Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2003; 47: 11901195 Copyright # Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2003

Printed in Denmark. All rights reserved


ACTA ANAESTHESIOLOGICA SCANDINAVICA
ISSN 0001-5172

Review Article

The first intensive care unit in the world: Copenhagen 1953

P. G. BERTHELSEN and M. CRONQVIST


Department of Anaesthesia, Gentofte Hospital, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark

After an extensive survey of the medical literature we present Accepted for publication 4 September 2003
compelling evidence that the first intensive care unit was
established at Kommunehospitalet in Copenhagen in Decem- Key words: Critical care therapy; critical care unit; history;
ber 1953. The pioneer was the Danish anaesthetist Bjrn Ibsen. intensive care therapy; intensive care unit; polio epidemic;
The many factors that interacted favourably in Copenhagen to recovery room; respiratory insufficiency.
promote the idea of intensive care therapy, half a century ago,
are also described. # Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica 47 (2003)

Disease desperate grown by desperate appliance Furthermore, the patient was given one unit of
are relieved or not at all. William Shakespeare, blood (500 ml), isotonic glucose (1000 ml) and an anti-
Hamlet. biotic (Aureomycin 250 mg four times a day).

F OR the purpose of this investigation we have


defined an intensive care unit as a ward where
physicians and nurses observe and treat desperately December 22nd
ill patients 24 h a day. The unit may serve patients 7.15 a.m.: The condition of the patient had deteri-
from all branches of medicine. The primary goal is to orated. A tube with cuff was passed into his trachea
restore and maintain the function of vital organs, and manual positive pressure ventilation with 60%
enhancing the chance of survival. oxygen in N2O was started. After the injection of
With this paper we present evidence that the theophylamine (400 mg) and procaine (100 mg) his
worlds first intensive care unit was established at condition stabilized.
Kommunehospitalet, the Municipal Hospital of 10.25 a.m.: Blood pressure 140, pulse 120 and tem-
Copenhagen, in 1953 by the Danish anaesthetist perature 39.8 C.
Bjrn Ibsen. 00.45 p.m.: Oxygen saturation 80%. Increases to 86%
when 100% oxygen was used instead of the O2/N2O
mixture.
Patient no. 1 3.00 p.m.: An analysis of the patients arterial blood
revealed: bicarbonate 24.5, pH 7.51, pCO2 31 mmHg,
December 21st, 1953
and oxygen saturation 100%. Clinically the patient
6.00 p.m.: A 43-year-old-man was admitted from the
was much improved. The respiration was sufficient
medical ward to the Observation Room (Observa-
and he was extubated.
tionsstuen), at Kommunehospitalet in Copenhagen,
three days after he had attempted, unsuccessfully, to
hang himself. He was agitated, confused and cyanotic
with laboured respiration. Temperature 38.6 C and December 23rd
pulse 136. An X-ray showed bilateral infiltrates and 10.00 a.m.: The patient was returned to the medical
oedema of the lungs. It was felt that fatal cardiopul- ward.
monary failure was imminent. 5.00 p.m.: Readmitted in a condition very much like
Oxygen via a facemask and when the oxygen the one he was in when first admitted to the Observa-
saturation (monitored with a Milikan Oximeter) tion Room.
decreased, with positive pressure ventilation from a 7.55 p.m.: A tracheostomy was performed and posi-
bag and mask, was started. tive pressure ventilation was resumed.

1190
The first ICU

December 24th
The condition of the patient was unaltered. He
appeared dehydrated. A stomach tube was inserted
and an infusion of raw eggs and milk (2500 ml) was
started. He was given another transfusion of blood.
Positive pressure ventilation was continued.
Hyperthermia (41 C) was combated by covering the
patient with wet blankets.

December 25th
The patient was somnolent with paralysis of the legs.
His respiration was still insufficient with large
amounts of secretions obstructing the airways. Ther-
apy was continued as outlined above and Penicillin
(2,000,000 IE) was added.
On December 26th the patient died from cardiopul-
monary failure.
The abstract from the medical charts illustrates
many aspects of intensive care even as we know it
today: the continuous recording of the function of
vital organs; the immediate intervention when
changes in the patients condition mandated it; moni-
toring of the effect of the intervention.
There is no doubt that what was described in the
records of this patient and in the records of several
others subsequently treated in the Observation Room
was bona-fide intensive care therapy.

