Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Development of An Experimental Solar-Powered Unmanned Aerial Vehicle
Development of An Experimental Solar-Powered Unmanned Aerial Vehicle
To cite this article: Jaw-Kuen Shiau & Der-Ming Ma (2015) Development of an experimental
solar-powered unmanned aerial vehicle, Journal of the Chinese Institute of Engineers, 38:6,
701-713, DOI: 10.1080/02533839.2015.1018327
Download by: [National University of Sciences & Technology] Date: 28 September 2015, At: 12:36
Journal of the Chinese Institute of Engineers, 2015
Vol. 38, No. 6, 701713, http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/02533839.2015.1018327
This paper summarizes the design of a solar-powered unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV). Two major achievements, aerody-
Downloaded by [National University of Sciences & Technology] at 12:36 28 September 2015
namic performance design of a solar-powered aircraft and its solar power management system design, are presented. For
aerodynamic performance design, the mass of the aircraft is parameterized as a function of two performance parameters:
wing reference area and cruise speed. With the parameterization results, a tness function that links the optimization
problem and the genetic algorithm is established. The genetic algorithm searches for the optimal results for minimum
energy operation. A solar-powered UAV is then built based on the optimization results. A solar power management
system is designed to obtain electric energy from the solar system to support the required power for the aircraft propul-
sion system and on-board electronic systems. The system includes solar cell panels, maximum power point tracker, and
power conversion. An auto-ranging non-inverting synchronous buck-boost dc-to-dc power converter is designed to
perform the maximum power point tracking, power conversion, and battery charging functions. The proposed design
methodologies for solar-powered UAV and solar power management system are veried through successful ground and
ight test. This is the Taiwans rst ever solar-powered UAV.
Keywords: solar-powered UAV; mass parameterization; solar power management system; buck-boost power converter
consideration, panel is the efciency of the energy not consider ying the airplane at night. Thus, we set
conversion of the solar cells. Solar cell panels with Tdusk = 0 and Tnight 0. For safety, an Li-ion battery is
panel = 0.20 are adopted in this design. Thus, the carried on-board as a backup power source for when the
supplied power can be rewritten as: solar power is insufcient to support the aircraft
operation. The parameter Tday_battery is used to account
Psupplied 97:5Sref ; (9)
for the time required for the battery to power the aircraft
Equation (9) indicates that the expected power supplied and is assumed to be 0.5 h. The factor of the depth-
from the solar panel also depends on the referenced of-discharge fDOD = 0.8 and efciency of the battery
surface area Sref. discharge discharge = 0.95 are also assumed. Thus, the
required battery can be expressed as:
The weight of the airplane can be counted by adding up Thus, the mass of the battery is:
the weight of all subsystems including structure, propul-
Mbattery 4:3367 105 Sref v3 0:0084; (16)
sion system, solar cell panel, batteries, and payloads. In
this optimization process, we will limit the decision vari- The mass of the payload is limited to Mpayload 0:7 kg
ables to cruise speed (v) and reference wing areas (Sref ) for this design. Therefore, the total mass of the airplane,
by nding a means to represent the aircraft weight in Mtotal = Mstructure + Mbattery + Mthrust + Mpanel + Mpayload
terms of v and Sref. The parameterizations of the mass of is
YueZhuo airplane are discussed below.
Mtotal 2:4003Sref 4:3367 105 Sref v3
The mass for the unit area of the selected solar cell
5:1084: (17)
panel is 1:1 kg/m2 in this design. Thus, the mass of the
solar cell panel, Mpanel, is In Equation (17), the total mass of the airplane is
Mpanel 1:1 0:65 Sref 0:715 Sref ; (10) expressed as a function of the reference wing area Sref
and the cruise speed v.
The mass of the structure, Mstructure, is computed from For minimum power operation, the constraints of
the wet area and the unit mass of the structure. The unit Equation (1) must be satised. With total mass of the
mass of the structure is 0:6 kg/m2 for this particular airplane being parameterized as Equation (17), the opti-
design. Then, mization process is to search for an optimal solution pair
Mstructure 1:2 Sref 4:4; (11) (Sref, Vopt) that satises Equations (1) and (17) under the
conditions of the lift force being equal to the weight of
where 4.4 is the mass of fuselage and other xed parts. the airplane and the supplied power from the solar power
The mass of the propulsion system is proportional to the panel being higher than the total consumed power. From
referenced wing area. The corresponding unit mass of the above discussions, the following optimization prob-
the propulsion system is 0:485 kg/m2 (Ma 2005) in this lem is formulated to nd the optimal solution for the
design. Thus, the mass of the propulsion system is: minimum power operation.
