Professional Documents
Culture Documents
15 21 1 PB Bioefff - On Aphid
15 21 1 PB Bioefff - On Aphid
nigseni, a foliar beetle pest of beans and other plants and mature dry fruits of chinabeny, all at 200
legumes in many parts of Africa (Karel 1987). gllitre of the water were used. In case of neem, water
Aqueous leaf extract of neem @ 1 kg leaf powder14 1 dispersible powder (based on seed kernel, obtained
of water) significantly reduced the potato leafhopper, from Agrochemical Division, Indin Agricultural
Jacobiasca lybica, in Sudan (Siddig 1987). Research Institute, New Delhi, India) at 0.1 % was
also included. (b) Chemical pesticides : malathion
Low concentration aqueous leaf extracts (0.1- (50% EC) and monocrotophos (36% EC), both at
0.2% w/v) of chinaberry affected the growth and 0.05%, were included as chemical checks. (c) An
development of the fourth instar larvae of the dia- untreated check. Hence, there were 10 treatments
mondback moth and various larval stages of cabbage which were replicated three times.
butterflies (Pieris brassicae and Pieris rapae) and
Mamestra brassicae. In higher concentrations (0.3- The fresh green leaves and dry seeds of each
0.5%) the extracts of chinaberry showed repellent plant species were ground individually with the help
and insecticidal properties (Zhu 1991). of an iron mortar and pestle, mixed with required
amount of water in individual plastic buckets and
The objective of this study was to evaluate the kept aside for about 12 hours. Then the contents of
efficacy of locally available pesticidal plants in their each bucket were stirred for about one minute with a
crude form (water extract) for managing cruciferous stick and filtered through a fine muslin cloth. The
vegetable insects at the research station and farmers' leaf- and seed-extracts thus obtained were sprayed on
fields. plants with a hand compression sprayer. Insecticides
were diluted in water and sprayed on plants with a
Methodology separate hand compression sprayer. The cabbage
plants were treated with the botanicals and insecti-
On-Station Studies cides 5 times at an interval of 7 days starting 4 weeks
after transplanting.
The tests were conducted at the Plant Protection
Field Laboratory of the Institute of Agriculture and Data recording. Insect pests associated with cab-
Animal Sciences (IAAS), Rampur, Chitwan, during bage plants were sampled one day before and one
1991- 1992, 1992-93, 1993-94 and 1994-95 cropping day after each spray from the central two rows of
seasons. each plot. At harvest, the cabbage heads were
cleaned - the old as well as insect damaged leaves
were removed and only the clean portion was col-
lected and weighed. The mean differences between
Establishing the Experimental Plots. Cabbage treatments were separated by Duncan's multiple
seedlings (variety KK cross) were raised at the range test and Least significant difference test.
experimental site. They were transplanted at the age
of 6 weeks. The experiment was laid out in a ran- 1992-93 Study
domized complete block design with three replica-
tions. Each plot measured 2.6 mZ.The plant to plant Establishing the Experimental Plots. The same
and row to row spacings were 50 and 60 cm, respec- procedure as described under 199 1-92 study was fol-
tively. ,Farm yard manure was applied @ 5 t k a dur- lowed. The variety of cabbage was also the same.
ing land preparation. The chimcal fertilizers were The individual experimental plot measured 5.4 mZ.
applied @ 80:60:60 kg NPKIha. Boron was supplied Malathion was excluded. During the later part of the
basally through borax at 18 kglha. Nitrogen (urea) experimental period, there was an acute shortage of
was split into two doses, half at planting and the irrigation water which compelled the researcher for
remaining half top dressed at 30 days after trans- abanadoning one replication of the experiment. Only
planting of the cabbage seedlings. Standard cultural two replications could be saved.
practices were maintained throughout the experimen-
tation. Treatments a n d Their Applications. (a)
Treatments a n d Their Applications. (a) Botanicals: The following plants here included in
Botanicals: The following plants were choosen for the study: neem, chinaberry, and malabar nut. The
this study: neem, chinaberry, malabar nut, crown fresh green leaves of these plants and mature dry
plant and mug-wort. Fresh green leaves of these fruits of chinaberry were used. The dosages and
F. P. NeupaneINepal Journal of Science and Technology 1 (1999) 77-84
method of extraction were the same as described a single row with 15 plnats was allocated and repli-
under 1992-92 study. (b) Chemical pesticide : cated thrice at each farmer's field. The trial was laid
Monocrotophos (0.05%), (c) an untreated check. in a completely randomized block design.
Hence. there were 6 treatments.
A sticker (Teepol) was mixed with the plant
Data Recording. The same procedure as extracts at the rate of 1 ml for 3 litres. Spraying was
described under 1991-92 study was followed. done during the afternoon. ~ d treatments
e were
applied 10 days after transplanting at weekly inter-
1993-94 Study vals and in total eight applications were made.
