Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gerrard Lilburne (Pseudonym For Atle Hesmyr) : Agraria and Urbania
Gerrard Lilburne (Pseudonym For Atle Hesmyr) : Agraria and Urbania
Urbania
Gerrard Lilburne
1
Agraria and Urbania
ISBN 9781976729614
Nisus Publications
2
For Viktoria, in thankfulness for all the
inspiration
3
I
It was springtime in 1758. The world wide war between
England and France was raging in its third year, and
innumerable ships with their crews had been sunk – in
the Atlantic as well as in the Indian Ocean. To the French
yeoman and artisan, Louis-Olivier Fourier, the war was –
as such – an abominable absurdity. He had himself, with
his own hands, participated in building several of the
ships which were sacrificed in the war, and he had lost
several of his comrades in the battle at sea.
4
Bacon, Gerrard Winstanley and John Locke, and these
philosophers’ thoughts had also influenced the
intellectual life of Continental Europe to a certain extent.
7
between their workshops, in the old neighbourhood in the
old port of Newcastle-upon-Tyne.
8
studying history and doing historical research for more
than 30 years.”
9
After the lunch break the both of them went back to their
craft work. Gaius hade recently been hired for blacksmith
work related to the equipment of the British war ships – a
work which he spoiled as much as possible, without
bringing him troubles with the authorities. Instead, he
used his time for making rifles for the planned revolt.
Like most artisans, Faith had also been commanded to
furnish the battling forces with equipment. She was
supposed to sew leather boots for the marines, and due to
the fact that the availability of leather was more even
than the availability of iron – because of the customarily
calm and sedate farmers, compared to the far more
riotous tendency among the members of the peasantry
who had been driven off their soil in the past generations,
only to be absorbed in the mining and metallurgical
industries – she had considerably more trouble with
sabotaging her delivery of ready made boots. However,
she managed to put away a pair now and then, meant for
the needy within the ranks of the revolutionary when the
time came.
10
II
11
this species was meant to be obsessed with gold mining,
and it came to populate vast areas of the Middle East and
also to spread into Europe.
12
nationalist, and he supported to the fullest extent the
Enlightenment philosophers in his country by offering
them high positions within his state administration, and
let thinkers such as Diderot get peace in their work
situation, even though it occasionally had to be
conducted in prison because of the pressure from the
Franch clergy as well as nobility.
13
went there on special market days, which regularly
occurred towards the end of every week.
14
Jeanne had learned glass blowing from her father,
Olivier, who was still active in procuring coal for the
glass making process in her workshop, which required
temperatures upwards to 1200 degrees Celsius. He still
blew glass, presently in Jeanne’s workshop, although he
had gradually relaxed his labour activity lately. Instead,
he concentrated on studying and doing research on the
history of glass production in France and elsewhere.
Among the scholars in France in the mid-eighteenth
century it was commonly held that this craft had its
origin in ancient Mesopotamia or ancient Egypt. Olivier
clung to the latter theory, which was the least common at
the time. He had stuck with the making of drinking glass,
and had not extended his production to sheet glass
production. The demand for glass had increased
considerably during the last few years accompanying the
new canning techniques which were spreading both in
the countryside and in the cities, and wine production
was on the rise due to the enlarged productivity following
from the new agronomical and micribiological insights
regarding plant cultivation, so that the demand for bottles
grew correspondingly. Apart from that, Jeanne used the
bottels herself in connection with her production of
tinctures from the herb cultivation – natural medicines
which encompassed everything from hemp root
decoction for use as a pain killer, especially regarding
bone fractures, to sage and thyme tinctures for treatment
of lung diseases. The new insights regarding ancient
15
Greece and Rome had, moreover, revealed those peoples’
usage of milfoil tea and milfoil decoction for healing
bone fractures and torn sinews through increased blood
circulation – which had also contributed to the
improvement of tooth health, which was of special avail
now that sugar was about to appear in large quantities on
the European market.
17
already mentioned magnum opus of Montesquieu, The
Spirit of the Laws, and in certain locations armed bands
of peasants had burnt the chateaus of the nobility and
thereby also eradicated the hated feudal tithes – the
mystical disguise of which had been revealed by Jean
Jacques Rousseau in his On the Origin of Inequality a
few years back. According to Quesnay there was no way
around liberation of the serfs and defeudalization of the
French countryside. The question was how much the war
against England would cost in the form of diverted labour
and waste of natural resources and materials, and whether
the price was going to be so high that it would spoil the
possibilities for equalization by the fact that the new
demands for taxation of the nobility, so that even the
members of this social stratum would contribute to the
community’s finances, would be so high that the nobility
itself would resist them. In that case, the people would be
turning revolutionary, in Quesnay’s view – and the
outcome of a revolution one could never take for granted.
As for himself, Olivier Poisonniere could not recall a
single revolution which had been successful yet – maybe
with the exception of the Spartacus-revolt in the age of
the Roman republic, even though Spartacus and his army
of maybe as many as 100 000 runaway slaves were
defeated in the end.
”How do you think that this war will turn out?” Jeanne
asked her father one freezing February night as they sat
around the stove, reading and discussing. Presently,
18
Jeanne read a book on the Thirty Years’ War, and to
what extent it had ruined the whole infrastructure over
most of the Northern European continent. ”Do you think
that we will manage to see an end to it – in time to
prevent it from ruining our economy, and thereby also
spoiling Quesnay’s reform efforts?”
19
which the monarchy and the nobility have conducted
there. If this war is protracted or, even worse, if England
will emerge victorious from it, I fear that the very basis
of civilization in Europe will be threatened. Alas, the
British hardly have any tradition with acknowledging the
soil related aspects of our civilization – which is a
common feature among all civilizations throughout
history. Of course, there are certain exceptions among the
British, like Gerreard Winstanley and the Diggers
movement – and, to be generous, one could include the
entire Levellers movement during the English revolution
in the 1640’s. Moreover, they had the agronomist Jethro
Tull and his experiments with various cultivation
techniques.”
20
tilled and sowed St. George’s Hill. Even if my English is
not the best, I have greatly enjoyed the reading of
Winstanley’s pamphlets from the revolutionary years and
in its immediate aftermath. In the years following the
revolution, by the way, he was a very disillusioned man,
and his later utopian works include a rigid disciplination
of the public, which he deemed necessary after all the
years with revolutionary turmoil and lawless conditions
in general.”
”Oh, well, my dear, that’s the way it has turned out to be.
We will have to keep faith in Quesnay’s ability to
enlighten people about the real issues at stake, so that he
can convince both town and country that they are
21
mutually dependent on each other, and that they enrich
each other’s respective cultural spheres.”
III
In Portsmouth on the southern coast of England there was
a very hectic period. The port was strongly involved in
the ongoing war mobilization at sea, and the ship builders
worked under strict command in the building of new
ships for the navy – as ever more ships were sunk out at
22
sea. Theophrastus Dirt – a name which he had adopted
from the gardening profession and especially the
knowledge of composting processes – spent most of his
labour at ship building during the winter season, and in
peace time he managed a fishing boat building company
in companionship with some colleagues. In other words,
they were running a kind of cooperative with a flat
leadership structure. Suppeosedly, the concept was
inspired by the cooperation between Winstanley,
Lilburne and the other Levellers members who had set a
standard within English radicalism and social liberalism.
It had come to represent the main opposition against the
tendency within the monarchy and among the nobility to
focus one sidedly on the predominance of trade, and
eventually industry, above agriculture and other primary
branches of the economy.
IV
In Paris there was an intense activity and tense
atmosphere, caused primarily by the war which had
rendered the capitals of both the belligerent countries far
more important than before – indeed, it had launched an
urbanization process which, particularly in France, was
viewed with suspicion and dismay. There were protests
from farmers and appeals from the intellectuals against
this increasing tendency of drawing people in ever larger
numbers towards the capital and the other larger cities.
From officials, and in accordance with the ancient local
and regional assemblies of estates, one had in France a
more or less conscious focus on preserving a
decentralized social structure, with viable village cultures
26
embodying the economic foundations of society at large.
In England the situation was completely different as the
farmers were more or less isolated in their campaigns
against centralization, which was welcomed from the
state authorites as well as from the major part of the
intellectual circles.
27
and fruits. Apart from covering their own nutritional
needs, the crops went to the market places of Paris,
where the demand was on the rise because of the
increasing concentration of people there in recent times.
The farm demanded a significant amount of labour,
especially during the main growth season, which tended
to be long but still was conditioned by the event of night
frost in the early spring and in the autumn. However,
only in rare instances did the farmers’ and
horticulturalists’ crops freeze in France, as they had
become very clever at planning the growing season.
28
the higher nobility within it. In that era, it was an even
stronger bond between peasants and artisans, and in most
instances one and the same person combined the
respective occupations of agricultural and craft work.
What if the present French authorities contract the wrath
of the peasants and the artisans because of the war and its
costs, and moreover because it becomes too indulgent
towards the nobility and the clergy? It was questions like
these which occupied Olympes’ thoughts in her studies,
and she often discussed them with her colleagues and the
students at the university. There were many who held the
view that the war would be a lasting one, and hence
would take a heavy toll on the French economy and the
well being of her people, and in that case the people
would sooner or later revolt. Others clung to the hopes –
in part based on rumours spread through trade with
British coastal communities – that the British people
themselves would shorten the war thorugh a revolt
against their own authorities.
