CHE692- PROCESS MODELLING AND SIMULATION - ASSIGNMENT

Groups Tittle: __________________________

Semester: ____________________________

Unacceptable (0- Marginal

Topic
1) (2 - 3)

A brief introduction to the A brief introduction to the process

process was written. No was written. Literature search on the
evidence that literature topic has been conducted, but with
1 Introduction to the process searches has been little relevency to the topic.
conducted.

Assessment on the mistakes Assessment on the mistakes of the

of the choice of equipment
and sequence of equipment
was not carried out.
2 Choice and sequence of equipment
choice of equipment and sequence
of equipment was carried out, but
with major mistakes. Justification of
the assessment was weakly
described in the report.

Assessment of the Half of the assessment on the

equipement efficiency, the equipement efficiency, the presence
presence of saleable products of saleable products and wastes in
and wastes in both products both products and waste streams
Separation process efficiency, the
and waste streams were not were incorrectly carried out.
3 feasibility of products and waste
carried out.
streams.

4 Fluid flow principle
Assessment of the fluid flow
principles were not correctly
carried out for the plant. No
justification was given on the
assessment of the pressures
selected for streams and
equipment.
More than half of the assessment on
the pressure drop was incorrectly
carried out. Most of the justification
given on the assessment were
incorrect.

Majority of the assessment on About half of the assessment on the

the process conditions process conditions adopted for the
adopted for the whole plant whole plant was incorrect. The
was incorrect, or were not recommendation of the process
carried out. The conditions were partially justified in
recommendation of the the report. No optimum process
Choice of Process Conditions adopted,
5 process conditions not conditions were suggested for any
and optimum conditions of the plant
correctly justified in the report. unit operations.
No optimum process
conditions were suggested for
any unit operations.

Assessment on the overall Assessment on the overall feasibility

feasibility of the plant were
not carried out. No conclusion
Overall feasibility of the plant, to the report presented and
6 the references were not
conclusions and references.
written.
of the plant were not carried out.
Both the conclusion and the
reference were present in the report,
but with limited information.

Overall Performance Unacceptable Marginal

REMARK: _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Panel : . Signature:..
AND SIMULATION - ASSIGNMENT
Name of students: (1)
(2)
(3)
Acceptable
(4 - 5)
A relevant introduction was well written,
describing the process adopted.
Relevant literature searches have been
conducted to aid the process
description.
Assessment on the mistakes of the
choice of equipment and sequence of
equipment was carried out but with
minor mistakes. Justification of the
assessment was described in the
report.
Minor mistakes were found in the
assessment on the equipment
efficiency, the presence of saleable
products and wastes in both products
and waste streams. Comments and
suggestions on how to improve the
process and equipment efficiency well
written.
Exceptional Full
Points Marks
(6) Marks
A relevant and concise introduction
was well written, describing the
process adopted. Outstanding
literature searches have been 10 0
conducted to aid the process
description.
Assessment on the mistakes of the
choice of equipment and sequence of
equipment was thoroughly carried out.
Justification of the assessment was
outstandingly described in the report. 10 0
Correct assessment on the equipment
efficiency, the presence of saleable
products and wastes in both products
and waste streams. Comments and
suggestions on how to improve the
10 0
process were outstandingly described
in the report.
 Minor mistakes on the assessments of
the pressure drop along the process
lines and equipment. Justification was
given on the recommendation of the
new pressure drops and pressure of
both streams and equipment. The
juistification of the new suggested
pressure drops were well described in
the report.
Minor faulty on the assessment on the
process conditions adopted for the
whole plant. The recommendation of
the process conditions were justified in
the report. Optimum process conditions
were correctly suggested, for selected
unit operations, whereever appropriate.
Assessment on the overall feasibility of
the plant were carried out. Both the
conclusion and the reference were
present in the report, correctly.
Acceptable
______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
Correct assessments of the pressure
drop along the process lines and
equipment. Justification was given on
the recommendation of the new
pressure drops and pressure of both
streams and equipment, and 10 0
outstandingly described in the report
Assessment on the process conditions
adopted for the whole plant was
carried out correctly and justified in the
report. Outstanding optimum process
conditions were suggested and
described, for selected unit operations,
whereever appropriate. 5 0
Assessment on the overall feasibility of
the plant were carried out. Both the
conclusion and the reference were
outstandingly presented in the report.
5 0
Exceptional 0 50 0.00
Date:..