Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Muldoon Igntn Workout
Muldoon Igntn Workout
first w o r k o u t
u n d e r s t a n d i n g our
p e r f e c t i o n and
imperfection
83
4 WORKOUTS
thefa ll semester, M ike started to realize that hed rim out ofcash
before the end o f the year, an d he started to get little concerned.
He fo u n d O n eveningjo b offcam pus a t a local grocery store, m aking
m inim um wage, a n d it bored him to death. H is grades continued to
suffer, even as he kept up his social life. By the end o f the semester,
he h ad faile d out o f school a n d had to move out o f the residence
b a ll He was too embarrassed to go home to bisfather, so he stayed
a t a jrim d 's off-campus apartm ent during the w inter breaks till
w orking a t the supermarket. He was miserable a ll hisfriends had
gone home, he was short on money, worked a boringjob, a n d bad
squandered his chance a t the university.
EventiuiUy M ike decided hed had enough an d w ould go back
home. He e-mailed his dad, saying bed be on the next bus, but
d idn't say much more than that. When he arrived a t the bus station,
his d ad was there, happy see him after m any months. They
headed home, a n d M ike saw his brother W illfo r thefirs t tim e in a
wbiU, too. H is d ad remarked that they were havh g a New Years
Day bow lparty a n d u>u id invite some o f the neighbors in the area
whose kids were also students a t the university theirfo o tb all team
was in the Orange Bow l this year, so it was a pretty big deal D ad
ordered lots o f food a n d drinksfo r everyone arid was happy to talk
about how his son was student a t the university.
M ike had a great tim e a t the partyeven though hefe lt
strange cheering on the team from the very university he'djustfa ile d
out of. He told bis d ad about the semester, fearing that hed be
angry, but bis dttd was really great about it. He d id n t criticize
M ike or make him feel bad butju s t told M ike he was g lad to see
him home again.
W ill was pretty upset here was a party a ll about M ike and
his school even though M ike had wasted his tim e there. He couUnt
undem and why his dad w ould let M ike o ff so easily. W ill had never
even had the chance to go to college^ an d he knew That M ike was
more o f a screwup than he was. He later told bis d/id about this.
D ad ju st replied that it tvasnt a reflection on W ill but, rather, a
chance to let M ike know that his dad s till loved him .
IS WORKOUTS
This story is a version o f the parable o f the prodigal son (Lk 15).
M any people have heard the parable, and for this reason often dont
pay attention to what its about. W hat I want to su^esr is that it gives
us a useful model for understanding mUsing the mark and therefore
for understanding how our spiritual lives must involve recognizing
how we muse change.
The word prodigal means ,,exce5sivc,> someone who spends roo
much. Some commentators have suggested that it is the father who is
prodigal, tor he spends too much on rhe son who didnt deserve ir. In
rhe parable, Jesus describes G od this way, always seeking out the one
who has gone away and chosen ( return. G od rhe Father is eager to
welcome back those who have missed che mark and loves to cclebrace
our return lavishly. W e have nothing to fear from deciding to make a
change back ro God.
This idea is so important because everyone finds himself or herself
in a posirion like M ikes at some poinr in life. Ic is worth observing
rhat M ike is not an evil person; at no point docs he choose anything
malicious. O n the contrary, he is someone who just wants to have a
good time; this is the way Jesus describes the prodigal son. I think
everyone can identify w ith the experience o f m aking choices that
seem good and harmless, only to find out later that they arc destruc
tive, either to ourselves or to someone else. It is at these moments of
our lives that the notion o f missing the mark makes sense. We have
tried to live right and make reasonable choices, but it seems that, at
some point, we have gotten off track. W e have missed the mark we
have missed the will o f God.
The first workout is about understanding the first principle and
foundation, and, at the same time, recognizing our tendencies coward
sin. So as you come to have a better understanding o f the foundation,
ask G od to help you recognize the choices in your life char contribute
to your missing the mark. Ask for the understanding o f the pain you
have caused yourself and others, so that you might have better insight
into avoiding bad choices in the future.
Sin i$ one o f those topics that turn a lot o f people off, so it may be
helpful to take a m om ent to put Ignatiuss ideas in some context.
FIRST WORKOUT 87
M any arc familiar with the graphic descriptions o f sin and hell that
we see, for example, in paintings or stories from centuries ago. I think
o f Michelangelos fresco The Last Judgm ent on rhe wall o f rhe Sistine
Chapel, a towering imaginative depiction o f the consequences o f sin.
