RESERVED JUDGMENTS / VOORBEHOUE UITSPRAKE

THURSDAY / DONDERDAG, 29 JUNE 2017

1. 26/04/16 Ward v Netbet (Pty) Ltd 9847/15

JUDGMENT: Desai, J

2. 13/06/16 T.L. Mbele v Road Accident Fund 13000/13

JUDGMENT: Desai, J

3. 14/06/16 MI Patel v The Master of the High Court & 2 Others 10550/15
JUDGMENT: McCurdie, AJ

4. 06/09/16 PS Van Zyl N.O. v Keith Getz & 1 Other 18213/09

JUDGMENT: Kose, AJ

5. 28/09/16 Wooding GW & Others v Goudvis RAL & Another 17982/12

JUDGMENT: Schippers, J

6. 30/09/16 K.E. Oelz v M.F. Oelz 6912/13

JUDGMENT: Kose, AJ 21450/14

7. 14/10/16 Lusithi & 3 Others v Cape Lifestyle & 1 Other A511/15

Erasmus, J et Gamble, J et Boqwana, J
JUDGMENT: Erasmus, J

8. 08/11/16 Agricultural Research Council 22891/15

v Leslie Bergh & 5 Others
JUDGMENT: Kose, AJ

9. 09/11/16 Nain & 3 Others v St Clair Cooper & 4 Others 18547/16

JUDGMENT: Desai, J

10. 11/11/16 Abrahams & 2 others v Elegance Estate Bk A295/16

Erasmus, J et McCurdie, AJ
JUDGMENT: McCurdie, AJ

11. 14/11/16 James King N.O. & 5 Others 21972/15

v Cornelius A de Jager & 8 Others
JUDGMENT: Bozalek, J

12. 14/11/16 Immobiliari Trading CC 7705/16

v Golden Circle Investments 123 (Pty) Ltd
JUDGMENT: Desai, J

13. 23/11/16 Daniel Terblanche N.O. & 1 other 9382/16

v Ciriaglo (Pty) Ltd & 9 others
JUDGMENT: Kose, AJ

14. 14/12/16 Shaun Rhoode v City of Cape Town 23341/11

JUDGMENT: Ndita, J
 2

15. 30/01/17 Anathi Ngcukana v The State A443/15

Erasmus, J et Samela, J et Rogers, J
JUDGMENT: Erasmus, J et Samela, J et Rogers, J

16. 01/02/17 Rhynhardt Beck v Bergrivier Municipality A107/16

Yekiso, J et Saldanha, J et Savage, J
JUDGMENT: Saldanha, J

17. 03/02/17 University of Stellenbosch 2788/15

v Master of the High Court & 1 other
JUDGMENT: Desai, J

18. 14/02/17 Dean Aland Prinsloo v Simeon Ivanov Penev & 2 others 14650/12
JUDGMENT: Steyn, J

19. 15/02/17 Iris Fischer & 2 others 297/14

v Unlawful Occupiers 11705/15
JUDGEMENT: Fortuin, J 14422/14
20. 23/02/17 Yellow Star Trading 1154 (Pty) Ltd 711/16
v Minister of Agriculture, Forestry & Fisheries + 1 other
Steyn, J et Dolamo, J
JUDGMENT: Dolamo, J

21. 03/03/17 Dillon Thomas v The State A48/17

Saldanha, J et Sher, AJ et McCurdie, AJ
JUDGMENT: McCurdie, AJ

22. 08/03/17 C.A. Rautenbach v Minister of Safety & Security 7357/12

JUDGMENT: Le Grange, J

23. 13/03/17 Telkom SA SOC Ltd 22032/16

v Residential Estate Dennegeur (Pty) Ltd & 1 other
JUDGMENT: Saldanha, J

24. 21/03/17 A.T. Kasonga 8855/15

v Chairperson of the Standing Committee for
Refugee Affairs & 3 others
JUDGMENT: Yekiso, J

25. 22/03/17 Exdec Supermarket CC v Helshoogte Foods CC 24117/16

JUDGMENT: Van Staden, AJ

26. 27/03/17 Mia M Boon v Health Professions Council of SA & another 6678/16
JUDGMENT: Van Staden, AJ

27. 19/04/17 Viking Inshore Fishing v Minister Agriculture & 28 others 24899/16
Ndita, J et Cloete, J et Magona, AJ
JUDGMENT: Magona, AJ

