Professional Documents
Culture Documents
მედიის წინასაარჩევნო მონიტორინგი 1 აპრილი - 31 ივლისი, 2016 შუალედური ანგარიში
მედიის წინასაარჩევნო მონიტორინგი 1 აპრილი - 31 ივლისი, 2016 შუალედური ანგარიში
მედიის წინასაარჩევნო მონიტორინგი 1 აპრილი - 31 ივლისი, 2016 შუალედური ანგარიში
1 - 31 , 2016
:
:
, FPU-
:
, , , ,
, , , ,
, ,
:
/ IBDesign
(MDF)
,
.
.
2016,
MDFGEORGIA.GE
MEDIAMETER.GE/GE
2016 1 31
, -
.
,
;
, .
,
.
. Free Press
Unlimited- (FPU) .
: ( 20:00 -), 2 ( 21:00 -),
( 20:00 -), ( 20-), ( 20:30-), (
19:00), GDS (20:30). 1 ( 19:30)
16 .
2016 1 31
. 1 1
(- ); (,
GDS- ) . 1
-
.
- ,
- .
, :
/ ;
(//); ;
; - ,
- , , ,
, .
,
:
, , ,
, , -
No.R(99)15.
.
. ,
,
. -
12
.
"
, . ,
1
http://mdfgeorgia.ge/geo/view-library/33
1
,
.
(1 -31 ) , "
155 ,
0,18%-. ,
, , 3 .
.
, 8
8 , 53
, - .
2
,
.
5
,
.
. I -
, / ,
, ,
. -2
. -3
, -4 . -5
, -6 - ,
.
: (,
, , );
3 4
; ,
5
, 1%- ;
,
. , 1%- ()
; ,
, , 1%- .
2
MDF , 19 , 2016 http://mdfgeorgia.ge/geo/view_news/463
3
.
4
, - , .
5
.
2
4
1. - 7
2. - 10
3. - 11
3.1. ; 11
3.2. 2; 15
3.3. ; 20
3.4. ; 24
3.5. GDS; 30
3.6. ; 34
3.7. ; 38
3.8. . 41
4. 47
5. 50
6. 51
6.1. 51
6.2. PIA 56
6.3. 61
6.4. 65
6.5. 69
7. 75
8. 79
82
3
- 4 (1 - 31
) ,
,
, ,
, .
:
(34,6%)
. (41,2%) GDS- (41,1%)
, - 2 - (25%).
-
(27,4%) 2-(25,1%) , -
(15,8%). ,
.
- (56,5%),
(36,4%) .
( - 62,8%; -
30,7%) .
7 (15,5%),
2- (19,7%) , - (9,8%).
, (10,2%)
, .
(15%) , -
2- (4%). 2- (35%),
- GDS- (6%) (8%) .
(18%), 2-
(32%) (28%) . GDS- (8%)
(12%) .
" "
(9%) 2- (8%), - (30%) (29%).
- -
(0,7%), (0,1%).
,
, (9%),
2- (48%) .
(17,5%) , (14,2%)
(10,7%) ,
.
, , , , ,
, , - 3%- .
,
. ,
: ,
,
.
, , , -
, (GDS, , )
,
.
,
(,
; " " ).
,
, . 22
6
,
6
(22 , 2016),
. http://bit.ly/2bd0wWZ
4
.
,
(, GDS), ,
.
(16%), ,
(84%). (19%),
- , GDS- (15%) .
( 77%),
(65%).
4 ,
.
,
25
, .
17 , 5
, 1 , 1
, 1 .
(13) -
. (5)
, 2
, .
5
. PIA- (54,6%) IPN-
(53,9%) , - (33,1%).
,
(IPN PIA) 2016
7
.
-
(27%), IPN- (14.4%) .
.
-
64,6%-, 2,3-
(28,2%). (71,2%) PIA-
.
. (13,9%) (13,7%) ,
2,5%- .
PIA (5%).
(29%), PIA- (5%)
. : PIA (1%)
(2%).
(17%) (11%) .
-
(24%), - IPN- (8%) (8%).
(25%)
, - (2%) PIA- (3%).
(8%)
, - IPN- (1%) PIA- (2%).
(72%) PIA- (43%) .
- -
, 2,2%-.
6,5%-; 0,5%
- 0,01%.
,
: (14%) ;
7
MDF (16 , 2016),
http://mediameter.ge/ge/research/reklamis-da-inpormaciis-gavrcelebis-miznit-mediashi-sabiujeto-resursebis-ganacilebis
5
(1%).
(31%), - PIA- (8%) .
(21,8%).
(10,6%) (8,4%).
,
(7,2%).
,
.
.
, -
,
(, )
.
,
, .
( , PIA)
, .
- (, )
- , .
,
, . IPN,
, .
,
.
,
(PIA, ).
, , (15%)
(85%);
PIA- (19%), (12%) .
(58%), (50%).
, - (11)
.
2
, 1
.
6
1. -
- 4 (1 -31 )
, (34,6%)
- " " (21,9%) , (56,5%) .
- (64,6%) 8%-
.
, "
" (15,5%) .
: " " (4,7%), " " (4,5%), "
" (1,3%), - (1%) " " (1%).
1%- : " " (0,8%),
" " (0,5%) " " (0,5%).
,
(1,7%). (0,9%), (0,4%)
(0,3%).
2,1% .
- 6,3%-. - 0,7%,
- 0,1%.
1.1 ,
1.2. 1%- ,
7
/
. 1.3. ,
(
38%,
32%). 3 ,
( 23%, 20,3%), ( 7,4%, 5,3 %) ( 0,8%,
0,4%).
, , ,
. ,
(0,1%).
1.3. ,
. ,
(21%) , 7% .
(17%) (17%),
(9%) (5%) .
(
10%, 3%) ( 7%,
2%) .
(
16%, 4%) , -
(
10%, 2%).
( 7, 3%).
(96%) "
-
" ,, 2-2%
2 .
1%- (25%)
, (7%) .
(7%)-,
(7%) 1% .
( 4%, 1%) (
3%,
2%) . ( 5%, 2%)
( 6%, 3%) , .
(9%) (2%),
(
12%, 3%).
100%- .
8
1.4. ,
.
. ,
-
.
, ,
.
2- (48%) ,
(35%), (34%), (33%)
(32%) . 26% , GDS-
- 22%.
(9%),
- (6%). 2-, GDS-
(5%) , ,
(4%).
