Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Beatles - Allan Kozinn Cap 3
The Beatles - Allan Kozinn Cap 3
The Beatles - Allan Kozinn Cap 3
just before the sessions for 'Please Please Me' and its flipside - a
sfightly Lafin-flavoured Lennon-McCarmey collaboration called
'Ask Me Why' - the Beatles had spent two wecks ar the Star-Club
in Hamburg, shang a bill with one of the!r tieroes, Little Ricfiard,
and they returned to the Star-C[ub one last fime in mid-Decembcr,
staying until New Year's Eve. On that final night, one of ttieir
[verpool colleagues taped their performance on amateur equipment.
The tapes [anguished in Liverpool until i97z, when Allan Williams
found tfiem and approached Harrison and Starr with a proposal to
release ttiem and split the profits. They declined, bur Williams even-
tualy found a buyer, and the tapes were released over the Beatles'
objections in 1977.
In their original state, the recordings are quite raw: the perform-
antes are imperfect, and without Epstein there to overscc thcm,
ltie Beatles slip back imo the profane stage pauer ttiat hacl been their
pre-Epstein st~le. But before the tapes were released, they underwent
an ambidous editing and sonic restoration job, the result of which
was an ideafized thirty-song ser that offers a fascinafing gtimpse ofthe
Beatles at a mrning-point in their career. Ir captures them in the
milieu that shaped them, playing rock favourites, covers of recent
hits, and new songs of their own. Bur they were already on their way
out ofthat wor[d.
When they returned to the smdio on n February, 'P[ease Please
Me' was making steady progress up the New Musical Express cha rt,
and thougti not yet number one, ir was a certitied hit. The conven-
tional strategy called for the quick release ofan album to capitalize on
these successes. Martin had already broken the mould by presenting
the Beatles as a cotiesive group ratfier than as a singer with backup.
and by favouring their own songs over those of professional song-
writers, Now there would be another innovation. ~l}pically, a pop
album would present the hits, padded out with lightly cooked ti[ler.
Martin followed this formula only to the extent that be induded the
Beotlemonia in England 1963 59
Left, Poul McCartn ey+ the +Devil in Her Hear t'. And their concert sets stili included the Tcddy
most personable of thg Bears' 'To Know Him is to Love Him', with the gender changed.
Beatles, wa5 oflen the most
eoger ~o discuss the group'$ The Motown aw~d girl group songs did not pass through the
work wilh inler vJewers Beatles repertory without leaving trates on Lennoffs and McCarmey's
compositional styles. Both genres made prominent use of gospel's call
and response gesture, in which a solo vocal line is repeated by a back-
ing chorus. Thc effct is hcard in thc 'come oJ section of'Please
Please Me', and its mirror imagc - the chorus singing the main
melody and the solo vocalist responding with free-floating, impro-
visatory amplifications - is heard near the end of'ES. I Love You'.
A variation of this move was to have the lead singer's lines punctuated
by nonsense syllables, 'sha la la,' or 'doo wah doo.' This too becamc
pari of the Beatles arsenal, starting with 'Do You Want to Know a
Secret'. And ir may be that the BeaTles' interes: in Motown at~d
girl groups led them to expand their harmonic style from the pure
duet sound ofthe Everly Brothers to a richer texture, oftcn with a
bluesy cast.
Of course, as much as the cover versions reli us about the wells the
Beatles' were drawing ffom, the real points ofinterest onPleasePlease
Mare the originais. Some show the signs of confinuing apprntice+
ship. 'Ask Me Why', for example, has ah underlying cha-cha beat that
even in T963 was on the border of sounding dated. 'Misery' ai~d
'There's a Place', by contrast, present a new kind of vocal and ins~ru-
mental texturc, somcthing diff~rent ffom 'Love Me Do' and 'Please
Please Me', and a precursor ofthe sound the group would explore
throughout ~963. Both havc Lcnnon and McCartny singing tandem
lines, in unison for strethes but with ear-catching divergentes at key
points. And both feature a tightly compresscd lcad and rhythm guitar
sound, energetic, efficient drumming, an active bass line, and brief
patches ofextraneous but effective colour Martink briefpunctuat-
ing piano figure in <Misery', Lelmon's harmonica on ~Thcre's a Hace'.
As songs, they are not timeless masterpieces. But they capture
something of the adolescent spirit of t963. 'There's a Place', for
instante, argues that the best escape from the heartache and so~row of
unrequited love is to turn inward, to a world of introspective fan~asy.
