Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Effect of Cavity Design On Tooth Surface Strain - Jefferson Ricardo
Effect of Cavity Design On Tooth Surface Strain - Jefferson Ricardo
Effect of Cavity Design On Tooth Surface Strain - Jefferson Ricardo
surface strain
Jefferson Ricardo Pereira, DDS, MSc, PhD,a
Ailbhe McDonald, BDentSc, MSc, PhD,b Aviva Petrie, MSc, PhD,c
and Jonathan Campbell Knowles, DDS, MSc, PhDd
UCL Eastman Dental Institute and School of Dentistry, University of
Southern Santa Catarina (UNISUL), Tubaro, Brazil; Unit of Biosta-
tistics, UCL Eastman Dental Institute, London, England; Dankook
University Graduate School, Gyeonggi-do, South Korea
Statement of problem. The loss of tooth structure can increase cuspal exure, thereby reducing the fracture resistance of the
tooth, or open the tooth-restoration interface, leading to microleakage.
Purpose. The purpose of this study was to evaluate tooth strain in teeth with different cavity preparations after loading and
unloading.
Material and methods. Ten intact human maxillary premolars were selected and embedded in epoxy resin molds. Constantan
strain gauges were used and tested as an intact tooth (group I), occlusal cavity (group O), mesio-occlusal cavity (group MO),
and nally mesio-occluso-distal cavity (group MOD). All teeth were subjected to gradual nondestructive occlusal loading and
unloading (50 N, 70 N, 90 N, 110 N, 130 N, 50 N, 0 N) in a servohydraulic testing machine. All data were analyzed
statistically by performing a repeated measures ANOVA with load and cavity as factors to compare the relevant mean strains,
and a Bonferroni post hoc test was performed for multiple comparisons (a.05).
Results. The repeated measures ANOVA did not provide any evidence of an interaction between load and cavity but indicated
a signicant difference in the mean strains both between the loads (P<.001) and between the cavity groups (P<.001).
Conclusions. MOD cavities presented statistically signicantly higher values of strain than MO, O, or intact teeth, and a
signicant increase in the values of mean strain for all cavities was observed, even with intact teeth, when nondestructive
occlusal loading was increased. (J Prosthet Dent 2013;110:369-375)
Clinical implications
In restorative dentistry, the deformation of teeth by occlusal load is
important. The increased loss of tooth structure can increase cuspal
exure, thereby reducing the fracture resistance of the tooth, or open the
restoration-tooth interface, leading to microleakage and ultimately to
recurrent caries.
Traditional operative dentistry has modern cavity shape is dictated by the requirements. The tooth preparation
involved the removal of carious tissue carious lesion, the removal of tooth is followed by placement of restorative
and the restoration of the cavity. The structure at risk of fracture, and esthetic materials to achieve a functional,
a
Senior Lecturer, Division of Biomaterials and Tissue Engineering, UCL Eastman Dental Institute and School of Dentistry, University of
Southern Santa Catarina-UNISUL.
b
Senior Lecturer, Unit of Prosthodontics, UCL Eastman Dental Institute.
c
Senior Lecturer, Unit of Biostatistics, UCL Eastman Dental Institute.
d
Professor, Division of Biomaterials and Tissue Engineering, UCL Eastman Dental Institute and Department of Nanobiomedical Science &
WCU Research Center, Dankook University Graduate School.
Pereira et al
370 Volume 110 Issue 5
biologic, and esthetic outcome. protection are at a higher risk of frac- All specimens were embedded in
Restorative materials should be of turing than those with cuspal coverage, clear epoxy resin (Specix-20; Struers
appropriate width and pulpal depth to frequently with unpredictable conse- Ltd) and handled according to the
ensure sufcient strength. An important quences.2,5 The inuence of marginal manufacturers recommendations.
