20 itt ~ 80 .if 1t tf ~. ,. 1£ J :tft 0 ~ ;{£ J::t Jt ft[ ~ ±t ii tf 1!;~ YT;,W~~~~o90.if~. ~m~~,~%~%,~#,+# 1t:¥1r. ~ff;., ;J±!'I5.
ABB, z s , LG, fiir~. Wfl-=f, it;ij!ilHr .0~*AW~~.~M*~~.*~~_~~.i~ ••• ~. ~~~S.AW~~.~~~~*~~~.~*ffl~OO~~*~ ~ •• ~,~ ••. ~"~~~*M~~$~ .• *.*~m~ ;{£*~t •• *~*~~~* •• ~~~;{£*at.*~to~ W~~~W~~*~~~~;{£~~. k~~~S*L~~~~~ ~ffl~.~T~*~~~~AW.~.~~~.~o
~~~~AW~~.~~~~~~~~~~a~~~. ~~ S~~~~*.±OOAW~~.~~~I~~~~~T*.~I fF. ~:f& JfX.. :rJJ ~;j;. T QY J¥ ± 00 J\ W. ~ * ~; 2003.if ~ >t T J\ W ~ ~ "" 1!r ju if, 7d~j. it s: T J\ W ~ fJb ~ 1!r it Jlft if -i#. 1~tJ,1t • ~ 2004 .if~~~~ftT~*aJlft;,W~~~1!r±oo~-if~;~;j;.T* * J\ IN. ~ ~ \Iifi * 1)11 *; 2004.if ill JItt T fJ - JItt « J\ W ~ ~ If JJ.. » ~#; 2006 if-m~~J>t T «J\ W*fJb.~if1frJjt!ilO>. PJf;ff1t~. M~OOAW.fJbf~~ft*IfF~T*~~x#fFfflo
«AW~fJb~~» (fJ-JItt) iliJlttffi. ~~R**%. iliJltt~ **'~o ~~;{£~mrliitf~~~~W~;ff~*~.~.~_ ~. ~~.~ffi*>t~fJ-JItt ••• ~o;{£«AW.fJbf~»fJ ~JItt~~±tiitf.±OOAW~fJb.~~*IfF~~~~~~~% ***%~~,.*%~~~R~rl~.r~~*1~W~fJb~ ~~~~**~*~~~. ~~-JItt~~W~T~~*~~~, 1~t1t. {rJEfP 16.0
«J\W~Jlb.ll)) (~.::AAJ tE~*, {!iJillillI1f3:.~o ~:Iw. ~IfF~*{!iJ~, ~~~, ~~~, ~~tf, ~~*, *_,4 ~~,~ ••. ~~.£~*,M.~.:lwT*.~.~,#~ fP.~IfFo *.,.~£,.~M.:lwT.~~.~&~IfFo ± •• ~tfl{!iJ~iA _l1l:f{o
* •• ~±tiitf~~T~OOJ:.~~I~*.±OO~w~~
~~ft*I~~~%~*~.~*hx*~±OO;,W~~*~~~I~~~%~~~~, ~ili~~M~~~*~, o/OO~~I~#-~m*~, o/OO~~I~.~.m*~,*~ ~~~m~~0~,~~o/OO~~0~,TCL~m*~*~$**~~~~~~r*. }it i9.: 'Ii av :t Jl!. •
*~~~#-.~£.~.n~~~,~.~,.~*.£ ••.• M,~* •. * ••• ~r*~#- •• ~I~,~~~~fi#iliav*~*~~.~ ••.
»~*~~.~~**~rOO*$M#.£.~§ "~~AW.~ •• ~*~*.~ ;it -P)f J'E" (. %: 70372062), "ilJlj:i! ~ ;' ... W.~ i9.: it::ff *;fI1 $_ m-P)f J'E" Uj} %: 70572044)
tp ";' ... W.~ * JJ tfJ 1% P$: ¥L iIJIj ;fI1 ~ '* -P)f J'E" (. %: 70672088) ~ * j);, ~ ~ -:#- * ;:fJttlti ~
.$, ftm¥*~_ltio/OOA~*.ili.~~*~.*tfJ ••• ~tp~*. *f~Mtp~~m~, ~o/.~#~ •• ~ ••. & •• ~aw.~. A~.Jl!.~~ *- ~ wll@eaq. argo en. 11 * ~ ili.:t.1If- , I1i1 J * it ~ * ;:f- -I: ~ II:; av _ iti ~
(:;'\1§:t3El_JI.» t.III~* ~OO~.~RW~~~~~*I~~~~
~1. ~ ~ 1
~ 1 ~ :t\:i!i;t3Jij.J!..~ , ,"', , .. 3
1.1 ,,\ &;f;&.~*~~j(~ 3
1.1. 1 Jlf:- .. ~~~*-~Jti:f'~~j(JA. 3
1.1.2 ,,\ &;f;&.~tt~~~at~j(_.J_ 9
1.2 ,,\ &;f;&.~~ .. ~¥1tJJ1 13
1.2. 1 *&~~~ .. ~ 13
1.2.2 ,,\ &;f;&.~'i"~~1tJfl 15
1.3 ,,\ &;f;&.~*~~4Ji~,:t-it¥'*.4 19
1. 3.1 ~.&4ji~-tf.*&;f;&.~'i"~9='~1tJJ1 19
1. 3. 2 ,,\ &~~11Iii~~ ~.:Il:.:t -it 22
1.3.3 ,,\&;f;&.~tt1.t~~.:Il:.&l.4 .. ···· .. ···· .. ···· .. · .. · 24
1. 4 *~;f;&.~f-1.t~m~¥.ffl*- 28
1. 4.1 *lV;f;&.~tt1.t~bI.MM~ 28
1.4. 2 ~&~~f'J.!.~.ffl:it.~ 32
1. 5 *&~~-f~~** 34
1. 5.1 *lV~~a*-~:.tl.i<.~DMAIC 34
1.5. 2 ~~;f;&.~i~:.it~:.+l;\ 36
~ 2. *j§'ta~liju:t;.J!. 38
2.1 :it:fItt1.t£.ltI! 38
2. 1. 1 :it:fI~ Jt51.. 38
2.1.2 i±::t¥..:6i. -tA_~iij*7,r 40
2.1.3 1ft{tftEj:iii!.4tll] 41
2.1.4 :ii:fI.l;jlfR~~,~ ~ fr9:X:t 42
2.2 NJi-i: 1; *j)-;f;f '" 44
2.2.1 Ai.iIi-i:fr9iJ,.ji] 44
2. 2. 2 )ijj-i:~ -t" Ej Ai.iIi-i:.t1JlJt 45
2. 2. 3 jjIj.$.4t4%-MJ Jj9;:!: 47
2.2. 4 Ai.iIi$4t4%-fr9~;f;f 49
2.2. 5 *it)ijj.$.~*fr9#1t. 50
2. 3 MifM* .. · .. · .. · .. · .. · ·· ·· · .. · ·· .. · ·· .. · · .. ·· · .. · 50
2.3. 1 i!:if.lt~3!tJt ~;fij'# 50
2.3. 2 Jj<..-+~);t. 54
2. 3. 3 Jilt :4}-lItjt 56
.. 3 ill *l!i"~~:I.ifi~tf:J!l 66
3. 1 * i!i1;j$~~ ~ ~~ 66
3. 1.1 *i!i1;§~~ ~ ~~J.5tJlIJ 66
3. 1. 2 *VEJ#-~~ ~ ~.ttIt:fI. 67
3.1. 3 *i!i1#-~~ ~ ~-1t1;i.iI;fr9I'Q]:H! 70
3. 2 *i!i1#-~~ ~ iL~4l:fPit~] · · · .. · .. · · .. · · · 71
3. 2.1 ~ ~ ic.~-*--$>H~!] .. i!. 71
3.2. 2 ~ ~ J;!t*,I].I..J!. 73
3.2. 3 ~ ~.:t..#i 75
3. 3 *VEJ;§~~ ~ ~FA..Jti.lt· .. · .. · .. · · · · .. · ·· .. · · .. ·· · .. ·· · .. · 75
3.3.1 [ij FA..¥"mJt_:;fp.:ftlx. 75
3.3.2 [ij j!J...~J&.FJt-a 77
3.3. 3 ~ FA-#} iJ Ej!t3tt 78
3. 3. 4 ~ j!J....I..J!. 80
3. 4 *i!i1#-~'!Ii ~ Jltt.tEj110!~.f · · · · · .. · 83
3.4.1 '!Ii I§J *llt:;fpJlt~ 83
3.4. 2 1Jt*-~.f 85
3. 5 *~.~~ ~ f"~Ej ~*,IJ .I..J!. 88
3. 5. 1 *iP H:l :... 88
3.5.2 **00 .. · .. ·· .. · 89
3. 5. 3 ~ H:l 90
3.5. 4 ~1':f.H:l 91
3. 5. 5 it 51:. 4<e. ~ III 92
3.5.6 i:!:;fli:k:J(fI.JtJII 93
3.5. 7 jji]~JII 95
3.6 ~'.,~~~~~,tit~)iVlt1f'¥ ·· 97
3.6. 1 *~~~~ g) ,ft·M 98
3.6. 2 *,g,~~~ ~ Jli..*1f'¥ ~~.:f 99
~ 2 lIi DMAIC liffl.'l . .. .. .. . .. . 103
~ ,4,. W:iE 105
4.1 .JF-Jt~ro~~ 105
4· 1.1 ~iAjilL~:#::4t~*- 105
4· 1. 2 :it;fl~ SIPOC~;Vf- ~ 106
4· 1. 3 :#:: 4ti:!:fI.ft t!r ~ ~~ ~ Jt~-#f111 m * 109
4.1. 4 ~ g) ~;fHU~:#:::-t~# 112
4· 2 ~Jt~ g) iJIlJ-J:";flft;f. 113
4.2.1 :#::4t$i.'#'t1, CTQ ~WOO~:1t 113
4.2. 2 ~_;lJ!u-f:;flf# 114
4·2.3 J!ux~g)~,g,~~*1- · · .. • .. • · • .. · .. • • .. ·115
4. 3 !A1'Iitj;fp:;t-l-~ g) _;lJfli:'*- 115
4· 3. 1 ~ ~ 1t~ 115
4·3.2 1~J!/tJt.~;fpg)#~M;it. 116
4·3.3 Jfli: ro ~lil J9~;fpffl FAif:-~ 117
4· 3. 4 Jfli: g) it 3l.lj .. . .. . .. . .. .. . .•. 118
4.3.5 Jfli: g) ji_~~#l1IJ 118
• 5!j! .J. .. 121
5. 1 l±;fl~;Vf- ~ xtJi 121
5.1. 1 ~/.i:.f1.1fl 122
5.1. 2 V5J*OO~ V5J*~~ 124
5.1. 3 Jt.~iifI.J)-# .r..J!.19 x~ 126
5. 2 .. *~~g$tit£.llI: 128
5. 2. 1 .**£.llI:~jp" 128
5.2. 2 ~;fIt.~ -J:J,l~1)i' 132
5. 2. 3 ~ "* JJl!l,:J5] 1ii.~ :-t _£ .............•.....•..........•..•..•..•.••..•.••.•.••... 137
5.2·4 'f JfJ 9Ij ~.31'-Aji" 139
5.2.5 't JfJ fIlJ:l!J,tJ)-1)i' 142
5.2. 6 'f'.;:;:4:1lJ~Jtg 147
5.2. 7 AA..it"'~~#1t::$" 148
5. 3 ~.lr?Jit. .. ¥jf~ 151
5.3. 1 jt.~1!Ej~N~JtJt 151
5.3.2 . Jit. .. ~.l¥J7i* _. 152
5.3. 3 ~#7i* , 153
5.3.4 ;#4i<£AtM.it7i* 155
5.3. 5 ~.l¥J m .r-7i* ; 158
5. 4 iJI~-:I:' H-tt~# 166
5·4·1 .£.-*-#t$ 166
5·4·2 lJIll-l:" ~ttlr?~jf iJ ..................................•......................... 168
5.4. 3 ll~-i"~ttlr?1iJ1t,~·t±;fI>e:.t.·ti. 170
5·4· 4 iJI~ -I:" ~ ttlr? ~ .t_.):t_Ej -ItJJt!At. ................................•............... 173
5.4· 5 «~·):tj;\ftlr?lJIll-l:" ~M.1t# : 181
5.4.6 _£·):t1t.ft.lr?lJIll-I- ~tt~# _ 184
5.4. 7 itl'l;f1X.~fFJa*~~:.t. ~ 187
5. 5 it:f1tlt}]~# , 190
5.5.1 it:f1M.it:J2-i!iJ);!k.;5 ............................•..................•............ 190
5.5. 2 it;f.lnt}]~it:f1*j{_ , 191
5.5. 3 it:f1tlt}].tlf~ C, Ej Cti< 192
5.5.4- ii:f1fllt.h ;flf~ Cpn~ C/mk 195
5.5. 5 itU.!tj{_,flf~ Pp Ej P t* 197
5.5. 6 ii;f1.~It.h,f!f.Ej4ilt~.fFJ*~ .. · .. ···· .. ···· .. ···· .. ·· ·· ··· .. ···· .. ·· 199
5.5. 7 *JfJlfl~iJ Ej~JfJlnltiJ 201
5.5. 8 4J:..iE.;5~.l¥J 1:.~ 202
5.5.9 _£·ti.1t. lr? iliJi$.~J]<.-t1! ~ 205
.. 6. *:tJT 208
6.1 :W.-t·):t_a.~#¥it:f1~# 208
6.1. 1 :W.,*,.):t,jt.~# 209
6.1. 2 li:f1~# 215
6.1. 3 .~.1*it~gfa]1irit 219
6. 2 1li. ii.~~ 224
6.2. 1 1li.i.t~~lr?.l.-*-#t$- 225
6.2. 2 ~1t.,7i.£;fI> tt1J~ lr?1li.i.t,;t.§- 230
6.2. 3 It.~ •• ~.!lt 240
6. 2. 4- ~...t~1:ILJt,;t.!lt 242
6.3 :;;titjf-;j:Jt 244
6. 3.1 .:ifmlf~ ltjf-# 244
6. 3. 2 i11J ml f ~ it jf- # .. . .. . .. . .. 250
6. 4 11] lTlt* 256
6.4. 1 ~.:ftA1 .. :tt~.~ 256
6.4. 2 1Ij*;j..a<i~_;i..,t1.:tt~~* 257
6. 5 4~ ~.:tt ~ 263
6.5. 1 .ff-5-:tt~ 264
6.5. 2 ~-,t#Jt.-.)j.A~# .t.:tt1Jk 269
6. 5. 3 J! *:# Jt • .ff-5-iU~$- 272
6.5.4 .t-t-J!Jf-t- *-~;f~J!Jf:tt~ 275
6. 5. 5 • {l ~ _;i.. ,11. a<i *:tt -¥t .. . .. . .. .. . .. 277
6. 6 ;f~ * jf-.fJf ~ U!1 ~3 jf- # 279
6. 6. 1 _;j:~ * jf-;j:Jf 279
6.6. 2 -Jt~A1..U!1~3il~ ~ 282
6. 6. 3 J Jtt.lt·t1.. U!1 ~3;j:l~ 290
.. 7. ~:i! ; 296
7. 1 1;!;,~i§tit ~J:I: 298
7.1. 1 io\~itit ~a<i~-*-~i~ ·· ·· · .. · .. 298
7.1.2 io\$-itita<i.l..-*-,m-.!ilt] 303
7.1. 3 io\~itita<i ~,~.t1.. 304
7.1. 4 io\~itita<i ~~ 305
7.1. 5 1;!;,~itita<i .. ~'ll:i*.ff~ 306
7. 1. 6 1;!;,~it it a<i.l..-*- ::v • .. 307
7. 2 .:if ~ -r-io\JJtitit l:i ~# 308
7. 2. 1 .:if f.tJ jf- ~ it it .. . 308
7. 2. 2 J :ljl[ i\. U!1 ~3 .. . .. . .. . 310
7. 3 ~ ~ fitit l:i jj-;j:Jf 314
7. 3.1 ~*-t±-I!lfio\$-.j£_ 314
7.3. 2 ±-~-ti§tita<iit~tJ 316
7.3. 3 1:-~ -ti§tita<ijf-tIj- 318
7.3. 4 1:-~ fitit ~1J~ 323
7. 4 ~~I!l-tio\$- ~ 340
7. 4.-1 ~jj-I!l-r-io\-¥t n::- 340
7.4. 2 ~jf-~;#..~-tio\-¥ta<iitM 345
7.4. 3 ~£--~~~ -r1R.~fI!J£--#~1f'J 347
7. 4. 4 Plackett-Burman it it-J1-~ ~:i! ~ -ritit 356
7.4. 5 ';_7]<.-t~£-- ~ f-ii.$-fI!J £--tJj- 356
7.5 ,,;, il 'III11f7itit ~ £--# 359
7.5. 1 ~il1il11f7itit .. i{:;- 359
7.5. 2 -PJil1il11f7Rit99it~.'J ; 1 364
7.5. 3 -PJilllb1f7Rit997}-#J,l~if~ 365
7. 6 ::llt1t*JM:.itit· 375
7.6. 1 ::llt1t*:aitit99;j:l~ ; 375
7.6. 2 it1t*:aitit99it~j 380
7. 6. 3 lt1t*,ttit it ~1f~ 7}-# 382
7. 7 i~*i.tit ~ 7}-tJj- 390
7.7.1 ilt.#i.tit .. * 390
7. 7. 2 i1t.##\.~99 it :l!,IJ .. . .. . .. .. . .. .. .. . .. .. 392
7.7. 3 i1t.*#\.~99jf-# ~ 396
7. 8 i}lJf/[.~Jf. 400
7. 8.1 iJlJit.~Jf. .. ~ ; 400
7.8. 2 i}lJit.:iiiJf.~* 400
.. 8. ~$J 402
8. 1 ;f.;l~J fft-a"it , , 402
8.1.1 li>t~?tlZl:~~99j:_*H-t· · .. · .. · .. · .. ··· · .. · .. ·· .. · · · · 402
8.1. 2 ;t_j:,j:t:f1.#:~lit:l!,IJ ; 403
8.1. 3 ~~#~99ii;f_~)J!IJi:>fP;jt~J 404
8. 2 'tJJl.-tt~J III 404
8. 2. 1 #: ~J III fI!J £~ .. $- .. . .. . .. . .. .. 405
8.2. 2 iti:"#:~J 00 413
8.2. 3 it4t;j!l~J!Il 419
8. 3 #~¥J4t~J m 423
8. 3. 1 J ~::f.7;jt~1 III 423
8.3. 2 ~,ttjp~m-~-tM];j!l~I!ll 427
8.3. 3 4iH.JIR±;f-tJt.itl:Vf£;jt~I{t~ 429
8. 3. 4 1i!i;f.1l~J 429
II 3 Ai M:§~F!jt\N.t&~~it 431
.. 9. "A.~r 433
9.1 ftji±;f-«it 433
9.1.1 ;ftA1..j&¥;j& l..21itJk 433
9.1. 2 itA1..j&¥;;j;t,~:~,~ 434
9.1.3 itjt1..j&Ej##t1..j&-ilA¥;J:I::.t: 435
9.1. 4 itA,~~¥;.£.tffi~'*-ffi9!~ 435
9. 2 ;fkA1..j&¥;4t;f,..'*~21j:_~L;Jf-tt.:f... 437
9. 2.1 :tf;A1..j&¥;-tt*'*~ 437
9.2.2 :;ti&.ii#J A1..j& 438
9.2. 3 :hl]~1t1..j&~it1i-¥;,~:it~w.1Jij~ 440
9.2.4 i9:.1i-¥;~JJ:.i[>I~_$-ttnt1t:1l:.jl_ · .. · · .. · ··· ·442
9.2. 5 #;1!1t1t~ 443
9.2.6 5S E; !§J i.li!..ofJJ: 445
9. 2. 7 m 1f,h1t~ li-.4trfillJ?f 447
9. 2. 8 1:-i11..j& ~-tP 448
9.2.9 1fIi1ijJ .. OO ~iJf 452
9.3 itAtE; 7;;~i$-~¥;M~ 458
9.3.1 lttA1..j&E; _,\ ~i$-~¥;#A21J:t-tX 458
9.3.2 i.t.iiE; ~\ ~i$-~¥;;(f;fJT..M~ 461
9.3. 3 ,**A*v!l-M·~¥; ~.#..~~j.tt*~~ 462
~ 10. *a;ft~i9:i.t 465
10. 1 7;;~i$-Jl!ritit.i£. 465
10. 1. 1 7;; ~ i$-~it it ¥; j& 1..~ itJk 465
10.1.2 ~\ ~i$-~itit¥rf:~~5<.. 466
10.1.3 ~\ ~i$-~i.itit~Jrt;f1E. 468
10.1.4 ~\ ~i$-~1tit~:i- : 470
10.1.5 _,', ~i$-~i.itit¥;-1lPf·:~m 471
10.1.6 ~\ ~i'$-~*-it¥;_i_~..r..J!- 472
10.1. 7 j&Ji,1:-Ji:~%l$Jl¥; ~\ I!ll:i'$-~~;}t;t-t ; 474
10. 2 ~1t:rfJ~tJk7t··· 475
10. 2. 1 ~it 475
10.2.2 QFD ¥;)!.,*-;ti!- 476
10.2.3 QFD ¥; ..r..1t:t1..;f 482
10.2.4 ELm T1Wllt:1l:..t5'r¥; QFD 487
10. 3 ~#ti.itit .. · .. · .. · ··· .. · .. · .. · .. ··· .. · .. · ··· · .. · .. · .. · .. · · .. · 489
10. 3.1 *-#t*-it¥;)!.'*-},f!.JJ:~:;t* 489
10.3. 2 Miki~lt,l±)liJ;R§_¥;JJ:* 490
10. 3. 3 TRIZ ;;5- * WI M::ttl tf.. $. 493
10.3. 4 ··Mlt·~rp):J!WI?}*;;5-* 495
10.3. 5 -€JJxt,~f"l:J!WIM*=~* 499
10. 4 *6~4t.ii.it .. ·· .. · ·· .. · · · .. · · .. · .. · · .. ·· · 503
10. 5 $:.'£ ii. it ·· 503
10.5.1 JJt-I-.:iM;tJit4t. 503
10.5. 2 :t.,£69~5t.~* 504
10.5.3 !1. ~ ,!1.'J'#·~69:t.,£itit 509
10.5.4- !1.k#,t±lt?:t..£i.tit 510
10.5.5 it4t'*li- 511
10.6 FMEA?}* 517
10.6.1 FMEA ~li-WIitm ttlJJ 517
10.6.2 FMEA ~li-WI?}~ 518
10.6.3 FMEA 69-AltiI;f 518
10.6.4 DFMEA?}* 519
10.6.5 PFMEA :0'-* ~ 524
10.7 tf1{.i] X 69ii.it 530
10. 7. 1 lir f<i:J X ii. it 69 ..w..{Il .. . . . .. . . .. .. . . .. .. . .. . . . . .. . .. . .. . .. . . . . .. . .. .. .. . .. 530
10.7. 2 lirf<i:J$tJxt~*-~frlJii.it 534
10.7.3 lirf<i:JA..$.-69itit 535
10.7.4 iIi1 f<i:JiA:..!ltl¥Ji.tit 537
10.7. 5 iIi1f<i:J1ifi".~~~1t,~l¥Jitit 538
10.7. 6 ti1f<i:Jt.s-J1Jl~frlJitit 539
10.7. 7 ti1f<i:J~~l¥Jitjt 540
10.7. 8 ti1{.i].x:.~~ -tfrlJitit 541
I'H" -*-... 542
'fm~ .. ~~~'f'.t:j:___g-j.iJ't~I· ·· .. · · .. ·· ·· .. · ·· .. · .. · ·· · 565
.;f x.4t .. . .. . 577
'f'~Jl'l:i;lJ.4t~:I1IJ-*~~~.~ .. ::fiA'.#:I! 580
A~1±% a<J mtil:7lifW m kJ.:Ul1i JlJ ~ ~ at 1-t, !fiHIJ! tt;f: Jet. a<J J9tJtif II rn ~ Ji!t~:lA 20 tlttc.tn 7f:lla a<J 0 lAJIt, A~1f AT kJ.1JOI f1L~ 1t, f~~Ummft, 5~f:it>:1ti$T1t ~~iiE a<J I.ill'. ftat1-t c
mtfiifJll!.ffit~ a &P2{:Jl{, ~~JJ7*)XI,~*~,fJ}.?t **. AW~~'lfIlR:J9t:l:'lfJll!tE 20tit~*fi~tiha<J~2{:Jl{Z~.AW~~'lfIla<J®~,2t~;KR:tE~:I:.~~*~ J9t:lt1fJll!2t~ a<J * 'W1l( r :i1!:1ia<J o
1. Jt -I- • .t- tr? iJ! ltt ~~~.ifIl.rt*~~*~~~2t~,~:l:a<J.~~~~~~~,~1t~~~.tE ISO 9000: 2000 fif-ll9=t, J1lt:l:*;.E)(~ "-mml1f~ttt.llfJE~*tG~1t" c
( 1) J9t:l:.~ 9=t .:E 1* tG ili{:111o J9t:l:.&: 9=t1l9 ±. 1*m Il9 R: " it -2. J¥.J J9t 11", 1& ,II« ~ :i1H19 ifiFf, m ~ifi~ :
.• f=&ta<JJ9tiL :.fgfflttW, mffif£~~!fmmt:lL
• f=&lrfll~ll*tGmt:l: c it JlJlJ{gfflllat3t11, mJMatrSJ~HIl*mtit e
• ~£.~*~MWa<Jmt.ca9=tMfiJ9t:l:(&.I~mt.)~*5WE(A,m, ~, }!. ~. 11). ~attGmt.BR:1*~ Q (~!fmJ.m::lt), c (~*). D (3t1>t) , E (~ :It), S (~~) ~1l9~*mt ••
• f=&lr. ~Il*, i1fiffi~*ll9mt:l:. i!j!a<J1**mtiiI!P'lfJ!l!*~a<Jmt., ~~1fB!.mt :I:,~g~:I:,m~R:-~m~tG~fi~mJ1lt:l:,~.?tm~~-~1fm~~~1*~~~~ :I: (~n l=j J@(1ffll#tmn€ljtGfk1*-**J1lt:lt, l±IKt~ 7lrm:tr 1m::l:) •
H~, ~~-~J9t.E8 "/J/' .?t "*" agili{:ilti1fi.
(2) J1lt •• 29=t1fi*tG~*o mt:l:.29=ta<J1f1*mtGR: "~JEft-2.~*a<JJ1Ii::I:", 1& JHUiHltB9JI!mJ'f, m~:i3~:
.~*ttJ1Ii::l:c~JE~li~.~~*, ~~M,&z~~~~c
• 5!.fflttmtil c mt.~tl~:t.llfJEJij{~~~~WJ3t, mtl:~~M-*tJ!#Mf@t~R:~Jgm c
•
• ~t: l:t;fg:k1r~,*nw~ ~ J9J:"iL lktBt Erti.J9iit e. f2~f=' 8l., ~!Hs, i:t l'Uu1$. * ~ «1::.
J.m:J1:" ~,*~)EJiiJ!~, JB!:*, _MI, mmz~bti1tftk#, t±~~f!JM;jti*1ra9W}jL
mtii'1fl_l*JIfIi*~tE «*~mtil~;IlIt» (1$ 5!l&) r:pj!f-ftlHU. 20 tltf2. 80 iFft. "* mtjl" a9.~~1tIT}~ A fnllT~~. iiJil(;1'1/FIlJ;i!~a9~~ 0 iE:1i!::(£j!f-f--t mtil.~iJ ~~i1iOt~ (8 iFft. A gg tlf f13'fl_l~1:. T 0 f5I I1t. A lffl* f13 'fl_l7*7*:lt!!Jr .L T "*mtil" .~ a913$o 21 tltf2.~!OO:it(8tltfG, !JFI!P "*mtit" a9t1tf2.o :(£j!f-f--t "*mtit" a9atf-t, Alffl~~'1fl_l~~§tIt.:(£tltW~~~~~~o
2. $ -f: of Jl'. fr{J ~Al
#~~mt •• ~Erti~a,~ftmt.'1fl_lill:(£~*o~~*I~~~OO~(8mR#.~ iI'1fl_lm~Tmtjl~~,~*~.~~~~mJ.m:.'fl_l~*lli~~~o~=~tltW*~~ frrijJ~tftF~-~~, jjj_1it$~~.~1ji~~; 20 tltf2. 40-50 ~f-t1'1~=~~. jjj_#f$ ·~~ttmJ:it~$JM-~; ~~M-tlt~ 20 ittre 60 ~ft*Mia9~m.&t:l:'1fl_lM-tlto
(1) mJ:it~~M-~o mJ:.~~It:@Vit*, tE~Jtgtfjjj$J1:.f='~f4r. 1:.F1lR~~~~ ~~m~**owtltre~.~.m.~*1:.F(8W., •• ~~~1:.f='~ ••• *.W *oj!-M-~±~~~TI~1ji(81rA*~~~~~FW~~Ar~Iff(8f='~mt •• ±~ ~M~.Ere*o~~*mW1'1:IA§.,I*~ •• ~,.~_M~~o~m~*~~ OOI'I9~1g1J (F. W. Taylor). ft!!if!~ "f4~'fl_ljgz;fj" ag~¥A. ~W T~~'fJJIJJI~, ~ *~1lR~ag/F~*Bi1JJIag*I,e~~mJ:.~.tF1'1-~'fl_l~.~1:.FM@r:p*.W *, @il T ~~~1t:g1Hl ~~.$mL 1PJft;J, ~r*1tt.1:.f='I¥1F~1t*f"~$.ag@ill!l0 ftWml¥J~~.~1'1.&t.~~~~T~~o
~at.mt.~.ff:(£~-t±~~m:-~*Fo~ •• ~~:(£1:.FMWr:p*Bm~~~ $J. miiiJMT~F!lffImi;/], ~fa:.~.agf-tffi-. f51I1tAff1tt!$z.~ "9EJ§".'p"; =:1i!:~~ ••• _ijjt*:*~. ~}jIJ:1i!::(£mt~tt •• ~f4r1!~~~*B 0 a'llJt~~~ttmt.~$Jl_I~ 1¥1i1!!1:. 0
(2) ~ltEJ::l:ltftjlJID't~o ~ltmJ::I::lt$J (statistical quality control. SQC) M-tltftZ;m T 20 titre 20-30 ~ft, ]f}Jil(;r 40-50 iFf-to j!-M-fJ!:~~1iE:1i!:~l_I~*:ni!~mJ:.'1f l_I(8.~,~ •••• m.~.".J§"re*",~ •• Mfi~ •• ]f}.T •• ~~Mtt~ $J~.Fo~.;jti~~(8'fl.l1rAo
:(£1:.~~.i;/]r.~*.(8mm~Tm*a.oWmrew.~.oo.~*.$~ (R. A. Fisher) ~~~~~.~tf:l1rft?ttJT~iA~ii*~mi£, 1'1j[f~~l_I~*$~~7 ~~o~~IPJft;J.~oom~~~~Jil(;ilT~-t~MM~m:--t~Uw~.m,$*~. A:!iH***f (W. A. Shewhart). ~tlm7~ltM@~$J (statistical process control, SPC) JJIi£, ~.T mffl~lttt*.X>t1:.FMfi(800:~; J3--t~FJl,~*Jm •• *fft1tA~jli>~ (H.F.Dodge). ftk~IPJ$~*~ (H.G.Romig) *Bna:W •• I¥J~~, :(£19294=~~T «Mf-f~~1r~»,*ii*T~magMW~~~,m~7~~~~~.~tt@~~mfflr:p1¥J Wx1L
~ 20 titre 20-30 ~f-t~tf:lMN~$Jl!I~~1Iitf-ft't~m~z~, t(:t:iigg:n~~OOjt~ T~mJf~atM. wr~j!.@jfJ.!l!~zAfilJ$o 1t~Jm=1X1itW*~MJa], EBrOOMI~i!i m~~*~~* ••. j!@l_Ii£~~~}~mmo__t~JJI~I¥J~~mm~*~~.~~T
Jtt~iA1iJ, ~J§JX\,h~1!tjlL
~it1Jt!tJ9mffl~YT/Fif:m~, IIoffa:T 1:.f=:ftfflo mYttrMl:.~$H:1:'HjM~tr1J f!, M! A 1(J~iA.1:71OO::I: ~J1l~;:I!tfE it1Jf!. ffjj _§_ :(E~z tr. m In fAJ!I!~ it~ flj: j(jq tJ9tA' No 'r. if $ A~¥Jj~lf*. MItt<:5Il ft it*~1f 1:. f=!¥J utili:, ~ I(nj r- ~ 100:. I'J9 JZ3 ~i!!BIH~ $, iJtM! *.~it1Jf!:;fPJ figfWlk:-tJ] &:S: 1'6] f! 0 &:S:1lfJ1l fiT lItJE rtJ ~ YEIW I'J9J1U& 0
(3) ~W&:S:1lfJ1lwrRo 20 1ft~ 60 &f:ftr.olE, MItt<;f4~~*lnI~1:.rz:I'J92tR{, X>t 19tit~ ~*~jIH~~, i!~~~ AffJ~m "~YtIW" {J{Jl!l~, ~ Ni:iitfil]m1f~-1'-fltJL tH~tJfll;H;:~if,H1TliJf~, ~ni~m. ~:UW. ~1t_lfk_ 1'81lf J1lo ~ oo)im It! ~ 01iJ (fJ • .f{H~ m (Feigenbaum) tJJtt/lH::b T ~OO~.~J1l (total quality control, TQC) 1'J9.~, 1961 ~:(E~«~m •• 1lf.»-~~mw: "~oo •• ~J1l;:l!~T~:(E.~fil'J9*~k*~ • • ~*mg.$.*I'8*#r~ff~.liJf~.Rtr.1:.f=:fI1~*,re~~*.nl'J9liJf~& •• !lH~&.l!l~reJ &.l'8mi;IJfignlt-1*£8:ff~1*~ 0"
a *iE 20 1!tfc 50 &f:ft51~~00i19&.~J1l1Jft:Ja-. X>t~~fiT~JifW~. ~W T ~ 0P.l&.~J1l (company wide quality control, CWQC). tJ-€.tlT ~"ifJ!I!.IJ .. m (quality control circles. QCC) 1It!. IE D1If! (Taguchi method), 5S 1tll. (a)c Seiri , Seiton, Seisou, Seiketsu, Sits uke , ap ~ J.11!.- m: iijt. m $. mE In. ~). ~ 00 1:. f= ~ tp (total productive maintenance, TPM). 1OO:.J}J~R{:1f (quality function deployment. QFD) l!l $- IE 1:.f=1Iit (Toyota production system, TPS) ~, Jafll) T "~-t:;fJI", "jf-t;fJI" IA *~~mT •• &~ln •• ~M,~~OO •• 1lfJ1l~~T::k.jfi19~~o •• ~lI.l'J9~~ ~~~mT~.YEtr,ffjj£~m~~m*fJI~J1l~*l!l1Jf!o a*~~mm~OO&.ifll. 1*f' Tt&::kl'8n1tW. 51~T1ttJ}\t*OO!¥J*tf:. ~OO1OO:.ifl!l!¥J~~iE~~MmtP3f'J1J)i£ W •. &OOMif*ei19~.R~.W:ffm~.~~Ji.
1979 &f:. ~OO&.1lfJl1(~~~:wrlt (Crosby) WJl&Tf1!!l'J9:1ftlt;t,1f «mI:.~Jt~fifO JE.&i:ii !¥JZ:/f'» , fifO 1l. T "~-IXi:>re¥.1Mt~t" l!l "~~~" I'8I!1 le 0 "~~ ~" {J{J ImlJi ~*JJf:9!IJ:~: IlJJfifOiW:t, ~%-Bt~, -IXifoij". ;f4~if ••
1987 &f:;:I!&:fi'ifJ1l2tR{~L.I~ !¥J-&f:: 00 1ij\:f~11Htmg;t~1fi TJt~-~~J1I!fIF It-ISO 9000 *Jtlt~1t, ~J.l!Z~~itjt~(fJ.:l:1*~iAiiEE8J1tt.:L:1f~.; .;J{;~tJL~PJ tE,~!i!i 70 ifftJt~**,Jag~ilflL~W7'\Iffl~~1If!*:(E0PJiE~~:6t; !l!mm4tr 1987 ~:ii:i:1:T «.Q,$f4m· ilt$.m*00~mI:.1Iitlir!- "0~f!~ 100-107"». ttc}E~;lJt1t $.m.~ ••• ~W*.~~~W1tt~M.ft~~ooI.*.~.~a*ag~R{.~ TQC btR{¥Ij TQM (total quality management) ~*{J{J-1'-" .mW~, -Jg TQM mJt T -1'-"
M:i:1:W J1J~ * as -'i!~!'ft3'&iftft;jg~ 0
m TQC rtJ TQM ~i!i{~. ~.k:m.:I:.~m "f=~~DIl*ll •• JEJi!Jl$~~" rtJ "::k~HilmJEJij!$RltJ*1I~~", .:I:~l!I!.m "-i:W{J{Jmtit..,l!I!." IPJ "~OOml::ltagff J1l" {J{Jllii~.OO~fffi1titmtJl.tE ISO 8402: 1994 a:p~ TQM }E)(1g "-1'-m~t.lJ.l.~ 9=' 'L' , t.l ~9t~~ ~ ~ilfl , ~ ~iE TiM:i:1:it.$nl1t~fIl*mg;tNr 1f ,QX;~ a f.±4t~ id ffij:i2l¥!1 *MJVt:9JEt9'ifJ!l!:it~", m~~-f*jl-'i!~t£1fi191§""tl!l1Jf!o m11~fiiJ~@m~HJ9 TQM? 11~ fiiJiffi5 TQM i{¥IJftz..Wlt. nIt~11f1fij? ~!lfijijUJIj~1:f'1fJ!l!~tt~f:Uailfm4t, *~l;1J:f~ ~~.it!~~jf, ~$f"reJifJ.!l!!¥JnIt~*~? T;:I!Ji!~~~ (100:.~) :tlAJ.iilllimJ1:.. ]V¥
~~~m~~~~~~~~~*~~~~.~T~~~~ ••• (m.~).~. ~.~ ~~~ ... ~~~ .• ~.~~.~~.h.* .. ~.~.~ •.. ~~=*m. ~:~OO~$~*~.m.~,~~m.~~s*.~~,~~~$~*oo.m.~~~ ~OO~~~~mh~»~.~~OOOO.~.h~~mm.~nW®~T~~~m,~~~ 19i7Zo
19Tm~aOO*a~m~~~m*,~MAmm~ft~.~.~,~.~m.~oo~ $I.OO ••• ~~a*.~~~W~.~.~k, ~OOm.~~~2001~~~T~m @::lt1f~sl;tif$I~, jfjA 20051rF:ffJz€j. *JtJT~§.ljlf1ff~rnI.f.f-fl GB/T19580 «Jii~. 3&WffrflmU» ~ GB/Z19579 «Jii.~.ifffrfl9tU~jjIiIJ~m» Ottffi?m:!lIl00 1-1 ~7.f-) 0
iii 1-1 GB/Tl9580 ~ GB/Z19579 m!'Nil1li
4-3(, ••• 3tt,t~tA;B~1gml1-t TQM a9~Diif1f~~if1ftfl9t~, ~J;j1£:.ill'.~~1f~$ ~_t~OO~f.jflo lEflo*~it±~~, lj! •••• Aa9i7Z~ •. ~J_: "~1g~~ TQM pg~l'J9.i1gJt~I'J9}E5C' 0
3. £-1" *-$li fl91tit
~m •• ~~.Mm~ili.T~$ •• W~* •. _~OO~~*~,.~.*~ .• 11H!!dJ. :R:~WTrt, ·li;.glt!-I'J9*i@;~m, B *1'J9Q")I'., EB t1~ -~, ftfn~A1rJ:xtm.1k l!It.1fI!l!ffTJ!*-~l'J9iJd.R, xt •• 'lf~~~J"UIl:it!~® T §*a91&~tFm. ~_mflj~ frfflJt~.~~I'J9JLfJl,
(1) W. A. ~*f¥ (l891-19671¥-L iRt~· ~~i@; • ~*t# (W. A. Shewhart) ili ::i::~~~ #t;f1j *#tfH ~ ~:tX '1'.m, 1917 1¥-~f~ 1m 1+1 *'F1S J2;;f1J?t-:f3Hm ~f!I!~ft±$f\l, 1918-1924 ~{H!j1f~~0WJ (Western Electric) ffIW!liJi, 1925-1956 ~f.f9HR~!1i 'is:liFfJElQ, WlfEiJ5tmft1t~*~, Wi*)(~I'F~. ~~:&.ill'.mHjJf~1:.~~fP1.Jti#$.
~*t¥1t ±~ T xt gs:nlt! '=\:% RJ EJffblJ ii r: Jl. tf{J!Wftt 3f: Rt 8{J ~ t± fIl x;j1JlJ *F 3ti * a<J Wf Jl • ~~JLT!'Jttt:i1m~fbIJ (SPC) ~ito 19241¥- 5 JJ 16 8 f&!l!tb T1itN_tm~~iH~i~~m, 1931 ~2(7&~.lftF «fbIJnx;Jl.m5:l'J9~m~fljrJ». #Jf1f~fljrJ 00 J:iilffl iEgs:n It!. ~0RJ.~I r~ •• ~,~~~~~It!M.~a<J~~_t,.
~**,ff±:tEWf1Eq:r~i!@~?elJ, .~ r&NrtRI!llo~Jl. ~I'J9EJf7ff$~~~~1:.'i:~. liFfR':
~~~~#~~~~~~.a*~±~~~o£~~Hft~~~~~m~$~,m*.~ X!i!,?J!f~ffJ JiX;PI r.m iOO~ ~jj;~ a f1I! ,g, ~ tI:l j1ij ~ I~ ~ JJ1-fIIl. : (1) ~:1F~ ~ PI 3I:t. ~ ; ( 2 ) 4i~X!i!,m~JL.sp.~fmt*JJil(;1fX!i!,~.~*m 0 11 T #lJwr%i!$m~ffj~, PI LU:i1fX!i!,iJ!~mLU~T:1JA ~LU •• :-~:1JA~~ •• m.~Jil(;~:1JOO,~PJLUM~%i!~m~*$MR;~-~:1J A~* jffi X!i!,m~m~ M!f:i1f z. tE 00 _tJJ #., ~f-f.{j!ffJ Jil(;~ Jf:k: 00, J:3:X>t T %i!~fdQi~~ In ,P.iHlij ~~ #~ m 0 #.;JI€t* .3:3fEm fj!Jf:k: m * %i!?J!!I ~rM. f1I!:il!: - tV m ttl ffftlf m ~ '11 mEi': jF fI<J .@: [;51 : .1't-~ffIl;&'@: [;51, ~m ft~ '11 J§fr£IHlVNlti:9J ~ »~.@ f5l ~, Jt~ IIJIiI ~/J\, {!3_~jdi .H'~¥ Im;!tt~ jj;;Th;, '* m I=j=t J L'flU~J£fIIl. ;fU%i!j~ ~ ~* *f't: {n Jil1it:llI {C( H~M..IE;Th; * ;ffl; jt Jf I'!<J ~ - ~~f51~*~ft~~,~~~~m~~~~~~JJ1-~mm~*;ffl%~I'!<J¥~~mo~*~ t:! $lJ 00 ~ TffIl?& 1* f:5I etf% Jilt 1'8 .IE ~ * ;ffl f8 3 CJ .@:.mU}tj'[ T ~ gll ~ ffttJ W. ~, 1I:{ilJ 1& tE:t3: ~ W. mZ7~f8~~£~f'I'~ 1it~~f8X!i!,j~mtf5~~ PffjffifftE~ *mft1*f:5I, fi:r -T.ftIHi~* etf~~.!fm~,m~~fftE~.~##m~W3a ••• tI:l*om~,~Mm~X>tMW m~~~mH.fI<J~jFf8-~m~.~,~m~~OO:il!:IT~~MW~t:!.PJLUR~~Im~ *~I'!<J~~, #*~m~T~r.m~;fU~~o
~**I'!<JPOCA(IT~-~IT-~~-~~)M~I'!<J.~ •• ~~A)~mm.~~ iJ?J?& ~Elt:l:fi'J!UH.£A 1'!<Jt.f~I&:il!:fi'mmA;fU,~Ji:1JA 0
(2) W. E. Atf!13 (1900-1993 ~)o ~tt . ~~$~ •• I!ij CW.A. Deming) 1t± 1921 ~Ytf-ttffft~*$=IW$=±$={Jz:, 1925 ~tE#~j}I$*$=~j1HfaJ,t$=R#JJ!I!$=1Wf ±~Ul, 1928 ~YtJfflfj-*~4WfIIl.$=1f±~Ul.