In this picture, we see horrible demons literally grabbing and dragging
unrepentant sinners inro rhe fires o f hell, while the sinners shriek in
horrible agony. Its an intense and terrifying picture, consistent with
the depictions o f hell in famous works like Danres Inferno or M iltons
Paradise Lost. All o f these works, which have had a great influence on
Western ideas about sin and hcl), were produced around rhe rime
Ignatius was writing and s u re s t something o f the way people then
thought about these topics. As a product o f that era, Ignarius, roo,
was very influenced by rhese ideas, and so his sometimes graphic
descriptions o f sin can be frightening.
In the context o f imaginative spiritual exercises, these depictions,
which seem us macabre and even distasteful, begin to make sense.
I f im agination helps us co more realistically confront things, then
imagination about sin is no different. I think that these depictions
were seen as attempts to help people confront the reality o f their bad
decisions, evil choices, thoughtless actions, spiteful words, careless
attitudes. I hey put pictures to the outcomes o f sin, making people
really chink abour rhe consequences o f what they did.
Today, in a culture o f visual saturation (movies, TV, magazines,
billboards, photographs, etc.), we need not imagine anything its ail
done for us. O u r deepest em otions o f fear, horror, sadness, and
despair, as well as hope, love, joy, and happiness, arc easily portrayed
in various media. W c donr need ro think about these things, because
our thoughts are already available in attractive ways for us ro con
sume prepackaged pathos.
O ne writer described how he would bring ro his college class rwo
types o f writing. O n e was a poem, exquisitely penned by a well-
known American poet o f rhe twentieth century; the other, a short
prose synopsis o f the poem. He asked the class which writing they
preferred, and inevitably they chose the second. The first one, they
said, was too hard ro understand. The writer, com m enting on this
S8 WORKOUTS
SIN
Now the serpent was more subtle than nny other w ild creature that
the Lord God bad made. He said tl)e woman, D U i God say,
'You shall not eat o f any tree ofthe gardenT A nd the woman said
to the serpentaWg may eat ofthe fr u it o f the trees o f the garden;
FIRST WORKOUT 8S
b ut God said, 'You shall not ear ofthe fr u it o f the tree which is in
the m idst o f the garden, neither shaUyou touch it, lestyou die.
Bur the serpent said to the woman, aYou w ill not die. For God
knows that when you eat o f it your eyes w ill be opened, an d you
w ill be like God, know ing good a m i evil. nSo when the woman saw
that the tree was goodforfood, and that it was a delight to the eyes,
an d that the tree was to be eUsired to make one wise, she took o f its
fr u it an d ate; a n d she aho gave some to her husband an d he ate.
Then the eyes o f both were opened, an d they knew that they were
naked; an d they sew edfy leaves together an d made themselves
aprons. (G n 3:1-7)
Note that in this story, the sin is not a dcliberare malicious act. In
some ways, it can be described as an immature choice 'this is how ic
is regarded by some Jewish rabbinic readings. O n e can imagine a
young child being deceived by an older brother or sister in a similar
way. The older .sibling says, Sure you can cat a cookie now! M om
w o nt m ind! A nd the younger sibling believes it because he or she
wanes to. 1 his idea o f sin being a deliberate choice ro believe what we
w ant ro believe is very suggestive. In w hat ways have you made
choices in your life based on something you wanted ro believe? W hat
consequences exist because o f these choices?
The story moves 115 ro consider one o f the fundamental experiences
o f alicnarion h:u all hum an beings experience: that involving our sex
uality. The consequence o f [he characters sin, it notes, is shame about
their nakedness. Sin, it seems, makes them self-conscious; and
whereas before rhey were naively content with being naked, now if
makes them uncomfortable. This observation suggests rhat the very
experience o f alienation between man and woman is a consequence o f
sin. This is nor difficult co connect to ordinary experiencemen and
women have, over history, been alienated, and the mosr obvious con
sequence o f this alienation has been rhe suppression o f womens free
dom. Today this is still the case in many ways. O u r attitudes toward
sexuality have led, for example, to advertisers' glorification o f unrealis
tic images o f womens bodies; ro rhe expectation that womens sex
SO WORKOUTS
confront David with the gravity o f his sin; and when David realized
what he had done, he repented. Psalm 51 is attributed to David when
he realized what he had done:
This prayer, called the Miserere in Latin, has been used in liturgical
settings for the purpose o f asking G ods forgiveness for hum an sins.
