Professional Documents
Culture Documents
30 Mil Mueretes Por Recortes en Sanidad
30 Mil Mueretes Por Recortes en Sanidad
2015, a large increase in deaths in January of that Table 1. Causes of death used in the decomposition of
year, again considering possible explanations. differences in life expectancy.
Figure 1. Age-standardised death rate per 100,000 population, England and Wales, 19802015.
1300
1100
1000
900
800
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015
Year
Figure 2. Percentage increase in death rates at individual years over 75 from 2014 to 2015, England and Wales. Source: Authors
calculations from ONS mortality data and population estimates.
14
Percentage change in ASMR 2014 to 2015 (%)
12
10
0
75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90
Age
expected had mean monthly deaths in 20062014 The accompanying paper will explore this nding in
occurred.10 Over the entire year, the excess deaths detail.
number 30,515. Note that calculations of excess
deaths in this paper vary slightly due to dierences Contribution of deaths from different causes, at different
in standardisation in the various comparisons. ages, to the change in life expectancy. We now examine
Looking in more detail at deaths in the rst in detail the deaths contributing to recent changes in
ve weeks of each year (to ensure all of January life expectancy. Although the deterioration was great-
is included) since 2010, 2015 clearly stands out est between 2014 and 2015, we focus on the change
(Figure 4).10 Other than in week 1, there were between 2013 and 2015 in recognition of the slight
many more deaths in every week of January than in improvement in 2014. Figures in parentheses are
the same weeks in the previous years (dotted line 95% condence intervals. There was a small but
shows average for the 5-year period 20102014). non-signicant deterioration in life expectancy at
156 Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 110(4)
Figure 3. Excess deaths per month in 2015 compared to the monthly average 20062014, England and Wales.
10479 January
4386 February
3719 March
3091 April
-894 May
3555 June
1675 July
-682 August
3692 September
1102 October
514 November
-122 December
Figure 4. Number of deaths per week, weeks 15, 20102015, England and Wales.
18,000
16,000
Absolute number of deaths
14,000
12,000
10,000
8,000
6,000
4,000
2,000
0
1 2 3 4 5
Week number
birth, from 81.22 (81.1881.25) years in 2013 to 81.17 2015. The corresponding gures at age 75 were
(81.1381.20). However, this includes a small increase from 12.39 (12.3712.40) years to 12.28 (12.26
of 0.03 years among men, due entirely to fewer deaths 12.29) years.
at young ages that compensated for the increase mor- Figures 5 and 6 show the results of the decompos-
tality at older ages, and a larger decline, of 0.1 year ition of changes in life expectancy for both sexes, by
among women. At older ages, the declines are signi- age band and cause of death, in England and Wales.
cant. At age 65, life expectancy fell from 19.91 Bars above the line indicate that a fall in deaths con-
(19.8819.93) in 2013 to 19.84 (19.8219.86) in tributed positively to life expectancy and vice versa.
Hiam et al. 157
Figure 5. Decomposition showing the contribution of deaths at different ages from different causes to change in male life
expectancy, England and Wales, 20132015.
0.10
-0.05
F01, F03 Vascular and unspecified
dementia
-0.15
The corresponding gures for the change between For men, continuing reductions in deaths from
2014 and 2015, accompanied by a commentary on diseases of the circulatory system and all other
the ndings, are included in a web appendix. causes made positive contributions to improved life
As expected, given the changes in life expectancy expectancy in the 85 and over age band (0.04 and
at each age, the largest contributors to change in life 0.03 years, respectively). The greatest contributors to
expectancy in both sexes were seen in the over 85 age worsening life expectancy were dementias, with vas-
band. Notably, inuenza did not signicantly con- cular and unspecied dementia contributing a loss of
tribute to changes in any group, although caution is 0.06 years, and AD a loss of 0.02 years. Pneumonia,
needed as coding practices can record complications responsible for a loss of 0.01 years, may include some
of inuenza as the cause of death, such as pneumo- deaths due to inuenza. All age bands from 65 years
nia, rather than inuenza itself. and over saw a negative contribution of vascular and
158 Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 110(4)
Figure 6. Decomposition showing the contribution of deaths at different ages from different causes to change in female life
expectancy, England and Wales, 20132015.
