Professional Documents
Culture Documents
School Lunch Memoir Essay Final
School Lunch Memoir Essay Final
Anna Baumann
Ann Anagnost
Anth 311 A
Feb 26, 2017
I have had a varied experience with school lunches. I went to elementary school in
Berlin, Germany, middle school in Albany, California, and high school in Ontario, Canada.
Germany had a state-based lunch program which served low cost nutritional meals, while
Canada had no unified school lunch program and only served a la carte items. In this essay, I
focus on my middle school experience in California, where I sometimes ate the not so nutritious
reimbursable meal. Ive eaten a full meal on a real plate at school and Ive eaten a pre-packed,
four-dollar, partially raw chicken burger at school. Janet Poppendiecks account of school lunch
in Free for All made me aware of just how many issues and challenges contributed to me eating
the rather bland and unhealthy middle school lunches that I did. It also made me aware of how
problematic it is that we treat children as consumer citizens, with the power/resources to buy
whatever product they desire to eat, and that school food isnt free for all, leaving many children
hungry still.
Reading Free For All has given me a much better understanding of all the problems
schools face in trying to feed children. I attended Albany Middle School in Albany, California.
Before reading Poppendiecks book, I thought little about my middle school lunches. Half the
time my mother would pack my lunch and, when life got a little too hectic in the mornings, I
would eat the school lunch. Mostly I remember a lot of curly fries which I, as a new immigrant,
found quite fascinating. I did not know potatoes could come spiral shaped. There also was a veg
and fruit bar, but the main meals often consisted of burgers, fries, pizza and, on ethnic days,
correctly. Poppendieck described how POS systems came to be introduced in the 1980s to try to
simplify the school lunch sorting and payment process. Some of these systems used personal
identification numbers.1 Now my former middle school uses a system called My School Bucks
where parents can deposit money online to further simplify the process, but when I attended from
2008-2011 my mother still had to bring a check into the main office.2 Lunch now costs $4.25 but
when I attended it cost $3.25.3 The reduced price meal was less than a dollar.
At the time I was going to middle school, my parents were both in graduate school and
not making much money. Even though I was eligible for the reduced price meal, I never went on
it. Poppendieck states that this is often the case due to the stigma associated with the reduced
lunch and the hassle involved in the application process.4 Yet in my case I was not the one
ashamed, my mom was. I told her to get me onto the reduced lunch, but she never did. She
wanted to be independent and not need the governments help. I do not know if I simply didnt
notice a stigma in my school or if there really wasnt one, but in my experience reduced priced
kids werent ridiculed. They bragged that they only had 10 dollars on their accounts but would
still never run out of lunches. Those of us who paid the full prince often had accounts that would
At my school, if our accounts reached near or past zero and we didnt have enough to
pay, we would still usually get our lunch, but the lunch lady would give us a stern warning and
tell us to speak with our parents about depositing more money. This was the embarrassing part
1
Janet Poppendieck, Free for All (Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press, 2010), 216.
2
Pre-Payment Options, Albany Unified School District Food and Nutrition Services,
http://ausdschoolfoodproject.org/index.php?sid=1212122355243477&page=prepaidacct (Accessed Feb 22, 2017).
3
Menus, Albany Unified School District Food and Nutrition Services,
http://ausdschoolfoodproject.org/index.php?sid=1212122355243477&page=menus (Accessed Feb 22, 2017).
4
Janet Poppendieck, Free for All (Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press, 2010), 198.
Baumann 3
that caused me to not eat on the few days my account was in the red. I would rather go hungry
than to face the staffs glare. Poppendieck mentions the story of a 6 year old boy who saw his
lunch dumped into the trash in front of him and then got an alternative penalty sandwich
instead.5 While this is horrible and I am sure was very traumatizing for the child, I can
understand the schools dilemma. In one Florida school district, a 675, 000 dollar deficit was
reached yearly, because of debts in lunch accounts.6 This is an enormous amount of money to
From my middle school experiences, in connection to the reading, I have concluded that
school food should be a social program. It would be free for all and a great equalizer in schools.
Yet, this is an as of yet far-fetched dream. Many hindrances stand in the way of universally free
lunch. The US system has dug itself into a hole. The reduced price option makes the system
much harder to administrate and oversee, having to categorize meals into different sections and
verify parental incomes if applications are even returned. Because the system is so complicated
and a stigma is attached to it, many that are eligible do not apply and children go hungry. The
full-priced version needs to exist to raise school income levels. The school store needs to exist
for the same purpose. All these different parts are needed to run the system as it currently stands,
but they also smother each other. Competitive foods lower reimbursable meal participation; yet
they also raise money since many find the school meal unappetizing.7
but it also needs to be appealing to children so they will participate.8 When fries are the only
thing students will eat, is it better to feed them something so they wont go hungry or is it still
5
Janet Poppendieck, Free for All (Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press, 2010), 218.
