Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Community Assessment of Physical Activity For Children in The City of New Brunswick
Community Assessment of Physical Activity For Children in The City of New Brunswick
Brielle Cattley
Kelsey Musselman
Maya Harb
Chelsea Dizon
Chelsea Cotugno
October 20, 2017 Christina Constantinou
Life Span Community Nutrition Kayla Samson
1
New Brunswick is a medium-sized, densely populated city located in the state of New
Jersey. It is an ethnically-diverse city with a population of 57,035 people and eleven constituent
neighborhoods. (US census 2016). New Brunswick is the nineteenth largest community in New
Jersey with a median age of 23.5 years old (US census 2016). Since the year 2000 there has been
a 17.5% increase in the New Brunswick population (US census 2016). The city is 100% urban,
The children who call New Brunswick home, describe themselves as belonging to a
variety of racial and ethnic groups. People of Hispanic or Latino origin are the most prevalent
group in New Brunswick, accounting for 55.80% of the citys residents, followed by
white/caucasian with 20.9%, African American with 13.2%, Asian with 8.5%, and lastly, some
unspecified races with 1.3% (Data USA 2016). It is important to note that people of Hispanic or
Latino origin can be of any race. Important ancestries of people in New Brunswick include
Our target population is children between the age of two and twelve years old. Children
constitute for 20.82% of the population, thus out of the 57,035 individuals that reside in New
Brunswick, 11,874 are children (Data USA 2016). Most of these children reside with their
parents in residential areas on Westone Mills, Raritan Gardens, Remsen Avenue, Jersey Avenue,
French street, George Street, Hamilton Street, and Joyce Kilmer Avenue (Data USA 2016).
These geographic areas are in near proximity of both schools and parks, thus making it an ideal
area for parents and children to live in. Since our target population is focused on school aged
children, it is understood that the children play no role in bringing an income to their families.
The degree of acculturation within the population varies. First there is the non-
acculturated population, whom only know how to navigate their daily lives within the standards
2
of their native culture. Next there is the acculturated population, whom were born in the United
States with immigrant parents, but only know how to navigate daily life to the standard of
American culture. Finally, the semi-acculturated population, which includes those who can
navigate in both their native culture and American culture with ease.
The childrens literacy level is evident through school data performances. The city of
New Brunswicks rankings in academic performance and college career readiness significantly
lags in comparison to schools across the state. Additionally, its student growth performance lags
in comparison to schools throughout the state. In 2016, the children of New Brunswick
outperformed 6% of schools statewide, and 27% of schools educating students with similar
demographic characteristics (nj.gov 2016). Additionally, the children are meeting 42% of their
performance targets in the area of Academic Achievement (nj.gov 2016). Children of New
Brunswick are meeting 0% of their performance targets in the area of College and Career
The purpose of this community assessment was to determine the standards, needs,
barriers, and current situation as pertains to New Brunswicks adolescent population and
physical activity. Standard physical activity guidelines for children, as defined by the United
States Department of Health and Human Services (USDHHS), is 60 minutes or more of either
these three types of physical activity should be completed at least three times per week.
sufficient physical activity. Factors that may contribute to lack of physical activity include poor
health, poor access to healthcare, lack of fitness mandates in school, limited or no access to
3
The first issue faced by the children of New Brunswick, is poor health. In the Healthier
New Brunswick Community Survey, published April 2006, one in four children were considered
to be overweight or obese, with nearly another quarter of the population considered to be at risk
of being overweight (Cantor et al 2006). These numbers are significantly higher than the national
average which, at the time, was 15% for both children who were overweight, and at risk children
(Cantor et al 2006). Another major issue which can hinder physical activity is asthma, the most
common chronic childhood disease. One in ten children in New Brunswick suffer from asthma,
which is actually half the New Jersey urban rate, but plagues 15% of the target population
(Cantor et al 2006).
