Professional Documents
Culture Documents
China5000yearsin00lees PDF
China5000yearsin00lees PDF
China5000yearsin00lees PDF
5,000 YEARS
INNOVATION AND TRANSFORMATION IN THE ARTS
http://www.archive.org/details/china5000yearsin00lees
/
t i
*ft /
m ;:
m
:
0%mmM:
^rptp&i*
W$$.
M~ --y
: .,
imJ*^:
CHINA
^ 5,000 YEARS
GUGGENHEIM MUSEUM
*5f
front cover: CHINA: 5,000 YEARS
Rearing dragon Curated by Sherman Lee
Tang dynasty (618-907)
cat. no. 59 Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum
February 6June 3, 1998
back cover:
Shang Xi Guggenheim Museum Bilbao
The Xuande Emperor on an Outing Summer 1998
Ming dynasty (136S-1644)
cat. no. 190 (detail)
cat. no. 46
Lufthansa NOKIA
1998 The Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation, New York, and
Arc Exhibitions China, Beijing. All rights reserved. r
6foKdj^P-r f<fmfir/ v. tMc (^Gm&ffl/Hwp
Guggenheim Museum Publications
New York, New York 10011 This exhibition has also been made possible in part
by a major grant from the National Endowment for
ISBN 0-S109-6908-4 (hardcover) the Humanities, expanding America s understanding of
ISBN 0-89207-202-4 (softcover) who we were, who we are, and who we will be.
Design hyTsang Seymour Design, Inc., New York This catalogue is supported by a grant from The Li-Ching
Printed in Italy by Manogros Cultural and Educational Foundation.
CHINA
5,000 YEARS
LACQUER Calligraphy
TEXTILES PAINTING
98 Zhao Feng 174 James Cahill
Art of Silk and Art on Silk in China Chinese Painting: Innovation After
"Progress" Ends
193 CATALOGUE
SPONSOR'S STATEMENT
Of all cultures that have existed for thousands of years, China's is one of the oldest. Since the travels of
Marco Polo, it has intrigued the Western imagination and has had an immense influence on European art
and culture. This fascination with China has thrived right up until the present day, and a journey to "the
Middle Kingdom" remains an extraordinarily rich and captivating experience. Since the earliest contacts
between China and the West, transportation technology has made considerable contributions to cultural
interchange, first through maritime trade and later, on a more extensive scale, through air traffic as well.
Lufthansa, which has participated in the realization of this exhibition, undertook its first test flights to
China during the 1920s, and in 1927 and 1928, the famous Asian expert Sven Hedin explored the Gobi
desert and its climate with Lufthansa's assistance.
These initial adventures developed into commerical flights, when, in 1930, Lufthansa and the Chinese
Ministry of Transport signed an agreement for the operation of a European- Asian air-mail company,
Eurasia. The company flew its Shanghai-Nanjing-Beijing-Manshuli route once a week, and, although this
scheme soon had to be given up, its pioneering flights represented a further step in China's relationship
with Europe and the rest of the world.
Today, air connections to China are both comfortable and plentiful. As in the early days of aviation,
however, Lufthansa's commitment in China is greater than the transportation of passengers and cargo.
Together with Air China, Lufthansa operates a maintenance center for Chinese aviation, cooperates in the
China: 5,oooYears is an expression of the ties between the West and China as it reemerges as an economic
and political superpower. We are pleased to offer our support for this exhibition as a Global Partner of the
Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation, with the conviction that works of art build the longest-lasting
bridges to mutual understanding.
Frederick W. Reid
President and Chief Operating Officer
Lufthansa German Airlines
Lufthansa
SPONSOR'S STATEMENT
As we begin our association with the Guggenheim Museum, Nokia is especially pleased to play a role in
bringing this rich story of five thousand years of Chinese art and culture to people of the Western world.
In our contemporary global society, where the written and spoken word may disjoin, art unifies. It projects
For Nokia, art embodies the principles of openness, creativity, and lasting value to which we as an institu-
tion are committed. For that reason, we are proud not only to sponsor China: 5,000 Years but also to support
the Finnish Museum for Modern Arts in Helsinki and the Chinese Year of Fine Arts 199S in Beijing. The
thinking that underlies these sponsorships is reflected in our products, which are designed for aesthetic
Because of this, our association with the Guggenheim is a natural step in the continuing evolution ot
Nokia's corporate culture. We share a common vision of connecting people and enriching lives through
technology, art, and design. From its original location in New York to the new museum in Bilbao, the
Guggenheim is synonymous with the development and preservation of art, and thus with furthering
knowledge and social achievement.
China: 5, 000 Years is the culmination of the efforts of a distinguished international team of experts. As the
largest exhibition of such art ever to be seen outside China, it presents an extremely broad and unprece-
dented view of Chinese cultural development in which we all can find inspiration. We hope that you enjoy
the exhibition and the great wealth it offers.
Jorma Ollila
NOKIA
SPONSOR'S STATEMENT
On behalf of the thousands of Ford Motor Company employees around the world, I am pleased to salute
all of those involved in presenting China: 5,000 Years. Their unique collaboration offers the people of the
United States and Spain this extraordinary exhibition, which demonstrates the full scope of Chinese artistic
Our thanks go to the Guggenheim Museum; Qian Qichen,Vice Premier and Foreign Minister of the
People's Republic of China; Li Daoyu, Ambassador of the People's Republic of China to the United
States; the Ministry of Culture of the People's Republic of China; the National Administration for
Cultural Heritage of the People's Republic of China; China International Exhibition Agency; and Art
Exhibitions China for organizing this major cultural exchange between the United States and the People's
Republic of China.
We at Ford Motor Company believe deeply in shared understanding between nations, and especially in
strengthening the relationship between the governments, businesses, and people of the United States and
China. We are particularly pleased to serve as a partner in bringing the rich cultural heritage of China to
the people of the United States and Spain, and look forward to introducing the people of China to
American art when the exchange exhibition America: 300 Years is presented in Beijing and Shanghai in late
Alex Trotman
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
<X^jtJg/i>Aizm/M
SPONSOR'S STATEMENT
China: },oooYears offers Americans the opportunity to appreciate the beauty created over five millennia by
one of the world's oldest civilizations. From early Neolithic jade carvings to twentieth-century pieces, the
exhibition allows the world its first view of many magnificent works.
The Coca-Cola Company commends the Guggenheim Museum for bringing an extraordinary collection
of Chinese artistic treasures to the United States, and for its leadership in fostering mutual understanding
between cultures. We welcome the opportunity to demonstrate our commitment to education through
the arts, from the global exchange of ideas and information to the promotion of human understanding
and diversity.
As a partner of the Guggenheim Museum, we are pleased to help spotlight China s rich cultural heritage,
and to encourage a deeper understanding of the profound achievements of generations ot Chinese artists.
M. Douglas Ivester
HONORARY COMMITTEE
GUGGENHEIM MUSEUM
Mrs. Caroline Leonetti Ahmanson Vice Chairman, National Committee on United States-China Relations
Professor and Mrs. A. Doak Barnett Professor of Chinese Studies, School of International Studies,
Jerome A. and Joan Lebold Cohen Paul Weiss Rif kind Wharton and Garrison
Douglas Dillon Former United States Secretary ot the Treasury; Former President and
Chairman of the Board, The Metropolitan Museum ot Art
10
Dr. Simon X.Jiang Deputy Chief, United Nations Pension Fund Investments
Robert A. Kapp President, United States-China Business Council
Dr. David N. Keightley Department of History, University of California, Berkeley
Alice King Alisan Fine Arts Limited
Dr. Henry A. Kissinger Former United States Secretary of State
Geraldine S. Kunstadter Chair, Albert Kunstadter Family Foundation
David M. Lampton President, National Committee on United States China Relations
Ambassador Donald F. McHenry Distinguished Professor in the Practice of Diplomacy, Georgetown University
Clare Tweedy McMorris Chairman of the Board, The China Institute
The Honorable and Mrs. Leon Polsky Board of Directors, The Metropolitan Museum of Art
Philip J.
Purcell Chairman and CEO, Morgan Stanley, Dean Witter, Discover & Co.
The Honorable Ambassador Qiu Shengyun Consul General of the Peoples Republic of China in New York
Frederick W. Reid President and COO, Lufthansa German Airlines
Ambassador James R. Sasser Ambassador of the United States to the People's Republic of China
Patrick T Siewert Chairman and President, Greater China Region. Eastman Kodak
Chengdu
Xu Huping Director, Nanjing Museum, Jiangsu Province
JiaYang Deputy Director, Bureau ot Culture ot Tibetan Autonomous Region
Li Kunsheng Director, Yunnan ProvincialMuseum, Kunming
Shu Zhimei Director, Hubei Provincial Museum, Wuhan
Xia Lu Director, Shanxi Provincial Museum, Taiyuan
Wang Mianhou Director, Liaoning Provincial Museum, Shenyang
Xiong Chuanxin Director, Hunan Provincial Museum, Changsha
Zhang Lizhu Director, Hebei Provincial Bureau of Cultural Relics
Ji Genzhang Director, Jiangsu Provincial Bureau of Culture
Bao XianJun Director, Zhejiang Provincial Bureau of Cultural Relics
MaiYinghao Honorary Director, Museum of the Tomb of the Nanyue King of the
Western Han Dynasty, Guangdong Province
Zhang Qingjie Director, Shanxi Provincial Institute of Archaeology, Taiyuan
Wang Limei Director, Foreign Affairs Office, National Administration for Cultural
Heritage, P.R.C.
Meng Xianmin Department Director, National Administration for Cultural Heritage, P.R.C.
Zheng Guangrong Department Director, National Administration for Cultural Heritage, P.R.C.
Yang Yang Deputy Director, Art Exhibitions China
Yin Jia Director, Exhibition Department, Art Exhibitions China
Zhang Jianxin Director, External Affairs Department, Art Exhibitions China
Qian Wei Assistant Research Fellow, Exhibition Department, Art Exhibitions China
ADVISORY COMMITTEE
GUGGENHEIM MUSEUM
Jenny So Curator of Ancient Chinese Art, Freer Gallery of Art and Arthur M. Sackler
Gallery, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C.
Peter Sturman Associate Professor, Department of the History of Art and Architecture,
University of California, Santa Barbara
Wu Hung Harrie A.Vanderstappen Distinguished Service Professor in Chinese Art
History, University of Chicago
Zhao Feng Professor, China National Silk Museum, Hangzhou
ADVISORY COMMITTEE
PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA
Heritage, P.K.C
Xu Pingfang Researcher, Former Director, China Social Science ofArchaeology
Institute, Beijing
13
EXHIBITION PROJECT TEAM
GUGGENHEIM MUSEUM
15
NOTES TO READERS
Romanization. Chinese is here transcribed according to the pinyin system of romanization adopted by
the People's Republic of China and now in general use. Sanskrit names and terms are transcribed using
full upper diacriticals but no lower diacriticals. Parenthetic C: and S: stand for "Chinese" and "Sanskrit,"
respectively.
Names. All Chinese names are cited in traditional Asian fashion, surname followed by given name.
Dates. Following custom, Chinese emperors from antiquity to the beginning of the Ming dynasty are
referred to by the name of their dynasty followed by their posthumous names (e.g., Song Huizong, whose
personal name was Zhao Ji). Again following custom, emperors of the Ming and Qing dynasties are
referred to by the auspicious name chosen by themselves for each of their reigns (e.g., the Xuande
["Far-Reaching Virtue"] emperor). Note that the reign-era (iiianliao) never exactly corresponded to the
dates of the reign itself, usually being proclaimed some months after the enthronement and continuing in
use until the successor, some time after his enthronement, proclaimed a new reign-era.
Ceramics. Chinese place-names changed frequently, usually reflecting political changes. Most ceramics are
conventionally called by the ancient names of the states, counties, or towns in or near which the principal
kilns were located (Cizhou ware.Yue ware), or by the site names of the first characteristic finds (Yangshao
ware). Names of other wares refer to their glaze color (e.g., qingbai, "bluish white," or sancai, "three-
colored"). Note that the gray-green, blue-green, or olive-green wares formerly differentiated as Northern
and Southern Celadons, Ru ware, and Guan ware are here all termed "green-glazed ware," as an indication
that they are all branches of a single stylistic and technological "family."
16
ntroduction
Zhang Wenbin
Director General,
National Administration for
China: 5,oooYears, an exhibition nearly cultural Heritage, Beijing
warm and heartfelt congratulations for the so doing to build bridges of understanding and
exhibitions opening at the world-renowned trust. Although the various artistic treasures
Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, and to displayed in China: 5,000 Years are but a tiny portion
anticipate its resounding success. of China's ancient artistic heritage, they are among
the most representative and most expressive
The exhibition China: 5,000 Years is aptly named, specimens. My respected teacher, Professor Su Bai
for the more than two hundred Chinese cultural of Beijing University, and others have prepared
treasures here assembled range from extraordinary excellent detailed comments and analyses. I am
and inspired creations of our prehistoric forebears therefore fully confident that through an
to objects of luxury and paintings dating from the appreciation of these remarkable works of art,
reigns of the Yongzheng (r. 1723-1735) and viewers will gain a clear and deep, albeit not
Qianlong (r. 1736-1795) emperors of the Qing comprehensive, impression of the Chinese people
dynasty. Thirty-nine different cultural institutions over five millennia, and of the breadth and depth of
throughout China have made these treasures their history and culture.
of the Hongshan culture in Liaoning Province Among the world's great civilizations, that of China
(cat. 2), the extraordinary four-ram bronze zun of is unique in The Mesopotamians or
its continuity.
Shang date from Hunan Province (cat. 23), and a the Mayans have no modern heirs, but modern
mwe-glazed octagonal bottle from the Famen Chinese culture has demonstrably descended in an
Temple in Shaanxi Province (cat. 125), as well as unbroken line from its ancient roots. Chinese
stone carvings from a Song dynasty temple site in culture is also remarkable in the degree to which
Shaanxi Province (cat. 177), and Song, Yuan, Ming, cultural differences, born of time and vast distance,
and Qing dynasty paintings from the collections of interpenetrated and catalyzed the development of a
the Shanghai Museum and the Palace Museum in coherent and enduring Chinese culture. Like a
Beijing. Some of these national treasures of long- mighty and luxuriant tree, China stands tall in the
standing fame are being exhibited abroad for the forest of the world's peoples, surviving and thriving
first time. I may therefore say without exaggeration through five thousand years of winds and rains, a
that, for quality, size, comprehensiveness, and remarkable history that may not be well known in
cultural relics. This is truly a magnificent show, and In this exhibition one can see about thirty bronzes
those who see it will have reason to rejoice. from the Xia, Shang, and Zhou periods (21st-
conditions, art, which expresses as well as nourishes and diversity was occasioned not only by passage
the essence of the human spirit, often epitomizes of time and change of dynasties but also by
the starting and end-points of human development. differences in region and ethnicity. This richness
It transcends the limitations of era, country, and and diversity testifies to continuous progress in
ethnicity, brings together all the dignity and pride social productivity, social structure, and social
of the human race, and demonstrates that most consciousness in Bronze Age China. Diversity of
precious wisdom and capacity inherently possessed form and technique, however, was subsumed in a
by people. Hence, works of art can reflect the commonality of function: the bronzes of this period
continuity and variation of a cultural tradition, the all served as utensils for rituals and ceremonials
internal meaning and outward manifestations of an (such as sacrifices and banquets) and as symbols of
era, and the internal character and spiritual qualities the social status of their users.
of a people. They do so in the profoundest and
most diverse ways, from a wealth of perspectives, So too with other types of artworks from other
and through the freshest and liveliest forms. For this periods of Chinese history; interpenetration and
reason, works of art can also easily overcome the continuity became a basic phenomenon of Chinese
constraints of time and space to communicate cultural development. Such cultural intermingling
knowledge and friendship between people of and merging demonstrate the influence and
INTRODUCTION 18
absorptive power of the orthodox culture, which
was primarily that of the majority Han people
(as well as of their predecessors, the Huaxia people).
It reflects the stability of that culture, as well as the
and abilities.
INTRODUCTION 19
Introduction and
Acknowledgments
Thomas Krens
The Solomon R.
Director,
Guggenheim Foundation
China: 5, 000 Years explores innovation
and technologically innovative art for a longer peri- ously and systematically until after the founding of
od of time, and at a higher level of sophistication, the People's Republic of China. During the nearly
than any other civilization in history. This exhibi- five decades since then, the pace of discovery has
tion, which is designed to confirm that assertion, quickened from a trickle to a deluge of new finds, a
results from the timely convergence of two distinct logical outcome of the surging economic develop-
factors: a wealth of newly excavated objects and ment that required the digging of foundations for
artifacts of stunning beauty and significance, and an new factories, houses, office buildings, roads, air-
increased appreciation in China of cultural achieve- ports, and power facilities. China has now become
ments of the twentieth century. As a consequence, the scene of more archaeological activity than any-
the juxtaposition of modern Chinese art with its where else in the world, and the discoveries have
traditional counterpart in an exhibition mounted added immensely to our existing knowledge in
by a major Western museum has been made possi- some areas, while opening entirely new chapters in
ble for the first time ever. others. The discovery, conservation, and analysis of
these objects and artifacts will, of course, continue,
The major exhibitions of art from Taiwan that have and a definitive cultural history remains to be writ-
been staged in recent years have encouraged a pop- ten. But China: 5,oooYears, which draws heavily on
ular perception that works of comparable quality these new resources and discusses them in a schol-
do not exist today in China. It is important to arly context within this exhibition catalogue, has
stress, first of all, that significant portions of the for- become an active participant in that process.
ten thousand premodern paintings and pieces of museums throughout the People's Republic of
calligraphy. Second, major collections remained in China, as well as the discoveries that haw come to
private hands, and many of these works subsequent- light in the last fifty years, to present an expanded
ly entered public collections in Shanghai (where vision of Chinese culture. Professor Sherman Lee is
approximately six thousand scrolls are located), the chief architect of this enterprise. 1 lis lifetime
Nanjing (about fifteen hundred scrolls), and other commitment to the art of China, his extraordinary
large and small museums throughout the country. professional career which included twenty-six
Finally, large-scale artworks, such as stone sculpture, years as Director of the Cleveland Museum of Ait.
which could not be readily removed, remained in where he built one of the great collections oi
numerous religious and secular contexts. Chinese antiquities and his reputation .is
unlike that of Greece or Rome, was preserved mulate an exquisite sensitivity toward and under-
beneath rather than on the surface of the ground, standing of Chinese art history. Professoi 1 ee's
due to the long-standing practice of burying art- insights, which are reflected in his selection >'t
works with the deceased. The clandestine opening objects for this exhibition, include the dynamic
of tombs began as early as the time of Confucius, in relationships that existed between the earl) Chinese
the fifth century bce, and bronzes and jades so and the spiritual, natural, and cosmological worlds
gathered formed part of the imperial collection in in which the) lived, lie also emphasizes an aggres-
later centuries. But formal archaeological excava- sively innovative and transformative impulse
tions were virtually unknown in ('lima before the rather than a reliance on tradition as the enduring
present century, and were not conducted continu- achievemeni of Chinese art, and he gives an
Professor Lee's numerous trips to China over the The late nineteenth to early twentieth centuries
past four years. During these visits, he traveled brought a certain cultural cross-fertilization
throughout the country to provincial museums and between China and Europe. Just as European artists
archaeological excavations, as well as to the great were influenced by Asian block-printing tech-
collections in Beijing and Shanghai. He searched niques, perspectival flatness, and decorative tenden-
through warehouses of recently excavated material cies, for example, Chinese artists were drawn to
and considered well-known objects currently on Western approaches, methodologies, and tech-
display. The selection of objects he made for this niques, such as Impressionism, abstraction, realistic
exhibition reflects his personal vision, and it has a portraiture, and oil painting. The late nineteenth
freshness and a breathtaking elegance that will century in China saw innovations within the tradi-
make scholars and laymen alike feel that they are tional context, which developed under the patron-
seeing Chinese art for the first time. Professor Lee's age of Shanghai's new economic elite. Highlights
vision has been supported by an impressive array of included elaborate works with bird and flower
international scholars, who have provided assistance themes, and paintings based on fantastic narratives,
and consultation on every aspect of the project, which appealed to a new class of collectors in this
including Helmut Brinker, James Cahill, Regina vibrant industrial port city. Chinese art of the early
Krahl, Howard Rogers, and Jenny So, who rendered part of the twentieth century reflected the growing
continuous support and advice on all aspects of the cosmopolitan attitude of Chinese artists, many of
exhibition as it was being planned and on the whom studied abroad. The 1920s saw a re-
structure and rhythm of the installation at the emergence of the woodcut as a powerful artistic
Guggenheim Museum. On the Chinese side, Zhang medium, as art became swept up in the social and
Wenbin, Director General of the National political upheavals that were coursing through
Administration for Cultural Heritage, and Wang China. The inherently stark contrast and imminent
Limei, Director of the Foreign Affairs Office of the reproducibility of woodcuts made this a natural
National Administration for Cultural Heritage, medium for communicating the horrific realities of
structured the lengthy discussions and negotiations the Japanese invasion, and the numerous prints
with the various museums and archaeological exca- reflecting the horrors of war from this period recall
vations that have lent objects to the exhibition. the graphic work of Francisco de Goya in their
They also provided invaluable advice, as did the shocking impact. Postwar communism brought a
directors of the Palace Museum in Beijing and the socialist-realist format that produced some of the
Shanghai Museum, Yang Xin, Ma Chengyuan, and most outstanding examples of realist painting ever
Wang Qingzheng, who not only made their collec- seen. Although Chinese socialist realism was not
tions available, but often suggested improvements to considered by most Western critics, there is no
the checklist that went beyond our expectations. In doubt that painterly technique flourished in the
short, the traditional section of China: 5,oooYears is Chinese academy at a level of extraordinary sophis-
a visionary and collaborative enterprise of unprece- tication, and this laid the foundation for a rejuvena-
dented proportion between Chinese, American, and tion of Chinese art during the past two decades
international scholars. through a blending of traditional, academic, and
international influences. In short, the art of China
The modern section of China: 5,000 Years has no in the twentieth century tells a compelling story,
less an engaging history. As China has modernized which demands to be considered in the context of
and gradually become more accessible to the the long train of Chinese art history, and in the
Western world during the past 150 years, so too has context of an emerging global sensibility.
from which it derives much of its inspiration, or Professor Andrews has been ably assisted in her
from the Western traditions that it also reflects. Its selection by contributions from Kuiyi Shen,
particular fascination will not be found in the Presidential Fellow, The Ohio State University;
degree to which it participated in the development Jonathan Spence, Sterling Professor of History,
of a Euro-American Modernism, but rather in the Yale University; Shan Guolin, Chief Curator of
challenges and contradictions. In its very title, and universities, constituting the single largest body
China: 5,000 Years poses many questions: Can any of foreign students in the United States; more than
single exhibition legitimately explore five half a million American tourists visited China in
thousand years of any culture, let alone one as rich 1996; and fifteen million Americans are of Chinese
as this? Does it make sense to link twentieth- ancestry. His Excellency Jiang Zemin, President of
century Chinese culture with forty-nine centuries the People's Republic of China, visited the United
of "traditional" culture? Is the Guggenheim States last October, and the Honorable Bill Clinton,
Museum with its collections and expertise firmly President of the United States, is planning a state
rooted in twentieth-century Western art a legiti- visit to China later this year. The growing need for
mate organizer of such an event? How does the China and the United States to accommodate one
narrative thread of this exhibition relate to the his- another has created a simultaneous demand for
tory of Chinese art as it is understood through the cultural engagement, and this was the major pre-
weight of scholarship on Chinese history and art to condition for the motivation, the will, and the
date, and through the Chinese objects exhibited opportunities on both sides required to conceive
and studied in museums in Taiwan, Europe, and of and organize this exhibition.
inevitably be found in the exhibition itself. The On a more local level, another major precondition
importance of China: 5,000 Years will be a function for the exhibition was the nature of the evolving
of its ability to present a fresh, incredibly rich, and direction and focus of the Guggenheim Museum
provocative new chapter to the study of the cultural itself. During the past ten years, the Guggenheim
history of China. has experienced a significant transformation. With
the renovation of its original Frank 1 loyd Wright
The story of the genesis and development of building, the construction of a new addition, and
China: $,oooYcars as an exhibition project is itself an the establishment of the Guggenheim Museum
extraordinary tale. That it is organized by, and S0H0 in 1992, the Guggenheim Foundation broad
shown in, the Guggenheim Museums in New York ened its physical and programming base and estab
derives from a specific sequence of conditions and lished a strong position in New York City, or
circumstances favorable to such an enterprise, and the greatest cultural capitals 111 the world. This local
committed to China and to fostering international Guggenheim Collection in Venice, and In the dra-
understanding through cultural communication. matic completion and opening of the Guggenheim
The initial impulse for the project its primary Museum Bilbao, a building designed by Frank
motivation derives from the simple fact that Gehry that mam critics are saying will take its
China is a country of deep traditions, extraordinary place alongside the Frank I loyd Wright designed
achievement, startling paradoxes, and enormous Gueeenheim in New York as one ol the two
The Guggenheim is becoming a truly international reflected Japanese culture and traditions, in a vocab-
museum not only in terms of buildings and loca- ulary that was simultaneously recognizable and
tions, but also through an equally intense commit- original. Various commentaries on the exhibition
ment to expanding its programming, reflected both noted the "Japaneseness" of the material, and
in the growth of its permanent collection and in pointed out that this was an art that had been
the breadth and depth of its special exhibitions. consistently ignored or overlooked by Western
The original mission of the museum was to collect, museums. For the Guggenheim, the project was
preserve, and present the art of the Modern and exhilarating. The task was to understand the
contemporary periods. Nine superlative curators narrative of postwar Japanese art not only as a
from three countries have dramatically expanded reflection of its immediate sociohistorical context,
the scope of programming, with major but also in relation to the some three thousand
monographic exhibitions devoted to, among years of cultural history that preceded it.
Oldenburg, and Robert Rauschenberg; important By late 1994, the stars were almost in alignment for
historical exhibitions such as Tlie Great Utopia: China: 5, 000 Years to become a reality. The skeletal
The Russian and Soviet Avant-Garde, igi5-igj2, The framework of the global Guggenheim and the
Italian Metamorphosis, ig43~ig68, Picasso and the Age exhibition-organizing engine were largely in
of Iron, and Africa:The Art of a Continent; and place. The concept of a far-reaching exhibition pro-
smaller, focused exhibitions such as Max Beckmann gram that included, every few years, an exhibition
in Exile, Visions of Paris: Robert Delaunay's Series, and challenging the conventional direction of the
Rrose is a Rrose is a Rrose: Gender Performance in Guggenheim while taking advantage of its scholarly
Photography. In the process of developing these criteria and organizational capacities was approved
projects, the Guggenheim has become a major pro- by the Board of Trustees. All that remained was to
ducer of exhibitions. A measure of its success is connect the source of the vision for China: 3,000
reflected in the fact that, during the past five years, Years with the curatorial expertise to bring it to life.
Guggenheim-organized exhibitions have been pre- That connection was provided by Sherman Lee.
sented in more than eighty museums around the More than twenty-five years ago, in 1969, as an
world, from Bilbao to Shanghai, from Los Angeles undergraduate economics and political-science
to Munich, and from Singapore to Vienna. major at Williams College, I took my first art-
Guggenheim recognizes that culture in the twenti- there was never any doubt in my mind that
eth and twenty-first centuries cannot be treated as a Professor Lee was the only person to provide the
Western-oriented, Euro-American hegemony. bold and unique vision to select it. Happily, several
Museums in particular cannot maintain a high weeks after I presented the general thesis of an
regard for classical and antique cultures from exhibition of five millennia of Chinese art drawn
around the world while remaining skeptical about exclusively from material in China to him,
the contemporary art of non-Western traditions. Professor Lee agreed to head the curatorial team
That a new postmodern, multifaceted, multilingual for the traditional section.
increasingly interconnected and Internet-linked The next step was to secure the participation and
world is a fact that cannot be ignored. Africa, Asia, cooperation of the Chinese. In the autumn of
and South America all sustain vibrant contempo- 1994, the Honorable Gianni De Michelis, former
rary cultures that a global museum must engage. Foreign Minister of Italy and Guggenheim trustee,
The Guggenheim's aspirations as an international helped arrange a meeting with the Honorable
museum are viable only to the degree that a broad- Qian Qichen,Vice Premier and Foreign Minister
based international program comes into place. The of the People's Republic of China. Our mission
museum buildings for all their architectural bril- was simple: to seek an unprecedented collaboration
liance and geographic diversity are only a point of with the Chinese government by presenting the
departure. objectives of China: 3, 000 Years with reference to its
History, Brussels; Jenny So, Curator of Ancient of organizing the specifics of the exhibition in
Chinese Art, Freer Gallery of Art and Arthur M. particular, arranging loans from the many lending
Sackler Gallery, Smithsonian Institution, institutions fell to the Ministry of Culture of the
Washington, D.C.; Peter Sturman, Associate People's Republic of China and, for the traditional
Professor, Department of the History of Art and section, the National Administration for Cultural
Architecture, University of California, Santa Heritage. At the Ministry of Culture, I would like
In addition, the National Administration for providing direction and focus. With particular
Cultural Heritage of the People's Republic of respect and friendship, we would like to single out
China, our partner in the organization of the Zhang Wenbin and Wang Limei at the National
traditional section of China: 5,000 Years, provided Administration for Cultural Heritage, without
scholarly assistance at all levels of the planning and whose professional and steadfast leadership, this
development of the exhibition. Zhang Wenbin complicated and far-reaching exhibition would
assembled an impressive team of support for the never have come to fruition. This exhibition would
project, including the following prominent scholars also not be possible without the support ot
and high-level museum professionals who Lei Congyun, Director of Art Exhibitions China,
contributed essays to this catalogue: Su Bai, and Yang Yang, Deputy Director of Art
Professor, Beijing University; Yu Weichao, Director Exhibitions China, who oversaw all the logistical
of the National Museum of Chinese History, and organizational details, in addition to research
Beijing; Ma Chengyuan, Director of the Shanghai responsibilities. We are also indebted to the team
Museum; Wang Qingzheng, Deputy Director of the of specialists who accompanied the artworks from
Shanghai Museum; and Liu Jiu'an, Researcher, China for their installation in New York; Shan
Palace Museum, Beijing. Yang Yang, Yin Jia, Zhang Guolin of the Shanghai Museum: Feng Xiaoqi ot
Jianxin, Qian Wei, and Chen Shujie of Art the Palace Museum. Beijing: and Chen Shujie ot
Exhibitions China; Lu Chenglong and Xu Qixi.in Art Exhibitions China. Our very special thanks go
of the Palace Museum; Wang Changqi and to Hu Chui, photographer at the Palace Museum,
Gao Man of the Institute for the Protection of who spent many days and even months traveling
Cultural Relics and Archaeology, Xi'an; Li Xuefang around China, applying Ins art 10 the task ol
of the Forest of Steles Museum, Xi'an; and Han photographing the objects in the exhibition.
Jianwu of the Shaan.xi History Museum, Xi'an. also The beautiful plates in this catalogue are testimony
provided important scholarly contributions and to his uncompromising eye for quality and detail.
research for this exhibition. June Mei skillfully We will provide our extended thanks to the team
Hao Zhan, Director, and Wan Jiyuan, Li Li, and Zhang, who impressively managed the
I would also like to express my gratitude to Gianni research and organizational support, formed the
De Michelis for his inspiration and generosity, and hub of the exhibition, holding together the
for nurturing this project at its inception and project's many varied spokes. Our thanks are due
remaining a strong supporter and advisor. Ji also to Frances Yuan, Eileen Hsu, and Andrew
Chaozhu and Simon Jiang also must be thanked for Leung, who provided research for the didactic
their support. material, and to our interns Patty Chang, Shihong
Aldin, Jackie Chien, Simon Murphy, and Katherine
One of the astonishing aspects of this exhibition is Cheng for their tireless efforts and their valuable
the large number of lenders from all over China contribution to the complicated administration of
who recognized its historic importance and this multifaceted project. Suzanne Quigley, Head
contributed to its success by allowing precious Registrar for Collections and Exhibitions; Mary
works from their collections to travel to the Jane Clark, Project Registrar; and Joan Hendricks,
exhibition venues. A separate page is devoted to a Associate Registrar, professionally handled the
list of our lenders thirty-nine in total in the logistics of the international transportation of the
traditional section of China: 3,000 Years but I objects. A highly skilled staft of conservators,
would like to take this opportunity to offer them including Project Conservator Tracy Power of the
our deepest gratitude for their enormous generosity Asian Art Museum of San Francisco; Gillian
and cooperation, without which this exhibition McMillan, Senior Conservator (Collections);
would not have been possible. Carol Stringari, Senior Conservator (Exhibitions);
Eleanora Nagy, Assistant Conservator; and Ellen
In the United States, there were also a large Pratt, Project Conservator, oversaw the care and
number of people without whom we would not condition of the precious objects in the exhibition
have been able to bring this exhibition to fruition. at every stage of the project. The exhibition design
It has been a privilege and an honor to work with is the work of Arata Isozaki and Adegboyega
Sherman Lee on this project. A deep debt of Adetope. The Art Services and Preparations
gratitude is owed to him, and also to his wife, department lent their considerable expertise to the
Ruth, who accompanied Professor Lee on his many installation of the exhibition. In particular, I wish to
visits to China in preparation tor this exhibition. thank Karen Meyerhoft, Director of Exhibition and
I would also like to thank Howard Rogers, who Collection Management and Design; Scott Wixon,
served as consulting curator and as general editor of Manager of Art Services and Preparations; Peter
this catalogue. Having worked closely with Read, Manager of Exhibition Fabrication and
Professor Lee over a period of many years, he has a Design; Jocelyn Brayshaw, Acting Chief Preparator;
deep appreciation and sensitive understanding of Liz Jaff, Assistant Paper Preparator; Joseph Adams,
Professor Lee's vision. His own formidable grasp of Museum Technician; Richard Gombar.
Senior
all aspects of Chinese art is the result of more than Museum Technician; Mary Ann Hoag, Lighting
thirty years of involvement in the field, including Designer; and Jocelyn Groom, Exhibition Design
eighteen years as a professor of Chinese art history Coordinator. David Horak also provided invaluable
at Sophia University, Tokyo. Howard Rogers's wife, assistance with the installation. Len Steinbach,
Mary Ann, herself an expert in Chinese art, was Director of Information Technology, provided
also ever generous in her support. David constant support for the many sophisticated
Sensabaugh, Ann Wardwell, Pat Berger, and Jan technical requirements of a dual-language database.
Berris also provided important advice. I would also like to thank Marilyn Goodman,
Director of Education, and Diane Maas, Education
At the Guggenheim, Jane DeBevoise, Director of Program Manager, who developed an outstanding
the China Exhibition Project, assisted by Manon education program; Rosemarie Garipoli, Deputy
Slome, Project Assistant Curator, oversaw all aspects Director for External Affairs, and George McNeely,
of the exhibition planning, coordination, and Director of Institutional Development; Ruth Taylor,
execution, from checklist and loan negotiation to Director of Budget and Planning; and Jay A.
installation planning and design, as well as catalogue Levenson, former Deputy Director for Program
development and execution. With considerable Administration, who steered the project at its early
managerial expertise, indefatigable energy, true team stages. Patrick Seymour of Tsang Seymour Design,
leadership, and impressive facility with the Chinese together with Marcia Fardella, Graphic Designer,
language, Jane DeBevoise ably moved each stage of Susan Lee, Assistant Graphic Designer, and Jessica
the project toward completion. Manon Slome Ludwig at the Guggenheim, produced the
coordinated the myriad details of the exhibition exhibition's many graphic-design elements with
planning and design with intelligence and sensitivity and expertise.
Ammirati, Editorial Assistant, as well as Keith As I complete these remarks in a Tokyo hotel
Mayerson and Nicole Columbus. room, I look at the scroll of calligraphy that hangs
in the tokunoma alcove ot my room. A Japanese
An exhibition of this scale could never take place friend tells me that it was created by a nineteenth-
without the generous support of our sponsors. century Japanese artist whose style was based on
First, I would like to thank Lufthansa for the that of a seventeenth-century calligrapher named
ongoing commitment and leadership support it has Dong Qichang, whose work is included in China:
shown to the Guggenheim as a Global Partner. 5, ooo Years. The text, "Peach Blossom Spring." by
In particular, I would like to thank Frederick W. the fourth-century Chinese poet Tao Yuanniing.
Reid, Lufthansa German Airlines's President and speaks of the peace and contentment that become
Chief Operating Officer, and Josef Grendel. possible on removal from the temporal world, just
Lufthansa's Vice President Corporate as the author himself achieved lasting renown by
Communications, for their enlightened generosity. giving up secular ambition in order to cultivate his
We are also very fortunate to have had the soul. My friend then comments that the writing
opportunity to work with Nokia. Their itself seems lacking the confidence expressed In the
international vision and their skill at connecting verbal content, winch leads to this final observa-
people and cultures are deeply impressive. For their tion: the boundaries between Easl and West,
support, I am particularly indebted to Jorma Ollila. between past and present, are truly falling. Artists
President and Chief Executive Officer; Lauri and poets today are no different from their prede-
Kivinen, Senior Vice President Corporate cessors in their willingness to appropriate or reject
Communications; Jim Bowman, Vice President what they need from their own history, from then
Corporate Communications, Nokia Americas; and contemporary context, from outside influences to
Micaela Tucker-Kinney, Manager. Corporate formulate a response to their dilemma. China: 5,000
Communications, Nokia Americas. We are also Years will appeal to experts and scholars. But by far
most grateful to Alex Trotman, Chairman and Chiel the Ingest number of people to see the exhibition
Executive Officer of Ford Motor Company, lor his will be those with only a limited understanding ot'
leadership and commitment to this project. At the culture of this extraordinary country, ["hey are
Ford, we also wish to thank Wayne M. Booker, Vice lice to approach this art from their own pels;-
Chairman; Peter J. Pestillo, Executive Vice rives, to hung themselves into the encounter and
President, Corporate Relations; Gary L. Nielsen, challenge their preconceptions. The process will
Vice President, Ford Motor Company Fund; and challenge them to learn and grow, and the two
Mabel H. Cabot, Director, Corporate countries will move a little closer as a result. It is in
Programming, for their creativity and their this potential thai < hina: $,oooYcars finds us ulti-
DYNASTIC CHINA
28
SUI DYNASTY {589-618}
Xianfeng [851-186]
Tongzhi [862-1874
Gangxu [875 [90J
Xuantong 1909-19I]
29
Introduction
Sherman Lee
Director (retired),
Cleveland Museum of Art
Vast generalities of time and space are
30
varying periods of creativity and stagnation are extended, and border regions pacified, so too is
averaged into a neat and continuous timeline, all of nature tamed and contained in urban hunting
which contributes to the popular image of China parks, which figure significantly in the poetry of
as a monolithic country, fixed in its boundaries and the period as well as in the art. Animals continue to
evolving only slowly over time. be important but now within a context defined bv
purely human concerns.
This exhibition seeks to deconstruct that invariant
image, to demonstrate artistic diversity rather than Among these human concerns are ideas about
unity and to identify periods of heightened activity religion, expressed in Buddhist and Daoist thought
and creativity in the arts. These pieces, which will and imagery that comes to dominate art in the Six
delight their audience by aesthetic merit, were Dynasties-Tang era. As the foreign styles associated
carefully chosen to emphasize the themes of with Buddhism are gradually assimilated and
innovation and transformation: the conceptual Sinihed, the human figure continues to dominate
innovations that led artists to shift focus from the its pictorial environment. The fantastical creatures
supernatural to the human world, then to the of the past survive as decorative forms rather than
natural world, and thereafter to adopt elements as embodiments of awesome powers. At the same
from all these worlds as vehicles of self-expression; time a growing interest in landscape for its own
and the technological inventions and discoveries sake becomes apparent alongside the dominant
that occurred as artists sought the most appropriate figural tradition.
Early Chinese art manifests in form and decoration technical evolution can be traced from the linearitv
a fascinating world of imaginary beasts, demons, of early incised, inlaid, and painted designs to the
chimeras, and grotesques. These may have more complex spatial representations of the later
originated in real creatures, whose forms were then Tang era; conceptually it is the final stage and
abstracted, commingled, and otherwise transformed beneficiary of the supernatural- and human-
into complex animal images. These images are not centered worlds described above. In this aesthetic
merely decorative; the major elements must have culmination, which occurred in China centuries
embodied meanings, whether as totems, clan earlier than elsewhere in the world, natural forces
insignia, or other consequential signifiers.This early, which had earlier been describable only as
animistic art is essentially static; the designs delimited and isolated forms, are fully encompassed
covering the bronze ritual vessels imply no by the human mind and described in integrated
potential for movement. landscapes that are monumental in scale and
freighted with symbolic meanings.
appearance of the human world and of potential Another way of approaching the art and culture of
movement. Recognizable animals are placed in early China is by considering the continuous series
comparatively realistic environments. The animals of technical innovations occurring in the various
and landscape are still not interconnected as a mediums used by early artists. It was William
scene, but the animals now appear capable ot switt Willetts, in his Chinese Art of [958, who first
is freed. On lacquers and incised bronze tubes of of Chinese art. Willetts 's focus on technology
the late Zhou-Han period even the mountain created .1 particularly useful framework for the
peaks, cliffs, foliage, and "cloud patterns" pulsate study of such "decorative" or "useful" or "minor"
with life. We see here the first signs of an interest in arts as jades, bronzes, lacquers, textiles, and ceramics
representing real landscape in the arts. ,is well as sculpture and painting.
The Qin-Han era, however, is predominantly the Worked jades fust appear in the Liangzhu and
world of humankind. Beginning with the lite-size I [ongshan Neolithic cultures, demonstrating at that
and startlingly lifelike Qin military figures, human early period already advanced techniques for
scale and a human point of view come to dominate shaping this most recalcitrant material. I he lorms
much subsequent art. Given the epochal and designs of the earliest jades the pig-dragons
importance of this shift, it seems appropriate that and in.isks doubtless held potent meanings foi
the English name "China" derives from the name theii contemporaries, notwithstanding our inability
of the first of the imperial dynasties, the Qin. And to interpret them. Eventually these formal and
just as the frontiers of the empire .ire gradually hieratic patterns give wa) 10 ever more intricate
designs, and many centuries later jade working substance of their living relations. Upper-class
became and remained a purely decorative art. tombs were abundantly furnished with realistic
Bronze casting, which begins during the Xia and humans that constituted the material world
Shang dynasties and flourishes into the Han, perhaps idealized of the living. These lively and
follows a similar sequence, in which great early closely observed tomb figurines, created to
invention and ingenuity in support of meaningful accompany and serve the dead, represent the broad
iconography are gradually superseded by technical and complex world of the living and are material
mediocrity and decorative repetition. The use of evidence of society over a significant period ol
ceramic piece-molds, which permit shape and time. The burial furniture and figurines manifest
surface decoration to be created simultaneously, is artistic creativity, but at the same time their vast
the distinguishing feature of Chinese bronze numbers attest to virtual mass production, with
technology, and had reached a stage of enormous great technical skill and high standards of quality.
complexity and brilliant virtuosity by the Anyang The alert and natural figures of animals and humans
phase of the Shang dynasty. The vessels cast in these provide us with a visual image of their world far
piece-molds testify to the early Chinese interest in more vivid than the descriptions by historians of
vessels bear inscriptions that constitute important century CE and its enthusiastic acceptance in the
historical documents, and by the end of the Zhou succeeding centuries brought with it a great figural
these same forms were embellished with the style of image making as it had developed in India
precious metals and gemstones that enhanced their and had been transformed as it moved eastward.
new function as visual markers of social and The Chinese adapted it rapidly and creatively in all
Lacquer as a protective and decorative coating is in varied in nature, with strong provincial styles being
origin Chinese and is known to have been used created during the fifth and sixth centuries in
very early on, although the first extensive remains Shanxi, Shaanxi, Shandong, Yunnan, and Sichuan.
date from the Warring States era of the late Zhou By the beginning of the seventh century, in the Sui
dynasty. Painted and incised lacquer designs of that and early Tang dynasty, a national Chinese style was
period relate stylistically to contemporaneous emerging. Ultimately this became a truly
textile and bronze designs. In later centuries international style, prevalent throughout East Asia.
lacquer-working techniques became more
complex; forms and designs were molded using a In general, the Chinese intellectual and cultural
variety of techniques, then carved and/or inlaid elite placed little aesthetic value on the sculptor's
with various precious materials. These manifold art, especially that in stone. But the protean artisan
techniques as well as cultivation of the lac tree itself image-makers have left a large body of work that
spread to Korea, Japan, and Okinawa, and those begins in the early Six Dynasties with images
cultures continue to benefit from this Chinese imbued with great energy and movement and
innovation. develops by the Tang dynasty into figures ot
worldly and splendid elegance. The sensuous and
Silk manufacture too was an early Chinese rounded volumes of Tang sculptures correspond to
invention, one that had an even more complex the fashions of female court beauties as revealed in
development and greater impact on the larger the early scroll paintings, seen in this exhibition in
world, spreading to the West during Hellenistic and photographic reproductions of contemporaneous
early Christian times. Paper and printing, appearing wall murals. This is the first exhibition from China
in this exhibition in the form of early paintings and to feature stone Buddhist sculptures in significant
block-printed books, are even more famous numbers.
examples of Chinese inventions that were
instrumental in shaping Asian and European Among Chinese contributions to world culture, it
INTRODUCTION
development of various types of body and glaze the past, painters created new pictorial structures
and styles of decoration, each reflecting the united by innovative grammars. At its best, this
technology and the ethos of its time and its intensely art-historical later painting drew ever-
particular patrons. renewing vitality from the singular vision of each
of its practitioners. But as printed books in the
An almost equally long-lived and practical art is exhibition demonstrate, complex styles could be
calligraphy, which in China had a double nature. Its analyzed, broken down into their constituent parts;
practical uses are readily apparent in the West. But these in turn were often made the hill substance of
in China calligraphy was not simply a tool for later paintings. Such a concentration on details and
recording; it was the premier art, the badge of on technical features like brushwork ultimately had
rulers and officials, landowners and literati. In an adverse affect on the pictorial tradition. A similar
China, unlike the Near Eastern and European emphasis on technology rather than creativity-
empires and kingdoms, writing calligraphy was a overtook later Qing dynasty jades, lacquers,
key or pass to greatness and station. The proper porcelains, and textiles, and this tendency
manipulation of ink with brush was the most constitutes one of the greatest challenges
respected of accomplishments, held to reveal the bequeathed by late dynastic artists to their
discipline, and criteria of excellence, evolved during The reader will by now be aware that this is an
four thousand years of continuous development. exhibition which stresses the art of an ancient
Even without access to the literary meanings, culture with particular relation to innovation and
philosophical assumptions and implications, and creativity. It is not meant to emphasize the
long stylistic history, we in the West may still sense historical, sociological, ethnographical, or literary
the kinesthetic accomplishment of the brush aspects of Chinese culture. But so compelling are
moving across paper or silk. the achievements ot these artists and artisans that
It underlay both calligraphy and painting, the twin constraints, its social obligations and expectations,
insignia of the civil and civilized life as distinct its moral compulsions and freedoms, its aesthetic
from its correlative opposite, the military or preferences and boundaries. These works appear
physical life. It is noteworthy too that, in a society before us as tangible witnesses to China's cultural
33
INTRODUCTION
1/ w
ij>
""ft*'"*-* ':
>t
Some Elements in the
Intellectual and
Religious Context of
Chinese Art
Patricia Ebrey
Professor, Department of History,
University of Washington
As with the art of any other great
36
Some of the most important of these ideas the context of Buddhist teachings. In this chapter I
appeared early and persisted for centuries; most shall take a broader view and try to relate the larger
were altered in major ways over time; some died contours of the history of Chinese art to the larger
out or were supplanted; others coexisted with contours of Chinese religious and intellectual
opposing but equally entrenched ideas. history. I will do this by examining four complexes
of ideas that have particular bearing on Chinese
The relationship between art and these diverse art ideas about rulers, mountains, writing, and
ideas is just as complex. Religious and philosophical icons. I selected these four not because they make a
traditions provided the occasions for creating many nice Chinese-sounding set of "The Four Sacred
objects later treasured as art. The finest examples of Things," but because they let me get at some key
jade, bronze, silk, and ceramics were frequently tensions and contradictions in the layered traditions
made to be used in religious rituals. These traditions of Chinese religious and intellectual thought. Other
also provided a significant share of the imagery of ideas, ones associated for instance with the sage,
Chinese art: phoenixes, dragons, cicadas, birds, and vital force, the cosmos, paradise, flowers, fate,
other creatures of cosmological significance are emotions, and so on, could have been added or
common decorative motifs; sages, filial sons, substituted. But the four discussed here are diverse
Buddhas, bodhisattvas, immortals, demons, and gods enough toshow something of the dynamics of a
are frequent subjects of figure painting and cultural framework in which inconsistent, even
sculpture. Chinese discourses on aesthetics, personal contradictory, ideas interacted in fruitful ways. '
In
refinement, and the value of the past all influenced ordinary social life, the coexistence of ideas in some
which objects would be treasured and preserved. way opposed to each other gives people room to
Placing higher value on a sample ot handwriting think for themselves and to maneuver against
than on a finely crafted chair, for instance, owes others for personal advantage; in the sphere of art it
much to Confucian and Daoist ideas about self- gives artists and patrons the freedom to pick and
cultivation. But certainly it is not always the case choose elements that suit their moods or purposes
that the ideas are prior and the art an expression or as well as to refashion them into something new.
reflection of them; meanings can be created and When their work is most creative, it provokes the
conveyed through objects independently of words rethinking of basic notions, thus altering the
and texts. Sometimes it is the textual version that is intellectual traditions from which they drew.
the reflection or rationalization of meanings created Although we may feel strongly the urge to look for
by the deployment or decoration of objects. For key principles that bring clarity to the apparent
example, most Chinese explanations of the meaning untidiness of Chinese culture, in my view we
of objects buried with the dead probably should be actually gain a deeper understanding it we resist
and Helmut Brinker places Buddhist sculpture in was either made for kingly use or influenced by
exquisite objects from the tombs of the royal a dissolute, sadistic king who had lost Heaven's
consort Fu Hao, the marquis ofYi, the king of favor and the Zhou conquerors as just and noble
Zhongshan, and the First Emperor of Qin are the warriors who had gained it. Kingly tendencies
most obvious examples of this. Even art not from toward ostentation were judged harshly. The charges
royal tombs owes much to the technical advances against the last king of the Shang included spending
made by artists and artisans in the employ of rulers too much on his personal enjoyment, taking
who demanded objects of the highest possible resources from the people to build "palaces, towers,
quality and who could provide the material pavilions, embankments, ponds, and all other
2
resources required. That rulers had resources at their extravagances"; kings were not, however, criticized
disposal is probably best explained in terms of for commissioning lavishly decorated bronze vessels
political and economic history. But the way they for use in sacrifices or for burial in graves, since
chose to use those resources has much to do with that was done for the ancestors.
conceptions of kingship.
To the contrary, bronze sacrificial vessels remained
The notion that properly there is only one supreme an important symbol of lordship. Many early Zhou
ruler goes very far back in Chinese history. In the vessels bear inscriptions showing they were
late Shang known from the excavations at Anyang presented by the king to a lord to accompany the
(ca. 1200 I too bce), the king referred to himself as granting of a fief. A myth grew up about the
'"The One Man" or "The Unique One," and seems "nine tripods" created by the founders of the Xia
to have operated on the assumption that he could dynasty. These tripods symbolically united the
command the obedience of everyone in the realm. realm, as they were made of metal from the various
Above him, however, were powerful spirits, regions and decorated with images of animals
especially his own ancestors. He was the from all over. They also were attuned to Heaven.
intermediary between humankind and these When the ruler's virtue was commendable and
celestial powers, whom he served through sacrifices brilliant, the tripods would be heavy though small,
of animals and even human beings. In the most but when the ruler lacked virtue, they would be
important cults the king acted as the head priest, light even though large. When the Xia dynasty
making the sacrifices and pronouncing the prayers. ended, it was believed, the tripods passed like royal
He expended much of the wealth at his disposal on regalia to the Shang rulers, then centuries later to
performance of the king. If he neglected his sacred aggressive, heavy-handed, vainglorious rulers of the
duties and acted tyrannically, Heaven would display states of his day. The true king would honor the
its disfavor by sending down ominous portents and ancient ways and rule through ritual (//) and moral
natural disasters. If the king failed to heed such force (rfe). He would not overburden his people to
warnings, political and social disorder would ensue, satisfy his own greedy desires for ostentatious
signaling that Heaven had withdrawn its mandate. display or incessant conquest. "If a ruler himself is
upright, all will go well even though he does not Confucius and his followers elevated the ruler by
issue orders. But if he himself is not upright, even placing him firmly at the top of a moral hierarchy
though he gives orders, they will not be obeyed" in which all rulers and subjects, nobles and
(Analects, 13.6). "Were a true king to appear, within commoners, parents and children wholeheartedly
a generation goodness would prevail" (Analects, devote themselves to fulfilling the parts assigned to
ancestors would cause harm to those who failed to mostly his. Mencius (ca. 370ca. 300 bce) once told
perform the sacrifices to them properly; he himself a king that if a ruler were to appear who was not
is said to have performed sacrifices "as though" the inclined toward killing people, "The people would
spirits were present. Later followers like Xunzi flow toward him the way water flows down. No
(ca. 310-ca. 220 bce) explicitly denied any link one would be able to stop them" (1A.6). On
between the performance of rites and the action of another occasion he told a king that if he treated
spirits or gods. Xunzi argued that Heaven is his people well by reducing taxes and lightening
impartial and human affairs result from human punishments, they would be so eager to fight for
efforts. Praying to Heaven or to gods does not get him that even if armed only with sharpened sticks
responded to the beauty of well-choreographed As texts recording the teachings of Confucius and
ceremonies combining instrumental music, song, his followers began to circulate in the late Zhou,
and dance. But their intellectual argument, they helped freeze the Confucian position and also
addressed to rulers, concerned the nearly magical invited counter-arguments. A few thinkers
way in which ritual can create social and political generally ones labeled Daoist went further than
harmony. Confucius told his disciple Yan Hui that the Confucians in urging rulers to do less. The
"the whole world would respond to the true Laozi said, "The sage manages affairs by doing
goodness of one who could for one day restrain nothing and spreads the teachings that are not put
himself and return to ritual" (Analects, 12. 1). Ritual, in words." The more a ruler does, the worse the
to Confucius, was not restricted to dealings with result: the more laws and regulations, the more
ancestors or deities: it was also an aspect of the way thieves and robbers. The sage ruler "ensures that the
the ruler dealt with his subjects. "Lead the people people know nothing and desire nothing." 4
have no sense of shame. Lead them by means of were calls for action. Mozi (ca. 490-ca. 403 bce)
virtue and regulate them through rituals and they proposed strengthening the ability of rulers to
will have a sense of shame and moreover have command obedience. He argued that unless one
standards" (Analects, 2.3). man was elevated above all others, there would be
no final authority and everyone would have Ins
Xunzi went much further than Confucius in own opinion, making any sort of cooperation or
emphasizing the connection between ritual and social organization impossible. The solution was for
distinctions of rank. The funerals of rulers had to be everyone to agree with those above including the
on a scale corresponding to their rank in every ruler, who must conform to Heaven: "What the
detail the numbers of inner and outer coffins, the superior thinks right, all shall think right."The text
quality and quantity of burial clothes and food attributed to Guanzi (traditional dates 683-642 BCE)
offerings, the length of the interval between death agreed that the peace and stability of the state
and burial. In ancestral rites, the highest ruler, depend on elevating the ruler. But Guanzi drew
presiding over the entire realm, had to offer attention to the need for coercion. What secured
numerous types of food and wine to seven the ruler's control was his power "to grant life, to
generations of ancestors, but a ruler of a single state kill, to enrich, to impoverish, to ennoble, to debase"
should make fewer offerings to only five Even if the ruler's personal conduct was not
generations, and so on. Rulers must perform these superior, given these powers, all would accept his
rituals correctly, not because they need the aid or leadership and "not dare to indulge 111 opinions
fear the wrath of the dead, but in order to about the quality of his conduct."
demonstrate their filial gratitude and respect for
tradition, and to show that they accept their place Ihe leading Legalist thinkers would largely have
in the political hierarchy. agreed with these sentiments. In the book ascribed
d. 338 bce) urged the ruler not to hesitate to to the four corners of the universe and to live in
8
institute changes in his efforts to strengthen his perfect unity with everything in the cosmos.
people create laws while ignorant ones are smaller states (such as Zhongshan, prominent in the
controlled by them; the worthy alter the rites while exhibition) were eliminated by their larger
the unworthy are held fast by them." Law to him neighbors, the competition between the surviving
was the sovereigns will, carefully codified and states became even more intense. The state of Qin
impartially applied. systematically eliminated the hereditary lords of the
Han Feizi (d. 233 bce), author of the fullest unprecedented concentration of resources in the
exposition of Legalist thought, argued that the hands of a single ruler, the king of Qin. Legalist
Confucian notion of ruling through virtue rather ideology insists on rationality and efficiency as the
than force was based on a faulty analogy with the means to achieve and exercise authority; there is no
family. "A mother loves her son twice as much as a implication in the writings of Lord Shang or Han
father does, but a fathers orders are ten times more Feizi that the ruler would be wise to spend freely
effective than a mother's." Moreover, the common on luxuries in order to impress his subjects with his
people have about as much understanding of what power. But Legalist ideology does not explicitly
is good for them as infants who when their
scream urge austerity on the ruler, or indeed set limits of
loving mothers lance their boils. The ruler who any sort on his actions, and the man to oversee the
taxes the people to fill granaries against times of unification of China by Legalist means, the First
famine or war should ignore their protests the way Emperor of Qin (Qin Shihuangdi, r. 246210 bce)
the mother ignores the baby's wails. Rulers should (see cats. 88-92) did not set many limits on himself.
even be wary of the advice of their top ministers. Drawing together the resources of All-Under-
Given subordinates' propensities to pursue then- Heaven made possible enormous construction
own selfish interests, the ruler cannot afford to be projects. Although he already had several hundred
candid or warm toward any of them. Rather he palaces and scenic towers, in 212 the emperor
should keep them in awed ignorance of his conscripted seven hundred thousand subjects to
intentions and control them by manipulating build his tomb and a huge new palace complex,
competition among them. "When the ruler trusts large enough to seat ten thousand people. Many of
someone, he falls under that person's control."'' his palaces were connected by elevated walkways
and walled roads so that the emperor could move
By Han Feizi's time ideas about the ruler were also between them undetected.
colored by myths about the Yellow Emperor
(Huangdi), first of the sage-kings of high antiquity. Although he was rigorous in enforcing such
Han Feizi at one point referred to the Yellow Legalist policies as strict rewards and punishments,
Emperor summoning the ghosts and spirits to the the First Emperor of Qin was personally open to
top of Mount Tai, travelling there on a chariot non-Legalist ideas as well, including the more
pulled by dragons, with tigers and wolves leading grandiose conceptions of rulership conveyed by the
the way, ghosts and spirits following, lizards and myth of the Yellow Emperor and cosmological
snakes below, a phoenix above. In the version of the schemes that proved to him that the Qin ruled
myth current in Han Feizi's day, the Yellow through the power ofWater and thus was destined
Emperor was notable above all for his military to succeed the Zhou, which had ruled through
might.He had overcome the Divine Husbandman Fire. This cosmological strain of thought drew on
(Shennong), who had introduced farming but shied very old ideas about the production of the myriad
away from the use of arms. By teaching the bears, things through the workings of Yin and Yang. Yang,
leopards, and tigers to fight for him, the Yellow identified with the sun, Heaven, light, the male, the
Emperor had been able to conquer all those who assertive, and the changing, contrasts with Yin,
opposed him. In addition, the Yellow Emperor had identified with the moon, earth, darkness, female,
associations with rain and with dragons; some texts dampness, receptivity, and continuity. The
say he had the face of a dragon and that dragons movement from Yin to Yang and back again
appeared when he received Heaven's mandate. 7 The corresponds to such phenomena as the daily
later chapters of the Daoist text Zhuangzi present changes in the position of the sun and moon and
the Yellow Emperor sometimes as an arrogant the yearly succession of the seasons. The theory of
conqueror, dangerous in the excess of his zeal for the Five Phases (earth, wood, metal, fire, water) is a
bringing order to the world, sometimes as a much more complex system, which divides and
devoted disciple of the master Zhuangzi, listening classifies the cosmos in both time and space on the
to teachings on longevity. Often he was identified basis of equivalencies, resonances, and influences
with the Daoist Sage, a being of immense powers, connecting cosmic principles, astral events, and
anomalies and regularities in the skies, the weather, advocate austere textually-based "ancient" rituals
flora, and fauna, they fostered advances in while experts in the occult or later Daoist priests
astronomical and calendrical calculation and in choreographed elaborate ritual pageants more
natural history. satisfying to many emperors.
