Tools of Critical Thinking METATHOUGHTS FOR PSYCHOLOGYser is ain hs reyooatige (ean og iL wo gE aes Sana ttn bree San otngn wane pe pooja pe epi regulon Mey pa ag po Hee eT, sry eer z seriou pe vex se mean ee Seon emp SSomncrenaone ssi seen ane ge ee pins ome) IS HON snd eqn ec pp, spy 2am op tg Si ms etm gs ‘ih ae nes np Bdge pon ee eee Fo por" oan apd ena put a, "ope a anu pur sop ot ney apd br pe sa a 7 ri fon 3a {yen son os ns ae pons pgs ea bataersuntyneptcscd eet ote ets ‘ey eo ora el pn grip pr se ‘Sd ape Pee eae a sot dann eye a — ‘ear = yee Sa pan ee one ds ya fe ge OL Soumya sesame pa is ae AE FupyUryL PeOMED Jo STOOL 404 wreppoy [won Tenses ‘pum josoms un sor FE gn oe Spon rnd myn ne ts asin 2 ap ep feu oo a Pa seroonus-raus nasa, Teenoouset NESTON “uy sg pony 4 01029 uSb09 ou oy apy ues on oe 9 4 sagt obo ter 9 se wot pee) 2 HK ssooponurat 00-9 Gr) caseuoo a Sat Dat au put es o0 a ing ema 2past, present, and fre* o 8 sognantion eon 94-9300, a WHUED A, pres, pu oon 3074 en SOBs TENN AL a po ss ogy uN EY opr santo pars upg enue o1 290480 9 SID aro sp aa Fara SEE HONORED ponsaturg seme Sa noi onan Sans aur at Sao snopes pa See EN soe regen mp sue AL ase we corpse poy Bed 09 ION aL, yng oa oe ok euros ue aL as s ‘woowounya Forzemdooney 300 bea pny on my ou 9 moo woe] om 2g cranys a pnog squaqu0g pcoments x ‘Than Tews Eaanng Phenomens s ‘Gas Fives Osher lass and Fallacies n Thinking 129 X Cameo Dns Not ae Cason: Conn "Whi “Wy” 68 yg, BM Metra FerndMietCanpain 1) g Xl kstna Cas qv, the ality Ba The Perv Foe of od res am Gt, Hey pi nd eC 2 hig, XR Theiler To Undead ior Neyo t 28 Ti. Wolpe Chun: Nox “EO Be BA 7 RL eee fat: tA Case fe Ce Eg 8 Part Sins Concaiona a EV. Malle Pao Casas oem Caen Sime ct Oban Se Cones _____ait {0X Bey Deoson 4 Te O Tae Suck Pes and Mwy 218 J Pat Tie: Common Minatbtins 35 pga Cacig Met Meng as XV, Theta Attin or eat Somaya Te a ‘Weng be np Er ec % liso vases eaagey ota 4 X0LThelnaion Como Fal Tt ol of i ed EN tc bee ee te Ce 1 Ferre ateln Dore w® Fim. The Cepia Flay ‘een: The pers osm Claes “he es Dna Powe tet 2 icteuaobecouacong naenaly a aia Fats Psst Una as coy Themen bobs hs -epen:Case be poste Mezoagt VD 24 12K The Spc penn Flay: ype Sl Bano Sees Oeon8) 255 stata es Do Nees xray Cass 6 gp Set Aars Cape ures 26 hasay mm ‘art For: Invstgting Phenomena 18 oe 7 XX Deluca nice Resning TreMetaletiacae 135 eure = Suter 2s 21201. Rect To Oe ia ° “xs. Tesehlig Pps When xpos CteReiy 17 14 34 The Aan Be vine Wet hgh hom Core me as TRLW. Theo ie YS nd On Win eStaSek 10 ; Q.SXV. Thetelel Pesce ic The als Aas Rie im Fic. The Hindi i: ding Winer afer he Race shed 181 =al a sl Ao gy ase ax, IMA 8 SN “Srp pamuro Seq nen su Nod ou 4 ‘unity act sone por tn sn one nal SES poe ‘Bate ond a 2 5g spe 9855 ee Le 90 mA ap eH AE HS ean ong HP SON a ng ing 9 110 ft nds py Ys 3901s AYO TIEN ‘henge wm! ean so age gd po A Says pi san pomp ano 058 Sr pocrenon cnn ne sec sn) sydney oN oa on por eds we EO doe ge snes ne ton ne ra teu aeons nam oe oO ‘Thou s fuses “npn sos! o) pom +o suyeN mage Sete secon eves of a pt np Seo nO a ovary dd sd a on oj om 4 wae ‘fanogeep tes Beno 0 a RAN ee prs uy ny ns A yom sy He aps hogar sy Ue oD 1 oN yoke nen mm Su in ae aa uous nf anon ean Ws compa tea an Erma, Hh, Leo, ay Lf, td torr Corde it tee Nee Bene Rb New td Seng eooun Brace tpt Rit seer Cle Walt an Ane Whar Athogh ser antes pest fo iting veyns ey ane ey ‘heey sae dank Ta elf ial ost fr words whe comes to ees eat oe gate sd neering deo sy wil Baste tony sank Beth “Heth Goes David A Ley Notes "Serie ga pin war, cd Introduction tn of ocd pos meh no ya coding ne oer ct thing fen my em expe ‘Fenske nud and oer! yr mld of contrary if ‘fecsseggung te pope sedge ays foe a ‘Sonar “he wy ng Inthe ama nd coer he ‘Meerincting te wet nny fe ating to el eh and po opal): In uci he wk sotines seems most foie Samar ne comple andthe vive cosets nae ruiely Mrs te thers ido ower o peo ute shdeire Iogear ease empl sraion Nos igen al Rogen