL, koll rt? atJrr/. co? yap ekeyov apypp.evos, irepl
Trokkov rjp.lv TvyyavtL ov Tovbe tov veavio~KOV o~0(p6v re 5
Kat ayadbv yevecrdaL.

'Eyco p.ev ovv raCra cTttov, 00 KpiToov rco be /merd tovto 283
eaop.evu> irdvv crcpobpa irpocrelyov tov vovv, Kal eirecrKOTrovv
riva TTOTe. Tpoirov clxj/olvto tov koyov koX oirodev &poivto

TrapaKekev6p.evoL rco veavicrKoo crocpiav re Kat dperrjv ao~Kelv.
6 ovv TrpeafivTepos avT&v, 6 ALOWcroboopos, irpoTepos fjpyeTO 5
tov koyov, koI r)p.els irdvTes efikeTrop.ev irpos ovtov a>s
avrtKa p.dka aK0vo~6p.evoL 6avp.ao~iovs tlvcls koyovs. oirep
civv kol crvvefii) r)pXv 6avp.ao~Tov ydp TLva, a> Kptrcop, aviip b
KaTrjp\ev koyov, ov crot d^Lov aKodcraL, cos TrapaKekevoTLKbs
6 koyos r)v e7r' dpeTijv.
Et7re p.0L, e(pr\, a> 2coKpare's re Kat v/xets 01 dAAot, ocrot

(pare eirLdvp.elv Tovbe tov veavicrKOV o~o(pbv yevecrdaL, 7ro're- 5
pov 7rat(fere raiSra Ae'yoyres r) oos dkrjdoos eiri6vp.e'LTe koX

cnrovbd(eTe;
Kdyco bLevor]6rjv otl oor}6r}Tt]v dpa r)p.ds to irpoTepov
iraiêLv, rfvUa eKeketiop.ev bLake\6r)vaL rco veavio~K(o avrco,
Kat 8td ravra Trpoo-eTraLcrdTr}v re Kat ovk ecriTovbacrdrqv 10
d.5 Routh : oTov B T

o'iwv W
(otov . . . rbv irpoTpeirriKhv \6yov corr.
Ang. C 4) I e 1 &7rA(7roj' B : cnrfMiirov WiirtSeiârov : T T
iircStlZaTov B (sed t supra e B ) 64 ws yap Hermann {Sxrirep yap
s
corr. Coisl. ) : Sxrirep B : T W

s Sxrirep Schanz a 2 iirto-K6-rovv
B W : io-Koirovv T a3 aipotvro Heindorf : ctycupTO BT W
a5 fy>X eT0 l %PX e Schanz b 1 aviip Bekker : 6 avijp Vat. 1029
avijp BT b2 aol B : o~v T b 9 avrw T : avTcji B

283C nAAT&N02
C ravra ovv biavo7]6els eu ijd.KX.ov etirov ort 9avpao~Tu>s
0~ TTOvb 0.(^0 Lp.V.
Kal 6 ALovva~6bcopos, SKoVet p.r\v, ec/>??, > Sw/cpare?,

07T0)s px\ eapvos eV?/ a vvv Aeyets.
"EcrKe/xpxu, ?/z> 8' eyar
5 ov yap pj\ ttot eapvo$ yeVco/xat. Tt ovv; <pr\' cpare
(3ovX.<r9aL avrbv o~o<pbv yevecr9aL; Udvv p.ev Nvv
ovv.
be, r) 8' 6$, KAetzuas Trorepov <ro<pos ecrrtz> t)

ov; Qvkovv
cpi/cri ye' ttoo' <ttlv bi, rjv 8' eyco, oii/c dAacoz>. 'Tpets 8e',
d ecprj, j3ov\tr9e yevio~9aL avrbv crocpov, dp.a9r) be p.r) etvai;

?Q.p.o\oyovp,V. Ovkovv h$ piev ovk <-o~tlv, \3ovkeo~9e
avrbv yevicr9aL, bs 8' efcrri z>w, p;??Kert etvaL. Kat eycb
aKO??cras 6opvj3rj9rjv' 6 bi \xov 6opvj3ovp.ivov VTToka\3<av,

v
5 AAAo rt oS^, ecprj, e7ret \3ovkeo~6e avrbv bs vvv ecrrii
pr/Kert eTvaL, \3ovkeo~6e avTov, <hs eoLKev, diroktokivaL; Katrot

7ToAAou av aftot ol tolovtol etev cptAoi re Kat epaarat,
otrtês ra 7rat8tKa 7rept iravTos av itoLf]o~aLVTO e<fbAcoAe'z>at.
e Kat 6 Kr?/crt7r7ros' aKovcras r)yavaKTr\<riv re V7rep rwy

9
7rat8tK<Si> Kat et7re^* 12 <fe'z>e ovpte, et p.r\ dypoLKOTepov,
e<pr\, rjv elTrelv, ei7roz> av " 2ot et? Ke<pakr\v," otl p.a6<av p,ov
Ka\ tQ>v dkkcov Karai/Vevo?/ tolovtov irpdyp.a, 6 eyco otpai

5 ot>8' ocrtoy etz>at kiyeLV, co? eyco roV8e \3ovkoCp.r\v av e<~okco-
AeVat.
Tt 8e', ecpr/, a> Krr/crt7r7re, 6 Ev0?;8r?pos', ?] 8oKet crot olov
t LvaL \(revbeo~6aL; N?) Ata, e<pr\, et p.i\ p.aCvop.aC ye.~
v
ITorepoz> kiyovra to irpdyp.a 7rept ov dv 6 Aoyos r), ?/ /x?

284 Xiyovra; Aiyovra, <prj. 0?jkow et7rep Aeyet avro, ovk
dXXo Aeyet r<3z> ovtcov r) Klvo oTtep Aeyet; Yltos yap dv;
e<pri 6 Kr?/cri7r7ros. *Ev p.r\v KaKelvo y Icttlv t&v ovtcov, 6
XiyeL, \cop\s tcov dkXcov. Tlavv ye. Ovkow 6 eKeXvo
O 1 davnacrrus (a>s) Cobet C5 rfj ^ Schanz C6 f}ov\etrOai

B T favAeo-Oe
: W
C 8 ^j/ S' iyd> T om. B d6 frovXto-Qe
: W
T $ov\fo-0ai B
: d 7 &' izîoi T avd^toi B e 1 re T T6
: :
*caJ B e3 fj.aOdv] iraQiev Schanz /xov~] e/xov Heindorf e oiov ~]
T o!6s B
: a 2 tbv ovtuv secl. Badham fo B T W &v &\\aas t :
a3 ko.k(7vo B: /ra;ce?T

ET0TAHMO2 284^
Ae'ya>z> rd 6v, e<pr\, Ae'yet; Nat.'AAAd mt/v 6 ye rd ov 5
Keycov kcu tcl oito. Ta\rj$ij Aeyet* ojo"T o Aiovvo-o'6a>pos,

elirep Ae'yet rd dVra, Ae'yet TaXrjOrj kol ovbev Kara crov
vx/evderat.
Nat, e<prj* dAA' 6 ravra Xeycov, ecprj 6 KTrjcmnros, a> b

Evflvdr/pe, ov to. ovra Ae'yet.
Kat 6 Evflvdr/uos, Td 8e mt/ dvra, e<pr\, dAAo ti r/ ovk

Zcttlv; Ovk eortv.
v
AAAo Tt ovv ovbap.ov t<x ye mt/ dzra
ovra eoTtv; Ovbap.ov. "Eortv ovv 6tt<os Trept rajjra, tcl mt/ 5
ovTa, 7rpdcfeiez> av tls ti, <o<tt eKetva Trotr/o-etev av Kal

octtlctovv tcl p.r\bap.ov ovra; Ovk euotye doKet, ecpr/ 6 Krr/o--
t7T7j-os.- Tt ovv; ol prJTopes otov \4yoxriv ez> ru dr/ua),
ovdev TTpaTTov<TL; TlpaTTovcrL piev ovv, r/ d' os. Oijkovz'
et7rep irpaTTOvcrL, kol ttolovctl;
retv re Kat iroLe.LV eoTtv;

Nat. To Aeyetv dpa
Ovk apa
'XlMoAdyr/o-ez'.
irpar-
t<x
C
ye jut) dvr', i<pr\, Ae'yet ovdets ydp av

7roioi r)br) rt* o-v Se
a)MoAo'yTTKas rd mt) oy mt/ otdz> r etvat fxrjbeva ttolcXv
cocrre KaTa. tov <tov Xoyov ovbels ix/evdr/ Ae'yet, dAA' enrep >
Ae'yet Atovva-dSa)pos, TakrjOrj re Kat rd om Ae'yet.
Nr/ Ata, ecpr/ d KrT/o-t7r7ros, a> Ev6vbr)p.e' dAAd rd 6i<Ta
p.ev tpottov tlvcl Aeyet, ov MeVrot &$ ye eêt.

Tl<o$ Ae'yets, ecpr/ d Aiovvcrddajpos, <o KrTjcri7r7re; etcrtv
ydp rtves o\ Xeyovcri tcl Trpa.yp.aTa <os exei; Eto-iv p.evToi, d

ecprj, ot KaAot re Kayaflot Kat ot TaXrjOr) Aeyovres. Tt ovv;
r/ 8' os* TayaOa. ovk ev, e<pr/, e)(ei, tcl de KaKa KaK<os;
Svvexwpei. Tovs be KaXovs re Kat ayadovs duoAoyets Ae'-
yetv ws eêt rd Trpa.yp.aTa; .'OMoAoyai. KaK&is apa, lcpr/, 5
XiyovcTLv, <o Kti]<tltttt, ol ayaOol tcl KaKa, et7rep <a$ lx ei

Ae'yovo-tz'. Nat pd Ata, r/ 5' d?, crcpobpa ye, rovs yovz'
b4 &\\o tj T : dAA.' ori B bs ovra secl. Hirschig 0?/ T:

om. B tcx fii) ovra secl. Badham b6 yp. Sxrr iKtlva in marg.
T et in marg. W &s ye icAtivia B
: W
0-7' iKAftvia T
: c 4 rb
fjdj ov B W : tci /x^ vvra T /j.r)Stva T ttrjSf B 05 \6yov
:
TW: om. B
a84d nAATHNOS
kcikovs dvOpcoTrovs' cov crv, kdv \xol 7ret0r/, vka/3r)crr) etWt,
e Xva pvq cre ol aya6o\ KaKoos kiycocrLv. cos e3 tcr0' otl KaKcos
XiyovcrLV ol ayaOol tovs KaKOVS. Kai tovs /xeydAous, ec/jr/
6 F,v6vbr)p.os, /xeydAcos Aeyoucrt kcCl tovs OepjJiovs 6epp.5>s;-

MdAiara 8r/7rot>, e<pr/ 6 Krr/cri7T7ros' tovs yovv ^rv\povs
5 \f/vxpS>s keyovcrC re Kal cpacrlv 8taAeyecr0ai. 2v p.iv, fcpr) 6
ALOVvcrobcopos, koLboprj, S> Krr/crt7r7re, AotSopf/. Md At' ovk

eycoye, r/
8' os, S> ALOvvcr6bu>p, eVei c/hA<5 cre, dkka vov-
6ht5> cre cos eratpoy, *cat Tretpw/xat 7ret(9eii> /xr/8e7rore IvavrCov
t\p.ov ovtws aypoLKcos Aeyetv ort eycb roirrorjs /3ocvAo/i.ai
285 efoAcoAeVat, ovs 7repi 7rAetVrojj iroLOvp.aL.
'Eyco ovy, e7ret8r/ pot e8o'Kow dyptcorepcos 7rpos dAAr/Aocvs

exetv, irpocrTraL(6v re rov Krr/a-tTTTrozv Kai et7TOiv ort 'X2
Kr7jo-t7r7re, e/>iot peiv 8oKet \prjvaL r/pas irapa tG>v <feVcoiv
5 hiytcrdaL a kiyovcrLv, edi> efle/Xcocrt 8t8divat, Kat /xr) 6v6p.aTL

8tac/>epe<r(9ai. et ydp e7rt<rraivrai orjroos ZokkvvaL dv6pco-
ttovs, oocrr' e*K Trovrjp&v re Kai dcppovcov yj>r)crTovs re Kai
ep.cppovas ttolcXv, kol tovto etre avrco rjvprjKarov etre Kai
b 7rap' akkov tov c\p.a6zTr)v cpdopov tlvcl Kai okadpov tolovtov,
&ctt CLTToX4cravTs TTOvr)pov ovTa xprjcTTov ttci/Klv a7TocprjvaL'
et roCro iirCcrTacrdov 8/7A01V 8e ort kiTLCTTacrdov kcpaTr)v
yovv Tr)v Ttyvr)v crcpG>v etivat rr/iv iveooo-ri t)vpr)p.ivr)v dyadovs

5 7rotety totjs dvdpcoirovs eK Trovrjpcov crvy\oipr)cru>p.iv orjjv
avTow avTO' dirokecrdvTOdV r)p.lv to peipdKiov Kal cppovLpLOV

TTOLrjcrdvTcav, kol aTravTas ye ^//.as roi)s dAAovs. et 8e v/xets
C ot re'ot c/)o/3etcrf9e, wcrTTep ey Kapi ey e/xoi ecrrco 6 Kti>8wos #
cos eyco, e7ret8r/ Kai 7rpecr/3vrr/s etpt, TrapaKtvSwevety erot-
/u.os Kai TrapabCbcopLL epLavrov ALOvvcrobu>p(o tovtco cocr7rep rr/
Mr/8eta r?/ Ko'Ax<f). aTroAAvrco pe, Kai et /xev /3or;Aerat,
e2 /cal B T ^ /cal t
: e 6 \0tS0pu AoiSope? AoiSopei . . W
W
. :
. AoiScipet BT a 2 aypiwrepws B T aypoiicaiTepces a 3 toj/

W
. . :
KTrio-nnrov B t^ KTijaiTnr^ T
: a 5 & \iyovo~iv secl. Badham et
mox aj/ pro eav scripsit StSoâj BTW (sed /xeTa in marg. T)
C 1 (po&eto-Qe T : </>o/3eJV0at B /capl T W : a/capi" B V ante
ifxol secl. Cobet

ET0TAHMO2 285C
ei//-e'rco, et 8', otl /3ovAerai, tovto 7ôtelrco ,

p.6vov \pr\o-Tov 5
a.TTO(pr]vdT(o.
Kat 6 Kr?;o"t777ro?, 'Eyco p,eV, ecpr/, Kat avTos, 2> ScoKpares,

(TOLfios etpt -napiyeiv ip.avTov rots tvots, Kat eay fiovkaiv-
v
rat bepeiv ert pJdXkov i) vvv bipovcnv, e? juot 17 8opd /x?/ ets
dcrKov reAew?/o"ei, cocr7rep ?/ rou Mapo-wu, dAA' ets apeTrjv. d

Katrot pe oterat Atoi;?jcro'8copos ovroo-t yakeiraiveiv a?3rco
eycb 8e ou x a ^ f7ratz;ft) > a^' dvTikeyai irpbs ravra a p.01
boKtl irpos jue /x?) KaAcos Ae'ye\ ctAAd cri ro di>rtAe'yeu>,

ecpr/, co yezwate AtorucrdScope, /x?) KaAet Aoi8opeto-<9ar tTtpov 5
ydp ri eart rd Aot8opeicr<9ai.
c
Kat AtoyutrdStopoy, 2s dVros, e<p?/, roS dj>rtAe'yeu>, co
Kr?/cri?T7re, 7rot?/ roi/y Adyovs;

ndurcos' 8?/7rou, ecpr/, Kat crqbobpa ye* r/ o-v, co Atorucro'- e
8cope, ovk otet etyat dvTiXiyav;
Ovkovv av y dv, ecpr/, a7ro8etais 7rco7rore aKO?Jo"as ovbevbs
dvTikiyovTOs kTcpov erepco.
'AA?/<9?7 Ae'yets; ecp?/' dAAd aKovcov /xev iwt <rot d?To8et- 5
Kvvp.i dvTihsyovTOS Kr?/cri7nrou Aioi>t><ro8copco.
*H Kat ?37ro'o-xois dv tovtov Koyov;

ndyu, e<p?/.
Ti ovv; r) 8' os' etcriy eKacrrcp t&v ovtuiv Adyot;

ndyu ye. Ovkow ct>? eorty <-Kao~Tov r) cos ouk 4cttiv; . 10
'i2y ecrrty. Et ydp /Aep.yr/crai, ecpr/, co Krr/cri7r7re, Kat dprt 286

e7re8eta/xey pvqbiva Kiyovra ws ovk eorr rd ydp /x?/ dy
ovSets ktpdvi) Ae'ycoy. Tt ovv br) tovto; r) 8' ds 6 Kr?/ai7r-
ttos' T]ttov rt drrtAe'yo/xez> eyco re Kat o~v; Ylorepov ovv,
r) 8' os, dvTikiyoipav dv tov ovtov irpdyp.aTos Xoyov dpicpo- 5
d i Sxrirtp i\ rov Mapvvov secl. Susemihl d 2 kcutoj /t

T W Kal t' oi)uoi B CI4 ri W: nji BT ds êwaFe
W
:
B : om. T d7 ol B : koI 6 T ei iriT: iraiB

e3 7' aV Coisl. av T :
: r' r' av B 65 okovwv fikv vvvi
Badham okovw fihv vvv e? B : aKovw/xtv vvv tX T : aKovofitv vvv'
W
:
tl e8 7raVi/] ttocu 7' Heindorf as toOJ rhv rov

Heindorf
1 ;
286a nAATi2N02
repot Aeyovres, r) ovtco p.\v dv brjirov ravTa Aeyoiuev;
2vvx<opi.
'AAA' orav p.1)bTpOS, <prj, tov tov Trpdyp.aTos
b Ao'yov Ae'yr/, tot dvriKyoLp.v dv; r\ ovtco ye to irapdirav
ovb' av p.p.vr)pAvos etrr tov 7rpdyuaros ovbircpos r)p.(ov;-*
Kat tovto <rvvcop.oK6yL.-

'AAA' dpa, otov eyco p\v tov tov
Trpdyfj.aTos Koyov Kiyco, cru Se ctAAou tlvos dKKov, tot
5 dvTikyop.v; r\ eyco Ae'yco p.v to irpdyp.a, <rv 8e ovb\ Ae'yets
to Tsapditav; 6 be p.r) Kiycov rco KiyovTL ttcos {dv) cWiAe'yot;

Kal 6 piV Krr/cri7nros ecrtyrrcrezr eyco 8e 6avp.d<ras tov
Koyov, ITcos, <pr)v, <o ALovvo~6bcop, Ae'yets; ov ydp tol
c dAAd tovtov ye tov Koyov ttoKKcov br) k<u noKKaKLS aKt)Kocos
det 6avpA(jo Kal yap ol dp.<p\ Ylp<oTay6pav <r<pobpa iyjpcovTo
avT<o kol oi tl 7raAatdrepoi* e/uot 8e det 6avp.a<rTos tls
boKL LvaL koX tovs t dKKovs dvaTpitrcov Kal avrbs avrov
5 otuai 8e avTOV Tr)V dKrjd^Lav irapd <rov KciAAtcrra ttv-
<T<r6aL. dKKo tl \j/vbrj Ae'yetr ovk Kcttlv; tovto yap

bvvaraL 6 Koyos' rj ydp; dAA' r/ KiyovT dKr)6rj KiyeLv r/
wr) KiyLv;
^VV\<OpL.
d TloTcpov ovv ~pvbfj uez> KiyLV ovk <ttl, bo^d&LV p.ivrcL
<TTLV,
Ovb~ bodLV, <f)t).
Ovb* dpa \l/vbris, rjv cV eyco, boa ecrrt to irapdirav.

5 Ovk <pr).
J
Ovb dpa dp.a6ia orj' duacêts dvdpcoiroL' r) ov tovt av
Lt) dp,adia, enrep etr/, to ^/V0cr6aL tcov -rpayp,dTcov
Yldvv ye, <pi).
AAAa tovto ovk <ttlv, r\v o eyco.
io Ovk <\>r).
a6 \iyovTts W: yv6vr(S BT ovtu T: ovtoi B tiv Srfirov
B W Sfaov bv T (sed corr. T)

: b 3 &pa B T tyy in marg. T W :
b4 &WovB: SpaTW b6 hv add. Par. 181 b7 effiyr)o-ev
T W e\tytv tv B eAeyec ovoev Schanz C 5 KaWiffTa B T W :
W
: :
jUaA.Hrra in marg. T C 6 a\\' oti B &\\o ti T d 7 e?7rep : f)
T u irapuy B
elfr; : W
;sed e supra a W
; ;
EY0TAHMO2 286d
Aoyov eVe/ca, ) ALOvvcrobcope, Aeyets rbv koyov, tva br)
aroirov Ae'y?/s, ?/ cos akrjdcos Soxet ctol ovbds etvai ap.a6r)s
avdpcoircov;
'AAAd o"6, e</)?/, eAeycfor. e

*H Kal eort tovto Kara tov crbv koyov, e<feAe'y<fat,
py]b(vbs xjstvbop.evov
Ovk eortzv, tcprj 6 Ev6vbr]p.os.
Ov8' apa (KzXevev, tcprjv ey&r, vvvbr] ALovvcrobcopos 5
To yap /xr/ ov ttcos av tls KeAevcrat; crv 8e KeAevets;

f
'Ort, rjv 8' eyco, S Er3t9rJ8?//xe, rd o~o<pa ratira Kal tcl ev
ZyovTa ov irdvv tl p.avddvco, dkka T-ayJ.it)s ttcos (vvoco.
"lctcos pic-v ovv cpopTLKcoTepov tl pr]crop.aL, dAAd cTvyyiyvcocrKi. 10
dpa 8e'* et yap p-?/re \jrevbecrdaL ecrrtzv /u?/re \j/vbrj 8o<fd(feu' 2 ^7

p?/re dp.adr) etzvat, dAAo rt o?38' Zap.apTavLV zcttlv, orav rts
rt 7rpdrr?/; irpaTTovTa yap ovk c-cttlv ap.apTaVLV tovtov o
TrpaTTzL' ov\ ovtco Ae'yere;
ndivu y', ecp?/. 5
Tot5rd ecrriz; ?/8r/, ?]y 8' eyco, rd cpopTLKOv epcorr/pa. et
ydp /a?/ ap.apTavop.zv p.?/re 7rpdrroz>res //?/re Ae'yoz>res p^/re
bLavoovp.voL, vp.cls, o) irpbs Atds, et Tavra ovtcos exet, rtz>os

8t8dcr/<aAot ?/Kere; r/ ovk dprt ecpare apTr)v KaAAicrr' dy
7rapa8o?3z>ai avdpcoTTcov tco kOikovTL p.avddvLv b
Etr', e</3?j, co 2wKpares, 6 ALOWcrobcopos virokaficov, ovtcos
et KpoVos, cocrre a rd irpcoTov et7ropez> w avap.Lp.vf]crKr], Ka\

et rt TrkpvcTLV *lttqv, vvv avap.vt]crdr]CTr], tols 8' ez> rco irapovTL
Aeyo/xeVots ov\ eeis ort XP 7}' 5
e5 cKe'\t/v, e<f>7jf Hermann : (KeXcvov e<pri B T 8ioj/u<7o'5a>0os B :

6 DiovvcrdSapos T e7 ci; Se Ke\eveis ori in marg. yp. ouSe W
W
:
*c\Us 8rt B om. T e8 ijj/ 8' ^'^cb 5 -v6v8r)fi.e B W : S
W
:
iit?u5r)yue ^' 5' e^w T e 9 ou W

T : om. B iraxtcms : raxtos
BT as ?iA\0Ti Routh: dAA.' grt BT b2JBT:om.W
outwj e? Kpovos T owtwo-1 eros
: BW (sed e? supra t W) et yp. Kevbs in
marg. T b4 vvv ava/j.vrio-6-fio-fi secl. Badham b5 A.e70/ueVo(yj
Ktyontvois \6yois ci. Heindorf: Ao'7ois Baiter xpi? l :
XP^ BT
287b IIAAT&NOS
Kat yap, (pr]v eyco, xaAe7rot etcrty tt&vv eiKoVcos* 7rapd
crocpojv yap Ae'yoi>rat e7ret koX tovt(o rto reAeuratco iray-
X&keirov yjpricrao-Oai Icttlv, co Aeyets. to yap " Ovk e>(co drt
Xpcop.at " rt 7rore Aeyets, S Atoin;crd8cope; 77 8r/Aoy ort cos
C ovk eyob eeAe'yat avrov; e7ret et7re', rt aot aAAo yoet tovto
to prjpa, to "Ovk e'x<w dVt XPW^H- - 1 T0 ^s Adyots ";
'AAA' o cri; Ae'yets, ecpr/, {tovtg tco 7rdy?j xaktirov xpV (T ^ al''}
e7ret attoKpivai.
5 ripty ae airoKpivacrdaL, rjv 8' eyco, co Atoi>i)cro'8cope;
Ovk airoKpivri; icprj.

T
H Kat hiKaiov;
AUaiov peVrot, ecpr/.
Kara rtya Adyoz>; ^y 8' eyco* r/ 87/Aoy ort Kard roV8e,
10 drt crv vvv TT&crcrocpos rts r)pXv d<ptai 7rept koyovs, Kat olcrOa
d dVe 8et arroKpivacrdai kol 6're /ur/; /cat zwv o?38' ai> drtow
aTTOKpivrj, a,T yiyvcacTKOiv otl od 8et;
AaAets, ecpr/, d/xeAr/cras airoKpivacrdai' dAA', coyatfe', ttclOov
kol aTTOKpivov, kirtLhr) Kat dpoAoyets /xe crocpov etz>at.
5 ITeicrreoi; Toivvv, rjv 8' eyco, Kat avayKrj, cos eotKey cru
ydp apx^LS. dAA' epcora.

IloVepo^ ow \jrvxr)v X 0VTa V0 ^ Ta voovvTa, r) Kal tol
a\j/vx a ;
Td ^rvxw *X 0VTa '
10 Oto-0a ow rt, ec/)r/, pr/p.a \j/vxrj v %X 0V >

Md Ata ovk eycoye.
e Tt oijy apri r/pou ort jaot root rd prjp,a;
Tt dAAo ye, r/y 8' eyco, r) irjp.apTov 8ta rr/i> /3AaKetW;
b9 t( Heindorf : 4 t( B
ewoiiBT
T
: W C2
c 1 t( aoi B : t(s coi T
^
j/oe? ci. Stallbaum : xpfovH-"- 1 "T : xP^ <rolJ ai -
C 3 dA\* & B : #AAo T ry BT:

toiJt^ . . .
XP^ *^ 01 * seclusi
7' oip Badham Sauppe : c 6 airoicpive? Heindorf
toi d 1 ovS'
&i/] ovSeu Heindorf ou5' Schanz d.3 toO ante airoKpivaadcu add. t
:
airoKpivaaQai B : airoKpivaadai Kal Sre ^ TW d4 aotybv T :
o-oc/>br B d5 iruar4ov t: viareov BTW (sed ei supra 1 W)

roivvv B W : toj T d 10 r( T : oVt B
ET0TAHMO2 287e
ij ovk etfqp.apTov dkkd xal tovto 6p6<2s etirov, elircov otl
voel Ta. pr\p.aTa; TTOTepa <pj\s eap.apTavLV p.e r\ ov; et ydp

p.r\ er\p.apTov, ovbe crv eeAe'yets, Kaiirep <ro<pbs cov, oi38' 5
8' er\p.apTOV, ovtcos 6pd<os
e\et? ort XPV T <? Ao'ycp' et otj8'
Ae'yet?, <pdcrKcov ovk elvac eâp.apTavLV. Ka\ raiVa ov irpbs 288

a iripvcrLv ekeyes kiyco. dkka eoLKev, e<pr\v eyco, <h Aiovvcro-
boopi re Kal Ev6vbr\p.e, ovtos p.ev 6 koyos ev tovt<o p.iveLV
Kal ert uxnrep to irakaibv /cara/3aAcor ttlittlv, Kal coore

tovto p.r\ itacryjeiv ov8' virb rrjs vueTipas irco rixyqs e$r\vpr\- 5
crOai, Kal Tavra ovrcocrt 6avp,acrTrjs ovcrqs els aKpifieiav

koycov.
Kat 6 Kr7/o-i7T7ros, QavpLacrcd ye kiyer, <pr\, a> avbpes
QovpLoi etre Xtot et#' birodev Kal ottij xaCperov 6vop.aCpp.evoL' b
<os ovbev vpuv p.ikec tov Trapakrjpelv.
Kat eycb <po^r\6e\s p.r\ koLbopia yeVrjrat, ttclXlv KareTrpdv-
vov tov Kti\o-lttttov Ka\ elirov *X2 Krr/o-t7T7re, /cat vvvbr) a
irpbs KkeLviav ekeyov, kol Trpbs cre Tavra raOra Ae'yco, otl 5
ov yLyv(ccrKLS T(2v ivoov Tr)v crocpiav otl 6avp.ao~ia Icttlv.
dAA' ovk eOikerov r\pXv e7rieiacr0at crirovbd(fiVTe, dkka tov

UpcoTia pLLuelcrOov tov kiyviTTLov crocpLcrTrjv yorjTevovre r)p.as.
r/juets ovv tov Mevikaov p.ip.<ap.e6a, Ka\ p.r\ d(pL(op:eda toIv C

dvbpolv ecos dv r)p.lv eKCpavrjrov ec/>' co avToo cnrotjdciêrov
ot/xat ydp tl avrolv TrdyKakov cpavelcrdaL, eireLbdv dpa)VTac
crTTOvbdCeiv. dkkd be(op.eda Ka\ irapap.v6oop.e6a Ka\ TTpocrevx^-
p.e6a avTolv eKcpavrjvaL. eyoo ovv p.OL boK<2 /cat avrbs TrdkLV 5
vcprjyijcracrdaL otco Trpocrevxop-cii avrco cpavrjvaL p.oi' odev ydp

to TTporepov dirikLiTOV, to ei-rjs tovtols 7retpacro/xat, ottcos dv d
bvvcop.aL, bLekdelv, edv ims KKakicrcop.aL Ka\ ekerjcravTi
e 6 XPV * :
Xph BT a 4 tJ ira\cuhv~\ rb iraKcuov ci. Stephanus :
6 ira\aio)v ci. Green a 5 tovto /xi] B W

^fjj tovto T
: ww Hein-
dorf e Ficino : irov BT b 1 x a 'p er Cobet
'
b 2 ovScv vfuu B W :
bfuv ovSfv T C 2 ^KcpavrJTov T (K<pdvr)Tov B iKcpavrj tJ> Badham

:
W
:
C5 /cal] Kav Schanz C 6 v(piryti<reo-dat Heindorf olw T ol :
ais B abrui T avTW B : d I aireA7roi' t6 B airt\iirovTO T :
d 2 idv ira>y t : irav oirccs BT

PLATO, VOL. III. 11
288d IIAAT&NOS
pe ml olnTipavTt <rvvTeTap.evov koX <nrovhd(flVTa Kai avro)
cnrovhdo-qTov.
5 2i/ hi, S) KketvCa, e<pqv, avdp,vq<rov p.e irodev tot aire-

\C7rop.ev. a)s p.ev ovv ey&ptat, evOevhe iroOev. <pt\o<ro<pq-
reov <op.okoyqcrap.ev Tekevr&VTes' i) ydp; .Nat, i) 8' 6$.

C
H 8e' ye <ptko<ro<pCa kttjctls eTTt<rTr]p.qs' ox>x ovro)$; e<pqv.
Nat, e<pq. Ttya ttot ovv av KTq<rdp.evot eTTtcrT-qp.qv 6p8<2s
e Krq<raCp.e6a; ap ov tovto p.ev dirkovv, ort ravrqv rjrts fjptxxs
ovqcret; Udvv y , e<pq. Ao' ovv

T
dv rt rjpids ovqcretev, ei
(zTTi.crTaCp.eOa ytyvuxrKetv irepttovTes ottov rrjs yrjs yjpvcrCov
irkelcrTov KaTopcapvKTat; "Icrws, e<pq.

'AAA.a to irpoTepov,
5 i)v 8' eya>, tovto ye eqkeyap.ev, ort ovhev irkeov, ovh' ei
dvev Trpayp,aT<t)V Kal tov opvrretv tt)v yrjv to ttov i)pXv
XpvcrCov yevoiTO' coare ovh' el ras ireTpas \pvcras eirtcrTaC-
289 p.e6a Trotety, ovhevos dv ata r) eTTt<TTr]p.q elrj. el ydp p.-q kol
Xprjcrdai eTrt<TTq<r6p.eda rw \pv<rC<o, ovhev ocpekos avrov
ecpdvq 6v r) ov p.ep.vq<rat; e<pqv eya>. Yldvv y, e<pq,
p,ep.vr]p.ai. Ovhe ye, <1)$ eotKe, rfjs dkkqs eiri.o-Trip.qs 6<pekos

5 yCyverat ovhev, ovre \pqp,aTtcrTtKr)s ovre laTptKrjs ovre dk-
kqs ovhepuds, rjr ts Trotelv rt eWararai, yj>i)<r6aL he pJq co dv
TTOfqo-rf ovx. ovt<os; ^vvecpq. Ov8e ye el tls ecrrtv eirt-
b <TTr\p.q uxrre ddavdrovs irotetv, dvev tov eirCo-TacrOat rfj
ddavacrCa \pi)<r6at ovhe ravrqs eotKev 6<pekos ovhev, et tl
8et toIs TrpocrOev <op.okoyqp.evots TeKp.aCpe<rdat. SweSoVei

i)p.lv irdvTa Tavra. TotaurTjs rtvbs dpa i)p.tv eirt<TTr]p.qs het,
5 o) Kake ttol, r)v 8' ey<a, ev ?f

<rvp.TTeiTT<i)Kev dp.a to re 7roteu>
Kat to eirCcrTacrOat yj)i)crdat tovt<p 6 av irotfj. âtrerat,
d3 olKreipavre T : oiKreipoyre B e 1 '6ri rairi)v T W : om. B

62 &v rt rjfias B W : rjfias &v ri T e5 ovb" el T : ov 5e? B a1 Ka\
Xpri<rQai ci. Heindorf: Kexpv<rBai BT a2 avrov T: avrb B
a4 rrjs om. ci. Heindorf : rrjs &\\r]s secl. ci. Schanz a6 ^ B :
a T (sed suprascr. 6) a7
ovbe ye el corr. Coisl. : ovb" et ye eX B T
b2 (cus) eoiKev vel ovbev (elvai) ci. Heindorf b3 reK/xaipeaOat
TW : reKfiaipeffdat 8e? B b 6 eTrtcrraffOai B T irote^crQai ko\
:
Iamblichus : secl. ci. Schanz irotrj BT : rrotr)(rr) Iamblichus

ET0TAHMO2 2 8gb
ecprj. rToAAou dpa 8et, cbs eotKejj, r/pas hvpoiroiovs bzlv

tlvai Koi Toiavrrjs tlvos 7TLcrTr]p.r]s e7rr//3o'Ao?js. ivravda c
yap br) ^copts p.e;j r/ TTOLovcra Tiyvr), x^P^ ê V X/3a) M ein7
Strjprjrat ro?j avrorj 7re'pr r) ydp A?jpo7rottKr/ /cat r/ Ktc9apto-riKr/
ttoXv 8tacpe'peroij dAArjAotij. o?3x orjroos; StWcprj. OrjSe

arjAo7roti/c% ye StjAotj ort Seo/ueâ* Kat ydp kripa
/xtjjj
TOLavTt]. 2we$o'Ket.
'AAAa 7rpds 0eco7J, ecpr/rj
a7jr?j
eyco, et tt\v
5
KoyoTTOLLK7]V rexTJrjjJ p.ddoip.ev, dpd ecrrtTJ avTrj rjv edet fce/crr/-
p.ivovs r)p,as vbaCp.ovas etTJat; Ovk olp.ai, ecpr/, eyco, o

KAetJJtas rj7roAa/3co7\
Tlvl reK/xr/ptco, tjtj 8' eyco, X/7?> d
'Opco, ecpr/, rt7Jcxs Aoyo7roto?js, 01 rots tStots Adyots, ots
avTol ttolovctlv, ovk kiricrTavTaL xprjcrOaL, coo7rep ot A?jpo7roiot
rats Arjpats, dAAd Kal evravOa dAAot Swarot \pfjcrdaL ots
eKet/Jot r)pydcravTO, 01 Aoyo7roietJJ arjrot dbvvaroL' brjkov ovv 5

ort /cat 7rept Aoyorjy \copls r) tov iroLilv Tcyvt) K0^ V tov
\prjcr6aL.
'I/carjoy /xot boKeTs, ecpr/rj eyco, TKp.r)pLOV AeyetTJ, ori orj^
arjrr/ eoTt/j r/ tcotj Aoyo7rotco7J 7-e'x^r/, t/tj cxtj KTr\crdp.zv6s tls
e?JOaiucoJJ etrj. /catrot eyco coutjtj eijrarjc^d 7ro?j qbavrjcreadaL 10
ttJjj e7rtoTTj/xrj7J r)v 8r/ 7rdAat 0)TOvpev. Ka\ ydp pot ot re e

djjopes avrot 01 Aoyo7rotot, OTav crTjyyeVco/xat avTols, virip-
crocpoL, 00 KAetTJta, So/coucrtJj eiTJat, Kat avrr) r) Tiyvr) ovt&v

6(criTcrLa rts Kat ?j\//tjAtj. Kat ueVroi 07j8e7J 6avp.acrTov' ccttl
ydp rrjs t&v e7rco8co7J re'x^r/s p.6pLOV ptKpco re eKetTjr/s rj7ro- 5
8eecrre'pa. r/ /xeTJ ydp tcojj e7rco8co7j ix^cov re Kat cpaAayytcorj 290

Kat o~KopTTL(ov Kat rcorj dAAcorj c?rjptcojj re Kat vocrutv Kr/Ar/cris
kcrTLV, r) b\ StKacrrcoJJ re Kat eKKArjcrtacrrcoJj Kat rcoy dAAcoij
b
7 Serv Heindorf (Serv Sctvoiis Heusde) : 8z/o{/s BT e 1 ^7tt?-
/3oAous T
eWn/SouAous 4irtfi6\ovs B W C 3 Sjt/oijtcu T SirfpTjrai Se
WB
: : :
SitlpriTai . . . wfpi secl. Schanz d1 XPV T xM ^: ^4 ^^

. . . d 5 dSuvoTot secl. Schanz d 5 Ao-yoTroteu' anonymus apud
Routh : \vpoiroiuv B T e 2 outoI] o5to ci. Heindorf e 3 out?;
T : attTri B 65 Te] 8e anon. ap. Stallbaum
11*
:
2goa IIAAT&NOS
cxXoov Kr/Ar/crts re Kal irapafAvdia rvyyaveL ovcra' i) <roi,
5 e<pr]v eyco, dAAcos tt(ds boKel;

Ovk, dAA' ovTU) pot <paCveraL, e<pr\, cos <rv Ae'yets.
Ilot ovv, <-<pr}v eyco, rpa7rotp.e#' dv ert; e7rt itoiav ri^vrjv;

'Eyco /iez; otjk eviropG), ecpr/.
AAA , r/v 5 eyco, epe otpat rjvpt]Kvau

10 Ttra; e^>r/ 6 KAetznaj.
b 'H <TTpaTr\yiKr\ pot doxet, ecpr/j; eyco, reyyr] iravTos p:d\kov
elvaL rjv av tls KTr]<rdp.evos evbaLLioov etr/.
Otjk epotye Soxet.

ricos; r/i>
8' eyco.
5 r/perjriKr/ rt? r/8e yk ecrriv Teyyr] dvdpanraiv.
T/^\
t or/
*?
ovv;
V*
e<pr]v eyco.
'/
Orj8e/xia, ecpr/, r% 6r]pevTLKr)s avrr)s errl irkeov <tt\v r)
6<rov 6rjpevcraL Kal yeLp<racr6aL' e7ret8dv 8e )(eipcocrcoz>rai
rorjro o dv drjpevcovraL, ov bvvavraL Torjrco yjpr)crdaL, dAA' ot

io piev Kvvr/yeraL kox ol dAtr/s rots d\//07roiots 7rapa8t8dacrtz>, ot
C 8' arj yecojueVpat Kat ot dcrTpovoyuOL kol ol AoytcrrtKoi 6r]pev-
rtKOt ydp etcrt Kat ovrot* orj ydp 7rotorjcrt ra Staypdppara

eKacrroL tovtcov, dAAd rd cWa dvevpL<rKOV<rLV dre orjy yjpr)-
crdaL avrol avTols ovk e7rtcrrdperoi, dAAd drjpevcraL laovov,
5 7rapa8t8dacri br)iroV rots StaAeKriKOt? KaTa\pr)cr6aL arjrcoz> rots

evpr\LLa<TLV, 6<tol ye axrr&v pr/ 7ravra7racrtz) dvorrroi etVtr.
Etez>, r]v 8' eyco, co KaAAtcrre Kat crocpcorare KAetzna*

rovro orjrcos exet;
ndz>u p.ei) orji\ Kat ot ye crrparr/yot, ec/>r/, orjrco rdz; arjrdz>
d TpoTTOv e7ret8dy r/ 7rdAtz> rtz>d ^r/perjVcoz/rai r/ crrpard7re8or,

7rapa8t8dacri rots 7roAtrtKOts dvbpd<rLV arjrot yap ovk eVt-
oravraL yjpr)<rdaL tovtols a e6r\pev<rav- &o-nep otjuat ot
oprvyodrjpaL rots 6pTvyoTp6<poLS 7rapa8t8dacrty. et orjy, r/

8'
5 os, beop.eda eKeCvr/s rrjs Te\vr]S, r/rts a> hv KTr)<rr]TaL r) itol-
a7 tj ci. Stephanus '6ri B T : b 7 awrijs] Suva/tts ci. Heindorf

alii alia C 2 Ta StaypdfjL/Mara secl. Cobet C 3 (Kacrrot T
W
:
g/cao-Ta B c 4 auToi T om. B Wd 5 5} B

: ^rts av T W :
ET0TAHMO2 2god
7/cracra 77 6r)pcvcrap.ivr) avTr) Kat e7rtoT?/crerai -^prjcrBaL, koX r)
ToiavTt) 7rot?/o-et 7/p.as paKapiovs, aX\i)v bfj Tiva, <<pr),
<j]ti]tc.ov avTt rfjs crrpaTriyLKfjs.

KP. Tt Ae'yets' crv, a> Sw/cpares; eKetuo rd /aeipaKtov e
rotaCr' ec/>#e'ycfaro;
2,12. Ovk otet, o) Kptrcoy;
KP. Md At" ov yAvroi. ot/nai ydp avrbv eyco, et ra?3r'
et7rei', ovr' E7!>0?j8?7pou oi/re dAAou oTJSeros er' avOptaTtov 5
Setcrflai ets 7rat8eiai/.
212. 'AAA' apa, co 7rpos Atds-, 7*77 6 Kr?/at7r7ros t/v 6 raCr'
eiTrcoV, eyco 8e ou pip.vr)p.aL;
KP. riotos Kr?/ori7T7ros; 291

12. 'AAAd p.f)v rd8e ye eu otoa, drt ovre E?3ûo?//xos oure
Aioz>?jcro'8copos' f)v 6 (Ittcov Tavra' dAA', a> baipovLe Kpircoi>,
p?/ rts raw KptLTTovoov Trapcov avra ec/30e'yaro; drt ydp
?/K0ucra ye raura, ev otoa. 5
KP. Nat p.a Ata, a> 2a>Kpares #

rcoi> KpetrroVcoy /ueVrot
ris e/xot 8oKet, Kat 7roA?J ye. dAAd p.erd tovto ert rtra
e^?/r?/crare Txyr)v; KaX T/tfpere eKtivrjv 77 ov\ T/vpere, fjs
eveKa e^T/retre;
212. I7o'#ej>, co /jtaKapte, -qvpopnv; dAA' 7/pev 7rdrt; yeAotot* b
uxrirep rd 7rat8ta rd rovs Kop7j8o?js 8ia)K07Jra, det cod/xefla
eKacrrr/y rcoy ki:LCTTr)p.G>v avruca A?p//ecr0ai, at 8' det ?j7refe-
(pevyov. Ta p.\v ovv TroAAa rt dz> crot Ae'yot/xt; e*7rt 8e 8?/
77)1; (3acn\LKr)v eAfloVres T\vr)v koX bLaaKoirovp.VOL avrrjv 5
et avr?/ et?/ ?/ r^y evbaLp.ovLav irapiyovcra re Kat a7repyab-

/xe'y?/, evra{5c9a cocnrep ets- XaftvptvOov e/x7recroVre?, olop.voi
rjbr) eVt re'Aet etyai, irepLKapLxj/avTes ttoXlv totnrep eV dpxf) r?/s
f?/r?/creco? avecpavr)p.zv ovtzs Ka\ tov Xcrov beop.evoL ocrovirep C
dre ro 7rpcoroi* e^r/rovpey.
d6 oi-t)/ T aSrrj B
: d7 J^ T 8 B a 2 T({8e 7
W
:
Bernhardy: royeBT: r68e a6 twT: om. B ba Sxxirep

(ya.p) Cobet b3 virei-ecpfvyov W :vwe^t<pvyoi' B T b4 rcb . . .
7roA.\a B : Tas . . . iroWas T b6 Trapexovcrd re Ka\ T W : om. B

2gi c IIAATX2N02
KP. ITws hf) tovto vp.LV o-vvtftrj, u> 2<wKpares;
2X2. Eyco (ppao-a>. ehoe yap hf) f)p.lv f) TTokLTLKr) nal
5 f) f3ao-i\iKr) Ttyvr) f) avrf) elvaL.
KP. Ti ovv hfj;
2X2. TavTrj Trj Tex v V V T * orparrryiKT) Kal al aXXai

Trapahihovai apyj-iv tu>v epyu>v u>v avTal hrjpuovpyoC dcrtv,
u>s p.6vr) TTLo-Tap,vr] \pr)cr6ai. <racpu>s ovv ehoKL f)p.lv avTi)
io ilvai fjv (r)T0V)Xv, Kal f) alrta tov 6p6u>s irpdTTeLV ev Tr}
d irokei, Kal a.TxvS>$ KaTa. ro Al(rxv\ov lapfielov povrj ev

Trj Trpvp.vrj KadfjadaL rfjs tt6\u>s, itavra KVf3epvu>cra Kal
iravTu>v apxpvo-a irdvTa yjpr\o~ip.a ttollv.
KP. Ovkovv Ka/\u>$ vfuv thoKti, u> ~2(aKpaTs;
5 2X2. 2l/ KpLVLS, U> KptrCOV, CLV fSovXfJ O.KOVIV KOL TCL fieTCL
ravra o~vp.f3dvTa ffftxv. ov6l$ yap hr) irdkLV ecrKOirovfxev

u>he ttcos' 4>e'pe, TrdvTutv apxovcra r) /3acriAtKT) Tyvt) tl fffxiv
e a.TTpya(TaL epyov r) ovhev; TldvTu>$ hrjirov, fjfxels ecpafxev

Trpos dkkrfkovs. Ou Kal av av ravra cpatrfs, u> Kptrcov;
KP. "Eycoye.
2X2. Ti ovv av cf>atr)s avrfjs epyov elvaL; uxrirep et o-e
5 eyu> epu>T(or)v, TrdvTcov apxovcra f) laTpLKr) 8>v dpxeL, fi epyov

7Tapex* Tai '> ov "ryv vyteiav {av) <patr)$;
KP. "Eyu>ye.
2X2. Tt he r) vfxeTepa Tex vrl V y^pyta; irdvTu>v dpxovcra
292 S>v apxeL, t'l [epyov] a7repyderai; ov Tr)v Tpo<pf)v av <patr)$
rf)v eK rfjs yfjs irapex^v fffxlv;
KP. "Eycoye.
2X2. Tt he r) /3acrtAtK?) irdvTcov dpxovcra u>v dpxeL; t'l
5 a7re/>yderai; tcru>s ov Trdvv y eviropels.

KP. Ma tov Ata, u> 2w/cpares.
d4 vfuu T : 7}fiiv B d5 aicoveiv BT : aKovoov b Kal ra /xera

ravra ffvfj.fia.vra T ixera yap ra eii,wpoo~0ev ffVfj.f3ct.VTa B W d6 rjfjuv
W W
:
re vera B T aldis T (sed suprascr. t ai ris B W)

yap
ravra B W
:
Si] ird\iv T : /j.tTa e 2 o5 T ov B e 4 eiff cre

:
cy&> B : e* iy<i cre T e 6 l\v add. Ast a 1 epyov B om. T W :

EY0TAHMO2 2g2a
212. Ovbe yap r//xets, co Kpircav dAAd Tocrovbe ye oTada,

otl et7rep ecrrtv ai/rr/ f\v r/juets (fr/roSuey, cocpi\Lp.ov avrrjv 8et
eizât.
KP. Udvv ye. 10
212. Ovkovv ayaOov yi tl 8et r/uty avrqv Tiapabibovai;

KP. 'Avay/cr/, co 2coKpares.
212. 'Ayaflov 8e' ye 7rou cop.o\oyrio-ap.ev dAAr/Aots eyco re b
Kal KAetiaas orjdey e>ai dAAo r) tiricrTrip.r}v TLvd.
KP. Nat, orjrcos eAeyes.

212. Ovkovv tcl uez> dAAa epya, a cpatr/ dv us 7roAtrtKr/s
etyat 7roAAa 8e 7rou ra{5r' dy etr/, otoi> 7rAoucrtous rous 5

7roAtras itapiyjELV kol eAerjcVpous fcat dcrracridcrrojjs iravra
Tavra ot/re KaKa ovre ayaOa ecpdyr/, e8et 8e crocpovs rroLtLV
koX e7rtcrrT/ur/s uera8t8oVat, enrep eueAAe^ avrr/ etWt r/
axpeAoScrd re Kat vbaip.ovas iroLovcra. C

v
KP. Ecrri raura' rdre yow oi/rcos vuu> couoAoyr/t9r/, cos
cru rovs Adyous d7rr/yyetAas.

"> >
212. Ap ovv r) /3acrtAtKr) crocpovs 7rotet rovs avOpcoTrovs
Kat dyatfods; 5
KP. Tt ydp KcoAvet, co 2coKpares;

212. 'AAA' dpa 7rdi>ras Kai 7rdi>ra dyaflotjs; Kat 7racrai;
e7rtcrrr///r/y, cr KVTOTop.LKt]v re Kat reKroftKr/i; Kat rds dAAas

a7rdcras, avrr/ r/ 7rapa8t8oCcrd Zcttlv;
KP. Ovk otuat eycoye, a> 2coKpares. IO
212. 'AAAa rtVa 8rj e7rtcrrr//xr/i;; r/ r yjrr)cr6p.z6a; tcov d

uer ydp epycov ovbevbs 8et avTi]v brjpLOvpybv etrat rcoi; ur/re
KaKcov p.i]T dyadcov, e7rtcrrr//xr/y 8e 7rapa8t8di;ai ur/8eutay

dAAr/v r/ avTrjv kavrrjv. Aeycouei; 8r/ ow rts 7rore ecrrty
avrr/, r/ rt ypr]cr6p.(0a; /3o7jAet cpcop.V, co Kpircov, r/ dAAous 5
dyat9ovs 7rotr/crouez;;
KP. ndyv ye.
a 1 1 76 Tt] i/ yf ri Cobet C 7 itavra B W : iravrws T d 1 ^

B : ^ T d5 prius $ in marg. B 2
: ^ B : fj T

ag2d IIAATI2N02
212. Ot rC efowrat rjpXv dya6o\ KaX tl \pr)o~Lp.oL; r) ert
Ae'ycouev otl aWovs TTOLr)o~ovcrLV, ol 8e aAAot Ikzlvol akkovs;
e otl bi ttotc ayadoC cIctlv, ovbap.ov r)pXv (paCvovTaL, TTLbr)TTp
tcl epya Ta kyop.va tXvaL rrjs irokLTLKrjs r)TLp.do~ap.V, dkk'
a.Txya>s to Aeydueiw 6 Alos KopLvdos yiyveraL, col 07rep
eAeyor, tov lctov r)p.Zv evbel r\ ert 7rAeovos Trpbs to etSeVat rCs
5
7rore ko~TLV r) TTLo~Tr)p.r} KCvr\ r) r)p.ds vbaCp.ovas 7TOLf)o~L;
KP. Nt) tov Ata, co 2coKoares, ets 7ro\Aî; ye diropCav,

i)S toLKV, a<pLKO-0.
22. "Eycoye ovv koll ovtos, w Kotrcoy, TTLbr) V TavTri
293 rfj aTTopia eVe7re7rrco Kr/, Trao-av ijbr* (p(ovr)v r)(pULV, bop.VOs
tolv zvolv c2o"7reo Atocncoupcoy e7rtKaAo?juei>os o-coaai r)p.as,
eue re Kat rb ueipaKtoy, k rrjs rptKvuias tov koyov, kol

TravTL TpoTTco o~TTOvbdo~aL, Kal o-TTOvbdcravTas e7ri8etfai rts
5 7ror' 0~tlv r) TTLo~Tr)p.r\ r)s Tvy6vTS av Kak<2s tov ttlKolttov

j3CoV bLk0OLp.V.
KP. Tt ovv; r)0kr\o~V tl vp.lv e7rt8etcjai 6 Ev$vbr\p.os;
212. ITcoy yap ov; Kal rjpâTO ye, a> eratpe, 7rdi>v p.yako-
(ppovoos tov koyov cSde
b YioTpov br) o~, ecprj, <o 2coKpares, TavTrpj tt\v TTLcrTr)p.r\v,
TTcpl r)v irdkaL a7ropeire, 8tSdco, r\ e7rt8etcfco ZyovTa;

'12 uaKapte, 777;
8' eyco, ecrrt Se e7rt crot tovto;
Udvv p.v ovv, (pr\.
5 'E7rt8eioi> toCvvv ue 7vr) At", (prjv eyco, \ovTa %

irokv yap
paov r\ p.av6dvLV TrjkLKOvbc avbpa.
uot diroKpLvaL, <ttlv otl e7rtVracrat; Yldvv
<J>e'pe 8r/
ye, 17V 8' eyco, Kat 7roAAa, o~p.LKpd ye.

<pr\-
'ApKet, ec/)r7. ap' oi5y
'AAAarwr
8oKets oto'i' re rt ovtcov tovto o rvyxdyet oy, avro tovto
C ui) Lvai; p.a At' ovk eycoye. Ovkotjv o-tj, ecpri,
TTLcrTao~aL tl; "Eyooyc. Ovkovv TTLo~Tf)p(tiv et, et?rep e7rt-
crracrai; Yldvv ye, tovtov ye avrov.^ Or!>8h> 8tacpe'pef dAA'
62 y)Tifi.a.<ra.f]Lev BTW: airedoKi/j.dtfaibiet' t 05 iroirjaci ci.

Heindorf : wotrifftie BT a2 SioffKovpotv Vat. 1029 : AiocrKopaiv
Hirschig b5 yue T : om. B c 1 e^ Stephanus : f<pris BT W
;
ET0TAHMO2 293C
ovk avdyKri cre exet ^dvra e7r tcrracrflat kTTicrTrjpovd ye ovra;
Md At , (-(prjv eyco- e7ret 7roAAd dAA' ovk e7Ticrrauat.
5
Ovkovv et rt pr) e7ricrracrat, ovk e7Ticrrr/ucoi> et. 'EKetrou ye,
cb </>t'Ae, r)y 0' eyco. ^Httov ovv tl, e</>r/, ovk e7ricrrr/ucoi'
et; aprt 8e e7rtcrrrjucoi' ec/>r/crt?a etât* Kat orjrcos rrjyxdz/ets u>v

avros ovtos 09 et, Kat av tt&Xlv ovk et, Kara TavTa apa. d.
Ete^, r\v 8' eyco, EuflrjSfjue' rb yap Xeyofxevov, KaAa

Sr/ 7rarayets* 7rcos ovv e7rtcrrauat eKeCvqv tt)v e7rtcrrr/urj;j
r/y Zr]Tovfxev; cos 8rj rotro dSrjVardy ecrrtr ro avrb tlvaC re

Kat Mr/, et7rep Itj e7rtcrra/uat, cnravTa eirCo-Tap.ai ov yap 5
av eXrjv e7ricrrrjuco/j re Kat d;je7ricrrrjuco;j dpa e7ret 8e 7rd;jra
e7rtcrra/xai, KaKeCvqv 8r/ rrjv e7r tcrrrjurjr ex ar V> a o^^s Aeyets,
Kat rorjrd ecrrty ro aocpov;
Avtos cavTov ye 8rj e<feAe'yxets, ec/jr/, a> ScoKpare?. e
Tt 8e', r/y 8' eyco, a> Er3c?rj8r/ue, crrj orj TtiirovOas tovto to
avTo irdQos; eyco ydp rot pera crov otiovv av Trdo-^cov Kal
uera At07Jucro8copou rouSe, </>tArj? Ke</>aArjs, ouk du 7rdi/u
dyavaKToCrjv. et7re' uot, crcpto ouxt rd uei> ir/io-TacrQov tQ>v 5
ovt(ov, tcl 8e ouk iirCo-Tao-Qov

"HKtord ye, ecprj, cb ScoKparey, 6 AtouucrdScopos.
ncos Aeyerou; e</>rju eyco* dAA' ouSerJ dpa lirCo-TacrQov;
Kat udAa, r/ 8' 0?.
ndur' dpa, ecprju eyco, lirCo-rao-Qov, e7ret8rj7rep Kat 6rtow; 294

ndur', e</>rj Kat <ru ye 7rpo's, et7rep Kat h> iTrCo-Tacrat, irdvTa
e7rtcrracrai.
'12 ZeC, ec/jr/y eyco, cos Oavpao-Tov Aeyet? Kat dyatôy ueya
TT(pdv$ai. pa>v Kal ol dAAot 7rd/Jre? dvQpuiTTOi irdvT IttC- 5
crrayrat, r/ ovhiv;
Ov yap 8r/7rou, ec/>r/, ra uey kirCo-TavTai, to. 8' or!/K e7rt-
orarrat, Kat etcrii; dua e7rtcrrr/uoye's re Kat dyeTrtcrrr/uorey.
C5 ^l T îrl B
: d i iraAjj/ (Ss) Badham da iyd, (3)
Heindorf d3 TrarayeTy Photius iraVra \eyeis BT TrarT' &yeis
: W :
schol. T d4 iffTiv\ hv Badham secl. Schanz d6 îrel B ' T

: :
6 5 <Tl) eiVe Badham a t<prtv B <pr) T (sed suprascr. v)

i :
a 7 (/)r> Aldina : e<p7iv BT

294 a nAATftNOS
'AAAa rt; r\v 8' eyco.
10 ndrre?, r\ 8' os, irdvTa eiricrTavTat, etirep Kal ev.

b '^2 7rpos rSy 0ecoi>, ^y 8' eyco, w Atovvcroboope 8r/Aot ydp
p.oi e<TTOV ?/8l7 OTt CTTTOvbdeTOV, Kol p6ktS VptCtS TTpOVKake-
o-afATjv cnrovbdCetv avToy rco 6Vri 7rdyra eiricrTacrdov; olov
TeKTOVtKTJV Kal CTKVTtK1]V;
5 Hdvv y , e(pi].
H Kat vevpoppaqbelv bvvaroi ecnov;

Kal val pta Aia KaTrvetv, Zcpr].
H Kal Ta Totavra, tovs dcrTepas oTrocrot eicri, Kai rr)v

dp.p.ov;
io nai>u ye, r) 8' 6V etr' ovk civ oiet 6ptokoyr)o-at r)pus;

Kat 6 KTr]o-tTTTTOs virokafiaiv' Ilpbs Atos, e<fir], Atovv-
C o-oba>pe, TCKpi.rjpt6v rt ptot tovtoov eirtbeiâTOV Totovbe, &>
etcro/xat 6'rt dkrjdr) keyerov.

Tt TTtbei(o; fcprj.
Olcrda EvOvbrjpiov oirocrovs obovTas %xzt, koI 6 Evdvbr]pos

5 ottoo-qvs o~v;
Ovk eâpKei crot, eqbi], aKovcrat ort TrdvTa eirtcrTdpeda;

Mrjbap.(2s, r) 8' os, dkka tovto ert r)pXv ptovov etiraTov Kal
eirtbeiâTov ort akrfdr) Aeyerozr #xat ectv eiirrvrov ottoo-ovs

exarepos e\et vp.G>v, Kal cpaivqo-de yvovres r)p.G>v dpt6p.r\-
io crdvToov, rjbt] Treto-6p.eda vp.lv Kal raAAa.

d 'iiyovp.evoo ovv crKOJTTTecrdat ovk r)6ekeTT]v, dAA' cb/xo-
Aoyr/crdrT/i/ irdvTa yjpr)p.aTa eiricrTacrdat, /cac9' ev eKao-rov

epooToop.evot vtto KT-qcriTnrov. 6 yap KTr)crt7TTT0S Trdvv airapa-
KakvTTT(os oibev ort ovk r)pa>Ta rekevroov, /cat to, atcr^tcrra, et
5 eTTtcrTaicrdrjv too 8e dvbpetOTara 6/xdcre ^r?jy rots epooTr)pacrtv,
opokoyovvTes elbevat, oocriTep ot Kairpot ol irpbs Ti]v -nkriyrjv
6p.6cre oo6ovp,evot, (xxtt eyooye Kal avros, a Kpiroiv, vtt
b3 (TTrouSii^jvobelo notavit Schanz e 2 Aeyerov T : W

AeêtcrTO^ B
(sed eur puncto notatum) Xtytis Schanz 04 <xh :
ante Ei/dvSrifjiov add. Dobree CQ <pait>r>o-0e T: (paivr)<rdo,i B

d 5 17T7JJ/ t e^rrj^ B T Xrr\v ex etrrjv fecit
: : d 7 <}/xoVe secl. W
Schanz vir a.iriaria.s T W
viram aa B xiif airopias b: :
)
ET0TAHMO2 294d
aTTia-Tias r)vayKd<r6r)v reAevrcoV epicrOai [tov Ev6vbr\p.ov\ et
Kal 6pxio~6ai cirioraiTo 6 ALovvcroboopos' 6 8e', Yldvv, <pr). G

Ov brj-rov, rjv 8' eyco, ko.1 is pxtyaipas ye kvj3lcttolv Kal
TtI TpOÔV biV(A.O~6at Tt]KlKOVTOS COV, OVTCO TTOppCO crocpias
rJKeis;
Oibev, cpr), otl ov. 5

Ylorepov bi, rjv 8' eyco, rrdvTa vvv p.6vov itio~Tao~6ov r)
Kal det;
Kal aei, .cf>r).
Kai 6Ye 7rat8ta i)o~Tr)v *ai v6vs yv6p.V0L r)7rio~Tao~6
navTa; io
'Ec/>drrii> ap.a ap.cpoTpco.

Kat r)p.lv p.v o.-tlo~tov e8d/cet t6 Trpdyp.a etfar 6 8' 2g5
Evdvbrjp.os, 'Attlo~Tls, ec/)T7, a> 2coKpares;
Ylkrjv y otl, {rjv 8') eyco, et/cos vpxis ecrrt aocpovs etvat.
'AAA' rjv, cpr), 6ekfio~r\s p.0L aTTOKpivo~6aL, cyco e7Ti8etcfco
kol o~ Tavra tcl 6avp.ao~Ta 6p.okoyovvTa. 5
'AAAd pvqv, r\v 8' eyco, T/8tcrra Tavra eeAe'yxo/xat. et ydp

tol Ae'A7?0a p.avTov aocpbs cov, o~h 8e tovto e7rt8eiets ws
7rdzrra e7rto-rauat *ai det, rt /xeibz> ep/xatoz/ atVou ai> vpoLp.i
iv navrl rco (3lco;
'At;okplvov brj, <pr~. *
'X2s a.TTOKpLvovp.Vov eocora. b

9
Ap' ow, ec/>T/, 2co/coares, iTLCTTr)p.cov tov et 17 ot>;
Eycoye. Florepoi' ovv co TTLo~Tr]p.cov et, rodrcp xai e7rtcrracrai,

t/ aAAcp rco;' ?X2t 7TLO~Tr)p.cov. otjwat ydp cre rTJv y\rvyr\v
Aeyety 77 otj rovro Ae'yets; 5
d.8 toj> Ev0v5r)/j.ov secl. Hermann ei IldVt/ (7') Ast e3 8c

v(i<rOai T : 5ii/i<70ai B (ot/irco) oStco Schanz eu (riaPTa,
(<parr\v Schanz a 3 r)v 8' add. Cornarius yco secl. Winckel- :
mann post (y<a lacunam indicat Schanz (intercidisse putans cWicttco)

:
a 4 aAA* f)v (<pr\ 40(\r)<rais fioi B yp. t aAAci /xr/v 4av (fJ.ol (0(\r)S T:
a 5 (S/uoAoôiWa T W
om. B (xovra Schanz : a 7 <rv 8e corr.
:
Coisl. ovb~( B T
: W
b a tou T toC B r<p spec. emend. W : :
Vindob. (1858) 8
295b nAATilNOS
Ovk alayyvr}, (pr\, 2) Sw/cpares; ipo)Tcop.VOS drrepcoras;
Eter, r)v 8' eyco* dAAd ttcos 7Toico; ovto) yap TTOLr\cro)
ottcos av o~v KeAev???. orav p.r\ etdco drt epcoras', KeAedets
ue opos airoKpCvccrOai, dkkd u?) tiravepio-Oat;
C ^Tirokap.fiidvtLs ydp 8?/7rou rt, ecp?/, 6 Ae'yco;

v
Eycoye, ?p> 8' eyco.
ripds rouro roivvv diroKpivov 6 VTrokap.(SdvLs.

Tt ow, f(pr)v, av o~v pev dkkr\ epcoras Staroouueyos, eyco
5 8e dAA?/ virokdfio), eTTetra ?rpds rouro aTTOKptVcouat, eapKet
crot edi> p,r\bev irpbs eiros aixoKpLvu>p.ai;
"Euotye, r] 8' os #
od ueVrot croi ye, cbs eycouat.
Ov roivvv p.a Ata airoKpivovp.ai, r)v 8' eyco, irpoTepov

Trplv av 7rv6(i)p,ai.
io Otjk aTTOKpbvfj, e(pr\, 7rpds d dz> det vTrokap.j3dvr\s, otl e^coy

pkvapels Kat apyaioTtpos et rot> 8e'oi>ros.
d Kdycb eyvo)v avrbv drt uoi yakeTraivoL hLacrTekkovTL rd

key6p.eva, j3ovkop,ev6s ue 6r\pevcraL rd 6v6\mTa irepLO~Tr)cras.
dvep.vf)o~6r\v ovv tov Kovvov, otl uot KaKeu>os x.aAe7rairet
eKacrrore dray avrco u?) vireiKO), eTretrd pou t\ttov eTTtueAeirat
5 cbs dp.adovs ovtos' emel 8e ow hLvevor)p,r\v Kal Trapd tovtov

(poLTav, <j>f)6r\v belv VTreiKeLV, p.r) ue crKaLov r)yr\o~dp.evos
(poLTr\Tr\v p.r\ TTpocrhiypLTO. eXirov ovv 'AAA' et 8oKet crot,
e Edt^TJSrjpe, ovrco 7rote\ TTotrjreov av ydp Trdyrcos ttou
KakkLov e7Ttcrracrat 8taAe'yecrc9at 7/ eyco, Teyyr\v e\o)v tStcorou
dv6po)TTOv. epcora ovi> rrdkLV e<f dpxrjs.

'AnoKpivov bf), TTaAty, TTOTepov eiricrTacrai rcp d
5 eTTtVracrat, ?) ou;
"Eycoye,e(f>r\,
ec/>??i>, r?j ye ^rvxV'

296 OSros av, ec/j??, TrpocraTroKpiveTaL rots epcorcoueVots. od
ydp eyo)ye epcorco orco, dAA' et eTTtcrracrat rco.
ITAeoi' av, e<p?jv eyco, roS 8eWros dTrtKpLvdpvqv vtto diraL-
b9 fywos B W : S7ra)s T yuj; scr. recc. yuV BT W c 10 utto-

W
:
XafiPdvris Stephanus : inro\afii3<ivets BT d5 eVel 8e B :
. tVeiSr; T Stevej/o^/irjc B W : Siei/oov/j,7)u T tovtov W

tovtoiv
:
BT e 1 7rojetV secl. Schanz irou] ejuoi) Cobet (secl. mox t; e,,yw)

ET0TAHMO2 296 a
btvo-Cas. dAAd crvyyiyvcocrKe' p.0L' aTroKptvov\xai yap ?/8?/
drrXQs otl eTTtcrrapai rco a eTTtcrrauai. IT orepov, r/ 8' 6s, 5
tG> avTco rovrcp y det, ecrrt uer 6t tovtco, ecrrtp 8e 6t
erepco;
'Aet, oray
17
eTrtcrrcouai, t/z> 8' eyco, rovro).
0?3k av, ecpr/, iravarf Trapac/bfleyydperos ;
'AAA' o7ra>? p.r\ rt ?/uds crcpT/A?/ to " det " tovto.

Ovkovv y, dAA' dAA' drroKpivov b
7;
rjp.as
det rovra) e?ricrracrat;

ecp?/,
'Aet,
etTrep,
771;
cre.
8' eyco, e7ret8?/ 8et atptXtiv

to " orav." Ovkovv det uei> rodrtp e?Ticrracraf det 8' eTTtcrrd-
ueros' iroTepov tcl uez> rovrco eTTtcrracrai cp eTTicrracrai, rd 8'
dAAcp, 77 rojjro) irdvTa; Tovrco, ecp?7Z> eyoo, arravTa, a y 5
e7ricrrauai.
Tour' exetro, ecp77

#
7/Kei rd avro Ttapd<p6eyp.a.
a \ \ 'j <j / << ^ / n
AAA '
acpatpco, ecprjz/

eyco, ro
\ </
a y e?Ticrrapai.
'AAAd prjSe eV, ecpr;, acpiXrjS' ovbtv ydp <rov 8e'opat.

dAAa uot diroKpLvaL' bvvato av airavTa eTTtcrracrâi, et p?/ C
Trdz/ra eTTtcrrato;
Tepa? ydp dz> etr/, r/y 8' eyco.
Kat os etTTe* npocrrtflei roivvv 7/877 ort /3o.vAef d?raz>ra
ydp dpoAoyets e7Ttcrracrcât. 5

v
Eot/ca, ecp?77.' eyco, e7ret8r7?Tep ye ovbep,iav exei hvvap.Lv to
a eTTtcrrapat," TTarra 8e eTTtcrrapai.
OvkoCz; Kat det couoAdy?7Kas eTTicrracrflai roiyrco cp eTTtcrra-
crat, etre oraz> eTTicrrr/ etre ottcos /3o.vAef det ydp a>poAo'y?7Kas
eTTtcrracrât Kat dua TTarra. 8r/Aoz> oi/y ort Kat 7rats coy 10
r/TTicrrto, Kat or' lyiyvov, Kat dr' k<pvov Kat 7rptz> avrds- d
yzvivQaL, Kal irplv ovpavbv koX yr\v yeviadaL, r/TTtcrrco
airavTa, etTTep det eTTtcrracrat. Kat yat pd Ata, ecpr/, avrds

det eTTtcrrr/crr/ Kat airavTa, av eyco /3oivAcopai.
'AAAa (3ov\r]dir]s, r)v 8' eyco, co TToAurtprjre Ev^vSr/pe^ 5
et 8r/ rtp dVri dkrjdrj Ae'yet?. dAA' oil croi TTaru 7Ttcrrei;co
a5 & W t : oZ2 BT a 9 o-^Xp B T W <r0a\6? Heindorf

TW
:
b 3 2 5' ... b 4 rovrcf) iirio-racrai om. B

: b4 ra 5' T :
a 5' B (I3 avtbs ahi BT : tvObs dl aS Heindorf : aS ael Schanz

296 d nAATI2N02
iKavQ tlvai, et p.r\ crot crv[xj3ovkr]0Cri 6 abekcpos crov ovrocrl
ALOvvcroboopos' ovtoo 8e T&ya dv. enrerov 8e /xot, rjv 8' eyco
e ra p.ev yap aXXa ovk \co vpuv ttG>s dpi.cpLcr[3r)ToCr)v, ovtco?
ets crocpCav reparcoSecrty dvdpcorroLS, ottoos eyco ov irdvTa

kiricTTap.ai, kitzibri ye vp.els cpare tcl 8e rotd8e ttcos cpco
kmcrTacr6ai, Kvdvbr)p., cos ol ayadol avbpes abtKOL tlcnv;

5 cpepe ei7re', tovto trCcrTap.aL r) ovk e7rtcrrap.ai;
'E7rtcrracrat peVrot, (cprj.
f $l 1 /
T/t; r]v o eyco.
fr\
Urt ovk aotKOt
'V^s / 9 /1/
etcr> ot ayaooL.
297 I7dz>u ye, ?/y 6' eyco, 7rdAat. dAA' ov rouro epcorco* dAA'
cos ddtKOt eto-ty 01 dyadoC, ttov eyob rouro ep.adov;
Ovbap.ov, Hcprj 6 ALOVvcrobcopos.
Ovk apa e7rtVraju,at, ecprjv, tovto eyco.
5 Atacpfleipeis, Ic/)tj, rdi> Ao'yoy, 6 Evdvbr)p.os 7rpds tov

ALOvvcrobcopov, Kal cpavrjcreTaL ovrocrX ovk e7rtcrrdp.ei>os, Kat
TTLcrTrip.cov dp.a obv Kal dveTTLcrTr)p.(ov. Kat 6 Aioûod8copos
r)pv6pCacrv.
'AAAd crv, r)v 8' eyco, 7rcos Aeyets, co F,vdvbr)p.; ov 8okc-i
b crot dp0cos dSeAcpds Aeyeiv 6 tt&vt elbcos;
'ASeAcpds yap, ecpt), eyco etjiu E,v6vbr)p.ov, Taxy imokaficov

6 ALovvcrobcopos;
y
Kdyco etTroy Eacroy, <bya6e, ecos av Ev6v'br)p,6s p.e 8t8d?7
5 cos e7rtcrra/>tat rovs dya#oi>s dz>8pas drt d8iKOt etcrt, Kat p.r\
lxol cpdovricrr}s tov p.adr)p.aTOS.
evyeis, ecpr), 2> 2coKpares, 6 ALOVvcrobcopos, Kal ovk

edekeis aTTOKpCvecrdaL.
EtKorcos y', et7roy eyco* rJTT<ov ydp et/xt Kat tov eripov
10 vp.<ov, cocrre 7roAAou 8e'co /x^ ov 8vo ye cpevytLV. ttoXv ydp
C 7rod ei/xt cpavXorepos tov 'HpaKAeous, ds oii^ otds re ^y rfj
d7 <TvfifSov\r)6tiri T W : fiovXi]Otl-q B d 8 ofJrw Sf T ovtw B :
e I (&>') a.fJL<piafiy)Toi-riv Heindorf 62 e-yi ou TtavTa 011 iravTaW :
<?7 T : oi> Tr({^ra B e3 76 T : om. B b 1 aSeAcpbs Bekker :
aSeA^bs BT : 6 a.5f\(pbs corr. Coisl.

ET0TAHMO2 297 c
re vbpq 8tap.dxetr0at, crcxpHTTpCq ovcrr) xal 8td Tr)v crocpiav
diueto-?/, et p.[av K(pakr)V tov koyov tls d7rore'pot, 7roAAds

avrX Trjs /xta?, Kal KapKLVio tlvI ere'p tov abtk(pLbovv (3or)66v e7reKaAeVaro, 6 8e avr<o
LKav&s efiorjdrjo-ev. 6 8' ep.os 'Io'Aea)s [YlaTpoKkrjs] et eA0ot, d
irkiov av d&Tepov iroLrjcreLtv.
'
' AiroKpLvaL brj, e<p?/ 6 Aioiwo-dScopos, 67ro're aot raOra

vpLVrjTaL' TTOTepov 6 'IoAecos rou 'HpaKAe'oi;? /xaAAoy ?|y
d8eA<ptSo?3? r) o~6s; 5
Kparto-roi; tolvvv /xot, w AtorucrdScope, t/v 8' eyco, cltto-
KpCvaaOaL ctol. ov yap p?/ avrjs ipo)T(2v, axeSoV rt eyco
tovt cpOov&v JW pe
eu oT8a,
Ev6vbr)p.os eKtlvo to o-ocpov.
/cat 8taKcoAvcoi>,
'AiroKpCvov bi),
/u?j
e<p??.

8t8d<f?/
'A7TO-
c
KpCvopLai bt), elirov, otl tov HpaKAe'o?;s rjv 6 'IdAecos d8eA- 10
cpLbovs, ep.6s 8', cos epot 8oKet, ot8' 67rcoo-riow. ov yap e

YlaTpoKkrjs r]v avT<2 7rar?/p, 6 epos dSeAcpds, akka trapa-
Ttkr)crLov p.ev Tovvopia 'I<piKA?/s, 6
c
HpaKAeot>s abekcpos.
narpoKA?7s 8' os, ads; Tldvv y, eyco, op.op.1)-
TpLos ye,
8e',
ov /xeVrot
r)
6po7rdrptos.'
'A8eA<p6s t!<pr)v
apa eari <rot 5
Kai ovk d8eA<po's. Ov^ opLOTr&TpLos ye, co /3e'Artore, e<p?/^'

,
(KeCvov pikv yap Xatpe'8?7/x,os rjv 7rar?/p, e/xos 8e Scocppoino-Kos.

nar?/p 8e ?/i>, e<p?7, 2co<ppori<rKOS Kat Xatpe'8?7pos;ndzn;
y\ e<p?/I; 6 /xeV ye e/xds, 6 8e klvov. Ovkow, 17

8' os, erepos 298
r)v XaLp4br)p.os tov ixaTposi Tovp.ov y, (pt)v eyco. -'Ap'
ovv 7rar?/p r)v f-repos (ov TraTpos; t) av et 6 avros rco Ait9co;
Ae'8oiKa /xei; eya)y'', e<p??i>, p?^ cpavco ?J7r6 <rou 6 a?3roV oy

p.ivroL p.01 8okco. Ovkow f-Ttpos et, ecp?/, rou kidov; 5
C3 TW:
ets B Ke<f>a\^v tov \6yov rts airoTifioi B W (sed in
marg. yp. kcu tov '6\ov W^ : Kecpa\i]v a.TroTfj.r}0firj tov \6yov T C5 fioi
T: /*oi rivi B d. 1 riaTpoKATjs secl. Heindorf d.9 airoKpivofiat
B W : airoKptvovfiat B2 T 6 2 irapair\r)aiov B : irapair\T\atov T :
TraoenrAô-ios olim Heindorf

298 a nAATGNOS
"Erepos AAAow
ovv erepos, 8' os,
"EortXi0ov
p-evroL. rt r) cbv ov
Xi0os et; kcu erepos u>v \pvcrov ov xpvcrbs et; ravra.
Ovkovv Kal 6 Xaipebr)p.os, ecpr), erepos oov irarpbs [ovk
av] Trarrjp eo-riv. "EotKey, rjv 8' eyco, ov rrarqp eXvaL.
b Et yap brjirov, ecpr), rrarrjp ecrrLV 6 XaLpebr)p.os, VTroXafioiv
6 F>v0vbi)pos, iraX.LV av 6 ôicppovicrKos erepos oov Trarpbs
ov Trarrjp ecrrLV, uxrre crv, 2) ScoKpare?, dirdroip eX.
Kat 6 Kr?7o-t7r7ros Kbedpevos, 'O Se vp.erepos, ecpr), av

irarrjp ov ravra ravra ireTrov0ev; erepos ecrrLV rovp.ov irarpos;
5
rioAA.oo 6 Ev0v8r?/xo?.
'AAAa, 8'
'O y, 8et, 6
ecpr), r) 5$,
avros; avros jueVrot. Ovk av o-vp.j3ovXoLp.-rjv. dXXa.
C rrorepov, oo Ev9vbr)p:e, ep.bs p.6vov ecrrl Trarrjp r) Kat rS>v
aXXa>v av0po)rroiv; .Kat rS>v aAAcoy, e<pr? , r) otet rbv avrbv
irarepa ovra ov irarepa eXvaL; y
Q,Lp,r)v bfjra, ecpr) 6 KrrjV-
lttttos. Tt 8e; r) 8' 6V xpvcrbv ovra p.r) \pvcrbv eXvai;
5 rr avdpoiirov ovra p.r) avdpoiirov; Mr) ydp, ecpr) 6 KrrjcrLTr-
iros, a) F>v0vbr)p.e, rb Xeyop.evov, ov Xivov Xivco crvvaTrreLS'
beivbv yap Aeyets rrpdyp.a el 6 crbs Trarr)p rravroiv ecrrlv
rrarrjp. .'AAA' ecrrLV, ecpt). Horepov dv0pu>iroiv; r)
8' 6?
6 Kr77o-t7r7ros, r/ *cat tmroiv kol tG>v dXXoiv irdvroiv cocoi>;
d Ylavroiv, ecpr).
*H Kat p.r)rr)p r) p.i)rr)p; Kat r) p.r)rr)p ye.
Kat tS>v e\Cvoiv dpa, ecpr), r) crr) p.rjrr)p p.r)rr)p ecrrt rGiv
0aXarrLOiv. .Kat r) crr) y, ecpr). Kat crv apa abeXcpbs

et tS>v KOi/BL&v koX Kvvapioiv Kal yoLpLbioiv. Kat yap o"6,
5 1*077. Ka7rpos apa ctol rrarrjp ecrrL kol Kvoiv. Kat yap
croi, ecpr).
AvrUa be ye, r) 8' oj 6 ALovvcroboipos, &v p.0L diroKpivr),
a 8 oijKow Schanz : ovkovv BT ovk hv B T oJW: secl. Schanz

W
:
a 9 io-riv B e1r\ T W : b i e<r? : e<pi}v BT b 4 o3 rrar^p

B : irariip oS T (sed add. signis transpositionis) e 1 ix6vov
Stephanus : /xSvos BT C5 /i^l i{ Ast e6 <rvvdwTT)s corr.
Coisl. C9 Ka\ T&v W t) Ka\ to>v BT d i prius ii W om. B T
W
: :
d2 &pa etpr) BT : <pri &pa d 3 twv OaXaTTiwv secl. Schanz

d4 tuv KwfSiwv T: tuv wiSiaiv W
(sed in marg. yp. twv Kofitwv W) :
tv fioiSiwv B d 5 Kdirpos Hoeffer /cal irpbs d6 <rol

: BT W
T: <rb B
.
ET0TAHMO2 2 g8d
S) Kr?/o-i7r7re, 6p.okoyricreLS ravra. elire ydp /uot, ecrrL crot
kvoov; Kal p.dka irovqpos, ecpr] 6 Kti]<tlttitos. "Eo-tlv ovv

avrG> Kwihia; Kat p.dk\ ecpr], erepa roiavra. Ovkovv e
7rar?/p (cttiv avr&v 6 kvojv; "Eycoye' rot etcW, ecprj, avTov
dyjevovTa tt\v Kvva. Tt ovv; ov cros kcrnv 6 kvu>v; Yldvv
y, ecpr]. Ovkovv Trarrjp abv cros ecrTLV, cocrre crbs Trarrjp
yiyverai 6 kvoov Kal crv Kvvapioov dbekcpos; 5
Kat avdis Ta\v VTrokafiobv 6 Aiovvcrobcopos, tva p.r)
irpoTepov tl enrot 6 Kr?jo-i7r7ro?, Kat ert ye pot p.LKpov, ecprj,
aTtoKpLvaL' TVTTTtLS tov Kvva tovtov; Kat 6 Kr7/o-t7r7ro?
yeAdo-as, N?) tovs 6eovs, ecprp ov yap bvvap.aL cre. Ovkovv

tov cravTov Trarepa, ecpt], r?J7rreis; 10
Tlokv p.evTOL, ecpt], biKaLOTepov rbv vp.eTepov iraTep a{v) 299

TVTTTOLp.L, otl p.adoov crocpovs vels ovtozs ecpvcrev. dAA' 77
7rou, Ev6vbi]p.e [6 Kr7/o-t7r7ros], 7ro'AA' dyada dirb ttjs

s
vp.Tpas crocpias Tavrrjs dirokekavKev 6 iran]p 6 vp.eTepos
re /cat t&v KWLbioov. 5
'AAA' ovbev 8etrat 7roAAa>y dyad&v, 00 Kr?jort7r7re, ovt
CKelvOS OVT o~v.
Ovbe crv, 7]
0' os, o) Ev6vbt]p.e, avTos;
Ovbe aAAo? ye o?38ets dvdpanroov. elire ydp /uot, co
Kr?/o-t7r7re, et dyadbv vop.ieLs etyat dcrdevovvTL cpdpp.aKov b

7rieu> 7] ovk dyadbv elvaL boKel ctol, orav Serrrai* 77 els
irokepLOv otov Xrj, oirka eyovTa p.akkov teVat 77 dVo7rAoix\

"Ep.0Lye, ecpi]. Kairoi 01/u.ai ri cre tG>v Kakwv epelv. 2u
dpLcrTa etcrr/, ecpj]' dAA' diroKpivov. 7TLbr) ydp a)/uoAo'yets 5
dyadbv etvat cpdpp.aKov, orav 8e'r/, Trive.LV dvdpooiTU), dkko tl
tovto to dyadbv cos TrAetcrroy bel TriveLV, /cat KaAcos exet eêt,
edv tls avrco rpi\j/as eyKepdcrr] ekkeftopov ap.aav; Kat 6
e 9 7Ao<ras T W : yeAcus B a 1 vaTep' av Sauppe : iraripa

BT (StKaiorepov hv Ast) a2 /naOwv^ ira6a>v corr. Coisl. a3 6
Kt^cjttitos secl. Schanz : e<prj 6 Kriiariinros vulg. a5 rS>v W : 6 rwv
BT bs 6fxoKoye?s Heindorf by rb Par. 1808 : om. BTW
int7] tKtivcp Voegelin : kuvos Schanz b8 ahrtp B : avrb T
PLATO, VOL. III. 12

299 b ITAAT&N02
Kr?7<n7nros et7rev Tldvv ye crcpobpa, S Erj#rj8r/ue, idv f)
ye
C 6 irCvoiv ocros 6 avbpihs 6 kv AeAc/>ois. Ovkovv, ec/jrj, kol iv
rco 7roAe'juco e7ret8r/ dyaOov o~tiv 6ir\a ex ( v

'
> cos TrAetcrra 8et
X iV bopard re Kat dcr7ri8as, e7ret8r/7rep dyaOov ioriv;

MdAa 8r/7rorj, ecpr) 6 KTrjo-nnros' ov 8' ovk otet, a> Ev6vbrjp.c,
5 dAAd /jttaz> Kat er 8o'/>?j;

w
Eycoye.
*H Kat tov Yr]pv6vr)v dv,
ec/>r/, Kat tov Bpidpecav orjrcos ctv 6ir\CcraLs; eyco 8e co/vtr/z/ cre
btivoTepov etfat, dre OTTkop.dyr)v ovra, Kal rovbt: rbv eratporj.

Kat 6 f>tey E?j0rj8r//xos icrCyrjcrt-v 6 8e Atoz>rjcrd8copos 7rpds
d rd TTpoTepov diTOK-iKpLp.iva rio Krrro-t7r7ra) rjpero, Ovkovv Kal

XpvcrCov, ?/
8' ds, dyaOov SoKet o-ot etyat k"x il - v
'
ndz;?j,
Kat raurd ye 7roArj, ec/>rr 6 Kr?/cri7r7ros.' Tt ovv; dyaOd ov

boKL croL xprjvaL det r' eêty Kat iravTaypv; ~2,cp6bpa y,
5 ec/>rr. OrjKorjz/ Kat rd \pvo-Lov dyaOov dpoAoyets etpai;
'HpoAdyr/Ka pez> orjz>, t/ 8' ds. OrjKow det 8et avrb %x - v

Kal Travraxov Kal cos /xaAtcrra kv eavrco; Kat etr/ d?J erjSat-
~
e pLovicrraTos et exot XP V0 l0V P- V TP- a fdkavTa kv tjj yaorpC,
TakavTov 8' iv rco Kpazncp, OTaTrjpa 8e xprjcrorj ev eKarepoi
rcoc/J0aA/jicp; 4>acrt ye orjzj, co E?3c9rJ8rj/Ae, ec/jr/ d Krr/ot7r7ros,
rodrovs edSatuoz/ecrrdrorjs etrjat l^Kvdcbv Kat dptcrrorjs drdpas,
~ ~'
5 ot xP va i0V T * v ro ' ? KpavCoLs ex ovo v ttoAu tois earjrcoy,
&cnrep crrj vvvbr) eAeyes rdy KrjVa rdz> 7rarepa, Kat d 0arj-
/xacrtcorepdrj ye ert, ort Kat ttCvovctlv eK rcoz> eaurcoy KpavCcov

Kixpvo-(jL>p.ivoiV, koX rarjra erjrds KaOop&cnv, rr)v eaurcoy
KOpv(pr)v iv rats x 6 /30"^ eôrjres.
300 ndrepoy 8e opdoLV, e<pr/ d Erjt9rj8r//itos, Kat 2Krj(9at re Kat

ot
bvvaTa
dAAot dvOpwTTOL
br/TTOv. ÔrjKorjy
to. bvvard opdv
Kat crrj, icpr);
7/ rd d8wara;
Kdyco.
'OpasTd orjij
rd fipLt-Tepa i/xdrta; Nat. Avvard ovv opdv

ecrrtv Tavra.
5 'T-rrcpcpv&s, ec/jr/ d Krr/o-i7r7ros. Ti 8e'; t/ 8' os. Mrjbev.
c 1 %<ros B W : <5 o-bs T c7 xai . . . kratpov secl. Schanz

d2 7roeu] rrtivu ye Heindorf d4 xP')*' al Badham : xpJi/jLara BT
d6 &fio\6yr)Ka fjiiv Serranus : wjxoKoyfiKa/j.ev BT a 1 tc] 7
Sauppe ,

ET0TAHMO2 300 a
(tv 8e i(T(as ovk otet avra opav ovtws r)bvs et. aXXd /uot
boKels, EvOvbriiAe, ov KaOevboiv e*7rtKeKoijUT/o-0ai Kai, (et) olov
re keyovra p.rrb\v Ae'yeti>, Kal o~v tovto ttolcIv.

*H yap ov\ olov t ', (cprj 6 Aiovvo-obwpos, cny<2vTa b
Ae'yeu>; Oi>8' ottojcttlovv, t/ 8' 6? 6 KrT/cri7r7ro?. Ap' ovSe
kiyovTa cnydv; "Ert rJTrov, cprj.
"Oray ovv ki$ovs Aeyr/s
Kal vka kol crLbrjpLa, ov crLyGtVTa Aeyets; Ovkovv et ye

eyco, ecTjrr, Trappyop.aL ev rot? x a^ Ketots, > dAAa cpdzyy6p:(va 5
Kat /3o<Syra pe'yicrroz> tcl crLbr\pLa Aeyerat, eay rts ar^TTraf

wrrre rouro juey vird crocpias ekaOes ovbev cIttojv. dAA' ert
pot rd Zrepov (irtbeiâTOv, O7rcos aii ecrrtz' kzyovTa crLyav.
Kat fxot eSoKet imtpayaivLav 6 KrT/cri7r7ros Std ra 7rai8i/ca. C

v
"Oray o-iyas', e(/>TT 6 Et3i9tJ8tt/uos', otj 7rarra crtyas; Eycoye,
t/ 8' ds. Otjkow Kat tcl ksyovTa crtyas, et7rep rco^ airdvTOiv
ZcttIv [tcl Aeydpeâ]. Tt 8e'; ec/Jrr 6 KrT/cri7r7ros, ou crtya

irdvTa; Ov brjirov, ecpr/ 6 EvdvbtrpLos.' 'AAA' dpa, co /3e'A- 5
rtcrre, Ae'yet ra irdvTa; Ta ye brJTrov keyovra. 'AAAd, t/
8' os, ov tovto epcorco, dAAa ra 7rdrra crtya t/ Ae'yet;
OvSeVepa Kat dpcpdrepa, ecpT/ vcpapTrdcras 6 ALovvcrobcapos' d

ev ydp ot8a 8'rt rr/ diroKpicrcL ovx eets ort XP$
Kat 6 KrT;cri7r7ros, <ocr7rep etcotfet, p,e'ya 7rdû draKayxdcras,
?
12 Evt^TJSrjpe, ecpTT, 6 dSeAcpds aou e^r/p.cporeptKei' roi Adyoj,
Kat d7ro'Aa)Ae' re Kat r/rrTjrat. Kat d KAewtas Trdvv t/o-#tt 5
Kat kyikacrtv, u>ctt 6 KrT/crt7r7ro? eyivtTo irkelov r) 8eKa-

7rAdcrto9. d 8e' p.ot 8oKet dr^ Travovpyos &v, 6 KrrjcrLTnTos,
irap avT&v TovTOiv avTa ravra TrapT/KT/Koef otj ydp ecrrty
dAAcoi TOLavTr) crocpta tS>v vvv dvOpoiiroiv.
a6 oiiTa ipav B W : dpav avra T a 7 firiKeKotfirjaOai corr. Par.

1808 : iiriKtKoiij.a(rdai BTW e add. ci. Stephanus b2 6 T:
om. B b4 yêW: ^êB: ij-yeT bs xaAttoisB: x 01 *'^ '*^
b6 \76to] AeVet Ast C4 to Xs^tJjuevo secl. Schanz to : Xtyovra
Stephanus d 3 avaKaxx&o-as B avaKKax<x<ras T d5 fJTTTjTai
W
:
B : ^tt77<toi T d6 gS<tt6 T : 8>o-irep B irA.eloi' BT W : irkuv

Aristides 8(Kair\d<nos B T b~nr\d<rios : W Aristides d7 8' dfiol
SoKti oTe Ast St, SoKf? fiot, oVe Heusde

: yp. S' iSoKtt
: fjtot fire T : 5e'
fj.ot BT :
8' olfiat Badham d8 irapaK^Kott BT 12*

30oe ITAAT&N02
e Kdyco cIttov Tt yeAas, to KAetivta, eVt (nrovbaiots ovrco
irpayiiacriv kol koKoIs;
2v yap rjbr] rt ttu>ttot etBes, co ScoK/rares, KaKbv irpaypa;

((prj 6 ALovvo-6ba>pos.
5 "Eycoye, e(pr]v, Kal 7roAAd ye, co Atoi/iWScope.

301 'Apa Tpa ovTa tov koKov, t(pr\, r/ ravra r<S KaAco;
Kdyco ep 7ravrt yev6p,r]v virb aTropCas, Kal r)yovp.r]v
bUaLa TTeiTOvOevaL otl eyprja, 6p.a>s 8e ertpa (pr]v avrov

ye tov koKov' TrapscrTLV pivTOL eKacrra) ovt&v KaAAos rt.
5 'Eay ovv, et/>r/, irapaykvqTai ctol (3ovs, fiovs et, Kat ort
vvv ey&> croi 7rdpei/At, ALOvvo-6ba>pos et;
F,v(pr]p:L tovto ye, r/v 8' eyco.
'AAAa rtVa Tpoirov, e<pr/, kripov erepco Trapaytvop.kvov

to tTtpov Tpov av etr/;
b Âpa roiVo, e<pr/v eya>, cnropeLs; "Hbrj 8e rou> avbpolv

Tr)v o-ocpCav ir tyeipovv /u/Aeurflat, are TTL0vp.a>v avrrjs.
YIa>s yap ovk a.TTopa>, e<pr], Kat eycb Kat 01 aAAot a7ravres
avOpcoiTOL 6 ftr) i-o-ti;
5 Tt Ae'yets, rjv 0' eyco, co Aioin>o-o'8a>pe; ou ro Kakbv koKov

icrTLV kol to alo-yjpbv alcry^pov; 'Ecu/ e/xotye, e<pr/, Soktj.
OrjKorjiv ooKet;- Yldvv y , ec/)r/. Qvkovv koX to ravTov ravTov
Kal to erepozv 'krepov; ov yap br]Trov to ye erepov ravTov, dAA'
C eycoye ov8' av iralba a>p.r]v tovto aiToprjcraL, <w? orj to erepoiv
Tp6v eartv. dAA', a> Atovvcr6ba>p, tovto p.ev ko>v TraprJKas,
eVet tcl dAAa /uot OKetre axnrep ol br]p.Lovpyol dls eKacrra
irpoo-r]KL cnTtpya&crOaL, Kal vp.LS to 8taAe'yecr(9at 7rayKdAtos
5 d7repyd(êo-(9ai.
Olcrda ovv, ecprj, ort 7rpoar/Ket eKacrrot? rwy br]p.LOvpyS>v;
irp&Tov TLVa xaAKerJeiy irpoo-t]KL, oto-0a; "Eycoye" ort XA"
e 3 e?8es t i$es B T
: 646 supra versum T a 2 iwb secl.
Schanz b 1 8 rorv avtipoTv T Stcfc twc d^Spwj' B 5m (suprascr.
W
: :
e) tv (suprascr. 01) avtip&v (suprascr. 01) 8' : *5j'qi to?i/ avSpoTv

Schanz C 3 ivel ra Cornarius eireira B T : ols fKao^ra] a
eicdo-Tois Badham c 6 ^rj B om. T W :

ET0TAHMO2 3<>ic
Ki.a. Tt 8e', Kpap.VLv; Kepa/xea. Tt 8e', o-(paTTLV re

Kal eKSepew Kal ra /utKpd Kpia KaTaKo\\ravTa \j/iv Kal oirTav;
Mayeipov, r\v 8' eyco. Ovkovv idv tls, obr\, ra irpoar]- d
Kovra -npaTTri, 6p65>s 7rpdet; MdAtcrra. HpocnjKet 8e' ye,
rdy p.dyLpov KaTaKOiiTLV Kal KbpLv; co/AoAdy?/cras

cos
ravra
</)?js,
r) ov;
'XlpoAdyrjcra, (pr\v, akka avyyv(op.r\v /xot exe.
Aijkov Toiwv, r\ 8' d?, 6'rt ay rts cr</>d<fas r6i> p.dyLpov Kat 5
KaTaKo\ffas ei//?/cr?/ Kat 07rr?/o-?7, rd irpoar\KOVTa TTOLi\aL' Kal

Zav tov x.a\K*a tls avrbv )(aAKev?/ Kat r6y Kpap.ia Kpap.vi\,
Kal ovtos tcl -npoar\KOVTa 7rpd<fei.

'12 ndcret8oy, ?jy 8' eyco, ?/8r/ KoAocpcova e7rtrtt9eis ttj e
cro</>ia. apd /xoi Trore ai/r?/ Ttapayvr\aTaL cocrre /xot otKeta
yereVflai;
'E7rtyi>oir/s ay avr?ji;, ai ScoKpare?, e<p?/, otKetai' yero-
p.vr\v; 5
'Edu <rv ye /3ovA?j, e</>?/i> eyco, 8?/Aoy ort.
Tt 8e', ?/
8' ds, rd aavrov otet ytyj>co<rKeii>;
Et p.r\ tl av dkko Ae'yets* a7r8 aov ydp 8et dpyjtadaL,
TektvTdv 8' ets Evt9d8?jp.oi> roV8e.

*Ap' ow, ec/)?j, raura ?jy?j crd etrat, cSy dz> dpfys Kal e?j io
crot avrots \pr\a6aL otl dv (3ovki\; olov j3ovs Kai TTp6/3aTov, 302
ap' dv ?/yoto rarjra o-d etVat, d crot e<fet?/ Kat d7ro8o'o-0at
Kat bovvaL Kal 6vaaL drco fiovkoLo Oe&v; a 8' du p.r\ ovtcos
^XV' ov ""
Kdyco (?j8?j ydp drt e avT&v Kakov tl dvaKv\j/OLTO tG>v 5

pot)Tr\p.aTcov, Kat djua j3ovkop.Vos otl TayjiaT aKovaai)
Tldvv p.V ovv, (pr\v, ovrcos ex et " T d TOLavTa o~tlv p.6va
e/xd. Tt 8e'; (fcoa, ec/)?j, ov raura KaAets a dv x/atx^ ex?7
Nat, (pr\v.
'Op,oAoyets ovv t&v (^cocoy raCra p.6va etvat b
e8 Tt (bis) BT : riva (bis) scr. recc. cg ra /xtKpa npea secl.

Hermann ra Kp4a : o-puKpa Badham d7 avrbu] o anonymus
apud Stallbaum e 1 iirtTidtls B intriOrjs T 64
imyvoiris]
W
:
iire\ yvoiris Badham a 1 irpofiarov BT (sed o supra ov T)

a2 rryoT' T : iryol '6rav B : ^0) r av W ^{eir/i T :
ef ei r| B
a5 draK-ityoiTo B : dyaKttyoi to T twj/ ip<Drr\fJtdrwv secl. Cobet

302b IIAAT&N02
crd, irepl a dv <tol eov<ria rj -navra ravra Troielv h vvvbrj
eyo> ekeyov; 'Op.okoyG> Kat 6s, elpo>VLK(2s irdvv eTTLcryo>v
8>s ti fxiya crKOTrovp.evos, EiVe /xot, ecpt), 2> 'StoKpares, eVrrty
5 ctol Zev? iraTpG>os; Kat eyo> vTroirTevo-as ijeLV tov koyov

olirep eTekevT-qo-ev, diropov Tiva crTpocp-qv ecpevyov re /cai
ecrTpe<p6p.r]v rjbr) uxnrep ev bi,KTva> eikr)pp.evos' Ovk ecrTLv, r)v
o eyo>, o> Aiovvaob<i)pe. TakaiTT(opos dpa tis o~v ye dvdpo>-

C iros eT Kal oibe 'AdrjvaXos, <j> pJ]Te deoi iraTpGtoi elcriv p.r]Te
lepa p.r]Te dkko pvqbev Kakbv kol ayaOov. Ea, v

rjv 8' eyd>,
o> AtomWSajoe, ev<pr]p.ei re Ka\ p.r) yakeirG>s p.e irpobibacrKe.
eo-TL yap ep.0Lye koX [3o>p.ol Kal lepa. otKeta Kat TrarpGia mt
5 tcl akka oo-airep tols aAAots A6t]vaioLS tG>v tolovto>v.
Etra tols aAAots, eqbr], 'AdrjvaioLS ovk eoTLV Zevs 6 iraTpG>os;
Ovk eo-TLV, r)v 8' ey&>, avTt) r) eiro>vvp.ia Tdvoiv ovbevi,
ovd' oo-ol eK rrjcrbe rrjs ir6keo>s diro>KLcrp.evoL eicrlv ovd' r)puv,
d akka Airokktov iraTp<2os 8ta rr)v tov "Iojvos yeveo-tv Zet>s
b r)p.lv iraTpG>os piev ov KaAetrat, epKeLos 8e kol cppaTpLos,
Ka\ 'A6r]vaia (pparpia. 'AAA' dpKei y , e<pr) 6 ALovvcr6bo>pos'
ecTTLV yap ctol, d>s eoLKev, 'Airokkojv re Kat Xevs Kal 'Adrjvd.
Tlavv, 8' eyo>. Ovkovv Kat ovtol av eXev;
5
ecprj.
r)v
Ylpoyovoi, r)v 8' eyo>, Kat 8e<77rorai.

o-ot <9eot
'AAA' ovv croi
ye, e<pr)' rj ov crovs a>p.ok6yrjKas avTovs elvai; 'X2/xoAo'y?iKa,
ecprjv t'l yap Ovkow,

ird6a>; ecprj, koX (,G>a. elcrLV ovtol 61
e êot; o>p.ok6yr]Kas yap ocra \frv)(ri v ^X ei C*? a *""*' V ovtol
61 deol ovk exovo-LV xf/vxqv; -"Exovo-t^, rjv 8' eya>. Ovkovv
Kal <3a elarLv;
Zaia, ecprjv. TG>v be ye C4 v > ^V w/xo-
koyr)Kas ravT etvaL cra, oo~a av o~ol er) Kat bovvaL k6X
5 d7ro8o'o-0ai Kat ^jjaat br) 6eG> ora> av ]3ovkr].
'H/toAoyTjKa,
e<pr)v ovk ecrTLV yap jxol avdbvo-Ls, o> Evdvbr]p.e. "16l 8?/ poi
b6 otirtp Hertlein : yirtp BT fcpevySv re Kat secl. Badham

b8 tjj T T B :
04 fiufiol ical TW : om. B c6 S secl.
Schanz c 7 ovtievi'] ob$eo~iv Naber c8 ovff . . . ov6' . . .
Bekker : 0J8' . . . ovb" . . . BT d2 Hpn tos BT d 3 'AOrivata

Cobet : 'k6r\vaij) Eustathius Porson : aQ-qvix BT d 4 'A9r)vaia
Schanz d5 irdvv"} ndvv ye Ast 65 5}f Schanz : av B T om. al. :
ET0TAHMO2 302 e
evdvs, ?/
8' 6s, et7re'* eVeto^/ crov opoXoyels etmt rw Ata
Kat rovs 1
aWovs 6eovs, apa eêort o-ot avroiis a7rooo-0at 33

?"/ Sowat ?*/ dAA' ort ay /3ovA?/ \pi]o~daL oxnrep rot? dAAots
{wots;
'Eya) /xeu w, 2> Kpiro)v, uxrnep 7rA?/yets ?j7ro rou Ao'yoi>,
(Keipr\v d<pu>vos' 6 be. Kr?/o-t7r7rds' p.0L lu>v ws fior\6r\cru)v, 5
ni>7r7ra a 'HpaxAet?, e<p??, KaAoO Ao'yo?j.- Kat 6 Atozn;o-d-

bu>pos, Uorepov ovv, ecprj, 6 'HpaKXrjs 7rt>7r7rd eo-TLV rj 6
7rt'7r7ra 'Hpankfjs; Kat 6 Kr?/o-i7T7ros, *X2 ndo-et5oi>, ea3?7,
beiv&v \6yu>v. dcpicrTap.aL' ap.ayu> tu> dvbpe.

'Fivravda p.evTOL, u> ojtAe KpiTu>v, ovbels ootis ov tu>v b
irapovTOiV vnepeiirjveo-e tov koyov kol to) dvbpe, txal yekcovTes
Kat KporovvTes kol yaCpovTei oXiyov napeTa6r]o-av. enl p.ev
yap tols epLTrpoo-dev ecp' eKacrTOLS ixacrL nayKa\o)S edopvfiovv
p.6voL ol tov F,vOvbrjp.ov epacrrai, evTavda be okiyov koX 61 5
KLOves oi ev r<3 AvKeio) e6opv/3r}(rdv r' enl tolv dvbpoiv Kal
ijcrdricrav. eyio p.ev ovv kol avros ovtu> bLTe6r\v, uxne
opoXoyelv ptrjbevas nu>noT dv6pu>novs Ibeiv ovtu> crocpovs, C
Kat navTanacrL KaTabov\u>6els vno rrjs cro(pias ovtolv en\
t6 enaLveiv re Kat eyKto/xtaêti' avTu> Tpan6p.i]v, kol etnov
^Q. /uaKaptot crcpu> ttjs 6avp.acrTrjs (pvcreu>s, 6i too-ovtov npaypa
ovtu>Taxy Kal ev dAtya) XP V(? *eCpyacrOov. noXXd p.ev 5
ovv Kat aAAa 01 Aoyot vp.u>v KaAa exovcriv, <*> F.v6vbi]p.e re
Kat ALovvo~6ba>p' ev be tols kol tovto p.eyakoTrpeTTecrTaTov,
OTL TU)V TTO\KS)V dvdpO)TTO)V KOL TU>V CTp.vG)V bl] KOL boKOVVTO)V
t\ eivaL ovbev vplv /xe'Aet, dAAa tQv 6poCo)v vpXv p.6vov. d
eyu> ydp ev olba otl tovtovs tovs Ao'yoi>s irdvv piev dv oAtyot
dyaTnSev dvdpo)noL 6p.oioL vp.lv, oi 8' aAAot ovtu>s dyvoovcrLV
a6 iru-rat B : irviraf^ T (sed mox a 7, 8 7ri/7r7ro| B irvir-rat T) etpri

W W
:
: (<pr)v BT b 2 koI post &t>Spe B om. T y-Xwvres

:
. Kporovvres . .
x---P 0VTfS Badham yeKuiVTe Kporovvre
W (xtpovT- W)
. . . : . . . . .
W
.
XaipovT' B T b3 -rap(Ta.dr)o-av T : -raptTeOi-o-av B

b 7 H\<TQi)aav T : 4\tffdT\(rav B C4 of\ -l Cobet C 5 iêipyaoQov
T (sed ex
yp. 4l~eipyd<ra<r8ov t)ifepyadov
: : B C 7 fieya\oirpf-
tri<TTaTov Stephanus : fitya\o-rpfire<rrepov B T d. 3 ovrws ayvoovaiv
T : oi/Tw voovffiv B W : oJ/to> fttffovffiv Naber : alii alia
303d IIAAT&N02
avrovs, &<tt ev olba otl alo-yyvOeuv av pAkkov eeAe'yxoyres
5 tolovtois koyoLS tovs akkovs r) avrol eêAeyxoêrot. koX
ro'8e av Tpov brjiJLOTLKov tl kol irpaov iv toIs koyOLS'
oiroTav (prjre p.r)Te Kakbv cXvaL p.r)bv p.r)T dyaObv itpayp.a
p.r)Tt kevKov pLrjb' dkko t<2v tolovtoov p.r)biv, p.r)be rb Trapdirav
e eTepcav trepov, aTeyyGis piev tG> ovtl crvppdiTTCTe ra o-Top.aTa

T&V dvOpbiTTOiV, OiO"7Tp KOL (paTV OTL 5' 0V pLOVOV TCL T&V
akkcov, akka 6o'atre av Kal tcl vpLerepa avT<2v, tovto ttclvv
yapUv ri (o-tlv koX to eira\0es t<2v koyoiv cupaLptLTaL. to
5 8e br) peyLo-rov, otl raura ovtcos e)(et vplv koX TeyyLKuts
Z^rjvprjTaL, aVr' e{v) iravv 6kCyu> xpovoi ovtlvovv clv p.aOelv
dvOpoiiTOiv iyvoiv eya>ye Kal tu> KTtro-LTTirui tov vovv Trpocri-
\(av a>s Taxv vp.as ex tov irapaxpr)p.a pLp.*:lo-0aL olos re rjv.
304 tovto p.tv ovv tov TTpayp.aTos crqjGiv to cro<pbv irpbs p.\v rb
Ta\v TrapabLbovaL Kakov, kvavTiov 8' dvOpoirroiv 8taAe'yeo"0at
ovk iTTLTrjbeLOV, dAA' av ye p.0L ireL0r)o-0, evkaftrjo-eo-Oe p.r)
7Tokk>v evavTLOv Aeyetiv, Xva pvf) Tayy Kp.a06vTs vp.lv p.r)
5 dbaxTLv yapLV. dkka judAtcrra ptv avTOi irpbs dkkr)k<a p.6vu>
8taAe'yecr0ozr et 8e p.rj, etirep aAAou tov Ivovtlov, zkzlvov

povov bs av ip.lv 8t5<S dpyvpLov. tcl avra 8e ravra, eav
b o-(D<ppovi)T, Kal toIs p.aOr)Tals ou/x/3oi>Aevoere, p.i)biiT0T
p.r)bevl dvOpoiiroiv 8iaAe'yecr#ai dAA' r) vp.lv re Kat avrots*

to yap crirdvLOV, u> EvOvbrjpt, TLp.Lov, to 6e vbcop evaivo-
TaTov, apLcnov ov, <pr) YlLvbapos. dAA' dyere, rjv 6'
<j)S
5 eyw, oirais Kape koX KkeLvtav rovbe TrapabzêcrOov.

Taura, Zi KpLTcov, kol dkka drTa ert fipa\ea 6taAe-
d 4 &<rr T :
<fir B d6 tj B : Te T (sed suprascr. i)
d 7 ^tt^toj' B : '6ti ot txv T <pfJTe fi-fiTf B /j.}/ <prJTe T /x-fiTe
W
:
aya.Obi' d8 . . . fj.rjSev T : om. B d8 /xr]5e B : /nijTe T to

irapdiray T to : 63 avTwv corr. Coisl. avTw T avTcb
irapav B : :
B W e5 exeil ev ex Badham e3 Schanz e 6 Sxtt ev ci. :
Heindorf: S<rre BT 67 Kai] xat (avTbs') Schanz irpo<rex<v

Heusde npo<rex <ro<pbv T om. B a 3 evKofifaeffde T evAafi-f)-

: :
<re<rdai B a4 evavTiov T : evavTtwv B as /j.6vw secl. Cobet

b5 irapalieZeffOov scr. recc. : irapaSeâffdov BT b6 &\\a &TTa eTt
W : a\\' aTTa eTi T : &\\a B

ET0TAHMO2 3<Hb
yfiivTes dirf\p.ev. crKoVei ovv oirois o~vp.(pOLTr)creLS irapa to)
dvbpe, cls tKeCvoi (parbv oXoi re etmt bibaat tov edekovT c

apyvpiov bibovai, Kal ovre (pxxnv ov0' fjktKiav eêipyeLv
oibep.iav o be Kal crol /xdAiora TrpocnjKeL aKovaai, otl oibe
tov )(prip.aTte(TdaL <parov biaKOiXveLV oibev- />?/ ov Trapa-

Xafielv ovtlvovv eiirerois tjjv crcpeTepav crocpiav. 5
KP. Kat /a?/j>, ai 2c)K0ares', </uA?/koos' /xey eyoaye Kal

))beois dy rt p.av0dvoLp.L, KLvbvvevoi p.evroL Kayoi ets eu>at
v
rcoi/ o^x 6p,o(oov Evc9u8?///g), dAA' eKeivoiv &v 8? / Kat cri)
ekeyes, r<2i> ?/8toi> du eekeyyop.evoiv vtto tG>v tolovtojv d

Ao'ycoi> ?7 eêkeyyovTOiV. drap yekoXov p.ev p.0L boKei elvat
to vov0eTeiv cre, 6p.oiS be, a y Jjkovov, e0ekoi ctol diray-
yetAai. t&v dc/>' vp.&v dirLOVTOiV Xcrff otl Trpocrek0oiV tls
P-ol irepLTraTovvTL, avrjp olop.evos Trdvv etVat crocpos, tovtoov 5
ris t5>v Trepl tovs koyovs tovs els tcl 8tKacrr?//)ia beLv&v,
'12 KpLToov, ecprj, oibev aKpoq T&vbe tS>v o~ocp>v; Oi p.a
tov Ata, r)v 8' eyco* oi yap otos r' ?) irpocrcrTas KaTaKoveiv
vrrb tov fykov. Kat p.r\v, ecpr), d<fioV y r)v aKovcraL. Tt
8e'; r)v 5' eyco. "Iva iJKOvcras dvbp&v bLakeyop.evoiV ot vvv e
croc/jcorarot etcri rcov 7rept roi)? rotourovs Ao'yovs. Kdyco
**
enroir
Ti/ * } /
It
/
ow ecpaLvovTo
/
crot; rf/
It oe
5;\ Jf
aAAo,
\ \ <?
?/
>
os,
rf A
?/
/
OLairep
del dV rts rwy tolovtojv aKOVcraL krjpovvTOJV Kat 7rept oi/Seô?

a^LOiV ava^Cav crirovbriv TroLovp.iviov ; {ovToicrl yap ttojs Kal 5
et7rer rots 6v6p.acrLv). Kat eyco, 'AAAd p.ivTOL, Zcprjv, yapUv

yk tl irpayp.a ccttlv ?/ c/>tAoo-oc/)ta. Iloibi/, ecprj, yapUv, ai
/xaKapte; ovbevbs p.ev ovv cllov. aXXa Kat et vvv Trapeyevov, 35

irdvv av cre ot/uat alcr-^vvdijvaL virep tov creavrov eratpov
ovTOis rpv axoiros, kdiXoiv kavTov TrapiytLV av0poiTTOLS oTs
oibev /xe'Aet ort av XiyoicrLV, TravTos be prjp.aTos avTeyovTaL.
C2 y-tipytiv T : itepyeiv B c4 toS] rb ci. Stephanus

C 7 fiavddvoifii B W : /xddoini T d2 ûeV T : om. B d4 fcrtV
ci. Heindorf: olo-0' BT d7 ovSlv] ovde Badham d8 ^]
l\v B : ? T (sed in marg. jji) vpoo-o-ras Heindorf : irpoaras BT
d9 </>t;j' BT 6 1 Se BW om. T 64 d(coi)era BT
W
:
<f>7j]
a4 fr-fifxaros T :
xP'hlxaT0S ^
305^ nAATGNOS
5 kcu ovtol, ottep dpTL ekeyov, ev tols Kpdriorot etVt tSh>
vvv. dkkd ydp, oo Kpircov, ecpr], rb ttpdyp.a avTO nal ol
avOpamoi ol eirl rw itpdypaTL 8tarpt/3oi>res cpavkoi do~LV Kal
KarayekacrTOL. 'Ep,ot 5e, <o ScoKpares, to itpayp.a eboKeL

b ovk op6a>$ ^/eyeLV ovO' ovtos ovt eX rts dkkos êyer to
pievTOL edekeLV biakeyecrdaL tolovtols evavTLOV Ttokkwv
dvOpoittoiV dpO&s p,OL eboKeL pep.cpecr6aL.
2L '12 KpiTOiV, 6avp.dcTLOL elcTLV OL TOLOVTOL CLvbpS.
5 a.Tap ovttio oTba otl p.ekkoi epetv. itoTepoiv rjv 6 Ttpocrekdoiv
ctol Kal pLep.cp6p.evos rr)v cpLkocrocpiav ; ttoTepov t&v dyoivi-
cracrOaL beLvdv ev rots bLKacrT-qpioLS, prjTOip tls, rj t&v tovs

tolovtovs eicr tt ep.it ovTOiv, ttolt]ti]s tS>v koyoiv ols 01 pr]TOpS
ayoiVL^pvTaL;
C KP. "HKio-ra vr) tov Ata prjroip, ovbe ot/xai ituntoT avrbv
eitl bLKao-TrjpLOV dvaê^KevaL' dAA' eitaieLV avTov cpacrL
ttepl tov 7tpa.yp.aTos vr) tov Ata kol beivbv eXvaL Kal beLvovs
koyovs crvvTLdevaL.
5 22. "Hbr] p.av6avoi' itepl tovtcov kol avrbs vvvbr) epek-
kov keyeiv. ovtol yap eicrLV p.ev, co Kpiroiv, ovs ecpr] Ylpo-
biKOS p.edopLa cpLkocrocpov re avbpbs Kal ttokLTLKov, otWrat

5' etât itdvTOiv crocpoiTaTOL avBpoiitoiV, itpbs be rw etvat
/cat boKelv itdvv itapd itokkols, &ctt itapa itacrLV evboKLpeXv
d ep.TtobdiV crcpLcrLV eXvaL ovbevas akkovs rj tovs itepX cpLko-
crocpiav avOpantovs. ryyovviaL ovv, edv tovtovs els boav

KaTacrTr]croicrLV p.t]bevbs boKelv aiovs eXvai, dvap.cpLcr(3r]Tr]T0is
rjb-q itapd ttacrLV ra VLKrjTrjpLa els boav olcrecrdaL crocpias
5 itepL. eXvaL piev ydp rr/ dkrjdeiq. crcpas crocpoiTaTOVs, ev be
toTs ibioLs koyoLs orav aTtokr]cpdS>crLV, vttb t&v ap.cpl Evdv-
a5 Schanz /cpaTiVrois B T
KpaTurToi ci. a 7 <pav\ol B T add. :
W
:
kolvv in marg. t C 2 iirl T aoi B C 3 xal post ehai

:
secl. Schanz c 5 fiavddvoo B /xavddvuv T fjfteWov B T

:
e 7 t T ye B: c 8 t# tlvat scr. recc. to elvat B T secl. Schanz : :
d 4 eh 86tav secl. Naber otcreo-dai B oleadat T d 5 acpas

:
ao<pwTa.Tovs T acpas aocpwrarot B

: a<pe?s aocpwTaTOt Naber
:
d 6 airo-
XeupQwatv Ast

ET0TAHMO2 3 <>5d
brjp.ov KokovecrOaL. crocpol be fiyovvrai elvat Trdvv eiKorcos'
/xerptcos fxkv yap cpLkocrocpias exety, /uerptcos de 7roAtriKco;j,

iravv e etKoros koyov p.ere'xeti> yap dp.cpoTepoiv ocrov edet, e
eVrds be 6vt$ KivhvvoiV Kal dyoivoiv KapiiovcrOaL ttjv crocpiav.
KP. Tt ovv; boKovcri croi ti, co ScoKpares, keyeLv; ov

ydp toi dAAd o ye Adyos eêt Ttva evTjpetxeLav t>v dvbpGtv.
22. Kat yap eêt dWcos, co KptVcoi>, evTrpeireLav pdAAoy 5
?/ dA?/0etai\ ou ydp pq.bi.ov avTovs itelcrai ort Kat dvOpoiTTOL 306

Kat raAAa 7rdyra dtra p.Tav tlvolv bvolv cttlv /cat dp.cpo-
repoLV Tvy\dvtL p.tTiyovTa, ocra p.ev K KaKOt) Kat dyatô?},

roo /xey /3eArtco, roS 8e x^P- ytyi>erar ocra de eK d?jou>
dyafloiV /x?/ 7rpds tovtov, dp-cpolv xeipo* ixpbs o di> eKdrepov 5
?/ xPV"rov (Keivoov e coV crvveTeOr]' ocra 8' eK Sjjoii; KaKolv
crvvTeOevTa p.rj 7rpds ro adrd ovtolv ev r<3 p.e'trcp ecrrtV, raiSra
/xoVa /3eArtco eKarepov eKeivcov eVriv, 8>v dpcporepcov p.epos b

p,eTx ovcrLV ' et /xev ow ?/ cpLkocrocpia dyaOov cttlv Kat ?/
7roAtrtK?/ 7rpdts, TTpbs dAAo 8e eKarepa, ovtol b' dpLCpoTepoiv
p.TxVTes tovtoov ev /xeVco etcrtV, o?38ey Ae'yo?jcrt^ dp.cpo-
repoiv ydp ettrt cpauAdrepot et de dyaObv kol KaKov, tG>v 5

/xev /3eArtot>s, rcoy de xîpous' e * de KaKa dpc/jdrepa, ovrcos
dv rt Ae'yotey dkrjOes, dAAcos 0' ovbap.<o$. ovk dv ovv otpat
avroi/s d//,oAoy?7crai ovre kokco adrco d/xcporepco eti>at ovre C
rd /xe^ KaKov, rd 8e dyadov dAAd rco dvrt ovrot dpcpo-
Ttpoiv perexovTes dp.cpoTepoiv rjrTovs elcrlv Trpos kKaTtpov
irpbs b ij re 7roAtrtK?j Kat ?/ cpLkocrocpia d^tco Adyou 0~t6v,
koI rptroi dvres r?') dkriOeiq (j]Tovcn 7rpcorot doKeti' etrat. 5

v
crvyytyjJcocrKeiy />tey ovy avrots XPV T V$ T"Ldvp.ia$ Kal /x?/
XaAeTratvetv, ?/yetcrt9at p.VTOi tolovtovs etrat otot etcrtJJ*
TtavTa yap dvbpa XPV dyairdv octtls Kal otlovv Ae'yet e"xd-
p.Vov <ppovr\o-Oi$ 7-payp.a Kal dvbpeiois i-rcîoiv 8ta7royetrat. d
KP. Kat p.r\v, cb ScoKpares, Kat avrds 7rept t<2v veoiv,
63 SoKovffl TW: doKu B 65 ovrtas scr. Ven. 184: ovtcos

BT W a3 rvyxavft fX(Ttx'"ra BT /x(T(X el Tvyx^vovTa W
W
:
a 4 X ( Pw T
l
'
: x*'l P wv ^
1
3o6d IIAATX2N02 ET0TAHMO2

uxnrep ael irpos cre Aeyco, iv airopiq etpt tl 8et avTOLs
Xprjcra<r9ai. 6 p.\v ovv TJecorepos ert Kal ap.LKpos eortTJ,
S Kptro'/3ouAos 8' 7/817 r)kLKLav eytL Kal 8etrat tlvos oorts

avrov ovrjarti. eyco p.ev ovv orav o~ol crvyy(v<*>p.ai, ovto>
bt.aTi6ep.ai. coor' epot 8o*et p.aviav etrat to eVexa tS>v iraCbcov
akkcov p.ev irokkG>v o-TTOvbr)v TOLavTrjv ka-yrjKevaL, kol irepl
e tov ydp.ov OTrcos eK yevvaLOTaTtis ecroyrat p.r]Tpos, Kal
irepl t5>v \pr\paT(s>v ottoos cos 7rAo?jcric6rarot, ovtG>v be 7rept
7rai8et'as dp.ekrjo~aL' oTav 8e ets rtva a7ro/3Ae\//-co rcov (f>a-
(tkovtcov av 7rat8evjo-at dv9panrovs, eKTriirkriyp.ai Kai p.01
5 8oKet ets eKacrros avT&v o-kotxovvtl iravv dkkoKOTos elvai,
307 cos ye 7rpos ae Takr]9r) elpr)a9aL' coore otjk exco 6'7rcos
7rporpe7rco ro p.eLpaKLov eirl cpiAoo-ocpt'az\
2X2. 'X2 <ptAe Kptrcoi>, otjk dlo-9a otl ev iravTi eiTLTr]bev-

part 01 p.ez> (pavkoL 7roAAot Kat ox/bevbs dtot, 01 8e o-7ro?j8atoi
5 oAtyot Kat iravTos dtot; e7ret yvp.vao~TLKr) ov Kakbv boKel

crot etyat, Kat yjpr]p.aTLcrTLKr] Kat pr]TopLKr) Kat crrpar?7yia;
v
KP. Epotye 7rdzjrcos 87j7ro?j.
2X2. Tt ouv; ev eKaa-Tr) tovtoov rovs 7roAAo7JS 7rpos

b eKacrroy ro epyov ov KaTayekdo~Tovs opas;
KP. Nat pd rcV Ata, Kat pdAa dkr]9r) Ae'yets.
2X2. 'H ovy tovtov eveKa avTos re (pev^t] irdvTa ra

e7rtr7]8e7Jpara Kat rco ?3et otjk e7rtrpe\//eis;
5 KP. Otjkotjjj bUaLov ye, co 2coKpares.

2X2. M77 tolvvv 6 ye otj ô^ 7rotet, 00 Kptrcojj, dAA' edcras
Xatpety ro?)s e7rtr7?8e7jWras (pLkocrocpLav, etre ~^pt](TTOL elo~LV
etre TrovrjpoC, avrb to Ttpdypa ftao-avLcras KaAcos re Kat ev,

C eai> pey crot cpatVT/rat (pavkov ov, irdvT dvbpa diroTpeire,
p.r) p.6vov tovs Tjets* edy 8e cpatvr/rat oTojj otpat avro eyco
etVai, 9appG>v 8tcoKe Kat do-Ket, to keyop.evov br) tovto, avros
T Kal tcl 7rat8ta.
d7 SoKei} Sok(?v Par. 181 a3 iv\ iiri Aristides a6 ffrpo-

T7)yia T : ffTparriyeiaB bi t! epyov B T tcS' epywv Aristidis :
cod. M b3^B:4jT:<r/ Aristides

v> 1
npiiTAroPA2
st. i
ETAIP02 2X2KPATH2 p.309
ET. YloOev, 5> ~2d>KpaTes, (paivrj; i) br)\a br) otl cnrb a

KvvrjyecrCov tov irepl Ti]V 'AA/ci/3ia8ot> copav; koX p.r]v p.OL
Kal 7Tp<ar]v IbovTi KaXbs p.ev eqbaCvero avrjp ert, avi]p p.VTOi,
o> 2toKpares, cos y ev avTols ijpuv eiprjo-dai, Kal Trcaytovos
ijbi) VTT07TLp.TTkdp.eV0S. 5
2X2. Etra tC tovto; ov crv p.evTOL ~Op.i)pov eTraiveTrjs el,
bs <pr) yapLo-TaTr)v i](3r)v elvaL tov (rrpcoTOv) VTTi)vr)Tov, r)v b

vvv 'AhKLftLabris ~xl;
ET. Tt ovv tcl vvv; r) irap eKeCvov qbaCvr); Kal tt&s

TTpos cre 6 veavias 8taKeirat;
2X2. Ev, ep-OLye eboev, ov^ rJKLcrra be Kal Trj vvv r)p.epa' 5
Kat yap iro\Xa VTTep euoti elire fior)6G>v ep.oC, ml ovv Kal
dpTL cltt' eKeCvov epyop.aL. aToirov /ueVrot t'l ctol edeXco
elTrelv TrapovTOs yap eKeCvov, ovre Trpocrelyov tov vovv,
TTe\av6av6p.r)v re avTov 6ap.d.
ET. Kat tC av yeyovos etrj 7rept o~e kciklvov tovovtov C
Trpdyp.a; ov ydp bi]TTov tlvI koKXCovl Vtv\^s aAAw ev ye
Ti]be Trj 770'Aet.
2X2. Kat 7toAv ye.

ET. Tt <fifis; aar<S r) êvco; 5
2X2. EeVa).
a3 prius avijpW 6 aviip Athenaeus : aviip Bekker a 4 avro?s

fifiiv~\ Athenaeus
Vfiiv avrois b 1 tov~\ ri)v rov corr. Ven. 189
KpwTov add. Hirschig sec. schol. B (qui tamen rb irpwros ujtt^ttjv , ut
o' pro irpcvTov habuisse videatur) b7 fpxo/j-ai W :
&pxofj.at BT
;
3og c I1AAT12N02
ET. TIobaTT&;
212. 'A/38 rjpCTrj.
ET. Kat ot/rco koKos tis 6 eVos e8oeV crot elvai, coore
io tov KAetrtou vôs KaAAuoy crot (pavrjvai;
212. n<3s 8' otj /xeAAet, w /xaKapte, ro croc/jwraroi' koXXlov

qbaCvecrdai;
ET. 'AAA' 77 cro<pa> rtzn r/pty, a> 2a>Kpares, ei>r7jxa>i> 7rdpet;
d 212. 2ocpa>rdra> pez; ovv brjirov tS>v ye vvv, et <rot SoKet
o-ocpwraros eu>at Flpcordydpas.
ET. 12 rt Aeyets; ITpcoraydpas iTnbebr]p.r]Kev
212. TpiTrjv ye ?)8?] r)p,4pav.
5 ET. Kat dprt dpa eKeiVco crTjyyeyo^cbs rpcets;
3!0 212. ITdyu ye, 7roAAd /cat et7rcoi> Kat aKOTjcras.

ET. Tt ow ov 8tr7yr;cra) r/ptv Tr)v crvvovcrCav, et p:?/ cre
rt KcoAvet, Ka#eb'/xei>os ivravOC, iavacrrricras tov Tiaiba

tovtovC;
5 212. LTdvi; p.ei> OTjy Kat yapw ye etcropat, edz> aKovrjTt.
ET. Kal /xr)y Kat r/pets crot, edi> Ae'yr/9.
212. At7rAr/ ay etr/ 7/ âpts. dAA' otjz; aKouere.

Tr]s ydp irapX.6ovo-rfs vvktos TavT-qcrC, ert fiaOios opOpov,
'iTTTTOKp&Tris, 6 'A7roAAo8a>po7j uds ^dcrcoros 8e d5eA<po's, rr)y
b dvpav Trj fiaKTrjpCq iravv crcpobpa Kpove, Kal e7ret8r/ ai3rai
dz>e'a>fe rts, evcTus etcrco r/et e7retyd/jie7Jos, Kat rf/ cpcoyr/ p.e'ya
"
Ae'ycoz>, '"12 2a>Kpares," ecpr/, " iyprjyopas r/ Ka0eubi.s;
Kat eya> r7/i> (paivrjv yvovs avTov, " 'l7r7TOKpdrr/s," ecprjv,
5 ouroy //r/ rt vecarepov ayyeAAets; Ovoey y , ?/ 5 os,

<f 1 V /1 / > ff TT 1
* * \ / 9 fc / t V fc\
et ]u.r/ ayu0a ye. Ev az> Aeyots, t]V b eyar eort oe
rt, Kat tov VKa rr/ytKaSe dcptKou; " " ITpcoraydpas," ecpr/,
" #
r/Ket, crras 7rap e/xot. l\pw)v, <pr)v eya>- cru oe
c8 djSSTjpiTj? afiSripelTp BT WC 11 (To^toto'] aoty&Tepov

:
Heindorf e Ficino {quod sapientius est) a3 Kad(6/j.evos Laur.

Ixxxv. 6 Kadi6/xevos B T
: W
a 7 SiirKrj B 8t7r\T? T 8(tt\?7 : :
7' Sauppe a8 yap Didymus: om. a9 vlbs BTW

T W : t/cVos B
nPXlTArOPAS 3iob
o/>rt 7re7rvoat; N77 rovs Oeovs, ecpr?, cnrpas ye.

Kat a/ixa TTL\J/r]kacpricras tov crKLp.7robos eKaOeêro irapa toiis c
7ro'8as /aotj, Kat erTreir " 'EoTrepas 8^ra, //dAa ye 6\j/e acpL-
Kop.evos e OtWr/s. 6 ydp rot 7rats /ue 6 Sdrupos atrebpa'

Kal bijra p.ekko)V oot cppaeLV otl $icobip??i> avTov, vtto tlvos
akkov eirka66p.r]v. eirevbr] be rjkdov Kal bebeLTrvrjKOTes r)p.ev 5
Kal ep.ekkop.ev avairavecrdaL, tot p.01 abekcpos Aeyet otl
i]K(i HpioTayopas. kol ert p.ev eve\Lpr]cra ev6vs Trapa oe
teWt, e7retrd p.0L kiav iroppo) eboe tg>v vvkt5)V etvaL' e7ret8?/
8e Ta.yji.o-Ta p.e ex rov K07ro?j 6 inryos avrJKev, evdvs avao-ras d

ovtu) bevpo eiropev6p.r]v." Kat eyco yiyvcooKCOi' avrov rqv
avbpeiav Kal ti]v iTToir]crLV, " Tt ovv ctol" r)v 8' eyco,
" tovto; p.5)v tl oe d5tKet ITpcorayopaj; " Kat os yekacras,
" Nt) tovs deovs," ecprj, " a> 2coKpare?, ort ye p.6vos eort 5
1/ \ fc\ /N > * A \ \ \ \ \ A ' JJ *J 2 '
crocpos, ep.e be ov 7rotet. AAAa vat /ua Ata, ecprjv eyco,
" ay avrco StScps apyvpLov kol Trei6r\s eKelvov, troLr\cri nal

oe crocpov. Et yap, 77 0?, co Zeu Kat oeoi, ev
tovto) eiT/* cos our' du rcoy epcoy e7riAi7rotpi ovbev ovt rcoy e
cpiko)v dAA' a?3rd raCra Kat vvv ?/kco 7rapd oe, tra ?57rep
ep.ov bLakeydrjs avrco. eycb ydp ap.a pikv Kal vecarepos etpt,
ap.a 8e oiSe kcapaKa YIpo)Tay6pav 7rco7rore o?j8' aKr/Koa ovbiv
ert ydp 7rats ?/ ore t6 irpoTcpov e7re8?/p?7oe. dAAd ydp, co 5
2o)KpaTts, iravTes tov avbpa CTTaLVOvcrLV kox cpacrLV crocpo)-
raTov (TvaL kiyeLv akka tl ov /3a8tbpey 7rap' avrov, tva

evbov KaTakaj3o)p.ev ; KaraAvet b\ cbs eyco rJKovcra, irapa 311
KaAAta rco 'l7r7roi;tKou' dAA' tcop.er." Kat eycb et7roy
" Mr/iro), ayadi, eKetoe tcoper 7rpco yap eorty dAAd bevpo
eavacrT(ap.V ets rqv avkr)v, koX 7reptto'yres avrov Starpt-
yp-o)p.ev ecos hv cp&s yivryraL' etra tco/xe^. Kat ydp rd iroKka 5
C6 oSeA^bs Heindorf: aSe\</)6s BTW:

6 aSf\<f>bs Ven. 189 corr.
Coisl. d7
Kal irftdris iiteivov secl. Cobet e i ef?j B
W
:
<ot 1
toi T 65jB :|iBtW
U5 tjo 5 :i|idi vk a 3 yuljTrw
/tîrw c07066 : yuvjTro) BT
wyade corr. Coisl. : /iVj7r&> 76, 5 'yafle Hirschig fjrf]jireo 7', Sryade Cobet
:
(secl. mox iicuce 1u/j.tv) Iw/xtv T : lo/JLtv B

3iia IIAAT&NOS
ripcorayopas evbov 8iarpi/3ei, cotrre, ddppeL, KaTakrj\j/6p.eda
aVTOV, COS TO LKO$, VboV.
Mera raura avaa-rdvTes els ttjv avkrjv TrepLfjp.ev Kal eyco
b d7ro7retpcopei>os tov 'iTriroKpaTovs ttjs pcoprjs hiea-Koirovv avTov
Kal r)pu>T(ov, Elire pot, <pr]v eyco, co 'l7nroKpares, 7rapd
Flpcoraydpav vvv eirLyeLpels levai, dpyvpLov reAcoi> eKeivo)
p.LO-6ov virep creavTov, o>s 7rapd rtra d<pL^6p.evo$ koll tls
5 yevr}o-6p.evos; uxnrep av et eirevoeLS irapa tov oravTov dpco-

vvp.ov ekdoov 'IirTroKpaTr) rbv KS>ov, tov t&v 'Ao-/cArj7rta8coy,
dpyvpLov Teketv ij7rep aavTov p,Lo~6bv eKeivco, et t'ls cre rjpero'

" Et7re /xot, p.ekkeLS Tekeiv, co 'iTTTroVpares,
c
l7r7roKparet
c p.Lcr6bv o)$ tlvl ovtl; " dv direKpivoi;
rt
Et7roz> av, e<prj,
otl cos tarpcp. .*'

'Q.s tls yevr)o-6p.evos ; "
l
H$ larpos, ecprj.
Et 8e 7rapa noAu/cAetroy tov 'Apyetoy r) ei8taz> tov 'A0ti-
vaXov eirevoeLS d<pLK6p.evos p.LO~6bv virep oravTov rekelv e/cet-
5 vois, et rts cre rjpero' " TeAety tovto to dpyvpLOV cos tlvl
ovtl ev vS> eêLS rioAu/cAetrcp re /cat 4>etoia; " rl av dire-
/cptVco;
Et7roy dv cos ayaXp.aroTrotots'. '* '12?
rts be yevqcro-

p.evo$ avTos; " .Arjkov ort dyakp.aTOTroLos. Etev, r)v 8' eyco*
d Trapa 8e br) YIpoiTayopav vvv d<\>LKop.evoL eyco re Kat av
dpyvpLov eKeivu* p.Lcrdbv erotpot ecr6p.eda rekelv VTrep aov,
av p.ev e^LKvrjraL tcl r)p.erepa yjpr)p.aTa koX tovtols Trei6oip.ev
avTov, et be p.r\, kol tcl t5>v <j>ikoiv TrpocravakicrKOVTes. el
5 ovv tls r)p.ds irepl Tavra ovtco crcpobpa o-Trovbd(pvTa$ epoLTO'

" Et7re p:ot, u> 2coKpares re Kat *l7r7roKpare?, cbs t'lvl ovtl
rco UpoiTayopq, ev v5> eêre \pr)p.aTa Tekelv; " Ti av avr<2
e diroKpLvaip.e6a; t'l 6vop,a dkko ye keyop.evov irepl Ilpco-
Tayopov aKOVop.ev; &o-Trep irepl QeLbiov dyakp.aTOTroLov kol

irepl 'Op.r)pov TroLrrrrp), tl tolovtov irepl Ylpoyrayopov aKovo-
p.ev; 'SiO<pL<TTr)v br) tol 6vop.d(pvo-i ye, 3) 2a)KpaT$, tov
5 dvbpa elvaL, ecprj.
'12? <ro<pL<JTr) dpa ep\6p.e6a rekovvres tcl
e I airoKpival/xtda W : airfKpivai/xeda BT ye secl. Cobet e3 rl

. . . aKovo/xev secl. Cobet aKovofiev corr. Coisl. : riKovofj.ev BT W
e5 (Tyai, e<^r;] eTev, ecpyv Cobet Socrati tribuens
;
nPHTATOPAS 3 ne
\prpxaTa;
MdAtcrra.
Et ovv kol tovto tls cre 7rpocê'polro ,
" Avtos 8e 87) <as tls yvi]aop.Vos epxj/ Ttapa tov Ilpcora- 3 12
yopav; "
Kat bs etirtv ZpvOpiaaas 7/877 yap VTTcpaLVV tl
///xepas, coore Karacpavrj avTov ytvio-Bai Et p.iv tl rots
p.irpocr0V olkV, bijkov otl o-ocbLorrjs yvr]o~6piVos. 2t/ 8e,
r)v 8' eyco, npbs 6zu>v, ovk av aloryyvoLo ets tovs "Kkkrjvas 5
aavTov Ttapiyav; tov Ata,Nt/ ScoKpares, et7rep
o-o-pLorrjv
ye a biavoovp.aL \pr) Ae'yetz\

'AAA' dpa,
5>
>
e
l7T7ro'Kpares, p.r)
ov TOLavrrjv {mokap.j3dvLS crov tt)v irapa npcorayopou p.d-

6i]olv 0~o-6aL, dAA' otaTrep 77 irapd tov ypap.p.aTLo~Tov eyivero b
Kat KL0apLorov Kal 7rat8orpt/3oi;; tovtcov yap o~v eKacrr7/i/
ovk e7rt Ttyvr] epacês, cos br)p.LOVpybs o~6p.VOS, dAA' e7rt
7rat8eia, cos tov IbLcoTrjv Kal tov ik^vdepov 7rpe'7ret. Yldvv

p.v ovv p.01 boKtl, ecpT/, TOLavTi) p.dkkov etrat 77 Trapa 5
TTpcorayopoJj p.ddr)o--s.
8'
Olcrda ovv pe'AAet? vvv 7rparret^, i) o~ kav6dvi; r)v
eyco. Tov 7re'pt;

"Ort /xe'AAet? rr)v \j/vxr)v rr)v aavTOv irapa-
o-ycLV 0epa7reCcrai avbpi, cos <pj]s, o-ocpLo-Tjj' otl 8e' ttotc 6 crocpt- C
cm/s ko-TLV, 0avp.d(pLpC av et oto~0a. Katroi et tovt dyvotls,
oi)b orco 7rapa8t8cos Tr)v \f/V)(r]v olo~6a, ovt et dyadio ovt et
kokco 1-pdyp.aTL. Otpai y', (pr], et8eVat. Ae'ye 87/, rt r)yij

iivaL tov o~ocpLO-Tr]V
'Eyco pAv, r) 8' os, cocr7rep Tovvop.a Ae'yet, 5
Oiikow, 8'
tovtov etuat tov t&v o-ocpcav e7rtcrr7/poya. r)v
eyco, tovto p,ev eêort Ae'yeti> Kat 7rept (fcoypdcpcov Kat 7repi
tkt6v(ov, otl ovtol etcrty ot rcov aocpcav kim LO~Tr]p.ovS' dAA'
et rtj ipoLTo rjpas, " Tco^ rt o~ocpS>v etcrty 01 (fcoypdcpot e7rt- d
crn/poyes," tLitoLp.V dv ttov avTco otl rcoy 7rpos TT/y aTxepya-
o~iav Tr)v t&v (Ikovcov, Kal raAAa ovrcos. et 8e rts eKeiVo
ZpOLTO, " 'O 8e 0~0(pLO-Tr]S T&V TL 0~OCpG>V 0~TLV;" TL OLV
&6 ffavrbv scr. recc. : avrbv BT W a8 viro\aixfidvtts B :
viro\a/j.lidvr)s T t> I otairtp rj irapa T W : ola letpl B : ota

irapa Hermann b8 irapaax^v] irap4x~iv Cobet C 6 uo-
<pS>v T : ffo<ptffrS>v B (sed ttrrerasum) d 4 ffo<pG>v~\ <ro<pwv 4*1-
ffTr)/LLwv ci. Heusde
PLATO, VOL. III. 13
3i2d nAATflNOS
5 diroKptvoipeda avTu>; voias epyaarias TTtordTt]s; Ti dv
eXTrotptev avrov elvat, co SvKpares, r) e7riordrriiv tov Trotrjo-at
betvbv keyetv; 'Icrcos' av, rjv 8' eyco, dkt]drj keyotp.ev, ov

ptevrot tKavS>s ye* ep(tiTt]cre(os yap ext 17 diroKpto-ts fjpuv 8eirai,
7repi otov 6 o-o(pto-Tr)s betvbv -rrotel keyetv cocnrep 6 Ki0a-
e pto-rqs betvbv brjirov 7roiei Ae'yeii> 7repi ovirep Kal cTriorrip.ova,
irepX Ktdapicretos- r) ydp; Nai.Eiey 6 Se 8r) o-ocptarTrjs
irepX rivos betvbv irotel Aijkov

keyetv; 6Y1 7repi ovirep Kal
eirto-TacrOat; Eikos ye. ri 877 eoru tovto rrepl ov avTos re
5 irto-Trjp.ttiv io-Ttv 6 crocpicrrr)? Kal tov p.a6rjTr)v iroteX; Mct
Ai', ecprr, orWri eyut o-ot keyetv.
313 Kai eyco ei7roiv p.Ta tovto' Ti ovv; oto-Oa eis 010V ru>a
Ktvbvvov epx?? inrodrjo~(ov Tr\v y\fv\r]v; rj ei ptev to oS>p.a
eTTtTpeiretv cre e8ei rco btaKtvbvvevovra i) xprjo-Tov avrb
yeveo-dat r? irovr]p6v, 7roAAd av -
7repiecrKe\// co eir' eTrtTpeTrreov
5 eire ov, ml eis o-vp.f-)ovkr]v tovs re (pikovs av TrapeKakets

Kat tovs otKeiovs o-KOTrovptevos r)p.epas o-v\vds' b 8e 7repi
7rAeioôs rov crcoparo? 77y?7, ri]v y\rvyj]V, koI ev co 7rcW eoriy
tcl o-a r] ev 7] kokco? irpaTTetv, \pr)o-Tov r) irovqpov avrov
yevoptevov, Trept be tovtov ovre rco 7rarpi ovre rco dbekcpS
b eTreKotvdo-to ovre r)p.S>v tS>v eraipcov ovbevi, etT eirtTpeiTTeov
etTe Kal ov rco d(ptKop.ev(o tovtu> cfeVco rr)v o-rjv y\rvyr)v, dAA'
eo~TTepas aKovaas, cos cprjs, opdptos tjkcov 7repi p.ev rot/rou
ovbiva Ao'yoi> ov8e o-vp./3ovkr]v Trotfj, etre yjpr] CTTtTperretv
5 o-avrbv avT& eire p.i], Totp.os 8' ei dvakto-Ketv rd re craurou

Kai Ta tS>v (piktov xPVIJiaTa > & s V^V bteyvtcKcbs ori 7rd^rco?
ovvecrTeov ITpcoraydpa, bv ovre ytyvtao-Kets, cos cp?js, ovre
c bteikeât ovbeTratiroTe, o~o(pto-Tr]v 8' crôpdêis, roi 8e o-oqjt-
d.5 a-roKpivaifMfda Bekker d6 eiVot/tej'] (et) yirojê' Schanz

(et mox om. t) cum B T) ~) W : om. BT toC W t : rov rb BT
d8 fifvroi T : /Afvroi ye B ^ atc^Kpicns T ^ airoKpiatus B
W
:
G 1 Si^7rou T : S' elf 7tou B icaJ eiriffTiifj.ova ... 6 3 ovirep T :
om. B e3 (?)) StjAoj Heindorf Socrati tribuens 64 eVi-

-TTuaQai Stahl : eVio-Tara BTW a3T(jjT:ToB a5 7rape-
KaKets T : 7rapacaAers B b3 opBpios corr. Coisl. : opBpiov BT :
opflios W C I 5(ei\e{a< T W : SiÂeâi B

npuTAropAs 313C
cttijv drt ttot o~tlv cpatrr/ ayvowv, (S pe'AAets aravTov e7rtrpe'-
7ret;j; Kat ds aKovcras, "EoiKtv, ecpr/, co ScoKpares, e cotj.
o~v Aeyets. *Ap' orjV, co 'l7T7ro'Kpares, 6 crocptcrrrjs rrjyxaî

a>y ep,7ropo's rts */ Kd7rrjAos rwr aytoyCfMov, dcp' >v ^v\h 5
rpe'c/Jerat; cpatVerat ydp epotye rotorjrds rts. Tpe'<perat 8e,
co ScoKpares, ^rvx'1 r^* Maflrjp.acrii' 8rj7rou, ?]y 8' eyco. Kat

o7rcos ye /xt/, co eratpe, 6 o-ocptcrrrjs kiraivG>v a 7ra)Aet e<fa-
Trar^/o-r/ r/pds, cocr7rep 01 7rept r?/y rorj crcoparos rpocprjy, 6
ep7ropos re Kat Ka7rrjAos. Kat yap orjrot 7ro?j cotj dyorjcrt/j d
d.ycoytp.a)7J orjre arjrot tcracrti; ort yj>r\crTov r/ Trovrjpbv 7rept rd
crcopa, tTraivovo-iv 8e 7rciyra 7ra)AorjVres, orjre 01 b>vovp.evoL
7rap' arjrcoiJ, eai> prj rts rrjxrj yvp.vao-TLKOs rj tarpos cStj.
ovra) de Kat ot ra p.a6i]p.ara 7reptayoyres Kard ras TrdAets 5
Kat 7rcoAorjVres Kat Ka7rrjAerj07Jres rco det ^TnOvfxovvTL eiraL-

vovo-iv fxev iravra a 7ra)Aor3crii>, rdxa 8' di> rtres, co dptcrre,
Kat tovtu>v dyTJOOteTJ coi> 7ra)Ao?jcri7J ort yj>r)o-Tov r/ Trovrjpov
7rpos r7j/j y\rvyj}V cos 8' arjrcos Kat 01 <avovp.VOL 7rap' avT<av, e
edy pr/ rts r^x?/ 'Ttpt TT V ^v\i]v av tarptKos coy^- et
pejj orjjj crrj rrjyxdijeis e7ricrrrjp,a)7J tovtwv ti yj>i)a~Tov koX

TTovrjpov, ao-qjaX.es crot cojjetcrflai p.a6i)p.aTa koX irapa. ITpco-
rayopov Kal 7rap' dAAorj drorjorjv et 8e pr/, dpa, co p.aK&pi(, 5

pr/ 7rept rots cptArdrots Krj/3erjrjs re Kat Kty8werjr/s. Kat yap 314
5r/ Kat 7roArj pet^coij kitjcWo? eV rr/ rcoy p.a6r)p.a.TU>v aW/ r/
eij rr/ rcoij crtrtcoy. crtrta per yap Kat ttoto. Trpi.ap.tvov Trapa
tov Ka7rr/Aou Kat ip.TTopov e^toTLv iv dAAots dyyetots a7ro-
cpepeLV, Kal irplv 8e'âcrc9at avra ets rd acopa 7ridi>ra r) 5
qbayovTa, Kara6ip.vov otKacê eêcrrti' crrjpôrjAerjcracrcât,
C2 y Cobet
4-Kirp4irtiv secl. C 7 /uafl^/xafft T /xdOijfftv B :
W
. . . :
fiaO^fftL C 8 âiraT^trei Bekker d 1 irou T iroi B :
d 2 TtpJ] irpoy Hirschig irepl to ffwfia secl. Cobet e 1 irpos ri]V

îvxhv secl. Cobet e3 &>v post iirtffr^fiuv add. Heindorf t/ . . .
novi)p6v secl. Cobet a 1 T /cal Kif Suveurjs secl. Cobet a 3 irapa

toO B irapa tou T
: irapa i/xif6pou secl. Hirschig
. . Kairl)\ov tcal
. :
ifiir6pov secl. Hermann (qui ap tou) : al ifnir6pov secl. Sauppe

as vt6vra % <pay6vra secl. Cobet a6 |eo-T(' secl. Cobet
1S*
3Ha nAATXlNOS
irapaKakioavTa rbv TraiovTa, otl re eSeoreW rj ttotov nal
.otl fxrj, Kal ottooov koX 07rore' coore ev rfj oovfj ov p.4yas 6
b Kivbvvos. pa6r)para b\ ovk Hcttlv V dAAco dyyetco d7rei>ey-
khv, dAA' avdyKr) KaradtvTa tt)v TLp.r)v to p.ddr)p.a kv avrf}

Trj tyvxfj Aa/3oVra Kal p.a66vra dirUvai rj /3e/3AaupeVoy 57
cocpeAripeVov. raura ovv a-KOir(o[xeda Kal perci t&v 7rpecr/3t>-
5 ripoov r)p.S>v r)p.LS yap ert vioi coore tooovtov irpdyp.a

8teAe'o-#ai. vvv p.VTOL, cocr7rep o)pp.i)oap.V, tcouev Kal aKov-
.1 o-a)p.ev tov dvbpos, e7retra aKovoavTS kol akkois dvaKoi-

va)o~(tip.e6a' kol ydp ov p.6vos UpooTayopas avToOt Zo-tiv,
C dAAa Kal 'IirTrias 6 'HAetos otpat 5e Kat IIpobiKOv tov

Keiov Kat aAAot 7roAAot Kat o-ocpot.
A6av r)plv ravra e7ôpeJJo'pec9a iTLbr) 8e eV rco Trpodvpoj
y(vop.0a, eiTLo-TdvTfs irepC tlvos koyov 8teAeyo'/uec1a, bs r)pxv
5 mra Tr)v bbbv Vtt0V tv ovv p.r) drekr)s yivovro, dkka
bLaiTpavdp.evoL ovtojs 0-ioLp.V, ordvTS V rco TTpo&vpoj
8teAeyo'pec9a ecos o~vvoop.okoyrio-ap.iv dAA?/Aots. 80/cet ovv

MOt, 6 OvpOipOS, (VVOVXOS TLS, KOTr)K0VV r)p.5)V, KLvbvVVL 8e
d 8ta to 7Tkrj6os t5)V o-ocptorcov dxêcrflai roty cpotrcocrty ets Tr)v
OLKiav TTLbr) yovv Kpovarap.V rr)v 6vpav, dvoiâs Kal lbd>v
"v
r)pjds, Ea,"ecpr7,"o-ocpicrrai tlvS' ov oypkr) avrco* " Kaidpa
dpqbolv tolv yjepolv rr)v 6vpav irdvv Trpo6vp.o)s cos olos Tr)v lirr)-
5 pa^V. Kal r)p.ls 7rdAtv Kpovop.V, koj. 09 eyKeKAr/peVrrs Trjs

"v " ovk
6vpas aTTOKpLv6p.Vos et7rer, l dv6po)TTOL," ecpry, aKi]-
Koare ort ov o-ôkr) avrco; " " 'AAA' coyacê'," <pr)v eyco, " ovt
irapd KaAAtar i)Kop.V ovt o"Ocptcrrat o-p.V. dkkd ddppL'
e Upo)Tay6pav ydp tol bop.VOL ibelv rjkdop.V etcrdyyetAoy
ovv." p.6yis ovv ttot r)p.lv avdpooTTOs dvOi^v rr)v 6vpav.
b3 ko2 fia06vTa secl. Deuschle b6 Kal aKov<Tunev] aKov<r6fi(vot

ci. Cobet b7 iAAots] rots &\\ois Ast C 2 Keiov (sic) : W
10 B kiov T C 6 arivTts T W Io~t6.vt*s B iirio-TavTts
W
: : :
Schanz eo-TUTt s Cobet d 4 toIv B to.7v T d5 e'7/ce-

W
: :
K\r)fievT]s Bekker ^yKeK^fifievrfs B iyKtK\eiffixivr\s T e 1 toi

W
: :
scr. recc. : BTW e 2 avdpwiros Bekker : &v6pwiros BT :
t> &v0pa>vos Ven. 189 et corr. Coisl.

nPIlTArOPAS 3He
'E7ret8j/ 8e d<rr)\6op.ev , KareAd/3o/xej> Up(oTay6pav iv rw
Trpo<TT(p(p TTcpnraTovvTa, (i)s 8' avrG) o-vp.irfpwna.Tovv eK pxv
tov eirl Oarepa KaAAtas 6 'Ittttovlkov nal 6 dbe/\<fios avrov >
6 6pLop.-qTpi.os, Yldpakos 6 TlepLKktovs, Kat Xapp.Cbr]s 6 Fkav- 3 X 5

k(j)vos, K 8e tov eirl d&Tcpa 6 ereooy tG>v TlepiKkzovs
Bdv6nrTTos, Kal ^LXLTnrCbris 6 Lkop.f)/\ov Kal 'AvTCp-oipos 6
Mevbaios, ocnrep evboKLp.L /xdAtora tG>v Ylpo)Tayopov p.adrj-
tG>v kol (tt\ T)(yri p.av6dvL, ws <ro<fiL<rTr)s <r6p.evos. tovtcov 5
8e ot ottl<t6(V t)koKov6ovv (TraKOVovTes tG>v Aeyo/xe'wor t6

p.ev tto/\v eVot <paCvovTO os dyet e eKaorcoy t<2v 7ro'Aecoi>
6 Ylpa>Tayopas, 81' <av 8tee'pxeTat, ktjAw^ tjj <fi<avf\ tocnrep
'Op<peus, ol 8e Kard ttjv <fio)vr)v tirovraL KKr)Xr)p.VOL b

rjcrav 8e' tlvcs Kat t&v eiTLyu>pmv (v tG> xPV' tovtov tov
yppov /udAiora Zyoiye ibo)v r)cr6r)V, <as KakG>s r)vXa(3ovvTO
p.r]biTTOTe ip.TTobo)V iv tG> irpocrdzv (IvaL YlpoiTayopov, dAA'
e7ret8?/ airos dva<TTpi<fioL k<xl ol /xer' eKeCvov, eu 7rco? Kat ev 5
Kocrp.0} TTpLTyC(pvTo ovtol ol eTTT/KOot <(v6ev Kat evdev,

k<xl iv kukAco 7repttoVre? det ets to 6ttlo~6zv Ka6C<rTavTo
KaAAtcrra.
Tov 8e /xer' eicrev6r)<Ta, <-<pr) "Opr/pos, 'iTTTrtW tov
'HAetor, Ka6f)p.evov eV rco KaT dvTLKpv 7rpoo-rcpco ev 6povoi' C
7rept avTov 8' Ka6t)VTo Zttl /3d6po)v 'Epvt/xaxdV re 6
'AKovuerou Kat fratSpo? 6 MvppijWcnos Kat "Avbpo)v 6
'AvbpoTMVos Ka\ tG>v evo)v 7roAtrat re atiroC Kal aAAot

ru>e's. i<paCvovTO 8e 7repi <fiv<reo)S re Kat rcoi; p:erecopcoi> 5
d<TTpovop.LK.a aTTa Stepcoray roi> '\TnrCav, 6 8' er 6p6vo> Ka6f)-
p.vos kKacrTOLS ovtG)V bL^KfiLViv koX 8 teêi ra ipO)TO)p.Va.
a I irapaAos Bt T: a 2 eToTpos B T
irdpaWos (sed 6 supra W
a? W) a 4 Heindorf iiSo/ctyue B T
eiiSoKjûsr fiadi)Tobv W
W
:
T fiadfifiiruv B
: a 6 ot Laur. lxxxv. 6 om. : BTW
a 7 ^{ /cao-Tcof T W
efa/too-Teo' B : ruv B om. T b 4 lp :
T(j3 irp6<rQfv secl. Cobet irp6o-Qtv B <EfjLirpoo-9ev T b 9 tynj

:
"Ofiripos secl. Schleiermacher c 4 di/SpoT^roy T apio-rtwvos B :
(sed, v. Gorg. 487 c) c6 ao-rpovo/xiKa secl. Schanz 0poV<jj> &

KaOfotvos secl. Herwerden c 7 al Siefj/ei secl. Cobet

315C nAAT12N02
Kat piev 8r/ kclI Tdvrakov ye elo-elbov e7reSr//uei
d yap dpa ko.1 YIp6bi.KO$ 6 Kelos rjv be ev olKr]p.arC tlvl, a)
Ttpb tov piev a>s ra/Aieia> e\prJTO 'Ittttovlkos, vvv be vtto tov
TrXrjdovs t&v KaTa\v6vT(ov 6 KaAAtas Kat tovto eKKevcocras
eVOLS KaTaKvCTLV TTTToCr]KV. 6 p.V OVV HpobLKOS TL KaT -
5 KLTO, eyKKa\vp.p.VOS V K(obCoLS TLCTLV KOL CTT p(i>p.aO~ LV Kal
p.dKa ttoWols, cos ecpaCvero' irapeKadrjvTO be avrai eTU rats

TrX-qcrCov kAiWis YlavcravCas re 6 Zk Kepap.eoov Kal p.Ta
YlavcravCov veov tl ert p.LpaKLOV, a>s piev eyayxai KaAoV re
e Kayadbv Tt]v qbvcrLV, Tr)v 8' ovv Ibeav irdvv koKos. eboa
aKovcraL 6vop.a aiiTo} elvaL 'Aya0a>ra, Kat ovk av 6avp.doLp.L
et 7rat8iKa ITauo-aytou rvyydveL &v. tovto t rjv to ixeLpd-
klov, Kal ra> 'ASet/xarra) apicpoTepoo, 6 re Kr/7rt8os Kat 6
5 AeuKoAo(Tjt8ou, Kat aAAot tlvcs ecpaCvovro' irepl be &v 8teAe-
yovTo ovk ebvvdp.r]v eyooye p.a6elv eoodev, mCirep KiTrapoos
\(OV aKOVLV TOV YIpobCKOV irdcrcrOCpOS ydp p.OL b0KL avi]p
316 etrat Kat 0etos dKKa 8ta tijv (3apvTr]Ta Trjs cpoovrjs (3op.(3os
tls iv rai olKr]p.aTL yLyvop.evos ao-acpr) eiroCeL tcl Keyop.eva.
Kat r)p.LS p.ev aprL elcreKrjKvdepLev, KaroTTLV be r)p.G>v
TTLcrr)XOov 'AAKt/3ta8r?? re 6 KaAo's, a>s (pf]S o~v Kat eyoo
5 7TC6op.aL, Kat Kptrtas 6 KaAAaiaxporj.