The collapse of the Qin within a few years of the To sum up, throughout the imperial period, the
death of the First Emperor led to the discrediting production of luxury goods to be used in imperial
of Legalism but not of other ideas on which Qin palaces, temples, and tombs took place in a cultural
had drawn, such as the Five Phases cosmology or context in which rulers were given all sorts of
the myth of the Yellow Emperor, all of which in advice. They were told to demonstrate their rank in
Han times were drawn together into an ideological everything they did but not to burden the people
justification of imperial rule. Dong Zhongshu through excessive extraction; they were told to
(ca. 179 ca. 104 bce) wrote at length on the model themselves on sage-kings whose attributes
among Heaven,
interconnections earth, and ranged from the mild and temperate Yao to the all-
humanity. Among human beings, the ruler was conquering Yellow Emperor; they were likened to
unique in his capacity to link the three. Moreover, gods but also told to perform highly scripted roles
using terms that echo Daoist and Legalist that left them little in the way of personal
conceptions, Dong described him as ruling through discretion. Art produced for the court would have
nonaction abstaining from administration to resonated with these ideas in various ways.
maintain his exalted status. The Record oj Ritual, Moreover, art produced for other sites often was
dating from the early Han, draws on earlier texts shaped by these discourses indirectly. In later
like the Liishi clumqiu to depict the ideal ruler as centuries Buddhist and Daoist temples were often
one who coordinates the activities of his state with modeled on palaces, and their deities on kings and
the forces of nature, analyzed in terms ofYin and queens. Thus, ways ot decorating temples and
Yang and the Five Phases. His movements had to depicting deities participated in the discourse on
be in tune with ritually demarked times and places. rulership. Art that was distinctly nonimpenal also, of
In the first month of the year, for instance, the Son course, drew from this discourse. Scholars who
of Heaven lives in the apartments on the left side of identified with the Confucian critique of imperial
the Green Bright Hall, rides in a chariot with extravagance had to choose a more austere style for
green pennants drawn by dark green dragon horses, their own homes and gardens.
arms be taken up. Chinese art from the late Warring States period on,
Although Confucian scholars claimed to be experts (cats. 50, 51 [reverse], 153, 186, 189, 192-95, 200,
in the traditional texts on ritual, they were not the 2049, 212).
I0
Mountains share some of the aura of
only ones designing the rituals that would keep the kings. Kings sacrifice to mountains. The sage-king
ruler in harmony with the Five Phases. Rituals Shun, the Book of Documents reports, regularly
designed on the basis of ancient texts by Confucian sacrificed to the mountains from afar, and once
scholars who held secular views of ritual were every five years made a journey to each region of
always in danger of becoming mere social the empire, making burnt offerings to Heaven at
ceremonies, useful for creating and confirming the sacred mountains Tai in the east, Heng in the
social distinctions, but unable to touch people in south, Hua in the west, Heng in the north, and
powerful ways. As a consequence, Confucian Songgao in the center. Mountains were also like
scholars were not able to monopolize the design of rulers, rich in Ymg power, lowering above the
court rituals, and many rulers were receptive to ordinary, linking the lowly to the heavens. The
men who claimed alternative ways to tap into death of .1 ruler was euphemistically called the
cosmic powers. In 110 bce, when Emperor Wu of collapse of a mountain. "Great and lofty 1-- the
the Han dynasty journeyed to Mount Tai to mountain/ With its might reaching 10 I leaven,"
perform thefeng and shan sacrifices, he dismissed read the first two lines in a poem in the Classii el
because they were not the same as the ones used in mountains and the deities or ere. nines thai
who climbed to the top of Mount Hua and left an embodiments of the paradises of the immortals in
inscription there saying, "King Zhao once played a the remote mountains.
creatures lived. The late Zhou and Han Shanhai jing started to visit mountains to search for herbs, to
("Classic of Mountains and Seas") describes receive divine revelations, or to acquire magical
mountains inhabited by animals like the human- powers. Ge Hong 280 ca. 343) proposed that
(ca.
devouring zhuhai, with horns like a bull, human those seeking immortality should go to mountains,
eyes, and hog's ears. The deities residing in the where they could pursue their quest without
mountains are also often hybrid, combining human, distraction. But he urged them to choose "big
bird, snake, sheep, or dragon parts. mountains" ruled by gods, rather than little
Sea, and he sent out teams of young people to Maoshan) school of Daoism of the fourth century
search for them. In Han times Emperor Wu was and later, adepts could also visit mountains without
told that the Yellow Emperor had attained leaving home by visualizing their visits to the
immortality by visiting these islands. The abodes of the immortals. Because of the assumed
Huainanzi, a Daoist-tinged compilation sponsored correspondences between the macrocosm and the
by a Han prince during the mid-second century microcosm, the exploration of a mountain or even
bce, describes the magic realm of the Kunlun a single rock could lead to an understanding of the
Mountains in the far west, where immortality could entire cosmos.
"science" of earth forms, or geomancy, which dates obligations. These hermits and recluses were
back at least to Han times and flourished in generally conceived as men of wisdom and
subsequent centuries. The earth is viewed as an conviction, uninterested in material things, content
organism with energy flowing through its veins, to eat and dress roughly and live in caves or huts.
much the way blood flows through the body. They are thus almost exact opposites of the
Mountains are full of such energy in their "dragon immortals dwelling in diaphanous robes in palatial
possible for one skilled in geomancy to site a house each other. The image of the mountain enhanced
or grave to best advantage. the image of the ruler by stressing his imposing
majesty, connections to Heaven, and links to the
By the end of the Six Dynasties (220589) the realms of the immortals. At the same time,
earlier image of the mountain as a wild realm of mountains had an anti-monarchical side, from their
fearsome powers coexisted with a more benign association with recluses who refused to have
image of the mountain as the favored dwelling anything to do with the ruler and the world of
place of immortals, who lived in palatial luxury in government with its hierarchies and rules.
these texts did not convey the words of gods, they well. During the course of the Han, it became
contained the teachings of the sages. In later widely accepted that officials should be men
centuries, after the use of paper became common, trained in the Confucian classics and respected for
paper with writing on it was considered sacred, and their character. Ambitious young men sought out
well into the twentieth century old men would teachers with whom to study the classics, for
collect and burn scrap paper, that being the way to learning could lead to power and prestige. All over
dispose of it with proper respect. Writing was also, the country teachers attracted large numbers of
of course, considered an art to many, calligraphy students and disciples, and the enrollment at the
was the highest of all the arts. imperial academy increased from a few dozen
students to more than thirty thousand in the mid-
The power of written texts can be fully tapped second century ce.
repertoire by writing books themselves. Because the to the ruler in moral terms, made forthright critics
Chinese language was written in a logographic of imperial policies. During the Han many
script one graph for each word reading and Confucian scholars and officials opposed activist
writing were skills that took many years to master, policies such as government monopolies,
and from Shang times on those who had mastered questioning their morality and their effect on
the thousands of symbols used to make records people's livelihoods. Scholars regularly objected to
were technical experts in demand at court. In imperial extravagance, urging emperors to reduce
Confucius' day learned men served at court as their spending on palace ladies, entertainment,
advisers, teachers, strategists, and clerks. They knew hunting parks, stables, and rituals. Thus, the
the rules for rituals and ceremonies, such as coupling of Confucianism and the Chinese
sacrifices to ancestors and reception of envoys; they bureaucracy created a sort of balance of power
knew about the Heavens and could advise on between the emperor and the Confucian-educated
setting the calendar; they kept records and advised officials who staffed the government but did not
on precedents. But they depended on rulers for consider themselves mere servants of the emperor.
employment, and as states were destroyed, these Because the court set the standards that the literati
learned men frequently found themselves in the had to fulfill to gain entry into officialdom, it
uncomfortable position of having to locate a new circumscribed their autonomy, their capacity to set
lord in need of their services. their own standards, but it never eliminated it. By
the end of the Han those with Confucian
Confucius urged his followers to master the literary educations had become self-conscious of their
traditions of their day, and the Analects reported that common identity. In the succeeding centuries the
Confucius often discoursed on "poetry, history, and strength and coherence of this elite of educated
the performance of ceremonies" (7. 17). Yet he did gentlemen proved as important as political
not want men of education to think of themselves centralization or economic integration as a basis tor
as narrow experts, but rather as persons whose the unity of Chinese civilization.
moral sensibilities had been cultivated by studying
the words of the sages. Their aim should be to The impact of these developments on Chinese
become "gentlemen," men of integrity and honor culture was profound. The importance placed on
who deserved to be respected as much for their texts and learning fostered some of China's most
moral cultivation as for their mastery of tradition. renowned advances, such as the invention of paper
The true gentleman, in Confucius s vision, is not in the Han period and printing in the Ting period.
moved by profit like the petty man, but rather The obligation of the gentleman to devote himself
aspires to things lofty. He concentrates on both to learning the tradition and to refining and
improving himself and is indifferent to recognition cultivating his own character legitimated artistic
or reward. "The gentleman feels bad when his activities of many sorts, above all. perhaps, poetry-
capabilities fall short of the task. He does not feel writing and calligraphy, but also painting and
bad when people fail to recognize him" (15. 18). If connoisseurship of ancient objects. A highly self-
he can retain his self-respect even though no ruler referential style 111 painting and calligraphy, one thai
employs him, he is not dependent on the ruler, and required firm grounding in what had come before,
can develop ideas and take stands independent of accorded well not only with the Confucian
the ruler. commitment to learning but also with the literati
writing commentaries on the classics. of men long gone. When the duke demanded
either an explanation or his life, the wheelwright
group of learned men who owed their standing to chisel at a wheel, if I go slowly, the chisel slides
mastery of a body of texts. In Han times the and does not stay put; if I hurry, it jams and
astrologers, diviners, and experts in unseen forces doesn't move properly. When it is neither too
transmitted their knowledge both orally and slow nor too fast, I can feel it in my hand and
through texts. Buddhism had entered China as a respond to it from my heart. My mouth cannot
religion with a vast body of scriptures, and monks describe it in words, but there is something
gained standing, both within the Buddhist there. I cannot teach it to my son, and my son
community and outside it, by mastering a body of cannot learn it from me. So I have gone on for
texts and adding to the understanding of them seventy years, growing old chiseling wheels. The
through writing commentaries. In the fourth and men of old died in possession of what they
fifth centuries religious Daoism acquired a large could not transmit. So it follows that what you
body of revealed texts, and although these texts are reading are their dregs. 13
flutes and drums, and the colors of robes and recognized an obligation to bring this truth to the
banners. attention of the ruler, Zhuangzi, who did not see
truth in books, felt no need to serve in
But the story does not end there. The supremacy of government. He told of receiving an envoy from
the written word and of those learned in the the king of Chu, bearing an offer to give him
written word did not go unchallenged in China. To charge of the entire realm. In response he asked the
the contrary, from very early times important envoy whether a tortoise that had been held sacred
philosophical and religious thinkers disputed the for three thousand years would prefer to be dead
priority given words, texts, the educated, and the with its bones venerated or alive with its tail
kind ot knowledge that gets created and promoted dragging in the mud. On getting the expected
through words and texts. They pointed to the limits response, he told the envoy to go away; he wished
ot language and to forms of knowing that could to drag his tail in the mud.
not be communicated through language. To put this
another way, some thinkers have always resisted the Although the social standing of the educated in
way writing fixes, limits, and binds meanings, and China owes much to Confucian ideas of the worth
have tried to preserve or recover the reality that of written traditions and men educated in them, it
exists prior to or beyond writing. These sets of would be a mistake to infer that the educated elite
ideas have been as powerful in Chinese art as the always thought exclusively in pro-text terms. In
pro-text ideas, perhaps particularly because visual particular, Daoist ideas that questioned the role of
symbols are not words. words and texts appealed deeply to many educated
men. These ideas also colored the development of
The earliest formulation of this challenge to words Buddhism in China. The most Simfied school of
is found in the early Daoist classics. "The Way that Buddhism, the Chan school (known as Zen in
can be told is not the invariant Way" is the opening Japan), rejected the authority of the sutras and
line of the Laozi. Words and writing are assertive claimed the superiority of mind-to-mind
and thus destructive. It would be better, the Laozi transmission of Buddhist truth through a series of
asserts, if knew less, if they gave up tools and
people patriarchs, the most important of whom were the
abandoned writing. They would be satisfied with First Patriarch Bodhidharma, an Indian monk who
their own lives and not envy their neighbors. came to China in the early sixth century, and the
Zhuangzi argued that the labeling of experience Sixth Patriarch Huineng, a Chinese monk who
with words and its division into distinct categories died in the early eighth century. The illiteracy of
was a falsification from the start, since reality could Huineng at the time of his enlightenment was
never be conveyed in this way. Zhuangzi placed the taken as proof of the Chan claim that
knowledge of the craftsman above the knowledge enlightenment could be achieved suddenly through
found in books. In one parable he had a insight into one's own true nature, even by people
wheelwright audaciously tell a duke that books who knew nothing of textual traditions. Chan
minds from the traps of discursive thought by From the Han period there are many portrayals of
taking language to the limits. They would assign human figures on the walls of temples or tombs;
them baffling anecdotes or questions to ponder and some of these appear to be generic figures, others
respond to their efforts with cryptic utterances, are labeled as specific figures from history or
shouts, or even blows. mythology (cats. 103, 104).
Tension between the world of the book and the There is little evidence, however, that these
world that cannot be contained by the book cut depictions of human beings were idols or icons,
across many different traditions. In China, as made to represent gods or spirits during sacrifices
elsewhere, people felt a strong urge to impose order or other rituals. Pre-Buddhist Chinese shrines were
on experience by specifying, categorizing, not centered on statues or paintings of deities.
evaluating, and judging via words and their Chinese sacrificial ceremonies could be performed
inscription in texts, but their attempts could never either in the open, with a temporary altar, or in
totally succeed because of all that could not be temples, but in either case objects other than
contained by texts, the disrupting forces and paintings or statues were used to represent the
uncontrollable potency of rulers, mountains, spirits or gods. The central object for the she
divinities, oral revelations, dreams, emotions, and so sacrifices to the earth, for instance, was a small
on. The Confucian literati normally took their earthen mound; for sacrifices to ancestral spirits, a
stand on the side of texts and order, but the tablet inscribed with the name of the dead was
distinction here goes beyond simple divisions of sufficient.
Confucian scholars to varying degrees drew on the expanded radically (see essays by Helmut Brinker
magical power of rituals and the visual and and Su Bai in this volume). Buddhists used images
emotional power of images, not to mention both to teach Buddhist doctrine and to provide a
retreating to mountains or practicing meditative focus for devotional activities. Within a few
techniques that could lead to insights without use centuries of the introduction of Buddhism, not
convey. The strength, balance, and flow ot the disciples in India. But by the time Buddhism
strokes were believed to convey the calligrapher's arrived in China as a religion of foreign merchants
moral and psychological make-up as well as his and missionaries, the use of icons was well
momentary emotions. The flow of energy within established. The Scripture on the Production of Budtllui
the person was found manifest in the movement of Images (Ztiofo xingxiangjing), one of the earliest
his hand and brush and the resulting traces of ink. sutras translated into Chinese, records the
The ideas discussed so far are indigenous ideas, lives by those who produce images ot the
developed in the huge subcontinent we loosely Buddha. u Even the most eminent monks taught
label China. But some key elements in Chinese followers devotional practices centered on images.
religious traditions entered from outside, The learned monk and translator Daoan (312 (85
particularly as part of or in the company of would set up a holy image and light incense
Buddhism, and these elements also provided part of whenever he gave a lecture. The equally eminent
the context of Chinese art. monk Huiyuan (334-417) in 402 assembled .1 group
of monks and lay people in front of .111 image ot
Representations of human beings appear the Pure Land, the Western Paradise of the Buddha
occasionally in early Chinese art. Some Neolithic Amitabha. With such prompting, the production ol
pots have human faces depicted on them (cat. 114), Buddhist images expanded gready. IK S-a.
as do a few Shang-period bronzes; some Zhoulate according to one observer, there were over .1
bronzes are decorated with small images of human thousand Buddhist statues in the city ofl uoyang.
beings engaged in warfare, hunting, rituals, or Each year, on die seventh da) of the fourth month,
agriculture; sometimes the base of a lamp or tray all these were brought to the [ingming Temple.
scatter flowers on them as part of the Great polymaths like Shen Gua (1031-1095) contributed
Blessing ceremony. to everything from mathematics to geography,
Both Confucians and Daoists denounced many military strategy, and agricultural technology. Other
Buddhist ideas and practices as immoral or unsuited Confucian scholars like Cheng Yi (1033 1107) were
to China. For instance, they portrayed the great drawn to metaphysical speculation about the nature
sums spent on construction of temples, statues, and and workings of the cosmos. 16
ceremonies as a drain on the economy that
impoverished the people and thus indirectly the Certain trends and issues crosscut many traditions.
state. At the same time, they borrowed extensively For instance, concern both with texts and with
from the repertoire of ideas and practices that what cannot be conveyed in texts enlivened
Buddhists had introduced into China, including the intellectual life in many circles. Many highly
use of images on altars. Probably the adoption of educated Confucian scholars were attracted to
icons should be attributed to their visual forms of spirituality that did not rely on texts,
effectiveness. Icons work differently from words and including meditation and visionary experiences,
texts, because images of the human form are potent and they were ready to make use of Buddhist and
in arousing emotions. Moreover, the meanings they Daoist traditions toward these ends.' 7 At a less
can convey are not fixed, but mediated by the elevated level, many literati were captivated by cases
response of the viewer different people can give of spirit-writing, in which spirits created texts by
an image different meanings at different times an possessing objects or people. Zhu Xi (1130 1200),
attribute that makes images good objects for the towering figure in Confucianism, took a strong
meditation. line against Buddhist and Daoist practices,
advocating the "investigation of things" through
Although most of the icons that survive from Tang careful reading of the Four Books and the classics
and Song times are of Buddhist divinities, not local more generally; he also, however, advocated "quiet
or Daoist gods, ancestors, or Confucian sages, there sitting," a form of meditation. In a comparable way,
is abundant textual evidence that by Tang and Song Chan Buddhism, notwithstanding its emphasis on
times temples of all sorts represented their central transmission outside texts, was expanded to
objects of worship with images. These statues and accommodate highly literate Chan monks who
paintings must have constituted a large share of the excelled in poetry and other literary arts. The
art that the average person had occasion to see. impact of this lively interest both in words and in
Temples to Confucius and to Confucian sages and what goes beyond words is evident in Chan
teachers regularly had statues in them. The imperial painting, which seems to extend the idea of
ancestral cult was expanded to accommodate halls communicating through nondiscursive means to
with statues of emperors. And Buddhist monasteries painting that is suggestive much more than
added halls with images of their former abbots, descriptive.
OF THE SONG DYNASTY moral authority helped rather than hindered artistic
I have already suggested some of the ways the creativity. The Song was a time when the moral
diverse ideas sketched here were linked to the autonomy of those with Confucian educations was
equally diverse objects we now view as China's art strongly reasserted and became a matter of political
treasures. The best way to extend my analysis of the struggle between the court and the Confucian
ways creativity played out in a cultural context that literati. The size of the educated class grew so large
encompassed the coexistence of numerous in Song times that there was always a large supply
unintegrated ideas is to look at the conjunction of of highly educated men who could not find
such ideas in a single time period. The Song employment in government service, but this did
dynasty (9601279) offers a good case. not make them more subservient to the court. To
the contrary, literati residing in their home
The Song was without doubt a time when new communities found a variety of ways to assert their
ideas and practices appeared in profusion. Science moral autonomy. For instance, they frequently
and technology were making rapid progress, with erected shrines to honor scholar-heroes of the past
advances in abstract disciplines like mathematics who had been persecuted or unfairly neglected.
and in such practical matters as the technology of Leading literati like Su Shi (1037 1101), who took
iron and steel, ceramics, ballistics, and textiles. New an interest in painting, calligraphy, and poetry
gods appeared, and existing cults spread. In writing, helped validate aesthetic and scholarly
Buddhism, Tiantai teachings underwent a revival. In pursuits in and of themselves, even if they did not
Daoism, Celestial Heart and Thunder Rates lead to serving the ruler. Others, like Cheng Yi and
Art comes into this story because both the court Huizong (r. 1100-1126), did not care for Guo Xi's
and literati circles used art to bolster their own paintings and had them put in storage. Moreover,
authority and legitimacy, and the resulting he did not share Su Shi's rejection of technique. In
competition, collaboration, appropriation, and his paintings he took considerable pains to convey
specialization seems only to have promoted the outer form of objects, and he trained court
,s
creativity. The tremendous flourishing of artists to observe nature with minute attention.
landscape painting and caDigraphy in Song times Some of this difference in artistic taste may relate to
should not be seen simply as automatic outgrowths Huizong's ambivalence toward the Confucian
of the long-established cultural value placed on scholars of his day. Intellectually, Huizong was
mountains and writing, but rather as the product of attracted to subjects like music, poetry, calligraphy,
the conjunction of many elements, including the and medicine, interests many literati like Su Shi and
competition and collaboration between the court Shen Gua shared. As a prince, he had shared a
and circles of literati ambivalent about their passion for art collecting with his uncle, the painter
relationship to the court. Wang Shen (see cat. 1S4), who in turn was on good
terms with Su Shi. As emperor, he invited Su Shi's
The creation of a canon of masterpieces that set the friend, the renowned painter and calligrapher Mi
standards in calligraphy involved an interplay of Fu and later his son MiYouren (d. 1165) to come to
imperial sponsorship and literati connoisseurship. In court as curators/professors. Yet politics estranged
992 the court had ordered the printing of a book Huizong from the circle of Su Shi, since for most
of rubbings that reproduced copies of famous of his reign he excluded from his court those
pieces of calligraphy, especially early ones by Wang involved with the opposition to Wang Anshi, who
Xizhi (307?-365?) and Wang Xianzhi (344-386). had been prime minister during the reign of his
But comparing these pieces and determining their father, Shenzong (r. 1067-1085). Even the books
relative quality was largely the work of private written by the leaders of the opposition, such as Su
scholars such as Mi Fu (1052-1107/8). J
Shi, were banned and could not be reprinted.
Court and literati taste often diverged, of course. Su Huizong took a strong interest in Daoism, which
Shi, who enjoyed social occasions at which can be seen in such paintings as the one he made
educated men would compose poems, paint to commemorate the appearance of white cranes
pictures, or inspect antiques, offered a theoretical over the main gate of the palace during a festival in
justification for the superiority of "scholar's 1112. Such a painting certainly glorified Huizong, as
painting" over professional painting. He valued the appearance of the cranes was interpreted as a
spontaneous creation over laborious technique, portent that cosmic powers approved of his rule.
asserted the moral superiority of creating a work But the painting itself was probably seen only by a
without thought of financial reward, and viewed relatively small number of people in the palace.
painting as a form of self-expression much like Much more important for impressing the general
poetry. Capturing the outward form of an object population with the grandeur of his rule would
was not nearly as valuable as conveying its inner have been his many construction projects. Over the
20
principle. course of his reign he had main' temples, palaces,
government buildings, and gardens constructed,
Some of the monuments of landscape painting often on grand scale. To Huizong. however, the
were created at court for imperial patrons, but religious impulse behind these projects may have
court painters viewed themselves not as artisans been stronger than the desire to impress Ins
but as scholar-officials, with all the moral subjects. Through his gardens, in particular, he
independence claimed for that status. Guo Xi attempted to recreate the cosmos, with .ill ol its
(ca. 1061-ca. 1090), for instance, was a learned man myriad plants and animals, mountains and waters.
who wrote on the theory of painting and
participated in literati circles, and in his writings he Although Confucian scholars might condemn the
took a romantic view of art as self-expression. Yet grandiosity ofl [uizong's construction projects, it
his employment at court would have required him was much more difficult for them to decry Ins
choosing. To complicate matters further. Guo Xi is Huizong had .1 passion for antiques, especially
also known to have been a Daoist devotee, and his Shang- and Zhou period bronze vessels and
efforts to gain the support of the literati. He University Press, 1983), 1991), PP- 26-31. pp. 196-234, passim.
calligraphy to favored officials. He brought Mi of the Tao (La Salle, 111.: Open Buddha Images," in Religions of
Youren back to court and had him serve as the Court, 19S9), pp- 232-34. China in Practice, ed. Donald S. 22. See Julia K. Murray, Ma
Lopez, Jr. (Princeton: Princeton Hezhi and the Illustration of the
curator of the palace painting collection and court On Mozi's and Guanzi's University Press, 1996), pp. Book of Odes (New York:
5.
painter. Art, thus, had become a site for earning the political thought, see Kung- 261-67. Cambridge University Press,
this frame of mind, but we do not need to Civilization: A Sourcebook, 2nd Portraiture in Medieval
ed. (New York: Free Press, China," Cahiers d' Extreme- Asie
subscribe to it. Even if Huizong and Zhu Xi would
1993), pp. 33-37. 7 (1993-94), PP- 149-219-
have each agreed that the world would be a better
place if all thought as he did, much of the vitality 7. See Mark Edward Lewis, 16. For an overview ot the
Sanctioned Violence in Early religious and philosophical
and creativity in Chinese culture derives from the China (Albany: State University situation in Song times, see
fact that such unification of thought was beyond of New York Press, 1990), Peter N. Gregory and Patricia
NOTES 9. Burton Watson, trans., The 17. For a good example, see
1. The existence of opposed Records of the Grand Historian of Robert M. Gimello, "Chang
tendencies in Chinese thought China (New York: Columbia Shang-ying on Wu-t'ai Shan,"
has long been recognized. See University Press, I96i),p. 57. in Pilgrims and Sacred Sites in
Confucianism in Action, ed. and their expression in Chinese 1992), pp. 89-149-
David S. Nivison and Arthur E art, see Kiyohiko Munakata,
Wright {Stanford: Stanford Sacred Mountains in Chinese Art 18. For recent overviews of
University Press, 1959). Here, (Urbana: University of Illinois Song court art, see Craig
because my focus is on Press, 1990); Lothar Clunas, Art in China (Oxford:
connections to art, I have Ledderhose,"The Earthly Oxford University Press, 1997),
selected a rather different set of Paradise: Religious Elements in pp. 53-63, and Wen C. Fong,
ideas than Schwartz did. Chinese Landscape Art," in Beyond Representation: Chinese
,h th
Moreover, I do not see a larger Theories of the Arts in China, ed. Painting and Calligraphy S 14
system that comprehends all of Susan Bush and Christian Century (New York:
the polarities, but a much Murck (Princeton: Princeton Metropolitan Museum ot Art,
messier situation in which University Press, 1983), pp. 1992), pp. 173-245-
inconsistencies and even 165-83; and John Hay, Kernels
incoherence are not only of Energy, Bones of Earth :Tlie 19. See Lothar Ledderose, Mi
possible but an accepted part of Rock in Chinese Art (New York: Fu and the Classical Tradition of
the way things are. China House Gallery, 1985). Chinese Calligraphy (Princeton:
Princeton University Press,
2. See James Legge, trans., Tlie 11. Robinet, p. 95. 1979) and Peter Charles
Chinese Classics IILJlie Shoo Sturman, Mi Fu: Style and the
King (Hong Kong: University 12. On this topic, see also K.C. Art of Calligraphy in Northern
of Hong Kong Press, i960; Chang, Art, Myth, and Ritual, Song China (New Haven: Yale
reprint of Oxford University pp. 81-94; Derk Bodde, Chinese University Press, 1997).
Press ed.), pp. 283-85. Thought, Society, and Science: Tlie
Yu Weichao
Director, National Museum of
Chinese History
Recent years have seen a growing
artistic traditions have coexisted in the world: the system of secularly derived moral values-
East Asian tradition centered in China, the Western Confucianism come to constitute the foundation
tradition centered in Europe (and, after the of society. This created a distinct aesthetic, which, in
eighteenth century, in the United States), and the conjunction with differences in the conditions of
Islamic tradition. All three have long historical life, gave rise to an artistic tradition different from
roots, and these roots are neither unitary nor linear. the other two both in content and in forms of
Their later evolutions have been shaped primarily expression.
systems the East Asian based on Confucianism, the At a time when Christianity and Islam were widely
Western on the commingling of Classical thought accepted in Europe and the Middle East, Buddhism
and Christianity, and the Islamic on the teachings had an enormous following in China. Why, then,
of and for behavior acquired and transmitted by Europe and the Middle East; government and
symbols, constituting the distinctive achievement of religion were integrated. In China, on the other
human groups, including their embodiment in hand, although the embrace of Throne and creed
artefacts. . . . Culture systems may, on the one hand, was sometimes close, it was always limited in time,
be considered as products of action, on the other as space, and degree. Additionally, Buddhism was never
conditioning elements of further action." 1
In short, supreme in the culture of the Han ethnic majority,
"culture" consists of those predominant concepts even during its apogee, from the Northern and
that determine the rules of behavior of members of Southern Dynasties era through the Sui and Tang.
society and form the "cultural phenomena" of their Furthermore, Chinese Buddhism absorbed many
groupings. From this perspective, it is the "culture" Confucian moral and ethical concepts. In other
of any country or people that truly gives shape to words, among the three major cultures, the Chinese
its artistic expression. was by far the most secular.
Because for a long historical period artists were It was in the Middle East that cultural systems
considered mere craftsmen, their works expressed coalescing government with religion originated
not the maker's subjective aspirations but the some five thousand years ago. In ancient Egypt, for
collective or individual values of society's dominant instance, the Pharaoh was also the monarch, uniting
groups, whence came their patrons. Subsequently in his person state and creed. In Europe, by
there emerged some artists who did not depend on contrast, almost till the end of the Classical age,
patronage for their livelihood, and whose works state and religion were mutually supportive but
therefore could express their own interests and structurally and functionally separate institutions.
perceptions. Because these were generally members Not till the fourth century CE did Rome adopt
of the upper classes, however, their works too Christianity as the official religion, a policy soon
mostly reflect the consciousness of the social elites followed by Rome's successor kingdoms in Europe
to which they belonged. Not until the modern era and continued (although not unchallenged) into the
have art works come increasingly to express the era of the modern nation-states. In this regard, the
individual characters of their makers, and to show a Classical civilization of Europe, including its Cretan
concomitant proliferation of styles. Within every and Mycenean precursors, must be considered an
artistic tradition, this pattern in the history of art interlude between the cultures of Mesopotamia and
has caused the works of different periods to be ancient Egypt and that of medieval Europe. As for
strongly stamped with hallmarks of their eras. Islam, it has since its beginning been accepted as a
processes of historical development, but at disparate The formation of the Chinese cultural tradition
paces and with disparate cultural content. This proceeded along different lines. Since its beginnings
underlying similitude of developmental paths during the Xia, Shang, and Zhou eras, government
produces considerable similarities among the art and religion were separate, except under King Xin
works of different countries and peoples at the of the late Shang, who at one point assumed the
same stage of social development; at the same time, power to offer sacrifices. The separation of
the overlying disparities in cultural characteristics government and religion simultaneously reflected
make for entirely different artistic traditions. Among and promoted a strong sense of secularism in the
the three major world artistic traditions, two were Chinese cultural tradition, but this secularism did
First, the polity that emerged was multiethnic, some of these practices survived into the Ming and
centered around the Huaxia people (later called the Qing dynasties as ceremonials protective of state
Han people) and associated with other somewhat and society and as evidence of Heaven-pleasing
closely related peoples. Even when one particular righteousness in the practitioners.
ethnic group seized political control from another,
the state always remained multiethnic. In fact, its The (to us) mysterious images on ritual bronzes of
specific structure became ever more tight knit. A the three early dynasties could not have been cast
multiethnic state in which the Han people formed solely for the purpose of evoking awe. According to
the majority group emerged during Qin and Han. the entry for "the third year of Duke Xuan" in the
Second, government took the form of an autocracy, Eastern Zhou period, probably compiled toward
centered around the ruler as Son of Heaven. the end of Eastern Zhou), "There was virtue in the
Heaven, however, was not a personalized deity, nor time of the Xia, so the Nine Provinces submitted
were the emperors god-kings or even priest-kings. to the Xia, and offered bronzes which they made in
Rather, Heaven represented an idea of willed tribute. Those living afar also offered drawings
cosmic order and propriety which the emperor depicting local spirits and demons. Then the Xia
was expected, by means of moral example, cast a large ding on which were portrayed all the
prescribed ceremonial, and efFective governance, spirits and demons, so that the people might know
to reify on earth. of them. Thus, when they travelled to the
mountains, rivers, and forests around the land,
Third, a basically uniform writing system was they would not be molested by the main spirits
adopted, which promoted cultural interchange and and demons. To handle affairs from all over in
consensus among regions and peoples. this manner was to act according to the mandate
of Heaven." 5
Fourth, hierarchical systems of rites were
established, to set norms for the conduct of the I Hiring the three early dynasties people were just
different social classes. Of the systems created beginning to emerge from .1 state of barbarism.
during the three early dynasties, that begun during They attributed all good and ill to supernatural
the Zhou was the most comprehensive. Since 11 was forces that were amenable to prayer and
originally created to stabilize the Zhou class system. propitiation, hence the popularity of shamanism.
By the Han dynasty, and particularly after the reign aging, death, and their earthbound condition. This
of Emperior Wu, the magical cosmos of the three begot an obsession with the occult, including
early dynasties had changed into a secular cosmos alchemy, numerology, divination, and quasi-magical
conceived in strongly Confucian terms. dietary-respiratory-gymnastic regimens all
objects of worship were heaven and earth, arrived and was accepted in China, conflated to a
mountains, rivers, and ancestors. Similarly, moral certain extent with early religious Daoism.
precepts stressed the duties of venerating heaven
and earth, worshiping all the spirits, 7 and honoring A common subject of Han art was the coexistence
one's ancestors. Magical beliefs and social morality and congruence of secular activities and the
were basically one. heavenly world. This was most intensely and
completely manifested in the pictorial programs
During the Eastern Zhou, and particularly after the that covered the walls of Eastern Han tombs. These
late Spring and Autumn period, the teachings of included pictures of the heavenly world and
Confucian and other secularly inclined astronomical phenomena, as well as many
philosophers flourished, gradually coming to immortals and divinities; drawings of auspicious
dominate the ideological sector; at the same time, symbols that represented the idea of "resonance
secular works of art began to increase. between Heaven and man"; and depictions of the
everyday life of the deceased. Since the simple
Confucius, from whom the Confucian school of burials of the poor have not survived, what we see
thought is considered to take its origin, are the concerns and the appurtenances of the
propounded a coherent system of social ethics and upper classes: mansions, banquets and
morality. During the reign of Emperor Wu of the entertainments, carriage processions and outriders,
Western Han, other schools of socio-political along with the farming, animal husbandly and
10
thought were proscribed and Confucianism alone handicrafts that supported the estate. Most
reigned supreme. Thenceforth, although individual strikingly, abundant images of everyday life have
rulers might espouse or even promote Buddhism or joined the spirits, deities, and shamans who form
Daoism, Confucian ideas held sway over China for the principal subjects of surviving pre-Han art.
the formula "three human relationships and five possessions cherished in life reflect less of a sense
constant virtues" {sangcmg wuchang), 9 which of mystery and more of a simple secular feeling
remained normative throughout the next two than pre-Han tomb accoutrements. Even art works
millennia. Dong also proposed that "Heaven and with religious themes had a strong humanistic tone.
man are one," a theory of "resonance (or mutual This was an extremely important change in the
interaction) between heaven and man," which course of Chinese art; for a very long time
linked the shamanistic worship of Heaven with hereafter many purely religious works of art sought
secular ethics and morality. In other words, Heaven to stir the feelings of believers and art lovers alike
is possessed of supreme power and beneficent will, through their expression of humanity.
humans are possessed of the potential for virtuous
or evil actions; the "oneness" or "resonance" or IV.
mutual interactivity of Heaven and humankind Throughout human history certain universal social
posits that human actions affect Heavens will, processes have promoted the spread of religious
which in turn affects all mundane events, including beliefs in medieval eras. Beginning about the end of
human fortunes. the third century, in the period of disunion
following the fall of the Han dynasty, religious
In the ancient world the theory of "Heaven and belief became widespread, permeating Chinese
man are one" was unique to Chinese culture, 9 and culture. In China, from the Northern and Southern
from the reign of Emperor Wu it dominated Han Dynasties period through the Sui and Tang,
philosophy. The theory generated a vast body of Buddhism reached its apogee. Society was still
omen lore: the appearance of rare animals or plants governed, however, according to Confucian ethical
or meteorological phenomena, or the discovery of and moral precepts. Moreover, the ardent Buddhism
of these centuries was many times punctuated by interior walls of tombs. Murals in later aristocratic
government-sponsored anti-Buddhist campaigns, tombs like that of Lou Rui (531-570) of
motivated by political necessity or by a given rulers Northern Qi; or of Princess Yongtai and the princes
pro-Daoist leanings in the perennial competition Yide and Zhanghuai of Tang, all buried in 706
between Buddhism and Daoism. Clearly, despite its reflect metropolitan style and court standards of
popularity, Buddhism remained ideologically workmanship and are secular in content. As one
subordinate. would expect, the contemporaneous murals in the
Buddhist cave-temples at Dunhuang, in far western
Furthermore, during the late Han and Three Gansu, show a great mixture of stylistic influences
Kingdoms periods, as Buddhism began to flourish, and a more provincial level of workmanship.
it did so in part by acculturation, that is, by taking
on, in part, the teachings of Confucius and When court sculptors were set to work to produce
Mencius. For example, the Shijiamuni lihuo, the first Buddhist sculptures for the ruling houses, the results
Buddhist text written (and not just cited) in China, equaled any contemporaneous secular works. Court
proposes the essential "unity of the three creeds"- sculptors of the Northern Wei imbued the colossal
Buddhism, Daoism, and Confucianism." In the Buddha atYungang with solemn dignity and the
third and fourth centuries certain Buddhist reliefs in the Binyang Cave at Longmen with
metaphysical doctrines (xuantan yili) were held to devout majesty. Court sculptors of the Tang empress
be related to contemporary neo-Daoist Wu Zetian (r. 684-704), a wily ruler and passionate
metaphysical teachings (xtiaii xue), which were Buddhist, imbued the colossal Buddha and eight
themselves tinged with Confucian theories. attendant divinities at the Fengxian Temple of
Cultural influences did not flow in one direction Longmen with benevolence, gentleness, earnestness,
only. Based on the theory that every human mind and power. All these figures embody Chinese
contains and can discover within itself the Buddha- sculpture at the top of its bent, and reflect the
mind, the Chan Buddhist patriarch Huineng cultural efflorescence of the capitals to which they
(638-713) propounded the doctrine ofsudden were adjacent. They combine sublimity with a
enlightenment" (dunwu). In later centuries, long worldly magnificence that attests to the secular
after the heyday of Buddhism, this concept of coloration acquired by Chinese Buddhism.
sudden, unmediated perception or realization Arguably, the finest Chinese Buddhist sculptures of
became a key element of Chinese philosophy and this period were also the finest art works of their
aesthetic theory. Its influence on the intellectual life time anywhere in the world.
of China was profound, pervasive, and lasting, but it
exerted that influence not as a precept of Buddhist Mainstream ideas, the cultural basis of both
faith but as an element of secular Neo- religious and secular art, evolved gradually during
Confucianism.'-This Sinification ot Buddhist the Southern Dynasties, Sui, and Tang from the
society even when Buddhism was at its peak. Confucianism. This trend continued until after the
doctrines, all aspects of social culture will be importance held by its precursor during the Han,
permeated by religious overtones; where Confucian and Buddhist art went into a rapid decline.
culture from the period of disunity through the Sui Song Neo-Confucianism, and us continuations
and Tang was clearly of the second type. during the Ming and Qing. was by no means .1
Buddhist sculpture and painting of this era, assembled under this rubric ranged considerably in
adorning temples and cave-temples, was indeed their opinions and disputed then differences
highly sophisticated, but no more so than art works vehemently. But the common core "l Nieo-
of secular content. Noted artists of the time, such as Confucianism was .1 primary concern with
Gu Kaizhi (ca. 344-ca. 406) of the Eastern Jin, problems of ethics and epistemolog) and .1 wholt)
portrayed religious and mundane subjects alike. secular approach to both these sets of questions.
New artistic heights were achieved both by the Vastly oversimplifying, we might saj that Neo-
Buddhist volumetric sculptures ofYungang and Confucians sought to understand the metaphysical
Longmen in the north, which show influence from essence of the universe (the Dao) and to bung the
Gandharan and Guptan art, and by the Six human mind heart (.vm, which of itself "has no
Dynasties tomb carvings near Nanjing in the south, substance; it takes its reactions to the rights and
which continued the Eastern Han tradition oi relief wrongs of everything in I leaven and earth for us
primarily in ink monochrome, that were expressive 4. Zhang Guangzhi, Six Lectures 12. Chinese Buddhist
in intent and amateur in rendition). Of course, on Archaeology (Wenwu Association, ed., Chinese
Publishing House, 1986), Buddhism, vol. I, articles on
during the millennium from the founding of the "Buddhism of the Northern
pp. 47-5 2-
Song to the overthrow of the Qing, the styles (and and Southern Dynasties," and
Part of the Jiaosizhi in the "The Chan Sect" (Shanghai:
to some extent the subjects) of literati-approved 5. 1
and Chinese art has been in constant turmoil. Of Celebrating Su Bingqi's Fifty Years
rituals.'
course of Chinas culture over the last five thousand
years, to think about the traditions existing within 8. The three relationships all
Elizabeth Childs-Johnson
Visiting Scholar, New York University
55
obdurate stone, known as nephrite jade, could be Minerals sometimes mistaken for jade referred to
worked into what are for Chinese tradition as "false jades" or as "pseudo-jades" include agate,
technical masterpieces of ritual and aesthetic bowenite, fluorite, talc, and serpentine. The major
function. Yu jade was, in fact, the preeminent scientific means of distinguishing tremolites and
medium of the late Neolithic period, exploited actinolites from other minerals is by their specific
earlier than bronze as a political and religious gravity. Nephrites have a higher specific gravity and
power symbol which may now be associated with greater hardness than pseudo- and false jade
2
China's earliest civilization. Late Neolithic minerals. 5
three successive jade- working cultures of circa on Mohs's scale of hardness for minerals (ranking
3600-2000 bce, predating the historic Xia, Shang, from 1 to 10) jade measures 66.5; thus, it requires
and Zhou periods. Each culture boasts a major jade a harder stone such as quartzite (7-7.5) or diamond
art that is idiosyncratic yet telling in the formation (10) to abrade or "carve" it. Several scholars have
of later Chinese values and cultural expression. theorized about how early jade the translucent
nephrite as opposed to emerald green jadeite
In this exhibition, jades are drawn not only from was worked in ancient China. 6 Each has described
the jade-working cultures of Neolithic date, but a technique that involves various stages of working
also from other periods of great innovation such as with abrasives, from initially slicing off a chunk or
the Western and Eastern Zhou, when jade was first slab of jade from a rock outcropping to boring holes
used for head and body covers in burial and for and modeling linear motifs and openwork designs
elaborate pectorals hanging down the front of on the final jade piece. It is likely that a straight-
aristocratic robes, and from later periods, Han edged hand or gut-string saw was the tool used to
through Tang, when jade was worked into a variety cut, slice, and pare the jade into a workable form.
of exquisite ornamental forms.
Other tools involved probably included the awl and
JADE AS MATERIAL tubular drill, which may have been of bamboo.
Nephrite, like jadeite, is considered "true jade" by Since a flint (suishi) awl has been excavated from a
specialists today. Unlike the emerald green and Liangzhu tomb, it is possible that this was the type
harder jadeite, nephrite varies in color from of tool used to carve the minute detail decorating
translucent white to various shades of green and cong (prismatic tubes) and related ornaments. 7
brown and is the only jade that was used during Other specialists have argued that shark teeth
the Neolithic and early dynastic periods. excavated from Liangzhu tombs were used or that
only a tool with a diamond point was sufficiently
Based on a recent identification, nephrite can now hard to carve such refined detail.
8
That the
be documented as originating in Neolithic China. Liangzhu craftsmen working jade used a bamboo or
A specimen taken from an outcropping of rock at comparable drill with quartzite as an abrasive to
Zhaomeiling in Liyang, Jiangsu Province, has been make holes in ritual jades such as bi (disks) and cong
confirmed as having mineral qualities similar to (prismatic tubes) is convincing, since the remaining
Liangzhu-period nephrite. 3
It is likely that local elliptical marks, particularly marked in the centers
deposits of nephrite were found elsewhere in the of cong, identify that type of tool. These holes are
lower reaches of theYangzi River. The nephrite created from two sides by a bamboo drill whose
found in tombs of the far northeast (Hongshan point loses sharpness and thus width at the very
culture) is also thought to have been mined locally. center so that a ridge is formed. Quartzite crystals
densely intergrown, randomly oriented, interfelted was the abrasive used with water when working the
fibers of the minerals tremolite and actinolite. These surface. On Neolithic jades, abraded decorative
minerals are calcium-magnesium-iron silicates, motifs often appear chipped; on later jades, metal-
Caz (Mg,Fe 2+ ) 5 Sis O22 (OH) 2, and belong to the tipped tools were used so that these decorative
amphibole mineral group. 4 The difference between motifs appear as clean, crisp lines.
actinolite and tremolite is in the quantity of
magnesium and iron. In actinolite, iron appears in In recent experiments on jades at the Freer and
greater quantities, 10 to 50 percent; in tremolite, Arthur M. Sackler galleries in Washington, D.C.,
iron occupies under 10 percent of the total. Iron Wen Guang and Janet Douglas have shown that
content affects the color of nephrite by darkening certain jades of dark green and brown color, dating
it, creating gray to green hues. In its purest form, to the Longshan and successive cultures and
the nephrite is translucent white (see, for example, deriving from north and northwest China, are
cats. 17, 20). mineralogically iron- and manganese-rich
nephrites. 9 These jades possess small amounts of
translucent.
Jade as a precious stone has an eminent history in Fig. l.Jade types of the Hongshan culture:A. Hooked
China and for this reason is intimately linked with cloud; B. Horse-hoof shape; C. Dragon; D. Pig-dragon;
the beginnings of Chinese ritual and Chinese E. Disk; F Cat-headed bird; G. Cicada; H. Fish;
civilization. As one archaeologist has pointed out, I. Turtle; J. Double dragon-head arcli; K. Three-ring
all characters, or graphs, written with the jade ornament with pig-head protomes; L.Ax M. ; Three-hole
graph yu are associated with spiritual power or flat ornament; N. Bead; O. Bracelet; P. Pencil-shaped
2
beauty.' For example, the word bao ("precious") stick; Q. Bauble; R. Animal face with tusk-like
incorporates the jade graph. So does the word gtti extensions; S. Animal-face handle; T. Hook-shaped
(a kind of jasper stone or an adjective meaning handle. Neolithic period, Hongshau culture (ca. 3600-
"extraordinary" or "admirable"). ca. 2000 bce).
anecdotal descriptions, but rather through excavated evidence documents this reference: jade was the
finds and the earliest literary reference to ritual (//) primary medium exploited by the elite to
in Shang period bone inscriptions.' 3 The character symbolize their power to rule. Whether or not we
//'
incorporates the jade graph yu, suggesting by its use the label "Jade Age," the use of jade over an
inclusion that jade was the earliest material as art to approximate sixteen-hundred-year period (ca. 3600-
be used in religious worship. The function of jade 2400 bce) may be traced largely to coastal pari'- of
as a preservative and symbol of immortality is also China, an area of great cultural innovation at this
well known through Han alchemical practice and time. 15 Elite tribal groups forming what
the life-preserving quality that is signified in the anthropologists now describe as China's earliest
burial jade body suits of the Warring States and city-states are associated with these jade-working
Han periods. cultures the Liangzhu in China's southeastern
provinces of Zhejiang andjiangsu and in Shanghai;
JADE AS RITUAL IMPLEMENT AND INSIGNIA and slightly later Shandong Longshan cultures ol
The working of jade is well illustrated by numerous northeast China; but also possibly by the slightly
finds from the three successive late Neolithic earlier 1 -longshan, ol far northeast China, primarily,
cultures, that occupied coastal northern through 1 iaoning and Inner Mongolia provinces.
southern China, from Liaoning down as far as
Fujian. As Willetts once noted, Yuan Kang in The Jade types from I longshan tombs (see tig [) are
Lost Records of Yue (Yue jueslni), a Warring States sinking in their seemingly non-Chinese taste for
text, wrote that after the Stone (Neolithic) and sculpturally sensuous form. Two jades in this
before the Bronze and Iron ages, man used jade for exhibition an ornament 111 the form >>t hooked
weapons; this "Jade Age" was a period clouds with profile bird cat. 1) and an ornament in
contemporary with the legendary Five Emperors the form of a curling so-called pig-dragon {zlmloiig;
The pig-dragon (cat. 2) also suggests a potent B. Short and tall prismatic tubes (cong,); C.Ax head
symbol in its emphatic disposition which begins in and reconstructed ax with parts; D. End attachments to
a boar-like head flaunting tusks and beady eyes and the staff of an ax; E. Arrow and spear heads; F.Three-
ends in a short thick body curl. This fetal posture pronged headdress ornament; G. Trapezoid-shaped
emphasizing birth and nascent power is imitated in headdress ornament of a talisman; H. Lower body/shoe
the shape of the pictograph for qiu, the earliest ornament; I. D-shaped headdress ornament; J. Arc-shaped
lS
form for writing dragon in Chinese script. In all ornaments (huangj; K. Spindle whorl; L. Belt buckle;
later Chinese history, dragons bring rain and M. Staff knob; N. Bird, fish, cicada, tortoise, and frog
beneficence. During the Neolithic period the ornaments; O. Necklace ornament; P. Slit earrings;
Chinese domesticated the boar. As symbols of Q. Ornament; R. Plain and decorated bracelets. Neolithic
wealth, boar (or pig) skulls are commonly found in period, Liangzhu culture (ca. 3600 ca. 2000 BCE).
elite tombs. 19 That the image of dragon with boar
tusks and other fertility deities presided as symbols
of control in this northern Hongshan culture is also leaders, but now appears worked into shapes of
20
made clear by the remains of dragon and fertility ritual implements and weapons (fig. 2). Liangzhu
goddess sculptures, which decorated the wall of jade owners wielded power over more sophisticated
what, at Niuheliang, excavators describe as a and complex religious rites and political and
mother goddess temple. In addition to their military matters as well.
sculpted, wet clay rather than flat and linear, numbers complements the more complex scenario
calligraphically defined jades that are traditionally of ritual and socio-political administration that
associated with Chinese aesthetics. anthropologists currently describe as characterizing
China's earliest city-state. They propose that the
The Liangzhu culture, of overlapping and slightly Liangzhu culture encompassed a time span of
later date, reflects a more advanced social stage in roughly 3600/3300-2000 bce and that it included
the new and more complex layout of religio- four major phases. 21 Fully mature jade types
administrative centers, as well as an increased representing Liangzhu periods III IV of circa 3000-
complexity of jade types and their functions. In 2400 bce are represented in the exhibition by three
burials, jade not only decorates the dress of elite cong (cats. 3, 4, 5).
locally described as tuzhu jinzita ("earth- Yaoslian ,Yuhang county, Zhcjiang Province. Neolithic
22
constructed pyramids"). period, Liangzhu culture (ca. 3600-ca. 2000 bce).
forces in a universe that was conceived as Jiangsu Province, with (A:z) drawing ofjade cong. and
prismatically square. It is no accident that the (B) outdoor altar at Zhaolingshan, Jiangsu Province.
shamanic jangxiang, or u'tt, the major exorcizer of Neolithic period, Liangzhu culture (ca. 3600-ca. zooo
marvel of craftsmanship. Twenty-four tiny Fig. 3. Shape and decor of time exhibited jade prismatic tubes
representations of simple and complex mask types (cong): A. Cong (cat. 3) from tomb No. 12, Fanshan,
decorate all the flat surfaces of this vessel's exterior, Zhejiang Province; B. Cong (cat. 4) from Fuquanshan tomb
straddling all corners and intervening passages (fig. No. g, Qingpn county, Shanghai; C. Cong (cat. 3) from tomb
5 A). Two alternating image types the semihuman No. 3,11'ujin county, Jiangsu Province. Neolithic period,
mask with horizontally striated headdress and the Liangzhu culture (ca. 3600-ca. 2000 BCE).
Fig. 6A. T\ie bird and cloud motif on a jade disk (hi) Fig. SB.fade disk (bij. Neolithic period, Liangzhu
from the Freer Gallery ofArt, Smithsonian Institution, culture (ca. 3600-ca. 2000 BCE). Freer Gallery of Art,
Washington, D.C. (17.348). Neolithic period, Liangzhu Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC. (17.348).
culture (ca. 3600 ca. 2000 BCE).
;
1 A mouth, and headdress.
i
historical period, which begins with the Xia
| (ca. 2100-ca. 1600 BCE).The new jade types that
animal mask with layered eyelids and nasal ridge The blades (zhang; cats. 7, 8) reflect two styles. The
decorate each prismatic surface. These semihuman first is a classic Xia blade (zhang; cat. 7), seen in
and animal-mask images are also represented more excavated examples from Erlitou (fig. SA).The
complexly on the interstices. The latter, more handle is typically rendered with a delicate, dentiled
elaborate version portrays the semihuman with outline and paper-thin relief strips running from
feathered headdress, trapezoidal face, and winged top to bottom on the front side only. This
arms embracing the animal mask, which has tusks geometrically textured area contrasts with the
and framing limbs ending in claws (fig. 5). Both blade, which flares out and is slightly concave. The
Mou Yongkang and Wu Ruzuo have identified blade (cat. 8) from Sanxingdui, Guanghan, in
these masked deities as sun gods. 30 When depicted Sichuan Province, is a manneristically distorted
as two different images, they should be interpreted regional version of the classic Xia type. For
as a sun god and his vehicle, the embodiment of example, the blade's mouth does not flare; it comes
animal power. Working these minuscule motifs must to a point like a dagger-ax that then is bifurcated.
have required great delicacy and painstaking labor Comparable blades excavated from the same two
in digging and working away the surface with a hoards at Sanxingdui are equally eccentric (fig. SB).
tiny flint or diamond awl. Although it has altered in They either violate classical form through the
color to a chalky white, the cong retains its brilliant addition of an extraneous, small profile bird placed
luster, which through burnishing seems to have at the bifurcated mouth or destroy the beauty of
intentionally captured the rays of the sun. This cong the paper-thin strips through harsh, repetitive
has been nicknamed the "king of cong," after the incised lines across the handle. The latter examples
vessel's large size and superbly worked imagery. 3 '
parts, only one millimeter wide, of both the masked chatou), were used with abrasives 10 carve the
images and birds are filled with tiny whorling cloud insignia and their decor. The appearance of
scrolls. On the cong from tomb Number 3 at Sidun, multiple, small lengthwise scratches on .1 jade's
Jiangsu Province (cat. 5; fig. sC) thirteen levels of surface indicates burnishing with metal ripped
American totem pole of the Northwest. The more certain jades particularly, weapon-, in the form of
types that eventually replace the insignia are the flat and extended chest and body pectoral with
or round small figurines, designed more for additional, flanking jade insignia ot dagger-axes and
3S
decorative than ritual purposes. The small animal hi (fig. 10), excavated at Sanmenxia in 1990. This
and human figures popular during the Shang are earliest of jade face masks, dating to the ninth
represented in the exhibition by four pieces century bce, clearly anticipates the creation of a
excavated intact from the celebrated tomb complete jade body suit by the Western Han period
belonging to the Shang queen popularly referred to (206 bce-8 ce) in provinces as far afield as Hebei,
as Fu Hao, 34 but correctly identified by the name Shandong, Guangdong, Jiangsu, and Hubei. 39
Fu Zi. 35 Three of the jades represent variations of
the bird motif- one naturalistic version from the Sanmenxia has long been known as a Western
side (cat. 10(3]), another with headdress and Zhou cemetery site of the Guo state an
human-like legs tucked in profile (cat. 10(4]), and a enhefment that was probably of very early Western
third bird with ram's horns (cat. io[l]). A fourth Zhou date.
40
In the 1950s over two hundred tombs
small jade (cat. io[2]) of light translucent green were excavated at this site, and in the last fifteen
represents a human whose hands rest on his knees years new finds, including tomb Number 2001, to
in servile attitude. All four jades have holes for which the jade mask (cat. 12; fig. 10) belongs, were
attachment and were probably worn suspended as reported. This burial find is of high interest for
charms or decorative baubles. In the excavation what it says about Western Zhou burial rites and
report, jade figurines from this rich tomb amounted ritual reform, which required sets of vessels and
to over three hundred out of a total of six to seven jades that by their number and quality were
hundred jades. 3 designed to signify status. For example, tomb
Number 2001 included not only bronze sets of gni
JADE AS LIFE PRESERVATIVE AND ORNAMENT (grain), ding (meat), and li (steamer) vessels (six to
The Western Zhou period (ca. 1100-771 bce) is eight per set of identical form but different size),
represented here by two jade works. A jade dagger- but sets of chimes and bells, as well as other unusual
ax (ge\ cat. 11) from Xi'an, Shaanxi Province, is a art works such as an unprecedently early belt with
Western Zhou version of this weapon made gold decorative attachments and an iron sword with
popular during the Shang period. The Zhou date is jade fitting.
this point in Western Zhou history. the Soul" in the Chuci ("Songs of the South").
up the departed spirit which relatives and friends decorative object. Competitiveness in the arts was
sought to keep from drifting fir away. 44 After the at a premium during the Waning States period
invocation rite, the jade face mask would then be This was the time of "The Hundred Schools."
buried with the corpse. (In archaeological literature, when roving philosophers plied their trade in
this face mask is commonly described as a "sewn trying to win the support of an overlord. Confucius
jade face guard" [zhuiyu mianzhao].) The interest in allegedly worked the literati crowd ol' 1 u in
invoking the spirit is well known as the objective ot Shandong. By the seventh century BC1 . the central
the shaman that inspired the poem "Summons ot Zhou state was reduced to puppet status and was at
Fig. 10. Jade mask and pectoral from tomb No. 2001,
Shangcunling, Sanmeuxia, Henan Province. Western
jade the artistic domain of jade was not limited to Nanyuc, Guangdong Province. Eastern Zhou Western
this northwestern state. Jade girdles and pectorals Han periods (770 BCES CE).
8 CE).The Museum of the Western Han Tomb of the rise symmetrically out of tightly coiled C-hooks, a
Nanyue King, Guangzhou. motif that appeared on late Zhou bronze vessels
next world. There is, however, some question about texturally varied concoctions, and elegantly
which jade necklaces were worn in life and which inventive assemblages hung down the front ot both
appear to have been made for burial. The jades male and female aristocrats. Variations ot girdles and
initially used to create jade face masks from the pectorals, clanging and swaying, glittering and
late Western Zhou as represented by the jade face ringing signified dignity and rank a sonorous and
mask (cat. 12), and eventually body covers, well-dressed elite.
An early example of one these decorative Eastern animal carvings, those from the I Ian and later
Zhou pectoral jades is the small plaque (cat. [3; periods tend to be more naturalistic. The winged
fig. 11) excavated in 1987 from Xiasi, Xichuan horse (cat. 17) and so-called bixic (a winged lion
county, in Henan Province. This jade (only with horns, cat. iN) illustrate the new naturalism,
7.1 centimeters high) apparently came from tomb seen in images ofboth mythical and non-mythical
Number 1, which belonged to the wife of the Chu animals of Han date (2or< m 1-220 ce). Although
Prince Shuzhi Sun Peng, chief minister of Chu stereotyped through such conventions as the arched
wearing the distinctive mortarboard-style headdress. Xi'an, Shaanxi Province: 1. (top) lion plaque (detail,
It has its source in the Daoist cult of immortality cat. 20) and 2. (bottom) Persian tribute-bearer plaque.
symbolizing the mountain Kunlun, which was the Tang dynasty (618 goy).
domain of the Goddess of the West (Xiwangmu)
(see cats. 19, 49, 50, 51). This scene in relief
complements the Hongshan Neolithic sculpted decor of so many of the solid silver and gold vessels
ornament. Both are emblematic: the Hongshan jade of this hoard, the major decorative motifs of the
(cat. 1) represents a bird amid clouds, most likely belt represent Central Asian and Persian subjects.
signifying the skyward realm of heaven; and the The belt is composed of sixteen pieces: fourteen
relief on the Western Jin vessel (cat. 19) represents that are square and two that are D-shaped. On the
the heavenly abode of Mount Kunlun, where back of each piece are loops where the piece was
immortality was granted by an empowered goddess. sewn to a leather backing. Each jade piece was
worked into a relief image of a lion: poses vary
Jade continued to be valued for its immortal power from standing, sitting, sniffing, to pawing the air
and beauty during the Tang dynasty (618-907). The all different and all indicative of a very lively animal
translucent Xinjiang white jade belt excavated from (fig. i4B:l).This motif is one of three that appear
a cache at the village of Hejia, in Xi'an, Shaanxi to be popular on jade belts of eighth-century Tang
Province (cat. 20; fig. 14B) is one superb example. date. The other themes are also exotic, featuring
Discovered in 1970, this cache has become famous Persians playing musical instruments or Persians
for its gold and silver vessels, amounting to about bringing tribute offerings (figs. 14A, B:2).The lion
270 out of some 1000 objects, which are is also well known as foreign to Tang and earlier
unprecedented for their variety, workmanship, and China, and is probably of Central Asian origin. 5 '
(Hongkong: Woods Publishing, zhounian jinian wenji ("The yuyan suo zhuankan 50), p. 49.
SOURCES FOR FIGURES Civilization Collected Essays 14. Willetts, Chinese Art, p. 90;
Fig. i . After Elizabeth Childs- Fig. 14 A. After Zhongguo in Commemoration of the Yuan Kang, Yue jue situ, ed.
Johnson, "Jades of the Hongshan meishu quanji, vol. 60th Anniversary of the Qian Peiming, vol. 13 (Beijing:
9
Culture," hits Asiatiques 36 (Shijiazhuang: Hebei meishu Discovery of Liangzhu Zhonghua chubanshe, 1985),
chubanshe, 1993), Culture") (Nanjing: Nanjing p. 5S; or Yue jue shu, Sibu
(1991), Jig. i, p. 83. pi. 219,
pp. 12021.
bowuyuan, 1996), congkan ed., vol. 62, p. 93b.
(1988), figs. 19-20, p. 12; Gems of in William Willetts, Chinese Art, the Hongshan Culture," p. 95.
(New York: George 8. For the argument that shark
the Liangzhu Culture: From vol. 1
Fig. 7. After Elizabeth Childs- "Stones from Heaven," Ancient Zhejiang wenwu ehu, ed..
('993). PP- 112-14; and for the
Johnson, "'Symbolic Jades oj the
Chinese Jade Symposium, Los Liangzhu guyu ("Ancient Jade
argument on the diamond
Erlitou Period" Archives of Angeles County Museum of o( Liangzhu'
1
)
(Hang
point, sec I [ayashi Minao,
Asian Art 48 (1995), fig. 2, p. 66.
Natural History, 24 March Zhejiang wenwu chubanshe.