1950 ~7f~, IVAm B *#$=tt;t~J~m:i!lif$iXlJjli3J B *, ijHfmtfifi'J!I!~W. at OOm~~A~mmIT~fit:!~(SOC)~~~~~M~tt,MmITmt.~~tES*f8~M fn1*tt®T§:kfI<JfFm. 1fMjiftiJ, 51®3{t$1!kr;fU~~rmi!:~)Jj(fflI9=t:ff 85%tET1£~I'!<Jfi' J!l!* m iffl Rfi15 % ~ Eb .m. I~Jilt ~ 0 it I!ij rm.&i ~ I'!<J~ 'L' £t~1tm m IT 1!ljji~ffttJ *iJUjrJ¥ ~fI<J~~~~fn~?&~~o11T~*B*mt.~~I'!<J£~, ~~~~X1B*I'!<JN~fnm Nit, S *7 1951 ~t2:1r Titf!l3~o f!3_~;IDJ 1980 if 6 jj, ~OOIE~U'--fl0PJ (NBC) frT 1Hi:hJ «:tlJt~ S *PJ!;1, 11ttz,.ftff1~H~?» 1'!<J1Il:i1!ZE •• 1!ij~tE~IE~Ft* ••
• ~JHB.:l::~,~,!£t~~ftal]tEf1B~lli~J1ltIt~m 14 ~#.I=j=t:
1) $IJJ£i!:l(jE:F&.l:Jlij~*1'81§ ;ftjfn~~l'!<Jit~J, ~jJ-Tmtl~~X>t~.
2) *mif~rm.~fIIl.,~!to
3) ~l.I:*3:kfi~~*:tif.fj~i1:.
4) ~~1£5tfft~~~{#J:iiZlll. ~ lli,~JiIt*:iifl!;11 § fffi 0
5) ~J3II.riiJ~#3&jJ-Ta:ll!:IfFf*1!VL
6) *fflIm{-tt¥,FtEMi:ffiJl[:1Jf!. 7)~*~~~h,*m~I'!<J~~:1J~o
8) m~_mI~-mmm\t
9) tJllffIH1Mi1i1, {m~~6Hiit, ~~, ~f=~$nmfIAilfF.
10) n'i~JJ~.®~*.m.I {$Jlj~~[s§litf.fj1::~jJ*1i~ 1=1-li}, miJttlit § ~, 1f£~.l:Jlfl!; ~F$~~~~~l'8iffl~~~I~Ii3J~~
11) ~r~I fFJEtlJi. f-tZLU 9!~1lRM!5~Ht 0
12) m~*;f!f!~uliiJ!nI~ EI BIi'F.IlIl::l:mf EI*a9~~o
13) iiir.~~m-ma9f.{1f;fil § ~!t!~tt~L
14) m.:V:{t~m1r~1!f~~$MEl9J~1'-~Irtc_t~ 13 *~jJIi'Fa9m$t
(3) J. M *~ (1904~ ). :tJW~· M • *~ (Joseph M. Juran) 1924 i:Fl*1~I!JIJe !$:i!i*~ ~ T- I~1t ~ ~±"F{1L. *" ~~ T~1Jn ~W1J ~ 9:.0 Fij 1I:~I r (Hawthorne Works) ~~$. 1926~, -1-*§m$~~'¥:l¥Iool?A (Jtr:p'E1A!i*~~~I]j1!*) ~AAJ.T itIr, *"1t1TJJ:!$~Hi'¥:7f2ta9IAlJl1J7*o *~ndlt~q:.1¥120 1-5¥:.iJlI1!fz-, £I.f'F ~iR~ A~I¥IW;j1- INifiliz -, fJJiT-€'jJ!a9~HiMtit$I fF:.
1928 &P. *~.~T ftBl¥I~-$*TlW:.I¥I1ifF, -*~7g «~tz:fii]111Hf9~it1J7* JiY:.m» IhflltT-o 1937~, *~~~a~1f.~~1l~f.t*"1i\l.mTmt.i:&:itL 1945 i:F, *~~ Jf#l:~.~lr~1JEt!.9:.0PJ, fF1JJ!kir.a9~WJ!fiIiJfJlIfF:o 1951 i:F. «*~Jjl:ilflflllJf;llJf» tI:I Jt!i. 11 ftB.1~ T IE ~ld "!IL
fit; iA. ~ lW::l:3fOJ, T !@t ~ a9 ~ *. tE fit!. I¥I « * ,>J: llft. f;llJf » (~5 1l!i) q:. X1 llftil a9 ~ 5l::l! :
I)Um." •••••• ~.~a9~~Mmf{tB~.R •• a9.@tz:~Mtt;
2) ".IlIl:J!:" ••• !€.T~ a.: llPi9:~JJ~®fffi~m:j[IfF: CiSI) !lIG~.Iil'~:PJ!t11~5OC, J@[~~w.f, J@[~~iJF~Et9&~.
*~iA.1J~~~llft.,~MMJ!ir.m~Et9~.~~1Jft;fil§~*~. §~~~*a9~ f.t(~mt.~~~~)~~tt~~MW**ffEt9oftB~1gtE~.~~~~r:p~~m.mEt9= 1-tt~::l!:m:l: •• ,m:l:~~;fiIm •• *. ~*~Et9*,>J:m.~~=.~.fIt!.~uAa9 ~lt" 1JOAllftil'lfJJl!.ttfl. t1!m.1f~Mi~7 tt*a9~it~.
1954~, *~m±EiZ B *#.!f:1t;:fll*Ml¥J:it'!if. fJJ a *1Jr:piWigff~A~ i1t~m. 'lJ~ilNo 19791f. *~J!ir. T *~~~. ~Jl4-t:BJilt1Jitt3'it_t®t5ta9m:l:ff~~mJ0 ~.*1-$~~~*,*~~llft.ftft~*;fiI1J7*X1~1-ittWlW:.ff~~3'it~~T§*a9 J;~o
(4) .:filII. (1915~1989 i:F). -1iJII. (Kaoru Ishikawa), 1939 ~.$~T*jj!..*~ IfJ1*, 1960 i:F~IWplj±~{1Lo {tBa9 «@;t~ilJlj)) -i1~ u.I!JI~", "S * Keizai if J1B~" lJlI~;fffilt1t~o 19711f:, :1tllft:l:~iIJIJ~1fr.m § ~~OO@;.t>JJ.~ ":m~*f~." 0 19681f, 1i)II.tf:Ht&T «m.~1IJIJmj¥J»o ft!!~E§*OOa92tIlJ31W, m.ffJJI!JJ,m CQCC) ~.~AZ-.::l!~OO*~*m.~JJI!.~~lJl1J~~a*~.~.~l¥J~*.
1iJfI.iA.~, ~OOIdi:.ff~ (TQC) tEa *it::l!~0~m:l:ff~ (CWQC). A1*J*J $§Ui:
1) fJT~'liIHlt15$1JOa9Idi:.~~, llP:&~JYf~'liIH1~Affltl5~):], $~Idi:.'lJJJI!.; 2)~~.~~llft.~~. ~:&~~~~,m$ .•• *,~.A~,I.* .• fF:
A~,.mA~~~~Affl.~~,*.*~~~.,tt~.;
3) %;f,iltt191.ff~, llPV_.tljj:-1:ff:oo.1gr:p,L'. FPl(J;Ht*~*1'f~ (;fIJ?1i1, fft~ff~), fL.~J1I!. (~., ilHi, rHi), x~:Mtr:oo.o
(5) HHl1{"- 0924~ ). HHl-g - (Genichi Taguchi) it±:;I!f{~~it1i\lJflf1*
1Jm~.~~1!f,"mp1J~"l¥Ja~A,.~~~ •• 1W.
"ffiO~~"~*~*tt*:.*m.~~ .• ~m.~~.* •• ~tt*~~.N ittt*o "ffiQ~1!" tlf:I±ITm.t6!~P1§~ (QLF) 8911J{~. rem.~~ttfiW1-1i1_89. ~~-~*.~m.~~89~.~rr*~~~T¥~o~~~mTffi~~(SNR) 89. ~,~~.Nrrtt*~~T~89~~,~~~~~~~~u~89~~tt,~.ft~~~. ~~~rii]8:1f~ T ifT:l!12 0
"(I) Q~" ~I±I Ti£ifT~~:1f2tu@~it!:tr -=:.M-.f3!:ii:it89}~,1.!t, l!P *~Nit. ~fi itit:it. ~£itit:ito ~*~~mtriiJm. ~~rSJfI9.{t7j(f~l:l:fr. ~llll'l'&t~fI9~~o
"ffiQ~~"~.m~~.~,x~~~~~~~;~~m.ft~*~1!. X~%~ ~Ytrr%@.,Sr;*1i1f~m •• J1I!, ftl!.~I@~lI1tt*;@~1i1f~m •• ft~~ffln~, Jf..:ff iMm tt~~.ttfl9M~, ~~x •• ~"m.Iw~"o"(I)o~~"ifa*I~~ •• Tr~ ~m.***T§*fI9~M.~, §ftm~k.*.$fI9002if~m"ffiQn~"og. ffiQ~.itit:*n1!*~*i£-@~~L~,@~M.~~~~~~20m~$~fI9m •• ~4t~o
1. 1. 2 1\eBmlW~~8SJ~~;m6tnl
1. id~~~*fffl9~~
if. 1lJ1, *~ fI9 'Wi J:lJfF, ~ lk iUtH~ f.!ij TQC lI~-ftH_!I!_ ~ 89 '31 ~ r. a * Ara -fr;tt 00 '~X1m •• J!I!it!:trT*.l¥J~~lI1{WifT 0 20 t!t~ 70-80 &f:f-t. !~:i::t 20 $ifag1#~i&*, a *FJl.l19m.H$~~, 6@fT *$*~OOm:IM. mf~ 001i::jtl'J9F~ 9ltl:ii~~* ~ C. fI9 m~, if$~ 001i::jt oollffi~9Efft::I¥J['ii]Dfo
.H£~t'l. (Motorola) 0m[l'1J~1IifIIffi:#~9Ef¥t::fI9~.0 20 m&! 70 iff-tmAA.· *f£ ~~B~~~~*x.iMffiF£l¥J@f~~,*~.~~~tt~0~~~~M$*m-®$ ~*~1*F~fI9.*m~jftfl¥Jlli:fL 1974 &f:. 81-.*I19*~1*rfl}j1f 51-* ~ ~OO. 3 1-* ~ W\lJtIo fI:l1&'~*~1*mJiJl¥J~~~1-'Jl:1ir$:~~, fJU5l:(£ 51fJ§'l¥J 19791F. 81-.* IW~Jt~FJfIf~tt;ff 21-* ~ S *0 .tf;~t'l.i£ 19741F#flt!mm~j}~§€tT S *¥k"F, 1980 ifiE S *jt~ifWlWX~* T{f~mtmo S *AtI!MJ!:tf;~~if~OOfl9~lJftJtm~ ~@f~~m~~T~~0~~~tf;~m0~:1f~R~~BfI9['ii]m,~m •• ~~~m.~ mL~I*~~*, jf~~§Bt~*$*~OO0mJW~"1I'JtJm~mt.~${t~5Go ~..Ji!::*f£ ~m0m~~~~*~~.~~.:1f~T~m.~*z~0{E~*~fl~~~·~$X (Bob Galvin) fI9@i~r, ~1-MjJIJIf1=mJfMl~*1t~f.iLas-@:tljff:lljt~jtH~$IJ~tt~J. ~J]!Itf~lIDJ~ • ~J~.:t§ffti (Art Sundry) rm1-'¥il1JnJ!2t~, l1SI~ftM'¥iJT..f£~tL.iJliR ~~.~f:Ilmpl¥J.~&.,jf*~.~"anl¥Jm.@ •• T"o.$~fI9If1=mf:ll. }~,.tfjl¥JWf~~-1-Il!IMit~JF~jf~ 1980 &f:~MP:. Jt § IWtE~19fI~*tt~tLi£1t~(r(J 9i~f1t1.{\[o
0) ~~jt~h 0 Jii:i::tJ:;j~~.X;f~*tr*+.X;fJt. NitOOI'1iJ~~rpthfl9~~. ijH~ft nit!! ilL
(2) ~J:;j;J:\1J~0 11&~~wmt.1f3]!ZM$. ~ QCC (r(JW-jm~~i!~1 A..t£~t1l1'f9 ~~::t1t, tE~0P]rrijl*.~7t~nj/L~ (total customer satisfaction. TCS) /J\!1l rlSJgjo
(3) ,rm.&:ilL :m&*l3fffi1E1>J 5 ~r'gam: 10 m, :mml:.am:I3f.'F!jBlTfl"'llf;ElA]l.
IW~Pibit~tlt£f1;}-~ 1'-p:u:llfi-r TAI'!H;§-~3M~IW:kfli.
(4) *t£;29W:tfii)II-!:3W:1f9='t'L', 7B.mt*t£;~f1tk"FIWME%, ±~1f*~Jm:l1tfilJlIM!m.
IIW.h.~,rm •• fi!j'llf;El~~IW§*~~IW.*.
~:l1JL~IW~~;fIHE •. *t£;~t\l:tE 1987 ~~W1tB7\gg~~. ,~1r&Y7\W~J.q~ 3MlWxfli. m~JF· ,*Jifit (Mikel Harry), lt~· :£liWi (Bill Smith) ;fIU-'1f~· ~29i1 (Richard Schroeder) ~~AW~'&~~.'I:~IW-€lj!mA. :tE~atlWtrmHAB1rf*!tIJ . iWi $~~*h~~-r,AW~~:tE~0mm~~~WTr~.ft •• r.*W~~~~IW~ *~hM!~*t£;~t\l~1ET~.Wk~JL.~m.~.IW§~: 20me~~ft~AAIWI3 ;f'F~4fJ 5 4=am: 10ffl. J§"*a;1;;4lj 2 4=~J(:11l10 m, ¥IJ 1992 4=~Jlt5fUijll*J9l:.iE¥lJ*W ~~ml:.7j(~. Eb-r~.7\W~~. 0m-r 1988 4=~1·¥H~~t!t$m~OO~J9l:.~, M.* 1Ia~.1W 1987~1997 4=a<J 10 4=I'BJ. m-!fWlijH~ Y 5 ffl-, 5flJ7Jfj4fJ4=:!t1Jo 20%, .li!i:l1~.t\ W~.&'lfJ1l!.wr1It*89~:MJ:ttiE 140 16~ft. JR~ifl'~f:K]4lf~ k~ 21. 3%. ~!OI:!:-t5tJ[
*.
2. ~~*"~t-J_f_~.tfir
~~~~~m .• $~~~.WAW~~a<J§~5fU.~89 ••. :tE~89~~9='t.flt\l m ·1tesif!! (Larry Bossidy), mt.li!ifflEl!~0ml~,~,~, Jmffl~~trm:Vt.tr1r~~· ~$ ~ (Jack Welch) 1W!!1J-¥-!:3Ri~-Wa<JM~. 1991~, 1fWJm£tf*T~t£:il!im~~891f1{R. ~-¥ T~U~uEb~~0P1itjfifjjJVta<J~*ffi-'%0P1 CAllied Signal). tlHf CEO. bUaffl~ ~~~-1-"~ili~a"890m*W~*m-,%,MWif!!~~*£ •.• OOk.§* •• it ffi-'%~.m~~fl.~~89.~~%~V •• fi.@~.itm%,~@.fi*.R~-@ ~~a<J%~,mfl"~~.*d.*.~.Afim~*~" •• ~~h,r*~~ffi., • • ~~m."~A~~ •. ~'lffl.m$G~5fU~.a<J]l.I.@~~tt~5fUB~Z~~:tE 1~*89~liE. £flf~89~, {t.ill'_!wADL ~_5fUi?i1T.*mT45- I"J ;1;;~!W~A:, 4lf1-At9r .n .. ~maa<J~~,~W.A.*m%Z~ •• Wif!!OO.a<J ••• ~~.~~M~. itm-,%1{.iE~£tf.-1-~ft.:., # ll*;i!:tma~0iij89 "vr.1T" ~jJ5fU "th.B" ~~. OJTY *f£;~t\la<J~., 1m~L:@":i.R¥lJ, AW~J!!iE~fm~~IWItJ~~lf**1~%m.ii!~1m'L' § 9='t 1tAk.!W~~.
1992~, ttW:i!!!#J-7\W~~'1IA.*ffi-'%0PJ. "~fn~1J:!~~A1n.tI:I § f,'F. :l&~ .{!tit~a<JIJt.5fU~~", .*ffi-'%I¥J'lfmL~i!~llio Aff1JA45-*Jff*. "FJ3 7\W..m-~~ t! 0 r& Jff rm ~J ~ a 89 ~ f11:. #J- BlT"F m T~tk:~ ~ I'll] I1L ~ ~ L . X1lf*-ft-f~ -'% * lli, ~-& iffl ~ •• m •• I •• ~.A1n •• 89~~.~~Afi*I"J.~0m,A~~~~a<J{t~~ ~~~,ff.*ffi%~~%~~-~*~~~~.~T~*W..m-~£~~ill*lf**ffi%~ § ag. ~MWif!!a<J*®rf, j.q:$~f$1>J "txIJ\" Btr~~H~JE¥lJt\W~fl!~fE9='t. ;It~{g ffi*.~*-rm~~ •. ~~h.~~~.{t~~~~OO89~$ .
• Wif!!~~T. /,W~fl!~~TJlJC*m%89t~1f-!:3i?ifF~A:, 0ma<J.ill'_~l±l.T'tJcj! :IfI*IW~~. m-!f$!~~J~*~~.4lj~w.JiiL~a<J:IfI*. 0PJ a<J1&MJA 1991 ~a<J 3.4216 §!1!JC~*¥IJ 1997 ~a<J 11. 71l§!1!5L. :ft~iiH~Ia<J6 4=~JL3JLIJlT1h9 •• TIffllJ!~ 311-*fl ~~.JR~RI3%~kag**,0PJ89Hm:lfl*T8m.iE~~;1;;MW~ffi**m-,%,$
}J\W~-tXllfiiJt T7\g!j.m~ 0 JltJ§, mEfiWTf)(:H~-m0RHfl~5IA T7\g!j;f§~. ~~ JOC~ T $;lJj.
~OOJ&ffl~4:0P]{E 20 1it2 70-90 1ffti&JJE~&1G:lII&it~tlJOC1' T nlGlJj, i3:M!:uJJ&ffl~ 4:~~T0P]~~~~g$~~~£M, ~~~0m**T§*~~o{Ei3:~~AA,J&ffl ~4:.~~~~~~*~.~** ••••• ,~&.~.m{E~m.~&&.*~~ 3-4~ftM~*~.m.~*~.***,~.~ •• *.~W~ •• ~E·~}J\.{E~ § f{(9='@l'tZi3L 1995 1f 4 jj ftJjffl ~ 4:Ji.J$fftIiJJJf9=' £:m!. JlIl:.riiJ.B~~iq:$ fftIEJT Wtt.
19951f][. ~1l:. ~$._mJlJT{t!!.a9M1it1tft~ • .f1Bffli>*JUT1OC1fm%$;J}Ja9,*IEL i3:tX*ii5~-'t}J\.t¥rFTi*~tlB9fp~o § J:{£c'(*. -'t$.Bf£mJ&fflJt!4:Jtl:tTT -¥ytl *n.*~~¥.M!Rffl~4:{E~~~~*.~~ •• ~".-.=na9offi~}J\ •• m J&m~4:~~81f~m~~~Z$;JjJ.~$.~~~.mRffl~4:0ffltr~$;~*W~~ iE:~. ¥f~.f1B 20011fJIH~~~jjm~ 9:.Mra9:1t3r:~a9~F 0
{E~$.~*~r.Rffl~4:0P]*~T~~*WM~z*offi~.ft~$.~9=', lit~a97\ft~~B~::F~11tata9t\ftM~. EB~{'{{'{~*T#tit~~. ~if'E~~#ttt 1!*-; ~i:f!~f{f{~~Ti&Jtl:mt.B9. '@1fB.~~mt.:1c'iill~*. ~$.~:mt\ftM ~~*JiJtr~.J1Im~4:0PJ#<JC.,~~j]~&1G:~mtXo {E 1996 iF 1 JJ jjffllt! 9:..~p§-F~ l)l.J: • .f1B#f7\W~~:j$~JdlmJt! 9:.i'ltrEJT*~B9m:.,(.,tJJfh~IfF, ftt!iJi: "~.Iift;U~iE :It!!.~iiffl~4:»daT~,ga90jiJz-:i!~mj[. J:*~U~~mrJH@x>t:e:T~Ea90ffl. J! ~m~a9EJT~A.~~M~ •. i3:~~.~m~~mlif~a9,.~~~m101f~~~~ ~, :fIG{fJ'.I6'5.miE 5 1fJi.J~Jm-~~jHLttJEiii£, ffif~jj:ct~J]ftl!.A."
~$.U~7\WM~~~2zz.iliTM.~.#~,~.J1I:ct.~mM.M~~a • • M!.~mreIfFtim~%,AWM~a9~G~M!-~0~m~ft~.{E~.*,7\WM ~ "JibiJfJ~ 4:0il]JA*19:~i£J1i:cta9ii::I:~~jtM&1G:~". 1995 1fm;. I!.ii;ff 200 1'-t\W Mll3JYf § a9~Pl!i:, i3:f'P~JJlt:111!{Ejjffl ~ 4::1cttm:lt!!.*Ji,g*. 1997 iF, i3:~~JYf §@ MT 6 000 1'-. flHSJdlffl~4: 2000 1fJl~fIl1}: 1999iFjjffl~4:0ffla9f!Jm~ 107 {Z~ jG. It 1998 1f:ttt* T 15%. ;ltq:t, ~:M!!7\W~~~~~!&~~i5jlJT 15 {l~jG. jlJ 21 ittrr.1JJ. ~1'-.,¥:iisJlJT 50 1l~fto ffif 2000 1f, ftjjmlt!4:~m~*UiiE~.91IB:iisJJj 90% C.(L. 0iij9='~1l1J:~t~JJI!9='~:ct7\W~~~'f!H£JIj~AFt B:iis 15%.
ft~m~4:,7\WMll3~~~~~-1'-~JJI!* •. t\W~~~~~0m~:1c~~(~ Jtft, BIl*. 7\ftM~~~-f-jij*) Z-*~:M!!; 0RJ~j'[TJA "{lr!;f~" (champion), .. 1tfi*~*" (master black belt, MBB), "~1if" (black belt. BB) jlJ "~*" (green belt. GB) t8*WMl1!miiR~ftJ; 7\WM~~m!!~*_!:jffJJI!.Affdf7t~~iL~~~1f a
~~.~~Rffllt!~0il]~20iF~~m,Rm~4:~~.*m**T30$ffl. i5~ T 4 500 {l~ft. 1-IM'IJAtltN~+fil..*J1JT~=m. ft.f1Ba9*.r~~ "81f~m" ~ £ T lW Nf*::tf a9l't1fffl jJ •
tEJmm~4:0R]@:m/\gg~~Jflt1'§:1c$;JjJz~. I\W~~~~ittjlf.:Jt~, *)jIJR::iq: $ «Rtf*'» 500 ~!:Jt~~:X:~. U1Jt*ti~o 1It~:Jt~£Jmt\W**~~~lifll1m § c.f=::i. .~~.*~.~.Emi:f!*M:1cjJ.fiAW**~.~M.~.~* ••• _~.~n,
ABB, 3M, *z, ]g1Ftri, =m., LG, Iffin~~ ~:s'Lf~, 1~5tW:{i-~T, ItEJI!L tt mUHl' ~ J. P. ,*,flL ~OO:iEjj, ~*f1F, 1ll~~i!fOO0R]. 4-*, T\i!§.m~~JjizJije~ bt,*f{;~tsL jjJijEt! 4::t:rtlT ~1ttW: JAW1r:t:rtlT*1r. JAtttw 500 ~;'~ffil0R]j£rtl T tfii1f:~r]J~~/J\:l1:Ak.. JAEt!r, .tfL,fft, itI. ~~~ftI!J~!ltJtrtl TlttH=r, 1:Ji!:~~ !it~, Et! T Iflj *~ nlH}!It e
3. /', iEJ ~~ of J£ frlJ -mr :It_~
Ai!§.m~~~T~m~.~~~~~~~20ttt280~~~AA.~~~OO~.~~~ W~ ••• *~~~.*~.~ •. W.~*.T\i!§M~B~:t:ttTm*~~.~w. fF~-f+,*~~M~1r7!. 'En:3l;~~~¥IJT~$f~Jt:3l;;fU~Jl{. T\i!§.ff~~.p}-&£-# ~.i&:it!ag1ff!. ffii~Bt:2:~~~~IlTI;1~:l1:~1:Ji!:**~i&:it!. !ft5;'~-&r9i~fmh, ~ttJf ~~~$~~N~~~~~*~*E*~mag-~~~~~~~¥~1ff!.~~* •• ~ ~VL~1:fj T ".T\W.ff~" 1f7!--ftiEbj1gjj, miJiI. 9i~"l:*, fflM.-&rfF. NiUll1;1 )@[$ ~ ~ 'G'~ffrmJ~~Z91 ~ 3k:1fi.1n! , §'n:m ~ {tAk.~i'- jJ ~~1fi: {tAk.x it c
~~~T\i!§.m~~)~~:iEfflTi&#~~ag •• ,ft~mmT~~~~~.~I;1~~ ~M~~Y~# ~~,G,ag. ffiijfT\W:m~£--t-9i~ jJ~~:WFf. ~*T ,hH*Ak.9t-i&:ilttJ9 1rf!. 'Emtk: T ~J1IA~ JiJT 00 11$ ft9 w.I~ I'D] m: -1rOO~iitt~i! 119 Ak.)} i&:iH: J]! § :i3 ¥IHiffAA ft99!H} §l$; ¥t-1rOOiE~t£*fitAT~~Jc.,mC¥i1rm1>J**I¥J~.fJtlHi~jJ o
lj~PJL.jftt*-F. ~)}mtw~~, ii1fj~$mM.. ~~'L.,!lt9t-mw*rr*~~$T~1l{f~~ IA~AWM~i&#mtN~-&r~*.mAi!§M~1rf!~~T-~~ml¥J1ff!~m~~rr~ IJt,. I;1fJ~~A~n:!It)}~~ttN~:itJlJ3jZ-.jf. w. 1-} 7tll±ll¥J£jfAi!§M~1rf!I¥J®! ~ fJ )]t:filIJ c
~1-1
mit (align)
.ffl~~~~~A(~~$m~~.~~~~mm),~~~~~*~~*~~~ }.t~'L,~*V!tf!l!ffi~il" • .~~~~~~§~.~~~~m~tt~A~§~~~§~~.~~. §~~~~ M'fl~ItJf~, ilJ~.~, !U~*~~'a~*~*, ~1!tli9J~ij,g.§f,j~~1.m •
~i9J (mobilize)
• ~m~ma,~rl.m~~AmB_~~§,~ffl~§W~~$~*W~~~$ };5¥lJ~*Et<J §~.
• fflrJ! §_f[J~t~, n'tJjJft!il~fIIF~~if1ti~~$:I1fmlRm.#h~* •
• ~ lID 1R!I!#tlkJJ;f~Jtii)IlBll**gtu1!Jf1!!.fll~Jtftliffii9J •
1ml! (accelerate)
• *ffl~~3itffl (action learning) ~jJ$. ~~U7t~:tgi)fl!;J~~~:rm§If1::~H1f-'il' ~il"®*, .ffki!?Ilj~m~.B¥lj~I&~~mL iJ:mlfi$J®*~i9UJbttm~1UHh **~*,m~.~T&JJ;f~~:rm§~§~,~~ttm~x~~~ilJY~ •
~iIJIJ (govern)
• M~~it)t-F~~*fi~iIJIJ, 1lE:it!:l&~~~~, *Mt~Diif!l!$~§mxt~*t;!iIJIJ -F (dashboard) ~EIi~, VJ&1£1t,~at~iff~Diif!l!~:rm § ~mr~. ~®!-'il'fll)t$ .ft~~~~at,~~~ilJ~~?Ilj~.
f
AM~~~~~*~~,~~~~*~*n~~*,~~ft*~~*~~~*~W, ~~~~~~~~~h~oE~u*~~,~~~*ffl~*~*~@,~~x~~~uN Ntt (design for six sigma, DFSS) , jf~tJffi1f uw.*qjuWWj£ (define), 001:1: (measure), :frtIT (analyze), 1:&* (improve), ;j£iIJIJ (control) -nQ$ DMAIC VitN, m~ ufi.~~x~m~~,MW •• M:I:~.*,~M~*, •• ~~ ••. ~~~~~~ ~~, ~5!~~~1t JJ 0
1. ~'., ~~'&M1!if.it*"5l
a ~-1'-:ffl-Jm'f:-BJ=, *~ "M~E!", tE~~~}trp~lf- "f,jm£", ~ffl*~W:ff~ -m~.~ufi.WM.~ •• fi~~mti,~-~W~~£~~~ufiMtt.~*~~ ~lto
M~E!.:I:*.~~~Mfi.W~.~m,tim£~M.~*~§tim, •• ~.* ~**rrlt~, ~~tufit~tIEM:I:~*trej]~-~J.t.o M~~*.~ •. :l:1:fimJJEM:I: ~*~@j]~~5!;&Z,M~E!*.~M,Mfi~JEM:I:~*~trej]~~MoAM.E! M:I:*.~,*ffa7JtB~m~ (DPMO) ~/Fmu 3. 4 ~~I!§o
~ml-2~lf-~~~:fr~~, ~~T •• ~Z£~l~(+~,~ufix •• , ~ ~~:fr~~JL.'~ •• ~JL.,_milB1, 1ij;;TT •• ~ LSL fJI.T ~.~~ USL ~ifjjW- (:fIl $) ~jJ o. OOlppm, J~,.~:fIl*jJT1Z:frZ=o m~ fL jJ~~:fr~Et9~JG,m, M~ •• rp ,L.', II jJf,jm~.
LSL
J.L=M
USL
0.00 1 ppm
O.OOlppm
fE!.~~~, :l:1:fi.tB.:I:!f,ftt~?t~t:p'L.,~ •• rp'L'IiI~1'iJfmtt11VJ\, ~tTA~1't9 ~~:ctW. ffiT~~:l:1:fi.lli~£*M.~~(A,m,~,~,~,OOI)~~~~~.
I~ :i:tw.tfj~~mttlJffi •• H:iE't~, :tlllm }-3 Bff5Fo {Ett.tlfi*.jgrrrpWJl..I!§~ :fI$IJ1, -Nl:~ m*t __ti£iE~*;fJf ~ 9=t 'L' rPJli:~rPJ :ti"~. 1. 5II, J1tBt-{JmEt9.~ 1-1 3. 4ppm. J3-~nlN~.#1tti/J\PLt?UI~1'}t, J~,~~;fIl$jJaJJ*.:t 3. 4. :tllll!l 1-4 Bfflf-.
ISL
-1.5u + 1.5u
USL
3.4ppm
3.4ppm
ffl1Jttii1t3fi)Uf97'\W,*~ffltiiJj(fft~ 3. 4DPMO, ::lik~mT :l:i;mK*W:lilifT~, Jt ;fJl~}L.,;ffix>tm.,*~JL.'iJfj;±1. 50" EI:fj~~~B9.$o ~ 1~2 H~T.::FIRJW,*~Jj(fatlW DPMOo
1.0 690000
2. 0 308700
3.0 66810
4. 0 6210
5.0 233
6.0 3.4 2. *&~~ffJrfJl'."*"5Z.
~7'\ gy ftt ~ 1Wt1E itft 5Cf~ in 9al J1t: (J::lik -:ffi" JJi ~ -fij:, tE ~'O.ltft it ~ ~ jf- "f,j ti ~ " ; "WMEJJj(1JL" jtFf1if:lif='Jl~, BIl*~:ttl'ilB9~~7J<f; *W**EJ*f~m 100 JHxi±l~ tJt~!:f:ff 3. 4 ~~~i¥J{!ik:l~Jj(f-o ~*,7'\WMEJB~~.i±I~m#ftX,~~-#.~.~~B9~.~*B9.~.
J:\, {f:jjdtfT7'\WMEJ, i:I1.::F{R{Rre7'\WM~ rs. 4DPMO) fi:~-# §f,j~mf,j, 7'\W
.~~~~~.~~$ .. ~*~,~m:
(1) t\W:mEHJtT-o {f:i:fW~T§tjjtm:#~y.ilt~, :U1Pj(~~~, j£pj(jG~L ~~L,~~7'\W:m~#~-~~~~7'\W~~*~~~.,W~~~:i:f~*IT~~ tt~j:&*W,gUtfio 00 1-5 IVRT "IS"" i1f1: fnffij~fl~ilt~/J\, m:l5]m:1J#*~ ntT$X$~Dik:~; flW~m-:I5]{Rt# f$/J'. milt~*ii1~nt T$X$~~M; xm X lfE--ilt~W#]{Ri~~U$#]t}VJ\, ~T~~I~L t\W~Jq §ti-8tR:: "XWL>U{E": fj!:i:ff1~ ~~~{R#~y.~~,~*~~~.~*%~o
i i
LSL USL _ ~M LSL USL
1111-5 0j!i~J!?~~: xm3vt
(2) AW~~1f1!o 7'\W:m~iE1J1!~ITif5jiftiJ*m.J1X;~-€~m, i!_m~JJtl~mili. 7'\ W:m~it~~{R {R)1iJfl~tttt*mtlcriiJR!, 't~-~*~~~:%- i&:ilE1f1!1*~, jt:IAW1f 1!~mJ£ftM!:_l:1flltt*, J.llUHm-tttt*, I~If1Wjtft!!.m!fi~/lflltt*, ffi,@,tt*~ 0 (3) AW~~jc1tWl&lI&o #f7'\w:m~1fIm;w.Wi&*1Jf!iiI!A1i::~jc1t, ~~:1g1i::~~ ~~,~~~~~~~rrn,~:ilEm~%nt~{f~,~J£jt:m~~l&~~~Q
1.2. 2 1\f!!H8J!}~II~if~ ~.AWM~~"-.$."~,$.~~II&B_o~.*W~~~~~$~$W, @m~~d*, •• ~~h,*~*.ffiM,.tt.~.~~~~m.~~ .• y..~.
i&5f~mjc1t, i&:ilE~&t:fUHlt9}~c *~#f~.*W:m~~~m!BflIj:1glV.rllY--r1JW:
• fPJ~f8¥tIc~JlIG.*~f!£ Q f8¥tIc IE tJt0m ~.~ffijjt5.tl:I¥J~I!, I*f!£~ ~M!:.JlIG.*c
• jcft;~1(iQ Jt:ll.#j~i&:itI::fUfttljfl¥J{£~jcft;, iflj,*~W~~o
• ~ ~~nm e ~ jlij tli:fl-0 'ffl1¥J ~ ,L.' ~~ h :fU f£ti' ffJ1l!.fflt~If Q ·mI~Mo~~r-ft~~~,~:itl:mI~~~~o
1. $fm: I!l-tt-'A'-a] ~~~J?i1 i_*~.;l!, rrt1t~ ~Jti:~*
---r~~TdJjJ. ~~Tm*!j!~890mtt:$t~~ftIU § B ~~uL **Jt~LitJl{~j(lV. '&rr~1fE!JItl, J!PfaJt0PJ ~M!iIf, !!~l!t~,L.'1frmAAL jtiX~~T{f~, ~::etln~'G,fftm ~,~~§B~~~§~:fU~~n~c~~~~~~~~~~~~~~'~~~~~~~ *._~mtT- (KPI), #¥J*.~~ffifffitirtJ?t1ru¥lJffJ*Iif{~~~f1~J:iW, ~rPJmm*
M Jll ffi l~kflllJ\ I 0
~#* ••• m5~0~~~~~~~.~M ••• *.~~~~*m¥.~w,¥ ~J&* ••• mt;~1t1it~.1f1!l~aU£~, fl#iE$Jl.~tJt0~$1f:. ~3t7HlI5Jl.1*J.J®t~ :::t'i~hi:~j[~fPJ~, §fi5:
• F£;ftlH[l*lffi::l:rii]~;
• iE.fi ~*IOJm; .1:F$. iilt~mJWHPJ»2;
• rP~;ftlJ®t~iilt~ IOJH!;
• Jf~;ftl~~fii]JH!L
~.®IOJ»2llD*:::t'W"~1Jo r;JJiJ1Hk:, ~~'~~~~0PJl&Ifa<J~1l. ifjj¥fWHk:~#~m, ~, ~~.~.~m~ifjj~ •• m,~~~-@A1f.~~~M_~~h~tt~a<JA~.~~ #~~iilt~.~mm~~~~~Htt*~~~~~IA*m~.
~~~m~.~,¥~.I$~~A~?~.~~DM~~H~ .•• ~~~Afi~ :fFi~: "~~¥IJ~~-z,..~mt., J£~~:a~1t~§Jf?" "~if1~l91::fi*fl§ADM~~~~ *$T.~~llADM~,%~~~1t~*.~~*~~~*~&*tt*,~:fFtiJ£~~ :a~.?"~~,~~~ADM~~~~-~~M~.~a<J~WM~~~~J£~.*~~ ~~1£tE~f:N:1f.~. ~-gB~HiH£~tL. ~i=fffl%,Jim~"'t~ "tltcWr&" {J?:~~~ ~EffiiE IJIj •
~jjj, 3t1f1M..::f- ~l91::l:JlX* (cost of poor quality, COPQ) ~JrJlli!Ri!R~+r-z,.ADM ~fi •• M{J?:~.*~~H.~@ •. *$.0PJ~~3-4DM~*f, • .::f-~lffi:.JlX *11J 2:l¥lJ~tHI!i[~ 20%-40%, ifjjADM~J£~a9.:r- ~JJQiiJll(;*i£2:l~!f.a9 1%-5%. ~m~~R~,0PJM.3-4DM~*f~~~ADM~*f,.~~~.:r-~~ii~*~ 1f:RJ~ 80 1l~~~ 120 fZ~7G.
~@~*.~*m~£~?.::f-~m.~*I1Jr;J*~~.a9~~*~~*~, •• *ili -:fF,.tE*OO~~~ftfi~.~H~B#~~F~ •• *:::t'~ifjj.~~.~,~.~~ ~a.~*~#~~.~~I*J.~*.~.~*m~#a<J.*oN~*$.J£~*m,~ @.*.*2:lm!f.~4%-5%.@~W~fl •• 1£.WTa9.*,~Aftfi~ • .:r-~~ rr~:::t':1gAff11[1W.@X~~tEtEff.1£~J£~9='B9~*tM~. ~@ " •• ~*" .*~tt. tJjEt<JW**~",$, mi*j~~~.a916%-35%. :l!@~.a9fD •• B9.::f-~a.$;*e.~:@. ~iii~Tm!f*,Jm. ,fIH~~OO.~~m§UU0~ Imberman & Deforest 1£ 20 tit2 90 1f:tt fJJP.JTfFagiIJ:i!t, '-~1£~ag1jZ~*,J11fj*3jZttr!Jm1!f.B9 1 %-4% 0
ADM~~m.~~.M~§~WEt<J~m;ftltt~, •• ~@~.Et<JfD.*a9.*. *.m"*ili"~~"~ili",~"I.Et<J •• ,I.Et<J.*.~.~*~l§1:~M •. J!31f.nw )EJij(~Et<J~*" 5t~1l~.
~m~"'t0m~*~*~fim~m~{J?:~~~~mm~a9~~nOO,*.mT§*a9 i&id. ttllU: AjJ~~.m*D~~ifJlIt1Jr!ai1!A91Et<JDCIl; M*.ffl:jttf!.1t~a9Jl. 1t-f11.!:3lfE~f£; IW-uamF &lr tiit ~ RJ#f£;ftl~. 00 W:;~jrfi; $IJ:li!$ ~~*,J :li!"iRM * ..EI. ~.~~M.; HIt§$tI'.JJI:t*nfi.JE1l~fB.J~~~lt-frB.J; nL@,$1l.nL@'~~a93'&$~ .• ' 9=',-~*ftM~~6~m%~T&.~~~M~Ma<J~§.~mTm~,.~.m~~
rltx11WJ~ib'11O x. iffl~jij;_tf1B1fJi'J9F8bx11.AA3jl-~1g 33 x. 38njgm/\I!!f*~1f ~,.m.XM.AA.m~~~~3*,tt~-~.~~~~a ••• i'J9§m.A50~~ ~.~m~~.ffi$n.M~I!!fM~W~~§,.XW~i'J912~~£~~m.M~%. iWiJlJ 97%, .1f:Jt1JUt&A 130 JJ~~o :B:.mf@.~*FiJ9=t, J!f.F~;lfJiJ~~)f£~. J!tkgt ~*I!!f*}q~lifflf@. "l;0FiJ{f* T:!lI1~~jl11jtl~)I&AfIl:ft*it1t~-1'-m:~ 1*m.
~lt~*4~RJI: :!l11*-1'- 3 W*Jl!*~f'I9~~m~;a;FJf~tgt~i&m:M:m. *~.1fPJ ~.~-1'-I!!fMJl!*:if, HJlJ~J1J 4. 7 ggM~*3jt.· Xt§l:A'±~~:I:&iftl'&12iiiUftffl. ifflJE @i::*:tf<J!8f;$.:t§l:A. J!MfEiJ. *,JJ1$f'I9!ti; ~ -t?tB.~. iffl~~JlJ 4. 8 WMJl!* 3fEBt, ~fIf!ti; ;t#jW,ffE+,*3fE, lJl~~~X>tMWm:1Tm:!JfNit, :fttlll!8f~t§l:A. {EHtfffF ~/ Blt*5E~ ts, m:lj,61f~~¥tJJJ_ijHI¥J.~. ~;f-1'- 3 W,ffJl!JK1l-~~.IIt*iJl., .~-1'-W,ffJij*:ifPJ a~ 'F ltt&:M; :
• ;fIJfi$:ft* 20%;
• FI:J:HmfJ.~ 12%~18%;
• 91~JJ~Y 12% ;
• tgt;$.:t§l:A1lty 10%~30%.
~OOl[(:l:tb~m ttl: "*WMJl!1f~~*:B:-1'-if~l¥.JfffrEiJ rJg1fJlJD.fHI9 oom." . ~;n;$; ~I¥.J-t*~~~-o ~~,~~~~ggMJijW~~~~{f*I¥.J~~~~ff~~§$.~.
2. Jt..!i..#~ a.lt-fp~J *'T~ Ie- 3I::.Jt1-t, ~)lj F:bt:J ii~:i. M~~~~%ml¥.J~~~:~~~*MI¥.J~~fIl£.9=t%dl¥.J,~;$.:~~m.~I¥.J. _§_~1f:.~$f{d53.1t: IPJJltl ~* I§' C(j! -til), • ~ § flF O!:J:), t1Hifj ffL ~* m ~fIl tr
~.~(~m.).i'J9~fIlA~:B:~~m~~i'J9&_.
~jix1t:A~;ffifllr~, 1bIJll~;fJl!fMl[(~:=:: 1'-~tXi'J9taftJ. :!ll1oo }-6 JYfiF.
?'~ tE ;~IU!ll, fII. -1* i~"":'::"_---__J w.m,g ~ J1j~;t; fJ:I.m,,~~
f' it?'~ ~!Ik@!~ tt*,ii4i~~
II J'2C tIi: "'lit ,1t )(ft.-I*ll~f.S~fitl!: em ,2f.t.ti~$t
.%~m,~~~~~~~~~~~.*~~~~~o.~~~~~~~~~.~~ ~~m~~o~~~~~~~A~~tr~k~$MM$~, ~~~~~~I~*, ~~~ ~:m:1* ~ I it Jxl/=(. fPff 1; rttlil~ 0
*W~~~tttt~-~M~~~~~*n~. ~~ill~-#~~~~$~~~.~~ ~$.~"*~".~~r~~.~~m~-#~~,-#* •• mft •• ~~~o~~ ::F$f~~~~A111~Itf::tr~o IlJHff/\W~~~ttm. {E:~~~ill~{4¥1J~ItJT~~*, ~ %~-#~Jt.,tlrhJt;HiIIl;H~, AAml&:kr±, ~.!=J.m;fPi!tl.(8~1tjRIIL
:Jt-~a9~{.,~9}mtl'i8Jt~~-1ktlli'iJmt~ (8fuJ, W$]:ff(8l{RWAm~!af1g1lt511l#ArJ!J ~ *~ .• nz~~~~*§~~~~~.T~ •• £.~#~ •• ~X**.~~T.W ~ffM.*;fP.*o~.~W~~.~~M~m.~ •• £,~m~~W~tf~~~.~ wm~~.T~M.~it~m~.m.T.n~A~~.~(8 •• ,~mTm~~ •• rJ!J fP#ArJ!J~~tfo~ft~~~§tttt~~M.~o~Aft~~~M.OO~~, OO~~~:ff. ~~~OO~~.;fP§~,#H •• *~~B~M • .!=J{E:~~~ •.•• ,._§~~:k. ~.mtffi~:k*, .iR¥li~9HlitN~.*~ffJ1f.*~tl:, .~-€Hi!rtJj-#fmJriE~M'OO~ ~tf ~~~~f1;]fPPFflL jffl~#J[;jll :W-~tf~ "flHW" iE~fl ff5;'*15!!.~ {f(JJl1!r, Jl1!r ~~Jll{;J1J.~'®fnit.nZrilJMI!f.o
*Dm~B9"J[;jll:W-"~1t~.m~~.~M.*Z-.~~ •• h~m •• nA~ ~.~~ •• ,~mm~~ •• rJ!JfP.Ii'iJ{f(J~tf,.~TM~&tt~~~.~~~~~fP {E:~pg •• nrilJ(f(JjE~rmt6!~*II:~~~~Ro j!#fMI:~i&mT 1E~pg.{f(J~ft::. 15!!1E~
3. ~li1:bt.1t IA--,j) ¥J#:,,:;:t ~ fJ ~f& 1ftt~J&.~~ Awm~~m~~-#~~.-#~oom~0~~*n~~~~~~~~~~~.A wm~ft::~0~~~,~~Wll~rft::m*~~0~~~~§~.
