Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Get PDF
Get PDF
Get PDF
IV
XVII : ,
, 2013.
:
, ,
_______________________________
.
IV XVII
.
.
.
.
,
( 21:24; 22:34). ,
, .
, ,
, ,
.
.
.
.
, ,
, , .
.
, . 7. .
, , .
, , .
, ,
.
, , ,
, . .
, ,
, 19.
. , ,
, .
, .
, ,
. ,
, .
,
(J. 2, 1921; M. 15, 38).
,
. , 10.
.
.
, .
.
.
.
.
.
,
. , , ,
.
,
,
, ,
.
, ,
.
. , ,
.
, ,
.
,
, , .
.
: , , , , ,
, , , , .
: 27-4:27-526.2
Tihon M. Rakievi
THE ALTAR SCREEN ICONOSTASIS IN THE PERIOD FROM THE 4TH TO THE
MIDDLE OF THE 17TH CENTURY
SUMMARY
Key words: altar, altar screen, templon, iconostasis, linear concept, Eschaton, Eucharist, icons,
iconolatry, intercession of saints.
UDC: 27-4:27-526.2
......................................................................................................................................... 3
I ...................................... 12
1. ....................................................... 12
2. ........................................................ 17
3. .... 25
4. .......................................................................................................................... 32
II NOMEN EST OMEN . 34
1. ..................................................................................... 35
2. ........................................................................................................................... 42
3. ........................................................................................................................ 53
III ...................... 58
1. ........................................................................... 58
2. ............................................................................. 62
3. .................. 63
4 . ............................................................. 68
5. ....................................................................... 72
6. .......................................................................................... 77
7. ........................................ 80
8. ............................................................ 85
9. ............................................................................................................ 98
IV .................................... 101
1. ....................................................................................................................... 101
2. ............................................................................................................................ 108
3. ............................................................................................................. 114
4. ............................................................................................................................. 119
V
............................................................................................................................ 129
1. ..................................................................................................................... 131
2. ......................................................................... 133
3. .............................................................................................................................. 134
4. ...................................................................................................................... 135
5. ........................................................................................................................... 137
6. ....................................................................................................................... 138
7. ............................................................................................................................ 140
8. .............................................................................................. 141
9. ........................................................................................ 141
10. ...................................................................................................... 142
11. .................................................................................................... 143
12. ......................................................................................................................... 145
13. ........................................................................................................ 148
14. .................................. 148
VI ................................................................................................ 151
1. ...................................... 151
2. CONTRA..................................................................................... 162
3. PRO ............................................................................................. 167
4. ................................................ 175
1
VII ........................................................................................................ 197
1. .......... 197
2. ................................................ 204
3. ......................................................................................................... 207
4. ........................................................................................................... 209
5. ........................................................................................................ 212
.......................................................................................................................... 217
.............................................................................................................. 226
: .......................................................................................................................... 226
.................................................................................................................... 232
2
:
, ,
, ?
?
,
, :
. ,
,
,
, , ,
. ,
,
, ,
.
, ,
,
, . ,
1986. 800 ,
.
2009. . ,
,
.
, ,
, 2012. .
, ,
3
.
,
19. . 19.
20. .
.
.
19. .
, 20.
.
.
.
. 1930.
.
,
, ,
, .1
,
.
20. ( )
. 1647.
,
.2 , .
, , 3 .4
, 5
.6
1
Brhier, 4950.
2
Goar, 1420.
3
Holl, 365.
4
Lasareff, 127.
5
Felicetti-Liebenfels, Entstehung, 49.
4
,
( 1906. . . .)
. ,
, (Euchologium sive rituale Graecorum, Pariz 1647, . 18)
( )
.7 , ,
, .8
:
,
.
.
.
.9
20.
, . ,
,
, . .
10 -,11
. 12
6
Lasareff, 120.
7
Holl, 367.
8
Holl, 367.
9
Holl, 368.
10
Konstantynowicz, 1939.
11
Felicetti-Liebenfels, Entstehung 4958; (Felicetti-Liebenfels, W., Die Geschichte, 7388).
12
Lasareff, 119120.
5
, 20. ,
, ,
. 13
.14
.15
,
, , ,
16 .
. , .
, ,
.
.
, ,
, .
. ,
,
.
.
,
13
. : Goar, 14.
-. : (Felicetti-Liebenfels, Entstehung, 49). .
(Lasareff, 120).
14
Lasareff, 120.
15
Lasareff, 120.
16
,
,
, 14. . Lasareff, 120. :
(Dlger, 116).
6
. ,
,
.
.
, ,
,
, , ,
.
.
, ,
11. . . . ,
. . 12. , 14.
. . , . -.
,
.
.
a, .
(4. ).
. (6. ). . (7. ),
. (9. ), (9.
) (10. )
.
(11. ), (11. ),
(11. ), (11.
), . (11. ),
(12. ), (12. ),
(12. ), (13. )
(13. ).
.
, , ,
7
, , ,
.
,
. ,
, (9. )
, II
(10. ).
,
.
, ,
, , , (
11. ), (12. )
(13. ). .
, , -,
.
(1192), ( 12. ),
( 12. ),
( 13. ).
.
.
.
.
.
, 7.
. . , ,
, 14.
( ).
. ,
. ,
.
8
,
, , .
, ,
.
, ,
.
,
, .
.
1517.
19. . , , . ,
.
.
.
19. ,
20. .
, , ,
.
, ,
20. .
. , ,
,
.
,
20. ,
. , ,
, , .
,
.
.
9
.
,
, , .
- .
20.
,
.
. , ,
,
, , ,
, .
, ,
,
,
.
, ,
.
() 2003. ,
. , ,
.
, ,
,
, .
.
- ,
.
, , ,
10
.
.
,
,
, .
,
. ,
.
, ,
, , . ,
,
.
.
.
, , ,
, .
, M . ,
,
, .
11
I
.
.17
.18
.19
,
20 . , .
.
1.
. ?
.
.
.
. ,
, .
,
( 27, 121; 30, 110 1721).
.
17
Branham, 375.
18
Hickley, 407. .
. (Bouyer, 25).
19
, , 113.
20
Branham, 375.
12
, ,
. ,
( 25, 2340).
.
( 26).
,
. .
( 25, 1022).
, ( 16).
( ),
,
.21 ,
,
.
: ,
, .
,
a ( 40, 1 ).22
, (10376. .)
( . . .) ,
;
23.
, , .
.24
, .
21
, 125.
22
Duguid, 4359; (Patton, 7389); (Kohn, 159169); (Schwartz, 6171).
23
, , XIII, 13, 5, 570.
24
, 13, 5, 570.
13
.
.25
,
, .
( 12)
.
( 25:9). .
( 27:21).
, , ,
.
,
,
.26
,
.27 . ( 19,
912), ,
.
. , , ( 24, 12
912; . 19, 2024), ,
,
. ,
( 19, 20; 24, 1213)
25
, 125.
26
Leder, 17; (Gorman, 3945); (Haran, 3038); (Kearney, 375387); (Strange, 3738); (Blenkinsopp, 113);
(Douglas, Jacobs Tears, 119, 146148).
27
,
( 3, 5).
, ( 3, 12).
, .
, , ,
.
( 19:6). (Ratzinger, 14).
14
, , ,
.28
,
.
, ,
.29
.
:
, .
.
(...)
. ,
.
.30
,
,
. ,
.
.
,31 .32
.
, , ,
, :
, ,
,
. .33
28
Clifford, The Cosmic Mountain, 177181.
29
, ( ) . Wenham, 1135;
Kline, 3738.
30
Neusner, 43.
31
, , PG 9: 57a.
32
, , PG 80: 281a-b.
33
, , PG 9: 57a.
15
, ,
.
, , , , , ,
, .34
.
, , ,
, :
() , .35
, ,
, .
, ,
.
, ,
.36 : (...)
() . , ,
.
(...) ,
, ,
(...)
,
.37
,
,
.38
.
, ,39
34
, 129.
35
, , PG 63: 117.
36
, 129.
37
, , PG 80: 281a-b.
38
, 129.
16
. :
,
... ( )? ,
.40
, , ,
, :
, ?
? ?
, . 41
,
.
2.
? ?
,
, .
,
. ,
.
39
, , . ,
. .
, , . ,
. ,
,
,
. , , . , ,
.
40
, , PG 49: 357.
41
, , , PG 29: 28a.
17
. 42
, , ,
. 43 , ,
. , ,
, ( 8: 2).
, , , . ,
,
( 9: 1112).
,
, . , .
,
,
.
: ?
, ( . . .)
, ,
.44
,
: , ,
, ,
( . . .)
( . . .). , , .
, (
. . .) , (...). , ,
, ,
, .45
, :
, ( .
42
, , 347.
43
, 347.
44
, , PG 44: 380 .
45
, 381 .
18
. .). , ;
.46
, , ,
,47
:
( . .)48.
.49
2 6: 16 (. 1 3:16).
, 1 6:19.50
, ,
(2 6:17). (
), , .51
(1 2, 48), .52
. .53
.
46
, 385 .
47
, 380 .
48
Les constitutions apostoliques, 230.
49
.
(LXX). , LXX
. . .
LXX , .
(1Ko 3: 1617; 6: 19; 2Ko 6: 16; E 2: 21; 1 2: 4; 2 2: 4).
(. 1
3: 1617; 6: 1520; 2Ko 6: 16; E 2: 21).
50
: Morris, NZK: Prva Korinanima, 96.
51
, ,
... (2 6, 16). 37:27 -
.
, (, 64).
52
Gnilka, 350; 356360; (Stibbs, 72).
53
, 7275.
19
.
.
.
( 7: 3738;
8:12; 18:28, . 1 5:7) ( 1:51). , ,
, ( 15:38).
(6:1920; 8:2; 5; 9:24).54
,
. ,
( 8:5).
( 9:24).
.
.
,
( 12:2),
( 4:25).
( 9:33; 11:26), ,
( 4:26).55
,56
( 57:19; 9:7).
,
, .57
.
( 4 5 . 1 7: 2326; 6: 911; 11:19; 15:6; 16:1;17).
54
Hewitt, 83; 115116; 132133.
55
Cole, NZK: Galaina, 121.
56
( 2: 1422).
(
4:2124).
57
( 4:1216). (2022).
20
, , ,
(
21:22).
.
;
; ;
.
( 3:12; 14:1;
21: 210). .
(11:19; 14:1415; 15:516:1).58 ,
( 11:19) ( . 45).59
, ( 21:22)
. -
.
. 60 ,
. , ,
.
( 1:14 . 2:21). 61
58
Mounce, 219220; 262263; 271.
59
.
(4:23; 9; 5:1; 7;13). ,
. (4:1)
.
60
Mounce, 359362; (Briggs, 104).
61
1:14 () ,
.
, .
...
() ()
,
. Morris, NZK: Ivan, 9899.
21
, . .
, ,
. ( 3:12).
. ,
(22:4 . 25:6).
,
, , .
,
( 21:24; . 22:34).62
. 63
14:1,
, . . ,
, 144.000
, , (E 1:22; 4:15; 5:23;
1:18; 2:10;19).64
,
. ,
, .
,
( 7, 412; 14, 14).
.
,
62
(
). Mounce, 349.
63
, 350.
64
( 144.000 , 13:1617). 2 2:42
47 : 144.000 ( 7:112),
:
(). , 144.000 .
, , . (, 155162; 251).
22
. , ,
, , ,
.65
,
. ,
,
.66 ,
. ,
.
,
. ,
.67
,
.68 , , .69 70
.71
.72 ,
, 73 3. ,
,
.74
65
, 155162; 251, 349350.
66
,
, (2Ko 5:1) .
67
, , 114.
68
Rebi, 178.
69
, 68.
70
3. . Rebi, 186.
71
, , 114.
72
, 114; (Bouyer, 17). , ,
. (Rebi, 187).
73
Bouyer, 15.
74
, , 114.
23
domus
Dei , ,
,
.75
76
.
(: 3:12). (:
3, 16) (: 36: 1638; 37: 2627)
,
.
, ,
, ,
.77 . 78
.79
80
,
.81
( 2, 1921)
, ,82
. ( 2, 13), 83
( 15: 38) .84
:
75
, 114.
76
Turner, 75.
77
, , 115. 10
(Turner, 97).
78
, , 115.
79
Branham, 375394.
80
Hickley, 407427.
81
Turner, 174.
82
, , 115.
83
Turner, 149150.
84
, 68.
24
,
,
.
(...)
.
.85
.
(: 21:24; . 22:34).86
.
.
3.
, , ,
- .87
, ,
.88 domus Dei
.89 ,
, -
.
,
. .
85
Turner, 149150.
86
Mounce, 349.
87
Hickley, 407427.
88
, , 116.
89
Turner, 161162.
25
. 90
.91
92 ,
.
. ,
,
.
domus ecclesiae
, [ ]
.
4.
;
,
.93
,94 , ,
.95 , ,
.96
.
(, , ) ,
domus Dei .97
, , ,
, 98.
90
, , 117.
91
Lowrie, 168.
92
Cobb, 473487.
93
Turner, 174.
94
, , 117.
95
Turner, 163.
96
Ouspensky-Lossky, 59.
97
, , 118.
98
Turner, 173.
26
.99
5.
, ,
.
: ,
.
100
, , .
.101
.
, ,
. ,
( 27:21).
.
, .102
, . .103 4.
, :
,
, ,
(, , . . .) .104
99
, , 118.
100
315. .
: 4 , ,
, , . , 57.
101
, 5657.
102
, 128.
103
, , , PG 12: 366b.
104
, , PG 20: 877b.
27
, ,
105 ,106
.
4. , .
: , , ,
, , .
, ,
.107
.108
: ,
, /
.109
-
110 ,
. , 3.
, (. ) .
: () a
, ,
. :
, .111
:
.112
, ,
, , .
105
, , PG 9: 57a.
106
, , PG 80: 281a-b.
107
: , , PG 37: 1232.
108
, 128.
109
, , PG 37: 1232.
110
, , PG 3: 137a-c; ( ,
, PG 3: 425c, 445c).
111
, , PG 91, 672.
112
, , PG 155: 345c.
28
, .
. , 4.
, .113
,
,114 .
.115
,
. :
, .
. , ,
.
.116 ,
,
e.
4.
. . ,
, , , .
: () .117
. , .
, : (...) .118
:
,
113
Turner, 164168.
114
Krauthajmer-uri, Ranohrianska i vizantijska arhitektura, 29.
115
: , , PG 98, 392a-b.
116
, PG 48: 753d.
117
, , PG 20: 865c.
118
, , PG 87: 2836c.
29
, . 119 :
,120
,121 122.
(11291152) .
, ,
( .
. .):
.123
4.
. 19. 44.
.
, 19. :
(= ) ().124 44
: (= ).125 ,
:
(= ) (= ),
, ,
.126 , , .
. ,
.
, .
. , ,
119
, , PG 98, 392a-b.
. Mathews, 170.
120
, , PG 98, 392a-b.
121
. ,
. (, 1, 199).
122
, 1, 199.
123
, , PG 132, 953b-c.
124
, 293.
125
, 297.
126
, 179.
30
,
.127
.
,
.
, , :
, ,
. ,
(...)
. ,
, ... ?
, , , , ,
, , . 128
.
,
.129 ,
, , ,
.
. , , .
,
par excellence.130
,
, . .
131
127
, 127.
128
, , PG 49: 370d.
129
,
. .
, , PG 44: 388a.
130
, 130.
131
, , PG 98, 392a-b.
31
132 .
133 , ,
.
4.
.
, .
.
, 134
. ,
.
.
.
, ,
.
.
, ,
.
,
, .
.
.
,
, .
,
.135 .
132
, 1, 199.
133
Mathews, 170.
134
, , PG 98, 384b.
135
19 44 69 (
, 293, 297, 179).
32
, ,
, : ,
. , ,
.
4.
.
, ,136
.
.
.
.
.137 -
,
. , 4. ,
,
.
.
136
, 55.
137
, , . Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 327.
33
II NOMEN EST OMEN
. ,
,
.
.
,
. 138
-
.139
: (),140 (, ),141 (, ,142
),143 144 ( , ),145 146 (,147 ,
).148
.
. ,
.
.
,
138
, 123124.
139
, 130.
140
, , PG 865cd 868a.
141
Braun, 650.
142
, 650.
143
Konstantynowicz, 31.
144
. ,
, PG 132, 953b-c.
145
Braun, 650.
146
Brhier, 52; (Salaville, 455456); (, 221); (Lemerle, 361).
147
Konstantynowicz, 31.
148
Braun, 650.
34
, .149
, , ,
, ,
, .
.
, .
,
.
150
.
,
, .
,151 .
, ,
.152
.
. ,
.
1.
- ,
.
149
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 270.
150
, 270.
151
(...) . .
(, 271) (sub ) : (Mateos, 279329).
(Arranz, 389).
152
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 271.
35
.
. 153
. 154
. .
, ,
.
155 .
.156 .
157 , .158
, .159
, : ,
, , .160
, 1872. ,
.
, ,
.161
, .162
163 164
153
, 123124.
154
Konstantynowicz, 30.
155
, 30; Braun, 650.
156
, , PG 865cd 868a.
157
: , , PG 37: 1122a.
158
Liddell-Scott, Greek-English Lexicon, 376.
159
Braun, 650.
160
The Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium I, 2023.
161
, 575576.
162
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 272.
163
, , PG 82: 1236d1237a. , ,
36
165.