1.5. ,
9
2. -
- (10 229 ) 4 (1 -31 )
,
(17,5%)
. (14,2%),
( ,
2-, ,
,
.. ),
- , .. ,
. (10,7%)
,
. (9,4%)
(9,1%).
2.1. TV
-
8
2016
, ,
( , , ,
/, )
. - ,, ,
,
1,6 %- % .
, ,
(1,5%), (1%),
(0,5%) - (0,9%)
.
8
NDI (, 2016),
https://www.ndi.org/files/NDI_June_2016%20poll_Public%20Issues_GEO_VFF%20(2).pdf
10
3. -
3.1. -
: 1956
-
, , 2004
. , 2 2
,, ,
9
, ,
.
9
. TVMR ,
2015 (ARM) 0,74%,
(SHR) 3,92% .
. 4 (1 - 31 ) (1763 )
, -
(13) , 1% 1%- .
(39,2%) (16,5%) , 55,7%
.
: "
" - 1,5%,
" " - 1,1%, " - "
- 1,1% ,
" " -1%, "
" - 0,7% ""
- 0,6%.
(1,4%),
(1,1%), (0,6%)
(0,3%).
7,6%-, - 1%.
3.1.1. , -
9
http://www.tvmr.ge/ka#!ka/news/44/
11
4 ,
.
- ,
(
39,1%, - 39,4%) (
( 16,7%-,
- 16,2%) . ,
.
"
" (-11,9%,11,9%, - 13,9%),
( - 5,7%, - 9,3%), (
- 1,8%,
- 2,4%), " "
( - 1%; - 1,7%) (
- 0,7%,
- 1,3%) , .
, .
3.1.2 , -
. (99%), 1%-
.
:
(96%), 1%,
3% ; "
- "
(94%), 3%-
3% ; "
" (93%), 6% 1%
.
(15%) ,
1%- , (14%),
5% .
(13%),
(12%) . 8%-.
(8%), " "
(6%),
(6%), "" (4%), "
" (3%), "
" (3%) .
, , :
( 16%, 1%), "
"
( 13%, 3%) " " ( 10%,
1%).
(9%) "", 4%-.
12
3.1.3. - -
.
(47,7%) " " (22,3%) ,
70%- .
( 22, 2%). 30% .
(37,3%) , ,
.
" "
- 10%, 2- -
20,3%-. " "
- 6,3%, - 0,5%-.
" " - 3,5%, - 0,2%-.
0,2% "
" (2,2 %), (0,3%) ,
""
(1,6%), (0,3%) .
(2,3%), 2- (4,7%).
-
(6,1%), - 0,2%.
0,2%
3.1.4
-
,
13
,
.
, ,
,
. , ,
.
/ . 22 ,
(22 , 20:01 )
, , 10-
, " "
. :
,
, " "
.
.
,
, ,
, . ,
,
. , ,
,
.
, ,
.
/ . 30 20:00 ,
.. . 5
,
.. ,
, .
, :
, - 3 , ,
, (" ") ,
.
,
, . ,
,
, .
, ( 2-, , )
.
,
( 2) (" " " ")
.
. 17 (20:21 ) ..
. ,
.
,
.
, .
,
, .
/ . 28
2- - GFK-
.
,
(, , 2012
14
;
).
. ,
, (" " - 22,4%; "
" - 21.7%; " " - 7.8%), ,
, , 8
, ?, : (10%)
, / (19.4 %),
(3.9%).
.
.
:
,
, . 2- .
, 2200 .
2- ,
, , -
, .
14 , (20:23 ), 2-, ,
, GHN
.
.
, ,
,
. ,
.
( , , , ..) .
3.2. 2
10
2- : 1994 2 ,
. 2003 ,
, 2004-2012 2- 20-
. 2004 ,
.
.
2016 4
2- .
,
11
. TVMR , 2015
2 (AMR) 5,43%
, (SHR) - 28,78%.
. 2- 4 (1 -31 ) ,
- (1 728 )
(28,2%) (25,1%) ,
53,3% .
, (19,7%) "
" , " " (7,5%) "" (3,3%)
. 2- -
10
Mediameter, MDF, 2, http://mediameter.ge/ge/media-profiles/rustavi-2
11
http://www.tvmr.ge/ka#!ka/news/44/
15
(1,6%), - 1%-
: " " - 0,7%,
- 0,7%,
" " - 0,6%, "
" - 0,4%, "
" -
0,1%. 1,9% .
(2,9%)
,
:
"" - 0,4%
-
0,3%.
5,2%-, - 0,6%.
3.2.1. , 2
( 26%, 12,8%)
.
" " (
( 11,2%, 3,3%)
.
,
:
- 36%, 21,3%;
- 31,2%,
19,7% .
3.2.2- ,
,
.
, 1%-
.
(6,3%) (4,2%),
,
(3,8%) (1,9%) .
3.2.2. , 2
16
. 2
(96%), (96%), " " (91%),
1%- (91%), (88%),
" " (88%) " " (84%) .
(35%) " " (32%) .
(11%), " " (8%)
" " (8%), . "
" - 8%, "" 1%-.
(18 %, 2%), "
" (11%, 1%). .
- 4,5%, 15.8%-.
3.2.3. - , 2
.
" " (29,5%), - 7,8%.
- 25%, 47,1% .
-15,9%, 0,5% . " " (14,1%),
(38,7%) ;
(10,6%) (0,2%) .
: " " -
- 1,1%, - 0,02%; "" - - 0,9%, - 0,1%;
1%-, - 2,8%;
- 0,5%, - 0,4% .
17
3.2.4. - 2
2,
, .
(67%) 2- ( 49%,
44%, 21%, 24%, 22%, 20%, GDS
14%). .
,
, ,
.
/ /
. 11
(21.33) - " "
.
, 200
, ,
.
,
1 .
: 10 000
.
, . ,
.
.
, ,
,
,
.
,
. , ,
,
, -
,
.
,
.
. 18 2- ..
. (21:08 21:15)
,
18
, . 5
7 4
.
" ",
.
, , ,
7- (2 , 4 , 1 )
.
,
.
. 3 (22:00 ),
32
.
.
, ,
.
. 28 (21:59 ) -
.
,
. , .
, ,
3 , 11 .
, ,
, .
/ . 28
2- -
GFK- .
11 10 , 1 ,
. GDS-
, GFK- BCG- ,
, . ,
, 2-
, .
" "
, ,
, GFK- . 2-
, (22,4%)
12
(21,7%) , NDI- 5%- .
