2010-05-04 European Sovereign Debt Crisis in Perspective F

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 5

 

This is for investment professionals only and should not be relied upon by private investors

FIXED INCOME MAY 2010

Euro-zone sovereign risk: Will the Greek


debt crisis be contagious or contained?
AT A GLANCE: TIMELINE Fear and contagion have broken out in European sovereign bond markets. The well-
 23 April: Greece formally applies for documented government debt problems in Greece - which are by common consent much
financial assistance from the IMF. Instead worse than anywhere else in the Euro-zone - prompted the Greek government to ask for
of calming investors, it triggers panic in emergency funding from the IMF.
Euro-zone sovereign bond markets. Despite fears over Germany’s lack of political appetite, Euro-zone finance ministers green-
lighted a $110 billion rescue package, which significantly reduces the danger of a debt
 28 April: Fears over Germany’s
restructuring in the short-term. The larger than expected package, which includes painful
willingness to agree an EU bailout sees
austerity measures and quarterly IMF spot-checks, seems to have credibility.
the yield on Greek 2-year bonds soar past
the 25% mark (now back to around 10%). However, it remains to be seen whether this will restore confidence in all Euro-zone bond
markets and the single European currency. Could the contagion spread to other peripheral
 28-29 April: Standard & Poor’s cuts the
European economies? And, could it derail the global economic and stock market recovery?
sovereign ratings of Greece, Portugal and
Spain to ‘junk’, ‘A-‘ and ‘AA’ respectively. GREECE IS A BASKET CASE
 02 May: Euro-zone finance ministers We have known for some time that the Greek economy is in a very bad state. However, that
approve a $110 billion finance package. weakness now threatens to cast a dark cloud over the entire Euro-zone. Despite the fact that most
 03 May: Euro slides to a 12-month low market observers anticipated Greece would need IMF help, the confirmation of the need for a bail-
against the US dollar as short positions out nevertheless inspired panic in sovereign bond markets.
against it hit a record high. Bond investors pushed up yields in Portugal, Spain and Ireland, concerned by the possibility that
these economies might be next in the IMF queue. Standard & Poor’s reacted by downgrading
Greece by three notches to BB+ or junk status, while reducing Portugal’s sovereign rating from A+
KEY POINTS to A- and Spain’s by one notch to AA. If Greece is in such a bad way, should we be worried about
 There has been limited new factual news- other Euro-zone economies with, what are on the face of it, a similar set of fiscal pressures?
flow behind recent events. Most market On balance, probably not. Greece is a basket case. It is the ‘weakest link’ in the Euro-zone by a
observers anticipated Greece would significant margin. And, while other economies have their problems, there are reasons to believe
require emergency funding. they are surmountable. On the other hand, there are reasons to doubt Greece’s problems can be
 Confirmation of the need for a bail-out overcome and austerity measures can be successfully implemented. This is because Greece’s
raised the fear level and attention quickly dire financial situation is exacerbated by some specific structural weaknesses that are specific to
focused on other ‘suspect’ economies its economy, Greek working practices, retirement laws, political stability and the size of the state.
such as Portugal, Spain and Ireland. While the $110 billion emergency funding stabilises the short-term situation, these structural
issues are likely to challenge the austerity plan and cloud the medium to long-term outlook.
 Global economic conditions remain robust
and the corporate sector has been THE SPIKE IN BOND YIELDS – GREECE IS THE ‘WEAKEST LINK’
reporting healthy earnings.
12
 The crisis should largely be contained to
Greece and the global economic and Portugal Greece Germany Ireland Spain UK

stock market recovery left intact. 10

 The slide in the euro is actually a net


Redemption Yield

positive for European equities. This 8


combined with attractive valuations in
many areas, means there are attractive 6
opportunities available.
4

0
May-07 Sep-07 Jan-08 May-08 Sep-08 Jan-09 May-09 Sep-09 Jan-10 May-10

Source: DataStream, as at 30.4.10. Redemption yields on Benchmark 10-Year Government Bonds for countries shown.

