Professional Documents
Culture Documents
When We Freeze, We Die: Rogan Jacobson, Xavier College
When We Freeze, We Die: Rogan Jacobson, Xavier College
When We Freeze, We Die: Rogan Jacobson, Xavier College
little thugs who guarded the Kremlins latest American is told in the first person and mainly in
battlement.11 flashback. The novel reads like Fowlers confession,
To explore how Greene and Le Carr present starting and finishing on the hot evening Pyle is
their ideological battlegrounds, let us turn to the assassinated. The heat around Fowler increases as
setting of both novels. There are many similarities the novel progresses, reaching boiling point as the
between the physical setting and charged moral novel reaches crisis the night Pyle is killed, where it
atmosphere surrounding protagonists Fowler and was too hot in bed and Fowler is metaphorically
Leamas. Both novels are set in war-ravaged foreign woken up from a postcolonial sleep to begin his
countries, Vietnam and Germany, which became key new life with Phuong (a name meaning Phoenix in
battlegrounds in the Cold War. These settings would Vietnamese). Whenever we meet the American cold
be relatively alien to a British readership, and reflect war ideologue Pyle, however, he is followed by cold
the global reach of these ideological battlefronts. symbolism. The first time Pyle meets Phuong, it was
Binary metaphors of light/dark and warm/cold are a momentary cool ; when Pyle tracks Fowler down
employed by both novelists to directly characterise in Phat Diem, cold dominates despite the flames
their protagonists, with both novels starting and and a cold wind ruffled the straw of the yard . That
finishing at night where the darkness conveys a rich night, before Pyle declares his love for Phuong, the
symbolism of secrecy, evil, and immorality. For our temperature was only a degree above zero and again
protagonists, integrity and humanity become the when Pyle and Fowler are trapped in the tower, Pyle
enemies, for the integrity of individuals must be reminds us its going to be quite chilly .
subverted before they will betray secrets.12 As the events progress and Fowlers anger at Pyle and
Quiet American starts and finishes on the same what he represents begins to rise, the atmosphere
night as it is told, largely in flashback and recount. heats up. Fowlers first meeting with Heng is
Key events all happen in the dead of night; such surrounded by heat imagery: when Dominguez sends
Pyles death13, the events at Phat Diem and Pyle Fowler to meet the communists, sweat is pouring
saving Fowlers life. Nights in Quiet American see down his face, but he just let it run as though the
heavy drinking, brothels visited, opium smoked, drops were alive and sacred ; as Fowler waits to meet
murders committed and lives betrayed. Spy also them drinking tea the heat scorched my fingers.
opens and closes at night on the Berlin Wall under When Fowler starts to argue with Pyle over his
the glare of arc lighting14. It is at night that beatings divorce, it was a hot afternoon. Heat, then, becomes
and torture happen and at night that all of the most symbolic of a reaction to the cold ideologies of the
significant deaths occur. Similarly, both novels begin USA, and its robotic approach to human life.
and end with allied spies being brutally executed Ideas of cold are explored further when an angry
by communists Pyle in Quiet American and Karl and fired up Fowler goes to the American Legion
and Leamas in Spy. And both start and finish in the to rail against Pyle and ends up crying in their
same physical place: Quiet American with Fowler bathroom, leaning against the cold wall and
at his home over the rue Catinat the night Pyle is presently the temperate tempered air dried my tears
assassinated, and Spy with Leamas at the empty as it dries the spit in your mouth and the seed in
stage of the Berlin Wall, firstly to fail, then finally your body. Greene here uses the metaphor of the
to die. The global political associations surrounding air that has been tampered with in the American
each physical setting would resonate strongly with Legion, where Pyle works, using the alliteration of
the British reader. These settings serve to drop the temperate tempered to stress robotic precision,
reader in res into the local battlegrounds of the showing the truly inhuman nature of American cold
Cold War in all its bloody glory, war ideology. By use of this metaphor, it is as though
enforcing the common tropes the very buildings occupied by Americans exude all
of espionage and murder from the unnatural horrors of the Cold War: they dry spit
the very beginning of the novels. or refuse to allow passionate debate; they dry tears