Optimization problem: Find a referenced wing area
Mthrust Sref 0:485 kg/m2 ; (12)
Sref and a cruise speed v to minimize the objective
The mass of the battery, Mbattery is: function
J Sref ; v w1 jL=g
Mtotal j w2 v Vopt
Ebattery
Mbattery ; (13)
qbattery
w3 Psupplied Prequired (18)
where battery is the energy density of the battery and subject to
Ebattery is the required battery energy. The energy density
2 q1 v Sref CL Mtotal g 0
1 2
of the battery battery is assumed to be 196 Wh/kg in this
study. The required battery energy is: v Vopt 0 (19)
Psupplied Prequired 0;
0:5Tdusk Tnight Tday battery Ppropulsion Pothers
Ebattery ; where Vopt, Prequired, Psupplied, and Mtotal are dened in
fDOD gdischarge
Equations (1), (6), (8), and (17), respectively.
(14)
The YueZhuo airplane is designed to y at a cruise
The constants Tdusk and Tnight represent the duration the altitude of 100 m. Hence, the air density and gravita-
battery has to power the aircraft, fDOD and discharge tional constant g are set to 1.214 kg/m3 and 9.8 m/s2 ,
are the depth-of-discharge and discharge efciency of the respectively. The constants w1, w2, and w3 are positive
battery, respectively. In this development process, we do weighting factors imposed to balance the numerical
704 J.-K. Shiau and D.-M. Ma
signicance of the physical variables contributing to the shown in Figure 1, the tness value converges to an
objective function J(Sref, v). In this optimization problem, acceptable result rapidly.
a difference of 1 or 2 (watts) between the supplied and The following results are obtained after the comple-
required power is considered acceptable. But, a differ- tion of the optimization search routine. The referenced
ence of 1 or 2 (m/s) between the cruise speed and the wing surface area Sref is 1:12 m2 , the cruise speed v is
optimal cruise speed is signicant and not acceptable 13:98m/s, the tness function is found to be J(Sref, v)
due to the fact that the energy consumption is propor- = 0.1625. That is, the reference area Sref 1:12 m2 and
tional to the cube of the speed. Similarly, the difference cruise speed v 13:98 m/s are the optimal solution for
between the lift and the weight must be within an the minimum power operation for YueZhuo aircraft.
acceptable region. After several evaluations, Under this condition, the required supply power is
w1 ; w2 ; w3 10; 60; 1 is selected for the optimiza- Prequired = 109.12 W. Using these design results, the
tion process in this design. We will obtain the optimal YueZhuo airplane is built, a picture of the airplane is
Downloaded by [National University of Sciences & Technology] at 12:36 28 September 2015
value of the referenced wing surface area Sref and cruise shown in Figure 2. Table 1 lists the specications of
speed v when the objective function J(Sref, v) is mini- YueZhuo.
mized. The MATLAB genetic algorithm and direct
search toolbox is used to nd the optimal solution. The
objective function Equation (18) serves as the tness 4. Solar power management system
function for the genetic algorithm and links the optimiza- Besides the aerodynamic conguration design, another
tion problem with the genetic algorithm. We map the key challenge for the design of a solar-powered aircraft
decision variables (wing area and cruise speed) into is the design of an efcient and reliable solar power
chromosome-like binary strings. Two sets of chromo- management system. The purpose of the solar power
somes (one for cruise speed v and another for referenced management system is to obtain electric energy from the
wing area Sref ) for the initial population are randomly solar system to support the required power for the air-
generated. Each set contains 100 chromosomes. Each craft propulsion system and on-board electronic systems.
chromosome is represented by a 10-bit binary string. A typical solar power management system mainly
Genetic operators (crossover, mutation) are performed on includes solar cell panels, maximum power point tracker,
a population of such binary string for a series of solution power conversion, battery management, and battery mod-
evolutions. The search process stops and returns the opti- ules. The major functions of the power management sys-
mal solution when one of the following conditions is sat- tem are to provide the required power for the propulsion
ised: (1) The number of generations reaches 200. (2) and avionics systems and monitor the health and the
The tness measure J(Sref, v) is reached. (3) The availability of the power source. The maximum power
weighted average changes in the tness function over point tracker attempts to obtain the maximum power
100 generations are less than a specied tolerance. (4) available from the solar cell panels. The battery manage-
There is no improvement in the tness function for over ment system monitors and controls the energy storage
50 s. Figure 1 shows the results of the evolution and and delivery of the solar power drawn from the solar cell
convergence of the tness function in GA process. As panel. The power conversion unit provides a reliable
power source for the propulsion system.