'H/xets ovv a)S eta-rjAô/xev, frt O7111K0' arra bLaTpC\fravres
Kat raOra bLa6eao dp.evoi Trpocrfjp.V irpbs tov YlpooTayopav,
m
b Kat eya> eiTroiv *H ITpairayopa, 7rpos oe' rot r)X6op.v eya> re
Kat 'l7r7roKparr7s ovros.

TloTepov, ecpr], p.6v(o fiov\6p.evoL bLaKe\6r)vaL r) Kal juera
tG>v dXX(ov;
l
5 H//tz; p.ev, r)v 8' eyw, oi8ev bLacpepeL' aKOVcras be ov
eveKa i]k6op,ev, avrbs crKexjrai.
c8 utreTSov W tt'<rib'ot> BT îrjSrj/Uf? Heindorf d1 &pa

W W
:
Ka\
2
: pa Kal B : 4po T /cetos kios B : kTos T d. 2 ws
W
:
secl. Dobree e 1 KaXhs T koKws B e3 toDto' t' : toCt'

W
:
BT e7 avijp Bekker : & avijp W : avijp BT a4 ts T :
om. B b 1 Tot scr. recc. : tiBTW b3 /xovcf] /novoi /x6v(p

Cobet
nP&TATOPAS 3 i6b
Ti ovv bij kaTLV, ecrjr/, ov eVe/ca r//cere;
'lifnoKpaTt]^ 6'8e eortp p.kv t&v (iTL\topitov, Âtrokkobojpov

vos, oiklcls /xeyciArjs re kcll vbaip.ovos, avrbs 8e rr)v <pvaLV
OO/Cet (VapLLkkoS CLVaL TOLS TjkLKLtoTaLS. e7Tl0rjUeU> b pLOL IO
oo/cet eAAo'ytuos' ytviaOaL iv rrj 7ro'Aet, tovto be oterat ol C

//.aAioV a{v) yevtadaL, et crol avyyivovro' Tavr ovv i)br) av
o/coVet, TTOTepov 7reot avrtov p.6vos otet btlv 8taAe'yea#at TTpOS
p.6vovs, t/ /xer' aXktov.

'Opdtos, icprj, Trpop.r)0fi, a> 2co/cpares, xnrep (p.ov. (vov 5
yap avbpa Kal loVra ets irokeLS p.tydkas, Kal iv TavraLS
TTiiQovra t&v veoov tovs /3eArtororjs a7roAei7ro;;ras' Tas t&v
akktov avvovaias, /cat ot/cetcou /cat odvtitov, Kal irpaf3vTp(ov
Kal vctoTepoov, eawco avvcLvaL tos /3eArious (aop.(vovs ota

ti]v havrov avvovaiav, XPV (vkafieiaOai tov ravra irpaT- d
TovTa' ov yap o-ut/cpot ircpl avTa cpOovoL re yiyvovraL /cat
ctAAat bvap.(vtLai re /cat e7rt/3orjAat. eyco Se tt)v ao(pLaTLKr]V
T(yvr)v (pr)pX p.kv eTuai 7raAatcirj, tovs 8e MeraxeiptbMeVorjs

avTi]V ratv iraXaLcov dvbpG>v, <pofiovp.(vovs to (irayjjes avrfjs, 5
Trp6ayr\po. iroLtiaQaL /cat irpoKakviTTtaOaL, tovs p*v TToir/aiv,

olov "Op.r]p6v re /cat 'HcrioSor /cat ^Lp.tovibr)i>, tovs be av
Tekerds re /cat xpr)ap.tobias, tovs ap.<pi re *Op<p(a koX Mov-
aaiov (viovs b( TLvas f]aOr)p.aL /cat yvp.vaaTLKr\v, oXov "\kkos
re 6 Tapavrlvos Kal 6 vvv ert tov oibtvbs rJTTtov ctoc/hott/s io
'tlpobiKos 6 SrjkvpLftpLavos, to b\ dpyaiov Meyapevs- p.ov- e

aLKi]v 5e 'Aya#o/cAr/s re 6 Tj/xereoos TTp6ayr)p.a e7rotT70-o.ro,
p.(yas <bv o-oc/hott/s, /cat EfDôxAetSrjs 6 Ketos /cat aAAot 7roA-

Aot. ovrot 7rai>re9, ooairep kiyto, (pofir)0(vTts tov <p66vov rats
re'xyats TavraLS TrapaTTtTaap.aaLV k\pr)aavTo. eyco be tovtols 5
uTraaLV /cara tovto etrat ou avp.(p(pop.aL' r)yovp.ai ydp avrovs 317
C 2 fj.a\ta-T hv Hirschig (fxdKto-ra av Stephanus) fia\i(rra B T : W

C 6 Kal I6vra B T W
Kari6vra in marg. T
: C 7 aTro\tlirovras~\
airo\iir6vras Themistius (cf. Apol. 20 a, 1 Theag. 128 a, 5) d6 irp6-
o-\Tiixa irotti<rOai Kal secl. Herwerden Kal irpoKa\virrtffOat secl.
Cobet e3 Ktios W : kios B : k7os T a i arct] ri ara Ast
:
3i7 a ITAATilNOS
ov tl bKmpaâarOat, o ij3ovkr)6r)o-av ov ydp ka6t.LV t&v
avdp<tiTTU)v tovs bvvap-tvovs ev Tals tt6A.o-i TrpaTTtiv, cavTrep
pCNft Tavr (o-tlv Ta TTpoo-\r)p.aTa' eVet ot ye irokkol 6>s
5 7ros et7reiV ovbcv alo~6avovTai, dAA' arr av ovtol biayyik-
kcocri, ravra vp.vovcrLV to ovv atr obLbpdcrKOvra p.r) bvvaadat.
airobpavai, akka Karacpavrj elvai, irokkr) p.copia Kal tov kiri-
b \iipt]p.aTos, Kal irokv bvcrpLCvecrTepovs irapzyeo~6ai avdyKr)
tovs dvdpcoTTOvs' fjyovvTai. yap tov tolovtov TTpbs rois aWois
Kai iravovpyov etvat. eyco ovv tovtcov rr)v ivavriav airacrav
obbv ikr)kv6a, kol 6p.okoyS> re crocpLcrTrjs etVat kol 7ratoevetv
5 av6pd>TT0vs, Kal evkaficiav ravrijy dlp.ai /3eArtco iKtivrjs etvat,
to 6juoAoyeii> p.dkkov rj zâpvov eirat* Kai dAAas 7rpos rairnj
eo-Kepjuat, coore, crvv 0e<3 elirtlv, p.r)b(V bcivbv irdo-xtiv bia
C to 6px>koydv crocpio-T-qs eTvai. Katrot irokkd ye frr) rjbr) etjut
iv Tjj Texvrr xal yap Kal ra crvpLiravTa 7rokkd p.oi icrTLV

ov8eyos otov ov irdvTcov av vp.5>v Kad' rjkLKtav iraTr)p eir)v
coare TTokv p.oi rjbio-Tov ioriv, et rt fiovkeo-dc, 7repi tovtcov
5 d7rdz>rcoz> ivavTiov tcov c-vbov ovtcov tov koyov Troieicr6ai.
Kai eyco v7rco7rreucra yap fiovkcicrdat avrbv rco re IlpooiKco

Kat rco 'Ittttlci ivbeiacrdaL Kal KakkcoTricracrdaL otl epaarai
d avTov dcptypeVot elpLtv Tt ovv, f-cprjv iyco, ov kol Hpo-
bLKov Kal 'liTTTLav eKaAeVap.ez; Kai tovs /uer' ovtcov, 'iva
iiraKovo-cocTLV r)p.cov;
Yldvv [AV ovv, f-cprj 6 YJpcoTayopas.
5 BouAecr0e ovv, 6 Kakkias ecprj, crvvibpLOV KaTacrK(vdcrcop.ev,

tva Kade6p,zvoL bLakiyqcrdt;
ESoVei \pr\vaL' acrp,avoL be TrdvTes r)p,ds, cas aKovo-6p,(voL
avbpcav crocpG>v, kcu ovtol re dvTLkaj36p.evoL tu>v (3ddpa)v

Kat tQ>v Kkivcov KaTcrKvdop.V Trapd rco 'iTnriq et ydp
a6 rb scr. Ven. 184 : rbv BT W a 7 voWij /xcopia B iroWrj
TW
:
/jLwpiq c 1 tlfii TW : el fii) B 03 irdvrwv secl. Cobet

C4 rfnTW: elre B d.i eltiixtv BT d6 icaOe&nevoi T
Ka0i(6ixevoi B d8 tj del. corr. Coisl. : fort. r6re Kral d9 t^
liriria B : rbv iiciriav T
riP12TArOPA2 3i7d
TTpovTTTJpxt rd fiddpa ev be rorjrco KaAAta? re Kat 'AAki- io

/3td8rjs rjKerrjv dyovre tov TlpobiKOv, avacrTricravTes e/c tt)s e
Kkivr)S, Kal tovs p.erd tov YlpobUov.
'E7ret be 7rdvres o~vveKade(fip.e6a, 6 WputTayopas, NrjV 87)
di>, ec/Jrr, Ae'yotj, co ScoKpares, eireiSr) xal ot8e rrapeicnv, 7rept
cSr oAiyoy irpoTepov p.veiav eTroiov 7rpds eue V7rep tov 5
yeayicrKOU.
Kat eyco ei7roy ort *H avrr] uot apxv ecmv, co TlpooTayopa, 318
rJTrep dprt, irep\ 8>v dcptKourji/. 'iTnroKpdrqs yap obe Tvy\dvei.
ev eTTi6vp.iq oov rijs arrjs crvvovcrias' oti ovv avrco aTTO^rjcreTai,
edv croi ovvr), r)beo)s &v cprjcn Trvdeo~6at,. toctovtos 6 ye
rjp^Tepos Adyos. 5
'TTrokafiojv ovv 6 Ylpoorayopas eXirev *i2 veavicrKe, ecrrat
Toivvv crot, edv euot crvvfjs, 77 av r)p.epq euot o-vyyevrj, dirievai.
ot/ca8e /3eAriozn yeyovon, koI ev Trj vcrTepaiq ravrd ravra'

Kal eKacrTrjs r)p.epas ael eru. to /3e'Artov e7ri8i8dvat.
Kat eyco aKovcras eTirov *i2 npcoraydpa, rouro p.ev ovbev b
0avp.acrTov Ae'yet?, dAAd eiKo's, e7ret Kar cru, Kaiirep rr?At-
Korjros cov Kat ourcoj crocpos, et rts ae 8t8deiev 6 p.r) rrjy-
Xaôts eTTtcrra/xeyos, /3eArtW dv yevoio. dAAct U7/ ourcos,

dAA' u>o"nep av et avrt/ca udAa uera/3aAcbi/ T77V eiri.6vp.iav 5
'l7T7roKpdrrTs o8e eTTi6vp.rjcrei.ev rrjs crvvovcrias tovtov tov
veavio-Kov tov vvv vecocrri e7r t8r/uowros, Zeui7T7rorj rou
'HpaKAecorou, Kat d<piKop.evos 7rap' avrov, tocriTep irapd cre
vvv, aKovo-eiev airov raurd Tavra aTrep crov, drt eKacrrrjs C

rjpepas crvvutv aurco /3eArtcoy ecrrai Kat e7rt8cocrei, et avrov
eiravepoiTO' " Tt 8r/ c/jtjs /3eAr^co ecreardat. ko.1 els rt e7rt8co-
creti'; ' et7rot du arjrco 6 Zerji7r7ros ort Trpoy ypacp(.Kr\v kolv
et 'Opdayopq rco 0rr/3atco crvyyepbpevos, aKorjcras eKeivov 5

ravrd raura a7rep croC, eTravepotTO- avrov els drt /SeArtcoy
Kat9' r)p.epav earat cruyytyi/dueros eKeivoj, et7rot dv ort ets
d 10 KoW/os] KpjTtos Hermann a8 ^^ secl. Hirschig

b3 ti/7x 1 ' 's Bekker Ti^yx'"'*'* B (cum
: vitii nota) T b7 (tvîir-
irov B : frviiriros T c 3 iiriSwfftiv T W : iiriHoaiv B
3 i8c IIAAT&NOS
avkr)<Tiv ovtoj 877 kou cri/ et7re rto yecuHcrKto Kat epot vnep
d rovrou epcorcoyrt, 'iTnroKpaTrjs 6'8e Ylpoorayopa o~vyytvop.evos,
77 av adrco ^juepa crrjyyeVrrrat, /3eArtW airao-i ycvoptvos
Kal t>v dkkoov r)p.epG>v e/cao-rrjs ovtojs e7rt8cocret ets rt, cb
rtpwrayopa, Kat 7rept tov;
5 Kat 6 Ylpoorayopas epoo raiSra aKodcras, 2d re KaAcos

epcoras, ecpr?, co ScoKpares, Kat eycb rots KaAcos epcorcocrt
yaipoi a7TOKpLv6p.(vos. 'linroKpdT-qs yap irap' e/xe dcptKO-
p,evos ov Tretcrerat a?Tep dv Hiradev dAAco rco cruyyeydpevos

rcoi> crocptcrrcov. 01 pev ydp dAAot Aco/3cbz/rai rous yeôuy
e rds ydp T\vas avrovs 7re<peuyo'ras aKoiras 7rdAu> av dyovres
(p.(3ak\ovo-t.v ets ri\vas, Aoytcrpovs re Kat ao-Tpovop.iav ko.1
yeoop.Tp(av Kat p.ovcriKr)v bibao~KOVTes Kat dp.a ets rdy

'iTnriav a7re'/3Ae\//ei> 7rapd 8' ep,e dcptKopeyos paflr/crerai ov
5 7rept dAAou rorj 77 7rept ou Tpcet. to 8e pAdt]p.d Zcttlv evfiovkCa

7rept rcoz> oLKtioov, O7rcos av dptcrra rr)i> a?jro?j oLKLav 8101K01,
319 Kat TTepi rcoy r^s 7ro'Aecos, o7rcos rct r^s 7rdAecos owarcoraros
dy etrj Kat 7rpdrre tz/ Kat Ae'yeu\
'Apa, ecpT/y eyco, e7ropat crorj rco Adyto; 8oKets ydp pot
Aeyetu r?;y 7roAtriK7/r t4x.vt]v Kal viricryvLo-6aL 7roieti' dvbpas
5 dyaflovs 7roAtras.
Avrd p,ey o?ji> tovto o~tlv, ecprj, tb ScoKpares, rd e7rdyyeApa
6 e7rayye'AAopat.
'H koXov, 77V 5' eyco, T&yvr\p.a apa KKTt]craL, enrep
KtKrricraL' ov ydp tl dkko irpos ye cre etpTjcrerat 77 a7rep
10 voS>. eycb ydp rorjro, co YipooTayopa, ovk coprjy 5t8aKrov

b etvat, aot 8e Aeyorrt ovk e^c*) ottcos [ay] d7rtcrrco. dc9ey 8e
awd rjyovpi.aL ov bLbaKTov etvat prj8' vtt' avOpoiTroov irapa-
o-Kvao-Tov dvdpojTTOLS, SiKaids etpt elirelv. eyco ydp 'Ac^rj-
ratorjs, cocr7rep Kat ot dAAot "EAArjyes, cprjpt crocpovs etrai.

5 ' dpco ovv, oTav crvkky>p.V ets rr/y eKKArjcrtar, e7ret8dv pe^
C 8 8i]~} 8 Heindorf d3 iiriHwaei scr. recc. : iiriSwiroi BT W

e 6 irepl B T inpi tc
: t a 8 &pa post t)fffp transp. Cobet
b 1 av secl. Heindorf
nPUTArOPAS 319 b
7rept OLKohop.Cas tl 6e'?/ 7rpdat ri)V ttoAlv, tovs OLKoh6p.ovs

fXTaTTfxiTOfJLVovs (rvpfiovkovs 7rept tojv OLKohop.r)p.a.T ojv, orav
6e irepl vavTrrjyCas, tovs vavirr\yovs, Kal raAAa iravTa ovrcas,
60-a i)yovvTai p.adr)Ta re Kal hihaKTa eirar (av 6e' tls akkos C
(TTLXtlpfl aVTOLS 0-Vp.f3ov\VLV OV CKtLVOL p.r) OLOVTaL ht]-
p.Lovpyov elvai, kolv itavv koXos 17 Kal ttXovctlos kol tojv

ytvvaCojv, ovhev tl paXkov airohiyovTaL, dAAd KarayeA<3trt
kol QopvfiovaLV, W av r) avrbs airocrTr} 6 (TTL^Lpoiv Ae'yetv 5
KaTadopv(3r}6tLS, t) 01 rooTaL avTov dqjiXKVcrojo-LV t) (dpojvraL

KtXevovTajv tG>v irpvTavOJV. irepl p.iv ovv &v oXovTai iv
Ti\vr) elvaL, ovtoj hLairpaTTOvTaL' ZircLhav 6e' tl irept tojv rrjs
7rdAea>s hLOLKrjcrtoos 6e'?? fiovktvcrao-dai, crvp.fiovX.avtL avTols d

avLo-Tap.vos irepl tovtojv 6p.oCojs p.\v tzktojv, 6p.oCojs 6e
XakKevs o-KVTOTOp.os, i!p.TTOpos vavKki)pos, ttXovctlos ttvi)S,
yevvalos aytvvrjs, Kal tovtols ovhels tovto e7ri7rA?/rret ajcnrep
toIs TrpoTepov, otl ovhap.66av p.a6ojv, ovhe ovtos 6i6ao-KaAo?j 5
ovhavos avrqi, eTretra o-vp.fiov\avaLV e7rtxeioei" hrjXov ydp otl

ovx rjyovvraL hLhaKrbv alvaL. p.i) toCvvv otl to kolvov rrjs
noXaojs ovtojs ex ei > aXXd IhCq r)plv ol o-ocpojTaTOL koX dptarot e

tojv ttoKltSjV TavTr\v Ti)v dparijv rjv ax oV(rlv 0V X 'ot' Te -^ ot ^
7raoa6t6oVar iirtiTlepLKkfjs, 6 tovtojvI tujv veavCo-Kojv iraTijp,
tovtovs a pkv hLhao-KaXojv etxero /caAws Kat eu e7rat6e?Jo-ei',
a 6e avros crocpos acrTLV ovTd avTos 7rat6e?jei o?jre ra> aAAw 320
7TapahCho)(TLV, dAA' avroi TrapLLovTas vap.ovTaL uxmep d<perot,
aav ttov avroparoL 7TpLTVxoj(TLV Tr) dpaTrj. et 6e /3ovAet,
KAetviay, t6v 'AAKi/3idooTj tovtovl veojTapov ah\(p6v, e7Ttrpo-
TTdVOJV 6 aVTOS OVTOS OV1)p Yl(\pLKXl)S, hthLOJS TT(pl aVTOV p.1) 5
hLa(pdapf) hr) vtto 'AAKt/3td8o?j, d7roo-7rda-as a7ro tovtov, Kara-
b6 ti ante wepl transp. Cobet b 8 oStuss '6cra T W ovrais o** B

W
:
C i fxaO-riTa. T : fj.ad^fj.aTa B c6 QapusvTai Bekker : QaipaivTai

T W : iepccvTat B (^ 4dpwvTai secl. Cobet)
C 7 iv T(x v v\ tvTtx va
Badham c8 Kroschel
trtp\ tSiv'] twvtD' punctis notavit t
irtp\
di ir6\tcDs secl. ci. Kral (coll. Dem. 24. 102; Isocr. 4.41): SwtK-fi-
fftais secl. Schanz (alterum <r puncto notavit B
2
) e 4 inalStvcrtv
B itraiStvev T
: a 5 IlepiKAfjr secl. Cobet
3 aoa nAAT&N02
dipevos iv 'Aptcppovos tTTaibcve kclI irplv e pJqvas yeyovivai,
b cnreScoKe rorjrcp ovk %\u>v otl yjp-qa-avro arjrco. Ka\ akkovs (tol
TrapLTTokKovs e^w kiycLV, ot avrol ayaOol ovtcs ovbiva 7rco7rore

/3eArtco tTroLrjcrav ovtc t&v otKetW ovtc tG>v dAAorptW.
eyco ovv, co WpoiTayopa, ets raura dirofikiTroiv ov\ r)yovp.aL
5 8t8aKror elvai dperrjv' e7ret87) 8e crou d/covco raura kiyovros,

Kap.irTop.aL Kal olp.ai ri cre Aeyetv 8ta ro rjydcrdai crt TTokk&v
pv fyireipov ytyovivai, 7roAAa 8e p.ep.a6r]KvaL, ra 8e avrbv
er)?jpr7KeVai. et ovv exets ivapyicrrepov rjp.lv e7ri8etâi a>s
C 8t8aKrdV eorty 77 dperr/, p,r) (pdovrjcrjjs akk' iiribeLôv.

'AAA.', co ScoKpares, e<p77, ou (pdovrjcrai' akka -rroTepov ip.lv,
o>s TrpecrfivTepos vecorepot?, p,v6ov kiyoiv e7ri8eico r) Ao'yco
8te<feA{9coV;
5 IIoAAoi ovv avrco vTrikafiov t&v irapaKa6r)p.ivoiv oiroripois

fiovkoLTo ovrois 8te<5ieVai. Aoxet tolwv p,oL, <pr),
x aP l *~
crTepov etrat p,vdov vp.lv Ae'yeu\
*Hv ydp 7rore XP 0V0S 0T( ^ 60 ' /
x " ; r/ fra *'> flrrrra 8e yeVrr
d ovk r)v. eTTubr) 8e Kat rorjrots XP 0V0S ?lA0ei> ilp.app.ivos
yeyecreco?, ri>7ro{5crty avra 6tol yfjs Hvbov ck yfjs Kal Trvpbs

8'
petavres Kai rcoy ocra 7rvpt Kat yfj KepdvvvTaL. iireLbr)
ayety avra irpbs <p&s epeAAoy, 7rpocre'ra<fai> Ylpop.r)6cl kol
5 'E7ri/X7jc?et KOo~p,f}craL re Kat reip-at bvvdp.LS eKacrrots cos
irpiiTL. Ylpop.r\6ia 8e 7rapatretrat 'E7rt/>tr7c9eus avTos velp.ai,

" Netpavros 8e' p,ov," lcpTj, " eTricncer/far" Kat oflrco 7retcras
vepxL. vip.oiv 8e rot? p.ei> tcrxw dz>eu rdxous TrpocrfjiTTev,
e rovs 8* acrdtvecTTipovs Taxet eKocrpet' rovs 8e co7rAt(fe, rot?

8' do7rAoy 8t8ovs (pvo-LV dkkrjv tlv avrols ip.rixava.To bvvap.LV
ets crcorrjptW. a p*v yap avrwv crptKporrirt *]p.irLcrxev, Trrrjvbv
(pvyr)v r) Karayetov otKrjcrtr ez>e//.ezv a 8e rrvê /xeye'êt, rco8e
a7 aplcppovos T : aepicppovos B al (fts) irpl/ Cobet b 1 toi5t^]

ovtos vel out^) vel tovtov ci. Heindorf c2 tr^Ttpov B T sed p in
marg. B C 3 ^ \6y t ^ A.cf-yy 8te|eA0w Cobet
: d8 i/eTtef T W : i/er/xat B
e 1 tovs S' aadevtffTepovs . . toi/s Se . . . BT : ts 8' ao-QeveaTtpa . .
W
. .
to 8e . scr. recc.
. . 6 4 fitye0ei T : neytOri B
n.ilTATOPAS 3 2ia
avrio avTa. ecrcpCev nal rakka ovtcos eiravLcrStv evep.ev. ravra 321
be ep.r)xavaTo evkdjieLav eyoiv p.r\ tl yevos dicTTcodeCrj' eTreibi)
be avroXs dkkr]kocpdopLcov bLacpvyas eirrfpKeo-e, 77005 Tas K

Alos copas evpApeiav p.r\yava.To dp.(pLvvvs avrd ttvkvoxs
re 6pt.lv Kal OTepeois bepp.ao~LV, LKavois piev c\p.vvai ytLp.G>va, 5
bvvarols be koX Kavfxara, Kal els evvas Iovctlv ottcos virdpxoL
tcl avTa Tavra oTpcop.irq 01/ceia re koll avTO(pvi]S eKacrrco' Kal
vrrobcov to. p.ev oTrkais, tcl be [dpL^lv Kal] bepp.acnv (rrepeois b
Kal avaCpLOLS. rovvrevdev Tpoqbas dkkoLS dkkas eeTT6piev,
toIs p.ev eK yrjs (3ordvr)v, dkkoLs be bevbpcov Kap-novs, tols be
p\Cas' ecTTL 8' ols fbcoKev etvaL Tpo<pr)v (cocov dkkcov \3opdv
Kal tols p.ev okLyoyovCav irpocrr\\\r, tols 8' ava\io~KopAvois 5
virb tovtcov TrokvyovCav, <rcoTr)pCav tco yevei iropC(fi>v. aYe
,
br] ovv ov ttclvv tl crocpbs (ov 6 ETTLp.r)6evs ekadev avrbv
KaTavaXcocras ras bvvdp.LS els tcl akoya' koLirbv br\ clko- C
a~p:r]Tov eri avrco rjv to dvdpcoircov yevos, kcu r\Tr6peL otl
XprjcraLTo. diropovvTL be avrco epxeraL Ylpop.r\6evs eTTLCTKeij/o-
\xevos tt]V vop.r]v, Kal opa rd p,ev dkka coa ep.p.ekcos ttovtcov
exovra, tov be dv6pcoirov yvp.vov re kcxl dwir6br]Tov koX 5
dcnpcoTOV kcu doirkov rjbrj be kuI r) elp.app.evr] r\pApa irapr\v,
ev 17 ebeL Kal dvdpcoirov efieVai K yrjs els <pcos. aTropCa ovv

(rx6p.evos 6 Hpop.r)6evs rjvTLva crcoTr]pCav tco dvdpcoTTCo evpoL,
KkeiTTei 'HcpaCcrrov Kal 'A6rjvds Tt]v evrexvov o~ocpCav crvv d
irvpC dp.rJxavov yap r)v dvev irvpbs avrrfv KTryrqv tco r\
Xpr)crCp.r}v yevecrdaL Kal ovtco br) bcopelrai dvdpcoTTCo. rr)v
p.ev ovv irepl tov (3Cov (Tocpiav dvdpcoTTOs TavTt) ecrxev, tt)v be
TTokLTLKr)v ovk e^xev r)v ydp irapa tco AlC. tco be Ylpop.r^del 5
a 4 flfidpttav W ei/fiapiav BT & 5 x fi fL ^ yas Kro^chel

W
:
a 6 v-rdpxoi B T : imdpxv 1 W (sed supra ijt)

01 a 7 oltctla :
olKtla. T oUla B b 1 v-toS&v Cobet {virotitwv coniecerat Bad-

W
:
ham) : inrb -ToStbi- BT 0pilv Kal secl. Ast Hvv^t Ka\ Baiter ::
Hdptî Orelli $4pfi.afftv ffrfptols glossema putat Kroschel (ad rv\ots

o-K\r)po?s vel tale quid) b2 &\\ots T dAA^\oiy B b 7-
W 8);]
:
5 Kroschel c 1 us rit&\oya T om. B : 5)j aK6aixi\Tov

T W SiaKoo~iu.riTbv
: B, C 6 iraprjv T irapfj B : C 8 ffxdfMvos
B ix^ fV0S T
: dz TifBT sed 01 suprascr. T
32id riAAT&NOJ
(ls p.V T1)V aKpOTToklV T7)V TOV AtOS OtKria-LV OVKTL V\(opL
elcrekdelv 71756? be kcu al Alos QvkaKal (pofiepal f)crav ets
8e to rfjs 'Adrjvas Kal 'HcpaicrTov OLKrjpxi to kolvov, ev <o
e eqbLkoTeyyeiTriv, kadcov elcrepyeraL, Kal Kkexpas tt\v re iinrvpov

Teyyrpj ttjv tov *H(paicrTov Kal rf)V aWrjv rrjv rfjs 'Adrjvas
bibcocriv dvdp(oiT(o, Kal K tovtov eviropia pev dv6pd>TT(o tov

322 /3tov yiyveraL, YlpopvqOia be 81' 'ETTip.r)6ea vcnepov, r)Trep
keyerai, KkoTrfjs bUr) p.Tf)k6ev.

'ETreLbrj be 6 dvdpoiiros deias p.eTecrye p.oipas, TrpS>TOV p.ev
8ta TrjV tov 6eov crvyyeveiav C<aoov p.6vov deovs evojxicrev, koX
5 eireyeipeL (3top,ovs re IbpveardaL ml dydkp.aTa 6e(av eireLTa

cpoovrjv Kal 6v6p.aTa Tayy bLt)p6p(oaaTo rfj Teyyr), koX olKf)aeis
Kal ecrOfJTas Kal inrobecreLS Kat crTpoop.vds Kal tcls k yrjs

rpocpas rjvpero. ovtoo bf) TTapeaKevaap.evoL Kar' dpyas . {
b avOpoo-noL (okovv o"nopabr\v, TrokeLS be ovk r)crav diTdikkvvTO ?
ovv virb T(2v 6r)picov bLa to TravTayf) avT&v dcrdeveaTepoi

elvai, Kal f) brjpLOvpyLKrj reyyr) avroTs Trpbs p.ev rpocpfy
LKavf) fior)dbs r)v, Trpbs be tov tlov 6r)piu>v ir6kep.ov evbef)s
5 7roAiriKr)z> yap Teyvi]v ovttco elyov, fjs pepos iro\ep.LKi)

eCf)Tovv bf) adpoiêcrdaL koX crdoêcrdaL KriCflVTes TroAety 6V
ovv aOpoLcrdelev, f)biKovv dAATjAou? a,T ovk eyovres rf)v
7T0\lTLKf)V T\Vr)V, (ti(TT TTClKlV (TKbaVVVp.eVOL bL(p6eipOVTO.
C Zevs ovv beicras irepl T(o yeveL f)p.S>v p.f) dirokoLTO irdv,
J
'Epp.fjv Trep.TTL dyovra els avOpcoTrovs alboo re Kat biKf)v, tv
elev TToketov KoapoL re Kat beap.ol (pLkias crvvayu>yoi. j eptoTcl
ovv 'EppLrjs Ata riva ovv Tpotrov boir) bUr)v Kal albG> av6pd>-
5 7T0is* " YloTepov (os al TeyyaL vevep.r)VTaL, ovtco kcxl Tavras
a 1 Zi Sauppe
'EirifiriOfa secl. a 4 Sia, . ffvyyti/eiav secl. . .
Deuschle rov Otov secl. Hermann t&v Otwv ci. Kroschel : ffvyye-
vctav) i vvrex v ^ a v c '- Blass
l
- fi6vot>] /xovos Cobet &6 rrj rexvri
secl. Deuschle a 8 nvpero~] ijSpev Cobet irapeffKevacrixevoi B
(sed 1 in ras.) T : irapeffKevaff/MevovVJ (sed j supra v) b 1 airw\vvro
(sic) W
air6\\vvro (sic) B T
: h 5 noKtriKiiv iro\efiiKi) secl. . . .
ci.Karlowa b7 a6poiffde7ev T : aOpoiffetev B 04 80/17] 8

Cobet
nP&TATOPAS 322C
veijiu); vevip.r)VTaL 8e cSSe* t-Xs e\<x>v la.Tpua)v irokkois t*ccu>os
tStcorai?, Kat ol aAAot br]p.Lovpyoi' koX blio]v br) Kal albti

ovTOi 6(a iv toIs dvdpcairoLS, rj irrl TrdvTas veipioi; .
" 'E7rt d
TravTas," ec/>?j 6 Zevs, " kol TrdvTes p.t\Tt\y6vT(nv ov ydp av
yivoivTO 7roAet?, et oAtyot avT&v p.t\TiyoLt\v too-irep dAAcov
T\y&v Kat vop.ov ye 6cs irap i\xov tov \xr) bvvdpnwov
albovs Kal bbKrjs p.t\Ti\t\tv KreiVeii' cos vocrov 7roAecos." ovroi 5
877, co ScoKoares, Ka\ bta ravra ot re aAAot /cat 'Adr/valot,

orav piev 7rept dpTrjs TenTovtKfjs fj koyos 7) dkkr)s tlvos
br)p.LOvpyLKrjs, okCyoLS olovraL p.t\Tt\ivat o-vpLJ3ovkr}s, Kal idv
tls ktos uiv tG>v dkiytov crvp.[3ovkt\V7], ovk dviyovTat, co? o-v e
c/jtjs eiKoVcos, cb? eyco cpT/pt oray 8e ets o~vp.fiovkr)v irokt-
tlktjs dpcrrjs tcoo-tv, rjv Set 8ta SiKaiocnJz/Tis Trdcrav iivat Kat 323
crcocppocrvvqs, et/corco? a7rayros drSpo? dvixovrai, -s 7rairt
TrpocrfJKOv ravrris ye /uereêtr r?/$ dpfTrjs r) /u?) e?mi 7ro'Aet?.
ai/r?/, <o 2co/cparey, tovtov atrta.
"Ij>a 8e p,?) oh) dtiaTacrdaL co? rw o/rrt rjyovvraL irdvTt\s 5

dvOpoiiroL iravra avbpa p.t\Ti\t\LV StKatocrw??? re Kat ttjs dkkrjs
TTokLTLKrjs dperfjs, Tobt\ av Aa/3e TKp.rjpLov. iv yap rats
dAAat? dperats, &cnrt\p cru Aeyet?, idv tls <pfj dyadbs avkr)Tr)s
etrat, 7) dkkr)v tjvtlvovv TcyyvjV f\v p.r\ icrTLV, r) KarayeAcocru/
?/ x aAe7rau'ot;o-ii>, Kat 01 otKetot 7rpocrioVres vovOctovo-lv tos b

p.aiv6p.t\vov iv 8e bLKaLocrvvr) ml iv tt) dkkr) TTokLTLKfj dpCTfj,
edv TLva Kal (Ib&crLv otl dbLKos (cttlv, iav ovtos avros KaO*
avrov Takr)drj Ae'yr/ ivavTiov irokka>v, o eKet cru>(ppocrvv7)v
rjyovvro t-lvai, TakTjOij keyeLV, ivravOa p.aviav, Kai cpacrLV 5
ixdvTas bzXv tpdvaL etrat SiKatoTj?, idvTe ooctlv idvTt- p.7), 77
fxaivccrOaL tov p.7) iTpocn-oLOvp:Vov [biKatoir6vr)v\- cos dvay-

Kalov ovbiva ovtlv ov\l dp.m yi ttoos p.t\Ti\'-Lv avTrjs, 7) /x?) C
etrat iv dvdpatTroLs.
d.6 aOfivcuot BT: ol aQ~-vaioi W ai 8 Bt: Sii T

a2 Sitovtos] wai/Tbs Schanz b3
tlSwo-iv T: 5wo-v (sic) B
b5 (pao-iv irdvras St?v B tf>a<rl St7v irdvTas
: T
(sed signis transpositionis
fecit irdvras (paal St7v) 6 ^dV t So-jj/b ^r
iav pA\rt n^TW:
&ffiv iav (jA\ B b 7 StKcuovtvriv secl. Cobet ava-yKcuoj/ ( 6/) Hirschig
323C nAATilNOS
"Otl p.ev ovv Ttavr dvbpa etKoVtos aiTobtyovTai irepX ravrrjs
ttjs dpeTrjs crvp.j3ovkov 8td to fjyeLcrdaL -ravrl p.eTeXvaL avrfjs,

5 Tavra keyco* otl be avrfjv ov cpvcreL fjyovvTat. elvaL ovft anb
tov avTopidTov, dkkd bibaKTov re /cat e e-TLpLekeias irapayi-
yvecrOaL co av -TapayiyvryraL, tovto o-ot juerd tovto ireip6.o~op.ai
dirobelâL. ocra yap fiyovvrai dAArjAovs Kana ex LV dvOpcoTTOL

d cpvcreL rj Tvyrt, ovbels dvpovrat. ovbe vovOeTel ovbe bt,bacrKei
ovbe KoAdet tovs raura e'x 0VTas > tva p.f] tolovtol u)ctlv, dAA'
eAeovo-tzr otov tovs alcrxpovs ri crp.LKpovs f) acrOeveis rts ovtcos
avor]Tos cocrre tl tovtcov errLxeLpeiv -tolLv; ravTa piev yap
5 oTp.aL to-ao-ty ort cpvcreL re Kat TVXV rots avdpca-joLs yiyverai,
tcl Kaka. Kat rdvavria tovtols' ocra be e e7ri/AeAeias Kat
acrKrjcreois koX bLbayrfs olovTat yiyvecrOaL ayaOa dvdpcoiroLS,
e edv tls ravra p.f)
$XV> dkka rdvavria tovtcov KaKa, e-fi
tovtols ttov oL T 6vp.o\ yiyvovTaL Kat at KoAdcrets Kat at

vov9eTrjo~LS. &v ecmv ev kol r) dbiKLa Kal r) dcrefieLa Kai
324 crvW.rj(3br]v irdv to evavriov rrjs 7roAirtK7/s aperrjs' evOa 8r/
ttcls TTavrl 6vp,ovraL Kal vovOereT, bfjkov otl cos e e7rt/xeAeias
Kat p.adf\crecos KT-qrrjs ovcrrjs. et yap eOekets evvofjcraL to
KokaeLV, Si ScoKoares, tovs dbLKodvras tl ttot bvvaraL,

5 aurd cre 8i8det otl ot ye dvOpco-roL fjyovvraL TrapacrKevacrTov
eXvaL dpeTrjv. oi/bels ydp KoAdcfet tovs d8iKowras 7ro6s
TOVTirt TOV VOVV eÔV Kat TOVTOV $VKa, OTL f]biKT]CTV, OOTtS
b pvq cocnrep OrjpCov dAoyto-rcos rt/xcopetrat* 6 be p.era koyov
-TL)(LpG>V KOkd^LV OV TOV TTapek-qkvOoTOS VKa dbLKT]p,aTOS
TLpxopeh-aL ov yap dv to ye irpaxdev dyevrtTov deir] dAAd
tov p.ekkovTos X^P IV> Lva M ox>Qis dStKT/crrj p.f]Te avros ovtos
d4 &<rre rt T : &<tt' tj B d5 ol/xai Itraartv W : olfiai etaaaiv

(cum nota) B : to-ouriv T (sed
vitii extra versum add. t)
olfiat d 6 rot
Ka\a] ra koko, Ficinus (Jtaec mala) secl. Schanz post rovrots transp.ci.
W
: :
Turner d7 oiovrat T : otovrat ^ B e 1 Kaxd secl. Herwerden

a 1 evOa B : Hvdev T a 4 <% ^c&Kpares secl. Cobet a 6 irpos tovto
Stobaeus a 7 TjStKijcrev B T Stobaeus ijSlKtiKev Cobet b 1 \6yov :
BT Stobaeus: Aoyto-fnov ci.Herwerden \>2 aSiK-r)naTos B T Stobaeus:

secl. Cobet b 3 r6 ye T Stobaeus t6t^ B W
b 4 x^P lv ^ ^ :
Stobaeus X9^V0V Cobet

: aSiK-fi<rti T Stobaeus a5iK-fi<rr> 'Iva B W :
nPI2TArOPA2 3 24b
fAi]T dAAos 6 tovtov lbu>v KoKao-divra. nal Toiavrr\v Oiavoiav 5
t\u>v biavoelrai 7rai8etjrr/i> elvai dpTi]V airoTpoTrrjs yovv

(veKa KoAdêt. Tavrrjv ovv Ti]v boav ndvTes tyovcrLv dcroLirtp
rtucopowrat Kal Ibiq Kal Sr/uoata. rtucopowrat be Kal KoAd- C
(pvTai ot re dAAot dvdptoTTOL ovs av otcoyrat abiKelv, Kal ov\
i]KLo-Ta 'AOr/vaZoL ol o~ol TToAirar coare Kard tovtov tov
koyov Kal 'Adr\vaZoi etcrt tG>v fjyovp.evcov TrapacrKtvao-Tov
elvaL Kal bLbaKrbv dperriv. cls pikv ovv etKorcos' aTTobiiyovTaL 5
ot crot 7roAtrai kol yakKtcos Kal o-kvtoto-lov o-vp.j3ovkVOVTos

tcl TTokLTLKa, Kal otl bLbaKTov Kal 7rapacrKei;aaroi> fjyovvraL
dp*Tr]v, d7ro8e'8etKrat croi, a> ScoKpares, iKarcoy, cos ye uot

cpatrerat. d
"Ert 8?/ Xoltti] diropia eortr, fjv diropeZs irepl tu>v dvbpiov
t5>v dya6G>v, ri 8r/7rore ol dvbpes ol dya6o\ tcl p.\v dAAa

tovs avTwv vets bLbdo-KovcrLV a 8t8acrKdAcoj; eêrat /cat
crocpovs ttolovctiv, fjv 8e avrol dperf/v dyaOol oibcvos /3eA- 5
rtou? Trotoucrty. tovtov 8f/ 7re'pt, co ScoKparey, orWrt -ivOov

ctol epco dAAd Ao'yoi\ cooe ydp w6r]o-ov iroTtpov Zcttlv tl
tv fj ovk tcrTLV ov dvayKaZov irdvTas toxjs TTokiras uere'xe>,
enrep ue'AAet 7ro'Ats etrat; tv rorjrco ydp avri] Arjerat r/ dtropia e

fjv av aTTOpeZs fj dkko&L ovba/xov. et p.ev yap etrrty, Kat
tovto kaTLV to tV ov TdKTovLKi] ovbt \akKia oibe Kepaueta

dAAd otKatotrwrj Kat crcocppocrwr/ Kat to octlov etuat, klu 3 2 5
rruAAr//38r/y tv avrb Trpocrayopevto etât dvbpbs dptTrjv et
tovt eartv ov 8et irdvTas uere'xeti> Kat uerd tovtov irdvT

dvbpa, (dv tl Kat dAAo /3orJAr/rat p.avddvLV r/ 7rpdrreti>, ovrco
7rpaTTtv, dvV 8e tovtov p.~], r/ r6v pr/ -LtTtyovTa kol bi- 5
8d(rKetv Kat KoAdfety Kat 7rat8a Kat dvbpa Kal yvvaLKa,

ecotr7rep dv KoAa^dpeôs /3eArtcov yvr]TaL, bs 8' di> pr/ V7ra-
b7 Ko\d(~i T W : /coA.aîv B e3 ol <rol T W : 6 B

ffoi c 6 ot
o-ol T W : oTs ol B C 8 y- fioi B y : i/xol T d 2 Aojit^ (^)
ci. Heindorf e 1 -toKis BT: ^p. i-o\iri)s t e2 riT: o-oi B
e3 K-pa/i-ia W : K-pa/mia BT a5 /U17, r) T : juij p B a 6 at
wa<5a /cal SvSpa ca yvvawa secl. Deuschle
PLATO, vol. iii.
'
325a IIAATttNOS
Kovr\ Koka6p.evos Kal bLbacrKOfxevos, eos aviarov ovra tovtov
b Kf3dkkeLV K tGv Trokeoov r) diTOKTeiveLV et ovtoo fxev ex* l >
ovtco 8' avrov irecpvKOTOS ol dyadol dvbpes et rd p.ev dXka
bibdo-KOVTai, tovs vels, tovto be fxrj, crKexjraL eos 6avp.acricos
yiyvovrai oi dyadoi. ort piev yap bibaKTov avrb rjyovvrai

5 Kal Ibiq Kal brjpocriq, aTrebeiâfxev btbaKTOv be ovtos Kal
OepaTrevTov rd p,ev dkka dpa tovs vels bibdcrKovTai, ecp' ols
ovk eort Odvaros r) Crjjiiia *dv p.r) eTricrTeovTaL, ecp' co 8e rj
re (jjfxia Odvaros avroov toIs Traicri Kal cpvyal p,r) fxadovcrL
C fxrfbe. OepaTrevQetcrLV eis dpeTr/v, kol Trpbs tG> davdreo \pr)-

fxaToov re brffxevcreLS Kal eos iiros elrrelv crvkkrjj3br)v tG>v
olkcov dvaTpoirai, ravra 8' dpa ov bibdcrKOVTai ovb' em-
fxekovvraL irdcrav eTTLfxekeLav; oUcrOai ye yjpri, o> 2coKpares.
5 K Traibcov o-p.LKpG>v dpdp.evoL, fxeyjpL ovtrep dv (ptcri, kol
bibdcrKovcri Kal vovOerovcrLV. eireLbav OaTTOv crvvir) tis rd
keyop.eva, Kal Tpocpos Kal fxrjrrip Kal -naibayeoybs Kal avTos
d 6 iraTrjp irepl tovtov biap.d\ovTai, ottoos (cos) /3e'ArtoTos' ecrrat
6 Trat?, ira eKacrTov kol epyov Kal koyov bibdcrKovres Kal

evbeLKvvpevoL otl to fxev bUaLov, to be dbLKov, Kat ro'8e fxev
Kakov, ro8e 8e aloyfiov, Kal ro'8e p.ev octlov, ro8e 8e ovoo-lov,

5 Kat Ta piev iroieL, ra be fxr) iroieL. kcu edv fxev koov ireiOr)-
raf et 8e fxrf, &cnrep vkov bLacrrpecpofxevov Kal Kap.7rT6p.evov
evOvvovcrLV d7reiA.at? Kat Trkrjyals. S fxera be Tavra els oi-
bacrKdkojv 7rep.7rovTes Trokv fxakkov evrekkovTaL eirLpekelcrOaL
e evKOcrp.ias tG>v iraiboov r) ypap.p.aTcov re Kat KL0apicreoiS' ot
8e 8i8dcrKaAoi tovtcov re eTTLfxekovvTaL, Kal e7retSdy av

ypap.p.ara fxdOeocnv Kal fxekkeocrLV o~vvr)creiv rd yeypap.fxeva
cocnrep tot rr)v cpeovi]V, 7TapaTL0eacrLV avrols eirl to>v fidOpoov
5 dvayLyvbicrKLV TTOtr/rcSy dyad&v TTOLrffxaTa kol eKpavOdveiv
b3 Oavfiaffiws] Oavfidaiov vel Oavfidina (et mox ylyvoir &v, secl. oi

ayadoi) ci. Dobree : davfidaiol croi ci. Schleiermacher : davfidtrwi ci.
Kroschel 8avfj.a<riws &tottoi ci. Thompson b4 yiyvovrai}
&TW
:
i-XavSivTai ci. Muenscher b7 T f) BW ^ re vera B

W
: :
fi
d. 1 owus ws t : Siroos BT d5 to /xhv . . . tk 8e . . . B : rdtit

jxiv . . . rdSf Se . . . T 63 (rvvficr-iv T : avvoiativ B
nPUTATOPAS 3 26a
avayKaov(TLV, iv ols 7roAAai p.\v vovdtTijcrtiLs eveio~iv, ttoK- 326

\al bt butjoboL Kal irraLvoL Kal eyKco/xta Trakai&v dvbpa>v
dya6a>v, iva 6 ttoXs t/Aco> /xt/iT/rat Kai 6pzyr\Tai tolovtos
yere'cr0ai. 01 r av Ktflapicrrai, CTcpa Toiavra, craxppocrvvqs
re (mpLtXovvTat. Kal 07T(os av ol vioi pitjbfv KaKovpy&cnv 5
TTpbs 8e tovtols, (TTeibav KL6apC(LV pd6a)o~LV, aXkcov av
7T0LT]Th)V dyad&V TT0L7)p.aTa bLba.0~K0V0~L p.i\OTTOLO>V, tzls TCl
KL6apCap.ara ZvTcCvovTt-s, Kal tovs pvdpovs re Kal ras ap- b

piovCas avayKaovo~Lv oiKeio?3crc9ai rats \j/v\als t&v TraCba)v,
tva 7//xeocorepot re coctlv, Kal evpvdpLOTepoL Kal evap/^tocrrorepot

yLyv6p.(V0L \pi]crip.0L S)o~lv t-is rb Xt-yaLV re Kai 7rpdrret;r
ttcls yap 6 /3los tov av6pa>7rov tvpv6p.Cas re Kat t\vapp.oo~TCas 5
b-iLTaL/y ert toCvvv Trpbs tpvtols ets 7rat5orp/3otj TTt\p.7rovcrLV,
Lva tcl crco/xara /3eArtco 4\ovTS vrn/percocri rj/ bLavoCa xpr/crTfj
ovcrrj, Kal p.rj drayKdcoi>rat a7ro8etAtay ota Ti]V Trovr\pCav C

rcoy crcop.drcoi' nal t\v tols 7ro\e:p.oLs Kai t)v rats dWais
TTpdêcrLV. kcCl Tavra ttolovctlv ol p.d\Lo~Ta bvvdp.nvoL (/xa-
Atcrra) udAtcrra be bvvavraL ol 7rAot>cricoraroi Kai 01
tovto)v v(ls, 7rpcoatrara ets bLbao~Kd\a)v rijs r/AiKias dpd- 5

pcvoL (poLTav, oif/LaCraTa d7raAAdrrwrat. e7ret8di> oe eK
StSacTKaAcoy d7raAAaycocriy, 77 7roAts av tovs re vop,ovs dvay-
Ka(t:L pav6dvLV Kal Kara tovtovs Cv v Kara 7rapd8etyua,
u>a ur/ avrol ecp' avrcoy etKtj TTpaTTuxTLV, dAA' drex^tos d
tocr7rep 01 ypappaTLcrral tols pi]TTO) 8etrots ypdcpt-iv t&v
7ratocoy v7T0ypd\f/avTes ypap.p.as rr) ypacpCbL ovrco ro ypap.-
/xaretoy dt8o'acrti> Kai drayKdbt;crt ypdcpiLV Kara ttjv vcpi]-
a 7 fxt\oT-oiSiv secl. Cobet b 1 tvrtivavTis ci. Sauppe b3 rj-
Hepdrtpoi T W
^ fierfwpoi B
: b6 irt/j.irovo-iv T i-ifxirwffiv B W :
b 7 j3e\Tt'eo] $4\tiov Cobet C 3 01TW: ov pr. B fj.d\i<TTa add.

Sauppe (post iroiovanv Heindorf) C5 i-pwiaiTaTa T irpoitTaTa W :
pr. B es oihao-KaXwv ttjt T)\ti<ias apdfj.tvoi BT: tt}s rj\tKias tis

Sioao-Ka\wv ap^dfj.tvoi t c6 e*TW:
dsB: secl. Cobet c 7 au
tous t T W avTov 8t* B
: c 8 aTa -rapaStiyfxa secl. Schanz :
fort. KadaTrep irapdStiyfia ci. Heindorf CI3 ypafifjaTtiov Bt:

ypafjfidTiov t
14*
326d nAATXlNOS
5 yt\(Tiv tcov ypap.p.Q>v, &s 8e kclI r) 7ro'Ats vop.ovs vTroypd\j/acra,
dyadcov nal TrakaLcov vop,odTu>v evprjp.aTa, Kard tovtovs
dvayKa&L Kal dp\eiv Kal apxeadai, bs 8' av eKrds /3atVr/
tovtcov, Kokd&L' Kal 6vop.a rr) KoAda-et ravTtf kol 7rap' vp.lv
e Kal akkodL irokkaôv, cos V$vvovo~r)s rrjs biKrjs, tvOvvai.
roaaurijs ovv rr)s e7rt/xeAetas ovo-rjs irepl dpcTrjs IbCa Kal
br)p.ocrCa, 6avp.a&LS, d> ScoKpares, Kal diropus et bibaKTOv
to-Tiv dptTr); dkk' ov )(j>r) 6avp.dCeLV, dkkd irokv pJdkkov
5 et p.r) bibaKTov.
Ata tC ovv tcov dyadcov Trarepcov Trokkol veis cpavkoi
yCyvovrai; tovto av p.d6v ovb\v ydp davp-acrTov, eiirep
dkr)drj eycb ev tols ep.Trpoo-dev eAeyoy, otl tovtov tov irpd-
327 y/xaros, rrjs dperrjs, et /AAet 7ro'Ats eticai, ovbiva 8et Ibico-
revetr. et yap br) Aeyco ovra>s eêt eêt 8e /xdAto-ra

TrdvTcov ovtcos ,
k vdvp.r\dr\TL dkko tcov kTTLTr)bevp.aTcov otlovv

Kal p.adi)p.dTcov irpoekop.evos. et p.r)ôX6v r' r)v irokLV etrat
5 et p.r) irdvTes avArjrat r)p.zv ottows tls ibvvaro t-Kao-Tos, koI
tovto Kal ibCa xat br)p.ocrCq iras Trdvra kol ZbCbacrKe Kal
eTTtTTkrjTTt tov p.i) KaAcos avkovvra, Kal p.r) ecpfloVet tovtov,
(oo~TTep vvv tcov biKaC(ov kol tcov vop.Cp.cov ovSets cpdovel ovb*
b airoKpvTTTeTaL cocnrep tcov akkcov Teyvr)p.aT(ov Auo-treAet

ydo otpat rjp.LV r) dkkr)k(ov bLKaLocrvvr) Kal dperr)' 8td Tavra
Tras iravTL irpo6vp.cos Aeyet /cat 8t8dcrKet Kat rd 8tKata Kat
ra vop.Lp.a et ovv ovtco Kal iv avAr/crei iracrav irpo6vp.Cav
5 Kat dcpdovCav efyopLev dkkrjkovs 8t8do-Ketz>, otet av tl, fcpr),
ixakkov, co SiCOKpaTts, tcov dyadcov avkrjTcov dya6ovs avkrjTas

tovs vds yCyvtcrdaL t) tcov cpavkcov; 6tp.aL p.\v ov, dkkd
otov eTv\ev 6 vbs evcpvicTTaTos yzvop.zvos ds avkqaLV, ovtos
C av eAAo'yt/xos r)vr)6r), otov 8e dcpvr)s, aKkerjS' Kat 7ro\AaKts
p.\v dyadov avkr)Tov cpavkos dv a7re'/37j, 7roAAaKts 8' dv
d. 8 ovofia ttj T b : ovofiart B a 1 ttoAi s Bt ito\It7]s T 3, a b

W
:
Kiyw T 6 \4ywv B
: a6 Kai eS/SaffKe BT : iSiSacrKt b2 Tjfuv
Stephanus v/mv
: BT W b3 nal post StSdo-Ktt secl. ci.
Kroschel
nPXlTATOPAS 327C
ipavkov dyados' dAA' ovv avkrjrai y dv irdvTCS rjcrav IkovoX
6f 7rpos tovs IbiojTas ko.1 p.i]bev avki]o~eojs cTratovTas. ovtojs
olov Kal vvv, ootls 0*06 abtKdoTaTos cpatWrat dvdpojiros tcov 5
cv vofxois Kal dvdpojTrois Te6pap.p.evcov, bimiov avrbv elvat

Kal bi]p.Lovpybv tovtov tov irpdyfiaTos, el bcoL ovtov KpivccrdaL
irpbs avdpojirovs ols p.i]Te Tratbeia carlv ju?/re SiKaorr/pia p.r]T d
vop.oL p.i]bc avayKT] pi.rjbep.ia bta iravTos dvayKa(fivo~a dpcTrjs
eirLp.ckeXo~6aL, dAA' eteu aypioi tlvcs oXoiirep ots irepvo~LV

<>peKpaTris 6 7rot??r??? ebibaev cttI Ai]vaioj. 1] crcpobpa cv
TOLS T0L0VT0LS dvOpOJTTOLS yv6p.CV0S, OJO~TTCp 61 CV CKcivOJ TO 5
XP<? p.LcrdvdpcoTTOL, ayaTTrj(rat.s av el ivrv\OLS EipvfiaTOj Kal

l Ppvvojvbq, Kal dvokoqjvpaC av tto6S>v ti]v tcov evda.be dv6pco-
ttojv irovqpiav. vvv be Tpvcpqs, o> SojKpaTes, Stort Trdvres e
bibaaKaXoi elcriv dperijs Ka6* ocrov bvvavTai cKaaros, Ka\
ovbeis ctol cpatrerar eW\ cotnrcp av el ^V/rots rts 8t8do-KaAos
tov ckkqvi&LV, ov8' av els cpavciq, ovbe y av oi/xat et 328
?irots rts av rjpXv btbd^CLCv tovs tSjv yeLpoTeyycov vels
avTi]v TavTiyv rqv Tcyyqv rjv br) irapa tov Trarpos p.ep.a6r,-
Kao~Lv, Kad* 6a~ov oXos r' r)v 6 7rar?/p Kat ot tov TraTpbs cptAot
dVres 6poTe\voL, tovtovs ctl rts av i8deier, ov pqbiov 5
otpai eXvai, co SojKpares, tovtojv bLbdo~Kakov cpavijvaL, tSjv
be aTTeipojv TravTaiTacrL pq^LOV, ovtco bc dperijs Kal tcov
dkkcov TrdvTcov dAAd kciv ei okiyov cotlv tls ocrrts Stacpepet

i]p\o>v TTpoj3LJ3dcraL els dperqv, dyairqTov. 5>v bi] eyo> otpat b
ets etvat, Kat StacpepoVrcos dv tS>v akkoov dvdpojTTtov 6vi]o-ai
TLva Trpbs to Kakbv Kal dya6bv yeveo~6ai, Kal dioos tov
C 3 y' h.v Shilleto 701;' B T : W

C 4 av\ii<r-cos (irept) Cobet
C 5 olov kcu\ <pov ic&c Sauppe C 6 eV v6jxois Kal avQpdnrois] ittter
homines sub lege viventes Ficinus 4v v6fiois Kal ivv6/xots avdpdiroLS olim
:
Sauppe 4v 4vv6fxois avBpdvois L. Schmidt 4v v6fj.ots ical voixi.fi.ots avdpdi-

: :
i-ots Cobet d. 1 iratSda T tratStd B d 3 oloiirep ot/s] otovs Athe-

:
naeus olovainp Hirschig d4 6 irotijr^s secl. Cobet AT-vaitp.

W
:
^] \t)vaiw fi T (sed tj supra versum) Xijvaiwv B d 5 S>o-rrtp~\

:
oToi-rrep Cobet d 6 fxtffivOpuirot] rifxtavOpoiirot Heinrich fxtdvOpuirot :
Jacobs /xfffdvdpwirot Lehrs

: ivrvxots B 4 v rvxats T 63 tid :
B tld' T tlvat Heindorf *fs Hermann

: : : ba dvrjcrat ci. Dobree :
voijcrat BT W
328b IIAAT&NOS
/JHCrOov OV TTpaTTOfACU kcu ert 7rAetoi>os, coore koX avTio boKelv
5 rco p.a06vTL. 8td raura Kat tov Tpoirov rrjs 7rpdecos tov
puo-Qov tolovtov 7T7roi77juai* e7rei8di> yap rts 7rap' ep.ov p.a0r),
kav pikv (BovXrjTai, airobebwKev 6 eyob TTpa.TTop.aL apyvpiov

C tav 8e p.r/, eA0obi> ets Upov, opo'cras ocrov av <prj dfta etVat
Ta p.a0r)p.aTa, toctovtov KaT0rjKC
TotouroV crot, ecpr), co ScoKpares, eyob Kat pJvOov Kal Koyov

etprjKa, cos 8t8aKroi> ap.Tri /cal 'Aflrrvatot oiDrcos ^yoiJyrai,
5 Kat ort ovbev 6avp.aor6v t&v aya6u>v 7rare'pcoi> (pavAovs t>ets
yiyveo-Qai /cat rcov cpauAcoi> aya0ovs, eirel Kat ot noAt>KAeiro?j
rjets, YlapaXov ko.1 Eav0LTnrov rorj8e r/AiKtcorat, orj8ei> 7rpos
rw 7rarepa elcrCv, Kat dAAot dA\coi> br)p.iovpy<av. Tcavbe 8e
d orj7rco acftoy rorjro Karrjyopriv ert ydp ez> aiVots etcrti>
eA7ri8es* i>e'ot ydp.

ripcoraydpas pikv Tocravra Kal roiaijra e7rt8etcfdjuei>os a7re-
7rarjtraro roo Adyou. Kat eyco e7rt pei> 7roAii/ yj)6vov KeKrrAri-
5 peVos ert 7rp6s avrbv e/3Ae7roi> cos spovvTa tl, e7TL0vp.Cjv
clkovLV e7ret 8e 8r) r]cr06p.r\v otl rco oi>rt TTTravp.evo$ etrr,
pdyts 7rcos ep.avTov cocr7repet ovvaytCpas cTttov, jSAeS/fas 7rpos

'12 7rat 'A7roAAo8copov,
x-P w' ^X w
rdi/ 'iTrTroKparrr* cos " 01
ort 7rporjrpe\âs fte <S8e dd)iKe'crt9ar 7roAAorj ydp 7roto?jpai
e aKTTKoeVat a aKrjKoa ripcorayopou. eyco ydp ei> pei> rco ep-

7rpocr0v xp6vu> r)yovp.r\v ovk etvai av^ptoTTLvrjv iTTLp.iX.CLav
t/ dyatôt ot dyatôt yiyi>oi>rar i>rji> 8e 7re'7retcrLtai. 7rAr)y
crp.LKpov tl p.0L ep.TTob(av, 6 8r/Aoi> ort ITpcorayopas paStcos
5 e7reK8t8dêt, e7ret8r) Kat ra 7roAAa raCra eê8t8aei>. Kai
ydp et p.zv rts 7rept avrcoy rorjrcoy crvyyivoLTO otwovv t&v

329 Srjprjyopcor, rd^' dz^ Kat rotorjrorjs Ao'yorjs aKowetev r\ YlepL-
KAe'ous 17 dAAou rtyos rcoy tKa^coy ei7rety et 8e iiravtpoLTo
b7 /
a7ro8e 5a>/cej'] aireSwKfv secl. Sauppe
Kroschel : d4 M
Hfv~\ iri /xiv scribendum et moxsecludendum putat Schanz
eri
d6 81 677 B : Si) 5e T irciravfxevoi T jreiravix/j.fvos B (sed a punctis
:
notatum) e r tyi) yap T eyuye B: e 3 rT ayadol T jT W :
ct'ya8oi' B a 1 roioxnovs] rovrov roiovrovs Sauppe

1 T
nPOTArOPAS 32 9 a
TLvd tl, uxTirep /3t/3Ata oibev eyovo~Lv ovTe diroKpCvacr6aL ovre

avTol ipecrdai, dAA' idv tls Kal crp.LKpbv e7repam/o-?/ rt tcov
pr]6evrcov, coanrep TOL yjakKCa i:\rjy4vTa p.aKpbv r)yeZ kol diro- 5
retVet idv /ur) e7rtAd/3?/rai tls, Kal ol pr]Topes ovtco, erpLiKpd
ipcoTr]6evTes bokL\ov KaTareCvovcrL tov koyov. UpcoTayopas b
8e. obe lkovos p.ev p.aKpovs \6yovs Kal KaXovs etTretr, &>s
avrd 8?/Aot, LKavbs be ml ipcoTr]6els diroKpCvacrdaL Kard

fipayv Kal ipop.evos 7TepLp.elvaC re /cat dirobiao-6aL rr]V
aTTOKpLtTLV, a oAtyot? eort rapecrKevacrp.eva. vvv ovv, oo 5

UpcoTayopa, crp.LKpov tlvos ivber)s elp.L ttovt eyeiv, et
p.0L airoKpCvaLo robe. rr]v dperrjv tpfis bLbaKTov eTvai, ml

iyco et7rep dAAa> tco dvdpcoTrcov TreLdoCp.r]v dv, Kal crol ireC6o-
/xat* b 5' idavp.acrd o~ov \eyovros, tovto p.0L iv Tr) \jrv\i} C

dTTOTTXrjpcocrov. ekeyes ydp otl 6 TLevs rr)v bLKaLocrvvqv
Kal Tr)v albco TTep.\f/eLe T0^ dvdpcoTTOLS, kol av 7ToX.Ka\ov iv
tols \6yoLS eAeyero vtto crov r) bLKaLOcrvvr] Kal crcocppocrvvr]
Kal oo-lottjs Kal trdvTa raOra cos ev tl eirj o-v\.Arjfibr]v, 5

x
dpeTr']' TavT ovv avrd bCekOe p.0L aKpL(3cos tco Xoyco, iroTepov
ev p.ev tC icrTLV r) dperr], pdpta be avrrjs icrrLv r) bLKaLocrvvi]
Kal crcocppocrvvr] Kal bo-Lorqs, r? rairr' eo-rtv a vvvbr) iyco
ekeyov iravTa 6vop.aTa tov ovtov evbs ovtos. rotrr' eorij; o d

ert iTTLTTodco.
'AAAa pabLov tovto y, ecprj, u> ScoKpares, oTTOKpCvacrdaL,

utl evbs ovtos rrjs dpcrrjs pdptd icrTLv a ipcoras. TIoTepov,
ecp-qv, cocTTTep TTpocrcoTTOv rd /xdpta pdptd io~TLV, crTop.a re 5
/cat pls Kal 6cp6a\p.ol Kal ooTa, ?/ cotnrep Ta tov \pvcrov p.6pLa
a3 wffirep] obx SxTirfp Hermann a 5 xoXkjo Cobet : xaAKe?a

BT 77X 6 ' K(ti] ?IX 0V Cobet a-roTtiptt T aworivei B bi SoKtxov
W
:
Stephanus : Sohixhy BTWb 3 afca B T : aiirb scr. Par.

181 airoKpivao-daiVJ axoKpiveadai re vera B
: b6 irivT'
BT : Kal TcavT W b8 tîTW: rmv B &v secl. iretdolfj.T}v
Kroschel -rtiOofj.at om. ci. Heindorf (sublata distinctione post av)
c 1 rovr6 B tovt6v T : t[t7 ^fxpl ^ inclusa suppl. b in lacuna : :
om. c a yap '6ti 6 T suppl. b in lac. om. 8 : c 3 ante :
Ka\ t^v lac. in B Tre/jupete Tb ire/j.*** a3 T suppl.

B8 :
b in lac. : om. C 8 ^ ravT T eX t aZ B :

: i
32gd ITAAT&N02
ovbev otacpepet ra erepa t<2v erepoiv, dAA?/Acoi> *cat tov 6\ov,
dAA' ?/ p.eye$L nal o~p,LKpoTr]TL;
'EKeiVco? p.0L (paiveraL, 2)
e ScoKoares, &<nrep ra tov TTpoo~o)7rov p.6pia ex ei Tpos ro 6'Aov
3Tp6o~(i>Trov. ITorepov ovv, r)v 5' eyco, Kat p.Ta\ap.(3dvovo~Lv

o\ avOpooTTOL tovtoov T(2v rrjs apeTrjs p.opio)v ol p.ev aAAo, ot
be aAAo, ?/ avayK-q, eavrrep tls %v Ad/3?7, airavTa eyeiv;-.

5 Ovbap.<2s, e<pr], e-rel 7roA\oi avbpeioi elcriv, aSt/cot be, Kai
StKaioi av, o~o(pol be ov. "Etrriv yap ovv xat ravra fxopia
330 r?/s apeTrjs, e<pr]v eyco, crocpia re Kai avbpeia; YIovtiov

p.a\i(TTa brjTTOV, !(/>?/ Kal p.eyicrTov ye r) o~o<pia t<2v p.opio)v.
E,Kao~Tov be air&v ccttlv, r\v 0' eyco, a\\o, t6 be aWo;

Nai. *H Kat bvvap.iv avrStv eKaarrov Ibiav eyei; (ocntep ra
5 tov TTpoo-oiirov, ovk ecrTLV 6<p$a\p.6s olov tcl S)Ta, ovb* ?/
bvvap.LS avTov r) avrr]' ovbe tS)v a\\o)v ovbev <ttlv olov to

erepov ovre Kard tt)v bvvap.LV ovre Kard tcl dAAa 1
ap' ovv
ovto) Kal tcl rrjs aperrjs /xopta ovk eo~TLV t6 erepov olov to
b eTepov, ovre avro ovtc avrov; bfj\a otl
ovt(os ex et > dnep r
r) bvvap.Ls
7tapabeiyp.aTi ye eotKe;

rj
'AAA' ovrco?,
br)
e(pr}, )(eL, o) 2coKpares. Kat eyco eliTOV Qvbev apa o~tlv
tG)V tt)s aperrjs p.opio)v aWo olov TTLo~n]p.r], ovtV olov

J
5 SiKaiocr?Jz/?7, o?35' otoy avbpeia, oi5' otov o~uxppoa~vvr], ovb
0I0V 6o~l6tT]S. OVK (pt]. p bt], (pT]V y0), KOLVfj 0~K\j/0)-
p.0a TTOLOV TL aVT(OV 0~TLV KaO~TOV. TTpiDTOV p.V TO TOLOvbe'

C r) bLKaLoo~vvrj irpayp.a Ti o~tlv T] ovbev Trpayp.a; ep.ol p.ev
yap boKL- t'l be o~oi; Kd/xot, !</>?/. Ti ovv; el tls epoLTo
r^ epA re koX o~e' " 'i2 Ilpcorayopa re Kai ScoKpares, etireroj^ brj
p.0L, tovto to TTpayp.a d)vop.ao~aTe aprt, r) bLKaLOo~vvr], avro

5 tovto biKaiov eo~TLV ?/ abLKOv;" eyco p.ev av avrco airoKpLvaL-
p.t]V otl bUaLov crv be riv av \j/rj(pov 6elo; tt)v avrr)v ep.ol
d7 to . trepwv secl. Schanz

. . er-pa rwv suppl. b in lac. om. :
6 aWfawv Ka\ rov suppl. b in lac. om. (aAAÂwj/ seci. Sauppe)

:
d.8 fityedei suppl. b in lac. fie**** B

b3 ex el ^ crwKpareiTW
W
:
om. B b 4 fiAAo otov T oAA' oTov B a\\o?ov :

(sed in marg. :
oTov e-Tto-riifj.Ti' ev &\\cp 5e' fiopicov aWoliev) 02 KauoC] Kai /xoi B :
Kal ifioi T
npiiTAroPAs 3 3 oc
?*/ d\\r]v; T?/i> avTijv, ecpry.

"Eorty dpa tolovtov ?/ <3t/cato-
avvr) oXov hUaiov eXvai, tpab]V av eycoye diroKpLv6p.evos rcu
epcoTcovTL' ovkovv Kal o~6;- Nat, !</>?/. Et ovv p-era roSro d

r)pJds epovro- " Otjkow *cai ocrioVrjra rti>d c/)are etrat;"
tpalp.ev av, cos eywuat. Nat, ?)
0' os. .*'
Ovkovv tpare Kat
rovro irpayp.d tl eu>at;" tpaXp.ev dv ?/ 01!; Kat rovro
o~vvetpr). " YloTepov be tovto avrd to irpayp.d tpare tolovtov 5
iretpVKevaL olov dvoo~LOV eti>at ?/ olov octlov;" ayavaKTi]o~aLLi

av eycoy, etprjv, r<3 epcor?/uart, Kal eiVotu' dv E?)c/)?7uei,
v
2> dvdpcoire' o-\o\f] p-evrdv tl cxAAo octlov eh], et u? / aiV?/
ye 7/ do~ioTt]s ocriov ecrrai. rt oe crv; oi>x oflrcos av e
diroKpivaio; Ilarv piev ow, e</>?/.
Et ouv p.era tovto eliroL epcoTcov 7/uas* " n<3? ovv 6\iyov
irpoTepov eAeyere; ap ovk 6p6cos vp.u>v KaTr]Kovo~a; ebotâre
p.01 tpdvaL (rd) rf]s dpeTrjs uo'pta eu>at ovtcos e\ovTa irpbs 5
d\\r)\a, tos ovk eiVat to erepov avrtov oXov to erepov"
ei7rotu' av eycoye ort Td p.ev d\\a opdcos tJKOVcras, otl be
Kal eue otet etVety tovto, irapr]Kovo~as' WpcoTayopas ydp
obe Tavra direKpivaTo, eyco be t)pcoTcov. et ovv clttol' 33 1
" 'AAt/cI^ obe Aeyet, co TTpcorayopa; o~v </>?/s ovk eXvai to
erepov p.6pLov oXov to erepov tcov tt)s dperrjs; o-6s ovros
6 \6yos o~tlv;" tl dv avrco diroKpivaLo; 'AvdyKt], etpt),
6) ScoKpares, ouoAoyetf. 5
Tt ovv, S) TlpcoTayopa, diroKpLVovp.e6a avrto, raCra 6p.o-
\oyr]o-avTS, edv rjp.ds iravepr]TaL' " Ovk dpa ecrrir 6crtor?/s
oXov bUaLov eXvaL irpdyp.a, ovbe 8iKato<rw?j otov octlov dAA'

oXov pir) 60-LOV r) 8' oo-lott^s oXov u?/ bUaLOV, dAA' dbLKOv
apa, to be dv6o~Lov;" tl avrco di70KpLV0vp.eda; eyco p.ev ydp b
avros vixep ye euauroC c/jatr/y dv ml Trp bLKaLOcrvvqv octlov
d1 av T : ffoi B d4 <pa/xei' pr. B (sed suprascr. j) d6 <ryu-

vaKThaain' av
1
T W : ay avaKri\ffaifnev B d7 t<pi}v scr. recc. *<p-ri
W TW
:
BT d8 aiVHj : outtj B
e 5 to tt/s corr. Ven. 189 :
T7Js BTW <^Ta /xSpia} /x6pia ci. Turner (non addito to) ag &\\'
&Zikov scr. Par. 181 1 dAAo 5iWo/
: BTW

33ib riAATi2N02
eu>at koI rqv dcrtdrrjra bUaLov nal rjTreo crov 8e', et /xe ecorj?,
ravTa hv rarjra aTroKpLVOLp.rjv, otl r/rot Tax/Tov y Io-tlv 81-
5 KaioTTjs do-tdrrjri tj ort 6/ioto'raroy, Kat /xdAtcrra , 7rdi/rcov
77 re biKaioo-vvr] olov dcrtdrrjs Kat 77 dcrtdrrj? oToi> 8iKaioamTj.
dAA' opa et StaKcoArjei? aitoKpivta-Oai, rj /cat crot crrjrjSoKet
orjrcos. Od 7rdz>rj juot 8oKet, ec/>rj, co ScoK/rares, ovrcos a7rAow

C elVat, cocrre crrjyxcooTjcrai Tr\v re StKatocrwTjTJ dcrioy etVat Kal
rrjv dcrtdrrrra 8tKaioi>, dAAd rt p.OL 8oKet iv avrco biacpopov

elvat. dAAd rt tovto 8tac/>epet; ec/STj' et yap /3orjAet, ecrrco
^/jtif Kat btKaioo-vvr] oaiov Ka\ dcrtdrrjs 8tKato*>. Mtj /xot, rji'
5 8' eyco* orjSeTJ yd/r cWo/xai rd " et /3o7jAei " rorjro Kat " et
8oKet" eAe'yxecr0at, a AA' e/xe re Kat cre' rd 8' " ejue'

crot
re Kat cre " tovto Ae'yco, olop.VOs orjrco rdv Adyoy /3eArtcrr'
d dy eAe'yxecr0at, e? rts rd " et " dc/WAoi arjrorj. 'AAAd /xeV-

rot, tj 8' 6s, irpocrioLKtv tl SiKatocrrjyrj dcrtdrrjrt' Kat ydp
drtojjy orcoorjrj djurj ye 7rrj 7rpocre'oiKey. ro ydp kevKov rco
jue'Aai>t Ivtlv 07rrj TrpoaeoLKev, Kal rd o-kAtjpotj rco /xaAaKco,
5 Kat raAAa d 8oKet ejjarjrtcorara etjjat dAArjAots' Kat d rdre

ec/>auev dAArjy bvvap.iv exeiy Kat ovk etrjat rd erepov dlov
to eTtpov, tcl tov 7rpocrco7roTj popLa, d/jtrj ye' 7rrj 7rpocre'otKey
Kat ecrrtTJ rd Tpov olov to ereooi/. cocrre rorjrco ye rco rpo7rco
e Kav rarjra eAeyxot?, et /3otjAoio, cos a7rarrd eoTW dttota
dAArjAot?. dAA' otjxi rd 6p.oLov tl eyovTa d/xota StKaioiJ
KaAety, od8e ra av6p.oLov tl eyovTa avop.oLa, kclv irdvv

0-p.LKpov )(ri to op-OLOv. Kat eyco davp.do-as clttov irpos
5 avTov
T
H yap ovtu> crot to bUaLOV koL to oo-lov irpos dAArjAa
eêt, cocrre 6p.oLov tl o~p,LKpov X lv dAArjAots; Orj 7rdrjrj,
332 ec/jrj, ovTcas, ov p.4vT0L ovbe av cos crrj p.0L 8oKets otecrc9at.
'AAAd p.r\v, ec/Jrjy eyco, e7ret8rj 8vcrxepcos 8oKet? p.0L ex ecv
b4 ravra at> ouro Stobaeus b7 airoKpiveadai B : airoKpivaffBai

T <ro\ T : o-i> B C5 oi-Sei/ T 0686 B d3 gr<p o5y TW :
^ W sed
:
oVw oS B d4 oVr; corr. Coisl. : b /j.^ BT :

< suprascr. o
63 ouSf . . . av6)xoia om. Kral 64 i%V ^ '
^X el BT rb '6/j.oiov
secl. Hirschig : rb (ovJ/uoioi/ ^ rb) Suoiov ci. Heindorf
; ; ;
npiiTAroPAs 332a
TTpbs tovto, tovto fxkv cdtrtofxev, Tobt 8e dAAo <3jj eAeye?

y
TTta-K\}/(ofXda. dcppoo-vvrfv tl KaAets; E<p?/. Tovrto r<3
npa.yfj.aTL ov irav tovvovtlov itrrlv r) <ro<pta; "E/xoLye 8okci, 5

e<p?/. rioVepojj 8e orar irpaTTcotrLV avOptoiroL opOtos re Kat
a><peAiua)s, ro're trcocppovtLv <rot 8oko?jo-iij ovrco 7rparrorre?,

[et] TOvvavTLOv [j-irpaTTov]; Scotppovtilv, ttprf. 0?jko?jjj
7/
o-cotppocrvvrf trcotPpovovo-Lv;
'AuayKT?. OtjkotjV 01 fxr) opOcos b
7rpdrrojjres aqbpovcos 7rpdrrou<rtij Kai ov trtotppovovcrLV ovtco
TTpaTTovTes; Su^SoKet uot, e<p?/. Tovvovtlov apa earijj
to dcppovcos TTpaTTUv r<5 crcocppovcos; "Ecprf. Ovko7ji; tcl fx\v
dcppovcos irpaTTOfxeva dcppocrvvrf TrpaTTfTai, rd 8e crtotppovtos- 5

crcocppoo-vvj] <
X2jUoAo'yei. Otjkotjjj e? rt io-x?ji irpaTTiTaL,
Ivyyptos 7rpdrrerat, Kat et rt dcrOeveLq, dcrOevtos; 'E8oKei.
Kat et rt uerd rdxovs, Taxâs, Kat et rt uerd fipabvTrJTOs,
fipabt-cos; "Etprf. Kat et rt bif cocravTcos Trpdrrerat, 7j7ro c
roTj avrov irpaTTtTaL, kol et rt ivavTLtos, vtto tov ivavTCov;
227jjje'</j7/. 4>e'pe brj, rjv 8' iyto, ecrriJj rt KaAoV; 2?j7jexwpet.
Tovtco eo-TLV tl ivavrCov irkrfv to alcrxpov Ovk zcttlv.
Tt 8e'; eortij rt ayaOov; "Eotitj.Tovtco Zcttlv tl ivav- 5

rtoy irkrfv to KaKov; Otjk eortJj. Tt 8e'; eoriij rt 6v iv
(ptovfj; "Etprf. TovTto p.rf ccttlv tl ivavTLOV dkko irkrfv to
j3apv; Ovk 107/. Otjkotjjj, rjv 8' iyto, ivl eKaoTG) Ttov ivav-
TLtOV kv fXOVOV CtTTLV ivaVTLOV KOL OV TToXXd; S7J7JO)jUoAo'yei.
8' rd
"16l brf, rfv iyto, dvakoyLcrcofxzda cofxokoyrffxiva d
iffxlv. tofxoXoyrfKafxev tv kv\ fxovov ivavTiov etyat, 7rAeta)
8e fxrf, .'iljuoAoyT/KajueJJ. T6 8e ivavTLcos TrpaTTOfxevov
V7TO kvavTLtov TTpaTTecrOaL; "Ecprf. 'Q.fxo\oyrfKafxev 8e
ivavTLcos 7rparrecrc9at o dv acppovcos 7rpdrr7/rat r<3 trtotppo- 5
tjo)S TrpaTTOfxivto "Ecprf.' .To 8e o-totppovtos TrpaTTOfxevov
vtto o-totppoo-vvrfs irpdTTecrdaL, to 8e dtppovtos vtto dtppo-

crvvrfs; 2?jjjex(>/)ei. Otjkow enrep evavTLcos irpaTTeTaL, vtto e
a4 t(f>rj B : f <pijy T a5 ov Stephanus : ov B T W Sc- a6

Opwiroi BT : oi ivdpwiroi W a8 ci et (irparTov secl. Stallbaum
b2 irpa.TTovo~iv~\ wpaTTOvai ; Nai' Kal Dobree
W ;
332 e IIAATANOS
ZVdVTLOV TTpUTTOlT UV ,' Nat. X\p6.TTTai o\ TO p.V VTTO
acoqjpoavvqs, to be virb aqjpoavvqs Nat. Evavrio>s; >
Yldvv ye. Ovkovv virb evavrioov ovtojv; Nat. 'Evavriov

5 ap earlv dqjpoavvq acoqjpoaijvqs; Me/x^cat
dpatverai.'
ovv otl ev rots ep.irpoaOev o>p.o\6yqTaL r)pXv dqjpoavvq aoqjiq

kvavT\.ov elvaL; Swco/toAdyet. *Ev be evl p.6vov evavriov
333 elvai; 4>rj/xt. ndreooy ovv, o> Ylpo>Tay6pa, Xvaoopev tcov
\6ya>v; rb ev evl p.6vov evavriov eXvaL, r) eKelvov ev <o eAe'-
yero erepov elvaL acocppoavvqs aoqjia, jxopLov be eKarepov

apeTrjs, kol irpbs t(o eTepov elvaL Kal dv6p.0La Kal avra koa
5 -at bvvdpeLS avrcov, coairep tol tov irpoacoTrov popia; iroTepov
ovv bq \vao>p.ev; ovtol yap ol \6yoL dpcpoTepoL ov irdvv
p.ovaLKcos XeyomaL' ov yap avvqbovaLV ovbe avvappoTTovaLV
dXX-qXoLS. tt&s yap av avvqboLev, elirep ye dvdyKq ev\
b piev ev p.6vov evavriov elvaL, TrkeiocrLV be p.rj, rf] be aqjpoavvr]
evl ovtl crocpia evavria Kal acocppoavvq av cpaiveraL' r) yap,
o> YIpojTayopa, ecprjv eyo>, r) akXtos tto>s; ?Qp.o\6yqaev
Kal p.aX* clk6vto>s. Ovkovv ev av etrj r) acoqjpoavvq Kal r)
5 aoqjia; to be irpoTepov av eqjdvq r)pZv r) bLKaioavvq Kal

fj oaLorqs a-êbov tl ravTov ov.
"\6l br), r\v b' eyco, o> YIpo>Tay6pa, p.r) aTTOKap.o>p.ev aXXa.
Kcu ra Aot7ra bLaaKe\f/o>p.eda. apa ris aoL boKel dbLKcov

C avopcorros aoxppovelv, otl dSiKet; Aiayyvoipvqv av eycoy',
eqjq, o> ScoKpares, tovto opoXoyelv, eirel iroXXoi ye cpaaLV
tu>v avOpcoTTcov. Ildrepoy ovv irpbs eKeivovs tov Xoyov TTovq-
aop.aL, eq>qv, r) irpbs ae; Et (3ovXeL, ecpq, irpbs tovtov
5 TrpcoTOv tov Xoyov bLa\ex.dr]TL tov tG>v ttoXXS>v. 'AA.A.'
ovbev poL bLacpepei, eav p.6vov av ye aTTOKpivq, etr' ovv

boKel aoL Tavra etre p.r]' tov yap Xoyov eycoye /xdAto-ra
e5 aucppoffvvTjs BT W : aoxppoo-vvri Laur. lxxxv. 6 /jLf/xvriffai
corr. Coisl. : fitfivrifiat BT ai irdrepov olv T W : irp6rcpov

ovkovv B Kvawfiev B T \vcrofiev W (teste Kral) a6 \v-
W
:
(rwfiev BT : \vffofifv a8 tv) fiiv tv~\ fort. ev fiev (vl

Kral bi irAtioffiv] irAf/co Heindorf C2 iroWoi^ ol iroKXol
Heindorf C3 t>v] rwv vvv Cobet Koiijffwfiai Heindorf
-
IlP*2TArOPA2 333C
eerdco, arvpj3aLVL /xeVrot tcrcos kcu ipk tov epcorcoi>ra Kal

tov diroKpLVopzvov e<ferdecr0ai.
Td pkv ovv i:pG>Tov eKaAAco7Ttero ijpXv 6 YipcoTayopas tov d
yap Xoyov ^twlto bvaêprj et/Jat e7retra pivTOL crvve\d>pr](Tv
aTTOKpCvto-dai. "10l br'], ecprrrj eyco, e dpxrjs M ot diroKpLvaL.

boKOVO-L TLVS CTOt O-OXppOVCLV dbLKOVVTCS "EoTCO, ecprr.

',
Td 8e craxppovtlv Ae'yets erj cppovtlv;- "Ecprj. Td 8' eu 5

cppovelv erj /3orjAerjeo-(9ai, otl dbLKovcrLv;
"Eorco, e<pr7.
YIoTepov, rjv 8' eyco, et eti 7rpdrrorjcrt7J d8iK0rj/jres r) et KaKcos;

Et Aeyets ovv ayada aTTa
(v. etrjat; Ae'yco.. ''Ap ovv,
r\v 8' eyco,

ravr dyaOd a iarlv ecrrtTj coc/je'Aipa rots av0p(a-
Kat
ttols; TJat /xd At', <pr], kolv prj rois dvdpa>TTOLs e
co<pe'At/jta dyadd. Kat
7/, eycoye KaAco /xot edoKet 6 ripcora-
yopas rjbrj TerpayyvOaL re Kat dycoTjtdy Kat 7raparerdxât
7rpos to airoKpLVtcrOaL' iirtLbr] ovv ka>pa>v avrbv orjrcos eyovra,
v\a{3ovp.VOS rjpipa r)p6pr]v. YloTcpov, r]V 8' eyco, Aeyets, co
rTpcoraydpa, a p.r]bevl dv6pd>Tra>v coc/Je'Ai/xd iorLV, r) h /xr/Se 334

t6 irapatrav co<pe'At/xa; Kat rd rotarjra crrj dyadd KaAets;
Orj8a/xcos, ecprj' dAA' eyaryt 7roAAd 018' d dvdpa>7TOLS pikv
dvaxptXi] ecrrt, Kat crirta Kat ttotcl Kal </jdp/xaKa Kat dAAa
/xrjpta, tcl 8e ye co<pe'Ai/xa' rd 8e dvdpatiTOLS pkv orj8e'repa, 5
t7T7rots 8e'* rd 8e (3ovcrlv povov, rd 8e Krjcrty rd 8e ye tovto>v
pkv ovbtvi, bzvbpoLS 8e'* rd 8e rorj bivbpov rats p.kv ptais
dyafld, rats 8e /3Adcrrats irovrjpd, olov kol t) KO-npos TravTarv

T(2v cpvT(2v rats pkv pCâLS dyaObv Trapaâkkopivr], et 8' b
et9e'Aots e77t tovs TrropOovs Kat rovs yeorjs KAcoyas e7Tt/3dAAeiy,
7rdyra d7^dAArJc^; e7iet Kat to eAatoy rots pkv cprjrots airao-iv
kcrTLV TrdyKaKov Kal raXs OpL^Xv 7roAe/xtcoraroij rats rcoy dAAcoy
Ccocoy 7rAf/y rats rorj dv6pa>Trov, rals bk tov dvdpd>TTOv dpa>ybv 5
c8 <rv nfiaiv ti T: crvfx.âifftv B d3 airoKpivuaBai Hirschig

d6 2t<] 8t6 ci. Hermann 6't aSj/coCir^ secl. Schanz d7 /
tSTW: 3 B 63 7rapaTToxât] irapaTtTaaOai Kock a3 o!8'
& corr. Coisl. o!8a :BT a 7 oiiSe ft] ouSeVi Naber a 8 oVpos
T Kunpos d> in fine versus B sed w obscuratum
! b 1 irapafiaK-
\ofj.ivr\ irtptfia\\o)xsvri Naber 8' f0t\ois B 8t 0e\ois T ;
334 b nAATilNOS
kclI t<o dAAco o-copari. ovtu> be ttolklKov tl Icttlv to ayaOov
Kal iravTobaiTov, cocrre Kal evrav6a rots piev eto6ev tov
C rrcafxaros dyadov <\<ttlv t<o dv6p<aiT<o, rots 8' cvtos ravrov
TOVTO KQLKLO~TOV' KOL 8ld TOVTO OL laTpol TTaVTS aTTayOpeVOVCTLV
tols dcrdevovcrLV p.r) \pr)<r6aL eAatcp dAA' r/ otl crp,LKpoTaT<o
ev tovtols ols pe'AAet e8ecr0at, oo~ov p.6vov rr\v bvcryepeLav
5 Karao-/3eVat rr)v errl rats alcr6r\<Teo-L rats 8td rcov pircov
yLyvopn-vrjv kv rots crtrtots re Kat o\fsoLS.
Et7roVros ovv ravra avrov ol irapovTes avedopv(3r)crav <as

T
ev Ae'yot, kol eyco eliTOV i2 IIptoTayopa, eyco Tvyyavoa <\ttl-
\f)crp.<ov tls <ov avdpctiTTOs, Kat edv rts juot p.aKpa keyr\,
d <\TTL\av6avop\aL irep\ ovavfj 6 Adyos. <o<Tirep ovv et ervy\avov

VTTOKaxpos <ov, <oov h.v yjprjvaL, eXrrep ejueAAe's p,ot 8taAe'ecr0at,
p,eibi> <p6eyye<rdaL r) TTpbs tovs dAAous, ovtco kol vvv, e7ret5r/
TTL\r]crp.ovL evervxes, 0-vvTep.ve p.0L rds diroKpLcreLS kol
5 fipayyrepas ttoUl, et /xe'AAco cot e7recr0at.

IIcos ovr KeAevets /xe fipayea d-rroKpLveadaL; r) fipayyTepd
croL, e<pr\, diroKpLv<op.aL rj bel;
MrjSapcos, ?/i> 8' eyco.
'AAA' oaa 8et; ec/>?/.
e Nat, r)v 8' eyco.
llorepa ow ocra epot boKel belv diroKpLvecrdaL, roaavrd

<tol aTTOKpLVcapxLL, r\ 6o~a <tol;
'AKT/Koa yovv, riv 8' eyco, 6'rt crv oto's r' et Kat avrds Kat
5 akkov 8i8dat 7rept t&v avr&v Kal /xaKpd XeyeLV, eav \3ovkr\,
ovt<os doore tov Xoyov p.r\beiTOTe e7riAi7retr, Kal av fipayea
335 ourcos axrre p.r\beva <rov t\v (SpayyrepoLs elirelv' el ovv

/ute'AAets ep.ol 8taAe'êcrâi, t<2 eTep<a \p<a rpoVo) 7rpo's p.e,
Trj /3paxi>Aoyta.
'II SwKpares, ecpr/, eyco TroAAots rjbrj ets dycoya Ao'ycoy
C 5 iirl rcus alcrd-l]ffitri rcus secl. ci. Torstrik 8to twv pivwv] rwv
evKpwuiv Bergk 8ia twv xH- wv '' Kroschel m d 7 a-roKpivw/iat
W
:
T : ai-oKpivofiai BW ^]i|BT e3 airoKpivofiai B T diro- :
Kpivwfiai Par. 1608 e4 T

o-{; : <roi B aa xptb Tpimw B: Tp6irtf

nPiiTArOPAS 3 35 a
dcpiKOfxrjv dvOpojiroLS, Kal et tovto eiroCovv o o~v KeAeuets, 5
cbs 6 a.VTik*ya>v eKe'AeueV pe 8taAe'yecr0ai, ovtco bukeyofi-qv,
ovbevbs av /3eArtW (qjaLv6p.r]v oib' av eyiveTo HpojTayopov

ovop.a iv tols "Ekkqo~LV.
Kal eyco iyvojv yap otl ovk r/pecrer avrbs avrai raty
airoKpio-^cnv rais tintpocrOtv, Kal ort ovk e0eA?/crot kodv etrat b
cnroKpivopievos 8taAe'yecr0ai i]yr]crdp.evos ovkcti epor Hpyov
etrat Traptlvat kv rats o~vvovo~iaLs, 'AAAd rot, tqjqv, co
YlpojTayopa, ov5' eyco At7rapcos \oi irapa rd croi boKovvra

ttjv crvvovcriav i)puv yiyveadai, dAA' tireibav crv fiovkr) 5
5taAe'yecr0ai cos eyco bvvafxai eVecrtfai, totc ctol 6taAe'o/xai.
o~v fjitv ydp, cbs Ae'yerat 7rept crou, qjrjs Se kol avros, Kal iv
p.aKpokoyia Kal (V fipaxykoyiq olos r' et crtwoucrias 7rotetcrc9ai
o~oqjbs yap et eyco 5e ra fxaKpa Tavra abvvaros, e7ret C

((3ovk6fj.r]v av olos r' etrat. ctAAa o~\ (XPV V VP^V ovyyoaptiv
rbv dpcpoVepa bvvdfxevov, tva fj o~vvovo~ia eytyrero' vvv 6e
eTTcibr] ovk e#e'Aets Kat epot rts dcrôAta ecrrty Kat ovk av olos
t drjv o~ol 7rapapetz>at airoTtivovTL fxaKpovs koyovs .eA0eti> 5
ydp ixoi pe 6et etpr erret Kat ravr av Io~ojs ovk dtfb&s o~ov
TjKOVOV.
Kat dfxa raijr' et7rcbi> dvLcrrdfxqv cbs d7ricoV Kat pou

avLo-Tap.ivov e7rtAap,/3dz>erat 6 KaAAtas rrjs x e -Ps fr) 6efta,
rfj
0' apLo~Tepq di>reAd/3ero tov rpifiojvos TOVTOvi, Kat ei7rev d
Ovk dqjqcrofxiv cre, cb ScoKpares* edu ydp crv i*kdt]s, ovx
bfxoiojs r/ptf ecrovrat 01 StdAoyot. 8e'opat ovy crou irapa-
petvat 7/pty cos eycb otj5' dy eiôs r/8tor aKovo~aLp,L 7/ cro{) re
Kat YlpojTayopov bLakeyofj.4vojv. akka xapt^ctt r/pty 7racr\ 5
Kat eycb (Ittov- 7/877 8e dyetcrr7/K7/ cbs (ia>v -*X2 7rat
iTTTrovtKou, det pey eycoye' crou rqv cptAocrocptay dyapat, drdp

Kat yjjy e7raij;cb Kat 0tAcb, cocrre /3ovkoifxr]v &v x a P^C<r ^ a ^
a 7 tytvtTO ] iKeytro Kroschel b 2 r)yr]o-a.fifPos B T fiyr-ffa- W :
,uei/os ouj/ ci. Heindorf C3 ^ W:

om. BTc6 Im t: ju
BT C9 aviaTa/jLtvov T : dôo-ToueVou B 6.2 n-b T <roi B (sed :
u suprascr. B)2
d 6 aveffTr)KTf B t : kvt(rTt]Kti T
335 ITAATGNOS
<xot, et p.ov bvvara deoto* vvv d' e<rrti> uto-Ticp av et bioio
/iov Kpio-covL r<S 'Ip.epaiu> bpop.(l aK.p.a(pVTi eVecrclat, 77 tS>v
bokL\obpop.cov tw t] tG>v r)p.epobpop.tov btaddv re nal (irco-daL,
336 ei7roi/u av crot drt 7roAv aov jmWov eya> ep.avrov oeo/xat
tVoucri/j tovtols aKoXovdelv, dAA' ov yap bvvap.ai, dAA' et rt
berf #ed<ra<r#at tv r<p avrGt e/xe re fcat KpL&tova Otovras,

tovtov biov o-vyKadelvaL' eyw p*v yap ov bvvap.ai ra\v 6elv,
5 ovtos 8e SuVarat /3pae'cos. et ovV e7ri0uj(xets e/xorj Kat ITpcora-
yopOV O.KOVCLV, TOVTOV beOV, lOO"TTp TO TTp&TOV IJ.OL aTH-KpLVaTO
8td fipayetov re /cat avrd rd epcorco/xeya, ourco Kat vvv airoKpL-
b Vo-$aL' et 8e pr/, rfc 6 Tpoiros ecrrat r<3i> dtaAdyco/j; x^P' 5
ydp eycoy' cpjurjj; ei/jai rd cruyetrat re dAAr/Aots StaAeyopieVorjs
/cat rd br\p.r\yopLV.
'AAA' dpas; e<prr, to 2coKpares, dtKata doKet Ae'yety
5 UpcoTayopas dt<2/j a7jra> re e<fetvat diaAeyeaflai O7rcos /3otj-
Aerat, /cat crv ottcos av av crv /3otjAt?.
'TiroXafttov ovv 6 'AAKt/3td8r7S, Ov /caAcos Ae'yets, ecpry, co
KaAAta* ScoKpdrrrs /xev ydp o8e 6/xoAoyet p.r) //eret/jat ot
jua/cpoAoytas /cat irapaxtopel Ilpcoraydpa, rorj de 8taAe'yecrât

C otds r' etrat xat e7r&rra<r(9ai Ao'yov re 8owat Kat 8ea<r<9at
<9arj/xd(foipi' dz; et rcp avdptaTTtov Ttapayjupti. et p.e7J otjtj /cat
ripcoraydpas dpioAoyet cpavAdrepos eT/jat ScoKpdrous dtaAe-

yQr)vaL, eapKet ScoKpdrer e de djjrtTroieirat, dtaAeye'<r<9co
5 epcorco/j re Kat cmoKpLVop.tvos, /xr) ecp' eKacrrT7 eptoTrjo-eL
ixaKpbv koyov airoTHLVtov, (KKpovtov tovs Xoyovs Kal ovk edi-

d Acov dtddyat Adyor, dAA' d7ro/ArjKWcoi' ecos dy e7TiAd(7Wrat 7rept
drou rd epcorr7p.a rjr ot 7roAAot rcov dKo^;oVrco7J , e7ret 2coKparr/
ye eyco eyyucopiat p:r) e7rtAr7crecr<9at, ovx. drt 7ratXei Kat <prj<rty
e7rtAr/cr/jtcoi' etmt. ep,ot pter oui; doKet e7rtetKe'crrepa ^,(t)KpaTr]s

5 Ae'yety xp7) ydp ^Kao-Tov rr)v kavTov yv<op,r)v a.TTO(paLVor6aL.
63 Spofiu aKfidfrvTi secl. v. Priusterer tV(r{ai secl. ci. Kroschel

e 4 t* cal eVeo-t/ai secl. Cobet a 6 Stow T2 : 5e'ot BT a 6 yuoi
T: 8 potB b 4 8ok? B t ? : T b6 tri T (<rol t) : <roi B
d 3 iyyvwfxat t iyyvw Kal B T
:

ITP&TArOPAS 336d
Merd be rbv 'AAKt/3td8?/r, co? eycouat, Kptrta? ?/i> 6 etVcoV

?
fl ripoSiKe Kat '\i77Tia, KaAAta? uei> 8oKet uot udAa irpbs
Ylptorayopov etmt, 'AA/ci/3tdo7j? oe det cpiAdViKo'? eort 7rpd? o e

di> dpu?/cr?/ r)p.as be o{roef oet crvp.(pLkovLKeiv ovre ScoKpdret
v
otlre ITpcoraydpa, dAAd KOtrTj dp.(poTeptov oeto-flai u?/ p.erav
bia\va~at ri]V crvvovcrCav.

Et7roVro? oe avrov ravra, 6 ripo'8tKO?, KaAco? uot, e(prj, 337
SoKets keyeiv, u> Kptrta* XP/ y a P ro ^ ? ^ rototo-8e Adyot?
iiapayiyvop.ivovi kolvovs p.ev elvat dp.(poiv Toiv StaAeyoueV olv
aKpoaTas, Xaovs be u?/ eorty ydp ov tovtov kolvt) piev yap
aKOva-ai oet dp.cpoTeptov, p.r) Xcrov oe veip.aL eKarepco, dAAd 5
rco uei> oocpcorepcp TrAeoy, rco oe dp.a6ecrTepco eAarroy. eyco
u> Kat avro'?, co Ilpcoraydpa re Kat 2)co/cpares, dtco vpd?

oi>yx<opeu> Kat dAA?/Aot? 7rept rcoy Adycoi> d/xcptcr/3?/rety ueV,
epCêLV 8e p?/ dpcptcr/3?/ro?jcrt uey ydp Kat 81' evvoiav 01 b
cptAot rot? cptAoi?, epCôvcriv oe ot biacpopoC re Kat e\6pol
dkkrjkots Kat o?5rco? dy KaAAtor?/ T/uiy ?/ o-woucrta yiyvoiTO"

vuet? re ydp 01 Ae'yoi>re? udAtar' di> ovrco? eV t/uu> rot?
aKOvouo-ty etôKtuotre Kat ovk eiraLVoio-6e evboKLpeiv p.ev 5
ydp ecrriy irapd rat? yjlrvyais tQ>v aKOVovrcov dvev a7rdr?/?,

eiraLveicrdaL be ev Adyco 7roAAaKt? 7rapd boav rrevbop.ev<x>v
7/uet? t av ol aKovovres udAtcrr' av ovtcos evcppaLVoCp.eda, c
ox>x rjboCp.ecrda evcppaCvecrdaL p.ev yap Zcttlv p.avddvovTa tl
koX (ppovr/crecos p.eTakap.^dvovra avTrj rrj biavoCa, rjbecrdaL be
ecrdCovTa tl r) aXXo rjbv irao-xovTa avrQ> rco crmp.aTL.^
Tatrra ovv elirovTos tov YIpobCKOv 7roAAot 7rdyi t&v 5
TrapovTcov aTrebiâvTO' p.Ta be tov TlpobLKOV 'I7r7rta?
crocpd? et7rer, *X2 avbpes, e(prj, ol irapovTes, r)yovp.aL eyco
vp.as crvyyeveis re Kat oLKeCovs ml 7roAtras a7rai>ra? etrat

(pvcrei, ov vopa>' to yap 6p.0L0V rco dpotco cpvcreL crvyyeves d
e 1 JBTW: Sti in marg. T a 1 (<pr) T : i<prjs B a 2 rovs

t : rols BT b3 ovtoos Uv KaWiffTri BT : icdWiffT' (xv ovrws W
bs iiraivoTffOt B : iiratveTffde T (sed suprascr. 01) C2 ifioiixeffOa
B : r)Soi/xeda T c8 fyuSs] ^,u2s Heindorf
PLATO, VOL. III. 15

337d IIAAT&N02
ecrrtv, 6 be vop.os, rvpavvos (bv tu>v av6pu)TTu>v, irokka. irapa
tt]V (pvariv /3tderat r)p.as ovv alcryjpbv tt\v p.ev cpvaLV tu>v
Trpayp.aTU>v elbevai, o-o(pu>Ta.Tovs be ovras tu>v 'Ekkr]vu>v, nal
5 Kar avTo tovto vvv o-vvekrjkvdoTas Trjs re 'EAAdSos ds amb

to irpvTavelov rrjs crocpias koX ai/Trjs Trjs irokeobs ets tov
p.eyLo-Tov Kal 6k(3LU>TaTov olkov Tovbe, p.r]bev tovtov tov
e at,(op.aTos dftov a-no(pr]vao-6aL, dAA' u>o-nep tovs (pavko-
tcltovs t&v av6po)iru>v Sia<pe'pecr0at akki]koLS. eycb p.ev ovv
Kal beop.aL Kal a-vp.(3ovkevu), S Ilpcoraydpa re Kal 2co/cpare?,
(rvp.j3r}vaL vp.as a>o-irep vtto Statrryrcoy r)p.Q>v avp.(3L(3a6vTu>v
338 ets to p.eo-ov, Kal /x?jre cre to a.Kpij3es tovto elbos tS>v
bLaXoycov Qqrdv to /card (3paxy kiav, d p.r) rjbv Ilpcoraydpa,
dAA' e<peu>at /cat
x a ^ a(Ta Ta $ yvias <- rots Adyots, tva p.eya-
koirpeTreo-TepoL koX evo-yr\p.oveo-TepoL r)pXv (f)aivu>VTaL, p.r]T av
5 YIpu>Tayopav iravTa Kaku>v eKTeivavra, ovpiq ecpeVra, cpevyeLV
els to irekayos tu>v koyu>v airoKpv\jravTa yr)v, akka. p.ecrov
tl ap.(f>oTepovs Tep,elv. u>s ovv 7roi?jcrere, /cat ireideo-de p.0L
pa(3bovxv Kai ' eTTLo-raTrjv /cat irpvTavLv ekecrdaL bs vpuv

b <puAdet to peVptoy p,rJKOS tu>v Xoyu>v e/carepou.
Tavra ypecre rots irapovcrL, /cat Tra.VTes eirriveo-av, Kal ep,e
re 6 KaAAias ovk ecprj aq^rio-eLV Kal ekecrdaL ebeovro eiTLO-Ta.Tr]v.
elirov ovv eyu> otl alcrxpbv etrj (3pa(3evTr)v eAeVflat tu>v koyu>v.
5 elre yap x,eipu)V eorai r)p.G)V 6 alpedeis, ovk 6pdu>s av eôL

tov x e V" v (3eX.TL6va)v eiTLcrTaTetv, etre 6p.oLos, ovb*
ovtu>s 6p6u>s' 6 yap 6p.oLos r)pXv 6p.0La /cat TrotTjcret, cSore K
C irepLTTov fiprjo-eraL. dAAd br) (ieXriova r)p.u>v alprjo-eo-de. rr)
p.ev akrjdeiq, co? eyco/xat, abvvarov vp.lv coore Ilpcoraydpoi;

Tovbe cro(pu>Tp6v TLva ekeo-6aL' et be alpricreo-de p.ev p,r]bev
d6 au-TTjs] o5 Bekker rbv"] rb BT (sed v in marg. B 2

et add. in
textu rec. b) a3 koX xaXaa-ai secl. Cobet a4 tj/juv W vfuv
BT a 5 koXwv W t : kuKov B : Ka\ov T a7 TroWjtrere] iroi-fjo-are
:
Beck 7re(0<r0e] ireio-to-dt scr. Ven. 184 iridearde : (et mox k\4cr0e
Naber) b3 re] ye ci. Heindorf eXeaOai B T : yp. alpe?<r6ai in
marg. T c 1 rjpfjfferai B : rjp-fio-erai T : elp-fifferai W (sed ai supra
et) t aip-fiffeffde scr. recc. : aip-ficrecrdai BT W C 2 6/j.7v Siffre] ov
v/Mv Xffre Badham C3 aip-fjffeffde"] awfi<reff8ai re vera B
nP12TArOPA2 338 c
/3eArtco, cprjrrere be, alcryjpbv kol tovto rcobe ytyyerat, cocnrep

cpavXco dv6pcoi;co k-ruo~TaTr\v alpelcrdaL, eirel to y ephv ovbev 5
p.01 bLacpepet. dAA' ovtcoctI edeXco 7rotr/crat, Iv o irpodvp.elcrde

crvvovcria re Kat dtdAoyot ûty yiyvcovraL' et ut) /3odAerat
FTpwrayopas aTTOKpivecrdaL, ovtos p.ev epcoTarco, eyco de diro- d
Kptforjuat, /cat afia 7retpdcrouai arjrco detat cbs eyco cpr7pt
Xpijvai tov aTroKptvopLavov airoKptvecrdaf e7retddv Se eyco
dtroKpivcop.aL ottoct av ovtos /3orJArrrai epcoTav, Tiakiv ovtos

euot Adyof virocr\eTco ouctcos. edz> oSy u^ doKr) irp66vp.os elvat 5
7rpds avrd rd epcoTcop.evov diTOKpivecrdaL, kol eyco Kat vuets kolvt)
bet]cr6p.e6a avroiS a7rep rjuets euorj, ut^ biacpdeipeLV Ti]V ctvv-
ovcriav Kal ovbev det tovtov eveKa eva e7Ttcrrdrrjy yevecrOai, e

dAAd 7rdyres kou>tj e7rtcrrarr/crere. 'EdoKet iracrLV ovtco ttoly]-
reov eTvat' ko.1 6 YlpcoTayopas 7rdi>rj piev ovk ijOeXev, ducoy

be r]vayKacr6r] duoAoyr/Vat epcoTrjcreiv, Kal eireLbav LKavcos
epcoTi]crr], iraXLV bcocreLV Xoyov Kara crp.LKpbv diroKpLv6p.evos. 5
v
Hparo ovv epcoTav ovTCocri ttcos' 'Hyorjpat, ecprr, co 2co-
Kpares, eyco avbpl iraLbeias p.eyLcrTov p.epos etrat 7rept eTrcoy

beLvbv elvaL' ecrTLV be. tovto tcl vtto tcov TTOLrjTcov Xey6p.eva 339
oXov t elvaL crrjzneVat a re opdcos 7re7rotrjrat Kat d p.r\, Kal
eiricrTacrdaL bLeXelv re Kat epcoTcop.evov Xoyov bovvaL. kcxl br)
kcxl vvv ecrrat rd epcorrrpa 7rept rorj avrov piev irepl ovirep eyco
re Kat ctv vvv bLakeyop.e6a, irepl apeTr)s, p.eTevr)veypAvov 5

5' ets iroir]crLV toctovtov p.6vov dtotcret. Aeyet ydp ttov
Eipcovtdrj? 7rpd? ^Koirav tov KpeovTOS vbv tov erraAorj otl
avbp* dyadbv p.ev dXaOecos yevecrdat yjxXettov, b
yepcriv re Kat 7rocrt Kat voco Terpdycovov, dvev \j/6yov
Tervyp.evov.
tovto e7rtcrracrat rd acrpa, r) -ndv ctol bLeeX6co;
C 4 cpfaer* W ^creTOj B C 5
T : T alpucrOat alpecrdat B C6 yuoi
W
:
8a<ppei] /cwA.u{ Cobet d4 airoKplvwnai t airoKpivofj.ai BT

6Vws T W
:
îrrfir' B : a4 B T a5
rb : ti^ vvv Sia\ey6fj.eda BT vvv
W
:
Sie\(y6fifOa : vvv Stallbaum

8)] 5ie\(y6fj.(6'a ci. fj.eTtv7fveyfj.evov Ast
b 1 4/Sp'] &vSpa B T W b 2 x a^ BTW eP X*P**
15*
.
339b ITAATX2N02
5 Kat eyco (Ittov otl Ovbev der e7rtd-rapat re ydp, kol irdrv
Ixol TvyydveL pepeAr/Kos rorj atrparos.

Erj, ecp-q, keyeis. Trorepov ovv KaAcos crot doKet 7re7roir/cr0ai
/cat opdcas, t) ov; Tidvv, ecprjv eyco, (xaAcos) re Kat dp&M?.
AoKet bi ctol KaAcos 7re7rotr/trt9ai, et evavrCa Ae'yet arjrd?
10 arjrco 6 7rotr/rr/s; Orj KaAcoy, 8'
"Opa
C /3eArtoz\
'AAA', chyade, ecrKeppai tKavcos.
r]y eyco.
Otcrfla orjV,
S?7, ec/)rj,
ec/>r/,
ort TTpoiovTos tov qcrp.aTOs Ae'yet ttotj

orjde' p.0L eppeAe'cos ro IltrraKetoy vep.erai,
Katrot crocpov irapa cptoTos elpr]p.evov x.aAe7roi> t/>ar' ecrOkbv
5 ep.p.evaL.
evvoels otl 6 avrbs ovtos Katrdde Ae'yet KaKelva tol ep.TTpocr6ev;
Ot8a, r/v 8' eyco. AoKet ow o-ot, e</>r/, ravTa eKeCvoLS dpoAo-
yelcrdaL; 4>atWrai e/xotye (koi ajua peVrot ecpo(3ovp,rjv pr/
rt Ae'yot) drdp, ecpt]v eyco, crot orj cpaCveraL; ITcos yap av
d cpaCvoLTO dpoAoyety avrbs earjrco d rarjra dp.cpoTepa Xeytov,
os ye to p.ev TrpS>TOv avrbs v-neOeTo yaXeTrbv elvaL dvbpa
dyadbv yevecrBaL dXadeCq, okCyov be tov iroLr\p.aTos els to
irpocrdev irpoeXdcov e7reAd#ero, Kal ULTTaKov tov TavTa

5 Xeyovra earjrco, drt \akeTrbv ecrdXbv ep.p.evaL, tovtov
p.ep.cpeTaC re Kat orj cprjcrLV aTTobeyecr6aL avTov rd arjrd earjrco
keyovTos; Katrot oTroTe tov rarjrd Aeyoz^ra arjrco p,e'pc/)erai,
brjkov otl Kal eavTov p.ep.cpeTaL, coare r/rot to irpoTepov r/
vcrrepov ovk opdcas Aeyet.

io Et7rcoi> ovv Tavra Tiokkols Oopvftov Ttapecryev kol eiraLVOv
e tS>v aKovovToov Kal eyto to piev TTp&Tov, cocr7repet rj7rd dyaOov
ttvktov 7rAr/yet?, ecrKOTcaOrjv re Kat tAtyyiacra ei7roWo? avTov
raura Kai t&v aWtov eTTL6opv/3r}crdvTO)V' eireLTa- co? ye 7rpds
b7 oZv scr. recc. oS : T : ov re vera B W b8 y<&, ica\ws n

Bekker iyd re B eywye T W C3 iriTrdicftov W n-tTrd.Kiov BT
BT W
: : :
C4 (pdr'] tpaTo i<r\bv Boeckh d3 a.\a9eiq re vera B t:

akrjOetq T d.8 %toi tJ> yp. t et fort. ante ras.T : ityolTo B et in
ras. T irpSTepov T 2
: ir^npov BT d ro koI firaivov secl.
Sauppe e2 fotyyfaura t : etAt^^/atra BT

nP&TATOPAS 33ge
(T elprja-dat Takrjdrj, tva /uot X p6vos eyyevryrai rfj crKeyj/ei tC

keyoi. 6 770117717? TpeTrop.ai 77009 tov YlpobiKOV, Kal KaAeVas 5
avrov, '12 TlpobiKe, ecpr]v eyco, cros pevroi 2t.p.a)vCbr]s irokCTiqs'
biKaios et (3or)6eiv rco avbpC. 8okco ovv /uot eyco TrapaKakeiv 34

o-e* axnrep t-(pr) "Oprjpos tov "2,Ka]xavbpov irokio pKovp:evov vtrb
tov 'AîAAeW tov 2t/uo'ez>ra irapaKakeiv, elrrovTa
cptAe Kao-CyvrjT, adevos dvepos dp.qboTepoC irep
a X &p.V, 5
drdp Kal eya> cre irapaKaka), /ut/ fjfuv 6 Upcorayopas rbv
"2ip.(i)vCbr)v eKTTepar). Kat yap ovv Kal 8etrat ro V77ep 2t/uco-
i>t'5ou k-nav6p6oip.a rrjs arjs povo-iKrjs, rj to re /3ovkeo-dai, xat

TTidvp.eiv biaipeis cos ov Tavrbv ov, kol\ a vvvbi) elires Trokka b
re /<ai KaAd. /cat zw o-KOTrei et crot cnjyooKet cnrep e/uot.
ov yap (paCveraL evavrCa keyeiv avrbs aurco 2ip.eovCbr)s. crv
ydp, cb YIpobiKe, TrpoaTroqbrjvat, rf]v crf]V yva>pr)v tovtov crot
boKel elvai to yevecrdai Kal to elvai, fj dkko; AAAo v

vf) At", 5
eqbq 6 TIpobiKos. Ovkovv, eq>r]v eyco, ev pev toIs TrpcoTOis

axiTos 6 '2ip.(ovCbr)s Ti]v eavrov yva>\xr]V direqb^vaTo, oti avbpa
dyadbv akqOeCq. yeveaOai xakenbv evq; ?Akr)6rj key eis, eqbq c
6 TlpobLKos. Tbv be ye IIirraKoV, i]v 8' eyco, /ue^cperat, ovx
cos oterat Ilpcoraydpas', ravrbv eavrco keyovra, dAA' dAAo.
ov yap tovto 6 IT trraKO? ekeyev to x a Ae77oV, yeveo~6ai
eo~6k6v, cocrirep 6 St/ucoznSr/S', dAAd to eppevaL' ecrriv be ov 5
TavTov, 2) IlpcoTayopa, a>s qbr)criv TlpobiKos obe, to elvat Kat
to yeveo~6ai. et be pi) to avro ecmv to elvai rco yeveadai,
ovk evavrCa keyet 6 2i]MovCbr]s avrbs avrco. Kat tcrcos' av
qbaCr) YIpobiKos obe Kal akkoi 770AA01 Kad' 'HcrtoSoy yeve- d
crcât pt.ev ccyadbv xakeirbv elvat yap aperrjs
rrjs Zp.irpo-
crdev tovs deobs tfipcora deivai orav be rt? avrrjs ets
aKpov iKrjTai, pr)'ibCr]v 8?/77etra irekeiv, âkeirrjv
irep eovo-av, eKTrjo-dat. 5
6 4 776I/TJT01 W : fKyeurirai BT 65 Ae'701 B W : \eyet T

C 4 to xaAeiro' B TW : xo-^rrov Sauppe C 6 o&e Bt : ovSe T
d5 eKrrjo-dM scr. recc. : KTTJadai BT W

34od ITAAT&N02
'O p.ev ovv TTpo'8tKos aKovo~as ravra kitr\vs.n-kv pe #
6 8e
rTpcoraydpas, To e7ra7jdp0copd aoL, e<pr\, S> ScoKpares, peifoTJ
apLaprripLa exei V c-Travopdols.
Kal eyfa) et7roy KaKOTj dpa p.0L etpyacrrat, cos colkcv, oo
e npcoraydpa, Kat etpt rts yeAotos tarpds* tcopcTJos /xet^bv ro

v6crrjp.a 7rotco.
'AAA' O7j'rcos ex et ^ 7?*
ITcos 877; t/tj 8' eyco.
5 IToAAtj ai, ecp??, dp.a6(.a et?/ roi 7rotrjrou, et ot/rco cpavkov

ti (prjaiv elvat. tt)v apeTTiv cKTrjo-daL, 6 co~tlv irdvroiv yahc-
TTOiTarov, cos airao~i,v boKci dvdpoiiroLS.
Kat eyco et7roy Nt/ w Ata, ets Kaipov ye irapaTCTvyr\Kcv

rjp.lv kv rots Adyots ITpo'8iKos 68e. Kty8wevet ydp rot, co
34 1 ITpcoraydpa, 17 ITpoStKOTj aocpia 0eta rts etTjat 7rdAat, ?/rot
airb 2tp,cozu8o?j dpap.cvr\, ?/ Kat ert 7raAatore'pa. crv 8e

dAAco7J 7roAAcoy ep,7retpos cotj TavTrjs a7retpos etTjat (paCvr}, ov^
cocr7rep eyco ep7retpos 8td ro p.a6r\Tr\s eti>ai ITpo8iKo?j ro7jroui*
5 Kat tjtOV fxot SoKets ov p.av6dvcLV ort Kat ro "xaAe7roi>" tcwto

tacos 07jx otjtcos StpcoinSr/s ime-\dp.fiavev (oo-nep cr?j vnoXap.-
(3dvLs, dAA' cotnrep 7rept ro> " 8ewo?j " IIpo'8iKds pe ovrocri
7ô?jt9eret eKacrrore, oray eiraLV&v eyco 77 tre 77 cxAAotj rtra

Aeyco 6'rt ITpcoraydpas trocpos Kat 8ei7Jos ecrrty a7J?/p, epoira
b et 07jk alo-yyvop.aL Taya6a 8et7ja KaAcoTj. ro ydp 8et7Jo'7J,
(prjo-Cv, KaKov ecrrty ovSets yo?J7J Aeyet eKacrrore " 8etvo?j

7rAo?jT07j " o?j8e " beLvrjs dpr)vr\s" o?j8e " 8et^?/s Tjyietas," dAAd
" " Kat " 8et7Jo?j 7roAe'p,o?j " Kat " 8et7J?^s Trevias,"
8et7J?/s TJocroTj
5 cbs tov bc-LVOv KaKov ovtos. Tcrcos 07J7J Kat to " xaAe7rov " av ot
Ketot Kat 6 2ipco7Jt8?/s ?) KaKov vTro\ap.f}avovo~L r\ aAAo rt
o cru o?j p.av6avw epcopefla ow ITpoStKOTJ bUaLOV yap Ti]v
2tpco7Jt8o?j <po)vr)v tovtov ipojTav rt eAeyeTj, co IToo'8tKe, r6

C " x a ^ e,roy " 2tpco7jt8?/s;
KaKoV, ecp?/.
e2 7rojaj] iroiuv Hirschig

.
npnTAroPAs 341 c
Atd ravr apa kol p.ip.cpeTaL, rjv d' eyco, co IIpo'8tKe, tov
YliTTaKov keyovra xakeirbv ecrdkbv ep.p.evaL, wcnrep av
et ijKOvev avrov keyovros ort eoTU> KaKov icrdkbv fp.pi.evaL. 5
'AAAd rl otet, ecpr/, keyeLV, u> ScoKpares, 2,Lp.(ovibr]v akko

7) tovto, Kal 6veLbieLV rco IltrraKcp ort ra 6v6p.aTa ovk r)iri-
maTo 6pda>s 8taipeii> are Ae'cr/3tos cov Kal ev cpcavr) (3ap(3dpco
re6pap.pevos;
'Akovzls brj, Zcprjv eyco, co npcoraydpa, TlpobLKOV rovbe. 10
eêis tl irpbs ravra keyeiv; d

Kat 6 IIpcoTaydpaj, IloAAoiS ye 8et, ecpr], ovtcos eye.Lv, u>
"
YlpobLKe' dAA' eyco ev 018' ort Kat 2iLp.a)vibrjs to " xakeirbv
eAeyeu 07rep r)pels 01 aAAot, ov to KaKov, dAA' o di> pr/
pabiov 77 dAAa 8td 7roAAcoz> Tipayp.aT(x>v yiyvrrraL. 5
'AAAd Kat eycb otpat, ecpr]V, u> Ylpcorayopa, tovto keyeLV

^Lpu>vibr]v, Kal YlpobLKOv ye ro'i>8e et8ei>ai, dAAd 7rateii> kol
crov boKelv aTTOTrcLpacrdaL et oto's r' ecr?/ rco crauroC Adyco
(3or]6elv. eirel ort ye 2,Lp.a)vibr]s ov Ae'yet rd x a ^ e7roi;
KaKov, p.eya reKjUT/ptoV ecrriy evtûs rd /xerd rouro p^/u.a" e
Ae'yet ydp 6'rt
6ebs av p.6vos tovt eyoL yepas,
ov br]T:ov tovto ye keya)v, KaKov ecrdkbv ep.p.evaL, etra

tov 6e6v cpr]crLV p.6vov tovto av ex*w Ka ' r*P ^ e(? T0^T0 5
yepas aireveip.e poVco* ctKokacrTovyap av TLva Ae'yot Stpcovi-

8r/y 6 Ilpo'8tKos Kat oibapL&s KeXov. dAA' d pot 8okci
Staroetcrtât ^Lp-oovibrjs ev rodrco rco acrpart, edekco croi etTrety,
et /3odAet ka(3elv p.ov Trelpav ottcos e^co, o crv Ae'yets roOro, 342
7rept e7rcoy edy Se (3ovki] y
crov ctKovcrop.aL.
'O pey ovy ripcoraydpas aKovcras p.ov raura Ae'yoyros, E?

c
crv /3ovAet, ecpr/, 2 ScoKpares* 6 8e ITpdSiKds re Kat d l7r7rtas
KkVTT]V TTCIVV, Kal OL akkoL. 5
C3 8ta secl. Hirschig 63 rovr'] rovro BTW 64 e?To]

efrrep vel ? 76 Kroschel e6 ffifxwyiSrju 6 T W : <rifiwviS7)s B
a 1 (tii T : crot B
342a IIAATI2N02
'Eyco tolvvv, r/y 8' eyco, d ye uot 8oKet 7rept rov qo~p.aTos
rovrou, 7ret/)d(rouai vpuv 8te<feA0et/A c/uAocrocjbia ydp kcmv
c
iraXaioTaTt] re Kal 7rAeio-rr/ rcoi EAAr/ivcoi> eV Kpr/rr/ re nal
b ei> AaKe8atuoi>t, Kat crocptcrrai 7rAetcrrot yrjs eKet etcri/r dAA'
iapvovvTat. Kat cryr\p,aTi(jovTai dp-adels eii>at, Iva p.r] Kard-
8r/Aot (iio~iv otl o~o(pCq tcov 'EAAr/i;coy TTtpUicnv, tocnrep obs
UpcoTayopas eAeye tovs crocpicrrds, dAAd SoKcocriiV rco p-d\-
5 crc9at Kat dvbpeiq Treptelvai, f)yovp.evoL, et yvcoo~6eiev <o
TTHpUitnv, iravTas tovto dcrKr/creiv, rr/z; crocpiW. vvv 8e

aTioKptnpap.evoL eKetvo ecfr/7rarr/Kacrty rovs ey rats 7ro'Aecrt
kaKcovCovTas, Kal ol p.ev cord re KaTayvvvrai p.Lpovp.evoL

C avTovs, Kal lp.dvTas TreptetAtrrorrat Kat (pLkoyvp.vao~Tovo~LV
Kal fipayeias dvafiokds <popovo~LV, cos 8r/ rovrots Kparovvras
tcov 'EAAr/ycoy rovs AaKeSatuoiHous* ot 8e AaKe8aiudi/tot,
e7ret8av (3ovkcovTaL avebrjv tols irap avTols o~vyyevio~6aL
5 o~o-pLo~TOLS Kal r/8r/ dyJdcovTaL kddpq o~vyyLyvop.evoL, cfen/-

Aacrtas iroLovp.evoL tS>v re AaKcoutfoVrcoi; tovtcov koX edv tls
dkkos evos obv e7rt5r//xr/crr/, crtryyiyiwrai rots o-oc/jicrrats
KavddvovTis tovs cfeVous, Kat avrot ovbeva ecocrty tcoj; i>e'coi>
d ets rds dAAas 7rdAets ecfieVai, &o~~rep ovbe KpijTes, tva pi]
a-Top.avddv(t)o~LV a avrot 8t8dcrKOjcriv. etcrty 8e iv rat/Vats
rats 7rdAecrii; ov p.6vov dvbpes eVt 7rat8erjcret p.iya cppovovv-
tcs, dAAd Kat ywatkes. yyotre 8' dy ort eyco raura akr^drj
5 Ae'yco Kat AaKeSat/jtdytot 7rpds cpLkocrocpLav Kal koyovs dpLO-ra

7re7rat8ewrat, <58e* et ydp e6VAet rts AaKe8atuoz>icoi> rco
cpauAordrco o~vyyevio~6aL, rd piev 7roAAd iv toIs Adyots e75pr/-
e cret avrdy (pavkov TLva (paLvopLevov, e7retra, o7rou av tv)Q]

tG>v kyop.Vcov, eye/3aAev pijp.a &lov koyov /3paî/ Kat
o~vveo~Tpap.pi.tvov axmep 8eii;ds aKovTLo~T7]S, cocrre -paLvecrdaL
a6 7 ipol Bekker b5 avSpeia T : dvSpeioi B $ -repUuri

Heusde 01 irepUio~ii> B : Sinrep clo~\v T : o?jrep etVi W b6 -Hjp
W
:
iropiau B t : om. T C4 aiirols BT C 5 &x^ wvral ^ :
i^ô^Tai T d. 1 KprjTts T : ko^ttjs B d. 2 SiSacr/coi/crt' B :
SiJdVfcaicru' T (sed suprascr. v) d 4 yi/oir]T- B T d 6 -reirai-

Ofvvrai T : 7re7ra('Scurat B
nPHTATOPAS 34 2e
tov irpocrbLahey6p.Vov 7rat8d? p.t]bv /3eArtco. rorjro ovv

avro Kal tG>v vvv tlcrXv ot KaTavevoriKacn ko.1 tS>v 7rdAat, drt 5
to haKo>vi(tLv irohv p.dhhov Zcttlv cpikocrocpziv r) <pLhoyvp.va-
o~tlv, etddres otl rotarjra olov t et/jat pr\p.aTa cp6iyycr6aL
reAeW TtiiraLhzvp.ivov ecrrtrj dv6po>irov. tovtcov r)v Kal 343

Qahr)s 6 MLhrjcnos Kat n trraKos 6 MrjrtAr/yaios Kat Btas 6
YlpLrjvcvs Kal SoAcojj 6 r//>ie'repos Kat K.Aeo'/3ouAos 6 Aitj8ios
cat Mvcrwv 6 Xi-vtvs, ko.\ tfibopios iv tovtols eAe'yero AaKe-
baLp:6vLos XiAcotj. orjYot Trdrres ^r/Acorat Kat epaarat Kat 5
pat5r/rat r)crav Trjs AaKeSatpoiuW 7rat8etas, Kat Karap.ddoL
av tls avT&v tt)v crocpCav TOLavT-qv ovcrav, pr]p.aTa fipayjza
a^Lop.vrjp.6v(VTa eKdcrrcp etprj/xeVa* orjrot Kat KOLvfj avveh-

dovres dirapyr]v rrjs crocpias dvtdecrav tS> 'ATrdAAcozJt ets tov b
i>ecoy tov v AeAcpots, ypd\j/avTs ravra a 8r) 7rdi>res
vpLVOvcTLV, Tv&Ol cravTOV kol Mr/8e7J dyav. tov br) evtKa

raura Ae'yco; ort ovtos 6 Tpoiros i)v tS>v TraAatcoy rijs cptAo-
aocpias, /3payvhoyia tls AaKoovLKt]' Kat 8?/ Kat tov FltrraKorj 5
t8ta 7repiec/)epero tovto to pr)p.a (yKa>p,La6p.vov virb tS>v

crocpS>v, to Xaharov eorflAd/J ep.pei>at. 6 ovv ^Lp.covibr}s,
dre cptAo'rtp,os o>v eVt crocpiq, tyvoo ort et KadthoL tovto to C
pr)p.a cocr7rep vboKLp.ovvTa d6hi]Trjv Kal 7reptyeVotro avTov,
avTos erj8oKtpr/o-et iv tols totz dv6po>TTOLS. ets tovto ovv to
prjpa Kat tovtov eveKa rodrcp kirLpovhavojv KoAorjcrat arjrd
aTray to acrpa 7re7roir/Ke/j, cos p.0L cpatjjerat. 5
/ 'E7rtcrKe^co/xec?a 8t) a7jro kolvt) aTravTts, et doa eycb dhr)6r)
Ae'yco. ei30vs ydp ro irpG>Tov tov acrp.aTOS p.avLKOv dv cpavtir),
et j3ovhop.vos Ae'yety 6'rt dvbpa dyadbv yvkcr6aL yaheTtov,

e7retra eie'/3aAe rd ju.e'z>. roCro ydp ov8e 7rodj eVa Adyoy d
c/Wi>erat e/x/3e/3Ar]crc9at, eay /i,r/ rt? rj7roAd/3r/ 7rpds rd rorj
a 2 ymmA.Tji/cuos B W : ixitv\i)voXos T a 3 ^|iTpos] rnj.er(pews

Herwerden a8 e/pij/ueVa] tipi)ix4va a Hermann : dpijfidv' &
Schanz (<r(coirj/ ante /cctcrT^ add. Kral) C2 /col irepiyfvoiTo avTov
secl. Cobet c 3 tv8oKi/j.r)<rft 4v B tvSoKif>.f)(retfv T
: d 1 eW/8aA.e
to scr. recc. : eVe/8a\eTo BT W
343d ITAAT&NOS
YIittclkov prjp.a uxnrep epLôvra XeyeLV tov 2,Lp.0)v(br)v Xeyov-
tos tov YliTTaKov otl \aXeTrov eo~6X6v ep,p.evai, ap.q>L-
5 o-firjTovvTa eliretv otl Ovk, aXXa yevecrdaL p.ev \aXeirov

avbpa ayadov o-tlv, o> ITtrraKe, &>s aXrjd&s ovk a.Xr}de(q
ayaOov, ovk em tovtm Ae'yet rrjv aXrjdeLav, o>s apa ovto>v tlv5>v
e tQ>v p.ev &>s aXrjd&s aya6S>v, tG>v be ayad&v p.ev, ov /xeVrot
b\Xr]6G>s evr)6es yap tovto ye (pave(r) av kcll ov St/xamSou
dAA' virepPaTov bel delvaL ev tG> ao-/xart to a.Xa6 eo>s,
ovto>o-( 7ra>s vireLTTOVTa to tov ITirraKoO, a>cnrp av et 6e1p.ev
5 avTov Xeyovra tov ITirraKoy /cat 2,Lp.o)v(br)v aiT0KpLv6p.V0V

el7ôVra *12 av6po)troL, \aXetr6v ecrdXov fft/xevai, rw 8e
344 airoKpLVopLevov otl '12 ritrraKe, ovk dA?/0?7 Aeyeis* ov yap

etrat dAAd yevecrdaL p.ev o~tlv avbpa dyadov \epo~L re
Kat 7roo"t Kal v6(j> TtTp&yaivov, &vev \j/6yov ttv-
yp-evov, yjaXeirov dXadews. ovto) cpaiveTaL [to] irpos
5 Aoyoy to p.ev epi.j3ej3Xrjp.4vov Kat to a.Xa$ eois 6p6G>s eV

eV)(dr<f) KLp,VOV KOJ. TCL TTLOVTa TTCLVTa TOVTO) p.apTVpL, OTL
ovtojs elprjTai. ttoXXcl p,ev yap eart Kat 7rept ko.o-tov tQ>v
b ev r<3 aapart elpr)p,evo)V d7ro8et<fat &>s ev ireiTo(r]TaL Trdû

ydp yapLVTo>s Kal p.ep.eXrip.evojs eêt dAAa p.aKpov av elr)
aiiTo ovto) bLeXdelv aXXa tov tvttov ai)TOV tov oXov 8tee'A-
6o>p.ev Kal Tr)v f3ovXr)crLV, otl iravTos puiXXov eXeyyos o-tlv
5 tov ITtrraKetou prfp.aTos bia iravros tov qo-p.aTos^
Ae'yet ydp perd tovto oXiya bLeX6o>v, o>s clv et XeyoL
Xoyov, otl yevecrdaL p.ev avbpa aya66v yaXeTrov a.Xa6e o>s,
oX6v T p.VTOL 7TL y yj>OVOV TLVCL' yVOp.VOV 8e bLap.VLV
C ev TavTjj Trj eei Kat etrat avbpa ayadov, o>s av Ae'yet9, o>
ITtrraKe, abvvarov Kal ovk avdpo>TTLov, clXXcl deos av p.6vos

tovto eôt to yepas,
d.6 isBW: kcl\ w$ T d7 ovk) ovti' Hermann B2 ov (7rpta)

Cobet e3 rb a\a6ews B : rb* aXrideus T e4 6fir]f>.v B T
a4 rb secl. Heindorf : poi Ast : re Schirlitz b5 irmaKeiov W
rec. t : TrtrraKiov BT C 2 avdpdiretoi' T : av$pumov B C 3 to
secl. Hirschig

OPXiTArOPAS 344 c
dvbpa 8' ovk eo-rt p.r) ov Kanbv epp.ei>at,
bv [av] dp.rjyavos o~vp.qbopa Kadekr). 5
rCva ovv dpvqyavos crvp.cpopa KaOaipei (V ttXolov dpyrj; brjkov

otl 011 tov lbi<oTr)v 6 pikv yap IbLcorrjs det Ka6f\pr)TaL. <3o-7rep
ovv ov tov KLp.evov tls dv Kara/3dAot, dAAd tov pikv eoroird

7rore KaTafidkoL av tls coare KeLpevov TTOLrjcraL, tov 8e Ket-
p.evov ov, ovtco Kal tov tvp.r]yavov ovra 7rore dp.r]yavos av d
crvp.cpopa KaOeXoL, tov 8e det ap.riya.vov ovra ov, Kal tov
KVf3pvi]Tr]v p.iyas yeLpcov kTTLTTtcrcov dp.r)yavov av TroLr]o~LV,
Kal yecopybv yakeiTr] copa tTTtXOovcra dp.r)yavov b\v OeCrj, Kal

larpbv TavTa Tavra. tco piev yap io~6kcp eyx<opet KaK<2 5
y(VcrdaL, cocriTep Kal irap dkkov TrotrjroO juaprvpetrat tov

(Ittovtos
avrap dvr)p dyadbs totc p.V KaKos, dAAore 8' eo-0AoV
rw 8e KaK(i> ovk iyycopel yev&crdaL, dAA' dfl etmt avdyKr). e
coo~t tov pikv tvp.rjyavov kol aocpbv Kat ayaObv iireLbav
ap.r]yavos o~vp.cpopd Kadikrf, ovk eari p.r) ov KaKov eju/xe-
vo.L' o~v 8e cpfo, a> IltrraKe', \akeTrbv icrdkbv ejup,ei>ar

to 8' eort yev4o~daL piev yakeirov, bvvarbv 8e', icrdkov, 5
tp.p.vai 8e abvvaTov
irpdâs piev yap eu 7rds dvr)p dyaOos,
^jKaKos 8' et ko.kcos.
r($ ovv els ypdp.p.aTa ayaOr) irpa^LS io~TLV, koX tls dvbpa 345
dyadbv 7roiei ets ypdp.p.aTa; brjkov otl r) tovtcov pd6r)o~LS.
tls 8e einrpayCa dyadbv larpbv 7rotet; bfjkov ort r) tQv
KapvovTutv rrjs dtpaireCas p.d6r)o~LS. KaKos 8e /caKw$' rts
ovv av KaKos iarpbs yivovro; brp\ov 6tl <S irp&Tov pikv 5
virdpyjL tarpai etvai, e7retra dya6& tarpai ovtos yap dv KaX
KaKos yivovro r)p,ety 8e ot tarptK^s t8twrat ovk dv 7rore
c 4 S'] 5e BT tart T : ecrriv B c 5 hv om. Bergk

c 9 KaraPiKoi ... d i oti secl. Herwerden e 5 iaQKov secl.
Schneidewin e 6 f/x/j.evai 5e Bt :
8' yit/uevai T 67 irpaâis
Boeckh fikv secl. G. Hermann &$ 5e] 8' ei Ast
6
345a IIAAT&NOS
ycvoijjieda kclk&s TrpaavT$ ovtc larpol ovre reKTOves ovtc
b ciAAo ovbkv t5>v TOLOvroiV octtls 8e p.r) larpbs av ykvoiTO

KaK&s Trpaas, brjXov otl ovbX KaKos iarpos. ovroi xa\ 6
pikv ayaObi avr\p yeVotr' av ttotc kol KaKos r) virb \povov rj
VTTO TTOVOV 7] VTTO VOCTOV 7] VTTO CtAAoU TLVOS TTpLTTTO)p.aTOS
5 avTr) yap p.6vr\ eort kokt) rrpa^LS, kiTLcrTf]p.r]s o~Tprjdr}vai

8e KaKos avr\p ovk av 7rore ykvoLTO KaKos earti> yap ati
ctAA' et /xe'AAet KaKos yeviaOai, 8et avrbv irpoTepov ayaObv
yevicrOaL. tocrre Kal tovto tov qcrp.aTOS irpbs tovto TtivtL,
C ort etyat piev avbpa ayadbv ov\ oXov re, 8tareAot;vra ayadov,
yevzo~6ai 8e ayadbv olov re, Kat KaKov ye tov avrbv tovtov
e7rt irAeta-roi; 8e Kat aptorot eio"ty ovs av oi 6eo\ cptX&o-iv.
Taura re ovv iravTa Trpbs tov YliTTaKov etprjrat, Kat tcl
5 kmovTa ye tov qcrp.aTos ert piaKkov SryAot. ojtio-i yap

TovvtKtv ov ttot eyto to p.r) yevicrdac bvvarbv
bi(jqp.vos Ktveav es airpaKrov eXrriba p-olpav ai&vos
/3aAe'co,
Travapi.oip.ov dvdpoiTrov, evpvebovs ocroi Kapirbv aivvp.eda

10 yOovos'
kiri 0' vp.lv evpoiv airayyekeoi,
d cprjcriv ovrco crcpobpa Kal 8t' oAou tov qo~p.aTos eireêpxtTcu

rco tov ITtrraKou pr\p.aTi
Travras 8' eiraivr\p.L Kat cptXeoi
eKtoy ocrrts epori
5 p-rjbev alayjpov dvdyKrj 8' ovbe 6eo\ pAyovTav
Kat TOVT eCTTL TTpOS TO aVTO TOVTO eipr)p.VOV. OV yhp OVTOiS

cnraibtVTos r)v 2,Lp.oivibr]s, coore tovtovs cpavaL kiraLveiv, bs
C 1 aya9Av addub. Sauppe an verba SiartKovvra ayadov delenda ?

:
Schanz Sict rekovs [ayad6v] Cobet

: C 7 nevtav Kfveav T W : :
Ktv iav B c 11 hri ff ifuv Adam iwi r ififxtv Schneidewin eirl

: :
8' iifxfj.iv Bergk îretd' ifuv B T

: iwl Sr) fitv Sauppe: d. 3 irdvTas
Bt : Trdvra T 8'] 8e BT W eiraivi\fii b : etraivrifjLiv B ewaivrjfj.iv T
BT W
:
CI5 avdyKa Diogenes Laertius 8'] Se d.7 rovrovs BT :
rovrois W
.
nPX2TATOPA2 345 d
dv K(ov p,r]bh> ko.kov ttolT], cos ovroiv tlvcov o\ eKoVres mm

Tioiovcriv. eyco yap crytbov tl otuat tovto, otl ovbels tG>v
aocpG>v dvbpcov ?/yeirat ovbiva avdpcoircov kmvTa kap.ap- e
Taveiv ovbk alcry^pd re Kal mm kmvra kpydêcrdaL, dAA' eS
L0~a0~lV OTL 7TaVTS OL TCL alo^pCL Kal TCL Kam 7TOLOVVTS CLKOV-
re? iroLovo-LV Kal br) ml 6 2tpcoiaS?7? ov\ 09 av p.r) Kam
TTOLrj KU)v, tovtcov cprrcrlv TTaLVTrjs eTvaL, dkka 7rept kavrov 5
Ae'yet tovto to kKcov. ^yetro yap avbpa mkbv KayaObv
ttoWclkls avTov iTravayKafav cpikov tlvI yiyvecrdai ml e7rat-
VTT]v [(ptAetf Kat e7raiz;eu>], otov dvbpl Trokk&KLs crvp.fSrjvaL 34^
p.t]Tpa r) TraTtpa dkkoKOTov r) Trarpiba r) dAAo rt t&v tolov-
tcov. tovs pikv ovv irovrrpovs, orav TOLOVTOV Tl aVTOLS
avp.j3fi, <oo-7rep acrptvovs bpdv ml ij/iyovTas iirtbeLKVvvaL ml
Karrjyopuv Tr)v Trovr]pCav tcov yovecov r) iraTpibos, tva avrols 5
dpekovo-LV ai/Tcov mt) iymkcocrLV 01 dvdpcoiroL p.r]b' 6vtbicocrLV
otl dp.kovcnv, cocrre ert p.akkov \j/yiv re airovs ml fydpas

kmvcriovs TTpbs rats dvayKaiais 7rpocrric9ecrc9ar tovs 8' dya- b
6ovs iTTLKpvTTTecrdat re Kat iiraivelv dvayKaeo~6aL, koX dv tl
6pyLcr6G>crLV Tols yovvo~LV rj iraTpCbt ddtK?;0eVres, avrovs kav-
tovs 7Tapap,v6eZcr6ai ml 8taAAdrrecr0ai irpocravayKa(pvTas

kavTovs cpLkelv tovs kavrcov Kal iiraLveXv. irokkaKLS be 5
otuai Kat 2imcoi>i8?is fjyrjcraTO Kal avrbs r) rvpavvov r) dkkov

TLvd tG>v tolovtoov e7rau>eVat Kal kyKcopLacrat ov^ eKcov, dAA'
dvaym(6p.evos. Tavra br) Kal tG> IltrraKa) Ae'yet ort 'Eyco,
cb ritrraKe', ov 8td TavTa cre \ê'ya), ort etut <pLko\f/oyos, C
eVet
ep-OLy eâpKet bs dv p.77 KaKos rj
p.r]$' dyav dirdkauvos, dbois r' ovrro-LTTokLV bUav vyLr)s
dvi]p- 5
e 1 eK^vra. BT : skov W e5 tovtwv BT : tovtov W

a 1 <pi\elv Kal iiratve?v secl. Grou a3
toiovtSv ti B W : ti toiovtov
T b x avayKalais Heusde : avdyKats B T W b3 iraTptdi
aStKridfVTts B : iraTpiSt StaStKTjdevTts T C3 efj.oty~\ t/xotye BT W
C4 t hvi\a'nro\tv G. Hermann : yt bvâtt ir6\tv BTW
. :
346C ITAATI2N02
ov /jllv eyco /xco/xrjcro/xai
ov ydp et/xt cptAd/xco/xos

t&v yap r}ki6mv aTreipcov yev6ka,
&ctt et tls -âCpet i//e'ycoz;, e/x7rArjor0eirj h.v (Ketvovs /xe/x-
IO (p6p.VO$
Trdvra rot KaAd, rotcri T ala-^pd fir/ /xe'/xetKrat.
d ou rorjYo Aeyet, ooo-irep hv et eAeye 7rayra rot AerjKa, ot?

pikava /xr/ /xe'/xetKrat yeAotov ydp di> etrj 7roAAa>(r/ dAA'
ort avTos Kal ra /xecra d7ro8e'xerat cSVre /xr/ i//e'yeiv. Kal ov
Crjrco, ecprj, itavdp.ojp.ov avdpojirov, evpvebovs dcrot
5 KapTtbv alvvp.e6a \6ov6s, e7rt 0' rj/xty evpoiv airay-

yeAear ooVre rodrou y' eVeKa ovbiva e7raiveVo/xat, dAAd
/xot eapKet di> r^ /xeVos Kat p.r\b\v KaKov TTOLrj, ws eyci) 7rdz>ra9
cptAeco Kat ciraLvrip.L Kai rrj cpcoznj evrarjfla Ke'xp>/rai rr/
e rcov MurtArjmtW, cos 7rpo? EltrraKoy kiyoiv rb irdvras 8e

ira(vr)p.L Kal cptAeco kojv tvravda 8et kv rto eKcoz 8ta-
Aa/3etz> keyovra ocrris ep8rj /xrj8ez> aicr\p6v, &kojv 8'
ecrriz/ o$s eyco kitaLvGt kol cptAco. cre orjV, Kat et /xeVcos
347 eAeyes e7rteiK7j Kai dkr\6r), co IltrraKe, otjk dz> 7rore f-xjfeyov
vvv 8e acpobpa yap kol 7repi rcoy /xeytWcor \j/evb6p.vos boKtls

dk-qdfj Ae'yetz>, 8td raSrd cre eycb \j/iyoo. ravrd /xot 8oKet, a
IIpo'8iKe Kai ITpcoraydpa, 771

8' eyco, St/xcozJtSrjs 8taz>oo7j/xez>os'
5 7re7roirjKez>ai tovto to acr/xa.

c
Kai 6 l7r7rtas, Erj /xeV /xot SoKets, ecpr/, S ScoKpares, Kai
o-7j 7repi rorj acr/xaros SteArjAufleVar eVrtz> /xeVrot, cprj, Kai
b e/xoi Adyos Trepi avrorj eS excoy, 6y 7j/xiz> e7rt8et<fco, dz/
/3odAr/o-t9e.
Kai 6 'AAKt/3id8rjs, Nat, ecpr/, co 'I7r7rta, ets avt^ts ye* vvv

8e bUaLov ecrrtv a cb/xoAoyr/crdrr/y Trpos dAAr/Aco ripcoraydpas
5 Kai 2coKpdrrjs, TIpooTayopas [xev et ert )3orJAerai epcordy,
c 6 o# yutv Schleiermacher ou fx)jv B T : W 07 i/i( <|>(A^/ia)/i(os]
(pi\6fiw/j.6s tlfii Sauppe Simonidi tribuens d5 hti 6'] eweid' BT

d6 -y'T t' B e 1 fj.vTi\tivaiwv B : /j,irv\rivaiwv T to B t
W
:
to Se T b5 /3ov\Ta( BT : 0ov\ecreai
riPX2TArOPA2 347b
v
a-rtOKpiveo-Oai ScoKpaTi], et be 8? / /3ouAerat ScoKpaTei aTTOKpC-
veadaL, epcorav tov eTepov.

Kat eyco et7rozr 'E7rtrpe'7rco per tycoye UpcoTayopq. oiroTepov
avrco rjbtov et 8e jSovkeTaL, 7rept p,ey qcrp.aTcov re Kat e7rcoy
edo-coper, 7rept 8e coi> rd irpcaTov eyco o-e ?'/pcorr/cra, u> Tlpco- C
rayopa, rjbecos dv eVt re'Aos ekdoLp.t perd crov o-KOTrovp.evos.
Kal yap boKel pot to nrepl TTOLrfcrecos biakeyecrdaL opoLOTarov

ejvai toIs crvpTTocrCoLS toXs tcov cpavkoov Kal dyopaCow dv-
6pco7rcov. Kal yap ovtol, 8td t6 pr) bvvaadai dAAr/Aots 81' 5
kavT&v crvvelvaL ev rco 7ro'rcp pr/oe Std Trjs eavrcov cpcovrjs
kol tcov koycov tcov eavTcov vtto d7TaLbevcrCas, rip.ia? 7toio?3oh

rds avkr]TpCbas, ttoXXov p.Lcr6ovp.evoL dkkorpCav (pcovr)v ti\v d
tcov avkcov, Kal 8td r?/? eKeCvcov (pcovrjs dAA?/Aoi? crvveLCTLV
ottotj be KaAot Kayadol crvp.TTOTaL Kal ireiTaLbevp.evoL eicrCv,
o?3k dy t8ots oiir' avkr]TpCbas oure dpxrrorptSas ol/re âA-

rptas, dAAd ar/rovs avrots iKai>ois dVras crvveivaL dvev tcov 5
A?/pcoi> re Kat 7rai8ttoi> rorrrcov 8td rrjs avrcor (poivrjs, keyov-

tcls re Kat aKorWras ev p.e'pet eaurcoy KOcrp.Ccos, Kai> 7rdi>u
7roA?/y otroy ttCcoctlv. ovtco be Kat at rotatSe crvvovcrCaL, eav e

p,eu XaficovTaL dvbpStv otot7rep r/pcoy ot 7roAAot cpacrti/ eu>at,
ov8ey 8e'oyrai dAAorptas (pcovrjs oibe ttoli]tcov, ovs ovre

dvepecrdaL olov r ecrTLV irep\ <ov keyovaLV, eTrayop.evoC re
avrov? 01 7roAAot ev Tois Adyots 01 p.ev Tavrd cpacrLV tov 5
TTOLi]Tr]v voeiv, 61 c? eTepa, irepl TTpdyp.aTos bLakeyop.evoi b
dbvvaTovcTL eêAeyât -
dAAa tcls piev TOLavTas o-vvovcrCas
ecocrLV yaCpeLV, avrol 8' eavToTs crvveLcrLV bC eavTcov, ev tols 34^
eaurcoy Adyot? irelpav dAAr/Acoy Kap.(3avovTes Kal 8t8di>res.
rovs tolovtovs poL boKel ypfjvaL pdAAov p.tp.etcr(9at e/xe re
Kat cre', Kara6ep.evovs tovs 7rotr/rds avrovs 8t' r)p.S>v avrcov
TTpos dkkr]kovs tovs koyovs 7rotetcrt9at, rfjs dkr]6eCas Kat 5
?/pcoi> avTcov Trelpav kap.f3dvovTas' kclv pev fiovkr] ert epcoTav,
C 7 tcSj' ante Aâjf om. Athenaeus d3 aJ irfira.i8fvfj.fvoi t
Athenaeus ireiratHtvixfvoi
: secl. Schanz BTW: 05 ravTO. B :
Taura T e6 h om. B T W :
348a nAATJ2N02
eT0Lp.6s elpi crot irapeyeLV diTOKpLv6p.evos' edv be /3orJAri, crv
e/uot tiapacryzs, irepX cov /xerarj eTravcrdp.e0a SteioVres, tov-

tols rekos iTTLdttvai.
b AiyovTos ovv ep.ov Tavra Kal rotairra dkka ovbev aire-
o-dcpet 6 Ylpcorayopas cnroTepa 7ro;a-oi. et7rei> ovv 6 'AAki-

T
/3td8rr? irpbs tov KakkCav (3ke\[/as, X2 KaAAta, boKel ctol,
ecprr, Kal vvv KaAco? YIpcoTayopas ^XTQLeXv, ovk e0ekcov etre

5 Scocret. koyov etre ur) bLacracpelv; ep.ol ydp ov boKel' dAA'
ryrot StaAeyecr&o r/ ei7reYco ort ovk e0ekeL 8taAeyecr0ai, tva
tovtco p,ev TavTa crvveLbcop.ev, ScoKodrr/s be dkkco rco bLake-
yrjrat r) dAAos ocrris dv /3orJAr/rai dAAco.
C Kat 6 Ilocoraydpas alcr^yvêCs, cos yk p.0L eboev, rov re

'AAKt/3tdSou ravra keyovros kol tov KakkCov beop-evov kol
TCOV dkkcOV CTêboV TL TCOV TTapOVTCOV, p.6yLS TTpOVTpdlTtTO etS
to 8taAeyecrc9at Kat eKe'Aeuei' epcordv avrbv cos airoKpLvovp.evos.
5 Et7roy br) eyco' '12 TlpcoTayopa, p.r) olov bLakeyecr0aC p.e
croi dAAo rt j3ovkop.evov r) a avrbs airopco eKacrTOTe, raCra

r
8tacrKeâcrc9at. r)yovp.aL ydp irdvv keyeiv tl tov 'Op.rjpov
TO
d crvv re bv ep\op.evco, Kai re TTpb b tov ev6r)crev.
eviTopcoTepoL ydp ttcos d-navTes ecrp.ev ol dvOpcoiroL irpbs dirav

epyov koI koyov kcxl bLav6r\p.a' " p.ovvos 8' eiirep re
vor/crrr," avTLKa irepLLcav Cr/ret r(p eTTiSetfr/rai Kat pe0'
5 otov /3e/3atcoo-r/rai, ecos dv evrv^rj. tocnrep koX eyco eveKa
tovtov crol rjbecos 8iaAeyo/xai p.dkkov r) dkkto tlvC, r)yov-

p.evos cre /3eArtcrr' &v eTTio~Ke\j/ao~0aL Kal irepX rcov dkkcov
b I Coisl.
aireffd<pet corr. arreffd<pr) B T : b 2 itoifooi B T W
W W
:
iroff)ffet b 5 Sdiret B T Sdxreiv ob B T : om. W

W
:
b 7 ffvveiSwfiev (sic) B ffwiSu/iev T : crvvetSufjLev t &\\w T

W
: :
&\\6 B Sta\eyr)Tcu B T Sia\eyerai (sed suprascr. r/)

: C i 3>s
ye noi~\ &s y' ifiol T W
&<xre ftot B 03 Trpovrpdi-eTo] irov TpdireTo
W
:
B et yp. t rrpovTpeireTo T (sed suprascr. o) irov tTpd-rero

: :
C 4 airoicptvovfievos B T airoKptv6fievos : C 5 fxe B T ^toi W : W

C 7 toj/ "Ofiripov secl. ci. Schanz d 4 vo-ftffT) B T voâet W
W
:
irepttwv t 7rpJ 5v B: ireptwv T : eirtSei^r)Tat B T (sed e supra W

W) iirtSeil-eT.ai al.
: d 5 f3ef3at(iffr)Te fiefiaiwaeTai al. W :
7?
:
riPUTArOPAS 348 e
TTfpl cov eiKos (TKo-nexcrOat. tov k-nitLKi), koX br) Ka\ irepl dperrjs. e
riva yap dkkov r) o~e; 6s ye ov p.6vov avros otet jcakbs
Kayadbs eXvaL, cocrirep TLves dkkoL avrol piev ZirutKels elcnv,
dkkovs be ov bvvavrai iroLelv crv be k<u avrbs ayaObs eX

Kal akkovs olos t el TTOLeZv dyadovs, Kal ovtco TreTrC- 5
crrevKas cravrco, cocrre Kal akkcov Tavrrp) tt]v Teyvt]V diro-

KpviTTopLevcov crv y dvacpavbbv creavTov v7TOKr]pvdp,evos els 349
iravTas tovs "Y^kkrjvas, crocpicrTrjv 7rovop.dcras creavTov,
aTtecp-qvas TTatbevcrecos Kal dperfjs bLbdo~Kakov, TTpcoros tov-
tov p.Lo~6bv d^Lcocras dpvvcrdaL. ttcos ovv ov o~e \PV V ^ aP a ~

Kakelv eirl rr)v tovtcov crKe\\rLV kcu epcorav Kal dvaKOLVovcrdai; 5
ovk ecrd' ottcos ov. Kal vvv br] eyco eKelva, direp rb irpcoTov
r)pcoTcov TTepl tovtcov, irdkLV e7TL0vp.co e dpxrjs Ta P* v

dvafxvr]cr6rjvaL Trapa o~ov, ra be crvvbLacrKe^/acrdaL. r\v be,
cos eycop.ai, to epcoTr]p.a Tobe' crocpCa Kal crcocppocrvvr] Kal b

dvbpeia Kal bLKaLocrvvr] Kal octloti^s, iroTepov ravra, irevTe
ovra 6v6p.aTa, e7rt evl 7Tpdyp.aTC Zcttlv, r] eKacrTco tcov 6vo-
p.drcov tovtcov VTTOKeLTaC tls t8tos ovcrCa Kal 7rpdyp.a e\ov

eavTov bvvap.LV eKaarov, ovk ov dtov to erepov avrcov to 5
erepov; ecpr]crda ovv crv ovk 6v6p.ara eirl evl elvaL, dkkd
eKacrrov IbCco irpdyp.aTL tcov 6vop.drcov tovtcov emKelcrdaL, C
irdvTa be ravra p.6pLa eXvaL dpeTrjs, ovx cos ra tov \pvo~ov
p.6pLa 6p.0La ecrTLV dkkrjkoLS kol ra dkco ov p.6pLa o~tlv,
dAA' cos rd tov irpocrcoTTOv p.6pLa Kal t<5 dkco ov pLopLa ecrTiv
koX dAAÂois dvop.OLa, IbCav e/cacrra bvvap.Lv eôvTa. ravra 5
ei p.ev ctol Soxet ert cocnrep TOTe, cpd0L- et be dkkcos ttcos,
tovto bLopLcrai, cos eycoye ovbev ctol virokoyov TC6ep.ai, edv

Trrj akkr] vvv t^r/crr/s" ov ydp dv 6avp,doLp,L el Tore aTTOTTec-
pcop.evos p.ov Tama ekeyes. d
AAA' eyco crot, ecpr], keyco, co ^coKpares, otl ravra Trdvra
p.6pia p.ev eo~TLV dpeTrjs, Kal rd p.ev Terrapa avTcov eiTLeLKcos
a6 ov T : ov B (dist. post oirws) C 7 vir6\oyov] viro\6yov T

inrb \6yuv B : viro\6ywv W C8 <$>'}\arris BT : Q{\o~fis W
PLATO, VOL. III. 16
;
349 d I1AATJ2N02
irapaTrk-qa-ia akkr]koLS io-riv, r) 8e dvbpzia irdvv ttoAv 8ta-
5 tpt-pov TrdvTiov tovtlov. (oba 8e yvcoarr] otl eyo d\rj6rj
Ae'yw ivprjtrcLS yap irokkovs tQv dv6ptoTTtov dbLKtoTaTOVs

pkv ovras Kal dvoo~LcoTCLTOvs Kal aKokao~TOTaTovs Kal dp.a-
6tTTCLT0VS, dvbptLOTCLTOVS 8e bLa<ppOVTLOS.
e "Ex e ^ 7/ * (t> rl v ^yw" dtoi> ydp tol (TTLtTKkyj/acrdaL o Aeyets.

