Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ijct 10 (3) 257-264
Ijct 10 (3) 257-264
Ijct 10 (3) 257-264
Modified DGEBA epoxy resin system was prepared using epoxy phenolic novolac (EPN), bisphenoi A cyanate
ester prepolymer and polyether sulphone (PES). DGEBA epoxy resin modified with cyanate ester prepolymer offers
process advantage in making prepregs for the preparation of structural composite materials. Further, the DGEBA
epoxy resin modified with EPN and PES along with cyanate ester prepolymer was fully polymerised by curing at
200C for 4 h. The cured resin was characterised by FT-IR, thermogravimetric analysis and differential scanning
calorimetric methods. The moisture resistance properties were studied for the cured resins. The morphology studies
were done for cyanate ester monomer, cyanate ester-epoxy polymer and PES-modified cyanate ester-epoxy polymers.
Carbon fibre laminates were made based on PES-modified cyanate ester and epoxy polymer. Mechanical properties
of the laminates were evaluated.
Epoxy resin is one of the most important increase the degree of crosslinking, it is intended to
thermosetting resins employed for high performance introduce epoxy phenolic novolac (EPN) component
industrial applications 1-6 . However, epoxy networks (scheme 2) into the epoxy system, which may result
are typically rather brittle and di splay low fracture in a more crosslinked network structure in the region.
toughness in contrast to high toughness, high modulus
characteristics required for high performance
applications. Moreover, the nature and amount of the
crosslinking agent used for making epoxy networks
also induces relatively high moisture absorption
characteristics. ln addition to this , lack of toughness
has limited the application characteristics of these n
systems. In order to improve these above-mentioned
drawbacks in properties, the DGEBA was chosen as Sche me 2-Structure of epoxy phenolic novolac (EPN)
model epoxy system for modification (scheme 1).
To reduce the water absorption of the cured resin 7-9 ,
bi sphenol A cyanate ester (scheme 3) was selected as
a curing agent to the epoxy resin.
Table !-Formulations (% WIW) , Tg and % moi sture absorption data of epoxy-cyanate ester
B 60 40 225 1.6
c 30 30 40 25 210 1.6
D 60 40 260 2.7
E 65 35 262 4.5
258
Suguna Lakshmi & Reddy: Modification of epoxy system for industrial application Articles
Instruments
Nicolet Ff-IR spectrophotometer model 20 DXB
was used for studying the IR spectroscopy (400-4000
cm- 1) of monomers and cured samples . Analyses were
done using solid KBr pellets. 1H and 13C-NMR of the
compounds synthesized were run on a Bruker 320
MHz spectrometer at room temperature using CDCb
as a solvent and tetramethylsilane (TMS) as an
internal standard. Differential Scanning Calorimetric
(DSC) analysis was performed using a Du Pont 200 II l 1
instrument. The heating rate for DSC was I 0C per 160 120 80 40 0
min in the nitrogen atmosphere. Thermal stability of PPM
the formulations A, B and C (Table 1) were
Fig . I (a)- FT-IR spectra of cyanate ester monomer; (b) - 1H-
investigated on Mettler 3000 TG equipment. A S440 NMR spectra of cyanate ester monomer and (c)- 13C-NMR
model Scanning Electron Microscope was employed spectra of cyanate ester monomer.
to examine the morphol ogy of cured samples. The
surfaces of the samples were vacuum coated with Results and Discussion
gold . The universal testing machine model H T E-S- Characterization of cyanate ester monomer
Series, Hounsfield equipments Ltd , UK was used for FT-IR Spectr a
the following tests, employing ASTM specifications The cyanate ester monomer shows strong
(Tens ile test: ASTM-0 3479-76 and ASTM-D 790- absorption peak around 2236-2273 cm- 1 for the
84a). Mode I Fracture toughness (G 1c) was meas ured presence of - OCN and a doublet peak around 1351-
using Double Cantilever Beam (DCB) method . Mode 1383 cm- 1 for the presence of isopropyl group of
II Fracture toughness (G 1;c ) was measured using the bisphenol A cyanate ester. The peaks at 1169 and
End Notched Flexure (ENF) 17 method . 1198 em_, are due to C-0 stretchin g of phenol. The
259
Articles Indian J. Chern . Techno!. , May 2003
broad peak around 1593-1631 em' implies the C=C polymerisation requires high temperatures around
stretch in the benzene ring. The stretches at 811 and 150C and above. Here the reaction proceeds faster
831 cm- 1 show the 1,4-substitution in the aromatic and results in highly crosslinked solid resin.