Establishing the Experimental Plots. The same Insects attacking cabbage were recorded at week-
procedure as described under 1991-92 study was fol- ly intervals. The trials were harvested during April
lowed. The variety of cabbage was also the same. 29-to May 12, 1994. Before harvesting, the overall
Individual plot measured 6.0 mZ.The cabbage plants insect damage rating of the cabbage plants was done
were transplanted on February 23 and harvested on jointly by the farmers and researchers. A damage
April 25, 1994. rating scale of 1-5 was used for this purpose. At har-
vest, the total biomass produced and the edible mar-
Treatments and Their Applications. (A) ketable produce were weighed separately. The data
Botanicals: The following plants were included in were subjected to analysis of variance and the means
the study: neem, chinabeny, malabar nut and lantana. were separated by Lezst Significant Difference test.
The fresh green leaves of these plants were used.
Their dosages and method of extraction were the 1994-95 Study
same as described under 1991-92 study. (b)
Chemical pesticide : Monocrotophos (0.05%), and The same participants farmers, Mr. K.B. Gurung
(c) An untreated check. Hence, there were 6 treat- and Mr. T.R. Paudel, who also had participated in
ments. this trial in 1993-94, cooperated to conduct this trial
again on their farms. The treatments cabbage variety,
Data Recording. The same procedure as experimental design, methods of establishing the
described under 1991-92 study was followed. plants, and data recording were all the same as in
1993-94. The cabbage plants were transplanted dur-
On-Farm Studies ing the third week of February and harvested during
the last wek of April, 1995. In total only five applica-
1993-94 Study tions of the treatments were made during this year.
Table 1. Effect of various botanicals (as water extracts) and insecticides on marketalbe yield of cabbage,
Rampur, Chitwan, 1992
Table 2. Effect of various botanicals (as water extracts) and monocrotophos on cabbage insects, Rampur, I993
6 WAT 10 WAT
DBM CB DBM CB
Neem fresh leaves 02.70 20.7 4.5 10.5
Chinaberry fresh leaves 1.25 21.0 4.5 11.5
Chinaberry dry fruits 0.25 20.0 4.7 11.7
Malabar nut fresh leaves 1.75 15.2 7.2 11.0
Monocro-tophos (36% EC) 0.25 08.2 3.0 04.2
Untreated check 10.50 32.0 8.7 27.0
The major insects encountered were the tobacco Farmer B.The 'F-test' of treatments is significant
caterpillar and the cabbage butterfly. The former (P < 0.01). The yield obtained in monocrotophos
caused major damage compared to the latter. (17.93 kg) is significantly highest of all. Though the
yields of other treatments are higher than the untreat-
Farmer A. The total and marketable yields of ed control, statistically the yields are as good as the
cabbage have been presented in Table 6. The 'E test" yield in control treatment.
Table 3. Effect of various botanicals (as water extracts) and monocrotophos on the marketable yield of cabbage
(KK Cross), Rampur, Chitwan, 1993
Table 5. Effect of various botanicals (as water extracts) and monocrotophos on the marketable yield of cabbage,
Rampur, Chitwan, 1994
Table 6. Effect of various botanicals (as water extracts) and monocrotphos on the total and marketable yield of
cabbage, Kholaghari, Kabilash Village Development Committee, Chitwan, 1994
Farmer A Farmer B
Treatment Dosage Yield (kg) Overall Yield (kg) Overall
( g %a ) Total Marketable damage Total Marketable damage
ranking ranking
Neem fresh leaves 200.0 14.73 10.00 111 15.63" 6.16" IV-
chinaberry fresh leaves 200.0 11.60 6.20 IV 16.30" 10.30" 111
Indian privet fresh leaves 200.0 16.60 11.10 11 17.03" 7.66 I1
Monocrotophos 0.05% 17.46 11.16 I 24.43" 17.93'' I I
Control 10.50 5.70 V 12.43'' 5.76" V
F test N.S NS S HS
CD at 5% 5.60 5.34
1% 7.78
Farmer A = T. R. Paudel; Farmer B = K. B. Gurung; S = Significant; N.S. = Non-significant H.S. = Highly significant;
Damage ranking scale: I = Lowest; V = Highest
Table 7. Effect of various botanicals (as water extracts) and monocrotophos against cabbage insects,
Kholaghari, Kabilash Village Development Committee, Chitwan, 1995. Farmer A (Mr. Tika Ram Paudel)
At 4 WAT At harvesting
Table 8. Effect of various botanicals (as water extracts) and monocrotophos against cabbage insects,
Kholaghari, Kabilash Village Development Committee, Chitwan, 1995. Farmer B (Krishna B. Gurung)
dry fruits, and neem seed kernel-based water dis- limonoids common to neem seeds except
persable powder in suppressing the insect pests of azadirachtin Chinaberry does not have a bright future
crucifers on cabbage, namely the cabbage butterfly, as a pesticide due to its extreme toxicity to warm-
the soybean hairy catrpillar, the tobacco caterpillar, blooded animals (Jacobson 1989). The young leaves
and the diamondback moth; and also increasing its and young fruits of this plant contain higher amounts
yield when compared to unttreated check plots. of the toxic principles as compared to the mature
Though the suppression of insects and increase in leaves and fruits (Zhu 1991). Hence, it is recommend
yield of cabbage were better in plots 'treated with that the young leaves and young fruits of chinaberry
insecticides, namely malathion and monocrotophos, should be used to suppress the cruciferous insects.