Aggravating, or potentially lending cause to, these health issues is poor access to
healthcare. According to a survey published by Robert Wood Johnson (RWJ) in 2014, 24% of
New Brunswick residents surveyed stated that they obtain their primary care from the emergency
room (Pellerano et. al 2014). Of those surveyed, 20% of those surveyed said that it is very hard
or somewhat hard to obtain health care in New Brunswick (Pellerano et. al 2014). Additionally, a
2012 US Census estimates that as much as 32.6% of New Brunswicks population is without
health insurance (Pellerano et. al 2014). All of this culminates in limited access to physicians and
other medical professionals that can instruct the population on how to achieve the USDHHS 60
minutes of recommended physical activity a day. Information from parents of children in New
Brunswick state that only 19% of the target population is meeting the recommendation
(Pellerano et. al 2014). As little as 43% of the child population is getting 30 minutes of physical
One of the shortcomings that children in New Brunswick face is the lack of mandated
physical activity in school. In the 2011 New Jersey Childhood Obesity Study, 55% of students
4
report that they are involved in physical activity for two or fewer days a week at school (Lloyd,
et al 2011). Additionally, the target population is reported to have the lowest rates of physical
The same study did a survey of New Brunswick and noted that the majority of
elementary and middle schools are located in heavily populated areas (Lloyd et al 2011).
However, the parks and other physical activity centers are primarily spread around the
boundaries of the city (Lloyd et al 2011). 19% of children do not have any parks in their
neighborhoods, and an additional 42% state that there are no exercise facilities in their area at all
(Lloyd et al 2011).
There are multiple potential reasons why children do not use the parks or other physical
activity centers in their area. Hazards stated by parents include lack of facilities (42%), traffic
(41%), criminal activity (36%) and unpleasant conditions (25%), assumed to be the state of the
parks (Pellerano et. al 2014). It is interesting to note that while there are areas in New Brunswick
that have as high as 3-4 times the national average of crime, primarily around the elementary and
middle schools, sources from New Brunswick Tomorrow claim that the crime rates are
significantly lower than in other urban areas in New Jersey (Santiago et al 2017). Comparatively,
in an evaluation of five New Jersey communities published in May 2011 (Camden, New
Brunswick, Newark, Trenton, and Vineland), which focused on not only issues that these urban
areas face, but also the disparities found within these low-income areas, parents of New
Brunswick children considered crime to be less of a deterrent to use exercise facilities/parks than
In New Brunswick, the greatest clinical issue arising is obesity due to diet-related
5
Brunswick, almost half of the New Brunswick public school children in every age group
(46.4% average for all ages) are overweight or obese with the highest rates (47.9%) seen among
the youngest, ages 3-5, and the lowest rates (44.0%) among the oldest, ages 12-19 (Ohri-
Vachaspati et al., 2010). With low-income children in the state, New Jersey's adult obesity rates
increased from 19.6% to 24.6% between 2001 and 2012, according to Healthy NJ 2020
(HealthyNJ2020). In addition to that, Healthy NJ 2020 states that, there has been a dramatic
increase in adults, teens and children who are either overweight or obese in New Jersey and
people who are physically active and eat nutritious foods are at a decreased risk of being
overweight and obese. (HealthyNJ2020). Obesity harm is very real it quadruples the risk of
diabetes, to name just one serious consequence, according to the NJ Obesity Prevention Plan.
The prevalence of obesity among children in the United States was 17.0% in 20112014,
according to the CDC, and the prevalence of obesity among preschool-aged children (25
years) (8.9%) was lower than among school-aged children (611 years) (17.5%) and adolescents
In the city of New Brunswick there are various resources for physical activity throughout
the year. New Brunswick is home to fifteen different parks, the majority of which have
included in these parks are walking tracks, tennis courts, and basketball courts. The largest of
these parks are Buccleuch and Boyd (thecityofnewbruswick). These two major parks are
maintained well by the city, but these parks are not completely accessible by everyone in the
There are also several community, church, and school gardens that are accessible in New
Brunswick (thecityofnewbrunswick). Some of these gardens are within the grounds of the public
6
schools, and are therefore only accessible by students, but these school gardens provide learning
The elementary schools of New Brunswick also offer swimming lessons in conjunction
with the Robert Wood Johnson fitness center (Jaymie Santiago). This occurs about two times per
week that elementary students are transported to the fitness center (Jaymie Santiago). Students
are also encouraged to participate in daily recess, gym class, and extracurricular activities
through the schools and through the New Brunswick recreation centers (Jaymie Santiago).