, "" , -
, (14 , 21:11 ), ,
. ,
, , ,
. ,
, ' " " " 3%-
- (NDI) .
,
, 2- .
12
http://www.tabula.ge/ge/story/110317-ndi-archevnebshi-monatsileebi-19-ocneba-enm-14-uari-pasuxze-13
19
3.3.
13
: "" 2001
,
90-
(, "
"),
- - -6- .. 2008
. 2007 7
, . 2007
13 100%-
100% -
,
2009 27 100%-
, 45%-
. 2012
,
. TVMR , 2015
. (AMR) 4,23%,
(SHR) 22,39% .
. 4 (1 -31 ) ,
,
(1460 )
(41,2%)
(21,6%) , 62,8%-.
" "
(12,6%), "
" (6%), "
" (3,1%) "
" (1%) .
1%- , 4,4%-,
1,4%-.
"" (1,3%) " "
(1,2%)
. 1%-
.
6,2%-, - 0,3%.
3.3.1. ,
(45,8%) (36%) ,
.
"
" ( 6,7%, 5,2%) "
"
( 4,2%, 1,8%). "
" " ( 23,1%, 20,3%), "
" ( 16,6%, 9,1%) " " (
1,8%,
0,7%) , , .
" " , " ".
13
MediaMeter, MDF, , http://mediameter.ge/ge/media-profiles/imedi
http://mediameter.ge/ge/media
20
, ,
..
"
" ( 1,5%, 1,1%) ,
- ( 0,7%, 1,8%);
(8,2%) (4,4%),
( 0,5%, 0,2%),
, , (0,03%)
.
3.3.2. ,
. ,
,
(95%), "
"
(94%), "" (92%), 1%- (92%), "
"
(89%) (89%)
.
(10%) (9%); .
(10%) (13%) .
(29%) " "
, 1% . " "
(17%) (18%) . "" 9%-
2%- , " " - 8% , 2%
- ; "" 4% - ,
4%- .
(10%) (1%) ;
(4%) (4%) .
3.3.3. - ,
21
.
(56,8%) " "
(30%) ,
86,8%-.
(2,9%), "
" 2,6%- " "
1,9%-.
, 1%- , 5,8%-.
(31,5%) "
" (30,2%) , " " (24%)
"
" (3,8%) .
(5%) (0,9%) ;
(0,2%) (0,1%) .
3.3.4. ,
, 86,8 %-
,, ,
13,2%-;
, ,
. . ,
, ,
.
17 "
/ .
" ,
2 ( , ),
22 "
" ,
14
35 000 .
,
,
, ,
,
.
,
" " ,
. -
, " " ,
.
14
" .. " ",
,
. 2006
.
22
,
"
"
,
.
,
-
.
.
,
,
- 20/30--
, " "
.
. 22 , (20:01)
/
,
. ,
, , ,
,
.
.
-,
-
,
. 304 .
" " (186 ).
- 21:03 -
( - 229 ). , ,
.
. 30 () "
"
(22:34). ,
,
,
. ,
, , "
"
.
,
. ,
, .
. , PIA- ,
/ 25
(20:15 )
, ,
.
, ,
9 3
.
. , :
.
,
9
, 3 .
,
.
, 2012-2015
2012 5 769 406
, 4 850 343 .
..
, 9 ,
.
. 1 -
-
(20:05 ).
" "
23
, " "
.
. 30
" " (20:09).
,
. , :
,
2 : 1.
" " 2- . 2.
- .
: " .
35% , " " - 13%-.
: ,
?
, : 41%
, .
.
: , ,
?
,
. : 65%
, .
,
, , ,
,
.
11 3 - ,
,
.
3.4.
: 2- , - 2015
2016 -
15
. 2016
- ,
, 15-15%
(55%) .
, , 2008
.
,
,
. 2016 , GDS-
16
. , 2015
-3 . (AMR) 1, 18%,
(SHR) 6, 27% .
. 4 (1 - 31 ) , -
(1458 )
(34,4%) (22,5%) , 57%-.
(13,2%) " " ,
15
MediaMeter, MDF, . http://mediameter.ge/ge/media-profiles/maestro
16
, 2015, , 3. http://mediameter.ge/ge/research/mediis-
tavisupleba-2015
24
" " (5,1%), " " (4,2%)
( )) (2,3%) .
" " (1,8%) "
" (1%)
1%- :
-
(0,9%),
" "
(0,8%), " " (0,7%). "
" , : "" (0,8%),
" " (0,6%) "
" (0,5%) .
2,7% , ,
,
6,8%-.
6%-, - 0,4%.
3.4.1 ,
,
.
" " . ,
(37,6%) (30,5%) , " " (24,3%)
(21%). " "
(16,8%) (10,3%) .
( 6,5%, -5,2%),
5,2%), "
" ( 5,5%, 4,7%), " " (
4,9%, 3,3% ),
" - " ( 1,1%, 0,5%), "
" ( 1,9%, 1,6), " "
( 0,8%,
0,7%), " "
( 0,9%, 0,5%) .
, (2,8%) (1,9%).
,
.
25
3.4.2 ,
.
(95%), " ' (91%),
(89%), (88%), "
" (85%) " "
(84%) .
: " "
( 18%,
15%); (
15%, 9%); " "
(
11%, 4%); "
" (16%, 2%);
( 24%, 5%), "" ( 4%, 1%).
, (7%) ,,
(4%).
3.4.3
- ,
.
(40,7%) " "
(31,2),
71,9%- . "
" (9,4%),
(28,3%) " "
(28,6%) , 2%- (26,
5%).
(2,3%) (3,6%),
"" ( 1,2%, - 2,5%),
26
" "
, (3,5%)
(1,4%) .
( ) (4,2%)
, - 0.9%-.
4.1 % , - 6,3%.
3.4.4 -
.
, .
.
. 22 ,
/
,
17
. 22
(20:01)
, ,
, ,
,
.
. 22 ,
.
, , ,
.
.
, . -
,
.
.
17
, 2016 8 .(5)
27
,
,
,
. ,
,
.
/.
2 -
"" "-" - .
2 (20:14 )
, , , - ,
. ,
,
, ,
.
18
: , , .
,
,
. ,
, , ,
.
, ,
.
- ,
.
-
- .
25 - (20:10 ),
, - . ,
, ,
, 9
3 .
.
:
, 5 769 406 ,
4 850 343 .
(9
3 ) ,
, , .
-
? .