in comparison to the botanicals (mentioned above),
the ill effects of chemical pesticides and their higher The malabar nut is a tropical and subtropical
prices cannot be ignored. Hence, in the Nepalese perennial shrub which is found in abundance in
context (illiteracy and poverty of the farmers), the Terai, Inner Terai and hilly regions of Nepal. In the
botanicals with their mild effects on insect suppres- hilly regions, this plant is used as green manure (in
sion and presumably low or negligible side effects rice seed beds). It can be propagated by stem cut-
(to beneficial insects, microorganisms, human beings tings.
and other animals), could be regarded ideal as com-
pared to the synthetic chemical pesticides. The The Indian privet is also a tropical and sub-tropi-
botanicals reported in this paper are abundant in cal shrub which is found in Terai, Inner Terai and
many parts of Nepal and they can be easily propagat- hilly regions of Nepal. It is used as a fencing material
ed. and fuelwood.
Prasad Adhikary, Fieldman, Department of Neupane, F.P. 1989. Insect pests of crucifers in Nepal. J.
Entomology at IAAS, are highly acknowledged for Entomol. Soc. Nepal. 1:47-58.
their help in this research. Neupane, F.P. 1999. Jadibutidwara Kira Niyantran. A
manuscript accepted for publication by Sajha
Prakashan, Pulchowk, Lalitpur (in Nepali).
References Shpan-Gabrielith, S.R. 1965. Preliminary investigations on
the palatability of wild and cultivated plants for
Ahmed, S. M. Grainge, J.W. Hylin, W.C. Mitchel, and J.A. Schistocerca gregaria Forsk. (Orthoptera). In: Proc.
Litsinger 1984. Some promising plant species for use 12th. Int. Congx Entomol. (Abstract). pp. 549
as pest control agents under traditional farming sys- Siddig, S.A. 2987. A proposed pest management program
tems. In: Natural Pesticides from the Neem Tree and including neem treatments for combating potato pests
Other Tropical Plants (Eds. H. Schmutterer and in the Sudan, pp. 449-459. In: Natural Pesticides from
K.R.S. Ascher). GTZ Press, Eschborn, Fedral Republic the Neern Tree and Other Tropical Plants (Eds. H .
of Germany. pp. 565-580 Schmutterer and K.R.S. Ascher). GTZ Press, Eschborn,
Jacobson, M. 1989. Botanical pesticides. In: Insecticides of Federal IRepublic of Germany. pp. 449-459
Plant Origin (Eds. J.T. Arnason, B.J.R. Philogene and Singh, R.P. 1983. Search of antifeedants in some botanicals
P. Morand). ACS Symposium Series 387. American for desert locust, Schistocerca gregaria Forskal. Z .
Chemical Socieity, Washington, DC., USA. pp. 1-10 Angew Entomol. 96:3 16.
Jacobson, M. 1990. Glossary of Plant -Derived Insect Thapa, R.B. 1993. Studies on the insect pests of cabbage,
Deterrents. CRC Press, Coba Raton, Florida, USA. cauliflower and radish at IAAS, Rampur. In: IAAS
Karel, A.K. 1987. Response of Ootheca bennigseni Research Reports (1985-91) (Ed. F.P. Neupane)
(Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae) to neem extracts, pp. Institute of Agriculture and Animal Sciences, Rampur,
393-403. In: Natural Pesticides from the Neem Tree Chitwan, Nepal. pp. 70-74
and Other Tropical Plants (Eds. H. Schmutterer and Thapa, R.B. 1997. An overview of pesticide pollution in
K.R.S. Ascher). GTZ Press, Eschborn, Fedral Republic Nepal. Nepalese Hort. 1:31-39.
of Germany. pp. 393-403 Zhu, 1991. Investigations on the Effect of Lecg Extracts of
National Research Council 1992. Neem: A Tree for Solving Melia azedaruch L. on Cabbage Insect Pests and
Global Problems. National Academy Press, Isolation of N Leaf Substance Affecting the
Washington, D.C., USA. Metamorphosis of Insects. Ph.D. Dissertation, Justus-
Neupane, F.P. 1989. Crop Pests and Their Control, 3rd.ed., Liebig - University, Fedral Republic of Germany (in
Sajha Prakashan, Kathmandu (in Nepali). German).
Neupane, F.P. 1995. Country Profile - Agricultural
Entorqology in Nepal. Rev. Agric. Entomol. 83 :1291-
1304.