Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BAB I The Effectivness Using Cartoon Movie To Test Speaking Ability
BAB I The Effectivness Using Cartoon Movie To Test Speaking Ability
INTODUCTION
This chapter presents some issues related to topic of the study. They are the background of
the research, the problem of the research, the objective of the research, the hypothesis, the
significances of the research, the area of the research, ant the operational definition of the
terms.
a. How can the use of Cartoon movie media improve students speaking
achievment in oral descriptive text of class VIII at SMPN 2 Glagah
Banyuwangi in the 2015/2016 Academic Year?
b. How can the use Cartoon movie media improve students active participation
in learning of class VIII at SMPN 2 Glagah Banyuwangi in the 2015/2016
Academic Year?
Based on the background and the problems of the research, the research objectives are
formulated as follows:
In this action research, the hypothesis of the the research is formulated as follows:
Cartoon movie can improve the speaking ability of the VIII grade students at
SMPN 2 Glagah Banyuwangi in the 2015/2016 academic year
Cartoon movie can improve studentss active participation of the VIII grade
students at SMPN 2 Glagah Banyuwangi in the 2015/2016 academic year.
The results of this Research are expected to be useful for the English teacher,
the students , and the future researchers.
The research results of this study may give contribution for English
teacher to develop and improve their teaching method in english lesson
especially in oral descriptive text.
The area of this research is the Eighth year students of at SMPN 2 Glagah
Banyuwangi in the 2015/2016 academic year. One out three clasess had been taken as
the subject. This class is the one that has listening skill.
Speaking is one of language skill that must be mastered by the students. The
purpose of the speaking is to share idea or meaning. Rebecca (20016:144) stated that
speaking is teh first mode in which children acquire language, it is part of the daily
involment of most people with language activities , and it is the prime motor of
language change. The students must be able to organize the ideas to construct the
sentences, to use pronunciation, voabularies, grammar, and spelling well.
In this study , speaking achievment refers to the students speaking
performance in oral descriptive text that means the students are able to give more
vocabulary, to show the grammar structures and capable to give their opinion. The
students can be more active to speak in oral descriptive text, with the organize the
idea to construct the sentences, to use pronunciation, vocabulary, grammar and
spelling well.
Cartoon han been widely used as one of the teacing aunthentic audio visual
materials in language learning classes. In other word, cartoon movie is a kinds of
movie that series of drawing and tell story or express a massage either funny and
serious and paly a television type screen. According to Rule and Ague (2005), cartoon
are preffered because they create low affectives filter atmosphere which causes high
degree of motivation.
In addition, cartoon are also considered as excellent teaching tolls because
they not only add humor to a topic but also illustrate the idea in memorable way. In
deed, cartoon make learning enjoyable and, more importantly, memorable experience
because the activities in teaching and learning process using cartoon interisting and
interactive for the students.
There are related literatures to support of the theory of the research that will be presented in
this chapter. They consist of speaking achievment. Some aspect of speaking ability, speaking
in oral descriptive, of cartoon movie media, the procedure on the use of cartoon movie media
in teaching speaking, the strenght and weakness of using artoon movie media, previous
research, and hypothesis. Those topic will be discussed in following section repectively.
The mastery of speaking skill in English is a priority for many second language or
foreign language learner. Consequenly, learner often evaluate their success in language
learning as well as the effectiveness of their English course on the basis of how much hey
feel they have improved in their spoken language proficiency. Teacher and textbook may use
of a variety of approaches, ranging from direct approaches focusing on specific features or
oral interaction (e.g., turn taking, topic management , and questioning strategies) to indirect
approach that create condition for oral interaction through group work, task work, and other
strategies (Richard, 1990).
In speaking and listening tend to be getting something done, exploring ideas, working
out some aspect of the world, or simply being together . In writing, may be creating a frecord,
commiting events or moments to paper (Jones, 1996). Research has also thrown considerable
light on the complex city of spoken interaction in either a first or seecond language. For
example, Composed of idea units ( conjoined short phrases and clauses), planed (a teacher) or
unplanned (conversation), employees more vague or generic words than written language,
employees fixed phrases, fillers, and hesitation markers, involves reciprocity (interaction are
joinly constructed), and show variation (between formal and casual speech), reflecting
speaker roles, speaking purpose and the context.