wn sappy ceed et es po nied tes a sy ay td ho aso em tere fps Mena perce cl scmbed in inter wg oe {Stele kaso rsicay Sonate mode eae ec se ly las ane wy et of el Tag Mew hows ogy a ey hon ode ah ews eet nthe dg of nemo apogee map et ot pes Pcp) a ween met een qui huge toon pel ano fe en reste Had expe coll and see eee ‘he wr enamel edacton eri eee ale {ed comple oer ht stad escent and realy nde Sool tye weap ce sen ke. he bos sept wth compe epextmps nd psd ce hat lb opel ot bce, (Obie leetarraseegy a ny a Gs sou hy ong Be ‘alone oe goa ly ne) Py, to ips ampsay eens 209 a) page hor A ‘Epo fn spe seman yy PN eH ‘ogg of ame pavpin psn’ yom ote 0 Jo Uo {Sy ota sooner e pass por uma gap Pes] Pilg aoe osm nar joondae pu oawoay smo ‘Ses Setny qa ops) 20) oppo eds Fos mo psu ep pede ag se Bus nod a Typo sol ome pp es a8 Pot ‘Shum we pe ood wy oem pose se 4) 0 "Vion 2 deta os 0 ley Sapa. pasion ne an pons oa et um re yar trex posndutgmanor mes po eee poo Sasi panos sani eon 0 uapeny Yk ‘Huo sans gan 9 0s) pean Hxymisd Jn appt or fog po sao sep > sa woe es [ot Aojplay jo mera Sans pause a Moped ene “ai pbs pode et ea eR ON FS “ale azs von Woy gpd gat Fo VIN tng opt itp vi pe ora upg ayaa ot 1p VN Strom oe ony Sap ga pus ta E> Siena apes no eg pone eh vps Anam aio oq eg I POL “nie pm pron oad soon me Sy ae 2 soyyny oy} NOGY Jusoaun a0 ‘Boon ror ‘oe 3p sano mati pp yon wpe, ‘ota py a samo use, uno UpSY pos ee “aude we pleas a yn pon opr sp a oes ‘op yuan ofan su 8 waer-yu-anp foe oy Set ot ipa A 9 spe ome spe 9 am a mp est she ous a8nit Auth Aon she enn hei nln ea ‘psn Reine Sele (LPS) hae ben ised nena ‘yates ets be brs member fe tot Eb othe Ail of Hones Ply Ty i ao te stor of mies stb aie, ng “The Enyrars Postar Cle: A Bil Guie to Desonetrcing Haden tly ihionble Prete Uninats "How Bea ond cts fy Pate” "tychomerie Inlisiy Reals One SPA FRyetnopal Prie “Sikes. An Empl ivexiptin of ‘eas cet Tey and"A posed Cpr the Dag and Sat ‘ha aa of Med Dn (SAD Reve Ltting Dae” ‘sen conmn, Ley bs pared on dozens of lero nt ‘no bracing CNN, CS NC, PS NP. AE Eo, Wig pps penpcoes co caren crn an xing es ed "reo nthe mental ba He uss ered ltl i {oy proces, ter al cor a moon pres, tees ae ae He ‘eecedan Ey nomlaton fe ousting peraance ns eto le ‘isn ss adem pest Sa thee series Chas, wre Be tyler of reer isle go. ion! Hogg ‘tater aye fandom apr ioa ee vase ‘il oa ecpis aoe ptesuae oye ea ‘aquosard 04 S] aquosaq OL aBensuey Jo seg aarenyeng Oy], | Taadoy apupreee erg “yor ot‘Lenguage secre macy functoes. One of its most crsmon and most imgor- tac ur obey de rls phen ch es, anand pepe “Wha = Aner pps ae hse ne enone" gon orbu™ pele omar despa be ‘js: bern ye nals vlan te abject "hth dtneson tener cece dec rd stot a sont du 9 The ewer Inthe nt maj 0 cast nb. Wy? esate meds both Sesrband ete, Whenever we asm sere ‘omingor seen, he wow te ae eat iy ae ae ‘hah refer ur nm pra ss dl Ths ou eo ay pat ‘llr sm eres nooo eb, bat ds osha ese ‘wandeblewar "Tsp its ren nthe pyc ance, are 12 se gl snc Latte ea lution the toma a a In the dot pyc basher en iy ner me, eral em evn“ ue ldo" Ia oe” Wea we ae ee ‘ine eet dete apron, howe ey ek on a iinet ‘Saar man tnd of Tt woman se Thee conegoees ofthe snes agg? The word ‘ha we we ca ho het sine coe Powel rumen of ‘ange Inshore nares here eae lvl aepig ene ‘esr aren arn et, we tool et Mods ht st ference out: In many ces ower th proce {iter unmnsonl Gu beacons remain nade cose the bt angnge When i comer oct pene ey or ‘Sito tnd wot thc advo of anv cram. ene 8 ‘my sum, we spy don hve neal acta fodescbe pesca? ‘hrs, ete nal ca edie acta up ANE ‘enifauh made exo, el wold ey ely to tz te ones ‘hat er our om peso pees “Te eran ta olpnge raed in he owing le at scompusng ence et ay tht Seren tres eon AS ero) ths rent of wae edo ce Se tone or op. Nate bw the ed the eel ha om ss Serie pomect ee the Baht BsofLangage 5 Speen Pa vo irate hag Sand ddrgs Sie | i et dee irene | Sat caver pr Exercise 1 Afr evewing ae 1 ys xa on