Professional Documents
Culture Documents
May-Jun 2006 Atlantic Coast Watch Newsletter
May-Jun 2006 Atlantic Coast Watch Newsletter
In the wake of Hurricane Katrina (Atlantic CoastWatch, November-Decem- MD Critical Area in Trouble 6
ber 2005), casualty insurance companies quickly began to study how to adjust to the
related threats of global warming, coastal population growth, and increasingly Menhaden Overfished? 7
frequent and violent storms. Some, we added, had already moved beyond
research to action, redlining areas from Massachusetts to Florida where they
would no longer supply coverage even to longtime customers. z
Board of Directors With so much of Floridas coastal waters being dredged and our coastline
being rebuilt, it is essential that environmental regulations are in place to protect
Freeborn G. Jewett, Jr., Chair near-shore reefs and sea grass beds (habitats important to healthy recreational
Robert J. Geniesse, Chair Emeritus and commercial fisheries) and the full spectrum of coastal resources.
Roger D. Stone, President
Dale K. Lipnick, Treasurer It is these coastal resources that define Florida and support tourism and
Gay P. Lord, Secretary coastal recreation. Consequently, Florida has an extensive regulatory and permit-
Hart Fessenden ting framework in place to protect these resources and ensure that the newly built
David P. Hunt beach resembles as much as possible the natural beach in appearance and func-
Simon Sidamon-Eristoff tion. Sand grain size and color, clay and carbonate content, and compaction
qualities are all regulated.
Advisers
While preserving sea turtle nesting habitat is a prime motivation behind
William H. Draper, III some of the sand quality requirements, it is important to remember that Floridians
Gary Hartshorn need the same basic things as sea turtles healthy sandy beaches, thriving near-
Stephen P. Leatherman shore reefs, clean and pollution-free coastal waters, and healthy sea grass beds. In
Jerry R. Schubel other Atlantic coastal states sand quality is not so closely monitored, and as a
Christopher Uhl consequence beach quality is sometimes compromised. In some areas the rebuilt
beaches no longer resemble the soft white sandy beaches of the past.
Staff
By protecting sea turtle nesting habitat, we ensure that future generations
Roger D. Stone, Director & President of Floridians will also be able to enjoy the healthy natural beaches to which we are
Shaw Thacher, Project Manager all accustomed.
Robert C. Nicholas III, Contr. Editor
Anita Herrick, Correspondent
Feds Waffle on Beach Protection
Foundation Donors
In a lengthy article, New York Times science reporter Cornelia Dean
Avenir Foundation describes many costly efforts to use seawalls and dredge sand as ways to prevent
The Fair Play Foundation beaches and wetlands from migrating naturally. Offering persuasive arguments
The Madriver Foundation that such initiatives will often prove futile, especially in parts of Florida and along
The Moore Charitable Foundation North Carolinas Outer Banks, Dean then describes her effort to obtain comment
The Curtis and Edith Munson from James Titus, a knowledgeable EPA official.
Foundation
The Summit Fund of Washington In 2000, Dean reports, Titus, the agencys project manager for sea level
rise, published an essay stressing the need for the nation to make decisions on
Sponsored Project whether or how wetlands and beaches should be allowed to migrate inland.
Without such policy, Titus stated, what the government is saying is that wetlands
Environmental Film Festival in the and beaches are important, but whether they survive for the next 50 or 100
Nations Capital years is not our problem.
March 15 - 25, 2007
When Dean reached Titus by phone, he told her he was no longer allowed
Featuring screenings of documentary, to comment publicly on such matters, and referred her to Bill Wehrum, the agencys
feature, archival, childrens and acting assistant administrator for air and radiation. His bland comment: it seems
animated films. quite likely that people will want to protect developed areas and might be willing
www.dcenvironmentalfilmfest.org to let undeveloped areas like wildlife refuges or coastal farms migrate.