28. 20/04/17 M. Rautini v Passenger Rail Agency of SA 19132/14

JUDGMENT: McCurdie, AJ
 3

29. 21/04/17 Sehle Matshebe v The State A88/17

Gamble, J et Magona, AJ
JUDGMENT: Magona, AJ

30. 24/04/17 Clidet No. 947 (Pty) Ltd v Ivan Adams & 2 others 21704/15
JUDGEMENT: Kusevitsky, AJ

31. 24/04/17 Construczioni Moncada SA & another 17553/15

v Solar Capital (Pty) Ltd & another
JUDGMENT: Mantame, J

32. 24/04/17 Lambertus Von Wielligh Bester N.O. & 2 others 9772/14
v Albert Pretorius
JUDGMENT: Saldanha, J

33. 25/04/17 Secure Electronics v City of Cape Town 24107/12

JUDGMENT: Kusevitsky, AJ

34. 26/04/17 Deon Johann Pienaar 13665/16

v King Financial Holdings Limited & 7 others
JUDGMENT: Ndita, J

35. 04/05/17 Craig Charles Barley & 1 other v D.K.D. Moore & 1 other 20388/11
JUDGMENT: Dlodlo, J

36. 05/05/17 Zakariya Booi v The State A30/17

Dlodlo, J et Van Staden, AJ et Sher, AJ
JUDGMENT: Sher, AJ
(Awaiting dissenting judgment: Van Staden, AJ)

37. 09/05/17 D.W. Janse Van Rensburg v T.N. Obiang 22470/15

JUDGMENT: Saldanha, J

38. 11/05/17 Paarl Media v Saint-Gobain Isover South Africa & 12 others 2682/12
JUDGMENT: Parker, AJ

39. 12/05/17 Dr. W.J. van Rooyen v Nico Smit A449/16

Le Grange, J et Steyn, J et Papier, AJ
JUDGMENT: Papier, AJ

40. 12/05/17 Zulfa Samsodien & 1 other v E.D. James N.O. & 4 others 7627/17
JUDGMENT: Henney, J

41. 12/05/17 CTICC Company Soc Ltd v Commissioner for SARS VAT 13876
JUDGMENT: Nuku, J

42. 15/05/17 Bush Lapa Offroad Caravans (Pty) Ltd 14438/16

v Jacques Serfontein t/a Jaguar 4x4 Trailers
JUDGMENT: Dlodlo, J

43. 16/05/17 D.H.Harper & 2 others v G.E.Crawford N.O. & 1 other 9581/15
JUDGMENT: Dlodlo, J
 4

44. 19/05/17 M.N. Ebrahim v C. Simonsz 20243/14

Desai, J et Mantame, J et Nuku, J
JUDGMENT: Desai, J

45. 19/05/17 Johannes Lategan v The State A414/15

Dlodlo, J et Sher, AJ
JUDGMENT: Sher, AJ

46. 24/05/17 Harald Escherich v Hjalmar De Waal & 4 others 2912/16

JUDGMENT: Bozalek, J

47. 24/05/17 D.V. Heinrich v A.C. De Cerff 19893/12

JUDGMENT: Magona, AJ

48. 26/05/17 Maud Isaacs v City of Cape Town A93/17

Binns-Ward, J et Mantame, J
JUDGMENT: Mantame, J

49. 29/05/17 J.M.A Louw N.O. & 2 others 5795/16

v Lamolor (Pty) Ltd & 1 other
JUDGMENT: Kusevitsky, AJ

50. 30/05/17 Absa Bank Limited v Tambes Pita CC & 2 others 231/14
JUDGMENT: Samela, J

51. 30/05/17 J. Du Plessis Botha N.O. & 2 others 24611/11

v MEC for Education & 7 others
JUDGMENT: Baartman, J

52. 31/05/17 Brendel Property Developers CC 18610/13

v Stellenbosch Municipality
JUDGMENT: Nuku, J

53. 31/05/17 Propell Specialised Finance (Pty) Ltd 16864/12

v Attorneys Insurance Indemnity Fund NPC & 3 others
JUDGMENT: Dlodlo, J

54. 01/06/17 Jacqueline Folley 15559/09

v Pick n Pay Retailers (Pty) Limited & another
JUDGMENT: Boqwana, J

55. 02/06/17 H.R. Pettenburger-Perwalt v Nicolette Vosloo & 9 others A113/17

Ndita, J et Holderness, AJ
JUDGMENT: Ndita, J

56. 05/06/17 Skycape Investment 110 CC 973/17

v Living Africa (Pty) Ltd & 2 others
JUDGMENT: Ndita, J

57. 05/06/17 J.W. Petersen & 1 other 7884/16

v Standard Bank of SA & 1 other
JUDGMENT: Samela, J
 5

58. 07/06/17 J.A. Pretorius v Dani G Truter Wines CC & another 2880/17
JUDGMENT: Holderness, AJ