0.15
0.1
All other causes
-0.1
F01, F03 Vascular and unspecified
dementia
-0.2
J09 Influenza due to certain identified
influenza virus; J10-J11.3 Influenza
-0.25
unspecied dementia, but the younger age groups while deaths from diseases of the circulatory system
experienced a positive contribution. Deaths at and all other causes made a modest positive contri-
younger ages contributed very little to the worsening bution to life expectancy. As with men, increasing
life expectancy, except those <1 years, where all deaths from dementia impacted negatively from
other causes contributed a loss of 0.01 years. 65 years on, with modest positive contributions seen
For women, during the years 2013 to 2015, the at younger ages. These ndings indicate that increas-
overwhelming negative contribution was from ing deaths in the over 75 years contributed most to
deaths in the over 85 age band, with vascular and the reduction in life expectancy, with dementias the
unspecied dementia contributing a loss of 0.13 predominant cause.
years and AD 0.06 years. Increasing deaths from
pneumonia were the third most important cause of Changes in reported deaths from dementia. Given the fre-
declining life expectancy, contributing 0.01 years, quency of multi-morbidity,11 coupled with the
Hiam et al. 159
Figure 7. Number of deaths and age-standardised mortality rates for dementia and Alzheimers disease, persons 75 and over,
England and Wales, 20012015.
70,000 1400
60,000 1200
100,000 population
Number of deaths
40,000 800
30,000 600
20,000 400
10,000 200
0 0
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
Year
Deaths Rate
Figure 8. Recorded prevalence of dementia, all ages, England, 2014/15 to 2015/16. Source: HSCIC.17
challenges of attributing deaths at older ages to a and dementia have rarely been recorded as a cause of
specic cause, it is important to ensure that the death.13,14 The ONS codes deaths using specialist
changes observed are not a function of changes in software and highly trained coders, and in January
recording or coding. We now consider this possibility 2014, the software package was changed.15 This
for the dementias, noting that the initial data show an change has been associated with a 7.1% increase in
upward acceleration in deaths attributed to both deaths coded with an underlying cause as dementia.15
dementia and AD, above the trend line in 2015 In addition, nancial incentives encouraging early
(Figure 7).12 diagnosis of dementia in primary care were put in
Our ndings must, however, be interpreted in the place between October 2014 and March 2015. That
context of other changes at the time. Historically, AD was associated with a marked increase in recorded
160 Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 110(4)
prevalence, as seen in Figure 8.16,17 In contrast, epi- deaths have occurred, yet, as far as we can ascertain,
demiological research using standardised diagnostic this has stimulated no signicant interest among
criteria show a declining age-standardised prevalence politicians. A search of Hansard reveals only one
of dementia,18 although in terms of absolute num- question from a Member of Parliament (MP) about
bers, this is counteracted by population ageing. mortality in 2015. Scottish Nationalist Party MP, Ian
However, it is important to note that the overall Blackford, asked The Minister will be aware that
rise in mortality is not due to population ageing. mortality rates in England and Wales have increased
In summary, while the change in coding cannot by 5.4% in 2015the biggest increase in the death
explain the increase from 2014 to 2015, the incentives rate for decades. She will also be aware that mortality
for early diagnosis may contribute in part. This rates have been rising since 2011. Has she done any
cannot explain the increase in overall deaths but analysis of what has been behind those trends? and
does caution against reading too much into the received the reply We welcome the overall trend
apparent rise in deaths from dementia. towards longer life expectancy. There are annual uc-
tuations, but overall the trend remains positive. The
key thing is helping people to live longer, healthier
Discussion lives.19 Two further questions were asked by Dr
The results show a rise in deaths for the whole of 2015 Sarah Wollaston following communication about
but also a large spike in January, of necessity exam- our research.
