Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Loss Final
Loss Final
Sarah A. Parker
Introduction
The classic American adage that “anything is possible through hard work” reflects
many things about our society, specifically what it is that we look for in both the stories
that we hear and the stories that we tell about ourselves; that we have gone through
hardships and come out stronger on the other side- a successful person- the Redemptive
Inherent in this way of thinking is also the certainty, the expectation that when
problems arise they are solvable in some way, as McAdams (2008) posits, or at least
resolvable through the lessons and future insight into life or human nature that they will
provide, able to be woven into the fabric of our life story. This is especially important
when problems are imminent, unavoidable and seemingly unsolvable. Death, for
example.
Though sometimes a welcome relief for those who have watched a friend or
family member suffer, death, even when expected, is clearly an unalterable and difficult
event. Death when unexpected and senseless or violent, serves as an especially traumatic
cause of suffering- the same suffering that is an unavoidable part of the redemptive story,
as McAdams (2008) reminds us. There can be no redemption with no suffering, even
“when the suffering has no ultimate meaning, benefit, or human cause. . .[it] is to be
endured, but not necessarily redeemed.” It will be then that we most seek to find some
The postmodern perspective reminds us that it is our role to bring this meaning to
events and objects, that the meaning does not explicitly exist. A lesson is not a lesson
until we as audience and participants define and apply it as such. McAdams implies that
Loss 3
suffering is essential even when there is nothing redeeming about it, no ultimate meaning
to be found; but in the case of suffering in conjunction with the event of a death, I argue
that it goes against the instinct of man and threatens cognitive dissonance to leave
unresolved something that threatens what is most dear to us- our mortality. We need to
understand something about what happened, even if it is just a warning for our own future
behavior, or an avenue for connecting with others who have been affected.
It is this final point that McAdams (2008) also touches upon, that tragedy “opens
people up to each other and sometimes brings them closer together”. The commitment to
anything strengthens with loss, as seen when veterans of war recommit themselves
mentally and spiritually to the cause if they have lost a limb (Browning, personal
communication, Fall 2008). It is something that I have experienced personally, and been
struck by the connectedness of a particular community of people all affected by the loss
the internet. Just after my freshman year I received an email from the listserve of a
student organization I was involved with that stated that my friend Shannon had died in
car accident. Her Facebook wall was memorialized, then deleted. Perhaps not any more
impermanent than flowers placed on a temporary alter, but then the pixels that made up
the words “I‟ll miss you” never really existed in the same way that petals and the fabric
Years and months later on an early fall evening I was chattering happily away on
stopped me and said he had something that he needed to tell me, wasn‟t sure if he really
should because he didn‟t know what was going on yet. . .but that Chris had died the night
before.
I stared at the pixels that made up those words, blinking in my Instant Messenger
box, for a while before I really processed them. I was friends with Chris through the
Sailing Team, of which I had been a dedicated member during my three years of
undergraduate study at UT. Barrett had grown up sailing against him on Galveston Bay.
My friend Nataleigh had been dating him since they were teenagers, living together with
I tried to think of some offer of comfort to Barrett, wondered how fallen apart or
strung together Nataleigh was. I called another friend from the Sailing Team with whom I
was close, KJ. I suppose I needed to talk to someone else that knew him as I had. I
"People are like stained-glass windows. They sparkle and shine when the sun is out, but
when the darkness sets in their true beauty is revealed only if there is light from within."
-Elisabeth Kubler-Ross, M.D.
When I was sixteen years old, I was involved in the most important production
and performance of my high school acting career: a play based on Dr. Elisabeth Kulber-
The play was called The Shadow Box, written by Michael Cristopher, and it was
the most important to me because it was both highly challenging and the piece I
Loss 5
connected with more than any other, before or since. Death is still a somewhat obscure
subject for most teenagers to grasp- most have lost maybe a grandparent, but with an
entire life still held out in front of you, what is there to connect you with forgotten people
in the ground?