30
”Indeed, in that case a revolt will have every opportunity
to succeed. It would be like manna from heaven for us
here in France, as well as for Europe’s future in general,”
commented one of Olympes’ ageing colleagues.
31
V
The smokestacked inn in Newcastle on the north-eastern
coast of England was packed with people. Artisans from
all over the city and its environs were organizing another
meeting for the planning of the forthcoming revolt. Every
precaution was taken so that the authorities would not
unveil the activities, as manifested by the prescription
that the participants were told to arrive at intervals, rather
than rushing in all together at the start of the meeting.
These meetings were usually held during work hours, and
wall to wall with a carpenter’s workshop, in order that it
would be harder for the government officials to discover
what was really going on. Such as it was it appeared that
the traffic of people was merely the result of a particuarly
busy day for the artisans at the workshop. The workshop
itself had been exempted from the general mobilization
order which the government had issued to artisans from
all over the country, because of the fact that it delivered
indespensable furniture and other inventories to the city’s
dwellings and, moreover, had important deliveries to
foreign countries. Thus, its furniture ended up in France
and Germany as well as in Scandinavia, and the mariners
who brought them there exchanged ideas and news from
their own country as well as from the lands of the trading
partners. It was by this means that the word about the
planning of the revolt had reached Paris.
32
The chairman of the meeting clank his glass and raised
his voice in order to get the public’s attention, which was
often a challenge among all the invigorated and even
almost sanguine artisans who finally got to exchange
their virws on the future prospects and various planning
details.
33
manufacturer from the valley along the river Tyne would
like to know.
34
monopolization claims almost all the available raw
materials in addition to our artisans’ labour. Those who
see themselves fit are conducting various forms of
sabotage against the war related deliveries. However, a
great many of our brave colleagues and fellow
revolutionaries have been made to pay for this
disobedience and been sent to jail. Luckily, the barbaric
torture methods which were applied in the Middle Ages
are no longer in operation, otherwise our plans of revolt
would have long since been revealed. Despite the
challenges, however, we are well under way to fill our
secret weapon depots, and quite a lot of militiamen have
also been handed a certain amount of rifles and pistols,
the distribution of which they themselves will take the
responsibility for during the revolt. We consider such
flexibility as absolutely necessary for our success in this
daring but indespensible venture.
35
Gaius Digger was eagerly listening to the presentation of
the guild chairman. After a few minutes’ break, in which
considerable amounts of the finest Virginia pipe tobacco
were consumed, Gaius asked for the crowd’s attention:
36
The meeting ended with a relatively intense discussion
regarding the concrete alternatives which the revolt was
meant to produce. There were basically two conflicting
factions, one of which pleaded allegiance to a kind of
guild communitarianism, in which power was to rest with
the respective members of the artisanal guilds, while the
other faction – which was supported by the majority –
veered towards a more directly confederal orientation.
There were many who thought that a social, economic
and political organizing on the basis of municipalities
and citizenship would create more solid community ties
than an organization based on the various trades, which
would tend to be inherently particularistic. A cratfsman
who had been involved in a freight vessel transportation
to Paris could inform the meeting that quite a similar
discussion was going on in that city, and that the French
now were eager to modify and modernize the system of
estates, and instead base the fundamental confederal
levels on the status of citizenship – even in relation to
people in the countryside. Interestingly, this had
happened even in the Middle Ages and the Renaissance
in Flanders, when in the 12th and 13th centuries
democracy developed once more after being wiped out in
Europe since the Greeks were subjected to the
Macedonian invasions in the fourth century B. C. The
Flemish Medieval and Renaissance democracy, which to
a large extent was founded on the guild organization, was
known to have succumbed to state centralization during
37
the 16th century, in a period when The United Dutch
provinces and the Swiss cantons were among the few
inheritors of the ancient confederal legacy. During the
previous century, however, an increasing centralization
process had set in also in Holland, on a par with the
country’s increasing involvement in the strife for
hegemony at sea among the European great powers.
Thus, the outcome of the present large scale war would
necessarily have a decisive influence on the future of
confedralism in all the beliggerent countries.
VI
Despite the war at sea, Louis-Olivier Fourier had
ventured on a couple of sailings to several German ports
and all the way into the Baltic Sea during the previous
two years. He had especially good trade relations with
the merchants of Riga, and gave high priority to
nourishing contact with these Easterners. I was now time
for this spring’s seafare towards the East, and Louis-
Olivier had recently completed the loading of his self-
made brig, on which he freighted cargo and conducted
trade in companionship with tre artsianal colleagues –
two boat builders and one blacksmith.
39
The war had resulted in considerable turmoil also in the
Eastern parts of the continent; Prussia had clashed with
Austria in a ferocious struggle over hegemony in
Eastern-Europe, while the German peasants and
cratfsmen resented the growing tax pressure which
resulted from the war expenditures. King Fredercik the
Great of Prussia was an ardent supporter of the
Enlightenment ideas, and in the long run he wouldn’t
consider it fortunate to antagonize the bulk of the
population. In Austria, Maria Theresa led an autocratic
regime which was rather reactionary despite its
pretentions of having a claim in so-called ”enlightened
despotism” – which was meant to replace the
supernatural principle of kingly power ”instituted by
God.”
42
colleagues, one of the boat builders. ”Maybe I should
expand my fishery to include eel as well?”
”Indeed, it’s maybe the most healthy diet one could make
avail of, in the long run,” the blacksmith added.
The smith and the two boat builders nodded and gave
their unreserved consent. They knew how to appreciate
43
Louis-Olivier’s ever philosophically penetrating and
most often accurate and enlightening evaluations of the
manifold circumstances of life.
”Well, folks, I hope the eel fat did you good. Let’s have a
toast before creeping into our sleeping bags and dream
about a fortunate wind direction tomorrow!” Louis-
Olivier raised his glass of fine brandy, which they had
purchased from a destiller in Normandie during their last
trading voyage.
”Cheers! Cheers!”
VII
In England, the book printing business had been
progressing greatly during the past few decades, and in
one of London’s printing houses worked the free spirited
young woman Angelica Shelley. Angelica worked
throughout the week in the morning hours at the printer
Douglas Cooper’s printing workshop, a man who had a
long standing in the trade. She had moved to London
from Cardiff a few years back in time, in order to make
an effort at establishing herself as an essayist within the
male dominated English intelligentsia. Angelica often
spent long evenings in several of the city’s coffee houses,
more precisely those which were not owned and run by
altogether patriarchically oriented keepers, and where
there was an occasion for a young woman to take part in
the discussions. It was, however, aways difficult for a
44
woman to be taken fully seriously in intellectual
discussions – a challenge which, by the way, was even
greater for Angelica because of her attractive appearance.
Even London’s intellectual men were most often more
interested in the bodily features than in the intellect when
it came to women.
45
relationship with nature to be understood? Are we
humans something ”quite other” in relation to the general
tendency among the innumerable species of this globe?
Or do we possess something fundamentally in common
with them? Will our self-consciousmess as a species
make us ”aliens” within nature’s development and
evolution, and what will this eventually mean for our
existence, our civilization and, indeed, our very survival
as a species? Angelica had frequently discussed such
issues with several of London’s intellectuals, who clung
to the opinion that it was mainly our free will which
fundamentally separated us from other animals. They
rarely agreed completely in their discussions, for
Angelica emphasized far more strongly the importance of
actual social conditions regarding the ways in which the
single individual appeared and acted at any given
moment throughout history. Her view was considered
highly controversial in an age when notions of natural
rights entitled human beings, as biological beings, to
certain inalienable rights, regardless of social structures
and aspects of power. Regarding Burke’s work there
were many among Angelica’s regular discussion partners
who were flattered by his usage of the concept of a
sublime nature, and what kind of impact this concept had
on human taste and volition. As for herself, she was of
the opinion that this focus on the ”incomparably great”
and the ”immensity of natural forces” in due time would
give human beings an inferiority complex in relation to
46
the well known natural forces, such as for example
majestic mountains, thunder and lightening, hurricanes,
and so on, and that this feeling of inferiority in turn
would lead to grandiose and nemesis ridden human
projects in the form of abuse of technological insight in a
vain attempt to become ”Nature’s masters.”
”True enough. But we will never escape the fact that our
very existence is conditioned by the ecosystems in which
we live and our adaptability to our respective natural
environment,” Angelica quickly replied. She had
considered this question at length, and her conviction had
been hardened by previous discussions. ”And does not
Burke also hold that there are forces in nature to which
humanity simply has to bend?”
47
capabilites. ”We women are not very often taken
serioulsy in philosphical discussions like this one, so
your support and encouragement is very welcome. I am,
moreover, of the opinion that humanity’s focus should be
directed towards activities which can really add
something to the fertility and diversity of Nature, and
that’s particularly the case within agriculture. One only
has to consider the great variety we have achieved from
the wild cabbage plant, which during ages of plant
cultivation has become everything from headed cabbage
to broccoli!”
48
assisting the farmes in Southern Wales during their
spring labour as well as in the harvesting period. There is
a lot of insight among the farmers which deserve the
same attention which has been devoted to the French
farmers by their encyclopaedists.”
