International Journal of Recent Advances in Mechanical Engineering (IJMECH)

ISSN : 2200-5854
http://wireilla.com/engg/ijmech/index.html

PAPER REVIEW

MANUFACTURING AND MECHANICAL CHARACTERIZATION OF AL-SIC FUNCTIONALLY

Chapter Title:
GRADED MATERIAL
Authors: Siva Surya, Sridhar Atla, and Kondal Reddy Patlolla

NOTE: Please put X to show your selection

Type of this paper
Research Survey Tutorial Speculative Others

Your Choice X

Evaluation:
Very Poor Poor Average Good Very Good

Significance of the main idea(s) X

Originality X

Technical quality of the paper X

Awareness of related work X

Clarity of presentation X

Organization of the manuscript X

References X

Paper Length X

How comfortable are you in reviewing this paper?

Very Confident Confident Adequate Not Confident Not my Area

Your Choice X
 International Journal of Recent Advances in Mechanical Engineering (IJMECH)
ISSN : 2200-5854
http://wireilla.com/engg/ijmech/index.html

Overall comments and changes that MUST be made before publication:

Please review text repeated that could be found in many parts of text.
Review and rewrite portions of the text in an impersonal way.
Figures and Tables: lack of call in the text, sequence of figures are wrong, some figures need to be
improved (figure 5 and 4.4 as example) and make corrections in description of tables (hardness)
indicating the hardness parameter used please verify and review.
Some minor errors of typing please review all text.

Suggestions which would improve the quality of the paper but are NOT essential for publication:
None

Overall Recommendation:
Strongly Reject Reject Marginally Accept Accept Strongly Accept

Recommendation X