//. 14 -
2
(20:17 ). ,
.
,
, 2 , . ,
:
18
, 1 , http://marshalpress.ge/archives/40682
28
, -
.
,
2013 ,
, 5 3 .
-18
.
, ,
,
,
,
, .
, ,
,
, ,
.
,
:
,
, ,
.
,
. ,
,
, ,
,
. ,
2 .
. 2- , 14
--
(20:17), ,
. , ,
. ,
, , .
, ,
, , -- ,
.
,
, " "
,
.
,
, --
.
5 "--" ..
(20:06 ). ,
. ,
:
, / .
29
3.5. GDS
19
GDS- : GDS 2012 , -
. 100%--
. 1
.. GDS-
GDS 100%-
. GDS (
)
, 2015
-
. 20/30- ,
, -
2-
. , ,
2012 80% .
8 . TVMR-
TVMR , GDS- 2015
(AMR) 0,55%, (SHR) 2,92%-.
2,92%
. GDS- 4 (1 -31 ) ,
- (752 ) (41,1%)
(20,7%) ,
61,8%-.
(15,7%) "
" , "" (4,2%), " "
(3,7%)
- (1,2%).
5,3%-, : "
" - 0,9%, "
" - 0,7%, " "
- 0,5%, " "
- 0,4 %
" " - 0,3%.
-1,4%, 1% .
4,6%-, - 0,7%-.
0,7%
3.5.1. , GDS
GDS-
.
, : ( 42,5%, 39,5%);
" " ( 21,7%; 19,2%).
, (22,5%) 2- (10,8%).
" " ,
, :
( 5,7%, 3,7%); " ' ( 1,5%, 0,7%).
19
MediaMeter, MDF http://mediameter.ge/ge/media-profiles/gds-tv
http://mediameter.ge/ge/med
30
,, 3.5.2.- ,
.
3.5.2. , GDS
. GDS- (100%)
" "
.
, "
", (27%) (2%)
. "
"
, 1%- ;
(9%), " "
(8%) .
(11%) "
(9%).
"" 4%-
.
( 1%, 3%).
(5%-
, 2%).
100%- 100%
- . ""
(4%, 2%),
(4%) ,
(96%) .
3.5.3. - , GDS
. GDS-
- 63,4%, " " - 24,7%, - 88,1% .
- 11,9 % . - 25,2%,
" " - 15,9% .
31
(43,5%),
(25,2%), " "" (15,9%) ,
4,5%- . , "
"
(6,6%), .
1%-
- 3,1%-.
GDS-
- (0,9%) .
- (0,7%),
- 1,5%-
3.5.4. ,
GDS
GDS-
, - GDS-
88,1% ,
,
, 11,9%.
/
.
.
. 22 ,
/
, " "
20
, GDS- 20:30- 23 (20:38 ) .
, 45 ,
.
:
("
", "
")
20
- 20:30 .
32
, -
" ", .
, " "
. ,
21
,
.
, 9 7- " ", 2-
" " . , -
, , ,
.
/. 8 GDS- , 13
(20:59 ) ,
.
, 13 ,
.
, ,
.
, , ,
, ,
.
2 , 1 .
,
(42- ) (
).
.
/. GDS
,
- .
, 25 (20:32 )
. .
.
,
. 265 . -
.
, ,
,
. , :
, .
, -
.
/ /
. GDS- 752 54
. 21
17 . ,
,
, :
26 , (20:38 )
.. 2006 27 -5 ,
7 .10
.
, ,
. ,
.
, ,
.
, ,
21
- - -
, .
33
.
, ,
.
15 (20:51 ) GDS-
;
, .
, .
, , ,
.
. 29 GDS- (20:46 )
- .
. . , ,
" " ,
.
, " "
" " . -
? 21% " ", 19%- " " .
, 3%- +/- 2,1% .
28 (20:44 ) 2- ?! 2-
- GFK- .
: , 8
, ? , ,
22,4 %, 21,7 % .
,
- 30,5% , " " - 28,2%. ,
.
, GFK-
. ,
.
, , .
3.6.
22
: 2013 ,
, 2012 .
2010 () ,
- , ,
. ,
2014 . TVMR , 2015
(AMR) 0,20% , (SHR) 1,08% .
. 4 (1 -31 ) , ,
- (27,7%)
(27,4%), - 55,1%-. " "
(774 ) :
" " - 18,4%, " " - 5,8%, " " - 5,4%
" " - 1,3%.
1,1%
, 1%- ,
, 3,5%- : "
" - 0,6 %, " - " - 0,5%, ""
- 0,4%, " " - 0,4, " " - 0,3%,
" " - 0,3%, " " - 0,2%, 0,6%.
6,8%-, - 0,2%.
22
Mediameter, MDF, , http://mediameter.ge/ge/media-profiles/tabula
34
3.6.1. ,
4 ,
.
: ( 36,1%, 22,3%), "
" ( 29,6%, 25,7%) ( 8,3%, 5,9%).
,
( - 20,4%, - 14,6%) "
" ( - 7.5%, - 2.8%) . "
",
- 6,3%-, - 4,1%.
3.6.2. ,
.
( 21%, 5%) ( 20%, 6%)
, "
" ( 13%, 5%) .
( 19%, 3%),
(
10%, 90%). 100%-
" ",
95%- - (
5%).
35
" " (94%), - 4%,
2%-. (93%) 4%
, 3% .
(8%) (2%) . 18 %-
%
82% . .
3.6.3. - ,
.
(30,6%) "
" (25,2%),
("
( " -
39%, - 38,1%). "
" (18,9%)
(15,9%), "
" - 12%- ,
.
(4,2%), 0,2%-
.
(3,8%) (2,6%) ,,
(0,9%) .
3.6.4
-
36
. ,
.
/. 29 (19:03 )
.
( , ; ,
)
, - -
- .
: , ,
.
.
,
, .
.
/ . 11 (19:11 )
,
.
,
. ,
,
2016 .
(4 ). (
) , ,
, . ,
.
, (, ,
2016 1 ).
.
. 20 (19:12 )
. , 19
. ,
.
, ( )
,
, .
() ,
.
,
, ,
( ) .
-
. ,
.
/ . 28 (19.01
) 2- - GFK
. .
, .
, ,
,
,
.
,
.
37
, .
,
(
, ,
),
.
3.7.
: 1994 .
, ,
, 2016 1
, ,
, , ,
. - (90%),
(7%) (3%) . 100
. TVMR ,
2015 (AMR) 0, 20%, (SHR) 1, 04% .