3
People
Courts & the Seashore Dead by his own hand is the journalist,
yachtsman, and environmentalist Phil
Merrill, 72. A board member of the
z Last year the US Supreme Court, in a controversial 5-4 decision, upheld
Chesapeake Bay Foundation (CBF) for
the city of New London, CTs use of eminent domain power to evict homeowners in
many years, Merrill donated the $7.5
the modest Fort Trumbull neighborhood. The city sought this power to make way
million needed to build its handsome
for an upscale hotel, office, and condominium complex. The Court thus affirmed the
and very green headquarters near
right of municipalities to make way for private development generating tax rev-
Annapolis. Out for a solo spin on the
enues. Recently another shoe dropped. After a long period during which the city
Bay on a breezy Saturday afternoon,
attempted to reach settlements with all seven of the community residents who had
Merrill disappeared from his 41-ft.
taken the battle through the court system, its city council voted 5-2 to allow the city
sailboat. His body, tied to a small
attorney to obtain a court order to demolish the homes of the last two holdouts.
anchor and bearing a gunshot wound,
was recovered more than a week
z In another closely-watched case, the US Supreme Court unanimously
later. Merrill was the publisher of
ruled that a Maine power company, S.D. Warren, must comply with state require-
Capital-Gazette Newspapers whose
ments even though, the company argued, the five dams it owns and operates on
principal product, the Annapolis
the Presumpscot River do not discharge anything and are therefore not subject
Capital, is a source frequently cited in
to regulation under the Clean Water Act. No matter whether water flowing out of
this newsletter and in the Coastal
such dams contains pollutants, wrote Justice David Souter, the word discharge
News Nuggets section of our website.
has a plain meaning of flowing or issuing out and thus covers outflows from
Said John Page Williams, CBF natural-
hydroelectric dams. The ruling, requiring the company to maintain minimum stream
ist: He loved the water, loved the bay
flows and provide fish passageways, affects some 1,500 hydro power dams that
and believed it could be saved. He
may not emit pollutants but, said the Bangor Daily News, do alter rivers and the
passionately wanted that to happen.
surrounding landscape. Said Rebecca Wodder of American Rivers: This is a
victory for rivers, for clean water, and most of all for good old common sense.
Environmentalists apprehensions
about management policy for national
z For decades both developers and environmentalists have been fighting
parks (Atlantic CoastWatch, January/
pitched battles over what constitutes a wetland. Hopes that the US Supreme Court
February 2006) lessened when, in an
would clarify the situation this year came to naught, however, when the justices
early declaration, new Interior
issued sharply divided opinions on two pivotal Clean Water Act cases and re-
Secretary Dirk Kempthorne reaf-
manded them to a federal appeals court. Under the Clean Water Act, the federal
firmed conservation as the primary
government has jurisdiction over navigable waters, legally defined as the
job for the National Park Service.
waters of the United States. The logic, says the Washington Post, is that protect-
Recent drafts of new management
ing navigable waters is impossible without protecting the waters that empty into
guidelines for the service had stressed
them. But the legal question of how far upstream the Clean Water Act goes has
recreation, arousing fears of ex-
troubled courts for years. In one of the two recent cases, Michigan developer
panded freedom for snowmobiles, off-
Keith Carabell sought to fill wetlands to build condominiums but, reported Associ-
road vehicles, and cell phone towers.
ated Press, the US Army Corps of Engineers balked, saying the property had
But, stated Kempthorne amid wide-
wetlands within the Lake St. Clair drainage system even though they were sepa-
spread sighs of relief, conservation of
rated from a tributary ditch by a man-made earthen berm. In the second case,
natural and historic places would
Michigan developer John Rapanos had filled in a property with sand to build a
prevail over recreation or energy
shopping center, insisting that no wetlands were involved since the nearest
development in instances of conflict.
navigable waterway is 20 miles away. In their ruling, four justices (Roberts, Scalia,
Preservation, he said, is the heart of
Alito, and Thomas) favored sharp cutbacks in Clean Water Act protections. But the
these policies and the lifeblood of our
five others favored continuing broad government power to protect wetlands. The
nations commitment to care for these
critical vote in the 5-4 decision was that of Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, who
places and provide for their enjoy-
agreed that the Corps should remain empowered, but cheered the developer
ment.
community by asking the lower court to establish where there is a significant
nexus between the properties in question, and navigable waters.
Awards