7roTepov tovs dvbpaiovs dappakiovs Ae'yets r) akko tl;
Kat tras ye, itpr), e$' a ol 7roAAot cpofiovvTaL UvaL. 4e'pe
8>j, tjji dparrjv Kakov tl tpf]S clvai, klv. tos Kdkov ovtos
5 avTov o~v bLbdo~Kakov travTov TtapiyjeLS KdAAtoroi' pkv
ovv, etpr), et p.r) p.aivop.ai ye. ndTepoi ovv, rjv 8' iyto, to
p.iv tl avrov alo~\p6v, to 8e' tl Kakov, r) okov mkovi "OAoi>
TTOV Kakbv t\>S OLOV T p.dkLOTa.O7cT0a OVV TLViS ets TCL
35 <pp*a-Ta Kokvp.j3too~iv dappakitos; "Eya>ye, ort ol Kok.vp.fir]-

TaL noVepoi bioTL kiTLOTavTaL rj 8t' akko tl; "Oti em-
trravTaL. TlvS 8e a7rd Ttov lttttlov TTokep.aLV OappakioL eitriv;
TTOTCpOV OL LTTTTLKol 1] OL atplTTTTOL; Ol LTTTTLKoi. TivtS 8e

5 7re'ATas ixpvTis; ol 7reATaoTiKoi r) ol p.rj; 01 irckTacrTLKoi.
kol tcl dkka ye irdvTa, et tovto (jyrsis, ftpr], ol eTTLtTTrjp.oves
Ttov p,r) TTLLTTap.4vcov dappakttoTtpoi etcru, Kal avTol kavTtov

b 7T(iLbav p.ddtotTLV r) irplv p.a6(LV.
"H877 8e' Twas ecopa/cas,
H<pr]V, irdvTtov tovtcov dv7TLtrTr]p.ovas ovras, Oappovvras Se

irpbs KatTTa tovtlov;
"Eycoye, r) 8' os, kcli kiav ye 6ap-
povvras. Ovkovv ol OappakioL ovtol kox dvbp&oi elo~Lv;
5
Alaxpbv pLCVTav, ftpri, ur] r) dvbpt-ia- e7ret outoi ye
p.aLvop.(voi dltTLV. I\Q>s ovv, Ztpriv iyto, Ae'yets tovs dv-
bpeiovs; ovx' tovs Bappakiovs etvat; Kat vvv y, etpr].
c Ovkovv ovtol, r)v 8' eyw, ot ovtco OappakioL ovtcs ovk dv-
opetot dAAd p.aLv6p.zvoL tpaivovTaL; kcv. exet av ol o~o(p(OTaTOL
ovtol Kal dappaketaraToi lltlv, 6appakcoraTOL 8e ovres
d4 iravv i-oKv] -rdfi-ToKv Cobet d. 8 avSpeiovs 5e 8ta<pcpovTu>s

Cobet (Sta<pep6vTws secl. Schanz) a i eyarye T
iy<& Te B :
b 3 enao-Ta B T enao-Tov : W b6 e<pf]v B T ecpr)

: W
b ~J tovs
ante 0appa\eovs secl. Sauppe
npiiTAroPA2 35oc
avhpzioTaToi; nal KaTa tovtov tov koyov r) crocpia av avhpeia

*fy; 5
Ov Kak&s, 60)7, p.vr]p.oveveLs, 2> SoiKpares, a ekeyov re
koI a7reKpLv6p.r]v ctol. eycoye epa>Tr]dels vtto o~ov ei ol
avhpeloL 6appakeoL eicriv, 6)p.ok6yr]cra' ei he ml ol dappakeoL

avhpeloL, ovk r)pu>Tr}6r]v et yap p.e totc tfpov, elirov av otl
ov iravTes tovs he avhpeiovs 6>s ov dappakioi eicriv, to d
ep.bv 6p.ok6yrjp.a ovhap.ov eneheLâs 6>s ovk 6p66>s 6)p.ok6yi]o-a.
7Ttra tovs eTTio-Tap.evovs avTovs eavr&v 6appakeo)Tepovs

ovTas aTTOcpatveLS Kal p.i] eiTLo-Tap.evo)v akkcov, Kal ev tovto)
otei ti]V avhpeiav Kal tijv crocpiav tovtov etvaL' tovto) he 5

rpbVa) p.eTLoov kcll tijv icrxyv oir]6eir]s av eXvaL aocpiav.
Trp&Tov piev yap el ovto) p.TLO)v epoto p.e el ol icr^vpol
hvvaroi eicrLV, cpair/v av eTretra, ei ol eiTLcrTap.evoL Trakaieiv e
hvvaT(oT(poC eicrLV t&v p.i] eirLo-Tap.eva>v irakaieLV Kal avTol
avriav eiTeLhav p.a6o)crLV 77 irplv p.a6eiv, cpairjv dv ravra

he ep.ov 6p.okoyi]o-avTos eêirj dv aoL, \po)p.evo) toIs avrols
TeKp.r]pioLS tovtols, keyeLV 6>s fcara ttjv ep.r]v 6p.okoyiav r) 5

aocpia eo-rlv iarxys. eyco he ovhap.ov ot35' evravda 6p.okoyo>
tovs hvvaTovs io-\vpovs elvaL, tovs p.evTOL icryypovs hvvaTovs'
ov yap Tavrbv elvaL hvvap.iv re Kal iayyv, akkd to p.ev 351
Kal aTTo eiTLo-Tr]p.r]s yiyvecr6aL, ttjv hvvap.LV, Kal airb ptavias
ye Kal 6vp.ov, ia)(yv he airb cpvaeo)s Kdl exiTpocpias tS>v
ao)p.aTO)v. ovro) he KaKeZ ov Tavrbv elvat dapcros re Kal

avhpeiav coore avp.]3aivei tovs p.ev avhpeiovs dappakeovs 5
eifai, p.i] p.evroL tovs ye dappakeovs avhpeiovs iravTas'

ddpcros p.ev yap Kal airb Teyyrjs yiyveraL avdpoiiroLs Kal
airb 6vp.ov ye kol airb p.avias, &aTrep r) hvvap.LS, avhpeia b
he ctTTO cpvaeois Kal evTpocpias to>v \j/v\(av yiyverai.
09 TiiTeBTW: toCto Par. 1811 d.7 eloiT: et B ei ei oi

t : oiei B olfei T
: e 2 TraA.aieic secl. Cobet e 7 Svvarobs~\
Svi/a/u.evovsStobaeus a 3 -ye t Stobaeus W
Te B T Bvfiov T :
Stobaeus anb Ov/xov B t

: (i>Tpo(plas B T ctaro tvrpo<p(as Stobaeus
:
a 5 o-vnfiaivfi re vera B T Stobaeus a 6 irdvTas om. Stobaeus

b 1 ye
'
Kal Stobaeus Te Ka\ B T : W
awb secl. Naber
16*
:
35ib IIAAT&NOS
Ae'yets 8e' tlvcls, <\>rjv, co UpcoTayopa, tcov avdpcoTrcov
v r}v, tovs 8e KaKcos; "E<prj.

'Ap' ow 8oKet <tol dv6pcoTros
5 dv et 77 y, et dvLcop.v6s re kcu d8wcopei>os' ori; Ouk

e<pr7. Tt 8' et fjbicos /3lovs tov (3lov reAeurrjcretei'; ovk v
<5lv o~ol boKel ovtcos /3e/3tcoKeVai;
v
Epoty', <prj.- Td p.V apa
C fjbtcos f}v ayaOov, to 8' dr?8cos KaKov. Enrep tols KaAois
y, <pr), cori fjb6p.Vos. Tt 8?;, a> YIpcoTayopa; p.f) ko.1 <rv,
cocr7rep ot 7roAAot, r)8e" arra KaAets koko Kat avLapa ayaOa;

eyco yap Aeyco, Kad* 6 7/8e'a <tt'lv, apa Kara tovto ovk
5 dyafla, p.f) et rt a7r' avTcov a7ro/3?/crerat aAAo; koi a?c?ts av
tcl avLapa cocravTcos ovtcos ov Kad' ocrov avLapd, KaKa;
Ovk ot8a, co 2coKpare?, (<prj, a7rAcos ovrcos, cos <rv epcoras,
d et ep:ol aTTOKpiriov eVrtv <os tcl fjbc-a re dyadd <ttlv ctTrayra
Kat rd dvLapa KaKa' dAAd /^tot 8oKet ov p.6vov irpbs rfjv vvv
diroKpLo-LV ejuot d<r<pa\<i<rTpov waL diroKpLva<r6aL, dAAd Kat
7rpos 7rdyra tov aWov (3(ov tov kjxov, otl ecrrt piev a tcov
5 fjbetov ovk <ttlv dya#d, ecrrt 8' av Kat a rwi' dvLapcov ovk
ecrrt Ka^d, ecrrt 8' a ecrrt, Kat rpLTOv a ovbertpa, ovt KaKa
ovt dyaOd.ti-^Hbta 8e KaAets, 7)y 8' eyco, ov rd fjbovfjs
e p.Te.yovTa rj troLovvTa fjbovrjv; Tidvv y , <prj. Tovto rot-
vvv Aeyco, Kac^' ocroy 7/Se'a ecrrty, et ovk dyat^d, rf]V f)bovf)v
ai)Tf]V kpcoTcov et ovk dyaOov ecrrtv. "Lltmep <rv Ae'yets, ecprj,
^* 1 / Ka<rTOT, CO 2<0KpaTS, <TKOTTC0p.6a avTo, Kal av pkv Ttpbs

5 Adyor boKrj %vai to o~Kp.p.a nal rd avrd cpatyrjrat ^8d re
J Kat dyacôV, <rvy\coprj<r6pL6a' et 8e p.7/, rdre fjbrj dp,<pL<r(3rj-
Trjtrop.V.
YloTpov oxiv, rjv 8' eyco, cri /3ovAet fjyjxovVLV Trjs
o~K\lfcos, rj eyco fjycojxaL;

io AtKatoj, ecpr;, cri/ f)yLcrdaL' ov yap Kal Kardpxets tov
koyov.
b 7 So/ce? scr. recc. : Soko? BT W ovtws T W (sed o supra w W)

oStos re vera B C4 xa6b T (sed suprascr. v) : nadov B a&' o
:
yit}5' W C5 juf/tfTiBTW: si^Ti t: 1 MW e ^ T< c '- Thompson

d6 oi/T <coa out' ayafl^ BT : oHt ayada ovtc /caa
nPIlTATOPAS 352 a
*Ap' ovv, i]v 8' eyco, rfj8e' 7r?/ Karac/myes av i)p.iv yivovro; 352
uxnrep et rts avdpcoTrov ctkottcov Zk tov etbovs t] irpbs vyUiav
r/ TTpos dAAo tl tcov tov <rcoparos epycov, ibcov to irp6cru>TTOv
kcxl Tas xet/>? a/cpas etiroi' ""16l 8r/ poL a.TTOKakv\j/as Kai tcl
o~Tr}6ri Kal rb p.eracppVov e7ri8eioJ, Xva e7rtcrKe'v/Vcopai <ra<p4- 5

crrepov," Kal eyco tolovtov rt 7ro0co 7rpos Ti]v o-Ktxjnv dea-
<rdp.(vos otl ovrcos exets 7r/00 ? TO dyadpv koX t6 r)bv cos
v
cprjs, 8e'opat rototirbV rt eZiretv* I0t 8r/ pot, a> ITpcorayo'pa,
Kat ro'8e tijs biavofas aTTOKakv^/ov ttcos exets Tpos e7riaTrj- b

.ftrjjj; iroTepov Kal roCro crot boKtl uxrirep rots 7roAAois
dvdpcoiroLS, r) dAAcos; 8oKet 8e rots 7roAAots 7repi e7rtcrr?jp.?js
tolovtov rt, ovk lo-)(vp6v o?j8' r)yep.ovLKov otj8' apyj.K.6v tlvai'
ovbe cos 7repi rotovrou avroC dVros SiarooTjzrrai, dAA' eVorjcrrjs 5
7roAAd/<ty dvdpcoirco iTL<rTi]p.r)s ov rrji/ e7rtoTrjp.rj7J arjrou
apytiv dAA' dAAo rt, rore /uey 6vp.6v, tot\ 8e r)bovt]V, rore
8e kvirrjv, eiuore 8e epcora, TrokkaKLS 8e <fi6(3ov, aTe\/v ^'i
btavoovpevoi irepl r?js e7rtcrr?jp,7js cocnrep 7rept d?j8pa7rd8o7j, c
TrepLekKop.evi]s ?j7ro rcof akkcov airavTcov. dp' ovv Kal crol
tolovtov tl irepl avrr/s boKei, r/ koAojj re eu>at r/ e7rtcrrrjp?j
Kat otoj; apyeLV roO dvdpcoiTov, Kal edvrrep yLyvcocrKi] rts

rdyat^d Kat rd KaKa, /xrj d^ KparrjdrjvaL vtto p,r)bev6s uxrre 5
dAA' drra irpaTTeLV r\ av e7rtcrrr/u?/ KeAevr/, dAA' tKayr/y etrat
rr/ij <pp6vr\crLV (3or)6eiv rco dvdpcoTTco;
Kai 8oKet, ecp?j, uxrirep <rv Aeyets, cb 2coKpares, Kai dp:a,

et7rep rcp aAAcp, alcrypov ecrrt Kai ipol aocpiav Kal e7rtcrr?j- d
p.?j7J p.i] ov)(l ttclvtu>v KpcxTLcrTov cpdvaL etrjat rcojj avdpu>TTLcov
Trpayp.aTcov.
KaAco? ye, ecp?ji; eyco, <rv keycov Kal akrjdrj. oTada ovv
otl ot 7roAAoi tcov avdpcoTTcov epot re Kai croi ov 7ret#oi>rai, 5
dAAd ttoAAotjs cpacrt ytyiJcocrKOTjras rd /3e'Artcrra ovk idektLV
TrpaTTfLV, ed?j arjroty, dAAd dAAa irpaTTtLV kcxl oaovs 8r/
a8 ejTreiV] iimirflv Cobet h$ &s irtpl BW: &(nrep T

toiovtov T : rov ov tov BW c6 jjii; Sauppe & &i/ Stephanus)
W
(?) :
7) & 7) B
1
: -^ hv T ^ & v
: d4 <rv BT : aoi W
352d IIAATi2N02
eycb r)pop.r]V otl 7rore oXtlov ecrrt tovtov, vtto r)bovrjs cpao-iv
e r)TTOip.evovs r) kvTrr]s i) &v vvvbr) eyco Zkeyov vtto tlvos

TovToiV Kparovp.evovs Tavra iroieiv tovs TroiovvTas.
Ylok\a yap ot/xat, ecpr/, o) 2coKpare?, Kat dAAa ovk 6pda>s
keyovo-Lv ol avdpoiiroL.
5
"16 1 brj /xer' e/xorj eTTLxe(.pr]crov TreCOeLV rorj? av6pa>TT0vs
/cat StSdcrKety o ecrrty avrots rorjro ro 7rd#o?, 6 qbaaiv virb
353 y r)bova>v r)TTao-6ai ml ov 7rpdrreuv bia Tavra tcl /3e'Artcrra,
eireL yLyvoio-Kecv ye avrd. tcrco? yap av keyovroiv r)pa)v

otl Ovk opOais Ae'yere, co dvOpoiioL, dkka \}/evbeo-de, epoLvr
"T
&v r)p.ds' X2 Ylpoirayopa re Kat SoiKpares, et /xr/ ecrTLv
5 rorjro ro 7rdc?r//xa rjbovrjs r/rracrt9at, dAAa rt 7ror' ecrrtV, Kat
rt rj/xet? avro c/>are etz>ai; eLirarov r)pZv."

Tt 8e', ai 2o!>KpaTS, beX 77/xd? crK07retcrc9at rr/y rcorj Trokk&v
boav avdpojTToov, ot drt df rrj^cocrt rorjro keyovcrLv;
'
b Ot/xat, r/y 8' eyco, etvat tl r)pXv tovto Trpbs to eêvpelv

7rept dvbpeCas, 7rpd? rakka /xdpta tcl rrjs dperrjs 7rco? 7ror'
e\ei. et ovv crot SoKet ep.p.eveLV ol? dprt eboev r)pXv, e/xe
7/yr/cracrt9at r/ ot/xat av eycoye KaAAtcrra (pavepbv yevecrOaL,
5 eTTov et 8e /xr) /3orjAei, et crot cpCkov, ea> yaCpeLV.
'AAA', ecpr/, 6p6cos Aeyet?" Kat irepaLve &criTep ?/pco.
C ndAtv tolvvv, ecpt]v eyco, et epoLvro r)pJas' " Tt orjV cpare
rorjro etyat, 6 7//xet? t/Vtco etyat rcoy r)bovGv eAe'yop,ej>;"
et7roi/j.' ay eycoye irpbs avrovs co8t* 'AKorjere 8r/* 7retpacrd-
/xe#a ydp rj/xty eyco re Kat ITpcoraydpa? cppdcrat. dAAo rt
5 ydp, co avOpoiiTOL, cpare rjpty roCro yCyvecrOaL ev Tolcrbe,
OLOV TTOkkaKLS VTTO CTLTOiV KCLL TTOT&V KOL Ct(p pob LO~ LOiV KpaTOV-
p.evoL rjbeojv ovtoiv, ytyvoia-KovTes otl Trovrjpd ecrrty, d/xco?
arjrd 7rpdrrety; 4>atei' av. Ovkovv epotpet^' &V avrovs
eyco re Kat cnj 7rdAty Ylovrjpa be avTa 7rr/ cpare etvai;
E2 7rel yivdxTKtiv (sic) W imyivdxrKtiv BT E3 epoivr' BT :
W
:
epoir' a 5 aAAcfc T oA\o B : b I B T vfuv

tijxiv : W
bs &ov\ei, el secl. Herwerden ei tj corr. Coisl. : fnBTW
C2 i\eyofiev~\ \eyofxev Cobet

nPf2TATOPA2 353d
TTorepov otl tijv ']bovi]V TdvTrjv h> tu Trapaypi]p.a irapiytL d

m\ r)bv ccttlv emcrTOV avT&v, r) otl et? tov vcrrepov ypovov
vocrovs re 7rotet Kal irevias Kal dXXa TOLavra 7roAAd irapa-
o~K(vd(L; f/ Kav et tl tovtiov ets to vcrTepov p.r]bev irapa-
o-Kevdet, yaipcLV oe fxovov 7rotet, op.cos 8' av mm rjv, otl 5
p.a66vTa yaipeiv 7rotet Kal ottjjovv; ap' oto'jue0' av avrovs,

Sj IJpoiTayopa, dXXo tl cnroKpCvacrOaL 7/ otl ov mrd ti]V
avrrjs rrjs rjbovrjs rrjs Trapo)yprip.a Zpyacriav mm ccttlv,
dXXd ota rd vcrrt-pov yLyvop.va, vocrovs re Kat rdAAa. Eya) e

fjLtv oijuai, ecprj 6 Ylpoirayopas, tovs ttoXXovs av ravra
diroKpCvacrdaL. Ovkovv vocrovs TTOLovvra dvias 7Totet, jg(ur
TTevCdf^TTbLOvvTa avCas 7rbiei; 'O/xoAoyotcr dv, o>s ey<j>/uat.
2tW</>ri 6 YlpoiTayopas. Ovkovv cpaCv(TaL, o> dvdpioTroi, 5

vp.lv, u>s cpap.V eyco re Kat Yipojrayopas, tV ovbev dXXo
Tavra mK.d ovra rj 8toVt ets dvCas re d7roreAet;T3 Kat dXXcov
rjbovcov aTTocrTpL; 'OpLoXoyoltv dv; SweSoVet. rjpuv dp.- 354

cpolv. OtiKOM> 7rdAty av avrovs to ivavTiov et kpoCp.eda'
'II dvOpojiTOL ol Xeyovres av dyada dviapd civai, dpa ov ra

Toidbe Ae'yere, olov Ta re yvp.vdcTLa m\ ras oToareta? m\
Tas vtto t&v laTpotv OepaTTtCas ras otd mvcreoiv re ml Top.u>v 5
Kat cpapp.aKLwv ml Xlpoktovlwv yLyvop.(vas, otl Tavra

dyaOd p.iv Icttlv, dvLapa be; tpalev dv; SwetidKet. rioVe-
pov ovv mra robe dyaOd avrd KaAetre, ort ev tco Trapaxprjp.a b
obvvas Tas ZcryaTas irapiyjL ml aXyr]bovas, t/ oti et? tov
vcrTepov ypovov vytetat re a7r' avrcov yiyvovTaL m\ eve^tat
tS>v o~ojp.aToiv m\ tcov ttoXcojv crcorqpiaL m\ dXXcov apyal

m\ ttXovtol; QaTev dv, w? eywuat. SvveboKd. ^TaOra be 5
dyaOd (cttl 01' dAAo ti rj otl ety r)bovds aTTOTfXevTa mi
XvTTcav a7raAAaya9 re Kat aTTOTpoirds; i] eêre' rt dAAo reAoy
Ae'yet;', et? 6 a7ro/3Ae'\âyre9 avrd dyaOd KaAetre, dAA' (?/) C
&=, î/] efrj corr. Ven. 189 d6 /xaOSvra] ira06vra Stallbaum :
irapo vra Hermann a2av) o5 Schanz a 4 ffrpartia? T :
arparias B a6 (papfiaKtiwv T W : (pap/xaKwv B : (papfiaKiwv B*

b5 5e] 87; Sauppe c 1 fj add. Stephanus

354 c nAAT&NOS
fjhovds re kcu kviras; Ovk dv cpalev, u>s eydi/xai.
OvS' e/xoi" oo/cei, ecpi] 6 ripcorayopa?. Ovkovv ti/v p.ev
f)hovf)v otwKere a>s dyaObv ov, rf)v he kvirrjv cpevyeTe a>s
5 KaKOv; IjvvehoKei. To?3r' dpa f)yelcr6

,
eTrai kukov, ti]v
kvirrjv, Kal dyaObv tt)v f)hovr]v, etrel /cai avrb rd yoipew
tot keyere KaKov elvai, orav pei(6vu>v f)hovG>v dirocrTepf}
7] oo-as avrb eêt, rj kv-rras p.ei(ovs Trapao-Kevd(i] tG>v ev

d avT> f)hovG>v eirel et KaT dkko tl avrb to yaipeiv KaKov
KaAetre Kat ets dAAo rt re'Ao? diro^keâvTes, eôtre av Kal
f)pXv eiirelv dAA' ov^ e&re.- Ov5' ep.ol hoKovcriv, ecpr] 6
TipcoTayopas. AAAo
v
rt ovv irakiv kclI -rrepl avrov tov
A.U7reto-0ai 6 avrbs Tpoiros; totc KaAeire avrb to kvirelcrdai.
dyadov, orav r) p.ei(ovs Av7ras tG>v ev avrG> ovcrG>v cnrak-

kaTTr] 7] p.e((ovs fjhovas tG>v kvrrG>v TrapacrKevd(r]; e7rei et
7rpo? aAAo rt re'Aos a7ro/3Ae'7rere, otov Kakrjre avrb to kv-

. e irelcrOai dyaOov, f) irpbs 6 eya> Ae'ya>, eyeTe f)piv eiirelv
dAA' ovx *eTe. 'Akridfj, ecprj, keyeis, 6 YlpooTayopas.
ITdAii' toCvvv, ecpqv eya>, et pe dvepoiaOe, a> avOpooirot,
"Tlvos ovv h]iroTe eveKa 7roAAa irepl tovtov keyeis Kal
5 TroAAa^rj;" 2vyyiyva>a-Kere' p.oi, cpairfv av eycoye. irpG>Tov
p.ev yap ov pabiov drrobelât rt iariv 7rore tovto 6 vp.els
KaAetre tG>v f)hovG>v r/rra> eTvai' eVetra ev tovtio eicrlv
Trdcrai at a7ro8eiets. dAA' ert /cat vvv dvaQeo-Qai eêortr,

fV Tfyi ^X eTe AAo rt cpdvai eXvai to dyaObv
355 f) Tr)v fjhovrjv,
rj to KaKov dkko rt rj ti]v dviav f) dpKel vp.lv to f)heu>s
Kara/3t(Syat tov $Lov dvev kvirG>v; et he dpKel Kal p.f] ex T

p.r]hev dkko cpdvai. elvai dyaObv i] KaKov 6 p.f) eis TavTa
5 reAeura, to p.eTa tovto dKOvere. cprfpu yap vplv tovtov
ovtcos eyovTos yekolov tov koyov yiyvecrOai, orav keyqre
ort 7roAAaKts yiyvojo~K(t)v rd KaKa dvOpcairos otl KaKa ecrTiv,
C5 tout
1
TaCr' Cobet c 7 AeyeTe T Xtyerai B W
]
W
:
c8 irapaffKvd(ri BT irapa<rKtvati (sed i) supra et W) d.5 Ka-

W
:
Aeire BT : Ka\e7rat (sed e supra at W) a 2 &\\o ri t : fj &\\o

t( BT W a7 &vQpu>iros} 6 &v0pwiros Bekker : avdpwwos Sauppe
nP&TArOPAS 355a
dpcos 7rpdrret avrd, ibv jut/ irpaTTeLV, virb t>v fjbovcov
ayop.evo<s nal eKTrkrjTTopLevos' nai avdis av Aeyere ort b

yiyvu>o-Ko)V 6 avOpcoixos TayaOa. 7rpa.TTiv ovk et9e'Aet 8td tols
Trapaxpvp-a f]bovds, vtto tovtcov f]Trcop.evos. cos be ravra
yekold ecrTLv, KaTabr/kov ecrraL, edv pr/ irokkots 6v6p.acri
Xpcope$a dp.a, ffbel re /cat avLapco ko.1 ayadco Kal KaKco, dAA' 5
e7ret8Tj bvo ecpdvr] Tavra, bvoTv Kal 6v6p,acrLV Trpocrayopevcop.ev
avrd, irpcoTOv p.ev dyaOco Kal KaKco, eireLTa av$LS r/8et re
Kat avLapio. 6ep,evoL 6?/ ovtco keycop.ev otl TLyvcocTKcov 6 c

dvBpcoTros tcl KaKa otl KaKa Icttlv, op,cos aira 7roiet. edi> ovv
tls T/p.as epr/rat, "Ata rt; " 'Hrrcopero?, cpr]crop.ev "'Ttto
tov; " eKetôs epT/crerat fjLias' fjpXv be vtto p.ev fjbovfjs ovkc-tl
eeoTLV eliTelv dAAo ydp 6vop.a p.eTeCkr]cpev d^rt t?]s fjbovr)s 5
rd ayaOov eKeivco aTTOKpLVcop.eda Kal keycop.ev 8tl
'Hrrcopews
" bf)
'T7rd tlvos; " c/jT/cret. ToS ayaOov, cpf)crop,ev
vf] Ata. av ovv tv\i] 6 epop.evos f]p,as ?5/3ptcrrT/? cov, yeAdcrerat

Kat epel- "*H yeAotoy Ae'yere irpayp.a, et 7rpdrret rt? KaKa, d
yLyvcoaKcov otl KaKa ecrTLv, ov beov avrbvirpaTTeLV, f]TTco-
p,evos virb tcov ayaOcov. dpa" cp?/crei, " ovk dtW ovtcov
vlkclv ev vpXv tcov ayaOcov tcl KaKa, f) aicov; " cpt]crop,ev
bfjkoV OTL aTTOKpLVOp.eVOl, OTL OvK CL^LCOV OVTCOV OV yap CLV 5
er]p,apTavev 6v cpap.ev ?/rrco etmt rcou fjbovcov. " Kara rt
be," cpr]aeL tcrco?, " ava^La ecrTLV TayaOa tcov KaKcov t/ rd KaKa
tcou ayaOcov; f) KaT dAAo rt t) otov tcl iiev pet^co, ra be
0-p.LKpoTepa f) T-keico, tcl be ekaTTco " ov^ eop.ev elTrelv e
fj; fj;
d:AAo t/ tovto. " Afjkov apa," c/)T/cret, " drt to ?/rrdcrc9at tovto
keyere, clvtI ekarTovcov ayad cov p.eico kokcl kap.fia.veLv."
Taura p.ev ovv ovtco. p.eTakaficop.ev bf] tcl 6v6p.aTa irdkLV
a8 avrd T: abr6 B bi \eyere'] Xtyr-re Heindorf: secl.

Hirschig b 5 &f.ia corr. Coisl. ipoBTW
b6 na\ BT:
W
:
om. -rpo<rayopivwfj.(v"\ Trpoffayopevojutv re vera B T W^ c 1 Ae-

yiafiev T Atyo/xev B W
C 4 toi/ (sic) T tovtov B W
^pi creTat T:
W
: :
t
eipr,at rai B c6 a-TOKpiviifieda BT : airoKpiv6fie9aVJ Xeyatfiev

scr. recc. : Keyofxev BTW C7 </>ô-et corr. Ven. 189: </)tjo-i BTW
6 3 Keyere corr. Coisl. : XeyeTai BT W
355 e ITAATnNOS
5 to rjbv re Kai dviapbv eirt rots avrols tovtols, kcii keycopev
OTL "AvdpCOTTOS TTpClZJ-fL TOTe fXV ekeyOpeV TCL KaKtt, VVV be
keycop.ev tcl dvLapd, yLyvtocrKtov otl dvLapd ecrTLv, riTTcopevos
356 virb tcov i]betov, brjkov otl dvafcCtov ovtcov vlkxxv. Kal rt?
dkkrj -*dvaCa r)bovfj Trpbs Xviniv ecrrCv, dAA' ?/ vTrepl3okr]
dkkrjkcov Kal eAAen/ft?; Tavra 8' eVrt p.eC(co re Kal trpLKpo-
repa yiyvopeva dkki]ktov Kal TrkeCco Kal ekaTTco Kal p.dkkov
5 Kal rJTTov. el ydp 7-19 Atyot Sri " 'AAAd ttoAu Oia<pe'pei, <o
2w/cpare?, to irapa\pr]p.a i]bv tov ets tov vcrTepov \povov

Ka\ ijbeos Kat kvTrrjpov," Mcov dkkco rto, cpaCr/v dv eytoye,
y
?/ rjbovfj ko.1 kvirrj; ov ydp etr$ orto dkkco. dAA' tocnrep
b dyaObs lcrTdvaL dvOpcoiros, crvvdels rd i)bea ko.I trvvOels rd
kvirr]pd, Kal to eyyvs Kal to Troppto crrqcras ev tco Cv y<?>
et7re TroTepa irkeCto etrrCv. eav p.ev yap ?/8e'a 7rpd? i)bea
loTfjs, rd p.eCCco det Kat irkeCco Ar?7rrea* edv be kvTrrjpa Trpbs

5 kvTrrjpd, rd eAarrco Kat crp.LKpoTepa' edv be i)bea irpbs
kvirr]pd, edv p.ev rd dvLapd virepfidkkrjTaL virb tiov i)becov,
edvre Ta eyyvs virb tcov troppco edvre Ttx Troppto virb Ttov
eyyvs, TavTtiv Tr)v irpd^LV irpaKTeov ev rj av raur' evrj- eav
C be rd r)bea virb tcov dvLapcov, ov irpaKTea. p.rj 7rr? aAA?/
eêt, cpaCrjv dv, Tavra, a> dvdpco-roL; ot' drt oiik dv eôLev
akktos keyeLV. 2weSo'Kei Kat eKeCvco.
"Ore br) tovto ovtcos eêt, rd8e p.ot aTTOKpCvacrde, (prjcrco.
5 cpaCveraL vpZv rr) ov/>et rd a?3rd p.eyedr\ eyyvOev p.ev pei^co,
Troppcodev be eAarrw rj ov; ^r/crovcrLV. Kat rd iraxea

Kal Ta Trokkd cotravTcos; Kal al cpcoval (at) to-ai eyyvdev
p.ev p:eCov$, Troppcodev be crp.LKpoTepa.L; âtev dv. Et ovv
d ev tovtco r)p.LV r)v to ev irpaTTeLV, ev tco rd p.ev p.eydka
e 5 \fyuju.fv T \4yofiev B e 6 avdponros Sauppe

: W
6 7 \4-
ywixey T
\eyofnev B
: W
a 2 &\\tj B T hv &\\y avaîa B T : W W
[indignitas Cicero) aia Schleiermacher : Si) d|i'a Schanz iiSovrj :
Heindorf: fiSovrjs Ast : ^5oj/^ BT W a8 r)Sovfj koI \\mri B T:

t)Sovtiv Kal \virr\v W b3 etire corr. Coisl. eTire BT W ei oi
in marg. T : om. BT W c2 avdpanrot BT
:
&vdpa>-re W o?5'
W
:
T : oi>5' B 07 prius al secl. Deuschle posterius 01 add.

Heindorf

nPHTArOPAS 356d
p.r]Ki] K<xi Tip6.TTi.iv kcCl XapjidveLV, Ta be crpiLKpa Kal cpevyeLV

Kal u?/ 7rpaTTiv, rt? av rjplv crtor?/pta icpdvt] tov /3io?j; apa
r) uerp?jriK?/ Ttyvr] r) r) tov <pai.vop.zvov bvvap.Ls; ?/ avrri
piev r)p.ds iirXdva ko.1 iiroieL dvco re ml Karco iroXXaKLS 5
peTaXap.fSdveLV Tavra kol ueraue'Aetz> koX iv rats TrpdêcrLV

Kal iv rats aipecrecrLV r<2v p.eydXtov re Kat o~p.LKpG>v, r) oe
uerp?/riK?/ aKvpov piev av i-iroirrcre tovto t6 cpdvTacrpa, brrXca-
rracra be t6 aXr]des r)crvxio.v av iiroir]crev ex LV T? VX7 e V V

p.evovcrav iirl rw aXr]6el Kat ecrtocrev av tov fiiov; ap av
opoXoyolev oi dvOpooiroL irpos ravra r)p.ds rr)v p.eTpr]TiKr]v
cr&têLV av rexvr]v V dXXr]v; Tr]v uerp?/riK?jy, copoAdyet.

Tt 8' et iv rfj tov irepLTTOv ko.1 dprtou atpeVet r)puv rjv r) 5
crior)]pia tov /3tou, cnroTe to irXeov opdcas e8et eXecrOai kol

o-oVe to eXaTTov, r) avTo Trpos eavro ?/ to erepov Trpos to
tTtpov, etr' iyyvs etre Troppoo et?/; ti av eaco(ev r)pXv tov
>
fiiov; ap av ovk e7rtcrr?/u?j; /cat dp av ov uerp?/rtK?/ rts, 357

e7ret8?/7rep VTrepfioXrjs re Kat ivbeias icrrlv r) re'x^; eVetS?)
8e irepLTTOv re Kat dpTiov, apa dXX-q tls r) dptc?u?jriK?7; 'Ouo-

Aoyotei' ar ?/uu> 01 dvOpcoiroL ?/ o?/; 'E8o'kow av Kat r<5
ripcoraydpa dpoXoyelv. Etey, a> dv6poo7TOL' iirel be

v
8? / 5
r)bovrjs re Kal XvTT-qs iv dpdf] ry atpeVet icpdvq r)pXv r) crco-
TrjpCa tov /3tou ovcra, tov re irXeovos Kat eAdrroros Kat

p.ei(ovos Kal crpLKpoTcpov kol TroppcoTepco kol iyyvTtpoo, apa b
Trp&Tov p.ev ov p.eTpr]TLKr) (paivcrai, VTrepfioXfjs re Kat ivbeias
ovcra Kal lcrdrqTos Trpos aXXrjXas crKeyjrLs;
'AAA' avdyKr].
'E7ret be p.eTpr]TLKrj, avdyKj] brJTrov Texvr] Kal e7rtcrr?/jui?j.
"2vp.cpr]crovcrLV. -"Hri? p.ev Toivvv Texvq Kal iiTLcrTr]p.rj io~Tlv 5
avTi], els o.v6ls crKey\rdpe6a' otl be iirLcrrripri icrriv, roaovrov
d4^^W:^BT d.5 re kcl\ secl. Naber d6 ravra. T :
ravra B /tero/if Aeiv BT : f.Lra/jie\\fti> W d8 ST]\dxra(ra T :
$-r)\<iiffas B e3 01 W: om. re vera BT a 1 ovk add. t om.

W
:
BT W a3 7) corr. Coisl. : f) W : om. BT apid/j.ririKJ) B :
apid/j.r]rtKri T a5 eirel 8e Sr) Adam : iirl 8 8^ W : eirftSri Se BT

a6 Ti) Bt: p T b6 avrr) corr. Ven. 189: r) avrrj BTW
crxttyiiueda B T <rKtifi(i/.ie6u
: W (sed a supra u w)
357 b IIAATilNOS
eapKei irpbs ri\v airobeL^LV r)v epie det kou YlpajTayopav
C d7roSeiai 7rept 3>v r/pecr0' r/pd?. rjpecrde 8e', et p.ep.vr]crde,
'
rjvUa r/pets dAAr/A.ots o>p.okoyovp.ev e7rtcrr r/pr/s p.rjbev elvaL
Kpeirrov, akka tovto ael Kpareiv, ottov av evfj, kol r)bovr)s
Ka\ tS>v akku>v cnraVTUtv vp.eis be br) ecpare rr/y r)bovi]v
5 7roAAaKts Kpareiv koX tov elboros avOpunrov, e7reidr/ Se vpXv
ov\ uip.oKoyovp.ev, perd tovto ijpeo~6e r)p.as' " 'X2 ripa}rayo'pa
re Kat ~2o>Kpares, et p.r/ eart tovto to 7rdt9r/pa rjbovrjs fjTTacrdaL,

akka tl ttot ecrriy Kat tL vp.eis avro cpare elvai; etrrare
d r)p.iv." et pev oSv rdre evc^ws rjptv elirop.ev drt 'Ap.aOia,
KareyekaTe av r)p.S>v vvv be av r)p.S>v KaTayekare, Kal vp.S>v
avT&v Karayekdcrecrde. Kal yap vp.eis cop.oAoyr/Kare e7rtcrrr/-
pvqs evbeia eap.apTaveiv irepl Tr)v tS>v r)bovS>v aXpecriv kcu
5 XvttS>v tovs eap.apravovTas ravra be ecrrLV ayadd re Kat

KaKa Kat ov p.6vov e7rtcrrr/p.r/?, dAAd Kat rjs rb Trpocrdev ert
copoAoyr/Kare otl p.erpr/rtKr/s' r) be eâp.apravop.evrj 7rpdts
e avev eTTLcrTr]p.r\s tcrre irov Kal avrol otl ap.adLa 7rpdrrerat.
cocrre tovt eo-rlv to rjbovrjs fjrTco eXvaL, ap.a6ia r) p.eyicrTi],
rjs ITpcoraydpas obe cprjcrlv tarpds etyat Kat IIpdSiKOS Kat

'iTTTrta?' r3p.ets de dtd to olecrdaL akko tl rj dp.adiav elvaL
5 ovre avTol ovre tovs vp.eTepovs iraibas irapa tovs tovtchv

bLbacrKakovs rovcrbe tovs crocptcrrds 7re'/x7rere, cbs ov dtdaKrou
ovtos, dkka Kr]b6p.evoL tov apyvpiov Kal ov bLbovres tovtols
KaKco? 7rpdrrere Kat Ibia Kal Sr/pocrta.
358 Taura p.ev rots TroAAots airoKeKpLp.evoL civ rjp.ev vp.as be
l
br) p.eTa YIpoiTayopov epcorco, (co) \TTiria re Kat ripdcHKe
C 1 diro5?|ot] v/uv airodeTâi Stobaeus C 2 wfioXoyovfiev T

Stobaeus 6fj.o\oyovfj.ev B
: fiijdev elvai] fiii elvai /xr]Sev Stobaeus
C 6 &fxo\oyoi)fiev T Stobaeus
2
6fio\oyovfiev B T : C 7 el] ei 5e
Stobaeus c 8 dAA.d T Stobaeus &\\o B
.
elirare Stobaeus
: :
el-rere B T d 6 oii fiSvov] ovKeri Stobaeus ^sBT Stobaeus :
etsW d.7 Stl B T W

Stobaeus secl. Hirschig eâfiapTavofievi)']
:
afiapTavofxevt) Stobaeus e 5 post avrol add. ci. fre Madvig yre :
Adam otne iratSas post e 6 TovoSe transp. Cobet

. . . tovtoiv]
tovtov Cobet e6 tovs (rocpto-ras secl. Naber a2 add.
Ruckert
nPXlTATOPAS 358a
(kolvos yap br) ecrrco vpiv 6 koyos) iroTepov 8okco vp.lv dkrjdfj
keyeLV r)
'OpoAoyetre
\frevbeo-0aL. 'Tirepcpvcos eboKL airacnv dkrjdrj zlvai
ra etprj/xeVa. apa, i)v 8' eyco, t6 piev r)bv dyadbv 5

>eu>at, to be aviapbv KaKOV. rr]V be YlpobiKov rovbe biaipecriv
tS>v 6vop.aT0)v irapai.Tovp.aL' etre yap r)bv etre Tepirvbv
keyeLs etre \apTov, etre 07ro'c9ev Kal oircos x a ^P eiS Ta foiavTa
6vop.dcov, S) /3e'Aricrre Ilpo'8iKe, tovto p.01 irpbs b l3ovX.op.ai b
airoKpivai. reAacras ovv 6 YlpobiKos crvvtop.ok6yr]cr, Kat ot
aAAot. Tt 8e 8t/, Si avbpes, ecpr]v eyco, rb Toiovbe; al eirl
tovtov TTpaêts airacraL, eir\ tov dkvirois rjv Kal r)bea>s, ap*
oi Kakai [cai a>c/)e'Aip.ot]; Kat to Kakbv epyov ayaOov re Kat 5
a>cpekip.ov; ^vveboKeL. Et apa, ecpr]v eyco, to r)bv dyaOov
ecrTLv, ovbeis ovre elbcos 01/re oiop.evos dkka /3eArtco etrat 1]
a irotet, xat bvvara, eVeira 7rotet ravra, ebv tcl /3eArtar ovbe C
to ijTTio elvai avrqv dkko rt tovt' cttIv ?; dp.a6ia, ovbe
KpeiTTco eavTov akko rt rj crocpia. 2ui'e8o'Ket 7racrii\ Tt be
8?/; ap.a6iav apa to Toiovbe Ae'yere, to \j/evbrj eyeLV boav
koX e\\revcr8aL irepl t5>v irpayp,aTtov tu>v irokkov aia>v; Kat 5
tovto iracrL crvveboKeL, AAAo rt ovv, ecp-qv eyco, eiri ye tcl
KaKa ovbels eKcov epêrat oi38e eirl a oterat KaKa elvat, ovb'
eCTTL TOVTO, b>S OLKV, V dvOpCOITOV CpVO~L, Trl CX oteTaL KaKCL 6.
elvaL edekeLV ievai clvtI t5>v aya6S>v orav je avayKacrdr\

bvolv kokolv to eTepov alpelcrdaL, ovSeis to p.elC v atpr/crerat
ebv to ekaTTov; -"ATra^ra Tavra crvveboKeL airacrLV r)plv.
Tt ovv; ecpr]v eyco, KaAetre' (rt) beos Kat cp6/3ov; Kal dpa 5
TrpocrboKiav tlvcl
07rep eyco; (7700$ cre keyco,
keya> KaKov tovto, etre cpofiov etre beos KaAetre.
S> YlpobLKe).
'E8o'Ket
TipcoTayopq, p.ev Kal 'iTTTriq beos re Kat cp6/3os elvai tovto,

ripoStKCt) 8e 8e'os, cpo(3os 8' ov.
'AAA' oibev, ecpr]v eya>, e
a4 ais a\r)d7J Cobet

ato}07}] a 7 Kre yap B T elire yap W
W
:
a8 Ka\ BT:
om. b4 roirov] to<l>tci> ci. Heindorf bs nal
w<p(\i/xoi secl. Schleiermacher c 1 irotet Heindorf tiroUi. B T : W
Svyard Schleiermacher Swarai : BTW
d.4 aweSSKei W:
ffwSoKt? B T d5 ti add. Heindorf d.8 touto] ravr6 Cobet
e i 5e T om. B : Sios (m' ) Cobet /
;
358 e TIAAT&NOS
Ilpo'8tKe, 8ta<pe'per dkka Tobt. et dkr\0rj ra ep7rpocr0eV Zcttlv,
apd tls dvOpanroiv e#eAr/cret e7rt ravra Uvat a btboLKtv, eoi>
e7rt a p.i\; r) abvvarov e/c t&v cbpoAoyr/peVcoi'; a yap 8e'-
5 8otKei', cbpoAo'yr/rai r/yetaOaL KaKa etrar a 8e r/yetrat Ka/ca,
ovbeva ovre teVat e7rt raura oi!re Aap/3dye> kKovra. 'ESoKet
359 ât ravra Trdo-LV.

Ovrco br\ tovtojv v7roKeipeVcov, r)v 8' eyco, ripdSiKe' re Kat
'iTTTTia, dirokoytCcrOoj rjp.lv ripcoraydpa? d8e a ro irpoiTov

ctirtKpCvaTo 7rcos 6pOG>s eêt pr) a r6 rrpSiTov TravTairacrL'
5 rore pey ydp 8r) 7reVre ovtojv p.opCo>v rrjs apeTrjs oibev (cpr\
_ etuai r6 irepov olov to frepov, ibCav 8e avroS Kao~Tov eyeLV

bvvap.iv dAA' ou rarjra Ae'yco, dAA' a ro vcrTtpov ZLirev. ro ydp
vcrTepov ecprj ra /xei> TtTTapa e7rteiKcos 7rapa7rAr/crta dAAr/Aots
b eti/at, ro 8e y Trdû 7roAu biacpipav t&v dAAcov, rr/y dvbpeCav,

yvcacreo-OaL 8e // e$rr reKprrptco rco8e* " Erjpr/crets ydp, co 2co-
Kpares, dvOpanrovs avocrioiTaTovs p.\v ovTas Kat dSiKcordrorjj

Kat aKoAacrrordrous Kat dpac9eoTdrou?, dz>8peiordrovs 8e'* co
5 yvoicrri otl 7roArj 8ta<pe'pet r/ dvbpeCa t&v dkko>v p.opCo>v rr/s
dperr/s." Kat eycb erjflrjs ro're 7rdi>u kOavp.acra Tr\v ctTTQKpicriv,
Kat ert pdAAoy e7rei8r) rarjra pe<9' rjpcoy bL^rjkOov. r\pop.r\v
8' ouy roroy et rorjs dvbpeCovs Aeyot Oappakiovs' 6 bi, " Kat
C tras y'," e<pr7. p.zp.vr\crai, r\v 8' eyco, co npcoraydpa, Tavra
aTTOKpLv6p.evos 'i2poAo'yei.' "\0l br\, ecprjv eyco, et7re r\pXv,
TTL tC Aeyeis tras etyat rorjy dvbpeCovs; rj e0' a7rep ot
8etAot; Ovk ec/br/. OuKoCi' ec/b' eTtpa. Nat, r/ 8' 6s.

5 FloVepoy ot pikv 8etAot e7rt rd Oappakia epxorrat, ot 8e
dvbptioL e7rt rd 8etyd; Aeyerat br\, co ScoKpares, ovrcos rjTro
t5>v dvOpoiTTcov. 'AAr/t^r/, ecpr/y eyco, Ae'yeis f dAA' ov tovto

d epcorco, dAAd cri; e7rt rt $r\s tras eti'at rovs dvbpeCovs; dp
6 2 (5) npo'8j/ce Bekker as 5 ante ITpoSt/ce add. corr. Ven.

189 a7&B: TW bi irdvu iro\v B tto^ T W
W
:
b2 yvclxrto-de BT 03 tIBTW: tiVo B B 2

yvdxreo-dai : r) :
^ T C6 Seivu corr. Par. 181 1 Sa\d B T :Sr; B T 8e W : W

(sed ?j supra e W)

nPilTAFOPAS 35 9 d
e7rt to. beLva, i]yovp.<-vovs beiva tivai, ?/ c?7ri rd pr/;

'AAAd
tovto y , ecpr/, (v ols o~i) eAeyes rots XoyoLs a-ntbtlyQy] dprt
otl abvvaTov. Kat tovto, ecpr/z/ eyco, dAr/fles" Aeyets* coor' et
tovto 6pd<as d7Te5etx^J7, eVt uev a detud r/yetrat etrat orjoYts 5

epxerat, r6 etyat eairrorj r)vpe6r] ap.a6Ca ovaa.
'HjuoAoyet.
e7ret5f/
'AAAa t/7tco
p.r)v e7rt a ye 6appovcrL iravTes av

cpXovraL, Kal SetAot Kat drjopeibi, Kat ravrr] ye eVi avra
cpyovTaL ol SeiAot re Kat 01 dvdpetoi.
'AAAd tcl
p.eVrot, e<pr/, e
<h SctfKpareS, TTCLV y TOVVaVTLOV (0~TLV TTL CL ot T 8etAot
(p\ovraL Kal 61 avbptioL. avTLKa ets tov Ti6X.ep.ov ol pkv
kOikovcrLV teVat, 01 oe orjK idiXov<JLV. TloTcpov, c<pr]v eyw,
KaXov ov ieVat r/ alcr\p6v; KaAoV, ecprp Ovkovv et7rep 5
Kakov, Kat ayadbv <op.oX.oyr]crap.V iv tols zp.Trpocr6tv rds
yap KaXas 7rpd<fets a7rdcra? dyaflds <op.oX.oyr]<rap.V.
Aeyets, Kat det epotye 6oKet orjYtos.
'Opflcos ye, ec/jr/i'
'AAr/t9r/
eyco.
dAAd TTOTtpovs <pf]S ets rdy Tr6X.ep.ov ovk ZOeXeLV teVat, KaAdt 360
dV Kat ayadov; Tovs 8eiAods, r/ 8' ds. OvkoiSi;, r)v 5' eycoV
et7rep koXov kol ayaOov, kou fjbv; c

i2p,oAo'yr/rat yovv, ecpr/.
Ap' ovv yLyvGHTKovrts ol SetAot ovk eOtXovcTLV ieVat eVt rd

KaAAioV re Kat dp.uvov kol rjbLov;
'AAAd Kat rouro eay 5
6p.oXoy<2p.ev, ecpr/, 8ta<p0epo?jp,ei' rds tp.TTpocr6tv dpoAoytas.

Tt 8' 6 drSpetos;
ovk eVt rd KaAAtoV re Kat ap.Lvov kol
ijbLov epx^rat; 'A^dyKr/, ecpr/, dpoAoyeu\ OrjKOw 6'Acos ot
dySpetot ovk aiaxpovs <p6j3ovs cpo/3owrat, d'rar cpo/3coyrat, b

odde atV)(pd dappt] 6appovo~Lv;-
'AArjflr/, Et ec/jrj. 8e
alo~xpa, ap ov KaXa;
'X2poAdyet. Et 8e KaAd, Kat ayadd;
p.r)
Nat. Ovkow Kat ot SetAot Kat ot Opacreis kol ol p.aLvo-

p.evoL TovvavTiov al<rxpovs re <p6fiovs <po(3ovvTaL kol aiaxpa 5
d6 T tvpt(h\ y B
evpeOt} : ei 01 avSptloi B
correctum fuisse videtur) T: AvavSpoi vulg.
avavSpuot W :
{avSpetot e8 a~l
f/xoty- B T 4/xo\ ad y-
: W
a 1 -rorepovs T voTtpev B
W
:
fh
B T yt
<pô--is B T
:
W
a 5 icdWiov Stephanus Ka\6v B T
a 6 DiacpB-povix-v T Stacpfpovfi-v B
<f>))S
r- : W
: b 4 0} ot
:
tlpocrers secl. Dobree ko2 ot dpacrus xal oi naivo/n-voi om. Kral

:
Bpacrus
1'
: dapa-ts B

36ob IIAAT&NOS
Odpprj OappovcrLv; 'HuoAoyei. QappovcrLV 8e rd alcr-^pa
Kal KaKa bC dXXo tl r\ bC dyvoiav /cat dp.aOCav; Ovtcos
C ex eL >
^fy 7)' Tt ^ v > tovto bC o 8etAot zlcnv ol SetAot,
betXCav r/ dvbpeCav KaAets; AetAiay eycoy', Z(pr\. AetAot
oe ov 8ta 'irjv tS>v btLvcov ap.aOCav i(pdvrj(rav ovtcs; Yldvv
y, (prj. Atd Tavrrjv dpa Tr\v dp.aOCav beiXoC cIctlv;
5 'HuoAdyet. At' o 8e SetAot dcnv, SetAia 6/xoAoyetrai 7rapa
croS; Swecpr]. Ovkovv r) tS>v btLvcov Kal
'AAAd p.r\ beLvcov dp.aOCa
8etAta av etr/; 'E7reVerjcre. p.r\v, r)v o' eyco, ivavrCov

d dvbpeCa 8etAta.
"Ecpr/. Ovkovv r) tS>v btLvcov Kal p.r\ beLvcov
o-ocpCa ivavrCa ti\ tovtcov dpaOCq icrrCv; Kat ivravOa ert
iirivevcrev.
'H 8e tovtcov dpxxOCa 8etAia; Yldvv p.6yLS
ivravOa iirivevcrev. H l
crocpCa dpa tS>v beLvcov Kal ur/
5 beLvStv avbpeCa iarCv, ivavrCa ovcra rf) tovtcov dp.aOCq;

OvKeVi ivravOa ovt iTTLvevo-aL r)0iXt]o-ev icrCya re. Kat iycb
zlttov Tt br), co YlpcoTayopa, ovtc av cpr/s d Ipcorco ovt?

a7ro'077s; Avros, ecprj, Tripavov. "Ev y', ecprjv iyco, povov
ipop.evos Irt cre, el ctol cocnrep to irpcoTOV ert 8oKo5crti>
etuat rtyes dvOpcoiroL dp.a0io-TaTOL fiiv, dvbpeioTaTOL 8e.

<J>tAovtKeu' uot, ecpr/, SoKets, S> ScoKpare?, to eue elvat tov
aTTOKpLv6p.evov yapLovp.aL ovv crot, Kat Aeyco drt eK tS>v
5 (op.oXoyrjp.ivcov dbvvaTov uot boKtl etrat.
Ovrot, r)v d' eyco, dAAou eveKa ipcorco ixdvra ravra ?/
(TKi^facrOaL (3ovX6p.evos ttcos ttot lêt ra 7rept rrjs dperrjs Kal
tC ttot icrTLV avro, r) dperT/. otoa yap otl tovtov (pavepov

361 yevop.ivov /xdAtcrr' dv KardbriXov yivovro iKelvo irtpl ov iyco
re Kat cttj p.aKpdv Xoyov kKarepos direTeCvap.ev, iyco pkv Xiycov
ios ov bLbaKTOv dpeTt], crv 8' cbs 8i8aKroV. xai uot boKtLr)p.S>v
r) dpTL côbos tcov Xoycov cocnrep dvOpcoTTOS KaTrjyopdLV re Kat
b 6 alcrxpa tal /ca/ca BT : /ca*cct /cal a<Vxpa W 03 Seivwv corr.

Ven. 189: Set\a>v BTW c6 oeivwv . . . oeivcov corr. Ven. 189 :
SetXwv . . . 8ei\a>v BT W d 4 Seivwv . . . Seivuv T SetXwv

: . . .
Set\a>v B W 63 i<pi) B W : ert T to] irpbs rb ci. Schanz

rbv T : rb B
nPOTArOPAS 361 a
Karayekav, Kal et <po>vr]V kafioi, et7reu> av otl ""Atottol y 5

eore, o> StoKpaTts re Kal Tipo>Tay6pa' av p.ev kiyo>v otl ov
bibaKTov ia-TLV dperr] iv tols ^p.TTpocrdev, vvv aeavTG> ravavTLa
cnrevbeLS, iiTLyeLp&v aTrobeiâi cos Trdvra \pr\p.aTa icrrLV Zttl- b
OTrjfirj, Kal r) bLKaLocrvvr] koI croxppocrvvr] Kal r) avbpeia,
co rpoVo) /xdAior' av bLbaKTov <pavt-Lr] r) dpeTj]. et p.ev yap
dkko tl r]v i] e7rtcrrr/ur/ r) dptTij, uxrirep Ylpo>Tay6pas e7re)(eipei
Ae'yeu>, crac/jcos ovk dv r)v bLbaKTov vvv oe et <pam/crerai 5
TTLo-Tr]p.r] okov, cos av cnrerJSei?, oi) ScoKpares, 6avp.daLov

ecrrai p.r) otoaKrdy ov. YJpooTayopas o' av otSaKrdv tot
VTTodep.cvo$, vvv ToivavTLOV olkV airevbovTL okiyov TrdvTa
p.akkov <pavrjvaL avrb r) irrLaT-qprjv koX ovto>s av r/Ktora C

etr/ bLbaKTov." eyco ovv, o> Ylpo>Tay6pa, trdvTa ravra KadopS>v
dvo> /cdrco TaparTopieva bLvo>s, Trdaav 7Tpo6vp.Lav i\o> Kara-
<pavr) avrd yei>e'cr0at, Kal /3ovkoLp.r]v &v Tavra bieêkdovTas

r/wds iêkdelv Kal inl Tr)v apcTr]v otl Zcttlv, Kal Trdkiv 5
iTTLo-Ki\j/ao-6aL irepl avTOV eire bLbaKTbv etre p.r] bibaKrov,

p.r) TTokkaKLs r/uds 6 'E7Tip.r]devs e/cetôs Kat iv rf/ oTceSêi
<r<pr]kr] iaTraTr]o-as, cocr7rep Kal iv rf/ bLavop.fj r)p.ikr]aev d

r)p.u>v, cos <pf]S o~v. rjpeaev ovv uot Kal iv rco p.v6o> 6
Ylpop.r]6evs pakkov tov 'E7rtur/c9e'cos' cS \po>p.evos eyco ku\
Trpop.r]6ovp.evos virep tov /3tou tov euaurorj Travrbs TrdvTa
ravra 7Tpayp.aTevop.aL, Kal et av idikoLS, oirep koX kot ap\ds 5
ekeyov, /xerd <tov dv T/otara rarJra avvbLaaKOTTOvqv.
Kat 6 ripcoraydpas, 'Eyco p.iv, e0r/, o> 2coKpares, eTratrco
crov rr]v 7Tpodvp.Lav Kal ttjv bLtobov t5>v koyo>v. Kat ydp 01/re
rdAAa dlpaL KaKos elvaL dv6po>Tros, <pdovep6s re r/Ktcrr' dv6po>- e

7rcoy, e7ret Kat 7rept crou 7rpds 7ro\Aoi? 8r/ eXpr]Ka otl coy ivTvy-
\dvo> irokv /xdAtcrra dyap.aL cri, tS>v pX-v rr]kLKOVTo>v Kal Trdvv
Kat Ae'yco ye ort ovk &v 6avp.d(fiLp.L et rcoy ikkoyCp.o>v yivoLo
a7 aperi) BWt: 7) apfr^ T b4 f) iiriffT^fir) f) Stephanus: 17

ti-iffri)HT) ^BTW b6 '6Xov BT W : ov vulg. c 5 ifa\6uv
BT : 4\0t?v t d5 f l ffv T : tlaoi B d6 ffvvStaffKOTroirjv BT
W
:
StaffKo-roir)v
PLATO, VOL. III. 17

36ie nAAT&NOS nPX2TATOPA2
5 avbp&v kia aocpia, xai nepl tovtcov 8e eis avOis, orav fiovkr},
biiip.V vvv 8' &pa ?/otj nal eV akko tl TpiirearOai.
362 'AAA', r)v 8' eyoi, ovtoo \pr] 7roteu>, ei o-ol Sokci. koi
ydp e/xot otTreo (j>rjv livai 7rdAai wpa, dAAd KaAAia r<5
KaAw yjxpiCpp.evos irapip,tiva.
Tavr' dirovTts nal anovo-avTes aTrf}p.ev.
e6 SielinfvBH: SieJ^BT
^b
ropriA^
KAAAIKAH2 2I2KPATH2 XAIPE<M2N .
St. I
ropriAs n&AOs p.447
KAA. noAe/xou ko.1 p-dxrjs c/)acri \prjvai, S 2w/cpares, a

odra) peraAayxdreiv.
212. 'AAA' ?/, ro kty6p.e:vov, KaToiriv koprrjs ijKopev Kal

vo~Tpovpev;
KAA. Kat fxdka ye dcrreias eoprT/s* 7roAAd yap Kal KaAd 5
Topy(as r)pXv 6\(yov nporepov e7re8et<faro.
212. To?Jrcoi> pzvToi, 00 KaAAt/cAet?, atrtos Xatpecpcor 6'8e,
iv ayopa avayK&cras fjpas biaTptyai.

XAI. OvSef irpaypa, a> ScoKpares* ey<w ydp /cat la.o-op.ai. b
(p(Xos ydp pot Topy(as, cocrr' e7ri8etcferat ^pu;, et ph' 8oKet,
yuz>, eay 8e /3ovA?/, ets a50i?.
KAA. Tt 8e', ct> Xatpecpaw; (Tridvpel 2coKpdr?/9 aKovarat

Topyiov; 5
XAI. 'E7r' a?3rd ye rot roCro 7rdpecrp.ei\
KAA. Ov/cow oray /3ovAr/crt9e 7rap' epe ?//cety otKa8e* 7rap'

epot yap Topyias KaraAdet Kat e7rioeterat ?3pti\
212. Ei! Ae'yets, co KaAAtKAets. dAA' apa ec9eA?/oretev av

fjp.lv btaXcxOrjvaL; /3ovAopat ydp TtvdiaOai 7rap' avrou r& ?/ C
a3 ctAA' ^ B P
2
:a\\' ^BTF Olympiodorus Suidas : apa in marg.
T (schol. B a\\' f) &\\' &pa)
*"*
ical vo-repovfxev secl. Cobet (non laudat
Olympiodorus) as eoprrjs secl. Hirschig b3 eisP: ^sBTF
b 7 j)Keiv} TJ/cer' Cobet b8 yap BW : om. TPF /col secl.
Schanz (post Kara\vet distinguens) hg ede\i)o-eiev av BTP F:
10e\r)ffet Olympiodorus
5
17*
447 c nAATI2N02
bvvap.LS rr)s Te\vqs T v avbpos, koa t'l ecrrLv b eTrayyekkerai
re kcu 8t8do-Ker r?p' be aAAr?i> eiribeL&v els avOis, &crirep crv
keyeLS, TrovqcrdcrBoi.
5 KAA. Ovbev olov to avrbv epoirdv, 3) ScoKpares. /cai yap

avrco kv tovt r)v rr)s eTTLbeieo)S' eKekeve yovv vvvbr) epcoray
ort rts flovkoLTO tG>v Zvbov ovtcov, kol -rrpbs diravTa ecpr]
aTTOKpiveTo-daL.
22. *H KaAcos Aeyets. co Xatpecpcor, epov ovtov.

io XAI. Tt epcojuat;
d 212. "Ocrrt? ioriv.

XAI. IIws Aeyets;
2H. "lcnrep av et ervyxctrey coy virobr]p.dTO)v br]p.Lovpyos,
aireKpivaTo av bt]Trov o-ol otl (tkvtotoplos' rj ov p.av0dveLS us
5 Aeyco;
XAI. Mav0dvo) /cat eprjo-op.aL. Et7re' p.oL, w Topyia,
akr]0r) Aeyet KakkLKkrjs 6'Se ort e-rrayyekkr] aTroKpivecr0aL otl
av tls cre epcora;
448 rOP. 'AA??0r?, S) XaLpecp&v kol yap vvvbr) avra ravra

eirr]yyekk6p.r]v, Kal Ae'yco ort ovSets pe' 7rco ?}pcor??Ke kolvov
ovbev -rrokkwv eT&v.
XAI. 'H ttou apa paSicos aTTOKpLvfj, 00 ropyta.
5 rOP. Hdpecrrt rovrou irelpav, 0) XaLpecp&v, kap.fidveLV.
nX2A. Nr) Ata* ar 8e' ye ftovkr], co Xaipecpcor, epoO.
ropyta? pey yap Kat a7retpr?/ceVat pot 80/cer Trokka yap dpTL
bLeki]kv6ev.
XAI. T 8e, co ncoAe; otet ov KdkkLov b\v Topyiov
10 aTTOKpivacrOaL;
b ni2A. T 8e tovto, eav croi ye iKat*<Ss;

XAI. Ovbev dAA' eVetS?) o~v /3ovAet, airoKpivov.
ni2A. 'EpcoYa.
XAI. 'Epcorco 8?/. et ervyâye Topyias eirLorr]p.o)v tov
d 7 a/KOKplveaQai BTP : airoKpivelaQai F a 4 aTro/cpive? B a7ro- :
pireiT airoKpivi)
: PF a5 \afxr3dvetv B T P Xafietv F : a 6 8
BTP : om. F a 8 8 AÂvfle/ B T P 8if t \-f)\v0 F
:
TOPriAS 448b
rrjs rix^vrjs rjcnrcp 6 d8eAc/>os avrov 'HpobLnos, tC dv avTov 5

(avop.dCop.ev biKaCcas; ov% orrep tKiivov;
riX2A. Udvv ye.
XAI. 'Iarpcw apa (pdcrKovTts avrbv elvai Kak&s hv

kkzyop.zv.
ni2A. Nat. 10
XAI. Et 8e ye rjcnrtp 'Apto-Tocp&v 6 ' AyXaocp&vTos rj 6

dbtkcpbs avrov tp.Tttipos rjv Ti"yvr)s, Tiva av avTov opd&s
(Kakovp.tv;
YlilA. Aijkov ort wypd<pov. C
XAI. Nw 8' eTTtt.br) tCvos Ttxyis tTno-Trjpcov ZcttCv, Tiva
av KakovvTts avrbv 6p6S>s Kakoip.ev;
r
ni2A. il Xaipecpcov, Trokkal Ttyvai. iv dv6p<aTrois etcrtv
(k tS>v (p.7reipi&v tp.TreCptoS r)vpr)p.evai.' Zp.TTZipCa pkv yap 5
7roiei tov al&va r)p.&v TropevecrdaL Kara Teyvr)v, drreipCa 8e
KaTa rvyjjv. eKao-Tojv 8e tovtcov peTakap.f3dvovcnv dkkoL
dkkcov dkkcos, t&v 8e dpCcrTcov ol aotoroi* a>v /cat Topytas
ecrrtz/ o8e, Kal juere'xei Trjs KakkCcrTrjs tQv TeyyGtv.
212. KaAcos ye, a> TopyCa, c/>au>erat ricoAos TrapecrKevd- d
crdaL ets Ao'yous' dkka yap 6 VTrecryeTO Xaipecp&VTi ov
TTOlti.
rOP. Tt udAtora, co ScoKpares;

2X2. To epa)Tu>p.evov ov Trdvv uot c/mtrerai aTTOKpCvzaOai. 5
rOP. 'AAAd crv, et fiovkei, ipov ovtov.
2X2. Ovk, et avrco ye crot (3ovkop.ev<o o~tlv aTTOKpCvo~dai,
dkkd rrokv dv ijbiov cre'. 877A0S yap uot IIcoAos koX e coi
ipr)K(v otl tt)v Kakovp.ivr)v pr)Topt.Kr)v p.akkov ueueAerrjKei'
r) 8taAe'yecr#at. IO
ni2A. Tt brj, 00 2coKoares; e

2X2. "Ort, 00 IlcoAe, epopevov Xaiptcp&VTos tCvos FopyCas
b5 T)p6hiKos BTP : irpooiKos F W Olympiodorus : riva BT WF

C3 Ka\o?/j.eu BTP: av KaKolpav F ds eis BTPf: irepi F
d7 airoKpivto-Qai. BTP : anoKpivaaOai F d8 tre F <roi B (sed
W
:
acccntum add. B :
) T ct suprascr. f
44e FIAATX2N02
zTn(TTi]ix(DV Te\vr]s, eyKcoptdcfeiS' p.ev clvtov ti]v Te\yi]v uxnrep
tlvos \f/eyovTos, r/ris 8e ecrTLV ovk aireKpivco.
5 ni2A. Ov yap a-neKpLvdp.r]v otl eti] i) KaWCarr];

2X2. Kat /xdAa. dAA' ovbels epcoTa 7rota rts 77 Yopyiov
n)(vr], dAAd rts, kol ovTiva beoi Kakeiv tov TopyCav (ocnrep
ra ep.irpocrdev o~ol vireTeJvaTO Xaipecp&v kol avrG> KaAcos
449 Kat 8td (3pa)(ecov direKpivco, Kal vvv ovtcos elrre tls i) Teyyq
koX TLva Topyiav KakeXv )(pr] r]]ias. p.a\kov be, Z> TopyCa,
avrbs r]]uv elire rtVa o-e \pr) KaAety cos rtws eiTLcrTi]p.ova
T)(Vr]S.
5 rOP. T77S pr]TopLKrjs, S> 2coKpares.

212. 'Pr/ropa dpa XP?7 ce Kakelv;
TOP. 'Ayadov ye, w 2coKpares, et 877 o ye ev\op.aL elvaL,
m e<pr/ "Op.r]pos, fiovkeL /xe KaAeti\
212. 'AAAd /3or/Aop,at.
io TOP. KaAet 5r/.
b 2X2. Ovkovv kol aXXovs cre obG>p.ev bvvarov eTvaL iroLelv;

rOP. 'E77ayye'AAopat ye bi) raura ov poVoi> evda.be dAAd
Kat dAAoflt.
T
212. Ap' ovv edeki]craLS dv, S> Topyia, locnrep vvv 8ta-
5 Aeyo'pe0a, StareAeVat t6 p.ev epcorcov, to cV arroKpLvop.evos,
to be iirJKOs tG>v Xoycov tovto, olov koX ilcoAos ijpgaro,
els av$LS airoOecrdai; dAA' 07rep vttlo-)(vT], p,?/ \f/evcri], dAAa
ede\r]o~ov Kard fipaxy to epcoTcop.evov diroKpivecrOaL.
rOP. Etcrt p.ev, a> 2coKpares, eVtat tG>v airoKpicrecov
io dvayKalaL 8td p.aKpG>v tovs koyovs TroLelcrOaL' ov p.i)v dAAd
C ireLpdcrop.ai ye cos bid (3paxyTaTcov. Kal ydp av Kal tovto
ev ecrTLV cov c/>r/pt, ]xi]beva av ev [SpayyTepoLS e/xou rd avrd
elirelv.
2X2. Tovtov p.r]v 8et, S> Topyia' Kai pot eiribeL^LV avrov
e5 ^BTP: om. F e6 epooTa BTP : rovr' tpooTa F : ^piira

Bekker ffoj post iroia ris add. B T : post Topyiov F delevi :
b7 airoQio-Bai BTPF (sed va supra iro f) post aTroOtaOai lacunam

indicat Schanz C2 4V eVT/ B P Ft : ivto-riv T 04 ;uV
BTPF : fi4vroi Olympiodorus
:
:
TOPriAS 449C
tovtov iroCrjcraL, tt)s fipayyXoyCas, p.aKpokoyCas Se ets 5
avdts.
TOP. 'AAAci ttouJo-o), fcai ovbtvos cpr/creij fipayy\oyo>Tipov
a.Kovo~ai.
2X2. <Pe'pe 8r/- pr/Topt/d/s yap cpr)s (TiicrTT]p.o>v Txyr]s
elvau Kal Troirjcrai av kol akkov pfjTopa' r) prjTopLKr) irepl tl d

t&v ovtojv Tvy\dvL ovcra; coo-irep r) vcpavTLKT] irepl tt]v tS>v
tpariW epyacrCav r/ ydp; rOP. NaL Ovkovv 2X2. Kal
r) poucri/a/ irepl ti]V tS>v p.ckS>v TroCrjcrLv; rOP. Nai.

2X2. Nl/ rr/y "Hpav, o> YopyCa, dyapat ye tcls cnroKpCcrfLS, 5
OTl CLTTOKpCvi] b>S OLOV T 8ta fipayVTaTOiV.

rOP. Tldvv yap otpai, o> 2coKpares, e7rteiKcos' tovto ttollv.
2X2. Ev Aeyets. t0t brj /xot diroKpLvaL ovtcos Kal 7rept
T?]s pr]TOpLKT]S, TTfpl tC TU>V OVTOiV (CTTLV ZlTLCrTT]pLr] ',
TOP. Ilept Adyous. 2X2. rioiou? tovtovs, o> TopyCa; apa e

o*t br]\ovcn tovs Kap.vovTas, cos clv taircop,e*>oi vyLaCvoLtv;
FOP. Ov. 2X2. Ovk apa 7rept 7rdi>ras ye tovs Xoyovs r)
pr]TopLKr] ko-T.LV. rOP. Ov br)ra. 2X2. 'AAAd p.r)v Aeyety

ye 7rotet hvvaTovs. rOP. Nat. 2X2. Ovkovv ircpl covTrep 5

Aeyety, fcat cppovetv; rOP. Hcos yap ov; 2X2. *Ap' ovv,
rjv wvbr) eAeyopei, r) laTpLKr) irepl tG>v Kap.vovTo>v ttolu 450

owarovs eiâi cppovtlv Kal Ae'yetv; rOP. 'Az/dyKr/.
2X2. Kat r/ larpLKT] dpa, cbs ZoLKtv, 7reptAdyovs iorlv

TOP. Nat. 2X2. Tovs ye Trept tcl vocrr]p.aTa; TOP. Md-
Atcrra. 2X2. Ovkovv Kal r) yvp.vacrTLKr) 7rept Adyous ecrrty 5
tovs 7rept tvc^Cav re tS>v cro>p.dTo>v Kal Kaytj-Cav; rOP. Tldvv

ye. 2X2. Kat p.r]v /cat at aAAat TtyyaL, o> TopyCa, ovtois
(XOVctlv eKao-TT] avT&v 7rept Adyous eortz> tovtovs, 01 ruy- D
Xavoucrii' ovres irepl to trpayp.a ov kKacrTr} Icttlv r) Teyyr].
C 5 rrjs &paxv\oyias secl. Cobet c B T P ôjtjs Suv F

7 (pâfis :
(sed Suv punctis del. f) C9 t4x v7 s BTP: rix^

l-Kitrri\)uev
iTri(TTr)iJ.wv F 65 iroier B F W : iroitiv T e 6 \eyetv B T P
1
Kal \4ytiv F olv B T P F ov k<x\

: suprascr. b a 1 %v B T P f
7j F e\iyofj.ev i) scr. recc. : \4yotiev 7) B W : \eyo/j.ev T : \eyofiivti
F ttou? F : om. BT et re vera W a3 tj BTP : om. F
45ob I1AATX2N02
rOP. 3>aiverai. 2X2. Tt ow 8?; 7rore tcls dkkas Teyvas
ov pijropiKas KaAets, ovcras irepl koyovs, eXirep ravrr]v
5 pt)TopiKi]v KaAe??, i) clv r) irepX koyovs;

rOP. "Ort, 3) 2coKpares, rcoy juey aAAcoi> TeyvQ>v irepl
yeLpovpyias re Kal rotavras TrpdeLS cos eTros et7reu> Trdcrd
ecrriv r) iTTLo~Tr)p.r}, ttjs be prjTopiKrjs ovbev eo-TLV tolovtov

yeLpovpyr]p.a, akka 7racra r) irpd^LS Kal r) KvpcocrLS ota koycov
C ecrriv. 8ta ravT eyco Tr)v pr]TopLKr)v Te\vt)v dftco elvaL irepl
koyovs, opdcos keycov, cos eyco <p?7Ui.
2X2. *Ap' ovv p.av6dvco otav avrr)v (3ovkeL Kakelv; tclxo.
be etcrouai aacpecrTepov. dAA' cnroKpLvaL" eicrlv r)p.w TeyyaL.
5 V yap;
TOP. Nat.
2X2. Ylacrcov br) otuat tcov Teyycov tcov p.ev epyaaia to
irokv Zcttlv Kal koyov (Bpaxeos 8e'oyrat, eviai 8e ovbevbs
akkh TO TTJS TX vr1 s TTepaivOLTO CLV KCU bLCL (TLyijS, olov
io ypacpLKr) kcxl dvbpLavToiroLia kol aAAat irokkai. tcls tol-
d avra? uot SoKets keyeLV, irepl as ov cpj)s rr)v pr)TopLKr]v etvaL'
r] ov;
rOP. Xldvv p,ev ovv mkcos virokap,fidveLS, co 2coKpares.
2X2. "Erepat 5e ye etcrt tcov Te\vcov a\ ota Aoyou ttclv
5 irepaivovcrL, Kal epyov cos eiros eiirelv r) ovbevbs irpocrbeovTaL

7] (3pa\eos ttclvv, dlov r) dpic9ur?rtK?) xai AoyicrriK?) /cai yeco-
uerptK?) Kai 7rerrei>riK?7 ye Kai aAAat 7roAAai reyyaL, cov
eVtat o~yebov tl Xcrovs tovs koyovs eyovcrL rats 7rpdecr/, ai
be TTokkal Trkeiovs, Kai to Trapdnav Tracra r) 7rpafts Kai to

e Kvpos avTaxs 8ta koycov ecniv. tcov tolovtcov TLvd uot
SoKets keyeLV rr]v pr\TopLKj]v.
TOP. 'A\ri0rj keyeLS.
2X2. 'AAA' oUrot tovtcov ye ovbep.iav otuat cre fiovketrdaL
5 pr)TopLKr)v KakeXv, ov\ otl tco p?/uari ovtcos eXires, otl r) bLa
c 7 5}; BT WF : 8* al. /iiv BTP : (ih iv F d i 5oe?s

BTP : Soku F e 4 oCtoi F : oti n BTW
ropriAS 450 e
koyov to Kvpos <-x.

ovo~ a pi)TopiKr) ecrTLV, kclI V7Tokd(3oL dv tls,
ei (3ov\oito bvcryepaCveLv ev rots koyoLs, " Tr)v api6p.r)TiKi)v
apa pr]TopiKr\v, a> Topyia, keyeLs; " dAA' ovk ot/xai cre ovre
ti]v api6p.r]TiKT)v ovre ti)v yeoip.TpCav pr)TopiKr]v keyeLV.
rOP. 'Opt9<S? yap otet, a> ScoKpares, Kat bLKaCtos vtto- 451
Aap/3arets\
XQ. "\6l vvv Kal o~i> Ti]V diroKpLcrLV i)v i)p6p.i)v bLairepavov.
eirel yap prjTopLKr) TvyydveL p.ev ovcra tovtcov tls tG>v T(\vS>v
tG>v to ttoXv Ao'yco xpcop.evcov, TvyydvovcrLV be Kat aAAat 5
TOLavTaL ovaaL, 7retpco eirreXv i) irepl tC ev koyoLS to Kvpos

ex.ovcra p?/ropiKT/ <ttlv. &o-rrep av et tls p.e epovro 5>v vvvbr)
ekeyov irepl ijo-TLVocrovv t5>v T\vG>v "*H ScoKpare?, rts
ecrrty ?/ apL6p.r)TLKi) re'xi>?/; " ei7rot/!x' av avT<2, Sicnrep <tv dpTL, b
ort tG>v Sta Ao'yot> tls to Kvpos e\ovo-G>v. Kal et pe eirave-
poLTo' " TG>v irepl rt; " eXiroLpC av otl tG>v irepl to apTLov re
koX rrepLTTov [yvGto-Ls], ocra av eKarepa Tvyyavr) oVra. et
5'
av epoLTO' " Ti]v be AoytcrriKT/y rtVa KaAets Teyvi]v; " et7rotju,' 5
av otl koX avTt) <jt\v tG>v Aoyco ro ttclv Kvpovp-evoiV kol ei

eiravepoLTO' " H 7rept rt; " et7roip' av uxnrep ol ev rco bijpao
C
orvyypacp6p.VOL, otl tcl p.ev dkka KaOarrep i) apL0p.i]TLKr) i) C

AoytartK?) eêt 7rept to axrro ydp <ttlv, to re dpTLOv /cal
to irepLTTOv 8tac/>e'pet be too-ovtov, otl koX irpos avrd Kal

7rp6s aAAr/Aa 7rcos eêt TrkqOovs ttlo-kottL to irepLTTOV Kal
to dpTLOV ?/ AoytcrrtK?/. Kat et rt? Ti]V daTpovop.Cav ave- 5
Polto, ep.ov keyovTos ort Kat avrr) Ao'yco KvpovraL Ta iravTa,

" 01 be koyoL ol rrjs ao-Tpovop,Cas," et cpaCi), " irepl tC elcnv,
6) ScoKpares; " et7rotp,' av otl irepX ti]v tG>v dcrTpcov cpopdv
Kat ?/At07j Kat o-eki)vr]s, irG>s Trpos akkr)ka Ta\ovs e\t"
e 7 V F : om. BT W B T 2 P F ytu- e9 yeco/xeTpiap f>r)ropiKi]v :
fitTpiK^v v
ut videtur) T
F a3
%v\ ?J ci. Sauppe vvv BT W : o5v
a 5 \6yv B T P twv F (^suprascr. &v
: F :
bv vvv f) b 2 ^x 000"*" B T F exv<rav T b 4 yvwffis secl.2

W :
Bekker oaa av Tvyxdvrj B T P '6a av . Tvyxdvei F

. . So~a : . . . :
. .Tvyxoivtt Ast
. C 5 avepoiTO T P avaipono B (sed supra a< :
b) tpoiTo F
: c 9 ttcSs B T P ical nus F :
45ic nAATX2N02
10 rOP. 'Op#<Ss ye keyoiv av, S> 2c)Kpares.
d 212. "\di br) Koi av, 2> Topyia. rvy^dvei. pkv yap br) 17
pr)Topt.Ki] ovaa ratv Adya) tcl Travra bLairpaTTopivoiv re Kal
Kvpovp.ivu>v r) ydp;
v
rOP. Ecrri TavTa.
5 212. Ae'ye br) t&v 7rept rt; (tl) ecrrt tovto t&v ovTOiv,
Ttepl ov ovtol oi Adyot elalv ols r) pr)TopLKr) xPV Tai >
rOP. Ta peytora rwy avdpomzCoiv Trpaypdroiv, a> 2co-
/cpares, Kat dpiarTa.
2X2. AAA , cb ropyta, dp.cpLafir)Ti)aLpov Kat rouro Ae'yets

e xat ovbev ttoj aacpis. oto/xat ydp cre dKT?Koe'vai er rots
avp.iroaCoLS qbdvTOiv dvOpoiTroiV tovto to crKokidv, *v <L Kar-
apidp,ovvTai qbovres otl vytaiveiv p.ei> dpio~Tov kaTLV,
to 8e 8edrepoz> KaXov yzvkaQaL, TpCrov bi, a>s cprjaLV
5 7rotr7rr)s roi) o-koAiou, ro 7rAourety dddAcos.
rOP. 'AKT/Koa ydp* dAAd 7rpds rt tovto Aeyets;
452 212. "Ort et crot avrwca irapaaTaTev oi br)p.Lovpyo\ tov-

TOiv a>v kirr)veaev 6 to crKokLov TTOLrjcras, larpds re Kat
7rat8orpt/3r?s Kat \pr)paTLaTr)s, kol clttol irpuiTov pev 6 iarpos
drt "'12 2wKpares', ea7rara cre TopyCas' ov ydp iaTLV i)
5 tovtov Ttyyr) nepl to p.iyLcrTov dyaOov tols dvQpoyiroLs, dAA'

r) ep.r)
"
et ovv avrov eya> epoCp.t)v 2v 8e rts a>v Tama
Aeyets; enrot dv laa>s otl laTpds. Tt ovv Aeyets; r/ to rrjs
arjs Teyvr)s epyov p.eyLaTov Icttlv ayaOdv; " n3s yap ov,"
cpaCr) av laois, " d> 2wKpares, vyCeLa; rt 8' ecrrti> p.el(ov dyadov
b dvOpoiiroLS vyLeCas; " et 8' av p.erd tovtov 6 7rat8orpt)3r?s et7roi
ort " Qavp.doLp.C t&v, co 2coKpare?, Kat avros et crot eôt
Topytas p.ziCpv dyaOov e7rt8et<fat rr/s arjrou Ti\vr)s r) eycb
d.3 Kvpov/j.evut' F (suprascr. tii f): Kvpovfievwt/ tivwv BTW d5 rl

add. Heindorf om. : BTWF d6 o5 BTWF: t> Hirschig ovroi
secl. Cobet e 1 otofiai BT P : o?yuot F a 1 if o-o< F : croi
BT P ot-rr/ca BT PF
(sed av suprascr. f) a 7 9, B T P SVt F :
^9 vyUia secl. ci. (^s 7') u^êta ci. Vahlen

Hirschig : b 1 tovtov
BTPF : toOto Olympiodorus b 2 t&v B T P F y' &v Coracs &y : :
Heindorf: pevT&v Cobet cxotBT: xet PF

:
TOPriAS 45 2b
rijs epj/y" eiTToifjL dv av nal irpbs tovtov 2i 8e 8?/ rts et,

oo avdpcoTre, Kal tC to abv epyov; " natoorpt/3?/s," c/W?/ dv, 5
"ro oe epyov pov kaTLV koKovs re Kat la^vpovs irotelv tovs
dvdpcoirovs Ta awpara." perd oe t6v iraiboTpi^rjv clttol
av 6 \pqp.aTLOTr\s, <ws eywpai 7rdm> Karaqbpov&v aTrdvTcov

'*
^Koirei bijra, a> ScoKpares, edi> aot 7rAo?jro?j c/ja^?) rt /xet^bjj C
dyadbv ov ?/ 7rapa Topyta ?/ 7rap' dAAco drc<)o?jV." cpat/xey av
ovv irpbs avTov Tt oe 8?/; 77 crt tovtov br)p.Lovpyos; 4>at?/
d<v. Tts &v; " XpTj/xarto-rT/s." TiotjV; Kpivets av p.iyLarov

avOpwirots ayaObv etvai ttX.ovtov; cpijo~op.ev. " TLcos yap ovk;" 5
epet. Kat p.rjv dp.q)La(3qTL ye TopyCas obe tijv 7rap' avr<2
Teyjvqv p.eC(pvos ayaOov ahCav etvai r) r?ji> ar]v, qâxp.ev av

?//xets\ brjkov ovv otl rb /xerd tovto epotr' av " Kat rt earty
tovto to ayadov; diroKpLvdadco TopyCas." Wl ovv vop.Caas, d

o) TopyCa, ipcoTaaOaL Kal V7r' tKtCvcov Kal v-n e/xou, diro-
KpLvat tC o~tlv tovto 6 <p7/s av /xe'yiaro7J dyadbv eti>at rots

dvdpcoiroLS Kal ae br\p.Lovpybv etrat avrov.
rOP. "Oirep karCv, > ScoKpaTes, Trj dArjfleta p.eyiaTOV 5
dyaObv nal oXtlov dp.a p.ev eXevOepCas avrots rots dvOpco-
ttols, dp.a be rotS dAAcoy dpyetv ev r?j ai)Tov 7ro'Aet
Kao~T(p.
2X2. Tt ovv br) tovto keyeis;

rOP. Td ireCOeLV eycoy oidz; r' etrat rots Aoyot? Kat e
ev 8tKaoT?/pt 8tKacrras Kat iv /3ovAeur?/pt<i) /3o?jAe?jras Kat
ez^ eKKAr/ata eKKA?/a-tacrras Kat ey dAAw a7jAAo'ya> ttovtC,
oo-tls av ttoXltlkos cr?jAAoyos ytyrr/rat. Katrot c?y TavTrj

Trj bvvdp.L bovkov p.ev
"
e<fet? w laTpov, 8o?3Aoy 8e roy 5
TTaLboTpCf3r]v 6 8e xP rlfJLaTLO rV s ovtos dAA<o dvaqiavrjcrtTaL
b7 8 Vind. 21: 8}|BTPF Ci <rf<{7ret BTP : cnt6t-ei tovtwj/ F

t/)oi/f5 BTP : (pavttv F C3 t 8 S^j ; ^] yp. Tt 8e 8^ ^ in marg. b :
rl St av B i)i W ti 8e 77 T (sed supra tj ras. et suprascr. 8) yp. t< 8 :
W
:
ai/ ii t : ti 8 *) F c4 <ri/ BT : om. F 05 (p4\<rotAtv BTP

<pfaei F d3 ffb supra versum T d 7 tov B T Pf : tcv' F
e2 Kal V fiovXtvTJipiw fiovKevTas T WF et in marg. b : om. B

e4 yiyvriTai BTP : ytvr)Tai F
45ae nAATI2N02
XprjfxaTtCo^vos kcu oi>x avr<2, dkka <rol rco bvva]ievu> keyeLV
Kal TreCdeLV to. Trkr]dr).
22. Nvv [xoi boKels SrjAcocrat, a> Topyia, eyyvTara ti\v
453 pf]TOpiKr)v rjvTLva Teyyr]v r)yr) etvaL, Kal et tl eyoo <rvvCr]p.L,
Aeyets ort ttclOovs brjfxiovpyos <\<ttlv r) prrTopiKr], Kal r) irpa-

yp.areCa avTrjs aira<ra Kal to /cecpdAator ets tovto reAeura*
t] eêis tl keyeLV im Trkeov rr)v prjTOpLKrjv bvvao-daL r) 7ret0co
5 TOLS OLKOVOV<TLV kv TTj ^VyT] TTOLZLV ,*
rOP. Ovbap.Q>s, cb 2co/cpares, akkd jxol boKeis t/cai/cos
dpC(je<r9aL' i<TTLV yap tovto to Ke<pdkaLov avrfjs.
212. Akov<tov brj, <h TopyCa. eyco yap ev to-0' otl, cbs
b ep.avrbv ttl6<o, etirep tls akkos dkku> 8taAe'yerat fiovko-

p.evos eibevai avTo tovto trepX otov 6 koyos ecnCv, kol ep.e
eXvaL tovtojv eva' dtco 8e /cat cre.
rOP. Tt ovv br), u> 2co/cpares;
5 2X2. 'Eyco epco vvv. eyco Trjv dirb rrjs prjropLKrjs 7rei0co,
77'ris 7ror' ecrrti' rjv <rv Aeyets /cat 7rept u>vtlvcov TTpayp.aTO)v
eariv 7rett9co, cracpcos p.ev ev tcrt^' ort ovk olba, ov ]xr]V dAA'
V7T07rrevco ye r?y ot/xat cre keyeLV /cat 7rept coV ovSe^ peVrot
r\TTov epr)o-op.at cre rtra 7rore Ae'yets rr)v 7ret#cb rr/z/ a7ro rrjs
C pr\TopLKr)s koI irepl tCvoov avTi]v eTvaL. rou eW/ca 8?) avTos
VTTOTTTevuiV cre epi]o~op.aL, dAA' ov/c avros Ae'yco; ov crou
ere/ca dkka tov koyov, Xva ovto) 7rpo'tT? cbs pdAtcrr' dv r)puv
Karacpaves ttolol 7rept otov Ae'yerat. cr/coVet yap et crot
5 80/cco 5t/catcos dvepooTav cre* axnrep av et eTvy\avov <re
ep<x>T<2v tls ecrTLV t&v (u>ypd<poov ZeC^ts, et //01 et7res ort
6 ra (fcoa ypdcfxav, dp' ovk dv 8t/catcos <re r)pop.r]v 6 ra 7rota

rcoz> C(ri&,y ypd<po)v Kal ttov;
e 7 xpTj/ionCôyuews T F x/,T?M aT 'C AtW' B (sed suprascr. o<r et

W
:
accentum supra posuit B 2 ): xpVfâriCSfxeuos P et suprascr. wi o-o2

BTPf: fiF a4 B eV2 T P F (sed en suprascr. f) Stobaeus
k\4ov B T P Stobaeus irXelov F : a5 iroieiv B T P F Stobaeus :
ifiiroiuv a 6 Sokus B T P F Soki? Stobaeus

Cobet : b 3 b~k
B T P 8' e-y&rye F
: C 8 K al ttov B T P F (et sic legit schol. B sed
non habet Olympiodorus) ^ ov" Woolsey :
:
rOPriAS 453C
TOP. Udvv ye.
212. 'Apa 8td tovto, otl koX dAAot elcrl (caypdcpoL ypd- d
<povTes dAAa 7roAAd <3a;
TOP. Nat.
212. Et 8e' ye p.r)bels aAAos r/ Ze?jis efypacpe, KaAws ay
0-01 direKeKpLTo; 5
rOP. riwy ydp ov;
v
2,12. I0t 8?/ Kat 7rept Ti)s pr)TopLKr)s el-ne' iroTepov <roi
boKU 7ret$co iroLelv 7/ prjToptKi] p.6vr) i) Kal aAAat reyyaL;
Aeyco 8e r6 rotoVSe* ocrris 8t8do-Kei otlovv Trpayp.a, iroTepov
o 8t8dcrKei TreCdei t) ov; 10

rOP. Ot> brjra, a> 2a>Kpares, dAAd irdvTcov tidAtoTa 7retc?ei.
212. ndAiy 8?; e7rt tcoz; avr&v Teyi>G>v Xeyo>p.ev u>virep e

2'vy8?/* 77 dpL6p.r)TLKt) ov 8i8dcrKet fjp.as ocra ecrTLV tcl tov
dpLOpov, Kal 6 dpL6pr\TLKos dvdpomos; rOP. Udvv ye.
212. Ovkovv Kal ireCdeL; rOP. Nat. 212. TleLdovs dpa
br)p.Lovpyos ecTTLV k<xl f) dpL6pr)TLKT); IDP. 4>atVerat. 5
212. Ovkow edv tls epcora r)pas iroCas TreLdovs Kal Trept rt,
dTTOKpLVovp.e6d ttov avTS) otl Tijs bLba<rKa\LKrjs tt)s irepl TO

dpTLOv re Kat to irepLTTov ocrov eortv Kal Tas dAAas as 454
vvvbi) e\eyop.ev Teyvas aTrdcras eôpev dirobelaL ireL6ovs
bi)pLOvpyovs ovcras Ka\ tJcttlvos Kat 7rept otl' rj ov;

TOP. Nat. Ouk 212. dpa pr)TopLKr) p.6vr) TreLdovs ecrrir
br)pLovpyos. rOP. 'AArjdrj Ae'yets. 5
2,12. 'E7ret8rj toCvvv ov p.6vt) a7repyderai tovto to epyov,

dAAd Kat dAAat, 8tKatcos axnrep irepl tov coypdc/Jou p.eT<\
>
tovto eTravepoLp.e& av tov keyovra' Tlotas br) TreLdovs kol
Tr)s Trepl tC ireLdovs f) pr)TopLK.r) ecrTLV Teyvr); rj ov boKel ctol
bUaiov etvaL eiravepecrdaL; t>
d5 &7rt KtKpiro BTf : aireKpivaro PF d8 r/ BT P om. F :
dio6BTPf:&F ei 5PPF; 8''T Uywpev T P

\eyo/j.fv BF 63 apiBfiov BTF : apiOfiijTiKov W Kal . . . avQpunros
secl. Cobet a 1 ftoov iffTiv secl. Kratz : 8<ra 4(ttIv v. Kleist
aa 4\4yo/x(v BT P : <1irontv F E3 tiBTP (sed 8 in ras. B)
f : brov F et rec. t a 4 ^t/toîk^ BTP faTopiK^ F
: r;
;
454b nAAT12N02
TOP. "E/xotye.
212. 'AiroKpivai 677, co Yopyia, e7ret8?7 ye koi o~ol 8oKet

ovtojs.
5 rOP. Tavrrjs roivvv Trjs iteiOovs Ae'yco, o> 2coKoaTes, rijs

iv rols 8tKaoT??0iois Kai iv toTs akkois o)(Aoi?, &cnrtp /cat
a/)Tt eAeyov, Kai 7re/)i tovtcov a eort 8tKaid Te Kat aoiKa.

212. Kat eyco Tot vircoTTTevov TavTrjv o-e Ae'yetz> ttjv ttl6o>
Kal irepl tovtojv, o> Topyia' dAA' tva p.i] 6avp.a(jf]s iav Kal
10 oAtyoy vcrrepov tolovtov ti o-e avt\po>p.ai, o 8oKet /xei> Sj/Aoi
C etWt, eyco 8' t\7ravepo>TG> o7rep yap Ae'yco, tou e?7? eVeKa
Trepaiveo~9ai tov koyov epcoTco, ov o~ov t-vtKa dAA' Xva //?/
t\6i(u>p.ti6a V7roi>oo{5i>Tes irpoapira&iv akkt]ko>v tol Aeyo'pei>a,
akka av tcl cravrov Kara Trjv virodticnv 6iro>s o\v /3o?JA??
5 irt-paivrjs.
rOP. Kat 6p9G>s ye /xot 8oKtts 7roteu>, S> 2coKpaTes.

v
212. I#t 8?) Kai To8e e7rtcrKe\^cop,eâ. KaAets Tt p.ep.adq-
Ktvai; rOP. KaAco. 212. Tt 8e'; 7re7ricrTet>Ke'i>at; rOP.
- d Eycoye. 212. Ylortipov ovv ravTov 8oKet croi eu>at p.ep.a6r]-
Ktzvai Kal 7re7rto"TeuKeVat, Kai ,/xd#?/crts Kai_jrtcrTi?, r) akko

ti; rOP. Otopat p.\v eycoye, co 2coKpaTes, dAAo. 212.
KaAcos ydp oter yvtocrr] 8e v6vbt\. et yap tCs cre ZpoiTO'
"
5 "'Ap' ecrTty tis, co Topyta, 7rtcrTis \jst:vbqs Kal akrjdqs;
tpai-qs av, cos eycb otpai rOP. Nat. 212. Tt 8e'; e7rtcm//>i?/
iarlv \j/evbr)s kcll akqdrjs; TOP. Ovbap.G>s. 212. Arjkov

ap av ort ov ravrov ecrriv. rOP. 'Akqdrj Aeyets. 212.
e 'AAAd p.r)v o't Tt- yt\ p.eua0?7KOTes 7re7retcrjueVot etcriy Kal ol
rreTTio-TtiVKOTes. rOP. v
Eoti Tavra.
212. BovAet ovv bvo etbq 6G>p.ev ttl6ovs, to p.ev tri-TTiv
irapt-yoyu-vov avtiv tov etSeVai, to 8' kiricrTqp.rp} rOP. Yldvv
b5 B T P F Olympiodorus S^) al.

roiwv b 9 davfidCys scr.
:
recc. : BTPF
0ovij.cI(ois 4av Kal F iav B T P b 10 cre B T P : :
<re erepov F d 3 olofiai B T P olfiai F d 6 tyie olfxai B T P

: :
ey&ixaiF d 7 a\r)Q))s Kal \pev8-f)s P d8 ip' a3 scripsi ^poOlym-

W
:
piodorus yap aS B T
: F yap Sij Schanz :iariv] o-r6v Badham
e 1 TeBTW: om. F 63 eUr) pcst irti$ovs transp. F
TOPriAS 454 e
ye. 2X2. Ylorepav ovv r) pr)TopLKr) TTL0oi ttoll ev biKao-rrj- 5
ptoty re Kal tols dAAots o)(koLS irepl t&v btKaCcov re Kal

abiKMv; e rjs ttlo-tVLV yCyveraL avev tov elbevaL ?/ e
rjs to elbevai; rOP. A?Âou brJTrov, Si 2&>Kpares, otl e rjs
to TTLcrTeveiv 2X2. 'H pr\TopLKi) apa, ois eoLKev, ttl8ovs
brjpLLovpyos ccttlv TTLcrTevTLKfjs dAA' ov StSao-KaAiK??? 7rept 455

t6 bLKaiov re Kal abiKOv. rOP. Nat. 2X2. O?3o' dpa
8t8ao"KaAtKo? 6 pi]T(op earlv bLKao-rrjpCoiv re Kat t5>v dk-
koiv oykoiv biKaCcov re 7rept Kat abUoiV, dkka 7rto-rtKos
fxovov ov yap br/irov o)(kov y av bvvavro toctovtov ev 5
oAtyw XP V<? 8t5dai ovroi p.eydka irpdyp.aTa. rOP. Ov

brJTa.
2X2. <J>e'pe 8?/, lboip.ev tC irore Kal ke.yop.ev 7rept rijs
prjTopLKrjs' eyco p.ev ydp tol ovb' avros ttlo bvvafxaL Kara- b
vorjaaL ort keyco. orav irepl tarpcSv atpeVeco? tf Trj 7roAet
crvkkoyos ?/ 7rept vavirriy&v ?/ 7rept dAAou rtyo? bt]p.iovpyLKOv
edvovs, dAAo rt rj tot 6 pr/TopLKos ov o~vp.(3ovkevo-L; brjkov

yap otl V Ka.crTr) atpeVet tov TeyvLKbiTarov bel aipeio-0at. 5
ovb* orav retx<Sy 7rept otKo8op?/o-ecos ?/ kLp.evoiV KaracrKevrjs

y
r) veoopCwv, dAA' 01 dpyjxeKTOves' ovb av orav crTpaTrjy&v
aipecreois 7re'pt ?/ rdecos tlvos irpbs TTokep.Covs t) \oipCcov
KaTakr)\jreois crvp.fiovkr) rj, dAA' 01 crTpar-qyLKol tot avp.- C
/3ot>Ae?Vo?jo-iz>, ol pi)TopLKo\ be ov' t) ircos keyeLS, co TopyCa,
ra TOLavra; eireLbr) yap avros re cp?7S prJTcop etrat Kat dAAous
TTOLLV pr)TOpLKOVS, V \L T(X TTJS Crrjs TX.Vr)S TTapCL CTOV
TTvvOaveo-OaL. kol ep.e vvv vopncrov Kal to crbv o-irevbeLV 5

Lcrtos yap Kal rvyyaveL tls twv evbov ovTOiv p.adr)Tr)s crov
e7 Q (bis) T P F
?)s etfs (bis) B : (spiritus corr. rec. b) vicr-
revfiv BTPF: rh iriffreveiv vulg. e8 ^ ^j TPF: ej-rjs B
(non correctum) a4 iriffTiKds fxovov BT sed suprascr. ei T :
ireiffriKos /j-ovov P : iriffriKov fi6vov F b1 pev B T P F om. Olym-

:
piodorus toiBTPF Olympiodorus : om. al. b 4 &\\o rt t)
rire P F aAA.' ori

: r) rire B : &\\6 ri r6re T (^ suprascr. rec. t)
b 6 Ttepl B P F irepi T : b8 aipeffews irepi B T P : wepi alpeffeus F
03 TeTPF: 7<B 04 pi)TopiKovs secl. Cobet
"
455C ITAAT&NOS
fiovk6p.evos yevearOai, ws eyoo TLvas cryebbv koX crv\vovs
alo-0dvopxiL, o% Xo-oos alcryyvoLVT av cre avepeo-daL. vn
d ep.ov ovv avepooT(6p.evos vopucrov Kal vit' eKeivoov avepooTao-daL'
" Tt rjp.iv, oo Topyia, ecrTai, edv o-ol crvvG>p.ev; irepl rivoov rr)
Trokei crvp.fSovkeveLV oloi re ecrop.eda; iroTepov irepl biKaiov

p.6vov Kal abiKov rj Kal irepl <av vvvbr) ScoKocm/s eAeyev;
5 rreLpG> ovv avrols aTroKpivecrOai.

rOP. 'AAA' eyoo crot Treipa.o-op.ai, oo 2coKoare?, cra(pG>s
aTTOKaXvxlsat. rr)v rrjs prjropLKrjs bvvap.iv aTracrav avrbs yap
KakG>s vobr)yr)o-a>. oXcrda yap brjnov otl tcl vecopia ravra
e Kai Ta Teiyr) tcl 'AdrjvaiodV ko.1 r) tG>v Xip.evo)v KaTao-Kevij

eK rrjs &epaa-TOK\eovs crvp.(3ovkrjs yeyovev, tcl o' eK t?js
YlepLKkeovs dAA' ovk eK tG>v brjp.LovpyG>v.

XQ. Aeyerat ravra, a Topyia, itepX ep.io~TOKkeovs %
5 YiepiKkeovs be kol aiiTos rjKOVovoTe crvvefiovkevev r)pxv irepl

tov bia p.ecrov Teiyovs.
456 rOP. Kat orav ye tls aipecris 77 8>v vvvbr) o-v ekeyes, S
~2(OKpares, bpas otl ol pr\Topes elo-tv o\ avp.j3ovkevovTes Kal

ol vlkG>vtS tcls yvu>p.as irepl tovtoov.
212. TaCra Kat 6avp.d(u>v, S> Yopyia, 7rdAat eoooroo ris

5 7rore r) bvvap.is ccttlv rrjs prjTopLKrjs. baLp.ovia ydp tls
ep,0Lye Karac/>au/erat to p.eyedos ovtoo o-kottovvtl.
rOP. Et TrdvTa ye elbeir}s, S> SooKoare?, ort oos eiros
elTrelv drrdcras tcls bvvdp.eLS crvkkafiovo-a vc/>' avrrj eêt.
b p,eya be crot TeKpvqpLov epG>' TTokkdns yap ybrj eycoye p.era

tov dbekcpov Kal p.era tG>v dkkoov larpGv eicrekOoov irapd
TLva tG>v Kap,v6vToov ov\l edekovra r\ (pdpp.aKOv TXLeXv r]
rejuetr r/ KaScrai TrapacryeLV tG> larpG>, ov bvvap.evov tov
di koI BTP: Sii Kal F d2 wepl BTP : *, nepl F d.4 vdv

5{)BTPf: 5{|F ei ri 'AOrivalcev secl. Cobet e 3 rwv] rris
rwv Schaefer : rrjsButtmann e 6 rov B P F t rov T a 1 wvSi) :
scripsi : vvv o5 F 8^ B T P f
: a 4 nd\at B T P F ird\iv Olympio- :
dorus rls F tfris B T P

: a 5 Svva/nis io-riv B T P iffriv
r) :
riovva/xisF &1 E/] Ti el Madvig T/ o' el H. Richards : l>4 ^

Kavffai} Ka\ Kavffai Blomfield
ropriAS 456 b
iarpov 7reurai, eyco eVeiaa, ovk dkkrj T\vr] rj rfj prjTopiKi}. 5

</>?7juu 8e Kal ets ttoAlv oitr\ /3ovAet kkOovra prjropLKov dvbpa
Kal iarpov, et 8e'ot Aoyco oiaycoinecrc9ai iv KKkt]o~iq, rj iv
aAAcp tlvI cruAAo'yco diroT^pov 8et aipeOfjvaL iarpov, ovbapov
av cpavfjvaL rov iarpov, dAA' aipeOrjvaL av tov et7reu> bvva- C
tov, et fiovkoLTO. kcli et irpos dkkov ye brjpiovpybv 6v-
TLvaovv ayu)v(CoLTo, 7retcreier av avTov eAe'cr0ai 6 pr]TopLKos
pxikkov r) dkkos octtlo-ovv' ov yap ecrrtv 7repi otov ovk av

TTLdavtoTepov ei7rot 6 pr]TopLKos i) dkkos oartaow t&v bt]- 5
pLovpyGrv V Trkr]6cL. rj pkv ovv bvvapLS Toaavrr] ecrrir
Kal TOLavrr) rrjs T\vr]s' oet pkvTOL, co ScoKpares, rl/
pryropLKr\ xprjo-daL cocr7rep rfj akkrf Ttacrr] aycoviq. Kal yap

Tr) akkt] dycoviq ov tovtov VKa 8et irpbs aTravras \pr)cr6ai d
avdp-onovs, otl p.a&V ttvktVlv re Kal 7rayKpartdetz> Kal
kv oirkoLS pd\adaL, cocrre Kpetrrcoi eu>at Kat cpikcov kol
\6pG)V, OV TOVTOV VKa TOVS CpikoVS bL TV7TTLV oib
KVTlv T Kat aTroKretrwat. ovbk ye p.d Ata idv tls ets 5
TTakaicrTpav cpoLTrjcras v \cov to crcopa Kal ttvktlkos yvo-
p.Vos, e7retra tov Trarepa tvtttj] Kat Tr)v p-Tirepa rj dkkov
TLvd tcov otKetW r) tcov cpikcov, ov tovtov eVeKa oet tovs
7rat8orpt/3as Kat tovs v tols d-rkoLS bLbdo-KOvras pdycr6aL e
pto-ety re Kat Kf3dkkLV K tG>v irok^cov. eKetrot pkv ydp
irapibocrav tt\ rco StKaicos \prjcr6aL tovtols Trpos tovs 7roAe-
piovs Kal tovs dbLKovvTas, ap,wop.Vovs, pi] VTrdpxovTas'
oi b p,TacrTp\J/avTS \pG>VTaL rrj io-yyi kol rfj Tyyr] csvk 457
6p6G)s. ovkovv oi b^bdâvTs Trovr]poi, ovb r) Tyyr] ovt
ahia ovt iiovqpd tovtov VKa ccttlv, dAA' 01 p.i] xpcopefot
olpaL 6p6G)S. 6 ai/Tos bi] Aoyos Kat 7rept Trjs prjropLKrjs.
bvvaTos p..v yap irpds diravTas 0-tlv 6 pr]Tu>p Kat 7rept 5
b6 8*77B T P F ftwoi scr. recc.

: AfloVre Dobree C 7 rp . . .
&<nrtp B T P (in lacuna textus suppl. f tij prjropiKy xprjaOai wcrirtp ko!)
d. 1 Tovrov 'ivfKa secl. Findeisen '4veKa 8? B T F : St? ece/co P
d 6 ttvktikos~\ -KoiriTiKbs P 63tijjBTP:t()F a2 oijKOVV
T P F b ovkovv B
:
PLATO, VOL. III. 18

457 a riAATttNOS
Ttavrbs Xiyf.iv, coore TTLdav<J>Tepos tlvai iv toIs TTXrjdemv
b ep,/3paxu Trepl otov av /3ovAr/rar dAA' ovbiv tl p.akkov

tovtov eVe/ca 8et ovre rovs larpovs r?/y boav cupaipticrOai
oti bvvaiTo av tovto 7rot?/crai ovtc tovs dkkovs brjpLovp-
yovs, dkkd SiKatcos Kat ri) prjTopLKy \pr)<r6aL, axrircp xal tj}
5 dy<x>viq. kav 8e ot/xai prjTopLKOs ycvop.cvos tls Kqra TavTij

tt) bvvdp,L Kal rr/ Tzyvr) d8tKr/, ov tov 8t8davra 8et /xtcrety
re Kat eK/3dAAetv eK r<Si> 7ro'Aecoi\ eKetroy /uey ydp eirt
C biKaiov xptiq 7rape'8coK>, 6 8' ivavrioos yjprjTaL. tov ovv

ovk opd&s \pp.cvov pllo~lv bUaLov Kal eK/3aAAety Kal
airoKTLVVvaL dAA' ov tov bibdâvra.
212. Ot/xat, 3) Topyia, Kal o-e ep.irLpov etyat 7roAAcoi>
5 Adycoy Kat Ka#ecopaKeVat iv avTols to TOLovbe, otl ov pqbiu>s

bvvavraL 7rept S>v av i7TL\Lpr]cr(i><rLV 8taAe'yecr(9ai Stoptcrd-
pei>oi 7rpos dAAr/Ao?Js Kat p.adovTs kol 8i8d<fa^res kavTovs,

d ovrco 8taAuecrc9at rds ovvovcrias, dAA' idv 7rept tov ap.<pL-
o-l3rjTricr(i)o-LV koX p.rj

<pfj
6 ircpos tov t-Tepov 6p6S>s Ae'yeti> 17
p,r) o~a<p<2s, yakciraivovo-i re Kat Kard cpdovov olovTaL tov

kavrtov Ae'yetz>, cpLkovLKOvvras dAA' ov (j]TovvTas to irpoKci-
5 p.Vov iv t<2 Adyci)* Kat evtot ye reAeirnSvres atcr^tcrra

d7raAAarroi>rat, koLboprjdivTtis re Kat et7ro'z>res Kat aKOV-
cravres 7rept <r<p<2v avT<av TOLavra ola Kal tovs irapovTas
dydecrdaL virkp crcfxav avT<2v, otl tolovt<dv dv6p<oTTa>v rjîuxrav
e aKpoaral yevicrdaL. tov 8?/ eveKa Ae'yco ravra; otl vvv
ejuot 8oKet? cru ov irdvv aKokovda Ae'yety ov8e <rvp.<p<ava ols
t6 Trp<oTov eAeyes 7rept Trjs prjTopLKrjs' <poj3ovp.aL ovv 8te-
kiy\LV cre, p.ij /*e v7roAd/3r/s ov Trpbs to Trpdyp.a cpLkovL-
bi efifipaxv B T P ^v /3pox" F et rec. t

: b3 Svvairo F et in ras.
T : tiivaivTo re vera B P et pr. T b4 &o-irtp . . . aywvia secl. ci.
Sauppe b 5 K$ra scr. recc. Kara BTPF C 1 SiKaiov B T P F
: :
StKaia scr. recc. C3 8t8of avra B T P SiSdo-Kovra F C5 A.dywi']

:
Aoîo)/ Madvig: avdpdirwv Cobet : <pt\o\6ywv Schanz d. 1 tov

BTP: tovtov F afjL<pto-^-qTi]o-(tiffiv BTPf : d/i(|)j(r/8ijTcrj F d.6 A01-
Sopridevres re cat secl. Hirschig d.7 irepl a<pwv avTuiv secl. ci.
Sauppe d8 i/n-ep crrpwv avT&v secl. Cobet 6'rt TOtovT<av\ o'lwv

Cobet e 4 <pt\ovtKovvTa secl. W. Headlam
TOPriAS 457e
kovvtcl kiyeiv tov Karaqbavcs yevicrdaL, dkkd TTpos crL 5
eycb ovv, et pikv Kal crv et tcov dvOpooTToov oovirep Kal eyco, 45^
T/8e'cos av tre Stepcorcor/zr et 8e pr/, iooi]v dj\ eyob 8e tCvcov
etp.t; T<av r/8e'cos pikv b\v iknyxîvToov et rt p.i] dkr]6(s

Ae'yco, r/8e'cos 8' di> ekeyâvToov et tis rt pr/ dAr/fles Aeyot,
ovk ar]bo~Tpov p.evTav ikeyxOivroov i) Zk(yavToov p.elov 5
ydp avro dyafldu rjyovpat, dcrco7rep /txetbi> ayadov icrTLV
avTov a-nakkayi]vai KaKOv tov peytcrrojj r) dAAoi> a7raAAdat.

ovb\v yap ot/xai rocrotSroy KaKov tlvai dvdpooiToo, ocrov boa
\j/eu8rjs irepl &v Tvyyavti vvv rjpiiv 6 Adyos oov. et pikv ovv b
Kat crv (prjs rotoirros ea>at, 8iaAeycope0a' et 8e Kat 8oKet
Xpijvai idv, ecop,ez> 7/877 yaipeiv koX bi.akvoop.ev t6v koyov.

rOP. 'AAAd c/)7?/xt pev eycoye, co ScoKpares, Kat avrds rotoij-
ros etWt oXov o~v iKpriyrj- tcrcos p.ivTOL XPV V ivvozlv Kal t6 5
toov TxapovToov. Txakai yap toi, irpXv Kal vp.as ikdeZv, eyco
rots mapovai Trokkd e7re8etdp.Tjij, Kal vvv tcrcos -roppco diro-
Ttivovpav, i]V 8taAeycope0a. crK07retr ovv \pr] Kal rd tovtoov, C

pi) Tivas avToov Kare'xop,ei> /3ovkop.ivovs rt Kat dAAo 7rpdrreti\
XAI. Tov pikv Oopvfiov, 00 TopyCa re Kat 2coKpares,
adrot aKoveTe tovtoov toov dvbpoov (3ovkop.ivoov aKOVcLv idv
rt Ae'yTjre* epot 8' ow Kat arjrco p.i) yivoLTO TocravTr) do~xokia, 5
cocrre tolovtoov koyoov Kal ovtoo ke:yop.ivoov d<pep,eVcp npovp-

ytairepoV rt yevicrdaL dkko ~rpaTTe.LV.
KAA. Nr/ rovs #eorjs, cb Xaipecpcoij, Kat //ev 8r/ Kat avrds d
7roAAots 7y8rj Adyots Trapaycv6p.(vos ovk ot8' et 7rco7rore ijo~dr)v
ovtoos cocr7rep rwr cocrr' e/uotye, Kay rr/i; rjp.4pav okrjv

idekr)T 8iaAe'yecrtât, xapieitrfle.
b 4 ^Tjyul B TP : ^rjs F b 5 xprl' B T P F (in marg. 8t b t) xp> :
al.Olympiodorus b6 u^tosBTPF (sed cx emend. T) i5 b 7 -ro\\a

B T P f iroAu F: dTOTf ovfiev B T P f a-roffrepovfiev F ci jjv :
T P F /xtV B (sed
: puncto notatum) /j. C 2 Karex ^" B P t are'- :
Xffxev T F c5 5' oZv B T P F yovv Olympiodorus c 6 irpobp-

:
yiair-pov] -Tpori/xSrtpov suprascr. P C 7 yevt o~6ai B T P ylv~o~8ai F

wF
:
d3oTwBTPf:om.F w/i'BTPf: 3^ BTP : om. F

d4 i04\i\T' F : tOihoir- BTP x<V*'*^ TPF : xap'er&M B
18*
458 d I1AATX2N02
5 2X2. 'AAAd pr/i>, a> KaAAtKAets, to y kphv ovb\v Ka)Adei,
et7rep e0e'Aet ropytas.
rOP. Aio-yjpbv bi] to Xoittov, a) 2a>Kpares, ytyyerat epe'
ye /xr/ e#e'Aeu>, clvtov kirayyzikaiievov ipcoTav otl tls /3od-
e Aerat. dAA' et doKet rouroici, 8taAe'you re Kat epcora ort

/3orJAet.
212. "Akovc br], ai Topyta, a 0a?j/xda) eV rot? Aeyo/xeVots

v
?j7rd o-ojj* aa>s ydp rot o-o?3 op6cos ktyovros eya) ovk dp0a>s
5 VTTo\ap.^dvco. p-qTopiKov <pr)$ Troialv olos r' etvat, edv rts

/SodAr/rat 7rapd ororj piav9dviv; rrOP. Nat. 212. Ovkow
7rept 7rdyra)^ wor' kv o\X<o mdavbv etTJat, ov bibdcrKOVTa dAAd
459 TT(C6ovTa; rOP. Yldvv p*v ovv. 2X2.
v
EAeye's rot vvvbr)
ort Kat 7rept rou rjytetvojj tov iarpov Tndav<oTepos eorat d
pr/Tcap. rOP. Kat ydp eAeyo/j, eV ye dxAa>. 2i2. Ovkow
to eV o\\<o tovto kcrTiv, kv rots p.rj tibocriv; ov ydp 8?/7ro?j
5 tv ye rots etSdat tov iarpov mdav<oTpo$ earat. -IHOP.

'Akrjdrj Aeyets. 212. OrjKow enrep ro{5 iarpov mdav<oTepo$
eVrat, tov etSdros m6av<oTepos yiyverai; rOP. Yldvv
b ye. Ovk
212. tarpds ye <ov r) ydp; TOP.
Nat. 212. 'O
oe pr/ Mzrpds ye brjirov dvmo~Tr]p.<ov <ov 6 tarpos imaTrj-
paov. rOP. Afjkov drt. 2X2.
c
O ovk etoa>s dpa tov etddros
eV ovk etSdo-t mdav<oTpo$ eorat, ora/j 6 /5r/ra>p rou iarpov
5 mdav<oTpos ry. rorjro orj/x/3atvet r/ dAAo rt; rOP. TotSro
eVratjfld ye <Tvp.(3aivti. 2X2. Ovkow Kat 7rept rds dAAas
aTrdaas T\va$ <o<ravT<o$ eêt 6 pr]T<op Kat r/ pr]TopiKr]' avra
pikv ra npdyp.aTa ovbev 8et avrr/TJ etdeVat 07ra)s eêi, p.i]yavr)v
C 8e' rtra 7retôus r/rjpr/KeVat wore <paivto-6ai tois ovk etSoVt
/u,aAAoi> etSeVat rwy et8dra)y.
rOP. Ovkow 7roAAr) pqo~T<ovr], Kpares, ytyêrat,
d8 ad 48e\cip adscripsit *coJ toCto f 4pwrav . . . fiovKerai secl.

Badham e i rovroiffi scr. recc. : rovroitn P : rovroicriv BT :
tovtois F 67 iraVTouj' B TPf : 7tovtJ>s f ai roi vvvSij B P

2
:
Toivvv Sr; B (ut videtur) T : roivvv vvv 5^ F a 2 irepl tou uT-teiroO

secl. Cobet a5 ^<tto BTPf icrnv F
: baoBTFôm. P
b7 na\ rt priTopiKi) secl. Cobet b 8 oiitV] avTov Beck, Cobet

TOPriAS 459 c
pi\ padovra rd? akkas re'xâs dAAd pCav TavTr\v, p.r\bev
e\aTTOv<rdai tu>v br\p.LovpyG>v ; 5

v
2X2. Et />tei> eAarrotrrat ?*/ u? / eAarroOrat 6 prjTcop t<2v
dkktov 8td rd ovrcos *xeiv, aVT ^Ka eTTLaKexyopLcoa, edv tl
rjp.iv irpbs koyov vvv 8e ro'Se irpoTepov aKeyf/cup.e6a, dpa

f\'
Tvyyavei irepl to biKaiov Kal to abiKOV Kal to alo~xpbv Kal d

to Kakbv Kal dyadbv ko.1 KaKov ot/rco? e^coy 6 pT/rootKos
tos 7rept rd vytetiw Kat 7rept rd dkka &v ai dAAat Ttyvai,

avra p.ev ovk ei8co?, rt ayadbv ?/ ri KaKov eorii> ?/ rt Kakbv
?/ rt alaxpov 77 biKaiov 7) dStKou, 7ret0to 8e 7rept avr&v ue- 5
pi\X a VT\p.evo$ coare boKelv ei8eVat oiik et8cbs ev ovk elboo-Lv

pdkkov tov elboros; 77 avayKrj elbevai, Kal oet 7rpoe7rtcrrd- e
pevov ravra dcpLKeadaL 7rapd cre rdi> pekkoi>ra p.a6r\creadaL
r?/y pr\TopiKr]v; et 8e /xtj, o~u 6 rr^s pr\TopiKr\$ 8t8do-KaAo? tov-
tcov p.ev ovbev 8i8dets tov d<pLKVovp.evov ov yap abv epyov
7roi?/crets 8' ev rois 7roAAots 8oKetz> ei8eVat avTov rd rotaOra 5
ovk et'80'ra Kat boKelv dyadbv etrat ovk ovra; r\ to Trapdirav

ov\ olos re ecnj avrbv 8tSdat rr)v pr\TopLKr\v, eav p.r) Trpoeibi)
irepl tovtcov ti\v akrjOeiav; 7/ 7rto? tcl TOLavra exet, * TopyCa;

koI Trpo? Ato's, <oairep dprt ei7res, diroKakv\j/as Trjs pr\TopLKr)$ 460
et7re rts 7ro0' 7/ bvvap.Cs earLV.
rOP. 'AAA' eyco p.ey otuat, co 2coKpares, edi> n/xj? p/
etScos, Kat raOra 7rap' ep.ov />ia07/crerai.
2X2. "Eê 8?/* KaAco? yap Ae'yets. idvnep pr\TopLKOv 5
cru rt;'a 7^01770-779, dvdyKr\ avrbv et8e'ât rd StKata Kat ra

d8tKa ?/rot irpoTapov ye 77 vaTepov p.a66vTa irapa aov.
rOP. Yldvv ye. 2X2. Tt ovv; 6 ra tcktovlkcl p.ep.a6r\K(>>$ b
tcktovlkos, r\ ov; .rOP. Nat. 2X2. Otjkotji' Kat 6 tcl pova-LKa
p.ovaLKos; rOP. Nat. 2X2. Kat 6 ra tarptKa tarptKoy;
C8 irpbs \6yov BTP: irpb \6yov Olympiodorus : wpbs \6yov F

d 1 irepl supra versum T kcl\ irep\ Olympiodorus : d3 ws irepl
B T P &airep F
: d 4 at>Ta B T F avrbs P : e 3 tj 8e /ufy av
T P F et in marg. yp. b ei 8t av B 67 a&r?/ : 88a|ai re vera
BTF : 8i8a|at aiirbv P a4 fxa9-f,o-frat BTPf : fxa6^ff(T0ai F
a6 flSfvai BTP : (rrai tlSfvat F a^ ^t<" BTPf: ^ F

46ob IIAATX2N02
kcu rdAAa ovtu) Kara tov avrbv \6yov, 6 p:p:a6>]Ku>s eKaora
5 tolovtos o~tlv dlov r) e7rtrrn//zr/ eKaaTov dTrepydêrat;
rOP. Yidvv ye. 2X2. Ovkovv Kara tovtov tov \6yov Kal
6 tcl bUaia p,(p.adr\K(bs 8ucaios; TOP. UdvT(o$ br\irov.
2X2.
f
O 8e oucaios bUaid ttov 7rpdrret. TOP. Nat.
C 2X2. Ovkovv dvdyKrj tov pr\TopLKov biKaiov etmt, tov 5e
biKaiov /3ov\o~6aL biKaia 7rpdrrety; rOP. 4>au>erat ye.
2X2. Ovb7?OT dpa /3oi>A?/crerai 6 ye bUaios abtKiv.
IDP. 'AvdyKt]. Tbv 2X2. 8e prjropiKov dvdyKr\ K tov \6yov
5 bUatov ivai. IDP. Nat.2X2. OiSeVore dpa /3ouA?/o-erai
6 prjTopLKos abiKiv. rOP. Ov <paCvTa[ ye.

2X2. Mepyrjcrai ovv Ae'ycoi> dAtycp 7rpo'repov otl ov 8et rots
d 7rat8orpt/3ats eyKaAetr ovb' K(3d\\Lv K tG>v tto\U)V, eay 6
TWKTrrs rfj irvKTLKr\ yjpr\Tai re /cat dSi/cco? \pr\TaL Ka ' dbiKrj,
cocravrcos oe ovrcoy ko.1 iav 6 pf\TU>p rfj pr\TopLKr) dSiKco?
XprjraL, p.r\ rco bLbdavTL iyKakelv pr/8' ê\avvLV K rrjs
5 7roAea>?, dAAd ra> dbLKovvTi Kal ovk 6p6a>s \p(tip.V(o tt)
pr-TOpLKrj; ppr\6r\ ravra r) ov; rOP. 'Epprjdrr. 2X2. Nvv

e <k' ye 6 avrbs ovtos cpaLVTaL, 6 pr\TopLKOS, ovk dv 7rore
dbLKrjo-as. r\ ov; rOP. tatrerat. -2X2. Kat kv tols 7rpco-
rots ye, co TopyCa, \6yoLS eAe'yero 6'rt r/ pr\TopLKr\ iTp\ \6yovs
etr/ ov tovs tov aprCov Ka\ 7reptrroS, ctAAa tovs tov bLKalov
5 Kat dStKoir r\ ydp; rOP. Nat. 2X2. 'Eyco tolwv o~ov tot
Tavra \eyovros vTT\aj3ov ios ovbeiroT av etr/ r) pr\TopLKr\
dbiKOV irpdyp.a, 6 y det 7rept StKatocrwT/? tovs \6yovs

7rotetraf e7ret8^ 8e 6\Cyov vo~Tpov eAeyes ort 6 pr\Tu>p
461 Trj pr\TopLKr) Kav d5tKco? XP<? T0 > ovtco 9avp:do~as Ka\ r)yr\o~d-
p.Vos ov crvvqbeLV tcl Aeyo/xeva Klvovs ?ttov tovs \6yovs,
b8 'O 5i . . . Nai. secl. Deuschle (et mox e 4 Tbu tih 05 Kai) . . .
C 1 Ovkovv ...C2 âiverai ye secl. Schanz (sed legit Quintilianus)

pilTopiKbv . . . tie secl. Hirschig c 2 &e2 ante fiov\rOat add. Hir-
schig, post fiovKeffdai add. Thompson 03 ovtifirore . . . c6 (paiverai
ye fort. non legit Quintilianus (ii. 15. 27) C 4 tou BTP : F
toC aov
d 2 supra ttukti/ctj add. Ka\ws rec. f /cal atiiKws xP^ Ta< f om
-
BTP e 1 6 priTopiKis secl. Cobet e6 1) pr>TopiK^ BTP :
p^ropiK^ F e7 8 y BTP : el y F
TOPriAS 46ia
oti et fxev Kepbos r)yolo elvac rb eAe'yxerrc9at oocnrep eyco,

<xlov eh] biakeyecrdaL, et be p?/, eav \aipeiv. vo-repov be
?/pco> eTrLo-KOirovp.evu>v opqs bi] Kal avrbs otl av dpoAoyeirat 5
tov pr\TopiKov ahvvaTOV elvai dotKcos \pijo-0ai, tt) pr)TopiKi}
Kal eOekeLv abiKtlv. ravra ovv oinj irore ex l > M^ TOV

Kvva, d> Topyia, ovk okiyrjs o-wouo-tas eortv coore tKa^cos b
(Hao-KeS/fao-pYii.
IIX2A. Tt be, Z> ScoKpares; ovtco kcu o-v irepl tt/s
prjTopiKTJs Sodets cocr7rep vvv Aeyets; r/ otet drt Topyta?

r)o-)(vvdr] crot p?/ 7rpo(TO]XokoyfjcraL tov prjTopiKov avbpa p?j 5
ov)(l Kal to. bUata elbevat. Kal rd Kaka Kat rd ayaOd, Kat
eav /xf/ eA0?/ ravra et8cb? 7rap' airdi>, avros oidaeiy, eireiTa
1
eK TavTit]$ tcrco? rrjs dpoAoytas evavriov tl crvvefir] ev rots

Adyot? roirro (o) 6;/ dya7ras, a?3rds dyaycor eVi Toiavra C
epcor?/para e7rei rtVa otet aTrapvr]aecr6aL fxr) ov)(l Kal avrbv
e7TLo-Tao-0aL tcl dtKata Kat aAAou? 8t8deti>; dAA' ets tcl
TOLavra ayeLv Trokkr] aypOLKia ecrrlv tovs koyovs.

212. '12 KaAAitrre FTcoAe, dAAd rot ee7rtr?j8es KTcofxeda 5
eraipovs Kat vets, ti>a eTreLbav avrol 7rpeo-/3drepot yevofxevoL
rrcpaAAcopefla, 7rapdyre? ?3pets ot recorepot eiravop6G>Te f]fxS>v
tov fiiov Kal ev epyots Kat ev Adyots. Kal vvv et rt eyco Kat
Topytas ev rots koyois crcpakkofxeda, crv irapiov eiravopdov d
dtKaio? 8' et Kai eyco edekco tS>v a>fxokoyr]fxev(ov et rt crot
doKet fxi] KaAcos copoAoy?/crc9at, dvaOecrOaL otl av crv /3o?JA?/,
eav ]xol ev \xovov cpvAarr?/s.

nX2A. Tt tovto Ae'yets; 5
2Ii. Tr]v ixaKpokoyiav, co ricoAe, r)v Ka6epr]s, 17 to irpSiTOV
eirexeipr]o-as xPW^ al"
a5 oSBTP: iri\tp oSF b4^F:^BT:KalW Ci J
add. f : om. BTPF oz atrapvfiiTfadat BT : a.irapvi\<TaoQat PF
03 6i's to B T P : (1 ye F (V supra et f ) c4 toi/s A0700S secl. Cobet
C 6 eraipovs Ka\ vliis Ft : erepovs vtus B T W : tTaipovs Schanz ytv6-
/xfvot F : ytyvSfjtevoi BTP C7 tiravopdcoTe F : iiravopdoiire BTP
d.2 eya) BT et re vera W : 7^ o-ot F ei w/jtoXoyâOat
. . . secl.
Cobet d6 KaOepfris BTP Olympiodortis KaOetys F:
46id nAATX2N02
FFXIA. Tt de'; ovk ee'crrat /xot keyeLv oTtocra av fSov-
Aoo/xat;
e 2X2. Aeiva p.evThv 1:6.6019, u> /3e'Aricn-e, el 'AdijvaCe

acpLKop.evo$, ov tj}$ 'EAAdSo? TrAetcrr?/ earlv iovo-(a tov
keyeLV, eireLTa o~v ivravQa tovtov p.6vo$ dri>x?/crais. akka
avTiOes ror crov jua/cpa XeyovTos Kat p.r) idekovTos to epcorco-
v
5 fxevov aTTOKpCveo-Oai, ov beLva av av iyu> TtaQoi\xi, et /u? / ee'crrai
462 jtxot aTriivai Kal p.r) aKOveiv aov; dAA' et rt Krjbri tov koyov
tov elpr\p.evov kol iisavopQ&crao-QaL avrov ftovkeL, oocr7rep
vvvbr) ekeyov, avadep.evo$ otl ctol hoKti, iv rco pepeL ipu>ru>v
re *ai ipu>Tu>p.evos, u>o"rrep eyco re Kat Topytas, ekeyê re

5 Kat ikiyxov. cpys yap brfnov koI crv e7rtcrracrâi airep
TopyCas' rj ov;
IIX2A. "Eycoye.
212. Ovkotjj Kat crv KekeveLS o-avrbv ipu>Tav eKaoroTe otl
av tls j3ovkr]TaL, d>$ i-nLo-Tap.Vos airoKp(vecrdaL;
10 ITX2A. Ylavv p.ev ovv.

b 2X2. Kat vvv bij tovtu>v oiroTepov /3ovkeL ttoUl, ipcara r)
CLTTOKpLVOV.
nX2A. 'AAAa TTOLf)o-u> ravra. Ka( p.OL airoKpLvai, u> 2co-

Kpares' iireLbr) Topyias airopelv ctol boKeX irepl Trjs prjTOpiKrjs,
5 crv airrjv r(va cprjs elvaL;

2X2. 'Apa ipu>Tas rjvTLva Texvrjv cprjpl elvai;
nX2A. "Eycoye.
2X2. Ovbep-Ca epoLye boKel, 00 n<3Ae, co? ye irpbs cre
TakrjOrj elprjo-0aL.
10 FIX2A. 'AAAa r( ctol boKel r) prjTopLKr) etrat;
2X2. Ilpdypa 6 <pf\s av TroLrjcraL Te\vrrv iv rco crvyypappaTi

^_ C o eycb evay\os aveyvutv.
I1X2A. Tt tovto keyeLs;
2X2. 'Ep,TTLpLav eycoye' tlvo.
v
I1X2A. 'E/xTretpia apa ctol boKel fj /3?/roptK? / etyat;
a4 Te post e\eyxe om. P ehcu om. b6 P b8 76 BTf :
om. F bo. tlpTJa-dai BTPf: Soku fipr)<r6at F b n <rb <prjs P

F
ropriAS 4 62c
v
2X2. Euotye, et u?/ tl <tv dAAo Aeyets. 5
FIX2A. Tivos eu7retota;

2X2. Xaptro? Ttvos Kat rjbovrjs a7repyacrtas.
ITX2A. Ovkovv Kakov <tol 8oKet ?/ pT/roptK?/ etvaL, X<3.pi-
(fecrflat olov re etrai av0p<aitoLs;

2X2. Tt 8e', a> FIcoAe; 7/877 nitrvaaL -nap \p.ov otl cp?/ut 10
avTi]v zlvaL, cocrre ro p.iT<x tovto epcoras' et ov KaXrj uot d

boK(l ftvai;
I1X2A. Ov yap TT(Trv<rp.aL otl eu7retptW tlvcl avri]V </>?/?
etWt;
2X2. BoJAei ovv, e7ret8?) riuas to yapiz<r0aL, <rp.LKp6v ft 5
uot yapi<ra<T0aL;
nX2A. 'Eycoye.
2X2. 'Eootj vvv ue, 6\f/oiroLia r/rts- uot 8oKet Ttyvr] etivat.
nX2A. 'Epcorco 8?/, rts Teyvr] 6\j/oiroLia; 2X2. 0?38euia,

io n<SAe. riX2A. 'AAAa rt; cpdflt. 2X2. <P?/ui 877, euTTetpia 10
rts. nX2A. Tts; <pd#t. 2X2. ^rjpu 877,

r
x-P tT0S Ka ' vbovrjs

a7repyacrias, 00 TTcoAe. e
ITX2A. Taijrojv ap' ecrrt/V d\^07rotta Kat prjTopLKi];
2X2. OvSaucos ye, dAAd r?zs avr?7s uev e7rir7/8e?jVecos
wo'ptojv.
T1X2A. TtVos Aeyets rarjrr/s; 5
2X2. Mr/ aypoLKOTtpov ?/ ro dA?/0es ehrcu* 6kv> yap

Yopyiov eVeKa Ae'yetu, u?) oiT/rai ue SiaKcoucoSeii; ro eaurou
e7rtr?/oeJJwa. eyco 8e', et uei* toiSto' ecrra> r/ prjTopLKi] r/iv ropyta?
e7rtrr/8ei;ei, o?3k oT8a Kat yap dprt eK tov Adyou ovbzv r/pXv 463
KaTacpaves kykvero ri 7rore ovros 7/yetrat o 8' eyco koAco
Ti]v pr]TopLKr]v, 7rpdyuards tlvos ecrri udptoy ovbzvbs t<2v
KaAcoTJ.
rOP. Tivos, co 2coKpares; e^Tre'* u?78ei> eue atcrxittvflTJs. 5
c to B T P 5r> F
8 di PFet suprascr. B i) B ^ T
:
2
: :
d. 8 F f tis B T
jj-m : W
Tex V7 îvai B T P elyat rex vr
^"
l
:
l
d 1 1 tis B T P F rivos in marg. f : e 2 2/>' F ipo Olympiodorus : :
8'BTP e 6 yap om. B T Wa 5 ai<rx v " V s ^ ( se(*

:
supra ead. m. 6)
j? al<TxvQri<i T PF: aicrxvvOels scr. recc.
:
4633 FIAATX2N02
2X2. AoKet roLvvv wot, co Yopyia, clvai n e7rtTr/8eup.a
Tex^tKov ptv ov, ^rvxrjs 8e oroxacrTiKr/s Kal avbpdas ko.1
cpvcra beivrjs Trpocrop.iXetv toIs avOpcaTTOiS' KaAco 8e avrov

b eyco to K<pakaiov KokaKtiav. TavTi]s uot 8oKet Trjs iin-
Trjbevcreoos 7roAAd p.ev Kal dAAa p.6pia elvai, ev 8e Kal r)
6\JfoiroiiKfj' 6 SoKet piev elvai Tzyvr), cos 8e d euos Ao'yos, ovk

icmv Ttyvr) dAA' eu7retpta Kat Tpt/3r/. ravrr]? p.6piov Kat
5 tt)i> prjTopiKijv eyco KaAco *at T^f ye /cou/xcoTt/cr/v Kat tt/i;
crocpicrTiKriv, rirrapa TavTa p.6pia e7rt TtTTapaiv Trpayp.ao~iv.

et ow /3ovAeTai ITcoAos Trvvdaveo~9ai, TrvvOavicrOoi' ov yap
C ttco 7re7rucrTat d7roioV cpr/pt eyco Tr/s KoAaKetas p,6piov et/ât
Tr/y prjTopiKr/v, dAA' avrbv Ae'Ar/t9a ov7rco cnroKKpip,4vos, 6 8e

Travepa>Tq et ov KaXbv r)yovp,ai cTvai. eyco 8e avTco ovk
aTTOKpivovp,ai TTpoTepov eire KaAoy eiTe alo-ypbv r)yovp.ai

5 etyai Tr)z/ pi]TopiKi]v irplv av irp&TOV a.TTOKpivo)p.ai oti IcttLv.
ov yap bUaiov, ) ncoAe* dAA' et7rep /3orJAet Trv6io~6ai, epcoYa
birolov p.6piov Tr)s KoAaKetas cpr/ui eu>at Tr/i> prjTopiKrjv.
ITX2A. 'EpcoTco 8r/, Kat cnroKpivai oirolov p,6piov.

d 2X2. 'Ap' ovu av p,ddois a.TTOKpivap,ivov; eo~Tiv yap r)
prjTopiKrj Kara tov ip,bv koyov iroXiTiKijs pxtpiov etScoAor.
nX2A. Tt ovv; KaXbv r) alo~\pbv Aeyets avTi]V elvai;

2X2. Alcrypbv eycoye ra, yap KaKa alo~)(pa KaAco e7rei8r/
5 8et crot aTTOKpivacrOai cos r/8r/ etSoVi cx eyco Aeyco.
rOP. Ma tov Aia, co 2coKpaTes, dAA' eyco or38e ovtos

o~vvir]p.i oti Aeyets.
e 2X2. EtKoVcos ye, co Topyia' ovbzv yap ttco cracpes Ae'yco,
FIcoAos 8e obe vios ecrTt Kal d^rjs.
a 6 t B T P F om. Aristides (sed habent Proll. in Aristidem)

:
a 8 abrov ey&i B T P Aristides iy&> avrov F : b2 ^BTPF: om.

Aristides c 2 oiirw F Aristides et suprascr. b oStu B T P :
C 4 e?T KaXbv ehe aicrxpbv B T P JVe alffxpov etre Ka\bv F Aristides

:
C 5 8rt eo-TiV B T P F g iariv Aristides

: C 6 i-vdtoBai B T P F :
i-vvdiveo-Qai Aristides e8 Kal /uJpioi> secl. Cobet (legit

. . .
Aristides) fxoi post airiKpivai add. Aristides d 5 iy&> B T P F :
om. Aristides d6 ^-yiiBTPF: iywye Aristides

:
TOPriAS 4 63e
rOP. 'AAAa tovtov p.\v ea, euot cV etVe 7rco? Ae'yets
TToXiTinrjs fxopCov ib(a\ov elvai rtjv pr\TopLKr\v.
2X2. 'AAA' eycb 7reipdcrouai cppdcrai 6 ye' uot <pa(vTaL 5

etrat 7/ pr\TopiKiy et 8e ut/ rvyxdi>et oy roCro, n<3Aos o8e
eAe'yet. crcoud7roi; KaAetsrt /cat \lrv\r\v; VOP. Tl&syap ov; 464
2X2. Ovkovv Kal tovtoov otet rtva etiuai e/carepou eveîav;
rOP.
v
Eya>ye. 2X2. Tt oe'; boKovcrav \xev evfîav, ovcrav
8' ov; olov rotoVSe Ae'yco* 7roAAot boKovo~iv ev %x ieiv ra
crcouara, of)s otjk a> paStco? alcrOoLTo tls ort ov/c ei) eyovcriv, 5
dAA' r/ larpos re *cat rcoi> yvpvacrTLK&v tis. IDP. 'AAr/flf/
Aeyets. 2X2. T6 rototJrov Ae'yco Kat ey crcouart etrat Kat eV
^rvxfj, 6 7roiet uei> 8oxety ev exetr t6 crcoua Kat r?/y \j/vx>jv,
exet Se ovSei' /xaAAor. rOP. "Ecrrt raCra. b

2X2. <J>e'pe brj crot, ech> bvvu>p.at, cracpicrTepov e7rt8eico 6
Ae'yco. Svoty ovtolv tolv irpayp.aTOLV bvo Ae'yco rexvas* rT/y

uey e7ri Trj ifrvxf] tto\ltlki\v koAco, 77/1 be eVt crcouart utay
uei> of/rco? ciVoudcrai ovk exco crot, utas 8e 0150-7/? rf/? roO 5
crcapiaTos <9epa7retas 8vo p.6pLa Ae'yco, rr/y uey yuuâcrrtKj/y,

rr/r 8e laTpiKrjv Trjs be TroAtrtKf/s cWt uev rf/? yvpvacrTLKrjs
Trjv vop.o0TLKr\v, dvTLcrTpocpov be rf/ tarptKT/ rr/i btKaLOcrvvr\v.
TTLKOLVu>vovcrL p.\v br\ dAAT/Aat?, are 7rept ro avro ovcrai, C

eK&TcpaL tovtojv, fj re tarpiKT/ r?/ yvp.vacrTLKr\ ml r) bLKaLocrvvi)
Ty vopoOeTLKij' oucos 8e ta<pepoucru> tl d\Xr\X.u>v. TtTTapuiv

bi\ tovtojv ovcraiv, kol det 7rp6s r6 fiikTLcrTOv Oepairevovcr&v
rcoi* pei> ro crcopa, rcoy 8e rTJy y\rvyr\v, r) KokaKtvTLKi) alcrdop.(vr\ 5
e6 ^ TPF Aristides om. B : rvyxa-vt t TP Aristides : TvyxdvTt

BF a6 dAA' ^ Aristides: jAXos BTPF
% larpSs BTP
Aristides : 6 torpJs F a8 h F Aristides oVt BTP : ba îrc
Stif o)B T P Aristides m5eiai F : b 3 ovroiv toIv irpayn.aroiv B T P
vvtoiv irpayixaroiv F ovraiv tuv wpayfidTuv Aristides
: t\\v fifv B T P
Kal t))v fiiv F t V fx^v odv Aristides
: b 4 tij <Jwxf? B T P F Aristides 2
t^v tyvxh v T ffdfiaTi B T P t$ ffdfiaTi F Aristides : b 7 cij/tJ

fLtv ttjs yvfivaffTticris B T P F avriffTpo<pov fikv Tp yv/xvaffTtKfj Aristides
:
b8 SiKaioffvvriv BTP Aristides Olympiodorus : HticaffTiK^v F et Proll.

adAristidem e2 StKatoffvvri B T P Aristides : otKaffTtK)] F 048^
BTPF: 5e Aristides OI3 nipiodorus 05 alffQofitvi) F Aristides
atffdavofitfvr) BTP

464 c nAAT&NOS
ov yvovcra keyco dAAa crToya.crap.evr] TeTpaya eavrr)v 8ta-
veipacra, vTrobvcra vtto eKacrrov tcov p.opicov, irpocriTOLeiTaL
d etVat tovto oirep virebv, Kal tov piev /3eArtcrrou oibev cppovriêL,
ra> 8e det i)bicrTco drjpeveTaL rr]v avoiav Kal eâiraTq, cocrre
oojcei -TrAetarou dta etWt. virb piev ovv rr)y iarpLKrjv r)
tyoTTOUKr] inrobebvKev, KaX 7rpoa-7roieirai to. /3eArto-ra crtrta
5 rco crcopart dbivai, coctt et 8e'ot ev 7raicri 8taycoi>tCeo-0at
o-^roiroiov re Kat iarpov, r] ev avbpacnv ovtcos avorJTOLS cocnrep

ol Tratbes, TTOTepos e7ratei 7repi tlov xpi]crTcov o-tricoy xat
e 7Tovr]pcov, 6 iarpbs 7] 6 6\j/ottol6s, Atpcp av cvrrodavew tov
laTpov. KokaKeiav piev ovv avrb Kakco, kol aicrypov cpr/pt
465 etz>ai to tolovtov, S) IIcoAe tovto yap irpbs cre Aeyco ort
tov r)beos oToyd(eTaL avev tov /3eArtcrrotr Teyvr]v be avrr]V

ov cpr/pt etvat dAA' ep.ireLpiav, ort ovk ey^ koyov ovbeva
co Trpocrcpepei a 7rpocr<pe'pet 07rot' arra rr)v <pvo~LV ecrTiv, cocrre
5 rr)v atrtai' eKacrTOV p.r) eyeLV elirelv. eyco 8e Teyyrrv ov

Kakco 6 av r/ akoyov irpaypa' tovtcov be 7re'pt et ap.cpLcrfir]Te'is,
edekco VTTOcryeiv koyov.

b T77 per ovy tarptKT/, cocnrep Ae'yco, 7} oxjroTTOLLKr) KokaKeia
VTroKetrat' rvj 8e yvp.vacrTLK^ Kara rov avTov Tpoirov tovtov
r) Kop.p.coTLKr], KaKovpyos re Kai d7rgrrjA?/ Kai dye*>in/s Kat
dvekevOepos, cryj]p.acrLV Kal ypcop.acrLV Ka\ Aeto'rTjri Kat ecrOrjcrLV
5 cLTraTcocra, cocrre 7rotety akkoTpiov Kakkos ecpekKopevovs tov

OLKeiov tov 8ta rr/? yvp.vaoTLK7]S dp.ekeiv. "lv ovv p.r]
paKpoAoyco, eOekco ctol elireiv cocnrep ol yecopeVpat 7/8?/ yap
d 1 oirep P Aristides et suprascr. rec. b '6irov B T F birb t Schanz : :
(oVfp vireSv om. Sauppe) d 2 &el B T P F om. Aristides dripev- :
rai B T P F Oriptvfi Aristides

: d 3 SoKt? B T P (sed v add. B 2 ) :
SoksTu F Aristides (qui mox d|iov) a 1 clvcu post UuXe transp. F

a 2 aurV B T P f Aristides Olympiodorus outoO F a 4 y icpoo-Qfpei :
a irpoa<p4pu B T P F Philodemus $ irpoff<p4pei Aristides wv irpo<r<pfpei

: :
Cornarius b 1 dipoirouKi) B T P o\f/o7roi7jTiK^ F b 2 toCtoj'

:
T P F rovruv B om. Aristides

: : b 3 t* B T P F Aristides Olympio-
dorus (sed oSiro in marg. add. f) b 4 \et6rr)Ti B T P F Aristides :
AeioVijo-i scr. recc. <?o-0t1o-i F (v add. f) laOrjTi Aristides alo-Orja-ti : :
B T P eo-flijo-ei Coraes
: b 5 e<pe\KOfMcvovs B T P F f<pe\Ko/j.evv :
Aristides toO . . . yv/j,va<rTiKr)s secl. Cobet (habet Aristides)

ropriAS 465C
av i<r<x>s aKoX.ov6i]<raLS ort o KopLp.<x>TiKi] TTpos yvp.vacrTLKi]v, C

tovto <to<Pl<ttlki] irpbs vop.o6TLKi)v, Kal ort o 6\j/ottollki] TTpbs
laTpiKijv, tovto prfTopiKt] trpbs SiKatoo-wrjr. o-ntp p.ivToi
Xiyco, ote'cm/Ke p.V ovra> <pvcrL, <xt 0' iyyvs ovtcov (pvpovTat
iv t<2 avT<2 Kal irepl TavTa <ro<pL<TTal Kal pi]TopS, Kal ovk 5
\ovo~lv otl yjpr)<rovTaL ovt ovtol kavTois ovt ol dAAot
dvdpooiroL tovtols. Kal yap dv, et ut/ r) \pvyj] t<2 crco/iari
TTTTaTL, dAA' avrb avT<2, Kal p.i] vtto TavTrjs Karetêcopetro d

Kai oteKptyero 17 re 6yj/OTTOLLKi] Kat r) larpiKrj, dAA' avrb to
<r<2p.a KpLV <TTadp.<2p.Vov rats yapL<TL rats irpbs avro, to tov
'Avaayopov av ttoXv rjv, co cptAe IIcoAe <rv yap tovtcov
epLTTiLpos 6p.ov clv TTCLVTa yjpf)p.aTa <pvpeTO ev t<2 avr<2, 5
UKpLTOJV OVTCOV T<2v T laTpLK&V Kal VyLLV<2v KOl 6\j/OTTOLLK<2v.

o p.V ovv eyd> cpr/pt Ti]V pr]TopLKr)v elvai, aKi]Koas' clvtl-
<TTpo<pov oxj/oTTOLLas V ^vxf), s * K &V0 *v crcop.art. tcrcos e

pLV OVV CLTOTTOV TTTTOL7]Ka, OTL <T OVK <2v pLaKpOVS \6yOVS
XiyeLV avrbs avxybv koyov d7rore'raKa. cllov p.ev ovv
ep.ol <rvyyva>p.i]v e\LV <ttlv kiyovTos yap p,ov fipayjia ovk
ep.av6aves, ovbe xpr)<rdai Trj d7roKptcret rjv <tol aTTKpLvdp.r]v 5
ovbev oXos t r)<rda, dAA' ibiov 8tT/yr/crecos. eav p.ev ovv Kal
eyco <rov <XTTOKpLvop.ivov p.i] e\co otl yjpi]<rcop.aL, o.tt6tLV 466
Kat <rv koyov, eav be e^co, * a r1 * Xpr)<r6aL' bUaLov ydp. kol
vvv Tavnj rrj aTTOKpL<TL et rt \LS Xpr)<r6aL, \p&'
nX2A. Ti ovv <pr)s; KoAaKeta SoKet crot etyat r)
pi]TOpLK1]! 5
212. KoAaKetaj pkv ovv eycoye et7iw p.6pLov. dAA'
c 1 '6n k.t.A. ita F Aristides ante haec verba add. cfrt h ko/jl/mutikti
:
xpbs yvfjLvatTTiK^v, tovto 6\poirotiKi} irpbs laTptKi)v' fxaWoi> 8e w8e B T P

(secluserat Thompson : ego delevi) e3 b~iKaioo-vvr\v BTP
Aristides biKacTiK^v F
: C 4 StecrTijKf /jihv F : 5te<TTT)Ktv BTP
C6 xpi\(TovTai BPF J)~ UVTal T ^2 bi\/oiroiT)TiKT) F d. 5 e<pv-
BTWxP
:
ptTo F : ttpepfTo iv Ttp avri? secl. Hirschig d6 vyittvwv

Kal secl. Dobree otyoirotriTtKGbv F e 1 ûxfi B T P ttj tyvxfi F
:
e3 B T P f om. F
\6ryov 64
: 4/jiol BTPf : )xoiF a 1 iiro-
Kptvofjtevov B T P airo\oyov/xivov F
:
xp'h (ru lJial B T P xp^l<ro JLal ^* '
:
>
a 3 xpyvO B T P xp7 <raar^ al r

011 :
)
466 a nAAT12N02
ov fjLvrjfxoveutis TrjXiKOVTOs &v, 5> n<SAe; H Taya
opacrets;
1112A. *Ap' ovp boKova-i crot cos Ko'AaKes kv rats iroAecri

J o cpaSAot ropieo-<9ai 61 ayaOol prjTopes;
b 212. 'Epcorr/p-a rovr' epcoras r/ Aoyou ru>os ap\r)v Aeyets;

ITX2A. 'Epcorci) eyajyc
212. Ov8e vop.i&adaL epxuye 8okoSctu>.
nf2A. ITtSs ov vop.i&o~6ai; ov p,e'yiorov bvvavraL kv rats
5 7roAeo">;
212. Ovk, et rd 8wacr0ai ye Ae'yets ayaOov tl etj>ai rcp
owa/ueVco.
ni2A. 'AAAa /ut)i> Ae'yco ye.
2X2. 'EAa^to"roy roivvv /xot boKOvaL t5>v eV rr/ 7roAet

io 5wacr0ai ot p?7ropes.
ni2A. Tt 8e'; ot>x> &o~TTp 61 rvpavvoL, cnroKTLvvacriv re

C ov av /SovAcoyrat, /cat acpaLpovvraL \pi']p.aTa kol eK/3aAAoi;criy
ex tG>v TTokeoov ov av 8okt} ovtols;
212. Nr) roz> KWOj ap.(pLyvoS> jueVrot, co n<2Ae, ecp' (Kao-Tov
<5i> Ae'yets Trorcpov avTos ravra Aeyets Kat yva>p.i]V aavrov
5 aTTocpaivrj, y\ e/xe epcoras.
ni2A. 'AAA' eycoye cre epcorco.
212. Etey, co cpiAe* e7retra 8vo a/xa /ue epcarqs;
FI12A. Ilcos 8vo;
212. Ovk dprt ovrco 7rcos eAeyes' "*H ovxt airoKTeLVvacrLV

d ot p7/ropes o#s av /3ovXo>VTaL, co<X7rep ot rvpavvoL, k6X \pi']p.aTa
cKpaLpovvraL Kal (ekavvovcrLV ck t&v 770'Aecov 6y av boKj]
"
avTols;
y
ni2A. Eycoye.
a 8 ad Spdffeis adscripsit in B manus saec. xvi non antiquior \eiirei

(sic) irpecfivTris yev6fxevos, quod ortum est ex interpretatione verborum
rr)\iKovros et t<x<* quae in W ita legitur veos &>v irpecrfivTT)s yev6-
/xevos b6 ye BTP : om. F b 8 fxijv scripsi firjv 8r) :
B T P F fxev 8i) Heindorf c7 elev TPFb : et ev B erreiTa

W
:
T P F errel tb B
: C 9 'H oi>xl scripsi : el oi>xl F : < 2tj BT :
cJt.P
f
ropriAS 466 d
2X2. Ae'yco tolvvv trot ori bvo ravr eVrty tcl epoiTijpara, 5
Kat airoKpivovp.aL yk ctol 7rpds ap.<poTpa. cpr]pX yap, co
IlcoAe, eyco kcu rorjs pijTopas nal tovs rvpavvovs bvvao~dai

p.\v iv rals tto\o~lv 0-p.LKpoTaTov, &o-TTp vvvbi] eAeyov ovbev
yap TTOLelv 5>V [HovkoVTaL 0)S (TTOS HTTelv, TTOLelv pikvTOL OTL &
av ovtols boi] fikkTLcrTov eti>at.
I1I2A. Ovkovv tovto Ao-tlv to p.kya bvvaadaL;

2X2. Ov\, u>s yk (prjaLv ricoAos.
I1X2A. 'Eycb ov (prjp,L; c/jrj/xt p.\v ovv eycoye. 5
2X2. Md rbv ov cru ye, eVet to pkya bvvacrdaL e</jr/s
ayadbv etrat rto bvvap.kv(p.

