Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Autobiography As Advertisement - Why Do Gertrude Stein's Sentences Get Under Our Skin
Autobiography As Advertisement - Why Do Gertrude Stein's Sentences Get Under Our Skin
Autobiography As Advertisement - Why Do Gertrude Stein's Sentences Get Under Our Skin
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://about.jstor.org/terms
The Johns Hopkins University Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and
extend access to New Literary History
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Autobiography As Advertisement:
Why Do Gertrude Stein's Sentences
Get Under Our Skin?*
Helga L?n?rt-Cheng
*l am grateful to John Stauffer for help and encouragement with this essay.
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
118 NEW LITERARY HISTORY
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
AUTOBIOGRAPHY AS ADVERTISEMENT 119
ing houses. Even her lifelong dream was fulfilled when both the Atlantic
Monthly and the Saturday Evening Post agreed to print some of her works.
The success of her memoir triggered an avalanche of positive changes in
her entire artistic career. "Until this year the public has steadfastly
refused to read Miss Stein, preferring to deride her at a safe distance,"
remarked a reviewer in October 1933, "but during recent months the
tide has turned with a vengeance, and it is apparent that the reading
public, having thoroughly digested the work of her followers and
imitators, are turning their attention, at long last, to the far more
impressive original."7 Another commentator guessed that "many who
will read [The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas] will do so as [she] did?
read other things she has written and try to understand them, because
they like her so much."8
As the latter quotation suggests, not only did her writings become
popular overnight, but so did her eccentric person. In the years
preceding the publication of the autobiography, the public image of
Stein was quite scandalous, and her personality was surrounded by the
distrust attributable to notorious eccentrics. It is enough to look at a
picture of Gertrude Stein from that period to understand the reserva
tions of the audience?a rich, eccentric, lesbian American Jew living in
Paris who wore monk-style clothes and hairstyles?no wonder she gave
to many of her contemporaries the impression of an unapproachable,
rigid Sphinx.9 After 1933, however, even in the United States where
initially she had been received even less favorably than in France, Stein
was at once surrounded by attention only due to Hollywood stars. "In the
matter of fans you can only compare her with a motion-picture star in
Hollywood and three generations of young writers have sat at her feet,"
observed her friend, Carl Van Vechten.10
Confronted with this sudden turn in Fortune's wheel, Gertrude Stein
herself was perplexed and struggled to find an explanation. "Since the
Autobiography I had not done any writing, . . . somehow if my writing
was worth money then it was not what it had been, if it had always been
worth money then it would have been used to being that thing but if
anything changes then there is no identity," she pondered retrospec
tively in Everybody's Autobiography?1 Seeing Stein's unexpected transfigu
ration, the audience was equally at loss and many contemporaneous
reviewers seemed puzzled: how could "out of the dark seed of such
books as Geography and Plays, The Making of Americans and other pieces
that have amused and bemused simple literal folk [have] blossomed a
masterpiece which is crystal clear in style, exuberantly live, strangely
fascinating and filled with the miracle of laughter?"12
Although a few critics did see the autobiography as a logical continu
ation and culmination of Stein's previous stylistic experimentation, most
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
120 NEW LITERARY HISTORY
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
AUTOBIOGRAPHY AS ADVERTISEMENT 121
put down the book, Gertrude Stein gave the impression of a kindly,
good-humored, chatty "neighbor" who was at the same time a remark
ably talented writer. Convincing the audience about the versatility of her
personality was certainly not a difficult task for Stein, for it is well known
that it was precisely this ability that fascinated her admirers most: "In her
maturity, she gave the impression, not merely of doing what she liked
but of being almost anything she wanted to be. She seemed, as the many
surviving likenesses of her suggest, at once female and male, Jew and
non Jew, American pur sang and European peasant, artist and public
figure, and so on" (GI xi).
Thus, Stein's personality became immediately accessible, and this
confidential initiation evoked in the public a feeling of complicity so
greatly longed for by readers in an era that marked the literary market's
depersonalization. "Mahomets in their own right, they [the readers]
insist that Mountain Stein should come to them. And now [with The
Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas] at last the mountain has come. At one
long deferred bound she has moved from the legendary borders of
literature into the very market place, to face in person a large audience
of men in the street."19
For decades, it was considered a sacrilege in critical circles to mention
the name of an esoteric modernist writer and the words "market place"
or "men in the street" within the same sentence. Because modernist
writers were surrounded by the myth of the purity of art, critics did not
question the methods used by these authors to win over audiences. In
recent years, however, modernist writers have been dragged from their
pedestals and the critically suppressed relationship between canonical
modernist writers and the commercial marketplace has been reconsid
ered. Numerous recent studies aim at providing a metacommentary on
"exclusionary and political effects devolving from such a pristine con
ception of modernist poetics, its dense and mysterious 'purity.'"20 With
titles such as "Making Poetry Pay: The Commodification of Langston
Hughes," or "Make It Sell! Ezra Pound Advertises Modernism,"21 the
authors of these articles aim at demonstrating how market-oriented and
entrepreneurial in spirit modernist writers really were. In a similar fashion,
critical articles addressing the question of Gertrude Stein's place in the
literary marketplace often focus on her attempts to secure a readership
for her works by using crafty career moves.22 In connection with The
Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas, Bryce Conrad, for instance, gives a rich
account of how Stein capitalized on her connections to the French art
world and the Relief Fund in order to popularize her image in America.