In this research, we use monocrystalline solar cells as
the power source. To accommodate the aircraft
voltage divider. The voltage Vosense at the output, the auto-ranging buck-boost power converter is shown in
obtained from output voltage Vout through the voltage Figure 6. The buck-boost converter is successfully used
divider, is regulated to 0.8 V in the LTC3780 controller for the maximum power point tracking, Li-ion battery
as shown in Figure 4. Thus, the output voltage is charging, and voltage regulation for the propulsion sys-
regulated to: tem on the YueZhuo aircraft.
The major systems required to support the operation
R1
Vout 0:8 1 (Volts) (20) of the YueZhuo aircraft are shown in Figure 7. They
R2 mainly include the solar power management system, avi-
onics and control systems, and ground station. To ensure
To provide the auto-ranging capability, a peripheral inter- ight safety, a hybrid power system is designed for the
face controller microcontroller-based control unit is YueZhuo aircraft. As shown in Figure 7, the power con-
design to automatically control the voltage at the output verter is regulated at 26 V for the propulsion system,
terminal or current delivered to the load for specic pur- while the backup Li-ion battery will supply 25.2 V when
pose such as maximum power point tracking or battery fully charged. If the power from the solar panels is suf-
charging. The schematic of the auto-ranging power con- cient for ight operation, the output of the converter will
verter is depicted in Figure 5. As shown in Figure 5, the be well regulated at 26 V which will inhibit power from
output voltage is controlled through controlling the resis- the battery. On the other hand, if the power from the
tance ratio of the output voltage divider. An image of solar panel is insufcient for ight operation (especially
during takeoff or high dynamic maneuvers), the power measurement unit (IMU) board, a UAV control board, and
converter will not be able to hold the output voltage at a GPS receiver. The UAV control board contains a high-
26 V. The battery will supply power to the aircraft. At performance ATmega1280 microcontroller. The IMU
the instance of battery supplying power to the aircraft, board contains a three-axis gyroscope, a three-axis acceler-
the load for the power converter is reduced which leads ometer, an absolute pressure sensor, and a temperature
to an increase of the output voltage. A balance of the sensor. The power required for the avionics and control
power from power converter and the Li-ion battery will systems are from the electric speed controller which
be reached eventually. obtains power from the solar power management system.
The avionics and control system on the Yuezhou air- The Ardupilot UAV control board collects the aircraft atti-
craft is an Arduino-based Ardupilot system from DIYDro- tude, airspeed, and GPS information and transmits them to
nes Inc. The system mainly contains an inertial the ground station through Xbee wireless communication.
708 J.-K. Shiau and D.-M. Ma
Item Mass (kg) Distance to quarter chord (m) Moment (Nt-m) Moment of inertia (kg-m2)
Wing 4.400 0.09 3.885 0.004
Tail 1.100 0.83 8.957 0.652
Main gear 0.700 0.34 2.335 0.055
Nose gear 0.742 0.645 4.690 0.369
Motor 0.610 0.787 4.704 0.438
Fuselage 1.500 0.03 0.441 0.012
Total 9.052 0.060 5.322 1.530
5. Preight and ight test environment and to verify that these characteristics are
Downloaded by [National University of Sciences & Technology] at 12:36 28 September 2015
Preight testing is critical to the success of any ight test as desired. Proper preight testing helps ensure that the
program. Preight tests are performed to measure and UAV is ready to y and contributes toward an efcient,
evaluate the characteristics of a UAV in a non-ying productive, and safe ight test program. There are sev-
eral parts of preight testing, such as wind tunnel tests,
simulation tests, propulsion tests, weight and balance
tests, ground vibration tests, structural loads tests, gain
margin tests, verication and calibration tests, and taxi
tests, that are usually accomplished prior to ying a new
or highly modied aircraft (Stoliker 2005). In the
YueZhuo program, only the weight and balance tests,
propulsion tests, and taxi tests were accomplished before
ight. The following paragraphs describe the tests.
