Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Large Chilled Water System PDF
Large Chilled Water System PDF
by:
ASHRAE India Chapter and Xylem, Inc.
Presented by:
Larry Konopacz, Manager of Training & Education
Bell & Gossett Little Red Schoolhouse
Saturday, September 21, 2013
Large Chilled Water System Design Seminar
The Production Loop
Chilled Water Sources
Chillers
Cooling towers
Free-Cooling &
Waterside Economizer
Thermal Storage
Water Source Heat Pumps
Whats a Ton?
I Ton Ice =
2000 LB;
1LB Ice =
144 Btu;
1 Ton ice =
288,000 Btu
Rule of 24
Centrifugal
Condenser
Rotary screw
Reciprocating
Absorption
Evaporator
Refrigeration Cycle
Expansion Device
Evaporator
High Pressure Zone
Condenser
Cooling
Load
Tower
Cool Water
Vapor Flow Return
Water
Compressor Chilled
Condenser Motor Water
Water Pump
Pump
Where is What Used?
Large chilled water plants - centrifugal
Mid-range size - rotary screw
Smaller chilled water applications -
reciprocating
Inexpensive source of steam or other
energy source - absorption
Combinations of the above
Chiller Piping - Evaporator Side
Chiller 2
H
C
R
E
L
L
I
Chiller 1
Chiller 3
Chiller 2
Triple
Chiller 1 Duty
Supply
Triple
Duty
Common
Pipe
Return
Adding Pump Redundancy
Chiller 2
Triple
Chiller 1 Duty
Supply
Triple
Duty
Common
Pipe
Return
Headered Primary Pumps
Actuated Control Valve
Chiller 3
Chiller 2 Supply
Piped for Triple
Standby Chiller 1 Duty
Pumps
Common
Pipe
Triple
Duty Return
Chiller Piping - Condenser Side
Cooling Towers
Pumps
Triple Duty
Condenser
Condenser
Condenser
Multi-celled Cooling Tower
Condenser
Condenser
Condenser
Triple
Duty
SRS
Standby Pump
Tower Equalization
Cooling Towers
Equalization
Line
Condenser
Condenser
SRS
Triple Duty
Condenser
Cooling Tower Piping Practices
Fill all sections of pipe to purge air.
Size piping at a minimum of 2 fps to
move free air bubbles to tower.
All piping installed below system purge
level.
Condenser Water Piping Above Grade
SRS
Overhead Piping Concerns
Piping manifolds can result in low velocities.
Low velocity will allow air to be released.
Air trapped in piping increases head required.
Piping installed above purge level compounds
problem.
Unpurged areas are potential sources of
problems when pumps are turned on.
Elevated Suction Piping Concerns
Condenser water pump difficult to purge.
At start-up a manual air vent may be required.
During operation air will again accumulate.
Automatic air vent may not work.
If above the basin fill level, the result is
cavitation.
Improper Piping Above Basin Level
SRS
Tower Piping Observations
At part load reduced velocities in headers may
allow air to be released.
Idle pumps will accumulate air that should be
released prior to starting the pump.
Tower basins should be elevated to ensure
positive pressure under all flow conditions.
Pump casings should be fitted with automatic
air vents.
Condenser Head Pressure Control
With centrifugal chillers a minimum supply
water temperature is needed to:
Water in
Air in Air in
Water out
Forced Draft, Cross-flow Tower
Air Out
Air in Air in
Water out
Water in
Dynamic Relationship of Load,
Approach, and Range
Temperature Water Flow
L lb/min of water
Hot water F (R F)
Load
Range
Heat Load = L x R
Cold water F
Approach
L lb/min of water
(F)
Wet bulb F
Tower Size Relationships
Variables:
Heat Load (Varies Directly)
Range (Varies Inversely)
Approach (Varies Inversely)
Wet-bulb Temperature (Varies Inversely)
Water in
Air in Air in
Water out
Earth Contact
Evaporative
Earth Contact Characteristics
Usually indirect.
Cooling medium and load separated by heat
exchanger.
Stable temperatures.
Water temperature limitations.
Water treatment and pumping costs.
Environmental concerns.
Heat Exchangers
How do they work?
Thin plates are stamped with
a unique chevron pattern and
assembled in a frame
Four holes punched in the
plate corners form a
continuous tunnel which acts
as a distribution manifold for
the inlet and outlet of each
fluid
How do they work?