your. Remembthi frets eer ord tha ea ee Perens soa ates ard {es which cy and conte maps han eso (Se ‘Sansone pear in sea) Reina Peon PesonA Peon 8 bade conformist = prolen andou aa fare lesion sehen edu impuciy —__} itt es concn ceseeaess - + mee |sae cond un Seas roe seta apt Sse oasis: ogee conten ame deperd concn oe sm PP Tenia ee stings sea zpos aeons paint ‘eos = somo ap au (HHA) SF HOG A, sua 41885015) acme maint ss10N = sora tintin ae psp pm mi sps net Ss 8 8 ‘pion ses ear 3p fede Salon po (Pp sta one a se gone a aera Solo sept one sto Butea pu pony spa 0 Stan ono) a a etn id wo layramar aon ho a Sei o sg see a ON Seaman sng pode ae po deg snes no 8 sine anes ono Sy ae rvs bin ot ng og pono suns fa > age [dt gor 0 poe sey aut pa mus 0m, ‘tae paco Spe tn nes 3 Ah cura Sak xe sam a on Pye) cr bom ‘Boy am ou oy ss amy SH Samy esa ps 9B sou ey Ss pe Pa [poor oeonouy ee pate oe na i sre one ‘Rie peg beim espn tee spay ec aah ll te emporio wo aod tis "plow eso ASNT, yo rap) a8 og 0 ‘ip seen jue apm enon Sons! HSN A 1 sie oerm ea “05 pn ap og a ane sx adnan epg oom uM | ‘Toy porn rama aes dow oud or 0 gS {omen aoe “Ie NBrowesy 9) eons pe oe ep in ume ot Sean 5th nN 99 0 Spestanénad po pene 0 op ons mt, ABC ‘prio some ead sep one HBO SA vwsmpea ap a Fam] >erewody seein | sopniopo ase a —— pea eid sem Pepe spon | su Saas is pe esis sonst ao oc eer prog ae ‘aeons sa stoped : vena | mt sone kien | ——— atop ———— biermpopisd | ———— serge suo Bendg 240 °Chapter 2 IL The Reification Error Comparing Apples and Existentialism ‘Tes iC a He i Waa at a! i the Reerion Boor $ Teistecing tt miseing trp barac concep as ifthe wer con ‘ates rin thing cle fein T fora 3 Soweto enc) give tame shen emg tes a sh Bing bet niente wore rR a pnt erm sie. 18 ey ore tse ‘eset nt sing thu sumone sai “ha Rae oi ‘Src dun eco twee ese op ognize an mie se tf ter pops wel aot on behav Unum, hon ‘Sry enema nas eset relight conmac er Tea ty nine tre, Yor See 0 lov, you nett tov efie-asfscenten wr some Kl of omnes a nb pe {ada or cl amo sp ae. ‘Te any cons hat sna nthe el of poe coy venting Tt bts ew ineigence omens ‘esion Shapes Cention ea as frsonaly eset dors {beuneomdoss eat esses ‘tere toc se eal sg ofthe term terse eo of he ast perience fiestas in he enema ei” (Fl emerber ht mass meraporied ens ot ofciv ety Ht ‘inert spe laa stig, he Fates pedi py err ieekal™ Tak tha gvesion tcaare ‘Xone things shes concp Toe sa hg themida cae ‘ep ales att ngs we ng estate seaenp Ths {He gneon, te pens rb pylon” ae ss “omparing sper nd sss onan ar araterlasaon res epion of hun sce. In sng he tea ah mpg, Fo (19571968) lwo mea ly ar hn ae cos etn hat have pee ani he ah. ute they wee e's shand wy of desgnaring maou oth esorliypocees Reo a hex cont “fl so de ‘Ending whch nse Hm epics ew of ow pole wor In ke lon the wconaour a oe "Sieovead” eas ew ian ss not sentanered far ued ates Wee “Cte” the Serenep an pp a pow go oun eu, 1 pes pote suo na eros ore yw oa eosin nat ages armpes age op og ON en “ie aos, fuonenon, pmo Spay “Tag ius sna sodlSsi ansgspaa t ony Boy ye jou a sors Hong expe ‘nc uopeisat wpun maucuayd a ange sues 41 feu) ‘tae 1 2 pps ron yr ypu one “Nouuaou oy wooo put tnd wopous wounds way Baraca ten ney aetna a op a "pos ‘pion "wees “opened Jo aap ‘js py Hos jo stn Aa poner sce Dano some aime anor ‘xp serge me ema mart fog, Paar + on a ‘Boum snbno> omen Abi ma a ‘Sep von pond eens fq ers a) pene asn as Stops weve fap oe sony se jos sor ren sans slg ee eye Soncees -zlpasng pny noo tn a 84 a, ma oan are mee "ssa sank ne 3 pee 0 a UE "eee a 2 ada 4 puja ay 0 apuR 9. ‘ang Suns wean jo ams apn ato 8 SO, He 38) ‘tenn oa fn oy end ain es “eeogyney esr soa fe, aan a ‘essa py er sumanie apd ay, US 0) “ong neni pt og mg do om ssesong sau iear a eau pune owen pooled "eta anja cosy ea hay Su Sy Suce Ba ‘gay sr sas os ain Sure pau Sane snc ung soe ns omen a a a ALO aH JO WORTOMOA TUL 6 stone — nape ae ee cont ‘ttn so, = a ten (0) mm (my Stent a Seiten _ = slayong come iat — ath bq sown pas napa on 8 eer sooo ‘am song nes — sa Ee st a = meer im ae se Shee ee “ne ee “<9 ser pomp nao aces acpece =e (sain ze sony) Daasus pepo saa pa et age sop nun oo oe fs fa itoord (eaoodl Dei tae ED) sie onsrayy oe al bape ea Se ta spnnsuoo put sia Sunes. 