"Liangzhu wenhua yuqi,"
1996); and Elizabeth Childs- 1996), pp. to"
p. 338.
Fig. 8. After Elizabeth Childs-
Johnson, Ritual and Power: Jades
Johnson, "Symbolic Jades of the ofAncient China (New York: ii. Bian Fcngshi,"! iangzhu
fane! >ouglas, persona]
Erlitou Period" Archives of
China Institute, 1988).
J I
Zhejiang, 14 November no. 2 (1994), PP- H5-I9- pp. 121-40. For other examples, see jade Hebei meishu chubanshe,
1996). For an English summary masks illustrated in Luoyang 1993), pi. 108, and p. 40. This
of Song's paper, see Elizabeth 28. See, for example, a 35. For example, see Chang Zhongzhoulu, (Beijing: Kexue jade is probably unfinished
Childs-Johnson, "The reference to this myth in the Cheng-lang, "A Brief chubanshe, 1959); see also since there is a lack of
International Symposium on Huainanzi, in John Major, Discussion of FuTzu,"in Kaogu yanjiu suo, ed., corresponding detail on one of
Liangzhu Culture," Early China Heaven and Earth in Early Han Chang, ed.. Studies of Shang
"Tianma Qucun yizhi the upper sides; one side of the
News 9 (1996), p. 28. Thought: Chapters Three, Four, Archaeology, pp. 103-20. Beizhao Jinhou mudi disanzi piece lacks the corresponding
and Five of the Huainanzi yu disizi fajue" (The Third and filler detail of the claw and
22. As used by Li Wenming and (Albany: State University ot 36. Yinxu Fu Hao mu ("The Fourth Excavations of the scale motifs. This piece may be
Wu Rongqing, "Zhongguo New York Press, 1993), p. 49; Burial of Fu Hao atYinxu) Cemetery of the Marquis ot compared with one similar in
wuqiannianqian de 'tuzhu and in David Hawkes, Ch'tt (Beijing: Wenwu chubanshe, Jin at Tianmu Qucun size and shape from the
jinzita' -Jiangsu Kunshanshi Tz'u: Tlie Songs of the South 1980), pp. 114-15. For an Remains"), Wenwu, no. 8 Cunguoji burial at Lianjiaxian,
Zhaolingshan yizhi ji qi chutu (Oxford: Clarendon Press, English translation of the (1994), pp. 4-33. For the Shandong; ibid., pi. 103.
wenwu" ("The Five- 1959). P- 47- original site report, see recently excavated jade face
Thousand- Year-Old Earthen Elizabeth Childs-Johnson, mask ofWestern Han date 48. Representative examples of
Pyramid of China The 29. Major, Heaven and Earth, Excavation of Tomb No. 5 at from Changqingxian, this popular jade dragon type
Remains and Relics Unearthed Yinxu, Anyang, Chinese Shandong, see Zhongguo are illustrated in Zhongguo yuqi
PP- 38-39-
at Zhaolingshan, Kunshanshi, Sociology and Anthropology wenwubao (10 October 1996), quanji 3: Clutnqiu Zhanguo
Jiangsu"), Longyu wenwu yishu 30. Mou Yongkang, "Dongfang Series, vol. 15, no. 3 (Armonk, p. 1. ("The Complete Set of
(1993) 17, pp. 24-32. shiqian shiqi taiyang chongbai N.Y.: M. E. Sharpe, 1983), p. 83. Chinese Jade 3: Spring and
de kaogu xue guancha" 43.J.J. M. de Groot, The Autumn and Warring States
23. Che Guangjin,"Yu cong ("Archaeological Investigation 37. Kaogu yanjiu suo, ed., Religious System of China Periods") (Shijiazhuang: Hebei
yu Sidun yizhi" ("The of Sun Worship in the East Shatigcunliug Guoguo mudi (reprint, Taibei: Chengwen, meishu chubanshe, 1993),
Remains of Sidun and the Jade During the Neolithic"), ("The Cemetery of the Guo 1969), chap. 3, pp. 269-74. pis. 36-40, 132-33, 209, 213-15.
Cong"), Zhongguo wenwu bao Gugong xucshu jikau 12 (1995), State at Shangcunling")
(31 December 1995), p. 3; p. 4; Mou Yongkang, "Liangzhu (Beiiing: Kexue chubanshe, 44. Yili ("The Classic of 49. For the site report on
reprinted in Xu, ed., Dongfang yuqi shang shen chongbai de 1959), pi. 21:810. Rites"), Sibu congkan ed., Huangshantou, Anxiang,
wanning, pp. 371-73. tansuo" ("Discussion of Deity Vol. 12. Hunan Province, see "Hunan
Worship ot Liangzhu Jades"), 38. For the site report on this Anxiang Xi Jin Liuhong Mu"
24. Ji Jianfang, in "Liangzhu Qtngzhu Su Bingqi kaogu tomb, see Kaogu yanjiu suo, 45. Hawkes, Ch'tt Tz'u, ("The Tomb of Liuhong ot the
wenhua mucang yanjiu" wuslnwu nian lunwenji ed.,"Sanmenxia Shangcunling pp. 105-9. Western Jin at Anxiang,
("Research on Burials of the ("Collected Essays Celebrating Guoguo mudi M2001 fajue Hunan") Wenwu, no. 11 (1993),
Liangzhu Culture"), in Xu, ed., Fifty-five Years of Su Bing's lianbao" ("A Brief Excavation 46. Jade trom other, earlier pp. 1-12.
Dongfang wenming, fig. 12, Archaeological Research") Report ot Tomb No. 2001 at contexts was often reused to
p. 191, proposes a slightly (Beijing: Wenwu chubanshe, the Cemetery of the Guo State make face masks for example, 50. For the site report on
different design which he 1989), p. 186; and Wu Ruzuo, at Shangcunling, Sanmenxia"), for those buried in the Jin state Hejiacun, Xi'an, Shaanxi
describes as a patriarchal clan "Luolun Changjiang, Huanghe Huaxia kaogu, no. 3 (1992), cemetery at Beizhao, Tianma- Province, see "Xi'an Nanjiao
cemetery mound at Hang Huyu shiqian shiqi de pp. 104-13. Qucun, Shanxi Province; see Hejiacun faxianTangdai
Zhaolingshan (see fig. 4B in taiyangshen congbai" Wenwu, no. 1 (1994), p. 27. jiaocang wenwu" ("The
Zhang Zhiheng,
this essay). ("Discussion of SunGod 39. For a very recent discovery "Pseudo-jade" was used to Cultural Relics from the
"Liangzhu wenhua juluo qun Worship Along the Two River of an early Western Han jade create burial suits for some Cache of the Tang Dynasty
de tezheng" ("Special Valleys ot the Yellow River burial suit, see the report on occupants ot the Nanyue Discovered at Hejiacun,
Characteristics of Settlement During the Neolithic"), the burial of Liu He at the tombs (tomb No. 2); see Wen Nanjiao, Xi'an"), Wenwu, no. 1
Groups of Liangzhu Culture"), Huaxia kaogu, no. 2 (1996), Han imperial burial center Guang "Xi Han Nanyue {1972), pp. 30-42.
Zhongguo wenwu bao (7 April pp. 75-85. near Xuzhou, Jiangsu Province, wangmu yuqi di zhi kaogu xue
1996), p. 3, reviews evidence in Zhongguo wenwu bao yanjiu" ("Geological and 51. For an explanation of the
for a similar structure at 31. Zhejiang sheng wenwu, (20 October 1996), p. 1. Archaeological Research on origin of the lion in China, see
Mojiaoshan, although this site ed., Liangzhu wenhua yuqi, Jades from the Royal Tomb of Laurence Sickman and
also possesses significant 184. the King of Nanyue"), Gugong Alexander Soper, The Art and
p. 40. See Kaogu yanjiu suo, ed.,
remains of columned Shangcunling Guoguo mudi, xuexujikan 11, no. 1 (1993), Architecture of China, (reprint,
foundations. 32. Elizabeth Childs-Johnson, pp. 48-54, and pp. S3-85 pp. 930; and Wen Guang, "Yu Harmondsworth: Penguin
"Symbolic Jades of the Erlitou (English summary). yu min guyu" ("True and Books, 1984), pp. 61-62.
25. Che, "Yu cong yu Sidun Period: A Xia Royal Tradition," Pseudo-Jade"), Gugong wenwu
yizhi," p. 3. Archives of Asian Art 48 (1995), According to the yuekan 11, no. 4 (1993),
41. site
27. FanYuzhou,"Yinxu buci Oracle Bone Inscriptions," in ("Burial Jades of the Western p. 324; for the jade, see also
zhong de 'wu' yu 'wu di'" K. C. Chang, ed.. Studies of Zhou Excavated Material at
Zhongguo meishu quanji, 9: Yuqi
Epitome of Ancient
Chinese Civilization
Ma Chengyuan
Director, The Shanghai Museum
69
of China's bronzes is unmatched by those of any Xia domains after the dynasty was founded. Ot
other Bronze Age civilization. course, the picture of Xia bronzes is far from
complete. Much more archaeological excavation of
which note that bronze casting was already quite into early, middle, and late periods.
culture. The Erlitou site atYanshi, Henan Province, Erligang period, have been found mainly at
which predates the Erligang site of the Shang at Zhengzhou, Henan Province, and date
Zhengzhou, was discovered during the 1950s. approximately to the sixteenth century BCE. New
Found in the third level of the tumulus at Erlitou vessel shapes such as the gong, zun, and li appeared
were a tomb and bronze vessels, weapons, and jades during this period. The strong primitive inclination
bronzes of the Erlitou culture atYanshi comprised absent in those of Erligang. Among bronzes ot this
primarily jue, but also jia, he, and cooking vessels. In period zoomorphic masks (taotie) are the most
shape, these vessels were exceedingly similar to commonly seen decorative motif, and animal forms
pottery vessels of the same period or earlier. The were used extensively as well.
closely resembles the pottery jue found at the Mid-Shang saw further variations in the types of
Erlitou site, and is obviously primitive in its casting bronzes. Shapes were gradually perfected.
and design. Xia bronzes also include some relatively Decoration expanded to cover much of the surfaces
finely worked pieces. of the vessels, and also greatly increased in both the
line density and complexity of composition.
Some of the more distinctive Xia bronzes are Further development produced decorative patterns
turquoise-inlaid ornamental plaques of unknown rendered in strong relief, and bronzes began to be
use. But apart from these and a very few vessels that ornamented with animal heads done in high relief.
bear simple geometric decorations, the vast Casting technology extended to the casting of large
majority of Xia bronzes are plain and undecorated. vessels, as revealed by the number of large zim and
In this, they differ greatly from the Shang Erligang other vessels discovered. A large square ding, a meter
period bronzes from Zhengzhou, which are tall, has also been unearthed at the site of the Shang
generally decorated with zoomorphic patterns. One city in Zhengzhou. Bronzes of the middle period
of the items unearthed at Erlitou is a round bronze include the dragon-and-tiger suif discovered at
ornament decorated with an inlaid turquoise cross Funan, Anhui Province; a jar with movable loop
within concentric circles, a decoration unique to handles' found with a group of bronzes at
the Erlitou culture. A bronze ax (yue) with similar Zhengzhou, Henan Province; and bronzes from
inlaid turquoise crosses in a circle is in the some of the sumptuous Shang tombs at Panlong
collection of the Shanghai Museum, and its date city in Huangpi county, Hubei Province. 4 All of
can be ascertained through a comparison with the these vessels are markedly more mature than the
objects from Erlitou. This yue, which is very large early Shang bronzes of the Erligang period at
and heavy, is the most magnificent of extant Xia Zhengzhou. At the same time they differ noticeably
bronzes; it was not a functional weapon but a from the late Shang bronzes, marking the period
symbol of military authority. From it, we may from the fifteenth through the fourteenth, or
anticipate the discovery of similarly large and perhaps into the thirteenth, century BCE as one
impressive Xia bronzes. Functional bronze weapons of transition.
found at the Erlitou site include dagger-axes (ge)
and battle-axes (iji).The Xia bronzes discovered to The late Shang was the greatest period in the
date were cast in the latter part of the Xia dynasty. development of Chinese bronzes, showing the
largest variety of shapes and decorative schema, and
Palace foundations and groups of tombs have been the bronzes from the "Yin ruins" at Anyang, Henan
found at sites of the Erlitou type located along the Province, offer the most representative and
Yellow River in Henan Province; similar culture complete view of the period. Along with the
sites are also located north of the Yellow River in increase in types of objects there developed set
southern Shanxi.The remains of a rather large early rules governing the proper combinations of vessels,
Shang city, which is later than the Erlitou site, has and the shapes of pieces reached a fully mature
been discovered east of Yanshi. According to stage. New to this period were vessels in the shape
historical records, this region became part of the of birds and animals. In these vessels artistry and
practicality were superbly integrated, as exemplified which existed in what is now Jiangsu, Zhejiang,
by the Fuhaoxia zun in this exhibition (cat. 24). and Shanghai, were often carved with images of
deities represented by their two eyes. Often, a bird
It is noteworthy that the bronzes with the most in flight was placed on each side of the deity, with
distinctive animal designs are often found far from the birds' heads turned away from the central
Anyang, in peripheral areas of the Shang domain. image. The heads of the birds accompanying the
For instance, the pig zun and elephant zun in this zoomorphic masks on late Shang bronzes are the
exhibition (cats. 27, 25) were unearthed in Hunan. same as those on the Liangzhu culture jades,
Moreover, Shang bronzes from places other than indicating that this type of decoration was an
Anyang, particularly those from Hunan and Jiangxi adoption and continuation of the traditions of
provinces, which lie south of theYangzi River, do Liangzhu culture. Oracle bone inscriptions describe
not merely differ in their form from those at the phoenix as the Wind God and also the envoy of
Anyang but are often conspicuously more ornate. the Celestial Emperor, 7 entrusted with the mission
This kind and degree of difference merits our of relaying information between Heaven and
attention. Why were these most lavish Shang humans. An animal mask flanked by bird patterns
bronzes not unearthed in the area that was the may have been an image of deity. The decorative
political and economic center of the Shang dynasty, motifs on Shang bronzes always invoke the Celestial
but rather in places so distant as to be regarded as Emperor and various spirits; they were not merely
barren wilderness in that era? Their exquisite more or less stylized animals. Rather, they expressed
craftsmanship indicates that these pieces could not a strong religious desire for communion between
have been cast in such places, and the names of Heaven and humans and for blessings from the
individuals and clans cast on some of the bronzes Celestial Emperor and various spirits. The birds
show that they were possessions of some of the flanking the zoomorphic masks may represent the
great clans of central China. Archaeological data phoenix as emissary in these transactions. The great
gathered during their excavation shows that flourishing of decorative art on Shang bronzes
unlike the bronzes found at Anyang the vast manifests religious aspiration.
majority of them were not burial furnishings, nor
are there any signs that they were ever used in sets The casting of Shang bronzes was done in pottery
for rituals. They were generally buried at various section molds. Specially prepared clay was made
sites atop mountains or along the banks of rivers. It into the number of external and internal mold
is highly possible that these choice samples of sections required by a particular shape. Patterns and
Shang bronzes were specially imported into the inscriptions were carved or incised into the
peripheral regions, where they were regarded as external mold sections. After being thoroughly
expressions of respect and admiration for Shang dried and fired, the mold sections were fitted
culture. In 1963 an animal mask you was unearthed together and reinforced to form a complete mold,
in Ningxiang, Hunan Province. Inside this vessel which was fitted with a cover containing a pouring
were over a thousand solid and tubular jade beads.' hole for the bronze to enter and one or more holes
This exhibition features the Ge you, from a royal through which air bubbles would be expelled.
tomb in Ningxiang, Hunan Province, which also Molten bronze was poured between the inner and
contained over three hundred jade beads, jade outer molds. After the bronze had cooled, the mold
pieces, and tubular jade beads (cat. 26). An animal was broken and the bronze removed and given .1
mask pou found in Hunan contained over two final finishing and polishing. Shang workmanship in
hundred small bronze ax heads. From this, we can the making of pottery molds was extremely hue.
see that in this outlying region Shang bronzes were and set the highest standards in the ancient world
preserved as a form of wealth. Perhaps future for the casting of bronze pieces in pottery molds.
archaeological discoveries will elucidate the Pottery molds were used exclusively to cast bron; es
formation and nature of this cultural phenomenon. through the Eastern Zhou, after which additional
methods were introduced.
The most common decorative motif found on late
Shang bronzes is the zoomorphic mask formerly WESTERN ZHOU BRONZI S
known as the taotie pattern. This was generally (IITH CENTURY-771 BCE)
executed in clearly layered relief against a dense and Early Western Zhou (ea. [050-ca. 975) bn
fine-lined intaglio spiral pattern. In particular, the making was to a large extent a continuation ot late
eyes of the mask were made large and prominent, Shang practices. 1 ate Shang and earl) Western
enhancing the mysterious, solemn, and intimidating Zhou are often considered as .1 single and
aspect of the image. On late Shang bronzes small supreme period in the evolution of Chinese bronze
birds or small dragons often flank the mask, with making. Withal, the Zhou people differed
bird patterns the more frequent. This type of design significantly from the Shang people in their
composition has ancient historical origins. Late political organization, religion, and cultural
Neolithic jade cons from the Liangzhu culture. > on< epts, differences concretely manifested as time
corresponding increase in bronze vessels for food. gradually changed in appearance. Major parts of the
The establishment of rites that stressed food rather mask, such as the relatively well-formed ears,
than drink led directly to considerable development eyebrows, mouth, fangs, and claws, were simplified
of such existing types of bronze food vessels as the or sometimes omitted altogether. The eyes, which
ding, the yan, and the gui. The large round ding of had been the paramount feature, lost their former
the Western Zhou greatly outnumbered those of power, sometimes being reduced to two small,
the Shang; the yan was used more extensively than socket-less circles, and at other times only faintly
during the Shang; square-based gui, such as the Li suggested by a stylized outline. These changes
gui and Da Feng gui from the time of King Wu, drained the masks of their former solemnity,
were entirely new to this era. The Zhou attached ferocity, and mystery.
great importance to ancestor worship, in strong
contrast to the Shang worship of gods and spirits. The middle period of the Western Zhou also saw a
Religious connotations are less apparent in noticeable reduction in the use of dragon and bird
bronze decorations of the Western Zhou. Apart patterns for bronze decoration and, as with the
from zoomorphic masks, the most gorgeously zoomorphic masks, modifications in the design of
executed bronze motif of the Western Zhou, these traditional motifs. These modifications
particularly during the time of kings Kang and transformed the dragons and birds into what were
Zhao (perhaps early ioth c), was the phoenix formerly known as "curved zigzag patterns" what
pattern. Phoenix patterns, beautifully accomplished we now call "modified animal patterns,"
in limitless variety, became a feature of this period, "intertwined animal eye patterns," "coiled animal
imparting an aura of wealth and luxury to the body patterns," etcetera. These patterns were
bronzes. Their vogue, however, was brief; beginning generally composed as continuous bidirectional
in middle Western Zhou, such sumptuous phoenix horizontal bands of decoration around the bronzes,
patterns were seldom to be found on bronzes. imparting a sense of simplicity and sprightliness.
But, like the last burst of twilight, they brought the The most distinctive pattern of this period was the
peak period of Chinese bronze making to a wave pattern (formerly known as the "curved band
magnificent close. pattern"), whose regular, rhythmic undulations
create a powerful sense of motion.
capital, Chengzhou (in the area around present-day variants, one was flat-bottomed with a relatively
Luoyang, Henan Province) by King Cheng, shallow belly, the other round-bottomed and deep-
successor of the Zhou conqueror: "It was at the bellied. The principal form of gui had a contracted
time when the king began the building of Cheng- mouth with cover, swelling belly, two symmetrically
zhou. . . .This happened in [King Cheng's] fifth placed animal-shaped lug handles spanning the
8
year." These inscriptions are our most direct and belly, and three evenly spaced zoomorphs serving as
most reliable historical sources for the study of feet under a ring base. The decorative combinations
ancient Chinese history. were also more fixed: for example, a flat-bottomed,
shallow ding would generally have a modified
From the reign of King Mu of the Western Zhou, animal pattern around the lip and a wave pattern
the types, shapes, and decorations of the bronzes around the belly, whereas a ding with deep belly and
changed significantly reflecting new customs and rounded bottom was usually more simply
uses. Bronze wine vessels, including the jia, gong, decorated, sometimes with only a few parallel lines
zun, and you, essentially faded from use, and under the lip, sometimes with an overlapping fish-
although some new shapes such as the ling appeared scale pattern in a band around the lip. This trend
to take their place, the proportion of wine vessels toward formulanzation suggests a certain stagnation
was much smaller than before. Beginning in the in bronze making at this time; nevertheless, some
middle period (ca. 975-875) of the Western Zhou, items produced for royal use were still very well
many new types of food vessels such as the fu and made. During the late Western Zhou the greatest
shu appeared, and older types of food vessels such as innovation in bronze decoration was the interlaced
the dou and pu were used more extensively than dragon pattern. This consisted of a central dragon
before. New variants of some commonly used flanked on both sides by several subsidiary dragons.
merely overlapped but passed under-and-over one had prevailed since the late Western Zhou has here
another, creating a sense of undulant motion that been wholly replaced by the innovative spirit first
was further developed during Eastern Zhou. Late apparent in the mid-Spring and Autumn era.
hu recently unearthed from the tomb of the Spring and Autumn era are best exemplified by
Marquis of Jin in Quwo, Shanxi Province, both works from the kingdoms of Qin in the west, Jin in
bear this type of pattern. the north, Qi in the east, and Chu in the south. In
AND AUTUMN AND WARRING STATES Liyu village in Hunyuan. Shanxi Province. These,
PERIODS (770-221 BCE) together with the bronzes recently found in tomb
Aristocratic tombs of the early Spring and Autumn number 251 at Jinsheng village inTaiyuan, can be
era have revealed very few bronzes that were considered representative of Jin style bronzes
relatively well crafted. The Zhou kings had lost the (cats. 43, 44),
9 whereas those from the Chu tomb at
western part of their domain and relocated their Xiasi, Xiquan county, in Henan Province are typical
Luoyang. In the smaller states that made up the the recently discovered he of King Fuchai of Wu is
Zhou realm, bronze making was rather crude. In an example of how features of the Jin and Chu
the larger states, however, signs of progress were bronzes were absorbed and integrated elsewhere."
already appearing.
Improvements in casting techniques using pottery
By the mid-Spring and Autumn era Zhou kingly section molds, the spread of the complementary
authority had declined and the various fiefdoms processes of casting-on and precasting, and the
were expanding their power and their borders and considerable maturing of the lost-wax casting
beginning to come into collision. But as the technique all reflect significant advances in the
authority of the Zhou ruling house dwindled and bronze technology of this period. A major
the political and military struggles between the revolution in the art of bronze making during the
states intensified, ideas and political institutions Spring and Autumn and Warring States periods was
evolved apace. Unsettled times stimulated major the use of stamps to create the surface designs in
advances in the forces of social production, the molds. Besides increasing the number of
begetting countless new forms of workmanship. bronzes that could be produced, it also assured the
The earlier forging of iron weapons and uniform quality of the decorative patterns on the
implements led to mastery of the art of casting pieces. This advanced technique is seen most
iron. Bronzes became an indispensable symbol of frequently among the extant bronzes ot the Jin
power, status, and legitimacy for the new elites in state. Excavation of the site of the Jin bronze
the aristocratic states, spurring bronze making to an workshop at Houma in Shanxi Province has fully
unprecedented period of innovation and revealed the advanced bronze casting technology of
development. To meet rapidly escalating military the time.'- Advances such as the use of stamps in
needs, the casting of bronze weapons was also mold-making changed the nature ot creating
carried to new heights. Even some small states surface decoration: only the maker ot the stamp
possessed significant quantities of bronzes, and with required artistry: the workers who impressed the
the breakdown of centralized patronage along with design from the stamp onto the mold needed only
centralized authority, regional traits of bronzes of simple technical skill. Subsequently new arts ot
this period became quite distinct. surface decorating appeared, using inlaid gold,
New vessels appeared, and old types were rendered The gold, silver, and copper would be hammered
with fresh shapes and unusual designs, which made into sheets or threads, and the threads might be
for an entirely new look. Included in this coiled into tight spirals, then inlaid into the grooves
exhibition is the square lotus-and-crane hu (cat. 45) cast in the bronze to receive them. (. In some
found in Xinzheng, Henan Province, in 1923. bronzes, copper, gold, silver, and turquoise were
Openwork petals rise from the lid, on which stands inlaid in combination to form a sumptuous,
a crane raising its wings as if about to fly. Lug brocade-like design.
handles on two sides of the hu take the form of
crested dragons looking backward, and winged It was during the late Spring and Autumn period
dragons mark the four corners of the square belly. that human activity began to be used .is .1
Iwo powerful slinking animals support the vessel, decorative motif. .1 clear manifestation of the
which is decorated overall with an interlaced unprecedentedly strong social humanism ot the
double-bodied dragon pattern. The effect is opulent tune. Subjects like battles, hunting, banquets, rituals,
inlaid gemstones. Both linear and fully modeled and Autumn Era Tomb (no.
Jenny So
Curator of Ancient Chinese Art,
Freer Gallery of Art and Arthur M.
Sackler Gallery, Smithsonian Institution,
ERLITOU PERIOD Washington, D.C.
75
LIAONING
INNER MONGOLIA
AUTONOMOUS REGION
Site O City
Map l. Map of China showing major ancient and modern cities and sites.
Map 2. Map of China in the Tang dynasty showing Eurasia and the Silk Road.
Metallurgical analysis ot the Erlitou wine cups clay. 3 It is possible to incise designs into the hard
shows that they were cast from a deliberate alloy of surface of cold bronze, but such a technique could
copper and tin, poured in a molten state into a not have created the flowing rhythm ot the many
mold made up of four or more fitted sections. The scroll designs on the early bronzes. The raised linear
alloy and casting (instead of cold-working) designs on the fang ding (cat. 22) embody the
technology evident on these vessels, as well as the decorative possibilities of section-mold casting
mold-assembly methods, were major innovations in technique at their simplest: lines incised on the
material use and manufacturing technique for interiors of mold sections become raised lines
China of the early second millennium bce. But (thread relief) on the cast vessel. Continuous
these first bronzes were also firmly linked to refinement of this unique advantage offered by
China's older, established ceramic industry. The section molds enabled the bronze workers to create
eccentric shape of the wine cup, certainly not easily vessels with ever more ornate surfaces from circa
cast in bronze, was based on cups commonly made 1300 to circa 1 100 bce (cats. 23-26). 4
in pottery during the early second millennium bce
(fig. l).The potter's experience in maintaining high More amazing, perhaps, than the advance in
kiln temperatures must have contributed to the decorative technique is the existence, as early as the
bronze maker's ability to smelt, refine, and mix his mid-second millennium bce, of foundries that
ores for casting. Excavations at Erlitou habitation could handle such monumental castings as the fang
sites also yielded fragments of clay casting molds, ding (cat. 22). Nor was this rectangular cauldron,
further demonstrating that the early bronze casters which weighs about 40 kilograms and is S2
worked closely with potters of the time. 2 centimeters high, entirely unique in its time: it was
found, in a shallow pit at Qian village, Pinglu
ZHENGZHOU PERIOD county, Shanxi Province, with two round ding
The unassuming beginning exemplified by the vessels, each about 70 centimeters high. 3 Farther
small drinking cup (cat. 21) does not prepare us for east, in the vicinity of Zhengzhou. Henan Province,
the bronze caster's astonishing progress in the believed to be the site of one of the earliest capitals
following centuries. By 1500-1400 BCE the of the Shang dynasty.'' three separate discoveries
undecorated early vessels had given way to vessels have unearthed eight other square or rectangular
with surfaces enhanced by varied scrolled designs cauldrons, closely comparable to the present
(cat. 22). Bronze makers must have been quick to example in size and decoration, together with
realize (lie decorative potential offered by a casting additional large round ding vessels.' I he largest ol
technique that utilized section molds (fig. 1): it gave these fang ding is 100 centimeters high and weighs
access to the interior surface of the mold, allowing S2.4 kilograms.
designs to be executed with relative ease in the soli
ANYANG PERIOD
Sometime around 1300 bce the Shang kings
relocated their capital to the vicinity of present-day fringes of the Shang domain, along the Yangzi
Anyang in northern Henan Province. The two River basin. 9
centuries or so between the manufacture of the fang
ding (cat. 22) and the bronzes associated with the Conceptually different from vessels incorporating
court at Anyang (cats. 2326), saw huge strides in animal forms are two creations (cats. 27, 25) that are
the bronze caster's craft. By about 1200 bce not wholly sculptural. An accidental find in Hunan
only were China's bronze casters able to create Province, south of the Yangzi River, the boar (cat.
dense, multilayered decoration on a vessel's surface, 27) is exceptional not just for its size but for its
they were also able to produce vessels with realism; its cloven hoofs, boarish snout, and tusks
complex shapes that must have challenged the are all carefully observed and convincingly
ingenuity of the section-mold makers of the time. depicted. Even the fine scale-pattern and the large
Whereas decorating the bronze surface allowed spiraling motifs on its haunches evoke the animal's
bronze casters to develop two-dimensional designs, hide and musculature. Unlike most bronzes of the
the inherent three-dimensional form of the vessels time, the boar is not a container, and we can only
presented opportunities to create sculpturally. For surmise its function. Cylindrical channels running
example, a fairly ordinary abstract shape a four- crosswise through the boar's front and back
sided vessel (cat. 23) became, with the addition of haunches suggest that it might have been carried,
a ram at each of the vessel's four corners, an by means of poles inserted through the channels,
inspired organic form that still fulfilled its function perhaps at ceremonial processions. 10 If so, the
as a container. The rams' heads emerge as fully choice of animal would have been related to the
three-dimensional sculptures, while their chests and religious or ritual requirements of the local
front legs appear 111 relief, rendered with astonishing (southern) patrons for whom it was made. The
realism amid a dense sea of spiral and scroll elephant (cat. 25), one of only two known (the
patterns. The shallow well of the large basin (cat. other is in the Freer Gallery of Art, Smithsonian
29) becomes a viable pool for the coiled dragon Institution), served a better-attested function as a
whose three-dimensional head rises most wine or water container." Though a vessel, it too is
convincingly from its two-dimensional snakelike animal-shaped; its elaborate surface motifs, however,
body. These vessels are made more remarkable by are utterly nondescriptive of elephants. The small
their unusual size the basin is the largest example hare-like creature perched on top of the elephant's
of its kind and by the likelihood that they were trunk serves no function but presents an
made not in the capital region of Anyang but in incongruous therefore witty juxtaposition.
workshops in the remote southern and southeastern
anomalous both as vessels and as animals. Neither manufacture (ca. 1500-1300 bce); if correct, this
accurately represents a real animal or can be linked means that local bronze-casting workshops were in
to a specific shape in the standard vessel repertoire. operation in the south at about the same time as
The silhouette of catalogue 28 suggests a snake or a their northern counterparts in the Shang heartland
crocodile; in fact, both snakes and crocodiles appear along the Yellow River basin.
as decorative motifs on its surface. It is likely that
the creators of this vessel, excavated in the brackish Dramatic evidence of the geographical extent of
semidesert region of northern Shared Province, in southern bronze casting and the skills of the casters
the middle reaches of the Yellow River basin, were has been afforded by recent discovery of two
2
actually familiar with these creatures. '
shaped vessel (cat. 24) is one of a pair recovered second millennium bce, at Sanxingdui, Guanghan
from the late thirteenth-century bce tomb of the county, Sichuan Province in southwestern China.' 7
Shang royal consort Fu Hao at Anyang, Henan The Sanxingdui pits and Fu Hao's tomb at Anyang
Province.' 3
It is not based on any recognizable bird, are closely contemporary but about eight hundred
although its large hooked beak suggests that of a miles apart, and the bronzes from the two sites
parrot. The ambiguity of its shape carries over onto differ strikingly in type, form, and size (fig. 3). The
its decoration, where visual puns and double impressive bronze mask (cat. 30), the largest of three
meanings tease the eye and the imagination. Two recovered at Guanghan, has no parallel elsewhere in
dragons diving onto the bird's forehead double as China. Its function and context of use are unclear,
horns; the large spirals of its wings are also coiled its form and size unprecedented, and the meaning
serpents; an owl, with distinctive eyes and beak, of its extraordinary projecting pupils is a mystery.
appears as part of the tail feathers. The small three- That they had special meaning for the society that
dimensional figures of a bird and dragon, which created them is evident from the extra effort
also serve as handles for the lid on the back of its required to produce them. Projecting a startling
head, seem to peer playfully between the horns. distance from the face, the pupils appear to have
range, in productivity, and in creativity during the second pour of metal. In the use of precast
last centuries of the second millennium bce, as elements, as well as in its monumental size, this
demonstrated both by the artifacts themselves and casting is reminiscent of similarly ambitious
by their archaeological locations. The magnificent products of northern workshops, such as the large
four-ram zun (cat. 23) and the bronze boar (cat. 27) fang ding (cat. 22) discussed above. The rectangular
were found south of theYangzi River in Hunan slot at the center of the forehead may have held an
Province; so were the elephant-shaped vessel (cat. extension, perhaps resembling the long scrolled
8
25) and the bail-handled covered container (you; projection fitted on one of the other two masks.'
cat. 26). u The large basin (cat. 29) came from the Clearly the people who commissioned the bizarre
lower Yangzi River basin in southeastern China, the bronzes at Guanghan and buried them together
serpentine vessel (cat. 28) from a site just south of with a rich assortment of bronze, jade, and ivory
the Great Wall in northwestern China. In the objects in two large pits (not tombs) were masters
quality of their workmanship some of these vessels of a bronze-casting technology closely comparable
are virtually indistinguishable from the best to that of their counterparts farther north in the
products of the capital region of Anyang. Some, like Yellow River basin. Although the bronze casters of
the elephant or the you, may have come from the the lower Yellow River basin may have been the
area of Anyang; others may have been made by first to explore, develop, and eventually achieve
regional workshops according to local tastes or high standards in bronze casting, it was the distant
ritual needs (cats. 27-29). workshops that seem to have tested the limits of
the technology by attempting eccentric shapes,
Other artifacts from theYangzi River valley, like the unorthodox decoration, and gigantic castings.
Fig-3- Bronze standing figure. Late second millennium Besides introducing new aesthetics and motifs, the
BCE. Sanxingdui, Guanghan, Sichuan Province. Zhou conquest also appears to have brought a
exhibition dating from the early part of Zhou rule of three vessels different in shape but identical in
(ca. 1100 ca. 1000 bce) illustrate some of these surface decoration and inscription. 27 Zhou nobles,
distinctive Zhou features (cats. 31, 32, 35, 41). prompted perhaps by religious customs or ritual
The container for liquids (lei; cat. 31), found far group to require sets of vessels with matching
from the Zhou realm in a cache in Zhuwajie, Peng designs, shapes, or dedicatory inscriptions. By the
county, Sichuan Province, is an outstanding example early ninth century bce, when the large container
21
of Zhou's invigorating effect on bronze design. tor liquid (hu; cat. 39) and its mate were made, large
Vessels of equally imposing size were made by the sets of bronze vessels, often carrying matching
Shang casters, but the bold elephant-trunk handles dedicatory inscriptions and comprising a narrow
and the ferociously hooked flanges running from lid range of shapes and designs, had become the
to foot create a bristling silhouette that is assertively norm. 2S This development, which required that the
difierent from the monumental lei vessels of the bronze caster produce virtual duplicates (often in
Shang. Its surface decoration augments this effect decoration and sometimes in shape), presented new
with a host of new motifs: taotie (semiabstract demands on an industry that, up to then, had only
zoomorphic motifs) with almost freestanding been making one-of-a-kind bronzes.
capital at Xi'an to marauding nomads and fled to repeated patterns on a vessel (fig. 4), or identical
their eastern capital near present-day Luoyang, handles, legs, or decorative appendages on a single
Henan Province. Their shrunken power accelerated vessel. For sets of bronzes in graduated sizes, a series
the fracturing of the realm into powerful of similarly graduated master units could produce
aristocratic states, with concomitant explosive rise appropriately sized but otherwise identical handles
in the demand on the bronze industry. This political or accents (fig. 5).
32
With a wide variety of master
decentralization must have been responsible in part patterns at the workshop's disposal, the decor
for the radical changes that took place in workshop possibilities were virtually unlimited.
foundry site, under excavation at the city of with three other identical vessels, recovered from
Houma, southern Shanxi Province, since the 1950s, the rich tomb of a noble of the Jin state at [insheng
has yielded workshop debris that hints at village, outside Taiyuan, the capital of Shanxi
techniques capable of meeting all requirements Province (see also cat. 44). 33 As a measure of the
sets of ritual vessels matching in shape and/or bronze caster's facility in replicating vessel shapes
decoration, vastly increased scale of production, and decoration in a variety of sizes and designs, the
foreign exotica, and everyday needs without tomb that yielded these four hn also contained
sacrificing the high-level workmanship that court matching sets, but in graduated sizes, of seven and
and noble patrons had come to expect. 31 six tripod vessels (ding); a set of eight matching
stemmed and covered food containers (don); four
Foundry debris at Houma suggested a production basins (jian); and two sets of bells (bo), five in one
process organized according to specialization and set and fourteen in the other (fig. 6). Detailed
division of labor. The multistep processes of studies of a hn in the Freer Gallery oi Art.
shaping, decorating, and assembling the clay molds, Smithsonian Institution, demonstrated that the
as well as the manufacture of different types of continuously interlacing dragon and twisted-rope
bronzes (both ritual and utilitarian), probably took designs on such vessels were actually replicated
place in separate areas of the workshop compound, from just four or five master pattern units, each
with different groups of workers contributing repeated as necessary to compose .1 given register of
specific skills toward the final product. Most decoration (tig. 7)." Similarly repeated pattern units
compelling of all the finds at Houma were the form the designs on the interior and exterior ol the
thousands ot pieces of decorated clay foundry rectangular basin (pan; cat. 4SI. The first-rate
debris, suggesting the wavs in which surface workmanship possible on bronzes decorated by
Province, nearly two thousand years later (see essays Taiyuan, Shanxi Province. Late 6th early $th century
by Wang Qingzheng and Regina Krahl in this BCE. (Drawings by Li Xiating [Shanxi Institute of
volume). Archaeology]).
Rujiazhuang elephant the elaborate surface illustrates the ancient Jin state's contact with
decoration of the earlier vessels has dwindled to a nomadic peoples living in the area north of today's
large spiral above each leg, no doubt intended to Great Wall. v' Its peculiar shape was probably
suggest rippling musculature but appearing inspired by the animal-skin flasks carried by hunters
essentially ornamental. The animal's head, however, and herders who lived along ancient China's
is rendered with considerable realism. northern and western borders, an antecedent more
clearly illustrated by a plain bronze example
40
The bronze bell (bo; cat. 33) represents a group of recovered in northern Hebei Province (fig. 9). Its
bells with similar decoration that date from the late surface decoration, however, was drawn from the
tenth century bce and are now in various Chinese standard late sixth-century bce Chinese decorative
and Western collections. 37 Like bronze drums (cat. repertoire, and its workmanship is typical of Jin
34), bronze bells are closely identified with the state bronzes. Such bronze vessels were probably
Yangzi River basin, having a continuous history of made in Jin or similar workshops as exotica for
use and production there since the late second their noble patrons, and occasionally to be
millennium bce. 3 * By the tenth century BCE, presented as gifts to leaders of northern tribes.
Other peripheral regions also contributed to lamp eight monkeys, perceptively even
metropolitan bronze designs, as exemplified in an affectionately portrayed, scamper about and hang
unusual lopsided vessel (cat. 44). Part of the large from the tree branches, as two bare-chested fellows
group ot bronzes unearthed from the same fin below appear to be cajoling the monkevs, rc.uh to
noble's tomb that contained catalogue 43, this flask catch whatever may be flung to them. Two
with asymmetrical profile and bird-shaped lid centuries later the elaborate fittings on the
Fig. g. Flask. 6th century BCE. Lijiazhuang, Xingtang encased in clay, the whole assembly is heated so
county, Hebei Province. that the wax melts away through vents left for this
topknotted foreigners riding elephants and camels primarily to cast complex decorative appendages on
(cat. 49; see also cat. 51). 42 This exotic iconography Chu bronzes (like the horns on cats. 45 and 46); it
is further enhanced by lavish inlays of gold, silver, may have been prompted by the special demands of
and turquoise, colors that might have approximated Chu aesthetics. 46
(cats. 45, 46, 52) can be associated with the state of a handsome product of metropolitan workshops. 47
Chu, the most powerful ruling house to emerge The frank realism and exotic imagery of the
south of theYangzi River in the second half of the bronzes from the Dian kingdom in Yunnan
millennium. Chu s exoticism differs from that of Province, in southwestern China, illustrate the
the north, featuring intricate baroque forms and foreign heritage of its people and the huge
fantastic, serpentine imagery. 4 1 "
The sinuous distances that separated them, culturally and
creatures with elaborate horns that support the artistically as well as geographically, from the Han
large, early sixth-century bce vessel (cat. 45) are court (cats. 55 58). 48 The Dian peoples wore fitted
close relatives of the pair of slightly later, malachite- trousers and short tunics typical of horse-riding
encrusted beasts, one of which is represented here tribes of Central Asia and seemed to delight in
(cat. 46) .
4S
The rhythms generated by the sinuous animated (perhaps even rowdy) dancing (cat. 56). 49
body, animated pose, lolling tongue, and spiraling Bulls appear to have held a significant place in Dian
horns of the fabulous animal amplify the more ritual and sacrifice (cat. 57); and the brutality of war
subtle rhythms produced by the interlaced pattern was apparently acknowledged, perhaps even gloried
and sculptural appendages on the earlier vessel in (cat. 55). These Dian bronzes were all made with
(cat. 45). A kneeling humanoid, biting one snake as the lost-wax casting technique. In subsequent
technical innovation allowed bronze casters to This remarkable object is ingeniously designed with
produce the myriad Buddhist and secular gilt fifteen moving parts: six turning wheels; four
bronzes of the Tang dynasty (cats. 160, 169) as well hinged openings (on top and at one end); a sliding
as such spectacular creations as flying dragons door bolt; and four pivoting birds. The one-legged
(cat. 59). doorkeeper might have been chosen specifically for
Lost-wax casting constituted a major technical the treasures he is guarding. The carriage's clever
innovation of the first millennium bce, but by no design, movable parts, and miniature size all suggest
means the only one. Continued intermingling of that this was a toy. Perhaps it and other miniatures
new ideas from different parts of China stimulated a found in the same context were indeed toys, the
variety of new decorative techniques. One of these idle elite's playthings or collectibles perhaps even
was the use of color. Whereas the decoration of containers for precious memorabilia.
bronze surfaces had previously been
monochromatic, accomplished solely with Demand for similar utilitarian or luxurious secular
patterning, the bronzes might now be inlaid with items flourished by the end of the first millennium
gold, silver, and semiprecious stones (cats. 46, 49, bce (cats. 49, 51, 52, 56). The crowning
50), gilded with mercury amalgam (cats. 51, 52, 56), achievements in this category must be the bronze
or simply painted with pigments, among other lamps made in the last centuries bce (cats. 53, 54).
devices (cat. 53). These colorfully decorated bronzes Never meant as funerary paraphernalia or as ritual
kept the industry healthy and productive well into implements, bronze lamps were strictly functional
the first centuries ce, despite rising competition furnishings in affluent households. Some, like the
from the lustrous jades, colorful lacquers, and multiarmed lamp (cat. 54), performed their function
embroidered silks that had begun to capture the simply by supplying effective lighting through a
50
hearts and budgets of wealthy elite patrons. delightful shape; others, like the lamp in the shape
Echoes of past absorb the smoke. This keeps the room free ol smoke
traditions continued to figure in bronze designs of and smell/' Man dynasty householders were clearly
the late first millennium bce, contributing to their as mindful of the air they breathed as we are today.
TANG PERIOD
A third driving force behind the creativity of the Even surpassing the extravagant luxury goods of the
first millennium bce: had little connection either Han court were those made for the ruling class of
high in the air and its front legs held taut, it seems Shaanxi Province.
use or context. As an emblem of the power of the variety of cultural backgrounds: the fabulous,
Tang empire, both at home and abroad, this flying single-horned winged horse (cat. 60) recalls the
dragon is unmatched. similar creature of West Asian myths; the bear (cat.
and West Asia glittering precious metals had long wares, but they left a lasting influence on China's
held pride of place, and their prestige at the Tang native lacquer and ceramic industries. Their metallic
court was a direct result of prolonged contact with shapes and relief decoration were adopted on
these peoples along the Silk Road. 57 Two caches Tang and Song lacquers and glazed ceramics
recovered in recent years in Xi'an illustrate the best (cats. 133, 138).
sealed in the foundation of the Famen Temple During the two thousand years from the creation
pagoda in 874 reveal the exalted status of gold and ot the first crudely made cast-bronze vessels of the
5S
silver in religious and imperial rituals (cats. 64, 65). early second millennium bce to the exquisite
The rich assortment of tea utensils from the trove bronze and silver objects of the Tang dynasty,
illustrate that tea drinking and its associated rituals China's metalworkers invented, developed, and
and ceremonies had noble connotations in Tang perfected the casting of bronzes using section
imperial, literati, and Buddhist circles (fig. n). The molds, exploited as necessary new casting (lost-wax)
rarified custom of storing processed tea in the form and decorative techniques (inlaying, gilding), and
of hardened cakes is revealed by the openwork eventually also acquired and mastered the foreign
basket (cat. 64) used to keep the cakes dry until techniques of cold-working silver and gold. A
they were ground for brewing. Among the tea multitude of forces political, cultural, social, and
utensils, articles like the salt caddy (cat. 65) confirm religious contributed to these changes and
practices previously known only from texts, such as developments over time. The cornucopia of
adding salt and spices to tea to reduce its bitterness. beautiful objects they produced remains as evidence
of their remarkable achievements.
The three gilded silver plates (cats. 6062) were
part of a cache of 270 gold and silver objects,
1. Kaogu.no. larger of which is also see Wenwu, no. n (1961), the he, see Zttongguo wenwu
5 (1975), pi. 9,
p. 2; and Henan sheng wenwu illustrated and discussed in Wen 16. For earthenware drums, see pp. 2S-31. jinghua, no. 49; for the gui, see
yanjiusuo, ed., Henan kaogu Fong, ed.. The Great Bronze Age Rawson, ed.. Mysteries of Zhongguo wenwu jinghua, no. 79;
(Zhengzhou: Henan renmin Metropolitan Museum of Art, evidence of wooden drums, see county, Shaanxi Province; brief report on the excavations
chubanshe, 1994), p. 176. For 1980), no. 11; two more, Kaogu, no. 1 {1983), pi. 6:5, Wenwu, no. 1 (1966), p. 4; in Zhongguo wenwubao,
calibrated carbon- 14 dates
identical in size and recovered A pictographic Wenwu, no. (1976), pp. 60, 66, September 1996.
PP- 37~39- 1 1
ranging between 1900 and in 1982, are published in inscription on from Fong,
a fang lei 93; see also ed.. Great
1500 bce obtained from wood Wenwu, no. 3 (1983), pp. 49-59; Luoyang, Henan Province, Bronze Age, no. 42. For examples of bronzes
30.
remains at the site, see Kaogu,
and the remaining four (83, 75, shows two hands, each holding associated with various states.
no. 10 (1983), pp. 923-28; and 64, and 59 cm. high, up club to drum on A Rawson,
a a a 23. detailed report of the see Western Zhou
Institute of Archaeology, ed., respectively), found in 1996, are stand: see Luoyang Cultural tomb that yielded this vessel is Ritual Bronzes, chap. 4; Jenny F.
published in Zhongguo
Radiocarbon Dates in Chinese Relics Team, ed., Luoyang chutu in Lu Liancheng and Hu So, Eastern Zhou Ritual Bronze*
Archaeology (1965-1991) wenwubao,2i April 1996. All, wenwu jisui (Beijing: Zhaohua Zhisheng, Baoji Yu Guo mudi, from the Arthur M. Sacklcr
Wenwu including the present example
(Beijing: chubanshe, chubanshe, 1990), no. 3, 2 vols. (Beijing: Wenwu Collections, Ancient Chinese
J99I). (cat. 22), were discovered in indicating that the type, in Bronzes from the Arthur M
chubanshe, 1988); see also
caches, not burials. bronze or another material, was Sackler Collections.
Zhongguo wenwu jinghua
2. Henan sheng wenwu, Henan certainly not unknown along (Beijing: Wenwu chubanshe. (New York and Washington,
kaogu sishinian, p. 174.
8. One vessel showed only 0.1 the Yellow River basin. 1993). no. 74- D.< \i thin M Sackler
percent lead, while another Foundation and Arthur M.
contained 17 percent lead; see See Robert Bagley, "A
3. Much of the discussion here 17. 24.Thc,\yN '
lv
is part of a cache Sackler Gallery, Smithsonian
and Wenwu, no. 3 (1983), p. 59. Shang City Sichuan of 103 bronzes discovered Institution. 1995 chaps. - -3;
in subsequent sections in in ,
regarding the relationship Province." Orientations 1976 .it Zhuangbai, Fufeng and Ja\ \u." ["he Cemetery of
between early bronze casting 9. For cat. 29, see Zhongguo (November 1990), pp. 52-67. county, Sh.uiiM Province. Sec the Western Zhou Lords of
and the pottery industry is
wenwu jinghua (Beijing: Wenwu Selected bronzes from the Wenwu, no. ; 1 1978), pp. 1-24. Jin," Artibtts Asiae $6, nos. 3 4
treated in greater detail in chubanshe, 1993), no. 70; for Guanghan cache are also 42; see also Fong. ed 1
pp. 193-231.
Robert Bagley, Shang Ritual cat. 23, a chance find in 1938 at discussed m Rawson, ed., Bronze Age, no. 45.
Bronzes in the Arthur M. Sackler Yueshangpu, Ningxiang county, Mysteries ofAncient China, So, Eastern Zhou Ritual
Collection Ancient Chinese Hunan Province, see Kaogu, nos. 22-32. A general discussion 25. For .1 discussion of the for an
Bronzes from the Arthur M. no. 12 (1963), p. 648. For a of southern bronzes is 111 "ritual revolution" during the account of the site and its
G Bunker, Ancient
; (bilingual), with
M. Sacklcr Museum, Harvard chap. 3. Chinese Art History, to.01. Chinese ati.l i >>.. introduction and English text
by Jay Xu, ed. Robert Bagley the type, see So, Eastern Zhou Brundage Collection (San
(Princeton: Princeton Ritual Bronzes, nos. 39-40; and Francisco: Asian Art Museum,
University Press, 1996). Jenny F. So and Emma C. 1977), pi. 43: top left.
32. More detailed discussions Chinas Northern Frontier 52. For examples of such
of these new foundry (Washington, D.C. and Seattle: "archaisms," see So, Eastern
techniques are in So, Eastern Arthur M. Sackler Gallery, Zhou Ritual Bronzes, nos. 1, 5,
Zhou Ritual Bronzes, chap. 4.2; Smithsonian Institution and 62, 80; Jenny F. So, "The Many
and Robert Bagley, University ofWashington Faces of the Past in Eastern
"Replication Techniques in Press, 1995), no. 20, chap. 3. Zhou Bronzes" (paper
London: Smithsonian "A Sampan Shan Chariot Foundr)', pp. 1314 (English
Institution, 1993), pp. 234-41. Ornament and the Xiangrui summary on p. 83).
chap. 4.2 and app. i:4G for a 43. This is discussed in Emma
detailed discussion of the C. Bunker, "Sources of Foreign 54. For cat. 9, see Zhongguo
tomb. Elements in the Culture of kaogu wenwu zhi mei (6):
and Robert Bagley, "What the Art, 1983). wide range of examples; one of
Bronzes from Hunyuan TelJ Us these is discussed in Fong, ed.,
about the Foundry at Houma" 44. This is discussed in greater Great Bronze Age, no. 94.
Orientations (July 1995), detail in Jenny F. So, "Hu
pp. 20-36. Vessels from Xinzheng: Toward 55. For a study of exotics in
a Definition of Chu Style," in Tang society, see Edward H.
35. Zhongguo wenwu jinghua, Kuwayama, Symposium, Schafer, The Golden Peaches of
no. 49; for a similar type from pp. 64-71. Samarkand: A Study of Tang
Jiangsu Province, see Wenwu, Exotics (Berkeley and Los
no. 5 (1984), pi.: left. 45. For cat. 6, see Fong, ed., Angeles: University of
Great Bronze Age, no. 67; So, California Press, 1963).
Zhisheng, Baoji Yu Guo mudi, 2 chap. 3.2, app. i:3D; for cat. 11, 56. Wenbo, no. 5 (1987),
vols. (Beijing: Wenwu see Zhongguo wenwu jinghua, 80, pi. 4: top. This one
PP- 79 is
chubanshe, 1988), cpl. 18; the no. 83, where the pair is of two identical dragons
same tomb also yielded two shown; and Rawson, ed., recovered in a chance find in
bird-shaped vessels (ibid., Mysteries of Ancient China, the southern suburb of XTan.
cpl. 19). no. 61. Its mate is damaged beyond
repair.
Hakkokan, Kyoto, and the chap. 2.6; and So, Eastern Zhou ancient China, see Emma C.
Arthur M. Sackler Gallery, Ritual Bronzes, pp. 35, 5354. Bunker, "Gold in the Ancient
Smithsonian Institution, are Chinese World: A Cultural
discussed in Fong, ed., Great 47. Fong, ed., Great Bronze Age, Puzzle," Artibus Asiae 53,
Bronze Age, no. 58; Rawson, no. 95. nos. 1/2 (1993), pp. 27-50; and
Western Zhou Ritual Bronzes, Emma C. Bunker, "The
no. 129; and Lothar von 48. Fong, ed., Great Bronze Age, Enigmatic Role of Silver in
Falkenhausen and Thomas D no. 97; the find is reported in China," Orientations
Rossing, "Acoustical and Yunnan finning Shizhaishan (November 1994), pp. 73-74.
Musical Studies on the Sackler gumuqunfajue baogao, 2 vols.
Bells," in So, Eastern Zhou (Beijing: Wenwu chubanshe, 58. Reported in Kaogu yu
Ritual Bronzes, p. 440. wenwu, no. 2 (1988), pp. 94-106;
1959)-
and Wenwu, no. 10 (1988),
38. For Shang dynasty 49. So and Bunker, Traders and pp. 1-43.
prototypes, see Bagley, Shang Raiders, pp. 23, 34-35; also
Ritual Bronzes in the Sackler nos. 59. See Wenwu, no. (1972),
1, 3, 11. 1
Collections, no. 104; also Lothar pp. 30-42; and Kaogu, no. 6
von Falkenhausen, Suspended 50. For these later trends and (1980), pp. 536-41.
Musk: Chime-bells in the Culture developments, see So, Eastern
of Bronze Age China (Berkeley Zhou Ritual Bronzes, chaps. 3.2,
and Los Angeles: University of 46; and Fong, ed., Great
California Press, 1993); and
Bronze Age, chaps. 89.
Falkenhausen and Rossing,
"Acoustical and Musical
51. For a prototype, see an
Studies."
example in the Asian Art
Museum of San Francisco:
39. Wenwu, no. 9 (19S9), pi. 2:2.
Rene-Yvon Lefebvre
d'Argence, Bronze Vessels of
40. For a detailed discussion of Ancient China in the Avery
So Fine a Luster:
Chinese Lacquerwares
Michael Knight
Curator of Chinese Art, Asian Art
Museum of San Francisco
The objects grouped together as lacquers
89
of the court, the aristocracy, religious groups, and Cinnabar, the pigment used to color red lacquer, is
wealthy merchants. Lacquers have also served as a crystalline form of mercuric sulfide. Deposits of
valued objects of trade. And yet lacquer, for all its this mineral are found in many parts of China, and
lustrousness and durability, has never been translated its ubiquity along with its stability makes it an ideal
into symbol, a curious omission in China, where so pigment for use in lacquer. Red was also an
many other materials have acquired symbolic auspicious color for the Chinese, and cinnabar was
and extravagance, with the women's quarters, and during the Qin and Han dynasties (221 bce220
with the imperial court; therefore only select types Ce). Once suspended in the matrix of the lacquer
of the medium are found in objects made for the polymer, this substance becomes a stable pigment.
scholar class. The primary exception is furniture.
1
For most furniture, a single coat or a few thin coats During much of the Bronze Age in China cinnabar
were applied to protect a softwood core. Only the red lacquer was applied to the interiors of wood
most expensive pieces of lacquered furniture, such coffins and vessels, a further indication of its special
as the examples from the imperial workshops, were significance.
affected the study of the material, which, until lacquers; because it is not entirely stable in urushiol,
recent decades, has been viewed primarily as a it often yielded a dull and brownish hue. The desire
minor decorative art. For certain periods in for a pure and glossy black surface led later lacquer
Chinese history, however, and for the social classes artists to employ pickled iron, often mixed with
who patronized it, lacquer was a medium of great arsenic. Yellow was accomplished through the use of
value and significance. orpiment. Brown, in a range of tones, is the natural
color of lacquered wood; other more opaque
Lacquer production is a long process, beginning browns can be obtained through the addition of
with gathering the sap of the lacquer tree by carbon.
making small slits in the bark and collecting the
secretion. The raw sap is a thick, creamy substance To enlarge the available palette, methods were
filled with impurities; initial steps in preparing the developed to add pigments to the surface of
material include filtering through cloth of varying lacquer. Among these was suspending pigments in
fineness until the desired purity is achieved and oils from the tong tree and painting them onto the
allowing excess water to evaporate. Once purified, lacquered surface. Inlays of sheets of precious
the clear, viscous, amber liquid is ready to be metals, shells, mother-of-pearl, colored stones, glass,
applied to a core. These cores have traditionally and a broad range of other materials as well as the
been wood or fabric, but sometimes are made from suspension of powdered metals in lacquer were also
other materials such as leather, ceramic, or even important decorative techniques.
bronze. 3
There are five principal applications for lacquer: as
Raw lacquer contains very high concentrations of a protective coating; as a paint to apply two-
urushiol. 4 Under the right conditions, including dimensional decoration; as an adhesive; as a resin
high humidity and temperatures between 60 and 85 that, in combination with other mediums, creates a
degrees Fahrenheit, urushiol undergoes a chemical product of superior strength and durability; and as a
change and forms a natural polymer having many medium for carving. These applications are not
of the properties of modern plastics: it is mutually exclusive, and it is common to find two
impervious to water and to many chemicals, and or more present in any given object.
stable throughout a range of temperatures;
depending on the material used for the core, the The earliest use of lacquer must have been as a
lacquered object can also be extremely lightweight. protective coating, and this remained one of its
primary functions. Thick and viscous, lacquer is
In its raw state urushiol is very caustic, therefore difficult to paint with. Nevertheless, Chinese
only a limited number of stable pigments can be lacquer artisans achieved remarkable results, and
used to color The most common colors for
it. some of the earliest surviving evidence of Chinese
lacquer are red, black, brown, and yellow. Certain of attempts at painting are in this medium.
these colors, such as red, had their own significance
in Chinese culture, and considerable effort was Use as an adhesive was another early and enduring
expended in mining and refining them. application of lacquer. Because it is sticky when
wet, adheres to most materials, and cures to create a
soaked in lacquer and molded, creating a vessel or equipment and left many traces where they were
sculpture that will retain the molded shape. Applied set up, lacquer required only areas for refining the
to a wood core, lacquer will form a lightweight, raw material and brushes and other perishable tools
strong, and, if desired, elaborately shaped vessel or for its application. No sites of early lacquer
object of considerable strength and durability. production have been located.
A sophisticated understanding of the medium was A cup excavated in 1978 from a site of the
required before carved lacquers could be created. In Neolithic Weizhi culture atYuyaohe, Zhejiang
order to undergo the chemical change required for Province, is known Chinese lacquered
the earliest
6
curing, lacquer must be applied in very thin coats. vessel. Made of a wood core coated with red
The thick coverings necessary for carving are lacquer, it dates between 5000 and 3000 bce. The
achieved by applying multiple coats. The most application of colored lacquer to a wooden base
complex carved lacquers might have a thin wood attests to an advanced technique; it is likely that
core reinforced with a layer of lacquer-impregnated lacquer had been in use for some time before this
cloth; over that, base coats created by adding cup was created. The remains of early Bronze Age
combinations of ash, rice paste, wood powder, or lacquers found in Shang dynasty sites in Anyang,
fine clay to lacquer; and multiple finish coats of Henan Province, and elsewhere indicate that
refined lacquer. Each coat has special qualities of lacquer technology advanced rapidly during this
sealing, filling, leveling, and finishing, and must be period. Most Shang dynasty lacquers have a red
applied in the proper conditions and in proper ground with designs of taotie (abstract zoomorphic
sequence. Since each coat must cure and be masks), leiwen ("thunder patterns," which take the
mechanically smoothed before another is added, the form of squared spirals), and other motifs derived
thickest applications can require as much as a year from bronze decor of the time.
from the initial coat to the final finish. 5
The use of lacquer as an adhesive was also known
EARLY CHINA (CA. 3000 BCE-220 CE) during the Shang dynasty, as attested by surviving
In the past, much of the study of early Chinese art objects inlaid with the shell of fresh-water clams,
has been focused on the nonperishable materials of turquoise, ivory, and sheets of gold foil. Western
bronze, jade, and ceramics. In part this was due to Zhou (ca. 1 100771 bce) lacquers from north China
the interest of Chinese antiquarians, who were show that lacquer continued to be used extensively
most interested in those materials mentioned in as an adhesive during this period as well. 7
bronzes and jades followed similar lines, with a the third century bce were the creation of a
greater emphasis on surface decoration and form. painterly style and ot a representational art; lacquers
Their advanced technologies and intrinsic beauty are among the major surviving examples of both.
have long made Chinese ceramics a focus of Lacquered vessels with smooth, curved surfaces
Western scholarship. Rarely did objects of devoid of relief or other three-dimensional
lacquered wood or other perishable substances patterns, and large lacquered wood objects with Hat
survive to enter a museum or a private collection surfaces, such as tomb chambers and coffins, relied
and allow a glance into their early development. exclusively upon contrasts in lacquer colors tor
decoration.