It was not an uncommon conceit. Five months la!cr and halfa world
away, the Beach Boys recorded Brian Wilson's 'ln My Room', a some-
what more sophisticated e:~ploration ofcomparable sentiments.
The Beolle~
Wilson is unlikdy to have fieard tfie Beades song, whih was not yet
released in tfic USA. Yet the songs are uncanni]y similar and in facr
begbl with the same line, 'There's a place where I can go'.
'There's a Place' and 'Misery' are pcriod pieces. Bur 'l Saw Her
Standing Thcre' has a vita[ity that rime has not tarnished. Thc song is
essential[y McCarmey's, bur Lennon added some useful touches. In
its ofigina[ forro, ir began: 'She was just seventeen, never been a beauty
queen'. Lennon replaced the second line witfi 'and you know wbat I
mean' hardly profound, and less picturesquc than McCarmey's line,
yct wondcrfully suggestive and exactly the right line for that moment
in the song. The arrangement evolved too. A Cavem C[ub rebcarsal
tape recorded sometime after mid-August ~962 includes ala embtTonic
version ofthe song with an awkward harmonica accompaniment,
square phrasing and seemingly unfinished bridge lyrics. By tbe rime
they played the song at the Star Club in Deccmber, thc harmonica
was dropped, and the song was in its finished forro.
Melodically, it could not begin more simply: the first two fines are
real[y just inflected speech. Bur just as expectations drop, McCarmey
provides a beautifully arching line, a short rhapsody on the lyric, 'and
thc way sfic lookcd was way bcyond compare'. On the verse's final
coup~et, Lennon sings a lower harmony in thirds, fourths and sixths,
and the active bass [ine keeps the song moving while fietraying its
roors: it is similar in shapc and spirit to the bass line of Chuck Berry's
'|'m Talking About '/ou', a song the Bcatles performed ar the time.
Several sonic gimmicks on their way to becoming Beades signa
tures are found here roo. Ah octave leap to a falset to 'oooh', first heard
in 'Piease Please Me', wou[d return in most of their bits of 1963. Its
roots are in the songs ofthe Isley Brothers and Litde Richard, bur
the Beatles made it their own by incorporating ir in the amalgam f
English and American styles that yielded their identifiably Beat[esque
sound. They also found ir a uscful effect in their stage sfiows. The
days of screaming girls was upon tbem, and when they stepped up to
tfie microphone, shook their heads and delivercd that falsetto 'oooh',
tbe audiences went even wilder.
However, tbc Beatles disliked literal repetition. So wben tfiey
repeated an effect, even sometfiing as seeming]y inconsequential as a
Zalsetto 'oooh', they tried to find a different use for ir the second time.
When they returned to Abbey Road to record their third single on
Beatlemonia in England ]963 63
ABBEY
R O A D N . W. 8
A cornpone~l o[ 5 March, they brought 'From Me to You', a song that uses that 'oooh'
BeoPlemonio wos a desire
again. Bur where the effect had been merely an ornamen: in 'I Saw
to own anything associaled
Her Standing There', it found its way into the ]yrics of 'From Me
w i t h t h e B e a fl e s , h o w e v e r
peripherally Once ir to You', giving the song's second line. 'ir there's anything I can do' a
become k~own fhof lhe burst of energy on its final word. In Fact, the effect is expanded here.
~Qt[es reorded ar EMI's
Lennon and McCartney sing the first rhree words of that ]ine in
sludios in Abbey Road,
$1eel sign$ vo~ished unison, but on the last three words McCarmey leaps up an octave
regularly This one turned and sings in a falsetto with a slight vibrato that suggests the head-
u p a i o u c t i o n y e o s l a t e r.
shaking ofthe stage show.
Lennon and McCarmey were also testing a new theory here, the
notion that songs in which "me' and 'you' were used prominently and
repeated frequently would strike ]isteners as personal, and would have
a special appeal. Ir may seem quaint that the Beatles, who would soon
rule the pop charts and spawn countless imilators, were so intent on
discovering the key to audience app-al. Bu as they composed 'From
Me to You', they were savouring the success of their first number one
record, then in its second week ar the top. However confident they
may have been, thcy had no reason to assume that everything they
touched would turn to gold, and ar this point they were intent on
discovering the mechanics of hitrnaking.
The Berilos
Beatlemania in ErLgland 1963 65
wrote specifically for them, or found unsuitable for their own use.
'Hdlo Little Girl' became a hit for the Fourmost. Cil[a Black, a for-
roer hat-check girl at the Cavem, had an early hit with 'Dove of the
Loved' and was later given other McCarmey songs, 'It's for You' and
'Stcp lnside Love'. And 'Bati to Me' was written for Bil]y J. Kramer
and the Dakotas.