ined in a separate accompanying paper. Yet, even Our ndings must be seen in the context of the
without it, mortality in 2015 would have increased. severe disruption to the operation of the ONS follow-
The decomposition revealed that deaths among those ing its move from London to Newport, with the loss
aged 75 and over contributed most to changes in life of many key sta and institutional memory, coupled
expectancy, with dementias the predominant cause. with severe cuts to its budgets changes that have
Changes in coding and diagnosis of dementia makes been blamed for the downgrading of the quality of
the data dicult to interpret, but, even so, it is not the UKs trade statistics.20 Given the delays and
clear why more people would have died from demen- problems we have faced, there is a strong case for
tia, if the gures are taken at face value. viewing the strengthening of ONS as a strategic
As noted above, attributing a specic cause of national priority.
death to older people is recognised to be challenging, The older population particularly relies on a func-
given the presence of multi-morbidity. However, the tioning health and social care system, and it has been
causes of death that contribute to the increase share suggested that the increase in mortality 2015 could be
the characteristic of being either a cause of frailty in related to austerity and the resulting health and social
older people or a common terminal event. This pat- care cuts.4,21 There is already evidence linking auster-
tern, coupled with the earlier nding of an increase in ity and increasing suicide rates22 and dependence on
deaths throughout the year, suggest a general failure food banks.23 One study has examined in detail
of care for this group, whose members are typically changes in life expectancy in England in the years
dependent on others for many aspects of their daily 2007 to 2013,5 nding a close correlation with cuts
life. Clearly, many live lives that are precarious, at in pension credits at the level of local authorities.
risk of infections, falls and fractures, so the question These funds provide an important source of income
is not why any particular individual died but why, for the poorest pensioners. Although these ndings
after many years of declining mortality, their death predate the current increase in mortality, they oer a
rate should increase so much? possible clue.
This study has many limitations, largely arising For those working in health and social care, the
from the limitations in the data available. For exam- impact of austerity is already clear, with one survey
ple, at the time of analysis, data by single year of age of general practitioners nding that 94% of respond-
in each area were not available. Published data on the ents reported that their workload had increased as a
number of deaths in England and Wales varied if direct result of the nancial hardship of their
weekly deaths are totaled, the gure is 539,007, patients.24 Recent reports from the British Medical
equating to 37,583 excess deaths compared to 2014, Association (BMA)25 and the Royal College of
and a rise of 7.5%.10 As such, even now this can only Physicians26 have both highlighted the serious
be considered a preliminary analysis, although we public health consequences of austerity and the
believe that we have gone as far as the data available underfunding of the NHS, with the BMA calling
to us currently allow. However, this raises an import- for robust action to mitigate the adverse impacts.
ant question about the priority given to monitoring It is not possible, with the limited data currently
the health of the population. Almost 30,000 excess available, to explore this hypothesis in more detail,
Hiam et al. 161
at least as it relates to deaths throughout the year, but publically available data from the Oce for National Statistics,
some further clues can be found in the second part of NHS England and Public Health England, the analyses and
hypotheses were developed and explored. LH wrote the paper ini-
our analysis, of the January 2015 spike in mortality.
tially as her dissertation under Prof McKees supervision. Dr Hiam
In addition, cuts to local authorities budgets have then converted this into the two present papers with substantial
resulted in the withdrawal of many services that older input from MM and ongoing advice from DD and DH, each of
people depend on. Rural bus routes have been whom have extensive experience in research on mortality patterns
reduced dramatically, increasing isolation of those and trends.
dependent on them.27,28 Meals on wheels services
Acknowledgements: We are grateful to Marina Karanikolos for
have been stopped in a third of top tier councils, methodological advice.
with the National Association of Care Catering
(NACC) drawing attention to the consequences, Provenance: Not commissioned; peer-reviewed by Julie Morris
noting how a daily visit can reduce loneliness and and peer reviewers comments from a previous submission were
also made available.
isolation, prevent admission to hospital by support-
ing independent living and reducing medical prob-
lems resulting from malnutrition.29 Given these References
circumstances, it is unsurprising that, in 20142015, 1. Eberstadt N. The health crisis in the USSR. New York
29.2% of those 80 years and above reported high Rev Books 1981; 28: 2331.
levels of loneliness.30 2. Xu JQ, Murphy SL, Kochanek KD and Arias E.