1-2 ame owD4y SoRaHeD INO LAE OLcoe: Conepaiig Phen or wrong, core one Tie aes F Ther ae, pri Flere an ere ea). Fre etie ce: hoerer er Conse Thee, which are neve capt fbn proven diel Ar sds sens jet Const “Fy eon of cg, Ho then, ate we to ene Const ‘Tew Sly pin es of th lth ary fl fr nae Infeting us to eaibe, ed rested arcu enone? Fs Sey can sire ol at Nemo’ heey of gaan fe ‘ough mat cle lo ne hor of oro [eens ning ts lee haan using he (Benth tpe Tou vant shall pure coated sod ‘Sl eke en ntact se scald eid, reves, i rete, dicariod ‘wy artesian impo? ec we create ating bt cepa oto etn hosp have or uses when Weenie SEES ever ey In pari we mast be vps earl 10 (25 Clee theory esing them ae they wee Een Ten. ‘acest eyo opr’ ypeC Thor tre oct Tees dere he ut sme er on pins une oh ‘impose en the ule ps ane tat dosnt en none ‘Comolli aly athe net Why? Beas he esto We ‘Sting ian nt, lng Tete tence we canner prov ar orre ay he ex oct ofthe uconocuy epost fo ok whe rea ey Sea thetane nyt lac ews ot nature” Gray SESS mal“ nt arb" an eves Vl” Sane iis ming mae an aypotbexl moa archi too: theta, fom Neen o Ensal,ve etd secreted oss em reining wey bjt ine ese apes to Be arated 0 ober bjt were ne vey nna consequence of hs onset he Bl of pydclony teeming wih euted af ena unsped aies ‘Rar tae log oversayed dr eae Way do such ete pers? RESTS tk ins sess har Sey Have seer Ben ely le ‘ecw soe pope mialealy ake a clcence of thi ey eich hese he ain fn, ae? Nv once weal tt hey ety ula, pe ¢ Thar and tur ae nox cipal a being FOE ‘iSelect upopie citeon era rang se heen Tey shal be gested lyn tor of te ‘fies or ck te "MRE ote aed be? Dot make te lake oping conn nora, Remember tate € Tears we a8 eject fs omen ot ee jist wing be subi prin i Oo tae aE ee eh en ads WtheRetfeten Eee 13 sectiongage and impetus eens to pin Tew oan Notes 2 8 Ratan ETI i ywchen pide 8, Cin me = eon = = oa —_ = Sa = ea = ee = ze a a —— ine ttnapus a pao yng peeve Op opm wea somo (0g PY a ag ee ices song ao Pu ease Sp tO ps “nce por sm fy os 9p po ong dv ay na a Susan ae spy us ao basin pm pou ssn 4h oa oa poe 900 ‘notion ys sjot an ao) tbouizadusuans a [anu or mds sun a oop rn 0 Ape ay eo un BQ ‘nso edocs onan mp noun Gf te {San stun seo pao foo aria ey Sa eae guano Den 0 ‘eae pr jamu eys n mim ta alittle mai pd Treen ne cusp eerste Se a SEIS care 1 ean pee fem pe [saipanint almost act's a OE sons oa i a a opty a an pt Soe ta ya mln | HI Pa ‘suave ors ug ar na a cea parse eo Spe roar OR ua ‘oor snope pue ase a "fem oo aauruce Hos rove wane oy Sasa nfo ra a Ly (qotli) os sao a fen) on te rope nei weap sso sp M4001 qb a np esos ce ps ies ome wpm a woned = HAS U KON Sx sama youd ged pa, nop A "pte sp rep porns Tong me st yes os pone fur a sts ory pnts Xp cane so me St ‘pr sts opp BUNS oe esteseeom oN SS'aeose ap ot a) Ah Toman oops) Ae ‘gpd ni pogo oan pap se OBES A oy, tre qs fe sto na Gu pose us ‘hun dh pp any susp saa so 4 sod plu sig (am) rn sos eer ea ‘po an 0 co 5 py pw ame a et Fa p38 = PP CRB yp 1) an ae onal ones 0 saan TH ro eluent ana pase natn md ¥ feo seus eer roi ate squaag eoiFojoyoasg pue Teoistyd Jo AyoUEYMUIS ay WordyOSeq Jo Saar] adn INW ‘TIT ¢ sndvyyPx: ne Conpoling Pena 2 Whe fae A henge Fs manila ie x eh being ed te) then heb canges acing sly when Frese Atos ‘ign sve be mnie ies Sch sing sed then Event changes arden py parla ateson oe tonne He empl easy ent A sot reine vet hn by ‘te Aamo cose B Th or A eal rea Bie A et ‘Sednue FursiEewh ad Erb car canna hen A es ean 8nd fue Bes nto A Aa, et rat ‘Satay he hy 6 oo Gr they caves cies ‘tener Fring Cente dino wk Soulless oe doesnot crete hr be ty ene {Epa fenenenon snp Gesell ef ast ire se he ony cre scat saeco opel even fore ven eden, buchen cin ene ‘Slaw oy Sonos ue arg ans pel mn ethno a's pal ent The saponin owls In fc Es ‘Rhema toasune ate mel ere ome eaepeng py ‘reine Tsing haps and eet eal noo eet ‘echenial th dsons deen, shri. They oe al ‘Shoe rays nwa fr scaly. wher ce a at {Spee re wor ppteog sl leap we Iida te hey oe Strona one "pebl- ont see De esa Sa aoe e saa aoe eee Se eae or ere ements ea ee etn nc ental Sree poate sa sean Seen radiates tates ae Sede ae i tac eee tee nes pee Tae antec vet geangein te U.AbkpieLeete Design 17 rotate le any spc phys lines hey seins ump othe con “Sit hes blom set pyar Be ‘Bema” When we cnn the inane ul py pe rer his sees (ad Inf pee ba den Asan lsion of thi Mectougy, lets sae the phenomenon of “ane ving th dave mde Scion (el fg 91). the ‘ropa! ee! (5), se ee pf beater acy (ue ‘eal fe seman of the one peo Fer ook ‘hoch err erlang). Cover. he eo. Tepe! oe!) acy ete he sje pra nd epeie ‘prcenin ra Tuy nerecesy dvs ase fl al nt dee ‘fie each thy ae iit a mules eowens mee ‘fsb nwo ret Was ane no ieee ees of aaa Pt other a, By dws cae Py and, oes case Bete ey ar tether at gar Peet) The sue sue rl ell pe ‘men, tol tober. he lasnrp Seren “phic and nan by Seon not conceit ene eel “Tdabone on temple lay hat» pera’ nny en 1) aus want fener Even 2). Ths vet anc fe te ‘how alee hs enconal Sacre) hich ecm he Holga crea (or “aay af hs pyc hve sate) ree 2 the ete Even mama the mains laf cn fv aay Feducin (eececoatie tates, aan, aie wh fad ‘elec i) parser searcher sc) ‘Noe le pete Ut epson dec asuge sms by ak ing a any ncaa Th eta vet & Wik cos he ‘enc fy (avaon he preys sino the noone ‘es sue dang wl ew euclapaleontgraon) ah (je ‘hens cel el, Aerating pl te yerzon opr soothe anaes phe who pomp oe thn kode ‘eon and eppre hare oncones Theme Even feb ‘semtialyequtee the ne pce by eakng tangles. Ts vo ‘Stat Counc aon ruses o faehoter) ae the Se (le oe Mettawa MU, elle stays of Csi. Fete cer ours acon ovat th lal en ppc ‘el enon i may iin wn nan, by “peahane eh cosa yur wading hee ast snl lng iftrec phenomenon fr nn, ison, anger, sa nt ‘preston oay example efron chs sn th lel ee sftcscpion Wu ae ay Bo hela co mt pape Sequence ng gure 1 aa engl Touch ure aon he oul equncs a ach ee of sda see ae area sae ae aoe aoper verona ns Sat reson oe Sona =e soe 4 coor outapr nm som she ad utd ‘one pd voranr nian eames ma man roped ‘ones =< snes = oP pot re sone Ina soot om so 0 0 PU 0 (ORE) EY HM sary £58015 mugs epee woh i sooo et ‘tet nar prt ott ttm pena at ap) canon to na i'n eet ogo ae SSeS Ses Sega me Si ee eather enna ness oir SN pep ene rim so UN pace 6 He SEE ata eat png Seana pap aN TY yg ale > “io a al fms no ee 61 toning p aor aC ao 265 eee 2 REY Hy LANDA pow BaP [petra pa nephews Mela ros gdp poy ors sg 0 NE bump eoond ponte oye ust a ad {Foor escent ap ono mad jog jos Spy pus eo yp anon el sp 1M5 resop cia sn por saab yon way foes ay aK Sov pessoa snep oy ogy te ag sds Soi cy sa poy ue p> a oye sa) Dao $e utoy su Sb vop oni SPT SOE Pe Shee ue ae mune paso «ay pO ‘ran non Gra eugene “Ze o) a etme psc sin D2 al NOD “ade oneguas eons pea sau 08 rp faaag PS ‘ov saaino mop ou iso ane ceed oe ‘pam soates 49 me pm 8 S82 ero pe ion od yap de 39 2 195 vores oem age ay J st Wn Totton fer sec oop sem eo ea 4 Fost po cso Bene Ne Ro Stet Suge oop ena oso soa AP spon sg ne eso eo oa a a (Gynt goes sa) ma 8) gap sno 3 soa als aN 00 FO Sas yelad a foyer unt see hur on 28m, ong (Ef svn spa 2) wes sdsecpd ace se) ‘Pabst oo sp an ppc au at adv ap Aad [anne eur aeuip su psa po opr om eoouyg forme 200 my|TV. The Nominal Flac and Tapp Reasoing 21 Chapter a The Nominal Fallacy nao me ct tt gellar eet hat Sloe cement t | eens octet emma IV. The Nominal Fallacy and ihe) Satan ceet etter ee sane same ; ery Tautologous Reasoning yn ere fy no ing we” To Name Something Isn't to Explain It "Because she got sci” ‘oy ocr ce pe ety on™ Suomen ny dete pain ea eset, aol ear of beg?” “Gere gies” ny he reaped with hwnd a ht She has seis doce ees i Seat erotics” ‘esi die eer Why doe oy sey ued yng apn on “Ara Blok “Because hls got Froteurim* ‘esa 4 Tautologous Reasoning eu The Non Pal pay ne ear tg mig A ‘ee tanga mesey pte fsa een yt sale: ord tht ently say te same ng tice or exp Tepe who ra ‘te aout oer ite empire pole who ee ent ce ‘Hout oh er "Pie who day gre ipurmen fn ey ete igo hin who echt iy oe pres ‘Semen that cps ah runt logy ae conceit ‘cha ay at hee prptn ure aed eae cans eile rine, "err os gy heey ae” alec“ ie opal "your amen you've, you et lokngin thet ple” nega logs the seenent ae ie ‘ostens ome o ll ifr Sry the dt am, ‘eb tear tin pend my ranted eich, ‘hevwoald bey ganda) itn, bt Cteaooly) pies‘cr cyen Sa10N jooxd pow pean ww 2 fn pp ap ame 2 at dom fon ep pend oy Soe eNO “Se aeons oy gens odo ep lg "iam open ep ou sys ee a ewe sn inte een agea a 9 oy ‘eenanan paren arom fae a pa emotion anny eos an oh ‘Soe crore otc ly ‘Sead gp spa garg cpa ‘stem oy og unr nD ur ae ‘yo esp om pr oe ap as ‘poe ts Spent a a nid ‘Slips apn sap pny a oe ‘eno ace 9, Bawa sono pag Fo a ‘Bong a ma ep aoe ap ota eae -meageppienu i a ose, et gma 0 oagman wd esd EP a _putomyanys Saye nner, 09 eno pungent ad aye 09 pn TEA 18 yee, te! std Se ase J ndnd soe sonal Spoon! An 34 8 Ae ££ Auwony seotqoum, po nye ony a, AE npn mag oq powgye ef as ep Ho HA 9 OH, opt tsi) Pong P52 .etap yar Bose sono aoe me Ep AN, pres ays ons aan W361 18 MOH MOK Ho, “Spat tog acd 39, 8 a a ng su ea sy ep sun eeeeny‘ge on Suey Sep, soap odor Bawa) a Bas A, Lp aspiowg, -shyougmps non ego et aoe ni 0p pt reo) pig jo sou» pu ayo ua lab on ep ponaeony Ss Jo wep w sooNeL ‘Dp soso sso Husraetps spacdnp esl nyo ue op aupaniog wunty Jo moe vou PON) “sium no sop oteanng shane © Hyp pen. we Stays agaop depp sper no] pp a8 eS, sat ee supe aaa Jo" SuoErNs RRO sPUM aL np anmptoppronucind asa fun 0%8, “amy 510 8 PP =P 2 op EI PI AA, somo shoo jo snore 5 sie 2p teen peg 18 OY Mop me, enon aeosg peur oso, sup fon sop Pe a een anette m0 9a pO onion ce hid tt Sys sstaene sues sep oN e2uousye Bade 9 ue ee2A Pat One Canepualag Penamens Glossary Terms “Th lowe a a in he sae = — Chapter 5 ohn igre Sern eon dtr Some tiene one ere V. Differentiating oe FE aloe evening Dichotomous Variables Ietntty and Continuous Variables Black and White, or Shades of Grey? oc | ‘incre cn oem ay io) 2s~ ining Anes yh, “poem ps Se ise es oped nod ee son suns ~ psp yond — eaom foe ene eke Se ogpmess soil tomas aod Bow —tannma tones re grave ate pa sepsis -yscend on ps Seer po Mie bea seen pe aia pogo Solo (sande de snsuy 0) vorsoxaed cout? xs st pu (gf som aH a pu nop ap pes fo esunio tenons pr shake ‘tema ie aoved pao ot a spe Ss AL Tes asparg ne [nee aan TE Se me) ym smog ow nema stowminpng FuNNDDTT A asp asgep pene Sggpasee rape rogmnes ba Sin oer ne ale) “Seepage open mote pomp pon) ‘pure rorracsnote8 uy ye en pone pane rnd snus tn i pean 0a pune az don asp sexgnum opi nagupion o nes a8 a WO A Smt pot so fundus ar wim a9 osuopnesish oe ane or smote spc os ac om ale et Sor gad po y wae og Seo) unmonanys opBa se ia atest sy sa oli spo uD ot 3 ‘1 pons pny (omnis ed ti) woe fomarionod our sgn one eed 36 PAs unow soe seyr fee seep orp © say 3 > ely syslog nit oo ue aan og “aiap mr aa sy potato wos 0 sander ye ol i ys se eo “Shum 2 toma yan i sim samo 3 ‘ep i sop xin pores pos fp «39 IM ‘poe pad sane tahun a oe SS Sie roms od 0 Sedo mont am Alo 0 ‘Bens see onan nson> ae IRL AND eno ae) ps ope a eA « (fd ce a) 509 1S ND WINN Y + "iy do a bon eS gr EY © "yo wp PIE Y sey np aor eae ed nana a ann pepo, wan, 9 “Mrecaqionm ne Soy pa pp emo pe Speci une sma ord luxe na ny Sy ee Seiesucooyd jo sede sau) bul boppeseo wo samen Ae “on on em) ap 9 ee a aan uo montouny 249g28 Pat One: Coes eon eer Seam © Theoretical and Clinical Applications Intenso eel en he oct fe cot itu he feo mecha cing I cpaing ey ‘no Soopent tone weoews ef. Ke 07 Mac Be ran 91) heer he il bth we ys ese ‘eat eonar he mtr Acrhgts hese se, od ‘Repertreet nfe: ynpng Sepang” wd fot era tad compas by eg thn alles ‘a a, mante th sane ease medion, wey e "rea vein tons mae pel of lg ldecigmen . “is etch ao ar meru pions he rte pp cote A conto go of copie hy sponse ‘eipcens moth bac ore ein eng recs Ciao eet 80 he Bar 99, peso wh ng {ede ay ea o ea and mod sh chosing pa fen 2 so tins pero pect and “te tlre Improve ieee tomancon so fda deat cs ‘si day yer sn am ai Sco ‘sibs sch "ou tes ow aor Fp aig th gi ok ay ee) seg Nt jon (L160 Bon my adage stg Sea ‘ane anes aon eae Srosd ts Ue aM 1 ‘apy Si seid eng ps ony onenon nt tro oumus orn yp esandSo fa od uy genic uo sag ge tp ond aa A Slaiy ye sg Sons yo al} clans a {am ann 0 aa a ero GzP 1 ‘Sm tory rwoncn moana fee nh SNE 4 dyaou aia my, Deep ean nn pm toes ea aque sen nod es oe ony ooo Poeapan 3 ‘he serps pur nt og on senp aA nod se soeasan eo eng mye ay inoansp po sun an dept pu adept pom ogy doy pot “lor Saree pursue apt po anyon ares! pot ‘Top sem pur uopeay ‘nad poopy says ose Say sp alo une eg, tmp Supp oe rp te sar popu Jn be rosa Seep ange = ‘bea pr in en eae ‘op mov am ny csi Yu, yo awe psa “iru mot psn po osprey OE ‘Sebpepnman ey oem apm 9 pe OF Fe aaldo a BID TA = __ er 2 QUA 09 S] ISeIIUOD OL aysoddg ayy saprsuoy ‘1A 9 sdoyPa One Concepaling Pinon Signond Freud crit considre he ppt wen he anepund ‘he eg done mechan fc fmatin ch nese ‘bs tarsraton af unceale ple t ops thus ‘noe bcp frms (A. reat 196) For stance, tte Wo wes ‘Scouts ages lng od BSc ay became ees onzrd for is ele a sly. eis eer wh apex ob ‘hemes amprogrpy tay be unas) maa by te es {dese apne wc es poy cunt ke ane pti ‘tho vey pone nerds oon ay be ang ecard als is her om ncoscus Momeni deste (fora sae qosennae dat us fhe Metauge explore eles ‘out etl fel eration. ee apent 3) cal ser Many encanta therapy (ee 98), fr anc a esged tol ets cone (al hrely nee) espa Sepals a yeh len lt betwee Hs deste rage Seuss fang be gs eps mh ae oe payee Tog tceen the psig et ting When fed wits en ee ( eo mah rin) thc he io ne! ste fan ‘ip ines ve sah fed Semen wo aman pees slings dt mee my fe nou cae wt toe to conser theese equ to ery poate pre deo, fc sean of Meaugh ithe cll ecigeof ring pep pana ine Pl 1988 Hale, 1970, [ech therapar geste cena dreine that eo ke tual wants ‘ee he etn ange aera conroeace tthe het [Eph thei Tseng and undermine cen estan ‘ng fron strain the tf change o ener eer ‘cy spat the unvnted or uncer In el, te ther Feral peor might beuaed te bare even mare upon. Or = ed couple etingherapy with cop a thy ig tosh ry tected ogo Rene alae eb, wer daly fone Wek Sinn x cen who ata of og ee may be traced forth exe ‘mek not spend ay tne aloe To ake suber camp, how might we con person of things to soi sr patent n peep” align, me it pe ‘Sie the ne eps bey ipa te rae sco VLconsiderthe Opposite 33 4 1 a ma ot ret ret ey ih, agains on RE et ee area fit blr da ey crt? (era phage da nor ip leh mtb yo nti i : den ro too . 8 Pa, teint ala fetta aoe nde oan atone 7 Buh sy oye apa hae pmbe puts wc”ssi apoio pet cr sad pedo tint ato sop g) Sen ep sami ores be wn > ‘lure anos ores nape i 00 ‘Sane spine pny mon So pod a | aia : oe ogee none os Tee ti a ‘SES ong opp tn ey ed ES aman aleu monies. ea ‘Seis lpeds puja Spansion gato sae ae = me (Shoendio a Sepp oon nae ose pea sees eh rey guog reuosreduy Jo uonnjosoy ays psy 1-9 ION sg clea Se spoon mp9 Th oworey)SuRIeMDN) 230 5g36 Pex One: Conn Phenom In efing a0 yor segs to hs exes rey emma he oxen) ewig se es om opps especies Las esi some pial insane o santa a whi tling ‘hich of orn ne opsite may contr to esc eo Ion tne eons Notes 79 Ai ei rai fe 59, HIME pct eae Glossary Terms ‘The fatoning es (rns ate ine in thes “eo erbuson sce tenses ‘tigposs Upton che aes aaa ‘hic ‘iene Serene euhteer Site ‘epecna sepeton do Feronaly Foe feescpiae rojo Phe Frcotgl rele a Soe eon pesicn ‘i Cansei Oppcste 37 mal tsonent spam theres ‘heey te ahsuyo'a ssquesie 9 wa aoa ga n 53 paw w sdoun ap Bdny ent oo ‘an poh to ten see yur cag oH "op ny eroded a abies ou Stop soe 0 A Seu sng poses any oo alse ‘Bars sa poe po aro sok pm souteno [as edn oa St 9) do 9 oa wk Sauna poe sie Saws supupa voy Bu eam ‘eon enor nj ep as ets oun ayo o> $henay erm Ane ao aed se ae ‘un pag ap Teta Sem gen eps se ‘ssc or apo ops fea an al unsang pomanan nan 2 3 Mf oe “on cl es pte ese oS ay pond eaman es Aeon et SH nc noo) wan on saosin ‘Sand vamp win epee dr po en {nn wy eg por nam ge in oy 5 gsm sous a E93 BE ST PHA macnn nna py 90 S39 Yeas a oq oping mg m9 0 5] eNO 9 Ea ET HO oro oy pS ve wn una ay sng a se eg ‘oko etd rary tgs anonym) sin So ag gone '9 sano ann Da =v 2am 1902 Bu 0p pom ey Bags 2304S 9) pl ng ae on xian a un eg 6 sopeny sont nm 24, 04 ~ ee [= ged tapnag noua erat orm WIFIWIG pue FePWIG \pog ary euawouayd [IV xopesed Ssouanbrug-AyreyTUNS OYL “ILA. L aasdoyyFat One Canepa enone on you meet spre th quetian wih an ines ig beni utanes tt ae ly to bon your ene lee te oe nse woul beh Ti este hat ona he ber te thugs bata cial nee pe mer Fonte eherhand yo were ook the ame ie ba i time tll se Ferns mou inte caret arse wuld be D (Glin) tecase he eer hee de ae eer comple el ‘aarp, taco, cpr wou proper athe. “he augose ht ou se tempting oer nes cs oft cme tne lente mes ge Hee tbe Ce “Shower woul te tceae fe legs el metas cat ‘only pene ty acre (peal x Aten De peti De (eer sometnes or meg tec. Ty le ty hat you ae condaciagresuch no he drain of roam pen to ppl sl cas rom 8 ape pi, he Fenner bec cn cle) wa cgay anlage ‘the works on feos sla, CocsCas CC") (Ando ett ‘Noesong on ttc bn cha a) Leto ap ck and examine net deta he neacig eo exe comping sh costing penn Fae now ewe dtr ‘bedeges owt phesoena a nr Te paw any two pena eine coon fara oe damental mney: ane hy te both phenntens Ws ss sting pi, hey ay sbseueny Ce ‘Speed long ital intra of denn "stg as ‘ann ome de of univers propre othe mint om or sinc, ate he phenemens in qonionobtae py) or theoreti Cesecpa? thera in which cmap oi Hf living of noalving? Testa or exraterestral? If Eving on eh, which yes! Gena? Spe? Ser? If human wht af haya eats {Pgs wei nat ee clr, ay nen tratrenest? Demo pic cheer ase. many cae lon, Lone, ‘cigar? Sec conten Compete opera sacred, ambi ‘cule, spp) rset ane elec, maa pe Isat pier, oping chine ard arson ane ten mnoadon noth swtene oes bee since, goa? Psa ‘ns ins muse on ersten sows app? When compan ay vs penamenaon hee ans de oth) Hao ter ow many te tay might hr in comune no eesing be eae fa at sop, here il be accept {Erbin inte on whet he enor ier We may foie ars pnt of itn PED), bee whch he pea ‘cee eining an aAMP ARS Gayton items Vi. The Sinn Unigene Prox AT Ce hen hen eat sting defi car, hd ones 2y wo permenant thw ny and ein he PCs hat eo Ror ie pra ce wser stay er ten wee ‘tree eer he ana temeen he evens e soa examine the ares happen Bethe PCD by cones re wk ose he ‘Mfc been te same to cen Sel us om eves hat ‘ppc ate rhe PCD, (Ofer on sland congreense der Eiking of tr enti, we shld eae the vals Ua area Techie and afer tbe ACO, th prc atecon othe PCD i) Sonnets ote cane a dept nthe Ven agri fue rn meeting tae pute, oe ta ovepping a ste ‘Gmmenity been theo ptenonana Ths, age of Seep esate ort no (that morse, then recs), reas sry sll ae oni 2 lor ‘rani teens a (te eres han sine). ‘woe pene Tose Figure 7-_four ainsi beeen phenoment A and 8om cxxtrageans Snr cee ae SR same | “rena oom eal oa Samo nce pox pa 0) “ye pueos sommpais so, apuewos pr cid = sas SS eh oe oes wossad aaipo fue pure asinod vortneoud pur Aderampoaied came — remem oo ea —— crest ma — cee ett spa bmn erent tit segnnspii se apace ce nora ar Eoreurers scape ent, rennet gl = — enue Began Petree curation eo Sa nit elas a eee oe SS, hme, stia ina cannon recent pa sng ron re pe poor esp nok sao ‘Seo ya po sa TLS agape pe ong os ee ee hose oe eae momen SECIEy gana a ; retenperaioed —— “sur ie ales emma ee net ee top at sno! ta sei neo Ua 8 “utp gogo i oss eens op eh a sep ees fp we aq st 990 slogan pera pina "0e ¥ 9 A SeAN GGovecty eat 2) AEA a Sonepat US ‘Stepney aa = no pu