Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Research Says / Non Ction Reading Promotes Student Success
Research Says / Non Ction Reading Promotes Student Success
Research Says / Non Ction Reading Promotes Student Success
The average child in the United States spends roughly 4 hours and 29 minutes a day
watching TV, 2 hours and 31 minutes listening to music, and 1 hour and 13 minutes
playing video games. And how much of their leisure time to do they spend reading BUY THIS ISSUE
non ction?
That's the nding from a national study sponsored by the Kaiser Family Foundation (Rideout, Foehr, & Roberts,
2010). Sure, children are reading outside schoolabout 25 minutes a day, according to the study. But most of
that reading appears to be ction. Another study found that juvenile ction outsells non ction by more than 4
to 1 (Milliot, 2012).
Even in classrooms, non ction appears to be in short supply. Duke (2000) conducted a study of 20 1st grade
classrooms and found that informational texts constituted, on average, just 9.8 percent of texts in classroom
libraries. The mean number of informational books per child was just 1.2 in low-income districts and a still
relatively paltry 3.3 in high-income districts. On average, students spent just 3.6 minutes with informational
text each day. Lower-income students fared worse, logging just 1.9 minutes of exposure to informational text
(for example, during student reading, teacher read-alouds, or writing activities) during an average school day.
For many schools and districts, the Common Core standards' greater emphasis on text complexity, reading
comprehension, and non ction likely represents a sea change. Porter, McMaken, Hwang, and Yang (2011)
found low to moderate alignmenta range of 10 to 48 percent overlapbetween states' existing language
arts standards and the Common Core standards, with an average alignment of only 30 percent.
http://www.ascd.org/publications/educational-leadership/dec12/vol70/num04/Nonction-Reading-Promotes-Student-Success.aspx 1/4
4/2/2017 Educational Leadership:Common Core: Now What?:Nonction Reading Promotes Student Success
In light of this new emphasis, we should ask what the research says about the bene ts of reading non ction. Is
it really worth tearing kids away from The Hunger Games , the Harry Potter books, or Diary of a Wimpy Kid ? After
all, with multimedia consuming so much of students' time, shouldn't we be happy they're reading at all?
Only in the past decade, however, have researchers begun to uncover that it's not just how much students read
that matters, but also what they read. In particular, students need to read and comprehend informational texts
as oftenand as uentlyas they do narrative texts.
Traditional basal textswhich consist of largely narrative contenthave come under increasing scrutiny. A
comparison of an enrichment reading program and basal reading programs (Reis, Eckert, McCoach, Jacobs, &
Coyne, 2008) found that the enrichment reading group scored signi cantly higher in oral reading uency than
did the basal reading group. Students in the enrichment reading group received instruction on thinking skills
during teacher read-alouds; independently read self-selected books; participated in individualized reading
conferences; and engaged in a variety of enrichment activities of their choice, including book discussion
groups, creative writing, and other interest-based projects. The researchers concluded that providing
"structured silent reading of self-selected challenging books, accompanied by supported, individualized
reading instruction may be a promising way to increase reading uency" (p. 312).
In the Common Core State Standards, the National Governors Association Center for Best Practices and the
Council of Chief State School O cers (2010) cite a compelling research base supporting the shift to more
complex, non ction texts. They note, for example, that students who are able to answer questions related to
complex text have a high probability of earning a C or better in an introductory-level college course in U.S.
history or psychology.
One reason reading non ction may be so important is that it helps students develop their background
knowledge, which itself accounts for as much as 33 percent of the variance in student achievement (Marzano,
2000). Background knowledge becomes more crucial in the later elementary grades, as students begin to read
more content-speci c textbooks (Young, Moss, & Cornwell, 2007) that often include headings, graphs, charts,
and other text elements not often found in the narrative ction they encountered in the lower grades
(Sanacore & Palumbo, 2009).
Book reports will ask students to analyze, not summarize. Presentations will be graded partly on how
persuasively students express their ideas. History papers will require reading from multiple sources; the
goal is to get students to see how beliefs and biases can in uence the way di erent people describe the
same events. (Santos, 2011)
http://www.ascd.org/publications/educational-leadership/dec12/vol70/num04/Nonction-Reading-Promotes-Student-Success.aspx 2/4
4/2/2017 Educational Leadership:Common Core: Now What?:Nonction Reading Promotes Student Success
One English teacher who taught a unit on the in uence of media on teenagers said that she had previously had
her students cite just one source for their papers; this year, she had them read multiple sources, including
surveys, newspaper columns, and a 4,200-word magazine article by Nicholas Carr titled "Is Google Making Us
Stupid?" (Santos, 2011).
Teachers may nd that this shift pays o in terms of student enthusiasm. Researchers have noted one other
bene t of non ction reading: the potential to motivate young children to read by tapping into their interests
(Caswell & Duke, 1998). This may, in fact, be the most important insight to be gleaned from research. Although
students may continue to nd ction appealing, non ction doesn't have to be boring. On the contrary, allowing
students to explore and pursue their interests within a broad array of informational texts can help them to see
that the real world can often be just as surprising and intriguing as make-believe.
