Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PSD CEU 180Sept11-Corrosion PDF
PSD CEU 180Sept11-Corrosion PDF
PSD 180
Continuing Education from Plumbing Systems & Design
SEPTEMBER 2011
PSDMAGAZINE.ORG
CONTINUING EDUCATION
Reprinted from Plumbing Engineering Design Handbook, Vol 1. © American Society of Plumbing Engineers, 2009.
electrolyte electrolyte
corrosion product corrosion product
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
high oxygen
H2O 02 NaCI concentration
NaCI 02 H2O
H2O FeCI2
NaCI
NaOH NaOH
FeCI2 FeCI2
corrosion
flow current
copper iron
low oxygen
concentration
H2O NaCI electrolyte H2O NaCI
Figure 8-6 Concentration Cells
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
corrosion product
metal
back to the protected structure. This causes severe corrosion environments may yield slightly different results. Metals
at the point of current discharge. that are far apart in the series have a greater potential for
Corrosion by differential environmental conditions galvanic corrosion than do metals in the same group or
(Figure 8-11): Examples of differential environmental cells metals near each other in the series. Metals listed above
are shown in Figure 8-11. It should be noted that variations other metals in the series are generally anodic (corrode) to
in moisture content, availability of oxygen, change in soil metals listed below them. The relative area of the metals in
resistivity, or variations of all three may occur in some cases. the couple must be considered along with the polarization
As in all corrosion phenomena, changes or variations in the characteristic of each metal. To avoid corrosion, a large
environment are a contributing factor. anode area with a small cathode area is favorable.
Equation 8-6
iZ = 150,000 ×
p
f × 0.27
where:
iM = Current output of magnesium, mA
iZ = Current output of zinc, mA
p = Soil resistivity, Ω-cm
f = Anode size factor
The cost of galvanic cathodic protection generally
favors the use of zinc anodes over magnesium at
soil resistances less than 1,500 ohm-cm and the
use of magnesium at soil resistances more than
1,500 ohm‑cm.
Impressed current The impressed cur-
rent system, illustrated in Figure 8-14, differs
substantially from the galvanic anode system
in that it is externally powered, usually by an
AC/DC rectifier, which allows great freedom
in adjustment of current output. Current re-
quirements of several hundred amperes can
be handled by impressed current systems. The
impressed current system usually consists of
graphite or high-silicon iron anodes connected
to an AC/DC rectifier, which, in turn, is wired
to the structure being protected. Current
output is determined by adjustment of the
rectifier voltage to provide current as re-
quired. The system is not limited by potential
difference between metals, and voltage can
be adjusted to provide an adequate driving Figure 8-12 Cathodic Protection by the Sacrificial Anode Method
force to emit the necessary current. Impressed
current systems are used for structures hav-
ing large current requirements, such as bare of power and ease of installing the ground bed are required.
pipe, tank farms, large-diameter cross-country pipelines, After all of the above are satisfactorily done, it is generally
cast iron water lines, and many offshore f acilities. necessary to perform a current-requirement test utilizing
Impressed current cathodic protection has the following a portable DC generator or storage batteries. This defines
advantages: an apparent DC current requirement to protect the struc-
• Large current output
ture. Tests to determine any adverse effects also should be
conducted on foreign structures at this time. Any current
• Voltage adjustment over a wide range drained to foreign structures should be added to the cur-
• Can be used with a high soil rent requirements.
resistivity environment After the total current requirement is known, the
• Can protect uncoated structures ground bed is designed so that the circuit resistance is
• Can be used to protect larger structures
relatively low. Actual ground-bed design depends on soil
resistivity. A number of empirical formulas are available
Impressed current cathodic protection has the following to determine the number of parallel anodes required for a
disadvantages: certain circuit resistance.
• Higher installation and maintenance costs Cathodic protection criteria Criteria for determining
• Power costs adequate cathodic protection have been established by the
• Can cause adverse effects (stray current) with foreign structures National Association of Corrosion Engineers (NACE). These
criteria are based on measuring structure-to-electrode
When designing impressed current cathodic protection
potentials with a copper-sulfate reference electrode. The
systems, the engineer must determine the type and condi-
criteria are listed for various metals, such as steel, cast iron,
tion of the structure. Obtaining knowledge of the presence
aluminum, and copper, and may be found in NACE Standard
or lack of coating, size of structure, electrical continuity,
RP-01.