49
VIII
The trading quartet of which Louis-Olivier was one of
the members sailed initially via Ghent to Hamburg. In
Ghent, they obtained some fine woolen cloaths, and in
Hamburg fish prices were very favourable. It had been a
good year for the fishermen along the Northern
Norwegian coast, and catches of cod had been above
average throughout the winter months – especially
around the Lofoten peninsula.
50
”Well, I guess we’ll do well to hoist the white flag if
anything which looks like a war ship shows up,”
suggested the boat builder.
51
side. He managed to grab hold of a rope fastened to the
foot of the mast, and thereby avoided to be washed over
board and into the cold sea water. How many sailors had
lost their lives in this way througout history?
IX
In the counsel chamber of his luxurious residence, king
George II had, on an evening in September, 1758, an
exchange with prime minister William Pitt which came
53
to be fateful for the British imperialistic ambitions. While
the autumn wind was howling outside, Pitt persuaded the
king to send troops to the Continent, as part of the
increased war efforts. The troops were to be depatched
before the onset of the first autumn storms were expected
to set in during the forthcoming month. What neither of
them knew, and which had also remained successfully
hidden from the entire British upper classes and members
of parliament, was that countrywide actions of sabotage
against quay facilities and war vessels already had been
well prepared by the revolutionaries – in a well
coordinated system thanks to dexterous revolutionary
seamen who speedily made their way along the coast
lines in order to organize the revolt.
The two men raised their glasses to fortune and luck. The
Scots could at least be thanked for the good whisky, the
king thought to himself, but as usual he had to go to bed
with the certainty that it did not balance out all the
54
troubles the Scots caused him. The Irish, however, he
thought that he controlled to a larger extent, at least until
further noticed…
55
free the prisoners locked up in Newcastle dungeon, but
came to the conclusion that it would be too risky an
effort, and that they would incur the danger of a
revelation of the encompassing revolutionary plans if the
efforts to free these prisoners were to fail. Instead they
agreed to concentrate upon the plundering of the wagons
rolling towards the city, in due time before this became
impossible because of the increased use of guards
escorting the freight. The same pattern occurred in all the
larger port cities.
56
revolutionary militias needed a continuous supply of
weapons and equipment, and secondly in order that he
should not incur unnecessary suspicion by inactivity
regarding his labour. Life had to proceed as normal as
possible. It was a widespread desire among the
revolutionaries that the revolution should be fought more
by the pen than by rifles and pistols. Thus, Gaius
conducted propaganda efforts and both wrote and
distributed pamphlets to artisans and merchants as well
as farmers. Everywhere there were established
clandestine discussion forums, which most often were
held in private, and with the same precautions which
were taken by the central revolutionary excecutive
commitees.
”Who’s there?”
Gaius opened the heavy oak door and let in his friend and
revolutionary companion. Jonathan Johnson was one of
the ardent young spirits of the city, a sailmaker
57
apprentice who had joined one of the city’s revolutionary
clubs at an early stage, and who played a central role in
the sabotage actions directed against the supply and
repair of the war fleet’s sails.
”Yes, here you can stay for now, Jonathan. I have a well
hidden room in the attic. Faith is doing quite all right –
she is eagerly occupied with the pre-revolutionary events.
The workshop in which she is employed has taken part in
the sabotage actions, and has sent several cargos to the
militas instead of the war fleet. Moreover, she is in the
midst of a very creative process regarding her poetry
writing. The events these days certainly inspire her. She
spends all her leisure time at poetry and studies, besides
being ready at emergency calls with respect to her
midwife services.”
58
across the Atlantic. We have contacts in the American
colonies who are very displeased with their current
situation, and would gladly keep the respnsible British
authorities there as hostages. Then the path would be
cleared for proclaiming a republic on the British Isles –
in other words a confederation of the Irish, Scottish,
Welsh and English nationalities.”
59
which will be established in every township and village,
as well as in neighbourhoods in the larger cities. The
delegates who are chosen, preferably by lot, from these
assemblies in order to conduct strictly administrative
tasks at higher confederal levels will be mandated by the
public assemblies and are subject to recall, and
replacement by others, if they were to disregard their
mandate or otherwise abuse their position. The higher
confederal levels, of course, will exist to make feasible
the coordination of the various communities throughout
the entire Isles, and, moreover, build ties to communities
and regions on the Continent and elsewhere in the world.
The long term ideal is a global confedral civilization.
However, there is a long way to go – especially when one
keeps in mind the highly centralized and authortitarian
social conditions in Russia and, according to what I have
read recently, also in countries like China and Japan.”
”This sounds quite magnificent. But tell me, why did the
confederacies succumb to centralization processes in
ancient times? And where have they survived in modern
times?”
60
succumbed to particularism and imperialism respectively
in ancient times, confederalism has primarily been
represented by the Swiss cantons and the relatively flat
organization of The United Dutch Provinces.”
Stand up now...”
61
X
Home at the farm of Jeanne and Charles in the Vendee
province they were expecting a grand visit this last
weekend of September. The harvest of vines had been
above average, and the wine press was already in full
operation. For a couple of years Charles had been
corresponding with Denis Diderot, the Encyclopaedist,
and now the latter intended to visit their farm and its
wine press, which had become renown as an exemplary
model for wine production in North Western France. At
the moment Diderot was working on a volume of the
Encyclopaedia which focused on the technical details of
the equipment for wine production in general, and now
he wanted to draw some sketches of the technology
which was in use at Jeanne and Charles’ vineyard.
62
came wandering into the farmyard Jeanne and Charles
had already for several hours been busy operating the
wine press. They greeted him heartily, and invited him
into the kitchen for a taste of wine of good vintage from
their farm’s own manufacture.
63
”This good old method is still working well. Indeed, it
may well be the most efficient one when it comes to
exactly this kind of equipment,” Diderot encouraged
Charles when the latter complained that there were no
creeks nearby which could power the press.
64
this lamentable war will not result in an accellerating
centralization process in France.”
65
that the general mass among the population across the
Channel in one way or another manages to preclude the
war efforts of the English crown.”
66
everywhere else, even though new conceptions of the
singularities of childhood and the need for freedom to
play to an increasing extent manifested themselves in
connection with the new Enlightenment ideas. As for
himself, Robert could not envisage any other kind of life
apart from the one which included a certain amount of
farm work; however, he was eager to embark on
scientific studies. It was particularly his father’s interest
in history which had been transferred to the son.
However, his mother’s thorough investigation of the
virtues of herbal medicine also proved to have a certian
attraction on the teenager. Maybe there were new
scientific opportunities related to the combination of the
two fields of study, the young man wondered. The
University of Paris was the right place to focus his future
attention on. There he could obtain the impulses which
would guide him in the right direction in his studies.
Until then he had to settle with the hours spent in the
public secondary school – hours which had become
somewhat boring to him lately, as he felt that there was
too much concentration on Christendom at the cost of
science and philosophy…
67
the farmyard and entered the kitchen, where Jeanne had
finished the day’s household tasks.
68
he had observed and depicted so far, and that he felt
certain that he would include drawings of it in the
fortcoming volume on agricultural technology and labour
processes. There had been momentous progress within
agriculture as well as crafts and industry during the past
decades, and together they held out great promises for the
productivity within the French economy in the years
ahead.
69
Diderot and his hosts stayed around the kitchen table
sipping wine and discussing various topics until late at
night. The encyclopaedist and philosopher loved good
conversations and often spent the night after a day’s work
with people whom he visited during his scientific
journeys. Jeanne, Charles and Diderot discussed
everything from the latest discoveries within biology,
including the new perspectives on and proofs of the vital
role of microorganisms in the soil, to the prospects for
the European Continent in view of the recent war
developments. Jeanne eagerly joined the discussion,
especially the parts of it which concerned agricultural
science and medicine. Politics and war were of far less
interest to her, to put it bluntly, so when the conversation
turned into these topics she retreated to her study in order
to indulge in literature on herbal medicine.
XI
The summer season in Portsmouth had been relatively
warm and dry, hence Ophelia Oakarden had not been
able to test the full potentiality of mycorrhizal symbiosis
with respect to horticulture. However, the initial
experiments had provided some significant results. The
dry weather during extended periods of time had caused
70
problems for many farmers due to their lack of any kind
of irrigation systems for their fields and meadows. In
Ophelias garden, however, which covered some two
acres in the spacious garden surrounding the house which
she had inherited from her grandparents, the vegetables
and herbs had withstood the drought periods excellently,
and there were no signs of damage to the crops which she
had treated with mulching and mycorrhizal inoculation
throughout the summer months. However, in the various
parts of her garden which she had not inoculated with
mycorrhiza, due to the experimental value, the reduced
crops were highly tangible compared to average seasons,
which generally brought extensive precipitation here
along the southern coast.
73
Portsmouth – set in, Ophelia joined together with several
other gardeners and farmers at the city square. This
autumn it was a special joy to present the products of the
season because of their outstanding quality – and she had
tasted a lot of vegetables and herbs during her 30 years.
Both the regular customers as well as her farmer and
gardener colleagues were stunned by the virtually shining
texture of Ophelias products this autumn, and
Theophrastus – who often joined her at the square
sessions, and who had held as usual to composted animal
manure in the nurturing of his plants this season – was
somewhat envious of Ophelias’ outstanding results, even
while sharing her joy. Thus he contemplated applying her
methods on the fields in the next growing season.