, , , :
[ ] . 166
167, 168
:169
, 170
( )171
de la sainte iconostase,172 .
, , 4.
.173 1619. 174 :
(...) , (...) . (
.175 ,176
13. 177 . ,
(13701375), : ( ) ()
.178
. . (
, , PG 66: 1592); (Braun, 650).
164
, , PG 80: 193a.
.
165
Dagron, Vie et miracles de sainte Thcle, 340.
166
, , PG 109: 341c.
167
, 341C.
168
Constantine VII Porphyrognte, 11.
169
, , PG 155: 704c.
170
Gautier, Le Typicon de la Thotokos vergtis, 5101.
171
, , 617; (Gautier, Le Typicon de la Thotokos vergtis, 19,
f.182v).
172
Gautier, Le Typicon de la Thotokos vergtis, 18.
the holy screen (... he stands near the holy screen...). (Typikon of Timothy for the Monastery of the
Mother of God Evergetis, 473).
173
, 37.
174
IX H 8 ( 10).
175
, 3637.
176
, 6061.
177
CHIL AS 156.
178
, 250.
37
() ( 14. ): ( ) ()
.179 14.
180 ,
, .181
. ,
,182
.
,
183 ,184 185
.186 17.
.187
188 , .
.189
,190
.191
,192 .193
. , 194,
.195
179
, 32.
180
Liddell-Scott, Greek-English Lexicon, 376/2.
181
, 575576.
182
Gautier, Le typicon du Christ Sauveur Pantocrator, 3233, 33, . 11.
183
, , PG 109: 341c.
184
, , PG 155: 704d.
185
, , PG 100: 465a-b.
186
, , PG 146: 897a-b.
187
, 65.
188
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 278.
189
Liddell-Scott, Greek-English Lexicon, 733.
190
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 272.
191
, , PG 109: 345d.
192
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 272.
193
Liddell-Scott, Greek-English Lexicon, 177.
194
, 577.
195
, 577.
38
.
.196
. 197
()
.
,
.198 199 , ,
, . 200
201.
.202
.203 . ,
():
( = = )
(= ) ( = ),
( = = ) ,
.204
() -
.205
196
Liddell-Scott, Greek-English Lexicon, 261.
197
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 272.
198
, 273.
199
,
.
. (The Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium I, 702)
200
, , PG 98: 389d.
201
, Commentarius liturgicus, PG 87,3: 3984d.
202
, , PG 155: 345d. (Du Cange, 720).
. (Liddell-Scott, Greek-English Lexicon, 389/1).
203
, 577.
204
, 1, 198; ( , ,
98. 389 D).
205
, 1, 198, . 10.
39
206 207 (,
, ). -208 209
210 (, ).211
. , ,
. 212
.213
.214
:
,215 216 .217
218 ,219
220 221.
cancellus,222 223 224.
206
,
, , ,
.
, , ,
.
Braun, 650.
207
Konstantynowicz, 31.
208
, , PG 98, 389d.
209
-, , PG 157: 625d.
210
Konstantynowicz, 31. : (, , ).
211
Braun, 650.
212
Walter, Further Notes on the Desis, 175; (Salaville, 455); (Brhier, 52, . 47); (Pace, 203).
213
Walter, The Origins of the Iconostasis, 255.
214
Konstantynowicz, 31.
215
, , PG 100: 465a.
216
, , 865cd 868a.
217
, , 617; (Gautier, Le Typicon de la Thotokos vergtis, 19,
f.182v).
218
, , ( ), PG 67: 1496b.
219
Braun, 650.
220
, 650.
221
Konstantynowicz, 31.
222
Liddell-Scott, Greek-English Lexicon, 3762.
40
, . 225 9.
,226 10. 227 11.
.228
. , ,
. 229
17. .230
6. 231 (, ,232 ,
).233 234 (, ,
, ),235 ,
,236 intercolumnium237
.238
,239 .240
241 ,242 243.
223
, Commentarius liturgicus, PG 87,3: 3984d. ( ,
, PG 110: 916b).
224
Braun, 650.
225
, , PG 95: 357b.
226
, , PG 110: 916b.
227
, , 98. 392a.
228
Gautier, Le Typic du sbaste Grgorie Pakourianos, 73.
229
, 576.
230
, 65.
231
Konstantynowicz, 31.
232
Braun, 650.
233
Konstantynowicz, 31.
234
, , 704 C D.
235
Braun, 650.
236
, , PG 155: 345; ( ,
, PG 109: 341c).
237
Konstantynowicz, 31.
238
, 32.
239
Liddell-Scott, Greek-English Lexicon, 167/1.
240
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 271.
241
, 271.
242
, , PG 155: 345; ( ,
, 155: 704d).
41
,
.244 ,
.
2.
. 245
246 7.
. .247
.248
.
.
.
249 .
/ : ,
, ,
, .250 ,
.
251, ,
, : 252
243
Darrouzs, Sainte-Sophie de Thessalonique, 53; (Gautier, Le Typicon de la Thotokos Kcharitmn,
153154).
244
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 273. . ( )
. . (Taft, The Pontifical Liturgy of the Great Church,
284, . 12).
245
Mango, 43.
246
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 276.
247
-, Varia graeca sacra: IV
XV , -
- , XCV, 1909.
248
Mango, 40
249
1, , , . Mango, 42.
250
Mango, 4243.
251
.
Mango, 43.
42
()
.253 , 7. 254
.255
, ,
.256
8. 9. 257
.258 . 11. ,
, . 259
. 260
( !)
,261 , ,262
.263
.264
252
, 619. . Mango, 43.
253
-, 53.
254
Mango, 43.
255
, 43.
256
8. . Alchermes, 49.
257
, 49.
258
, , PG 99: 1796.
259
, 65. , Giros, 409443.
: [] [][],
: Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 247, . 17; (Sotiriou, 63, . 285);
(, , 75, . 285 ( 1)); (, 6566).
260
, , PG 99: 1796a.
261
Braun, 651.
262
Brhier, 52. , . . (Pace, 195).
263
: : , , PG 99:
1796a; Konstantynowicz, 32.
264
Theodoros Studites, Jamben auf verschiedene Gegenstnde, . 194. Salaville
(: Salaville, 455456), , .
(Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 276).
43
. 7. ,265
9. 10. .266
: (
), 267 .268
. , ,
269 confessio270, .
.271 ,
,
, . 272
templum 273.
,274 .275
templum, ,
, (
) . 276 , ,
265
i, i , 208; Lasareff, 120.
266
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 276; Pasini, 1367.
267
, 136.
268
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 276.
269
III .
, 579.
270
, 579.
271
, 579.
272
( : Du Cange, 15421544 [ : ])
,
, . , 579.
273
: ,
, , , , , . ,
,
, ,
. , 579.
274
, 579.
275
, 66.
276
Konstantynowicz, 32.
44
.277
, , .278
templum279
.280 , .
, ,
, domus Dei
.281
.282 ,
. ,
.283
, ,
.284
,285 .286
, ,
.287 :
, ,
.288 ,
277
, 32; (i, , 177, 181, . 3).
278
Konstantynowicz, 32.
279
, 66.
280
, 66.
281
, , 118.
282
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 326.
283
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 277.
284
i, i , 206207; (Konstantynowicz, 32). chevrons de
la toiture, . (Lasareff, 121).
285
i, i , 205208.
286
Lasareff, 120.
287
Konstantynowicz, 32.
288
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 327.
45
. ,
, , ,
289.
, , .290
.
, 1077. ,
. : (...)
:
.291
. .292 , 1077. , -
.293
294 M , 1081. ,
.295
.296
.
. 297
, .298
289
Lasareff, 120; Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 278.
290
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 327.
291
Gautier, La Diataxis de Michel Attaliate, 88, 96. ( : volution de icne
aux 11e13e sicles, 339).
292
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 338.
293
, 65; (Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 277).
294
Gautier, Le Typic du sbaste Grgorie Pakourianos, 73, 121.
295
, 65.
296
, 65.
297
Gautier, Le Typic du sbaste Grgorie Pakourianos, 73.
298
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 277.
:
, 12 . (Gautier, Le Typic du sbaste Grgorie
Pakourianos, 121); (Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 339).
46
, 1110.299 ,
, 1136. ,300
. 301
.302
.303 , 1142. ,
.
. 304
:
.305
1202. 306 .
307 , , :
(...) ,
.
,
, .308
.309
1247. ,
, : ,
12 .310
299
, , PG 127: 1080b, 1084b-c; (Gautier, Le Typicon de la
Thotokos Kcharitmn, 109, 113).
300
Gautier, Le typicon du Christ Sauveur Pantocrator, 37, 39, 73, 81.
301
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 326327.
302
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 277.
303
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 340. Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 346; (, 65).
304
, 65.
305
Actes de Saint-Pantlmn, 74.
306
Miklosich-Muller, 55; Epstein, 7.
307
. Mango, The
Art of the Byzantine Empire, 240.
308
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 338.
309
, 66.
310
Epstein, 22.
47
.311
( 1400 1453)312
, . 313,
. 314
,
, .315
, , . 316 ,
, ,
.
.317
,
,
,
12
.318
311
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 278.
312
,
, . Braun, 651.
313
Laurent, 222.
314
Braun, 651. : Les Mmoires du Grand Ecclsiarque de lglise de
Constantinople Sylvestre Syropoulos sur le concile de Florence (14381439)
http://www.syropoulos.co.uk/translation.htm iconostasis,
.
315
.
1438,
.
,
. :
, , , , ,
. Epstein, 5.
316
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 277.
19611962. . (Epstein, 3).
317
Epstein, 45.
318
, 65.
48
,
. ,
,
. 319
, ,
, .320
.321
.322 ,
,
323 324.
. 325
,
,
.326
,
.327 .
.328
,329
16. .330
319
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 278.
320
Konstantynowicz, 32.
321
, 32; (Du Cange, 15431544).
322
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 278.
323
Konstantynowicz, 32; (Du Cange, 15431544).
324
Konstantynowicz, 32.
325
, , 865; Konstantynowicz, 33.
326
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 278.
327
, 17. .
, 65.
328
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 327.
329
, 66.
330
. , 66.
49
,331 , ,
.332
, ,
tmpl333 .334
.335
.336
.337
.
.338
: , , ;
.339
340 ,
. ,
, .
XVII .341
,342 , .
343.
331
, 66.
332
, 66.
333
. : timpla,
catapetezma iconosts. Catapetezma
. Konstantynowicz, 34.
334
Lasareff, 120.
335
Konstantynowicz, 34.
336
, 34.
337
, II, 663.
338
Konstantynowicz, 35.
339
, 35.
340
, I, 651.
341
Konstantynowicz, 35.
342
, III, 10961097.
343
, 10961097.
50
. , ,344
.345
: .
, , ,
.346
, , ,
.347 timpla
.348
349
350.
,
.351
.
18.
,352 .
353 1728. 354.
344
( = , ) tabula
. , 579.
345
, 580.
346
, 580.
347
Konstantynowicz, 34. , , i
. (, 331).
348
Konstantynowicz, 34. iconosts () . (Tiktin, 354).
349
Lasareff, 120.
350
Konstantynowicz, 34.
351
: . , 239, 240.
352
17291734. , 235; (,
168169); (Medi, Une version slave de Erminia, 403408); (, , 3132).
353
(
) 1728. . (, 369374).
354
1728. 19. .
(: , 370). :
. (, , , 400).
(, 373374).
51
,
.355
, 1826. :
, ,
, ,
.356 , ,
357
. 1876.
: (
. . .) . ,
.358 , ,
, .
, 1898. , 359,
, , 360
.361 362 ,
52
1900. , .
. ,
. : :
1850. ,
,
.363 :
, .364
3.
. 365
366 12.
.367 14. - ,
1347. 1368. 368
1387. , .369 15.
.370
, ,
.371
.372
.373
362
. , 1. 1900.
. . 12. 1914. .
(, 1).
363
, 2.
364
, 2, . 1.
365
Alchermes, 49.
366
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 326.
367
: , , PG 127:
1120c.
368
The Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium II, 1135.
369
28 Actes d'Esphigmnou, 167.
370
Laurent, Les Mmoires de Sylvestre Syropoulos, 428.
371
Konstantynowicz, 30.
372
Braun, 650.
373
, 651; Alchermes, 49.
53
-.
, ,374
, , ,
. : 24. ,
, , , ,
() (,
. . .),
. (),
.375
, , . ,
.376
,377 . 378
.379 380
, .
.381
. 382
, ,
383 , .384
374
-
. (Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 326).
375
Verpeaux, 189 ( , , : -, ,
PG 157: 61d).
376
, 3.
377
Alchermes, 49.
378
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 326.
379
Verpeaux, 189; (Laurent, Les Mmoires de Sylvestre Syropoulos, 428).
380
Konstantynowicz, 33. . ,
( ),
(: , , , )
( ). (Pallas, 370).
381
Konstantynowicz, 33.
382
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 326.
383
Pace, 195.
384
, 3.
54
,
, .385
12. .386
, ,
.387
.
,388
.
, 19. , , ,
, .389
i ,390
, 1939. , ,
.391
iconosts392 ,393
timpla, , ,
. 394 ,
iconosts .395
, 17. , 18. . 396
385
Alchermes, 49.
386
, , PG 127: 1120c.
387
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 326.
388
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List, 272.
389
, 239240.
390
, 331; (Konstantynowicz, 34).
391
Konstantynowicz, 34; (, 331).
392
Tiktin, 354.
393
Konstantynowicz, 34.
394
, 34.
395
, 34. catapetezma
.
396
i, , 183, . 6.
55
,397 398
.399 ,400 ,
, , .401
.402
.403 404
. 405
,
.406 , ,
407 .
, .408
, ,
. , , . ,
.409 410 14. :
397
, II, 663/1.
. (Konstantynowicz, 35).
398
, II, 663/1.
399
(.
) (, III, 10961097)
, . . (,
III, 10961097).
400
Konstantynowicz, 35.
401
i, , 172.
402
, I, 651
403
Konstantynowicz, 33.
404
Pace, 195.
405
Alchermes, 49.
406
, 49.
407
Braun, 651.
408
, 651.
409
Walter, The Origins of the Iconostasis, 251.
410
Verpeaux, 189.
56
.411
412
, .
,
. , , ,
.413
, .
,414 ,
.
.
411
11, col. 710.
412
Walter, The Origins of the Iconostasis, 252.
413
, 18.
414
, 18.
57
III
1.
,
,
. a,415
416 417.
,
, , .418
419
.
.420
.421
?422
423 3.
, , , , ,
415
, , PG: 20, 849880; ( ,
PG 20, 10961100).
416
, , PG 87: 28282837.
417
, , PG 86b, 21452147.
418
Gr. 510, fol. 452a, 880. (H. Omont, Fac-
simils des plus anciens manuscripts grecs de la Bibliothque Nationale (Paris 1902), p. 31 and pl. Lx).
(, 87, . 2, 3); (Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 15).
419
Millet, . 75, 2.
420
, 78, . 26.
421
, 34.
422
3.
.
. Leclercq, Iconostase, 31. .
, 3. . (, 32).
423
, ( 300. ) ,
, .
( 300. ) .
, 123.
58
.424 4.
. - 4.
, , 425
4. .426
, ,
. -
/ .
. ,
,427 ,
, .
. 428
,
.
.
,
.429
,
.430 A. , ,
,
.431
,
. ,
424
. ,
. , . , 123.
425
, , PG 20: 865b868a.
426
, 123.
427
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 327.
428
Walter, The Origins of the Iconostasis, 253.
429
i, , 168.
430
, 168.
431
Grabar, art de la fin de Antiquit et du Moyen age II, 1158.
59
. ,
, .
,
, .432
, ,
. 433
,
. ,
, 434
. ,
.435
.
,
. 436
.437
.438
439 .
. 440 ,
, :
432
, 124. . 45, 50.
433
Grabar, art de la fin de Antiquit et du Moyen age II, 1158.
434
Bleckwith, 15 156, 14 22; (Walter, iconographie des conciles, 176 . 72).
435
,
. .
. Walter, The Origins of the Iconostasis, 253, . 1; ( ,
126, . 151).
436
Grabar, Lempereur dans lart Byzantin, 207209.
437
, 124.
438
Grabar, art de la fin de Antiquit et du Moyen age II, 1158.
439
, 124.
440
, Sermones de sanctis, CCX, 2, PL 38, 1413.
60
.441
.442
, ,
. .
,
.
.
. ,
.443
.
,
.
.
,
.444
. .445
.
.446
.
,447 4. ,
. 448
441
, , PG 98, 392a. (,
1, 199).
. (, . 199, . 11).
442
, Commentarius liturgicus, PG 87,3: 3984d.
443
Sodini-Kolokotsas, 2650.
444
Walter, Further Notes on the Desis, 173.
445
Walter, The Origins of the Iconostasis, 253.
446
Walter, Further Notes on the Desis, 173.
447
, , PG 20: 846c.
448
. ,
, PG: 20, 10961100.
61
, .449
.
.
. ,
.
.
, ,
.450 ,
,
, ,451
.452
2.
4. 5.
, ,
. , ,
. 453
, . .454
. 455
, . 456
9. ,457
449
, , PG 20: 846c.
450
, , PG 20: 10971100.
451
Wagner, 43.
452
, , 227.
453
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 327.
454
Mathews, 109, 170; (Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 328).
455
.
.
. Walter, The Origins of the Iconostasis, 253.
456
.
, M . Zovatto, 137158,
111.
457
, 87, . 2 3.
62
.