Was the Observation Room, at the Fig. 1. Bjrn (Aage) Ibsen (1915). Initiator of the first
Municipal Hospital in Copenhagen, the multidisciplinary intensive care unit. Ibsen graduated from
first intensive care unit in the world? medical school, University of Copenhagen, in 1940. From 1949
to 1950 he was Resident in Anaesthesia, Massachusetts General
In science, the credit goes to the man who convinces Hospital, Boston. In 1951 he received his specialist diploma in
the world, not the man (to) whom the idea first anaesthesiology. The turning point in his career came when he
occurs. William Osler became involved in the treatment of the most severely ill victims of
When it is impossible to establish who did what, the 1952 poliomyelitis outbreak in Denmark. In 1954 Ibsen was
elected Head of the Department of Anaesthesiology,
where and when in medicine, priority is awarded to Kommunehospitalet, Copenhagen (Photo c. 1955).
the one who first publishes on the subject. Conse-
quently, we carried out a thorough search of the med-
ical literature (see Appendix A). Why was an epoch-making paper published in a
The first paper on intensive care therapy appeared language few speak and understand? and why did it
in Nordisk Medicin, September 18, 1958: Arbejdet pa en take 5 years before Bjrn Ibsen first published on his
Ansthesiologisk Observationsafdeling (The Work in an innovation and the results of establishing an intensive
Anaesthesiologic Observation Unit) (1). The authors therapy unit? Ibsen cannot, today, remember what
were the Danish anaesthetists Bjrn Ibsen (Fig. 1) prompted him to publish in a journal with limited
and Tone Dahl Kvittingen from Norway (Fig. 2). The circulation outside the Nordic countries. It is true
paper was in Danish but the English resume is shown that he was the Danish coeditor of Nordisk Medicin
in Fig. 3. but he was also coeditor of the newly started (1957)
The number of patients treated in the intensive care Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica, where his ideas
unit increased from 1 in 1953 to 13 in 1954, 34 in 1955, and results would have been presented in English.
91 in 1956 and 120 in 1957. The average length of stay What we did was just to use the principles and
also increased from 2.1 days in 1954 to 5.3 days in 1957. techniques, which served us well in the operating

1191
P. G. Berthelsen and M. Cronqvist

Fig. 2. Tone Dahl Kvittingen(19112001). Norwegian coauthor of


the seminal paper on intensive care therapy. After receiving her
medical degree from University of Oslo she completed her basic
training in anaesthesiology at Rikshospitalet in Oslo. In 195556
she attended the WHO-sponsored course on anaesthesiology in Fig. 3. The resu`me of the first paper on intensive care therapy.
Copenhagen. From 1959 she was Head of the Department of
Anaesthesiology, Trondheim Sentralsykehus [her career was much
more exciting than these few facts suggest: see Strmskag (4)]. Ibsens idea was accepted that critically ill patients
(medical as well as surgical) should be observed and
theatre, also on patients with medical diseases, Bjrn treated in a special ward by physicians and nurses
Ibsen told us when we interviewed him in February trained in restoring and/or maintaining the function
2002. Really we felt that it was not such a big deal and of vital organs. In the years following the Second
therefore there was no hurry in publishing the results World War Danish physicians had contributed signifi-
of the treatment in the Observation Room. cantly to the battle against tuberculosis in postwar
In line with this there was no official opening of the Europe. As an appreciation of this effort WHO
unit. It started little by little in the hospitals newly decided [at the suggestion of Erik Husfeldt (190185)
opened(July1953)postoperativerecoveryroom(Fig. 4). the first Danish cardio-thoracic surgeon] to establish
In the beginning, the doctors and nurses were on the so-called Anaesthesiology Centre Copenhagen in
duty when needed but from April 1954, when Bjrn May 1950. For 23 years, from all over the world, train-
Ibsen was appointed Head of a new and independent ees came to Denmark for a 1-year course in anaes-
department of anaesthesia, the Observation Room thesiology. And most importantly the teachers were
was staffed around the clock. the leading anaesthetists from the UK, Sweden and
Bjrn Ibsen was not the first to envisage a special the USA. Among many others, Henry K. Beecher,
unit for severely ill patients (2), but it is our contention H. C. Churchill-Davidson, Stuart C. Cullen, Robert
that he was the first to follow up on the idea. He Dripps, Francis Foldes, Olle Friberg, Torsten Gordh,
rejected the generally held views on the utility of T. Cecil Gray, H. W. C. Griffiths, Martin Holmdahl,
treating critically ill medical patients. Instead of the R. R. MacIntosh, Eric Nilsson, Jackson Rees, John
prevailing fatalism and therapeutic nihilism, Ibsen W. Severinghaus, Leroy Vandam and Ralph M.
chose an aggressive and optimistic approach. Waters. There is no doubt that the centre increased
Many factors interacted favourably, in Copenhagen the prestige of anaesthetists in Denmark and created
in the early 1950s, to create a scene where Bjrn an international stimulating and fruitful professional

