Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Shimizu2005 PDF
Shimizu2005 PDF
To cite this article: Akifumi Shimizu , Corinta Q. Guerta , Glenn B. Gregorio & Hiroshi
Ikehashi (2005) Improved Mass Screening of Tolerance to Iron Toxicity in Rice by
Lowering Temperature of Culture Solution, Journal of Plant Nutrition, 28:9, 1481-1493
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the
information (the Content) contained in the publications on our platform.
However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no
representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness,
or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any opinions and views
expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors, and
are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the
Content should not be relied upon and should be independently verified with
primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any
losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages,
and other liabilities whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or
indirectly in connection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of the
Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes.
Any substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan,
sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is
expressly forbidden. Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at
http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions
Downloaded by ["Queen's University Libraries, Kingston"] at 18:03 28 July 2013
Journal of Plant Nutrition, 28: 14811493, 2005
Copyright Taylor & Francis Inc.
ISSN: 0190-4167 print / 1532-4087 online
DOI: 10.1080/01904160500201352
1
Laboratory of Plant Genetics and Breeding, College of Bioresource Sciences,
Nihon University, Fujisawa, Japan
2
International Rice Research Institute (IRRI), Makati City, Philippines
ABSTRACT
Breeding for tolerance to iron (Fe) toxicity in rice (Oryza sativa L.) is hindered by
lack of a suitable screening technique. In the culture solution methods used to date, a
major difficulty has been maintaining an excess level of iron concentration in order to
reveal toxicity symptoms. Experimental results showed that this problem was solved
by lowering the solution temperature to around 20 C, at which leaf discoloration in
susceptible cultivars became more pronounced. At 20 C Fe uptake was increased from
a threshhold content of 300 mg/kg of dry weight of shoot for toxic symptom to more
than 1000 mg/kg in susceptible and in tolerant cultivars. Concentrations of other related
minerals in the plant tissue, i.e., potassium (K) and phosphorus (P), were not affected
by the low solution temperature itself but by Fe content, which can be inferred on the
basis of their response curves to the excess Fe treatment. Using the proposed screening
method makes it possible to obtain reproducible results in screening a large number of
plants or breeding lines.
INTRODUCTION
Iron (Fe) toxicity in soil is a widespread problem for rice (Oryza sativa L.)
cultivation in India, South and Southeast Asia, South America, and West Africa
1481
1482 A. Shimizu et al.
(Mahadevappa et al., 1979; Ottow et al., 1991; Tanaka and Yoshida, 1970).
Leaves affected by a high level of iron (Fe) reveal brown spots on their tips
and finally turn entirely brown. This symptom is called bronzing and markedly
reduces grain yield of rice. Many attempts have been made to ameliorate such
soil conditions, but no sustainable method has been available in affected areas
where farmers cannot afford the necessary investment.
There are great intervarietal differences in iron toxicity tolerance in rice
(Gunawardena et al., 1982; Mohanty and Panda, 1991; Virmani, 1976), which
Downloaded by ["Queen's University Libraries, Kingston"] at 18:03 28 July 2013
Basic Procedures
Table 1
Bronzing score classified into seven ranks according to inspection
of leaf blades
Leaf order
1 N or T N N N N
Downloaded by ["Queen's University Libraries, Kingston"] at 18:03 28 July 2013
2 W N N N N
3 W P N N N
4 R R N N N
5 R R P N N
6 R R R P P
7 R R R R R
The experiment was arranged in a split-split plot design with three replications,
in which excess Fe factor, solution temperature, and cultivars were assigned
to the main plot, the subplot, and the sub-subplot, respectively. For each plot,
a plate with 10 10 holes was used in a 12 L solution. The experiment was
conducted in a greenhouse at the International Rice Research Institute (IRRI),
where the average air temperature was 30.2 C. Three levels of additional Fe so-
lution (0.13, 2.81, and 5.50 mM), including 0.09 mM Fe-EDTA and 0.04 mM
of Fe from Yoshidas solution and two levels of solution temperature (18 C
and 28 C), were compared. The 10 cultivars tested were six indica cultivars
(IR24, IR36, IR64, Suakoko8, BG90-2, and Kasalath) and four japon-
ica cultivars (Asominori, Gimbozu, Koshihikari, and Nekken2). Of these
cultivars, IR24 (Gunawardena et al., 1982), IR36 (Mahadevappa et al., 1979;
Gunawardena et al., 1982), Suakoko8 (Abifarin, 1985; IRRI, 1997; Virmani,
1976), IR74 (IRRI, 1997) had been reported as tolerant and IR36 (Virmani,
1976) and IR64 (IRRI, 1997) had been reported as susceptible. Reports on
IR36 are contradictory, which may be because of the differing methods of
1484 A. Shimizu et al.
Eighty-five F3 lines from a cross between IR36 and Nekken2 were applied
to the mass screening of iron toxicity under 20 C culture solution. These par-
ents were previously tested with a pot experiment (Shimizu et al., 1996) and by
culture solution (unpublished), and showed different tolerance depending on
screening methods. IR36 was more tolerant than Nekken2 in a pot experi-
ment, but less tolerant than Nekken2 in culture solution. Five plants per line
were grown with two replications. For this screening, a polystyrene plate with
19 15 holes was used in a 35 L culture solution. This ratio of plant number
to solution volume is nearly equal to the ratio of 10 10 plants per a 12 L so-
lution in the previous experiment. After 30 d cultivation, the shoot dry weight
and bronzing score were recorded according to Table 1. The experiment was
conducted in a greenhouse at Kyoto University, and the average air temperature
was 28 C.