.458 , ,
.
,
.
,
. 6., 5. ,
. ,
, 9. , .459
, 5. , . ,
, ,
.
, 460
461. 6.
. . 462
.
,
.463
3.
.464
458
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 15.
459
, 400. . Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de
l Iconostase, 15.
460
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 328.
461
Mathews, 19, 25, 27, 54 110.
462
( 400)
. . . Stern, 9398; (Grabar, Deux Notes sur l
histoire de l Iconostase, 1516); (Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 328329); (Mathews, 168).
463
Xydis, 1ff; (Mathews, 9698, 122). . ,
. (Naumann-Belting, 54ff); (Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 329).
63
, , ,
465
. .
. 466
.
467 .
.
, . . .468
,
.
. , ,
,
.469
.470
464
, , PG 86b, 21452147.
. (Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 329).
. 562. 563. . (Mango, The Art of the Byzantine Empire, 8788).
( , , PG 86b, 21452147).
465
, .
, , , .
: ,
, . . , 72.
, . .
(, 7). , . .
, , 10. . (,
, 382).
466
, , PG 86b, 21452147.
467
Mango, 4043. 659. 668. : (Grosdidier de
Matons, Les Miracula sancti Artemii, 263) (Droche, L'authenticit de l'Apologie, 658659).
468
Mango, 43.
469
. . ,
. , , 37
. Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 249.
470
: Lemerle, 361.
64
.471
, , .
,
, .472
.473
. 474
. 475 6.
. ,
.476
VII (10. )477
.
. ,
.
.
,
.
.478
471
, ,
. Walter, Further Notes
on the Desis, 172; (Mamobury, 197); (Swift, 29, 99 191).
472
,
. Walter, Further Notes on the Desis, 173.
473
.
. Zovatto, 137158, 411.
474
, . , 20. , ,
(proscenium). Holl, 365.
475
(, 365)
. - (Felicetti-
Liebenfels, Die Geschichte, 7388), : Trois fragments, 120.
476
Leclercq, Cancel, 18211834.
477
Constantine VII Porphyrognte, 11.
478
Walter, The Origins of the Iconostasis, 255.
65
, ,479
,
. . 480
, . 6. ,
.481
.482 483 ,484
. 485
.486
487 488.
,
,
.489
,
. ,
479
Mango, 40
480
. Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 330.
481
Naumann-Belting, 54ff, 2124, 710.
482
, , PG 86b, 2146 ab; (Friedlnder, 287289 293); (Du
Cange, Glossarium, 136 et seq.); (Swift, 29, 99 191 et seq.); (Walter, Further Notes on the Desis, 171).
483
, , PG 86b, 21452147.
484
Walter, Further Notes on the Desis, 172.
485
Kreidl-Papadopoulos, 279289.
486
(Hager, 66) . .
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 330.
487
,
, (VI ), . Lasareff, 123.
488
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 330.
489
Lasareff, 123.
66
, ,
.490
.
imagines clipeatae.491
492 .493
,
,494 ,495 .496
.
, 497
498 ,
,499 .500
.501
,
490
, 123.
491
Clipeata imago ,
. ,
( ) (. ),
(. , ).
. ,
, . , 15.
492
Lasareff, 123. Xydis, 67.
493
. Konstantynowicz, 82.
494
Xydis, 9.
495
Kreidl-Papadopoulos, 279289.
496
.
6. , ,
,
. Walter, Further Notes on the Desis, 175.
497
, , PG 86b, 2146a.
498
( ,
, PG 86b, 2146a), ,
. (Konstantynowicz, 82).
499
, , PG 86b, 2146a-b.
500
, 2146b.
501
, .
(Grabar, Les ampoules, 6061 . IX); (Walter, Further Notes on the Desis, 176).
67
. .
20.
. 502
.
.503
. , ,
.504
. ,
,
.505
4 .
, , . .506
.507
,
502
Xydis, 1; Lasareff, 121; (Kreidl-Papadopoulos, 279289); (Mango-Parker, 241245).
503
7. ( ,
, PG 87, 3: 3557d)
504
Walter, Further Notes on the Desis, 177.
505
, 177.
506
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 330.
507
Mathews, 178.
68
.508
.509
, 510 .511
,
, ,
, ,
, .512
,
.513
.
, , 514
.
, 515 .516
508
.
,
, 10. .
I .
, PG 109, 341a-b.
509
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 331.
510
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 334.
511
9. 11. . Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 336.
512
: Megaw, 11.
513
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 334.
514
Grabar, Sculptures byzantines de Constantinople, . XXVI, XXVIII.
515
, 7680, . XXVIXXVIII; Firatli, La sculpture, 8792, . 278297.
.
516
.
, . ,
, 72. , ,
, , .
Cumiculum Velatio,
69
, , ,
.517
9. ,
,518 .
.
, . .
.519 ,
(817828)
.520
.
521 .522
,
.
, ,
, .
.
,
. , ,
. Grabar, PACh, 116, fig. 115.
517
Lasareff, 123.
518
, , PG 100: 464d465a-b; (Grabar, L'esthtisme,
6369); (Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 160161); (Kitzinger, Byzantine Art, 42
Kitzinger, The Art of the Medieval West, 198); (Sodini, 134); (Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine
Sanctuary Barrier, 245).
519
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 330.
520
, , PG 100: 464d465a-b.
521
, 464465.
522
. Grabar, L'esthtisme, 6369.
70
.
.523
, ,
,
. -
. ,
.
, 524 ,525
526 527 , 9. .
,
9. 14. .528
, .529
.
530 .
523
Lasareff, 124.
524
Grabar, Sculptures byzantines de Constantinople, 123124, . LXIV4.
525
, 97, 134, . XLV3.
526
, 97, 123123, 137, . XLV3, LXIV4.
527
, 106107, 135, . LIII.
(Skripu) (873874)
(876877), , , ,
9. . Grabar,
Sculptures byzantines de Constantinople, 9099, . XXXIXXLII; (Megaw, 11).
528
Lasareff, 125.
529
, 125.
530
.
Grabar, Sculptures byzantines du Moyen Age II, 1165.
71
.531
532
.
,
. .
.
,
.
,
, .533 ,
.
,
. ,
, ,
, .
, , , .534
(11.
12. )
. ,
, , ,
.535
5.
.
11. 13.
531
, 165168, 4.
, . (Lasareff, 125).
532
Lasareff, 125126.
533
, 23.
534
, , 250.
535
Lasareff, 129.
72
,536 , ,
, , . ,
, . .537
. , , 538
. .
, , ,
.
.
11. 13. .
20. .539
9. 10.
.
540
, .541
536
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 336337.
537
, 338.
538
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 333.
539
, 333334.
540
:
( , , ,
900. ), (Lasareff, 126; , , 380),
.
(Firatli, Dcouverte, 158, . 14; 159, . 1518) ,
.
, 5 , 18 21 ,
, , 12 .
. ,
. (Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 336337).
541
Grabar, Sculptures byzantines du Moyen Age II, 109f I v; (Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux
11e13e sicles, 335).
73
,
, , .
9. 11.
542
. , .
, 1213. .543
, ,
. ,
10.
.544 . . ,545 ,546 547
9. .
,
.548 ,
, ,
, . .
549
, 14. 18. ,
.550
542
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 337.
543
. , .
.
. Stoufi-
Poulimenou, A Byzantine Architrave with a Deesis, 185, . 12.
544
, 8. , : Dalton, 664666.
545
, , 100.
546
, , 380; (, , 277).
547
Lasareff, 122 126.
548
(
, , ). Grabar,
Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 20.
549
oroviLjubinkovi, 144.
550
, 15.
74
,
, 14. .
, , ,
.551
.
. 552 ,
,
.553 ,
.554 .555
.
556
.557
.
, ,
.
551
, 17.
552
. Brhier, 56.
553
, 17.
554
15. . Lasareff,
135.
555
, 18.
556
. 12
( 14. )
( , 13931394).
, .
, , .
1213. . (Djuri, 348).
, . (Radoji, 72, 73).
557
0, 99 x 0, 74. (Djuri, 333335).
13751380, ,
1360 (Djuri, 333335)
,
. (Djuri, 348). .
(Lasareff, 140).
75
558
,
, 559.
12. 13. ,
560 561.
, , ,
.
. 562 ,
.563
558
, 140.
559
, 141. : -,
XIV , 135152. -
( )
. :
XVI
.
, XI XII
, XIV XV .
, ,
XV . ,
-, 0,77 . (. : 2,10!).
(: , 348) ( 1387).
16. . () . (Lasareff, 141).
560
( XII XIII )
. Lasareff, La scuola di Vladmir-Susdal, 918.
561
Lasareff, 133. XII ,
( ),
. : ,
, , .
, 133.
562
, 142.
563
1405. 2, 10 .
, 3, 14 .
. ,
, (1, 60 x 1, 09 .)
, ,
. ,
.
, 17. 18.
76
6.
564
9. ,
.565 (910. ), ,
,566 ,
. ,
.567
.
. ,
.568
,
. , .569
,
,570 12 .571
, ,
. : , 142, 234, 235.
564
J. Goar, ,
, ,
. Goar, , 14; (Lasareff, 127). ,
. (Holl, 367368), -
(Felicetti-Liebenfels, Entstehung und Bildprogramm, 49) .
(Lasareff, 127).
565
, 127.
566
Walter, Bulletin, 263.
567
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 334.
568
, 8.
569
, , PG 109: 225-369.
570
9. 10.
,
, . Lasareff, 126.
571
, 8.
77
.
, .572
9. ,
.573
,
9. . , ,
.574
,
. 575
.576
, 577
823. . : ,
, , , .578
579 . 580
, , ,
,
572
. , PG 109:
225369.
573
, 8.
574
Alchermes, 49.
575
: (...) ,
, , , ,
, .. Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 334.
576
, 334.
577
, , PG 100: 464d465a-b.
578
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 335.
579
, 335.
580
, I
, ,
. , , PG 109: 225369. (Chatzidakis,
volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 335).
78
, ,
.581
.582
.583
584 9. .
,
.585
, (...)
586.
.587 ,
.
10.
, .
, 10. ,
588 , .
.589 11. 14.
.590
581
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 337.
582
, , PG 100: 464d465a-c. (Grabar, L'esthtisme,
6369); (Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 160161); (Kitzinger, Byzantine Art, 42)
(Kitzinger, The Art of the Medieval West, 198); (Sodini,134); (Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine
Sanctuary Barrier, 248).
583
Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 248.
584
, , PG 110, 993a. 865. ,
III (842867) 813.
842. .
585
Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 248.
586
, , PG 110, 993.
587
Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 249.
588
, t, 83 .
589
, , 381382.
590
, 9.
79
. 591
,592 .593
,
.
.
.594 , ,
, ,
, .595
7.
11. ,
- .
,
.
, . 596 ,
.597 10. 598 11.
591
Lasareff, 127129. . , , .
, . , . , ,
, 11. . 12. , ,
, . , .
, , , (
13. ) .
592
Brhier, 5051.
593
, , . 11 14; 12; 13; 54 55 ; 14.
594
, 9.
595
Lasareff, 127. Goar, , 14; (, , 122),
.
596
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 22.
597
, 22.
80
.599 14. 600
-.
, ,
.
, .
, ,
, , .601
- ,
.602 , 603
. ,
.604
, ,
,
, .
, 605 .
. 606 ,
598
, , 185187. , ,
. (Chatzidakis,
volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 336).
599
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 2021.
600
, 20.
601
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 336.
602
, , . : Lange, 1718.
603
: . ,
. , . , , , ,
. (, 8391); (, , 16, 13, 6).
604
. , ,
144; 104105.
605
Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 256.
606
XII ( 418, 269)
. Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir
81
, , ,
,607
.
608 , .609
,
.610 ,
, .
611 (1164) (1259).612
82
-, , ,
. . :
,
,
,
.613
, ,
.614
,
.615
.
. ,
,
.616
:
.617
.
- .618
619 10. 13.
613
, , 15.
614
, 15. -, , PG 157, 61d.
615
, , 15; (Grabar, Liconoclasme, 385, . 1).
(Ms
710/5), 1100. , , 15.
616
, 15.
617
, 16.
618
10. . .
11. ,
( ) . , ,
16, . 15; . 1.
619
, 1718, . 910, . 12.
83
.
.
.
, , 11. ,
. , ,
, 10. ,
.
.620
.
,
.621
,
,
, ,
, ,
()
.622 , ,
.623
.
,
, 11. ,
,
.624
.
, , . ,
, , .
620
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 336.
621
, 336.
622
, 337.
623
, 337.
624
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 22.
84
12. ,
,
, ,
, .625
626
, .627
,
; ,
,
; ,
;
; .628
,629
.
, , .
8.
. 630
-
,
.631
,
625
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 337.
626
Walter, Bulletin, 263.
627
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 363.
628
, 363.
629
, 363.
630
Lasareff, 130, . 34, . 8; . 35, . 10.
631
-, , 170173, 912; (Miljkovic-
Pepek, 388391); (, 126127, . 312).
85
, .632 ,
-
. ,
.633
12.
.634
, . , ,
, .635
, .636
.
, ,
.637
, ,638
639 .
, .
632
Lasareff, 131.
633
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 22.
.
. , ,
, ,
. , 2021.
634
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 344.
635
Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 249.
636
,
. Lasareff, 131.
637
.
,
. , 12.
638
. Lasareff, 135.
639
, 135. , ,
. , 135.
86
, . 14.
18. ,640 ,
.641
- ,
, , 642
. ,
.
, ,
12. , ,
.643
.
. .
.
. ,
.644
,
,
.645
.
.646
, ,
640
orovi-Ljubinkovi, 144.
641
, 15.
642
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 18.
643
Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 257.
644
, 258.
645
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 341342.
646
.
, 341.
87
, , . 647
.648
.649
J ,
, .650
, . 651
. , III,
, ,
.652
653
654 . 655
.656 , ,
647
, 341.
648
(, , .), (
), ,
.
, 341.
649
. . , ,
.
, , .
. Pallas, 367.
650
Weitzmann, Icon Programmes of the 12th and 13th Centuries at Sina, 8694.
651
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 341.
652
Lasareff, 132.
653
, 131132. - ,
. : Felicetti-Liebenfels, Entstehung und Bildprogramm, 54.
654
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 332.
655
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 339.
656
Lasareff, 132.
88
, . 657
,
.658 11. ,
1056. 1086, , ,
.659
. ,
11. 12. .
.660
1081.
11. , .661
662 .
: , .
.663
, .664
, . . ,
.665
657
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 339.
658
Lasareff, 132.
659
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 339.
660
, 339.
661
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 341.
662
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 339.
663
Gautier, Le Typic du sbaste Grgorie Pakourianos, . 73.
664
Epstein, 2122. (Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 258)
: Gautier, Le Typic du sbaste Grgorie Pakourianos.
: (...) , . , ,
, ,
. , . (Gautier, Le Typic du
sbaste Grgorie Pakourianos, . 73).
665
, 258.
89
,
,
. 666
11.
.
.667
11. 12.
.668 , , 1192. ,
(1, 05 0, 62 )
.669
,
670
12. .671
11. 12.
,672
, 12. .673
, .
666
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 339.
667
, 340.
668
. , 340.
669
,
. , 340.
670
, . , 341.
671
, , ,
. ,
, ,
, ,
.
12. . , 341.
672
. , 343.
673
, , 11.
.
, 343.
90
. ,
,
.674
.
, 1247. ,
, : (...)
.675 ,
.676
.677 , ,
, ,678
.679
. ,
11. 12. ,
. 680
,
.681 ,
682 .683
674
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 342.
675
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 340.
676
Epstein, 22. .
, ,
. (Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 341).
677
Epstein, 22.
678
. Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 166.
679
. .
, 4849, 50.
680
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 356.
681
, 356. , .
: ,
, ,
.
( ) . , 356.
682
,
, :
12. ,
91
,
, 684
.
, ,
11. :
685 1067. ,
, .
, .686
12.
. , ,
.687 ,
, , . 688
.689
.
, ,
, , .
, 361.
683
, 357.
684
.
. , 357358.
685
,
, 358.
686
, 358.
687
, ,
, .
, , ,
. , 358.
688
, 358. 14.
(Lasareff, 139), -. (Felicetti-Liebenfels, Die Geschichte, 7688).
1142.
M . (, 139)
, ,
, . (, 139)
, , ,
92
.
.690 ,
10. , , , 691
.692 (1012. )
, .693
,
,
.
. ,
.
- , ,
. 694
11. . 695
696
.697
. (, 139.) , ,
.
, . 1,00 1,58
0,700,90 1,25 . (, 9395, . 1617; 9899, . 23).
689
. ,
() . (). Chatzidakis,
volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 358.
690
Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 253.
691
,
. : , 11.
692
Thierry, Nouvelles glises rupestres de Cappadoce, pl. 10a 54, (Restle, II, pl. 134, III, pl. 388, 409, 433,
483, 518).
693
Elmale Kilisse, Qaranleq Kilisse, Tchareql Kilisse, Gueurme Guk Kilisse,
, . , 10.
694
, 10.
695
Rodley, 169, 172, 175, 176, 181. Wharton
. (Wharton, 133)
696
Qezlar Kalessi (12. ),
, .
93
698
,699
,700
.
.701
, .
, , , ,
.702
,
. , ,
, ,703
.704 ,
, ,
. ,
. , 11.
697
Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 253.
698
, , , , Tokale Kiliss,
,
,
. , 11.
. ,
. Brhier, 53.
699
. Brhier, 5354.