Figure 9. The installed engine ground test. Figure 11. The taxi test.
Journal of the Chinese Institute of Engineers 709
Figure 12. Image of the YueZhuo aircraft in the air. all individual components. The neutral point of YueZhuo
is located after the wing quarter chord line by 0.109 m characteristics. These tests are usually the last ground
and the static margin is 12.58%. To measure the center of tests done prior to ight. They provide nal verication
gravity, two students stand by the sides of the UAV and that the UAV, with all systems fully operational, is ready
lift it as shown in Figure 8. When the balance is achieved for rst ight. Figure 11 shows the taxi test which took
the center of gravity is determined. at the sport track of Tamkang University, on 17 August
2012.
idle to maximum thrust (Figure 9). The propulsion is Figure 7, an XBee transmitter (Xbee B) on the upper
powered by the hybrid power supply as shown in left is used to transmit the output voltage of the power
Figure 7. In the propulsion test, the power is controlled converter. Another XBee transmitter (Xbee A) on the
to gradually increase from idle to 100%. After that the lower right is used to transmit the data from Ardupilot
power setting is gradually decreased back to idle condi- Mega, which include the data of GPS, IMU, and Air
tion. Test results are shown in Figure 10. When the speed packages. Unfortunately, there are no data
power setting is low, the voltage from the solar power received from Xbee B and the data from Xbee A are
management system is 26 V as expected. When the only part of takeoff, and a small portion of the cruise
power setting is increased to a point that the solar power before landing, and the landing. Although no data were
is insufcient to support the need, the battery starts to available for verifying the power converter, the charac-
deliver power to the propulsion system. As indicated in teristic of solar power management system was still
Figure 10, voltage balance is reached when the solar veried, since the Li-ion battery itself can only supply
power and the battery both power the propulsion system. sufcient power for ight for 10 min. Figure 12 is an
When the power setting reduces to a point that the solar image of the YueZhuo aircraft in the air. Figures 1315
power is capable of supporting the operation of the are the takeoff and landing trajectories which are estab-
engine alone, the output voltage from the solar power lished from the telemetry data. Figures 16 and 17
system will rise to 26 V again and stop power delivery are the airspeed and altitude histories for the portions
from the battery. of cruise before landing and landing, the abscissa axis
is the number of data-sets since no time tag was
transmitted. Referring to the gures, the average cruise
5.3. Taxi tests altitude is about 50 m and the average airspeed
Taxi tests are conducted primarily to verify the landing during cruise is 10 m/s, and 14 m/s is the maximum
gear shimmy characteristics, and ground handling airspeed.
Spanel solar cell panel area (m2) Vehicles. Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace Technology
Mpanel the mass of the solar cell panel (kg) 78 (3): 187193. doi: 10.1108/17488840610663648.
Mstructure the mass of the structure (kg) Boucher, R. J. 1984. History of Solar Flight. In Proceedings
of AIAA/SAE/ASME 20th Joint Propulsion Conference
Mthrust the mass of the propulsion system (kg)
AIAA-84-1429, Cincinnati, OH, 1113 June 1984: 113.
Mbattery the mass of the battery (kg) New York: AIAA.
Mpayload the mass of the payload (kg) Boucher, R. J. 1985. Sunrise, the Worlds First Solar-powered
Mtotal the total mass of the Xihe airplane (kg) Airplane. Journal of Aircraft 22 (10): 840846.
Ebattery required battery energy (Wh) doi:10.2514/3.45213.
battery energy density of the battery (Wh/kg) Brandt, S. A., and F. T. Gilliam. 1995. Design Analysis Meth-
Esun average irradiance of solar radiation energy odology for Solar-powered Aircraft. Journal of Aircraft 32
(W/m2) (4): 703709. doi:10.2514/3.46780.
Ppropulsion power consumption of the propulsion (W) Giannakoglou, K. C. 2002. Design of Optimal Aerodynamic
Pothers power required for other systems (W) Shapes using Stochastic Optimization Methods and Com-
Psupplied power supplied from the solar power panel putational Intelligence. Progress in Aerospace Sciences 38
(1): 4376. doi:10.1016/S0376-0421(01)00019-7.