During the past few decades, however, archaeology
has provided a more complete record of these The majority of surviving lacquers dating from the
perishable materials. Lacquered objects have been Spring and Autumn (770-476 bce) and Warring
found in considerable numbers in tombs dating as Si. lies (475-221 BCE) periods come from what was
early as 3000 BCE and have provided indications of then the kingdom of Chu. 1 OCated along the
some of the developments in use and style in a central Changjiang basin. Chu enjoyed .1 favorable
compared, say, to casting in bronze) gave the artists AY. .* .*:' ,'> i: > K~.
ninth century bce to the time of the fall of the Fig. 1. Set of lacquered wood coffins from Mawangdui
state in 221 bce, Changsha was an important Chu tomb No. 1
as a center of trade with regions even farther south. outer boxes that would exactly fit their contents.
members of the lower aristocracy and perhaps even During the Western Han dynasty the Chinese lived
of the merchant class. at floor level: all seated activities customarily took
place on platforms or on mat-covered platforms;
Changsha remained an influential political center in large-scale raised chairs and tables and other
southern China during the Western Han dynasty furniture of corresponding scale were not yet in
(206 bce-8 ce) and served as the capital for a state vogue. The impact of this custom on the
that, while under Han rule, retained a great deal of preparation and presentation of food is quite
autonomy and local leadership. In 1972 a series of apparent in the lacquers found in the Mawangdui
tombs belonging to the ruling family of the state tombs. Food for the deceased had been laid out in
centered at Changsha was excavated at the suburb a variety ot dishes (fig. 2) assembled on large trays
of Mawangdui.The arts found in them reveal a (cats. 69, 70). The large rectangular tray (cat. 70)
continuity with earlier Chu materials combined could well have served as a small portable table.
with an awareness of Han philosophical and Low screens found in the Mawangdui tombs (fig. 3)
religious practices. are the ideal height to have deflected drafts and
preserved privacy for the floor-sitting occupants of
The Han period residents of Changsha used Han interiors.
found in contemporary or slightly earlier texts such bronzes of the late Warring States period. By the
as the Churi ("Songs of the South"), hint at the Western Han dynasty, however, these patterns had
extensive use of lacquer in architecture as well. 8 come to resemble clouds and served religious as
shapes were found in the Mawangdui tombs; rather, (fig. 4), these clouds are occupied by a multitude of
sets of these vessels were created in lacquer (cat. strange and wonderful beasts. Beliefs in paradises
66). 9 This clearly reflects changing attitudes toward inhabited by immortals became increasingly
these two materials and the rising status of lacquer. widespread during the early Western Han. The
Early Western Han writings indicate that a lacquer Chuci ("Songs of the South"), a collection largely of
vessel might cost ten times as much as a comparable late Warring States date, describes these paradises;
piece in bronze. many of them exist in the sky among just such
clouds and are occupied by just such fantastic
Also found in the tombs at Mawangdui were creatures as are depicted on this coffin.
10
(cat. 67), toiletries boxes (cat. 68), and document Magical clouds were also thought to be omens of
boxes, among others. Nested containers (cat. 67) good fortune and, as such, played an important role
black bands. The narrow borders also hold abstract Mawangdui tomb No. 1
hunting scenes. The covered box (cat. 71) is a technology continued to develop and that new
typical example. In many cases the incised processes were introduced for the production of
decoration is found on the inside surfaces of the luxury goods, vessels, and furniture. During this
piece, while the exterior is decorated in more period various sects of Buddhism became
traditional techniques. important institutional patrons for the lacquer arts;
lacquers in Shandong, Henan, Guangdong, and region, foreign luxury goods, .ill the more desirable
Guangxj provinces." These areas continued to be for being exotic, provided still competition for
important centers of lacquer production for most of native luxuries such .is lacquerwares.The artisans
China's history. working in lacquer responded with .1 wide range ol
lacquerware, covered with several layers of lacquer, had a broad-ranging impact on such mediums as
then the whole rubbed just till the gleaming metal ceramics and lacquers.
emerged flush with the surrounding lacquer, a
technique called pingtuo; or patterns might be created The artistic movements brought about by these
in the lacquerware by inlaying thin sheets of mother- changes in attitude and patronage were fully
of-pearl or other iridescent shells. Both these realized during the Song dynasty. Influenced by
techniques are found on mirror backs, mirror cases, Confucian principles and inspired by conscious
musical instruments, and a variety of other objects. archaism, the people of the Song took renewed
interest in the arts and philosophies of the Han
During the middle and late Tang dynasty a series of dynasty and earlier. Cut off by hostile neighbors
events occurred that profoundly affected lacquer from the foreign influences that had been so strong
production and attitudes toward it and a variety of during the earlier centuries of the Tang dynasty,
other materials. The An Lushan rebellion of 755 Song dynasty artists innovated within traditional
vastly diminished the political and economic power Chinese mediums. Among these was lacquer.
of the Tang hereditary elite. During the remainder
of the Tang dynasty other societal groups emerged Song dynasty innovations in lacquer included
as the principal arbiters of taste. They often showed making lighter and stronger cores, rendering details
a preference for native materials, including lacquer of the decoration in relief by means of a moldable
in more traditional forms. paste made by adding materials such as fine clay or
declined, China's borders contracted and the lacquer. Many of the pieces created during this
Central Asian trade routes were interrupted by period were elegant utilitarian vessels and domestic
foreign conquest. This encouraged the resurgence furniture. Others were specially designed to serve in
of native traditions in the arts, which continued Buddhist ritual practices.
Because they have long been removed from their saucer diam. 14.2 cm. Unearthed at Hanyang, Shilipu,
original context, the use and patrons for this type Wuhan county, Hubei Province. Hubei Provincial
during the Northern Song. Chan Buddhism originally highlighted by applications of gold dust
influenced many of the arts of the Song dynasty, suspended in lacquer. In addition, seed pearls were
and lacquer was no exception. It is likely that this inlaid into the lacquer to emphasize certain aspects
piece was created for the Chan-influenced tea of the design. The beginnings of the raised lacquer
ceremony that became prevalent in China during technique can be seen in the box from Mawangdui
the Song dynasty, perhaps to hold a small tea bowl. (cat. 68). We also know from materials preserved in
The costly materials establish that the patrons were the Shdso-in, in Japan, that both relief and inlaid
among the wealthy elite of the time. designs were popular during the Tang dynasty.
1
-'
On
the Northern Song reliquary and sutra boxes these
Lacquered wood also proved to be the perfect techniques are used in a very sophisticated manner
medium for creating elaborate and decorative to frame the areas of pictorial design and to create
storage boxes for sutras and other Buddhist major decorative motifs in relief.
container in the form of nested boxes (cat. 73), all On each vertical side of the reliquary floral scrolls
quite large, have been found at the site of the frame a scene of Guanym, the Buddhist deity of
Huiguang Pagoda, built in 1043 at Ruian, Zhejiang mercy and attendant to Amitabha Buddha. These
Province. They have been identified as products of scenes are painted in lacquer pigmented with
Wenzhou in the same province, one of the most powdered gold. On the outer sutra box are images
famous centers for lacquer production during the of Buddhist deities seated on lotus blossoms and a
Song dynasty. The vertical box (cat. 72), identified as series of auspicious animals and birds, all in molded
a reliquary, is decorated on all four sides with lacquer. The inner sutra box is elaborately decorated
Buddhist scenes. The pair of nested boxes (cat. 73), with scrolling floral designs painted in gold lacquer.
three are relatively simple shapes, they represent THE YUAN AND MING DYNASTIES
some new departures in decoration and decorative (1279-1644)
technique. Profound changes occurred during the brief
Mongol-ruled Yuan dynasty (1279-1368) that had a
The overall base color of both the reliquary and the deep impact on Chinese society and the art'-.
outer sutra box is light brown, with a band of red Forced from their traditional role m the Confucian
on the top section of the reliquary. Applied to the bureaucracy, many of the educated elite turned to
surface of both are extensive areas of floral the arts as .1 vocation and refuge. Patronage patterns
decoration, auspicious animals, and Buddhist figures also changed dramatically during this period.
created from raised areas of molded or embossed Although Chan and other forms of Buddhism
lacquer. Portions of the molded floral designs were remained strong supporters of the arts, the Yuan
particularly those in the south, became the primary devastated the artisans' health. But we know very
patrons of a broad range of artistic activities. little about the personal lives or working conditions
of the artisan class.
Not surprisingly, the larger-than-life heroes and furthermore, deeply carved designs rendered them
villains of these works, whether fictional or less than ideal for any practical purpose. Most of
semihistorical, were the subject of many of the art them must have been meant for display. The large
objects commissioned by the wealthy. Some appear porcelains were often made for foreign markets, and
as topics of lacquer decoration. this may also have been true for the lacquers.
Flowers-and-birds or overall abstract cloud-like
Several lacquer techniques initiated during the designs were the usual motifs. In general, these
Song dynasty were fully developed during the Yuan pieces are dark brown or black, although examples
sections, out of very thin wood. In Yuan examples, Figural scenes are relatively rare on the carved
the pieces that made up the well of the plate were lacquers of the Yuan dynasty. The covered box
laid with their grain perpendicular to the grain of (cat. 74) is a superb example of this type. Even rarer
technique strengthened the very thin, lightweight corresponding to 1351. 16 Almost no other dated
core so that it did not check or shrink as easily as Yuan dynasty lacquers have survived. The scene on
the thicker, single-piece cores of the Warring States this box, like those on many of the underglaze
period and Han dynasty. These complex cores were decorated porcelains of the period, is drawn from a
susceptible to warpage, however, a problem found contemporary novel or play. Patrons of such
in many of the large plates of the Yuan dynasty. lacquers must have included the wealthy gentry, the
One of the most complex of the core types began to be produced under imperial patronage.
described above, cloaked to a considerable depth by The covered box illustrated here (cat. 75)
preventing him from carving through the finish emissaries on special occasions.
<travagant amount of time and energy was that on the Yuan dynasty box discussed above
required before the blank was even ready for (cat. 74). It has a strong narrative content, with a
ving. The finest carved lacquers of the Ming and main figure standing on an open terrace. His
Jing could have as many as two hundred coats of servant stands directly behind him, while another
lacquer, each requiring a day or more to cure and scholar busies himself in an open building. Pictorial
to be buffed before another could be applied. 15 The space on this Ming box is more developed than on
cost in human terms for carved lacquer must also the Yuan dynasty piece: the number of elements has
have been very high. Breathing the dust created increased considerably, and their relationships are
extensive use of diaper patterns as background or to quality were produced during this period. As with curing.
indicate sky or water and the replacement of the many court-supported arts, production of lacquer
5. The complexity of these
abstract patterns on the sides of the Yuan box with declined during the nineteenth century. Lacquer applications are well described
various auspicious flowers. On a majority of production for the merchant class and for a by Shogyo Ohba in "The
Kyushitsu Technique
fifteenth-century covered boxes the sides are growing export market continued, and was the
Demonstrated on a Natsume,"
similarly decorated. main source of support for the medium into the in N.S. Bromelle and Perry
imperial commissions for lacquer varied with Fig. 2. Changsha Books, 1985).
After
emperor (1522-1566) was a period of high chubanshe, 1973), vol. 2, pi. 160.
Mawangdui, see Changsha
reign of this emperor, who abdicated almost all his ("Han tomb No. 1 at Mawangdui,
Changsha ") (Beijing: Wenwu 9. Hawkes, 77ic Songs of the
authority to court eunuchs. The Jiajing emperor's
chubanshe, 1973), vol. 2, pi. 192.
South.
fascination with Daoism distracted him further
from affairs of state, but was a major influence on Fig. 4. After Changsha 10. Wang Shixiang, Zhongguo
A final burst of imperially commissioned artistic Culture," Arts Asiariques 36. Brommelle and Smith, eds..
corruption and poor leadership and instead Materia! Culture and Social Status Treasures of the Sfioso-in, vol. 1
squandered time and resources on artistic in Early Modem China (Shoso-in Homotsu I). North I
patrons of the lacquer arts, chiefly members of the was a lacquered bed. Clunas,
mother-of-pearl inlaid lacquers of the late Ming for use together, lacquer has pi. 4^. p. 206,
and early Qing were intended for them. been used to dc< orate bronze
(1662-1722) and reached a peak during the reign of causes dermatitis, Special care is
Zhao Feng
Professor, China National Silk Museum,
Hangzhou
Sericulture and silk production are
feeding on mulberry leaves grows from about one reasonable to assume that the cocoon had been cut
millimeter to about seven centimeters; its ceaseless open in order to observe the final metamorphosis
feeding is interrupted by four day-long dormancies, and emergence of the moth a form of augury
after each of which it molts, then continues eating. that we might term seriomancy.
After some forty days, each worm is placed into an
individual compartment, where it spins the cocoon Images of the fusang tree appear frequently in
within which it metamorphoses into a chrysalis, or ancient art. Most texts explain the fusang tree as a
pupa, and finally into a new moth. To emerge, the giant mulberry tree that connects earth with
moth secretes an enzyme that softens and breaks Heaven, or as the Tree of the Sun. In Chinese
the fibers or the cocoon. To preserve most of the legend there were once ten suns, one of which,
cocoon intact for silk reeling, the pupa is killed carried by thejingwu bird, traverses the sky from
before its final metamorphosis into a moth. east to west every day, then rests on the fusang tree
all night. Therefore mulberry groves, the true
From the number of very early renderings of habitats of the Jusang tree on earth, were places
silkworms and their life cycle, we may speculate from which people could ascend to Heaven to
that such a sequence of metamorphoses, with its communicate with the gods, and thus places
alternations between stillness and motion, reminded of prayer.
the early Chinese vividly of the human life cycle,
perhaps with the motionless chrysalis within the The fusang pattern probably appeared on Neolithic
cocoon representing death and the emerging moth art objects, but the fust verifiable image is the
seen as an allegory of rebirth. bronze Jusang tree excavated from .1 Shang ritual
have discovered many representations of caterpillar, unearthed from a tomb of the Warring States
chrysalis, and moth in many Neolithic sites in period U~s n\ bce) in Hubei Province, shows the
north and south China. A carved ivory from archer Yi shooting at thejingwu bird. The modi'
I [emudu, Zhejiang Province (sooo-4000 bce), derives from .1 legend in which all ten suns
shows four pairs of silkworm patterns; a black appeared together in the sk\ one day, threatening to
pottery shard from Meiyan.Jiangsu Province incinerate the earth; the heroYi saved the world by
shooting nine of them out of the sky. On objects of Jiao's illustrations appeared throughout the Qmg
dating from the Warring States period through the period (1644 1911), in the most various mediums
Han dynasty (206 BCE-220 CE),fusang trees appear wood carvings, stone reliefs, painted porcelains,
more frequently than before. We find it, albeit very molded ink sticks, and woodblock-printed book
small and much changed in shape, on the silk gauze illustrations. Furthermore, the Pictures of Cotton
embroidered with dragons and phoenixes found in Production by Fang Guanchen (ca. 1765) and the
the Chu state tomb at Mashan,Jiangling county, twelve pictures of sericulture done in relief carving
Hubei Province. On the famous silk painted banner on stone in the Guangyuan Temple in Sichuan
from Mawangdui tomb Number (ca. 168 bce), at 1 Province are undoubtedly derived from the earlier
Changsha, Hunan Province, we also find afusang works by Lou Shou and Jiao Bingzhen.
tree with nine small suns and one large one. Relief
resembles a mulberry tree. Age the zoomorphic patterns on jades and bronzes
were simply rendered against relatively plain
Contemporary with Han stone reliefs bearing backgrounds. Increasing complexity became the
fusaiig designs are a number of reliefs illustrating silk rule during the middle and later Bronze Age, with
production. According to archaeological reports, at the principal zoomorphic motifs set against
least seventeen such reliefs exist, nine from geometric background figures such as S or T shapes
Shandong, six from Jiangsu, one from Anhui, and or squared spirals. What inspired this change? The
one from Sichuan, including a stone relief depicting creation of design, of course, was the main reason.
silk production now on display at the National Silks featuring animal motifs embroidered on a
Museum of Chinese History in Beijing. damask ground woven with small geometric figures
prominent art motifs in the Song (9601279), From fragments of mats unearthed from Neolithic
reflecting the great importance of sericulture in the Hemudu, Banpo, Qianshanyang, and
sites at
economy of that time. The best-known example is Caoxishan, we know that patterns made from
perhaps the Gengzhitu ("Pictures ofTilling and woven bamboo and braided c-hemp threads were
Weaving") of 1145, text and pictures by Lou Shou, being executed long before patterns woven on the
administrator of Yuhang county near Hangzhou, loom. Some traces of the earliest woven patterns on
then capital of the Southern Song (1127 1279). In silk can be seen in the form of "ghost" impressions
part two of this work twenty-four illustrations left by cloth or mats that were used to wrap
depict and describe the whole process of sericulture jade and bronze objects of the Shang dynasty
and silk weaving: hatching; gathering newly (ca. 1600-ca. 1100 bce). Although the cloth or mat
hatched larvae; silkworm feeding and raising; first, wrapping have long since disintegrated, the patterns
second, and third moltings; arrangement of feeding that remain include a lozenge pattern from silk
trays; gathering mulberry leaves; last molting; tabby on a bronze ax excavated at Anyang and now
picking mature silkworms; cocooning; warming the in the Museum of Far Eastern Antiquities,
cocoons; gathering the cocoons; selecting the Stockholm, noted by Vivi Sylwan; the S-shaped
cocoons; storing the cocoons; reeling the silk; silk pattern from silk tabby on a jade knife now in the
moths laying eggs; making offerings to the gods of Palace Museum, Beijing, which was noted by Chen
sericulture; winding; warping; wefting; patterning; Juanjuan, and an S-shaped damask pattern on a
cloth cutting. The earliest known version of Pictures bronze ritual vessel found at Anyang. Some carved
of Sericulture and Weaving, in the Heilongjiang jades and stone sculptures also manifest textile
Provincial Museum, bears an inscription attributed patterns, including T-shaped diaper patterns.
to Empress Wu (ca. 11271162). A later version, Furthermore, we also find traces of silk embroidery
attributed to Chen Qi of the Yuan dynasty on some of the woven figured silks in which the
(1279 1368), now in the Freer Gallery of Art in excavated bronzes have been found wrapped;
Washington, was widely influential. But the most although the complete pattern of most of these has
frequently reproduced version is that of the court been lost, the embroidered patterns on the
painter Jiao Bingzhen (act. ca. 1680 1720), whose fragments seem to be large-scale mythical animals
illustrations accompany didactic verses attributed to on a damask ground with small geometric figures.
the Kangxi emperor (r. i662-i722).Jiao's Some jade figures from Shang sites show
illustrations contain Western stylistic elements, background patterns similar to those found on
learned from the Western missionaries with whom bronzes of the same period. Patterned silks of that
he had contact at the imperial court. Close copies time have two "layers" of design, the woven ground
contains examples of both types: a looped warp- printing blocks to be used on silk or on paper; both
faced compound tabby and an embroidered types of printing developed contemporaneously in
complex gauze. In one section of the potpourri we China. Some examples are three pieces of stamp-
find a polychrome compound tabby, known as jin, resist dyed silk bearing a portrait of Sakyamuni
with large woven geometric patterns forming the Buddha and a number of printed Buddhist
background and various smaller looped patterns scriptures, discovered in the underground treasury
forming the foreground. Another section of the of the wooden pagoda inYingxian, Shanxi. Apart
potpourri is made of patterned gauze with from tie dying, the Chinese generally created
embroidered cloud designs. Catalogue 77 is another designs on fabric by means of printing blocks and
example of silk gauze with woven lozenge patterns. the closely related stencil technique. For block
printing, the pigment was spread on the relief
Similar silksmay have been made as early as the portions of the carved block, and then the block
Shang dynasty. We know that the style persisted in was applied to the silk. In block-brush printing, the
later periods in a variant known as "brocade piece of silk was laid on the block and rubbed with
windows," a principal motif framed by a circle or a stone to receive an impression of the design on
roundel against a geometric or similarly figured the block; this blind impression was then colored
woven ground. Such designs were also widely used with a pigment-laden brush. Stencil printing, often
in architecture, as is evident from architectural texts used in north China to make New Year's pictures,
of the Song and from stamped bricks and carved creates the design by applying colors to the cloth
wood of the Ming and Qing dynasties. through the holes in a stencil. All of these later
PRINTING
Paper, printing, gunpowder, and the compass are SILK TAPESTRY, EMBROIDERY, AND CHINESE PAINTING
four Chinese inventions that greatly influenced the Silk, both woven and spun, was once the principal
course of world civilization and the development of material for Chinese calligraphy and painting.
the various cultures. Joseph Needham has listed Woven silk is usually unscoured tabby; many
twenty-six great inventions of Chinese science and Chinese documents and paintings were written or
technology, one for each letter of the alphabet, drawn on this type of silk. Spun silk, sometimes
including the horizontal treadle loom and pattern known as cocoon paper, is formed directly by the
loom, silk reeling, the spinning and doubling wheel, silkworm spinning a flat sheet instead of a cocoon.
paper making, and printing. Everyone recognizes Spun silk was used as a painting ground or even for
the importance of paper and printing, but few clothes in south China. The renowned calligrapher
people are aware of the significance of silk in the Wang Xizhi's celebrated Lanting xu ("Preface to the
invention of paper making and printing. Orchid Pavilion") of 353 was written using three
treasures of the calligrapher: an ivory brush pot. a
It is generally thought that printing originated in mousehair brush, and cocoon paper, a splendid
the use of stamps. Many stamps were in use in the medium still used by modern-day painters and
Qin (221-207 BCE ) and Han dynasties, but most of calligraphers. Once invented, paper replaced silk to
them were employed as seals to make impressions a considerable extent for painting. But in Chinese
on clay rather than as printing devices to make ink the character for "paper." :hi. refers to a kind ot
graphs on silk or paper. The first trace of a stamped paper-like silk, a sheet of short, scoured silk fibers
graph on a textile is found on a piece of warp-faced By using vegetable fiber instead of silkworm fiber
compound silk tabby from a Warring States period to make such a thin sheet, the Chinese invented
tomb near Changsha, Hunan Province. The graph true paper.
seems to be a mark of the weaver or the owner of
the bolt of silk. Later finds include two famous During the Song dynasty, and especially the reign of
printed silks from Mawangdui tomb Number 1. one Emperor Huizong (r. U00-II26), the arts ,>t
in fine tabby, printed 111 three colors (two of them painting and calligraphy were greatly in favor at
silks were exquisitely woven and embroidered to famous weaver Zhu Kerou (cat. 82), or the
mimic contemporaneous paintings, especially anonymous Garden Rocks with High Mallow and
flower-and-bird paintings. Silk art tapestry (kesi )
Begonia, after a painting by Cm Bai (act.
developed at that time to answer the demand for ca. 1060-1085) (cat. 83), and many others of the
fabric designs as naturalistic in style as the works of flower-and-bird genre. During the Yuan dynasty kesi
favorite painters. The resulting woven paintings and embroidery also served to make Buddhist
were regarded not as patterned fabrics but as works icons, such as the King of Blight Wisdom Budong
of art. (cat. 85), the Heavenly King of the West (cat. 84), and
Sdkyanwni Buddha (cat. 86).
threads instead of weft threads that run the whole and silk production during the Ming and Qing
width of the fabric, as they do in ordinary woven dynasties, kesi and silk embroidery continued to be
silks. In kesi, the weft is introduced only at the heavily influenced by literati painting, which
point where its particular color is required in the flourished in the Jiangnan region, heart of the
design, which allows the weaver enormous freedom Ming dynasty textile industry. Women of
in the shape of the design elements. aristocratic households, most famously the women
of the Gu family of Shanghai and Ni Renji in
Zhuang Chou, a scholar of Northern Song, pointed Zhejiang, became expert at mimicking paintings in
out this feature in his book Jilei pian:"At Dingzhou many varieties of embroidery, usually with finishing
they weave kesi. But they do not employ big looms, touches added with brush and pigments. This
and they use natural-colored silk. They string the practice of enhancing kesi or embroidery with paint
warps on wood and thorns. As desired, they make was prevalent during the Ming and Qing dynasties,
figures of flowers, plants, birds and animals, using as seen in the Qmg dynasty kesi tapestry of Li Bai's
small spools. When they weave the wefts, they first "Evening in the Peach and Plum Garden" (cat. 87).
they take variously colored silk threads and In summary, silk, in addition to all its "practical"
interlace them into the warps. Along the weft uses, has served as a ground for painting and
direction, [the individual masses of color] combine calligraphy, as a medium in which paintings were
to form a finished pattern, as if they were not superbly imitated in weaving or needlework, and as
connected. When the completed kesi is held up to an inspiration for the invention of paper.
the light, [due to the slits between adjoining colors]
Death: Constructing a
Posthumous World in
Funerary Art
Wu Hung
Harrie A. Vanderstappen Distinguished
Service Professor in Chinese Art History,
"Realities of life after death," from the University of Chicago
103
Fig. l. Diagram of tomb No. 7, Niiqiapo, Changzi,
Shanxi Province. Eastern Zhou period.
and Zhou dynasties gradually declined, and the known collectively as "spirit articles" (mingqi).
center of ancestral worship shifted from the lineage Among these forms were grave figurines (muyong),
temple to the family graveyard, generating new which increasingly became a regular component of
rites and ritual paraphernalia. Increasingly, tombs tomb furnishings during the middle and late
were furnished not only with sacrificed humans Eastern Zhou period, from the sixth to third
and animals and articles taken direcdy from the century bce. 1
Archaeology also enables us to develop this Zhangqiu and dating from the mid-Warring States
"substitution" theory further. It is possible that period. 7 Here the main burial was surrounded by
figurines substituted for some but not all kinds of five smaller grave pits of young women; of these, pit
human sacrifices. Scholars have distinguished two Number 1 contained a group of thirty-eight
main types of human victims in early China: pottery figurines (fig. 2).
animal" (sheng) and always suffered a violent death. of clay. The differences between the northern and
Fig. 7. Diagram of tomb No. 1, Mawangdui, Changslia, Fig. 9. Decoration on front and left panel oj third coffin
Hunan Province. After 16S BCE. (from the outside), tomb No. 1, Mawangdui, Changslia,
Hunan Province. After 16S BCE.
[l^-i'
1
'
j
:
tomb, arranged in a single tableau, were thirty-eight
clay sculptures: twenty-six human figures (including
F(g, S, Decoration on front panel of second coffin (from musical instruments; and eight birds (fig. 2). The
the outside), tomb No. 1, Mawangdui, Changslia, Hunan role of such a "set" as a self-contained tableau is
Province. After 168 BCE. reinforced by its miniature form. Almost all
southern figurines, however, go far beyond their often merely seven to ten centimeters allowed
tall
materials to include their manner of representation only rudimentary representation ot faces and
and grouping. costumes. 8
Most Chu figurines have brightly painted clothes We wonder why such tiny figures were given wide
and facial features, and some of the figurines attest currency in funerary art. The answer must be found
to an intense effort to mimic live human beings. in the specific artistic goals of the miniature. It has
Two extraordinary specimens from Baoshan tomb been suggested that miniature representations most
Number 2, for example, are each more than a consciously create an interior space and time 111 a
meter tall (fig. 3). Their ears, arms, hands, and feet fictional world. Unlike realism, which attempts to
were carved separately and then attached. Their map art upon life, the metaphoric world ot the
mustaches and braids were made of real hair, and immature skews the temporal and spatial relations
silk robes originally covered their bodies. In Chu of the everyday world. Buried in a tomb, "the
mausoleums of Emperor Jing (r. 156 141 bce) and Mawangdui, Changsha, Hunan Province.
other Han royalty show sensitively observed and After 168 bce.
tradition, they also integrated features of southern structures constructed at the bottom of a deep
figurines: their naked bodies were originally shaft. The outer wooden encasement (guo) was
clothed, and their wooden arms, which have divided into five rectangular compartments, or
completely decomposed, could have been chambers (fig. 7). The middle chamber, called gucm,
manipulated into various positions. Typical southern contained the woman's body inside nested painted
figurines of the second century bce, still made of coffins. Numerous household articles and food
wood, are exemplified by those from the famous were stored in the four surrounding compartments,
Mawangdui tomb Number 1 , whose discovery in identifying these chambers as a replica of the
1972 near Changsha, in Hunan Province, was one deceased's former residence.
of the most spectacular archaeological finds in
Chinese history. 13 The tomb's undisturbed condition Most of the wooden figurines were found within
further enables us to explore the belief in the the four peripheral chambers of the guo. Some ot
afterlife, an ideological system that must have them, including a group of five musicians (cat. 94),
underlain the structure and furnishing of this were in the northern chamber, which imitated the
burial.' 4 "retiring hall" (qin) in a traditional household. Silk
grave, the tomb consisted of a cluster of wooden clothed figurines represented Lady Dai's personal
Fig. u. Cross sections of tomb No. 1, Shaogou, Luoyang, Fig. 12. Drawing of heavenly realm, ceiling mural and
Henan Province. Late Western Han dynasty. detail from tomb of Bo Qianqiu, Luoyang, Henan
Province. Late Western Han dynasty.
attendants, as well as dancers and musicians. Quite innermost of the three outer coffins, lacquered a
different figurines were found in the guo's eastern shining red, is painted with a divine mountain
and southern chambers. Images in this second centered on the front panel and on one side,
group, exemplified by a male figure in the flanked by auspicious animals and a heavenly being
exhibition (cat. 95), represent the household's (fig. 9). Inside this third coffin is the "inner unit"
servants. These rigidly shaped standing figures were of the burial, which preserved the woman's body
not arranged to form a large tableau; they were both physically and symbolically: while the corpse
packed tightly in multiple layers along with cases of was carefully wrapped in layers of cloth and tightly-
household articles and food in the chambers. The sealed in the innermost coffin, the likeness of the
servant figurines thus symbolized a particular kind dead was preserved on the painted silk banner
of household property, whereas the dancers and (fig. 10).
contained representation of social life and space What we find in the Mawangdui tomb, therefore, is
lacquered differently, signifying their different ritual banner), the underworld (as shown on the
symbolism and forming a coherent pictorial patterned black coffin), the immortal paradise (as
program. The outermost coffin, solid black, shown on the patterned red coffin), and the
separates the dead from the living (as well as from underground household (as symbolized by the four
the four outer compartments of the guo, which peripheral chambers and their contents). The
imitate the world of the living). The second, also relationship between these realms is by no means
black, is decorated on all four sides with human, clear. It seems (hat in their eagerness to express
semihuman, and animal figures amid swirling cloud their filial piety and to please the dead, the tomb
patterns symbolizing qi ("universal energy"); the builders provided all the answers they knew to
deceased woman appears on the lower edge of the questions about tiie afterlife,
murals, which implies a crucial change in mortuary mural from tomb No. 1, Shaogou, Luoyang, Henan
structure: "horizontal burials," which flourished in Province. Late Western Han dynasty.
^^i^^^^^^^^tssszasSras^;?*^?1 * ".
Bo Qianqiu near Luoyang, Henan Province, has Fig. 14. Funerary procession over a river. Relief carving,
been dated to the mid-first century bce. 16 The west wall of main chamber of tomb at Cangshan,
demon-queller Fangxiang and accompanying White Shandong Province. Mid-second century CE.
structure. Most interestingly, a scene close to the east wall of main chamber of tomb at Cangshan,
yang group at the far right illustrates the journey of Shandong Province. Mid-second century CE.
the deceased couple to the lands of immortality: the
wife rides on a three-headed phoenix and the
husband on a snake-like creature; they are traveling quelling. Thus, the significance of these wall
to the abode of the Queen Mother of the West paintings lay not only in the pictures themselves,
(Xiwangmu), a goddess in Han popular religion but also in their transformation ot the tomb's
who is shown here seated on wave -like clouds. architecture into a coherent symbolic universe for
the dead.
The themes and images of these murals are not
unfamiliar: paintings in the Mawangdui tombs A nearby tomb at Shaogou (tomb No. 61; fig. 11)
expressed the same desire for underground was built at about the same time, but its wall
protection, immortality, and divine blessing. But paintings signified another trend in tomb
instead of being associated with individual objects, decoration: the illustration of traditional stories and
as in the earlier burials, in the Bo Qianqiu tomb morality tales.
17
For example, at Shaogou one
these themes and images were reorganized into an composition on the inner side of the partition lintel
architectural space: the ceiling provided a logical depicts the story of "Three Gentlemen Killed by
location for images of celestial bodies and the Two Peaches," exemplifying the ethic of loyalty and
heavenly journey; the murals on the front and back mutual friendship (fig. 13). A second composition
walls complemented each other with their depicts the visit of Confucius and Laozi to the
respective subjects of divine blessing and demon child prodigy Xiang Tuo, encouraging Confucian
Fig. 16. Banquet in the afterlife. Relief carving, niche in Fig. 18. Driving outdoors in the afterlife. Relief carving,
east wall of main chamber of tomb at Cangshan, outside face offacade-lintel of tomb at Cangshan,
Shandong Province. Mid-second century CE. Shandong Province. Mid-second century CE.
learning. These and other such images entered the wives of the deceased are taking a boat across the
stock of funerary painting themes, persisting river, since female (yin) had to be separated from
through Eastern Han. The world of the dead was male (yang) and water embodies the yin principle.
were employed; burials embellished with stone bas- deceased. The wives get into special carriages for
reliefs or pictorial tiles became fashionable in the women and escort the hearse outside the city
first and second century CE (cats. 103 04). An (fig. 15). Arriving at an inn, they are greeted by an
Eastern Han tomb often combined two- official. With its half-open door, this inn symbolizes
dimensional pictorial images with sculptured spirit the tomb: entering it symbolizes the burial of the
articles often vivid miniature representations of deceased and the beginning of his underworld life.
servants, dancers, storytellers, musicians, buildings, This is why, in the next scene, the deceased is no
wells, pigpens, livestock, and household furnishings longer represented by a hearse but appears in
and equipment of all kinds (cats. 96102). human form as the honored guest at an elaborate
banquet. This "portrait," engraved in a special niche,
Scholars have tried to explore the symbolic announces his rebirth: having regained his human
"program" constituted by the various forms of desires, he is now living in his underground home.
funerary art found in a tomb. A long inscription The scenes that follow represent the fulfillment of
excavated recently in an Eastern Han tomb of the all his desires in the afterlife. He is accompanied by
mid-second century CE in Cangshan, Shandong the fairies called Jade Maidens (fig. 16); he is
Province, describes the pictorial carving inside the entertained by musicians and dancers (fig. 17); and
tomb in a coherent narrative.' 8 The writer begins he takes a grand outdoor tour (fig. iS). These last
his description with the rear chamber, which held two scenes, engraved respectively on the inside and
the physical remains of the dead person. The images outside faces of the tomb's facade-lintel, represent
carved in this chamber are all mythical: directional the two major diversions that the tomb occupant
animals and heavenly beasts transform the solid would forever enjoy.
dragons guard the entrance of the burial chamber The Cangshan tomb inscription provides a specific
to keep the corpse safe. The front chamber is vision of the reality of life after death, focusing on
decorated with two horizontal reliefs on the lintels. the soul's transformation and underground pleasure;
The first relief, on the west wall (tig. 14). shows a pictures in some other Eastern Han tombs
chariot procession of local officials crossing a bridge- emphasize the social status and moral worth of the
over a river that symbolizes death; below them, the deceased. Each pictorial program reflects the beliefs
the ceiling, transform the underground chamber Museum and Archaeological Warring States and only 2 Li Rixun, "Shandong
Institute, CASS, Changsha dating from the middle Zhangqiu Nulangshan
into a miniature universe. A posthumous paradise is
Mawangdui yihao Hanmu Warring States period Zhanguo damu yueqi
the second element: various symbols of immortality (Beijing: Wenwu chubanshe, contained figurines (7 in all). zongkao" ("A Systematic
in a tomb reflect the desire to transport the W3)>fig 36- By contrast, 5 tombs of the late Examination of the Musical
Warring States period Instruments in a Large Warring
deceased to an eternal land after death. The final
Fig. S. After Hunan Provincial contained a total of 23 States Tomb at Nulangshan in
element is an idealized secular world. The world of Museum and Archaeological figurines. See Kaogu, no. 9 Zhangqiu, Shandong
Institute, CASS, Changsha (1963), pp. 461-73. Province"), Zhongguo wenwu
the dead person is depicted as an extension and
Mawangdui yihao Hanmu shijie ("The World of Chinese
idealization of his former life: death would permit
(Beijing: Wenwu chubanshe, 1971), 2. Kaogu xuebao, no. 4 {1984), Art"), no. 127 (March 1996),
him to enjoy all that he had most valued during his
fig 18 pp. 504-7- pp, 86-107.
in colorful entertainments. In death, too, an ideal Mawangdui yihao Hanmu Jiangling") (Beijing: Wenwu Fenshuilmg in Shanxi and at
(Beijing: Wenwu chubanshe, 1973), chubanshe, 1996), p. 278. Huixian and Luoyang in
society would be realized, a society regulated by the
figs. 23, 25. Similar inscriptions have also Henan. See Kaogu xuebao, no. 1
highest social and moral values of Confucian been found in Chu tombs at (1957), P- n6; Huixian fajue
teachings. The elaborate banquet scenes, carriage Fig. 10. After Hunan Provincial Xinyang and in Mawangdui baogao ("A Report of
Museum and Archaeological tomb No. 3 of the Western Archaeological Excavations at
processions, and Confucian morality tales illustrated
Han. Huixian") (Beijing: Kexue
Institute,CASS, Changsha
in funerary art enact such earthly desires. Mawangdui yihao Hanmu chubanshe, 1956), p. 45; Kaogu,
(Beijing: Wenwu chubanshe, 1973), 4. See Huang Zhanyue, no. 12 (1959), p. 656; Kaogu,
Zhongguo gudai dc rensheng he no. 7 (i960), p. 71; and Kaogu,
fig 38.
First established in Han funerary art, these three
renxun ("Human offerings and no. 10 (1962), p. 516.
elements the cosmological model, the Fig. 11. After Kaogu xuebao, companions in death in ancient
posthumous paradise, and the idealized secular 1964.2, p. 110. China") (Beijing: Wenwu 9. Susan Stewart, On Longing:
builders of later ages to create new architectural, 10-11. Collection (Durham: Duke
sculptural, and pictorial forms such as those so 5. Not all early figurines University Press, 1993), p. 65.
(cat. 106) and Yuan tomb tiles (cat. 112) in this number of examples implied of No One: (Re)presentmg the
specific ritual or magical First Emperor's Army," Art
exhibition. Fig. 14. After Wu Hung,
Monumentality in Early
functions. Changtaiguan tomb Bulletin 77, no. 1 (March 1995),
A Brief Survey
Wang Qingzheng
Deputy Director,
The Shanghai Museum
invention.
found expression primarily in painted designs, Fig. 1. Pottery shard with incised design. Longshan
whereas in theYangzi basin, during both the culture (2400-2000 bce). Shanghai Museum.
Hemudu culture and the slightly later Majiabang
through Liangzhu cultures, incised decorations were Fig. 2. Pottery shard with incised design. Liangzhu
prominent. Whether the origins of the incised culture (ca. 3600-ca. 2000 BCE). Unearthed at Tinglin
decorations of the Longshan culture can be traced site,Jinshan, Shanghai. Shanghai Museum.
to southern influences is a question worth
pondering. A typology of the incised decorations
on Neolithic pottery reveals clearly that these were Some three thousand years ago, during the late
the origins of the later bronze decoration (figs. I, 2). Shang dynasty, a type of green-glazed ware, different
temperatures high enough to sinter the kaolin, these temperatures under iooo^C.) Probably [200C was
vessels, though white-bodied, are nevertheless the highest temperature achievable anywhere .11 thai
"pottery." White pottery has been found in both time (not just in China): even bronze casting the
Yangshao and Majiayao culture sites. The Shang defining technology of the Shang only required
dynasty double-eared white jar in this exhibition temperatures under [iooC. Protoporcelain was
(cat. 117) was decorated with patterns taken from highly regarded from the late Shang dynasty, some
the bronze repertory; it was made solely for three thousand years ago. through the Warring
aristocratic appreciation. This type of white pottery States era, which ended in the late third century
comes mainly from the Shang ruins at Anyang in bce. Its characteristic thin greenish glazes had iron
Henan Province, and it exemplifies the great skill in oxides as their colorant. The green-glazed :nn
pottery carving achieved during the last phase of (cat. 11.S") in this exhibition is a typical piece of
the Shang period. Shang protoporcelain.
The high-temperature glaze applied to the Tang dynasty (618 goy). Xing ware; h. 7.2 cm, diam. at
protoporcelains mentioned above was fired at mouth JJ5. 7 cm. Shanghai Museum.
I200C. High-temperature glazes were first used in
China, but low-temperature pottery glazes, fired at
roughly 700 900C, were in use even earlier in the ewer with dragon handle (cats. 121, 122) have the
Middle East. Low-temperature lead glazes were exuberant forms unique to the north, and are
probably not used in China before the fourth typical of green-glazed porcelain produced in
century BCE, and they were not in widespread use the north.
until the Han dynasty. Lead-glazed pottery burial
objects were very popular during the Han, with a Tang polychrome-glazed pottery ware developed
limited palette of colors created by the addition of out of Han lead-glazed pottery. The more extensive
different colorants to the glazes. The principal Tang palette comprised primarily green (from
colors used in the Han were rust browns (some copper oxide), blue (cobalt oxide), and a range of
with a reddish tint) with iron as the colorant, and a ferruginous hues from cream through yellow and
green for which copper was the colorant. The amber to dark brown (ferric oxide); it also included
reddish-glazed pottery dog (cat. 101) in this a near-black, purple, and white. The famous Tang
exhibition is lifelike and appealing, and the green- three-color (sancai) wares were generally decorated
glazed waterside pavilion (cat. 100) affords a vivid with overlapping splashes of different-colored
example of Han architecture. glazes, which were allowed to flow together in the
reaching its apogee during the Western Jin. The best Yellow-and-green as well as blue lead-glazed pieces
wares of this era had glazes of a consistent greenish were found in the tomb of Zheng Rentai (664 CE)
gray or a slightly yellowish green, with a rather at Liquan county in Shaanxi Province, proving that
lustrous surface. Beauty of shape and ornamentation polychromes were being manufactured by the early
was prized in vessels. Animal forms were widely Tang, and they were produced on an even greater
used, and vessels of all types were decorated with scale by the reign of Empress Wu (r. 684 704). The
stamped, incised, or applied patterns. Openwork polychrome braying camel with monster-mask
and modeling were also very highly developed. saddle (cat. 107) is a representative work of this
period.
Green glazes were developed much later in
northern China than in the south. To date, not a In the history of Chinese porcelain making potters
single kiln making green-glazed porcelain during of the Tang dynasty accomplished the transition
the Western Jin period has been found north of the from the production of green-glazed wares alone to
Yangzi River. It is believed that green-glazed an equally significant production of white porcelain
porcelains gradually appeared north of the Yellow as well; they also advanced the development of
River around the sixth century CE.The Northern black, brown, multicolored, and painted porcelains.
Qi incised jar with six lugs and the chicken-headed
ware (fig. 4). This guan cannot denote the fabled guan. Five Dynasties (907960). Yue u>are;h. 28.6 an,
Guan ware, because many superb pieces of Ding, diam. >it mouth p.j an. I 'nearthed in 1970 from .1 Five
Yue, and Yaozhou ware are not marked guan; Dynasties tomb in Banqiao, Un'an, Zhejiang Province.
moreover, not .ill the pieces so marked are Zhejiang Provincial Museum.
outstanding. During the Tang dynasty a
the Tang, Five Dynasties, and Northern Song many peak. In the northwest, potters of the Yaozhou kilns
pieces of porcelain were marked with the name of in Shaanxi, building on the successes of Yue ware,
the agency that had ordered them. worked toward the creation of a truer green glaze;
these Five Dynasties potters accomplished the
Although the Five Dynasties lasted altogether only transition from the varied green glazes of the Tang
fifty brief years, they have an important place in the to the more uniform blue-green of the Northern
history of ceramics. During these years Ding ware, Song. It was also during the Five Dynasties that the
major development ofYingqing ("shadow blue" base 9.1 cm. Shanghai Museum.
glaze, also called Qingbai) during the Northern
Song.
renowned for its ash-colored body, its sky blue
In the history of Chinese ceramics many wares glaze with fine crackling, and for being wholly
reached their florescence during the Song dynasty, glazed and fired on tiny sesame seed-shaped spurs
whose so-called "five great wares" were Ru, Guan, (fig. 7). Of all the great Chinese porcelain wares,
Ge, Ding, and Jun. Ru ware has survived in the smallest numbers and
is perhaps the most prized. For a long time, the
There surely must be some significance in the fact location of the Ru kilns could not be confirmed,
that of these five wares, the organizers of this but in the winter of 19S6 two studies made by staff
exhibition chose to display only Ru, Guan, and from the Shanghai Museum verified the site ot the
Ding wares, and not Ge or Jun wares. In fact, the Northern Song Ru kilns at Qingliangsi in Baofeng
site and period of production of Ge ware remain county, Henan Province.'' The kilns were then
major topics for exploration in the history of excavated by archaeologists from Henan Province.
Chinese ceramics. Although an international Ru ware was produced only for an extremely brief
symposium on Ge ware was held in Shanghai in time, and in very limited quantities. Some pieces
October 1992, 4 no answers were to be had (fig. 5). found at the kiln site lack the above-mentioned
As for Jun ware (fig. 6), it exists in some quantity in defining characteristics; these clearly are not
the United States and Europe. The Art Institute of Ru ware.
Chicago, in particular, owns a collection of
Northern Song Jun ware unequaled in China Song dynasty Guan ware is ,m even more
except in the Beijing Palace Museum and the controversial subject in the history of Chinese
Taibei Palace Museum. In the first half of the ceramics. Historical documents indicate that there
twentieth century some European and American were three types of Guan ware, one made in the
collectors and scholars had regarded these Northern Song capita] of Bianliang (present-day
specimens ot Northern Song Jun ware as Yuan or Kaifeng, in Henan Province), one .11 the Xiuneisi
Ming products. But excavation of the site of the ("Palace Works Bureau'") of the Southern Song
Northern Song kilns at Diaotai in Yu county, capital at Hangzhou, and one at the Jiaotanxia kilns
I lenan Province, 5 completely verified the existence of Southern Song Hangzhou. To date, only the
recently questioned whether the Northern Song wares. Mostly they made white and black
1997 an ancient kiln site was discovered at pieces, and during the Jin dynasty they even created
Fenghuangshan in Hangzhou Municipality, underglaze painted porcelains. Most of their output
Zhejiang Province, but further scientific excavation was sold to the mass market. Cizhou ware was
is needed before it can be determined if this is decorated in a variety of ways, most often with
indeed the Xiuneisi kiln. underglaze black or brown designs painted on a
However exquisite and acclaimed, the "five great designs might be carved or incised through the
wares" of Ru, Guan, Ge, Ding, and Jun do not white slip to the buff-colored body fabric, then
encompass the total achievement of Chinese clear-glazed another way of creating two-tone
ceramics during the Northern and Southern Song, decoration. Sometimes an allover pattern of small
Liao, and Jin dynasties. Yaozhou wares of the north circles, called pearl-dotting or ring-matting, would
and Longquan wares of the south, both green- be stamped on the ground. Green-painted and
glazed, were enormously significant both in the polychromed Cizhou pieces have also been found.
quantity produced for use by society and in the
quality of individual pieces. During the Ming and Qing dynasties Jingdezhen
achieved wide recognition. Prior to the 1950s little and an avid foreign trade. (It should be
was known about ancient green-glazed wares from remembered that the technique of making
northern China, and except for Ru ware and Jun porcelain was unknown in the West until the
ware, all pieces produced during the Northern eighteenth century.) Long known for its many
Song and Jin dynasties were called northern superb wares, the most immediate and
Longquan or northern Chuzhou ware. Since 1984 consequential cause of its ascendancy was the
large-scale scientific excavations of the Yaozhou development there in the mid-fourteenth century
kilns have fully revealed their nature. Although the of underglaze blue and underglaze red porcelain.
Yaozhou kilns of the Northern Song also produced Blue-and-white, red-and-white, and all the
white-glazed, black-glazed, and brown-glazed polychrome variants descended from these, swept
porcelain, green-glazed porcelains were, of course, the public taste, ousting monochrome green-glazed
their principal output. These were decorated by ware from its millennia-long supremacy.
carving, incising, molding, appliqueing, and
modeling, and the powerfully carved pieces are Porcelain manufacture in Jingdezhen entered its
was made mostly from the mid-to-late Northern no endorsement of blue-and-white, nor did the
Song until the early Southern Song, whereas the gentry consider blue-and-white to be aesthetically
thin-bodied, thick-glazed powder-green celadon important. Beginning in the Yongle era, however,
was popular during the late twelfth and early blue-and-white began to make its way into the
thirteenth centuries. The peak period for powder- palaces and houses of the social elite. Relative to
green and metei-green celadons was the thirteenth the Yuan dynasty, there was major progress in the
century. The jar with everted mouth and molded production of both body and glaze. Potters in the
bowstring pattern in this exhibition is a classic imperial kilns during theYongle and Xuande
example of powder-green Longquan ware (cat. 134). periods perfected blue-and-white wares beyond
anything seen during the Yuan dynasty, achieving a
Cizhou ware derives its name from what is now Ci finely textured and pure white body, bright and
county in Hebei Province (formerly a part of lustrous glaze, and rich, well-controlled blue color.
yielded an interesting contrast with the rich blue Underground Palace at the
this exhibition (cat. 146), though of the Yongzheng Celebrating the 30th Anniversary
Regina Krahl
Independent Scholar,
Affiliated with the Royal Museums
of Art and History, Brussels
122
China is particularly rich in resources of earth, clay,
The fame of Chinese ceramics is built on these called porcelain are some sixth-century white wares
latter high-fired wares. Porcelain stone, or china from the Northern Qi (550-77) or Sui (5S1-618)
stone, the raw material from which stoneware is period (fig. 1). Between that period and the
made, is abundant in many areas of China, north thirteenth century (Yuan dynasty; 1279 1368), a
and south. Very high quality porcelain stone can be great variety of more or less "porcelaneous"
used more or less as it is mined, without requiring stonewares was made throughout China, until in
any additions or much preparation. Stonewares have the second half of the Yuan dynasty the continuous
been made in China since the Shang dynasty production ot nothing but porcelains began at the
(ca. 1600-ca. 1100 bce), and predate their Western kilns of Jingdezhen and China's stoneware tradition
counterparts by over two and a half millennia. came to an end.'
The origin of porcelain is more difficult to specify, EAKTHENWAIIE IN THE NEOLITHIC PERIOD
for it was not an invention but an evolution from Only in prehistoric times was earthenware an
stoneware, an advance along the continuum of important material in China. The most practical
high-fired wares. Where one ends and the other and versatile material available for vessels,
temperature. Since these cannot easily be area that we call China, which, between the sixth
determined for ancient items, more superficial and the second millennium net. was inhabited by
features have to be taken into account, such as the many independent and distinctive cultures. The
translucency and the whiteness of the body and the ceramics produced during the Neolithic period
clarity of its sound when struck. The Chinese (ca. 7000-ca. 2000 bci ) .ue as varied and complex
themselves do not distinguish at all between the as the cultures themselves, but they do not vary
two high-fired materials stoneware and greatly in material and workmanship. I he red or
porcelain and use the same name (ci) for both, as yellow pottery is often burnished and most
distinguished from low-fired earthenwares {tito). frequently painted with abstract geometric designs
been utilitarian.
EARTHENWARE SINCE THE BRONZE Fig. 2. Goblet with eggshell walls and openwork stem.
From the middle of the second millennium bce, earthenware; h. 26.$ cm. Unearthed at Donghaiyu,
earthenware was little used for quality crafts. It still Rizhao, Shandong Province. Shandong Provincial
wall tiles and bricks were mainly for underground From the Warring States period (475-221 bce) until
structures, because Chinese buildings were held up theHigh Tang period (713779) earthenware was in
by wooden pillars rather than supporting walls. demand as an inexpensive, versatile, and attractive
During the Shang (ca. 1600 ca. 1100 bce) and in funerary practices: figures of men and beasts
Zhou (ca. 1100256 bce) dynasties, China's Bronze (cats. 88-92, 96-97, 99-101, 105-7, 109). models of
Age, earthenware had the important but naturally structures (cats. 100, 102), and copies of objects of
unglamorous function of supplying models and daily life. These replicas were painted or glazed or
molds for bronze casting. Bronze Age potters thus both. The figures substituted for the living beings
left an imprint on the crafts of their time, but their that previously had been sacrificed for important
actual works were not meant to be preserved and burials; the copies considerably reduced the costs of
2
have survived in only a very fragmentary state. funerals by replacing more valuable goods.
An exception is the white pottery jar from Anyang, The most remarkable aspect of this tomb pottery is
in Henan Province (cat. 117) a rare instance of a the sculptural quality of some of the figures. Since
bronze vessel, presumably shaped after a pottery burial goods were status symbols for both the
model, being in turn copied in clay. 3 Beautiful but deceased and the survivors, they became more and
impractical, it is made of white earthenware of finer more ambitious over time. This trend reached its
quality and brighter color than that used for model zenith in the High Tang period; grave figures of
making, yet is similarly soft, porous, and brittle. Not that time can be strikingly naturalistic and lively
surprisingly, such pieces do not seem to have been (cats. 1057) or else highly imaginative and
made in any quantity, nor for long, and they do not elaborate in their modeling (cats, no 11). 4 They
Funerary pottery inspired little innovation in before firing. Whatever the process, the glaze was
ceramic technology. Glazes were used on Chinese never smooth or even.
earthenwares beginning only in the Han dynasty
(206 BCE-220 ce), almost a thousand years after Vessels of glazed stoneware were made throughout
they had appeared on Chinese stonewares. The the Bronze Age (ca. 2100 bce220 ce) without
glazes have a wider range of bright colors than the major changes. Whereas in the Eastern Zhou
early stonewares, beginning with a leaf green period bronze vessels became more and more
(cat. 100) and a reddish brown (cat. 101) in the Han flamboyant in shape and design, their surfaces often
dynasty, followed by a blackish brown in the enhanced by dramatic inlay in silver, gold,
Northern Wei (386-534), various tones of yellow malachite, and other materials, and lacquerware
and amber from the Northern Qi on, and provided an elegant alternative in the form of far
eventually blue and turquoise in the Tang. 5 more delicate vessels with intricate polychrome
painted designs, the finest ceramics were still
glazes, they were decorative but of very limited use into a number of independent kingdoms. The
to the living. This made them even more desirable kingdoms most important for the continuation of
for burials, as they held no attraction for tomb indigenous Chinese culture were all located in the
robbers. southeast and all had their capitals in Nanjing. The
manufacture of stonewares burgeoned in the south.
STONEWARE FROM THE SHANG Among the earliest ceramic centers to become
DYNASTY TO THE SIX DYNASTIES famous by name are theYue kilns of Zhejiang
PERIOD Province, not far from Nanjing. They were the
In the production of these various earthenwares earliest kilns to make stonewares with glazes that
since the Neolithic period, China was no more were applied in a liquid state and therefore evenly
advanced than most other countries. The important covered the whole vessel (cats. 119, 120). In color
and unique development of Chinese ceramics these liquid glazes, whose yellowish olive tone was
toward the production of porcelain took a separate derived from oxidized iron, are similar to ash glazes;
route. Its origins can be traced back to the Bronze but they tend to be brighter and more intense since
Age, when stonewares began to be produced the contents of a liquid glaze can more easily be
simultaneously with earthenwares, but at different manipulated than those of wood ash.Yue ware was
kiln centers and for different purposes. made in much greater quantities than earlier
(cat. 118) may have been considered less attractive During this multistate period China was more
than its white earthenware contemporary (cat. 117), receptive than ever before to foreign goods and
but technically it is far more sophisticated. It has a ideas. Probably the most significant influence came
stoneware body and a natural glaze derived from from Western Asia with the introduction of
wood ash. Fired at a high temperature (over Buddhism. The southern kingdom ofWu (220-80),
1200 C), its body became hard and completely in whose domain theYue kilns were situated, was
dense and wood ash on its surface turned liquid, one of the first to embrace the new religion. Yue
forming a glaze over part of the vessel. wares therefore show some of the earliest Chinese
representations of the Buddha (cat. 120).
7
indeed. Whether the porcelain stone that forms the shapes seem to embody the taste of their time and
body materia] was used in a pure state or enhanced to represent precious artifacts in winch the period
by admixtures of kaolin (china clay) and other was otherwise poor, the most elaborate pieces were
Substances, it always remained gray and rather destined for burial; only the simpler ones were
s
co. use. The glaze might have been accidental. intended lor use.
TANG DYNASTIES (cats. 124, 125). With their very pale bodies, highly
Although Buddhism remained enormously glossy light-green glazes, and surfaces as tactile as a
influential until the end of the High Tang period, well-polished gem, they are exceptional indeed,
ceramics did not reflect its influence for long. In unmatched in quality by any other pieces surviving
the early Tang dynasty and during the two brief from that time, even if closely related (cat. 123)." In
periods that led up to it artistically, the Northern the repository's inventory, they were listed as mise
Qi (550-577) and the Sui (581-618), Chinese ("secret color") ware, a term well known from late
potters again became more inward-looking. At the Tang poetry, which tells us that mise ware was made
12
Yue kilns in the south, which continued to make at the Yue kilns.
potters were creating ceramics with most desirable exquisite and expensive gifts from the imperial
features: a clear and clean color, a glossy sheen, a court, clearly documents their elevated status. When
smooth tactile surface, and an even, flawless the Tang empire began to break up into smaller
appearance. The sheer beauty of such material made kingdoms, not long after the Yue wares at the
ornament superfluous. Famen Temple site were made, the kings of Wu-
Yue, in whose domain the kilns were situated,
Yue and Xing wares were more than merely reserved Yue ware for their own use.
Chajing ("Classic ofTea"), an eighth-century text, played a similar role at another court. Some of
bowls ofYue (cats. 12325) and of Xing ware them are inscribed on the base with the character
(cats. 126, 127) 9 are recommended for tea guan ("official") (cats. 126, 127) or with similar
drinking then an of almost
activity ritual identifications. The significance of this inscription
body of Xing ware can be reminiscent ot silver, ceramics singled out in this way might have had.
these ceramics were neither conceived nor regarded The only other Tang stonewares besides clear- and
as substitutes for such elevated substances but rather green-glazed ones were those with black glazes,
as their equivalents. These early literary references often with light blue splashes, but for those no
signal the dawn of connoisseurship in Chinese elevated status can be claimed.' 4
ceramics.
STONEWARE DURING THE SONG
In the early Tang dynasty. Buddhism had gripped DYNASTY
not only the population at large but also the Stylistically, these undecorated monochrome wares
imperial household. Buddhist temples regularly of the Tang are completely indigenous Chinese
received valuable offerings and thus became products. They initiated a taste in ceramics that
veritable treasure houses. One of the foremost found its fullest expression only during the Song
temples of the time was the Famen Temple, not far dynasty (9601279). Both aesthetically and
from the Tang capital ot Chang'an (present-day technically, the Song dynasty represents a high
Xi'an); it held one of the most sacred relics, a finger point of Chinese culture and particularly of
bone of the Buddha. In the mid-Tang period this Chinese ceramics. It was a time when exquisite
relic was repeatedly borne in procession with great materials and sophisticated workmanship were
ceremony from the temple to the palace, and then combined with a calculated simplicity in form and
returned with lavish donations from the court. The design.
Helmut Brinker in this volume). ceramics in the Tang, dozens of kiln centers had
mastered the basic principles by the early Song.
When this repository was discovered in 1987 under Kilns that during the Tang had made only basic
theFamen Temple pagoda, the Buddha bone was utensils which were not known by the kiln names,
round to be preserved among the most precious refined their body and glaze materials and
objects of gold and silver, the rarest pieces of rock improved potting and firing techniques to such a
crystal and glass, over seven thousand pieces of degree that by the tenth century they were able to
mastery gave free rein to creativity and allowed the Kaifeng. They were made for the court for only
potters to concentrate on detail and subtle some twenty years in the last two decades of the
variation. The most important ceramic wares ot the eleventh and first years of the twelfth century. Only
Song all developed from the three basic types of some sixty examples have survived today, but
stoneware made in the Tang: those with green, collectors have lamented their rarity for centuries.
clear, and black glazes. Most Ru wares are accessories for the scholar's
desk, such as brush washers (low bowls for cleaning
Song shapes are almost invariably simple, functional, the writing or painting brush). They are extremely
and well proportioned. Song vessels tend to be simple, evenly and thinly potted, and almost
monochrome-glazed in subtle, rarely seen shades invariably undecorated. Ru wares are fully glazed
rather than bright primary colors. Often they are (including foot and base), having been placed in the
wholly undecorated, or have surfaces modestly kiln on supports that left only minute so-called
enlivened by the faint tonal gradations created by sesame-seed marks on the glaze. The ware is
incised or carved designs, or by the random celebrated above all for its tactile glaze in varying
patterns formed by a crackle, the decorative crazing evocative shades of bluish and grayish green, usually
of the glaze that can occur during the cooling with a crackle. The comparison with well-polished,
The most admired features of Song ceramics look When the northern capital was captured by the Jin
as if they had come about naturally, without all the invaders and the Song fled south in 1127, they set
effort and precision work that they in fact require. up kilns at their new capital in present-day
Only an intimate familiarity with the properties of Hangzhou to make an "official" (guan) ware
all raw materials and a thorough understanding of (cat. 133) modeled on Ru. Using the different raw
their reactions during the firing cycle enabled materials of the south, the potters came up with a
potters to manipulate them as they wished. ware that appeals for the same reasons but looks
different, having a thicker, clearer glaze and a more
The appeal of perfected simplicity achieved pronounced crackle. Guan and Ru wares represent
through exquisite craftsmanship is very subtle the epitome of Chinese ceramics the
indeed. Ceramic masterpieces of the Song were not transformation of earth as a medium into a
made for ostentatious display, but for handling by substance deemed more beautiful and more
connoisseurs in an intimate, private setting. It was precious than the most valuable materials.
in the literati circles of the Song that ceramics were
first appreciated as works of art, that they were Since these two wares could not easily be obtained
deemed worth collecting, whether antique or new, except by the imperial palace, their beauty was
and worth handing down trom one generation to emulated by other kilns. "Celadon," as green-glazed
the next. stonewares are usually called in the West, was in fact
in seemingly limitless supply. IS
The Yaozhou kilns in
Although the preference for artifacts made of clay Shaanxi Province in the north were stylistically less
over precious metals or stones probably emanated immediately dependent on Ru; their wares bear
from the literati circles of the Song, where swiftly incised, carved, or combed designs (cat. 130).
understatement was a celebrated virtue, the But the Longquan kilns in Zhejiang Province in
imperial court manifested a similar taste. Of course, the south clearly aimed at imitating Guan (cat. 134).
not all the vast and varied Song wares were Some Longquan celadons do this so successfully
officially appreciated, but some were made that they were, and sometimes still are. mistaken for
exclusively for the court. No comparable Guan ware."'