700
Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 253.
701
, 10.
702
Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 253.
703
, . ,
,
, - ,
, .
. ,
, .
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 342.
704
XXXVI. 5 6. , 342.
94
, ,
.
. 705
. ,
, ,
13. ,706 -;
,
.707
708 .
, , 709
, , 710
711 14. .712
713 .714
. ,
, ,
, , ,
, .715
705
. , 342.
706
, 342, . XXXVII.
707
, ,
. , , .
. Pallas, 367.
708
. : , , 69, . 3.
709
, ,
.
: Brhier, 54.
710
, 11.
711
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, . 5, . 17.
712
, , 69, . 54.
713
. Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, . 17, . 6.
714
. . Brhier, 54. (Millet, . 15, 2).
. . (,
, 444445, . 3).
715
, 444445, . 3.
95
.716
717 -
.718
,719 , 720 ,
.721 ,
.722
, ,
.
.
, ,
,
.723
, ,
, , .
11. 12. , .
724 . ,
, , , ,
716
,
, , ,
, ,
. , 14.
717
(10671071), 1313.
.
718
, , : 69, 73, 8386.
719
, 84.
720
, 86.
721
Lasareff, 138.
722
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 18. :
. Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de
l Iconostase, 18.
723
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 19.
724
, 10.
96
,
. , ,
, 14. . 725
?
. 1313. 1318. ,726
,
14. .727
728 .729
.730
1342. 731 - ,
,
. .
, ,
, .
, , -,
725
. . ,
, 140189 ( 14. 173176).
: , 212223.
, ( ): (, 87120).
: (Bljajev, 386394, . 12).
726
1313. 1318. . Grabar, Deux
Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, . 10, 5.
727
. :
11.
. Lasareff, 138. . , , : ,
, ,
, , 14. , . ,
, 219; (, , 173176).
1318. (Lasareff, 138).
728
, 12.
729
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, . 17, . 6.
730
, 1535; (Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, . 10, . 8).
731
1928. 1332. 1337. . ,
14. 1342. . (, ,
1719).
97
, ,
.732
, .
, . , ,
; , , ,
, ,
.733
.
?
,
, ,
, .734
-
,
, .
9.
. , 1112. .735
.736
,737 738 , ,
.739
732
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 19.
733
, ,
. , 19.
734
, 19.
735
, ,
. Lasareff, 133.
736
,
, . , 133.
737
, 117.
738
, 133134.
739
. . . i, i , 205206.
98
,740
: ,
.741 , ,
.
.742
. ,
743
.744
, 745
. 746
.
: .
, 747
. 13. .748 . .
749
,
.
740
. . ;
. Lasareff, 141.
741
, 141.
742
, 142.
743
1930. (Louis Brhier) (Gabriel Millet)
( , ,
, ). Brhier, 4950.
744
Lasareff, 142.
745
. ,
,
. . , 16.
746
, 16.
747
, 129131.
748
, 16.
749
, , 100101.
99
,
.
14. .750
, 14. ,
, .
.
,
.751
,
.
. 1592. .752
.
750
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 346.
751
, 17.
752
, 17.
100
IV
1.
, ,
.
, .
, ,
10. .753 11. .
11.
.754 :
(...) :
.755
.756
.757
,
.
758 11.
.759
753
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 338.
10, . Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 343.
754
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 338.
755
Gautier, La Diataxis de Michel Attaliate, 88, 96.
, ,
, .
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 338-339.
756
. Lasareff, 131132;
(Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 332); (Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 339).
757
, 339.
758
Lasareff, 132.
759
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 339.
101
, .760
.761
.762
, , .763
764 .
.765
,
. ,
:
. 766
.767
,
,
. 768
, 1112. ,
, .769
760
Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 259.
761
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 343.
762
, 344.
763
, ,
70 . , 344.
764
Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 259, a 6.
765
Lasareff, 117.
766
, ,
, . Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux
11e13e sicles, 344.
767
Lasareff, 117.
768
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 345.
769
, 349.
102
.770 . , ,
.771
. 772
, , 18. .773
, ,
, ,774 12
.
. ,
.775
20.
, .776
770
, 345346.
771
, 346.
772
Weitzmann, The Icon, 78, . 20; (Weitzmann, Illustrations to the Lives of the Five Martyrs of Sebaste,
109110, . 2829).
773
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 346.
774
, 346.
775
. , 344.
776
12. 13. ( )
, , ( . .
; ;
. ;
). , 14. 15. ,
( , , ,
T ; , .)
( ,
;
;
;
; (Pala d'oro) ,
, ,
, , 15. ,
103
11.
,
10. .777
12
1059. ,
:
.778 , ,
.779
.780
.
: ,
. 12
.781 .
.
1093.
.782
. 1142.
.
: . (...)
.783 ,
,
.
104
1247.
:784
.
.785
,
12. .
: , , ,
, , , ( ), ,
, , .786
. 787
788
, , .
.
.789 ,
, ,
784
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 340.
785
, ,
. , X ,
12.
. , -
,
. Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e
sicles, 347.
786
,
. Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 262.
787
.
. , 264.
788
(
), (
). , 264.
789
, 263.
105
.790 .791
792 793, 12. .794
795.
,
. , ,
.796 ,
.
, , 11.
,
.797
, ,
790
, , ( ), PG 52: 799802.
e o.
. (Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 263).
791
, 263.
792
, , PG 120: 1197a-b.
793
, , PG 133: 1123a-b.
, 12. ,
1166. (Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, 264).
794
( )
( 12. ). , 264.
795
, 264.
796
11. 12. ,
, . Lasareff, 132.
797
11. , .
, , .
. Chatzidakis,
volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 349.
106
.798
799 .
, ,
.800
, .
, 11. , . 801
, , , ,
12 ,
.802
,
, .
.803 ,
, .804
,
. 805 , . ,
13. ,
798
, 350.
799
, 351.
,
, ,
.
,
, 1204. .
800
, 352.
801
. ,
. , . , , (1093)
, . , 352.
802
, 352.
803
, 353.
804
. , 353.
805
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 349.
107
.806 16661667.
.
. 807
,
.808
2.
,
. , .
,
.
, .
: (...) , . .
; ,
806
( 12. )
, , , .
, .
. ( 49,3 )
,
.
. , , 12. ,
-
. Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 353354.
807
16661667. .
, .
, : (...) , .
.
(...), ,, . (
. ).
808
, 1667. ,
. , 19. .
, , 12.
108
.809
: (...) .810
. , .
.811
. 19.
.812 12. 13.
,813
.814 , ,
17. 18. 815
. 816
, ,
10.
, , . 817
,
.818
, .
. :
, , ,
.819
11. ,
809
Dalton, 664665.
810
Bleckwith, 169.
811
Bogay, 59,
812
, 60.
813
, I, 651.
814
Bogay, 60.
815
, 58563; ( , 409679).
816
Bogay, 60.
817
Dalton, 664665.
818
Bogay, 61.
819
, 61.
109
.820
821 .
, .
. ,
,
,
, , 822 .
, 10.
.823
. , .
.
,
. ,
,824 , .
, , . .
, .825
:
.
.
.
,
, , .
.
820
, 62.
821
Grabar, Lempereur dans lart Byzantin, 103.
822
Bogay, 64.
823
, 68.
824
, , 121.
825
, 120.
110
. ,
; :
, ,
, ,
. , ,
. , ,
, ,
, .826
10. ,
, .
, , , ,
.827
.828
,
.829 ,
, , .830
.831 11.
,
.832 ,
, .833
826
, 18.
827
Bogay, 72.
828
, 68.
829
, 69.
830
,
, ,
. (Walter, Bulletin, 262).
, , 913920. . (Thierry, A propos
des peintures dAyvali ky (Cappadoce)), 522.
831
Walter, Bulletin, 268.
832
, 268.
833
, 269.
111
. 834
,835 ,
, , .836
. 837
6.
,
4. 5. .838
.839
.840
. , ,
: (...) (...) . 841
.842
.
, : (...) 9.
I.
. 843. 12. ,
, , ,
834
, 269.
835
.
836
Walter, Bulletin, 269.
837
,.
838
Walter, Further Notes on the Desis, 177.
839
, 178.
840
, , PG 100: 464d465a-b.
, .
Kitzinger, Byzantine Art, 21.
841
, , PG 100: 465a-b.
842
, , PG 100: 465a-b.
843
, , PG 109: 341c.
112
.844 ,
.845
846
.
, I (9. ) 11. ,
847 . 848
. 849 ,
.
, ,
, .850
.
,
, ,
, .
, ,
.851 , ,
.
, , ,
,
844
Epstein, 45.
. , , 399.
845
Walter, Further Notes on the Desis, 178.
846
, 179.
847
Lasareff, 117143.
848
Walter, Further Notes on the Desis, 179.
849
, 180.
850
, 180.
851
, 181.
113
.852
. -
,
.
.853 , 15. 16. ,
,854 -
, ,
.855
3.
.
.
, 4.
.856
, ,
.
.
: ,
.857 .
: (...) (...)
852
, 181.
853
Walter, Bulletin, 262.
854
, 145, 146, . 11; (, , 21).
855
, , 40.
. (Walter, Bulletin, 262). 16.
,
. (, , 3941).
856
, 55.
857
, , PG 37: 1122a.
114
858
.
,
.
, .
.859
:
, . 860
5. 6.
, ,
.861 ,
. : ,
.862
. , 863 ,
,864 . , ,865
.866
a . 867 :
,
....868
, .
858
, , PG 37: 1232a1233a.
859
, 56.
860
, , PG 112: 160a.
. (, 87 . 1).
861
Ouspensky-Lossky, 59; (-, , 1923).
862
, , PG 62, 29.
863
Mathews, 160171.
864
, , PG 155: 708b.
865
, , PG 36, 656b.
866
, 56.
867
Mathews, 163171.
868
, , PG 140, 418468,
( 445b-c, 21).
115
, .869
.870 ,
, , .871
,
,
, . .
872 873
.
.874
.875 ,
5.
, , .
, , .
, .876
869
, 57.
870
(Mango, On the History of the
Templon, 4043) 8. . . ( ,
, PG 99: 1796a).
871
, , 8.
872
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 15.
873
: H. Omont, Fac-simils des plus anciens
manuscripts grecs de la Bibliothque Nationale, Paris 1902, p. 31 and pl. Lx. :
(, 87, . 2 3).
874
. , 87, . 2 3.
875
, 57 . 21.
876
, 57.
116
6. ,
.877
10. 13. 878
.879 ,
, 12. 880
. 14.
. , ,
.881
, , .
, ,
, , .882
, .
, ,
,
.883 , .884
,
, .
885
II.
. ,
877
,
. , 58.
878
11. ( ,
, PG 127: 1120b) -
. (-, , PG 157: 61d).
.
879
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 338.
880
, 338.
881
, 59.
882
, 62.
883
, 62.
884
, , 5378.
885
, 87, . 2, 3.
117
.886
, 11. 12. ,
. ,
,
12. 13. .887
1208. .
,
.888 ,
. , 13. 14. ,
,
.889
, 4.
: ,
, . , .
, ,
.890
. ,
, , .
, .
. : ()
a ,
, . :
, . 891
: (...)
.892
, , .893
886
, 62.
887
, 88, . 6.
888
, 63.
889
15. , . , 63.
890
, , PG 37: 1232a.
891
, , PG 91, 672a.
892
, , PG 155: 345c.
118
,
, . 894
, .
.895 ,
.896 ,
, : ,
, ( 10, 7,9).897
: (...) ,
.
, . , ,
()
, (...).
, .
,
.898
, ,
.
, .
4.
. 4. 9.
. 899
. , 10.
, .900
893
, 61.
894
Goar, 20.
895
, 64.
896
19. , 44. , 69.
, , 293, 297, 179.
897
, 64.
898
, , PG 155: 720721.
899
, 64.
900
, 64.
119
, , ,
.901
, , ,
, , .902
:
, ,
.903
.
: , ,
, , ,
, ,
, ,
( 10, 1922). . :
,
,
(...) ,
,
,
.904
: (...) ,
905 , ,
: (...)
, , ,
.906
901
, , PG 155: 704c-d.
902
, , 140141.
903
, , PG 98: 400, 425d, 428a.
904
, , 141.
905
, , PG 155: 732b.
906
, , 141.
120
,
, .907
: (...)
, ,
, ,
, .
. ,
,
.908
-, ,
,
,
.909
,910 .911
,
, ,
.912
:
,
,
, . ,
.913 : ()
(...) (...) (...).914
907
, 69.
908
, , 143.
909
, 137.
910
, , PG 62, 29.
911
, 70.
912
, 85.
913
, , PG 91, 693c.
914
, , PG 91, 708d.
121
: () 915
.
, ,
, .916
,
.917
.
, .
, , , .
.918 ( 1, 10),
( 1, 10), .
,
( 3, 6) , ,
( 11, 52)
( 1, 10). , ,
, . ,
919 1680.
.920
,
, . 921
922 . , ,
.
915
, , PG 91, 708d.
916
, 86.
917
,61.
918
10, 20.
. , .
, , 327.
919
, , 245.
920
, , 4045.
921
Labrecque-Pervouchine, icnostase, 22.
922
. : ( . . .), ,
, ,
,
. ( , , 54).
122
, .
19. , :
,
.923
,924 , .925
, 926
. ,
, ,
.927 ,
( 11251150)
.928
929 .
, ,
.
,
, .930
,
, .
923
, , 174.
924
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 354356.
925
, 71.
926
, 87, . 3.
927
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 354.
928
. , 72, . 89.
929
,
. (1607).
,
,
. , 72, . 90.
930
. Ouspensky-Lossky, 63.
123
12. .931
, . 932
.
.933
,
,
.
:
, , :
,
,
( 44, 13).
,
.934
: , , ,
, , , , .935
(6. ) 936
(8. ) .937
, ,
, .938
, , ,
.939
931
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 343.
932
11. 12. ( 1082.,
, 1114. )
. , 73.
933
, 73.
934
, 74.
935
4, 8, 8, 10. , ; ; ; .
936
, , PG 97, 861b881b
937
, ', PG 96, 656b.
938
, , PG 96, 664c, 665d, 673d, 676c.
939
, 74, . 103.
124
.
,940 ,
. ,
, ,
.
.
,
,
.941
, : , , ,
, . ,
, .942
, ,
.
.943 .
,
.944 : ,
; , .945
.946
.
, 14. .947
940
, 5.
941
, 75, . 105.
942
, 3. , . , .
943
, 77.
944
,88, . 7.
945
, .
946
, , ,
. , 78.
947
,
, . 947
,
125
.948
, , ,
, ,
.
, .949
. 950
, ,
,
.951
. 15. .
,
.952
, ,
, .953
.
, 79.
948
, , PG 155: 321b.
949
,
,
. , 81.
950
-, , 145146.
951
, 82.
952
, , PG 155, 297b.
953
: ,
, ,
.
, : ,
, ,
. , , PG 91: 669b.
.
126
.954
.
.955
, ,
956, .
.957 ,
.
,
, 15. .958
, 959 ,
, . 960
.
( 15, 45).
( 15, 5). , ( 15, 1),
. .
: , ,
, .
, , .
, .961
.
.962 ,
954
-, , 145146.
955
, 83, . 158.
956
, , PG 155: 345c.
957
, 83.
958
.
18. .
, 84.
959
, 162.
960
, 84.
961
, , 60.
962
: ,
. , Argumenta ex codicibus Coislinianis, PG 150, 823.
127
.
.963
? . 964
, .965 ,
, ,
.966 , , ,
, . .
,967
(1 5, 5; . 12, 36) (: 13, 43).968
, ,
, , ( 22, 5).
, . , .
, , .969
.
.970
. , .
.
.
.
963
, , 599.
964
. , , 175.
965
, , 599.
966
, Argumenta ex codicibus Coislinianis, PG 150, 823.
967
: ,
, .
968
: ( 13, 43).
. (,
, 89).
969
,
, , . (
) .
, , ,
. , , 601.
970
, 84.
128
V
, 14. ,
.
,
.971 .
. , . , .
.
.
12. 14. ,
. 13.
, , .972
(1318. 1331. )
. ,
.973 ,
, , .
.974
, ,
.
, -
. 1191.
-
,975 ,976
971
, , 40.
972
, , 37.
973
, 37.
974
7. .
. . (, 37.)
975
10. 12.
. (, , 38).
976
, 139.
129
, ,
( , 1199. ,
).977
( )
13. ,
.
.978
.
1230. ,
. .
10.
.
,
. , ,
.979
. .980
13. . ,
,
.981
977
, ,
. ,
, 38.
978
, , 38.
979
, 40.
980
, , 41.
981
, , 20.
130
1.
,982 ,
1186. 12081209. .
. ,
, .
,
, . ,
, , 983
, .984
.985
,
. ,
,
.
.
, ,
( )
.986 987 ,
.988
, .989
? ,
982
80- 20. ,
. , , 141152, . 13, 79.
983
(12081209). , , 3133.
984
, , 2123.
985
, , 141152, . 13, 79; (, 3342, . 112).
986
, 141152, . 23, 7, 9.
987
, , .
, 3342, . 112.
988
, 36, . 4.
989
, , 42.
131
, , , ,
-.
, .990 . 991
,
9. 11. . 992
, .993 ,
,
, ,
.994
, ,
. 995
. 13. .
2011. , 2012.
.996
,997 -
. 998 ,
990
, 38, 4041, . 7, 912.
991
2011. () .
.
992
, , 42.
993
, 42.
994
, 42.