(1) 1£~J®!~~:f:tt, m1iJ®!~, :Et1J~mtilffiIL Iliff~--tff~jE~{f(J a M1i*:~!!~A J@i~~*B9~ltJTm~, &{)[m~ "M{f(J" M "~~i¥.J" f'&lr;fPHIHfBt£~mH~iH.IE{E:~B9. J}J 0 ~ftm~ ~J®!~ 1>1 JtiE 1f9:kr± ~ 'L" j!~:f:IW:.~~~YHJTI!$.®ffi"m~11®1~~~:f:~ B9Att:iG~51llfiiJ ~J@i~~f:Jtj!.®ffi"mB9 ~ a1 X ~~Nl*,l 0 J@i$tR:XErPtil, WJ@i~i¥.Ji2'f~fT-?l~ f'&bmtIL ~~~W~.&mt!l:A1f5;'~~rP~5l*no
(2) ~j;-~I~€Hti~. ~fi£JXt.~;fIl~*o FJf1fB9~M-m~$1g*T JXt.~, fE!.JXt.~::F-XE 1*~~~M~~~o *W~~B9 § i¥.JiE~~~JXt.~, :JHF{)[tt~~m~M'3I~B9~~m *c*w~~~.a~.~;fIlft.,RM •• *fi~a~~*~~~~,~tt •• TJ@i$ ~~~&b~~.mi¥.JJXt.~.~~.Tm~~&b{f(J~~~JXt.~.AW*~~.tt1f.B9n~ .~~&mt.~*. m~"=.Ir",Mrm~AJXt..~.*.
(3) .mf'£AnlHh 15!!{tj!t_$lE1'*.B9~J}J 0 *wm.&~ooti~~~tIH:Jt~Itfl-€~.
B9tt~;fP~1ti¥.J::tr~,~M~~~~~;fIl*~.~~,*m~m~A~~~.*m~~ ~.~{E:~ffi"m.*~, •• I®1~ •• tt,.~~M.~~~n,~~m~5l~h{f(J§ i¥.J. JArm~{E:~1'J1J*~i¥.J~~o
(4) 1J~'~i&*B9JtIto *ff~tlL~ 1987-1991 if- "4if-i&* 100 1&" B9~~V3J}J~A W*.&i¥.J~.o.${f(J~*~~~~~i¥.J, •• ~ttli~~m~.i¥.J~~.Amm~Hfi
fti&:il!: Er9fffl*~*~~I~. i&:i1!it1t:li:tk:Er9 J1:~ ~tE5Eit 9=J:m ¥U *~ jt~. /\ Wfi} EJjji1: m~Jtfl!!~ffEr9IA~,m!t. PJI2J.f8!!1Jj£~tE~*~3'&Er9~Btnuili5c*vrt@.
4. ~~ 'F -fl{,Alf"**, 1Jt#l:lJ! _LlJR~~~ jjffllt!9:~/\W*Jq'lJm!l§AjJWfill1f11l!~tJJ~it. 1997 iF 3 JJ 22 a. ~$~~i1 ~~ffl~9:~~~1fm!AM~5T-~~A, ~~~~1fm!AM~~*~H~~/\W~Jq
rtflil; 5 J] 22 S, ~$~~fI!!~w-JlliJitljf$*II);:il~jtT -**r~*W~Jqmi)II~*~ If * tIL ~ffJ II);: * Er9 iti~; 1998 1p 1 JJ 1 S, .rm ffl ~ 9J~IT Jl:ii* Er9if 11I!A ff'dlf 71- *,J It lE:a: 1.: ~: MHP a ~, ~fi!1fm!ABull,m$5'G;iii1:/\ w.mJq~'1tf11X;!.~HfEr9mi)rl, .::tfjg~Ytm-lf71- *~~~~lli~~~Wm!~lli~Wf~oM~,*W.mJq1fm!~~.rmffl~9:**~~AEr9~ :at. -:kmi)rl~fl~, tI*~f~M~$~!WHk:IOJ~lUitHTtk:.Er9AlJlJE_t T~mlt! 9:* m~Er9~~Mlli. ~.rmffllt!9:$~*Er9~~~~~~7~~(f,JAjJWf~~~.
/\W~Jq~~mI~j£~~~~ittt~Er9~*,/\W~Jq1f~Er9~D~~fl~~.~ MIEr9 ••• ~*mIEr9~~~ •. "~~~m~·~~.$A~~~mm.MmD~Er9 :fI~rc:~T 20 titre 90 ~ft, II);:itfg%Er9~~mx;f~i1f1friJ?: "fit~ A$l£~it~.33. ill illy fl A rei?: m- ~ f:k$fl91 I Er9 S lIt:1:. f,Ii * 0" /\ W~ Jq ~-lil(UJ I2J. :(:Em~ ~ ftBI lU nu itif,m.!tEr9~~lU7t $a{rJJr!.
/\D~Jq.~mIEr9~.tk:~~Er9~r!offiI~mtt.rmi1:.~~~~~,OOH4~~ ~~mmffl~~~9=J • .rmi1:~~~~~~.tk:~~Er9~~~r!, ~m~w*$~Er9@*, ~a;f~jftj_mIEr9~ A~j] • .rmjj:_mI~ AfT~Er9i&¥, 1Jf*~.33lUffJIU~~, ~i'i1I1Afi! • • ,*Wi&~j£~~~(f,Jx~~OO,~J1:~~~-~~.33~m~.
/\D~~.W~j£~~.M.,~.tt(f,Ja*~~ •• mT~~.Er9.WIA~.~ !irs, m~1i::~~~ T A1ltll~fjgj], lti:liifJfJtiJ, JY! § .11I!!i~lU~W~it~~tmj] ~9! ~~,~®A~J1:~**~.lU~.~.~j].,~j£~~ftm.MM~.*~~*§M M')" tt~3'&j£, ~*'l;Icit~JJi!~.'I1:&t%t:. m WJj£~~:OO~~ § f~.
1. ~~4jf~-tf.k~~~ tffl91t m -~J1:~(f,J~~~~.~~~~m~~~~n,m~~~~, ~~9!~.::t~~~~~ ff~IJ&(f,J*.. "is ~ 9=J7HI~~7r.
3l11~re1i::~ttfl:-ftl.\~, f,:jm®i~~~JJE¥. ~®i~lHlI.~~~-~J't;~~tlt~o ~}j!@!~.~*~~fJI:UEfillUffffl:itjHl_l[ -~j£~** ~ 2tJl1f~ ~~3'&Mm, HP~~ ~.\ll'.B<Jtt-filr, ~jj(lU1*{.'1friixw... :(:E:i£.ill: 9=J1!'ii!-#~III. -#~~Aff]~T~JlJI. §~oo ~fJ CH~ra91E:_illr.Jc{tmoo.
~iti (mission) ~mj£~(f,JjFJf3, ffj}11X;,r:t,~~fJ~. li~ T -~j£~Z~l2J.ff:(£B<J WEln&1frii. 12J..&J1:.ill:(f,J~~Z~·tL fffiiJj£.ill:Er9ffl£$~;Jt § Er911X;~iti, 1lnIT€lfj£~B<J
~~~~~~~~~*~~~*m~F~~~*off~-~~~~~~~§B~~~~ .,~ •• h".~~~*"oA~~~~~.£m~~~~.~.~~ •• Mtt,~~ T't:"Z.§f~~'Eml:::FH::1f:fijjJljl'i9tJL;MJo lrt-0RJfW!l€iA.z-i£~· IjIE--FM~ 1960 if~m ~ M I.§f1$:I'i9i1l i1t:"P m I±l, ~Ak. ~ ~ fJrtilk I'i9 ~-falt~ T .tlZ:9H¥J.J!J*J~Hj;: I'i9 0 RJ ~~ mm,~1$:-~~~ml'i9.o~~~~T~m~*,~~,MI,~n~~~~W,tl~ ~~~R*~~~*nml~~I'i9, ~~~~~~MNi1t:,~Ak.~~~.§ffl~~~~*n~ ~iJLjf (t9 ~m 0
j!jj{ (vision) £m~Ak..§f~:mI'i9**mjj{~~9\!, ~-1-~~I¥J.U:R~nloJ~JYf .**~~fi .• m.~~~A§~~~m,~~ •• ~., •• ~~-1-.~,~M, ~A.,~*~.~.~R~~~+~~*~.(t9~jj{§~.*IoJA~~~~~~ml±l.~ faIt§~~~~~OO*~¥~L.~~~tt~h~~~ •• -gA.~fl~~~~~~~~~ 1!~. it~f'1:§*~h, *jj:tl~H'HtntUg, ~T:fP~.mHt~A1n91fIoJ**. l!jj{ ~~~H~:~Ak.~U:JiltM~j:tlaH,'1!, -tl!.~&I!!tt4}*,j~:.m*jJm~Ak.B9~3'&:M.mo
~m~ (values) I::mW1~~~.&JtMI:tmfij:@:tf~m~DJ.:Y!~:fP!~rr~fly!IJ. ~mxw. &~:fP:tI5i~~.§f~~t¥J)(ito ~1R~~m:~l¥JjJj:t3t*l1lm'1I4ij:-ULMI.~~, fBltfJ ~~%Jilt.~ •. ~JiltX~jj{o~m~~-1-~~JYfW~:fPffi$B9*W,H::-1-~~.I .t¥JT=Il.7j( tiIB9m5k. H::-/Nm*+~Eltra] fP~~B91titmli&1t B9 W-Y!tl. ~~~:ft{iEltI'a] 1'i9~8i, l!P1J!~Wfl~-~mxw.ffjjjf~~~-tl!.+~i&~'E. 'Efl jJlj T~Ak.B<J~if&1t~l1l~ .ffl~.~~~.~.~~~~~ffjj&~~*wo~m~~~T~~mT~~~,m~ ., •• ~~:::FM.~.B<Jft~.~m~:::F~-falt~~ttB<J~~,ffjj£-1-~~B<JM~o ~m~&Hm~~m@!~B91T~fP:ff~t'F~~*, :aY!U'EB<JR;fji~~tElb&9=';liiJVtA.fnB<J~ .~~oJilt~t¥J~mxw.~~U:.T~~~U:MI(t9~1T~~.~A~~~#fi,m*:fP~ m~~,Jilt~~~Jilt~~~W¥~*~,*~u~mm~~~~~~~*jJ.
~~ m.~iJA~ T ~~B9fJ!., 1!jj{fP1*JL,~m~. ~~~~**lt~ T ~RtnloJ fP *~mjj{ZE,.I~B<J~~.~u&1t~~~,~~I±l~ttE~B<J~~.~~~~it~~ :ff 19J ~ M'Jt~ •
2.~~~~~~~~~*~~~~~~*~*.~~ AW~~~~~~-falt~*jJ~,~~~#)(~fP&1t~.~~~~AW~~,~~~ *~~xitB9~~fP&1t~§~B9~~,~~~*~~~.B<J~.~~~~~Jilt.ffjj~~@!
~~Aw~~~~~mi1l~*.B<JM~o~~AW~~~~~~~AW~~~~~U$~ ~~.,~AM*WM~d~~.t¥J~m~.~.:::F~w~.re.~~B9~*fP.~~~ d~B9~-*m~.o
Jilt~~:ffAW~~~~*~~$~Jilt*~~~$Wfl*§~~B9~~mm~.~@! ~.w~-m~h~W,~~:::FW,~m$M~~m~,£I~~~~~~~~~AW~ ~1f~"P. 1mfn~~JJ:J.Xt~PJfm1}~Tfk. if1lnjjffl~~0RJ~%· i51F1tI¥Jmh, ~~ m~*RJ~~·.®~~F~.*K~~*RJ~~·.1Fx~X~:::F~,mM.i¥J~1m ~tIHA.m~JT~*l1lfRt&.~~AW~~~JJ:d~i¥J~mo AW~~1fm~ § _tml~HE1T i¥J. ffi~A®~~~~.~~~~~T~~B<J~Lm. ffi~AW~~1fm~~~~*~~ i¥J)(it,ffi~,~~~~~m~:ff.~~R~o~m@!~~m~~~*®~~*:ff~rr
1 ..••................ / .....•.. ' : ' .. ' .. '.\
~ -.-'< T. W;j$.J1b" 1Ijlie·i. . •...•.
~J, ~~f~!;f.*, ?t~{5I!JtlWt7Jj, ~:f:j~i&~tt~7(~Ym~IT~. jfm~w*~1fJ!lP'311::.!Ik. ~ ItJT ~~ I't9 ~ JI3. § fijfl=l ~ il 0
Af**iJt, :ii ~ ff J!I!)iHI~J iF Jtl1!l.1JIi :
(1) tHE 2~5 if:ag~Wmlql&~§.fjfto j!@ §fJ:F~,@fttm0PJAf*1f~ftffiIJIJJE, jf Hm0PJ~~*~~o~mag~~£,:i3:@§.fjft~@f&~ili~flM~Wm~~~oo~~ag !&fi. ffii~£1A0PJ~lfagf**~l!PIlJw.:tc~a~~ag1&~o rmf£JL~.~ag!=H;j:
• ~~*,Ji1ij1if,llj 5%~10%;
• ~!It!&f@)lIl$:ft1JD 5%~ 15%;
• 4iJif:!&A:ttt1JD 10 %;
• ~J~ 20 % ag~f=ffJ!l!~ mll1J9J::S:~*;
• rP~flHlji 4iJif::ft *' 4 % 0
:i3:@§~ •• ~ •• m~M~fl0PJ.*§*l't9m~.~~.ag§~ ••• ~.r~ 11::.ill:'.ag ,1~,~, jf. B;T:tmJf1f § :f,j:fJlWf jJ-~~ag 7HJtoo: ~ jJ:Ii ttJ§* 0
(2) fltt-~lftJJ!/J\~IL ~WmEJ:ff1$~»ffi:, ~~~¥IJ11::.ill:'.agjjjjlIifOO 0 @f~JRagfrAil.*Hl:i3:W agJlf if: JESlJt.ff J!!!~ W * lq{E11::.ill:'. ~ ag % it , w.lit~~ fiiJ Jf1fJt~ *:fJl *,J fi ~:i!MfmAo {E*$lt1f~r. :li~ffJ!l!*~~@~ff~tt~lfti£/J\m, ffif~~/J\m.±~ fA ftiIJIJJE#fm ag ~JII[ tt~tl jf~fj(.
**ag~f*§.fjft.£~~§.fjft:fJlM.W.lit~JEi&~lI1~~~~. W.~*~.~ffJ!!!JR ~lit"f~lWJit 0 ffUi0FiJm.m*/J\w.litm-1-11::.ill:'.ag~~f11t. lfE*/J\m1V6~~Jm~>ftt~J* IT_a, t£ 21-£WI.¥: 3 ~ _ij fBJ, **/J\mmzi*~f!J$:m~iIJIJJE-~:jt*jj~.
(3) $IJJElfE*jj;t. **/J,mm:lii!1fjffJ!l!JRfnJltffJ!!! (-Aimf~~11f!Hffm*). Jt
lIR.1!l.m:
• ~JE 11::.ill:'. Jilf tm3'& 1I1 MWI !Jt~z.rBJ tI9 £ Ill! ; ·~JE~fiiJ~JII[~W.~~~ •• :i3:-£~; • ~~fji~W.~*JJE-1-jj~o
:lim ~ £~?tf1T IlJ [:l.~~Hfl~~, if! IlJ W. f$:~~1fl ~. , :i3:.IOC t1cr11::.ill:'. t191V6~. t£ ,HR ~nllia~~fl~~~1lJ3~M.gff~~m#t19~M~~~-@jJ~oMWI!Jt~~M*' ~§5~~ili. ~~~fl •• ~ffiWl~~~~I't9£~.m.,~~11::~.~JRfl&~t19. ~iAiR¥lJ*fi~~t19~,~tto
- .§.m*/J\m%~T£iE?tt1f •• ~ilJljJE~~w~t191J~. jj;tllii*igm:
• ~w.m~m~~f1;J:fJlAFt lV63jt;
• ~Jji § fij~littJ (~~ft9a-tm, ~~ft9A1J!lt:S:lI1:l1fiJlI~~~);
• mt~Hif.fi~1i,&§tJF (~*fIl*,J~)o ~§~W~rr~~~*~~.~J!I!m~w.mEJ, W.'&~~0FiJf=~ag~~~M~~
~o~~.§fl~ •• NOO*t1f,~W~.~.!;f.~m.~wm~¥~m.8.&~ JXl~o
(4) .~~*~~~. ~l!I.lq'lfJ!l!mIT~J}Jli:~.agf;§~:liH1iiJi¥m1£o .Ji¥:i:m~ «~~t£ftA~.7Jjk,~ •• ~Jt*~~~~.~w.*~IT~.~ •• ~WM~.m, ~m~tt~#,iJt~,~~~~~jjA.~~~m*w*EJag~No~@11::.ill:'.,~JR.~
1. A-~tt~11t-{i~Jt
7\~ ~ EH1rmxw,lj)\ ep tasl* ~ t8 Jj_~, tr~, ;;Ifdl::jltjlm:7\~ m- ~1fJ1l!. t8 m ~ JJj{JJ!U ~ 1T~lllllU 0 ~£tt 20 1f:i¥.J~~;fUtt!1$, lfjpX;T LTf /Y1-:1fOOi¥.J7\W~EHft{R%i!O
(1) ~]@[$~q:.JL\o "~J®i$~q:.JL\" ::ff!:l_~/,W~~'lfJj_jt~*i¥.JffdRxw" lli~~ f-ti£At 'lfJ1l!Jj_ ~~ ~ ~i¥.J~* mUlti 0
It~ * if T J@!$, tit 1~ ~ i¥.J I®i: ~ ntUr. J3t ~ ,~, iJ£ It ~It AtJiJf~ * i¥.J .:E~ gj tj 0 r& ffij]@[ ~ R~~~S*;fU~ •• ~~*ft.*a.m&~.~~ •• ;fUm*.ItAt~~.AT.]@[ $lli~~**i¥.J~*~AA.,**~~~~¥~, ~~~~~.am:,m~~~,~]@[$ .~~M,.~]@[$~**~*m~]@[$AA.,~W~~~~i¥.J]@[$**,::f~~m:]@[$ m.~,~,il!to
:(£7\~~~1JJj_q:., V).J®i$1iJq:.)L,~a:-ffl;)ti¥.J$, 5ji};!iJ "ff!i!PJf]@[$l¥Jfoif" (voice of customer, VOC) 0 7\W~Jl;1JII~ff!i!PJf]@[$i¥.JJiiif7f1z€t. ~T]@[$~*~~am:~Wfftam:i¥.J ••• Q-m~]@[$ •• ;fU1iJ]@[$ft.fft-m1iJq:.~.
(2) £T~m;fU*~ i¥.J'JfIl 0 "£T~m;fJl*~ i¥.J 'JfJj_" ~~~'tfJ1l!.£jftt~~@'tfJ1l!. (fJ*;1jd~ c
~*.$i¥.JIt~7fM.S~A*~~R;fJl~~WJ1l!.m~~fi.ilii¥.JW$~.~.~ r&~£T.~;fJl~.,~~-~m~1iJ~i¥.J.~~.~.A~~~WJ1l!.re"£T •• ~. ~i¥.JVJ1l!."I¥JJ1I!.~;fJl~~.~T-~~.i¥.Jm~o7\w*~.J1I!..*M~~-.~~.mm~M;fJl*~i)tilS, -7fMlWtm. JEfrliIil~:l:J1Wtw ili*tI*l.mf~htjt£~m, r&§mJf:! ~itjJ1'!:i1!1T.mi¥.J*:fIT;fJli*iIil~. iiOfEliP.i!f~PInJ*.~.mtji¥.Ji1:W[5l~. jfNittP1:i1!tit 14ft~i¥.J~ •.
(3) .~Tttma:i1!o J1..ttw, :ffHi.'fi1:W, ".~T:i:1:@P1m:", ~]@[$-€~:iif1tm, ~~~~~ft~i¥.J~.:1fj! 0
:(£7\W*~.I1q:.,:i:1:fi~*.a:i1!1T~i¥.J~~~ •• R#~~;fU.*,~:I: •• * :i1!h*:fIT,am:;fJl~~.~~~.ItAt~.$~~:i:1::i:1:WWm:1Ti¥.Jo tt@:(£7\~~~q:.~~~i¥.J*mo-mffi~$~um,M~~nW~~~~,A~~ ~m WJ~fn~.~~n:w~~~ 0
(4) ;ff19!~~{ftt&WIlo "{fttfr" ~m~Z9Ji!!!,:(£*m2t~~mr:ilE1T1fJJ., W::f;l!~~ Jt!1~J1I!.D~.@4- )dtl5Li¥.Jfltm, Mf$~ "~;k" 0 "~!MJi!.i¥.J{ftt&1ff!l!." .~lJ~fn~~*~ • .@# ••• ~~*~*,jf~~~.:.JE~*i¥.J§~*~~#~~~.;.JE •• i¥.J I*re)t~~;~.M~~BW::f~.T~J1I!.B2t~~fitm;~#~Rafi •• ~§i¥.J, ffff~F~ 110 * tIT i!!!,!1H~;oo:tR: 0
/,afl't~tgf!l!.1!!ffi-*J~IJ!;f!l~iH£!}i. 'f::m~~i¥.J, epB1!im~, ~ffim~, {ft .~.mjJ~.ft.~.~~~.,~~~~~~~m*A~%~i¥.J~:I:*~W::fwru. i¥.J~~}.f:fjff. fm'$1;kit rPJ ~ 2t~ 0
(5) :X:itIW1tfFo ":X:itIJf.1tfF" ~It~m~1IRfm~I'B}, )RfllZrB}J1~1tfFtkff.ZI'a]
~~w~£. oo~~*~~,~~ttw~~~$~~*~~.o
¥TJflU\flliOO!V-.~:It!I¥J*wmI.q'lfJ1l!.tlJlT"Xi!I!lf-it~"~m~,lffl1l*tffJ!fI!~i!I ~it~ ll9 .. ~ 1!f" WtRoll~ ®:A If 51ii. ?!H~ itr ~ I¥J J!l\HW 0 IE T ~ 1tf £lJ! § &:It! B'I !V-. ~ fft JJf A • W~1!flJ!§tttt£Jf.nl¥J, ••• w~~.~mlE •• $.~~oo~n •• nOOI¥J • • ,.tt"Xi!I!lf-it~"*~*DM~lJ!§o
~A~.~T~M~gal¥J~.~~~~ •• ~m~~,.~.m~#~~ ••• W I ~~~ 4Ft$* ~;ffJ1[ *t!i!,rt 0 tE/\ DM Ji!'lfJ1l!. q:, ~i!I .w.ir~ # ~ -,*If X;jHlJ: I¥J 1'- A!fW M,W~.~~.~~m*m~£.k.~~~~~~~~~§Ao IET*WM~.J1I!.£ ~~ff)tt~~~.k~, ~~*WMI.q'1fJ1l!.~.g~-~.~~*OO!V-.it~l'f9.J1I!.tff~ ~;bl:i1io
(6) if!>l(*~, ~]£)f(!QL ~1t-z"ff "~*jC~" 1¥J~~:i:E~ "~~~9&"? =~~ ~*a.~®~mDM*m~*,J!M~OO£1[*~o~~-1'-~m*_.~§5l'f9.J1I!. ~~.*WM~'lfJ1l!.~~~~~T-1'-~.%~I¥J~n~~,~~~~~rr~n~,~~ f#fJ1l!.:3:.~~1jf!!J, WM J1!'1fJ1l!. ~ ~~, W;i3: *FM,~, 4d!r*JXI,~ 0 iEtirr* W M Ji! 1fI!IUI9 jj:
W~.~flli~~~~~~~9&,~~M~~~~~~~~*,$]£~~l¥Jx~~m. ~m m.Mm-~~~~'L'~, iltTOOx1~~*Mq:,illJlj{~~fti)ll. :i:7~~Jt!E~ilJjD
2.~~.~~~.~MA~~~~~£$
iE: jt::t ~ii ~ JL' ll9. *Ro Jt * ill Xfl'.o :#J. J\ 1m MI.q1ftillXltIILAiE: ~ l*lf ll9 fir m xw. q:" •
~-~~!ltX~a9~1fiD
~~~~~~.~ffrmm,~~~~::t~l¥Jm.D~~~tirrJ\WMJ1!~,~~~~ M§:#J.J\WM~1ftillXltmA~~l*~l¥Jfirillm.~1fi~~x~~£~~~.~~I~ffi :3:,~N~M.~*DMI.qWW~~;.~.~~M*B.~I¥J~ •• Nfft •• #~~fI! m;flt!~~j1jm1'-~~ ~*; .m.~~~ -~ ~:lH~. &:\m_iJtjlJ~ffHIOJ~@j{if-(l£IE:~ ll9 .~~~~~~£I¥J~~,.~~~.A~-®~~~~fi*WM~l¥Jm~~*;.~~ ~~#H!lTJ\ BM~n~IW~~ h l*.!ilUftif~. (ftt!.~ 1-1), ~tr~ftlJltt~iE:!ltJ\Bm ~1fJ1l!.I¥J~-'if. no
~WM~_.I¥J1ftm.~~S~~~M~~~'~.~~~~~~~~o~*B.Ji! 51ii.~.n~mF~I¥JW~~~~I~,m-~~~$~:It!fi*~,:i:7~~~~*~,W+Ro "mm~" 0 §*wm~~:i:7~il'.;i&mlW-#i!~~, :#J.1A~*~71li,*~:Jk~i~fIl~~~~ ~~~IW"MA~RoM*"I¥J~~.~.*~5.a.iE:jtl¥Jm.fIl~.IWI~n~, ~ T~iJe. ~**~~~~Bt~]g9c9&, tre~~§;fIJ!ltJ1l!.flll~~r:IHJT 0
~f'P X ~ i't9 5t .1i!.~7\ B.:E!3'1f Wlf{ l' mt J}J J9T &;\$ll9 0 IE: il'. X ~~__,.1'-~Jl¥,R *m I1t * m.*m~~*~~.J9T~m# •• ~".*~~"oiJe.,m:A •• n~I¥J.~.~* ~.£;g!Iti1ti't9*)\.31t? *~ii\OO.~A1nl¥J.*~~~. X~~_ljV~ili§.*t¥.lmh 0 rel1i1 ~~~~x~~~~.x~m~; ~~~x~~~*i't9~~+ffl$~,~1fiI¥J~h~~~ ~9&o
7\@mJ131fW±.Ji.k-*T~~~'8'il'.~&:It!B9, fgil~.~*1E:~ (r(J)c ~ 0 Jj~® ~J1J .~~T*W.J13'1fWll9~jt~~~~fimOO,~mtt~,W~m~,*.fIl~*~ti~ ~1fi.wg~£~~m~(~Rm~~~~m~~~5t~)ti~~*DAWMJi!1i1~~~
*~~&~I~Mfi~~.~.~a.,~ •• ~~a~m~*~mOOAm~I~~ A~~#r!fQ;£ftB1f1~If1":;§tf-, ~;W~.ftBff1~If1":;jt~, ftB1f1~IfF~$~!:1fpJf1JnIt; ~!:1fpJ~J1l!m~r*J'IW~~*, ~;W~:E!Il..Ej)@.[$, {jtfllljf[~**~~. ~@3£~?lVlkm~~~ &-~ A, &-1-Wfl. 1E:jt.~:M!!AiN:mE31fl_lE. gtlf.,*ff&Hma3£Afn~IfF:1fA, ~.~1E:~OO~~.~: 1E:~~~~3£ ••
1. 3. 3 1\[!Hg~~Jt ~!Eft~M
1. kjk..w.4fr!J.j~~~;f ~~~mm~~~m**~~~~~,***M~ff~~~W*ff~~~~~~~
~o ~~~iE$;m.:a-, ~~ftiJr~~(2:, &1Pk; T m~ § :!1rfth F.!:9r:W-JF:lji 4t EfflJlff ~tJt~ .Ej •• ~-~~~~~~,r!fQ~T.~~m,mm,tt*.m~~~.~m~~~~*. ~nIt:9Jf§~. Eftjt$f:t~it~J:G:*, ~4J!-*t~~~J:G:/J'.
(1) ~~$IJ;£o ~~$Ij}E-ft*ffl SWOT JttR, SWOT ~f:t~ (strengths). *'~ (weaknesses). m~ (opportunities) • .litJfJJ. (threats) ~!ffIEJ, j!;:9='f:t~, *t~JttR±. ffm~m~§:!1r~~hlkj!;:.Ej~.~~~~~,Wm~.Ej.JfJJ.JttR~~.*WJF:lji~~~ lkj!;:x>t1E:~I(~ft~~~~n[iij. $~~~~iiElY.I, SWOT JttR~~~Jft~J 4tftffHiH'-i'Z. :G:*!A.~JttRIJ'L SWOT JttR~&.tJl;tti%RJ~.t*,G·~1'tjJ, IlP~~JEffW~~:8f~~ ~jJ~lk~fflEm~~~~~:1f,WH~.~tti~~.~.~~.~~~~ffl~m~~lk ~~~~ •• ~am, •• _.~~~.A~,.tt~~'IW~f:t •• *, • .Ej*.~m~, •• ~~~~.~~o~~~~~M~~~W:
1) W#i~ •• ~:
a. ffl~:8ft&~., ElflJft~W#i~iW.~~.b
h. W#im~~iW~~~., ~M: f:f!-6P, m.:a. ~II&, :1fft. 2)W~m~~J1l!:wmm~~m~~(~M.~~~~m~l_lE~)~.~;
3) Jt1n:9r.~:tl: ~~JIQ.iKtfjm~ (0) :fa •• (T) ~~III~H5I~;
4) JttRr*JWJF:l1i: ~tt~~tt.(S).Ej~.(W) ~~~~~;
5) r!fQ~~ar& Eff,j; 6)*HSWOT~~f§~~~JttJT,~nIt~r!fQ~~~~~.
".a •• ,W~~M".m~~*M~~~.~~,.~:1f&.$:1f~.t&.*.~ P3 :9r$fdti~ffL~" *)i:Ct~f{t.«fIlffLm Il9 JttJrilfJl, JttR :9r.~:lji ~ '-ill B ff~ ~ ~ PI ~~ll9m~.Ej.~,*tRP3.JFm~~~~*m~nIt*~tt~~~~~~~~.o
Jf:fJtJttJr.~oo:~, Wift, 5ttR* ~ :9r$;f:Jl P3WJF:fJill9m ,~., '-1:~MlfPJfm~m~nIt IJ&lfm?!~.ID~~~.~~ffi~, w.{tm~~JffrtH~1EJt, Ji!i.I*~mP3:9HfI)~JF~1e~, 19U ~tEJF.ljfffl*13m~{M~i, m~H~*.Ej~:ijt~~~fEi]A1f (jlj!fIl9~~~DG, ~~~4J!-tt ~,.~~Jf~*,~*;f:Jl~~~, ~**AA~~. ml-7JIQ.ffiTJf:l1iJt1n~~~:1foo ~ffi~.
~JF~JttJT4t,~~~~~-~ffl*~~~*PJfm~~~~-~~~mll9:1f~.~T _iDm·*Il9~~~~TiD~ ~JE(nj, iii:Ct1f:J:JfttJ, PJ~nl!- *ytltwlH:Jl1f:J:, -fgMMIl9* *' ~1l9**~~PJfj!~ ~ttR, f@1E:jt~ "JIlHlr" -f-f, lfJlJb\*lf¥lJ:Ct~ €:I a, ~
1111-7 ll\.~~tfJ~Jj;1riii;JllW.
IltJ"T~;fHk:.J1W ~ J11l ~ m fUm!l!fYc:~-'i¥~ ~ 1It m fi~, fF tfj bilJif ~fi;fJitttl 0 ~%.T*.fU~.~~OO~~m~fi~,m~~m~OT~a.M* •• ~.~ ~~#~fi~~a~, ~~~~~§~.%.~~n~o
(2) i&~.~~L ~!:HllAA~~~§fjfU~~jj~ttJ5EJ§. s::m:~~~:;Ii!:i&~.:!-. M!~ ~ ~~Aft.:1t, ttJ5E~ ~ ~J;!ittl -tE:9;ffM pg ~ ~ (p..fm~ ~ Et<JtF ftB J;!i:tlJ, § mfi;fJit:tlJ lk3Ht! ~3'&mfj. fJii.fU:fll*lIffi}f~, mllJ.!l[M~, a;f fa] JR rEij~1"ti1tM*, *7 ~~It DCIL
#-=f~ai#.: "l:rjr:ijiit1lfJf:L" mAA~ft¥lJ "l:rFn1iit", -:;Ii!:fllJ{t5.!il~jJEt<JmAAx 1t,=:;Ii!:~~T~~~~~m~*~~~~~~~.:!-tt~oi&~.~tt~:;Ii!:-~~~Et<J ~~IW.~~wtt#*,*~®~}fEt<J~a,~mAAEt<Ji&~§~fU~~~~~~~-~ M~. 4lj-1";ct~fU4lj-1"B;ffEijf2:. ftfD1*mAAl: rlC1iEt<Jf!J}iftiJ-~. M* 1[1r 0
3jLifii·~-F (balanced scorecard, ESC) :;Ii!:i&II&.:!-Et<J!lI!-~jja 0
1992 &f. ~OOP€l1'lrtflf*Il*Et<J~fE*f· -Fti'~fU;![~n~-0PJ ,~,t&.!t . i!~{E «P€I ~~~W~»~~l:~*Et<J-.~3'&.W*~Et<J~x~~tfjT~ifit~-FEt<J.~,~~ff fPJ1(!- Et<J~~mtj1f5~ ~li. ~mAAEt<J~3'&~~, ~,@fm -~1jl-ifEt<Jm~1*~t*~>jHllAA~ fmM!zf@J.l:lt!!.~Mo ttJ§. 3jLifit~-F It "~~;1j1*WJ'N" ~M¥1j "i&III&;1Jf*fU'lfJ.!l[WJ' N"o~~.1jl-ifit%-FfF~-~~~~fifU~~1fmIA,{E~~W}~bilmo
~OOI-8~~,~1"3jL.Et<Jm~ft.:*§m~.m~: M*,.~. ~.ttfi~&~ ~~.-tE:,M~mAA~ •• fUi&.,jJOO~ifM*fU$M*§~,~ •• * .• $,~I ~~~~~nEt<J*m.1jl-ifmMfU-tE:AA§~,~if~~ttfU$J§ttm~,*MM~*,M MilJtJ5Efi;fJitilJ. %~*.n, rn I?AfU~I 1" A Et<J1jl-irit%-F 0
~~, "~~~.-tE:".1tmmm~~IM~OOEt<J~~~.-tE:. ~~.&_~~IOO jJ, tt1tmmx1tl,l,{lkaffm,@'lUjHf:lJt~, §mAjJ:8fll. mAAx1t, m,mfM:JJiit, if JI1*~ I;.,tlkfltlffi ~am:~jjOOEt<J~iI~~m~ 0 -.~,"~~~dK".~~m5:;1i!:a.£~fU •• £Et<Jm~,~~."~.~." m~; w "P3'$:i1l'l" m~;;V1gZ9J.i' "b!l~" !t~mtj; "b!l$" tilfH1Jtj!jg~.~~1'f9 "M*"m~o~~tt(~~tt)m~1*~TmAA~~**.~Et<J~~~jJo ~~it~-F~~t!f.1'f9 §tj1fJ.!l[;fIHt, J!1Jn~jiIJ "1jl-jf" fU "&till". ~ilJm~~1IROO
Et<J§~~fiZ9J$~~jf*~~nl'f9~~.1jl-.*~~mM§~,~.~~tt~~Ettm
1M }}
jg JIi{.m 1M }} Jli:rtJ , JUl
t'£ JI2::$: iliflltr JliI.t1ll fiiJ *:OO?
§ ~ I fEi'ij;{H I fii9JtttJJ
I I
f@i 1f- r pg$ttw
jg3l;;:OO~~ ,:mfntE jg m ,IE Jij! 1f- fIl iN:$: ,
~1f-lliflltr @.ftJlfriJ*:OO? I !!~"3M\~ I &:" {ill f,1~J9~IIIl~m u fj! ?
L I
§ f,'F I fEi'ij;UlI fii9Jtt:IQJ 1 § $f,. I fEi'f,'FUlI fii9Jtt:IQJ
I I I I
~;.lJ"3Jli*
jg3l;;:OO!!~ ,@.~llfriJf*
~:m{fJ IfJjt1$.fIl~m:m;,jJ?
§ $f,. I ffi'f,'F{H1 fii9JtttlJ
I I ~,.~I~m~~~ •• ~~.~m~z~o
(3) ~it~5&mf,r-lU!tl.*~o 1t~JgJtPjL1jj'it?t-F:1n!ilHr~~5tffll~~.$:fiJa, ~it~3'&mf,r-&tB#£"!E7 0 JtJ1.~§~~jf~~mtffimtl.*~, ;fPflJ~JIi[lU!tl~.~$ :fi, :iliJ.17\gg~~~/J;t!?ttff;fJlr1:itt~.~~, X1~.~M!!1ft£:itffTi'¥W;fJl;j£fljfJ 0 ~ff~~.~~mtlit~tft1i!Z-§ffir .. rF 5WIH ~~:
~ft~i!i!I1. (why): ~~flt~mf,j, ij~~&l!9Cm~~f$:'L'JE*j] 0
iflHift.z. (what): ~7mtl:mf,j~ffF, mf,jiO:ZYr, )f-§ffimf,r-JE5l;fJlit.05:t, k'l JJ!t*' ttl IN.Jtt 5l , $ i)l. •
:tmfpJij!~:It (how): ePiJJltlit/Jr!, -§ffift~*~ Ole § IN.j:~, wL~,*~9X;:Jtf1MIEit~
m),a./J;t!(~ •• ,.*,M~ •• ,*f$:Wm~) k'lH~ •• W~o fiiJlJt~~. (when): epiJ!IJ:ltlJtr6Jmt!fJHX, 5l[Jtj,IiiJ, Jj, *, ~&f.9X;&f.mtl:lt. tEfiiJ:it:it!JJil: (where): epi!i!I1jb~EFftE1I!!.,~, $t1mtttW.
itU!tlil:, ll?ttff;fJli&:itf (who): -§ffifA m-tyJ~~il:Hmit, ?t:fJT;fJli&:itt~m-ff$ n ~~ffA.
2 .... '-&#-.fll,: ffJ.7-#:i'e-.1l:.6\1f3.. tEJ.1*~~$~~,7\gg~~~~.m~-~~*~r~.~mt~-~J.1~i&:ittI ~,m*~~~~i&:itt~~uW'~~~~~~o®tE:ilim~~0~'AWm~B#£m~ ~-~@~~~~~~~~,W~~~~$j],.~*~~~~1t~~.,~~0~~~ ~@~~.z-o~~.m: "BM~~1I!!.~.~~.,ftfiB#£**1I!!. •• 7Bm~~ ~~;fJlH1Hr~~. 0 ffi~, ~fnf4t1i1Jj~jfujfu~~, ~frJt!!.i1J~jfujfu~~~J::f1J~@W;ffttt :Wl9!m~Jl.@:il:~0RJ:fI3m.jf~. ;I!.®0RJBMl)t¥!T l=j:Jtft!!X1f~$l':I9m:w. ffii~ § c. rPJ §a.ttl.M,~®m~~~m.~~~.,~.~m~o"~~,ft!!~~.:It~i&*~ ~~Bm~~~~M~nm~.~~,~~m~0ffl~j]k'l~,jfH~AWm~~~J::fB m~~0RJ~tE~.~:Jtft!!~.:fI3M~, ~1Jt.~~W~~~:itf0R]~"M.mj]";fJl "5Git1:WittF" 0 7\Wm.E!ff11l!~~it~~~t* -;f.FI&~lf:m:~:ilim ~ "'t, M!Z~~M;ff~
~tJ, ittIL~_m~~~%i'il 0
4'-7'2, j£.ill'.j:WlIffi~frIm*~a9g£~ffijJ, ;i!fJl1lijJ::::f'~* ~ ~~nlt*a9~~, -tt!.* E! g:2~:It -IX:, JJIl it ,gUJrfll ~_rz: jJ M"!:ttll::1t a9~~, * ~ rtf~32;~, ~J:j(: 1t, wH~tDt# Pllk ~ g~¥~&~~~DMj£.ill'.W~._rz:~~.~.,Mrtf~~~it&~,~.~.,~~. ~*~~~,~~*A~~~*~~~, B~nlt~32;~~*m,;i!::::f'tt~~Tj£.ill'.~nlt ~,£~~T~HD~§*~ffijJWoo,j£.ill'.~~~~tIl:~~~~~, ~~a~~~.ill'.~ ~m~o*~~~*~-#~~tt~.ill'.~~~~~~KT, ~~F~~~~E~~M~g ~~~~~ttaitt~~,~-~~~~m~m~~~~w~~~@*,.~~~~~~~ =*(~~,~_rz:.,~M~~,~*~)fIlm_=*(g~.~,rtf~&.,g.ill'.eA ~).~~j£.ill'.~~~g~~~~~,*.~~~m~*A~~~&*~m, tIl:~-fJl~ ~E~,-~**~~W~~~~~~~o
3. _.\~i'-~: 1th£\(.4-!f3italJi~;t* 1Z1l*¥fAW~~-ft~-#~~~1tfj-*~m~'lffm~~~ltljJ~:iZ\l1J, jj~.z., ¥fA~ mJq*~~~~~&Jltj]~, ¥fAW~E!lJIi § ~mg;; § fjWtJJJ9C.¥.. JJ!u~m:fj*~~~'lf fmm1Z'$~. *wm~lJIi§~mg;;§~~.~,~~~A®~E!lJIi§*~Tj£.ill'.~*~~~m~*·
~. ~lifH~*®~~fj~U$~*~.ill'.~~~~~o jjtt*iI~3'&)Hfr, ifiji, i.JUjU*W**~ ~a*m~, ~~~§~fIl*m~~m~~~*wm~~~~o
*.~~ww~~~~~~ttw~.~~~~*~~~~~~~~~-ft~~,~~a *~~~~~~~R:~T~~~*~fIl~~,ifijim~~~~~~~~jJ,§mm~~ ~~, ~32;~~1~fIlf,jff!1f~B9lttx~lk*mM §f,j~*Ji, a)Hffflm~ft932;~~UL, liffJJE i&itt*iI.ill'. 4}-1¥J it1G{jz1f, *iJUjIJ,guiJr I¥J tJL~ 0 1lJ ~M. ~ T 1m ~ 1Jiti itt fi if ., :
(1) if"£lI.g;;~~~ ~auJJ< ~; (2) WWgll.~~~I¥J~~;
(3) ~~~~~fjff~~~1 H:;
(4) Wiji~~fJ!i*~*:it¥lJ T *.I¥J~~~*.
-~:lm, A®mJ13'lffmJ1Ztrm:f8¥~jj~.®~%~~RI'2Hl=i*I¥Jm:~W£~tt9, 1ffl~~ittt ~ittl¥J-*l!, Wjj~® m.I:!irit1ff~l¥J-ftitlrllJ~, JJ!UPI~.iiltu QCC ~1J~*:fjm.~o
4. * ~ ;f3.~ £\(. 4- fttJ§:-;} ~Jf K~I¥JJEX~:m§aum**tt9fi~,K**~~~~.M=*(~&)~PJ~tl. ~*/J, llJ m~IJ&tt9:fft.~~IJ&I¥JFn*w;j~'Jt.*fjiJt.
AW~~~~ JXtI~jt;f1fm~11£~1tfiA~mli!~~ft9 KIl&-*~ 0 ~~ PI ~jjttm~~ :!ttl, J1Zffl SWOT:5ttR, x1~tHT7\W-tfJ13~~a9pg'$m5jJ, ~~fIl)(1-t~EWagit~fIlg;; ~r.t&7HflUfmft9tJL~fIlJRMJ.*rr*~:fIl!8~, *ffMmiJUjU~ pg$~~, :9~$mtMJ~m ~JXtIl&-,***fJlm~*~M,~M~~~o
-fti~,*~m~~~~~I¥JK~PJ§m:
(1) *wm~~~!jj£.ill'.~-fIE.~~B9tfJ.iNiJtto AWm~'lf~I¥J~nm~,mEjJE::Jk~-fIE.~ _~* a:!lf~tfJ.iNiJtt, ~~:lmilEut~.ill'.jt-flE.~~l¥JitJVtQ fJlJ1Zrt, ~:ljm ~ "'t. AWm.E3~ ~l:j ~~1t, H!H}fIlEt! ritlf *~~I¥J~tJJfJ!i.g., ~1~1m*~Bf1f:9:;**, i'IH~i.i~o
W~*~W*~fiw~.*%~~ft~~~~.WM,~~~~~ftM~~§~.~ ~UI!t37j~ ~~ § tj a9 ~nX., jj~ 2. ¥tX;t13mJ:!ffttr /\ ® *~ifJ:!l!.1I;fh'E:At a9 f* J~\ ~~ jJ. ii? 1!UIEYH~~m®1~a9~i*iA JRJ;fj:j.:t~, {ti~7\®*J1!'lfJ:!l!.~~~M'~r 1::.