I had lost my grandmother when I was five or six, too young to really grasp the
gravity of the situation. I remember coming home from school, my brightly-colored and
lightweight backpack still clutched near me when my mother sat me down on the couch
and told me that she had good news and bad news. Which would I like to hear first?
I thought. Bad news, I decided. Then the good news could cheer me up.
Mom was probably trying to hold back tears at this point, or at least I imagine that
she would be, trying to smile as she told me that the good news kind of had to come
second, because Grammie had died, but now she was in a better place. She was in
Heaven.
I remember that we cried together on the couch that had its back to the display
cabinet with the little David Winter cottages I loved to collect. I don't remember if I cried
was upset. It was my father's mother, but I don't remember anything about his grief at all.
I have a vague memory of playing tag at the funeral with my cousin Amanda, who
is eight months younger than I. This was no more than the reaction of children to a
situation they cannot yet fully understand, but it says something clearly about
functionality when you exist in a state of denial. Denial can be a powerful coping
person] to collect himself and, with time, mobilize other, less radical defenses” (Kubler-
All of the characters in The Shadow Box dealt with each of the various stages,
sometimes briefly and sometimes not at all, skipping around and backpedaling much as
with denial. I was the crazy old woman; body steadily failing but clinging desperately to
life to see my favorite daughter one last time. This was not the daughter who was my
caretaker. This was unfortunately the daughter who had been killed years before, but in
I was a dirty old woman, singing the lines to an old dirty song "roll me over/in the
clover/roll me over lay me down and do it again. . ." the minute I was rolled onto stage. I
was the comic relief. As Kubler-Ross (1969) quotes in her book, “who was it that said,
„We cannot look at the sun all the time, we cannot face death all the time‟?”. These are
our coping mechanisms: this denial, this humor- humor that denies the emotions we are
pastel floral pajamas that I wore and the glasses I put on over my contact lenses in order
to really blind myself, which I'm sure was good for my still steadily declining sight. Such
a method actor.
as often as possible and as stalwartly as possible was that "all you teenagers, you just
think you're made out of Teflon!" I would shake my head in a serious manner, thinking
Loss 7
that for all of my conversations on death surrounding this play, for my solitary and little-
remembered loss, that I had at least a little bit of an understanding of my own mortality.
I do remember very clearly when I realized, suddenly and with finality that
someday I would really, actually and truly die. Dead in the ground- to speak, to breathe,
to talk, to love, to anything- no more. Ever. I was ten or twelve and sitting in front of the
television. Some commercial was on and I stared blankly at the screen, this thought
coming from nowhere and terrifying me. It is one of the more vivid memories of my life,
as I suppose it should be. Facing sudden death- or suddenly facing death, as it were-
disrupts your “sense of continuity” (Bochner, 1997). This new knowledge cannot be
ignored and must be incorporated into the sense of how you move forward, how you live
What I did not know, at sixteen, was that I was going to have to put my beloved
cat Peaches- who was my tenth birthday present- to sleep the following year. And that I
would lose my other grandmother that year as well. Bochner (1997) “studied, theorized,
and taught about loss and attachment for more than two decades, but. . .didn‟t really
begin to know loss until [he] experienced [his] father‟s death” and I wouldn‟t know as
much as I thought I did until the next year, until sudden and sad years later with each new
loss felt fresh. The power of the lived experience is more alive than any theory written
(Bochner, 1997).
I cried hysterical tears on the phone, scarring all seventeen-year-old boys in the
vicinity when my mother first called to tell me what had to be done to my beloved cat
Peaches. I remember the subsequent feeling of those awful scratchy brown paper towels
in the bathroom, scraping across my skin and smearing tears and mascara rather than
Loss 8
absorbing them. I held the cat when we took him to the vet to be euthanized, I held him
through the whole procedure and cried as quietly as possible until he was still and he was
gone.
I gave the eulogy at Nana's funeral and didn't cry until years later.