References
Caswell, L. J., & Duke, N. K. (1998). Non-narrative as a catalyst for literacy development. Language Arts, 75 ,
108117.
Coleman, D., & Pimental, S. (2012). Revised publishers' criteria for the Common Core State Standards in
English language arts and literacy, grades 312 . Washington, DC: Council of Chief State School O cers.
Retrieved from http://groups.ascd.org/resource/documents/122463-
PublishersCriteriaforLiteracyforGrades3-12.pdf
Cunningham, A. E., & Stanovich, K. E. (2001). What reading does for the mind. Journal of Direct Instruction,
1(2), 137149.
Duke, N. K. (2000). 3.6 minutes per day: The scarcity of informational texts in rst grade. Reading Research
Quarterly, 35 (2), 202224.
Gewertz, C. (2012). Districts gird for added use of non ction. Education Week, 31 (12), pp. 1, 14.
Marzano, R. J. (2000). A new era of school reform: Going where the research takes us . Aurora, CO: McREL.
Milliot, J. (2012, July 20). Industry sales pegged at $27.2 billion. Publishers Weekly . Retrieved from
www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/industry-news/ nancial-reporting/article/53112-industry-sales-
pegged-at-27-2-billion.html
National Governors Association Center for Best Practices & Council of Chief State School O cers. (2010).
Common Core State Standards for English language arts and literacy in history/social studies, science, and
technical subjects, appendix A . Washington, DC: Authors. Retrieved from
www.corestandards.org/assets/Appendix_A.pdf
Porter, A., McMaken, J., Hwang, J., & Yang, R. (2011). Common Core standards: The new U.S. intended
curriculum. Educational Researcher, 40 , 103116.
http://www.ascd.org/publications/educational-leadership/dec12/vol70/num04/Nonction-Reading-Promotes-Student-Success.aspx 3/4
4/2/2017 Educational Leadership:Common Core: Now What?:Nonction Reading Promotes Student Success
Reis, S. M., Eckert, R. D., McCoach, D. B., Jacobs, J. K., & Coyne, M. (2008). Using enrichment reading
practices to increase reading, uency, comprehension, and attitudes. Journal of Educational Research, 101 ,
299315.
Rideout, V. J., Foehr, U. G., & Roberts, D. F. (2010). Generation M2: Media in the lives of 8- to 18-year-olds .
Menlo Park, CA: Kaiser Family Foundation. Retrieved from www.k .org/entmedia/mh012010pkg.cfm
Sanacore, J., & Palumbo, A. (2009). Understanding the fourth-grade slump: Our point of view. The
Educational Forum, 73 , 6774.
Santos, F. (2011, April 24). A trial run for school standards that encourages deeper thought. New York
Times. Retrieved from www.nytimes.com/2011/04/25/nyregion/100-new-york-schools-try-common-core-
approach.html
Stanovich, K. E. (1986). Matthew e ects in reading: Some consequences of individual di erences in the
acquisition of literacy. Reading Research Quarterly, 21 (4), 360406.
Young, T. A., Moss, B., & Cornwell, L. (2007). The classroom library: A place for non ction, non ction in its
place. Reading Horizons, 48 (1), 118.
Bryan Goodwin is chief operating o cer at McREL, Denver, Colorado. He is the author of Simply Better: Doing
What Matters Most to Change the Odds for Student Success (ASCD, 2011). Kirsten Miller is a lead consultant at
McREL.
KEYWORDS
Click on keywords to see similar products:
common core state standards , literacy, reading
Requesting Permission
For photocopy , electronic and online access , and republication requests , go to the Copyright
Clearance Center . Enter the periodical title within the " Get Permission " search eld.
