CURRENTS IN RESEARCH AND TECHNOLOGY
48
Bacteria in the Oil a
Petroleum engineers are nothing if not
eclectic. in their quest for hydrocarbons,
they exploit esoteric disciplines ranging
fom nuclear physics to satelite-asisted
‘communications, from factor analysis to
information theory. An area as far from
home as any of these, but as pertinent, i
microbiology.
Interactions of bacteria—both good and
bbad—with oilfield equipment and earth
formations have been known for decades.
‘As eatly as 1923, von Wolzogen Kahr dis-
cussed electrobiological corrosion down-
hole, and 11 years later he coauthored an
electrochemical theory of bacterial coro
sion. In 1946 Claude Zobel of the Amer-
can Petroleum institute patented the frst,
method for injecting bacteria into the for
mation to increase oil mobility.” Today,
entre disciplines are devoted to discourag-
ig bacterial-related problems and to
encouraging bacterial-elated enhanced oi
recovery {EOR). To understand how bac-
teria help and hare ol wells, first consider
‘what bacteria are and how they work
Bacteria belong toa group of organisms
called procaryotes, whose cells have n0,
‘compartmentalized nucleus (above righ.
all forms of fe, bacteria use enersy to
‘ary on vital functions and to build new
4H,0 + H,S + Energy.
Although the details of anaerobic bacter
al metabolism are still debated, specialists
agree on its three main products (right)
hhydrogenase, an enzyme that catalyzes the
Eucaryo
yale Mushre
niy Pino
ar |
CAI fv things eas Procary-
‘tes, comprising the group that contains bactoria, are one ofthe oldest
lors of Ife. Tei els are not divided ino compartment, but have mem
‘branes that separate various cellular functions. They have bah forms of
_genetc material, deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) and ribonucleic acid (RNA).
Viruses ae selceplicating units that eit a parasites in er cells and are
also though ob quite primitive. They contain either DNA or RNA, but ot
both, uses do not fit ensily into conventional biological clessicaions
and there some question whether they qually as living things. Eucaryotc
‘ells have both DNA and RNA and have various compartments and sac
tions devoted to specialized physiologic function,
[DPreposed main reactions of sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB) in anaerobic
conrosion. (Aer Cord-Ruwisch, reference 8)
oxidation of hydrogen even in anaerobic
environments, converting iron from the
metallic state to ionic state; acetic acid
[C,H,O,], which forms pockets of corro-
sion, called concentration cells at inter-
faces between iron sulfide [FeS,] and
The Technical ReviewBad News, Good News
metallic iron; and hydrogen sulfide [HSI
which converts metallic iron to iron sulfide
flocs (befow right and righ0. Most bacterial
cconrosion detected by the Casing Eval
{(CET*) tool is caused by anaerobes.
‘Aerobic bacteria are also present, but in
smaller numbers and with fess significant
effects. Meny aerobic bacteria oxidize iron
from the ferrous [Fe*?] to the ferric state
[Fe], with the precipitation of rust iron
hydroxide, $Fe(OH)y:
4FeCO,+0;46H,0> Fe(OH, +4CO,
Cortosion is also hastened by oxygen con-
=100 milidarcis since
bacteria measure »1 micron), depth
(10,000 feet [3,000 meters), and residval
«il saturationt=25 to 30 percent.» The goal
must be clear: waterloeding or permeability
modification. Using core analysis or logs
(euch as the Geochemical (GLT* log or the
Ltho-Density* log), as much information as
possible should be collected on rock matrix
‘mineralogy, clay mineralogy and distibu-
tion, and, from produced water samples,
the nature of indigenous microorganisms.
‘Temperature and salinity can adversely
affect te project by increasing retention of
the injected microbes through attachment or
filtration, and clays may aso adsorb surfac-
tants and solvents produced by fer-
mentation. Indigenous microbes may ether
holpo- hinder.
"Aer injection, itis Important to monitor
produced fluids. The presence of nutrients,
for example, suggests bacteria arent grow-
ing well or that excess nutrient is being
injected. Black water can indicate ion sul-
fide production by indigenous SRB. Micro-
bial activity can also be assessed by exam
ining samples of backflsh water for foam or
high turbidity, by smell (with certain
microorganisms) or, more reliably, by ab
culture and microscopic examination
A field-wide test of MEOR was done in
the Mink Uni of the Delaware-Childers
field in northeast Oklahoma to determine
whether MEOR could increase production
in a mature waterflood.? Four of 21 in-
jection wes were each teated with 10 ga
{ons (38 liters] of molasses before and after
injection of 26 gallons (99 lites] of micro
bial formulation. Afer the wells were shut
in for two weeks, backtlush samples were
dawn. The samples showed foam, indicat
ing surfactant production and microbial
viability. Thisty weeks later viability was
{urthercontiemed by the appearance of in-
jected microorganisms in production wells
about 1,000 feet (300 meters) from the
injection sites. Ths is believed to be the
firs observed transport of microorganisms
between injection and production wells
‘Ourut from the fel’ 15 producing wells
iereased 13 percent inthe year after bac-
terial injection. Presumably, production
might have been higher ifall 21 injectors
had received the same treatment. n add-
tion, water/oll ratios at producing wells
dropped nearly 35 percent.
