Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ce1999 Cairo Metro
Ce1999 Cairo Metro
Ce1999 Cairo Metro
Engrs,
Civ. Engng, 1999,
A. Madkour, M. A. Hudson, BSc, CEng, MICE and A. Bellarosa 132, May/August,
103-117
A new 30 km underground railway line is being built in the heart of Cairo,
one of the worlds largest and fastest growing cities. Cairo Metro Line 2 will Paper 11668
link the pyramids of Giza on the west bank of the Nile to central and north- Written discussion closes
ern Cairo on the opposite bank when completed in 2001. This paper briefly 15 November 1999
describes the methodology used for construction of the 18 stations, tunnels
and workshop which make up this US$2 billion projectincluding the first Keywords: transport
ever tunnel under the Nile. A number of innovative solutions were devel- planning; rail & bus
oped to solve the problem of water leakage during construction. stations
Cairo is one of the largest cities in the Middle East trically powered vehicles with a catenary system.
and the population reflects Egypts ancient cultural To complete Line 1, these independent railways
heritage and diverse society. Egypt has been called were connected by cut-and-cover tunnels with
the mother of the world and has a recorded histo- underground station construction in the centre of
ry, over five millennia, of large public works pro- the city, and power was supplied to the vehicles by
jects. The pyramids are renowned as one of the a full catenary system.
seven wonders of the ancient world and varying The number of passengers using Line 1 has con-
forms of pyramid stretch along the west bank of the stantly increased and 1995 studies recorded that
Nile from Cairo as far as Nubia in northern Sudan. the Line 1 passenger count was 328 million passen-
Many other monuments from early periods of histo- gers a year with an estimated passenger count of
ry remain and artefacts continue to be found. 530 million passengers a year anticipated for the
Relatively more recent historical monuments in combined Line 1 and Line 2 operations by the year
Cairo include the churches on the route taken by 2000. Line 1 operational expenditure including
Mary, Joseph and Jesus on the flight to Egypt, the depreciation in 1994/95 was greater than revenue A. Madkour works
citadel of Saladin and the Khan El Khalili, an from Line 1 operations by a factor of approximately for the National
ancient souk which is still in use. two, resulting in a deficit which continues to be Authority for Tunnels
Greater Cairos population is rapidly increasing borne by the Egyptian Government. Ticket prices in Egypt
and is expected to exceed 239 million in the year today cost an average of 50 piastres for a single
2012. The present population is now estimated at 18 journey (0.10) and the main expenditure is for the
million and is densely packed into a city, forced by cost of depreciation of assets.
the surrounding topography to expand along the The newest line (Line 2) also lies along the citys
Nile River banks. Before completion of the Aswan north/south corridor but for the first time connects
dams, the Nile River cut high escarpments into the the east and west banks of the Nile in bored tunnel.
sandstone underlying the alluvial sands and these The successful tenderer for the underground
have acted as barriers to the expansion of the city. civil work construction for the first phase of Line 2
The urban transportation corridors therefore follow was a joint venture of French and local contractors
a north/south corridor in order to reach the cen- led by Campenon Bernard (SGE) France. However,
tres of highest population density. a separate local contract was provided for the civil
works for the at-grade and elevated sections in the Malcolm Hudson
Greater Cairos metro network was principally
first phase. The project consultant selected by the works for Parsons
planned to increase the mobility of the people of
client for the design review and construction ser- Brinkerhoff Europe
Cairo and, in addition, to improve population mobili-
ty. The metro was also planned to reduce the vices was a joint venture of international and local
growth in private car ownership. However, car consultants formed under the title of Greater Cairo
growth has rapidly exceeded earlier estimates in Metro Consultants (GCMC) and led by Parsons
parallel with the economic growth recently experi- Brinckerhoff, USA.
enced by Egypt. Construction of Line 2 commenced on 12 June
Construction of the first metro line was complet- 1993 and operational testing of the first section,
ed in the 1980s. This line upgraded two existing phase 1A, was scheduled to start 40 months later
suburban railway lines to metro standards. The city, and phase 1B in the following year. Phase 1A and
prior to 1980, had an existing north/south subur- phase 1B have both met these targets.