6
Janet Poppendieck, Free for All (Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press, 2010), 219.
7 Janet Poppendieck, Free for All (Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press, 2010), 190-121.
8
Janet Poppendieck, Free for All (Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press, 2010), 113, 38.
Baumann 4
wrong to feed them unhealthily? If they are served healthy food they wont eat, the National
School Lunch program will have to shut down as it will not make enough money back in
reimbursements anymore.9 This was essentially the argument made by the food service director
at Any Town HS (whose name is not stated for anonymity reasons) to explain why potatoes
(another starch) are served with pizza at lunch instead of salad. While I understand his point, it is
also true that if you feed children only healthy foods, and take away the unhealthy, but seemingly
more attractive options, they will eat it. It may take a week or two, but once they are hungry
enough they will eat the healthier meal and learn to like it. Beyond this, healthy school food
options need to taste good, not be a pre-packed wilted salad or over-cooked green beans, so that
children can get used to the taste of real food and be conditioned in a better way.
possible to keep the power of choice, and still use lunch as a teaching moment. In Germany, I
always had 2 to 3 healthy options presented to me from which I chose one. Then I ate on real
plates, with mouth closed, using utensils. If I didnt, my teachers would correct me. They also
told me when I had eaten enough and could wash my dish. Lunch was relaxed and social but also
a strict learning exercise on how to behave properly in society. I had choice, and I learned.
Olivers exploration of Italian school lunches could not be more different. In America, children
are treated like consumer citizens, with vending machines, school stores, and purchasable junk
food aplenty. Poppendieck states that SNDA-IIIs findings indicated that all high schools, 97%
of middle schools, and 80% of elementary schools had some form of competitive foods.10
Comparatively, in Italy, only organic food is served to children for a very cheap price and food is
9
Janet Poppendieck, Free for All (Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press, 2010), 38.
10
Janet Poppendieck, Free for All (Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press, 2010), 159.
Baumann 5
used as a teaching moment.11 And I do believe that that is at the heart of the school food issue in
the USA. Through it, we teach children to view unhealthy, highly processed foods as favourable
and attractive. It offers two unhealthy options, the reimbursable meal and the store items, and it
School lunch can be a catalyst for overall change. If school lunch is treated as a learning
moment, it can change the course of a childs life, especially if that child does not receive
nutritious meals in his/her home. We can teach children how to eat nutritiously, care for their
bodies, be self-sustainable, socialize and form close peer bonds, and care for the earth/appreciate
where their food comes from. We can see a good example at MLKJ Middle School in Berkeley,
California, of how a local food source (school garden) can help children understand the process
of preparing foods and teach them how to work for it.12 If we condition our children to view
whole foods as appetizing they will eat healthily in the future and that will stop the obesity crisis
currently plaguing our country. They will carry what they learned in school into the future and
hopefully help change the toxic food system that we are all currently living in. If enough people
grow/source food locally and demand and fight for change, it will eventually occur.
School food is a difficult issue. It should be free for all, but it isnt. It should teach
children how to eat nutritiously and with manners, but it doesnt. It turns them into consumers
instead. My own middle school is an example for this. The school food system needs to revise
heavily to become healthier, less complicated, and eliminate hunger among children. It is a
difficult challenge, one which I do not know how to fix entirely either, but if enough people fight
for change and start reforming school lunch locally, eventually change will spread.
11
Ann Anagnost, Free for All: The Paradox of Free and Reduced Lunch (Lecture, University of Washington,
Seattle, WA, Feb 15, 2017).
12
Ann Anagnost, The Edible School Yard (Lecture, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, Feb 22, 2017).
Baumann 6
Works Cited
Anagnost, Ann. Free for All: The Paradox of Free and Reduced Lunch. Lecture at the
Anagnost, Ann. The Edible School Yard. Lecture at the University of Washington, Seattle,
Pre-Payment Options. Albany Unified School District Food and Nutrition Services.
http://ausdschoolfoodproject.org/index.php?sid=1212122355243477&page=prepaidacct
Poppendieck, Janet. Free for All. Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press,
2010.
http://ausdschoolfoodproject.org/index.php?sid=1212122355243477&page=menus