74
”Good point. It is indeed an exciting time period we are
living through. Would only this damn war come to an
end, so that the people of Europe eventually could
embark fully on creative ventures. As it is, agriculture is
steadily drained of labour power, due to the fact that
people are driven towards the cities to fulfil their duties
according to the government’s rigid war labour regime.”
”I have heard rumours that the revolt against the war and
the king’s ministry is imminent. However, I cannot tell
more about it at the moment – as for myself, I have only
a peripheral role in the revolt plans. Someone will have
to feed the people in the midst of it all, too,” he said,
before they once again had to serve the many customers
who had come to town this Saturday, which was one of
the major market days in Portsmouth, due to the recent
harvesting.
XII
It had been a good growth season in the district around
Paris. Favourable temperatures throughout the summer
and certain periods of extensive precipitation had made
the storage rooms at Olympes Diderot and Pierre-Joseph
Germe’s farm full to the brink with a rich variety of
75
vegetables – cabbages, leek, onion, roots of many sorts,
including turnips and beets, the latter two primarily for
animal feed.
76
forthcoming season, and other important issues related to
their business.
77
pulsated with life this autumn afternoon. There were
people from the capital itself, of course – craftsmen and
intellectuals, and even a few farmers from nearby
villages – as well as seamen from far away places. It was
especially the latter Pierre-Joseph was eager to meet and
listen to, to the extent that they were able to make
themselves understood in the French language, or
mastered English at a level which corresponded with his.
He got to hear about the latest events on the war fronts,
both on the continent and at sea. There were even a
couple of British sailors who could convey the
germinating revolt in England – and told tales about the
actions of sabotage against the supplies to the British war
fleet and about the arming of the revolutionaries.
78
”There have been discussions as to whether he is to be
sent in forced exile in the American colonies,” one of the
sailors whispered. ”It is presently great social ferment at
the other side of the Atlantic, and immense grievances
against the colonial status and the extortions made by the
colonial power. There are many proud puritans ’over
there’ who want to gain self determination over their own
resources. Moreover, many colonials wish for a
democratic development based on the ideals of the
English revolution in the 1640’s. The legends about
Winstanley and Lilburne are still told in many parts of
the American continent, particularly in New England
where there are conducted regular town meetings at the
city squares.”
79
Parisians preferred the former, while most of the farmers
and seamen enjoyed the dark beer, which was mainly
imported from Ireland. There were also served certian
simple dishes in the bar, and an aromatic scent from
French herbs spread in the room as the courses of the day
were being prepared. Pierre-Joseph stayed there for a
couple of hours more. Food, however, he was well
supplied with in his workshop, so that he could save his
money for other expenditures. The freighters who
conducted the transportation of materials were supposed
to get their pay within the next few days, and the farmers
who ran the cooperative saw mill further up along the
Seine were also due for payment for their delivery.
80
into the workshop, and as dry and well stored which they
usually were it would be a sin to expose them for rain.
The materials, for the most part oak, was split at the
cooperative saw mill, and had been stored and dried for
almost two years – exposed to wind and rain in the first
period and then covered but open enough for air drying.
The people at the saw mill had split the oak into ready
made staves, so that Pierre-Joseph only needed to cut the
right lenghts and plane them properly before joining
them together into barrels and buckets. To keep these
together he used osier bands which he steamed together
with the oak staves in order to soften them and make
them elastic. In this way the products would be
completely water proof. This, moreover, was quite
crucial, as most of the barrels and buckets were to be
used for storage of liquid substances such as wine, beer,
oil and milk.
81
After hauling the materials onto his wagon, Pierre-Joseph
drove back to the workshop, eager to start the new season
of cooper work. He fed his horse with oat from a barrel
he kept standing in the stable, wall to wall with the
workshop, and started carrying the oak materials into his
storage room. Several things had to be done before the
actual cooper work could begin; he had to chop fire wood
for the steam apparatus, the osier bands had to be
prepared, and last but not least he had to sharpen the
cutting tools properly – saws and knives as well as
planers. He figured that he would need the forthcoming
days for these preparations. Moreover, he wished to find
some freightmen or taxi drivers who could rent his horse
during the long period in which he did not need it in
town. The horse thrived better being in activity, he
thought. Moreover, he saved precious forage in this way.
XIII
In London, the new year, 1759 – the fourth year of the
war – had started turbulently. The city’s artisans and
even many of its merchants, who were frustrated over the
war which undermined their businesses, had gathered
together in secret during the holidays in order to plan a
well coordinated tax refusal in protesting against the war.
Simultaneously, the city’s people’s militia was busy
conducting sabotage actions against the supplies to the
82
navy – particularly by dumping cannon balls into the
Thames. The king and his parliament were about to run
out of counter-measures, and despite the fact that the
police had managed to seize some of the saboteurs – and
already hanged some of them – the entire power
apparatus in the capital was about to be crippled. What
would be the next, wondered the king as well as the
members of parliament. Both Pitt and George III
expected the worst – bearing in mind the fate that had
met Charles II towards the end of the revolution in the
1640’s. But it would hardly go that far this time, they
tried to soothe themselves. They had no idea about what
the rebels speculated in as the definitive counter-stroke
against the war, and as the starting point for an entirely
new social, economic and political direction for the
British Isles.
84
appearance immediately appealed to her, and they started
talking.
85
”Oh, thank you for reminding me about that. May I
already call you my friend? I feel that we immediately
struck such a good note. You see, I have been to sea for a
while, and there has been little spiritual contact with
women – and of course in other senses to…”
86
other, more trivial labour, as he put it. He was pleased
with leaving the seafarer’s life behind, as he experienced
both discomfort with the rolling waves, and, moreover,
found it hard to engage in good dialogue with his
colleagues, as they were most often dead drunk in their
spare time. However, now they had at least been men
enough to conduct mutinies, as their form of protest
against their own war crazed authorities, he said. “That is
something!”
87
”Well dear, I feel that I have every reason to trust you, so
I can give you a few hints. But you must promise me to
keep them to yourself until the plan has materialized.
There are only a handful of revolutionaries who are
informed of this as yet.”
88
republican idea has seemingly been dead and buried – at
least in England.”
89
the colonies recently, there are increasing murmurs that
the colonists aim to rid themselves of the kingly yoke and
their denigrating colonial status. Thus, I have suggested
to the people’s militia of London that we rig a fast
moving and ocean crossing shooner bark, simply kidnap
the king himself and maybe some of his closest relatives
and subordinates, in an unguarded moment; then force
them on board the bark, and set sail for Boston. We will,
in other words, send the king in forced exile to the
freedom loving American city, which will gladly
welcome the initiative and see to it that kingship on the
British Isles is relegated to the history books once and for
all! Only a few details remain as regards who will ’take
care’ of the king and his eventual ’companions’ over
there. The fast moving shooner bark is more or less ready
for the expedition. Of course, there are certain dangers
and risks involved, such as the possibility that our ship
may be assaulted by the navy out at sea – but we have to
take that risk. Moreover, our crew will be well equipped
with firearms, and the men are very eager to get the
operation started.”
90
indeed, maybe even egged on by the drunken utterances
from some of the men on board. But in essence, this is
my own plan, and I am flattered that it has been approved
by the militia.”
XIV
A dry and clear Saturday in early October, Louis-Olivier
was present at one of Paris’ several markets in order to
offer some of the commodities which he and his trading
companions hadde obtained during last spring’s voyage
91
eastwards. The harvests had been nothing more than
mediocre over most of France, thus there was a certain
demand for Louis-Olivier’s wares, particularly the wheat
from the Baltic countries. But also the dried cod was in
high demand, in part due to the restrictions put on
marketing and consumption of fish from the Seine. It was
a long distance to the sea and hence very few, if any,
fishermen who would be troubled with the long freights
of their catches up against the river current to Paris. Most
of their fish was instead sold and consumed in the cities
and villages along the Atlantic coast.
95
condition that it did not occur at the expence of their
tasks and duties in the homes. He added, however, that
the role of art may easily be exaggerated under
civilization – and referred to a treaty he had written on
the subject.
97
consciousness and widened their horizon – and thus laid
a solid foundation for further reflection.
98
among the cultural elite, and got the full support of
Madame de Gouges and also several of the other women
and men present. All in all the meeting ended in a
reconciliatory mood, in the sense that it was agreed upon
that the very Enlightenment project itself was highly
nourished by such happenings and debates. In her
farewell speech de Gouges informed the public that the
theme for the next meeting in her salon was going to be
the Encyclopedie and its role in the public life of France.
It would occur on the first Saturday in the next month,
and she had invited no less a figure than Denis Diderot to
deliver an introduction.
99
The coming spring the boat was supposed to be be
impregnated all around with pine tar and flax oil. It was
many years since it had been done last time, and now it
was hight time for such an important task. They had
ordered flax oil from some noblemen who ran a common
oil press in Normandy, and with whom Louis-Olivier had
established a professional contact during one of his
trading voyages. The pine tar came all the way from
southern Norway, and had been produced and exported
by thrifty farmers up there in the cold north who
conducted these trades during the winter season, before
and after tending to their harvests – a combination of
agriculture, craft and trade which was largely unknown in
rural France, primarily because of the feudal restrictions
on peasant activities. Many of the Norwegian farmers
were yeomen, and enjoyed a singularly prominent
position within Norwegian society despite the economic
privileges assigned to the burghers by the Danish crown
– which had governed Norway more or less like a
province since the late Middle Ages.