Finally, both novelists extensively through machines not empathy, and they dry the
use weather to explore ideological seed in your body killing off all real human passion
forces in the construction of their in the face of the artificial or theoretical. At the crisis
protagonists. of the novel Fowler is surrounded by heat symbolism
Rich in fire and heat imagery, Quiet from the hot morning of the bombing through the
warm evening chat with Pyle in a flat full of droning
1990 Kim Philby, commemorated on a Soviet postage stamp. summer mosquitoes to Pyles nighttime assassination
Source: Wikimedia Commons
Attack on the US Embassy, Saigon at the time of the Tet Offensive. Source: Wikimedia Commons
while Fowler is eating at a restaurant in the instructed to stay out in the cold a little longer. This
heavy evening heat symbolism which continues atmosphere recurs at every key event for Leamas in
through the dnouement of the novel, as Fowler is the novel: when he walks home after his first day at
interviewed by Detective Vigot. work in the library it is bitterly cold outside ; when
Like Greene, cold for Le Carr also symbolises Liz finds him near death it was bitterly cold in the
a world ruled by ends justifying means ideology. room, and dark; and when he leaves Controls final
An inhuman and immoral atmosphere, the Cold briefing he slips out into the cold . It was cold the
War diegesis of his novel is a place where Nazis are morning Leamas begins his mission, cold but clear
helped to execute Jews, love is betrayed and allies his first morning of interrogation with Fiedler, his
executed all in the name of ideology. Leamas feet were icy cold the morning after Mundt tortures
lives permanently out in the cold physically and him and finally as he and Liz escape to the Wall,
metaphorically. As a professional spy, he is a paper Le Carr tells us that a full moon had risen and the
figure15 who exists in a moral near-death state16. frost hovered in long shrouds across the fields. The
Cold imagery follows Leamas for the entire novel. character of Leamas, then, is characterised in direct
When we first meet him at night on the Wall, he is opposition to life, to warmth, to the normal human
being buffeted by the Icy October wind drinking ties that bond. Metaphors of heat and cold, and the
liquor to keep warm, foreshadowing the brutal choice to engage in the passions of love and life, to
ending of the novel, as the reader discovers that, rebel against the cold world of ideology come to
despite a newfound love for Liz, Leamas will not be typify Greene and Le Carrs construction of their
allowed to warm up, will not come in from the cold protagonists.
and he will not start a new life. For Le Carr, the The attitude of both British novelists towards
distance from normal human relations a spy must Cold War ideologues is one of cynicism and moral
maintain to protect himself and his secrets is seen outrage at their secrecy18 and methodologies.
metaphorically as distance from humanity and, as Leamas and Fowler actively deride the Cold War
Martin notes, spies become enmeshed in an infernal ideologies where ends justify means philosophies
web of lies and deceit and treachery.17 When Leamas are espoused by the leaders around them to achieve
is brought in to London after the death of Karl, he is the distant philosophical ends of defending
as is a kind of insanity , and prides himself on his paid off, and thats the only rule. For Leamas, spies
journalistic objectivity: as a reporter, I had no real are not heroes or moral warriors. They are merely
opinions about anything. Leamas, an experienced a squalid procession of vain fools, traitors too, yes:
British spy, voices a similar lack of opinion: I dont pansies, sadists and drunkards, people who play
believe in anything. Fowlers objective detachment cowboys and Indians and brighten their rotten lives.
from the politics and ideological passion of war is As Le Carr wrote to the Russians, The Communist
so total, that he refuses a protective helmet from a should be able to reconcile the loss of innocent life
French soldier near Phat Diem, replying, Those are with the progress of the proletarian revolution;
for combatants. Western man cant.28
We meet Greenes cold warrior late in his career. He Both novels characterise their protagonists by their
is old, and immoral even by the jaded standards of opposition to the mouthpieces of Cold War ideology
a modern reader. Fowler has lived a life of lying and (Fiedler and Pyle) who they befriend then betray. For
betrayal. He smokes opium regularly, betrays his wife Pyle and Fiedler individual deaths do not matter in
with the much younger Phuong, and lies to everyone the drive towards unchanging29 ideological ends.