Performers outside the Epstein circle tapped the Beatles' golden
songwriting machine as well. In 1963, the Beatles became friendly
with the Rolling Stones, a blues band making its way in London, and
still without a number one record. Lennon and McCarmey cobbled
together 'I Wanna Be Your Man', a riffy, basic song thar suited the
Stones' ear[y style. When the Stones' recording hir rhe top of the
charts, the group's singer, Mick Jagger, and its rhythm guitarist. Keith
Richards, decided that ir Lennon and McCarmey could write their
own songs, so could they. They were not a|one in this realization, and
by I964, rock bands that composed their own music - rather than
recording songs handed to them by their record producers becarne
the rule rather than the exception.
Between visits to Abbey Road, the Beatles undertook a non-stop
touring schedule. By August i963, Epstein took them entirely off the
they argued that if their fans had bought their singles, they should
not have to buy the same tracks again on albums. In immediate prac-
tical tcrm, this mcant that the four songs released on singles since
Hease Please Me could not be considered for ~he new album.
In its broad oudine, Witb tbe Beatles follows the pattern established
on Please Please Me. The opener, Lennon's Motown-inspired 'It Won't
Be Long', immediately grabs the listener's attention with its call aI~d
response refrain a back and forth on the word 'yeah'. And an aggres-
sive cover, Barrett Strong's 'Moncy', doses the ser. As on the ~rst
outing, the band supp[ied eight originais and performed six covers.
Bur this time one ofthe originais was a Harrison song, 'Don't Bother
Me', bis first composing credit since 'Cry for a Shadow'. Harrison
devoted the rest ofhis microphone timc to Chuck Berry's 'Roll Over
Beethoven' and the Donays' 'Devil in Her Heart'. Stuck for some-
thing for Starr to sing, Lennon and McCartney gave him 'I Wanna Be
Your Man', the rave-up they had written for the Rolling Stones.
McCarmey's facility as a crooner is again tapied for a show tune, 'Till
There Was You', but he aiso sings his own somewhat punchier 'Hold
Me Tight' and the magnificent ~11 My Loving', certainly the most
memorable of the originais.
It is Lennon, however, who dominates the aJbum. He sings lead
on most ofthe originais (an indication, usually, ofwhich collaborator
was the principal composer), as well as on three Motown covers, ali
hard driving songs that showcase his remarkably communicative
volte. Ali told, the album has a tougher edge than P[ease Hease Me.
Yet ironicaily, it also sounds more leisurly, more carefully considered,
more settled.
This rime the sessions were staggered, with stretches ofwork in
July and September, and touch-up sessions irx October. The Beades
were [earning that even ir their albums documented their concert
sets, they need not be limited by the instrumentation of their stage
arvangcments. They raised no objecUon to Martin adding pialao parts
to 'Money' and 'You Really Got a Hold on Me', or Hammond organ
to '1 Wanna Be Your Man'. They even gare him the solo in 'Not a
Second Time', a graceful, single-line piano part. Martin encouraged
them to experiment with textures. On 'Till There Was You', Harrison
plays a seemingly un-Beadesque nylon-stringed Spanish guitar, and
Starr, lured away from his trap set, plays bongos. Lennon, McCarmey
The Beal[~s
formats, and Martin had little choice but to provide stereo versions
in which the extreme separation ofthe raw tapes was modified only
slighdy. Still, cxactly bccause the early stereo is so primitive, these
recordings offer a bird's eye view ofthe group's instrumental and
vocal arrangements, and reveaJ details that are ]ost in the compressed
morto nlixes.
melody ofits conclusion, 'it's such a feeling that my love I can't hide,
I can't hide, I can't hide'.
Seeing a sexual undercurrent in such a seemingly na/ve song is
not merely analytical fantasy. In the manuscript ofthe song's iyrics
(now in the British Museum), McCarmey jokingly noted thc sccond
verse reffain ~s 'you'll let me hold your thing', and in some ofhis
more unbuttoned interviews, Lennon referred to the song as 'I want
to hold your head' - which is what he often seems to be singing on
tapes ofthe group's concerts.