995
, 42.
996
, ,
. , 3342, . 112. : (, , 141152);
(, , 3950; 52 (. 3)).
997
.
, 35, . 2; 36, . 3.
998
( 12. )
.
, (...) , 36, . 4.
132
.999
. 1000
.
2.
1001
.
, . ,
12. ,1002 1003
.1004
1005 ,1006
, 1007 ,
,1008 .1009
,1010
, , .
, , 1011
999
, 39, . 8.
1000
.
.
. , 37, . 5, 6.
1001
, . , 94.
1002
, 109.
1003
. , 108109.
1004
, 85/2.
1005
95 .
1006
, 88/2.
1007
, 89, . 78.
1008
, 89, . 78.
1009
-, , 40, 42, 64, 66.
1010
, 89, . 78.
1011
. . . , 92, . 10 11.
133
.1012 ,
. 1013
-,
( )
.1014
3.
,
, . 1206. 1217.
.1015 ,
. 1016
. ,
. 1017
,1018 14.
, , .
.
,
. -
,
.
1217. , , 14. , .1019
,1020
.1021 .
1012
, 94.
1013
, 8594.
1014
-, , 66.
1015
.
1016
-, , 1517.
1017
, 5761.
1018
. -, , 115, . 2.
1019
-, , 58, . 26; 60, . 27.
1020
-, , 123, . 9.
1021
, ,
. , , 43.
134
, , 120 ,
, .1022
. , , .
,
.1023 , ,
. 1024
14. , ,
-.
. ,
, . 1025 ,
-
.
: - 14.
,
. . ,
, , , .
.1026
, , . ,
, , .1027
4.
. 1219. 1228. .
,
1022
, . -, : -,
, 125, . 11.
1023
, , 43.
1024
, 43.
1025
( 1938. ), ,
.
1026
-, 345357.
1027
. ,
III (13091316). , , 23, . 15 16.
135
.1028 ,
,
. 16. ,
, ,
. , ,
, -
.1029
13. , ,
: ;
,
, . 1030
-
. , ,
.
, ,
.
.1031
.1032 , ,
.1033 , ,
, .
1028
, , 44. . (-,
, 118, . 5).
1029
, , 44.
1030
, 44.
1031
-, 345357.
1032
. ,
XIII .
( ) , , , ,
,
13. . ,
, 23.
1033
Walter, Bulletin, 263.
136
5.
, , 1252. , ,
.
1034 .1035
, , ,
.1036
.1037 . -
,
.
, ,
.
.1038
-
.
.1039
,
.1040 -
, ,
.1041 ,
.1042
.
1034
119 . -, ,77.
1035
-, , 3233. , 19,
. IV.
1036
( . ) , , 53, . 7 :
-, ,78, . 6.
1037
, , 44.
1038
, 44.
1039
-, ,72.
1040
, 71.
1041
, 73.
1042
, 75.
137
.1043 -
.1044
1045 ,
.1046
, 14.
, , ,
.1047
6.
.
1245. 1260. . ,
, , .
1048
, .
.
,
, ,
1049 .1050
1043
-, , 233, . 231. ,
.
1044
-, , 76.
() . , 77.
1045
, 78, . 6.
1046
, . ,
2628.
1047
. (1574)
13. 14. . ,
, 24, . 13, . 4.
1048
. , , 146,
. 4, 5.
1049
, , 2329.
1050
, , 146, . 4.
138
, ,
.1051
13. .
,
.1052 , :
.1053 , ,
, 1054
. , ,
.1055
.1056
. , ,
.1057
50 .
1058
. ,
, .
, ,
,
.1059
1051
, , ,
.
1052
: , 147, . 4.
1053
, , 45.
1054
, . , 45.
1055
-, 17.
1056
, 17.
1057
.
, , , ,
. ,
-,
, , . ,
, 4546.
1058
.
1059
, 45.
139
7.
, 13. ,
, ,
.1060 - 1061
,
.
- 1062
. 1063
.
1064 .
.1065
, . : (...)
,
.1066 , .
-1067
.
, .
1060
:
, , 148, . 5 : (, , 145150, . 104113).
1061
. , , 47.
1062
, , 144150.
1063
19.
. , , 46.
1064
, . , 46.
1065
, , 145146, . 104105.
.
1066
, 144; 104105.
1067
(
). , , 46.
140
8.
,
1283. 1296. .1068 19.
.1069 , ,
-,1070
.
.1071 1072
. ,
. 1073
: (...)
, .1074 ,
, .
-
.1075
9.
13131314.
. ,
1068
-, , 8589. .
1069
, 1876. .
, .
-, , 412. 1826.
: (...) , 213. (-, , 232).
1070
, 235, . 232.
1071
, 234. ,
, 21,5 . , 232236.
1072
, ,
. , 235236.
1073
, 233, . 231. , .
1074
, 236.
1075
-, , 73.
141
, , . 1076
. 1077
.
. ,
,
, , .1078
10.
,
(10671071), 13121313. .
.1079
, . .1080 - ,
,1081
.
, , .
1082 .
14. , .
, , .1083
1084 , ,
13161318. 1085 -
1076
, , 4750, . 8.
1077
, 4750, . 8, : , , 3234, . 1114.
1078
, , 48.
1079
. , 14.
1080
, , 29.
1081
, , : 69, 73, 8386.
1082
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 18.
1083
, , 38, 123. : (,
, 173176); (, , 212223).
1084
, , : 69, 73, 8386.
1085
. : , ,
, , , 14. ,
. , , 219.
142
1086 1087
.1088
. 1089
, 1090
.1091
,
.1092
.1093 .
- ,
-
. ,
.1094
,
.1095
11.
.1096 ,1097
,
.
1086
, , 84.
1087
, 86. . Lasareff, Trois fragments, 138; (,
, . 7). : (-, 297319);
(Bljajev, 386394, . 12).
1088
, , 30.
1089
, , 8486.
1090
, 83.
1091
, , 30.
1092
, 30; , , 85.
1093
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 18.
1094
, , 8486.
1095
, , 48.
1096
-, , 6567.
1097
( . -) : , , 58, . 13.
143
,1098
, 1321. 1324. ,
1099 . ,
, .
, , ,
14. .1100 ,
, .1101
, .1102
17. ,
, ,
.1103
1330. ,
II, . .
.1104
, .
.
.1105 , ,
.1106
,
.1107
1724. 1594. .1108
1098
, , 1932. ,
. -, , 65.
1099
, . 105.
1100
( 4, 89 ) . -,
, 66.
1101
, , 49.
1102
, , 32, . 8 . 22.
1103
, 30.
1104
-, , 66, . 107.
1105
, , 49.
1106
. -, , 67.
1107
, . , , 32.
144
,
, 14.
16. .1109
1346. 1375.
, ,
, .1110 ,
.1111
.1112
12.
13271335. .
.
,1113
.1114 .
.1115 , ,
, 1116 .
.
1108
-, , 65.
1109
.
1110
, , 35.
1111
, 36.
1112
-, , 345357. (13401342),
( 1330), ( 13471348), (1348),
( 13401350), (1350), (1361),
(13651371), (13661371) .
, ,
(, , , , ). (,
), 37.
1113
, -, , 225226, . L L . 176.
1114
. , 226, . L.
1115
, 225.
1116
,
. , , 49.
145
,1117 , ,
.
.
13. 14. .
1118
1119.
,
.1120
1327. 1335. .1121
.
, , , 1122
.
,
.
,
, .1123
,
.
,
.1124
1117
.
1118
: , , 141152; (-
, , 114131).
1119
, -, , 225.
1120
.
1121
, , 115.
1122
, 116.
1123
( 13. ). , , 2141.
1124
, -, , 226.
146
, , :
,
.
( 1276)
( 1290) ;
( 1270), ,
XIII .1125
() .
1343.
, . .
,
.1126
,1127 -
:
,
, .
, ,
:
, ,
.
, ,
,
.1128
1125
, , 116.
1126
, 116.
1127
, 117.
1128
, 117.
147
13.
.1129
14. . .
.
.
14.
, 14. , ,
.
.1130 , ,
.1131
.1132 ,
, , .1133
,
. . 1134
.
14. . 1135
,
.1136 ,
, .
1129
( . ) : , , 60, . 15.
1130
, 4849.
1131
, , 50.
1132
,
. , 48.
1133
.
1134
.
1135
.
1136
, 48; Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 1322 (-,
, 828).
148
.
( ) 14.
.1137
, ,
, .
, ,
. ,
,
.
,
. 1138 ,
.
( 12. ), .
14.
,
.
, ,
. ,
13. , 1139
.1140 .
14. . ,
, . 1141
1137
, 49.
1138
, , 40.
1139
( )
102 135 . : 135 ; 126;
120 ; 108 ; 107; 102
129 . :
3, 20 ; ( ) 3, 15 ; 2, 5
; 2, 81 ; 2, 46 . -,
, 77.
1140
, , 39.
1141
, 50.
149
13. . , ,
,
.1142
,
.1143
. .
-
, .
13.
. , 14.
,
. . ,
,
,
- .
.
14. -
. -, ,
. , .
.
1142
.
1143
.
150
VI
,
.
, .
, ,
. ,
,
, ,
,
.
1.
, 1144
19. .
?
1482.
: ,
(...) ;
, . 1145
15. , , ,
: , .1146
, 16.
, : 7016 (1508. ),
(...)
1144
, 696.
1145
, 3.
1146
, 71.
151
, , .1147
15. , ,
16. . 1148
.1149
, 15.
. , , , :
6927 (1419. .) , (...)
, (...)
, ,
.1150 16.
, 15.
, . ,
15.
.1151
.1152 16.
. 1582. :
(...)
,
, ;
. ,
, ,
66;
,
( . . .).
;
1147
, 34.
1148
, 4.
1149
, 701.
1150
, 4.
1151
, 4748.
1152
, 698.
152
, ,
, ,
. ,
;
, ,
, ,
, ,
;
, ,
, .1153
15. ,
.
.
: . , , , ,
.1154
.
, , .
.
, , , , ,
.1155
. ,
.
.1156
, ,
, 1528. .
,
. ,
, , .
1153
, 5.
1154
, 701.
1155
, 58.
1156
, 67.
153
.
. ,
, 15.
.1157
16. ,1158
, , .
1529. : 7037. ,
, (...)
.1159
.
, , .
, ,
, , ,
, .1160
? . ,1161
:
, ,
,
,
.
, ,
, .1162
16. .1163
, . ,
1157
, 7.
1158
. .
1159
, 7.
1160
, , 332.
1161
, 334.
1162
.
1163
, 8.
154
,
1164 16. .1165
17. ,
. ,
, ,
.1166
, 17. .
, , . 1167
.1168
.
. 1169
17. , - .1170
, ,
.
, 16. 17. .
, 1171
1164
, .
1165
, 701.
1166
, 9.
1167
17.
. , 9.
1168
, 711.
1169
, 9.
1170
, 910.
1171
16. 17. : - ,
1591. , ; -
, 1604. ,
; ,
1642. , .
. -
1675. ,
, , .
, 10.
155
17.
16661667. ,
,
:1172
,
, . .
,
;
;
,
, ,
, ,
: . .1173
.
16. 17.
16661667.
.1174
.
,
.1175
.
,
.1176
, ,
, .1177 ,
1172
, 11.
1173
,, . . ).
1174
, 11.
1175
, 12.
1176
,, . . .
1177
, 12.
156
1666. 1667. , ,
.1178
, ,
. 1179 ,
, .
17. .
17. ,
.1180
.
. ,
17. .1181
, , .
17. .
, ,
. , ,
.
, .1182 ,
.
17.
, .
,
1178
, 13.
1179
, . .
17. . ,
,
. , 31.
1180
, ,
. , 13.
1181
, 60.
1182
, 15.
157
.1183
, , .1184
18. .1185
.1186
.
, , ,
.1187
,
1188 . ,
. 20.
.
.
.
. 1189
1190 .
.1191
, , .1192
, , 1193 ,
.
1183
, , ,
. , 16.
1184
, 70.
1185
, 21.
1186
, 22.
1187
, 2223.
1188
. , 41.
1189
Labrecque-Pervouchine, 20.
1190
. OuspenskyLossky, 62/2.
1191
().
1192
LabrecquePervouchine, 22.
1193
. OuspenskyLossky, 57/2.
158
.1194
.1195 . 1196
,
.1197 , ,
.1198
, .1199
, ,
.1200
, , ,1201
1202 , . .1203
1204 .1205
.1206
1194
Labrecque-Pervouchine, 22.
1195
, 41.
1196
.
,
, . , . OuspenskyLossky, 62.
1197
,
. OuspenskyLossky, 62.
1198
. , 43.
1199
. LabrecquePervouchine, 22.
1200
. OuspenskyLossky, 63. .
1201
, . ,
, , , ,
, , . , 42.
1202
, . ,
, . , 43
1203
.
( , , ), :
, , , /, ,
, , , / , ,
/ (
), ( ,
). ,
. , 4243. : OuspenskyLossky, 57.
1204
.
159
, ,
. , ,
, .
, ,
.1207
.1208
, ,
.
, .
,
. ,
. .
,1209 .
:
, .1210 1211
. 1212 (, )
:1213 , , .
.
,
, , .1214 ,
, .
1205
. . .
1206
.
1207
, 43.
1208
17.
.
1209
, ,
.
1210
OuspenskyLossky, 60.
1211
.
1212
. OuspenskyLossky, 60.
1213
, 5760.
1214
, 44.
160
17. , ,
: , ,
, , ( 19, 28),
, ,
. .
, , .1215
.
. , ,
, .1216
,
.
.1217
.1218
, . 1219 .
( .
), .
1215
, , . Ouspensky
Lossky, 57.
1216
,
. , 57.
1217
.
1218
, , , , ., . ,
.
, . ,
. , , 318.
1219
17. , ,
o : , ,
. 16.
, .
(1551)
( 1666. .),
. , , 321493.
161
.
. ,
.
. , , .
,1220 .1221
,
.1222 .
2. CONTRA
,
.
.
, .
, . ,
.
,
.1223 ,
, .
. -
.
. 1224
1220
, 325.
1221
. . ,
, ,
. . , 246.
1222
, , 325.
1223
, , 233.
1224
, 246.
162
, ,
.1225
, , , ,
.
.1226
, 18. 19. ,
,
.
19. 20 ,
.
.
.
. ,
. 1227
19. , 27. 1905. .
1228
,
.1229
1225
, 40.
1226
. II 1767. , ,
.
, , 513.
1227
, 196.
1228
19.
20. . , ,
. , , 134.
1229
, ,
,
163
.1230
19. 20. .1231
: . 1232
.1233
1234 .1235
.1236
.1237
,
.1238 28. 1917.
,1239
.
. ,
. ,
, . ,
, 131134. ,
,
.
, ,
(
) , , . (
I, 10.)
1230
, 196.
1231
, , 131134.
1232
, 196.
1233
: , 478483. (, , 131).
1234
Freeze, 305339.
1235
.
1905. ,
, , 1913. .
1236
Meyendorff, Russian Bishops, 148.
1237
, , 131; (, 197).
1238
I, 10.
1239
1918. Pospielovsky, The Russian Church, 33; (, 8).
164
, 20. ,
.1240
.1241
. ,
,
.1242
:
, ,
- .1243
- .1244
,
. 1245
.
, ,
.1246 1906. ,
,
.1247
,1248
.
1240
II, 597.
1241
, 223224.
1242
II, 598.
1243
, , 1027.
1244
, 1018.
1245
, 224.
1246
II, 599.
1247
, . . . , 599600.
1248
, 196197.
165
.
().
, , ,
.1249
1917. . 1250
-
, :1251
, ,
. (...)
,
.
,
,
, .1252
.1253 , 9. 1917.
.1254
.1255 ,
.1256
1249
, , 157159; (, 8791).
1250
II, 603.
1251
, 603.
1252
. . . , , 94.
1253
, , ,
. . , . II, 604.
1254
, 604.
1255
, .
1918. . , 604605.
1256
2. 1919, 17. 1921,
14. 1925. . , 605.
166
. ,
, :
.1257
, , .
, .
,
.1258
,1259
.1260 , ,
,
. , ,
(...) .1261
.
.
3. PRO
.
.1262 ,
1257
, 223.
1258
, , 134.
1259
, 223.
. , 224.
1260
. , .
,
, :
. , ,
, 324, 336.
1261
, 224.
1262
- ,
,
, .
167
,
.
.1263
, .1264
.1265
e.
.
. ,
. 1266
, , .
,
.
. ,
.
.
.
.
, .
, ,
, ,
, .
, ,
. ,
,
. Labrecque-Pervouchine, 25.
1263
Cheremeteff, 27.
1264
Labrecque-Pervouchine, 23.
1265
Ledit, Prface, 14.
1266
Labrecque-Pervouchine, 25.
168
, .1267
.1268
,
.
, , ,
.
.
.
.1269
.1270
.
. ,
, ,
.1271
.1272
.1273
.1274
1267
, 22.
1268
, 23.
1269
, 23.
1270
, 23. -
(Labrecque-Pervouchine, 235) : . , .
, . , . , . , . . .
1271
, 246.
1272
, 240. ,
, , . Ouspensky
Lossky, 57.
1273
, 248.
1274
, 243.
169
( ,
, ), .1275
.1276 1277 ,
, ,
, .
.
.
. :
, , .1278
1279 .
,
.
,
.1280
, ,
,
: .1281
, :
.1282
1275
:
, , (
) ( ). ,
, ,
(16661667). , 242.