Through their absolute mastery of the technical potted white body; clear, translucent glaze: and
process and their acute sense of aesthetic principles accomplished, swiftly carved designs. Ding ware
the potters, none of whom known by name, were
is (cat. 131 and its predecessors, cats. [28, [29), from
able to manipulate their medium so sensitively and Hebei Province in the north, has a characteristic
intelligently that they turned one of the most basic ivory-tinged glaze and was used at the court. But
raw materials earth into one of the most the so-called qingbai ("bluish white'") ware, whu li
precious commodities. has a blue-tinged clear glaze (cat. 135) and came
from fingdezhen injiangxi Province in the south,
By tar the rarest and most desirable Chinese was never highly appreciated, h was the Jingdezhen
ceramics of all times were and are the green-glazed kilns, however, that were lo establish a virtual
stonewares from the Ru kilns in Baofene county. monopoly on Chinese ceramics with their
decorations of calligraphic or painterly quality. with purple suffusions. Jnn kilns, Henan Province, diam.
PORCELAINS SINCE THE YUAN stressed about later Chinese painting is equally true
DYNASTY for later Chinese ceramics: the groundbreaking
For some time the Jingdezhen kilns of Jiangxi discoveries, both technical and conceptual, took
Province had been able to create a clean, white, and place so remarkably early in China that all later
translucent porcelain. Perhaps the most valuable craftsmen had to battle against a "near-
aspect of this material is that it is totally neutral. A overpowering weight of the past" to maintain their
pristine ground such as this provides an ideal originality. Cahill's admiration for the "stratagems"
surface for painted decoration. The introduction of the painters of the Ming and Qing period devised
fine cobalt from the Middle East and experiments "for escaping repetition and stagnation" could
with copper in China suddenly introduced two equally be extended to the potters of the period,
striking pigments, a bright blue and a deep red, for even though their ways of working were in no way
painting with a brush on the dried but still unfired comparable. In fact, the phases in which Chinese
and unglazed porcelain body, very much like ceramics had the greatest impact on ceramics
painting in ink on paper or silk. Sealed with glaze worldwide were yet to come.
and fired at high temperatures, the colors are
permanent. With this innovation, the stylistic From the early fourteenth century the most
concept of fine ceramics underwent a fundamental important aspect of a ceramic vessel was its
is, the auspiciously worded designation of the Beijing; h. 20. J cm. Private collection.
patterns were precise and materials absolutely decoration remained spirited. I'.imting 111 overglaze
which is then refired, was perfected in the poetic colophon written in black in a calligraphic
Chenghua period (1465-1487). Enamel colors such hand, followed by (painted) "seals" (fig. 5). The
as red, green, yellow, aubergine, and turquoise were subtly nuanced color and the microscopic precision Finest Cultural Relics of
China: Ceramics Volume")
used first in the doucai ("matched" or "clashing" with which minute details are rendered make this
(Taipei: Shangwu ymshuguan,
colors) technique, in which those overglaze colors the most sophisticated porcelain painting ever
1993). PP- 76-163.
which underglaze blue outlines were considered Northern Wei tomb dated to
greatest heights. It required not only more highly 1981), cpl. B; and for a rare
Fig. 5. Copyright Sotheby's.
example ot a Tang turquoise
trained artists but also a much larger palette of
glaze, see the figure of an earth
suitable pigments to achieve a flexible range of NOTES spirit in The Tsui Museum of
1. For the purpose of this Art: Chinese Ceramics I, Neolithic
colors and shades.
exhibition, the term to Liao (Hong Kong: The Tsui
"porcelain" has been used very Museum of Art, 1993), pi. 121.
Imperial workshops had been set up within the conservatively that is, only for
wares from the Yuan dynasty or 6. In addition to functional
palace precincts in the Forbidden City under the
later, even though some earlier
containers, Yue wares of the Six
Kangxi emperor (1662-1722), for painting enamels pieces may also seem to qualify
Dynasties include unmistakable
for that designation.
on copper, porcelain, and glass. For this purpose the funerary wares such as plates
science and technology, were assigned to these Institute of Archaeology of iianfang zhi hi ("The Southern
Shanxi Province, ed.. Art of the Route of the Dissemination of
workshops from time to time, to their great
Houma Foundry (Princeton: the Buddhist Faith") {Beijing:
chagrin. Among these artists it was Giuseppe Princeton University Press, Wenwu chubanshe, 1993),
and Robert Bagley
Castiglione (1698-1766), known to the Chinese as
1996); passim.
"Debris from the Houma
Lang Shining, who greatly influenced the
Foundry," Orientations (October
8. A series of the most lavishly
decorative arts through his naturalistic painting 1996), pp. 50-58.
embellished funerary vases of
style, with its sharply defined contrasts between the Northern Qi dynasty is
character guan ("official") are respectively: see Wenwu, no. 12 shapes characteristic of the
generally associated with the (1979), pp. 18-23; and Wenunt, Yuan and Ming dynasties, with
Ding kilns, but are not no. 12 (1975), p. 41. shaded blue and purple glazes.
Chajing ("Classic of Tea"), see from kilns in Henan Province, controversial archaeological
Francis Ross Carpenter, The with and without light blue evidence some scholars also
Classic of Tea by Lu Yii (Boston glaze splashes, see Regina attribute the latter to that
and Toronto: Little, Brown, Krahl, Chinese Ceramics from the period. For examples of the
1974), where this discussion Meiyintang Collection, vol. 1 two types, see Zhao Qingyun,
appears on pp. 90-93- (London; Azimuth Editions, Henan taoci shi ("History of
11. The two octagonal bottles other important Tang Zijincheng chubanshe, 1993),
(cats. 123, 125), which stoneware kilns not represented pi. 18 and cpl. 11, nos. 42, 43,
superficially look very similar, here are those of Changsha in 45 for the former, and pi. 19
are in fact very different. The Hunan Province, which made and cpl. 11, no. 44 for the latter.
clay and glossier glaze and has glaze; see Timothy See- Yin selection of Song black wares,
more elegant proportions than Lam, Tang Ceramics: Changsha see the exhibition catalogue by
the one in the Palace Museum, Kilns (Hong Kong: Lammett Robert D. Mowry, Hare's Fur,
no, no (Hong Kong: The 16. Several of the most Jingdezhen injiangxi Province,
University of Hong Kong, exquisite Longquan copies of which can be traced back no
[994). P- 34i. pi- iG.The two Guan ware presented as earlier than the first quarter of
types therefore appear to be tributes to the court during the the fourteenth century.
contemporary products of the first Qing reigns were included
same kilns; why they should be in the National Palace
so different cannot yet be Museum exhibition Song
explained. guanyao tezhan (Special
Su Bai
Professor, Beijing University
Bingling Temple, Cave i6g:6, Liujiaxia city, Gansu Bingling Temple, Cave i6g:i2, Liujiaxia city, Gansu
Province. Province.
I.
consisting of a Buddha sitting in meditation and Cave 20, Yungang, Shauxi Province.
(fig. 3). In 1949 a Buddha seated cross-legged in According to the History of the Northern Dynasties.
meditation was unearthed in Xingping county, in 47(1 the dowager empress I eng "s.it in Court and
Shaanxi Province, which dates from 471 (cat. 147). held all power."' During her ascendancy the
Sakyamuni's attire; rather, he was portrayed wearing 484. Painted lacquer screen. Tomb oj Sima Jinlong and his
the Confucian scholar's loose gown and wide sash. wife, Shijiazhai village, Datong, Shanxi Province.
The face and torso also were transformed
increasingly from square and powerful to thin and
elongated. The earliest dated example of this new found among the figures of worshipers in the
type of Buddha statue is found on the upper east above-mentioned Yungang and Longmen caves, as
side outside Cave 11 atYungang (No. 11:14, which well as among the earthen burial figures and the
is numbered lid by Mizuno Seiichi and Nagahiro paintings and stone carvings in Northern Wei
Toshio in ThcYungang Caves). An inscription dated tombs of the Luoyang years. Among these secular
to 489 is carved below the grotto. Thereafter, figures, the earliest known examples from the north
elaborate flowing drapery and elongated faces and are the persons painted on a lacquer screen found
figures became the vogue and spread throughout in the tomb of Sima Jinlong and his wife. The
the Northern Wei domains (fig. 4).TheYungang screen, discovered in the village of Shijiazhai in
cave sculptures from 489 to 524 are the most Datong, dates from 474484 (fig. 5).
1
There is some
representative of this style. In 493 the capital was speculation that this screen may have been
moved from Datong in Shanxi Province, near the imported from southern China at about that time.
Yungang caves, to Luoyang inHenan Province. The
various sculptures from the Guyang Cave at The scholar's loose robe and sash, elegant
Longmen near Luoyang similarly display the physiognomy, and purity of image characterize
characteristics of this era. During the late Qing human figures of the Eastern Jin and Liu Song eras.
dynasty a carved stone panel donated by one Liu In 847 Zhang Yanyuan of the Tang dynasty
Gen, dated to 524, was unearthed in Dongyipu, (61S907) compiled the Lidai mingh.ua ji ("Record
Luoyang (cat. 152). Some of the figures in the of Famous Painters of Successive Dynasties"). 2 In it,
middle of the tablet exquisitely exemplify the the Jin and Liu Song dynasties are referred to as the
slender, linearly rendered figures of relatively late Era of Middle Antiquity, and in volume 2 of this
date. Buddhist icons were not the only images in work the painters of the Era of Middle Antiquity
this style: good examples of the same style are are thus critiqued:
rf
Gu Kaizhi (ca. 344-ca. 406) and Lu Tanwei
(ca. 440-ca. 500) are cited as representative painters
conceived in nothing more than ink. In Fig. 6. Gu Kaizhi (ca. 344-ca. 406). Admonitions to
painting figures . . . Lu gets the bones right, the Court Ladies (last section). Song dynasty copy.
while Gu [Kaizhi] gets the spirit. . . .Yanyuan Handscroll, ink and color on silk. British Museum.
considers this an appropriate assessment.
8).
s
Such figures were particularly in vogue during
the Liu Song and Southern Qi dynasties. Hence
the contemporary writer Xie He of Wu, in his
praised by mere effusiveness, yet (his work) is of paintings and the earthen tomb figures from the
the greatest value. There is nothing to say brick tomb in Xuezhuang village of I )eng county,
except that he is the best of the best, but the I lenan Province, which is on the west bank of the
III.
courts was reflected in artistic styles, namely, the with traces of pigment. Xuezhang village, Deng county,
popularity of Zhang Sengyou's (act. ca. 500 ca. 550) Henan Province.
wondrously as a magician. So I suggest ranking flesh right," can be seen in the two stone carvings
him at the top with Gu and Lu (preface to of Amitabha and Maitreya Buddha from Mao
vol. 7, Lidai minghua ji). county, Sichuan Province, dating from 483 (fig. 11).
their praise of Sengyou, but for a specific Chengdu, which date from 523 (cat. 150), 529, 537,
description of Zhang's style we have only Li's and 548, all bearing inscriptions from the Wuji
remark about his marvelous sense of bones. What period of the Liang dynasty. (The above are all in
should we make of this phrase? After the previous the collection of the Sichuan Provincial Museum.)
passage, the Lidai minghua ji goes on to quote These same traits are also evident in the carved
Zhang Huaiguan: images of female attendants from the painted brick
tomb of the late Southern dynasties period in Qijia
6
In the subtleties of drawing people, Zhang gets village of Changzhou,Jiangsu Province. '
And as
the flesh right. the bodies grew fleshier, the garments became
simpler.
is even more explicit: By about the second quarter of the sixth century
the new Southern style represented by Zhang
In drawing the bones of people, Zhang falls Sengyou had probably diffused all the way north to
behind Gu and Lu. Zhang gets the flesh right Luoyang, the new capital of the Northern Wei,
(vol. 6). which was again turning avidly to southern China
for models in conduct and in art. According to the
In contrast to the styles of the great masters who "Biography of the monk Fazhen":
preceded Sengyou, the main point about Sengyou's
"marvelous sense of bones" is his shift in emphasis The monk Fazhen . . . was well wised in the
from spirit and bones to "getting the flesh right," Chengshilun, and had a profound grasp ot its
that is, the shift from slender to ample. Hence, the meaning. His lectures were brilliant and
terms used in temple inscriptions of the time to original, and he was peerless between tlu-Yi
describe the Buddha's image included "a relaxed and 1 110 rivers. His tame was as great as that o\
moon face"
1
'
and "a face like a full moon." These
1
so highly regarded before. Early signs of this change ascendant, predictions of doom were
from the slender style, and of the gradual increasingly common, suspicions were rampant.
emergence of the fuller-bodied figures that "tret the envy was excessive this is whal the world was
and they preach the correct ways. Let us go Fig. 13. Figures of patrons. Mid-6th c. Rock carvings.
there." . . .Jian said, "The moment is not to be Dalishan cave-temples, Gong county, Henan Province.
killed. . . . [Jian then] travelled to the kingdom volume 24 of the Beiqi shu ("History of the
in the south and reached Jiangyin, where he Northern Qi") records the following conversation
lived in the Heyuan Temple. 17 that Gao Huanping had with Du Bi after he
pacified the capital, Luoyang (532):
naturally became the fashion among artistic circles a level of clean government seldom seen, and
in central and northern China to emulate the new he mentioned it to Emperor Gaozu. Gaozu
styles of the south. Thus, after the eighth month of said, "Come here, Bi, let me tell you something.
519 a group of sculptures was made and placed It has long been the custom for the country to
within the pagoda of the Yongning Temple, built by be corrupt and chaotic. Nowadays many of the
the Northern Wei royal family at Luoyang. lS The generals' families live west of the pass where
surviving heads are about seven centimeters high, Heita [i.e.,YuwenTai] is constantly beckoning
and greatly resemble those of the Liang dynasty to them, and it is unclear if their loyalties will
I9
(fig. 1 2). The trend toward simpler draperies and be to stay or to go. In East China there is an
fleshier bodies is increasingly evident in the slightly old man named XiaoYan living in Wu who
later figures of patrons from caves 1, 4, and 3 of the specializes in the proper dress and rites. The
Dalishan caves in Gong county, Henan Province gentry of the central plains regard him as the
20
guardian of the correct ways. I am eager to
establish laws and rules, and would not mind
borrowing, for I fear that if the generals go over
to Heita and the gentry leave to follow Xiao
Yan, then our talents will have all dispersed, and
how then could I run the country?"
northern suburb of Xi'an in Shaanxi Province the Yang school, which was so popular during the
(cat. 159). These figures, most likely from a Northern Qi. Zhang Yanyuan calls the period from
multistoried stone pagoda, are also of the Northern the Qi and Liang through the Chen and Zhou the
Qi style. Because many white marble figures came Period of Recent Antiquity, and he discusses the
from Dingzhou, in Qi territory, there is speculation paintings of Recent Antiquity thus:
be the Wuning Mausoleum in which Gao Yang was Sengyou and Zihua. 25
buried, and its date is believed to be 560 (Northern
Qi). In this tomb, as in the tomb of Lou Rui, Just as Gu and Lu were contemporaries, practiced
Prince of Dong'an, discovered in 1979 atWangguo similar styles, were ranked as equals, and were
village in Taiyuan, Shanxi Province, and dated to considered comparable in excellence to the best
570, there are large murals depicting a cavalry painters of the preceding age, so Zhang and Yang
honor guard; in both murals the full-fleshed bodies were paired with each other and compared with
are particularly obvious (fig. 14).
2I
Both tomb their predecessors Gu and Lu. Volume 2 of the Lidai
murals are drawn with simple and forceful lines, minghuaji lists Yang Zihua among those painters in
and show a vitality in keeping with the high social central China during the Northern Qi period who
standing of those buried there. 22 Quite a number of had learned from Gu, Lu, and Zhang Sengyou:
commentators believe may have been
that they
done by the Northern Qi court painter Yang Tian Sengliang.Yang Zihua, Yang Qidan, Zheng
Zihua. 23 Yang Zihua was the most highly regarded Fashi, Dong Boren, Zhan Ziqian. Sun Shangzi,
of the Qi painters, and the early Tang artist Yan Yan Lide, andYan Liben learned from Gu, Lu,
Liben praised his works thus: and Sengyou. 26
As for painting people, the subtlest lines, the Of these, Tian Sengliang.Yang Zihua. Zheng Fashi,
utmost beauty in simplicity, having little enough Dong Boren. and Zhan Ziqian were famous during
so that not a single thing can be omitted, yet the Northern Qi and Zhou, 17 while Sun Shangzi
just enough that nothing should be added and Yang Qidan were active during the Sui, and the
only Zihua cm do this!
24
Yan brothers during the early rang. Sengyou, in the
probably safe to say that they were in the style of studied. Hence, the Lidai minghuaji also cites earlier
Pel [
Xiaoyuan] said: " Yan [Lide and Liben]
studied with Mr. Zhang and surpassed their
teacher. They mastered all the subtleties of
this was done by Sengyou, but that is untrue Wu Daoxuan probed all the subtleties of
Zhou and Sui paintings and reliefs from the He is a reincarnation of Zhang Sengyou (Lidai
Maijishan caves ofTianshui in Gansu Province, the minghua ji, introduction to vol. 9).
Gaozong and Wu Zetian; and extant Song copies of Painting and sculpture have long been closely
early Tang Portraits of Emperors through the Ages linked, and as Chinese sculptures were always
(fig. i5). 3 The great artist Wu Daozi of the High colored, those engaged in sculpting had to have a
Tang era drew people in relaxed poses that, solid foundation in painting. In his Wudai minghua
according to the Lidai minghua //', can also be traced buyi ("A Supplement to Famous Paintings of the
back to Sengyou: Five Dynasties"), Liu Daochun of the Northern
Song noted that among those -who studied
Wu Daoxuan [Daozi] studied under Zhang alongside Wu Daozi under Zhang Sengyou was
Sengyou (vol. 2). Yang Huizhi, who was famous for his sculptures:
was adept at sculpting. During the reign of the Fig. 16. Mural and carved figure qfSakyainuni. Sth c.
Empress, the local officials Dou Hongguo and (High Tang period). Mogao Cave 325, Dunhuang, Gansu
Mao Poluo, Supervisor of the Eastern Garden Province.
exceptionally skilled. This generation also thoughts for three years, whereupon he
[studied] painting. They were all excellent completed the sculpture. . . . Also, in middle age,
draftsmen, but their tone was not very high. Dai Andao drew figures of great draftsmanship
(vol. 5).
scenery in the ancient style were wonderful. that the face is thin, but that the shoulders are
While in his teens, he was painting in the too big." He then pared down the shoulders,
Waguan Temple. General Secretary Wang and the face's proportions then became right.
|Meng] saw him and said, "This child is not just Everyone was impressed by the sharpness of his
He had made a wooden statue of Amitabha Bochang in Le'an. He had .1 keen and nimble
Buddha 1.6 zhang tall, together with attendant mind, and was adept at calligraphy and painting.
bodhisattvas. Kui used the simple ancient style, He was skilled at painting people and at
curtain, listening secretly to everyone's The Indian monk l.inmozhuovi |ot the Sin
comments. He gave careful consideration to dynasty] was also skilled at painting. During the
both praise and criticism, and collected his reign of Emperor Wen of tin- Sui, he came from
King Asoka in China. When he came to the Chinese Caves"), p. 108, jig. 4, and the seeds of the future, yet
p. wg, Jig. 5. stands out among both past and 13. Vol. 6 of the Lidai minghua ji
Dashi Temple at Luo county in Chengdu, he
present; he cannot be praised cites Zhang Huaiguan thus: "As
saw the forms of twelve spirits in the sky, Fig. 12. See Xinzhongguo de merely by effusiveness, and for Lu, Gu, and Zhang
whereupon he studied the looks of each one kaogu faxian yu yanjiu exhausts all description. He is Sengyou, commentators stress
("Archaeological Discoveries and the best of the best, there is each of their strengths, and
and then carved their images at the base of
Studies of New China"), pi. 14$. nothing left to say ... so the these are all appropriate." This
the temple's pagoda. They still survive today most I can do is place him in can be taken to mean that the
(vol. 8)J
6 Fig. 13. See Zhongguo shikusi: the first rank. He is the styles in vogue during the three
Gongxian shikusi ("Chinese toremost person ot the first periods following the Eastern
Cave Sculptures: Tlie Cave rank." Jin Liu Song, Qi, and Liang
These are all well-known examples. Extant sites Temples of Gong County"), pi. 38. all differed, and hence different
such as the Mogao grottoes at Dunhuang indicate 7. Work team of the Henan emphases were placed on them.
Fig. 14. See Wenwu, ig83;io, Provincial Bureau ot Relics,
that even the earliest surviving caves show a
lower illustration on color page. Dengxian caisc huaxiang 14. Yiwen leiju, vol. 76, quoting
consistency of layout and a uniformity in design zhuangwu ("Color Paintings the stele of the Buddha
and style among both paintings and sculptures that Fig. 16. See Zhongguo shiku:
from a Brick Tomb in Deng Amitabha in thejmxiang
Dunhuang Mogao san County"), 1958. Temple of Yongzhou, carved by
could only have been achieved by a single creator
("Chinese Cave Sculptures: The Liu Xiaoyi of the Liang
(fig. i6).That accounts for the roughly synchronous Mogao Grottoes, Part 3"), pi. 114. 8. Relics Administration Office dynasty.
NOTES Jiajiachong huaxiang zhuanmu" 15. Yiwen leiju, vol. 77, quoting
prior to the late Tang. From the Northern Song,
("A Painted Brick Tomb
I. Wenhua dageming qijian chutu in the inscription for the Buddha
painters increasingly specialized in particular genres, wenwu ("Archaeological Relics Jiajiachong, Xiangfan"), Sakyamuni by Emperor Jianwen
jianghan Archaeology, 1986:1. of the Liang.
and neither court painters nor literati painters Unearthed During the Cultural
ji ("Record of Famous Painters Tongdian, "By an edict in the Painted Bricks," Wenwu, 1979:3.
longer properly reflect the tastes of the times.
of All the Dynasties") cited in
second year of Yongnnng
this paper is based on the during the reign ot Emperor 17. In vol. 6 of Xu gaoseng
Translated, from the Chinese, by June Mei. original Xunyang edition of Wu of the Qi, the Minister zhuan ("Further Lives of
Wangshi huayuan ("Wang's ordered the officials to establish Eminent Monks"), by the
Garden of Paintings"), which is
the Five Rituals. Then Emperor monk Daoxuan of the Tang
now in the Beijing University Wu of the Liang ordered the dynasty.
Cave Sculptures: Tlie Singling page, 1 1 -line edition published of the Zhou"), vol. 41, Yongning Temple and climbed
in Lin'an during the Southern "Biography of Geng Xin." Also up the nine-story pagoda.
Temple"), pi 21.
Song, and is the earliest extant "Biography of Baochang" in Guang submitted a memorial,
copy of the Lidai minghua vol. 1 of Xu Gaoseng zhuan saying ...'Although the image
Fig. 2. See Zhongguo shiku:
ji.
see vol. 57, the "Arts and 11. Vol. 90, Xin Tangshu ("New the eighth month of the second
Fig. 3. See Yungang shiku ("Tlie
Letters, Part 1," of the Xin History of the Tang"): year of Shengui.
Yungang Caves"), pi. 92.
Tangshu ("New Tang History"). "Biography of Li Sizhen."
skins for blankets and urged to and at the time had a higher 31. See n. 3. and taught craftsmen to carve
stay with fine cups. . . . Leave reputation than Dong and the images of the Three Holies,
the dangerous for the safe, and Zhan"; "During the Zhou, 32. Wu Daozi and Yang Huizhi the Jade Emperor, and Zhenwu
return now to the correct Zheng Fashi was a Dadou were regarded equally highly at which are in the Zaocheng
ways; change disaster into good Duzuo Yuamvai Shilang, a the time. Vol. 212 of the Taiping Monastery at Huiqi. These all
fortune, we have escaped the Jianzhong General, and was guangji cites Tang Kangpings display the greatest dignity and
net.* "This mention of the given the fief of Changshe Jutanlu thus: "There is a gentleness in their visages, and
correct ways refers to the Liang county, and entering the Sui Xuanyuan Monastery on Mt. their expression is one of
dynasty kingdom in southern period he was made a Zhongsan Beimang of the Eastern capital. natural ease as if they were
China. Datfu; his Images of the Northern To the south of the monastery human, such that all who saw
Qi . . . is still extant"; "Dong stands a temple to Laozi. Its them were awestruck. People
21. See Xu Guangji, Boren was from Ru'nan, and a buildings are tall and imposing, of that prefecture call them
"Excavation and Studies of man of many talents .... and overlook Yiluo. All of its treasures of wood. . . . Zhai felt
Large Tomb Murals of the [During the Sui] he reached clay sculptures of the deities that the old work was not well
Northern Dynasties at the positions of Guanglu Datfu were done by Yang Huizhi done, and personally resculpted
Wanzhang in Ci County, and Dianzhong General. . . .
during the Kaiyuan period. it. He captured the Rulai
Shanxi Provincial Institute of were summoned together to done and meticulous, and compassion for the world and
Archaeology et al., "Brief the Sui Court, one from everyone who sees them is sympathy for the weak, and
Report on the Excavation of Hebei, the other from southern filled with admiration. The even if Dai Andao and Yang
the Tomb of Lou Rui of the China. Initially they were not walls have paintings by Wu Huizhi were to be reborn, they
Northern Qi in Taiyuan," taken seriously, but later they Daozi of the Five Sages and of would have a hard rime
Wenwu, 1983:10. were rather well regarded. stories from Laozi. The surpassing him." For more on
Dongs Emperor Ming of the paintings are exquisite, and Zhai Ruwen s life, see his
22. See Beiqishu, vol. 4, "Annals Zhou Hunting is still extant"; have no peer either past or biography in vol. 131 of the
of Wenxuan"; vol. 48, "Zhan Ziqian lived through present." History of the Song (Song shu).
minghua preface to
Catalogue of Paintings"). See [Liu] Song dynasty."
24. Lidai ji,
land as the Divine Painter, and "Pei Xiaoyuan wrote Huapin hi and Wang Zhishen's Songji
was forbidden to paint for ["Ranked Catalogue of ['Record of the (Liu) Song']."
outsiders, except by imperial Paintings"] in one volume. He
edict. At the time there was a was a Zhongshu Sheren, and 35. At the end of his comments
prince named Chong Shan recorded events of the on Jiang Shaoyou, Zhang
whose chess-playing was Zhenguan and Xianqing Yanyuan appends the following
godlike, and the two of them periods."Vol. 1 of Tulnnt note: "See the Houweishu
were known as the Two jianwen zhi ("Notes on ['History of the Later Wei']."
Yang Zihua: "Tian Zengliang 30. See Jin Weinuo,"Thc Dates Various Sages oj the Ten
and Artists of Ancient Portraits Mmatcs, Ih, Nine Heavetu
reached the official position of { as
Divinities: Buddhist
Sculpture in China
Helmut Brinker
Professor, University of Zurich
religious system based on a variety of doctrines, or the stupa, a tumulus-like monument erected over
practices, and premises that the ancients would his holy bodily remains. During the time of the
never have understood. The new faith assumed that Kushan empire, established in the latter half of the
life was transitory and illusory, essentially painful, first century ce, the worship of images at last
and thus inevitably unsatisfactory. It offered, triumphed, and soon thereafter iconographic
however, the consoling prospect of finding release schemes and forms of great intricacy and
from fatal destiny and breaking through the endless complexity rapidly evolved. Buddhism's historic
chain of causality in the illusory world of founder, known as Sakyamuni, or Gautama
phenomena, in Sanskrit called samsara. Siddhartha, is naturally the most widely worshiped
figure of the Buddhist pantheon. He is said to have
Following the Noble Eightfold Path that is, the lived between 565 and 486 bce the dates are not
Buddha's rules for right living one could escape precisely fixed in what is now southern Nepal.
the perpetual cycle of rebirth by the virtues of Sakyamuni achieved enlightenment in his lifetime
sincere belief, compassion, meditative discipline, by discovering the middle path between severe
exemplary moral conduct, accumulation of ascetic self-mortification and self-indulgence. After
religious merit, development of wisdom, and spreading his new insights, performing miracles, and
renunciation of worldly wealth and status in order gathering disciples, he entered into nirvana at the
to seek the truth. The doctrine of karma (literally, age of eighty and receded far beyond the
"work" or "action") was thought of as a system of imagination and reach of mortal believers. His truly
moral causalities. Good or bad actions of an unfathomable reality could only be experienced
individual would be rewarded or punished either in and visualized through supreme insight, assisted by
this life or in the next. To attain supreme sacred images and rituals, by magic words, gestures,
enlightenment was the ultimate goal for the and symbols, by the mysteries of faith and worship.
practitioners of the faith. A person who had
reached this awakened stage became a Buddha and BUDDHIST CULTURE IN CHINA
qualified for entering into nirvana. For the first FORMATIVE STAGES, EXPANSION,
time the Chinese had to come to grips with totally CURTAILMENT
alien beliefs and highly sophisticated religious In Buddhism's formative stages in China, Buddhist
concepts. The success of Buddhism in China was imagery appears only sporadically, and mingled into
due mainly to its tolerance for other philosophical indigenous Han contexts. Traditional Buddhist
paths and religious practices, its readiness to adopt motifs of Indian origin were fused with Daoist
and adapt to Daoism and Confucianism. beliefs, figures, and customs, and rendered in
mysticism, and magic, Buddhism was originally an missionaries from the West knew little if any
aniconic religion. Since the Buddha stood Chinese and that their local collaborators probabr)
ultimately for an abstract, metaphysical concept, had no comprehensive knowledge of Central \sian
initially he was not depicted as a human figure. or Indian languages. Pertinent Daoist terms and
Rather, his salvific presence and power were metaphors as well as loanwords from the Cotlfui ian
evoked by such representative symbols as Ins classics were appropriated in the attempt to rendei
notions of transmigration and reincarnation. wasteful] Efang [palaces of the Qin dynasty
(221207 bce)]. Indeed, [Buddhist activity was
According to tradition, extensive translation so intense] that it was not merely a matter of
activities began with the arrival of two Indian clothing wooden [figures] in silk or painting
2
monks, Dharmaratna and Kasyapa Matahga. They earthen [idols] in rich colors.
Han dynasty (r. 57-75 ce) in order to track down temples in Luoyang by the beginning of the fourth
the import of a miraculous dream apparition. We century ce and that this number increased rapidly;
are told that the two missionaries brought with by the end of the Wei dynasty in the second half of
them a copy of "The Scripture in Forty-Two the sixth century we have an estimate of no less
Sections," which they translated into Chinese as than 1,367 Buddhist temples in and around the
Sishi'er zhangjing traditionally the first Chinese capital city. Medieval Chang'an was also early
rendition of an Indian Buddhist text. The true famed for its magnificent temples. Notwithstanding
origin and date of this work, however, have been two serious persecutions during 446452 under
subjects of scholarly controversy. By medieval times, Emperor Taiwu of the Northern Wei and again
Dharmaratna and Kasyapa Matahga were regularly during 574-578 under Emperor Wu of the
credited with the translation of this "short Northern Zhou the Buddhist church continued
collection of aphorisms and pithy moralistic to flourish during the Period of Disunity
parables."
1
The emperor is said to have established (220-589), the Sui (589-618), and most of the Tang
the Temple of the White Horse (Baimasi), the first (618-907) dynasty.
official Buddhist institution on Chinese soil, as their
new residence in Luoyang. The third and most severe suppression, gathering
head from about about 841 and culminating in
Another pioneer missionary and translator was the 844845, under the reign of the Tang emperor
Parthian prince known to the Chinese as An Wuzong, marked the beginning of a gradual
Shigao, who came to Luoyang in 148 ce. The decline in influence, power, and wealth of the
impact of the Central Asian missionary translator Buddhist church as an established institution. A
KumarajTva (344409/413?) was even greater. A series of increasingly harsh imperial edicts was
Kuchean aristocrat turned monk, he had been directed toward confiscation of monastic property
invited to China by the ruler of one of the Sixteen and secularization of the clergy. The violent return
Kingdoms, but en route was captured by a rogue to secular life of more than a quarter of a million
general and held for nearly two decades in the area nuns and priests was witnessed and recorded by the
of present-day Gansu Province. There the Kuchean Japanese pilgrim Ennin (793864), who kept a
monk learned Chinese. A new ruler, equally pro- detailed diary of his sojourn in China. The vast
Buddhist, finally destroyed the rogue general, at properties and monetary wealth of the Buddhist
least partly in order to secure KumarajTva's release. church were confiscated by the government, and
KumarajTva arrived in Chang'an in 402 and became some of the splendid temple compounds in
the spiritus rector of one of the greatest Buddhist Chang'an were converted into imperial parks.
translation projects of sacred scriptures. Buddhist bronze bells and metal icons were ordered
to be surrendered to the state authorities and were
At first, Buddhist congregations existed primarily in eventually melted down. In the entire empire no
the foreign merchant quarters of larger cities; only images of bronze, iron, gold, or silver were
gradually did the new religion gain a substantial permitted for public or private worship. Only
following among native Chinese. From roughly the sculptures made of stone, wood, clay, or other
fourth century, however, religious life in China was nonmetallic materials are said to have been exempt
largely dominated by Buddhism. In his preface to from the tragic suppression and devastation. The
the Luoyang qielau ji ("Record of Buddhist Temples actual extent of the loss of religious art and
in Luoyang"), completed in 547, the military leader architecture and of Buddhist literature, icons, and
and chronicler Yang Xuanzhi noted: sacred paraphernalia toward the end of the Tang
dynasty can hardly be imagined. Arriving in
The people and wealthy families parted with Dengzhou after his own expulsion from Chang'an,
their treasures as easily as with forgotten the Japanese pilgrim Ennin noted in his diary:
side by side, and stupas [pagodas] rose up in row Although it [Dengzhou] is a remote place, it has
after row. People competed among themselves been no different from the capital in the
in making or copying the Buddha's portraits. regulation of monks and nuns, the destruction
Golden stupas matched the imperial of the monasteries, the banning of the
confiscation of the property of the monasteries. the two Sacred Ones were installed under
Moreover they have peeled off the gold from sumptuous floral canopies in a special palace
the Buddhas and smashed the bronze and iron building. Rituals and sacrifices were performed with
Buddhas and measured their weight. What a pity! pomp and ostentation, using precious vessels of gold
What limit was there to the bronze, iron, and and silver, consecrated beads, and embroidered
6
gold Buddhas of the land? And yet, in textiles.
Tradition holds that the first Buddha image was propagandist for Buddhism, reportedly built a
introduced into China sometime between 64 and structure of considerable size to house a gilded
75 CE, as the result of a dream of Han Mingdi.The bronze statue and to accommodate a large
emperor saw a divine man whose body was congregation: "He erected a Buddha shrine, making
a human figure of bronze whose body he coated
golden in color, wearing a solar halo about the with gold and clad in brocades. He hung up nine
crown of his head. He inquired of his courtiers, tiers of bronze plates [on the spire] over a multi-
one of whom said: "In the West there is a deity storied pavilion; his covered galleries could contain
known as the Buddha, whose form is like what three thousand men or more." 7
Your Majesty dreamed of; may it not have been
he?" Thereupon envoys were dispatched to Buddhist icons must have been in ritual use in
India, who had copies made of a Sutra China well before this date; they probably arrived in
[scripture] and [obtained] an image, which they the luggage of foreign merchants and missionaries
displayed in China. There from the Son of who had come along the ancient overland trade
Heaven on down through the princes and routes of Central Asia or by sea around Southeast
nobles, all paid them honor; for when they Asia. Most of these images were probably made of
heard that a man's soul is not extinguished by gilded bronze. Their shining surface was intended to
death, there was none who was not fearful of reproduce the sunlike radiance of the Buddha's
being lost. 4 body. It is only toward the end of the Eastern Han
dynasty, about the year 200, that the Chinese
This famous dream-and-envoy story was themselves may have started to experiment with
considerably embellished over time. It occurred casting such icons. We are informed by the noted
initially in an early preface of the Sishi'er zhang jing Vinaya master, translator, and biographer Daoxuan
("The Scripture in Forty-Two Sections"), which (596667) that a certain monk Huihu made a gilded
may be dated to the Eastern Han (25220 ce) or Sakyamuni image at the Shading Temple in Wujun
shortly thereafter. Such edifying anecdotes later in the year 377. According to Daoxuan, the sixteen-
acquired an aura of fact, and were often cited as foot-high statue was cast in a cave dug on the steep
literal truth by Chinese buddhologists.-s By the fifth south side of the temple."
century the icon mentioned among the Buddhist
paraphernalia in the luggage of Mingdi's returning In general, bronze casters and sculptors enjoyed little
delegation had been identified in Chinese records social eminence. Like their craftsmen ancestors, they
either as the original or as a faithful, equally sacred remained anonymous. Very few won recognition
replica of the celebrated Sakyamuni portrait comparable to that of contemporary painters. One
commissioned by the youthful king Udayana, of the earliest sculptors perhaps the first whose
Buddha's ardent admirer and pious patron. Although name entered historical records was Dai Kui (d.
this account of the legendary Udayana icon is 395). He is said to have made monumental
apocryphal, it tells us something about the configurations for various temples and to have
significance of imagery in the transmission of achieved an unprecedented technical versatility and
Buddhism and the early Chinese concern and inventiveness, beauty and expressiveness 111 casting
respect for the foreign religion and its art. bronze icons, carving wood sculptures, and making
portable lacquer statues. In Daoxuan's view, Dai
A century after the purported introduction of the Kui's genius contributed decisively to the
hist Buddhist scripture and image, a lavish religious progressive disuse of exotic foreign styles in t.ivor of
ceremony in honor of Sakyamuni and ofLaozi, the Sinicized Buddhist imagery;
founding figure of Daoism, is mentioned by the
astrologer and scholar Xiang Kai in his well-known hi [Dai] Kui's opinion die images made m
memorial presented to the Han emperor Hiun in Middle Antiquity had almost all been rude and
r.66. His text refers to the beliefth.it Buddha was in oversimple, and in their function of inspiring
Since he was both pure in faith and highly appropriateness of the represented deity. Yingxiang
inventive, he was spurred to alter the carving of ("shadow image") characterizes the icon as an
the August Visage, so as to attain the utmost in ultimately illusory reflection without inherent
truthfulness. He pondered the problem for years reality, and is regularly used to designate the
on end and finally succeeded in producing a visualized image of a deity and its pictorial
statue in which the excellence of Chinese representation. In his instructions on the methods
figure sculpture exceeded anything previously of performing such visualization, the extremely
known. 9 learned Tang monk Zhiyan (602-668), who is
Xuanzhi tells us that the unexpected discovery of follows: Is this Buddha made out of clay or
thirty sacred images "was interpreted as an wood, or is it made out of gold or bronze?
auspicious reward for the dowager empress's After such a visualization he truly recognizes
conversion to Buddhism. As a result, she spent all the Buddha whom he sees. If you, only relying
the more lavishly on its construction." He describes on your own self, visualize the form image
the splendor of the temple in great and admiring [xingxiang] of the Buddha in a pure abode, and
detail: remember it day and night, then this Buddha
will appear constantly before your eyes."
North of the stupa [pagoda] was a Buddhist
hall, which was shaped like the Palace of the Icons were a means to the fundamental goal of
Great Ultimate (Tianjidian). In the hall was a every devoted Buddhist, a goal the Chinese called
golden statue of the Buddha eighteen feet high, jianfo ("seeing the Buddha"). Material substance
along with ten medium-sized images three of and form remain a totally worthless "shadow"
sewn pearls, tive of woven golden threads, and that is, a mere visual perception as long as an icon
two of jade. The superb artistry was matchless, has not received its proper spiritual enlivenment
unparalleled in its day. . . . Here were kept all through consecration in an adequate ritual. Only
the Sutras and Buddhist images presented by then does a sculpture change from a piece of stone,
foreign countries."3 wood, bronze, clay, or lacquer to a sacred image: it
ASPECTS OF BUDDHIST FAITH AND shadow image (yingxiang) into the Original
icons azefoxiang and foxingxiang, both meaning enlightenment and salvation. The final step in
"Buddha images." Since ancient dines the main creating an icon depicting the pupils of the
object ot veneration or prime statue worshiped in a eyes was an act of ritual as well as representation.
particular ritual or enshrined in a building of a The practice seems to have been known in ancient
Buddhist temple has been called benzun ("Original Indian Buddhism as well as in Brahmamsm, and it
Honored One"); as a rule, the chapel or hall is was common cultic practice (along with the
dedicated to and named after that particular deity. "mouth-opening" ritual) in Mesopotamia perhaps
The word benzun can be traced back at least as far as early as the third millennium bce. Called the
as the Northern Wei dynasty (386-534). Stronger "eye-opening" ritual (kaiyan), it is the most
emphasis on the intimate relationship between the important process in consecrating a new icon:
devotee and the deity addressed in an icon is endowing the image with gaze endows it with a
connoted by the word zizun ("Personal Honored sense of life. The Tang emperor Taizong (r. 627649)
One"), defined in early exegetic medieval texts as himself attended such an inaugural "eye-opening"
"the venerated deity to which one's Self is ceremony for the main Buddha image in the
clinging." We may assume that icons of this Xingtu Temple (formerly Hongfu Temple) in
category were preferably set up on the private altar Chang'an, which in 634 he had renamed and
of a practitioner. Another key term frequently rededicated to the spiritual felicity of his mother.
encountered in Buddhist scriptures is xingxiang Unfortunately, the sources give no further details of
("form image"), emphasizing the perceptible this dedication service, but the monarch probably
Buddha and endowing his image with beneficial repair or finishing work essentially would not
and protective power. 12 impair its efficacy.
Since early times Buddhist theologians have In the orthodox Buddhist sense, the sarTra (C: sheli)
speculated and commented on the relation of the refers to the pure crystallized grains found after the
outer form and the inner principle, the actual and historical Buddha's cremation; to his ashes and
spiritual presence of deities or saints in images other bodily remains, such as teeth, hair, finger
made by human hands. They were deeply bones and fingernails; or to the ashes, bones, and
concerned with the degree of reality and potency similar physical fragments of saints. According to
dwelling in a pictorial representation. The efficacy ancient tradition, Sakyamuni's body was incinerated
of Buddhist icons, and therefore of the rituals after he had attained his final nirvana. His ashes and
addressed to them, was thought to depend to a physical remains were divided with diplomatic skill
great extent on their magic essence. To reinforce and interred in eight separate tumulus-like burial
the potency ascribed to the images, all sorts of mounds, or stupas. In the third century bce, India's
objects precious relics, ritual implements, holy first Buddhist ruler, Asoka of the Mauryas,
scriptures and pictures, printed or written magic recovered and brought these relics together again,
spells, miniature figures of deities, even textile later dispersing them throughout his far-flung
models of human organs were sometimes kingdom in 84,000 stupas that are said to have been
deposited in special cavities or in the hollow erected in a single day.
interior of a sculpture before it received its
finishing touches and initial consecration. Literary The miraculous division and widespread veneration
evidence and extant statues bear witness to the of the Buddha's remains established a powerful
early existence of this magic-religious practice in precedent. The process of dividing the sarTra again
China, which was not limited to any particular and again not only those of Sakyamuni himself,
Buddhist school or category of religious imagery. but also those of his disciples and of later saints and
patriarchs of the various Buddhist schools created
SACRED ICONS AND THE BUDDHIST CULT an almost inexhaustible supply of minute holy
OF RELICS objects for the entire Buddhist world. The
One of the earliest references to a sacred deposit in enormous number of 84,000 refers to the number
a Buddhist figure appears in the biography of the of atoms in the Buddha's corpus as well as to the
distinguished evangelist and translator Dao'an corpus of his sacred words. Thus, by erecting these
(312-385), who once received a foreign gilded- stupas, the pious king As'oka intended to recreate
bronze statue that was seven feet high: Sakyamuni's physical body symbolically and to
reconstruct his myriad teachings. The sarTra of the
Whenever there was a lecture or assembly, the historical Buddha and his doctrines were
holy images would be set out. Banners and considered equivalent manifestations of the same
canopies would be hung up; festoons of beads reality and sacred presence. The possession of
would swing; everywhere would be incense "authentic" relics ensured the possessor an elevated
smoke and flowers; so that those who mounted place in the ecclesiastical hierarchy as well as in
the steps and crossed the threshold were society. At the same time, it was a powerful
awestruck and paid the utmost in devotion. The instrument of monastic and imperial legitimacy
foreign bronze image was so archaic in form and, by stimulating donations from the faithful,
and workmanship that most people had no guaranteed economic independence.
great respect for it. [Dao-] An said: "The shape
and the body-marks are excellent; the only fault In recent years discoveries of Buddhist reliquary
is that the form of the usnfsa [the protuberance deposits have been reported from almost every part
on top of the head] is incongruous." So he of China, from Liaoning in the northeast to Yunnan
ordered a disciple to fire and re-mould the in the southwest. Sacred Buddhist relic assemblages
usnTsa. At once a light flamed up with such were mostly found within or on the site of
brilliance that it filled the whole hall. On close pagodas, which served as monumental architectural
inspection it was discovered that inside the reliquaries and usually stood at a distinguished place
usnTsa there was a relic. The brothers were filled on the temple grounds. Relics might be enshrined
with consternation; but [Dao-| An said: "The not only in a sealed crypt but in other parts of the
statue is already a wonder-working one, and structure as well for example, at the base of the
will not be disturbed by recasting."'' 1
mast atop the pagoda. The finds date from the tune
of the miti.il impact of Buddhism and its arts on
The unexpected discovery of a sacred relic in the Chinese culture and increase concomitantly with
Buddha's head secured this rare foreign statue a the faith's subsequent powerful spread from the
special rank as miraculous icon, and therefore even fourth century through the Ming dynastt
concealed in precious reliquaries in the Tang aspects of faith and worship and thus favored
dynasty underground palace (digong) of the Famen particular figures from the vast pantheon. Sacred
Temple's sixteenth-century octagonal brick pagoda. texts offered clear-cut descriptions of the special
The collapse of the pagoda in 1981 made possible qualities and appearance of the Buddha and all the
the investigation of its crypt. Thus well-known other figures of the Buddhist pantheon, providing a
literary evidence for the cult of relics, such as Han basic assurance of iconographic correctness and
Yu s (768824) forthright memorial to the Throne conformity.' 5
bones, was substantiated more than a millennium In artistic representations the Buddha's ideal figure
later by archaeological evidence. appears very austere in stature, pose, and dress.
Usually, his modest monk's robe and the near
HanYu had serious grounds for protest. absence of specific attributes and individualizing
Sakyamuni's physical remains had several times been features convincingly indicate his holy status of
carried in lavish procession between Famen Temple utmost unworldliness (cats. 147-49, 156, 162). Such
and the Tang capital, a distance of more than 100 utter simplicity gives his human figure a lofty
kilometers. Like many conservative literati of the majesty. Several unusual, seemingly aesthetic or
day, HanYu was appalled by the religious frenzy miraculous features were assigned to the Buddha.
pervading all strata of society, and he proposed They are manifestations of the Sacred, and basically
drastic measures to suppress the enormous statements of ontological quality, like the mudras,
influence of the Buddhist church. When, in 819, the the gestures (literally, "seal marks"; C: yin[xiangj)
Famen Temple finger-bone relics were received by formed with the hands to convey such actions as
an enthusiastic crowd in Chang'an and temporarily preaching, meditating, wish granting, protecting, or
placed on view at the imperial palace, he wrote the releasing from fear. The Buddha's thirty-two major
Lunfogu biao ("Memorial Discussing the Buddha's distinguishing physical marks are called lakshana
Bones") and presented it to the Throne. HanYu (C: xiang). One of the most important is the
criticized His Majesty in harsh words: "You are . . . protuberance on top of his head symbolizing the
putting on for the citizens of the capital this absolute perfect wisdom of the Enlightened One. It
extraordinary spectacle which is nothing more than is usuaUy referred to by the Sanskrit term ushntsha
a sort of theatrical amusement. . . . Now that the (C: rouji or dingxiang); ancient Buddhist scriptures
Buddha has long been dead, is it fitting that his sometimes explain it as a "mark of the crown that
decayed and rotten bones, his ill-omened and filthy is invisible" to ordinary people and list it as the
remains, should be allowed to enter in the sixty-sixth among the eighty minor distinctive
forbidden precincts of the palace? . . . Without marks of the Buddha. Another sign of supreme
reason you have taken up unclean things and enlightenment is the lima on his forehead;
examined them in person."' 4 originally a white curl (C: baihao) between the
Buddha's eyebrows, it was later simplified to a light-
DEITIES OF THE BUDDHIST PANTHEON emanating spot that illuminated the world. Most of
AND THEIR ICONOGRAPHY the exceptional marks and supernatural qualities
Three major doctrinal divisions, emerging were either derived from legends associated with
successively, coexisted within the Buddhist faith. the Buddha's life and virtues or devised as symbols
First in time is HTnayana, the "Small Vehicle," a of ultimate truth beyond human imagination, of
conservative form of Buddhism based almost unworldly beauty, holy distinction, and the sublime
exclusively on the Pah canon and asserting that power of omnipresence.
enlightenment comes only through one's own
efforts. The second is Mahayana, the "Great In accordance with their salvific mandate,
Vehicle," the doctrinal outlines of which seem to bodhisattvas appear less austere and inward than
have been formulated in India as early as the first figures of the Buddha in sculpture and painting.
century bce, advocating salvation for everyone Bodhisattvas are compassionate figures "whose
through the assistance of a vast pantheon of essence is enlightenment." Renouncing their own
compassionate divinities. The third is Esoteric salvation and immediate entrance into nirvana, they
Buddhism, also called tantric orVajrayana devote all their power and energy to saving
("Diamond Vehicle") Buddhism, known in China suffering beings in this world. As intercessionary
as mijiao, "Secret Teachings." This form of figures, majestic in power and sublime in
or lion, for example), indicating the irresistible his light the darkness of ignorance. Each Tathagata
nature of the Buddhist Law. Others appear with had a particular bodhisattva and vidyaraja as his pair
multiple heads or arms to signify their limitless of agents, representing his benign (sauta) and
compassion and their suprahuman potential as wrathful (krodha) aspects. Practitioners of the mijiao,
beneficent intercessors (cat. 164). Perhaps the single or "Secret Teachings," believed that each person's
most popular focus of Buddhist art and devotion is body, mind, and speech were inherently divine and
Avalokitesvara (C: Guan[shi]yin or Guanyin; "One that his or her deeds, thoughts, and words were
Who Perceives [with compassion] the Sounds [of actually those of Mahavairocana. Through such
the suffering world]"). Religious imagination has ritual practices as incantations, recitation of magic
endowed this widely adored bodhisattva with the spells, mystical hand gestures, and trances the deities
greatest variety of attributes and manifestations. No could be constrained to fulfill material goals cure
less than thirty-three forms became canonized in illness, defeat one's enemies, protect the state and
the Lotus Sutm.They are indications oi his government and spiritual goals hasten one's
compassionate omnipotence to save sentient beings enlightenment or progress to a higher state of
in different states of existence. As a benign consciousness. Correct performance of such rituals
emanation and agent of Amitabha, the Buddha of was beheved to offer access to the power of the
the Western Paradise (cat. 160), he has a small image expansive Buddhist pantheon. That pantheon was
of this Buddha in his crown. This image alone systematically defined and organized into a highly
suffices to identify him as Guanyin (cat. 176). intricate and complex schema, more elaborate than
any previously known in the Buddhist world.
Like the bodhisattvas, the vidyarajas ("Bright Kings Picturing that pantheon presented a new challenge
[of Esoteric Wisdom]"; C: mingwang) are easily to the imagination and skill of Chinese artists of
recognized. The vidyarajas, however, are wrathful the Tang dynasty.
threatening weapons in their hands, and flame- 167, 169). Among them are the belligerent
edged halos (cat. 170). But their anger is beneficent. dvarapalas, who evolved out of Indian demonic
They embody the militant energy and retaliatory creatures (yakshas) and Chinese warrior heroes and
power of the Tathagatas when confronted with such who protected the entrance of a sanctuary. In
evils as heresy, ignorance, illusion, passion, and other China they became known as envang ("Two
spiritual obstacles. Tathagatas are a class of fully Kings"), a pair of guardian deities. Four lokapalas, or
enlightened Buddhas.The Chinese epithet, rulai, "Divine Kings" (C: tianwang) were responsible for
means something like "he who has thus come," that protecting the Buddha and his Law, the sanctuary,
is, like other Buddhas before him. Although the and the Buddhist congregation from dangers and
Five Bright Kings, their names, and their function threats of evil forces arising from the four cardinal
are of Indian origin, they were probably conceived directions of the compass. Their images became
as a distinct group of five in Chinese Esoteric standard furnishing on a Buddhist altar platform
Buddhism during the seventh to eighth centuries. and at the four corners of a stupa or a mandala.
The Five Bright Kings, or protectors of faith,
correspond to the Five Tathagatas, just as the five Symbolically, figures on the human level of
cosmic elements, the five cardinal points, the five existence, such as arhats (C: luohan; supran.itur.il
transcendental wisdoms, the five senses, the five persons who, having attained enlightenment, will
colors, the five vitality centers, and the five viscera enter into nirvana after death) and the Buddha's
human body do. These Tathagatas of the Five
of the major disciples, were more important as .1 group
Wisdoms (wuzhi rulai) were thought of as spiritual than as individuals. Arhats received .1 much simpler
principles constituting the body of the universe; iconographical treatment than bodhisattvas.
and the relationship among them was clarified by vidyarajas, and other suprahuman beings: on the
the use of schematic diagrams, known as mandalas. other hand, they were represented with greater
Such formal geometric diagrams, depicting artistic and doctrinal freedom. The legendary.
Buddhist deities in a highly abstract theological wonder-working arhats were often depicted .is .1
schema, originated in India. In China mandalas of group groups of eight, sixteen, or five hundred
painted or sculptural images were employed in being the most tr.ulition.il. Arhats are frequently
(cat. 177). Originally worshiped as saints of the detail on the marvelous rewards that may be
Hmayana pantheon, in China by the fifth century expected in a future life by those who make and
the sixteen arhats would become guardians of commission sacred icons. This short text is among
Mahayana Buddhism. Their names and abodes the most popular and earliest Buddhist scriptures to
appear in a scripture translated into Chinese in 654 be translated into Chinese, perhaps in the first half
by the famous pilgrim-monk Xuanzang (600-664). of the third century. Virtually nothing is known of
According to this text, the Buddha advised the its provenance or translators. The scripture does not
arhats to remain in this world to await the advent give any ritual, artistic, or technical instructions on
of the redeeming Buddha, Maitreya. the actual making of Buddhist icons. But it provides
the background for the production of the first
imagery was limited on the whole by iconographic "When people perform virtuous acts they gain
and iconometric constraints. Needless to say, statues good fortune, but where does this lead them? I
were appreciated not primarily as art objects but as dread no longer being able to look upon the
sacred icons. Nevertheless, such variables as the Buddha after the Buddha is gone. I want to
nature and intensity of piety in various parts of the produce an image of the Buddha to venerate
vast country; locally available materials; patrons' and bequeath to later generations. What sorts of
preferences; the function, purpose, placement, and good fortune will I obtain thereby? I ask the
installation of a given icon; as well as adaptations of Buddha to take compassion upon me and
Indian and Central Asian aesthetics and stylistic explain this matter, as I earnestly desire to
owing to the Chinese urge for accurate make offerings to the relics of the Buddha of
documentation. Dates, names, and facts were variegated silk, fine flowers, exquisite incense,
inscribed on Buddhist sculptures with such lamps, and all the precious jewels and rare
thoroughness that, with the aid of more or less objects of the world. Afterward for innumerable
accidentally surviving material, we can reconstruct aeons he will practice the path to nirvana.
almost uninterrupted chronological sequences of Those who aspire to present precious jewels to
dated works. This, at any rate, is generally the case the Buddha are not common men; they have all
in northern China, where the new religion and its practiced the Buddhist path in previous lives.
arts were strongly supported by the Tuoba, the Such is the fortune obtained by one who
foreign rulers of the Wei dynasties (386-557). In produces an image of the Buddha.' 7
southern Chinamany of the ancient Buddhist
monuments have not survived. Besides the date of On the pedestal of a gilded bronze altar of the Sui
completion or consecration of an icon and the dynasty (581618), representing the Buddha
names of its donors and beneficiaries, inscriptions Amitabha and his retinue, we find a long engraved
often indicate the dual motivation for inscription (cat. 160). This masterwork of bronze
commissioning a Buddhist statue. The devotee casting, made up of twenty-three components, once
intended to provide a main object of worship and served a pious person and his family members for
at the same time to incur the manifold blessings their private worship. It was discovered in 1974 near
promised by the sacred texts to those who, solely or the village of Bali on the outskirts of Xi'an, in
jointly, sponsored the making of an icon. In Shaanxi Province. The beginning of the inscription
compliance with the doctrine of karma, the pious is almost formulaic: "On the fifteenth day of the
donor could even transfer or extend merits and seventh month in the fourth year of the Kaihuang
virtues to others to the imperial house, to [era, i.e., 584] the general of Ningyuan and deputy
ancestors, to living members of the family, to "all district magistrate ofWujiang [in present-day Hebei
sentient beings." Province, by the name of] Dong Qin had this
below all may perceive the correct Law [of the Western Buddhist monuments with their own eyes.
Buddha] ."There follows a panegyric in four verses Only now and then could they draw inspiration
on the prospects of salvation, the true marks ot the from major Western prototypes that had been
Buddha's body becoming manifest, cause and effect, imported or officially presented to the court or to a
illusion and rebirth, and finally on salvation in renowned temple in China. Instead, sculptors had to
Amitabha's paradise. A red sandstone stele more rely largely on oral descriptions by missionaries and
than sixty years older than the Sui altar was returning pilgrims, perhaps on their sketches and
unearthed in 1954 at the ancient site of theWanfo drawings made en route, on manuals handed down,
Temple ("Thousand Buddha Temple"), at Chengdu and on images made for private worship small and
in Sichuan Province (cat. 150). Tradition holds that therefore easily portable.
middle of the second century; under the Liang Canonical scriptures some of Indian origin, some
dynasty (502557) it was known as Anpu Temple apocryphal contain accounts of
detailed the
("Temple of the Peaceful Riverbank"), and under imagining, in the true meaning of the word, of
the Tang (618-907) as Jingzhong Temple ("Temple Buddhist deities. These compilations of ritual
of the Cleansed Multitude"). The first Buddhist prescriptions read like iconographic handbooks.
sculptures were discovered at this site in 1882. They provide accurate descriptions of the figures
Subsequent investigations in 1937, 1945, and with all their features and attributes. Although no
1953-54 brought to light a total of about two early Chinese manuals on designing and making
hundred figures and fragments (cats. 151, 163, 168, Buddhist images have survived, there must have
176). The elaborate configuration of this stele been guides plus strong oral traditions with
depicts the standing Buddha Sakyamuni surrounded rules, instructions, perhaps even illustrations. The
by pairs of bodhisattvas, deities, and disciples. A famous Pmtiinamana laksliana was translated from a
scenic composition in shallow relief on the rear of Tibetan version as late as 1742 by the Manchu
the stele shows Sakyamuni worshiped by prince Gongbu Chabu and published under the
ceremonially aligned men and women in a title Zaoxiang liangdu jing ("Classic of Measurements
landscape setting as he sits in meditation under a for Making [Buddhist] Images"). 18 As with the
tree. The inscription below may be translated: canon of classical Greek sculpture, Buddhist
stone image of Sakyamuni made. We pray that pratimamana) is based on various modules. For
his present relatives may always be at peace and example, the smallest unit is the width of a finger
quiet, and that by giving up the world [entering (S: angula; C: zhiliang). Next comes the span of a
priesthood] his body will be blessed with hand (S: tala or vitasti; C: shouliang): this maximum
receiving a state in which he forever will see the distance between tips of thumb and middle finger
Buddha and hear his Law. May his fathers and corresponds to the length of the face from hairline
mothers for the past seven generations, together to the tip of the chin. The length of the forearm
with all sentient beings, share one and all in this from elbow to the tip of the thumb (C: zhouliang)
prayer. May they quickly attain Buddhahood constitutes another unit. Standard measurements of
and altogether magnificent salvation. this sort provide the fabric and grid for the canon
of proportions. Although derived from parts of the
ON THE PRODUCTION AND ICONOMETR.Y human body, the proportions were not used to
OF BUDDHIST IMAGES represent observed reality or to depict the natural
A few Buddhist image makers may have been beauty and harmony of the human figure. Rather,
ecclesiastics or artists loosely associated with a this system of proportions embodies spiritual and
religious institution; most were probably metaphysical laws of the Sacred, symbolic norms of
professional lay craftsmen who may have been abstract character: it prescribes different
organized in workshops through which they mathematical relationships for the various categories
handed down their technical skills and experience of figures, according to their level ot existence in
to following generations. Ancient Chinese prejudice the Buddhist pantheon. Multiples of the modules
condemned even the most talented masters in the determine the size of a standing or .1 seated figure
laborious art of sculpture to social inferiority and as well as the height and proportions ol .1 Buddha,
anonymity. Not until the end of the Tang dynasty is bodhisattva. deity, guardian, or an ordinary human
any individual sculptor known to have left his being. In sculpture, configurations are dominated by
signature on an extant work. A few sculptors are this principle of hieratic scaling. Individual figures
known by name solely through literary sources. are also distinguished h\ then volume and
(cats. 150, 161), they range from the central figure of for dedicatory inscriptions. Portable miniature altars
the Buddha, on his supreme level of transcendence, and small icons for private worship stood more
who stands out against the background and is chance of preservation than did the monumental
carved almost completely in the round, to the temple bronze statuary, almost all of which was
worldly donors, who occupy subordinate positions destroyed in the course of infrequent but ferocious
at the bottom and the edges and are rendered in persecutions of Buddhism or in other disasters, such
low relief or simple line engraving. as revolts, wars, earthquakes, fires, or floods.
to visualize the sacred essence of the faith through sequence of the establishment of cave-temples. The
majestic manifestation of the deities, through their architecture of the earliest Chinese cave-temples
serene nobility, and through their lavish follows Central Asian models and clearly reveals its
adornment an aesthetic quality called alamkara in Indian origins. Textual evidence suggests that the
Sanskrit (C: zhuangyan) .The fine linear engraving first was built in 366 at Dunhuang in the extreme
on a horizontal panel depicting the Buddha northwest, a junction of the great trade routes and a
surrounded by bodhisatrvas and disciples suggests a gateway to Western influence. Soon afterward,
convincing vision of the reward awaiting pious extensive work was carried out in the southeast and
believers in paradise (cat. 152). Highlighted by a east. The construction of the Bingling cave-temple
large mandorla and seated beneath a precious at Mount Xiaojishi in northwestern Yongjing
canopy, the central figure can probably be identified county, Gansu Province, seems to have begun early
as "Sakyamuni Preaching the Law." Subsidiary in the fifth century; in 1963 a votive inscription in
figures, "varied in pose and expression, are ink bearing a Western Qin date corresponding to
hierarchically grouped in front of luxuriant trees. 420 was discovered in Cave 169. The cave-temple at
This hierarchical symmetry and concern with three- Maijishan, east ot the ancient Buddhist center of
dimensional form extends to the entire Liangzhou in Tianshui county, Gansu Province, may
composition, inviting comparison with wall have been founded at about the same time. In his
paintings of Buddhist paradise scenes in cave- biographical account Gaoseng zhuan ("Lives of
temples. The fluent draftsmanship creates Eminent Monks"), Huijiao (497554) records that
an exquisite pictorial effect that must have been the monkTanhong from Chang' an, who was living
considerably heightened by the now-vanished as a hermit at Maijishan in the early 420s, was
polychromy. On both sides the figures are flanked joined there by another monk, Xuangao. 20 At that
by a long dedicatory inscription dated in time, a congregation of more than a hundred
accordance with 524, making this Northern Wei monks is said to have resided at Maijishan.
technique for casting bronze icons employed overlooking the Luo River. A votive inscription
traditional molds as well as the lost-wax method dated in accordance with 531 has been discovered
(cats. 160, 169). Overall fire gilding was favored. under niche 227 outside Cave 5.