1192
The first ICU

infusion, electrolyte replacement) and respiratory


insufficiency(lung physiotherapy, prophylactic
penicillin) the mortality rate decreased signifi-
cantly. Nobody, however, extrapolated these
favourable results to other patient categories.
In the late forties postoperative recovery rooms/
wards were established in many hospitals around
the world and also in Denmark. Usually the patients
were observed and treated in such units only for a few
hours postoperatively until the effects of the anaes-
thetic had vanished. In the medical literature we have
found no evidence that such a service was extended
also to patients with medical diseases before Ibsen
started doing so in December 1953.
The pivotal point came with Ibsens involvement in
the 1952 polio epidemic in Copenhagen.
When 27 out of 31 poliomyelitis victims, with
Fig. 4. Kommunehospitalet in Copenhagen. The hospital was
inaugurated in 1863. The student nurses classroom turned into
respiratory involvement, had died during the first
the worlds first intensive care unit was on the first floor, right next few weeks of the epidemic Professor H. C. A. Lassen
to the main entrance (Photo ca. 1980). (190074), Head of the Medical Department, Bleg-
damshospitalet, condescended to ask Bjrn Ibsens
milieu in Copenhagen that increased the public advice. It must be remembered that, in those days,
awareness of the potential of this new speciality. anaesthetists were not highly regarded by other phys-
The 1950 report from the Second Commission on icians. They were seen as technicians who knew a few
the future organisation of the anaesthetic services in gimmicks. When Ibsen was consulted in August 1952
the hospitals of the municipality of Copenhagen (3) (6) he almost immediately realized that polio patients
also helped pave the way. It was coauthored by two died from respiratory insufficiency with carbon
influential professors of surgery [Jens Foged dioxide retention and not from an overwhelming
(18971956), chief surgeon, Bispebjerg Hospital, and virus infection of the brain as was generally believed
Otto Mikkelsen (18951960), chief surgeon, Depart- by the epidemiologists. Ibsen proposed to treat the
ment of Surgery I, Kommunehospitalet]. patients with tracheal intubation via a tracheostomy
The report recommended that independent and controlled or assisted manual ventilation with a
departments of anaesthesia should be established bag and a to-and-fro system with a Waters cannister.
in all hospitals. The anaesthetists should care for He first proved his point when a 12-year-old para-
the patients during the operation and postopera- lyzed and cyanotic girl, Vivi, survived when she was
tively maintaining a sufficient circulation of blood treated as Ibsen advocated (7, 8). In the following
by transfusion of blood and plasma, and infuse salt months mortality decreased markedly to approxi-
and water to restore the fluid balance and secure mately 25%. It soon became clear that it was imprac-
the best possible oxygen delivery by an energetic tical to treat patients with respiratory insufficiency in
support of the respiratory function . . . These prin- all the different wards in the hospital. When the
ciples for supportive therapy should also be patients were concentrated in three specially desig-
applied to patients with medical diseases and self- nated wards, each of 35 beds, the quality and effi-
poisoning. Furthermore, the report suggested, for ciency of the treatment of respiratory insufficiency
financial and practical reasons, that it would be and circulatory instability improved.
prudent to design and designate a room where So although the special wards at Blegdammen
patients could recover postoperatively. treated patients with the same modalities as was
Special wards for specific purposes were not later used in proper intensive care units, nobody
unheard-of in the early fifties. In 1949 Carl Clemmensen, suggested that the concept should be broadened to
Head of the Department of Psychiatry at Bispebjerg encompass all types of patients with critical illnesses.
Hospital in Copenhagen, established a centre for the An important side-effect of Ibsens contributions,
treatment of patients with barbiturate poisoning (5). during the epidemic, was to increase considerably the
Barbiturate poisoning was often lethal in those reputation of anaesthetists generally and Ibsen person-
days, but by intensive therapy of shock (serum ally. A fact that helped when a year later he needed to

