Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jurnal Tts
Jurnal Tts
Jurnal Tts
00/0
THEJOURNAL OF ORTHOPAEDIC AND SPORTS PHYSICAL THERAPY
Copyright 0 1984 by The Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy Sections of the
American Physical Therapy Association
The medial tarsal tunnel syndrome is a compression neuropathy involving the tibial
nerve or its branches as they pass through the tarsal tunnel under the flexor
retinaculum. Medial tarsal tunnel syndrome is not recognized as readily as its
counterpart in the wrist. This syndrome can lead to a painful burning sensation in the
medial border of the foot and into the great toe. In its fullest extent medial tarsal
tunnel syndrome can involve sensory changes in the heel and the lateral part of the
sole of the foot as well as the remaining toes. In addition, it may lead to weakness of
the intrinsic muscles of the foot. This syndrome often goes unrecognized or
misdiagnosed particularly in the athlete. While medial tarsal tunnel syndrome may
Downloaded from www.jospt.org at on May 11, 2017. For personal use only. No other uses without permission.
The medial tarsal tunnel syndrome is a thorough knowledge of the condition, protracted
compression neuropathy of the tibial nerve or its symptoms can be alleviated before permanent
terminal branches, the medial and lateral plantar motor or sensory damage ~ccurs.~.''
nerve^.'^^'^^'''^' This impingement occurs within This paper will review the anatomy of the tarsal
the boundaries of the fibro-osseous tarsal tunnel tunnel as it pertains to the medial tarsal tunnel
or as it passes into the abductor hallucis mus- syndrome, its etiology, pathology, clinical picture,
Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy
~ l e . ~ .Because
~ . ~ ' this syndrome is not as well differential diagnosis, and treatment. In addition,
recognized as its counterpart at the wrist, there details of the authors' clinical experience with this
may be a delay in diagnosi~.~,~.~.' condition will be outlined (Table 1).
The first comprehensive report of: the tarsal
tunnel syndrome was presented by Keck15 in ANATOMY
1962, and later in the same year by
However both these authors credited earlier pass- The tarsal tunnel is a descriptive space with
ing reference^.^, The tarsal tunnel syn-
'6317'2032529
rather ill-defined limits. It begins a few centimeters
drome has since been divided into the anterior proximal to the tip of the medial malleolus where
tarsal tunnel syndrome, which implicates the crural fascia starts to condense forming an
compression of the deep peroneal nerve at the unyielding "roof," the flexor retinaculum (laciniate
inferior extensor retinaculum, and the posterior or ligament).7~8.20 It ends where the medial and lateral
medial tarsal tunnel syndrome. The latter is more plantar nerves enter or pass deep to abductor
common and will be described in this paper.'-24 hallu~is.~'
Physiotherapists should be aware of this syn- The tibial nerve enters the tunnel in the neuro-
drome, particularly if they are associated with vascular bundle lying just posterior and slightly
treatment of athletes, since they may be in a deep to the posterior tibial artery and vein. This
position to make the initial diagnosis. With a more bundle lies behind the tibialis posterior and flexor
digitorum which are contained in their separate
Candidate for M.Sc.P.T., Department of Physical Therapy, Corbett fibro-osseous sheaths, and anterior to flexor hal-
Hall, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta.
t Associate Professor of Surgery. Division of Orthopaedics, University lucis longus and its heath"^'^ (Fig. l ) .
of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta. Unlike the carpal tunnel, there is no sharp prox-
39
KUSHNER AND REID JOSPT Vol. 6,No. 1
Med. Malleolus
Lat. Malleolus
Deltoid Lig.
Tibialis Post.
Flex. Digitorurn -Peroneus Brevis
Longus -Peroneus Longus
Post. Tibial Vei
Post. Tibial Art. ' /\A 'Flex. Retinaculum
Tibial Nerve
Flex. Hallucis Longus
Tendo ~ c h i l l e s ' ~ ~ ~
within, immediately distal or, rarely, just proximal discreet structure, but is a condensation of the crural fascia.