consideration when restoring a tooth is ridge removal and the depth and Three millimeters of the roots was left
the quantity and quality of the width of cavities continues to be under exposed below the cement-enamel
remaining dentin, which, together with debate, but the anatomy of the junction, simulating the alveolar bone
occlusal forces, may determine the tooth probably plays an important level. The teeth were embedded in
subsequent potential for fracture.1-5 role.24,27-29 This is of particular impor- molds (2.5 cm in height), ensuring that
Cusps deect when stressed because tance for teeth in the posterior region each root was positioned centrally with
of the interocclusal relationships and (for example, maxillary premolars) the long axis of the tooth aligned par-
anatomy of posterior teeth. Although because their anatomy favors deection allel to the mold walls. The acrylic resin
healthy teeth normally withstand of the cusp and fracture under masti- was allowed to polymerize for 24 hours
masticatory loads and rarely fail, cuspal catory forces.2,7 at room temperature, the mold was
fracture may occur in teeth that have The purpose of this study was to opened, and the acrylic resin trimmed
been weakened by cavity preparation evaluate tooth strain in teeth with such that its base was orthogonal to
and caries.1-6 Several studies have different cavity preparations after the long axis and parallel to a small
shown that as the cavity width and cyclical loading. The null hypothesis attened area on the occlusal surface of
depth increases during cavity prepara- was that no difference would be found the tooth. These areas were attened
tion, the tooth strength decreases.2,7-11 in mean strain in teeth of different with a cylindrical, round-edged, coarse
Others8,12-18 have observed a correla- cavity size and design. diamond rotary instrument (Two
tion between the cuspal fracture of the Striper, Abrasive Technology; Myerson
restored teeth, tooth morphology, and MATERIAL AND METHODS Ltd), and then a ne grit diamond ro-
cavity parameters. The loss of tooth tary instrument (no. 585.8VF KS-2, ISO
tissue reduces the force required to The research project was reviewed shape 146 with a grit size of 45 mm;
strain and subsequently fracture the and approved by the research ethics Myerson Ltd), both with water spray.
teeth in vitro, with the pattern of loss committee, NRES Committee, Ben- The mounted teeth were kept in a
inuencing the magnitude of the tham, London (REC reference 11/LO/ hydrated state throughout.
induced strain.2,4,19 0939). Consent was obtained from Strain gauges (Constantan; Mea-
The resistance to fracture of restored patients undergoing routine tooth ex- surements Group UK Ltd) were used
teeth is lower than sound teeth.4 One tractions for orthodontic and peri- with attached copper leads, a resistance
study showed that 92% of fractured teeth odontal reasons. Ten intact human of 120U (type EA-06-062AP-120, op-
had previously undergone restoration.20 maxillary premolars with approximately tion LE), and a gauge factor of 2.05.
The presence of wide and/or deep res- the same coronal dimensions (8 mm in The polyimide backing of the gauges
torations may confer the highest risk of height, 7 mm in mesiodistal width, and was trimmed to a 1-mm border around
tooth fracture.21 In addition, even if 9 mm in buccopalatal width) were the gauges to optimize positioning on
fracture does not occur, the deection of selected from 23 recently extracted the tooth surface. The gauges were then
a weakened or compromised cusp may premolars. Each tooth was microscop- bonded to the cervicobuccal tooth
open the interface between the tooth ically examined to ensure the absence surface with a thin layer of cyanoacry-
and restoration and lead to micro- of microfractures, cracks, or carious late adhesive (M-Bond 200 Adhesive;
leakage and eventually to recurrent lesions. The teeth were planed with Measurements Group UK Ltd) so that
caries. This may in turn predispose the periodontal curettes (Gracey Curette; the top edge of the backing was
tooth to fracture.22-24 Hu-Friedy Mfg) and intermittent water approximately 1 mm below the at-
In an unrestored tooth, the stresses irrigation and were stored in distilled tened area of the occlusal surface and
are mainly compressive in response to water at a temperature of 37 C until vertically aligned along the long axis of
an axially applied compressive load, but use. The sample size of 10 premolars in the tooth. A control tooth received a
in a model with a deep and wide cavity each group was based on a power dummy gauge and was subjected to the
preparation, tensile stresses occur at analysis. The sample size provided an same environmental conditions but
the pulpal wall.25 This change in the 80% power at the 5% level of signi- without loading.
stress type, from compression to ten- cance to detect a difference of 1120 me The teeth were wrapped in damp
sion, could increase the risk of fracture between the intact tooth and the gauze within a sealed polyethylene bag
in teeth with deep and wide cavity mesio-occluso-distal (MOD) cavity at a until ready for testing. Before the test, a
preparations.8,12-18,25,26 load of 130 N with a 2-sample t test length of shielded twin cable (RS
Severely compromised teeth that and assuming a standard deviation of Components Ltd) was soldered to
have been restored without cuspal 800 in each group. the copper leads on an electronics
The Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry Pereira et al
November 2013 371
prototyping board (Double Side PHT; group O, the dimensions of cavities
Veroboard), and to ensure function- were 3 mm in height for mesial, distal,
ality, the gauge resistance was checked. palatal, and buccal walls, 3.5 mm in A
The bridge circuit was balanced to a width for buccopalatal walls, and 3 C
baseline value and output logging mm in length for mesiodistal walls B
commenced; 20 seconds after this, the (Fig. 1). The dimensions of MO cav-
calibration resistor was switched into ities and MOD cavities (groups MO
the circuit for a further period of 20 and MOD) were the same for the
seconds, and the transducer was occlusal cavities except for a 4.5-mm
adjusted to record a second baseline height of the buccopalatal walls in
value. After this, the loading test began. the box (Figs. 2, 3). The gingival oor
The periods of time used were selected was kept above the cementoenamel
to enable adequate sampling. junction.