During the summer, various day camps provide physical activity opportunities for
children to stay active when school is not in session. Rutgers Scarlet Knight Camp and the
YMCA summer camp are both available to New Brunswick children (rutgers.edu). However,
these camps can be costly. There are programs like Oasis Summer Camp through the Youth
Empowerment Services that provide summer programs for children grades five through eight to
participate, but these children need to raise money from sponsors to attend (YESNB). Also, there
is the Help New Brunswick Kids Play S.A.F.E. program during the summers where children of
ages six to twelve have access to different activities throughout the summer, but the website for
this program is not very up to date so it is unclear if it has been running during recent summers
(Patch).
Many organizations, agencies, and services exist in the New Brunswick community that
provide residents with amenities which promote health and wellness. The first organization that
contributes to the city is the New Brunswick Cultural Center. This agency influences cultural
development and economic growth of arts and entertainment in the city of New Brunswick (New
Brunswick Cultural Center). They are responsible for hosting annual events such as the Hub City
Music Festival, as well as, Hub City Sounds. These types of events advocate physical wellness
7
and administer ways to stay active because they encourage residents, specifically children, to
sing and dance and interact with people from different neighborhoods. It also provides an
opportunity for kids to grow in an environment where they are able to learn from a variety of
cultures. The New Brunswick Cultural Center is supported by Johnson and Johnson and
Middlesex County. The Middlesex County Board of Chosen Freeholders provided a grant award
from the Middlesex County Cultural and Arts Trust Fund to fund the center (New Brunswick
Cultural Center).
identifies community needs and issues and develop solutions to improve the livelihood of the
community (New Brunswick Tomorrow). They are supported by Robert Wood Johnson
University Hospital, Johnson & Johnson, and other organizations. One recent work of New
Brunswick Tomorrow that helped the target audience is reversing the trend of childhood obesity.
With the support from Robert Wood Johnson, they formed The New Jersey Partnership for
Healthy Kids -- New Brunswick. This project is co-directed by New Brunswick Tomorrow and
the Raritan Valley YMCA. The projects goal is to change the direction of childhood obesity
rates by improving access to affordable healthy foods and beverages, and especially by
Lastly, the Catholic Charities, Diocese of Metuchen provides quality services to the poor,
vulnerable, and all people in need and partners with families and communities to improve the
communities across Middlesex County, however they also have bases in other counties of New
Jersey. In particular, they contribute child care services, such as the Youth Enrichment Services
(YES), which is located directly in New Brunswick, that ensure every child becomes a successful
8
learner. Not only do these services improve learning, but they also provide affordable child care
and summer camp programs. Summer camp programs are extremely valuable, especially for
children living in low income communities because it gives them the opportunity to engage in
activities that keep them active in which their own communities may be lacking. Catholic
Charities, Diocese of Metuchen is supported by other organizations such as, Joint Commission
and United Way. They are all nonprofit organizations who partner with one another to enhance
As a community nutritionist, the best partners to recruit to further the mission for keeping
children of the New Brunswick community physically active is New Brunswick Tomorrow. New
Brunswick Tomorrow works to remain active and involved within the community to ensure that
the residents of New Brunswick have everything that they need. They are also based in the
community, which provides leverage for them to get a hands-on experience on the issues and
needs the community may be facing. By having this advantage, they are better able to develop
solutions that attempt to accommodate almost all of the citizens in need. Solutions, such as
developing ways to keep children physically active, are one way that New Brunswick Tomorrow
may resolve these issues more easily compared to the other organizations, because they include
employees that have grown up in the city, such as Manuel Castaneda, the Director of Community
Health. With locally based employees, the organization is better able to gain a perspective on the
Given that Rutgers University is immersed in the city of New Brunswick, many of the
events that occur in New Brunswick are related to, or executed by, the Rutgers community.