Mortality in the United States. NCHS Data Brief, No
267. Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health
Conclusion Statistics, 2016.
Approximately 30,000 more people died in 2015 3. The Economist. Illness as Indicator. See http://www.
than 2014 in England and Wales, with the increase economist.com/news/united-states/21710265-local-
in year on year deaths the greatest since World War health-outcomes-predict-trumpward-swings-illness-
indicator (2016, last checked 28 January 2017).
II. Decomposition methods showed that the deaths
4. Hawkes N. Sharp spike in deaths in England and
in those over 75 years contributed most to changes Wales needs investigating, says public health expert.
in life expectancy, with dementias the predominant BMJ 2016; 352: i981.
cause recorded. Changes in diagnosis and coding of 5. Loopstra R, McKee M, Katikireddi SV, Taylor-
dementia likely had an impact on these gures, and Robinson D, Barr B and Stuckler D. Austerity and
as such this should be interpreted with caution. old-age mortality in England: a longitudinal cross-
What is clear is that the older population, who local area analysis, 20072013. J R Soc Med 2016;
rely heavily on a well-functioning health and social 109: 109116.
care system, were the most harmed by the mortality 6. Hawkes N. Recent high death rates in older people are
increase. not exceptional, says Public Health England. BMJ
With no satisfactory explanation provided for this 2013; 347: f5252.
7. Auger N, Feuillet P, Martel S, Lo E, Barry AD and
increase so far, the accompanying paper in this series
Harper S. Mortality inequality in populations with
will aim to explore possible causes for such a rise in
equal life expectancy: Arriagas decomposition
mortality, along with closer consideration of the method in SAS, Stata, and Excel. Ann Epidemiol
impact of the cuts to the health and social care 2014; 24: 575580. (80.e1).
system. 8. Office for National Statistics. Deaths Registered in
England and Wales 2015. See https://www.ons.gov.uk/
Declarations peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsandmar
Competing interests: MM, DD and DH are unpaid members of riages/deaths/bulletins/deathsregistrationsummaryta
public health Englands mortality surveillance advisory group. LH bles/2015 (2016, last checked 28 January 2017).
has no competing interests. 9. Office for National Statistics. Vital Statistics:
Population and Health Reference Tables. See http://
Funding: None declared.
www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/
Guarantor: LH. populationandmigration/populationestimates/datasets/
vitalstatisticspopulationandhealthreferencetables
Ethical approval: Approval was obtained from the London (2016, last checked 28 January 2017).
school of hygiene and tropical medicine board for the initial 10. Office for National Statistics. Weekly Provisional
dissertation project. Figures on Death Registrations in England and Wales.
Contributorship: LH is a postgraduate student at LSHTM, See http://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcom
under the supervision of MM. Having noted the increase in mor- munity/birthsdeathsandmarriages/deaths/datasets/
tality and suggested explanation of u, they decided to explore weeklyprovisionalfiguresondeathsregisteredinenglan
this possibility with help of the expertise of DH and DD. Using all dandwales (2016, last checked 28 January 2017).
162 Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 110(4)
11. Barnett K, Mercer SW, Norbury M, Watt G, Wyke S 20. OConnor S. Office for National Statistics criticised
and Guthrie B. Epidemiology of multimorbidity and over UK trade data errors. Financial Times. See
implications for health care, research, and medical edu- https://www.ft.com/content/aeea9a3e-07ae-11e5-9579-
cation: a cross-sectional study. Lancet 2012; 380: 3743. 00144feabdc0 (2016, last checked 28 January 2017).