F1X2A. ^rj/xt yap ovv.
2X2. 'Aya0oy ovv otet etrat, edz> rts ttolt] ravra a ay
boKj] arjrco /3e'Arttrra etrat, yow /xr/ t\d>v; Ka\ tovto KaAety 10
crrj /xe'ya bvvao-6ai;
IIX2A. Ovk eycoye.
2X2, OrjKorjjj a7ro5etc5ets tovs prfTopas vovv fx oVTas Kai

Ttyvr\v Ti]V pr]TopLKi]v akka. p.i] KokaKtCav, e/xe Zekkyas ; et 4^7
tW /xe edcrets dvkkcyKTov, ol /5?/ropes ot 7rotowres ei> raty
irokecrLV a 8oKet arjrots Kat 01 Tvpavvot ovbev ayadbv tovto
KiKTf]o-ovTai, 7/ tre bvvap.is koTLV, cos crv c/jrjs, ayadov, to
8e 7rotety dyerj you d SoKet Kat crrj 6/uoAoyets KaKov etrat* 5
r/ orj;
nX2A. 'Eycoye.
2X2. FIcos av ovv ol pr]Topts p.kya bvvaLvro r/ 01 TvpavvoL
kv rats irokecrLV, iav /xr/ 2coKpdrr/s eeAeyx$r/ rjTro EIcoAorj ort
ttolovctlv a /3orjAorjrat; 10
d5 TiBTWF Stobaeus e 2 $e\TiaTov efoai secl.

: om. al.
Cobet 64 BT P F
Stobaeus
iruKos e6 fia. tov
: 6 iraihos
B T P F /jlo. tov Kvva Stobaeus
: etpys B T P F Stobaeus <pi)s Baiter :
e9 aicBPPFStobaeus & T e 10 /3Atktto tlvai seel. Cobet

:
eivai om. P e 1 1 ffb F Stobaeus om. B T P e 13 airoSei&is :
. a 1 ê\tyâs B T F Stobaeus awoSeif eis

. . i\eyâs P curotiei-
: . . . :
|ay ie\eyeis Hirschig

. . . a 1 t^v {>r)TopiKiiv secl. Cobet (habet
Stobaeus) a 3 to5to B T P F Stobaeus tovtw fecit rec. b :
a 4 ^StBTPF: el Se Stobaeus ei 5^ Heindorf :

467 b FIAATX2N02
b I1X2A. Ovtos dvr/p
2X2. Ov cpr\p.L iroLeiv ovtovs a [3ovkovraL' akkd p? e'Aeyx.e.
IIX2A. Ovk dprt coju.oAdyets iroLeiv a boKei avrois /3e'Artcrra
zlvai, [tovtov irpocrOev];
5 2X2. Kat yap vvv 6/xoAoyco.

ni2A. Ovk ovv ttolovctlv a fiovkovTai;
2X2. Oii cpr\p.i.
TTX2A. rioiovvTts a 8oKet ovtois;

2X2. <l>r)p.L
io IIX2A. 2xe'rAtd ye Aeyets Kal inrepcpvrj, co 2coK/xtres.
2X2. Mt/ KaKtjyopeL, co Acoore IIcoAe, tW 7rpocret7rco cre
C Kard cre'* dAA' et p.ey *X els eM e epwTav, eTribeLôv drt

\jrevbopiaL, el 8e /ut/, avros aTTOKpCvov.
nX2A. 'AAA' edekoi aTTOKpivecrdaL, Xva kol elbG> drt
Aeyets.
5 "2X2. IloVepoi' ovy crot boKOvcnv ol avOpunroi tovto /3ov-

Aecrflat 6 &y 7rpdrrcocrty eKcicrrore, 17 eKetro ov eveKa 7rpdr-
roticrti rout^' 6 TTpaTTovo~iv ; olov oi ra cpdppxiKa ttlvovtcs
Trapa. t&v tarpcoi/ ttoTepov crot 8oKO?jcriy tovto fiovkecrdaL
o7rep 7rot07jcrty, irCveLV t6 cpdpp.aKov kcCl dkyeiv, r/ eKeivo,
10 r6 vyLaCveLv, ov eveKa ttCvovctlv; I1X2A. Arjkov otl to
d vyLaCveLV. 2X2. Ovkovv Kal ol irkeovres re Kal tov dkkov
yjpr\p.aTLa-p.bv ypr\p.aTL(pp.evoL ov tovto kcrTLV 6 (3ovkovTaL, 6
ttolovctlv eKacrTOTe (tCs ydp /3o?JAerai nkeiv re Kat KLvbv-
veve.LV kol TrpdyaaT exetv;) dAA' eKelvo otjuat ov evem
5 irkeovcTLV, irkovTeiv irkovTov yap eveKa irkeovcrLv. I1X2A.
Yldvv ye. 2X2.
v
AAAo rt ovv ovrco Kat 7rept irdvTUiv; edv tCs
b3 Cobet (habet Stobaeus)

/8eATi<rra elvat secl. b 4 rovrov
irp6adev secl. Schleiermacher (habet Stobaeus) b 8 irotovvres F
Stobaeus: irotovvres b~e BTP: irotovvres ye ci.H. Richards b 10 o-%e-
r\ia BTPf: exerataF 7 e Olympiodorus Stobaeus om. :
BTPF bn
KaKTrySpei Naber Karriy6pet libri c 10 8?}Ao'
:
u-ytatVe' BW
om. T F sed add. in marg. Tf d 1 ov eveKa
W
. . . :
klvovo-iv post vytaivetv quoque add. et in marg. T om. B F Stobaeus :
(I3 re Kal B TP Kal F Stobaeus

: ds ttKovtov TtKeovatv secl. . . .
Cobet (habet Stobaeus) d6 irdvTwv B T P ardvruv F Stobacus :

ropriAS 467 d
TL TrpUTTll VKO. TOV, OV TOVTO (3ovX.Tai 6 TTpaTTL, dAA' KHVO

ov evKa 7rpdrret; IlX2A. Noi. 2X2. 'Ap' ovv ecrrtr tl tcov e
ovtcov b ov\l ?/rot ayaOov y eo-rlv ?*/ KaKov r) p.Tav tovtcov,
ovre ayadbv ot/re
v

mKov; ITX2A. IloAA? drdy/cr?, co 2co- /
KpaTes. 2X2. Ovkovv keyeis etât c\ya0bv pev o-ocpiav re Kat

vyieiav Kat 7rAoDroz> Kat rdAAa rd rotairra, Ka/cd oe Tavavria 5
tovtcov; IIX2A. "Eycoye.- 212. Td be /x?/re dya#a p.r\Te
Ka/cd dpa rotd8e Aeyets, a einore piev p.Te\L tov ayadov,

vioT be TOV KOKOV, VLOT be OvbeTpOV, OLOV Ka0r)o-0aL KOl 4^8
(3abieLv Kat TpeyeLv Kal irkelv, koi 0101 av ki0ovs Kat vAa
Kat rdAAa rd roLavra; ov ravTa Aeyets; rj dAA' arra KaAets
rd /x?/re dya0d /u?/re koko; ITX2A. Ovk, dAAd ratrra.
2X2. Y\oTpov ovv tcl /btera^v ravra eveKa tcov ayadiov 7rpdr- 5
tovctlv brav irpaTTcoo-LV, r) Tayada tcov /xerav; ITX2A. Td
/jteraî brjTrov tcov aya0S>v. 2X2. Td ayaObv dpa buoKOVTes b
Kat (3abiop.ev brav /3a8ttop.ei>, o\6p.evoL (3ekrLov etrat, Kat
rd ivavTLOV eo-Tap.ev brav ecrrcopei', tov ovtov eveKa, tov
ayaOov' 1) ov; nX2A. Nat. 2X2. Ovkovv Kat cnroKreivv-
p.V, et TLV aiTOKTLVVp.V, KOL K(3akkop.V KO.X CL(paLpOVp,0a 5
XP?//xara, olop.evoL ap.Lvov etVat r)puv ravra ttollv r) p.r\;

ITX2A. Ylavv ye. 2X2. "Ei>eK' apa tov ayadov airavTa
Tavra ttolovo-lv ol ttolovvtS. ITX2A. t>?//xt. 2X2. Ovkovv
cop.okoyrpTap.ev, b. eveKa tov iroLovp.V, p.r) eKelva (3ovkeo-0aL,
dAA' eKelvo ov eveKa ravra TroLovp.v; I7X2A. MdAto-ra. C
2X2. Ovk apa o-cpaTTLV (3ovk6p.0a ovb' eK/3dAAety K to>v
it6\.<0V oib \pr]p.aTa dc/)atpeto*c9at dâis ovtcos, dAA' iav

pikv cocpeÂt/jia ?/ Tavra, /3ouAo'/xec9a rrpdrreti' avrd, /3Aa/3epd
8e ovTa ov (3ov\6p.0a. ra yap aya0a (3ov\6p.0a, cos <pr)s 5
cru, ra 8e p.?/re dya#d p.r\T KaKa ov (3ovh.6p.e0a, ovbe tcl
d7 ti BTPF : om. Stobaeus e 4 ehai ayaObv B T P F 0706^ :
Stobaeus t B T P f ical F Stobaeus

ical : e 6 /xfre ayaBa
/*^T KaKa BTP Stobaeus fjA\r* KaKa ix-fire ayaOa. F
: a 5 eveKa]
iv iK P : '<eveKtv B T F Stobaeus b 6 fifiiv ravra B T P Stobaeus :
TaSra t)h?v F
PLATO, VOL. III. 19
468 c IIAATX2N02
KO.K&. r) ydp; dkr\0r) crot Sokco keyeiv, co TTcoAe, r) ov; tC
ovk aiTOKpivri; fII2A. 'AXrjdr).
d 2X2. Ovkovv etirep ravra 6p.okoyovp.ev, et tls diroKTeCvei
Tiva r) eKfidkkei eK 7ro'Aecos rj dcpatpetrai \pr)p.aTa, etre

Tvpavvos cov etre pr/roop, olop.evos dp.ecvov elvai at/rcp, Tvyy6.-
vei be ov k6.ki.ov, ovtos bf)irov iroiei a boKel avrco* r) ydp;

5 ITX2A. Nat. 2X2. 'Ap' ow Kat a /3ojJAerat, et7rep ruyxavet
raura /ca/ca ovra; tC ovk diroKpCvr]; TTX2A. 'AAA' ov /xot
8o/cet 7rotety a fiovkerai. 2X2.

v
Ecrriv oily o7rcos 6 rotoiSro?
e p.eya bvvarai ev tjj Troket TavTr/, eXirep ecrrt r6 /ue'ya bvva-

o~9ai ayaOov rt /cara Tr)v o-fjv 6p.okoyCav; TTX2A. Ovk
ecrTiv,- 2X2. 'AAt?0?7 dpa eycb fkeyov, Aeycoz/ ort ecrrty dv-
OpcoiTov TTOiovvTa ev 7roAei a 8ocet avrco p,r/ p.eya bv"vao-0ai
5 p.??8e 7rotety a /WAerai.

ITX2A. *X2s 8?) o~v, 3> 2coKpares, o?3k a*> beaio eetvai
cot 7T0tet^ ort OKet o-ot ez> rr) 7roAet p.akkov r) p.f), ovbe
(/r/Aots orav tbr]S Tivd r) diroKTeCvavTa bv eboev a?)rco r)
dqbek6p.evov \pf)p.aTa rj bf)cravTa.
io 2X2. Atxatcos Aeyets i) dStKco?;
469 I1X2A. '07ro'rep' ar 7toit/, o?jk djucporepcos friAcoroV ecmv;

2X2. F,v<pf)p.et., a> TTcoAe.
nX2A. Tt 8?/;
2X2. "Ort ov XP*7 ^ re T0VS dÂcorous (friAow ot/re rovs

5 ddXCovs, dAA' eAeetr.
I1X2A. Tt be; ovrco crot SoKet eêty 7rept &v eyco Ae'yco
rcoy dv0p<oTTcov;
2X2. ITcos yap ov;

TTX2A. "Ocrrts ovv aTTOKTeivvo-iv bv &V bor) avrio, blKaicos
10 a7ro Kr etvvs, a0kios boKeT crot etvat Kat eAetro's;
2X2. Otjk e/j,otye, ovbe /xeVrot (fr/Acoros.
TTX2A. Ovk aprt d0\iov ^(f>r]o-0a elvat;
e 8 avoKTfhavra BTPf Stobaeus : airoKreivovra F a 1 t)\t6v

BTPF Stobaeus : (VjAcotJj al. a 7 rwv B T P Stobaeus om. F :
: -
TOPriAS 46gb
2X2. Tov dotKcos ye, co eratpe, airoKTCLvavTa, Kal eAetroV b

ye Trpos' tov 8e StKatcos dÂcoroi'.
nX2A. 'H ttov o ye airodvrjcrKcov abUm eAetrds re Kal
adkios co-tlv.
t
2X2. Httov rj 6 cnroKTeivvs, co n<3Ae, Kat ^rroy 17 6 5
StKaico? aTTo6vrjcrK(i)V.
ni2A. IT<3s 5^ra, co 2coKpare?;
212. Ovrcos, o)? peytcrroy tG>v KaK&v TvyyavtL ov to

abiKtlv.
nX2A. *H yap tovto p.yicrT0v; ov to dStKetcrflai /xettfor; 10
2X2. "H/aara ye.

ni2A. 2u dpa fiovXoto &v abiKelcrOat. pJdkkov rj abiKeTv;
2X2. BovkoLp.rjv p.ev av eycoye ovbirepa' et 5' avayKaiov etr/ C
abiKtiv r) abiKticrdai, kkoip.r\v b\v pJakkov abiKeio-Qai, r\ ab\.Ktiv.
nX2A. 2v apa Tvpavveiv ovk av biato;

2X2. Ovk, et t6 Tvpavvelv ye Ae'yets dVep eyco.
nX2A. 'AAA' eycoye tovto Ae'yco cnrep dprt, eeti>at eV r?/ 5
7roAei, 6 av boKi) avrto, 7roieti> tovto, Kal aTTOKTfLVVVTL Kal

KJ3dkkovTL Kal irdvra irpaTTovTL Kard ttjv avrov boav.
9
2X2. X2 /jtajcdpte, epot) bi] kiyovTos rto Adycp ZirLkafiov.
et ydp eyco eV ayopa Trkr)6ovcrr\ kaficov vtto p.dkrjs cyêt- d
plbLov Ae'yotpt 71730? cre ort "*X2 n<SAe, e/xot bvvap-is tls Kal
rvpavvls 6avp.acria dpTL Trpocryiyovev kdv ydp dpa ep.ot
borj TLvd tovtcovI tg>v dv6pa>TTtov cov o~v opqs ai)TLKa pdAa
beiv TedvdvaL, refon/cfet ovtos bv dv bo^rj' Kav TLva bo^rj pot 5
ttjs K<pakr}s avT&v KarayijvaL bdv, Kareaytos lcrrat avriKa
b 2 ye F Stobaeus : 8e BTP b5 supra 5 in B ndvv tiev oZv

manus recentissima b 10 ^] suprascr. ei B2 bri ye BTP
Stobaeus ydp : F c
om. Simplicius (habet Stobaeus)
1 ttv eyarye :
av om. P ovSerepa B T P F Stobaeus ovSerepov Simplicius :
avayicaiov etrj B T P F Stobaeus avdyKt] Simplicius : C 2 4) aStKe7v

secl. Cobet (habet Stobaeus) c 7 irdvTa B T P iravrax&s F :
d3 post &pa add. F (om. mox 86t) pr. F)

itpoo-yevt\rai d 4 rov-
4/j.ol
rwvl B T P rovruv F
: d 5 redvfjêi B T P redvfiêrat F et erai :
suprascr. P d 6 avrwv B T F avrbv P Karayrjvai scripsi

:
Kareayrjvat B T W
F Kareayevat recc.
:
19*
46gd nAAT12N02
ixdka, kclv doLixdriov 8tecrxitr0at, bLecryj.o-p.ivov eVrat^>urco
e p-iya eycb bvvap.aL ev rr/8e rfj 7ro'Aet," et ovv diTLa-TovvTL trot
8et<fatpt to eyyeLpibLov, tcrcos b\v et7rots tScou ort "'12 2co-
Kpares, ovrco p.ev Trdvres av p-iya bvvaLVTo, enel Kav ZfxTrpr)-
crdeir} ot/cta tovtio rco rpoVco rjvTLvd crot 8okoi, Kat ra ye
5 'Adrjvaicov veiopta Kat at rptr/pets Kat ra 7rAota irdvra Kal tcl
Sr/pdtrta Kat ra !8ta*" dAA' ovk dpa tovt eo-TLV to p.iya
bvvaadaL, to iroLelv a Sokci avrco* r) Sokci trot;.

II12A. Ov brjra ovtu> ye.
v
470 212. Exets ovv et7rety 81' ort p.ip.<pr) rr)v TOLavrqv
bvvap.Lv;
I1I2A. "Eycoye.
212. Tt' br); Aeye.
5 II12A. "Ort avayKalov tov ovtco 7rpdrroi>ra ij}p.LOvo-6ai
ecrrtv.
212. Td 8e ij)p.Lovo-6aL ov KaKOv;

ni2A. nd ye.
212. Ovkow, co 6avp.d<TL, [rd p.iya bvvao-6ai\ 7rdAu> av

10 crot cpatverat, edy pey irpaTTovTL a 8oKet e7rr)rat rd axpeAi-
p,cos TTpdrrtLV, dyadov re eii>ai, Kat roCro, cos Zolkcv, Zo-tIv
t6 p.iya bvvacrdaL' et 8e p?7, KaKoi> Kat crpiKpoy 8wacr0at.
b <TKe^r(op.eda 8e Kat ro'8e' dAAo rt 6p.oXoyovp.ev eviore p.ev
dp.Lvov eti>at raura 7roteiV a z>w8t) ekiyop.ev, diroKTeLVVvaL re

Kat eekavveLv dv6p<aTtovs Kal dcpaipeicrtâi xpi)p.aTa, eviore
e ov;
5 I112A. Yldvv ye.

212. TotJro /xei> 877, <as eWe, Kat 7rapd trou Kat 7rap'
ep.ov djuoAoyetrat.
II12A. Nat.
e 4 ^vtjj/cJ <rot Soko? F ^tjv' &v aoi Soko7 B T ^vriv &v troi 80/cfj P
: :
(sed suprascr. oj) a 1 olv B T P om. F : a 5 rbv ovrw\ rovro

Olympiodorus a 9 rb fieya Svvaadcu secl. Thompson a 12 post-
erius Svvao-0ai non legisse videtur Olympiodorus : secl. Thompson
bi SUTP: 8), F
:
TOPriAS 47ob
2X2. Ylore ovv <rv <pr)s &p.Lvov ilvai ravra ttolclv; ei7rc -
riva opov opify. 10
IIX2A. 2i) p.\v ovv, Si 2coK/>ares, airoKpivai [ravrb] rovro.
2X2. 'Eycb p.V roivvv <pr]p.i, o) FIcoAe, tl crot irap' kp.ov C

ijbLOV tCTTLV CLKOVfLV, OTaV p.tV SlKatCOS TLS TaVTa 7TOlf/,
ap.eivov LvaL, orav 8e dStKcos, kclklov.

ITX2A. Xakcirov ye' cre eAe'yat, cb 2coK/)ares' dAA' ov\l
kolv irals cre eAe'yetei> otl ovk dkr]$rj Ae'yets; 5
2X2. noAAr/y apa eyco rco 7rat8t \apLV eco, tcrr/iJ 8e Kat
crot, kdv /xe eAe'yr/s *ai airakka^rjs qbkvapias. dAAd p.r)
Ka/xr/s <pi\ov avbpa eveoyercoi>, dAA' eAeyê.

I7X2A. 'AAAd /ur/i>, co 2coKoares, oij8e'r ye' cre 8et 7raAaiois
irpdyp.ao-LV eAeyxety rd yap ex#es Kat irp<ar]V ycyovora ravra d

tKavd cre eeAe'y<fat ecrri^ Kat d7ro8etat cbs 7roAAot dSiKowres
av6pu)TTOL vbaip.ovs etcrti/.
2X2. Tct 7rota raura;

I7X2A. 'ApxÂaoy brjTrov tovtov tov UepbiKKov opqs 5
dpypvra MaKtbovias;
2X2. Et 8e //?/, dAA' aKOvco ye.
nX2A. Eibaip.(v ovv <tol 8oKet etmi r) clOXlos;
2X2. Oijk otSa, ) ricoAe* ov ydp tto) avyyiyova rco dvbpi.
I1X2A. Tt 8e'; cruyyei^/xeros &v yvoirjs, dAAcos 8e avrodev e

ov yiyycocrKeis ort ev8at/xoi>et;
2X2. Md At' ov bijra.
I1X2A. AijXov 8r/, 2) 2coKpares, ort ovbe rbv p.kyav /3acriAe'a
yiyycoo-Kcty <pi]<rLS vbaip.ova ovra. 5
2X2. Kat dXrjdr) ye epco* ov ydp oT8a 7rat8eias O7rcos eêt /
'
Kat bLKaLoo~vvr]s.
I1X2A. Tt 8e'; ey rovrcp 77 7racra zvbaLp.ovia ecrrtV;
b9 ir<$T F (poi/ suprascr. f ) : itdrepov BTP ab (prjs B T P f

<prjs <tv F ravra B T P ravrb rodro F
: fo 1 1 ravrb secl. ci.
Heindorf c 1 /uei/ roivvv T P F fi4vrot vvv : B c2 ô-n' anovtiv
BTP: F C4 oiixiBTPf: ou F C6
TPF : WB
aicoveiv tariv
(suprascr. r\ B :
y
d 1 e X 0 BTP Stobaeus x F :
Jfo-rj'
:
470 e IIAAT&NOS
212. "ls ye eyco keyto, 2> rTcoAe* tov p.ev yap Kakbv nal
10 dyadbv avbpa nal yvvaina evbaip.ova etvai cpripi, rov oe
dbiKov Kal TTOvripbv adktov.
471 ni2A. "A0Atos dpa ovtos ecmv 6 'Apx^kaos Kara tov
crbv koyov;
212. Enrep ye, co cptAe, ahiKOs.
1112A. 'AAAa p,ev br) thSs ovk cioikos; a> ye itpocrrjKe p.ev
5 r?)s a-pXV s ovbev rjv vvv eêt, ofrt eK yuz>atKos 17 ?ji> cWA??
'AA/cerou tov YiepbiKKOV dbekcpov, Kal Kard p.ev to bUatov
bovkos rjv 'AAxeVou, Kat et efiovkeTO rd bUaia Ttoielv, ebov-
kevev av 'AAKer?? Kat tjv evbaipLcav Kara tw croy Adyor.
w be 6avp.acri(i)s cbs aOkios yeyovev, ette\ rd peytcrra ?}8i-
b Kr\Kzv os ye nrpStTov p,ev tovtov avTov tov becntoTrjv Kcii
delov p,eTaTtep,y\rdp.evos cos d7ro8cocrcoi' r?)y apyr)v rjv YlepbiKKas

avTov dcpetAero, evicras Kal KaTap.eOvcras avTov re Kat roz>
?5di> aTjrou 'Akeavbpov, dve^nbv avTov, crxebbv t/AikicoVtjz',
5 epLftakobv ets ap.aav, vvKTcop eayaycoz> ditecrcpaêv re Kat
r\cpdvLcrev dp.cpoTepovs. kcu ravra d8tK??cras ekaOev eavTov

d0Aicoraros yevop.evos Kal ov /xerepeA??crez> avrco, dAA' oAtyoy
C vcrTepov tov abekcpov, tov yvr\criov tov WepbiKKov vov, ttaiba
a>s e7rrerr7, ov r) apxj] eyiyvero Kara to bUatov, ovk e/3ou-

kr]dr\ evbaip.oiv yevecrdat SiKatcos eK0pe\j/as Ka\ dttobovs Tr)v
apxrjv eKetycp, dAA' ets cppeap efxjSakcbv Kal ditottvifcas rrpbs

5 Ti]v p.r)Tepa avTov KkeottaTpav XV VCL tyv 8tcoKoz'ra ep,itecreiv
Kcti dttoOaveiv. ToiyapToi vvv, aTe p,eyicrTa t}8ik??kcos rcoy
ev MaKeboviq, dtÂtcoraroV ecrriy 7rdyrcoi' MaKe8oVcoy, dAA
o?3k evbaiixovecrTaTos, Kal tcrco? ecrrtz' ocrrts 'Adrjvaicov airo crov
d dp^dpievos beair hv akkos bcrTicrovv MaKebovo)V yevecrdai

p.dkkov rj 'Apxekaos.
e 10 B T P F ev5ai/j.ovas Stobaeus
ev$a([xoi>a : a 3 ye B T P f
om. F a4 juei/BTPF: ^v al. Olympiodorus a8 ^BTP:
^vavF & 9 &BTP: om. F iirel B T P &rM) F bi/te^ :
tovtov B T F toCtoj/ ^tej/ P

: b 4 <rxeo~bv B T P Kal ffx^bv F :
C 1 toO F tov B T P C 2 eitTeTT} F e^TaeT^ B T eirTaeTTj P

W
: : :
d 1 8e'|aJT' T P F 8e{atT' B (e suprascr. b)

: SA\oy B F &\Accs T :
TOPriAS 47id
S12. Kai kclt apyjxs t&v koyo)V, co llcoAe, eycoye' cre
iirr\vzo-a ort pot SoKets eu 7rpos t?V pr]TopLK.r]v 7re7rat8ei;cr0at,
tov 8e 5taAe'yeo-0ai rip.ekrjKivac Kal vvv akko rt ovtos iaTLV 5
6 Aoyos, (o jue Kat ay 7rats eeAe'yete, Kat eyco u7ro croS yfip,
cbs o-u otet, eeArjAeypat rovrw rco Aoyco, cpdo-Koiv tov dcjt-
icowra ouk eibaip.ova dvai; irodtv, coyafle'; kol p.r)v oibiv ye'
croi tovtcov 6p.okoy) 3>v o~v cprjs.
FIX2A. Oi yap et9e'Aets, e7ret 8oKet ye' crot tos eyco Ae'yco. e
SX2. *ll //aKapte, prrropuccos ydp pe e7rtxetpeis eAeyxetr,
coo-7rep 01 e*> rots 8tKacrrripiois i)yovp.evoi eAe'yxety. Kat ydp
eKet ot erepot rovs iripovs boKovaiv ikiyytLV, e7ret8ay rcor
koyoov ojv av Aeycotn p.dpTvpas irokkovs irapix^VTaL Kat 5
(vhoKip.ovs, 6 Se TavavTia kiycov eVa rwd 7rapex??Tai ?r
p.r)hiva. ovtos be 6 eAeyxos ovbevos dto's io-TLv irpbs Tr)v
akrjOeiav iviore yap av Kat Kara\//û8oLtaprrjprrt9eirr tls vtto 472

7roAA(3i> Kat OKOwrcoi> etrat rt. Kai w 7rept cou cn/ Aeyets
dAiyov crot 7rdi>res o-vp(pr]crovo-LV raurd 'AO-qvaZoL Kal ol ivoL,
iav ftovkr] Kar ip.ov p.aprvpas- Trapao-yJ(r0aL cos ovk akr]0f]

Aeyco* papTvpr]crovo-L ctol, iav pxv /3ouArr, NtKtas 6 NtKrr- 5
pdrov Kat ot dSeAcpot p.er' avrov, &v 61 Tphrobes ol e<pe<fr/s
ecrrcore'? eicru> iv rco Atowcrico, iav 8e /3orJArr, ' AptcrroKpdrrrs
6 SKeAAtou, ou aS eorti> eV Ilrjtfiov rorjro ro KaAdy avd0r]p.a, b

ây 8e fiovkr], r) IIcpLKkiovs 0A17 otKta 17 dAAry cruyyeVeta
rjvTLva av fiovkr] tG>v iv0a.be iKkiaa0aL. dAA' eyco crot ety
coy ov\ opoAoyco* ov ydp p,e crv dyayKaêts, dkka \j/evbo-
p.dpTvpas TTokkovs Kar' ip.ov i;apao-y6p.tvos eTrtxetpets iK/3dk- 5
Aetz> p;e eK rr^s oiaCas kol tov akr]0ovs. eyco 8e av pr; o-e
avroy eVa ovTa p.dprvpa Trapdcryu>p.aL 6p.okoyovvTa irepl <5v
Ae'yco, oibkv otctat dior Ao'you p.ot Tr7repdv0aL irepl &v av
d 3 twv \6ywv, 2> B T P S> T\S>\e, ru>v \6yuv F Olympiodorus

riaiXe :
<re B T P f om. F
: d 4 iirrfveaa addubitant Cobet Schanz 5o/cf?s]
fort. iSuKtts Thompson ds rov 8e BTF ovSi P
'
d7 0U1 :
BTP : 0U1 flvai F e 4 iicu 01 B T F iKuvot P bi irvdiov :
F (cf. Thuc. vi. 54. 7, C. I. A. i. 189) : 7rt/t?or BT W f b3 VfleSSe
BTF : &\\wv P
472C I7AATi2N02
C fjpuv 6 koyos fp
ot/xat 8e ovbt <tol, kdv pvq eyco troi paprupco ets
obv p.6vos, tovs 8' dAAous Ttdvras tovtovs \aCpcLV eas. ecrrti>
p,V OVV OVTOS TIS TpOTTOS iktyxpv, b)S <TV T6 oUi Kol dkkoi
TrokkoC' <ttlv be nal akkos, ov iyco av otpai. 7rapa/3a-
5 AoVres ovv ttap akkr\kovs o-Kex/fcopefla e? ri Sioicrovcru; dAAr/-
Acoy. Kat yap koX Tvyyavti itcpl <%v dp.<pL<rfir\Tovp.v ov itdvv

crptKpd ovra, dkkd a^bov rt raCra 7rept cov etcieVai re
KdAAtcrroy p.r) etSeVat re atcrxlOTOl' rd ydp Kpdkaiov avrcov
Zcttlv r) yLyv<ao-KLV r] ayvoalv 6<ttls re vbaip.cov i<rrlv ko.1
d ocrrts pvt], avTLKa Ttpcorov, Ttepl ov vvv 6 koyos icrTLV, ctv
r)yr) dtov re etmi paKapioi dvbpa abLKOvvrd re Kat abLKOv

ovTa, efore/) 'Apxe'Aaoi> dbLKOv piev r)yr) etvat, vbaip.ova Se.
dAAo rt o)? ovrco <rov vop.iiftVTOs 8uwocop.e#a;
5 JJilA. Yldvv ye.

212. 'Eyco bi cprrpi abvvarov. %v p.\v tovtl d/x<ptcr/3T7-
Tovp.ev. eterr dbLK&v Se br) vbaip.cov ecrrat dp\ dv Tvy\dvij

bUrjs re /cat rt/xcootas;
r
ITflA. 'H/ciard ye, e7ret otfrco y' di> dflAtcoraros etrr.
e 212. 'AAA' idv dpa p.r) Tvyyjxvri 8iktjs 6 abLKcav, /card tov
<tov koyov tvbaip.cov ecrrat;
ni2A. <&r]p.i.
212. Kard de' ye rr/i ip.r)v boav, cu ricoAe, 6 dStKcoy re
5 Kai 6 dSiKos Ttdvrcas /xey ddkios, d#Atcorepos /ueVrot edz> /xt)
8t8co 8iKr/y /xr?8e Tvyxdvrj rt/xcoptas dStKcoy, r/rroy 6e d0Atos

edv StScp oYkt/v Kat Tvyxdvr) Sikt/s VTtb decov re Kat dvOpcoitcov.
473 ni2A. "ATOitd ye, co 2coKpares, e7rtxetpets Aeyetr.

2f2. rTetpdcro/xat 8e' ye Kat ae TtoLr)<raL, co eratpe, Tavrd
e/xot Ae'yety cpCkov ydp ae r)yovp.aL. vvv /xey ovv d otacpe-
03 tijBTP: t(ji!F c 4 yo<> oS B T P o? y& F wapo-

W
:
fia.\6vTesF iropaAajSoVTcj B T
: 06 tal ôp koI F ko! 70^ :
BTP d 4 0A.A0 ti F aAA' Stj B T P dAA' 8tj ^ rec. b

: 8<o- :
vodfieda B T P Siovoov/tefla F
: 64 ytBTP: om. F 65 7ra'-
Ttes F Stobaeus airdvTuv B T P
: /xevToi F Stobaeus /xev toIvvv :
BTP e 7 t koI B T P nal F avOpdirwv B T P *' d^pajTro!'

: :
F Stobaeus
:
TOPriAS 473a
p6fX(0a TO.VT k<TTlV <Tk6iT1 b\ KoX <TV. (LTTOV eyCO TTOV V
tois tixTTpoo-Qtv to abiKtiv tov dStKetcrtfat k6kiov tlvai. 5
nX2A. Ylavv ye.
2X2. 2u 8e to abiKeicrOai.
ni2A. Nat.
2X2. Kat rot/s abiKovvTas aOkiovs ecpr/v zlvai eyco, Kat
kr]kzyyOr]v vtto ctov. *
ni2A. Nat p.a Ata.

2X2. 'X2s (tv ye otet, a IlcoAe. b
FIX2A. 'AAr/fl?/ ye oto'/xevos.
212. "Icrcos. crt/ 8e' ye vbaipi.ovas av tovs abiKovvTas, iav

p,?/ bib&crt. bUrjv.
ni2A. Ylavv ]xkv ovv. 5
212. 'Eya> 8e' ye avroi;? dflAicordrovs <p?/p.i, tovs 8e

bibovras bUr]v tjttov. /3ovAet Kat tovto eAe'yxeu>;
11X2A. 'AAA' ert rotrr' exetVou yakeirtoTepov eo-rir, ct>
2coKpares, eeAe'yat.
2X2. Ov S^^/ra, co EIcoAe, dAA' dSwaroy rd ydp akrjOts io
ovSeVore eAe'yxerat.
nX2A. TIcos Aeyets; edu dStKcoi/ avOpmiros kr]<pOf] Tvpav-
vibi imfiovkevoiv, Kal A?/cp0eis crrpe/3Acorat Kat (KTipLvqTat, C
Kat rovs 6<f>0akpLOvs eKKOTjrat, Kat dAAas 7roAAds Kat peydAas
Kat 7rayro8a7rds Aco/3as avros re Aco/3?/0eis Kal tovs avrov
(TTibuv iralbds re Kat yvvolKa to icryaxov ava<rTavp<oOf] ?/
KaTa\LTT<nOr], ovtos evSatpoi>e'crrepos earai t/ edy bia<pvy<ov 5
Tvpavvos KaTaarfj Kal apyuiv eV r?/ 7ro'Aei 8ta/3icp Troicoy ort
dz> (3ovkr]Tai, ?/Acords coy Kat evSatpoinôpeyos V7rd rcoy
7roAtrcoy Kai rcoy dAAcoy eVcoy; raura Ae'yets d8vraroi> etyai d

eêAeyxetr;
a io inkfyx8vv virb aov BTP : ty\(y6r)s F (suprascr. av uirb crot/ f):
^rjA.7X 0T? <ra / " 7ro *" *

' b i 7 F om. B T P : b 3 firws revera
Socrati tribuit B (sed add. quoque :) Polo vulgo continuant
: aZ
tovs T P aiirovs B (sed accentum super ai> add. rec. b) F
: b 6 8e
ye F 8e B T P
: b 12 clSikwv secl. Dobree C 4 ywaiica B T P
yvvaiKas F C5 fvSat/xovfO-Tfpos F : vSat/itoveVTaTos BTP
473 d IlAATilNOS
212. MopjxoXvTTj] av, co yevvaie IlcoAe, nal ovk ekey\eLS'
aprt 8e ep-aprvpov. opco? be vir6p.vr)o~6v p,e apiLKpov. eav
5 dStKcos e7rt/3ouAetW Tvpavvibi, et7res;
IK2A. "Eycoye.
212. EvSaipotveVrepos /j,ev tolwv ovberroTe ecrrat ovbe-
Tepos avrGiV, oiJre 6 KaTevpyaa-p.evos Tr)v rvpavviba dbUcos

ovre 6 btbovs biKrjv bvoiv ydp ddkioLV evbaLpLOvea-repos p.ev
e ovk av elrj dtJAtcorepos /xeVrot 6 bLacpevycov koI TVpavvevcras.
tl tovto, 3) IlcoAe; yeAas; dkko av tovto elbos ekeyxpv

ko~TW, eneLbdv tls tl elirr], Karayekav, ekeyyeLV Se ju.r/;
ITX2A. Ovk otet efeAr/Aeyxtfat, a> 2coKpare?, orai; rotavra
5 Ae'y?7? a orjSetS' ay c/>r/creiez> avOpunrcov; eirel eporj rtz>a rowcoin.

212. '12 IlcoAe, ovk et/xt rcozv 7roAtrtKcoi>, Kat trepvaL j3ov-
keveLV kax<*>v, eireLbr) r/ qbvkr) eTrpvrdveve koX eSet /xe e7rt-
474 "j/rrqbiCeLV, ye'Acora TTapL\ov kol ovk r)TTLo-Tap.r}v errL^j/rrcpiCeLV.
/xr/ ovv /xr/Se zvw /xe Kekeve eVn//r/c/>ieiiv rovs irapovTas, dAA'
et /zr) eêts rorjrco/v /3eArtco ekeyyov, oirep vvvbr) eyco ekeyov,
epot ez> rcp /xepet 7rapdSos, Kat 7retpacrai rorj eAe'yxoi> otorv eyco
5 otpat Set/v etzvat. eyco ycip cor cW Ae'yco eVa fxev TTapacryecrdaL
p.dpTvpa eTTLCTTapLaL, avrbv 7Tpbs ov av pot 6 Ao'yos -fj,
tovs be
7roAAous eco yaipeLV, Kat eva eVt\//r/c/>i(êii> e7rttrrapai, rots 8e
b 7roAAot? or!>8e StaAeyo/xat. opa oS^ et efeAr/creis erv rcp pepet

StSotvat ekeyyov dTTOKpLv6p.evos tcl epcorcopem. eyco yap br)
otp,at Kat epe Kat cre kol tovs dkkovs avdpuirovs to abiKelv
tov abiKelcrOaL KaKLOV r)yelo-0aL kol to pr) 8toVai 8tKr/y tov
5 bLbovai.
ni2A. 'Eyco 8e ye ovt epie ovt dkkov dvt9pco7rcoy ovbeva.
enel crv 8e'ât' dv p.dkkov d8tKetcrt9ai r/ dStKety;
d.9 SiSovs Si/crjv F : SjSous BTP : Si/ctji' Sovs H. Schmidt ei Sia-

(pevyaiv BT WF : Siacpvywv Vind. 21 rvpavv{\ffas F e 2 tovto
av aAAo F e?Soj toCto P e 6 $ao-i\ivav P a 1 %)i-iaTap.t\v
ini^/r}<piCeiv'] Tjovvd/xriv 4-Ti\pTj<t>i(Tai Athenaeus a 1 post 4-rvpT)<pi(eiv
add. tovs irap6vTas F a3 exets PF :
x?' s ^ "^ f\eyov 4yd> P
a5 5e?i/ BTPf : om. F fiev] ixovov Cobet a6 avTov} ovtov
tov Cobet b 6 oAAoj/ B P aWoov T F :
.
TOPriAS 474b
2X2. Kat crv y dv nal ol dkkoL Trdvres.

FIX2A. IToAAoi] ye 5et, dAA' orjr' eyco orjre cri/ ovt dkkos
ovbeis. IO
2212. Ovkovv cnroKpLvfj; C

nX2A. ITdrrj p.ev ovv Kal yap eTTL0vp.<2 elbevaL otl ttot
epels.
2X2. Ae'ye 8r/ juot, ty' etoT/y, uxnrep av et e apxrjs o~e
rjpu>T(tiV' TroTtpov boKH ctol, 2) ITcoAe, kolklov etvai, to 5
d8i/ceiy ^ rd d5iKetcrc9ai; TTX2A. Td d5iKercrc9ai e//.otye.
2X2. Tt 8e 8r/; ato"xioi> iroTepov t6 dStKeiV r/ rd d8tKetcr#at;

a-noKpivov. 11X2A. To abiKeXv 2X2. Ovkovv Kal kclklov,
elirep alo-xLov. EIX2A. "H/ao-rd ye 2X2. Mav0dvo)' ov

Tavrbv fjyfj crv, cos eoLKas, Kakov re Kat dyadov Kal KaKOV d
Kat alcryjiov. I1X2A. Ov brJTa.
2X2. Tt 5e Tobe; rd KaAd 7rdyra, olov kol crcojuara koi
Xpdop.aTa Kal cryjip.aTa koX cpeovds Kal eirLTribevp.aTa, els
ovbev aTTofikeTTa>v Kakels eKacrTOTe Kakd; olov irp&Tov Ta 5

o-coju.ara tcl Kakd ovyl r/rot Kard Ti]v \peiav Aeyets KaAd
etrat, TTpos 6 dv eKacrrov \pr\crLpov r\, Trpbs tovto, r/ Kard
rjbovqv nva, edv ev rco 0ecopel<r0aL yaipeLV t 1 $ tovs 0eo>-
povvTas; eyeLS tl eKTos tovtcov keyeLV Trepl au>p.aTOS Kak-

kovs; riX2A. Ovk eyo). 2X2. OrjKow Kai raAAa 7rdyra e
ovtgo koX cryj>]p:aTa Kal \p(>p.aTa r/ 8td rjbovrjv TLva r/ 8td
oxpekiav r) cV ap.aboTepa Kakd irpocrayopeveLs; I1X2A.
"Eyooye. 2X2. Ov Kal rds 0cords Kat rd Kard Ti)V p.ov<JLKi)V
Trdvra oxravToos; TTX2A. Nat. 2X2. Kat p.r)v rd ye Kard 5
tovs vop.ovs Kal rd eirLTr)bevp.aTa ov br\-!rov Iktos tovtcov

ecrriv, rd KaAd, tov r) coc/jeAt/xa etmt r/ r)bea r) dju.c/joVepa.
ITX2A. Ovk e/xotye boKet. 2X2. Ovkovv Kal rh t&v /uac9rj- 475
d I kcl\ Ka.Kbi' B F Kaicbi> TW d 4 Kal axtnaTa B T P om. F

: :
d6Ta/caAaBTPf Ka\aF d8eVBTP:om.F

: efwpe?<r6ai B
(sed ras. ante et post : aliquid suprascr. rec. b) e 2 Kal xp<&-
fiara Kal <rxT)M aTa f e 5 ir&vra B T
P airavra F : 7 BTP :
T F e 7 Tcfc Ka\a re vera B PF T rov t) uKpeMfxa WF: ^ w<p4-

\ifna B : rov w<pi\ijxa T a 1 fj.adr]fidrwv T WF : fiadr\rwv B
475 a 11AATX2N02
fxaTcov nakkos (ocravTtos; I1X2A. Yldvv ye* nal na\m ye
vvv dpiCjf, ft) 2a>Koares, r)bovf) re kol dyaOSt 6pL(pp.tvo$ to
Kakov. 2X2. Ovkovv t6 alo-\pbv t<2 eVai>rta>, Kvttt\ re Kat
5 KaKa>; HX2A. 'ArdyKrj. 2X2. "Oray apa bvolv Kakolv Od-
Tcpov KakXiov r) ra> erepa) tovtolv r) ap.<poTpois xnrcp-
fj,
fiaWov kclWlov Zo~tlv, tjtol rjbovfj r) axpeAta r) dpoborepots.
ITX2A. Yldvv ye. 212. Kat orav 8e 8r/ ouoty ato-xpoti; ro
b tTepov aX(ryj,ov t), ?/rot Av7rr7 17 KaKai v-nepfiaXXov aXcryjov
eo-rat* r) ovk dvdyKr\; IlX2A. Nat.

2X2. 4>e'pe 877, irm eAeyero vvvbi] 7rept tov dotKetv Kat
d8tKeio-0ai; ovk eAeye? ro /uei> dSiKeio-0ai Kauov etrai, ro
5 8e dStKety aXcryjov; 17X2 A.

v
EAeyoi\ 212. Ovkow et7rep
alo-yjov to dbLKtiv tov dStKeio-flai, ?/roi XvTrrjpoTepov Io~tlv

kol \virr\ virepPdWov aXcryLov av etrj 17 KaKw r) d/ix</>ore'pois;
ov Kat tovto dvdyKr); I7X2A. T\G>s yap ov; 212. YlpGtTov
C piev br) aKe\jf(op.eOa, apa Av7T7i v7rep/3dAAet t6 dotKeu' tov

d8iKeto-0ai, Kat dAyouo-t ixdWov 01 dStKowres r) ol dotKov-
pavoL; IIX2A. Ovbap.Gs, 2 2a>Kpares, tovto ye. 2X2. Oiik

dpa kv-nii ye vtrepiyjiL. I1X2A. Ov brjra. Ovkow
2X2. et
5 p.r) X.VTT1I, d/u<pore'pots piev ovk dv ert v7rep/3dAAot. Ov I1X2A.

(paCveTaL 2X2. Ovkow tS> ere'pa> AetVerat. Nat. IIX2A.
2X2. Ta> KaKu>. nX2A. v
EoiKe*>. 2X2. Ovkow KaK<2 virep-
/3dAAov to dStKeiv KaKLOv av etr? tov d8iKeio-0at. ITX2A.

ArjXov brj otl.
v
d 2X2. AAAo rt ovv vtto piev tS>v tto\X<ov dvOp(oir(ov kol
,
vtto aov w/xoAoyetro t)lxlv h tQ> Zp.Trpoo-dtv xpdvio aXo-yj.ov
dvaL to dbLK&v tov dbLKtlcrOaL; TTX2A. Nat.2X2. Nvv

8e' ye k^klov k<pdvr). ITX2A.
v
EotKe. 2X2. Ae'âto hv ovv
5 av /uaAAoy to KaKLov koX to aXo-yjov dvrl tov tjttov; p.r)
a6 tovtoiv BTP : avroiv F a 7 ^ prius B T P % KalF :
a8SeS^BTPf:8)/F bi post xaicQ add. f) a/xQoTepois Hirschig

b3 4\tyeT0 PF : iAtyeTO TiBTW b 4 KaKiov B P F t Kanhv T :
C2 apyovffi C 4 76 in ras. B
P d 2 ifnrpooQev B T F irp&ffdtv : P
Xpovcp] \6ycp Findeisen secl. ci. Cron d 5 cri supra versum
:
P
d 5 alffxiov F alo~xpbv B T : W
tov P tov rb B T f tovto F : :

TOPriAS 475d
okvcl cnroKpCvacrOai, co rTcoAe' ovbev yap j3kaj3i]crr]' akka

yevvaCws ru Ao'yo> cocnrep tarpai irap4\o)v cnroKpCvov, Kal ?/
(padi r) pi] ni2A. 'AAA'

a epcorco. ovk av 8eatp.T>i>, co 2co- e
Kpares. "AAAos 212. oe tls dvdpo)7ro)v; ni2A. Ou /xot
boKtl Kara ye tov koyov. tovtov 2X2. 'AAt70?7 dpa eya>
eAeyor, ort ovt av eya> ovt av crv ovr aAAos ovoets avapo)-
iro)v 8e'atr' av p.dkkov abiKCLV r) dbLKelcrOaL' kAklov yap 5
TvyyavtL ov. IT12A. <J>au>erat.
212. 'Opas ovv,. <o n<2Ae, 6 eAeyxos irapa tov ikey\ov
TTapa/3akk6pLVos otl oibev eotKey, akka crol pkv ol aAAot
Trdvres 6/xoAoyoi;crii> irki]v epov, epot 8e crv eâp/cets els a>v
p.6vos fcat opokoy&v Kal paprvpS>v, Kal eya> ae p.6vov (TTL^/rj- 47^
cpL^tov tovs akkovs eco ya'LP* lv ' KaL tovto pkv i)plv ovtcos
exera)" perd tovto Se 7rept ov to bevrtpov r)p(pcrj3r]TricrapV
a-/ce\â>//.e0a, to dbiKOvvTa 0180'yat bLKrjv apa piyLcnov tS>v
KaK&v kcrTLV, a>? crv coov, r) p.iL(pv to p.r) bibovat, cos av 5
eya> co/xrjy.
2/co7ra>juecâ 8e rT/Se* ro ot8wat 5t/cr>y /cat ro KoAdecn9at

8tKatcos dSiKotVra apa ro avr6 KaAets; Ili2A. "Eycoye.
212. "E^f ls ovv Ae'yeti> cos 01}^ Ta y* bUaia irdvra Kakd b
tcrTLV, Ka6
y
ocrov StKata; Kat biacrK\(rap.vos etire. ni2A.
'AAAd p,ot SoKet, co 2coKpares. 212. 2K07ret bi] Kat ro'5e*
apa et rts rt 7roiei, avayKt] tl etrat Kat iracr-ôv vtto tovtov

tov ttolovvtos; I1_2A. "E/xotye SoKet. 212. 'Apa rouro 5
7rdcrôy to ttolovv 7rotet, Kat tolovtov olov 7rotet to ttolovv;
Aeyco 8e rb TOLovbc et rts rv7rret, dvdyKr] tl TVTTTfcrdaL;
ni2A. 'AydyKrj. 212. Kat et acpobpa tvtttl r) Ta\v 6
TV1TT(*)V, OVTO) Kal TO TVTTTOpCVOV TVTTT0~daL; IT12A. Nat. C
212. TotoSroi' dpa irddos rco tvtttopAvm ecrrtr olov c\v to
d 6 airoKptveo-ea.i F 61 iBTPf: ii F ai iiriifaQifav

B TP: lvttyn<plfa BF
2
aa rohs BTP: rovs 5i F &3 ovF
Stobaeus t B T P
: rb B T F om. P a 5 ws ai B T P &s 7 av F
: :
b 2 olicaia B T P F ical dlicaia Stobaeus

: 8ia<rKt\pdiJ.fPos B T F Sij :
aKfipd/xtvos P b 4 irdo~xov B T P F irdo~x*iv Stobaeus b 7 t& :
roi6vSe B TP r6S( roi**** F: roi6v$t Stobaeus

:
476 c I7AATX2N02
TVTtrov 7rot.fi; 11X2 A. ndvv ye 2X2. Ovkovv nal et KaeL
tls, avdyKr] tl Kcieo-t?ai; I7X2A. YlG>s yap ov; 2X2. Kat et
5 crcpobpa ye Kaet ij akyetv>s, ovtoo Kdecrdat to Kaopevov w?

av to kclov Kar\; ITX2A. Udvv ye 2X2. Ovkovv kol et
TepveL rt, 6 avros koyos; Tep,veraL ydp tl. I1X2A. Nat.
2X2. Kat et p,eya ye r/ (3adb to Tp,i]pa r) akyetvov, tolov-
d tov Tp,r\p.a repyerat to Tep.vop.evov olov to Tepvov Tepvet;
ITX2A. <J>atWat 2X2. 2vkkr]j3br]v ot) opa et o/xoAoyet?, o
aprt eAeyoy, 7rept TrdvTutv, otov av TTotr) to ttolovv, tolovtov
to iido-yov Trdcryetv. ITX2A. 'AAA' 6/xoAoyto.
5 2X2. Tovtcov br) 6p,okoyovp,evu>v, to btKrjv btbovat iroTepov
Ttdo-yeLV tC ko-TLV r) TroteXv; nX2A. 'Aây/crj, co 2a>Kpares,
7TaCT)(tV. 2X2. OVKOVV V7TO TLVOS 7T0L0VVT0S,' ETX2A. IIcOS
yap ov; vtto ye tov Kokd(ovros 2X2. 'O oe 6p6G>s Ko\d(<ov
e bLKaCcos KoAaêt; 1IX2A. Nat. 2X2. AtKata ttol&v rj ov;
nX2A. Atxata. 2X2. Ovkovv 6 Koka(6pevos btKrrv btbovs
ouata Trao-xet; ITX2A. 4>atWai 2X2. Ta oe otKata ttov
KaAa d)jLtoAo'yrirat; ITX2A. Yldvv ye. 2X2. Tovtoov dpa 6
5 p.ev 7roiet KaAa, 6 oe Trdcrxet, 6 Koka(6pevos IIX2A. Nat.
477 2X2. 0?3ko?jz; efrrep KaAa, dyadd; r) yap r)bea r) wcpe-
Atwa nX2A. 'Ai>ayKT7 2X2. 'Ayafla dpa Trdcrxet 6 bU-qv
Siootjs; I7X2A. "EotKei; 2X2. 'X2cpeAetrat dpa; ITX2A.
Nat'.
5 2X2. *Apa rjvirep eya> v7Tokap.fidvo) rqv axpekCav; /3eA-

tlu>v rrjv ^rvxw yCyverat, et7rep btKaCcos KoAdfferat; I1X2A.
Eiko's ye 2X2. KaKtas dpa xj/vxrjs a7raAAdrrerat 6 bLK-qv
btbovs; ITX2A. Nat. 2X2. *Apa ovv tov p.eyCo-rov aTrak-
b kaTTeraL KaKov; <58e be crKOTret' ev \pr)p.aTix)V KaTao-Kevrj
dvdpd)7Tov KaKtav akkt]v tlvcl evopas r) TTevCav; I1X2A. Ovk,
akka. TrevCav. 2X2. Tt o' ev o-(ap.aros KaTao-Kevrj ; KaKLav
av (p7]o-aLS ao-deveLav eTvaL kol vocrov Kal atcr)(OS Kat rci
C7 tiTP: rl B F ns Stobaeus
: d 3 &j/ B T P Stobaeus &u :
ri F e 4 >fj.o\6yr]Tat B T P F dfioXoyeTrai Stobaeus

: a 5 /8f \-
riuv BP F Stobaeus f3e\rla> T
: b 4 ttv B T P F om. Stobaeus :
:
TOPriAS 477b
Totavra; ITX2A.
v
Eycoye. 2X2. Ovkovv Kal h yjfvxfj tsovry 5
piav fjyfi rwa etVat; nX2A. Tlcos yap ov; 2X2. TavTr)v
ovv ovk ahiKiav Kakels koX apLadCav ml beiXCav Kal ra
Toiavra; nX2A. Ylavv /xkv ovv. 2X2. Ovkovv xP r\il0 TC0V -
koI (rw//aTos Kal yf/v\rjs, TpLcov ovtcov, rpirras eipr/Kas irovr)- c

pCas, TrevCav, voo~ov, ahiKCav; FIX2A. Nat. 2X2. Tts ovv
tovtoov rcov itovr\pi,G>v ato-)(ioTrj; ov\ r) dStKia kol ovkkrj-
fihrjv r) rrjs \^t>x?/s irovrjpCa; I1X2A. Ylokv ye. 2X2. Et hr)
alo^xCa-Tr),
c
kol KaKCo-n); nX2A. Ylcos, oo 2coKpare?, Ae'yet?;j 5
2X2. X25t" det to ato~xio~Tov r/rot kviTr)v fJLeyCorqv
iraptxov r) /3Ad/3rji> r) djoKpdrepa aLcrxLCTTov ear> ex tcov

cbp,oAoyrjp.eVcoy kv r<3 (.[mpoo-Qzv. ITX2A. MdAtora. 2X2.
Alo-xiorov 8e ahiKCa Kal crvfxiTao-a \jrvxys itovqpCa vvvhr)
cojuoAdyrjrat 77/xiV; ITX2A. 'X^/xoAdyr/rat yap. 2X2. Ovkovv d
r*/ avLaporaTov eari Kat avCq VTTepfiaXkov atcrxLO-Tov tovtcov
eorlv r) /3Ad/3r/ r) dpgWepa;' ITX2A. 'AvdyKr/. 2X2. 'Ao'
ovv akytivoTepov Zcttlv tov Triveo-Qai kox k6)xvlv t6 ahLKov
(IvaL Kal aKoXacrTov Kal 8eiAw Kat afxaOrj; IIX2A. Owk 5
(piOLye SoKet, co 2coKpares, cltto tovtcov ye. 2X2. 'TirepcpvtL

r>i dpa cos fxtyakr) /3Ad/3rj Kat KaKco OavfxacrCco VTTpf3akkovo~a
raAAa r) Trjs \jfvxvs irovr)pCa ato-îo-rdy etrrt iravTcov, e7ret8r/ e
ovk dAyrjodvt ye, cos 6 crbs Adyoy. I7X2A. 4>au>erai.
2X2. 'AAAd fxrjv irov to ye /xeyto-rr/ /3Ad/3r/ virepfSakkov

\1iyL0~T0v h\v KaKov etr/ rcoV ovtlov. IIX2A. Nat. 2X2.
C
H
dSiKta apa Kal r) aKokao-Ca Kat r) dAArj ^rvxV s irovi)pCa 5
\xkyLo-Tov rcoV ovtcov KaKov cttlv; E[X2A. 4>atVerat.
b 5 reovr\piav rtyu B T P F fiyrj rrovr\piav Stobaeus C 2 oZv B T

:
P F om. Stobaeus
: C 3 ox>x V B T P Stobaeus ovxl F C4 S^ :
B T P Stobaeus 8e F C 7 &/io\oyrififva>v B T P F dfio\oyovfj.eva>v

: :
Stobaeus d.2 ^F: rJBTP: et Stobaeus aviap6rarov F t

aviapdrarov B T P Stobaeus iari /cot F Stobaeus icrrtv B P et :
compendio T aKaxiarov rovruv iarlv secl. Dobree (habet Stobaeus)

d3 $\dt3ri F Stobaeus : f3\di3r) f) \xnrr) BTP afi<p6repa BTPF
Stobaeus : afKporepois Hirschig ea &>s B T P : F
&>s -brifflv <pai-
verai BTPF : oftrws (paiverai Stobaeus e 6 Kan6v BTFP : kok&v
Stobaeus
:
477 e ITAATX2N02
212. Tts ovv T^xvrj itevias d7raAAdrret; ov XPVH- 7 ''- -
(TTiKr\; ITX2A. Nat. 212. Tts 8e vocrov; ovk laTpiKrj;

478 ITX2A. 'Ai/dyK??. 2X2. Tts 8e Trovrjpias Kat doiKtaj; et p.rj
ovrcos evTTopets, <38e o-K07rer ttoZ ayop.ev koX irapa rivas

tovs Kap.vovTa$ ra. crcopMTa; ITX2A. Uapa tovs larpovs, co
2coKpares. 2X2. IT01 8e tovs abiKovvTas xat tovs a.Ko\a-

5 crTaivovTas; ITX2A. ITapd tovs btKacrTas Aeyets; 2X2. Ov-
kovv bUrjv bcacrovras; ITX2A. <>rjp.i. 2X2. *Ap' ovv ov
biKatocrvvr\ tiv\ xpaipLtvoi. Ko\a<pvcriv ol opOcos koX&ovtS ;
nX2A. Arjkov bij. 2X2. Xp7?/xariaTiK?) p.ev apa Tttvias aTrak-
b Adrret, tarpiK?) 8e vocrov, bUrj 8e aKoAao-tas' Kat dStKia?.
ITX2A. 4>aii>erai.
2X2. Tt ovv tovtcov KaAAtcrroy eartr [cov Aeyets];
ITX2A. Tivoov Aeyets; 2X2. Xp??/Aarto-rtK?7S, tarptKT/s, biKtjs.
5 ITX2A. IToAv Stacpepei, 00 2coKpares, 77 8ik?j. 2X2. Ovkovv

av rjToi. f)bovr)v TrXeicrTrjV 7rotet 17 axpeAtW ?*/ dpxpoTepa, elirep
KdAAtcrroV ecmv; ITX2A. Nat 2X2. *Ap' ovv to iarpeve-
o-0ai rjbv kcrTiv, koX yaipovcriv ol laTpevop.evoi; ITX2A. Ovk
epotye 8oKet. 2X2. 'AAA' c\cpekipov ye. ?/ ydp; ITX2A.
C Na. 2X2. MeydAou yap KaKov a7raAAdrrerat, coore Xvcri-
reAet virop.elvai rrjv aXyr\b6va koX vyir) elvau ITX2A. litas
yap ov; 2X2. *Ap' ovv otjtoos av irepl o~G>p.a evbaipovecrTaTos
dvOpcoiros etrj, iaTpevop.evos, r) p.r)be Kap.ycov apxrjv; ITX2A.
5 ArjXov ort p.rjbe Kap.vcov. 2X2. Ov yap tovt r\v evbaip.ovia,
a>s eotKe, KaKov aTrakkayrj, dAAd rrjv dpxyv p-rjbe KTrjcns.

y
ITX2A. Eort Tavra.
d 2X2. Tt 8e'; d#Atcorepos Trorepos bvolv kypvTOW KaK.bv
etr' ev crco/xart etr' ev yj/vxv, 6 tarpevd/xevos Kat a7raAAarrd-
e 8 tij B T P F : rrjs Stobaeus a 4 kuI robs B T P rovs k<x\ F

:
ical Stobaeus b3 olv TPf Olympiodorus : om. B F Stobaeus

3>v \tyets BTP F
Stobaeus : secl. Hermann (non vertit Ficinus) S>v :
\eyw Findeisen c a ko\ 71^ ilvai BTP F Stobaeus secl. Morstadt :
ku\ vyiii ilvai Par. 1815 03 ei)Sai/j.ov4ffrepos F d 1 WBTPf:

rls F Stobaeus irSrtpos B T P F irSrtpov Stobaeus KaKbv B T
:
Stobaeus kokwi P Kanolv F

: : d 2 ko2 B T P F koI 6 Stobaeus :
ropriAs 47 8d
fxtvos tov xaKov, rj 6 jxij laTptvdfxtvos, (^(1)V bi; FIX2A. <t>aC-
veraC jxol 6 fxif larpevofxtvos. 2X2. Ovkovv t6 hiKt]v otobVat
fxzyiaTov KaKov aTraX.kayrj r)v, TrovrjpCas; ITX2A. *Hv ydp. 5

212. SaxppovCCft. ydp irov Kal biKaioTepovs 7rotei Kat la-
TpLKrf yiyvzTai irovrjpias r) nX2A. Nat.
oiktj. 212. Ev8at-
fxovo~TaTos fxkv dpa 6 jxrj \u>v KaKiav iv ^vxfj, iireibrj tovto
fxiyLcrTov tG>v KaKu>v icpdvrj. ArjXov
IIX2A. brj. 2X2. Aev- e
Tcpos bi irov 6 aTrdkXaTTOfxnvos.
IIX2A. "Eoikcv. 2X2. 05-
tos 0' r)v 6 vovdeTovfxevos re Kat imixXrfTTOfxtvos Kal bUrjv
bubovs. nX2A. Nat. 2X2. KaKtora apa fj
6 tyjov [dotKtai>]
Kat jxij aTraXXaTTOfxtvos. ITX2A. 4>atVerat. 5
2X2. Ovkow ovtos Tvyyavti a>v os av to. fxiytcrTa dotK<2i>
Kal -)(p<ofXVos fXyo~Tij abtKiq biaTrpa^rfTai aVre fxrjre vov-
OtTclo-dat. fxijTt Kokd(cr$ai fxrfTe bUrjv bcbovai, (oo"trep oa/ 479
(prjs Wpxiâov TtapscrKtvdcrOai Kal tovs dWovs rvpdvvovs
Kat pifTopas koX bvvdcTTas;
y
nX2A. EotK.
2X2. 2xe8oi> ydp irov ovtol, co aotare, to avrb ota7re- 5
v
irpayfxivoi dcrlv <2o-7reo h.v e tls toZs jueyiorois vocrrffxao-LV
crvvLcryojxzvos ota7rpaâtro fxrj otooVat bUrjv t&v irepl t6

oSifxa ajxapTrjjxdTOiV tols larpols fxrjbe laTpeuzcrQaL, (pofiov-
fxevos otcnrepavel iraXs to KdecrOaL Kal to Tefxvecrdai, otl

akyeLvov. r) ov ooKet Kal o~ol oura>; b
nX2A. "Euotye.
2X2. 'Ayvo&v ye, <ws eotKei>, olov io~TW r) vyteta Kal
aperij (TcofxaTos. Kivbvvevovo-i yap eK tG>v vvv rjjxlv cofxo-
Koyrjjxivoiv tolovtov tl iroLelv Kat 01 rrjv bUrjv (pevyovTts, 5
d 4 ix 03V 5e post larpev6/j.evos add. F Stobaeus d5 fj.eya.Kov

d 8 tovto om. Stobaeus e 2 5e -rov F Stobaeus : Sri-rov BT W
e 4 iSiKtoj/] xaiciav Dobree om. Stobaeus : e 6 to om. Stobaeus
a4 eoiKt BTF: om. P Stobaeus a6 fxeyio-Tois om. Stobaeus
a 7 avviax&nwos T F Stobaeus avvrjcrx^^vos B crweÂ* 6 '' 05 P
: :
8(07rpa|ajTo] 5jirpa|oTo Stobaeus a 9 So-irep av el ira?s B T P :
&o-Kep av j' elirou F Stobaeus b 3 ye B T P Stobaeus Sh F :
b 4 awfiaTos"\ tov aa>fi.aTos Stobaeus

PLATO, vol. 111. 20
479 b FIAATX2N02
S) IIcoAe, to dkyzivbv avrov KaOopdv, irpbs b\ rb cocp4kip.ov
rvcpkcos exeiy KaX dyvozlv ocrcp ddkLcorepov ecrrt p.r) vyiovs

crco/xaroj p-rj vytet tyvxjj crvvoLKtlv, dAAd craOpa Kal dbUoo
C Kal dvocrio), odev Kal ttclv ttolovo-lv coore biKrjv /xt/ bibovai,
p.rjb' d7raAAdrrecr#at tov /xeytVrou KaKov, Ka\ yjprjp.aTa irapa-

o-Kva6p,Voi Kal cpikovs Kal ottcos av cocrii> cos TTLdavcoraTOL
Aeyetv* et 8e r)p.LS akridrj cop.okoyrjKap.ev, co FIcoAe, S/>'
5 alo-davy tcl 0-vp.jBaivovTa eK tov koyov; r/ /3ovAet crvkko-

ytcrco/xefla avra;
nX2A. Et croi ye 8oKet.
211. *Ao' ovv 0-vp.fiaLVZi p.iyLo~TOV KaKov r) ahiKia Kal ro
d abiKeTv; IIX2A. ^PatVerat ye. 212. Kat p,r)v airakkayr) ye
kcpdvr) tovtov tov KaKov to biKrjv bibovai; nX2A. Kivbv-
vevei. 2X2 T6 8e ye p,r) bibovai ip.p.ovr) tov KaKov;
IIX2A. Nat. 2X2. Aevrepov dpa ccttlv tcov KaKcov /xeye'0et
5 to abLKelv to be abLKOvvra p,r) bibovai bUr)V Travrcov p.iyi-
o-tov re xat irp&rov KaK&v irecpvKev. nX2A. v
EotKer.
212. *Ap' ovv ov 7rept tovtov, co c/>tAe, r)p.cpcr(3riTijcrap.V,
crv pikv tov 'Apêkaov evbaLp.ovi(ov tov tcl p.{yLo~Ta d8t-

e KovvTa bUrjv ovb<-p.iav bLbovra, eyco 8e Tovvavriov oiop.t\vos,
v
e re 'Apêkaos etr' aAXos dvdpcenrcov octtlctovv p.r) bibcocri
biKrjv abLKcov, rovrcj) Ttpo&rjKCLV aOkico eu>at dtacpepwrcos

t&v ctAAcov avQp&itcov, kol det tqv abLKovvTa tov abLKov-
5 p.ivov ddkLcoTepov elvai kol tov p.r) StSoVra 8iktjv tov

bLbovTos; ov ravT r)v tcl vtt e/xou key6p,va;
IIX2A. Nat'.
2X2. Ovkow a7ro8e8etKrai ort akr)6r] eA^yero;
nX2A. <J>atyerat.
480 2X2. Etev et ovv br) Tavra dkr]$r], co ricoA.e, rts r)
p.eyakrj XPâ ôrlv Trjs pr\TopLKr)s; 8et pkv yap br) ck rcoy
iyut ^f/vxv T P F Stobaeus vyii/s tyvxb B (corr. rec. b)

b8 c 7 troi
W
:
ye F trol ye &\\ws B T P
: /xij <rol ye &\\us vulg.
: d 3 84 ye B F :
ye T d 5 a.SiKuu^ aSiKuv SIktjv 8i86vra Stallbaum oZlkovvto. 8i86vcu :
8Ut]v Hirschig d 6 t T P F yt B d 7 otv oi>

: F olv B T P :
TOPriAS 48oa
vvv lopoXoyrjpzvtov avrov kavrbv udAtcrra cpuAdrreiy oVcas
v
u? / d8tK?/trei, cos iKavbv KaKov tôvra. ov yap;
YILIA. Ylavv ye. 5
212. 'Edy 8e' ye d8tK?/cr?/ ?/ avrds ?/ dAAos rts coi> dv
KT/8r/rai, airdy eKoVra teVat eKeiae o7rou cos rdx,ttrra
8cocret hUrjv, Trapa tov hiKao~Tr]V cocnrzp 7rapd tov larpov,

v
o-nevhovTa ottcos u? / ky\povio~6\v rb v6o~r]pa rrjs dSiKias b
VTTqvkov tijv ~yj/vxv v 7rot?/o-et fcal drtarov ?*/ 7rcos Ae'yo-
uei>, co IlcoAe, et7reo rd Trporepov ueVet fjp.lv 6po\oyi]p.aTa;

ovk avdyKrj ravra (khvois ovtco p.\v ovpcpcovtiv, dAAcos
le u?/; 5
v
IIOA. Tt yap 8? / <pcouei>, co ScoKpares;
2X2. 'E7ri uei> dpa rd a7roA.oyeto-0at 7j7reo r?/s d8tKias
r?/s ai/rou t/ yovicov ?/ kraipcov r\ Ttaihcov ?/ narpihos ahiKovarjs
v
ov \pi]o~ipos ovhzv r) pr]TopiKi] fjpuv, 2) FIcoAe, et u?/ et rts
v7roAd/iot e7jt TovvavTiov Karrjyopiiv helv udAtara uei> C
kavTov, e7retra 8e Kat rcoy otKticov Kat rcoy aAAcoy ds av
v
ael tcov cpikcov rvyyavr] ahtKcov, /cat u? / a7roKp?J7rrea-t9at dAA'
ets to cpavtpbv a.yeiv to ahUrjpa, iW 8<S 8tKT/z; Kat vyt?/s

yevrjrai, drayKacfeiv re avrbv Kal tovs dAAous u?/ d7ro8eiAidi> 5
dAAd iraptyj-iv pvcravra ev Kal avhpzicos co<r7rep ripvf.iv
v
kcx\ Kaety tarpco, rd ayadbv Kal Ka\bv htcoKovra, u?/ VTToAoyt-
(ppcvov to akyeivov, iav p.kv ye 7rAr/y<3i> d<fta ?/8ik?jkcos
77, r?J7rreii> isapkypvTa, iav 8e 8ecruo?j, 8et*>, eai> 8e (fr/utas, <?
airoTivovTa, iav 8e (pvyfjs, (pcvyovra, eav 8e câydrou, a7ro-

6vi](TK0VTa, avrbv Trp&Tov ovra Karrjyopov koX avrov Kal
t5)v dAAcor otKetcoy Kat e7rt tovto yjptapavov r?/ prjropLKrj,
ottcos av KaTahrjkcov tG>v d8tK?/udrcoy yiyvopivtov a7raAAdr- 5
a 4 aZwf\<rti F : a.5iKt)(TT) BTP Ikovov secl. Cobet /co/cJ>i/ secl.

v. Kleist b2 irotf)<rei scr. recc. : 7rot^<r?j BT WF \4yonev
WF: Kiywfxtv BT ci WBTPf: ^rtl F: secl. Deuschle
C5 t F ( Kc a add. f) : 8* /cal BTP c6 e5 ol F: *oi BTP
d4 koX BTP : Ka\ fi}) <t>f&6fxtvov a\\' F d5 OTraAAoTTWvToi BPt
(sed u in ras. B) : airaWaTTovrai TF
20*
;
48od IIAAT&NOS
TCOVTCU. TOV /XeytOTOU KCLKOV, d8lKtds. (f)(ap.V OVTOOS T/ /XT/
c/>co/xei>, a> n<SAe;

e II12A. "Atottcl p.(v, a> 2coKpares, e/xotye 8oKet, rots /ueWot
,
k p.irpoo~6ev tcrcos o~oi opoAoyetrat.

212. Ovkovv r) Ko.Kti.va kvriov r) rd8e avayKt) o-vp.(3aCvei.v
ITX2A. Nat, tovto ye ovtoos ^x 61,

5 212. TovvavrCov 8e' ye av /u.era/3aAo'jvra, et dpa 8et rtm
kokcos 7roieu>, etr' kyOpbv etre oT/riz/oSiv, eav p.6vov pr/' avrbs
abiKrJTat. vtto tov eyjSpov tovto p.\v yap evAa/3?jreW kav
8e aAAoy dStKrj 6 k^dpos, TravTi rpoTroi TrapacrKevacrTeov, Kal
481 7rpdrroi>ra Kat keyovra, oVcos pr/ 8<o bUrjv p.rjbe ekdrj 7rapd
tov biKacTT-qv kdv be ek6r\, p.r\yjavrjTeov ottoos av 8ta<pTJyr/
Kat p.r) 8<S 8ikt/i> 6 ex$pds, dAA' edyre yjpvcrCov (r/) rjpiraKoos
irokv, p.r) aTiobibQi tovto dAA' excoy avakCcrKrf Kal ets eavTov
5 Kat ets rous earjrot) dStKcos Kat adeoos, kdvre av davdrov
d<fta ?/8ik?/ko)S r/, O7rcos p.rf diTodaveiTai, /xaAtcrra /xer p.rjbe-
7rore, dAA' dfldvaros ecrrat Trovrfpbs &v, et 8e p.r/, O7roos cos
b 7rAetcrroi> \povov /3tco<Terai roto?3ros coy. e7rt rd roiairra
e/xotye 8oKet, co EtcoAe, r/ pr/roptKT/ yjpf)crip.os elvai, kirel rco
ye /at) p.ekkovri abiKelv ou /xeydAr/ rts uot 8oKet r/

XP eta
avTr)s eTvai, et 8r) Kal ecrrty rts X/ e ' a > ^s ^ y rots
5 Trpocrdev ovbap.rj ecpdvrf ovcra.
KAA. Et7re' p.01, <o Xaipe<p<2y, <77rou8det Tavra 2coKpdrr/s

r/ 7rat(et;
XAI. 'E/xot p.ez> 8oKet, a> KaAAtKAets, virep(pvQ)S o-ttov-
baCeiv ovbev p.evrot oTov to ovtov epcoray.

10 KAA. Nr) tovs deovs dAA' kindvp.S>. diri p.01, 3) 2co-
C Kpares, Trorepov cre 65>p.ev vvvi antovbatfiVTa rj iraCtflVTa; et
/uey ydp o-7rou8dêts re Kat r7jyxdret ravra dkr\6r) ovra a
d.6 /uLfyiffTov BTP: fieyd\ou F aSjKtas BTF: om. P

e3 KtLKiiva BTPF : 'Kelva Hirschig a 3 5 F t : Swjtj B :
8?7J PT add. Schanz (post ripiraKks Par. 181 1)

rj a4 ava\iffKrj
L. Dindorf: avaKiffKtirt P (sed T6 puncto del.) avaX(<TKT?Taj : BTF
a5 al F om. B T P
: c 1 0/*/ Madvig : <pw/xev BTPF : om.
nonnulli teste Olympiodoro vw\ BTP : vvv F
ropriAS 48ic
keyeLS, dkko tl *; r)p.cov 6 (3los dvaTTpap.p.evos av eXi) tcov dv-
Opcoircov Kal iravTa ra kvavTia TTpa.TTop.ev, a>$ eoLKev, ?/ a 8ei;

V
212. X2 KakkUkeLs, et u?/ rt t/V rot? dvdpcoiroLS Trddos, 5
rois /xer aAAo rt, rot? 8e akko n [?^] to avro, dkkd rts
^juaw XbLov tl eTracryev irddos rj ol aAAot, ovk av rjv pabiov
ei'8et<fao-#at r<S ere'pa> to eavrov Trd6r]p.a. keyco 8' ewo?jo-as d
ort eya> re Kat crv vvv rvyyavop.ev tovtov tl ttttov6ots,
pU)VT bllO OVT bvotv KaTpOS, eyco p.V 'AAKt/3ld8oJJ T
tov KkeLviov Kal cpLkocrocpLas, crv be bvelv, tov tc 'A61]-

vaicov bi]p.ov Kal tov YlvpLkdp.7T0vs. alo-6a.vop.aL ovv crov 5
eKaaTOTe, Kaiirep ovtos beivov, ort av </>?) crov ra 7rat8tKa

Kat oTTU)S av cpr) e\Lv, ov bvvap.evov dvTLkeyeLV, aAA' ara>
Kal KaTto p.eTafia\kop.evov' ev re Tij eKKkrjcriq., edv tl crov e
keyovros 6 brjp.os 6 'AdrjvaLoov p?/ cpfj ovtcos eyeLV, p.ra-
j3aWop.evos keyeis a eKetro? /3ovAerat, Kat TTpos tov IIupi-

kdp.TTOvs veavCav tov Kakov tovtov TOLavra erepa ireTrovdas.
tols ydp tcov iraLbLK&v fiovkevp.acriv re Kat Ao'yot? ov^ otds 5
t et evavTLOvcrdaL, tocrre, eX rts crov keyovros eKacrTore a

8ta tovtovs keyeLS 6avp.d(pL cos aro7ra <ttlv, Xcrcos ei7rots
dv avrco, et (3ovkoLo Taki]6rj keyeLV, otl et /x?/ rts 7ra?Jo-ei rd

crd 7rat8tKa tovtlov tcov koytov, ovbe crv Travcrr] ttot TavTa 482
keycov. vopLLê tolvvv kol irap ep.ov ^(pfjvaL erepa TOLavra
aKoveLV, Kat pvt] 6avp.ae otl eyco TavTa keyco, dkkd tt]V
cpLkocrocpLav, Ta e/xa 7rat8tKa, 7ra7Jo-or Tavra keyovcrav.

keyeL ydp, a> cpike eratpe, a vvv ep.ov aKOveLS, Kat pot eo-rti^ 5
tcov ereptov 7rat8tKwy irokv tjttov epLirkrjKTos' d p.ev ydp KAet-

z'tetos ovtos aAAore aAAcoi' eo-rt Ao'ya)?J, ?; 8e cpLkocrocpLa ael
tcov avTcov, Aeyet 8e a crv vvv 6avp.deLs, Traprjada 8e Kat b
C3^BTPf: om. F c6^TPF: ^B: om. Aldina

d.4 dvo?t> BTPF : om. Vind. 21 F ort Hirws ttv d.6 Srt &v <pr\ :
B '6ti '6it<0$ Wv avTt<f>rj T P

<f>TJ : e 2 & Srjftos 6 T P F 6 5?}yuos B :
e'5 Pov\(vfia<rt{v) BTPF: ôv\{\ixa<rt vulg. a 5 & re vera B F :
atl & T (?) P f a 6 eTepwy B F eTatpwv T P e/iirA7j/CTOS B T P F

: :
7p. e/cÂijros B quam lectionem novit Olj-mpiodorus

5
a 7 ol corr.
Coisl: e?F: om. BTP
482b IIAATX2N02
avrbs Aeyo/xeVoty. rj oliv kclvi]v ee'Aey<5or', oircp dpTL
eAeyor, cos ov to abtKclv Icttlv kcxl abiKovvra bUrjV y.i] bi-
bovai. arrdvTcov ZaryaTov KaKcov r) et tovto edcrets dveXeyKrov,
S p.a tov Kvva tov AlyvirTLcov deov, ov ctol opLoXoy r/crei KaA-
AtKArJs, co KaAAtKAets, dAAd Stac/jcorr/crei ev aTravTL ru /3tco.
Katroi Zycoye otjwat, S /3e'Artcrre, Kai rr)i> Xvpav /xot Koeirroj
eivai avapixoorov re Kat biacpcovelv, Kal \opbv co \opr]yor)v,

C Kat 7rAetcrrous dvdpcoirovs fj.r) d/xoAoyet> /xot dAA' ZvavTia
Xiyciv pLaXXov r) eVa ovra e/xe e/tat>rcp dcrvp.cpcovov etvat
Kal IvavTia Xkye.Lv.
KAA. 'X2 ScoKoares, SoKets veavieveo-Qai ev rots Adyots
5 cbs dXrjdcos 8rr/xr?yo'pos &v Kal vvv Tavra br]p.r)yopels tovtov

iradovros IIcoAotj 7rd0os 07rep ropytou Karr/ydpet irpbs ae
rradeXv. ecprj ydp 7rou ropytay epcoTcofxevov U7rd crou, edy
dcptKrrrat 7rap' at/rw pr) eTrLO-Ta)xevos rd StKata 6 rr/i> /rrrro-
d ptKr)i; /3ouAo'pez>os fxadelv, et 8tSd<fot aurdr 6 Topytas,

alo-yyvOrjvai avrbv Kal <pdvai Stddfetv dtd ro e(9os rcoy di>-
Opcoircov, otl ayavaKToUv av et tls fxr) (paCrj 8td dr) TavT-qv
Tr)v ojxokoyiav dvayKao-6r)vaL evavrCa avrbv aurco et7reu',
5 cre be aurd rouro dya7rdu Kat crou KarayeXdv, cos ye' /xot
SoKetu dpt9cos, rdre* vvv be 7rdAtu aurds Tavrbv tovto eVatfeu.

kol eycoye Kar' avTo tovto ovk dya/xat ITcoAoy, drt crot
crvveyjtiprio-ev to dbiKLV olo-^lov etuat tov d8lKe^c^c9al eK

e raurrrs yap av rr/s dpoAoytas aurds virb aov crij/x7ro8icri9eis
ev rols Adyots e7recrro)U.t(rt9rr, atcri(V7;9eis a evdet et7retr. cru
yap rco ovtl, co ScoKpares, ets rotarrra dyets cpoprLKa ku\

br]p.rjyopLKa, (pdo-Kcov Tr)v dkrjdtLav bLcoKeiv, a cpvcrcL pikv
5 oi/K ecrrty KaAd, vopico 8e. cos rd 7roAAd 8e ravra evavTL*

dAAr/Aots Icttlv, rj re cpvcrLS Kal 6 vopLOS' eav ovv tls alo-yy-
b5 rbu alyvirrlwv B rbv alyvirriov F Olympiodorus

: rS>v alyv-
W
:
irrlaiv TP(sed rbv supra rwv T) ko\\ik\t}s T F Ka\\iK\e? B :
b 8 avapfioirruv Heusde c I ir\uo-rovs B T P : icoWovs F

C 4 8o/ceiV B T P 5okc7s fioi F
: d 3 el yd\ rts cpairi P (sed add.
signis transpositionis) d 5 Karayt\av Kartyt\a f Vind. 21 BTPF:
e6 "av olv TifBTP: koI idv ris olfiai F
. :
TOPriAS 483a
vr)Tai /cai fxrj roA/xd Ae'yeii> ct7reo voti, avayKa&Tai ZvavTia 483
Xiyf.LV. b br) Kal <rv rovro to <ro<pbv KaTavVor\Km KaKOvp-
yet? kv rots Adyot?, edv \tv rts Kard vop.ov Xtyrj, Kard
<f)V<TLV VTTpO)TU>V, edv 8e T(X TTJS <fiv<TU)S, ra tov vop.ov.
axnrt-p avrUa kv tovtols, rcp dStKetv re Kat rco d8iKetcr0at, 5
IIcoAov to Kard vop.ov atcr^tor Ae'yovros, av tov Xoyov

e8tcoKa#e? Kard <pv<riv. c/>vcret pkv yap itav ol<txl6v eortv
o7reo Kat kolklov, to d8iKetcr0ai, v6fj.a> 8e rb abiKeiv. ov8e
yap dvbpbs tovto y eortv to 7rd0T/jua, to d8iKeicr0ai, aXX* b
dv8oa7ro'8ov rtvds cj> KpeiTTov <ttlv retWvat 77 (rjv, o<ttls
a.biKovp.evos Kal 7rp07rT/AaKio'/xevos /xt/ oTds re' ecrrtv avrds

avr co ftorjdelv /ur/8e dAAco ov &v KT/8r/rat. dAA' ot/xai 01
rt0e'/xevot rovs vd/xovs 01 dcr0eyeis dv6p<t)iroL etcrtv Kat 01 5
7roAAot. 7rods avrozJs ovv Kat rb avrots <rvp.<\)ipov rovs re
vd/xovs rCdevTai kol rovs e7rati>o?JS e7ratvot)cru; Kat rovs

\/>o'yovs y\ryov<Tiv eKc/>o/3ovVres rovs eooco/xeyecrrepovs rcov C
av6p<a-n<iiv Kat Swarovs dvras irXtov X HV > tva /xt) avrcov
irXtov fxaxriv, Aeyovcrtv cos alaxpbv Kat d8tKOV ro 7rAeov-

eKretr, Kal rovrd ecrrtv ro dStKetr, to ttXcov rcov dAAcov
CrjTeiv exeiv dya7rcocrt ydp ot/xat avrot hv to X<tov 'x
co(TLV 5
<pavXoTpoL dvres. 8td ravra 8t/ vd/xco /xei> tovto d8iKov Kat
alo~xpbv Aeyerat, rd 7rAe'ov Cr TC *X (LV T v ôXX&v, Kal
/
;
abLKtiv avrb KaXov<TLV r) 8e' ye ot/xat c/jvctis avrr) a7roc/)aivet
avrd, ort bUaLov Icttlv tov d/xetrco rov x ^P ovos ^^0J '
exetr Kat rdy 8warcorepoi; rou d8vvarcorepov. 8r/Aot 8e
ravra 7roAAaxov ort ovrco? exet, Kat iv rot? dAAoty (mols

Kal t5>v dv6p<aTr<t)v iv oXais rat? 7ro'Aecrt Kat rots yerecrtv,
a 3 Kara (bis) BTP : t^ icara (bis) F a6 aXaxiov (al<rxpov

F) . . . v6/j.ov TF :\6yov Riemann
om. B W
v6fiov B T P F :
a 7 iSidKaOes Kara. cpvaiv (rb ante Kara add. P) B W

4b~L<&Kadts T :
(^SiWcj F et in marg. T et yp. W) a8 ante rb abtKuffOai laeunam

statuit Stephanus rb aSiK(7o-0ai . abiKeiv secl. Dobree
. b 2 itr-
ri(v) r(0vivai BPF : rtdvavai tarlv T (compendio) b 4 ov BPF :
<T b5 01 ante dureei^rs om. P C3 \4yovo-LV secl. Hermann

di avr6 BTPF: a S Par. 2110

483d nAAT12N02
5 oti ovtco to bUaiov KeKptrat, tov /cpetrrco tov iJttovos dp\eLv
'
Kal irkeov ix ctv ' ^ 776 1 TroCca StKatco xpcapevos He'pr/s eirl
tyjv 'EAAdSa ecrTpaTevcrev r/ 6 iraTr)p avrov eirl ^Kvdas; r)
e dAAa pupta dv rts exot TotaOra keyeiv. dAA' ot/uat ovrot

Kard (pvcrLV Tr)v tov hiKaiov ravra irpaTTovo-iv, koX vaX p.a
Ata Kard vop.ov ye roz/ T77S (pvcrecos, ov peVrot tcrcos Kard
roCroy bv r/pets TL0ep,e6a' 7rAdrroi>res rovs /3eAriorot>s /cat
5 eppu>p.evecrTdTOvs r)p.(ov avT&v, ck vecov kap.(3dvovTes, wcnrep

keovras, KareirqbovTes re Kal yor/rerWres Kara8ot>Aor;p,e0a
484 Aeyoures cos ro tcroy \pr) eyeLV koX tovto ccttlv to Kakov
Kat t6 biKaiov. edv be ye ot/xat (pvo~Lv tKavrjv yevrjraL
e^coj; di^r/p, irdvra Tavra aTrocrei.crdp.evos Kal 8tappr/ds Kat
bia(pvya>v, Kara7rarr/cras rd r)p,Tpa ypdp.ixaTa Kal pxxyya-
5 vevp.aTa koX e7np8ds Kat vopovs tovs Trapa cpvcriv airavTas,
eiravacrTas avecpdvrj becnroTrjs r)p.Tpos 6 bovkos, Kal evTavOa
b eekap.\(/V to rr/s cpvcrecos biKaiov. boKel be p.01 koX YlCv-
bapos cnrep eyco Ae'yco evbeUvvcrOat. ev rco aayxart ev co Ae'yet
otl
vop.os 6 irdvToiV âcnkevs
5 Ovar&v re Kat dOavdTOiv
oVtos be 8r/, cprjcrCv,

dyet 8tKatcoy to fiiaioTaTov
VTrepTaTq x LP^' TeKp.aipop.ai
epyoicnv 'HpaKkeos, eirel d7rptdras
10 Ae'yet otfrco 7rcos to yap qcrp,a ovk eiricrTapaL Ae'yet 0' ort
ovTe 7rpidp.evos ovtc bovros tov Tr\pv6vov r/Adcraro rds fiovs,

C cos tovtov ovtos tov bLKaCov cpvcreL, kol fiovs Kat rdAAa KTrj-
62 tV rov 8u<alov secl. Schleiermacher 63 rrjs re vera BT(?)

PF om. Schanz (errore typothetarum ut videtur)
: e 4 rt6e/j.f0a
secl. Hermann a 1 \4yovres secl. Cobet a 3 avrip B P F :
6 avrip T 0,4 Sia<pvyiov secl. Naber ypd/xfj.ara~\ jrepid/jL/iara

Valckenaer ir\dff/j.ara Cobet
: b 7 SiKaiwv rb fiiaidrarov Aristides
(cf. Legg. 714 e &yetv StKatovvra rh fiiatSrarov) fitaiwv rb StKaiSraTov:
BTPF b8 X ei P BF: x^TP

r
ropriAs 484C
ixara elvai irdvra tov /3eArtoi>o's re Kal Kpeirrovos ra t&v

\eLp6voov T Kal rjTTOVCOV.
To p.ev ovv dki]6es ovtoos lx et yva>crr) be, av eVt to.
/xeta> ek6i]$ edcras 7/817 <ptAocrocpiaz>. (pcXoo-ocpia ydp Toi 5
(cttiv, u> 2co/cpares, yapiev, av rts avrov p.Tpia>$ di/n/rat ev

tt\ r/At/ctcr edv be 7repatre'pco tov beovTOS eVStarpii//'?/, ota-
cpdopd tcov dvdpwTTCov. edv ydp koX irdvv ev(f>vi]$
f]
Kal
iroppco rr/s r/Ai/ctas cpikoo-ocpf], dvdyKrj irdvTcov direLpov yeyo-
vivai IcttXv a>v xpi) ep-ireLpov eu>at tov p.ekkovTa Kakbv d
Kayadbv Kal evboKifxov ecrecrdaL dvbpa. Kal ydp to>v vop.cov
a7retpot ytyi>orrat t(ov /card rrjv ttoKlv, /cat to>v koyoov ols
bel \pojp.evov bp.Lketv ev tols crvp.f3okaioL$ rots dv6pa>TTOL$

/cat Ibia Kal h]p.ocria, koX tG>v r)bova>v re /cat eiTL6vp.La>v tcov 5
av6pa>Treicov, Kal cTvkXr]ftbi]v t&v i)6a>v TravTaTracriv direLpoL
yiyvovTaL. etreLbdv ovv ekdcocrLv eis TLva 181W r) TrokiTLKi]v
irpa^LV, /caraye'Aacrrot yiyvovraL, coo-rrep ye otpat ot 7roAirt- Q

Koi, TTLbdv av ets rds vp.eTepa$ 8tarpt/3ds ek6o>aLV Kal tovs
koyovs, /caraye'Aacrroi elcrLV. crvp.(3aiveL ydp to tov Ei3pt7rt-
bov kapLTrpos re' ecrTLV e/cacrros ev tovtco, Kal eirl tovt

exreiyerat, 5
Vp.O>V TO TrkeLCTTOV r)p.pa$ TOVTO) p.pOS,
tv avrbs avTov Tvy\dveL /3e'Artcrros &v

5' dv cpavkos evrevdev
8ttov r), cfrevyeL /cat AotSopet tovto, 485
rd 8' erepov eiraLvel, evvoiq. Trj eavTOV, r)yovp.evo$ ovtcos
avrbs kavTov eiraLvelv. dAA' ot/uat to opdoTarov (ttlv
dp.(poTpojV p.eTaayêw. cptAocrocpias p.ev oow 7rat8eias \dpLv

Kakbv p.TexeLV, /cat ovk alcr\pbv /ueipa/aco wrt cpLkocrocpelv 5
exretSai' be ijbrj Trpecrj3vTepos &>v dvOpooiros tl cptAocrocpT/,

Karaye'Aacrror, w Sco/cpares, to XPVP 01 - yiyveraL, Kal eycoye
bp.oLOTaTov 7rdo-)(<o 7rpos tovs cpLkocrocpovvTas cocnrep irpbs b
d2 fv$6Ktuoi> T W F Gellius : evSatfiov' B d3 t))V BTP : om. F

e4 ko\ tirlB T P F Ka7r> vulg.: e 7 rvyxdvft T
rvyxdvri : B (cf.
Alc. ii. 146 a6 rvyxwy PF
: j3*Atj(Ttoj] Kpdrio-Tos Alc. ii. 1. c.
485b nAATI2N02
tovs \êAAtb/xeVo?js kcu TraC(ovTas. ftTav p.V yap TraibCov
tbto, <S ert 7Tpoa"t]Ka. dtaAeyecrflat ovroi, ijrekkLCofxcvov ko.1
i:aZ(fiv, yaipu) re kol yapUv /xot (/Wuerat kol iktvOipLov Kal

5 npi-nov ttj tov iraLbCov rjkLKLq, orav oe cracp&s StaAeyo/xeVou
iraLbapCov aKOVcroi, TTLKpov tC liol boKcl XPVH- a cwai Kal dvLa
fXOV TCL U)Ta KaC fXOL SoKet bov\OTTpTTS TL ZLVaL' OTaV bk
C avbpbs aKovcrr) tls ^kktôfxivov 77 iraCCpvTa bpq, Karayi-
kacrrov cpaCveraL kol avavbpov Kal irkrfyStv cllov. ravrbv
ovv eycoye tovto irdcryjn kcl\ irpbs tovs </>tAocroc/)Owras. irapa
viqt fxkv yap /zetpaKtco bpiov c/hAoctoc/hW dyafxaL, klu irpiirzLV
5 /xot boKel, kol r)yovfxaL ikevOepov TLva elvaL TOVTOV TOV

avOpcoTTOv, tov bk fxr) dpLkocrocpovvTa dvekevdepov Kal ovbi-
ttotc ovbevbs a<ftcoo-oi>ra kavTov ot!re koXov ovtc yevvaCov
d 7rpdyp.aTOS' otov 8e br) TTpcrj3vTpov i8co ert </)iAoo-oc/)owra
Kal fxr) dirakkaTTOfxevov, irkr]y<2v fxoL 80/cet 7/817 belcrdaL,
cb ScoKpare?, oilros 6 dvifp. 6 ydp vvvbr) Kkeyov, VTrdpycL

TOVTio rco dv0pb)7Tq>, Kav Trdvv evqbxxqs dvdvbpio yevicrdai
fj,
5 qievyovTL rd fxicra rrjs 7roAecos Kat ras dyopds, iv ats e</>r/ b

TTOLrjrrjs tovs avbpas dpLTTpeirzLS yCyvccrOaL, KarabtbvKOTL 8e
tov kuLirbv fiCov /3tcoVai fxerd /aetpaKiW iv yoivCq TpL&v rj
e TtTTapoiV \lrL0vpCovTa, ikevOepov 8e Kat fxiya kcxl Xkovov

fxrfbiiroTi q\QiyâcrQaL. eyco bi, 00 ScoKpares, 7rpos cre e7rtet-
kQs exc*> c/uAikcoV KLvbvvevto ovv TrcrrovOivaL vvv oirep b

Zrj$os Trpbs tov 'A/x</>iWa 6 Evpt7rt'8ot), ov7rep ifxvrjcr6r)v.
5 Kat ydp ifxol TOLavr arra iiripyjtTaL irpbs cre kiyLV, olaTrep
eKetros 7rpos tov dbzkqbov, otl " 'AueAety, Si ScoKpares, &v

8et cre e7rt/xeAeto-c9at, Kat qbvo-Lv ^vxv^ ^be ycvvaCav pet-
3
486 paKtcoSet tlvl otarpeVet? /xopc/)copart, Kctt ovr hv Sikj/s /3ou-
b2 ira/Cwras secl. Morstadt (et mox b 4 Kal irdi(ov, C 1 t) iralCovra

/caJ
6p<f) b 3 tyfWt6/xtvou Kal ira?ov secl. Cobet C 3 rovro

irdffxo B T P iriffxo rovro F xepl B T P F
2
: irapa Stephanus : :
irepi B post hanc vocem distinguens C 6 Kal B T P riva ehat /caJ F :
d 2 fiotB T P ^juoi F e 1 iKavbv] Ka\bv Coraes veavtKbv ci. Heindorf

: :
e 2 wdvv supra eirieiK&s P 67 y>'w(a'] yevvalau exû Ruhnken {*x oiv

,
add. Nauck post tûx^y \ax&u Cron) a 1 oiarpeireis F (coniecerat

Grotius) Stairpeweis
: BT
P $taffrpe<pets Valckenaer
: l\v~} lv Coraes

ropriAS 486 a
\ai(TL TrpoqdtL dv opd&s koyov, ovt eiKo? av Kal TTLdavbv

J
b\v Ad/3oi?, ov6 vnep dAAov veavLKov /3ovAevua /3ouAewato."
KaCroL, ) c/uAe 2coKpare? KaC /xot p.r)bev dxd(o-0fjs' evvoLq
yap epco rrj cr?) ovk alcrxpbv boKtl o-ol etrat ovtlos exetr 5
cos eyco cre otaat exti> Ka ' T0VS dAAous tovs roppoo det
c/uAocroo!>ias ikayvovTas; vvv yap et tls arov kafi6p.(vos 7)
aAAou otovovv t&v tolovtoov ds to beo-p.coTr)pLov airdyoi,

1
(pao-K<i)v dbiKdv p.r)bev abLKOvvTa, otcro ' otl ovk av exots otl
X/>?/o-ato aavrS), dAA' lAtyyico?/? &v Kal xa"M<{>0 0VK *X- V otl b
eiiroiy, fcat et? rb Suacrn/ptoiv dvafids, KaTi)y6pov rvx^v thxvv
(pavXov Kal p.oy6t}pov, ditoQdvoLS dv, et /SovAotro davdTov
croL TLpMo-daL. Katrot ir&s o~o(pbv tovto o~tlv, o) ScoKoares,
ijris t-vcpvr} Aa/3ot5cra Tix vr ) <p**>Ta flr/Ke \t\Lpova, 5
M?jre avrbv avrS) bvvdp.evov (3or)ddv p.rjb* eKcrcocrai eK rcoy
jueytcrrcoy KLvbvvcov M?jre kavrbv /xr/re dAAoy -xrjbiva, virb 8e
tS)v kyOpdv TrepLcrvkacrBaL i-dcrav tt)V ovo-iav, drex^coy 8e C

aTLp.ov ij)v kv rf) 7ro'Aet; tw oe rotouroy, et rt Kat dypoLKo-
v
Tepov dprjo-6aL, Zfjeoriv eVt Koppr)s TVTTTOVra m? 8t8oVat / b(Kr)v.
dAA' coyafle', euot ireidov, TiavcraL oe eAe'yxwr, 7rpa-

yp.aTcov evpovaiav dcrKet, Kat dcrKet
6' btroQev 8o'ets 5
cppovelv, dAAots rd Kop.\j/d ratlra d(peis, etre ArjpTjwara >**~Jz
XP 7/ <f>dvaL elvaL etre cpkvapias, e cou Kei>otcrtz> eyKarot-

K?/crety 8o'uoty (fr/Acoy otjk eAe'yxoi>ras dvbpas rd MtKpd
raura, dAA' ots ecrrti' Kat /3tos Kat o'a Kat dAAa 7roAAa dyafld. d
212. Et XP V(T1) V *X C0V *Tvyx avov TV V r XV v> <*> KaAAt- y rv
KAet?, ovk av otet we acrp.(vov tvpdv tovtcov tlvcl t&v kCdcov

fl fiaaravLifivo-Lv rbv xP V(T dv, tt)v dpio-Tr)v, Trpbs ijvTLva eueA-
a 3 &v \d$ots B T P f : ava\d$ots F : \d$ots recc. : \dxots Bonitz

a 5 flvat B T P om. F : a7 wBTP: yvvl F a8 a-rdyot
BTPF Philodemus a-raydyot Par. : ano &g /MjSfi/] ovdiv
Philodemus bi l\tyyicj>T)s F b t : fl\iyyte^ns BTP b5 r^rts
B Philodemus ^ rts F et rts T P: : cv-burj BTP : eixpvu F : eit-bva
vulg. ca Tb/ 5e TPF : T({i/5f B rhv : 5^ ci. Heindorf tX rt
koI TPF :
-1 nB C4 irefflou BT PF : irt$ov Cobet i\fy X >v
B T F /xaTaiaâ' P iv &\\<f> -rp6o-K~irat
: : i-avaat paratdGwv in marg. T
d4 $ BTP F ofj ci. Stallbaum at
: t) : : Par. 1812
486d IIAATJ2N02
5 Aoi> irpocrayayu>v avTr\v, et /xot 6p.oAoy7/creiey iKeivt] KaAcos
TtOepairevo-dai Ti]V \\rvyr\v, ev elo-eo-dai otl XkovSis ex 00 K"
ovbiv /xe 8et akkrjs ftacr&vov;
e KAA. ITpos rt 877 tovto ipoiTqs, oo ScoKpares;
212. 'Eyco o*ot epar i>t)y otjuat eyco croi eVrerux*?*^?
ToiovTti) Ip/xatco kvTCTvyjiKivai.
KAA. Tf&fc
5 212. ES 018' ort, dv juot crv 6p.okoyi]crr]s 7repi a>v r) e/x?/
^v\r) Socfdêt, ra?3r' 7/8)7 *~tIv avra Takr]dr). ivvoS> yap

487 otl tov p.ikkovTa fiacravulv iKav&s ^rvyjis iripL 6p6S>s re
cocrns Kal pt,r) rpia apa 8et exetr a cnj 7rdrra lx ets e7rtcrr?/-
p.T/z' re Kai evvoiav koX Trappr]criav. eyco yap 7roAAois eVrvy-

Xa^co 01 e/ute ov% oloi re etcrty fiacravi&iv Sta rd p?) crocpol
5 etyat cocnrep crTr erepot 8e crocpol p.iv elcriv, ovk i6ikovo~Lv 8e'
p.01 Aeyety ttjv dA?7#eiai' 8td ro p.?/ Ki]bcrdai p.ov oocnrep crv'
tlo 8e eVco rcoSe, Topytas re Kai ITcoAos, crocpco p,ei> Kai
b c/uAco ecrroi' e/xco, ei>8eecrre'pco 8e Trapprjcrias Kal alo-\vvTr)-

porepco /zaAAoi; roi SeWros* ttcos ydp ov; co ye ets toctovtov
atcrxTJyTj? ik-qkvdarov, cocrre 8td to alcryyvecrdai roApa eKa-

repos avT&v avTos avrSi ivavria Aeyeiv ivavriov TrokkS>v
5 avdpcairouv, Kal Tavra 7repi tS>v pt-eyicrToov. crv 8e ravTa
iravTa exets a 01 dAAot 07jk \ovcnv' 7re7rat8eucrai re ydp
iKa^cos, coy TroAAot av cpr]craiV '
A6i]vaiu>v, Kal ip.ol et tvvovs.
C rtVt reKpr/ptcp yjpS>p.aL; eyco crot epco. otSa ?3pas eyco, <o
KaAAtKAets, TtTTapas ovras kolvoovovs yeyovoras crocpias, cri
re Kal Teicravbpov tov ' AcpLbvalov Kat "ArSpcoâ tov 'Avbpo-

Tioovos kol Navo~LKvbr]v tov XoXapyea' Kai 7rore vp.S>v eyco
d6 eS BTP F :d 7 ,ue B T
^5tj ed F M oi scr. recc. Su W :
BTP : ti 5? ei 8J)BTP:S^F
F e 5 av ci. Bekker (& Sf
Par. 1811) &v B T P F
: a 2 rpfa Spa B T P F Stobaeus rpi' arra :
ci. Thompson & <ru ira^râ) B T P F aTJva (ru irdvTws Stobaeus :
a3 (ijvoiav corr. Ven. 189 et legisse videtur Clemens SSfâv B T P F :
Stobaeus bi alffxuvrrjporepa) BTP: alcrxvvmjKorepcaF b5 TauTa

ira^raBTP: iravra ravra F b7 (oj) noWol ci. Sauppe C3 Tei-
o~avb~pov F rto~av5pov B T P f
: c 4 uyucSi/ ^7^ B T P e^yco y/tcS' F :
:
ropriAS 487C
emfiKovcra fiovkevofxivcov fxi\pL 07701 ri]V croqbCav do-KT/reW 5

etr/, Kal olba otl ivUa iv vpuv TOia.be tls boa, fxrf irpoQv-
ueicrtfai d$ Ti]v aKpif3Lav <ptAocrocpeu>, akkd evAa/3etcr0at
V
7rapeKeAeueo-0e dkkr]koL$ ottcos U7/ iripa tov biovros crocpco- d
v
repot ytvop.voL A7/trere 8ta<p0apeVres. e7ret5j / ovv crov aKovco
ravrd ip.ol o-vp.(3ovkevovTO$ a7rep tols crzavTOV eratpordrots,
LKaVOV UOt TKp.r]pLOV i(JTLV OTL (OS dkl]dcOS UOl tVVOVS et.
kol p.r]V otl ye otos Trappr/o-tdêcrflat kol ut/ alcr)(VVcrdai, 5

avros re cpTjs Kal 6 koyos ov okiyov TrpoTpov eAeyes 6p.o-
Aoyet ctol: exet br] ovrcocrl brjkov otl tovtcov 7rept vvvi'
idv tl av iv tols koyoLS 6p.okoyr]o-r\s uot, /3e/3acrazncrueVoi/ G
tovt 7/877 ecrrat LKav&s vtt* ifxov re Kat crov, xat ouKeVt avrb
8e7/cret eV dkkr]v fSdcravov avacpiptLV. ov yap av 7rore
avro crvveyti>pr]cra$ crv ovre crocpias ivbeiq ovt alo-\vvr]s
irepLovo-iq, ovb' av diraTcov eue o-vyycopr]<raLS dv <piko$ ydp 5

uot et, b>s Kal avros <pr']$. rco ovtl ovv rj euT/ Kal rj crr)
6p.okoyia re'Aos 7/877 e<fet Tr]$ akr]6ciia$. irdvTcov 8e Kak-

kicrTrf icrrlv 7} o-Kt\\rLS, a> KaAAtKAets, 7rept tovtcov <av av
07/ p.OL iireTifxrfcras, ttolov TLva yjrrf etvat tov dvbpa xai ri
iTTLTrfbevtLV KaX ue'xpt Tv> ât 7rpeo-/3vrepoi> Kat vecoTtpov 488
ovra. iyco ydp et rt utj 6p6co$ 7rpdrrco fcara tov fSiov tov
ifxavTOv, av l<t6l tovto otl ov\ iKcov iap,apTavco dAA' dp.adiq
rfj ifxfj <rv ovv, cocnrep 7/p<fco vov6ztzlv ue, fxr) aTrocrTffS,
akk' LKavS>$ fxoL j-vbdLâL t'l zcttlv tovto e7rir7/8eure'oy juot, 5

Kat ru>a tpottov KTi](raip.r]v dv avTo, Kal idv /xe kdfSfjs vvv
p.iv (tol 6p.okoyrfcravTa, iv 8e rco vcrTtpbi XP V<? M^ Tavra
TrpdrTovTa aVeo (ofxokoyrfcra, irdvv /xe 7/you /3AaKa etyat Kat "^f
p.r]KTL 7rore' ue youc9er7/cr7/s vo-Tepov, cos fxrfbtvbs d^Lov ovra. b
e dpxfis oe' uot e7rayaAa/3e 7rcos <pr]s to bUaLov \LV kol
C 5 iir^Kovcra, B T P inri\Kovo-a : F d 3 TauTct Ficinus {idem te mihi

consilium dantem) TouTa B T P : : TauTa TauT' F d 6 b\iyov B T f
6\lya> P : om. F d7 vvvl B T F vvv P : 64 crvvex *>pr)~<* F c
ffv B T : 0-01 F : om. P 65 vepiovffia F irapovffia B T P : 66 tj
(T^BTPF: ffb vulg. eg tico B T P riva itdtc F : a6 idv fxt

F : âx ^BT: iav P : ^y yt f b /cal
2 BT P tc F <ri/ : trtJ
488b 11AATX2N02
crv kcu Tlivbapos to Kara (pvcnv; dyuv ftiq rbv KpetrTco ra
tcov rjTTovoiV Kal dp^tiv tov /3eArtco tS>v yjeipoviav Kal nXiov
5 Zx*iv T0V duetyco tov (pavXoripov; p.r\ rt dAAo Aeyets rb
bimiov etWt, r\ 6p6S>s p.p.vt]p.ai;
KAA. 'AAAd ravra eAeyoy Kal totc koX vvv Ae'yco.
2X2. YloTepov 8e rbv avrbv /3eArtco KaAets crv Kat Koetrrco;
C ovbe ydp rot tot olos r ?/ fxaOziv o~ov rC 7rore Ae'yots.

TTOTtpov rovs icryyporipovs Koetrrous KaAets /cat det aKpoa-
crQai tov io-\vporepov tovs dcrflepeoTepous, otoV juot doKets
xat tot evbetKVvcrdai., cos at //.eydAat 7ro'Aets e7rt rds o-puKpas
5 Kard rd cpvcrei. biKaiov epôyrat, drt Koetrrovs et<rti> Kat
icryypoTtpai, cos rd /cpetrroy /cat rd icryypoTtpov koX /3e'Artoy
ravTov ov, rj ecrrt /3eArtco /utey eu>at, 77'rrco Se Kat acrOevi-
crrepov, ml Koetrrco picv etrat, p.oy6r}poTipov bi' rj 6 avrbs
d dpos ecrrty tov fiekriovos koX tov KpeiTTovos; tovto /xot
atrd cracp(2s btopicrov, tovtov r) erepov ecrrtv rd KpeiTTOV Kal

rb /3eArtov Kat rb icryypoTtpov;
KAA. 'AAA' eyco crot crac^cos Ae'yco, ort ravrov kcrriv.
5 2X2. Ovkow 01 7roAAot rov kvbs Kpetrrous etVtv Kara

(pvcnv; 0% br) koI tovs vop,ovs rttfevrai eVt tco kvi, cocnrep
Kat crv dprt lAeyes.
KAA. ITcos yap ov;
2X2. Td T(2v 7roAAcoy apa v6pu.p.a ra tG>v KpurTovoiv
10 ecrrty.
KAA. Ylavv ye.

e 2X2. Ovkovv ra. rS>v /3eArtoVcoi>; ol yap Kpetrrovs /3eA-
rtovs 7roAi Kard rbv abv Xoyov.
KAA. Nat'.
2X2. Ovkovv ra tovtojv rd/ut/xa Kard (pvaiv KaAd, Kpeir-

5 tovoov ye ovtmv;
b4 wXeoj'] irAerov BTP : ir\tlw F b7 e\ yo' secl. Schanz

#
C 1 t i} F (t' e? f ) : t' i}t BT : r ^v P \4yom F : A.e'<y<" BTP

c3 6*o/ce?s] 4S6kus Coraes c 6 ko.1 rb F ical B T : P 07^
TPF :
B e a woXi. BT P F *ov Hermann
:
ropriAS 488e
KAA. il>r)(i(.
2212. *Ao' ovv 61 ttoWoI vop.i(pvcrLV ovtcds, cos apri av <rv
eAeyes, bUaiov dvai to lctov e\*LV Kal alo-îov to d8tKeu>

tov abiKeladat; eo-riv ravra r/ ov; Kal oVcos /u?) dAcocrr/ 489
evravda crv av alcryyvppLZVos. vop.i(pvcrLV, r/ ov, ol ttoWol
to Xcrov cx LV dAA' ov T 6 irXiov biKaiov zlvai, kol atcr-^LOV
to abiKelv tov d8iKetcr0ai; fxi] (p66vL uot aTTOKpCvacrdaL

tovto, KaAAucAets, %v, kav uot duoAoyr/crr/s, /3e/3aicocrcouai 5
7/817 7Tpa crov, are LKavov avbpos bLayvS>vaL a>p.okoyrjKOTOS.
KAA. 'AAA' ol ye 7roAAot vop.L(pvcrLV ovtois.
Si2. Ov vop.<ti apa p.6vov Icttlv alcryj.ov to abLKHLV tov
abLKCLcrOai, ovbt bUaLov to lcrov zyf.LV, dAAd Kal (pvcniL- b
cocrre KLvbvvveLs ovk akr)6ri Ae'yetu kv rots Trpocrdzv or38e
opddis euorj KarrjyopeLV Aeycou ort kvavTLOV ecrrty 6 vop.os
kol r/ (pvcrLS, a 8r) Kat eycb yrous KaKOvpyG* kv toIs Ao'yots,
kav ueV tls Kara (pvcrLV Ae'yr/, e7rt tov vop.ov dycoy, eay 8e' 5
rts Kara vop.ov, eirt Trjv cpvcrLV.
KAA. Ovrocrt avrjp ov 7ravo"erat cpkvap&v. et7re' uot, S

ScoKpares, ovk alcryyvr\ rr/AiKOuros wv cWuara 6r\ptva>v, kol
kav tls pr/|uart ajuaprrj, epp.aLov tovto 7rotorJuei>os ; eue yap C

otet aAAo rt Ae'yeti> to Koetrrous elvaL r/ to /3eArtous; ov
7raAai crot Ae'yco ort tovtov c/jr/ut etvat r6 /3e'Artoi> Kat to
KptLTTov; r/ otet ue Aeyetis ear avpfcTos (rvWgyfj 8orJAcoz>
Kat 7rayro8a7rcoy av6p(aira>v ur/Sei^ds dtcov 7rAr/y tcrcos rco 5

crcouart Lo-yyplo-acrdaL, Kat ovtol cpaxrLV, avTa. raSra eirat
io'utua;
2i2. Etey, co oooicorare KaAAtxAets* ovrco Ae'yets;
KAA. ndVv uey ovy.

212. 'AAA' eyob ue'y, co 8atuo'yte, Kat ariros 7raAat ro7rd(fco d
tolovtov tl (r Xt-yt-LV to KptLTTov, Kal dêpcorco yAixd/xeros
cra(pa>s ei'8eVat ort Ae'yets. orj ydp 8r/7rou 07J ye rovs 8rJo
a2 oS F : om. BTP a5 j8/3aiw(rw/toi TF : $tfiaiw<ro/iai re

vera BP b6 v6/jloi> F : t^ v6fiov BTP c 4 (rw\A.7]) B T Pf
2
:
avKKtyp B : <ru Aeyr; F C6 ai-ra] arra ci. Heindorf

489d nAATX2N02
(iekrCovs fjyfi tov evos, ovbe tovs crovs bovkovs fiekrCovs
5 aov, ort iayypoTepoC eicrw r) <rv. dkkd irdkLV ef dpyrjs eiire
tl trore Aeyet? tovs j3ekrCovs, e7ret8r/ ov tovs icryypoTepovs;
Kal & davpdcrLe irpqorepov p.e TrpobCbacrKe, tva p.r) d7rocfJoirr/crco
irapa crov.
e KAA. Elpcovevrj, 2> 2co/c/)are?.
2X2. Ma tov Zrjdov, <o KaAAucAet?, cp o-v yj>cop.evos irokka

vvvbr) eipcovevov irpos pe' dAA' t#i eiire, Ttvas keyeis tovs
fiekTCovs etmi;
5 KAA. Tovs dp.eCvovs Zycoye.
2X2. 'Opqs apa drt crv avrbs 6v6p.ara keyeLs, brjkols be
ovbev; ovk epets, tovs /3eArtous Kal KpeCrrovs iroTepov tovs
<ppovLp.coTepovs Aeyeis i) dkkovs tlv6s;
KAA. 'AAAa val p.a ACa tovtovs keyco, Kal <r<p6bpa ye.
49 2X2. rToAAd/as dpa eXs (ppovcov pvpCcov p.rj <PpovovvTcov

KpeCTTcov ecrTiv /card tov <tov koyov, koX tovtov dpye.LV oet,
tovs o' apyecrOai, /cat irkeov eyjetv tov apyovTa tcov dpyo-
p.evcov tovto ydp p.OL boKels \3ovkecrdaL keyeLV /cat ov
5 prjparL drjpevco et 6 eXs tcov pvpCcov KpeCrTcov.
KAA. 'AAAd raiir' la-riv & Aeyco. tovto yap oXp.aL eyco
to bCâLov elvaL cpvcreL, to /3eArtco ovra /cat <ppovLp<oTepov

Kal dpyeiv Kal irkeov ZyeLV t>v <pavkorepcov.
b 2X2. "Eye br) avrov. tC Trore av vvv keyeis; eav ev
rco avrcp cop.ev, cocnrep vvv, 7roAAot ddpooL, /cat r)puv ?/
ev kolvco Trokka o-trCa Kal Trord, oop-ev be TravTobairoC, ol
piev icryvpoC, ol b' dcrdevels, ets be r)p.cov r/ <ppovLp.<oTepos
5 irepl Tavra, iarpbs <ov, r/ 5e', oXov et/co'?, tcov piev icryypoTepos,
tcov be dcrdevecrTepos, dkko tl r/ ovtos, (ppovip.oiTepos r)p.(2v
(ov, /SeArtcoy Kat KpeCrrcov ecrrat et? Tavra;
d6 rlB T P Jrt F : : rivas Routh (quos Ficinus) &(\riovs F W :
$e\ricrrovs BTf 2 fih B T P F ov na Hermogenes

: as p-f)-
ixari B T P F (>i)fj.ara
: vulg. : f>r)/j.drta Badham a 7 rh] rbv Madvig
b2 kdpooL scripsi :avQp6oi F (tivdpwiroi 6vrts ut videtur f ) : adp6oi
&v8p<i)Troi BT: &v6pwiroi adp6oi P (ppovi/xwrepos b4 BTPf:
<ppovtfj.os F b6 (ppovifuararos F
:
TOPriAS 490b
KAA. Yldvv ye.
212. 'H OVV TOVTCOV T(2v CTLtCcoV TT\4oV TjfX&V KTOV avrS, c
otl j3(X.tCoov kcrrCv, r) rco pikv dpytLV TravTa Znelvov 8et vip.LV,
iv rw oe ava\Lo~KLV re aura Kal KaTaxprjcrOaL ets t6 kavrov

cr&pa ov irkoveKTr\TOV, et /X7/ pikkeL (j)pLovcr9aL, dkkd t<2v
pev irkiov, tmv 8' ekarrov eKTeov iav be Tvyrj irdvTOiv 5
ao-OevdvTaTos o>v, ttolvtcov eAd)(i0TOi> rco /3eArtcrrco, co KaA-

AtKAets; ov^ ovtcos, d>yade;
KAA. Ilept criria, Aeyets, Kat 7rora Kat tarpovs Kat cpkva-
pias' eyco bk ov ravra Aeyco. d

212. YIoTcpov ov tov cppovLp\(j)Tepov /3eArtco Aeyets; cpd0L
V M-
KAA. 'Eycoye.
212. 'AAA' ov roy /SeArtco irkiov beiv ix (lv > 5
KAA. Ov ctltCoov ye ovoe 7ror<3z'.
212. May0di>co, dAA' to-cos t//,artcoy, Kat oet roi> vcpavTL-

KtoTarov pAyLarov lp.aTLOv eêty Kat 7rAetora Kat KaAAtcrra
dp.-nexdp-tvov 7re/HteVai;
KAA. rioiW t/xartW; io
212. 'AAA' ets v7ro0T///ara brjkov ort 8et 7rAeoi>eKreu> tov

cppovLp,(oTaTov ets ravTa kol /3e'Aricrroi\ tov crKVTOTopov e
tcrcos Lte'ytcrra 8et virobr)p.aTa Kat 7rAetcrra v7ro6ede/xeVoi/
7rept7rarety.
KAA. ITota virobr)p.aTa; cpkvapeis 'x

o)Vt
212. 'AAA' et p.r) ra rotaCra Aeyets, tcrcos tcl rotdoe* otoi> 5

yecopytKoy dvbpa 7rept y?7i> cppovLp.6v re Kat KaAoz> Kat dyadov,
tovtov br) tcrcos bel 7rAeoi>eKrea> rcoy crirepp.dTOiV Kal <as
7rAetcrrco cnreppaTL yj>r)crdaL ets rr^y avrou yT/y.
c3 t<J> 5e BTPF : 5e t< scr. recc. e 4 peWei T 2 P /utAAt?:
BTF 07 wyaOe Callicli tribuit Hirschig c 8 wepl B T P F

ri 5 Vind. 21 et suprascr. b d.2 oi> BF : oSeTPf d.5 Stlv
: T
B F 5e? (sed suprascr. 1) : ye Se7v P 6.6 ov] a\\' ov Cobet
d. 7 Kal B T P f om. F : e 1 <ppoviix<SiTrov F : (ppovijxdirtpov BTP
e4 f x>v B T P f \4ywv F :
PLATO, VOL. III. 21

:
490 e nAATX2N02
KAA. *X2s det ravrd Aeyets, a> 2coKpares.
10 212.Ov p,6vov ye, co KaAAtKAets, dAAa Kat 7rept rcoi>
avrtov.
491 KAA. Nr) rovs Ofovs, drex*><>s y* &*L o-Kvrzas re Kat

Kvacpias Kal payetpous Ae'ycoz> Kat tarpovs ovbev iravr], cos
7rept tovtoov r)pXv ovra tov koyov.

2X2. Ovkovv o~b epets 7rept tIvojv 6 Kpctrru-v re Kat
5 (ppozn/xcorepos irXiov eyoav StKatcos TrAeozêKrei; 17 ovre epou
V7ro/3dAAorros dve'^77 ovr' avrds epets;
KAA. 'AAA' lycoye Kat 7rdAat Ae'yco. ttp&tov p.ev tovs
KpetTTOVS ot elcnv ov crKVTOT6p.ovs Aeyco ovSe /xayetpovs, dAA'
b ot av ets ra r^s 7rdAecos 7rpdy/xara cpp6vip.ot Sxrtv, ovTiva h\v
TpoiTOV eu otKotro, Kat pr/ p.6vov <ppovip.oi, dAAd Kat avbpetoi,

tKarot dvres a dz> vor/crcocrty e7rtreAeu', Kat p.r) a.TTOKap.vojcn
bia paAaKtay rr/s ^vyjis.
5 2X2. 'Opas, co /3e'Artcrre KaAAtKAets, cos ow Tavra crv t

epotS KaTriyopeis Kal eyco croS; cru p.ev yap e/xe c/>r)s det
ravra Aeyeu>, Ka /xe'/xc/)r/ /xor eyco 8e croS Tovvavrtov, drt
ovhtTtoTe TavTa Ae'yets 7rept rcov avT&v, dAAd rore /xez; rovs
C /3eArtois re Kat Kpetrrovs rovs lcryypoTepovs copt^bu, aS0ts
de rous </>pow/xcore'poi>s, vvv d' aw erepdz; n r/Kets tyusv
avbpaoTtpot tivcs vtto crov Ae'yoz/rat 01 Kpetrrous Kat 01
/3eArtous. dAA', coyafle', dircbv d7raAAdyr/0i rtvas ttotc- Aeyeis

5 rois /3eArtous re Kat Kpetrrovs Kat ets drt.
KAA. 'AAA' clpr)Ka ye eycoye rovs <ppov(p.ovs ets
ra rr/s 7rdAecos irpayp.aTa Kat avbpetovs. tovtovs yap

d 7rpocrr/Ket rcor 7ro'Aecoi> apxêiv, Kal rd bUaiov tovt
kcTTtv, irXeov
^X LV tovtovs tG>v dAAcov, rovs dpxorras rcoi'
dp)(op,e'vcoy.
a 1 oTex^ws T P F ^Tex^s B : a2 nvcupeas B T P (sed /c ex 7 T)

yvaQeas F (sed ki/ supra 7^ f) d>s] Sxnrep Baiter a3 ovra re
vera BPFt: T oT a4 irtpl secl. Hirschig a5 ^TPF: om.
B (sed suprascr. B ) 2
b5 oi> raiira TP : ovt' avra. B : 011 ra. avra. F
b 8 r6re B P F t<Jt*
: T c i fitXrlcrrovs P 07 TojJrouy BTPf :
rovrots F
TOPriAS 49id
22. Tt 8e'; avrcov, co eratpe, rt; ?} rt apyovTas r) apx-

p.evovs; 5
KAA. ITco? Aeyet?;
212. "Eva (Kaa-Tov Ae'yco aurdi' eaurot; apyovTa' rj rovro

uei> ov8er 8et, ambv kavTov apyatv, tG>v 8e akKoiv;
KAA. n<5? eai>rou apyovTa Aeyet?;
212. OiSey ttoikL\ov aAA' coo-7rep ol irokXoi, croicppova 10
oVra xat lyKparq avrbv havrov, T<av rjbovoiv Kal Trt6vpn6~)V
.apyovTa t>v ev eaurcp.

KAA. '12? fjbbs et* rov? t/AictYojj? Ae'yet? rou? aoiqbpovas.
2X2. n<5? ydp [ot/]; ov8et? ocrri? ovk av yvoir\ ort ov tovto
Ae'yco.
KAA. Ilaru ye crcpobpa, o> 2coK/>are?. e7ret 7rco? b\v 5

nvbaip.oiv yivovro av6poi7ro$ bovXevoiv oroiovv; dAAd rour
ecrri> t6 /card qbvcrtv Ka\6v Kal bUatov, o eyco crot vvv irap-
pqataCoptevos Ae'yco, ort 8et tov opd&s fitoicrop.Vov rd? pikv
TTtdvp.ias rd? kavrov iav co? /xeytVra? etât /cat /ut^ KoAdêty,
raurat? 8e cb? /^teytVrat? o?jcrai? tKaz>di> etVat inrqptTelv 8t' 49 2
avbpdav Kal <pp6vrio-tv, Kal airoTrtp.TTkavat 3>v av det t) e7rt-
dvpia yiyvr\Tat. aXka tovt otuat rot? 7roAAot? ov bvvarov

66(v xj/tyovo-tv tovs Totovrovs bt alcryvvqv, aTtoKpvnTopmvot
ti]v avriov abvvap.iav, Kal alcrypov 8t/ cpacrtv etWt ti]V clko- 5
AacnW, o7rep kv rot? irpoadev eyco eAeyor, bov\ovp.evot tovs
/3eAriot>? rqv cpvcrtv ctvdpoiTrovs, Kal avrol ov bvvap.evot

KTropiô-6at rat? rjbovals Tr\f)poicrtv iiratvovcrtv Tqv croicppo-
crvvqv koX Ti]v btKatocrvvqv 8td Tqv avrcor ctvavbpiav. e7ret b

dcrot? e apyrjs VTrrjpêv r) /3acrtAeW vicrtv etrat r) avTOvs rf/
cpvcret tKavovs kKiropicraadat a.pyi)V Ttva r) rvpavviba r) bvva-
d. 4 avrup BT : avruv WF ri ; ^ ti] ti ^ ti B : ri f} rtT WF :
&r)/ Olympiodorus (Callicli tribuens) ipxoâj ^ apxontvovs

TWF : apxofiwovs B (^ tois opx o,/Taj K *l apxofJ-evovs in marg. rec. b)
e3 oi; secl. Routh Alexander
oo-tis ayvooi-rj ov rovro P F Alex-
ander : ov rovro ** (sed toC ex emend.) T outw : B a2 rf] lv P
a6 irp6o-0ev BPF : tuTcpoffdfv T b2 oVois F : Otorr BTP 5 ofs
W
:
: y oTs f et rec. b : to?s t b3 tKiropiffaffdai BTP : itopiaaffOai F

21*
492b IIAATX2N02
crreiav, (rt av) rfj akr]0eiq aXcryj.ov nal kclklov eXi} crtocppo-
5 avvrjs Kal bLKaLOcrvvris tovtols toIs av0po)TTOLS, oXs ebv

aTTokaveiv to>v aya0a>v Kal p.rjbevbs ep.TTobu>v ovtos, avrol
eavrols h0"noTr\v eirayayoLVTO tov t5>v irokkwv avOpcoiruiv
vop.ov re Kal koyov kol \poyov; rj tt<2>s ovk hv adkioi yeyovores
C eXev vrrb tov Kakov tov rrjs bLKaLocrvviis Kal rrjs aoxppocrvvrjs,
p.r)bev irkeov vepLOvres rots cpikois toXs avT&v 7/ rots e)(0poLs,
Kal Tavra apyovTes ev rrj eavrS>v Trokei; akka rfi akr)0eiq,
0) 1,U>KpaTS, fjV CpTjS CTV bLO)KLV, (58' e\eL' TpVCpr) Kal O.KO-
5 Aaerta ml ekev0epia, eav eiTLKOvpiav e\r), tovt Icttlv apeTi)
re kol evbaLp,ovia, tcl be akka tovt ccttlv tcl Kakko>Tricrp.aTa,
tcl irapa cpvcrLV crvv0t)p.aTa av0po>7TO)v, cpkvapia Kal ovbevbs

ata.
d 212. Ovk ayevv5>s ye, u> KaX\i/cA.et?, eireêpxt) tu> koyo>
TTapprjcrLa(6p.evos' cracpa>s yap crv vvv keyeis a ol akkoL

bLavoovvraL p.ev, keyeLV be ovk e0ekovcrLV. beop.aL ovv eyo>
crou p.r)bevl Tpoiru> avelvaL, Xva tu> ovtl KaTabrjkov yevi)TaL
5 ttu>s fiLooTeov. Kai poi keyc ras piev eTTL0vp.ias cpf)s ov

KokacrTeov, el p.ekkeL tls olov bel eXvai, eu>VTa be avras a>?
p.eyio-Tas TrkrjpoxrLV avTaxs ap.60ev ye iro0ev eroi/Aaeu>, /cat
e roCro eXvaL Trpj apeTrjv;
KAA. r)pLi ravra eyu>.
212. Ovk apa 6p0u>s keyovrai oi p.rjbevbs beop.evoL evbai-
p.oves eXvaL.
5 KAA. Ot ki0oL yap civ ovtu> ye kclI ol veKpol evbaL-
p.ovecrTaTOL eXev.
2X2. 'Akka p.ev br} Kal u>s ye <rv keyeis beivbs 6 /3ios.
b4 rlhv Woolsey B T P F (add. ri in marg. rec. b)

: om. b 5 k a\
SiKaioirwTjs F : b 6 avrol F avro?s B T P (sed a erasum
om. BTP :
in B) b 7 kavrots om. P iir&yoivro P b 8 ko! \6yov seel.

ci. Schanz C 1 etrjo-av B T P F rov rrjs <r<t><ppoo-vvi)s Ka\ SiKaio-
avvrts F c6 iffr\v] &pa Schanz d.7 afiSdev (sic) F: ifioOtv f:
dKKoOev BTP e2<?7c6BTP: \eyu F e 5, 6 av . . .
thv F av : uffiv B T P
. . 5^. dfftv Schanz : 67 SjBTPF
. . .
Stobaeus Sv Badham
: iriiBTP: <rv ye F
.
TOPriAS 492e
ov yap rot davp.aCoip.' av et EvpLTrCbrjS dkrjdfj ev ToicrSe
Ae'yet, Ae'ycoi>
rCs 8' otSei>, et rb rjv p.iv ecrrt Kardavclv, 10
ro Kardavelv 8e t/V;
Kat r/ju.ets' rw dVrt tcrcos Tidvap.ev 7/877 y^P T0U iy^ye Kat 493
r]Kovo-a rcov ao(p<2v cos ytli' 7/uets Ti6vap.ev Kal to p.\v
oS>\xd ko-Tiv fjpuv o-fjp.a, tt/s 8e ^vxfjs roCro eV co e7rt-
6vp.CaL etcrt rvyxavet 6V 0101 avaTrtCOecrdai Kal uera7rt7rreu'

ara) Karco, Kat rotSro apa tls p.v6okoywv Kop.\}/6$ avrjp, tcrcos 5
StKeAov rts 7) 'IraAtKo'?, irapdycov rco cW/xart 8ta ro tn6av6v

re Kat tihlo-tlkov d>v6p.ao- ttC6ov, tovs 8e droT/roD? d/xw/ro7js,
rcoy 8' dôT/rcoi; roSro rfjs ^VXV^ v a<L *Tu6vp.Cai etat, b
to aKokao~TOv avrov Kal ov areyavov, cos TiTpr\p.ivos et?/
tiC6os, 8td r7/y dirkrjo-TCav d7retKacras. tovvovtCov 877 otiros
crot, co KaAAtKAet?, ivbeUvvrai cos rcoy ei> "AiSod ro dt8es

877 kiya>v 01/rot d#Aicoraroi dy etez>, 01 ap.vr)Toi, Kal qbopolev 5
ety rov TTprjp,ivov irC6ov vb(op erepcp rotourco TeTprjp.iva>
Kocnctvco. ro 8e koo-klvov apa Aeyet, cos ec/)7j 6 7rpos e/xe
kiyu>v, T7/i> yf/vxw eiz>at* tt/i 8e \j/v)(f)v koo-kCv(o airfiKao-ev C

ttjtj rcoy dyoT/rcoy cos TTprjp.ivr}v, olt^ ov bvvap.ivrjv 0-Tiys.1v
81' aino-TCav re Kat kfjdrjv. TavT e7rieiKcos /ae'p ecrrtv VTro'
e8 toi F Stobaeus: n BTP Iamblichus e 10 8' BTPf:

om. F a 1 ^Srj yap F Iamblichus Stobaeus B T P '6irep : rjtiri :
fjSf} vulg. a3 ai iiriQvfxiat. F a4 (8rt) rvyxdvei c ^

H. Richards a 5 &vw Karo> B P F Iamblichus Stobaeus SVw :
Kal k6.tu T a6 a-iKe\6s BTP: <rtKe\iK6s F Iamblichus Olym-

piodorus Stobaeus tra\tK6s BTPF
Stobaeus: ira\iK6s rts
Iamblichus a7 rretcrrtKbv Stobaeus Iam-
F: m<rriKbv BTP
blichus b 1 5' vel Se B T P F Iamblichus Stobaeus secl. :
Madvig avoT)Twv F Iamblichus Stobaeus aixv^rwv B T P ai :
B T P F Iamblichus om. Stobaeus : b 2 (5m) rb a.K6\a<rrov

ci. Heindorf avrov om. Sauppe rb (rreâ'^' secl. . . .
Hirschig b4 ajSes F (cf. Phaed. 79, a 4 et passim) aeiSes :
B T P f Stobaeus ariSh Iamblichus : b 5 av ehv B T P f ehv :
Stobaeus elo-\v F Iamblichus

: b 6 JJSwp] olvov Stobaeus rerpri-
fievw secl. Hirschig c 2 ttj^ rerprififvriv secl. Cobet
. . . c 3 St'
. .\r)Or)v secl. Cobet
. amo-riav] ait\r)o-riav ci. Schleiermacher
imeiKws secl. Cobet
493 c IIAATJ2N02
rt aroira, brj\ol p,r)v o eycb /3o?jAouai o~ot eivoeicfdueuos, idv
5 7rcos otds re co, ireicrai. p.-\TaQio~Qat, dvrl tov d7rA?/o-rcos nal

dKoAdorcos (ôvtos tSCov tov Kocrptcos nal rots det Trapovatv
LKav&s Kal kâpKovvTOiS eyovTa [3Cov eAe'cr#ai. dAAd Trdre-
d pov -reCOto tC ae Kal uerart$ecr0at -ivbatp.ovtaTipovs tlvai

y
tovs Koap.Covs tS>v aKokdo~TO)V, r) ovb av dAAa 7roAAd
Totavra p.vdo\oyS>, ovbiv tl udAAof uera0?jcr??;
KAA. Totrr' dA??0e'o-repoiv etp??Kas, S> ScoKpares.
5 212. e'pe brj, dAA??z> aot eiKora Ae'yco e/c tov avrov
yvp.vaaCov r?) iw. o-K07rei yap et rotoVSe Aeyets 7rept tov
(3Cov kKarepov, tov re aoicppovos Kal tov aKokdaTov, olov
et bvolv avbpotv eKarepcp 7ri#ot TroAAot eteiv Kat rco pkv
e ere'pco vytets Kat 7rAr/pets, 6 uev oizjojj, 6 de ue'Atros, 6 8e
ydAaKros, Kat aAAot 7roAAot 7roAAct>j>, vdp.aTa be airdvta Kat
XaAe7rd eKacrroi) tovtcov et?j Kat perd 7roAAcoz; ttovojv Kal
XaAe7r<Sy eK7ropt(fdpeva 6 uey ow erepos TrAr/pcocrdueivos
5 p?/r' e7roxerevot p?/re rt <ppovTCoi, dAA' eyeKa rovrcoi;
r)avyj.a.v ^x -' T H- ^
^P^ ra ueJ; vdptaTa, toairep Kat
eKetVco, 8?jzvard pez> 7ropCea6at, x.
a ^ e7ra & e > ra &' dyyeta
TtiTprip,va Kat o~adpd, dvayKaôiTO 8' det Kat vvKra Kal
494 i)p.-\pav Tnp.TTkdvai avrd, rj rds eo^dras A?j7rotro A?j7ras'
dpa rotodrou kKaTtpov ovtos tov /3Cov, Aeyets rdz> ro?j oko-
Adorou vbat,p.ovo~Tpov etvat ?/ rdz> ro?j Koap.Cov; TTtCOto
tC cre rat)ra Ae'ycoz> cruyxcopi/crai rdz> Koap.tov /3toy ro?3
5 dKoAdorot) duetz>co etz>at, r/ od Treiflco;
KAA. Od 7ret0eis, co 2coKpares. rco pei> ydp 7rAr/pco-
crapeVco eKetVco ovkct o~tlv fjbovi] ovbep.Ca, dAAd roCr
C 4 StjAo? )uV T f Iamblichus $r)Koi/xriv F 8?j\or /xei/ B (5e suprascr.

: :
b) P d i /x-TaTtdeadai BTPf:
/terafleVflat F: fitTaTiO-aai scr.
recc. d 2 0118' ac &\\a Sauppe oiiSe' a\\a B T ovdev a\\' : :
hv P ouSe a.\\a F ovSiv dAAa :&' t

: : d 4 a\i~Qio-T(pov B T P :
a\r\d(GTaTov F Olympiodorus e2 /cal x a^- e7r sec l- Morstadt

e 7 eVetf B T P f e'/cet F
cfi e 8 8' dei F Iamblichus d(0ei B T P
: :
(aJ ante dj/ayKaôtTo add. vulg.) a 2 ticaTtpov B T P F : om.

Iamblichus efcarepy scr. recc.
: a 7 ovk4t P ou/c e'rt F ouk tT* : :
B : ovk T
;
TOPriAS 494a
Zcttlv, o vvvbr) eyd> eAeyov, rd cocnrep KCdov (ijv, (TTHbav
ir\r}p(tio-j), /XTjre yaipovTa ert p.r)T kvnovp.evov. dAA' iv b
roirrco kcrTXv to i)bio)S rjv, kv ru cos 7rAetd-roy (TTipptlv.
2212. Ovkovv avayKr] y , av irokv ki:ippir\, tto/\v Kal to

aiuov ilvai, Kal peydA' aTTa tcl Tpr)p.ara eti>at rats (Kpoais;
KAA. Yldvv pikv ovv. 5
212. Xapaoptorj Tiva av <rv fiCov Aeyets, dAA' ov veKpov

ovbe \l6ov. Kai p.oi Ae'ye* rd rotoVSe Ae'yets oiotj Trtivrjv
Kal irtLv&vTa o-6Ulv;

KAA. "Eycoye.
212. Kat bL^/rjv ye Kat bL\j/o)VTa ttlvclv; C_
KAA. Ae'yco, Kat tcls dAAas Tii6vp.Las airdo-as exwra
Kal bvvdp.evov 7rAr/porjVra yaLpovTa evbaLp.6vo>s r}v.
212. Erjye, co /3e'Arta-re* 8tare'Aet ydp a>o"irep r/pco, Kal
6tto>s pr/ a7raio*;(WT7. 8et be, cos eotKe, p.r)b' e/xe a7rat- 5
ayyv6r)vaL. koX irpooTov p.\v enre et Kat xj/oop&VTa ko.1
Kvr)o%S)VTa, dtpdovoos \ovTa tov KvrjcrdaL, KVo>p.tvov 8ta-

reAoJjyra tov [3lov erjoatpoVcos' eort r)v.
KAA. '12s otottos et, co ^coKpares, Kat aTexv&s brj^yopos. d

212. Totydprot, ct> KaAAtKAets, ncoAov pkv kcu Top-
ytay Ka\ eêVAr/â Kat ato-^weo-ât kiTOvqo-a, o~v 8e orj /xr/
eK7rAayr/s orjSe pr/ ato-xw^r/s* di>opeTos ydp et. dAA' a7ro-

Kpivov p.6vov. 5
KAA. 4>tijuu tolvvv Ka\ tov Kvo>p.tvov rjbicos av /3tcoi>at.
212. Ovkovv et7rep r)beo)s, ko.\ erjSaipoVco?
KAA. ndw ye.
212. Uorepov et Tr)v KecpaXrjv p.6vov Kvrjo-Lco r/ Irt rt e

o"e epcorco; dpa, a KaAAtKAets, rt airoKpLvfj, kdv tls ae
b1 rr\ripwo-r) BTPF : K\r)pwcrr)Tai vulg. : TrArjpwflf) ci. Stallbaum

b3 7' &i BTP: iav F C2 C3 vKrtpovvra
awio-as om P
B T P F w\r)povi> Stephanus
: C 6 x^wpwvra B T P tywpiwvra :
F rec. t C 7 Kvqo-iwvra T P F nvqo-Tiwvra B d 1 ar(x vws ^ ^*

:
a.Tex vus B arexôs F

: d 3 ko\ ante 44ir\ria om. F d 4 oi>o'
011 jur; F e 1 Kvrio-iw Bekker kvtjo-ioI B T P KvriaOr) F
: :
e 2 aTTOKpivt? B arroKpivei T arroKpivr) P F

: :
494 e IIAATX2N02
ra eypp.eva tovtols e<peijs a-navTa epoirq. nal rovroiv
TOLovTcnv ovTOiv Ke<pg.katov, 6 tS>v KivaCboiv (3ios, ovtos ov
5 beLvbs Kal aiaypbs koX aOkios; r) tovtovs roAp^crets keyeLV
evbaip.ovas etvat, eav a<p66vois Ixcocrty &v beovTat;
KAA. Ovk aicryyvr) eis rotaSra ayoov, oa 2coKpares, tovs
koyovs;
2X2. *H yap eyco dyco evravOa, ct> yevvalt, r) eKelvos
io os av <pfj
avebrjv ovtco tovs yaipovras, birois av yaipoi<rtv,
495 evbaiptovas etvai, Kat p.r) btopi(jt]Tat tS>v r)bovu>v oTrotat

,
ayadal KaX KaKai; akk Irt Kat vvv keye iroTepov <prjs elvat
to avTO r)bv Kal ayadov, i) etvai rt tg>v rjbecav 6 ovk <ttlv

ayadov;
5 KAA. "Iva brj ptoL p.r) avop.okoyovp.evos f/
6 koyos, eav
erepov <prjo~oi etvat, to avTO <pr)p,t etvai.
2X2. Ata<pdeipts, 2 KaAAtKAeis, tovs irpoiTOVs koyovs,

Kai ovk av Irt per' ep.ov Ikov&s tcl ovra eerdbt?, enrep
7rapa ra boKOvvra <ravr& epetV.
b KAA. Kat yap <rv, a> 2coKpares.
2X2.Ov Toivvv opOois ttolS> ovt eyco, enrep 7rotco tovto,
ovTe a"6. akk\ aj /uaKapte, d#pet p.r) ov tovto fj
to ayaOov,
to TT&VTOis yaipeLV Tavra re ydp tcl vvvbr] aivtydevTa
5 7roAAd Kat ai<rypa <paiveTat <rvp./3aivovTa, et tovto ovrois
lx* l > Kai AAa 77oAAd.
KAA. 'Q,s <rv ye oteL, co 2coKpares.
212. 2v 8e rco ovtl, oi KaAAwcAet?, ravra i<ryypi(y;
KAA. "Eycoye.
C 212. 'TLiTLyeLpoip.ev apa rco Ao'yw cos crofi o-7rou8dwros;
KAA. Yldvv ye <r<pobpa.
e 3 4x4ficv] Bekker secl. Schanz

eirSfxeva ci. (ri) tovtwv
:
Buttmann e 4 Ke<pa\aioy F b Kpa\ai(av B T P Ke(pa\at6rarov

: :
fort. Antiatticista Bekkeri e 6 &<pdova F 67 roi/s Aoyovs

secl. Cobet e 10 aveSriv B T f avaiSrjv P F a 2 dyaSal /eai
W
:
P F of : cfyafla} Kal BT : 01 dyaflal Ka\ al a 5 /xTf avofio\oyov/xevos

BTP : firi 6/j.o\oyov/ji.cvos F :
yp. Ka\ avo/j.o\oyovfj.tvos Ka\ /J.r) 6/j.o\oyov'
faevos Olympiodorus b 5 iroWa secl. ci. Sauppe
;
TOPriAS 495C
2X2. "16l brj p.0L, eiret.br) ovtoi boicel, bteXov rdbe' em-
arr]\xy\v irov KaXels rt; KAA. v
Eya>ye 2X2. Ov nal av-
bpeiav vvvbi] ekeyes Tiva eXvai /xerd eTrLcrTr)p.r)s KAA. 5
"EXeyov ydp. 2X2. "AAAo tl ovv &>s erepov T7]v dvbpeiav

rr}$ 7ri(rrr/jur/s bvo Tavra ekeyes; KAA. 2<po'5pa
ye.
2X2. Tt be; r)bovr)v nal eirLo-Tr]p.7]v toiitov ?/ erepov;

KAA. "Erepov brjirov, a cro<pa>rare o~v 2X2. *H Kal dv- d
bpeiav erepav rjbovfjs; KAA. IT<3s ydp ov; 2X2. <J>e'pe br)
07ra)? p.ep.vr]cr6p.e6a ravra, otl KaAAtKA?/s ecpr) Ââpvevs

i]bb p.ev Kal dyaObv tovtov elvai, eTno-Tr]p.r\v be Kal dvbpeiav
Kal dAA?/Aa)j/ Kal tov dyaOov erepov. 5
KAA. 2a)Kparr7s be ye rjpuv 6 'AkojTreKrjdev ovx opoAoyet

Tavra. ?*/ opoAoyet;
2X2. Otj^ 6/xoAoyet' otpat be ye ovbe KaAAtKAi/s, orav e
avros avTov 6edo-r)Tai opd&s. enre ydp pot, tovs ev irpar-
TovTas roty kokcos TrpaTTovcnv ov Tovvavriov rjyfj TraOos
ireTrovOevai;
KAA. 'Eycoye. 5
9
2X2. Ap' ovv, eXirep evavria eoriv Tavra dAAr/Aois,
dvdyKT] irepi avra>v eêtv &o"rrep irepl vyieias eyei koX voaov;
ov ydp dp.a brjirov vyiaivei re kol vocrel 6 avdptoiros, oibe
dp.a a7raAAarrerat vyLeias re Kat voaov.
KAA. YlQis Aeyets; io
2X2. Olov Trepl otov /3ovAet tov o-u>p.aTos d7roAa/3a>i>
o-KoVet. yoo"et 7rot> dvdponros 6cp6aXp.ovs, a> ovop.a ocpdak- 496

pta;-KAA. YI<as ydp ov; 2X2. Ov br/irov Kal vyLaiveL ye
dp.a tovs avrovs; KAA. Ovb' diroio-TLovv. 2X2. Tt be
orav Trjs 6cp6akp.ias a7raAAarrr/rat; apa TOTe koI rrjs vyLeias
a7raAAarrerat tu>v 6cp6akp.S>v Kal Tekevr&v dp.a dpicpoTepoiv 5
d7rT/AAaKrat; KAA. "HKtora ye. 2X2. avp.do~Lov ydp
05 tlvai supra versum T c6 erfpov (hv~) Heindorf

d 2 tTtpov P d.5 aya8ov) ^Seos H. Schmidt d.6 Se 7 BTf:
5e PF e 11 otov B T P rov brov F (o\ov suprascr. f)
: airo-
\o/3oij/ BT P f ai/a\afHi)v F
: ai &vOpwnoi\ avOpwwos Bekker
;
496 b nAAT12N02
b ot/xat Kcti dkoyov yCyvcTav r) ydp; KAA. Scpobpa ye.
212. 'AAA' eV /xepet ot/xai kmTepov ml kap./3dvcL Kal airok-
Auet; KAA. <f>r]p,C. 212. Ovkovv Kal lcrxyv Kal dcrOcvcLav
cocravrcos; KAA. Nat. 212. Kat ra)(os Kal fipabvTrJTa;
5 KAA. Yldvv ye. .212. *H Kat rayadd ml rrjv cvbaLpovCav ml
rdvavTLa tovtcov, mm re Kat dOkLOTtiTa, iv jueoet kapLfSdvcL
Kat iv /uepet d7raAAdrrerat imrcpov; KAA. UdvTcos 8777701.
C 212. 'Edv evoco//ei> dpa drra coi> dp.a re d?TaAAdrrerai

dvOpcoTros Kal dp.a eêt, 877A01; ort ravrd ye otjk av etT/ ro'
re dya06v xat r6 mKov. 6p.okoyovp.zv ravra; ml ev p.dka

o-K^/dp.Vos aTTOKpLVov. KAA. 'AAA' virep<pvG>s <as 6p.o-
5 Aoyco.
212. "\6l brj eTTt ra zp.irpocrOzv <ap.okoyrjp.eva. rb ircLvrjv
eAeyes iroTcpov r)bv 77 dvLapbv etrat; avrb Aeyco ro TrcLvrjv.
KAA. 'AvLapov eycoye* ro pkvTOL TTCLV&vra icrdCcLV r)bv
d MavOdvco'
Aeyco. 212. dAA' ovi> to ye ircLvrjv avrb dvLapov.
77 KAA.
07j)(t; <t>r)p.L. 212. Ovkow Kat ro bL\jrrjv; KAA.
ndrepoy
2c/)o'Soa ye. 212. ovv ert TTAetco eocorco, 7} 6//oAoyeis
ml
diracrav evbciav iiTL6vp.Cav dviapbv etvai; KAA. 'Opo-
5 dAAd
Aoyco, p,r) epcora. 212. Etey 8t\^coyra 8e 8r/ ttCvclv
dkko tl r) r)bv <pr)s etvat; KAA. v

Eycoye. Ovkovv 212.
tovtov ov Ae'yet? rb p,cv 8tv/fcoyra kvirovp,cvov brjiTov ccttCv;
e KAA. Nat. 212. T8 8e ttlvc.lv TTkrjpaxrCs re Trjs evbeCas

m\ KAA. Ovkovv Kard
r)bovrj; Nat. 212. to itlvclv yaC-
pcLV keyeis; KAA. At^coyrd KAA. MdAtcrra. 212. ye.
r]p,L. KAA.
212. AviTovp.cvov Nat. 212. AiaOdvrj ovv
5 to <rvp.(3aLVov, otl kvTrovp.cvov yaCptLV Ae'yet? dp.a, orav
bL\\rS>vTa ttlvLV keyrjs; r) ov^ dp,a tovto yCyveraL mrd
b 1 yiyverai] eyiyver' av Sauppe i) BTPf : oi F b2 airo\-
\vei B T P airo\vei F
: air^Wvoî : Hirschig C2 &v6puiros'\
avQpanros Bekker ye om. P c4 B
vTrepcpvws
>s F W :
virep<pva>s T d
\eyu> Stallbaum
1 : na\u Badham ital iyh
ci. :
BTPF (Socrati tribuentes) 7^ al. : : secl. Ast d 5 Se 8rj]

Si) F d6 ?) om. Sauppe e 1 ir\7ipco<ris F ir^pys B T P
W
: :
ir\i)p7)
ropriAS 496 e
TOV aVTOV TOTTOV KCU \pOVOV LT tyvxi]S LT CTCOparOS
fiovku; ovbiv yap otpat 8tac/>e'pet. <ttl Tavra r) ov;

KAA. "Eo~tlv. 2X2. 'AAAd p.j]V ev ye irpaTTovTa kokcos
TrpaTTtLv ap.a abvvarov <pr)s ivai. KAA. <Pr)pu ydp. 2X2. 497
WvLoifjLfvov 8e' ye ya(pLV bvvarbv copoAdyrjKa?. KAA.
(
Pau/erat. 2X2. Ovk dpa t6 \a(pLV <ttIv v 7rpdrretz>
ovbe to avLaaOaL kcikco!,, u><tt Tpov y(yvTaL to r)bv tov

ayadov. 5
KAA. Ovk 010' drra <ro<p(r), > 2coKpares.