to satisfy his base desires: he lies to Phuong about It is against this maxim that Leamas and Fowler
the divorce, lies to Pyle about Phuong, lies to Vigot become engag. After the massacre at the caf, Pyle
about Pyle, writes false or confusing reports26 tells Fowler they were only war casualties it was
and on and on it goes. Greenes cold warrior, a pity, but you cant always hit your target. Anyway,
then, is presented as a grey man with no personal they died in the right cause. Similarly, Fielder
morality. As a reporter in wartime he knows almost tells Leamas I myself would have put a bomb in a
everything he writes will be censored, heavily edited restaurant if it brought us (the party) further along
or just plain ignored, but it is through Fowlers the road. Afterwards I would draw the balance so
confessional tone that the narrative criticism of US many women, so many children: and so far along
ideology is voiced. As Whitfield argues, it is precisely the road. It is this debasement of the individual
this warts and all portrayal of Fowlers moral faults, before the demands of ideology that Greene and Le
his cynical aloofness from the ideological claims Carr fight so vehemently. As Greene says, it is not
of the Communists and from the patriotism of the betrayal or defection that interest me, but what goes
French, his scarred frailty and moral uncertainty
(which) all validate his authority as a teller.27
Le Carr uses a hearsay style of narration to
introduce us to Leamas at the end of a long career
as a spy, which has cost him a marriage, his children
and his friends. His entire operation in Berlin has
failed, with all of his agents killed by the ex-Nazi
head of the Abteilung, Mundt. Leamas is a heavy
drinker with few friends who looked like trouble,
and perhaps most importantly like Fowler before
him he is not quite a gentleman. When recalled to
London, he expects to be put on ice and Control
asks if he is burnt out. Leamas has no political
philosophy and doesnt trust those that do, and
in the face of ideology, even from his own side,
he is lost. When Control starts to talk Cold War
philosophy early in the novel, he writes it off as
drivel and when Mundt is described as a non-
intellectual practitioner of the Cold War, Leamas
adds like us. When Fiedler presses him for his
own views on Cold War ideologies Leamas sums
up his entire philosophy with the line I just think
the whole lot of you are bastards. In Leamas world
there is only one moral rule: it is justified by results,
an idea repeated towards the end of the novel when
Leamas tells Liz it was a foul, foul operation. But its
Graham Greene. Source: Wikimedia Commons
with it, a sort of waning faith30 and for Le Carr, having lived long lives working for those that do.
this immoral behaviour a cost too high for society to It is precisely in reaction to the actions of such
pay.31 ideologues as Pyle and Fiedler that our protagonists
eventually become engag, pledging themselves to
Events eventually force our protagonists to become
life and to love in the face of the immoral espionage
engag, and to embrace the passions of the real
bureaucracies and faceless ideologues from both
people (not the spies) around them. Both men are
sides of the Cold War. Greene shows us the rectitude
led down this path by love for a much younger and
of such action, as Fowler is handsomely rewarded
more vibrant woman, though the results are very
for his attack on ideology and his life changes almost
different. The word engag comes from an ancient
entirely for the better: his rival is removed, his wife
French notion of a pledge, and it is this meaning
grants him a divorce, his employer a promotion and
Greene and Le Carr bring forth in very different
his lover a new life together. Le Carr is perhaps
ways. Fowler becomes engag after the caf bombing,
more cynical; however, as for Leamas, there will
when he realises what Pyle will inflict upon the
be no redemption. His new love and new life are
innocent people of Vietnam. Fowler cannot stay
kindled, begin to glow but are then dragged down
degag forever: sooner or later one has to take
with him into his cold grave.
sides, if one is to remain human. As White argues,
the event forces Fowler to confront the insufficiency
of his critical detachment and marks a moment of Endnotes
transcendence wherein his love for Phuong becomes 1
Hobsbawm, E. Age of Extremes: The Short Twentieth
a greater love for the Vietnamese people signifying Century 19141991. Great Britain: Abacus (1995), p226
Fowlers awakening to true empathy.32 When Fowler 2
Hindersmann, J. The Right Side Lost but the Wrong
betrays Pyle to the communists, the transformation Side Won: John Le Carrs Spy Novels before and After
is complete: I had betrayed my own principles; I had the End of the Cold War, Clues 23, no.4 (2005), p27
become as engag as Pyle. For Fowler to become 3
Stevenson, A. (ed.) Warsaw Pact Oxford Dictionary of
engag is an ethical imperative: to champion the English. Oxford University Press, 2010. Oxford Reference
cause of life by insisting on the authenticity of those Online. Oxford University Press. Sydney University. 17
deaths Pyle considers to be merely symbolic.33 June 2012 http://www.oxfordreference.com.ezproxy1.
