Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Selfservice Research Report
Selfservice Research Report
To assess how the world’s leading contact centres are addressing today’s
challenges, we have undertaken an industry research study of contact centre
managers, customer service executives, and everyday consumers.
I hope you’ll take some time to digest the wealth of market intelligence in this
report, compiled from interviews with over 230 European customer service
executives. Their thoughts and ideas provide useful insights in succeeding with
self-service, and we greatly appreciate their involvement. I trust you will find
the results valuable.
Wes Hayden
President & Chief Executive Officer
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories Inc.
1
A research study of consumer attitudes and how European Contact Centres are managing self-service
Contents
Executive Summary 4
Investing in self-service 19
Automating more 19
Choosing who can self-serve 19
The customer experience 20
Internet self-service 21
Consistency in multi-channel customer care 21
Being accessible in times of need 22
Speech recognition 25
Key drivers for speech 25
Types of speech applications 26
Resistance to speech 26
Building a business case 27
Consumer acceptance of speech 27
Results with speech recognition 30
Conclusion 31
Where to go for more information 32
3
A research study of consumer attitudes and how European Contact Centres are managing self-service
Executive Summary
4
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc • Contact Centre Realities • Volume 1
• Consumers aged over 65 are more likely to be unsatisfied Speech
with touchtone IVRs, yet they are far more likely than
younger consumers to be satisfied with speech enabled • 21% of organisations have already deployed speech
IVRs recognition technology or are developing their first
application
• Men demonstrate a greater preference for speech
recognition systems than women • Of those, 72% have more applications planned or under
consideration, and 75% have seen an increase in customer
• 82% of consumers consider it valuable to be able to satisfaction
request a call back when having problems on the web
• A further 23% of organisations are currently evaluating
• 25% believe it is essential to be able to send an email on the business case
the spot when using a website
• By the end of 2005, 29% of European and 50% of North
• 58% of consumers under 35 years consider text messaging American contact centres will have deployed speech
a valuable way to receive information from suppliers
• 71% of consumers think speech recognition works
satisfactorily or very well and 74% are happy to use it
The customer experience again
• With less two-way interaction with customers, supporting • 56% of consumers prefer speech to touchtone, and 34%
the brand and providing a consistent experience have have no preference
become major factors in maintaining customer loyalty
• 47% have had difficulty with websites and have not been Offshore outsourcing
able to get meaningful support or assistance over the
phone • 14% of organisations are currently using offshore
outsourcing, and 11% are evaluating it. 36% have no plans
• Executives are increasingly concerned about consistency to offshore and 35% say they definitely will not
of service across interaction channels, and are actively
pursuing solutions inside their organisations • Those executives who definitely will not offshore cite the
loss of local jobs and lack of local cultural understanding
• Consumers demonstrated that having to interact with as the most common reasons
computers is the least frustrating thing about touchtone
and speech enabled IVRs. It is the frustration of poor • Offshore outsourcing is explored in more detail in the
design that most annoys them global edition of this study which is available by request
5
A research study of consumer attitudes and how European Contact Centres are managing self-service
Introduction and Scope
Self-service technologies have been a great gift to contact contact centre and customer service executives from 20
centres and the people responsible for managing them over countries were interviewed about their self-service systems
the past two decades. While customer expectations for service and strategies, and more than 1500 consumers were surveyed
have steadily risen and markets have become increasingly about their self-service and contact centre experiences.
competitive, contact centre and customer service executives
This report presents the key findings from the European
have been able to consistently enhance service for customers
component of this study, with an analysis of 235 interviews
while simultaneously reducing costs. A stream of contact
with contact centre and customer service executives, and
centre technologies has enabled them to deliver increasingly
1056 consumer surveys. A global report examining the trends
lower operational costs to boards of management hungry for
and differences between major global regions is available by
opportunities to improve the bottom line.
request, along with three further reports analysing the results
Doing more-with-less has been enabled by key technologies from North America, Asia-Pacific, and Australia and New
like CTI, advanced call-routing, virtual call centres and Zealand.
workforce management, but probably the most profound
improvements have come from touchtone IVR systems and
internet technologies which have provided unprecedented
opportunities to serve customers at greatly reduced cost, and
make organisations more readily accessible.
6
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc • Contact Centre Realities • Volume 1
Profile of respondents Total number of seats in your contact centres
Europe
The value of this self-service research study is reflected in
the diversity and size of the organisations that participated. 5,000 - 29,000 • 5%
In total 235 contact centre managers and customer service 5 - 50 • 21%
1,000 - 3,000 • 17%
executives from 14 countries and 19 different industries
were interviewed by telephone in October 2004. Of the
235 interviewed, 4% do not have an IVR in place, and 12%
do not have a functional website. This section profiles the 400 - 900 • 13%
operations of the respondents.
