Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Debate 2nd Motion - Xps
Debate 2nd Motion - Xps
Debate 2nd Motion - Xps
Pro Con
disciplining unruly children Walter Williams. helps discipline children. Even the power of
"Making a Case for Corporal Punishment". Bnet. physical punishment to teach a child the difference
Sept 13, 1999: "Regardless of what the experts between right and wrong is dubious; a young child
preached, the undeniable fact is the 'uncivilized' may learn that the adult is displeased, but not why.
practice of whipping children produced more Spanking will cause a state of extreme distress and
civilized young people. Youngsters didn't direct foul confusion which makes it less likely they will analyse
language to, or use it in the presence of, teachers their behaviour with clarity. In older children
and other adults. In that 'uncivilized' era, disciplined at school, a physical punishment is likely
assaulting a teacher or adult never would have to provoke resentment and further misbehaviour.
Corporal punishment can ethically help intellectual development. 3 A study of 960 children
save a child's future Walter Williams. "Making a found an average 4 point reduction in IQ among
Case for Corporal Punishment". Bnet. Sept 13, students, from and average IQ of 102 (above
1999: "Let's think about cruelty. Today, it's not average) for children who are not spanked, to an
uncommon for young criminals to be arrested, average IQ 98 (below average) for who are. A
counseled and released to the custody of a parent reduction of 4 points is enough to have a significant
20 or 30 times before they spend one night in jail. negative functional effect on the students. More
violence in society.
General statements in support of corporal
Foundations: "I also believe the scriptural reference punishment Psychologist H. Stephen Glenn said
to the 'rod' best corresponds to a switch or perhaps "Corporal punishment is the least effective method
not respectful
Pro Con
Physical injuries only occur in abusive Corporal punishment can cause serious
corporal punishment. Serious physical injuries physical damage The actual physical damage
only occur where disciplined, strategic corporal inflicted via corporal punishment on children can be
punishment becomes child abuse. There is a strict horrifying. Examples can be found of students
line between the two (see above) and to ignore it is needing treatment for broken arms, nerve and
[] []
Pro Con
punishment is inherently wrong While it is true child abuse "Child Corporal Punishment: Spanking.
that corporal punishment can be abused, this does The anti-spanking position". Religious tolerance: "It
not demonstrate that it is always abused, or that it can escalate to abuse: Because a spanking works
is inherently abusive. If it is used abusively, than for a while, the parent often repeats the spanking
measures should be taken to limit such abuse, whenever the child misbehaves. Corporal
instead of eliminating the practice altogether, which punishment may then become a standard response
abuse, on the contrary, is the unjustified and Parents and Teachers Against Violence in Education
unreasoned beating of children. The act of child- (PTAVE) from their website at www.NoSpank.net:
abuse is not meant to punish a child, but is inflicted "Spanking does for a child's development what
without restraint or concern for the general welfare wife-beating does for a marriage."[6]
Not clear whether corporal punishment way he can, given his age and experience, to
increases abuse David Benatar. "Corporal neglect of basic needs. Among these needs are:
Punishment Social Theory and Practice". Social proper sleep and nutrition, treatment of hidden
Theory and Practice. Summer 1998: "Clearly there allergy, fresh air, exercise, and sufficient freedom to
are instances of abuse and of abusive physical explore the world around him. But his greatest need
punishment. But that is insufficient to demonstrate is for his parents' undivided attention. In these busy
even a correlation between corporal punishment times, few children receive sufficient time and
and abuse, and a fortiori a causal relationship. attention from their parents, who are often too
Research into possible links between corporal distracted by their own problems and worries to
punishment and abuse has proved inconclusive so treat their children with patience and empathy. It is
far. Some studies have suggested that abusive surely wrong and unfair to punish a child for
parents use corporal punishment more than responding in a natural way to having important
nonabusive parents, but other studies have shown needs neglected. For this reason, punishment is not
this not to be the case.(7) The findings of one only ineffective in the long run, it is also clearly
but not abandoned David Benatar. "Corporal well-intentioned, a slap registers as the shattering
Punishment Social Theory and Practice". Social of the whole deal between parent and child. Young
Theory and Practice. Summer 1998: "Opponents of children are left awash in feelings of fear, shame,
the corporal punishment of children are rightly rage, hostility, self-destructiveness and betrayal
critical of its extensive use and the severity with that they can't yet resolve or manage."[7]
inflicted."