Nevertheless, while many of these studies masterfully analyze the
various efforts made by modernist authors to strike the best possible
deals in the literary marketplace (they quote, for instance, precise
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
122 NEW LITERARY HISTORY
A strategy is more effective if only those who initiate it know the tactics
used to reach the goal. In advertising this means that the planners of
advertisements do not reveal to the public the secret methods used to
influence them. Similarly, Stein did not warn her readers in the
introduction by saying that they should be on the lookout because her
autobiography was self-promoting. Instead she concealed her self
promoting strategy in a way that allowed her to convince her readers
that the book was not about herself. "My sentences do get under their
skin," she used to say with the satisfaction of someone who managed to
create an influential advertisement, "only they do not know that they do"
(ATT 66). And if Stein's self-advertising strategy escapes our observation
it is because it is precisely from us, readers, the targets of her strategy,
that Stein needed to conceal her methods. This explains why the opinion
is widely held that Stein's autobiography is not primarily about herself,
but rather about Bohemian adventures at the beginning of the century.
In reality, the anecdotes about the evocative Bohemian life in the
Parisian caf?s and Stein's salon that form the core of the book's
reputation only serve as decorations to a more important, central, but
well-concealed theme of the book: that of the representation and
promotion of Stein's artistic career. Already the very first sentence of the
very first chapter describing Gertrude Stein introduces this theme: "This
was the year 1907. Gertrude Stein was just seeing through the press
Three Lives which she was having privately printed, and she was deep in
The Making of Americans, her thousand page book" (A7T6). From this
moment on, Stein does not allow her readers to lose sight of the
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
AUTOBIOGRAPHY AS ADVERTISEMENT 123
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
124 NEW LITERARY HISTORY
to the explanation of her own art: How to Write, Lectures in America, What
Are Masterpieces, and Composition as Explanation all served the purpose of
self-exegesis (although, paradoxically, these texts often need more
elucidation than the original works which they were supposed to
decipher). Thus, it struck readers as a novelty that in her autobiography,
instead of reflecting on the philosophical-aesthetical background of her
writing technique, Gertrude Stein chose to approach the problem of
artistic creation from a much more popular and comprehensible
perspective. With Stein's own wording, "she began to describe the inside
as seen from the outside"(AAT 147).
Presented this way, Stein's commentary on her own art was no longer
a perplexing jumble of self-explaining words that made no headway.
Instead, on the pages of The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas, readers can
follow step by step an easy to understand, schematic process of the
unfolding of an artistic "genius." Starting from the hopeless years of
obscurity, Gertrude Stein recounts every little detail (including exact
dates and names) of her long struggle with the publishers for recogni
tion. The obscure theoretical statements characterizing her other writ
ings are here replaced by perfectly lucid explanations such as "It was
William Cook who inspired the only movie Gertrude Stein ever wrote in
english, I have just published it in Operas and Plays in the Plain
Edition,"(AAT 53) or "There were printed of this edition I forget
whether it was seven hundred and fifty or a thousand copies but at any
rate it was a very charming little book and Gertrude Stein was enor
mously pleased" (AAT 147). Thus Stein managed wonderfully to make
the abstract process of artistic creation more intelligible to her readers
by centering her narrative around the history of the publication of her
works which, ultimately, served as a perfect backbone to the presenta
tion of her otherwise abstruse art.
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
AUTOBIOGRAPHY AS ADVERTISEMENT 125
230), she confessed. Determined to solicit fame, she set out to create a
market for her own art. But how could an author popularize his own art
in an autobiography written in first person singular without violating the
taboo of direct self-praise? Gertrude Stein tactically escaped this problem
when she decided to write her autobiography in the third person, as the
autobiography of her friend.