Everyone can identify with rhe senriment o f the song, for it arises out
of" the experience o f guilt. Turning to G od under this circumstance
92 WORKOUTS
Imagine speaking directly wirh Jesus on the cross. As you do this, con
sidcr these lines from Scripture:
God shows his lovefo r us in that w hile we were yet sinners Christ
d iedfor us. (Rom 5:8)
FIRST WORKOUT 93
He him selfbore our sins in his body on the tree, that we m ight die
to sin an d live to righteousness. By his wounds you have been
healed. (1 Pr 2:24)
In this the hve o f God was made manifest am ong us, that God sent
his only Son into the world, so that we m ight live through him . In
this is love, not that e loved G od but that he loved us an d sent his
Son to be the expiation fo r our sins. (1 Jn 4:9-10
As you imagine rhe scene o f Jesus on the cross, again try to apply all
your senses. Whac do you sec? W hat do you hear around you? W hat
arc the smells and rasres in your mouth? Wliac does the air feel like?
Now, as you look at Jesus, what do you say? Consider how you fed
about these questions:
Speak whatever is on your m ind and later think about what these
words tell you about yourself.
This imaginative conversation with Jesus crucified is an important
part o f the first workout, for in it we are confronting the reality o f
who we arc before G od. It is the opportunity to honestly assess our
weaknesses, co come co greater awareness o f the parts o f our lives thar
wc must resolve change if we are to grow spiritually. But it is also a
chance to confront Jesus at his weakest momcnr, when (according to
94 WORKOUTS
This meditation naturally leads into the next important rheme; namely,
that we ourselves have contributed to the very evil that led to Jesus*
death. We roo are sinners; we roo have exacerbated the alienation o f
human beings from G od chat Jesus sought to reconcile. Thus, in this
prayer, we ask G od for an awareness o f rhe ways rhat we have helped
cause this rift. We pray for a kind o f catharsis, a state o f sincere sorrow
for all the evil we have done. And so Ignatius counsels that we imagine
a courtroom proceeding, during which the prosecutor gives a record o f
aJI our sins. As we listen to the prosecutor reading off the list o f rhings
we have done wrong througliour our lives, we are to consider what we
truly deserve. W ith these choices, we have slowly tarnished the original
beauty o f G ods good creation o f u$. We have taken a work o f art and
smeared graffiti all over it so that it is no longer beautiful. W e have
made ourselves less than whac we were intended to be.
In light o f this meditation, we can begin to get a different perspec
tive on who we are. Consider the following questions:
We live our lives behind the camera o f our own consciousness, record
ing our experiences from this limited perspective. As the documentary
that is our life unfolds, we encounter difTerent people and things com
ing into the foreground and dropping into the background. Some
retain importance for a time; but later che scene changes, and we arc
somewhere different. Experiences change, bur our perspective remains
che same: we are in charge o f ihe production; we are the center o f chc
world. T his exercise reminds us that ours is not the only show,
though; in face, it isnt even prime-rime material. To us, our lives arc
the most important thing, but what is this to eternity? Consider wh.1 t
Job says to G od after hearing G ods diarribc against Jobs arrogance:
HELL
T hink about what hell means. Avoid simply rehearsing the images
from movies or TV, especially the kind o f horror-movie demons th^t
portray hell almost as somewhere interesting to visit for the thrill o f it.
Instead, consider whar a self-chosen absence from the love o f G od
would be like. Remember that in many places Jesus .speaks o f hell as
the consequence o f a life badly lived; and while the images he uses
were those accessible to a first-ccnrury imagination and might be iim-
iting, it is still possible ro understand something o f what he is exhort
ing people to choose: namely, the love o f (io d over sin.
/ say to you that every one who is angry w ith his brother shall be
liable to ju d p n c n t; whoever insults his brother shall be liable to the
council, a n d whoever says, HYoufio lT shall be liable to the hell o f
fire, (M t 5:22)
Jesus rclls us that hell is real; and while wc can never know who has
chosen i(, still this image reminds us that our life choices have ultimate
consequences. These consequences arc not arbitrary but, rather, due to
our failure to love G od by loving others. As you close this prayer, then,
ask Ciod to give you greater compassion so that you may show mercy to
other people the way that G od has shown mercy to you.
Stage One
Ask G od why you were created this way. How might the works o f
( i d be made manifest in you?
160 WORKOUTS
Stage Two