Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Meetings and Workshops: Join Today-Celebrate 100 Years of Sierra Club Outings!
Meetings and Workshops: Join Today-Celebrate 100 Years of Sierra Club Outings!
Meetings and Workshops: Join Today-Celebrate 100 Years of Sierra Club Outings!
Motiva Accident
Tests State’s Resolve
by Debbie Heaton
require a new permit application and public hearings if proponents want
S AV E T H E D AT E ! to move forward with the dredging,” and that “DiPasquale has not yet
decided how to respond to the permit lapse.”
Friday Evening, November 16, 2001 Proponent, state Sen. George H. Bunting Jr., D-Bethany Beach, said
Wild Places, Cool Spaces that the decision angered him and he predicted the state would seek a new
At Del.Center for Contemporary Arts in Wilmington permit. South Bethany Mayor Sal Aiello, a dredging proponent for many
With Special Guest Jonathan Blair, years, stated in the press that the mayors of Ocean View, Fenwick Island
Contributing photographer for National Geographic
and Bethany Beach have joined him in support of the dredging, and that
An evening of music, photographs,
hors d’oeuvres, & silent auction to benefit the he and fellow mayors will soon meet with state officials to discuss ways to
Sierra Club’s conservation activities in Delaware. get the project back on track.
Check your mailbox in October for more details. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers district office in Philadelphia,
Continued on page 3
The Summer of Our Discontent want to make their money and run.
And then there is Motiva. When the refin-
By Jim Steffens, The Delaware General Assembly has recessed ery agreed with the EPA and with Delaware’s
until its special session on redistricting, having Department of Natural Resources to install
Chapter Chair
failed to pass even the mildest form of protec- major new pollution control equipment, promis-
tion for the Inland Bays. The U.S. Congress has ing to end years of noxious air pollution, the
recessed, having passed a massive tax cut and plant management sent a letter to environmen-
the most misguided energy bill imaginable. A tal groups in the state lauding this agreement as
tank containing hundreds of thousands of gal- a sign of the refinery’s interest in protecting the
lons of sulfuric acid blew up environment. The Delaware Sierra Club
at the Motiva refinery, causing probable loss responded to that letter, saying that we would
of life, other workers to be injured and major judge the performance of the refinery by results,
land and water contamination. What else not by promises.
could go wrong? Then came the explosion and fire. The
This country desperately needs an energy present management may have the best of
policy. That offered by the president is a give- intentions in running a safe and non-polluting
away to the financial interests that helped elect facility. But they inherit a culture that has over
him and nothing more. Gone are the days when and over shown little regard for the environ-
Delaware Chapter to be a conservative meant to conserve ment, no program of plant maintenance that
and Southern resources for future generations. Fortunately would prevent accidents from happening, and—
Delaware Group Congressman Castle saw fit to vote for the based on the most recent episode—a policy
Leaders
amendment to prevent drilling in the ANWR toward worker safety and a lack of hazards
Chapter Office 1304 N. Rodney St. (it failed) and against the final form of H.B. 4 review that defies common sense. The manage-
Wilmington, DE 19806 because it allowed such drilling. We must now ment of the Motiva refinery must demonstrate
Shiray Shipley 302-425-4911
hours: Tue-Thurs 9 a.m.- 4 p.m.
not only hope but work to see that the damage to the community that it can change this
done in the House is repudiated in the Senate. culture, that it can establish practices of plant
Chapter Executive Committee
At last Delaware has a governor who and worker safety, that ensures the safety and
(ExCom) Members
Jim Steffens, chair 239-9601 takes the issue of land use seriously, and who is health of the community, and that it can turn
Matt Urban, vice chair 661-2050 willing to make it the hallmark of her first term. around a long history of contempt for
Cornelia Melvin, sect. 945-4708 I applaud Governor Minner’s courage in tack- Delaware’s environment. Absent that change,
Terri Tipping, treas. 368-1452
Jay Cooperson 571-0660 ling this difficult issue. There are many interests the plant should be closed.
Debbie Heaton 378-8501 in the state who would like to see her fail: I would say that the summer has been
Boyd White 335-1323 those developers who want to continue the old enough of a burden. The long-range forecast,
Chapter Appointed Officers pattern of growth with few constraints; county however, requires continued vigilance.