However, there are a number of events in the city of New Brunswick that are open to the
community on a regular basis. One of New Brunswicks main scheduled community events is,
9
New Brunswick Ciclovia. New Brunswick Ciclovia is a free initiative that takes place across the
city and attempts to promote healthy active living. During Ciclovia, all the streets of New
Brunswick are closed to cars for 5 hours (Torres 2017), and essentially allow for people to walk,
run, bike, skate, or just enjoy and explore the city streets. There are typically three to four
different Ciclovia scheduled dates throughout the year; with the focus being on the spring,
summer and fall seasons. New Brunswick Ciclovia is a huge opportunity for various
organizations to get the people of the community more involved in benefitting their own health.
There are a number of different sponsors and volunteers that participate on the day of Ciclovia,
and thus this may be the perfect opportunity to further educate the target population on the
Another example of a scheduled community event in New Brunswick is the Fall Festival.
This is a seasonal festival day for children scheduled at Rutgers Gardens. This again, aims to
get children moving and outside. Things like a scavenger hunt, visiting the animals, and playing
games are scheduled to keep the children busy and entertained. These types of events happen to
address the concern that children are not getting enough physical activity, in that they are aimed
towards getting children to be more active and live a healthier, more balanced lifestyle.
There are additional resources outside New Brunswicks immediate community, such as
the larger supermarkets in both Edison and Highland Park, the Raritan Bay YMCA, and other
The patterns of social interactions in New Brunswick may restrict young children from
getting the recommended amount of physical activity due to the high poverty rate of the
community, lack of transportation, and dual income families. During the school year
(September-June) school aged children spend a majority of their day inside the classroom, rather
10
than outside exercising. New Brunswick middle schools and high schools (grades 6-12) provide
the opportunities for students to join after-school sports teams (New Brunswick Schools 2016).
However, New Brunswick elementary schools do not provide any intramural sports for their
students.
The low-income status of families in New Brunswick prevents community members from
participation in fitness centers of local gyms that may cost a standard fee. As previously stated,
the closest YMCA to New Brunswick is the Raritan Bay YMCA. The athletic club offers many
recreational sports and classes to children of all ages, however there is a membership fee to be a
part of the YMCA, in addition to the costs of specific activities at the club. For families with
more than one child, paying to be a member of the YMCA is not a plausible way to get children
the physical activity that they need (Raritan Valley YMCA 2015). Due to the low-income status
of the community, unless an activity or recreational center is free, it will likely not be utilized by
Additionally, many members of the community lack the transportation to get to places
like parks, the gym, or the YMCA. A majority of the community does not own a car, rather they
walk wherever they need to go. As many as 29.3% of households in New Brunswick do not own
a car, while 34.7% of households share one car (Data USA 2015). Although walking to where
they need to go provides extra exercise, it also limits the places they can go to. Also, when it
becomes cold outside, children are significantly less likely to be outside walking, and most likely
barely meet the recommendation for daily physical activity. Some members of the community
ride bikes, which is a great form of exercise, however, many of the bike riders are adult men,
using bicycles as a way to get to work. Less often we see young children riding bikes as a form
of exercise.
11
Due to dual-income families in the community, there is frequently no guardian home to
take children out of the house for exercise. When the parent/guardian(s) are working, children
often come home from school and stay at home until their parents return from work. At a young
age, it is not appropriate for children to be walking to local parks on their own. Furthermore, data
shows that children are spending proportionally too much time looking at a computer or phone
screen both while at school and at home. Screen time is not closely monitored amongst children,
especially when parents use technology to occupy their children when they are working.
These common social interactions in New Brunswick address the concern of lack of
physical activity amongst children in several ways. Sports teams in middle schools and high
schools help kids become more active, so long as the equipment is available to them at little or
Interactions between the Raritan Valley YMCA and New Brunswick schools might
further the mission of getting young children to be more physically active. The YMCA may be
able to work with the school system by providing children with transportation from the school to
the YMCA and back. This interaction would make it simple for children to be more active while
overcoming the barrier of transportation and two working parents. Additionally, reduced prices
of YMCA membership may be necessary in order to include more low income community
There are several county officials in Middlesex County whom advocate for a healthier
and more active lifestyle as well as promoting better education about healthy lifestyles. Charles
E. Tomaro, whom holds the chair of county Administration in Middlesex County, is dedicated to
his goal of improving the quality of life for Middlesex County residents (Middlesex County
2014). Tomaro spent some time living in New Brunswick while studying Business Management.
