k








            


 



%UDQNR3HWUDQRYL,VWRULMD-XJRVODYLMH,,,
%HRJUDGVWU


            

          
=5DGHOL+UYDWVNDX-XJRVODYLML
RG]DMHGQLWYDGRUD]OD]D=DJUHEVWU

73
 




         
         
,9

          
         
       3  

        
5
       



'%LODQGL+UYDWVNDPRGHUQDSRYLMHVW=DJUHE




              

  H - 3RSRYL 'RNXPHQWL ]D LVWRULMX -XJRVODYLMH HWYUWD VHGQLFD
&.6.-%ULRQVNLSOHQXP%HRJUDG

 
3
 9/XNL%ULRQVNLSOHQXP2EUDXQVD$OHNVDQGURP5DQNRYLHPVHDQMDLVD]QDQMD%HRJUDG
VWU

 






5
 





           









 

         
        
        







7







 





5
5DGRLQ.RMHNRX-XJRVODYLMLMXJRVORYHQVNLVDYUHPHQLFL%HRJUDGVWU
7
 $ 'XKDHN ,VSRYHVW REDYHWDMFD 8VSRQ L SDG MXJRVORYHQVNH REDYHWDMQH VOXEH %HRJUDG
9/XNL%ULRQVNLSOHQXP
2EUDXQ VD $OHNVDQGURP 5DQNRYLHP VHDQMD L VD]QDQMD %HRJUDG  $ 
61XPLDo-
EUD]HPOMRODXGRLVWLQHXEULRQVNRMDIHULSULVOXNLYDQMD%HRJUDG



 
           
              

$1HQDGRYL5D]JRYRULVD.RRP5LMHNDVWU
=DWYDUDQMHNUXJD,VKRGSROLWLNRJUDVFHSDX6.-
6DUDMHYR
.UKNDVUSVND
YHUWLNDOD%HRJUDG6QDJDOLQHRGJR
YRUQRVWL%HRJUDG




 -.HVDU36LPL/HND$OHN-
VDQGDU5DQNRYLRSURWDMEH]PLOVWL%HRJUDG


75
 



         


           

          
          
        
         




           



         
           



        

        




 


 .DUDNWHUMXJRVORYHQVNRJFHQWUDOL]PDXVYHWOXDQDOL]HWDMQHVHGQLFH,]YUQRJ
NRPLWHWD&HQWUDOQRJNRPLWHWD6DYH]DNRPXQLVWD-XJRVODYLMHPDUWD'LMDORJSRYMHVQLDUD
LVWRULDUD3ULUHGLOL+)OHFN,JRU*UDRYDF=DJUHEVWU

 ,,,


",,,



 









          
           


         






         

          




          
9,,,

        


 ,,,

         ;,,     


KWWSZZZPRGJRYUVODW
RUJDQL]DFLMDYEDYEDBLVWRULMDWSKSSKS

 



77
 


     
           




















            









             



 

 
01LNH]L/3HURYL6USVNDNUKNDYHUWLNDOD
%HRJUDGVWU

 $

             
$1HQDGRYL5D]JRYRULVD.RRP5LMHNDVWU

 




 

           



"
           
          


           




         

          
          

          



       
           



 


 

55DGRLQ.RMHNRX-XJRVODYLMLVWU

 
55DGR
LQ.RMHNRX-XJRVODYLMLVWU

 

 





55DGRLQ.RMHNRX-XJRVODYLML
MXJRVORYHQVNLVDYUHPHQLFL%HRJUDG

 9/XNL%ULRQVNLSOHQXPVWU


 

          






           

          
        

           


"
           
           




         
         

           






 9*OLL6XVUHWLLUD]JRYRULVWU

 -.HVDU36LPL/HND$OHNVDQGDU5DQNRYLVWU

 

 

20LORVDYOMHYL-XJRVODYLMDMH
ELOD QDD SUYD (YURSD UD]JRYRU VD /DWLQNRP 3HURYL 6QDJD OLQH RGJRYRUQRVWL %HRJUDG
VWU

 9,,,,;,9
9,,,,
9/XNL%ULRQVNLSOHQXPVWU


 


        



        



          
           

"

            

       



             

            






             

        


 ,,,
            
              



 
7RNRYLLVWRULMHVWU


 


           
   33      
           
            