59. 07/06/17 National Director of Public Prosecutions 6959/15

v A.G. Ivanov & 1 other
JUDGMENT: Cloete, J

60. 08/06/17 Simon Woolley N.O. & 1 other 5873/17

v The Body Corporate of Sectional Plan No. SS454/2008
in the Scheme known as Cape Royale & 2 others
JUDGMENT: Dlodlo, J

61. 08/06/17 Sechaba Protection Services WC Ltd & 1 other 17596/14

v City of Cape Town & 32 others
JUDGMENT: Samela, J

62. 09/06/17 James Sithole v Patrick Jacobs & 1 other A125/17

Dlodlo, J et Golden, AJ
JUDGMENT: Golden, AJ

63. 09/06/17 Pamela Brodgen 22778/16

v Commissioner Michael Edmunds & another
Ndita, J et Papier, AJ
JUDGMENT: Papier, AJ

64. 12/06/17 Hernn Sebastien Baumann & 5 others 845/05

v Tabea Jacobs & 2 others
JUDGMENT: Le Grange, J

65. 13/06/17 Drakenstein Municipality v Eric Ndecasi & others 3814/17

JUDGMENT: Dlodlo, J

66. 14/06/17 Cesar Alexandre 19960/08

v Milnerton Informal Traders Association & 2 others
JUDGMENT: Samela, J

67. 14/06/17 M. Jacobs v H.G. Moses & 4 others 3526/17

JUDGMENT: Golden, AJ

68. 14/06/17 City of Cape Town 22181/12

v Zulmeira Fedelia Stoffberg N.O. & 5 others
Ndita, J et Holderness, AJ
JUDGMENT: Holderness, AJ

69. 15/06/17 Pamela Gail Stacey v Supercare Services Group (Pty) Ltd 4515/14
JUDGMENT: Savage, J

70. 15/06/17 Phumeza Mlungwana & 9 others v The State 13665/16

Ndita, J et Magona, AJ
JUDGMENT: Ndita, J
 6

71. 19/06/17 Artur FP Dias v Marina Petropolus & others 22639/09

JUDGMENT: Bozalek, J

72. 19/06/17 IT14036

JUDGMENT: Dlodlo, J

73. 20/06/17 Ndumiso Dlayedwa & 14 others 5045/16

v Lewis Stores (Pty) Ltd & 1 other 2823/16
JUDGMENT: Dlodlo, J

74. 21/06/17 Giancarlo De Filippo v Alessandra Micillo & 3 others 23724/16

JUDGMENT: Golden, AJ

75. 21/06/17 Huguenot College v Octofin (Pty) Ltd 17084/10

JUDGMENT: Yekiso, J

76. 21/06/17 Nicolene Jones 15364/16

v
Member of the Executive Council (Health) WC Provincial Government
JUDGMENT: Henney, J

77. 22/06/17 Martiens Malan

v Minister for Safety & Security and Another 22484/14
Ndita, J et Holderness, AJ
JUDGMENT: Holderness, AJ

78. 22/06/17 Peter Dayton Hodgkinson 10019/13

v K2011104122 (Pty) Ltd & 1 other
JUDGMENT: Samela, J

79. 23/06/17 Ockert Johannes Stephanus Fourie v The State A160/17

Savage, J et Golden, AJ
JUDGMENT: Savage, J

80. 23/06/17 The State v Andries Petrus Retief A483/15

Le Grange, J et Weinkove, AJ
JUDGMENT: Le Grange, J et Weinkove, AJ

81. 27/06/17 A.E. Lincoln v Minister of Justice & 1 other 17967/12

JUDGMENT: Cloete, J

82. 27/06/17 A.D. Maher N.O. obo Justin Kennedy 21385/15

v Road Accident Fund & Smith Tabata Buchanan Boys Inc.
JUDGMENT: Parker, AJ

83. 28/06/17 Mwajuma Ekachi 22970/16

v Standing Committee for Refugee Affairs & 4 others
JUDGMENT: Golden, AJ

84. 28/06/17 South African Securitisation & 2 others 2233/17

v Eisenberg de Saude
JUDGMENT: Parker, AJ
29 June 2017