50 - 199 • 28%
Benelux countries 39
France 39
Germany & Switzerland 38
Number of physical contact centre sites
Italy 27
Europe
Scandinavian countries 20 20+ • 6%
UK & Ireland 66
6 - 19 • 12%
Other 6
Number of respondents
1 • 44%
Business • 16%
Contact centre size
Type of customers served
This study covered a wide range of contact centre sizes: from
5 seats at a single site, through to 29,000 seats across 144 sites.
The median size of operations was 200 seats and 2 sites.
7
A research study of consumer attitudes and how European Contact Centres are managing self-service
Consumer profile Age of consumer respondents
Europe
In October 2004, 1056 consumers were surveyed primarily
by telephone, with 20% surveyed via the internet. Of those 66+ • 6% 18-25 • 9%
1056 respondents 171 (16%) said they have never used the
telephone or the internet to make any inquiries or complete
45-65 • 26%
any transactions - with a very high percentage of those
coming from Italy, followed by Germany and Poland. 26-35 • 32%
4%
Employment
Employment Status Status
Full-time employed 48%
Self-employed 11%
Part-time employed 11%
Casually employed 3%
Studying 5%
Retired 13%
Unemployed 9%
8
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc • Contact Centre Realities • Volume 1
The Importance of Self-Service
This drive towards accessibility is an interesting trend that is How much of a priority are these contact centre
emerging in contact centres across the globe. Increasingly, issues?
How much of a priority are these contact centre issues?
industry leaders are citing this as a key priority for their Europe Benelux DACH France Italy Scandi- UK/
navian Ireland
future plans, and there may be a few reasons for this. First,
Enhancing multi- 3.9 4.3 3.9 3.6 4.0 4.1 3.6
it may demonstrate a level of maturity for some contact channel customer care
to an environment where customers can more readily obtain Integrating web & 3.6 3.9 3.3 3.8 3.7 3.6 3.5
call centre systems
information (on the internet) about their alternatives, more
Average rating of priority out of 5
9
A research study of consumer attitudes and how European Contact Centres are managing self-service
Why such a high priority? Many respondents highlighted the importance of reducing the
high expense of contact centre agents, which is not surprising
Unsurprisingly, the larger the call centre the more likely self- given that this usually accounts for 60-65% of operational
service is considered the absolute highest priority. In addition budgets. While this was referred to regularly it was interesting
to cost savings and improved customer satisfaction, executives to note that no one referred to channelling the savings made
across the whole spectrum of contact centre operations cited from self-service into greater investment in more service
the same fundamental benefits from self-service: capability for customers. In North America this was found
“
to be a growing trend amongst the most sophisticated contact
“It’s a huge priority because of savings on
centre operations, whereby savings made from self-service are
agents and fewer mistakes, but there is also the
convenience factor - many customers want the being channelled into longer call handling times, exploring
choice to serve themselves whenever they like. customer needs more thoroughly, providing more thorough
But then you have to think about how satisfied information and service to customers, or spending more time
customers are, and we don’t believe that the on cross-selling.
experience of touchtone is great. We’ve invested
in speech because it’s more accessible, and less In North America there is a stronger trend in the industry to
structured.”
(Banking - UK) shift focus from managing the cost of servicing customers, to
managing the quality of the customer experience. It could
“On the one side there is the cost effectiveness. be expected that the same trend will become increasingly
On the other hand we want to give our customers evident across Europe in the coming years. And with the
the best possible service with all self-serving customer experience being a paramount concern, executives
mediums right down to SMS. Customer satisfaction
need to consider how to best encourage more use of self-
with self-service is very important as it creates
customer loyalty.” service and balance it effectively with assisted service. This
(Telecommunications – Switzerland) issue is explored later in this report.
”
(Financial Services – Belgium)
10
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc • Contact Centre Realities • Volume 1
Most commonly, respondents who felt self-service was a low executives have acknowledged that providing high-quality
priority typically cited the nature of their business - be it self-service systems has become an imperative for satisfying
B2B or B2C – and concerns about delivering personalised and retaining customers.
service to customers. The common themes expressed by
these contact centre managers were: In time, the same could be expected to occur in European
“
countries as the rate of internet usage increases. However
“Self-service is a low priority because we’re the move to more self-service will rely upon the courage
very customer orientated and we advertise the of contact centre executives to introduce this technology to
personal relationship.” their customers. In some instances customers will recognise
(Insurance – Germany)
they want self-service capabilities, yet in others they will not
“We don’t use self-service at all. We believe that know what the advantages of self-service are without being
customers should be able to talk to people at all given the opportunity to try it. Increasing preference for
times.” self-service arises through increasing exposure to quality self-
(Industrial Manufacturing – Denmark) service: the more you use it, the more you like it. The more
accustomed you are to the speedy responsiveness and control
“Self-service is very important, because it reduces that self-service offers, the more you expect and demand it to
waiting times, improves customer service, and
keeps our costs down. But it’s not a priority for us be available. Before customers decide they prefer self-service
because we have so much in place. Customers can they need to be increasingly exposed to it, and contact centre
already serve themselves 90% of the time.” executives will need to drive that.