 
 

SENTIMENT IS DRIVING MARKET BEHAVIOUR


While there has been some clarification on the size of Greece’s government debt, there has been
little new information on economic growth and government finances in peripheral European
economies that explains the recent market action.
The upward pressure on Irish government bond yields and CDS spreads is particularly interesting.
This is because Ireland was widely applauded by bond investors for tackling its deficit and laying
out what was considered to be a credible restructuring plan. The fact that Irish bond yields were
pushed out tends to suggest recent market behaviour has been driven by sentiment rather than
fundamentals.
CDS spreads, which represent the cost of insuring against default in the underlying bonds spiked
sharply higher in Greece, but have also risen for Portugal and Ireland. In the CDS market, the
buyer does not need to own the underlying security; when they do not, this is known as being
‘naked long CDS’ and is a pure play speculation on default. The climate of political scrutiny on the
financial sector was expected to limit the extent of speculation on sovereign debt, with many
hedge funds, for example, fearing a political backlash at being seen to be profiting from crisis.
We can see some of the moves in CDS spreads have exceeded the moves in bond yields
suggesting there is a material element of speculative money behind recent market action.

CDS SPREADS – A MEASURE OF THE MARKET VIEW OF SOVEREIGN DEFAULT RISK

900
Greece UK Portugal Spain Ireland Germany
800

700

600
Basis Points

500

400

300

200

100

0
May-07 Sep-07 Jan-08 May-08 Sep-08 Jan-09 May-09 Sep-09 Jan-10 May-10

Source: DataStream, as at 30.4.10. 5-Year CDS spreads.

IMF PACKAGE REMOVES SHORT-TERM GREEK WORRY, BUT GENERAL FEARS REMAIN
Many observers within the Euro-zone and the IMF will now be hoping that the agreement of the
$110 billion package for Greece will represent a line in the sand. The loan effectively removes the
need for the Greek Government to issue debt for 2 years. Greek two-year bond yields have
responded positively with yields falling back significantly.
The decision by the European Central Bank (ECB) to suspend their minimum credit-rating
requirements - so that they can accept Greek junk-rated bonds as collateral - is another positive
that will help to shore up liquidity requirements amongst Greek banks.
On the basis of the new tougher austerity measures on which the package is conditional, the
Greek economy is forecast to contract 4% this year and 2.6% next year. The longer term outlook
is much more challenging but we must remember that Greece represents less than 3% of the
Euro-zone economy.
However, there is still widespread caution among investors and we are likely to see nervousness
remain a feature of sovereign bond markets and currency markets for the next few weeks. The
record short interest (the numbers of down bets) that has built up in the Euro provides an
indication that we can expect more volatility in the coming weeks as traders bet against the single
currency in expectation of further fall-out from this rapidly evolving crisis.

 
 
 

MIGHT WE SEE A DOMINO EFFECT?


The concern now is whether the Greek scenario might be repeated in another peripheral
European economy. The markets seem to believe the prime candidates are Portugal, Ireland and
Spain. All three economies have their problems but none are remotely in as dire a position as
Greece.
Spain is not the next Greece. While the economy suffers from high unemployment and the
government needs to undertake fiscal tightening, there are signs of cyclical recovery. The bleak
debt environment seems to have been priced into stock markets; however the potential to be
gained from the rapid growth of Latin American markets seems to have been underestimated on
the basis of current valuations.
Likewise, at first glance, Portugal has similarities with Greece. The European Commission
believes government assumptions of positive growth this year and next are over-optimistic,
particularly given the fact that Spain, its principal export market, has its own challenges to
overcome. However, like Spain, Portugal is not Greece. Its 9.4% 2009 Budget Deficit is more than
3 percentage points lower than Greece’s 13.6% and, crucially, the country has successfully cut its
debt before.
Ireland’s 2009 budget deficit is actually higher than Greece’s; however, in terms of the total stock
of public debt, Ireland’s is estimated to be a still manageable 65% of output while Greece’s was a
ruinous 110%.
Overall, European banks have a limited exposure to this potential crisis in comparison with sub-
prime mortgages. The Bank of International Settlements estimates that European banks’ total
exposure to Greek, Spanish and Portuguese debt represents only 5% of total bank assets. So, the
idea of persistent contagion seems unlikely given the relatively better economic and corporate
situation in the other peripheral economies, the better credibility of their governments and the lack
of exposure among the European banking sector, in general.

