Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Br. J. Anaesth. 2002 Bruemmer - Smith 489 95
Br. J. Anaesth. 2002 Bruemmer - Smith 489 95
Background. Coronary artery bypass grafting with hypothermic cardiac arrest and cardiopul-
monary bypass (CPB) is associated with myocardial injury. Our study investigated whether an
infusion of glucose, insulin and potassium (GIK) during elective coronary artery bypass surgery
decreases myocardial cell death.
Methods. We measured cardiac troponin I (cTnI), a myobrillar structural protein, which is a
sensitive and specic indicator of myocytic injury. With ethics committee approval, 42 patients
were enrolled into a randomized, prospective, double-blinded study. In the GIK group, 500 ml
of 50% dextrose solution containing 100 IU insulin and potassium 80 mmol was infused at the
rate of 0.75 ml kg1 h1. Patients in the non-GIK group received 5% dextrose solution at the
same rate. Arterial blood samples were taken before induction of anaesthesia, after removal of
the aortic clamp and 6 and 12 h after CPB.
Results. In both groups there was an increase in cTnI concentration (P<0.05), which was
greatest about 6 h after CPB. At no time did the cTnI concentration differ between the two
groups.
Conclusion. The results suggest that GIK does not decrease the irreversible myocardial dam-
age associated with routine coronary artery bypass surgery.
Br J Anaesth 2002; 88: 48995
Keywords: surgery, cardiovascular; infusions, glucoseinsulinpotassium; heart, cardiac
troponin I; heart, myocyte protection
Accepted for publication: November 16, 2001
The use of glucoseinsulinpotassium (GIK) for cardiac normal carbohydrate and fatty acid metabolism and thus cell
protection was rst described 25 yr ago.1 New interest in the function. The effects of GIK and its inuence on myocyte
possible protective effect of GIK in patients with myocar- metabolism, specically during ischaemia and reperfusion,
dial infarcts followed the 1998 Estudios Cardiologicos are complex. The protective effect of GIK on the functional
Latinoamerica (ECLA). In this multicentre study, a high- recovery of the heart has been investigated extensively.36
dose regimen of GIK (25% glucose solution containing Cardiac troponin I (cTnI) is a myobrillar structural
insulin 100 IU and potassium 80 mmol per litre) infused at protein, and the cardiac isomer is specic to heart muscle.
1.5 ml kg1 h1 in patients with acute myocardial infarct cTnI is a more reliable marker of irreversible myocardial
signicantly reduced mortality in patients given thrombo- cell damage than creatine kinase MB.710 Surgery using
lytic therapy or angioplasty.2 The mechanism was not clear, cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) with hypothermic cardiac
but one proposed mechanism was reduction in cell death arrest is associated with damage to the heart despite
and infarct size. improvements in surgery, anaesthesia and the technique of
During ischaemia, the heart has limited oxidative reserve CPB.11 12 We examined whether an intraoperative infusion
and energy-rich phosphates are steadily depleted. In of GIK could reduce irreversible myocardial cell damage,
hypoxia, GIK may protect myocardial tissue by maintaining using cTnI as a marker of myocyte injury.
The Board of Management and Trustees of the British Journal of Anaesthesia 2002
Bruemmer-Smith et al.
Table 1 Patient characteristics. Values are mean (SD), number (%) or ratio The same surgeon operated on all patients.
GIK group Non-GIK group Cardiopulmonary bypass was achieved with a roller pump
(19 patients) (20 patients) and membrane oxygenator with mild hypothermia of 32C.
Multiple anterograde doses of St Thomas' cardioplegia
Age (yr) 64.3 (9.9) 66.3 (10.4)
Gender ratio (M:F) 19:0 15:5
solution in cold (6C) oxygenated blood were infused for
Bypass time (min) 80.3 (22.3) 69.5 (20.3) myocardial preservation. St Thomas' solution contains
Cross-clamp time (min) 50.7 (13.7) 45.2 (12.4) magnesium chloride BP 3.253 g, potassium chloride BP
Hypertension 17 (90%) 18 (90%)
Hypercholesterolaemia 14 (74%) 13 (65%)
1.193 g and procaine hydrochloride BP 272.8 mg in 20 ml.
Preoperative ejection fraction <45% 9 (47%) 3 (15%) CPB time, aortic cross-clamp time and reperfusion time
Previous myocardial infarction 10 (53%) 8 (40%) were noted. Mean arterial pressure was maintained between
50 and 60 mm Hg either by adjusting pump ow or with
small boluses of phenylephrine. Anticoagulation was with
Methods heparin 300 IU kg1 and further doses to maintain an
With local ethics committee approval and informed patient activated clotting time greater than 480 s.
consent, we conducted a double-blinded prospective
randomized study of 42 patients scheduled for elective Blood sampling and laboratory analysis
coronary artery bypass grafting. Three patients were
Blood samples were taken into tubes without anticoagulant
excluded from analysis, two because of incomplete sam-
and centrifuged at 2500 g for 20 min. The serum obtained
pling and one because of missing randomization. All
was then stored at 70C until analysis.