Speaking type of talk that can usefully be distinguised has been called talk as
performance.
Speaking ability is the ability of students to speak English. Most students convey that
speaking is difficult lesson. There are many ways to teach speaking more interisting.
Therefore, the teacher must have creativity to teach speaking easily. Besides that the teacher
should pay more attention to improvement of speaking ability.
The goal of teaching the spoken language in the classroom is to enable the students to
express their ideas in the target language. However, the important thing in speaking that
should be known by the speakers is to make the listeners understand of what the speaker is
saying. According to Thornburry (1995:1) speaking is so much part of daily life taht we take
it for granted. The average person produces tens of thousands of words a day, although some
people- like autioneers or politicians may produce even more than that.
According to Johnson (1995:5), there are four major component generally recognized
in the analysis of speach process namely: fluency and accuracy of pronunciation, vocabulary,
and grammar. The speaker should know well those mayor component of speaking beside
knowing with whom, when and where they practice their speaking.
2.3.1 Fluency
Sometimes, there are many students could not speak fluently, it can make the listeners
not understand what the speaker is saying. In speaking is needed a fluency to speak up.
Thornbury (1995:6) said that speed is a factor, but it is by no means the only or even the most
important one. Listeners perception of speakers fluency suggest that pausing is equally
important, in other word, students need to stop or pause when they are speaking. It can be
concluded that fluency is a part of some components which is important in speaking because
the listeners will be aesy to understant when the speaker speaks with a godd fluent.
Speaking is not only bravery to speak loudly in front of many people, but also need to
understand of the English roles. In this case, the students need to know the pronunciation
rules, familiar vocabularies and the English Grammar.
a. Pronunciation
b. Vocabulary
Vocabulary is one necessary aspect in speaking. Sometimes, there are many students
could not speak fluently. It caused the students have the lack vocabulary. Without,
vocabulary the speaker does not speech about what the speaker feeling. And also students
will get difficulties in expressing their idea without have more vocabularies.
Wilkins i Thornbury (2002:13) stated that without grammar very little can be
conveyed, without vocabulary nothing can be conveyed. If the students have many
vocabularies, they will easy to master language skills.
Based on this description above, it can conclude that vocabulary is very important in
teaching learning process of the language especially in teaching speaking. Therefore, the
teacher should motivate the students to enrich their vocabulary, and to be active when the
students is saying.
c. Grammar
In teaching speaking, the teacher not only teach how to speak fluently, but also the
teacher teach how to produce good sentences. In order the listeners to understand what the
speaker is saying. According to Thornbury (1999:04) grammar is a process for making a
speakers or writers meaning clear when contextual information is lacking.
Descriptive text is a kind of text to describe the story that present tense. It means taht
if the speaker is retell the story aout descriptive text certainly the speaker use grammar
especially use present tense. In order the listeners understand what the speaker is saying. It
can be concluded that the student must learn grammar to speak well.
Descriptive text that describes what kind of person or an object described, good
shape, its properties, number and other. Objective (purpose) of any clear descriptive text, it to
explain, describe or express a person or an object.
The are three generic stucture of descriptive text. According to by Kane (2000:352)
there are two characteristic of descriptive text as follow:
Descriptive text is not simple as thought, a small scale survey shows that students
problem in speaking a descriptive text sre as follows : no idea to speak about, diffuculty in
organizing ideas, limited range of vocabulary, no motivation to speak, and lack of confidence
in grammar. In line with the survey stated, at the beggining of speaking activity including in
speaking descriptive text, students have to find out the idea to speak about. The speaking in
oral descriptive text the students can also figure out the object that they have to describe
easier, because they can see the object directly through video. Unfortunately, getting stuck of
ideas is often faced by students and it can be a block in writing activity. As a result, speaking
process goes slowly and stops immadiately.