(Telecommunications – Russia)
Already we are seeing in parts of Europe that customers
“We’re actually making money out of inbound increasingly prefer self-service systems, particularly on the
calls, with 1 in 14 service calls ending up in a sale. internet, and the plans of organisations interviewed for this
50% of total sales are from recognising the needs of
study reveal that internet self-service is the most common
the customer and making an offer on the spot, so
we’re pulling more calls out of the IVR.” area planned for investment. Growing internet use will make
”
(Banking – UK) this channel the most common way of interacting with many,
but not all, organisations. Customers will grow to prefer this
channel because of its ready availability 24 hours a day, the
Why an imperative?
ease of use, control and responsiveness.
“
With so many contact centre executives prioritising self-
service and multi-channel customer care it seems inevitable “Self-service is a growing priority because it’s
what customers now expect.”
that consumers will increasingly be expected to use these (Insurance - Germany)
means of interacting with organisations. However the results
from the consumer survey of this study indicate that some “With little competitive difference between banks
consumers are still reluctant to use this technology. So why at the moment, if you could differentiate your self-
are contact centre managers prioritising self-service? service then you could possibly take leadership.”
(Banking – UK)
To understand this trend one must consider the rise of
self-service in North America. As internet usage has risen
in North America so too has the practice of customers
serving themselves, to the point where consumers there
now display a preference for self-service over other means
of completing transactions and inquiries. Subsequently self-
service has become the number one method of interaction
between suppliers and their customers, and customer service
11
A research study of consumer attitudes and how European Contact Centres are managing self-service
“In financial services we believe there is a Across the whole European sample, men demonstrated a
growing and strategic segment that wants to serve stronger preference to internet self-service than did women.
themselves; its typically youth and the technology-
savvy. We decided to capture their business early
with a sophisticated natural-language speech system, European consumers’ preferred method of service
and this strategic segment is now worth almost a aside from in-person
European consumers’ preferred method of service aside from in-person
third of our profits. We’re now rated the number
one leader in banking with a score twice that of Internet Agent IVR Depends
your nearest competitor.”
(Banking - USA) Banking transactions & inquiries 57% 28% 2% 13%
“Self-service is critical because it is creating the Making bookings or reservations 47% 35% 2% 16%
impression.”
”
Making product inquiries 43% 36% 0% 21%
(Retail – UK)
Buying products or services 30% 40% 0% 30%
% of respondents who prefer channel
Leading customer service executives who are investing Banking transactions & inquiries 44% 13%
customers what they want. Consumers in this study clearly Making bookings or reservations 36% 20%
indicated a preference for using self-service systems when Making product inquiries 43% 11%
asked to choose their preferred method for undertaking Buying products or services 23% 6%
the most common customer service activities. While % who use channel often or always
preferences currently rate highly for the internet, they are yet
to approach the levels seen in North America or Australia,
where consumers far and away prefer the internet over other
channels.
12
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc • Contact Centre Realities • Volume 1
Looking more closely at the preferences for some of these Given these preferences it is interesting to compare what
transactions and inquiries reveals wildly disparate results level of internet usage there is for each country and region,
between different countries and regions. Clearly Benelux (note that those countries marked with an asterisk* will
consumers are the strongest advocates of internet self-service show above normal internet usage rates because 25-40% of
closely followed by Scandinavians, while Italians are far and respondents were surveyed on the internet):
away the least likely users of internet self-service.
Internet usage by country/region
Consumers preferred channel for paying bills aside
from in-person
Consumers preferred channel for paying bills aside from in-person 95% 94%
90%
84% 84% 87%
Internet Agent 77%
73%
70%
Benelux 82% 12%
Preferred channel for product inquiries aside from in- Method of Internet Access
personchannel for product inquiries aside from in-person
Preferred
Europe
Russia 8% 77%
At both work & home • 33%
13
A research study of consumer attitudes and how European Contact Centres are managing self-service
Importance of a website in maintaining your Significance of self-service in delivering customer
satisfaction satisfaction
Europe Europe
Extremely important • 31% 42%
36%
Completely irrelevant • 3%
Unimportant • 7%
19%
3%
% of contact centre executives A previous Genesys research study2 uncovered a similar gap
between the perception of executives and contact centre
agents. In that study, executives significantly underestimated
How user-friendly is your IVR system? how much stress agents experienced when dealing with
Europe customers complaining of long hold times and call transfers.
37% Could it be that some executives are under estimating how
much of an issue call-transfers can be?