(2) 7\WMJ1!fiJ!tx1ftAt)({t1f*a9~tlDL )({t~*, &t.~:ffl-; *ret •• :ffl-. ~. 5:ffl-.~W*~fiJ:!l!.~~At*~~Mfia9~¥. ~ftAt)({t~~¥a9m~~~3~.~¥ a9~jJ¥f:ill¥lJ~lJ&o 1f@1tAt%!. TW;i1~W*~~tl~*f~&3tta9Eti::I:)({t, i2:1f~m@! ~a9*ilf;fj:j~i*.mIa9j:t:lft, 3] tm:TJ]'!:*I¥.l~~ITff~!!lL~&~, ~-*:g1HlZIBJ~~WM. ITff~~~re*ft*~m~~~-~~~,~~~~~3ttT-~r,~X~~TMMa9 ¥fro
(3) 7\W*~tEfiW;fj:jtt*1j[ma9lill.jJ. tEfiJ:!l!.1Jmia9Iill.JJ'E1:JiS:
•• EM~*WI¥.l~§~ •• ~.1f@1t~.tr7\W*~,iA~Q~B.~~A.~ 7\IDj*Jq~3Jm, .¥1j7\ft*~m1f~~1fiif.=f:5WtrlJJd. T 0 ~7f1t~ q:ra97\[9*~~ §~ ~,ff~0ma9~W*~~*~~*~~~~~~-~ .
• m~~m~o1f@~tE~@*0~~~~*(~~~~~*)a9A~~Jd.*W*~ ~~§ fiii. ftlJt~Tre*0P]a9ff{~5gtlJnT-@q:r/J\ftjJ.r_, ~~M1tAta9A,*'Y:;PlFmHlt~~ m~.ff~-#fiJ:!l!.mA,~M~tta9W~;fj:j~~~rlJJd.~3]~~a9,ffitEA,*~fflL, ~~1tAt§~~~ili~,~*~.~~~~*lJ&l¥.lo
·m~~iA~~[9*~fiW~~~~~§,i2:1f~~7\[9*~m~~~,*.~M~ ~a9mi)ilJB$:'E1:JiS7\IDj*~fl.:}~~, ~~~*, m*;fj:j~*a9*.ff,*, %HJlIID !R~t9:,
.m~.~'E1M~§~~,~~,m_;fj:j~~~;i1fia9~Wm~fiJ:!l!.ft~, Jd.H~§ ~*£~,~$,iArlJ;fj:j~~~~,~~jJ:I:~g;AjJ,~M,~~~nmil¥.l~~~~ ~~~~g;~.tr.wmA~~,fiJ:!l!.~m,n~ZM~.~.,.~o~@~~~7\ [9m.&B9~%l:~.**}Xl.1!& 0
tE~*nma9ru=LjJ±~~~Ex>t~wm~fiJ1l!a9~~f1f-j)lIffi~mJo :ff@Am~:li!!.iA~ 7\ft*~.~mffn~tE1tAtq:ra9~fflo.ff~~~~$#.~,@~~~nX.~Atq:ra9~ ~Jli! § ~1±fM~ $#?t;ffi1J~;fj:jIAo 5lP*.z_iE~, 1f~a9mi)11 ;fj:jftfuum~, ,t_EIHj!~ M~mmff1J~, ~~*~1±~.ff1J~a9~mo
(4) 7\M*~fiJ1l!~ {tAt~Il?F'I!(5la9~~'1':t 0 MJ]'!:J:!I!.Li}t, 7\ftm~ l¥.l.wmA~m TJ9f:ff~~a9{tAt, @;Ij1dm*1t}]tI¥.l~mfjfimH'jpJ, ~mfjflM~~ff. ~~~~ Er, ~¥-f B91t~~Z;i1~~~)7\[9~~.J:!I!.m.~~~~~M~*o
1 . 4. 1 1\ft§m~~lt~m!H~~ 1tAt~.7\Mm~m;fjl¥.ltt~*.ff*~itl~-~~JJT11It@&*I¥.l~~m!R. *~ ~m!R~I¥.l*#~~~~.ff,mnX.~wm~a9m~,*~o~~~~~D~~WRI¥.l~*
*'f4: f:U &:'-ii-a<JWti1! c kA m1W 17!1 ~:1J £lilfj a<J:t\ 1m ~ flHfI.AA~~n&:t\ 1m ~ ~ ~li ttt&J£ a<J JiIt:ro fi!:iiL III 1 ~9 ~:t\Im~E!ffmmg;;~¥J7f-;l:1II 0
l 0JfJil'!i~®l~ I
I f~~:l I
I -"I::%-ffijltA I
I~*I I
1!f.*1
I ~* I ...... I ~* I
:t\D~~mg;;~.~~~.m~ •.••• * .• W .••• ~JiIt.~fia<J~.~a ~Ltfmr :
1. ji) £ 4ji -If-
.~.~~.flAW~E!.m~~.~a<J*.~.o.~.fi7\D~~.~* •• * ~.*a<Jfr~$W~*~.~a<J.~R~.x*~~~~~.~.
2. -m -If-;f
f~~.2t,g;fllxf~Jl~H!r:rm a. ~/\ D#S-~.~I¥.J*.jg~o f~ ~.j& 1ir ~fr_ft.rr:t\ D#s-~. ~!J\!lI.l¥.J ~ ffi., !1X:.~ 9=' ~ kA __t a<Jff~Affi., ;ttI fl'j& 1ir ~ kA ~ 1f:tW. ffJ~:t\ D ~ ~Wmmrr~ml¥.J~ •••. :rm§&§5.~ .• ~*E~Mfi~~, •• M:t\ImM~m 19J~i*ffl. c ;tt~JLAf9Hgffi:
.~*R~~~,:1J:t\D~~.~~mn~; ·.R;fIl~*:t\D~~.m~mmfl,~~~lfttl¥.J~§~~; · *~ "W:1$ft~", .~ff9}I¥.J~n&tt;tJ@!J¥:;
• -itm*E.It. ~m&:,~I¥.J~*;
·m~~~;
.~~m~,.~~~.~~~.~~§5; .Y.*Im#s-~ff~I~~~*l¥.Jmm;
• ffJ.lft®!~ ••• m:~.m: 0
f~~~1£*1!!i#S-~mAA 9=t®~*__tJa rl¥.Jfl'ffl, •• mfRt& ~JF.fl§l~.I¥.Jj:*c 3. t- ~~O!,. ;Jft
•• Jlm: I¥.J IlRFt1£:;f ~ I¥.Jfr~ 1f:;f ~ I¥.J ~~ o 19IJ~!l: 1£JAffll~/'\.01ij, £ 2t itM!1iIi!ijjt .~fIl~.f'};m; 1£.Jt.'tJ.R (Honeywell) 0PJ, Jf.Jlm:£~j§#J.~fl'm, trt.13 N .m.~§.~f:Um~I~I¥.J~m.m# •• 1f.o
1£~@~~9=t ••• Jlm:£$a<J~~~fr~~*I¥.J~aAffJ~,jtIf'};£W~1f.m ttJ9l:, IN:1Jft1f1f£1tffi..:tE~01ij~*~.~. mHl7fhi:t\fi#S-~.~Ifl'; ftff]~7\1!!i
,~
•
m~~~~~~~~~,~~m*wm~~~IA~~f.Awm~~~~*~±~~ Jffjg :
·mff0m.m~~®m~~~AW.~~~ •• ~W,A~~ •. m**w.~~
~ft~0m~*fJE~~. $n~7f~, t-f~~*0m~~ff:~~,c
• 1!! ff~iJIIr}iji, j;; ~*~ ffJ. ftfiJlI/\ W.~~JJ.lk~it1rj:ij~ffiiJ~ .
• m~m~~.ftJJ.~~~~~~AffJ.,~D.~.n&m.ft~~~~~. ·jg.~~§~.*.mm~~~~ .
• ~jgm~#,~~ •• lk~m~~*ft~.~~m~,n •• ~~~~~ill~ Iff: c
• A~m~®~D~.lk~m~ftAW.~~*tt~~~~~~$~~*~ff*o .j;;ffl~ft~ •• m.*fi.*~fi.N*~.lk~*~~.AffJ.~.~1rW.m.
Ji!.®mM.
4 •. w..~
•• ~*W.~WJJ.~.j;;.~~-~~~.~ill~m(~~m,m~m~.~~ ~)~.AW.~~*~§,~~~~~AW.~~§~~**~.~AW.~m~~~ ,c.'hii. flBffJ ~~ h~~~fEff*Wifr~if.~~!i&. J',1(Htr~ ±~ff*~:
•• ~oftm~#&~~ •• ~m%~,~fEAW.~~§,*.m~~mAW.~ 1rj!*JiIt~ § c
·.~.~fE~§.-~~ •• ~~JiIt~ff*,~Mm~"mn~Iff:.
• ftfiJl[. A~ftfiJllit§~, j;;~ § m~JiltffJ..#\JUr~~~~.:fr~ri9I~lk~*@mri9 ~f1~iJll.
• 4ii%. :hm_m.m-Jt-ri9X*. *~~W~fttJc:i!:fr5&::tt!!.Jts¥IJ~*ri9§tj.
• ~il.o ft~fI!]f;A~ftfiJll. ~f9tJ1i1f~. Iff:J*i!k~fJlxmtm;/J~, ~lIiri9~~~JUr ~ IA 1Jf!f~il.titffl ~ri9Jtf1!!.~1JJ. •
• £.oft~=~*.(~*@.~.~~)ftmJUr~~fJlJUrIA1Jj!~mri9m~, ~R~.*-§.fE:fr~mri9~§,.~-®:fr* •• ri9~ •.
• .iA. 5Mi1: -'=3:it f1!!.iJ1¥Jt ri9 ilff:. £JI,iJr ri91fif ~ m~ c
•• ~ofi:fr~Mri9A~**~mm~~,~m~~.~~~N~±~~afEri9 '~~o
.~ •. ~§%~E~ •• wJJ.m.m~§M~o ff*Wifr~~§~,.*m~.ww,~~.m~-~~fE~AWifr~~§ffl~7f~ Iff:. fJt~m~~ff:ri9Ja;/J, ffJJ.ffl~ri9*~. # •• 1l!.rm §~1-!1JiltJ}Jo ffmBr:Wifr;r.q ffJlri9:i£.I&.M, :tm*ii~ -®J't.:fr~ h _g)f~'1E *E~JM*, * W.;r.q~ § jj 'M'~F~ I&i~. f.i~*o
fF 13 - ~ •• Jj~Hm filfllJ. "F $~ it flli :
• ffJl~®!Ji¥nh Q JlIiHir~'@!~~U$~m:&hfJlIlR'!tvt~m~~ § ri91ft.:fi, ~n~~ilJg ffl§Bri9WJlfllihfJl~%~flli,#~flli~~~~ffl~§ffJJ.~nf!~~~o
.~ •• fEoft*W.~~§~ .• W%.~.~.~~~.o:h.fEm.,&~ri9 ~.,~.~M~~.~®T.~§ri9~-~1Jw.n ••• JiIt*.~~~.*.
·~~o~~§m~~~~~*~M~~~A~(OO~~~,L~~m*,~§m~ *~m~~~.~~~~n~)~~o
·m~@~~*~o •• ~m •• ~~~~A@~*~~._,~ •• ~,~.,m §'\'~9.L ~ § fl::l~* ~ f!tliiltDi ~, 3!H;: HI LfttiA Iiij if{J~tz 0 -1-tt ~ ~ It. &Hijf./f$r£ 'lit ~L •• ~~.~.ft,~~w.~~§~afia~tt~«. ·m~,M~~fi~o~~~~§~mm~~~,~w.~~§w.§m: §~@ ~,~§m~,~~I~~W,ff*M~,~*~.,~Mm~,m~~~~m~olt. ~,@f3l!:fi:ff%l:~mi;tl~i'£'j%l:~fi~, 1jZ;fl~ § ~i;lJ~aJt:tctl~, i!.@H::~ §nX;:9J~~.o .~~~~o-1-nX;~~ •• ~ •• @m~ffim~§ff*~~:ffnoo,WM~§~~
~:ii?t~~, rtJ.~~k!":x-t~ §mf*L~~tl$T 0
• A~3C1i~.jJo ~1-J~§.~, •• ~,@tA1f-),E~A.ltjJ: ~~, 1f.jJ, rtJm~, :ff§~JL'; ~Jjl §fm~1!f*pgll~~~.~J£i;f1j~n@~ (itM-~~*; ;f1fJt.:ff/F1iij 1f:lt~A~gll~-1-~-Jl9m~.
5. ~*
t.j:.H:: •• JYi § mM.if{J$;~~tlt/j\JYi § ~mM.fftJfA, ~fnfi~*mi.}IHt*mi)li~ ~§ ~ •• ~1lU, {§'I*J~~it~lXDI3-~o -.@~nt~l§".~~1E:~. 1It*lt{9lJ~~I$fi ~:ttt.j:.:t&i)Ii, ftMn~~.m~fE~l§".~~jf:fl~;f:UIA.¥!J1E:~~ l31itm~qt*"o tE~W.~ff.qt, ~{fH::Alt.$, 1i!.H::ii~*~jJ.o ~fn~JIRJfH:::
• t.IH*~~::t1W~~.ill'.~1R;
• @.1L~1W~l3ml?A, :#13~~m~~Iiij.3l!:fi7ig~;
• ilE3l!: m ~~~~ 3t: ;
• fEMrBJ~9='tEJYi § L;
• tAfii&aiti;lJkA~~$;*; ·~It{fM~JYi§~tAfi~~~~E~Jjl§;
• f~dt=i$i~~±~o
~~.~1-J~§OOM.fft~A~~~.~§M,illmA:ff •• tE~§mM.fft~Anoo~
l{g~, :&~~it. 0
6. jk_j}- §t -t A..
~T~J2li;~m~1lfrm§fft~A- •• z&h ~J;}J~~mi.~~§ifiW~~~~*m l'lfQ~A (:ttWWm!:lf) ~~*~~{;, &1fftMn~-w.iMJ;f:UfflIlb, ~IDi.f!!1~~1lk~*:fiJi ~JDi;:~a .ill'.*fQ.A/F~J!l!~~~Jjl s. ft!!fntE~W.Jl!ffJ!l!q:s~JIR~H!:
• i5~X-t~mi.f!!~~m;
• tIJ. IIbJ2li;1f •• , ~ '*' ;
• 1-Jlt1W, ¥i'*'tlf*Wfil~*;
I · ~tt •• , ~.~JYi§~nt:iif1;
4 • Wl~JiJf.@m:mr~~.*, ~.rm§, f*~~.ill'.~r:jJrtJ~-~tt;
.~~:ttfti&3l!:.~~~,~~i&*~*o ~~m~m~@~~~*~m~m~I~~*.~~,Af*~~W~m3.o
~!lm 1-10 NrlR. {£:2&*1Tt\~*Jij-~~*[g1"IVr-H. JIP~AWL :1JuitWL mt-ffW3 f!lmt~W3, *~~ ffl4~5 if::(fJatrBJ5CmtM.~AMJlJJif1;~W3I'B1::ii;N.
~t\~.Jij*ml'BiiW~,.-IVr-W.~~W=~~h:tt*mh(M~~I'B~m. tt*h.I'B~~.).W~mh(.n~(fJ~~.£ •• mmMf!l.~.~.)f!l~~m n(~~L~~~.3~~f!l~~.~~.~~~h.~~). ~mml'B~n~~~~~ :=~itimhl'Biihat, ¥t~I±\Jmm 1-10 Nr~(fJ "*fjUHJT,~". ~n*~~fl~:fdl!!.~m~ h.~fimh,t\WMJijW~¥t~~¥-.W"~~". W~.mt~.Mii~@fi~~, t\WMJij¥:t~~{£:jki*A. M"Rjt!r:ff ~ r"*, 19{£:2&f!~J!:M*M$I'B3'&ft, f!~~M*M~; ~(fJJif1;=9J~h c
t&M_ (:]I;) 7\W,,*~ 'Iil'*1¥J ~!&M
A
~*4*jJjt: Strategic Six Sigma, Best Practices From The Executive Suite, Dick
Smith and Jerry Blakeslee with Richard Koonce, Wiley.
1. .!f-AJt}J
~ AW3X ~ ]11J®tI7. Ji}i)fI.!3~m~~. ~M"~mU:J~f~mt=9J~tI7W.
(1) ®tI7. ~{£:'\&~;.E~~:oo!t\W.Jijat, ~n~{£:2&~{tPfW(fJJmtto ~at~~: • 0m~~®i~ (ltJt~1T'§. ,~,~) X:M"t\WMJij, :;Ii!:t\W.Jijl'Bf~M~; .0mB~flT;j{J~Tf~~1lf •• f*~W(fJ~;MiJ~ C~:l!!;~T -1-flf£®:(fJt2fiiUnlH}~); ·flT~~(fJ*~,1g0m~~AWMJijmliT~.~~WT-~~~(fJ~~~ffi; .~AW.~~1g0~~mt~~§~(fJ~~*m.~1lf~~T-~A~(fJt\WM.fij*
m1T~it:tJ, miTltm:rm § fIl~1IHifi)I[#-f- A:l!!;, flT:mWlt2:A(fJ!i!t*Bt.o
(2) mi)Ij.!3~m~~o /<ggM.fijWJ:MIi9Ji}iJlllJJ;9! §~~:;Ii!:*~AIi9. iijUIg-~il9. - ~j!5tmi)I[~-m~m= "#-f-:l.2'f¥". ~ffi~@#-f-:l.2'f¥ff.t~Ji}iJll!l1W. ~* 0 ;j{J*miJl! atIl*.J~f!l13 atI3m~ 1-3 NrlR 0
*1-3
~jJU Pi~ Bag
~~®!~ 7\W~EH!I[;~ Tm7\W~~ag~~~*m,~-~~agm~
{I'!~if 7\w*~®!~~m*,~~~*,~B •• ~ro~_~.~7\W.~~B,~ro.m
~~ 7\W.~
~{fl AW.~~~~~,~m%~ag;\w~ *W~~7\W*~~Bag~~,I~®tt*
~IJ'I.~
~'lI¥ 7\W~~~~~m.~m*~~#mI ~.~~7\W*~~Bag#m~~,IA®
A~tt* tt*
jf'l!l' 7\1!!l.~llt IHrn;:t Tm;,W.J13~mll~m (3) !!i~J~/FMlJ$lE1~$;J;b 0 tEtr:flt"HW:ttfi)lllU~1lf:lifiJll7t$;J§". mfl"-'/WJtJYi § e~ 7t~, 1f!.~ fl"-:fItJYi § 1£ tEittfi 'f:t. if J3: - at ,13! pg, :m: 1E ljiH~ fIl tiH.'. _R ~ ~*~lm:;, ~ fmij$1E5f. pg i&Yt -m~J}J B9 *~ 0 7r~:fJJWHiA/F ~::t:k, tIS ~~ 1E 5f. r*J i& @1Elffl"rtAjf$IE ~-1E.B9 @JiR..
~.M.~-atm*~AWM~.B.m~*,~~.~*ffl~~~~OO~A~~ at,~~*ffl~ •• ~~~. ~{E-@.n.~.~~£~~fiOO.fi.~M*~~OO. *m~~.,.mffiM.ffl~.*m.~ft'f:tB9~~AoJ3:~~~~M~~:Wa.~, 1Rfffi~fl"~B9.BM~i£, trT$NAB9lij'f~ Et~j;', !Z5LtItJXl~tE.t~VJ\ 0 j!~~~ ft~fF~ M7\WMf13l3IA{£!&~-~iJJA)JA. _Rfl"lkat~IoJ1E~0P]m:OOB<JJEJt.*, 7\W1*~ .B.:tDM.9:~ntl€. ~*~~, *Jfl.1~*AAB<J~J}Jo
fiii$~Atl1fl"jlJJf!P~f!: -~~~ 3~5 ~~*~~1tHH±l:ttfi)II, ~it:ttfi)II~:fi&i!fT 7\w.~.§,m.~~ •• ~~gB9.§.*B9m., ~at~i£.~.§~*AMB<J7\ W.~1li ~, ~ ~$lE1~~mB9BJWfIlst*; =:i:l31 A7Hm~mJl®U'iiJ, itttr/J\fiml B<J~*~ Jm1lf:ttfiJlJ. ~it:ttfi)II.~~nmi!fT7\W.~. §, ~at~.BMfIlJYi § ~~Am.itttr7\W
M~~A±S'i)" 0
2. ~itJt}J
~-5f.~ AMB<J$;J;bz 8, m~~B<J~11Tzat. 1fir&~i1:~-~. § I tF, 1E:ft$IE1-i T fJJ ~ ~~*, tl1fl" T ~bt B9~'1W lU;fftfR B<J ~lJ:i'f. -@It UIUW,iUi 3~:IiJ;f B<J A 1f!.* Mi~ ~~fl"~.~,mJ3:at~-~*.B<J~11T4o~*mfl~-~~iE.'/W.,AWM~~~ £-~mM~.tr#~~~m,W~-Q~Mlt$,~~~-."lt~",~~~N~ .. ~~ .. i19Xlltit-ftJ!:k. tEj!-~11T~_tm~l3IA "boJ£~:6ti1:~", {tAggM~~~~ ft~:6t~~ft~-JYi*AA.Bm~~~.
~~:OOJ3: -~1JT, ~ft£\Z'§:
.M~~W.~M*M., •• fIl.~~a,{t.*Aa~A*ggM~m~ •
• ~~~§~*~~,Jt~.Rmfll~&MIt,~&AW.~~*~m~o
• bo:kmiJilJJIt, %.*WM~fm~:i'f, J1ft*~Wfll~1lfJ3:-~.M1*, ~ffl-J.i*W *~~~n,~~AW.~~0~B<J}~~:6t •
• ~~AW.~W~~~,~mAW.~m~~~~&.§~~,~~,m=fIlAM
l'fJ~:U~.B~~ c
3. A*".JIJl m-~*A7A~~~~~~~~~7~~~I~E~~~,m~~ili~A~~~~ JlI!. .. $Tmt" ~~WO Yf1f~M[7'\W 1fr~~1f:~$%i8¥ljJ!f.¥.~ IE Xl, ;It ~ M:I~ ~ -1'- JQ: j;5j £~'ifF:fjlt£~$T~1t, ,~,1f~tt*, ~1J~l!l~ill.jf{~iliJJiL :1iJ7~1~*~1t}f{, ~~~ "lJt:7\W*~I ~:fflJiIiJJ01:i] ~Yf1f1.rj:fjj. -E1:ffi.m7\~~~ilE:ilU)ftt*~£\lJfl, ilEm:-€tl~ ~~m~~*1to~~~~~J!-ML~~~~,01:i]~~~~;ItX*~~:
·~W7\W1fr~~~~m~~~,~;ItmAW~~~~~~~ft*}f{*,~1tM:~~ mmm7\w*~~m~*~,~MW*,*~B*ffi~~§*~~~~~o
• f6~AW~l¥I~~M[®i~, ~lljJl]::k/" W~l¥I~JlI!.1Jf!{E~~*J .li~~ ~m:Jfl. m7'\W ~~~-j.t{@m:-€tljJfl!l7f1tI fF, ~7\w~~~~m~£\lfJ! rtJ~m:]fij;fllJ@i~Jilif'~ 0
• :JM!fAW~Jq~iJlI1**, tt::k±tfiJllmll, DIl::k!HW, ~* ~ mI,~,I!£~ ltf9!J 0 ·~7\W*Jq~~~~~ ••• ~, •• ;fIl~'iMfi~~,.1t7\W*l¥I~J@i~~* l!lm:l:~1tnH~ri~~iI 0
4. A~JIJl
.E-1'-~!lTi:I!.iLf~M:mXl~ 0 lf4fAW~f1$MA1f:~. ~:1iJ A. in ~-# I ~;fIl}i!Ht1.r A;. Mi~~1NXlJfl~i'iij~*EIHt;It~m!~riij ~ 0 3i;~L, $00 JL1'-1Wt ~ a<J~ jJ, ~~tE:1iJ J!1'-IWt~rr~~oJ!~~!IT~*.~lf4fAW*~~01:i];It~~W~~1f~~~~,m:-$ 5£1t~;g~1I;ttw, m:ll.~~~~~~_till:1**, 5jf-t)dn%\L~l!l1T:1iJ1.rA~i&1L ~~~ J!-~!IT, 01:i]m:~:
.~Aw~~~m.~0~~~ •••• ;fIl~0~m •• m~~,.1tA.m.~;fIlB 191.rAa<Ji&~ 0
·~7'\w*~~mrn;It~~m •• ,~m1**;fIli&m:1J?*~iI,m:ll..m~iI~~OO 19l::l:tfmliJt~~~~~Jm1**, .Il~iI~*~i&:it!:, -€tl~;fIl~W.**f**o .~AW~l¥I~:1iJS#IfF~-.*o
1. 5. 1 1\~m~~~eSJ.it-DMAIC .j:fjj*~,Aw~~~Wme80~~.~~.~~~~*.~M20~~1t.,~ tEB!2:71i[1t~:1iJ-:a:B;;t1f~~jHR:rp]R!lJl~.~~~~~*~~1.r~ii:;. Jt~f*~~. j\.1gDMAIc.
DMAIC ft*7AW*~i&:it!:~~~1i ~IWtN:
• !If ~ IWt a (define)
• ~.lWtf:lt (measure)
• -frtfflWtf:lt (analyze)
• i&.il!:lWtf:lt (improve)
• ~i!JrJIWtN (control)
~~w~~~§~~zFn,m~~m-~~~.*~~~ttW~li~~.,~~~~ .~.*D.~~~tta:itt.m~~I~M-~~.~.~~~fim*~ •• ~OOSmT· it$nii;IJ. JI:tt DMAIC :ttWtl<Jni1;fj~A' m lR~m m :liflXt.2tf.¥fFm, :1G~1Jt § M!-6tr 0
DMAIC ~-~~.F~tl<J:ttWtJjJf. 't; j!tE,~,~T 1tOO mt:l:1fmJL +1¥ tl<J 2tJlt.&~ ~~~~~~L~~~,~ffi~§~~tt*,~H*~tt*,.ft~mn~~~*~~~ Jj.,J1E~tt.o DMAIC 5EriJliJ~n~ (7~~:fIlI*J~) _)9~tt~,~, #-~*~a:itt~n~tA;i:~
.&~~~~§~~~.~*~*;'t;~~~~~~m~*M~~~~ttW~Xt,*M~M J1tfT~m. #- ft*jgm~:It*tJT:fIlMEit}j!M£l; 1::**lI<Jj!:fT~IEl fl J3 'm, fl.iE~1tll<J~ *:fIl~fl-€~f1f~lo]li!if8¥*n., ~~Ell*~a:itt~~~; 1::5!UftlJOOrtJ:ttN. #-jj:tt~/J,:tt N~~~~~~~.~~~~,~*~~m~M~§~o
1. DMAIC It:fI~#J
DMAIC :ttW~*li 1-wr~~1i&, 4ij:1-wr~~IfFl*Jtfiurf: w~wr~:.~D.~~m~*#-~m •• a:itt~~B~.fi.m~~§mlR.~2
19i § it:ttl. tk:2~:ittfT~!UI, *tfT, a:itt:flltlilltJ i't9~ • .rm::I:~tt (CTQ) , ~i&J1t~ § W ~:(£-€rmtI<JmmJ pg.
ft:ltM- &: jjttx;f.fl ttW tl<Jffitl:lt:ftlW1ti, illtJ ~WJm:i3J1J i't9 § tj"'&~Xt iifjitj"$, W. jjtl~lI(riJ:ttfiUY ill y I'J9~A x s. :tHiiiEmtl:lt*~!¥JflXttt, .~ttN~~.
*tfTM-&: Jlttf,{~*tfT.~~II(riJ~ill y 1'J9~.xs' NP.~ttfitt9~.~II(riJIEJ~o i&J1tIffi'&: ~ft:lif;lta:itt~*, f;lt1ti1:W~tB y #-71!i~!!X;~/J\~. XS tr9~lI(riJ, M!i.1: fitI<J~M!!X;1t#-~ _3i.~.
tlilltJM-&: X;ja:itt~**fTum1t, jjtt{t$nxf4~~~, M!.ffltJ;JJr£.~fti!J]_t1t, i!:tt~ XtI'J9~ftn~,~*ttWa:itttI<J~*#-~**-w~~a~~*I'J9*~a:ittn~.
2. DMAIC iiAJ.~#J~.~,Zl~.x.J!-
*M-&M!mtI<JIA:fIltt*~rI~ 1-4 Wfffi.
*1--4
liftS!: fflf;b~,.a 1ItmI~fIltt*
~Jii.Rl.r! jJ~OO
*~OO ~*m
D (W-JEIlftEV I!lH9D rnJ iii WOO j{$B<JJl'ffr
ffiJE Y (CTQ/CTP) mLflOO 1!IHi~~Jl:ff (QFD)
SIPOC 00 /Flil1!li.JlIt*
~li'itJt~ Jj!§1J1.!Il
j[~91JOO /Flil1!lijtJllt*
~*OO 7J<Jf-Mltlt
ffiJE~ll ~1Ii00 lI1fm
M (~jtllft&) ii!i:flOO ri~OO
jlIJit v, x, ~.*~?t~ ~ .. ~
FMEA tIk~tt~J
u.f!l~J:Jmf£ M-f!i mZjlJ~,~ 'lltfflTAfIl1t*
~!lWRI..$; iJt~tiiit
lifIJlE~[i;I ftLW:1!! M1tFit~~
A (5ttIT '* ,mJ iifIlIE ¥= j(X) FMEA iNN~~
*~:xtlt$; *1e#5tfIT
1f£5ttiT [iiJY3%fIT
m,*~ffiI lJt~i!tit FMEA
I ( i51:,itJ:l!ft f!i ) Vtft ¥= tcx: ~JiiLllIljijf$; ~a*t1E?ttJT
iJlIlft:iEjf (EYOP) i:t~i1!l:ilt
~iMm :i1l'!E fmjJ fMt
c (~i!lllwrf!i) f*M'Jjua!~ ¥= «x: mit:i1fl1l~i!llj f,j;flttftffJ'y:, (SOP)
WJ&*l'mnt i1~xf4~i!llJ DMAIC ViE~xtf'&:.tB,flIJJIf:ftftiTJJt.~ ~I~IH'L p::~]a] ~, Jm.§)t~-m:itl:f:PfEtB, ~~~~.~Y8o%tBf'&:.Jm.~~~M~H~R~~t8.~~&flAfim~-m:H.~* m DMAIC ViE~7IHt~f'&:.tBJm •• Jt~%(~~lI&tBo if~.lE~~t\fim~tBJm.* ft. tt&,@!~mAfim~~Jj_Mt~~:M[tBJ31r-#:it12-t\fimf.T!-m:it <DFSS) 0 t\fi mf.T!i&tIT~-#~~5t~~~f'Jfitfn:i:1~i_9jt~j]i*o 't~T}tHI;f¥;fO DFx (design ~~tB ••. OO~f'&:.tB~~.]a]M,*m~.t8~ •• ~j]~.re~ •• ~.*M Af'~-m:rru~~,~W~~f'£t8*~~~fnJm •• ~~f'£~.]a]M~*.~~~. ~f'Jfit;fOum-m:rr~M.~~.tBj]i!.
l:iAW*f.T!~jjj;9=t1¥J DMAIC t!rt~-*f. DFSS 1E.fl § G I¥.lViE~. 1E!. § lWJEi9:~.Ei9mit. it 4-. Wf~ 1!f E. ~ ill I¥.l DFSS vTt>~ ~ $ #. :!£~: DMADV ViE m • ep W IE, 1J11];&1::frfJT, iiit, !JiiiE; DMADOV t!rt~. iE DMADV t!rt~t8~~ilfLt.:tt1JIJYt't1tPfll; iE~ OCCDI iiltW. 1tU8H::W~, iJUjrJ.~fM*, .~iiit, f'Jl~;fJl;if~iiIT, ~~; DMEDI .m,ml¥JH::W~, ••.•• ,*~,~ •. 4*JE~~~I¥Jt\fim~iirr.m.~ DMCDOV, DOCV. DCCDI. DMEDI, DMADIC. ReI ~o &?&i!@iilt~tB~:i£/FII'1J,
~W_*~~~.i!I./F~-~mYo ~T.m.~~miE~~r~~mt8~~~~. 'WJj_~ * jf tI: I (Subir Chowdhury) ii ill t8 lDOOV ViE W. ep i.)U}IJ (identify), W. JE (define), *~ (develop), {tit (optimize), -%ttiE (verify) 0
0) iJUHo DFSS tElJU}IJIlfI&t8±~ff*H::!&~fn1ifDIE~*~f'&:'I¥.l.~i¥6*, #te tiEepllt-ffMI¥J DFSS J]j! § I¥.lPJH'IYL DFSS I¥J~A~\z-~T'f'£iiltZ1JJgtJE:fr~m)ijt~ 1¥Ji¥6*, ~1Jff $ P I¥JF {f. lIJffl-@iifffi" IJt.X;fJ®1~.*ittHi'}UJIJ lU t'i;;t#Jt fj~ FF • ~ ~iiE ~it tI:ll¥Jf'£$VE~ P t8i¥6JJ 0 iE4£mIlL*.±t!!.~ I!t1H~I~~~JL r1ft,hfnit.illr. J.fg'l'fflnw)E4 J]j!§7f£~i¥6I¥J.~~,~r1f.Lt8~.~~Ei9f'£~R,~~Ei9IZ* •. AmMR, 7f~Jtffl~. ~1ifft~J]j! § t8PJfi'I~:L i!-IlfI~x;f~1- DFSS J]j! § H::~F1it~~I¥.l. ~ll'1 "&_ Z.Jj, ~~ TI", if.lltIlflR/Ffi~JE:fr!&~;fJl)tfJTl®t~t8'f16*, ~X!I!.iifffi"rm § tBriJHtt. ~~rm§**a.l¥Jrr*oiE41lf1~t8~*-ft§m:.~I¥.l~**fJTM~,rm§t8~*
*tJT J:k_ PIiTtHIH!r, F ffb l¥.J J}J ~~~* ~ ~*+ 0
(2) JHE. W-JEM"EstJi1: DFSS ~b"9il¥.J~,L.,ttfi!, JttM"Estl¥.Jff*Ji1:;i1!:-tHmftMffJ@i~ l¥.J.*,~~ •• l¥.J,A~.~®~.JEtt~~~Ml¥.JVOC~m-@.~mA~~tt* ~ft1:lrfUff! VOC. Wimi1mHIJ)]~~Mff~ VOC~mMff~r~it~*, I£~*, ~F~ *.* •• m.~l¥.J~ •• * .•• ~~M,.ft.$.*~Mm*ff~.*~Mm;i1!:iT F~~#,.g~~F~l¥.J~#~.~I£~*m~~.
(3) :ff2t. if DFSS I¥.Iff$twr-m, JiJff~I¥.IIfFJi1:~ifrF&lr:itl:fivMIBl!<Jfi3jf$~it, i£lfrJ MIfF&tJEl¥.JMtk:~~~~L:{J:k_~.1iI!:.~tt (critical to quality, CTQ) ~~.itl'1¥.f 't1: (critical to process, CTP) RJ.t;;tI*J:itl:fi$ITF&lrl¥.JRit, npPIL:{fERitttNlffFtiJE -JEJ)].~*~~#~*l¥.Jttfti1W.*wrEstM*g~%~~&lrl¥.J~#,#1:l*~,~F ~~gBIl9HIl~-JEl¥.J~~fffifl~gwrEstitit-. ~Q~U*4~F&lrI¥.l~1&fl9!tl, ~JE:t(~~ tt~~mJiJf~~I¥.IF&lrmttL:{J:k_m~l¥.I~g~~~*~.
(4) ftft. litWt-Est~xtF&lr ~ttfi!~it~~l¥.Ittft. Jt lHffiJi1:ifJilt., ~*~3Cf1a1 IBJftj,q:I¥.I~1ilfl_t~J1Jlbl.bfiJjdl¥.J • .:kft. ttJtRit1ilzi.%<~~fml¥.l. if DFSS rp~!i't~B!Wi~ ~ f@tt; ~tX ~ it 1iIz ~ :I: 7~ ~ F &lr ~ BIl4r:k 5& I¥.I if:tE PI. , im i1 ~;a:fl:rt fIl ~ 1iIz 5} fJT (failure mode and effects analysis, FMEA) 5}tJTiltEl¥.I*5&:fl:rtfl1J)].:3tc1f!tt. h\ ITffi£ ~#Wt-~~~.~YF&lrfllttN*5&I¥.IPI •• 1itM"EstM*g1ilz~W~l¥.JF&lr~F~NOO, *xt1:::FI¥.I*Jf'W~fI3~I¥.I~F~*f,jft. %=&-I¥.I~ g llifliH**.
(5) ~ijL DFSS 1¥.I~"liEWt-Estl¥.lff*Ji1:~FJl~~itjj!~tiJE.$~*, Jk~:iEJlJ:WI~ l¥.JJllt.*~l¥.J.RttW.imi1~~F~~~~~-~~~l¥.J~F~m,~~~#l!<J.h, ~1@tEfI.lPI~'t1: .• g.x~#B<J~"liEfIHr~ DFSS J.j! J:=j l¥.I,ffi,M1!f 0
L:{__tJi1: DFSS ~b"9iWt-~l¥.Jfij~1rtB •• ~m~ l¥J~1af& DFSS 1fI'mJE l¥.J~NPI L:{iI M.ffii£~~l¥.IttWrplli~PI~~T~~~IAl¥.J~m, ITff~~NSSl¥J*JlltL~fEW~ ma, ,*1.WF&lrfl1~Wl¥.J~Jf~:i2U~~mm DFSS rpl¥.JIA. lit7/-. i£F&lrR#l¥.Jitl'1q:t :i!~,@f~ m#ffl¥.JF ~ lIli1f1~it, .ftJm3f1TIf1l¥.J}M-~*1Ti9jtF ~lJt:i:tf1, 4i1-Wt--m I¥.IIfF$~ft5}~m~E~M"-m.i£~~l¥.Jwr~z~~~~-JE~XXQ~~NSSl¥.J~ ~IA~if~ 10 :iJW~l¥1ii!o
*I:~~i
**~~t •• ~~~~&.~.~L.~*, ~~*T.*~.~~.~ •• ~L .... *~.~~.~~~m. *~*~.~~.~~~~*. g*~~.~~.~~ ~.~~~~4, *~.~*.~._~ •• , ~£*~.~~.~~#.~o*~.~ *.~~?~#.~*~~M*.~~~.~~~.~.*-+~~~~~.A4*~ ~~~~.*,~~t~.~~A~~~~M~. 'M~~~~M**~~~ •. *~~ A~._#~~~~&.~~,~~T-~~4~~. -+~*.~~*~A~~~~o
nN.~~$~~~~~*~.2Z-.n~~~~~$tt~~.~*~n~Z-. ~mm~~~,~~,~~~,~~~§~~~~~~.$~~ttn~~~*~~;m~ ~&i11~-€~fkti!..m~imnnW5llll: ffij;!kn![ ~. JlJltt ~JJ.m:fE~ :!iIHJl-€~ ;ll~m, fEl.!E * ~ ~ ~$~imnnWffif*1~~, !l§1tt'E&:'~iIi.frPJn~o x;fr-1'-**Jii~ti<Jmmffij~ .tt~;Ii! ~'~*M~~~Z*,M§~ttJii~ti<JnW*~Jii~~~*o
AW~~1fIm]w.z-itl!JH~T:l:1:~&JZt. ~Y~ll1j,*ttl'13t:1F 0 J\W~~ff~/FM .~-~~~x .. ~~§m~,ffM5l*~~h$~~~~~.~~,D3~~.~§ ~*n~$*~~~.ffif~~~~n![~D3~~~~*fl~*~~~.m~im:l:1::l:1:W*~ ;!k. ~~.AW~~~~M~£Tm~~~~ttw~~~*~,~~r:l:1:l'1~~~~m~ &il!.
2. 1. 1 ii~9'SJ:lE)(
1. :it:U.1¥J Jt. s:
tE ISO 9000: 2000 «@::II~JJ.~*: £WtII~*i*» rp. :m:l:1:WJ:EJt.1:J: -m:mtlflJA~ ~1:J~iliti<J~~*~~~K~mti<Jm~.
tEttWffi:!:oo (31000 2-1) rp:
II' 2-1 tl~jf-.III .ttW~ff~:fEr:m.A~~1:J~ili,ffif~ili.~:l:1:.~~~(~m.*),~A, *W ili Ii.( ~:l.1:W*ttM~ 1iJ il~n:l1 ti<J 0 .tR A ~BUfJj ti<J~ ili 1iJ t2tl.if:ff jfj ~ (!mN; *, U l4 ~ 5L H ¥f:), itf~li.(~xjfjfl'!J (~Q~:it~m,@J 0 ~ili-tl!.1iJ~~~FB!jtijfl'!J, ~Q~1SI-9.X;Y5!.tk.
• X1jfJ~(J{JF&ld~-Nir,*~~~::f~~vr:!&*11'~idE(J{J:i:1:N, il1ft~jg "fij:I*:i:1:N" 0 ·mm~X1MNOOMm, ~.-~Mfi~~.~~m(J{J:i:1:fi,-N~~*fi~*~ IJ~o
.jgT~:i:1:fi*m,m~~~X1Mfi*ff.~,~mm:i:1:fi&X.*,*fi:i:1:fi.# :JfjfJ JiltfiJ¥, }!JL:i:1:W~~~UilU :i1fitlrjlj:1I?* 0 MfifiJ¥ (J{J ~»&tt5'Jj~m~H~,~~ tl:!& a.~m,mjgT~MfiA~~.(J{J*m~h.m~~~~X1:i1fi~ff~ •• *~~.o .~.A~~jg~lli(J{J~~~~~,OOH~-m~~*~~~~*m(J{J~~o
• ufiA~f'Jlltt: --t-:i:1:fiP]TJ5t_Jilt;a:T~/J\(J{JT:i:1:N; *T/J\ttfillJ~Jiltjg-t-~*(J{J ttllL ·.~m*m~(J{J$~,*~,ttfillJ~~--t-*ttN(~F~~~ttfi),~IlJ~ ~--t-/huN C:tm;lit-~{IfI~1:.FttN) 0
uN. A PI ~~AjJ, i!hli9::M!! l!lfJ1SJ., ~1!f~lk:.l!lffL~, ~ 0 ~ A -fQ:fifPJtl [;§ ~, ~-fQmI!iJl'i~#. llP~~@itiAjg::fPI;f£rjlJ. ::fMm~rjlJ~;f£ifilJ ~ Jij elHlt(J{J j;§ ~ 0 ~mOOfIjJ .Ef(JttlllHI~:m~~: y ~x (J{JBl§~, llP
~~,y~~~*~.;xft~~A~.~MN~.ox~a~ •. ~~JLOO~~,y~ ~~.,~~~~JL~.ok~~~(J{JmA~,ilttB.::f~Ef(Jxm,W~ •• Mfi~lliY 119m. Jt~*.fjjjA~.l:l!l~H1I!tfjlli~.5t§JU~jg KPIV (key process input variables), KPOV (key process output variables) 0
2. iiiUt~ii:f_lM~
Mfim~mm~ l*J~m~ra]-~-t-1:r }l!;$~(J{Jttfi~~l¥Jm*, WttN ~~.mtl~EB $ -t-:i1fif5!$tt. :JfttOOfkJJiltOO~g*o :!loW 2-2 mffi:
&~B &tllC
1112-2 7:1: •• ff-alll
.~MN(J{J~lli~~E.ttfiOO~A, EB~fkJJiltufi(J{J*~m~,~JiltTufim,~ f*~ "im~"o tt~Zra]t€oflr!L*~. #J~f'FmOOo ·1Wufi~~±.~m§Jtl:flHifOJErg.ttN(J{J.* c
• E.Mfim~~~Mfi.lli.*,*~ft&.MN~A •• ~~~mA,OttNm llt:ll!:ff:i:t@i9:tt, 1-lrjlJlnrt3l! 0
.~*Mfi.&.I¥J~m~Z~OO*:i:1:fim., •• ttfi •• ~ •• ~ •• (Mfi A), m~ GiN B) fOl@!~ CMN C) Ef(Jt!!;~f.i!o ~mm 2-3 mffi:
·.~~,M~~~~ •• ~~M._ •• ,*~M*_ •• (*M~ttfi~~m IT, -jt~ llit\]jg E-Mf'lI¥J~A) 0
.-~Mf'l~~$~~A, ~~m~~~$~~llio
·Mf'll¥Jm_ •• ~*.~I¥J.OO2-3~MfiBA-~ttfi.~Mfi(~I£.* MtiD, ;1t"lli~mtjg:l1fi c ~fi}'f qmI£,mfi~fF_Mi'j!J~45J, mf:l1~ c ~ D A:Jf_ I¥J, Jttw lli [iij ~t15 ~:l1fi E I¥J twA.