9,,,

         

         
         
           

         

        





       
       
35



        


           
           
          



 -.HVDU36LPL/HND$OHNVDQGDU5DQNRYLVWU
33
 

 
35
 9,,,,;,9
9,,,,


 








    37     

           
          


         
         

           

         
         

         
       

           
           
         



 
37
 


55DGRLQ.RMHNRX-XJRVODYLMLVWU

           

          

             
61XPL'REUD]HPOMRODXGRLVWLQHXEULRQVNRMDIHULSULVOXNLYDQMD%HR
JUDGVWU

 9/XNL%ULRQVNLSOHQXPVWU

 $'XKDHN,VSRYHVWREDYHWDMFD
VWU


 

       




             

          















          
       






 
               


 9/XNL%ULRQVNLSOHQXPVWU

 9/XNL%ULRQVNLSOHQXPVWU

 9LMHVQLNOLVWRSDGVWU

 9/XNL%ULRQVNLSOHQXPVWU

             


          9 /XNL
%ULRQVNLSOHQXPVWU


 


          


            






        

          













         


            
VLF
           


 
$

 9/XNL%ULRQVNLSOHQXPVWU

 

 



 








          




            
         


          
          



53

         


           




 9,,,          



 9,,,,;
,99,,,,

 
53
 

 

9,,,,;,99,,,,



 

         
          








         

          






55


           


            


            



57
          

55
 

9,,,,;,99,,,,

 

57
 9,,,,;,9
9,,,,


 




9,,,





         
           

         
        
          



          













       
        



              
        

 

 9/XNL%ULRQVNLSOHQXPVWU


 












           
          

"

"
       
            
         
          
            

            




          
          
         


 9/XNL%ULRQVNLSOHQXPVWU

 9,,,,;,9
9,,,,

 1HQDGRYL5D]JRYRULVD.RRP

 

 $-


 



 

          
           
        


        


           

          
        

             
"














         



55DGRLQ.RMHNRX-XJRVODYLMLVWU

 9/XNL%ULRQVNLSOHQXPVWU

 9LMHVQLNOLVWRSDGVWU

 9,,,,;,9
9,,,,
$


 'XJD


 



         







          
          

           
          










          
           
           







           


 $'XKDHN,VSRYHVWREDYHWDMFDVWU

 01LNH]LSULUHGLOD/3HURYL6USVNDNUKNDYHUWLNDODVWU


 

         
         
       


         
          
          

            
          
            







         
       

73






           
           


 9*OLL6XVUHWLLUD]JRYRULSULOR]L]DELRJUDMX3HWUD6WDPEROLD%HRJUDGVWU2
0LORVDYOMHYL-XJRVODYLMDMHELODQDDSUYD(YURSDUD]JRYRUVD/DWLQNRP3HURYL6QDJD
OLQHRGJRYRUQRVWL%HRJUDGVWU
73
 


            

,,,


 9*OLL6XVUHWLLUD]JRYRULVWU


 

           
          
         
        

            




75





            
          

















          
            

75
 6QDJDOLQHRGJRYRUQRVWL%HRJUDGVWU

 ,,,9
*OLL6XVUHWLLUD]JRYRULVWU


 


          

          




"
        
          



          




           

77





77
 $1HQDGRYL5D]JRYRULVD.RRPVWU

 

9,,,,;,99,,
,,


 