Each plate has a gasket that
confines the fluid to the port
or to the heat transfer area of
the plate
Units are built to order with a
standard 150 psi ASME Code
stamped design or to custom
designs
Earth Contact - Summer Cycle
C E H E
O V E X
N A GPX LOAD
D P A C
TOWER T H
Triple Duty
C E H E
O V E X
N A GPX LOAD
D P A C
TOWER T H
Triple Duty
C E
TOWER O V
N A LOAD
D P
Triple Duty
Triple Duty
Sediment Removal
Separator
NOT RECOMMENDED
C E
TOWER O V
N A LOAD
D P
C E H E
O V E X
N A GPX
A C LOAD
D P
TOWER T H
Triple Duty
C E H E
O V E X
N A GPX
A C LOAD
D P
TOWER T H
Triple Duty
CH. WATER
52= t2
7F TEMPERATURE
45= T2
CROSS
3F COOLING
COND. WATER APPROACH
42= t1
EXCHANGER
LENGTH
Heat Transfer Area vs Approach
COND. WATER CH. WATER LMTD AREA EXCH. COST
EWT LWT FLOW EWT LWT FLOW DEG F SQ.FT. MODEL INDEX
42 52 1000 57 45 834 3.92 1390 GPX807 1.00
Variable volume
distribution Vent
pump
Warm Storage
Cool
Chiller
Temperature Stratification
Top 0
Depth of tank, ft
-5
-10 Thermocline
-15
Bottom -20
30 40 50 60 70
Temperature, F
Use of Pressure Sustaining Valves
Load
Distribution Primary
pump pump
Chiller
Direction
Transfer Pump control
valves
Vent
Warm
Storage Cool
Constant volume
Pressure sustaining primary pump
and check valve
Incorporating Heat Exchangers
Load T
Variable volume
secondary
pump
T Heat
Exchanger
Variable volume
primary Vent
pump
Warm
Storage Cool
Constant volume
Pressure sustaining
primary pump
and check valve
Chiller
Ice Harvesting System
Load
Ice water
recirculation
Chilled water
pump pump
External Melt Ice Storage
Discharging Mode
Charging Mode
Encapsulated Ice Storage
Charge and Discharge Modes
Ice
Cold glycol Warm glycol
Ice
Water
Full Storage Strategy
Chiller on
Charging Charging
Storage Storage
Chiller off
Tons
Cooling load
(met by storage)
Chiller meets load directly
Time of Day
Partial Storage - Load Leveling
Cooling load
(met by chiller)
Time of Day
Partial Storage - Demand Limiting
Reduced on-peak demand
Charging Charging
Storage (met by storage) Storage
Tons
Cooling load
(met by chiller)
Time of Day
Production Source - Water Source Heatpumps
Cool Warm
Air Compressor Air
Compressor
Water Source Water Source Water Source Water Source Water Source
Heat Pump Heat Pump Heat Pump Heat Pump Heat Pump
Buffer
Tank Water Source Water Source Water Source Water Source
( Optional ) Heat Pump Heat Pump Heat Pump Heat Pump
Heat Pump-Water Source Schematic
Closed Circuit Cooler Compression
Heat Rejecter Tank
Water Source Water Source Water Source Water Source Water Source
Heat Pump Heat Pump Heat Pump Heat Pump Heat Pump
Buffer
Tank Water Source Water Source Water Source Water Source
( Optional ) Heat Pump Heat Pump Heat Pump Heat Pump
Comments?
Questions?
Observations?
Large Chilled Water System Design Seminar
Variable Volume Distribution
Variable flow through coil Variable flow through coil
Constant flow through system Variable flow through system
C C
H H
I I
L L
L L
E E
R R
A Problem
We want:
a. variable volume, to save pumping
costs at part load,
b. constant flow through the chiller to
protect it.
A Solution
a. constant flow primary system for the chillers
b. variable flow secondary system for the load
Primary-Secondary Terms
Supply
Primary Loop
Production
Secondary Loop
Distribution
C C C
H H H
I I I
L L L
L L L
E E E
R R R
Primary-Secondary
Common Pipe
Return
Fundamental Idea
Secondary
Pump
Tee Tee
Primary A B
Pump
Low pressure drop in the common pipe
Primary-Secondary Pumping
The idea is based on:
Conservation of Mass
Conservation of Energy
Law of the Tee: Diversion
50 GPM
50 GPM
100 GPM
Law of the Tee: Mixing
100 GPM
60 GPM 40 GPM
No Secondary Flow
Secondary
Pump
Off
A B
100 GPM @ 45F
100 GPM @ 45F 100 GPM @ 45F
Primary
Pump
Primary = Secondary
Pump On
A B
100 GPM @ 45F 100 GPM @ 55F
0 GPM
Primary > Secondary
A B
100 GPM @ 45F 100 GPM @ 50F
50 GPM @ 45F
Primary < Secondary
Pump On
A B
100 GPM @ 45F 100 GPM @ 55F
100 GPM @55F
Mixing at Tee A
Control Valve in Secondary
Two-way Valve
Primary-Secondary Pumping
Supply
Primary Loop
Production
Secondary Loop
Distribution
C C C
H H H
I I I
L L L
L L L
E E E
R R R
Primary-Secondary
Common
Return
Common Pipe Design Criteria
Use the flow of the largest chiller
Chiller staging at half of this flow is
common
Head loss in common <1 1/2 ft
Distribution pipe size is often used where
reductions would be inconvenient
Three pipe diameters between tees
Excessive length increases total head loss
Low velocities in system piping
Design of the Common Pipe
Secondary
Constant Speed
Pumps
Supply
Chiller 3
Chiller 2
Chiller 1
Pump
Controller
Common
Return
10 dia.
Common Pipe Configurations
A B
C D
Secondary System Curve
Control Valves
Closing
H1
H2 Control Valves
H3 Opening
Head
F1 F2 F3
Flow
Typical System
Distribution
Production 45F
To Loads
Chiller 1, on
Chiller 2, off
Secondary Pumps
1500 gpm each
Common
1500 gpm
each
From Loads
Production = Distribution
CHWS Temp
45oF
1500 1500
Chiller 1, on Secondary
Chiller 2, off
Pumps
1500
Common -- No Flow
0 1500 1500
1500
Secondary
Chiller 1, on
Chiller 2, off
Pumps
2000
Common -- 500
0 1500 2000
Supply
>1500 GPM
>1500 GPM
@ 47.5oF
Chiller 1, on
Chiller 2, off
0 GPM Be Careful!
Common
>1500 GPM
Return @ 55oF
>1500 GPM
What can we do?
Supply
Step Linear
Function Function
Chiller 3
Chiller 1
Chiller 2
Primary/Secondary
Common
Distribution
Production Return
Typical Load Profile
30
25
20
% Time
15
10
0
0-10 30-40 60-70 90-100
% Load
Multiple Chillers
Chiller 1
Chiller 2
Chiller 2, 60%
Chiller 1, 40%
100
80 1
% Load 60
40
1 2 2
20
25 50 75 100
% Time
What else can we do?
Reset Supply Temperature
Lower chiller set point when mixing occurs to
maintain a constant temperature to the system.
Allows us to mix colder water and maintain supply
temperature to secondary. (coils)
Expect increases in cost of chiller operation at
lower set point: 1-3% per degree of reset.
Adds to control complexity.
Delays start of the next chiller.