XV
A grey and cold winter day towards the end of 1759 the
king’s troops suddenly amassed in Newcastle, in the form
of both cavalery and marine corps. Obviously, the Crown
had got extensive hints about what was going on in the
100
city regarding preparations for an extensive revolt. There
had been sporadic razzias and subsequent arrests in a
number of other cities as well, and troops had even been
sent to Ireland and Scotland in order to prevent the
expected support for the revolt in these regions.
”As you say yourself, the chances are very slim that the
government will target you, so that you will probably be
safe staying here in Newcastle and continuing your work
duties. On the other hand, the chances for getting in
contact with Gaius or any of the other prisoners are less
than slim. Furthermore, if you show any effort to contact
them you might very well be suspected for complicity. If
the prisoners are held in the castle, you may send
someone in your place to bring them the most dire
necessities – but I doubt that the prison guards will let
you in.”
105
while in the castle, there would still be a possibility to see
them, if you only could find a way to confirm that they
are kept there. But I have to warn you that the castle is a
nasty place, with frequent executions, and moreover the
prison authorities have surely received orders to lay their
hands on persons who arouse their suspicion.”
Faith thanked the doctor for his advices and their good
cooperation during the sucessful child birth the day
before, and returned home in order to make an attempt at
getting some nourishment – despite her low appetite due
to the recent events – and most of all to write some
poetry in an effort to digest the harsh impressions.
Writing poetry was the best means she knew for coping
with difficult emotions – and the present situation was by
far the most challenging she had ever experienced.
During the events of the previous months she had written
dozens of poems, and read them for Gaius in their
intimate moments of mutual confessions and romance.
106
During the dinner preparation, in which she as usual
made an extra portion in order to save for the next day,
she got the impulse to invite the lady next door for
dinner. Her husband was away on a longer trade venture
to Wales, and Faith used to have good conversations with
her on a variety of subjects. Even though the neigbour
couple did not belong to the active revolutionaries, they
sympathized with their case and eagerly wanted to see an
end to the war – both in order to stop the meaningless
spill of blood and resources, and so that the trading
husband once agian could experience normal, quiet work
conditions.
107
”Oh, dear! So, that’s why I witnessed military troops
riding towards the city centre yesterday morning. I
certainly was distubed by the fact, but I had no idea that
it was as dramatic as that. Have you heard anything about
Gaius’ situation?”
108
which may be traced to single individuals. The former
has to be achieved in order to win crucial adherence to
the case and prepare for what’s coming next in the event
of a successful revolt – in the sense of toppling the crown
and the government. The latter has been attempted by
consistently publishing under pseudonyms. However, if
there are traitors in our ranks, we have no guarantees
whatsoever against getting our entire movement ripped
apart.”
109
XVI
A Staturday in February in the new year, 1760, Jeanne
Poisonniere and Charles Terrau had made a journey to
Paris in order to look for a copy of the Encyclopedia
volume on agriculture. According to Diderot’s
suggestions when he visited them last autumn, it should
be published by now and available in the book stores.
The journey to town had been somewhat strenuous for
the couple, as frequent rain dureing the previous weeks
had made the roads muddy. They kept their spirits high,
however, by singing French folk songs, and also joined
up with some other travelers.
110
who also came from a village in the vicinity of Paris.
They were two brothers, relatively young farm boys, who
had an errand in the city on behalf of their father – an
errand consisting in ordering some blacksmith wares for
the horse equipment back on the farm. Having already
completed this task, they were the more eager to sit
talking for a while. Both Jeanne and Charles appreciated
the good conversation, centering mainly on agricultural
subjects, and almost forgot their time schedule with
respect to their own errand in Paris that day. As it was
getting dusk outside the thought suddenly struck them
that they now only had a short time before the book
shops closed. The two brothers understood very well that
Jeanne and Charles was eager to get hold of a copy of the
fresh volume of the Encyclopedia, which they intended to
buy one day themselves. However, as for now they had
too much maintenance work to do on the farm, and
reading had to wait. Even the evenings were spent with
practical tasks, they said.
111
”Yes, they have arrived recently, but demand has been
high so I have already ordered more. It is somewhat hard
to foretell how great the demand there would be here in
Paris for a literary work on agriculture. However, there is
no doubt that it has caught the interest of more people
than the farmers themselves.”
112
were eager to take a closer look at the Encyclopedia
volume, they still chose to spend the rest of the evening
in good company in the inn’s bar. There conversations
were always lively, and presently they centered round
topics such as the last war news as well as other events of
varying degrees of actuality and importence. Despite the
serving of alcoholic fluids there was a sober atmosphere
in the bar, which was natural enough as the guests mostly
consumed tea and coffee that evening. Jeanne and
Charles were eager to bring the discussion onto the
Encyclopedia, and eventually found themselves in a
dialogue with one of the city’s many freelance writers, a
man who was equally interested in this subject and had
written quite a few pieces on it in the past.
113
precision demanding work he had conducted with his
sketches and also the awareness he had shown towards
Charles’ own descriptions of the functioning mechanisms
of his wine press. ”I am, however, stunned by the
ultimate result. What would France have done without
him?”
114
D’Alembert, were responsible for the content being
printed – even if most of it was penned by others. It was
particularly the clergy who were the main instigator of
the efforts to stem the tide of the encyclopaedists’
publishing activity, and this estate still excercised a
strong influence on the secular authorities. Hence, Louis
XV could not see any way around granting their demands
of censorship to a certain extent, although he was
sympathetic towards Diderot both in a personal sense and
towards his efforts on behalf of the ideas and ideals of the
Enlightenment. This sympathy led to his silent faciliation
of proper work conditions for Diderot while he was in
prison.
115
articles for one of Paris weekly newspapers and
experienced that the eye of the needle was very narrow
indeed regarding what kind of perspectives which were
considered ”suitable” for printing. Criticism of one’s own
authorities had to be camouflaged in an ingenuous
manner, for although there was no doubt that the British
crown was the real aggressor in this context, France’s
government was not spotless either – and a journalist’s
main task was to keep an eye on how the country was
governed.
116
and Charles certainly agreed. ”The military attack by the
British is exactly the opposite of Reason, and their
motivation seems highly suspect. Have the British
authorities enfeebled their peasants to such an extent that
the British Isles have become compeletely dependent on
supplies of staple goods from overseas?”
”So it seems,” said Charles, who had tuned into the new
topic of their concersation. ”However, at present there
are disturbances among the British people – and many
rumours and even reports about major revolt events. May
it succeed!”
117
At noon the next day, the farming couple embarked on
their way home after a short weekend in Paris which they
both considered highly rewarding in every way. It had
started to rain, and the road was in an even poorer
condition than the day before. The only thing for them to
do was to make avail of time and patience. Fortunately,
the two horses were strong and steady on their feet, but
they did not want to press them more than necessary –
they were outside their most active season and, hence,
not as well trained as during the summer season.
118
”Well, if French agriculture doesn’t get a significant
boost through this publication, I will eat my hat!” said
Jeanne as they went to bed.
XVII
Throughout the winter Ophelia Oakgraden had prepared
the lecture she was going to present on her tour in East
Anglia in the spring, in addition to in depth studies of the
various agronomical publications she could obtain. There
were quite a number on this subject even in England,
119
although the country in that respect lay way behind
France when it comes to the extent of knowledge as well
as the number of publications. As yet, Ophelia was not
familiar enough with the French language to embark on
the French originals – and translations into English were
few, among which Du Monceau’s work on the role of
mycorrhiza represented an honourable and highly
valuable exception. Indeed, precisely the latter work
constituted a fundamental frame of reference for the
lecture she had written. Hopefully, the farmers in the
rural districts around Bedford, Peterborough and
Norwich, the cities which she was going to visit, would
be able now in March to attend her lectures and come up
with their questions and comments. And if the weather
lately had been as dry in East Anglia as in Portsmouth,
the roads would be well traversible, even over longer
distances.
123
countryside, had brought their fiddles, mandolins and
other string instruments with them, and flutes were
borrowed from the owner of the place, who was an apt
flute player himself. Drums of various kinds were
frequently applied, and Ophelia enjoyed drumming, in
addition to join the chorus, on occasions in which she had
not had the opportunity to bring her own string
instruments or to borrow such.
124
and wondered if she was on a holiday trip. When he
heard about the purpose of her journey to Bedford, he
was sincerely impressed.
125
Ophelia enjoyed the company of the sympathetic man,
with his Irish descent and his warm appearance. So she
kept sitting there for quite a while talking with him about
her prospects for the future, and first and foremost her
hopes for the lecture tour, while he shared his memories
from a life in the small town of Bedford.
126
Naturally, many among the audience were farmers, and
were highly interested in obtaining knowledge about
biological processes which could be utilized in order to
increase the fertility of soils without conducting the
toilsome and unpleasant handling of animal manure –
which included long term composting processes and a lot
of manual labour before the end product could be made
avail of in the fields.
127
sporulation, or ’sprouting’, to use a more mundane word
for the germinal processes of microbiological fungi.”
128
also be procured, but these entail small expenses. For
your part, I am sure that you have access to acreage
which may conveniently be laid under legume
cultivation, for instance, and you probably also have
woodland in which mycorrhiza spores can be found.