1193
P. G. Berthelsen and M. Cronqvist

convince the health authorities of Copenhagen and his Carl Jrgen Carlsen: Senior Resident from September 1951 to
colleagues at Kommunehospitalet that anaesthetists December 1954, Department of Surgery I, Kommunehospitalet
(later Chief Surgeon, Thisted Sygehus, Denmark).
were indeed proper doctors and could take care of Ole Juhl: Senior House Officer from April 1953 to December
patients also outside the operating theatre. 1956, Departments of Surgery I and Anaesthesiology, Kommune-
In April 1953 Ole V. Secher (191895) became the hospitalet (later Chief Anaesthetist, Aalborg Kommunehospital,
first Head of an independent Department of Anaes- Denmark).
thesia in Denmark at Rigshospitalet in Copenhagen. Hans Heugh Wandall: Senior Resident, Department of
Surgery I, Kommunehospitalet 195056 (later director of the
Rigshospitalet was the most prestigious hospital in
Institute for Experimental Medicine and Surgery, University of
Denmark at the time. The appointment of Secher Copenhagen).
was a wise choice but it was at the expense of Ibsen Very useful background material has been provided by Niels
who was both older and more experienced. This rejec- Fjeldborg, former Chief of the Department of Anaesthesiology,
tion was a disappointment to Ibsen, but there is little Aarhus Amtssygehus, and Henning Sund Kristensen, former
Chief Anaesthetist, Blegdamshospitalet, Copenhagen.
doubt that it also acted as an incentive. He became
We obtained useful ground plans and pictures of Kommune-
determined to show the Professors at Rigshospitalet hospitalet from Erik Dauv-Pedersen (Senior Pharmacist) and
that they had taken the wrong view. So, in April 1953 Jrgen Wiedemann (Hospital Manager).
when Ibsen became Senior Resident (anaesthetist) in Kjell Erik Strmskag, Molde, Norway, provided data on Tone Dahl
the Department of Surgery I at Kommunehospitalet Kvittingen coauthor of the first report on intensive care therapy.
his fighting spirit had been roused. and he needed it
right away. In the surgical department there was dis-
agreement between the surgical senior residents as to References
the best postoperative volume replacement therapy.
To solve this problem, Otto Mikkelsen, Chief of the 1. Ibsen B, Kvittingen TD. Arbejdet pa en ansthesiologisk
observationsafdeling. Nordisk Med 1958; 38: 134955.
Department, asked Ibsen to supervise and direct how 2. Kirschner M. Zum Neubau der chirurgischen Universitatskli-
surgical patients should be treated in the recovery nik Tubingen. Der Chirurg 1930; 2: 5461.
room (and the wards) (9). This controversy between 3. Betnkning II. Afgivet Af Den Af Magistraten Under 28. Februar
his surgical colleagues allowed Ibsen to take charge of 1944 Nedsatte Hospitalskommission. Kbenhavn: J.H. Schultz
Universitetsbogtrykkeri, 1950.
the recovery room and subsequently made it possible 4. Strmskag KE. Et fag pa syler. Anestesiens historie i Norge.
for him on 21 December 1953 to change a purely TanoAschehoug 1999.
surgical recovery ward into a unit where all types of 5. Nilsson E. On treatment of barbiturate poisoning. A modified
patients could receive professional help. clinical aspect. Acta Med Scand 1951; 139 (Suppl.): 8998.
6. Ibsen B. The anaesthetists viewpoint on the treatment
In conclusion, it is beyond reasonable doubt that the of respiratory complications in poliomyelitis during the
first intensive care unit in the world was established epidemic in Copenhagen, 1952. Proc Royal Soc Med 1954; 47:
in the Observation Room at Kommunehospitalet in 724.
December 1953. and that Ibsen, as the initiator, must 7. Wackers GL. Modern anaesthesiological principles for
bulbar polio: manual IPPR in the 1952 polio-epidemic in
be counted as one of the people who were instru- Copenhagen. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 1994; 38: 42031.
mental in laying the foundation of our profession. 8. Kristensen HS. Comment on the description of the polio
epidemic in Copenhagen 1952. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 1996;
40: 1345.
9. Ibsen B. From anaesthesia to anaesthesiology. Personal experi-
ences in Copenhagen during the past 25 years. Acta Anaesthe-
Acknowledgements siol Scand 1975; 61 (Suppl.): 2933.