8%
Most executives clearly understand how critical these issues
6% are, but it seems that some might be underestimating their
importance. A banking executive explained, “Managing
Excellent Very good Good Average Poor contact centres for customer satisfaction is not a complicated
16
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc • Contact Centre Realities • Volume 1
Causes of annoyance with touchtone IVRs
Causes of annoyance with touchtone IVRs
to be equally receptive to using speech technology, although
18-25 year olds are more likely to be satisfied by it.
How annoying? Time it takes to Confusion Dealing with a
listen to options caused by too computer rather
many options than a human Also, in comparison with the global findings of this consumer
Extremely annoying 31% 31% 25%
study, it is evident that European consumers are equally as
satisfied with and receptive to speech as North American
Very annoying 25% 24% 16%
consumers who have generally been exposed to more
Mildly annoying 29% 25% 26%
speech-enabled systems because of the higher rate of
Doesn’t matter 15% 20% 33% adoption there.
% of consumers
Highly satisfied 14% 17% The four key inhibitors most commonly referred to are:
Satisfied 49% 50% 1. The cost of self-service technologies and difficulty building
Dissatisfied 29% 19%
a business case
Highly dissatisfied 4% 7%
2. Concerns about consumer acceptance of self-service
systems
% of consumers
3. Disparate, complex or insufficient technology systems and
databases
Looking at the differences between age groups, the over-45
group show only a slightly higher level of dissatisfaction when 4. The complexity of inquiries and transactions
it comes to using speech-enabled IVRs. All age brackets seem
17
A research study of consumer attitudes and how European Contact Centres are managing self-service
Some comments from executives highlighted the key themes Too much self-service?
that were expressed by those who feel they are inhibited:
“
There were also a number of organisations who felt they
“The key inhibitors for us are linking the had reached a very high limit to the amount of transactions
technology platforms, the organisational tensions
they could automate. Some felt that only the most complex
and conflicts, and the confidence to implement
more.” transactions remained, but a few organisations with high
(Banking – UK) rates of self-service also said they were struggling to identify
anything else they would want to automate, not because of
“Our main limit lies at the moment in the the complexity but rather because they wanted to retain the
integration of all our systems and channels.” live agent calls. They were concerned that personal contact
(Banking – Finland)
with customers could become too rare, and therefore the
“Part of our overall strategy is to be perceived opportunities to explore customer needs and cross-sell were
by the customers as a solid, professional and becoming limited. These organisations aren’t planning to
heavyweight company and to combine this with implement more self-service.
“
self-service is a challenge.”
(Insurance – Denmark) “We’ve already automated 80% in self-
service, so we’re running out of functionality to
“The key inhibitors are the technical challenges of add, and it’s really about marketing it to customers
integrating new systems with old.” effectively to get it higher. We’ve adopted a
(IT – Finland) strategy of charging customers small amounts for
making changes for them that they could have
done themselves. 30 cents here or 50 cents there
“A good deal of our older clients don’t utilise it
is not a lot, but it’s about conditioning them to
like we would like them to.”
”
understand that service from agents costs more and
(Insurance – Germany)
users should pay. It’s much the same as banks do
with account fees. A more significant challenge for
However what one group of people perceive as inhibitors, us is identifying which types of calls are the ones
others see as mere challenges that can be overcome. Concerns that are most appropriate to deliver to an agent, and
about consumer acceptance would seem to be less relevant it’s not necessarily the calls with inherent value, but
possibly lower value calls where there is a better
given the growing popularity of self-service systems, and
opportunity to up-sell.”
”
consumers’ willingness and preference for using them. Some (Wireless Telecoms – Czech Republic)
executives believe that customers are becoming increasingly
conditioned to accept and prefer these systems. Certainly it is true that most organisations have products
and services that might always demand some direct human
Also, when it comes to the complexity of inquiries and
interaction, but the growing trend is for seemingly more
transactions it is certainly true that some are just far too
complex transactions to be automated through multiple
complicated and involved to bother trying to automate, but
channels. While some customers are demanding enhanced
at the same time it is interesting to note that a number of
self-service capability, others will always demand the human
respondents to this study have been successful in automating
touch. The challenge is deciding what to automate and
increasingly complex transactions and inquiries.
how, and empowering customers with a range of options for
Interestingly there were many organisations in the same interacting with the organisation.
industries whose attitudes to self-service conflicted – some
suggesting self-service deployment is limited by complexity
of their product or service, while their competitors indicated
they are embracing more technology to automate those same
complex transactions. It would seem that some organisations
could be held back by lagging perceptions of technology
capability and a misunderstanding of consumer attitudes.
18
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc • Contact Centre Realities • Volume 1
Investing in Self-Service
The success of self-service implementations has meant that are being offered by a smaller percentage of organisations in
at least 68% of organisations are planning to invest in more Europe as opposed to North America. Clearly there are
of it. However faced with competing priorities and limited more advanced applications deployed in North America
budgets, what opportunities do executives see for self-service? and European contact centre executives could benefit from
And what are they planning to invest in? investigating and understanding the experiences and successes
of more progressive operations.