·Mfi~ •• ~mtT~ml¥J"~~"~"~~"oB:l1.~~m.:l1~HJt~lifFm mmt~~., ~:l1~fFjg-~ ~~:ittfT1fm, ;1tt1Ji)a15EfTiN1inifFjg "1fmi¥J~~1ff!". ~~&~*~~*,~-~mm.*~i¥J~~,-~0roi¥J~~,_0mi¥J~~. ·~~~:l1fii¥J~mt,~~~§~iNu:l1fimf~mto ·~:l1fi~.~®±~fFm~:l1fi~jg*.:l1fio
2.1. 2 it~~~A~~*15
jg~~~~.**~~mufi~~~li*~,1fm~M~,m~~~Ai¥JfFm~~~o m.¥-ttfi~A~m~B#.jg.:l1fi~m.AojgT1fm:l1fiZOO~~li*~,.~ -~ "Jififfm/J\!Ji" m:l1fi?:tm~1tHf:mWJI¥L :t!~/J\mM~~mlfMfi, __§_~-~~ ~fFm~ufi.M~ft*#~,.~,.~m~~~~Jifi.~*.fi~m~A.~OO 2-4~,.~~~:l1fi~~A.~M~~~~ .•• fF~i¥J.fFI, ~Hm~.fF~~ '1fffmJ¥HiE-ti:, *r8J_±{f c
• -~ttfi.lf.$~~:l1fi.lli.~~.tt~ffl*~(~IDm~~m~~$~,~m
-~~*$i¥J),~ID~:l1fi.m (~~~)~.~#, ~rXI¥J.$o~Affl*1fmmm i¥Jrr;.tJ~mt:9Jm.n~~m1flW~. *ili¥JfrJ.id~*1fB 1it§M.~. IN:*, tttM]tIJ ~-ft-fF ~~,mI~Hlig~oftOO2-4~~~rttfi~~Mffl*1f~M~M~~tt~.~. ~*~JBJ!~, ~~~Wl~£:J:m~, ~"1.~~jlfi¥J.n~*t±g (~tt), :l1fiwL@,twm (1ll~, ~*)~ufi •• (~m.mt*, •• ) i¥J.~#JN:*~~JN:*~~1fm0mi¥JWmm, j_[W1(~.)~Ht9."~# mI, ~§mtt;f£twAi¥J5'HmtttMltlf *" ~W:fn Pl $tttM]tIJ~£E M.#~B,~*$ .• *.,Ah ••• ~.
~21=); '.-.:~~:.
~:}'
f.;.W;jj~lj:liW"¥- ... _f/":'
W;E\Z1l'fi' fliA *1-1: flilfl ijf.1f s. ItfIM{I s»
i:t~m:jit .f!tfflf'
-*-r -*-
~* ~*mF
~lY ~ ;l;[§1?_.~~
J£~ tt J.K (Jf#l )
2"lEM ~9: ~:Il:
tt~J$ tt~J *~
ilJ1t4- JlU~/'lf l_!ILl~
**$ It: iC*
Itl*$ Wf~
F{i ,Jllt* ,~* JIVt-/'W J1Il ~ •• 3i:~-+---~- 1112-4 Um~.~m
1. *114
m~ ff9 ~ fFffl2t~*'-f4 T)ij!~, mf )ij!~~mlAJ!!J~ ff9 t= Jlt ~DIH} rp ~1i~f'I! ffttil, Hff lU.m~&Hmm:W;OO~1!& 51 ;mf*~)ij!~ff9ffttilQ
jj~z., fftii~~n{iiJii{!Hi'i J@!~ ff9 ~? I::JMM~ ~:f.t*l ;fn;l'tfm~ ~~1!': jg Jiji ~tE *fJE fJ>t raJ, t¥JEJt!!,r2:, lU.l¥JE1JA;g~ff9t=&b!i_X;DIH}-*~:fN,J¥J 0 ;I!®~~*ff45f1lJt1t!!~#~~jg !@!~m=~ J¥J-ffrii lU.11J®(~ m ~ j;J llt 1ti.% ff9 iil!Ufft{ fij ~, !pfg 18 7 - * * It if $:IF!PI~-!3 *(~1J,mI,!@!~)~~ff9ii~,m~~MOOHff~J¥Jii~~,iiW~~o~~mJ¥J~ ~~,~~~~~m~mff9ii~~(~~)~~~T-ffrtil~Q)mf~z,ffttil~~~~t= ~~J£~J.tW O;fT1IJIJ:iijlt_*~, ~J!)A_J.ijt*f:M1JUI¥lJt=~8b:i!l6l1Ut-Jij[~) rp, JYf~~ m$.m~J¥J~.~m~,~~~ •• J¥J-.~m~o*~J¥Jfftm~~OO~fg18~~1Jff9 ~1JJljJ@!~J¥J!@!~J¥JJYf1f.7} 0
:ill:1l$ • iJt*fiE 1985 ~t£Jltiff9 «1tirft~: -€~:iiffi*~1j!~f~~H&» rpm:t£ 71frtilb! ft9.~: re*PJ (m~) Wixt~ "i!iit, ti'lrl, ftG;l!ffix~t=Jit~-.7tlm~J¥J.~~"o fm~itt:2:JI1nJ!l!f(fr:hI®!$,€~~1fIilIJ¥Jm~m;;IJJ¥JJf7lJ, *5j).mJt£JIfn~,@fJIMftI!1nJ¥Jm~ ~:,g# .iiIOC:fT jt J¥J~1'-1frm ~:iim~ J¥J 0 1frm~fft~ J¥J -= 1-*fftiUHe "fffiX., tt~" ~ ~ jg1E_'4klfmLA±*i±J¥J~B Q
.1frijlH:i!~5; Tjlt_9tm~~$Ji9*iI~*. m:ijt*Tm!ft~~J¥J~tmttD ~!PIB9J1Rtm .n~m~ft9£*§~rpfi.~~B9~m: ~D~~.~#~~ff9fftM,~M.B9ffM~.*rp~d~~(:IF~JIR •• nZraJJ¥J:IF~~.~~mJ¥Jm~).~.~1frm~. i1tiL
• fft-m:b1TdrJJETJlRmBl'lH1J¥J9t~*. ~4it1-JlR.mHl.9t~ffttilfJ>t, Jtrp-®E3::-@ f'Fffl, Jj5'''~®~?j\_~f'Fm. 1*'G,tt~B9:m~$lt~JiUfo
·~m~~~~~0m~~~~mmmo
m~ •• ~.£.~ .. ~~m~x •• ~, ~m~~I~~~*~,~.~:~. gll~, £fl$}~ffL!~L £tRB3!@!~&illl:l!lt;fl:l£~~!Il*~, ~fllJfJE;fJlili~!@!;;B3~*;fI:I Mm,~.~~mm~*~*g~~~~.~~,!@!;;.~M •• ~~Mili, ~mm.~ ~~9J. -€~mJM. 0
m~illl~~ttmm •• ~,*~~~~~~~,~~~~~§~,*W~.~~$;fI:I 11 ••
2. ii.~-l:JN m~~~.~~.m~~~~,&~~~~,mI,m~;fl:lli~~~.~A~~~~ .1fr~0
m~~*m*~.~:-~~.~~!@!;;*m;~-~~~m~e~*m. ~~.* 5; § Billl;t>jJ~~JF:t.i, ~l!J-KW-l~J}J~**,L,~~jJ.
a~~~~~*m,m~~*~MW&%~.~,.~!@!;;*~B3~~~.Mfi;fl:l~ m~e~*~~~gttfi.~~*mMfi.~~Tm~~mm •. ~~*m~*,~~~ B3.~u**~Mfi".~_~ ••• ~~&.~"~.mm~.Mfi" .• ~~R~*~. ~~~~;fJl!@!~~*Mfi. ~~milllW~,* •••.•• ~ •• M ••
~mmB3Mfi •• Mfi~.~ .• T~~ •• ~.mm~Mfi*.~~-~MfiMM ~.~~.mm.m~~mm~.ttfiB3~.;fl:lm~a#~~&~M.S~~ffl,.fi. Z'j;] u5[~ttfi". ~~~~.~X.'j;] "~.~M:i1fi", .~I¥.J31IlAjJJfmt. M9t-. a 1ilfJ~~~1itffi,~,tbf~1t~:i1fio
~W.~.~ •• ~Mfia* .• m~.~Mfi~a.,&~mM~.5[MMfil¥.J &.0
2.1. 4 j1~ !§lH~, J.roElS5J*~
1. it~~~~~*.~
m~~ftJ~m~ ~ .LEA$}}E I¥.J nl!I ~ ff *1' ~ %f8l. mit lIli9J.M B9 ~iH!I!1* *.' ~. ~. ~t1EB9m~!ii~~lIRfm~~:ftJ, I!p:W~fr.{WZ;flJ~lIR]tI¥.J!llImit~-&, ;Jf3~lIRtm$ n 0 ~tt,~~%I~$}. :A*iJ~1?]titfll~l9-Jt:$, *~YA!ll fIlJfIHf{_Jm:~ftC ... lH-3 ~*.~.~~~~1?]titB9~.,~.&.nW.M%.M*.nl¥.Jm:.ttfll~a,m *lIRfm§~w.m~1*§~ .• nz~~~~.OO~ •• ~~~1*~a.;Jf3~"~m. !If". ~ ~ ti rDli9J.ifflJ fIl ~ ii D
002-5~lIR~~m~~~OO~~fioo~m~, ~~$%~-~~*~WOO.~*~
W. :i1fi~:WHP]B9, Wt~-~~[ti]mtl1mB3fPJ, WlIR~~$n, lIRfIMit!lll~rDJl¥.J*:fY!.' $f1z ~m~~*§~I¥.J~#~~T~~M£, ~~~~M£X**~~~Tmtfi~hl¥.J~*fIl
~*.
~~B9l1R~~m~~~B~tmmilll~~;fI:I~~itl¥.J~:t.i •• ~m~I¥.J~~~~m~tt
~~.ttI¥.J11'f**~lt;fl:l ~:fIFm~ B3 IfF:, Jl:fz31W.Ii¥ [ti] ~m~~fiJ, fTit$ n i-H!11a<J m ~D*w.~~§~a~lIR~m~~~I¥.J,*w~~m~.~!@!~lIl~]tI¥.J~1*~Wili ~.~.~.*~ft~~.~~rDJ,M~.~~W.~~hl¥.J~.~~~I¥.JM~,tt~~
f;$:.iiltW, ~~M'!tI&J1!: 0
2. it:f1..£i ~ ~ a9 * ff.. ~~~m~~~~~£*~~~~£~,~~20~~20~~,~m~*0~~~~ T "'$ n raJ ~* ~ ffi.~" *6l.tJ1l!1=.~~ J::ijjt{i!! '$ n zrs] a9 t;.t& 0 P])t xtJL~ I*J '$~ Iii] ~rm $f1zrB]~".o ii:l:1: "m~N~", "ga~Ill" ~m,OOi;, it;OO1Tlatm~I*J$~iia9l!i\l~ ~M~,~~~I~~~L~~~*,~~~*ro~J1!:HZ~o
~mm*MJ1I!.Mfi~AA.z[ilJa9~#,#_.~~~~$f1a9~~*.~:I:1:W~, ~]:Il$f1I8JAiEiffF~*.~~itl±l]:ll T 0 .*.$a9mm*:tm~ A~TOO M.~~:f:1J, ~ ~~~:f:1J,x~~mm~~~~mm~]:Il~mm~:f:1J~~,~~T.*.$~J::ij~*mtw ~~-.~~~~mM., ~1T.~~$nzraJ~~~.£, •• M~~ •••• *~. Jltto
~*, ~*iiltfil&J1!:~ BH.T ~ £a1J, ~~iE~a1JmttuB3t, *lIR T:ffm~I'J9~-t-JJf §&J1!:~~Ao~~AW~~,Q~.~#~~~~AA.~~§mM.,~M~§~J1I!*~ 1i8!~*iiltfil&ilI:~-~:ff.~Jm~ 0
JJf §~m "Eb-mfl~lI::~I8J~. ;ffi:!i.#JiRiJ~~~m7#JmRX.~J!k~MW, i*MW~it JlJ*if~I8J, JiI(;*~55'fml'J9~*~ftf:~I*J~~JE~*~ §f,j" (ISO 9000L 4i-t-tJi § aTfF ~-~~*~§~:f:1J~l'J9mRX.$)t,jtga*m~~-#~~~~~o~§£T:I:1:fi~P~ CA 1iJf, ;:I!~M - mk:£Mm~tl ~;ffi:!i. ~ if a1J:I:1:fi (§ ffi )~:P9J, it~J, ~,OOi;. Jl[tl;fn!&,ij; ~1i*MW) *~]:IlI'J9, {!3.rm § l3-fN:a9:1:1:fi~lii], ;:I!-f~Hi~I8J~JE~. Ilailfilt£~J!k~ Mfi, ~ § m M. m~IIaiBtttm~, ~1Ji § %1fIr )!JW:ll*Jff~ 0
~OO1Ji §~J1I!#J~ (PMD iE «rm§'lfJ1l!~W.f;$:..~H~m» ~ml±l: ~ §'lfJ1l!it~m4t ~~m,~~.~~~~*MmT1Ji§Z~, ~it~1Ji§~~*oJJf§'lfJ1l!~iiMmm® ~ifif~mJa7#J. J&ilJ. ;g;;mg, ll{[tl*"!&~~JJf§'lfmMW*J1!:fi~o 1Ji§~I!I!~~~~;oo 1Ji § §f,j~~ Ao
~1Ji§WJ1l!ttfi~,m@~fl*~[ilJ,~*®mm~~:I:1:fi~~~ •• m~, ~1Ji§
'l"fJ.m*.~;at1J!tl.mflF. kJ.illitli!~, t£1lJIJ :fIlWlfitW § 'fW:11tlf_!::j~*; lilH!:fL'@J%JYf §. w.rm§~~.-*~~~~.*~rm~~M~m~Ma~. m~~~.
00 Jf;] :9Hq:$m~~~~i1Ea)j. fl~:lt!!*fflJJ\\1-trm § 'fW~tt*:fIl:1rr!. ~y-ar k'J ~JL ~:1rW.~M~:~*g~ •• :fIl~~ .•• tW~_M.~~d* .• YK~ .•• mI ~~~tt.:fIld •• ~&~~~~~nh.~g~,~.*,mI.m~.:fIlli~~m~ m.ffi~.VW.§*~.~ •••• ~~§M~fi.*.*~~.¥~.fl.~rm§~ W.fl~T~~.~~**:fIl~~.~§m~~~~:fIl~h.k'J&~§~~m*:1r~ 1m-FJ c
:ttw~tB~f8:~*j!g~o t\[9**~vw1fImxw.Z-~k'Jg~~9=t·c., .•• )iji~~. ~:fIl~~~.d*~*[9**~vm~m*~.~ •• g~ •• N~~~.ffT.g~~~ *. *ii~.ffre:t!ln~~*fI~*, ~g~a)j7.R~~*71-, ;iE1Qmg~~m~~*. * ii.~~~~ffl~.~ •• *~IAre.~~*.~**fi$~~.~%fi.fi~~~~ ~tt*~tt.N~¥*~.~~§nu~~~*~~~~fi~r!.~~A[9*~~m~.~ ~~-~.~~M~rJL:1rW~~~o
2.2.1 ~~es~~u
1. Mi$-a~ia:l~
Jij!~~m "f8:~~~~m~~1- A" (ISO 9000 JE50, ~~-1-) )(~JE5(' ~QOO 2-4Mtlf~.%fi~7.R, ~T~~.)(k~.~*.Mfi.tB (~~) ~.~.;iE1Qm li~ .• *.mI~~~~~m*:1r.
(1) *,1!~F&b.~*~1Wl£. )iji~-ar k'J%~71-$g~:fIl Jf;]$.~Wj~ 0
.* •• ~o~mm~* •• ~F~~.~~m~d~A .• m ••.•• ~ffl., ~nA. ~t!ffll~ •
• Jf;] •• ~o~mmmJf;].*~.~~~~.~~Amd.n .•• ftfi.~~Mfi .tB~~ •• ~*o.F~~~.*dk~.~I,rmI~~.~.~kmI~~. ~. *lIt~nt.
(2) *mU:t5tFI1~a9tf!m:1r~. )iji~OJvJ.%~9=trBJg~:fIl •• n~Wi~o .9=t~g~o~m •. *m.d~~~m~~o
••• g~.m~~~d.~~~ffl*.
(3) *Jffi.~F~~S1rBJ)IIDtFF, PJ*~i't~g~. ~nuJ®t~:fIlm~Jiji~-=~o .M~g~. Bg~Mm~~~d.*~~~ .
• ~ng~o~~.~m~~~~.~~g~ .
•• ~.~.~*.~Mm~~~~.*.mfl~~.m~g~M~.~~.«~ J®t~.
(4) * Jffl.~~~, .illdtJi. m:%~Jgt, ~~~1i.E~, g~;iEOJ ittfitm%. :tm:k.
~.~mg$,*mB$®-ftB$ ••
)iji$~3jt~mB~ "!!A~B9, :ffli1it~*B9mt!%,mRirr8<J~*~-WI~" (ISO 9000 5E ~),~-#M5E8<J.*,~!!A~B9mt~~~~W.8<J.OOH-H.~~~.8<Jg~.* ~-Wlmm~ . .ttmtE8<J, i9J;5~1t8<J¥-i,~M!p~.*~*~J[~W_§_$5t. m?tB~8<J~* § 8<JtE r: ~M~[PJ)iji~tffi**;}:§~ [PJ B9j]~, f!litl11T® T _~[PJB~
tl¥8<JJ't-i*. ~~1ti¥J~*, }t.:ll.J:jZ;j;§mmagB~**, :i1!:WJt:i1!:p~m2,ffJJ®t~,,&.~o 2. *~;§~.1Ji fl ~Ji.ili1;.
Mr-~~W~~~§W~,~§~~8<J~~~m~~~§i¥JB~o
tt;'G. )_jiz~i.Jt_grJ*fJE~§i¥JJ®t~, §m~$B~®Yr$B~, #:flHI~§~~fIlP~ .*ag~#fi~:i1!:rr:i1!:-~i¥Jm?t,M~.5Eili*magm?tB~WoM~,am~ •• ~ ~-~i&:i1!:~ft;!.f.:~n~agl\gg~~~ §, ¥r!!l 2-4 nf'1.~?t:fJTPffmit~i.Jt_gtlW:JJi! §agP~:~~ffl?,~*ffl?,M*®~W~.li~. MwMI.
jt~,?t:fJTtE.JJi!§~~#B~ag.*~~~?~~~.~~~?~~~* •• *? ~M~.~8<J.*~1t~JJi!§§~? •.
1. ,ijj 1;. ~ ~
B~~;t\~m ")iji~x1:lt~*B*~JEagW~8<J~~" (ISO 9000). B.;!;~?Jt~-# .JEfi~~ag •• ~8<J~~j]~,m.$~~.#~-5E~~B$m~2 .• ~~MB~ ~5Eag~*, m~-JE.*.~f~m2o B~m2agf'1m*~TP';!;8<Jmm.~-Wlmm(R~m.)J:j~.~8<J~~mt~*~
reag~ •• p';!;8<Jmm.~5ET • .;!;agMmm.Wmm.m8<J~~d~*(nfiag~ili) Jfj~.~I¥J~~~~t* (~~mt.). W;j~x1~8<J*t{fW~tIi!:JETJ®!$~-N.;!:.
~rB~~;t\~B~RnM-~~~(d-~~*)agPf.~B9 •• (.~mt.)~ ~ag-WIm(R~mt.);j;§~~~~%~ag.~~;5, ~~, •• *~~.~I¥J •• ~-WI. mZ~B9~~~ftoB~Pf~~m=#~[PJ.~~~~8<J-#.~ ••• ~rM.,M. ~~~.JE, •• ~~ •• ;~.Pf~~ •• J:j-WIm;j;§~~.M.3W.JE,.$ •• • ; :M.Pf.~ •• mnM:m, B~.~W-:;:, /ti!I±lMm. lI.3I~!.f.:.'tiAt C:tmm 2-6 ]iff
-~*~,~~~~*~~~ag,&~~~i¥Jmt.~ttm~~.~~,~~~tt~~ mB~~mrag~*.iE)_jiz~m~~**ag~*, ~mm~$~$T~1tI'f<J~*.D$I'f<J~* ~~§m~~I'f<J.:ffli#~*ag~~~gfil¥J~~j]OOo ~r~$~m~~~*W.~~d .*mt.,~~* •• ili$.I'f<J .• ~8<J.*m~,~ •• ~mm~~7 •• ~I'f<J-Wlm, .~~.IB9.*,MW~~gBag~~d.*M •.
2. -t* (Kano) Jl~il~ a*m.~~~~~~ffi~.*~.~8<J~~~.JE~~.*I'f<JWN?t~~#~.: &*m.,-~~ •. ~hmt •. ~m2-7]iff~.
(1) ¥*mt:l:~tt. ~.tt*ftt~1EJE (~iiJEB';!;~*) 81, J®t$fM~iA.; ~.tt~ tt1EJE(.JEJ@t~~*)B;f,p~R~~m~8<J.Jt:Jt.m.~~~~o
1112-7 ~$.Jl •• ~
~*~.~tt~~~~.~*.~~m~~.~m~~~-~tt~w~~~~~ •• ;fi~m/F~~m. )iji~~}E~1&::f$i;f:. ffiI~Ji~~~mM:~*~@: •• ~ 9tU¥t::f~l*~ ~m7o~~,~~~~~~~mM:~*~J9t.,~~~*M~~efi~~*.;fiili$M It!. mB!J13HI1$. ~~~, Aif]~~~1it::f$i;i:, ffiI~~~~:lU!Hij~~*o
(2) -~~.~tt. ~Jt~tt/F1E)Eat. Jiji~::f$i;i:; JE)Eat, )iji~it$i~. 1t:)EW
11-9$iitll~~tt*¥ 0
-~M:.~~.~1it mffl.A. ~~t;J.~m~i9JJ, "#.fmBtfa)". "~i&ffi%" :;I!~m~ M::i:~ttz-, ~Jl*f.f:tfUJ1fB]*, m t;J.1r{l!)iji~, ~~J@i~~1EIt!BtrB], 1l!w.~~-6Ir~ *;.i&~%~,~m~~~* •• ,J@i$.~ •••• ~&,Mmat~m •• i&ffi% ~, ij!$.~/F$i:tlt.
(3) tijJ19J:.~tto ~Jt~tt/F1E)E*ft~x*~~~~tt (~~m:~~tt) at. J@i~
x~m.~.Mtt~£~,g~.~ •• ,*.m.~~ ••. ~~h~~.tttt~~.~~~ttft~(~~~F~~tih~,~R),W~:ff~r
f~,~:
• A1f 3:::iIf~:9J~, ~mrJA.*Jt!.:ct;
• f.£~f}1*~i\t;
• '31 j1!-# ~ mriJt:ff J[:ct~jftJLfti!J, mHHBlTl!&~~, Jiji~,~,lJit1l14f1Jf}1*~~;
• -#~p1ltjffm~JXl.:wt.
~¥tJL~1f ••• ~~.~~~,~A1f~~~.~.,AAm~~ ••• ~X~-~ •• X~ •• ,g$Xmm,m~~~., •• MM.~.~~m.~,mM~ •• -tJL $.,.$.*.~,+* •• o ~~,~.h~m.~F~~.*A~~~h(~~) a<JmJt*i1E.
@~, ~#m.~ffi~~~, ~~.h~m.~~~~~~~$tt~ .• *~~~ft{f<Jm.,K~~m~~~~m~~{f<Jm.o
-FwHl~i¥J-=-#m.~J?t, ~A[9:wt~i&:i1t$l!#tT:1i~. tllt*J!~*m., •• *iiE ¥*~It*tt1'ff1f~* (f,jll) , .£g~~£*.*, JY1 § BlM.J.llZif<~tp~tl~filJ'*lJf;$ •• k;~*~-ftm •• ~§BlM.*~{f<J.~J!~.*ttJ!~~~.M(~Il)~., W.~~ ••• M(5m)*~,~~ •• m.~tt,~*.3 •• 1l~.*;~*~. JJma, mtl~ •• JEg3m~tlff*, {!F.Pp&;HR%ltflJ4t1®l3l\t~~JlJ{f<Jilfm •• lJi § m M.J.llZ~tta<J~~M~.~mr~~m.{f<J¥.k,~~.~m~~*,~m.F~®~~. m~JlJ{f<J.lwjio
3. Mf:i:,tlll.
.~.~~mg3~~¥-F~&;.%{f<J •• 1l~~ •• {f<J~.k, •• ~~.F~ ~HOC%, ~lURf}1rPJfm.Afftffif<f'~~ijOC%~:NJm. ,*,iJil{f<Jg~X>tm~'&.F~~HOC9}~ ~H{f<J ••• rPJtt,.*~m~~~a<J.~~ •• ~$~~~~~ •• ~.
m~~.~~~~:N~,*m~flg~~~*~.m~.~{f<J~*.M~$(l~ 6).! J®!;;,~,iJilWll~iWi, l\t~tf~~~*~*~IiJ3t~f"", ;§'jkt&AfnfJJ?1JJa<J~)£!tt*, 1:t!. ¥i.~if~~~~{tjt1W*£M-~M*~5&. ~r.'bJ®!~,$lJitJ3tX11t}]t{f<J~)£;fIlli:fltfllf.~ (f<Jl\tJ(, ±'.f*~ f:
·m •• ;; •• ~~®.#~~, ••• *£${f<J~~t&Afn~.;
• ,~, iJil. fffJl3~£ mf}1:tm~l:;) {t}]jt_ {f<J 1" &b, BOC~ ®'1f~{f<Ji&j1!~.tfHti3L; ·m.n;;~±.~g~1t~{f<J~W~m.,~~fm.~~flt;
• 1~ Mf,~ iJilg${f<J~UII!J, ~ WJf1£}]jt_~ffifl~.jin~~i9:VfwiJfg?& 0
2.2. 3 Je;!~.~£rsJI&!l
~.iEjl~HI~n;;.*, 8)t~lt3Ln;;&i~UUft. 1§i!l1JTfnT. "J@i${f<JPfil"". ~~ Tffif.;;~*a<J~lf-&, &:,m~~~?t.mo Mtt~ "J@i;;a<JF"1f" tpag ".3" Ho~~5({f<J.a,.TF~~m~fnm~{!m.,~.~~M~m?t •• ,~~ •• A~. ~f'~~.~M~~*mWag*.~~.agm~fnAm.Mf*~ •• ~~{f<J*li:, "J@i ff{f<J%."~*g~$a<J~W.~*,~~a.,~3:::~m.~*~fi~{f<Ja+,a.~
lIHlFliL ~m:, EHTttJJ&Tf'Il~*tti¥Jt~*~{4, ii!JiiLJtlAIij(~~*~m:~. R{£ft*Jlli I¥J;ffJM~ ~, iE&,@fi*A!f:!!5T:tfT1iJf~:fIl~mJ®!~a<Jm:t£fffl*5ftlF&b l¥J£jf~{-t~tJ, J£~ i¥J2t~:1JrPJ5ftl£~~~~ 0
pJTJ.M.~lPJagJ®($ll~£1&.&1tEf9fltm:fllfjlL@" -§15: ~mr~¥tJnw;@:agJ®!$, ~mr~ fJJ~nw~a<JJ®!$ (iQ.ffi_ij~.®~~5ftlN-~~~l¥JJ®(~), mt*l¥JJ®(~, ~*x1¥B9J®i$, m :t£l¥JJ®i~~ 0
m~1&."J®i$l¥J~."a<J:1J$iQ.ffi:
(1) Jiji$iffiJ1t. jj:ttiffiJw~, J®(${~~~iJR~~IDATfWnora~Jiji~X1**F&bB9 ~*o
( 2) Jiji $m~:fIl Niff a<J !lH_I.IL fJttlti: i9J!f:!! *yJ~}iji$ a<J ffM'&:fIl Niff, JJI ttl1 a;f if ~ a<J !it .,~*.$ •• :fIl~~.a*F&b,.*:fIlW.,*T.}iji$a<J.~~*.
(3) IPJ~F&b,19Himjff;:fIl~)§-BIl*fj!f'!~,5T:tfT 0 T.~flF&b qt~J®(~nw.!lX;m?&l¥JJ9t
~~tl,~~W~~~J®(~~*I¥JIDA~~o
(4) ~fl~I¥JJft~r!tt~~AJ®!~~*!lX;fF ~F&b7f ttag~~t~f4.
(5) 5T11f0RJ ag~~5ftlJ'l~tEf'&b7f2t9=' I¥J:!ItWr1fA, ~;I$I±i&\~l¥J}ij!~~*.
(6) F&b2tJl~~~~~5T:tfT 0 Jjtt~1*bt1(~~;!;~¥l3li!&*Wi,@" 5T.f1f;21J11!., JA ~~~re.F&b£.:1J~,M~Qrn~ml¥J~.R.~«.~~~:1JAml±il¥J.$_* *rrgm:®fO*~1EQ
1. -# liJ "'Ht-iftl ~
.#ml¥J.1t:1Jr!~~.~m~~*rrJ®!~ •• miffiJ~oW$0RJ~M!f:!!.l±iiffiJ1t~ ~.reM*~~~~,~mAAl¥Jm~~~~~&1toif.®mAA~~m*rr •• miffiJ1t,~ -®m~.mrJ4ijJJ IOOJJL:f1tIJf{J®(~2t;i!I'ii]~ 0
~mt!aJ~f4jJ1ij1f It ~ it5iffiJ~:fIl1( A iJjI'ii]~.I¥J!J;frB_J*, @M:£:t£M~Ef9iffiJ1'tf;Ji* 9=' %Hg tl./J'i¥J1t*, ~~@_]~~PT~ § c.:®1f!J;fraJ7i:JDt.1f. lIl~f4.1t lt1( AlJil'ii] ~m{ij;. JJI 'ffl' ltlt!. ffiiJjj'ii] I¥.J. mtt!.{ij; 0 lS@)$fij;;:IikIll~f'tiffiJ1t±~m{.'l¥J riiJJm. ffi)t:Ul~, mEff ~M-l¥J frmm,~jff;~1t:t£~~qt&fl@_]~l¥J~Jm.~~~lS§$l¥Jfl~tt~o~.~~~1t 9='. -JIiPTt:Jit¥lJ 30%~50%l¥JlS@_]$.o
M:#iffiJ1tJDt*fl£. ifWJ~~tt5Ttfi 0 aJ~f4~1f9='retPT~-§.m~.itl'ii], tt!.PJ~1g15~ tl.~.@7f~A~tl~~ •• ®M.~~~it5~~!lX;1(A.~M-.~~tE.f't.1f9=', m~~~AmX1~7i:.agOO~d •• ~§~.I±iJ9t.d.wm.o
~~ •• *,~oo~f't.1f~mlt~ •• ,~~~nstt~~, ~.~.~~1f •• ~iffiJ1tl¥JPJntt.M:~.T.~l¥J •• o~OO~f't.1fl¥J§~~~~ml¥J, ~~ ••• ~ ffi~~ •• I¥.J.$ltNif~~.~l¥JA.I±i@_]~Ef9.$£*o~T~.M:~~B,0mPJ ~w~~~~~mM.l¥J.$.*, •• 5ftl~~~OO.1tM.~~~~o
2. ~ -i{;i)!l ~
W$0m~m~8.1f#1Ed.ft~mM1folt!.it5 •• X1~!&.~~0m.~i¥Jm ,m, !lX;~ ~1m m ~:fIl ~1l*:iS. fF a<J 1{Rfi~~~ ~ Wi ,~, WfJJtlfl~ 0 iJj ~ A.m. rr It!. it5~ $ f'. iJUjlJ ~*#T.0m.~.$~*:1Jm.~~MQ*it5.~~~ftJ1l!..*H.1tM.PJ~m~
~m.~.#M.~~,~~~~~~, ~~~~*~., ~MM.~~~~.~*.m r.,( $2/J\, 0 P] IlJ r.,( ii JE :ftM~Il:ii ~ ~ M .IOJ 1m i¥J A 0 It! M iNiJ 1!f tt 4Hti ilHi fl ~ * (j<J R m tt , ~~fl~.i¥J •• ~IlJr.,( •• $*Mi¥J~~m*,m~.~~~.~@(j<J.~._.fl~ u~ ~ tg:iJll (j<JiJjfiiJ 1l, ~ PI r.,( 1* iiEJf 1iutif~f)jmfl~M i¥J Im::I: 0 It! MM. 4'iWi~ tt;i: i¥J ~~*mfli¥J~~A~~B-.i¥J~~~ •• §, r.,(~~~~~~A~i¥J.~~~i¥J. ~.fl~,~ult!ffi~~~1lW~~~_~tt~~~.
It!ffi0~fl~~m.,M.~~-.tt.#M§*,ffitt~A0~~~ •. ~~.~ ~~fiaMi¥J~OOM •• m.,ffitt~A0~.m~.~fflW~~j£~fftt.0~.,* _§Jllj] s ~~1JIl, t-f§jlj~* § i~.1li¥JltijJ 0 f511It, )7Z:llf!*mflFiI!~f4;fU~-W1t! ffiJ$.~ ~iWi,~u$~~j]r.,(~m~mi¥J~~*o.ti,~~~m.~m.~,.~PI~mfl~ lli~i1S%li!S~&flIt!Mo 1&00, ep~tE;l!~~*,J~14r, ~~M§-ffl~*~~:ii, J$.~lf!j .;fU.~.*M:I:&*uWili~(j<J.A*mo
3. -t A_ it 1'.iJ
~ A wlDJ ~OOx;j"OO iJi IOJ ~!IBj fl j] i¥Jffi g ~jfH~*z - 0 1:: PI m TiJUlj x;j" Jij!~!Il:m: ~ (j<J.~, r.,(mtE~OO~lt!ffliNiJ.4'~iNiJ;l!~.~.~AVJ~~~-~~.j£ttmA~ •• ~t! 0 -1-iJH~fl# (j<JiJifOJ 1l PI r.,(illd!:llf!l&lIk.~i¥J:k"fFLI~L iJiIDJAfft llT r.,(ia ~.m:~ J¥J®!J!iX., 1*J'Emlll, N~if J.Q..)WVW1Jt! 0 xit~J>l..I*J'$.~~~7Hm.~~1~m,@" ~ A iJiIOJ~~-~1f~i¥JIAo
~AVJ~(j<Jft~~1f:_**fiT~ ••• i¥JiNiJ§,j£.i¥JM*.IlJr.,(~~.&~.
M1!fAffi¥J:@,:_!]t!, 0 ~~)~vJ\miNiJ§~r!~ f'PJ 8I.J~, .iJliJ.Ai¥J ~~*1lA T fit! § B i¥J:i:J.Q.., OO~r.,( fffBJ~~~/J\gll$.;f:_!]t!,~ ~ xDC:ft!!.tLi¥J$~1li¥JI3~r:rr. ~.*.i¥J~A0~J$.*W*,t-f~~~0P]Wfl*.i¥J.~~.~~~~~.~~ ~.lIt,f5I~iWi¥ili£,~.T*.i¥JJ$.*;fU~~Milio~A~~~~*~m~.1f. J¥J,m1f.J.Q..i¥J0~A~,D~;l!.~.iWi¥~m0~r.,(*J¥JAm.
4. :tf-"?,, ,1' ill
~}~/J\m~j£ftJ¥J;J\mitit, Jli1itfl 8~ 10 --}$!:jif, -rettli:mt-j£i¥Jml5Hl!J!tl, :!til ~~~m~~m,~.,~A,ft~~.MitZ~~*M~ •• M~~Nitmmo~~~ MEIlf~t~?A\flLi:#FA.ili**qTm~o ~i~VJ'IgllllTr.,(m§jljilil[~i¥J&~$t~J¥J±'M. i!~ ±'N!~.~x1rc~~nlt*J¥JWUltli1t, :kl3.~fffi*kAhUJt~&*~tfl.~1f:ko
»-t~VMll~M~~~~4lt~fJl]mi¥JJ$.*~ffl:;. ~AVJ\gll~~~~*fi~OO~~~iftiJ]t J¥J.-~,m~ •• m~~~.~~.Wffig.#~J¥J&.o ~ •• ~~~~mllTr.,(~~ *&*,~~,Jf£,h~~m~~ •• nW.~~Ao
2. 2. 4 Je9i~I![~«sJ7.HJf
~ •• ~.MR~.-~,~.~*fi.~ •• o.~.fBJ~fi.~&.~ •• ~? "g~~F-w".mT~M~.~iWi*.~~r.,(.m~,*ft~.,a*,.~,**ff ~~;fU~~,~tt.]t*fi.~~~.~~*J¥J~~li~o ~g~~*~*~1f-JE~*, ~~~:
• m~faYtJ!i, xJttSl:.;
• -J!llI@j}g:~*9*it-1-*fJE~~,~,; ·~remm~IW~*M~n~~A~~~*;
• 1£ T IWAll!;ij!fM ;
• 1PJ-~JJU~)@(~iWi)1<A1t1ltJ!R.1l:. pg¥fXtfW.'&XX,
jJiJ! T IfiAll! 11M. Mx;f m iE-:ilI:B~fi1 ft~;ij!, it:I~All! PI~ lIt~tB;j;§ M ~fM~j] ~ 0 11 TE.1l:!®t~fi'ff*r8Ji¥JJRtX~*. *~mi!~-~%~fl~i¥J-¥Ei 0 Jl1*zt.;lJI:~urf:
(1) re4iJYi)@(~fi'ff>1<?tJJtl.ij;ft-*/J\~*1:, ~td$:t*J$'1fi:j[~~*, ~reElffl~~lIF 7tl~*;
(2) ret*J¥f;j;§JlI~~~~1g-:!l, ~-1- PI f2.(.fI!UJ5Jtt*J¥fi¥J:it~, 1'f11~-#}t~)@(~ W&":.jt. :!ij 7~ 'fff:tE~ * 1: ;
(3) ~~'fffIf9~~tf{I*J~;j:§ilifill]Il:!l, ill:it, 1'f11£~-~i¥JJ®i~J?*. *:'137r~ :tE~*1:;
(4) ~rlfl!.l6'~, gj:f~1:-tt;f£, 1.[¥IJ)@(1f3*~*~ffij?tJRtXJt!!.m~~*o ~T.~-@i¥Jr£, ~T~A •• Jt!!.?tfi.~mr£If9~:.jt,~.fi'ff~ • .1l:$#}t)@( ~fi'ff*, ~'Efn.ij;Afi'ff>1<mJ:.I:~7f*~ (3i!.* 2-1) 0
~2-1
1r>.: 2r>.:
L tlfF1i1l! 1.1 m'lll':n1l!
1. 2 tlfFrpl'~1lt~J1
1.3 xftlfF $) -r 31[_
1. 4 fru~tkll$JtR:It!!tlfF
1.5 tmkl;31[j[~fiijg
5. *~ 5. 1 :J6~7WfF ~~.,.JlI!i¥J.~.m,m*mm*ni!.~~1Ji!.~ttIf9IJl*?tfi~JlI!MJ®i ~l¥J~:.jto
2.2. 5 ~.w!~~*9SI~it
MmmJ:t~.~7f(QFrn~.~(mp.it:mj])m~£1f93*:ilI:B$JR~l¥J.~ ?tfi. flJJtItftW1J!i1Ji!. iQJJIJ~m)@(1f3* (critical customer requirements, CCR) * ~~~ft~~£i¥J~~~*.~$#~tl.I~~*,~F~*, ~m~~~l¥J~#~~ i.iEF&M8£it (Wm~ 10 lit),
2.3. 1 jf~~~~~m~
ttfi.~~ttfi~ml¥J •• ,m*~.ttfi •• i¥J.M~M_.~ •• (~.#.m
Itt,w~mittmfd~D ;mii~~IkM (llil$tt:l:m:IkM).
1. ~ .1!! M: -illt .. J-;til # *w~~~m~~m~u~~~~~~N:l:m~~:$m~~Ik,m~~~*~an
m%~Jf§Ik~itBmmt'F. :Ia~1i~*, -7k1i~$, mtiHi1ifilf*~itf4mmtjL ull!. 1G1rm et "F -®£~qft~ 0
• $m (unit): ullf1JOIuJ¥JX>t:it, l!l1;~ii~J@!~~-1'-F~lk-lXmHh
• ~~ (defect): F.R. (.!!l1;BIl~) 1!lflTP1LfEJ@f~~~*~~filftjffL .~~m~:$mF.R.L~~ili~~~~m.~m~(~~m~~~~~N.m~
~-.).-.~.~.~m~Ik~~u*=~:~m~~ili •• ~~m~.$;~~ ~-~.M~D~~m*~J¥J,K;£~~.M;m~~~~* •• F~~Mm~~ IkIL
(1) $tL.~1k (defects per unit. DPU). lfitLf=&tt_t1jL:Mj~.M1'-lt. BIB Ur% j\lt.:
_ :fk iW~ £: JJt ~ ~ 1\'1 ~ DPU -1\il Jf;'. ~ if!.1if" £ ~
- •.• ..05"··· .........• DPU;_100 =u, 05
(2) m~.I16$ (defects per opportunity, DPO). 4jHXm~~ili~.M~It*. *- 7f-*F* ~.lI6fl ~ :@:$m~lk~ It f9lJ. E IB rj\it.:
~Ml*:
(3) a:ntfL~~~1k (defects per million opportunity. DPMO). DPO 1Itr,nf]Jm~ ~.~~~$. I!P
DPMO= DPOX 106
(4) .~iI~~ (process final yield. PFYL tl~S:~tt9i1~$:ii!l1tJl1:mj~Li:i;j;iBiI¥J .~iI~.m.~M~~.~~.m.~~~.mJl1:,~~ •• Wm~~~R# •• Mfi l¥J.ili~:ii!ltt.~ •• ®£~~~I.~.~.~.~Ift~re~I.~~" •• Ir" (hidden factory) ••• Ir~iRiliJlJ\ftftJlJ~ttl'll. lRJR1illiliJlJ\i£Hlt*ttl'll.
(5) -7XiI~$ (first time yield. FTY). ~-7Xtltre.ffi~m. E8i9:~t~~I~. {£:iilM I¥J :ttl'll. ili .lli.® it. ili ~ it- ~$ •
(6) Vft:iilit-~~ (rolled throughput yield, RTY) • .X>fT-~ijHT~f'-ttfi. 'II~UE* Ml~H!{~J!RJL, jj!UJtiiltWit-~$1g~~Tiifi~ FTY ~*fg, ~Iffl E8i!.®TMW$~ftJ ~J¥J*iil'll~-7X*~$.
RTY=FTYj XFTY2 X .. ·XFTY.
;a:q=., FTYi Jl1:*T:i1Wtt9-lXiI~~; n Ji1::T:i:tfitt9~fc
:;f>=.19iJ4t RTY 1i!.JjJI;.t~:fHt~:
RTY=Yl Y2 Y3 Y4 Ys =0. 92XO. 82XO. 84XO. 82XO. 95=0.493=49.3%
tEl!! 2-81r3il, ~inltllilii4ij:-1'"f-iil~HI9.ti'l1f{ § 1 000 iljff:il.~ 920, 754, 633, 519, 1I~ 493 .ti'lo ~ 1 000 .ti'l19:Am-1'f-iiWIJ1, R:ff 920 .ti'l-lX1tf&o aOO~~~,Hfi~~*~~*M.ti'l~~~:~.ti'l.~.~,~.ti'l.~~I*.
jf@]¥IJ1=.f..t1Jf. tE*-l'-=fuW9=', ~ 920 !JiUL-1Jzir-m1i'01ltt:iltA~=1--=fifW, It -7X1r-m$1-J 82 %, 1'~J 7541'-7XirmEt9tE1bIJ J'b. ~IlJlt£tt~:iEff:, 1[~J7t$;FJi:ff Ii. 1-T ;i::tW, ;f!t~1 493 1-~:i:t@:t5]:;ffm3SIEt91r-m&l., ltiRt:i!irm$ (RTY) j] 49. 3 % o
00 2~8 Et9::t;itl!J!tlm~~llfiiJit~ PFY. t~if~-1-T;l1~, lJJ( 1 000 1-1'9:A!(!lli:~~ j] 960, f5J1-Jlt9=' 40 !Ji1:il:$;j]J$:J'bx7!]gI. ijJ3SIJ¥J 40 !(!1fLirm§ (jJfm1tmt9L ~ IDfi~FJi~3SIJ¥Jf"J'b6.Rif~.),1'9:A.=1-Tiffi.~~I,~~.-1--=fuW J¥J PFY j] 96%. ~*_3HfBi1-TifN, tl~S:~1rm$~jJ 70.9%.
*~J9=', W;f1if1:1J7!itJJ:J¥J1rm$5HJljj] 70. 9%£j 49. 3%. ~!&Et9~iti!rJff:i!#*.