ban railway line to the north of the city and a simi- The next phase (phase 2A) of metro construction
lar line to the south separated by the city centre. on the west bank of the Nile is also complete. The Aldo Bellaros works
The north line was operated using diesel locomo- lessons learned on the first phase have been inte- for Estp/Chebap
tives while the south line was operated using elec- grated into the project management system to the Eiffage in France
103
MADKOUR, HUDSON
AND BELLAROSA
St Thereza
Description of Line 2
Rodel Farag
Fig.1 shows the two existing north/south lines
Imbaba
Massara
with station locations and the proposed new Line 3
which connects the area of highest population den-
Mubarak
sity through the centre of the city to the airport in
Giza Sadat
Attaba the north. Line 2, the line now under partial opera-
Gezira Abdeen
Behoos
tion and construction, commences at grade as
Cairo University phase 1A in the north of Cairo at Shubra El Kheima
Giza Square Cairo and enters the underground section of the line
Giza Station north of Mazallat Station and continues under-
Giza Suburban ground, south to Mubarak Station in the city centre
(Fig.2). Phase 1A also includes the workshop.
The next section, phase 1B, is situated in the city
Line 1 (42.5 km) centre and is totally underground between the two
Line 2 (30.5 km)
interchange stations (Mubarak and Sadat Stations )
Proposed Line 3 (30.0 km)
completed during Line 1 construction.
Phase 2A connects from the existing Line 1 Sadat
Ri
Contract programme
The contract duration and phasing of completion
of the workshop buildings, from start of detailed
design to final handing over for operation, were
Helwan
based on train deliveries, storage requirements,
0
Phase 1A Phase 1B
Cut-and-cover tunnel
River Nile
Cairo
Sadat Gezira TBM University
+20 (West) (Opera) Dokki Behoos shaft Bored tunnel 0 Scale of km 2
0 Stations
Phase 2A
104
CAIRO METRO LINE 2
Phase Start End Number Bored tunnel Cut and Phase total
station name station name of stations length: m cover tunnel length: km
U: underground length: m
A: at grade
E: elevated
Workshop
Stage 1 27 0 In operation
Stage 2 36 0 In operation
Stage 3 48 0 In operation
Phase 1A 36 3 In operation
Phase 1B 48 3 In operation
Phase 2B 35 2 In progress
training, testing and maintenance requirements in drainage pipes and a lower aquifer confined within
advance of the train trial running dates. the sand deposit beneath the silty clay/clayey silt
The contract durations for phases 1 and 2 are layer. Piezometric pressures in the confined aquifer
shown in Table 2. At the completion of each phase are generally about 34 m pressure head less than
a short experimental working period (EWP) was ground level and generally are affected by Nile
carried out to ensure integration of all systems River water levels.
including train running, safety of the line and also
to provide for a training period for operations staff. Construction methodology
The later phases of the project necessitated com- Safety
plex staging requirements at terminal stations The contractor was required under the terms of
where the operating line was extended to the new the contract to submit its overall health and safety
line. Wherever possible the operations complexity procedure for the works during the initial stage of
was minimized by commencing line operation on construction. The initial procedure included a work
short completed sections of the new phase in breakdown analysis and this was used to assess the
advance of its total length. types of work expected for each site and to identify,
for areas of risk, detailed procedures that needed to
Geology be submitted. It also proposed safety staffing levels
Line 2 soil profile consists of man-made fill, silty required for these areas and also for the whole of
clay/clayey silt, interbedded clay silt, and sand and the works. The safety staffing levels were also
alluvial sands. The soil profile under the main based on the anticipated numbers of workers per
branch of the Nile is shown in Fig. 3.1 The ground- month at each site including back-up sites, laborato-
water regime comprises a perched aquifer ries, batching plants and at the off-site production
recharged by leaking city water supply pipes and factories.
