Professional Documents
Culture Documents
05 Debateunitoverview
05 Debateunitoverview
05 Debateunitoverview
UnitOverview
Bytheendofthisunit,youwillbeableto:
Becomeanexpertonatopicthatinterestsyou.
Closereadavarietyofnonfictiontexts:print,digital,andmultimedia.
Evaluatethecredibilityandbiasofasource.
Developstrong,convincing,balanced,andlogicalarguments.
Counteropposingargumentsconvincingly.
Task:Selectacontroversialtopicaboutanissuethatismeaningfultoyou.Then,
formagroup,researchthetopic,anddebateanopposingteamontheissueat
hand.Whiledoingso,beonthelookoutforbiasedsources--theyreeverywhere!
Toproveyoucanavoidthem--oratleastusethemforwhattheyre
worth--composeanannotatedbibliographythatevaluatesthecredibilityofat
leastthreesources.
Purpose:
Toconvinceothersthatyourargumentismorevalid.
Toevaluatesubtlebiasesinsources.
Toformandacknowledgecounter-arguments.
Audience:yourteacherandclassmates.
Assessments:
Writing/Reading/Research:Compostanannotatedbibliography.
SpeakingandListening:debateanotherteamonyourchosentopic.
UnitSequence:
PartI:SourceCredibilityandBias
PartII:ArgumentStructure
PartIII:Counter-Arguments
PartIV:SpeakingandListening