Statistical Procedures
RESULTS
culture solution in all cultivars, the bronzing score increased with an increase of
Fe supply, while at 28 C of culture solution only the variety Kasalath showed
a higher score. Shoot dry weights and root dry weights of the tested varieties
also were adversely affected by iron toxicity (Figures 2 and 3), except for root
dry weight under 28 C of culture solution.
Figure 2. Response curves of shoot dry weight (log-transformed) at two solution tem-
peratures. Scales of vertical axis in figure are re-transformed to original scales. Formulas
for the curves were (a) at 28 C: Kasalath, log(y) = 0.17x + 1.6(r 2 = 0.97); Gim-
bozu, log(y) = 0.052x + 0.91(r 2 = 0.68); IR74, log(y) = 0.013x 2 0.20x +
9.5(r 2 = 0.98); others, log(y) = 0.13x + 1.3(r 2 = 0.86) and (b) at 18 C: Kasalath,
log(y) = 0.029x 2 + 0.40x + 1.7(r 2 = 0.99); IR74, log(y) = 0.018x 2 0.21x +
1.1(r 2 = 0.91): others, log(y) = 0.021x 2 + 0.23x + 1.3(r 2 = 0.92).
cultivar Kasalath was differentiated from other cultivars (Figure 4). Iron con-
tents of Kasalath and other cultivars increased quadratically with the increased
Fe supply. The mean Fe content of Kasalath and other cultivars were increased
179% and 224%, respectively, in response to increased Fe supply of from 0.13
mM to 2.81 mM, and were increased 1093% and 281%, respectively, in response
to Fe supply of from 2.81 mM to 5.50 mM. Overall, the mean Fe content was
significantly increased at the lower temperature even under a low level of Fe
supply. For an instance, at the Fe supply level of 5.50 mM, the mean Fe content
of 489 133 mg/Kg at 28 C was one-third of mean Fe content of 1579 851
mg/Kg at 18 C.
Mass Screening for Iron Toxicity 1487
Downloaded by ["Queen's University Libraries, Kingston"] at 18:03 28 July 2013
Figure 3. Response curves of root dry weight at two solution temperatures. Formulas
for the curves were (a) at 28 C: Kasalath, y = 0.017x 2 0.045x + 2.4(r 2 = 0.89);
BG90-2, IR24, and IR64, y = 0.10x 2 + 0.085x + 0.91(r 2 = 0.27); IR36, IR74,
and Nekken2 y = 1.4(0.35s.d.); others, y = 0.044x + 1.7 (r 2 = 0.16) and (b) at
18 C: Kasalath, y = 0.27x + 1.7(r 2 = 0.96); BG90-2 and IR24, y = 0.099x +
1.2(r 2 = 0.85); IR36, IR64, and Nekken2, y = 0.12x + 1.4(r 2 = 0.76); others,
y = 0.064x + 1.0(r 2 = 0.74).
Mass Screening
More than 3000 plants were screened at once by the culture solution, which was
controlled at 20 C. The scores in Table 1 can be roughly classified from tolerant
Mass Screening for Iron Toxicity 1489
Downloaded by ["Queen's University Libraries, Kingston"] at 18:03 28 July 2013
DISCUSSION
Figure 7. Distribution of bronzing score in F3 lines from a cross between IR36 and
Nekken 2. Five plants each per line (total 85 lines) were exposed to 10.9 mM FeSO4 .
After 30 d bronzing scores were recorded according to Table 1. Horizontal bars show
ranges of bronzing scores of parental cultivars.
and other cultivars at 18 C of culture solution was 713% and 284% larger,
respectively, than the contents at 28 C of culture solution. A high level of Fe
accumulation was found in Kasalath at the 5.50 mM iron supply at two solution
temperatures. This result seems to be attributable not to the solution temperature,
but to the extreme susceptibility of this cultivar to excess Fe. Kasalath showed a
severe bronzing symptom even at 2.81 mM of Fe supply. The mean Fe content of
Kasalath at 2.81 mM Fe supply was higher than that of the second susceptible
variety, IR64, at 5.50 mM iron supply. This result implies that Kasalath has
a genetic factor that controls Fe toxicity susceptibility differently from other
cultivars.
There was no significant difference in P contents of shoots between 28 C
and 18 C of culture solution. According to Takahashi et al. (1955), P2 O5 ab-
sorption was highly inhibited by a low water temperature of 16 C. Since the
addition of excess Fe promotes Fe-P precipitation in the solution, the resulting
decrease of P2 O5 concentration in the culture solution may have inhibited the
P uptake. Accumulated Fe in the plant may also have inhibited P uptake. The
power of P-uptake inhibition by the accumulated Fe in the plant may have been
so strong that there was no significant intervarietal difference in P content.
Potassium content was not affected by the Fe content at 28 C. At 18 C
of culture solution, K content was not reduced in 0.13 mM iron supply, but
monotonically decreased with increased Fe supply. The resulting K content
was still much higher than the marginal K content of 1% (Yoshida et al., 1976).
The reduction in K uptake was caused not by the low solution temperature but
1492 A. Shimizu et al.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors dedicate this work to the memory of Dr. Senadhira. This research
was funded by the Japan-IRRI Shuttle Research Project.
REFERENCES