It's an interesting expression, I think, "lost". Like they've gone missing in your
couch cushions or you only find the other half of their sock pair in the back of the dryer.
It‟s difficult to designate what type of sock someone might be; I think I‟d like to be
patterned, maybe one of the St. Patrick's Day ones I have where the shamrocks are all
The trouble is that nobody's a sock. And nobody's "lost". They're dead. Really,
truly and actually, dead. There is no guarantee that you will see them, hug them, or hear
their voice again. Euphemisms help us combat the weight of that, I suppose. Denial.
Humor.
Present Loss
My roommate handed me a bottle of wine. I stared out the screen door, noting
how pretty the weather was. Nice weather for sailing. I remembered my relief, crewing
for Chris at sailing practice two years earlier after having taken a dunk from some
newbie- who swore up and down he knew what he was doing- into the freezing cold
water. I'd had bronchitis. The new kid had been wearing jeans. Chris had laughed.
Loss 9
How was Nataleigh? They'd been living together for. . .years. Two years? Three?
I just saw them, two or three weeks before when she brought over an athletic brace for
my ankle.
There was a wake the next afternoon. I wore what I was beginning to associate as
my Funeral Dress. It was covered in cat hair, but there was no time for a lint roller.
I'd never been to a wake before then. Very Irish Catholic, I thought. Will there be
keening? I'd ridden there with two friends, Barrett and James, but we all sat apart from
each other, staring out the window or at various parts of the walls. I felt very stoic and
unbreakable until other members of the Sailing Team began to show up. Michelle hugged
me. I cracked.
Open casket.
That was not the Chris I knew. People always say that, don't they? That wasn't
him, man, didn't look like him. Well this was not my shaggy, scruffy friend, his goofy-
sweet grin cracked askance at whatever was amusing him at the time. He. . .he had gel in
his hair. Clean shaven. Only the top portion of the coffin was open, but I was pretty sure
I needed him to be in a boat on the lake. Sunny day, good steady breeze. Maybe
But we were here instead, in this small cramped room. I could not go near the
coffin. I sat in the back row with Barrett. He had his head in his hands, I rubbed his back,
noticed he was wearing the suit I'd helped him pick out earlier in the summer. He got up
to go to the bathroom, Nicola took his seat. We squeezed hands. Barrett came back and
sat a few rows further up. That was as close as he got to the casket, to the friend he grew
Loss 10
up sailing with. To the rest of the family that still lived blocks away from his parent‟s
house.
Each member of that family went up to say goodbye- mother, father, sister,
brother.
The most moving, however, was a guy who wouldn't have looked out of place
tending bar with the way he was dressed, his blond hair in slightly-frizzy tight spirals past
his shoulders. He walked in and went straight up there, crouched down and bowed his
head. Shook it very slowly; just like all of us he was trying to understand. You couldn't
tell how old he was until he turned around to sit back down. Then I noticed the gray in his
hair.
Eventually we left, trickling out the door into the sun one at a time. I checked the
time. We'd been in there, crying in various poses for a little over an hour. It was cathartic.
Food and drink were now necessary. I suppose this is a tradition after funerals, memorials
and wakes to remind the rest of us that we are alive and human. Eat. You need your
strength.
Born June 11, 1986 in Webster Texas, Chris was employed as a veterinary
A native of Texas and an avid sports fan, Chris was an accomplished soccer
player, sailor and active in animal rescue in the Houston and Austin areas.
Chris is survived by his loving family: parents Terry & Nancy Flynn of
Shoreacres; brother, Colin; and sister, Samantha; grandparents Charles and Beryl Wiley
Loss 11
Easton, Maryland.
There was still the funeral next week, in Houston, and I was sure that even more
people would come. A week passed quicker than I imagined possible, and my prediction
There were doves on every banner lining the walls on the left-hand side of the
church from where we sat, in the middle of the many rows of pews. The usually-left-bare
overhang of wall at the entrance, past the glass doors, had been covered in crosses of
varying shapes, sizes, textures and colors. Heavy wooden beams contrasted with the
Jerusalem ran along the back wall of the stage where the alter sat.