The importance of texture in this recording is evident rom the
first line. McCarmey and Lennon sing ir in unison, bur when
Harrison fills in the pause~ in the lyric with a winding guitar line
se~ in the same register as the voices, his playing seems less aia embd-
lishment than aia integral part ofthe melody. There are also small
but effective touches - the stray twangs of a solo guitar that dor the
texture like sighs, and the overdubbed handclapping that supports
the rhythm and brightens the record's sound. Starr's drumming is
also ah important element. When Lennon and McCarmey take their
octave leap on the word 'hand', Starr plays a cascading fill. And in
the bridge, he taps along with patient steadiness until 'I can't hide',
and then mirrors the tension ofthe vocal line witb a steady, driving
b~sh ar the floor tom tom and open high hat.
Ifanyone had the idea at the beginning of 1963 that the Beatles
were a flash in the pan, 'I Want to Hold Your Hand' made them
think again. Released on z9 November (a week after W#h the Beatles),
it so[d L5 million copies within six weeks in Great Brkain alone, and
when ir replaced 'She Loves You' ar the top ofthe hit parade, it was
the Beatles' fourth number one record ofthe year. The albums were
doing equa[ly well. Please Please Me topped the album chart for thirty
weeks, until With the Beatles replaced it. According to a ret3or~ in ~he
British trade publication RecordRetailer, the group's record sales for
I963 totalled some 6,z5o,ooo.
Their ascendancy was ref[ected outside the pop charts as welL
On 90ctober they were featured in The Meney Sound, a tdevision
documentary about the Liverpool rock scene, Anal on 13 October,
~our days before they recorded '1 Want to Hold Your Hand', the
Beatles topped the bill on Sunday Night ar the London Palladium,
seen by ah estimated fifteen million television viewers. Ir was after
Beat]emania in England 1963 13
'The Beatles? I thoughl lhey this performance, with its accompanying screams from the audience,
were wonderlul - who
that the British press began reporng on what it called Beatlemania.
doesn'lg' osked lhe German
On 4 November, Beatlemania went upmarket whcn the Beatlcs
film and caboret star
Marlene Dietrich. who p]ayed in the Royal Command Variety Performance ar the Prince
aeored on lhe same bilh of Wales Theatre in London. Their contribution was a fairly sedate
as the Beatles ot the Royal
performance of four not particularly sedate songs, 'From Me to You',
Variety Sl~ow [n 1963.
'She Loves You', 'Till There Was You' and 'Twist and Shaut'. Before
the last, Lennon delivered bis oft-quoted introduction, 'Would the
pcople in the cheaper seats clap your hands? And the rest ofyou, if
you'll just rattle your jewelry.'
Newspapers and magazines went wild over the Beatles, filling
their pages with pictures and stories. And manufacturers of trinkets
Beatle wigs, handbags, buttons and even wa[lpaper - cashed in on
the phenomenon. Yet amid ali the madness, one serious, respected
critic, William Mann a The "limes of Londan, published ah end-of-
The Beatles
year review rhar argued that thcrc was more to Beatlemania than
head sha!sing, sreaming girls and pop cukure ephemera. Whar be
Found most fascinating, be wrote ou z7 December, was the music. [n
a music theorist's rhapsody, Mann celebratcd what be hcard as pandi
atonic clustcrs in 'This Boy', Mahleresque Aeolian cadences ar the
end of'Not a Second Time', and the major tonic sevenrhs and ninths
and iqat-submediant key switches he hcard in severa] other songs. The
musicologist Dryck Cooke, writing about the Beatles tive years larer,
poked fun ar whaz be called Manns 'dovecor-~qu ering', arguing hat
a harmonic analysis is misleading (but conceding that Mann's was
accurate}. The Beatles, unmtored in music theory, did not have a alue
what Mann was talking about, and did not particularly cate, although
With their first hits be~ind
ir tickled thcm to be taken so seriously.
them, and Ameria a~d
A Hard Doy's N~ghl just They were making headway outside E~gland roo. Australian
oheod, the Bea~les sang for radio had adopted them enthusiasticall They were taking ot~'in
3,000 members of I~eir
Europe as well, although television and radio recodings rom their
British }ah club ai the
Scmdinavian tour in Octobcr show that audiences there were consid-
Wimb~edor~ Palais, London,
on 14 December 1963 erably more sedate than those at home. Their greatest frustration,
Beot]~mania in Er~glond 1963 75
The Beatles
though, w=s that until the final weeks of I963, they h=d f=iled to crack
the American market. The h=d been some television cover=ge,
mostly condescending, which presented the Beatles and their f=ns as
the latest examples of British eccentricity. But Capitol Records, EMI's
American arm, had turned down each of their singles and albums.
And when EMI licensed the material to the smaller Swan and Vee Jay
labels, they scarcely made a ripple on the charts. And so America, the
world's largest record market and the source of their early inspiration,
remained closed to them.
That was about to change.