ACTUAL AND EXPECTED GOVERNMENT BUDGET DEFICITS (AS A %OF GDP)

GREECE SPAIN PORTUGAL ITALY IRELAND


0

-2

-4

-6

-8

-10

-12 2008
2009
-14 2010

-16

Source: Thomson DataStream for 2008-9 figures. Economist for 2010 figures based on forecasts by the Economist Intelligence Unit.

THERE ARE STILL BIG ISSUES TO BE RESOLVED


Nevertheless, recent events point to a worrying division within the European Union and the
possibility of a two-tier Euro-zone economy. This could be exacerbated by a greater willingness on
the part of Germany to look after its own interests. The realisation that monetary union may be the
underlying root of many of the problems could see the euro come under continued pressure.
Rather than convergence, many experts are willing to argue it is the euro and centralised ECB
policy which have ultimately caused divergences between economies to become entrenched.
These divergences in economic competitiveness, fiscal policy and now sovereign credit ratings
are raising questions over the rights and wrong of a common currency and centralised monetary
policy. During the good times, prices and wages rose more strongly in Portugal, Spain and Ireland
than they did in Germany. Property bubbles in the former countries were responsible for much of
this effect. This loss of competitiveness could historically be resolved by currency devaluation.

 
 
 

However, ‘competitive devaluation’ is no longer an option. One alternative solution would be to


end the hard-line inflation targeting policy of the European Central Bank and promote
expansionary policies across the Euro-zone that would lift the ‘second tier’. However, ‘inflation
fundamentalism’ is deeply embedded among the elite central bank and European economic
officials. In short, they might see the risks of allowing inflation to climb above 2% as worse than
the benefits of avoiding a two-tier Euro-zone. There still appears to be little room for economic
growth considerations in the ECB’s mandate.

VIEWS FROM FIDELITY’S FIXED INCOME TEAM


David Simner - Manager of FF Euro Bond and FF Euro Corporate Bond
"We were running short Greece until recently. The rationale for covering the short was the German
finance ministers’ appearance in front of a German parliament committee stating that Germany
would provide funds and that it was likely to be greater than was envisaged. We took this as a
green light, and once the Greeks formally asked for assistance on Friday 23 April we added a little
more, taking the funds to a slight overweight position. We have been running short of Spain and
Portugal and have had a small long to Ireland. I think Greece (and the peripheral economies
generally) will face enormous headwinds but that we will see enough cohesion in Europe for the
project to limp along, albeit with bouts of volatility and doubt".

VIEWS FROM FIDELITY’S EUROPEAN EQUITY TEAM


Alexander Scurlock, portfolio Manager of the FF European Growth Fund
"The ongoing crisis in Greece has affected sentiment towards European equities with many
investors currently shunning the region. It has also somewhat obscured the good news coming out
of Europe, with the region continuing to benefit from the recovery in global trade, inventory rebuild
and a more competitive currency. Indeed, industrial production within Europe is running at
impressive levels, while strong exports and high margins are likely to provide a further boost to
company profits as the recovery unfolds. Furthermore, inflation remains subdued, which should
mean that monetary policy stays accommodative for longer. As credit concerns about peripheral
countries ease, and the EU/IMF package for Greece comes into place, there should be a
significant reduction in the chance of debt-restructuring taking place and, as a result, we could see
markets improve on the back of strong earnings growth and attractive valuations."
Fabio Riccelli, portfolio manager of FF European Dynamic Growth
"National Bank of Greece is a stock that, along with all other Greek banks, has suffered in the
recent turmoil over Greek fiscal deficit. I am taking a long-term view on this stock as I believe that
there is significant potential for this bank, in particular in the Turkish market, where it is already a
key player. The under-penetrated Turkish banking market is and National Bank of Greece is well
positioned to benefit as this market grows."
Firmino Morgado, Portfolio Manager of FF Iberia and FF European Aggressive Fund
"Issues over sovereign debt in the peripheral economies and the subsequent downgrades in
Greek and Portuguese debt are not a surprise. The markets have reacted strongly, but there is a
possibility that they have overreacted. The likely disbursing of the EU/IMF aid should see Greece
through the forthcoming redemptions/coupons. However, the solvency question depends on the
Government's ability to convince the market that it can deliver on its austerity programme.
The markets attention has been increasingly focused on Portugal and Spain due to heightened
concerns of a contagion effect from Greece. However, Portugal and Spain have been better
economic fundamentals than Greece. So, while Portugal and Spain still face having to implement
tough fiscal measures and economic reforms, there is more confidence in both governments.
Furthermore, Spanish companies are internationally diversified with only 42% of sales coming
from the domestic economy, while over 30% of the total comes from outside of Europe.
As a stock picker, this high volatility event offers the opportunity to buy stocks that the market has
been selling indiscriminately, purely because of where the companies are listed. This throws up
attractive valuation opportunities for fundamentally strong, internationally diversified companies."