Toklas, an unconditional believer of Stein's genius and a loyal
supporter of her art, became in The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas an
easily manipulated instrument of Stein's self-promotion. Toklas's famous
introductory sentence, "I met Gertrude Stein. ... I may say that only
three times in my life have I met a genius and each time a bell within me
rang and I was not mistaken,"(AAT 5) is only one of dozens of
statements in which Stein?in Toklas's name?asserts her own special
talents. "Ultimately, the stratagem, far from corresponding to an inner
'doubling' or social anxiety, is a cunning form of self-hagiography which
neutralizes or forestalls criticism," comments Philippe Lejeune on
Stein's ingenious solution.26 The strategic importance of this idea lies in
the fact that the "ad copy" that Stein could not pronounce directly, seems
perfectly natural and acceptable from Toklas mouth.
Nevertheless, to have only one's best friend attesting to one's talent is
certainly not very convincing. First, Toklas was too closely associated with
Stein in order for her opinion to be accepted as an independent source.
Second, the name "Toklas" did not evoke reputation that would have
lent weight to her opinion. Consequently, Stein had to place within the
pages of her book a series of independent, distinguished "experts"
who?through Toklas, in a doubly indirect way?bore witness to the
unique values of Stein's writings. Most readers are likely to smile at a less
known friend's na?ve indignation about why Stein's name never ap
peared in Who's Who ("I hate to look at Who's Who in America . . . when
I see all those insignificant people and Gertrude's name not in,"[A7T
183]), but a similarly enthusiastic recommendation from a famous T. S.
Eliot, Ernest Hemingway, or Pablo Picasso certainly has its intended
effects.
Expanding her own vast repertoire of praises, Toklas quotes dozens of
such famed supporters. For example, "Elliot Paul, when editor of
transition once said that he was certain that Gertrude Stein could be a
best-seller in France. It seems very likely that his prediction is to be
fulfilled"(ALT 53). On another occasion Alice remarks, "The other
thing in connection with this her first book that gave her pleasure was a
very enthusiastic note from H. G. Wells"(A7T 106). As a consequence,
given that Stein chose a context in which so many respectable artists
chant her praises, what reader would not start doubting the validity of
his own negative prejudices or that of the mocking reviews?
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
126 NEW LITERARY HISTORY
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
AUTOBIOGRAPHY AS ADVERTISEMENT 127
Sometime every one becomes a whole one to me. Sometime every one has a
completed history for me. . . . There is then a history of the things they say and
do and feel, and happen to them. . . . Repeating is always in all of them.
Repeating in them comes out of them, slowly making clear to any one that looks
closely at them the nature and the natures mixed up in them. . . . Repeating is
a wonderful thing in living being. Sometime then the nature of every one comes to
be clear to some one listening to the repeating coming out of each one. (MA 265)
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
128 NEW LITERARY HISTORY
narrator, Toklas, is telling her story orally and that this is why she keeps
losing her thread. She regularly suspends the chronological order to tell
of an event that happened only later, which gives her later on a chance
to repeat the same incident a second time. Curiously enough, Stein uses
almost all these narrative detours to reflect on a positive moment in her
own writing career.
Commenting on the first publication of Stein's works, for instance,
Toklas declares: "The only little magazine that preceded it was one
called Rogue, printed by Allan Norton and which printed her descrip
tion of the Galerie Lafayette "(ATT 108). A few pages later she repeats
her comment: "He interested Allan and Louise Norton in her work and
induced them to print in the little magazine they founded, The Rogue,
the first thing of Gertrude Stein's ever printed in a little magazine, The
Galerie Lafayette"(A7T129).
On another occasion Alice mentions four times the same scene
describing Stein at work. "Gertrude Stein was just seeing through the
press Three Lives which she was having privately printed, and she was
deep in The Making of Americans, her thousand page book"(A7T6),
she remarks first. Two chapters later she repeats the same statement:
"Gertrude Stein was writing The Making of Americans and she had just
commenced correcting the proofs of Three Lives. I helped her correct
them"(A7T 65). Later, the same episode gets another mentioning: "I
helped Gertrude Stein with the proofs of Three Lives and then I began
to typewrite The Making of Americans" (ATT 81). Finally, as an ultimate
proof of her absent-mindedness, Toklas describes the same scene for a
fourth time: "When I first came to the rue de Fleurus Gertrude Stein was
correcting the proofs of Three Lives. I was soon helping her with this
and before very long the book was published"(ATT 105).
Why all these repetitions? According to Stein's theoretical argument,
this technique of repetition serves the purpose of character develop
ment. In The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas just like in her other writings,
a character?in this case Stein herself?is accompanied by a set of
constant attributes, and it is through the repetition of this set of
attributes that the "whole" of the character is supposed to emerge at the
end. Evidently, this set of attributes should not be understood as short
epithets that are repeated each time word by word, but rather as a
collection of a few typical activities, behaviors, and poses that constitute
the character.