compound (Fig. 1a). The cobalt naphthenate, manganous octoate and
copper acetyl acetonate catalysts were employed 18 19
1
H and 13
C-NMR Spectra for polycyclotrimerisation. Nonyl phenol was used as
1 a co-catalyst. This catalytic system was employed
In the H NMR spectrum, aromatic protons of the
benzene ring appear around 7.0-7.2 ppm. The protons because of its miscibility in neat resins , low
of the isopropyl group were observed at 1.5-1.6 ppm temperature curing and good latency at room
13 temperature. These catalysts perhaps help bringing
(Fig lb). In the C-NMR spectrum, the OCN group
was observed at 151 ppm, which confirms the cyanate groups together into the ring forming
formation of OCN group. The carbons present in the proximity while the hydroxyl group donates protons
20 2 1
phenyl rings were seen between 108-128 ppm while for imido carbonate formation and step transfer .
the quaternary carbon present in the isopropyl group To obtain low crosslinked cyanate ester, it was
was observed at 42.6 ppm. The methylene group necessary to optimize the quantity of the catalyst and
present in the isopropyl group was observed at 31.3 the temperature at which it was to be trimerised. After
ppm (Fig lc). The 1H and 13 C-NMR spectra confirm conducting a number of trial experiments varying the
the absence of phenolic proton and the formation of catalyst/co-catalyst concentration, the curing
OCN group. conditions were optimized. The co-catalyst (nonyl
phenol) also acts as a solvent for the metal catalysts,
which is sparingly soluble in neat resins. When the
Characterization of cyanate ester prepolymer
nonyl phenol concentration was increased, it
Though epoxy-cyanate system is known for good . .
pIastiCizes the cyanate ester22 . Hence, the liquid
adhesion, high temperature resistance, and low
cyanate obtained in the present investigation may be
moisture absorption properties, the physical state
due to the plasticizing effect of nonyl phenol present
(solid) of the cyanate ester possess difficulty in the
in the mixtures . The cyanate ester prepolymer
preparation of its prepregs (the impregnated fibers
prepared under present experimental conditions was
which are in the ready form for making composite
found to be in the liquid form at room temperature
materials). Prepregs made by impregnating in the
which is advantageous for making tacky prepregs .
solution of epoxy-cyanate mixture becomes dry once
The pot life of the liquid resin was also observed and
the solvent get evaporated . On the other hand ,
was found to be 25 days.
prepregs made by impregnating in the melt liquid of
epoxy-cyanate mixture also becomes brittle after the
prepregs gets cooled. Since prepregs made by solution Characterization of cyanate ester prepolymer-epoxy
and/or melt impregnation methods are dry, it is prepregs
difficult to stick them together. In the present studies, The prepreg plies made wi th cyanate ester
cyanate ester prepolymer is in the liquid form for prepolymer were placed one above the other and
making better prepregs. Both the epoxy-cyanate stacked well. On the physical observation, the plies
systems prepared were found to be in the semi-solid were in stack with each other for a minimum period
or liquid form which forecasts that the prepergs made of 25 clays. Also, the liquid cyanate ester prepolymer
with them will have required tack properties. can be easily formulated with other liquid epoxy
Therefore, attempts were made to gel the cyanate resins to impregnate the fiber for making various
ester monomer so as to prepare the homogenous composite materials. The prepregs made out of liquid
epoxy-cyanate liquid system for application in cyanate prepolymer-epoxy system need not have to be
making tacky prepregs. The gelation was carried out heated to melt the cyanate so as to stick the prepregs
by the partial polymerisation of the cyanate ester together for making composites .
monomer. The polymerisation reaction proceeds via
polycyclotrimerisation by non-catalytic (thermally) FT-IR Spectra
and catalytic methods . Non-catalysed thermal The cyanate ester prepolymer (Fig. 2a) shows
pol ymerisation reaction is possible and the reaction is ab orption peak at 1598 cm- 1 which represents the
supposed to be catalysed by impurities including tri azine ring formation. The strong absorption at
moisture and residual phenol from synthesis. Thermal 2236-2273 cm- 1 shows the presence of - OCN. The
260
Suguna Lakshmi & Reddy : Modification of epoxy system for industrial application Articles
E
Ill
c (b) c 376 376-592 400 526 583 609
..-e
Characterisation of epoxy-cyanate ester polymer
FT-IR Spectra
261
Articles Indian J. C hern. Tec h110I. , May 2003
- -- -0
---- b
-------- ----'C
M~- - 411 .