The dotted lines indicate the extent recommended for surgical
to the The one or two very fine release.
sensory medial calcaneal branches arise from the
tibial nerve, or occasionally the lateral plantar
nerve. They supply the major portion of the medial
and plantar skin surface at the hee1.4~5.7~11~21*28 Saphenous M ~ e d Plantar
. N.
ings of anatomic, trauma, tumor, inflammatory, syndrome of which 16 (28%) required operative
and miscellaneous causes. Because of the great decompres~ion.~ It may also occur with ankle
variety of etiological factors and their anatomic sprains, crushing injuries, dislocations, or with
location in the canal, there may be a variety of tightly fitting plaster casts.4~8.11320*22
Last, the syn-
presenting symptoms contributing to a delay in drome is seen postsurgically following osteoto-
Copyright 1984 Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy. All rights reserved.
TABLE 1
Copyright 1984 Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy. All rights reserved.
Age Sex Sport Occupation S~de monthsin Foot alignment Symptoms Sensory Motor EMG Consewative Findings at
Results
treatment' suraerv
Runner, 40 mi/ Student Normal Pain into great Hyperesthesia of None US Constriction by fi- Relief by 24 hr
wk toe after run- great toe and lnjection brous band in
ning medial foot superior tunnel
Tinel +ve
Runner, 60 mi/ Teacher Valgus heel Numbness and Impaired pin prick None us Thickening of Relief by 3 months
wk. Chronic te- Pronated forefoot paresthesia Tinel -ve TNS nerve and fibro-
nosynovitis of Nocturnal pain lnjection sis
tibialis poste-
rior over 3-yr
Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy
period
Runner, 45 mk/ Student Valgus heel Burning sensation Hyperesthesia None US Fibrosis of nerve Relief in 1 month
wk Pronated forefoot in great toe Tinel +ve Orthototic
Runner, 65 mi/ Lawyer Valgus heel Burning sensation Impaired pin prick None Orthotic Fusiform thicken- Relief by 36 hr
wk Pronated forefoot Tinel -ve ing of nerve PostoP
Skater (skate Student Prominent calca- Burning sensation lmpaired pin prick None Modificationof Normal appear- Relief in 24 hr
pressure?) neous Tinel -ve skates ance
Soccer (postcon- Phys. Ed. Normal lntense burning Decreased pin None US Dense scarring Relief at 1 month
tusion) teacher Nocturnal pain prick over en- SWD
tire medial plan- lnjection
tar nerve dis- Mobilization
trib.
Tinel -ve
Ice hockey (post- Construction Broadened heel lntense burning Paresthesia in None Wax baths Dense scarring Relief at 6 wk
fractured calca- worker Noctural pain foot and toes US Neuroma
neus) Tinel +ve lnjection
Mobilization
Runner, 80 mi/ Student Valgus heel lntense burning Decreased tactile None Orthosis Scarring near ab- Relief at 24 hr
wk Pronatedforefoot after running sensation US ductor hallucis
Tinel -ve muscle
- --
deed, surgical release should not be contemplated bate this condition. When the condition is associ-
until these studies are ated with edema, support hose may help.4
Nerve conduction studies both to the abductor d) Drugs. Oral nonsteroidal, anti-inflammatories
digiti minimi and abductor hallucis are imperative, may be used where a coexisting inflammatory
as only one may be abnormal.*' Latencies of more condition is suspected. Occasionally, local admin-
than 1 SD above the normal for the particular istration of steroids may be warranted but care
laboratory carrying out the test is considered di- should be taken not to inject the nerve itself. There
agnostic. Possibly, evaluation of evoked sensory is always considerable danger of skin atrophy with
and motor potentials may be a more sensitive injection of steroid into this area and this may
indication of this ~ o n d i t i o n . ~ ~ ~ - ~ ~ ' ~ ~ ultimately
~~ prove a larger problem than the entrap-
ment syndrome. Caution is, therefore, urged.