Production > Distribution
CHWS Temp
45oF
P/S Chiller Bridge - Front Loaded Common
(Flow in GPM)
3000
Secondary
Chiller 2, on
Chiller1, on Pumps
2100
Common -- 900
1.0
0.9
KW per Ton
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Percent Load
Typical Load Profile
30
25
20
% Time
15
10
0
0-10 30-40 60-70 90-100
% Load
60/40 Chiller Split to Help Minimize
Low Part Load Operation
Chiller 1
Chiller 2
Chiller 2, 60%
Chiller 1, 40%
100
80 1
% Load 60
40
1 2 2
20
25 50 75 100
% Time
Three Unequally Sized Chillers
Chiller 1 or Chiller 2
and
Chiller 3
100
Chiller 3, 60%
Chiller 2, 40%
Chiller 1, 40%
Chiller 1
and
Chiller 2
80
60
% Load
40
Chiller 3
20
25 50 75 100
Chiller 1
or
Chiller 2 % Time
Approaching Flow = Load
% Load
Time
Applying a Variable Speed Chiller
100
Ch 1
75
Ch 2
Ch 1
% Flow
50
Ch 2 Ch 3
Ch 1
25
Ch 2 Ch 3 Ch 4
Ch 1
25 50 75 100
% Load
Back Loaded Common
To Loads
Chiller 3
Chiller 2
Chiller 1
Common
From loads
Production = Distribution
CHWS Temp
45oF 1500
1500
Secondary
Pumps
Chiller 1, on
Chiller 2, off
1500
Common
0 Flow
1500 1500
CHWR Temp
55oF
Distribution > Production
CHWS Temp
47.5oF
Mixing (1500 @ 45) + (500 @ 55)
500
Secondary
1500
Chiller 1, on
Chiller 2, off
Pumps
Common 2000
500 gpm
0 1500 2000
500
CHWR Temp
55oF
Production > Distribution
CHWS Temp
45oF
900 600
Secondary
Chiller 2, on
Chiller 1, on
1500 Pumps
1500
Common 2100
900
Secondary
Pumps
Primary-
Secondary Supply
Common
Free Cooling
Chiller 3
Chiller 2
Pump
Controller
Return
Primary-Secondary System
Secondary
Pumps
Supply
Chiller 3
Chiller 2
Chiller 1
Pump
Controller
Primary-
Secondary
Common
Return
Pump Horsepower Comparison
150
Constant Flow Primary Pumps, only
125
BHP 100
75
Secondary Pumps +
50
25 50 75 100
110
Base Constant Flow, C/S Pump Pump Head Matched
100
Design (3 Way Valve) to System @
90 Design Flow
HP %
80
70
60
% Full Load 50
(Design) HP 40
30
20
10
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
% Flow
Impact of Piping Length and Overheading
350
300
250
c/s @ 1.0
Yearly Operating Cost x $1000
c/s @ 1.25
200
c/s @ 1.50
c/s @ 2.0
150
100
50
But...
Uncertainties
Coils
Control valves
Primary data
Lead times
Dealing With an Overheaded Pump
Secondary
Constant Speed
Supply
Pumps
2
Chiller 3
Chiller 2
Chiller 1
Pump
Controller
6 5
Primary
Secondary
Common
Return
Chiller Staging Instrumentation
TS-S FS
TP-S
ProductionChiller 1, on
FP To Loads
Chiller 2, off
Secondary/Pumps
Distribution
Common
TP-R TS-R
From Loads
Common Pipe Flow Indication
Distribution
Production
To Loads
Secondary/Pumps
Chiller 1
Chiller 2
Flow Switches
Common
From Loads
Comments?
Questions?
Observations?
Large Chilled Water Design Seminar
Variable Speed Pumping
Why variable speed?
30%
20%
15% 15%
5% 5%
2% 3% 3% 2%
Bell & Gossett 70V
1970s
Adjustable Frequency Drives
Rectifier section
converts AC to DC
several varieties available
Inverter section
forms a synthetic sine wave
several varieties available
maintains a controlled frequency/voltage ratio
Requires an automatic control system
Adds to the initial cost of the system
Affinity Laws
1. Capacity varies as the RPM change ratio:
100
90
80 Flow
70 Head
Percent
60 Horsepower
50
40
30
20
10
0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Flow/Speed, Percent
Theoretical Savings
120 120
Pump Curves 100% Speed
110 110
100 90% 100
Design
90 90
80 80% Head 80
70 70
% Head
% BHP
60 70% 60
50 60% 50
40 HP Draw 40
50%
30 30
Head
20 40% 20
BHP
10 30% 10
Flow
0 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
% Design Flow
Required Differential Pressure
P Sensor/Transmitter
25 Ft. Head
System Curve
& V/S Control System
110
Pump TDH
60
Overall
40 system curve
Distribution
20 piping head
loss curve
0
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600
Flow
Effect of Constant* Set Point
110
As the valve closes,
100 the pump slows down
Set point,
Control curve
80 25 FT
Head
Pump TDH
60
Overall system curve
40
Distribution
20 piping head
loss curve
0
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600
Flow
*Whats Constant?