-- ... 1-4 ...... ......... . .
c
a (\
CTI
I"
I \
'
I
I
~
r1
\
.\
\. J
'
I \ !
\ \I
I
I
II I
0
I ~
I ,I
f1rv,.
~ l
100 200
262
Suguna Lakshmi & Reddy : Modification of epoxy system for industrial application Articles
moi sture resis tance property has not been system to allow the formation of micro-voids for the
compromised. Thus, the PES modified epoxy-cyanate shrinkage compensation. Phase separation may be
system shows good Tg (210C) and low moisture caused by a change in the miscibility of the monomer,
absorption (1 .6%). The low moisture absorption in the prepolymer and catalyst during curing. Therefore, the
case of cyanate-cured epoxies may be due to the thermoplastic/thermosetting system undergoes several
formation of strong networks and the absence of steps before it reaches a maximum reaction rate point.
hydrophilic amino groups to some extent. Initially before the reaction, at room temperature, the
two systems remain separately. Phase one remair s as
Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) a continuous phase and the phase two may perhaps be
There are reports on toughening of the highly dispersed in the continuous phase. During heating, the
crosslinked thermosetting polymers with hi gh systems become miscible and transparent. Further, the
modulus and high Tg thermoplastics as studied by reaction takes place in the miscible systems to form
SEM 24 - 26 . In a thermoset/thermoplastic blend the highly crosslinked having hi gh molecular weight
components are usually mixed together and the micro-gels. This decreases the miscibility of the
crosslinking of the epoxy occurs in situ. The increase overall reacting system and at this point phase
of the molecular weight of the epoxy during curing separation occurs. The separated micro-gel gets
may result in phase separation even if the temperature crosslinks themselves to produce a macrostructure
27
is kept constant . One of the most studi ed and di splays as co-continuous phases in the two phase
thermoplastics for the modification of epoxy resin is network structure.
the polyether sulphone (PES). PES is added to
increase viscosity during hot lay up of the prepregs Evaluation of carbon fiber laminate properties
28
for the manufacture of composites . The mechanical properties of the laminates are
given in Table 4. It can be seen that the flexural and
Morphology tensile properties are good while the fracture
SEM photographs of the cold snap surfaces for the toughness properties are high in the order of 0.32
cured systems are given in photomicrographs I to Ill (KJ/M 2)29 , compared to standard epoxy system (0.080
(Fig. 4). The cyanate ester homopolymer (I) KJ/M2)3o_
morphology appears to be transparent and
homogeneous under the magnification at 800 x. The Conclusion
blend of DGEBA and EPN with cyanate ester DGEBA epoxy resm was modified with EPN ,
monomer (II) appears nearly transparent. cyanate ester and PES to obtain an epoxy resi n
Nevertheless, so me amount of phase separation was system, which offers improved properties. The EPN
observed which may be the immiscible region s was included to enhance the degree of cross-linking
formed during the reaction of epoxies with cyanate while the cyanate ester was introduced to improve the
ester monomer. The phase separation of PES in moisture resistance and to establish the less densed
epoxy-cyanate ester (III) was observed at 800 x crosslinked structure upon curing. Further, the
magnification . During the curing reaction, the epoxy cyanate ester monomer was prepolymerised by
rings opens up and produce polar hydroxyl groups. varying the catalyst and co-catalyst concentration.
The related enthalpy of mixing seems to cause the The liquid cyanate ester prepolymer had a pot life of
PES to separate from the solution. On the other hand, 25 days. The cyanate ester prepolymer-epoxy blend
with more than 20% of polysulphone content, the offers process advantage for making epoxy prepregs .
cyanate ester/polysulphone blends were phase The DGEBA epoxy resin modified system shows high
separated by spinodal decomposition 27 . The phase glass transition temperature and low moi sture
separation during the curing process seems to be an absorption. The morphology study of PES modified
important parameter because it provides a two-phase epoxy resin system by SEM shows phase separation.