2X2. Otcrfla, dAAd aKKL^r), co KaAAtKAety Kat irpoLd( ye
ert ets ro p.irpocrdV, [otl \<>jV Ar/pets] tva dbfis ws <ro<pos
&v pe youêrets. ov^ dp.a bL\}/S)V re Kao~TOS r)p.G>v irk- b

Travrat Kai dp.a r)bop.Vos 8td tov ir(vLv;
KAA. Ovk ot8a drt Aeyets.
rOP. Mijdapcos, 5 KaAAtKAets, dAA' diroKp(vov Kal r)p.S>v
VKa, tva TrtpavOoiCTLV ol Adyot. 5

KAA. 'AAA' det tolovtos <ttlv 2coKpdr?js, a> Topyta*
<rp,LKpa kol dAtyou dta avtpajTq Kal eeAe'yxet.
rOP. 'AAAd rt crot 8ta<pe'pet; irdvTcos ov <rr) avrr) r) TLp.r\,
a> KaAAtKAets* dAA' vir6<r\S 2coKpdret eeAe'yat O7rcos clv
(3ov\r]TaL. 10
KAA. 'Epcora br) <rv rd <rp.LKpd re Kat crrefd raira, C

e7ret7rep Topy(q boKL ovrcos.
2X2. EvcWpcoz/ et, co KaAAwcAets, ort rd peydAa pe-

p.vr)<raL irpXv rd <rp.LKpd' eyco 8' ovk <ap.r)v 0p.LTOv etz>at.
dtêy odi; d7re'Ai7res airoKp(vov, et ovx dpa 7raverat bL\j/<2v 5
Ka<TTos r)p.<2v kol r)bop.vos. KAA. <t>r)p.(. 2X2. Ovkovv

Kal TrLV<av Kal t5>v aWoov TTL6vp.L<av Kal r)bovS>v dp.a
e 7 -)(p6vov BTPf : rp6irov F e 8 yap oT/j.o.1 BTPf: ydp /xoi F

a 1 <pr)s Baiter : 4<pr\s BTPF a 7 -np6iBi\ irpoi oiF a8 roH/xTrpo-
adev F oti fx> v Arjpe?j secl. Thompson : ri i'x a>v ^tpus scripsit et
Callicli tribuit Badham : post b3 Hermann post b 1
\tytis transp. :
vovdereTs Lamberton J8t}s F b 3 '6ri B T P ri F b 8 ov :
fTTj avTT) ^TWF: oijo-t) avTT] ^B cirtrBTP: om. F c 2 ovrws

Socrati tribuunt BP 05 airtMins B T P aire\fiirts F :
:
497 c I1AATX2N02
Traverat; KAA. "Ecrri ravra. Ovkovv 212. Kal tG>v XvnS>v
d Kal tS>v f)bovG>v ap.a 7raverat; KAA. Nat. 2X2. 'AAAa

p.f)v tG>v dya6G>v ye Kal KaK&v ov\ dp.a 7raverat, ws ov
co/xoAoyets' vvv b\ ov\ KAA.
6/uoAoyets;
v
Eycoye* tl
ovv or);
5 212. "Ort ov ra avrd yCyverai, co <ptAe, Taya$a rots

Tjbio-iv ovbe ra KaKa rots dzuaoots. tG>v pkv yap dp.a
7raverat, tG>v be ov, cos ere'pcoi> ovtcov ttG>s ovv ravrd av
etr/ Ta f)ba rois ayaOols f) ra aviapa rots KaKots; kav oe
fiovXr], Kal Trjbe kirCa-Kâi (otpai ydp crot ovbe ravrr\
e opoAoyetcrflar d<9pet 8e) rovs dyaflovs ovyJ dyaflcoy irapov-

aCq ayaOovs KaAets, cocr7rep tovs koAovs ofs av KaAAos
napfj; KAA. "Eycoye. 212. Tt 5e'; dyadovs avbpas KaAets
acppovas Ka\ btikovs; ov yap dprt ye, dAAd tovs avbpcCovs
5 Kat (ppovCpiovs eAeyes* 17 ov tovtovs ayaOovs KaAets;
KAA. Yldvv piev ovv 2X2. Tt 8e'; 7rat8a dvoriTov yaCpovra
v
fjbrj etoes; KAA. Eycoye 2X2. "Avbpa 5e ovttco etoes
dvor\rov yaCpovra; KAA. Otpat eycoye* dAAa rt tovto;

498 2X2. Ovbev dAA' aTroKptW KAA. ETbov 2X2. Tt oe;
vovv Zyovra X.V7rovp.vov ko.1 yaCpovra; KAA. $>r)p.C. (
2X2. Ildrepot 8e p.a\kov yaCpovcri Kal Xvnovvrai, ol tf>po-
vip.01 f) ol acppoves; KAA. Ot/xat eycoye ov ttoXv rt 8ta-
5 <pe'pea\ 2X2. 'AAA' dpKet Kat tovto. h 7roAe'pcp 8e i)br}
etSes dvbpa btikov; KAA. ITcos ydp ov; 2X2. Tt ovv;

dinovTcav tG>v 7roAe/xiW Trdrepot croi kboKovv p.d\\ov \aC-
peiv, ol SeiAot 17 01 dvbptloi; KAA. 'Ap<pdrepot epotye
b [p.aXkov]' et 8e p.r\, 7rapa7rAr/crtcos ye. 2X2. OvbXv bia<\>ipa.
d2 76 F : om. B T P om. F
BTP ov ra avra P F
d5 8ri : :
ov raura T : ov raura t : B
d 6 ad ovSh add. flrt in marg. t
aura
d 7 &s ertpwv ovtwv secl. Deuschle d 9 ttJSc T F et ex ri 5 P :
t^5 B ei 8('BF:8i)TPf e 4 &<ppovas B T F robs W :
&i>povas f 65 eKeyes T F b e\eyes B W

e 7 eUes B T P f
:
?$es F t fet mox) oiSirw B P F ovSeirw T a 3 TrSrepot F

t : :
Tr6repov B T W
b i fiaAKov B T P F om. al. djxoiws Sauppe : : :
post fiaWov intercidisse putavit 8' tcrws oi SeiAoi Hermann

;
TOPriAS 4g8b
yaipovcrtv 8' ovv kolL oi SetAoi; KAA. 2<po'8pa ye. 212.

Kal oi d<ppoves, o>s eoiKev. KAA. Nai. 212. TJpoo-tovToov
8e 01 8etAot povov kvirovvTat r/ KAA.

Kal oi dvbpetot; 'A/>t-
cpoVepoi. 212. *Apa 6/xotcos; KAA. MdAAoy to-co? oi 5
8etAot. 212. 'Attiovtmv 8' KAA.

ov pdAAoi> yaipovcrtv;
"Tcrcos. 212. Ovkovv kvTrovvrat pez> Kal yaipovcrtv /cat 01
dcppoves Kal oi <ppovtpLOt koX oi SetAot koX oi dvbpetot trapa-

7rArjcrtco?, co? <rv <prjs, pxikkov be 01 8etAot t<2v dvbpeioiv; c
KAA. 4>tj/lu. 212. 'AAAd p.r)v ol ye cppoVtpot Kat 01
dy8peibi dyaQoi, 01 8e 8etAoi Kai d<ppoves kokoi; KAA.

Nat. 212. napa7rArjo-tcos apa yaipovmv koX kvirovvrat oi
dyaOot koI oi KaKoi; KAA. ^r/pt. 5
212. 'Ap' ovv TrapaTrkr\<ri<os etcrty ayadol Kal kokoI oi
dyadoi re Kat oi KOKoi; r) Kat ert pdAAou dyaflot [01 ayadol
Kal oi KOKoi] elo~tv oi kokoi;

KAA. 'AAAd pd At" ovk 018' 6V1 Ae'yets. d
212. Ovk oto-c^' ort tovs ayadovs aya6<2v <pr)s Trapov<ria
etvat dyacôrj?, Kat kokovs be kok&v; rd be ayaOa elvat tcls
rjbovds, kokcl 8e Tas avias; KAA. "Eycoye. 212. Ovkow

rots yaipovcrtv Trdpecntv rdyadd, ai rjbovai, etirep yaipov<rtv ; 5
KAA. Ilcos yctp ov; OrjKow

212. aya$<2v irapovTcov
dyadoi etcrtv oi yaipovres; KAA. Nat. Tt 212. 8e'; Tots
dvttoptevots ov irdpecrTtv ra Kam, ai kvirat; KAA. ndpeoriy.
212. KaKcoy 8e ye irapovcria <pr)s crv eTvat kokovs tovs e
kokovs' r/ ovKtrt cprjs; KAA. y
Eycoye. .212. 'Aya0ot dpa
ot av yaipcocrt, kokoX 8e o\ av dvt&vrat; KAA. Yldvv ye.
212. Ot p.ev ye ptakkov pxikkov, 0% 8' rJTTov rjrrov, 01 8e
irapairkr]<ritos irapaTrkrjo-itos KAA. Na. 212. Oukow 5
<Pfjs TTapairkrjo-iios yaipetv Kai kvrreladat rorj? <ppovipLovs
b4 jj.6vov BTPf F : c 7 kcl\ ol B T F /coi

ix6voi ol : W
ayadol secl. Routh ayadol ko\ ol kokoi B
ol 01 ayadol /cal kokoI :
TWf Kal 01 ayaBol /col KaKoi F

: secl. H. Schmidt (elcriv quoque secl.
:
Schanz) d 3 /col /ca/cot/j F /ca/covs B T P tovs KaKobs f

: d 8 ai :
BTP Kal al F 640? (ter) F : ol (ter) BTP ^rrov ^ttov

W
:
T F : ^TTOf ?ittov ^t]to^ B

498 e nAAT&NOS
kcu tovs d(ppovas na\ tovs SetAovs /cat tovs dvbpeiovs, r)
Kal p.d\Xov ert tovs beLXovs;

v
KAA. Eycoye.
10 212. 2rjAAdyt<rat 8r) /cot^ /xer' epov rt r7ju.1i' crvp./3aivet
eK tu>v <j)po\oyr}p.eva)V /cat 8ts yap rot Kat rpts (pacnv KaXbv
499 etrat ra Ka\a \eyeiv re Kat e7rto-/co77etcrâi. dyadbv piev
etmi rdy (pp6vip.ov Kal dvbpelov (pap.ev. 17 yP> KAA.

Nat. 212. KaKov be tov acppova /cat KAA.
8etAoV; Tidvv
ye. 212. 'Ayadbv 8e av rov yaipovra; KAA. Nat.
5 212. Ka/cdv 8e tov dvL<ap.evov; KAA. 'Ayayjcr;.' 2i2.
'Aridcrt9ai 8e /cat \aipeLV rbv dyadbv KaKov /cat 6p.oia>s,
t<rcos 8e /cat p.d\\ov roy KaKov; KAA. Nat. Ovkovv 212.

6p.oia)S ytyverat KaKos Kat dyaflds tw dya0<2 r/ Kat p&Wov
b dyaô? 6 /ca/co?; or3 raura o~vp.(3aivei koX ra irpoTepa e/cetra,
edy rts ravrd qbfj r)bea re Kat dyadd etvai; ov Tavra avdyKrj,
S) KaAAtxAei?;
KAA. FldAat rot crov d/cpow//ai, 2) 2coKpares, Ka6op.o-
5 Aoycor, ev6vp.ovp.evos otl, Kar 7rat(/Joy rfc crot ei>8<5 drtorOV,
tovtov acrpevos XV dvTrep rd p,etpaKta. cb? 8r) o"i/ otet
ep.e 1] Kal dWov ovtlvovv dv6poiiro)v orj^ ^yetcrât rds /xei
/3eArtow rjbovds, rd? be yeipovs.

212. \ov lov, (o KaAAucAet?, <b? 7rai>o?3pyo? et Kat pot
C wo-Trep 7rat8i xpfj, rore piev ra avrd (pdcrKOiv ovtojs exet?',
TOTe 8e krepojs, eâiraT&v /xe. Katrot ovk w/ir/y ye Kar'

dpxas vtto crov eKovros eTvai eaTraTr)6r\crecr6aL, <b? ovtos
(pi\ov vvv be exffevcrdrjv, Kal <b? eoiKev dvdyKt] p.01 Kard rdi>
5 7raAaidi> Ao'yoy rd irapbv ev iroielv koll tovto beyecr6ai to

bibop.evov irapd crov. ^cttiv be 8r/, cos eotKev, vvv Xeyeis,
otl r)bovai Tives elcrtv a\ p.ev dyadai, al be KaKai' rj ydp;
d KAA. Nat. 212. 'Ap' ovv ayadal piev al coc/jeAt/xot, KaKat
e 11 &>ixo\oyovfi4vwv F ai t4TPF: tJB a4 ScBTP:

t F b
4 roi ffov BTP rov <rov F
: C 1 to avra F av :
BTP 04 </>fAou] <pav\ov F c 6 Se B T P F 8e Stobaeus

S-f, :
C 7 Tir/s etVr}p.i.
2X2. *Ap' ovv rds TOLacrbe Aeyeis, olov Kard to a5>p.a as

vvvbr) eXeyopev ev r<3 ecrdieLv kcil iriveLV r)bovds, t/ dpa 5
tovtcov ai p.ev vyieiav iroLovaat, ev r<3 cro)p.aTL, 7/ Jo^vy 7;
d\kr\v TLvd dperrjv tov cro)p.aTOS, aSrat piev dyadai, al be

Tavavria tovtojv KaKai; KAA. Yldvv ye. 212. Ovkovv G
Kal XviraL o)cravTO)s al pev \pr\crTai eicrLV, al be Trovrjpai;
KAA. Ilu)S yap ov; 212. Ovkovv rds p.ev xP rl (rTa ^ Ka '
rjbovds /cat XvTras Kal aipereov ecrrlv Kal irpaKTeov; KAA.
Yldvv ye. 2X2. Tas <5e Trovrjpds ov; KAA. Arjkov brj. 5
212. "EveKa ydp ttov t(ov dyad&v diravTa r)pXv eboev
TTpaKreov eXvaL, el p.vr)p.oveveis, ep.oi re Kal YIo)Xo). dpa
Kal crol crvvboKeL ovtco, re'Aos eti>at a7ra<r<3i> r<3z> Trpdeo)v to
dyaOov, kol eKeivov eveKa belv iravTa raAAa 7rpdrrecrt9ai
dAA' ovk eKeivo tS>v dWcov; crvp.}l/r]cpos r)pXv et Kat crv K 5 00
Tpirtov; KAA. v
Ey&>ye. 2X2. T&v dyaOGtv dpa eVexa 8et
/cat raAAa Kat rd r)bea irpaTTeLV, dAA' ov TayaOd tS)V rjbecov.
KAA. Tldvv ye. 212. 'Ap' ovv iravTos dvbpos cttlv
eKkeâcrdaL irola dyaOd tQ)V rjbetov ecrrlv Kal ottom KaKa, r) 5
rex^tKoS 8et ets eKacrTov; KAA. TexvLKOv.
2X2. '
\vap.vr)crdG)p.ev br) &v av eyo) Trpbs YlutXov Kal
Yopyiav ervyxavov heytov. eXeyov yap av, et pLvrjpoveveis,
otl eXev TTapacrKeval ai piev ju.e'xpt r)bovrjs, avrb tovto povov

7ra/3ao"Keva^bi>o"at, dyvoovcraL be to /3e'Artoi> Kat rb x^P 0V Q i t
be yLyvbjcrKovcraL otl re ayaObv Kal otl KaKov Kal Tidr)v

T&v p.ev irepl rds r)bovds Tr)v /zayetptKi/y epLTreLpiav dk\d ov
d2 8 ye BTP : 8e d 5 vvv Si) B T P F S^ vvv

F Stobaeus :
Stobaeus ^ &pa SauppeB T P F Stobaeus apa Heindorf

: c{ &pa :
(qui mox iroiovcriv) d 6 iroiovcrai B T P F Stobaeus iroiovo-iv al. :
e 9 evtKa F Iamblichus Stobaeus tveKev B T a 2 rpirwv^

: W
rovrwv F a 5 6iro?a B T P F iroTa Stobaeus a 8 e\eyov yap
:
aZ F e\eye yap avrbs Stobaeus

: eXeyov yap B T :bi u6vov
B T P F om. Stobaeus
: b 3 IrlOriv B T P iriOeiv P 7-1 0e?v F : : :
eridovv p f Stobaeus b 4 uayetptK^v B F Stobaeus uayttptKijv :
Kara rb oS>ua TW : in marg. irepl rb aruua f

:
5oob FTAATGNOS
5 riyvr\v, ra>v be irepl to ayaObv rrjv iarpiKijv Teyyt]v. kol
irpbs <J>tAtoi>, 2> KaAAtKAets, pvqre avrbs otov beXv rrpbs ep.e
TraCCeiv p.rib' otl av tvxjjs napa tcl boKovvra aiTOKpCvov, pr)T

C av tcl 7rap' ep.ov ovrcos airobexov cos 7ratwros* opqs yap ort
7rept tovtov rjpuv eicriv ol Aoyot, ov tC av p.a.XXov cnTovbacreie
tls Kal o-p.i.Kpbv vovv e\u>v avdpwnos, rj tovto, ovTLva XPV
Tpoirov fjv, iroTcpov eirl bv o~v irapaKaXels ep.e, tcl tov
5 avbpbs br) ravra irpaTTOVTa, Xeyovra re ev rfi brip.ti> Kal
prjTopLKrjv ao-KovvTa Ka\ 7roX.LTevop.evov tovtov tov Tporrov
bv vp.eis vvv TToXLTeveo-Qe, rj [e7ri] rovbe tov fiCov tov ev
<ptAocroc/>ia, Kal tl ttot ecrriv ovtos eKeCvov Stacpeptov. Tcrcos
d ovv /3e'ArtcrroV eoTLV, cos aprt eyco eTrex^Cprjcra, Statpetcrât,
SteAojueVous be /cat 6/LtoAoy7jo-ai>ras aAAÂots, et ecrriv tovtoj
Strrcb rco /3tco, crKeâa-QaL tC re bLacpeperov aXXrjXoLV koI

oiTOTepov /3icoreW 'avrotV. tcrcos ovv ovtt<o dlo-da t'l Xeyco.
5 KAA. Ov brjra.
2i2. 'AAA' eyco o*ot o~acpeo~Tepov epco. e7ret8r) co/xoAo-
yi)Kap.ev eyco re Kal o~v etvai p.ev tl ayadov, elvaL be tl rjbv,
erepov be. to r)bv tov ayadov, eKarepov be avrolv p-eXerijv

tlvcl etvai Kai 7Tapao~Kevr)v rrjs KT-jo-eojs, rr)v p.ev tov rjbeos
io drjpav, rr)v be tov ayadov avrb be p.0L tovto TTp&rov r/
e o-vp.cpa0L r) p.rj. avpnprjs;
KAA. Ovrcos cpr)p.C.
212. "I6i brj, a Kat 7rpds rovcrge eyco eXeyov, bLop.oX6yr)craC
p.0L, ei apa ctol eboa rote a.Xr)6rj XeyeLV. t-Xeyov be ttov
5 ort rj p.ev 6\jroTTOLLKr) ov p.OL boKel Texvrl e ' yat aXX* ejmeLpig.,
501 r)
8' iarpLKr), Xeymv otl r) p.ev tovtov ov depaireveL koll rr)v
cpvo-LV eo-KeTTTaL /cat rr)V ahCav &v TTpaTTei, kol Xoyov eêt
tovtodv eKacrrou bovvai, r) tarptKTj* r) 8' erepa rr)s rjbovrjs,
b7 fjL-fir o5 Ta BTP : ju)) ravra F C2 fjfuv dffiv BTF : tlaiv

rifiiv P C7 îrl secl. Findeisen 6.2 effrtv] tffrbv Hirschig
d3 rt BTPf : om. F d 4 vSrepov F d 10 8 fxoi BTPf
$)) 4/jloI F e 1 fx-f). ffvLHpris ; F : fiij ffvfi(pris BTf 63 iyio om P
e5 o\voitouk}) BTP : oôirorjTj/c^ F a3 ante ttjj add. i\ f
TOPriAS 5 oia
Trpbs rjv r) Oepinrua avTr\ ecrrty aTracra, Kop.Lbf] drexfcos eV

avrr\v epxerat, ovTi tl ti]v (pvaLV crKâpivr) rrjs r)bovfjs ovtc 5
Tijv aiTiav, dAo'ycos re TiavTairao~i.v cos iiros et7reii> ovbev
hi.apidp.r\o-ap.Vif, rpt/3?) /cat ejU7retpia p.vr)p.r)v povov crcofopeVr?
tov dooOoros yiyvtaOai, <o 8?/ /cat 7ropterat Tas rfbovas. TavT b
ovv TTp&rov crKOTret et 80/cet crot iKai^cos Ae'yecrc9ai, Kat eti>at
tlvs Kal 7rept î>x 7 V rotatrrat aAAat 7rpayparetat, at /uer
rex^tKat, itpop.f]Oeiav riva exoucrat ro?3 /3eArtVrou 7rept njy

x/VuX 7?*' a & ^ rovrou per dAtycopo?3crai, ecrKep/ueVat 5' aS, 5
oocnrcp eKet, r?)y r)bovr)v p.6vov rfjs i//t>x 77 s > riVa ay avrj/
Tpoirov yCyvotTo, rJTLs 8e 77 /3eArtW 17 x eL P v v fjbov&v,
ovt 0-Ko-novp.tvaL ovre p.ekov avTais akko 77 x a P l Cicr ^ ai
p.6vov, etre {3\tlov etre yjupov. epot /uei> ydp, co KaA- C
AucAets, 8oKot;crti> re etrai, Kat eycoye' cprj/ut ro rotourov
KoAaKetW etrat Kat 7rept acopia Kat Trept y\rvyj]v Kal 7rept
aAAo orou dV rts rrjv r)bovf)v depaTrevj), dcrKeVrco? Zx.oov tov
ap.eCvov6s re Kat roC x* L P 0V0S ' crv 8e 8?/ Trorepov cruyKara- 5
rtc?ecrat r/pty 7rept rovrcoy rr/y avrrjv boav f) a.VTLcpr]s;
KAA. Ovk ya>y, akka cruyx^pco, u>a aot Kat Trepavdfj

6 koyos Kat Topyiq r<38e x aP"r(P a '-
XX2. rToVepoy 8e 7rept pez; puw \/>jjx
t
V oru> tovto, irepl d
8e 8tjo Kat 7roAAds ovk ccttlv;
KAA. Otjk, dAAd Kat 7rept bvo Kat 7rept 7roAAas.
2X2. Ovkovv Kat adpoaLs ap.a x aP L (*'Q a <' ccrt, p.rj8ey
o-KOTTovp.evov to fitkTLorov; 5
KAA. Otpat eycoye.
v
212. Exets ow etTrety avrivzs do~Lv at e7Ttrrj8evcrets at
ro?jTo 7roto7Jcrat; piakkov 8e', et /3owAet, ep;o{) epcorcorros', r;
a 4 oTex^wj B P 2
: oTexf ws BTF a 6 dxJyws] &A.070S Findeisen
a 7 TpjjSjj . . . i/Airfiplq B T P F Tpt/3r?
fjLvt)fjiriv : i/xiretpia . . . /ju>r)fj.ri
vulg. b3
&\\ai Totavrat F b 6 avrrj B P F avri) T avrrt : :
Heindorf 05 toO x il P ovos B T P x*'P ovos ^

: 6 rriv avrijv
L
86av secl. Thompson d.3 /cal B T P f om. F d 4 u?;8'

:
(
F :
M 7,8 BTP
P1.AT0, vol. iii. 22
:
5 oid riAATX2N02
\xev dv ool bonrj tovtojv eXvaL, (pddL, r) 5' av \xr\, /xr) <rja#t.
e TTpwrov be oKe\j/o>\xe6a ti\v avXr\TLKi\v. ov boKel croi T0Lavrr\
tls etWt, o> KaAAtKAeis, rr)v r)bovr\v r\\xG>v \xovov bLo>KeLV,
akXo b' ovbev (ppovrC(eLv;

KAA. "Euoiye boKel.
5 2X2. Ovkovv Kal al rotatde diraoaL, olov r) KtâptcrriKT/ r)
v rots dyatcnv;
KAA. Nat.
2X2. Tt be r) t5>v yop&v bLbao-KakCa kol r) tG>v 81-
6vpd\x(3o>v ttoCi)ols; ov roiavrr/ tCs ool Kara<paiVerai; rj rjyfj
io tl (ppovTLêLV KLvrjoCav tov Mekr\Tos, 6tto>s epel tl tolovtov

odev av ol aKovovres /SeArtorjs yCyvoLVTo, r\ otl pe'AAet
502 yapLelodaL t5> oyXu tS>v 6eaTu>v;
KAA. Arjkov br) tovto ye, o> 2a>Kpares, Klvi\oCov ye

7re'pt.
212. Tt 8e 6 -naTr\p avrov Me'Ar/s; r) irpbs to /3e'Art<rroy
5 fiki-noiV eboKeL ool KLdapo)belv ; r) eKelvos \xev oibe irpbs to
ijbLcrTOv; r)vCa yap qbo>v tovs deards. dAAa 8r/ oKoireL'
oi>xl r/ re Ktt9apit>8iKr/ boKel ctol Ttdo-a Kat 57 t5>v bLdvpdu(3o>v
7ioCr;oLs r)bovr)s \dpLV r\vpr\o6aL;

v
KAA. Ep;oiye.
b 2X2. Tt 8e br) r) oe\xvr\ avrr/ Kat 6av\xaoTr), r) rr?s
rpaycpStas 7rotr/cris, ec/>' co ecr7rorJ8aKei'; iroTepov ecrrtr avrrjs
to eTTL\eCpr\\xa Kat r/ o-irovbf), 5>s 00X boKel, xapCeadaL rots

6earals \xovov, r) Kal bLa\xd)(eo6aL, edv tl avroLS r)bv p.ev 17
5 Kat Keyapi>o-\xevov, Trovrjpbv be, oVcos tovto \xev \xr\ epel, et
be tl TvyydveL ar\bes Kat dxpekL\xov, tovto be koX Ae'et
Kat acrerat, edvre yaCpoio-LV edvre \xf); 7rore'pcos ool boKel

TrapeoKevdodaL r) t5>v rpaya>8t<Si> iroCr)o-Ls;
d.9 P et supra versum Tf: om. BF

fj.it
ei ffK^6fje6a P
e5 B T P iraffat F
airaffai : e 10 (f>povri(fiv Kiprifflav rbv B P F t
Kivriffiav (ppovrifctv rbv T epe? ti B F t tpurai T W
a 2 <y :
irepi B T P tc 7re'pt F
: a 5 f3\firwv om. Coisl. ba ^ e<T7rou- e'(p'
So/cec secl. Cobet avrfjs ffirovH secl. Hermann. . . b 3 &s <rol

W
T F Sj <toi B Ss m<>' Schanz
: : b 6 axpeMfxov (6v) Hirschig
TOPriAS 5 oab
KAA. Aijkov bi] tovto ye, co 2c)Kpares, otl irpbs Ti]v
r)bovi]V p.ak\ov a>pp.r]TaL nal t6 yapi(jea~dai rots 0earats. C

212. Ovkovv to tolovtov, 2) KaAAtKAeis, ecpauey vvvbr)
KoXaKtCav etrai;
KAA. Tldw ye.
212. <J>e'/)e 8r/, et rts 7re/He'Aot rr/s 7rotr/o-ecos 7rdcrr/s ro' re 5

//e'Aos Kat roy pv9p.6v Kal to p.-\Tpov, dAAo rt rj Ao'yot yCyvovTai
to XenropLevov;
KAA. 'Amy/CT/.
212. OvkoC/v 77/365 7roAvi> oxAoi/ Kat brjp.ov ovtol Aeyoprai
01 Ao'yot; 10
KAA. 4>7?u.
212. Ar/ur/yopta dpa rts eorti/ 77 7rotr/riKT/.
KAA. afoerai. d
212. Ovkow prjTopLKr) brjpiriyopLa av etr/* 17 orj pr/ropevetr
SoKorjcrt crot ot 7rotr/rat ez/ rots 0edrpots;
KAA. "Euotye.
212. Nvv apa r/uets r]vpr]Kap.ev pr/roptKT/zv r/a 7rpds brjp.ov 5
rotouroy 01W 7raico*v re ouoi) Kat yi/ivaiKcoz/ Kat avbpQiv, Kal
bovkcov Kal eAei/flepcoz/, rjv ov itaw ayap.zda- KokaKLKqv yap
arjrr/z/ cpauez/ etz/at.
KAA. Ylavv ye.

'
212. Etey rt 8e r/ 7rpds tov A^r/z/atcoz/ brjp.ov prjTopLKi] 10
Kat roz/s dAAorjs rot/s ez/ rats 7ro'Aecriz/ 8r/uorjs rovs tG>v e
eAerj#e'pcoz/ avbp&v, tl ttotc fjp.LV arjTrj ko~TLv; itoTtipov ctol
boKovaLV 7rpos to /3e'Artcrroz/ det Aeyetz/ 01 pr/ropes, rorjrorj

o-roâfdueyot, O7rcos 01 7roAtrai cos /3e'Aricrrot ecroz/rat 8td roi/s
avT&v Adyous, r/ Kat orjrot 7rpds rd yapL&crOaL rots 7roAtrats 5
(app.rjp.ivoL, kol %VKa tov ibCov tov avT&v dAiycopoijz/res rou

koiz/ojj, cocnrep 7ratcrt Trpocrop.LkovcrL rots 5r/uots, yapi&crdaL
b9 5^ BTPf : om. F c 5 weoteAot F Aristides et schol. B :
irepi4\oiro BTPf d 2 ^rfropiK^ scr. recc. /Stjtoojk^ B T P F

:
7;
d8 <ô uei'] (pw/jLtv

/
P e2 ^/*tj/ F: ûi/ BTP e7 tos
BTP: rt to'is F
22*
5 02 e IIAAT11N0S
avTols 7reipc0/xei>oi p.6vov, et oe' ye j3e\riovs eowrat r) x_e ipovs
503 bia ravra, ovbev (ppovTi(ovo~Lv;

KAA. Ov\ clttXovv Itl tovto epoiTas' etat pkv yap 0%
KY)h6p.voi t&v tto\ltu>v \eyovo~LV a \eyovo~LV, eicriv 5e Kat
olovs av Aeyets.
5 2X2. 'EâpKet. et yap Kal tovto eVrt owrAow, to p.~kv
erepov ttov tovtov KoAaKeta av etr/ Kal aio~xpa orj/xr/yopia,

t6 8' (Tcpov Ka\6v, to TrapacrKeva&LV ottojs (os /3e'Artcrrat
ecroj>rai tG>v 7to\lto>v al yj/vxoi, Kal bLap.a\o-0ai \tyovra tcl
/3e'Ariara, etre 778100 etre ar)beo~Tepa earat roty dKovouatr.
b dAA' ov 7rc)7rore o~v ravTrjv et8es r^y prjTopLKijv r/ et rtra
Xets r ^^ pr]Top(ov tolovtov et7reu>, tC ovx) Kal ep.ol avTov

e(ppao~as ris eo~TLv;
KAA. 'AAAd jua Ata ovk %x~ *y>ye
" ot f**' t&v ye
5 yuy pr/rdpcoz; ovbeva.
2X2. T 8e'; rcor ira\aLS>v eêt? rtâ etweti' 81' ovTLva
airiav exovcrLV 'AdrjvaXoi fte^riovs yeyovevai, e7ret8rj eKelvos

rjpaTO br)p.r)yopLV, ev rco TrpoaOev XP 0VL? X ^P 0VS ovtcs; eyco
piev yap ovk olba rts ecrrty ovtos.

C KAA. Tt 8e'; 0e/xiaroKAe'a ovk aKovets di>8/m ayadov
yeyovora koX Kip.oiva Kal Mi\TLabr)v Kat IIe/)iKAe'a tovtovl
tov Vojo~tI TiT\evrr)KOTa, ov koX o~v aKr-Koas;
2X2. Ei Io-tlv ye, a> KaAAuAets, 771 TrpoTepov o~v fAeyes
5 dperT/v, a\r)6r)s, to tcls 7TL$vp.ias airoiTLp.TT\avaL Kat rds avrov

Kal ras tS>v a\\oiV et 8e jut) tovto, dAA' orrep ey rco wre'/>cp
Adycp r)vayKao~0r)p.ev 77/Lteis o/ôAoyety 6'rt a% p.ev to>v
7TL0V)IlG>V TT\r)pOV(J.VaL /3eAriC0 7rOlOrjcri TOV avOpOJTTOV,
d rauray pikv a7roreAety, a% 8e x ( W-> Wh tovto oe re'x^r/ rts
a 2 ^rt B T Aristides irrri P F tovto Aristides tovto h B T P F

: :
ot T F 0 B: a 8 /cal B P F t Aristides koI o1 T a 9 eirrai :
B T P F <?(rr2 Aristides
: b 1 av -Tw-rore F b 2 ouxl B T P F :
ou Aristides b 3 tIsBTPF: oVtis Aristides b 4 /laBTPF:

H&, tov Aristides Zywye B T P om. F Aristides y- B T P F om.
: :
Aristides b 9 /*' om p ^ r t/x^ t ^ e ^ scripsi (efy av

-
ci. Heindorf) Texvrj tjs errat B T P F

: Texfrjs efra* Ast Tex^r/s : :
Ttrbs Setrai Liebhold

ropriAS 503 d
et?/ tolovtov avbpa tovtcov tlvo, [yeyovvai\ ovk e^co eycoye

7TCO? 177(0.
KAA. 'AAA' kav (jt]Tr)s nakS>s, vprjcrLs.

212. *lb(t)[XV br) ovTOicrl arpp.a crK07rovp.VOL et rts tovtcov 5
tolovtos yiyovtv c/>e'pe ydp, 6 ayados avr)p xat e7rt to
fiikTLcrTov ktycov, a av Aeyr/ 6.XX0 tl ovk ei/07 e/set, dAA'
airoj3k7rtov Trpos tl; cocr7rep koI 61 dAAot 7ravT$ br}p.Lovpyol e
[/3Ae'7roi're?] 7rpos to avrc2v tpyov (-Kao-ros ovk et/a/ e/cAeyd-
p.VOS TrpocrcpipeL \r:p6s to <kpyov t6 avT&v,} dAA' o7rcos hv

etbos tl avr<2 cr^r) tovto 6 eoyderat. otor et j3ovkL tSeti> tovs
{toypdcpovs, tovs olKobop,ovs, tovs vavTrqyovs, tovs dAAous 5
7rdz>ras br\p.Lovpyovs, ovTLva /3ovAet avrcov, cos ets rdcfty tlvcl
e/cacrros l/caoroy TL0r)crLV 6 av TL0i), Kal 7rpocrai>ay/cdet to

Tpov rco erepco ixpi-rov re etzmt koll app.0TTLV, ecos av to
aTTav crvcrrrjcrriTaL TTayp.ivov re /cat KKocrp.r\p,vov rpayp.a' 54
kol ol re ot) dAAot br]p.Lovpyol Kal ovs vvvbi] eAeyo/xe^, 01
7rept to crco/xa, 7rat8orpi/3at re /cat larpoC, Koo~p.ovo~L ttov
to crco/xa /cat crvvTaTTovo-LV. 6p,okoyovp,V ovtco tovt \clv

?/ ov; 5
KAA. "Eotco roCro ovrco.

212. Tdecos d/>a /cai Kocrp.oy Tvyovcra ot/cia \pr\0Tr) b\v
cXrj, dratas oe p.o\6r)pd;

KAA. 4>T/ut.
212. Ov/coTjy /cat 7rAotoz> cocravrcos; IO
KAA. Nat. b
d2 eiVj] e?j/ot tuetur et post hanc vocem lacunam indicat Schanz

'
u>fjLo\oyriTai' irus &v rts ex ot *"'*<' supplet K. Fuhr) yeyovevai
seclusi post yeyovevat add. ex etv *hr& marg. m f ovk e"x u
W
:
. . .cume1rru> Socrati tribui et mox 'AAA' . evp^ffets Callicli . . :
ovk ex<o -1i-ci> Callicli et 'A\\' . evpf)o-ei~ Socrati tribuit B et

. .
ut videtur T (I7 &\\o rt ovk F (sed ti suprascr. f) e2 $\e-

irovTts om. Sauppe 63 irpoff<p4p-i BTPF:
Trpoff<pepet a irpofftpepet
Vind. 21 rrpos ro epyov rh abrwv om. Sauppe auTtov B avruv :
T P F aiTov vulg.
: e 4 (156- T F tltes B W
avr$ : BTP:
avrb F ai t(F TtBTP: a 2 or)fuovpyot post ^\eyofxev
transp. F
;
504b ITAATX2N02
2X2. Kai p.r)v koX ra crcop,ard cpa/xey tcl r/ueYepa;
KAA. Ylavv ye.

2X2. Tt 8' 77 i$rvyri; dracjta? Tvyovaa ecrrat \pr\crTq, r)
5 Tae<ti$ re nal KOcrp.ov tlvos;
KAA. 'AvayKri Ik tQ>v TrpocrOev kol tovto crwopoAoyeiV.

2X2. Tt ovv ovofxci cttlv ev ra o-c6p.art rco Ik r^? rdcfecos
re Kal tov Kocrfxov yLyvop.{vu>

KAA. 'Tytetav Kai lcryvv tcrcos Ae'yet?.
C 2X2. "Eyooye. tl 8e av rai iv rfj \j/V)(fi eyytyi>o/xeVco e/c
rrjs T&êcas Kal tov koo-jjlov; 7retpco eupelv Kai etiretz> cocr7rep
eKet t6 6vop.a.
KAA. Tt 8e ovk avrbs Ae'yet?, co ^coKpares;
5 2X2. 'AAA' et crot rjbLov ecrrtv, eyco epco* crv 8e', av p,iv
ctol 8okco eyco KaAcos Ae'yetr>, cpddL, et 8e p.r\, eAeyê Kai pr/
(TTLTpcTTC. ip.o\ ydp SoKet rats ueu rorj crco/xaros rdfecrti>
ovop.a clvaL vyLCLVOv, e ov ez> ar/r<3 r/ rjyteta ytyyerat Kai r/
dAXr/ dperr) rorj crco/xaros. eoTW raOra r) ovk ecrrtjj;
io KAA. y Eoru\
d 2X2. Tat? de" ye rr/s ifrvxrjs rdcfecrt Kat KOcrur/crecrti>
vop.Lp.6v re Kat vop.os, oOev Kal vop.Lp.OL yCyvovraL ko! Kocr/xtof

raSra 8' ecrrtz; SiKatocrrjVr/ re Kat croocppocrvvr\. r) ov;
cpfis
v
KAA. Ecrrco.
5 2X2. OrjKorjV 7rpds rarjra ^kiiroov 6 pr/rcop eKetyo?, 6
rexwws re Kat dyaflds, Kat rorj? Adyorjs irpocroCcreL rats

T//rjxats orj? az> Aeyr/, Kai ras irpd^CLS d7rdcray, Kat 8<Spoi>
edy rt 8t8co, 8cocret, Kai edz> rt dc/jatpr/rat, dcpatpr/crerat,
7rpds rorjro dei rdi> 7Jorjz> i\cov, ottoos av avrov rots 7roAtrats
e bLKaLocrvvri /zei> ez> rats ^/vxals yiyvryraL, dStKta 8e a7raA-
Adrrr/rat, Kai crcccppocrvvri pikv iyyCyvrjTaL, aKoAacrta 8e
b6 irpoffOev TPF
irp6ade B C 3 ^cer scripsi (?k* /o B T P F : :
W
:
fKeivcp Heindorf C 7 ûol âp F e/xoiye T f efioiye yhp B (sed

: :
yap punctis notavit et yap ad ye in marg. adscripsit B ) d 1 84 ye

2
F: Se BTP na\ B T F re Kal P d 5 ravra a pr. F

:
d 9 auToO T P F auToO B at>r KaAAtKAeis, o-co/xart ye KapvovTi

Kal pioxOrip&s cnaKet/xeW o-LTia irokka bibovai Kat tcl rjbio~Ta
v
rj ttotcl rj dkk' otlovv, b /x? / din/<ret ovto e<r#' otl irkOV rj
rovvavriov Kard ye tov bUaLOV koyov Kat eAarroi'; eort

Tavra; 10
y
KAA. E<rrco. 505
212. Ov yap ot/xat AucrtreAet p\Ta p.oydr)pias o-co/xaros
(rjv avdpatTTLp' dvdyKtr yap ovrco Kat r}v p.oxOrrpm. rj ovx
ovtcos;
KAA. Nat. 5
212. Ovkow Kat tcls TTL0vp.ias dironTLLnTkdvat, oXov 7rei-

vStvra (paytlv daov /3ovAerat ?/ 8t\//coi>ra ttllv, vyiaivovra
p.ev iQo-LV oi larpol o>$ tcl irokkd, Kap.vovTa oe &>s eVoy
et7rety ovoeVor' ecoo"tv e/x7ri'/x7rAao-0at &v e7rt5v/xet; ot>yx<>0eis
tovto ye Kat o~6; IO

y
KAA. Eycoye.
212. Ilept 8e ^svxrjv, a> dptcrre, ovx 6 ai/rds Tpoiros; b
ecos /xey du irovrrpa ?/, dvdr/rd? re ovcra Kat aKo'Aacrroy Kat
aStKos Kat dôcrioy, etpyetv airrqv 8et rcoy TTL6vp.L<av Kat
/x?j TTLTpTTLV aAA' drra 7roteu> ?) dc/j' <3i> /3eArtW torai'

(pfjs r) ov; 5
'
KAA. 4^/xi.
212. Oi/rco ydp 7rou air?/ dp.LVOV Trj ^vxfi'
KAA. ndw ye.
212. OvKOW TO LpyLV (Tt\v d<p' &V TTL0vp.l KOkd&LV,

KAA. Nat'. 10
e 6 6<pt\os TPf : &<p(\os B F e 8 o^<rei F : 6vti<ry BT W

avrb T Pf : axnbv B (sed v punctis notatum) F eVfl
1
SViJ 4V0' ore
Cornarius eg 0x07]
Kard yt Cornarius: kcito 8e Schleiermacher
t)
a 1 eo-To] Vtii> P a3 P F Iamblichus na\ yuox#?Jps B

fioxîipws :
(sed /cal punctis notatum) T a 6 ovkovv koL F Iamblichus ovkoZv :
B P ofooi/v T
: b 4 d</>' i/ B T P a iroiuiv F a av noiwv Iamblichus
: :
)
505b ITAATX2N02
2X2. Td /coAdecr0at apa rfj ûxf? apeLvov ecrTLV rj r)
a/coAacrta, &o"!rep crv vvvbr) &ov.
C KAA. Ovk ot' aTTa Aeyets, aj 2fe>/coare?, dAA' akXov

tlvcl epcora.
2X2. Ouro? dvr)p ovx viropeveL wcpekovpevos Kal avrbs

tovto irao-)(jMv TrepX ov 6 koyos ecrrC, Koka6p.evos.
5 KAA. Ovbe ye p.0L p.ekeL ovbev <ov crv Aeyets, /cat Tavra
o-ol TopyCov yapLv a.TTKpivdp.i]V.
2X2. Eiezr rt ovv br) TTOLr)crop.V ; perav tov koyov

KaTakvop.ev;
KAA. Avros yvcacrr].
ô 2X2. 'AAA' ovbe tovs pvOovs cpacrl /xerau 6ep.LS elvaL

d /caraAei7ret;c, dAA' eTTidevTas Kecpakr)v, Xva p.r) avev Kecpakrjs
TrepLLrj. airoKpLvaL ovv /cat tcl XoLTTa, Xva i)puv 6 koyos
Kecpakrjv Ad/3r?.
l
KAA. X2? (BCaLOS et, a> 2co/cpares. edi> 8e e/uot TTeCdr],
5 edo-ets \aCpeiv tovtov tov koyov, r) Kal dAAco rcp 8taAe'<fr7.
2X2. Tts ow dAAos edekeL; /u.t) ydp rot aTekrj ye w

koyov KaraAt7rco/xey.
KAA. Avrds oe ov/c di> owato SieA0eti> tov koyov, i)
keycov /cara crauroi; 17 aiTOKpLv6p.evos craDrco;

e 2X2. Ira /jtoi to tov 'E7rtxdp/xou yevryraL, a " irpb tov
bvo avbpes ekeyov," et? cov LKavbs yevcopaL. arap KLvbv-
veveL avayKaLOTarov eTvai ovrcos. et p.evToi TTOLrjcrop.ev,
oi/uai eyioye \pr\vaL iravras r)p.as c/hAoih/cco? exetr 7rpo? to
5 elbevaL to akr]6es tC Zcttlv irepl S>v keyop.ev Kal tC \j/evbos'
b 11 7) om. F Iamblichus e 1 o?5a ri \eyets F 03 avrbs

BTPF : avrb corr. Coisl. e 4 irdtrxetv P C 5 av om. F
C 7 iroti)ffofiev BT W : votr)ffa>/j.ev F e 8 Kara\vofiev B T P Kara- :
\v<rofiev in lacuna f d1 Kara\eiiretv BTf : Kara\nre?v P F

d2 rreptiri Tf : rrepteirii B : irepii)ei PF rifuv post d 3 Ke<pa\riv
P
transp. d4 5e om. F d5 koI om. F d6 i6e\ei
BTPF : iBe\i)ffei f are\rf\ are Sr/ F d7
Kara\iirwfxev W :
/caTctAnrcbj' yuey F : Kara\eiirwfj.ev BTf d 9 crauTco] ayToD P ei iVa

BT WF : /ca 81" in marg. add. F e 2 oVSpcs BT
P F' (sed r puncto
notatum in B e3 oSroos- el BTP : outcoctI F irotiiffofxev W :
iroiT)ffuftev BTF 64 iravras F : 7rafTa BT W

ropriAS 505 e
koivov yap dyaObv airao-t cpavepov yevecrdai avro. Stei/ut
pev ovv rto Ao'yco eyco cb? av pot boKrj e-êiV' eav 8e rco 56
vpQ>v pi] ra ovTa 8okco opokoyelv e/j.at>rcp, xprj dvTikap.-
(idvecrOai Kal ekey\eiv. ovbe ydp rot eycoye etScb? Ae'yco
a Ae'yco, dAAd (ji}tG) Kotvr) /xe#' vp&v, wcrre, ai> rt cpaivrjrat
keya>v 6 dp(pio-(3r]TS}V epoi, eycb rrpwTOS crvyyu>pr)crop.at. 5
Ae'yco pevrot Tavra, et 8oKet \pr)vai btaTrepav6r)vat tov

koyov et Se /ut/ (3ovkecr$e, eSipev 7/877 yaipetv koX diriu>p.ev.
rOP. 'AAA' e/xot juer ov 80/cei, S ScoKpare?, xPV va ^ ,ra)
dirtevat, dkka bteek6etv cre tov koyov cpaiverat be //ot b
xat rot? dAAot? 8oKetz>. (3ovkop.at yap eycoye fcat airbs

aKOvaaC aov avrov bttovTOs rd eirikotTra.
212. 'AAAd piev 87/, co ropyta, Kal axiTos i)beo)s /xer ay

KaAAiicAet tovtui ert btekeyopr/v, eco? aiirco rr)v tov 'A/a- 5
cpiovos a7re'8coKa prjcrtv dvTt rrjs tov ZrjOov eTretbr) 8e trv,
cb KaAAtKAets, ovk eOekets o-w8ta7reparat rov Ao'yoy, dAA'

ow e/u,o?3 ye aKovoiV e7rtkap.(3dvov, edv rt trot 8okw /xt)
KaAcos keyetv. Kat /ue edi> eeAe'yx7/?, 07jk dyOecrdricropai C

crot &crirep crv e/moi, dAAd p.eytoros evepyeTf]s irap epol
dzâyeypd\//7/.
KAA. Ae'ye, cbyafle', avrd? Kat irepatve.

212. "AKoue 8t) e dpxrjs epov dvaka(36vT0s tov koyov. 5
'Apa rd 7/81/ Kat rd dyadbv rd avrd ecrrtv; Ov ravroV,
cb? eyco Kat KoAAikAtI,? cb/uoAoyT/cra/xei'. Ylorepov 8e rd t/8v
eveKa tov dyadov trpaKTeov, 77 to dyadbv eveKa tov r/8e'os;
Td r)bv eveKa tov dyadov. 'Hbv 8e' eVrii' tovto ov

vapayevopevov r)b6peda, dyadbv 8e ov irapovTOs dyaOoi d
ecrpev; Tldvi; ye 'AAAd pr)v dyaOoi ye ecrpev Kal r)p.els
Kal rdkka irdvTa ocr dyadd ecrriv, dperrjs tivos Trapayevo-

pevrjs; "Epoiye boKel dvayKaiov elvai, oo KaAAtKAet?.
'AAAd pev br) rj ye dpere/. eKacrTOv, Kal crKeyovs Kal aco/xaro? 5
a3 \fyw & Ktyw BT P Trdvv ri \4yw. oAA' 4ya> F

: a5 7<1>
B T P tyaiye F
: a 6 SiaTrepai/flrjj/ai B T P f Siairepavai F a7 ySrj
W
:
F:8^BTPf bs aix<piovt>s F a.Lt<p(wvos B T P b6 : tt/j om. F

5o6d riAATI2N02
kcu \lrvxns o-v xal (ipov iravTos, ov tS> elKr) KaAAiora itapa-
ytyyerat, dAAd rdet Kal opdo TrjTL Kal je^vrj, jjtls eKaaTop
anobeboTaL ai/T&v dpa ecrTLV raura;
'Eyco jxev ydp (prjpi.
e Tdet apa TTayp.evov koX KeKOcrp.rjp.evov ecrrlv r) dperrj

ko.(ttov; QaCrjv av eycaye KoVpos tls dpa eyyev6p.evos
ev exdcrra) 6 eKacrroti oIkclos ayadbv Trapeêt eKacrrov twv
ovToov; Ejuotye
v
boKet Kat dpa \j/vxrj Koo-p,ov exovo-a
5 tov kavTrjs dp.eCvo)v
ttjs aKoo-p.rjTov; 'Avdy/cTj 'AAAd prjv
rj ye KO(rp.ov eyovcra KoapCa; ydp Tl&s ov pe'AAet;
C
H bi
507 ye Koap.[a cro)(ppo)v; HokXrj dvdyKrj 'H dpa auxppoiv
\jrvxv dyadrj. eyco jxev ovk eô) irapa ravra dkka (pdvai,
(o cptAe KaAAtKAets* av 8' et exeLS, 8t8acnce.
KAA. Ae'y', coyatfe'.
5 2X2. Aeyco brj otl, et r) cro)(ppo)V ayaOrj ecrrty, rj tov-

vavTiov rr) aaxppovL treTtovQvia KaKtj ecrTLV rjv be avrrj r)
dqbpoiV T kol aKokao-ros. ndû Kat ye. p.rjv 6 ye crco-
(ppoiv Ta Trpoo-rjKOVTa TtpaTTOL av Kal Tiepl 8eovs Kal 7repi
dv9po)TTOVS' ov ydp av o-ooqbpovoL rd

b rcoi>;
'Ai>dyKT7 TavT elvaL oifrco. Kai
p.r) Trpoo-rjKOVTa irpdr-
p.rjv rrepl p,ev dvOpoy-

ttovs Ta TrpocrrjKovTa 7rpdrrcoi 8tKat' dv irpaTTOL, irepl be
deovs ocria* tov be Ta 8tKata Kai ocrta TtpaTTOVTa dvdyKrj
bCâLOv Kat oo-lov etrat.
"Eart ravra. Kat p.ev brj Kal
5 dvbpeiov ye avdyKrj' ov yap brj o-axppovos avbpos ecrrty ovre
bLO)KLV OVT (pVyLV OL pVtJ TTpOCrtJKL, dAA' a 8et Kat 7T/)d-
yp.ara koll dvOpdnrovs kol rjbovas Kal Xviras qbevyeLV Kal

bLo>KLv, Kal vTTopievovTa Kaprepelv ottov 8et' cocrre 7roAA?/
C dvdyKrj, co KaAAtKAet?, tov cro)(ppova, (oo-irep bLrjX.60p.ev,
bCâLov ovTa xai dvbpelov ko.1 oo-lov dyaObv dvbpa elvaL

reAecoy, tov be dyadbv ev re Kat KaAcos irpaTTeLV a av 1
d 6 ov t$ B T Iamblichus ovtoiP:
o\jtoi al. Sauppe": ovx ovtw F
:
KaWiffTa secl. Coraes ydp B P F yap S^j Td8 e 1 Tera- :
yfitvov B T P F TeTayfievov ti Iamblichus

: e 3 l/cdtrroi; B P F
Iamblichus eKaffTOv T eKao-Tuv t
: : a 6 o-axppoavvy) P a 8 irep\
avdpwirovs B T P F avdpwirovs Iamblichus
: b 6 a\\' a 8e? Hein-
dorf a\\a Se? B T f Iamblichus a\\a 8},PF
: c 3 re B T P ye F
: :
ropriAs 507 c
irp6.TTr\, tov 5' ev TrpaTTovTa paKapLov re koX evbaCpova

elvaL, tov be itovqpbv kol KaKcos irpdTTOVTa dOkLOv ovtos 5
8' av etr) 6 evavrCcos eycov T $ o~to<pP ovl > aKokao-TOS, bv
CTV 7T7)veLS.
'Eyto p.ev ovv ravra ovtco rCdepaL /cat qbrjpL Tavra dkrjdr)
eXvaL' el be eoTLv akr\0r), tov (BovX.6p.evov, cos eoLKev, ev-

baCpova eXvaL o-cocppocrvvqv pev bLcoKTeov Ka\ dcrKr)Tov, d
aKo\ao-Cav be cpevKTeov cos eyei irobCov cKao~Tos r)pcov, /cat
Trapao-KtvacrTiov /xaAtcrra piev pr)bev belcrOaL tov /coAaea#at,

edv be berjOfj ?/ avTos ?/ dkkos tls tcov olKeCcov, ?/ tcUam/s'
?/ TToXlS, 7Tl6TOV bLK7]V KOl KokaOTOV, el pekkeL evbaCpCOV 5

Lvai. ovtos ep.0Lye boKel 6 o-kottos elvaL rrpbs bv fike-
irovTa bel r)v, koX irdvTa els tovto tcl avrov o-vvreCvovTa
koX tcl Trjs TTokecos, O7T00S bLKaLOO"6vr) irapeo-TaL koX crcocppo-
crvvr) T(2 p.aKapC(o p.ekkovTi ecrecrOai, ovtco irpaTTeLv, ovk e
eiTLdvpCas e&VTa d/coAdcrroi;s eXvaL koX ravras eirvyeLpovvTa
Trkrjpovv, dvqvvTOv /ca/coV, krjo-Tov fiCov Si>ra. ovt yap
cxv dkk(o av9p(oTT(o 7Tpocr(pLkr)s dv etr) 6 tolovtos ovre Oeto'
KOLVtovelv ydp dbvvaTos, otco be pr) evL KOLVcovCa, cpLkCa ovk 5
av elr). cpacrl 8' ol crocpoC, co KaAAt/cAet?, koX ovpavbv koX
yrjv koX Oeovs koX dvOpcoTrovs tt)v kolvcovCov crvveyj.LV koX 58
cpikCav Kal Koo-p.LOTr)Ta /cat crcocppoo~vvr)v koX 8t/caior?/ra,
/cat to okov tovto 8td raSra Kocrpov KakovcrLV, 00 eTaipe,

ovk aKoa-p.Cav ovbe aKokacrCav. crv be poi 80/cei? ov irpocr-
X iv T v v vv tovtols, koX ratira aocpbs cov, dkkd kekr\dev 5

ae otl r) Ictottis r) yecoperpLKT) kol ev deols Kal ev dvOpcoTTois
peya bvvaTai, av be irkeove^Cav otet belv do-Ketv yecope-
C5 vovrfpus P oSj/ om. Oxy. C8ravra a\7)dr) B P F Oxy.

Stobaeus : T
a\r)drj C 9 ei 5e ianv a\r)dTJ om. F (add.
ravra
in marg. f) Se B T P et in marg. f 8^ Iamblichus Stobaeus :
d 3 irapaffKevacrriov B T P f Oxy. Iamblichus iroas (TKevacrreov ut :
videtur F irapa<TKevao-riov eavrov Stobaeus

: d 4 ^ prius B T P F
Oxy. Stobaeus om. Iamblichus
: e r ovrw B 2 T P F ov r$ B :
6 2 twtmTWF Stobaeus ravra B Iamblichus (in Oxy. lacuna)

:
64 l\v eXi) B T P IV; F Oxy. Stobaeus

: e 5 8* B T P f yap Oxy. :
Iamblichus Stobaeus : om. F a7 otet wAeoveiav P

5o8a ITAATX2N02
TpCas yap dueAets. etev ?; eeAeyKre'os 8?/ ovtos 6 Adyos
b jjjXLV ccttlv, cos ov bt,Kaioo~uvt]s Kal croocppocrvvris KTr/o-eL evbaC-
p.oves ol evbaCp.oves, KaKtas 8e ol clOXlol, r) et ovtos aXr}di]s
CTTLV, 0-KTTTOV TL TCL CTVpjSaCvOVTa. TCL TTpOCrOtV (KZLVa,
u> KaAAtKAets, crt>u/3au>ei tiavTa, ec/>' ofc crv ue ?/pou et
5 o-TTovbaa)v Aeyotut, keyovra otl KaTr\yopr]Teov etrj Kai a?3roC

/cat x>eos Kal eratpou, edv rt d8tK?j, Kai Trj prjTopLKrj cttl
tovto yprjcrTeov Kal a IIcoAor alcryyvr) u>ov crvyxLopeXv,

akrjOrj apa rjv, to clvaL to SZlkclv tov abLKCLcrOaL ocru>irep
C aLcryj.ov toctovtu> KaKLov ko.1 tov p.e\\ovTa 6p6u>s prjTopLKov

ccreo-dat otKatov &pa bel etmi Kai TTLcrTr)p.ova raw bLKaCoov,
o aii TopyCav e<pr] IIcoAos cV alcryyvrjv 6p.o\oyr}craL.

Tovtoov be ovrcos eyovroov o-K\jru>p.8a tC ttot ecrrlv a cr?j
5 e/uoi dyeiiets, apa KaAcos Ae'yerat 17 ov, cos apa eyco ov\
olos t etut /3orjdf}o-aL ovtc ep.avTu> ovtc tu>v cpCXoov ovbevl
Ovbe TU>V OLKeCoOV, Ovb' eKCTCOCrat K TU>V p.yCcTTU>V KLVbvVOOV,

elpl 8e eirt rco /3ovAoueVcp cocrTrep 01 ctrtuot ro?3 eOekovTos,
d aVre tvtttLV /3ovA??rai, ro veqvLKov br/ tovto to tov aov
koyov, eTTt Kopprjs, eavTe XPVIxaTa a.cjyaLpelcrOaL, edvTe eK-
/3dAAeiv eK r?/s 7ro'Aecos, edyre, to eayaTov, aTTOKTelvaL' ical
ot/rco cuaKetcrflai ttclvtcov bij atcryjLo-Tov cttlv, cos d crds Adyos.

5 6 8e brj euds dcrrts, 7roAAdKts piev ?/?? etp??rai, ovdei> de
KcoAvet Kat ert Ae'yecrc9at #
Ou </>??ut, co KaAAtKAets, ro rv-
TTTo-0aL ttI Kopprjs d8tKco? atcr^tcrrov etât, o?38e ye ro re'p-
e Vcr9aL ovt to crco/jta ro e/xor ovre ro fiaW&VTLOv, dAAa ro

ru7rretv Kai eue Kai rd eud abCicoos Kal rep.VLV xal atcr^Lov
ml kclklov, Kal k\tttLV ye ap.a Kal avbpairobC&crdaL Kal
b 2 &6\wi post Se add. Bekker post &d\iot Heindorf (semel habet

:
Oxy.) b 3 tiBTPF: riva vulg. (et mox C 4) b 7 rovrw P

b 8 tov ao~iKe?v rb ab~iKu<rdai P C 2 Se? F (sed 1/ add. f) C 7 ouSe
awffai F Oxy. C 8 67rt ry fiov\ofj.ev(j) B T P iir\ rip fiov\evofiev<f F : :
secl. Morstadt (sed tn ru> /3o[ iam Oxy.) rov 40e\ovros

secl. Hirschig d 1 toDto rb F touto B T P d 2 enfSdWav
:
B T P F eK$a\eiv Oxy.
: d3 airoKre?vai] airoKrivvvvat Badham
d4 eartv om. F e I prius otire BTP : oi/oe F (3a\\dvriov
B T P &a\Avrtov F
:
TOPriAS 5 o8e
Toi\oipvx^v kglI o-vkh.r\fibr\v otlovv abtKeiv kol e/xe koX tol
e/xd rco abiKOVVTt. Kal kolklov ko! alcr\Lov etrat r\ e/xot r<3 5
abiKovixevio. ravTa rjpuv avco KL V tols irpoa-Oev Xoyois
ot/rco cpavevra, cos eyco Ae'yco, KaT\TaL Kal 8e'8erat, kch

ei aypoiKorcpov tl lttlv ecrrtr, o-Lbr\pols koX abap.avTLV0L<s 509
Aoyoiy, cos yovv av odetev ovtcoctl, ots crv et //.?/ Avcrets
?/ ctotj rts veavLKcorepos, ov\ olov T aXXcos Xeyovra T\ cos
eyco ro Ae'yco KaAco? Ae'yety e7re e/xotye 6 arjrds Adyos

eVrty det, drt eycb ravra ovk olba ottcos X e6 > OTt M* VTOt 5
coi> eycb VTTvyr\Ka, cocnxep vvv, oi8ets otds r' ecrrtTJ dAAco?
Xeycov /xr) ou Karaye'Aacrros etfat. eyco pXv ovv av TLdr\p.L
ravra ovtcos eyeLV et be ovrcos exft Kat /xeytcrroy rcoy KaKcou b

o~tlv r) doiKta rco deHKoSrri Kat ert tovtov p.elov /xeytcrrorj
ovtos, et otoV re, ro ddiKorjVra /*?/ 8tcWai bLKrjv, rCva av

v
(-\or\deLav /x? / 8wd/xe7Jos avOpcoTros fiorjOelv eavrco Karaye-
Xaoros av Trj aXr\6eCa. etr/; d/aa ov TavTr\v, rJTLS a.-TOTpe\}/L 5
Tr\v /xeytcrrr/y r/jucoy (3Xa(3r\v; clXXcl 7roAA?) di>dyKr? ravTr\v
elvai Tr\v aia-yj.crTr\v fior\6eLav /177 bvvacrOat fiorjdelv p,r\Te

ovtco /z?/re rots a?3ro?j cpCXoLS re Kat oIkLols, bevrepav 8e
r?/y rot) bevrepov KaKov Kat Tpvrr-v ttjv tov rpCrov Kal raAAa C
orjrcos* cos Kclo-tov KaKov p.eye6os irecpVKev, ovtco Kal KaAAoy
tov bvvarov elvaL ec/>' eKacrra /3or\6eLV Kal alcr)(yvr\ tov p.r\.
apa dAAcoy 77 orjrcos

X* l > ^ KaAAtKAets;
KAA. 0?jk dAAco?. 5
^12. Avotv OVV OVTOLV, TOV dblKLV T Kal abLKLCrdat,
p.l(pV p.V Cpap.V KaKOV TO 6\bLKLV, \aTTOV b rb abLKLcr6at.

tl ovv av Trapao-Kvao-ayi.Vos avdpa>Tros (aor\dr\o~LV arjrco,
&ctt t\p.cpoTpas tols coc/jeAtas ravras \lv, ti\v re a7ro tov d

/xr/ dotKety Kat tt\v a-ro tov \ii\ d8tKeto-cât; 7ro'repa bvvap.LV
e 6 Trpoc-etv T P F irpJo-fle B : e 7 *al ef BTF : <i /cal P

a2 A.u(Tts T f: Avffjrs BWF
2
b3 rb corr. Par. 1811 rbv :
BTPF h.v] Srj Hirschig b5 a-Tocrrptrp-t F b.7 Poi)6eia.v

obelo notavit Schanz aSvvafiiav ci. H. Richards
: c 1 Kal ante
Tp'm-v om. F c 3 tov nv F rec. b erofyirj B T P : 07 fniv om. F
5ogd IIAAT&NOS
r/ fiovkr](Tiv; <S8e be Aeyar iroTepov edv fxr) /3orJAr/rat abt-
Kticrdai, ovk dStKr/crerai, rj edv bvvap.LV 7rapacrKeudcrr/rai tov

5 fxr) abtKdo-Oai, oi/K d8iKr/crerat;
KAA. Afjkov br) tovto ye, otl edv bvvafj.iv.
2X2. Tt 8e br) tov abiKelv; TTorepov edv fxr) /3orJArjrat
dotKeiv, LKavov tovt Zo-tlv ov yap doiKrjcret' .77 Kal eirl
e tovto bel bvvafxiv TLva Kal Ti\vr\v irapao-Kevdo-acrdaL, cos,
edv fxr) jidOrj avra Kal dcrKrjcrrj, dotKrjcrei; rt ovk avro ye'
fXOL TOVTO aTTKpLV(0, 00 KaAAtKAet?, TTOTipOV ctol boKodfxev

opO&s avayKao~6r)vaL dfxokoyelv ev rot? ifx-npocrOev Adyots
5 eyco re Kat IIcoAos r) ov, rjvLKa co/xoAoyrjcra/xey fxrfbeva
fiovkofxevov abLKtLV, dAA' aKOi>ras tovs ddtKowras itdvTas

dbLKLV;
w
510 KAA. Ecrrco aot tovto, w 2coKpares, oi/rcos, Xva cua-
TTepdvfjs tov koyov.
212. Kat e7rt tovto apa, cos eoiKev, irapacrKevao-Teov
eort bvvafiLV TLva Kal TeyvrfV, 6tto>s fxr) d8tK?jcrco/xei\
5 KAA. Tldvv ye.

212. Tts ovv 7ror' ecrrtv Teyvrf rrjs irapao-Kevrjs tov
fxrfbkv d8iKetcrc?at r/ cos dAtytcrra; o-Ke\j/aL et crot 8oKet rj7rep
ifxoL efxol fxev ydp boKel rjbe' r) avrbv apyew belv ev

rrj 7ro'Aet rj Kat Tvpavveiv, i) rrjs vTrapyovcrrfs 7roAtreias
10 eratpoy etvai.
KAA. 'Opas, co 2coKpares, cos eyco eroLfxos elfxi eTraLveiv,
b dv tl KaAcos keyrfs; tovto fxoL boKeis irdvv KaAcos etprjKeVai.

212. 2K07ret br) Kal robe edv ctol 8okco ev Aeyety. c/jiAos
fxoL boKtL (-KacrTos eKacrrcp etiuai cos otdy re p,dAtcrra, ovirep

oi 7raAatot re Kat aocpol keyovcrLV, 6 ofxoLos t5> djiotcp. ov
5 Kat crot;
e2 /col BTP Kal : /i)j F y4 /jloi F : ye /u.ol BTP e3 aireKplvco

scr. recc. : BTPF
aireKplvov a 1 oiirais BTF : ious P Sia-
ircpavris T P F hiairepavri B : a4 adiK-fiao/j.ev Heindorf a7 %itip
T P f jJTrtp B /col eftrep' F
: : a8 ?,Se PF : f,Se B T ( T jj8e Buttmann
et supra rjirep cum B) Se"iv &pxeiv P a 10 eratpov F erepov :
BTP et in marg. f
ropriAS siob
KAA. 'Epotye.
2XX. Ovkovv ottov Tvpavvos ko-Tiv apyoiv dyptos koX
a-naibevTos, et rts tovtov iv r?/ 7ro'Aet ttoKv /3eArtcoi> et?/,
(pofiolTo bi]iTov av avrbv 6 rvpavvos Kal tovtio e aTravTos

tov vov ovk av 7rore bvvairo (pikos yzvkaQai; c
KAA. "Ecrrt Tavra.
2X2. Ovbe ye et rts ttoXv <pauAo'repos et?/, oi>5' dy otVos*
Karacppovol yap av avrov 6 rvpavvos Kat ovk av 7rore cos
7rpos (piXov o-TTOvbacreLtv. 5

KAA. Kat raur' d\rj6rj.
2X2. Aet7rerat 8?/ eKetvos povos dtos Ao'you cptAos rco
rototrrcp, os av 6puor)6r\s coz>, raurd yfreyoiv Kat ZiraLV&v,
e0e'A?/ apyeo-daL /cat V7roKeicrt9ai rcp apyovTL. ovtos \iiya
kv TavTrj rf/ 7ro'Aei SurT/crerat, roOroy o?35ets \aipu>v dStKT/cret. d
ovx otVtos exft;
KAA. Nat.
2X2. Et apa tis (vvorjatLev ei> Tavrr\ rr} 7ro'Aet rcov veW,
" Ttra av Tpoirov eyco p,e'ya bvvaip.r\v /cat p,??5eis pe dtKoi;" 5
avr?/, cos eotKer, airtp 68o's earty, e?j#i>s eK ie'ou e6i(LV
avTov tols avTois yaiptLV Kal axdeadaL rco SecnroVrj, Kat
7rapacrKe?jdêtv 07rcos ort /xdAtcrra opotos ecrrat eKetVco. o?)x
ovrcos;
KAA. Nat. 10
2X2. Ovkow rotVto ro p.ev pT) d8iKetcr0at Kai p,iya
bvvaadaL, tos 6 v/xeVepos Aoyos, ey rr/ 7ro'Aet 8ta7re7rpd- e
erat.
KAA. Ildvv ye.
2X2. *Ap' ow Kat rb /xtj dotKeti'; ?*/ 7roAAou 8et, et7rep
o/xotos ecrrat rco ap\ovTL ovtl doiKto Kat 7rapd tovto) p.iya 5
8w?jcrerat; dAA' otpat eycoye, 7rdi> TOvvavTiov ovtcoo\ r)
b 7 &pxov P C3 oSros B T P F ovtws Schanz : di rp

P F b om. B T
: d 4 W &pa tis B T P dp' oSi/ tjs F tovt?7 F )f
W
: :
outi) B T fort. iv outtj ToiyT?? Stallbaum

: d 6 oi/'t?j F out^ : rj
B fP oSJs B T P jj 6S6s F: e 6 outwo-1 B T P ovtws F :

;
5ioe IIAAT&N0.S
TrapaaKCvr) ecrrat avrip e7Tt to otco re et/Jat cbs 7rAeicrra
dSiKet/J Kat d8tKowra p.r) hihovai hUr]V. r/ ydp;
KAA. <f>au>erat.
511 211. Ojjkojji' to ix&yio-Tov avT(o KaKov 7J7rdpet px)\6r\p(a

ovtl rrjv \}'vxr)v Kal AeAco/3r7peVco 8ta tj]v pCp.r](TLV tov 8e-
o"tt6tov Kal hvvap.iv.
KAA. Ovk 018' oirri crrpe'c/>eis' kKaaTOT* tovs Koyovs avco

5 xat KaTU), cb 2coKpares* r/ otjk oto#a ort ovtos 6 p.ip.ovp.(.vos
tov pr) p.tp.ovp.evov Zkclvov airoKTtVii, edy (3ovKt]Tai, Kal

dcpatpr/crerai tcl ovra.
b 212. Ot8a, coyafle KaAAucAets, et pr) Kcocpos y et/xt, kol

crou d/covcoy /cat ITcoAou dprt ttoXKclkls Kat ra>i> aXXcov okiyov
irdvTcov t&v iv rrj 7rdAef dAAd Kat o-v epov ctKove, 6Y1
diroKreret p.iv, av ftovkqrai, dAAd irovr)p6s <av koKov myadov
5 ovTa.
KAA. Ovkovv tovto hr) Kal to ayavaKTrjTov
212.Ov vovv ye tyovTi, cos 6 koyos o-iip.aiva. rj otet
8ety tovto ?rapacrKe?jdecr0ai dv6pcoirov, cbs 7rAetcrroy xpovov
Cijv, Kal /xeAerdy rds Te^vas ravras at r)p.as det eK rcoy

C Kivhvvcov o~<p(ovo-LV, coo-irep Kat fjv ov KeAevets e/xe /jteAerd^
rr/y prrroptKr/y rqv h tols 8tKacrrrrptois SiacrcoôTjcraJj;
KAA. Nat p.d Ata dp0cos ye crot o-vp.fiovktvcov.
212. T 8e, cb /3e'Artcrre; 17 Kat 77 rot) vclv iirLcrTr]p.t]
5 o~ep,vr) rts ctol hoKcl etrat;
KAA. Ma At" ovk e/xotye.
212. Kat p.r)v crcoêt ye Kat arjrr/ eK câydrov rorjs dv6pco-

ttovs, orav ets rt rotourov kp.iiicrcocrLV ov 8et ra7jrrrs rrys
iTLo-Tr)p,r]s. et 8' a?jr?7 crot 8oKet o~p.LKpd etTJat, eyco oot

d /xet^co TavT-qs epto, rr/y Kvfiepvr]TLK-r]V, rj ov p.6vov tcls ^f/vxas
crcoêi dAAd Kat rd crco/xara Kat rd xp^M ara ^ K '"^^ ecrxdrcoy
e 8 dStKoDvTa B T PP Si/coiWi
aSiKovvrt F : a 4 oV?
?$7rr; oiroi B T
F oVoj : W
b2 &prt B T P &pa F : o~vnfiov\ev(i>v F (ite\evwv
C 3 ffvnfiovXivwv
c (ittKevwv in marg. f ) :
av/xfiovKevw B T P 04^
C 4 $ /c al ^ ToO F r\ nal 7] tov B rj Kal tov T P
: :
c8 ti toioCto^ F toiovtov
oCto' B T P
: d 1 /ueitfw F nufava B T P :
ropriAS 5nd
KLvbvvoov, axnrep f) /5r/roptK?/. koX avT-q p.ev TrpocreaTaAueVr/
hrr\ koX Koapta, Kal ov crepvvveraL ea-vj/aarto-ueVr/ <w?
VTTpr\(pav6v tl bi.aTtpaTTop.ivr), akkd raiVd biairpaâpAvr) 5
rrj bLKavLKjj, idv p.ev e AlyCvrjs bevpo o-taVrj, otpat bv

ofiokovs (TTpdâTO, idv oe e AlyvTTTOv rj ck tov YIovtov,
idv TTap.TTo\v, ravTrjs rfjs p.eydkt]s evepyeaCas, ococracra a e
vvvbf) ikeyov, Kal ax/Tov Kal rraibas Kat \pr]p.aTa koX yvvai-
Kas, d7ro/3t/3do-ao-' ds tov AtueW bvo bpa\p.ds e7rpdaro,

Kal avros 6 e\oov tt)v Ti\vr\v koX raCra bLaiTpadp.evos
eK/3ds irapa rr)v ddkaTTav koX ti)v vavv 7repi7raret iv /u,erptv o-vp.Trk(.6vToov ovk idcras
KaTaTTOVTOiOrjvaL kol ovo-Twas e/3Aai/rey, etocos ort ovb\v
avTovs /3eAriot;s ee/3i/3acrey f) oXol ivi(3r]crav, ovtc tcl crco- 5 12
p.ara ovt tcls ^rv\ds. Aoytcferat ovv otl ovk, et p.iv tls
weydAots Kat dvtdrots vorrfjp.ao-LV Kard to crG>pa crvvexo-
pevos p.f] aTTTTvyr], ovtos pikv ddkLos ecrra/ otl ovk diri-
>
davev, koX ovbiv vtt avrov dxpikrjTaL' et bi tls apa iv r<3 5
tov crcowaros rtMtcore'pcp, tjj îvyr), iroAAa voo-r\p.aTa e)(ei
koX dviara, tovtoo 8e /3tcore'oi> ecrrty /cat tovtov dinjcrei,
avT iK <9aAdrrrjs avTt eK bLKacrrqpiov idvrt dkkodev otto-

6evovv crcacrT/, dAA' otoei ort ovk dp.tLv6v icrTLV fjv rco b
p.oy6r]p(ti dvdpojTroo' kokcos ydp dvdyKr] ecrrty fjv.
Ata ravra ov vop.os eart 0-ep.vvvecrdai t6v Kv(3cpvf]Tr]v,

KatVep o-((pvTa r/pas, ovbi ye, 00 (9avudcrte, tov p.r)yavo-
ttolov, os ovt o~TpaTr]yov, p.f) ort KVj3epvr]Tov, ovtc dAAou 5
ovbevbs eAdrrco ivioTt bvvaTat crcoêty 7ro'Aeis ydp ecrrty
ot o\as crcpcfet. pfj ctol boKel Kard tov biKavLKOv etrat;
d 5 8iaTrpaa.fj.ti>ri F Olympiodorus : 8<airpoTTO/*evTj B T P f

d.6 Scvpo BT
P 5e : F 6 2 yvvdiKas] ywcitKct Naber 03 aTr[o-
fitfido-cura] F (sed inclusa in lac. suppl. f) : airofiifidcras BTW
a 1 ofo< Ft : ot BTP a5 for' BTPf
F a 7 fitorbv
: air
(ffrai Hirschig oj^cret Deuschle bvi\a(t(v B T P F
: b 4 Oavfidffte
BTP : OavfjtaffK&Tare F b 6 ir6\fts T P F nr6\ts B :
PLATO, VOL. III. 23

5i2b nAATUNOS
Katrot et {3ov\olto keyeiv, S> KaAAtKAets, airep v/xets, <rep,-
C vvvaiv t6 TTpayp.a, KaTay&creLev av vfxas rots Ao'yots, Xeycov

nal TrapaKakdv ZttI to belv yiyvecrOai. p.y)yavoTTOLOvs, <as
ovbev raAAd ecrriir lkovos yap avr<2 6 Adyos. dAAa o~v
ovbev fJTTOv avTov KaracppoveXs Kal Trjs Teyvr-s rrjs eKet-
5 vov, Kal ws kv oWtSet d7roKaAe'crais av p.rjyavoTTOL6v, Kal

tS> vet avTov ovr' b\v bovvai dvyaTepa e0e'Aots, ovr av
avTos Aa/3eti> ttjv eKeivov. Katrot ef S>v t<x <ravTov iirai-
vels, tlvl StKato) Ao'ya> tov pvqyavoiroiov Karac/joo/vets kou.
d t<7>v dX\<av 8>v vvvbrj eXeyov; 018' ort cpaL-qs &v /3eAriW
eTuat Kat eK /3eArtoVcoz\ to 8e (3cXtlov et pt,rj io~Tiv 6 eyco
Aeyco, dAA' avro tovt eorlv dpeTrj, to <tu>(^lv avTov koX
tcl kavTov ovTa oiroios rts tTvyev, Karaye'Aacrrds crot 6
5 \j/6yos ytyuerai Kat p.r)yavo-roiov koX larpov kol tG>v dXXojv
Teyyutv oo-at tov <t<Luv evtKa TTTToir}VTai. dAA', co
/xaKapte, opa p.r] dXXo rt to yevvalov Kat to dyaOov $ t/ rd

crtocfety re Kat cru>&cr6ai. p.r) yap tovto /xeV, to C,r\v otto-
e crovbri xpovov, tov ye &>s dXi]d<as dvbpa iariov <ttlv koCl
ov cpLXo-J/vxqTiov, aXXa e7rtrpe'i//az>ra 7rept rorjrcoy t<2 0eco

Kat 7rto-reJjVaz>ra rats yvvailv otl ti]V et/vtap/xeVr/y o?38' cw
ets CKcpvyoL, to eirl tovtu> crKe7rreW tlv av rpoTrov tovtov
5 ov /xeAAot ypovov /3t<o/vat cos dpL<TTa /3toir/, dpa eop,OL<2v
513 avTov tjj 7roAtreta Tavrr) eV fi

av oikt/, kcll vvv 8e dpa 8et
o-e a)s opioioTaTov yiyvecrdaL rw 87//UO) rw 'At^r/vatW, et
/Ae'AAets rovra) TrpocrcpLkris etvat Kat /ue'ya bvvacrdaL iv Tr\
7ro'Aef ro?3(9' 6'pa et o-ot Avo-treAet Kat e/>iot, 07ra)s /atj, S
5 8ai/xoW, TreLo-Ofueda oVep oiao-i rds rr)y o-eAT/rr/y KadaL-

povaas, ras 0erraAi8as* aiw rots cptArdrots r/ atpeats t//>uj.'
C 6 o(/t' &j/ ante t$ transp. Cobet e 7 outos B T F avTbv P aS : :
Schanz auTos t$ <rauroi; al.

: d 1 oI5' T P F 01 8' B d 7 ?J :
^ to Heindorf 77 to B j? to T P F toC Coisl.

: : d 8 yu^ yap] $ yap
:
Schanz br6aov SijWf Antoninus 6ir6<rov St B oiroaov S7 T P F : :
ei 7f BTF: reW 65 ÂAoi B T P F ÂAe Antoninus :
jSiijJrj B T P F a 2 t adrivaiwv T P t&Sj' adrivaiwv B F a 6 0* t-:
TaAtSas BF : OeTTaAiKas TP
ropriAs 513 a
errrat TavTi]$ tF]S 8wd//,ecos rfjs ev rfj 7rdAet. et be rrot otet
ovtlvovv avdpcoiroiv Trapabcacreiv Te\vr]v tivol Toiavrrjv, ?/'rts
cre 7rot?/crei p.eya bvvacrOai ev rfj 7ro'Aet rf/8e avop.oiov ovra b

tt\ 7roAtreta etr' e7rt rd /3e'Artov etr' e7rt to yeipov, cos e/xot
Sokci, ovk 6p6G>s j3ov\evr], 00 KaAAucAetS' ov yap p.ip.r]Tr]v
8et et/jat dAA' avrocpvcas 6p.01.ov tovtois, et /j.e'AAets rt yy?7-
crtoy aTrepyaêcrOaL ets c/uAtay rco 'A6r]vaio)V br]p.(o nal val 5
/w.a Ata rco ITupiAa/x7ro?jy ye 7t/jos. dcrrts ovv o-e rovrots

6p.oioTaTov d7repydo-erat, oi!rds cre 7roi?70-ei, cos ein6vp.eis
7roAtrtKos eiVai, 7roAtrtKoy Kai pr]ToptKov rto avr&v yap
?/0et \eyop.evcov tu>v \6yu>v e^Kacrrot yaipovcn, rto be dAAo- C
rpta dxôrrat, et p.r] rt crv aAAo Aeyets, co c/uA?/ Kecpakr'].
keyop.ev rt 7r/)ds raura, co KaAAtKAets;

KAA. Ovk 018' ovTiva p.01 Tpo-nov Sokcis ev keyeiv, u>
ScoKpares, TTeirovda be to t5>v TrokkcHv Trdflos* ov 7rdi>?j o-ot 5
7ret#ojuai.
2X2. 'O 8?/juo?j ydp epcos, ct> KaAAtKAets, eij<07J ev rfj \j/v\f]
Trj crrj di>rtcrraret p.of dAA' edv 7roAAaKts [tcrcos Kat] ftekTiov
TavTa ravra b(,acrKOira>p.eda, 7retcrc9?/cr?/. avap.vr]cr6r]Ti 8' o?jtj d
ort 8?j" ecpap.ev elvai rds TtapasrKevas enl to eKacrTov depa-
irevetv, Kal crto/xa Kat \l/vyj]V, p.iav ptev 7rpds r)bovr]v 6p.tketv,
Tr)v erepav be 7T/)ds rd /3e'Art<rro;j, /urj KaTayapt6p.evov dAAd

biap.ay6p.evov. ov TavTa r)v a Tore iopi(ftp.eda; 5
KAA. Ildw ye.
2X2. OvkoCtj 77 /xeu erepa, 77 7rpds ?/8o7J?/7J, dyeTJTJTJs Kat

o?j8e;j dAAo r) KokaKeia rvy\avei ovcra' rj ydp;
v
KAA. Ecrra), et /3ovAet, crot oiJrcos. e
2X2. *H 8e' ye erepa, drrcos cos /3e'Artcrroy eo-rat ro{!ro,
etre au>p.a Tvyyavet ov etre "tyvxr], 6 6epairevop.ev;
b5 dirfpâêtrflcu B T P airepydaaaBat F
: b 8 TroAertK&s om. cod.
Meermannianus auTwvBTPf: airrw F 03 \4yofitv B T P F :
\tywti4v al. c4 oii/c B T P F /xe' ouk : o-i Aristides c8 Xixws xal

seclusi (Iffws secl. Schaefer : iroAAa/cis tffws secl. Schanz) d1 Tain-a
om. F d 5 a r6re BWFt: StcT ei tffrw ffot ravra tl f}ov\tt
ot?Tw F 63 post Oepairtvofitv lacunam indicat Schanz
513 e ITAATftNOS
KAA. Udvv ye.
v
5 212. Ap' ovv ovtoos eTTL\eLpr)Teov rjplv eoTLV ttj iroXeL
kcu toTs TroX.tT<us QepaireveLV, o)s )3e\.TioTovs avrovs TOVS
noXiras iroLovvTas; avev yap br) tovtov, g>s ev tols ep-

TrpocrOev rjvpio-Kopev, ovbev ocpeXos aXXrjv evepyeoiav ovbe-
514 p.iav TrpoocpepeLV, edv pr) KaXr) KctyaOr) f) bidvoia fi
tS>v
peXXovToov r) yjpr)p.aTa ttoXKol X.ap.(3dveLV t) apyr)v tlvoov r)
akXrjv bvvapLV rjvTLVovv. cpS>p,ev ovtoos e\eLv;

KAA. Yldvv ye, el <rot rjbtov.
5 22. Ei ovv TrapeKaX.ovp.ev dXXrikovs, 00 KaAAuAeis, brj-
pocriq irpdôvTes tS>v ttoXltlkSv Trpayp.aToov eiri tci olKobo-

p,LKa, r) TL)(o>v r) vecopioov rj lepS>v em tcl p,eyioTa olKobopr\-
para, troTepov ebeL &v rjpxis O7cev/rao-0ai frp.ds avrovs Ka\
b eêraVai irpStTov p.ev ei eTTLordp.eda tt)v Texvrl v V 0VK
eTTLordpeOa, Tr)v olKobopLKrjv, kol 7rapa tov ep.ddop.ev; ebeL
4 * V
av rj ov;
KAA. Ildvv ye.
5 212. Ovkovv bevTepov av Tobe, el tl tt<H)1tot olKobop,r)pa
u>Kobop.r\Kapev Ibiq f) tS>v cpiXoov tlvl f) rjperepov avrSv, Kal

tovto to oiKobop.r)pa KaXbv r) alo-\pov loriv Kal ei p.ev
qvpicrKopev crKOTrovp.evoL 8i5acncaAovs' re f)pS>v dyaOovs koX

C eXXoyip.ovs yeyovoras kol olKobop.f)p,aTa iroXXd piev Ka\ KaXd
peTa tS>v bibaoKaXoov <2>Kobop.r)p.eva fjplv, irokkd be Kal ibia
f)pS>v eireibr) tS>v bLbaoKaXoov aTrqXXayrfpev, ovtoo pev 8ia-
KeLpevoov, vovv eyovTOOV f)v av levaL eiri tcl brjpooia j-pya-
5 el be p.r)Te 8i8aovcaAoz; elyppev f)pS>v avT&v e7rieiat oIko-
bopi)p.aTa re f) p.t)bev r) TroXXd Kal p.r)bevbs aia, ovtoo
e5 tV tt6\iv koI robs iroXiras F

6 6 depairtvuv secl. Cobet
e 7 e/xTrpocrdev BTP e 8 fvplo-KOfiev B T P wp-fiKaixev F
: irp6o-dev F :
6<pe\os T P Fb &<pe\os B : a 3 <pwfiev F (coniecerat Madvig) :
Ou/jiev B T P a 6 Ttpatovres F irpdâvres B T P (sed o supra a P :
rec. b) rdâvTes Madvig

: b 1 t)\v Texvyv f) ovk evto-Ta/j-eda P F
et in marg. B T om. B T : b 2 oIkooo/j.ikt)v T P F (sed v supra
8 T) otKovofjuK-f)v B (sed ras. supra v)
: irapa tov B P F wapd :
tovT c 2 r5m] ISia. B T P F 5ia Voemel Ma 8' (5ia Schanz) : :
Madvig C4 av levai F: avievai BTP

ropriAS 5hc
br) avorjrov r)v br\irov cirix.ei.peiv Tois br\pocrCoLs epyois koX
irapaKaXeiv dAAtjAous eV avra. cp&pev ravra 6p0G>s Xe-

yeo-Qai r) ov; .
d
KAA. Uavv ye.
2X2. Ovkovv ovtco irdvra, Ta T dXXa Kav ei einxeipr)-
cravres brjpocrLeveLV irapeKaXovp.ev dAArjAous ots iKavol larpol

ovres, eireo-Ke\jfdp.e6a brjirov av eya> T cre /cat crv ep.e, (Pepe '5
irpbs 0eG>v, avTos be 6 2a>Kpdrrjs ir&s ex et ro ~<>)

P'
a '"730 ?
vyiciav; r) ijbr\ tls dXXos bia IjoiKpdrqv dirr\XXdyr\ voo~ov,
r) 80SA0? rj eXev0epos; k&v eyto oTpuxL irepl crov eTepa

ToiavTa ecrKoirovv Kal cl p.r\ r\vpCarKop.ev bC r\p.as p.r\beva
j3eXrCoi ycyovora to crG>pa, p.r\Tc tG>v evoiv p.r\TC tG>v Q

dcTT&v, /uTjre dvbpa p.r\Te yvvaiKa, irpbs Aios, a> KaAAtKAei?,
ov KaTaycKacTTOV c\v r)v Tr) dXr\0cCq, els toctovtov dvoias
cX0civ av0poiirovs, &crre, irplv IbioiTcvovTas iroXXd piev oirois
crvxopev iroirjcrai, 7roAAa be Karop0G>aaL ko\ yvp.vdcracr0aL 5
LKav&s tt\v Tcxvr\v, to Xey6p.evov br) tovto cv tG> irC0oi tt)v
KepapeCav eirixeLpeiv pxiv0dvLV, Kat ovtovs re br\pocrLeveLv

CTTLxeLpeiv Kal dAAous tolovtovs irapaKaXeiv; ovk dvoryrov
ctol boKei dv etvaL ovTOi irpaTTCLv;
KAA. "EpoLye. 10
212. NCy be, a> /3e'Arto-re dvbpGtv, eireLbr) crv pev avrbs S l S
dpTL dpxi\ irpdrTeLV rd Trjs iroXeois irpdyp.aTa, epe be irapa-
KdXeis Kal 6vLbCeLS otl ov irpaTTOi, ovk cirLo-Kc^r6p.c0a
dXXr\Xovs, ^cpc, KoAAikAt/s rjbr\ Tivd /3eAu'a) irciroCrjKcv
tGv ttoXlt&v; ccttlv octtls irpoTcpov irovr\pbs &v, dStKos re 5

Kat dKoXacrros Kal dcppoiv, td KaAAtKAea KaAo's re Kdyaflds
yeyovev, r) evos r\ dcrros, r) 8013^0? rj eXcv0epos; Xeye p.0L,
C 7 8}/] 5e Basileensis altera v Sîrov B T P om. F (sed add. ?jv :
post iicixfipeTv) : ?iv &v irov Schanz e 8 (pwfj.ev B T P f Sufxtv F :
d- 3 iirixftpâvTts B T P F iTrixapô-ovres Heindorf

: d. 5 Sij &v
irov F iyd) Te T
2
W
F iyarye B T : d 7 JJSt? corr. Par. 1812 :
6 S^ B T P F d 9 ijvpio-Ko/jiev B tvp(o-KO/j.ev T P F : 09 ovtw

BTP: tovto F a4 Ka\\tK\rjs T F Ka\\tK\ets B W a6 Ka\6s
:
BWFt: koM($sT a7 f) ao-rbs TWF:om. B

515 b 11AATX2N02
b edv ris cre ravTa ecferd^V/, co KaAAucAets, H epets" rtVa
cpr/crets /3eArtco 7re7rot?/KeVat dvOpcoTrov rrj o~vvovo~iq tt) cr?/;
oKêis aitoKpLvaadai, et7rep ecrrtiv rt fpyov o~bv ert tico-
rerWros, 7rpti> br)p.oo~LevLV kirLyeLpeiv;
5 KAA. *I>iAoVikos et, a 2coKpares\

2X2. 'AAA' ov cpiXovLKLq ye epcorco, dAA' cbs dA?70cos /3oi>-
\6p.evos etSeVat ovtlvcl 7rore Tpoirov otet 8etv 7roAtrevecrât

e> 7//jiu\ 77 aAAou rou apa TTLp.ikr]o~r) r)pXv ekdiav eVt tcl
C r^s 7ro'Aecos TTpa.yp.aTa r) otto)s otl /3e'Aricrroi ot 7roAtrat u>p.ev;
t) OV TToXkCLKLS ?/8?/ Ot>p.o\oyJ]Kap.V TOVTO belv TTpaTTe.LV TOV

ttoXltlkov dvbpa; a>p.o\oyr)Kap.ev ?/ ov; aiTOKpivov. cbpo-
Koyr)Kap.ev eycb V7rep croi) airoKpLvovp.aL. et tolvvv tovto
5 8et ror ayaObv dvbpa TrapacrKevdêLV tt) eavTOv 7rdAet, uw
/xot avap.vr)o~de\s elire 7rept CKeivoov t&v dvbp&v S)v dAiyco
irpoTepov eAeyes, et ert crot boKovcnv dyaOol 7roAtrat yeyo-
d J>ez>at, riepiKA?/s Kat Kip.cov Kal MtArtaSr/? Kat eptcrroKA^?.
v
KAA. Ep.otye.
2X2. OtjkojjV et7rep ayaOoi, bfjkov otl eKao~ros avT&v
/SeArtovs eVotet roi)s TroAtras dvrl \eLpovcov. eiroieL ?/ ov;
5 KAA. Nat.
2X2. OrjKow 6're YlepLKXrjs f]pyeTo keyeLV eV rco dr/pco,
\eipovs r)o~av ol 'AdrjvaloL r) ore tcl reAevrata eXeyev;

v
KAA. Icrcos.
2X2. Ojjk tcrcos br), o) /3e'Artcrre, dAA' dvdyKr) eK rcoV

io b)p.oXoyr)p.VO)v, eXirep dyaflds y' ?]y eKelvos 7roAtr?/s.
e KAA. Tt ow/ brj;
2X2. Ovbiv dAAa ro8e /xot et7re e7rt ro7jrco, et Aeyovrai

A0r)vaLOL cud JleptKAea /3eArto?js yeyoêVai, ?/ 7razv Tovvav-
t'lov biacpdaprjvaL vtt' eKeivov. raurt ydp eycoye aKorjco,
b2 d^pciTrcoj' Hirschig b8 ^ TP et in lac. textus f: ^ B ^ :
Heindorf: Schleiermacher Ci ol iroKTrai B T P iroKlrai F :
(o om. Hirschig, Schanz) e 6 oAiyip B T P bhiyov F C 7 dyoflol :
BT P : d-yoflol 0/ F CI4 ^7roi post x'po'"<>>' transp. F (om. mox

altero iiroUi) d 5 toiBTPF: Aldina
eVoi'j d7 ol BT P !
om. F d 9 S^ P F 8e B T : avdyKy Schanz

TOPriAS 5i5e
riepiKAea 7re7roi?/KeVai '

A6r\vaiov$ dpyovs ko.1 8eiAoi;s nal 5
AdAous Kal (pLkapyvpovs, ets pLcrdocpopiav Ttp&rov Karaorq-

o-avra.
KAA. Tcotj Ta )Ta KareayoVcoy aKoveis Tavra, S) 2co-
/cpares.
212. 'AAAd rabe ovk4tl aKova>, dAA' otSa trac/>cos Kal 10
eyco Kat o~v, otl to pikv irp&Tov r]vboKip.ei TlepiKArjs Kat

ovbep.iav alcryjpdv bUrjv KaTe^rqcpicravTo avrov 'AdqvaloL,
rjvUa \dpovs rjcrav' e7rei5?/ 8e KaAot Kayadol Zyeyovecrav
v-n ax/Tov, eVt reAeurr/ roC /3tou tov TlepLKkiovs, Kkomjv 5 J 6
avrov KaT\f/r]cpicravTo, okiyov 8e Kat davdrov iTipjqcrav,
brjkov otl d>s Trovrjpov OVTOS.
KAA. Tt ovv; tovtov evtKa KaKos r\v YlepLKkrjs;
212. "Ovcov yovv av e7rtju,eA ?/r?/s Kal trrnrwv kol j3oa>v 5
tolovtos a>v KaKos dv iboKL eii>ai, et 7rapakal3d>v /x?/ AaKrt-

(ovras kavTov /xr/Se KvpirrovTas ti?/8e baKVOvras d7re'8ete
rairra airavTa iroLovvTas bC dypLorqTa. ?/ ov boKel o-ol
KaKos eti>ai imp.kr]Tr)s dcrrtcro?jV otovovv coo?j, os - v irapa- b

kaj3d>v r/juepcoreoa airobei^r} dyptcorepa ?/ 7rape'Aa/3e; SoKet
* V
t/ otj;
KAA. Yldvv ye, fo/a crot \apicra>p.aL.
212. Kat ro'8e roivvv p.oi ydpLcraL aTTOKpLvdp.evos' 7ro're- 5

pov Kai 6 dv6po)7ros er rcoi> fcocoi> ecrrtv ?} ot>;
KAA. Ilcos yap ov;

212. Ovkovv dv6panra>v YlepLKkijs e7re/.te'A ero;
KAA. Nat.
212. Tt ovv; ovk eSei avrovs, cos dprt co/xoAoyo?3/xe7J, 10
bLKaLoripovs ytyovivaL dvrl dbLKa>Tpa>v V7r' tKeivov, et7rep

eKetôs e7re/ueAetro avrcov dya0ds d>v tcl 7roAtrtKa; C
e 6 \a\ovs tB (sed & erasum) T P: Ka\ovs F

f : c\\d\ovs e 1 1 17080-
(cfyi B : TPF
fvSoKififi a 1 iir\ UcpiK\tovs seel. Cobet . . .
a 5 6vwv yovv av T P F ovuv av y olv av B (sed prius av erasum)

: :
ovwv yovv Aristides a6 eiBTP: F a7 eavrbv B T avrbv jurj :
PF Aristides : avrovs I" a8 airavras F b2^PF:^*T:r5B

b8 4ire/j.e\eTo BTP : cirt[tf\e?TO F b 10 &oti BTP : aprius F
5 i6c nAATilNOS
KAA. Yldvv ye.
2X2. Ovkovv oX ye StKatot r)p,epoi, a>s ecpr) "Ofxrjpos' crv
be rt cprjs; ovx ovtohs;
5 KAA. Nat'.
2X2. 'AAAa pLTjv dypmTepovs ye avrovs drrecp-qvev rj oXovs
rrapeXafiev, Kal ravT ds ovtov, bv ^'kioV av e(3ov\ero.

KAA. BouAet croi bp.oXoyr)croi;
2X2. Et hoK& ye crot dkr)0ij keyeiv.

v
io KAA. Eor&> br) ravra.
212. Ovkovv eXirep aypioiTepovs, dbiKiaTepovs re Kat
Xelpovs;
d KAA. "Ecttoi.
2X2. Ovk ap' dyaflos Ta 7roAtriKa riepiKA?7s r)v eK tovtov

tov koyov.
KAA. Ov o~v ye cp-rjs.
,
5 2X2. Ma At' ovbe ye o~v e &v &>/xoAo'yet?. rraXiv de
Ae'ye /xot Trepl Ki)xcovos' oi>k eôio-TpaKicrav avrbv ovtoi ovs

eOepairevev, Xva avrov beKa tG>v fxrj aKovcreiav rfjs cpojvijs;
Kal @e/xioTOKAe'a ravra raCra eiroir]o-av koL cpvyfj irpocre-
(j)p.io)crav ; MCKriabr-v be tov Mapad&vi els rb (SapaOpov

e ep.(3a\eXv e\j/r)cpicravTO, Kat et pvf) 8ta tov trpvTaviv, eveirecrev
av; Kairot ovtol, ei r)crav avbpes ayaOoi, a>s av cpr\s, ovk
av 7rore ravra eiracryov. ovkovv oX ye ayaOol i)vioyoi Kar
dpxcts fxev ovk eKTriiTTOVcriv Ik t&v (evy&v, eireibav be
5 Oepairevcroicriv tovs Xirirovs koX avrol dfxeivovs yevoivrai
rjvioxpi, tot eKTriTTTOvcriv' ovk e"oTi raur' ovt ev i)viox*is eoiKev, ot ep.irpocr6ev Ao'yot rjcrav,
517 ort ovbeva i)fxeXs Xcrfxev avbpa ayaBbv yeyovora ra 7roAtrtKa
c 7 avr6v P : airrbv BTF : secl. Cobet d5 aijio\6yeis BTP :
6fio\oye7s F d.9 napadwvi F (scripserat Schanz) iv napa&Hvi :
BTP e4^BTPF: om. Aristides 65 aixtivovs yevwvrat

BTPF ; yfvuvrai afj.dvovs Aristides
ropriAs 517 a
eV rfjbe rfj 7ro'Aet. <rv be co/xoAdyets rcoy ye vvv ovbeva,

tu>v p.evToi ep.TTpoo-0ev, kcli irpoeikov tovtovs tovs avbpas'
ovtol be avecpdvrjcrav e Xcrov tols vvv ovres, cocrre, et ot!rot
priTopes r)crav, ovre rfj akr)6ivfj prjTopiicfj expcovro ov yap 5

aV CêTTeCTOV OVTe TT) KOkaKLKr).
KAA. 'AAAd /xeVrot irokkov ye 8et, co ScoKpares, p.r]
7rore' rts t<2v vvv Zpya rotaura epydcnirai ota tovtcov octtls
/3oi/Aet etpyacrraL. b
212. *12 batp.6vic, ov8' eycb \}reyco tovtovs cos ye StaKo'-
vovs etrat 7ro'Aecos, dAAd /xot Sokoucti rcoi> ye w taKoi>iKco-
Tcpoi yeyovevaL Kal pMkkov oloi re eKiropiêLV rr/ 7ro'Aet cop
iTie6vp.il.. akka yap /zera/3t/3de> rds eiri6vp.ias koI p.r) 5
eTTLTpeireiv, ireidovTes ml /3tafo'/xeyoi e7rt rouro o0ey e/ueA-
Aoi> ap.eivovs ecrecrdaL ol 7roAtrai, cbs e7ros e27reti> ov8ey
tovtcov bUcpepov iKelvof oirep p.6vov epyov cttIv ayadov c
7roAro?j. yaus 8e Kat Ttiyr) ko! vecopta koX dAAa 7roAAd
Toiavra Kal eyco crot d/xoAoyco beLVorepovs elvai eKeivovs
tovtcov eKTTopieiv. irpayp.a ovv yekolov Troi.ovp.ev eyco re
Kat crv ev tols Adyots* ev 7Tavrl yap rco XP V(? v StaAeyo'- 5
p.eOa ovbev irav6p.eda ets rd avrd det Trepi(pep6p.evoL Kal

ayvoovvTes dkkrjkcov otl keyop.ev. eyco yovv cre TrokkaKLS
01/u.ai (op.okoyr\KevaL koX eyvcoKevaL cbs apa 8ittt) avrri rts
r) TTpayp.areia ecrTLV ko.1 irepl to crcopa Kal irepl rr)v \j/vx^v, d

Kat r) p.ev erepa bLaKovLKrj ecrrLV, y bvvarbv elvaL eKiropiêLV,
eav p.ev ireLvfj tcl crco/jiara r)p.(ov, o-iria, eav be bL\(rfj, ttotol,
eav be /atycp, t/xdrta, crTpcop.aTa, viTobrfp.aTa, dAA' coi> epxerai

crco/uara ets eiTL6vp.iav Kat efe7rtrr/8e's crot 8td rcoy avrcov 5
etKoVcoy Ae'yco, IW paov KaTap.adr\s. tovtcov yap itoplotlkov
etvai 77 Ka7rT7Aoy ovra r) ep.Tropov r\ bt]p.Lovpy6v tov avrcov
a 4 i ovtoi] eJ Toiovroi Aristides a7 /t^] ou /x); Madvig et in

editione Schanz (nunc fiit tuetur v. Rh. Mus. xli. 152) : tcal ov /j.7)
Cobet mox a 8 So-m F bs B T P
'
(et ipydtreTai) : e 5 tv
BTF: SP C7 yoi/v Ven. 189 t o?y F : : o?j/ B T P C 8 tis
aiiTt) F d 4 aXXa S>v rec. p : &XXwv 3>v BTPF
517 e nAAT&NOS
e TOVTOiV, CTLTOTTOLOV 1) 6^/OTTOLOV T/ VCpdvTr)V f/ CTKVTOTOpLOV r)
o-Kvrohôv, ovb\v davfxacrTov Zcttlv ovra tolovtov boai Kal

avrS> Kal toIs aAAots 6epaTTVTi)v dvaL croip.aTos, Travrl tS>
p.r) elboTL otl Icttlv tls irapd Tavras cLTracras Ttyvr) yvpiva-
5 cttlkti re kol laTpLKT], rj br) tS> ovtl ye (crrlv croip.aTos
Qepairda, rjvirep Kal irpocrr)KeL tovtohv ap^LV iracrS>v t&v

Ttyy&v koX yj)r)cr6aL tols tovtoov epyois bia to etoeVai otl
Xpr)o-Tov Kal Trovrjpbv tS>v ctltlcov r) itotS>v etrrtv ds dperriv
518 cra>pLaTos, tcls 8' ctAAas Trdcras ravras dyvodv bib br) Kal
ravTas pikv bovkoTTpeTrds re Kal bLaKOVLKas Kal dvtkcvdepovs
dvaL irepX crcapiaTos Trpayp.ardav, ray aAAas Ttyyas, ti)v b\
yvpLvacrTLKrjv Kal larpLKrjv /cara to bUaLov btcnroLvas eTvat
5 rovTcav. Tavrd ovv raura otl Hcttlv ml irepl ^rv\n)V, totc
p.kv p.oL boKds p.av6dvLv otl Ae'yco, kol 6p,o\oyd's <os dbois
otl eyco Ae'yco* r/Kets 8e dAiyoz> vcrTepov Xkyoiv ort avOpomoL
b KaXol Kayadol yeyovacrLv 7roAtrai t)v tjj 7ro'Aei, Kat TTLbdv
eyco epcorco otrtres, SoKets p,OL 6p,OLOTaTovs TrpoTeCvecrOaL
dvOpooTTovs irepl rd 7roAtrtKa, oicnrep dv d 7rept rd yvp.va-
crTLKa epov po>TQ>VTOs oItlvzs dyaOol yeyovaarLV r) elcrlv
5 croip.dTOiv depaiTevTaC, ekeyes p.0L irdvv cnrovbdfav, eaptW

6 apTOKOiros Kal MCOaLKos 6 tt)v 6\j/07T0LLav crvyyeypacpois
Ti)v 2tKeAiKr/v /cat "Sdpapfios 6 Kairr)kos, otl ovtol 6avp,dcrioL
yeyovacrLV crojp.aTOiv OepairevTaC, 6 p.ev dprovs 6avp.acrrovs

C TrapacrKvdoiV, 6 be oxj/ov, 6 be oTvov. tcrois dv ovv r)ya-
vaKTtLS, et crot ekeyov eyco ort "AvdpoiTre, e7ratet? ovbev

irepl yvp.vao-TLKr)s' bLaKovovs p.OL Ae'yety Kat iTnOvpL&v
irapacrKevacrTds dvOpoiirovs, ovk Tra'LOVTas Kakbv Kayadbv
5 ovbev TTcpl avT&v, ot, av ovroi TvyoicrLV, ip,Trkr)cravTes xat
e5?)PF:$BT ^F; om.BTP e 7 tovtuv B W f et yp.

T : tovtcii F toiovtois T
: '6ti recc. '6ti t\ F '6ti to B T P a i tuv-
: :
tos] Tawro Coraes a 3 irtpi ffdijxa.Tos irpayfiaTuav] vepl ffwfia irpayfia-

Teias Cobet a 5 oZv B T F yovv P tot^ . a 6 '6ti\ t6tc
: . .
. .0V1 B T P F
. toVc . oVe Madvig
: . b 5 (Stj) eapiwv Cobet
.
(secl. mox b 7 otj OtpanevTai). . .b 6 apTOK07ros B T P apToiroibs F :
c 5 ovStv F t ovSe re vera B T P

: ovtu B T P f om. F :
ropriA^ 5 i8c
na\vvavTe$ ra crco/uara tG>v avdpo)7TO)V, eiraLvovpevoL vif

avr&v, TTpocraTToXovcrLV avrG>v koX tcls ap\aCas crapKas' ot
6' av 8Y aTtzipCav ov tovs ecrnco>ras atrtdowrat tG>v vocrtov d
atrtous etvat /cat ttjs aTTOtSokrjs tG>v apyaCuiV crapKwv, dAA'
ot ctv avTols tv\o)ctl tot irapovres Kal crvp.fiovkevovTis rt,
orav br) avrols ?/kt/ r) totz TTkr]crp.ovi] vocrov cpepovcra crv\vG>
vcrTcpov \p6vo>, are avtv tov vytecvov ytyovvia, tovtovs 5
atrtdcrovrai Kat \j/4ôv(tlv koX KaKov rt 7rot?/cro?jcru', av 0I0C

t cocrt, tovs e irpoTepovs tKeCvovs koX aWCovs tG>v KaKtav
ZyKutpuacrovcnv. Kal crv vvv, S> KaAAtKAets, 6p.oioTaTov e
tovtoj (pyafy' eyKcojutdcfeis avdpanrovs, ot tovtovs etcrrid-
Kacrt^ nvo>\ovvTes 5>v TTdvp.ovv. KaC cpacri p.tyakr\v tt)v
TTokiv 7re7rot??KeVat avTovs' otl be otSet Kat virovkos ecrriy

cV (KeCvovs tovs TrakaLovs, ovk alcrOavovTaL. avev yap 5*9
(roxppocrvvrjs Kal bLKaLocrvvrjs At/xeVcov Kat vo>pCo>v kol
retxcoy koX cp6pa)v Kal tolovtlov cpkvapLtov e/x7re7rA?/Kacrt ri]v

ttoXlv orav ovv eA0T/ i) Kara/3oAT/ avTt] tt)s acrOtveCas, tovs
t6t( irapovTas alTLacrovTaL crvp.\3ovkovs, 0e/ztcrroKAe'a 8e 5
Kat KCp.(ova Kal YlepLKkta eyKco/jttdcroTjcrii/, tovs alrCovs

tG>v KaKU>v crov 8e tcrcos kiTLkq-^rovTaL, tav p.r) cvkafii), Kal
tov e/xoS traCpov 'AAKt/3td8ou, orav Kal rd apyaia irpocr-
anokkvtocrL irpos ols KTr]cravTo, ovk alrCtov OVTO)V tG)V KaK&v b

dAA' tcrcos ctvvq.ltCo)v. Katrot eycoye avoryrov TTpayp.a Kat
vvv 6pG> yLyvoptvov koX ctKovto tGjv TrakaLtov t\vbpG>v iripi.
alo~6avop.aL yap, orav r) TrokLS tlvcl tG)V TrokLTLKtov avbpG>v
/xeraxetpt^r/rat co? abLKOvvra, dyavaKTOvvTtov KaX crxerAta- 5
CovTtov G)S beLva TracryjovcrL' 7roAAd Kat dyat^d rrjv rrokLV

7re7rot?/Kdres apa abUoos vtt avrrjs aTTokkvvTaL, i>s 6 tovtcov
koyos. t6 8e dAoy \jrevbos ecrny TTpocrTctTrjs yap 7rdAecos
7
ovb av ets 7rore d8tKcos d7ro'Aotro ?j7r' aijTrjs rrjs 7ro'Aecos ?^s C
C7 ttpoira-ToKovaiv B: Kpoo-ai-oXKovGiv F: npoo airoKKvovcri{v)

,
T W
d4 F Se B T P f
5-Jj : b3 aicovw B T P ovk okovu F
: irepi.
aiffBdvofiai bt: Tctpiaicrdavofx.ai BTP: v-repatcrGdvofiai F {irtpi in
lac. suppl. et vxep punctis del. f c r outtjs B T P avTjjs ravrris F
:
519 c IIAAT&NOS
irpocTTaTi. KivbvveveL yap ravrbv eTvaL, 0V01 re ttoKltlkoi
Kal yap ol crocpi-
irpoanroLovvTaL eTvaL Kat ocroi crocpLcrTaC.
araC, Takka crocpol ovres, tovto otottov epya&VTaL Trpayp.a-
5 <pao~KOVTs yap aperi]s 8i8ao"KaAoi etvat 7roAAaKts Karrjyo-
povcriv t&v p.a9r)Tcov cos aoLKOvcn crcpas [avTovs], tovs re
pLLcrOovs aTrocrTtpovvTes Kat a\kr)v yapLv ovk aTrobibovTes,
d ev rradovTes vtt avrcov. koI tovtov tov koyov tC av akoyco-
repov elr) iTpayp.a, avOpcoTrovs ayadovs Kal bLKaCovs yevo-
p.evovs, eâLpedevras p.ev abLKCav v-nb tov bLbacTKakov,
crypvTas be bLKaLoo~6vr)V, abLKelv tovtco &> ovk ZyovcrLv; ov

5 8oKt o-ot tovto cltottov eTvaL, 3) eratoe; cos dkr)6cos br)p.rj-
yopelv p.e r)vdyKao~as, a> KaAAtKA.eis, ovk edekcov airoKpC-

vecrOaL.
KAA. 2t> 8' ovk hv oTos r eXr)s keyeiv, ei pvq tCs croi
OLTTOKpCvOLTO;
y
e 2i2. EotKO: ye* vvv yovv crvyyovs reivco tcov koycov,
7ret8?7 jotot ovk eOekeLS anoKpCvecrdaL. akk\ coyaOe, eirre
irpbs <t>LkCov, ov boKel ctol akoyov eTvaL dyaObv cpacrKOVTa

TTiTOLr)KvaL TLVO. p.ep.<pecrOaL tovtco otl vcf? eavTOV dyaOos
5 yeyovcos re Kat cov eTretra Trovqpos o~tlv;

KAA. "E/xotye 8oKet.
2X2. Ovkovv aKoijeLS Toiavra keyovTcov tcov cpao~KovTcov
TraibeveLV dvOpcoTTOvs eis dperrjv;
520 KAA. "Eywye* akka tC av keyois dvOpcoircov nrepL ovbevbs
aCcov;
2X2. Tt 8' hv Trepl iKeCvcov keyois, ot cpdcrKOVTes Trpoe-
crravaL Trjs Trokecos Kat eiTLpLekelcrOaL ottcos a>? /3eArio-rr7
5 eorat, nakLV avrqs Kar-qyopovcrLV, brav tvx coo~- v> ^ novr)-
poTarr)s; oXeL n bLacpepeLV tovtovs eKeCvcov; tovtov, co
xaKapC, cttlv crocpLcrTr)s kcu prjrcop, r) eyyvs tl Kat 7rapa-
C6 avrois (sic B) secl. Bekker di /col] Kairoi Heindorf

d4 axivras B T : ex ovTas PF ^frftBTP: a\\' F d5 rovro
om. F d6/xeTPFb:;ite/B 61 yovv B F : 7* olv T : 5e in
marg. t :
8' oZv P 64 rivh om. F vtt' ai/ruv F
:
TOPriAS 5 2oa
nXrjcnov, axnrep eycb eAeyoy irpbs Yl(akov ov be bC ayvoiav

to p.V irayKakov tl otet ?vai, ri\v pr/TopiK-qv, tov 8e /cara- b
<f>povLS. Tr) be akqdcLq k6.Wlov ioTLV croc/uerriKT) prjTO-
piKrjs ocr(dTTp vop.o6TLKr) bLKaoTLKrjs Kal yvp.vaoTLKr) iarpLKrjs'
Plovols 8' eycoye Kal iop.qv tols brjp.qyopoLS re *cai oocpLorals
ovk y\copLV pe'pc/>ecrc9at tovtu rco TTpa.yp.aTL o avrot ttol- 5

bcvovoiv, u)S irovqpov otlv ets ocpas, r) rcp aurcp Ao'ycp
tovt<0 apa Kal iavTcav Karrjyopelv otl ovbcv (hqikr)KaoLV
ovs cpaoLv ct>c/>eA.eu>. ovx ovtojs X L >

KAA. Ylavv ye. C
212. Kat TTpoioQaL ye 8?j7rou rrjr evepyecrtW cireti p.Lo6ov,
(i>s to etKo'?, plovols tovtols erexcopet, enrep dkrjdrj eAeyoi\
aXkqv p.kv yap Vpyoiav tls evepyenjt9eij, otoy Tayys
yv6p.VOs bia iraLborplfiqv, locos b\v a.TTOOTprjoL rqv 5
\apLv, et TrpqoLTO avrcp 6 TraLboTpCfirjs Kal p.q ovv6ip.vos
aiiT(2 p-Lodbv otl. pAkLora ap.a p.TabLbovs tov T&xpvs kap.-
(36vol to apyvpiov ov yap br) ttj /3pabvrr}TL oXp.aL abiKovoiv d
01 avdpcoTToi, dAA' ddtKia' r) yap;
KAA. Nat.
212. Ovkovv et rts avr6 rotrro dcpatpet, rqv dbiKLav,
ovbcv bLvbv avrco p.r\TTOT abLKr)6fj, dkka poVco doqbaXis 5
Tavrqv rqv evepyecrtai irpoiodaL, etwep rco ovtl bvvaiTO tls
ayadovs ttolclv. ox>x ovtco;
KAA. <J>7?pt.
212. Atcx ravT apa, co? OLK, tcls p.v aAAas ovp.fiov\as
ovp.f3ovX.VLv kap.fiavovTa apyvpLov, olov OLKobop.Cas Trept 10
rj T(2v akkcav TXV(ov, ovbcv aloxpov.
KAA. "Eoi/ce' ye. e

212. ITepi bi ye ravrqs ttjs irpdcfecos, ovtlv av tls Tpo-
ttov G)S /3e'Artcrros etrj Kat aptcrra tt)V avrov olKiav StotKot
b 1 (j.ci> BTP : /j.ty ye F c7 avT<j! om. F d 1 yitp Si/ F

7 ap BTP d5 iAAa F: aAA* fc BTP dgrajBTP:^
riis F 63 /3e'ATn-os F : PcKrurrov B T P 5joko? ^ TPFb :
dioiKoii} B

52oe I1AATX2N02
r) TTokLV, alcrxpbv vevofXLo-Tat fxif (pavaL crvfxfiovkeveLv, eav
5 //r/ tls avTu> apyvpiov 8t8c?>. ?/ yap;

KAA. iiat.
2X2. Arjkov yap otl tovto airLov eaTLV, otl \iovr\ avTrf
t&v evepyeo-L&v tov ev Tradovra eiTLOvfxelv ttolcl clvt ev

TT0LLV, COOTe Kakbv boKL TO VrffXeZoV elvaL, cl V 77017/0-05
io Tavrr]v tt)v evepyeo-(av clvt ev 7reto"eTar et oe fxr], ov.
eort Tavra ovtcos fyovTa;

521 KAA. "Eo-tlv.
2X2. 'Etti iroTepav ovv fxe TrapaKakeLs tt)v 6epaire(av

Trjs 7roAecos, 8topto"ov fxoL- Tr)v tov hLaiiAyeo-QaL *
A6r)va(oLS
01TO)S COS (3e\.TL0-T0L eCTOVTaL, h)S laTpOV, r) 0)5 SLaKOVljo-OVTa
5 Kal Trpbs \6pLV OLLLkqcrovTa; TakrjOrj fxoL eiire, S) KaAAt/cAeis*

bUaLos yap et, &o~irep r/ocfco Trappr/crtdêo-flai irpbs efxe,
bLarekelv a voets keycav. /cat vvv ev /cat yevva(o)s eiire.
KAA. Aeyct) tolvvv otl cos bLaKovqo-ovTa.
b 2X2. KoAa/cevcroira apa fxe, co yevvaLoraTe, irapaKakeLs.

KAA. E crot MrcrdV ye rjbLOV /caAeiV, 2> 2c6/cpaTes" cos
et fxr) Tavrd ye 7roi?/o-eis
2X2. Mr/ et7rr/j 6 7roAAd/as etpr//cas, oti a7ro/CTei>et pe

5 6 (3ovk6p,evos, tva fxr) av Kal eyco eXiro), otl Ylovrfpos ye
wv ayaObv ovra- jur/o' otl dcpatpr/creTai eav tl ex 10 ' ^va
fxr) av eyo) etiro) otl 'AAA' acpekofxevos oi>x eet 6Yi XP 1!'
,
crerat avrots, akk cocr7rep fxe d8t/ccos dceiAero, ovrcos koX
" "
C kafiuv dot/ccos XP 7? 67 - 1 ' ^ dSt/ccos, atcrxpcos, et oe
alcrxp&s, /ca/ccos.
KAA. "X2s p,ot boKets, 2> 2co/cpares, Tricrreveir pr/o' av

kv tovto)v Tradelv, cos oikco^ eK7ro8cby Kal ovk av elo-axOels
5 et? bLKaa-TrfpLov vtto iravv tcrcos fxoxdrfpov avdpo)irov /xat
cpavkov.
e 7 tovto B T P cuito : F a5 S> F : om. BTP a6 Trpos

/xcF a8ijom. F b37eBTP:TF b4&TPF:
2tj B b7 xp^<reTo] xp^*'7 Ta Schanz' c a KaK&s B T P ko.1 :
KaKws F C3 8o(cers 3> ffa>Kpi.Tt\% F : 8o/cf? ffdsKpaTts B T P DoKti :
Zta>Kp6.TH]s Schanz
ropriAs 521C
2X2. 'Ardr/ros dpa et/xt, co KaAAuAets, cos dAr/0cos, et /xr/
otopat ei^ r?/8e rr/ 7ro'Aet <Wu>ow> dv drt rvyoi, tovto Tradelv.
Tobe peVrot ev 018' ort, edvnep eicrico ets 8t/<acrT7/pioy 7rept
T0VT(av tlvos Kivbvvevtov, o-v Ae'yets, TTOvqpos rts u' ecrrat d

6 elcrdytav ovbels yap av xPT1"ros p.r) dbLKOvvr' dvdptoirov
etcraydyoi xat ovbev ye dro7rov et cnrodavoip,i. /3ouAet crot
enrco 81' oti ravra 7rpocroKco;
KAA. Udvv ye. 5

v
212. Otuat /xer' dAiycoi; 'At9r/z/aiW, Lva ut/ e 7rco \i6vos,
zinyjeipeiv ttj cos dAr/flcos 7roAtTiK?j Ttyyr] Kal irpaTTeLV tcl
TToXlTLKCL pLOVOS OVV OV TTpOS X-P lV ^ycOV TOVS

T&V VVV CLT
Adyovs ots Aeyco e/cdoTOTe, dAAd 7rpds to /3eATtcrror, ov irpbs

TO i]bL(TTOV, KO.I OVK edekcOV TTOLeiv & CTV TTapaLVels, TCL KOU\|fd e
ravra, ovx eco drt Ae'yco ev rco dtKao-rrjpico. d avrbs be
uot ?//cet Adyos ovnep irpbs U&kov eAeyorr Kpti/orjuat yap
cos ev 7raidiois tarpds dv KpLvovro KaT-qyopovvros 6\jfOTTOLov.
o"K07ret ydp, rt av d-nokoyoLTo 6 tolovtos dvdpcoiros ev tovtols 5
Arjcpflets, et avrov KaTr\yopol tls Keytov otl " '12 7raioes,
7roAAd vuas kol KaKa obe etpyacrrat dvr)p Kal avrovs, Kal
tovs vetoTaTovs vp.u>v Stacpfletpet rep.vtov re xat /cdcoi>, Kat

lo-yvaLVcov Kat Trviytov diropelv 7rotet, 7riKpdraTa 7rcouara 522
dtdoi/s Kat ireLvrjv Kal bL\jri)v dvayKafav, ovy ooo-Trep eyto
TToXka Kat 7/8e'a Kat 7rayro8a7rd rjvco)(ow vuas*" rt dy otet
ei> rot/rcj) rco kokco diroXrjcpOevTa laTpbv exeiv elTrelv; ?j et
et7rot Tr)v d\r\6eLav, otl "Taura iravTa eyco eTTOLOvv, co 5
7raides, vyieuxos," ttoo-ov tl otet dv dvafiofjo-aL tovs tolovtovs

bLKacTTas; ov p.eya;
KAA. "Icrcos* otecrdaL ye xPV-
di &BTPF: &v scr. recc. d 3 riffaydyot B T P elffdyoi F :
d8 vvv BTP : vvv\ F 05 rovrots B T P towutols F

: 67 dv^p\
aviip Bekker koI clvtovs . . . Siatpdeipti secl. Cobet e8 yp. Kal
tffX<v Kal irviyuv Olympiodoms
a 1 airope?v irote? secl. Madvig
ird>fj.ara Bekker ir6fj.aTa B T P F
: a 4 d F (sed punctis del. f ) :
om. B T P a 6 ir6ffov F 6ir6ffov B T P rt oUt K. Fuhr

: wote? :
B (sed ir puncto notatum et acc. corr.1 0U1 T P F a 8 oleffdai ye :
Xfri) post ob fxeya transp. et Socrati tribuit Forman

522a IIAATftNOS
212. Ovkovv otet ev irdcrr) diropiq av avrbv e\ecrOai ort
b XPV *1'*&, S
KAA. Udvv ye.
212. Totorjrov /xeVrot ical eyco oT8a ort Trdflos 7rd0otjui a>
etaeAflcoi' ets biKacrT-qpiov. ovre yap r)bovds as eKireTropiKa
5 eco arjrots Xeyeiv, ds ovrot evepyecrias Kal <o<peXias vop.i-
(jovcriv, eycb 5e ot/re tovs iropiôvTas CrrAoo ^ Te ' s TtopieTai'

edz> re rts /xe r) vecarepovs <pr\ bia<pOeipeiv diropeiv iroiovvTa,
r) tovs irpecr^vTepovs KaKrjyopelv Xeyovra TTiKpovs Xoyovs r/
ibiq r) brjp.ocriq, ovre to dXrfOes eco etireii', ort AtKatcos

C 7rdz>ra Tavra eycb Aeyco, Kat 7rpdrrco to vpLerepov or) tovto,
6o dvbpes otKaarat, ovre dXXo ovbev coare ftrcos, ori av
rvytii, tovto 7reto"o/xai.
KAA. AoKet ovv croi, co 2<oKoares, koAcos eyeiv dvOpco-

5 7ros ey 7rdAet ovrcos biaKeipievos Kal abvvaros <ov eavroo
fiorjOeTv;
2X2. Et eKetyd ye ey avrcp virdpyjn., co KaAAtKAets, d o-i>
7roAAaKis w/AoAdyjjo-as* et j3e/3orr0rrKoos etrj ai>T<o, jurfre Trepl
d av0p<oTTOVS p.rJTe irepl Oeovs abiKOV /xrj8ev p.rjre etprjKcos jur/re
dpyacrfxivos. avrrr yap rrjs ftorjOeias eaurco 7roAAdKts 7/ju.ty
cojuoAdyrrrat Kpariorrr etvai. et juev ovv e/ue rts eeAe'yxot

TavTt\v ttjv fioriOeiav dbvvaTov 6Vra e/uaurcp Kat dAAco /3or)0elv,
5 alo~xvvoip.r)v &v Kat ev 7roAAots Kat kv dAtyots eeXeyy6p.evos

Kai p.6vos vtto p.6vov, Kal et otd Tavrr/v rr)v abvvapiiav airoOvfi-
aKotjott, ayavaKToirjv dv et oe KoAaKtKr/s prrrooiKr/s evbeiq
TeXevr<or)v eyooye, eS ota drt pqbicos t8ots dy /xe cpepovra
e rdy Odvarov. avrb piev yap to diroOvr)<rKeiv orjgets c/>o/3etrat,
oaris jur) iravTdTracnv dAdyto-rds re Kai dvavbpos kcrTiv, to

be dbiKeiv g3o/3etraf 7roAAcoy ydp d8tKrj//,drcoy yejuorra rr)y
r/
y\rv)(r)v ets Aioorj dcpiKecrQai irdvrcav toyaTov KaK<av ecrTiv.
b 4 ^Soj/cfcy &y T P F 7J801/&S B b 8 Kariryopuv F

: C7 /
F (coniecerat Coraes) iv B T P 5 o-v B P F t bs o~b T
: : d2 tt/s
fior)Oeias F tjs jSo^fleio B T P
: ^ fio^deta Cobet d6: al e 8a
Fbt al 5fa BT ISla P
: 64 aKaSj/ BTP aK({j/ F
: :
TOPriAS 522e
et 8e /3ovAet, crot eyco, cbs tovto ovtojs eêt, e0e'Aco koyov 5
Ae'fat.
KAA. 'AAA' e7rei7rep ye Kat raAAa eiripavas, nal tovto

iripavov.
2I2. "Axoue 8?;, cpacrt, pAka KaXov koyov, ov av p.tv 523
r)yr']ar] p.v6ov, cos eycb otpat, eycb 8e Ao'yoi>* cos akr)6rj yap
ovra rroi Ae'co a peAAco Aeyetr. cocr7rep yap "Opr/po? Aeyet,
huviip.avro tt)v apyr]v 6 Zeus Kai 6 riocrei8coi> Kat 6 nAourcoi;,
e7ret8r) irapa tov 7rarp6s irapiXafiov. r)v ovv vop.os 6Se 7rept 5
dvdpoiiroiv eiri Kpovov, Kal det Kat vvv ert ecrrti' ei> 0eois,
tG>v avOptoTToov tov p.ev biKaCois tov fiiov buXdovra koX

oaitos, (ircLbav reKevTrjar), ets p.aKapoiv vrjaovs airiovTa oIkclv b
(V Ttdar) evbaip.oviq cktos KaK&v, rbv 8e abUois Kal ddeois
ets to rrjs rtaecoy re Kal Siktjs beafxoiTrjpiov, o 81) Tdprapov
KaXovaLv, teVai. rovTOiv 8e 8tKacrrat e7rt Kpovov ko.1 ert
recocrrt tov Acbs Tr)v dpyj/z; e\ovTos C&vres rjrrav (javTOiv, 5

(Keivj) Ty r)p.pq biKatpvres ?| pe'AAotez> reAe^rral' kokco? ovv
al bUai eKpivovTo. re ovv I7Aovrcoy Kai 01 e7rip.eAr7rat 01
eK p.aKapoiv vqaoiv toVres eXeyov irpbs tov Ata 6'rt cpotrcoeV
a-qbiv avdpoiTToi eKare'ococre avaioi. etirev ovv 6 Zevs* " 'AAA' C

eyco," eabrj, " 7raucrco roirro yiyvop.evov. vvv )i\v yap kokcos
al Swcat btKaovTai. dp.irey6p.cvoL ydp," ecpr/, " oi KpLv6p.evoL
KpivovraL' (fcoyre? yap KpivovraL. 7roAAot ovv," 7]

8' os,
"
V^ U X^ ? TTovqpas exovres T/pcpiecr/iieVoi etcrt aoip:ard re KaAcx 5
Kat yeVr? Kat 7rAovroi>y, Kat, e7ret8ar r) KpiaLS fi,

epyovTaL
avroLS ttoAAoi p.apwpes, p.apTvpr)aovres cos 8tKaicos /3e/3tco-
e6 Xe'|aj] 5e'|ou F a t <paai BTPF ^tjo-i Stobaeus Plutarchus

:
a2 70 olyuoi BT : iy^fiai PF Stobaeus Eusebius Theodoretus

a5 85e B T P f 5e F : a 6 !V< om. P b 4 eVl /cpôo T Sto- W
baeus Plutarchus et in lac. textus f :eirl xpovov B b 6 rrj F Stobaeus
Plutarchus om. B T P
: b7 oi VrueA.?jTal ot Plutarchus oi eVt- :
/j.e\rira\ B T P F Stobaeus e 1 a<piv T P o-<plv B F o-tpiaiv Sto- : :
baeus Plutarchus c 4 C^Dires yap Kpivovrai B T F Plutarchus om. :
P Stobaeus olv B T P F Stobaeus fxkv olv Plutarchus C 7 fidp- :
rvpts B T P F Stobaeus om. Plutarchus :
plato, vol. 111. 24

523 d nAATX2N02
d /cacrijr 01 ovv StKacrrat viro re tovto)V eK7rA?/rroi>rai, Kat
ap.a Kat avrot ap.irey6p.evoL bLKatfivcri, -trpo rrjs ^vxys T77S
avr&v 6<pda\p.ovs Kal cora Kai oXov to crG>p.a TrpoKCKaXvp.-
\iivoi. ravra br) avrois 7rayra eiriiTpocrOev yiyveraL, Kal tcl
5 ovtG>v duc/)tecr/xara Kat ra rcoi> KpLvop.eva>v. irpG>TOV piev
ovv," ecprr, " iravcrTeov ecrrlv 7rpoet8dras avrovs rbv ddvarov

vvv yap 7rpotcracri. tovto piev ovv Kal br) elprjrat r<5 Tipo-
e p.r]6el 6tto)s av Travcrr] ovtG>v. eireLTa yvp.vovs Kpvreov

airavTo>v tovtcov TedveG>Tas yap 8et KpivecrdaL. kol tov
KpiTr]V 8et yvp.vbv elvaL, re6veG>Ta, avTr) rfj \}rvxfj avrr)v rr)v
^/v\r]v decopovvra eâicpvqs airoOavovTos eKacrTov, ept]p.ov
5 7raVrcoi> tG>v crvyyevG>v Kai KaraAt7roVra e7ri rrjs yfjs iravTa

eKelvov tov Kocrpiov, 'iva hiKaia r) Kpicris r). eyto p.ev ovv
ravra eyvo>KO>s Trporepos r/ vp.els eTTOLr]crdp.r]v biKaaras vels

kp.avTov, bvo pev eK rrjs 'Acrtas, MtVco re Kai 'PabdpLavdvv,
5 2 4 eva oe eK r^? F,vpo>7rr]s, AlaKov ovtol ovv eTreLbav reAerj-
rr/crcocrt, StKacroycrty ev tG> XeLp.G>VL, ev Trj rpto'8co e rjs
cpepeTov rco d8co, r/ piev els p.aKapo>v vrjcrovs, r) b* els Tdp-

(
rapov. Kal tovs piev eK rr^s 'Acrtas Pabdp.av6vs Kptvel, tovs
5 8e ck rr}s Eupco7rr/s AtaKos* Mtvco be 7Tpecrj3eXa barcro) e7rt8ta-
Kpivetv, eav airoprJTOv tl rco erepco, tVa 6>s SiKatordrr/ 77 KpicrLs
r/ 7rept r?}? Ttopeias tols dvdpo>TTOLs."
Taur' ecrTLV, o> KaAAucAets, a eyco aKi]Kou>s TTLcrrevto
b a\r]Orj elvaf kcil ck tovtojv t5>v Adycoy rotdrSe rt Xoyi(pp.aL
ds rb BTPf: d 4 8^ BTPF Plutarchus 5e Sto-

om. F :
baeus B T P F enirpo<r6tv Stobaeus 4itiirp6ffOi}o-is Plu-

inlirpocrdev : :
tarchus d 7 yap B T P F Stobaeus êv yap f Plutarchus ntv :
B T P F Plutarchus fikv Sij ko.\ Stobaeus

olv Kal S^ e 1 avruv B T F
:
Stobaeus avr6v P avr6 Plutarchus

: e 5 Kctl om. F
: rrjs yrjs
B T P F Stobaeus Plutarchus yrjs Eusebius Theodoretus e 6 Si-
:
Kaia Kpiais B T P F Stobaeus

r) Kpiais SiKaia Plutarchus /j.cv odv
: 7)
ravra B T P F /xiv oZv Stobaeus olv ravr' Plutarchus

: e 7 irpo- :
rtpos B T P F Stobaeus irp^repov Plutarchus :a 2 rrj BTPF

Plutarchus om. Stobaeus : a 6 airoprjr^v ti t&> eWpco Findeisen
e codice Meermanniano airopprjT^v t tw tTepw B P air6ppr\Tov ti to>
: :
fTepu T F air6pprjT6v ti ?J t$ irepw Stobaeus Plutarchus

: r) Kpiais
p B T P F ?J Kpiais Stobaeus npiffis 77 Plutarchus

: :
ropriAS 524 b
o~vfx(3aLVLV. 6 Odvaros Tvy\avei <av, o>? cfxol boKfl, oibev

dXXo r) bvolv irpayfxaTOLV bLaXvo~LS, Trjs ^VXV 9 Kat T v
crcofxaTos, cltt' dAAT/Aoty e7ret8ap oe biakvdrJTOv &pa dir'
aXXrfXoLV, ov iroXv tJttov eKarcpov avTolv e\L ttjv c^lv Tr\v 5
avTOv rfvrrep nal otc It/ 6 dvdpcoTros, to re acofxa ttjv cpvcriv

Ti]V avrov Kal tcl QepaTrevfxaTa kcll tcl ira6f]fxaTa evbrjXa
iravTa. olov et uros fxeya rjv to o~G>fxa cpvcreL r) Tpocpfj r) C
dfxcporepa <Si>roy, tovtov Kal ZireLbav aTroOdvrf 6 veKpbs
fxeyas, ko.1 el iraxvs, iraxvs Kat d7ro0aroVros, Kat raAAa
ovrcos* Kal el av cTrertfbcvc KOfxav, KOfxrfTrfs tovtov Kat 6
vcKpos. juaorrtytas av et tls rjv ml Xx v V clx* v ^V"/- 01 '
5
ovAas ev ra> crtofxaTL r) vrrb fxao-riycov rj aXXcov TpavfxaTcov

G>v, kciI tc6vc5>tos to o~S>fxa ccttlv ibelv ravra ex ov '
V
Kareayora et tov ifv fxeXrf r) bieo-rpafxfxeva covtos, kol
tc6vcG>tos TavTa ravra evbrfXa. evX be Xoyco, oTos eTvaL d
irapeo~Kevao~TO to o~G>fxa (>v, evbriXa ravTa Kal TeXevTf)o~avTos
r) TtavTa r) tcl 7roAAa e7H Tiva xpovov. Tavrbv bfj fxoL boKel
tovt apa kol TTepl rqv ^j/vxrfv cTvai, co KaAAtKAets 1
eVor/Aa
TTcxvTa co~tIv ev rf) 'yf/vxfb cTTCLbdv yvfxvcoOf) tov crco/xaros, rd 5
tc rrjs cpvcrecos ko.1 ra TradrffxaTa a bid rrfv eiTLTrfbeva-LV
eKacrTOv Trpdyfxaros eo~x* v cv ttj ^rvxfj dvOpcoTTOS. cTTCLbav
ovv dq^LKCovTai Trapa rbv bLKacrrrfV, ol fxcv ck Trjs 'Acrtas

7rapa tov 'PabdfxavOvv, 6 ^PabdfxavOvs ckclvovs CTTLo~Trfo-as e
dcCLTaL CKaCTTOV TlfV \j/VX11 v , OVK cib(t>S OTOV CO~TLV, dXXa.
TroAAcxKts roi; fxeydXov f3ao~LXccos cTTiXa(36fxevos r) aAAou
otovovv f3ao~LXecos rf bvvdcrrov Karelbev ovbev vyies ov Trjs
ijrvxrjs, dXXd bLafxcfxacrTLyu>fxcvrfV kol ovX&v fxeo~TrfV vtto 5
eTTiopKL&v Kal dbiKLas, a cKao~Trf // Trpd^LS avrov ecofx6paro 5 25

ety rrfv \j/vx>jv, Kal irdvTa crKoAta v7ro \f/evbovs Kal dAa-
b7 ri)v om. P 03 iraxvs, iroxus] traxv, iraxvs Hirschig

c6 ov\as secl. Heindorf C7 Kart ay6ra Eusebius Kar(ay6ra
fj :
B T P F Kartay6ra re Par. 21 10: Kal Kartay6ra Schanz Kartay6r aZ

: :
Forman d. 1 ravrh. ravra F ravra B T P d 3 iravra Fin-

: f)
deisen ?jv irdvra B T P F

: d 5 irdvra B T P ravra irdvra F :
24*
525 a ITAAT&N02
bvetas Kai ovbev ev6v bia to dvev dkr)6eias Tedpdcpdai' kou
virb eovcrias *cai Tpv(pr)s Kal vj3peo)s Kal aKpaTias tG>v
5 irpdêoiv dcrvp.p.eTpias T Kal aicrxpoTrjTOs yep.ovcrav ttjv
tyvxqv elbev IboiV be drijouos TavTrjv diTeiTep.^rev ei6v rrjs
cppovpds, ol p.ekkeL kXOovaa dvarkrjvaL ra TrpocrrjKOvra Trddrj.
b TTpoo-rJKei be TravA ra> ev TLp.copiq ovtl, vir dkXov 6p6G>$

Tip.(i>povpev(a, rj fiekriovL yiyvecrdaL Kal ovivacrdaL r) Trapa-
be(yp.aTL rot? dAAots yiyvecrdaL, Iva dkkoi 6pG>VTes TrdcryovTa
a dv irdo-)(r\ cpo(3ovp.evoL fiekTiovs yiyvoiVTat. eicrlv be ol
5 p.ev d)cpekovp.evoi re Kal biKrjv bibovres vtto 6eG>v re Kal

dv9pu>TTO)V ovtol 0% dv idcrLJla ap.apTrjpaTa dp.dpTOdo~LV opMS
be 8t' dkyrjbovojv Kal obvvoiv yiyveraL avTols r) oxpekia Kal
f
evddbe koX ev 'At8ou* ov ydp olov re dkkois d8tKtas dirak-
C Adrrecrflai. ot 8' dv rd eâra d8tKT70-axri Kat 8id rd
TOLavra dbLKrjp.aTa dviaroL yevoiVTaL, K tovtcov ra irapa-
beiypxvra yiyveraL, kol ovtol avrot piev ovktl ovivavraL
ovbev, &t dviaroL ovres, akkoi be dvivavraL oX tovtovs
5 dpGiVTes 8td Tas ap.aprias rd pjeyLcna Kal obvvqpoTaTa Kal
cpof3epa>TaTa irddr) -rdo-xpvTas tov del xpdvov, aTexvGjs irapa-
beiypxiTa dvr)pTrjp.evov$ eKet ev "At8oi> ev rco becrpxorqpiu),
tols del tQ>v dbUoiv dcf)LKVovp.evoLS OedpxiTa Kal vov6eTt]paTa.
d &v eyco c/bri/xi eva kol 'Apxekaov ecrecrOaL, et dkrjdrj Aeyet
FIcoAos, Kat dAAoy 6'o-rts &v tolovtos rvpavvos tj* otjuat be
kol tovs TTokkovs elvai tovtoov t5)v irapabeLypaToiv eK
rupdvvoiv Kal (3acrLkeo)v Kal bwacrTG>v ml rd tG>v irokeoiv
5 irpadvTO)v yeyovoras' ovtol yap 8td ttjv eovcriav /ue'ytora Kat
drocrtwrara ap.aprqp.aTa dp.apTavovcri. p.aprvpel be tovtols
a3 rt0pd<p6ai BP TF
: a 4 axparias B
TerpdcpOai F t axpaaias W :
T : aKpareias Eusebius a 6 dStv T P F 15ei> B b 2 irapaSeiyfj.art

:
scr. recc. irapd8eiy/xd tiBTP: irapdSeiynara F irapdSetyfia Eusebius

: :
Theodoretus b 3 rots B T P oni. F Gellius Theodoretus Suidas

:
b 4 a ird<rx el F C1 posterius t& F Eusebius Theodoretus Suidas :
om. B T P C 7 ev SSov B T P eSiSov pr. F d 3 tovtwv tSiv

:
napaSety (jiAtwv F Eusebius tovs tovtoov tuv irapaSety/xdTuv B

: tovs :
tuiv TtapaSeiy/j.aTuv TW : tovtwv ci. Heindorf

:
FOPriAS 525d
kclI "Ofxrjpos' /3aertAe'as yap kclI bvvdords Klvos 7TTroir]Kev
tovs ev "AtSou tov det \povov TLpMtpovpIvovs, TavTakov Kal e

Sicrvcpov Kal Titvov &epcriTr]v 8e, Kal et rts dAAo? Trovrjpbs
i]v i8icor?is, oi38ei? 7Tiroir]KV ueydAats Tip.copiaL$ crvv)(6-
pevov 10$ aviarov ov yap olpuu erjv avrco' 8td xai evbaip.0-
veorepos i]v rj ols efjv dAAd ydp y
ct> KaAAt/cAet?, in t&v 5
bvvap.evcov etcrt Kat 01 crcpobpa irovrjpol ytyvopevoi avdpcoTTOL' 526
ovbev p.i]v KcoAdet Kat ev tovtols ayaOovs avbpas eyyiyvecrdaL,
kol acpobpa ye d^cov ayaardaL tcov yLyvop.evcov yaXeTrbv ydp,
S) KaAAt/cAei?, Kat 7roAAou k-naivov cllov ev ueydAr/ eôvcria
tov abLKLv yev6p.evov StKatcos 8ta/3tcoyat. dAtyot 8e yiyvovrai 5
01 roioSroi' ewet Kat evdabe koI &XXo6l yeyovacrLV, otjuat 8e
Kal eaovrai KaXol KayaOol TavTi]v ti]v aperrfv Ti]V tov bLKaicos
bLaxtipiCeiv a av tls eTTLTpeTrrp ets 8e ml Trdvv eAAdytuos b
e
yeyovev kol els rovs dXXovs 'EXXi]vas, 'Apto-retSris 6 Aucri-
pdyov 61 be TroXXoi, co dptcrre, kokoi yiyvovrai tcov bvva-
e
cttcov. o7rep ow eXeyov, e7ret8dy d Pa8duai>0us eKetros
tolovtov TLva Xdftr], aXXo p.ev 7rept avTov ovk ot8ei> ovbev, 5
o#' dcrrty oi!0' covtlvcov, otl 8e Trovr]p6s tls' Kat roirro
KartScoy a7re7rep.\j/ev els Tdprapoy, (7rLo-rjp.rivap.evos, edvTe
tdcrtpo? edrre drtaros Sokt/ etrar d 8e eKetcre a(pLKop.evos
tcl TTpoo-r]KovTa Trdo-yeL. eviore 8' dAA??i> etcri8coi> dcrtco? c
/3e/3tcoKUtai> Kat uer' dA??0eia?, dvbpbs IbLcoTOV 77 dAAou riws,
/xdAtcrra ueV, eycoye cpr/ui, co KaAAtKAet?, cptAoadcpou rd
avrou irpdâvTos Kal ov TToXvirpayp.ovi]o-avTO$ ev rco /3tco,
r)ydo-6i] re Kat ey p.aKapcov vr/o-ovs d7reVeuê. raurd 8e 5

ravra Kal 6 AiaKos eKaTepos tovtcov pd/3bov eycov 81-
KaeL d 8e Mtycos TTLltkottcov Kac^r/rat, p.6vo$ eyuiv \pvcrovv

o-KijTTTpov, cos cprfo-LV 'OSvcrcrei'? 6 'OpLrjpov IbeTv avTov d
Xpvcreov o-KiJTTTpov eyovTa, 6ep.Lo-TevovTa veKvcro-Lv.
e 4 ov yitp ...65 Qrjv secl. Morstadt a 1 Zvvaixvuv B T P F :
avrwv Aristides a 7 posterius tV F om. B T Aristides : W

b 1 & &v B T P F &v (i. e. Sv) Aristides
: b2 ap((TTi5rjy TPF
apurTiHris B c 5 ^s re vera B T P F
526d IIAATftNOS
eyo> p.ev ovv, S> KaXXUXeLS, vtto re tovtoov t5>v Xoyoov
TTTTeio-fxai, Kal <tkottS> ottoos o.TTO<pavovp.aL rfi Kpirrj >s vyie-
5 (TTaTr)V rr\v y\fv\riv' \aipeLV ovv ed<ras ras TLp.as rds tu>v
ttoXXoov dvdpcoiroov, Ti]v dXr\6eLav d<rK<av ireipa.o-op.ai tQ> ovtl
&)? av bvvoop.aL /3eArt(rros oov Kal (r\v Kal TTLbav aTTo6vr)o-Koo
e a.7To6vfio-Kiv. TrapaKaXca be Kat tovs dXXovs irdvTas dvdpdo-

ttovs, Kad' ocrov ovvap.ai, Kal br\ ml cre avTnrapaKaXca eirl
tovtov tov (3iov ko\ rbv dyoova tovtov, ov eyco <pr\p.i clvtI
tt&vtoov t5>v ev6&be dycovoov elvaL, /cat 6veLbi(oo ctol otl oi>x
5 oto's r ecrr\ aravT<a (3or\6r\craL, orav r) bUrj <tol r) koa r) Kpio-LS
fjv vvvbr) eyoo eA.eyoi>, dXXd eXdoov Trapd tov bLKao-rf\v,
527 tov t{)s Alyivr\s vov, TTLbdv <rov TTLXa(36p.evos dyr\,
yacrp.r\crr\ K<t\ iA.tyytdo-ei? ovbev r\TTov rj eyoo ev6a.be <rv
eKel, Kai <re i<roos TVTTTf)<reL tls ko.1 eirl Koppr\s drt/ixcos Kat
TTO.VT00S TTpOTTrjXaKLeX.
5 Tdâ 5' ovv Tavra p.vdos crot boKel XeyeadaL &<Tirep ypabs
Kat Karacppovels avroov, ko.1 ovbev y av r\v 6avp\acnbv Kara-
cppovelv tovtoov, et irr\ (rjTovvres eL\op.ev aircov /3eArico Kat
aXrjdeo-repa evpelv vvv be optls otl rpets ovres vp.els, oXirep
e
<ro<po>TaToi e<TT toov vvv E,XXrjvoov, <rv tc Kal UcoXos Kal
b Topyias, ovk eêre aTroSetât <as bel aXXov tlvcl /3iov (r\v
,
rj tovtov, dcnrep /cat e/ceto-e cpaiveTaL <rvp.<pepoov. aXX ev
toctovtols XoyoLS tcov aXXoov eXey\o{XVoov povos ovtos
ripep.el 6 Xoyos, w? evXafHr\Tov ecrrlv to abLKelv piaXXov r)
5 ro dStKetcrflai, Kat 7rayro? p.aXXov ctvbpl p.eXeTr\Teov ov to

boKelv etvaL ayadbv aXXa to elvai, Kal Ibiq. Kal br\p.ocria'
eav be tls koto. tl KaKos yiyvryraL, KoXao-Teos eari, koX tovto

befJTepov ayadbv p.Ta to elvaL bUaLov, to yiyvecrdaL kol
C KoXa6p:Vov bLbovai biK.r\v kol Tracrav KoXaKeiav koll ti\v
d3 Te F : om. BTP d4 aKoirw B T P F yp. ao-Kw T : d5 tV

TWF Eusebius : om. BP d6 ao-Kuv F Eusebius o-kovwv : BTP
a 1 rov BTP : tKtlvov rhv F &yri B T P (kcTvos &yp F
: a 2 l\iy-
yi&aeis TP: ttKtyyido-eis BF a3 Kal ante eir\ et arifxecs secl.
Cobet eVl K&ppris secl. Heindorf
: as ypahs BTP : {nrb ypabs F
Eusebius Theodoretus a 9 vvv om. P
ropriAS 527C
Ttepl kavrbv koX Tr)v 7rept tovs aAXovs, Kal Tiepl oKiyovs
Kal Ttepl ttoXKovs, cpevKTtov Kal Trj prjropLKrj ovToi xprro-Ttov
eVt to hUaiov det, koX rf/ dAAy/ TTao-t) irpa^zL. e/zot ovv
TTi66p.zvos a.KoXov6r]crov (VTavOa, ol aqbLKop.Vos ebbaip.o- 5
vi]o-ets Kal a>v kol reAeurr/a-as, <as 6 \6yos o-r//xaii/et. ml

eaaoy riva o~ov KaTacppovfjaat. (hs avot]Tov Kal 7r0O7rr/AaKio-ai,
cav (3ov\rjTai, Kal val p.a Ata o~6 ye 6appS>v 7rardat rr/v
a.Tip.ov Tavrqv TrAr/yr/y ovbev yap bzLvbv Treio-r/, kav tS> ovtl d
t/s koKos Kayados, o.o~kG>v ap^rqv. KairtLTa ovTOi Koivfj
ao-KijcravTS, tot ybr], edy boKrj yj>r)vai, kin6r]cr6p.tda rots
7roA.iriKots, r/ 07rotor av rt r)pXv boKjj, tot /3ouAeuo-o'/xe0a,

/3eArtous ovths /3oJjAeveo-0at rj vvv. alcrxpbv yap exovrds 5
ye o>s vvv <paLv6p.zda \lv, e7retra vavLVrdaL <as rt ovras,
ots ovbiiroTi Tavra. 80/cet 7reot tG>v avT&v, Kat ravra 7reoi
tu>v /xeytVrwv ets tovovtov iJKop.ev ai7ai.bzvo~ ias too-TTtp e

ovv r/ye/ioVt tQ> Adya) xpt]<ro>p.da r<5 iw irapaqâviVTL, os
rjp.lv crripxxivti otl ovtos 6 Tpoiros apLaros tov /3iov, Kal rrjv
bLKaLocrvvrjv koX ti]v a\kr]v doerrjy aaKOvvTas kol fr/y Kat
T(6vavaL. tovto> ovv kiro>p.da, koX tovs dAAous irapaKa- 5
Aw/xer, p.r) eKetVo), <5 o~v ttlo~t<\vo)v e/xe TraoaKaAets* eori yap
ovbcvbs dcftos S> KaAAtKAets.
C4 Ttaari irpa|et BTP: c6 6 Xôs F: 6 ffbs

irpa|t ndffr) F
\6yos B T P c8 B T P to.vtt\v ti\v &Tifiov F
t)iv &TI/JLOV toJ)ti\v :
d 7 touto HoKei B T P Soku touto F

: 6 2 xPVO-dH-fOct B T XP 1l<r6~ :
/u0a PF e 5 eiroViefla P -rapaKa\ovfjLtv P

$

MENXIN
st. II
MENJ2N 212KPATH2 nAlS MENX2N02 ANTT02 p. 70
MEN. "Exets /Aot ei7retv, 00 2coKpares, apa btbaKTov r) a

ap^Tr]; ?*/ ov bibaKTov dAA' do-Kryrov; i) ovrc d(TK.r}Tbv ovre
IxaOrjrov, aX\a cpvcret 7rapaytyverat rots dvOpcbirois i) dAAcp
Tivl Tpdir;
2X2. *X2 Meixiw, 7rp6 tov p.kv erraAot evboKipot. rjcav 5

ev rots "EAA/criv Kal 6avpA(ovro ecp' iTrniKf) re Kal 7rAovrcp,
vvv 8e', cbs epot 80/cei, Kat e7rt aocpta, Kal ovx rJKiara oi tov b
0-ojj eratpou Aptgjr_t7T7rov 7roAtrat Aaptcratoi.
' rovrov 8e vp.iv
airto's ecrrt ropytas" dcpiKopevos yap ets tt)v tto\iv epaords

eVt erocpta etA?7cpei> 'AAevadcov re rovs 7rpcorovs, cov 6 <ros
epacrrr/s eartv 'AptartTiTros, Kai rcov dAAcov erraAcov. Kat 5
6tj Kat roiiro to Zdos vpds etfliKev, dcpd/3cos re Kat peyaAo-

7rpe7rcos cnroKpCvecrOat. edv rts rt epr/Tai, cocr7rep etKos rovs
etodras, are Kat avros Trapzyoov avrbv epcordy rcov 'EAAr/vcov C
rco /3ovAop.e'vco ort dv rts /3ovAr/rat, Kat ovevt orco ovk
aTtoKpi.v6p.ivos. kvOdbt 8e', cb cptAe Mevcov, to kvavTiov
TrepteVrrjKev too-7rep avxpds rts rf/s aocptas yeyovev, Kai kiv-
ovvevet eK rcovde rcov roVcov 7rap' vptds otxeo0at 7/ crocpta. et 71
yovv rtva e0e'Aets ovrcos epeVtfat rcov ev0d8e, ovoets 6Vrts ov
yeAdcrerat Kat epet* "*X2 <fe've, KtvSvvevco crot SoKetv paKapto's
rts etmt dperr)v yovv etre otSaKrov et0' 6'rtp Tpoiru irapa-
70 b 2 'Api<rriirirov secl. Naber \apuraioi F: \apicraiov BT W :
\apKT<raiov t : secl. Naber c

avrbs i W
F : avrois B T f (sed
s in ras. B) C 3 rb tvavriov} rb npayjj.a us roi/vavriov Cobet
71 a 4 aperrjv . . . & 5 ubevat secl. Naber
PLATO. VOL. III. 25
7ia IIAATX2N02
5 yCyveraL et8eWt eyco 8e toctovtov 8e'to etre hihaKTov eire
p.r) hihaKTov et8eVai, aVr' ot8e avro 6'rt 7ror' eort to -napa-nav
aperi] Tvyyava> et8cos."
b 'Eycb ovy /cai auro's, a> MeVcoi>, ovrcos ex<w* o~vp.-nivop.ai,
tols 7roAiVats rourou rou TTpa.yp.aTos, Kal euauray Kara-

ueuc/jouat cos ouk et8cos 7rept apeTrjs t6 "napaitav 6 8e ut)
ot8a rt io~Tiv, 7rcos av ottoIov ye rt et8eiT?i>; i) 8oKet aot

5 otoV re etrat, oorts MeVcova ut) ytyycoo-Ket to irapaTTav otrrts
IcttCv, tovtov et8eVat etre KaAos etre 7rAo7Jtrios etre Kat
ytvvaLos ccttlv, etre Kal TavavrCa tovtcdv; 8oKet a-oi otoV r'
eti>at;
MEN. Ovk euotye. dAAa o~v, a> 2toKpares, aArrdcos

C ou8' ort apeTT] zcttlv oTo~6a, dAAa raSra 7rept troS Kat otKaSe
aTrayyiAAa>uei> ;
2X2. Mr) p.6vov ye, a> eratoe, aAAa Kat ort otjS' aAAto 7ra>
kvfrvyov etSoVt, cos euot 8okcS.