. 4 (1 -31 ) ,
- (1334 )
(35%) (21%) . 56%-.
"
" "
"
(15,1%), " " (4%) "
" (3,4%) .
" - "
(1,6%)
" " (1,2%) ,
1%- :
" " (0,7%),
(0,6%), (0,5%), (0,5%), -
(0,02%).
3,2%-
3,2% .
(1,5%). (1%),
(0,4%)
(0.1%).
8,5%-, - 0,3%.
3.7.1. -
4 , , ,
.
(
30,6%, -
40,7%)
( 19,4%, - 22,9%).
38
..
( 7,9%, -9.1%).
3.7.2 ,
..
3.7.2. -
. (98%)
.
" - " " "
(96%),
.
"
"
(13%, 4%) ,
(11%) .
(21%) ..
( 28%, 3%)
( 21%, 11%). (
15%,
4%), ( 9%, 5%)
( 8%, 2%) .
, (4%)
, (2%).
3.7.3. - ,
39
.
, ( 63,6%,
42,1%)
( 9,5%, 33%) . ,
"
" . "
" (9,1%) (13%) ,
" " (6,9%) (0.8%)
.
, 2-
"
" (48%).
.
, ,
. ,
,
.
. 17 (20:40 )
1 2 .
,
2014 ,
.
, ,
17 ,
,,
. , ,
( )
( ).
6 , 2 .
"
- "
2
, .
,
, .
40
. 11 (21:38 )
.
,
,
, .
.
. 15 (20:49 ) -
, , .
.
. 17 (20:31 )
. 11
( , - ),
.
.
, .
. , (
2- ) 14 (20:48) --
, , " " .
, ,
, , .
.
30 (20:40
). , ( , , ..)
, ,
, 2 (" ", " ")
, . ,
, ,
, , .
, . ,
, , 65% , " " ,
, 65% : ,
, ?
("
", " ", " ", " -
", " " ") .
3.8.
: - 2010 .
, 2014
. ( ,
) 2016 .
, ,
.
23
(ECRI) -
,
, .
2016 16 .
24
TVMR 2015 , - . 8
25
, -
6 , 2016 (1 - 30 )
, -
23
http://www.coe.int/t/dghl/monitoring/ecri/Country-by-country/Georgia/GEO-CbC-V-2016-002-GEO.pdf
24
http://www.tvmr.ge/ka#!ka/news/44/
25
2016 1 - 30 8 : 2 (46%),
(25%), (8%), (7,5%), GDS (2,3%), (2%), (1,9),
(1%).
41
, (33,1 %)
.
. ,
16 . , 2 (1
- 31 ) .
, -
(960
) (35,7%) "
" (15,8%)
. , " "
" "
(10,2%) ,
" "
(9,8%).
3,8%-, 1%-
3,4%. : " " (2,3%), "
" (2.1%);
- (1,8%), "
" (1,9%), " "
(1%).
,
(1,6%)
(1,5%) ,
(1,3%) (0,3%).
5,7% , - 2,1%.
3.8.1. , (1 -31 ,, 2016)
2 ,
.
( 25,5%), " " (15,8%) "
" (15,1%)
. , (15,8%) (6,3%) "
" .
(42,8%)
(25,5%).
:: " "
( 16,4%, 15,1%), " " ( 11%, 8%), (
6,4%, 4,7%).
,
, .
42
3.8.2. , (1 -31
, 2016)
. "
" (98%), "
" (97%), -
(97%) "
" (92%), "
"
(93%), (91%), " " (90%) " " (90%) .
(13%),
" " (8%), "
" (7%), (6%) 1%-
(6%) .
3.8.3. - , (1 - 31 , 2016)
.
(43,7%) "
" (17%)
. (45,8%),
" " (1,4%).
"
" (11,8%) (22,1%),
" "
(
3,6% 17,5%).
(9,8%), - 1.8%.
(5,3%) "
" , .
43
2%, - 3,3%-..
:
" " 3%, .
,
,
(10,2%). ,
.
.
.
/. ,
.
:
15 (20:01) ,,
. -
,
.
9 (19:30 ) ,
.
7 (19:52 -)
" "" ,
.
/. 7 (19:48 )
,
44
, .
.
/. 8 (19:44)
.
,
:
, .
, ,
. 2 ,
, ,
,
-5 .
,
.
/. 4 (12:04) ,
, ,
.
,
,
. ,
2008 ,
. , :
, , 80%- . ,
2008
, .
, .
,
.
/ . 29 (19:34)
.
. ,
.
, .
: - , -
. ,
,
.
/. 18 19:31
.
, , ,
, - ,
.
,
,
, , , .
. "
" , ""
" "
" " .
, " " .
, ""
, ,
. , :
- , , ,
, .
45
" "
. , " "
. , ,
.
/ .
( )
. 2 ,
.
1
(19:31),
, .
.
, .
.
.
,
1 (19:40 ) . ,
111- , 55-
. , ,
.
, 26 (19:33 ) . 2
. , ,
.
, ,
.
.
- 29
(NDI ) . -
, - .
, , ,
(57%), .
46
4.
, , , 4
(1 - 31 ) , ,
.
46,6%,
-
18%, 64,6%-.
(9,2%),
" " (5,1%), " " (2,8%),
(2,2%)
(1,9%). 1,6% .
6,5%-, (0,5%)
(0,04%).
4.1. ,
4.2. 1%- ,
47
/
. ,,
.
(50,8%) (40,8%) ,
" " , (22,2%) (15%) 7,2%-
.
2 :
"
" ( 11,6%, 5,9%) " " ( 2,1%, 1,7%).
4.3. , .
4.3. / ,
. 4 ,
( 12%,
10%), (10% 5% )
"
" ( 9%, 4%).
( 34%,
4%),
( 14%, 6%),
" " ( 10%) " " ( 8%;
3%).
(1,5%)
5%) (98%) "
" . (93%)
( 4%, 3%).
1% "
" ( 26%, 4%) .
( 10%, 7%).
( 5%, 4%).
: " "" ( 95%,
3%, 2%); "
" ( 95%, 3%,
2%); " " (
94%, 3%, 3%); "
" (
94%, 5%, 1%); " -
" (
94%, 2%, 4%).
( 7%, 5%)
( 7%, 1%) ,
(94%) (6%) .
48
4.4.
. ,
. 4 ,
. (14%) ,
, (14%).