12
Before attending Rutgers, he attended Middlesex County College (Middlesex County 2014).
After calling this community home for so many years, Tomaro would be a great leader to get
and is dedicated to offering the best devices and tools for children in the community to learn
(Middlesex County 2014). He has been involved in public service within the Middlesex
community since the age of 19. As a councilman, Mr. Armwood was involved in the renovation
of Quibbletown Park, where the All Childrens Playground was designed for children with or
without disabilities so that they can play together, providing Middlesex County with one of the
most unique parks in the State (Middlesex County 2014). Armwood is dedicated to the health
and wellness of all children in the community, and therefore he would be a key leader and
politician to have on board for any wellness projects posed to take place in the community.
Furthermore, more opinion leaders could be found in the staff and board members of
New Brunswicks school systems. Often the teachers and board of education are on board to
participate in any programs that will help the children live a healthier lifestyle while also being
better educated about healthy habits. School boards, PTO, Boy Scout and Girl Scout troops, and
churches all contain opinion leaders whom may be beneficial to have on board with a community
It is necessary to have involvement from local politicians and local educators as well as
having involvement from parents and children within the community. If parents and children
show an interest in wanting to better their own communities, more opinion leaders are likely to
welcome the idea. Freeholders such as Charles E. Tomaro, and Kenneth Armwood are important
13
figures to get involved with activities in the community because they have power and money to
New Brunswick, as a city with over three times the poverty as the statewide average
(Poverty in New Brunswick 2017), faces significant difficulties when attempting to overcome
the issues pertaining to adolescent physical activity. Many of these issues can be attributed to the
high rates of poverty within New Brunswicks community. Poor access to healthcare, which
(Thomas 2014). New Brunswick is no exception with nearly 50% of the adolescent population
transportation among the families of the target population. While New Brunswick is equipped
with fifteen parks, as well as multiple fitness facilities, both within the city and in surrounding
towns, lack of transportation prevents the majority of the population from being able to utilize
their resources. New Brunswick is 5.23 square miles (New Brunswick, New Jersey 2017) and
can be difficult to traverse on foot. The crime rates, listed to be a concern for 36% percent of the
overall population (Pellerano et all 2014), also adds to the undesirability of walking to each of
these locations.
The next barrier that high rates of poverty contributes to is the inability of adolescents to
participate in the programs available due to high membership fees. New Brunswick has multiple
recreational sport programs, but due to the sign-up fees, attendance from the target population is
low (DAlonzo 2017). Other resources, like Raritan Bay YMCA or summer camps, also have
admission fees and can be too costly for the families of the target population. It is important to
14
note that the elementary schools in New Brunswick do not have school-facilitated sports
The final barrier to success in promoting physical activity among adolescents, is the lack
of support from the school system. As previously stated, New Brunswicks elementary schools
do not provide after-school sports programs for the younger target population. Additionally,
standards for physical activity for adolescents reportedly results in exercise two or fewer days
Despite the many barriers that persist within the community, there are several objectives that
potential activities may include but are not limited to: Training sessions and
sport/recreation forums.
2. Find financially accessible ways for children to stay active throughout the
summer. One way to do this would be for the various summer camps listed to
group. This would encourage children to work hard in school so that they are able
to have a truly enjoyable and active summer. The members of New Brunswick
15
Tomorrow as well as representatives from the individual summer camps would be
the most direct groups to work with to make this a possibility for children.
USDHHS standards if a partnership between the Raritan Bay YMCA and New
Brunswick school systems were implemented. The YMCA may be able to work
with the school to provide children with transportation from the school to the
YMCA and back. This interaction would make it simple for children to be more
active while overcoming the barrier of transportation and two working parents.
This objective would require transportation from the township, similarly to the
middle school and high school sports teams being bussed around for games.
4. All elementary schools should host a Field Day every semester that promote
physical activity. During this free event, teachers and/or adults who have
extensive knowledge in health and fitness will provide lessons teaching children
how to find strategies in which they can be active around the community. Not
only will these trainers help children find everyday physical activities, they will
also demonstrate a variety of simple workout routines that young children can
active, they can execute this newfound knowledge outside of the school, where
5. The cleanliness and safety of the recreational parks in New Brunswick can be
Communities Council of New Jersey and the New Brunswick Police Department.