129
presentation. She delighted in the response, and as she
rolled in her hired wagon on her way to a follow up in
Peterborough a few days ahead, she envisaged a wholly
successful lecturing tour.
XVIII
Towards the end of February, 1760 Olympes Diderot
visited Paris in order to conduct a few more source
researches in connection with her dissertation on Etienne
Marcel and the revolutionary movement he led in the
Paris area in the 1350’s. Most of the raw draft for the
dissertation was already completed, but she still thought
that a few more details were lacking in order that the
parts were to make up a satisfying whole. It was still one
more month until the spring labour back home on the
farm would commence, and she figured that she would
be able to hand in the dissertation well ahead of the
scheduled time limit this spring.
131
1381, led by John Ball and Wat Taylor, and the German
Peasants’ War in 1524-25, led by Thomas Münzer.”
132
after their leaders were executed – as such revolutionary
efforts were at least equally dependent upon dexterous
and brave leading figures back then as now,” Olympes
added.
133
When Olympes and the history professor went back to
their sceduled tasks for the day, Olympes thanked him
for a very interesting conversation and his invaluable
input. He retorted exuberantly that conversations such as
the one that they just had experienced made life as a
history researcher so much richer.
134
themselves and develop their abilities in self-organization
through trials and failures. For, after all, this ability had
manifested itself at several previous historical stages,
most notably in ancient Athens. However, at that time
and in that context the cultural circumstances were
altogether different from anything else in the overall
European history, and it was certainly not an easy matter
to ascertain what exactly was needed in order to produce
a similar conditional framework in modern times, she
thought.
135
winter months, and now almost all of the orders were
already delivered – and he was also about to run out of
materials. He reckoned, however, that he would have
enough in order to finish his cooper season in a
respectable manner. ”In the worst of cases I will have to
rent back the horse one day, and make a journey up to the
saw mill,” he thought – and without much consideration
laid aside the alternative of ordering a freight boat for the
little materials that eventually would be needed for the
rest of the season. The main delivery of materials for the
next season had to wait – for he had to adjust it to the
orders which he received during the summer season
before he, in his turn, sent off an order to the farmers’
cooperative who ran their saw mill secretly in the debths
of a densely forested valley, and smuggled their products
down to the Seine disguised as noblemen.
He opened and let her in. They held each other tight and
kissed passionately – the one positive thing regarding not
seeing each other for a while was that their passion
towards eachother flared up more intensely than in
periods when they were together day out and day in for
several months, such as generally was the case during the
summer season. Although they enjoyed to the fullest
137
extent each other’s company, a little ”air” in the
relationship had never hurt anyone, as the years went by,
they agreed.
”Oh, yes, that’s what I’ve always said, my dear, that this
work is made for you, with your handy fingers and
estethical sense” – such nice words from Olympes which
made life a pleasant ride for Pierre-Joseph.
138
Pierre-Joseph knew the man through previous
conversations with Olympes, and had read a couple of his
works – and had registered his political preferences.
”Thank you so much for your support all along the way,
my dear. Yes, we certainly agree upon the politics.
However, you know, as a student of history I have more
professional touching points in common with him than
you have – with your stronger focus upon the present
situation and what may be done in the foreseeable future.
As you know, I share your main perspectives on the ideal
organization of society, and I am also fascinated by the
utopian literary tradition, but simply do not manage to
engage as deeply as you in these issues. Probably the
difference between us in that respect is related to your
craftman’s occupation, which brings you more directly
into important events in the present era and their political
connotations.”
139
They updated each other on the additional private news
on their respective fronts, and ended the night in erotic
activities – they had long since made the experience that
these were a pleasant way of obtaining relaxation and
expanding their horizon, in addition to adding glue to the
ties between them. And at the present moment Olympes
knew that she was in the middle of a ”safe period”…
XIX
One day Angelica was at work in the printing office in
the autumn – in the foggy London – she and the owner of
the print shop were doing the type setting of a purely
military strategic volume on the English crown’s warfare
in Scotland throughout the centuries with the purpose of
quelling the independent and rebellious spirit of the
Scots. The volume contained no seductive ideas, and
neither any socio-political criticism of the powers that be,
as it was penned by a historian who adored the English
crown. Angelica talked with her employer about various
aspects of their trade, and also touched upon political
issues – naturally also the revolt which was gathering
momentum in several places across the country.
141
not able to do much before four policemen appeared in
his office.
142
“You are aware of the penal ramifications with respect to
accusations of treason and sedition? In the very least it is
punished by penal labour for life!”
143
transported to extended interrogation and imprisonment
on bread and water until their trial – at some point in the
future. The most important thing for king and parliament
was to get rid of them, before the spirit of revolt spread to
an increasingly enlightened – and hence threatening –
English public, which also had numerous sympathizers in
Ireland and Scotland.
144
bereft of any intellectual stimulation, easily drives people
crazy – and they were both utterly depressed about their
situation.
It took him the rest of the day and most of the following
night to reach the horse breeder’s location, as he had to
follow several diversion paths in order to avoid causing
suspicion through his long, purposeful wandering without
much luggage in the lousy weather. He went to sleep for
a couple of hours in the hay piled up in the horse
breeder’s barn, and woke up by the cockrow at dawn.
After meditating for half an hour, and contemplated the
most favourable unfolding of the coming day, he strolled
over to the stable, where he expected to find the horse
breeder at this time of the day. He was right, and the
horse breeder welcomed him in the friendliest way and
invited him in for coffee and breakfast.
146
who obviously was in deep trouble, and had a strenuous
task in front of him. Paine had just told him the bad
news, and what he considered necessary to do for his
own part – if he loved his life and freedom.
147
and the Swiss cantons are rather top heavy, to put it that
way, even though both of them represent the confederal
principle in their separate idiosyncratic ways. Presently,
we are in need of someone democratizing its ideological
fundament so that the principle as such may appeal to the
fullest extent to all the freedom loving people out there
among the common artisans and farmers.”
148
had shown great endurance and had experience with
similar long rides. Moreover, it was very frugal and able
to go far only after pasturing some clover or wild grasses
along the way – after a meal of oats it was absolutely
invincible.
149
XX
At the boat construction site along the Seine, the boat
building crew, under the leadership of a guild master, had
laid down the keel of a new galiot – a relatively flat
bottomed vessel suited for cargo freight up and down the
river, primarily of wine. Louis-Olivier Fourier had
dedicated some days, before preparing for the coming
spring’s trade expedition, to give a helping hand to the
boat building crew, in which two of his trading
companions were engaged. Louis-Olivier enjoyed being a
part of the boat building work, and even contemplated
applying for an apprentice position as a boat builder at
some point in the future – either in the actual boat
building crew or with some other boat builder in the Paris
area. At times, the trading business was slow, particularly
in these times of war, and the occasional work he
performed in between trading efforts – such as various
transportation work for several craftsmen and industrial
establishments – did not quite satisfy his vocational
preferences. Moreover, the two boat builders in his
trading company were very good colleagues, and he
enjoyed co-working with them. He was of a very sociable
nature and, hence, did not thrive well working alone for
long intervals.
150
year, if the supply of boat materials was sufficient. They
had already received the oak materials, to be chopped
into frames, and which had been hand picked by the boat
builders themselves in a forested area by the coast a few
years previously. By now the oak was well dried, and
could be cut and shopped conveniently with optimally
sharpened tools. The fir planks for the carcass had also
been ordered – from a saw mill up along the Swiss
border, and they were expected by early summer. At the
moment, the main task consisted in raising the frames on
the keel, and it was exactly this physically demanding
work that Louis-Olivier was hired in to assist.
“It is a fine boat type this galiot,” said one of the boat
builders as they sat there looking at the frame
construction. “I wonder whether similar boat types are in
use on other rivers around the world, too?”
152
the German states, was a secure and profitable business.
The same could be said about the importation of quality
wheat from Eastern Europe to the French market –
especially in years of ill harvest for the French grain
growing farmers.
153
probable that people in the cities and villages by the foot
of the mountains are dependent on imported furs to a
certain extent,” commented one of the boat builders.
154
Louis-Olivier. “After all, we have got by somehow
during our previous voyages on the open sea, but it is
probably more due to pure luck than anything else, I
suppose.”
155
“Well, let’s hope that the English revolutionaries manage
to overcome the present crisis and succeed in inhibiting
the English war machine. Indeed, the many actions of
sabotage already have contributed in that direction, even
if they so far have been countervailed by the terribly
efficient mobilization economy initiated by the English
king and his parliament. It shows that the war was well
prepared by the British,” concluded one of the boat
builders.
In the event they stayed at the dock area way into the
spring night discussing these complex issues, without
reaching an unanimous conclusion. They agreed,
however, that trade and markets regulated by high moral
standards were fundamental preconditions for any kind of
democracy, and in that context touched upon the example
of ancient Greece and the early revival of democracies,
156
especially in Flanders, during the early Middle Ages.
