JOSE MARIA COLLEGE

College of Law

PROPERTY LAW
st
1 Semester, SY 2017-2018

CASE OUTLINE

FINALS CASE ASSIGNMENT

ALANO = 1-7
AMBROCIO = 8-14
BAUCAN = 15-21
BACAYO = 22-28
BOLIGOR = 29-35
CAGAMPANG = 36-42
CANEDO = 43-49
DELA SERNA = 50-56
DOSDOS = 57-63
ESCALANTE = 64-70
LACANDULA = 71-77
LAURENTE = 78-83
MACATOL = 83-90
MAIZ = 91-97
MALOLOY-ON = 98-104
MIRANDA = 105-110
NENARIA = 111-116
PACQUIAO, LUIS = 117-123
SALCEDO = 124-130

Title VIII. Nuisance

Case Title Citation GR # Date
Bengzon v. Province of Pangasinan 62 PHIL 816 1
Ayala v. Baretto 33 PHIL 538 2
Ramcar v. Millar 6 SCRA 517 3
Iloilo Cold Storage v. Municipal Council 24 PHIL 471 4
Espiritu v. Municipal Council 102 PHIL 867 5
Canlas v. Aquino 2 SCRA 814 6
San Rafael Homeowners v. City of Manila 46 SCRA 40 7
Velasco v. Manila Electric Company 40 SCRA 342 8
Tamin v. CA 208 SCRA 862 97477 May 8, 1992 9
Lucena Grand Central Terminal v. JAC Liner 148339 Feb 23, 2005 10
Hidalgo v. Balandan 91 PHIL 448 11

1
City of Cebu v. Judge Gako AM 08-2111 May 7, 2008 12
Soriano v. Laguardia 164785 Apr 29, 2009 13
RP v. Mijares 170615 Jul 9, 2009 14
Telmo v. Bustamante 182567 Jul 13, 2009 15
Ganvayco v. Government 177807 Oct 11, 2011 16
Perez v. Spouses Madrona 184478 Mar 21, 2012 17

Title IX. Registry of Property

Case Title Citation GR # Date
AFP Mutual Benefit Association vs. CA 104769 Mar 3, 2000 18

Title VII. Easements or Servitudes

Art. Case Title Citation GR # Date
Different 613- Borbajo v. Hidden View [613] 152440 Jan 31, 2005 19
Kinds of 619 Solid Manila v. Bio Hong [617] 90596 Apr 8, 1991 20
Easments Dela Cruz v. Ramiscal [619] 137882 Feb 4, 2005 21
Valdez v. Tabisula [619] 175510 Jul 28, 2008 22
Unisource v. Chung [618] 173252 Jul 17, 2009 23
Liwag v. Happy Glen Loop [614] 189755 Jul 4, 2012 24

Modes of 620- Ronquillo v. Roco [620] L-10619 Feb 28, 1958 25

Acquiring 626 NPC v. Spouses Campos [620] 143643 Jun 27, 2003 26
Easements Laureana Cid v. Irene Javier [621] L-14116 Jun 30, 1960 27
Fe Velasco v. Cusi [622] L-33507 Jul 20, 1981 28
Bogo-Medellin Milling v. CA [622] 124699 Jul 31, 2003 29
Juan Gargantos v. Tan Yanon [624] L-14652 Jun 30, 1960 30
Taedo v. Bernad [624] L-66520 Aug 30, 1988 31
Aneco Realty v. Landex [624] 165952 Jul 28, 2008 32
Goldcrest v. Cypress Gardens [625] 171072 Apr 7, 2009 33
Privatization v. Legaspi Towers [624] 147957 Jul 22, 2009 34
Bicol Agro v. Obias [622] 172077 Oct 9, 2009 35

Rights and 627 Valderrama v. North Negros 23810 Dec 18, 1926 36
Obligations 630 Aneco Realty v. Landex 165952 Jul 28, 2008 37
Pilar v. Dumadag 194336 Mar 11, 2013 38

Modes of 631 Cabacungan v. Corrales [631] L-6629 Sep 30, 1954 39

Extinguish 633 Benedicto v. CA [631] L-22733 Sep 25, 1968 40

2
ment Taedo v. Bernad [631] L-66520 Aug 30, 1988 41
Salimbangon v. Tan 185240 Jan 20, 2010 42

Easement 637 Banzon v. Banzon [642] 27296 Oct 8, 1927 43

Relating to 648 Gonzales v. Purificacion de Dios [643] L-3099 May 21, 1951 44
Waters Valisno v. Adriano [648] L-37409 May 23, 1988 45

Easement 649 Costabella v. CA [649] 80511 Jan 25, 1991 46

of Right of 657 Francisco v. IAC [649] 177 S 527 47
Way Floro v. Llenado [649] 75723 Jun 2, 1995 48
Quimen v. CA [649] 112331 May 29, 1996 49
Sta. Maria vs. CA [649] 127549 Jan 28, 1998 50
Villanueva v. Velasco [649] 130845 Nov 27, 2000 51
Dela Cruz v. Ramiscal [649] 137882 Feb 4, 2005 52
Napocor v. Manubay [649] 150936 Aug 18, 2004 53
Woodridge v. ARB Construction [649] 157825 Feb 16, 2007 54
Obra v. Badua [649] 149125 Aug 9, 2007 55
St. Michael v. Masaito [649] 166301 Feb 29, 2008 56
Valdez v. Tabisula [649] 175510 Jul 28, 2008 57
NPC v. Suarez [649] 175725 Oct 8, 2008 58
NPC v. Benjamin Ong Co [649] 166973 Feb 10, 2009 59
Dichoso v. Marcos [649] 180282 Apr 11, 2011 60
NPC v. Heirs of Sangkay 165828 Aug 24, 2011 61
Juana Complex v. Fil Estate [649] 152272 Mar 5, 2012 62