5 MEN. Tt 8e'; TopyCa ovk Zvervxes ort eV0d8e fjv;
2X2. "Eycoye.
MEN. Etra ovk e8o'Ket o-ot et8eVai;
212. Ov Trdvv etut p.V7]p.a>v, > M4v(ov, coare otjk e'xa>
et7rety ey rco irapovTL 7rcos uot rdre e8oei>. aAA' ttrtos
io eKeu>o's re ot8e, Kat av a eKetros eAeye* avap.vr)crov ovv

d ue 7rcos eAeye/A et 8e /3o7JAet, avros etTre'* 8oKet ydp 8t/7tou
trot a7rep eKetPto.
MEN. "Euotye.
2X2. 'EKetvoy uei> toCvvv ecouev, e7rei8T) Kat a7reoTty tru
5 8e aurds, co 7rpds 0ecoi>, MeVcov, rt cprjs aperrjv eivai; zlttov
kol p.r) (pdovrjcrjs, Lva cvTvyioraTov \^vcrp.a i\jrevo-p,vos a>,
a5 BT
roffovrov W
F roaevrov Buttmann : a 6 &o~r F &s :
BTW b4 yi t BTW: cVtIi' F: ye t/ eVrn/ Naber

b 5 yivdffKn B T yivcoaicri :F b 6 tovtov B W
F tovtwv W
W
:
T /col êj/paios B T F -yeyj/aros C 3 irco B T

: iroo F W :
C 10 avdfivriaov fKeytv punctis notata in T

. . d 4 fikv toivvv
W
.
T F ptVTOi vvv B d 5 tiirov B T F tVe scr. Laur. xiv. 85 W

W
: :
d 6 fvrvxcarraTov B T F iiToxf^raTos :
MENX2N 71 d
av (f>avf)s (rv p.ev 6w>S kcu Topyias, eyto 8e elprjKcos p.r)bevl

7T0)TTOT elboTL l>TTV)^t]KeVaL.
MEN. 'AAA' ov ya ti c--r6v, S> 2<oKpare?, elirelv. irp&Tov e

pev, el (3ov\eL dvbpds dptnjv, pabLov, otl avrrj eo-rlv dvbpbs
dperi], LKavbv elvaL tcl tijs WAecos TTpaTTeLV, ko.1 irpctTTOVTa
TOVS pikv qbi\0VS V 1TOLLV, TOVS 8' e\$povs kokcos, Kal avTov
av\af$L(TdaL prjbev tolovtov TraOeLV. et be /3ov\L yvvaiKos 5
apTi]v, ov yaXeTrbv bie^delv, otl 8et avTi)v ti)v olklov ev

olklv, criUfivo~dv re tcl evbov Kal KaTi]Koov oxxrav tov dvbpos.
Kal a\\r] 0~tIv 7rat8os dpeTi], Kal 6i]\ias Kal dppevos, Kal
TTp0~(3vTpOV CLvbpOS, 1 p.V (3ov\L, e\ev6epOV, L be (3ov\ei,
bov\ov. Kal aAAat 7rdu7roAAat dperai lo~lv, coore ovk 72

CLITOpLa llTLV dpTl)s 7Tpi OTL OTLV' Ka6' Ka(rTr]V ydp
Tb>V TTpd^COV KO.I tG>V f]\LKL(2v TTpOS Ka(TTOV pyOV Ka(TTU)
i)pa>v r) dpTr) (j-tlv, (hcravTcos 8e otjuat, a> 2&>K/)are?, Kal 1)
kokio. 5
2X2. IIoAA?) ye tlvl evTvyia eot/ca Keypr)o~6aL, a> Mevcov,

et p.iav (J]tG>v dperip crprjvos tl dvi]vpr]Ka dpercov irapcL crol
Keipevov. drdp, S) Mevcov, Kara ravTijv Tr)v etKoVa ti]v

JTpl Ta o~p.r]Vi], ei p.ov epopevov ueAtrrr/s 7rept oixrias ort b
7ror' (ttlv, 7roAAa? kcxl TTavTobairds e\eyes avras elvaL, tl
dv dTTKpCv(o p.01, et o~ r)p6p.i]v "'Apa tovto> qbr)s 7joAAa?
Kat 7rai>ro8a7rd? etrat Kat bia(ppovo~as d\\r)\cov, r<3 ueAtrras
etmt; ?/ rovra) piev ovbev bLa(pepov(Tiv, a\\u> 8e rw, otoz> 5
i] KaAAet 17 peyedeL r) aAAw ra> tcov tolovtcov" LTT, t'l dv
direKpivo) ovtcos epcorr/êiy;
XMEN. Tovr' eycoye, ort o?38ey bLa(ppovo~LV, ij p.e\LTTaL

L(riv, i) kTepa ti)s eTepas.
2X2. Et ovv eliTov perd ravra' " Touro Toivvv wot C
avrd elire, a> Mevcov u o?38e2' bLaabepovcrLV dAAa Tavrov
e 6 avrty BTF : avrrj j W

e 9 /xkv B T W : jikv oZv F tl
S^ frov\ei\ tl 8e Cobet a 2 StiBTW: 6'tou F a 4 ^ supra
versum T a 6 Kfxpyo-dai B T xpv<r0at PW F a 8 Ktifxfvov
W
:
F : Kttfxtvwv BT b 3 tySpriv B WF : elp6/jii-v T

25*
72C nAATXlNOS
elcnv aTtacrai, tl tovto zlvai" dv rl
<pf>s ^x ? S?/7rou /uot
et7reu>;
5 MEN. 'Eycoye.
212. Ovrco brj Kal irepl t&v dpercoy nav et ttoKKol Kal
iravTobaTral elcriv, f-v yi tl etbos tovtov diracraL \ovctlv
oY b dcrlv dperat, ets o KaAcos ttov eêt aTrofik\\ravTa rbv
dtroKpLv6p.zvov rco ipcoTrjcravTL e/ceiyo 5??Acocrai, o TvyydveL
d ovcra apeTrj' r) ov p.av9dvLS otl Ae'yco;
MEN. Aokco ye p,oi p.av9dveLV ov jueVrot cos /3ovAoixat
ye 7TO) KaTZXUi to eocorco/xeroz/.

212. ITorepoy 8e 7rept dper^s p.6vov o~ol ovtco 8oKet, co
5 MeVcov, dAA?? p&v avbpbs etmt, aAA?? 8e ytwatKos Kat tu>v

dAAcor, 77 Kat irep\ vyteta? Kat 7reot /xeye'0ot>? Kat 7reot lo~xyos
oio-avTUis; aAArj /xei> avbpbs boKd ctol etrat vyteta, aAAr/
8e yjJvatKo'y; 77 ravrbv TravTaypv dbos Zotlv, kdvrrtp vyteta
e ?), edrre ei> dvbpl ZdvTt iv dAAco drcoow 77;
MEN. *H avr?; poL SoKet vytetd ye etmi Kat avbpbs Kal

yvvaLKos.
212. Ovkow Kat /xe'ye0os Kal lo"xys; edvTrcp loyypa
5 yvvrj
f\,
r<o avrco etdet Kat ry avrfj lcrxyi lo~xypd lcrrat; rd
yap Trj avrf] tovto Ae'yco* ovbev 8tac/3e'oei 7rpoy rd lo~xys elvaL
7) lcryys, edvTe iv dvbpl ?) ZdvTt e> yvvaiKL. r) SoKet tl
ctol bLacpipeiv;
MEN. Ovk e/xotye.
73 212.
C
H 8e dpTr) irpbs rb dperr) etrai 8tocret tl, cdvre
cv TraLbl fi
idvTe ev TTpecr^vTj}, edvTe eV ywatKt tdvre h
dvbpC;
MEN. "E/Ltotye' 7rcos SoKet, co 2coKparey, tovto ovkztl
5 6p.oLov etVat rots dAAots tovtols.
212. Tt bi; ovk dvbpbs p.kv dpeTr)v eAeye? 7rdAty ev
C9 airoKpiv6(i.tvov WF : airoKptvd/xtvov BT 62 So/cf? BT W :
Sok(7 elvai F yf F : BTW e6 Siafptpet BT WF : tiiatyipttv

Laur. vii. 85 7 ^ trî/s ^c(' tsTWF: jj foxvs fj. Hv rt B
Soku t( (To BT W : ffot Sokc? ti F
.
MENX2N 73 a
bioiKew, yvvaiKos e ohiav; MEN. y

Eycoye. 2X2. *Ap'
ovv oXov re et> biotKelv i) ttoXlv aAAo
t/ oikiclv i) otlovv,
ixi] ocotppovcos Kal bcKaicos bLOLKovvra; MEN. Ov brJTa.
212. Ovkovv avirep bLKaicos kol ococppovcos bLOLKcooiv, 8t- b
KaLocrvvr\ kol ococppoovvi) bLOLKrjo~ovo~Lv;- MEN. 'AvayKt}.
212. Ttov avTcov dpa d/xcpo'repoi beovraL, et7rep LxekkovoLV
dyadol eXvai, klxl r) yvvi) Kal 6 dvijp, bLKaLoovvqs kol oco-
tppoovvqs. MEN. Tt <S>aivovTaL. 2X2. 8e itals Kal 7rpe- 5
ojBvrns; aKokaoTOL
llcov ayaOol av ovres kol abLKOL ttot--
yivoLVTo; MEN. Ov 'AAAa br)ra. 2X2. ococppovt-s ko.1
oiKatot; MEN. Nat.

ap 2X2. Yldvres
>
dvdpcoTroi rco avrto C

Tpoirco dyadoi yap tv\6vths dyadol
t-loLV tcov avrcov yi-
yvovrai. MEN. Ovk dv v
Eoi*e. 2X2. brjrrov, et ye p.i) ?/
avTi) aperi) i)v avrcov, rco avrco dv Tpoirto dyaOol rjoav.

MEN. Ov brJTa. 5
2X2. 'E77et57/ Toivvv i) avTr) dperr) irdvTcov koriv, 7retpco
drrtlv Kal dvap.vr)odi)vaL t'l avro tpi]OL Topyias nXvaL /cat
ov fier' iKiivov.
MEN. Tt aAAo y r) dpytLV oXov r' t-XvaL tcov dvdpcoircov;
enrep eV yk rt ^r/rets /cara irdvTcov. d

2X2. 'AAAa fxi]v r/rco 7*- a ^ a P a Kai rraLbds i) avTi)
dperr/, to Mevcov, Kal bovkov, apytLV otco re etvai tov 8e-
ottotov, Kat So/cet crot ert b\v bovXos etVat 6 dpyjcov;
MEN. Ov Trdw lxol boKtu, 2> 2coKpare?. 5
2X2. Ov ydp cIkos, S apto-re* ert yap *cat Tobe ok6tt<~i.
apycLv tpfis oXov r' t-XvaL. ov irpoo9i]ooin-v avToati tq

bLKaitos, dbUcos oe ixi);
MEN. Ot/Ltat eycoyv r) ydp bLKaLoowi), co 2cofcpares,

dptiTi) eoTiv. 10
2X2. YloTt-pov dpcTi), do Mzvcov, rj dpeTi] tls; e

MEN. rTcS? tovto Ae'yeu;
b I StKaiws Kai <ru<pp6vm B T W

ffu<pp6vu>s Kal StKaiwt F d 3 otu>
W
:
olu B T oli) F oT6v (vel olov) Buttmann d 6 yap Kal B T

WF
: : :
Kal Schanz
: 8e /coJ Fritzsche
:
73e IlAATilNOS
2X2. 'X2? Tiepl dAAou otovovv. dlov, et fiovktL, o~Tpoy-
yuAdrrjros 7re'ot et7rotp,' hv eycoye otl <r\r\p.& r( o~tlv, o\>x
5 otfrco? a7rAcos drt a-yr)p.o.. bia ravra 8e ourco? av alTroip.L,
otl Kal akka ecrrt aryjip.aTa.
MEN. 'Op0co? ye Aeycov crv, e7ret nal eyto Ae'yco ov povov

hLKaLoo~vvr]v dkka koa. dAAa? etyat dperd?.
74 212. TtVa? ravras; et7re'. otoi> /cai eyco crot ei7rotpi av

Kal dkka o-^Tj/xara, et pe KeAeuot?* Kat av ovv epot etTre
dAAa? dperds.
MEN. 'H dvbpda tolvvv epotye SoKet dper?) eii>ai Kat
5 o-axppoo-vvr] Kal crocpta koj. peyaAo7rpe'7reta Kat dAAat 7rdp-
7roAAai.
212. ndAty, o> Mt-vatv, tovtov 7re7r oVt9ap.ezr -nokkds av
T}vpr\Kap.ev dperd? piav (jitovvtzs, akkov Tpoirov rj vvvbrj-
Tr)v be fxCav, f) td iravTOiv tovtcov Io~tlv, ov bvvdp.n6a

io avtvpew.
MEN. Ov yap bvvap.ai iro), co 2coKpare?, co? cry (jiTets,
b p.iav apTi)v Aa/3eu> Kard TrdvTOiv, u>o~irp ev rots dAAots.
212. EtKorcos ye* dAA' eyco irpo6vp.ria-op.aL, eav otds r'
co, r)p.ds 7rpo/3t/3dcrai. p.av6dveLS ydp irov otl ovrcocrt eêt

7rept 7rai>rds* et rts cre dvdpoLTO tovto o vvvbr) eyco eAeyoy,
5 " Tt eaTiv o~xr}p.a, cb MeVcov;" et aurto et7res drt o~Tpoy-
yvkoTT-s, et o-ot eiTrep airep 4yo), " YloTtpov o~yj)p.a r) o~Tpoy-
yvkorrjs (\o~tIv t/ cryj)p.d tl" enre? 8r/7rou av otl cryr)pA tl.
MEN. Udvv ye.

C 212. Ovkovv bLa TavTa, otl Kal akka ccttlv cryjipaTa;
MEN. Nat'.
2X2. Kat et ye 7rpocraznipcora o~e cnrola, eAeyes &v;

MEN. "Eycoye.
a2 KeKevots BT WF: 2
neAeveis T oZu BTW: /u.ev ovv F
a
BT W
7 a5 evp-f)Ka,u.ei> BT WF : avevpr)Ka/j.ei> Buttmann a8 ^.lav
Ka\ /xiav F &g io~Tiv\ elcrtv ci. Madvig an irw
W
:
BT
BTW:
: F
7Tos b3 irpofiifidffat WF : irpofffitflaffai BT b4 ff
om. F 03 irpoffavr)p&Ta ae BTf: irpbs av -qpdira ffe F:

-rpoffavr)pu>T7)ffev W
MENX2N 74 c
avijpero otl
2X2. Kat av et 7rept xP (* P- aT0 $
> ô-avroos 5
0-tlv, nai (lttovtos <tov otl to XtvKov, /uiera ravra V7reAa/3eu

6 (pMTfav " YloTcpov to Xcvkov XPP- a *o~tlv V XP^P- a Tl >"
XP~P- a Tl 810'rt Kal aAAa rvyxavtL

ei7res av otl >
6Vra;
MEN. "Eycoye.
2X2. Kat et yi o-e eWAeue Ae'yeu' aAAa xP<*>P- aTa > eAeyes 10
av aAAa, a ouSei rjrrov TvyxaveL ovra xpcojuara Tv AevKoC; d

MEN. Nat.
212. Et ovv u>o-TTp eyto /uerrjet roy Aoyoi/, Kat eAeyev
ort " 'Aet ets 7roAAa a<pLKVOvp.da, aAAa p.rj /uot ovrcos,
dAA' e7ret8T) rd 7roAAa raura em' rtyt TtpocrayopevHS ovo- 5

/uart, Kat <pr}s ovbtv avTwv otl ov orxvp-a *wai, kol ravra
kol (vavTLa ovTa dAATjAots, 6'rt eorty tovto 6 ovb\v tjttov
Kare'xet r6 arpoyyvkov rj to i>6v, 6 br) 6Vo/mdets o~xW a
Kal ovb\v piaXXov <pf}s to aTpoyyvkov o-xvp-a. eivaL r) to e
v6v;'' 7/ ovx 01/rco Aeyets;
MEN. 'Eycoye.
2X2. *Ap' ovv, orav ovtio Aeyr/s, tot ovb\v p.a\kov <pr)s
to crTpoyyvXov etmt crTpoyyvkov 1] evdv, ovb\ to v6v eiidv 5
r) orpoyyvkov;
MEN. Ov br)TTOV, a> 2coKpares.
2X2. 'AAAd p.r)v <rxrjp.a ye ov8ei> p.a\Xov <pfis elvaL to
oTpoyyvXov tov zvOios, ovb\ to Tpov tov ere'p07j.
MEN. 'AAt)0t/ Aeyet?. 10
2X2. Tt 7rore ovv tovto ov tovto 6vop.a Cttlv, to o-xVfJ-a;
7retpa) Ae'ye\ et ovv t<2 epcorcorrt ovtojs r) iripi crxWaT0S 75

" 'AAA' ovb\ p.av6avo) eycoye ort
77 xP^M aT0S clttcs otl
/3o7JAet, a> av6poiTT(, ovbt olba otl Ae'yei9," to-cos av kOav-
fxao-e Kal lttV " Ov p.av6a.VLS otl ^ra) to tt\ ttclo-lv
C7 iBTW: om.F d 7 Sn B T WF : rl Gedike &T 2

:
om. BT WF d8 Karex*' BT F W : del. rec. b ovo/idCeis

BTF dt>ofui(ei W e 1 o'X''Ata e 5 T^ o"rp<>Yyv\oi> om. W
W
:
,add. in marg. w) e
7 ov Sîrou BTF : ou Stjtci (sed suprascr.
irou W) a2 a\A' ou5f B T f W : fiAAou F
7Sa nAATJ2N02
5 tovtols Tai/Tov" Tj ox>b em tovtols, S) Mzvoov, \ols dv
dTTtlv, et rts cre epcorco??' " Tt eorti tt\ r<S crrpoyyvAcp
ko\ V0L nal im rots aAAois, a br) ayjip.aTa KaAets, ravrbv
ZttI Trao-Lv;" 7retpco dirtlv, tva Kal yivryral croi jueAeV?? 7rpos
ti]v rrrepl Trjs dpTrjs drTOKpLo-LV.
b MEN. Mrj, aWa. crv, co 2coKpares, et7re'.
212. BovAet o-ot yapLcroop/iL;
MEN. Udvv ye.
212. 'E0eA?/o-ets ovv Kal av ep.ol lttlv 7rept ttjs apeTrjs;
5 MEN. "Eycoye.
212. UpoOvp.r\Tov Toivvv aiov ydp.
MEN. Udvv p.\v ovv.
2X2. <J>e'pe brj, 7reipcope(9d crot et7reu> ri kaTiv cryr)p.a.
ctk6ttL ovv et ro8e a7rode'x*7 ai)TO etrat* eorco ydp br) i)fuv
io rouro cryjjp,a, o p.6vov tS>v ovtcov rvyydvL XptopaTL <*et
7r6p.Vov. LKavtos ctol, r) dAAcos ttoos Cv 7 ^; eyco yap kclv
C ovtoos ayaiT&rpj et pot dper?/i> lttols.
MEN. 'AAAa tovto ye et/T/tfes, co 2coKpares.

212. FIcos Ae'yets;
MEN. "Ort o-yr)pA 7ro?J eortv Kard tov crbv koyov 6 det
5 xpoq e7rerat. etef et 8e 6t) r7)f yjpoav tls p.r) cpaCr) etcWrat,
dAAa cocravrcos diropol cocr7rep 7rept rou o-x?//xaros, tl dv otet
0"Ot a7TOKKpLO-0aL;
212. TdA??0?7 eycoye* kol et p,eV ye rcoy crocptov tls et?/
Kat eptOTlKCOl/ T Kal dyCOVLCTTLK&V 6 p6p.VOS, CLTTOLp? dv

d avriti otl " 'E/uot p.V etp??rai' et 8e /x?j 6p6G>s Aeyco, oof
epyoy Xap./3dvLV koyov Kal eAeyxetv." et 8e cocr7rep eyco
re Kat cru vvvl cptAot oi>res /3ov\olvto dAA?/Aots 8taAe'yeo-0ai,
as^BTW^^F a6 <re F: om. BTW r/TWFb:

tIjB a8 B T F om. W Ka\ b2 B T x aPônat
2
W
T F b4 BTW 40e\-fi(reis
:
xP'o"Ma'
li edeXrio-us F
:
b 8 vtip<ifif0d
W
:
BT F
bn BTW:
Schanz
: ireipwfiai b 10 rovro B WF : rovro rb T
tcav F Kal vvv Ca eM BTW: tbifiws F
c4 T W F o-x^MT B
<rxniJM : c 8 lywye BT W : Ae^wj/ F
C9 ip6fA.*vos BTWf: ip<i/xevos F
)
MENX2N 75d
5et byj irpqoTepov ttcos kcu StaAeKrtKcorepoj; aTroKpivacrdaL.
eo-rt 5e lctcos to 5taAeKrtKCtfrepoi> p,?/ jxovov TaArjOi) aTTOKpi- 5

vt\o~6aL, dkkd Kal 5t' eKnivcov cov av TTpoo~op.okoyf] ei5eVat
6 kpcoTcop.t\vos. TTLpdcro[J.aL br) Kal eyco o~ol ovtcos et7reu\
Ae'ye ydp p.OL' reAeurrjy mkels tl; rotoV5e Ae'yco olov ntpas e
Kal Zo-yaTov TxdvTa ravra ravrov tl keyco' tcrcos 5' i\v
r)p.lv YlpobLKos bLacpepoLTo, dkkd o~v ye' ttov KaAeti irtTTepdvOaL
tl Kal TereAevr7]/ceWt t6 tolovtov j3ovkop.aL kiye.LV, ovbev

TTOLKLkov. 5
MEN. 'AAAa KaAco, Kal ot/xai p.avOdvuv Aeyets.
22X2. Tt 5'; (Triirabov KaAets tl, xat tTtpov av orepeoV, 76
olov ratrra t<x kv tols yeco/uerptaiy;
MEN. "Eycoye koAco.
2X2. "Hbr~ tolvvv &v piddoLs ptov eK tovtcov o~yj)fxa o
Aeyco. mrd yap TravTos o~yj-p.aTos tovto Ae'yco, ets o ro 5
(TTtpzbv 7repau>et, tovt etyat cr-^rjp.a' oirap dv crvkkajScov
et7rotp,t crrepeoi) Trt-pas o~yr\p.a eti>at.
MEN. To 5e \p(op.a r( Ae'yets, co 2coKpares;

2X2. 'T^pLcmjs y et, <o M4vcov avbpl TrpncrfivT-] irpa-
yp.ara 7rpocrrarrets diroKpivao~6aL, avrbs 8e ovk e#e'Aeis 10
dvap.vr]o~dals diroLV otl ttoth Ae'yet Topytas dpcTr)v aivaL. b

MEN. 'AAA' e7rei8cu' juot o~v tovt et7rr/s, co 2coKpares,
epco crot.
2X2. Kdv KaTaKeKakvp.p:4vos tls yvoir], c\ Mivcov, 5taAe-

yop.t-vov o~ov, otl Kakbs et Kat epaorat o*ot ert aicriv. 5
d.4 airoKpivtffdai . d 5 toAtjOt/ . . aitoKpiv-ffBai . TW:

SiaAe/mKw- . .
Tepoy om. B anoKpivfffdai . TaKr-drj om. F (add. in marg. f)

W
: . .
d 6 wv av B T W
av S>v F (ar f : i-poaofnoXoy^ B T wpoffwfxo- :
\6yet F (irpoffofxo\oyu f) irpoo/ioAoyf? Gedike : d 7 epwTciyuej/os]

tpofievos Cornarius e Ficino (qui rogaf) 4pwrwv E. S. Thompson :
e r \4yu> B T W
F : \4yuv t a 1 ri B F to T et suprascr. f W :
a2 Ta?j BTWF om. vulg. a4 fxddots /xov B LiddTjs fxoi F

W
: : ;
fiavBdvois fxov TW a 6 ffvWafiwv B T o~v \a&wv F a9 7'

WF
:
BT W : om. F a 10 irpocrrdTTtis B T : irapx*s Cobet

bs 0-0 BTF: om. W b 5 o~oi !Vi BTf: It o-o W:
<roi F
PLATO, VOL. III. 26
;
76b I1AATI2N02
MEN. Tt hr);
212. "Ort ovhev dAA' rj eTrtrdrreis 1
kv rots Adyots, oirep

TTOIOVCTLV ol TpV(p&VTS, &T TVpaVVVOVTS CCOS av V &pq
C ooaiv, koX dp.a kp.ov tcrois KarkyvoiKas otl et/ut rJTTOiV t&v
KaXGtv yapiovp,ai ovv ctol Kal diTOKpLvovpAXL.
MEN. Ylavv piev ovv x&pLcrai,
212. BovAet oZv ctol KaTa Fopyiav aTTOKpivoip.aL, r) av
5 crv judAtcrra a.KoXov6i]crais
MEN. BovX.op.aL' 7rcos yap ov";
212. Ovkovv Aeyere airoppods rivas tG>v ovtcov Kara

'Eju,7reooKAea; MEN. 2</>o'8pa ye. 2X2. Kat -nopovs ets
ots Kal ot' &v at airoppoal TroptvovTai; MEN. Udvv ye.

io 212. Kat T<av airoppoGiV rds p*v ap/xorrety kvioLs t<2v
d iropoiv, rds 8e eAdrrous r) p,tiovs etz>at; MEN. v
Ecrrt
ravTa. Ovkovv Kal o\}nv KaAets rt;
212. MEN. v
Eycoye.
2X2. 'Ek tovtcov hr) " crvves o rot Aeyco," ecpr) Tlivhapos.
cttlv yap \poa diroppor) cryr)p.aTOiV oi/êt crvp.p,Tpos kol
5 aicrOrjTos.
MEN. "Aptcrrd /u.ot SoKets, a> 2coKpares, TaijTrjv rrjv
cmoKpicnv dprjKtvat..
212. "Icrcos ydp crot Kara vvvrjOetav elprjTar Kal dp,a

ot/xat kvvoels otl eôts av e<f avr?/s e7reti> Kat cpoivi]v b ecrrt,
e Kal 6crp,r,v koX dXXa 7roAAa rcov tolovtohv.
MEN. Ildw p,v ovv.
2X2. Tpayt/a) ydp ecrriv, a MeVcoy, ^ aTtoKpicns, cocrre
dpecrKei ctol p,aXXov rj r) irepl tov crxr]p,aTos.

v
5 MEN. E/xotye.
212. 'AAA' ovk cttlv, co 7rat 'AAe<ft8?7p.ot>, cbs eycb kp.avTov
iteiOoi, dAA' eKtivq /3eArt'coy otpai 8e ot>8' ay crot 8d<fat,
b 6 Tt B T f 6tj F W C 7 \ty(T T F \4yerai B W

C 9 7rdVu :
W
:
B T W Kal iravv F d 1 ir6pwv B T f ir6pvwv F tos B T F

W
: : :
rovs d 3 8 TOi B T 8toi; F (6'tj f W 8 tiv Cobet

: )
W
:
d 4 anoppoi) B T W
airopt<rr)s F
: axwaTwv B T F yp. xpVf -^ rwv J
W
:
. T (probavit H. Diels) d 5 uI<t6i)t6s B T f (sed <rtt supra t6s W :
aloB-fjcrei P; tadrjTos F
:
MENX2N 76e
et utj, axnrtp x^ ekeyes, avayKaiov ctol airUvat, irpb tG>v
pvcrrqpLcav, dAA' et TrepLp.e(vaLS re Kal p.vr]6e(r]s.
MEN. 'AAAd Trepi.pi.4voi.pi,' av, > 2coKoares, et uot 7roAAd 77

Toiavra Aeyots.
2X2. 'AAAd utV 7rpodvp.(as ye oi>ev airoketya), Kal aov
eveKa Kal ep.avrov, keycav Toiavra' dAA' oVcos p.r) oi>x olos
r' ecrouat iroXka TOiavTa XeyeLV. dAA' t#t 8?) ireLpG> Kat 5
cri/ euot ttiu TjTroVxecrtz/ airobovvai, Kara. okov elrrcbv aperrjs

irepL otl ecrr(v, Kat 7rai;crat 7roAAd ttolG>v ck tov evos, oirep
cpacrl tovs ovvt pifiovTas tl eKaaroTe ot aKCOTrroiJres, dAAd
edo"as oXrjv kciI vyLrj elrre ti eortr aperr]. tcl be ye irapa-
Setyuara 7rao' euoii etAricpas. k-

MEN. AoKet tolwv uot, S> 2coKoares, dperTj eiVat, Ka0d-
7rep 6 7rotriTT)s Ae'yet, " x aiP* lv T KaKoicrL Kat bvvacr6aL^
Kal eyco rooro Aeyco apeTrjv, eTndvpiovvTa tG>v koKG>v bvvarov
eiVat Trop(ecr6aL. 5
2X2. *Apa Aeyets tov tG>v KaAcoy eTTL6vp.ovvTa c\ya6G>v

kiTL6vpr]Tr]v etvai; MEN. MdAtord ye. 2X2. *Apa ws
OVTtOV TLV&V 0% tG>V KaK&V eTTLdvpOVCTLV, eTepCDV be 0% Tb>V
aya6G>v; ov TrdvTes, cootore, eoKOTjcrt crot rcor aya6G>v eirL- C

MEN. Ovk
6vp.eiv; 'AAAd euotye. 2X2. rtves tG>v KaKG>v;
MEN. Nat. OtVueôt KaKa ayada

2X2. tcl etVai, Xeyeis,
r) KaKa
Kal yLyvti>crKOVT(.s ort eorty oucos eTTLdvp.ovcrLV av-
MEN. 'AucpoVepa
tG>v; epoLye boKovcrLv. 2X2. *H yap 5
SoKet rts ctol, a> KaKa

Mevcav, ytyycocrKcoy tcl otl KaKa eorLV
MEN. MdAiora.
oucos eiTLdvp.eiv avrG>v; 2X2. Tt e7rt0u-
uetV Aeyets; MEN.
t/ yevecrdaL atrcp; TevecrdaL' tl yap
dAAo; KaKa
2X2. Ylorepov r)yovp.evos tcl Gxpekeiv eKeivov d
a 3 76 B T W Te F a8 t* BT W om. F : _b 3 KaKolffi
W
W (sed
:
BTF : KaXodffi in ras.) b 4 \4yu> B T F ttvai \4yo> :
Ka\wv BT W Ka\wv Ka\ F b 7 imBvniiJ^v B T F iin0vfj.vrhs :
W
:
C2 rwv BTWf om. F C3 ayaOa tlvai \4yeis BTW :
W
:
\tyfts ayaQa tlvai F C 5 an.<p6rtpa . . . C 7 avruv om. (in marg.

add. w) Hokovviv F : Soku BT
26*
;
77 d IIAAT&NOS
cj> av yevrjraL, rj yLyvu>o~Koov ra KaKa otl ftkdrrrtL co av
Trapfj; MEN. Eich pikv oi r)yovp.VOL ra KaKa bHpekuv,
elalv 8e Kal ot yiyvcoo-Kovres otl /3Aa7rret. 2X2. *H koX
5 boKovai crot yiyvvto~Ke.iv ra KaKa otl KaKa (o~tlv ol r)yov-
]x*vol tcl KaKa dxpekelv; MEN. Ov rrdvv /uot SoKet tovto

ye. 2X2. Ovkovv brjkov otl ovtol ]xev ov tS>v KaK(2v Zttl-
e Bv]xovo~lv, ol ayvoovvrcs avrd, akka klvo>v a &ovto ayaOa
ilvaL, tto~TLV 5e TavTa ye KaKa' cocrre ot dyvoovvres avra
Kal ol6]xevoL ayaOa etvaL brjkov otl tu>v dyaOQ>v ttlOv]xovo~lv.
?/ ov; .MEN. KLvbvvevovo-LV ovtol ye.

5 212. Tt 8e'; ot rcoy KaK&v ]xkv ttlOv]xovvtS, tos <pfjs crv,
r)yov]xevoL be ra KaKa /3Act7rreii' Zkzlvov co clv yiyvqraL,

yLyva>o~KovarLV brjirov otl /3Aa/3?/owrai vrr* avr&v; MEN.
78 'AvdyKt].- 212. 'AAAa tovs (3kairro]xivovs ovtol ovk otovraL
dOkiovs LvaL KaO' ocrov /3Acnrroyrai; MEN. Kat tovto
avayKr]. 2X2. Tovs 8e adkCovs ov KaKobaC]xovas MEN.
Ot/uat eytoye. 212.
v
Eo-rii> ovv oo~tls /3ovAerat aflAtos koX
5 KaKobaLpLUv etmt; MEN. Ov ]xol boKei, a 2coKoares.
2X2. Ovk apa /3ovAerat, co MeVcoy, ra KaKa ovbeis, etrrep ]xr)
/3o?JAerai rotoSros eii>at. rC yap akko kcrrlv dOkiov elvai

t] TtL6vp.iLV re tu>v KaK&v Kal KTacrOaL; MEN. KLvbvvevtLs
b akt]$r) keyeiv, co 2toKoare$' Kat o?38ets f3ovkeo~0aL ra
koiuL
212. Ovkovv vvvbr) eAeyes ort eoTtr 7; dperf] fiovkecrOai
re rayaOd kol bvvao~0aL; MEN. Eitiw ydp. 2X2. Ovkovv
5 tov kexOevros to fxev (3ovkeo~0aL irdo-LV v-ndpyeL, koX Tavrr]
ye o?38ey 6 hepos tov krepov /3eAriW; MEN. 4>atrerat.
2X2. 'AAAa brjkov otl etrrep ecrrt /SeAricof aAAos aAAou,
Kara to bvvao~6aL av etrj d]xdv<t>v. MEN. Yldvv ye.
2X2. To{5r' ecrrty dpa, co? eoiKe, Kara tov crbv koyov aperi],
d 5 0/ iyyovnivoi B T W
Siyyovfievoi F e 1 01 ayvoovvrts avrd
W
:
BT F Stobaeus secl. Cobet : a 7 icrriv B T iariv W : tj
iri6u/jLuv F b 1 Pov\t<r6ai B F &ov\tTat T f b 5 rov W

W
:
Ast tovtov B T
: F tovtov tov Schlciermacher
:

MEN12N 78 c
Swapt? tov TTOpC(e(rdai rayadd. MEN. UavTaiTao-L pot c

SoKet, 2 2coKpare?, ovrco? xeiy co? oii vvv vnoka\xfidvei<i.
2X2. "lb<t)[XV 8r/ Kal tovto et dkt]dh Ae'yet?* tcrco? ydp
av ev Aeyot?. rdyadd c/>r)? otov t tlvai 7ropteo-0ai apTr)v
ilvai; MEN. "Eycoye.22. 'Ayatfd oe KaAet? or5xt olov 5
vyUidv re Kat TrAoiroy; MEN. Kat yjivcrCov Aeyco /cal
apyvpLov KTao-Qai. Kal upd? eV 7ro'Aet Kat dpxds; 212. Mr/
dAA' arra Aeyet? rdya0d r) rd ToiavTa; MEN. Ovk, dAAd

irdvTa Aeyco rd rotavra. 212. Eteir xpvcrCov 8e 8r/ Kat d
dpyvpiov TropC(O-0aL dpeTij errrti% co? cprjcri Mercoy 6 rorj
peydAorj /3acrtAe'co? TrarptKos feVo?. TtoTtpov 7rpocrri0ei?
rorjrco rco 7ro'pco, co MeVcor, ro oikoico? Kat dcrico?, rr orjder
crot 8tacpe'pei, dAAd kojj ddiKco? rt? ar3ra 7roptrjrai, dpotco? 5
rri> arjrd dpert]v KaAet?; MEN. Orj 8r/7rou, 2> 2coKpare?.

212. 'AAAd KaKiW. MEN. ndn-co? 8rj7rorj. 212. Aet dpa,
co? eotKe, rorjrco rcp 7ro'pco 8tKatocrrjVrjy r) o-ayqjpoarvvqv r/
dcndrrjra 7rpocreiVai, r) dAAo rt p,6pL0V dpeTrjs' et 8e //rj, e

ovk ecrrat dp(Ti], KaCtrep kKiropC(pv(ra rdyaQd. MEN. IIco?
ydp dvev tovtcov dperi] yeVotr' dv; 212. Td oe p.r) eK-
itopC&Lv yjpvcrCov Kal dpyvpLov, orav fxr) bUaLOV r/, p.t]T
aurco /zrjre dAAco, ovk dpcTt) kolI ar/rrj ecrrty r) atropCa; 5
MEN. 4>atVerat. 212. Ovbev dpa /LtdAAoy 6 tropos tS>v
TOLOVTOiv dyaOGtv r) r) diropCa dperr) dv etrj, dAAd, co? colkcv,
o p.(v dv p.erd SiKatocrrjVrj? yCyvqraL, apeTr) Zo-Tai, b
av dvev Trdvrcov t&v tolovtoov, Ka^Ca. MEN. Aokci pot 79

dvayKalov etvaL cb? Aeyet?.
C 3 aA?jflj B T F : aA7j0ws W C4 e5 Ktyots BT W f : e3 \4yois

rb b: \eyoi/M F C5 ehai BTW:
om. F sed pal ante 670)76
c6 /cal xP vffl0V k.t.X. Menoni primus tribuit Sehrwald c8 \4yeis
BT W Aeyei tis F
: d 2 aper-fi iffTLv B T iaTiv apeTk F W :
d 3 fiaffiKfus T F &t\fws B W irpoffriQels F

: irpoffTi6rj s B t : :
ttpooTiQy\s T W
d4 tovto F (suprascr. jroC t'i ut videtur f) ti
W
:
Tovr<fi B T W
irot; toutcj) Schanz
: d 6 auTct B T F out6 :
Schneider secl. Ast d 7 'AAAct Kaniav Socrati et ITayTcos Sîrou

W
:
Menoni primus tribuit Hirschig StjttouBTF: 5r)iru> d8 5<-

Kaiocrvvr\v T t) W
F 8icaiO(Tw> B : e 8 ac B T W ctf 8$i F :
79a nAATX2N02
212. Ovkovv Tovrcav K.ao~Tov okiyov irpoTepov p.6piov
aperrjs e<pap.ev eTvaL, Tr)v bLKaLoavvtfv koX auxppoavvrjv Kal
5 irdvTa tcl Toiavra;

MEN. Nai'.
2X2. ETra, Si Mevoov, TraiêLs irpos p.e;
MEN. Tt brj, 2) 2coKpares;

212. "Ort apTL ep.ov berjOevros aov p.r) mrayvvvai pvqbe
io Kipp.aTi(eiv Tr)v apeTf)v, Kal bovTos Trapabeiyp.ara Ka9' a 8e'ot
diroKpiveaQaL, tovtov p-ev r)p.ekr)aas, keyeis be p.0L otl dpeTi)

b kaTLV oTov t eTvaL TayaOa TropiêadaL p.eTa bLKaLoavvqs'
tovto be <pfjs p,6pLov aperrjs eTvai;
MEN. 'Eycoye.
212. Ovkovv o-vp./3aLveL e 3>v av op.okoyets, ro juiera
5 p.opiov dperfjs irpaTTCLV otl &v 7rpaTTr), tovto dperrjv elvaL'

rr)v yap bLmLoavvrjv p.6pL0v (f>f)s dpeTrjs eTvai, ml emara
tovtohv. t'l ovv br) tovto keyco; otl ep.ov berjdevTOS okov
elirelv tt)v dpenjv, avrrjv p.ev irokkov beis efaelv otl eariv,
iraaav be (pfis irpa^LV dpeTr)v elvai, kavirep p.eTa pLopiov
C aperrjs TrpaTTrjTaL, wairep elprjKm otl dperr) earLv to okov
Kal rjbrj yv(oaop.evov ep.ov, Kal eav av mTaKepp.aTiQr)S avTr)v
Kara p.6pLa. 8etrat ovv aoL Trdkiv e ap\rjs, a>? ep.ol boKet,
Tr}s avrrjs epooTrjaeays, S> (pike Mevoav, ri earLV dperr], et
5 juera p.opiov dperrjs iraaa Trpa&s apeTr) &v etr); tovto yap
eaTLV keyeLV, oto.v keyr) tls, otl iraaa r) pLera bLmLoavirqs
Trpa^LS apeTT) eaTLv. r) ov boKel aoL TrdkLV belaOai rrjs
avTrjs epcorrjaeoos, aAA' otet tlvcl elbevaL p.6pL0V dpeTrjs otl

eariv, avrqv p.r) elbora;
a 9 (rov /xi) T WF : aov 6 fiij B (sed supra 6 add. rov rec. b)

aio Seoi BTW: Se? F bi t'BTW: om.F b 2 fx6piov
aperiis BT W : aperrjs /xoptov F ta 4 Tb T F b to B W b 7 ri :
odv Sii rovro \(yu Socrati primus continuavit Heusde S\ov BT

WF (sed 7] supra W) e a <rv B T W F <roi 03 nara
W W
:
BT : om. F Se7rat B : 5e? ti F : Se? T 04 el corr. Par.

1812 : )/ BWF: |T C5 touto . . . C7 iariv secl. Nabcr
C6 eo-Tii' \4yeiv B : io-ri \4yeiv TW : tri \4yeiv F: &pa \tyei Schanz
MENI2N 79C
MEN. Ovk e/xotye Sokci. io
2X2. Et yap koX pipvqcraL, or' eyw trot aort aireKpi.vdp.riv d

7repi tov arx/ipaTos, aTrej3dkkopiv ttov rr)v ToiavTrpj aito-
Kpio-iv ti)v 8ta tS>v eVt Qf]Tovp.4vo3V koX prjirca o>pokoyr)p.ivoiv
TTt\ipovcrav diTOKpivicrOai.
MEN. Kal opOQs ye a7re/3dAAojotei>, o> 2a>Koares. 5
212. Mt) toCvvv, o> dpttrre, p.r)he crv ert t^roupeVjjs dperrjs
oArjs otl eoriy otou 8td tG>v Tavrtis p.op(o>v aTTOKpi.v6p.evos
brjko>cr(LV avrr)v 6t<j>ovv, ij akko otlovv tovto> tQ> avrto

rpoTTio kiya>v, dkka Trdkiv rrjs avrfjs berjcrecrOaL epconjo-etos, e
rtVos ovtos dperrjs Ae'yets a Ae'yets* 1] oibiv croi Dok5>
keyeiv;
MEN. "Epioiye Sokcis opd&s Aeyeiv.
2X2. 'ATTOKpivai tolvvv Trdkiv e ap\rjs' tl cpfis dperTjy 5
eiVat Kai crb Kal 6 eratpds o-oi>;
MEN. *i2 2toKpares, i)kovov pkv iyo>ye Trplv kol crvyye-

vicrQai croL otl crv ovbev akko r) avros re a7ropeis Kat tovs 80
dAAous Troiets aTTOpeXv Kat vvv, 6>s yk p.oL 8oKets, yor/reuets
jue Kat tpapp-drrets kol aTtyvGis Kare7ra8ets, o>ctt petrrov

aTToptas yzyovivai. kol SoKets p.01 TravTtk&s, et 8et rt Kat
o-Kwrât, ojuotoraros etyat to re ei8os Kat raAAa Tavrrj rrj 5
7rAareta vdpKrj Tr) OakaTTLq.' Kal yap avrr) t6v dei 7rArjo-td-
(ovra Kai aTTr6p.evov vapKav 7rotet, Kai crv 8oKets p.ot vvv epe
tolovtov tl TTTTOirjK4vaL, [vapKav]' aki)0&s yap eycoye Kat
rr)v \\rvyr\v koX to ordpa vapKo>, Kal ovk e^to ort d7roKpiVcopat b
0-01. Katrot pvpidKLS ye 7repi dperrjs 7rap.7ro'AAovs Adyous
etpr/Ka Kai 7rpds 7roAAovs, Kai Trdvv v, cos ye epaurco iboKovv
vvv 8e ov8' ort eoriz; to TrapdTrav e^to et7retf. Kat /uot 8oKets
eS fiovkevecrOaL ovk eK7rAeW ivOtvbe ov8' diToo'r)p.G>v' et 5
d1 BT
8t' W : 6Vt F ipn T Wd 2 cwre-
: om. BF
fidWofjLti/ BT W : oirejSaAo/uej/ F BT d5 aii(fid\\ofiev W :
aTTf/SaAXrf/xTjy F d 7 Iotj oJbu F Vtjj/ ov B ô-Tt o~v T 1'o'Tti'

W W
: : :
o-u twv B T f Tt'i' (ut videtur) F a 2 7 /*o B 7'

W
: :
e/uol T : tfwiye F a 8 vapKav secl. Dobree b 1 arSfia

BT W : ffiatxa F awoKplvwfiat B T airoKplvofxat F : W

8ob IIAATX2N02
yap evos ev dkkr\ nokeL Totavra ttoloIs, tu^ av cos yorjs
dTray6eLr]s.
2X2. Ylavovpyos et, co Meviov, ical okiyov eîraTrjo-ds p.e.
MEN. Tt /xdAiora, co 2coK/>are?;

C 212. Yiyv<ao~Ku> ov eveKa /xe r/Kacra?.
MEN. TtW br) 0U1;

r
2X2. lva cre <xvTiKao~a). eyco 8e tovto olba irepl irdvT(t>v
t&v KakQtv, otl yatpovo-t,v eiKa(6p.evoL Ayo-ireAei yap avrols'
5 KaAat yap ot/xat t5>v Kak&v ko.1 al eUoves dAA' ovk
dyretKao-ojuat o-e. eyco be, et fxev r) vdpKi) avrr) vapKGxra
ovto) Kal tovs dAAous 7roteT vapmv, eoiKa avrrj' et 8e /xr/,
ov. ov yap eviropaiv ovtos rovs dkkovs ttolG> drropelv, dkkd

iravTos piakkov avrds aTTopG>v otrrcos Ka\ tovs aAAons 770110
d diropuv. KaX vvv irepl dperrjs 6 eaTir eyco p.ev ovk otoa, (tv
pevroL tcrcos TrpoTepov piev rjbr)(rda irplv ep.ov axj/ao-dai, vvv
p.evroL op.OLOs et ovk eiboTL. o/xcos oe e6ek( p.eTa aov
o"Ke\/rao"0at koi o-vCr)Tr](raL otl iroTe ecrTLV.
5 MEN. Kat TiVa Tporrov CyTWeLs, co 2co Kpare?, tovto o

p.r) oto-da to TTapaTTav otl eoriv; 7roiW ydp &v ovk oTada
Trpodep.evos Crrrr/o-ets; r) et Kat ort /xdAto-ra kvTX>x.OLS ovtG>,
-
7rco? eta ?/ ort tovto Zvtlv o crv ovk rjbr](r6a;
e 212. Maz^drco otoy /3orJAet keyeLV, > Mevo>v. opas
tovtov cos epLo-TLKdv koyov KardyeLS, co? ovk dpa emLv
Cf]Telv dvdp(j>TT<s> ovre o oTbe ot/re b p.r) oTbe; ovre yap dv
6 ye otoer (^rot olbev ydp, Kat ovbev Set rco ye rotorjrco
5 C]Tr](Te<x)s ovre o p.i] otbev ovbe yap otbev otl (frjr?/o-et.
81 MEN. Ovkovv KaAcos o-ot 8oKet keyeadaL 6 koyos ovtos,

o> 2coK/5are?;
2X2. Ovk e/xotye.
MEN. "Excts Aeyety 07rr?;
02 8)1 TF: 8e BW e6 BTF: ' t, W ds toCto

BTW: om. F d6 ^ B T W: Sn F S : Ast d8 BTW:
in-tvo b F 62 irapa.-yets Buttmann e3 otirt yap BT W :
ol5 yap F e4 '6 y- o75f F Stobaeus : 76 6 o/5e' BT W ra> ye

BTWf: om. F
.
MENI2N 8ia
2X2. "Eycoye* uKi]Koa yap avbpQ>v re Kal yvvaiK&v crocp&v 5

Trepl tcl 0eta irpdyp.aTa
MEN. TCva koyov AeyoVrcov;
2X2. 'AAtj^, e/xotye Sokuv, Kal Ka\6v.
MEN. Tu>a tovtov, Kal TLves 01 keyovres;
2X2.^01 piev KeyovTes etVt t&v lepecov re /cat rcoz> lepei&v 10
6V019 p.ep.ekr]Ke irepl <ov p.Ta\Lpi(j>VTai koyov oXols r* etrat
8t8oVar Aeyet 8e xat IIii>8apos Kat dAAot iroAAot t>v TroLrjT&v b
6V01 êtot elcrLV. a be keyovcrLV, ratrrt eori/r akkd o-KoVet
et o-ot SoKoiVtr akrjdfj keyeLV. <pacrl yap ttjv yf/vxqv tov
avdp<0TT0v elvaL addvarov, Kal tot piev Tekevrdv o 8?/
aTTO0vt]crKLV mkovcrL tot be TTakiv yiyvea-QaL, cmoWvcrQaL 5
8 ovbeiroTe' beiv 8?/ 8td Tavra &>? dVtcorara 8ta/3ico>ai tov

[Slov oIctlv yap av
<&epcre<p6va ttolvclv TrakaLov irevdeos

8e'<ferat, els Tovy virepOev oXlov Keivcov eVdrco eret
avbLboi \j/v\ds irdkLV, 10
K Tav fiacrikrjes ayavol C

Kat CT0VL KpaLTTVoX CTOCpiq. T p.yL(TT0L
dvbpes avôvT' es be tov Xolttov yjpovov rjpooes ayvol
rrpbs av0pa>TT(ov mkevvrai.
"At ovv r) \f/vx)] d0dvaTos re ovcra Kal TrokkaKLs yeyovvia, 5
Kat eoopaKvla ml tcl ev0dbe Kal Ta ev "At8ou Kat 7rdi>ra
XpjjpaTa, ovk ecrTLv otl ov p.ep.d0r)KV cocrre ovbev 0avp.acrTbi'

Kal irepl dpeTrjs ml irepl dkkcov olov t etvaL avTr]v dvapwi]-
a 10 re BTF: om. W
olois BF: an oT6s T: oToi W
b 7 oTcriv yap av sermoni Platonico accommodata : oTai 8e Pindaro
reddidit Boeckh b9 StcJeTOi BTWf: $(t,r)Tai F Stobaeus
tls BT WF is Stobaeus netvwu BT Ktivov W F (Ktivuv
W (coniecerat
: : :
(Tti ?WF Stobaeus en : BT b 10 xf/vxas

Boeckh) tyvxav BTf tyvxav F: tyvxa Stobaeus c tRv 1 f Tct^
BTW
: :
W
:
B : rav T : ruv : rav F C2 aotpiq F : aoipiav

C 3 aCôvr' Boeckh : adôvrai BT WF ayvol BTW F : ayavol
C4 Ka\tvvTat BTW: KaXfovrai F C6 /col ito^to j
irdvTa
Struve
8ic IIAAT12N02
crOrjvaL, d ye Kal TrpoTepov r)TrLOTaTO. dYe yap rrjs cpvoeuis
= d airdcrr)S o~vyyevovs ovot)S, ko.1 p.ep.adr)Kvias Trjs \ffVXVS d-rravTa,
ovbev KtoXijH V p.6vov dvapLvr)oOevTa o br) p.ddr)o-Lv koXovolv

avOpctiiroi. TaAAa 7raWa ovtov dvevpelv, edv tls avbpelos r)
Kal p.r) aTTOKap,vr) (j)tG>v' to yap 0)Telv apa kol to p.av8dveLv

5 avdpLvrfcns oXov Icttlv. ovkovv bel 7ret0eo-0at tovt<o tG>
kpLOTLKG) Xoycd' ovtos p.ev yap av rjpJds apyovs TroLr)creLev
koX cttlv Tot? p.aXaKo\s tG>v dvdpcairaiv r)bvs aKOvoai, dbe
e 8e epyaTLKOvs T Kal Cr)Tr)TiKovs 7rotet' S eya> irio-Tevaiv
dXr)8eZ elvaL e6eX.(a p.eTa o~ov {j)Tlv dperr) otl ea-TLvJ

MEN. Nat, u> 2toKoaTes' dAAd tt&s Aeyets tovto, otl oi/
p.avddvop.ev, dXXa rjv KaXovp.ev p.ddr)CTLV dvdp.vr)crLS ecrTLv;
5 exeis jae tovto 8t8dat a>s ovtcos ^X L >

212. Kai dpri eLirov, S) Mevcov, otl iravovpyos el, kol
82 vvv epaiT&s et )(&> cre 8t8dai, os ov cpr)p.L 8t8a^y eivat
dAA' dvdp.vr)crLV, Xva br) evdvs qbaCvcop.aL avrbs ep.avTG>
rdvavTLa Xeycav.
MEN. Ov jad tov Ata, S 2a>KpaTes, ov Trpbs tovto
5 f3Xe\}ras et7roy, dAA' virb tov edovs' dAA' et 7xa>s /uot ^X as
evbeiâcrdaL otl ^x L <2oTrep Ae'yets, ez;8eiai.
212. 'AAA' eart p.ev ov pabiov, opa>s be edeXoi Trpodvp.r)-
drjvaL crov eveKa. dXXd p.01 irpocrKdXeoov tG>v ttoXXG>v
b aKokov6(av Tovrcavl tG>v cravTov eva, ovTiva /3ovAet, tva ev

tovtu ctol e7rt8eta>pat.
MEN. Yldvv ye. bevpo irpocreXde.

212. "EAA^y p.ev eart kol eAAr/ytêtj
5 MEN. Udvv ye crcpobpa, olKoyevqs ye.
d 4 airoKdfivT) B F : airoKdfirj T W(sed suprascr. i/TW) Stobaeus

d 5 ireldeadai B F W iricrBai T : suprascr. f
'dirfcrdat d 7 %<rri{v)
W
:
B T F eri W 6 1 ipyartKovs T F ipyaarriKovs B

: w
W
:
62 a\ri9ei BTW : oAtj0j} F e$ 3> BTF: om. a\\a

irws F Stobaeus : a\\' air\S>s BTW e$ fie TWF : fiera B
a5 a\\' ei irws~\ in marg. a\\' elires f a8 'iveKev BTWF
irpoaKdXeaov BTF : irpoo~Ka\eaai W bi fV rovrw croi B W : iv
rovrwl ffot T rovrw F
aot iv b2 iirtdei^wfjtai BT WF : ivSei^w/jtat
W
:
Naber b 5 ê alterum add. F : om. BT

MEN12N 82b
212. Tlpoo-eyc br) tov vovv oiroTep &v ctol (paivqraL, f)
dvap.Lp.vr)crK6p.evos rj p.av6dvoiV irap epov.

MEN. 'AAAci Trpoaigco.
212. Eiire br) pot, a> 7rat, yiyvoio-KeLs Terpdyoivov yjnpiov
otl tolovtov eo-Tiv; -11 AI.

v
Ey&>ye. 212.
v
Eotu> ovv 10
TfTpaycovov yoipiov Xcras eyov tols ypap.p.ds ravras irdo-as, C
TtTTapas ovaas; IIAI. Yldvv ye. 2X2. Ov Kal TavTacrl
ras 8ta p.ecrov eorlv to-ay eyov; ITAI. Nat. 2X2. Ov-
kovv eir) av tolovtov yoipiov koX p.ei(flv koX ekaTTov;
riAI. Wdw ye. 212. Et ovv eXr) avrr) r) Trkevpa bvoiv 5
iroboiv Kal avTrj bvoiv, iroo-oiv hv eXr) irobGtv to okov; &be
be o-KoVet* et rjv ravTr) bvoiv iroboiv, ravTr) be evos Trobbs
p.6vov, dkko tl diraf; av r\v bvoiv iroboiv to yoipiov; ITAI.
Nat. 212. 'Eiret&T) 8e bvoiv iroboiv Kal ravrr/, dkko tl r) d
bls bvoiv yiyverai; ITAI. Ttyyerat. 212. Avoiv dpa bls
yiyverai irobSiv; ITAI. Nat. 212. IToVot ovv elo-LV 61 bvo

bls TTobes; koyLcrdp.evos elire. ITAI. TeVrapes, 2wKparey.
212. Ovkovv yivoLT b\v tovtov tov yoopiov erepoi/ biirkd- 5
o-lov, tolovtov be, Xcras eyov irdcras ras ypap.p.as <2o-7rep
tovto; ITAI. Nat. 212. Uocroiv ovv eorat iroboiv; ITAI.

'Oktw. 212. 4>e'pe br), 7reipG> p.0L ei-rreiv irrpXiKr) tls eorat
eKeivov r) ypap.p.r) eKacrn). i) piev yap Tovbe bvoiv iroboiv tl e
be r) eKeivov tov bLirkacriov; ITAI. Arjkov brj, S 2a>Kpares,
ort 8t7rAao-ta.
212. 'Opay, S> Mevoov, oos eyoo tovtov ovbev bLbdo-KOi,

dAA' epo)T<a irdvTa; kol vvv ovtos oterat elbevaL oiroia eoTiy 5
d</>' rjs t6 oKTOiirovv yjiopiov yevrjacTaL' r) ov boKei o~oi',
MEN. "Ep.oiye.
212. Olbev ovv;
b6 ^l el Ast c 7 î/ F (coniecerat F. A. Wolf) ^BTW :
iroSoiV BT W : om. F d. 3 yiyverai iroS&y BT W iroSoiV yiyverat

W W
:
F d6 roiovrov BT : rovrov F d8 tisBTF: ti

tarat BTW: tffriv F 64 rovrov B F towtwpTW
: e6 ^s
BT W : ffs irov F OKrwirovv BTF : oKrdirovv W

82e nAATHNOS
MEN. Ov 8r/ra.
io 212. Oterat be ye ctaro ti)s 8t7rAacrtas;
MEN. Nat.
212. 0eco 8r/ arjroy avap.ip.vrjcrK6p.evov ec/>er/s, cos 8et
dva/>itjLiV7]crKecrt?ai.
2rj 8e' pot Ae'ye' airb rrjs 8t7rAacrtas ypap/xr/s c/jrys ro

83 bnrXdcnov xcopcov yiyveo~6at.; Toiovbe Ae'yco, p.r) rarjYr/ peij
fxaKpov, rrj be ftpayy, aXka Xcrov iravTayr) ecrrco tocnrep tovtl,
8t7rAdcrioJj 8e rojjroi;, o/crco7row dAA' dpa et ert crot a7ro rr)s
8t7rAacrias 80/cet eaecrOai.. OAI. "Epotye.' 212. Ojjkojjj'
5 8t7rAacria avrrj ravTrjs yCyverai, av erepav Too-avrriv irpocr-
6wp.ev evOevbe; HAI. Ylavv ye. 2X2. 'Atto Tavrrjs 8?/,
cpr/s, ecrrat to oktcottovv ya>piov, av Terrapes Too-avrai
b yevcovrat; ITAI. Nat. 212.

,
Avaypa\jfu>p.eOa br) a7r' av-
rr/s tcras TtTTapas. aAAo rt r) tovtI av etr/ o cpr/s to oktcottovv
etvat; IIAI. IIdz;jj ye. 212. Ovkovv ev avrS> eartv rarjrt
T&TTapa, 3>v e/cacrroy tcroy rojjrco ecrTtv rco rerpa7ro8t;
5 riAI. Nat. 212. ndaw ovv ytyverat; ov reTpaKts too~ov-

tov; IIAI. ITcos 8' orj; 212. At7rAdcriojj ojjjj eVrtJJ ro
Terp&Kts too-ovtov; IIAI. Ojj pd Ata.' 212. 'AAAd iroaa-
irXacrtov; IIAI. TerpairAdcnojj. 212. Âiro rr)s 8t7rAacrias
C apa, S> 7rat, orj 8t7rAdcrtOJj dAAd rerpa7rAdcrt0JJ ytyverat yobptov.
HAI. 'AArjc^r/ Ae'yets. 212. TerrdpcoJj ydp rerpd/cts ecrrtj'
eKKatSeKa. 019(1; ITAI. Nat. 212. 'OKrcoTrojjjj 8' a7rd 7rotas

ypap/xr/s; orj^t a7rd piev rajjrrrs TeTpairX&o-tov; IIAI. <f>rip.t.
5
.
212. Terpa7roujj 8e a7rd rr]s r)p.io-eas TGLVTr)cr\ tovtl; IIAI.
Nat. 212. Etev rd- 8e dKrco7rot>jj ov rovbe piev bnrXaatov
ecrrtr, tovtov be r/ptcrjj;
(IIAI. Nat.) 212. Ojjk a7rd ptev
p.ei(ovos earat r) Tocravr-qs ypap/xr/s, a7rd eX&TTOvos 8e r/
e 12 avafj.i/j.vri(TK6fx.evop BT W ava/j.tfjLvriaKo/j.evos F a 1 ravrri

W
:
BT W : rairriv F a3 oKrdirovv BTF : oKTairovv (et mox a 7,

b 2, C 3, C 6) b4 tovtcj) Io~t\v T W : tovt^ ip Iotiv B iar\ :
Tovra F C3 oi>xi BTW: } ovx't F C5 reTpdirovv Cornarius :
TerapTov BTW
F ri/Ato-fas BTF : ^refas B 2
W C7 vai add.
corr. Par. 1812 om. : BTWF
MEN12N 83 d
Tocrt]crhC; r) ov; II AI. "E/xotye 8oKet ovroi. 212. KaAcds 1

d
to ydp ool hoKovv tovto diroKpivov. KaC p.0L Ae'ye* ov\ r/8e
pkv hvolv iroholv r)v, r/ 8e rerrdpcoTj; IIAI. Nat. 212.

Aet dpa Ti]v tov OKTunrohos yoapiov ypap.p.i]V //etco piev tlvai
TTJo-he rr/s hiTiohos, eAdrrco 8e tt)s TeTpdiTohos. I7AI. Aet. 5

212. Iletpco 8r/ Aeyetz' TTi]XiKT]v TLvd <pr)s avTijv etmt. e
riAI. Tpiiroha. 212. Ovkovv dvrrep Tpiirovs r), to r)p.Lcrv
ravrrjs 7rpoo-Ar/\//o'//.e(9a Kat ecrrat Tpiirovs; hvo p.ev yap ot'8e,
o 8e ets 1
Kal (v0h'he cWarJrcos hvo p*v ot8e, 6 8e els
Kat
ytyyerat tovto to \oipiov b cpr)s. II AI. Nat. 212. Ovkovv 5
dv fi
rrjhe rpL&v xat rf/8e rpicoy, to dXov yoipiov TpL&v rpls
noh&v yiyveTaL; IIAI. 4>aiverat. 212. Tpels 8e Tpls ttoctol
etat 7rd8es; ITAI. 'Ewea. 212.
v
E8et 8e to 8t7rAdcrtoy
TTocroiv elvaL Troh&v; I7AI. 'Oktco. 212. Or38' dp aTro rr/s
rpiTTohos TTOi to oKTOiTTow \oipiov yiyverai. I7AI. Ov hfJTa. 10

212. 'AAA' aird Troias; ?retpw r)p.lv et7reu> aKpt/3<3s* Kat
et fir) /3ovAet apLOfxzLv, dAAa helov dird iroias. I7AI. 'AAAd 84
/xd tov Ata, oi 2coKpares, eycoye ovk olha.
212. 'Ewoets av, 00 MeVcoi>, ov Icttlv r/8r/ (iahifav 6'8e
tov avap.Lp.vrio-Kio-daL; otl to fxkv irpGiTov r/8et fxkv ov, r/r ts
errrty r) tov oKTOiTrohos yoipiov ypafXfXT], &cnrep ovh\ vvv iroi 5

ot8e;j, dAA' ovv coerd y avri]v tot et8eVai, Kat dappaXcois
direKpiveTo cos et8cos, Kat o?jx rjycLTo aTropelv vvv 8e r/yetrat
aTTopclv r/8r/, Kat oicnrep ovk oThev, ovh' oterat etSeVat. b
MEN. 'AAr/c9r/ Aeyets.
212. OvKorjy vvv /3e'Artoy eêt Trepl to Trpdy\ia ovk
f/8et;
MEN. Kat tovto /xot 8oKet. 5

212. 'A7ropeti' ovv avrdv 7rotr/o-ayres Kat vapKav &o-irep r)
vdpKT], fxS>v tl e/3Adâ/xer;
di ToffijaSL BTWf: roo-rjoSe F d3 V BTW: om. F

e4 6 5e (bis) BTW: 6Se 8 F e6 rph TWF: rpe7s B
e 7 rpus BT W rpls F e 1 1 BT
&7ro 7rotoy W
d7rot'as F a 4 oi/
W
: :
B T o5j/ F a6 7 outV B TauT7jfTWF a7 airtKpivtro

W
: :
BT f : airtKptvaro F is BTWf;on).F
84b ITAATX2N02
MEN. Ovk euotye 8o*ei.
2X2. Upovpyov yovv tl TreTTOLf}Kap.ev, &>s eotKe, irpbs rb
10 efcevpelv ottt) ?x 6t * P*" 7aP KCtt Cr) T'H <Tei * v av
v ^v ovk êW
eibois, Tore 8e pqbiois av Kal Trpbs iroXXovs Kal iroXXaKLS
C coer' ai> ev XeyeLV 7rept to{5 8t7rAacriotj yjapiov, <ws 8et 8i7rAacHav
7-771 ypap.p.r)v Z\eLV /ixjjKet.
MEN. "Eot/cey.
2X2. Otei oSy ay auroi; Trporepov eiTLyeLprjo-aL (/iTelv 7)
5 p.av6dveiv tovto b coero etSeVat ovk etfiws, 7rot> ets diropiav

KaTeireo-ev r)yr}aafxevos ut) etSeVat, Kat eir60r)o-ev to elbevai;
MEN. Ov uot boKeX, aj 2coKoares.

212. "lvr)To apa vapKr)o-as;
MEN. AoKet uot.
10 2X2. 2Ke'ât br) eKravrrjs rrjs diropias otl Kal dvevpr]o-eL
(rjT&v p.er ep.ov, ovbev dAA' r\ epoirooVTOs ejxov kol qv 8t8d-

d o-ji ovTos; c/wAarre 8e dv ttov evprjs ue StSdcrKoyra Kat
StetftoVra avT(o, dXXd ut) ras tovtov boas dvepoiT&vra.
Aeye ydp jxol o~v' ov to fxev TeTpdirow tovto r)[XLV ecrrt
ytopLov; [xavddveis; ITAI. "Eycoye. 2X2. "Ereooy 8e avr&

5" irpoo-OelpLev av tovtI lo-ov; ITAI. Nat. 2X2. Kat Tpirov
Tobe Xa-ov eKarepoi tovtojv; IIAI. Nat. 2X2. Ovkovv
^Tpooâva^TXr)poio-aip.e$
,
av rb ev Tr) yoiviq Tobe; ITAI.
Yldvv ye. 2X2.
v
AAAo rt ovv yevoLT av Terrapa foa yoopia
e ra8e; ITAI. Nat. 2X2. Tt ovi>; ro oAoi ro'8e 7rocra7rAdcrioy
rovbe yiyveTai; TTAI. Teroa7rAdcrtoz\ 2X2.

v
E8et 8e ye
bLTrXdcrLov r)pXv yeveorOaL' r) ov p.ep.vrjo-aL; ITAI. Yldvv ye.
2X2. Ovkow eortv avrr) ypafxfxr) K yoivias eis yoiviav
85 [rti/a] Tep.vovo~a biya eKao-rov TOVTOiv t&v yoipioiv; ITAI.

Nat. 2X2. Ovkovv reVrapes aurat yiyvovrai ypap.p.al tcrat,
b 10 ^5os BT W f : #5rj F c 6 rb B T f et supra versum W :
tF CiiouBTW: om. F d 2 rovrov F (sed uv W

suprascr. f ) : rovroav BT e 2 rovSe B T W
rovrov F : ye F :
om. BTW ai wiBTWF: secl. Schleiermacher rtivovaa :
corr. Par. 181 1 Cornarius (cf. 85 b4) avriav Wex

:

MENX2N 8sa
7reote'xo?Jcrai tovtI to \oopCov; IIAI. TLyvovTai ydp. 212.
Skoitcl brj' TTrjXUov tC Zotiv tovto to yapCov; II AI. Ov
p.av0dvoa.- 212. Oi)(l TerrdpoiV ovtwv tovtojv rjp.Lcrv kKacrTOV 5
eKaarrj r) ypap.p.r) a.TroTTp,r)KV ivros; r/ HAI. Nat.

ov;
2X2. Ilocra ovv rqkiKavra iv tovtu eveo-TLv; IIAI. TtTrapa.
2X2. IloVa Se iv ra>8e; IIAI. Avo. 212. Td 8e rirTapa
tolv bvolv tC ccttlv;' TIAI. At7rAdcria. 212. To'8e ovv
TTOcrdTTOvv yiyvfxai; ITAI. 'OKTcaTrovv. 2X2. 'A7r6 7rotas b
ypap.p.rj$; IIAI. 'A7r6 ravTrjs. 2X2. 'A7r6 Trjs ex ycavCas
ets yoovCav TCLVovcrrjs tov rerpa7ro8os; IIAI. Nat.- 2X2.

KaAoScrtv bi ye TavTrjv bidpLCTpov ol ao^tcrrat' coor' et TavTjj
bidp.(Tpos 6vop.a, aTtb Trjs 8ta/xe'rooi> dv, &s crv (pfjs, S) 7rat 5
M4vu>vos, yCyvoLT av to 8t7rAdcaoi> ya>pCov. IIAI. Ildif

pikv ovv, & 2a>Koares.
2X2. Tt crot SoKet, ai MeVaw; eorir rjvTLva boav ov\
avrov ovtos dirtKpCvaTo;
MEN. Ovk, dAA' kavrov. C
2X2. Kat p.r]v ovk r/8et ye, cos ec/>a/ixev dkCyov TrpoTepov.
MEN. 'AAtiOt/ Aeyets.
2X2. 'Evrjcrav bi ye avrai aSrat at boaL' r) ov;

MEN. Nat. 5
2X2. Ta> ovk et8o'rt dpa trnpl &v hv p.r) dbfj evetaty
dkrjOds boaL 7rept tovtojv &v ovk otbe;
MEN. <J>atWai.
2X2. Kat vvv p.iv ye avT<o cocr7rep ovap aprt dvaKKCvr)VTai
al boaL avrat* et 8e avrov tls drepTjcrerat 7roAAdKts rd avrd io
Tavra /cai 7roAAax$, o?cr0' otl reAeuraiy ovbevbs tjttov dKpt/3a>s

t7rtcrr?7crerai 7reot tovtojv. d
MEN. 'EotKer.
a 3 ydp F : om. BT W b3 rov BT WF : t?s f b 4 &<rr >
e? BT W f S(tt F b6 yiyvoir' ivBT (sed post av ras. in B) :
W
:
yiyvtr av : yiyvoiro F c6 eiS?} tvttffiv BTWfi u$t?fv tio~\v

C 7 irepl . o75e secl. Schleiermacher 8>v olSe secl.
W
. : . . .
Schanz c 10 avrat BT f :om. F avtpfio-irai T W ; av

ip{\atrat, BF
85 d FIAATX2N02
2X2. Qvkovv ovbevbs bibaavTos dAA' epw>Tr\cravTos (ttl-
crrr/crerat, dva\a(3o)v avrbs ef avrov rr\v kTTLo-Ti\\xr\v;
5 MEN. Nat.
2X2. Td 8e dva\ap.j3dvLV ai)Tov kv avrco iTTLO-Trifj.r]v ovk
dvafXLfxvpo-KecrdaL Zcttlv;
MEN. Udvv ye.
212. 'Ap' ovv ov rr\v e7rtcrr7/pr/i>, rjv vvv ovtos e'xet, t\tol
io e'Aa/3eV ttotc rj det etxey;

MEN. Nat'.
2X2. Ovkovv et p.~kv det eixer, det Kat r\v e7rlcrrr7/xco^>

,
et
8e eAa/3eV 7rore, ov/c dv er ye rco iw /3t'cp etAr/c/xbs etr/. r/
e 8e8t'8axeV rts rouroy yeco//.erpetr; ovros ydp 7rotr/cret 7rept
Trdcrr\s yeco/*erpi'as ravrd rafira, Kat rcoy dXka>v p.a6r\fj.aT0)V
dirdvTOiv. to-TLv ovv ootls tovtov Trdvra 8e8t'8axei>; 8i'kios
ydp 7rou et ei8eVat, dAAcos re e7rei8r) eV rrj crr/ otKta yeyovev
5 /cat re'0pa7rrat.
MEN. 'AAA' ot8a eycoye ort ov8ets 7rco7rore e8t'8aei\

v
2X2. Exet 8e ravras rds 8das, r/ ovyi;
MEN. 'ArdyKr/, 2> 2coKpares, cpatferat.
2X2. Et 8e \xr\ iv rco i>w /3i'cp Kaf3(ov, ovk r/8r/ rouro
86 brjXov, drt ev dAAco rtpt xpovu* etxf Kat e/ue/xac9r/Ket;
MEN. *atWrat.
2X2. Ovkow orjrds ye ecrni> 6 xpovos ot ovk r\v av-
6pa>TTos;
5 MEN. Nat'.
2X2. Et ovv ov t av 17 \povov Kat bv dv \xr) r/ dv6pooTTOs,
eWawrat avrco dAr/flets 8dat, at epcorr/cret e7reyep0etcrai
d 6 oj/oAoMflctVeii' B T ava\a$uv F W d 9 ov B T F om.

: : W
(sed post otv duarum litterarum rasura) d 13 tcJS vvv B T F :
tuc i/u W(sed in ras.) efrj B T r/ F e 1 8e5i5oxe(") W W

W
:
BT W f b-eSlxafiev F
: o&ros B T F : o/'ts e 4 e? B T :
om. F Te B T F t koI : W
e 9 *?5?j scr. recc. IjSu B F :
:
W
775ei T a6 Sv r av Baiter (bv av Cornarius) Srdv B Srav :
T W Stuv F (bis) BTW f om. (bis) F xp^vov] ex v fecit

W
:
: 7}
ii et suprascr. o- rec. f Kal F : ^ koi BT a7 ot ipwTfau

corr. Par. 1812 : o< ipuTô-ets BT WF
MENX2N 86a
e7rtcrr?//xat yiyvovraL, dp ovv rbv det \povov pepadrjKvta
emaL r) \l/vxt] avrov; orjkov yap otl tov itavTa yjiovov (cttlv
T) OVK eCTTLV dvdpaiTTOS. IO
MEN. atzverai.
2X2. Ovkovv et det 17 dA?/<9eta rjplv tu>v ovtu>v ecrrlv ev b

tji ^vxfl, dddvaTos av r) \jrvxv îf], <2crre dappovvra XPV
pr/ Tvyyavus eTTLCTTdp.evos vvv tovto 8' ecrrii; o p.rj p.ep.vr\-
p.evos e7Ttxeipeti' (rjrelv Kal dvap.Lp.vr\crKecr6aL;
MEN. ES p.0L boKels XeyeLV, co 2coKpares, ovk 018' O7rcos. 5

212. Kat yap eyto epot, co MeVcoiv. Kat rd p.ev ye dAAa
ovk av irdvv VTrep tov Xoyov OLLcryypLcraLp.r]V' otl 8' olop.evoi
belv (r/Telv a p.r) tls ot8e<v /3eAriot;s dy etpeTJ /cat dvSptKCo-
repot /cat T/rro^ dpyol r) ei oloip.eda a p.r) e-nL0-Tap.e6a p.r/8e
Suivardf etfat evpeXv p-rjbe belv (rjrelv, 7rept rovrou 7rdw dz> C
bLap.axpip.-qv, et otds re etr/r, Kat Adyco Kat epy<o.
MEN. Kat tovto p.ev ye 8oKet? p.0L ev keyeLv, co 2coKpares.

212. BodAet ovv, e7ret8i) 6p.ovoovp.ev otl (rjTrjTeov irepl
ov p.f) rts ot8e^, e7rtxeipr/crco/xeJJ kolvjj (rjTelv t'l ttot iarlv 5

dpeTf);
MEN. Yldvv p.ev ovv. ov p.evroL, o> 2coKparey, dAA'

eycoye eKetô av 7/8tcrra, 07rep r)p6p.r}v to irpa>Tov, Kal crKeyf/ai-
p.rjv Kat aKO?jcraipi, iroTepov cos 8i8aKrco dWt aurco 8et e7rt-
Xetpetr, r/ cos tpdcret r) cbs rtrt 7rore rpo'7rco TrapayLyvop.evr\s d

roty dv6p<airoLS Trjs dperrjs.
2X2. 'AAA' et /xejv eyco rjpxov, co MeVcoy, p.T/ /xojjot; e/xau-
ro{! dAAa Kat croij, ovk dy ecrK\frdp.e6a Trporepov etre SiKaKrdy

etre ov bLbaKrbv r) dperr/, Trpty ort ecrriv irp&TOV etfT/rr/crapey 5
atird' e7ret8r) 8e cri( craurou piev ou8' e7rtxetpfts apx*w, Xva
a8 oSv] oii Stallbaum b6 y ôf BT W : iywfiai F /cal
BT f W
om. F : b8 olSe^ BT W f : o^S^ F 6?^" BT :
^fj/W: rl^^F bg êJBTwf ^W: : eiF oloi/x.e6a T (sed of

ex emend.') F oUÔa W B aBTWâvF^ caelfrjvBTW:
W
:
^ F c 7 a\\' eywye F : fej' Xf^w 76 B T : &y Xe7<w C8 T)p6p.r\v

BTWf:J|^f d5r/BTW:om. F
PLATO, VOL. III.
27
86 d IIAATX2N02
br) ekevdepos fjs, ep.ov be eiTLxeLpeXs tc apxeLV Kat aPX a? >
avyxoiprjcrop.ai crot rt yap \PV TTOLeiv; eoLKev ovv crKeTTTiov
e eivai ttolov ri Zo-tlv 6 p.f)Troi Xo-p.ev otl ecrTiv. et p,rj tl ovv
akka o~p,LKp6v yi p.oi rrjs dpxrjs yakao~ov, Ka\ o~vy\o)pr)crov
e<f V7ro6io-eoiS avrb aKOirelcrdaL, etre bLbaKTOv Zcttlv etre
ottooo-ovv. kiyoi be rb e virodio-eois <3<5e, &o-rrep ol yeoip.i-
5 TpaL ttoW&kls crKOTTovvTaL, eireLbdv tls eprjTaL avTovs, olov

irep\ yobpiov, el oXov re es rovbe tov kvkXov robe to yoapiov
87 Tpiycovov evraOrjvaL, etrroL av tls otl " Oviroi olba ei ecrTLV
tovto tolovtov, dkk' &crirep p.iv TLva vttoOco-lv irpovpyov

ot/xai ex lv npbs to Trpdyp,a TOLavbe' et p.iv ecrrtv tovto to
X(*>p(ov tolovtov olov irapa rr)v bodelcrav avrov ypap.p.r)v
5 irapaTeivavTa ekkeiireLv rotovra> *ov av o-vrb to

X^pfy
7rapaTTap.ivov fj,
akko tl crvp,fiaiveLV p.0L boKel, Kal dkko
av, ei abvvarov Zo-tlv ravra Tradelv. vTro6ip.evos ovv edikoi
b ei7retz> <rot to o~vp,fiaivov irepl rrjs evrdcreois avrov els rbv
KijKkov, etre dbvvaTov etre p.r]." ovtoj br) Kal irepl dperrjs
fjp.eis, e7ret8j) ovk tcrp,ev ovd' otl eorlv ovff biroiov tl, vtto-
6ep.evoL avrb crKOTrG)p,ev etre bLbaKTov etre ov otSaKrov ecrTiv,
5 <Se Ae'yoi>res* Et 7roioV rt eoru' tS>v 7rept tt)v ^rvxw ovtojv

dperrj, bLbaKTov av etr; r) ov b^baKTOv; irp&TOV p,ev br) et
ecrrtr dAAoibr rj oXov eTTLo-rqpr), apa bLbaKTov r) ov, rj 6

wvbr) ikiyop,ev, avap.vt]crTo'v 8tac/>epe'rco 8e prjbev r)piv
C o7rore'pco av rco 6vop.aTL XP^M e ^ a a a P a bLbaKrov; r) ^'
tovto ye TravTL brjkov, otl ovbev akko bLbdcrKeTaL avdpoiTros
7] eiTLcrTr\p.r\v;
MEN. "Ep.oLye 80/cet.
5 Et bi y
2i2. ecrTLV eTTLorrjpr) tls r) dpeTrj, brjkov otl
bLbaKTov av eXr}.
MEN. n<S<? yap ov;
a5 itapa.Teiva.VTa BT W : vapaTelvovTa F tWelireiv TW F

W
:
4\\iireiv B : eWnreTv B 8
b I BT
ivTacrews ivffTaffeces F
W
:
b6 fiev Si,
f)o6BTWF:
F : fxev BT b 7 aWowv T F W : a.W' otov B
irov Schanz ci *)BTW: e /^F
MENX2N 87 c
2X2. Tovtov ixev dpa ra\v d7TT/AAdy/xe0a, ort rotouSe

OVTOS blbaKTOV, TOiovbc 8' ov.
flCV
MEN. Tldvv ye. IO
2X2. Td br) /zerd tovto, cos eot/ce, 8et o-KtyaaOai TTOTepov

eoriy eTTtor^jurj 7/ dperT/ 77 dAAoioy e7rtcrr77/x77y.
MEN. "Ejuotye 8o*et tovto p.erd roCro <tkttt4ov elvai. d

2X2. Tt 8e 877; dAAo rt r) dyaObv avro <pap.tv etvai rr)v
aptrryv, koL avTT) r) vTrodevis /xeVet r)pxv, dyaObv avrb etrat;

MEN. Udvv p.ev ovv. 2X2. Ovkovv et pAv ri ecmy
dyaObv koX dAAo y&pi(pp.vov kTTi<TTr)p.r)s, rdx dv et77 r) 5
dperf) ovk kiri<rTr)p.r) rts* et 8e p.r)biv 1<ttw dyaObv ovk

7n<rTijp.r) 7repte'xet, 7n<TTrjp.r)v dv rti>' avrd v7ro7rre7Jorres eu>ai
dptfcos VTToirTevotpiev. MEN. "Eort Kat raura. 2X2. p.r)v
dperT/ y kapfcv dyaOoi; MEN. Et Nat. 2X2. 8e dyaOoi, e

d)<piA).p.oi' TtdvTa ydp TdyaOd MEN. Nat. <j><pkip.a. oi>xi;
2X2. Kat i) dperr) MEN.

87/ co<pe'Atp.o'y <ttw; 'AvdyKrj
Zk t<2v cop.oAoyrjp,eVcoi\
2X2. 2Ke\j>cofte0a br) Kacf e/cacrroy dva\ap.fidvovT$ irotd 5
eo-rty a 7/pds cocpeAet. vyteta, <pap.iv, kol l<rxvs /cat KaAAos

Kat ttXovtos Stj* raCra Ae'yo/jtei> /cat rd roiaira cocpe'Ai/Aa.
oti^t; MEN. Nat. 2X2. Tavra 8e raurd <pajuez> einore 88

xat fiXdiTTeiv r) <rv dAAcos <pf)s 7/ o?3rco?; MEN. Ovk, dAA'
otjVco?. 2X2. 2fco7ret 87/, draz> rt efcdo-rou tovtoov
1
rryrjTai,
cocpeAet r)p.as, Kal orav ri, /3Aa7rret; dp ovy^ orav piev opOi)
Xpr)<ris, cocpeAet, orav 8e //7/, /3Aa7rret;' MEN. Ildw; ye. 5

y
2X2. Ert roivvv koL rd Kard ri]V ^rv\^]v o-Ke\v/cop,e0a.
o~(o<fipoaijvr)v rt /caAetj Kat biKaio<rvvr)v /cat dvbpeiav /cat
C9 fxiv 6vtos BT W : fievovTOS ovSe F d4 fiev ti BT W :
fj.4vTot F d6 } BTW: om. F d7 tiv scr. recc. ti :
BTW F o.vto BT W f avTod F e 2 irdvTa yap Tayada

W
:
TWF irdvTa -ra yap ayaOa. B e3 rj BT om. F 65 ava-

W
: :
W
\
\afifidvovTfs BT : F ava\a(36vTes e6 <pafiev BTF : fxiv

a 1 5e W
: Si; BTF a 3 rjyrJTat B T W ^yelrat F a4 f3\di-T(t
W
:
BT (sed in ras. T) /3\aVrrj F : a 5 wfeAT? . . . /3Aa7rTT/ F

a 7 t\ BTW : yap
' Tt F
27*
t
88a IIAATX2N02
cvp.a6l.av na\ p.vi]]xr]v koI /xeyaAo7rpe'7retai> Kal itavra tcl
b Toiavra; .MEN. v
Eya>ye. 212. 2K07ret bfj, tovtojv arra
o-oi boKel p.r) Tno-Tr)ixr} etuat dAA' dAAo e7rto-rr/ur/?, et 01%
tot fxkv /3Aa7rret, tot 8e dxpeAet; olov dvbpeCa, et /ur/ eort
<ppovr]o-is r) dvbptCa dAA' otor ddppos rt* ovx orau /xer
5 azêu yov dappfj av6pa>7ros, /3Ad7rrerat, drai> 8e crvv vS>,
dx/JeAetrat; MEN. Nat. 2X2. Ovkow Kat croicppocrvvr]
aio-avTcos Kal cvp.a6Ca' perd pikv vov Kal p.avdavop.eva kol

KarapTvopLtva dxpe'Atpa, avev 8e iôC /3Aa/3epd; MEN. nd/vrj
C crcpobpa. 212. Ovkovv o-vkXrjftbrjv iravTa tcl rrjs ^rvyjjs
e7rt)(eip?7/xara Kal KapTepi]p.aTa r)yovp.ivr\s p.\v cppovqcreois ets
evbaipLOvtav reAerjra, dcppocrvvrjs 5' ets TovvavrCov; MEN.

"EotKeu. 212. Et dpa dperr) t&v kv rfj ^rvxfj tC ccttlv kol
5 dvayKalov avT& dx/jeAipa) etrat, cppovrjcrLV avTO 5et etmt,

e7ret?j7rep Trdvra rd Kard tj]v y\rvyj)v avrd p.ev Ka#' avrd
ovt axpe'At/xa orjre /3Aa/3epd eortv, TTpocryevop.cvr]S be. cppo-
d vrjcrectiS r) dcppoavvrjs /3Aa/3epd re Kat dxpe'Aip,a ytyverai.
Kard 8r/ rouro/V rdi> Adyov dxpeAtpdy ye orVav rrji> dptrijv
cppovrjcrLv 8et r/' etvat. MEN. "Epotye 6oKet.

2X2. Kat [xkv br) Kal raAAa a rrjz>8r) eAeyopeiv, 7rA ordi>
5 re Kat rd roiaSra, totc fxev dyada totz 8e /3Aa/3epd etz/at,
apa ovx d)0-7rep rrj dAArj ûxf? ^ cpp6vr]CTLS r)yovp.kvr] dxpe'Atpa

rd rrjs ^rvyrjs iiroiei, 7/ 8e dcppocrvvr] /3Aa/3epd, ovrcos aS
e Kat tovtols r) ^rvyr) dpd&s p.ez> ypoip.kvr) Kal r)yovp,kvr) ax/je'-
At/xa avTa 7rotet, p,r) dp0d>s 8e /3Aa/3epd; MEN. ndyu ye.
2X2. 'Opd&s 8e' ye r) <-pi.cppo>v 7/yetrat, r/paprr/pe^cos 5' r/
acppojv; MEN. v
Eo-rt ravTa. 2X2. OrjKouy ovrto br) Kard
5 TtdvTcav et7rety ^cttlv, r<S dvdpaiTrco t<x p.\v dAAa irdvTa ets rr/y
a8 evfia6iav BTF : eifid6fiav W b2 et suprascr. W : r^ B :
^ T WF ovx^ totc] ouxi TroTe BT W : oi>x oVt F b4 Tt

f)
W
:
BTWf: om. F b7 ev/xadia B T F evfj.d6eta fj.av6av6/j.eva

W
:
BTWf : fxav6dvofiev F C5 aiiTb B T F aiiTco : C6 eiretS-fiTrep
BTWf: 4ireiSi)ireplF di^BTF: K alW dayeBTF:

re W d 3 Se? Tti/' BT : 8r) r*r W : Tiva 8et F e3 bp6a>s Se ye
T F et in marg. w : 6p6ws \eye B : om. W prius ^TWF: el B
:
MENX2N 88e
^t>X 7 V avr]pTTJ(T0ai, ra 8e ttjs \j/vx>}s avrrjs ets <ppovr]aLV, et
/xe'AAet ayaOa etvaL- nal tovtu> rw Ao'yco <pp6vqo~i$ av etr/ 8g

to dxpikLpLov <\>ap.\v 8e tt)v dp(Tr)v axpi.kLp.ov tivai;
MEN. Yldvv ye. 2X2. povr]<rLV apa <pap.iv apTr)v zlvai,
?/rot o~vpi.Tra<rav r) p.ipos ti; MEN. AoKet /xot koAcos Ae'ye-

<rdai, o> 2coKpares, tcl key6p.cva. Ovkovv 2X2. et ravra 5
ovTois ix*-> 0VK av ( V
*
t V0~*-
P MEN.- ayaOoi. Ov p.0L
boKti.
2X2. Kat yap av irov Kal ro'8' r)v et <pvo~t. ol ayaOol b

iyiyvovro, r)<rdv irov av r)pXv 01 iyiyvuxrKov tQ>v via>v tovs
dyadovs ras <pv<rei.s, ovs r)p.eis av TrapakafiovTes iKeivo>v

aTro<f)r]vdvT(i)v i<pvkaTrop.ev av iv aKpoirokeL, KaTa<rr]p.r]vd-
p.<\voi irokv fmkkov r) to \pv<riov, tva pLqbels avTovs 8te'- 5
qjdeipev, dAA' e7ret8?/ d<piKOLVTO ets tt]V r)k(.Kiav, \pt]<rip.oi

yiyvoivTo rats 7roAecri.
MEN. Eiko'? ye' rot, a> 2coKpares.

2X2. *Ao' ovv e7rei8?/ ov <pv<rei 01 dyaOol dyadol yiyvov-
rat, dpa jxadrjo-eL; C
MEN. Aoxet uot ?/8rj dvayKoXov etvar Kal brjkov, S>
2coKpares, xara rr)v vnoOeaLV, eitrep iTrLo-rrjpLr] \<tt\v dperr],
OTL bLbaKTOV i<TTLV.

2X2. 'Icrcos vr) Ata* dkka p.r) tovto ov KaAcos co/xoAoy?/- 5
crap.ev;
MEN. Kat p.r)v iboKeL ye dprt KaAco? Ae'yecrt9at.

2X2. 'AAAd p.r) ovk iv rco dprt p.6vov 8e'?/ avrb boKelv
Kakm keye<rdaL, dAAa Kat iv rcp iw Kat iv rco e7retra, et
/xe'AAet rt avrov vyies eiuai. 10
MEN. Tt ovy 8?/; 7rpos rt fikiirav bv<r\epaiveLs avrb d

Kat a7rtcrrets /x?^ ovk e7rtcrr?//x?/ 17 ?/ dpeTT];
&2 Sh BTW: hij F a6 aâflor BTW: aya6ol ayadol F

bi ol B T Wf: om. F b3 o&s W
BT f: om. F bâv
F om. B T
: W
et punctis notavit f b5 SitcpOftpev BT WF
Sia<p6(i P eiev Madvig C 7 ye F : plv B T W c8^BTW:
fxijv F d2 dfno-Tfis BT W : aTriartt F : amaroiris f ?J
BT
Wf: om. F
8gd nAATX2N02
212. 'Eyco crot epco, a> Mivoov. to p.ev yap bibaKTov
avrb etvaL, eXirep eirLcrTt)pr) eo-rCv, ovk avaTC9ep.aL p.r) ov
5 KaAcos Ae'yecrc9ar ort be ovk Zo-tlv eiTLcrTrip.r), arKe\frai eav ctol
boK<a cIkotcos amo-Tiv. Tobe yap p.0L etTre'' et eorij; 5toa-

ktov otlovv irpayp.a, p.r) p.6vov apeTi), ovk avayKalov avrov
Kal bLbao-Kakovs Kal p.a6r)Tas etvai;
v
MEN. E/xotye ooKet.
e 2,12. Ovkovv rovvavTLOV av, ov p.r)Te 8t8do-KaAot p.rjre
[xa6r]Ta\ etev, KaAcos av avTo eLKaQjVTes elKa(oLpev /at)
bLbaKTov etrat;
v
MEN. Eoti ratSra* dAA' dpeTrjs StodcrKaAot ov Sokowi
5 crot etvat;
212. IloAAdKis yovv (j)Ta>v et rti;es etei> avrr/s 8t8d-

crKaAot, iravra ttolGjv ov bvvap.aL evpelv. Katrot p.eTa ttoWojv
ye C1? *at tovtojv /udAtora ovs ay otco/uat ep.TreLpoTa.Tovs
etj>at rou Ttpa.yp.aTos. kol br) kol vvv, a> MeVcoy, ets KaXbv
v
io 77/uii; Ai>i;ros o8e irapeKaOeêTo, co /xera8co/xer rj/s (^rT/crecos.
90 eiKorcos 8' dz; p,eTabo1p.ev "Avvtos yap obe Tipojrov p.ev ecrrt
iraTpbs TrkovcrCov re Kat crocpod 'Avdep.Cojvos, os eyevero

TtXoVCTLOS OVK CLTTO TOV aVTOp.0LTOV oibe boVTOS TLVOS, &0~TTp
6 vvv veu>crTL el\i)cpojs rct IIoADKodrous \prjpaTa *\ap.r)vCas
5 6 0ji/3aios, dAAd rfj avTov crocpCa KTT)crdp.evos kol eiTLp.e\eCq,
e7retra Kat rd dAAa ov\ virep-qcpavos boKGjv etvaL TroXCrrjs
ovbe SyKOibrjs re Kat eTray6r)s, dAAd KOcrp.Los Kal evcrraA?/s

b avrjp' eVetra tovtov ev eOpe-yj/ev Kal eTraCbevaev, cos 8oKet
AOrjvaCojv rco 7rAr/êf atpoS^rat youz; ovtov e7ri rds /ueyt-
oras apyas. bCKaLov brj p.eTa tolovtcov ^rjTelv aperijs 7re'pt
8t8acTKdAovs, etr' eicrtr etre p.r\, ml OLTLves. otj ovv r)p2v,
5 o) "Avvre, cru^rr/cror, e/xot re Kat rco aavTov evo) MevoiVL
e 6 woWdKis BTF : 01 ttoAXokjs W e? nj-es BT W

W
:
olrives F out^s SiSacr/taAoi B T SiSao-KaAot aiiTr)s F 6 8 tou-

W
:
twj/ BT F : tSiv e 10 ^/xr/ BT Wf: 6 F aVuros F oiitos

W
:
BTWf ai^8' ai/BF: 8'aSTW avyros F : aV aurbs BT

a7 in marg. 6 np brjha^ W b3 Sij BTW : Si) rb F bs o-auToC
BTWf: lavrovF
MENI2N gob
r<S8e, 7rept tovtov tov 7rpdyp.aTos rlves av elev 8t8ao-/<aAot.
cobe 8e (r/ce\âi # et (3ovkoCp.e6a Mevcova Tovbe ayaQbv larpov
yevecrdai, irapa TLvas av avTov 7rep.7T0Lp.ev bLbao~Kakovs; ap C
ov irapa tovs laTpovs;
AN. Tldvv ye.
2X2. Tt 8' et o~K.vTOTop.ov dyadbv /3ovAoi/xe0a yevecrdaL,
ap ov Ttapa tovs o~kvtot6p.ovs; 5
AN. Nat.
2X2. Kat raAAa ovrcos;
AN. Yldvv ye.
?
2X2. X28e 877 /xot 7raAty 7rept t5>v avrcov et7re'. 7rapa rovs
larpovs, <pap,ev, 7rep.7T0VTes Tovbe Kakcos av eTre pL7rop.ev, /3ot>- 10
kop.evoL laTpbv yeveo~6aL' ap' orav tovto keycop.ev, ro'8e
keyop.ev, otl irapa tovtovs TrepLTrovTes avrbv o~cocppovoLp.ev d

dv, tovs dvTiTTOiovp.evovs re rrjs Te\vr\s p.dkkov r\ tovs p.r\,
KaX tovs pLLcrdbv 7TpaTTop.evovs eV ovtco tovtco, a7rocpr\vavTas
avTovs bibao~Kakovs tov ôvkop.evov teVai re *cat p.av6dveLv;

dp ov irpbs TavTa j3ke\j/avTes Kakcos dv Tre p.7T0Lp.ev; 5
AN. Nat.
2X2. Ovkovv Kal ixepX avkr\o~ecos Kal tG>v dkkcov Ta avrd
Tavra; irokkr) dvoid eort /3ovkop.evovs avkr\Tr\v Tiva iroir}crai e
7rapa p.ev tovs v7TLo~xyovp.evovs 8i8a<feii> Tr)v Teyyr\v kol
pucrdbv 7TpaTTop.evovs p.r) edekeiv 7Tep.7reLV, aAAots 8^ rtcriy
7Tpdyp.aTa 7rape\eLV, (jrjTovvTa p.av6dveLV Trapa tovtcov, 0%

p.r]T TTpocrTTOiovvrai. bibdcTKakoi. elvai p.r\T eo~TLV avrcov \xadr\- 5
Tr)s p.r\bels tovtov tov p.a6r\p.aTos 6 r\p.eis d^Lovp.ev p.av6d-

vew irap avTcov bv av 7rep.7Tcop.ev. ov 7rokkr\ ctol 80/cei
dkoyia eti/at;
AN. Nat \xd Ata epotye, /cat ap-adCa ye Trpos.

2X2. KaAcos Aeyeis. vvv tolvvv etfecrrt cre /xer' ep.ov 10
C9 irapa, BTF W
irpbs C 10 4w4fiirofi(v BTF iKirefj.irou.fi'
W
: :
d.2 ttjs BTW: om. F ^ robs pf) BTW: i]fj.as F

d4 rov f3ov\ofi(vov BTW tovs $ov\ofi4vovs F 64 ^rjToui/TO
W
:
. . . tovtwv secl. Naber e9 tfioiye BT : t/j.oiye SoKti F

e 10 BTW: <rot F
gia 11AATJ2N02
91 KOLvfj fiovXevcr6ai Trept tov îvov tovtovX MeVcoyos. ovtos
ydp, o> "AvvTt, Ttakai Ae'yet irpos fxe ort eTTiOvfxel Tavrrjs
tt}s crocpCas Kal aperrjs
fj
01 dv6po>7TOL Tas tc oi/ctas Kal ras
TToXeis /caAcos Sioi/cowrt, Kal tovs yoveas tovs avr&v depa-
5 tkvovctl, /cat 7roAtras Kal evovs inrobeâcrdaL re koll 0.770-
TrzpâL cTTLo-TavTaL dtcos dvbpbs dyadov. TavTrjv ovv tt)v

b dperrjv cr/coVet 7rapa TL-vas dv TrefXTrovTes avrbv 6p9a>s Trefx-
TTOLfxev. r) brjXov brf /cara tov dpTL Xoyov otl napd tovtovs
tovs viTLo-yvovnivovs dpeTTjs bLbao-Kakovs eTvai Kal dirocpr]-
vavTas avrovs kolvovs to>v 'Ekkrjvodv to> fiovXofxevo) fxavOdveLV,
5 fXLcrObv tovtov Taafxevovs re /cat TTparrofxevovs;

AN. Kat TLvas Aeyets roirrous, co 2co/cpares;
212. Otcrfla 6777701; /cat cri/ otl ovtol eicrLV ovs oi dv6po>7TOL
KaXovcrL CTOCpLCTTds.
C AN. 'Hpd/cAets, evcpfffxeL, o> 2co/cpares. fxrfbeva tQ>v y
fXO>V fXT]T OLKL00V fXT]T CpikOiV, fXT]T aCTTbv fXT]T eVOV,
ToLavTt] fiavia Xdj3oL, coore 7rapd tovtovs eX.66vTa Xu>f3r]drjvaL,
7TL ovtol ye cpavepd ecrrt Aco/3ri re /cat bLacpdopd tG>v
5 o-vyyLyvofxevoiv.
2X2. IIcos Ae'yets, co "AvvTe; ovtol dpa [xovol tG>v dvTL-
TTOLOVfxevoiV tl 7TLcrTacr$aL evepyerelv toctovtov tG>v dXXcov
bLacpepovo-LV, ocrov ov fxovov ovk axpeXovcrLV, cocr7rep ot dAAot,
ort dv tls avrols 7rapabG>, dXXd Kal to evavriov bLacpdei-

d povcrLv; kcu tovto>v cpavepG>s yjpr)fxaTa dftoucri 7rpdrrecrt9at;
eyco fXV ovv ovk e^co o7rcos crot 7ricrrevcrco* otda ydp dvbpa
eva Upoirayopav 7rAetco xPVIxaTa KTTfcrdfxevov d7ro ravrris
TTjs crocpias r) 4>etotaz> re, bs ot/rco TrepLcpav&s KaXd epya
a1 rovrovl B T tovtov F W
a 6 avSpbs B T : av avSpbs F W :
b1 post o/>tV lacunam statuit Cobet, ixafh\o-6ix*vov vel (3ov\6fj.evoi

avTbv ffofybv yeveaOai intercidisse ratus b 2 SrjKov 8)1 B T : W
S7jA.a8^ F b 4 Tcj> povXofxevif twv eW-fivoov F b 6 Tivas et mox
tovtovs om. F ante \eyeis in lac. add. f
: b 7 ovs F olovs B T W :
C 1 y ifiwv scripsi yefiuv F avyyev&v B T : C 2 fiAyre . . .: W

fx^Te . . . fit)Te . . . fxi\Te BTF : fiifhe . . . firiBe . . . /nftre . . . fxiyre W
aGTbv . . . >\evov BF : affTwv . . . evuv TW C 4 ovtol T W F :
oHtoi B 09 TiiBTWf: tiF d4 TeF:yeBTW

MENI2N gid
ripydêro, kclI aXkovs SeVca t&v dvbpLavToironov. Katrot 5
reoas Aeyets et ol p.tv ra virobr\p.aTa epya(6pevoL ra iraAaia

Kal ra t/xarta eaKOV/ueroi ovk hv hvvaiVTO kaQtiv Tpi&KOvQ'
rjpepas p.oyQr\poTepa a7root8oVres r\ irapzkafiov tol t/uarta re e
Kat vTtobr)p,aTa, dAA' d rotaura Trototer, Tayy av rco At/xco
d7rot?drotei>, YlptcTayopas 8e apa 6kr\v Tr\v 'EAAdSa eA.au-
Qavzv biacpdeipcov tovs crvyyiyvopivovs koX po\QripoTpovs

aironip.TraiV r) Trapekdpfiavtv irkiov r) TCTTapaKOVTa <-Tr\ 5
ot/xai yap avrbv aTroQavtiv zyyvs Kal kfibop.r\KovTa irr\ yeyo-
vora, TerrapaKovTa be ev rfj Teyvj) ovra fcat iv airavTi

rco xpovip TOVTOi ert ets Tr\v r)p.epav TavTr\v\ fiboKLp.S>v
ovbkv ireVaurat, Kat ov p.6vov YIpcoTayopas, akka Kal

dkkoL TTapLTTOkkoL, OL p.V TTpOTCpOV ytyOVOTS fKcCvOV, OL 92
8e Kat vvv ert ovres. iroTtpov br\ ovv (pcop.v Kara tov
o~bv koyov dboTas avTOVS ea7raray Kal Aco/3acrt9at tovs
vtovs, r) kzkr\6vai kol kavTovs; koX ovtco p.aCvcrQai
dtcocroju.ey tovtovs, ovs ivLoC (pacrL crocpcordrous dvQpcoircov 5

etmi;
AN. noAAoC ye oeoucrt \xaCveaQaL, 00 ScoKpares, dkka
TTokv pJdkkoV OL TOVTOLS blboVTCS dpyVpLOV TCOV VCOV, TOVTCOV
0' ert p.akkov ol tovtols e7riroeVoyres, 01 Trpocrr\KOVTS, irokv b
oe /jtdAtora irdvTcov al 770'Aets, ecocrat avrovs dcraqjLKveicrQaL
Kal ovk eeAawoucrai, etre rts eVos e7rt)(etpet tolovtov ti
ttolzlv etre atrTos.
2X2. YloTepov bi, > "Avvre, r/oiKTjKe' tCs cre t5>v trocpLo-rcov, 5
r) tC ovtcos avTois xAe7ros et;
d. 5 Tipyd&ro T : upya&ro B WF d6 epyaîfifvoi secl. Cobet

e 1 irape\af3ov B W : irape\af3ov tc TF ra. . . viroSTifiara secl.
W F
.
Hirschig 6
Te roiavra
/cal BT ical 2 el iroioUv secl.
BTW
:
Cobet BTW &pa

e 3 &pa e oK-qv : '6\i)v 7 8* :
F
8e ttj BTW F e8
iv tj5 BTW F avlt) touttjcI Taxnr)v
B T W om. F
: :
a B T W om. F
2 Kal a ante f : 4 ical kavrovs : ovto>
TWF B
: a5
ov W
Ttfi BTF a8 aâ>o-o/j.fv : aîdcrufiev toutojs
BTF mox bij:
(et W mox b bi toutoi/s (et 1) /iciWov
B T W wo\v fiaWov F
: B T W om. F b2 oi irpocrfaovTts : itav
twv B T W F : tovt<dv
92b IIAAT12N02
AN. Ovbe fxa ALa eycoye crvyyiyova itoiitoTe: avT&v ovbtvL,
orj8' av aXXov ed<rat/u,t t&v ip.(2v ovbeva.
212. "Aireipos dp et 7raira7rao-t t<5i> avbp&v;
io AN. Kat etr/i; ye.
C 212. n<3? orjrj dy, a> baip.6vie, dbeLrjs itepl TorjYorj tou
irpaypLaTos, etTe Tt dyafldjj eêt ei> arjT<S eixe cpkavpov, ov
TtavTaTtao-iv dtttLpos etr/s;
AN. 'PabCuts' tovtovs yovv olba ot eto"ti>, er' ovv

5 drttLpos avr&v et/xt etTe /xr/.
212. MdvTts et to-cos, "Aj/rjre" e7ret ottois ye dAAcos

oto-fla Tovroiv Tiipi, e <5tj a7jrds Aeyets <9a?j/xdbiju,' dy.
dAAd ydp ov rorjrorjs e7rtr?ro7j/>tez; rtVes eto-iV, 7rap' ovs di>
d MeVaw a(pui6p.evos juo^r/pds ykvoLTO orjrot pkv ydp, et oH
/3orjAet, ZcrTa>v ol o-ogWrat dAAd 87) ckcLvovs et7re 77/jur,
cai rdrj TTarpLKOv Tovb kralpov e?jepyer7jo-07J (ppdoras avro}

itapa rLvas acpLKop.Vos kv Tocravrrf 7ro'Aet ttjv dpTr)v r)v
5 vvvbrj iyui birjXQov yivovr av dto? koyov.

AN. Tt 8e aiiTio ov crv ecppacras;
212. 'AAA' ots p.\v eyco a>ju.r/7j <$t8ao-KaAovs tovtojv etJjat,
et7roi', dAAd rvy\dvoi ovbcv ktyoiv, obs crv cprjs' Kal t<rcos t\
e Ae'yets. dAAd oa br) iv t<S /ue'pet a7jr<3 et7re 7rapd tiWs

eAflr/ *AQr)vaL<&v et7re ovo/Lta ototj /3orjAei.
AN. Tt de erjds dvQpoittov 6vop.a 8et aKorjo-at; dr<o ydp

dy kvTvxn 'AQrjvaLoiv t&v Ka\(2v KctyaQ&v, orjSets eoriTJ bs
5 ov /3eAruo avTov itoLrjcreL r) ol crocpLo-TaL, cdvitep kQtkrj
ireLQecrQaL.
212. ndrepo;j 8e orjrot 01 KaAot KayaQol dttb tov

avTop.aTov kyivovTo tolovtol, Ttap ovbevbs p.aQ6vres op.u>s
b 10 /col] Kal del Heindorf C 2 iv avrip F kavrif B T ov W

W
:
BTWfretF C 3 txireipos B T fxveipov F 03,46^;

:
âStwj BT WF : ef; AN. 'H v a.Uu>% Schanz C 4 0'/ B T 0T01 F W :
C6 B T
/xdvrts
2
W
F ixavrr\s B c8 imr)Tovfitv F (eTre^rjToCjaev
W
:
f) ifyTovfnev B T ^tjtoC/UC' d2 iarwv oi Schanz : eo-Taxrav

01 B T
:
W
effTwaav F
: d. 6
:
auTv irpoTepojv p.a$elv,
ovTtov Kak&v KayaOGiV' r) ov boKovcrC ctol ttoWoI Kal ayaOol
yeyovevaL ev Tjjbe rfj irokeL dvbpes;
v
212. E/xotye, "Avvre, kol etvaL boKovcrLV evddbe dyadol 5
tcl TTo\LTLKa, Kal yeyovevaL ert ovx tJttov r/ elvaL' dkka

fi&v kol bLbdcrKakoL dyaOol yeyovacrLv rrjs avr&v dperrjs;
tovto ydp Icttlv irep\ ov 6 koyos rjfuv rvyydveL &v ovk ei
elcrlv dyadol rj pvrj dvbpes evOdbe, ovb' el yeyovao~LV ev r<S

TTpocrdev, dAA' et bLbaKTov ecmv doerr) irdkaL o-Koirovfxev. b
tovto be crKOTTOvvTes Tobe o-KOirovfxev, dpa ol dyadol avbpes
Kal t&v vvv Kal t&v irpoTepcov TavrrfV tt\v dpeTrjv r)v avTol
dyadol rjcrav ifTrCcrTavTO Kal akkut TrapabovvaL, t/ ov irapa-
boTov tovto dvOp&TTU) ovbe TTapaXrjTTTov dAAa> irap aAAou" 5
tovt ecrTLV 6 TrdAat (rfTovfxev eyo> re Kat Mevoiv. <58e ovv
crKOTTeL Ik tov aavTov koyov 0e/>uoTOKAe'a ovk dyadbv b\v
cpaCrjs dvbpa yeyovevaL; C

AN. "Eytoye, irdvTOiv ye //.dAtara.
212. Ovkovv Kal bLbdo-Kakov dyadov, eX^rep tls aAAos lijs
avTov dperrjs 8i8do-KaAos rjv, KaKewov etrat;
AN. Ot/xat eyo>ye, eCirep e/3ovAerd ye. 5

212. 'AAA', otet, ovk av efiovkr)6r) dkkovs re' TLvas
Kakovs KayaOovs yevecrdaL, judAtara 5e' irov tov vbv tov
avrov; rj otet avrbv cpdovelv avru> Kat eêirLTrjbes ov irapa-
8t5o'i>ai Trjv dperrfv r)v ovtos dyadbs rjv; r) ovk aKriKoas otl d
e/xto-roKAT/? KAedoJayroi' tov vbv iTnrea piev e5t8daro
ayadov; eirefxevev yovv errl tu>v lttttuiv 6p6bs eo-TrjK&s, Kal
e 9 6vt(s BT W : laovrai F a i e^toOoj/ BTF : 4^/j.aOov W

a8e/BTW:om. F ag ovb" rf BT W f : om. F b4 ayadol
B W t f (ctpTî' in lacuna textus suppl. f)
. . . âav oi aya0ol T fj :
W
ov irapaSoTbv BT W
** ovde rbv F f b 5 trapa\TiirTbv B T f
f)
W
:
yap oAt77tto/ F &AAtfi B T f : 0AA0 F W

C 4 tlvai B T f :
om. F c 6 4$ov\ii6r)v F c 7 irov B T et refingens f : om.

W quid pr. F habuerit incertum
: d.3 iir4ixtv(v B T iirentive W :
F 6p6bs B T W
opdws F (sed mox bpdbs d 4)
:
93d I1AATX2N02
rjKovTiîV arrb tG>v tinroiv 6p66s, kcu aXXa Trokka Kal 6av-
5 pacrra r)pyd^TO a eKetVos avrbv e7rat8evcraro koX erroi-qcre
crocpov, 6Va bt,bacrKaX.o)v dyaOGtv zlytTO' r) ravra ovk aKr)Koas

t&v TrptcrfivTepcdv;
AN. 'AxTj/coa.
2X2. Ovk av apa Trjv ye rf>vcnv tov vtos avrov r\TiacraT

10 av rts zlvai KaKr/v.
v
e AN. Icrcos ovk dv.
2X2. Tt 8e ro'8e; <ws KXeocpavros 6 0e/jiicrroKAe'ovs dvr]p
dyaObs Kal crocpbs lyivcTO arrep 6 iraTr)p avrov, rjbr) tov
aKriKoas r) uecorepot/ r) TrpccrfivTtpov;
5 AN. Oi brjra.
2X2. *Ap' ovv Tavra p&v olofxeOa fiovktcrQal avrbv tov

avTov vbv TraibevcraL, rjv Se avros crocpiav r)v crocpos, ovbtv
tG>v yeiTovoiv /3eArtco TTOirjcrai, et7reo rjv ye bibaKrbv r) aperr);
w
AN. Icra)s pa At' ov.
io 2X2. Ouros pkv br) croi tolovtos bLbdcrKakos aptTrjs, bv

Kal crv opoAoyets ev rots dpLcrrov tG>v TTporepoov elvac akkov
94 8e br) o-Ke\*Vco/xec9a, '
ApLo~Tibr)v tov Avo-Lpdyov r) tovtov
ov\ opoAoye ts dyaObv yeyoiveVat;
AN. "Eyojye, Trdvrois brfirov.
2X2. Oukow Kat ovtos tov vbv tov avrov Avcripayov,
5 ocra pkv 8i8acrKaAcoiv etxero, KaAAicrra 'Adrjvaioiv eVatSeucre,
dvbpa 8e /3eArtco 8o/cet crot otovovv 7re7rotr)KeVat; rovrco ydp

irov kol avyy&yovas kol bpqs olos eoru\ et 8e /3ovAet,
b rieptKAea, ovrcos peyakoirpeirG>s crocpbv dvbpa, otcr0' ort bvo
Vls ec?peê, riapaAoy Kat Eai>[9i7r7roi>;
v
AN. Eycoye.
2X2. Tovtovs pivTOL, cbs otcrOa Kat crv, Imrias p.ev ibi-
dg TjTJoffaT'] alridaair de virtute 377 c 63 rov T: rov B W

W
:
tout' F e 6 Pov\eo-6ai B T F 0ov\e<r6e : 67 ovSev BT

W f : yuijSe F e 10 8i8d(nca\os roiovros F en /calBTW:
om. F &piarov BF : apiarois T W a6 So/ce? iroiTWF:
80/cejs coi B
MENI2N 94b
baev ovbevos xeipovs 'Ad-qvaioov, ml p.ovo-LK.r]V Kal dycoviav 5
Kal raAAa iiraibevcrev ocra Ttxvrjs ex*rat ovbevos x ( ^P 0VS '
dyaOovs 8e apa avbpas ovk e/3ouAero TTOLr}o~ai; 8ok<3 \iiv,
ifiovkero, dAAd p.r) ovk rj bibaKTov. tva 8e fxr) oktyovs olrj
Kal tovs (pav\oTa.Tovs 'AOrjvaicov dbvvdrovs ytyovivai tovto

t6 irpayp,a, iv6vp.r)6r\TL otl GovKvbibrjs av bvo vels e6pe\f/ev, C
MeArjo-tW Kal ^Ttcpavov, kol tovtovs iiraibevcrcv t6. dAAa
re
eS ml iirdkaLo-av KaAAiora 'Adrjvaicov tov il\v yap aavdia
eScoKe, tov 8e EvScopco* ovrot 8e ttov iboKovv t&v totc
KaAAtcrra 7raAaietr
v
?/ ov p.ip.vr\craL; 5
AN. Eycoye, a.Kor).
212. OVKOVV bijkov OTL OVTOS OVK tkV TTOT, OV LICV I8et
baTravcoLievov 8t8dcrKet:>, ravra iikv e8t'8ae tovs Tralbas tovs d
avrov, ov 8e ovbev e8et draAcocra^ra dyafloi? avbpas TTOLrjtraL,
ravra 8e ovk e8t'8aei>, et bLbaKTdv r)v; akka yap tcrcos 6

0O7jku8i8?/? cpavkos rjv, Kat ovk rjcrav avrco 77Aetcrroi cpikoL
'Adrjvaicov Kat T<av ovp.p.ayu>v ; Kat otKtas /xeydArjs r)v koX 5
r/
ebvvaTo p,iya iv r?/ 7ro'Aet Kat iv rots dAAots EAA?/o-ii/, coore
enrep rjv tovto 8t8aKroV, i&vprfv av ootls ejueAAeu avrov
tovs veLS ayadovs 7roi?/creiz>, r) t&v iTTLyoipicov tls r) t&v
voav, et avrbs p,r) ecrxo'Aaei> 8td ttjv Trjs irokecos iiTLiiikiiav. G
dkkb. ydp, co eratpe "Arvre, p.r) ovk bibaKTOv dperrj.
fj
AN. '12 ^coKpares, pabicos /xot OKets kokcos Ae'yety dv-

dpcoirovs. eyco piev ovv dv ctol crvp/3ouAevcratp,i, et idikeLS
ip.ol TreidecrdaL, evkafieLcrdaL' a>s lcrcos p.ev koX iv akkrj 7ro'Aet 5
b 7 &pa &v$pas BT W : T F SoKw/xev

&vSpas &pa F Soku (jl4v W :
B b8 5 BTWf: BT om. F
F {oi>) robs bg rovs W
W
:
ci. Stallbaum ^ rovs Vermehren

: adwdrovs B F Svvarovs T :
Ci Sn BTW: Srt 6 F
W
C 3 rbv ixkv B T F rb /t " fo^/a : W
BT f âvOiav F
: 04 evti&pep B F ôStopcp evoStipy T : W :
wou B T W ir<o F e 6 dcop B T f aK^noa F C 7 oStos W

W
: :
BT towvtos F
: <$ oS B T W
F (et mox d 2) oT de virtute 378 b :
(probavit Schanz) d 3 Tavra BTWF: toOto de virtute c. 1.
(probavit Schanz) d 4 <pi\oi T F om. re vera B d 6 koIW

W
:
iv B T koI F : d 7 i^vpeiv B T F Qevpev de virtute c. W 1.
W
:
e 2 apeT-fi B T
F
apeT^ F : 03 KaKus Keyetv B T
t) \eyeiv W :
kokws
94 e riAATX2N02
paov <ttiv KaKw? iroieiv dv8pa>TTovs rj ev, iv rrjbe 8e koi
95 ttavv otuat 8e ae ko.1 avrbv ei'8eVai.
2X2. *X2 Mivoiv, "Avvtos fxiv fxoL 8oKet \a\iTaCveiv, Kal

ovbev 8avp.aoi' olerai ydp ue TrpG>Tov fxkv KaK-qyopelv tovtovs
tovs dvbpas, eVetra T/yetrat kol avrbs eTvaL ets tovtojv. aAA'
5 ovtos fxev Zav ttotc yvS> olov o~tiv rb KaK&s Aeyetv, 7rawerai
yakenaCvtiiv, vvv 8e dyvoel' crv 8e uot et7re, ov kol irap vfxlv
do-Lv Kakol KayadoX dvbpes;
MEN. Udvv ye.
b 2X2. Tt ovv; ZdekovcrLV ovtol irapiyjeLv avrovs 8t8aaKa-
kovs tols vcols, Kal bfxokoyelv 8i8daKaAot re etuat Kat
8t8aKrov dpeTr/v;
MEN. Ov fxa tov ACa, o> 2coKpare?, dAAa tot fxev av
5 avT&v aKOvcraLS o>s 8t8aKroV, rore 8e 6>s ov.
212. <$>5>fxev ovv tovtovs bLbao-Kakovs elvaL tovtov tov

7rpdyuaros, ols fxrjbe avTO tovto ouoAoyetrat;
MEN. Ov fxoL boKel, o> 2&>Kpare?.
212. Tt 8e br); ot crocpLcrTaC o"ot oSrot, ot7rep uoVot
io e7rayyeAAoyrat, boKovcrL 8i8do-KaAoi etuat dperfjs;
C MEN. Kat ropytou udAtora, o> 2coKpare?, Tavra dyafxai,
otl ovk dv 7rore avrov tovto aKovcraLS vTTLpyvovp.(vov, dkkd
Ka\ t5>v dkko>v KarayeA3, orav aKOva-r] vTTLcryvovfxevo>v dkkd
Aeyety oterat 8ety 7rotety btLvovs.
S 2X2. Ov8' dpa crot boKovcrLV ol o-ocpLoral 8i8do-KaAoi

eti>ai;
MEN. Ovk e\o> Aeyetv, o> 2wKpares. Kat yap avTos

OTTp OL TTOkkol TTtTTOvda' TOt\ fXtV fXOL SoKOUO-U', TOT 8e ov.
e6 fiq6v Buttmann : pdSiuv BT WF avOptiirovs] adrivaiovs

suprascr. f ^ S B T F tres litterae perierunt in
: a2 avvros W
B T F ivvTov
: Wa 3 KaKTiyopeTv B T Karr)yope?v F W :
b 2 posterius ica\ F (coniecerat F. A. Wolf) 7) B T (verbum periit :
in W) b 6 rov T F om. B W b 7 SfioKoyelrai B T F

W
: :
6/j.o\oyr)rai (sed suprascr. e? W) C 2 avrov B T avrh W :
F C3 viriffxvovfifvoov BTWf: vTtia\vt\ii.iv<t>v F: secl. Naber

C5 ovo' dpa 0-01 BT WF : ovSe aoi suprascr. f C 8 t6t( (bis)
BT W (et mox) : '6re (bis) F
>
MENX2N 95 c
212. OlcrOa be otl ov p.6vov o~oi re koI tols dAAots tols

7roAtrtKOtS TOVTO boKel TOTC p.eV eZvaL StSaKrOI', T0T 8' OV, IO
dAAd Kal QeoyvLV rbv TroLrjTrjV oZcrd' 6tl ravrd Tavra Ae'yet; d
MEN. 'Ey irotot? eirecrLv;
2X2. 'Ez> rot? eXeyeCoLs, o5 Ae'yet
Kat 7rapa roto-ti' 7Ttz;e Kat ecrt^te, Kat /îera rotcrty
te, xat dyoajje rot9, <2v p.eydXrj bvvapLs. 5

ecrOX&v p.ev yap a-n ecrOXd St5dear r)v be KaKoZcnv
<Tvp.p.C<ryr)s, diroXeZs Kat tov eovra voov. Q
>
oZa& otl ev tovtols fxev cos 8t<5aKrotS ovo~rjs rrjs dperrjs Ae'yet;
MEN. 4>aiWai ye.
22. 'Ev aXXoLS 8e' ye oXCyov /xera/3ds,
et o' 771 TtOLrjTov, cprjo-(, Kal evdeTov dvbpl v6r}p.a, 5
Ae'yet ttcos otl

TtoXXovs ay puo-0ov$ Kat jueydAous ecpepov
ol bwdp.eVOL tovto 7roieti>, Kal

ou 7ror' av e dya#oi> 7rarpos eyevro kokos,
TreL86p.evos plv8ol<tl craocppocrLV. dXXd ot8dcrKcoi> 9"
ov 7rore 7rot?7creis tov kokcV dvbp* dyadov.
evvoeZs ort avTos avT<2 7rdAtv 7repi rcoy avrcav TavavrCa

Ae'yet;
MEN. 4>aiWai. 5
212. 'Eêts ovv elirelv dAAou otovovv Ttpdyp.aT0S, ov o\

p.ev cpdcrKOVTes cuSdcrKaAot etrat ov\ ottcos dXXo)v cuSdcrKaAot
6p.oXoyovvTaL, dAA' ovbe avTol eirioTaadaL, dXXa Trovqpol
eZvaL 7rept avTo tovto t6 irpdypa ov cpacrt cuSdcrKaAot etvat, b
ot be 6p.oXoyovp.evoL avrol KaXol Kayadol rore p.ev cpacrLV
avro bibaKTov eZvaL, rore be ov; tovs ovv ovtco reTapaypevovs
irepl otovovv cpaCrjs &v cn> KvpCcos bLbacrKaXovs eZvaL;
d3 o5 T WF : ou B d4 prius rolaiv BT W : tkti F (suprascr.

oi {) d.6 t>t8deai BTF SiSdêrai W Kcuto?<riv B kokoToî
W
: :
T : KaKoTs F e i o-vn/nicryijs ex ifj./j.io-ytis fecit F : o-v/j./xiyrjs

BTW eg^WoBTWF a6 &\\ov B T F: om. W '
)
g6b I7AAT&N02
5 MEN. Md At" ovk eycoye.
2i2. Ovkovv et /ou/re ol crocpto-rai fxrjre ol avrol KaAoi
KayaOol ovtcs 8t8dcrKaAot etcrt tov i:pdyp.aTos, brjkov otl ovk
av dAAot ye;
MEN. Oti fxoi boKtl
C 2X2. Et 8e ye p.r) 8t8do-KaAot, ovbt p.a6r)TaC;

MEN. AoKet pot X iV ^ 5 Ae'yeis.
212. 'Q.p.oXoyrJKap.ev 8e' ye, npa.yfj.aTos ov p.r)Tt 8i8dcrKaAot
p.r\T [xaOrjTal etei>, tovto p,rj8e SiSaKrdy eivai;

5 MEN. 'lp.okoyr)Kap,v.
212. Oukoiw dperrjs ovbap.ov (paCvovraL 8t8dcrKaAoi;

v
MEN. Eoti ravra.
212. Et 8e' ye p.r) 8t8dcrKaAoi, ovbe p.aQryraC;
MEN. <J>au>erat otfrcos.
v
io 212. 'Aper?/ dpa ovk av et?? 8i8aKrdr;
d MEN. Ovk eotKey, et7rep opO&s r/pet? eo-Ke/u/xe0a. cocrre
Kat 0aujud(fco 877, co 2coKpare?, iroTepov ttotc ovb' etaiv dyacôt

dz>8pe?, rj tCs av et?? rpo7ro? Trjs yevecrecos rcoi> dyaO&v
yi,yvop,kvi>v.
5 212. Kti>8twe?Jo/uei>, co MeVcoy, eyco re Kai cn/ (pavkoC tlvcs

elvaL dvbpes, kol o-i re YopyCas ov\ tKazxSs' 7re7rat8ei;KeVai
Kai ejue ripd8iKOs. 7rai>rds p.dAAoz> ovv irpoareKTiov tov vovv
r)p2v axiTOLS, Kai Cv TV T ^ 0V ooris rjpas kvC yi rco rpo'7rco ftekrCovs
e 7roi?jcrer Aeyco 8e raura aTrofiXtyas irpbs Tr)v dpTL i)Tr)o-LV,
cos r)pJds Hkadev KarayeAdcrrcos ort ov p.6vov iTrio-Trip.r)s
r)yovp.ivi)s opd&s re Kat ev rots dv9pa>TTOLS 7rpdrrerat rd

irpdypara, rj tcrco? Kat 8iac/>evyet ^pds ro 1
yz>coz>at rtz>a 7rore
5 TpoiTov yCyvovTaL ol dyaOol dvbpes.

MEN. E[cos tovto Aeyets, co 2coKpares;
b6 BF: olW: om. T

et 04 fi V Sh Bekker M^ T e B T firi F : W :
d8 evl BT
ye eZ 7 FW : 6 2 KaTayeKaffTws B T f /caTa- W :
ye\affTOs F 63 rtyovnevrjs opdws T( B T bpQws rjyov/xevris F W

W
:
{6p8ws Te r)yovfj.4vr)s f eS B T F &/ e 4 rj Madvig ^

: :
BTWF 8<a(/)ei>yej F (coniecerat Madvig) 5ia<pevyeiv B T : W

:
MENX2N g6e
r
2X2. X2oe* ort piev tovs ayaOovs dvbpas oet cocpeAi/io?js elvaL,
6p6S>s (j>p.okoyi]Kap.ev tovto ye otl ovk av aAAco? ex 0i '

7/ ydp; 97
MEN. Nat'.
2X2. Kat ort ye (lxpekip.oL eawrat, av 6p6G>s fjpuv 7/ycoi>rat
t&v irpayp.aTu>v, koI tovto ttov KaAcos ujp.oXoyovp.cv;
MEN. Nat. 5
212. "Ort 5' ovk taTiv 6p6G>s fjyeTcrdaL, edv p.f) (ppovLp.os
7/, tovto ftpLOioi eo~p,ev ovk 6p6S>s d>p.okoyr)K6o~LV.
MEN. n<5? bf) [6p6<0s] Aeyets;
2X2. 'Eycb epco. (et) etScos rr;i/ 686y ti)V els Aapia-ai> 7/
o7rot /3o?JAei dkkocre j3abioi Kal aAAots 7/yotro, aAAo rt 6p6G>s 10
av Kal ev 7/yotro;
MEN. Udvv ye.
2X2. Tt 8' et rts 6p65>s p.ev bo^dfav i]tls eo-Tiv f) dbos, b
eA?/A?j0cos be p.f) ^778' eTTLa-Tdfxevos, 0x1 /cai ouros ay dpflcos
7/yotro;
MEN. Ilciw ye.

2X2. Kat ecos y dv ttov 6p6f)v boav Zyr) ^P^ & v %T *Ps 5
(7Ti.crTi]p.i]v, ovbev \eLpo>v i)yep.u>v ecrTai, olop.evos p.ev dki]6f),
(f>pOVU>V be p.1], TOV TOVTO (ppOVOVVTOS.

MEN. Oibev ydp.
2X2. Adfa dpa dkr)6f]s irpbs 6p6oT7]Ta Trpdea>s ovbev
yeipasv fjyep-wv <ppovf)cr ea>S' Kal tovto Zo-tlv wvbf) irape- 10
keiiTop.ev ev Tjj irepl rfjs apeTfjs aKe'\/fei ottoIov tl elrj, keyovres
otl <pp6vr)(TLS p.6vov T/yetrat tov 6p65>s irpaTTeLV to be. dpa C
Kal boa ?]V aki]6r]s.
a 1 a>fj.o\oyfiKafj.(v BT W f wfj.o\oyr)ffa/j.ev F a4 w(j,o\oyov(iev

BT W : d/xo\oyovfj.ev F
:
a8 dpOws BT W f : avrov F : secl.

Schanz aZ tovto
: fort. ei eiSws scripsi : ris eiSws B T f a9
(quid pro ris pr. F habuerit incertum) : rts S' eiSws et ris eiSws W
WF
:
Ven. 189 \dpio-av T \dpiffa B b1 ri S' ef ris BT W f

W
:
ri risF b2 f av B T
om. F b3 BTW
rjyoiro f rryeiro F
W
: :
b5 BT
6&>s 7' f TT/s F b 7 toDto: BTWf: om.F b 10 irape-
\eiirofiev B T F rrape\iirofxev : W C 1 BTW
T b Se f r6Se Se F
W
:
C 2 a\t}0r)s T F oAtjOcj B :
plato, VOL. III. 28

97 c IIAATX2N02
MEN. "Eoik* ye.
212. Ovbev apa tjttov <acpeXLp.6v ecrrty 6p6i~\ boa e7rt-
5 orrjurj?.
MEN. Toowrcp ye, co 2co/cpare?, ort 6 pey rrjy e7rtcrrrjMr]i'
iyo&v det av eiTLTvyxavoL, 6 be tt)v opdrjv boav rore piev av

Tvyyavoi, totc 8' ov.
2X2. IIco? XeyeLs; 6 det excop 6p6r\v boav ovk det di>
io ruyxayot, ecocnrep 6p6a 8ofdbt;

MEN. 'ArdyKr? pot cpatVerar cocrre 0ai>pdco, co 2co-
d Kpares, tovtov ovtcos e\ovTOS, otl 8rj 7rore 7roAv TLp.LcoTepa
17 e7r1.crTrjp.r1 Trjs 6p6r)s 8dfrj?, Kal 8t' ort ro p.ev erepov, to 8e
irepov ecrTLv avTcov.

2X2. Otcrfla ovv 8t' ort 0ai>pdet?, r) eyco croi et7rco;
5 MEN. Uavv y etTre'.
2X2. "Ort rot? Aat8dA.ou aya\p.acnv ov irpocrecryriKas tov

vovv tcrco? 8e ov8' eVriu 7rap' vp.lv.
MEN. Ilpd? rt 8e 8r) tovto XeyeLs;
2X2. "Ort Kal TavTa, eav p.ev p.rj bebep.eva f\,
a7ro8t8pdcrKei
10 Kat 8pa7rereuet, eav 8e bebep.eva, i:apap.evei.

e MEN. Tt oZv 8rj\-
2X2. Tcov eKeivov 7roirjp,drcoi> XeXvp.evov piev eKTrjcrdaL ov

7roAArj? tlvos cllov eVrt rtprj?, cocrTrep 8pa7re'rrri> avdptoTrov
ov ydp irapap.evei bebep,evov be ttoXXov aiov iravv yap

5 *ca\d tcl epya ecrTiv. irpbs tl ovv 8rj A.e'yco ravra; irpbs
tcls 8da? tcls aXrjdels. Kal yap al 8dat at dArjflet?, ocrov
p.ev av \povov irapap.evtocrLV, KaXbv to xpr)p.a Ka ' navT

98 ayada. epydbi>rat* ttoXvv be \povov ovk edeXovcrL irapa-
p.kvew, clXXcl bpaTreTevovuLv eK rrjs ^vxfjs tov avdpcoirov,
C6 rotrovrcp BT W f : roffovro
TW
F C 8 rore . . . C g S6âv om.
W
W' cq ael ttvF: aU\ B : ael d 1 S-f) nore BT f: om. F
d.4 6av/xd(ets F: 0av/j.d(ois BTW d7 vovv TWF: v6ov B
dq n\v BT Wf:
om. F dio om. F eaî/ SeBTW:
BT Wf om. F e 3 inter rivbs et a^tov lacuna sex fere litterarum
in F
:
65 Ka\a B T F Ka\Sis 67 irdvr ayada

: W
wdvra W :
ayada Stobaeus ttdvra rayaOa B T F

: a 1 4pyd(ovrat B T F W :
airepyd(ovrai Stobaeus
;
MENX2N 9a
(oore ov iroWov dtat eicnv, eW av tls avras 8770-77 alrias
Aoyto-uw. tovto 8' ko-Hv, a> Miva>v eratpe, avdp.vr]o-LS, a>s
ei> rots TTpocrOcv r)pXv wuoAdyTjrat. eVetSay 8e htd&criv, 5

irpSiTov pikv tTTt.o-TrjiJ.ai yiyvovTai, eVeira fj.6vLp.OL' Kal 8td
rairra 877 TLp.La>Tpov iiTLo-Tr)p.r] opOrjs borjs iariv, Kal 8ta(pe'pet
8eo-u<3 (TTLo-T-qp.rj opdrjs borjs.
MEN. Nf; tov Aia, a> 2a>Kpares, eotKev rotovro) rtvt.

2X2. Kat utji; Kat iya> ws ovk et8a>s Ae'ya), dAAd etKa^coy b
drt 8e' eoTty rt dAAotoy dp^ 8o'a kol i7TLo-Tr]p.r], ov irdvv
p.0L boKa> tovto (Ikcl^lv, dAA' enrep rt dAAo cpairjv dv
etdeVat dAtya 8' av obairjv %v 8' ovv kol tovto tKiivcov
6zii]v av d>v otba. 5
MEN. Kat 6p6a>s ye, a> 2a>Kpares, Ae'yets.

2X2. Tt 8e'; ro'8e ovk 6p6G>s, otl aXr]dr)s boa r)yovp.ivr)
to epyov kKa.o-Tr\s rfjs 7rpdea>s oi8ey yzlpov a7repyderat fj
iTTLcrTi]p.rj
MEN. Kat tovto 8oKets uot akrjdrj Ae'yeti>. 10
2X2. Ovbtv apa 6p6r) 8o'd iiTLo-Tr]p.r)s xzlpov ovbe. rjrTov C

a)0eAturj eorat ets rds 7rpdets, oibt avr)p 6 \a)V 6p6r)v
boav r) 6 eTTLcrTrjp.rjv.
MEN. 'Eort raura.

212. Kat p.r)v 6 ye dyaflds avr)p axpe'Atuos r)pXv a>uo- 5
Adyrjrat etrat.
MEN. Nat.
212. 'E7ret8r) Toivvv ov p.6vov bC iTTLcrTr)p.r)v ayadol avbpcs
av etey Kat dxpe'Atuot rats 7ro'Aeo-ti>, enrep eter, dAAd Kat 81'
6p6i\v boav, tovtolv 8e ovbirepov (pdo-et eorty rots av6pa>- 10
a 4 \oytcrfj.cji BT W \oyio-fxwv F 3 F BT
om. W a 6 irpwTov
W
: :
BTF : irpwTai a7 ooflrjs 8ojs BT W Stobaeus $6ris

W
:
opdrjs F io-riiv) BT f : F
om. b 2 ov irdvv F irdvv B T : W
b4 toCto W eiceivoov BT : 4k(7vo F b 5 av wv B T f S>v av F W :
b7 t65* BTWf: F 856 ca avV Hirschig: av%p BTWF

C5 BTW
a>fio\ 6yr)Tai f ii/xo\oy(7To F C7 yatBTJ": om. W
BTW
:
C8 iyafloi fi^Spes : avSpbs ayadov F C 9 w<pt\t/j.oi B T W :
W<p(\tfXOV F
28*

g8d IIAATX2N02
d 7rois, ovre eincrT-qpr) ovre 8o'a akr)6r)s, ôvt eiriKTTjra 17
boKtl 001 cpvcrei oTTOTepovovv avrolv eXvai;

MEN. Ovk epiOLye.
2X2. Ovkovv eireLbr) ov cpvcreL, ovbe ol ayadol cpvcreL
5 iev av.
MEN. Ov brjra.
2X2. 'EneLbr) be ye ov cpvcreL, ecrKOTiovp.ev to /Jiera touto
et bibaKTov icTTLv.
MEN. Nat.
10 2X2. Ovkovv btbaKTov eboev eXvaL, et (ppovrjcns r) apeTrj;
MEN. Nat.
2X2. K&v et ye bibaKTov etrj, cppovrjcns av elvai;
MEN. ITazn; ye.
e 2X2. Kat et pAv ye 8toao-KaAot elev, bibaKTov av etvai,
p.r) ovtcov be ov bibaKTov;
MEN. Ovto>.
2X2. 'AAAa p.r)v b>p.okoyf)Kap.ev p.r) elvat, avTOV bibacrKa-
5 kovs;
v
MEN. Eo-ti Tavra.
c
2X2. X2ju,oA.oyT7KajiAei> apa p.r)T bibaKrbv avrb p.r)T cppo-
vrjcnv elvai;
MEN. Udvv ye.

10 2X2. 'AAAa p.r)v ayadov ye avrb 6p.oKoyovp.ev elvai;
MEN. Nat.
2X2. 'Q.cpeALp.ov be Kal ayaObv elvai to 6p6a>s r)yovp.evov;
MEN. Ucivv ye.

99 2X2. 'Opd&s be ye r)yeZcr6ai bvo ovTa Tavra pova, boav
Te aKr)6r) kol emcrTrjprjv, a e\u>v avdpumos 6p6S>s T/yetrat
d1 BT
oir iwinTriTa f W
ciriKrvrai F secl. Cornarius ovr itrl-
W
: : :
kttjto Apelt d 2 6-iroTfpovovv B T F 6ir6repov (sed suprascr.

:
oZv) avroiv BTWf: ovttjj/ F d^ ye BTW: om.

F d 10 el~\ suprascr. F
f) rj] cl, suprascr. F r)d 12 Kav
BWF: ital (compendio) T 67 avrb B T et post v 5e avdpcoiros f}ycp,d>v ko-TLV irl to

6p66v, bvo TavTa, boa aXr)6f)s Kal TTLcrTr)pr). 5
MEN. Aokci poi ovrco.
2X2. Ovkovv e7ret8r/ ov bibaKTov eorty, oi/b' kiTLo-Tr)p.r) bf)
ert yLyverai f) aptTrj;
MEN. Ov (patveTai.
2X2. Avoiv apa ovtolv ayadoiv Kal axtjeAiuoiy to p.V b

ercpov d7roAe'Aurat, Kal ovk av etr/ kv 7roAiriKr/ irpa^tL
(moTrip.r) f)yepcov.
MEN. Ov uot boKU.

2X2. Ovk apa crocpCq tlvI ovbe crocpoX ovtcs ol tolovtol 5
avbpes fjyovvro rals tt6X.0-lv, ol ap.cpl 0euioroKAe'a re Kal
ovs apTL "Avvtos obt eAeyey 8t6 orj Kal oi>x olol re aAAous
770tetV TOLOVTOVS 0I0L aVToC tLCTL, CLT OV bl TTLO-Tr)p.r)V OVTS
TOLOVTOL.
y
MEN. EotKer ovtcos \lv, a> 2a>Kpares, a>s Aeyets. 10
2X2. Ovkovv et urj e7rtorr/ur/, evboCq Sr/ to X.olti6v
yCyvtTaL' r/ 01 7roAtrtKot avbpts xpa>p.V0L Tas 7roAets 6p- C

6ovctlv, ovbtv bLaqbtpovTeos \ovtS ~np6s to q\povLV r) OL
Xpr)crp.oiboC re Kat ot 0eoudyrets #

Kat yap ovtol ivdov-
crL&VTes kiyovcTLV pXv aki)6f) Ka\ 7roAAd, to-ao-t Se ovb\v 3>v
Xiyovo-LV. 5
MEN. KLvbvvevL ovtoos \lv.
2X2. Ovkow, a> MeVaw, cllov tovtovs 6tCovs KaAety
tovs avbpas, oXtlvgs vovv urj \ovtS TroAAa Kat p.yaKa
KaTopdovcrLV 5>v irpaTTovo-L kol XiyovcTL;
a3 Tivbs opBws F : om. BT W a4 r)yefiovia B'TW: riye-

fioveia B ex 1 inter scribendum fecit F >v F Stobaeus $
W W
: :
BT a8 eri yiyverai F emyiyverai B T b3 imaTr)fir)

W W
:
rryefju&v BT : ryyefjiwv imo-rr)firi F b7 Sr) F om. BT

W
:
b8 ov 5i' imo'T4)(t,r)v BT : ovk imo~Tr)firi F b 10 eoinev B T

Wf: om. F ovtws exeiv3T"W: exeiv ovtws F C3 iv-
OovaiwvTes F: om. c8 BTW
BTWf: om. F ^ iroWa koI
BT W : rroWdKis F
:
99 c IIAAT&N02
10 MEN. Yldvv ye.
212. 'Oo0<ws dp av KakoLp.ev deCovs re ots vvvbi] <\kiyop.cv
d xpr]o-p.<abovs Kal p,dvTCLS koX tovs ttolijtlkovs airavTas' Kal
tovs TrokiTiKovs oir^ 7/Kto-ra tovtcov cpalpev av Oziovs re etmt
Kal evdovmafciv, ttCttvovs ovTas Kal KaT\op.ivovs k tov
deov, oTav KaTopOGxrL Aeyorres irokka koX p.eydka irpdyp.aTa,
5 p.r]b\v etSoVes 8>v kiyovcrLV,
MEN. ndvv ye.
212. Kat at ye ywawces b-qirov, u> Mzvu>v, tovs dyaOovs

avbpas deCovs Kakov<TL' Kat ol AaKMves oTav tlvo. eyKa>/md-
(uxtlv dyadbv dvbpa, " 0etos dvi]p," cpacrCv, " ovtos."
e MEN. Kat (paCvovTaC ye, 2) 2coKoares, 6p6Gs Ae'ye\
KaCroL t<ru>s "Avvtos o5e ctol d\#erat kiyovTL.
212. Ovbev jueAet e/xotye. tovt(o p.kv, u> Mdvcav, koX avOis
bLake^6p.e9a' et 8e vvv rjpidls ey ttovtI t<2 Adyco tovtoj KaAcos
5 eCqTrjo-ap.zv re Kat ek<-yop.v, dperr) av ttr] ot/re cpvcreL ot/re
bLbaKTov, dkka 6<-Cq p.oCpq itapayLyvop.ivr] dvav vov ols av

IOO ixapayCyvrvraL, et p.r\ tls eti] tolovtos tG>v 7roAiriK<Sz> dvbpG>v
olos koX dkkov TTOLrjaraL TtokiTLKov. et 8e etr/, cryjebbv dv tl
OVTOS kiyOLTO TOLOVTOS V TOLS QSxTLV OLOV ecpt] "Op.1]pOS (V

tols TcdveGio-LV tov TiLpao-Cav elvaL, kiyu>v 7rept avrov, otl
5 otos iriiivvTaL tGv kv "At8ou, rot 8e o-Ktat dto-o-ovo-t.

tovtov av koX ivOdbe 6 tolovtos uxnrep irapa crKtds dkr]6es
dv TTpayp.a etrj 7roos dpeTijv.
w MEN. KdAAtora boKels p.0L kiyeiv, 2> 2coK/>ares.
212. 'Ek pev toCvvv tovtov tov koyLo~p.ov, u> M<-vu>v, deCq
p.oCpq r)p2v cpaCveraL TrapayLyvop.ivi] r) dpaTr) ots dv irapa-
C ii &p h.v Stallbaum : &pa F &> B T

: d 2 <pcufiei> W BT W f
(pafihv F d.3 tov Oeov~\ rov dewv Cobet rov Beov Schanz d.8 Tiva
W om. F W
:
BT : BTF 4yKw/j.ia,âxnv : yK/j.id{ov<rtv d9 0e?os

BT WF Casaubon e 3 tovtw B T W
ffeios F : tovto ai tis
W
:
BT f F : a3 irus ex videtur F XeyoiTo ycvoiTo ut a5 rol

8e] o?8e F BTW : a6 al Se F BTW ivddSe 6 evdbs ba txev
b 3 B T W om. F
:
Toivvv TWF B : fievToi vvv t) : ols av F :
ols BTW W wapayiyveTat B T F

irapayiyvrjrai :
MENI2N ioob
yCyvrjTar r6 6 craês irepl avrov elo-opaOa totc, orav Ttplv
SiTivL Tpoiru) rols avdpa>~70LS Ttapayiyv^Tai aptTij, irpoTepov 5
iiTL)(Lprjcr<t)pLV avrb Kad' avTo (jr\Telv tl txot zcttlv aperr].
vvv 5' p,ol pikv copa ttol Uvai, o~v 5e Tavra raOra airep
avros 7re'7retcrat 7rei0e Kat tov cvov roV5e "Avvtov, tva
TTpqoTepos fi'
tos iav TTHLcrrjs tovtov, io~TLV ort Kat 'Adrj- c
vaCovs ovrjcreLS.
b5 irapayiyv-Tai BTF irapayiyvi-Tai W b6 ii~ix~ ip^crwfitv

W W
:
BTF : li-iij-T i(\owfi.tv b7 ravra toOto F : toOto BT

c 1 8nBTW: St F
nf
inniAS MEiznN
St. III
2f2KPATH2 mniA2 p. 281
2X2. 'iTnrCas 6 KctAos re Kat <ro<pos' cos 8td \povov r)puv a

Karrjpas ets rds 'Adrjvas.
117. Ov ydp crxoAr/, co 2co Kpares. r) yap *HAts orav rt
Serjrai ota7rpdacr0at irpos Tiva t&v 7ro'Aecoi>, det e7rt Trpcorov
epe epxerat tG>v ixokiT&v alpovp.ivr\ irp*cr$s.vTr\v, rjyovpiivrj 5

bLKacrTijv Kal ayyekov LKavooTarov ttvat toov \6yoov ot av
irapa t5>v 7rdAecoi> kKaaToov Aeycoyrat. 7roAAaKts pei> ow b
Kal ets dAAas 7rdAets e7rpe'cr/3eucra, 7rAetoTa 8e Kat 7rept
7rAeiVra>y Kat /xeyftrrcoy ds ti]v AaKtbaifxova' 010 677, o rrw
epcoras, orj 0aptco ets rowcrfie rovs ro7rous.

212. Totoirroy /xeVrot, co 'lTTTrta, eart rd r?/ dAr/0eia 5
ao<pov re Kat re'Aeioy avbpa eti>at. cri/ ydp Kat tdia iKavds
et 7rapd rcoi> vioov 7roAAa xpr/para kap.j3aveov ert 7rAetco
cocpeAeu coi> Aap/3dj>ets, Kat a5 8r//xocria rr)y craurov 7ro'Ai7J C

tKaws evepyerety, uxnrep XP7) roy /xeAAorra p.r/ Kara<ppo-
vr)o-zo-Qai dAA' ev8oKtp,r/creii> ei> rots 7roAAots. drdp, co 'iTTiria,
tl 7rore rd atrtoi> drt 01 7raAatot eKetVot, coz; dz^djuara peydAa
Ae'yerat e7rt crocpia, ntrraKOi) re Kat Btavros Kat rcoy d/xcpi 5
rcn> MtAT/crtoy 0aAr/y Kat ert rcoi> v<TTepov p.e'xpi 'Avaay6pov,
ws r) 7rdi>res r/ 01 7roAAot avrcoy <paLvovraL aiicyopLZVOL t8>v

TroAtrtKcoi' irpaîctiv;
a 6 SikcmttV] SiamiTV Burges : SoKifiaffriiv Naber : tucpoariiv

H. Richards b3 fitflffrwv TW : irpi fieylffruv F t awTW
et suprascr. f : om. F b6 o-ii TWf : 0? F
PLATO, VOL. III. 29

a8ic nAATX2N02
in. Tt 8' otet, 2 2coKpares, dAAo ye r/ abvvaroL rjcrav
d Kal ov\ i<avol eiKvelo~daL (f>povrio-L e7r' ap.(p6Tpa, ra re

Koiva Kal tcl i8ta;
212. *Ap' ow '7rpos Atds, u>o"jTp at dAAai re'ât e7rt8e-
8coKacrt Kat etcrfc 7rapd rovs vvv brjp.LOvpyovs ol 7raAatoi
5 cpavkoL, ovtco Kal rr)v vp.Tpav ttjv tS>v crocpicrrco/y Texyrjv

iiTLbebcoKivaL cpco/xev Kal etivai t&v apyjiicov tovs irepl ttjv
o~o(piav (fiavAovs irpbs vpJas;
in. Tldvv piev ovv opO&s Aeyets.

212. Et dpa vvv r)pXv, S> 'I-nria, 6 Btas avaf$Loir\, yikcor
282 c\v ocpkoL ~rpbs vpJas, coo~iTp Kat tov AaibaXov cpacriz; 01
avbpLavToiroLOL, vvv et yevopLcvos TOLavT kpyatflLTo ola rjv
dcp' 8>v Tovvop? o~xv, Karaye'Aacrro/7 av ctvai.

IIT. "Eart p.\v ravTa, S> 2coKpares, ovtcos cos o~v Aeyets*
5 etco0a pAvroL eycoye tovs iraXaLovs re Kat irpoTepovs r)p.5>v
r-poTepovs re Kat /xdAAo/v eyKco/Aideiiv r\ tovs vvv, cvXafiov-

p.Vos p.h> q>66vov tS>v o>vtcov, cpo(~)ovp,Vos 8e p.rjvLV t&v
rereAevri/Korcoy.
b 212. KaAcos ye o~v, o> 'iTmia, ovopLafav re koI bLavoovp,Vos,

cos ewot Sokcis. o-vp.p.apTvprjo-aL 8e crot e\co drt akqOr) Aeyets,
Kat rco oyrt vp.5>v iTTLbdbcoKdV r) Teyyt) irpbs to ko.1 rd 8r//xdcrta
irpcLTTLV bvvacrOaL /xerd rcoy i8icoz>. Topyias re ydp ovros

5 6 AeorrtVos o~oq>Lo~Tr\s 8e?3po dcptKero 8r//zocria otKO0ez> 7rpe-
o-fieueov, a>s tKaz>coraros coz> Aeovrivoov tcl kolvo. irpa.TTLv,
Kat ez> re rco 8r/ju.cp eSocfez apLora et7retz>, Ka 28ta e7ri8eteis

TTOLOvp,evos Kal cTvvoov toXs V0ls \pf)p,aTa 7roAAd r/pydaaro
C Kat eAa/3ez> K rr^crSe rr/s 7rdAecos* et 8e /3orjAet, 6 r/uerepos

eratpos IIpd8tKOS ovros 7roAAaKts uev Kat dAAore br)p.oo~iq
d. 5 tV twc <ro(\>iffT&v T WF rwv ffotyiffrwv al. : secl. Naber (etiam

W
:
rcxvtjv secl. Cobet) a 1 câirJ' F et ex tprjfflv T : ^>airl
a3 e<rx ei' TF :
""X^ W : yp. e?X in marg. f) ivTW: om. F
as nivroi WF: fievroi ye T a6 irporepovs TWF: -rpArtpov
Schanz b 1 ovo/xdCwv T WF : vofxlCwv corr. Coisl. b 2 SoKeTs
TW So/cet F (sed s erasum videtur) b6 Aeovrivwv secl. Schanz
WF
:
b 7 M<- T W
ttfa /cal F
: e 1 cal ?\a(3ev T : secl. Cobet
inniAS MEIZGN 282C
dcpUtiTo, arap ra reAevrata Zvayyos a<pLKop.evos bi~p.oo~iq Ik

Ke'co Ae'ycov t iv rfj fiovkr} irdw r]vboKip.rjo~V Kal Ibiq
e7rtSetets Troi.ovp.evos /cai rots v4oiS crvvoiv xPVriaTa eAa/3e/v 5
6avp.ao-Ta dcra. t<2v be TTakaL<2v (KfivoiV ovbels 7rco7rore
r)ioicrt!v apyvpiov p.Lo~6bv irpaacrdai ovb' e7rt8etets ttoli]-
cracrOaL kv TravTobaTTOLS avOpcairoLS rijs kavTov crocpias' ovtois d

rfcrav evr\6et.s koX ekeXrfdei avTOvs dpyvpLov <as ttoKKov
<xlov cirj. TOVTOiv 8' eKarepos nrkiov apyvpLov airb crocpCas
etpyacrrat rj aAAos br~p.Lovpybs dcp' ^crrtôs Te\vr\s' Kal ert
irpoTepos tovto)v YipoiTayopas. 5
in. Ovbev ydp, o> ScoKpares, otcr#a rcoy Kak>v irepX tovto.
et yap dbeCr/s ocrov apyvpLov eipyao~p.ai eyco, 6avp.d<raLs dv
Kal tcl p.\v dAAa eco, dcpLKopevos be 7rore ets StKeAtW, ITpcora-
yopov avrodi f)~nbr]p.ovvTOS Kal evboKLp.ovvTos ml TTpecrfivTepov e
ovtos TTokv veoiTepos u>v ev oAtyco \p6vq> Trdvv irkiov 1] iTVTr\-
KOVTa Kal tKaTov p.vds i)pyacrdprjv, Kal e kvos ye yoipCov

irdvv crp.LKpov, 'Ivvkov, nkeov rj etKOcrt p.vds' Kal tovto ikdoiv
oiKabe cpipoiv rco Trarot eScoKa, cocrre eKeti>oi> Kat tovs dkkovs 5
7roAtra? 6avp.d<^nLV re Kat eK7re7rA^x^ at Kai <ryebov tl oXp.aL

e/ue 7rAetco \pi}paTa etoyacr&u rj aAAou? crvvbvo ovcrTivas
jiovkei tG>v crocpLcrT(2v.
2X2. KaAdV ye, co 'iTTTrta, Aeyets Kat jote'ya TKp.rjpLov
crocpCas ttjs re creavTOv kol tG>v vvv avdpcaiTOiV Trpbs 283

tovs ap\aCovs ocrov biacpipovcrL. t&v yap Troorepcou [7reot
'Avaayopov Ae'yerat] Trokkrj dp.a6Ca Kard tov crbv koyov.
tovvovtCov yap 'Avaay6pq qbacrl <rvp,(3rjvaL 1] vp.LV Kara-
ktLcpdzvTOiV ydp avT<2 Trokkcav XP rJriaTOiV KaTap.dkrj<rai k<u 5
6.2 e'A\^6 TF: \ f A^6( d3 elr; W TW et suprascr. yp. tXi)
FteTfojF apyvpiov F apyvplov T et re vera

: W d.4 ô-rtvosTW:
1\o-tivos fiov\fi F d 6 rovro T tovtuv W : F e i iwtSriiuLovvTos
TW et in marg. yp. F e 2 iro\v F Ka\ iro\v
itriH-qixrio-avTOs F
W
:
W
:
T Xpd v V ~~avv T F XP V V ~~o\v olim Stallbaum -Kavv XP VW '
W
: :
Schanz a1 TF:
om. a 2 Saov Sia<p4povat T W :
Sta<pepov(rtv So-ov rwv vvv F a 3 KvaJTay6pov secl. Sydenham (qui

'
irpoTfpwv ~~ipt) ~--p\:'Avaayopov om. Bekker irep\ Ava?ay6pov \4ytTat : '
secl. Stallbaum oq*

283a I1AATX2N02
airokicrai Ttavra ovrcos avrbv avorjra o-o<pitio-8aL Ae'youcri
8e nal irepl aAAcoi/ tG>v nakaiGtv erepa Toiavra. tovto uV

ovv pLOL Sokcis koXov TCKurjpLov d~ro<paiviv ITCpl <ro<pias T&V
b vvv irpbs tovs irpoT&povs, Kal 7roAAots crvvboKtl ort tov aocpbv
avTov avrG> /xdAtcrra 8et croqbbv -\Xvai' tovtov 8' opos corlv
apa, bs av 7rAetcrroi> apyvpiov kpydo-r\Tai. /cat raOra pikv
iKavu>s exerco* ro8e 8e uoi et7re', av avrbs itodev ttXho-tov
5 apyvpiov 7/pydcrco tG>v 7ro'Aecoy ets cxs dcpiKvfj; rj brjkov ort eK
AaKcbaifwvos, ol-rep kol 7rAetcrrdKis d<piai;
in. Ov uh tov Ata, co 2coKpares.

2X2. IIcos <prjs; dAA' eAaxtaroy;
C IIT. Ovbtv UV ovv rb -rapd-rav 7rco7rore.
2X2. Tepas Aeyets *at davuao-Tov, S> 'Irnria. KaC uot
eiTre'* iroTepov r) <ro<pia r) <rr) oi>x ota tovs crvvovTas avrfj
Kal uavddvovTas ets dprr)v /3eArtous 7rotety; III. Kat

5 7roAv ye, co 2coKoares. 212. 'AAAa tovs u\v 'Iwklvojv
vtls oio's re ^cr0a dueivovs 7rot?/crai, tovs 8e 27raprtarcoy
?}8wdreis; IIT. IIoAAoti ye 8e'co. 2X2. 'AAAa brjra 2tKe-
Atcorat /utev (ttl8vuovo-iv dueivovs yiyveo-Qai, AaKtbaiuovioi

d 8' ov; III. YldvTois ye' irov, co 2coKoares, Kat AaKeSat-
uovioi.< .2X2. Âp ovv xprjudroiv evSeta <pevyov Tr)v crijv
opaXiav; .III. Ov brJTa, e7ret tKava avrots eoriv.

y
2X2. Tt brjr av drj ort eTrtflu/xowres Kat ^xovtcs XP yl~
5 juara, Kat <rov bvvauivov ra /xe'ytcrra avrovs a>c/>eAeu>, oi)
-rXrjpr] cre dpyvpiov diri-nu^fav ; aAA' klvo, uG>v /utr/ AaKe-

SatftoVtot crou /3e'Artoz/ ar 7rat8evcretay rois avr&v iralbas; rr
tovto <pG>uv ovto), Kat cn) cruy^copets;
e IIT. Ov8' c)7rcocrrio{!i'.
a6 droT/ra] av&vriTa scr. Par. 1812 bi ow8o/cei T W : fwSo/cet

F (sed ovv supra e? F) b6 oTTep Heindorf: oo7rep TWF
C 5 'iwKtwv ci. Bekker Iwkivwp T Ivvktivuv W Ivvvivuv F
W
: : :
C 6 ô-Oo T F o7<r0a W TroiT/o-at T f : iroffi<reiv F di 71F:

W
W
:
om. T d4 dpeT7j$ post eVjfluôDVTes add. F om. T

W
:
d.5 ovtovs TF : aoToTs W d6 itA^dtj T : vKiiprt* : i-hfyris F

^TWiom.F d8o-uTW:om. F

lnniAS ME1ZX2N a83e
2X2. YloTepov ovv tovs viovs ov\ olos r fjcrda ireCdav ev

Aa.KcbaLiJ.ovL cos o~o\ crvvovres irkeov av ets apeTi]v iiTLbLbouv
r) TOLS kaVT&V, f) TOVS k(CvC0V TTaTepaS fjbwaTCLS TTtCdtLV 0TL

o~ol XPV irapabibovai paAXov r) avrovs eiTLp.eKeLcrdaL, direp tl 5
rcor veoov K-qbovTaL; ov yap ttov kcpdovovv ye rots kavT&v
iraLcnv cos /3eArtcrrois yevecrOaL.
117. Ovk otuat eyooye cpOoveiv.

