Hall of Fame Tier: 25+

Story Gameplay Re-playability Score (30)

1) Dark Souls III 9.5 10 9 28.5
2) The Witcher 3 10 9.5 9 28.5
3) Fallout 4 9.5 9.5 9 28
4) Wolfenstein Series 10 9 8 27
5) Borderlands Series 8.5 8.5 9.5 26.5
6) Devil May Cry 8 8.5 8 25.5
[Rocket League, Fifa Series, l4d2]

Commendation Tier: 20-25

Story Gameplay Re-playability Score (30)

7) Killing Floor series - - - 24.5
8) The Forest 7 8.5 8.5 24
9) Modded Skyrim 8.5 7.5 8.5 23.5
10) Dragon Age: Inquisition 8 7.5 7.5 22
11) Middle Earth: Shadow of 8 7.5 7 21.5
Mordor
12) Zombie Army Trilogy 7 8 7 21
13) Dying Light 7 8 6.5 20.5
14) Dragon Dogma: Dark Arisen 6.5 8 6.5 20
Games you like or probably would like:

RPG:

Just Cause 3

Bioshock series

Hitman series

Metro series

Batman- Arkham Knight

Deus Ex series

Dead Rising 3

Far Cry 4

Far Cry Primal

Dishonored series

GTA 5

Mass Effect series

Mad Max

Shadow Warrior 2

Rise of the Tomb Raider

Dishonored 2

Survival:

Ark
FPS:

Arma III

Battlefield 1

CoD series

Crysis series

Metal Gear Solid 5- The Phantom Pain

Rainbow Siege

Star Wars- Battlefront

Doom

Cars/Racing:

The Crew

Project Cars

DiRT: Showdown

Assetto Corsa

Horror:

Outlast

Resident Evil 7

Strategy:

Total War series

Civilization series

I dont like this category so idgaf

Pay day 2

Warframe
Defiance

The division

Viscera cleanup detail

Saints row

Sniper ghost warrior

Trine 3

Serious sam HD

Dead Space 3

Cry of fear

Necropolis

Dead island

Keep Talking and Nobody Explodes

Raw Data

Shellshock live