Five (alphabetical order) colleagues have contributed with their


first-hand knowledge and impressions of the events leading up
to the establishment of the first intensive care unit in the world.
Elieser Arge: Senior House Officer (Reservelge) from August Address:
1953 to September 1955, Departments of Surgery and Anaesthe- Preben G. Berthelsen, MD
siology, Kommunehospitalet (later Chief Surgeon, Thorshavn, Department of Anaesthesia
Faroe Islands). Gentofte Hospital
Bjrn Ibsen: 1 April 1953 to 1 April 1954, Senior Resident University of Copenhagen
(1. Reservelge) (anaesthesiology), Department of Surgery I, Niels Andersens Vej 65
Kommunehospitalet. From 1 April 1954, Chief, Department of DK-2900 Hellerup
Anaesthesiology. Professor of Anaesthesiology, University Denmark
of Copenhagen, 1971. e-mail: prbe@gentoftehosp.kbhamt.dk

1194
The first ICU

Appendix A Anaesthesiologists. Copenhagen, 1112 June 1954 (even though


the main topics were respiratory insufficiency and respirators
The following sources were searched to find the first article on the the concept of an ICU was not mentioned).
treatment of patients in an intensive care unit: Abstracts from the First World Congress of Anaesthesiology. The
Netherlands, 510 September 1955 (again no mentioning of
Index Medicus, 195060 an ICU).
Web of Science (www.wos.isiglobalnet.com). In this database it is Rushman GB, Davies NJH, Atkinson RS. A short history of anaes-
possible to search for author names and words in the titles of 1.5 thesia. The first 150 years. Butterworth and Heinemann, 1996.
million papers published between 1945 and 1960. We used the Rendell-Baker L, Mayer JA, Bause G. Pioneers and Innovators in
following search string: icu or sicu or care unit or recovery room Anaesthesia. In: The History of Anaesthesia. The Fourth Inter-
or intensive care or critical care or observation ward. national Symposium on the History of Anaesthesia. Lubeck:
Verlag Drager-Druck, 1997.
Atkinson RS. Bjrn Ibsen and his contribution to the start of
Ugeskrift for lger (Journal of the Danish Medical Association),
intensive therapy as a part of the speciality of anaesthesia
195060
and intensive care. Current Anaesthesia and Critical Care.
Nordisk Medicin, 195060.
1997; 8: 184186.
Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica, 195763.
Evans TW. Hemodynamic and Metabolic Therapy in Critically
Anaesthesia, 195560.
Ill Patients. N Engl J Med, 2001; 345: 141718.
Der Anaesthesist, 195560.
Webel N, Harrison B, Southorn P. Anaesthesia origins of the
Anaesthesia and Analgesia, 195067.
intensive care physician. In: Proceedings of the 5th International
Anaesthesiology, 195269.
Symposium on the History of Anaesthesia. Amsterdam: Elsevier
British Journal of Anaesthesia, 195563.
Science, 2002.
Journal of the American Medical Association, 195060.
Safar P. Development of cardiopulmonary-cerebral resuscita-
Lancet, 195060.
tion in the twentieth century. In: Proceedings of the 5th Inter-
New England Journal of Medicine, 195060.
national Symposium on the History of Anaesthesia. Amsterdam:
Surgery, Gynecology and Obstetrics, 195060.
Elsevier Science, 2002.
Proceedings of the Third Congress of the Scandinavian Society of

1195

You might also like