212. 'AAAd p.r)v evvop.6$ y r) AaKebaCp.oov. III. Y1S>$ yap
ov; 2X2. 'Ev be ye rats ewd/xots tt6\ctlv rt/xtcorarov r) 284
aptTrj. III. Ylaw ye. 2X2. 2i) 8e TavTt]v irapabLbovai -
dAAco KaAAtcrr' av0pooiToov e7rtcrracrai. III. Kat 7roAv ye,

co 2coKpares. 2X2. 'O ovv KaAAicrr' eTTLOTap.evos iiTTTLKr)v
TrapabibovaL ap ovk av ev erraAta rfjs 'EAAdSoy /xdAtcrra 5
TLpQ>To Kal 7rAetcrra xprjp,aTa Aa/x/3di>ot, Kat dAAoc?t o7rot>
tovto cnTovbaoLTo; III. EtKo's ye.' 2X2. 'O bf) bvvap.evos

napabLbovaL tcl 7rAetcrroJj dta p.a6r]p.aTa ets aperfp ovk iv
AaK(baCp.ovL /xdAtcrra ri/u?jcrerai Kat 7rAetcrra epyacreraL \pr]- b
p.ara, av /3ovAr/rat, Kat ev dAAr/ 7ro'Aet fjrLS tu>v 'Ekkr]vCbu>v
ewo/xetrat; dAA' Iv 2tKeAia, 2> eratpe, otet p.ak\ov Kat ey

'IruKco; raura 7ret0co/xe0a, a> 'lTTTrta; edy yd/> cri/ KeAein/?,
7retcrre'oy. 5
in. Ov ydp TraTpLov, 2> 2coKpares, AaKeSat/xoiHots klvclv
tovs vop.ovs, ovbe irapa tcl eioodora TraLbeveiv tovs vets.
2X2. ITcos Aeyets; AaKe8at/xoz>tois ov iraTpLov opd&s
Trpa.TTLv dAA' eap.apTavLv; C
1IT. Ovk av cpaCrjv eyooye, co 2coKpares.
2X2. Ovkovi; opd&s av irpaTTOLev /3e'Artoy dAAd p.r) x^pov
TraLbevovTes tovs veovs;
IIT. 'Op&oV dAAd ^VLKr)v TraCbevcrLV ov vop.Lp.ov avTols 5
62 o3f TW om. F : n-eiOtiv post AaKfSaifj.ovi transp. F 64 t)
toOj aurir iroTepas F (sed in marg. >yp. to?s kavrSiv) a6 ottou

TW: oVot F ba jjruTFw: tl ris W b5 itnffriov TFw
W
:
marrtov t C4 veous T W : w'rs F C5 iraltievffiv^ iraiSuav

Ven. 189
284C I1AATX2N02
Traibeveiv, eirel ev lctOl, elirep tls akkos eKeWev \pr\p.aTa
ekafiev tto>ttot eirl 7ratSeucrei, nal p.e av Aa/3ety Trokv
Ixakio-Ta yaipovcrL yovv aKovovTes ep.ov Kal eiraLVOvo-LV
dAA', 6 Aeyco, ov vop.os.
d 2X2. N6p.ov 8e Aeyets, co 'J7nria, fikafirjv irokecos elvai r)
axpekiav; -IO. Ttflerat p.ev oi/xai axpekias eveKa, eviore be
Kat /3Ad7rret, eav KaKco? re#?) 6 vop.os. 2X2. Tt 8e'; o^x

cos ayadbv p.eyLcrTov 7ro'Aet ridevraL roy vop.ov o\ TL6ep,evoL;
5 Kat ayeu rovrov /xerd evvop.ias abvvarov otKetv; IFI. 'AA??0?7
Aeyets. 2X2.
f/
0rav apa ayaQov ap.apTaxjLv ol eTTLyeLpovvres
tovs vopovs TiQkvai, vop.ip.ov re /cat vop.ov r)p.apTr\KacrLV' r\
e 7Tcos Aeyets; IFI. Tco pev dxpt/3et Ao'yco, S> 2a>K/3ares, ovra>s
eêi' ov p.evTOL etcoflacrty av6pa>TTOL 6vop.a(eLV ovrco. 2X2.
Uorepov, co
c
l7r7rta, 01 et8o'res r) 61 p.r) ei8o'res; 111. Ot
TTokkoi. 2X2. Etcrtu 8' ovrot 01 etSoVes rdkrjdes, 01 irokkoi;
5 in. Ov brjra. 2X2. 'AAAd pvqv ttov 01 y et8o'res to

axpekLp.a>Tpov tov avaxpekeo~Tpov vop.Lp.d>Tpov rjyovvraL Trj
akrjdeiq ttclctlv avdpa>TTOLS' r) ov <Tvyyu>pels; III. Nat,

avyx_a>p(H, ort ye Tjj akr]6eiq. 2X2. Ovkovv cttlv re Kat
exet otVcos cos 01 etSores r)yovvTai; .III. Ilavv ye.

10 2X2. "Ecrrt 8e ye AaKe8atju,ovtots, cbs o~v (pr)s, a>c/>eAt/Aco-
285 repov ttjv vtto o~ov iraibevcrLV, eviKr)v ovaav, iraLbevecrdai
p.akkov r) rr)v eiTLxaipiav. III. Kat akr-drj ye Ae'yco. 2X2.

Kat ydp ort tcl cocpeAi/Acorepa vop.Lp.a>Tepd ecrrt, Kat tovto
Aeyets, a> ^lTnria; III. Et7roy yap. 2X2. Kard tov aov
5 apa koyov toIs AaKebaip.ovia>v veo~LV vtto *\7Tiriov iraLbeveo-OaL
vop.Lp.u>Tep6v eo-TLV, vtto be tG>v TTaTpa>v avopLO>Tpov, etiTep rco
oyrt V7rd croS 7rAetco dxpekqOrjcrovTaL. III. 'AAAd p.r)v dxpekii-
b flrjcrorrai, co 2coKpares. 2X2. Ilapavo/jtoucrty apa AaKeSat-
C6 tXirep T W tirt etirep F 07 iroAi fiaXiffTa T W /x<i\i(Tra

WF
: :
iro\b F d5 cvvo/j.las'] avofiias T (sed u supra versum)

d6 ol TF W
6 2 avdpwiroi Hirschig
om. &vdpwiroi : TWF
e8 Tf F:
:
yeTW
a2 imxwpiav T iirixwpiov F a 3 po/uj- W
W W
:
ftdrepa F vofjHKainpa T a 6 avofiwrepov T F avofiif/.<&repov :
W
:
a 7 aAAo ^V w<pi\i\Oi\o-ovTat T et in marg. f om. F :

HITTIA2 MEIZX2N 285b
p,6vL0L ov bibovrfs <tol \pv<rCov kol e7rtroe'7ro7're? tovs avT<2v

vels. in. 2i>yxcopco TavTa' boKels ydp pot tov koyov Trpbs
kp.ov Ae'yeti>, Kal ovbiv we 8et avrco (vavTiovaOai.
2X2. Ylapav6p.ovs p.ev 8?/, co eratpe, tovs Aa/ccoyas e?3p- 5

o-Kop,v, Kal Tavr et? tcl p.iyL<rra, tovs vop.ipuoTa.Tovs boKovvras
etrat. (TTaivovo-L 8e brj <re Ttpbs 6e<2v, <a 'IrnrCa, Kal \aipovcnv
aKovovTcs TTOia; r) brjkov br) otl (Kelva a crv KaAAtcrra
e7rtcrracrai, tcl 7rept ra aarpa re Kat tcl ovpdvia irddr]; C
in. Ov8' ottccotlovv ravrd ye oib' dvtyovTaL. 2X2. 'AAAa
7rept yecouerptas tl yaCpova-LV clkovovtcs; IIT. Ovbap.(2s,
eVei ov8' dptc9/Aeiv fKeCvcov ye, <2s Zttos (IttcTv, ttoXXoI
(TTLoravTai. 2X2. IIoAAot; apa beovaiv irepC ye Aoytcr/Acoy 5
avzyta6aC <rov (TTLbiKvvp.4vov. III. IToAAov ueVrot vr) ACa.
2X2. 'AAAa brjra eKeti/a a av aKpi/3e'crrara kirCaraaaL
av0p<ti7T<jov 8tatpeiz', TrepC re ypap.p.aT<jov bvvdp.cos Kal avX.- d
\aj3<2v Kal pv6p,<2v Kat app,ovL<2v; III. IToicoy, coyafle,
app.ovL<2v Kal ypap.p.aTcov; 2X2. 'AAAa rC p.r\v <ttlv a r)becos
crov cLKpo&VTaL Kal kiraLvovaLv; avTos uot et7re, e7ret8T/ eyco
oi>x dVpCaKCO. 5
IIT. ITept t<2v yv<2v, co 2coKparey, t<2v re r)pcocov ml t<2v
dv6pcoircov, Kal t<2v KarotKicrecoy, <2s to dpyalov eKrCadrraav

at 7roAet?, Kat <rvXkrtjSbr]v irdarrs rrjs dp\aLo\oyCas rjbLara
aKpocozrrat, coar iycoyti 81' avrovs r\vdyKaap.aL eK/xepaflr/KeVat e
re Kat eK/xe/zeAerr/KeWt 7rdi>ra rd rotaura.
2X2. Nat pd At", co 'iTnrCa, r\vTvyr]Kds ye on AaKe-
8atuoVtoi ov xaCpovcrLV av tls avrols airb 2o'Acovos tovs
dpyovTas tovs T/aerepous KaraAe^yr/* et 8e p.r\, 7rpdypar' dy 5
etx^? eKp.av6dvcov.
III. Ilo'0ei>, co 2coKpares; a7ra aKowas 7reyrr/K0i;ra
ovopLara aTTop.vrrp.ovVo-<a.
2X2. 'AAr/07/ Ae^yeiy, dAA' eyco ovk ivtvorrcra otl to
d 2 irotuv F : 7rfpi irotwv T W d7 t^ apxcuov T W : rapxaiof F

3 7 8t F: 7 Stj ^fTW 04 toi/s &px oyTas T W om. F
W
:
69 ivev6t)(ra TF : tv6ijo-a
285e IIAATX2N02
io p.vr)p.ovLKov (\(LS' ^ "
7
"'
*vvoS> otl etKorcos trot \aipovcnv
286 ol AaKeSat/xoVtot art 7roAAd ei'80'ri, Kal xp&vrai ooa-Trcp rats
npzo-fivTicnv ol 7rat8es 7r/>ds rb 7/8e'cos p.v9o\oyfjcraL.
III. Kat val p.a At", co ScoKpares, 7rept ye eTrtrriSerj/xdrcoi/
Ka\S>v Kal eVayxos avroQi r/rjSoKi/xr/tra 8tettoy a \PV T0V

5 z>eoy e7rtrrj8evety. eo-rt ydp //01 7repi ai/T&v irayKaKois Adyos
0-vyKeip.evos, Kal dAAcos erj StaKet/xevos Kat rots <W/xao-r
itpoo-xw - &e fiot eort Kai apxr) Totabt rts rorj Adyorj.
e7rei87) 17 Tpota r/Aco, Aeyet 6 Adyos drt Neo7rro'Ae/xos
b Neoropa epotro 7rotd eVrt KaAd e7rirT/8eTj/xara, a dj; rts
e7rtr7j8ewa? ve'os coz> eTj8oKt/xcoraros yivoLTO' /xerd ravra 8r/
Aeycoz/ ecrrtv o NeVrtop fcat viroTL0p.evos avrS> 7rd/x7roAAa

z>d/xt/xa Kal irayKaka. tovtov br) /cat exet e7re8eid/XT/z> Kai
5 ez>0d8e /xe'AAto kmb^LKvvvaL ets TpLTtrv r)p.ipav, ez> rco 3>et8o-
orpdroTj 8t8ao-KaAeico, /cat dAAa 7roAAa Kai dfta d/cor^s'
e8er/t^r/ ydp /xorj Etj8ikos 6 'A7rT//xdz>rorj. dAA' 07rcos 7rapeVr/
C *at arjrds Kat dAAorjs dets, oiriz>es tKaz>oi aKOTjVaz>res KpwaL

tcl Aeyd/xez>a.
212. AAAd rarjr' ecrrat, dz> 0eds 0e'Ar/, to 'I7r7rta. wrt

/xeVrot fipayy tl /xot 7repi avrorj airoKp tvat' Kal ydp /xe ets
5 KaAoy inrip.vr]o-as. t-vayxps ydp rts, co dptare, ets aTroptav

/xe Kare'/3aAez> ez> Adyots rto-i rd /xez> ^riyovra tos atVxpd,
rd 8' ZiraLvovvTa tos KaAd, orjrto 7rcos epd/xez/os Kat /xdAa
vfipLo-TLKSts' " Tlodev 8e' /xoi o-rj," etrjr/, " to ScoKpares, oto-0a
d 07rotaKaAd Kat alcrxpa; e7ret </>e'pe, exots dz> et7retz> tC eart
to Kakov; " Kat eyco 8ta tt)v Zp.r}V (pavkoTrjTa r)Tropovp.r)v re
Kal ovk zlypv clvtS Kard Tpoirov cnroKpLvao-daL' airLu>v ovv
eK rrjs crvvovo-Las e/xavrco re d>pyt(j6fxrjv Kai coyetStcfoi', Kai
5 r/7retAorji', 07rdre TrpS>Tov vp.S>v rco rtoy aocpSv evrrjxot/xt,
aKorjcras Kai p.ado)V Kai eK/xeAerr/cras teVat 7rdAty e7ri rdy
pu>T7]o-avTa, avap.ayovp.tvos tov Xoyov. vvv ovv, 6 Ae'yco,
^3 76 TW: Tt F b5 <peidoarpdrov T (piôo-Tpdrov F W

W
:
b 7 etfSjKos T evSoKi/nos F
: 03 0e\r] F ÔeAp T C 6 kot/- W
W
:
3oAtj/ T F KartffaWfv
: (sed \ alterum puncto notatum)
)
inntAS MEIZX2N a86d

ets Kakbv rJKeis, kgli jue bibaôv \kovS>s avrb t6 KaXbv otl
errrt, Kal 7retpco pot ort /xdAtrrra aKpLJ3<as et7reti> airoKpivo- e
fjicvos, p.i] eeAey)(0eis to bevrcpov avdis ye'Acora ocpAco.
olarda yap bijirov <ra<p<os, kv tto\/\G>v kiricrTacraL.
in. TjpuKpbv /ueVrot vi] At", S) 2coKoares, Ka\ ovbevbs 5

&lov, cos iros et7reu\
2X2. 'Paotcos apa p.a6i]<rop.aL Kal ovbeis p. eeAe'yet ert.
in. Oibels pAvroL' cpavXov yap av et?/ to ep.bv 7rpd y/ua
Kal IbLCOTLKOV. 287
2X2. E?j ye vi) Ti]v"Wpav Ae'yets, co 'iTnria, et yjeLpojcrop.cda
tov avbpa. drdp p.r) tl kcoAvco p.Lp.ovp.evos eyco eKeiror,

eay o-oS airoKpLvop.vov dvTL\ap.(3dvojp.aL to>v \6yo>v, tva otl
pdAtard p.e eK/xeAer?/cr?/s; crêbbv ydp tl ep.7retpo's etpt t<2v 5
avTLXrjxj/eoiv. et ow />t7/ tC <tol 8iacpe'pei, /3o?JAop.ai drri-
AapLJ3avr6aL, tv eppcopteveVrepoi' p.d6o>.
v
in. 'AAA' avTLkap.j3a.vov. kol ydp, 6 wi>5? / et7roy, ov
pe'ya eart to epwrrj/xa, dAAd Kat 7roAu tovtov )(ttAe7rcorepa b
ay cnTOKpivacrdaL eyco ae 8i8datp.t, cocrre p.r]biva dvdpa>TTo>v
bvva<rdai <re eeAe'yxeti\

2X2. 4>eu wj eu Ae'yets' dAA' dy , e7reior/ Kat a?j KeAevets,
f/>e'oe ort /xdAtcrra eKeu*os yevop.cvos 7retpcopat cre epcoTav. et 5
ydp 8?) avrco roy Ao'yoy tovtov e7ri8etdts oi> <p?js, rro 7rept
rcoy KaAcoi e7rtrr/8et;/xdrcoi', aKovaas, e7rei8?/ iravcraLo \iya>v,
epotr' av ov 7rept dAAou irpoTepov t] 7rept tov koKov e0os

ydp tl tovt \L Kat et7rot dv
"*X2 eVe 'HAete, ap ov C
bLKaiocrvvr] bUaLoi elcriv o\ otKatot; " diroKpLvaL 0?/, 00 'iTnritt,
cos fKeivov e/xorcozrros. HI. '
' XiroKpLVovpaL otl bLKaLocrvvr].

.2X2.
"
Ovkovv *<ttltltovto, r) bLKaLocrvvr];" IIT. Yldvv
63 irov TW (sed n suprascr. T) om. F (in marg. yp. irou f

W
:
6 7 &pa T f : afia F e8 bTW: om. F a 3 fx.ifiov/jievos

T
eyo) F iyw fx.tfiovfj.evos W a 5 yap tiTW: ti yap F a 6 /n;
W
:
tTF ju7? b 4 a\\' 07' scr. recc. aAAa ci n y'TWF

T F om. W
:
W
:
: t x* T 1f :
*x tlv F
PLATO, VOL. III. 30

a87 c I1AAT12N02
5 ye. .212. " Ovkovv kcu oo(pCq oi oo(poC eloL ooqbol Kal ra
aya6(o7ravTaTaya6aaya6a;" IFI. Il<Ss 8' ov; 212. "Ovcri
ye tlol tovtols' ov yap brjirov pr/ ovo~[ ye." III. Ovo~i
livToi. "'Ap' ovv
212. ov nal ra KaAd ixavTa r<S KaXSt
d eort Kaka; " in. Nat, t<S KaAai. 212. ""Ovtl ye tlvl
tovtu>; " in. Ovrr dAAd v
"
tC yap /ue'AAet; 2X2. " Et7re
brj, S) eVe," tpr/oeL, " tC eort tovto t6 KaXov;
v
in. AAAo ti ovv, o) 2coKpares, 6 tovto eptorcoy 8etrai
5 irv6ia6aL tC eort koXov;
l
212. Ov pot 8oKet, dAA' ort eo-ri to koXov, o> linrCa.
ITl. Kat tC bLaq>ipL jovt ZkcCvov;

212. Ovbiv ool boK-\C;
in. Ov8ei> ydp 8ta<pe'pei.
io 212. 'AAAd p.ivTOL brjXov otl ov kclXXlov olo6a. o/xws

8e, a>ya#e, &6pL' iptorq ydp <xe ov tC eort KaXov, dAA' oti
e eart to KaAoV.
in. Mavddvco, 6>ya6i, kol diroKpLVovpLaC ye avru> otl eort
to KaAoy, Kat otj /xr/ 7TOTe eAeyx#<3. eort ydp, S> 2toKpares,
eS i<r<9i, et 8et t6 dAr/<9es Ae'yeti>, Trapdivos KaXr) KaXov.
c
5 212. KaAws ye, S l7r7ria, z>r/ t6v wa Kal tvbo^tos
dneKpCvo). dXXo ti ovv, av iyo> rorjro aTroKpCvo>p.aL, to
288 pO)T(6p.(lv6v TC aTTOKKpLp.VOS OOp.aL KOL 6p65)S, KtlL OV p.1J
7rore eAeyx#<3;
III. 11(3? yap dv, S> 2wKpares, eAeyx#ei*?s> 6 ye irdoLV

boKL Kat 7rdi>res <xot p.apTvpt]oovoLV ol aKovovrcs otl 6p6&s
5 Ae'yets;
c
212. Etei>' 7rdi>j //,> ow. </>epe brt', a> l7T7rta, 7rp6s
ip.avTov dvaXdftoo o Aeyets. 6 pey epr/o-eTat pe ovto>oC tto)s'
""16l p.0L, S> 2a>Kpares, diroKpLvaL' ravra trdvTa a oSt)? KaAd
C6 Td/yafla d-yafld T W : rd dâfld F d1 ttfTi T W : -l<rt F

d2 AieAAei T W /le Sf? F
|
(eV fiAAip peWei in marg. f) d 3 87/

W W
:
TW:8eF dn ffrtTF: gr t e 5 ko\u- y- T :
Ka\b-' Ka\ov F e6 a-rvKpivw/Aai T : airoKptvov/j.at W : anoKptvofiat F

a2 woTe F om. T
: W
mniAS MEIZ12N 288a
flvai, et tl kcrTLV avrb t6 na\6v, Tavr' av et?/ /caAa; " eycb
oe bi] epco otl et irapdtvos KaA?/ KaXov, eart 81' b ratV av 10
etr; Ka\d;
IIT. Otet o?3i> eri ovtov e7rixeip?/creii' ae zktyytLv cos ou b
KaAdv ecrrii> 6 Ae'yet?, 17 iav e7rtxeip?/o-?7, ov Karaye'Aacrrov
ecrecrflai;
212. "Ort peu e7rtxeip?/aei, co 6avp.do-L, ev ot8a* et oe

e7rtxetp7/aas eorat Karaye'Aaaros, a?3ro oetcfet. a /xeWot epet, 5
eoVAco ctol Aeyeu\
in. Aeye 877.
M M
212. '12s yAuKV? et," cpT/oet, co 2coKpares. #r/Aeta oe
"
t7T7ros koAt/ otj KaAoy, 771; Kat 6 0eos eV rco xpt/cpw eTrf/recrer;
rt cp7/crop;ey, co 'l7T7rta; aAAo rt r/ cpcopey Kat r^v 1777701; KaAoy C
etrat, rrjv ye koAt/v; 7rcd? yap ar roApcopey ecfaprot etrat ro
KaAoy p.77 KaAoy etrat;
IIT. 'AAt/^ Aeyets, 00 2coKpares* eVet rot Kat dpflcos avrb
6 #eos et7rezr 7rayKaAat yap 7rap' rjp.lv Ittttol yCyvovTai. 5
" Etey," " "
212. cp?/crei 8t/' tl be kvpa KaA?/; ov KaXov;
crjcopei;, co 'IinrCa;
in. Nat'.
212. 'Epet tolvvv p.Ta tovt eKeu>os, a^bov tl ev olba

eK rou Tpoirov reK/xatpdpeyos* ""M2 /3e'Artcrre o-tj, rt oe yyTpa 10
"
koA?/; otj Kakbv apa;
in. '12 2coKpares, rts 8' ecrrty 6 avdpixnros; cos airaC- d
oeurds rts os ourco qbavka 6v6p.aTa 6vop.dC(LV roAp.a eV
rreprco 7rpaypart.
212. Totoirrds rts, co 'I7r7rta, ov ko/u.\//6s aAAa aupcperds,
a9 F I ti T
et ri : e-yi W . . . a 1 1 KaAa om. W aio e
Sydenham
secl. ci. post koAoV dist. Hoenebeek Hissink koKov
'
... a 11 aâ secl. Hermann iffri) tffri ri Schanz 6Y 0] 8<o

T W : choVj F b4 ei 8' T W 6V1 F c 1 oA6r fort. pr. F :
W
:
Ka\$}v T et corr. f F roXfiwfKv T c2 To\fj.^/xev W tapvoi

dvai T
f W
Qapvdxrtwv F
: cj /i))TWF: ôu
:
scr. Ven. 189

c 7 TWf:Td>F C9 M e T aTW: Ka2 M eTaF iJTWet
suprascr. f : om. F
30*
288 d HAATX2N02
5 ovbkv dkko cppovTiôov 7/ to akrjdis. dAA' opcos ciTTOKpireW
ru avbpi, Ka\ eycoye Trpoa7TO(paivopLaL' et7rep r) \vrpa KtKepa-
peupeVr/ efr/ vtto ayadov Kepape'cos Aeta Kat crTpoyyvkr] koll
KaAcos a)7TTTj/xeVij, otat tG>v KakG>v \VTpG>v dcri rtves biooroL,
tG>v t x" s \oipovcrG>v, TrdyKaAat, et rotavrr/i; epcorcor/
e \vrpav, Kakr)v 6p.okoyr]Tov etyai. ttcos yap av cpatp.ei> Kakbv

ov p.r) Kakbv eTvai;
in. Ovbapiios, co 2a>Kpares.
212. " Ovkow Kat xvTpa," cpT/crei, " KaAT) Kakov; ano-
5 Kpivov."
111. 'AAA' oiircos, Kpares, exei> ot/xaf Kakbv p*v Kal
tovto to crKevos eort KakG>s iipyacrp.voVy akka to okov tovto
ovk etmv &lov Kpivtiv cos ov Kakbv TTpbs Xttttov re Kat
irapdivov koll raAAa irdvTa tol Kakd.

289 212. Etev p.avddvoo, 00 ^limia, cos apa \pr\ dvTikiytiv
?
irpbs tov raura epcorco>ra rdbv X2 dvdpooTTt, dyvotis ort to
tov 'HpaKAetrou ev e^ft, a>s apa " Y\i6r']K(av 6 KaAAitrros ai-

or\pbs dv6pa>TT(t)V yeVet crvpLJ3dkkeLV," Kal x.vrpG>v r) KaAAttrrr/
5 alcr^pa Trapdivoov yivu trup./3dAAeii>, cos cprjcm; iTTirias 6

o~ocp6s. ov\ ovtoos, S) Itnria;
in. Yldvv p.ev ovv, co ^QOKpares, 6p6G>s aTreKpivoo.
212. "AKoue 877. perd tovto yap ev 018' ort <p7/cref " Tt
bi, co 2a>Kpares; to tG>v Trapdivoov yivos 6eG>v yeVet dv tls
b crvpLfidkkr], ov tovtov Tretcrerat 07rep r6 rtoi' \vrpGv rco raw
7Tap6iva>v o-vp./3akkop.evov ; ovx r) KaAAtVrr/ Trapdivos aicrxpd
(pavelrat; 7/ ow Kat 'HpaKAetros avrb tovto Ae'yet, ov o~v
<(,
<?7rdyr/, 6Vt Av6pco7TO)V 6 trotptoraros 7rp6s cêoy Tri6r]KOS
d9 irdyKa\cu T W : iraryKaKoi F 64 (ô-ei T W ^s f : t F

e 7 tovto rb tovto F TW e8 kTWf: iyF ai fj.avQa.vw
W ix
:
T W f navBdvwv
: (om. F Ang.) a 3 aVxpis ^T f : dP os
&4 avBpwirav ci. Bekker (avBpa>iriv Sydenham avdpwireiw Heindorf)
: :
&Wcp TWF a5 alaxpo. T W : val' ixBpa. F (a*Vx6pa COrr. f ) va\ :
alaxpa Ang. a 7 airtKpivw T W f : aneKpivov F b I ffv/xfiaWri

T W o-v/j.i3d\ai. F sed corr. f (fftyt/SdVUr; ^ Ang.) TJiWF: rb T
W
:
b3 aiiTb F : Tai/Tb T
:
inniAS MEIZX2N 28gb
cparetrat Kal crocpta xal KaAAet Kal rots aAAots iracrLv; '
5
6fxoXoyri<r(tiixv, 'iTnria, ri]V KaAAtcrr??!/ irapOivov irpos OeStv
yeVos alaxpav elvai;

in. Tts yap av avTeiiroi tovtm ye, co 2coKpares;
2X2. *Av Toivvv Tavra 6/u.oAoy/jcrcouei', yeAdcrerat re /cai C
epet* "*X2 2coKpares, pe'pzn?crat ovv ort r)p(oT-q0rjs; " "Eycoye,
v
cp?/crco, otl avrb to nakbv otl ttot4 ecrrti>. " E7reira," cp?/cret,
" ro KaAor arroKpLVtj 6 ruyxdêt

epcor??0eis oV, cos atros cprjs,
w
ovSei' paAAor nakov r) alcr^pov; " Eot/ce, c/jr/crco' ?/ fl pot 5
cnjp/3ot>Aevets, S) cptAe, (pavaL;

v
III. Touro eycoye* *cat ydp o? / 7rpo's ye t9eois ort ov KaAdy
to avdpanreLov yeVos, akrjdfj epet.
. 2X2. " Et 8e' cre r)p6p.r\v," c/>?/crei, " e dpx?/s tl ecrrt
koXov re /cat alo"xj)6v, et /xot a7rep iw aireKpLVU), ap ovk av d
dpflcos d7re/ce'/cptcro; fri 8e /cat 80/cet crot avrd rd /caAoV, a>
/cat raAAa Tra^ra Kocrpetrat /cat /caAa cpatVerat, eVetddy

TrpocryeVr/rat e/cetyo rd etSos, ro?3r' eti>at irapOevos ?/ i7T7tos
?/ kvpa; 5
in. 'AAAd peWot, co 2coKpares, et roCro' ye (^ret, iravTOiv

pao~TOV aitOKpLvao~6aL avrco ri ecrrt rd KaAw co Kat rd aAAa
7rdrra Kocrpetrat Kat Trpocryevop.vov avTov KaAd cpatWrat.
evrjdeoraTos ovv ecrrii> 6 avOponros Kal ovbev eiraici 7rept e
Ka\(av KTrjfxaTcov. Zav yap atrco arroKpLVTj otl tovt ecrrty
6 epcora rd KaXbv ovb\v a\Xo r) \pvo~6s, a7rop?/crei Kat ovk
e7rixeip7/0"ei o"e eAeyxei?'. tcrpev yap irov Tr&VTts otl ottov &v
tovto Trpocryvr\TaL, kclv irpoTepov alcrxpbv qâCvrjTaL, KaXov 5
"
cparetrat XP U0 ? y e
< Kocrp.r\6v.
b6 6/j.o\oyfiffoD/x.ev W : 6ixo\oyf)<rofj.tj/ TF 3 ante 'IirTria add.

Coisl. : om. TWF 07 yipF: om. TW C9 Se (T<= T Wf
8e 7? F d 1 3p' ou/c W : 4pa ou/c T ap' obic F apa
: Schanz : o"{
da rnTWf: 8rt F d3 ku\c\ T W raAAa F

: d 5 AiJpa
TW et suprascr. f: x^P ^ 01 d6 7 ^VrrerTWf 7' ^re F :
d7 riTWf: 8ti F 6 2 Kri)fid.ruv TW

70. ipwT7iiid.Twv : in marg.
T: (pwTTjud.Twv F (in marg. ^j/ SAAo(y KTTffiaTwv f) 84 n TWf:
76 F 65 /c&c F : ca( T W
289 e IIAATflNOS
Si2. Airtipos et tov dvbpos, o> 'lTnria, o>$ o-)(e'rAids eort
Kat o?38ev pqbio>$ dirobexdp-evos.

III. Tt ow roi)ro, o> SwKpares; rd ydp 6p0<2s keyop.evov
290 avayKr] avT<2 airohiyjzcrOai, r) p.r) dirobexopevijj KaTayekdcrTia
etVat.
SX2. Kat jLtej; 8r/ TavTrpj ye rr/y dtroKpLo-LV, o> dptare, ov

p.6vov ovk d7rode'<ferat, dAAd 7rdj>u pe Kat ra>0do-erat, Kat epet*
"'12 TeTV<po>p.eve "
5 crv, 4>et8tav otet KaKw etVat brjpuovpyov;
Kat eyw otpat ep<3 ort Ot38' 67ra>o-rio?3j'.
m. Kat 6p$G>s y epeXs, S StoKpares.

SX2. 'Opf9<2? p,evTOL. ToiyapToi eKelvos, fTreibav eyo>
o/utoXoyw ayadbv etvat br\p.Lovpybv tov <t>eibCav, " Etra,"
" "
b <pr/o-ei, otet tovto to Kakbv 6 av Aeyets r)yvoeL 4> et5tas';
Kat ey&v Ttp,dAiara; cpr\cro>. ""Otl" epel, " rrjs *A$r]vas
tovs 6cp$akp.ov$ ov xpvo~ovs eTroirjcrev, ovbe to dkko irpocr-
(tiirov ovbe tovs Trobas ovbe ras \eipas, etirep \pvcrovv ye
5 8r/ oy KakkLcrrov epeAAe <paivecr$aL, dAA' ekecpdvTLvov brjkov
otl tovto viro dp.a$ia$ er\p.apTev, ayvowv otl \pvo~bs ap'
Zo-tIv 6 Travra Kaka ttol&v, ottov av Trpoo-yevrjTaL." ravra ovv
keyovTL tl diTOKpLVo>p,e$a, o> 'iTnria;
C III. Ovbev xakeirov epovp,ev yap otl 6p$<2$ eTToir\cre. Kat
ydp to ekecpdvTLvov otp,ai Kakov ecrTLV.
2jLL. Lov ovv eveKa, <pr)<reL, orj Kat ra p.e<ra to>v
6<p$akp.5>v ekecpdvTLva r)pydo-aTO, dkka ki$Lva, o>$ olov t ijv
5 opoLOT-qra tov ki$ov r<3 ekecpavTL eevpo>v; r) koX 6 kiOos 6

Kakbs Kakov eart; " <pr]o-op.ev, a> 'lirTria;
IIT. <t>rjcrop,ev p.evroL, orav ye TrpeTroiv r/.
SX2. ""Oray be p.r) TTpeiTa>v, alcr^pov; " 6p,oAoy<S r) p.r);

c
III. Op,oAo'yet, orav ye p.r) TrpeVrr.
b6 e-fifj.aprev secl. Schanz XP V(T ^ S TF 6 xP vtr W

^> s b8 airo-
W
:
Kpivw/ifOa T : airoicpivSfXfda F c5 o/xoioTTiTa T W av9ofxoi6T7]Ta

W
:
F Ti> \e<pavTL T f t<j5 i\t<pavTivT/<rei, " S> d

o-o</>e o-u, o^x drav i^ v Ttpiirr], Kakd 7rotet (paiveadai, orav
5e pr\, alo~xpd; " efapvot iaopeda r) 6pokoyi]aopev avT<2

6pd<7>$ Aeyew avrov;
in. 'Opokoyqaopev tovto ye, ort 6 av TTpiiri] eKaorrcp, 5
ro{5ro koKov itoll exacrroy.
212. " ITo'repoi> ow irpeVet," c/jr/crei, " oray rt? rr)i>
Xvrpav rjv dpn ikiyopev, ti]v mki]v, ev/n/ hvovs Kakov

/xecm/y, XP vo~y Topvvr] avrr) r/ avKLVii;"
III. 'HpaKAet?, otoy Aeyet? dv9pa>TT0v, S> 2coKpare?. ov io
/3o7JAet /uot etVety rt? karLv; e

212. Ov yap av yrotrj?, et crot et7ro.t/xi Tovvop.a.
IIT. 'AAAa /cat vw eyo>ye ytyrcocrKco, ort apa6r}$ rt? ecrrii\

212. Meppepo? irdvv eariv, S> ^XTnria' dAA' o/uco? rt
<pr]aop.ev; Troripav itpiiriLV tolv ropvvaLV rco erret Kat rrj 5
XVTpa; 1) brjkov otl Tr)v avKLvqv; eva>biaTpov ydp ttov

to Ztvos Trotet, Kat dpa, S> eratpe, ovk bv avvTptyaaa r)piv
tt)v xvTpav eKê'at to Ztvos kol to irvp aTroafiiaeLev Kal roi/?
pikkovras ecrrtacrc9at dvev o\j/ov av irdvv yevvaiov 7roirjo-eiei>*
8e ^Ketinj TtdvTa av raSra 7rotT/o-etey, coor' epoLye 10

r)
XPV(r V
ooKety Ti]V avKLvqv r)pas pJdkkov <f>dvaL irpiireLV ?/ Tr)v xpvarjv, 291
et pr] tl av dkko Aeyet?.
III. npeVet pev ydp, S> 2coKpare?, paAAoi>* ov p.VTav
eycoye rco av0pb>i~v avaTripTrkaadaL, KaAco? p.ei> ovrcocrt ap.ire-
XO/xeVco, KaAco? 8e vTToheftepivu), evboKLpovvTL 8e cm croc/>ta
ei> 7racrt rot? "EAAr/crty. dAA' e/xot ovSey Trpaypa q^vpeadaL
d1 S <ro</>e <ri; T W
F (<lv &\\ois S> <ro<pe <rb in marg. f)
: < tiriria
d.6 tovto F: toCtoi/ TW
d.7 oZv F om. d.9 auTfj : TW
TWf: ai/TTj F e 5 toiv T F TaiV e 6 fvade<rTepov
: W
W
T f eV w 8* eTtpov F
: e 9 ttyou av tyov T F e 10 So-t' W :
tjxoiye SoictTv F: Ss 76 /to< Sone? a3 âp TW

ye F TWf:
^7 viroSeSefifvcf! TWf: viroDex ^" '
^"
a^ T<r< to?s TWf:
irAeioTois F
agib IIAAT0N02
b irpbs tov dvdpcoirov ep.e ovv TrpobCbacrKe na\ ep.r]v
x^P lv
airoKpCvov. " Et yap br) irpeireL ye p.d\Xov r) crvKtvrj rrjs
Xpvo-fjs" cpr]creL 6 dvdpcoiros, " ciAAo tl kol KaXkCcov av elr],
eTreLbi]irep to irpeirov, S> 2coKpares, KciAAtoy cop.o\6yr]cras elvaL
5 tov p.r\ irpeirovTos; " dAAo tl bpo\oyS>p.ev, a> 'linrCa, rr)v
crvKLvrjv Ka AAtco rrjs XP V0~V S zwaL;

IIT. BovAet crot ei7rco, co 2coKpares, o ei7rcoz> eti>at to KaXbv
d7TaAAafet? cravTov t&v ttoXKcov Xoyoov;
C 2X2. Yldvv p.ev ovv pjr) p.ivTOL TrpoTepov ye 7rpti> av p.oi
(LTTrjs TTorepav a.TTOKpLVcop.aL olv dprt ekeyov toIv ropvvaLV

TTpeTTOvcrdv re Kat KaAAtco etvat.
in. 'AAA', et /3ovAet, avrco airoKpLvaL otl r) eK ttjs crvKrjs
5 elpyacrp.evr].
212. Ae'ye br) vvvl 6 dprt e/xeAAes Ae'yeu\ ravTj] piev yap
Trj airoKpCcreL, [$] to Ka\bv xP vo~ ov cirat, ov5h' cbs
av cpco
eotKe ftot avacpavqcreTaL KaAAtov oV XP V0~$ V vkov ctvklvov

to be vvv tl av Aeyets to Ka\bv eti>at;
d III. Eyco crot epco. r]Teiv ydp pot 8oKets tolovtov tl

to Kakbv dmoKpLvacrQaL, b p.r]beTTOTe alcrxpbv p.r]bap.ov p.r]bevl
cpaveWaL.
212. Yldw piev ovv, w 'lirirCa' kol KaAcos ye vvv viro-
5 \ap.[3dveLS.
v
in. AKOve 877* 7rpo? ydp tovto XctOl, edv tls exv otl
avTeLTTT], cpdvai epie prjo' drtow eiraieLV.
212. Aeye br) cbs TaxicrTa 7rpbs 6eG>v.

III. Aeyco tolvvv det Kat 7rai>rt Kat iravraxov KaAAtcrrov
io etmt avbpC, ttKovtovvtl, vyLaCvovTL, npcopeVco v7ro rcoi 'EA-
b5 6/j.o\oya>fifv TWF 6fj.o\oyovfici> f b6 KaWiai rrjs xpvo^rjs

TW
:
rrjs xp v<r V s KaWiu F b7 W crot T oZv ffoi F b8 aavrbv

W
: :
corr. Coisl.
W
: ainbv : aurbi' TF C2
T F auTo W
0^ T F : otov W to?>/
TF : Torv C 4 avr<f : airSKpivat TW f aiVb
W
:
Kpivat F e 6 vwi T f : vvv F 07 |TW: ^F: secl.

Hermann riTWf: ti'F 6.2 /nrjBafxov /IriSevlTW : /xriSevl
yu7j5a,uoi F
TW
d4 Kal TF : om. W d 7 iwatetv F : e7rai'e?'
mniAS MEIZX2N 291CI
krivoiv, acpLKopevu) ety yrjpas, tovs avrov yovias reAei>r?7-

o-avras KaAcos TreotoreiAayri, vtto t&v ovtov Znyoviov KaAcos e
Kal ueyaAo7rpe7rcos ra<prjvai.
2X2. 'lov iov, ) 'iTXTtia, ?] davp.ao-Lo)S re Kal ueyaAetcoy
Kal dtcos aavTov etp?/Kas* koX vr) Tr)v"Hpav dyauat crov otl
p.OL boKtls euvoLK&s, KaO' oaov olos t et, fiorjueiv dkka yap 5
tov dvbpbs ov Tvyxp.vop.ev, dAA' t/ucojv br) vvv ko\ irkelarrov
KaTayekdcreTaL, V "lctOl.
in. Hovrjpov y , S) 2coKpares, ye'Aa>ra' orav yap Ttpbs

Tavra exT/ piev ur/oez> drt Ae'y/7, yeAa 5e', avrov KaTayekdaeTaL
Kal vtto t&v TrapovTutv avrbs earat Karayikao-Tos. 292
212. 'Icrcoy ovtcos exer tacos ueVrot e7rt ye raTvr?/ rfj
dtiOKpLcrf.L, cos eyco p.avr(.vop.ai, KLvbvvzvo-ti otj p.6vov pov

Karayekdv.
IIT. 'AAAd rt u?;y; 5
2X2. "Ort, dr ttjxt/ fiaKT-qpiav i\o)V, div ut) eKcpuyco cpeuyoiv
avTov, cv udAa uou icpLKecrdai 7reipdo-erat.
in. Ilcos Ae'yet9/ 8ea-7rdrijs rts crou 6 dv6po)Tr6s ccttlv, Kal
tovto iroLr]o-as ovk ay6r]crTaL Ka\ bUas dcpA?/cret; ?/ o?3k
ei'8tK0s vp.lv r) 7rdAtj earty, dAA' ea dotKcos tvtttclv dAA?/Aovs b

tovs 7roAtras;
212. Otv8' o7rcooriow ea.
IIT. Ovkow ococret Sikt/v dStKcos ye ae rv7rrcoy.
212. Ov uot SoKet, co 'iTTTrta, ovk, et Tavrd ye aTtOKpL- 5

vaip.r\v, dkka StKatco?, euotye SoKet.
in. Kat euot tolvvv 8oKet, a> 2coKpare?, e7ret0T/7rep ye

avros racvYa otet.
2X2. Otvkotj/v enrco o~ol Kal rj avTbs otouat StKatco? b\v
TVTrrecrOaL Tavra aTTOKpLvop.evos; r) ko\ av ue aKpLTOV 10

rv7rrr/0-ets; t/ 8e'cf?/ koyov;
e 1 iKy6va>v T iyySvuv F W : e 6 5r; vt/> T F j/Oi/ 5^ W

W
:
e 9 \typ T F AeVet: a 7 iQiKeadcu] in marg. KaToAajSeTi' T

a 9 ax^jfftTaj F axOffffrat T W
airax"^<reTaj ci. Naber h 1 ia
W
: :
T iav F (âc Ang.)

: b ir 8<= T f Atfeji/ F (Ae'{ej Ang.) W :
:
292 c nAAT&N02
C IIT. Aetzw yap av eirj, S 2coKpares, et p.r) bexoCprjv
dAAd tt>s Ae'yets;
2X2. 'Eyco trot epco, rbv avrbv rpoirov oWep vvvbr], ptporj-
p.evos Zkclvov, tva p.r) npbs cre Ae'yco pr]p.ara, ola Znelvos ets
5 epe epet, xaAe7rd re Kat aAAo/cora. eS yap lct6l, "Enre' pot,"

cp?/crei, " 2 2coKpares, otet ay dStKcos 7rArjyds Aa/3et7J, 6'crris
hi.6vpap.liov toctovtovl axras ovto)S d/xorjcrcos' 7roA?j a.iir)cras
airb tov epcor?7paros; " IlcSs 8?/; cprjcrco eyco. ""Ottcos;"

(pr]crL' " oi\ olos r' et p.cp.vr]cr6aL otl ro nakbv avrb T/pcorcov,
d b 7rayrt cp av 7rpocryeVrirat, VTrapyei eKetyco KaAco eti>ai, Kat
At0cp Kat cfvAa) Kat av6p(oir(a kol 0eto Kat 7rdcrrr 7rpdet
Kat 7rai>rt p.adr]p.aTL; avrb yap tywyt, to?j0pco7re, KaAAos
epcorco ort ecrrtV, Kat ovbev crot /xdAAoTJ yeycovety bvvap.aL ?*/
5 et /uot TTapKadt]cro Kl6os, Kal ovtos p.uAta?, /utr/re cora /xr/re

eyKe'cpaAoy e^cov." et ovtj <po/3r?t9ets et7roipi eycb e7rt rorjrois
rd8e, apa ovk dv dx$oto, co l7nrta; 'AAAd pe'i>rot Tobe rb

e KaXbv elvaL *lTnrCas ecprj* Katrot eyco avrbv r)p(aTu>v ovtms
ojanrep crv ep.4, b irao~L Ka\bv Kal det etrrt. 7rcos ovv t/Jr/s;
ovk dêcrr/, av enrco Tavra;

in. ES y' ow ot8a, 2 2coKpares, ort 7ratrt KaXbv tovt
5 etrrtV, o eyco et7roy, Kat Sdfet.
212. "'H Kat eo-rat; " cpr/cref " det ydp 7rou to ye KaXbv
KaAdy." III. ITdvu ye. 212. " Ovkow Kat ?/jj;
" <7j?/tret.
-in. Kat rjv. 2X2. "*H Kai rco 'AxiAAet," c/jr/crei,

'*
6
îvos 6 'HAeto? ecpr/ KaXbv etât ?3o-re'pcp rcov irpoyovaiv
io Ta(prfvat^ kol rco 7rd7T7rcp avTod AtaKco, Kat rots dAAots oo-ot
"
293 <?k c9ecoy yeydyacrt, Kat arjrot? rots deols;
C 2 &AAa 7r5s T W f oAA' 07rXcSs F 07 toctoi/toj'2 T W

W
: :
toutoÎ F c8 $}) T &y F sed

: 8ij suprascr. f (&? Sr) Ang.)
09 /xefivrja-Oai TW: fivnaQrivai F d 1 0] $ vel Si' o Stallbaum
d2 6e^5 T W : Oeia> F Trao ?;

-
F : a7ra(T?? T W d5 irapeKaOriffo
WF: TrapeKaQicro T (Uto TW: vovv F (in marg. /j.r)n &ra f)
64 eSTWf: (tu F e6 îTF: ^hJccj W t6 ye Ka\bv
Ka\6v F to ye ko\6v T P Ka\bv t6 ye Ka\6v
: : W e8 r) T W f
ei F fj 69 7;A.e?osTWf: 7}A.(os F
inniAS MEIZX2N 293^
IIT. Tt tovto; /3dAA' e? na.Ka.piav. tov dvOpdtirov ovb'
ev(prjp.a, 2> 2a>K0are?, Tavrd ye ra epu>Tr]p.aTa.
2X2. Tt de'; ro epop.evov erepov (pdvat raura ot/ra)? exy
ou TTavv bvcr(f>rjp.ov; 5
v
III. Io-coy.
" y Io-co? " o?
2X2. toCvvv crv et oi!ro?," cprjcreL, Trayrl <p7/s
Kat det KaAdi> eti>at V7ro p.ev raw Kyovu>v Ta(pr)vai, rovs be
yoêas 6d\j/aL' r) ov\ ets twv airdvToov kol HookAt/s ?/y Kat
"
ovs iwo?/ ekeyopLev irdvTes; io
in. 'AAA' ov rots 0eots eyu>ye ekeyov.

2X2. " Ovde rots rjpuxjLV, a>s eotKas." b
in. Ovx. dVot V* 0ea>v 7rat8es 7/o-aj/.
"
2X2. " 'AAA' oo"ot uj/ ;
in. Yldvv ye.
2X2. " Ovkovv KaTa tov crbv av koyov, a>s (paCveTai, tu>v 5
r)pu>o>v tu> p.ev Tai>rdAa> Kal r<S Aapbdv<a Kal r<S Z?/t9
beLvov re Kat dvocrLov kol alcr^pov eort, rie'Ao7rt be Kat rots .
dAAois rots ovtu> yeyovocrL Kakov."

in. "Euotye doKet.
2X2. " 2ot tolvvv boKel," cprjcrei, " dpri ovk ecprjcrda, to 10
Od^f/avTL tovs irpoyovovs racpfjvaL vtto tu>v eKyovoov evCore Kat
ev(oL$ alcryj>bv eu>ar ert be pukkov, a>s eoLKev, dbvvaTov C

Trdoi tovto yevecrdaL Kal etrat KaAoV, o3ore tovto ye uxnvep
Kal Ta epLirpocrdev eKelva, ?/ re Trapdevos Kat r) yyTpa, ravrbv

TteTtovOe, Kal ert yeAotorepoos rots ueV eort KaAoV, rots 5' ov
koAov. Kat ovbeiroo kol Tr]p.epov," <p?/<rei, " otds r' et, S> 5
2g> Kpares, 7rept roi! KaAod drt eort rd epu>Tu>p.evov diroKpC-
vacrdaL." raurd uot Kat rotadra dvei8tet dtKata)?, edv avrw
&4 (pofxfvov Bipontina tpufievov F (sed suprascr. tw f ) epurw-

:
W W
:
/xeVovTW a8 I T 5^ F iity6vwv T f iyy6v<ev F

W
: :
a 10 irdvTts T F irtij/Tos : b 10 <p-f)o~ei T f fiTjcrl/ F to W :
T W :tc3 F to t f (et sic Ang.)

: b n (Ky6vuv T iyyovwv W :
F C2 jr2o'< tovto TW: tovto irao-i F ê TWf: om. F

C 3 iKtlva F K?>/a T : W
C 4 yfAoioTtpws T F ytAoiortpois W : t
C 6 ipwTi&nfvov T f W
ipairrifjLevov ut videtur F
:
293C IIAATf2N02
ovtcos airoKpiv(a}xat. ra pez ovv 7roAAd, co 'linria, crxecW
d tl pot ovtco StaAeyerar evLore bk cotnrep ekerjcras pou ti\v
direLpCav Kal a7rat8eucriW ai)Tos p,oi 7rpo/3dAAet epcoTcov ei

TOLovbe /xot boKd etrat t6 Kakov, r) Kat 7rept dAAou otov av
XV Ttvv0av6p.evos Kal Trepl ov dv Adyo? $.
5 in. Ylu>s tovto Aeyets, co ScoKpares;

212. 'Eyco o-ot cppdcrco. "*X2 8atpdrie," cpr/cri, " 2co-
Kpares, tcl p.kv rotaura aTTOKpLv6p.evos Kal ovtco iravcraL
AtW yilp evri0r\ re Kat evee'AeyKrd ecrrir dAAd to rotdrae
e o-KoVet et o-ot SoKet KaAcV etrat, ov kcu vvvbr) e7reAa/3dpe0a
ev rfj aiTOKpLtrtL, r)vLK ecpap.ev tov yjpvabv ols p.kv TrpeireL
Kakbv etrat, ols bk p.r\, ov, Kat raAAa iravra ols av tovto
irpocrfj' avTO br) tovto t6 Trpeirov KaX tt)v cpvcrLV avrov tov
5 7Tp7TOVTos ctk6ttl et tovto Tvyyavti ov to KaAoV." eyco pikv
ovv etco0a cri>p,<pdrat tcl rotaura eKacrTOTe ov yap eyco otl
Aeyco crot 8' ovv boKel rd Trpeirov KaXbv etrat;
IIT. YldvTcos brjTTOV, a 'EcoKpares.
2X2. 2K07rcopet9a, p.r\ Trr\ dp e<fa7rarcop:ec?a.
10 IIT. 'AAAd xpr) o-kottclv.

212. "Opa tolvvv to TrpeTrov dpa tovto keyop.ev, o -rrapa-
294 yevo\xevov 7rotet emo-Ta <paLvecr0aL KaAd tovtcov ots dv irap?\,
r\ o etrat 7rotet, r\ ovberepa tovtcov;

v
IIT. Ep;otye SoKet [7rdrepa] 6 7rotet cpatyecrrat KaAd*
cocrirep ye eTreLbdv tpdrtd rty Ad/37/ 17 vTrobjjpLara dppioTTOVTa,
5 Kay r/ yeAotb?, KaWicov cpaiWrat.

212. Ovkow etirep KaAAtco 7rotet cpaivea-0aL 17 ecrrt rd
Trpeirov, a7raTr\ tls dv etr/ 7rept ro Kakbv to TrpeTrov, kol ovk
av etr\ tovto 6 ^p.et? (frjrovpei', co M7T7rta; ^pets pikv ydp trov
d 2 irpo$d\\et T W f irpo<rf}a\ei F d. 3 ?j/oi t^ /caXbi' TF

ri Kakhi/ elvat W :
d 4 Affyos T WF : 6 \6yos scr. recc. d7

:
fiev
TF : /x4vroL W d 8 euîfy T W f : evvorj F (u Ang.) e 6 âp
eX" TWf: irapfxw F aa owSeVepa] a/xQSrfpa ci. Sydenham
a3 7T(5Tpa secl. Baumann. Socrati tribuit Apelt o . . . as
ipaiverai Hippiae tribuunt Apelt Baumann a8 ixev ydp F :
ydp TW
inniAS MEIZ&N 294b
ckclvo i(j]Tovp.a>, <o Trdvra tcl Kaka 7rpdyp.aTa Kakd ccttlv b

coaircp <o irdvTa Ta p.eydka ecrrt /u,eydAa, rco vTTtpixpvTL'
T0VT<p yap ttdvTa /xeydAa eort, Kal eav p.i] (paLvnraL, virepixij
8e', dvdyKri avrols /u.eydAots etrat ovrco 077, <pap.iv, kol to

Kakov, <o Kaka. irdvTa IcttLv, dvT ovv c/jati/r/rat dvre p.r), tl 5
av etr/; to p.ev ydp Trpiirov ovk dv etrr' KaAAtco ydp ttolcl
(paCvto-daL r) Zo~tlv, a>s 6 crds koyos, ola 8' ecrrty ovk ea

(paCvea-daL. to Se ttolovv etvat Kakd, oVeo vvvbi] cIttov,
zdvTt (paCvrjTaL edvrt p.r\, 7reioare'oy Aeyety tC ecrrr tovto C

ydp 0]TOvp.v, enreo rb Kakbv (r]Tovp.V.
III. 'AAAd to TTpiirov, a> 2-coKpares, Kat etmt xat (paL-

vccrdaL Trotet Kaka irapov.
SH, 'ASwaroy dpa r<o oi>rt KaAd oVra /ar/ c/jaiVecr0at 5

KaAa etmt, irapovros ye rou 7rotowros' (paLvccrdaL;
III. 'ASwarov.
12. 'O/xoAoyr/o-o/xei' ovv roCro, a> 'iTnrLa, Trdrra rd ra>
ovrt KaAa Kal vop.Lp.a Kal e7rtrrr8eu/ji.ara Kat Socfdcfecrflat Kaka
etVat Kat (paLvzcrvaL aet irao~LV, r) irdv TovvavrLov ayvoelcrdaL d
Kat 7rarrcoy /xdAtcrra e/>u> Kat p.dyj]v irtpl ovt&v etrat Kat
181'a eKacrrots Kat 8r?/u.o<ria rats 7roAecrw;;

in. Oi/rco /uaAAoi/, co ScoKpares** dyi>oetcrt9ai.
2X2. Ovk dv, e? ye' 7ro?j r6 cpaLvecrOaL avrols irpocrr)v' 5
TTpocrrjv 8' aj>, et7rep ro irpiTrov Kokbv r)v kol p,r) p.6vov Kakd
e7rotet etyat dAAa Kat cpaLvecrdaL. cocrre to Trpiirov, et p.zv
to KaAa 7rotow eoriy etyat, to p.\v Kakbv dv etr/, 6 r//uets
(r]Tovp.ev, ov p.ivT0L to ye ttolovv cpaLvtcrdai' et 8' au r6

(paLvccrdai ttolovv (cttlv to irpiTTov, ovk dv etr/ to Kakov, e
bI (^riTovfMfv T WF fyTovfiev scr. recc. /caAa ^<ttj' TF /caAoc

W W W
: :
etTTat b3 nal hv *cal ai' : /c&j' T F vTreptxv Se T :
TW
:
imepex* 1 8&F b7^F:rTTW C8 d/j.o\oyfio-Ofi.ev et

suprascr. f dfio\6y>)o-ov ev F (sed corr. &fj.o\oyf)o-wfiev f) C9 vifiifia
W
:
Kal T : vofxifxa F d I ctypoflcrflat TWf: 8ia\eye<rOai F d.3 tica-

cttchs TWf: eKaarais F d8 Ka\a itoiovv TWf: Ka\oiroiovv F
fie v TWF : secl. Bekker e 1 <paivea9ai noiovv iartv T W f : irotovv
ioTi (paiveadai F

294 e IIAAT12N02
r)pcls (r]Tovp.V. dvai yap eKetW ye 7roiet, (paCvcr$aL de koI
[ttollv\ zlvat. ov fxovov Kaka ovk av ttotc hvvavro to avro, dAA'
ovbe akko otlovv. eAco/xefla 8rj irorepa SoKet to TTpiirov elvai
5 to cpaCvecrdaL Kaka ttolovv, t/ t6 etzvat.
in. To (paCvecrOaL, ep.otye 8oKet, co Sw/cpares.

>
2X2. Ba/3at, otxerat ap 17/xa? 8ta7rec/Ser;yo's, a> 'iTTirCa, to
mkbv yvSivaL otl ttot4 ecrrt/V, e7ret8?/ ye to Trptnov akko tl
ecpavr] ov r) Kakov.
10 IIT. Nat p.a Ata, S 2coKpares, Kat pdAa ep,otye droVcos.
2g5 2X2. 'AAAd p.ivTox, co eratpe, /177770) ye ava>p.ev avTO' ert
yap rtz>a eA7rtda e^co eKcpavrfcrecrOaL tC ttot ecrrlv to Kakov.
III. Ilayra)? 8r/7rou, co 2coKpares" ovbe yap yakeTrov Icttlv
evpeiv. eycb piev ovv ev 018' ort, et dAiyoz> yjpovov els epi]p.Cav
5 ckdcov cTKeât/jtr/y 7rpds ep.avTov, aKpi/3e'crrepoiv av avro crot
LTTOLpL TJ]S aTTCLCrilS 0,KpLJ3eCaS.
2X2. *A /xt) /ue'ya, co 'I-nrCa, Ae'ye. dpas 6'cra irpaypara

i]pXv r/8r/ irapecryjfKe' p.r) Kat opyLcrOev r)puv ert /jtdAAoy
b cnTobpq. KairoL ovbev Aeyco* cn /xey ydp ot/xat pqbCios avrb
evpr]crLs r eireLbav p.6vos yvr\. dAAd 7rpds 0ecoi e/aot) evavrCov
avrb eêvpe, et 8e /3oi/Aet, cocnrep w ep.01 crD^r/ret* Kat edv
p,ez> evptop.ev, KaAAtcrra eei, et 8e pr/, crre'pco otpat eyco r$
5 ep,r/ ru)(>7> cri> 8' airekOcov pqbCcos evpr/crets* Kat edz> p.ev vvv
evpcop.ev, dpe/Vei ovk dxArjpds ecrop.aC crot 7rvv0av6p.evos otl
rpj eKetro o Kard craurdy ecfr/jjpes* wi' 8e OkacraL avrb 6 crot
C 8oKet etrat rd KaAdy. Aeyco 8r) arjrd etrat dAAd ydp e7rt-
ctk6ttl poL Travv Trpoo-iyjov tov vovv p.r) 7rapaAr/pr/crco tovto

yap br) ecrrco r)puv Kakov, 6 av yjpr]crLp.ov
fj.
elirov de eK
62 76 TWf: om. F *al irote?j' eTôt TWF: /cal eTâi troie7v

Heindorf : iroieiv kcu elvai Hirschig : voieTv seclusi e3 t6 T W :
om. F a.\\' ovSe T W aWa ical ovSe F e8 8 ti irore T S rl

W
:
W
:
ttot' F
S rl rore
: e 10 arowus T F (sed o~k supra r W)
a 1 /xi)irwye T W
fjAynore F (sed t refinxit f)
: a4 5 T om. F W :
a5 avF: om. TW airro o~oi T "W avrb 01 F avrbsoôif b 4 /j.tv

W
:
W W
:
T F om. : b 5 ti/x?? T f tyvxv F ea' /uej/ F eav T

W
: :
b 7 8e] S^; Heindorf a6Tb <roi F ovt6 ei T a5 r6$' el Her-

'6 : :
mann C 3 yap T pev yap F W :

inniAS MEIZX2N 295C
T&vbe ivvoovLxevos' KaAot, </>apeV, ol 6<pdaXp.0L etmr, ov\

01 av boKcoaL tolovtol etrai oXol p.i] bvvaTol opav, dAA' ot av 5
bvvaroC re Kal xPW i
P- 0L irpbs to tdeu>. rj ydp;
m. Nat.
2X2. Ovkovv Kal to okov <r<2p.a ovrco Aeyo/xev KaAou
etrat, to pikv Trpbs bpop.ov, t6 8e 7rp6? Trdkr}v, kol av tcl
<2a TtavTa, lttttov KaXbv Kal aktKTpvova ml oprvya, kcll d

tcl CTKevrj TrdvTa Kal tcl oyr\p.aTa tcl re 7rea Kal tcl kv tt)
OakaTTri ttXolcl re Kat rptr/peis, Kal tcl ye opyava irdvta

tcl re i>7r6 rfj fxovcrLKr) Kal ra vtto rats dAAats reâts,
et 8e /3ovAet, tcl e7rtrrj8ev)uara /cat tovs vop.ovs, ayzbov tl 5
7rdrra ravra KaAd Trpo<rayop<iVop.<iv rco avT<a rpoVco* a7ro-
f3Kivo9Tt$ 7rp6s e/cacrroy avr&v fj TT<-<pvKv, r) etpyacrrai,
fl
Ketrat, ro p.\v XPW 1
P- 0V KaL J7 XPW PL0V t KCtt "npbs 6 XP 7/-
<TLp.ov Kal OTTOTe xpri<TLp.ov Ka\6v <pap.av elvaL, rb be Tami) e
ttclvtji a\pr\<TTOV alcryjpov ap ov Kal <to\ Sokci ovtcos, Sj
'I7r7rta;
III. "E/xotye.
'Opflcos dpa vvv Xiyopev otl rvyxdvL iravTos ov

212. 5
pdAAoy KaAoy rb xpW tPL0V in. 'Opflcos fxivToi, > 2co- >
KpaTes. 212. Ovkovv to bvvarbv eKao-rov d7repydecr0ai, els
07rep bvvarov, ets tovto Kal XPW L
P- 0V > T0 dbvvarov
dxpr\<TTov; 111. Ildm> ye. 2X2. Avvap.LS piev dpa KaXov,
dbvvapLLa oe alcrxpov; 111. 2c/>o'8pa ye. rd re yow dAAa, 10
3) 2coKpares, papTvpel r)pXv otl tovto ovtcos *X a drdp ovv 296

Kat rd 7roAtrtKd' kv yap tols ttoXltlkols re Kat rfj kavrov
7rdAet ro pey Swaroy etrat Trdrrcoy KaAAtcrroi', to 8e dbv-
varov TrdvToov atcr^tcrroi'. 212. Eu Aeyet?. dp' ow 7rp6s
c4 (pa/ifv TF : /j.iv W d 1 KaKbv secl. Schanz d 3 ir\o?a

re /cal rpffipeis secl. Burges d 5 t& TW ko\ ra. F d 7 irpbs
W
:
T f : om. F irpbs t> tKaarTov airrav ^ irfcpvKfv (tpyao-rai t) Kelrai

Apelt d8 Ka! p T WF :
$ Heindorf (al rj
1)
. . . ^7t^t6 xp^r'A">"
post d 7 Ke?Tat transp.' Baumannj e 1 Ka\<)v <pa/j.tv T WF : Kav
ut videtur suprascr. f (koAoV <pafi.tv Ka\bv Ang.) e 10 yovv F
W
:
ohv T a 4 TraWeoi' T airdvTUv F W :

;
296 a 11AATX2N02
5 0eS>v, 'l7T7rta, 8td Tavra Kat r) (ro(f)(a ttclvtcdv kclKKkttov, r)
8e aixadia ttclvtcov alo~)îo-TOV III. 'AAAd tL otet, a> 2co-

Kpares;
2X2. "Ex e ^ 7) 77P e'/xa > * </>i'Ae eraioe* cbs c/Jo/3orj/xai tl ttot
av kzyop.ev.
b in. Tt 8' arj c/Jo/3r/, cb 2coKpares, eVet w ye crot 6 Adyo?
TrayKaAcos 7rpoj3e'/3rj/ce;
2X2. BorjAot/xr/v dv, dAAd /xot ro'8e avviTtio-Ki^rai' ap av

rts ti TroLi]o-ei(v b p.r]T e7rcrrairo pr/Te to Tiapaitav bvvavro;
5 in. Ovbapcos' ttcos yap av 6 ye p.r) 8rjVatro; 2X2. Ot

ovv eap.apTavovTs Kal KaKa pya(pp.evoL re Kai 7rotorji>res
&kovtS, akko rt oilrot, et /xr/ eSrjjjavro rarjra 7roteu>, ovk clv
7rore kiroiovv; .III. Arjkov 8r/. 2X2. 'AAAa /xeWot bvvdpeL

C ye bvvavraL ol bvvdp.evoL' ov ydp ttov dbvvap.La ye. III.
Orj brjra. 2X2. AvvavraL oe ye 7rdi/res 7roteiv ot ttolovv-

Tes a ttolovctlv; IIT. Nat. 2X2. Ka/ca 8e ye 7roArj 7rAetco
ttolovctlv rj ayaOa irdvTes avOpcoTTOL, apdp.evoi e/c TraCbcov,
5 /cat kâp.apTavovcrLV clkovtgs. IIT.

v
Ecrri Tavra. 2X2. Tt
ovv; TavTr\v tt)v bvvap.LV kol TavTa tol ^pr/crt/Aa, a av r/ eiTL
to KaKov tl epydecr0ai \pr\o~Lii.a, apa cpr)o-op.ev Tavra elvaL

d. /caAd, r/ 7roAAorj 8et;- III. IToAAorj, e/xotye So/cet, cb 2co-
/cpares. 2X2. OrjK apa, S> 'I7r7rta, rd Swardy re /cat rd
Xpr)cTLp.ov rjp.lv, cos eoLKev, ecrrt rd KaAoV.
in. 'Edz> ye, a> 2coK/rares, ayada bvvrjrai xat eVt rotaGra
5 XPW 1
P- 0V V'
2X2. 'EKetvo /xey tolvvv otêrat, ro 8wardv re Kat XP7/-
0-Lp.ov airkcos eirjat KaAoV dAA' dpa rorjr' r)v eKelvo, co 'Itt-
TTLa, o e/3orJAero r//xcoy r/ û)(r) et7reti', drt r6 xPy] <TlP-'v Te

Kal t6 bvvarbv eVt rd ayadov tl 7rotr/crai, ro{5r' ecrrt to
e koKov; in. v
E/Aotye 8oKet. 2X2. 'AAAd p.i)v tovto ye
ui<ptkLp.6v o-tlv. t) ov; IIT. Yldvv ye. 2X2. Ovrco 8r/
a5 iinrla TF : 3 Ivwia W a6 5 T om. F W : a9 Kfyo/j.tv']
\4ywfjLtv Stephanus b 3 poiTW: om. F b4 (itio-raiTo

T W : imo-Tarat F c 3 yc T W
om. F c6
: & T W f : om. F
:
inniAS MEIZX2N 296 e
<al ra mkd rrco/xara ml ra Kaka vop.Lp.a Kal r) o-oc/na kol

a vvvbr) eAe'yo/xe/' iravra Kakd eoTtr, otl coc/)e'Atjua. III.
Arjkov ort. 212. To QXp(:kLp.ov dpa eoiKtv r)puv elvai to 5

Kakov, & 'I7r7rta. .111. YIclvtoos 877770JJ, co 2coKoares.
212. 'AAAa p.r)v to ye coc/Je'At/xoz; to ttolovv dyaOov eoriv.
in. v
Eoti ydp. 212. To iroioui' 8e' y ecrrty ovk akko
tl r) to oltlov 77 ydp; 117. Ovroos. 212. ToC dyaOov dpa
aiTLOv io~TLV to Kakov. in. v
Eort ydp. 297
'1
2X2. 'AAAa p.r)v to ye atrtoy, co 771710, koi ov av oXtlov
77 to avrLov, dkko eVri/r ov ydp ttov to ye atrtor airiov
atrtoy av etrj. co8e 8e crK077er ou to oltlov ttolovv Zcpdvr);
in. Yldvv ye. .2X2. Ovkovv vtto tov ttolovvtos 770teirai 5
ovk dkko tl r) to yLyv6p.evov, aAA' ov to itolovv; IO.
v
Eoti ravra. 2X2. Ovkovv akko tl to yLyv6p.evov, dkko
8e to itolovv; 1IT. Nat. 2X2. Ovk dpa to y oXtlov oXtlov
alrCov kcTTLv, dkka tov yLyvop.ivov vqb? kavrov. IFI. Yldvv b
ye. 2X2. Et dpa to Kakov o~tlv atrtor dyaOov, ytyvotr' av
vtto tov Kakov to dyaOov koi 8ta ravra, cos eotKe, 0-770V-
bd(op.(\v Kal rr)v <pp6vr)o-LV Kal rdkka irdvTa ra KaAa, ort
to ipyov amQiV Kal to (Kyovov cnrovbacrTov ecrrt, to dyaOov, 5
Kat KivbvvevL e cSy evpCo-Kop.v iv iraTpos tlvos ibia etrat
to Kakov tov dyaOov. III. Yldvv p.\v ovv KaAcos yap
Ae'yets, co 2coK/>are?.
2X2. Ovkovv Kat Tobt koAcos Ae'yco, ort ovt 6 irarrjp vos
(cttlv, ovt 6 vos TTarrjp; III. KaAcos /xeVrot. 2X2. Ovbt- c
ye to oltlov yLyv6p.(vov earty, ovbe to yLyv6p.evov av oXtlov.
III. 'AAt70t/ Ae'yety. 2X2, Ma Ata, co aptcrre, ovbt dpa
to koXov ayaOov ecrrty, ovbe to dyaOov Kakov r) boKcl o~oi
64 8t T W marg.
et in f F sed punctis del. f
: koX 69 &pa
aXri6v ioriv T F sed post add. /cocttou f {&p' tKaarov Ang.)
&pa. &pa :
tanv alrtov W a3 alriov) avrov Dobree (et mox b 1) a 8 iroiovv

T W : TroLov/xtvov F y' T om. F W : b 5 ItKyovov T f W
tyyovov F b6 iv F om. TW ISta TW: elSia F (J ISia
Ka\bf W
:
Ang.) e 4 ko\6v tj corr. Coisl. : i? Ka\6v f) T : ^

KaAbr F <ro of<{' TWf : aot ov F (cro Ang.)
PLATO, VOL. III. 31
W :
297 c IIAATX2N02
5 otoV re eivat k t&v 7rpoeipi7p.eVa>v; IIL Ov pd r6v Ata,
ov poL cf)aCvTai.
2X2. 'Ape'a-Ket ow ^fxiy Kat e0e'Aotpei> av Ae'ye> <ws ro
Kakbv ovk dyadbv ovbe to ayaObv koKov;

III. Ov pa rov Ata, ov irdvv poL dpe'o-Kei.
10 212. Nat /ua roy Ata, S 'ImrCa' ipol bi ye Trazmoy
d r/Ktora apicrKti Stv elpr\Kap.ev koyoiv.

v
III. EotKe ydp ovrois.
2X2. Ktv8w>e?Jei dpa ^/xtr, oi>x axnrep dprt icpaCveTO KaA-
Ataros etvat t&v Xoycov to a><pe'Atp.oi> Kal to xpr]o~Lp6v re
5 Kat to bvvarbv ayaOov tl 7tollv Kakbv

ctvaL, o^x ovto}S
exetv, dAA', et otoV re icmv, iKtCvoiv eu>at yeAoioVepos r<5i>

irp&Tobv, iv ols rrjv re Trapdivov <L6pe6a zTvaL ro koXov kol
V f-KaCTTOV TU)V pTTpOO~dV \.tydtvTOiV.
v
in. EotKei/.
io 2X2. Kat eya> peV ye ovk ert ex<o, w 'lirnia, ottol Tpd-
Ttoipai, dAA' a-nopGf o~v 8e ex ets rt Aeyety;
e m. Ovk ei> ye r<2 irapovTL, dAA', <2o-7rep dprt eAeyoi>,

o~K\j/dpVos ev otd' 6Vt evprjo-oi.
2X2. 'AAA' eyoi) pot 6ok<S V7r6 iTTLdvpCas tov dbevat ovx
oXos re <re etrat 7reptpeVetz> pikkovTa' kol yap ovv br) rt
5 Kat ot/xat dprt rjvTToprjKivaL. opa ydp' et 6 dy yaCptLV r)pas

7TOIT/, /XT/rt 7rdo-as rds r)bovds, dAA' 6 dy dtd ri^s aKor/s Kat
Trjs oxjreois, tovto <pat/xei> etz>at Kakov, tt&s tl dp av aytovL-

c
298 otp,e#a; 0? re ye' 7rou KaAot dvdpoaiTOL, ai l7T7rta, Kat rd
7rotKtA/xara 7rdz>ra Kat rd (a>yp a(t VlxaTa Ka ' Ta 7rAdo-/mara

>
re'p7ret 7/juas 6p5>VTas, a av KaAd ?/ Kat ot qbdoyyoL ol KaXol

Kal r) povcrLKr) o~vp.TTao~a kol ol Ao'yot Kat at p.vdoX.oyCaL
5 ravroz/ ro{iro epyd^byrat, ojot' et anoKpLvaCpeda r<3 dpao-el
C 5 tJ' T om. F W C 7 rjixiv T W /cal tj/uv F d6 ye\oi6repos

W
: :
F: ye\oi6repov T W d8 t/xirpoo-Oev T irpocrQev F d 10 koI

W
:
T W : om. F foroi T : &Vtj F (sed corr. F) e 2 oTS' T F

TWf:
5' 0I8' ^3 <p06yyoi TWf: (/>0otToi F as 0pao-7
opdaei F
inniAS MEIZI2N 2g8a
KeCv(o av6p(0ir otl *X2 yevvaie, to nakov ecrrt to bi aKofjs

re Kal bC o\/fecos f)bv, ovk av olcl avrov tov dpacrovs em-
(r\oip.ev;
IIT. 'Ep,ot yovv boKi vvv ye, a> 2coKpares, eu Aeyecrflat

t6 Ka\6y 6 (o~tiv. b
2X2. Ti 8'; dpa ra TTLTr}bevp.aTa tcl KaAa Kal tovs vo-
p.ovs, w 'linTia, ot' aKorjs f) 8t' 6\j/ecos <pT/crop.ei> T/8e'a 6Vra
KaAa etvat, t/ aAAo rt et8os cx LV >
ITT. Taura 8' tcrtos, co 2coKpares, Kai> 7rapaAd0ot roy 5
di>#pco7ror.
212. Md r8p Kvva, Si 'lirTTLa, ovx 6V y av eyco p.aAiora

aio-)(yvoLp.r]v krjp&v kol Trpoo-rroLovp.v6s tl Ae'yeu> p.r]bev
Aeycoi/.
in. Ttra tovtov; 10
212. T6i> *2torf>povLCTKov, os epot 0Tj8ez> av p.dX\ov ravra

(TTLTpeTTOL dvepevvrjTa ovTa pabCcos Ae'yeu> 7/ co? et8dra a /ut/ C
ot8a.
in. 'AAAa //T/y epotye Kat avrco, e7ret8r) crt/ et7re?, 8oKet
rt aAAo eti>at tovto to 7rept tovs vop.ovs.
w
212. Ex' f)crv\f], co 'iTTTrta' KLvbvvevop.ev ydp tol, kv tt/ 5
auTT/ e/x7re7rrcoKores a7ropta 7rept rou KaAou ez> T^7rep vwSt?,
otetrflai ei> oAAtt rtin eviropLq eti>at.
in. ITcos roirro Ae'yets, co 2coKpares;
212. 'Eyco crot cppacrco o y' ep,ot Kara<patz>erat, et apa rt
Ae'yco. raura p:ez> ydp tcl irepl tovs vop.ovs re Kat tcl e7rtrTj- d
8et>fxara rd\ av (paviCrj ovk cktos ovra rfjs atcrc^T/crecos t/
a 7 8' oif 6cos TF aurJi' T

fycais W F avrwv f (aiirw Ang.) W :
W
:
6pi(rovs T f: a 9 ûol yoCi' F efxoiye olv T

hpdffovs F : W '
76 F: om. TW bi 2 ^Tii-TWf: 6n tari F b3 rjSta

ovra TWf 8rj\ov Sri F (fj $rj\ov '6ri Ka\a tlvai TjSeaAng.)
: f) h 5 8'
TF:8^W b7 7'ai/TW: yap F b 10 nVa C 2 oI8a . . .
secl. Schleiermacher bn rbv F awKparr\ rbv T f ei îrt- W

W
:
rptiroi T tirtrpciroifv
: imrptirei F P : C 6 j/wStj scr. recc. :
8^ 1'D' T FW c 9 7' fytol F 76 /uo T d 2 ovk secl.

: W
Stallbaum
31*
:
298 d nAATilNOS
8td r?/s aKor/s re Kat otyecos f)p.1v ovcra rvy\dveL' ciAA'
VTrop.eLvcop.ev tovtov tov Koyov, to bid tovtu>v f)bv KaKbv

5 etvai, p.r)bev to tQ>v v6p.cav ets p.e<rov Trapdyovres. dAA' et
fjjxas epovro elre ovtos bv Keyca, etre dAAos octtlo-ovv "Tl

br), co 'iTTiria re Kat ScoKpares, dcrjcopicrare tov r)beos to
ravTr) f)bv
fj
Keyere KaKbv etVat, rd be Kara rds dAAas
e atcrflr/creis ctltu>v re Kat ttotcov Kal tS>v rrepl rdc/>po8tcrta Kat
raAAa 7rdyra rd TOLavra ov <pare KaAd etyat; r\ ovbe fjbea,
ovbe fjbovds to itapanav ev rots rotovrot? <pare etivat, oib'

c
ev dAAco f) rco Ibelv re Kat aKOixrai;" tl <pr)<rop.ev, u> l7T7rta;
5 in. TlavTcos br)Trov <pr)<rop.ev, co ScoKpares, Kat ev rots

dAAots ueydAas 7rdru fjbovas etrat.
2f2. " Tt ovv," <pt)<reL, " fjbovas ovcras ovbev rjrrov f)
kol eKeivas d<paLpeL<r6e tovto rovvop.a Kal a7rocrrepetre tov
299 KaAds eti>at;" "Ort, <pri<rop.ev, KarayeAcor/ av f)p.5>v oi35ets
oarts ov, et <paLp.ev mt/ f)bv eTvai <payeXv, dKKa KaAd^, Kat
oCeiv f)bv p.f) fjbv dAAd KaKov rd oe' 7rou 7rep2 ra dcppoStcrta
Trdvres av f)p.LV p.dyoLvro cos r/8icrroy ov, beXv be avro, eav
5 rts Kat 7rpdrr?7, ovrco 7rpdrrety cocrre pvqbeva opav, cos
atcr^tcrro^ ov 6pd<r0aL. ravra f)p.G>v Keyovrcav, cb l7T7rta,

" Mav0dvcj)" av tcrcos <pair), " Kat eycb drt 7rdAat atcrxwecrfle
ravras rds fjbovas <pdvaL KaAds etmt, ort ov boKel rots

b av0pa>TTOLS' dAA' eycb ov ro{5ro r)p<aT<ov, 6 8oKet rots 7roAAois
KaAdy etrat, dAA' drt ecrrty." epovp.ev bf) otuat o7rep V7re-
Bep.e6a, otl " TovO' r/wets ye' <pap.ev to uepos rou fjbeos, to
eirl tt) drêt re Kat aKor) yvyv6p.evov, koKov eTvai. dAAd
5 ex et? ^rt Tt XPy~O ai r ôyw, t/ rt Kat dAAo epovp.ev, co 'I7r7rta;
d4 xmonilvwfiev TW viro/iieivof>.ev F d 8 Aeyere scr. Laur.

WF
:
vii. 85 \eyerai T e8 of/(Tas post (Ktlvas iterat F axpaipeTade

T
:
acpaipuaOai WF a r KarayeXcpT}, F Karaye\cj> T W a 2 6i
W
: :
TW eS troi F a3 m^ T F /i}8' : &4 Betv Heindorf

W
:
8e? T WF auTo ei/ T f a&Toy &v F : a7 ixavddvco

W
TW:
/xavBdvcofiev F &/ fo-ois T W
fcrws &> F
: b2 aAA.' Stj T : aAAa
'
t F b5 Ixejs t Tt scripsi : % en F (suprascr. xs :
X JS T4
TW (sed eri in marg. t) fj riTF ertW :
inniAS MEIZX2N 299 b
in. 'AvdyKt] irpos ye ra elpr)p.va, <o 2coKpares, p.r) aAA.'
a.TTa ravra keyeiv.

f)
2X2. " Kak<os br) Aeyere," c/rr/o-et.

" ovkovv etrrep to
bi otyeco? Kal a.Kor)$ f]bv Kakov e<rrLV, p.i) tovto Tvyyjivei C
ov t<ov i)becov, bfjkov otl ovk &v Kakbv etr/;" 6p.okoyr)crop.ev;
in. Nat.
212. "*H ovv to 81' ov/recos i)bv," <pr]<reL, " bC otyecos
Kal aKor)s ecrrty i)bv, f) to 81' aKofjs f)bv 81' aKofjs Kal 8t' 5
oxpecos ccttlv f)bv" Ovbap.cos, <pr)<rop.V, to 8ta tov erepov

ov tovto 81' ap.<poTepcov etr/ av tovto yap boKels i)pXv ke-
yeiv~a\\' fjp.els ekeyop.ev ort kol eKarepov tovtcov oxjto
Ka9* avro tcov fjbecov Kakov elt], Kal dp.<pOTepa. ov\ ovtcos
CLTTOKpLVOVpLtOa; 10
in. Udvv p.ev ovv. d

212. "*Ap' ovv," <pr]<reL, " i)bv i)beos otlovv otovovv 8ta-
cpepet tovtco, Tto fjbv elvaL; p.f] yap et pet^coz; tls f)bovf) i]
eAarrcor f) p.dkkov r) fJTTov <ttlv, dAA' et tls avrcp tovtco
bLa<ppL, T(0 f) p.V fjbovf) etWl, f) be p.f) f]bovr), TCOV f)bo- 5
vcov" Oix fjfuv y* boKet' ov ydp;

in. Oi ydp ovv boKtl.
2X2. " Ovkovv," <pr)<rei, " 81' dkko tl fj ort f)bovai etcri
TTpoeCkecrOe ravras ras r)bovas K t(ov dkkcov fjbovcov, tolov-
TOV TL 6p<OVTS eV dp.<pOW, OTL e\OV<TL TL 8ta<pOpOy TCOV e

dkkcov, ds 6 aTrofSkeirovTes Kakds cpare avras etrat; ov
ydp ttov 8ta tovto KaA.77 eorty f)bovf) f) 8ta Trjs oêcos,
ort 81' d\j/ecos <ttlv et ydp tovto avrfj f)v to atriop
Kakfj etvaL, ovk dv ttotc f)v f) tTtpa, f/ 8ta rfjs aKofjs, 5
Kakrj' ovkovv ecrrt ye bi otyecos f)bovrj." 'Akridf) kiytis,

<pr]crop.ev;
b6-yTW: T eF b8 $}) TW yc 5^ F C 1 tovto

W
:
T W rovrov F G5 Si' otytais TF : 6tyews C 8 Tovrtev

W
:
TW : avruv tovtwv F C 10 d.iroKpivovfneda F : airoKpiv<b/j.e6a T

d4 1) /jiaWov }TW: om. F tt tis avrcj) rovrtp T W f : ^7rl eavra V
d8 5i' TWf: *)5'F rt TW : irfn F eêts^TWf:
0I0S' F e 3 vov F : 7rai T W
:
299 e FIAATX2N02
in. ?/<ro/>tei> ydp. .
300 2X2." Ovbi y av r) ot' aKorjs r)bovr\, otl bC aKorjs errrt,

otd ravra TvyydvtL KaXrj' ov yap av irore av r) otd Tr)s
oxjseais KaXr) r)v ovkovv ecrrt ye bt aKorjs i)bovr]." akrjOr)
<pr]<rop.ev, co 'liTTTLa, Ae'yeti> tov avbpa Tavra XeyovTa;

5 in. 'AXrjOr).
2X2. " 'AAAd /xeVrot d/icpoVepai y etVt KaAat, cos c/mre'."

<papev ydp;
III. apxv.
2X2. " v E)(oi>cru> dpa rt t6 avrb 6 7rotet avras KaXas

10 etifat, rd kolvov tovto, Kal d/xc/jorepats avTats e7recrrt KOtvr)
b at e/carepa totcr 0?) ydp ay ttov dAAcos dp,<poTpat ye KaAat
?/cray koi eKarepa." drroKpivov ipol cos eKetycp.
III. 'AiroKptvop.at, kclI iptol do/cet eêty cos Ae'yets.
212. Et dpa rt aSrat at ?}8oyat dp.<poTepat ireirovdao-tv,
5 e/care'pa oe p,?7, oi/c ay rourco ye rco Tia6r\paTt elev /caAat.
III. Kat 7rcoj dz> etr/ rotrro, co 2coKpare?j prjberdpas 7re-
novdvtas rt rcoy ovtohv otlovv, e7retra roSro rd 7rd0os, 6

pr)beripa TriirovOev, dp<poTpas TrenovOivat;
C 2X2. Ou ooKet crot;
III. IIoAAr) ydp av pt fyoi diretpta Kal Tr)s tovtoov
<pv<reu>s Kat ri)s t&v TrapovTOiV Aeêcos Adycoy.
c f
2X2. H8e'cos ye, co l7r7rta. dAAa ydp eyco tcrcos kiv-
5 cWevco SoKety p\kv tl opctv ovtojs fyov cos <rv <pi)s dbvvarov
etvai, 6p<a 8' ovbiv.
iri. Ov Ktvbvvevets, 00 2coK/>ares, dAAd Trdvu erot/xcos
7rapopas.
2X2. Kat p?jy 7roAAa ye juot 7rpocpatVerat rotavra 7rpd
10 r?/s \ffvxi)$, dAAd a7rtcrrco avrots, ort oot pej> ov <pavTaeTai,
a6 fievToi T W F ^v vulg. 7' T W : om. F bi

76 scripsi
TWf
:
teTWF b4 ot 7J8oj/al Srj\ov al F

: C 2 -yap S û'
Xot TF : y' av /ul'
x 61 ^ uireipia T
F : airopla W C 4 -ye
TW : 5f F 05 ex '' TW :
x w '/ F e 9 Toiai/Ta T W ra :
TotaCTa F
) :
inniA2 MEIZX2N 3 ood
avbpi 7rAeicrroi> apyvpLov etoyacr/xeVct) tu>v vvv iiri crocpiq, d

e/xot bi, b$ ovbtv 7rco7rore r/pyacrd/xr/y. txal ivdvp.ovp.ai, cb
eratpe, ur) Trai^qs 7r/)ds /u.e txal eKcby e<fa7raras' ovtcos uol
crcpobpa Kal 7roAAd cpaCverai.
117. Ov8ets crov, S) 2coK/)ares, kolXXlov etcrerat etre iraiijo 5

etre /x?j, eay iirL\eLprjcrr)s kiytLV rd Trporf>aLv6uc:va ctol ravra'
(pavrjcrrf yap ovbev Ae'ycoi\ ov yap p.r\iTOTz cvpr\s, o /xr/r'
eycb TrcTTOvda /ur/re crrj, roOr' ap.cpoTpov$ r)pJas TtenovOoTas.

2i2. Ilcos Aeyets, cb ^liriria; tcrcos /xei> rt Aeyets, eyco 8' ov e
p.av6avu>' akXa uov cracpicrTepov clkovo-ov fiovkouaL Ae'yeu>.
e/tot yap cpairerai, o /tr/r' eycb TriirovOa etmt /ir/r' et/xt /xr/S'
aS cri) et, rorjro duqboTipovs TreirovdivaL r)p.a$ o\6v T eti>ar
erepa 0' au, a d/xcpdrepoi Treirovdauev elvaL, Tavra ovbirepov 5

etmt r//ucoi>.
in. Tepara au aTTOKpLVop.ivu) eotKas, co ScoKoares, ert

/xei^co r/ dAiyoi irpoTepov aireKpCvoi. o~k6ttL yd/r iroTepov
et apLcpoTcpoL bUaioC icrp.ev, or3 Kat eKarepos r//xcbi> etr/ di>,
r/ et d8iKos eKarepos, ov Kat d/i<pdrepoi, r) et vytaiyorres, 10
o?3 Kat eKarepos; r/ et KKp.r)K(as tl r) rerpco/xe'vos r/ 7re7rAr/- 301

y/xeVos r/ dAA' ortow TTenovOm kK&Tepos r)pG>v etrr, orj Kat
apqôTepoL av av tovto TTi.Tr6vQoLp.ev; ert Toivvv et yjpvcrdi r/
apyvpol r/ ikecpdvTLVOL, et 8e /SorJAet, yewatot r) aocpol

r/ ti/xioi rj yipovris ye 17 i>e'ot r) dAAo ort /3orJAet rcoV 5
et> avOpcairoLS d/tcdrepot rvyoLp.ev ovtzs, ap' or3 /xeydAr/
di>ayKr/ Kat K&Tpov r)p.S>v tovto etrat;

2X2. ndrrcos ye 8r/7rou. b
in. 'AAAd ydp 8r) crrj, co ScoKpares, ra /xei' oAa rcoi
7rpayp.6.TO)v ov crK07rets, ov5' eKetrot ots crv etcoc9as StaAe-
'd2^sTF: is W d.6 iirix*ifrfi<rv s ^ W îrx 6 'P^ ^"

^7 At ^ T
'
W W
"
^yci F ydyKOT i-y&> T e I ^tv ti F fiivToi rl T 7^

W
: :
T : taais F (sed suprascr. iyii f e5 & T W om. F ehai

W
:
T : 6?^ 5> F e9 dTW: om. F e 10 ^ / ante vyiaivovres

TF : t) W ar tKaTtpos T W et in marg. f a.fi<p6repoi F t secl. :
ci. Schanz a4 <ro(/>oiT W et suprascr. f: o-uxppoves F as jtAAo

tiWF: dA\o tj gTt T b 1 7 T 700 F W
b 2 SAo T F
:
aAAaW
:
:
30ib I1AATX2N02
yccrOai, Kpovtrt bk d7roAa/x/3divoi>res to KaXdv Kal tKaarov
5 tQ>v ovtcov kv rots Adyots KaTaTtp.vovTts. otd ravra ovto)
/ueyaAa vpas XavOdva. ko.1 biavtKr) o~a>p.aTa rr/s ovcrCas ire-
(pvKora. Kal vvv toctovtov cre Ae'Ar/0ev, &ctt otet etvat rt

t) TTados r) ovcrCav, rj 7rept pei> dpcpoTtpa ravra kcmv dpxx,
C 7rept be (KaTepov ov, r) av 7repi pikv kKarepov, irepl bk dp.-

cporepa ov' ovtojs dAoyicrrcos Kal do-KeVrcos Kal evr)6o)s at
d8tavor/ra)s 8tdKetcr0e.
212. Totaura, S> 'l-mrCa, ra r)p.tTpd kcrriv, ov^ ola
5 /3ovAerat rts, cpacrlv avdpojTrot, kKacrTOTt 7rapotpiadp,ei>ot,
dAA' ota bvvaraf dAAd crv r/pds dvCvr\s det vovdtr&v. e7rei
Kat vvv, irp\v vtto crov ravra vovdtrrjdrjvaL, cbs evr/dois ote-
Ketp.e0a, ert crot paWov eycb e7ri8etco et7rcbv a bt.tvoovp.tda
6 7repi ai)Tu>v, r/ pr/ et7rco;
in. Etoort p.kv epets, S> 2coKpares* ot8a ydp eKaoroijs

T&v 7rept tovs Adyovs cos Std/cetyrat. o/xcos 8' et ri o*oi
rjbiov, Ae'ye.
5 212. 'AAAd p.r)v ijbiov ye. r//uets ydp, co /3e'Artcrre, ot/rcos
d/3eArepot r/pey, 7rpti> cre raiir' et7retz>, cocrre boav eCyopcv

7repl epoC re /cat crov cbs e/cdrepos ?/p<3iv ets ecrrt, tovto bk
o e/cdrepos r/pcoi/ etrj oi/c dpa etpev dpcpdrepot ov yap ets
kcrp.ev, dAAd 8vo ovrcos et)r/t9iKcos etxopev w 8e 7rapd
e crov rjbr) dvzbibdy6i]p.V drt et p.ev bvo dpcpdrepot kcrp.ev,
bvo Kal kKaTtpov r)p,<2v dvdyKrj elvat, et 8e ets e/cdrepos,

eW Kctl dpLCpoTepovs dvdyKr)' ov ydp olov re dta/veKet Adyco
rf/s ovcrCas Kara 'IirirCav aAAcos e\eiv, dAA' o dy dp.cpoTtpa
b6 Siace/c^ TW (8ta Atoyeêja^s schol. W") SiTivfKr)

7rai/TJ>s oStcoj
W
:
F b7 olfet T F om.
et suprascr. b 8 $? F 4)
F : elri : :
TW afjL<p6rtpa ravra TWF:

afi<p6repa &rra Ficinus? {ambo
quaedam) a/x<p6Tepa rotavra ci. Heindorf
: C 3 aStaro^Toiy T f W
avo^Tws F 05 &v9pa>iroi T avOpcbrrois F W
C 6 bvivris :
T W ovivets F
: 0V1V77 ci. Naber
: C 8 e7n8eico T 7ri7rA*)co W :
F 8jej/oov/it?a F : 8jacooujue0a T W da inaarovs T Wf

eKaarov F CI4 7)8jojv TF: 5f8joj/ W d8 elrj/xev TW
F 63 Sjaj/e/ce? TW Moeris : Sjrij/ejcet F e4 ccj' TWf:
exej' F

inniAS MEIZX2N 3oie
*/, tovto nal eKorepov, Kdi b eKarepov, dp-cpoTepa etvaL. 5
iTiTLcrp.Vos br) vvv eyco virb crov evOdbe Ka6r]p.aL. irpoTepov
peWot, co 'iTTTTia, vir6p.vr]cr6v ue* iroTtpov els crp.ev eyco re

Kal o~v, r) o~v Te bvo et Kayco bvo;
in. Tt Aeyets, co 2coKpares;
2X2. Tavra airep keyco- cpo/3or3uat ydp cre o~a<pa>s keyeLV, 10
ort uot yakeiraLveLS, eireibdv r\ borjs cravrco keyeiv. ducos 3 2

0' ert uot ei7re'* ov\ ets r)p.cov eKarepos ecrrt Kal ireTrovde
tovto, els etvai; 117. Ildvv ye. 212. Ovkovv elirep eTs,
Kat TTnpiTTOs dv etr/ eKarepos r)p.cov r) ov rb kv TrepiTrbv

r)yrj; III. "Eycoye. 212. 'H Kat dp-cpoTepoL ovv wepirroi 5
ecrp.ev bvo ovres; IO. Ovk dv etr/,' ch 2coKpares. 212.

'AAA' dprtot ye dp.cpoTepoL' 77 ydp; 1IT. nd*>rj ye. 212.
M<5z> OVV, OTL dp.CpOTepOL apTLOL, TOVTOV VKa KOL KaTepOS
dpTLOs r)p.cov kcrTLv; in. Ov brjra. 2X2. Ovk dpa Tracra b

dvdyKr], cos vvvbi] ekeyes, a dv dp-cpoTepoL xat eKarepoi>, Kat
a av eKarepos Kal dp-cpOTepovs etvaL.
in. Ov rd ye rotarjra, dAA' ota eyio irpoTepov ekeyov.

212. 'EapKet, a 'I7r7rta* dya7njrd ydp Kat raCra, eVretSr/ 5
rd uh ovrco cpatVerat, ra 5' ovx ovrcos eyovTa. kol yap
eyco eAeyoy, et ue'ui>r/crai 66ev ovtos 6 Adyos eAe'x^r?, ort
r) 8ta rr/s 6\pecos Kat aKor/s r)bovr) ov tovtco etev nakai,
otl TvyydvoLev emrepa p.ev avrcov eTvaL TTeirovdvLa, dp.cp6- C
repat oe p.r\, 77 djucpoVepat ueV, eKorepa oe pr/, dAA' eKeivco
co dpcpoVepat re Kat eKarepa, dtoVt crwexcopeis dp.cpoTpas
Te avras eTvaL Kakas kol eKarepav. tovtov br) eveKa rrj
orjcrta t^ e7r' dp-cpOTepa eirop.evr] cop.r]v, elirep dpicpOTepd eori 5

KaAd, Tavrrj belv avra Kakd eXvai, rr) be Kard rd erepa
e 5rTW:^F:^j/Tf 67 /xfvroi T W f : roivw F e 8 t

TWf: yt F JTWf: om. F e 10 <re secl. Heindorf
a 1 ffavrifi T W eavru F a3 irdvv T W Kal iraVu F a8 eVt /c a
W
:
W
:
T : eVeKe/ F ical T : om. F b2 /cal a ac kKar-pos TW :
om. F b7 *A.f'x^ f: SfX^rj F: tAeyxOy T: Âe^X^ W(?)

b8 wal F: aUt' TW: ko! t> ** Stallbaum '
C2^...^TW:
om. F c6tTW: om. F

302C IIAATX2N02
airokenrop.evri UTp Kat ert vvv otouat. dAAd uot Aeye,
&cnrep e dpxfjs' *7 ^ 1 ' 6^/eu>s fjbovf) kcu f) 81' d/cor/s, et7rep
d dp.cp6TepaC t elcrl xaAat Kat CKarepa, dpa Kat o 7rotet avrds

KaAds ov)(l Kal ducporepats ye avrats eirerai Kat eKarepq;
in. Yldvv ye. 2X2. *Ap' ovv drt fjbovf) eKarepa r' ecrrt
Kat ap.(poTepai, 8td rouro dy etev Kakai; 77 8td rouro uey

5 Kat at dAAat 7racrat av ovbev tovtcov tjttov elev KaAat; ov-
bev yap fjTTOv fjboval ecpdvrjcrav ovcrai, et p.ep.vr)crai. IIT.
M4p.vrjp.ai. .212. 'AAA' ort ye 8t' ov//eco? Kat dKorJs avrat

e etcrt, 8td tovto ekeyero KaAds avTas elvai. in. Kat eppfjOr)
OVTCOS.
2X2. 2K07ret 8e et dkrjOf) Aeyco. eAe'yero ydp, cos eyco

p.vr\pr]s e\co, rovr' etz'at KaAoy rd 7/8u, ov irdv, dAA' 6 di>
5 8t' 6\j/eois Kal aKofjs f).

III. 'AkrjOfj. 212. Gvkovv tovto
ye to irdOos ducporepats p.ev C7rerat, eKarepq 8' ou; ov ydp
7rou eKarepov ye avT&v, oirep ev rots irpocrOev eAeyero, 8t'
ducporepcoy ecrrii, dAA' dp.cpoTepa p.ev 81' dp.cpoiv, eKaTepov

8' ov #
lcrrt raura; HI. "Ecrrtz;. 212. Ovk dpa rourco ye
10 eKarepov avT&v ecrrt kclXov, 6 u?) eirerat eKarepco (ro ydp
ap-cpoTcpov eKarepco oux e7rerat) cocrre dpcpdrepa uez> avrd
cpavaL KaAd Kard rT/y viroOecriv eêcrnv, eKarepov be ovk
303 eeoTr f) 7T3s keyop.ev; ovk dvdyKr); III. <J>aiverat.
2X2. <E>couei> ow ap.cpoTpa p.ev Kaka elvai, eKarepov be pr/
cpcouer; IIT. Tt yap KcoAwet;

2X2. Td8e euotye 8oKet, co cptAe, KcoAjJetv, 6'rt t/v 7rou
5 r/uty rd uey oijrcos eiri.yiyv6p.eva eKacrrois, et7rep ap.cpoTepois
eiriyiyvoiTo, koL eKaTepca, Kal elirep eKare'pcp, Kat dp.cpoTepois,
airavTa ocra crv btfjkOes' f) ydp;

m. Nat'.
c 7 vvv T W : om. F e 8 posterius ^TWet

suprascr. f (^ koX
Ang.) om.F : di r TW: y F fipowaiF: Spa d.2 7* TW
T W : T F 97 7roi/ T Trdvv F W
suprascr. ira> f : : a 1 \tyo/j.ev
WF :\eyw/x.ev T a 6 iiriyiyvoiTO T f iwiyiyvovrai : W iiriyiyvoiro
. . . aix<poTipois om. F (add. in marg. f)
:
:
inniAS MEIZX2N 303^

A
212. A bi ye av eyco btrjkOov, ov' &v br) r)v kcu avrb
to enaTfpov Kal t6 ap.(f>6Tpov. icrrtv oiVcos; io
in. "EcrTtV.
212. YloTtpctiv ovv, S) 'iTnria, boKel o~ot to Kakov etrat; b
7roTepov &v crv eAeyes* etirep eyco lcrxypos Kal crv, Ka\ ap.-
(poTtpot, Kal etirep eyco bUatos Kat o~v, kcu aptcpoTcpot, Kal
t7Tp ap.(pOTpOt, Kal KO.TpO$' OVTO) bt) KOt tTTp eyCO KakoS
Kal o~v, Kat apcpoTpot, Kat enrep ctuc/>drepoi, /ccu K<xTpos; 5
7] oibV KO)k.Vt, (00~7Tp apTtOiV OVTO)V TtVU)V ap.<f)OTpO)V Ta\a

p.v Ka.Tpa 7TptTTa etrat, Taya 5' aprta, kcu av appr)TO)v
KaTpo)v 6vto)v Ta\a pkv prjTa. Ta o~vvap.<pOTpa etrai, Taxa
8' apprjTa, Kal akka p.vpia rotatrra, a br) Kal eyco <\>r\v euot C
TTpocpaivcr6at; 7roTpo)v br) TtOcls to Kakov; ?/ cocrvrep euot
7Tpt avTov KaracpatWrat, KaX croi; 7rokkr) yap akoyia euotye
boKt etrat ctp.<poTpovs ptV rjptas etrat koXovs, KciTpov 8e
urj, rj Ka.Tpov ueV, ap.<poTpovs 8e /UT/, r) akko OTtOVV T(7)V 5
TOtovTO)v. ovto)$ alpfj, &o~TTp eyco, r) 'KetVcos;
in. Ovto)$ eycoye, co 2coKpares.

212. ES ye o~v Trot&v, o) 'iTnria, tra Kat d7raAAaycouev
7rAetoras' ^rirT/crecos' et yap tovto)v y eVrt to Kakov, ovk d
av ert etrj ro bt 6\j/0)$ Kal ctKorjs i)bi/ Kakov. ap.cpoTpa
p.\v yap 7rott Kaka to bC 6\p0)$ Kat ctKorjs, K<xTpov 8' ov'
tovto b' rjv abvvarov, cas eyco re Kat crv br) 6p.okoyovp.v,
6) 'iTnria. 5
in. 'Op.okoyovp.cv yap.
212. 'Abvvarov apa to bC 6\f/0)$ Kal ctKorjs i)bv Kakov
etvat, TTtbr] ye Kakov ytyvop.vov tG)V abvvaToov rt irapi-
\Tat.
&g avrbrbTWf: avrSyeF b8 TaTWf: om. F Ci&

TW : om. F c2 rifleh F t%s T riOrjs W &<rirep TF
W
: :
ftaircp hv C 4 S^ . . . C 5 (KaTepoj' TWf: om. F C 6 alpct

TW : ipu F Ktlvoos T : 4 K e ivws WF C 8 crb T W
aoi F
WF W
:
d4 6/j.o\oyov(jiev T : wpoKoyov-iev f d 6 6/j.o\oyov/x(v T

(6fjLo\oyov/j.ev ydp om. F) : wfj.o\oyov/xev ( d8 irapex fT ai T Wf
3 03d nAAT&NOS
v
io in. Eoti ravra.
22. " Aeyere br\ irdkLv," <pri<rei, " e dpxys, eireibr)
e tovtov btrjixdpT(T' tl <pare eu>at tovto to Kakbv TO eV
dp.<porepaLS Tals fjbovals, 8t' otl Tavras irpb tG>v dkk<ov
TLp.r\cravTs Kakds <avop.d<raTe ;" dvdyKr\ br\ uot boKel elvai,
co ^lmTLa, keyeLV otl dcrtêVrarat avrat tG>v r\bovG>v eto"t
5 Kat /3e'Arto-rat, Kat du</Jo'repat Kat eKarepa* r\ <rv tl eêts
Aeyetv dkko > bLa<pepovo~L t5>v dkkcov;
III. Ovbap.5>s' tG> ovtl ydp /3e'Artorat elo~LV.

212. " ToiV dpa," <pr\<reL, " Ae'yere br\ to Kakov eTvai,
r75oi>Tji> 5><pekLp.ov ;" 'EotKauev, cpr/crco eycoye* crr) de';
io m. Kat eyco.
212. " OrjKotV uxpekLp.ov," <pr\<reL, " ro TrotoiSi' rayadov,
to be 77010731; Kat ro TTOLOvp.evov erepov vvvbr) e<pdvr\, Kal els
tov irpoTepov koyov r/Ket r3utz> 6 Aoyos; ovTe ydp to dyaddv dv
304 etrr Kakbv ovre to Kakbv dyaOov, etnep dAAo avT<2v eKaTepov
ecrrt." ITavro'? ye fxdkkov, <pr\<rop.ev ) o> 'iTnrta, dv crcocppo-
vG>p.ev ov ydp ttov 6ep.LS tG> 6p6G>s keyovTL p.r\ a-vyyjupeiv.
in. 'AAAa brj y, S> 2coKpares, tl otet raura etmt <rvv-
5 diravTa; Kvr\<rpaTa tol eort Kat Treptrurjuara rcov Ao'ycor>,
oirep dpTL ekeyov, Kard fipayy oiTrprrueVa' dAA' eKeXvo Kal

Kakdv Kat ttoAAoS d^Lov, olov r' etyat ev Kal KaAcos Ao'yoy
KaTa<TTr\<rdp.evov ev 8tKacrrrrptco r) ev /3ovAe?jrr?pico r\ eirl dkkj\
b rtvt dpxfj, irpbs rjv dv 6 koyos TreCcravTa olyeo~6aL <pepovTa

fj,
ov rd crutKpoVara dAAd rd ueytora rcoi> ddk<t>v, crcorrrptai'
avTOV re Kat rcoz> avTov yj>r\p.aTiv Kal <pCk<t>v. tovtCov ovv
Xpr\ dvTexeo-0aL, â^pctv edaavTa rdy o-ptKpoAoytas rarjras,
5 JW ur) 8oKr) Atay avor\Tos elvaL kripovs koX <pkvapCas Sxrirep

vvv ueraxetpt(fo'uevo5. '
d 1 1 \eyere T W
\4yerai F e1 tJ> eir' T W r i-r F
e3 5J|TWF: 5t
:
suprascr. f (de $)) Ang.) elâi TF:

:
om. W
e4 3 tmrfa \eyeiv T W
\eyeiv fi> imrla F e8 Tf 8e F om.
W
:
: 8^J :
W e 1 1 iroiovv rayadbv F : iroiovvr ayaObv T a4 S^ TF :
8eT W 7 T W f om. F
: a5 Kvl\o~ix.aTa F fconiecerat Cobet)
W
:
Kviffâra T W a 7 xaAws TF : aA&s W b5 80/c?^ T f : Soktjs F

)
inniAS MEIZiiN 304D
îl. *H 'liTTTia cptAe, crv p.ev p.aKapLos et, ort re olo~0a
a XPV TTLTr\beveLV dvOpoiirov, kol TTLTTi]bevKas iKav&s, &s
(prjs' epe be baipiovLa tls rvxn> &s eWe, KaTex* 1' octtls C
TrkavQ>p.aL p.ev ko.1 airop& det, eirLbeLKvvs be ti\v ep.avTOv
airopLav vp.lv toIs o-ocpois Ao'yco av vtto vp.5)V irpoTT-qkaKL-

Cop,aL, 7TLbav e7ri8et'c;co. Aeyere ydp p.e, direp Kal crv vvv
keyeis, co? T/Ai't9id Te kcu crptKpa Ka\ ovbevbs dta nrpa- 5

yp.aTevop.aL' eireLbdv be av dva-neLcrOels virb vp.(2v Aeyco a7rep
Vp.LS, b)S TTOkv KpaTLCTTOV (TTLV ol6v T LVaL k6yOV V KCti
KaAco? KaTao-rrjcrdp.Vov irepaLveLV ev SiKacrrr/pito t/ ev aAAco
tlvl crvkkoyo), vtto re dkkoov rtrcor rcoi> ei>0d8e Kat v7ro d

TOVTOV TOV aV0p<t)TTOV TOV CLL p. ekeyXOVTOS TTOVTa KaKO.
cikovu). Kal ydp p.01 Tvy\dvL eyyvraTa yevovs (ov Kal ev

rco avrco otKco/r e7ret8cu' ovv elcrekOo) otKa8e els ep.avrov
Kat p.ov aKOVo-p Tavra keyovros, epo)T& et ovk alcr)(yvop.aL 5

roApcof Trepl KaXdv e7rirr/8e?jpdra>i> 8taAe'yecrt9ai, ovrco (pave-
pcos egekeyxdpLevos irepl tov Kakov otl ovb' avrb tovto otl
ttot ecrTLV olba. " Katrot 7rcos crv etcrT/," (f>i]crLV,
" t) koyov
octtls KaAco? KareaTT/craro 1} pr/, t/ dkkr\v irpa^LV i)vtlvovv, Q

to Kakov ayvoG>v; Kal 6tt6t ovto) StaKetcrai, otet crot Kpetr-
tov etvai (fjv p.akkov t/ rec^vdât;" cr7jp/3e'/3r/Ke 8r/ pot, o7rep
keyo), KaKco? piev vtto vp.G>v aKOveiv Kat oVei8tecrt9ai, kok&s

be vtt' KLvov. akka yap ttrco? dvayKalov VTTop.evLV ravra 5
Trdyra* ov8ei' yap aToirov et o)cpekoLp.r\v. eyco oZv p.OL 8okco,
co 'iTTTrta, cocpeAr]crt9at d-nb Trjs ap.(poTepo)v vp.G)V optAtas* rrjv
yap TrapoipiLav otl ttotc Aeyet, to " XakeTra tcl Kakd" 8okco
P-ol elbevaL.
b 8 &vepunrov T W
tJ' 6.vdp<t>irov F
: i/cewws om. F (suprascr. f
c8 (tj) vtpaiveiv Winckelmann CI4 (l<r(\0ci> T Wf elo-4\6w<riv F :
d.8 o?5o T W: om. F ea oJfft croi rec. f ofo-ei o-oi W(T?) os eT : :
<roi F (suprascr. <roi f) 64 prius /cewcws T ica\cvs F koc W

W
:
o'j8X''^ secl. Cobet e 6 axpfXoifi-qv scr. recc. c/)A.ovjurj' T :
W
:
wtpe\ovn(v F oSi/] 70C1/ ci. Heindorf e 7 iêAô-flai (sed

supra 7)) : a><p(\(7o-8ai TF
~7
->r
inniAS EAATTXIN
st. i
ETAIK02 2I2KPATH2 inniAS P-363
ET. 2u 8e br) tl crLyas, S Swjcparey, 'Ittttiov Tocravra a

e7rt5etap.eVoi>, nal ov-)(l r) o-vvziraiveis ti tG>v eipT/ueVtov ij
Kal eAe'yxets, et rt ctol p.7/ KakG>s botxel etpr/KeVat; aAAtos re

e7rei8?/ Kal ai>Tol AeAetp.Me#a, ot /xaAiar' av avTnroirjcraLpLeda
p.TeTvat r)plv Trjs iv c/uAocrocpia biaTpif3ii$. 5
212. Kai p.r]v, S> KvbiKe, ecrrt ye a ?/8e'tos ay Trv6oLp.riv

c t
l7r7rtou <3i> rw8f/ eAeye^ 7repi Op.r]pov. Kal yap tov aov b
irarpos 'A7TT//xavrou ijkovov otl r) 'IAias KaAAtoz; etr/ TTOLrjpa
rto 'Op?/pto 7/ t/ '08vcrcreta, roo-o?Jrto 8e KaAAior, ocrto a/xet-
va>v 'AxiAAevy 'O8?jcrcre'cos etr/' (Karepov yap tovtgov t6 p.ev
ets '08icrcre'a ecpr/ TT(.iroLr\crQaL, t6 8' ets 'A^tAAea. 7repi 5
Klvov ovv rjbicos ay, et (3ov\op.va> IcttIv ^XTnria, avatrvOoL-

p.r\v o7ro)s a?3rto 8oKet 7rept roty avbpoLV tovtolv, iroTepov
ap.Lva> (pr\cr\v etmt, e7ret87/ fcat aAAa TioAAa *cai 7rayro8a7ra c
ripxv e7rt8e'8etcrat Kai 7repi ttoltjt&v re aAAcop Kat 7repi
'O/iT/pOTJ.
ET. 'AAAa 8Âoy otl ov (pdovr/o-eL 'l7T7rias, ear rt avTov

eptoras, a.TT0KpLVcr8aL. r) yap, a> 'iTTTTLa, idv tl ZpcoTq cre 5
2toKpar77S, airoKpLvr); r\ ttGjs 7rot7/o-ets;
in. Kat yap av btLva TroioCrjv, a> Ev8tKe, et 'OA?jp;7riae
uev ets rr\v rtoy 'EAAT/rtoy Travr\yvpiv, orav tcl 'OAvp.7rta rf,
w
dei iiravLcov olkoOcv e HAt8os et? ro tepoy trapya> ep.avTov d
a4 Ktd TF : om. W b3 6V$> W : %<rov TF b4 tovtoi'
F : tuv iroi7)fi.dTa>v T W C 5 airoKplvrdai T W : airoKplvaffOat F

363d FIAAT&NOS
nai Xiyovra '6tl dv tls /3ov\r]Tai 5>v dv poL ds eiribeL^LV
Trapecr Kvacrp.Vov 17, Kal diTOKpLv6p.evov tS> /3ovXop.ev(t> otl
dv tls epcorfi, vvv be rrp ^(OKpdrovs epcor?]criz/ cpvyoLp.L.
364 212. MaKapLov ye, S> 'liTTria, irdOos TreirovOas, et eKdor?i?

'OXvpLTTLabos ovTOis eveXirLS cov irepl Ttjs \jfv)(fjs els crocpiav
acpLKvfi els to lepov Kal 6avp.do~aLp? av et tls tG>v irepX to

crG>p.a ddXr)TG>v ovtcos dcpofitos re kol ttlo-tzvtlk&s 'x u>v
5 crco//,ari epyeraL o-vrocTt aya>VLOvp.evos, totrirep crv cpfjs Tr\
bLavoiq.
in. EtKorcos, co 2coK/>ares, eyco tovto TreTrov6a' e ov
yhp r\pyp.aL 'OXvp.TriacrLV dytoviecr6aL, ovbevl 7rco7rore K/>etr-
tovl els oibev ep.avTov eveTvyov.

b 212. Kakov ye Ae'yets, 00 'iTnria, kcli Trj 'HAetW 7rdAet
ttjs crocpias avd$r]p:a tt)v boav elvaL rr)v crrjv koX rots
yovevcrL rois o-ots. aTap tl br) Aeyets r)p.lv irepl rov 'AîA-
Ae'cos re Kal tov 'Obvcrcretos ; iroTepov dp.eivto Kal Kara tl
5 cprjs elvaL; r)vLKa piev ydp 7roAAot Zvbov r)p.ev ml crv rrjv
etribeL^LV e7rotou, direXeicpdrjv crov tG>v Xeyopevcov &kvovv

ydp eiravepecrdaL, 8tort S)(Xos re 7roAiis evbov r)v, Kal p.r\
ctol epLTTobcov eXr\v eptoT&v Trj e7ri8etei vvvl be e7retc/ eAdr-

tovs re ecrp.ev /cat Ei>iko? obe KeAevet epecrdaL, elire re Kat
C bibaov r)p,as o~acpG>s, rl eXeyes 7rept tovtolv toIv dvbpolv;
ttG>s bLtKpLves avrovs;
in. 'AAA' eyco crot, co 2coKpares, e6eXu> ert cracpecrTepov
7} tot bLeXdelv a Xeyco Kal irepl tovtcov Kal aXXtov. cprjp.1
5 ydp "Op.r\pov 7re7rotrjKemt dpLcrrov p&v dvbpa 'A^XXea tS>v
ets TpoCav acpLKop.vtov, crocpcaTaTOV 8e Neo-ropa, 7roAvrpo-

7rcoraroy 8e '05t>crcrea.
212. BaySat, io 'lirirLa' dp dv tl /xot yapicraLo TOLovbe,
p.rj p.ov KarayeXav, idv /xdyts p.avddv(t> rd Xey6p.va Kat
d2 fiot T W : i/iol F d. 3 trapeaittva.aixevov] vaptaKfvaafievcev

Stallbaum b2 efoai secl. Baumann : elvat ot/xai ci. Vermehren
C 3 I?tj aacpearrepov T W : aatyearepov %ri F 04 tf A\a>' TW :
irep\ aWcov F C9 /uctyjs F : ^(Jaj TW

d
mniA EAATTX2N 364
TroWaKis drepcorco; dAAd p.0L 7retpco 7rpacos re nal euKoAcos d

cnroKpCvecrdai.
in. Alo-^pov yap av etrr, co ScoKpares, et dAAous /xev
avrd ravra 7ratoerJco Kal dtco 8td ravra xpijp.aTa kap.f5a.veiv,

avrbs be viro crov epcorco/ueyos /ur/ crvyyvo>p.r\v t tyoip.1 koX 5
irpqcos aTTOKpivoip.rjV.
2X2. Ylavv KaAcos Aeyets. eyco ydp rot, ^yua /ue/j apicrTov
tov 'AxiAA.e'a ecpr\cr6a 7re7rotr/crt9ai, eboKovv crov p.av6dveLV
oti eAeyes, Kat iivUa tov NeWopa aocpcoraroiv e7ret8r/ be e
roy '08rjcrcre'a et7res otl 7re7roir/Kcos etr? 6 7rotr/rr/s irokvTpo-
TTbjTarov, tovto b\ cos ye 7rp6s cre TaXrjdfj elprjcrdaL, iravTa-
iracTLV ovk ot8' drt Ae'yets. Kat piot et7re, dv tl evdevbe

p.ak\ov p.adon' 6 'A^tAAevs ov irokvTpoTTOs rco 'O/ur/pco 5
7re7rotrrrat;
in. "HKtard ye, co 2coKpares, dAA' d7rAorJcrraros Kal

dAr/0e'crraros, eirel Kat ev Atrats, r)VLKa irpbs dAAr/Aovs
7rotet avrorjs 6taAeyope'i>orjs, Ae'yet avrco 6 'A^tAAerjs 7rp6s
tov 'Obvcrcrea 10
Atoyeyes Aaeprtd8rr, TToXvp.r}yjiv 'Obvcrcrev, 365

Xprj p.ev bi) tov pvdov aTrrjXeyeois airoeLireLV,
cocnrep br) Kpaveoi re Kat cos reXeecrdaL dtco*
eydpos ydp p.OL Kelvos 6/xcos 'AtSao TrvXrfcrLV,

os \ *Tepov p.ev Kev6r\ evl cppecrCv, dAAo be et7rr/. fo
avrdp eycoy epeco, cos Kat rereAecrpeVoy ecrrai.
ev rodrots Sr/Aot rots eirecrLV tov Tposrov eKarepov tov dv-

opds, cos 6 /xei> 'A^tAAeus etrr dAr/0r/s re Kat a7rAorjs, 6 8e
'OSrjcrcrerjs 7roArJrpo7rds re Kat r/zerjSr/s' 7rotet ydp tov 'A;(iAAe'a 5
ets tov 'Obvcrcrea Xeyovra ravra tcl eirrj.
e 7 k al a.\i)6tcrraTos : om.F T W
a 3 So-jrtp T F rjTep S W :
cum libris Homericis (sed Sxnrep M

Kpav4w Homeri vulg.: (ppovtw
8
)
Aristarchus TfAeWflai T TereXieoQai

: TereAeV&ai F WTeAe-
:
(rfla* 0101] TeTeAetr/ieVo' <TTat S cum libris Homericis post bia> sequi-
tur II. 9. 311 &>s p-M fxoi rpv^rjre irap^fJifvoi &\\odev &\\os b 2 a>s Kal
TtreMafievov effTai Homeri vulg. &s /xoi Soku dvat &pio~ra Homeri A al.
:
plato, vol. 111. 32

365 b I1AAT12N02
212. Nvv r/8r/, S) 'iTnrCa, KLvbvvevu) p.av$dveLV o Aeyets*
tov TTokvTpoirov ^jrevbr} Ae'yets, tos ye qbaCveraL.
C in. MdAtcrra, S 2coKpare$' towvtov yap ireTToiqKev rbv
w
'OSrjcrcrea Op.rjpos TroKkaxov Kal ev 'IAtdSi Kal ev ÔbvaaeCq.
212. 'E8oKei dpa, cos eoLKev, 'Oprjpcp erepos perj etrat
dzn/p dAr/flr/s, erepos 8e \//eij8rjs, dAA' orj^ 6 avrds.
5 in. ITcos ydp orj pe'AAei, a> 2coKpares;
?
212. H Kat crot doKet avrco, a> 'lirirCa;
in. YldvTcav pdAicrra* Kat ydp dy betvbv etr/ et /ut/.
212. Tbv p.ev "Op.qpov toCvvv edao)p.ev, e7ret8r/ kol

d dbvvarov eiravepeaOaL tC ttotz jjocotj Tavra eiroC-qaev tcl e-rrq'
crrj 8' e7ret8r/ cpatjjr/ avabex.6p.tvos rrjjj alrCav, Kal crol crvv-
boKei ravra direp cprjs "Op.qpov Ae'yetjj, drroKpLvaL kolvT] inrep
'Opr/pou re Kat craurorj.
5 III. "Ecrrat rarjra* dAA' epcora ep.]3pa\y drt /3orjAet.
212. Toi/s \//erj8eis Aeyets oiojj ddwdrous rt 7roteiJJ, cocr7rep
rorjs Kap.vovTas, r) 8rjjJarorjs rt 7rotetJj; IIT. Avvarovs eycoye

Kat pdAa aqbobpa dAAa re 7roAAd Kat eâiraTav dvOpwTTovs.
e 212. Avvarol piev 8r/, cos eoLKev, elal Kard rdz> o-bv Koyov
Kat 7roArjrpo7rof r/ ydp;' 117.
Nat. 212. IToArjrpoTrot 8'
etcrt Kat a7rareco7Jes rj7rd rjAtc?idrr/ros Kat dcppoavvqs, r/ rj7rd
iravovpyCas koll qbpovqaeuts rtjjos; IIT. 'T7rd 7rajJorjpyias
S 7rdjjrtoj> pdAtcrra Kat qbpovqa eoas. 212. <>p6vLp.0L p.ev dpa

elaCv, cos eoLKev. IIT. Nai p.a ACa, kCav ye. 212. <E>po'jJt-
pot 8e orjres ovk eTrCaravraL drt 7roiorjcriJJ, r/ e7rtcrrajjrai;
in. Kat p.aka aqbobpa e7rtcrrarjrat' 8td rarjra Kat KaKovp-

yovcrLV. 212. 'E7rtcrrdperjot 8e rarjra a eTrCaravraL iroTepov
io dp.aOels etcrtTJ 77 crocpot; IIT. 2ocpot pev otjjj arjrd ye rarjra,
366 eâTrardv.
212. "Eê 87/* dvap.vqa-6Sip.ev tC ecrrtjj 6 Aeyeis. rorjs
i/Verj8ets cpr)s etvai Srjrjarorjs Kat qbpovCp.ovs Ka\ eTTLarr]p.ovas
C3 flvat avijp T W : avfyp elvai F d5 ûjSpax" T W eV

W
:
|3pax' F 8t* T : 87rp F 67 8ri iroiovtrtv ^ i-irlo-ravrai F ;
om. TW
a
lnnrAs eaattx^n 366
kcu aocpovs ets airep \j/evb(ls; IFT. 'Prjfj.l yap ovv.

212. "Akkovs oe tovs akrjdels re nal \//euSeiV, nal ivavTLoo- 5
t6.tovs akkrjkoLs; HI. Ae'yco ravra. 2X2. <J>e'pe brj
w
rcoy
p.(v bvvaToov tlvzs Kal croqboov, cos eoLKtv, tlalv ol \f/evbiLS

Kara tov abv koyov. IFI. MaAtcrra ye. 2X2. "Oray 8e
Ae'yjs bvvarovs kol aocpovs eti>at tovs i/VeuSets ets avra b
Tavra, iroTcpov Ae'yets bvvarovs zlvai ij/evbecrOaL eav (3ov-
Acovrat, r) abvvaTovs ets raSra airtp yj/tvbovTat.; III. Awa-
tovs Hyooyt. 2X2. *X2s kv KeepaAatco apa tipfjaOaL, ol if/evbtls
ticnv ol croc/W re Kat bvvarol \\/vbtcr6aL. III. Nat. 5
2X2. 'ASwaros apa \êw<5eo"(9ai cun/p Kal.ap.adr)s ovk av etrj
\f/(vbr)s. in. "Eêt ovtoos. 2X2. Awaros 8e' y ecrrtv
KaaTOS apa, bs b\v iroLr) tot o av /3ovA?/rai, brav fiov-

A//rar ovx virb vocrov Ae'yco ^Lpy6p.Vov ovb\ t&v tolovtoov, c
dAAa cScrTrep cru bvvaTos et ypd^/ai Tovp.bv ovop.a orav
(3ovkrj, ovtoo Ae'yco. r) oi>x> os av ovtoos ZxV> Ka ^& ^
bvvarov; IO. Nat.
2X2. Ae'ye brj p.01, 00 'iTnrta, ov cru /ueVrot ep.7retpos et 5
Aoytcrpcoi/ Kat AoyicrriK?/s; in. YIclvtoov paAtcrra, co 2co-

Kparts. 2X2. Ovkovv et Kat rts cre HpoLTo tcl rpts e7rraKo'crta
ottoctos ecrriy apL0p.6s, et /3ovkoLo, iravToov raxtcrra nal
paAtcrr' av clttols Takt]6r) ?rept roijrou; Ifl. Ilavv ye. d
2X2. *Apa ort bvvaTooTaros re et Kat croc^coraros Kara raura;
IIT. Nat. 2X2. noVepoy ovv crocpcoraro'? re et Kat bvva-
TooTaros p.6vov, r) nal aptcrros ravra cnrep bvvaTOJTaros re
Kat croc/>coraros, ra AoytcrrtKa; III. Kat aptcrroy 8j/7tou, co 5
2coKpares. 2X2. Ta /xe^ 8?) akr\6r) o~v av bvvarooTaTa et7rots.
7rept tovtoov r) yap;< .111. Otp.ai eycoye. 2X2. Tt 8e tcl e

\(/vbr) 7rept rcoy avraiv tovtoov; Kai p.0L, oocnrep tcl Trporepa,
yevvaCoos Kal /xeyaAo7rpe7rcos airoKpLvai, 00 'iTTTrta' et rCs cre
b iv T (sed supra versum) F W b 5 0/ F om.

W4 4v
ctj d>j : :
T b7 Se' 7' F :
5' T W c3 t) TW : 3 in marg. f Sp' F :
e 5 8^ M<" TW: 8e /xoi F 07 <re TW et in marg. f: om. F

d 1 /uaAtffTo Aeôis aA.;6^ F db JjjTWet suprascr. f : om. F
32*

3 66e IIAAT&NOS
epoLTO ra rpls kiTTaKoa-ia iroaa iarC, irorepov av dv pdkLara
5 ^/evboLO Kal deX Kara Tavra \j/evbi] keyoLS irepl tovtcdv, /3ou-
kopevos \j/evbeaOaL Kal p.r]beTiOTe dkrjOrj diroKpiveaOaL, 7] 6
367 dp,aOr]s els koyLap,ovs bvvaLT av aov p.dkkov \}/evbeaOaL

)3ovkop.evov; r) 6 p.ev dp.aQr]s ttoKKclkls av f3ovkop.evos \}/evbi]
keyeLV Takr]0i] av eliroL &ko)V, el tv\ol, 8ta to p.r) elbevai,
av be 6 aocpos, etrrep fiovkoLo \}/evbeaOaL, aeX av /cara ra

5 avTa \j/evboLo; III. Nat, ovtu>s e\ei (<>s av Aeyets.
212.
c
O \}/evbr)s ovv Trorepov irepX p.ev raAAa \}/evbr]s eaTiv,
ov p.evTOL TrepX apL$p.6v, ovbe dpL0p,(2v av \}/ev<raiTo;

in. Kat val p,d Ata irepX dpL0p,6v. 212. G>p,ev apa kgu
tovto, 3) 'IinTLa, irepX koyLap,6v Te koX apL0p.bv elvai TLva

b av0po)TTov ^/evbrj; in. Nat. 212. Tty ovv av eXr] ovtos;
ovx<- bel vTrap)(eLV avT(p, etirep /xe'AAet \j/evbr)s eaeaOai, d>s

av aprt a>jaoAo'yets, bvvarbv etvaL ^/evbecrOaL; 6 yap dbv-
varos \\/evbearOaL, et p.ep.vr]aaL, virb aov ekeyero otl ovk dv

5 7rore \\zevbr)s yevoLTo. III. 'AAAa. p,ep.vr]p.ai koX eke\0r]
ovtcos. 212. Ovkovv dpTL (pdvr]s av owarcoraros a)V \i\/ev-
beaOaL Trepl koyLap,(2v; 111. Nat, eke\0r] yk rot kol tovto.

C 212. *Ap' ovv kol bvvaTa>TaTos et dkrjOrj keyew irepX
koyia-p.(2v; in. Yldvv ye. 212. Ovkovv 6 avrbs yf/evbr}
koX aXrjOr) keyeLV irepX koyLap,&v oiwar&jraros' ovtos 8' eoru>

6 dyaObs irepX tovto)v, 6 AoytoTiKdV III. Nat. 212. Tts
5 ovv \f/evbr)s irepX koyLo~pJbv yiyveraL, a> ^liriria, dkkos 1] o
dyaOos; 6 avrbs ydp KaX bvvaros' ovtos be KaX dkrjOrjs.

in. 4>atz>erat. 212. 'Opas ovv ort 6 airbs \j/evbr]s re mX
dkr]0r)s irepX tovto)v, koX oi/bev ap.eivo)v 6 dXr]0r)s tov \}/ev-
a7 apiOfibv corr. Ven. 185 apiBnuv T WF apie/xwc scr. Ven.

185 : apidfj.bv T WF
:
hvTWF sed Sr) suprascr. W îaairo

TW: êvSoiro F a8 dwfxev] <pob/j.ev Schanz ba avrw
F: avrbv TWf &>s TWf t F :
sed dvai b6 ^ TWF
suprascr. W1)7 \oyio-fia>v corr. Coisl. \oytanbv : TWF
C 3 Swardraros F Svvarbs T f ovros . W
C 4 \oyioriK6s secl. . .
Bekker
:
C 5 \oyio-fxbv F \oyicrfiuv T C 6 5 avrbs F

: W :
ovros TW

inniAS EAATT12N 367 d
bovs; 6 avrbs yap brfirov ecrri Kai ovk ivavTLOiTara \L, d

cocnrcp crv (oov dprt.
III. Ov <paivTai ivTavdd ye.

212. BovXei ovv aK\(/(ap.e0a Ka\ dkkoOi;
III. Et [dAAco?] ye oi/ /SouAet. 5
212. Ovkovv Ka\ yecoperpta? eprretpo? et; IO. "Eycoye.
2X2. Tt ovv; ov Ka\ iv yeco/ierpta ovrois eêf 6 avrbs
bvvaraiTaTos \}fvbcr0ai Ka\ akrjOij Ae'ye> 7repi tG>v biaypap,-
p.aTiov, 6 yecofxerptKos; in. Nat. 212. Flepi ravra ovv

ayadbs dkkos rts tj ovtos; Hl. Ovk dkkos. 212. Ovk- e
ovv 6 ayaObs kol crocpbs yecop,e'rpT7S 8warcoraro'y ye
d/x(po'repa; Ka\ et7rep rt? aAAos \f/vbrjs 7repi biaypap.p.aTa,
ovtos av etr/, 6 dyaflds'; ovros ydp bvvaTos, 6 8e kokos
dSwaros r\v \jfvbcr0ai' cocrre ovk dz> yivovro \j/vbt]s 6 5
v
/ut) bvvdp.V0S \l/vbcr0ai, o>s a>/utoAo'yr/rat. III. Eart
Tavra.
v
212. Ert tolvvv /<ai ror Tpvrov TTLo-K\j/oip:0a, tov
dcrTpovop.ov, rjs av crv re'x^rjs ert pxikkov TTLcrTr}p.oiV otet
etyat rj tG>v ip.irpoaO^v. 77 ydp, a> 'I7r7rta; IIT. Nat. 368

212. Ovkovv kol kv dorTpovop.Cq ravrd raCrd o~tlv;
in. Eikos ye, co 2a>Kpares. 212. Kat v aorpovop.(.q dpa
enrep rts Kai dAAos \f/vbrjS, 6 dya06s dcrrpov6p.os \}/vbr]s
crTaL, 6 bvvaros \f/vbo-0aL. ov yap 6 ye dbvvaTOS' dp.a0i]s 5
ydp. in. <f>au>erat ovruis. 212. 'O avrds dpa kol iv
dcrTpovop.Cq dkt]0r\s re Kai \j/vbi]s 0~TaL. IIT.
v
EotKev.
212. "\0l brj, Si 'lintLa, dvib-qv ovrcocri TTLcrK\j/ai Kard
iracroiv tG>v TTLorr]p.oiv, et dAAcos X9 V V ovtoos.
7rou ecrrty b
7rdi>rcos 8e 7rAetcrras T\.vas irdvTcov crocpcoraros et dvOpco-
TroiV, cos eyco 7rore crou i]KOVOV p.yakavyovp.VOV, irokkr]v
crocpLav Ka\ (r]koiTr]V cravrov bL^Lovros V dyopq ir\ rats
Tpairifais. (pr]cr0a 8e dcpLKcrOaL 7rore ets Ôkvp.Triav a 5
d5 &K\m secl. Bekker az Taura raCTa Tf: toCto WF

a 5 ob yhp afiaOi/s ydp secl. Schanz
. . . b5 a elxe T W f (sed
X ex emend. T) at\ x^ F :

368 b TIAATftNOS
eixes Ttfpl to a&pa drravTa cravrov epya e\/(0V '
irp&Tov
piev baKTvkiov evrevdev yap i\p\ov ov f *X e? oravrov e\eLV
C epyov, a>s iTn.o-Tap.evos baKrvkiovs ykvcpeLV, koX dkkr\v

crcppaylba crbv Zpyov, /cat crrAeyyiSa Kal kr\Kv6ov a atros
r)pydcroi' eTrevra VTrobr\\xaTa a etxes ecpr\crda avrbs o-kvtoto-
fxijo-ai, /cat to IpaTiov vcprjvaL /cat rbv \LT0ivicrKOV /cat 6 ye
5 irdo-LV l8oei> aTOircaTarov Kal crocpias irkeicrTr\s eiriSety/xa,
e7ret8r) tt\v a>vr\v ecpr\cr6a tov \-ltlovlctkov, f)v eX\es, eTvai
p.ev olaL al nepcri/cai to>v TrokvTekcav, Tavrrjv be avrbs 7rAe'ar

7rpbs be tovtols 7rotrj/xara \(ov ekdelv, Kal eTtr\ /cat rpaycpStas
d /cat 8t0upap,/3o)js, Kal Karakoydbr\v iroXkovs Adyous Kal
TTavTobairovs crvyKeLp.evovs' /cat irepl t&v Te\v5>v 8r; 8>v
apTL eyoi ekeyov eTTLo-Tr\p.oiv d<rWe'cr0ai 8tac/>epoVrcos rwv

akkoav, Kal irepl pvd\xS>v Kal app.ovLOiV Kal ypap.pLa.T0iV 6p66-
5 Tt]Tos, Ka\ akka ert 7rpos tovtols irdvv rrokkd, cbs eycb 8o/ccb
pvrjfxoveveLV /catrot to ye p.vr\\xovLKov eTreka66p.r\v o-ov, cbs
eot/ce, Teyyr\\xa, ev co crv otet Aap,7rpdraros eXvaL' otpat be koa

e dkka Trdp.TTokka e7riAeAr/crc1ai. dAA' 07rep eycb Ae'yco, Kal els
ras cravTOV Teyvas /3Ae\/>as LKaval 8e' /cat ets ras rG>v
dkkoiv et7re' pot, edv ttov evpr\s e/c tS>v oip.okoyr\\xevoiv ejuot
re /cat crot, o7ro7j eo-rlv 6 piev dkr\6r\s, 6 be \}revbrjs, \oipls /cat
5 ovx o ovtos; ev rfrtyi (3ovkeL crocpia tovto cr/ce'i//at r\ Travovpyia
369 7} ortorjV yaipeLS 6vop.doiV dAA' otjx erjpr/creis, cb eratpe
ov ydp eo-TLV eVet crv elire.
III. 'AAA' ovk excoj <*> Sco/cpares, vvv ye orjrcos.
212. Ovbe ye eei?, ws eyco ot/xat* et 8' eycb dkr\6r) Aeyco,
5 p.ep.vr\craL 6 r\plv crvp.(3aLveL eK tov koyov, co 'iTTTrta.
in. 0?j Trdvv tl evvod, co Sco/cpares, 6 keyeis.
2X2. Nwi ydp tcrois ov xpfi T fu^pozn/cco rex^jiitari
b6 â TWf: om. F ea (tt\77(So Wt: (rA7<yfSo T:

a-T77t'So F 03 ?to T W
4*1 to F f : c6 fimS)) T WF :
secl.Ast : eiriticiKvbs vel îrtSf ifas fuisse susp. Schanz d2 t^x'''')']
Te rexv&v Baumann d3 iiriffriifjucv f imffT-fifiriv F einffritiJiwv

^
: :
T W 63 ttou T W : iroTe F a 7 XPV * :

XP^ ^F :
XP?J
a
inniAS EAATTX2N 369
bi)\ov yap otl ovk otet belv dAAd ey<o <re VTTop.vi)<r<o. dl<r6a
otl tov piev 'AxiAAca e<pi)<r6a dki)6i) elvai, tov be 'OcWo-e'a
\f/evbi) <al TrokvTpoTTOv; b

m. Nat.
2X2. Nvv ovv al<rddvi) otl avaiT<pavTai 6 avrbs <ov
\f/evbr)s re Kal aki)6i)s, cocrre et \j/evbi)s 6 'Obvao-evs fjv, Kal
dkr)6r)s yiyveraL, kol et dki)6i)s 6 'AxtAAevs, Ka\ \f/evbi)S, 5

y
koX ov btacpopoi dkki)k<ov ol dvbpes ovb evavTLOi, dAA
opotot;
IIT. '12 2coK/>ares, det <rv rivas tolovtovs irkeKeLS koyovs,
Kal airokap.ftav<ov b av 17 bva^p^Tarov tov koyov, tovtov
eyr) Kard <rp,LKpbv e<paTrr6p.evos, Ka\ ov^ 6k<o aym>i(j) t<o C
TTpa.yp.aTt Trepi otov av 6 Aoyos 77* e7ret Kat vvv, edv (Hovki),
eVt TroAAcoy TKp.i)pi<ov aTTobei<o <tol LKav<2 koy<o Op.i)pov
'AxiAAeâ TTTTOLi)KvaL dp.eiv<o '08ucro-e'cos /cat d^/evbij, tov be

bokepov re Kat 7roAAd \j/evb6p.evov Ka\ x et P C0 'AxiAAeW. 5
ei 8e fiovktL, <rv av avTLTrapafiakke koyov Trapa koyov, <os 6
TpOS ap.LV<OV <TTL' KOL p.akk0V etO"OZ>rai OVTOL OTTOTepOS
dpeLvov Ae'yet.
212. 'X2 'I7r7rta, eyco rot ovk dp.<pL<rfii)T<o p.i) ov)(\ ae elvaL d
,
<ro<p<i)T<zpov i) ep.e' akk de\ etco#a, e7ret8dy rts Ae'y?/ rt,
TTpo<re\LV tov vovv, dkk<os re Kat e7retdi; poL boKrj <ro<pos

eXvaL 6 key<ov, Ka\ ttl6vp<ov p.a6elv otl Ae'yet bLaTTVvda.vop.aL
kol eTrava<r kott<o Ka\ cn;/x/3i/3dco rd Aeyopeya, tva p.d6<o' eav 5
be <pavkos boKi) p.OL etrat 6 key<ov, ovre Travep<oT<o ovre
p.OL /xe'Aet <ov Ae'yet. Kat yvuxri) tovt<o ovs av eyco ?/yco/u
<ro<povs etrar evprjcreLs ydp p.e kLirapi) ovra irepi rd Aeyo'-
p.eva vtto tovtov Ka\ Trvv6av6p.evov 7rap' avrov, tva p.a6<ov Q
tl <o<pekr)6<o. e7ret Kat vvv evvev6i)Ka <rov keyovros, otl iv
toIs Tre<TLv ols <tv dpTL ekeyes, evbeLK.vvp.evos tov *\yj.kkea
C 1 o\>x 8Ay T W f : oi/b" '6\us F C 5 iroAAo \f/v56fi(vov T W

ty(v86utvov iroAAck F d2 fTf: ti W:
om. F d.7 rovrtf T
toOto W toDt' % F
: 70. rotnov in marg. f) 6 2 67TfJ koJ vCv T W
/caJ vvv iirfl F

369 e nAAT&NOS
els tov 'Obvcro-ea XeyeLV cos aka(6va ovra, oltottov p.0L boKel
5 etrat, el crrj dkr)6fj XeyeLS, 6rt 6 p.ev 'Obvcrcrevs ovbapov

370 c/mtVerat ^revo-dp.evos, 6 7roArjr/)07ro?, 6 e 'AxtAAerjs 7toA?j-
Tponos tls cpaCveraL /cara roy croy Adyozr v/ferjoerat yow.
irpoeLTrcov yap Tavra rd eVr/, a7rep Kat cry et7res dprt
ex^po? ydp /xot Ketvos 6/utcos 'AtSao TrvXrjcrLV,
5 os x' tTepov p.ev Kev6r\ evl cppecrCv, dXXo be et7rr/,
b oAtyoy vcrTepov Aeyet cos ovt c\v dvaireLcrdeCr] ?j7r6 rov

'OSrjoWcos re Kat rou 'Ayap.ep.vovos ovre /xeVot ro irapdiTav
ev Trj TpoCq, dAA'~
avpiov ipa Att peas, cpr)crC, Kat 7racrt deolcrLv,
5 vr\r\cras ev vrjas, eTrrjv aAae irpoepvcrcrco,
ov/êat, at k' edeXricrda Kat a KeV rot ra p.ep.r\Xr\,

c
r]pt pdA' EAAr/cT7roi;roy eV tx^wevra 7rAeo?jcras
C vrjas ep.ds, kv b' dvbpas epecraep.evaL p.ep.acoTas'
et 8e Kev evTrXotrfv 8cor/ KAuros 'Ewocrtyatos,

r/juart Kei> rptrdrco <P6Crjv epC(3coXov LKoCp.r)v.
ert 8e TrpoTepov tovtcov TTpbs tov 'Ayap.ep.vova XoLbopovp.evos
5 et7rey
yw 8' et/ut ^c^tr/y^', e7ret r/ 7roA?j Xcoiov ecrrtv
otKa5' t/iey crrjz; vqvtrl KopcovCcriv, ovbe cr 6Cco
d eV0dd' drt/u,os ecoi> dcpevos Kal ttXovtov dcpvêLV.
raura eiTrcbjj rore /uey evavrCov Trjs crrpartds airdcrr]s, TOTe

be Trpbs tovs eavTov eraCpovs, ovbap.ov cpatVerat orjre Trapa-
o~Kevacrdp.evos ovt eTTiyeipr)cras mdekKeiv tcls vavs cos a7ro-
5 irXevcrovp.evos oiKabe, dAAd 7rdz>?j yevvaicos okiycopcov tov

TaXrjdrj Xeyeiv. eyco piev ovv, co 'I7r7rta, Kat e dpxrjs cre
-)pop.rjv aTTopcov onoTepos tovtolv toIv dvbpolv dpeivcov

e 7re7rotr/rat rco 7rotr/rr/, Kat r)yovp.evos dp.cpoTepco dpicrTco elvai
a 1 xpevcrdfj.evos T W f : if/ev86/j.ei>os F b6 atic T W Homeri ad

L al. : al Ke F :S cum Homeri vulg.
t)v e6 iirel jTW: iiretS^ F
Kdii6v TW AcDJp F <peprtpov libri Homerici
: d2 arrairrjy F
W
: :
Trdffrjy T

inniAS EAATT12N 370 e
KCU hxKTKpiTOV OTTOTHpOS ap.tCv(t)V 61IJ KCU TTpl \j/vboV$ KCU
dki]deCas Kal rfjs dkkrjs dpeTrjs' dp.cpOTpo) yap Kal Kara

tovto 7raoa7rA?jcrico ecrroV.
in. Ov yap KakG>$ crKOireis, 2> 2toK/>ares. a p.\v yap 6 5

'AxtAAei/s \jrevberai, ovk e e7rt/3ouA?/s cpatrerat \}/evb6p.evo$
dAA' a.K(iiv, Sia tt)v crvp.cpopdv rr)v tov crrpaTOiribov dva-
yKacrdels Kara/ueti/at Kal fior)0i)craL' a be 6 'Obvcrcrevs, eKcoy
re koX e 7nj3ov\rjs.
212. 'Ea7raras p.e, 0) cptArare 'I7r7rta, Kal avTos tov 10
'Obvcrcrea p.Lp.f\.
in. Ovbap.u>$, u> ^coKpares* Ae'yets br) tC Kal irpbs tl; 371
212. "Ort ovk e TTLf3ov\r}$ -prjs tov 'A^tAAea i//-ev8e-
crQaL, 0$ r)v ovto) yorjs kol e7rt/3ot>Aos 7rpos tjj dkaôveCq,

u)$ TTTToCr]KV "Op.r]pos, cocrre Kal tov 'Obvcrcriats TOCTOVTOV
cpaCveraL cppovelv irkeov Trpbs to pqbCcas kavOdveLV avrbv 5
dAa^bz/euop.eôs, u>ctt IvovtCov avTov avrbs eaurw ero'Ap.a
evavrCa Ae'yew> *cai ekdvOavev tov 'Obvcrcrea' ovbev yovv
cpaCveTaL elircav irpbs airrbv cos aicrdav6p.VO$ avTov \\rev-
bop.4vov 6 'Obvcrcreus. b
in. rioia br) ravra Aeyets, a> 2<oKpares;
212. Ovk olcrda otl Aeycoy vcrTepov r) cos 7rpos tov
'Obvcrcria ecprj dp.a rr) 7701 d7ro7rAetJo-ercr0ai, 7rpos tov AlavTa
ovk av cpr)o~LV d7ro7rAeucreicrt9at, dkka aAAa Ae'yet; 5
in. Uov brj;
212. 'Ev ots Aeyet

ov yap Trplv TToktp.oLO pLbr]crop.aL alp.aTOVTos,
irpCv y vlbv nptdpoto batcppovos, "Exropa blov, C
Mvpp.Lb6vo)V eVt re KAtcrtas Kat vfjas tKe'crc?at
ktcCvovt 'ApyeCovs, Kara re c/>Ae'at 7rupt zn/as*
a 1 Sif\ 5e 8)) scr. recc. a3 tt) a\a(oveia Bekker tV a\a(oveiav

WF
:
T a8 ai)Tov ipev86fxevov F b3 4) <J>j WF : ir<uj T

b8 TW
fxeSri<rofj.ai : fxeK-rjaoixai F : fj.edr)o-ofiai vulg. C 3 KTfivovr'
T W KTfivavT F
: Kai-a re <p\4fâi TWf (sed er/xi; suprascr. W) :
KaTt<p\ef F: kotc( t6 iTjuCfa S cum Homeri vulg.

371C I1AATX2N02
dp</ji be p.LV rr\ 'p.77 KkLo-Cr\ Kal vq); \xekaCvr\
5 "E/cropa Kal \xep.a(oTa p>.dyr\s o-yr\aeo-6aL dCco.
(tv br\ ovv, a 'lirTTia, r. sepov ovtcos eirLkr\o-p,ova oCeL elvai
d roy r^s 0e'rt8ds re Kai virb tov crocpcordrou XeCpcovos ireTraL-
bev\xevov, cocrre dkCyov irpoTepov koLbopovvra tovs dka6vas

tt) ecryd.Ti\ XoLOoplq ovtov Trapa^prjp.a irpbs [xev tov 'Obvaaea
(pdvaL aTroirkeva-elo-daL, 7Tpbs be tov Alavra p.eveTv, dAA' ovk
5 iiuffovkevovTa re Kai r\yov\xevov apyalov elvai tov 'Obvcro-ea
Kat ai/Tov avT(a tovtco r<2 TeyvdêLV re Kai xf/evbeo-OaL trepLe-
crecrt9at;
in. Ovkovv euoiye boKel, co 2coKpares* dAAd Kal avra
e raSra virb evvoCas dvaTreLcrOeXs irpbs tov Paavra dkka eljrev
r) 717)05 tov 'OSua-crea* 6 be 'OSvcrcrerjs a re dkr\Or\ Aeyet,
TTLJ3ovkvo-as det Aeyet, Kat ocra \jrevbeTaL, cocravrcos.

212. 'AfxeCvcov ap' ecrrtV, cos eoLKev, 6 'OSucrcrei/s 'A^tA-
5 Ae'cos.
in. "HKtcrrd ye Sr/7rou, co 2coKpare9.

212. Tt Se'; otjk dprt e(pdvr\o-av ot eKoVres \jrevb6pLevoL
fiekTLOvs r) ol clkovtcs;
in. Kai 7T(os dy, co ^coKpare?, ot ckoitcs dotKOwres Kai 1
37 2 eKorres einfiovkevo-avTes Kai KaKa epyao-dp.evoL /3eArto?js di>
etei> rcoy clkovtcov, ols 7rokkr\ boKel avyyvcop.r\ eijvat, eav pr;
etocos rts dStK^cr?? r) \j/evai\TaL r\ dkko tl KaKov ttoit/ct?/; kol
ol v6p.0L br\TTOv TTokv xakeircoTepoC etcrt rots eKOvcrL KaKa

5 epyaop,evoLS Kal \j/evbo\xevois r\ rots &kovo-lv.
2X2. Opas, do 'Ittttlu, otl eyco dkr\Or\ keyco, keycov cos
b At7rap?/s etut 7rpds rds epcorr/crets rcoi o-o(pcov; Kal KLvbvvevco

%v uxovov eyeLV tovto dyaOov, rdkka e\cov irdvv qbavka'
tG>v p.ev yap Trpay\xaTcov f\
eyeL ecrcfjaApat, Kai ovk oto' oirr\
ecrrt. TeK\xr\pLov be pot tovtov LKavov, otl e-rreLbdv avyye-

5 vcop.aC rcp v\xcov tcov evboKL\xovvTcov eirX croc/jta Kai ot? ot
C4 /tivTW: ju^j/ F: toi libri Homerici d i reTWf: om. F

d2 a\a(6vas T W : &\\ovs F d4 txa/e?v~] yueVeiv T FW ei fu-
voias F : eurjfleios T W f
inrilAS EAATTX2N 37*b
"EAAr/res iravTes p,dprrjpe's etcri rrjs crocptas, (pai.vop.aL ovh\v
etocos* ovhev ydp uot boKel t>v avTatv nal vpXv, cos eVos
direiv. Katrot tl petbz> dpafltas reKp.T/pioi> r) kireLbdv rts C
ao(pols dvhpao-i Stacpepr/rat; %v be tovto 6avp.do-Lov ex&>
dyadov, 6 p.e ccoCef ov yap aio-yyvop.aL p.avddva>v, dAAd
irvv6dvop.aL Kal epcorco /cai x<*P iV ttoWijv ex<o rcp airoKpLVO-
peVco, Kal oibeva 7rco7rore d7reo-repr/cra xdp iT0 S' ov jbp - 5
7rore Zapvos y(v6p.rjv p.a6a>v tl, e/xarjrou 7rotorjpei>os to

p.ddr)p.a etWt cos evpr]p.a' dAA' eyKcopid^co tov 8i8darrd /xe
cos aocpov ovra, aTrocpaLVcav a Zp.a6ov irap avTov. txal brj Kal
vvv a crv Aeyets ov\ o/xoAoyco crot, dAAa otacpepopat Travv d

o~<pobpa' Kal tovt eS olba otl ot' epe ytyi>erai, drt tolovtos
etut oloo-jrcp et/xt, Xva pLribev ip.avTov p.d(pv etTrco. epoi
ydp cpatrerat, 3> 'I7r7rta, irdv tovvovtlov r) b (tv Ae'yets* ot
/3Aa7rroyres rovs dvdpdiirovs txal dStKowres Kal êvbop.zvoL 5
Kat ea7rarcoi>res kol ap.apTavovTt$ exoVres dAAd wr/ aKor/res,
/3eArtorjs eti>at r/ 01 d/corres. eVtore ueWot Kat tovvovtlov
doKet p.0L TovTu>v Kal TrXavS>p.aL 7rept raCra, 8r/Aoi> ort 8td
to p.r) elbevar vvvl oe eV rco irapovTL uot &cnrzp Kar7//3oAr/ e
7repteA7/Auc9ey, Kat 8oKorjcrt /xot 01 eKoVres eap.apTdvovT$
7rept rt /3eArtorjs etvat rcoi> aKovToav. atrtco/xat 8e rorj iw
7raooVros 7ra<9r/uaros rorjs lpnrpoo'6zv Adyous atrtous etmt,
cocrre <paiVeo-0ai urjy eV rco trapovTL roi/s aKoyras rovrcoi 5
tKacrTa iroiovvTas irovrjpoTipovs r) tovs kKOVTas. av ovv

Xaptcrat Kat /xr^ <pc9o^r/crrjs tdcracrc9at rr/v ^rvyjiv p.ov iroXv
ydp tol p.dC6v pe dyadov ipydo-r] dp.adias iravaas rr)v \}/vxr]v 373
f) vocrov to crcopa. p.aKpbv picv ovv Koyov et 't9e'Aets Ae'yeu>,
7rpoAe'yco crot drt ovk dy pe tdcraio ov ydp di> aKokov6iiaraLp.L

uxnrep 8e dprt et '(9e'Aets pot a7roKptVecrc9at, 7rdyrj d^r/creis,
otpat 8e ovb' avrbv cre /3Aa/3r/crecrc9at. StKatcos 8' di> Kat cre 5
irapaKaXoLrrv, a> 7rat 'ATrrjp.d^rorj' cru ydp /xe Zirrjpas 'I7r7rt'a
C 1 t/ WF : om. T a4 airoKpiviVdai T W
airoKpivaadai F
:
as SiKotwj 5' &' T W f na\ ws av F a6 (irrjpas F Trfjpos T : :
W
:
O7rppos
.
373* riAAT12N02
8taAe'yeo-0ai, nai vvv, cav p..J p.OL e#e'A?7 'lîrCas aTTOKpiveaOai,
biov avrov vrrep kp.ov.
ET. 'AAA', co 2coKpare?, olp.aL ovbev beqo-etrOaL 'iTnrtav

b rrjs r)p.Tepa$ berjo-ecos' ov yap roLavra avrco eort tcl Trpoupr]-
p.iva, dAA' otl ovbevbs av (pvyoL avbpbs ZpcoTrjtrLv. r) yap,
S) linrLa; ov ravra r)v a eAeye?;
in. "Eycoyc dAAa ^coKodrrj?, co Evbwe, dei TaparreL kv
5 rots Adyots koX Zolkzv tocnrcp KaKovpyovvTL.
212. 12 /3e'Artcrre 'limia, ovtl kKcov ye ravra eyco 7rotco
trotpbs yap av r) koX btLvbs Kard tov crbv koyov dAAd clkcov,
cocrre p.oi trvyyvcopvqv eyjE' cprjs yap av belv, bs hv KaKovpyi}

olkcov, trvyyvtop.r]v zyjELV.
C ET. Kat p.r]bap.cos ye, co 'linrLa, dAAcos 7rotet, dAAd *at

f]p.S>v (IvtKa Kal t&v TrpoeLpr]p,4v(i)v ctol koycov airoKpCvov a av
cre epcoTa ScoKpdrrjy.
in. 'AAA' CLTTOKpLvovpLaL, (tov ye beopAvov. dAA' epcora
5 ort ySouAet.
212. Kat p.r]v trcpobpa ye (Tn9vp.co, S> 'IirirCa, bLatTKâtrdai
to vvvbr] kcy6p.vov, 7roT(poL 7rore apLtCvovs, ol kovtS r) ol
clkovtcs ap,apT<xvovTS. ot/xat ovv e7rt tt)v o-k{\}/lv opdoraT

av tobe eA0eti>. dAA' airoKpLvaL' KaAet? rtua bpop.ia ayaOov;
d in. "Eycoye. 212. Kat kokoV; in. Noi 212. Ovkovv
ayaObs p.\v 6 ev Oicov, kokoj 8e 6 kokcos; 117. Nat. 212.
Ovkovv 6 fipabecos Okcov kokcos 0et, d 8e Taykcos ev; IIT. Nat.
212. 'Ei> bpop.co pikv apa kol tco O&v rayps p.ev ayaOov,
5 fipabvTr)s be KaKov; III. 'AAAd ri /xeAAet; 212. Ylorepos
ovv dp.eCvcov bpop.evs, 6 (kcov fipabecos Oicov rj 6 clkcov;
in. 'O eKcoy. 212.
9
Ap' ovv ov 7rotety rt eort ro #eti>;
in. Ilotety p.\v ovv. 212. Et 8e 7roietr, ov koi epyd(fecrc9at

e
rt; IIT. Nat. 212. 'O kokco? apa Oicov KaKov kol alcr^pbv
iv bpop.co tovto epyd(ferat; III. KokoV 7rcos yap ov;
212. Kokcos 8e t9et d ppabicos dcov;lU. Nat. 212.
a8 iirip F : irepl TW b7^F:î/TW
; ;
inniAS EAATTX2N 3 73 e
Ovkovv 6 fxtv dyados bpop.evs Iko>v to KaKov tovto tpyd-

(erai Kal to ai<ryj>6v, 6 8e kokos clko)v; III. "Eolkcv ye 5
2X2. 'Ev bpop.o) p.ev apa TrovqpoTepos 6 clkcdv kokcl ipya(6-

p.evos r) 6 cko>v; III. 'Ev bpop.u> ye. 2X2. Tt 8' ev irdkri; 374
TTorepos irakaLo-rqs dp.eivo)v, 6 ckcov iriTTToov rj 6 clkojv;
in. 'O (K<av, cos OLKV. 2X2. YlovqpoTtpov 8e koX aXo~yiov
iv irdkr] to ttltttLV r) to Karaj3dkkLv III. To ttlttt^lv.
2X2. Kal eV irdkri apa 6 ckmv tcl Trovqpd Kal aicrxpd epya(6- 5
p.evos /3eA.rtW TrakaLcrrqs r) 6 clkojv. III. "Eolkcv. 2X2.
Tt 5e b> rfj akkrj irdar] rfj tov <TO>p.aTOS XP eta > 0V X /3eA.uW
to <rS>p.a bvvarai ap.<p6Tpa epydeo-0at, Kat tcl i<r\vpa nal Ta
dadevrj, Kal tcl aio~xP a Kat ra Ka Ad* ftjare orav Kard to o~G>p.a b
TTOvqpa epya&jTai, tKo>v epydêrat 6 /3eArtW to crcojua, 6 8e
TTovqpoTepos clkoov; III. "EotKev Kat tcl Kara rqv icrxvv OVTOiS
2X2. Ti 8e Kar tv<Txw 0(rvvr v > )

o> 'l-Tnria; ov tov fiek.Ti.ovos 5
<ro)p.aTos <ttlv kKovTos tcl atcrxpa *at TTOvrjpa crxwara crxq-
p.aTL&LV, tov 8e irovr\poTipov clkovtos; rj trS>s <tol SoKet;
III. Ourcos. '2X2. Kat a<rxw 0(r" vi )

aP a V & kovo~ios
irpos aperrjs kcrriv, r) 8e a.Kov<rLos irpos irovqpias o-o>p.aTos. C

m. tatrerat. 2X2. Tt 8e qbojvijs iripL Aeyets; rroTepav
qbrjs (IvaL /3eArtco, rqv (KOV<rio)s dirabova-av r) rqv clkov<tlo>s;
III. Tr)v eKovo-LOiS. 2X2. MoxOrjporkpav 8e rqv aKovcrim;

III. Nat. 2X2. Ae'aio 8' av iroTepov TctyaOa KKTrj<r6ai 5
rj tcl KaKa; III. TayaQd. 2X2. IloVepoy ovv av 5e'âto

TTobas KKTr)<rdaL KOV<rio>s x oi ^ a ^VOVTas V aKov<rio>s;
III. 'Ekouo-icos. 2X2. XcoAeta 8e 7ro8coi; ovx^ irovqpia kol d
d<Txr)p.o<TVvr) <tt'lv; III. Nat. 2X2. Tt 8e'; dp.(3kvo)7ria
ov rrovqpia 6<pdakp.<2v III. Nat. 2X2. Ilorepouy ovv av

fiovkoLo 6<p6akp.ovs KCKTrjcrdaL ml rroTtpoLs crvvtlvaL; ols
Ikodv av tls dp.fikvo)TTOL Kat Trapopcorj 17 ots aKcor; III. Ots 5
a3 s oikc F coiKev T W a7 posterius ttj secl. Bekker

WF W
:
b3 Kal ra T : om. recc. b6 o-xVj/uara T : om. F

374 d IIAATX2N02
kKiav. 2X2. BeArtco dpa rjyrjcraL T<av cravrov rd KOVcrio>s
Trovrjpa ipyaôixeva r\ rd aKovcrioos; in. Td yovv roiavra.