IPN- (10%), (13%)
. PIA- (9%) (8%).
(31%),
(3%). (9%) (1%) .
4.5.
49
5.
TV , 4 (1 -31 ) (18 439
) , (21,8%)
/
, (10,6%)
(8,4%). (7,9%)
(7,9%) , ,
(7,2%) ,
..
,
26
26.
( . IPN, PIA, . 53; 61)
5.1. (1 - 31 ,
2016)
, , TV
, (2,4%), (1,1%),
(0,9%), (0,9%),
(0,6%), - (0,5%). , NDI-
(
, ,
, /, )
.
,
.
26
(2016),
. http://mdfgeorgia.ge/geo/view-library/31
http://mdfgeorgia.ge/geo/view
50
6.
6.1
27
: (IPN.Ge), 2002 , -
. , " "
, . 2015
, : 12%,
46%, 12%, 15% ( , 25%,
, 75%) 15% (
100%).
50%-
.
, 2015 249 352 , -
.
: (IPN) 4 ,
,
. (7202 ) 53,9%,
- 14,4%. ,
68,3 %- ,
: " " - 7,7 %, " " - 4,5
%, "-" - 3,1 %, " - " - 1,7 %,
" - 1%.
1% .
(2%), -
4%- . (1%),
.
1%- :
(0,05%), (0,5%), (0,4%)
(0,1%). -
(0,4%), " " - 0,3%.
(6,2%),
(1%)
(0, 01%), .
6.1.1 , IPN
27
http://mediameter.ge/en/media-profiles/interpressnews
51
/ .
( 43,2%, 60,1% ).
( 7,1%, 5,6%).
6.1.2 ,
, "
", (7,3%)
(8%).
,
(0,1%) ,
" ", ,
(0,1%).
""
( 2.2% 1%), (
1,9%,
1,8%).
6.1.2 / - IPN
.
. ,
(20%), -
(10%), "
" (9%), " "
(8%).
, (7202 )
(0,05%), 39%- .
(25%), " " (9%), " " (8%)
" " (8%).
52
. IPN-
65 % , 19%-
.
. 4%- , ,
(3%), (2%)
(2%) .
(1%)
( ).
).
1%- .
(33,4%),
(64,9
4,9%) .
26,2%- . 24,1%-,
.
,
(2,8
2,8%) (2,2%)
%) .
(2,5%). 1,9%- ,
. , , 0,5%-
.
6.1.4. - IPN
,
. ,
.
,
.
,
54%- ,
28
-
.
.
,
.
,
28
(2016),
,
v, . http://mediameter.ge/ge/research/reklamis-da-inpormaciis-gavrcelebis-miznit-mediashi
http://mediameter.ge/ge/research/reklamis mediashi-sabiujeto-resursebis-
ganacilebis
53
29
, IPN ,
- NS (News from subscriber) ,
.
, - 9
, 3- ,
3 , IPN-
NS,
. , 6.1. - ,
IPN- . ,
2016
.
6.1.
3 3 -
32
30
31
____
____ ____
NS
____
____
.
35
,
,
. , -
. 6.1.. ,
IPN- PIA- -
,
. , IPN-
.
6.2
29
.
30
IPN, 31 , 2016 http://bit.ly/2cZt89L
31
PIA, 31 , 2016 http://bit.ly/2cEohdc
32
, 31 , 2016. http://marshalpress.ge/archives/51058
33
IPN, 27 , 2016 http://bit.ly/2caop4Y
34
Netgazeti.ge, 27 , 2016 http://bit.ly/2ct4zzj
35
, , , .
54
IPN PIA -
NATO- NATO-
-
- - :
" NATO-
36
:
-
NDI- ,
- -
38
,
37
:
,
__________
39
:
:
40
:
:
,
.
,
- 10 (10
).
:
.
:
(13 ).
,
,
,
, .
. 22
. IPN- PIA-
.
( -
), IPN- ( #53-
) .
PIA-
, IPN-
.
/ .
-
,
51- (11) ,
36
IPN, 14 , 2016. http://bit.ly/2cn8Ov0
37
IPN, 29 , http://bit.ly/2cIYNKg
38
PIA, 30 , http://bit.ly/2cwn9YW
39
IPN, 30 , 2016. http://bit.ly/2cXEyrD
40
IPN, 22 , 2016, http://bit.ly/2cwPBq2
55
.
11
, .
: , ,
(30
, 1 ).
, 65 %- ,
(30 , 1 ).
- ,
13%-, 35%- (29 ).
, , ,
.
2- GFK-
( , , , ),
, .). ,
, :
- GFK- 2014
(28 )
, (
) - 2-
( ,
.) 28
2-
.
6.2. PIA
41
PIA- : 2006
2016 ,
, . 2010 100%-
, 2013
, 2014 100%- . PiA-
: Daijesti.ge, rubrica.ge, funtime.ge. 2015
80 236 .
: PIA- (4157 )
(54,6 % ) -
(16,6%) , 71,2%- .
. : "
" (5%); - ( ) (4,5%).
" " (3,7%).
1 % :
(1%), " " (0,8%), " " (0,3%),
(0,2%), " " (0,2%) "
" (0,1%).
2016 :
( ) (1,3%), - (0,4%);
"" (0,2%) " " (0,2%).
2,4%- .
41
MediaMeter, MDF, PIA, http://mediameter.ge/ge/media-profiles/pia
56
- 6.8%, - 0,3%,
- 0,1% .
6.2.1. - PIA
/
.
-
(21.1%) (12,8%),
(12,8%)
(59,1%) (49,5%) , IPN-, PIA-
,
42
.
(7,8%)
,
(1,8%); "
-
" , (6,6%) (2,7%)
.
( 0,2%),
0,1%, 0,09%. 0,9
%-
( ),
1,8%- .
6.2.2. / - PIA
42
(2016),
,
v, . http://mediameter.ge/ge/research/reklamis-da-inpormaciis-gavrcelebis-miznit-mediashi
http://mediameter.ge/ge/research/reklamis mediashi-sabiujeto-resursebis-
ganacilebis
57
.
(43%), - "
" (21%). " " (7%)
" " (6%),
(9%). PIA- (1%)
. " (9%),
(5%) (5%) .
, 1% ,
(30%) (22%) .
6.2.3. - PIA
.
(55,6%); (29,3%).
(6,2%).
2%- 1,7%
" (1,3%) .
" " (0,6%) " " (0,1%) .
58
6.2.4.