patients who electively received at least two bypass grafts
Quantitative cTnI analysis was performed using the
were included in the study. Exclusion criteria were an
Bayer Immuno-1 assay (Bayer, Leverkusen, Germany), a
abnormal creatinine concentration and type 1 and type 2
heterogeneous sandwich magnetic separation system using
diabetes. Assessment of ejection fraction was part of the
mouse monoclonal and goat polyclonal anti-cTnI anti-
routine preoperative evaluation.
bodies. Both antibodies were directed to epitopes at the
Patients received either 50% glucose 500 ml containing
centre of the cTnI molecule. The detection antibodies were
insulin 100 IU and potassium 80 mmol at a rate of 0.75
labelled with alkaline phosphatase and addition of substrate
ml kg1 h1 (GIK group) or an equivalent rate of 5% subsequently gives a colour change directly proportional to
dextrose (non-GIK group), given into a central vein. The the cTnI concentration. The assay had a detection limit of
infusion started immediately after induction of anaesthesia 0.1 mg litre1 and an analytical range up to 200 mg litre1.
and stopped at the end of surgery. Blood glucose was The interassay coefcient of variation was 6% at a
measured hourly and insulin was given according to a concentration of 0.2 mg litre1, which was the manu-
sliding scale to maintain blood glucose between 4 and 10 facturer's recommended clinical discriminatory level for
mmol litre1. Potassium was added to achieve a plasma myocardial injury (cTnI >0.9 mg litre1 is considered
concentration of 46 mmol litre1. Peripheral arterial blood diagnostic of acute myocardial infarction).
samples were collected for cTnI analysis before induction of
anaesthesia, after removal of the aortic cross-clamp and 6
and 12 h after CPB. Statistical analysis
A power analysis showed that 17 patients in each group
would be required to detect a mean difference of 0.9 (SD
Surgical and anaesthetic technique 0.8) mg litre1 in cTnI concentration between the two groups
at any of the time points with a power of 90% and a P value
A standardized anaesthetic technique was used for all of 0.05. The cTnI data were assessed with the ShapiroWilk
patients. Premedication consisted of oral temazepam 20 mg test of normality and were distributed asymmetrically. Non-
and ranitidine 150 mg. Anaesthesia was induced with parametric statistical tests were therefore used for cTnI
fentanyl 1015 mg kg1 and propofol 2 mg kg 1. A single analysis. The MannWhitney U-test was used to test for
dose of vecuronium 0.15 mg kg 1 was used for muscle differences in cTnI concentration between groups at each
relaxation. Anaesthesia was maintained with 30% oxygen in time point. Changes in cTnI concentration over time within
nitrous oxide and isourane before CPB. End-expiratory groups were assessed by Friedman analysis of variance
isourane concentration was held between 0.6 and 0.8%. (ANOVA) and the Wilcoxon signed ranks test. Fisher's
Thereafter, a propofol infusion of 100350 mg h1 was used exact test was used to determine whether there was a
to maintain anaesthesia until transfer to the recovery area. signicant difference in the proportion of patients with a
Supplementary i.v. fentanyl was administered according to low ejection fraction (<45%) in the GIK group compared
the discretion of the anaesthetist up to a maximum of 500 mg. with the non-GIK group. Other categorical data, including
Inotropic drugs were administered only when required to all patient proportions (hypertension, hypercholesterolae-
facilitate separation from CPB. mia, preoperative myocardial infarction, gender ratio), were
490
GIK for heart protection
Fig 1 Glucose concentrations in the GIK group and non-GIK group. Fig 2 Potassium concentrations in the GIK group and non-GIK group.
Signicant differences between groups are represented by asterisks Signicant differences between groups are represented by asterisks
(P<0.05). The graphs show mean concentrations and standard deviations (P<0.05). The graphs show mean concentrations and standard deviations
(error bars). BL=baseline; 1 h=1 h after anaesthetic induction; XC=aortic (error bars). BL=baseline; 1 h=1 h after anaesthetic induction; XC=aortic
cross-clamp; ICU=intensive care unit; 3, 6 and 12 h=3, 6 and 12 h after cross-clamp; ICU=intensive care unit; 3, 6 and 12 h=3, 6 and 12 h after
CPB. CPB.
491
Bruemmer-Smith et al.
Fig 3 Box and whisker plots showing cTnI concentrations in the GIK (G)
and non-GIK (nG) groups at four time points: 1=baseline; 2=after aortic
clamp removal; 3=6 h after CPB; 4=12 h after CPB. The boxes depict
median values with interquartile ranges and the whiskers show the full
ranges. In both groups, there was a signicant (P<0.05) increase in cTnI Fig 4 Correlation of cTnl concentration 6 h after CPB with cross-clamp
concentration, with a peak concentration at time point 3. There was no time.
signicant difference in cTnl concentration between groups at any time.