212. Ovkovv irdvTa, olov Kal 3>ra Kal plvas Ka\ o~Top.a koX
Trdcras ras alo~6r]o~Ls, ets koyos o-vveyzi, ras p.kv cikovtoos
e KaKa kpyaop.vas aKTrtrovs cXvaL cos irovrjpas ovcras, ras bk

KovcrC(os KTr]Tas cos ayadas ovcras. III. "E/xotye boKti.
2X2. Ti b4; opydvoov TToripoov /3eArtW r) KOLVoovia, ols ko>v
tls KaKa epydêrai r\ ots clkoov; olov inrtbdkLOV co clkoov KaK&s

5 tls KvfiepvrjcreL /3e'Artoz> r) & kKoov; III.
T
12t eKcoi\ 212. Ov
Kal toov oocravToos Kal kvpa /cat avkol KaX rdAAa o~vp.TravTa;
375 in. 'AkrjOfj Aeyets. 2X2. Tt 8e; xj/vxhv KCKTrjcrOaL lttttov,
17 K(ov tls KaK&s LTnrevcrei, dp.LVOv r) (rj) olkoov; III.

?
Ht

k<ov. 2X2. 'AftfttKav dpa Icttlv. IIT. Nat. 2X2. TfJ
dp.zivovL dpa ^rv\r) lttttov tcl rrjs ylrv\rjs epya TavrrjS rd
5 TTovr)pa eKoucrtcos av ttoloI, tjj bk rrjs TTOvrtpas aKovcrioos;
IIT. Yldvv ye. 2X2. Ovkovv Kal kvvos Kal t5>v dkkoov (fcocoy
irdvToov; III. Nat. 2X2. Tt bk br\; dvOpanrov yjsvxhv

CKTrjcrOaL to6tov dp.Lv6v o~tlv, rJTLS kKOvo~ioos dp.apTaveL
b tov ctkottov, x\ t\tls aKovcrioos; III. "Htls KOVO~i(jOS.- 2X2.
Ovkovv Kal avTr] dp,eivoov ds to^lktjv io-TLv; IIT. Nat.
2X2. Kat ~JfV\ri dpa aKova-ioos d\xaprdvovo~a TroviipoTt-pa r)
kKovo~ioos; 'Ey IIT. to^lkjj ye. 2X2. Tt 8' kv tarptKr/; ovyl

5 17 kKovcra KaKa pyaop,vr, irepl rd crcop,ara laTpiKcoTtpa;
IIT. Nat. 2X2. 'A-jLtivoov dpa avrt) eV TavTr\ rfj rdxvr] rrjs
p-r) [laTpLKrjs]. III. 'A/xetycoy.

2X2. Tt be; r) KtcâptcrriKco-
Ttpa Kal avkriTLKooripa /cat raAAa irdvTa ra Kard rds Ttixvas
C re Kat rds TTLO~Trjp,as, oi>xl V ap,eivo>v Kodo~a rd KaKa Ipyd-
{erat Kat rd alo~xpd kol eâ/âprdyet, r) bk irovrrpoTepa
aKovcra; III. âtrerat.' 2X2. 'AAAa fjt,rjv irov rds ye tS>v
d9 atcSvrws T WF : aKovaius Cobet a 2 &fiett>ov f a/xivov F : :
afielvaiv T W add. corr. Coisl.

?j a 5 rfj 8e rrjs irovypas W :
ttj 8e rrjs irovrjpias T f rt) Se rrj rrovqpa F rn 8e ^vxfj rfi novripa

:
W
:
Schanz a8 &fitivov F afifivovos T b 2 Kal F om. T W

W
: :
b7 iarptKrjs secl. Schleiermacher c 1 re T om. F :

IIH1IA2 EAATTX2N 375C
bovkoiv \}/vxas KKTrj<rBai 8eat'/xe0' dv /xakkov rds eKovcrCoos

77 rds aKOVcrCois dp.apTavovcras re Kal KaKovpyovcras, a>s 5
dpetVous ovcras ets raura. III. Nat. 2X2. Tt 8e; tt]v
7]fXTepav avT&v ov /3ouAot/xe0' dv ws /3eArt'crr?7y eKrTjcrflat;
III. Nat. 212. Ovkovv /3eArtW eorat, eay eKoCcra KaKovpyfj d

re *at ap.apTav7], 77 eay aKoucra;
IIT. Aiivov p.(VTav etrj, a> 2wKpares, et ot zkovtzs
ctbLKOvvTts /3eArt'o?js eowrat 77 ot aKovrey.
2X2. 'AAAd p.7]v cpaCvovraC ye eK rwr eip?7/xeVa)i\ 5
IIT. Ovkow e/xotye.
212. 'Eyco 8' &p.t]v, S) 'l7nua, Kat crot cpavrjvaL. irdkLV
airoKpLvaL' r) bLKaLocrvvr) ovxl rj bvvap.Cs tCs ecrrii> ?/ eirLcrTrjp.il
77 d/xcpdrepa; 77 ovk dvdyKr) iv ye rt rojVaw etrat ti]v
bLKaLocrvvqv ; III. Nat. 212. Ovkow et pxv bvvap.Cs ecrrt e

rijs ^v\rjs r) bLKaLoavvt], 1) bvvaTuiTepa if/vxri otKatorepa
ecrri; /3eArtW ydp 7rou t/uiV icpdvr), a> dptcrre, 77 TOLavTt).
III. 'E(pdyr/ ydp. 2X2. Tt 8' et e7ricrr7//x?7 ; ovx f) crocpco-
re'pa \^t>x?/ 8tKatore'pa, r) oe ap.adecrTipa dbLKooTtpa; (III. 5
Nat'.)-- 2X2. Tt 8' et ap-cpoTepa; oi>x y dp.cpoTepas exoucra,
k-nLcm]p.r)v koX bvvap.LV, 8tKatore'pa, 7)

8' d/xac9ecrre'pa d8iKO)-
repa; oi>x ovtcos avdyKr) exeti; III. 4>atrerat.2i2.

Otjkow f) bvvaTcaripa Kal crocpcorepa avTT) d/xeu>a>y ovcra
ecpdvr) kcli dfx<po'repa p.dkkov bvvap.vt) ttollv, Kat rd 10
KaAd Kat rd atcrxpd, 7rept 7rdcray epyacrCav; III. Nat. 37^

2X2. "Oraz> dpa rd atcrxpd epydîjrai, eKovcra epydferat
8td bvvap.LV Kal tx V71 v '
TavTa 8e StKatocrwT/s tpatrerat, ?/rot
d/xcpdrepa 7/ rd tTepov. III. "EoiKev 2X2. Kat to /xeV ye

d8tKe> KaKa 7roteti> cttlv, rd 8e p.r) dStKeiy KaAd. III. Nat. 5
2X2. Ovkow 7) bvvaTWTtpa Kat dp.zCvu>v ^X 7/ oTavirep
dbLKT), kKovcra d8tK7;cret, 7) 8e Trovrjpd &Kovcra;^ III. tWyerai.
2X2. Ovkow dyaObs dv7]p 6 tt)v dyadr)v ^j/vxqv eyu>v, kokos b
C 4 (Kovcriws T F Ikoixtiovs W d 5 (palvovral F <paiv(ra( T W

W
: :
e 6 yaf add. recc. om. T F

: 67^8' aixadeffripa aSiKwrtpa secl.
Beck e 9 avrr) T a\>Tt\ W : t\ F
b
376 I1AATI2N02 II7HIA2 EAATT12N

Se 6 ti]v KaKrjv; 111. Nat. 2X2. 'Ayadov uei> apa avbpos
Icttlv eKOVTa abiKelv, KaKov 8e aKovra, elirep 6 ayaObs aya6r)v
y\rvyj)v eêi. IFI. 'AAAa pvqv eyjei ye. 212. 'O apa eKcoy
5 ap.apTavu>v Kal alo^pa Kal aStKa ttol&v, co '\irnia, et7rep rts
eoriv ovtos, ovk av aAAos efoi r/ 6 ayados.

III. Ovk exco oircos ctol crvy\(apr]cru), 2 2&>K/)ares, ra?3ra.
212. Ovbe yap eyco e/xot, 2 'iTTTrta' aAA' avayKaiov ovrco
C (paiveo-Qai vvv ye 77/xty ex rou Aoyou. 6Ve/> weVrot 7raAat
eAeyoy, eyco 7rept raCra ai>co xat Karco i;\avG>p.ai Kal ovbiiroTe
ravTa p.01 boKcl. Kai ewe p.ev ovbev 6avp.acrTov irXavacrOai
ovbe aWov lotcorr/y et oe Kai vuets TrXavrjcrecrde ol crocpoi,
5 tovto ijbrj Kai ^juty btLvbv et /uj8e 7rap' vjaas acpLK6p.V0L

7ravo-o'ue0a r?/s 7rAayrjs.
b6 ovtos T W : om. F c3 /tot TW : ifnol F

^p
IX2,N
st. i
2GKPATH2 H2N p. 530
212. Tbv "lcova yaCpeLV. ttoOcv tcl vvv r\pXv itnbeb^- a

jur/Kas; r) olkoOcv e 'Ec/Wcrou;
IX2N. Ovbapaos, co 2coK/)ares, dAA' e 'Einbavpov ck tS>v
'Ao-KATj7rtetW.
212. Mcov koi pa^rcobcov aycova ridiao-iv rcp 0eco ol 5
'Ethociuoich;
H2N. ndw ye, Kat rrjs dAArrs ye p.ovo-LKr)s.
212. Tt ow; r)y<ovLov tl fip.Lv; Kal irS>$ tl r)ycovLcrco;

II2N. Td TrpStTa tcov adXcov r)veyKap.da, co 2coKpares. b
212. E3 Ae'yets* aye br) ottcos kol tcl Uavadrjvaia VLKrj-
crop.v.
IX2N. 'AAA' ecrrat raSra, eav #eds ec9e'Arj.
2X2. Kat p.r)v Trokk&KLs ye e^r/Acocra vp.as tovs payj/cobovs, 5

v
S> Icoy, Trjs rex^rrs* to yap 6.p.a pikv rb orcop.a KKocrp.r~)o~daL
ael TTpeirov vp.cov etrat tjj Tiyvri koX cos KaAAtcrrois cpai-
vecrdaL, ap.a be avayKalov etyat eV re dAAots Trotrrrais 8ta-
rpt/3ety 7roAAots kol ayaOols rtat 8r/ Kat /xdAtcrra eV 'O/zr/ocp,

rcp dptcrrco Kat fletordrco rtor 7rotr/rcoiv, kol rr)v tovtov 8td- io
ivotatv Kp.avddvLV, p.r) p.6vov tcl eVr/, (jjXcotov cttlv. ov c
ydp dy ykvoLTo Trore dya#ds pa^cobos, et /xr/ crwetrr rd
a7 7 T W f : T F a8 ti ^/xjv T W : tc ^/tiv F b 6 koco-

o-iArjo-Oai secl. Schanz b7 KaWiarots T WF : kAA/(Ttouj corr.
Par. 1812 C2 aâflbs ô^SJs F f5a^SJs T W oweir) F:
W
:
avvttir) f : o-uWrj T
PLATO, VOL. III. 33
:
530C nAAT&N02
keyop.va vtto tov ttolt]tov. tov yap pa\j/u>bbv kppxjvia 8et
tov ttolt^tov rrjs biavotas yiyveaOai. rots aKovovcri' tovto 8e
S KaX5>s ttolclv p.r) yiyv(ao~KovTa otl Ae'yet 6 7rotr/rT/s abvvarov.
ravra ovv irdvTa dta (jt]kovo-0aL.
I2N. 'AAr/flr/ . Aeyets, co 2coKpares* e/xoi yovv tovto

i:\iLcrTOV ipyov irapicry^v rr/s Tiyvqs, kol otpai KaAAicrra
av6p(oiT(tiV KiyeLV irepl ÔpJipov, cos ovtc Mr]Tp6bo)pos 6
d AapA/VaKr/ivds oi/re 2rrjo-i)a/3poros 6 dcrios ovre TkavKoov
ovt akkos ot>8eis rcov 7rco7rore yzvopAvoiv zo-yzv et7reti> orDrco
<
irokkas kol Kakas bLavoias Trepi Op.r]pov oaas eyco.
212. Erj Ae'yets, S> "Icoir brjkov yap otl ov (pdovrjo~LS
5 pot e7rt8etât.
IX2N. Kai p.i]v &lov ye dKoScrai, 5> 2a>Kpares, cos ev
KKoo-p.r]Ka tov "Opvt]pov cocrre ot/u,at v7ro 'Our/pi8coy dftos
X/31"7 ^ ~T*<pdvo) crre<pa/vco0r/Vat.

etrvat
2X2. Kat ur/rv eycb ert 7rotr/cro/xat o-\okr)v aKpodcrao-daC
53 1 "ou, vvv 8e uot roawSe diroKpLvaL' Trorepov 7repi 'Our/poTj

c
povov btLvbs et r/ Kat 7repi Ho-to'8orj xat 'ApxiAo'xprj;
II2N. Ovgaucos, dAAd 7repi 'Our/porj p.6vov LKavbv ydp

fxoL boKL et/vat.
5 212. "Ecrrt Se 7repi otov "Op.r]p6s re Kai 'HcrtoSos ravrd

Aeyerorv; IX2N. Otuat eycoye Kai 7roAAd. 212. YIoTtpov
ovv 7repi tovtojv KakkLov av eTfr/yT/craio a "OpT/pos Aeyet
77 d 'HcrtoSos; IX2N. 'Ouotcos dv 7rept ye tovtojv, co
b 2coKpares, 7repi c3y ravrd Ae'yorjcri7J. 2X2. Tt 8e cov
7repi ur) ravrd Aeyorjo-tJj; oto/v ?repi p.avTLKrjs Ae'yet rt
"Ourjpo's re Kai 'HcrtoSos. Ii2N. ndrjrj ye 212. Tt

ovv; oaa re dnotcos Kal oaa dtacpopcos 7rept p.avTLKr)s
5 Aeyeroy rco 7rotrjrd rorjrco, Trorepov o~v KakkLov av e^r/-
c 7 e^toi 70CJ/ WF : i/xoi y' o5v T C9 &s] o5(tt' H. Richards

d1 r\avKv~] r\avKos Sydenham d. 6 ye F : om. T W
d9 aKpodaaadai F aKpoaffdai T W a 2 jxovov Sttvbs tl ^
W
:
T : 5t/6s tJfTj /urfj/oi/ F (t) post efTj add. f) a3 -yctp T W f

om. F
IX2N 53i b
yr/craio r) tG>v pdvTa>v tls t5>v dya6G>v; 1X2N. Tcoy

IxdvTeoov. 2X2. Et 8e crv r)cr6a p.dvTLS, ovk, elirep rrepl
tG>v 6poia>s kyop.Vo>v 0X69 t rjcrda Z^rjyrjo-acrdai, Kal irepi
tG>v bi,a(p6p(tis kyop.va>v rynio-TU) av ecfr/yeto-flat; IX2N.

Arj\ov otl. IO
212. Tl OVV TTOT TTp\ p.V 'OpJfpOV bLVOS L, 7Tpl 8e C

c
Ho-to'8ot; ov, ovSe tS>v dkka>v iroirjT&v ; i) "Op.r)pos 7Tpl
dkka>v tlvG>v Ae'yet r) 8>vnep o-vp.TTavTS ol dAAot 7rorrai;

OV TTpl 7T0kp.0V T TO. TTOkkd bLkr)kvdV KOL TTpl 6p.lkl.5>V
rrpos akkrjkovs avdpanrutv aya6G>v T koX KaK&v Kal i8ia>Tcor 5
Kat br)p.LovpyG>v, Kal 7repi 6a>v irpbs akkrjkovs Kal rrpbs
dv6p<s>TTovs 6p.ikovvTo>v, 6>s 6p.ikov(Ti, Kal TTpl T&v ovpaviatv

TTa6r)paTa>v Kal 7rept tG>v V "kibov, KOL yV0-lS Kal 0G>V
/cat r)pa>a>v; ov Tavrd eort 7rept a>v "Oprjpos tt)v iroirfo-LV d

TTTT0ir)KV ;
IX2N. 'Akr)6r} Aeyets, co 2coKpaTes.

2X2. Tt 8e 01 dAAot TToiryrai; ov 7rept tG>v avTG>v
tovt(x>v; 5
IX2N. Nat, dAA', co 2coKpaTes, ov\ 6p.oia>s 7re7rot?/Kacrt

koL "Op.r)pos.
20. Tt pujv; KaKtov;
IX2N. noAv ye.
2X2. "Op.r)pos 8e dp.ivov; 10
II2N. "Ap.LVOV p.VTOL VI) Ata.

212. Ovkovv, S> qbikr) Kec/mAr/ "la>v, orav 7rept dpL6p.ov
7TokkG>v kyovTu>v ets tis dptora Ae'y?/, yycocreTat brjTrov tls

tqv v kiyovra; IX2N. <t>r)p.i. 2X2. Tlorepov ovv 6 avros e
ocr7rep Kat tovs KaKG>s kiyovras, r) dAAos; IX2N. O at>Tos
brJTTOV. 2X2. OvKOW 6 TT/y dpLdp.r)TLK1]V TX.Vr)V \(V OVTOS

io-TLv; IX2N. Nat. 2X2. Tt 8'; drav irokkG>v AeybVcov
7Tpl vyLLvG>v o-lt'lu>v oTTold Otlv, ets tis dpLOTa Aeyr/, 5
TTOTpOV TpOS p.V TLS TOV dpKTTa ktyOVTa yV(aCTTaL OTL
C]is dfuAovai secl. Cobet

33*
53ie IIAATX2N02
apurTa Aeyet, erepos be tov kolklov otl k<xklov, f/ 6 avros;
IX2N. Arjkov brJTTOv, 6 avros. 2X2. Tfc ovtos; tL 6vop.a
avrco; IX2N. 'Iarpo'?. 212. Ovkovv ev Ke<pakai<a keyop.ev
io a>s 6 avrbs yucocrerat aei, irepl t&v avT&v irokk&v keyov-
532 T<x>v, oo-Tis re ev Ae'yet Kal ootls KaK&s" rj et p.r) yvuxreraL
tov KaK(2s keyovra, brjkov otl ovbe rbv efl, 7rep ye tov
avTov. IX2N. Ovtu>s. 212. Ovkovv 6 avTos yiyverai beivbs
irepl ap.<poTep<x>v; 1X2N. Nat. 2X2. Ovkovv <rv <pfjs kol
5 "OpLrjpov Kal tovs aXXovs TTOLrjrds, ev ols Ka\ 'Ho-Cobos Kal
'ApxfKoxos tcrTLV, irepi ye tG>v avrS>v keyeiv, dAA' ovx
6p.oi<as, akka tov p.ev ev ye, tovs be x^P 0V > I&N. Kat
akrjdrj Aeyco. 2X2. Ovkovv, elirep tov ev Aeyorra ytyvco-
b o-Keis, k<xl tovs x ^P 0V kiyovTas ytyrcocrKOts av ort x*ty ov
keyovo-LV. IX2N. *Eolk4v ye. 2X2. Ovkovv, <o /3e'Artcrre,
6p.oi<as tov "\u>va keyovres irepl 'Opvqpov re beLvbv elvai Kal

irepX tQ>v akk<ov TroirjT&v o&x ajxapTr]o-6p.e0a, eireLbrj ye
5 avros 6p.okoyfj rbv avTov ecreadaL KpLTr)v LKavbv iravTObv
6<tol av irepX tS>v avrS>v Aeycocrt, tovs be TTOLrjTas o-x^bbv
airavTas tcl avTa TTOLelv.
IX2N. Tt ovv irore rb clXtlov, co 2coKpares, ort eyco, otov

p.ev tls irepX #AAoi; tov 7rotr/roi5 8taAe'yr/rat, ot/re Trpoaex *
C tov vovv abvvaT<2 re *at ortow avp.t3ake<r0aL koyov aiov,

dAA' a.Texv<as vv<rr<x<x>, eireLbav be" tls irepX 'Opr/pou p.vr)o-0fj,
ev0vs Te eyprjyopa kol 7rpocre'xco rbv vovv xat eviropSt otl

Aeyco;
5 2X2. Ov xo-keTrbv tovto ye etKcicrat, co eratpe, dAAd 7rayrt
brjkov 6tl Tx VTl Ka ' *TTi>o~Typ<V Trept 'OpLrjpov keyeLv abvvaros
et* et ydp Tex v V ' 0? Te W^ a > Ka ' ^repl tQ>v akk<av 7rotr;rcov
aira,VT<x)v keyeiv olos r av r)<r0a % 7rotr/rtKr) yap ttov ecrrty
to okov. r) ov;
e 7 6 avr6s F : abr6s : T W
avr6s Schanz e 9 \4y Ofxtv &s
Wf : \ey6fievos F : A7a>yuj> ws T eiooTW: om. F a7 3
ye TW F tv S 6 Keywaib F : Keyovffi T W b8 rh oXtiov
W
:
T : t' atriov F c8 andvrwv \eyeiv T F: om. W

IX2N 532 c
IX2N. Nat. ,o
212. Ovkovv eTreibav Ad/3r/ rts /cat akkrjv rzyyw t)vtl- d

vovv oAt/jj, 6 avrbs rpoiros rfjs crKe'\//ecos' earat 7rept aTracr&v
tu>v T\vQv; 7rco? tovto Ae'yco, 8e'r/ tl p.ov aKovo-ai, 2> "lcav;
IX2N. Nat p.a tov ACa, co 2coKpares, eycoye* yaCpm yap

a.KOV(av vp.5>v tG>v crocpQv. 5
212. BotjAoi/xt/ij ay cre dkrj$r) Ae'yeu>, co "Icojj" dAAd crocpol
p.ev ttov ecrre rj/xeis ot paxfrhibol Kat VTroKpiral koX cojj Tjpeis
aSere rd 7rotT/para, eyco 8e orjSerj aAAo r/ TaXrjOrj Ae'yco,
oIojj ewcos tcricorr/jj avOpoynov. eTret Kat 7rept ro7jrou o{/ jjjjjj
r)pop.r\v o-e, 0e'acrat cos cpavkov Kal ibmiTLKOv ecrrt /cat 7rarjrds
dvbpbs yvGtvai 6 eAeyoij, rr/ij ai>Ti]v etvaL crKeS/Vtij, e7ret8dy

rts oAr/y Teyyrjv Ad/3r/. Ad/3copeij ydp rco Adyar ypacptKr/
ydp rts ecrrt Ttyyr) -~b okov; IX2N. Nat. 2X2. Otjkotjjj 5
Kat ypacprjs 7toAAoi xat etcrt Kai yeydijacrtij dyadol Kat cpav-
Aot; IX2N. Ylavv ye. 2X2. v
H8r/ ow rtra etSes dcrrts 7rept
pey IToAuyiJcorou tov ' Aykaocp&VTOs betvos ecrrty airocpaC-
vs.lv a ev re ypdcpet Kal a /xr/, 7repi be rcoij dAAcoy ypacpecov

abvvaTos; Kal e7retdij peV rts rd rcoy dkkoiv (fcoypdcpcoij 533
epya eTTLbeLKVvr\, ij7jcrrdet re Kat d-ropel Kat otjk eêt ort
crrj/x/3dAr/rat, e7ret8ajj oe 7rept IToATjyzJcorou 17 dAAorj otov
/3ouAet rcoy ypacpeoov evbs p.6vov berj aTTOCpr)vacr9aL yjJco/xrjjj,
eyprjyopev re Kai 7rpocreyeL tov vovv kol evTropel ort et7rr/; 5
IX2N. Orj pa tov Aia, ov brjra. 2X2. T 8e'; iv avbpiavTo-

Ttoua ijbrj tlv et8es octtls 7rept p.ev Aat8dAou tov Mtitlovos
t/ 'E7retorj rorj ITa7J07re'cos r) 0eo8copou rorj 2ap,tou r) dAAorj b
tlvos avbpLavTOTTOLov tvbs 7re'pt SeiTjds ecrrtTJ e^r/yetcrât a
erj 7re7rotr/Keij, ei> 5e rots rcozj dAAcorj avbpLavTOTroi&v epyots
a7ropet re Kat rjrjcrrdêt, orjK I^cojj ort et7rr/; IX2N. Orj /xd
d2 *(TTai F : iffri T W d7 wro/)iTaJ F : 01 vKOKpiraX T W

d8 ra TW: om. F TdArjflf) TWF:
ra rrA^r; Madvig ei-^0Tj :
Schanz : utA^ vel Ta evrt A^ H. Richards e 1 jw] wrS^ Schanz

05 vaiTF: om. W a2 txdWFt; *x~lT a 4 M^" ow
secl. Naber
533b IIAATilNOS
5 tov ACa, ovbe tovtov ecopaKa. 212. 'AAAd p.r]V, a>$ y eyco
olfiai, ovb' iv avXrjcreL ye ovbe iv Ktflaptcrei ovbe iv Kidapcpbiq

oibe ev pa\j/(i>biq ovbeiranroT etbes avbpa octtls irepl p.\v
'Okvpirov btivos o~tlv ei7yeicr0ai r/ irepl Qapvpov r) 7rept
C 'Opcpeco? t) irepl r]p.Cov tov 'ldaKrjcrCov pa\(r(obov, 7rept be

"Iojvos tov 'EcpecrCov [paxj/bibov] airopel kol ovk eyjtL crvp.fia-
KecrdaL a re ev pa\^co8ei Kal a p.i].
IX2N. Ovk ex.ui croL irepl tovtov avTLkeyeLV, co ScoKpares*

5 dAA' ZkcIvo epaurco o-iWi8a, ori Trepl 'Opr/pou KaAAtcrr'
av6pa>Tmv Aeyco /cat evrropG) koX ol dAAot 7rdi>res p.e cpacnv

ev XeyeLV, -nepl be tu>v dAAcoy ov. KaLToi opa tovto tC
ecrTLV.
2X2. Kat 6p&, ) "liov, Kal ep\op.aC ye crot cnroq>avov-
d p.evos 6 p.0L boKti tovto elvaL. ecrrt ydp tovto Texyr] l

x *v
ovk ov irapa crol irepl 'OpLrjpov ev Aeyeu, 6 vvvbr) e/Xeyov,
6eCa be bvvap.LS rj cre klvzl, uxrirep ev rr/ At#co rjv Evpt-

7TLbrjs p.ev MayvrJTLV (hvopacrev, ol be 7roAAot 'HpaKAetW.
5 Kat yap axnrr) r) s\C6os ov p.6vov avrovs tovs baKTvXCovs ayei
tovs crLbrjpovs, dAAd Kal bijvap.LV evTC6r)o~L rots baKTvkCoLS
cocrr' av bvvacrdaL tovtov tovto ttolclv oirep r) \C6os, a/\/\ovs
e &yLV baKTvkCovs, cocrr' evCore oppadbs /xa/cpos 7rdzn> crt8?7-
pCcov Kal baKTv\LU>v e aWrikojv ^/prrjrat* 7rdcrt be tovtols

e 6KLvr]s rrjs XCdov r) bvvap.LS avrjpTr]TaL. ovtoj be Kat r)
Mo7jcra ivdeovs p.ev 7rotet avrt], 8td b\ tu>v Zvdecov tovtoov
5 dAAcoy ZvdovcrLaCovTcov 6pp.a66s kf;apTaTaL. TravTts yclp ol
h5 8>s y eyi> T W : ws 70)76 F c i fiatytpSov secl. Naber

C2 fjwp<fidov F om. T W ffvnfSaKio-dai WF : ffvfjL&aWeffBai T
W
:
C6 ^TW: ifie F C9 fyxofiat F &pxo/j.ai T &7ro-

WF
:
(pavoi>fj.evos Cobet : airo<paiv6fievos TW F d i Te'xi / ) Sto-

baeus txi'J7 T d.2 bvTW F : av Stobaeus d5 &ye 1
TW
:
WF Stobaeus om. T d7 a5 otivaffQai F: Svvaffdai

WF
:
e 1 fiaKpbs irdvv T WF : irdvv fiaKpbs Stobaeus aiS-qpiwv

Stobaeus: ffiS-fipuv T fftSvpuv Jacobs (secl. mox ko.\) 62 caJ
WF
:
Sa/cTuA.fwv secl. Hermann ^pTrjTat T Stobaeus efperat

TW
:
e 4 pev T F Stobaeus om. : W avr^ F Stobaeus : afirTi
e 5 &\\uv T W
F &\\os Stobaeus : T W F om. Stobaeus
ol re :
I12N 533 e
re tu>v k-nStv 7roiT/rat ol ayaOol ovk e/c Ttx vr)S dAA' eVfleot
ovres nal KarexdpevoL irdvTa Tavra ra *caA.a Aeyoucrt 7rot?/-
p.ara, Kat ol peAo7rotoi ol ayadol cocravTcos, axnrep ol Kopv-

l3avTia>VTS ovk fp.(ppoves ovres opyovvTai, ovrco Ka\ ol p.eko- 534
TTOLol OVK i!p.(ppOVeS OVTS TCL Ka\CL p.ekr} TaVTa TTOLOVCTLV,
dAA' e7ret8dy ep/3cocru> ds tt)v app.oviav koX ds tov pv0p.6v,
fiaKyevovo~L Kal KarexopevoL, uxnrep al fiaKXv TTOTap.a>v pe'At Kal ydAa Karexop-evaL, fycppoves 8e ovcrai 5
ov, Kal tS>v pekoiroLUiV i) \jrvxv tovto epyd(eTaL, oirep avrol

Ae'yot>cri. Aeyoucrt yap hr)Trov0ev irpbs r)p.as 01 iroLrjTal otl
d-nb Kprjv&v peAippvrcoz; K Movar&v kijttoov tlvS>v Kal vairSiV b
hpeiropevoL tcl p.ekr) r)p.LV cpepovcrLV axnrep at /jteAtrrai, Kat
avrot ovrco TTT6p.evoL' Ka\ dkrjdrj KeyovcrL. Kovcpov yap
XPW a 7roi7/r7/y eoTiv Kat iTTr)vbv Ka\ lepov, koX ov TrpoTepov

olos re 7roteti' irp\v av ev0eos re yevryraL kol K(ppu>v Ka\ 5
6 vovs /XT/Kert ev avrco evfj' ecos 8' av tovtl ixjl T0 K7"W a >
dbvvaros irds 7roteu> avOpooiros otlv ko.1 xPV^r1 *?^^' aT

ovv ov T^xvrj TTOLOVVTS KOL TTOkka XeyOVTCS Ka\ KaXa Trep\
tS>v irpayp.aT(jdv, uxnrep crv 7rept 'Op.r)pov, cxAAa #eta p.oipa, C

tovto piovov olos re eKacrro? itollv KaAcos ecp' 6 r) MoScra
airbv S>ppr)crev, 6 piev 8t0rpdu/3ov?, 6 8e eyKcouta, 6 8e
vTTOpxvp.aTa, 6 8' e7rr/, 6 8'

ldp.(3ovs' dAAa cpaCAostcl 8'
avrS>v eKaords Zcttlv. ov yap tx v V Ta ^ Ta heyovcrw dAAa 5
0eia vvdp.eL, iirei, et 7rept kvbs t4x v V Ka^^ s r)iTi(TTavTo
Aeyetr, kolv irep\ tu>v aXXoov dirdvTOiv 8ta ravra 8e 6 debs
e 7 /coAck TF /cok&W W e8 F /xe\oiroto\ T f : fihv \otirol

W Stobaeus
:
Stobaeus a 1 Kal T a4 /tev ol F flaKxevovo-i

T W F om. Stobaeus
:
F Stobaeus *al &oKxevov<Ti TW at ^3aKx al

TW
: :
apvovratW F Stobaeus T : a5
apvroi/Tai
W bi &
odarat oti : oSerat
F Stobaeus
oi; a T F Stobaeus 7 7rpby : irap'
TW
:
TWF ^ :Stobaeus
^/c b3 F inrofievot f : irT<6/xe/oj
Stobaeus b Upbv T W F Stobaeus

4 Dobree b5 : Siepbv tv()e6s
reTWf: F Stobaeus
tvBtos b6 avr$ T W F fi^Ktrt tv : iv avrlf
Stobaeus b8 TW F Hoenebeek
prius *cal rt nal secl.
TW
:
fi.t)Keri :
Hissink C Ka\ws W F Ka\bs T 2 C7 : airdvrwv :
vdvruv F Stobaeus
534 c nAAT&N02
eaLpOVp.VOS TOVT00V TOV VOVV TOVTOLS xPV Tai virqpeTais- Kal
d rots xP^Pôts Kal rots p.avTeo-1, rots 0eioLS, 'iva r/pets ol
aKovovres elb&p-ev otl ovy ovroi dcnv oi TavTa keyovres

ovtoo ttoWov dta, ols vovs p.i) irapeo~TLV, dAA' 6 0e6s avros
co-tlv 6 keyoiv, 8td tovtojv be cptVyyerat Trpbs r)p.ds. p.e-
5 yLo-Tov be TeKp-rjpLOv rco Adyco TrWtxos XaAKtSerJs, bs

dAAo juey o?38ei> tto)ttot erroi-qo-e iroir]p,a orou rts o:y dtco-
creiey p.vr]o-9rjvaL, tov be Traioova bv irdvTes a8ot>cri, crxe8di>
rt 7rdt>rcoz; p,eA<3i> KaAAtcrroz;, drexi>cos, 07rep arjrds Ae'yet,
e " evpqpd tl Moicray." ey roi/rcp ydp 8?) /xdAtcrrd /aoi 8oKet

6 0eds ez>8eiacr0at rjpXv, tva p.r) 8icrrdcop,ei', ort oiik avOpoi-
ttlvcl ko-TLV tcl KaAa ravra 7rotr//zara ovbe dv0poiTT(av, dAAct
0eta Kat 0e<3f, ot 8e wotrjrat ov8ez> dAA' rj epp-rjvrjs elcrLV
5 r<3z> 0e<3z>, Karexd/xerot ef otov dv eKaoros Kare'x?7rai.

ra>ra evbeLKvvp.evos 6 0ebs e<fe7Ttrr/8ey 8td tov (pavkoTaTov
535 7rotTjroi) ro KaAAioroj; /xe'Aos r/<rey r) ov 8ok<3 crot dX-qOq

v
Ae'yetz>, u> Icoz>;
IX2N. Nat pd tov Aia, e/xotye* a7rret ydp 7rcos p.ov rots
Adyots rr/s ^vyrps, > 2coKpares, Kat /xot 8oKO?3cri 0eta potpa
5 r/pti' 7rapd r<3z> 0e<3z> raSra ot dyacôt 7rotr7rat epp.rjveveLV.
212. Ovkovv r3p,ets au ot pa^cpSot ra tG>v 7rotr7r<3z> epprr-

z>evere;
I12N. Kat tovto d\ri0S Aeyets.

212. OrjKorjy epp.r]veo)v epp.i]vr)s yiyvear0e;
IO I12N. YlavTaTrao-i ye.
v v
D 212. Exe br) /xot rd8e et7re, S Iaw, Kat pr/ aTTOKpv\j/ri
otl dv cre epcopat* orav ei! et7rrrs e7rr/ Kat eK7rAr/^r/s pdAtcrra
rovs 0o>p.evovs, r) tov '08ucrcre'a oray e7rt rdy orjSd^ ecpa\-
Xop.evov a8r?s, Kqbavfj yvyvopevov rots p.vrjo-Trjpo-L ko.1 k-
d3 outco T WF : tA oStw Stobaeus oAA' iTF:

oXAo 6 Sto-
baeus : &\Xa W aiiT<Jy iariv T WF Igtiv avrbs Stobaeus
W
:
d. 7 Traiwva TF : iraicova e i evprjfid rt Stephanus evpfifiaTi

TWF
:
a 3 yap irws fiov T : ydp ircas fxov W ydp fiov irais F

:
b i /ioiTW: koi /tot F b3 ovbbv WF t : oSbc T

IX2N 535b
yeovra tovs olo-tovs irpb t<2v irobG>v, rj A\Lkkea errt tov 5

"EnTopa 6pp.5>vTa, rj koI tS>v irepl ""kvbpopLdyrjv ekeLv5>v ti rj
irepl 'EKafiriv r) irepl UpCauov, totc Trorepov ep.(ppoiV et 17 eco
cravTov yCyvrj kol irapd tols irpdyuacrLV oterat aov elvai r) c

yj/vxi] ots Aeyets v6ovo-ia(fi v<Ta> V *v 'I&wctj ovcrti> r) ev
TpoCq r) 077(os ay Kat rd eTrrj exj?;
IX2N. *X2s evapyes p.0L roCro, co 2coKpares, to TeKpvqpLov
et7res* ov ydp cre a7roKpv\j/dp.evos epco. eyco ydp orav 5
ekeLvov rt Ae'yco, baKpvcov ep.irCp.TrkavTaC p.ov ol 6(p6akuoC'

oTav re (poftepbv r) beLvov, opdal al TpCyes tarazrat V7r6
(pofiov Kal r) KapbCa Trrjbq.
v
2X2. Tt ow; (p5>p.ev, co Icov, ep.(ppova elvai tot tovtov d
r6v dvdpwirov, bs av KeKoo-p.rjp.evos ecrdrJTL TroLKCkrj /cat
Xpuaotcrt o-Tecpa.voLS Kkdrf r ev OvcrCaLS kol eopTals, p.r\bev

a7roAcoAeKcoy tovtoov, r) c/>o/3^rat rrkeov rj ev bLcruvpCois dvdpoi-
ttols ecrrrjKoos cpiAtots, p-rjbevbs aTiobvoVTOS p.rjbe dbLKOvvTos; 5
IX2N. Ov p.d tov ACa, ov irdvv, o> 2coKpares, cos ye

rdAjifle? elprjcrdaL.
2X2. Otcrfla ovv otl fcai t5>v 6eaT(2v tovs Trokkovs raura
raCra vaels epyd(êcr6e;
IX2N. Kat p.dka KaAcos otSa' Ka6op5> yap eKacrTOTe e
avTovs dvcoOev airb tov /3rjp.aTos Kkdovrds re Kat beLvbv
ep.(3keiT0VTas kol crvv6ap.fiovvTas tols keyoaevoLS. bel ydp
p.e kol crcpobp' avrols tov vovv irpocreyjELV cos edv p.ev
KkdovTas avrovs KadCaoj, avTOS yekdcrouaL apyvpLov kaufid- 5
vo>v, eav be yekS>vTas, avTos KkavcrouaL apyvpLOv aTrokkvs.

2X2. Ottrt9a ovv otl ovtos ecrrLv 6 6eaTr)s tG>v baKrvkCoiv
6 o"xaTos, (ov eyco ekeyov vtto rrjs 'HoaKAetcortSos At0ou

a7r' dAAÂcoy r?/y bvvap.Lv kaufidveLV ; 6 be p.eaos o~v 6
c2 olffiv T WF : olffa S c3 Hirois TF : irwj W C6 /jlov

TF : fioi W d. 1 tJt tovtov W F tovtov t<5t T tovtov recc.
TW
: :
Schanz d3 xP vff0 ^' i F XP

: V0~?S d 4 <pofirJTat T :
<po$e?Tai WF d5 <pi\iots TW F f : <pl\ois d8 Tcarrct TavTa

TF : tol Toiavra W
536a IIAAT&N02
536 pa\j/<jobos kclL VTTOKpiTr\s, 6 8e 7rp<2ros avTos 6 7roirrrr/s" 6 8e
6e6s bta tto,vtu>v tovtu>v eAKet tt)v \jsvxr]v ottol av /3orjAr/rat
tujv av6pu\iru>v, avaKpepavvvs e dAAr/Acoi/ Tr)v bvvap.iv.
Kal u>o"irep K Trjs kidov eKeCvqs 6pp.a66s 7rdp,7roArjs e^rjp-
5 rrjrat xP VT & v Te Ka ' 8t8ao-KaAcoy kol rj7ro8i8ao"KdAcoi>, Zk
irkayCov e^t]pTr]p.evu>v tu>v rrjs Morjcrr/s eKKpep.ap.evu>v ba-

ktvXloov. koX 6 p.ev tujv 7rotr/rcoi; e akkrjs MorjVrrs, 6 8e
e akkrjs e>;f)pTr]TaL ovop.aop.ev be avro KarexeraL, to be
b eort 7rapa7rAr/criozr eyjeTaL y ao K '
^ e tovtoov tu>v TTpu>Tu>v
baKTvkCu>v, tujv TTOLrjTobv, akkoL e dAAorj av r/prrj/jteVot elcrl
Kat e7J0orjo-idbrjo-tz>, 01 pev e 'Op<pe'cos, 01 8e eK Morjcratorj-

<
01 8e 7roAAoi e Qp.f)pov KaTe\ovTaC re Kat eyovraL. Stv
v
5 o-rj, co Icojj, ets et Kat KaTeyr] e 'O/ur/porj, Kat e7ret8dv /xeV
rts aAAov tov 7rotrrrorj a8rj, Ka0erJ8ets re Kat d7ropets ort

Ae'yrjs, e7ret8dy 8e rorjrorj rou ttoltjtov cpdey>;r]TaC tls p.ekos,
evdvs eypr)yopas Kal dpxetrat crov r) ^vyji KaX eviropets otl
C Aeyrjs* orj yap reyvr] or38' eirLcrrf)p.j] irepl 'Oprjporj Aeyets
a Aeyets, dAAa deCq p.oCpq Kat KaroKcoxr/, &crTTep ol Kopv-

j3avTLu>VTes eKeCvov p.6vov alcrddvovTaL tov p.ekovs oe'cos
6 av rj tov deov e drorj av KaTeyu>vTaL, Kat ets eKetyo to

5 p.ekos Kat 0-yjqp.a.Tojv Kal pr]p.a.Tu>v evTropovcn, tu>v 8e dAAcoi;
orj cppovTLôvcrLV' ovtoj koj. cru, u> "\u>v, irepl p.ev 'Op.f)pov
orav tls p.vr]crdi], evTropeis, 7rept 8e rtoy aAAcov d7ropets*
d tovtov 8' eort ro atrtoy, o />t' epcora?, 8t' ort cn 7rept /u.ey
'Op.rjpov erj7ropets, 7rept 8e rcoy aAAcoy orj, ort ov Texvj) dAAa

deCq. /xotpa 'Opr/pou 8etô? et eTratyeVr/y.
I12N. 2rj p,ey erj Aeyeis, co 2coKpares* 6avp.a(fiLp.L p.evTav
5 et orjrco? eS et7rots, cocrre p.e avaireLcrai cos eyco KaTtyop.evos

Kal p.aLVop.evos "Op.r]pov e7rati'to. oTjuat 8e otj8' &y oot
80'âip.t, et /xorj aKorjcrats keyovTOS 7rept 'O/xr/porj.
212. Kat /Ar)y edeku> ye aKovcraL, ov p.evTOL irpoTepov
b2 aS iiprri/Mfvoi TF : o^rjpTrj/ueVotW b5 S>W T f : om. F

b6 tisTWF: r(s (ti) Schanz CI4 o-i /xeveSTWf: eS^fj/eSFfeS
/xiv S) d5 r outws F : ovtws d T W d 7 7TpJ TW : tj rr^pl F
IX2N 536 e
TTpLv &v fxot aiTOKpCvr) ro'8e* S>v "Opvqpos Aeyet irepl tlvos e
ev Aeyets; ov yap biJTrov irepl airavTOiv ye.
IX2N. Ev to-0t, 2> 2a>Koares, 7reot ovbevbs otov ov.

2X2. Ov 8r/7T07j Kat 7reoi tovtcov &v <tv p.ev rrjyxdêts
ovk elbdis, "Op.r)pos be Ae'yet. 5
IX2N. Kat Tavra irold eoTiv a "Op.r)pos p.ev Ae'yet, eya>

8e ovk olba;
2X2. Ov Kal irepl Teyy&v p.eVrot Ae'yet 7roAAaxo?j "Op.r)pos 537
Kat 7roAAa; olov *cat 7rept r)vLo\Las eav p.vi)<r6G> tol etri),
eyw o"ot <ppd<rto.
IX2N. 'AAA' eya> epaV eya) ydp p.ep.vi)p.aL.
2X2. Et7re 877 /uot a Aeyet Ne'ara)p 'A7jrtAo'xa> rw rjet, 5

irapaLviov vkaj3r)6rjvaL irepl Tr)v Kap,irr)v ev t?) i7T7ro8pop.ta
rn eVt FlarpoK Aa>.
IX2N. KAu>0r/i>ai 8e', <pr)<rL, Kat airoj eue'o-ra> eVt bC<pp(o

r]K eV apL<rTpa touv drdp tov befJLOv "lttttov b
KeVo-at dpoKAr/axis, etat re 01 r)vCa yjepcrCv.
eV vvcrcrr) be rot t7nros apLtrTepbs eyxpLp.tp6r)Tto,

d)S av tol TT\r]p.vr) ye 8odo-o-erai aKpov tKeVâi
ktjkAotj 77011/^010' At'0o?j 8' dAeWflat eiravpelv. 5
v
2X2. 'ApKet. rarjra 8r/, a> Ia>z>, rd e7rr/ etre opdtos Ae'yet C
"Op.r\pos etre /xr/, 7ro'repo? au yuotr/ ap.eivov, larpbs r) r)v(o-
Xos; IX2N. 'HVtoxos br)iTov. 2X2. Ildrepoy 6V1 Teyj-r\v
tovtiiv exet r/ Kar' aAAo rt; IX2N. Otjk, dAA' drt Teyyriv.
2X2. OtjkoV (Ka<rTr) Ttov Te^ytov a7ro8e'8orat tl vtto tov 5
6eov epyov otq re etrat yvyvtotrKeLv; ov ydp ttov a Kvj3epvi)-
TLKrj yLyv<a<TKopLV, yvto<rop.eda Kal tarpiKT/. IX2N. Ov 8r/ra.
2X2. Orj8e' ye a tarptKr/, ravra ko.1 tKtovlkt). IX2N.

e 1 \tyci T W : S \(ya F 6 2 \4yeis Cornarius \eyei T WF
W
:
a iroWaxov
1 S/xrjpos T : S/xijpos iroWaxov F a2 rivioxeias ex
Vioxfas T F a 8 outos S^ K\ivOrjvai libri Homerici iv^ffrcp
TWF: iv-T\(Krci> S cum libris Homericis (ivêo-rov Xen. Symp. iv. 6
qui mox iri Sl<ppov) b 2 re T 8^ F W
b 4 &/ F et suprascr. :
W (et sic libri Homerici) : /xr) TW C 1 apK'?. ravra 8)|TW:

apK(7 Sr/ ravra F C6 iroi/ TW : Sr)irov F
537d IIAATX2N02
d Ov brjra. 2X2. Ovkovv ovtoo kol Kara 7rao-G>v tG>v Ttyy&v,
a rfj kTepq TX V V yLyvti>o-Kop.ev, ov yvtocropeOa Trj krepq;
ro'8e be p.oi Trporepov tovtov cnroKpivai' ttjv p.ev krepav (f>r)s
etvai Tiva Ti\vy]v, tt)v 8' krepav; IX2N. Nat. 2X2. *Apa
5 coo-irep eyto TeKp.aLpop.evos, orav r) piev erepcov irpayp.dTti>v rj
kiTLO-Tr)pi.r\, r) 8' krepcov, ovtco KaAco Tf)v p.ev akkr)v, tt)v 8e aXXriv
e Te\vr]v, ovt(o koX o~v; IX2N. Nat. 212. Et ydp irov tG>v
avT&v npayp.a.Ttov e7rtcrrr/p.Tj elr) tls, tl dv Tr)v p.ev krepav

cpalp.ev etvaL, Ti]v 8' krepav, oirore ye Tavra elr) eibevaL dir
dpcpoTepatv; tixrirep eyco re ytyi/cocrKco otl irevre elcrlv ovtol
5 ot bdrKTvXoL, Kal o~u, a>cnrep eya>, irep\ tovtlov ravra ytyrco-

o~Kls' kol et cre eycb epoip.r]v et Tr) avrrj Ttyvr] yiyycocncoper
Tjj dpL8p.r]TLKfi tcl avTa eyco T kol crv r) aAAr/, <paii]s av

br)Trov rfj avrr). IX2N. Nau
538 2X2. *0 tolvvv aprt e/xeAAov eprjcreo-Oai cre, vvvl eiire, el
/cara iracriov tG>v TeyyGiV ovtco o-ol boKel, rfj p.ev avTjj Te\v>]
tcl avrd dvayKaiov elvaL yLyvti>crKLV, rfj 8' krepq pvr) ra avTa,
dAA' enrep aAAr/ ea-riv, dvayKaiov /cat erepa yLyvaxrKeLV.
5 IX2N. OvTti) p.0L boKei, co 2coKpares. 2X2. Ovkovv octtls dv
pvq exil TLva Teyyr)v, TavTf)s rrjs Texvqs Ta Xey6p.eva r)
7rpaTT6p.eva KaAcos yLyva>o-KLV oi>x ' os r ' eo-raL; IX2N.

b 'AAr/0fj XeyeLS. 2X2. UoTepov ovv irepX tG>v ttGv S>v elires,
etre KakG>s Ae'yet "Opr]pos etre p.f), crv KaXkLOv yvti>crr) r)
rjvioxos; .IX2N. Hvioxos. 2X2. 'Pai/fcoSos ydp irov et dAA'

oi>x r)vioxos. IX2N. Nat. 2X2. 'H 8e /5a\/^co8t/c?/ Tex vr \
5 ere'pa ecrrt Tr)s r)vL0XLKr)s; IX2N. Nat. 2X2. Et apa krepa,

irepl kreptov Kal errio-Tr)p.r) irpaypaTcov ecrrtv. TX2N. Nat.
2X2. Tt 8e br) orav "OpLrjpos Ae'yr/ cos rerpcojaeVco rco
c
Maxaozn EKa/A7j8r/ r) Neo-Topos 7raAAaKr) KVKeG>va iriveLv
c bibcoo-i; Kal Ae'yet 7rcos' ovtoos
d 1 koI /cora T /cal to F W 64 4y<i re T W syarye F
W
: :
b 6 koI iiri<TT-i}fi7i irpa.yixa.Toov F : vpayjxaWwv KaX iirtffTi)fii) T : xal

irpayfxaTODV iiri<XT-l)fxi) signis transpositionis additis in TF b7 5^)
T W f : om. F b8 e/co^Vj87j i) T W f : eKafiri 011 r)v F irlveiv

T W : iriuv F
;
H2N 538 c
olv(p npap.veioi, <pt]criv, em 8' alyaov Kvr\ rvpbv

Kinjarrt. xaAKeirj" itapa. 8e Kp6p.vov ttotu> 6\j/ov
ravra etre 6p0a>s Aeyet "Op.ripo$ etre p.rj, TioTepov laTpLKrjs

eort biayvStvaL KaAcos r) pa^/(obLKrjs 5
IX2N. 'laTpLKrjs.
212. Ti 8e', orav Aeyri "O/ur/pos

r) 8e p.oXvj3baivr] tKe'Ar> es /3vcrcrbv LKavev, d
rj re KaT aypavkoLo j3oos Kepas ep-p.ep.avLa
epêrat b>p.r]o-TfiaL p.er ly6vo-L 7rfjp.a qbepovcra'
ravra TTOTtpov <\>5>p.ev a\LVTLKrjs etzvat Teyjftis luxKkov KplvaL

r) pa\l/a>bLKrjs, aTTa Aeyet Kal etre KaAcos etre p,rj; 5
I12N. Arjkov brj, S) 2coKpare?, ort aAteTjrtKTj?.

212. 2/ce'v/ât brj, crov epop.evov, et epoto' pe* " 'E7ret8T/
Toivvv, co 2coKpares, tovtwv tS>v T\vS>v ev 'Op.rjp(a evpicrKeLS e

a TTpoo-r]KL kKao-Tri bâKpiveLV, X6l p.0L efcevpe Kat rd tov
pAvtebis re Kai p.avTLKrjs, 7rotd ecrriz> a irpocrrJKeL avrco otcp
t elvaL bLayLyv(ao-KLV, etre ev etre KaKcos TreTrotr/rai "

o-Keât cos pqbi(os re Kat akr)drj eyco crot ai:oKpLVovp.aL. 5
7roAAaxou piev yap Kal ev 'Obvcrcreiq Aeyet, diov KaX a 6

rcou MeAa)bt7ro8t8coy Aeyet fidvTLs irpbs toxjs p.vr\crTr)pas,
&OK\vp.VOS
8aip,oViot, rt KaKov ro'8e Trdcrêre; wktI p.ev vp.eo>v 539
etAvarat KecpaXai re irpocroyna re ivepfle re yvta,
otpcoyr/ 8e 8e'8r/e, 8e8aKpwrat 8e 7rapetai'
e3Ki/^(TTt F Kvf)ffr(t
: W
et ex Kvi)ffrri fecit irapa cfyoe] T . . .
wl &A<ptra Aev/ca waAuce libri Homerici

5' C4 prius efre TF:
elVep W d
1 fivffabv F (et sic libri Homerici) fSvuffov vvBfiev T
W
: :
et in marg. t yKacej/] tipovoev libri Homerici (fj.fiefA.av7a d2

v. 1. in Homeri A
4fif3(f3av7a libri Homerici
: d 3 er'] eV
libri Homerici irrjfjta T W
f et sic IVjaJ rwv Kara iroAas Krjpa F :
et sic libri Homerici e6 &6 WFt: 6T

e 7 fieXafjnro-
StSwv T W: fxtAafAirootSctiv F jue\ajUToSwf Tf a1 Sai/UoVioi] 2
W
:
StiAoi libri Homerici v/xewv TF Lâ>e a2 7v?a] yovva

W
:
libri Homerici 83 8e'8?/e 8e 8^ (iStSa.Kpvvrai) F 8e'S7;aj T

: :
post irapetaj' in libris Homericis hic versus atfxari. 8' (ppdSarai rotxot
KaAai re fieff6Sfxat
53ga I1AAT&N02
elbtokaiv re Trkzov irp66vpov t 7rAetrj 8e kcu avkr)
5 lep.4vo)v epe/3o'o-8e vtto 6<pov r)cktos 8e
b ovpavov e<fa7rdAooAe, kcikt) 8' e7rt8e'8popei> a)(kvs'
7roAAaxou 8e Kat ey 'IAtdSt, otoi; Kat e7rt retxo/xa^ta* Ae'yet
ydp Kat ivravda

opvis yap o-cpiv 7rfjkde Ttzprô-ip.evai /xe/xaouo-tv,
5 aterds v\jnTTTrjs, e7r' dptorepa Aadv eepyoor,

C <pOLVriVTa bpaKovTa (ptpoov dvvyzcrcri 7re'Aoopoi>,
fojdr, er' avnaipovTa' Kai ovtko kr)6tTo yapp.r)s.
k6\\tz yap avrbv ZyovTa Kara arrjflos 7rapd Setprjv
i8z>oo0eis 07rtcra), 6 8' a7rd et9ei> 7^Ke yapxi(
5 dAyrjcras d8rjVrjo-t, //eVoo 8' kv\ Ka/3/3aA' dp,iAoo*
d avrds 8e KAdyas 7rerero iryoiTjs avip.oio.
rarjra <prjo-oo Kal rd rotarjra r<3 p,di>ret 7rpoo7JKetv Kat ctko-

7rety Kai KpLvs.iv.
IX2N. 'AArjflrj ye crrj Ae'yooi>, oo SwKpares.

v
5 212. Kat cn/ ye, a> Ia)y, akt)6r) ravra Aeyets. t#t 8rj Kat
o-rj ep,ot, d)cr7rep eyoo oot efe'Ae<fa Kat e<f 'Oducrcretas Kat e
'IAtddos 07rota rorj /xdz/recos eVrt Kat O7roia rorj tarporj Kat
e o7rota tov dAteoos, otjtoo Kat cn) epot eKAeoz>, e7rei8r/ Kat
ep7retpdrepos et ep,orj rwy 'O/xrjpou, o7rota rorj pa\j/(pbov eortrJ,

v
oo Iooy, Kat rrjs Ti\vr)s ttjs paôpStKTjs, a roo pai/VcoSco Trpoa-
7/Ket Kat o-K07retcrc9at Kat btaKpiveiv itapa. totjs aAAorjs
5 avdpatirovs.
II2N. 'Eyco peV <prjp,i, oo SooKpares, a7rayra.
v
2X2. Od crrj ye cprjs, co Iooi>, aixavTO.' rj otjVoos e7riArjcrpcoiv
et; Katrot otjk dy 7rpe'7rot ye Tukr)crp.ova etrat pa^rcdbbv

avbpa.
54 IX2N. Tt 8e 8rj e7riAai>0di>op,at;
b2 prius koJ T W f om. F c4 ojriVw WF diriixffw T 05 eVi

W
: :
Ka(i&a\' F (sed /t in /3 mutavit f) eV/coyu^SoA' fyicafi&aW' T (sed A

W
: :
alterum puncto del.) T d r 7reVeTo libri Homerici weVaTo

W
:
(sed suprascr. eVo) rreV^To F : : eVeTO Tf d4 ê TF : om.

e 7 </>p's Baiter </>?;$ T
: F W airavra T W f : ov Trdvra F

IX2N 540 a
2,11. Ov p.tp.vr]craL otl e<pr/cr#a ri]V pa\t/cpotK?/y Tt)(vr]v
erepav etVat tt}s tjvloxlktjs; IX2N. Mep.vqp.aL. 2X2. Ovk-

ovv Ka\ erepav ovcrav erepa yvaxrecrOaL copoAoyets; IX2N.
Nat. 2X2. Ovk apa TtavTa ye yrcocrerat r/ pa\^cp8tKr/ Kard 5
tov crbv koyov ovbe 6 patyipbos. IX2N. Ylkrjv ye tcrcos ra
TOLavra, S) 2coKpares.
212. Td TOLavra 8e Aeyets Trkr)v tcl rcov aAAcoy Te\v<av b
cryebov tl' akka irola br] yycocrerat, e7ret8r/ ov\ airavTa;
A
IX2N. A TrpiiTd, otp,at eyoaye, avbpl et7reu> Kat 07roia
yvvaLKL, Kal birota bovkio xat o7rota eAei>0e'pco, Kat o7rota
ap\op.ev<o Kal 07rota apyovTL. 5
2X2. 'Apa 07rota apyovTL, Aeyets, ez> OakaTTT] yeLp.a<jop.ivov

irkoiov 7rpe'7ret et7reiV, 6 pa\j/<pbbs yrcocrerai /caAAtoy r/ 6
KvfitpviJTrjs; IX2N. Ovk, akka 6 Kvf3epvr]Tr]s tovto ye.

2X2. 'AAA' 07rota apyovTL Kctp.vovTos 7roe'7ret et7reiV, 6 C
pa\\r<pbbs yvcocreraL KakkLov rj 6 larpos; IX2N. Ov8e
tovto. 2X2. 'AAA' oXa bovkco 7rpe'7ret,
Aeyets; IX2N.
Nat. 2X2. OToi> (3ovKok<o Aeyets bovkco a 7rpe'7ret et7rety
dyptatôucrcoy fiocov Trapap.v6ovp.4vu>, 6 pa\jr<pbbs y^cocrerat 5
dAA' ovy 6 ffovKokos; IX2N. Ov 8f/ra. 2X2. 'AAA' ota

ytwatKi TTp7T0VT<x tcTTLV eliTtLV raAacrtoupycp 7rept epiW
ipyacrias; IX2N. Ov. 2X2. 'AAA' ota avbpl 7rpe'7ret elireiv d
yycocrerat crTpaTrjycp crrparicorais irapaLVOvvTL; IX2N. Nat,
ra TOLavra yvcoaeraL 6 pa\pcpbos.
2X2. Tt 8e'; f/ pa\j/<pbLKr) Teyvt] crrparr/yiKr/ ecrrtj;
IX2N. Yvoir\v yovv av eycoye ola crTpariiybv 7rpe'7ret et7rety. 5 s

v v
2X2. Icrcos yap et Kat crrpaTriyLKOS, co Icor. Kat yap et
kTvyyavis t7T7TtKoy coy dpa Kat KLdapLcrTLKos, eyvcos &i> t7r7rot;s
ev Kat KaKcos LTnratfipAvovs' dAA' et cr' eyco i]pop.r]v' " Ylorepq e

bi] riyvr], <a*\<t)v, yiyi^cocrKets tovs ev t7r7ra(/)peVous t7T7rous;
b 8 a\\a W &\Ko F dAAa T

6 : : al 6 et in marg. f c 1 Kafivovros
F Kaixvovri T
: W d2 f vai scr. recc. : ^TWF d5 av
Sydenham &p' W T om. F ip' 70176 F fyo T W 6.6 &
om. T W
: : :
T W (sed
:
F : e 1 ypo/xriv ij in ras. T) : ipoiyn\v F

>
54oe nAATX2N02
fj
iTnrevs et r/ rf Ki0apio-rr/<? ; " tC av pot a7reKpu>co; 1X2N.
e
Ht iinrevs, eyooy dv. 2X2. Ovkovv el Kal tovs ev KiOapi-
5 ovras- bieytyvoocrKes, co/xoAo'yets av, 17 Kttâpto-rr/s et, ravrr/
Stayiyycoo-Keii', aAA' ov^ r) i7r7rerjs. IX2N. Nat. 212.

'E7rei8r/ 8e ra orpartcortKa ytyvcoo-Kets, iroTepov fj
o-TpaTr\-
yiKos et ytyycoo-Kets r)
fi
pa\jr(pbbs aya66s; IX2N. Ovbtv
epotye SoKet biacpepeiv.
541 212. n<2s; ovbev Aeyets biacpepeiv; \xiav Aeyets Te\vr]v
elvai rr/y pa\\r(abLKr\v Ka\ ti]v crTpaTr\yiKr]V r) bvo; IX2N. Mta
epotye 8oKet. 212. "Oorts apa dyadbs pa\}r(abos eoriv, ovtos
koX ayaObs o-TpaTr\ybs Tvyydvei 8>v; IX2N. MaAtara, co 2co-
5 Kpares. 2X2. Ovkovv Kat ootis dyaObs crrpaTriybs Tvyxdvei

o>v, dyaObs Kal payfr&bos ecmv. IX2N. Ovk av p.01 SoKet
tovto. 2X2. 'AAA' eKelvo pJqv boKel crot, oorts ye dyaObs
b pa\jr(obos, Kal crrparr/yos dyaObs elvat; IX2N. Tldvv ye.
212. Ovkow crv tS>v 'EAAr/vcoy aptcrros paxfr&bbs et; IX2N.
IloAv ye, co 2coKpares. -212. *H Kat o-TpaTt]y6s, S>"lo>v, tS>v
Ek\rjva>v aptcrros et; IX2N. ES tcr0i, 2> 2coKpares* Kat
5 ravrd ye ck tS>v 'O\xf)pov \xa6u>v.
2X2. Tt brj iroT ovv irpbs tS>v 6eS>v, co "ltov, dficpoTepa

aptoros (bv tS>v 'EAAt/i>coi>, Kat crTpaTrjybs koX pa\jr(ob6s,
pai//-<oSeis p&v Trepuoov rots "EAAr/o-t, o-rparr/yets ' ov; r/
C pa\l/(j)bov piev boKet crot xpvcrSj orecpaz/co ecrrecpavco/xeVou
7roAArj xpeia elvai rots "EAAr/o"t, crTpaTr\yov be ovbe\xia;

IX2N.
C
H /xey yap r)\xeTepa, S> 2coKpares, 7ro'Ats apxerat
W7T0 v/jtcoy Kat crrparr/yetrai Kat or38ez> Setrat arparriyov, r) oe
5 vp.Tepa Kal r) AaKebaip.oviu>v ovk av p.e eAotro crTpaTrxyov'

avTol yap olecrde tKavot etyat.
2X2. 'X2 /3e'Artore "Icoy, 'A7roAAo'8copoy ov ytyvcoo-Kets rw
Ku CiKrjvov;
e 3 airtKpiuu) F aveKpivov T : e 7 Ta T F W : om. W

e 8 dâ^ds secl. Schanz e 9 e/jioiye T e/*o2 F W : a7 ju-Jji/
F: M iy TW iro( <rot elj/at F TW: ye T W : re F

b7 cTTpaTtryoi T W : cTpaTrj^bs &> F
If2 N 541 c
II2N. rToto^ tovtov;

A
2X2. Ov 'AOrjvaioi 7roAAaKts kavTiov oTpaTr\ybv rjpr]VTai 10
eVoi> ovTa' nal <t>avoa0vr] rbv " Avhpiov *cat 'Hpa/cAetSrjy roy d
KAa^bjueViojj, ovs ?/8e i) 7ro'Ats 4vovs ovras, e7j8eia/j.e'jJ0?js
ort dtot Adyov etcrt, Kat ets o-TpaTrjyias Kat ets rds dAAas
dpx? ayet* "IcoTja 8' apa rojj 'EcpeViojj o?3x atp^crerat
orpaTrjybv /cat rt/a?/crei, edjj 8ok?j dtos Ao'you etjjat; rt 8e; 5
v
ovk 'Ac^jjatbt )LteV eaT ol 'EcpeVtot ro apyaiov, Kal r) E<pecros
o?j8ejUids eAdrrcoi> 7rdAecos; dAAa ydp crrj, Zi"\u>v, et /j.e?j aXr}6r) e
Aeyets cos T\vr\ Kat e7rtcrr?7p?7 otbs re et "Op-rjpov kiraiveiv,
dStKeis, dcrris epot VTroo~y6p,evos cos 7roAAd Kat KaAa 7rept
'O/xrjpou l7rt'crracrat Kat cpdcrKcojj e7ri8eieijj, e<fa7raras pe Kat
7roAAo?3 8ets e7ri8eiâi, ds ye o?j8e arra ecrrt rarrra ircpl 5
cojj 8etjjbs et e0e'Aets et7rety, 7rdAat eporj Ai7rapo?jVros, dAAd
drex^co? cocr7rep 6 ITpcoreTjs 7rajjro8a7rds yCyvrj crrpec/jb/j.eiJos
dv(o Kal k6.tu>, ecos reAerjrcojj Stacprjycojj /xe orpaTrjybs dvecpd-
jj?7S, ii/a p.r) e7ri8et<f?7S cos 8etJjbs et Tr)v 7rept 'Op.rjpov crocpCav. 54 2
et pejj orjV rexîKos cojj, o7rep iw87/ eAeyoy, 7rept 'Op.rjpov
vTToo\6p.^vos e7ri8ei<feii> e<fa7raras pe, dStKOS et* et 8e pr/

rexiHKos et, dAAd c9eia \xoipa KaTey6p.evos e 'Op.r\pov /xr/8er
et8cos 7roAAd Ka. KaXa Aeyets 7rept rorj 7rotr/ror3, cocr7rep eycb 5
ei7roi; 7rept crov, OTjSejJ dStKeis. eAorj otjjj 7ro'repa /3o?jAet
j*o/uecrc9ai vtto r)p.<av dStKos djj?7p etyai ?*/ fletos.
IX2N. IToArj 8ta</je'/)ei, co 2coKpares -

7roArj ydp KaAAtOJJ rd b
cêtoi; 7JO/xt(fecrc9at.
212. Torjro Toivvv to koXKiov vTrapxei 001 irap' r)plv, co

v
Icoy, ^101 etijai Kat />tr/ TtyjiiKov 7rept 'O/xr/porj e7rai7Jerr/7J.
e 5 5f?j scr. recc. 8r o-' T : 5' els F W e6 irtiAo T W

W
: :
woAAa F b r crwKpares T adKpares duos F : b3 uirapx 6 ']

imdpfct Schanz fi/uv T F fificDV : W
PLATO, VOL. III. 34

V
A
;
MENEHENOS
St. II
P-234
2X2KPATH2 MENEEEN02
2X2. 'Ef dyopds r) Tr68ev Mevifaos; a
MEN. 'E dyopas, co 2&>Kpares, xal a7ro rou fiovkev-
Tr\piov.
2X2. Tt naXicrTa crol npos (3ov\evrqpiov; r) 8Âa 877 ort

7ratoeucrecos Kat cpi\ocro<p(as irrl re'Aet ^yfj eu>ai, Kat co? 5
iKav&s rjbr] eya>v iirl rd p.eta> eTTiroeis TpirrtcrdaL, Kat

apxav r)p.&v, S) Oavpuxo-te, e7rtxetpeis t&v Trpeo-ftvTepcov
TrjXiKOVTos &v, Xva pr/ e/cXt7r7j v/xcoy 7/ otKta aet ru/a ?//acoi> b
Zinp.kr]Tr]V irapzyop.vi)
MEN. 'Edv crv ye, 00 2coKpares, eas Kat crvpL(3ov\evr]s

apxew, T7podvp.-qo-op.ai' et 8e /xt/, ov. vvv /xeVrot a<piKop.r)v
TTpbs to (BovkevrripLov irv66p.evos otl r) /3ojjAt/ p,e'AAei aipeio-0at 5
ocrrts epet e7rt rots a7ro0ai>oi;cnir racpas yap otcr#' ort
peAAoucrt 7roieti\
2X2. ndyfc ye* dAAd rtVa etAoyro;

MEN. Ovbtva, dAAa dvej3d\ovTo ets rr)y avpiov. ot/xat
pAvTOL 'Apxlvov r) ACcova atpec^T/crecrâi. 10
2X2. Kat /xt/i, co Mei>eei>e, 7roAAaxj/ Kti>8wevei Kakov c

etrat rd ei> 7roAepco aTrodvi]o~Kt:Lv. kol yap racprjs Kakrjs re
aa ^{TW: /coWf f (sed /col punctis del. f) K a\ secl. H. Richards

a4 <roJ F ov T W a5 irai5e>jcrea>s T W f ovvcatws (ut videtur) F
W
: :
b1 inKiicr) TF : ^KAelirri b7 iroje/ T W : Ttoff]o-etv F

bg cW0oAoj/to WF: avtfiaAAovro T
(sed A alterum puncto del.)
C2
Kal
Ta</>7/s
Stobaeus
KaArjs re /caJ TF : KaArjs ra(prjs re xal W
raiprjs re (caAfjs
:
34*
234C I1AAT12N02
/cat peyakoTrpcTrovs Tvyyavei, /cat av 7reVr/9 rt? cov TkVT7]o-r],
/cat kiraivov av TvyV, /cat Ztiv (pavkos r/, vtt avhpdv o-o<pG>v
5 T Kal OVK LK7] 7TaLV0VVT(0V, akka K TTOkkod \pOVOV koyOVS

irapo-Kvao-p.vo)v , o% ovtcos /caAcos e-naivovo-iv, cocrre koi tcl
235 Trpoo-ovTa Kal tcl p.7] 7rept e/cdcrrot; keyovres, Kakkio~Ta ttoos
rots 6v6p.ao~i TTOLKikkovTes, yo7]Tvovo-LV 7)p.(2v tcls ytyvyas,

Kal tt]v TTokLV ey/cco/xid(/wres' /card irdvTas Tpoirovs kcll tovs
rereAeuTTj/cdras v rco 7roAe'/xco Kal rovs irpoyovovs r)p.G>v
5 aTTavras tovs p.7rpocr6V Kal avTovs ?//xds tovs ert u>VTas

iiraLVOvvTes, &<tt eycoye, ) Mev^V, ycvvams iraw 8iari-
0]xaL iraLVOvp.Vos v-n ovt&v, Kal kclo-tot eêVrT/xa
b d/cpoco/xeros Kal Kt]kovp.Vos, 7]yovp.VOS iv ra> 7rapaxj)7]p,a
p.io)v Kal ycvvaLOTepos Kal Kakkicov ycyovevaL. Kal ola
7/ TCL TTOkkCL det p,T ]XOV <~VOL TLVS TTOVTaL KcCl 0~VV-
aKpo&vraL Trpbs ovs eyco o~p.voTpos v t> Trapaxprjpa
5 yi.yvop.aL' /cat yap e/cetrot TavTa ravra boKovcri p.01 irao-yLV
koI Trpbs e/xe /cat TTpbs tt)v akkrjv irokLV, 6avpacrL(OTpav

avrtjv 7]ylo-6aL etvat rj TrpoTcpov, virb tov kiyovTos avaiTL-
$6p.VOL. Kai p.oL avTT] 7) o-pvoT7]s 7rapap.evL r)pepas Trkeio)
C i] TpLS' ot/rcos evavkos 6 Adyos T /cat 6 cpOoyyos irapa tov
kiyOVTOS vbvTaL LS TCL 0)Ta, &0-T /UOytS TTapT7] 7] 7Ip.irT7]
r)pepq avapLp.V7JcrKop.aL ep.avTOv /cat alo-0avop.aL ov yrjs elpi,
recos be 6lp.aL p.6vov ovk ev pampoov vqo-oLs ot/cetv ovt(os r)pXv
5 01 p7]T0pS be<~Loi lo~LV.
MEN. 'Aet o-v TrpocnraiêLS, co 2co/cpares, tovs pyropas.
vvv p.VTOL oTp.aL eyo) tov alpeOivra ov iravv VTropr)o-LV e

viToyvov yap TravTairao-LV r) atpecris ykyovev, cocrre tcrcos
dz>ay/cacr#?7crerai 6 kiyo)V cocr7rep avrocr)(e8td(fety.
d 2H. U60V, oiyadi; elo-lv ko.otols tovto)v Adyot 7rape-
a3 rpSirovs TW: robs rplmovs F K<d rovs TWf: om. F

a6 iiraivovvres secl. Cobet &er TF : ais W a7 /cal T W :
* Kal y F ^f ecrTTj/ca F ecTTrj/ca T W b I d/cpoci/tci/os] ala>povfj.evos

W
:
Valckenaer b2 nelfev T : /cai (jififav F b5 yuot TF :
om. W b8 irAeta ^ T WF : TrKeiw Priscianus : tr\e7ov Hirschig :
ir\e7v Cobet
MENESEN02 235 d
crKnvacrp.(ivoL, Kal dp.a ovbe avroo-)(bLaeiv rd ye Toiavra

'
\akTTOV. et p.\v yap Se'ot AdrivaCovs iv Y\eko-rovvr]o-CoLS ev
Aeyetv rj YlckoTTOvvr]crCovs iv 'AdrjvaCoLS, ayaOov av prjropos
8e'ot tov TTfCaovTos Kal vboKtp.ijo~ovTos' OTav 8e tls iv T0VT0LS 5
ayatvCCrjTaL ovoTrep kol i-raLVCL, oibev p.iya boKeiv ev Ae'yeu>.
MEN. Ovk otet, 2> 2&)Kpares;
2X2. Ov p.eVrot p.a ACa.
MEN. 9 H otet oto's r' av etvat avTos (ltt^lv, et Se'ot ml e
eAotro' o-e r) /3ot/A?/;
2X2. Kat epot peV ye, a> Mez>e'<fez>e, ovbev 6avp.acrTov ota>
r etifat et7reti>, ai rjjy^dyet StSdo-KaAos ovaa ov irdvv cpavkr]
irepl prjropLKrjs, dAA' rjiTtp Kal dkkovs mokkovs Kat dyaOovs 5

7re7rot??Ke pr/Topas, eW 8e Kat bLacptpovTa t&v 'Kkkijvcov,
IleptKAe'a rdi> BavdCTnrov.
MEN. Tts avrrj; r) bfjkov otl 'AcnracrCav Aeyets;

2X2. Ae'ya> ydp, Kai KoWoy ye tov MrjTpoftCov ovtol ydp
p.0L bvo dcrlv 8t8do-KaAoi, d pei> p.ovo~LKrjs, r) b\ pr\TopLKr)s. 236
ovTo) p.v ovv Tpcp6p.evov dvbpa ovbev 6avp.acTTov bcLvbv tTvaL
Ae'yety dAAd Kat oarts kp.ov KaKLOv knaLbcvOr], p,ovcrLKr]V p.\v
vtto Adp.irpov iraLbevdeCs, pr\TopLKi]v 8e i>7r' 'AvTLCp&vTos tov
'
'Vap.vovcrCov, 6p.cos kclv ovtos olos T et?i 'A6r\vaCovs ye iv 5

'AdrjvaCoLS kiraLvQ>v cvboKLp.uv.
MEN. Kat tC av tyoLs et7ret;>, et 8e'ot cre Ae'yeti>;
2X2. Avrds pikv 7rap' kp.avTov lctoos ovbzv, 'Ao-irao-Cas 8e
Kat x@^ s r)Kpoa>p.r)v 7repatiWo-?/s tTTLTacpLov koyov 7rept ovt&v b

tovtcov. rJKOvcre yap direp crv Ae'yets, ort p.ekkoLV 'AOrjvaLOL
alpelcrdaL tov epovvra' e7retra rd p.tv eK tov TTapayjpr}p.d p.0L
8trjet, ota 8e'ot Ae'yety, rd 8e TTpoTepov eo-KejupeVr?, ore /xot
8oKet o-vvtC0l tov tTTLTacpLOv Koyov bv YlepLKkrjs et7rei>, 5

7reptAetppar' drra e (kcCvov crvyKokX&cra.
ds Seot tou TWf: SeWo F ei ofa TWf : ofe &/ F

e 3 ouSeu davnaaTov Si fi(v4^(V( 6avfj.ao-rbv F & 1 fi T : 6 W : 0/ F
a4 iratS(v0eis secl. Cobet 8l 5 ye F t- TW b5 5o/ce? T
WF
: :
tSoKft b6 irepiKeifxfxaT &TTa T f (sed ^p. Taxha in marg. T) :
TrepiAeiyUjuoTo toOto WF (TifyjcoA.AcDffa T W f : Kofiwffa F

236 b IIAATX2N02
MEN. *H kclI fxvi)fxovvcraLS av a eAeyev r)
'
'Xa-naaia;
2X2. Et fxr) abiK(o ye* fxdv6avov ye' tol irap avrrjs, Kal
C okiyov irkrfyds Zkafiov 6V irkavdav6fxr)V.

MEN. Ti ovv ov 8tr/A0es;
2X2. 'AAA' oVcos \xr\ fxoL \akTTavL r) SibacrKakos, av
(êvtyKa) avrrjs tov koyov.
5 MEN. Mrjbafx&s, oo 2&>Kpares, dAA' et7re', Kal itavv fxoi
X a pi-fj> & 'Acnracrias /3ot/Aet Aeyety etre otovovv akka

fXOVOV LTT.
2X2. 'AAA' tcroos fxov KarayeAdcrr/, av ctol 8o'co 7rpecr/3?jrr/s
a>z> ert 7raie\
io MEN. Ovbafx&s, S 2coKpares, aAA' ei7re Travrl TpoTria.
2X2. 'AAAa p.VTOL croC ye 8et yapi(Jcr6aL, u>ctt kclv okiyov,
d et p, KckcvoLS dirobvvTa opyrfcracrOaL, yapLcraifxrfv dv, e7ret8r/
ye judVco crp,v. dAA' ciKoue. eAeye ydp, cbs eycp/xat, dptjafxivr)
k4yLV dii avT&v t5>v t6vu>t(x>v ovrcocri.
"Epycp /xev r)plv ot8e ZyovcrLV tcl irpocrr)KOVTa crcpicrLV avrols,
5 <Sy ruxdvres TropevovraL rrjv Lfxapp.vr)v iropeiav, 7rpo7rep-
cf)6VTS KOLVr) fXV VTTO Trjs TTOk0)S, Ibiq. 8e VTTO T(2v oIk101V'
koyto 8e br) TOV kLTTOfXVOV KOCTflOV 6 T VOfXOS TTpOCrTaTTL

e a7ro8owat rots dvbpdcrLV Kal \pr). fpyoov yap v Trpayd^VToov
Adycp KakS>s prjdivTL fxvr)fxr) Kal Kocrp.os rots 7rpdfacn yiyvTaL
irapa tG>v aKovcrdvToov 8et br) tolovtov tlvos koyov octtls
TOVS fXV TTkVTr)KOTaS LKavG>S TTaLVCTTaL, tols 8e C&crLV
5 VfXV&S TTapaLVCTTaL, KyOVOLS fXV Kal dbekcpols fXLfXlcrdaL
Tr)v T&vbe dpcrrjv irapaKkv6fXvos, 7rare'pas 8e Kat /jtr/repas
Kal ef tlvS t5>v dvoodcv ert Trpoyovoov k^CirovTai, tovtovs 8e
b7 /ivTi/jLovtiarais TF : /xvi)/j,ovevcras W Ci 8t F ('6re

Schleiermacher) '6ti TW C3 xaXeiraveî T f x a^ eirav V ^ '
W
: :
XaAeiraivet F e 8 KarayeXaaei T KarayeXdo"r) KarayeXao-eis F

W
: :
& T : ôr F e 11 Sore] ^ >y ci. Stallbaum d 1 kcAcvois

scr. recc. Keheveis T W
/ccAeurjs F x aP l <Ta ^lx^ v av sec '- Schanz
W
:
WF
:
d6 8e T 5e 6koo-tos Longinus
: olKeiwv T et in ras. F :
npocrr)K6vTO)v Longinus
MENEEENOS 237a
irapap.vdovp.evos. tls ovv av rjpuv tolovtos \6yos (paviir); t] 237

ir66ev av dpda>s dpaiju,e0a avbpas ayadovs iiraLVovvTes, ot
((ovts re tovs kavT&v rivcppaivov 81' apeTrjv, nal tt]v reAewr/z;
avTL rrjs tS>v (a>VTa>v cra>TT]pLas r)kkaavTo; 8oKet p.0L \pijvai

Kard (pvcriv, &cmtp ayadol kyivovTO, ovto> koX kiraLveiv av- 5
tovs. ayadol 8e kyivovro bia to (pvvai e aya6S>v. tt)v
evyiveLav ovv irp&Tov avrS>v kyKa>p.LaCo>p.ev, bevrepov 8e rpoq>r]v

re Kal TratbeCav eVt be tovtols tt]v tS>v epyoov Trpa^LV kinbeL- b
8'
o>p.ev, ci>s KaX.r)v kol aCav tovtoov aiTe(pr]vavT0. rrjs
evyeveCas irp&Tov virrjpe Tolcrbe r) tS>v irpoy6vu>v yiveaLs

ovk (zTTr]\vs ovcra, ovbe tovs kKyovovs tovtovs aTToq>r]vap.ivr]
pLtTOLKOvvTas kv r?/ x^P a dAAo<9ei> crq>S>v t)k6vto)V, dAA' 5

avToyOovas kol tS> ovtl kv 7rarpt8t olKovvras Kal 5>VTas,
koX Tpeq>op.ivovs oi>x virb p.r]TpvLas o>s oi dAAot, dAA' VTTO
p.r]Tpbs rfjs x^P a? *v V Qkovv, Kal vvv KelcrdaL reAewr/cra^ras C
kv OLKtLOLS TOTTOLS TTJS TKOVCTT]S KO.I 6peâCTT]S KaX VTTob(a-
p.ivqs. bLKaLOTarov br) Kocrp.i]craL irp&Tov tt)v p.r]Tipa avrqv

ovroo yap crvp.]3aCveL ap.a koX t) T&vbe evyiveia Kocrp:ovp.evr].
v
Ecrri 8e d<fta r)
X^P a KaL ^ 710 navTcov av6po>TTU>v kiraL- 5
vclcrOaL, ov p.6vov wp' r)p.S>v, TroKkaxfi p*v Kal aAAr/, irpS>TOV

be Kat p.4yLCTTov otl rvyx^veL ovcra 6eoq>i\r]s. p.apTvpel be
r)p.S>v tS> Ao'ya> 57 tu>v ap.q>icrf3r]TqcravT0)V irepl avTrjs 6eS>v
epLS re Kat /cptVts* rjv br) 6eol kTTT]vecrav, ttS>s o&x vtt' d
av6pa>7roov ye crvp.TTavTa>v Stxata kiraLVtLcrdaL; bevTfpos 8e
tTTaLVos bLKaCa>s av avrrjs etr/, ort kv Zkclvo) r<S xpovop, ev <o r)
iracra yi/ dye8t8ou Kat <-(pve âia 7rai>ro8a7rd, dripCa re Kat /3ora,
kv tovto} t) 7/juere'pa 6r]pLa>v p.\v aypiojv ayovos Kal Kadapa 5
k(pavr], eêAe'âro 8e tu>v <jua)y Kat yivvr]crev avdpooTrov, o

o-vvicrtL re U7repe'xet t5)V aXXoov Kal bU-qv kol deovs p.6vov
a 1 t) TWf : om. F a6 Se T W : 8e ye F a 7 r^v

ante rpo<p-i)v add. H. Richards b4 iicySvovs TWf: iyy6-
vovs F b7 na\ TWf: om. F oi F Dionysius : om. TW
(fort. oAAot) C8 abrrjs F Dionysius avriivTW d 1 S^TWF:
W W
:
Se Dionysius d4 iraaa T : aira<ra F 4<pve F e<pv T

:
d6 oTW: t>s F
F
237 e IIAATJINOS
e vo/xiêL. fxkya 8e reKfxrfpLov tovtu t<S Aoyw, otl r/8e TKV
r) yrj tovs T&vbi re kclI rjfxerepovs irpoyovovs. irdv yap ro
tzkov rpocprjv ex*i e7riTr/8eiay a> av re/cr?, <o Kal yvvr) 8r/Ar/
TKovo~a re dArj^&is Kat /xry, dAA' r57ro/3aAAo/u,eVrj, tav fxr) exr/
5 irrfyas Tpocprjs tw yevvoofxtvut. o 8?; Kat r/ rffxtTtpa yrj Te Kat
fxrfTrfp iKavbv TKfxrfpLov irapêrai ws dvdpunrovs yevvrfcra-

jueVrj* judz/rj ydp eV tw tot Kal 7rp<oYrj rpocprjv dvdpojireCav
238 rjveyKcv rbv t&v Trvp&v Kal KpiOGtv Kapirov, <S /cdAAiaTa koX
6.pio~Ta TpicpiTai to dvOpojTreLov yivos, ws t<3 ovtl tovto to
<oov avrr) yevvqo-ap.ivt]. fxdXkov 8e virkp yrjs r) yvvaLKOs
TTpoo-rfKtL byjEo-0aL TOLavra TeKfxrjpLa' ov yap yr) yvvaxKa
5 fxefxCfxrfTaL Kur/<rei Kat yeiwrjcrei, dAAd yvvr) yr)v. tovtov 8e
to?3 Kap7ro{5 ovk icpOovrfcrev, dAA' eVetp.ei> Kal rols ol/Wols.
fxtTa 8e tovto eAatou yeVecrti;, ttovoov dpojyrfv, dvrfKev tols
b CKyovois' Opetyafxivr) 8e Kat av^r/cracra 7rpos tj/St/ij dp\ovTas

Kat 8i8acrKaAous avr&v 8eovs iirriydyeTO' cov tcl fxkv ovofxaTa
TTpTTL Iv Ttp T0ttp8e k"(XV LCTfXtV ydp 0% TOV j3CoV i)fxS)V
KaTecrKevacrav irpos Te rrjv Ka6* rjfxepav bCaLTav, Te\vas irpoi-
5 tous 7rat8e?jcrdp,ei'0i, Kat 7rpos rr)v inrep rrjs x^P as (pvXaicrfv
orrkoov KTrjo-Cv re Kal yjprfcrLV bLbadfxevoL.
TtvvrfOivTts 8e Kat 7rat8euc9eWes ovtco? ot Ttoi>8e irpoyovoL

&kovv TTokLTtCav KaTacrKevacrdfxevoL, rjs opO&s \L 8td f3pa-
C XeW kTTLfxvrfo-OrfvaL. 7roAtTeta ydp Tpocpr) dvOpoiirojv ecrrtV,
KaAr) fxkv dya6&v, r) 8e ivavria KaK&v. cos ovv eV KaArj

7roAtTeta iTpdcprycrav ol TTpocrOev rjfx&v, avayKalov SrjAciicrat,
81' rjv br) KaKtivoL dyaOol Kal oi vvv daLV, &v ot8e Tuyxdroucriz;
5 ovTts ol TeTeAeuTr/KoVes. r) yap avTr) TroAtTeta Kat tot r)v
Kal vvv, dptcTTOKpaTta, eV rj vvv tc 7roAtTeud/xec9a Kat tov det
ei StjF: tITW 64 (iirof3a\ofievri Ast e5 yevvai/xevy T W

yevofj.4v<fi Stephanus e 7 T<{Te T W
r6re Kaipw F a 3 out^ F
W W tovto T W
:
auTTj T a4 reKfi-fipia TF : t TfKfiTtpta a7 .
TavTa F b3 yap secl. Wilamowitz

foftev C 2 /caA); /ca/caS
W
. . .
T F
KaA.r) êv ayaQwv, /*}) Ka\)i Se KaKwv Stobaeus
: Ka\ rj fiev ayadij :
ayaOwv, fj.ii KaXii Se ko.kwv Dionysius C 6 apiaroKpwria secl. ci.

H. Richards
MENEHENOS 238C
\povov e ZkcCvov <os ra 7roAAd. KaAet 8e 6 pkv avrr)v

brjp.0KparCav, 6 be aXko, av x at PV' * <TTl ^ T V Â^êta per' d
a>
(vboCas Trkrjdovs apicTOKpaTia. (3ao~ikr}s p.\v yap det ijp.lv
etcrtv ovtol 5e rore pikv K ycvovs, rore 8e atpero^ iyKpares

be rr/s 7rdAecos ra 7roAAa ro TrXfjdos, tcls be dpxas dtScocrt
/cat Kpdros rots det 8dacnr dptorots eu>at, Kat orjre dcrdivaCq 5
orjre irevCq ovt dyvcocrCq TTarepcov a7reA?;Aarat orjSets orjde
rots IvovtCols rertftrjrat, coo-7rep ez> dAAats 7ro'Aecri7j, dAAd

ets dpos, 6 ddas crocpbs rj ayadbs etvat /cparet Kat dpxet.
atrta 8e r/pti/ ri]s 7roAtreias rarjVr/s r) e<f tcrorj yeVecrts. at pei> e
ydp dAAat 7ro'Aets eK 7ratToSa7rcoy Karecncerjacr/jteVai dvdpcoircov
etcrt Kat di>copdAcor, cocrre avTcov dvcop.aX.oL Kat at 7roAtretat,
rvpavvCbts re Kat dAtyapxtar oikouctiv orjz/ eVtot /xey 8odAorjs,
01 8e 8ecr7ro'ras dAArjAorjs vop.C(ovTes' r/pets 8e Kat 01 77/Ae'repoi, 5
pias pr/rpds 7rdj>res ddeAc/Jot cpvvres, ovk aiovp.zv 80CA01 239

orjSe 8ecr7ro'rai dAAr/Acoi> eti>ai, dAA' r) lcroyovCa r)p.ds r) Kard
cpvcriv l<rovop.Cav avayKaî rrreu> Kard vop.ov, Kal pr/8ei>i
dXXco rj7retKety dAAr/Aots r/ dperr/s Sdcfr/ Kat cppovrjcrccos.
"O0V br) iv 7rdcrr/ eAerj(9epia reflpap/jteVoi ot rcorde' ye 5
7rare'pes Kat 01 r/p.e'repoi Kat arjrot orjrot, Kat KaAcos cpvvTes,
7roAAd dr/ Kat KaAd epya airtcprivavTO ets 7rdyras dvOpcoirovs
Kal IbCq Kat br]p.ocrCq, olop.cvoL detu rj7rep rr/"s eAeufleptas Kat b
"EAAr/crty rj7rep 'EAAr/Vco7J p.d\(cr6ai Kal /3apj3dpots rj7rep
a7rdyrcoy rwv 'EAAr/ycoi;. Er3po'A7rou pei> ow ,

Kat Ap.a(pv(x>v
iiTLcrTpaTevcravTcov (ttl rr)v xP av Ka ' r(dy ^ rt Trporepcov cos
r)p.vvavTo, Kat cos i)p.vvav 'Apyetots 7rpds Ka8petorjs Kat 5
HpaKAetdats 7rpds 'Apyetous, o re \povos /3pa)(rjs dta>s

dir/yr/cracrât, 7rotr/rat re avrStv r)br) KaAcos rr/i> apTi]V iv
p.ovcrLKfj vp.vrjcravT<is ets 7rd^ras pepr/yrjKacrty edy ow r/pets
d 1 yl 8 Stallbaum d5 tcpdros T W rb Kpdros F

W W
:
6 1 ^/uIV T : 77/ure crTt F ytuecis TF : yfvrtats e 4 ej/jot]

etoj <oj') Bake as oiiSe TW ouS' aS F : jVoôy/o W?tf:
laoywvia T F as ye F: om. T a6 W 01 F: oro. TW
b 5 apytiois W F ap-yejoj T
: b 6 fipaxvs T W : fipaxvs Sfre F
b7 fjSrj xaKws T W f :
^ SiKaiws F (jjStj iitavws S)
'
239C nAAT&NOS
C -tl\l pS>p.ev tcl avra Adyco \/>iAco Koo~p,LV, rd\ av bevrepoL
paLvoip.eOa. ravra p,ev ovv bia ravra SoKet pot edv, eireLbr)
Kal ex et Tr) v dîav 5>v be ovre iroLriTiqs 7rco boav aiav eir
aioLS kafioov eyeL ert re ecrrty ey dpvr/crrta, tovtcov irepL pot
5 8oKet xprjvai. TTLp.vr)o~6r)vaL eiraLvovvTa re Kat irpop.voip.evov

dAAots es coSds re Kat r)y dkkrjv iroir\crLV avTa delvaL
irpeir6vTo>s tS>v trpa^dvTOiv. o~tlv 8e rorjrcor 8>v keyco
d irpS>Ta' Tlepcras r)yovp.evovs rfjs 'Acrtas /cat bovkovp-evovs rr)v

Evpco7rr/v eo~yov ol rr/crSe rrjs \copas eKyovoL, yovrjs be r)p.e-
repot, coV Kat biâLov Kal XP'7 irpS>Tov p.ep.vr)p.evovs eTratyecrat
avT&v tt\v apeTr\v. bel br) avTr)v Ibelv, et ue'AAet rts KaAcos
5 eiraLveiv, ev Keivo> tS> yjyovui yevop.evov Adyco, ore 7rdcra uez>
77 'Acrta e8ovAeue rptrco r/8r/ /3acrtAet, coi> 6 pev 7Tpcoros Kvpos

ekevdepcocras Ilepcras roi)s avrou 7roAiras rco avrou cfjpovr/part
e a/ia Kat rous 8ecr7rdras Mr/5ous eSouAcocraro Kat rr/s aAAr/s
'Acrtas uex.pi Atyv7rrou rjpev, 6 8e vbs AlyviXTOV re Kai
At/3y??s ocroy otdv r' r)v TTLJ3aiveLv, rptros 8e Aapetos 7rer)
uez> ue'xpt 2ku#cov rr)y dpyr)v cbptcraro, vaucrt 8e r7/s re
240 c9aAarrr/s eKpa.TL kol tS>v vr)o~o>v, cocrre u?/8e dcftoCy dvTiirakov
avrco p,r)beva etvar at 8e yycouat 8e8ouAcoueVat cnrdvTcov

avdpcoiroov r)crav odrco 7roAAd Kat p,eyciAa Kat p.d\Lp,a yevrj
Kara8e8ouAcoueVr/ r/y 77 Ilepcrcoz; dpyr). atrtacrduez/os Se
5 Aapeto? r/p.ds re Kat 'Eperptd?, SdpSecrty 7rL(3ov\evo~aL
Trpo(pao~L(pp.Vos, Trep.^ras p.vpidbas p.ev irevTr-KOVTa ev re

7rAotots Kat vavo~iv, vavs 8e rptaKOcrtas, Aartv 8e apyovTa,
elirev r/Kety dyovra 'Eperptds Kat Adrjvaiovs, el /3orJAotro rr)y
b eaurov K(pakr)v eyeLV 6 be irkevo-as els 'EpeTpLav eir dvbpas

0% tS>v tot 'EAAr/ycoy ev rots ev8oKipcorarot i)o~av tcl Trpos
tov Trokep-ov Ka\ ovk okiyoL, tovtovs exetpcocraro p.ev ev
C 2 fxoi lav WF iav /jloi T (sed add. signis transpositionis")

W
:
C 4 afivr)o~Tia F /jLvrjo-reia TW
d 3 irpwrov T /cal koSotov F
W
:
W
:
d 5 A.^79) T eV A^y F
: 6 2 wbs T f (sed outoO in marg. t)
W W
:
om. F 63 eirifiaiveiv T F tmfSrjvai a 5 re T

: 8e F :
a 6 irpo<pao~i6iJ.tvos secl. Cobet b 2 evSoKint&Taroi Hirschig ey5o- :
Klfi.03T6.TOLS T W /UaAKTTO tvSoKlflCOTaTOLS

: F
MENESENOS 240 b
Tptrrlv r/pe'pats, birjptvvijo-aTO 8e avrG>v iracrav rfjv \G>pav,

Xva pr/Seis diroq^vyoL, TOLOVTti> TpoTro>' e7rt tcl dpta eA0oVres 5
rfjs 'EperptKr/s ol o-rpaTicSrai avroC, eK t?aAdrrr/s et? OakaTrav
biacrTavTes, crwdâvTis tcls \elpas btrjkOov diracrav rf)v
y&pav, tv xoiv tu /3ao-tAei et7reiy otl ovbels crqbas airoTrc- c

q>evyo>s (Irj. rrj 8' avrf) biavoiq KarrjydyovTO e 'Eperptas-
'
ets Mapa6G>va, cos froLfxov o-q>LOLV ov Kal AdrjvaCovs iv Trj
avTjj TavTri dvdyKrj euavras 'EperpieJJcrtv dye.LV. tovto>v

8e tG>v fxev TrpaydevTojv, tG>v 8' kTrL\eLpovfxevo>v ovt 5
'EpeTpieuo-ii; il3or]6r]crv 'Ekkrjvoiv oibels ovtz 'A6r]vaioLs
irkrjv AaKbaip.ovio)v oSrot 8e rfj voTepaCq rr/s p-dxqs dcpC-
kovto 01 8' dAAoi 7rdi>res iKTreirkrjyfxevoL, ayairavTes Tr)v
iv rco TrapovTi croiT-npiav, fjo-vxCav r/yoi\ iv tovto> br) dv d

rts yevdfxevos yvoCr/ oXol dpa irvyyavov ovres ttjv dperrjv oi
Mapa6G>VL be^dfxevoL rf]V tG>v f3ap(3dpa)v bvvap.LV kol Kokaod-

p.evoL tt]V virepr]cpavCav oAr/s Trjs 'Acrias Kat 7rpcorot crrr/o-arres
rpoTOta tG>v j3ap(3dpo>v, fjyefxoves Kal 8t8do"KaAot rots dAAots 5
yevdfxevoL otl ovk dfxaxos etr/ f) YlepoG>v bvvafxLS, akkd irav
Trkrjdos kol iras Trkovros dperf/ vttLKL. eyco fxev ovv iêCvovs
tovs dvbpas cprffxl ov fxovov t5>v crcopdrcor tG>v ?]fxeTepo>v e
Trarepas elvat, akkd Kal rfjs ikevdepCas rfjs re r/pere'pas Kal
o-vfxirdvTOJV tG>v iv rr/8e Tr) r]ireCpo>' ets eKeiVo ydp to epyov
aTro(3k4\j/avTS Kal rds wrepas p.dâs iTokfxrfcrav biaKwbv-
veveLv oi"Ekkr]ves virep rr/s o-corr/ptas, pat^r/rat tG>v Mapa6G>VL 5
yevdfxevoL. rd fxev ovv dptcrreta rco Adyco iêCvoLS dvade-
t4ov, Ta 8e Seurepeta rot? 7rept 2aAaptra Kal eV' 'Aprepto-tco 241
yavLtaxr/cracrt Kat viKi]cracrL. kol ydp tovtoov tG>v dvbpG>v
7roAAa fxkv dv tls ^\ol biekdelv, Kal ola iirLovra vrrifxeLvav
Kard re yfjv Kal /card c^dAarray, *at cos r)fxvvavTO ravra' 6
8e' p.ot 8oKet /cat ckcCvojv KaAAtcrroy etyat, tovtov fxvr]o-6r]- 5
crofxai, otl rd er/s tpyov toXs Mapa6G>VL bLetrpdâvTO. ot fxkv
d4 SAtjs rrjs acrias F om. : T W a 2 tca\ viK^ffaai secl. Cobet

Ka\ yap T W : Kai yap ouSi F a4 /cora 8d\arrav T F: 6d\aTrai> W
241 a nAATONOS
yap Mapadu>vi toctovtov p.6vov i-nibcLâv tols "EAAr/crtr, otl
b /card yrjv olov re ap.vvacr6aL tovs j3ap(3dpovs dAtyotS' ttoWovs,
vavcrl 8e ert rpj abrp\ov /cat boav ilôv Ylipcrai aiiaypi etrai
/card OakaTrav koX TrXrjdeL Kal irkovTOi /cai Ti\vr) /cat pcour/*
tovto br) a&ov tTraLvelv tG>v avbpa>v tu>v totc vavp.a)(r]cravTo>v,
5 ort tov i\6p.evov <poj3ov bLikvcrav tG>v 'EAAr/z/cov Kat iiravo-av
<f>o(3ovp.ivovs Trkrjdos Vu>v re xat avbpa>v. vtt' ap.<poTi pcov
br) crvpt.(3aLVL, tG>v re Mapa6G>vL p.axrap.ivo>v Kal tG>v iv

C 2aAawii>t vavp.a\r)o-avTu>v, TraLbevdrjvaL tovs dkkovs "EA-
Xrjvas, vtto piev tG>v xard yfjv, virb 5e tG>v Kard dakaTTav
p.a66vTas Kal idLcrdivras fxr) ctjo)8etcr0at tovs (3ap(3dpovs.
TpCrov 8e kiyoo to iv nAaratats ipyov /cat dpL&p.G> Kal dperr)
5 yevecrdaL rr/s 'EkkqvLKrjs o-oirqpCas, kolvov r/8r/ tovto AaKe-

baLp.0VLa>v re /cat 'AdrjvaCoiV. to p.\v ovv p.iyLcrTov kcCl
XaAe7rcoraroi' ovtol Trdvres r)p.vvavro, /cal 8td TavTrpj tt)v

aperrjy vvv re vc\> r)p.G>v ey/cco/Atacfovrat /cat ets t6v e7retra
d XP 0V0V V7T0 v vo-repov /xerd be tovto Tiokkal p.ev Trokeis
tG>v 'Ekkrjvoiv ert r\crav werd tov (3ap(3dpov, avros be

r/yyeAAero /3acrtAet/s Stavoetcrtâi u>s e7rtxeipr?crcoi; 7rdAtz> e7rt
tovs "Ekkr/vas. bUaLov br) /cat tovto>v r)p.ds i7TLp.vr)o-dr]vai,
5 o% toIs t5>v TTporipoiv epyots rikos rrjs crcorr/ptas/ iiridecrav

avaKaOr]pap.zvoL /cat eêAdcrayres ttclv to (3dp(3apov e/c rrjs
6aka.TTr)s. rjcrav 8e ovtol ol re eV Evpvp.ibovTL vavp.ayj)-

e cravres Kat ot ets KvTrpov crTpaTevcravTes /cat ot ets Atyu7rroi'
TrAerjcrayres /cat dAAocre 7roAAaxo'cre, cSv XP^ p.^p.vr\(r6aL /cat
xdpiu avrots etSevat, ort /3acrtAe'a e7rotr/cray Setcravra rr/
eauroC crcorr/pta roy youy 7rpocrexeti;, dAAd p,r/ rr/ rcov EA-
5 Ar/ycoi' i7TLf3ovKevLV cpdopq.
Kat ovros /uez> 8r) 7rdcrr/ rf/ 7ro'Aet 8tr/vrArjc^r/ 6 7rdAeuos V7rep
b i atxvva<T6ai WF : afxvvea-Bai T C2 77}/ T W : tV 7^1/ F

C7 7}fj.vvavro F: ^wacTW: ^w<toj' Gottleber d3 r)yy4h-
Aero WF : rryye\eTO T
ijydWeTo suprascr. f
: $ao-t\evs T W :
6 jScunXevs F (^7ri(rTpaT6ii(rat) eirixeipiiarwv Schanz e6 Trotrj?]
7ros vel nas nao-ri Stallbaum

MENEHEN02 242 a
kavrGtv re /cat tS>v dkkoiv op.ocpcoVcoj' Trpbs tovs (3apj3dpovs' 242

elpi]vr)s be yevop.evi]S /cai rr/s Tr6kea>s rtpcouen/? i)kdev eir
atirr/j', o 8?/ cptAet e* t&v dv6pa>7roiv tols ev irpaTTOvo-L
irpoo-rriirTeLV, irp&Tov piev (fr/Aos, d-rrb (rjkov be cpdovos' o /cai
r?/i^8e rr/y 7ro'Ati> dKorjcrai> ev 7roAeucp rots EAAr/cn Kare- 5

o-T-qaev. uerd 8e roiSro yevop.evov -nok.ep.ov, (rvve(3akov piev
ev Tavaypq virep ttjs Botcorcor ekevdepias AaKeSatuoznot?

p.axpp.V0L, ducptcr/Sr/TT/criuou be rr)s p.dxi]s yevop.evt]s, bieKpLve b
rd vcrrepov epyov ol piev yap &yovTo drrLovTes, KarakLirovTes
[Botcorovs] oty ej3or)6ovv, 61 6 57/xe'repoi rotTTi r)p.epq ev Olvo-

qjvroLs vLKTjo-avTes tovs ddtKcos cperjyorras StKatco? Karr/yayor.
ouroi bi) 7rpcorot uerd roy IlepcriKcV 7ro'Aeuoz/, "EAAr/crty 77877 5
V7rep Trjs ekevdepCas (3or)6ovvTes irposÊkkrjvas, dvbpes dya6ol

yevop.evoL kol ekev6ep(oo~avTes ols e(3or]6ovv, ev rcoSe rco c
p.vi)p.aTL TLp.r)6evres vtto tt/s irokecos 7rp<orot ere6r)(rav. uerd
be Tavra irokkov irokep.ov yevop.evov, nal irdvToav tu>v
'Ekki)va>v eiTLo-TpaTevcraVTOiv nal Tep.6vTO)V tt)v yw>pav Kal

dvaCav yapLV eKTLVovroiv Ti) irokeL, VLKT]o~avTes avrovs 5
vavpa\Cq ol r/ueVepot kol ka(36vres avrS>v tovs r)yep.6vas

AaKebaLp.ovLovs ev rfj ^cpayCq, ebv avrols 8iacpc9etpat ecpet-
cravTo koI direboo-av kol elpr)vr)v eiroLijo-avTO, r)yovp.evoL irpbs d
piev to 6p.6rf>vkov p.^xpi' vlki)S belv irokep.etv, kol ut/ bC
6pyr)v Ibiav irokeois to kolvov tS>v 'Kkkrjvoiv otoAAwat,
7rpos be tovs (3ap(3dpovs ue'xpi 8ta<p0opas. tovtovs bi) cllov
eiraLvecraL tovs avbpas, 0% tovtov tov Tr6kep.ov Trokep.T]o-avTes 5

evddbe KelvraL, otl eirebeLâv, et rts dpa r/p.cpecr/Sr/ret cos ev
rco TrpoTepq) irokepca rco 7rpos tovs /3ap/3dpovs dAAot rtyes
etey dp.eCvovs 'Ad-qvaCcov, otl ovk dkr)6r) dpcplcr/3r/rotel' ovrot

yap evravda ebeLâv, crrao-tacrdcrT/s rrjs 'EAAdSos irepLyevo- e
a6 a-vvff}a\ov filv Tf: avve$a\ofisv F: crvvefiaWov fxev W

b2 yap TF: om. W
KaTa\nr6vres WF: Kara\eiirovTes T et (
suprascr. W b3 Boicdtovs secl. ci. Bekker 07 AaKfSai/xo-
vlovs secl. Cobet d 6 4ir4ottav T W: iTreStiâvTO F ûcbeo-jS^Tfi T:
WF
T\fl<plfffi4)Tfl
24 2e IIAATJ2N02
ixevoi. tS> 7roAe/jto>, rovs 7rpoeoT<3ras tS>v dkkoiv 'Ekkrjvoov
Xeipcotrdpevot, pe0' &v totc tovs /3ap/3dpous evLKOiv kolvT],
tovtovs vlkS>vtS lb(q. TpCros 8e 7ro'Aeuos p.Ta rarjrrji; tt)v
5 elprjvqv avekmo-Tos re Kal btLvbs lykvero, iv a> 7roAAo Kat
ayaOol TekevTrjcravTes ivOdbe Ketvrat, 7roAAoi uev dutpt 2t-

243 Ktkiav 7rAeto-ra rpo7rata oTT/o-avres virep Trjs Aeovrivojv
ikevOepias, ols j3or}6ovvres 8ta rot/s opKovs eirkevcrav ets
Klvovs tovs tottovs, 8td 8e mt/kos tov irkov ets diropiav
rrjs 7ro'Aecos KaraoTdcrrrs Kat ov bvvap.kvr]s avrols VTrrjpeTeLV,
5 rorjrco d7ret7roVres eSuo-rvxô-ay' coz/ o! eyOpol Kat 7rpoo-7roAe-
jitô-avres Trkeioi erraLvov eypvcrL o-oxppoorvvrjs kol dpeTrjs r)
tS>v dAAcov ot cptAor 7roAAot 8' eV rats vavp.ayJ.aLS rats KaO*

'EWrio-TrovTov, utft p.ev r)p.epq irdcras tols tS>v Trokep.ioiv
eAoVres raos, 7roAAds be Kal dAAas VLKrjcravTes' b 8' et7roj>

b
b(Lvbv Kal dvkkirLCTTOv tov irokkpjov yevkaOaL, ro'8e keyoi rd
ets too-ovtov cpiAoviKtas ekOelv Trpbs tt)v irokLV tovs dkkovs
"Ekkrjvas, coare Tokp.rjcraL tS> eyOicrTip eirLK-qpvKevcracrQaL
5 /3acriAei, ov kowtj ee'/3aAov ue#' r)p.S>v, Ibiq tovtov irdkLV
eirdyecrOaL, fidpfiapov ecp' "EAArryas, Kat crvvaOpoLcraL e7rt
rT/y irokLV TtdvTas "Ekkrjvds re Kat fiapfidpovs. ov br) Kal
C eK(pavr)s eykvero r) rqs irokeois pcoprj re Kai dpeTf). olop.evoiV
yap rjbrf avrrjv KaTa7reTrokep.r)cr0aL Kat dirLkr]p.p.kvoiv ev
MrjriArjrT? rcoy yecov, /3orr^rjcrayres k^r/KovTa vavcriv, avrol

ep/3dz>res ets rds raCs, Kat dz;8pes ys.vop.evoi 6p.okoyovp.evois
5 dpLcrTOL, VLKqo~avres p.ev tovs 7roAepiorjs, kvcrdp.evoL 8e rovs

cptAtous, ava^Cov Tvyjis royovTis, ovk dvaipeOevTes eK rr}s
tâAdrrrrs Ketvrat er0d8e. coy XP^ "" p.p.vrjaOaC re Kai
d iiraLVtLV rfj pxv ydp iKeivojv aperfj kvLKr)crap.ev ov povov

rr)i> rdre vavp.ayj.av, dkka Kal tov dkkov Tt6kepx>v boav
a 4 dvvafiepris avrols W Bvvafifvots avrrjs T 8vt>afi4vr)S

W
avrrjs F
W
: :
a 5 To&rip T toCto F Trpoo"iroAeiJ.-{icravTes T 7rpDiroAe-

W
: :
fxi)ffavTfs F a^ 5'eVTW: S^F a8 /*ia T : cai /xta F

(sed ical punctis del. f) l> 5 t>v] Kal t>v vel bv $1 Teuffel
C 2 ^Stj avT^v T avrVW : fJ5r7 F
MENESENOS 243!
yap bC ovtovs r) ttoXls efcrxev /x?7 ttot av KaTaiToXep.r]6i)vaL
1X7]$' VTTOTTavTtov av6pa>ira>v Kal dXr)di] eboêv ry be r)p.Tepq
avTa>v bia<popq eKpaTi)dr)p.ev, ov\ vtto t<2v dXXa>v ai]TT7]T0L 5

yap ert kol vvv vtto ye e.Keiva>v e<rp.ev, yp.eis be avrol r)p.ds
avrovs koI evLKi]crap.ev Kal f}TTrjdr]p.v. /ixera be Tavra
i]o-v\Cas yevop.vr]s Kal elprjvrjs irpbs tovs aXXovs, 6 otKetoy e
r)pxv Tr6Xep.os ovto>s TToXp.r]6r), cScrre eXirep elp.app.ivov etr/
avdpa>iT0LS crracridcrai, p.r) av dAAcos evacr#at p.r)beva ttoXlv
kavTOv vocrfjcraL. Zk re yap tov rietpaicos Kal tov dcrrecos
a>s dcrp.eva>s Kal otKetcos dXXi]XoLS crvvep.eLâv ol 7roAirat Kat 5
7rao' eXiriba tols dAAots "EAArrcrt, tov re Trpbs tovs 'EAeuatrt

TToXepiov cos uerptcos edevro' kol tovto>v airdvTa>v ovbev dAA' 244
atrtoy i) r) rco ovri crvyyeveLa, cpiXiav fiefiaLov Kal 6p.6(pvXov
ov X6ya> dAA' eoyco Trapeyjop.vr). \pr) oe kol t&v ev tovto>
tu> TroXep.a> TeXevTr)crdvTa>v vtt dXXi)Xa>v p.veiav (X LV Ka '
StaAAdrreiz; avrovs co bvvdp.e6a, evxcus Kai flvcriais', ev tols 5
rototcrSe, rot? KparovcrLV avT&v evyop.4vovs, e7ret8?7 Kat 57/xets
8tT?AAdyue#a. ov yap KaKta dAAr/Acoz/ ijxfravTo ovb' eyBpq

aXXa bvcTTVxiq- p.dprvpes be r)p,LS avroi ecrp.ev tovto>v ol b
(a>VTS' ot avrot ydp ovTes eKeivoLS yeVet crvyyva>p.7)v aXXi]XoLS
exop.ev a>v r' 7TOLi]crap.v &v r 7rd6op.ev. uerd be tovto

iravreX&s elprjvqs rfpxv yevop.evr]S, r)crvxiav r)yev r) ttoXls,
>
tols p.ev j3ap(3dpoLS crvyyiyvaxrKovcra, otl Tradovres vir av- 5
tt]s kokcos- [tKaixSs] ovk evbeats r]p.vvavTO, toIs be "EXXtjctlv
dyavaKTOvcra, p.ep.vr)p.ev7) &s ev Tradovres im' avrfjs otav
\dpLV aTrebocrav, KOLva>crdp.evoL rots /8ap/3apots, rdts re raus C
irepLeXop.evoL at ttot eKeivovs ecraxrav, Kal Teixr) KaOeXovTes
avd' <Zv r)p.eXs TaKeiva>v eKa>Xvcrap.ev Trecrelv biavoovp.evr) be
7) ttoXls p.r) av ert dp.vvaL p.i)Te "EAAr/crt 7rp6s dAAr]Acoi;
d.4 8JTW: om. F TW

d.7 tjtt-^Btj^v f 4\inT-fjer>fifv F
W &aT(ws F TW
:
e4 iretpaiws F : ireipaiews T &ffTfos f a 2 f) r/

fcfrawv T W fc$alav F
:
scr. recc. :}F:^TW a5 ^ T W:

TWF
:
&s F b4 iravTekcos : iravTeXovs scr. recc. b6 iKavais

secl. Bekker b7 o>s] 8<r' Cobet C4 &' addubitat Schanz :
$1) ci. H. Richards

244 c ITAATGNOS
5 bovXovixivois pvqTe virb (3apj3apo>v, ovtojs coKet. r)p.G>v ovv
iv ToiavTtj biavota ovto>v r)yr)<rdp.evoL AaKebaLp.6vLOL tovs p.ev
rrjs iXevdepias iiTLKOvpovs 7re7rrcoKeVat i)p.as, crcpeTepov be ijbr)
d epyov etmi KarabovXovcrdaL tovs aXXovs, Tavr eirpaTTOV. kol

p.r)KvvLV p.ev tl bet; ov yap 7rdAat ovbe iraXaLwv av6po>TTO>v
yeyovora Aeyot/x' av tcl p.eTa Tavra' avrol yap t<rp.ev cos
iKireTTXr)yp.ivoL cl<plkovto eis \peiav rrjs 7rdAecos tG>v re 'EA-

5 Xr)vu>v ol irp&TOL, 'Apyetoi Kat Botcorot Kat KopivdLOL, kol to
ye deLOTarov iravTO>v, to Kal /3ao-tAea eis tovto airopias
a<pLK(T0aL, coore 7re/noT?/vai avrto p.i)bap.66ev aXXodev rr)v
cro>Tr)piav yeveardaL dAA' r) ck ravrrjs rrjs ir6Xeo>s, rjv irpodvp.o>s
e a7rcoAAu. Kat br) koi et rts j3ovXolto rrjs ir6Xeo>s Karr)-
yoprjcraL cuKatco?, tovt av p.6vov Xeyo>v 6p6G>s av KaTrjyopol,

0)9 det Atav <pLXoLKripp.o>v ecrrt Kat tov rJTTovos depairis. koX
br) kol iv tG> totc xp6vu> ov\ ota re iyevero KapreprjcraL ovbe
5 biacpvXdâL a ibeboKTO avTrj, t6 p.r)bevl bovXovp.ev(a fiorjOetv
245 tG>v <r<pas abLKrjcravToiv, clXXcl iKap.<p6r) Kal i(3or)6r)<TV, kol
tovs p.ev "EAArjâ? avrr) (3or)6rjcra<ra aireXvcraTO bovXeias,

uxtt iXevdepovs etvat p-eyjpL ov iraXLV avro\ avTohs Kare-
bovXa>(ravTO, /SacriAei be avrr) piev ovk iToXp.r)(rev (3or)6rj<raL,
5 al<rxyvop.evr) tcl TpoiraLa to. re Mapaflcout Kat 2aAajuu>i Kat
rTAaratat?, <pvydbas be kol ideXovras iacraaa p.6vov (3ori6rj<raL
6p.oXoyovp.evo>s ecroxrev. TeL\L<rap.ivr\ be Kat vavirr)yr)(rap.vr),
b i.Kbeap.ivr) tov ir6Xep.ov, iireLbr) r)vayKa<rdr) TroXep.eiv, v-rrep
Haptoiv iTToXip.L AaKebaLp.ovl*6*Ls. (pofirjdels be /3acrtAei/s

rrjv ttoXlv, iireLbr) ecopa AaKebaip.0VL0vs rco Kara daXarrav
TToXep.0) aTTayopevovTas, a-rrocrTrjvaL /3ovX6p.evos e^vjret tovs
c 7 rjfias secl. Cobet d2 ovSe iraXaiwv F (coniecerat Gottleber) :
obSi T-oWwv T W f : ov$' eV &\\wv Dobree d4 T W:

eKireirAij-y ixevoi
d 8 awrr\-
ireT-\7]yfxevot F d 7 irepi<rrriva.C\ rrapaffrr)vai Stallbaum
plav (&') Stallbaum ax o-<f>as T W: ff<t>as avrovs F a2 abrrj F:
attrrjTW abrobs V? F abro?s T
a3 &4 abrr)F: avrt) T:
:
avri) W a 5 re T r iv F W
Ka\ .
: ical T ot iv . . W : . . .
Kal iv F: k&v k&v H. Richards

. . . bi vrrep rrapioov TWF
(KopivOltev Stallbaum 'Apyeiwv Hermann) fort. vrrepSptov H. Richards
: :
b4 ^toT: Iftrci WF
.
MENEEEN02 245b
"Ekkrjvas tovs V rrj ?/7retpcp, ovcnrep irporepov AaKeoat/xdinoi 5
arjrco iîbocrav, et pe'AAot crvp.p.ayria-cLV r)p.lv re Kat rots dAAots
avp.p.dyoLS, r)yovp.evos ovk e0eAr/ae>, "lv arjrcp 7rpo'cpaats etr/
rr/s a7roardaecos. Kat tS>v p.kv akk(ov arjp/xdxcoy \j/va9r)' C

r)6f:kr)aav yap aurcp eK0i8oVat Kat avvzdtvTO Kal (op.oaav
KopivOioi Kal 'Apyetot Kat Botcorot Kal ol akkoi 0-vp.p.aypi,
et pe'AAot yjpr)p.aTa irapi^LV, eKScoaety rorjs ey rr) ?77reipcp
"EAAr/ras* /xoVoi 8e T/Ltets otjk eroAp?/aaLtei> ovre eKSoCrat 5

01/re djuoVat. orjrco 8r/ rot rd ye rrjs 7ro'Aecos* ycvvalov Kal
ckevdepov /3e'/3atdy re Kat 7jyie's earti Kat </)Jjaet p.Laoj3dp-
/3apov, otd r6 eiAiKptycos (Tvai "Ekkr)vas Kat d/utyet? /3ap- d

fiapcov. ov yap Ylzkoires ovbt Kdduot ovoe AXyvmoi re Kat
Aaraot oi8e aAAot 7roAAot cpi/aei pikv /3dp/3apot dVres, vop.(j>
oe "Ekkrjves, crvvoiKovcriv r)p2v, dAA' arjrot "Ekkr)V(s, ov

peto/3dp/3apoi otKorjper, odev KaOapbv to plaos eVrerr/Ke rfj 5
7rdAet rfjs dAAorptas cprjaecos. d/ncos 0' ovv ip.ovco6r)p.v Trdkiv
bia to p.r) kdikuv aiaypov koX avoariov tpyov ipydaaadaL e
"Ekkr)vas /3ap/3dpots eKOoVre?. eAaoVres ovv ets rarjrd e
cSjj Kat rd TrpoTtpov KaTeirokep.rj6r)p.V, ai/i> #ecp dp.Lvov r/ rdre
6ip.ei6a tov rrokepLOV Kat ydp Tjafis Kat retxr/ i\ovTes Kal
ras r//iere'pas avT&v dtroLKias dirr)kkdyr)p.ev roij irokip.ov 5
orjrcos, (coar') dya7rr/rc3s a7rr/AAarroyro Kat ot irokip.LOL.
dvbp&v p.ivTOL dyad&v Kal iv rorjrcp rco Trokepaa iaTepr)6r)p.ev,

rcor re ez> Kopi/J0cp xpr)aap.ivu>v bvayu>piq koX iv Aexatco
irpoboaiq.' dyadol 8e Kat 01 /3aatAe'a eAeufleocoaa^res Kat 246
eK/3aAoVres eK rr/s âAdrrr/s AaKeSat/ioytovs* coy eyco /xev
rj/xds dvap.Lp.vr)o-KO), vpus 8e 7rpe'7rei avv7raLVLV re Kat Koa/xety
rotorjrous dvbpas.
b6 fj.t\\ot scr. recc. : jueAAet TWF e 1 tysvaBii TW : owk

eêuff^rj F 2 eJcStSoVcu TWf: eVStSdvo F 03 01 F:
om. T W (fort. aWoi) d1 (Wrivas tWrives T
F W
W F Longinus
:
CI4 ouTorÊAArjês T : avToeWrjvcs Cobet 6 2 ?AAt;-

vos WF : ?AA7j/j T : Schanz
"EAA7j/es "EAAtjvos e6 oi/toij . .
Kokt/itoi secl. Hermann SoV add. Madvig e8 Aex^V^^

Ax a "?T: Aex** W a2 eK0a\6vres F eKf$&\\ovTes T
: W
PLATO, VOL. III. 35
246a nAATiiNOS
5 Kat rd fxev bi) epya ravra tS>v dvbpS>v tS>v evddbe Ketfxevoiv
Kal tS>v akkoiv oaot vtrep Trjs TTokeo>s rereAewT/Kacri, -nokka
fxev Ta eiprjfxeva ko.1 Kakd, Trokv b' ert 7rAeico Kal Kakkioi ra
b viroketTTOfxeva' 7roAAat yap av rjfxepat Kal vvKTes ov\ tKavat
ykvoivTo r<S ra iravra fxekkovrt irepaivetv. tovtcoV ovv XPV
fxefxvrffxevovs rois Tovroiv eKyovots irdvT avbpa irapaKe-
keveadat, &airep iv TTokefxio, fxr) keiireiv tt)v rdtv rrjv tS>v
5 Trpoyovoiv 1x118' eis Tovtriaoi avayoipeiv eiKOvras KaKf). eyoi
fxev ovv Kal ovtos, co 7rat8es dvbpatv dya6S>v, vvv re rrapa-
Kekevofxat Kai ev r<5 Aoi7r<3 \pov<o, ottov dv tu kvrvy\dvoi

C vfxSiv, Kal dvafxvrjaoi ko.1 btaKekevaopuxt Trpodvfxetadat eXvat
<as dpiarovs' ev be ra> irapovTt bUatos elfxt elTrelv a 01
rraTepes r)fxiv eireaKrfirTov d-nayyekketv toIs del ketnrofxevots,
et rt irdcryoiev, r)vUa Ktvbvvevaetv efxekkov. (ppdaoi be vfxiv
5 a re avrS>v rJKOvaa eKetvoiV koX dta vvv r)beois dv elirotev vpZv

kafiovTes bvvafxiv, reKfxatpofxevos e<f &v tot ekeyov. dkka
vofxtêtv xpr) avT&v aKovetv eKeivcov a av dirayyekkoi' ekeyov
be rdbe
d *12 7rat5es, ort fxev ecrre Trarepoiv dyadSiv, avrb fxrjvvet to
vvv irapov r)fxiv be e6v (fjv fxr) KakSis, KakSiS alpovfxeda
fxakkov Tekevrav, irpiv ifxds re koI tovs eirevra els oveibi)
KaTaarfjcrat ko.1 irplv tovs rjfxeTepovs Trarepas Kai irdv to
5 TtpoaOev yevos aiayyvat, f)yovfxevot r<3 tovs avrov aia^yvavTt
df3toiTov elvat, koi tS> rotovrcp otire Ttvd dvdpoinoiv ovre
6eS>v (pikov elvat ovt eiii yrjs ov6' vtto yrjs TekevTi')aavTt.
XPV ovv fxefxvrffxevovs tS>v r)fxerepoiV koyoiv, edv rt Kat dAAo

e daKrjre, daKetv fxeT dperqs, elboras ort tovtov kenrofxeva
%dvTa Kal KTrffxara Kat eTTiTrfbevfxara aiaxpd Kal Ka/cd. ovre
yap 7rkovTos Kakkos (pepet rai KeKTrffxevia fxeT dvavbpias
b 4 Sicrirtp T f W
&<TTf F : b 6 irapaK(\evofiai secl. Schanz
W
C 3 rj/uv T Stobaeus vfiTv F del F StobaeusW om. T :
W
:
C 4 k ivSvvtvfftiv F Stobaeus mvSvvtvfiv T d 5 alaxvvavri F

W
:
Iamblichus al<rxvvovri T Stobaeus (sed t in rt ex emend. T)

W
:
d 7 yrjs T W
F Stobaeus yrjv Iamblichus : e 2 irdvra T F
Stobaeus awavra Iamblichus
:
:
MENEEEN02 246 e
dAAo> yap 6 tolovtos tt\ovt(-1 nal ov% kavT(2 ovtz cr(j>p.aTos
KaAAor nal icr-^vs 8etA<S Kat KaKco crvvoLKOvvTa TrpiirovTa 5

<pau>erat dAA' aTTparrj, Kal Tn<pav4oTpov 7rotet tw eyovTa
Ka\ K<paiVL tt]v beLkCav TTacrd re e7rtoTT7/ur/ \(apLôp.ivt)
hiKaioo-6vr\v eveKa kol irpcoTOV Kat vcrTaTOv Kal bia iravTos
irdcrav irdvTo>s irpo6vp.Cav 7retpdo-0e \lv o7rco? /udAtora pey
v7rep/3aAeto-0e Kal fjpuis ko.1 tovs irpocrOev erjKAeiV et 8e pr/,
tare cbs* i//xiy, di> /xh' vlkS>p.(-v vpus dperf/, t/ rtK?/ aicryyvr\v 5
<pe'pet, t/ 8e fjrra, *dv r)TT(J>p.da, zvbaLp.ovCav. /udAio-ra 8*
av VLKpi.da kol vp.els vlk(j>t\t, et 7rapao-Keuda-aio-0e rr/ tQ>v
itpoyovcav Sdtfr/ p.r\ KaTay prrcr6p.(V0L <

p.r\b^ avako>crovTS avTi\v, b
yvovres otl avbpl oto/xeVco rt etuat ovk zcttlv alcryjLOv ovbiv
r) irapiytLv kavrbv TLp.cap.tvov p.r\ 81' kavrbv dAAd 8td boâv
TrpoyovoiV. etuat p.ev yap rt/ud? yovko>v iKyovoLS Kakbs
6r\cravpbs Kal p.ydkoTTpirr\s' yjpr\cr6aL 8e kol \pr\p.aTcov Ka\ 5
TLp.G>v 6r\cravp(2, Kat p.r\ tols iKyovois 7rapa8t8oVai, aicrypbv
Kal dvavbpov, aTTopCq, ibCo>v avTov KTr\p.a.To>v re Kat evboiG>v.
Kal eav p*v raura e7rirr/8erJo-T/re, cpCkoL irapa cpCkovs r)p.ds C

d<pt<feo-0e, orav vpJds r) Trpocrr\KOVcra /uotpa Kop.Ccrry ap.ekrj-
cravTas 8e vp.ds Kal KaKLcrdivTas ou8ets vp.vu>s Tj7ro8e'<ferat.
rots pikv ovv Traicrl rarjr' CLpr\cr6o>.
64 (tw.uoto? KaWos TW F Iamblichus : koAAos adtnaros Dionysius

Stobaeus a 4 ei Se lacunam
fj.i), ime T W F Dionysius Stobaeus :
post ixr)Cobet ex Iamblicho ita fere supplendum oVws tls taov

statuit
/caToo-TT/ffeT* XffTe yap (KaltffTe malit Schanz)

as r)/uv TW
Stobaeus fyu' F r\ vlki) al<Tx^ vr v /xp"
: F Dionysius Stobaeus W
alaxivr\v cpepa T (t) viKr) ante <pepei add. t) a 7 viKwfxtda T F
)
W
Dionysius Stobaeus T/TTwêflo in marg. Tf : viKcprtre ex emend. W
Tf: /KaTe F Stobaeus wkbi/th T Trapao-Kt>ao-a<o (' T f rrapa-
-
W
: :
aKevdffaarde TrapaffKtvaffeade F Stobaeus b r Karaxpyffdnevoi

W
:
. avaAwffovres T KaTaxpyffdfJ-evoi ava\w<ravTes F Stobaeus .
W
. . : . .
b 2 ovtev 7) irapex^ v F Dionysius t) irapex eiv T ( se ^ t) rra ex ou) :
Iamblichus irapex*i v Stobaei A

: b 4 irpoyovwv T F Dionj sius r
Iamblichus Stobaeus irpoTepwv sed suprascr. yov) et in marg.

: W
yp. T koAos T F Dionysius Iamblichus Stobaeus om. W
W
:
b5 XP^" eaI T F Dion y sius Iamblichus: *caTaxpf;o-0a< C2 KOfxiari]

Koiulffr) Naber
35*
247 c ITAATX2N02
5 ITarepas be r)p.G>v, ols elcri, kol pLrjrepas del xpr) irapa-
p.v6eLcrdaL <as paara cpepeLV ttjv <rvp.<f>opdv, edv dpa avpLfSr)
yevecrdaL, Kal p.r) <rvvobvpeo-6aL ov yap tov kvn-qo-ovTOs
d TTpocrbericrovTai' iKavr) yap larai /cat 57 yevop.evr) Tvyj] tovto

nopiCeiv dAA' lo>p.evovs kol irpavvovras avap.ip,vr]<rKeiv av-
tovs otl 3>v r)vyovTO rd p.eyi<TTa avrois ol 6eo\ eirrJKooi
yeyovacriv. ov ydp ddavdTovs <r<pi<rt. Tralbas -qvyovTo yeve<rdai
5 dAA' ayadovs Kal evKkeels, oov ervyov, p.eyi<TTu>v dya6S>v

ovtojv irdvra be ov pqbiov 6vrjT<a dvbpl /<ard vovv ev t<0>
eavTOv /3ia> eKftaiveLV. Kal <pepovres p.ev dvbpeio>s rds

<rvp,<popds boôvcri t<7> ovti dvbpeioiv iraibo>v 7rarepes elvai
e Kal avTol tolovtol, VTreiKOvres be v7ro\f/iav irapeov<TLV r) p.r)
rjp-erepoL etvai r) r)p,S>v tovs eiraLVovvTas KaTa\frevbecrdaL' \pr)
be ovberepa tovto>v, dAA' eKeivovs /xdAtara r)p.G>v eiraLveras

elvaL epy<o, irapeyovTas avrovs <paivop.evovs t<2 ovtl TraTepas
5 ovTas avbpas dvbp&v. irdkaL ydp br) to Mrjbev dyav keyo-

p.evov KakG>s boKel keyecrdaL' rS> ydp ovtl ev keyeraL. ot<*>
ydp dvbpl els eavrbv dvqpTr)TaL irdvra rd 7rpds evbaipLOviav

248 <pepovTa rj eyyvs tovtov, kol p.r) ev dAAots dvdpo>iroLS
auopetrat e 8>v rj ev t) KaK&s irpadvTo>v irkavd<r6aL r)vdy-

Kaorat Kal rd eKeivov, tovto> dpL<rra irapeo-KevaoraL Cr)v,
ovtos ecrTLV 6 <ro><ppa>v k<xl ovtos 6 dvbpelos Kal <ppovLp.os'

5 ovros yLyvop.eva>v yj>r]p.aTa>v koX iraiboov kol bLa<pdeLpop,eva>v
pdAtara irei<reTaL rfj TrapoLp.iq' ovre ydp yaipa>v ovre kvirov-
p.evos dyav <pavrj<reTaL otd rd at>T<2 TreiroLdevaL. tolovtovs
b be fjpiels ye a^Lovp.ev Kal tovs r)p.eTepovs etvaL Kal (3ovkop.eda

Kal <f>ap,ev, Kal i)p.as avTovs vvv Trapeyop-ev tolovtovs, ovk
dyavaKTOvvras ovbe <pof3ovp.evovs dyav ei bel rekevTav ev t<o
C5 ae) F
Dionysius Stobaeus e/ c6 isF Dionysius
: TW
Stobaeus &s xph T W
d 2 iroplCeiv F Dionysius Tropl(eo-6ai T W
W
: :
d 3 eijxovro F Dionysius tijx <"/rat T e 5 ovras T

: f oflf. F W
W
:
a I tovtov T W
f Iamblichus tovtwv F a 2 aiwpurai T
: (sed
rj super u W) Iamblichus OewpuTai F a 7 irciroiB4vai T F
W
:
Iamblichus ireirovdevai
: bi 76 TWf: om. F. Iamblichus
clvvu T Wf: om. F
MENEHEN02 248b
TTapovTL. bop.c6a br) nal TraTcpoiv nal p.r)Tcpoiv Trj avTjj raim/
biavoiq \poip.cvovs tov CTrikoLTTov fiiov bidycLV, Kal cibcvai 5
otl ov 6pr)vovvrcs ovbc 6\o<pvp6p.cvoL r)pxis r)p2v pAkiora
yapiovvTai, dAA' et tls Ioti 701? rereAeurTjKoVtz; aio-6r)o~LS
t5>v (0VT0iV, ovTOiS ayap(,o~TOL clcv av p.aXi&Ta, cavrovs re c

KaicovvTCS Kal (3apeo)s -pcpovTCS Tas o~vp.(popds' Kov(po)s be Kal
/xerptcos uaAtcrr' av yapi(j>LVTO. tcl picv yap r)p.cTcpa TckcvTr)v
rjbrj eet rjirep KakX.io~rr) ytyyerat av6pd>irois, wcttc TTpCTTCL
avTa p.a\\ov Koo~p.clv r) 6pr)vclv yvvaLK&v oe tS>v r)p.cTpo)V 5

Kal Traiboiv ciTLp.eXovp.cvoL Kal Tpe(povTcs Kal evTavda t6v
VOVV TpCTTOVTCS TTJS TC TVXqS p.dkLO~T CLV LV cv Xr)6r) Kal
coei> Ka\A.LOv Kal 6p6oTcpov Kat r)pxv 7rpoo-<piAe'crrepoz/. Tavra d

br) LKava roty r)p.cTepoLs trap r)p.Stv dyyeXkeLV rfj be 7ro'Aet
irapaKcXcvoip.cB' dv oirois r)pXv ko\ iraTcpoiv Kal vcoiv
cTTLp.krjo~ovTai, Toits picv TraLbcvovTcs Koo~p.iois, tovs bc

yr]poTpo<povvTS a(oiS' vvv bc to~p.cv otl Kal cav p.r) r)p.LS 5
TTapaKc\V(ap.c6a, Xmv&s CTTLpLcXrjcrcTaL.
Tatrra ovv, 2) 7rat8es Kat yovrjs T(2v TcXcvTr)o~dvTO)v, ckclvol
tc cTTo~Kr)TTTOv rjpXv aTrayycKKcLV , kol eyco cbs bvvap.aL irpo6v- G

woVara a7rayye'AAco* Kat avros 8e'ouat virep CKcivoiv, tS>v p.cv
p.Lp.LO~daL tovs avrStv, tS>v bc 6appclv viTcp avr&v, cos r)p.S>v
Kat ibiq Kat br)p.oo~iq yr)poTpo(pr)o~6vTOiv vp.as koX CTTLp.cXr)-

a~op.cvoiv, ottov dv CKao~TOS eKaorcj) cvTvyydvr) oTOiovv tS>v 5
cKcCvoiv. rrjs be 7ro'Aecos tore 7rou Kat avrot Tr)v e7rt/xe'Aetay,

ort vop.ovs 6ep.evr) rrepl tovs tS>v cv rco 7roAe'/xa) reAeur?]-
(rdvTOiv 7rat8as re Kat ycvvrJTOpas cTTip.cXclTaL, Kal 8ta-
(pcpovTOis tS>v dkkoiv tto\ltS>v TrpoaTCTaKTaL tpvXaTTCLv dpyr\ 249
7j7rep p.cyCo~Tr) co~t'lv, otto)S dv 01 tovto)v p.r) abLK&VTaL traTcpcs
tc Kal p.r)Tcpcs' tovs bc Traibas o~vvcKTp(pcL avTr], TTpodvpov-
p.cvr) otl p.d\L(rT dbrjkov airot? Tr)v 6p(pavCav ycvco~6aL, cv
iraTpbs o-yjip.aTL Karacrrao-a avrots avrr) ert re Trato-ty ovctlv, 5
b6 Oprjvovvre s TF : Oappovvres ut videtur W

CI3 Tapa.Ke\evoi-
ji*e6' av TWf: TapaK*\ev6ixeQ' av F: TapaKe\ev6/xf0a Dionysius
a 1 apxy scr. recc: apxh TW F as avri) F: avrt) W : avri) T
249 a I1AATI2N02
nal TTibav ets avbpbs re'Aos tcoo-ti;, aTTOTrep.TTL enl tcl o-<peTep
avT&v TravoTrkCq KOo-p.r]o-ao-a, evbeLKVvp.evr] Kal avapLLp.vr]-
a-KOva-a tcl tov iraTpbs eiTLT-qbevpLaTa opyava rrjs irarpcoas

b dperrjs bibovaa, Kal dp.a olcovov xaptv dpyeo-QaL teVat eirl tj)v
naTpcoav ka-Tiav apovra p.eT lo"xyos oTrAots KKoap.r]p:evov.

ai)TOvs be tovs TeXevTrjaavras Ttp.coaa ovbeiroTe eKAet7rei,
Kad' eKao-Tov eviavTov avTr) tcl vop.i(6fAva iroLovaa KOLvr)
5 Tracnv airep eKaorco tSta yiyveraL, Trpbs be tovtols dycovas

yvpLVLKOvs Kai lttttlkovs TLOelaa Kal fiovo-LKrjs irdo-qs, kol
CLTexv&s tcov piev Te\eVTr]o-dvTcov ev K\rrpovop.ov Kal veos
C /uotpa Ka6eo-Tr\Kvia, tcov be vecov ev -rraTpos, yovecov be tS>v
tovtcov ev eTTLTpoirov, TTao-av TrdvTcov TTaph Trdvra tov xpovov

TTLp.ekeLav TTOLOvixevr}. Giv xpr) evdvp.ovp.evovs irpqorepov
cpepeLV Tr)v avpLcpopdv rots re yap TekevTrjcrao-L Kal rots
5 a>o-Lv ovtcos av 7rpoo"</)iAe'crraroi etre kol pqaroL depaireveLV
re Kat OepaTreveaOaL. vvv be rjbrj vp.els re Kat ot aAAot
TravTes KOLvfj Kara tov vop.ov tovs rereAetrr?jKoras cnroAo-
CpVpdpLVOL CL1TLT.
d Ovro's crot 6 Ao'yos, a> Mevet-eve, 'Acr7rao-ias rrjs MtArio-ias

iffrCtt.
MEN. N?/ Ata, a> 2coKpares, p.aKapiav ye Ae'yets rr)v
'Acnrao-Cav, et yvvr) ovcra tolovtovs \6yovs ota r' ecrrt
5 ovvTidevai.
2X2. 'AAA' et p.r) ttlcttVls, ctKoAovflet p.T ep.ov, koX
d,Kovo-r] avTrjs Xeyovcn]s.
MEN. FIoAAaKis, a> 2coKoares, eyco evTTV\r\Ka 'Acr7rao-ia,
Kai olba oXa cttlv.
io 212. Tt ovv; ovk dyacraL avTr)v kol vvv ydpLV eyjeis tov
koyov avrfj;
a6 Kal TF om. W b2 &povra TF apâvra W b4 avr^

W
: :
F : avrfi T b5 l/cdoTy /5io F : iKaffr^

5i'a IfSia T : kKaoTif
ISia IfSia W c 1 rwv tovtwv F : Kal tuv Toirrwv T W koL tS>v
W
:
toio6tuv corr. Coisl. C 4 re T F ye C5 tfrjTe T WF

W
:
d a Vti V
T F om. :
MENEEENOS 249 d
MEN. Kal 7rokkr]v ye, 10 SatKpares, eyw yapiv tyjio tovtov

tov koyov tKtLvr) 7/ (kclvco ooti? o~ol 6 ltt(ov (o-tlv avrov e
Kal 7Tpos ye aAAco^ Trokk&v yapLV \<d tG> zlttovtl.
2il. Ev av \ol' dAA' ottcos p.ov p.r) /careoeis, tva Kal

avdCs ctol Trokkovs Kal Kakovs koyovs irap' avTrjs irokLTLKovs
aTTayyekka). 5
MEN. aopei, ov KaTepcS* p.6vov arrayyekki.
2X2. 'AAAa ravT eorai.
e 2 irpos yt F itpo 7 T
: W &Akwv noAAwv T F W : aAAr}v iroAAriv
Heindorf 63 Kareptls TF: /caTepfjsW: Kaprtpris f 64 itoAitikovs
secl. Cobet e 6 011 Kartpw T W
ovk avTtpw F
:
>
OXFORD
CLASSICAL TEXTS
The prices given of copies on ordinary paper are for copies bound
in limp cloth ; uncut copies may be had in paper covers at 6d. less
per volume (ls. less for those priced from 6s. in cloth).
All volumes are also on sale interleaved with writing-paper and

bound in stout cloth ; prices on application.
April 1910
HENRY FROWDE
OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS
LONDON, EDINBURGH, NEW YORK, TORONTO AND
MELBOURNE
Greek
AesdiyluS. A. Sidgwick. 3s. 6d. (India paper, 4s. 6d.)
AntoninuS. J. H. Leopold. 3s. (India paper, 4s.)
ApolloniuS RhodiuS. R. C. Seaton. 3s. (India paper, 4s.)
AristophaneS. F. W. Hall, W. M. Geldart. (India paper, 8s. 6d.)

I. Ach., Eq., Nub., Vesp., Pax, Aves. 3s. 6d. (India paper, 4s. 6d.)
II. Lys., Thesm., Ran., Eccl., Plut., fr. 3s. 6d. (India paper, 4s. 6d.)
Bucolici Graeci. U. von Wilamowitz-Moellendoeff. 3s. (India

paper, 4s.)
Demosthenes. s. h. Butcher.
I. Orationes I-XIX. 4s. 6d. II. i. Orationes XX-XXVI. 3s. 6d.
Together on India paper, 12s. 6d.
EuripideS. Gilbert Murray. (India paper, I-III, 12. 6d. ; I-II, 9s. ;
III, 4s. 6d.)

I. Cyc, Alc, Med., Heracl., Hip., Andr., Hec. 3s. 6d.
II. Suppl., Herc, Ion, Tro., EL, I. T. 3s. 6d.
III. Hel., Phoen., Or., Bacch., Iph. Aul., Rh. (In the press.)
Hellenica Oxyrhynchia cum Theopompi et Cratippi fragmentis.

B. P. Grenfell, A. S. Hunt. 4s. 6d.
HerodotUS. K. Hude. (India paper, 12s. 6d.)

Vol. I (Books I-IV). 4s. 6d. Vol. II (Books V-IX). 4s. 6d.
Homer, 3s. per volume.
Iliad. (Vols. Iandll.) D.B.Monro,T.W. Allen. (Indiapaper,7s.)

OdySSey. and IV.)(Vols. III T. W.Allen. (Indiapaper, 6s.)
Hyperides. F. G. Kenyon. 3s. ed.

LonginUS. A. O. Prickard. 2s. 6d.
PlatO. J. Burnet. Vols.I-III,6s.each(India paper, 7s. each). Vol. IV.
7s. (India paper, 8s. 6d.) Vol. V. 8s. (India paper, lOs. 6d.)
I. Euth., Apol., Crit, Ph. ; Crat., Tht., Soph., Polit.
II. Par., PhiL, Symp., Phdr. ; Alc I, II, Hipp., Am.
III. Thg., Chrm., Lch., Lys. ; Euthd., Prot., Gorg., Men. ; Hipp. ma.,
mi., Io, Menex.
IV. Clit., Rep., Tim., Critias. Also Republic, separately, 6s. ; on quarto
writing-paper, lOs. 6d.
V. Minos, Leges, Epinomis, Epistulae. Definitiones, Spuria.
First and nfth tetralogies separately, paper covers, 2s. each.
Theophrasti Characteres. H. Diels. 3s. 6d.
ThucydideS. H. Stuart Jones. (Indiapaper, 8s. 6d.)
I. Books 1-4. II. Books 5-8. 3s. 6d. each.
XenOphon. E. C. Marchant. Vols. I-III. (India paper, 12s. 6d.)
I. Historia Graeca. 3s.

II. Libri Socratici. 3s. 6d.
III. Anabasis. 3s.
IV. Cyropaedia. 3s. 6d.
Latin
AsCOIliuS. A. C. Clark. 3s. 6d.
Caesar, Commentarii. R. l. a. Du Pontet. (india paper, ts.)

Bellum Gallicum. 2s. 6d. Bellum Civile. 3s.
CatllllllS. R. Ellis. 2s. 6d. (With Tibullus and Propertius, on India

paper, 8s. 6d.)
Cicero, Epistulae. L. C. Purser. (India paper, 21s.)

I. Epp. ad Fam. 6s. ; II. ad Att., Pars i (1-8), Pars u (9-16), 4s. 6d. each ;
III. ad Q. F., ad M. Brut., Fragm. 3s.
OratlOneS. (Rosc. Am. etc, Mil. etc., Verrinae, India paper,

18s. 6d.)
Rosc. Am., I. Pomp., Clu., Cat, Mur., Cael. A. C. Clark. 3s.
Pro Milone, Caesarianae, Philippicae. A. C. Clark. 3s.
Verrinae. W. Petersok. 4s.
Pro Quinctio, Pro Roscio Comoedo, Pro Caecina, De lege Agraria,
Pro Rabirio perduellionis reo, Pro Flacco, In Pisonera, Pro
Rabirio Posturao. A. C. Clark. 3s.
Rhetorica. A. S. Wilkins. (India paper, 7s. 6d.)

I. De Oratore. 3s. II. Brutus, etc. 3s. 6d.
HoraCC E. C. Wickham. 3s. (India paper, 4s. 6d.)
LucretiuS. C. Bailey. 3s. (India paper, 4s.)
Martial. W. M. Lindsay. 6s. (India paper, 7s. 6d.)
NepOS. E. O. Winstedt. 2s.
PerSlUS and Juvenal. S. G. Owen. 3s. (India paper, 4s.)
PlautuS. W. M. Lindsav. (India paper, 16s.)

I. Amph. Merc. II. Miles fragm. 6s. each.
PropertlUS. J. S. Phillimore. 3s. (India paper, see Catullus.)
StatillS. (Complete on India paper. lOs. 6d.)
Silvae. J. S. Phillimore. 3s. 6d.
Thebais and Achilleis. H. w. Garrod. 6s.
Tacitus, Opera Minora. H. Furneaux. 2s.
Annales. C D. Fisher. 6s. (India paper, 7s.)
Terence. R. Y. Tyrrell. 3s. 6d. (India paper, 5s.)
TibulluS. J. P. Postgate. 2s. (India paper, see Catullus.)
Vergil. F. A. Hirtzeu 3s. 6d. (India paper, 4s. 6d.)
Appendix Vergiliana. r. Ellis. *s.

*?-
BINDIKG
liJ4o
PA

Operarecognovitb 03 Platuoft

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

You might also like

Operarecognovitb 03 Platuoft

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Operarecognovitb 03 Platuoft

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

SCRIPTORUM CLASSICORUM

TETRALOGIAS V-VII CONTINENS

debeo ; is enim de omnibus fere locis gravioribus

bonensem F non testium duorum loco esse sed pro

Hippia maiore descriptum esse S ex Veneto Marciano

complures errores invenissem, quos ex unciali scriptura

Impressio secunda non nullis in locis correcta.

mense Ianuario m.cm.ix

TETRALOGIA I ED. STEPH.

Apologia Socratis . . . . I. pp. 17-42

Cratylvs I. pp. 383-440

Parmenides III. pp. 126-166

Definitiones III. pp. 411-416

W = cod. Vindobonensis 54. suppl. phil. Gr. 7 = Stallbaumii

F= cod. Vindobonensis 55. suppl. phil. Gr. 39

P = cod. Vaticanus Palatinus 173 s

S = cod. Venetus Marcianus 189 = Bekkeri 2

AH. *X2 ScoKpare?, (be6p.r)v arra <roi lbio\.oyrjcracrOaL, a

2,12. 'AAAd Kat dAAcos rrjyxdrjco oypXaijjov, kol br) crov

ye eVeKa Kat -navv. dAA' et rt j3ov\ei Aeyetr, eeoru\ 5

212. Et 001 8oKet.

Kal 7a ioa Ta re dAAa Kat avdpcoTros. koX yap iv rots

uer, to TtapacTKCvacracrdaL iravra rd 7rpd rorj cpvreveLV Kal 5

OepaireCa tov cpvvros Kal TroAAf/ Kat xaXerrr) Kal bvcrKokos

a 1 ltiio\oyf)<raffOai] Sta\oy(ffaffdai ci. Cobet a 2 nav el) Kav $

d c/>rjcri, crocpbs yeveadaL. y&p p.0L, tG>v tjXlkuot&v Tives

7rdA.at fxoL Trpa.yp.aTa Ttapiyei, o.lG>v eTTLfxekrfdfjvaL p.e kav-

5 tov Kal xPVriaTa rekiaaL tlvI tG>v aocpLO-TG>v, octtls avrbv

122 fxe\eL, r)yovp.ai oe tovtov ovk els fiiKpbv Kivbvvov teVat 61

6ecr6aL avrG>, Xva fxf) tto\\6.kls avev ep.ov avyyevofxevos rco

5 bLacpdapfj. vvv ovv 77KCO eV avra ravra, tva rco tovto>v

5 ov yap ecrTL irepl otov deLOTepov av av6po>Tros (3ov\evcraLTo

fxev ovv eyco re Kat crv o~vvofxokoyr)o~o>fXV tl ttot olofxeda

BT d. 6 Ka\ secl. Cobet a 1 /xeAei B fxiWzi T rovrov :

B: tovtuv T fiiKpbv BT fiaKpbvW :aa ffirevSei (^o-ittvSovra)

iSovkevm- kcu (tv o oTu/3orjAerjo'uero9, fxrjbev rS>v avrStv

AH. 'AAAa uot boKels 6p6<as KeyeLV, co 2ooKpares, Kal 5

TtOLCLV \pi] OVT(D.

2X2. Kat Ae'yco ye opdoos, ov ueVrot iravTa.TTao-( ye*

0-p.LKpov ydp rt /jterartfleuai. woco yap ur/ koll 6 uet-

AH. KtrSwevet yow ovrco /3e'Artcrrw et^ai co? cru Aeyet?. 5

2X2. EtVe 8r/ uot, rt KaAoi> ovop.a rco veavio-Ku; tl avrbv

AH. edyrjs ovop.a rorjrco, ob 2coKpares.

lepoirpeTTes. ei7re 8?/ r/uii>, co 0e'ayes, eTTLdvp-elv obrjs crot/>os e

6'rorj ay TTL(TTi)p.oves Sxtlv, r) tovs p.r\;

0E. Tovs eTrtorrjuoi-as eycoye.

Kat T^y dAArj7j dyooviav;

C9 Wu^fiBTW: 4wi6viJLTJ scr. Ven. 184 d6 aAii' secl.

ov eyto kiTL6vp.Gi'. rotatSra yap erepa Kal Trpos e/xe

/xd^erai re Kat o?3k e#e'Aet pe ovSevi o"?jtrr?7o-ai.

212. 'AAAd rd p.ei> cp.-rpoodev ool T/y 7rpds toutov p?/0eVra

tindvp.is. <ptp* y&P> e ' e7re0d/xets ravrr/s t^ ot avdpcoiroL

ovk e0e'Aei cre ovvLOTavaL itap &v av oi) oocpbs yeVoto;"

rd app.ara KvfitpvGiOLV etr' ep.4p.cpov rto irarpi, e/jtou au

etmt; ap' o^t r)vLO\LKr]v;

d. 0E. Tt 8e dAAo, S 2toKpares, ai/r?/ ovofid tls ipair) dz>

etVai dAA' r/ oocpiav;

eVtB eTt Kal trepa T