 
 
 
 

CONCLUSION
Global economic growth remains robust. Corporate earnings are healthy. The recovery in stock
and credit markets is unlikely to be materially derailed by the recent events in Greece, which
should ultimately be contained. Greece was always going to need a bail-out, given the severity of
the problems. That is not to say that other countries in the Euro-zone such as Spain, Portugal and
the UK do not have tough choices to make however, unlike Greece, they have more scope with
which to make them.
We know that there are pockets of slower growth in the Euro-zone, but the Euro-zone will also be
a beneficiary of healthy global and emerging market growth. Emerging market economies continue
to contribute significantly to global growth and the Euro-zone is a key market for imports of
machine goods, commodities, services and finished products. In this light, European markets
could offer excellent opportunities for investors looking for relative value. Another net positive for
many European shares is the fact that the weakness in the Euro makes their products more
attractive in export markets.
The midst of a crisis very often presents a rich vein of attractive, valuation-based opportunities for
those astute investors prepared to take a medium-term view.
Our fixed income portfolio managers have limited exposure to what are seen-to-be the likeliest
‘contagion’ economies of Spain and Portugal, but recently started to buy Greek bonds on a short-
term tactical basis due to the yield available and the likelihood of the IMF package improving the
outlook. This position has already performed well in the light of the rescue package being agreed
and announced.
Meanwhile, our equity managers are united in their thoughts. There is significant medium-to-long
term value to be found amongst this volatility in European equities. Many European shares are
under-bought, overlooked and under-valued and our portfolio managers continue to find interesting
ideas in an equity market that has more capacity than most to surprise positively.