(550577), in southwestern Hebei Province. Literary seated Buddha and placed in a recess with imitated
evidence and inscriptions on steles permit us to architectural elements, draped curtains, and canopy
assume that the emperor Wenxuan (r. 550-559) at the front (cats. 154, 155, 157, 158, 161). This
initiated this project. In Buddhist texts he is arrangement is strongly reminiscent of the walls of
described as a "devoted and generous follower of cave-chapels. The reverse side of such steles may
the Church." The work on the large complex of also be sculptured in relief, with groups of figures
Buddhist caves on the southwestern slope of from the Buddhist pantheon, narrative scenes of
Tianlongshan, southwest of present-day Taiyuan in sacred events and locations, or assemblages of
Shanxi Province, is likely to have begun around 535 donors. Often the rear is reserved for inscriptions,
and seems to have continued until the middle of including long lists of donors' names. In some cases,
the eighth century, after more than a hundred years pairs of intertwined dragons crown the work
of suspended activity, under the patronage of (cat. 157). Steles with images in relief on the front
influential people closely connected with the ruling only, leaving the rear unworked, were originally
Tang dynasty. most likely set into the walls of a temple structure.
In 1975 seventeen marble steles of this sort were
In addition to Buddhist images in cave-temples, unearthed near the village of Caotan, at Xi'an, in
images of stone, clay, bronze, and other materials Shaanxi Province (cat. 159). They were discovered
were worshiped in wood-constructed buildings, standing in pairs, face to face, which accounts for
temple courtyards, domestic shrines, and private their excellent state of preservation. Further
homes. Although we have a general view of the archaeological evidence suggests that they were
development of Buddhist sculpture in China, it will carefully buried at the site of an ancient Buddhist
require further investigation to more precisely temple for safety reasons probably to protect them
identify regional schools and individual workshops from the iconoclasts of one of the devastating
and to determine their characteristics, patrons, and Buddhist persecutions in old Chang'an. Steles with
periods of flourishing. More research is also needed a multitude of miniature Buddha niches
to discover when the first freestanding stone surrounding the central image are customarily
Buddhist images were created and where this referred to as "Thousand Buddha" steles.
in the round are not likely to predate the first half One of the earliest and most enduringly popular
of the sixth century. The use of micaceous white types of votive stele represents a seated or standing
marble known as Han baiyushi ("white jade[-like] Buddha haloed by a leaf-shaped mandorla, or
stone of Han") may have played an important role; aureole (cats. 147-49). The Buddha thus represented
it was an almost ideal material for the sculptors is often Sakyamuni, the historical Buddha, or the
working in the Dingzhou and Baoding areas in redeeming Buddha of the Future, Maitreya,
Hebei Province. Besides smaller sculptures and identified as a rule by his cross-ankled pose. The
steles, monumental statues in the round have been Buddha is presented in solemn frontality and high
found in this area that exhibit a delicate relief, almost in the round a stately figure, imbued
smoothness. The flat drapery folds cling to the body with majestic grandeur. A blissfully withdrawn smile
and flow in subtle, graceful lines, contrasting with on his face radiates tranquility and salvific certitude.
the rounded forms of the head. A large number of The symbolic gestures of the hands, or mudras,
marble sculptures, several inscribed and dated to the effectively convey powerful instructive messages to
520s, were excavated from the ruins of the ancient the devout beholder. On the front of the aureole,
Xiude Temple near Quyang in Hebei. dense patterns and ornaments are often interspersed
with miniature Buddha figures called
Most important for the study of Buddhist sculpture "Transformation Buddhas" (huqfo). Occasionally, the
is the comparatively large corpus of votive steles pointed mandorla curves gently forward at the top.
(huanyuan fobei) richly decorated with engravings This, along with other features such as the engraved
and reliefs of various depths and heights. They were wreath of flames, may have been inspired by gilded
usually installed in temple compounds, in bronze images. On the reverse, carved in low relief
monasteries and nunneries or their courtyards, and or incised, we find groups of minor deities and
also in cave-chapels. Their prototypes may be seen donors, along with narrative scenes of the Buddha's
in the memorial and other inscribed steles life and depictions of holy or miraculous deeds,
customary in China since Han times. Four-sided events, and encounters. Most of these features may
pier-steles resting on a pedestal usually have a be seen on a stele reportedly unearthed in
simulated roof that serves as a top member and are Xingping county, Shaanxi Province (cat, 147). The
adorned in several registers with Buddhist images, inscription on the rear of its pedestal is parti]
often set in niches on each of the four sides. damaged, but the date can be safely read: it
conspicuous parallel folds of the drapery suggest Three Worlds [of greed, hatred, and folly]) (cat. 170).
that the sculptor intended to transfer the qualities of One of his characteristic attributes is the ancient
a molded clay prototype into stone carving, which Indo-Aryan vajra, the magic thunderbolt or
may reflect stylistic influences from Taxila in diamond scepter (C: jingangchu), which symbolizes
Gandhara (in present-day Pakistan) or Bamiyan in the diamond-like, indestructible character of the
A great variety of freestanding Buddhist sculptures and eight arms. His furious, scowling visage, with
have been preserved from the Tang dynasty bulging eyes, bestial fangs, and knotted eyebrows
(618-907). One of the finest works is the white expresses his holy wrath (S: krodha; C: fennu), while
marble torso of a standing bodhisattva that was his combative attitude and flamboyant hair point to
excavated in the old precincts of Daminggong, the his destructive energies and militant opposition to
Tang imperial "Palace of Great Brightness," in Xi'an evil, both physical and spiritual. The Bodhisattva
(cat. 165). Only traces of gold and colors remain on HayagrTva, the "horse-headed" Matou Guanyin, also
the polished stone surface. The attractively rounded, has three heads and eight arms. He is shown sitting
swelling forms of the body and the pliant pose on a lotus-and-rock pedestal in front of an aureole
imbue this statue with the sensuous and tactile of swirling flames. Another prominent member of
beauty that so emphatically marks Tang sculpture at the Esoteric Buddhist pantheon is the mystic
its zenith, about the middle of the eighth century. Buddha of the South, Ratnasambhava (C: Baosheng;
The triple-bend posture, or tribhahga, suggesting a "Producer of Treasures"). This figure, now headless,
gentle sway at the hips, demonstrates the sculptor's is seated with legs crossed in vajrdsana pose (legs
interest in organic movement. At the same time this folded in the "adamant," or unshakable, posture) on
torso shows the influence of India's mature Gupta a lotus throne that rests on seven winged horses
art. An elegant scarf across the naked chest and a (cat. 171). Among the finest works in this group of
dhoti covering the lower body are draped in marble sculptures is the image of Manjusn
graceful folds and pleats that closely follow the (C:Wenshu), one of the agents of the Buddha
forms of the body. A precious necklace contributes Sakyamuni (cat. 172). In his left hand he holds the
to the effects of elegant courtly refinement, stem of a lotus. A palm-leaf book of Indian type
splendor, and grandeur. placed on the blossom above his left shoulder allows
us to identify him as the Bodhisattva of Great
A totally different stylistic approach is seen in a Wisdom. His cultic center was on Mount Wutai in
nearly contemporaneous sandstone torso of a Shanxi Province, which was thought to be his
powerful guardian figure (cat. 168). This statue was sacred abode. Richly adorned with heavy jewelry,
excavated in 1954 at the site of the Tang dynasty Manjusn is seated on an elaborate throne of
Jingzhong Temple (known as Wanfo Temple in late overlapping lotus petals. Deeply sculptured, scrolling
Han times) at Chengdu, in Sichuan Province. The leaves create an almost baroque quality.
of the sanctuary. Forceful workmanship creates an and fragments is exceptional. Their subtle and
almost overly emphatic, manneristic muscularity, elaborate surface treatment including the original
reinforced by manneristic elements in the agitated polychromy and gilding attests to the artist's or
treatment of the garment. the metropolitan atelier's remarkable technical skill
made of finely grained white marble with traces of Changle ward in the immediate neighborhood of
gold and polychromy, excavated in 1959 in the old the imperial palaces, just outside present-day Xi'an.
Changle ward of the Tang capital Chang'an, at least Local government workers digging for a water
eight qualify as members of the Esoteric Buddhist conduit discovered the sculptures, several in badly
pantheon (cats. 166, 170-72). Two depict the damaged condition, in a small tunnel; they had been
ferocious-looking Bright King Budong buried deep and were found at a depth of over ten
(S: Acalafnatha];" Immovable One"), who was the meters.
unshakable, indomitable adherent and protector of
the Buddhist Law. Two other terrifying deities on The Anguo Temple was founded in 710. According
bizarre, layered rock pedestals most likely represent to Duan Chengshi's (d. 863) Sitaji ("Notes on
chamber hall of the emperor Xuanzong (r. symmetrical, creating a rather austere, disincarnat&-
2I
712756). The structure was purportedly image, but one of compelling majestic poise. By the
dismantled and transferred to the temple grounds end of the fifth century all the stylistic idioms of
by imperial decree in 713. Its main image seems to Buddhist sculpture that had reached China from
have been a Maitreya statue that frequently emitted Gandhara, India, and Central Asia had been slowly
miraculous light. Unfortunately, there is no mention assimilated into a consistent Chinese declaration of
of any other icons. As a renowned study center for faith and zeal. Throughout the first half of the sixth
Esoteric Buddhism and a colossal monument to century traditional styles and motifs persisted in the
piety and the arts in the capital city of Chang' an, Chinese Buddhist sculptor's art, but from about the
the Anguo Temple was a chief target in the violent mid-sixth century a novel style was evolving in
persecution of 845. Anti-Buddhist iconoclasts may north China.
have buried the sculptures at such a great depth
because they feared revenge and punishment The sculpture of the Northern Qi and Sui periods
through the magical powers of the terrifying deities is clearly distinct from earlier linear, geometric NOTES
embodied in the images. The turmoil treatments of Buddhist images. In this new stage of 1. Robert H. Sharf. "The
Scripture in Forty-Two
accompanying general An Lushan's insurrection of the development we see a genuine attempt to
Sections," in Religions of China
755-763 had far-reaching negative effects, not only indicate the human body beneath the garments, an in Practice, ed. Donald S. Lopez.
on the subsequent political, economic, and social attempt that was stimulated by Indian influences of Jr., Princeton Readings in
Religions (Princeton:
structure ofTang China, but also on the prestige the classic Gupta period. In their striving for
Princeton University Press,
and development of the Buddhist church and its volume and graceful movement in their figures, IQQ 6), P- 360; for a concise
arts. The Anguo Temple sculptures probably predate Tang sculptors of the seventh and eighth centuries introduction to and full transla-
century. rhythmic drapery patterns follow the form of the shinshu daizokyo, ed.Takakusu
that Esoteric Buddhism first received official substantial, often plump, there was an ever- kankokai, 1968), vol. 17,
Subhakarasimha (637-735), known to the Chinese curves of the drapery folds. Their extraordinary (Tokyo, 1928; reprint, Tokyo:
Taisho shinshu daizokyo
as Shanwuwei, arrived in Chang'an with a number technical skill allowed the sculptors to reproduce
kank5kai, 1973), vol. 51,
of Sanskrit texts. Eight years later his Chinese the finest details of hair, ribbons, and jewelry with no. 2092, p. 999a. Translation,
disciple Yixing (638-727) assisted him in translating utmost accuracy. In the end the monumental with minor changes, by Yi-
t'ung Wang, A Record of
and commenting on one of the fundamental solidity of the mature Tang style was diminished Buddhist Monasteries in Ix-yang
Esoteric Buddhist scriptures, the Mahavairocana through an overconscious striving for aristocratic by Yang Hsuan-chih (Princeton:
Princeton University Press.
Sutra (C: Darijing; "Sutra of the Great Radiance of elegance and sensuous beauty.
[984), pp. sf.
Illumination"). This text describes most of the
important Esoteric Buddhist deities in some detail: Over the past decades several of the large cave- 3. Edwin O. Reischauer, trans..
must have overshadowed the appeal of the isolated images have been excavated; and several
4. Translation by Alexandei (
bodhisattvas, whose prominence they were spectacular reliquary deposits have been recovered
Soper, Literary Evidence fo\
usurping. from China's great Buddhist heritage. All these Buddhist Art in China, Ambus
Asiae, Suppl. n> (Ascona:
substantive archaeological finds and results of recent
Ambus Asi.u-. [959), pp. it'.
trends
stylistic; in buddhist restoration and research have greatly clarified and
sculpture enriched our understanding of historical records 5. Another version of this
icons mainly gilded bronzes of the fourth changes in Buddhist piety, worship, and faith;
("Records
i
in the Mingxiatigji
ot" Miraculous
century is very small, and their style is reminiscent developments in the structure and importance of Omens"), b\ VrangYan (act
Lite sih-early 6th Ik- 131
various schools and temples: prominence of
. I
ol famous images in
and abstraction. Early Chinese Buddhist images not least, its perfect Sinicizatdon.
chapter ; ofhisji shenzhou son-
tend to ignore rather than emphasize human
Three Jewels on China's Melbourne: Cambridge tip of the middle finger) [or] a
Assembled [Temples and University Press, 1987), p. 104. span of time (as marked off
Pagodas]"), in Taisho shinshu and articulated by audible and
daizokyo (Tokyo, 1927; reprint, 15. Mahayana doctrines hold silent gestures performed by
Tokyo: Taish5 shinshu daizokyo that the Buddha exists simulta- the hand[s])." See Kapila
kankokai, i960), vol. 52, neously in three essentially Vatsyayan, ed., Kalatattvakos'a,
no. 2106, p. 413c. identical "bodies": the A Lexicon of Fundamental
6. Soper, Literary Evidence, p. 4. and the nirmanakaya. The vol- 2, Concepts of Space and
dharmakaya, or true "body of Time, ed. Bettma Baumer
7. Soper, Literary Evidence, p. 4. the Law" (C: fashen), transcends (New Delhi: Sri Jainendra
sanbao gantong lit, chap. 2, phenomenal world. Thus, it 20. See Taisho shinshu daizokyo
pp. 416c 417a. can neither be depicted, nor (Tokyo, 1928; reprint, Tokyo:
expressed in words, nor con- Taisho shinshu daizokyo
Daoxuan, Ji shenzhou sanbao templated by the unenlight- kankokai, 1968), chap. 11,
9.
gantong hi, p. 416c. Translation, ened human mind. The sam- vol. 50, no. 2059, p. 397a.
14. Translation, with minor tion, has from a very early time
Peter Sturman
Associate Professor, Department of the
History of Art and Architecture,
Calligraphy is often called the most University of California, Santa Barbara
159
Fig. l. Cangjie, legendary inventor of the Chinese
characters. Computer-generated image.
fact, a
unknown
able to read
remarkably open
that
art,
Chinese characters, but
Chinese calligraphy
one that actively
is, in
it
jrm
m
engages its viewer in a manner unlike that of any
other art form of any culture. Little can be done
about the language divide
democratic engagement will remain largely beyond
hence, that sense of 'if
^'
(I
mi Tf^;
&| -WK'$ ' ft
:
r -
so engaging and thus why it is truly a unique art. Fig. zb. Oracle hone, inscribed. Shang dynasty. Tortoise
employment of the legendary Yellow Emperor and ancient myth Cangjie joins such other celebrated
a man whose remarkable vision and ability to culture heroes as Fuxi (inventor of the trigrams)
communicate with the spirit world was signified by and Shennong (the inventor of agriculture) as
his four eyes (fig. i). Ancient texts recount that curious personifications, convenient though vague
Cang Jie fashioned graphs in the form of pictorial markers of the early progress of Chinese
images after being inspired by such natural civilization. There is, however, an important point
phenomena as bird tracks, animal paw prints, and to be noted in Cang Jie's story: the characters, or
shadows cast by trees. "Millet rained from heaven graphs, in a sense are found, determined from
and demons howled in the night," reads one, 1
a patterns cast by images of the natural world. Cang
clear indication of how momentous was Cang Jie's Jie, or whomever Cangjie represents, created not
CALLIGRAPHY
by forging something new, but by carefully
examining what already existed. In other words, he
did not write so much as he read.
(fig.
(fig.
(ca.
2a)
2b) that
1300-ca. 1100 bce)
the general term used for
and tortoise
were used
specific questions
to
ft
^ \t
incised onto the bones ("Will it rain?" "Will the
oracle bones from our earliest evidence ot Stream." Dated to 10S8. Detail of a handsaoll, ink on
slightly modified, foundation of the art. The source the text. Stroke by stroke, character by character,
of the writing changed it was now a person column by column (from right to left), one "re-
rather than Heaven that communicated but what views" the original performance of writing. The
issued forth was still considered the embodiment of more informed the viewer, the more familiar with
inherent truths. "Writing is pictures of the heart," using the brush to write, the more vividly that
wrote Yang Xiong (55 bce 18 ce) in the Han viewer will sense the brush's original movements
dynasty. 3
The beauty of Chinese calligraphy is that and pacing. Some say that the visual retracing of a
the tools of writing, as well as the rules, allow particularly dynamic piece of calligraphy evokes an
practice to concur with this promise of expression. unearthly sense of the calligrapher writing it for the
Deceptively simple in appearance, the brush proves first time. No other art can claim such immediacy.
capable of conveying the slightest nuance of No other art captures the process of creativity so
movement. It is a direct line from that point where vividly.
through the fingers, hand, and wrist to the eye and The immediacy of Chinese calligraphy can create
brain; and as anyone who has tried to wield the an aura of timelessness. An informed viewer attuned
calligrapher's tool would know, skill or ineptitude is to the subtle art of reading calligraphy may feel as
readily apparent. Equally important, Chinese familiar with the author of a piece of writing done
characters are essentially of fixed form, composed centuries earlier as with a contemporary. No one
of an established number of brush strokes. There is illustrates this effect better than the Northern Song
a predetermined order to the writing of the calligrapher Mi Fu ( 1052-1 107/S). a celebrated
individual strokes in a given character, and a eccentric and dedicated student of his art.
predetermined direction for the writing of each Throughout his life Mi Fu diligently collected
stroke. These rules are integral to calligraphy's ancient bits of writing, savoring them to the point
expressive dimension, for they allow a later viewer of obsession."! have no desire for wealth or noble
to retrace visually the process ot writing, to re- rank." he wrOte,"My only love is for those letters
experience the spatial and temporal unfolding of from the brushes of the men ol antiquity. Ever)
CALLIGRAPHY 161
time I clean the inkstone and spread out a scroll, I
(fig. 3); afterward he recorded on another scroll the Fig. 4. Wang Xizhi (307?365?). "Ping'an tie, Heju tie,
poems he had written during the trip. 5 Both sets of Fengju tie. "Tang dynasty (61S-907) tracing copy. Detail
poems repeatedly refer to people ol the Jin dynasty of letters mounted as a handscroll, ink on paper. Palace
year and no doubt was proudly showing off to his 183 for an example of the latter), later calligraphers
friends. Needless to say, Mi Fu's calligraphy in these felt conversant with a spectrum of writing that
two scrolls of poems closely follows the Jin dynasty literally spanned millennia. The catalyst for the
style associated with Wang Xizhi and the Orchid interaction could be a masterful genuine work or a
Pavilion Preface. Although Jin calligraphy, even rare tracing copy of the type Mi Fu sought; it could
copies, became increasingly rare in later dynasties, be a faded rubbing from a compendium of
the spirit ofWang Xizhi and the Orchid Pavilion collected writings engraved in stone or from some
gathering would still be invoked through such ancient stele accidentally discovered in a farmer's
writing objects as inkstones carved with scenes field. In each case, the right viewer under the right
from the life ofWang Xizhi. circumstances would become engaged, assimilate
CALLIGRAPHY 162
AESTHETIC CRITERIA: RESONANCE,
METHODS, IDEAS
Looking back on the long history of calligraphy
that preceded him, the Ming dynasty theorist Dong
Qichang (1555 1636) recognized three epochs
aristocrats of his day. What can be gleaned from periods, but its manner of presentation differs
extant Tang dynasty tracing copies of calligraphy depending on both personal and period styles. In
attributed to Wang Xizhi suggests a remarkably writings attributed to the Jin period that energy
controlled hand that demanded nothing less than seems muted by refinement and decorum.
perfection of beauty from the brush (fig. 4). Each Individual elements tend to achieve subtle
stroke is utterly smooth and tensile, ribbon-like in balancing of forms and forces, with generous spaces
its twists and turns. At the same time, the created between the traces of ink. A quiet, self-
calligraphy displays an extraordinary sense of ease. It contained energy seemingly resonates about the
appears absolutely unforced and natural, which was writing like an electrical field. This, I would
precisely the writers aim. Early critiques of suggest, is what Dong Qichang refers to as yun
calligraphy almost invariably utilize metaphors of ("resonance").
the natural world to describe the forms and forces
of the writing. Suo Jing (239-303), for example, A single character from one Wang Xizhi attribution
wrote the following in reference to the informal will help to illustrate (fig. 5, left). The graph shuang
and abbreviated cursive script: ("frost") is composed of two basic elements: the
Not yet aloft, wings spread, units. Note the length of the stroke at the upper
Ready to rise, left. This was the second stroke to be written (after
Insects and snakes coiled and poised: pronounced that in writing the rest of the character
Some advancing, others retreating, the calligrapher had to consider ways to counter a
Some fragile, soft and willowy, threatened imbalance in the overall structure. Two
Others aggressive, charging forward. solutions are apparent: a strong right-to-left curving
Wandering freely, this way and that, stroke that connects the upper portion of the
Suddenly upright, suddenly twisted. character to the lower left element, and the vertical
An outstanding steed bolts in anger. stroke on the right side of the lower right element.
Struggling against the bridle. 7 The former parallels and balances that problematic
second stroke while echoing and amplifying the
Suo Jing's emphasis is on the energy of the curving stroke immediately above and to the right
calligraphy, its sense of movement and liveliness. (which preceded it), thus creating a strong
The general term used to describe such energy is cascading movement that helps to anchor the top
shi, which can be roughly translated as "configur.il element. The verticil stroke at the lower right was
force," or "momentum." Shi is the manifestation of the very last stroke of the character. It extends a bil
both potential and kinetic energy process about lower than it otherwise might have a last, minor
to happen and already realized. It can be embodied correction to balance the entire composition. This
CALLIGRAPHY 163
character radiates harmony, balance, and classical
beauty, but also, as we have seen, a strong inner
tension. It is this perfect balance of energy and
restraint that characterizes yun.
codification, all in the interest of assuring stable on paper. Palace Museum, Beijing.
continuity. Singling out Wang Xizhi's calligraphy as
one such standardization. Lu Jianzhi's calligraphy, as an imposition of the self, qualities of singularity that
well as that of many of the other early Tang draw attention to the distinguishing characteristics
writers, demonstrates the result: the spontaneity of of a particular person. Qualities of individuality are
Jin has been transformed into an image ot wrought not absent in the earlier calligraphy, but never are
perfection. "ideas" more strongly sensed and the individual
more directly celebrated than in the writing of the
Methods, of course, did not appear first in Tang Song calligraphers active in the second half of the
calligraphy. Rules, propriety, and established eleventh century. When Dong Qichang wrote of
standards ot aesthetic quality are the foundation for "Song ideas," he most likely had in mind the
the practice of calligraphy in any period. Similarly, triumvirate of great Song calligraphers Su Shi
yun is not necessarily absent from Tang calligraphy. (1037-1101), Huang Tingjian (1045-1105), and Mi
It is true, however, that these two very significant Fu but what he points to, in fact, was a
considered important. In the Jin dynasty it was particularly distinctive style (fig. 6), which Huang
spontaneity, naturalness, the images and energies of Tingjian made fun of by likening it to the images
the natural world; in the Tang dynasty it was of strange demonic creatures he once saw in a
elegance tempered by propriety, stateliness, piece of embroidery from a foreign land some
decorum, and orthodoxy. Both sets of aesthetic without hands and feet, some with too many. "This
criteria are essential components of Chinese kind of strangeness is not what is normally studied
calligraphy. "Resonance" and "methods" are simply in calligraphy," Huang wrote, "but Wang Shen
convenient terms to designate these two different certainly has developed his own style."" There is a
aspects of the calligrapher's art. tone of grudging approval in Huang Tingjian s
comment, admiration for Wang Shen's ability to
But what of "ideas," which Dong Qichang distinguish his writing from that of others, even if it
associated with the Song dynasty? Yi ("ideas") means means unorthodox results.
processes that distinguish an individual, along with Historically, the "ideas" of Song calligraphy proved
his or her idiosyncrasies. In calligraphy it suggests the most problematic for later Chinese
CALLIGRAPHY 164
* ^
^L v
"-
*-
v*
4^ # >fc> -7C HI
lii
indulgent and heterodox. Certainly, "ideas" tend to writer's presence or personality, and this happens
manifest themselves at the expense of the classical most readily with calligraphy that is particularly
norms of beauty evident in both Jin and Tang distinctive. To give an extreme example, one
calligraphy. The educated class of scholar-officials, twentieth-century author goes so far as to read
who were the primary practitioners of calligraphy, physical as well as behavioral traits from the
took it as their incumbent duty to represent the calligraphy of Northern Song writers: Mi Fu was
state, tradition, and orthodoxy. Excessive expression "tubby"; Shu Shi, "fatter, shorter and careless in
of one's individuality was at best irrelevant to this nature"; Huang Tingjian, "tall, lean and obstinate";
responsibility, at worst contradictory. By unhappy Emperor Huizong (r. 11001126), "handsome, slim,
coincidence, the Song dynasty came perilously meticulous, and somewhat effeminate" (fig. 7). "We
close to total collapse just one generation after the can even affirm that he [Huizong] was slow and
great individualist calligraphers of the Northern measured of speech," the author goes on to write! 9
Song. For those who truly believed in the If it does nothing else, this imaginative critique
expressiveness of calligraphy its ability to reflect presents one positive aspect of Song ideas: the
inherent truths the idiosyncrasies of Song "ideas" opportunity to establish so personal an imprint on
were symptomatic of the graver ills that ultimately the tradition that later viewers would be inspired to
led to the loss of the northern half of China in 1127. imagine what one was like.
Despite such reservations, most, if not all, PARAMETERS OF INNOVATION IN THE LATER
calligraphers wished to develop singular styles of TRADITION
calligraphy that would distinguish them as "Resonance," "methods," and "ideas" are vague
individuals and serve as the evidence from which labels, but they are useful for designating three
others would read their characters (or "understand different aspects of Chinese calligraphy: naturalness
their sounds," as an old saying goes, in reference to associated with spontaneity, skill and practice
expressive music). Certainly one of the most associated with tradition, and personal expression.
enjoyable aspects of viewing calligraphy is the By choosing these terms to epitomize the three
intangible pleasure that stems from the sense of the great epochs of writing that preceded the
CALLIGRAPHY 165
seventeenth century, Dong Qichang suggests both character compositions; but innovation here is
the aesthetic and historical parameters within revealed only by the most subtle of indications and
which later calligraphers worked at their art. After only to those who recognize hints of the brush
Dong Qichang's time another epochal movement modes and compositions of past masters under this
would take place in Chinese calligraphy, known as highly polished formal veneer.
careful examination of earlier calligraphy incised on Zhang Zhao wrote under the most restrictive of
old steles (many of them newly excavated) (fig. 8) circumstances. In contrast, both Deng Shiru (cat.
as well as cast on ancient ritual bronzes. Perhaps if 183) and Zhang Ruitu (cat. 180) worked within
Dong Qichang had lived in the twentieth century considerably broader spaces of the tradition.
he would have coined a fourth category for Qing Writing at a time when the rediscovery of ancient
dynasty (1644-1911) calligraphy: gu, or "antique." steles acted to liberate calhgraphers from the torpid
Again, this was not a quality lacking in the earlier repetition of learned habits, Deng Shiru found
periods in fact, the pursuit of antiquity was almost plenty to play with in archaic styles of writing that
always a concern of Chinese calhgraphers, and the appeared fresh and unusual to a largely jaded
systematic study of steles and bronzes began as early audience of scholars and merchants eager for
as the Northern Songbut the dominant trend in something different and sophisticated. Here the
Qing calligraphy sought inspiration in antiquity to solemnity of the clerical script is subtly tweaked
an unprecedented degree. Written in the clerical with whimsical touches in composition and
script (lishu), "Couplet in seven-character lines" brushwork so that the end result is a buoyancy
(cat. 183) by Deng Shiru (1743-1805) provides an within the weighty forms. The earlier Zhang Ruitu
excellent example. (1570-1641), on the other hand, sought an
innovative image by deliberately tapping into that
Each of the works in the exhibition reveals the portion of the tradition which was already
calligraphers attempt to create something new inextricably associated with individualism. In the
within the parameters of the tradition. This was no late 1620s, Zhang Ruitu retired from important
simple matter, considering the longevity and weight positions at the Ming court and pursued personal
of that tradition by the sixteenth century, when the interests in Chan (Zen) Buddhism. Chan had its
earliest of the included works was written. own tradition of calligraphy, one that had been
Moreover, the parameters differed, depending on strongly influenced by the Song dynasty emphasis
the specific circumstances of the calligrapher and on "ideas" and personality. In the context of the late
which particular aspect of the tradition was being Ming and such influential thinkers as Li Zhi
tapped. Consider, for example, Zhang Zhao's (1527-1602) and Yuan Hongdao (1568-1610), Chan-
(1691-1745) transcription of "Seventh Month" from inflected calligraphy discarded rules, methods, and
the Odes of Bin (cat. 182). Zhang Zhao was an standards in favor of recapturing the "child's heart,"
important minister and cultural figure at the Qmg or original nature, of the writer. Zhang Ruitu's
dynasty court, rising to such high positions as cursive script in his transcription of Wang Wei's
president of the Censorate and of the Board of "Song of the Aged General" (cat. 180) is highly
Punishments under theYongzheng (r. 1723 1735) spirited, yet by emphasizing an even tempo down
and Qianlong (r. 1736 1795) emperors. Zhang's skill his columns he manages to suggest an overall
as a calligrapher was much admired by Qianlong in uniformity, almost a placidity, that is most fitting for
particular, who employed him as a ghostwriter early the Chan devotee in search of personal enlightenment.
10
in his reign. In keeping with Zhang Zhao's high
profile at the court and the pressures of conservatism These general observations about the calligraphy of
that accompanied such prominence, both the Zhang Zhao, Deng Shiru, and Zhang Ruitu suggest
content and style of Zhang's transcription of how later writers established their art in the
"Seventh Month" are unfailingly orthodox, even context of their immediate surroundings largely by
predictable. The poem is from the ancient positioning it in a working relationship to some
compilation Shijing ("Classic of Poetry") long a , aspect of the past tradition. The same can be said of
favorite source for lessons of good government, and two major works by ZhuYunming (1461-1527) and
the calligraphy is written in a precise standard script Wang Duo (1592 1652), to which we turn now in
that instantly recalls the fa ("methods") of such order to explore this act of positioning in finer
early Tang dynasty exemplars of standard script as detail (cats. 179, 181). The goal is not to clarify Zhu
Yu Shi'nan (558-638), Ouyang Xun (557-641), and Yunming's and Wang Duo's contributions to the
Chu Suiliang (596-658). " The writing is a history of Chinese calligraphy a task that would
definitive statement of orthodoxy and, as such, demand much more time and space than is granted
allows only the most tightly controlled expression here but rather to elucidate the practice of the
of individual creativity. We admire Zhang Zhao's calhgraphers art by considering specific concerns
ability to carry off such a lengthy, if constrained, reflected in the writers' choices of script, style,
CALLIGRAPHY 166
Zhu Yunming, often considered the greatest
Zhang Xu, provides an excellent example of orthodox study, without which his wilder
eleventh-century kuangcao (fig. 9).' 4 experiments would have been unacceptable. The
proof lay in a stele exhibiting Zhang Xu's standard
Kuangcao presents interesting problems in all three script, which was a considered a model of Tang
ot the aesthetic domains previously described. Yun discipline and suggested to Song dynasty viewers
resonance is an important desideratum for all forms some relationship with the earlier Jin tradition
of cursive script, but wild-cursive script promotes because of its relatively open, sparse structures
an outward display of raw energy. Containment, aesthetic qualities generally associated with Jin
that subtle sense of resonating energies rippling writing. '' The existence of this standard-script
across characters or columns, is often lost in the writing was extremely important, for it validated
calligrapher's eagerness to open the emotional Zhang Xu's unconventional cursive by proving
floodgates. Similarly, methods {fa), reflective of that Zhang was steeped in rules and methods.
diligence and restraint, at first seem totally Huang Tingjian prided himself on the ability to
irrelevant. As for ideas (yi), their presence would be spot Zhang Xu fakes
wild writing by pretenders
antithetical to the absolute naturalness demanded of and followers precisely because rules and
the calligrapher. But herein precisely lies the methods were lacking."' Both Su Shi and Huang
problem. Later critics recognized that kuangcao, in Tingjian strongly emphasized the propriety the
tact, often was written with intention the solid foundation rooted in orthodoxy governing
intention to be as wild as possible. Wildness was not the dots and dashes of Zhang's drunken brush.
to be equated with genuineness, especially when It was what separated Zhang Xu trom his followers,
there was a ready audience and market for this new, who, by merely imitating the wildness ot his
exciting form of performance calligraphy. Eleventh- writing, were guilty of using conscious intent
century critics like Su Shi and Huang Tingjian to write that which should have emerged
were careful to emphasize that Zhang Xu's wild- spontaneously.
cursive writing was built on a solid foundation of
CALLIGRAPHY 167
mm
1
r&m
^ffpfi^l
Fig. w. Zhu Yunming (14611527). Examples of prose by
four masters of the Tang and Song. Ming dynasty
(13681644). Palace Museum, Beijing. Fig. 11. Yan Zhenqitig (709-785). "Record of theYan
Family Ancestral Shrine. " Dated to 780. Detail of a
rubbing.
kuangcao as a natural outlet for his personality, significant, for Huang Tingjian repeatedly
described by one friend as "bold and direct, with emphasized the importance of yun ("resonance") in
no patience for strictness and reserve," critics cursive calligraphy. Viewers cognizant of Zhu
disparaged it as "undisciplined," "careless," "self- Yunming's standard-script calligraphy will also be
indulgent," and "bordering on the heretical." tempted to recognize in the writing compositional
Interestingly, Zhu Yunming s wild-cursive writing, principles that Zhu had mastered from his study of
like Zhang Xu's, was apparently much forged. As the very early calligrapher ZhongYou (is 1230)
the contemporary scholar Fu Shen has (fig. 10). Samples of writing attributed to Zhong
documented, one later calligrapher went so far as to You epitomize that association of loose
claim that all of Zhu Yunming's wild-cursive works compositional structures with early writing. If Zhu
in circulation were outright fakes. 17
Yunming did apply the methods of standard-script
writing to his wild cursive, it would have been
The approach taken in the present scroll (cat. 179), reassuring to the viewer that the underlying quality
a late work dated to 1523, suggests Zhu Yunming's of propriety so important to Song dynasty critics
solution to the problems posed by the kuangcao was indeed present. Zhu Yunming refrained from
tradition. Unlike the eleventh-century "Poems" interconnecting many of the characters, opting
(fig. 9), which emphasizes a kind of zigzagging instead tor measured compositional interplay. The
columnar speed, Zhu's wild cursive explores a writing is dynamic and inspired, but the overall
broad horizontal dimension. He purposely leaves feeling is of a deep pool of complex, interweaving
many of the structures loose and open so that dots energies, like swirling eddies, rather than a
and lines almost seem to disperse instead of cascading release. Zhu Yunming successfully realized
connecting to form distinct characters. In fact, the a delicate balance between containment and vigor.
untutored eye may have a difficult time He explains at the end of the scroll that he wrote
distinguishing Zhu Yunming's individual columns of after drinking and that though he was fatigued, the
CALLIGRAPHY 168
brush moved spiritedly, without urging. No ideas; months because of his father's death and remained
in other words, no intentions -just Zhu Yunming. in mourning until spring of 1644, when he was
recalled to the same office. Unfortunately, before
Wang Duo's large, standard-script (kaislui) Wang could resume his duties the Ming dynasty
transcription of poems by the Tang dynasty poet collapsed. Wang Duo wrote this transcription of
Wang Wei (699-759) taps into a rather different Wang Wei's poems in the late autumn of 1643,
tradition (cat. 181). This is unusual writing by Wang while staying with friends. Those were chaotic
Duo, who is better known for the highly times, and one is tempted to read into Wang Duo's
individualistic style of semicursive and cursive adoption ofYan Zhenqing's style a statement of
calligraphy exhibited in the inscription at the left of dynastic loyalty and political resolve. Yet the two
the scroll, following his transcriptions. The poems poems Wang chose to transcribe are largely
themselves are written in the unmistakable manner celebrations of a reclusive lifestyle, and Wang's own
of the great Tang calligrapherYan Zhenqing inscription at the end speaks not of the nation's ills
(709785), whose bold, assertive standard-script but of the camaraderie of friends, the sweetness of
writing has served as one of the canonical models their wine, the clear sounds of a bubbling brook by
for calligraphers throughout the ages (fig. 11). Wang his window, and tomorrow's planned outing to
Duo, like Zhu Yunming, was a devoted student of scenic spots. Viewed retrospectively, the writing is
the art, and he avidly devoted himself to copying even more curious, because Wang Duo would later
classical models. It is not surprising to find him earn the unenviable historical reputation of a
writing a rather diligent rendition ofYan turncoat: he was one of a number of high officials
Zhenqing's style. But Wang Duo was first and who joined in ignominious surrender to the
foremost an individualist who commonly used the Manchus, founders of the Qing dynasty
ancient models as a point of departure for his own (1644 1911), and he immediately began to serve
expressive means. A more careful comparison is under the new regime, resuming his position of
merited, beginning with Yan Zhenqing. Minister of Rites in the spring of 1646 (Wang's
official biography is listed in the section Er chen
Yan's style is one of the most easily recognized of juan ["Officials who Served Two Houses"].) 20
all Chinese calligraphers. The brush strokes are
muscular, the character compositions expansive. In the light of such infelicities, Wang Duo's copying
Not everyone appreciated this style of writing. For of the Yan style begins to appear somewhat
example, Li Yu (r. 961-975), ruler of the Southern questionable. A closer look at Wang Duo's
Tang kingdom, found Yan's calligraphy offensively inscription confirms that he was not exclusively
direct
"like an uncouth farmer facing forward concerned with the state of the nation. He writes,
perceived through the later dynasties. Beginning had attempted before in other words, a forum for
students of calligraphy are often given Yan the expression of Wang's individualism. The
Zhenqing's writing as a model, no doubt in hopes decidedly unpolished quality ofWang Duo's
that some of the Tang minister's virtuous character writing here helps to explain his last modest
would be passed along with his particular brush remarks. At the same time, such self-deprecation
habits. Yan Zhenqing's style is so widely known that should not be taken seriously. One can imagine the
one's immediate perception of any later rendition calligrapher being somewhat pleased with the
ot the Yan style is colored by associations of results, knobby strokes, bleeding ink, and all. This
propriety, moral fortitude, and orthodoxy. calligraphy may not exactly be a work ot beauty.
That is precisely what makes Wang Duo's scroll so ultimately, was Wang Duo's goal.
interesting. In the 1620s and 1630s, Wing had served
in high offices, culminating in his promotion to The point here is not to question Wang Duo's
Minister of Rites in 1640. He retired after only two integrity or moral fiber, nor is it to accuse him of
CALLIGRAPHY 169
debasing the hallowed heritage ofYan Zhenqing. It
past in an attempt to explore new territories of the writing was preserved by those (reprint, Shanghai: Shanghai Huizong's Xuanhe shupu (juan
who read qualities of guji chubanshe, 19S7). of circa 1120. In recent
present. Wang Duo's appropriation
16)
and handling of
personality into the calligraphy years both Xu Bangda and Qi
the Yan style so that this most familiar of images are recounted by Lothar 8. Huang Tingjian,"Ba Wang Gong have both pointed out
became recast into something peculiarly Ledderose, Mi Fu and the Jinqing shu," in Shangu ji, Siku that a changed character in one
Classical Tradition of Chinese quanshu ed.,juan 29, I9a-b. ot the verses may reflect the
appropriate to the circumstances of a late Ming p.
and achieve a creative resolution. explicating the affairs of the and consequently ordered to and Qi Gong, "Jiu ti Zhang
world, recording them for be executed, he was pardoned Xu caoshu gushi tie bian," in
palpable sense of two artists molding the past to suit sounds and pictures, superior Ch'ing Period (Washington,
and lesser people are D.C.: Library ot Congress, 16. Huang Tingjian,"Ti
the needs of the present. In their works,
distinguished. Sounds and 1943), pp. 24-25. Jiangben fatie," in Shanggu ji,
calligraphy 's immediacy is once more confirmed. pictures by these, superior juan 28, pp. iob-na.
and lesser people move ones 11. Zhang Zhao's models for
feelmgs."Yang Xiong, Fa yan, standard script were Dong 17. Fu, Traces oj the Brush,
juan 4, pp. 2b 3 a, in Han Wei Qichang (1555-1636) andYan pp. 214-15.
congshu, vol. 24 (Taipei:Yiwen
Zhenqing (709-7S5). I am
yinshuguan, 1967). It would referring here to the 18. Dong Shi, Shu hi, Siku
appear that by "wnting,"Yang meticulous manner in which quanshu ed.,juan 2, p. 6b.
Xiong is referring primarily to
Zhang Zhao writes, which
the content of the written of the early Tang
recalls that 19. "Tang Yan Lugong shu Cao
word. In later times, however, writers. bei," in Ouyang Xiu, Ouyang
SOURCES FOR FIGURES Yang Xiong's comment was
Kin quanji (reprint, Hong
Fig. 1 . After Smcai tuhui clearly associated with the art
12. Shen C.Y. Fu, Traces of the Kong: Guanzhi shuju, n.d.),
(Taipei, 1970). of calligraphy.
Brush (New HavemYale juan 6, p. 31. See also Ronald
University Art Gallery, 1977), Egan,"Ou-yang Hsiu and Su
Fig. 3. After Gugong bowuyuan 4. Mi Fu,"Ba mige fatie," in
211, citing a colophon by Shih on Calligraphy," Harvard
p.
cang lidai fashu xuanji. vol. 3 Huang Bosi, Dongguan ynlim Zhu Yunming in which he foumal of Asiatic Studies 49,
(Beijing, 1982). (reprint, Taipei: Guoli discusses copying a range of no. 2 {December 1989), p. 372.
zhongyang tushuguan, 1974), Jin, Tang, Song, and Yuan
Fig. 6. After Gugong bowuyuan juan 1 , p. 46a b. calligraphers. See Mingshui Hung's entry
20.
cang lidai fashu xuanji, vol. 3 on Wang Duo in L. Carnngton
(Beijing, 1982). 5. The two scrolls are "Poems 13. Zhang Xu was celebrated as Goodrich, ed.. Dictionary of
Playtully Written and Presented one of the Eight Immortals of Ming Biography (New York and
Fig. 8. After Shodo zenshu, to My Friends, About to Wine in Du Fus poem London: Columbia University
vol. 2, pi. 118 (Tokyo, 1954 1961). Embark forTiao Stream," in "Yinzhong baxian ge," in Du Press, 1976), vol. 2, pp. 143436.
the collection of the Palace shi xiangzhu (Beijing:
Fig. a. After Tang Zhang Xu Museum, Beijing, and "Poems Zhonghua shuju, 1979), juan 2,
caoshu gushi sitic (Beijing, on Sichuan Silk," in the
Other
pp. 80-85. early sources
collection of the National
1962). on Zhang Xu include Zhu
Palace Museum, Taipei. See Changwen, Xu shu duan, juan
Gugong
Fig. 10. After Peter Sturman, Mi Fu: Style 1, in Chugoku shown taikei
CALLIGRAPHY
Calligraphy and
Painting The Essence
of a Civilization
Liu Jiu'an
Researcher, Palace Museum, Beiiin?
civilizations of world history, so too are Chinese plain, even awkward manner intended to signify
painting and calligraphy classic types among the their status as noble-minded amateurs. They claimed
world's art forms. to paint only for self-expression, "as a lodging for
[their] feelings" (Ni Zan), never at the behest of a
This exhibition features the works of thirty-seven patron or for the marketplace. Wang Meng's
painters and calligraphers, ranging from the middle Dwelling in the Qingbian Mountains (cat. 189) reveals
of the Northern Song dynasty in the mid-eleventh only to the closest inspection the dwelling of a
century through the middle of the late Qing recluse, to which the craggy, bristling mountain
dynasty in the eighteenth century. These seems to deny all access an emblem of the literati
outstanding works, selected from museums ideal of literally forsaking and spiritually
throughout mainland China, compose in microcosm transcending the mundane world. Ni Zan's Six
a history of the development of painting and Gentlemen (cat. 188) uses six trees, upright and
calligraphy during this period. For instance, Wang unbending, to allude to the austere integrity of the
Shen's Misty Riper and Layered Hills (cat. 184), the literati. Though the first painting teems with
Southern Song Snowy Landscape (cat. 186), and Zhao writhing forms and the second is almost minimalist,
Kui's In the Spirit of Poems by Du Fu (cat. 185), taken both of them slight pictorial description and
together, succincdy epitomize the rapid emphasize instead the quality of the brush stroke,
developments in landscape painting during the which was held to express the character of the
Northern and Southern Song dynasties. painter.
Misty Rii>er and Layered Hills invokes a vast From the mid-Ming period prosperous southeastern
panorama in the depiction of a single scene. Snout)* cities such as Suzhou and Songjiang in Jiangsu
Landscape uses instead the classic allusive technique tended to attract literati painters. These urban literati
of the renowned Southern Song landscape artist Ma transferred their love of nature and the bucolic life
Yuan (act. late I2th-early 13th c), suggesting the to their gardens and studios, which became favorite
immensity of the mountains by showing only their artistic subjects. Wen Zhengming's Studio of True
peaks and not their bases. The buildings have been Appreciation (cat. 197) depicted the study of Hua Xia
drawn not as architectural renderings but freehand, (b. ca. 1498), the most famous collector of his day.
without benefit of straightedge, and the dominant Shen Zhou, in Eastern Villa (cat. 196), abjured his
mood is one of quiet and solitude in a setting of usual broad brush strokes in favor of a meticulously
great beauty. Very few of Ma Yuan 's paintings have detailed picture of the garden residence of his
survived to the present, but this anonymous scroll literatus friend Wu Kuan (1435 1504). Likewise, Qiu
conveys some sense of them. The Qianlong emperor Ying's Playing the Flute by Pine and Stream (cat. 195)
of the Qing dynasty sought to express the essence expresses the literati pastoral ideal. From the mid-
of Zhao Kui's small painting of a bamboo grove Ming onward, the literati ideal dominated Chinese
(cat. 185) in the following couplet: culture and society, and the less rigorously austere
The tranquil lotus and verdant creek reject the court and among the mercantile class as well as
summer's heat, among the scholar-official elite.
unfurled in the little pavilion. From the outset Qing painting displayed a rich
This emperor's couplet alludes consciously to a (1598 1677), Wang Hui (1632 1717), and Wang
verse by the renowned Tang dynasty poet Du Fu: Yuanqi (1642 1715), collectively known as the "Four
Wangs" of Chinese art history, primarily carried on
The depths of the bamboo grove urge the the literati landscape traditions of the early Song
visitor to stay and Yuan dynasties. Artistic archaism paintings
And enjoy the coolness of the tranquil lotus. alluding to the styles of earlier masters became
fashionable at court and among the upper classes
Hence the title of the painting. To paraphrase the The literati style, revolutionary during the
generally.
great Song poet Su Dongpo: In the words of the Ming, became the new orthodoxy of Qing
poem we find the painting; in the lines of the painting, exemplified by the "Four Wangs"
painting we find the poem. This masterpiece of (especially the first three) and their epigones.
Chinese "poetic painting" is also the only known Contemporaneously, Bada Shanren, Shitao,
work by Zhao Kui. Hongren, and Kuncan, collectively known as the
"Four Monks" of art history, expressed their inner
During the Yuan dynasty paintings as pictures of turmoil at the fall of the Ming and triumph of the
things and paintings as cosmic metaphors began to non-Han Qing dynasty in powerfully individualistic
be displaced by literati paintings executed by works. Take, for instance, Ducks and Lotuses (cat. 210)
of the Ming imperial family. He used the splashed- freedom from the need to depict literally and
ink method to draw the lotus blossoms, and hooked completely. In Snowy Landscape, for example, only
brush strokes to depict the rocks in the pond, with the mountaintops are shown, while the bases are
just the slightest use of pale ink to limn the rocks. left to our imaginations, lending the landscape far
The Qing painterZheng Xie (1693-1765) inscribed greater monumentality than if the mountains had
on this painting, "Few ink drops, many teardrops," been shown in their entirety. The Chinese use of
alluding both to the drawing and to the artist's grief monochrome ink alone is a prime example of the
and anger over the loss of his country and family. penchant for allusion. Third is the creative leeway
given to subjectivity and expressiveness without
Distinct regional schools in abundance arose during ever abandoning description in favor of abstraction;
the Qing. Gong Xian (cat. 209), Zou Zhe this fusion of expression and objective description
(cat. 212), Gao Cen (cat. 214), and others who were is summed up in Bada Shanren's Ducks and Lotuses.
active around the Nanjing area were known as the Even calligraphy, which is wholly abstract, involves
Jinling school, while Gao Xiang (cat. 215), Yuan a complex process of "encompassing a million
Jiang (cat. 213), and others were active in the particularities and abstracting them into a single
Yangzhou area. Even artists working in the same image." The theory that calligraphy and painting
region and grouped into the same school show had a common divine origin, and that the two arts
distinctive characteristics. The style and method of have "different names but a common form," dates
painting of Yuan Jiang's Garden for Gazing clearly at least from the ninth century and has never been
differ from Gao Xiang's Finger-snap Pavilion.Tbis questioned since. That same theory has given rise to
wealth of expressiveness, the artistic hallmark of the "the three perfections" works in which poetry,
period, reflected the variety of artistic traditions calligraphy, and painting are integrated into one
available to painters during the Qing dynasty. totality, in which each form alludes to and
completes the others. Fourth is the insistence on
Elevating the writing of words into an art form was inner refinement
"freedom from vulgarity" of
an inspired development. The five pieces of the artists and of their works, for the simple reason
calligraphy exhibited here exemplify four principal that only a person of great understanding and
calligraphic scripts, namely, clerical, standard, cultivation could comprehend the preceding three
cursive, and wild cursive. Perhaps no other art form characteristics. Last is the honor paid to the
is as condensed and abbreviated as calligraphy, or as creation and even the collecting of paintings and
expressive of the artist. For instance, the Ming calligraphy, activities generally considered to denote
calligrapher Zhu Yunming, known as a free spirit persons of understanding, delicacy of perception,
and unbridled personality, was a master of all scripts and moral fastidiousness.
writing shows a firm and steady hand. Zhang stimulate our minds, and nurture our continuing
Zhao's scroll of the poem "Seventh Month" from growth.
the Odes of Bin (cat. 182) uses a dignified and
poised standard script that shows the influence of Translated, from the Chinese, by June Mei.