Opportunities for more self-service begin with the needs and
expectations of consumers. Accordingly some of the leading The implications for technology systems and business
large contact centres are taking a fresh approach to research processes can sometimes be profound. Many organisations
with their own customer base in order to understand what find that they simply aren’t equipped to readily link back-
kind of service delivery customers are seeking, and to gauge end systems to more sophisticated front-end applications.
their likely reactions to different technologies. However many large organisations have been successful in
doing so. Banks are enabling a full spectrum of transactions
Automating more to be completed online and through speech-enabled IVRs;
insurance companies are enabling quotes and policy purchases
Executives referred to a growing customer expectation that to be completed almost entirely without human intervention;
if one service or inquiry is provided through one self-service and companies from diverse industries are speech-enabling
channel, then they expect it to be provided through others, self-service to allow customers to update account details,
and this can create unique and unexpected demands. For check balances and request or submit information.
example, for some banks this has meant customers have
started emailing to request funds transfers and payments. Of Choosing who can self-serve
course as a highly insecure channel for communication, the
only way banks have been able to provide this capability has In deploying self-service systems an important consideration
been to provide the infrastructure for secure communications is who will demand self-service, who will be open to it and
either across the web or with digital signature technology, and who will be resistant to it? Another key consideration is
that was an investment that wasn’t initially expected. which transactions to automate. 27% of executives believe
that most of their organisations transactions and inquiries
Some organisations are planning to enable all transactions could be completed though self-service, while another 56%
and inquiries to be completed in all channels, to provide believe many could be initiated through self-service but would
their customers with the ultimate in availability and choice. require some human intervention. This is considerably more
However the majority of respondents plan only to offer some conservative than North American contact centres where
transactions and inquiries in all channels. Accordingly, the 40% believe that most transactions could be automated; again
challenge is to assess and understand not only what types of supporting the conclusion that self-service adoption is not as
activities could be automated, through which channels, and widespread and advanced in Europe. Different countries and
for whom, but also to understand just how much different regions appear to be more open to self-service deployment:
segments will actually need and use different channels. It
could be terribly unprofitable to automate processes that
are used rarely, by a small minority, unless those processes or
customers happen to be highly profitable.
19
A research study of consumer attitudes and how European Contact Centres are managing self-service
How many transactions and inquiries could be The customer experience
automated with self-service?
Europe With more customers completing more transactions through
self-service, what does less two-way interaction mean for an
47% organisation’s relationships with customers? If the majority
of a customer’s contact with the organisation is through self-
service systems, how do you define and reflect the brand,
establish customer loyalty, and develop a valued relationship
29% 28% with each customer?
25% 24%
Executives believe this demands more consistency in the
total user experience, tighter links between channels, a
stronger brand personality that is reflected in and supported
8%
by different types of interactions, and innovative methods of
communicating more regularly with customers.
Benelux DACH France Italy Scandinavia UK
With regard to the latter suggestion, a small number of
% who believe most or all executives explained they are now focusing on exploring new
transactions could be automated
opportunities to increase communication with customers
and gradually learn more about them. Self-service reduces
Across Europe 58% of executives are seeking to drive all or the amount of two-way interaction with customers so some
the vast majority of their customers to use more self-service, organisations are now exploring ideas for engaging customers
and it is evident that those organisations who are least in brief but regular email discussions where they can pick up
interested in doing so typically have very rare contact with a little more information about the profile of customers each
their customers, particularly complex transactions, or very time and then later use that to sell to them more effectively.
high value transactions.
One executive explained how they had introduced more
Which customers will you drive to use more self- outbound courtesy calls to existing customers to see if they
service? needed any assistance and to evaluate their satisfaction, and
Europe they have found it is having a significant impact on customer
retention and is lifting cross-selling rates. And by using call
Whichever are happy
Only the least-profitable • 10% blending to involve service agents in these outbound calls,
to use it • 31% None • 1% they have also seen an improvement in agent satisfaction.
”
(IT - Germany)
20
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc • Contact Centre Realities • Volume 1
Internet self-service Plans to allow online submission of inquiries
Europe
The dramatic growth in internet use has been a welcome gift
58%
for most customer service executives. The increasing uptake
of the web has probably had the most profound impact on
contact centres since the ‘controversial’ introduction of IVRs,
yet today websites probably generate mixed feelings for
most contact centre managers. For while they have become
the most preferred method for many forms of transactions, 26%
websites are also at the heart of many customer service
issues: disconnects between contact centres and websites,
10%
inconsistent levels of service, technical difficulties, email, 6%
and 24-hour availability, have all generated new issues in
the contact centre. Some of these issues were explored in Already using High priority Considering Not a priority
Unnecessary 3% 4% 3%
% of consumers
22
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc • Contact Centre Realities • Volume 1
Closer examination of responses to these questions reveals Live web chat
that the over-45 consumers have higher expectations for
support when things go wrong with internet self-service. Given the support that consumers are seeking when using
Across all three scenarios they rate the value of this support online systems, it is interesting to examine the plans for
20% higher than the under-45 consumers. deploying web chat in order to improve support for web
users. Some organisations have expressed doubts about
Consumers were also asked about their experiences of the need for live web chat and concerns about the cost of
receiving phone support for problems experienced on the handling web chat sessions, however the experiences of those
web. Unfortunately it seems apparent that many organisations organisations that have deployed it reveal interesting results.