Properties Resin content Flexural Flexural Tensile strength Tensile Fracture toughness (KJ/M 2)
(Volume%) strength (Mpa) modulus (Gpa) (Mpa) modulus (Gpa) G1c Gnc
263
Articles Indian J. Chem. Tec hn o l. , May 2003
The related enthalpy of mixing of epoxy with PES, 12 Hedri ck 1 C , Yilgor I, Wilkes G C & McGra th J E, Polym
Bull, 13 ( 1985) 20 I.
which seems to cause the PES to separate. The
13 Cecere 1 A & McGrath 1 E, Polym Prep, 27 (1986) 299.
flexural, tensile and toughness properties of the
14 Raghava R S 1, Polym Sci, Polym Phys Edn, 25 (1987) 101 7.
composite, are seems to be very good. 15 Rag hava R S 1, Polym Sci, Polym Phys Edn, 26 ( 1988) 65.
16 Grigat E & Putter R, Angew Chem lnt Edn, ( 1993) 6.
Acknowledgement 17 Alan 1 Russel & Ken N Street, Key Eng Mat, 37 ( 1989) 199.
One of the authors (MS) is grateful to Mr M K 18 Simon S L & Gillham 1 K, Am Chem Soc Eng, 54 (1986)
Sridhar, Ms P Kanakalatha, and Ms Chandra Ajay, 107 .
National Aerospace Laboratories, Bangalore for their 19 Liu H & George G A, Polymer, 37 (1996) 3675.
20 Osei-Owusu A Martin G C & Gotro 1 T, Polym Eng Sci, 32
help in the present work.
(1992) 535.
21 Harismendy I, Gomez C, Ormaetxea M, Martin M D, Ecei za
References A & Mondragon I, J Polym Mater, 14 ( 1997) 317 .
May CA (Ed), Epoxy Resins, Chemistry and Technology 22 Shimp D A, Am Chem Soc, Polym Mater Sci Eng, 54 ( 1986)
(Marcel Dekker, New York), 1988. 107.
2 Ellis B (Ed), Chemistry and Technology of Epoxy Resins 23 Shimp D A, 32"d International SAMPE Symposium, April 6-
(B iackie Academic and Professional Publications, Glasgow,
9, 1987.
UK), 1993
24 Macki nnon A J, Jenkin s S D, McGal P T & Pethrick R A,
3 Bauer R S (Ed), Epoxy Resin Chemistry, ACS Advances in
Polymer, 34 ( 1993) 3252.
Chemistry Series no. 114 (American Chemical Society,
25 Ino ue T , Prog Polym Sci. 20 ( 1995) 119.
Washington DC), 1979.
4 Lee H & Neviles K (Eds), Handbook of Epoxy Resins 26 Hwa ng 1 W , Cho K, Paark C E & Huh W , J Appl Polym Sci,
(McGraw Hill, New York), 1967. 74 (I) (1999) 33.
5 Lee H & Nevillee K, Hand Book of Epoxy Resins (McGraw 27 Clarke N, Mcleish T C B & Jenkins S D, Macromolecules,
Hill, New York), 1990. 28 ( 1995 ) 4650.
6 Gillham 1 K, Encyclopaedia of Polymer Science and 28 Buck nail C B & Patridge I K, Polymer, 24 ( 1983) 639.
Technology (W il ey, New York), 1986, 519. 29 Shimp D A, Christenson 1 A & Isin g S J, lnt SAMPE
7 Novak H L & Comer D A, Adhesive Age, Feb 29 ( 1990). Syn1posiwn, 34 ( 1989) 222.
8 Graveer R B, Polym Prep, 32 ( 1990) 182. 30 Sridhar M K, Suguna Lakshmi M , Kan akalatha P, Padma P,
9 McConnell V P, Adv camp, May- Jun ( 1992) 28. Pandare Kiran V & Chandra Ajay, High Fracture Toughn ess
10 Bucknall C B & Patridge I K, Polymer, 24 ( 1983) 639. Epoxy Resins, paper presented at the Second Joint CAE-
II Ibrahim A, Quinuivam T J & Seferis 1 C, Polym Prep, 26 NAL Workshop on Composites and Struc tures, XJ'AN ,
( 1985) 277. China, 6-8 August 1995.
264