Pump Control Curve
Initial Speed
B
A
Head, H
(feet)
Pipe, Fitting
Friction Loss
Q2 Q1
Flow, Q
(gpm)
Decrease in Heat Load Results in Troom < T set point
Causes Two Way Valves to Throttle Flow
Pump
Curve Speed 1
B Control Curve
A
Speed 2
Head, H C
(feet)
Pipe, Fitting
Friction Loss
Q3 Q2 Q1
Flow, Q
(gpm)
Head
(ft) Pipe, Fitting
Final Speed C Friction Loss
Flow, Q Q4 Q1
(gpm)
Supply
C C C
H H H Pump
I I I Controller
L L L
L L L
E E E
R R R
Adjustable Freqy. Drives
Return
Variable Head Loss Ratio
C/S, Constant Flow System Pump Head Matched to
Base 100 System at Design Flow
90
70
V/S, 25% Variable Hd Loss, 75% Constant Hd
60
50
V/S, 50% Variable Hd Loss, 50% Constant Hd
40
V/S, 75% Variable Hd Loss, 25% Constant Hd
30
20 V/S, 100% Variable Hd Loss, 0% Constant Hd
10
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
% Flow
Variable Head Ratio w/
Overheading
Constant Flow, C/S Pump Pump OHeaded by 150%
150
(3 Way Valve)
140
110
Base Constant Flow, C/S Pump Pump HD Matched
100
Design (3 Way Valve) to System @
90 Design Flow
HP %
80
70
60
% Full Load 50
* 25/75 Means:
(Design) HP 40 25 % Variable HD Loss
30 75 % Constant HD Loss
20
10
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
V/S Curves
120 50 % 60 % 70 %
80 % 85 % % Efficiency
110 85 %
80 %
100 100 %
90
80 90 %
Head, Feet
70
% Speed Curves
60 80 %
Constant
50 Efficiency
70 %
Curve
40
60 %
30
50%
20
40 %
10 30 %
GPM
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
Efficiency Changes
120
50 % 60 % 70 % 80 % % Efficiency
85 %
110 85 %
80 %
100 100 %
90
80 90 %
Head, Feet
70 % Speed Curves
80 %
60
Constant
50 70 % Efficiency
Curve
40
60 %
30
50%
20
40 %
10 30 %
GPM
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
Minimum Drive Speed
120
50 % 60 % 70 % 80 % % Efficiency
85 %
110 85 %
80 %
100 100 %
90
80 90 %
Head, Feet
70 % Speed Curves
80 %
60
Constant
50 70 % Efficiency
Curve
40
60 %
30
50%
20
40 %
10 30 %
GPM
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
Multiple Pump System Staging
Constant Differential Head Loss
Supply
C C C
H H H Pump
I I I Controller
L L L
L L L
E E E
R R R
Adjustable Freqy. Drives
Return
Parallel V/S Operation
Pump 1
1450 RPM
1150 RPM
600 RPM 900 RPM
Variable Speed Pumping Equipment
3f , 60 Hz Power
(Control Agent)
Controlled
Sensor/ Variable
System
Transmitter
The Controlled Variable Determines the Type of Sensor
Pressure
Differential
Pressure
Pump
4-20 Controller
ma
signal
Temperature
Differential
Temperature
Flow
3f , 60 Hz Power
(Control Agent)
Controlled
Sensor/ Variable
System
Transmitter
Technologic Pump
Controller
Controls pumps and drives
Accept set point, analyze sensor input
PID function
Pump staging
Pump alternation
Recognize and react to component failure
Provide message display
Central management system link
Safeguard system
PID Control
Eliminates offset from set point
Allows for timely speed change
Handles large, sudden disturbances
Prevents oscillation and over-damping
3f , 60 Hz Power
(Control Agent)
Adjustable
Set Point
Technologic +/- error Frequency
Set Point Pump
(Input Signal) Controller Drive
(Controlled Device)
Controlled
Sensor/ Variable
System
Transmitter
Adjustable Frequency Drive
Constant Variable
Voltage & Rectifier Direct Inverter Voltage & Pump
Frequency Section Current Section Frequency Motor
Power Power
100
Currently Available
Efficiency, %
80 AFDs
60 Typical Older AFDs
40 Other Types
20
0
0 20 40 60 80 100
Design Speed, %
Pump and Motor
The Pump
Minimum Flow
Minimum Speed
Inverter Duty
Motors
Motor Couplers
Maintaining Minimum Flow
120
100 % Speed
110
100
90
80
70
Head
60
30% Speed
50
40
30
20
10
0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
% Flow
EPDM couplers on variable-speed pumps
Failed Hytrel Coupler from a Variable
Speed Pump
Variable Flow
Through
The Evaporator
Primary-Secondary System
Constant Differential Head Loss
Supply
C C C
H H H Pump
I I I Controller
L L L
L L L
E E E
R R R
Adjustable Freqy. Drives
Return
Primary-Secondary
Common Practice.
Why?
Protection.
Nuisance shutdowns.
Freezing.
Costly downtime.
Variable Primary Flow
Two-position Control Valves Flow Meter, option
C C C
DP Sensor
H
DP Sensor
H H
DP Sensor
DP Sensor
I I I
L L L
L L L
E E E
R R R
Modulating
Valve
Ganged Pumps
FLOW SUPPLY
T METER
F F F
SIGNAL
TO TECH
DP DP
SENSOR SENSOR
DP DP DP
CHILLER CHILLER CHILLER
SENSOR SENSOR SENSOR
T
NOTE:
ALL SENSOR RETURN
SIGNALS WIRED TO
TECHNOLOGIC
5500 AFD AFD AFD
ISOLATION VALVE
CHECK VALVE
F FLOWMETER/TRANSMITTER
T TEMPERATURE SENSOR
Monitoring Chiller Flow
P sensors - Technologic controller ensures the chiller
is in proper working condition by monitoring each
working chillers differential pressure. Flow through the
chiller is calculated using the values defined in the user
setup.
OR
Flow sensors - Technologic controller ensures the chiller
is in proper working condition by monitoring each
working chillers flow rate.
Technologic 5500
Initial programming is
crucial.
Must use accurate data
from the chiller
manufacturer.
Start-up coordination
should include the BMS
too.
Technologic 5500 Control Variables
F F F
SIGNAL
TO TECH
DP DP DP
CHILLER CHILLER CHILLER DP DP
SENSOR SENSOR SENSOR
SENSOR SENSOR
SIGNAL SIGNAL
SIGNALS SIGNALS TO TECH TO TECH
TO TECH TO TECH
SIGNALS
TO TECH
T
NOTE:
ALL SENSOR RETURN
SIGNALS WIRED TO
TECHNOLOGIC
5500 AFD AFD AFD
ISOLATION VALVE
CHECK VALVE
F FLOWMETER/TRANSMITTER
T TEMPERATURE SENSOR
Alternative #2
Minimum flow bypass valve is controlled
to protect both the pumps and the
chillers.
