CIVIL PROCEDURE

Case Outline - Rule 6-10

Atty. Melissa Romana P. Suarez

Rule 6
Repor Back
Section Case Title ter up GR # Date
Sec. 2, 3
1190
Zaida Alberto v. CA 33 15 88 30-Jun-00
1596
Flour Daniel v. EB Villarosa 34 16 48 27-Jul-07
1544
Bank of Commerce v. Planters Bank 35 17 70 17-Sep-12

Sec. 5
1118
Tropical Homes v. CA 36 18 58 14-May-07
1465
Lucia Miranda v. Esperanza Besa 1 19 13 30-Jul-04

Sec. 6
1538
Mel Velarde v. Lopez 2 20 86 14-Jan-04
1242
UST v. CA 3 21 50 18-Oct-04

Sec. 7
1018
Spouses Meliton v. CA 4 22 83 11-Dec-92
1316
Felipe Yulienco v. CA 5 23 92 10-Jun-99
1331
Financial Building v. Forbes Park 6 24 19 17-Aug-00
1388
Evangeline Alday v. FGU Insurance 7 25 22 23-Jan-01
1465
Tan v. Kaakbay Finance 8 26 95 20-Jun-03
1551
Lafarge v. CCC 9 27 73 23-Nov-04
Korea Exchange Bank v. Judge 1422
Gonzales 10 28 86 15-Apr-05

1
Sec. 8
1015
Florencio Ruiz v. CA 11 29 66 17-Aug-92
1276
Ligon v. CA 12 30 83 7-Aug-98
1510
Petron v. Spouses Cudilla 13 31 38 18-Jan-12

Sec. 11
L-
5396
Samala v. Victor 15 32 9 21-Feb-89
1238
Allied Bank v. CA 16 33 71 31-Aug-98
1218
British Airways v. CA 17 34 24 29-Jan-98
1627
Erasmo Tayao v. Rosa Mendoza 18 35 33 12-Apr-05
1602
ACDC v. CA 19 36 42 17-May-05
1639
CDCP v. Cuenca 20 1 81 12-Aug-05
1526
Sarmiento v. CA 21 2 27 16-Sep-05
1619
Philtranco v. Paras 22 3 09 25-Apr-12

Sec. 12
1551
Lafarge v. CCC 23 4 73 23-Nov-04
1544
Bank of Commerce v. Planters Bank 24 5 70 17-Sep-12

Rule 7
Citati
Section Case Title on GR # Date
Sec. 2
1850
PCIC v. PNCC 25 6 66 2-Oct-09

2
 Sec. 3
1581
Buklaran v. CA 26 7 58 17-Jan-05
1723
Dadizon v. Bernadas 27 8 67 5-Jun-09
1628
Jocson v. CA 28 9 36 30-Jul-09
1525
SOPA v. Santos 29 10 79 4-Aug-09
1939
Galicto v. B.S. Aquino 30 11 78 28-Feb-12

Sec. 4
Verification
1350
Robern v. Judge Jesus Quitain 31 12 42 23-Sep-99
1496
Torres v. Specialized 32 13 34 6-Jul-04
1519
Christine Chua v. Jorge Torres 33 15 00 30-Aug-05
Rolando Clavecilla v. Spouses 1479
Quitain 34 16 89 20-Feb-06
1637
Fernando Go v. CA 35 17 45 24-Aug-07
1699
Marohomsalic v. Cole 36 18 18 27-Feb-08
1558
Tible & Tible v. Royal 1 19 06 8-Apr-08
1818
Hipol v. NLRC 2 20 18 18-Dec-08
1798
Negros Planters v. Presiding Judge 3 21 78 24-Dec-08
1755
Vallacar Transit v. Catubig 4 22 12 30-May-11
1657
Pagadora v. Ilao 5 23 69 12-Dec-11
1820
Vicencio v. Villar 6 24 69 3-Jul-12

Sec. 5
1361
None Uy v. Land Bank 7 25 00 4-Jul-00
1332
Ponciano v. Judge Parantela 8 26 84 9-May-00
Arquiza v. CA 9 27 1604 8-Jun-05

3
 79
1656
Eastland v. Mortel 10 28 48 23-Mar-06
1810
Mandaue v. Isidto 11 29 51 5-Jul-10