1276
, ,
, , ( ), . , 242.
1277
: Haase, 128130, 162168.
1278
, 247.
1279
, . , 249.
1280
, 249.
1281
, 230. , , PG 37: 1232a1233a.
1282
, 230.
170
.
.
.
. : totus Christus, caput et corpus.1283
, . 1284 ,
- 15. ,
, ,
.
, ,
.
, ,
.1285
. , ,
, :
.1286
. 1287
.
.1288
1283
, 246.
1284
, , PG 155, 345c-d.
1285
, 250.
1286
, 247.
1287
. , ,
, , 1917. .
,
, .
(Labrecque-Pervouchine, 241, . 8).
1288
, ,
, , ,
. 1915. .
. .
171
: . 1289
,1290 .
. 1291
.1292 ,
,
.1293
, ,
. ,1294
.
1295 .
, , , ,
. ,
.1296
.
;
.
:
,
.1297 , , ,
, , .
1298
, 1299. ,
1289
, 14.
1290
, 20.
1291
, 10.
1292
, 20.
1293
, 2023.
1294
, 82.
1295
, 31.
1296
, 83.
1297
, 20.
1298
, 20.
1299
, 31.
172
.1300
: , ,
1301 .
.
.
.
. , . ,
, [] .1302 : ,
, ,
, .1303
, , ,
,
.
, . , ,
,1304
.1305
,
(...) (...) ,
, , , .1306
,
; . 1307 :
, , ,
.1308 ,
1300
, 26.
1301
, 28.
1302
, 36.
1303
, 37.
1304
, 38.
1305
.
1306
, 39.
1307
.
1308
.
173
, , ,
. ,
, .
.
, ,
- ,
.1309
,
,1310 ,
1311 .
, ,
.
.1312 , .
.1313 1314
, .1315
,
, , ,
. ,
, .1316
,
, ,
,
.
1309
. Dwirnyk, 2128.
1310
, 250.
1311
, 249.
1312
, 31.
1313
, 23.
1314
, 14.
1315
Labrecque-Pervouchine, 255.
1316
, 255.
174
,
.1317
, ,
.1318
, 1319
, .
.1320
,
,
.1321
.
4.
.
,
.
.
, , ,
, ,
.
, ;
, . ,
,
.1322
,
, ,
, , .
1317
, 256.
1318
, 7.
1319
, 48.
1320
, 39.
1321
Labrecque-Pervouchine, 257.
1322
, 251.
175
. ,
.1323
. ,
,
.
, ,
, , , .
. ,
,
.1324
,
-,
.1325 20.
,
.
.
, .
,
. , ,
.1326
. , .
1323
.
1324
, 252.
1325
, 20.
1326
, , 318.
176
, .1327
. ,
.1328 ,
a
,
1329 .
, ,
,
,
, .1330
.1331 ,
.
.
, , ! ( 2, 21).
,
, . ,
, ,1332
, ,
.
, ,
1333 .
1327
Labrecque-Pervouchine, 236.
1328
, 236.
1329
, 243.
1330
OuspenskyLossky, 63/2.
1331
, , 316.
1332
OuspenskyLossky, 63.
1333
, 41.
177
.
,
.
. , ,
. ,
,
. . . ,
,
.
20.
. , ,
. ,
. ,
. 12.
13. ,1334
.
.
,
, ,
,1335 . ,
.1336
, , ,
, ,
.1337 , ,
.
1334
Lasareff, La scuola di Vladmir-Susdal, 98; (Lasareff, 133).
1335
OuspenskyLossky, 6364.
1336
, 64.
1337
, , 317.
178
1338, ,
.1339 ,1340 . 1341
.1342
,
. ,
1343
.
1344
.
.1345
,
,
,
1346
. : ,
: , ,
, , , .1347
1348 .
1338
( ).
Pallas, 370.
1339
, 3.
1340
Alchermes, 49.
1341
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 326.
. Laurent, 428.
1342
Verpeaux, 189.
1343
Konstantynowicz, 33.
1344
, , 317/1.
1345
OuspenskyLossky, 64/1.
1346
, 89.
1347
, 89.
1348
Braun, 651.
179
1349 1350
, ,1351 .
, ,1352
.
,
, .
:
.1353 , , .
,
?
.
, , .1354
, .
,
. ,
( 24, 27).
,
. : , ,
( 22, 17).
.1355
.1356
,
1349
, 650.
1350
Konstantynowicz, 30.
1351
Pace, 195.
1352
, 89.
1353
, 149.
1354
, , 294.
1355
, 92.
1356
, , 344.
180
.1357 ,
-
.1358
,1359 .1360
.1361 ,
,
.1362 , ,
.1363
-
.1364 .
(...)
,1365 . . :
.1366
,
.
. , ,
1367 1368
1357
, 344345.
1358
, 40.
1359
. , , PG 99, 405a.
1360
, , 194.
1361
, 194.
,
. , 194.
1362
, 2010,
.
(. 194),
.
1363
, 89.
1364
, 130.
1365
, 37.
1366
, 37.
1367
, 39.
181
,1369 ,
.
.
.1370 ,
,
.
1371 ,1372 .
? .
,
1373 .
.1374 ,
1375
.1376 ?
,
, ,
,1377
.
: , ,
, .1378
,
, :
1368
, 48.
1369
, 39.
1370
, 130.
1371
, 39.
1372
, 48.
1373
Labrecque-Pervouchine, 236.
1374
, 251.
1375
, 40.
1376
, 251.
1377
, 39.
1378
, 39.
182
, .
:
1379
, 1380
, 1381 .1382
.1383
,
19. .
, .
.
.
19. :
(...)
. ,
.
- ,
17. . ,
, . ,
. ,
(...)
-
-
.1384
,
1379
, 123124.
1380
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas, 327.
1381
Walter, The Origins of the Iconostasis, 253.
1382
, 124.
1383
Grabar, art de la fin de Antiquit et du Moyen age II, 1158.
1384
, , , 342.
183
. ()
. ,
, ,
17. .1385
19. . 1386
.1387
20. . ,1388
.
,1389
.
, , 1390
! 1391
, . 17. . 1392
, 17. ,
. ,
.
19. .1393
1385
, 146.
, ,
(. III),
. , 146.
1386
0,71 .
1387
2, 13 . ,
. , , 157.
1388
, .
1389
II, 600.
1390
, 150.
1391
,157.
1392
, 155.
1393
19. . ,
184
, 1394,
. , , ,
.1395
.1396 :
,
. ,
,
, ,
, ,
,
. , ,
,
, ,
.1397
, ,
: ,
, .1398
1399
. 1905. , .
,
.
19. 20. .
. ,
. (, , 131134).
1394
, , 226227.
1395
, 227.
1396
II, 601.
1397
, , 158.
1398
, 157159.
1399
II, 601.
185
(...)
, . 1400
:
,
.
,
. ,
,
,
,
, . .1401
. ,
. , 1402
. .
, . ,
, .1403
. 1404
.1405
,1406 1407 .
.1408
. ,
, , ,
( ) 1409, . .
1400
, , 157159.
1401
, 158.
1402
, 39.
1403
, 150.
1404
, 39.
1405
, 150.
1406
, 37.
1407
, 251.
1408
, , 157159.
1409
, 7.
186
,
.1410
,
,1411 .
,
.1412
, , 1413
() .1414 ,
1415 .
, .
. :
(...) ,
,
: , ,
, .
,
, , ,
,
, ,
, ,
, (.
23,14).1416
. .
.
, ,
1410
, 150.
1411
, 39.
1412
, 150.
1413
, 39.
1414
, 37.
1415
, 150.
1416
, , 159.
187
, .1417
,
,
.
,
, .1418 1419
.1420
. :
(...) -: , ,
, ,
. :
,
.1421
, ,
.1422
, .
, ,
. ,
:
(...)
.
,
,
.1423
,
1417
II, 602.
1418
, 197.
1419
. . . , 197.
1420
, , 197.
1421
, 197.
1422
, 224.
1423
, 225.
188
. , ,
, , .1424
.
.
. ,
, ,
, ,
, . .
,
, . ,
, .
.1425
. ,
,
, , , ,
, , . 1426
, .
, ,
.1427
, ,
:
;
,
, , . 1428
1424
, 225.
1425
, , 145.
1426
.
1427
.
1428
, 146.
189
, ,
. ,
. .
.
?
.
. ,
, :
(...) , .
, , ,
.
. ,
: (...)
,
.1429
,
.
,1430 .
, , , , ,
.
(
) .
1431 1432
1429
, , 157159.
1430
, 40.
1431
, 37.
1432
, 251.
190
,1433 ,
.
19. ,
1905.
.1434
.
,
, .
, .1435
, : ( 5, 39).
,
.1436 , ,
20. .
.
, .
.
,
, , , .
.
: , ,
, , ,
- .1437
,
, 1438 . ,
1433
, 150.
1434
, , 13134.
1435
, , 227.
1436
, 227.
1437
, , 195.
1438
, , 157159.
191
.
,1439
, ,
,1440 ,1441
,
.
,
, .
.
, , ,
. .1442
,
,
.
.
.
, .
1443 .
,
, . .
. , (, )
, ( 14, 1820)
.
,
, .
1439
, , 224.
1440
, 224225.
1441
, 225.
1442
, , 61.
1443
, 89.
192
.
- 1444
. .
.
.1445
?
, ,
.1446
.
:
, , ,
,
. ,
. ,
, . ,
,
,
.
.1447
,
,
.
. , , ,
, .
.
, ,
.1448
1444
, , 20.
1445
, 40.
1446
, , 225.
1447
, , 15.
1448
, 15.
193
,1449
. :
; , (
8, 12). ( ) ,
(1 2, 8). ,1450
.
,
(1 1, 7), (1 2, 9).
, .1451
: ,
, , , .1452
,
, , .
, . 1453
, ,
, ( 2, 12),
, .
, : ,
, . ,
,
( 2, 1314). , , ( 2, 21),
( 3,12), .
.
. :
( . . .)
1449
, 150.
1450
, 150.
1451
, , 312.
1452
, 312.
1453
, , 146.
194
.1454
. 1455
.
e.
, . . .
.1456
, ,
, ,
.
,
.
, .
, , .
. ,
, . !
(...) .
,
, ,
.1457 (
)1458 ,
- .1459
-
1454
, 37.
1455
19 44 , 69 . (
, 293, 297, 179)
1456
, 126.
1457
, , 223.
1458
, 223.
1459
, , 223.
195
, , (. 2, 21). ,
, , . !1460
.1461
.
- .1462
,
. ,
-
.
.
,
, , ,
. 1463
.
, .1464
, .
, .
, ( ),
-. .
.
, ( 24, 27).
,
.
.
1460
, , 139.
1461
, , 345.
1462
, 40.
1463
, , 317.
1464
, 317.
196
VII
, , . ,
,
.
, ,
.
,
.
1.
,
. , , : . 1465
:
: ,
,
, :
.
( 11, 3).
( 1, 2; . 8, 23).
,
. , ,
, .1466
,
, ,
1465
, I, 244.
1466
, 245.
197
.1467 ,
. , .1468
, , ,
,
. , , ,
.
, , , , .
,
( 1, 1) . 1469 ,
,
-
.
, .
:
, ; ,
, .
.
.
, ,
,
.
, ,
.1470
. ,
, .
.
,
1467
Kidner, 45; (Etkinson, 2329).
1468
, , 66.
1469
, 137.
1470
, , 228.
198
.
, .
, .
.
, ,
, , ,
.
, . ,
, ( 8, 14)
, ,
.
, .
( 8, 38).
-
-
( 7, 1427).
,
.
.
, . ,
( 6, 1820; 9, 1213),
( 10, 1921).
( 26, 1; . 36, 8).
( 27, 21),
.
.
199
( 4, 617),
( 24, 3).
, ,
( 27, 51; 15, 38).
,
, , .
( 2, 14).1471
: ,
, , ;
,
( 27, 5153) .
( 28, 2),
. , .
, ,
.
,
.1472 , ,
.
,
. , ,
. ,
( 37, 114). ,
, . ,
.
.1473 (1, 47; 1, 13; 2, 2, 5, 7, 9, 16)
, ,
( 6, 1920; 9, 3;
10, 20; . 4, 16).
1471
, 68.
1472
.
1473
, 69.
200
,
,
.
( 10,
20),
( 27, 51; 15, 38; 23, 45).1474
, ,
.
, .
,
. ,
,
. ,
.
,
.
,
, .
,
, . .
, ,
. . .
, ,
, .1475
1474
( ),
. ,
.
1475
( 2527; 3638),
. ,
201
, ,
. ,
, . 1476
:
,
( 21, 1314).
( 15, 5), .
.1477
.1478
,
, , .
.1479
,
, (. ),
.1480
1481
1482
.
,
. (, 58).
1476
-
. , 5960.
1477
.
1478
.
, - ,
( 21, 2123). , 60.
1479
, 61.
1480
, 6364.
1481
, Commentarius liturgicus, PG 87, 3: 3984d.
1482
, , 98. 389d.
202
, ,
, ,
1483 .
,
. ,
, (
), .
,
.
.1484
( . 4 5; . 1 7, 2326; 6, 911; 11, 19;
15, 6; 16, 1; 16, 17). ,
( 21, 22).
( 3, 12; 14, 1; 21, 210),1485
( 21, 22) .
( 21, 22), .
, : ,
, . (
3, 12).1486
. ,
(. 22, 4; . 25, 6).1487
. 14, 1, , .
.1488 ,
. ,
,
.
1483
, 62.
1484
, 6566.
1485
Mounce, 219220; 262263; 271271.
1486
, 111112.
1487
, 155162; 251; 349350.
1488
Briggs, Studies, 108.
203
( 22, 4).
. (1 13, 8), ,
. , ,
, .
(. 7, 9) .
.
(1 13, 8), ( )
.
1489
.1490 .
,
. ,
.
2.
. ,
.
.
.
, ,
, .1491
, . .
. ,
,
, , ,
, , ,
.1492
1489
, , 119.
1490
, , 183.
1491
, , PG 94, 1345.
1492
, , PG 94, 1345. :
Mansi, XII, 1066BC; . (, 278).
204
, ,
. 1493
, ,
, , , .
,
.1494
,
, . .
, .
,
.
,
.
, . 1495
, .
,
.1496 , ,
.
, . ,
, , ,
, . .1497
, . ,
, .
, ,
, .
.
.
.
1493
, 279.
1494
, 278.
1495
, , 193.
1496
, 193.
1497
, 271.
205
.1498 . ,
.
, ,
. ,
.
. .
, ,
.1499
. ,
, .1500
,
. 1501
1502
.1503 , ,
-
. , ,
,
,
. ,
,
.1504
1498
, 31.
1499
Walter, Further Notes on the Desis, 181.
1500
, 181.
1501
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 334.
1502
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 20.
1503
, , PG 110, 993.
1504
Lasareff, 135.
206
,
1505 .
.1506 ,
, -
, ,
,
.1507 .
,
.
,1508
.
.1509
. 15. 16. 1510
.
3.
. ,
.1511 ,
.
, ,
, , .1512
1505
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase, 22.
1506
Lasareff, 130, 134
1507
Fundi, 42.
1508
, , 40.
1509
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles, 342.
1510
, , 3, 7.
1511
, , 136.
1512
, 136.
207
, , ,
. ,
,
.1513
, , . 1514
- - - .
, ,
, ,
.1515
.
. .
(18. ), :
.1516
, .
,
.
.
.1517 ,
, .1518
. .
, , , ,
1513
Taft, The Liturgy of the Great Church, 52.
1514
, , 136.
1515
, 136.
1516
, 136.
1517
, I, 14.
1518
, , 137.
208
. , . 1519
,
( 5, 25) , ( 5, 25), . ( 4,
23), .1520
, .
.
.
( 10, 6).1521 ,1522
.
.
.1523
4.
, ,
, :
,
,
.1524 , ,
. .
: , ,
.1525
1526 , ,
.
1519
, , 228.
1520
, , 120.
1521
, 93.
1522
, , PG 98, 384b.
1523
, , 343/2.
1524
, , 183.
1525
Mansi, XIII, 344a.
1526
, 274.
209
:
.1527
.
( [1 13, 12])
.1528 ,
, .
,
, .1529
, ,
,
. ,
,
.1530
, . 1531 ,
, ,
, .1532 , ,
,1533 , .
, .
,
, ,
, ,
.1534
1527
, 70.
1528
, , 365.
1529
, , 119.
1530
, , PG 94, 1412a.
1531
, , 2121.
1532
, 33.
1533
, 33.
1534
, 33.
210
.
.1535
.
, ,
, .1536
, .
:
. .
. .
, ,
, .
.1537 ,
,
,
, , ()
.1538
, .
, ,
( 1, 11).
,
, , , ,
, . .
, , , ,
, .1539
1535
Mansi XIII, 237c.
1536
, , PG 151, 472d473a.
1537
, 18.
1538
, 18.
1539
, , 45.
211
.
, .
:
, .1540 ,
, . ,
. : ,
.
. , .
, .
. - ( 25, 31),
( 25, 34, 41).
- ( 22, 4).
.
.1541
- .
.
5.
,
( 2, 14; . 2, 17). .1542
,
1540
Ergo quicumque Christi salvatoris imaginem non adorat, is in secundo Christi adventu non videat ipsius
faciem. Mansi XVI, 399, : (Hefele-Leclercq, 522). 869/870.
I II
.
4. .