Pump requires >25% BEP flow
Minimum flow of largest chiller
Size the bypass valve using the zone
p.
Best for systems with extended light
loads or weekend shut-down.
Alternative #3
F F F
SIGNAL
TO TECH
DP DP
SENSOR SENSOR
DP DP DP
CHILLER CHILLER CHILLER
SENSOR SENSOR SENSOR
SIGNAL SIGNAL
BYPASS:
TO TECH TO TECH
FOR SYSTEMS WITH
EXTENDED LIGHT
LOADS/WEEKEND
SHUTDOWNS. SET
SIGNALS SIGNALS SIGNALS BALANCE VALVE
TO TECH TO TECH TO TECH FOR LOW FLOW TO
REDUCE THERMAL
STRATIFICATION
AND ALLOW QUICK
START UP AFTER
SHUT DOWN.
TDV TDV TDV
T
NOTE:
ALL SENSOR RETURN
SIGNALS WIRED TO
TECHNOLOGIC
5500 AFD AFD AFD
ISOLATION VALVE
CHECK VALVE
F FLOWMETER/TRANSMITTER
T TEMPERATURE SENSOR
Pump Selection
Equal size pumps.
Redundancy.
Parts.
Maintenance.
Unequal size pumps.
Control issues.
Flow issues.
Premature failure, large pump at low flow.
Chiller Selection
Equal size chillers.
Redundancy.
Parts.
Maintenance.
Unequal size chillers.
Control issues.
Flow issues
Additional equipment.
Design Considerations
#1 4-12 **
#2 20-30 2-5
#3 ** 30
#4 2 **
#5 ** 1.67
*Table 2-2
ARTI-21CR/611-20070-01, 2004, Bahnfleth & Peyer
** Information not provided
Do not use if:
Supply temperature is critical.
Zone A
Zone B
C C
H H
I I
L L
L L Variable Speed Pump
E E
R R
Direct Pumped Zones
Zone B Zone C
Zone A
WRONG !
C C
H H
I I DP Controller
L L
L L
E E
R R
Constant Demand Zones
Zone A Zone B
Zone C
T
WRONG !
C C
H H
I I
L L Automatic
L L
E E
Flow Control
Hard set valve Valve
R R
Primary-Secondary-Tertiary
Zone C
Zone A
RIGHT ! Zone B
C C
H H
I I
L L
L L Variable Speed Pump
E E
R R
Three Different Buildings
A has coils selected for 44F.
B has coils selected for 45F.
C has coils selected for 46F.
Zone A
Zone B
C
H
C
H ?
I I
L L
L L Optional Variable
E E Speed Pump
R R
Temperature Sensor Locations
MV
Load
MV
Load
Load MV
T1 T4 T1
T2 T3 T4
Tertiary
Zone
Pump Common T2
T3
Pumped Circuit Setter
Chilled
Water
Supply
Chilled
Water
Return
Tertiary Bridge
MV
Load
MV
Load
Load MV
T1 T4
Tertiary
Zone Common
Pump T2
T3
Pumped
Chilled
Water
Supply
Tertiary Bridge
Chilled
Water
Return
Temperature Sensor Locations
MV
Load
MV
Load
Load MV
T1 T4 T1
T2 T3 T4
Tertiary
Zone
Pump Common T2
T3
Pumped
Chilled
Water
Supply
Chilled
Water
Return
ADVANTAGES
1. Permits operating at highest allowable zone temperature
2. Maximizes coil flow rate, good film coefficients
3. Maximizes flow rate through each control valve
4. Ensures good humidity control
5. Minimizes the amount of coil reheat
DISADVANTAGES
1. Temperature of return water is unknown
2. Temperature of return water to chiller may be too high
3. Will not recognize increased supply water temperature
T2 Operation
MV
Load
Load MV
Load MV
T1 T4 T1 T2 T3 T4
Tertiary
Zone
Pump Common T2
T3
Pumped
Chilled
Water
Supply
Chilled
Water
Return
ADVANTAGES
1. Maintains chilled water return temperature at setpoint
2. Will not overload the chiller
DISADVANTAGES
1. No control of zone supply water temperature
2. Could lose humidity control
3. Will not recognize increased supply water temperature
T3 Operation
MV
Load
MV
Load
Load MV
T1 T4
T1 T2 T3 T4
Tertiary
Zone
Pump Common T2
T3
Pumped
Chilled
Water
Supply
Chilled
Water
Return
ADVANTAGES
1. There are no perceived advantages at this location
DISADVANTAGES
1. Little, if any, valve modulation unless it is set to
close on sensing supply temperature lower than
permissible in the zone
T4 Operation
MV
Load
MV
Load
Load MV
T1 T4
T1 T2 T3 T4
Tertiary
Zone
Pump Common T2
T3
Pumped
Chilled
Water
Supply
Chilled
Water
Return
ADVANTAGES
1. Maximizes coil flow rate
2. Ensures good humidity control
DISADVANTAGES
1. Temperature of return water is unknown
2. Temperature of return water to chiller may be too high
3. Will not recognize increased supply water temperature
No single sensor location
satisfies all design criteria
SO........
Applying Zone Valve Controller
MV
Load
MV
Load
MV T1 T2 T3
Load
T1
Tertiary
Zone
Pump Common T2
T3
Pumped
Chilled
Water
Supply
Chilled
Water
Return
Control Algorithm
1. Temperature control to the zone (T1 sensing).
2. If T1 is satisfied, return water temperature to the chiller
plant (T2 sensing).
3. Monitor secondary chilled water supply temperature
(T3 sensing) for temperature increase due to secondary
return water recirculation or temperature decrease due to
chiller leaving water temperature reset.
4. Reference point for automatic reset and T (T2 - T3)
control (T3 sensing).
So what?
Secondary Pumps
Problems
Bypass returns cold water to chillers,
reduces system t.
Linear valve characteristics can cause
increased flow at part load.
Balancing required in bypass pipe and
coil-to-coil.
High cost per ton at the chiller.
3-way Valve System
Load MV
Load MV
Load MV T1 T2 T3
T1
Common
T2
Flow
Meter
T3 Small
By-Pass
Secondary Supply
Secondary Return
Multi-zone Application
Zone 1 Zone 2 Zone 3 Zone 4
Terminal Terminal
Unit Control Unit Balance Zone
Valve Valve (Tertiary)
Pump
Zone Supply
Temperature
T1 T1 T1 T1
Zone Bias
3D Valves Control Valve
T2 T2 T2 T2
C C C
h h
C Distribution
h
i i i o (Secondary)
l l l m Pumps
l l l m
e e e o Rolairtrol
r r r n
District Cooling Application
Individual building temperature control
Static pressure isolation
Return water temperature control
Btu/hr totalization
Outdoor temperature reset
Independent operation
District Cooling Application
with GPX
Zone Supply
Temperature
T1 T1 T1 T1
Zone Bias
3D Valves Control Valve
T2 T2 T2 T2
C C C
h h h
i i i
l l l
l l l
e e e
r Rolairtrol
r r
Comments?
Questions?
Observations?
Large Chilled Water System Design Seminar
Primary-Secondary Zone Pumping Systems
Primary-Secondary Zone Pumping
C C
H H
Supply
I I
L L
L L
E E
R R
Return
Shared Piping
C C
H H
Supply
I I
L L
L L
E E Shared Pipe
R R
Return
Shared Piping
C C
H H
Supply
I I
L L
L L
E E Shared Pipe
R R
Return
Present and Future Piping
1500 gpm 1500 gpm (1500 gpm)
Flow :
Current = 3000
Future = 4500
Zone A Zone B Zone C
C C
H H Supply
I I Current = 0
L L Current = 1500 Future = 1500
L L Future = 3000 Future Zone C
E E
R R
Return
Zone A Requirements
1500 gpm @ 80 (1500 gpm) (1500 gpm)
4500 gpm*
A Zone A A1 Supply A2 A3
Pressure drop:A to A1+B to B1
Present = 20.8
*Future = 45.2
B1 Return B2 B3
B 4500 gpm*
Zone A Calculations
A1 Supply A2 A3
A
Pressure drop: Zone C
AtoA1+ BtoB1 + A1toA2 + B1toB2 + A2toA3+ B2toB3
Present = 45.2 + 33.4 + 21.4
Future = Present
B1 Return B2 B3
Load
Friction
Loss
0 0
Friction Loss
Supply Header
Friction Loss
Return Header
Primary-Secondary Equivalent
1500 GPM 1500 GPM (1500 GPM)
Chiller 2
Chiller 1
AFDs Pump
Controller
B1 Return B2 B3
B
1500 GPM
3000 GPM
P-S Calculations
Present = 3000 gpm @ 109.8 feet, increase impeller to 13.5 for future head requirements:
2 @ VSCS 8x10x17L @ 111.0 hp 125 NOL
1 @ VSCS 8x10x17L @ 111.0 hp 125 NOL, standby
Total 3 Pumps 375 NOL, Total
Future considerations
Reduced Horsepower
Comments?
Questions?
Observations?
Large Chilled Water System Design Seminar
Variable Speed Sensor Selection and Location
Direct Return Piped System
Supply
Differential
Pressure
Pump Sensor
Chiller 3
Chiller 2
Chiller 1
Controller
AFDs
Return
Single Point Pressure Sensor
Supply
WRONG!
Single
Point
Pressure
Chiller 3
Chiller 2
Chiller 1
Sensor
Pump
AFDs Controller
Return
Control Curve Using Single Point
Pressure Sensor
90
80
50
40 1750 RPM
(Maximum rpm)
30
20 1480 RPM
(Minimum rpm)
10
0
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600
Flow, gpm
Single Point Pressure Sensor
in a CHW System
A rise in the average water temperature
results in a net expansion of the water.
This net expansion volume flows into
the compression tank, raising the
system pressure.
The pump slows down.
What if?
Zone A Zone B Zone C
P Sensor here
Supply
C C C
H H H
I I I
L L L
L L L
E E E
R R R
Pump
AFDs Controller
Return
Sensor Across Mains At Pump
Whats the set point?
Its the greatest branch and distribution
piping head loss calculated at design
flow. In other wordsdesign head.
What will the flow be in each zone?
Determined by the zone path CV
Differential Pressure Sensor
at the Pump
90
80
Design Point
70
60
Head, FT
50
40 Maximum rpm
30
20
Minimum rpm
10
0
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600
Flow, gpm
Variable Head Loss Ratio
C/S, Constant Flow System Pump Head Matched to
Base 100 System at Design Flow
90
70
V/S, 25% Variable Hd Loss, 75% Constant Hd
60
50
V/S, 50% Variable Hd Loss, 50% Constant Hd
40
V/S, 75% Variable Hd Loss, 25% Constant Hd
30
20 V/S, 100% Variable Hd Loss, 0% Constant Hd
10
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
% Flow
Coil or Valve?
25 Head
Maximizing Variable Head Loss
Constant Head Loss
Supply
Differential
Pressure
Pump Sensor
Chiller 3
Chiller 2
Chiller 1
Controller
AFDs
Return
Control Area
Zone 1 Zone 2
20 ft 20 ft
A B C D
DP Sensor
C C C
H H H
I I I
L L L
L L L
E E E
R R R
Pump
AFDs Controller
E
F
Pressure Drops in Piping (Table 11-1)
TDH = P AB + EF + BC + DE + P ZONE 2 = 60 FT
Control Area Calculation
Table 11-2 Control Area Calculation
Flow Flow Friction Friction P Friction Friction P TDH
Zone 1 Zone 2 Loss Loss Zone 1 Loss Loss Zone 2
AB+EF Zone 1 BC+DE Zone 2
0 gpm 600 gpm 5 0 40 20 20 20 45
300 gpm 300 gpm 5 5 25 5 20 20 30
600 gpm 0 gpm 5 20 20 0 0 20 25
0 gpm 0 gpm 0 0 20 0 0 20 20
600 gpm 600 gpm 20 20 40 20 20 20 60
What pump head is required at:
zero flow?
full flow?
less than full flow?
Control Area
60
50
40
Head, FT
30
20
Lower Limit
10 Upper Limit
Single Point
0
0 100 300 500 600 900 1100 1200
Flow, gpm
So What...?
Staging pumps in a closed loop HVAC
system by flow alone may not work
because of different head requirements
for a given flow.
Wire to water pump efficiency
calculations at part load depend heavily
on the assumptions made about the
nature and shape of the control curve.
Single Sensor, Including
Balance Valve Pressure Drop
Zone 1 Zone 2
25 ft 20 ft
B (50) C
A
E (10) D
F
What do you mean...?
The head loss across the coil and the
wide open valve in zone 1 is 25 feet at
full flow.
If thats true, then we need to add an
extra 15 feet of head loss in the balance
valve to insure adequate flow out to
Zone 2 when the Zone 1 valve is wide
open.
Set Point, Zone 1, 40 ft
Flow Zone 1 Flow Zone 2 Friction Loss Friction Loss Head Required Setpoint -
AB+EF BC+DE Zone 2 Friction Loss
0 gpm 600 gpm 5 20 20 0
300 gpm 300 gpm 5 5 5 30
600 gpm 0 gpm 5 0 0 40
A B C D
DP Sensor
C C C
H H H
I I I
L L L
L L L
E E E
R R R
Pump
AFDs Controller
E
F
Single Sensor in Zone 2
Zone 1 requires 600 gpm at 25 ft
Zone 2 requires 600 gpm at 20 ft
P Avail -
Flow Flow Friction Loss Friction Loss Friction Loss P Zone1, Friction Loss
Zone 1 Zone 2 AB+EF Zone 1 BC+DE Available Zone 1
0 gpm 600 gpm 5 0 20 40 40
300 gpm 300 gpm 5 6.25 5 25 13.75
600 gpm 0 gpm 5 25 0 20 -5
Flow Zone 1 Flow Zone 2 Friction Loss Friction Loss Head Required Setpoint -
AB+EF BC+DE Zone 2 Friction Loss
0 gpm 600 gpm 5 20 20 5
300 gpm 300 gpm 5 5 5 20
600 gpm 0 gpm 5 0 0 25
Supply
DP Sensors
C C C
H H H
I I I
L L L
L L L
E E E
R R R
Pump
AFDs Controller
Return
Use Multiple Sensors?
Load
Similarity
Priority
Diversity
One building or several
Redundancy
First cost vs operating cost
The Active Zone
Zone set points do not have to be the
same.
Technologic pump controller scans all
zones often, comparing process
variable to set point in each case.
Pumps are controlled to satisfy the
worst case.
What happens to the rest of the zones?
Effect of Sensor Location
Zone 1 Zone 2
B
C
A
OR
E D
F
Multiple Sensors & Setpoints
Multiple sensors, set point across Zone 1, = 25 FT and setpoint across Zone 2 = 20 FT, (Table 11-6)
Flow Flow Friction Loss Minimum P Friction Loss Minimum P
Zone Zone AB+EF Reqd Zone1 BC+DE Reqd Zone 2
1 2 P Zone 1, Available P Zone2 Available
0 600 5 0 40 20 20 20
300 300 5 6.25 25 5 5 20
600 0 5 25 25 0 0 25
Supply
C
H
I
L
L
E
R
Return
Reverse Return Systems
If all the circuits are the same length,
will the pump still change speed?
Suppose a coil with a high p
requirement and another with a lower p
requirement are served by the same
reverse return piping system. OK?
If the coils are serving different sides of
the building, could we have a problem?
Tertiary Piped System
C C
H H
I I
L L
L L
E E
R R
Return
Zone Piped System
C C
H H
Supply
I I
L L
L L
E E
R R
Return
Summary
Give priority to the needs of the branch.
The rule of sensor location is simple and easy
to apply:
If you have to use a single sensor, put it across
the critical branch.
Whats the critical branch?
Its the same one that determined the pump head.
As weve seen, the analysis is more important
than the rule.
Comments?
Questions?
Observations?
Large Chilled Water System Design Seminar
Achieving Hydronic System Balance
Systems Approach
Control M
Load
Distribution Air Management
Verification
Philosophy
Source
Systems Approach
All components work together as team
Components interact and work as well as we
understand them
A collection of mismatched components will
not perform as expected
Owner, engineer, architect, contractor, and
operators are part of the system too!
Hydronic Balancing
We worry about balance because:
Load calculations are approximate
Piping circuitry analysis is approximate
Control valve selection is approximate
Approximations will lead to underflow and
overflow situations
Results of overflow or underflow
Design Dt cannot be achieved
Supply temperature controller hunts (?)
Sequence of operation can be upset.
For example:
Published by
ASHRAE &
Hydraulic
Institute
Darcy-
Weisbach
Equation.
Add 15%!
What Is Balancing?
Its test, adjust & balance
Test: The system, now built, is verified in
operation to perform to the expected level.
What do we measure?
temperature, flow, pressure drop, energy
consumption.
What do we test with?
Can we test with what is installed?
Can we obtain accurate readings?