PIA ,
. , ,
,
:
. PIA- ""
/
- (11 ).
:
() ( )
,
.
,
. ,
(25 ) PIA- ,
,
. ,
:
,
, - .
.
. IPN- , 22
PIA-
PIA
. , IPN-
,
, PIA-
. 1 3 ,
""
,
:
59
PIA
12: 58 , -
13:39
"" -
13:51
, - ,
. :
, " "
(22 ), - .
, /. PIA-
, ""
27% (28 ).
.
, ,
73%- , , ,
; , ,
,
.
,
20 .
/. PIA-
,
- (8 ).
, ,
.
,
,
.
. PIA- ,
,
-
. NDI-,
. :
43
51 (11) 11 4 -
43
1. , 2. ; 3.
; 4. ; 5.
; 6. ; 7.
; 8. ,
, ; 9. ; 10.
60
, , ;
3- , .
, ,
. NDI-
, ,
(57%) .
. , - :
, 2012
, . , ,
57% , , 2012
, , 38%-
, ,
.
NDI- PIA-
, 2012 ? - , 2012
38%, .
, , -
.
. IPN-
PIA-
. IPN- ,
, 6.1- (.. 54),
.
44
PIA- , MDF- , 2 -
- " () . 6.2 (. 55)
, .
6.3
45
. Netgazeti.Ge 2010
. , , -
(25%), (25 %), (25 %) (25 %) .
.
. 4 (1 -31 ) , ( 1397
) - 37,2%, - 19,2% .
" " (13,9%) " " (8%)
, (3,4%) " " .
1%- : " "
(0,9%), " " (08%), " - " (0,5%),
" " (0,4%), "" (0,2%) "
" (0,05%).
,
(2,7%) , (0,7%), ' -
" (0,5%) " " (0,2%) .
; 11. ,
44
(2016), ,
v, . http://mediameter.ge/ge/research/reklamis-da-inpormaciis-gavrcelebis-miznit-mediashi-sabiujeto-resursebis-
ganacilebis
45
MediaMeter.ge, MDF, Netgazeti, . http://mediameter.ge/ge/media-profiles/netgazeti
61
- 7,1%, 1,4% . ,
(IPN -1%,
- PIA
- 0,3%, - 0,2%).
6.3.1 ,
( 2,7%, 2,6%)
"" ( 0,7%, 0,6%)
, " -
" ( 0,6%, 0,3%)
( 0,5%, 0,3%) ,
(0,6%) (0,8%) .
(7,8%) (6,7%),
(1,9%) (0,4%),
(0.1%) .
6.3.2
/ ,
62
.
" " (96%), 1%-
(93%) " " (90%) .
" " (16%) ,
" " (13%), (11%) " " (8%) .
(13%) ,
(11%), " " (9%), " ' (8%),
(6%) "" (3%) .
, (7%) (2%)
. (14%) , .
6.3.3. - ,
.
(32,6%), (40, 6%)
. " - " (31,6%) (24,
3%) , " " (16,5%) (21,9%)
. - 4%- "
" (4,4%), - 0,4%-. ' " - 4,1%,
- 1,1%-.
- 2,1%, - 4,9%-.
- 1,9%-.
63
6.3.4 ,
,
, .
. -
,
.
. 27 30
-
.
, -
-
,
-
. ,
,
, ,
.
. 20 ,
, 18 ,
2-
.
,
,
.
. ,
.
,
- ,
.
. 13
,
,
.
.
. ,
64
.
, - . 30
, ,
.
,
, " "
" " 2 (
" " )
. , " "
2 , 28 2-
- GFK- ,
, "" ' " . 2-
" " ,
, GFK- .
. ,
,
.
(
) . , ,
- - .
6.4.
46
. , 100%- 2011
30 65%-
. 14 (16 ) 100%
, 2011
2- 30%- . 2007 2011
100%- , 1999-2007
5 - . 2013
,
.
. 4 (1 -31 , 2016)
(2945 ) (33,1%)
(20,2%) , 53,3%- .
46
MediaMeter.ge, MDF, . http://mediameter.ge/ge/media-profiles/pirveli-radio
65
6.4.1 ,
.
(16,4%) (23%) ,
(: 30,6%, : 34,9%) "
"
(: 10,1%, : 12,9%) .
, :
"" (:: 8,2%, : 5,5%), " "
(: 8%;
: 4,8%), " - " (
3,8%, 1,4%).
"
( 1,1%, 0,7%).
(7,1%), (7,3%)
. ,
.
6.4.2 / ,
.
(14%) 13% . " "
(8%), " " (6%) " " (5%) .
(25%) "
" (23%), ,
17%-.
66
(97%) " " ,
, 3%, 0%-.
(94%), , 6%,
. (5-5%),
(5
(90%) .
, ,
14 % .
6.4.3. - ,
.
(53,2%), (37,9%) .
3 .
: "
" ( 33,3%, 19,1%), " " (
17,6%,
6,6%), " "" ( 4%, 2%). "
"
, (10,9%) (0,8%)
. 1,8%
, , 94% .
, , ,
1% .
4,9%, 2,2%--.
6.4.4 -
67
. ,
,
. ,
, , .
/-.
,
, 6
,
.
,
.
, 5 2-
47
, 6
.
48
-
, -, ,
. ,
.
/. 6 , 175
,
.
,
.
2015
, .
.
. 15 ,
- ,
, -
. ,
.
,
, .
. 26 ,
,
47
, (5 , 2016), : http://liberali.ge/news/view/21892/gia-
volski-mtavrobashi-sakadro-tsvlilebebi-ar-igegmeba
48
-
68
" .
, ,
. , ,
.
, ,
.
, ,
,
.
. 31 " -
,
-5 ,
,
. -
,
, .
.
.
/ . 14
, : - 33,2%, - 30,7%.
,
49
-- ,
. , -- ,
, .
, .
, ,
, "
" , , -- .
, ,
, , , ,
. , ---
- " " (33,2%)
" " (30,7%) - .
6.5
: - 2015 18
. Marshallpress.ge- . , 100%-
2015 6 , 9-
. 2015 24
(49%) (51%) .
: (1 -31 )
(2738 ) (35,7%) (27%)
, 62,7%- .
(13,7%) "
" .
- 5,3%, - 2% -
2%.
1% 1%- :
" " " - " (1%),
0,4%, - 0,4%, -0,3%
0,3%.
5,9%-, - 0,2%.