M.~;.gIm:k, ;.gI$5H±ttf1t-~{t!&FJi%i~. f5J1ItfYJ\1g "~lIiiIr" 0
~m •• mmJ¥J~,tE~~~~:i:t.9='.~~tETif.J¥J* •• ~*~ff~-1- •• J¥JiiWmf.R1rm$. !J!tl.~)t;it~#.if.J¥J-1Jzir.ff$, ?&§~1tjJ-1-Tit. FTY, *Jil_Li£1J7!ttJriiW,hI,J¥J RTY. #Ii*itfi-l.X1rm$J¥Jit.§ffi:
• ~1l*~gllmt~&itJ¥J n 1-~$1tj:J¥J#$;.~~:i1W, li~~mHtj:J¥J~~ff[![J9{__\L. !J!tl# .:i1WJ¥J-7X1rm$m~~1-~#-1Xir~$J¥J*~. ·~*~~~~&ittE:;f~~~.J¥J#.~~if •. m#.ii.J¥J-7Xir.$1g~mft -1Jzir.ff $fl( ~.1Jo t£ f-:t5]. Wt1lttJfLhI, J¥J -1Jz1r.ff &it fi~ !1 ,hI, J¥J1'9:~~ 0
2. ~~~.ft.tJkJt:j:t~;f,f.
*~.~~m9='~mJ¥Jii.~~~~~ff.m~~:iiN~m (~&it)*.~ftJ¥Jif N.JJmfi (Cp, c.», if.~~mfi (Pp, P/i<) (~m*45. 51J9='J¥J "ifN~~JJ5t :fIT").
X~~~~~~~,~~~~~~M,6ijJ!1*mDPMO£j~.~*f-*ff.iiW tjf~ (~m*45* 5 :!it) 0
2. 3. 2 7.KlJlMtt
1. f+ Z. ibJ<.1- tt J:t.
* f-X1 tt~~A 1D:i! #i5tJ¥Jt.f-tf~m (benchmarking). ~-1-;fIJm-s:itt.f-ffE ~=m1T !&pg$~jr~$ ~~mz;fjJ¥J;ijl1!~~, J!P:j;!fii@, ~ J'b fI.lijlt* lOO:.~i}iAJ¥JtltT®fJ'GJmtLJ¥J ifW, ~&l.fI.lijlt*lOO:.lH'1Ttt$JC, lA1ffiiAfit §t.f-, #MlItmi71 § B J¥Ji&lH'!1~~J:il1!~~ 7)( f-i¥J ¥t1EitiiN.
2. ;91tZ.~*-ft~1-%J-J:t.
~4-, tt*fI.lfflf!&~it+JHii!~, i9:1fi}PJ.~!11JJl._lL 1&~mt*J¥J:1Js:.tjgff:~.iJt ~~*,J?1fL ~?jff~J¥J~&$L&at, ~~$, ~Im:.I'8t=&l.~ijlt*o 1T!lkI*JJ¥J~it19!1~1E: ~~~.~~~,~.*~~~~£ •.• ~~~,*f-X1~7!Et9~m~~tt.~*., # £j {t!& ~ lllF,Xif ,Iff!, t~ ill &Re. 1JtlH'lOO:it i:':lllH'. f1!1E:~ tE~$ 9=' iL T:;f !l& 2Jm . It3?: $; j;
~1TZmL 7)(.M~7!~-f'P~~1it:ff::&J¥J$I!*1E:!&~$JJJ¥J1J7!. OOi%0P]$)lGtE~!jili ,
mfi-Ftf'iftt, 5t:fIT, ~J3f1.lffl'~ EJ *1lfj]:m{t!&B9~t=~$, *'iJl'ttt*Jt~~o {E~00i *~m~J¥Jif.9=', ilf${t~RM:7}(f-M~, 2UJU:Ul~{£I'8i.&lH'm~. j]/\ 1!!i~~JY! §
fifO ~:1J JtiJ •
7)(.Mttili$!Y .Mi~itJ¥J-a 5(, it § J¥J:;f1:K{£THm~itjt!!f:il:*:!it, "tt" 5t~1~
"·"·~.~~~~~., ••• ~ •• ~~~.ft~.,m~m.~~~, ~.*~. ~~f£B<J?]{*fU-€rJf1fr.tlkl&lImJf~?HRtfi!i!tt*, .~~lJ.l "tE" ~ "MI" B<J § ~ 0
3. 1]<. -f- .xt H~ ~ 1f )f) :fI:r"*t 9.t
;1}(-¥xtttB<JffmfU~~tillT :
• JM:tt~)t*~l&B<Jx;ftt. a)HiffJ?]{*m~; ·~m*B.~~~~.B<Jft~§~;
• '1IAiiHfB<Jff1:T/J:tt; ·ltiLiE~~iJt.~i!:1Ji!;
• $:DlJJfIliat~ m M. ;
• ~1>~ ¥ B<J IlJfi:1i~ ;
• f!fmm3t~J!~~~%JJ; ·~m~m~J!~~.~.~~~B<J~*.
(I) %i1Il&lIItfo ;1}(1JLX;f It~JlX:jg--t%~1!If;$:~fFB<Jl&lItfm~. ;1}(1jLx;f ItB<J~*~.ItfJ T0~B<J~~~ •• ffl~~~.&.~~lk~~tt*l&~,~:tt;1}(1jLMItmr.tm~0~* ffl&Jf.tJ. 1brJJE;fniJ,ij1!Il&1/tf § t;jlk* ••• Wt;j. ;1}( 1jLX;f It:(£*~. J:fm!:~ltl!Bf1I¥J:IJ! § J:f:MJIiJ1iiZJfl, m:!E1E!j.
(2) ftj~~*. :(£f= tilt fUHIl9t J:f • .1E~.P B<J *it~*~*. ~. JiUf 1J11-1JOO :idl«JJ< -¥x;fIt, iji{tk:T-1-1£jt*.JlX:JjJIEI~ (l!P-1-1£l&JlX::9] I¥J ±~tk:~IEI~O 0 ffijX;f*.~ JjJ~1tI¥J~fW~: ~~jgft~~~i¥~fnl¥Jf=tilt? fll!fnjgft~mffJtfn? ±~-,*~:l!~fn ~~~~%~J:f.MB<J.~~~n~JJ%~~~-Ro~~,~~~*ttl¥J*it~**:l! ;1}( 1jL X;f tt B<Jm:AC
5. *-f-~j:G~-~:fl~~~. ;1}(3fLX;fttl¥J-M:m~fIltl7W1mm 2~9 film 2~lO FJf~o
~ f(J
1. xtltft.J;.? 2. ~f(J:i::~fPJWta<J?
3. ift!~::.M- a<J? 4. ftf(JR::~fPJf6ta<J?
ft i(J %.frIl"!W, iJUPJ.~
~- I ~i'e.&Jt!ill [§ .-----
1112-10 *~JItttl¥.l-.tIT.
6. ~-1'-~);t~~',i!'J~~f"~""~Elm ~~,*~M~~~*~~~mT.*~*~~~-~~~~n~,~~AW~~~ ~~~/~~~m, £~~~~~rnOO: (1)mTAW~~'1f~~~Aomi'Jt~),[;~TfBl~~J3~jIf~,&1ttW._t~AAW*~ '1f~:li$:J;}J~:i£:~ <:9Jl;iMmlt!.9:.0~~) ~iir!, ?&JI5Nl*}E ~ B:tmMft. ±~»-VJr JL
• :&fn1'lftz.~~At\iN*~'1f~? ·~W.~ff~~1'lft~~~A*W*~~~? ·~fi~~ftz. •• r~A*iN.~V.~?
• ~fn~VJftz.nP:~A7'\iN.~'1f.~?
• ~fn~~JlfiiJ~lif[7\iN.~V.~?
• AiN.~'1f~1'l~fi**i¥J~a:{mfiiJ?
• ~ff1~$:J;}Jt~!i~ftz.?
• ~~.@«Ht:&fnm!lif?
• :fQ~~ff1I¥JJl1.~, :&ff1Mi*~JlMft?
(2) fflT7\iN~~J9! § ~z~o :t\iN.~:0! § ±~*lIT:i£:jttJ9itwH&IIf, J®!$a<J1lW ~.~ •• ft~~~i¥J~~,~~M~i¥J~~~nOO, ~~.1lW~~B~~*~Hmi'Jt~ .~B*¥M~,tt~~llia<J~~,~~~~n~~~~a<J*iN.~:0!§ (W~~3,4 ·tn.
(3) fflTfJfO}E~ltJiltAW~~JY!§a<J§tjo -1"lJ1§ §tj~~i¥JlE~, l4~!5~~~
~JY!§JiltJ;}Ji¥J~.~~, ~~,~~JY!§i¥J§~l4~~~,~»-~rJL1"nOO~m: ·~1"JY!§~~§fi~.~i¥J.a*~~M? ·*mm~.~~~*g.~~~nOO~.~~M?~~.~? ·~ftz.~~~.~.~~jt*~.~~i¥J~~? ·~T~JY!§~B,~W.tJ9.D*~~$~?
• :&ff1~t£~jlfi¥JftZ.*¥? ·1'lftz.:&fi!5~W.~~~?~.i¥J~~~.£?
• tjff-:i£:jt~iinOOi¥Jft~~JlfilJ? .ftfi§.i¥J7\iN.~JY!§§~~}E~ftz.*.~~~?
• .ilrJL~#f ~JlfiiJ ~~jJ?
• ftz.atrEij.J!¥lJ~W.tJ9.D*.?
1. ~*,t1.-~\ ~~~¥rfj:,\;#.{iE §fil¥J~«~~~~:&fi~~m~~.tJ9~.,~:i£:~a<Jm.m~~at1'l.$.~
I. J9T~~~]t1"0~i~jjHft-m~§1JffiJ~. :t\g§m~lE~iif-(o-~'1f~~~, ~tt~m .tJ9~mtt.~:&fift.~~~.Mi¥J~@at,~ffi~AT~~~.JiIt*,~R_t*i¥J. $~~~X~~~~.%~*~mtJ9.$o~f-(o,~X~~*.~M~~~tJ9~~,»-W **~l&AB9~j]Jl 0
I"§llt, Ag!j*!f!!,1f:§!.I¥.rm,r.'!M'tiE~: j'ilfjl@t~nw:ttllfn1l£.JfItJ&*o ISO/TRI0014 «J9t .~~ttmM»~lliT~.~~tt~~~~~~*~~:~~.~m:ttllfn~~Jf~J& *. ffifi3:'~'~~/\W*~~~~~*1Jf(n!~fn~'L't~fiE (!h!.m 2-11) 0
~~!8fi1jJ&*~/\W:mfl31f~~--t-I~lij{9!~ 0 7\W:mfl3j~P~~~Jffi, Jt:4l§f § ~{E T~*-1X1.II&, -1JITifPI l'J. ~{J:!:;Jilijj)t Jt1J~ F &'b ~HIl* ~ 1X1.~, J3 -1JITif t!! ~*- T F §l. ~HIl* ~-m~~1X1.~o ~~Z, J.J!lm*jJg:mfl3*~~1X1.~;ft'*lHjf~~~f.fj. ~1lJ9t:lL fmfT, }1ij M~~.~~l'J.HJt~*.~~.i3:W, •• ~ •• T~~~~~.Mfn~M1X1.~m~~ J&*,Mffif~~T.~.~~~*-!8fBJ&*o
2. _.\ ~:f§.~'f ~1oj J!t 4rJjtj1
~M7\jJg*fl3~~,~.fn~~PIl'J.~~~~~"oM~.ffifE. l'J.fi1l£.PI*~~~ * HIJiJ~1-t T .M~ F &'b; X>t 1£~ ffif~, !iW~ 1;J./J\~RX;*fn.m~)1!iJ M~~ T :Ii:*: I¥J;frJ 11iJ. §i3:~~$~mlJiJ, "~:il:" i3:~iilJIT:.:tx1~~:ffT.jf~:tt5C
0) Jt11n!&:6a 0 MJt11n!&:6a:nITiflf, :g;hlli/\ W:mfl31f~x1J@i~ffif1f. PI l'J.~j;'Jt JII. ~llI:;tgmtt; X11£~ ffif~, PI l'J.~ ~;frJ11iJfnffl:!m r'l:ff*. ~m~~~nr: .H£.~,Mfl~F&fn.*.~~llI:.:ff~F&fn.*,~~j;'*Affl:!m~ ~fiij e
• Hfli.if F &b ~HIHf ~ffl:IM, ~ ~~;ftLtfn !~.!.lljtLt. J\1-tffi:ff, Jt 11u fflimffi'Wi • rITif~lli{E ••• MIJiJ~,~~.*)1!iJ~l'J.H~.~~~M.:nm~Jt~!&~~*. :nt!:
• .m:JWJMIJiJIBJ, 1Ju'~.*,mj~ (J.J!l!&!t. $;ff). ~~=*.t.X~~fk~*X •• ~*. 360
h~**~~- •• ~.X (l-~*~.) X •• +~~«~'X~~
11 Ji< -4"'-- 1%tt+~~ •• +~~
• ~.fllJiJxf1*.
~ "* _ iT l(! ,~, *. X (1 - Sf- #s ;< ft t- ) X f. I§ jR 4£ X 365 *
?lX.1Il!.- ;<ftM
(2) ~1~~*o »-~~~*1JiIii;fJ, ~~/\ gg~~ffJJIL~1Jijt$1i'ff~i'iJ (:J~y!l!'4Jilft, ~~.,§#ft,wm.~.~.~.~RmOO~~ •• m;~~~1i'ff~,m~~~~~ ~~~~~tt~~~~,§ffi~~~~~~~I,~.,£~,~~.*,m~~~~~ m~2l:1:.B<J1JtJtl, ~R*m~~~tE~~MMl~o ~~:it~1J.llr:
• ~1~~-g.f£~*: m:tJfi3tit~~m£ll1fjB<Jtt~ooj], mll1fj~1ftt@~jJ~m:jWjtt OO~o
• ~1~~~~-g.f£~*: ~Yra1Jt, ~Y~~~~IlKf!i, ~:9WI.~, ~1~tIL~, ~Y15~~Jij!$il!1t~ 0
r OO:JU tl:I tE'*1~px.* 1Joo ~it.1J#;; : • ~ffiipx.* 0
~]t = F. x If'-1ft~* 1lf1lt$i
• ~~~-EI~$o
~]t = ro.X (~*ra- RTY-~*1tr RTY) Xlf'-1iL~*
00 2-121I1~T7\W~~B<JJ.lftii:~1Jttt, ~fITJlJ~;fJtl:I~MB7\W~~J{!{m7\W~~J.lft .~M*M1JiIii:-~~ttm:~~~~J.lft.~f£,ttJ.lfttt~~~*m~ffi~, ~m£~~ 1&~; =!!iitt,*~~~, ~m~~, ,*1~tl:IrDtr~~J'lr~~IJ/H}J'lr~Rllir)§-~m~ px.*. l11mJ:tt.£fII;~,~,px'*o
tE~.7\W~~~Mat, fftElfij!~MfIl~~fl.M~. ij!~fl.W~Jtl1tffl~H5, 1J.njg ifJ&*, 1:.~J&*, ~-§,.JfL 'lfJJ!ftJtl, A.J&*~~Y. mT~.:ttl1o~Jt~1&A~
;bn~; Jfij$X~M1±1±J1EIV,~ftPJ~"B9m~, jlll_ryj_Inm~ll:tu)@(~t.lti:ll~:ltim. ~~-fW; ~,~~~*:tu~~~a*.~~~~~~*~c
3. £*-J!:tj}-i-lM
ffiTR~~lV,a~*m, ~~M~W~~~~ffi~~~~mc~ffl~~~m~M*~ .~~~~.,~~T~*~m~-~~M~ •• ~".m" (P~,~**~~OO~~ XH~-JE~~.:;!! "ftm" (FV) c
(1) ~m-!=iJ.{~L 7'\@:mJ1!ffW~k'J.J1l~1E~f~bt~:M, ~1$F__t7\@:mJ1!Igf § ii!.~ "1i~". ~'H'&ii!.;ff "00m.", ep "~m-!=iJ.m~&~" 0
FV=PVX (1 +i)n
~4', i ~~J$; n ~;ff~ <it,@J WL
(2) i$.m (NPV) c W1ft7'\@:mlijIgf § i39Ji1t*:tut&:MHt, JiX;*fIlt&Mii1lt~k'J..~ ~i39n~~~~.W~~-rT~$lli.o-~.~~~~~~~.~*.~~~~~~ ~$~~~oi$.m(NPV)~m~1i~~§~~~M~~~~M~i39i$.~~.m-~ ~~.$~W~.~~M~~#.mZ~,~*~A~:
n
NPV = b (CI, - m,)(l + io)--t
[=0
~4', CI, ~~ t 1f.i39~:M (.~miA); COt ~~ t 1f.~i't mx:tfj~*~ (.~~tfj); (CIt -CO,) ~~ t 1p~Jit.~miJb io ~~§ ~t&:tt$o ~*Jit.m*T~,7\@:mJ1!~§~~m__t:;!!~fi~o*.m.*.7\@.J1!~§i39 OOffl •• * c i$.m/J\T~, !J!ui$:1Yf § i39t:£mt£~M, ~1lJD c
(3) ~$~~$ (1RR) 0 pg$t&~$~~~11rffi ~Htriij~mi39M*)tmiif~:1f~. ~~ •• :1f.i39.~ •• #.llii39n**~~*.m.~$,~.~.~**.~~A •• m~T**.~rmlli •• m~D!~.$, ~*i~~~*.n*i$.m~~i39jUj.$o ;!t#. :1f~ii1ltfi~~m"mm~":~~~#-~M.$,m~*#.:1f.i39$.m.~*$ .m~ iEf{, i~J!ij:1f.*~ ~fflNII$~i1:~it~D!~.*. ~t.%iWi m.s.$£*-tI7iWJtit; JLQ **.m~m •• ~J!ij:1f.*~~m.~$~T~#~jUj.*,~_~M.$£*-tI7iWJ tit, 1i:~~t\tllitt*.mtJ:ili:~~D!~.$. ep~:1f.*~~~$t&:tt$o
(4) *~t&:tt$~OOm$ (ROIL
ROr=:: ~~+:: XIOO%
"~lil f)...JlItJt*-1l:t-:lIP.t.2~2 ,JlJf'
, .lIilJ15.JJfli1li1~I~~*J~~~,1lt."'(IC)~.}
4. ,t-t- A~fp;f: tt,t-t- A*-
(1) Iffi::l:AIt*lI~B9mJtL Iffi::ltAlt*B9;fl!{~~ 20 1it~ 50 ~ttEl3~OOIffi:it~W~~* ~,~*~m~A§~~lliB9o~~~~:~T~*~*~~~B9~.m£~B9~m~& m~~~ •• B9~.~mAltB9~~.~~~~~~~AIt*B9-~mAlt=*.
ffl-~B9 ~.AIt* EI3 LV: r 1m =?tfJJ Jt :
l).~AIt* .• ~T.~$.~~#B9~m,-.~m: ~ •• ~.m.~fi~. ~m.~~~~.m.~~&ITww~~~.m,~*~~~~w.m.~m~w~. ffl, !&i)rl.m~&~ffh.~.m 0
2).~Jt*.m~W~Iffi:.~*~~ •• £mmfi~ •. ~.~~~~~#B9.ffl, -H~m:~.~~ •• m.ITit.*.m,~.w •• m~&~~ •• ~~~~~ffh. ~Jtmo
3)~= •• (~~)AIt*om~~~~#~,~ft.Rm.~*~mAlt~~~,- 1N:~m: flt!!t~~, .ugI.ugfti~~. ~fJt~~. WI~~, lllt •• t&~w.m. ~~iEmJ1ll! .m~&~ffhJ*J ••• Jtm .
4)*.t&.(~~)Jt*om~~~~#~,~ •• £m •• *mmJtB9~~,.~m:~~w~.*&* •• m .• ~~w~w.m.~~.ff.m~*.t& •• fflo
~~B9m.AIt*~t&.Jt*~WB9~.m~~.,WH •• T~~~WB9"~ •• *": -~IfF;fJJ~Wm. (t~~u~~~~~~WB9IfF;fJJ:l1:fim.) $.~~; =~~1f 1:.f=1Hr1§ f=~m:iififfHi$B9~9(, J!ftif££~$* § :ii*B9!6'fll*i~~~~Ptlm~~fi&7 ~~;=~EI3~~am.m~.B9mW~~,~m~m.~mlV:&f=.~RW~.B9.~ mt9(~9(~.
J!~~A1nx1"$.pX;*B9:l1:f££#iit. ~~~iA~{Ef~~ 100%*~*~B9~~f.f~~ -~"m~B9m.Jt*". §ftm#~~~OOB9" •• AIt*"?t~~A~ •. * ••• AIt *5. mVJ.1'lli~~OO 2-13 ~jf-B9m!ftm •• *li~!L
mm~.fim.AIt*WWB9mAA.~mR~*~.~~~~AIt**~f££J*J*=$.Jt *, ~.m.*~;fJJ~SwwJt.mB9.*,mm_.h~.:ii*~.~pX;*~.f££.~ AIt*~ •• pX;*.~~~.~.~ftfi**B9~tt,M*~~~~~MmW.m.*~. ~. ~[rJt::l:pt*~1~, [!P~l~ "&.~~.I¥J" 0
o
III 2-13 l.lI!ft~.Al*IUW
Wf.M*~: *~, «*~Jlt.fJljf» (m:5/t1i), ;j~$, q:.OOA.~*~tl:IJt&U, 2003.
(2) ~iltt~*, ~~~iI'I1:$;*Ej~&.&l:It$;*o .&l:1t$;*flHt;tttt.&l:XitJ5t~~iI tt$;* (cost of conformity) :frI~F1\t*tt$;* (cost of nonconformity) 0 1\tilfinlt*J!m tEJJ.[1T:i:iNX~_m';£ rjC~Nf;ffJiiJ!$~*JiJf5[ Nt¥.JJt m; ~F1\tiltt$;*~ Eb TJJ.[1T:i:iW t¥.J •• oo.$;t¥.Jm~o~*tt~*~m.A~*:frI.~$;*(.~* •• A.5t);$~ iltt~*~1JIi.~nIt* (~~~~~I.El.*) :frIirt~~* (rJ;J.+)'H~lno
/\ gg~ f1! 'lfJll!¥ * ,*1l£f:£ ',§' J'I't ~$;*. ttN::¥~1l£~~1\til'l1:nIt* :frI1\til'Ii:$;*. ~F * *ft$;*A~*mt¥.J,001\t*tt~*Eb*m:frl~*m.~.*m~o~.:i:i~.t¥.J~m. ;ftte~itmt¥.JW*;lJD~I&j£, ~Pi~RMillft¥.J~jf{Ir, JAOO~1J!;~*. TJ!A1fJX~1JtT ~ &l9tJt$;*t¥.J:fjl~ (~~ 2-3), J!p
~a~.A*=~~~*~~~A*O/~~~~~~+~~~.A*O/~~~~*
;ft 2-3
1ttittt31ltnJt* l!Ill!.IJnJt* (~:ltfiB<J$1t)
~lit)_ijt:lt ~~nJt*(l!Il~~®l!Ill!.IJ~~:ltfi$1t)
nJt* ~F1ttitttlwJi~* !Nt ~nJt* (1tm'iliJ!f1J.ii; 15I )
iIi.~* (~$;fa?'~$m~) ~-.~BJ~~mT/\gg~f1!'1fJll!,N::mrnT~.~&OO~~~~*m~.~~m J!rnTftmN~.-~.re ••• m,.MOO.*Ntet¥.J.*. rnTm.~&OO.~t¥.J~ *.~~*.A!.~t¥.J~~$*.*tt~~~AmNf~o
ftfrJBf£itff:::i::tt!*Ft¥.JfiiJm: /\gg~~mm.~1T~? fiiJmt¥.J&:OOJ!: 1NJE~~1T/\gg ~l!?i, ft1fr:!mfilI? ~fH~~~, /FfFl&ll!:t¥.JnIt*R:tmfilI? xtmAAOO~. ~*~tIt~if:lHE$J ~~~.ffim~mm*~~~*~~~~*EjI&il!:~tIt~.*,~~.te~~~*JEo~ ~, ~~A~*ttd*,~~.R.~~M~ ••• ail!:~~~oaIDm.~~~.m. $ (efficiency) :fQ;ff.tt (effectiveness) t¥.Ji.&il!: 0
~ &m.nIt*~~~:#f:ff 1lfJTafnljkitf~~ ~~/\ gg~f1!:rm §, ~ ~tEnIt*ll~jjOO ~~;ffmjJN::ftfnJZt;~~ § ~1D:~~m.:rmz-o 1£~ §fJJWJm:1T~&l3t.~*~U':, liT ~fF~~§R_~.M,&:ff~~M~~§i.&ll!:t¥.Jjj~, ~~~~§SM~Wm~§M*
;'&ft~JE]\:;lilll 0 ~u*:rm § m lRf~U~mlE~:rm § S9~ mJ9t:l:~*ilt$j*/)\iItIH'FflF91j rn. ~J§ 1IJIJ Jl&31HI9 t't5tJIWlFf , tJ~¥f~t-Jt:ff~89, ~1!,{~1tJt1fi*89 I~ 0
(3) ~fjt@::I:~:;tq'4§£:J~fflV3~o
1) tJJI[ljj~* (~~Jtm:if~Jt) 0 1'1m[ljj~~2t~ji}fxit89Jt m. ;!tq:.-$JtE8 T ~Jt m.d#~*~Bm,~#A~I@::I:~* .• m~M[ljj~*M§:ff:
@: •• ~Wfflo:ff~.ndA&mT.~ji}f.~~89~mxili.m~.~@:.~.89 A~.~ji}f.~~~; •• ~£~#~.~M@:.89~* •• ~mTMfl.IFf~F£@: .~~89~~.WFf.m~~~ji}f.89~~.@: •• ~Wm~~mM.;!t~@: •• ~I~ ji}f.~r8J89~fflxttl. ~IlPJ#ft1i1f1E. iJt~~@:.Jttff, 1'1.1IJIJiJt~. t1l)j£!;fJlIff:fitrJ~ m~~~ji}f.~IBJ c
ttW~~wmo§m1'1@:.~~;fJl~*~:ffttW~h89~1E;fJlJttff~~MW(~m mm.89~~Iff)ji}f.~.~OO~~mxili;1'1:ff.~.d~ffm •• ~®~*OOI ~Am.mtt*m~ji}f.~~fflxili;~~~.~ttftq:.e~~.*ff~~ji}f3tili89 wm 0
.~~~Jtm.1'1T*M.~89.*ji}f*~89~~~~1i1fn;fJlJt~ji}f~.89.m. Im.mi)fll11k.~I~~h89JVfJ. fflT~*;fJl.~m.*3JLji}f~~89;f§*.m (~ ~mm~ M I~!lJt~ll~t~WJ.l89i)ll~W) 0
~£~it~JE/~~frrMW'ifiWffl. 1'1T ~Jl~it89m •• PJ3.ft;fJl~~'lf£miWiftiJt ~~£.'ifim~£.m~ji}fxm89Wffl.~*,~~M~~frrtJJIW'ifi.o m.~B~.891i1fn;fJl~BWffl.fflT~~@:.~B~.89~#;fJl~rn.m, ~1k.
WJJtffl c
~m.wfflwm 0 1'1~nf[~ffiLf.it~B®Jt~~:i!ffi'ift89mi}ljWffl.
;ltft!!M[ljjJtm. ~mm.1k~#t'fj_[~m~~ffi!&~rnJtm, ~'&~~Iiflitj;~. r 1% ~*!ttp~M[ljjttmnf[.ffl.
2) ~}E~* (~~~m.Jt) 0 1'1i'$ Im.~NfII~HE~*mJ :i!ff89iJt~. t1tg£!;fJl~1fji}f xit89 Wffl, ;!tq:.itI~*89.Jt~~Ul, ffiLitA~(i!m.~* (~jtrJttt~ll.JE89~1k. ~~~~**~~M~~~~.iJt~~*,PJ~~~m89~JE~*)o.m~~JE~*u §:ff :
)rH!!Jfj~Ht9iJt~;fJl~~Jtm. §m~~. iJt~.ULi'¥fft7H~ijfjfl@:.89.ffl, ~'&fl ~liJJl!.Am1k11,0'¥:Am PJ~ffl!lJ89ifMWffl, :ffi§M~~Am!lJ~~ rWiftji}fIjf!J;f:J$j.~ xilil¥J~*W 0
it. nlH} wm 0 itiitK31¥J~1l;fJl!tf!i~Wffl 0 ~®~o~~AmWiftr~~£tt*tt~~xili89~ffl, ~~~WAM;fJl~0'¥:Am llJ~xili 89fl~~m 0
~~Jt.iJt~AmfflTWiftr~~£tt*tt~~xili89Jtm. 11~.WAm;fJl~0* Am PJ~x ili 89:ff~W m 0 ~~I~Wo§m~rI~M~~OO~Wmxili--~~Amm~Imii#~89~*mi ~~eB89I~Im.;~~~ttfi~m~*e~~£;fJlIFf~~~M;m~~£.~£; :i!tT1JOIttW q:. 89F£ mt.Wffl~ 0
~~~~~~.~~§~Q~*A~~T*fitt~~~ffi~~fl*~*~~~~~~ Jfl~HL
iit~, t!l~t~*E1VJ\m!mt.l:ii4H.tJij 0 il\~, ~~lifkl¥J79JjJt~f€. :{m~fI;, rm t;1lit tEi!!:fiMttr-ttiit®' (~~~ilriit~!!X;tJflijJ*ft) 1J;f7~f€l¥JtU4lUfm lib; ytl ~~~ I.m~~ tr-l¥J/J\ m!mt"N:~Jitm Q
~ •• ~~Jijotr-lib,tlWlU~*.~Jit,~ffi~.lU~~nW.Q
7Hi1Hfi1*Jtm Q ~m7HW~~~I¥JItli£, 1*mU&~fit~ 0 P~~~N~~~o~T~p~(§m~$)~.W~W*h~*~~~~I¥JJitm. tr-~mr~~JitmQtE~~~~~~~~.~~~lU~~~~~xml¥J.mo ~~iit~.o~~~~m~I¥J~~~®tr-~IJ;f~~~l¥Jm*.~mfl*£~fitQ ;tt:1m~~.Jfl 0
3)~.~.(.~)~*Q ~~tr-~dn*tE~Mft~~~~ •• _*~~~I¥J. *.~mrrA~~ •• ~*o~ml¥J~.~.~*#§fl: *~~*Jito~tr-~~,*~lib,tE~lib~~~ ••• *Hx~~~!!X;tE~~L~m m~ •• ~*~~.~I¥J~m. t;1lit*.~.~, •• ~~aUftt£*.,~~,~., 1m~~:ttW r:p ~YJ:i!:riiJm~m~ l¥J_m (~~mm ~:lt1ma~mf~*I¥JUft) 0 ~I!!X;~~~*_o~~~~~~~~~~~ ••• *!!x;~M~Jij.*~xMl¥J.m
(~m:mjf:fiAJE1Tmrl¥J~?X~~Jitm) 0
~~.~~.m~~mt.~~~~~l¥J •• ~~W~~!!x;li~~.*l¥JJitm. ~=[.~Jit 0 I:§mt.l:l'iiJm~~wI~.*l¥J~Jij.
~£ ••• ~~ftJito~~ft~.~~ ••• ~~~Ml¥JJitm,~ •• M.!!x; ••• ~~x1tI¥J~Jij c
~.,* •• l¥J~~m ••. ~~~.~*.:ttfir:p~.l¥JWft~tr-£mt.~m~~ mI¥JJitm.§m~tt~m~~~l¥J~*.m.
;tt:~~.~ •• mo~mI~lUtlw ••• ~,ttfi~~$.*,~~~~~nOOl¥J .mo
4)*$~.(.*)~*o m~~£!!X;.*t£~M~*~~mt.~*~ •• l¥J.*, ~mit A~ 6!.mt:S:.&'Z*. 'fit JA!.l¥J7HWt&.~*# § fl:
P~:fiilf~ftJt. :(£1*!)H1JJEMOO~, x>tJ@(~:fiYfl¥J~~1i1F~~ ~W!!X;£~~~~ili l¥J~ffl.!!X;~~.~~~~m~~~~~:fiilfl¥J~~~W~xilil¥J~mo tr-£!f~B!H§-lit1*~.o lI1lm~-&iE~£~~~il\., 1*~tr-~i?X;.f4t;1litfflTt~ ~~~:fiilfMml¥J~.~I\Ic~. ~~ili IW-iJJ.m (~~m3iltij[H}J!:&.~ 1nJ~~l¥J!t~. m). tr-£~ff~Qm~~mt"~.W~_l¥J~*M~~*~m(*~~~~~iIf*,~~ ~).
jt~7~.iIJl*~o §mEE*~~IIl§l¥JBIl*lit1tltg_;g, ~~, Wf¥~*, m~~~t.fij .Wi11 ®l¥J~~m~~*, ~~mt*.9c. t;1:&.~~W. ~3&I¥J#liEmff&~~Jij. *~~~~§~~~.~*a~,IT.~~~.
;t t..flft~i!tt1H~ 1e: ~'*txt;4f# ?';4£ Jl fJi!titit;fJ_<F~ ~# 7t l¥- (bill of rna-
C~)!~~:::~~l'iif~;:;Dl~~it~r::T~"~~::
*"#3""it#-, y).~1JtJ1f-l"-I'~*"~$i..Jt:fIl~i9~*, JL.#.. 2-4 ~*- 2-'-5~
_- . , - - - -, .' _,' " _" _" .' '_',", ... ;-. '. _',', _". ','."". ','_ -',' . '.-''"'_'', _',"'. - -,"', ""-. -"0:"'" , .. ' _. ... , .. , .~. ':._ - ':' ': __ '-> .
.• 2· •. · .• 4\·~li.~ .•• jt.!i~~ •• i ; ....•
~lQ~tll~*A91,4iA~&F~1m 8/j\II>tMJi!ilII. ····; •• ".ff:;30.63Jfu1~Rf)< 10 A x 8 A' ftf j A =
' ..•...•. i ...... ~\~§9J,j.. .....•. . '. . . .
~'JJ~jij.j~~i~."6. '11*1 tmiJ 1!1' 20% , Af!f$3F:It41lt 3000 5GJjftW*i'$it • .Ilt;;f;:.1'1:
..•• 3~~?<6X~% ~3.~09~
.+~~·~~$~,giflj"i$(RfI'aJ~1'1 0.5 /1\~, r: *~~lt)(}S~*fF~i§,i ia:h1t* 1iJ: 30.63%!.rJ~afx 105 ~xo.5!j-.M !~=1 6085t
:«.,J\fa
.. ', ~~~ofJ.!.~~. -flt;fi.a*-. ~i}) ~h..iji~;l] 'f'':;, l!>jut:l. a!J ~*M- *-. *-*.fri'H llt;fi.~J.!.~~,~~~*~~*~~*~*-~~+~~~*~~~~J.!.~*a!J~~~ «; ~~llt;fi.~~~, ~1lt;fi..*A~~*~,~~.~lt.4~,lt.~~.~. ~~*~;~~l~M.~,~*~#~~~~'., ~~.~~ •• ~~*;*~#* la;fi..~~~#.t3#.*+~~*1~Sm. ~1~~~~~~aA~ •• ~*.
~§~~~m~~.~~.~D.~~~~~R*tt~.~~W~~~§~~~;~ ~ttm~m*i!!i~~Jjf § ~~f:I'lAi!!i~~lJ! § .lr.~~ifirJ~, ~i;lJtt~ I!P7\W~~Jjf § tti;lJ ifirJ~, ~D;fI1~~ttfi~m~W~l!!:gJi § OOM.mft. ~W~~&:ilt DMAIC BX;~W~l!!i9: itEt9Af*~:&&lP.IKi~, ~~tt@mtl~mAW~.Jij:gJi §;~~, nlt'l!=W$" .!oJ)t$.
Ai!!im~~~Wttflmm,fltt~~~~Awm~~§~~$~~~~~, ~~mW ttAW**lij~ § Et9~~*dJ?::iltAffJx!:iL~~D;~rjJAEt9~~. Agg**~~ § I fIO~~W Jllt* ttfi~~~~Z •. ~~,AWM~~§Et9~~~~~~~.~~~~.~*~~~~. &~.m~Afl~a~~Et9AWM~~~~~m~~~~m~~~nOO,mfl~T)tm~ ~;i:5C
3. 1. 1 1\~m~I!b:§~~lJRmu
1. *~~~S9i r=l ~ X.5l
~WM~:gJi §mffiIlR~f9HiflIfigmM.Wtt.ii!ffl~WM~1i~ (DMAIC ~ DFSS); :fE~
~ at fa] P'l, ~1't:llifi1i~jf~$BJf~ €:I fffi ~ 'l'¥~ttfi. 2. *~~~S9i r=l ifJ~#--~!i!IJ
-!VfEiJl., ~ W ~~:gJi § Et9 :®1f:ilM. ~ r 1*9!tl :
(1) fl!': 5(, fl fk m: (meaningful L ~ W ** J.q:gJi €:I fig!': s. ~ fk m: {:.$. $ ~ w. r JL l'
niM:
.AWMJ.q~§.~*.~.!':~~ •. W..3~~~~AWMJ.qfkm.Z-.AW **J.q;fr~1'~*M: -~f" ~liJtn[[9riJ:.~.Af,l[~,~,iIlt; =-~~:J;'~~ 1i~1W mir~ ~~ II§. f5I ~, J!Jimtk:~ fii] ;®!&HiJt* ~ M .$~*. .3 & tIt~ffL@, Et9)t:ffT, 1't ttl .31fiE~ ,L.'~I'iiJm, tEIlt¥mIl_tJiffIJE*.}j(A:~tl:o
.~WM~~§.~~~~~~§~fig~~.AWM.Jij~~~~~~$~~§~Et9fl ~¥~,~-1'AWM~~§m~~~~~~~fig~~o~~~~,~u~WM~:gJi§~ ~~Mi9:~~**~~§~Et9m~,~*~~~~§~~~o .~W.J.q:gJi§§~~fl.~tto-.*~;AWM~~§.~~~MB.~~, R
~ ~¥-t-, 7i·~~~Jmtt~~~tr:J ~~'I1:&ll! 0 ·~~~~~§~~~tlm~a*o.~Ttlm&*~~~~~~~~~Z-.~~ ~~~~tlmmUmn~*~~tlW~~~~tt&*~o .A~~~~§~~~~**tt*~~~~Mo~~~~~m~mM~tr:J~~~~m ~*¥~&*E~~~,mM~~~~~~~~~M*~Mo
(2) PJ1'fm (manageable) 0 4ij1'-7\gg~~JJi § :mm~ PJ1fJ]l~, ~~:J!iJ?. ~W~
~~ § W:fr;pj~~ iB1~mrrr~ ii PJ~~IL ~W~~&*/FfJ(3Cttr:: ~ J9tfl:. ffii ii3Cttt.f1Hi 1&J .d.~mm,&* •• d~M~~m~~ .•• ~r::~h, •• ~~*~um~h .• • ~ •. ~fi~&m.~*~oX~M~~iB1~,:m~m*~~".M",~~~m .• ~*J£~W*,J "M" "tr-" B<Jf,~ttlkJtiJ!~.nr!. ?&JEf;tWiffi!iW;-flYftkJP]~B<J~~*¥o
~W~~~§B<J~mmm~PJ~o~~~§:m~~-~~~~.~B<JiB1~.~~iB1~ B<J~mm~~~~,#ii~~.-~*~~§mft4~6~~~%~offi~~$~~r. -~iB1M~.~~~H$~nOO. ~~: •• r::~B<J~MM~PJ~~~HM.MWB<JJ9t •. m~~H~ti~*~~m,r::~~~~m.~~m.~-*~iB1mo~M,PJ*m~ JL~/J\~ s. tEt§x1IJ\i¥JPJr;!m;OOJ*JM~. lfT''lrJlIL
/\W~~JJi §mr1~¥IJ'lrJ1l!~i¥Jx*~mtto ~ §&'@H~¥IJ1fm~B9x*~mtt. ;tW ~m~~i¥J~~(A.M.~~)x*o
3. 1. 2 1\~~~IjjjJ3~~mt~
~~~~~~JJi§i¥J~m,m.~~u*~~~*~~~JJi§B<JM~o-R*m,~ §~~$~~U@~~~,~~§M:
$~-:~~~§i¥J*n~--~§B<JY;
;$-~=: ~Y*ffR~lfTy. :tnl: Yl' yzo "', Yn' *~JE*~§#xtil1l~~nOO:ilHT
&*;
;$-~=": #xtmJEB<J$~&*~ Y. ~~J®:(~3CttB<J3CilJ9t.*ftt (critical to quali-
ty. CTQ);
%~@:*~CTQ~JE~§~M--~~JJi§~~o ~W.~~§B<J~~.W~m3-1~~o
1. ZJtI ~ ~ 1§1 ftlJ k:;5- {,;J Y
1iJD}E~ § a9::k1f fIij. :wtimiJ1lt£ ::kifiJ ~ ~ ¥IJ m IIA Nt rPJ i¥J:.tr ~ 0 _R 1f 1f T iE ~ B<J ~ § 1f rPJ, ~ ill ;tfrnt£iE 1iJD B<J 11 rP:J .L fittiE lifD a9 .-~ ~ J]:f § 0 !~ 1... 110 fiiJ ~ }E JJ! § 1'B::k 11 (0] II£? -MVIEiJ&, PJWfAw-r JL1-1100*1T~m:
(1) ,*M~~~5&iif1fp:p jtJmB<J~.tj£m~. iiJU}E~ § B<J)j fIij ;
(2) ,*ji0R]~$f1 B<J1jl-1iftt*f~l'Bm;ftj~5l~1iJD}E~ § 1¥Jl&l£11f1ij; (3) iM:i1~iJ- x1lt;fljlJ( + x1 H:. :tt¥lJff{Eff9~ tB ~~;
( 4) ~1H8 X1 ~ 9~$1@l ~ ff9 pr if ( I@l ~ ~ N :J.C it I'B *itrrw*;fIj :jUlFl ) ff9 % f1r , fifO}E .i: ~
I'B l&:i1t 11 fIij o
fA~;fIjUff9~~. fAW-rJ\1-~,~~A:Ag!f~~Ji1i§, ~1'B~::k:
• Mt~~;OOi I¥.J *tI t,1: ;
• §~nHfl'Brp]~,~;
• I@l ~ * it~t!!VfI¥.J ~ t,1: ;
• YfttiUli¥J# 1It g;
• $nlB]ff9T~,~;
• *WH§tJt{tjf_iJ9~1t~;
• M*5&:MiJ9:t1*,~;
• 5j~iJ-x;f-¥lttltl'B~~,~o rOO.~~iJ&~-~+~tt*ft£Ag!f~~~~~i¥JMmo +i1itM~ff9D!l1-!tN~iJ943f-1-~J:lm~mPJJV.%§JrJfF:7g~ §~:f.¥ag::k11(ti]. l3:¥t1*
~TAg!f~~~§~mmI¥J~AA§~R**ag~~~-~Q~~~~I¥J~'fr~}E~§~~m tj~~mD!l1-~OCa9+1if, ~-flimfffiB<JMIij"M3~~Jj9~-#mtjtc1:./F ~o
1!1 3-2 ~~{tjf_B<J+ifjt%fmfffio
• J!t.f¥7J<.3f
• .$1tr$;* .It.f'$;*
.1~.li:Ir
• T> 1ltJ9t:l:$;* (COPQ)
)@i~
• )@i~t,tl[:fO CiQ
• ftEaty:ft
• .f'~J9t:l: (:ct:.flI!:~n:e KPOV)
• ~:i!i
.\IiIc~
• DPMQ. SIGMA 7J<.3f
• RTY ORi:i!iif.m$)
• :ct:.flI!:}iij.AA
• *lllillHtA (KPIV)
~.33~$;*
• /, g![.m f.!31JU;, I J!.1iiLJf:I
• ~~fiii)rl .7\jJIj.m~~W,JW.*iffjf
.m!';:!,ffl;iJitJ5
• 1$1111/, g![.m~J]J[ § l1l.IAlt
~3-2 ¥~~~~~#~*m~ +iftt%f~a9D!l1-*J:l~tlt$a9~Nm~MfF::1g~§z~B<J::k1fflij, ~*~{t~a9 +1if~~Q
~§a9*Y-.*.:1g0R].l¥.Jm~,~{t~a9.~.~N~.~tc5&.~~. :1gT *-$M.~ •. @~.~*Ya91fOOl£1T% ••
2. 4+ y ilii-r5J-Wf~~~T~~~*n~YE'~TY~~~~~~&~~~~~~nW~)~W-~, -fi.~*mY~.*fi~*.~~,~~%fi.~Y~~.nW,Wli~~%M.~ ~~&*~~~nOOY .•• ~~~.~N~~~,-fiY~ •• n.~~.~m~~~ ~* (BB) ~ §; ~mHl rJg~-JEm~mmJrJgmD.)M~~, :f±1±mffojgi'$* (GB) :rm €:I; mTmoo~~ .• ~~~~~W~ •• mffIA*%fiM~~:rm~ (m*~#IA~~~ #IA~l'!Pfm?tfi.~~fJi]~D. mJ£~~-fi~ €:I, W:i1 QCC ~m1:IMa*/J\g1i~n:rt~ •. ~m~.~ •• &~~-~~~W-~~~.~~~~~Mt*. ~~~.£~~~M ~.~-~Y,®m~.~~~~$~m:IM •. m.$.tt*$.~m.~*~, ~.~ .~fffl~~-1-~J{Rf:f~~ rn IR.