may still be failing to deliver the level of support consumers
are expecting for using these self-service systems. 34% of Those who have deployed web chat suggest it's “something
consumers have more than once had the experience of every corporate website should have”. An interesting
having difficulty with a website and called the contact centre example was explained by an online computer retailer in the
only to find that the agent has no idea of what they’ve been USA who had concerns about abandoned sales opportunities
doing and has been unable to help them. Unsurprisingly on the web. The organisation deployed a small team of 8
51% of them rated this highly annoying. web chat agents and soon found each agent was typically
running 5 simultaneous chat sessions with customers. So
Email response successful has web chat been for driving sales performance,
that organisation’s contact centre now has more than two
With email continually growing in usage by all segments of hundred chat agents who outnumber voice agents by more
the community, this channel presents ongoing challenges for than 2:1. A couple of European contact centre managers
contact centre executives. As consumers make more use of shared their experience of web-chat and revealed that they
internet self-service they are increasingly going to expect have found their agents running 3-4 simultaneous sessions
responsive email support. Consumers were asked what their with customers, and that a standalone session can cost about
expectation was for an email response. the same as a live call. Web chat was clearly most prevalent
in the UK where 16% of respondents are currently providing
Expected response time for email this interaction channel for their customers.
Europe
49% Plans for live web chat
Europe
Currently using • 5%
High priority • 8%
26%
Considering • 19%
11% 11%
3%
within 1 hour same day within 24 hours within 2 days within 4 days
Plans for live web chat
% of consumers
23
A research study of consumer attitudes and how European Contact Centres are managing self-service
Web knowledgebases Considering the variation in expectations for channels like
text messaging (SMS) highlights the importance for contact
Intelligent web knowledgebases are also seen as a valuable centre executives to understand the expectations of their own
technology for improving web self-service while also customer segments and how to best meet them. Leading
reducing call volumes for contact centres. Well designed web contact centres are endeavouring to provide all possible
knowledge bases allow customers to pose natural language channels of interaction for customers in order to be accessible
questions and receive a list of intelligent answers. Executives anytime, anywhere. A UK based organisation interviewed for
were asked about their plans for investing in web knowledge this study is currently delivering this accessibility by allowing
bases, and it is evident that there are increasing levels of customers to interact and transact through live agent calls,
interest in this technology. Web knowledgebases are most the web, touchtone and speech-enabled IVR, web chat, SMS,
heavily deployed in France, Italy and the UK. WAP, email, fax, mail, set-top box and in-store, and all of these
channels are linked to a single core customer information
Plans to deploy web knowledge base system. Leading contact centres are increasingly planning to
Europe take their contact centres in this same direction.
Currently using • 31%
Planning not to
implement • 5%
Currently
implementing • 15%
Evaluating • 28%
% of consumers
24
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc • Contact Centre Realities • Volume 1
Speech Recognition
After the emergence of the internet, e-commerce, and IP Clearly the DACH countries and the UK are leading the
telephony, natural language speech recognition is emerging implementation of speech, while Italy shows the greatest
as the most profound change in contact centres in the last disinterest in the technology. Other findings in this study
few years, and the initial evolution of speech is reminiscent of support a conclusion that DACH countries and the UK
the early years with IVRs. Back then there were doomsayers clearly lead the region in employing and encouraging more
and evangelists about IVR, and there was much conjecture self-service and Italy consistently demonstrates a reluctance to
about the appropriateness of making customers interact with deploy more self-service. The question remains whether this
a computer. Yet we find ourselves today with more than 90% is more about customer attitudes to self-service or executive
of contact centres fronted by an IVR system. attitudes, and this is explored further below.
Speech recognition technology appears to be rapidly heading Of those organisations that have already deployed speech,
in the same direction. After trailblazing efforts by industry one third implemented it more than two years ago, and
leaders, speech is now part of the mainstream, and some 55% have deployed it in the past 12 months. The majority
organisations are deploying their second or third generation of organisations who have deployed speech come from
of speech technology. With speech being such a valuable the financial services, information technology and media
technology for self- and assisted-service, this study thoroughly industries, however at least one organisation from each of
investigated organisations' experiences and plans with this eight industries included in this study have deployed speech
booming technology. to their customers.