A clean park for the children and families of New Brunswick will allow greater
16
access for everyone to do physical activity in. By helping to advertise and
advocate for Urban Cleanup Week, more people will be willing to aide in the
cleanup activities for their community. The frequency of Urban Cleanup Week
should be advocated for once a month, instead of 1-2 times a year. This way, the
parks can be cleaned more often, which will allow for a more aesthetically
pleasing physical activity environment. The safety of the park should be acted
This can be done by partnering up with the New Brunswick Police Department to
Bibliography
Cantor, Joel C., Guarnaccia, Peter, Brownlee, Susan, Schneider, Carl, Nova, Jose. .
Health and Health Care of New Brunswick's Children. Rutgers Center for State
Health Policy, April 2006, www.cshp.rutgers.edu/Downloads/6510.pdf.
17
City of New Brunswick, City Hall, The City of New Brunswick, 2016,
thecityofnewbrunswick.org/.Accessed October 2017
Lanman, S. Rutgers Offers Summer Arts, Academic and Sports Camp Programs for
Kids.Rutgers Offers Summer Arts, Academic and Sports Camp Programs for Kids |
Rutgers Today, 18 Feb. 2013, news.rutgers.edu/news-release/rutgers-offers-summer-
arts-academic-and-sports-camp-programs-kids/20130218#.WeE9iGiPI2w
Lloyd, Kristen, MPH, Yedidia, Michael, PhD, Ohri-Vachaspati, Punam, PhD, RD.
New Jersey Childhood Obesity Study. Publications, May 2011,
www.cshp.rutgers.edu/Downloads/8800.pdf.
New Brunswick, New Jersey. New Brunswick, New Jersey Housing Info, Advameg,
Inc, 2017, www.city-data.com/city/New-Brunswick-New-Jersey.html.
18
National Center for Health Statistics. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 28 Oct. 2015,
www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db219.htm.
New Jersey State Health Assessment Data New Jersey's Public Health Data
Resource. NJSHAD - Community Health Highlights Report Indicator Page
www26.state.nj.us/doh-
shad/community/highlight/profile/GeneralHealth.County/GeoCnty/12.html.
New Jersey State Obesity Plan. The Office of Nutrition and Fitness | Shaping NJ
2013,
http://www.state.nj.us/health/fhs/shapingnj/library/ShapingNJ%20Obesity%20Preventi
on%20Plan-Final.pdf
Nutrition, Physical Activity, and Obesity. Nutrition, Physical Activity, and Obesity |
Healthy People 2020, www.healthypeople.gov/2020/leading-health-indicators/2020-
lhi-topics/Nutrition-Physical-Activity-and-Obesity.
Ogden, Cynthia L., et al. Prevalence of obesity among adults and youth: United States,
2011-2014. US Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention, National Center for Health Statistics, 2015.
Pellerano, Maria B., and Eric Jahn. Measurement to Promote a Healthier New
Brunswick. Survey of New Brunswick, 2014,
rwjms.umdnj.edu/community_programs/measurement_healthier_nb.pdf.
19
Poverty in New Brunswick. New Brunswick, New Jersey (NJ) Poverty Rate Data,
Advameg, Inc., 2017, www.city-data.com/poverty/poverty-New-Brunswick-New-
Jersey.html.
QuickFacts. U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts Selected: New Brunswick City, New
Jersey,2016 www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/newbrunswickcitynewjersey/PST0
45216.
Thomas, Lillian. Poor Health: Poverty and Scarce Resources in U.S. Cities. Poor
Health, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 2014, newsinteractive.post-
gazette.com/longform/stories/poorhealth/1/.
Torres, Briana. New Brunswick Ciclovia. The City Of New Brunswick - Health,
thecityofnewbrunswick.org/health/2017/06/27/new-brunswick-ciclovia/.
20
Youth Enrichment Services. Catholic Charities, Diocese of Metuchen,
ccdom.org/youth-enrichment-services.
21