49
--, (14 , 2016), : - 33,2%, - 30,7%.
http://ghn.ge/com/news/view/151752
69
6.5.1 ,
(38,4%), (32,7%)
.
.
(35,3%) (17,9%) .
, (26,2%) (2,5%) . (7,1%)
(4,8%) ,
(: 2,9%, : 1,2%) .
"" (
: 0,1%, : 0,6%),
. 6.5.2 ,
.
6.5.2 / ,
.
.
, (29%),
(24%), (16 %), (10%), ,
1%-
1% (10%).
70
(72%) "
" , 4%-. (24%)
,
5%- .
,
(16%), (27%).
- 8 %-
- 48% .
" " (94%), " " (94%), "
- "
(92%), " - "
(88%)
.
6.5.3. - ,
.
(53,5%)
(33,7%) ,
87,2%-. (4,7%), " " (2,5%),
" " (1,4%) (4,2%) ,
12,8%- .
(60,5%) "
" ,
(9,6%), "
"
(7,8%), " "
(6,1%). (4,7%), " "
(3,8%), " "
(1,3%) (5,1%), 1%-
6.5.4- .
6.5.4 -
71
,
, , , .
.
.
, 24-
2015
,
50 51
(18 ) . 16
,
2 ,
,
,
.
, ,
,
.
, .
52
21 ,
ISIS- .
,
.
,
,
,
,
.
- ,
- ..
. 16
-
,
2-
53
.
,
,
,
,
.
50
, 18 , 2016. http://marshalpress.ge/archives/32867
51
France 24, The Interview , 23 February, 2015. http://www.france24.com/en/20150221-interview-mikheil-saakashvili
saakashvili-former-georgian-
president-ukraine-putin-poroshenko
52
http://marshalpress.ge/archives/49610
53
http://marshalpress.ge/archives/37792
72
,
(..?). 20
. ,
,
54
,
. - LGBT Pride-
, .
/. PIA- 22 ,
, ,
( ). -
, .
PIA- , , ,
(20 ). ,
,
.
, ,
.
,
- (14 ).
- ,
, ,
.
,
.
/ . ,
- (20 )
" "
. ,
.
,
, ..
. , .
/. ,
(0.4%), ,
:
!
(6); ?
? (19 ); (23 );
(16 );
(21 );
(14 );
,
(16 ).
/ . 31%,
-11% NDI (13 ) -
. , ,
54
http://marshalpress.ge/archives/33148
73
- ,
- 31% , 11%
55
. NDI- ,
. : 16 % , 15%
.
31% .
, - , ,
/ - 31% , 11%
.
51(11) 11
4 - , ,
.
PIA- NDI- ,
NDI- 57% , 2012
(29 ). , 57% 38%- ,
, .
5 - , , ,
56
.
55
NDI (,, 2016), .
https://www.ndi.org/files/NDI%20Georgia_March%202016%20poll_Public%20political_GEO_vf.pdf
56
: 1. , 2.
; 3. ; 4.
; 5. ; 6.
; 7. ; 8.
, ,
; 9. ; 10. ; 11. ,
74
7.
4 (1 - 31 )) ,
,
: :
( -84%, -16 %), ( -85% -
15%).
(52%), (34%), :
- 8%, - 2%, (2%),
-1%, -1%.
- ,
:
(45%); (42%); (7%); (2%);
(3%), (1%).
7.1. TV (1 - 31
, 2016)
(19%) -
,
(18%), 2 (17%), (17%)
(17%) .
7.2.
PIA (19%) ,
, (14%) ;
- (12%).
7.3.
75
, .
,
11% , 18% , (19%) .
14%-
14% 17%- .
7.4. (1 -31 ,
2016)
,
, ,
(77%), (65%).
7.5. /
, (5%) (6%)
- (9% 8%);
, (89%),
(83%).
7.6. ()
-,
,
.
58%-, - 50%.
76
7.7. /
93%- ,
(84%).
(4%)
(10%).
7.8. ()
. - ,
- 3
:
(20,2%);
, (11,4%),
;
(11,1%). (8%)
, ,
.
7.9.
- , 1%- .
, - , -
- 0,2%;
- 0,9 %; - 1,4%; - 2,2%.
-
- ,
77
(21,5%), - (14,4%),
- ; (9,9%) .
7.10.
.
/
4-
. . 7-
,
,
.
, :
..
, . ( 2, ,
, IPN;
, ,
, 25 ).
, ,
2
.
.
, "
":
( 2, ,
, 11 )
, "
": ,
, , ,
, ,
(
, 10 ).
-, :
, / : ,
, . , . . ?! .
,
! :: !
(, 27
).
78
8.
57
. 1997
, , ,
,
, ,
,
, ,
.
, ,
, .
: 56.3
:
,
,
, , ,
,
,
,
,
.
,
.
,
. 2009
( ),
),
58
. ,
,
.
25
(48).
(17) ,
(5) , 1
, 1 1
, .
1 .
8.1.
57
, No. R(97) 20., 1997
http://www.coe.int/t/dghl/standardsetting/hrpolicy/other_committees/dh-lgbt_docs/CM_Rec(97)20_en.pdf
http://www.coe.int/t/dghl/standardsetting/hrpolicy/other_committees/dh
58
, (10 , 2015)
79
59
(13) -
,
.
.
17 . 2
,
; 2
.
, : " ,
, ?.. , ,
, , , ,
(27 ).
, : ? -
? (7 ).
, /: ,, , ,
, , , , 20
? (7 ).
, /: " ,
. .
, , ,
(5 ).
, /: , - ,
. , - . - - ?... ,
.
-, : , ,
(24 ).
, / :
,
(29 ).
. 22 ,
" "
,
(3). 1
" - "
, 1
,
.
, " ":
(30 ).
59
.
80
.
-
.
, "
": ,, [-
] ,
(22 ).
. (1)
, :
, - : ",
[], ".
" "
.
,
-,
:
": ,
, "
.
.
,
,
. 12 ,
,
3 (
2,
1) , . 2-, ,
(6 )
,
.
3 ( 2, 1)
.
.
, 2
, 1
,
.
(11) .
. :
, ,
;
,, ;
, !
,
. 1
(. .. ?).
,
, 11
5-
(, , ,
) . 2
,
, . 2
.
81
,
, , ,
:
. ,
,
,
.
.
,
.
,
.
,
.
. ,
.
. ,
.
.
.
,
.
,
.
, .
,
.
.
.
,
.
, ,
.
.
,
,
.
.
,
. ,
,
.
.
.
82