105
MADKOUR, HUDSON
AND BELLAROSA
+20
yyyyyyyyyyy
@@@@@@@@@@@
,,,,,,,,,,,
y,@,,
yy
@@
+10 Gezira
Station
@@@@@@@@@@@
,,,,,,,,,,,
yyyyyyyyyyyy,@
Station
Bored tunnel To Dokki
-10
Station
@@
,,
yy
-20
-30
@@
,,
yy
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
Scale of m
Fill Clay Micaceous Silty Sand Sand Gravel
Specific authorities were defined for all staff on Only when the safety management were satisfied
the project and the safety officer was authorized to with the proposals were the procedures issued to
issue instructions to stop the works if any safety the client for approval. By using this system and
violations were observed. In addition, safety train- dramatically increasing site training, the accident
ing and reporting requirements were defined, site frequency subsequently reduced. Accident statistics
medical facilities including site ambulance provision for the project are shown in Fig. 4.
stated and the locations and telephone numbers of
hospitals and other emergency services given. A Environmental considerations
site safety manual was also developed and was Due to Cairos size and rapidly increasing popula-
issued in Arabic to each worker on first arrival on tion, severe problems are faced in provision of
the site. amenities for the population. Environmental consid-
After agreements of the overall procedure, specif- erations have, until only recently, been subservient
ic procedures were developed for activities such as to the achievement of economic growth. In the last
tunnelling, diaphragm walling, tower cranes, exca- 20 years, however, major projects providing
vation and strutting installation and removal. In improvements in water quality and sewerage treat-
addition, as the works progressed, new procedures ment have been carried out and larger sections of
were developed to accommodate changes in the the population now have these amenities.
working methods. In addition to restrictions on discharge of water
In the initial stages of the work, the incidence of from construction sites, with discharge of untreated
accidents was statistically significant and, regret- water to the Nile strictly prohibited, there are restric-
tably, the gravity rate increased. This is considered tions on heavy vehicle access to the greater Cairo
to have occured due to a lack of familiarity of the area. Dumping of waste such as building debris and
site labour force with the new methods adopted on excavation materials, however, is largely dependent
the project. The metro accident rates cannot, how- on private disposal services as the city services are
ever, be directly compared with accident rates in extremely limited.
other countries due to differences in working prac- Air pollution is, however, now attracting attention
tices in Egypt. and studies are proposed to identify sources and
As the project work load increased and the recommend solutions to improve the air quality in
gravity rate increased, attention to safety stan- Cairo. One action now being made is a reduction in
dards was reinforced by the contractor, the con- the number of petrol-powered vehicles on the
sultant and the client and maximum emphasis roads. This involves changing all taxis from petrol
was placed on ensuring that all activities were engines to natural gas with resultant lowering in
carried out in the safest possible manner. To this polluting emissions.
end the contractor ensured that, not only specific
health and safety procedures were prepared, but Works areas
also all site procedures and method statements The works areas provided to the contractor
were developed specifically on the basis of safe required closure of main city thoroughfares and
methods of working. The contractors safety man- diversion of traffic onto other routes. At each sta-
agement, to ensure that the risk of injur y to the tion site, wherever possible, the full width of the
work force was minimized, assessed the proce- street was closed to traffic and occupied by the con-
dures prior to issue. tractor. This allowed the contractor to complete the
106
CAIRO METRO LINE 2
15
Rate
10 Average
5
By month
0
Jan-94
Apr-94
Jul-94
Oct-94
Jan-95
Apr-95
Jul-95
Oct-95
Jan-96
Apr-96
Jul-96
Oct-96
Jan-97
Apr-97
Jul-97
Oct-97
Jan-98
Apr-98
Months
30 Frequency rate
25
20
Frequency
15
Average
10
5 By month
0
Jan-94
Apr-94
Jul-94
Oct-94
Jan-95
Apr-95
Jul-95
Oct-95
Jan-96
Apr-96
Jul-96
Oct-96
Jan-97
Apr-97
Jul-97
Oct-97
Jan-98
Apr-98
Months
.45
Gravity rate
.40
.35
.30
.25 Average
Gravity
.20
.15
.10 By month
.05
.00
Jan-94
Mar-94
May-94
Jul-94
Sep-94
Nov-94
Jan-95
Mar-95
May-95
Jul-95
Sep-95
Nov-95
Jan-96
Mar-96
May-96
Jul-96
Sep-96
Nov-96
Jan-97
Mar-97
May-97
Jul-97
Sep-97
Nov-97
Jan-98
Mar-98
Months
station roof slab, avoiding the time and cost associ- Utilities
ated with provision of numerous variations in the In general, all utilities were diverted prior to con-
traffic pattern. Immediately after the roof slabs struction commencement; however, where large
were completed some limited traffic provision was utilities, such as 220 kV cables and large diameter
made along or across the site to improve the situa- sewers and water pipes, could not be diverted spe-
tion for the local residents. cial excavation techniques were used where these
As the civil works ended and the finishing works crossed the cut-and-cover tunnel works. At all sta-
commenced the works areas were gradually tions except Rod El Farag Station all major utilities
opened again to traffic, usually by provision, initial- over the main station boxes were diverted and
ly, of one full lane in each direction which reduced excavation was therefore unobstructed allowing
the period of total road closure. efficiency of construction.