3. aJI #)Q ~ B. T Y ~ ::1t4t#.f1. ~~~T:rm§yUFn,~~~~fmH.~~~y~a~:rm§o~~ijuWB~~:i1,* g:H~~!'J<J1ftm~z-~UI®!~jgr:pJL', ~IltW~*X>t Y -2i:1lJT1OC1@!~B9JL'f5, iftilw#rMI@! ~x1 Y J¥.JW~. JAffij~~I@!~:I:*JL'!'J<J*ftElHi~tt CTQo X1Tjg.~~JilIWJM*~~ .,g~*~~crQ§m.~JAre.~jg.B9~~~MM~~~.~~.~~M*jg~ J'l9a>tISJ. ~N:fii].M~*. X>t!Wi~tD!~J'I9M1t~.
4. it:it:'fP~ ~JJi J§J j*:H!
Wjj_tOO.::::.~zv!JI, Bf£I!JHiI'!lTJ_m§J'I9a~g Y ~tEam:,~Y _t1®!$:&l*JL,:~tii*tE B9~~~~ft.~M~zv,.~tty~.~B9crQ«B#.~~~:rm§ ••• tE~@~ §i*.a>tW1it~~tt~Trii].:
(1) tltBJlif § 0 ftrl*~1Lt$ CTQ •• a*. rm_§_a*~$:fill&, !l!~m.t~H1i§'QJ'I9~ IIt&l1:Hl.~~a*:rm § ~gll§'Q**J'I9~3ii, ~~tltJl6a:itl:B9m~o PJ*m~I'L~1£tIt)tfi&.m fit (Pareto priority index. PPD *tTtltJlGfi&.flFff: X>t*gg:m~:rm § m-*S9!&:ft~lH0B9 .m.~~~~.ft,~§~.S9d*~~§~.S9~~.nm*tT~~~.,mff.~ ~ PPI S9n7!*f!tBJ_ijf 13 0 Jlif § PPI it.0jJ::;ftQT :
9t1ti ]t#JB'JfJfJ XJjfi § ~:0MJmt.
PPI Jjfi § fIff ftA MJ ~* X Jjfi § 3t~ ~ f~ (1f)
#t~'1itl"*~ 1Itji_~" ~ filiI •...•. t!J 1ft raJ ~ 4 .fiJi a{rljppf~~*-,3~1 •
• ~l tdif&lfi1ililiIiB.i;tt~~ •• (PPl)"w~... . -, "~. .... '-=
.JJ! § 1
175
o. 70 '. 50 O. 33
18.0
7.4 ..•...... \.
'·200 .
•... o, 9O:··./:029\j_ ' 0.50 , f
· .. ···\~ .. 1'l3
185
250
0.90 70 0.58
'.
(2) ~~:tgt § 0 ~~:tgt § 1¥JjJ:r\.~~~: -:!!1f.lt~J@t~1¥J CTQ M'I;Ej;J~Wrm § , ~lJ~ll: ~tm m:i8 ~ &b!lCl!I!ll>t Imf'F 11 l&:l1!lJf §; = ~Jj jj:~ ~ 00, 1~ ili ~ n~)ij( ~ CTQ i¥J;f§ ~~~, ~;E-~~~~~Wi¥JI&~~~:l1!~§o
( 3) :l1!fi 5C ~ i¥J 1'iiJ ~,*:i£ c 1f flU AlJJI~.i&}.E SUP] ~3:H!z. -it 0 (4) ~!E~ §iW:~~f$o
(5) tl.t\£r_ij!§ §t~. ~¥1J SMART:
Specific ~{if,;.i¥J Measurable PJiro~ I¥l Attainable PJfi I¥J
Relevant ffiJei¥J (!:J1f:_illI_6JI.~-3&I¥l) Time Bound 1fBtrB]~lHIJI1I¥J
SMART m:J!U~X1A[9~~~§llt~i¥Jm:~1Jf!o ~-, ~§ §f,.j&'{w~i*, Jt:!1.u, ~~W~:fi~~~-~~i*I¥J§~,&~mili~~~~~i¥JW~,ff~&b,m:~~~~~~ &b, ~fiiJ~~i¥JW:ffJaIZ§~::ffiiJi¥J, ::ffru-Itrmlt o~=' J]Jf § § :j:,.j~,{WPJ k'J,iroUi, fru$. -itili*o ~I¥J~ § §;fjftPJfllit!:~~~:I:-it, 1fl¥JttJttltm~, :!1.uJ®i~nw~*~~~-~~k'J, :l:fui¥Jm~,m~.ff-.*m~~R~~~~%mI~re~.fuili*.J]Jf§§~~ •• fu, ~~k'J,~i*§fjft~Nit;JlX;o ~=-, J_ij! §~ilil¥Jmfjft&,@f~PJfii¥J, ~Jji1:J]Jf §mi¥J~j] PJ~~.i¥J,J]Jf§§~&~1fm~tt,X~1fPJfftt.-.~~}.E§~Bt,~~.m~~i¥J *VftWi¥J:i:tE*+k'J,lit!:JfiiJff:i:tE*+tt$3Ci¥J~*o ~trn. ~ § ag §;f~&'{w!:J1f:_illI_ag~~ffi ~*, !:J ~~I¥J.:k1JrPJfl~:14'=-3&~1lf§~$:tt4'=1f:_illI_~~ § ;fjftl¥l~mL lUi, J_ij! § § tjfta<J~. ~titilill>tr8Jll,~. :!1.u*,~, §f,j~1f:fr § t,.j. tI!.~titili:fr§ t~~.ag~i*BtfB]l1,~ 0
~J]Jf§~~jj:ft~~~~ili.-®~~~.~,~~:
(1) ~ § W:Mtk:I¥JI'iiJ~!:J1f:_illI_£~ltM~JeitJijt~1rW*~&1flf*~, IZ§Jlti*.~ililJf § ifriK, x1t;~4J1J1fJJl!m 1¥J.~t#~**. Jlt~riiJMl~;@1t:l2t~AW~~J]Jf § 0
(2) J]Jf §&lltrkJ~~~ftx1J®1~1¥J CTQ, lJf §~JiW:j§";j-::fruxij" y ag&~, ::f!.\!.JVt5&. ~~~Mltl!.~;@1t:l2tjJA[9~~~§o
(3) 15t1fftxij"yiltfi:frtff, :frf(:, 1t*~Yf'F11l&ilt~§. ~JVtIZ§¥:Jt$, J_ij!§Jt .:k,~~tt~M,J]Jf§~k'J,~Ja§~.mm~Y:frMJVt~T~~i*I¥JAW~~J]Jf§o
(4) W:1Wftk:i¥JI'iiJillm:f§ Bt2llAliItl, 1T:Z9JfftniBt£tJJt17li1tlJE', Jltf'P rBJJl1!!J:i\Zm:lI:!IP*JOC1-J :Z9J.rm::f~~N~f'F*W~~~§,~~~~~~.~jj:~,m~AI~o
(5) lJf § 1liYiimfjft~llAliItl9JtlJf § § t,.j&1fi!lE6ttt, Jlt~ riiJJl1!!iftJtWf~, X~~, ~;@ 1tZ~AW*}i$~ § 0
(6) lJf § ~J3tJt.:k, JliiliJ]Jf § mlRl'8~jn;U~t£, ~m*:l2t:1g7'\[9~~~ § 0
(7) lJf §&ilt~I'aJj(/J" BiWli&ftj(fij;_, 1f:_illI_~~~~Jm~1¥J @lfll. Jlt~IBJmtP.~mft :l2tjJA[9*~lJf § 0 Ai¥J*~.~I'8H~~.~i¥J-~,B~~i¥J~§~1f:_illI_AW.~wmJVt~I'8Je.o ~~~AA[9~~vma<J1f:_illI_ff~.~~~~~§Bt,PJ~~~.~.~,~~m-®1l>t
~.~~~~~@&~~MW •• W,~_~*BM~.W~~~~~~~~~~.~I ~, $1t-@lJtfB]ii1..1M&'~ 0
:tfnt,Iffl7\W**~JPf § :J2!;1$a9~Ji!U~tti TJPf § Fo, tt~1ijij}iU.9f § j'[JPf~fIlit:JGtl, ~~JlIi §m*fIlm~JlIi§m~. ~.JlIi§~§~fIl~#~~~*~ft~~*~.,m~m~.h ~n~,~JlIi§~~~~~~~~~o
1. * m _n:1Ji !..#ti! JlIi§j'[JPf*~tt~m~JlIi§a9X#,~X#~~7\w**~JlIi§m*(~*~~*)ft
JlIi§m~~~mm~~~~o~§j'[~*~m~r~~:
• J9i § :?:l f$ ;
• J9i § 1f~ftm~J1I! El:! ;
• ri=iJJMiIm~,*;l£;
• § tJFIl*;l£;
• Jy! § [jj ~mnX;1.tJm:1It* I; ·~§~ft~tt~fIl~~~m,~*fIl~~;
• J.9f § IfIJ ~ ;flt~n ft Jt t; o(nj ;
• ,tt1*.m_W~*~~ (llfI",@{fHf:%- ftl1>trB]l(fI~);
• i~~:J!f89mfifll~~ 0 J9i§j'[JlIi~89~~~-~~~~u~,-~mJPf§m*mmJlli§~m-~W~,*
fi,~~tti~.,m~~m.7\B**~~ •.• *~~ •• *~~m~a~.~~.A in, l1lt:liftlil, ~iiU!1ifj*iSL i1iFom.i!:&JElmJlli § ~i~~:J!fmfio
JlIi§j'[JlIi~89~#~-~~~a9~~:ft*BM~JlIi§89W~IlfI",@{,m~~§j'[~~ ~.*ff*-~89~.fIl~.; ~~.IlfI"'@{M*Fo,~.J9i§~~ •• ~~ •• ~W~1lfI" m~~,~mM~mdm~~ft§5.~~~~~~~fifll~#; ~~§~MIJt, ~~JlIi §JLJlIi~WifrJffi § §;jyj89~JlU~()G.o
2. 1Ji m it\H~.i!
~~JlIi§~~m~#~.~~#~~JlIi§.mT-~m~m •. ~~~.[jj~89m~ fIl~~89rem 0 *B*~m ~m~~ ,t1,1*l!!W~:I1tl.t*, *J~~1tI¥JJffi § it~J 0 A W**Jij ~§*~-.~:I1tl.t*~~~.~.I1>t,~~~~*.m,Ah~.,~ •. ~~ •• ~ 4J-JlIiit:lGtl 0
:;tit;'Gz,fittit~J. ~-g~~~.mJ¥J: rm §it:l(.tJ~~~fff(Sl~~~~-fc 1_§.JYf § *~~~~.~m.ttx#,ft~~§m~fIl~ •• m~.89m~; ~1Jt, ~#JlIi§~. M~\mmJPf §itj;tl~ltff:itt:fT~fio t!Z~~i5L tEf!lrJ~~ §it:tJJBt16,@f*J&~ §fJF~~~1¥J m~, rmglitj;tl16'®i~§fi-~~~ilo
m ~OJ h WJtt:lt'! ~ ~!W.:cm § § tiJ> WJllt~H!;j'dIL tE 1&j J_£J»t § i-tj.lj I¥Hj: W. 9=t 1&1It ~ a-:J ~ m ~~~~#~*~~-~.~. §~,~~~m~rn~~%~**~I~ •• ~~B~~ a.* •••. m~A.m~-~~~$~~§,~§~~~~~I~ttttM~rn~m. A~m~.~#~§~~~~~~~-.~~~~OO~~B:-~#~~.w~.~m; =~~fttt~~rn~d~~~~~~~ft~WQ~ ~~,.~~M*~#~~n~w~. ~~nf[, I!P~~nf[T iE.:7Cl!:it~~f:jlJAA~~ § 1=Hif>. ~~, rn~d_m#~J.m B iLltH8i1itJ5Ett 5£l~jtjg:m:~o
tEilitJ5ErJI § it~tlat, rnM.dff!·Q} ~#Jffl ~ r &W%d:
0) if%-7tff¥t (work breakdown structure, WBS). &t~:m-jg:itd.rm § § fif>ffff~~:JGd. ~ DMAIC ~Alffi.m~i9:it~M-~ttI~7tmjgPJtltlf. PJIm~I¥JI ~.5G ({f%-. tlii9J~ *ttM"~), ]gur-&11Jj{iffJ. !R7t* Ift~5G, :i3iPJ~iliIJJEI~if%-5t1fif* (1Ji!.* 3--2).
*3-2
WBS~-% fHHs~ IfF:rJ3~ ~A ~1:Jj fif>/i ~ffA (2) ft.{f%-atfBJ.#'1!flJ~{f%-zrBJ ~**. JYi1!flJ T *-1' I ~i(i5GzJ§, M~ftitm~ • 5GJi)Trm ~ at fBJ J1l!t ~Z fBJ ~)'eJ§ *"*' aJ:l1!flJ;f§:*:~ if A. a>j" 18) fill. ~ 1J1!1~ $, ~£ 9- 1Hl11t~~-#: =: ,r2,l!.
E= (O+4M+ P) /6
~9=t, E jgB>tl8]ft.~*; 0 ]g*XW,1titB>tfBJ; M j;JiElItftita>j"18) ; p jg~%I'.1i!;itatrBJ. ~ I ~.5GZfBJ!R"* ~1!flJJE'±'~~~ .~{f%- ZI8) ~nJ~, ftQPB~JjJfI~,rjiz~tEl!!I~JjJfI ~Jt:;d.J§.:tn7fMt~ •
(3) #iililJJjJf§IfFit~tl. 19T~Alffim~J.m§~.~nt1i:, rn~tEJf.5EJ.m§8t, $t,rjiz~ tt.;f:JjJf § it~tll¥JtlfflilitJ;f!lililJ5E 0 *JffiAjl]m~~url¥Jli ~M-fl, PI ~ffI,rjiz:iIPJijij~it~tlJy! § Jt:; ~8;fI8]. trJ5E "J]1 §~~IJIfF*" Uii!.* 3-3). r&J§f't(P.~~M-fl{f9}7tm (WES) l~lli ~IfFff9}, ~iU'lt=t~¥OO (Gantt chart) ~1J1!1E~:lttl1JQ~~1t, {fTrn~tlii9J. iliIJ5Eit ~8;f,,rjizftm~d._m~~#~. ~m~~~#~*~*d~I¥J& •• ~~~mT*urm~ I¥J rJJJ ,c., j] •
*3-3
:til!S~f* I Jffi§m* I
m7#Jm~~ ~1H!1 (?A~m. §fjJ'1G~8m ~I!;FJE~8m
D WJ:EIlfrN
M i1.i!~..I: IIfr m:
A )t tffllfr ~
li&ilI:llfrf3t
C f<i JliiJ 1m- N ~.$IA~tt*U~~~M~§m~.~~§~~ •. m~~*~ •• ,~~§# ~~~.Mfi~ •• ~§~*.o~OO~m.#ffl~~~:~~OO~~~#~tt*(~. 1ltwrf$~jijJ!!OO, ifti1km!!J(;*~~» 0
1. %#00
~~m.~T •• ~~~ ••. ~§ff*Z~~~*o~~m~ •• ~~~.~ (~,.,~~),~.~ •• ~d~m~o.m~~T*~m~~~~*~~~~*.~ fBJ 0 • 3-4 ~~{f:2lf7'\j!!j.tf~:rm § 9f-/.EIifl'~~~~I~L
1ifOJE J@[ ~ ~* ~ * • [lid!: ~fi (CTO>
~4.mJ
5 Ji 28-31 EI
*3--4
~~OO~~*fi-~~.~~*§,~:*~~fi_.#~~~,~§*.m~,ff 9}fJl.~A~o
~~m~~20me~M~M~*OO~.~~~~~IA,A~m., •• ,m~. ~&,~OO~.~tt~,~~m~fiZ~.~-#.~#~~~~om~Mm.~~§# ~",~~m.ff9}Z~~ffi~~*.~.~ff*~~~ff**~Z.~m~d,.~ff *~~fpJ"*fi 0 f~~~t¥OOli<J±.~£Z-~.::F.~OO~mlJ1fffllFW;it!U[~~*J.mfI:*Z ~ffi~~ •. ~~*#.~~~.~*~~*. ~~~"~~~~fi~g.~m.~*. ~~, ~.-~ff*.m~,~~.~ff*~~~~.~.~.~~ •• ~W*o~M, ::k~f{~ t~ tg:{lUXf4-E1 (~Q Microsoft Project) .$j£~JiM[;\Zm Ji.~:*.~1f* fB] ffi
li*~;k*~itMm 0
2. l#)~it~Ht.:R
~Mm~T~~OO*H~~~Z*,m~~~.~w~.~m~~.@,.::Fa~~M "1B]~t:mm~~.~;fIJmitHrttit~~~, i~lm: (1) ~~~l:IHJ1W~~it~tl; (2) tEit :M~~::f{llT,aJ[.~-"5 }is'.5If; (3) *A~M!!Ilfl-~J§'~if~1titl:jit~tl':!t£~~~J1I!; (4) ;;ffttM~1~~~;!ft:rmfF2lf:18$xq-~1'~~Ji5u[fiJli<JiE1iJrJf1i,~.; (5) i.2:itnem-;ffi*l!p~~~ ~it::l4~~~; (6) ~DJ*~ltJTJJ!!t~~"j:,~ 0
~~~* .•• ~~~§,~ •• ¥*mIW~~IA,~M~§~~~, sw~m
ltl*h:kjilEl~J~~agtf.1'iffiJI f'F. 1N1it~3it1f -l*~as, £1lfas!liUi!lIBt~J as:1Jrtltlit:J(;IJ as 7&:it:1J A; 0
20 tltgc 50 &t:ftl~HfE, ff!~.A:mtE:t~t~fto~ftjlJ5E-#jfi¥Jit~J:1J?t. 1956~, ~OO;f± M0m(~~~ili)tE.5E~R~~~~~§.nas~ •• ~".~m~.:1J?t.5Eili ~-~~.tt:J(;rj. :l!#it:ttl1iIlJJT~~7&7.fi*JlIfFlkJtFJr~~asa1fBJ. :J:t7&7.fiili T *Jl Iff z: fBJ as lEI1tik * , JAiffff:lGili~ftjlJEjV\hit~JasikmJm~, FJrI;_.uE:l!#:1J?tf$~ "*m B*~?t" <critical path method). farf$ CPM. 19574=, ttn0m$ CPM J_j)zmT--t-*~ 1tIrasJll2:1t:ttlEj~ftjlJ, ~-4=ttlH~ 100 JJ~ft, ;flg~Tl*0PJmTm~*jt CPM 1J?t1Jt mas 5 -m 0 1958 ~. ~OO#jf~JEtHf,lJ:ff.ftjlJ5E::Itm.~Jif.~tt:J(;tla1, ~fF 1ili:m T ~g_;l:1J ?tltl~.m~.m~~.~&~ff*~3asW~~ •• ,FJr~re:l!#:1J?tf$~utt~W. tt#" (program evaluation &. review technique). Mf$ PERT. EEr1ili:mT PERT, IW IWiEEJ]~)IEit:J(;rJas 10 &f~m~ 8~. ~~:j'I}-iXilE~TruJg~it:ttl1f?t~-#rrZ1f~as M~W~1Jrt,m~TW~Wasr~~R~*m.:l!M#1f?t~ •• m.~~.tt~tt #. ~B.FJr.asruJ.OO.R*OOd~~OO,tEft~*.~ •• ~.
~mruJ.tt~tt#~rrJl~~*~ffi~-t-£*ag.m:.~, Sfi~*,~*ltl 1I[~o
• .:ttlM-mflff~mm WBS ~OO$~ § 5t.~A1*asPTv\h, PTIfFasff§dtilil9J, ~g~tt~®m~as*Ma1~~~d~@ml9JFJrfii¥J"~,re.-t-ml9J.m--t-n~*. :1f-, fi:J ~ Jl § i¥J ruJ. 00 0 .Jl§~mM-~.~fi:Jmili~1f.-t-m~as®~"~~HEj~.m~Z~**as"~ OO.~a1~Mmmili*.ml9J,~.~O®~Mma1~~asml9J,N.$~g~~-t-Jl~ as~Ilo *.ml9J~JfZT*.lm;fx:o
.a~M-m.~*f~*.lm~.*.ml9J*ha*oJl~~~~1ili:~~~R~*~ ~~asSfi~*,~~~PT~~*Jl§assfi~moPT~1ili:mM.~*~*m~.~*. ml9J)NjWiB;ffBJas*.f§~, imiii&*~M.~J&~mm:-t-Jl § as~JVt"f8] 0 ~*~WPT mr x;fB;ffBJ!f{il§B<rWYE, :J:ti'iJ m~a~~*~~JVt*!f{W*h5t~ 0
.1I[~~&f1ff~~m~.m*~rr~AAttasW~~~.o~m:*m~~*.~;fx:L as.-t-iiSl9J; mmJl § i¥J~Il;'F*JI, X>truJg~OOnth7#J~i¥J1~iT, 4¥J1IJ*~*m1i!i£asPT~ 1e:i:1; ftx;f~jt$fHft1\m~,tt~J.
~~it:ttltt*PT mT:
• ~l!fJJl §AA\:ttl~~~;
• fifO 5E tE too:5E S Wi iiI % I as i'iJ h'lt ;
• WJ}tlJVf §~:5f[~:Il PTfj~ tfj mBflHmas;rFlJ";
• ~it~ § fffi3itd S W~fI~as~1tx>tJl § as~ofnj;
• ~it{ijj~ S W~fI~x;fJl § B<JJ;afnj ; ·~it~~.%.B~m~ •• ~~§B<J~~. ruJ~m asfiJ~~mm$ m*_ 3. 5 lJ c
3. 2. 3 ~§:)(~
~~AW*~~§~~~-$~'~~-~~~§X~~~$~o~@~~~X~~ T*~i&J1f:m;/Jltfmm~lJt~W~~¥lHIUt~~m. tE~ §~n&:i.1:N~, Jjlzff~ Afft!lf~ ~@x~J1f:fi;/J~~~.,~~~~~.J1f:rr~mtt~*~,*tE~§~~mxmAW~ ~~~m~dm*W~$n~~.~.mA~~ft~~*.~m~~xffl*§~~§~_ ill p.ij WJ ~ m .!~jI~*~ttjio
~~~~~~M2~~~AWM~~§x~~ •• lt~*~*,m •• ~~*~~
pg$:
(1) lJt §..fLlJt~ltJt£~;
(2) WBS, ~§tt:trj (1t~m, fijJ~m~) ltJtJ!jf; (3) ~~Jlli".~*it!I1~*1!f;
C 4) ~ § r&~rutmtll:§!8fm$*, rut.; (5) m~~mtl;
(6) ~i\Hr.~, ~~IB~{tJ:lt~~~i2~; (7) ~ § ~~~tJT!8f;fSJ.. ilHr lti1ififtttt--l-;
(8) ~ §~~t*mtlif (~mJil(;*-r&:M~t1f) ~iJ8iJ..; (9) 1TZ1f~~m:oor~f,j;1fE1t Cfiff, m~~~l!i&);
(0) ~§,~tJ!i*i!f (~mf'£~~illl), Jil(;*2t:ffl~~$Mf:L -~*~.~rrA@*~w~~~~m~m..fLAWM~~§~*m~Nlt~§W~M
It. Jt~ mz~JE~t1ffi § XmWJ.ll!Il3JJ.1*~*.
1. Bl FAm.A-l--t-
Wff~It~tt-ft9m ~Jil(;ln l:§Wff~:i.1:~~i)II~Il3~~ A~f-¥:i:~. m ~Jjlzjt1lflitr I ~ .• ..fLMm~§51l3~m.Mm~~~M~.~-§tio~3-5~ili7m~Jil(;~~~ 1ifD~ Il3 Jig $ 0
$;3-5
~ ~ ~ *
~frr OOM.JlI{;JL~1¥tEB9§B9
l!i~ mM.B9~frr~w~~~§w~#~~~
§lij) X>tml~}.t~~~:Jj~.'&:
jlJ~ fflIRJlI{;91 (,'1*, ~*)
JlRJft ~*~§~~~~&JlI{;~B9J1R~~ff%
_t:~!I!.~. lJHHJlf ijfJ flit ra.I:~L :rm § m.1!f S JIll
~1R !Ii:~'lfl.!l!~B9~:&~~* 2. ~*m1Affi..m. /'\1m~~BI~jM1ItEB ~r A9Hl:I.JlX.:
(1) m~@i~/miC. EBJI':HWpj(;~1IH~ff, ~1m1-rm§fft:!lt, Jl.i*I!R:!lt$~m 1 •• ~T~m~.~/miC.fiM~I!R.,~~rm§~.~*.,~~§~~$,.¥.
*mm~*I~.*3-6~*3-7~iliT~~m~.~/miC.~~~*I~~~.* rmlUffl;u}li5L
D~~*~~A~~~A-~~.~§~~*
o ~Il~~. t1EJz'vl·m_mtlJ-l.
o ~**~jffiJlX;lJ-l.1JQA
o ~.§7X~W.El~
o *fI~~i~JErllJ$~
o :i2\;fi'-1')a;IJ~i~B1i1i!.1l1~3R~/J,:aJ'j D~n~~~A~~~*.*ll~T~~§~~~~~
o ffffi*~7HIT
o ;ffMi~7JJ/J,mJiJf~?'Hm5i:M' AJR il!)!~
S~*fI~:
• ~~:i!1!iW ./J,mJlltlJ-l.1rtB
• ii~/Nf!.JlltlJ-l.iW §.f}f" AA~~1I'I-@'. Bl!lAm;IJ~!JIL ~fl~
• 'ifi~~ § :ll)m*
• jtlti:l.t:~~*~~!)!
••• ~mmtJR.ti:l~.M.~§~~*&~7X~WJiJf~~*,~ti:lff~$~
• ~fE~7X~i;XB1fBll!lWfl
• if-1ii~i~~.t" .~*~i~
(2) :f*,L.,J£9L ~'L.'J£lJt.l!m~.~/miCjzUJ*~M!!J]Q§itj;~~AlJL -~EH~1W mff, fi!!ffJ~1m ~ ®!~ /£11. iCfft Jlt, 1=;:W$!3rm §, Jl.1*1lR •• ~m 1 ••
(3) tt .J£9L tt .JlX.fft ep~ttMJ!Ji § ~fflt~, f.1.'ftW'IliHt$!3J]Q § ~J£fft, 3l~ m ~ ~!itt
*:f*.Affl, ~illffljft*, 1-jJ~~lt*1(~~.
( 4,) ~9r fft m- A. ~* fft m- AN:::rm EllJrtE 'm5l1 ~ fft :!It A fP n W ffJ ~ J]! 1lf, J'l.i*1lR:!lt $
~m 1 iit.
(5) fl!!~1lf. ftBfn~att!!.ll*$!3m~ffl;u, Jt.i*I!R •• ~~ 1 ••
(6) rm Elm~A!lXttH%. ftBfnN::~m~nltfftm:~t\1m:m~1J7!, IJ'l.m~~Afft, - ~EB~~~1W~~~n~mff.~I!R.~m:
1) m.1mJYH~ '§-~f&ffJ~~!l!f~t\W:t-lt~jj#i;, IJ'J,:lifiJll; 2)m~~§~t\@:t-lt~jj#i;,~~m*; 3)~m~~M~"~m~mfflA@~~n~,I~~mm~o
~.~~~M~~I~, ~M~~mAd*~d.~m.m.~®~M~mM~.~ wmmMttw~*~*m~o~@~m~n*.W~~~BN~M ••. ~.~~m~~ ~~,m~I~~~~R~d~M~~~o~~~M~Tm~~~~m~-~mM(~OO 3-3).
Wttli4 Wttlil
tltfJ ffi.Jt
- ffi IR E. f2.Jt~ - j;~:i2l;j;~lJ'\ jfij FU't
- ~ItMJli¥J.jI; - ;;l;<:&:~*
- *'tt:i1l'i! - !IT i¥J ffi IR ~ Ifi
- ~~Jm;g - IJ\,c,'il1tt
-~~§f,j - ~1C~J!I!fjH~jlRf£*
mm: .~
- ffi IR 11B.1l'- -1-A£~,Im~
- j@j It tJJ. it - :W$ ,~, iJit i¥J ;1lIg.g
- ~lf.~:im - ~1t$]t%~;iE
- lIP~~:9 - x>tm:
- :*: it ffllR EH,j -1C~J!I!_mlRff:*
M-tli3 IIfrtli2 1113-3 lji~ OOJP..£Jltrol!ll1-lIfl'&'
~Rl:~d •. mM#~.~-~ .• ~mM.~-~.~~ffi .• ~M.@~O ~~1Jo:um~~~M*~-tE.~ftIlLlt .• ~ .AAfIVJ\'L'iltl~J11A~1-fF~, flR1il~~~.1¥J ~ffi~Mm~~ ••• ~~~~~.~LIt,~m~~m.m~ •• ¥MOO~§~,.~. ~~M~m~. J111Tm[)AJiii}I[. ~RitJlJJE~~~~1TPJ(fE!Jltl.
~S-2: .f%WL ~LItMI8]. mlR~_mx>tmlRff9HI9.~mt£B*::@:m., @.m~~ ffdJ} 1t .%it jg~1**}~t~, if1±1± 11:H~Hj B ~ i£.ffi {M{ W dcJE. ffij ~:.li1:!J ~fIR~9HjHfi Itt ~.~«.~.m[)AI~l¥Jm.,~m~~~.~§§~~.~n~~~*U,~~~~ §1¥J,g,1*§fi--tE.~nff~:fr~o *~if4t~:JJAl.1-A~~§ ~I¥JIfP1f~~~, ~@*~ ~niJ[®mIRI*J1¥J4Jtre~3?::T~ o .x>t~mIR7IHJt, ftll*~nk!:.m~~-~ml'8fp)l!, 1~1lJ n.~~.~§~.* •. MLIt,mlRa~/m*m •• '%fflffW~.m[)Am.:uw~~ .ili.~~.~R.~~~.:u~mlR~ml'8~m~D, •• ~[)A~§~ ••• ~M~ • • dcfiiJmE8it~~1fA;. fj~~~1i!}, 1tram ~~tt~ -~~o p;,¥fft~ ~ iR2fr91-fft!if A~
i~ ~if tI:.\ 00 5( t~fo
~m3:.~M.~~~m, m~~~B~~~~A~M~~~~~~.m~§~, + ABiMAm~9=t. m~~.m rB]~it~J-}E~J.ttt<Jt!t~~m. m~~.m7fj(&¥t~fattrii]Mit ~-.,* •• ~Tm~~~.~m.*~, ~w~~-t~mm~~T~$tt<J~.~M iI5. mlM.®~/!ll *-mTrJ.3t*~]t-j,ft
~m 4: ttI.tTM. ~lIt~m, m~Bt.£~:7g--tA~~lttiB'~JJtt<J~1*. m ~JiIZ~xt ftBA tt<J it~,a rJ.lt ftMf1 ~Qfi1I1GJilZM! ili T:!I1l ~*, JHrt~~.ftf1*ff¥HRI'ii] M. ~lItM rB], m ~ ~ ~.§~L*~~*~~, m~®~/m*-mTrJ.£$tt<J~~ •
• M£~tt<J~-t~m~MT"~tt<Jm.M*,m.~mlM.~~~£.M~~~Hm.
M~,m~~~m3~~m4~mlM.m.~OO~~ml~~m2.~*ftBfiUm~Zmtt<J 1Nut#~nlt1L, ftBfiBfflTtlcmtt<Jf~,@,#~liffltu, ~H::EI3TItFtt<Jifn1~~a~mlM.~nltm. ~*, ~fatt1f&~PJ.jt1:.. -®m~PJ.ft@:~mffmr~mr, fE!:g)i § t'8atrB]~~. 16'@f ~~~9=tltatifn1.,.tlcm~~~M.
3. 3. 3 ~lJAldJ1J !3~3&
-
116
1. ~;;t ffl FA a<J;ft :0
m~.~/m*-~.m~m~,#M:g)i§§~~ •• --t~.ntt<Jm~m.EI34-7~ if:J<;L'JiIZ.m lkJtftB16'¥tt<Jft M.QIl;.9HIl~. rJ. r :likJtt~if:J<,L.'.QIl;.m at. T ~ ~:*]-j,.Rlk 'W:a)1~:iIi~ ~~t'8IE1~:
·A~m~ .. #;
• m~ItF~~~b
• !l!Jfl¥J~m.jJ;
• •• tf;;~Mt~;
• ~ T~ !l1I~ I¥.l j'ii] J!~L -~JiIZ~l¥Jm~mm~--t~J.tmM,~1L§±~mlM.o~®~tttt~ffz~~lM.nIt
.mBt~~.t'8,~~-~m~ft7fMItF~M~9=tmm*MJJg~l¥J. ~~,jt9=tm~. -'i¥/m*~iA±~I¥JJ{R. 0 m1itmlM.~utt'8ZV~:!lQr:
(1) fHIB*11Tff9}' liffl}EFJfIffit'8tt.mit~I tFJXl.f!, rJ.% .QIl;1[;fI_Jf~ 1E, 1[;fI_Jf@~ I¥.l
mit;
(2) rtJ.-ULm~~m.itH:£mlM.t'8.:a, §f,f-t:llkM-t Al¥.lff9f¥>1t; (3) ~miJ6,~~tt.±lri)IIrJ.lkiJ6'~I¥J~U!l!IA (ititj:, ~#~);
(4) ~FnJ~1Lm~.!i!tl (:!lQOO 3-4). {gmm~L¥l19iJ~ftlJJ.t, I'ii]Mt'8~mMtlctJt1liL ~ftlJ:gJ! § 1LJ!i!~~; ,
(5) .IKf~~J.t, ~iiEmlR;t~JJ, #/FWTrtJ §f,f-:iQ~; (6) i£.m~ItF9=tt'8.Q1l;~, **-f':m:m.
7\ l!!i.m E! ffllR!IH1U ~111-3£fliJ~JA!UfJB'JIREf c~i!!l., jJ};ff~it!!.;fIJmB1fBJ. ~ffJ**CCffi'j]Il!J!U:
1. ~ is( 1lB17f Mt l'Il ~JfL
2. !Ilt";ffA~fm~1m~}~, ~~:Pil!WJ 1 ~:i!~m*.
3. 4lHX4.l;-t:{(f{J pg .§:m~il!WJiii~: fiJt-1-i~~, ~t£~WJft-};f~.
4. *a;f:5{;~Jjlf5ttJt((f{JIft. !I1l:W:it~J1J, ~~j,'il!Btr 1 J(:i!9;lWI*.
5. X>tfHHi'f~/F ••
6. 4.l;-t:{{>U~~Jl~~~~~:1JIl(f{JAo
7. ~t:{rJ7f!t.Tt~:tz;;{j<]1i.TtH!IT. ~f(JlItJlt#E~. :lillljU'l~.
8. jjJfiaat. ~iIl~;fIJYijlF11ia;tra]7f4.l;-.
2 . .ttl ~ m rrA.1¥] ;ft_:J?"
W~:t\IDfl*~'1fm!f'my~&t, :t\Wl*~B:rM.l6\®fijj:>JUIl M.fiJ5 0 Aff]$~gjJ I fF$;ir JIR.QI(.;tt, i§.1- Af'm.Ql(.¥t,~,~lfmf'm, mM.f'mtJf5&~ftT1- A.QI(.~o 1WWf1:;fnB~!Il¥IJIIW ~~16,@i ~llM!j'U1E it1Jr! f'm fmjJ, fiij IJif l6'®f!III If .$.jijg l¥J~ ~ jJ ~ * fIl jJ. M!:t\ Wl* ~ B:r M..QI(.ffd{fE: 'i&1¥, ;ffJE: m I!:fJ, tjji § _::tfmJIR ~Jt iE l¥J.QI(.J1J 0 j~ e. JM W:tm fiiJ ®! .!iJ! m M.JIR 1-'.QI(.:9J I!JB? iK~~~.!!t1Jr!fIlttJ5 0
(1 ) m M. WJlJJ 0 fP :% m M.l¥J fi1 Jtf A, W-:M!;tt:.QI(.9! jt IJiJ 19:rm § fi1]jf, itt!iIh fi J5 :1l:+ Jt I ~f'm, iKJE If -#9}~l¥J m M.$.!iIh1}r! llJ fjt~~, IW TARGET. A1*~mr:
• T (truth, $~)o mM..QI(.lJ!l6,m~*.~A;ffJ, !lWm~fflM..QI(.lJ!:I!l.iJ£#iJjj. Jt .~ •• ~:ffI!:fJT.~"~TOOm.~A;ffJ"f'mIfF~m.
• A (accountable, ffrilV 0 B:r M..QI(.9tillZi%<:% § B l¥JtJf5&fi1 iff 0 f,HlfllJ k.{JinJ;t1fjr:li~r1t tjji § tt~tlllU£WH~1trm § ~1i&'~6[.jfT t;t ffi~~, Jfl ~j B:r M..QI(.93. agiffff ~ 0
• R (respect, ~I) 0 mM..QI(.93.mi%<*iriE1L!j:lf!.lJ!ag~.mtl. :m1[~.33. JC~,L'#J.o 1L.!Ilili~M,~§.~~1-TM~M, •• ~Bf'm.£1J ••
• G (growt h • .QI(. -t~:) 0 m M..QI(.91,& m M.* ~ $16' ®f~ U]$ f£ IE ~ .33 ffij .QI(. * , U 1!J!lf fm jJ m~Im.l¥JIfFff9}o.w~uw~m~.m~mRn*ftM~m~®.*f'm.~ft, i1:m M..9!!!:l:g2EH ~ 53 W.QI(. * 0
• E (empowered, ttfXL .QI(.J)]agM1*1JJf$1-jjllagfi~, JtJt.J!1(~tt*1f:J:1fOO 0 .W lliZW iftil.ft%-fi1 iff A~ f~.!iJ!ilf, i1 m M..QI(.93. JIR 1'ttfX , 1i~1-jjtll¥J A1*1~;/J, t.t n 1- A ag~*o
• T (trust, ffiff). fF~~1-:M5&f'mM1*, :t\IDfl*~m~.mZra}lliZi%<;ffJ1[ffiff, :# 13. /pH,' W jJ %.QI(.1I?;.=E l¥J ff 9} 0 .W~ t;t t1J. I!:fJ m M..QI(.91 fI j£fltJit ra} l¥J ffl1[ ffi if 0 :ffT~~.~,*ftM~mM..~~*.ilir~ •• :t\ftM~mM.f'm~~*~:
• Jf~fmm IR 0 m M..QI(.mm* § ::f-1JiJ 1¥J~~~®!:I!jt, fJijlf11ffl:ff1[I!:fJJi*~l¥Jtt*fmJJ 0 ~ l{R~mM.ag$ft.Ql(.911JJ$iftjl!§B$nf'mIfFo
• yt&t'I1~5&o £lfVt~~)(I¥J~5&&Ut. ~$.1ilJJmM.±~o tEltHmI*JYr$)iji1;1'ffl>.K i&JJE891jE~ft § fjf-1Ii1i¥ T. mM..QI(.93. z['a} 1t:Jt#iJR , m M.JiX;mm~~ :*JIif ltJfl1Jn 0
• If.)( ag § tlF 0 m M.I¥J 4ij-m.Ql(.93. ~l6,m iA IJiJ m M. Hft l¥J vrm.&;tt:~;fm~U~1* ag:Vt
-." ..
-.
~. $.:rJJtfJtID l~}dt.)®l~* ~tjj\, *i~j\jJiJTtf ~1P. ~iJ... ~ c ·M~~~~.m~~~~m~~~~,.m.m.~~T.*.~.-~~M.~ ~~ .• N.~.~~W~Rm~~~~~tt~~~.
·*a~~R, ~~.~~~*a.~~~~.~R~-~~*~*o*D.~~m m~Z-~X~W~~.~~~~ft)~~~~~~ZL~ .
• 0~~@.o~T~w~~~.a~m,~I~~.~m~d.~M~ •• ffi. a,~*.#W •• ~ffl~0~~@ •.
(2) ~~:JtfiJlI, *j!!f.~m~m~zJ§", ~,@!~-EtJ:m§~·Mfi£~~~M:Jtfi)iI. tt~ "1gfPJ" (why), m~ "~rlfPJ" (how), f&iJll!ik*W.E!rm§tittrl¥r~Jr:.', _m:,~~~1H~j~ .m, t~jJtl~~* 0 §]~f&iJllff9}-fN:S:t:8fi>tHI*ffi~*mff.
3. m FJ....*3Ct-it-ft
~rm§m~~~.ttw~,~~~~~J:m§m~~ •• *fiW~,M~&~~.m~ ~.~~~Mo~~, m~ •• W~ill~~~m~&~m~~~.§~ttW~~*.ffl& ~-#~.~~.E~rm§m~~m~m~~x~+*_m:~o
KJ:m§~~~ttW~,~Tm~rm§§~~~.ffi&,*S:t~wmrm§m~~ •• 5'~, -mPJt;).7J~mpg$~~8<JffiiJ.m:tj, ~rlmlR~t>!.8<JW.*. m~.~ 8<J~~W1t. t;J.& ~~.~m~~h~~.~*W~.rm§mlR~~*tr~awm,*~ffl~~~~9}~. A.El!@W~m:tjB9mHf~* .
3.3. 4 ~M.I~
1. 1d~ $l...J. * ~~~~~~mlRI~~~.~m8<J~~.~~~~~-~PJ~*~~~~~.~. Wr"N~i±a9~/J\m~tl~W~,~-T8<J~ii. m=~~~~'ifim~@M-=f. Jij~~~.§:tjx ~B9M -=f. m .:::.~~-@mJl~j~rr*8<J,~ -J-f$*-tV8<J'ifi{m. *n:J'~Vl\m8<J~~, Jl'tin ilttrf;/t5tJ1Hf.
!k~m~~t~ttW~rlr :
0) ~~m~8<J£M1gIJ\m*~. *mmlltJiB9i!flaJ. t;J./J\m.m •• '#¥lJB9~A~
ti1*.
(2) m~:#~/J\~ll.~~*;f!~.
(3) $;9!~r4i}~;f!~, ~i.-;Hi:-. ?HRdfttW.
(4) J!~:t1:W}j£~¥IJN~jf8<J~~W •. N~'ifim~~.,~~.~A.m.'t,~J§"~~~~;f!~~*,%~PJmTN~B9
~j!.o
!k.R~~~~.m~~~~~,~~@~:~*~ma9.~d~4i}~.lli-~~ ~,~*~~~~~m •• MM,.#.~r-~A8<J~~.~~~N~-~,*~~ tit, ~~~-~4i}~A~~~jfa9~~~,~~~~~~~*o-mPJ~~m~~~ttw, mA •• ~Mam~8<J~~.~ ••• ~8<Jm.~~M~~£.d~M,~m$;mM- • • )E¥lJJ3- ••• re~ffJa9~~EJr*. K**mJ~Q{J!J\m~*FPJt;J.fIH~:li.~8<J~~* 1C$;~f~ 8<J ttwo
~JmIJxU}iI:ff -;fajI4*~ljl¥J1ir!PJJt]Tt( r:IMi5-: JW*JOtI¥J~~~tl~~I¥J.3:m. 11,VJ\!ll JOCff!raliliN:fl~JL~Nl¥Jmffo i!1'-1Jf!n~1Ml: Crawford ~Jtr!. ff4ij:1'- AilJiJfF1t!! (~~) ~a.r!~~~~Jt, •• ,.M-1'-PJffl.~A(M~, m~m.A),i!1'-A~~~ •• ~.-~~~.i!;fajI1Jr!~.~ttPJ~~Afim~.ili1t!!fi~.f!.~~m~~.~ ~~:ff~1'-A~.ffl~~.r!,M~*~~~~~~f~o
*fII!.~Jffij.Rt~JWF1:.r!~-A2:1Jr!~~ 5U_§_~* (nominal group technique) 0 mzJt] i!1-~*PJ kJ flj WJm ~M ftBilJ.ili ~.r! q:.;Q\;1f:ili:J>~:m:~~.r!. ~ 5U_§_~* ~ r7UiV W~.:
(1) X>tmr!7tl~i!t1-r~fII!.. #mJitl{t#, 1t.f!7U~:fG~, 7ff~. 1i~:m:JL (2) ff4ij1'-~bn;f~~1'-mf!i!trr~#&if1fl" ({§rHo. 1 ~7f;:Ii~, 8 ~m:litr-) 0 (3) ~4ij:rm9}:liIic~~$~bn*i'ili~~#&o
(4) xt4lfrm~~w**~o !~@,~,*ii11£~:rm!=J flpmlRiAjg.f1~1fo
~ 3--8 ~~5(!_§_~*mzJt]~-1-ffiJ .~{§rJ 0 ~{§rJq:.;!rt/J\!_§_JOCff! ~tk:J£ f1!ifn ~i&i!tjJ ~. Jji1~m.Rt~1t!!1fJ.ili T 41'-W;;Q\;1f:~1J~: 1J~-, 1J~=, 1J~="~1J~mL /1\ mm*m4ij1'-Ajgi!41-~:rmn*.~ftB~~~~1f:mii~~1f~ii*~1f:Ml~4if*, ~4lf1'- A~if*:lJiA~ 3-8 tp 0
*3-8
1" ).)'5 flF rF
1f~ mlJ.i.A mlJ.i.B mlJ.i.c mlJ.i.D mlJ.i.E {tit
1f~- 4 4 4 4 3 19
1f$.= 3 3 3 3 4 16
1f~=: 1 2 1 2 1 7
1J~1m 2 1 2 1 2 8 ~~1'-~1f:~,1J~-~*.11£(tt~#&.~).~#;Q\;. 3. ~ -t".-&$*
$I=N:~r!jMtmlR.ff!)j4f11Bfn~mr!~-J§*~53-#1Jr!. 1t)t, ~m~JOCff!~ JW:ff.f!~~o~~.~*ftBfi=N:~~iliftBfiiA~:lim~~.r!,R.ft~4ij:A=N:~.~ ~,~,~~-*tc;b 0 ~~$~bO*$f~tB=N:.~1fzJ§, rm § fft. A~~JiJti!tff~it 0 m BM.*$~~~,*M~~~$~,#N::ff~.~~.m:J>~.tB#M~~tp •• o=N: ~i1NI~*ff.~~~~~AA~:rm§~~o
riIiiiJ3~;!rt/J\!EI..ff!~tk:fEf1!iffJ~ai!tjJ~~f§rJ. ~-?x4ij:APJlV.fl31'-~1f:; ~= ?X4ijA-ar0t:ff z 1'-~1f:; ~=?X4ijAPJkJ:ff 11'-~ft (JIi!,~ 3-9).