Seen from a more down-to-earth perspective, however, this peculiar,
Steinese method of character development serves in Stein's hands as a
powerful means to influence the audience's opinion about herself. In
her autobiography, Stein attaches a constant set of positive attributes to
her own name that, on the pretext of character-development, she can
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
AUTOBIOGRAPHY AS ADVERTISEMENT 129
Final Flash
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
130 NEW LITERARY HISTORY
Harvard University
NOTES
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
AUTOBIOGRAPHY AS ADVERTISEMENT 131
1984), p. 42. Further references to this book in the endnotes will be signaled by the
abbreviation RLW.
6 Ann Sprague MacDonald, "The Business Woman's Bookshelf," Independent Woman,
(November 1933). Quoted in RLW, p. 45.
7 Lindley Williams Hubbell, "The Plain Edition of Gertrude Stein," Contempo 3 (25
October 1933). Quoted in RLW, p. 43.
8 Ola M.Wyeth, "Gertrude Stein's Autobiography," Savannah News, 22 October 1933.
Quoted in RLW, p. 52.
9 See, for instance, her photographic portrait entitled "Gertrude Stein in front of the
atelier door" in the 1933 Harcourt Brace edition of her autobiography.
10 Carl Van Vechten, "A Stein Song," in Selected Writings of Gertrude Stein, ed. Carl Van
Vechten (New York, 1990), p. xviii.
11 Gertrude Stein, Everybody s Autobiography (New York, 1937), p. 84.
12 W. A. Martin, "Review of The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas," Buffalo News, 9 September
1933. Quoted in RLW, p. 45.
13 "Review of The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas," Covington /Ky.] Post, 19 September
1933. Quoted in RLW, p. 48.
14 Lawrence J. Wathen, "Gertrude Stein Reveals Herself in Autobiography," Dallas Times
Herald, 24 September 1933. Quoted in RLW, p. 51.
15 For an overview of this criticism, see Monika Hoffmann, note 4. Some critics even
question the authorship of this autobiography.
16 "Review of The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas," Durham /N.C.] Herald, 17 September
1933. Quoted in RLW, p. 48.
17 Clifton Fadiman, "Books," New Yorker, 2 September 1933, 46-47. Quoted in RLW, p. 40.
18 Linda Simon, Gertrude Stein Remembered (Lincoln, 1994), p. 168.
19 jjames Agee], "Stein's Way," Time 22 (11 September 1933): 57-60. Quoted in RLW,
pp. 35-36.
20 See "Introduction" to Marketing Modernisms: Self-Promotion, Canonization, and Rereading,
ed. Kevin J. H. Dettmar and Stephen Watt (Ann Arbor, 1996), p. 3.
21 Articles by Karen Jackson Ford and Timothy Materer, respectively, published in
Marketing Modernisms: Self-Promotion, Canonization, and Rereading, ed. Kevin J. H. Dettmar
and Stephen Watt (Ann Arbor, 1996), pp. 275-96, 17-36.
22 Among others see Robert M. Post, "'An Audience is an Audience': Gertrude Stein
Addresses The Five Hundred," The Kentucky Review, 13 (1996), 71-93; and Bryce Conrad,
"Gertrude Stein in the American Marketplace," fournal of Modern Literature, 19 (1995), 215
33.
23 For an excellent study on the relationship of art and advertising see Jackson Lears,
Fables of Abundance: A Cultural History of Advertising in America (New York, 1994).
24 For basic principles of advertising see, for example, Harry L. Hollingworth, Advertising
and Selling: Principles of Appeal and Response (New York, 1920): a manual formulating and
systematizing the "facts and laws which relate to the processes of appeal and response in
the selling and advertising of goods" (Preface).
25 Paul Jordan-Smith, "I'll Be Judge You be Jury," Los Angeles Times, 10 September 1933.
Quoted in RLW, p. 43.
26 Philippe Lejeune, "Autobiography in the Third Person," New Literary History, 9 (1977),
43.
27 Gertrude Stein, "The Making of Americans," in Selected Writings of Gertrude Stein, ed.
Carl Van Vechten (New York, 1990), p. 264; hereafter cited in text as MA.
28 The Manchester Guardian Advertising Review: A Brief Notice on Some of the Theories and
Prindples of Advertisement and of the Contributory Arts, arranged and produced by Charles W.
Hobson (16 July 1924), p. 18; hereafter cited in text as AR
29 "Brain Anatomy," Newsweek, 9 September 1933, 29. Quoted in RLW, p. 37.
This content downloaded from 88.107.33.207 on Mon, 01 Jan 2018 23:26:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms