PETER KWASNIEWSKI
Noble Beauty,
Transcendent Holiness
Why the Modern Age
Needs the Mass of Ages
e
Foreword by
‘Martin Mosebach
#5 Angelico Press2
Reverence Is Not Enough:
On the Importance
of Tradition
Shocked to ee the enorme deraton Visited upon Umbia
tora sere of powefl earthquakes Thisreion of al inches
the town of Nort the birthplace of aint Benedict and Scola
tev and the ste (since the Jbl Yea of 2000) of + Benedieine
Imenasery famous for Latin Harpy and delicous bee. The ews
as prsilelydresing to me at an oblate of this monastery
tho ad just pent two weeks there inl teaching a course on the
Ep t the Hebrews As Tooked at photo ofthe damage could
not ep thinking of two vers fom that eter: We have Bere no
shige but we el one that come” (514) and"Whom the
lord loves, be chastity and he sourgth every son whom he
recive (Hb 2:6) The monk, tre to the pr ofthe Bene
ne moto scan vrei! are ebuding in eres. Many people
are coming to ther ai, and. in dae course, they will nt oly
sr bit, God wing ome ot stronger than before. Lignure
Ibe pe: praccisune ferrari et ran eu pale
Meme ri nigra cg etna ial lant. °A tee hth hope it be ext it groweth gre gan, andthe
Reet ali pony eso boughs thereof spot (jb 47).
asst Bey hance band ih hy is ae
I: rie Last mw mowrts of 2016 the Cathol world wasNoble Beau, Transcendent Holness
‘The damage in Norcia was subwati, The earhguakes hap:
pened suddenly, their magnitudes were considerable: and thee
have been power aftershocks, Beatifl churches throughout the
town, including the medieval basilica over the anceat Roman
crypt. are copied into ruins. Ie bulge that wee stil standing.
‘huge cracks zigaggeé down she wal Experts carefill nape
bulding afer bulking 10 anes problems and set prone
for reconstruction, Paces once Fl of life were no longe inhabit
ble eas of expensive reais wil be neesay before daly fe
‘an resume with any Kind of fallaess. Then there ae the costs hat
ae hares to speak about, berate they te emotional, personal,
‘pita some people wil be sanctfed by these ial wie others
‘ay tae ocasion fr sinning, De tthe phew of as a ew
separate days, Norcia became a lac of dite conson, head
‘ches and heartaches too numerous o count. Ihe lo beome &
place of heroic charity and generosy,» summons to patience,
«ope nd determination, and a reminder of whet is mom impor
fentinie
ft szems to me that we can take ths earthquake asa parable er
‘the Church in our times. Something sialar commenced about ity
eas ago inthe day-to-day if of the Catholic Church, namely, ¢
‘eres of sudden and sizeable changes inthe manner in which the
Holy Scrce ofthe Mas and the other Iturgles and sacraments
wee celebrated, together withthe often heel meanings that
were attached to thowe changes. The ground shied undemesth vs
4 enturieroldItugia tes and practices were replaced lost
vemig with rapily-constrated form and unprecedented nov.
lies [n Wester Europe and America, there was an epidemic of
‘unbridled experimentation; all crtaines vanished the mag aad
‘compas of tradition were discarded, replaced by communal exe=
expression. The advent ofthe Novus Ordo Misses
‘ike an earthgua in ts sddenness ar well a in the deasation
‘hat followed se it in so many places? Local churches that bad
oe eae ef ern mah tn Hy We Pll
Noverence Is Not Enough: On the Importance of Tradition
Iw thriving in numbers of fitful an in presty and religious
‘wwatonscolapsed, ax milions of Catholics stepped practicing
Iie ith snd thousands of pret, monks, nuns, and ses aban
Adve tei hoy cling When the due etd, instead of areaewa,
thee were ge crackin theetlectal and sta structre the
wil and elings of aris beauty had falen apart; ecesiascal
stares were dangerous inhabit not enable?
lls century later, however any in the Church have yet to
‘me to gup withthe reports of ur or engineering spect
ho wer eel swce ofthe mapnitade ofthe eethquake and he
‘ope of te damage—orpere who know and love (or Sew and
ted) she Char’ iergy. theology. an tations experts falar
vh human disciplines uch a anthopology,pyeblogy, and sci-
‘logy There wat Meg. Klaus Gamber, who, sein the vast ier
‘nc: beseen the cael Roman Rite andthe reformed arg in
‘ry sgafcant clement, maintained tht the new coud not be
vowed sea mere revision ofthe old but had tobe tented as die
src panes pet al ne poe at
‘So ype ego rot
ie sou in penn of Se cedar te
‘Soe tt pa eee oa ht
diene inte mapas ge te Die Ot wi el ce
‘inal ri the omputon osm ets iia ware
2a nr oc om paige
‘epae f pn Nevrna ge at dt
‘ovbgyvareting ln cent en esc de
Seis tga Ln ing Si ft iy On 9
cng Nt ci OF Rd Casey Me
ntsoplpaland yeh ences a Se! iy 3-3
sNoble Beans Transcendent Holts
tinct “modern site There was Michael Daves, who demon:
strated nis boo Cranmers Gay Order, thatthe changes made
to the Roman Catholic liturgy parleled thowe made by Thomas
(Cranmer in hs creation ofthe Protestant tary ofthe Church of
England, Therewad Lass Dobay, who pelastakingly docs
roeated the rtud>muscal incoherence ofthe new tes, Thee is
Doe Alcin Reld, who has ahown thatthe Iti refer of the
oe cant beconldered tbe in cntinnty with the Reman tr
{ition by eny historically grounded and phlesophicaly coherent
tundentanding of “orgnie"® There it host of authors, amon
whom coud be named Aidan Nichol, Catherine Pidatock, Mary
Douglas and Anthony Archer, who, droving on human daptines
such asthe athropelogyof religion, hae expoed with embarrass
ing arity how badly the revived Iiurgical tes asesed the actual
‘needa of modern man, and how they have not oly alle to ter
the tide of secalaram and dencralation but hee even conta
ed tot
‘Niarl disasters ze responsible for many physi and ctrl
cls bat thy alo serve toring out the bet n people. Something
Similar ofthe itargeal and theoloial eoluion tat tok
lc ast entry. Once became len thatthe get Caholic a
fon was under stack and exposed to the risk of extinction, the
oly Sint raised up many neble souls fom ll ranks sss nd
5. Kaus Gunter The Ror fhe Rot Ly Poi a ak
(sin aon cmmen "Theta est ak
‘toa of we, soe screed just PAelom the ees?
‘go pel nan Chan Ore ad phd Agpenrso
‘Ra i i rt bn
espa DewlpmentgfeLiny,
6
Reverence Is Not Enough: On the Imponance of Tradition
sete ifthe famous as wells the humble, oppose this fore
‘march of moderizaon. A high-profile petition signed by many
famous people fom Great Britain, beeing Paul VI for he contin
ued allowance of the Tidentie tag, rested inthe so-called
‘agatha Christ indult? whereby priests in England cou obtain
permision vo celebrate the tational rie. Pope John Paul
ncourged bishops tbe generous in making rom for Catholics
tached to thelr trplcl radon. Most nail, Pope Benedict
XVFealed the Church back o contnulty with her glorious past
her futile tradition, her unsurpassed culture of Beauty inthe
service of the Word. In these decades of wandering in the vid
ness inthis Babylonian capt o contemporary Western fashion,
‘he movement to rediscover nd rere the filles of the Churcs
‘worship has quiet grown. Clergy, religious, and lay dedicated to
the uae antiguior ate now found in every counzy and on every
continent tae communis are characterized by lrg failes
tnd high numbers of vocations tothe priesthood tnd consecrated
Le. Fully Catholic worship goes hand-in-hand wih doctrinal
incegegy consistent wines of if, and 2 renewed this fr hol
es. This rch good ne, amidst the robe
@
Aft ths extended metaphor an cbjecon might be rased “Why
‘eadion so important? len it enough jst to ave everett
gy As long as we ave sincere in our intentions and sous about
‘our prayer al these ether shings—the language of our worship, the
‘ype of muse the duction ofthe pie a the ls the way people
‘ecrve communion, whether or ad we kp the sume readings and
prayers that Catholics used for cats, and go forth—ate just
Incidental or accidental features. They re ‘exerals) end Jesus
taught or hat external eet the mala thing in eligion”
There i ofcourse, sme truth wo this objection. Our intentions
sre jndeedfandamenial If non-believer pretended o get beptized
2 par of «ply on stage be would not realy became a Christan,
‘No axernl by theses willever guarantee hat we are worship
Jing the Father in spiit and in ruth Jn-43-24)and an atteNoble Beauty, Transcendent Hotness
of reverence and seriousness the most ruil requiement ofthe
ars clarandi Nevers, ble thatthe ejection as stated i
‘erroneous, and dangerously 50, because it presumes, and thereby
fosers a radial wapsformation ofthe very nature ofthe Catholic
religion under the inuence of Elightenment philosophy
‘Prot tall angumentsdbout which peace s betas cr worse is
the overarching principle of the prizacy of tradion, meaning the
inherent daim tht our wligious inhertance, handed down fom
‘our feathers, mason a, We do not “ow thi gi, much ess
“produce” i Tradion comes to us fom above, from God who
rovdently designed us ab socal animals who inherit our lan
uage, our culture, and ou selon it comes tous rom aur ances
torn who ate called enacts in Latin telly, the ones who
have gone before” They ae ahead of us, nt behind ws the have
finished running the race and we stand to benefit for their calle
tive wisdom. St.Paul sats the principles Thessonians i: "We
pay and beseech you ia the Lord Jesus that a you have rexved
from! us ow you ought to walk and 19 please God, 9 also yo
‘would wal, that you may abound the moce”™
“The selection of tation andthe cal of change embodies =
pecllly modern atitude of mastery ove tradition? whic isthe
{oil equvalet of Baconian and Cartan “mastery over nate”
‘The comblaation of capita and technology bar slowed to
abuse the satura word treating raw material for exploitation
{a pura of the sisfaction of or sesh desires In sila way,
‘he influence of rationlem and incvidualem has tempted ue 2
tees Catholic tradition asi were a collection of isolated fice
from whic ws, who ae astonomovs and superior can make wh
ever section pleas us In adopting this arrogant stance, we fal to
recognize, with creatrely hum hat our rationality is socially
Contitted and traditon-dependet. By filing o honor ovr an=-
esos. we flo lve according to our pola nature and our
Christian dignisy as recipients of a concrete historical revelation
2 Theda sh hm a om
8
Reverence Is Not Enough: On the Importance of Tadton
that endures and develops organically overtime and space? The
palm verse comes to mind “Know ye thatthe Lor, hei God be
made us, and ot we ourselves (Ps 93) Sse eit ose om ps
‘on We donot mae osreves nor do we rae our lio or our
Trg we recive our existence, we recive ou fh, we recive
‘urworship! Ton comes tous om outside ouraes, before
{nd beyond ws. unambigensty xpressr our dependence on
(God as creatures, as Christiana cobs withthe sins An bit
is one who inherits no the salf-made man” of eptalism
‘The reformed tray, moreover, lke modern liberals its
ceaals choice spontaney, and divest, whereas the historic tar
fies of Christian, both Easern and Wester, present the wor
‘hiper wth uly atculated act of worship to which we rately
yield ours taking oni featres ean icon panel eceives yer
Mier lier of preseribed color unt the Deal image sande
ford! The worahiperactaconding to oles and a script they have
reeced, plating it words om thelr ps wearing the mas (ast
‘vece) or proapon of Cri, otha they may acguee is mind in
‘hile and deserve to obtain His glory fn theif come. The it
urgy is cosine puting on af Christ which presupposes a put-
ting of ofthe old man, with his warped desire for sutbensiy?”
9. Mae py God hom we wep isn abseacon bu os
elt annonce
decree te Te a ee Cay et
otentnnce tad re Rtnaes nny enh Wena ign
“Thelema dosnt ek expen fog ha rn ap
‘one that mt eproduig on pane adn he sol he posal ey of
2 ay re tmp ht hen ene Se rw