James Cahill
Professor Emeritus, History of Art,
University of California, Berkeley
The time is long past when Western
174
have instilled it firmly in the consciousness of both One might see these simply as misreadings: there is
academics and the larger community of art-lovers a large gap between the woodblock-printed
as ranking among the supreme artistic achievements painting manual cited by Gombrich and the
of any culture. And yet a curious belief about practice of serious later Chinese artists that he
Chinese painting persists that in its later phases it wrongly took it to represent; and there is an even
is essentially a performance art, within which the larger gap between Sherman Lee's unobjectionable
artist is reduced to making individual statement that further subtlety was unimaginable in
interpretations of long-established formulae. the later centuries in China (one could persuasively
argue that Gauguin does not represent any advance
Two examples can represent quite a few more. in subtlety over Giotto) and Danto's construing this
E. H. Gombrich, in his influential Art and Illusion, to mean that no further development took place. But
reproduces from a seventeenth-century Chinese it is less a misreading, I think, than a proclivity
manual for beginning painters a page of among Western scholars (even good ones)
instructions for painting orchids in ink, stroke by unfamiliar with Chinese painting: to believe a
stroke. This he takes to exemplify China's "complete version of its history in which innovation ended
reliance on acquired vocabularies," commenting about the fourteenth century and to take what they
that "there is nothing in Western art which see and read as evidence for that version.
compares with this conception of painting," which
he characterizes as a "combination of traditionalism What lies behind this inclination to see the later
and respect for the uniqueness of every centuries of Chinese painting as essentially
performance"' More recently, Arthur Danto, in repeating the earlier ones? In part, it is a carry-over
"Ming and Qing Paintings," misunderstands from the ill-informed belief of pioneer Western
Sherman Lee's opening statement in a catalogue writers on Chinese painting that its great creative
essay that by the beginning of the Ming dynasty period ended with the Song dynasty in the late
"the materials, formats, and techniques of painting thirteenth century, and that all beyond was
had developed in flexibility and complexity to a repetition and decline. No one seriously engaged
point where further subtlety was both with Chinese painting believes that now, but this
unimaginable and superfluous." 2 Danto takes Lee's attitude no doubt continues to resonate in the
statement to mean that, in Danto's words, "all the minds of people who have read the old books or
truths of Chinese painting were in place before that taken courses with the old teachers. Another
protracted [Ming-Qing] period began." And Danto, important reason is the inability of even sensitive
too, contrasts this reading of the Chinese situation observers to recognize stylistic distinctions,
with what happened during the same period in including large and crucial ones, within an
Western art: "Imagine, then, an exhibition which unfamiliar art, whether it be painting or music or
begins witli Giotto and ends with Gauguin." One poetry. I noted this often-encountered
scarcely could say ofWestern painting during that phenomenon at the beginning ot my book The
time, as Danto believes we can say of Ming and Compelling Image, recalling the experience ot taking
Qmg painting, that "everything was already in place a distinguished and recently arrived Chinese
at the beginning, further development of which connoisseur around the National Gallery in
[sic| was 'unimaginable and superfluous.'"' In Washington (yes, from Giotto to Gauguin and
support of his view, Danto cites observations by beyond) and being told: "Very nice, but they all
limitations not in the art but in the observer, who end of the history of art." This is not the place to
infers sameness from his own failure to perceive, or make that argument at length, nor am I the person
at least to properly evaluate, difference. Of course to make it; an unpublished book by James Elkins,
Chinese painting appears to have had no entitled "Chinese Landscape Painting as Object
development if the later ones appear no different Lesson" (1995) presents an interesting case for this
from the early ones. large and highly controversial proposal, in terms
with which I am generally in agreement. In any
Also accounting in some part for this phenomenon case, leaving aside particulars of argument, this is
is the insistence of many of the Chinese painters the direction in which any real understanding of
themselves, in inscriptions on their works, that they later Chinese painting's "failure to develop" must be
are "imitating" some old master: taken literally, such charted out. Instead of, in effect, writing off later
inscriptions would indeed attest to derivativeness. Chinese painting as attractive but more or less
But to accept such statements at face value would irrelevant to our own artistic concerns, we might
be equivalent to charging T. S. Eliot with being better look to it for ways out of what may seem
derivative because he claims in a certain passage to perilously like an end-game situation (Elkins s term,
be "imitating" Chaucer. When one looks beyond adopted from chess and Duchamp). A tradition that
the inscriptions to compare the paintings folds so insistently back on itself, that comes to be
themselves with their putative models, it is caught up in such a potentially paralyzing
immediately obvious that the old style is usually no engagement with its own past, obliges its artists to
more than a frame of reference, a jumping-off point devise stratagems for escaping repetition and
for formal explorations that can be as original as stagnation. An account of Ming and Qing
any in painting. All art, in some sense, imitates other painting a non-history, it might be called could
art; the Chinese have simply recognized and be constructed around the successive stratagems
institutionalized such derivation and made it more that were devised to this end, both by individual
self-conscious, more a matter of deliberate and masters and within particular movements and
sophisticated allusion than Western artists generally schools. Such an account would acknowledge some
have, at least until very recent times. of these stratagems to have been relatively
elements of truth that underlie the perceptions of brilliant transformations of older pictorial materials
repetitiveness. It is generally true (with exceptions, carried out by the Individualist masters of the
as always) that later Chinese artists were more open seventeenth century, as radical, even revolutionary.
in their reliance on established convention and
insisted less on direct observation of the world than Most of all, such an account would recognize that
Western artists of the same period usually did. One critical theorizing, in writings that are sophisticated
must quickly add, however, that the best of them and often contentious, affected the later practice of
accomplished such creative and even radical Chinese painting much as such theorizing has
manipulations of the conventions that, again, the affected the recent practice of painting in the West.
outcomes can scarcely be seen as any real loss of Many of the Ming and Qmg artists, along with
originality. It can also be argued that after the end their scholar-critic contemporaries, argued
of the Song dynasty in the late thirteenth century vehemently and interestingly tor this or that
no clear, unilinear development can be observed in position on what the artist should paint and how,
Chinese painting, in the sense of successive drawing their arguments from a diversity of
advances in representational techniques, or in grounds aesthetic, philosophical, moral, political,
pervasive stylistic shifts like those defined by the old economic. In both traditions, the artists themselves
art historians for European painting from might talk themselves into corners. But proponents
Medieval to early to high to late Renaissance, of established ideologies could also make
Baroque to Rococo to Romantic to Modern. moralizing judgments Confucian or Marxist or
other proclaiming certain kinds of painting to be
But granting this need not carry any implication low-class or inauthentic or otherwise unacceptable,
that Chinese painting ceased to be innovative. It thus effectively shutting off broad ranges of options
might, alternatively, be argued that the great global that artists might otherwise have found viable and
shifts took place earlier in China that their fruitful. Or, if they did not manage to shut them off
equivalent of the Giotto-to-Gauguin phase completely, at least they made them difficult and
happened between the Tang and Yuan dynasties unrewarding to pursue, so that those who pursued
(i.e., between the eighth and fourteenth them risked, and usually incurred, critical
centuries) and ended sooner, so that the Chinese condemnation. No artistic dilemma could resonate
aesthetic grounds, unconcerned with the broader capacity to arouse the feelings and responses that
issues of their time; but they surely had their own the depicted thing would arouse if seen in reality.
agendas, as their writings sometimes indicate, which Portraits, for example, captured salient qualities of
did not necessarily correspond with the established the sitter and presented them to the viewer, thus
systems that sought to control them and usually did. taking on the Confucian function of preserving for
Counterforces to the coercion of the literati critics contemplation models of moral worth or depravity.
were few and mostly weak. The painting could fool the viewer into confusing
it with the real thing: a picture of a beautiful
Two opposing forces, one aimed at narrowing woman would be mistaken for the person, a
options for artists and so inducing them to paint in painting offish hung on the riverbank would attract
the "right" way, the other at broadening again the otters to leap at it. For this criterion of excellence, a
spectrum of acceptable styles or breaking the high degree of verisimilitude and even "magic
boundaries altogether, are represented by the two realism" are obviously appropriate. But these naive
major writers on painting in the late Ming and views (as we would see them) were supplanted
early Qing: Dong Qichang (1555 1636) and Shitao relatively early by recognition of the evocative
(1642- 1 707). The two can be seen also as arguing in powers of paintings that transcended simple
opposite directions about what was for both of representation and required of the artist more than
them the central dilemma: how to stand up, as descriptive techniques. Brief essays by Zong Bing
creative and highly original artists, against the nearly (375-443) and Wang Wei (415-443) already credit
overpowering weight of the past. They establish landscape painting with the power to present
themselves as the most powerful proponents of two expansive and absorbing vistas to the entranced
different ways out. viewer, who can enjoy vicariously, through the
artist's subtle understanding and technical skill,
Dong's way was to reduce and absorb the past by journeys among mountains and rivers that refresh
to be appropriate for the practice of a cultivated that way, however, were preceded by centuries of
literatus-amateur like himself. He then "imitated" simpler landscape representation, a formative stage
the models in this established canon so freely that that can be traced in designs on bronze vessels and
the old styles virtually vanished under his hand, other objects, including several in this exhibition.
transmuted into new structures within which the An Eastern Han (25220 Ce) gilt-bronze vessel with
old are scarcely recognizable. Shitao s way out, based hills and animals (cat. 51) represents hilltops and
on a desperate recognition of the advanced state of clouds in the simplest schematic forms. By contrast,
conventionalization into which much of the art had on an inlaid bronze chariot fitting (cat. 49) the hills
descended, was to reject the past entirely and start on which the animals scamper are drawn in
over, as if situated at the first dawn of painting. intricate linear arabesques derived from earlier
That, at least, would be his claim and the ideal dragon forms, a metamorphic process common in
toward which he would strive in some of his late early Chinese art. Simple, overlapping triangular
and more extreme works. It was a magnificent but peaks make up a schematic landscape (a "magic
ultimately unrealizable attempt painters can no mountain") to which trees and animals and figures
more return to a state of pristine simplicity than are added in the splendid gilded bronze incense
anyone else and incapable of pointing a clear burner from the tomb of Prince Liu Sheng
direction out of their common predicament for (cat. 50). The landscape scenes on a late Han relict
artists who followed. Dong Qichang's direction, tile from Sichuan Province (cat. 103) achieve
carried on in ever more exclusionary ways by the remarkable (for that time) integrations of the
Orthodox landscape masters who claimed to be his pictorial materials in space, and some transcending
legitimate successors, was to prove more influential, of schematic forms, but the achievement was not
but its authority was sapped by the quick followed up, at least on extant objects. Three
debilitation of that landscape tradition. centuries later, for instance, the landscape settings
proposal outlined above, will accommodate it, as compartmentalize the composition into "space
conventional histories that attempt broad cells" within which the figures and other narrative
characterizations of the "period styles" of the elements are placed.
successive periods cannot.
copies of them, seem designed to fulfill the aims set acquired the capacity to embody metaphysical
forth in the texts. They typically offer densely filled concepts in forms and so convey them to its
scenes of mountains and rivers within which viewers. The rise of monumental landscape
travelers, mounted or on foot, move among trees; paralleled, not coincidentally, the great age of Neo-
cross bridges; pass by rustic residences and temples. Confucian philosophy, which similarly attributes a
The compositions may recede to high horizons, coherence and order to natural phenomena. It
demonstrating the painter's ability to carry the corresponded also to the ascendancy of expressive
viewer's gaze into depth. The individual entities that theories of painting: Mi Fu (1052-1107/8) wrote
make up these pictures, especially those of the Tang that landscape "is a creation of the mind and is
dynasty (618-906), are typically drawn in fine intrinsically a superior art" superior, that is, to
outline and colored with mineral pigments. This pictures of animals or human figures, which
analytical outline-and-color mode, characteristic of could, in his view, be done by simply copying
early Chinese painting, encourages the viewer to their appearances. These are, to be sure, Chinese
read the picture part by part while moving over its formulations; our own account of the rise
(9601127) periods that followed the collapse of the was the development by tenth- and eleventh-
Tang, this archaic mode was seen as charming but century artists of representational techniques that
unsuited to new directions in landscape painting, opened the way to all these achievements.
which in these centuries was rising to displace Specialists in portraying birds and animals were
figural subjects as the central concern of leading creating systems of patiently repeated brush strokes
artists and critics. Landscapes in the new manner for natural-looking renditions of plumage and fur,
are dominated by earth masses rendered in broader, while painters of interior scenes with figures were
scumbled brush strokes of monochrome ink, working out spatial schemes as intricately readable
strongly varied in tone, which shape the forms with as any that Chinese artists would ever attempt. Early
light and shadow while also rendering the tactile Song landscapists would refine the device of
qualities of their pitted surfaces. Indications of atmospheric perspective so as to create breathtaking
human presence buildings, figures, bridges are effects of height and deep space, within which
diminished in size and visually integrated into the strongly volumetric forms were shaped and
landscape setting, so that they no longer command geologically differentiated with new texture-stroke
the viewer's attention. Beside the attractive systems. We are, that is to say, at that apogee, or roll-
artificialities of the archaic landscape mode, this off point, arrived at by the Chinese relatively early
new manner can be seen (admittedly, in terms in the collective mastery of representational
unacceptable to "new art history" practitioners) as a techniques that allowed them to create, when they
great leap forward in naturalism in its power to wished, paintings that could be read as close and
engage the beholder's vision with forms that read as convincing likenesses of the persons, things, or
truer to one's experience of the physical world and scenes portrayed.
as all but palpable. It was exactly the development
new manner, combining refinements of
of this No painting could better exemplify this observation
monochrome ink tonality for effects of light and than the astonishing Bamboo, Old Tree, and Stones in
shade with systems of overlaid brushwork to Winter (fig. 1), attributed to a tenth-century master
differentiate textures, that opened the way to the named Xu Xi but in truth an anonymous work of
towering achievements of monumental landscape in the late tenth or early eleventh century. The subject
the Five Dynasties and Northern Song periods. carries a metaphorical meaning of survival and
integrity under harsh conditions, but we know this
The supplanting of figural themes, including only from external literary evidence: nothing in the
narrative, historical, and religious, by landscape at picture itself suggests that it is other than a
such an early period distinguishes the Chinese meticulously detailed, objective portrayal of a
tradition of painting from all others, prompting us passage of nature. The unknown artist, who has not
to ask what conditions and objectives underlay this signed his name but has inscribed "This bamboo is
crucial change. It is another question too large to worth more than a hundred pieces of gold" in tiny
address here, except to say that in the hands of a archaic characters (upside down! on a bamboo
succession of great masters, Chinese landscape stalk) has concealed his hand throughout, using
painting not only developed to a sublime point its virtually no outlining or other conspicuous brush
function of "making the viewer feel as though he strokes, creating the image as if entirely out of light
were in the very place," thus allowing it to serve as and dark, making the picture seem more a work of
spiritual refreshment for people who could not nature than a product of human artifice. In truth,
Fig. 1 . Anonymous (attrib. Xu Xi, 10th c). of the artist's mind; Su Shi (1037 iioi), the central
Bamboo, Old Tree, and Stones in Winter. figure in the movement, wrote in a poem that "If
Late 10th or early nth c. Shanghai Museum. someone talks of painting as formal likeness/ His
way of looking is like a child's."
the technical achievement it displays is nothing About the same time that these scholar-amateurs,
short of amazing. Some technique of reserve was some of whom held official posts in the
probably used for the light-against-dark passages; government, were working out their new styles and
but how the subtle shifts from these to dark- genres so as to separate themselves clearly from the
against-light were accomplished is not easy to professional tradition, another group of semi-
reconstruct. Like other moves toward realism in amateur artists were taking a somewhat different
Chinese painting, this one is abortive and produced course, aimed at endowing their paintings both
no following; it was suppressed, presumably, by a with poetic content and with a cultivated kind of
critical dogma that condemned the pursuit of archaism through allusions to early styles. This
verisimilitude, or "form-likeness," as an unworthy group might be called aristocrat-amateurs, since
objective for painting. The work has come down to they were associated with the court and imperial
modern times unrecorded and unnoticed by critics, family; their socially and economically privileged
with none of the collectors' seals and adulatory positions gave them access to old masterworks, and
inscriptions that embellish old paintings of more their "quoting" of these in their own paintings
prestigious kinds. credited their viewers with a correspondingly
"How many centuries must one wait for anything an emperor, friend of Su Shi. and himseli a
comparable 111 the West?" In descriptive painting distinguished connoisseur and collector, began
techniques as in technology, the Chinese far painting landscape during a period of political
outstripped the West in early centuries, then />)' banishment from the capital his works have been
choice largely turned away from that mode to pursue read (bv Richard Barnhart, who has written most
other directions, while Western artists took up interestingly about him) as landscapes ot exile." As a
(more or less) the descriptive vein the Chinese had style-conscious amateur, he could choose among
abandoned. This understanding of the matter will stvles with a freedom normally denied the full-
great court-academy contemporary Guo Xi for one An unsigned Snowy Landscape (cat. 186) is not
painting, reviving the old outline-and-color mode attributed to him but is closely in his style and may
from the Tang for another. Misty River belongs to well be from his hand. Whatever its authorship, it
the latter style, using green mineral pigment within belongs to a mode of poetic terseness that became
decoratively repeated outlines. Unrolling the scroll popular in the late Song. The scenery is simple: a
from right to left, one traverses a long stretch of traveler with his servant carrying the luggage
empty silk that stands for water and that renders the approaches a Buddhist temple in a ravine. Dark
farther shore of cloud-veiled hills, when it mists capture the wintry mood; earth banks and
eventually appears, even more remote. The picture hilltops recede in clear stages, the nearer ones given
echoes, presumably by intent, paradise or isles-of- volume, the farthest in simple silhouette. With all
immortals imagery in which the green and blue technical problems of creating effects of space and
colors represent jade and chalcedony. The flattening atmosphere long solved, insofar as China was ever
and decorative richness that can be seen as to address them, the artist could work in a broad,
genuinely archaic in early works (or close copies sparse manner, reducing the pictorial materials as a
after them) are here elements in an archaistic mode poet might evoke an extensive scene in a couplet.
consciously adopted for the cultural values it Art-historical hindsight allows us to see this as an
Lingrang (also called Zhao Danian; act. ca. 1070- poetic imagery is the woodblock-printed book
ca. 1 100), who did bucolic scenes of thatched Meihua xishen pit ("Album of Plum Blossom
houses on the riverside which evoked the ideal of Portraits") by Song Boren. First printed in 1238, it
escaping the sordor of the city for a simple life in survives in a single copy of a 1261 reprint and has
the (morally and physically) purer air of the been called the world's first known printed art
countryside (as none of these artists could do in book (cat. 187). In text and pictures it presents one
reality); and Zhao Ji, the emperor Huizong hundred aspects, or "moods," of blossoming plum
(r. 1100 1126), who painted bird-and-flower branches, each comprising a poetic title, a simple
subjects and was especially taken with the ideal of pictorial image, and a quatrain (four five-character
making paintings that embodied poetic concepts, lines) arranged on a single page with an elegance
enforcing it on the artists who served in his that is astonishing: the book appears to be the
academy. The late Song painter Zhao Km earliest attempt at anything of the kind, in China or
(1185-1266) did not belong to the imperial family elsewhere. A craze for blossoming plum had swept
but held a high ministerial post. The handscroll China in the Southern Song, producing thousands
titled In the Spirit of Poems by Du Fu (cat. 185) of poems and paintings that celebrate its pure and
originally bore his signature, according to a fragile beauty. A range of meanings, including the
colophon by a slightly later writer, but the signature erotic and the political, had come to be attached to
has been lost, probably in remounting. The painting the theme (as explored in Maggie Bickford's recent
echoes a couplet from a poem by the great poet Du book Ink Plum). 7 Song Boren's poems are full of
Fu (712-770): "The depths of the bamboo grove allusions to the plight of his country the Mongols
urge the visitor to stay/ And enjoy the cool of the had already conquered the north, and the Song was
tranquil lotus." Unrolling the scroll, we are taken soon to fall and admonishments to strength and
through groves ot bamboo by a stream and glimpse loyalty, themes that the various stages of the
the top of a thatched kiosk hidden among them, blossoming plum are made, somewhat forcedly, to
then two servants bringing donkeys along a path, symbolize.
and finally, toward the end, a man who sits in a
for some years. the Mongol dynasty in China, which they named
the Yuan. Although Mongol rule was to last less
The ideal of poetic painting advocated by Emperor than a century (1279-1368), it was a traumatic time
Huizong continued to pervade the output of the for the Chinese: never before had their entire
imperial painting academy in the Southern Song, or territory been under the control of one of the
late Song, where masters of transcending technique northern nomadic peoples whom the Han Chinese
and sensitivity created works that are among the had traditionally regarded as "barbarians." In the
glories of Chinese painting. One of the greatest of early Yuan period the civil-service examinations
a * *
ai Sit
: rr i
5* a -i
.'
ft*
4ft
J
J a
were abolished, and although Khubilai Khan sought Fig. 2. Zhao Mengfu (12541322). Villa by the Water.
to surround himself with traditionally educated Dated to 1302, Yuan dynasty (i2jg-i36S). Handscroll,
Chinese advisers, many such scholars who would ink on paper; 24. g x 120.5 cm. Palace Museum, Beijing.
scholar-amateur, movement in painting, inaugurated and simpler than any of DongYuan's, with
in the eleventh century but eclipsed during the minimal detail absorbed into the fabric of
later Song by the brilliant achievements of the brushwork to the point of being barely discernible.
professional and Academy masters, came to the fore It is executed in brush strokes that reject everything
during the Yuan and maintained its primacy during gestural and overtly expressive; the ink is rubbed on
most of the later centuries. dry to catch the slight nap of the paper, for an
last on a list of criteria forjudging paintings; what fully expanded in the late Yuan, especially in the
was to be esteemed, he wrote, was "plays with works of two artists who are often paired in a
brush and ink in which lofty-minded men and relationship more of contrast than of similarity:
superior scholars have lodged their exhilaration Ni Zan (i306[?]-i374) and Wang Meng
[intense feeling] and sketched their ideas." The (ca. 1308 1385). Ni Zan spent his early years as a
move from painting as pictorial description of rich, cultivated youth who collected antiques,
appearances to painting as an expressive art entertained a rigorously selected group of friends
concerned with its own conventions and its own (he was neurotically cleanly, washing his hands
past, the very shift that in the West (according to frequently and shunning anyone he considered
one common view) marks the beginnings of "vulgar"), and practiced poetry, calligraphy, and
modernism, thus happened at least half a painting. When he was in his thirties, however, the
millennium earlier in China. burden of taxes and the depredations of local
uprisings drove him to disperse the family property
A central figure in the creation of new literati styles and take up a wandering life. He traveled about by
in landscape painting during the early Yuan was small boat, staying with friends and patrons,
Zhao Mengfu (1254-1322). Although a descendant repaying their hospitality with his paintings, which
of the Song imperial house, he did not adopt the were increasingly in demand by the time of his
stance of a Song loyalist, but accepted high posts in death, we read, the ownership of a Ni Zan was a
the Mongol administration under Khubilai Khan mark of elevated cultural status for families in the
and had a distinguished official career. As a painter region. In his hands the sparse, dry-brush manner.
he rejected, like most others in his time, what he with its effect of visual disengagement, became a
saw as the polish and overt appeal of Song painting, metaphor for emotional alienation from what he
choosing instead to revive styles from the more saw as a contaminated world. His Six Gentlemen of
distant past, especially the Tang and Five Dynasties 1345 (cat. iSS). done for one of his hosts, presents
periods. His Villa by the Water of 1302 (fig. 2), his typical river scene with widely separated
painted for a friend whose retreat bore that name, is banks a compositional device itself expressive ot
for Chinese connoisseurs "in the style of" the distance and loneliness with six exiguous trees in
tenth-century landscapist Dong Yuan, whose the foreground "representing" the six men present
deliberately plain scenery and lulling repetitions at the gathering. This way ot endowing the barest
later periods.
Ni Zan's younger contemporary Wang Meng was under orders or on commission, for a diversity of
the grandson of Zhao Mengfu and grew up with a uses auspicious, decorative, seasonal besides
familiarity with old painting that informs his own doing pictures that carried political meanings for
works. Rejecting the reclusiveness of Ni Zan and presentation and hanging on special occasions such
others, he followed the family tradition of official as the appointment and retirement of court
service, holding a minor post in the 1340s and officials. A competence in portraiture was normally
another after the founding of the Ming dynasty, required of these versatile artists, even when their
densely packed and tactilely rich, can be read as the West are called history pictures, is credited with
emblematic of engagement and thus as representing a huge painting (over 2 x 3.5 m.), which may have
a stance opposed to that of Ni Zan. The highly been mounted originally on a screen, representing
activated forms that make up Wang Meng's best Emperor Xuanzong and members of his court
pictures create powerful tensions, even turbulence, setting off on a hunt (cat. 190). The emperor, seen
which undermine the original implications of at the top, is the largest figure, as longstanding
stability and coherence carried by the Song convention dictated; the principal figures among
monumental landscapes on which they are distantly the mounted party in the foreground are given
based. Such a calculated, expressionist distortion of portrait-like faces and must represent particular
an established type, intended to subvert its normal people. We can assume that their inclusion in the
associations, seems, again, a very modern stratagem. picture, and their positions within it, reflected their
cousin Zhao Lin and represents the Zhao family Another group portrait by a court master, this one
s
retreat at that place. Depictions ot secluded villas in handscroll form and more modest in size, is Tlie
were a specialty ofYuan literati artists, who Literary Gathering in the Apricot Garden, an event that
ordinarily portrayed them as securely sequestered took place in 1437 and was depicted by Xie Huan
from the outside world. Wang subverts this type (act. 1426 1452) (cat. 191). Xie had a long and
too, by confounding the viewer's attempt to read successful career in the Academy, attaining great
his picture as made up of coherent geological forms favor with the emperor, with whom he is said to
and spaces, and by instilling a powerful restlessness have played chess every day. His status, and the
through nervous, constantly shifting brushwork and place in society that a painter might attain by his
an unnaturalistic play of light and shadow. The time, is indicated by his including himself in the
insecurity was real: the two principal contenders for picture at the beginning of the scroll, to be sure,
the succession to Mongol rule were battling nearby farthest out from the garden that is its climactic
at just this time; one of them, Zhu Yuanzhang, scene, but still there. The central figures are the
would become, two years later, the first emperor of Three Yangs, members of the Grand Secretariat and
the Ming dynasty. the emperor's most trusted advisers. They have
invited high-ranking friends for a day of
EARLY AND MIDDLE MING PAINTING: banqueting and drinking, appreciating antiquities,
In the early Ming dynasty painters were called to the sizes, poses, and positioning of the figures
court and assigned projects, as they had been in the establish a clear hierarchy among them. Another,
Song. By the Xuande reign (1426 1435) of the shorter version of the picture is in the Metropolitan
emperor Xuanzong, a conscious attempt was Museum ot Art; it may be that the composition was
underway to revive the Southern Song Painting loosely replicated by lesser Academy masters for
Academy, employing court artists who basically presentation to participants in the event.
continued the Song styles. Literati, or scholar-
amateur, artists of the early Ming continued late Both these paintings were executed in the Song-
Yuan literati styles in a similarly conservative way; derived, traditional manner of the early Ming
the first century or so of the Ming might thus seem Academy; neither artist allowed his personal style,
to support the idea of a stagnation in later Chinese or "handwriting," to intrude. The first significant
painting. But the lull was not to last beyond the break with that practice was accomplished by Dai
middle and later fifteenth century, when both Jin (1388 1462), who served in the Academy, if at
works, large landscape hanging scrolls on silk, are spontaneous manner of execution seen in his
still relatively traditional in subject and paintings was taken to be a stylistic counterpart. His
composition, but are made up of massive, strongly subjects and compositions are in themselves
contoured earth forms. The brush drawing is less relatively conservative: Fishermen on a Snowy River
constrained than before by its bounding and (cat. 193), for instance, with a landmass on one side
texturing function, more expressive of nervous and a receding river on the other, follows a very
energy in the artist's hand. This stylistic move is not old pattern. In the eyes of the audiences for whom
only another assertion of the rising status of Wu Wei worked, fishermen represented an ideal of
painters, including professionals, but also an escape from the pressures and spiritual
incursion into the territory of the scholar- contamination of city and court.
amateurs who would, however, have been quick
to point out that Dai Jin's brushwork-oriented By the end of the fifteenth century the great city
paintings were still very different from theirs, less of Suzhou, which had been a gathering place for
subtle, as befitting the work of a professional. artists and poets in the late Yuan period but had
declined under persecution by the first Ming
An untypical, very fine work by Dai Jin is the small emperor, was recovering its cultural preeminence,
picture on paper now titled, somewhat which it would retain for about a century. Besides
misleadingly, Landscape in the Manner of Yan Wengui being the principal locus for the revival of literati
(cat. 192). The association with this tenth- to painting, it offered the most attractive patronage to
eleventh-century landscapist comes from the professional artists, who could benefit also from the
inscription written on it by Dong Qichang great collections of old paintings to be seen there.
(1555-1636), leading spokesman for the literati Among these professionals, three stand out: Zhou
position, who was, we can imagine, shown the Chen (ca. 1455 after 1536) and two who learned
work and invited to inscribe it by some collector. from him QiuYing (ca. 1495 1552) and Tang Yin
Dong, to whom Dai Jin's typical work must have (1470-1523). Zhou and Qiu are represented in this
seemed heavy-handed and overcharged, could exhibition by excellent paintings that display the
scarcely praise a painting without identifying in it conservative side of their output; judged by these,
the kind of style-conscious allusions to old masters they might seem to substantiate, once more, the
that he and other literati artists practiced idea that little had changed since the Song dynasty.
themselves; he felt obliged to find such allusions,
however forcedly, in Dai's work. The words of The subject of Zhou Chen's Peach Blossom Spring
heavily qualified, even evasive praise that Dong (cat. 194), which he painted in 1533, was a favorite
wrote on it reveal the uneasy relationship between among Suzhou and other big-city audiences, since
artists occupying different socioeconomic positions it was another image of escape from the "dusty
in Ming China: "Among the professional painters world." In the famous account by Tao Qian
of our dynasty, Dai Jin is considered a great master. (365427), a fisherman discovers a hidden elysium
This picture follows Yan Wengui's style, and is pure (the origin of the Shangri-la story) where refugees
and empty, not at all like [Dai's] everyday work in from an oppressive ruler had lived tor centuries
character it is highly unusual." Although the shape without aging. The fisherman returns to his town,
of the highest peak and a few other features may and a search party is sent to find this blessed place;
relate distantly to Yan Wengui, Dai's painting is not needless to say, they never do. The compartment-
style-conscious at all, but is a sensitive, painterly alized composition of Zhou's painting follows this
evocation of a misty scene centered on the narrative in its structure: passage from the
thatched retirement house of the man for whom it foreground, the outside world, to the elysium is
was done, identified in Dai's own inscription as through a cave; beyond, in the sequestered space,
"Old Teacher Yongyan." the fisherman is seen being greeted by the village
elders. The picture is executed in brushwork that
The "school" or movement that Dai Jin is credited conceals the hand of the artist, answering the
with founding was later named, after his birthplace continuing fondness of the Suzhou patrons for
in Zhejiang Province, the Zhe school. Among the Song-styic painting preference tor the styles of
artists who succeeded him in what is now called the Yuan literati masters had yet to become the
the Zhe school and who served in the Imperial dominant critical taste.
from the thatched house seen behind. The so that the attribution (first made in a colophon
melancholy sound of the flute merging with the dated to 1611 by Dong Qichang) is not absolutely
splash of water and wind in the pine is evoked as a secure; this might be an exceptionally tine work in
familiar metaphor for harmony with nature. The Shen's style by a follower. In any case, it exemplifies
spaces opening back successively beyond the flute the flattening and abstracting direction that literati
player serve as sounding chambers for these painting was taking in this period, notably in Shen
imagined sounds and are accomplished with Song- Zhou's own hands.
like gradations of tonal values. Other works by
Zhou Chen and Qiu Ying would bring out better That direction can be seen also in the works of
their individual styles and innovations; these reveal Shen Zhou's principal follower Wen Zhengming
them as heirs to a great tradition, who could still (1470-1559), who came from a Suzhou gentry
practice it on a high level. family, had a brief period of official service in the
capital, and in principle painted as an amateur artist
The literati, or scholar-amateur, movement in and "retired scholar" without thought of profit. In
painting, which had been concentrated in the reality, he, Shen Zhou, and the others engaged in an
Suzhou region in the late Yuan, had received a intricate pattern of exchanges of goods, services,
serious setback with the persecution of that city and favors through which they derived substantial
and its cultural elite by the first Ming emperor. Its "incomes" from their painting. Works such as Wen
real comeback, leaving aside a few secondary Zhengming's Studio of True Appreciation, painted in
masters active during the first century of the Ming 1549 (cat. 197), were usually done at the request of
who bridged the hiatus without ending it, was the owner of a house or villa and portrayed him in
accomplished by Shen Zhou (1427 1509). Born it, receiving visitors, surrounded by the trappings of
into a gentry family with land holdings, he was able high culture and taste, including in this case the
to live comfortably without attempting an official huge, fantastically eroded Taihu rocks brought from
career, and devoted much of his leisure to literary a nearby lake shore to be set up like natural
and artistic pursuits. His status also relieved him of sculptures in gardens. To have one's dwelling
the need to master high-level representational depicted by an artist of Wen's status and renown, in
techniques as a painter; he developed instead an his cool, disciplined, irreproachably upper-class
amiable and ingenuous personal style in which style, invested it with an aura of literati elegance.
forms, simply textured and bounded by thick brush
line, are made up into inventive compositions that The art of Shen Zhou and Wen Zhengming is
read basically as strong, flat designs. In contrast to highly style-conscious and self-reflective, deeply
the escape-and-reclusion themes of so much of the occupied with its past. Both artists sometimes
output of the Zhe school and other professional painted landscapes in the manners of the Yuan
masters, paintings by Shen Zhou and the Suzhou masters Ni Zan and Wang Meng, among others.
amateur artists who follow him typically take as The cautious moves into abstraction in their works
their subjects the local scenery, occasions such as were in part expressions of disdain for the "form-
outings and gatherings and farewells, the villas and likeness," or verisimilitude, toward which less
gardens of friends idealized versions, that is, of the cultivated artists were assumed to aspire; they must
here-and-now of their real lives. The Eastern Villa have impressed art-lovers of their time as strikingly
album (cat. 196) depicts scenes on the estate of original and "modern." To later Chinese
without quite realizing them occupying art- Handscroll, ink on paper; 30 x 1,053.5 an.
radical, might be seen as repeating themselves. section representing grapevines in his great
and Wang Meng. A corollary of this idea, popular in established literati disciplines of brushwork and
China as in the West (the "van Gogh's ear" notion), form. At the same time, however, he creates here a
was that eccentricity or even aberration in the moving evocation of what one might see in the
painter produced corresponding oddities in the corner of one's garden on a foggy morning. In all
picture. Audiences for artists identified as "mad," their moves to the very edge of abstraction,
then, expected some evidence of "madness" in the Chinese artists never renounced representation
paintings, and the artists responded. Those such as completely, presumably because doing so deprives
Wu Wei (cat. 193), who cultivated eccentricities of the artist of the power to create visually arresting
behavior and matched them with wild brushwork effects through tensions between image and
in their paintings, should be distinguished from abstraction.
playwright, calligrapher, and painter, exhibiting would-be official who failed the examinations
brilliance in all three pursuits. His emotional repeatedly, settling finally and reluctantly into the
disorder sometimes took violent forms: he role of professional painter. Both his level of
mutilated himself while in prison, and in a drunken cultivation and his bitterness can be read in his
fit beat his second wife to death, narrowly escaping paintings. I he nonconformity of his works,
execution for this. Xu Wei's favorite subjects as a however, is not manifested in bold, gestural brush
painter have no implications of violence, however; strokes; Chen paints mostly in the old manner ot
he painted plants, including fruits and flowers. fastidious fine-line drawing with washes of color.
cultivated archaisms of style that can turn quirky or much less the narrative or human-interest themes
even bizarre. His figures are often drawn in a pre- of other artists' works. Stylistically, he moved,
Tang mode, with elongated faces and flattened moreover, in a profoundly antinaturalistic direction.
drapery drawing that implies no articulated body "For splendid scenery," he wrote, "painting cannot
beneath it. equal the real landscape; but for marvels of brush
and ink, real landscape is not at all the equal of
In Chen Hongshou's handscroll Tlie Pleasures of He painting." He advocated a kind of free "imitation"
Tianzhang (cat. 199), done in collaboration with his of old styles ( fang), in which the canonical old
studio assistant Yan Zhan and a portrait specialist masters are evoked in ways that reveal the artists
named Li Wansheng (who painted the man's face, familiarity with them, at no real compromise to his
using the new illusionism derived from contacts originality; good analogies might be to Stravinsky
with European pictures), three levels of "reality" and in music or Ezra Pound in poetry. All three assume
artifice are clearly distinguished. He Tianzhang, a knowing viewer-listener-reader whose experience
seated at a stone table surrounded by the trappings of the work will include recognition of the learned
of high culture, is a "real person" looking allusions embedded in it.
banana leaf and holding an upright fan, occupies a "represents" a mountain near Nanjing, with its
lovely attribute of his than as an individual person. stark, diagrammatic exposition of Dong's
Such refinements of style and plays on understanding of old paintings (it invokes, among
representation bespeak both a highly sophisticated others, the monumental landscape type from the
audience and an art that can scarcely present its tenth and eleventh centuries); and as a near-abstract
imagery any longer in a straightforward way. construction within which dynamic forms interact
for powerfuDy unsettling effect. And this last
Chen Hongshou is the author of an essay reading, if one chooses, can be further linked to the
castigating both the professional masters, for not political situation of the late Ming by seeing the
looking far enough into the past in their search for picture as a consciously subversive distortion of
models, and the literati-amateurs, for using their an old type, a deliberate misreading of the
social position to claim lofty achievements in art monumental landscape in which established
beyond their real merits. 9 It is true enough that by implications of stability and order are denied, as
the late Ming period, a great many amateur artists Wang Meng (cf. cat. 189) had denied them three
of small technical prowess were engaging in a centuries earlier.
repetitive production of conventional river
landscapes and the like. One great master, however, When the achievements of Xu Wei, Chen
rescued the whole scholar-amateur tradition from Hongshou, and Dong Qichang, along with other
its doldrums: Dong Qichang. late Ming masters not represented here (notably,
Wu Bin), are set against Gombrich's "performance"
Dong Qichang (1555 1636) could be seen as a foil art, Danto's "further development unimaginable,"
to Chen Hongshou in almost all respects. He took and Fry's "atrophy of the creative spirit," these
high honors in the official examinations and held Western assessments of later Chinese painting fall,
several positions at court, including that of tutor to I think, into true perspective. And the great early
the heir apparent. During his long periods out of Qing Individualist masters are still to come.
service he lived as a rich landholder in Songjiang,
in Jiangsu Province. His paintings, writings, and The late Ming was also the peak period of pictorial
expertise as a connoisseur were constantly in woodblock printing, seeing notable advances in the
demand and were always, we can assume, suitably quality of block-cutting, refinements of design, and
recompensed. He was the most respected and the introduction of new techniques for color
influential painting theorist of his time, devising a printing. Major artists, including Chen Hongshou,
grand formulation in which the history of painting produced designs for printed illustrations. In a few
was divided into two "schools," the "southern" and of the pictures in the 1606 Cheng shi mo yuan
"northern" the former corresponding loosely ("Cheng Family Garden of Ink"), the linear designs
with the literati tradition, the latter with the were printed in color through the simple device,
professional and academy masters. As a painter, called yitao ("single block"), of putting pigments on
Dong limited himself almost exclusively to "pure" different areas of the single woodblock in place of
and rubbed with a burin, permitted subtle effects of creative manipulations of old compositions inspired
shading by applying the pigments unevenly or by the Individualist masters of the early Qing period
wiping the block after applying them. No two to attempt similarly radical feats of transforming
impressions, then, are quite identical. selected materials from their heritage while
seeming to embrace them. In the other, Dong's
This process was superbly utilized in two works authoritative pronouncements on the "right" way
published in Nanjing by Hu Zhengyan.The to paint, and the possibility of deriving a consistent
Shizhuzhai shuhuapu ("Ten Bamboo Studio Manual set of compositional techniques, brushwork
of Calligraphy and Painting") (cat. 201), completed conventions, and type-forms from his more routine
in 1627 and issued in eight volumes between then works, encouraged the emergence of an orthodoxy.
and 1633, reproduces paintings of flowers-and-birds, Such an orthodoxy took shape, in fact, in the
bamboo and blossoming plum, garden stones, and paintings and writings of the so-called Four Wangs
other subjects by a number of artists. It can be of the Ming-Qing transition Wang Shimin
admired both as the finest reproductions of (1592 1680), Wangjian (i598-i677),Wang Hui
paintings made anywhere up to that time, and (1632-1717), and Wang Yuanqi along (1642-1715)
simply as color printing of a technical and aesthetic with Wu Li (1632-1718) andYun Shouping
refinement similarly unmatched elsewhere. The (1633 1690), who have collectively come to be
Shizhuzhai qianpu ("Ten Bamboo Studio Letter called the Six Orthodox Masters. Their following,
Papers"), issued in four volumes by the same in turn, has continued down to the present,
publisher in 1644 (cat. 202), added a further although significant contributions to the style
technical innovation: in addition to the designs in declined precipitously after their time. An
ink and colors, "blind blocks" were used to impress appreciation of Orthodox school landscape, and the
low-relief patterns into the paper, a process called ability to discriminate between the different hands
gauffrage. It is hard to believe that these papers can engaged in it, has remained the very hallmark of
really have been intended for use, with letters or traditional connoisseurship in Chinese painting.
poems written (in elegant calligraphy, to be sure) Whole exhibitions, symposia, and book-length
over their exquisite designs. Happily, examples that studies have been devoted to the Orthodox school,
have survived have no such writing. and deservedly. It will receive less attention here, in
nineteenth centuries for the well-known Ukiyo-e achievements to a learnable system, in keeping with
prints, as well as for the less-known printed books hisown more limited talents and conservative taste.
called gaju, and these have understandably The "right" or "true" lineage of painting that Wang
overshadowed later Chinese color printing in Shimin and his followers defined was set in
foreign writings. A late nineteenth-early twentieth- opposition to other currents of painting in their
century Chinese publication titled Baihua tupu time: what we would regard as a healthy, exuberant
("Album of a Hundred Flowers") (cat. 203), based diversification of styles and subjects in late
bird specialist active in Tianjin, illustrates this fragmentation and decline. Variety in subject matte)
observation; the quality of the color printing is still was far from their purpose: an overall title such as
high, but represents no real advance over the Ten River Landscape with Houses ami Trees would cover
Bamboo Studio publications. The finest pictorial most of their output. Spokesmen today for this kind
printing of the late period is not in color but in the of painting exhort us to "I 00k .it the brushwork.
ink-line tradition: in stylistic and technical not the scenery!" but one can wish nonetheless for
refinements, the books designed by Ren Xiong a bit more variety in the scenery. Wang Shimin s
(1823 1857) nearly match those by his model, Chen fellow townsman and friend Wangjian, through an
Hongshou of the late Ming period. abundant and consistently high-level output, helped
to consolidate the style and establish its
two and trained in the Orthodox manner. He had They were mostly associated with local schools of
more natural talent and technique than his mentors painting in Nanjing andYangzhou (Jiangsu
and could imitate the old masters so successfully Province), and in Anhui Province, places where
that he was much in demand as a forger. He went patronage and other conditions were favorable.
on to a highly successful career, including a period Only Bada Shanren was isolated from these great
m the imperial court. centers, working in Nanchang, in Jiangxi Province,
court and edited an imperial anthology of writings politically dangerous secular affairs; Hongren had
on painting and calligraphy. Given his wealth and already been linked with an anti-Manchu
position, he could have achieved a successful career movement, while Bada and Shitao were both
in painting merely by carrying on the family style. descendants of the Ming imperial house and
Instead, he became the most innovative and therefore under suspicion. Although more or less
interesting of the four, the equal of the Individualist marginalized in their time by the "mainstream"
masters in his sophisticated manipulations of Orthodox masters and their adherents, the
semiabstract form. Even more strikingly, he Individualist artists had their own circles of
accomplished this within the boundaries of the admirers, and some following in the eighteenth
Orthodox style. No artist who followed that lineage century. Interest in them was reawakened in the
after him was to be so successful in revitalizing it. second quarter of our century, when major artists
Wang Yuanqi 's Complete in Soul, Sufficient in Spirit took up their strikingly "modern-looking" styles as
(cat. 204), painted in 1708, is a good example ot the basis tor a revival of landscape painting.
matter one can discuss with shallow-minded immediately as not made up, as Orthodox-school
people." landscapes are, of repeated, conventional forms
rendered in a neat system of brush strokes, nor are
Wu Li has been of special interest to Western the forms so clearly demarcated. On the contrary,
scholars because he was converted to Christianity, the heavily vegetated hillsides, depicted in loose,
becoming a Catholic priest in 1688 and serving in disorderly brushwork that imparts to them an
his late years as a missionary in Shanghai. Only a earthy naturalism, read as richly variegated
few of his paintings, however, betray any contact continuums of space and matter, imagery and
with European art; most are pure landscapes in his texture; the visual experience of moving over the
version of the Orthodox manner, in which the surface of one of Kuncan 's pictures is, accordingly,
earth masses seem to have been constructed in an more than usually akin to that of moving through
almost modular way out of simple forms and are natural terrain and absorbing transitory sensory
given an unnaturally consistent, sometimes furry stimuli. The effect is personal to the artist, a deeply
texture that eliminates surface differentiation. Wu troubled man who found no comfortable place in
Li's Reading "The Book of Changes" in a Streamside the tortured world of human affairs and took solace
Pavilion (cat. 205), painted in 1678, displays this in immersion in nature. His paintings typically lay
manner, which could be seen, like Wang Yuanqi s out an ideal narrative, the kind of excursion
painting, as doing for the traditional river landscape reported in his long inscriptions: from a secure
something comparable to, but far less radical than, base, a thatched house shown in the foreground,
what the Cubists would later do for still lifes. one moves upward along paths and through ravines,
Contemporaneous with the Orthodox landscapists, here) going at last through a gate leading still
spanning the tumultuous Ming-Qing transition and farther outward. Implied always is the safe return to
affected by it in different ways, were the artists who the security of one's hermitage.
have come to be loosely grouped as the
range of granite peaks that has inspired poets and used, not as one might expect for the portrayal of
painters from the late Ming, when it was first made comfortingly real-world scenery, but for
accessible to pilgrimages both religious and literary, otherworldly visions; and the whole effect is
down to the present day. In the early Qing a school somber and unsettling. Gong is another painter
of painters grew up in southern Anhui that took who was somehow involved in the throes of
Huangshan as their principal subject; the central dynastic change the short-lived court of the last
figure was Hongren (1610-1664). Responding in Ming pretender was located in Nanjing so that
part to the bare, geometncized patterns of political readings of his dark landscapes seem
Huangshan rock formations, the Anhui landscapists warranted.
most often worked in a dry-brush linear manner,
taking Ni Zan and some works by Dong Qichang Bada Shanren, or Zhu Da (1626 1705), is the other
(cf. cats. 188, 200) as their principal models, famously "mad" artist (along with Xu Wei) in
relinquishing washes and texture-stroke systems for Chinese painting. In the late 1670s, after spending
effects that are often stark and semiabstract. Their some years in Buddhist monasteries near
pictures thus occupy an opposite pole from Nanchang, he experienced bouts of crazy behavior;
Kuncan's dense textures and variegated forms. opinion is still divided over whether they were
Hongren's Peaks and Ravines at Jiuqi (cat. 207) is less feigned to escape suspicion of political subversion
severe and geometricized than some others of his or, as seems more likely, real. He burned his monk's
works (notably, the great Sound of Autumn in the robes and returned to secular life, but according to
Honolulu Academy of Arts), but exemplifies his contemporary reports never spoke again,
ability to create, within his self-imposed limitations, communicating instead by laughing and crying and
effects of substantiality and even monumentality in gesturing. His paintings, which he produced
his landscapes. Sparse pines and other trees grow came to be in great
prolifically in later years,
from rocky crevices; in the lower right, a path leads demand and probably were his chief means of
up from a bridge to a simple pavilion. This, no less support. He was not, like the other Individualist
than Kuncan's, is a landscape inviting imaginary masters, primarily a landscapist; his best-known
engagement with a somehow believable world. works are enigmatic portrayals of birds and fish,
cannot simply be dismissed as convention and project negative human feelings suspicion,
artifice, as most of the landscapes of the Orthodox disgruntlement, anger along with a dark humor.
masters can, is the large project underlying the best The models for these came chiefly from the
painting of the Individualists. They too plunder the mysterious pictures of such subjects by Muqi and
past, but less for style-conscious allusiveness, more other Chan (Zen) Buddhist monk-artists of the late
to retrieve pictorial devices that enhance the power Song and Yuan, which are known now only
and presence of their images. For a few of them, through examples in Japan, since Chinese collectors
including Gong Xian (1618-1689), the leading for the most part did not consider them worth
master of the Nanjing school in the early Qing, the preserving. Bada must have seen examples, and
search extended even outside the boundaries of perhaps a contemporary practice by monk-
their own painting tradition, to the European amateurs, 111 the local monasteries. His Ducks and
pictorial art that had by this time become known Lotus (cat. 210), painted in 1696, is a striking
to Chinese artists through paintings and prints example. The oft-balance poses and cryptic,
(principally, engravings in books) brought from mismatched interrelating of the two birds, the way
Europe for proselytizing uses by Jesuit missionaries. the lower-right rock hovers without a solid base,
The question of what seventeenth-century Chinese and the way the contours ot rock and lotus stalks
painters adopted from European pictorial art is repeat and intersect as thcv twist upward, confusing
complex and controversial, and it is enough for the mass and space, are among the devices that give the
present purpose to point out that the rendering of picture, like others of Bada 's, powerful instabilities
light and shade, air and space, seen in such Gong which viewers both then and now are inclined to
Xian paintings as his Summer Mountains after Rain ascribe to Ins bottled-up "madness."
groves ot leafy trees, set against strange, ambiguous traumatic. Late in his lite he renounced Ins Ming
on one of his southern tours, and traveled to the time to any artist who chose to draw on them
capital in Beijing, probably as the guest ot a and many were doing so, in diverse ways. Huaiyang
Manchu official. During his active years he lived for is an old name for the city ofYangzhou, where
periods of time in each of the major centers of Shitao lived as a professional artist in his late years.
his own terms, the local styles. In the end, he Nanjing in the early Qing period are designated in
became independent of all of them, and an artist of Chinese writings as the "Eight Masters of Jinling"
unparalleled versatility. It was Shitao who, as noted (an old name for the city). Two of the others are
earlier in a contrast with Dong Qichang, conceived Zou Zhe (1636ca. 1708) and Gao Cen (active
the extraordinary project of relinquishing all ca. 1645 1689.) A distinct school style runs through
established styles and making a fresh start, as if he the output of the Nanjing masters and is well
could return to a state prior to the formulation of exemplified by Zou Zhe's twelve-leaf Album of
conventions. "Before the old masters established Landscapes (cat. 2 12). The style includes a preference
methods," he wrote, "I wonder what methods they for angular divisions of the picture area strong
followed." To raise the question was to challenge diagonals, V-shaped compositions and a fondness
directly the Orthodox masters' insistence on "right for rich textures in both earth surfaces and
method"; what Shitao advocated was a "method vegetation. This textural richness responds to,
that is no method." The rhetoric of the claim, among other factors, the richly forested terrain
needless to say, could not be matched in his actual around Nanjing, just as the linear, geometricized
artistic practice. The attempt, however, while it style of the Anhui masters responds to the fractured
ultimately led (along with ravages of age and illness, rock masses of Huangshan. Dark, mysterious groves
commercialization, and overproduction) to a of trees often dominate Nanjing-school landscapes,
marked decline in much of the work of his last and can even, as in two of Zou Zhe's album leaves,
years, produced some strange and wonderful serve as the sole subject ot the picture. By contrast,
pictures. It also, together with the drastic failure of Gao Cen's large hanging scroll Hie Temple on
creative energy within the Orthodox school of Jinshan (cat. 214) avoids the local manner or any
landscape around the same time, left a curious and established manner, in fact to give a close visual
not entirely healthy legacy for the artists who report of a famous sight, using all the techniques
followed in the eighteenth century, confronting for convincing representation that an artist of his
them with still another "end of the history of art." time and place could muster, including some
The most interesting ot them turned away from adopted from Western pictures. Jinshan ("Gold
landscape altogether to pursue other subjects, and Mountain") is an island in theYangzi River near
landscape would not recover its central importance the neighboring city ot Zhenjiang; topped by a
until the twentieth century. Buddhist temple and pagoda that were visible from
atar, the island was a familiar landmark for travelers.
Two of Shitao's finest landscapes are in the
exhibition. Neither is dated. Pure Sounds of Hills and EIGHTEENTH-CENTURY PAINTING: THE
Streams (cat. 208) is probably from his years in YANGZHOU "ECCENTRICS"
Nanjing, 1680 1687, when he was affected by the By the early decades of the eighteenth century the
styles of the local artists notably Gong Xian older centers of painting had been replaced in
(cf. cat. 209). The heavy application of dotting over importance by the city ofYangzhou. Artists and
the surface, which seems to vibrate apart from the litterateurs were attracted by the generous
solid masses and to convey a psychological rather patronage of salt merchants and other wealthy men
than a physical state, is a feature also of Gong's late who settled there. Painters with different styles and
period, the 1680s. At the right of Shitao's picture, a specialties, polished professionals and self-styled
path ascends a ravine to disappear in fog; at the left, amateurs (who mostly depended, nonetheless, on
in a similarly constricted space, a waterfall seen at their painting for income), responded to a diversity
the top emerges below to flow under a roofed of tastes and demands.
bridge in which two men relax, listening to the
sounds and enjoying the cool. Clear Autumn in Two depictions of real places by Yangzhou masters
Huaiyang (cat. 211), judging from its style, must be exemplify this diversity. One, in handscroll form
much later; Jonathan Hay dates it to 1705 and (cat. 213), depicts the Zhan Yuan ("Garden tor
associates it with a flooding that Yangzhou suffered Gazing"), probably the garden of that name on the
then. 10 In brushwork it stops well short of the more Qin-Huai Canal in Nanjing, which still can be seen
extreme essays toward "stylelessness" seen in other today, although much altered and restored. The
works of Shitao's last years; in its handling of the artist is Yuan Jiang, who was active from the 1690s
flat recession along the river,it would appear to until about 1746. Such a work was ordinarily
betray some acquaintance with Western pictorial commissioned by the owner of the garden, who
inscriptions to it. The choice of Yuan Jiang as introduced (cat. 215). A more serious and prolific
painter indicates a desire for a detailed and artist numbered in the group is HuaYan
descriptive picture in the conservative tradition (1682-1756). Born in the southeast coastal province
stretching back to the Song dynasty. Yuan of Fujian, he was active in his later years in
accomplished this on a high technical level, laying Hangzhou and Yangzhou, supporting himself by
out his panorama of the garden so that the viewer producing a large and heterogeneous body of
can explore its spaces and appreciate its elegance. painting that encompasses nearly all subjects and an
astonishing range of styles, drawing on predecessors
The aim of Gao Xiang (1688-1753) in Finger-Snap as diverse as the Song Academy masters and Shitao.
Pavilion (cat. 215), by contrast, is certainly not close He is unmatched in his time for group figure
description, but rather to apply his loose, amiable compositions, of which Tlie Golden Valley Garden
style to conveying the rustic charm of the place, the (cat. 219), painted in 1732, is an outstanding
residence of a noted monk at the Tianning Temple example. This was the garden of Shi Chong, a
in Yangzhou. A Buddhist altar is visible in the upper fabulously rich man of the third century. HuaYan
story of the open building, and the monk himself portrays him with his concubine Lii Zhu ("Green
and a visitor appear outside, under shaggy trees. Pearl"), who was an accomplished flutist. Rocks,
Yuan Jiang s patron, given such a picture by his trees, flowers, and servants surround the two in an
chosen artist, would have returned it indignantly, arrangement that harks back to the "space cells" of
complaining of sloppiness; the recipient of Gao s early painting.
style, calling it fussy and stiff. Both artists worked in Another who was attracted from his native place in
response to well-understood expectations, instilling Fujian by the richer patronage and livelier
their paintings with visual pleasures of very different atmosphere ofYangzhou was Huang Shen
The ingenuous, technically less demanding
kinds. (1687after 1768). The local style he learned in
mode seen in Gao Xiang's work would be favored Fujian was too finished and detailed for Yangzhou
and developed in interesting directions throughout taste, to which he accommodated by moving into a
the eighteenth century by the artists known looser brush manner that had the added benefit of
collectively as the Eight Strange Masters ofYangzhou. permitting faster and more copious production.
Best known for figures, he also painted landscapes
Some time in the second decade of the century, and quickly rendered scenes from nature, such as
around the end of the Kangxi era, with the deaths Willows and Egrets (cat. 216). Here the gestural
within a few years of the major early Qing flourishing of a heavily loaded brush for the broad,
landscapists Wang Hui, WangYuanqi, and Shitao, suffusing strokes at the base of the trees and for the
Chinese painting seems to undergo a great change. trees themselves creates a sense of the momentary,
Whatever economic and other factors we introduce which is caught also in the stalking movements of
in accounting for it and however we assess its the birds through shallow water. The picture
effect it might be seen as the onset of decline, but demonstrates, among other things, how an artist
many specialists in Chinese painting would argue with Huang Shen's solid training can make
vehemently against such a reading we must seemingly free, calligraphic brush strokes serve
recognize that painting of the eighteenth and descriptive and evocative ends.
and less engaged in the large, complex formal and court in Beijing during the reign of the Kangxi
expressive problems of its predecessors. Interest in emperor (1662-1722), whose special favor he
landscape declined among the best artists and their enjoyed as a poet and painter. Later, after he had
audiences, who turned their attention to figures lost imperial support and become frustrated with
(including portraits) and flower and plant subjects, officialdom, he settled in Yangzhou as a professional
along with some fresh imagery, unknown in earlier artist. In a stylistic shift like Huang Shen's. he gave
painting, that expanded the artists' thematic up the more traditional and careful manner he had
repertories. The fondness of some eighteenth- learned at court to do vigorously executed pictures
century artists, especially those active in Yangzhou, of trees, flowers, and other plants, along with
for sketchy, quirky, and otherwise unorthodox vegetables and other mundane subjects. In addition
brush manners, and for compositions that are to their decorative value, all these carried auspicious
sometimes equally odd. has earned them and symbolic meanings that fitted them for hanging
reputations as nonconformists within Qing on particular occasions. Prominent in Li Shan's
painting. Prominent among them are the Eight oeuvre, accordingly, are large hanging scrolls such as
Strange Masters, or Eight Eccentrics ofYangzhou. his [755 Pine, Wisteria, and Peonies (cat. 217). Here
shapes of the rock and trees, and the odd, quasi- centuries will have elapsed since it passed through
postural way they answer each other, like partners the corresponding turning point, can look back
in an ungainly dance. In some of his smaller works, over those centuries and claim comparable
notably album leaves, Li Shan used opaque successes, it will be cause for rejoicing.
pigments and run-together brush strokes in ways
that opened new stylistic options for nineteenth- 7. Maggie Bickford, Ink Plum:
Tlie Making of a Chinese
and twentieth-century painters.
Scholar-Painting Genre (New
York and Cambridge:
The real amateur of the group was Jin Nong Cambridge University Press,
1996).
(1687-1764). Although his claim that he did not
begin painting until he was fifty is exaggerated, it is
8. Richard Vinograd," Family
true that most of his dated works are from his late Properties: Personal Context
years. Earlier he made his living as an itinerant SOURCES FOR FIGURES and Cultural Pattern in Wang
Fig. 2. After James F CahiU, The Meng's Pien Mountains of
antique dealer and calligrapher. It was, of course,
Compelling Image (Cambridge, 1366," Ars Orientalis 8 (1982),
not new for an amateur to paint and sell his works; Mass. : Harvard University Press, pp. 1-29.
undemanding types and Tokyo: Weathcriiill, 197S), Panning of the Late Ming
paintings to the technically
pis. 78-80. Dynasty (Tokyo and New York:
favored by the scholar-amateurs (unpeopled river Weatherhill. 19S2), pp. 264-65.
landscapes, ink monochrome bamboo and other NOTES
E. H. Gombrich, Art and 10. Jonathan Hay, "Shitao Late
plants), he took on subjects that usually required 1. s
A Thematic
professional skills figures, including religious
Illusion: A
Psychology of Pictorial
Study in the Work
Map"
(1697-1707):
(Ph.D. diss., Yale
images and portraits; horses; illustrations to old Representation, The A. W. Mellon University), vol. 1, p. 45: and
Lectures in the Fine Arts 1956, vol. 2, pp. 6061, n. 55.
poems; figure-in-landscape compositions. All these
2d ed. (New York: Pantheon,
and others he did with an ingenuous air, relying on IQ 65), pp. 148-50 (italics
leaf representing two men strolling and conversing Meanings: Critical Essays &
Aesthetic Meditations (Farrar,
in a forest from his 1759 Album of Landscapes and Straus and Giroux, 1994), p. 35.
Figures (cat. 218), for instance, he wrote that it was For the catalog essay, see
fine technique had become a bit boring, the Mastem'orks of Ming and Qing
Painting from the Forbidden City
demand for Jin Nong's paintings was more than he
(Lansdale, Pa.: International
could keep up with, and he used "ghost-painters" Arts Council, 1988), pp. 17-31:
tradition will seem familiar to us. We can conclude 4. Roger Fry, cited in Danto,
"Ming and Qing Paintings,"
by recognizing also that Chinese painting from the
P- 35-
that after artistic "progress" in the sense of a Shen and Late Northern Sung
Painting," in International
coherent series of pictorial modes that seems to
Symposium on Art Historical
&&-.
Ornament in the shape of hooked clouds
with central bird motif
Neolithic period, Hongshan culture
(ca. 3600-ca. 2000 bce)
Liaoning Province
Archaeology, Hangzhou
Prismatic tube (cong)
Nanjing Museum
Knife (dao) with semihuman mask motifs
Relics, Zhengzhou
MH
13-
Nephrite jade; h. 7. 1 cm
Unearthed at Xiasi, Xichuan county, Henan Province
Henan Provincial Institute of Archaeology and Cultural
Relics, Zhengzhou
14-
Relics, Zhengzhou
IS-
Relics, Zhengzhou
Id.
Winged horse
and masks
(Detail on facing page)
Western Jin dynasty (265-316)
Hunan Province
1 ' "- xflflSP'
)b
$
Sixteen-piece belt
/f /
"V %
21.
Vessel (Jue)
Bronze; h. 82 x w. 50 cm
Unearthed in 1990 at Qian village, Pinglu county,
Shanxi Province
Bronze; h. 45.9 cm
Unearthed in 1976 from Fu Hao tomb No. 5, Anyang,
Henan Province
National Museum of Chinese History, Beijing
25-
Bronze; h. 37.7 cm
Found in 1970 at Huangcai village, Ningxiang county,
Hunan Province
Bronze; h. 40 X 1. 72 cm
Unearthed in 1981 at Chuanxingshan, Xiangtan county,
Hunan Province
Bronze; h. 19 x 1. 43 x w. 13.4 cm
Unearthed in 1959 at Taohua village, Shilou county,
Shanxi Province
Zhejiang Province
Bronze; h. 65 x w. 138 cm
Unearthed in 1986 from Sanxingdui pit No. 2,
Vessel (lei) with elephant trunk handles and Vessel (rim), inscribed
Western Zhou period (ca. 1100-771 bce) Bronze; h. 38.8 cm, diam. of mouth 28.6 cm
Bronze; h. 70.2 cm, diam. of mouth 22. 8 cm Unearthed in [963 atjia village. Baoji county,
^
, ;
<-'.; '
iO jsf
^*\*^ShOh BfM
/*? 1 d?
;]\-~'''T^~~Z
rOA
-ni^HfTi -
i <*
>^ff^A '
M
** ^Ufa?
L y 1Efl&jj
r ^
"2
v
Sr? tI
IS^,w ;
ijSBJal
i
.
AJ/7 *'./#!?
"'
\ '
||^^H \ '
^i^
33- 34-
Bell (bo) with four tigers Drum (git) with abstract zoomorphic designs
Western Zhou period (ca. 1100-771 bce) Shang period (ca. 1600-ca. 1100 bce)
-.
mi/
Sufifn ||cj
m '
IfePl SSI \.
V '
?^^^^L *J u ?-
.
# . ;
"'
- .
t ,v. ,.
P
iL i -...^
J-^^
:':',
L f- - j
_Ss^.
S9, :
B
rJ
36.
Bronze; h. 28.7 x 1. 38 cm
Unearthed in 1976 at Zhuangbai village, Fufeng county,
Shaanxi Province
Bronze; h. 21 x 1. 38 cm
Unearthed in 1975 at Rujia village, Baoji county,
Shaanxi Province
Bronze; h. 26 cm
Unearthed in 1980 from theYing State tomb at
Relics, Zhengzhou
*
j?J1
t
mm
.
%*
* m ,
HK ^W*
V4 :
*. .,>.
'
39-
Rectangular vessel {fang yi), inscribed Miniature carriage with human guardians including
Western Zhou period (ca. 1100-771 bck) one-legged watchman, birds, and crouching tigers
Bronze; h. 38.5 x 1. of mouth 20 x vv. of mouth 17 cm Western Zhou period (ca. 1100- 1 bce)
Unearthed in 1963 at Qijia village, Fufeng county, Bronze; h. 9.1 x 1. 13.7 x w. 11.3 cm
Shaanxi Province Unearthed in lySo at Shangguo village. Wenxi county.
Shaanxi History Museum, Xi'an Shanxi Province
Four-sided vessel (Jiiif.i; hit) with square base and Vessel (/hi) with bird-shaped lid
lotus-petal crown Eastern Zhou, Spring and Autumn period (770-476 bce)
Eastern Zhou, Spuing and Autumn period (770-476 bce) Bronze: h. 41 x w. 2;. 5 cm
Bronze; h. 66 x max. width 34 cm Unearthed in [988 from tomb No. 2$i,Jinsheng village.
Unearthed in lHK from tomb No. 251,Jinsheng village, Taiyuan. Shanxi Province
Relics, Zhen^zhou
47-
Shanxi Province
diam. 3.5 cm
Unearthed in 1965 from Sanpanshan tomb No. 122,
of the immortals
Western Han dynasty (206 bce-8 ce)
Shanxi Province
Shanxi Province
mythical tree
Bronze; h. 41.5 cm
Unearthed in 1956 at Shizhaishan.Jinnmg county,
Yunnan Province
Yunnan Provincial Museum, Kunming
56.
Yunnan Province
Yunnan Provincial Museum, Kunming
57-
Yunnan Province
Yunnan Provincial Museum, Kunming
59-
Rearing dragon
Tang dynasty (618-907)
Storage container with bird designs for holding Jar with design of figures in a landscape
Tang dynasty (618-907) Silver with gilding; h. 24.7 cm, diam. of jar 12.3 cm,
Silver with gilding; h. 17.8 cm, diam. 16. 1 cm diam. of foot 12.6 cm
Discovered in 1987 in underground chamber of the Famen Discovered in 1987 in underground chamber of the Famen
Temple Pagoda, Fufeng county, Shaanxi Province Temple Pagoda, Fufeng county, Shaanxi Province
Famen Temple Museum, Shaanxi Province Famen Temple Museum, Shaanxi Province
bK
-%.:
N
c
J> .
' ;
-
X^
66.
diam. of foot 20 cm
Unearthed in 1972 from Mawangdui tomb No. 1,
LACQUER
68.
to ^H^^^B
1 ^1 iflH
ff ^sm
| 1
gESI
70.
Zhejiang Province
diam. 12. 1 cm
Unearthed in 1953 from the tomb of the Ren family,
Shanghai Museum
75-
inscribed
i wSmm
H
siifiBreiwsi
mm
iiiSSli
inlill
mm isiiiiiii
mm ilii!3iili
_ iiipiiiiipi mm
sit
.
111
if!
nf ' ft P J'lfi'S
iff"
\\H<W \y L
"ivy
%!
i-uT"
^ r
m
m 1
m\
'i i '
'"
- fifi
ffi
WBtt
,(ft(Mih|j
I,! *#
:
)l I. .
j!
:.!N,! I
76. 77-
Chain-stitch embroidery on patterned silk; 1. 48 cm Western Han dynasty (206 bce-8 ce)
f M w W
a
llfl
ffff.lf fill
'HlH^
Ili:#lK*i
IMA /
If if f
/K'
Mil a
i i
I
.
-. -X
&***&* i';
h
? '>
^,
fel^^WB^ >>
J-
*r ,
' '
> f
J*' " fc ;,
A'
ft '
<? -J-H* '
<>
.
J'*
'
r -^'-
M''
'A ^';\-i
14, ;^\ fr
'W^^^'^^S!
B -
c
1 *
.
SB* 'cc *x
' fi J 'J
> >
M il l
llMWWWpl W" 1
,
'
'
.-
^ '
, t>
I
7 8. 79-
Embroidered silk with designs signifying longevity Printed silk with small seroll motifs
WESTBRN Han dynasty (206 bcu-8 ce) Western Han dynasty' (206 bce-8 ce)
Chain-stitch embroidery on silk tabby; 1. 23 x w. 16 cm Silk tabby with pruned and drawn designs; I. 4 s X W. 53 Cm
Unearthed in 1072 from Mawangdui tomb No. 1 Unearthed in nj-: from Mawangdui tomb No. 1.