Reducing Fluid Mobility/Permeability
‘Microorganisms can also be used to reduce
fluid mobility. Biologically produced poty-
‘mers such as polysaccharide xanthan gum,
2 food additive, have been used for some
time in EOR to thicken injection water and
thereby increase sweep efficiency. Xanthan
‘gum is especially attractive because of its
The Technical Reviewshear resistance, tolerance of temperature
and salinity, and the convenience of manu-
facture within the formation, using a mix
{re of bacteria and nutrients.
‘A similar approach has been suggested
{or selectively plugging high permeability
cchannels and thief zones.'6 Although this
has worked in the laboratory, it has yet to
be tested inthe field. Plugging the borehole
could be avoided, f necessary, by separate-
sage injection of bacteria and nutrient; then
a small amount of bactericide could stop
‘growth at the face of the formation. Suc-
‘cessul plugging would depend on choosing
a microbial formulation that fosters creation
of aglycocalyx.
LW. Costerion of the University of Cal-
gary recently proposed an approach to
plugging with a different application in
rmind.2° Costerton observes that certain
starved bacteria shrink drastically then swell
500-fold after nutrients bacome available,
He suggests that these bacteria be used to
prevent coning. The cells would be injected
into the formation at the level of the oil-
water interface, where, because of their
small ize, they Could penetrate as much as
15 feet [5 meters} radially. Then, after being
fed an inexpensive diet of pulp and paper
waste products, they would swell and
clump, forming 2 plug that should prevent
_water from coning into the producing zone,
‘This general method has been tied before,
by injecting cement and polyacrylic, but
these materials do not penetrate far enough
into the formation and are mare expensive
than bacteria and nutrients, No field trials
have be made, but laboratory simulations
‘support Costerton’s hypothesis.
From the variety of field conditions stud
fed and the observations of different invest
gators, itis clear that much remains to be
learned of what could be called geomi-
crobiology and its engineering applications
16 Fock,
ecorey
7a bir a ape
17, sae IR: The Suphate Reducing Baie, 2,
Combe: Contre Univenty Fes, 1904
18. Bijan RS "Posen User Moca
Poeun Recovery Teco. Poe
‘Oda Academy of Sloe? (267997 108,
Biya and Doula “vahton ef Micah
‘Spt n Braue Mia fr Epc i Recor
purer Pt 16264, rveta atthe SP hers
tina Symposia on Onbeld Chem, San Ar.
Fo Teas Febuary 41987
19. yan 8S arch Te, Demis OM and Heznan
Dor ncbialErhance Watrfoodng: Make
Une Project paper SPUDOE 1734 pressed at
‘ke STUOOE Land OF Rete Syesum,
‘ole A 17-20, 1988
2. rnserch ol vig lp” The Econom,
aye, 987131
Volume 37 Number 1
Letters
Tothe editor:
enjoyed your October 1988 article "Archie I
Electrical Conduction in Hydrocarbon-Bearing
Rocks for very practical reasons which may be
ofirerest
‘Monto Petroleum Co. was a nonoperaing,
working interest ower inthe dling ef the
Wile Petroleum 61 Quinn Rushing 9 Lower
“Teacalosa test in Lincoln County, Misissipp.
‘A dualnduction log showed a clean looking
zone witha very low fessvity of about 0.2 ohm
'm.Despt tho fact that sidewall core showed up
015% ol the operator, with Monitor dissenting,
‘chose to plug and abardon the well No SEM
analysis wos attempted, buta visual inspection of
‘the cores indicated several discrete unite of
upwardly coarsning grain-size deposition cycles
apd thus the posbiity of dfering clay mineral
By within each eye
‘Aimosta yea late, the operator and Monitor
Pevoleum entered he wal, and despite some
‘mechanical difcubes, completed a pumping 0
wel dual induction log run on reenty showed.
A similar response. very low resisivin—to
the ital og,
‘The work cited in your ace, about how
mleroporosity reduces restiviy, would Ven cre-
dence fo our orginal misgivings and prompt us to
include SEM analyses when fred with solar
anomalous lg responses its possible that the
low resistivity was caused by microporous lays.
The producing srandine reervots ofthe
Lower Tuscaloosa in southwestern Missisppl are
notorious for their anomalously low resi,