The larger the contact centre the more likely they are
Plans for speech recognition
Europe to have deployed speech, although contact centres of all
sizes, from small to mega, have deployed speech. Of the
44%
organisations currently developing an application, half expect
to deploy within the next 6 months. And of those currently
investigating the business case, 35% expect they will deploy
speech in the coming year. Based on these expectations, by
23% the end of 2005, 29% of European contact centres will have
deployed speech, compared to an expected 50% of North
American contact centres.
12% 12%
UK & Ireland 20% 32% 37% 11% More efficient & accurate call Reduce contact centre resources
routing
25
A research study of consumer attitudes and how European Contact Centres are managing self-service
Some executives went further to explain the strategic Resistance to speech
opportunities that speech can offer, for example:
“
For those 44% of executives who are currently not considering
“ood customer service is the principle the speech, the most commonly cited reasons were:
company is built on. We sell and market directly
and we use outsourcing for overflows and peaks. Other technology and business priorities
Our over-50 customers tend to want a human
voice, yet they do use email. We don’t want to Lack of budgets for investment
force customers to use self-service, and we don’t Affordability of the technology
want to use a touchtone IVR, but we see speech as No compelling need to replace current IVR
an opportunity to reduce costs, handle peaks, and
Waiting until current IVR needs replacement
improve the speed and quality of service, and we
expect our customers will be responsive to it.” Inappropriate for senior customer base
(Travel & Tourism – UK) Customers want personal interaction
“In financial services we believe there is a These executives were asked when they expected they will
growing and strategic segment that wants to serve consider speech:
themselves; it’s typically youth and the technology-
savvy. We decided to capture their business early
with a sophisticated natural-language speech system, Currently not considering speech, but will in . . .
and this strategic segment is now worth almost a Europe
third of our profits.”
”
39%
(Banking & Finance - USA)
27%
Types of speech applications 25%
26
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc • Contact Centre Realities • Volume 1
Building a business case Consumer acceptance of speech
For the 23% of executives who are currently investigating In North America speech recognition has matured to a level
the business case for speech, 25% expect their speech IVR where consumer acceptance drives deployment as much as
to completely replace their existing touchtone IVR, and deployment drives consumer acceptance. In essence most
81% expect to automate high-value transactions. The vast consumers now prefer speech and willingly use it. So how do
majority of executives indicated they would like to deploy European consumers feel about using speech? First, consider
speech because they know it can be a better experience for this table from earlier in the report:
their customers, but some organisations expressed concern
about being able to build a business case for investing in Satisfaction with using IVR instead of 24-hour live
speech. agent service
“
Satisfaction with using IVR instead of 24-hour live-agent service
“Our main reason was the cost effectiveness. How satisfied Touchtone Speech-enabled
We are able to automate things like ordering, and IVR IVR
we can deliver 24/7 service without extra agents. Very Highly satisfied 4% 7%
We also use it for our “opt-out” line; if a customer
wants to terminate an order. It would hurt to Highly satisfied 14% 17%
have to put a live agent to take a call that is losing Satisfied 49% 50%
money.”
”
(Media – Germany) Dissatisfied 29% 19%
Highly dissatisfied 4% 7%
% of consumers
For some organisations the cost savings alone don’t appear
adequate to justify the immediate investment; however peers
in the same industry have explained how they achieved
their ROI on speech faster than expected. The difference Only 26% of consumers believe they wouldn’t be satisfied
may be in the approach organisations take to justifying the by a speech enabled IVR in place of 24-hour agent service.
investment. Many business cases for speech tend to focus Combine this with other findings from the study and an
on updating already deployed self-service IVR applications. interesting pattern emerges.
The resulting business case tends to focus on the cost of the
deployment and the costs it will dispense of, but neglects the Consumer use of speech recognition
Consumer use of speech-recognition
Russia 0%
Another key consideration is to explore the new possibilities Scandinavia 52%
for automating transactions and inquiries, for this is often Spain 63%
where the best opportunities exist for a rapid return. The UK & Ireland 52%
speech interface allows the automation of complex transactions % consumers who have used speech
and inquiries which touchtone IVRs are otherwise unable
to handle, thus opening up possibilities that haven’t been
thought of before. Those consumers who have used speech recognition systems
were asked how well they thought it works, how happy they
would be to use it again, and were asked what they did and
didn’t like about these systems.
27
A research study of consumer attitudes and how European Contact Centres are managing self-service
How well do you think speech works?
How well do you think speech works?