107
MADKOUR, HUDSON
AND BELLAROSA
Connection
to Egyptian 24
Railways
16 12
17
20 19 3
1
22 28 13
Local contractor buildings 11
1. Office building 2
2. Office and technical building
3. Maneouvre cabin 14 27
4. Office and technical building 21
5. Training centre 14
6. Control and security offices 4
16
7. Maintenance dept workshop and storage 15
8. Maintenance dept office 15
9. Dangerous goods store
10. Water tank
11. Sewerage pump room 9 5
11
Fig. 6. Workshop
panorama
108
CAIRO METRO LINE 2
Cut-off walls
Long section
To Dokki To Cairo
University
0 Scale of m 25
Fig. 8. Behoos Station
cross section
Stations
The primary function of the stations during the
civil works construction stage was to permit the
unobstructed passage of the tunnel boring machine
(TBM) through the stations. The main station Soft gel plug
boxes are generally rectangular in plan and were
standardized within the limits of the right of way. Toe level
-25.5
This standardization led to the use of the same con- 0 Scale of m 10
struction methods throughout the project and pro-
moted efficient use of construction resources.
109
MADKOUR, HUDSON
AND BELLAROSA
The station boxes have excavation depths vary- ered economic to improve the strength of the soil
ing from 1523 m and have accesses and airshafts and therefore reduce the depth of the walls.
attached to the main box. See Figs 7 and 8 for In addition to diaphragm walls, bentonite/cement
Behoos Station layout. The platform length is 144 slurry walls were constructed to divide the stations
m and is designed to accommodate an eight-car into smaller boxes to allow sectioning of the excava-
train. tion process. For more detailed explanations of the
The stations are designed to be fully watertight construction techniques adopted see references 3
and this specification required the use of reinforced and 4.
concrete diaphragm walls (of up to 12 m width) The station raft slab was designed to act as a sim-
incorporating CWS stop-end joints.2 Fig. 9 shows a ply supported beam/strut. Horizontal loads were
completed station at platform level (Attaba Station). transmitted into the walls in bearing, but vertical
The design of the diaphragm wall was based pri- ground water loads were directed into a line of cor-
marily on the loading applied during the construc- bels connected by couplers to the diaphragm wall.
tion stage. The depth of the diaphragm walls was The permanent structure construction sequence
also based on provision of a soft gel plug by injec- finally adopted was as follows
tion through tube-a-manchettes to limit water inflow
through the sand and avoid excavation instability. complete the roof slab
The soft gel plug was considered to impart no complete the ticket slab at the station ends
strength to the sand, therefore, the toe level of the complete the technical slab
diaphragm walls was controlled by the need to install two layers of strutting
maintain the maximum safe economic weight of cast the first stage raft slab
soil above the plug. complete the break in and break out slurry
The design of the diaphragm wall section was walls and grouting
also based on minimizing settlements caused by demolish the station concrete ends (tympan)
wall deflections where excavation was carried out for TBM transit.
Fig. 9. Attaba Station close to other structures. In a number of locations,
platform level hard gel plugs were provided where it was consid- TBM transit through the station however post-
110
CAIRO METRO LINE 2
111
MADKOUR, HUDSON
AND BELLAROSA
Cut-and-cover tunnels
The cut-and-cover tunnels were constructed in
the same manner as the stations and to the same
watertightness criteria except that the diaphragm
wall retaining structure was used only for tempo-
rary ground support. Inside the diaphragm walls an
arched tunnel structure of cast in-situ reinforced
concrete was placed against and surrounded by a
waterproofing membrane (Fig 11). In the transition
zone between the at-grade and covered tunnel the
Stage 1 Stage 2 Stage 3
Diaphragm walling Plug injection Excavation/strutting permanent retaining structure was the diaphragm
Pump testing Waterproofing wall connected directly to the raft and roof slabs of
Base slab
the tunnel. Again to assist excavation and improve
watertightness control, slurry walls were construct-
ed to divide the tunnels into sections.