Cons. Debbie Heaton 378-8501 interests who do not wish to be fettered by
Land Use Jim Steffens 239-9601
Litigation Carl Solberg 492-1225
cooperation with the state; those who fail to
Membership Al Denio 455-0389 see that the city of Wilmington has a major The Delaware Sierra News is published five times a year by
Outings Dan Soeder 284-2613 role to play in preventing sprawl. the Delaware Chapter of the Sierra Club. This publication is
Pol. Shamba Donovan 368-0174 written and produced entirely by volunteers.
One aspect of the governor’s Livable
Recycle Marsha Holler 735-9687
Trans. Bob Bennett 731-4524 Delaware initiative that died stillborn was If you would like to help with its publication, please contact the
Representative Price’s bill to mandate environ- editor (302-378-8501). The deadline for materials for the next
Southern Delaware Group Excom issue is October 1, 2001. We reserve the right to edit materi-
Sallie Callanen, chair 539-0635 mental impact assessments of major develop- als submitted for publication. Materials and Letters to the
Pete Okie, vice chair 856-2728 ments around the Inland Bays. As a state we Editor can be sent to: debbie.heaton@sierraclub.org.
Rich Anthony, sect. 645-1732 should all be working together to reverse the Ideas expressed in the Delaware Sierra News are those of the
Yuki Usuki 436-4042 columnists and do not necessarily reflect the position of the
Til Purnell 945-1317 harm that is occurring to this natural resource,
Sierra Club. While effort is made to check for accuracy, time
and to preserve the bays for future generations. constraints and limited all-volunteer staff do not allow for com-
SDG Appointed Officers
Cons. Terri Usuki 436-4042 We have yet to tackle substantive wetlands leg- plete data corroboration.
Land use. Rich Anthony 645-1732 islation that would protect these remaining sen- Editors: Debbie Heaton, Mike Casale and Chris Crotty.
Legal. Mike Lamb 539-1008 sitive areas. A lot more voices will have to be Contributing writers: Jim Steffens and others as noted.
Mem. Lauren Ide
raised around the state to ensure that this legis- This newsletter was printed on recycled/post con-
lation is passed. The Inland Bays are a state sumer paper with soy based ink by the Dover Post
Visit us on the web: Company, Dover, Delaware.
www.delaware.sierraclub.org resource, not the domain of a few people who
continued on the next page
Arsenic Standards and Your Health Sciences, long-term exposure to low concentra-
tions of arsenic in drinking water can lead to
On March 20th, Environmental Protection skin, bladder, lung, and prostate cancer. Non-
Web resources Agency administrator Christine Whitman sus- cancer effects of ingesting arsenic at low levels
U.S Geological Survey at pended the revised arsenic standard for drink- include cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and ane-
http://www.usgs.gov
ing water issued by the outgoing Clinton mia, as well as reproductive and developmental,
Arsenic - The EQI Nat. Well administration. Since then, the Bush adminis- immunological, and neurological effects.
Water Study --
tration has announced it will re-open the issue The revised standard, which lowers the
www.main.nc.us/ cleanwa-
terfundnc/cwlti.htm
to further research and review, in the meantime allowable level of arsenic in drinking water from
reverting back to the previous, outdated, 50 ppb to 10 ppb, was the result of more than a
National Research
Council's 1999 Report
unhealthy standard. decade of scientific reviews, public hearings, and
"Arsenic in Drinking By delaying the implementation of a more discussions with health experts and industry. In
Water" www.nap.edu/cata- protective arsenic standard, the Bush addition, the 10 ppb level is the international
log/6444.html Administration is threatening the health of an standard adopted several years ago by the World
World Health Organization estimated 12.7 million Americans who drink Health Organization and the European Union.
- www.who.int/water_sani- water that contains arsenic levels that are unsafe. In the United States, with the Safe Drinking
tation_health/Arsenic/ars Arsenic is the 20th most abundant element Water Act in place, the U.S. Environmental
enic.htm
naturally occurring in the earth’s crust and the Protection Agency considers the American tap
Natural Resources 12th most common element in the human body. water supply one of the safest in the world. Yet
Defense Council’s
While some foods such as fish contain arsenic the National Research Council of the National
February 2000 Report
Arsenic and Old Laws - compounds, those forms that are present in water Academy of Sciences estimates one out of 100
www.nrdc.org/water/drink- are of most concern. The U.S. Food and Drug people ingesting water containing 50 ppb of
ing/arsenic/aolinx.asp Administration estimates, on average, an adult arsenic will get cancer.