Summary
0LODQ3LOMDN

7KH%ULRQL3OHQXPRI
$Q$WWHPSWDW+LVWRULRJUDSKLFDO,QWHUSUHWDWLRQRIWKH(YHQW
Key words:7LWRWKH%ULRQL3OHQXP+LVWRULRJUDSK\/&<

%ULRQL 3OHQXP LQ  ZDV RQH RI WKH WXUQLQJ SRLQWV LQ KLVWRU\ RI
FRPPXQLVWLF<XJRVODYLD$OHNVDQGDU5DQNRYLWKHPRVWSRZHUIXOORIFLDODIWHU
-RVLS %UR] ZDV RXVWHG IURP SRZHU LQ DFFXVDWLRQ IRU FRQVLSUDF\ DJDLQVW -RVLS
%UR] WRJHWKHU ZLWK RWKHU  KLJK UDQNLQJ RIFLDOV RI VHUYLFH RI VWDWH VHFXULW\
6'% (YHQ QRZ DOO UHDVRQV RI 5DQNRYLV GRZQIDOO DUH XQNQRZQ 0DLQ
K\SRWKHVLV LV WKDW KH ZDV UHVLVWLQJ WKH UHIRUPV RI GHFHQWUDOL]DWLRQ ZKLFK ZDV
JRLQJLQGLUHFWLRQRIFUHDWLQJWKH<XJROVDYLDDFRQIHGHUDOVWDWH,Q5DQNRYL
KDGEHFRPHYLFHSUHVLGHQWRI<XJRVODYLDDQGPDQ\WKRXJKWWKDWKHZLOOEHWKH
7LWRVVXFFHVVRU:LWK5DQNRYLDVSUHVLGHQWRI<XJRVODYLDLWZRXOGEHKDUGWR
LPDJLQHWKDWFUXFLDOFKDQJHVRIWKHV\VWHPZLOOEHPDGH7KLVZDVXQDFFHSWDEOH
IRU WKH DJHQGD RI 6ORYHQLDQ &URDWLDQ 0DFHGRQLDQ DQG PDMRULW\ RI 6HUELDQ
PHPEHUV RI /&< 5DQNRYLV FORVHQHVV WR %UR] DQG KLV JUHDW LQXHQFH ZHUH
SHUKDSVFUXFLDO7KLVDUWLFOHLVDQHIIRUWWRJLYHDQVZHUDERXWKLVGRZQIDOOLQWKH
DQJOHRIJUHDWGLVDJUHHPHQWVZLWKLQ/&<DQGHIIRUWVRI-RVLS%UR]WRHOLPLQDWH
WKDWJDSE\RXVWLQJ5DQNRYL%XWVWLOOLVQRWGHQLWLYHO\FOHDUZKRZDVWKH
PDVWHUPLQGRIHYHQWV%XWVRPHWKLQJVDUHVXUH%UR]ZDVWKHPDLQJXUHLQKLV
GRZQIDOO:LWKRXWKLVDXWKRULW\QRWKLQJFRXOGEHGRQH7KHVHFRQGLVWKDWZLWKRXW
WKHKHOSRI6HUELDQSDUW\PHPEHUVRQ)HGHUDODQG5HSXEOLFOHYHODOVRQRWKLQJ
FRXOGEHGRQH7KH\VXSSRUWHGUHPRYDORI5DQNRYLLQGHVLUHIRUIXUWKHUVRFLDO
DQG HFRQRPLFDO UHIRUP$OVR WKH DUWLFOH LV SUHWHQGLQJ WR JLYH K\SRWKHVLV WKDW
QRW5DQNRYLEXW-RVLS%UR]ZDVWKHPDLQWDUJHW2XVWLQJ5DQNRYLUHPRYLQJ
RWKHU FHQWUDOLVWV ZRXOG GLVDEOH SRVVLELOLW\ IRU FHQWHU WR UHWXUQ WR WKH ROG 3DUW\
PHDVXUHVIRUVHWWOLQJSUREOHPVLQWKHVWDWH+HEHFDPHREVWDFOHIRUUHIRUPLVWV
EXWDOVRNQHZPXFKDERXWHYHU\RQHVZHHNVSRWVDVIRUPHUKHDGRI6'%(YHQ
PRUHLQWHUHVWLQJLVWKDWKHZDVQHYHUSURVHFXWHGIRUDFFXVDWLRQV%ULRQL3OHQXP
ZDVKHDY\EORZWR<XJRVODY6'%HVSHFLDOO\ZLWKLQRIFLDOVRI6HUELDQRULJLQ
:HDNHQLQJWKHDSSDUDWXVRIUHSUHVVLRQLQGHHGPDGHOLEHUDOL]DWLRQLQVRFLHW\EXW
LWZDVRIVKRUWEUHDWK7KDQNVWRODWWHUGHYHORSPHQWDQGKLVWRULFDOGLVWDQFHQRZ
ZHNQRZWKDWWKHUHZDVQR5DQNRYLVFRQVSLUDF\DQGWKDWKHGLGQWSXWZLUHLQ
7LWRVSULYDWHURRPVDQGWKDWKHZDVQRWPDLQWKUHDWWRUHIRUPVDQGWR%UR]