Adjust
120% 45
Total
40
100%
35
Waterside T (F)
% Heat Emission
80% 30
Sensible
25
60%
20
Latent
40% 15
10
20%
5
0% 0
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 160% 180% 200%
% Flow
30H X 46W 10 FPI / 4 Row 30 GPM / 10T 85 DB/ 71 WB Ent 45 EWT 15 Circuits 3/8 Tube 4000 CFM Nominal 10 Ton Rating
Chilled Water Coil Flow vs. Emission
100
97%
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
80% 100%
30H X 46W 10 FPI / 4 Row 30 GPM / 10T 85 DB/ 71 WB Ent 45 EWT 15 Circuits 3/8 Tube 4000 CFM Nominal 10 Ton Rating
Flow Tolerance 97% Design HT
-0 / +10% 5% 10% 15% 20%
Supply Water Temperature F
260
240
220
Heating
200
180
160
140
120
100
80
Cooling
6
70 16
60
50
40
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24
Suggested Flow Tolerance (%)
Balancing, The Obvious Answer
Maximum branch flows need to be controlled
Balancing valves are one solution
Pressure independent flow control is another
method
Systems perspective needs to be
maintained; pipe, valves, calculations.
Pressure Dependent Balancing Valve
Pressure Dependent Balancing Valve
140
120
100
Head (Feet)
80
60
40
20
0
0 50 100 150 200 250
Flow (USGPM)
Pressure Independent Flow Limiting Valve
Cartridge
Cartridge Operation
Flow Flow
P1 P2 P1 P2
P1 is low P1 is high
Cartridge Opens Cartridge Closes
P1 - P2 = Constant P1 - P2 = Constant
Pressure Independent Flow Limiting Valve
Fixed
Orifice
Control Range
Flow in GPM
.13 to 37 GPM
Nominal Pipe Friction Variable Friction Friction Variable Friction Friction Variable Friction
Size, in. Other Loss Rate Speed Loss Rate Other Loss Rate Speed Loss Rate Other Loss Rate Speed Loss Rate
(GPM) (Ft/100 Ft) (GPM) (Ft / 100 Ft) (GPM) (Ft / 100 Ft) (GPM) (Ft / 100 Ft) (GPM) (Ft / 100 Ft) (GPM) (Ft / 100 Ft)
2 1/2 120 10.01 180 21.78 85 5.2 130 11.66 68 3.42 110 8.48
3 180 7.26 270 15.78 140 4.5 210 9.74 110 2.86 170 6.51
4 350 6.55 530 14.56 260 3.72 400 8.46 210 2.48 320 5.52
5 410 2.84 620 6.25 310 1.67 470 3.68 250 1.12 370 2.34
6 740 3.47 1100 7.44 570 2.11 860 4.63 440 1.3 680 2.96
8 1200 2.2 1800 4.79 900 1.27 1400 2.95 700 0.79 1100 1.86
10 1800 1.52 2700 3.3 1300 0.82 2000 1.86 1000 0.5 1600 1.21
12 2500 1.18 3800 2.63 1900 0.7 2900 1.57 1500 0.45 2300 1.01
Velocity
Operating <2000 and <4400
Hours/Year <2000 Hours/Year Hours/Year >4400 Hours/Year
Estimated annual
energy cost based
on pipe size
Note that cost is based on a constant load it is
independent of the info in ASHRAE frame
Branch to Riser Pressure Drop Ratio
Ratio, Branch To
% Design Flow
Distribution
In End Circuit
4 95
2 90
1 80
0
Distance From Pump
Branch:Riser Pressure Drop Ratio
100%
constant
Reduced pump head
Head
0
Distance From Pump
Issue: System Curve
10 10 0 1 340 20 1000
CV
2 287 28 1000
G 1 g
4 8 4 3 1000
CV 253 36
F 2 f
4 16 4 4 229 44 1000
CV
E 3 e
5 211 52 1000
4 CV 24 4
D 4 d 6 196 60 1000
4 CV 32 4
C 5 c Total 6000@68
4 CV 40 4
B 6 b
4 4
Branch = 20
Risers = 48
A a
Ratio = 0.4
70.0
60.0
50.0
40.0
Head (Feet)
30.0
20.0
0.0
0.0 1000.0 2000.0 3000.0 4000.0 5000.0 6000
Flow (USGPM)
2
Q2
h2 h1 Min Control Head
Q1
2:1 BRPDR
70.0
10 10 0
CV
60.0
G 1 g
.83 CV
1.7 .83
F 2 f
50.0
.83 CV
3.4 .83
E 3 e
40.0
.83 5.1 .83
Head (Feet)
CV
D 4 d
30.0
.83 CV
6.8 .83
C 5 c
20.0 .83 CV
8.5 .83
Out Valves Close Head
Inner Valves Close
B 6 b
System Curve
10.0
.83 .83
0.0 A a
0.0 1000.0 2000.0 3000.0 4000.0 5000.0 6000.0
6000 @ 30
Flow (USGPM)
VFD
6 10 5 10 4 10 3 10 2 10 1 10
6000 GPM
@88 Ft Hd
10 10 10 10 10 10
1 40 32 24 16 8 0
2
2 2 F 4 E 4 D 4 C 4 B 4 A
3
20
120.0
Valve 6 Closed
Valve 6 & 5
Closed
100.0
Valve 6,5,4
Valve 6,5,4,3
Closed All Open
Closed
80.0
Valve 6,5,4,3,2
Closed
Head (Feet)
60.0
40.0
Valve 1 Closed
System Curve
0.0
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000
Flow (GPM)
Thoughts On Selection
Coil pressure drop dominates system
controllability.
Control valve selection with = 0.5
Balancing valves: provide trim
Use as much PD as possible in control valves
Absorb the rest at the balancing valve.
Use independent flow measurement
Triple Duty Valve
Pump
Circuit Setters
Summary: Why Test & Balance?