Cartoon movie is animated film that movement. Usually, the cartoon movie have
funny figures. In order theere are many students love it. For example: Dora cartoon, Walt
Disney cartoon, Tom and Jerry cartoon. In besides that, cartoon movie is one of media of
teaching learning process in the classroom. A creativity teacher must created the good
atmosphere in the classroom. Monotonous learning make the students bored. In the case, the
teacher must using interisting media to teach student is using cartoon movie.
Cartoon have been widely used as one of teaching authentic audio visual material in
language learning clasess. In other word, cartoon movie is a kind of movie that series of
drawing and tell story or express a message either funny and serious and paly a television
type screen. According to Rule and Ague (2005) cartoons are preffered because they create
low affective filter atmosphere which causes high degree of motivation.
In addition, cartoon are also considered as exellent teaching tools because they not
only add humor to atopic but also illustrate the idea in memorable way. In deed, cartoon
make learning enjoyable and, more importanly, memorable experience because the activities
in the teaching and learning process using cartoons interisting and interactive for the student.
11 Universitas PGRI Banyuwangi |
2.7 The Procedures of Teaching Speaking Using Cartoon Movie
In the study, cartoon film is chosen as a media of teaching English speaking. The
researcher will use Cartoon Movie as media to teach English speaking. Cartoon
Movie is an animated television series taht is wonderful show for the students. The
steps of teaching English speaking by using cartoon movie is:
1. First the teacher show the cartoon movie used the sound only ( without the
visual) and ask to the students try to guessing that sound
2. Second the teacher show the cartoon movie ( without the sound), and the third
the teacher show the cartoon movie using audio visual of the cartoon movie.
3. The model of the cartoon movie isa fabel have have text of the video when the
text use English language.
4. Third of the way already done, the teacher formed a group to discuss the
material that is given and ask the student to perform in front of class to
describe.
Cartoon movie media has weaknesses in its implementation in speaking class. If the
teacher teach speaking using cartoon movie media, the teacher need more expense. For
example: the teacher need LCD Projector and laptop. In other word, cartoon movie also has a
negative impact on the students, for example in the Spongebob Square Pants cartoon , this
cartoon indirectly can give suggestions to the children to always interfere with other people,
12 Universitas PGRI Banyuwangi |
and like other people meddling. In the impact can solve with use the good cartoon movie like
Upin and Ipin cartoon that give more knowledge.
Maulida (2013) used a classroom acrion research. She found that Cartoon Movie is a
media gave a significance effect on students speaking ability. The title of Maulida thesis is
Improving Students Speaking Skill Through Oral Description Practice On Eight Grade
Students of SMP Negeri 2 Tebas. The students enthusiasm while doing their performance by
using their own thing/object. It can be seen while teacher give time to themselves to practice
their thing through oral description. All of students practice with their own style and try to
have a good performance while describing thing in front of the class. So, they can increase
their pronunciation, fluency, and confident. She had to make sure taht all students practice
speaking correctly. Student mean score 75.37, the score was passed the criteria of (KKM) and
categorized satisfying. Based on the previous study above, the researcher will use cartoon
movie the students speaking achievement at SMPN 2 Glagah Banyuwangi.
Himawan (2013) used a CAR (Classroom Action Research). He found that using
cartoon film can improve students speaking ability of SMPN 2 Taman. The title of
Himawans thesis is Improving Students Speaking Ability by Using Cartoon Film of SMPN
2 Taman. The describe the teaching narrative speaking using cartoon film that is
implemented to improve students speaking skill. Students mean score is 7.91, the score was
passed the criteria of (KKM) and categorized satisfying. Based on the previous study above,
the researcher will use cartoon movie media to improve the student speaking achievement at
SMPN 2 Glagah Banyuwangi. The presence of cartoon film as media to improve students
narrative speaking had given a significant progress toward their speaking ability. Since they
were never taught by using films, the presence of thi research also gave the students new
persepective that they could also relate the material to their hobby like pictures, music, etc.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
This chapter presents the research methodology in this research . It covers research design,
research setting and subject, research procedure, research subject, data collection method,
research procedure, and data analysis method.