To translate this article, contact permissions@ascd.org
http://www.ascd.org/publications/educational-leadership/dec12/vol70/num04/Nonction-Reading-Promotes-Student-Success.aspx 4/4
100 Best Nonfiction Modern Library http://www.modernlibrary.com/top-100/100-best-nonfiction/
Top 100 100 Best Novels 100 Best Nonfiction Radcliffes Rival 100 Best Novels List
2 of 5 2015/4/19 8:50
100 Best Nonfiction Modern Library http://www.modernlibrary.com/top-100/100-best-nonfiction/
30. THE MAKING OF THE ENGLISH WORKING 29. THE ART OF MEMORY
CLASS by Frances Yates
by E. P. Thompson
30. DUMBING US DOWN
31. THE SOULS OF BLACK FOLK by John Taylor Gatto
by W.E.B. Du Bois
31. THE GOLDEN BOUGH
32. PRINCIPIA ETHICA by James Frazer
by G. E. Moore
32. UNDAUNTED COURAGE: MERIWETHER
33. PHILOSOPHY AND CIVILIZATION LEWIS, THOMAS JEFFERSON, AND THE
by John Dewey OPENING OF THE AMERICAN WEST
by Stephen E. Ambrose
34. ON GROWTH AND FORM
by DArcy Thompson 33. A MODERN PROPHET
by Harold Klemp
35. IDEAS AND OPINIONS
by Albert Einstein 34. THE FLUTE OF GOD
by Paul Twitchell
36. THE AGE OF JACKSON
, Arthur Schlesinger by Jr. 35. REAL PRESENCES
by George Steiner
37. THE MAKING OF THE ATOMIC BOMB
by Richard Rhodes 36. OUT OF AFRICA
by Isak Dinesen
38. BLACK LAMB AND GREY FALCON
by Rebecca West 37. WAYS OF SEEING
by John Berger
39. AUTOBIOGRAPHIES
by W. B. Yeats 38. THE SHADOW UNIVERSITY: THE BETRAYAL
OF LIBERTY ON AMERICAS CAMPUSES
40. SCIENCE AND CIVILIZATION IN CHINA by Alan Charles Kors
by Joseph Needham
39. PROPERTY MATTERS: HOW PROPERTY
41. GOODBYE TO ALL THAT RIGHTS ARE UNDER ASSAULT AND WHY
by Robert Graves YOU SHOULD CARE
by James V. De Long
42. HOMAGE TO CATALONIA
by George Orwell 40. STORMING HEAVEN
by Jay Stevens
43. THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF MARK TWAIN
by Mark Twain 41. THE TEXAN
by C. S. Barrios
44. CHILDREN OF CRISIS
by Robert Coles 42. HOMAGE TO CATALONIA
by George Orwell
45. A STUDY OF HISTORY
by Arnold J. Toynbee 43. THE VARIETIES OF RELIGIOUS
EXPERIENCE
46. THE AFFLUENT SOCIETY
by Williams James
by John Kenneth Galbraith
44. HOW TO LIE WITH STATISTICS
47. PRESENT AT THE CREATION
by Darrell Huff
by Dean Acheson
45. BUT IS IT TRUE?
48. THE GREAT BRIDGE
by Aaron Wildavsky
by David McCullough
46. A MATHEMATICIAN READS THE
49. PATRIOTIC GORE
NEWSPAPER
by Edmund Wilson
by John Allen Paulos
50. SAMUEL JOHNSON
47. ANATOMY OF CRITICISM
by Walter Jackson Bate
by Northrop Frye
51. THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF MALCOLM X
48. THE MAINSPRING OF HUMAN PROGRESS
by Alex Haley and Malcolm X
by Henry Grady Weaver
52. THE RIGHT STUFF
49. MODERN TIMES
by Tom Wolfe
by Paul Johnson
53. EMINENT VICTORIANS
50. MEN TO MATCH MY MOUNTAINS
by Lytton Strachey
by Irving Stone
54. WORKING
51. THE EDUCATION OF HENRY ADAMS
by Studs Terkel
by Henry Adams
55. DARKNESS VISIBLE
52. THE GREAT BRIDGE
by William Styron
by David McCullough
56. THE LIBERAL IMAGINATION
53. AMERICAN GAY
by Lionel Trilling
by Stephen O. Murray
57. THE SECOND WORLD WAR
54. THE DOUBLE HELIX
by Winston Churchill
by James D. Watson
58. OUT OF AFRICA
55. THE SENSE OF AN ENDING
by Isak Dinesen
by Frank Kermode
3 of 5 2015/4/19 8:50
100 Best Nonfiction Modern Library http://www.modernlibrary.com/top-100/100-best-nonfiction/
64. THE OPEN SOCIETY AND ITS ENEMIES 61. SILENT SPRING
by Karl Popper by Rachel Carson
75. THE GREAT WAR AND MODERN MEMORY 72. PARLIAMENT OF WHORES
by Paul Fussell by P. J. ORourke
76. THE CITY IN HISTORY 73. SEPARATING SCHOOL AND STATE: HOW TO
by Lewis Mumford LIBERATE AMERICAS FAMILIES
by Sheldon Richman
77. BATTLE CRY OF FREEDOM
by James M. McPherson 74. THE FUTURE AND ITS ENEMIES
by Virginia Postrel
78. WHY WE CANT WAIT
by Martin Luther King by Jr. 75. THE ELEMENTS OF STYLE
by William Strunk and E.B. White
79. THE RISE OF THEODORE ROOSEVELT
by Edmund Morris 76. ORIENTALISM
by Edward Said
80. STUDIES IN ICONOLOGY
by Erwin Panofsky 77. ECOTERROR
by Ron Arnold
81. THE FACE OF BATTLE
by John Keegan 78. WHY GOVERNMENT DOESNT WORK
by Harry Browne
82. THE STRANGE DEATH OF LIBERAL
ENGLAND 79. OUT OF THE CRISIS
by George Dangerfield by W. Edwards Deming
4 of 5 2015/4/19 8:50
100 Best Nonfiction Modern Library http://www.modernlibrary.com/top-100/100-best-nonfiction/
The Library Author Events Publisher Services View My Cart U.S. Consumers
Top 100 Newsletters & RSS Educator Services FAQs and Help International Consumers
Shakespeare Blogs & Podcasts Random House Speakers Bureau Shipping Information U.S. Booksellers
Reading Guides Reading Groups Rights & Permissions Return Policy International Booksellers
Personalized Books
Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use. Copyright 1995-2015 Random House LLC. All rights reserved. Site by Being Wicked
5 of 5 2015/4/19 8:50