Pro Con
Risks of sexual abuse with spanking can Corporal punishment on the buttocks is a
be regulated. David Benatar. "Corporal sexual violation Child Corporal Punishment: The
Punishment Social Theory and Practice". Social anti-spanking position": "Slapping or any other type
Theory and Practice. Summer 1998: "It is, of of force used on the buttocks is a sexual violation:
course, a concern that some parents or teachers The buttocks are an erogenous zone of the human
might derive sexual gratification from beating body. Their nerve system is connected to the body's
children, but is it a reason to eliminate or ban the sexual nerve centers. Slapping them can
practice? Someone might suggest that it is, if the involuntarily trigger feelings of sexual pleasure
anticipated sexual pleasure led to beatings that which become mixed with the pain. This can lead to
were inappropriate--either because children were confusion in the child's mind which influences the
beaten when they should not have been, or if the way in which they express their sexuality as
Effective discipline helps children learn to control their behavior so that they act
according to their ideas of what is right and wrong, not because they fear punishment.
For example, they are honest because they think it is wrong to be dishonest, not
because they are afraid of getting caught.
The purpose of punishment is to stop a child from doing what you don't want - and using
a painful or unpleasant method to stop him.
verbal punishment - shaming, ridiculing, using cruel words, saying "I don't love
you."
penalties - "You broke the window so you will have to pay for it with money from
your allowance."
The first two kinds of punishment, physical and verbal, are not considered to be effective
discipline methods. The other two, withholding rewards and giving penalties, can be
used either as effective discipline methods or as punishment - depending on how
parents administer them.
[] []
[Edit] [Edit]
Pro Con
teacher failures David Benatar. "Corporal engage students The Christian Science Monitor,
Punishment Social Theory and Practice". Social 1989-MAR-21: "The fundamental need of American
Theory and Practice. Summer 1998: "there is a big education is to find ways of engaging today's
difference between [...] a failure in the pupil, and a children in the thrill of learning. Fear of pain has no
Children who have been spanked feel that they have paid for their misbehavior and are
free to misbehave again. In other words, spanking frees the child from feelings of
remorse which are needed to prevent future misbehavior.
Parents who use physical punishment are setting an example of using violence to settle
problems or solve conflicts, Children imitate their parents' behavior. When parents use
physical punishment, children are more likely to use violent acts to settle their conflicts
with others.
Another disadvantage of using physical punishment is that parents have to find other
discipline methods when the child becomes as tall and as strong as the parent! Why not
start using effective discipline methods when the child is young?
Where reward and punishment focus on the child, encouragement and reality discipline
target the act. Reward and punishment teaches the child to be "good" as long as we are
looking. When rewards are our chief way of motivating children we run the risk of
creating "carrot seekers": children who are always looking for and expecting a reward
every time they do something good or right. If we give a child money for making his bed
this week, he'll wonder where his money is next week. Instead of being self-motivated by
a desire to cooperate or help other family members, we have taught the child to look to
us for his source of motivation.
Corporal punishment or physical punishment is a punishment intended to cause physical pain on a person. It
is most often used where there is a substantial disparity of power between punisher and punished.[original research?]
Corporal punishment is commonly practiced on minors, especially in home and also school settings, usually
employing more modest forms. Common methods in this regard often include spanking or paddling.
It is however also used on adults, particularly prisoners in some countries. In history most cultures have practiced
corporal punishment on adults in settings of imprisonment or slavery. Frequently employed methods
are flagellation and caning. In some countries bastinado is still practiced on prisoners as well.[1]