Classroom action research (CAR) was applied in this research. It is can improve the
students speaking achievement in oral descriptive text by using cartoon movie media at
SMPN 2 Glagah Banyuwangi. States Cohen and Manion in Susanto (2010:7) CAR is on the
spot study. It means CAR will be appropriately used as the design. As Susanto said
(2010:11), CAR is the implementation of teaching and learning in the classroom. Based od
those ideas, CAR was conducted to help the teacher to improve the students speaking ability.
CAR has four stages. They are planning stage, implementation stage, observation
stage, and reflection stage. The framwork of CAR used is adapted from Susantos framework.
The following is the framework
Cycle #1
Yes Reported
Yes Reported
Cycle #2
Identfy the problem faced by the English teacher in the classroom and the students in
learning English:
a. Planning the action (constructing the lesson plan for cycle I); It contained
identification of the problem not only in the classroom but also in students learning
English which are faced by the English teacher. Besides that, the researcher must
make lesson plang and prepare all of material and media
b. Observing the classroom while implementating the action in the first cycle. In this
step, the researcher as the doer did the teaching and learning process by applying the
lesson plan which has been made. The observers wrote everything while the teaching
and learning process occurred as the data for the research.
c. Reflecting the result of the action. It is donee afte the planning, implementation and
observation had been done. Analyzing the data would create the result of the action.
As had been indicated,if the first cycle could not fulfil the target of the research, the
researcher would do the second cycle in the same procedures.
(CAR must not do in some cycle, if the conclusion of the result is fulfill the target, the
research can be stopped and report it. But if the result is not fulfill the target, the researcher
must take cycle II and furthermore.
The Subject of the research is the class VIII students of SMPN 2 Glagah Banyuwangi
in the 2015/2016 academic years. This school only has one class in every grade. Each class
consists of the 33 students. Based on the information from the eight English teacher in
teacher in the interview, the eight grade students still had difficulties in narrative speaking. In
this research, the action cycle is done suitable with the English schedule in that class.
The research subjects focus is on the eight grade especially on VIII. The factor of the
selection of the class is the low ability of the students in speaking. It is known by the English
teacher who said that most of the students of that class could not achieve the target minimum
of the speaking score. Briefly, there are 10 students or 43.24% of 37 or 16 students who get
the score 75 in speaking test. But the researcher could not show the list of the score in
preliminary study because they did not give it shown but also told the mean and the
percentage only.
To achieve the goal of this research, the action was done in the form cycles covering
four activities. They are planning the action, implementation of action, observation, and
reflection that was explained as follows:
Planning the action is the first step in conducting classroom action research. In this step, the
researcher prepare everything which is needed to do implementation. There are some
activities done in this phase
The materials of the teaching learning process was adapted from students work
book. The learning of material is cartoon movie entitled is Moana. The teacher give
guiding question to the students about the topic, giving discription about the topic, and
give the key term of the topic.
Basic Competence: Prepare a written and oral descriptive text, simple, about people,
places of interest, and famous historical buildings, with due regard to social functions,
text structures, and linguistic elements that are true and contextual
Indicator : Analyzing story structure is descriptive
1. Recognize the parts or components which is in descriptive text
2. Identify the parts or components which is in descriptive text
3. Make a example descriptive text based on the situation that had been given
Teaching Strategy: The teacher introduce the topic with clue, the teacher give the
guiding question, and ask the students to give short description about the cartoon
movie.
Note:
1) The students pay attention the cartoon movie
2) The students can find the chaacteristic of person in cartoon movie
3) The student can fint the vocabulary in the cartoon movie
4) The students are able to speak English with grammatical structure correctly
5) The students can retell use their own in oral descriptive text in front of the
class.
