Professional Documents
Culture Documents
আফজল গুরুর ফাঁসি একটি জুডিশিয়াল হত্যাকান্ড-মুহাম্মাদ আব্দুল আলিম
আফজল গুরুর ফাঁসি একটি জুডিশিয়াল হত্যাকান্ড-মুহাম্মাদ আব্দুল আলিম
1|Page
2|Page
, , (, )
2
3|Page
, , , ( )
3
4|Page
4
5|Page
5
6|Page
,
-
-
/
,
,
, ,
,
, , , , ,
6
7|Page
, ,
?
,
,
(
)
/
,
?
?
7
8|Page
8
9|Page
the highest dignitary of the state. (AIR 1989 SC 653 State Vs Kehar
Singh)
( )
( , ,
)
,
,
, The deprivation of
personal liberty and the threat of deprivation of life by the action of
the State is in most civilized societies regarded seriously and
recourse fallibility of human judgment being undeniable even
in the most trained mind
9
10 | P a g e
, ,
(
)
--
--
,
,
-
(/
)
-
-- --
10
11 | P a g e
, ,
, - ,
-
- ,
( )
(--)
-
,
,
,
11
12 | P a g e
,
?
,
POTO (Prevention of Terrorism Ordinance)
POTA (Prevention of Terrorism
Act) (
)
12
13 | P a g e
( )
(?)
( )
,
?
,
?
,
13
14 | P a g e
-counsel had exercised her discretion reasonably. The appellant
accused did not object to this course adopted by the amicus
throughout the trial (SCJ, p 140)
!
, ,
(
)
, ,
taking an overall view of the assistance given by the court and the
performance of the counsel, it cannot be said that the accused was
denied the facility of effective defence (ibid pp 141-42)
,
( )
,
(
)
(his presence and participation
have caused confusion and prejudice vitiating the trial)
14
15 | P a g e
-
Beyond the shadow of doubt?
,
-- --
( )-
,
-
( , , ) -
15
16 | P a g e
-
,
,
, ,
(
)
,
,
(
) ,
,
16
17 | P a g e
( )
?
, -
,
,
, ,
,
?
? ? ,
17
18 | P a g e
,
-
, ,
(
)
(
)
, ,
,
18
19 | P a g e
, , ,
POTA
?
, (!)
,
,
,
,
- ? -
Afzal is characterised as a menace to the society, whose life
19
20 | P a g e
! -
-
( )
20
21 | P a g e
( )
-
, -
,
!
,
:
. ( )
( )
.
?
21
22 | P a g e
,
,
,
:
( )
-
()
22
23 | P a g e
()
( ) ( )
,
, , ,
-
- , ,
!
?
-
23
24 | P a g e
. -
. -
,
,
!!
24
25 | P a g e
. ,
,
. ,
,
The hanging of Afzal Guru is a
stain on Indias democracy ,
- ,
,
.
-
.
.
25
26 | P a g e
,
? -
.
, When the
Supreme Court bases its judgment primarily on the circumstantial
evidence, it becomes all the more necessary to commute the death
conviction to life sentence.
- ( )
,
,
: I think the hanging was both wrong & badly handled. Family
should have been warned, given a last meeting & body returned.
26
27 | P a g e
-
? :
, ,
:
? :
27
28 | P a g e
,
! -
: -
? ,
,
? ,
-
,
,
, ,
, ,
,
,
,
28
29 | P a g e
,
,
?
- , ,
,
, ,
-
, -
?
?
29
30 | P a g e
? ?
,
,
-
- ,
,
?
,
: ,
30
31 | P a g e
) ( / ) /-
) ? ( / ) /-
) ? ( / ) /-
)
( ) ( / ) /-
)
(
) ( / ) /-
)
( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) ? ( ) --
) ( ) ---
) ( ) ---
) ( ) /-
) ( ) ---
) ? ( ) ---
) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
)
( ) ( ) ---
) ( ) /-
) ( ) ---
) ( ) ---
31
32 | P a g e
) ( ) ( ) /-
) ? ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) ( ) ---
) ( ) ---
) ( ) /-
) ( ) ---
) ( ) ---
) ( ) ---
) ( ) ---
) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) - ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
)
( ) -
) ( ) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
)
32
33 | P a g e
( - , ) /-
)
( ) /-
) ( )
( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
)
( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) () [ ] /-
) [ ] /-
) [ ] /-
) ( ) /-
) ( ) /-
) ( )
[
()] ---
) ( )
[ ()] ---
)
( / ) /-
) ( )
[ - ]
33