Citati
Section Case Title on GR # Date
Sec. 5
Defective
1312
BA Savings Bank v. Roger Sia 12 30 14 27-Jul-00
1276
BPI Leasing Corp. v. CA 13 31 24 18-Nov-03
1496
Torres v. Specialized 15 32 34 6-Jul-04
1523
Expert Travel v. CA and KAL 16 33 92 26-May-05
1447
Spouses Estares v. CA 17 34 55 8-Jun-05
1329
Levi Strauss v. Vogue Traders 18 35 93 29-Jun-05
1604
Daniel Aninao v. Asturias Chemicals 19 36 20 28-Jul-05
1634
Concepcion Ancheta v. Metrobank 20 1 10 16-Sep-05
1430
PAL v. FASAP 21 2 88 26-Jan-06
1599
Shangr-la v. DGC 22 3 38 31-Mar-06
1408
Wilson and Peter Go v. Rico 23 4 62 25-Apr-06
1670
Panfilo Abaigar v. Jesus Abaigar 24 5 03 23-Oct-06
1750
RBA v. Salvaa 25 6 20 4-Oct-07
1499
Teresa Gabriel v. CA 26 7 09 11-Oct-07
1594
Chinese YMCA v. Remington Steel 27 8 22 28-Mar-08
1809
Altres v. Empleo 28 9 86 10-Dec-08
1613
Mediserve v. CA 29 10 68 5-Apr-10

4
 1618
RP v. Coalbrine 30 11 38 7-Apr-10

1647
Cebu Metro v. Euro-Med 31 12 57 18-Oct-10
1547
Vda. De Formoso v. PNB 32 13 04 1-Jun-11
Atty. Bautista v. Judge Causapin 33 15 Jul-44 22-Jun-11
1867
Medado v. Heirs of Consing 34 16 20 8-Feb-12
1939
Galicto v. B.S. Aquino 35 17 78 28-Feb-12
1794
Cosco v. Kemper 36 18 88 23-Apr-12

Sec. 5
1382
FALSE Cladius Barroso v. Judge Ampig 1 19 18 17-Mar-00
1286
Espinosa v. CA 2 20 86 28-May-04
1507
RMC v. Siesenando Singson 3 21 98 31-Mar-05

Sec. 5
Forum
Shopping
1293
Tirona v. Judge Alejo 4 22 13 10-Oct-01
1543
Land Car v. Bachelor Express 5 23 77 8-Dec-03
1589
Evelyn Paradero v. Judge Abragan 6 24 17 1-Mar-04
1111
Nordic Asia v. CA 7 25 59 13-Jul-04
1528
Reyes de Leon v. Del Rosario 8 26 62 26-Jul-04
1595
HSBC v. Cecilia Diez Catalan 9 27 90 18-Oct-04
Guaranteed Hotels v. Josefina 1643
Baltao 10 28 38 17-Jan-05
1422
Korean Exchange Bank v. Gonzales 11 29 86 15-Apr-05
1329
Levi Strauss v. Vogue Traders 12 30 93 29-Jun-05
Spouses de la Cruz v. Pedro Joaquin 13 31 1627 28-Jul-05

5
 88
1531
Manuel Laxina v. Ombudsman 15 32 55 30-Sep-05
Amando San Juan v. Miguel 1432
Arambulo 16 33 17 14-Dec-05
1401
Angel and Maritoni Sadang v. CA 17 34 38 11-Oct-06
1382
Spouses Cruz v. Spouses Caraos 18 35 08 23-Apr-07
1780
Wacnang v. Comelec 19 36 24 17-Oct-08
1742
St. Mary of the Woods v. ROD 20 1 90 20-Jan-09
1525
SOPA v. Santos 21 2 79 4-Aug-09
1677
Phil Pharma Wealth v. Pfizer 22 3 15 17-Nov-10
1867
Medado v. Heirs of Consing 23 4 20 8-Feb-12

Rule 8
Citati
Topic Case Title on GR Date
Sec. 1
1494
Marie Jao v. China Banking 24 5 68 23-Oct-06
1907
Lucas v. Lucas 25 6 10 6-Jun-11

Sec. 4
1602
Soriente v. Estate of Concepcion 26 7 39 25-Nov-09

1663
Sec. 5 Associated Bank v. Montano 27 8 83 16-Oct-09
1588
Luistro v. CA 28 9 19 16-Apr-09

1519
Sec. 7 Tiu v. PB Com 29 10 32 19-Aug-09
1741
Eastern Shipping v. Prudential 30 11 16 11-Sep-09

6
 2008
Ledda v. BPI 31 12 68 21-Nov-12

1198
Sec. 8 Filtex & Villanueva v. CA 32 13 00 12-Nov-03
1406
Permanent Savings v. Velarde 33 15 08 23-Sep-04
1695
Titan Construction v. David 34 16 48 15-Mar-10
1801
Equitable Card v. Capistrano 35 17 57 8-Feb-12
1713
Cua v. Wallem 36 18 37 11-Jul-12

1521
Sec. 10 Teraa v. De Sagun 1 19 31 29-Apr-09
1755
PBCOM v. Spouses Go 2 20 14 14-Feb-11
1668
RP v. SB 3 21 59 12-Apr-11