TABLE SPEFICATION
Core Basic Main Indicator Kind Numbe Type Bobot
Comptence Competence Material of Test r of of Soal
(KI) (KD) per Test Test
KD
Processing, Express the Descriptive The 1 a. Easy C3
reasoning, and meaning in text students
presenting in short are able to
the realm of functional make
concrete and text and sentence
abstract monologuein and
realms related the form of speaking
to the recount, of
development narrative, descriptive
of the self- and simple text based
study in the procedure in on the
school context of theme
independently, daily life
and able to
use methods
according to
scientific rules
In the process of learning English by using cartoon movie in this research aims to
improve students skills in speaking English. And with the improvement of the researcher
have criteria for success in the process of teaching the students. The success criteria for
mentioned three criteria there are:
The implementation of the action was conducted during the teaching and learning
process. The researcher was implemented the action teching speaking by using cartoon movie
media. Before the teaching learning process is begin, the researcher made lesson plan.
There are three activities in the classroom. They are pre-activities, main activities and
post activities. In the step of pre-activities, it was done about five minutes. For teh first
teacher greeted and checked the attendance list of the students. Then, the teacher give leading
question related about the materials that gave. In the main activities, the taeacher showed the
cartoon movie media to teach speaking in the class, then the teacher gave leading question
based on the cartoon movie that gave, and next the teacher asked to the student to made
summary or out line, after that the teacher asked to the students to retell in front of the class
ant the last activity is post activity, the teacher clarified the objective of the lesson to the
students.
3.3.3 Observation
Therefore, the students was categorized as the active students if they could reach
three indicators or more but if tehy applied less of three indicators they was categorized
as the passive students.
3.3.4 Reflection
Reflection was conducted to reflect the result of the actions that was collected from
the class observation and speaking test in each cycle. It was supported by Susanto (2010:60),
the reflection was done during the data was collected, and in another hand the reflection was
done after the data was collected. It is purposed to know whether the action is successful or
not. If the research target in the first cycle is fulfilled, the action stopped. However, if the
target is not successful yet, the action preceded to the next cycles until the purposes of the
research had achieved.
Data collection methods applied in this classroom action research covered the primary
data and suuporting data. The methods used in collecting the primary data were
classroom observation and speaking test. While the supporting data were gathered
through interviewed with English teacher and documentation.
The observation method was used to observe the students learning activities in the
teaching learning process. To record the students activities in the teaching and learning
process the researcher was used checklist paper. There are some points that must be
considered by the researcher and collaborator as the notes, they are:
Note:
1) The students pay attention the cartoon movie
2) The students can find the chaacteristic of person in cartoon movie
3) The student can fint the vocabulary in the cartoon movie
4) The students are able to speak English with grammatical structure correctly
5) The students can retell use their own in oral descriptive text in front of the
class.
Process evaluation was done whether the use of questioning technique can
improve the students speaking ability or not during speaking learning process. The
evaluaion is intended to know the students participation in the process of learning.
Speaking test is the way that used measure of student speaking achievement bby using
cartoon movie media. According Brown(2004:03)said test is method of measuring a person
ability, knowledge, or performance in a given doamin. The test item was constructed based
In each cycle, the teacher will pay the cartoon movie and asked te students to retell
the story in front of the class. The result of the speaking test is the score of the students
dpeaking ability. The score of the student speaking achievement is the sum scored of the
students speaking fluency, students speaking grammar, students peaking pronunciatition and
students speaking vocabulary. The students will perform or will speak up, the researcher take
a score. In orfer to get the score accurately, the researcher also record the students voice by
using mobile phone for future check.
The test wich given to the students must be valid and reliable. Hughes (1989:26)
defines two criteria of constructing a good test. A test should have validitya and reliability. A
test is said to be valid if it measure accurately what it is intended to measure. Then, the test
reliable if it gave consisted result in the same test but at different time. In this research, the
researcher will be used content validity because the content validity of the material are
constructed based on the syllabus of the school. The instruction based on the syllabus as
follow:
Moreover, reliable is the test which is given to the students must have consistently in the
result. In this researcher collaboratively with the English teacher to be measured the students
Based on the explanation about, the test constructed to measure the students
achievement in speaking covering their grammar, vocabulary, fluency, and pronunciation.