Leamas, however, begins to become engag after library.usyd.edu.au/views/ENTRY.html?subview=Main&e
falling in love with Liz, almost as though he is making ntry=t140.e0938560
a new pledge with life.34 Leamas tells us he knew 4
Kim Philby, quoted in Jackson, H. Kermit Kim
then what it was that Liz had given him. It was a Roosevelt: US presidents grandson who masterminded
respect for triviality whether it was bread for the CIA coup to restore the Shah of Iran, The Guardian,
seagulls or love. The affair reawakens an inner Tuesday 13 June, available from http://www.guardian.
vulnerability35 in Leamas. He starts to believe his co.uk/news/2000/jun/13/guardianobituaries.
love for Liz may be his salvation, for which Mundt haroldjackson
calls him a fool , and in his newfound humanity rails 5
Le Carr, J. Foreword, in The Spy Who Came in from
with his last thoughts at the death of the innocent the Cold. London: Sceptre, 2006, p5
children on the bus. It is this sense of innocence that 6
VietnamGear.com Vietnam War Timeline: 1963 1964
finally allows Leamas to choose death with Liz, over Available from http://www.vietnamgear.com/war1963.
a life without her as he climbs down the Wall at the aspx
end of the novel. 7
Kennedy, John Fitzgerald. Ich bin ein Berliner Speech
(June 26, 1963), available at http://millercenter.org/
In conclusion, we can see that the characters
president/speeches/detail/3376
of Fowler and Leamas are constructed in direct
opposition not only to the content, but the very
8
Allain, M-F. (Trans. By Waldman, G.) The Other Man:
articulation of Cold War ideologies. The physical Conversations With Graham Greene. Great Britain: The
Bodley Head, 1983, p39
atmosphere of both novels comments continually
on these ideologies, with political philosophies
9
Le Carr, J. About John le Carr: An overview of his
represented by cold winds and inhuman history and a word on the Author by the Author, available
environments and normal lives full of love and from http://www.johnlecarre.com/author
innocence symbolised by warmth. Our characters are 10
Greene, G. Ways of Escape. Great Britain: The Bodley
both constructed as moving in from this cold, with Head (1980) p164/5
very different results. Neither protagonist espouses 11
Le Carr, J. Foreword, in The Spy Who Came in from
any form of philosophy, but both are portrayed as
no. 3 (2001): 406419. Martin, B K. Le Carrs The Spy Who Came In From
Hopkins, M.F. Continuing Debate And New Approaches The Cold: A Structuralist Reading, Sydney studies in
In Cold War History, The Historical Journal, Volume: English 14 (January 01, 1988): 7288.
50 (2007): 913934 Maxwell, R. What Is a Spy to Do? Social Text, No. 56
Horn, E. and Ogger, S. Knowing the Enemy: The (Autumn, 1998): 125141
Epistemology of Secret Intelligence, Grey Room, No. Schrecker, E., Introduction: Cold War Triumphalism
11 (Spring, 2003): 5885 and the Real Cold War, in Cold War Triumphalism:
Jackson, H. Kermit Kim Roosevelt: US presidents The Misuse of History After the Fall of Communism,
grandson who masterminded CIA coup to restore the ed. Ellen Schrecker (New York: New York Press, 2004),
Shah of Iran, The Guardian, Tuesday 13 June, available 124.
from http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/2000/jun/13/ Smith, Z., Introduction, in The Quiet American,
guardianobituaries.haroldjackson Greene, G. (London: Vintage, 2004), vii-xiii
Kennedy, John Fitzgerald. Ich bin ein Berliner Speech Steigman, K. The literal American: rereading Graham
(June 26, 1963), available at http://millercenter.org/ Greene in an age of security, College Literature,
president/speeches/detail/3376 Volume 39, Issue 1 (Winter 2012): 126
Le Carr, J. The Spy Who Came in from the Cold. London: Stevenson, A. (ed.) Warsaw PactOxford Dictionary
Sceptre, 2006. of English. Oxford University Press, 2010.
Le Carr, John To Russia, with Greetings: An Open Letter Oxford Reference Online. Oxford University
to the Moscow Literary Gazette, Encounter, (May Press.Sydney University.17 June 2012http://www.
1966): 36. Available from http://www.unz.org/Pub/ oxfordreference.com.ezproxy1.library.usyd.edu.
Encounter-1966may-00003?View=PDF au/views/ENTRY.html?subview=Main&entry=t140.
Le Carr, J. About John leCarr: An overview of his e0938560
history and a word on the Author by the Author, VietnamGear.com Vietnam War Timeline: 1963 1964
available from http://www.johnlecarre.com/author http://www.vietnamgear.com/war1963.aspx
Le Carr, J. Foreword, in The Spy Who Came in from the White, C.D. Graham Greenes The Quiet American,
Cold. London: Sceptre, 2006: 58. The Explicator 67, no. 1 (2008): 3335.
Long, A. The Quiet Americans? CIA, NSA, and Whitfield, S.J. Limited Engagement: The Quiet American
Counterinsurgency, Journal of Cold War Studies as History, Journal of American Studies 30, (1996):
13, no. 3 (2011): 149184. 6586.