Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Baird Actionresearch
Baird Actionresearch
TimelyTransitionsGame
AndreaBaird
EDI685
Baird1
Myresearchfocusesonasecondgradeclassroominasmallelementaryschoolthatis
partofalargeinnercityschooldistrict.Ihavenoticedthatthestudentsinthissecondgrade
classroomhavebeenstrugglingwithtransitionsallyear.Thisincludescominginfromrecess,
switchingbetweenactivities,liningupduringtheday,gettingreadyforlunch,andgettingready
fortheendoftheday.Thestudentstakealongtimetosettlebackinandgettowork.
AsIbeganmyresearch,Idiscoveredthatalotofdifferentstrategiesandideashavebeen
usedtotrytoimprovethiscommonissue.Thereisalotofresearchtosuggestthatstudents
spendasubstantialamountoftimetransitioningbetweenclassroomactivities,whichmayreduce
timespentacademicallyengaged(Hineet.al495).Oneofthestrategiestofixthisproblemthat
IfoundintriguingwastheTimelyTransitionsGame,atermcoinedbyCampbellandSkinner
(2004).Theseresearcherslookedattransitionswithinasixthgradeclassroom.Theydecidedto
makeitagameforthestudentsbyusingastopwatchfortransitions,andwritingthetimesonthe
board.Thentheyrandomlypickedacardfromaboxthathaddifferenttimesonthem,andifthe
studentshadtransitionedwithinthetime,theyearnedapointtowardsaclassroomreward.Their
resultsshowedasignificantdecreaseintransitiontimes(CampbellandSkinner2004).
Afterlearningaboutthistransitionsgame,Ilookedfurtherintoitandfoundthatanother
groupofresearchershadimplementedthegameintoasecondgradeclassroom.Yarbroughet.al
(2004)implementedtheTimelyTransitionsGameinasecondgradeclassroom,targetingjustthe
transitionafterlunch,whichtheclassroomteacherhadsaidwasthemostdifficultforher
students.Theresearchersmadesuretodosomeobservationsofthistransitionbefore
implementingthegame.TheyalsowentfurtherthanCampbellandSkinnerbyusinganABA
sortofmodeltheyimplementedthegame,thentookitaway,andthenimplementeditagainto
Baird2
seewhatchangesmighthappen.TheydiscoveredthattheTimelyTransitionsGamedidindeed
producelowertransitiontimesforthetransitionafterlunch.Thestudentswereeagertoearn
rewardstowardsclassroomgoals,whichincludedthingslikewatchingamovie,eatingpopcorn,
orreceivingcandy(Yarbroughet.al2004).
Ilikedtheideaoffocusingononetransition,anddecidedthatthetransitionafterlunch
wasalsoonethatmyclassstruggledwiththemost.Iplannedtotakeobservationsthefirstweek,
timingthetransitionsecretly,andthenIwouldimplementthegameduringthesecondandthird
weeks.ImadeaTimelyTransitionsbag,inwhichIputtimecardsrangingfrom40secondsto
1minuteand20seconds(seeAppendixA).Iusedthisrangeoftimesbasedbothuponmy
observationsduringthefirstweek,aswellasYarbroughsresearch(2004).
WhenIbeganimplementingmyplan,Idiscoveredduringthatfirstweekwithoutthe
gamethatittooktheclassabouttwominutesonaveragetosettledownafterlunch.Wealways
havethesameroutineafterlunchthestudentscomeinafterrecessandsitatthecarpettoshare
theirwriteandtells.Atthebeginningofthesecondweek,Iintroducedthegametomy
students,showingthemthebagandexplaininghowitwouldwork.Ishowedthemthestopwatch
Iwouldbeusing,andexplainedthatwewouldbeearningletterstowardtheclassroomrewardof
candyeachtimewetransitionedwithinthetimeofthecardchosen.Whenthetransitiontime
came,ImadesurethatIwasoutsidetheclassroomwiththestudentsshowingthemthe
stopwatch,lettingthemknowIwouldstartitassoonasthefirstpersonwalkedintothe
classroom.Aftertheywereallsittingquietlyatthecarpet,Iwouldstopthetimeandwriteiton
theboard.ThenattheendofthedayIwoulddrawacardfromthebagtoseeifwehadearned
ourletterthatday.
Baird3
Ittooktheclasseightdaysoverthetwoweekstoearnthefiveletterstospellout
candy.Therewasonedayeachweekwherewedidnotimplementthegame,oncewhenIwas
goneandoncewhenwehadafieldtrip.Myfindingssuggestthatthegamedoesindeeddecrease
thetransitiontime,althoughnotquiteasdrasticallyasitdidinYarbroughsresearch(2004).In
AppendixB,Iincludedapictureofthetimesthatwererecordedontheboardduringthetwo
weeksthatweplayed.Ourfirstrecordedtimewas1minute19seconds,whichdidnotearnthe
classaletter.Thetimesdecreasedoverthenexttwodays,thenincreasedslightly,andthenover
thecourseofthelastfivedaystherewasaconsistentdecrease.Ourlastrecordedtimethatearned
ourlastletterwas39seconds.
Thedifficultpartofdoingawholeclassroomrewardsystemisthatonsomedays,there
werejustacouplestudentswhodidnotseemtocareandendedupmakingthetimelongerthanit
shouldhavebeen.However,myobservationsoverthecourseofthetwoweeksshowedthatthe
gamewasintriguingtothemajorityofthestudentsintheclass.Almosteverytimeattheendof
thedaywhenitwastimetodrawthecard,astudentremindedmethatwehadntdrawnoneyet.
Eachdaytherewerestudentscominguptomeaskingmeifweweredoingthegamethatday.
AndwhenIwasoutinthehallwiththestopwatch,thestudentswouldgetreallyexcitedand
husheachother.Afterweearnedthecandy,Ialsohadseveralstudentsaskwhenweweregoing
toplaytheTimelyTransitionsgameagain.
Furtherresearchisneededtoprovidemoreevidenceofthepositiveresultsofthis
TimelyTransitionsGame.Itwouldbeinterestingtoseeawholeschoolimplementthegame,
inordertoseehowdifferentgradelevelswouldreacttothegame.Itisalsoimportanttotarget
differenttransitionsaswellanothertransitionthatmyclassstruggledwithisliningup,during
Baird4
whichaTimelyTransitionsgamecouldbeimplemented.Itwoulddefinitelybebeneficialto
collectmoredataregardingthisgameindifferentclassroomenvironmentsandusingdifferent
kindsoftransitions.
Baird5
WorksCited
Campbell,S.,&Skinner,C.H.(2004).Combiningexplicittimingwithaninterdependentgroup
contingencyprogramtodecreasetransitiontimes:Aninvestigationofthetimely
transitionsgame.JournalofAppliedPsychology,20(2),1127.
Hine,J.F.,Ardoin,S.P.,&Foster,T.E.(2015).DECREASINGTRANSITIONTIMESIN
ELEMENTARYSCHOOLCLASSROOMS:USINGCOMPUTERASSISTED
INSTRUCTIONTOAUTOMATEINTERVENTIONCOMPONENTS.Journalof
AppliedBehaviorAnalysis,48(3),495510.
doi:http://dx.doi.org.ezproxy.gvsu.edu/10.1002/jaba.233
Yarbrough,J.L.,Skinner,C.H.,Lee,Y.J.,&Lemmons,C.(2004).Decreasingtransitiontimes
inasecondgradeclassroom:ScientificsupportfortheTimelyTransitionsGame.Journal
ofAppliedSchoolPsychology,20,85107.doi:10.1300/J370v20n02_06
Baird6
AppendixA:
AppendixB: