Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sciencedirect: Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 - 165
Sciencedirect: Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 - 165
com
ScienceDirect
Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 165
"-
. '$
/
+
0
)
1 " . -" 2%
!" -
)$
)03
0"
"!
)0-
+ '& ! 5 0
/&
6
"" 7")
&6
8
$
)
9
- !! "
# $ "%
!"
$& :
"
"
) +
"
)
"
""
)
+ !0-4
+ " 5 $%
/&
<
!"
$& )$
"
%
+
"
%
1%:
1 $
&
"
%
))
"
)
<1 )
%
&1 + !
) )
+"
%
) " =$
%$
&
;"
$ "
))
"
)
;+
-
"
$& :
)
"
$ "
!0-4
"$
+ ";
)
#%
/
& > !"
$&
% +
& "& $ " & %&
+
" +
"
+ "& "
":
"" )
$
%$
))
)
"""%
=$
&
)
!"
$
""
"
%
"%
!0-4 %$
"
%
"+)
1)
%
&
+
"
"
:
1"
+" )
%
&
+
&
&
+ $
?1 "
$
""
))
%
"
+" )
)
<
" !0-4
2016 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license !" #$"
$%
" %&
'(
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
$
&)*
!
+,
+A !
A0+
90
+ $" !B 5C A ):B 5C
)* ()""D$
$
&
2212-5671 2016 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-reviewed under responsibility of Universiti Tenaga Nasional
doi:10.1016/S2212-5671(16)00020-4
Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 165 157
/3/3 4
,
5
+-
4
)$
&)"
;
;"
&
)
;
+$
%$
"
)
)
E
)
"
%$ "
)
$
&
"
%
"$+" "
"
))
-
4#
"%$+"1 F"
. 6)
1 555A G%
&1 3& . 4"
1 A +1 4
"
. 7"<1
$
$&
"
""
))
"
)$
"
?+1 8
&./
1 C !" +
)$
"
@-
4 %"
"
) +
%& 7%
2:& #
"
&)
)
$ =$
& 8
. H
+1 >
-
/&
1 #<
<1 #
))
/"
5
"
$
+"
%
"
)
+
+
&
" $%
$"
1 "&
&<
5C $%
/&
" 5C
) 5C
"$
<
+ !")1
%
"
+
%"
"
$
)
$
)
"
)& " =$
)
;"
1
"%
&
)
&
&
")$
)&
@
) +
&)
&
/3-3
2
)"
+ 0-4
-
4
"
!
)
)
)
" $
+ +$
+ $"
#%
. 71 !"
&
+"$
)$
) 0-4 !"
%$
"$
)$
)
&
""
+)"
$
;"
""
%
;"
))
&
+"
)
"
;
+#
+ 8
1 #"
-
- 1 #
-
$0
)
$%
#$
#-0 # 1
#$
+ 7
'
#7'
#$
<
) " =$
%$
) +
$
!"
% %& "
#7'
"
)
+
<
)
"
7
) #$
+ 0
!"
";)
" $
)
$
/&
1 " '$
/&
&)
+ "$+" "
) 0"
0" 5 ) " E
+ 4=$
) '$
/&
7$
'" 0"#"
. #%
1 >
-3/3
45
'
$&
1
%
)"
"
)
"$
;
!"
%$
"
$
"
)
"
"
%)"
%
+8
-
"
)
+
1
&
)
-
1"
+" "
+ "
$)
"
$
$
"& $ " & ")&& =$& )
<
/
& >
$&1 "
" +&
@%
" $
"
--
"
")
+"
$%
""
))
;"
$"
;
+
+"
1"
$
"
" -C5
)"
"+
) )$$
+
"
"
""
)
+
& %& $
+
;"
""
+$& /
"
1)
#%
7
#%
/
& >
$&1 " *8
-
"
" )
+
+ " )=$
&)
158 Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 165
$
")
)
"%
+
=$
)%
$ I
!" )
$)$%
@
)
)
%%
"
;
")
"
+
'
1
+
+
"
" "&
)
&
)
"
"
)
"
"
=$
-3-3
6
,
<
/
& >
$
;& )
" )) "
)
#:
7; :"
+ !" !0-4
$ "$+" " $
1 $
"
1
) )$$ )
1
"
" )
" ' C 1 G&
?
;J"
C
"++
6+
") 555
$&@
$
<
/
& >
$&1 "&
"
)
"
"
+"
)$
" !0-4
$"
&
<1 & ) %$
&1 )
%
&1 +
"
)$ +
"
"
"
"
$$1 $
&1 %
"
<)%)
!"
"
+" "
)) "
;
%& )
$"
%
)
")
+
1 "& :
1)
%
&1 +1
$)
"
1
&
<1
=$
&1
"
$$1 )
+
1%
%
<
&
)$
$"
"
%
!0-4
""
%
$"
$)
"
1 +1 )
%
&
$
&<./
&1 >
#
$
$& %
-
"
%& #%
/
& >
"
)%
"
$$
" !0-4 " " !0-4 ";
)
" #%
1 7
'&
C
$
$& !"& :
) +
"
$
")
)
"
$"
%
1 $
&1
"
$$
1
<1 )
%
&
$
)
-
"
" !0-4
&
""%)
@
"
) :$
))
02
"
!"&
)$
"+
)
+"
$
"
%
'
")
+
1 "&
$++
"%
"
$$
)$
)
@
!0-4 %"
!"
""
"
)")
"
)
&
<
"
$$
" " !0-4
-373
%%
" "&
+
"
"
)"
"
"
"
""
#+
& "& )
"
"
%
"
" +
"
" +
)
@
%")
")
)"
;
+ $"
&
% "
" +
F
. /;
+1 5- -
1" "
$
&
+
& "& "
" "
+
A " :
$ %& "
" $
$
$
%& " +
1 %
A " :
$ " +
&$
"
"
"
"$$ "
+
%
" " +
)
"
"
+
"
!")1 +
&
%$
) "
)
)
""
1
+
%"
<
. /;
+1 5-
$ "
)
&
& !")1 " +
" ) $
&
$)
$"
)
&
& !"
"&
"
%
"
""
"
"
&
"
:$
02 +
" $
"
& "%& "
+
" $& )$)
"
%
+
:
<
+
""
K " !" +
+
;
+ $"
&
" " %$
1 "&
+
$
;+
!"
"
$& "
""
"
)
"
)"
& !"
$ %& #% 7
555
$& " "
""
+
)"
+" )
%
&
)
"
Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 165 159
-383 %
7
+
+ "&
%
"" )
$
%$
))
"
)
"
%
"
" =$
&
)
*
$&1 "
" " =$
&
)
)
)
"$
555 :
""
$
""
"
+&
)" $
+)
&
"
+" =$
& "$
" ) $
&
$ "$
'
+ "&
$++
"
""
+" )
%
&
& "
)
+
+
"
+"
@)
%
&
$
+
$
)
2&1 E
.
"1 I 1
"
"
)"
/
.
1 C
73/3
!"
$& :
"
"
) +
"
)
"
"
)$
"
)
+ !0-4 )
'$
/&
"%
<
!"
"
$ "
"%
&
$
"%
!"
@
$ :)
" '$
/&
"
@
%
&<1
"
$
)
%"
,"
1" )
"
"
") " )
&5
73-3
!% 0 3
/"
0"
- /
$
(
%
'
+
"%
': #+ L + + )
E
+" )
L+
+" )
:$
%& " +
+" )
4$ L 02
& ""
L 02
""
<
) 4$
%
&
E+ !%
%& "
+ % %1 ) +
"
"
"
1"
)
+
+ "
+)
" %
% )
"
) +
"
@
$ /
"
1)%:
$
&1
% )
"%)
)
"
$ +
+"
+1
+" )
#
))
"
$"
)
<
+1 "
)
+
+"
)
$
$ -
1
)")
%
& )
"
"
& !;
+
/ *-!/ %
$
+ " $
)
$
" $
)
%
"%
)
!% 0 !0-4 -
0";
, -
-
" )
%
$
M
-
"&)
%
$
M
160 Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 165
I -
"
&@
;
"
M
C -
"
)
$
)"
;
"
M
-
"
"%
M
- G " =$&
"
& &M
G
"
&
) )$$ )
M
> G
"
&
"
) " )$$
+
1
1M
5 G
"$
%& "
&M
=$
"$
"
:
"
" =$
!"
%"
"
!0-4 ) "
&
:
+ !% %
" ";
)"
)
#%
/
& >
<
/
& > "
&:
$
N@
)
)"
)$
N @
)
&)"
)$
)"
&
"%
#%
. /
&1 > #
) "
"
"
"" "
;
"
$
%&
+"
N@ L
&1 N @ L
)"
"
":)
" '$
/&
@
%
7373 %
-
!" %
$%
"
:$
"
#%
. 71 #
+ F
/;
+ 5- 1
:$
"%
"
"
) :$
$ "&
+" "
$
%"
!")1 "
:$
" %
"
" " :$
"
+%
@ ))
)) . 0;1 ,"
1 3$
E$
+ C :
" ?
+ 8
+
)$
""
"
%
"
$
&
$
!"
$&
"
+
/; I
$& %& $
+7
+)
#%
7 "
":
" *8
?1 "
$& )
#%
/
& >
$")
"&"
"
""
"
%
"%
!0-4 '
1 <
/
&
$&
>
)$
""
"
%
"
!0-4
"
+"
"
&
)
"
%
!")1 " )
"&"
/(
9
'
9
"%
3
-
G
"""
+" :
;
+)
" +
<
&
;
)
G"&1 E
. 1 55- #%
7 :
" +
)
)
"
)"
)
+ !0-4
" *8
"
7; :"
+ E7 !"
$& )$
" " +
"
"
"
%:
"
"
" !0-4
%
"
:
) + +
+"
) :$
& 0-4 ?
1"
:
)++
"
+" )
""
" =$
&
)
)"
$ !"
$&
$
" "&"
)
A
-(
9
'
'
"%
3
-9(
'
9
'
"%
3
+ #%
7 1 $
&$
"
""
) :$
))
02
"
)"%)
))
0;
""
)"
$ %& " +
& "&
) ";
"
+
@
)
3$
E$
+ C )$
" 02 $
&
" $
&
$
!")1
Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 165 161
0%$& 0
4
55
""+
"$
" ) 02
""
)"%)
$
%& #%
7
- 2" #%
7
$&
" "
+
"
%
" $
&
)
*8
#%
/
& >
$& "
)$
&
"
%
" $
&
!0-4
"
-
+&
1 <
/
& > )$
"" $
&
+
&
%A
7(
9
'
% '
"%
! "##
+ <
/
& > 1
<
"
%
+ " :
)
$/
I
""
&&
+"
<)
$"
&1 $
1
$
%)
&
&
'
% + " +
&%%
)
;
) "&
)
O
1 H
+
0" C :
"
%
" )
+
)
<
)$
""
"
!"
$ +
;& $
)
"
+& -!
")
+ "
"+
)
&
)
?
))
4
"
)$
" " $
&
$
"
+ /&
")
< "$
"#
7"1 /"
?
&
. /$
)
$&
5 " " )
<
)
) %" -
)
$
%& /&
-
1"
$& "
$"
"
%
")
<
)
+ !0-4
:
1 <
/
& > :
")
<
!0-4
+&
)$
"
"
%
"
%
!" "&"
)
A
8(
9
'
# '
"%
3
$
% #"
1'
+
1 /
7
)?
")
%
&
" :
) $
&
$
%:
)
!" )
"
)
%)
)
"
+
$
;
""
@)
"
"
+
+
!"
)
%)
)
:
"
)"
)
"
+
& !")1
+ "&
#&1 7
?$
&
$&
$++
")
%
"
)
+
"
+")
@)
%
&
" "&
&
$
$
+
)
2& 1 I
"
.
1 C /
&
$
$""
"
%
")
%
&
"
$
/
.
1 CA 2& 1 IA O
1 CA /
& . #7"
1 - "
)
G%
&
4"
1
-
""
"
<
/
& >
""
"
%
")
%
&
!0-4
+&
"
+
$
" "&"
%A
0(
9
'
9
% '
"%
'
<
/
& > 1 + )
"$
))
$
$"
%
% )$
" $
=$
& !"
""
"
+")
@)
&-
1 A E
.3
1 A 2& 1 IA O
1 C !"
%$
"
"""
+" +
)& "
%& $%
"
+
%
)
"%
$"
""
+"
)
"
%
& &%
/
"
1O
C
% " " +
& "& "
%
$
:
" +
"
!")1 "
+
$
;& $
&
"
)
" -
+"
162 Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 165
))
)"
+"%
&)
&%
!"
))
+"
%$
)
$%
=$
& $ " +
&
"$+" " $
):
+"
""
)
)
" -
-
1 '
1 <
/
& >
""
"
%
" +
!0-4 "
" "&"
%
%A
(
9
'
'
"%
&
83/3 45
:
4
!% I !0-4 -
0";
, - 4
$
- CP
" )
%
$
M
- >P
"&)
%
$
M
I - CP
"
&@
;
"
M
C - 5P
"
)
$
)"
;
"
M
- 5>P
"
"%
M
- G " =$& 5CP
"
& &M
G >-P
"
&
) )$$ )
M
> G -IP
"
&
"
+
) " )$$
+
1
1M
5 G CP
"$
%& "
&M
-IP
=$
1
"$
"
:
"
" =$
'
" % I %1
" "
) " ";
" )$
)
!"
""5
;
+"
%
"$
&
" %1 "
";
""
&
"
"
%
!"
"
)"$
&
"
@)
)
"" "&
+
;
+ "
/
"
1 " ";
""
"" "
$" )"%
":
)
"
)"
=$
'" ) "
"
&% %$
" $
)"
)
"$
"%
"1 "
" )"%
$
"
&$
& " $%
"
)
"" "
)
"" "&
&
"
)
;
83-3 "
5
%
!% C 0))
* 7 0
<
/ 0)) 7 &7
< 0)) +
' 7 ' ! (-
0 5 IC
'- I 5C IC
III> C C
#+ ) G I 5- -C- CC
Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 165 163
E CC I CC 5-- I
+" ) 7
4 G$ I - >5 I
&
C5 C5 --5 -5 CC>
7
<
E+ >> C> CI I I-5
I5
5- >I C5
,
7 ) 42
-!
$
+(
6
Q
$
!" )
"
:
"
"
%
"%
)
+ !0-4
" !% C %1
$
"
""%
"
""
"
%
"%
!0-4 ?
1?
$ !"
$
"
$
$& )
3$
E$
+ C "
":
" ?
+ 8
+
+
/; I
$& "
"$
7
+)
,+
"
"""
+"
%
& $
&
+ !"
&%$ ""
+"
$
%)
+" &
+)"
@%
"$
+"
)
+ " )$$ )
&
+ . /;1 I
7
%J
:
"%:
"
"
)++)
+" )
%&
"
)"+)
L -1 L !"$
1?
$ !"
$
%
" #%
7
$&
"
"""
+" + + )
"
" "
+" :
1"
&
+)
!" :
&
;$
)"
:
""
+" + ) +
"
+
))
&
%%
%
%&
;
$""
&
)
% "
$
" -
#%
.71 G
"1 )
" !% C1 "
"
L 1 L CC %
"
+" )
+
!"$
1 ?%
$ !"
$
" " #%
7
$& ?1 "
+
""
%
"
"%
+"
&""
&"
%
)
%& &
+"
) 0-4
!" "
"
:
" $
&
!0-4 !"
$)
!% C " "
"
%
"
%
L -1 L
"
!")1 ?I
$ #%
/
& >
$&
""
$
"&
)$
&
"
%
" $
&
!0-4
"
,
"
""
)) ) $
&
"
) 0-4
$"
1"
) "
"
+" % %" ) "
"
02 $
"" "
%
"
" "
+"
% ;
$%
""
#
<
1 5
$" %J
)"
$&
:
%
")
<"
" :& %& "
)
!0-4 !"
"
%
<
!0-4
)$
%
"
L CI1 L --5
"
+
?
1 ?C
J !"
$
" <
/
& >
$& "
" )$
"
"
%
"
%
+&
<
+" +
))
"
) 0-4
%" ) " +
+"
$
))
$
+"
0-4
:
1+
+" "
+"
)
)
"&
+
"
8$ , -<"1 I #
)
1 "&
+" "
))
$
$
&
"%
@
!" )
)" %J
:
"
"
%
)
%
&
!0-4 )
%
&
!0-4
""
"
L 1 L >I "$
" ? !"
$
"
)
<
/
& > 1 #"
,+
8" 55C
"
"""
+" )
&$
&
+ "
$
<./
&1 > "
+ "&
"
)
%)
)
+
$
;
164 Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 165
""
@)
"
"
+
+
#"
1 '
1 ,+
8" 55C
"
""
+" )
%
&
)
)
"& $ "
)
$
&
""
!"
%J
)
$&
:
"
"
%
+)
!0-4 "
"
"
!")1 ?-
!"
"
""
$
$"
<
/
& > 1 -
1 /
&
#7"
-
O
C
"
"""
""
"
+")
@)
)& "
%& $%
"
+
%
)
"%
$"
""
+"
)
"
%
& &%
-
1 A E
.3
1 A 2& 1 IA
O
1 C #+
& "&
""
+
$
;&
"
)
" -
&
+ " ))
)"
+"%
&)
&%
G%
& 1
'(
!"
%$
)"
!" )
%$
"
$&
+
"
))
) 0-4
"%
"
$
&
)
;"
;
+
))
&
)
'
:
"
$
))
)"
"
%
"$+" )
$
" %
$
&
))
$
1"
;)
$&
$
/&
"
))
)"
"
)
/&
+"
%
))
#
" /&
)
+
:
)
=$
)
$
+ )%
1"
+" +
%
"
!"
)%
"
+ " $
")
"
+
& % =$
% !")1 "
& )) "
"
)")
-
)"
"
%
)
" + !0-4 !"
)
"
)
" " $
"
)"
&$
)$ " $
&
+"
;
+"
"$ %
"%
+$& ?
1 "
&)"%
"$ % $
+$&
$
& ;
"" "
)
"%
%
%
+"
:
%
#% 7
1 21 ?1 555 !"
$ +$
)
;
+ $
&B !"
) +& "G !"
1?
6 *
&1
%$+"
#%
1 21 ?1 71 G1 E1 '&
1 71 /1 C 0
+ %& '7 7
:
-
#$
+4
1 > 1 >
#%
1 21 ?1 71 G1 E1 0 +
"
)
+ %& *8
F$
) -
#$
+1 #$
+ . !:
1 -1 I
#%
1 21 /
&1 #1 > !"
)%
"
$$
"
)
+)-
"
/
+
IC1 5 5>
#"
1 #1 '
+
1 '1 /
1 41 7
)?
1 /1 !" ) $
+
+
+ %
"
""
)
&
+%
!" #$
+4
1 C 1 >->5
#
<
1 G1
1 71 5
)$
+ 8$
K -
+ F$
)
#
7
11 I
#
7"1 ##1 /"
?
&
1 71 /$
)1 /?1 5 G
))
$
"$+" " -
%& /&
#
4
) #$
+ 1 5-
Wan Farhah Shafiy Wan Kamalluarifin / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 156 165 165
#&1 G1 7
1 F1 ?$
&1 81 G
)
+B
)
+& /
+
#$
+ F$
1 1 >
#
"%$+"1 F1 F"
1 81 /1 6)
1 !1 G1 555 0
+
"-
#$
+?
<
1 II 1 C
#<
<1 #1 #1 #
))
1 ,1 ,1 /1 /"
1 -1 71 5 -
/&
0
)
/"
+
0
$
+ I1 I I -
'1 81 C
+
"
7$" #)
/
#$
&4
"1 1
'
11
%1 !1 #
$&
$
&
$
"-
B
)
I $
*
!" -
F$
)G
+
#$
+4
"1 1
0"#"
1 # '1 #%
1 7 '1 > #$
&)
B#
) /&
'$
4
"1 C 1 II5 0
1 '1 /1 /
1 01 E1 555
+
"-
%&
+ *8
$
#$
+4
1 > 1 I III
G"&1 F1 E
1 # 1 G /1 55- !"
)
+"
)"
02B #
&
)
;
;
$
+ 03
B#
-
4
1 I >I
G&1 ?1 ?
;J"
1 81 C 0
+B
#
:
%
/
+
1 1 G%
&1 41 4"
1 #1
)
)
$$
$ !" -
F$
) #$
+1 C 1 C5>
G%
& 41 3&1 31 E1 4"
1 #1 !"
)-
+ F$
) #$
+
$%
&1 1 II5C
+1 E1 E /;1 H1 !1 I 0 +
$
&
$ F$
) #$
+
$%
&1 1 IIC +1 /1 4
"
1 (1 F . 7"<1 71 G
)
)
)
F$
) #$
+
$%
&1 1 II-5
<1 #1 /
&1 #1 > !"
) +
"
)
+ %& +&
/
+
IC 1 >C>>-
3$1
1 #1 E$
+1 71 C '
"
1$
@:
$
&
$ F$
) #$
+
$%
&1 I1 II5
/&
)1 /1 ?1 4
"
1 ?1 /1 #1 !"
)$
&
/&
B !"
)
+ *,-!#4 F$
11 C
?+1
1 G1 8
&1 F1 F1 /
1 1 #1 C G
")
+"
+&
"
&))
+M !" #$
+4
1 5 I 1 -> I
-
1 !1 ?1 #
+
))
)$
+ $
&
$
))
)
" -
" 300 $
6;
+1
% 774,
1 /1 01 /;
+1 61 ?1 5- !"& ) " )
B
+
%"
1 +
&
"
$$ F$
)
1 II 1 I I-
8
1 61 #"
18.-
1 #1 - !" )) ) +$
) )
+B
)
'
+
" F2##3 1
8
1 # 1 H
+1 H1 > !"
) +
+ F$
) #$
+
$%
&1 1 ->
8$ , -<"1 81 -1 I !" $
)$
) =$& )
/&
*
$%
"
10
)) *
&1 0
)) E
1 /1 3
1 '1 !" $
) " -
+ %& 7
"
!" -
F$
)G
+
#$
+4
"1 1 I>
1 01 I
+
" -
%&
+ F
00
$
#
-
F$
1 > 1 IIC
1 01
1 #1 C 0
+
"
%& 3
-
F$
) #$
+ -
)
7&
1 I 1 >I
/
&1 /1 !1 #7"
1 71 #1 G1 - 6%%
$
&)
+ ) F
-
4
) '$
4
"
1 1 I5
&
"
&
$
#
)
F$
) #$
+1 G
%1 5CC
2&1 1 E
1
1
"1 41 I G
) -
+ %& , R
F$
) -
/
+
#$
+1 C1 --I
"++1 '
6+
")1 #1 555
)
"-
B#
$& ) " "
+
) #$
$
#$
+4
> 1 I>II5
1 '1 !
)
$
B7
"
: -
F$
) #$
+1 I1 C-
O
1 F1 R1 H
+1 ?1 0"1 01 61 C !"
"
) $
&
$
%& 0"
F$
) #$
+
$%
&1 I1 5