'&
ms
"&'
7
General
QlN DYNASTY (221-207 BCE)
Terra-cotta; h. 196 cm
Unearthed in 1977 from the Qin Shihuangdi tomb,
pit No. 1, Lintong county, Shaanxi Province
Shihuangdi, Xi'an
GRAVE GOODS
8p.
Military officer
Terra-cotta; h. 198 cm
Unearthed in 1977 from the Qin Shihuangdi tomb,
pit No. 1 , Lintong county, Shaanxi Province
Museum of Terra-cotta Warriors and Horses of Qin
Shihuangdi, Xi'an
90.
Military officer
Terra-cotta; h. 192 cm
Unearthed in 1977 from the Qin Shihuangdi tomb,
pit No. 1 , Lintong county, Shaanxi Province
Shihuangdi, Xi'an
CRAVE GOODS
V
91.
Soldier
Terra-cotta; h. 185 cm
Unearthed in 1977 from the Qin Shihuangdi tomb,
pit No. 1, Lintong county, Sbaanxi Province
Museum ot Terra-cotta Warriors and Horses ol Qin
Shihuangdi, Xi'an
92.
Chariot horse
QlN DYNASTY (221-207 BCE)
Shihuangdi, Xi'an
93.
Chimera (bixie)
CRAVE GOODS
94-
CRAVE GOODS
95-
Standing figure
Wi STERN Han dynasty (206 bce-8 ce)
Painted wood; h. 47 cm
Unearthed in 1972 from Mawangdui tomb No. 1,
CRAVE GOODS
97-
Sichuan Province
\f
98. 99-
CRAVE GOODS
Model of tower and pond with animals
Eastern Han dynasty (25-220)
CRAVE GOODS
101.
Recumbent dog
Eastern Han dynasty (25-220)
Glazed earthenware; h. 47 x 1. 44 x w. 20 cm
Unearthed at Nanyang, Henan Province
Nanyang Municipal Museum
102.
Tower
Han dynasty (206 BCE-220 ce)
Earthenware; h. 147 cm
Unearthed in 1952 at Jmniizhong, Huaiyang county,
Henan Province
Henan Provincial Museum, Zhengzhou
CRAVE GOODS
m^m,
if'-fa to
ry I
i
V-K t
Tomb tile
(Rubbing
with scenes of hunting and harvesting
at right)
i> 5> ,
^
;i> , 'v .aW* ,
:
-i i^:'v":"..-
jSBi> |j
Eastern Han dynasty (25-220) >i*Ti;<*w**i'.-*^i(^^ii^iastftS^ ,
^M'j fl
m
. '
CRAVE GOODS
104.
(Rubbing at right)
GRAVE GOODS
106.
Horse
Tang dynasty (618-907)
CRAVE GOODS
107.
Camel
Tang dynasty ((jrH-907)
h. Si x 1.68 cm
Unearthed iii 1973 at Guanlin, Luoyang, Henan Province
Luoyang Cultural Relics Work Team, Henan Province
io8.
Shaanxi Province
GRAVE GOODS
109.
Civil official
CRAVE GOODS
I 10.
Tomb guardian
Heavenly king
Tang dynasty (618-907)
Earthenware with sancai ("three-color") glaze; h. 113 cm
Unearthed at Guanlin, Luoyang, Henan Province
Luoyang Municipal Museum
GRAVE GOODS
Four brick reliefs with figures
Yuan dynasty (1279-1368)
Earthenware; (1) h. 35 x 1. 35.8 x w. 21 cm (2) h. 34 x
1. 29 x w. 22.5 cm (3) h. 34 x 1. 31 x w. 19.5 cm (4) h. 35 x
1. 19.5 x w. 10 cm
Unearthed in 1973 at Xifengfeng village, Jiaozuo,
Henan Province
Henan Provincial Museum, Zhengzhou
CRAVE GOODS
Ceramics
ii3-
CERAMICS
114.
Sh.i.mxi Province
Shaanxi Province
Nanjing Museum
CERAMICS
117.
CERAMICS
IIS.
KV
in;.
Candleholder in the shape of a man riding Basin with applied liuddha figure
Green-glazed stoneware (Celadon), Yue kilns; h. 27.7 cm diam. of mouth 19.4 cm.diam.of foot 10 cm
Palace Museum, Beijing National Museum of Chinese History, Beijing
CERAMICS
Jar with six lugs and incised bird and tree motifs Chicken-headed ewer with dragon handle
Northern Qi dynasty (550-577) Northern Qi dynasty (550-577)
Green-glazed stoneware (Celadon); h. 28.5 cm, Green-glazed stoneware (Celadon); h. 48.2 cm,
max. diam. of mouth 18.5 cm max. diam. 32.5 cm
Unearthed in 1958 from the tomb of LiYun, Unearthed in 197S from the tomb of Lou Rui.Taiyuan,
Puyang county, Henan Province Shanxi Province
Henan Provincial Museum, Zhengzhou Shanxi Provincial Institute of Archaeology, Taiyuan
CERAMICS
123. 124.
CERAMICS
125.
Octagonal bottle
Tang dynasty (618-907)
Green-glazed stoneware (Celadon), Yue kilns; h. 21.5 cm,
diam. of mouth 2.2 cm, diam. of foot 8 cm
Discovered in 1987 in underground chamber of the Famen
CERAMICS
126. 127.
Dish in the shape of a five-petaled blossom, base Dish in the shape of a three-petaled blossom, base
inscribed with character guati ("official") inscribed with character glian ("official")
CERAMICS
Covered jar with four lugs
("glorious Ding")
CERAMICS
130.
CERAMICS
1)1.
rim band. Ding kilns; h. 6.4 cm, diain. of mouth 23.5 cm,
diam of loot 7.3 cm
Shanghai Museum
132.
CERAMICS
>33-
Mallow-shaped bowl
(View from below at right)
Vase with dish-shaped mouth and raised ribs Jar with incised floral designs
I ongquan kilns; h. 31 cm, diam. of mouth 10.4 cm, h. 26.6 cm, diam. of mouth 5 cm, diam. of foot 8.3 cm
di.1111. of foot 11.3 cm Palace Museum, Beijing
CERAMICS
i 3 6.
CERAMICS
i 3 8.
CERAMICS
139-
openwork
(View of lid above; full view on facing page)
Yuan dynasty (1279-1368)
Porcelain with underglaze cobalt blue and copper red
Hebei Province
Palace Museum, Beijing
CERAMICS
140.
CERAMICS
141.
CERAMICS
H3. 144-
Jar with flowering plum, bamboo, and pine Stem bowl with scenes of ladies in a garden
Ming dynasty, Yoncle period (1403-1424) MlNC DYNASTY', XlANPI MARK \ND PERIOD (
I4^f> 14.;>>
Porcelain with underglaze cobalt blue decoration, Porcelain with underglaze cobalt blue decoration,
Jingdezhen kilns; h. 36 cm, diam. of mouth 6.7 cm Jingdezhen kilns; h. 10.2 cm, diam. of mouth i>.s cm,
diam. of foot 13.9 cm diam. of foot 4.S cm
Palace Museum, Beijing Palace Museum, Beijing
CERAMICS
Hi- [46.
Vase with flower and bird designs Vase with flower designs
QlNG DYNASTY, KaNGXI PERIOD (1662-1722) QtNG DYNASTY', YONGZHENG MARK AND PI MOD (1723
Porcelain with wucai ("five-color") decoration, Porcelain with doucai ("clashing" or "matched color")
Jingdezhen kilns; h. 46.4 cm, diam. of mouth 11.2 cm, decoration, Jingdezhen kilns; h. .:<> cm, diam. of mouth
diam. of foot 14.7 cm s.-i cm, diam. ol foot n .8 cm
Palace Museum, Beijing Palace Museum. Beijing
CERAMICS
2\ 1
-V *'
.
.
*; .
1
** ?
'
t
'47- 14S.
SCULPTURE
149.
SCULPTURE
150.
Dated to 523
Sichuan Province
SCULPTURE
Stele: (obverse) bodhisattvas; (reverse) lower tier,
SCULPTURE
Pi].
152.
Henan Province
Henan Provincial Museum, Zhengzhou
SCULPTURE
'53-
Stone; h. 16.5 x w. 32 cm
Unearthed in 1966 from the Simajinlong tomb, Shijiazhai,
Stele with Sakyamuni and Maitrcya Stele: (obverse) Sakyamuni and attendants;
Dated to 532 (reverse) Maitreya
SCULPTURE
I 5 6. 157-
SCULPTURE
*W*T*'""V*1f'
iHi ! wmm*am*4tm4m
15s.
SCULPTURE
159-
Marble; h. 40 x w. 28 x d. 8.5 cm
Unearthed in 1975 at Caotan in the northern suburb of
SCULPTURE
160.
Amitabha altar
Dated to 584
SUI DYNASTY (581-618)
Shanxi Province
SCULPTURE
m
r
I6 3 .
Head of a bodhisattva
SCULPTURE
164.
SCULPTURE
W*T
|C>7. 168.
SCULPTURE
169. 170.
SCULPTURE
171.
Ratnasambhava
Tang dynasty (618-907)
Marble with traces of gold; h. 67.5 cm
Unearthed in 1959 at the Anguo Temple site, Xi'an,
Shaanxi Province
SCULPTURE
172.
Manjusn
Tanc dynasty ((iiH-007)
Marble; h. 75 cm
Unearthed in [959 at the Anguo Temple site, Xi'.in,
Shaanxi Province
SCULPTURE
'7S. 176.
SCULPTURE
177.
Shaanxi Province
SCULPTURE
[78.
Ink stone
CALLIGRAPHY
*^* Al
179.
ZhuYunming (1461-1527)
Dated to 1523
CALLIGRAPHY
* fe & />
;
j|J 4 7h 4ft* c#
*
CALLIGRAPHY
u
u
#"
*#
Wang Duo (1592-1652)
Dated to 1643
CALLIGRAPHY
;s -4- ft- ^ + n -t
fit 1
^ vs
a -f :'J.
* 89
|
& i
fm%^&. If 4
A
-jar * Jt
-?
>,.
Mi # ^ I- #*. ^ # $ .^ &
It* ft 1* ft ?l M J~ -t .&
**#
'&' ^ *"
* >1 ill. - g
9 f-IMf 1>
'" :
" ?', ' " '
' 'V.' '.1 " V '
'
-.. ,. ' ' ' '' . ' *
, * ' ~1 ^fe -*v
^rr
- .
's? 1 -
*'- <
* '.
*
^ i
3E Ml
^f . v.;
*"
H-- -i.'
'-
jR
. .
i
-W '-""*"
ffflSE^
1
.V-
:
:'^*^^
". -* ''.*' .. '" "* ' '
V ' ' '
2| v
"'>.*
W:'jKE*'+&
<*f
/ 7"-
^v &
'"'
'
--^-r*
'" '/*.*,( <
J*i > ,
<-"
iJjL^-
*&F*
M :**n--
s "': ':.
'
v:'V
:
VV
" '
'.'
!."''
'.
f
'V
-
'
,
?,v&'
*' "*.
.*
* *
2
>5 ^
E '
' 3r ** :^N*--''> ;
'
** ^^k i. '.
..''. r '.
* .'> ,'
.
* -',->
.1
ffl
-/^w ..^^^
. 1.
* *
182. 183.
_
Zhanp Zhao (1691-1745) Deng Shiru (i 4.;-iSos)
Transcription of "Seventh Month" from the Odes of Couplet in seven-character lines, written in clerical
Hanging scroll, ink on paper; 176 x 92 cm 1 langing scrolls, mk on gold-flecked paper. 130.1 \ 27 (> cni
CALLIGRAPHY
: . .
-a-
A
V -" XI 1
It
Wang Shen (ca. 1048 after 1104)
Misty River and Layered Hills
185.
m
~ .? ' r
*/P ill
i^TffS
186.
Anonymous
Snowy Landscape
Southern Song dynasty (1127-1279)
Handscroll, ink and light color on paper; 24 x 48.2 cm
Shanghai Museum
PAINTING
:p
mmm
M~
i8 7 .
44 ^
ids
if=
&*
OT
FT ^ -M
ft ~Tf
MA
Pi
fcP 1
m
%
I
m en
mm m ^^m_ a s
#r~
3MB1HE
I
>eAj*
ft-
ffer
A MS
M - w. ft- ^
ftlJ '
-I^L .5
jx \|_ ^ *) ,^l #,
ft
,;
A--'*e-J
j.
tjifen*
it
f
?"# IS ^ % /a* if
iS i?) Ji
#L j? yt
.-.<'
y**
K
-IV
jt Sj:
1
* i 4^
f%
a...t.
;H~
j=-
4,
-1?
**^JM^
- :
EC .<n -3^_
"<? Si
fl 1
f-fe-s -J"
*i
^,y. =flr
jt
flCft- iE-
j
^* -T;
fe.
a
i ; ii
^
*^sK&
Ni Zan (i306[?]-i374)
Six Gentlemen
Dated to 1345
PAINTING
it * It I
[89.
^T T "2
^ f Pi **
^S~"' "^*
"wmff; -i
190.
:;i:
A _*L
$&
;
V Aft.
191.
ft 4 $
(3
i #
192. 193
Hanging scroll, mk on paper; 98.2 x 45.8 cm Hanging scroll, ink on silk; 245 x 156 cm
Shanghai Museum Hubei Provincial Museum, Wuhan
194-
Ming dynasty (1368-1644) I hinging scroll, ink and color on Mlh: IKS
I langing scroll, ink and color on silk; [(Si. 5 x 102. s cm Nanjing Museum
Suzhou Municipal Museum
PAINTING
1#- &k
!;!-
sslii
If!
m 1(0
196.
PAINTING
01 *|l *
Ss ftega
...
" .
fie
a
M
i|Jt#fe
**'""
11
ill."
m
HI
;?!
r^ 1
-:
'W, pjl^ vfr
J--'-
197-
Dated to [549
Ming dynasti ,
PAINTING
I9 8
Xu Wei k: i i
PAINTING
*
^*$yt
'"
|8
'
J
:x.
^
^K"
I H
^"^U i / kj
;.i
'
;'
,fl
=
+
^
$
ft p.
s
v-
*
f
.
ft;
* a J * ;
I- f * # .* t *
a a $ #- #-
it % %
200.
Dated to 1626
Mini: dynas
i
I ing scroll, ink on paper; 133.1 \ 52.5 cm
Shanghai Museum
PAINTING
\.y.
MM
y ** ^
PAINTING
V fc
Hi *]
* %
n *.
ft k i:
ft
r
% lib.
& h I'i
9 At
'A
i l *K
*
~\
A
V
*i
I (A
&
-V* Eh^ :
-
\
\
s
V -
^
1
/
/
~t
Vr
.??.>.!
P p:
^~Ti?| >
1
iVfft*
-<^...r
PAINTING
<&r
&
it
c&^g?
203.
PAINTING
*
4ft "
1
ft
-*'
A
\i~ ;
% M f*
M % 4 * $ *f* 1-
/ir ^ i * ^ j* / $
1
1; k# " i * a S'J
'-"
a S i'J -r 3v <
* 3 # * *
&g!&!M-jBI-~a~,
204.
WangYuanqi (1642-1715)
Dated to 1708
Wu Li (1632-1718)
Dated to 1678
* * >
'-- i* '..
<*
? *.
% n
mU&ih
ft
*
_n2 ie *
r*
f if
i\ >1
a-
? ,i
v
$ ,
S "
^? !*!
-
f-
M'l^u Ill
206. 207.
PAINTING
*#
208.
PAINTING
209.
t
4b
*
S' ^i ^"5 c-
:
-r
1 5? f :-:
to Sfl 3& u^
J i.
* *tffcl
I "?
J
i \ n r-
_
rt -l f? i- -
- ft -
M "
I
-
T
* P
* *
IS- * ?] r- ?., ?. -a.
JS 5-
{A | 1 *. -r. :
:. '.;-ik i?
9-4*.
"
-"
*
* *- a
-/
" ^-
r
-
-
Sf!<
.
* .ft
I 5 fc ^
PAINTING
: .
H&fe
Ng-^ lte31PSf
J. ; ;
1 *v* X
m
! I
Album of Landscapes
(Above and facing page)
QlNG DYNASTY (1644-I9II)
'
'-"'I
m
^O/ .<^'> -:
Yuan Jiang acl ca. 1690-ca. 1746)
PAINTING
;
Yu 't
ten
? w f 1
ijj
a *: i
** * f* 3-"^
T *
*
1JZ
*
..
v
'*.
1111 .">;
;!W
;
^ -v. ' :v$ v
214.
Gao Cen (act. ca. 1645 1689) Gao Xiang [688 [73
216. 217.
Hanging scroll, ink and color on paper; 113. 7 x 57.7 cm QlNG DYNASTY (1644-IOII)
w ^,^.i *
r
x *
f-
<&&* :,;
i
yM
til. A ^
.&*
# ^ Uf fe V **
.El
ft!
Dated to 1759
s<
/.'"'
(0
..,'
f
se
.-'
TP
j3^3> i, -
^'
-~\ > -~
.'^VvK^^v-C'^v
f >^'v...,
(mum vmMmm
III TO' &*/'
m 1
.
i
<
>
w-
-i
** R'l
y:
A
mi
mm*
/ h- Jrjfx'i
MM
&".
#&#
miWMm$
;\li/
W
^
1
1^ ifif.
U Xi Si
m i;sTW-
t
'
---^
y v^
OS
\i
#J
U r'-
H 1
.1. :
...V
-;- ii
#-
9?
-M,^r
f! b\?
1 #fer^
%
X
1 A/) ^ >
_ v
|,: --i
;
j^li S3 |f
219.
HuaYan (1682-1756)
JADE BRONZE
i. Ornament in the shape of 7. Blade (zhang) 13. Ornamental plaque with 19. Vessel (Han or zun) with 21. Vessel (jue)
hooked clouds Xia or Shang period interlacery and animal mask design of deities, animals, Xia period (ca. 2100-
with central bird motif (ca. 2200-ca. 1100 bce) designs and masks ca. 1600 bce)
Neolithic period, Hongshan Nephrite jade; 1. 37 x w. 11.2 x Eastern Zhou, Spring and Western Jin dynasty Bronze; I1.11.7x w. 14. 1 on
CULTURE d. 0.6 cm Autumn period (770-476 bce) (265-316) Shanghai Museum
(ca. 3600-ca. 2000 bce) Palace Museum, Beijing Nephrite jade; h. 7.1 cm Nephrite jade; h. 10.5 cm
Nephrite jade; 1. 22.4 X Unearthed in 1987 at Xiasi, Unearthed in 1991 from the 22. Square cauldron
w. 11. 5 x d. 0.5 cm 8. Blade (zhang) Xichuan county, tomb of Liu Hong, (fang ding) with thread-relief
Unearthed in 1979 at Shang period (ca. 1600 Henan Province Huangshantou, Anxiang frieze of animal masks, and
Sanguandianzi, Lingyuan city, ca. 1100 bce) Henan Provincial Institute of county, Hunan Province nipple pattern
Liaoning Province Nephrite jade; 1. 68 x Archaeology and Cultural Administrative Office for Shang period (ca. 1600-
Liaoning Provincial Museum, w. 10.8 cm Relics, Zhengzhou Cultural Relics, Anxiang ca. 1100 bce)
Shenyang Unearthed in 1986 from County, Hunan Province Bronze; h. 82 x w. 50 cm
Sanxingdui pit No. 2, 14. A pair of dragon-shaped Unearthed in 1990 at Qian
2. Ornament in the shape of Guanghan, Sichuan Province pendants 20. Sixteen-piece belt village, Pinglu county,
a pig-dragon (zhulong) Sichuan Provincial Institute of Eastern Zhou, Warring Tang dynasty (618-907) Shanxi Province
Neolithic period, Hongshan Archaeology and Cultural States period (475-221 bce) Nephrite jade; 1. of pieces Shanxi Provincial Institute of
culture Relics, Chengdu Nephrite jade; 1. 11.4 cm 3.5-5 cm Archaeology, Taiyuan
(ca. 3600-ca. 2000 bce) Unearthed at Pingliangtai, Unearthed in 1970 at Hejia
Nephrite jade; h. 15.7 x 9. Chime with design of Huaiyang county, village, Xi'an, Shaanxi Province 23. Square vessel (fang zun)
w. 10.4 x d. 4.3 cm crouching tiger Henan Province Shaanxi History Museum, with four rams
Found in Jianping county, Shang period (ca. 1600- Henan Provincial Institute of Xi'an Shang period (ca. 1600-
Liaoning Province ca. 1100 bce) Archaeology and Cultural ca. 1100 bce)
Liaoning Provincial Museum, Stone; 1. 84 x w. 42 x d. 2.5 cm Relics, Zhengzhou Bronze; h. 58.3 cm, w. of
Shenyang Unearthed Wuguan
in 1950 at mouth 52.4 cm
village, Anyang, Henan 15. Ring (huan) with abstract Found in 1938 atYueshanpu,
3. Prismatic tube (cong) Province designs Ningxiang, Hunan Province
Neolithic period, Liangzhu National Museum of Chinese Eastern Zhou, Warring National Museum of Chinese
culture History, Beijing States period (475-221 bce) History, Beijing
(ca. 3600-ca. 2000 bce) Nephrite jade; diam. 10.6 cm
Nephrite jade; h. 8.8 x 10. Four figures; (1) bird Unearthed in 1991 at 24. Vessel (zun) in the
max. width 17.6 cm with ram's horns Xujialing, Xichuan county, shape of a bird, inscribed
Unearthed in 1986 from (2) kneeling human (3) bird Henan Province "Fu Hao"
Fanshan tomb No. i2,Yuhang, (4) bird-headed human Henan Provincial Institute of (one of an identical pair)
Zhejiang Province Shang period Archaeology and Cultural Shang period (ca. 1600-
Zhejiang Provincial Institute of (ca. 1600-ca. 1100 bce) Relics, Zhengzhou ca. 1 100 bce)
Cultural Relics and Nephrite jade; (1) h. 4.9cm Bronze; h. 45.9 cm
Archaeology, Hangzhou (2) h. 5.6 cm (3) h. 10 cm 16. Disk (bi) with grain Unearthed in 1976 from Fu
(4) h. 9.8 cm pattern Hao tomb No. 5, Anyang,
4. Prismatic tube (cong) Unearthed in 1976 from Fu Western Han dynasty Henan Province
Neolithic period, Liangzhu Hao tomb No. 5, Anyang, (206 bce-8 ce) National Museum of Chinese
culture Henan Province Nephrite jade; diam. 18.9 cm, History, Beijing
(ca. 3600-ca. 2000 bce) Henan Provincial Museum, depth 0.9 cm
Nephrite jade; h. 5 x max. Zhengzhou Unearthed in Zhouzhi county, 25. Vessel (zun) in the shape
width 7.4 cm Shaanxi Province of an elephant
Unearthed in 1982 from 1 1 Dagger-ax (ge) with Shaanxi History Museum. (one of an identical pair)
Fuquanshan tomb No. 9, grooved blade Xi'an Shang period (ca. 1600-
Qingpu county, Shanghai Western Zhou period ca. 1100 bce)
Shanghai Museum (ca. 1100-771 bce) 17. Winged horse Bronze; h. 26.5 x 1. 22. S cm
Nephrite jade; 1. 25.4 x Han dynasty Found in 19-5 at Shixingshan,
5. Prismatic tube (cong) w. 6. 1 cm (206 BCE-220 ce) Liling, 1 lunan Province
Neolithic period, Liangzhu Unearthed in 1983 at East Nephrite jade; h. 4.2 x 1. 7.8 x Hunan Provincial Museum.
culture Sidnoxiang, Xi'an, w. 2.6 cm Changsha
(ca. 3600-ca. 2000 bce) Shaanxi Province Palace Museum, Beijing
Nephrite jade; h. 29.7 x Shaanxi History Museum, : Vessel ( poll), inscribed
max. width 6.1 cm Xi'an in Chimera (bixie) Shang pi riod ca moo-
Unearthed in 1982 in Wujin Han dynasty ca. 1 100 i
1
county, Jiangsu Province 12. Fourteen-piece burial (206 BCE-220 ce) Bronze; h. 37.7 cm
Nanjing Museum mask Nephrite jade; 1. 13.5 x Found in 1970 ai Huangcai
Western Zhou period w. 8.5 cm village. Ningxiang county,
(>. Knife (dao) with (ca. 1100-771 bce) I'.il.h e Museum. Beijing Hunan Province
semihuman mask motifs Nephrite jade; max. width Hunan Provincial Museum,
Neolithic period, Longshan 10.7 cm Changsha
culture Unearthed in 1990 troni Guo
(ca. 3000-ca. 1700 bce) Statetomb No. 2001,
Nephrite jade; 1. 23.7 x Sanmenxia, Henan Province
w. 7.7 cm Henan Provincial Institute of
of a boar zoomorphic designs (fang yi), inscribed holding interlace tray goose holding a fish
Shang period (ca. 1600- Shang period (ca. 1600- Western Zhou period Eastern Zhou, Warring Western Han dynasty
ca. 1100 bce) ca. 1100 bce) (ca. 1 100-771 bce) States period (475-221 bce) (206 bce-8 ce)
Bronze; h. 40 X 1. 72 cm Bronze; h. 75.5 cm, diam. of Bronze; h. 38.5x 1. of mouth Bronze; h. 15 cm, diam. of tray Bronze with paint; h. 53.8 X
Unearthed in 1981 at drum 39.5 cm 20 x w. of mouth 17 cm 11 cm 1. 31.3 cm
Chuanxingshan, Xiangtan Found in 1977 in Chongyang Unearthed in 1963 at Qijia Unearthed in 1965 at Unearthed in 1985 at
Hunan Province
county, county, Hubei Province village, Fufeng county, Fenshuiling, Changzhi, Zhaoshiba village, Pingshuo,
Hunan Provincial Museum, Hubei Provincial Museum, Shaanxi Province Shanxi Province Shanxi Province
Changsha Wuhan Shaanxi History Museum, Shanxi Provincial Museum, Shanxi Provincial Museum,
Xi'an Taiyuan Taiyuan
28. Vessel (gong) in 35. Two-handled vessel (gut)
zoomorphic shape with ox-head motifs, 42. Miniature carriage with 48. Rectangular basin (pan) 54. Lamp with fifteen oil
Shang period (ca. 1600- inscribed human guardians including with and
turtle, fish, saucers in the form of a
ca. 1 100 bce) Western Zhou period one-legged watchman, birds, interlacing dragon designs mythical tree
Bronze; h. 19 X 1. 43 x (ca. 1100-771 bce) and crouching tigers Eastern Zhou, Warring Eastern Zhou, Warking
w. 13.4 cm Bronze; h. 31 cm, diam. of Western Zhou period States period (475-221 bce) States period (475-221 bce)
Unearthed in 1959 atTaohua mouth 25 cm (ca. 1100^771 bce) Bronze; h. 22.5 x 1. 73.2 x Bronze; h. 82.6 cm
village, Shilou county, Unearthed in 1981 from tomb Bronze; h. 9.1 X 1. 13.7 X w. 45.2 cm Unearthed in 1977 from the
Shared Province No. 1, Zhifangtou village, w. j 1
.
3 cm Palace Museum, Beijing tomb of the king of
Shanxi Provincial Museum, Baoji county, Shaanxi Province Unearthed in 1989 at Zhongshan, Pingshan county,
Taiyuan Baoji Municipal Museum Shangguo village, Wenxi 49. Chariot fitting with Hebei Province
county, Shanxi Province mythical hunting scenes Hebei Provincial Institute of
29. Basin (pan) with coiling 36. Vessel (gong), inscribed Shanxi Provincial Institute of Western Han dynasty Cultural Relics, Shijiazhuang
dragon design Western Zhou period Archaeology, Taiyuan (206 bce~8 ce)
Shang period (ca. 1600- (ca. 1 100-771 bce) Bronze inlaid with gold, silver, 55. Spear head with hanging
ca. 1 100 bce) Bronze; h. 28. 7 x 1. 38 cm 43. Four-sided vessel and turquoise; h. 26.4 cm, men
Bronze; h. 26 cm, diam. of Unearthed in 1976 at (fang hit) with square base diam. 3.5 cm Western Han dynasty
mouth 61.6 cm Zhuangbai village, Fufeng and lotus-petal crown Unearthed in 1965 from (206 BCE-8 CE)
Unearthed in 1984 at county, Shaanxi Province Eastern Zhou period Sanpanshan tomb No. 122, Bronze; h. 41.5 cm
Chenshan village, Wenling, Zhouyuan Museum, Xi'an (770-256 bce) Ding county, Hebei Province Unearthed in 1956 at
Guanghan, Sichuan Province 38. Covered spouted vessel Autumn period (770-476 bce) 9.7 cm Shizhaishan, jinmng county,
Sichuan Provincial Institute of (he) in the shape of a Bronze; h. 41 x w. 23.5 cm Unearthed in-
;
Unearthed in 1963 at Jia Relics, Zhengzhou Autumn period (770-476 bce) shape of a kneeling figure Shizhaishan, Jinning county,
village, Baoji county, Bronze inlaid with malachite; biting and holding snakes Yunnan Province
Shaanxi Province 40. Vessel (/in), inscribed h. 48 cm Western Han dynasty Yunnan Provincial Museum,
Baoji Municipal Museum Western Zhou period Unearthed in 1990 from (206 BCE-8 CE) Kunming
(ca. 1 100-771 bce) Xujialmg tomb No. 9, Gilt bronze; h. 31.5 x 1. 15.8 cm
33. Bell (bo) with four tigers Bronze; h. 65.4 cm, diam. of Xichuan county, Henan Unearthed in 1983 from the
Western Zhou period mouth 19.7 cm Province tomb of the king of Nanyue,
(ca. 1 100-771 bce) Unearthed in 1976 at Henan Provincial Institute of Guangzhou, Guangdong
Bronze; h. 44.3 x w. 39.6 cm Zhuangbai village, Fufeng Archaeology and Cultural Province
Palace Museum, Beijing county, Shaanxi Province Relics, Zhengzhou Museum of the Tomb of the
Zhouyuan Museum, Xi'an Nanyue King of the Western
Han Dynasty, Guangzhou
LACQUER TEXTILES
59. Rearing dragon 66. Vessel based on bronze hu 72. Reliquary with Buddhist bag
76. Potpourri 83. Garden rocks with
Tang dynasty (618-907) vessel figures Western Han dynasty chrysanthemum, high
Gilt bronze and iron; h. 34 x Western Han dynasty Northern Song dynasty (206 bce-8 ce) mallow, and begonia, after a
1. 28 cm (206 bce-8 ce) (9601127) .
Chain-stitch embroidery on painting by Cui Bai
Unearthed in 1975 at Wood-core lacquer; h. 57 cm, Wood-core lacquer with seed patterned silk; 1. 48 cm (act. ca. 1060-1085)
Caochangpo in the southern diam. of mouth rS.i cm, diam. x w. 24.5 cm
pearls; h. 41.2 Unearthed in 1972 from Southern Song dynasty
suburb of Xi'an, Shaanxi of foot 20 cm Unearthed in 1966 at the Mawangdui tomb No. 1, (1127-1279)
Province Unearthed in 1972 from Huiguang Pagoda site, Rui'an, Changsha, Hunan Province Silk tapestry (kesi); 102.5 X 43.6
Shaanxi History Museum, Xi'an Mawangdui tomb No. r, Zhejiang Province Hunan Provincial Museum, cm
Changsha, Hunan Province Zhejiang Provincial Museum, Changsha Liaoning Provincial Museum.
60. Six-lobed plate with Hunan Provincial Museum, Hangzhou Shenyang
design of mythical beast Changsha 77. Gauze with patterns of
Tang dynasty (618-907) 73. Sutra boxes with Buddhist pine-bark lozenges, signifying 84. Heavenly King of the
Silver with gilding; h. 1.2 cm, 67. Set of eight cups figures longevity West
diam. 15.3 cm Western Han dynasty Northern Song dynasty Western Han dynasty Yuan dynasty (1279-1368)
Unearthed in 1970 at Hejia (206 bce-8 ce) (960-1127) (206 bce-8 ce) Silk embroidery; 250.8 x
village, Xi'an, Shaanxi Province Wood-core lacquer; h. 12.2 cm, Wood-core lacquer with seed Silk gauze; 1. 75 x w. 48 cm 247.7 cm
Shaanxi History Museum, Xi'an w. 1619 cm pearls; (outside box) h. 16 x Unearthed in 1972 from Donated in 1949 by Mr. Fei
Unearthed in 1972 from 1. 40 x w. 18 cm, (inside box) Mawangdui tomb No. 1, Zhenshan
61. Six-lobed plate with Mawangdui tomb No. 1 h. 11. 5 x 1. 33.8 x w. 11 cm Changsha, Hunan Province National Museum of Chinese
design of bear Changsha, Hunan Province Unearthed in 1966 at the Hunan Provincial Museum, History. Beijing
Tang dynasty (618-907) Hunan Provincial Museum, Huiguang Pagoda site, Rui'an, Changsha
Silver with gilding; h. 1 cm, Changsha Zhejiang Province 85. King of Bright Wisdom
diam. 13.4 cm Zhejiang Provincial Museum, 7S. Embroidered silk with Budong
Unearthed in 1970 at Hejia 68. Rectangular box with Hangzhou designs signifying longevity Yuan dynasty (1279 1368)
village, Xi'an, Shaanxi Province cloud designs Western Han dynasty Silk tapestry (kesi); 90 x 56 cm
Shaanxi History Museum, Xi'an Western Han dynasty 74. Round covered box with (206 bce-8 ce) Administrative Office of Norbu
(206 bce-8 ce) aged scholar and servant Chain-stitch embroidery on Linka, Lhasa,
62. Plate in the shape of two Wood-core lacquer; h. 21 X Dated to 1351 silk tabby; I. 23 x w. 16 cm Autonomous Region ofTibet
peach halves with design of 1. 48.5 x w. 25.5 cm Yuan dynasty (1279-1368) Unearthed in 1972 from
two foxes Unearthed in 1972 from Carved lacquer on a fabric- Mawangdui tomb No. 1, S6. Sakyamuni Buddha
Tang dynasty (618-907) Mawangdui tomb No. 3, covered wood core; Changsha, Hunan Province QlNC DYNASTY (1644-1911)
Silver with gilding; h. 1.5 x Changsha, Hunan Province diam. 12. 1cm Hunan Provincial Museum, Silk tapestry {kesi); 1S2.7 x
.6
max. width 22.5 cm Hunan Provincial Museum, Unearthed in 1953 from the Changsha cm
Unearthed in 1970 at Hejia Changsha tomb ot the Ren family, Liaoning Provincial Museum,
village, Xi'an, Shaanxi Province Qingpu county, Shanghai 79. Printed silk with small Shenyang
Shaanxi History Museum, Xi'an 69. Round tray with scroll Shanghai Museum scroll motifs
63. Censer found with figure Western Han dynasty 75. Round covered box with (206 bce-S ce) Peach and Plum Garden"
of Ganesha (206 bce-8 ce) figures viewing a waterfall, Silk tabby with printed and QlNG DYNASTY (1644-1911)
Tang dynasty (618-907) Wood-core lacquer; h. 4.5 cm, inscribed drawn designs; 1. 48 x w. 53 cm Silk tapestry (kesi); 135.5 x
Silver with gilding; h. 41.8 cm, diam. 53.7 cm MlNC DYNASTY, YONCLE MARK Unearthed in 1972 from 70.2 cm
diam. of mouth 24.5 cm Unearthed in 1972 from AND PERIOD (14O3-I424) Mawangdui tomb No. 1 Liaoning Provincial Museum,
Discovered in 1987 in Mawangdui tomb No. 1, Carved lacquer on a fabric- Changsha, Hunan Province Shenyang
underground chamber of the Changsha, Hunan Province covered wood core; h. 7.7 cm, Hunan Provincial Museum,
Famen Temple Pagoda, Fufeng Hunan Provincial Museum, diam. of mouth 22 cm Changsha
county, Shaanxi Province Changsha Palace Museum, Beijing
Famen Temple Museum, 80. Embroidered textile with
Shaanxi Province 70. Rectangular tray with cloud design
scroll designs Western Han dynasty
64. Storage container with Western Han dynasty (206 bce-8 ce)
bird designs for holding (206 bce-8 ce) Chain-stitch embroidery on
brick tea Wood-core lacquer; 1. 75.6 cm silk tabby;!. 17 x w. [4.5 cm
Tang dynasty (618-907) Unearthed in 1972 from Unearthed in 1972 from
Silver with gilding; h. 17.8 cm, Mawangdui tomb No. 1, Mawangdui tomb No. 1,
diam. 16.1 cm Changsha, Hunan Province Changsha, Hunan Province
Discovered in 1987 in Hunan Provincial Museum, Hunan Provincial Museum,
underground chamber ot the Changsha Changsha
Famen Temple Pagoda, Fufeng
county, Shaanxi Province 71. Round box with painted 8l. Coverlet with dragon
Famen Temple Museum, and incised designs design
Shaanxi Province Western Han dynasty LlAO DYNASTY (Ql6-II35)
(206 BCE-8 CE) Silk tapestry (to ri) with gold
63. Jar with design of figures Wood-core lacquer; h. 18 cm. threads. Ii. 90 \ W, $6.$ Cm
in a landscape diam. 32 cm Unearthed in i*j-j acYemaotai,
Tang dynasty (618-907) Unearthed in 1972 trom Faku county,
Silver with gilding; h. 24.7 cm, Mawangdui tomb No. 3, I
iaoning Province
diam. of jar 12.3 cm, Changsha, Hunan Province I iaoning Provincial Museum,
diam. of foot 12.6 cm Hunan Provincial Museum, Shenyang
Discovered in 1987 in Changsha
underground chamber of the 82. Zhu Kerou
Famen Temple Pagoda, Fufeng Camellias
county, Shaanxi Province Not mi un Song dynast*
Famen Temple Museum,
Shaanxi Province Silk tapestry (fceri), mounted as
88. General 95. Standing figure 102. Tower 109. Civil official 113. Bowl with stylized floral
QlN DYNASTY {221-207 BCE) Western Han dynasty Han dynasty (206 bce- Tang dynasty (618-907) or leaf designs
Terra-cotta; h. 196 cm (206 bce-8 ce) 220 ce) Earthenware with sancai Neolithic period, Yangshao
Unearthed in 1977 from the Painted wood; h. 47 cm Earthenware; h. 147 cm ("three-color") glaze; h. 107 cm culture, mlaodigou type
Qin Shihuangdi tomb, Unearthed in 1972 from Unearthed in 1952 at Unearthed at Guanlin, (4th millennium bce)
pit No. 1, Lintong county, Mawangdui tomb No. 1, Jiuniizhong, Huaiyang county, Luoyang, Henan Province Red earthenware with black
Shaanxi Province Changsha, Hunan Province Henan Province Luoyang Municipal Museum pigment;
Museum of Terra-cotta Hunan Provincial Museum, Henan Provincial Museum, h. 23 cm, max. diam. 36 cm
Warriors and Horses of Qin Changsha Zhengzhou no. Tomb guardian Unearthed in 1979 in Fangshan
Shihuangdi, XT an Tang dynasty (618-907) county, Shanxi Province
96. Standing performer with 103. Tomb tile with scenes of Earthenware with sancai Shanxi Provincial Institute of
89. Military officer a drum hunting and harvesting ("three-color") glaze; Archaeology, Taiyuan
Qin dynasty (221-207 bce) Eastern Han dynasty Eastern Han dynasty h. 103.5 cm
Terra-cotta; h. 198 cm {25-220) (25-220) Unearthed in 1981 from the 114. Basin with human head
Unearthed in 1977 from the Earthenware with pigment; Earthenware; 1. 44.5 x tomb of An Pu at Longmen, and fish designs
Qin Shihuangdi tomb, h. 66.5 cm w. 39.6 X d. 6.5 cm Luoyang, Henan Province Neolithic period, Yangshao
pit No. 1, Lintong county, Unearthed in 1963 in Pi Unearthed in 1972 at Anren Luoyang Cultural Relics Work culture, Banpo type
Shaanxi Province county, Sichuan Province village, Dayi county, Team, Henan Province (late 6th-5th millennium bce)
Museum ofTerra-cotta Sichuan Provincial Museum, Sichuan Province Red earthenware with black
Warriors and Horses of Qin Chengdu Sichuan Provincial Museum, in. Heavenly king pigment; h. 15.5 cm,
Shihuangdi, Xi'an Chengdu Tang dynasty {618-907) diam. of mouth 39.5 cm
97. Squatting performer with Earthenware with sancai Unearthed in 1955 at Banpo
90. Military officer a drum 104. Tomb tile with carriage ("three-color") glaze; h. 113 cm village, near Xi'an,
Qin dynasty (221207 BCE ) Eastern Han dynasty and horses Unearthed at Guanlin, Shaanxi Province
Terra-cotta; h. 192 cm (25-220) Eastern Han dynasty Luoyang, Henan Province National Museum of Chinese
Unearthed in 1977 from the Earthenware with pigment; (25-320) Luoyang Mumcipal Museum History, Beijing
93. Chimera (bixie) Sichuan Provincial Museum, 107. Camel White earthenware; h. 22.1 cm,
Eastern Han dynasty Chengdu Tang dynasty (618-907) diam. of mouth 9.1 cm, diam.
(25-220) Earthenware with sancai of foot 8.9 cm
Stone; h. 114 x 1. 175 x 100.Model of tower and ("three-color") glaze; Unearthed at Anyang, Henan
w. 45 cm pond with animals h. 81 x 1.68 cm Province
Unearthed in Yichuan county, Eastern Han dynasty Unearthed in 1973 at Guanlin, Palace Museum, Beijing
Henan Province (25-220) Luoyang, Henan Province
Guanlin Museum of Stone Glazed earthenware; h. 45 cm, Luoyang Cultural Relics Work 1 1
8. Jar (zun) with mat
Sculpture, Luoyang diam. of basin 55 cm Team, Henan Province impressions
Unearthed in 1964 in Xichuan Shang period (ca. 1600-
94. Five kneeling musicians Henan Province
county, 108. Set of twelve calendrical ca. 1100 bce)
Western Han dynasty Henan Provincial Museum, animals Ash-glazed stoneware
(206 bce-8 ce) Zhengzhou Tang dynasty (618-907) (protoporcelain); h. 27 cm,
Painted wood; h. 32.5-38 cm Earthenware with pigment; diam. of mouth 27 cm
Unearthed in 1972 from 101. Recumbent dog h. 38.541.5 cm Unearthed in 1965 at
Mawangdui tomb No. 1, Eastern Han dynasty Unearthed in 1955 in the Zhengzhou, Henan Province
Changsha, Hunan Province (25-220) suburbs of Xi'an, Zhengzhou Municipal
Hunan Provincial Museum, Glazed earthenware; h. 47 x Shaanxi Province Museum
Changsha 44 x w. 20 cm
1. Shaanxi History Museum,
Unearthed at Nanyang, Henan Xi'an
Province
Nanyang Municipal Museum
LIST OF COLORPLATES
ii9- Candleholder in the 126. Dish in the shape of a 132. Tripod vessel in the 139. Covered jar with floral 146. Vase with flower designs
shape of a man riding five-petaled blossom, base shape of an archaic designs in painted applied QlNG DYNASTY, YONGZHENG
a mythical beast inscribed with character guan bronze Han or zun vessel openwork MARK AND PERIOD (1723-1735)
Western Jin dynasty (265-316) {"official") Northern Song dynasty Yuan dynasty (1279 1368) Porcelain with doitcai
Green-glazed stoneware Tang dynasty (618-907) (960-1127) Porcelain with underglaze ("clashing" or "matched color")
(Celadon), Yue kilns; h. 27.7 cm White stoneware with Pale blue-green-glazed cobalt blue and copper red decoration, Jingdezhen kilns;
Palace Museum, Beijing transparent glaze, Xing or Ding stoneware, Ru kilns; painted and applied decoration, h. 26 cm, diam. of mouth
kilns; h. 3.5 cm, h. 12.9 cm, diam. of jingdezhen kilns; 5.2 cm. diam. of foot n.S cm
120. Basin with applied diam. of mouth 13.8 cm, mouth 18 cm h. 42.3 cm, diam. of mouth Palace Museum, Beijing
Buddha figure diam. of foot 6.45 cm Palace Museum, Beijing 15.2 cm, diam. of foot 18.5 cm
Western Jin dynasty (265-316) Unearthed in 1985 at Unearthed in 1964 from a Yuan
Green-glazed stoneware Huoshaobi, Xi'an, Shaanxi 133. Mallow-shaped bowl dynasty hoard at Baoding,
(Celadon), Yue kilns; h. 7.5 cm, Province Southern Song dynasty Hebei Province
diam. of mouth 19.4 cm, diam. Institute for the Protection of (1127-1279) Palace Museum, Beijing
of foot 10 cm Cultural Relics, Xi'an Crackled pale blue-
National Museum of Chinese green glazed stoneware, 140. Covered jar with three
History, Beijing 127. Dish in the shape of a Hangzhou Guan ("official") lugs
three-petaled blossom, base kilns; h. 4.2 cm, diam. of mouth Ming dynasty, Yongle period
1 21. Jar with six lugs and inscribed with character guan 17.3 cm, diam. of (1403-1424)
incised bird and tree motifs ("official") foot 9.9 cm Pale green-glazed porcelain,
Northern Qi dynasty Tanc dynasty (618-907) Palace Museum, Beijing Jingdezhen kilns;
128. Covered jar with four Palace Museum, Beijing h. 3.8 cm, width of mouth
122. Chicken-headed ewer lugs 15.9 cm, diam. of foot 13 cm
with dragon handle Five Dynasties (907-960) 135. Jar with incised floral Palace Museum, Beijing
Northern Qi dynasty White stoneware with designs
(550-577) transparent glaze, Xing or Northern Song dynasty 142. Moon flask with dragons
Green-glazed stoneware Ding kilns; h. 26.2 cm, diam. of (960-1127) among lotus scrolls
(Celadon); h. 48.2 cm, mouth 10.4 cm, Bluish-glazed white stoneware Ming dynasty, Yongle period
max. diam. 32.5 cm diam. of foot 9. 1 cm (<jiHg/j(i/),Jingdezhen kilns; (1403-1424)
Unearthed in 1978 from the Donated by Mr. Zhou Rui h. 26.6 cm, diam. of mouth Porcelain with underglaze
tomb of Lou Rui.Taiyuan, Shanghai Museum 5 cm, diam. of foot 8.5 cm cobalt blue decoration,
Shanxi Province Palace Museum, Beijing Jingdezhen kilns; h. 44 cm,
Shanxi Provincial Institute of 129. Bowl inscribed with diam. of mouth 8 cm,
Archaeology, Taiyuan characters yaug ding 136. Vase with carved peony diam. of foot 14.5 cm
("glorious Ding") designs Palace Museum, Beijing
123. Octagonal bottle Five Dynasties (907-960) Northern Song dynasty
Tank dynasty (618-907) White stoneware with (960-1127) 143. Jar with flowering plum,
Green-glazed stoneware transparent glaze, Ding kilns; Cizhou-type stoneware with bamboo, and pine
(Celadon), Yue kilns; h. 21.7 h. 6.3 cm, diam. of mouth white slip and transparent Minc dynasty', Yongle period
cm, diam. of mouth 2.3, diam. 19.9 cm, diam. of foot 7.5 cm glaze; h. 34 cm, diam. of (1403-1424)
of foot 7.8 cm Donated by Mr. Huang Zhaoxi mouth 6 cm Porcelain with underglaze
Palace Museum, Beijing Shanghai Museum Unearthed in 1959 inTangyin cobalt blue decoration,
Henan Province
county, Jingdezhen kilns; h. 36 cm,
124.Bowl 130. Bottle with carved and Henan Provincial Museum, diam. ot mouth 6.7 cm,
Tang dynasty (618-907) combed peony designs Zhengzhou diam. of foot 13.9 cm
Green-glazed stoneware Northern Song dynasty Palace Museum. Beijing
(Celadon), Yue kilns; h. 6.8 cm, (960-1127) 137. Pillow with painted
diam. of mouth 22.4 cm Green-glazed stoneware, design of a hawk chasing 144. Stem bowl with scenes
Discovered in 19S7 in Yaozhou kilns; h. 19.9 cm, a rabbit among reeds of ladies in a garden
underground chamber of the diam. of mouth 6.9 cm, diam. Jin dynasty (1115 1234) Ming dynasty, Xuande mark
Famcn Temple Pagoda, Fufeng of foot 7.8 cm Cizhou-type stoneware with and PERIOD (I426- [435
county, Shaanxi Province Palace Museum, Beijing white slip, black pigment, Porcelain with underglaze
Shaanxi History Museum, and transparent glaze; h. 9.7 X ). cobalt blue decoration,
Xi'an 131. Bowl with incised ducks 24.7 x w. 17 cm Jingdezhen kilns; h. 10.2 cm,
and water weeds Henan Provincial Museum. diam, of mouth 15.5 cm,
125. Octagonal bottle Northern Song dynasty Zhengzhou diam. of fool 1
diam. of foot 8 cm h. 6.4 cm, diam. of mouth 23.5 NoRTHi rn Song m NAsn QlNG l'> NASTY, K INGXI p] RIl ID
Museum
;
county, Shaanxi Province Dengfeng kilns; h. \~. 1 cm, Jingdezhen kilns; h 40.4 cm,
Famen Temple Museum, diam. of mouth 7- 1 cm, diam. of mouth 11.2 cm,
Shaanxi Province diam. oi foot '*.<> cm diam ol fool 14." cm
Palace Museum, Beijing Museum, Bei|ing
147. Stele with Maitreya 153. Pillar base with 159. Stele with Buddhist 167. Torso of a guardian king 176. Head of Avalokitesvara
Dated to 471 mountains, dragons, and trinity Tang dynasty (618-907) Tang dynasty (618-907)
Northern Wei dynasty figures Northern Zhou dynasty Marble; h. 100 cm Sandstone; h. 41 cm
(386-534) Northern Wei dynasty (557-581) Forest of Steles Museum, Xi'an Unearthed in 1954 at the
Forest of Steles Museum, Xi'an (3S6-534) stand 24.3 cm, w. of altar stand Tang dynasty (618-907) Boshan Temple site, Fu county,
Sandstone; h. 90 x w. 46 x 24 cm Gilt bronze; h. 65 cm Shaanxi Province
149. Stele with Sakyamuni d. 14 cm Unearthed in 1974 at Bali Unearthed in Baoji, Shaanxi Shaanxi History Museum,
and bodhisattvas Institute for the Protection of village, Xi'an, Shaanxi Province Province Xi'an
Northern Wei dynasty Cultural Relics, Xi'an Institute for the Protection of Baoji Municipal Museum
{386-534) Cultural Relics, Xi'an
Stone; h. 96 x w. 43.5 cm 155. Stele: (obverse) 170. Trail okyavijaya
Unearthed in 1974 in Qi Sakyamuni and attendants; 161. Stele with Sakyamuni (conqueror of greed, hatred,
Henan Province
county, (reverse) Maitreya and attendants and delusion)
Henan Provincial Museum, Western Wei dynasty Northern Qi dynasty Tang dynasty (618-907)
Zhengzhou (535-557) (550-577) Marble; h. 71 x w. 42 cm
Sandstone; h. 48.2 x w. 21.5 x Sandstone with polychrome; Unearthed in 1959 at the
Sichuan Provincial Museum, Unearthed in 1954 at the h. 100.7 x w- 74-7 cm Anguo Temple site, Xi'an,
Chengdu Huata Temple site, Taiyuan, Palace Museum, Beijing Shaanxi Province
Shanxi Province Forest of Steles Museum, Xi'an
151. Stele: (obverse) Shanxi Provincial Museum, 163. Head of a bodhisattva
bodhisattvas; (reverse) lower Taiyuan Tang dynasty (618-907) 172. Manjusri
tier, figures, animals, and Sandstone; h. 36 cm Tang dynasty (618-907)
buildings in mountainous 157. Stele with enthroned Unearthed in 1954 at the Marble; h. 75 cm
landscape; middle panel, Buddhas and attendant Wanfo Temple site, Chengdu, Unearthed in 1959 at the
lotus pond; upper tier, bodhisattvas and monks Sichuan Province Anguo Temple site, Xi'an,
Buddha preaching to monks Dated to 559 Sichuan Provincial Museum, Shaanxi Province
in garden setting Northern Qi dynasty Chengdu Forest of Steles Museum, Xi'an
Liang dynasty (502-557) (550-577)
Sandstone; h. 121 x w. 60 x Limestone; h. no x w. 58.5 x 164. Head of Eleven-Headed 173. Head of a bodhisattva
d. 24.5 cm d. 10 cm Avalo kites vara Tang dynasty (618-907)
Unearthed in 1954 at the Unearthed in 1963 in Tang dynasty (618-907) Sandstone; h. 30 x w. 19 cm
Wanfo Temple site, Chengdu, Xiangcheng county, Henan Marble; h. 25.5 cm Unearthed in 1957 at
Stone; h. 39.5 x 1. 144 x (557-5Si) precincts of the Darmnggong, a Huata Temple site, Taiyuan,
w. 14 cm Stone; h. 259 x w. 73.4 x Tang dynasty imperial palace in Shanxi Province
Unearthed in the late 19th d. 19.5 cm Xi'an, Shaanxi Province Shanxi Provincial Museum,
century in Luoyang, Unearthed in 1963 in Luoning Forest of Steles Museum, Xi'an Taiyuan
Henan Province Henan Province
county,
Henan Provincial Museum, Henan Provincial Museum, 166. Head of a bodhisattva 175. Torso of a bodhisattva
LIST OF COLORPLATES
CALLIGRAPHY PAINTING
178. Ink stone 184. Wang Shen 193. Wu Wei (1459-150S) 202. Ten Bamboo Studio 211. Yuanji (Shitao; 1642-1707)
Northern Wei dynasty (ca. 1048after 1104) Fishermen on a Snowy River Letter Papers Clear Autumn in Huaiyang
(386-534) Misty River and Layered Hills Ming dynasty (1368-1644) Published 1644 by Hu QlNG DYNASTY | (
Stone; h. 8.5 x 1. 21.2 x Northern Song dynasty Hanging scroll, ink on silk; Zhengyan (15S4-1674) Hanging scroll, ink and color
w. 21 cm (960-1127) 245 x 156 cm Ming dynasty (1368-1644) on paper; 89 x 57.1 cm
Unearthed in 1970 near Handscroll, ink and color on Hubei Provincial Museum, Woodblock print book; each Nanjing Museum
Datong, Shanxi Province silk; 45.2 x 166 cm Wuhan leaf 21 x 13.6 cm
Shanxi Provincial Museum, Shanghai Museum Palace Museum, Beijing 212. Zou Zhe (1636-ca. 1708)
Taiyuan 194. Zhou Chen Album of Landscapes
185. Zhao Kui (1185 1266) (ca. 1455after 1536) 203. Album of a Hundred QlNG DYNASTY (1644 I9II)
179.Zhu Yunming (1461-1527) In the Spirit of Poems by Du Fu Peach Blossom Spring Flowers, after paintings by Album, ink and color on paper;
"The Terrace of Ode to the Southern Song dynasty Dated to 1533 Zhang Chaoxiang (act. 19th c.) three leaves each
Wind" and other poems (1 127-1279) Ming dynasty (1368-1644) QlNG DYNASTY, TONGZHI PERIOD 12.6 x 28.6 cm, remaining
composed by Zhu Yunming, Handscroll, ink on silk; 24.7 x Hanging scroll, ink and color (1862-1874) leaves each 12.6 x 14 cm
written in wild cursive script 212.2 cm on silk; 161. 5 x 102.5 cm Woodblock print book; each Nanjing Museum
(kuangcao) Shanghai Museum Suzhou Municipal Museum leaf 24.2 x 16.8 cm
Dated to 1523 Palace Museum, Beijing 213. Yuan Jiang
Ming dynasty (1368-1644) 186. Anonymous 195-QiuYing (ca. 1495 1552) (act. ca. 1690-ca. 1746)
Handscroll, ink on paper; Snowy Landscape Playing the Flute by Pine and 204. Wang Yuanqi (1642 1715) Garden for Gazing
24.6 x 655.6 cm Southern Song dynasty Stream Complete in Soul, Sufficient in QlNG DYNASTY (1644-I9II)
Palace Museum, Beijing (1127-1279) Ming dynasty (1368-1644) Spirit Handscroll, ink and light color
Handscroll, ink and light color Hanging scroll, ink and color Dated to 1708 on silk; 51.5 x 254.5 cm
180. Zhang Ruitu (1570-1641) on paper; 24 x 48.2 cm on silk; 116. 4 x 65.8 cm QlNG DYNASTY (1644-1911) Tianjin Municipal History
Transcription of Wang Wei's Shanghai Museum Nanjing Museum Hanging scroll, ink on paper; Museum
"Song of the Aged General," 137.2 x 71.5 cm
written in cursive script 187. Song Boren 196. Shen Zhou (1427-1509) Palace Museum, Beijing 214. Gao Cen
(caoshu) (act. mid- 13 th c.) Eastern Villa (act. ca. 1645-1689)
MlNC DYNASTY (1368-I644) Album of Plum Blossom Portraits Ming dynasty (1368-1644) 205. Wu Li (1632-1718) The Temple on Jinshan
Handscroll, ink on silk; 29.5 x 123S; reprint, 1261 Album, ink and color on paper; Reading "The Book of QlNG DYNASTY (1644-I9II)
629.5 cm Southern Song dynasty each leaf 28.6 X 33 cm Changes" in a Streamside Hanging scroll, ink and color
Palace Museum, Beijing (1127-1279) Nanjing Museum Pavilion on silk; 180.8 x 95.1 cm
Woodblock print book; each Dated to 1678 Nanjing Museum
181. Wang Duo (1592-1652) leaf 23.1 x28.6 cm 197. Wen Zhengming QlNG DYNASTY (1644-1911)
Transcription of Wang Wei's Shanghai Museum (1470-1559) Hanging scroll, ink on paper; 215. Gao Xiang (1688-1754)
"Enjoying a Repast at the Studio oj True Appreciation 2 1 1. 7 x 7S.7 cm Finger-Snap Pavilion
Home of Elder Zhao in 188. Ni Zan (i306[?]-i374) Dated to 1549 Shanghai Museum QlNC DYNASTY (1644-I9I1)
Qizhou" and "Passing by the Six Gentlemen Ming dynasty (1368-1644) Hanging scroll, ink on paper;
Herbal Garden of Master Dated to 1345 Handscroll, ink and color on 206. Kuncan (1612-ca. 1674) 69 x 38 cm
Hesui in Spring," written in Yuan dynasty (1279-1368) paper; 36 x 107.8 cm Clear Sky over Verdant Hills Yangzhou Municipal Museum
standard script (kaishu) Hanging scroll, ink on paper; Shanghai Museum Dated to 1660
Dated to 1643 61.9 x 33.3 cm QlNG DYNASTY (1644-I9II) 216. Huang Shen
Ming dynasty (1368-1644) Shanghai Museum 198. Xu Wei (1521-1593) Hanging scroll, ink and color (1687-after 1768)
Handscroll, ink on satin; 21.2 x Peonies, Banana Plant, and on silk; S5 x 40.5 cm Willows and Egrets
165.5 cm 189. Wang Meng Rock Nanjing Museum QlNG DYNASTY (1644-I9II)
Palace Museum, Beijing (ca. 1308-1385) Ming dynasty (136S-1644) Hanging scroll, ink and color
Dwelling in the Qingbian Hanging scroll, ink on paper; 207. Hongren (1610-1664) on paper; 113.7 X 57.7 cm
182. Zhang Zhao (1691 1745) Mountains 120.6 x cm
58.4 Peaks and Ravines at jinqi Shanghai Museum
Transcription of "Seventh Dated to 1366 Shanghai Museum QlNG DYNASTY (1644-I9II)
Month" from the Odes of Bin, Yuan dynasty (1279-1368) Hanging scroll, ink on paper; 217. Li Shan (1686-after 1760)
written in standard script Hanging scroll, ink on paper; 199. Chen Hongshou no. 6 x 58.9 cm Pine, Wisteria, and Peonies
(kaishu) 140.6 x 42.2 cm (1598-1652) Shanghai Museum Dated to 1755
QlNG DYNASTY (1644-1911) Shanghai Museum The Pleasures of He Tianzhang QlNG DYNASTY (1644-IOII)
Hanging scroll, ink on paper; Ming dynasty (1368-1644) 208. Yuanji (Shitao; 1642-1707) Hanging scroll, ink and color
176 x 92 cm 190. Shang Xi Handscroll, ink and color on Pure Sounds of Hills and on paper; 238 x (l8.2 cm
Palace Museum, Beijing (act. ca. 2nd quarter of 15th c.) silk; 25.3 cm
x 163.2 Streams Shanghai Museum
The Xuande Emperor on an Suzhou Municipal Museum QlNG DYNASTY (1644-I9II)
183. Deng Shim (1743-1805) Outing Hanging scroll, ink on paper; 218. Jin Nong (1687 1764)
Couplet in seven-character Ming dynasty (1368-1644) 200. Dong Qichang 102.5 x 42.4 cm Album oj Landscapes and
lines, written in clerical script Hanging scroll, ink and color (1555-1636) Shanghai Museum Figures
192. Dai Jin (1388-1462) Zhengyan (1584 1674) QlNC DYNASm (1644- wu''1 Shanghai Museum
Landscape in the Manner oj Yan Mim. m \\sn (1368 -1644] Hanging scroll, ink on papei
1 1 engui Woodblock print hook; each if>f> \ 76.3 cm
Mink DYNASTY (1368 1644) leaf 25.8 x 31 cm Shanghai Museum
Hanging scroll, ink on paper; Palace Museum. Beijing
98.2 x 45.8 cm
Shanghai Museum
Stephen C. Swid
Director Emeritus John S.Wadsworth,Jr.
Thomas M. Messer Cornel West
Michael F. Wettach
John Wilmerding
William T Ylvisaker