1730
Sec. 11 Union Bank v. Spouses Tiu 4 22 90 7-Sep-11

Rule 9
Citati
Topic Case Title on GR Date
Sec. 1
1432
Villanueva v. CA 5 23 86 14-Apr-04
1511
Katon v. Palanca 6 24 49 7-Sep-04
1535
Aquino v. Aure 7 25 67 18-Feb-08
1524
Anunciacion v. Bocanegra 8 26 96 30-Jul-09
1575
Toshiba v. CIR 9 27 94 5-Mar-10

Sec. 2
1331
Financial v. Forbes Park 10 28 19 17-Aug-00

7
 1528
Reyes-De Leon v. Del Rosario 11 29 62 26-Jul-04
1794
Loadmaster v. Glodel 12 30 46 20-Jan-11

Sec. 3
1358
Diaz v. Diaz 13 31 85 28-Apr-00
1170
Viron v. Pantranco 15 32 20 4-Apr-03
1527
Oaminal v. Castillo 16 33 76 8-Oct-03
1415
Cerezo v. Tuazon 17 34 38 23-Mar-04
1596
Acance v. CA 18 35 99 16-Mar-05
1445
Sablas v. Sablas 19 36 68 3-Jul-07
1726
United Overseas Bank v. Rosemoor 20 1 51 2-Oct-07
1718
Monzon v. Relova 21 2 27 17-Sep-08
1709
Santos v. PNOC 22 3 43 23-Sep-08
1704
David v. Judge Fruelda 23 4 27 30-Jan-09
1812
BDO v. Tansipek 24 5 35 22-Jul-09
1907
San Pedro v. Heirs of Enana 25 6 54 16-Nov-10
1697
Juliano-Llave v. RP 26 7 66 30-Mar-11
1692
City of Manila v. Te 27 8 63 21-Sep-11
2001
Otero v. Roger Tan 28 9 34 15-Aug-12
1757
Magtoto v. CA 29 10 92 21-Nov-12

Rule 10
Citati
Topic Case Title on GR Date
Sec. 2, 3
Spouses Tirona v. Judge Alejo 30 11 1293 Oct 10,

8
 13 2001
1508
Leonardo Andres v. Serafin Cuevas 31 12 69 29-Jun-05
1450
Armand Nocum v. Lucio Tan 32 13 22 23-Sep-05
1483
Bautista v. Maya-maya Cottages 33 15 61 29-Nov-05
1584
PPA v. WG&A 34 16 01 28-Jan-08
1589
Biglang-Awa v. PTC 35 17 98 28-Mar-08
1486
Limbauan v. Acosta 36 18 06 30-Jun-08
1519
Tiu v. PB Com 1 19 32 19-Aug-09
1432
Lisam v. Banco de Oro 2 20 64 23-Apr-12

Sec. 4
1543
Zosimo Godinez v. CA 3 21 30 15-Feb-07

Sec. 5
1306
Spouses Mercader v. DBP 4 22 99 12-May-00
1203
PEF v. PII 5 23 84 13-Jan-04
1524
Lolita Ayson v. Marina Enriquez 6 24 38 17-Jun-04
Azolla Farms v. CA and Savings 1380
Bank 7 25 85 11-Nov-04
1586
Royal Cargo v. DFS Sports 8 26 21 10-Dec-08
1668
Wenceslao v. Freyssinet 9 27 57 11-Sep-09
1630
Panganiban v. Spouses Roldan 10 28 53 25-Nov-09
1728
Spouses Dela Cruz v. Concepcion 11 29 25 11-Oct-12

Sec. 6, 7
8102
APT v. CA 12 30 4 3-Feb-00
1006
Soriano v. CA 13 31 33 28-Aug-01
Planters Development v. LZK 1537
Holdings 15 32 77 15-Apr-05
Lambino v. Presiding Judge 16 33 1695 24-Jan-07

9
 51
1824
Ada v. Baylon 17 34 35 13-Aug-12
Sec. 8

1586
Cagungun v. PDB 18 35 74 17-Oct-05

Number Name
1 CALLANTA
2 GINCO
3 RESSURECCION
4 DOMINGO
5 TAGTAGAN
6 LIM
7 MOTREJO
8 ARIBAL
9 GIDO
10 ACOSTA M.
11 DU
12 RUYERAS
13 BUHAY
14 _______________
15 LOMONDOT
16 FAUSTINO
17 JARDINEL
18 LAPU
19 PARRENO
20 VEGA
21 MELENDREZ
22 ACOSTA L.
23 PABALAN
24 ABAD I.
25 DIMALIGALIG
26 ALPARAQUE
27 DUCO
28 ABALORIO
29 GOPO
30 CHING
31 JULIAN
32 ALPAS
33 ATMOSFERA

10
34 ARAFOL
35 RODRIGUEZ
36 CASAN

11