Churches have always made me somewhat uncomfortable, and that feeling has
not diminished as I have grown older. The rituals of prayer and song, standing and
kneeling, seem stiff and wooden to me, uncomfortable rather than comforting. I weighed
this against the comfort of the presence of so many people who knew and loved Chris,
some of whom I also knew and loved, as I shifted in the hard and unforgiving pew.
It was past 3:00pm, when the service was supposed to start. I looked over the
Desiderata
-Written by Max Ehrmann in the 1920s
Go placidly amid the noise and the haste, and remember what peace there may be in
silence. As far as possible, without surrender, be on good terms with all persons.
Speak your truth quietly and clearly; and listen to others, even to the dull and the
ignorant; they too have their story. Avoid loud and aggressive persons; they are vexatious
to the spirit.
If you compare yourself with others, you may become vain or bitter, for always there will
be greater and lesser persons than yourself.
Enjoy your achievements as well as your plans. Keep interested in your own career,
however humble; it is a real possession in the changing fortunes of time.
Exercise caution in your business affairs, for the world is full of trickery. But let this not
blind you to what virtue there is; many persons strive for high ideals, and everywhere life
is full of heroism.
Loss 13
Be yourself. Especially do not feign affection. Neither be cynical about love, for in the
face of all aridity and disenchantment, it is as perennial as the grass. Take kindly the
counsel of the years, gracefully surrendering the things of youth.
Nurture strength of spirit to shield you in sudden misfortune. But do not distress yourself
with dark imaginings. Many fears are born of fatigue and loneliness.
Beyond a wholesome discipline, be gentle with yourself. You are a child of the universe
no less than the trees and the stars; you have a right to be here. And whether or not it is
clear to you, no doubt the universe is unfolding as it should.
Therefore be at peace with God, whatever you conceive Him to be. And whatever your
labors and aspirations, in the noisy confusion of life, keep peace in your soul. With all its
sham, drudgery and broken dreams, it is still a beautiful world.
I wondered what the significance of the piece was, if it had meant something to
Chris or if his family or Nataleigh had chosen it because it felt fitting? I watched the
people trickle in, a few of them I knew, most of them I didn‟t. The night before Barrett‟s
mother had said that sailing was “a small community, but a strong community”,
something I had recognized in my short tenure of three years on the UT Sailing Team.
Hours on the water sharing burning skin and muscles, burning words, yelling and praise,
pain and mistakes and personal bests, broken glasses and bleeding legs, bruises and
laughter- it binds you to people in a way that other things can‟t or don‟t.
There were people of all ages, some weathered and some fresher- you can always
tell the lifelong sailors. Most everyone was dressed neatly in dark clothing. Some were
not. KJ had on red shoes beside me. I was again wearing the Funeral Dress. Third time
this year.
At 3:30 the service began, the Asian woman who was the pastor of the church
stepped up to read the Call to Worship, which was printed for us in the leaflet. Everyone
followed along with the words, sang the hymn “How Great Thou Art” with varying
Loss 14
degrees of success. They are always too high pitched for me; I mouthed the words once I
fumbled through the heavy green book‟s pages to number 467. We sat down. She
introduced Nataleigh‟s stepfather- someone who was both close to Chris and himself a
minister.
I never know what to expect at a service; this was the first one that I had been to
that hadn‟t taken place at a grave site. I expected the coffin to be near the alter, covered in
flowers the way you always see it in movies, with photos all around. The only photo was
out front with the same poster that covered the leaflet and a book for everyone to sign and
Rev. Paul spoke. He spoke about how angry he was with Chris for committing the
“selfish act of suicide”. He spoke about how God is compassionate and forgiving, and he
knew in his heart that God had forgiven Chris and so it was not for us to hold anger in our
hearts against him. Chris was in heaven, Rev. Paul said, hopefully a heaven that had a
couch for him to sit on in his flip flops and shorts (apparently you have to dress up to
meet God, but you can change once you get there), one arm wrapped around a dog and
the other hand wrapped around a beer, watching the game. Catching the surf, that perfect
Endless Summer.