Preference for speech over touchtone IVR
Europe
Consumer segment Very well Satisfactorily Poorly Horribly
28
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc • Contact Centre Realities • Volume 1
It is interesting to note that many of the issues listed by How annoying is touchtone IVR on a mobile phone?
consumers can be easily addressed through interface design Europe
and system processing ability. However some speech systems
are limited in their ability to process all interactions. Case 36%
in point being the application of speech that was referred
to most often because of its poor performance: telephone
26%
directory assistance. It is evident that users find these systems
unsatisfactory, and they are often the only speech application
people have tried. It seems these applications don’t assist the 17%
industry in encouraging acceptance of speech. 12%
9%
When asked what they like about speech, consumers
commonly cited the following:
• Quick response Extremely Very annoying Mildly annoying Not annoying Insignificant
annoying
• Convenient when you’re doing something else % of consumers
• Faster than waiting for someone
• Not having to punch in numbers How preferable to say numbers instead?
• Efficient Europe
• Easier navigation
28%
• Great when driving 26%
29
A research study of consumer attitudes and how European Contact Centres are managing self-service
Results with speech recognition Impact of speech on customer satisfaction?
Europe
Organisations that have already deployed speech have been
46%
very pleased with the outcomes they have achieved. A
Banking executive explained how their implementation of
a speech-enabled banking platform has become a strategic
marketing advantage. In addition to capturing a valuable 29%
market segment of tech-savvy consumers, a recent consumer 25%
study of leadership in banking found this organisation at the
peak of the industry with a leadership score twice that of
their nearest competitor.
Has user adoption met your expectations? % of respondents who have already deployed speech
Europe
17%
Respondents who have already deployed speech 11% 11%
”
(IT – Germany)
30
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc • Contact Centre Realities • Volume 1
Conclusion
The ever increasing expectations of customers are the Leading customer service executives interviewed in this
fundamental drivers for implementing more self-service. study believe this demands more consistency in the total
Broadly speaking, customers are demanding and expecting user experience, tighter links between service channels, a
more availability of information, more accessibility to stronger brand personality that is reflected in and supported
organisations, and the freedom to choose when and how by different types of interactions, and innovative methods of
they interact with suppliers. In response more and more communicating more regularly with customers.
organisations are recognizing that they need to deliver
increased levels of service in order to retain customers and For self-service channels it means constantly refining and
grow their business. enhancing how they can serve customers. If customers are
demanding more from their interactions, then organisations
Self-service systems offer the most cost-effective opportunities need to look at how they can build more intelligence into
to provide these higher levels of service and availability, and self-service systems, and determine which interactions are
as customers have become increasingly accustomed to using best handled this way and which are best served by a personal
them, they have grown to expect and demand sophisticated interaction with a customer service representative.
self-service systems as part of the complete product or
service offering. Along the way self-service systems are Organisations need to establish a deeper understanding of not
becoming the most common method of interacting with only which interactions are the most valuable, but also which
many organisations, and becoming a critical determinant of interactions present the best opportunities for creating value.
customer satisfaction. This understanding will help them decide which transactions
to automate, and how best to automate them.
With these trends set to continue, it is evident that the quality
and availability of self-service will become an increasingly And with increased automation there are new challenges in
important competitive distinction. Customers will be won establishing and strengthening relationships with customers.
and lost based on the quality of these self-service systems, At a fundamental level, customers want to be acknowledged
and when it is needed, the availability and quality of personal and they want to feel that they are valued. If companies are
service. going to rely on more self-service interactions, they need
to consider how they can personalise and humanise those
Accordingly market leaders are focused on improving the automated interactions to make them more compelling and
availability of their organisation and making it as easy as highly-valued experiences.
possible for customers to interact with them. Leaders are
providing the customer with more choice and more control Some customers want more self-service, and some customers
over their relationship with the organisation, and self-service don’t. Some customers prefer a close relationship with
channels are valuable enablers for this. suppliers, and some customers don’t. Some want more
interaction and communication, and others don’t. The
With these drivers self-service has become a business challenge for customer service executives is how to balance
imperative and it is redefining the nature of relationships these different expectations and provide as much choice as
with customers. With more interaction undertaken through possible, in order to provide lasting satisfaction.
these channels and less personal contact with company
representatives, the opportunities to establish relationships
and sell to customers are changing. In response, companies
need to consider how they can strengthen relationships
that are increasingly based on automated transactions and
communications. They need to consider what this means
for how customers experience the organisation and establish
attachments to the brand.
31
A research study of consumer attitudes and how European Contact Centres are managing self-service
Where to go for More Information
Gene Blackley
geneb@bigpond.net.au
+61.414.888.414
Phone: +(31) 35 528 9080 Phone: +48 502 651846 Phone: +34 91 572 67 21
marcoh@genesyslab.co.uk miguelg@genesyslab.co.uk
Phone: +46 (0) 8 590 041 98 Tel: + 41 (0) 62 393 02 31 Phone: +44 (0) 118 974 7000
soheilaw@genesyslab.co.uk info@genesyslab.co.uk
Copyright © 2004 Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Reproduction or disclosure in whole or part is permitted
only with the express written consent of Genesys.
32
Genesys Telecommunications Laboratories, Inc • Contact Centre Realities • Volume 1