Encarnacion v. CA [651] 77628 Mar 11, 1991 63

Preysler v. CA [656] 158141 Jul 11, 2006 64

Party Wall 658 Case v. Heirs of Tuazon [658] 5044 Dec 1, 1909 65
666 Lao v. Heirs of Alburo [658] 10372 Dec 24, 1915 66
Valenzuela v. Unson [658] 10266 Oct 20, 1915 67

Easement 667 Cortez v. Yu Tibo [668] 911 Mar 12, 1903 68

of Light 673 Severina Choco v. Santamaria [669] 6076 Dec 29, 1911 69
and View Soriano v. Sterberg [670] 15628 Nov 18, 1920 70
Masongsong v. Flores [672] 36048 Sep 24, 1932 71

Drainage of 674 Cabacungan v. Corrales [674] L-6629 Sep 30, 1954 72

Buildings 676 Purugganan v. Paredes [674] L-23818 Jan 21, 1976 73

3
Lateral & 684 Ngo Sin Sing v. Li Seng Giap 172596 Nov 28, 2008 74
Subjacent Castro v. Monsod 183719 Feb 2, 2011 75
Support

Voluntary 688 North Negros Sugar v. Hidalgo [688] 42334 Oct 31, 1936 76
Easements 693 Trias v. Araneta [688] L-20786 Oct 30, 1965 77
Rivera v. IAC [688] 74249 Jan 20, 1989 78
La Vista v. CA [691] 95252 Sep 5, 1997 79
Unisource v. Chung 173252 Jul 17, 2009 80

Book III

Title III. Donation

Art Case Title Citation GR # Date
725- Nature Abella v. CIR [725] 120721 Feb 23, 2005 81
734 of Lentfer v. Jurgen Wolff [725] 152317 Nov 10, 2004 82
Donatio Ocampo v. Ocampo [725] 150707 Apr 14, 2004 83
ns Tan Queto v. CA [726] L-36548 Feb 27, 1987 84
Lagazo v. CA [726] 112796 Mar 5, 1998 85
Liguez v. CA [727] 102 P 577 86
City of Angeles v. CA [727] 97882 Aug 28, 1996 87
Del Rosario v. Ferrer [728] 187056 Sep 20, 2010 88
Villanueva v. Branoco [728] 172804 Jan 4, 2011 89
Pajarillo v. IAC [729] 72908 Aug 11, 1989 90
Maglasang v. Heirs of Cabatingan [729] 131953 Jun 5, 2002 91
Ganuelas v. Cawad [729] 123968 Apr 24, 2003 92
Spouses Gestopa v. CA [729] 111904 Oct 5, 2000 93
De Luna v. Abrigo [733] 57455 Jan 18, 1990 94
CJ Yulo v. Roman Catholic [733] 133705 Mar 31, 2005 95
Baretto v. City of Manila [734] 7 P 416 96
Shoppers Paradise v. Roque [734] 148775 Jan 13, 2004 97
Imuan v. Cereno 167995 Sep 11, 2009 98

4
735- Person Calicdan v. Cendena [735] 155080 Feb 5, 2004 99
749 who may Heirs of Sevilla v. Sevilla [737] 150179 Apr 30, 2003 100
give or Ortiz v. Basada [744] L-7307 May 19, 1955 101
receive a Catalan v. Basa [737] 159567 Jul 31, 2007 102
donation Lentfer v. Jurgen Wolff [748] 152317 Nov 10, 2004 103
Heirs of Maramag v. De Guzman [739] 181132 Jun 5, 2009 104
Pajarillo v. IAC [749] 72908 Aug 11, 1989 105
Lagazo v. CA [749] 112796 Mar 5, 1998 106
RP vs. Leon Silim [749] 140487 Apr 2, 2001 107
Quilala v. Alcantara [749] 132681 Dec 3, 2001 108
Valencia v. Locquiao [749] 122134 Oct 3, 2003 109
Shoppers Paradise v. Roque [749] 148775 Jan 13, 2004 110
Florencio v. De Leon [749] 149570 Mar 12, 2004 111
JLT Agro v. Balansag [749] 141882 Mar 11, 2005 112
Arangote v. Maglunob [749] 178906 Feb 18, 2009 113
Unchuan v. Lozada [749] 172671 Apr 16, 2009 114
Gutierrez v. Mendoza-Plaza [749] 185477 Dec 4, 2009 115

750- Effect Heirs of Velasquez vs. CA 126996 Feb 15, 2000 116
759 and Spouses Gestopa v. CA 111904 Oct 5, 2000 117
Limitati Calicdan v. Cendana 155080 Feb 5, 2004 118
ons
760- Revocati Ongsiaco v. Ongsiaco Mar 30, 1957 119
773 on and Eduvigis Cruz v. CA [760] L-58671 Nov 22, 1985 120
Reductio De Luna v. Abrigo 57455 Jan 18, 1990 121
n of City of Angeles v. CA [764]] 97882 Aug 28, 1996 122
Donatio Eduarte v. CA [765] 105944 Feb 9, 1996 123
ns Heirs of Velasquez v. CA 126996 Feb 15, 2000 124
Ricky Quilala v. Gliceria Alcantara 132681 Dec 3, 2001 125
Ganuelas v. Cawad 123968 Apr 24, 2003 126
Spouses Gestopa v. CA [765] 111904 Oct 5, 2000 127
RP vs. Leon Silim [764] 140487 Apr 2, 2001 128
Dolar v. Barangay Lublub 152663 Nov 18, 2005 129
Secretary v. Heirs of Dulay 164748 Jan 27, 2006 130