He spoke of Chris‟s nature, the duality of it. How Chris was sweet, but also
volatile. Quick to crack a joke, and laid back, but also intense. Searching. He did not find
what he was looking for here on earth and so he made a conscious choice to leave it.
“Some souls were not meant to weather this world,” KJ‟s mom had said when she
had spoken to her of Chris‟s suicide, and KJ repeated to me when I came to stay with her
the day before. I thought of this as Rev. Paul spoke, and I could feel the passion that he
Loss 15
had for Chris‟s person and his life through the words. Rev. Paul was admitting his anger
at Chris, different from Kuber-Ross‟s (1969, p. 4) musing that none of us very much like
to admit anger towards someone who has died. Perhaps as a Reverend he has had more
death to deal with and is more proficient in dealing with it, not removing anger into grief,
A slideshow played, pictures of Chris through every stage of life. Lots of dogs.
They made you laugh and cry at the same time, watching this little boy grow into the
young man that you knew him to be, that you knew was now gone. All Dogs go to
Heaven.
Other people shared remembrances- a family friend who was also Chris‟s former
high school assistant principal, then a young man who was one of Chris‟s best friends.
Nataleigh. She looked completely composed from where I was seated, but later she
confided to me and to KJ that her hands were shaking so hard she was afraid she
wouldn‟t be able to read the piece she was holding- Desiderata. Chris had put it on her
fridge; he‟d had it posted on his as well, read it a lot in the past few months, found real
This was something that we would all have to do in the coming days, hours,
months. Years.
I began to tune out as the church‟s pastor again stepped forward and began to read
and talk. I suppose it felt like a sort of lie, her talking about Chris when she didn‟t know
him the way Rev. Paul knew him. I almost expected people to be angry with the way he
addressed Chris‟s faults- after all, as Kubler-Ross acknowledged, you never speak ill of
Loss 16
the dead as a rule- but it was perfect. It was real and it had love behind it and so it fit.
different points from different versions. We stood, flipped awkwardly through heavy
green-backed pages one more time to 280 to sing “Amazing Grace”. I wished I had the
voice to do it justice, to fill the building and bleed out some of the emotion I was feeling.
More words were spoken from the stranger woman in her white robes. Then it
was over and we all began to file out into the lobby before our cars and the reception at
Drinks. We needed drinks. And a good strong sunset out on the water that Chris
“I am not afraid of storms, for I am learning to sail my ship.” –Louisa May Alcott
It was weeks later and I was sitting in a red X-terra (which was, in fact, burgundy
if you asked its owner) with the same two friends I‟d attended Chris‟s wake with, James
and Barrett; we were coming home from a weekend of camping outside of Houston. I
was tired and not in a particularly good mood anyway when through the stream of
consciousness flowing between my ears came a particular memory from the Alumni
Organized once a year by the undergraduates still running the UT Sailing team,
the Alumni Regatta is a chance for all the alumni who can make their way back to Austin
Loss 17
for the weekend to pretend like they‟ve never left the college sailing way of life. Actual
attendance of UT doesn‟t seem to matter much, as Chris was there with us that day.
Though beers are thrown from the starting line to the FJ‟s as they compete for the
best starting position when the three-minute whistles are blown, most take their sailing
pretty seriously and scores are kept to see who the best skipper is at the end of the day.
The best skipper was decidedly not my friend Will, which I could tell when I got
into the boat with him on a fresh crew rotation and heard the steel drum rattling of the
beers he had been drinking since lunch. I suggested that we abandon the final race to
chase down the party boat I could see not far from the race course- my friend Jasmine
had hired one for her boyfriend Kyle‟s birthday and I wanted to see if it was them. .