This focus on democracy belonged to the long term
socio-political goals they had in common, and which knit
them together as a well functioning labour team. Their
disagreements were more pronounced when it came to
choosing the best possible perspectives and the
corresponding actions in the actual situation. The boat
builders were naturally outraged by the horrendous waste
of precious wooden materials, through the accelerating
cutting down of oak trees in both countries for the
construction of war vessels, as well as by the aggressive
exploitation of boat builders’ labour in the whole of
North-Western Europe – resulting only in sunken war
ships. So they wished for an immediate end of the war –
almost regardless of “victor.” For his part, Louis-
Olivier’s view was that as long as the meaningless war
was raging, and had already taken its terrible toll – both
in human lives and invaluable materials – it would be a
catastrophe for European civilization if the English state
power succeeded in its militaristic orientation and
aggressive imperialistic efforts. He mentioned the
downfall of the ancient Greek civilization in the wake of
Sparta’s defeat of Athens in the Peloponnesian war, and
also related the outcome of that war to the decline of the
Roman republic two or three centuries later.
XXI
The rain was pouring down on the tiny column of
prisoners which were marched down towards the
Newcastle harbour. Gaius Digger was chained together
with thirteen other revolutionaries who had been arrested
during the meticulous razzias conducted in the city in the
previous two weeks or so. Since their arrest they had
been held in the castle – and been subject to severe
interrogations. Until now, Gaius had been able to keep
158
his mouth shut regarding everything he knew about the
revolt effort, and kept his focus on not revealing anything
which could lead the authorities on the track of other
revolutionaries. What scanty information he had given
was related to his craftmanship – such as the difficult
conditions of production during the war years and the
immense strain related to the compulsory deliveries to
the navy.
159
England the victory in the patriotic war.” Thus, the joy of
work was out of the question, and the days dragged by –
while Gaius thought about his beloved Faith and the fact
that they would never see each other again. Of course, he
also thought about the revolt, which at present seemed to
be foiled – by an infiltrator and the action of the
authorities.
160
During the evening she joined a conversation with a
harbour labourer who incidentally had observed the penal
column as it was loaded into the boats heading for the
hulk – and hence she received the news which she had
feared. She realized that her chances for assisting Gaius
and the other prisoners now were infinitely meagre –
unless they, by some circumstance, were to be rowed
back to town. And if the latter were to happen, it would
certainly not bring any joy – quite to the contrary, it
would simply mean execution. It was like the choice
between pestilence or cholera: Deportation or hanging.
The separation between her and Gaius would be a
defintie fact anyway – for very few people were able to
survive a deportation to the penal colonies. Faith felt an
immense emptiness inside. Could they have done
anything differently in order to avoid such a tragic
outcome of the revolt effort? She could not think of
anything in particular – and for either of them resistance
and revolt against the war had appeared both as a moral
duty and a necessity in order to secure the further
dissemination of the Enlightenment ideals.
162
their French origins had given him an urge to familiarize
with the French language. He had had a rich life, indeed,
and realized that he had lived his life at a crucial turning
point in the development of European civilization, and he
reached the conclusion that he could not have acted in
another way. It was a whole lot, however, which he
would have liked to accomplish. He had very much
wanted to write a comprehensive work on Gerrard
Winstanley – the 17th century revolutionary genius – and
his Digger movement during the English revolution in
the 1640’s, and had anticipated a highly interesting
source material research in that connection. With his
good contacts among the historians, especially in
Edinburgh, where they looked somewhat differently on
the English state power throughout history, he would
have been well positioned to succeed in his writing task,
he thought. And in all this, Faith would have played a
central role, as an inspirator with her beautiful soul and
poetic frame of mind – and as a loving wife when they
eventually would have had the opportunity to get
married, with a hope to bring children into this world.
Due to the troubled social conditions marked by the war
and their revolt effort, all this had had to wait – and now
it would never materialize. “Well, I am not the only one
to experience this kind of fate,” he thought and
commemorated people who had been subjected to far
worse things than himself – such as bestial torture and
corresponding methods of execution. He thought about
163
the so-called “witches” and what they had gone through
towards the end of their lives, before the Enlightenment
had put an end to the witch mania and the persecution of
innocent people, who simply had viewed life differently
than the clergy and the powers that be in general. Maybe
there were even envious neighbours playing a role in all
this? Indeed, he had been lucky enough to live in a
progressive era, with more humanistic ideals and a
pronounced focus on rationality and freedom of thought
– even though it all had been sadly inhibited by the
meaningless war. Not only did it disrupt the prospects for
the universal Enlightenment ideas in the decades and
centuries ahead, but it was so costly that the English
crown contracted an immense debt to English and Dutch
bankers so that the tax burden on the general public rose
to unprecedented heights. Surely, this fact had
contributed decisively to the relatively widespread
adherence to the revolt efforts, for among the public the
new philosophical ideas and scientific insights were still
not widely known – in England it was primarily the
nobility and the emerging bourgeoisie which had had the
time and opportunity to study such things. So Gaius had
been lucky, he thought, to have become enriched with
such intellectual aspects of life – even though it now
turned out to cost him the same. “Oh, well, ain’t life
ambiguous and complex,” he concluded once again – and
settled with his conclusion.
164
The four convicted men were held in their cells, with
only water and a tiny chunk of bread during the day, for a
few days more, before suddenly one day they were being
commanded on board a landing boat in order to embark
on their last ride – up to the castle. They sat chained
together in the prisoners’ wagon all the way up to the
infamous building – it was a dismal ride in every sense,
on empty stomachs and facing the end of their lives.
Gaius, however, had accepted his fate and tried to inspire
the others to be proud until the last moment. He told
them that they were all entitled to such pride in
themselves and their heroic effort, and reminded them of
their invaluable artisanal work through long years of
service to the common weal and their brave commitment
on behalf of the universal ideals of the Enlightenment.
165
centuries after the demise of ancient Greek and Etruscan
civilization.”
166
submission it was different; then the authorities singled
out and blamed certain individuals for eventual
disturbances. In this case it was another matter, however,
because the leadership was organized in so flat manner,
and seemingly with so many audacious and clever heads
involved, making the horror striking method useless. The
events had to be veiled as much as possible, and in the
history books only be referred to as “disturbances” and
“disobedience,” bereft of any political and ideological
implications. The very executions themselves were well
in line with this goal; a brief procedure in which the
convicts were led up to the gallows, blindfolded and
taken out of the course of history.
Taken today
In my direst throes
I lay restrained”
167
Such sounded the last verse she penned that night. Now
she wished for some sleep – it had been a while since she
had had a restful night, both because of midwife duties
but mostly because of her thoughts about Gaius and his
comrades. She wondered what would now become of the
anti-war campaign and English society.
“Oh, good Lord,” Faith exclaimed, “it can only mean one
thing – that they have been subjected to the severest
penalty and are about to be executed. Oh, dear, I had a
tiny hope that the sentence would ‘only’ be deportation –
168
so that there would have been a slight opportunity for
them to get away with their lives.”
169
long walk up towards the castle. As she arrived at the
lower gate everything was silent. She was halted by two
sentries who ordered her back to town – the area was
closed for the public at the moment, she was told.
Turning back a few hundred yards, she sat down on a
heap of logs by the side of the road, staring at the
towering castle, and at the starry spring sky, with tears
rolling down her cheeks.
XXII
A few weeks before the spring labour were about to set in
back home at the farm in Vendee, Charles Terrau was in
Paris in connection with the performance of a musical
work he had composed a few years back – and the event
was a major dancing ball to be held in honour of Louis
XV and meant to boost French optimism regarding the
outcome of the ongoing war. There were many celebrities
present, but the ball was still open for people from all
social strata – on the condition that one was properly
dressed for the festive occasion.
171
order to notice her that he was about to go for a ride to
the neighbouring village to see a friend, and even flirt a
bit with the girls, if any occasions for the latter presented
themselves. He was a dexterous rider, and the ten miles
or so were usually traversed in circa one and a half hour
– if he didn’t explore some new tracks in order to take a
look around and enjoy the scenery and wildlife. Today he
wanted to take the shortest cut, because he had important
things to discuss with his friend, related to the prospects
of starting a university education in Paris the forthcoming
autumn. His friend was determined to embark on
philosophy studies, and wanted to hear Robert’s views on
his choice. Moreover, Robert had not yet decided
definitely on which study he would follow – the choice
being between biology, astronomy and history. Maybe
even philosophy was an option, if his friend was able to
convince him...
172
the clergical brand – had in fact already started a
persecution of Rousseau and his like.
173
opinion, however, that we should and can do without it
today – the crucial question is how long it will take to
replace it with a purely secular ethics. As for myself, I
am of an impatient nature,” Voltaire admitted as they
thanked each other for an interesting conversation.
174
lead a conversation with anyone – and even profit
intellectually from it. Voltaire, for his part, identified
himself more with the “learned circles” in the cities.
175
weeks later. The very planting of the precultivated plants
in the fields was customarily scheduled to the middle of
May, after the direct sowing of the other crops had been
done.
176
physiology – which you have encouraged me to for so
long now.”