and location is a necessary first step. Next, the availability
Cathodic protection serves its purpose best, and is by far tached to the underground structure (pipeline or tank) to
the most economical, when it is properly coordinated with provide electrical contact for the purpose of determining
the other methods of corrosion control, especially coating. In protection effectiveness. Test stations also are used to make
general, the least expensive, easiest to maintain, and most bonds or connections between structures when required to
practical system is to apply a good-quality coating to a new mitigate stray current effects.
structure and then use cathodic protection to eliminate cor- Costs of cathodic protection Corrosion of under-
rosion at the inevitable breaks in the coating. The reason for ground, ferrous metal structures can be economically
this is that it takes much more current and anodes to protect controlled by cathodic protection. Cathodic protection costs
bare metal than it does to protect coated metal. The amount are added to the initial investment since they are a capital
of protective current required is proportional to the area of expense. To be economically sound, the spending of the
metal exposed to the electrolyte. funds must yield a fair return over the expected life of the
In addition to using coatings, it is necessary to ensure facility.
continuity of the structures to provide protection of the whole Protecting a new facility requires an initial increase of
structure. This also prevents undesirable accelerated stray perhaps 10 percent in capital investment. Payout time is
current corrosion to the parts of the structure that are not usually 10 to 15 years; thereafter, appreciable savings ac-
electrically continuous. Therefore, all noncontinuous joints, crue due to this investment, which prevents or reduces the
such as mechanical, push-on, or screwed joints in pipelines, frequency of leaks. Effective corrosion control through the
must be bonded. All tanks in a tank farm or piles on a wharf application of cathodic protection reduces the leak frequency
must be bonded to ensure electrical continuity. for a structure to the minimum with minimum cost.
Other important components used in effective cathodic Cathodic protection systems must be properly main-
protection systems are dielectric insulation and test stations. tained. Rectifier outputs must be checked monthly. Changes
Dielectric insulation sometimes is used to isolate underground or additions to the protected structure must be considered to
protected structures from aboveground structures to reduce see if changes or additions to the cathodic protection system
the amount of cathodic protection current required. Care must are required. Annual inspections by a corrosion engineer
be taken to avoid short-circuiting (bypassing) the insulation, are required to ensure that all malfunctions are corrected,
or protection can be destroyed. Test stations are wires at- and cathodic protection continues unhampered.
Inhibitors (Water Treatment) When water treatment or inhibitors are used, a testing pro-
Plant utility services such as boiler feed water, condensate, gram must be established to ensure that proper additive levels
refrigerants, and cooling water require the addition of inhib- are maintained. In some cases, continuous monitoring is required.
itors or water treatment. Boiler feed water must be treated Also, environmental considerations in local areas must be deter-
to maintain proper pH control, dissolved solid levels, and mined before additives are used or before any treated water is
oxygen content. Condensate requires treatment to control discharged to the sanitary sewer or storm drainage system.
corrosion by oxygen and carbon dioxide. Brine refrigerants
and cooling water in closed-loop circulating systems require Corrosion in Plastics
proper inhibitors to prevent corrosion. Plastic materials corrode by processes different than metallic
Water treatment may consist of a simple adjustment materials. Physicochemical processes rather than electrochemical
of water hardness to produce naturally forming carbonate reactions are responsible for the degradation of plastics. Plastic
films. This carbonate film, if properly adjusted, will form to materials are attacked by swelling, dissolution and bond (joint)
a controlled thickness just sufficient to prevent corrosion by rupture due to chemical reaction (oxidation), heat, and radiation
keeping water from contacting the metal surface. In cooling (sunlight). These reactions can occur singly or in combination.
water, where hardness control is not practical, inhibitors or The traditional method of expressing the rate of corrosion as
film-forming compounds may be required. weight loss cannot be used for plastic materials. Other evaluation
Sodium silicate and sodium hexametaphosphate are methods such as change in hardness, tensile properties, losses
examples of film-forming additives in potable water treat- or gains in dimensions, elongation, and appearance changes
ment. A tight, thin, continuous film of silica (water glass) or determine the corrosion effect on a plastic material. The effects
phosphate adheres to the metal surface, preventing pipe of various environments on plastic materials are tabulated for
contact with the water. (Phosphate additives to potable water each specific plastic material, as shown on Table 8-5. The designer
are limited or prohibited in some jurisdictions.) must evaluate plastic materials against the chemical environment
In closed-loop cooling systems and systems involving inside and outside of the material.
heat-exchange surfaces, it may not be possible to use film-
forming treatment because of the detrimental effects on heat Table 8-5 Chemical Resistance for Common Plasticsa
transfer. In these cases, inhibitors are used; these control Pipe Material
corrosion by increasing polarization of anodic or cathodic Chemical Name ABS PVC CPVC
surfaces and are called “anodic” or “cathodic inhibitors” Acetone NR NR NR
respectively. The anodic or cathodic surfaces are covered, Beer 120 140 180
Chlorox bleach solution, 5.5%CL2 NR NR NR
preventing completion of the corrosion cell by elimination
Citric acid, 10% 160 140 180
of either the anode or cathode.