.which we soon learned it was not. However, the large burly man hanging off of the back
of the boat offered to pitch us some Jell-O shots and consequently sent one or two
Sailing back in a few minutes later, we could see the race course being abandoned
as everyone sailed towards the dock- with one lone boat heading towards us. Hand firmly
“Hey I was just coming to join you guys! Where‟d you go?!” he yelled as we
“That random guy on the party boat threw us some Jell-O shots!” I yelled back at
him, laughing. Chris made the grand, sweeping hand gesture of disappointment and
“Man why didn‟t you tell me that‟s where you guys were going!” he lamented.
We all smiled at one another, sharing in the day and the anticipation of the night to come,
I smiled myself, in the backseat of the X-terra, remembering this afternoon and
this exchange, of the fun-loving Chris I remembered best. Memories of Shannon, the
friend I lost freshman year, still hit me at random when I see a girl near our old dorm on
campus who looks a little like her, or the flagpole where they held her memorial. I expect
the same will happen with Chris. The sharp little pang that comes with the realization that
these memories are all you have left of the living, breathing person you once called your
friend.
People are sympathetic when you first lose someone, but they expect you to begin
to move on in the following weeks, or at least cover up what you‟re feeling in public.
Similar to how as academics we are taught to separate our personal selves from our
academic work, to rely on theories and hard facts rather than personal experience and
stories, though some like Bochner (1997) argue “there is nothing as theoretical as a good
story. . .there is no split between theory and story when theorizing is conceived as a
social and communicative activity”. This social theory exists between history and destiny
(Bochner 1997); our own personal history of where we have been, how it shapes our
story of who we are (for identity and personal stories are intrinsically linked) and where
we are going. How this relates us to every person around us and how we all are, as
Vonnegut (1997) put it in Timequake, seeking “desperately to receive this message: 'I feel
and think much as you do, care about many of the things you care about, although most
Bochner (2002, p. 75) reflects this sentiment again from his 1994 essay “Theories
ideological and ethnical concerns. The tacit goal of many researchers. . .is the moral one
of enlarging and deepening the sense of human community”. I share my story about Chris
because it connects me to the larger human community of shared loss, of shared sadness.
I am not alone.
Morality and death are often linked, perhaps even more so in a violent, self-
induced death such as the one Chris chose. Bocher (2002, p.75) argues that “in this sense,
what we want from research is moral and ethical guidance”. But there cannot be a
handbook to dealing with grief and loss, there can only be shared lived experience- even
of her stages of grief are not set in stone; people experience them in various degrees of
intensity, skip around, backpedal, and pass over some of them entirely.
do in life. We tell stories about ourselves so that we may make sense of our lives, and
work such as Bochner‟s that draws “fuzzy borders” (2002, p. 75) between theory and
story are important to understand that a person‟s- and academia‟s- desire for rationality
and science overlaps with what it is that we experience when we live life itself. They do
not have to be mutually exclusive, as “there is no one right way to do social science
I was still thankful for the growing darkness that covered the glint of tears in my
eyes, sitting the back of James‟s Xterra as we drove back into Austin. It is difficult to
learn to communicate differently from the way you have always been taught- hide your
Loss 20
tears, hide your feelings, in darkness and in words. I am but a storyteller seeking meaning
to help me cope with my circumstance (Bochner, 2001) and still learning how to navigate
Chris was an example of the dichotomy of light and dark in all of our lives, of one
who gave up the sometimes unbearable difficulties of navigation to return home; “We
cannot look at the sun all the time and we cannot face death all the time” (Kubler-Ross,
1969).
remember.
Loss 21
References
Bochner, A. P. (1997, December). It‟s about time: narrative and the divided self .
Flynn, P., & Vann, N. (Eds.). (2008). Christopher Adam Flynn [Pamphlet]. Houston,
Texas .
Kubler-Ross, E. (1969). On Death and Dying. New York : MacMillian Publishing Co.
5(2), 100-122.
McAdams, D. P. (2008 , Spring). American Identity: The Redemptive Self . The General