The students speaking test is scored based on the Hughes rating scales of speaking test as
follow:
In this research, the research and the collaborator gave the score for the students. The
score would be taken based on the oral production of the students to measure the progress.
The aspect of the scoring pronunciation, grammar, fluency, amnd vocabulary.
Pronunciation
Level Description
`1 Pronounciation frequently unintelligible
Frequent gross errors and a very heavy accent make understanding difficult,
2
require frequent repetition
Foreign accent requires concentrated listening, and mispronunciation lead to
3
occasional misundertstanding and apparent error in grammar and vocabulary
Marked foreign accent and occasional mispronunciation which do not
4
interfere with understanding
5 No conspicuous mispronunciation, but would be taken for a native speaker.
6 Native pronunciation, with no trace of foreign accent
Level Description
`1 Grammar almost entirely inaccurate to phrases
Constans error showing control of very few major pattern and frequently
2
preventing communication
Frequent error showing some major patterns uncontrolled and causing
3
occasional irritation and misunderstanding
Occasional error showing imprefect control of some patterns but no weakness
4
that causes misunderstanding
5 Few error, with no patterns of failure
6 No more than two errors during the interview
Vocabulary
Level Description
`1 Vocabulary inadequate for even the simplest conversation
Vocabulary limited to basic personal and survival area (time, food,
2
transportation, family, etc)
Choice of words sometimes innacurate, limitations of vocabulary prevent
3
discussion of some commong professional and social topic.
Professional vocabulary adequate to discuss special interest; general vocabulary
4
permits discussion of any non- technical subject with some circumlocutions
Professional vocabulary broad and precise; general vocabulary dequate to cope
5
with complex pratical problems and varied social situations
Vocabulary apprently as accurate and aextensive as that of an educated native
6
speaker.
Level Description
`1 Speech is so halting and fragmentary that conversation is virtually impossible
2 Sppech is very slow and uneven except for short or routine sentences
3 Speech is frequently hesitant and jerky sentences may be left uncompleted
Speech is occasionally hesistant,with some unevennes caused by rephasing and
4
grouping for words
Speech is effortless and smooth, but perceptibly non-native in speech and
5
eveness
Speech on all professional and general topics as effortless and smooth as a
6
native speakers
A. Pronunciation
B. Grammar
C. Vocabulary
D. Fluency
The calculation of total score is based on the scoring scales proposed by Hughes above.
Dealing with the scoring guide, each aspect is classified into six level. The biggest score is 6
and the lowest 1.
25 Universitas PGRI Banyuwangi |
The scoring table is used to assess the students speaking test that is concerned with
pronunciation, grammar, vocabulary, fluency. The score took from the total number of the
four aspects. Then, the result of speaking test is seen from the mean score.
3.4.2.1 Interview
The purpose of interview, the researcher want to know the information about the
school. According to Arikunto (2002:132), interview defined as a dialogue that is done by
interviewer to the interview to gain the information. It is conducted to get the information that
support the primary data concerning with the English teaching at that school. The questions
of the interviewed about the English curriculum used, the English books, the students score
before, and the techniques that were used by the English teacher of eight grade at SMPN 2
Glagah Banyuwangi
3.4.2.2 Documentation
In this research, documentation is used to get supporting data about the total number
of the eight grade students, the names of the respondent and previous scores in speaking of
the eight grade students at SMPN 2 Glagah Banyuwangi.
In this research, the research, the result of the speaking test is analyzed quantitatively
by describing the result of the percentage. To know teh percentage of the students who get
sscore score 75 or higher, the following formula was used:
E= 100%
Notes :
More over, the action was considered if student had achieved mean scored of criteria of
success in this research is determined in the following statements
Furthermore, after the research analyzed the data, reflection will be done to know whether the
action is successful or not. The research and the English teacher will collaborate to make
conclusion based on the reflection of speaking test and observation in each cycle.