492
GIK for heart protection
undergoing non-cardiac surgery21 and in patients undergo- The different proportions of male and female patients in
ing coronary bypass grafting, because its concentration is the GIK and non-GIK groups is unlikely to have
related to the amount of irreversible cell injury. Higher inuenced the results, but this possibility cannot be
perioperative concentrations are associated with more excluded. The possible inuence of the ejection fraction
postoperative complications.22 It has also been used to was analysed retrospectively. Nine out of 19 patients in
indicate underlying cardiac injury in intensive care our GIK group and only three in the non-GIK group
patients23 24 and to examine the benet of different solutions had an ejection fraction of less than 45% (P=0.06). The
and temperatures of cardioplegia.25 The heart is most likely importance of the ejection fraction as a confounding
to sustain ischaemic injury when the aortic cross-clamp is factor is uncertain as there was no signicant difference
applied. This is supported by our nding of a correlation in cTnI concentration at any time point between patients
between cross-clamp time and peak cTnI concentration. with low and those with normal ejection fractions. It
In this study, despite the theoretical protective effects of remains speculative whether those patients in the GIK
GIK listed above and the reliability of cTnI as a marker of group with poor cardiac function would have had higher
myocardial cell damage, no cardioprotective effect of GIK cTnI concentrations without GIK infusion. Differences in
was observed. We did not nd a signicant difference in preoperative ventricular function can affect postoperative
cTnI concentration between the two groups. The median recovery but not necessarily the postoperative cTnI
values of both groups (Fig. 3) after 6 and 12 h showed that concentration, which specically indicates myocardial
some myocardial death had occurred during surgery, cell death. It would be useful to conduct a larger study
supporting the ndings of other studies,13 but there was no in diabetic patients or patients with decreased left
difference between GIK- and non-GIK-treated patients. ventricular function,34 testing for an even smaller
Before concluding that GIK confers no protective effect on difference in cTn concentrations, and to relate cTnI to
the myocardium during CABG surgery, other possible functional recovery of the heart. One problem with a
reasons for our negative ndings should be considered. high-concentration glucose infusion is hyperglycaemia
We used a high dose of GIK, as recommended in other during CPB, which could damage the brain and worsen
studies,16 26 but this was only given during surgery. It might neurological outcome. Hyperglycaemia may aggravate
be of more benet if started before surgery and continued ischaemic brain injury35 and be harmful after acute head
for 1248 h after surgery, as suggested by other studies. injury.36 The critical glucose concentration at which
Oldeld and colleagues examined the effect of GIK on treatment should be initiated is not known.37 A
complications of mitral valve replacement and demon- confounding factor is that high glucose concentrations
strated an increased myocardial glycogen content after an may indicate severe head injury, as hyperglycaemia is a
infusion of GIK 12 h before the operation.27 This reduced general stress response.38 However, there is consensus
complications after surgery, such as hypothermia and that the blood glucose concentration should be main-
arrhythmia. Lazar and colleagues28 found better cardiac tained within the normal range.37 38 Measuring glucose
performance and faster recovery from urgent coronary and potassium concentrations regularly is necessary.
bypass grafting in patients with unstable angina given GIK Blood glucose concentrations were higher in the GIK
infusion for 12 h after operation. These patients had greater group implying that, in future studies, more insulin
cardiac output, a signicantly lower incidence of atrial should be added to the glucose solution. Another
brillation (13.3 vs 53.3%; P=0.02) and a shorter stay in concern is that increasing glycolysis can increase the
intensive care. concentrations of end-products such as lactate. Lactate
GIK might be benecial in patients with decreased accumulation is associated with inhibition of glycolysis
cardiac reserve, poor left ventricular function and/or and mitochondrial changes leading to cell damage, but
cardiogenic shock. Patients with a high risk of death may in an animal study treatment with glucose did not affect
be more likely to benet from metabolic therapy.29 Patients the lactate concentration.39
with insulin-dependent diabetes might benet particularly
from GIK, as shown in the DIGAMI study for patients with
myocardial infarct.30 A recent study by Lazar and col-
leagues found better cardiac performance and faster recov-
ery after coronary bypass grafting in a group of 40 diabetic Conclusion
patients.31 Postoperative GIK infusion for 48 h is of benet We did not nd that the use of GIK infusion during surgery
in patients with refractory cardiac failure after hypothermic reduced myocardial cell damage associated with cardiac
cardiac arrest for bypass grafting.32 33 surgery and CPB. However, it was associated with increased
hyperglycaemia. As hyperglycaemia may worsen the
neurological outcome, routine GIK infusions cannot be
Limitations of our study recommended until studies have been performed that
It is possible that our study was too small and the demonstrate the value of this practice and determine
groups too poorly matched to reveal the benet of GIK. which patients are most likely to benet.
493
Bruemmer-Smith et al.
494
GIK for heart protection
neurological outcome in patients with head injury. J Neurosurgery injury: review and clinical recommendations. Mayo Clin Proc 1996,
1991; 75: 54551 71: 80112
37 Arrowsmith JE, Grocott HP, Reves JG, Newman MF. Central 39 Owen P, du Toit EF, Opie LH. The optimal glucose
nervous system complications of cardiac surgery. Br J Anaesth concentration for intermittent cardioplegia in isolated rat heart
2000; 84: 3047 when added to St. Thomas' Hospital cardioplegic solution. J
38 Wass CT, Lanier WL. Glucose modulation of ischemic brain Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1993; 105: 9951006
495