*3-9
:& ~
1f~ m-IX19:~ m=to.::&~ m=IX:&~
1f~- 1
1f~= 3 ~ j!lf
""
:1J~ m-l'X~~ m=l'X~~ m~?J.::~~
:1J~~ 3
:1J~1!!I 4 3
:1J~1i 5 4
:1J~T\ 6 6 2
:1J~{; 8 7 8 jJ:IM?tt1T~~1Ff.f .~)c (Kurt Lewin) tIltfH¥]-fP7Jfk, ~~mT~;Hf~#**N. ~~~~~~ffi~Q*mll~.~,-~m~~*#$m~~Du~~~~~~-#~m~ ~'~*ll#~~~~~~ffi&7J~L~m~~mjJ: ~~h(*~,~*)m~~~, W~~jJ(~ •• M.)~.~~.-~~¥~~.~mjJ.tt~jJ~~~.*~~jJ~ ~~~*~¥~~~,@~ymjJ~.~~~£M~~*Q
~fn k'J.lblt~1*m*7\I§~~1g{jlJlItRjJ:IM?tt1T~m_m c.!4!.OO 3-5).
:lnil. {t~ ~$ f.J 'If:f!l!~5[*/F$
:ft1Ju*JiIiJ ~zi*lOO
1'I:iWi ffIi.,~fl£.Ilt*, $(1 *Ul.±.)t., ~z~ii
!4am@~.ffl:IM
lIUli J®t~ tlUt It I flo -* it t t9Af II>t raJ f$::em §
1'I:il'1J'lfJJl!JJ<.'F i9:;fffl.
~*fHJti&* ~'ll'iJjf§~!i&
mil'1J{f:~~~Ji: ~ "'Hit IT tt;;of; 1113-5 :It!l!~.;;';;J~i~~:IJ$;t~1II
m-~: te~~7\W~~~:MI!:~WTlflZ§lV~~·~~~OO:lI!t~9tltl:l*, 5mfff!IL~~iA.i~;m x*W~,~I~iA.mWN,~~~~~.ff~~~~.
~=~: ~;fB7tl tI:I ~ 1Z§~--*fi?tt1T, ~tlltJj-jt~;fffEfi7\W*~ff~~ttW~lf;flJ ~ ~~~~~Q ~~,7\I§*~~~~~.jJ;mff~*~~.*lfmm,ll@lf~T7\W* ~~* •. Wff~~x*h~~.,~IWM~§~ ••• T~~IZ§ •.
~=.~; m-~f!jllUUIl~*,jJ;5l~a<J "hit" j(,J'IiltfT#ttt. TffP;!Jh~mjJl¥JjJiitM It. jM1ft. jJiitl¥Jj(,j'lPJiE O--}O Z(BJJJdRo #ffl*'JJN~l¥JjJ:iI:.1JDJ!p.J'g7;!JjJa<Jj(,j\. re ~~JN.l¥Jh •• M~.J'gmjJl¥Jj(~.~7;!JjJMD.~mjJ~.~W.~~M.~.fi. M~m~.Nff~.; ~~hj(~mh~.*n.~PJ~It~.~ •• fl.
jJ~~~PJ~*mm~~~~.~.~~l¥Jm.l¥J~m,BflmT~~*M~mjJl¥J *.,.Bfl~MftI¥JI~.~~M~,~.A~~~~m~*~ •. ~~.~~~~M .M~~miltff*n.~~~l¥Jm~,m~.mV~* •• ~.*W*~V~I¥J~m~ }[t~o
1. Jl ij ~~;fI:r Jlt;Jt J,f,. jl~
iE1Y! § 3f:tm JIfr m: , ffI ~ 1±1±~ttA~$1¥J flit I'BJ:ffl jJ * oW ~1Y! §, iliblj 1Y! § JZ JJ!:W "lit tJ 0 ~!!JY! § JZ1Ji!:WfJlittJtlt1ltflT •• 1tW~*lIt - *y~m •• illilHt*OO fIl fflJ~tttJtt * ~, li!~, 1Kr1unttiIJIJJJ! § I¥J ~ • .tt{£. 'EHiS 1Krm~1Y! § mw, fjiiJm, 2t ffiJf ffiHk: fillD! C{ ~£~tt~. ~~JJ!§*~~1ft~~o
~§~~I¥J§a<J~afji.~*~%~ff~oa~§mfTtlW~.~~~mffi~tt~~ ~1& a<J$11l. ~tIlt , ffI ~ ~~tlCi!:It!!iJUjJJ fiij m. ffiHk:fiiJ I! • .@!. tlCM! JY! § 19< ~ iE 1ft 0 ~ fPJM 1Ji!§mfifl~l¥J1Krtt~?OO3-6A1Ji!§~ttl¥J1ftm~w.
~§§~~iE~~~§tt~flit~~l¥Joft~~~§tt~flit,.J'gT~T~El¥Jm~~ flitJ. 1Ji!§tttJ~1iizW:~.m.W" (milestone) tttJ, xt4ij-1Ji!I~1iizW:fl~~I¥JtD!m~*o ~~~iit~mm~Wn-~¥~*M~1Ji!§§~l¥Jm~~~.~~¥m:§m~~~~.A ~m~#m~,ffI~~~,~~OO~~~. T.T§~JY!§m~~{£.~PJ~~1Ji!§tt~ ~1¥J~flmfTM~,~llift~.fl~~~HiEl¥Jfillmo
2. Jl Q Jltt!l.:r..Jt-;fp~*
(1) J9t § *f.t:5HlY. JjjiJ'i.oo:tt I¥J § I¥J AM!JY! § aBi~ ~ f1( flit%~. ffl. $~ 1:. PJ ~ tE ~~l¥Jfiif~fIlffl~~%~fji~ff*I¥J1Ji!§Jf~$o~~.1Ji!§tt~.~R1Ji!§I¥J~~fill
M.~.~.§~~~,ffi.~~I~mm?~T~.~~§m~~~~M .• ~~~~ J9i § ittJat, m~yH~ * tt:ilt fr:frfi • ~tH~:frfi~*. fl#XtttJl!!iflij~J9! § (J1t!.~ 3-10).
*3-10
:r_m §I ~MIi a;H~lJ :cpJ §I §ItT-
:cpJ§JiJT1Rf~1( B1!lA.f'iJJft i'/fiJll
~~~:frfi~*~.*tt.*~~R.,.~~~J9!§~.~~o~.~m, ~J9!§ ~¥lJfOJl!fffl~iflij~Bt. BI I?A 1t5t~m~~~1JuR., fifrl1*J9! § ~BrJEatr8J 1*J7i;~ 0
(2) 1Xl.~ifJ1l!ittJ. J9! § :::FmOO7i;~*Jmfjj!M~~~f-fmliJ*fT, -@~7~1f6i'.~~~ ~~rm Epnr*11tk~ibnllll, ~~~~3&:rm § ~~J&. j!:U~~!IiomriJUjtlJXL~#fl5&'lfJ1l!JXl If@:. ffli:J9BI l?A5ti1dmiflg**, FJf~.~~fi\t1'!.tt~~jfilJJEJ]! § ittJBt, r,( B ~wLl~t:J9¥ilIl jfilJJEJXl~ifJ1l!iti\tl. JXL~'lfJ1l!iti\tl~jfilJJEPJ ~~JffUxl.~iJUltl, JXL~Wt'l, JXt~ifJ1l!.::: 1-:$ W7i;$;o
.JXl~iJUjtlo -lItJl!!, J9i§JXL~*$T~1-1Jmr, -~J9!§*5t~. =~J9i§7~$ ~, :tm1t}(lt_&'tIf~iflij~, 1T}(lt_lft~~~{t~, BIrR ijJt.tjgffl~JffijJXtJi71dAl'1~~1-1JWii: iJUltlJPf § JXt~ .
·1Xl.~Wt'loml?AmTB~m~~JXLR*ftWt'l,Wt'l.JPfJXt~mJ9!§ •• ~*~, #mmoom:rm§m~~*.M~JXL~~JEMmftm~~~,*1TJXt~WJ1l!o-ftmJXLR~ Wt'l~=1-1JW*ft:JXt~~~EE*~F~tt,JXl~~~~.*,ft~~~JXt~~~£ ~1.t (J1t!.~ 3-11).
*3-11
R1.~ fr::HIHI9F.i:tt :&1:A911* lkat:&3O!!l A9JflL~1r ~J3[ J~,f;.$:~MJ.
1. n •• itill M H L L
2. rr •• F:I:/FJE H M L M
3. ~tiff\I:k.VIi* H L H M
4. Iatmit/Flkflt H M L H
5. Wf1"J%mtBlI H H L M
6. rr •• A;A91t1t:* M H M M
7. It;A9:1::k7Jt1t M M H M m~, Hft*.;Mft.~.;Lft* •.
A~.M$~JXt~fiJ1l!~tt~.~omT~~ •• ~~ftA~ •• *~,~~~JXl~ mmtt~Jo .JXt~.J1I!o~~M.:::1-1JW~m*~~JXtR.~~~,~m.~m.,@~m., JXlR2l:~B<JIIaij'\!.~)(, .~m~-~JXt~ftiJJt A (9i!.~ 3-12) 0
*3-12
f.>iT.~ m@"m:M[ E!l~m:6lli 119iW-)EJ( Jlfff.A..
2. trifl!l!:Fm~JE JfH~- i5il $ ~ (J9 ~11 tt1t1:.F~14~ ff~!I!:ffl:iT 2 000 €l £/J\~
#II
4. IB1~it~&fIit ~.A..ffl~~it E81:.F~~~'± :it~jJJnX~ ~ 1f~!J( I flit )l!i]::k#lf
'ilfJKi1i l'mH9ttlSL
5. J1if'~~ililf lit1:.FID'l-!3(jij:frfIfI ifi!iJiP.Gt !Ht~J J1i~iJt1:.F _t~-)l!i]E, t1~
$1l ~*it;~¥lJIE 1It* 3f
6. triflm.rt:H91£1t::k l!1F~1It?X,4ij1ltff9}. ~.J9!§tt~j INIt?X:t.f~-rr iflff~1iMi #*
~~*zIBJB9*~ ;t150%
7. IZ::(J9m:*~1t tJJHliIxt mUi!:rnJMH9JKi:fl ifi!iJm;Iz::lkAJJi 1It?X11Jl1t1ltfiiJM, :buF J:/J\~
MJiilt (3) llj'[Wtf:!t~.m.ftilJ!.7[]tl1fitlJJL :@j'[ DMAIC 1i --tWtf:!tll9:gJi § i!!:~¥Lm.m1fitl. :HI!M ~§rr~I~~.~M~Wtf:!t§~~~ffl£B9@~~W~,~~aff~~~~~~.~~ ~~~m~rr~.*~~§§~B9~~.~~~fl~~m~B9~~~~.~~.fl~B9~ §_li[~m~o
1. ~$'fJ£ ~~~~~§~~~MW~-~~@~.,~~~.~x~~.B9MWo~§B9~~ A ••• ~~D.~ •.• ~~ •. ~§w~~-n.~B9#~,~~B.~~~$~ ~.~§W~~B9~~~~.WW~~*~~§~BB9~.z-.~~B9~W~~~§~ ~~~-~~*I~,~~-~~~WWo
~.W~B9~*§B9~.~~§~~~~~~~~~ft~~~~x*~**, ~~~ ~~~~~mI.~*~m~B9*~~~~~Wo
J't.1*iffl1f, ~JfiifW&'®1~~~r §f,j: J:9f§ ~~.!:ij!lt9}$n • .!i¥, 0mlkj~'Ji!zl'a]
~i!!:~*~~0,~~fl~~~~.~iffl~~~~~x*,~.!:ij~~~;~§~~~$~ i!!:h~~~~~, ~~~~§~~~~~I~~~-~.~~,~&,~.~~ffim~§ f,f>, jH'¥IJi:A~.
~~.~mAA~m~*.m~§~.B9§B9,.~.!:ij*~.m~~~flmI ••• J:9f §~.B9~m,.~~~~~--tm~~m~~$.~$n~~AB9.~;r*~I~#~ 0~~~~.!i¥~M~~B~~~~m*~MT~§~~B9X*~**;*~m~~.~~F mIB9I~~~~~~~~, ~~~~~~B9m~~~~~o
»!J'p! § ~7!P ~B9A9l~:iltB~'~89ft1f Eg:ttfiJlI, {j!~~fgt&,±~~,L.'$JfI!~IlJ~89~ Jfi, *~fl:mJ:jlzB9ttit*~mi!"'~.; 1J1l5l~7r$B9][fti~~ii, ~;m § ~fil~*tr:i1t -flimllli3£llfifU}{1II 0
~*tfm!I.f1:B9~'L.'Rd~jio ~lj~lOC~n~~~~¥IJ~*.~B9AlI9x*B91HltIo ~ "'X*Rflff*.~.~~m~~*89~ffl*~~~.~T~.~.~~~§~~A~~ :Ro~*B9f~~~. ~m~Afl (;!jlfB9~jimLiJ~~llIiiJjJ 0
2. ~ m ~~.h~~~ K~*~W~~~§~UW~,~~~~#~~~§~~~~~,~ffi:
• jft~/*~-X>tji.4m~I'&;f:;
• il!*P-r.uXf£ rm il! , 'i'f,tEI jJ(mJt {E; ·~§~~-~~~-~,~fi~~; ·~m~,~%~~~m-~~~~$~~ffl;
• m-atri£--i2:mJL', "J!~PJ~JiI(;J}J";
• ~1.2*~-X>tJJ\!lHf,!lttl a<; u?tilb'-~~ iRiJ o 3. 1£. .f! J ~ M i:k: It £ I¥J ;ft >7
~ § ~ilt~~~~-r!J.R,.1Xl.Jf! a<;. m lR,~,~jijlnii -@ riiJ~lk. *#~~. ~ ~~-@ ~ ~.J!~m~§ •• Arm~.~tttt~.~.~~~~~§a<;~h,~.~m.~.,. lk-flP~lk.~!lla9ttJ5. J:Y! § iIiflnii~fIP~IlJ~* g mlRri3$, -tll.1lJ~* § mM.7p$. 5ti£-* g 111m, JJji § •• .A~'±.ff~~x>t~#fIP~*lRm.±~(fJlEm~1f, iA...~,m,fIP~.lk:1f*. K~,.(fJIIt~~~1f~i:R~I~fIP~*~¥ll g i3~ § (fJ. tt!..~~, JilttimJ~g i3~ *~~~M~~.~*.U*~.rm~~mm..m~*~.
JJji § •• A.l:k:*~JJi1t)t~3.Kx>t*~:f.JlRm._±~a9lEm~1f. -tll.it:R::m.. ~*~2t ~1It ••• ~lEa*~,rm~~m •• @.*~.~~~~J:Y!§~_.A, •• ~~lEm fIP~, Jj.iIifx>t*~, ~ •• ~~~mlR~mm§ i3a9~mff. lf~~~~*~~*#AlI ~x~~~.~~ .•• iIifmfIP~~~§_ • .A.)t •• (fJ.g~* •• ~ •• ~fi*~ ~~(fJ.~.*~~~~A~ttJ5(fJ.~mJil(;a9?~~~mM.~m~.~**~~.mJil(;
a9? ~~~~~ §ft'63.K3Nt~~a9? ft1ftt¥lJT*~~~(fJlI.U~, ;:tflli*Jti{1f~(fJ.
lk-1nt, •
• ~,~~~.m*~.W&~.~ •• lk-*~ •• l:k:*~(fJ:1f~~m$:.Ma9:1f ~~~JiI.~,~*~~:1f~llJflli~d- •• W.~a9ttJ5X~m$,K~W~~mM.~ ;f~m~(fJ-*.~mM.~ffi.~1f~#Ja9;fN:pjI c
4 .• Nh;ft>7
*r.llJb(fJffl-ME~B~~wr7! (Maslow) a9ft'63.KJiHx, f!p.AfnA~li~~*~3.K: ·~ff~~;
.~~~.;
• !8JM~;
•• m;
• JiI(;.~ g ~?k~.
Afn.tTJ(fJ~llJb*g.f(("iHX~~3.K. ?&rm. ~1&3.K~fA)E~, J!~1ffl3.K(fJ:i:~tt.
'*~, Afn(fJ?lllJb~* giWi-fiHx(fJ1rt3.K. n!Kilf$AKIf¥qt1t%~nwJEa9~.p}~!8J1 I
1VS3.K. J!#~3.Ker:£JiIuIf¥m¥lJfA)E. ff!!fn*3.Ka9~g i3(fJ":I:~d.a91rt3.K. J!Kr.u 5
i:RmI~~~~W, ~~m~li~~~~llJb~~:
• ~~o A1nmmffBfn(fJIf¥~m:~~. ifjjll1flllJ~m~a9$t~. ~~, {EJI~M-mm j{$m!m~~. aJl1iffI~ § § (fJllJk'1:R:HIl~:I:*1T(fJ~1iffI)£tt •
• lR.~~.Afn#m.~gi3~.~$t~.W~~*.~M,JiItt§~W~~~ •
-
It
-
•
:;
tt.lim~~~**~g~~~~~A£~.~-~~£m~~m*§~~~~h.Am ~~, ~~~~~~~.~~.~§~~A~~~~~m~~~I~rr~~u~~~ .
• ~$~~.~~~I~~~~~~,.~~~.~~~~~m~~~,#~m~~ ~~*!jr~~~jf(OO, itm~~~¥fftBfr1~~tJT~J1L .~~~jJifil'19~Sii1t1T1f*l'19x ~.~~~m~II'19~~~, ~~it~ftB~M~~~~ftBAI'19~~,M~~~ •. ·~A~~.~~mm$*~~m~I'19A~~~~~§~~~~*,ftBmIm~~1'19 tIL~, itftBfr1~1JuiJfJ9i § 8K~:ijt1JuftBfr1~)] iJf~Hi~tIL~, r.1:t11Ju~.:I~f:p § ~~it It. ~JItJ9t §~~tA.~~~~$'€!J3i-@:rJ&~ftBfr1;;t~l'19m~o ·~~LI'19~~o~-~~~~~~.~~~LI'19~~.~JIt,~§~~A~~*~
m~~m~mi1t~§I'19~~,~~m~~ml'19*W~~~~*~f:JlWh, $~ftBm-@m ~f:Jl~~§B*W~~~~*~l'19m~, ~~~}*mIf:p~~I'19~~o
5. ilJii
M~-~~§m~w~. ~~I'19~ •• «~.,m~~xmm.o.§m.A.~. § ~*iftjlf, :tEJft! § m:i1t;i1~9=', w~m ~ ;g~-~ ~M-I'19~;ljYF:Il~~~1tlt~1'19 0
·~~~~~.?~~~iliT~~;;t~.?~~~~o~~l'19m~~~~~~~~M- 1'19~.o~J9i~m~~~*~~.,~~~~m~~m~~~~~~§I'19.~,~~~m ~1'19~~~~§BI'19~~.~~~§§~,rr~~~~~.,it~~m~~~$~~.§ 1'19§~~rr~,;;tW~~*~~hl'19jJ~-~,;;tW~~~§*IT~m:i1t.ilim~am~ ~ii, ~j!Htm,**~JL'~l'19g00, ~¥IJIOJ~I'19"Hk:jJ;lo • §Jllt~m~#9., {!*~®~*~~,m~*~l'19m~a~~o
·~~~~~.?~M-I'19~.~~R~~~~;;t~:i1t1T.-~~mI'19YF~«M~m~ 1'19~.JOC 1'-l!M-I'19~)l. JiJf ~ ~*_L 1J$; * raJ- iE zw:IM~~J! m IV... ~ DI'19:IM FJf , "~Dx ~~~".
·~~~jJA~.?*~*~~.~I'19~.jJA.*$~mIV...)]~~~*~I'19~A~ iii. ~~~.l'19jJAfl1~$. # _§_fl@~*I:t*~lf~M-. ~~I'19ff1~PJ ~~~ § e. BlIV... ~~I'19*~,*m~~I'19~.jJ~.~~~~A~~.~~~~~,~~AI'19~~)]~~ ~,~~~§~~A~~T.~~AI'19~~*£**JOC«~~tt~~.jJA.flI'19A~~ jlHu]~. ~~~ JJtlA ii~. x;fT~:f¥"I'19A ~ ~*JOCifix>tifi I'19~D; lfl'19AJiii ~~ ~ ~, g ~}i!l~, x>tT~WI'19A*JOCJtI~#I'19~~jJA~fm~£«~.
~~I'19§~~~m~~-~~,*JOCtt~I'191T~.~~,x~~~,~~,~~~jJ A, ~rPJ1L·~AI'19~i!tl5~~1it11!~ 0 J!:fJIx1LA~~.~~~jJl'19l2:A. lJi § 1fJ.1ftAf:Jlffl ~~mw.PJ~1_I.l'19jJA, f1ABx~~ffl-ilffi,!~L ffI~~M~lRti~1_Iffi,~. f.lll*xit~ ~~YF~ili~T~£,~i!~jJ~~.m~~-£.ill~~*~jJ~~&~,~~m~~ jJf!*liJfJJEJ!!@uL~i9:1It1_l •• ~T~*~~;f1lX1LAI'19~Jm, ~ §iftm-A&'@{:
• Vl:!lffliltl. fat-1- ~M-I'19~Jmmm;;
• ft~mI ~ft*~#;JjiUt15 ;
• ~~m IV...lf{J~.fljrJl.t;
• ~1f1f*1T.tlHJII:fIliJll!:*, ~~~.1t15; ·~~OO~ifi~,~T~~~~~~AI'19~~~~.a~~~lf{J,m~~~D;
20 1it~ 70 ~f-trH~. S *ft9-.®Nl.~1l~l:fHU~rD:J "}i~l~tift9 TQC" , ffij}iff,~ti ft9TOC~*~*~~OONl.~~~~~*h$~%m,$~W~,~~~M-*~~~ EY:if<~!J&ft9:f1~. :i!8,!x1 Nl.ff~ft91J7!~ttl7 jfft9~*: ~fl JltJT1t~it~J ft9 pg$". ~ fl~rm~~~.~flJltJT~~*~X~~o~:i!~ft9~~r.F~7jf~~IA:*~ I!L *~OO, :WOO, jEI2'f:OO, 9€~fdi%:fJT7!, PDPC $;, ftH!OOo !j:t;~f'f!IJ!j!ti.iIllf[ M%m~~.jf~~IA£ttmMx¥~~ft9~~.£WWrD:J~~ff~~~~ffl~.~m ~ftfflft9m:~IJ!o mr3i€12'f:If[MJtmoolJJ.~~*:fJT~.±~Jt?HITJ;]~iIl. X1T~tt1J7! ft91&ti1ft1~H!l+1J7!ht 1iJ1lt1J:m l5L 'F ~~rJttt Am. x7!ftffl ft9 IA. EJf IJJ. § * AiD ~m ttJ'G 9€I2'f:OO~.E~J;]jf~~ff~~~~IAz-o
~ftffljf~~IJ!~,~~~tt~ft9~.mro~~mft9~m, ~ro~ft9~A*%mo :i3:i.I!.~!j:t;~~IA:ii*ft9~#o
3. 5. 1 ~:mlll
*~oo (affinity diagrams) ~m EI *$* JJI*EB=ft~ (Kawakita Jiko) T 1970 ifDtr §M~*~#~IJJ..rft9-~m.w~1J7!.X.J;]~7!oEJf.*~oo7!.~~~M¥ -~~.~*~.*~~.,~*,.7!~.m.m~,X¥.fl,DMm**h~A. *m~~~~ft9*~ti~~~~:i3:.®~~.ft~~m~~~.~-Um~~iIlI~. IJJ.~ TfilJ~Ji9ffHk: 0
*~ooft9'±~fflit:
(1) ~~,m"JL Um¥tmo x1*9lIft9.tm~9i:4!t. rrz~.~~~*4. *1A~m.x. ft9~~~m~ttl.tmJi9~~*~~~~.~¥~$m~ht~mo
(2) trl~UlUt~rPffreft9*~o DM.,m,r_tt~~jfft9~7!. *1JPk'J.!I3~~~o
(3) ~itJf~L ~[PjX!V.Bft9A.~:tE-ffi}. 1IUtH5E-:tlt~o ~_l.!ffrem:fll1i~fffH8Am httt~J/J\mo J;]lfftliUft9 §ti>. Ij\mJ!.vttll:ttl § Bt8~., • .!A!,~~7!, ~§:m~.®.fl t;J!-tJt**h~~o
(4) mWJ1J~ 0 rPJr~1JtWW~Am. a1J;~7!~1J~ 0 jlj!ti.j!!:tfti4-::f4?!IR W-MI'8 ~*. *lOOOPJIJJ.'fflJltJA1n*hit~, .,~,rM. Miffi~1J#§?&:ltt!.1JtWrfto
*~OO~ffl*re*mft9~§.m~~~~,w.~m~~~t8$Jtft9~7!o~~1J7!
A.ffl~~~M.7!Z§,M~~ttl~.7!mftm~omk'J..M.*~.*~,Mfi~. 7!m%~m~.~.J'G~EJfflt8.7!~~~tiJtm.~m~*ZB~%m~~~~~A~ *lOmo~~MNPJ~.OO~~~*J! •• ~.7!~-*-tJt.~m.~8~~Jt*hm ~. 1i¥lJ/J\gll~f*J!Jn.Mg1l1f~.1Jll:o ~~HfB~~~~, -@;R§nrlJJ.1ittE$~m~ 0
*~ool'8.=£~ttB~.~ 7 4i~ Ax;f*~~,7!~!ji-;ji-eft9-V-g.. fIf~~ 1'8 OO*~/J\gll~ m1l*~.~t8xtEJf*tlTriiJMJi911~~~L 00 3-7 ~ "i&.f.[J~fiJ;]1J7!" ft9*~mf9ljro
JlVR.*
m~'!':mfft~.A.
m~m(l.l..~jfEiI111f
J9i'flm(l.l..J£1AtII1ik~Im:11f
ml!A.i:Vlimm
!t*iifll: ~t!l.ttfll:
tNt ~ flll 5H1r tUtl i1t.~~lItraJ~{tJij
m I!A. ®!~11ffi<JmiJ'l lItym(l.l..J£mZraJfi<J/lf9~
fijjl'(!fi<J.tt;fj!i;&iI1~~ tE~i)L If $uJT j;-lJi
x*I~
ttJHfI,itQ
i)l..fi fII at raJ ~ tj/l it~.f§
~1It~~iSL~* ~~~OO~~~ffltl~~,~~~~.~~*m~~-~.$~X~~~~.~n~ ~~*~OO~ffl~~§~~~~m~.
3.5. 2 *ll~
*~OO (interrelationship graphs) -t!Zl*,**,OO C~OO 3~8), fflT~'**f6t~~tk~ ~.(~.~~.d~.~~mZ~x~~.), •• ~-M.d§~-~m~~ •• ~ ~~*,~m~tk~m,~~$~X~~~~-~OO~n~.,*~OO±~fflT:
• W.7E7\iN1*lij1jj! § ~1BIII~i!1W.;
• D1-1~HH1f: ~. zf8J~1f}Jj., !oc*-1-~. ~at~~W>i1-1,u~1- rJ._tJiiJm;
• liffJiA.*mif;lIfIiI~.; ·mrr~~MW~ffi~~~~~m~;
• mtfj.*rffJM['iiJm~mOO!;
• l:&J1h'bll'. ~ 131it~l1I! m~ . ,*~OOa31ilIffltV!l-fR1lnr :
• JiJUiAf'iiJJ2a3ff1t, fflOOIDIII~*;
• INaJi(;9HHa:lt!!t¥ili%~ff1tfPJm~~*m. (fQWD1-llL illm, -1- Alf~~); .ffl~.~$~~ffiili['iiJ~~~.~~~.fflOOm~~*; .lifIi7Ef'iiJM~~#~.riij~~.**, *m~~~.i!tt~*; .~~oom*tr~~#~,~.~X~~lifIiW!oc~~Z~,~~~U~L~~~~.
zr8J~~.**; ·~m~f'iiJm~m~~.ffl~~!OCm~g§.~ffiili*,*lifIi7EM~~A~m~ f'iiJ1!i.
~m~:!t'tti1t~ fI£ I¥J HVO.5 fI£ ~1ili'!t.t£ij!1tn-
J]tttff"*~fIl W~fH~~~"
3. 5. 3 t'ijlll
~oo (tree diagram) X¥lC~~ooo 'f:ttiJm "_i:M!-_i:~~~IJ-mJilG:~~--=fJ!.~" ~.~,~_i:M?t.~#?t~, ~~.**~.~~W, ~~~~.~_i:.?t.JiIG:~~~ W?t,~~~~£~r~.~.~o~~§4m~~§Lmr*~*o
~OO:ff ~ r JLl'P~~~JtLij'f:
(1) "§ ;f,-F-~N" ~~IJ ~~OO 0 ~~~ll~ § ~~ffltJ!.**~mMB~~f!i*~:tt!!~ *, ~~*~ft¥~~mMBo*m§ftm~~*~~$o
(2) "fii)M-~Il;l" ~~IJ~-WOO 0 mr?ttJT .&1i1rii)M!~jt~PII!JIl;l~~ra} ~ It5I ***. ~~***~~~M~mMBo*m§ftOO~~*~~$,~~L~~*OO~~-~~lln :it. ~1Il 00 3-9 lYfff;.
(3) mAA~ftJOOo mrm~mAA~>MI. -~*m§1:oor~~*%:ito
(4) JY! §1f~'ft~1f*?t. (WES). mr?t.:r.m § '1f~~ff*fBmJ, -1N:*m § 1:
oor~Jlt*%:ito ~iIJIJ*$JtOOIW-~tV~~Qr :
• ffifIYHm~:tt!!yt::i£m~~1j)fJEIW±'M (§tj, fii)M~);
•• ~._i:M~_i:~~~.~±'~lWm~o~~~~~m*~oo'ft~±.~~.&m~ ~m*~K.~'ft.~~±.~m~*.~; ·ftJ~~more_i:Ma~.~~d1:~IW*~.~.re_i:~~~a~~WdrW~
m.~;
·#M~~_i:~~M.~jtmJilG:~~~-=f~~,*.~@ili;
·w.~w~~m .• *x~~.~_t~~._t~&:ff§.~~~. ~~~R~~~~tt~'ft,~oo~~m*~~~~a~m~~B?t •• ~m.~A~
~R~m~:r.m § 0 !lQ;!it1P:.ill'.ft5(1~~I®t~fIIij~1l~tr)t.mJlJm 3-10 lYfm~~m, *m
l®l~m ~l!tif,l\1!t e'-J fl1m 1U!~J.1'W J§ ~Ii* e'-J * ~il$, jfij -§jfg:x tflS5tm ~ 89;l!~ lIS tz: ~ B9 ~ m~mu*,~ffl~~~~m~~F~~mm~~~AW~~~§,
rl f,tt1t/~~;fIHt1.
, L- __l
~at(*m:,~ 1J;f) ~ fro lk HtiNil JlHIii ~
t1i!:I;f f4= MFf ~HF:
3. 5. 4 ~1l$1!I
FJriW3:e~1!I (matrix diagrams), ¥:.tif::JAriiJJmI'l9*fIi~* q:.ttI:fjJilt~1~~. JH'l(fl~ ~m~l'I9m~,re~R&~~~~~~*I'I9*~~.*fi~~~.OO,*~~~~~51:fj .#~~I'I9~*.JAq:..~~.~OO~~.
~~*~.I'I9.~~m~.~§I'I9(dM*) •• MH~-~tt~m(d.~),~ PI ffl~oof!, r&1ffi. *~p;qfli lV.~1'I9 § 1'19 (~~!if;!:), YlUXMH fflm~m~tl'eh*m:.
:(:£7HlrJ.9HiriiJRI'I9Jjj(I2§, ~mffl?~*, :fr.LW:ii§-t~~, ~riiJR, ffl?~*, 1W:.I: §f,~ (~13 F) n>c:(:£m~ool¥Jftlt1, ~rOJRagJjj(l5I, ffl?~>lt~1tITff*I¥JLW:. § f,~]j~JtX1 1m.l: § -t~tli': I:fj 1'8 1m IHIt hi[ (l5[~ R) 71J:(:£ 3:e jr$ 00 B9 ~:n. ffl ~ [PJ B9 1<t% ~ffi E {n Z rEi] ~* I'I1Jji~, -fflH$ L ~3:e~00.
~~oo,~~~I2§*m~.:(:£Awm~~~~~~~.mffl.~Awm~~§~~u W~. -!iffl~~OOUl:fi~§~~~:fI~}f. :tl~~ 3-13 FJrffi 0
*3-13
Jt l!lUi B9 ~ ifoJ X1;lE!ft}WjMB9~ifoJ xtnX*I¥J~1foJ Mff JlIti ~ I¥J~ pij tYf § ffFff
tYfi=.ll © 0 © 6 1
lNI....I2 0 © 0 0 2
You might also like
- 义和团运动史料丛编 第一辑 中华书局1964Document273 pages义和团运动史料丛编 第一辑 中华书局1964another700No ratings yet
- (博弈：关于策略的63个有趣话题) 白波 扫描版Document318 pages(博弈：关于策略的63个有趣话题) 白波 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- 孫同文 (民91) ，全球化對府際關係的影響，研考雙月刊，26卷4期總號230，頁89-99。Document11 pages孫同文 (民91) ，全球化對府際關係的影響，研考雙月刊，26卷4期總號230，頁89-99。FangFLOWERNo ratings yet
- 038新教伦理与资本主义精神（ (德) 马克斯·韦伯 黄晓京 彭强译）Document218 pages038新教伦理与资本主义精神（ (德) 马克斯·韦伯 黄晓京 彭强译）another700No ratings yet
- 寬柔校刊合訂本 (1 18期)Document72 pages寬柔校刊合訂本 (1 18期)张英杰No ratings yet
- 张玉法：清季的革命团体Document759 pages张玉法：清季的革命团体another700No ratings yet
- GB T11352 2009一般工程用鑄造碳鋼件Document12 pagesGB T11352 2009一般工程用鑄造碳鋼件WuwaiNo ratings yet
- TCM - 黄帝内经 - 养生全书Document255 pagesTCM - 黄帝内经 - 养生全书ManalaniLinhNo ratings yet
- (六西格玛黑带不可不知的450个问题) 张驰 扫描版Document192 pages(六西格玛黑带不可不知的450个问题) 张驰 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- (沙俄侵华史（第三卷）) 中国社会科学院近代史研究所 扫描版Document424 pages(沙俄侵华史（第三卷）) 中国社会科学院近代史研究所 扫描版another700100% (1)
- 找尋山線2 地景篇Document136 pages找尋山線2 地景篇Yenju LeeNo ratings yet
- (运作) 郎咸平 扫描版Document245 pages(运作) 郎咸平 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- 《晚清宫廷生活见闻》 (全国政协文史委编) 扫描版Document364 pages《晚清宫廷生活见闻》 (全国政协文史委编) 扫描版another700100% (1)
- 物理化学－傅献彩 上册Document518 pages物理化学－傅献彩 上册Chun Che TsengNo ratings yet
- 《流放紫禁城》 (张建伟) 扫描版Document407 pages《流放紫禁城》 (张建伟) 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- 快樂工作人- 職涯決策一次做對Document136 pages快樂工作人- 職涯決策一次做對Wei-Ta HsiaoNo ratings yet
- (好吃懒做：家常菜做法) 萨巴 扫描版Document31 pages(好吃懒做：家常菜做法) 萨巴 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- (煲仔菜) 郑衍基 扫描版Document71 pages(煲仔菜) 郑衍基 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- (NLP学习突破的捷径) （英）黛安娜·皮弗 扫描版Document300 pages(NLP学习突破的捷径) （英）黛安娜·皮弗 扫描版lijieNo ratings yet
- GB 50286-2013堤防工程设计规范Document193 pagesGB 50286-2013堤防工程设计规范ccq0707No ratings yet
- (老子的智慧) 林语堂 扫描版Document267 pages(老子的智慧) 林语堂 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- 公路涵洞设计细则 (JTGT D65-04-2007)Document91 pages公路涵洞设计细则 (JTGT D65-04-2007)Huang WenjinNo ratings yet
- (烧烤大全) 张明华 扫描版Document104 pages(烧烤大全) 张明华 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- lv7 NewDocument59 pageslv7 NewHokYauClubNo ratings yet
- 064现代化的动力（ (美) C.E.布莱克 段小光译）Document300 pages064现代化的动力（ (美) C.E.布莱克 段小光译）another700No ratings yet
- CSCEC 管工手冊-1Document236 pagesCSCEC 管工手冊-1Gary Lo100% (1)
- (房地产法 (21世纪法学系列教材) ) 李延荣 扫描版Document252 pages(房地产法 (21世纪法学系列教材) ) 李延荣 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- (解读周易) 周山 扫描版Document429 pages(解读周易) 周山 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- 单元3 复习一 2Document15 pages单元3 复习一 2Zi'En WongNo ratings yet
- 鐵板神數中級教程 1Document30 pages鐵板神數中級教程 1calvinrabbitNo ratings yet
- (10分钟轻松做电锅菜) 陈富春 扫描版Document49 pages(10分钟轻松做电锅菜) 陈富春 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- 周易译注 (黄寿祺、张善文译注) 2007上Document255 pages周易译注 (黄寿祺、张善文译注) 2007上another700100% (4)
- (湖南人民出版社) 欧游杂录（徐建寅）Document163 pages(湖南人民出版社) 欧游杂录（徐建寅）another700No ratings yet
- 066 科学家在社会中的社会角色（ (美) 约瑟夫·本-戴维 赵佳苓译）Document382 pages066 科学家在社会中的社会角色（ (美) 约瑟夫·本-戴维 赵佳苓译）another700100% (1)
- (鸦片战争实录) (日) 陈舜臣 扫描版Document168 pages(鸦片战争实录) (日) 陈舜臣 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- (你一定要看董桥) 陈子善 扫描版Document214 pages(你一定要看董桥) 陈子善 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- 食疗进补靓汤1001秘籍Document256 pages食疗进补靓汤1001秘籍another700No ratings yet
- 031日本为什么"成功"：西方的技术和日本的民族精神（ (日) 森岛通夫著 胡国成译）Document299 pages031日本为什么"成功"：西方的技术和日本的民族精神（ (日) 森岛通夫著 胡国成译）another700No ratings yet
- 周易译注 (黄寿祺、张善文译注) 2007下Document269 pages周易译注 (黄寿祺、张善文译注) 2007下another700No ratings yet
- (餐厅名菜调味酱大公开) 李德全 扫描版Document52 pages(餐厅名菜调味酱大公开) 李德全 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- 經理人月刊56期-台大EMBA的第一堂課 當責 (商管系列叢書)Document163 pages經理人月刊56期-台大EMBA的第一堂課 當責 (商管系列叢書)Wei-Ta HsiaoNo ratings yet
- 0044 辛亥以后十七年職官年表（劉壽林編）Document659 pages0044 辛亥以后十七年職官年表（劉壽林編）another700No ratings yet
- (周易本义导读) 萧汉明 齐鲁书社 2003 扫描版Document300 pages(周易本义导读) 萧汉明 齐鲁书社 2003 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- 經理人月刊58期 一次讀懂專案管理 (商管系列叢書)Document132 pages經理人月刊58期 一次讀懂專案管理 (商管系列叢書)Wei-Ta HsiaoNo ratings yet
- �：耶鲁教授与女儿谈商业模式 陈志武着Document230 pages�：耶鲁教授与女儿谈商业模式 陈志武着Eason KaoNo ratings yet
- 062人的哲学：论"科学与理性"的基础（金观涛）Document214 pages062人的哲学：论"科学与理性"的基础（金观涛）another700100% (1)
- COMBAT BIBLE 戰鬥聖經3：特種部隊作戰篇「強行攻堅」Document215 pagesCOMBAT BIBLE 戰鬥聖經3：特種部隊作戰篇「強行攻堅」another700100% (1)
- 瓦德西 拳乱笔记Document203 pages瓦德西 拳乱笔记kamonkaNo ratings yet
- (岳麓书社) 出使英法俄国日记（曾纪泽）Document1,092 pages(岳麓书社) 出使英法俄国日记（曾纪泽）another700No ratings yet
- 058社会选择与个人价值（ (美) 肯尼思·阿罗 陈志武 崔之元译）Document243 pages058社会选择与个人价值（ (美) 肯尼思·阿罗 陈志武 崔之元译）another700No ratings yet
- (周易集解导读) 张文智 扫描版Document477 pages(周易集解导读) 张文智 扫描版another700No ratings yet
- 《人·兽·鬼》 三联版Document136 pages《人·兽·鬼》 三联版alejandro971806100% (1)
- Gb 51064-2015 吹填土地基处理技术规范Document135 pagesGb 51064-2015 吹填土地基处理技术规范ccq0707No ratings yet
- 裸妝天王Kevin -裸妝聖經 PART2 底妝Document27 pages裸妝天王Kevin -裸妝聖經 PART2 底妝Wei-Ta HsiaoNo ratings yet
- 趙鼎新：國家。社會關係與八九北京學運 2010年前言Document5 pages趙鼎新：國家。社會關係與八九北京學運 2010年前言vicvicvic711No ratings yet
- 熊十力全集·附卷 (下)Document894 pages熊十力全集·附卷 (下)another700No ratings yet
- 辛亥首义回忆录 第三辑Document181 pages辛亥首义回忆录 第三辑another700No ratings yet
- 辛亥首义回忆录 第四辑Document236 pages辛亥首义回忆录 第四辑another700No ratings yet
- 张玉法 清季的立宪团体Document571 pages张玉法 清季的立宪团体another700100% (2)
- 清宫热河档案 16 道光二十二年起同治元年止Document577 pages清宫热河档案 16 道光二十二年起同治元年止another700100% (2)
- 辛亥首义回忆录 第二辑Document232 pages辛亥首义回忆录 第二辑another700No ratings yet
- 清宫热河档案 17 同治四年起光绪三十四年止Document598 pages清宫热河档案 17 同治四年起光绪三十四年止another700No ratings yet
- 辛亥首义回忆录 第一辑Document242 pages辛亥首义回忆录 第一辑another700100% (2)
- 清宫热河档案 15 道光十三年起道光二十一年止Document589 pages清宫热河档案 15 道光十三年起道光二十一年止another700No ratings yet
- 清宫热河档案 14 嘉庆二十四年起道光十二年止Document616 pages清宫热河档案 14 嘉庆二十四年起道光十二年止another700No ratings yet
- 清宫热河档案 1 康熙四十四年起乾隆三十年止Document642 pages清宫热河档案 1 康熙四十四年起乾隆三十年止another700100% (5)
- 清宫热河档案 5 乾隆四十六年起乾隆五十一年止Document649 pages清宫热河档案 5 乾隆四十六年起乾隆五十一年止another700100% (1)
- 清宫热河档案 4 乾隆四十一年起乾隆四十五年止Document592 pages清宫热河档案 4 乾隆四十一年起乾隆四十五年止another700100% (4)
- 近代中国史料丛刊一辑 0891 国耻史要（梁心编）Document457 pages近代中国史料丛刊一辑 0891 国耻史要（梁心编）another700No ratings yet
- 近代中国史料丛刊一辑 0900 近代二十家评传（王森然着）Document420 pages近代中国史料丛刊一辑 0900 近代二十家评传（王森然着）another700No ratings yet
- 清宫热河档案 6 乾隆五十二年起乾隆五十五年止Document595 pages清宫热河档案 6 乾隆五十二年起乾隆五十五年止another700100% (4)
- 近代中国史料丛刊一辑 0897 西安事变史料（佚名编）Document424 pages近代中国史料丛刊一辑 0897 西安事变史料（佚名编）another700No ratings yet
- 近代中国史料丛刊一辑 0896 北征日记（项士元着）Document346 pages近代中国史料丛刊一辑 0896 北征日记（项士元着）another700No ratings yet
- 近代中国史料丛刊一辑 0895 - 4 三八惨案始末记（林本元着）Document70 pages近代中国史料丛刊一辑 0895 - 4 三八惨案始末记（林本元着）another700No ratings yet