,
. (, 237).
1541
, 193.
1542
, , 225.
212
. , ,
.
, .
.
,
.1543
, ,
,
,1544
.1545 ,
.1546
. ,
.
: ,
.
1547 .
,
,
, ,
- .
,
,
.
.
1543
, , 134.
1544
, , 223.
1545
, 223.
1546
, , 138.
1547
, 138.
213
, .
.
.
.
,
, , ,
. , , , .
,1548 , .
( 24, 27).
!
.
.
, , ,
,
.
.
, .
.
, .
1549
.
1550
, (1 2, 5). ,
1548
, XV.
1549
, , PG 151, 472d-473a.
1550
, , PG 37: 1232a; ( , , PG 35: 988c);
( , , PG 91, 672a); ( ,
, PG 98, 384b); ( , , PG 155: 720d721a); (
, , PG 155, 306362).
214
,
,
, . , ,
, .
.
,
.
.
.
.1551 .
,
.
, ,
, .1552
. , .1553
, .
.
,
.1554
,
,
,
, ,
. ,
1551
Mansi XIII, 261e-264a-c.
1552
, , 145.
1553
, 145.
1554
, 146.
215
, .
, , ,
, , ,
, ,
,
: .
216
.
.
.
.
, ( 21:24;
22:34), .
.
,
.
, .
.
.
.
, ,
, , .
.
domus Dei .
, .
.
,
. 4.
.
.
217
.
.
. ,
, , , .
, .
: , , , , .
,
. ,
, .
, .
.
:
,
.
7. . . ,
.
.
. .
19.
. ,
, ,
1900. .
, .
, .
, ,
218
.
. 4. 5.
, ,
, .
.
.
,
. .
.
, .
, , ,
.
.
, , ,
, .
.
.
, .
,
.
.
. ,
, .
,
(J. 2, 1921; M. 15, 38).
,
.
219
, 10.
.
12.
.
12. , ,
,
. ,
.
12. .
.
13. . ,
. 14.
,
. .
.
.
.
.
. ,
. ,
, ,
.
, ,
,
,
. ,
, .
.
220
, ,
. , 11. 13. ,
, , .
, , .
. , . ,
:
. ,
.
, , ,
.
,
, . ,
, .
.
.
, .
,
, , ,
.
,
.
.
, ,
.
. 10. ,
.
, , .
. 4. 9.
221
.
.
,
.
. , ,
, .
, ,
.
,
. ,
,
. 12. ,
. 14
.
, , 14. .
.
13. . , ,
,
.
.
13. ,
. ,
14. .
, ,
.
.
,
14. - . -,
,
.
222
. 15.
, : ,
.
18. , ,
, .
19. 20. ,
, 1905. , , ,
. .
.
,
.
.
. ,
, .
,
,
, ,
.
.
.
.
.
, ,
, .
. .
, ,
.
, ,
223
, ,
.
,
-
.
, . ,
.
,
,
, ,
. , ,
, ,
.
, , , ,
, .
,
.
.
, , ,
, ,
, .
!
,
,
,
. .
. , ,
.
,
.
,
224
,
.
.
225
:
, Sermones de sanctis = , Sermones de sanctis, CCX, 2, PL 38,
1413.
= , , PG 97, 861b 881b
Actes d'Esphigmnou = Actes d'Esphigmnou, Ed. Lefort, J., etc. (
Archives de l'Athos vol. 6), Paris 1973.
Actes de Saint-Pantlmn = Actes de Saint-Pantlmn. Ed. P. Lemerle, etc. (
Archives de l'Athos, vol. 12), Paris 1982.
= , -
1999.
, , = , ,
, 1, PG 29: 4-208C.
Verpeaux = Verpeaux, J., Pseudo-Kodinos. Trait des offices [Le Monde Byzantin 1.
Paris: Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, 1966], 130287.
Gautier, Le typicon du Christ Sauveur Pantocrator = Paul Gautier, Le typicon du
Christ Sauveur Pantocrator, De la Revue des tudes byzantines, tome 32, Paris 1974,
1145.
Gautier, La Diataxis de Michel Attaliate = Gautier, P., La Diataxis de Michel
Attaliate, De la Revue des tudes byzantines, tome 39, Paris 1981, 5143.
Gautier, Le Typicon de la Thotokos vergtis = Gautier, P., Le Typicon de la
Thotokos vergtis, De la Revue des tudes byzantines, tome 40, Paris 1982,
5101.
Gautier, Le Typic du sbaste Grgorie Pakourianos = Gautier, P., Le Typic du
sbaste Grgorie Pakourianos, De la Revue des tudes byzantines, tome 42, Paris
1984, 5145.
Gautier, Le Typicon de la Thotokos Kcharitmn = Gautier, P., Le Typicon de la
Thotokos Kcharitmn, De la Revue des tudes byzantines, tome 43, Paris 1985.
5165.
Goar = Goar, Jacobus, , Sive rituale Grcorum, Venetiis 1730.
226
, = ,
, PG 157: 25122.
, =
, , PG 98: 384453.
, = ,
, PG 35: 9851044.
, = , , PG 37: 11221233.
, = , , PG 36,
624a664c
, = ,
, PG 44: 298-429D.
, Argumenta ex codicibus Coislinianis = ,
Argumenta ex codicibus Coislinianis, PG 150: 800844.
, = ,
, PG 110: 411287.
Dagron, Vie et miracles de sainte Thcle = Dagron, G., Vie et miracles de sainte
Thcle, Brussels 1978.
, = ,
, PG 3: 119369.
, =
, , PG 3: 369586.
= , .,
, III, 2005.
, = , .,
, 1728, II, 2002.
A, = ,
, PG 127: 9921128.
, =
, , PG 20: 9101232.
, = ,
, , PG: 20, 849880.
, =
, , , PG 20: 1316C-1440C.
227
, = ,
, PG 95: 345385.
,
= ,
, PG 96: 12511319.
, = , , 648b661a.
, = , , 662b680c.
,
= ,
. , PG 120: 11231200.
, , ( ) = ,
, ( ), PG 52: 799802.
, =
, ,
PG 49: 351362.
, =
, , V, PG 63: 9236.
, = , , PG 62, 23a 30.
, = ,
, PG 49: 362372.
, , ( ) =
, , ( ), PG
63: 133138.
, = ,
PG 48: 747756.
, = , ,
2008.
, = ,
, PG 9: 9-205C.
== , ,
,, ..
,, ,, . ( :
http://www.twirpx.com/file/891444/)
228
, =
, , PG 112: 73844.
Laurent = Laurent, V., Les Mmoires du Grand Ecclsiarque de lglise de
Constantinople Sylvestre Syropoulos sur le concile de Florence (14381439), CNRS,
Paris 1971.
Les constitutions apostoliques = Les constitutions apostoliques, t. I, livres I-II, (ed. M.
Metzger), Sources Chrtiennes 320, Les ditions du Cerf, Paris 1985.
, = , , PG 91:
657717.
Mansi = Mansi J. D., Acta Conciliorum Oekoumenicorum nova et amplissima
collectio, Florentia 1759.
Miklosich-Muller = Franciscus Miklosich Iosephus Muller, Acta et diplomata
graeca, volumen III, Vienna 1865.
= , , .
, = ,
, PG 146: 747920.
, =
, , PG 100: 206533.
= , ,
2002.
, , = , , , PG 12:
297395.
, = ,
, PG 86b, 21202158.
- = -, .., Varia graeca sacra:
IVXV
, -
- , XCV, 1909.
, = ,
, PG 87: 28282837.
- , =
, , PG 157:
613634.
229
, = , III:
, , ,
, 22, 1905, 10181035.
, = ,
, PG 155: 697750.
, =
, , PG 155: 305361.
, = ,
, PG 155, 253264.
, = , , PG 66: 15871615.
, , ( ) = ,
, ( ), PG 67: 8431630.
, Commentarius liturgicus = ,
Commentarius liturgicus, PG 87,3: 39814001.
, =
, , PG
87,3: 34243676.
, = , ,
, 2006.
= , ,
1994.
Theodoros Studites, Jamben auf verschiedene Gegenstnde = Theodoros Studites,
Jamben auf verschiedene Gegenstnde, ed. P. Speck, Berlin 1968.
,
= ,
, PG 140, 418a468d.
, =
, ,
, PG 133:
11011221.
, = ,
, PG 99: 17801812.
230
, = , , PG 80:
77226.
, = , , PG 80:
225297.
, = ,
, PG 82: 8791279.
, = , , PG 132: 9
52969.
, = (Theophanes
Continuatus [ ]),
, PG 109: 225369.
Typikon of Timothy for the Monastery of the Mother of God Evergetis = Typikon of
Timothy for the Monastery of the Mother of God Evergetis, Byzantine Monastic
Foundation Documents: A Complete Translation of the Surviving Founders Typika
and Testaments, Volume 1, ed. by J. Thomas and A.C. Hero, Dumbarton Oaks Studies
XXXV, Washington D.C. 2000.
Hefele-Leclercq, = Hefele, C. J., & Leclercq, H. D., Histoire des Conciles, aprs les
documents originaux, tome IV, premire partie, Paris 1911.
Constantine VII Porphyrognte = Constantine VII Porphyrognte, Le livre des
crmonies, ed. A. Vogt, Paris 19351939.
231
= [], .,
?, , 14, 1914.
, = [], ., ?
( ), , 14, 1914.
Alchermes, = Alchermes, J., The Middle Byzantine Chancel Barrier, Byzantine
Studies Conference, bstract of papers, Third Annual, Columbia University, New
York City, 1977.
Arranz = Arranz, M., Index liturgique, Le Typicon du monastre du Saint-Sauveur
Messine, Orientalia Christiana Analecta 185, Roma 1969.
, = , ., , 1987.
, = , .,
, 11, 1975.
, = , .,
, 2, 1967.
I = , ., I, ,
2007.
II = , ., II, ,
2007.
= , .,
, XLIV, 2012,
, 2012.
Bljajev = Bljajev, N., , Byzantinoslavica,
ronk II, Sbornk pro studium byzantsko-slovanskch vztahu, v Praze 1930.
, =
, . .,
, ,
XIVXVI , [. 5], 1970/1, 1970.
232
= . .
, .
XIVXVI , [. 5], 1970/2, 1970.
Bleckwith = Bleckwith, J., The art of Constantinople, an introduction to Byzantine art
3301453, Phaidon-London-New York 1961.
Blenkinsopp = Blenkinsopp, J., Joseph, Sage, Priest, Prophet: Religious and
Intellectual Leadership in Ancient Israel, Louisville, KY, Westminster 1995.
Bogay = Bogay, v. T., Deesis und Eschatologie, Internationale Zeitschrift fr
Byzantinistik, Byzantinische forschungen, herausgegeben von Adolf M. Hakkaret und
Peter Wirth, Band II, Amsterdam 1967.
, = , .,
, , ,
, . VI, 1931.
, = , .,
, , XI, 1932.
Bouyer = Bouyer, L., Liturgy and Architecture, Notre Dame Indianna 1967.
Branham = Branham R. J., Sacred Space Under Erasure in Ancient Synagogues and
Early Churches, The Art Bulletin, Vol. 74, 3, sep. 1992.
Braun = Braun S. J., Der Christliche Altar In Seiner Geschichtlichen Entwicklung,
Zweiter Band, Mnchen 1924.
Brhier = Brhier, L., Anciennes cltures de chur antrieures aux iconostases dans
les monastres de lAthos, Atti del V Congresso Internazionale di Studi Bizantini,
vol. 6, Roma 1940.
Briggs = Briggs, A. R., Studies in Biblical Literature (Supplement), 10: Jewish
Temple Imagery in the Book of Revelation, New York 1998.
= , ., , 21999.
, = , .,
, 7, 2005.
, = ., ,
. ., 1897. = , . ,
1972.
233
Wagner = J.Wagner, Le lieu de la celebration eucharistique, in La Maison Dieu,
70, 1963.
Walter, iconographie des conciles = Walter, C., iconographie des conciles dans la
tradition Byzantine, Paris 1970.
Walter, Further Notes on the Desis = Walter, C., Further Notes on the Desis,
Revue des tudes Byzantines, Tome XXVIII, Anne 1970, Institut Franais dtudes
byzantines, Paris 1970.
Walter, Bulletin = Walter, C., Bulletin on Desis and the Paraclesis, REB 38, 1980.
Walter, The Byzantine Sanctuary A Word List = Walter, C., The Byzantine
Sanctuary A Word List, Pictures as Language: How the Byzantines exploited them,
The Pindar Press, London 2000.
Walter, A New Look at the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier = Walter, C., A New Look at
the Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier, Pictures as Language: How the Byzantines exploited
them, The Pindar Press, London 2000.
Walter, The Origins of the Iconostasis = Walter, J., The Origins of the Iconostasis,
Eastern Churches Review III, 1971.
Wenham = Wenham, G. J., Sanctuary Symbolism in Garden of Eden Story, Ninth
World Congress of Jewish Studies Division A: the Period of the Bible, Jerusalem
1986.
Weitzmann, The Icon = Weitzmann, K., The Icon, London 1978.
Weitzmann, Illustrations to the Lives of the Five Martyrs of Sebaste = Weitzmann, K.,
Illustrations to the Lives of the Five Martyrs of Sebaste, Dumbarton Oaks Papers,
Vol. 33, 1979.
Weitzmann, Icon Programmes of the 12th and 13th Centuries at Sina = Weitzmann, K.,
Icon Programmes of the 12th and 13th Centuries at Sina,
, (1984), 1986.
Wharton = Wharton A. J., Art of empire: painting and architecture of the Byzantine
periphery, a comparative study of four provinces, Pennsylvania State University Press
1988.
= , ., , ,
1901.
, = , .
XX , - - 2001.
234
, = , .
,
, 2007.
, = , .,
:
XVIII , 2008.
, = , ., ,
, 2012.
, = , .,
, , , 2013.
= , .,
, , -I-, 1904.
Giros = Giros, C., Remarques sur larchitecture monastique en Macdonie orientale,
BCH 116, 1992.
Gnilka = Gnilka, J., Teologija Novoga zavjeta, Zagreb 1999.
= , .,
, 1872/II.
i, = i, .,
i, i
, I, i , ii i,
, 1881.
i, i = i, ., i
, I, i , ii i,
, i , , 1904.
, = , .,
( ), 1913.
Gorman = Gorman, F. H., The Ideology of Ritual: Space, Time and Status in the
Priestly Theology, Journal for the Study of the Old Testament, Supplement series 91,
Sheffield 1990.
Grabar, Lempereur dans lart Byzantin = Grabar, A., Lempereur dans lart Byzantin,
Paris 1936.
235
Grabar, Un nouveau reliquaire de saint Dmtris = Grabar, A., Un nouveau
reliquaire de saint Dmtris, Dumarton Oaks Papers 8, Cambridge-Massachusetts
1954.
Grabar, Les ampoules = A. Grabar, Les ampoules de Terre Sainte, Paris 1958.
Grabar, Deux Notes sur l Histoir de l Iconostase = Grabar, ., Deux Notes sur l
Histoir de l Iconostase d aprs des Monuments de Yugoslavie,
7, 1961.
Grabar, Sculptures byzantines de Constantinople = Grabar, A., Sculptures byzantines
de Constantinople: (IVe-Xe sicle), Paris 1963.
Grabar, PACh = Grabar, A., Le Premier Art Chrtien, Paris 1966.
Grabar, art de la fin de Antiquit et du Moyen age II = Grabar, A., art de la fin de
Antiquit et du Moyen age, II, Paris, 1968.
Grabar, L'esthtisme = Grabar, A., L'esthtisme d'un thologien humaniste byzantin
du IXe sicle, Lart de la fin de lAntiquit et du Moyen ge, I, Paris 1968
( : Revue des Sciences religieuses, 1957).
Grabar, Sculptures byzantines du Moyen Age II = Grabar, A., Sculptures byzantines
du Moyen Age II (XIe-XIVe sicle), Paris 1976.
Gretser-Goar, PG 157, 304CD = Jacobi Gretseri ... in librum Georgii Codini
Curopalatae De Officiis et officialibus magnae ecclesiae et aulae Constantinopolitanae
Commentariorum libri tres. In: Patrologia Graeca (sive Patrologiae cursus completus,
Series graeca). ed J. P. Migne, Paris: Imprimerie Catholique, 18571866. T. 157, pp.
123 .
Grosdidier de Matons, Les Miracula sancti Artemii = Grosdidier de Matons, J., Les
Miracula sancti Artemii: note sur quelques questions de vocabulaire, Mmorial
Andr-Jean Festugire, Genve 1984.
236
= , ., , ,
, XV, , 167, 2006.
, = , .,
, ,
I, , ,
, 1895.
= . ., , , 7, 1907.
Douglas, Jacobs Tears = Douglas, M., Jacobs Tears: The Priestly Work of
Reconciliation, Oxford University Press, Oxford-New York 2005.
Dlger = Dlger, F., Mnchsland Athos, Mnchen 1943.
Du Cange, = Du Cange-Du Fresne, Glossarium ad scriptores mediae et infimae
graecitatis, duos in tomos digestum, Lugdunum,1688.
Duguid = Duguid, I. M., Putting Priests in Their Place Ezekiels Contribution to the
History of the Old Testament Priesthood, Ezekiels Hierarchical World: Wrestling
with a Tiered Reality (eds. Stephen L. C., and Patton, L. C.), Atlanta 2004.