(W)
Goldberg, D. E. 1989. Genetic Algorithms in Search, Optimiza-
Prequired total required power to support airplane tion and Machine Learning. Boston, MA: Addison-Wesley.
operation (W) Gonzalez, L. F., L. Damp, and K. Srinivas. 2007. Aero-struc-
Pcharge power required to charge the battery (W) tural Optimization of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles Using A
Tnight duration for ight without sunlight (h) Multi-objective Evolutionary Algorithm. In Proceedings of
Tdusk duration of dusk time (h) 2nd Australian Unmanned Air Vehicle System Conference,
Tdaytime duration of daytime (h) Melbourne, 1922 March 2006.
fDOD depth-of-discharge of the battery Hall, D. W., C. D. Fortenbach, E. V. Dimiceli, and R. W.
fsafety safety factor Parks. 1983. A Preliminary Study of Solar Powered Air-
panel efciency of the energy conversion of the craft and Associated Power Trains. Washington, DC:
solar cells National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Scientic
and Technical Information Branch.
charge charge efciency of the battery
Hall, D. W., and S. A. Hall. 1984. Structural Sizing of a Solar
discharge discharge efciency of the battery Powered Aircraft. Washington, DC: National Aeronautics
motor motor efciency and Space Administration, Langley Research Center.
propeller efciency of the propeller Holland, J. H. 1992. Adaptation in Natural and Articial Sys-
converter efciency of the power converters tems: An Introductory Analysis with Applications to Biol-
w1, w2, w3 weight factors for the optimization problem ogy, Control and Articial Intelligence. Cambridge, MA:
R1, R2 resistors for the voltage divider () MIT Press.
Vout output voltage of the buck-boost converter Hwang, W. J., C. M. Ou, C. C. Hsu, and T. Y. Lo. 2005. Iter-
(V) ative Optimization for Joint Design of Source and Channel
Codes using Genetic Algorithms. Journal of the Chinese
Institute of Engineers 28 (5): 803810. doi:10.1080/
Acknowledgments 02533839.2005.9671050.
This work was partially supported by the National Science Lee, Z. J., S. F. Su, and C. Y. Lee. 2002. A Genetic
Council, Taiwan, Republic of China, under Grant NSC100- Algorithm with Domain Knowledge for Weapontarget
2221-E-032-061, and partially supported by an in-house Assignment Problems. Journal of the Chinese Institute of
research project from Tamkang University, Taiwan. The authors Engineers 25 (3): 287295. doi:10.1080/02533839.
thank graduate students at Avionics and Flight Simulation Lab., 2002.9670703.
Department of Aerospace Engineering, for their help with fabri- Ma, D. M. 2005. UAV Design Hand Book. New Taipei City:
cation and testing of the UAV. Tamkang University.
Journal of the Chinese Institute of Engineers 713
Maccready, P. B., P. B. S. Lissaman, W. R. Morgan, and J. D. NASA Dryden Fact Sheet. 1998. Solar Power Research and
Burke. 1983. Sun-powered Aircraft Designs. Journal of Dryden. NASA Dryden Flight Research Center, FS-1998-
Aircraft 20 (6): 487493. doi:10.2514/3.44898. 10-0054 DFRC.
Miralbes, R., and L. Castejon. 2012. Structural Design and Noth, A. 2008. Design of Solar Powered Airplane for Contin-
Optimization Using Neural Networks and Genetic Algo- uous Flight. PhD dissertation, Swiss Federal Institute of
rithms of a Tanker Vehicle. Journal of the Chinese Insti- Technology Zurich.
tute of Engineers 35 (2): 181192. doi:10.1080/ Park, K., J. W. Han, H. J. Lim, B. S. Kim, and J. Lee. 2008.
02533839.2012.638516. Optimal Design of Airfoil with High Aspect Ratio in
Nagasaki, S., S. I. Higashino, and A. Sakurai. 2005. Auto- Unmanned Aerial Vehicles. International Journal of
matic Generation of UAV Conguration by Using Evolu- Mechanical Systems Science and Engineering 2 (4): 177183.
tionary Algorithm. In AIAA 2005-7080, Shiau, J.-K., D. M. Ma, C. W. Chiu, and J. R. Shie. 2010.
Infotech@Aerospace, Arlington, VA, 2629 September Optimal Sizing and Cruise Speed Determination for a
2005: 15. New York: AIAA. Solar-powered Airplane. Journal of Aircraft 47 (2):
Downloaded by [National University of Sciences & Technology] at 12:36 28 September 2015