This information is for Investment Professionals only and should not be relied upon by private investors. It must not be reproduced or circulated without prior permission. This communication is not directed at, and must not be acted upon
by persons inside the United States and is otherwise only directed at persons residing in jurisdictions where the relevant funds are authorised for distribution or where no such authorisation is required. Fidelity/Fidelity International means FIL
Limited, established in Bermuda, and its subsidiary companies. Unless otherwise stated, all views are those of Fidelity. Reference in this document to specific securities should not be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell these securities,
but is included for the purposes of illustration only. Investors should also note that the views expressed may no longer be current and may have already been acted upon by Fidelity. The research and analysis used in this documentation is gathered
by Fidelity for its use as an investment manager and may have already been acted upon for its own purposes. Fidelity only offers information on its own products and services and does not provide investment advice based on individual
circumstances. Fidelity only offers information on its own products and services and does not provide investment advice based on individual circumstances. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. The value of investments can
go down as well as up and investors may not get back the amount invested. For funds that invest in overseas markets, changes in currency exchange rates may affect the value of an investment. Foreign exchange transactions may be effected on
an arms length basis by or through Fidelity companies from which a benefit may be derived by such companies. Annualised growth rates, total return, sector median performance and ranks – Data Source - © 2010 Morningstar, Inc. All
Rights Reserved. The information contained herein: (1) is proprietary to Morningstar and/or its content providers; (2) may not be copied or distributed; and (3) is not warranted to be accurate, complete or timely. Neither Morningstar nor its content
providers are responsible for any damages or losses arising from any use of this information. Investments in small and emerging markets can be more volatile than other more developed markets. Due to the lack of liquidity in many smaller stock
markets, certain Country Select Funds may be volatile and redemption rights may be restricted in extreme circumstances. In certain countries, and for certain types of investments, transaction costs are higher and liquidity is lower than elsewhere.
There may also be limited opportunities to find alternative ways of managing cash flows especially where the focus of investment is on small and medium sized firms. For funds specializing in such countries and investment types, transactions,
particularly those large in size, are likely to have a greater impact on the costs of running a fund than similar transactions in larger funds. Prospective investors should bear this in mind in selecting funds. Due to the greater possibility of default an
investment in corporate bonds is generally less secure than an investment in Government bonds. Fidelity Funds is an open-ended investment company established in Luxembourg with different classes of shares. Reference to FF refers to Fidelity
Funds. We recommend that you obtain detailed information before taking any investment decision. Investments should be made on the basis of the current prospectus, which is available along with the current annual and semi-annual reports free of
charge from our distributors, from our European Service Centre in Luxembourg and from our legal representative in Switzerland: Fortis Foreign Fund Services AG, Rennweg 57, P.O. Box, CH-8021 Zurich. After a decision made by the Swiss
Financial Market Supervisory Authority - FINMA on 17 December 2009, Fidelity Funds can publicly market 98 of its subfunds in Switzerland. In Italy and the Nordics, they are available from your financial advisor or from the branch of your bank. For
the purposes of distribution in Spain, Fidelity Funds is registered, with the CNMV Register of Foreign Collective Investment Schemes under registration number 124, where complete information is available from Fidelity Funds authorised
distributors. The purchase of or subscription for shares in Fidelity Funds shall be made on the basis of the Simplified Prospectus that investors shall receive in advance. The Simplified Prospectus is available free of charge and for inspection at the
offices of locally authorised distributors as well as at the CNMV. In Portugal, Fidelity Funds is registered with the CMVM and the legal documents can be obtained from locally authorised distributors. Please note that not all funds in the SICAV fund
range are suitable for UK investors and tax advice should be sought before investing. Fidelity Funds is recognised under section 264 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000. Investors should note that loss caused by such recognised funds
will not be covered by the provisions of the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (or by any similar scheme in Luxembourg) if the fund is unable to meet its obligations, however claims for loss in regards to such recognised funds against a FSA
authorised firm such as Fidelity will be. The Full Prospectus and Simplified Prospectus for this fund is available from Fidelity on request by calling 0800 41 41 41. The UK distributor of Fidelity Funds is FIL Investments International. In the
Netherlands, the documents are available from FIL Investments International, Netherlands Branch (registered with the AFM), World Trade Centre, Tower H, 6th Floor, Zuidplein 52, 1077 XV Amsterdam (tel. 0031 20 79 77 100). Fidelity Funds is
authorised to offer participation rights in The Netherlands pursuant to article 2:66 (3) in conjunction with article 2:71 and 2:72 Financial Supervision Act. For Belgium: the current Prospectus/Simplified Prospectus, including the Addendum for Belgian
investors is available from Fastnet Belgium S.A., the financial service provider in Belgium. In Bermuda, the documents are available from FIL Distributors International Limited at 42 Crow Lane, Pembroke HM 19, Bermuda. Malta: Growth
Investments Limited is licensed by the MFSA. Fidelity Funds is promoted in Malta by Growth Investments Ltd in terms of the EU UCITS Directive and Legal Notices 207 and 309 of 2004. The Fund is regulated in Luxembourg by the Commission de
Surveillance du Secteur Financier. Issued jointly by FIL Investments International (registered in England and Wales), authorised and regulated in the UK by the Financial Services Authority and FIL Distributors International Limited (registered in
Bermuda and licensed to conduct investment business by the Bermuda Monetary Authority). SSO1402 
 

 
 

You might also like