XXIII
Safe and sound back in Portsmouth after her lecturing
tour in East Anglia, Ophelia Oakgarden had digested the
impressions. She felt that it had turned out well and been
met with a largely positive response, particularly from
the farmers. Obviously, they were the ones who were
most eager to find alternatives to the ardous manual
handling of animal manure, to the extent that they were
in a position to reduce their herds of cows and sheep. The
horticulturalists, however, probably thought that ordinary
garden compost served them well enough as plant
nutrition -- and moreover had somewhat lower ambitions
than those who made a living of the soil on a full time
basis. Ophelia regretted that the urban gardeners had not
shown up in greater numbers at her lectures – as it was in
the cities, in fact, that the new Enlightenment ideas, with
their corresponding scientific innovations, had the
177
greatest potential for further development and,
furthermore, were absolutely crucial arenas if these
novelties were to actualize this potential. In the event of a
general political reaction, and the domination of
industrialism in the field of economics, maybe even
exacerbated by by an undue focus on the role of
commerce, it was not hard to imagine that many of the
new scientific insights within agronomy would be
neglected and replaced by ecologically unsound methods
of cultivation. The Germans, in particular, were presently
putting a high premium on purely chemical soil
processes, and even though a prominent agronomical
figure like Johann Gottschalk Wallerius revealed a deep
biological sensitivity in his writings, it was hard to
foretell how his future colleagues would proceed in the
decades ahead. Urbanization had begun to spread in
Germany as well, in part because of the emerging
industrialization and also because of the ongoing
European war, and this situation was a poor basis for the
prolification of the new theoretical insights which
Ophelia had obtained and their utilization in practice – as
it certainly required a sufficient number of “hands” out
there in the countryside who could do the manual labour
related to the green manuring and mulching, which were
not easily conducted with the help of mechanical tools.
179
the publisher – to the extent that he cares about the
prolification of science in this country.”
182
“Well, it is very bold of a woman to present what claims
to be pioneering insights into the field of biology,” he
commented after a brief reading of the list of contents
and the main conclusion in her manuscript.
“Unfortunately I cannot take the responsibility of printing
your work – mainly because I will not risk affronting my
male contacts in the scientific circles.”
183
sympathized with the latter, but also a considerable
number of royalists present, hence the discussions were
generally high tempered – it was almost impossible to
reach a compromise in this matter. As for herself,
Ophelia preferred to lay low when it came to political
issues, and was more interested in scientific subjects –
along with her passion for music. However, she was
certainly engaged in the recent political events due to
their implications for the prospects of universal science,
and felt depressed by the fact that the war effort now
seemed to proceed uninhibited on the part of the English
government, so that the war had to be fought out to the
bitter end – with the certainty that England would
triumph in the long run, considering the country’s
unrivaled fleet and command of the sea. However, it
would mean a “victory over Reason itself,” as she
expressed it in a discussion with a couple of the other
guests – and she was urged to explain her point of view
in more detail. So she pointed towards the advanced
scientific acheievements of the French and the
outstanding work done by their encyclopaedists – and
additionally referred to the fact that it was French
thinkers like Bayle and Montesquieu who had initiated
the liberal turn during the past century or so. Admittedly,
the British had had their John Locke up in Scotland, but
she argued that the latter by far did make people think
their own thoughts to the extent that Bayle and
Montesquieu did.
184
It was certainly unpopular notions to express in a London
pub in the midst of an imperial war between the two
major European powers, and she was met with stern
opposition in this respect. The discussion reached a
stalemate, and she ordrered another whisky. She drank
quite a few of them that evening, and she felt very
grateful when the pub owner offered her a bed in the
second floor, where he lived with his family. He also
comforted her regarding the foiled publication project,
and tried to encourage her to keep on going with her
research and writings. Sooner or later there had to
emerge people in the publishing business who subscribed
to a more progressive stance towards women’s
potentialities in the various fields of science, as he
expressed. And with these soothing words she fell asleep
to the sound of singing by the pub guests. Obviously the
discussions had come to an end for now, and yet again
fraternization occurred in the form of English shanty
songs. Ophelia felt thankful that she did not lead this kind
of life on a daily basis, and promised herself not to
consume alcohol again in a long, long time.
XXIV
A weekend in June, while Pierre-Joseph was in Paris
with the sole purpose of meeting Rousseau, Olympes had
a well deserved break from the farm work – which
185
presently consisted in weeding the vegetable rows and
earthing up the potatoes – and spent her time in her study
completing the dissertation on Etienne Marcel and the
artisanal and peasants’ movement he led in Paris and its
surroundings in the 1350’s. It suited her well to sit down
with some intellectual and physically relaxing work after
the long sessions behind the horse in the potatoe rows
and vegetable fields. The farm work certainly satisfied
her aesthetic sensibility and need for economically
meaningful activities, but from time to time it could
become a bit too repetitive and automatically
programmed in her body. On the other hand it was
physically versatile, considering the season as a whole,
and both she and Pierre-Joseph were athletically built
after many years of agricultural practice.
189
in general nor for my own personal prospects. Private
property has got a much too extensive leeway and
economic inequality is only increasing as the years go by.
War is rarely progressive in any meaningful sense, and if
England were to win this war it would have huge global
repercussions. Who knows what will happen in the
American colonies, for example? And what about France
herself – in the wake of the immense economic strain
resulting from the war expenditures? What about the
integrity of the Enlightenment ideas? Will orthodox
religion – whether we are talking about Catholicism or
Protestantism – once again dominate the scene? The
uncertainties and risks are numerous.”
190
women will achieve. Are they to be ‘liberated’ from the
household or to spiritual and artistic activities? Are they
to get involved in the political domain and aspire to
power within the state apparatus? In general, I am highly
sceptical towards the tendency of politics to swell at the
cost of the more intimate social life and the public’s
economic conditions of production, and in this respect I
can underpin my scepticism by alluding to the ancient
Greeks, who hardly were in favour of expanding their
political domain to an unduly resource demanding extent.
Quite to the contrary – as their very political domain
itself was enforced upon them as a result of the recurring
military threats from the Persians and other foreign
invaders. Of course, Athenian politics aimed at
preventing tyranny and even oligarchy from developing
within their own society, but it was never meant by the
Athenians to throne above the oikos sphere. Neither did
Aristotle subscribe to such an expansion of the political
sphere, according to his work, Politics, in which he also
warns against admitting trade an undue importance and
role within economic life – at the cost of agricultural and
artisanal production.”
192
immediately, considering the possibilities for a
progressive development in the years ahead, including
the continuation of the economic reform work initiated
by the physiocrats. In his opinion it was absolutely
crucial that the remains of feudal society were rooted out
once and for all, so that the peasants could be elevated to
an equal level with the other productive classes of society
– indeed, maybe even alotted a decisive voice in the
public assemblies, and he added that he did not have an
unconditioned faith in European civilization considering
its modern developments. There had evolved far too
much vanity, envy and spite among people in general,
partly because of the difficult conditions for the
peasantry and the concomitant urbanization process,
Rousseau summed up, before explaining his choice of
location for a political asylum.
193
Pierre-Joseph was full of intellectual impressions as he
returned to the farm on Sunday afternoon, and he
discussed them lengthily with Olympes throughout the
evening, and for her part Olympes got the glimpse of a
few additional points which she ought to include in her
dissertation – albeit without direct reference to Rousseau,
she thought. Well, the next few days would reveal how
she was going to go about it. The crucial thing now was
to submit the manuscript for academic review, and
prepare to defend it in front of the stern Parisian
professors.
XXV
In the Tower of London sat Angelica Shelley and the
printer incarcerated for the fourth month for concurrence
in the revolt attempt. The isolation had already taken its
toll on Angelicas nerves when she suddenly one day was
locked out with the explanation that she as well as the
printer had been granted a pardon from the king – in her
case because she had only had an inferior role in the
printing of subversive writings, and he due to the fact
that, seen from the point of view of the government, he
had done an excellent job throughout his long career and,
moreover, had very promising children to take care of.
195
conversations with a few strangers while she awaited the
ride home told her that it was all over. The capital was
full of troops, and a number of revolutionaries had been
incarcerated, some of them had already been executed
and most of the others deported to some penal colony.
The heroic attempt had been aborted, and the prospects
for a Europe united in the universalism of the
Enlightenment, for which Thomas Paine was such a stout
proponent, were rather dismal. As it all stood at the
moment, the rivalry between nations would probably
dominate the agenda for many decades ahead, maybe
even for centuries to come – if nothing of importance
occured in the opposite direction.
196
In Aberystwyth, where Thomas Paine temporarily had
sought refuge, there had also been razzias, arrests and
deportations – causing him to lay low and go into hiding
in some tiny village in the interior. Here he had had the
lesiure to figure out a plan for coping with the new
situation, and had come to the conclusion that he would
apply for a job within the English state apparatus – in
order to camouflage his former revolutionary activity and
preserved political stance. Later on he would have to
conceive of a more long term solution, he thought.
Fortunately he had very good contacts in the American
colonies. Maybe there was a role for him to play there at
some point in the future, in which he could serve the
struggle for human liberation and the case for universal
human rights?
197
In the university library of Aberystwyth during one of his
brief visits there, he encountered a historian who had
specialized in the history of the American colonies. He
had told Paine about the solid foothold of puritan ideas
on the other side of the Atlantic, and emphasized that
historical names such as John Lilburne and Gerrard
Winstanley still were commemorated and honoured in
various ways over there – notably in the form of the New
England town meetings, a tradition which kept the idea
of direct democracy alive. These monthly public
meetings at the squares of a number of cities in the
North-Eastern parts of the American continent gave, at
least potentially, the citizens themselves the moral power
in society. Maybe this public power could one day even
be insitutionalized, the historian wondered, and added
that in that case it would be entirely in accordance with
the spirit of Rousseau – if one was to pay attention to his
political writings, which presently were about to be
included in a major work.
202
203