12. Office for National Statistics. Provisional Analysis 21. Dorling D. Brexit: the decision of a divided country.
of 2015 Death Registrations in England and Wales. BMJ 2016; 354i3697).
See https://www.ons.gov.uk/releases/provisionalanaly 22. Barr B, Taylor-Robinson D, Scott-Samuel A, McKee
sisof2015deathregistrationsinenglandandwales (2016, M and Stuckler D. Suicides associated with the 2008-10
last checked 28 January 2017). economic recession in England: time trend analysis.
13. Todd S, Barr S and Passmore AP. Cause of death in BMJ 2012; 345: e5142.
Alzheimers disease: a cohort study. QJM 2013; 106: 23. Loopstra R, Reeves A, Taylor-Robinson D, Barr B,
747753. McKee M and Stuckler D. Austerity, sanctions, and
14. Romero JP, Benito-Leon J, Louis ED and Bermejo- the rise of food banks in the UK. BMJ 2015; 350:
Pareja F. Under reporting of dementia deaths on death h1775.
certificates: a systematic review of population-based 24. Iacobucci G. GPs workload climbs as government aus-
cohort studies. J Alzheimers Dis 2014; 41: 213221. terity agenda bites. BMJ 2014; 349: g4300.
15. Office for National Statistics. Impact of the 25. British Medical Association. Health in All Policies:
Implementation of IRIS Software for ICD-10 Cause of Health, Austerity and Welfare Reform. London:
Death Coding on Mortality Statistics, England and British Medical Association, 2016.
Wales. See http://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulatio 26. Royal College of Physicians. Underfunded. Underdoctored.
nandcommunity/birthsdeathsandmarriages/deaths/bul Overstretched. The NHS in 2016, 21 September 2016.
letins/impactoftheimplementationofirissoftwarefor 27. Disney J. After brutal spending cuts, rural bus services
icd10causeofdeathcodingonmortalitystatisticsenglan have reached the end of the line. The Conversation. See
dandwales/2014-08-08 (2014, last checked 28 January https://theconversation.com/after-brutal-spending-
2017). cuts-rural-bus-services-have-reached-the-end-of-the-
16. NHS England. Dementia Identification Scheme. See line-63432 (2016, last checked 28 January 2017).
https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/ 28. Dorling D. Austerity, rapidly worsening public health
2014/10/dementia-ident-schm-fin.pdf (2014, last across the UK, and Brexit. Political Studies
checked 28 January 2017). Association. See https://www.psa.ac.uk/insight-plus/
17. Knight K. Patients in England diagnosed with demen- blog/austerity-rapidly-worsening-public-health-across-
tia. HSCIC. See http://www.hscic.gov.uk/catalogue/ uk-and-brexit-0 (2016, last checked 28 January 2017).
PUB20618/qual-outc-fram-rec-dem-diag-2015-2016- 29. National Association of Care Catering. Letter to MP:
sum.pdf (2016, last checked 28 January 2017). Meals on Wheels. See http://www.thenacc.co.uk/assets/
18. Matthews FE, Arthur A, Barnes LE, Bond J, Jagger C, downloads/675/MP Letter.pdf (2015, last checked 28
Robinson L, et al. A two-decade comparison of preva- January 2017).
lence of dementia in individuals aged 65 years and 30. Office for National Statistics. Measuring National
older from three geographical areas of England: results Well-being: Insights into Loneliness, Older People and
of the Cognitive Function and Ageing Study I and II. Well-being. See http://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopula
Lancet 2013; 382: 140514012. tionandcommunity/wellbeing/articles/measuringnatio
19. House of Commons Hansards. Topical Questions. See nalwellbeing/2015-10-01 - tab-Introduction (2015, last
https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2016-05-10/ checked 28 January 2017).
debates/16051027000024/TopicalQuestions?high
lightmortality%202015-contribution-
16051027000170 (2016, last checked 28 January 2017).