RESOURCES
1. Bosich, Joseph F. 1970. Corrosion prevention for
practicing engineers.
2. Claes and Fitzgerald. 1975–1976. Fundamentals of
underground corrosion control. Plant Engineering
Technical Publishing. Plant Engineering. New York:
McGraw-Hill.
3. Fontana, Mars G., and Norbert D. Greene. 1986.
Corrosion engineering, third edition. New York:
McGraw-Hill.
4. Kullen, Howard P. Corrosion. Power. December
1956: 74–106.
5. Laque, F. L., and H. R. Copson. 1965. Corrosion and
resistance of metals and alloys. 2nd ed. New York:
Reinhold Publishing.
6. National Association of Corrosion Engineers. 1971.
NACE basic corrosion course. Houston: National As-
sociation of Corrosion Engineers.
SD 180
CE Questions — “Corrosion” (PSD 180)
1. Which of the following must be present for corrosion to occur? 7. What is the most common method of corrosion prevention?
a. anode a. cathodic protection
b. cathode b. coating
c. electrolyte c. materials selection
d. all of the above d. passivation
2. ________ corrosion results from the localized breakdown of a 8. The most common sacrificial anode is made from ________.
protective film or layer of corrosion products. a. aluminum
a. galvanic b. zinc
b. uniform c. magnesium
c. pitting d. nickel
d. crevice
9. Galvanic anodes are advantageous because ________.
3. ________ is also called leaching. a. the driving voltage is low
a. impingement attack b. the installation cost is relatively low
b. selective attack c. no external power source is required
c. stress corrosion cracking d. both b and c
d. concentration cell attack
10. A disadvantage of impressed current cathodic protection is
4. Which of the following generally would be anodic to tin? ________.
a. lead a. power costs
b. active nickel b. large current output
c. steel c. voltage adjustment
d. none of the above d. both b and c
5. The ________ of an aqueous solution influences the corrosion of 11. ________ is the weakening of a metal due to contact with an
metals. alkaline solution.
a. temperature a. amphoteric corrosion
b. velocity b. caustic embrittlement
c. acidity c. hydrogen embrittlement
d. all of the above d. stray current corrosion
6. In a domestic hot water system, the rate of corrosion doubles 12. Anodic potential is another term for ________.
for each ________ rise above 140°F water temperature. a. corrosion potential
a. 1°F b. electronegative potential
b. 5°F c. electropositive potential
c. 10°F d. protective potential
d. 15°F
Please print or type; this information will be used to process your credits.
Name_________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Title __________________________________________________ ASPE Membership No._____________________________________
Organization___________________________________________________________________________________________________
Billing Address_ ________________________________________________________________________________________________
City_ _________________________________________ State/Province_________________________ Zip_______________________
Country_______________________________________________ E-mail_ _________________________________________________
Daytime telephone_ ____________________________________ Fax_____________________________________________________
PE State _ _____________________________________________ PE No._ _________________________________________________
Notice for North Carolina Professional Engineers: State regulations for registered PEs in North Carolina now require you to complete ASPE’s
online CEU validation form to be eligible for continuing education credits. After successfully completing this quiz, just visit ASPE’s CEU Valida-
tion Center at aspe.org/CEUValidationCenter.
I am applying for the following continuing education credits: ❏ ASPE Member ❏ Nonmember
Each examination: $25 Each examination: $35
I certify that I have read the article indicated above. Limited Time: No Cost to ASPE Member
Payment: ❏ Personal Check (payable to ASPE) $
❏ Business or government check $
Signature ❏ DiscoverCard ❏ VISA ❏ MasterCard ❏ AMEX $
Expiration date: Continuing education credit will be given If rebilling of a credit card charge is necessary, a $25 processing fee will be charged.
for this examination through September 30, 2012. ASPE is hereby authorized to charge my CE examination fee to my
Applications received after that date will not be processed. credit card