TREATMENT
Operative
Nonoperative
Surgical release may provide complete allevia-
a) Modification of activity. With the athlete in tion of the compression neuropathy as early as
particular, modification of activity is combined with 24 hours post~peratively.'~~'~ A few patients will
other therapeutic endeavors. This should include have residual weakness and numbness following
advice regarding terrain, distance, and spacing of surgery.' During surgery the laciniate ligament is
training sessions. completely divided, the nerve is freed from encom-
b) Therapeutic modalities. Most therapeutic passing fibrous tissue, the branches are explored
modalities are directed at the reduction of edema and, if possible, mobilized distal to the abductor
and fibrosis and may include a trial of ice, ultra- hall~cis.~~" Each fibrous hiatus for the medial and
sound, interferential current, intermittent lateral plantar nerves is checked and slit if nec-
JOSPT JulylAug 1984 MEDIAL TARSAL TUNNEL
jumping, skipping, and hopping can be added at 12. Janecki CJ, Dovberg JL: Tarsal tunnel syndrome caused by neu-
4 weeks, working within the limits of discomfort rilemoma of the medial plantar nerve. J Bone Joint Surg (Am)
and swelling. Results of surgery are usually last- 59:127-128, 1977
13. Johnston EW, Oritz PR: Electrcdiagnosis of tarsal tunnel syn-
ing, with most individuals experiencing early re- drome. Arch Phys Med Rehabil47:776-780,1966
lief.5.101'8Early complications of wound infection 14. Kaplan PE, Kernahan WT: Tarsal tunnel syndrome. J Bone Joint
and dehiscence are uncommon. Late complica- Surg (Am) 63:96-99, 1981
15. Keck C: The tarsal tunnel syndrome. J Bone Joint Surg (Am)
tions include rescarring of the nerve and, more 44:180-182.1962
rarely, subluxation of the tibialis posterior ten- 16. Kopell HP, Thompson WA: Peripheral entrapment neuropathies of
don.'' the lower extremity. N Engl J Med 26256-60, 1960
17. Lam SJ: A tarsal tunnel syndrome. Lancet 2:1354-1355,1962
Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy
18. Lam SJ: Tarsal tunnel syndrome. J Bone Joint Surg (Br) 49:87-
CONCLUSION 92,1967
19. Langan P, Weiss CA: Subluxation of the tibialis posterior: A com-
M a r i n a ~ c iin
, ~describing
~ the median nerve at plication of tarsal tunnel decompression. Clin Orthop 146:226-
227,1980
the carpal tunnel stated that "Almost every pe- 20. Linscheid qL, Burton RC, Fredericks EJ: Tarsal tunnel syndrome.
ripheral nerve, at some point along its course, South Med J 63:1313-1323,1970
passes through a constricted zone or tunnel . . . 21. Mann RA: Tarsal tunnel syndrome. Orthop Clin North Am 5109-
Here it becomes liable to any change in the sur- 115, 1971
22. Mann RA: Diseases of the nerves of the foot. In: Mann RA (ed),
rounding tissues, whether due to trauma, DuVries Surgery of the Foot. Ed 4. pp 469-470. St. Louis: CV
compression by edema, inflammation, or arthritis." Mosby Co, 1978
The posterior tibia1 nerve is no exception. Be- 23. Marinacci AA: Comparative value of measurement of nerve con-
duction velocity and electromyography in the diagnosis of tarsal
cause physiotherapists are often the first to ex- tunnel syndrome. Arch Phys Med Rehabil45:548-554,1964
amine the athlete they must be aware of this 24. Marinacci AA: Neurological syndromes of the tarsal tunnels. Bull
syndrome as it may be more common than we Los Angeles Neurol Soc 33:90-100.1968
25. Pollock LJ, Davis L: Peripheral nerve injuries. Am J Surg 18:361-
are presently aware." The authors have de- 401.1932
scribed the syndrome, paying particular attention 26. Reid DC, Kushner SF. Edmonton, Alberta (personal observations)
to the clinical picture and treatment. It is hoped 27. Saeed M: Compound nerve action potentials of the medial and
lateral plantar nerves through the tarsal tunnel. Arch Phys Med
that this will assist early recognition, thereby Rehabil63:304-307. 1982
bringing this condition into the realm of conserv- 28. Srinivasan R, Rhodes J, Seidel MR: The tarsal tunnel. Mt Sinai J
ative therapy, rather than the operative treatment Med 47:17-23,1980
29. Ward WC: Posterior nerve injuries. South Surg 14:124-129, 1948
which has been very much the rule.
The authors would like to thank Dr. John Kramer and Dr. Graham
Lowe for their advice and assistance.