Dwirnyk = Dwirnyk, J., Rle de iconostase dans le Culte Divin, Montral 1960.
= , . ., ,
, , 1938.
, = .,
, 1964.
, = .,
, .... (. . . .), 37, 19691970.
= , ., Imagines clipeatae
XIII , , 2008.
, = , ., , 1961.
, = , ., ,
1974.
Djuri = Djuri, V., Uber den in von Chilandar, Byzantinische Zeitschrift 53,
1960.
237
, = . .,
( ,
- ), ,
910, 1917.
Expressions, New York 1986.
Epstein = Epstein, A. W., The Middle Byzantine Sanctuary Barrier: Templon or
Iconostasis?, Journal of the British Archaeological Association 134, 1981.
Etkinson = Etkinson, D., Poruka Prve knjige Mojsijeve 111 Osvit stvaranja,
Beograd 2003.
= , . .,
, 1865.
Zovatto = Zovatto, P. L., La pergula paleocristiana del sacello di S. Prosdocimo di
Padova, Rivista di Archeologia Cristiana, XXXIV, Roma 1958.
= , . ., , 1995.
, = , ., ,
1999.
, = , .,
, , , 1996.
, = , ., ,
, - 20042.
, = , .,
( , 1990. ),
--- 2010.
, 1 = , ., ,
, , ,
, 1, - 2007.
238
= , ., .
, , 2003.
= , ., , ., , 2001.
, = .,
, , 1958.
Cameron, The Theotokos in 6th century Constantinople = Cameron, ., The
Theotokos in 6th century Constantinople, The Journal of Theological Studies 29,
1978.
- = , ., , ., ,
1985.
, = , .,
, 1200. ,
, , XLI, , 11,
1988.
, = , ., , ,
2005.
, = , .,
,
, , 2007.
= . ., :
, London 1990.
= , . .,
, () , 1898.
= , ., , ,
, 1928.
Kearney = Kearney, J. ., Creation and Liturgy: The P Redaction of Ex 2540P,
Zeitschrift fur die Alttestamentliche Wissenschaft 89, Berlin 1977.
= , ., , ,
2006.
Kidner SZK = Kidner, D. SZK: Postanak, Novi Sad 1990.
239
Kitzinger, Byzantine Art = Kitzinger E., Byzantine Art in the Period between
Justinian and Iconoclasm, Berichte zum XI Internationalen Byzantinisten-Kongress,
Mnchen 1958.
Kitzinger, The Art of the Medieval West = Kitzinger E., The Art of the Medieval West,
Bloomington-London 1976.
Clifford, The Cosmic Mountain = Clifford R. J., The Cosmic Mountain in Canaan and
the Old Testament, (Harvard Semitic monographs, 4), Cambridge, MA, Harvard
University Press, 1972.
Kline = Kline, M. G., Images of the Spirit, Grand Rapids 1980.
= , ., , ,
XLIV, ,
2012.
Cobb = Cobb, G. P., The Architectural setting of the Liturgy, Study of Liturgy, (Ed. by
Ch. Jones et all.), London, 1978.
Cole, NZK: Galaanima = Cole, R. A., NZK: Galaanima, Novi Sad 1986.
Konstantynowicz = Konstantynowicz, J. B., Ikonostasis, Studien und Forschungen,
(erster band) Band I, Lemberg (Lww) 1939.
Kohn = Kohn, R. L., Priest, Prophet, and Exile: Ezekiel as a Literary Construct,
Ezekiels Hierarchical World: Wrestling with a Tiered Reality (eds Stephen L. Cook
and Corrine L. Patton), Atlanta 2004.
, = , .,
, 5, 1975.
, = , ., , schola cantorum,
, , 2001.
Krauthajmer-uri, Ranohrianska i vizantijska arhitektura = Krauthajmer, R., i
uri, S., Ranohrianska i vizantijska arhitektura, Beograd, 2008.
Kreidl-Papadopoulos = Kreidl-Papadopoulos K., Bemerkungen zum justinianischen
Templon der Sophienkirche in Konstantnopel, JBG (Jahrbuch der sterreichischen
Byzantinischen Gesellschaft) 17, 1968.
Xydis = Xydis, S. G., The Chancel Barrier, Solea and Ambo of Hagia Sophia, The
Art Bulletin, 29, 1, 1947, 124.
240
= , ., , . .
. ., . , . 4, 1927.
241
= , ., , - 20022.
Liddell-Scott, Greek-English Lexicon = Liddell, H. G. and Scott, R. A., A Lexicon,
Greek-English Lexicon, New York-Chicago-Cincinnati. s. a.
Lowrie = Lowrie, W., Christian Art and Archaeology, London 1901.
= , .,
, , ,
IXX, 19581959.
, = , ., ,
, 1989.
, = , ., - ,
, 1994.
, = , .,
, 1995.
Meyendorff, Russian Bishops = Meyendorff, J., Russian Bishops and Church Reform
in 1905, Catholicity and The Curch, New York 1983.
, = , .,
, 1971.
Mamobury = Mamobury, E., Topographic de Sainte-Sophie, le sanctuaire et la solea,
le mitatorion, le puits Sacr, le passage de St Nicolas etc, Atti del V Congresso di
studi bizantini 2, Roma 1940.
= , ,
90, 2006.
Mango, The Art of the Byzantine Empire = Mango, C., The Art of the Byzantine
Empire 3121453, sources and documents, New Jersey 1972.
Mango = Mango, C., On the History of the Templon and the Martyrion of St.
Artemios at Constantinople, 10, 1979.
Mango-Parker = Mango, C. and Parker, J., A twelfth-century description of
st.Sophia, Dumbarton Oaks Papers, 14, Washington, District of Columbia 1960.
242
, = , ., ,
, - 2003.
, = , ., ,
2004.
Mateos = Mateos, J., Index liturgique Le Typicon de la Grande glise, Tome II,
Orientalia Christiana Analecta 166, Roma 1963.
Mathews = Mathews, T., Early Churches of Constantinople: Architecture and Liturgy,
S.L., Pennsylvania State University, 1977.
Megaw = A. H. S. Megaw, The Skripou Screen, The Annual of the British School at
Athens, Vol. 61, 1966.
, = , ., ,
III,
, 2005.
Medi, Une version slave de Erminia = Medi, M., Une version slave de
Erminia de Denys de Fourna datant de 1728, , , 2003.
Millet = Millet, G., Monuments Byzantins de Mistra, Paris 1910.
- = , ., , .,
, ,
XLIV ( ), 1877.
- = -, ., -
, III, . 2, 1955.
Miljkovic-Pepek = Miljkovic-Pepek, P., La fresque de la Vierge avec le Christ du
pilier situ au nord de iconostase de Sainte Sophie a Ohrid, dokumenta XI-og
Medjunarodnog Vizantijskog Kongresa, Minhen 19581960.
Morris, NZK: Prva Korinanima = Morris, L., NZK: Prva Korinanima, Novi Sad
1984.
Morris, NZK: Ivan = Morris, L., NZK Ivan, Novi Sad 1988.
Mounce = Mounce, R. H., NZK: Ivanovo Otkrovenje, Novi Sad 1991.
= , ., , . 1, 1971.
Muilenburg, The Form and Structure of the Covenantal Formulations = Muilenburg,
J., The Form and Structure of the Covenantal Formulations, Vetum Testamentum 9,
Leiden 1959.
243
= , ., .
, Zbornik zatite spomenika kulture, knjiga XIX, Beograd 1968.
- = -, .,
, ,
, . XLIX, , . 4, 1956.
-, =
-, .,
, , ,
, CCLXXIX, , 5, 1957.
NaumannBelting = Naumann, R., und Belting, H., Die Euphemia Kirche am
Hippodrom zu Istanbul und ihre Fresken, Berlin 1966.
Neusner = Neusner, J., Self-fulfilling Prophecy: Exile and Return in the History of
Judaism, Boston 1987.
= , ., :
, V, 1929.
The Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium I = The Oxford Dictionary of Byzantinum I, ed.
A. P. Kazhdan, Vol. 1, Oxford 1991.
The Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium II = The Oxford Dictionary of Byzantinum, ed.
A. P. Kazhdan, Vol. 2, Oxford 1991.
= . ., ,
, XXIII, 1953.
244
Pallas = Discussion, Manolis Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles
et la transformation du templon (Tab. XXXIVXLVIII), Actes du XVe congrs
international tudes byzantines, Athnes-Septembre 1976., 1979.
= , . .,
10 18 , ,
2008.
= , ., 11 13
., ' ,
1987.
Pasini = Pasini, C., Vita di s. Filippo d'Agira attribuita al monaco Eusebio, OCA, 33,
Roma, 1981.
= , .,
, 1960.
Patton = Patton, C. L., Priest, Prophet, and Exile: Ezekiel as a Literary Construct,
Ezekiels Hierarchical World: Wrestling with a Tiered Reality (eds Stephen L. Cook
and Corrine L. Patton), Atlanta 2004.
= ., XI XII ,
,
1962.
, = , .,
, , 1978.
, I = , ., I,
2003.
- = , ., , .,
, , 1.
1900 12. 1914.
Pospielovsky, The Russian Church = Pospielovsky, D., The Russian Church Under
the Soviet Regime, 19171982, Volume 1, New York 1984.
, = , .,
, ,
11, 1975.
245
Radoji = Radoji, S., Ikone Srbije i Makedonije, Beograd 1961.
= , ., , , 2004/2005.
, = ., ,
, 2010.
, = .,
, 2010.
Ratzinger = Ratzinger, . Duh liturgije Temeljna promiljanja, Mostar-Zagreb 2001.
Rebi = Rebi, . Biblijske starine, Zagreb 1983.
Restle = Restle M., Die Byzantinische Wandmalerei in Kleinasien, Recklinghausen,
1967.
- = , ., , .,
, , -, 1928.
Rodley = Rodley L., Cave Monasteries of Byzantine Cappadocia, Cambrige 1985.
Salaville = Salaville, S., Bulletin de liturgie, Echos dOrient 28, Paris 1929.
= ,
, , 2005.
= , .,
, , ,
, . VII, 1932.
Sinkevic = Sinkevic, I., The Church of St. Panteleimon at Nerezi, Reichart Verlag
Wiesbaden 2000.
= , .,
, , 510 ,
2005.
= , ., , 1971.
= , ., ,
, , 1892
, .- , . ., . 132,
1891.
246
, = , .,
, , ,
, 1892 , .- ,
. ., . 132, 1891.
, = , .,
, , ,
, 1892 , .-
, . ., . 132, 1891.
, = , .,
, , ,
, 1892 , .- ,
. ., . 132, 1891.
, , = , .,
, , ,
, , 1892
, .- , . ., . 132,
1891.
, I = , . .,
- , I, -, 1893.
, II = , . .,
- , II,
1895.
, III = , . .,
- , III,
1903.
Sodini = Sodini, J. P., Une iconostase byzantine Xanthos, Actes du colloque sur la
Lycie antique, Paris 1980.
Sodini-Kolokotsas, = Sodini, J. P., and Kolokotsas, K., Aliki II: La Basilique Double,
Etudes Thasiennes X, Paris 1984.
Sotiriou = Sotiriou, G., Guide du Muse Byzantin dAthnes, De lAcadmie
dAthnes, directeur du Muse Byzantin, Athnes 1932.
Stern = Stern, T. H., Cahiers Archologiques 3, 1948.
Stibbs = Stibbs, A. M., NZK: 1Petrova, Novi Sad 1989.
247
Stoufi-Poulimenou, A Byzantine Architrave with a Deesis = Stoufi-Poulimenou, I., A
Byzantine Architrave with a Deesis from the Monastery of St Nicholas Glemes at
Pikemi, Arcadia (Greece), Jahrbuch der sterreichischen Byzantinistik, 61.
Band/2011, sterreeichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Wien 2011, . 14.
Strange, = Strange, J. F., The Idea of Afterlife in Ancient Israel: Some Remarks on the
Iconography in Solomon's Temple, Palestine Exploration Quarterly 117 (Jan.-June),
London 1985.
Schwartz = Schwartz, B. J., A Priest Out of Place Reconsidering Ezekiels Role in
the History of the Israelite Priesthood, Ezekiels Hierarchical World: Wrestling with a
Tiered Reality (eds Stephen L. Cook and Corrine L. Patton), Atlanta 2004.
Swift = Swift, E. H., Hagia Sophia, New York 1940.
, = , .,
, 1931.
, = , ., , .,
, . `, 1958.
Turner = Turner, W. H., From temple to Meeting House: The Phenomenology and
Theology of Places of Worship, Hague-New York 1979.
Taft, The Liturgy of the Great Church = Taft, R., The Pontifical Liturgy of the Great
Church According to a Twelfth-Century Diataxis, OCP, 1979, 45; 1980, 46.
, = , .,
, : , 2005.
, = , .,
, : , 2005.
= , , , ., 1988.
Tiktin = Tiktin, H., Rumnisch-deutsches wrterbuch, 3., berarbeitete und ergnzte
Auflage von Paul Miron und Elsa Lder, band II, D-O, Clusium, Cluj-Napoca 2003.
Thierry, Nouvelles glises rupestres de Cappadoce = Thierry N., et Thierry, M.,
Nouvelles glises rupestres de Cappadoce, Paris 1963.
Thierry, A propos des peintures dAyvali ky (Cappadoce) = Thierry, N., A propos
des peintures dAyvali ky (Cappadoce), Les programmes absidaux trois registres
248
avec Dsis, en Cappadoce et en Gorgie, 5,
, 1974.
, = ., , 1993.
, = , .,
, 36, 2012.
, -, = , , .,
-, ., , 2005.
- = -, .,
, , IV, 1964.
= , . ., ,
, .4, 1894/I.
= , ., ,
, 2006.
11 =
, 11, , 1967. (19621968)
= , ., ,
, 1976.
= D. I.
, ,
1991.
-,
XIV = -, .,
XIV
, , , 1958/59.
-, = -, .,
,
, , 5, 1965.
orovi-Ljubinkovi = orovi-Ljubinkovi, M., Les Bois Sculpts du Moyen ge
dans les Rgions Orientales de la Yougoslavie, Rsum,
, , ,
5, 1965.
249
, = , .,
XVII , 2004.
= , ., , 44, 1963.
, = , .,
, 1997.
Ouspensky-Lossky = Ouspensky, L. Lossky, V., Le sens des icns, Paris 2003.
250
Haase = Haase, F., Die Russische Ikonostase und ihre liturgische Bedeutung,
Liturgische Zeitschrift, Breslau 1929.
Hager = Hager, H., Die Anfnge des italienischen Altarbildes, Mnchen 1962.
Chatzidakis, Ikonostas = Chatzidakis, M., Ikonostas, Reallexicon fr byzantinische
Kunst III, Stuttgart 1973.
Chatzidakis, volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles = Chatzidakis, .,
volution de icne aux 11e13e sicles et la transformation du templon, Actes du
XVe congrs international tudes byzantines, Athnes Septembre 1976,
. 92, 1979.
Haran = Haran, M., The Ark and the Cherubim: Their Symbolic Significance in
Biblical Ritual, Israel Exploration Journal 9, Jerusalem 1959.
= ,
. , , I, ,
, ,
, , , XVII, -.
1928.
= , CHIL AS 156, 1995.
= , T.,
, 10,
, , 1998.
Hewitt = Hewitt, T., NZK: Hebrejima, Novi Sad 1986.
Hickley = Hickley, D., The Ambo in Early Liturgical Planning A Study With
Special Reference to the Syrian Bema, The Heytrop Journal 4, (VII) 1966.
Holl = Holl ., Die Entstehung der Bilderwand in der griechischen Kirche, Archiv fr
Religionswissenschaft, band IX, Leipzig 1906.
, = , ., ,
, I`, 1956.
, = , .,
, ,
. , . 4, 1964 1965.
251
, = , ., , Studies in
Byzantine art and archaeology, London 1972.
- , = -, .,
, ., ,
, , 1986.
-, = -, .,
, ,
, ,
1988.
-, = -, .,
,
XX XXI, 1988/89.
-, = -, ., ,
, ,
XIII I, 1995, . 26 27.
-, = -, .,
, ,
, XIII ,
, 1995.
-, = -, .,
, 15941994,
, 1997.
-, = -, ., ,
, , 2002.
-, = -, .,
, ,
, XIII ,
2006.
-, = -, .,
, XXXIX, 2007.
252
-, = -, .,
, II, 1965, . I.
Cheremeteff = Cheremeteff, M., The transformation of the Russian sanctuary barrier
and the role of Theophanes the Greek, University of Oregon 1987 (
[Graduate School]
, 1987, Order Number 8800515).
= , . .
, , (-
. . ), 2000.
= , . ., - I. .
. , 1906.
, = , .,
,
12, 1976.
253
25. 1971. .
,
1990. .
1995. 9, 10.
-
,
1996. .
, 2002/2003.
.
10. 2008. :
, .
. .
1.
-a .
IV XVII
: ,
,
,
/
.
, _________________
_________________________
2.
: .
: IV XVII : ,
: ,
/ ________________________________________
/
.
, ,
.
, .
, ________________________
_________________________
3.
IV XVII
: ,
.
/
.
(Creative Commons) /.
1.
2. -
3.
4.
5.
6.
( ,
).
, ________________________
____________________
1. - ,
, ,
, .
.
2. . ,
, ,
.
.
3. - . ,
, ,
,
.
. ,
.
4. - .
, , ,
.
.
5. . ,
, , ,
. .
6. - . ,
, ,
.
. ,
.