Bored tunnels
The tunnel lining comprises seven segments and
a key, with the key introduced longitudinally to com-
plete the ring. This therefore required an overlength
on the TBM shoving jacks of 05 m. The lining is
tapered with a nominal segment length of 15 m and
112
CAIRO METRO LINE 2
113
MADKOUR, HUDSON
AND BELLAROSA
114
CAIRO METRO LINE 2
below ground level. Where these extended to the toe Fig. 16. Part section
of the column or connected to the outside of the treat- through tunnel lining
Excavated surface
ed mass, leakage paths caused erosion and cavities at circumferential
with the danger of soil collapse to the surface. joint
After some trial and error the final solution adopt-
ed was an unreinforced cement/bentonite slurry
walled box with an impermeable chemically grouted Tail void grout
hard gel base plug beneath the ground treatment, Hydrophylic seal
but still provided with a jet grout mass (Fig 15).
Elastomeric gasket
Quality control
The civil works specifications were based on
European and Egyptian standards. The quantities
of materials used were significant: almost 1500 km
of drilling for grout injection, 350 000 m2 of
diaphragm walls and 300 000 m3 of concrete. The
Segment
completed works including watertightness require- Waterproof concrete
ments, despite the speed of construction, complied
Groove
with the specification requirements. for Inner face
The bored tunnels, in every instance, complied caulking of lining
with the specification and there were no leaks or
dampness observed on the tunnel linings and
joints. Details of the lining joint showing the instal- at the raft/diaphragm wall connections.
lation of the Phoenix gasket and hydrophilic seal
are shown in Fig 16. At the time of completion of the phase 1 stations
Leakage, though small, was observed in the sta- the leakage was significantly reduced and the volume
tions during excavation but the extent of leakage could not be accurately measured as other sources of
was controlled by injecting either a hydrophilic water (i.e. washing) in the stations were in excess of
acrylic resin grout into the joints in the diaphragm the volumes which could be attributed to structure
wall structure or by structural repair. The locations leaks. In any event, the contract called for only two
of points of leakage were predominantly criteria for watertightness for the stations.
The first criterion, class 1, is for the diaphragm
leaks at the diaphragm wall joints walls and structure and this required the structure
around the tunnel linings at the station connec- to be completely dry; that is, no trace of moisture.
tions The second, class 2, is for diaphragm wall joints
115
MADKOUR, HUDSON
AND BELLAROSA
Sept
Sept
Sept
Sept
May
May
May
May
Nov
Nov
Nov
Nov
Aug
Dec
Aug
Dec
Aug
Dec
Aug
Dec
Mar
Mar
Mar
Mar
Feb
Feb
Feb
Feb
Jun
Jun
Jun
Oct
Jan
Oct
Jan
Oct
Jan
Oct
Jan
Apr
Apr
Apr
Apr
Jul
Jul
Jul
absorption was permitted on blotting paper laid on
Phase 1A 1
Sept
May
May
Nov
Nov
Aug
Dec
Aug
Dec
Mar
Mar
Mar
Feb
Feb
Feb
Jun
Jun
Jan
Oct
Jan
Oct
Jan
Apr
Apr
Jul
Access /Airshafts 11
Conclusion
The successful completion of the first phase of
Architectural works 12
Line 2 was due, in large measure, to decisive pro-
13 ject management by the National Authority of
116
CAIRO METRO LINE 2
Parsons Brinckerhoff (USA) lead Campenon Bernard SGE (France)lead Cogifer Entreprise (France)lead
Electrowatt (Switzerland) Arab Contractors (Egypt) Orascom (Egypt)
Sabbour Associates (Egypt) Dumez-GTM (France)
Spie Batignolles T.P. (France)
Bouygues (France)
Dragages Et Travaux Publics (France)
Eiffage (France)
GTM International (France)
Soletanche Bachy (France)
Intertectra-BTP (France)
117