Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pitcher Rating July 21
Pitcher Rating July 21
Pitcher Rating July 21
Since the inception of the ESPN Cy Young Predictor in 2002, it has "predicted" the winner with 62.5% accuracy. In that
same time span, Pitcher Rating has a 81% correlation to the actual voting. Pitcher Rating even predicted Tim Lincecum's
2009 Cy Young Award victory, albeit by the narrow margin of 0.01 points.
The two formulas are in agreement that last year's AL winner should have been Felix Hernandez, as well as Mariano
Rivera in '05 and Eric Gagne in '04.
The egregious difference between the two formulas comes in 2003, where the Cy Young Predictor rewarded one closer
too much and another not enough.
A Cy Young Award winner should at least pass the eye test. Keith Foulke and Mark Prior? Seriously? Foulke finished
seventh in the vote, Prior taking third.
This is why you must trust the Pitcher Rating over the ESPN Cy Young Predictor. Should everything hold, we will both
look like geniuses in the same year yet again.