NRC/NAS Report on ingests about .053 parts per billion (ppb) a day of
Arsenic in Drinking Water -- organic arsenic from dietary sources, and the At Governor Minner’s behest the 10ppm
books.nap.edu/books National Research Council estimates that arsenic drinking water standard is being implemented in
/0309063337/html/R1.h
intake from food is comparable to drinking water Delaware ahead of the EPA decision.
tml
containing 5 ppb.
According to the National Academy of
Motiva, from page 4 fixes and has been negligent in their mainte- appropriate budgets allocated for proper
nance practices. maintenance to become normal operating
These choices by Motiva show continued procedure. It is way beyond time for a change
production is valued far more than safe opera- at Motiva.
tion and the maintenance standards practiced
by other heavy industry in the state. They chose
money and profit over the safety of their work-
Preserve the Future
ers, neighbors, businesses and the coastal zone ot everyone can make a large gift to protect
that surrounds them. N the environment during their lifetime, but you
can preserve the environment for generations
We feel that Motiva needs to undertake a
to come by remembering the Sierra Club in
full review of procedures plant-wide as well as to your will.
undergo a complete site inspection. The public There are many gift options available. We can
needs to be assured that all proper maintenance even help you plan a gift for your local Chapter.
has been undertaken and properly completed For more information and confidential assis-
throughout the plant so that accidents like this tance contact: John Calaway, Director, Gift
Giving, Sierra Club, 85 Second Street, 2nd Floor,
don’t happen again. If necessary the plant San Francisco, CA 94105 (415) 977-5639 or
should be shut down to facilitate this review. e-mail: planned.giving@sierraclub.org
Company policies need to be updated and
Matt@mobiusnm. Shiray for details and to reserve a spot. Spend 2 days on the Delaware River, paddling
com) from Dingman’s Ferry to Kittatinny Point in the
Coast Day, UD in Lewes - October 7 - Visit the
Delaware Water Gap NRA. This is a relatively
Sierra Club booth as part of your visit to this day
flat stretch of river and an easy paddle, with
of marine activities. Chapter t-shirts and calen-
spectacular fall scenery and an overnight camp-
dars will be for sale. To help out at the booth for
ing stop on the shore. Contact Matt for details.
an hour or two contact Al Denio 302-455-0389.
It has been brought to our A Note and a Federal Update of 2001. The bill would extend
attention that the article about the program through FY 2004.
Senator Carper supporting August 1, 2001 - Senator Biden
efforts to protect the Arctic National fication in the future. Below are a few
clips we have received. co-sponsored an amendment with Sen.
Wildlife Refuge in the last issue of the John Kerry (D-MA) at today’s Foreign
Delaware Sierra News did not mention June 22, 2001 - The House approved Relations Committee meeting, calling on
or salute the long-term efforts of Sen. the Rahall amendment to the Interior the Administration to bring a proposal
Biden on behalf of the Arctic. A member Appropriations bill by a decisive vote of for the United States’ participation in
of his staff made clear that the Senator 242-173, including 47 pro-Monument a binding climate change agreement to
has worked hard in his efforts to protect Republicans voting YES. The Rahall the international climate change talks
these sensitive lands from oil drilling as amendment will prevent the Interior this fall.
well as co-sponsoring the Wilderness Department from undertaking any new
Bill. leasing or pre-leasing activity in National August 14, 2001 - According to a note
Monuments in the coming year. Rep. from Congressman Castle, he voted for
We did not intend to belittle Senator the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge
Biden’s efforts while trying to support Castle placed a pro-monument vote. Tell
him thanks when you see him! amendment, which lost. Then he said,
Senator Carper on his first steps to pro- “When this amendment failed, I voted
tect the environment in his new job. We July 24, 2001 - In a bipartisan effort to against the entire energy bill.” About his
realize the careful balance that will be conserve the world’s natural resources, votes on CAFE standards. He wants to
needed as we report on Senatorial Sens. Joseph R. Biden, Jr. (D-Del.) and be sure that increases in fuel efficiency
actions in the future. We hope that the Richard G. Lugar (R-Ind.) were joined by standards to do not compromise auto-
staff of both senators will share their Senate colleagues in unanimously pass- mobile safety.
news with the editorial board for our edi- ing the Tropical Forest Conservation Act