The block of acrylic resin containing All teeth were subjected to gradual
the test specimen was kept in a brass nondestructive occlusal loading and
receptacle within a servohydraulic then unloading30 (50 N, 70 N, 90 N,
testing machine (Dartec Ltd) with a 1.0 110 N, 130 N, 50 N, 0 N). Each period
kN load cell in the loading ram. The of load consisted of 3 stages: loading
force was applied to the center of the from 0 N to 50 N (the preload) (50
1 Occlusal cavity (A3.0 mm,
access preparation with a 2.5-mm- before); increasing loading from 50 N,
B3.5 mm, C3.0 mm).
diameter ball bearing. The brass 70 N, 90 N, 110 N and 130 N,
receptacle position was adjusted to unloading down to 50 N (50 after); and
place the loading ram over the center of unloading from 50 N to 0 N (after).
the cavity preparation and remained in The duration of each loading cycle was
this same position during all testing 25 seconds. The preload was set at the B
procedures. start of each period of loading by pro-
The tooth was mounted in the ser- gramming the test machine; the subse- C
vohydraulic testing machine and tested quent loading phase was controlled by
as an intact tooth, and without removal the testing machines software (Work- A
from the servohydraulic testing ma- shop 96, Dartec HC10; Zwick Ltd),
chine, the occlusal cavity was then programmed with the appropriate pa-
prepared and the tooth tested again; rameters. The data were recorded at the
this sequence was repeated for the end of the loading period. 2 MO cavity (A3.0 mm,
mesio-occlusal (MO) cavity and nally The results were converted from text B3.0 mm, C4.5 mm).
the MOD cavity. This sequential exten- to Microsoft Excel les (Microsoft
sion of the cavity was carried out in Corp). Shunting the calibration resistor
each of the 10 teeth. There was a 30- into the circuit produced a simulated
minute delay between the testing of strain, which could be calculated from
B
each specimen after each new cavity the resistances of the calibration
preparation. Central loading was resistor and also the bridge completion
C
veried before each episode of testing. resistors in the completed circuit. The
All specimens were prepared with subsequent peak output voltage from
diamond rotary instruments (Two the strain gauge on loading the tooth A
Striper; Myerson Ltd) in a speed- could be directly compared to the
increasing electric handpiece (MF- calibration output voltage; knowing the
Tectorque; W&H Dentalwerk) with strain value corresponding to the cali-
continuous water spray coolant. A new bration output, the peak strain value 3 MOD cavity (A3.0 mm,
rotary instrument was used to prepare could be deduced from a simple ratio. B3.0 mm, C4.5 mm).
the cavity in each tooth. Tooth struc- The peak strain corresponding to the
ture was progressively removed to output voltage (and loading cycle) of measures over teeth. If a statistically
produce 4 cavities in each of the teeth. each peak was deciphered. signicant effect in the ANOVA was
Groups were as follows: group I, intact All data were statistically analyzed noted, after adjusting the P values for
teeth; group O, class I cavities by performing a 2-way analysis of multiple comparisons, a Bonferroni
(occlusal cavities); group MO, class II variance (ANOVA) with load and cav- post hoc test was performed to
cavity; and group MOD, class VI. For ity as factors and with repeated establish which load was statistically
Pereira et al
372 Volume 110 Issue 5
different from the others. The as-
sumptions underlying the ANOVA were 2500 load (N)
tested by a study of the residuals and 50 before 130
were found to be satisfactory. A sig- 70 50 after
2000
90 after
The null research hypothesis that no 50 after After 1074.25 -1318.82 -829.68 .001
difference would be noted in the mean Difference is signicant for P<.05. (I) load (initial load) and (J) (load applied) were used to measure
strain in teeth with different cavity size difference in mean strain between both these loads.
To receive tables of contents by e-mail, sign up through our Web site at http://www.journals.elsevierhealth.com/peri-
odicals/ympr.
Instructions
Log on and click Register in the upper right-hand corner. After completing the registration process, click on My
Alerts, then Add Table of Contents Alert. Select the category Mosby or type The Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry in
the search field and click on the Journal title. The title will then appear, and having already completed the Registra-
tion process, you may add tables of contents alerts by accessing an issue of the Journal and clicking on the Add TOC
Alert link.
You will receive an e-mail message confirming that you have been added to the mailing list.
Note that tables of contents e-mails will be sent when a new issue is posted to the Web site.
Pereira et al